The Secret Alicorn Princess 🦄👑

Your mention of Alicorns becoming associated with royalty, more specifically princesses, got me thinking: maybe she wasn't an Alicorn at all. Maybe the idea of all princesses being Alicorns is just so ingrained in Equestria's culture that the illustrator just assumed that if she was a princess then she must have also been an alicorn.

A few related theories:
A) What if Cadance's mother was the original Queen of the Crystal Ponies before Sombra's takeover? The Hearts and Hooves day could still be brought into play here, and Cadance was conceived either directly or shortly before Sombra's rise to power. This would explain why Cadance was chosen to rule over the Crystal Kingdom almost moments before it returned.
B) Going off the "Queen Crystalise" theory about how she had been married to Sombra before he went dark. Once again, bringing to play the Hearts and Hooves day potion, what if they were the victims of this potion? The potion would've caused them to get together, bear a child, but something went wrong. Perhaps the potion's effects were broken, perhaps by Celestia, and Crystalise was enraged? She swore off love, left the Kingdom in anger, leaving her child behind and growing to despise it. She becomes the Queen of Changelings, effectively feeding off the emotion she hates. Then Sombra, a man who'd loved her, was corrupted by heartache when she left him. Celestia saves Cadance, the child born from this pair. Queen Crystalis overhears about the wedding, and goes not only for power but to also prevent her daughter from finding love in the same way she'd been forced into it? It would be poetic, using a "love" spell on Shining Armor to prevent Cadance, a child born from forced love, from being with her true love. This might also be why both Luna and Celestia didn't want to fight her since they were aware of why Crystalis became the way she did.

Sawtooth waves should be hired to make new storylines for My Little Pony so the show doesn’t have to end.

Next, I kinda want to see a "why are the princesses hair always ✨wAvY✨

Maybe it’s Princess Amore/ Princess Amore’s daughter as Cadence is a descendant of Princess Amore. Princess Amore is the ruler of the crystal empire- empire of love

Fun fact: Cadance was actually once a Pegasus who earned her “horn” like Twilight was once a Unicorn that earned her Wings. This is mentioned in a book...I forget the name of it but it is cannon I believe.

Rarity calling blue blood celestia’s nephew was actually what started my head cannon of celestia and Luna having a younger brother. I have no proof for this, just a head cannon.

Alicorns were definitely known figures. During the episode “The Crystalling” Spike pulls out an old ceramic piece of pottery designed with the detailing of the Crystalling. There, we see that the male in the image (who we can assume is the father) and a female alicorn (who we can assume is the mother) holding a baby. In fact, we see two alicorns . One was the honored Crystaller while the other was probably the mother. While the designs make it clear this was meant to parallel the Mane Six as well as Cadence and Shining Armor, this pot was made before any of them, which makes you wonder if clairvoyance was involved somehow, although it wouldn’t make sense since Twilight didn’t even end up as the Crystaller by the end of the episode. Either way, just thought it was a detail worth pointing out

My theory is princess cadence is the two pony’s from the hearts and hooves day tale foal and her mother was one of few other alicorns, if not the only other allicorn. Remember when we were first introduced to cadence and queen chrysalis in the canterlot wedding? How did she know how to find princess cadence and steal her life? I don’t know if anyone else noticed but chrysalis seemed to act like she already knew who cadence and princess celestia were from the past. It could be that Cadences mom was queen chrysalis (she probably had a different name before) and she transformed into the opposite of what the love spell was intended to do. But I thought when a changing is reformed they turn into bugs so that can’t be true. But then I thought all of the other changelings are different than her. None of them have allicorn magic like her. This makes me think that if she were to be reformed she would turn back into a allicorn. Also in that episode where she steals her life, it seem that she has a unknown past with princess celestial by the way she approaches the situation. Just my theory, I think it makes more sense.

Those are some interesting ideas, Sawtooth! I especially liked your explanation for how some of the royals of Equestria's past could have become alicorns by being exposed to magic—perhaps love magic?—from all three pony tribes. Thanks for sharing your thoughts with us! ^_^
There are some odd details in "Hearts and Hooves Day" that might complicate your theory about other alicorns existing in Equestria. When I checked the MLP Wiki for the episode's image gallery, I saw that the illustration in Twilight's book featured a princess with no visible horn or wings when Twilight was showing it to the CMC, which seemed to indicate that she was an Earth pony princess. However, when Sweetie Belle was talking about the love poison, the illustration was different and showed an alicorn princess instead. Since no one refers to the princess as an alicorn within the episode, it's hard to tell which illustration was an error. However, I believe it would make more sense for the prince and princess to both be Earth ponies to parallel Big Mac and Cheerilee.

You know their dedicated when they still makes theories even when the show has ended.

Wow, it's pretty impressive how they still make MLP videos even though the whole show has already ended ^w^ ❤✨

Ur theories are so interesting. There’s something I’ve always thought about. We’ve seen how Celestia and Luna would’ve been if they turned bad (like with nightmare moon and daybreaker) but what if the mane 6 were to turn bad? They solve so many problems that no one in equestria can solve by simply just being friends. There’s no doubt their extremely powerful, especially when they’re together. We’ve seen some of them individually turn ‘evil’ I guess (example: rarity in inspiration manifestation) but the 6 of them together represent friendship magic which is supposedly the most powerful magic of all according to the show. Not to mention they are connected to the elements of harmony which are also some of the most powerful artifacts in equestria. The power they hold is immense. So if the mane 6 were to all cohesively as a group team up and turn evil could anybody really stop them? It would be interesting to see and I wish they did something like that on mlp.(also I feel like their designs would look so cool if they were reformed to look evil I really wish the show did something like this)

I like to imagine that in the ancient past, there might have been more alicorns. Prehaps some "true" alicorns, as in being naturally born alicorns. It could explain some of the powerful magical relics in the world, such as the alicorn amulet. What became of these alicorns? Who knows?

What if the hearts and hooves day,it's actually a prophesy for a future princess to keep her eyes open for who she chooses to be her love interest

Since the crystal empire was separated and had different history there could definitely be a family from there. The earth pony could also be a crystal pony since they may be confused.

I'm so grateful for the time you take to make these videos even after the show has ended. It's kept the spark! Thank you!

I still say the Alicorn from the Hearts and Hooves Day story was Chrysalis before she became a Changeling!

Mini theory

Sombra is cadences dad?
After losing his wings, he would be power thirsty,
possibly enough to make a love potion to get back on top.

Edit: yes, l know that the pony is an earth pony, but sombra obviously might of changed his appearance, after all, he is a villlan 😉

Just a thought, it correlates to the Sombra and Alicorn Amulet theories, maybe the reason why there aren't any other alicorns is that, instead of just ripping the magic from all three tribes, Sombra was actively hunting alicorns as soon as they ascended after he figured out how to steal their magic, and left the two sisters for last since they were the first ones? It would explain why there aren't anymore real alicorns except for the ones nowadays (Cadance likely being born right after the hunts, which would explain how she is smaller than the sisters but taller and slightly older than Twilight, and Twilight was very carefully selected and mostly during times of 'peace', as there really weren't hitches with her ceremony), the immense power the amulet seems to have, and if Sombra was an alicorn himself why he was so powerful, he was culling out any more competition before he was stopped, because while we see one can become powerful by stealing the magic from each of the tribes as with Tirek, stealing the magic from several alicorns as soon as possible would definitely be either just as or more effective, until someone stepped in and he was turned back into a regular unicorn and the magic, now too twisted, corrupt and concepts that likely shouldn't have mixed together (as different alicorns might have represented different things) couldn't be returned, and thus stayed static in the amulet before Trixie got it.

Or his official backstory could be the one from the comics, I don't know, it's all just a thought that sprang in my mind over coffee, no one will likely read this anyway XP

My, isn’t this quite the “heart” wrenching mystery? 😉

I just wanted to say how much I love your theory videos! And I think there's a lot of lore on mlp that we can still explore.

I disagree with the theory of that when you inject yourself with magic strong enough you can just become an alicorn. Cozy glow could become an alicorn, but not a real one like Twilight. When Cozy Glow was rid of all the magic she had gotten from the bell, she was returned to her pegasi form, whereas when Twilight lost all her magic (not friendship) through Tirek, she remained an alicorn. Cadence's Mother must have been the former Princess of Love, and she had to also have done something worthy to become an alicorn, just like how it was explained Cadence was not born a unicorn according to Celestia and Luna in The Crystalling.

I love the spring background in the video! And i love the flower in you oc's hair.

I like the idea of the hearts & hooves day pony being cadence's mother. If we follow the belief that turning into an alicorn dosnt change one's DNA then that would mean cadence was born as a non-alicorn to an alicorn. This makes even more sense why everyone was soo surprized at flurry. Since every previously recorden birth from an alicorn has never resulted in another alicorn. Flurry is just the exception & I can explain her too: Cadence was pregnant with flurry in the crystal empire which soaks up 3-tribe power on a regular basis (like any holiday/festival/birthday/or evil-vanquishing event), plus the mother is already an alicorn & in a royal/leadership position which is exactly the position that earns the love & admiration of the people. Why isn't cadence's hair wavy yet? BECAUSE the baby was leaching 3-tribe/alicorn magic off her mother the entire pregnancy. Anyway, It's not hard to consider a jump to alicorn during development, it's as simple as why Riversong aka Melodypond from doctor who turned out to be a timelord when she was conceived in the presence of time vortex energy.

Let's just hope this secret princess isn't paid DLC

MY THEORY:

I think that there may be another kingdom or continent where the alicorns live because the map of Equestria only shows the kingdoms in the show and not the other parts of the world. I believe that Celestia and Luna were part of that ‘kingdom’. In the Journal of the Two Sisters, it says that there were other alicorns in the time of Celesia and Luna. We also know that StarSwirl trained the two main princesses so I believe that Celestia and Luna’s parents sent them to Equestria to learn magic and learn about the other ponies. However, I don’t think this was the only reason. We know that before Celestia and Luna came to Equestria, the three pony tribes were separated and thus the windagos came and were only stopped by the three tribes coming together. The tribes decided to make banners with their respected trait on it and create Equestria. The alicorns decided to send Celestia and Luna to help with stop the windagos because they recognized the potential threat and disharmony. We know that Celestia and Luna are mirrors of eachother. One with the power of light and the other with the power of darkness. I also believe that the alicorns sent the sisters is because the both represent very important things. Celestia representing warm, mentorship, maturity, and harmony while Luna represents cold, caringness, dreams, and harmony. There is harmony in the day but there is also harmony in the night. People could argue that the alicorns could have sent only one of the sisters or two completely different alicorns. We have seen what would have happened if there was only one sister ruling already. Nightmare Moon turned the world into a kingdom of darkness while DayBreaker would have most likely turned it into a world of fire. You can’t have light without darkness or darkness without light. That is why the alicorns sent Celestia and Luna. They were the two ponies that Equestria needed the most. The show has also shown of mirrors of a few characters such as Twilight and Cadance. Twilight has two mirrors. Sunset Shimmer, who wanted Celestia to pay for not being there for her and rejected her pleads to learn more magic and Trixie, who was so jealous of Twilight because she didn’t have any friends of her own and no one loved her. Cadance’s mirror is Chrysalis because Chrysalis was feeding on love and hurting the ponies who gave her love instead of sharing it and knowing what it actually means. I believe that the alicorns don’t need to send anyone else to Equestria because of how much it has evolved throughout the show and how much it is still evolving. The alicorns are still very mysterious and, as much as I want to know more about them, they should stay mysterious because it is more interesting that way.

I always thought she was Princess Amore, a distant relative of Cadence's

The one thing you gotta take into account is that the hearts and hooves day story.. is a story. Stories of that nature that cause traditions tend to change over time. Take Santa for example, he wasn't always the white bearded man in red we all know now. Maybe the princess in the story wasn't an alicorn to start with but changed into one because of the two sisters. As we have seen only female ponies have been alicorns so the story could of been changed a little to fit in with the new royalty system. So she may have been an alicorn but maybe she wasn't! The story doesn't have enough details sadly and we don't get much history behind it. It's fun to speculate tho!

My theory is that Celestia made the unknown princess into a alicorn, and so the new princess decided one day that she would rule her own kingdom.

So she left Equestria and found the Horse Country, lacking order and monarchy, and despite only being a pony, she soon assumed control as their princess. And since parts of legends are lost to time, the stallion who fell in love with her was actually a horse.

And so when the Kindom fell, it never recovered, the horses scattered and most came to Equestria, interbred with some ponies and formed Saddle Arabia, but that doesn't mean that there aren't horses outside of Saddle Arabia, I actually think that Troubleshoes is a horse.

Anyway, the princess found herself ruler of a broken Kingdom, losing trust and control of her subjects and eventually followed in their hoofprints towards Equestria.

She could not face Celestia after failing her kingdom, so she stayed away, carrying a foal that would be born any day now.

Unfortunately she gave birth in the woods and died in the process, leaving baby Cadence with no hope of survival.

Fortunately she was found a few hours later by a group of earth-pony mares, probably some type of nuns or monks or something.

They took her in but found that caring for a pegasus foal was no easy feat as they had no wings themselves.

So, somehow news got to Celestia, probably from the news of the Horse Kingdoms downfall and the knowledge that the unknown princess was with foal, so she searched Equestria and eventually heard of Cadence, who looked almost exactly like her mother. So Celestia took the filly in, adopting her as a niece, where she was cared for by castle staff and council, eventually earning her alicorn title and becoming the princess we all know and love today.

I still need to work on the details more but this is the basic plot. :)

Hasbro's animators who worked on mlp watching this be like: Finally, someone notices.

Well, I guess if one of the sister princesses was Cadence's mother, specifically Luna, then Cadence would actually be Celestia's niece.

In general, there are 100 official comics and several books in which you can find out how the Princess Luna became the Nightmare Moon, and who really is King Sombra, and even how Cadance became an alicorn.
Even on a simple Wikipedia, you can find information about how Princess Luna became the Nightmare Moon. I mean who helped her become Nightmare Moon.

One thing that has always hurt my head whenever I asked this question to myself: How the heck does Luna and Celestia raise the moon and sun?

This theory also makes sense for the upcoming G5 movie and series as there doesn't seem to be any alicorns in the modern setting (that we know of as yet, not ruling anything out), because the land has lost all it's magic that would influence a pony's potential to become one

Whomever that Alicorn princess was, chances are she was long gone and if she did turn out to be Cadence's mother that would certainly explain a lot, and it would also reveal a lot more about Cadence's origins (That's obvious i know but still)

My question is are we factoring in the lore from the comics. I know Candance was actually a Pegasus before becoming an Alicorn and Celestia adopted her as her niece. I think she might of turned into an Alicorn shortly before babysitting Twilight. When Candance and Shining Armor were in school she was already an Alicorn.

I though that cadence, had an entire story in a book dedicated to just how she became an alicorn. How she was a Pegasus first who stood against another female pony who was trying to corrupt pony love,

I was sure the book was produced around the same time as season three... though I am not denying your theory...

My theory with the alicorns has always been that there are two tiers of alicorns you have the princess of kind where that's Luna Celestia and Twilight where they represent the concept of something and they are the only ones with the extra natural powers, royalty alicorn wouldn't have the longevity because they're not connected to a concept

I think the "side alicorns" were weaker alicorns. Every alicorn ages (Flurry Heart grew up, the sisters went to retirement), but more powerful alicorns (like Celestia and Luna) age more slowly. So I think the other alicorns simply died from old ages after a few hundred years.

I wouldn’t call this a theory, but just something I’ve noticed...
Every alicorn we know about started out as a UNICORN and became an alicorn (except Flurry and unknown Cadence). Never has a PEGASUS or Earth Pony become an alicorn. I’ve been thinking, does this mean that unicorn magic can’t be given and must be born with? I mean, wings and strength seem to be able to be given, which makes sense. If this is the case, does Celestia know this? I mean, have you never questioned why she had a school for only talented UNICORNS, which is basically racist segregation in the MLP world? Maybe Celestia knows only unicorns can become alicorns? But let’s take this a bit farther... The wonder bolts. (If I’m wrong, I haven’t watched the show in a hot minute, give me a pass) Powerful and elite Pegasus’s chosen by royalty. What if the wonderbolts are failed ALICORNS-as in met all the requirements to be alicorns, but lack being born with unicorn magic-leaving them looking like normal Pegasus but with earth pony strength. Idk, I haven’t researched to prove or disprove anything. Feel free to comment anything that proves or disproves this, or just any feedback.

Celestia always hinted there were more Alicorns out there, especially when Flurry Heart was born. No one was born an Alicorn until Flurry Heart, they were created through "earning the right" like Twilight. So the story of another Alicorn Princess outside of the five makes sense even if the Hearts and Hooves Alicorn isn't Cadence's mom. Besides, the best we know about Cadence's family is that she's a niece of the Royal Sisters, hinting that they had siblings at one point. But considering their over +1000 age, Cadence is more likely adopted as a niece OR is descended from the unknown siblings of the Royal Sisters Or both.

Okay so hear me out… what if the secret alicorn is actually Celestia in her younger years… she did sound awfully experienced when she said that there had never been a naturally born alicorn… but here’s a new theory for you to explore, Is it possible that Celestia had a love life with someone and had a child herself? And if she did… with who? 🤔

I always headcannoned that Cadance is the reincarnation of the former Empress of the Crystal Empire (IE her cutiemark looking like the Crystal Heart) that was killed by Sombra during his take over.
The alicorn from the story could in theory be the Crystal Empress in her youth. So in a way she's both is and isn't Cadance.

Here’s my thought: After Celesta and Luna became the new rulers, the other rulers didn’t get as much love and praise. So after years of this, their wings or horn was striped because they didn’t get this attention anymore. So they soon became average ponies.

In "The Crystalling" the vase Spike shows depicts both the mother and the crystaler as alicorns. I believe the story involved an alicorn from the Crystal Empire and a unicorn princefrom the unicorn kingdom (depicted in "Hearth's Warming Eve").

There are now 6 known Alicorns in Equestria
Princess of the sun
Princess of the moon
Princess of love
Princess of friendship
Princess of light
Princess of ?

Hey Sawtooth, could you do an episode on why, when the mane 6 turned the keys, transformed and defeated Tirek... When they transformed, everypony's mane got longer and was blowing in natural wind but ONLY Rainbow's mane colors were in motion as if she had alicorn magic. What's up with that???

Sawtooth there’s one person you haven’t described yet: Princess Amore. She was the ruler of the Crystal Empire before Cadence and Sombra turned her into a statue, broke her into a thousand pieces and scattered those pieces into the ends of Equestria. Then Radiant Hope would’ve become the next Unicorn ruler of the Crystal Empire, so what if it came to a Alicorn starting to rule the empire during Sombra’s spell that hid the Empire from the rest of Equestria? That could be possible. Don’t you agree? Not to mention little is known about Princess Amore apart from The Journal Of The Two Sisters book and My Little Pony: Frenimes graphic novel which shows the origins of King Sombra, Trek, The Sirens, Nightmare Moon and Queen Chrysalis. I would really suggest reading those two books as I have them both and they are really good reads. They also allowed me to open up to this exact theory that I have now that I watched this video and read those two books. Thanks so much for reading this! Bye!!

My personal headcanon about who the mysterious alicorn is, is that she IS Cadence's mother*, but more than that she is the mysterious Princess Amore (I think she may have been mentioned in the show once, but she was definitely mentioned in the comics.). If the alicorn is Princess Amore, it would explain why that one pony at the end of The Crystal Empire Part 2 exclaimed, "Behold, the Crystal Princess!" because Cadence was destined to rule after her mother's descent from the throne*. I do consider the books and comics to be canon to some extent, so I believe that in the book "Twilight and the Crystal Heart Spell", when Cadence was explaining that she grew up as an orphan in a remote village, that she had escaped the crystal empire somehow before Sombra took over.

*For reference, in the comics Princess Amore is turned to stone by Sombra, then destroyed. It is also up to debate whether or not Princess Amore is Cadence's mom or not, but Cadence WAS confirmed to be a direct descendant of Princess Amore.

I know this is going to sound crazy, but what if when alicorns fall in love, get married, and/or have foals, they loose their "immortality". Since they have longer lifespans than their spouses, they may have to, or just choose to, give up that long life span for a regular life span. As for what happened to all the royal families, I'm guessing they married into each others families, each time limiting the diversity of the different royal lines until there are just a couple left today. (I'm talking about Prince Blueblood). So if the Princess in this story is Cadence's mother, she probably died a while ago since she probably gave up her immortality.

Also, I think I finally now know what happened with Flurry heart and her window! We never see Shining Armor and Cadence in the future, and i think Flurry Heart took over for her mother. Because as the alicorn of love, Cadence would have a pretty hard time outliving her husband, unless she gave up her longer life span so she could be with Shining Armor, leaving Flurry heart to rule the Crystal empire.

Well, we know Flurry heart is the first alicorn to be born in Equestria. If there were other alicorns than those we know, their children would probably be alicorns too, so no alicorn had children before.

well the episode specified there was "something about a dragon,chaos reigning,kingdom falling" cuz the pair was "so in love" , i think it'd be interesting is the princess wasnt a alicorn,but the author of the book didnt know what she looked like and associated "princess" with alicorn,so they depicted her as a pony alicorn,but she could've been anything,or maybe the stallion could have been anything,nothing stated they were ponies, so its possible they were shown as ponies in the book because there were no records of their apperances,and the story was written down by a game of telephone,i dare say,one of them was a dragon,the other a something else,maybe their relationship gave birth to Discord? theres many ways to go with this
edit: omg pony-washing

I see what you did there, but I have a much more simple theory:
The princess in the story died... not from old age, but she was killed, or she lost her powers like Cozy.

She must've been Crystal Empire royalty, seeing as how Cadence was called "the crystal princess" and her crystal heart cutie mark and how Celestia was so sure she had to participate in the rebuilding of the empire when it came back. Why else would she have sent her, right?

How come Twilight never noticed there was an alicorn civilization on her map unless, there wasn’t one. In past videos you talked about an ancient civilization were Celestia and Luna came from showing how they got their magical flowing hair. But Twilight has a map of all of Equestria and the lands beyond, yet she still never noticed a blank spot where there might be a civilization.

speaking of alicorns, y’know what i never understood? why does human twilight get wings when she “ponies up” in “forgotten friendship” (2018) , but when she goes into equestria in “spring breakdown” (2019), she’s still a unicorn? i figured you’d have some thoughts about it, should you ever see this :) love your vids!

I think this guy puts more thought into the show than the actual creators did

I think it's unlikely to be Cadance's mother, especially given that flurry heart was the cause of the direct genetics of an alicorn. The princesses clearly said that flurry was the first alicorn born naturally, so Cadance would also end up having the genetics of an alicorn mother, making her the first.
unless... there is a chance in many that a baby will be born directly with the genetics of an alicorn...
oh boy i just answered myself-

My headcanon is that Cadance was sealed away by some villain or another soon after she ascended to alicornhood, and was freed by Celestia sometime before the Rainboom, which would explain why she appeared so much younger when she was babysitting Twilight.

I don’t think that there were more alicorns in equestria’s past, the association with royalty being due to the royal sisters rather than a prevalent alicorn royal class. The vestigial royals like Prince Blueblood are likely descendants of Princess Platinum, and not really related to the alicorn royals at all. I could see Celestia adopting Cadance as a niece after making her a princess, which would make the other ‘royals’ jealous, throwing a fit and forcing Celestia to adopt one (or more) of them as well to prevent conflict.

That being said, just because I don’t think there were more alicorns in ‘Equestria’s’ past doesn’t mean there weren’t more alicorns. Pre-Equestrian alicorns are definitely possible, and that’s an interesting idea on its own.

I just found your channel and I love it the mlp universe is very rich and great for theorizing as well! Love to see more vids

here's my theory:
the princess in the book is indeed cadence's mother and i think blueblood's mother aswell. The thing is i also think that she is related to the royal sisters and i think she was their sister too but after the crystal empire was destroyed and in sombra's control, celestia and luna avoided any signs of relation between them and their other sister so that they wouldn't be caught in a scandal. Instead, celestia adopted cadenza, renamed her cadence and put her to training to be the ruler of the crystal empire in the future. I also think that cadence's mother, turned into a changeling aka chrysalis. And the reason Chrysalis steals love is because she never felt real love (cuz of the love potion the prince gave her) and that's my theory

MLP: (ends)
Sawtooth Waves: it's free real estate

"The birth of an alicorn is something Equestria has never seen."

The history of Equestria is interesting and attractive by its mysteriousness

Heyy, Sawtooth Waves! What do you think of idea of making a video about Gusty the Great? It's an INCREDIBLY interesting theme to reflex on.

In other theory of yours (about Grogar's previous being as the constellation) you did use much information about Gusty. Then we have found out that she was not only more powerful than the Alicorn Sisters and all the alicorns, but also more powerful than the f**King Elements! That's un-be-lievable. And she was just a unicorn!
Or not? We have seen she possessed a really weird form and looked like Shadow Pony. But Gusty was kind. And even Shadow Pony was much less powerful than Gusty.

I just have no suggestions about that and it'd be awesome if you made the video with your thoughts.

But isn’t Cadence an “artificial” alicorn?

Now that you mentioned Prince Blue Blood, I came up with an idea. What if Cadence was the princess and Blue Blood the prince in the story just like you said on the previous video about Cadence's past?

I will repeat myself:
I think that the Princess from the story is our mysterious"Princess Amore"

Anyway, whoever the princess is, she must be related to Cadence. Here’s some tips that might help you figure out and post ‘ Finally solving Alicorn princess.’
1. I think that Cadence would have just past the arguing people, but instead, she used her magic. It’s a waste when you need it for something more important. I think the Mayor was the one who gave her the guilty-ness so she used her magic.
2. Maybe the potion contains Cadence’s cells, which caused her birth. The Mayor could have been inside the whole mystery, and she might be Cadence’s cousin or something. She also could be the Alicorn Princess’s friend (or something connected to the Princess, at least!).Then, her parents told her about the mistake, and she felt sorry for her relative mayor.
All this I’ve said, is just that I think the Mayor has something to do with this. Hope it’s helped you!😘

P.S: I love your subjects for your mystery.❤️🧡💛💚💙💜❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️

It could also be that, like most fairytales this one was also first spread verbally.
Later it was written in a book and illustrated. Because by that time the idea of royalty=alicorn was so prominent the princess was drawn as an alicorn.

Is it Cadence's mother? Like you said at the beginning maybe it is passed down in DNA but differently to make people's relationships fixed or make people in love? It's a mystery.

This is so interesting, because if Cadance was the two’s daughter than that means she was conceived under a love potion, and we saw how that turned out with You-Know-Who 😂

Hold the phone
If blue blood is Celestia’s nephew and in this theory Candence is Celestia’s niece...
Who would be their parents? Are they siblings? Is Luna Blue Blood’s mom? Is there another Royal sister?

Cadence became an alicorn after defeating an evil pony named prisma. Here is the excerpt saying so from the wiki. It comes from a chapter book.

Chapter books

Princess Cadance is featured in the chapter book Twilight Sparkle and the Crystal Heart Spell. The book tells the story of Twilight Sparkle after she'd been made an Alicorn and seeks advice on being a princess. She turns to Cadance, who tells her life story, how as a baby Pegasus she was found in the woods by Earth ponies, who took her to their village. When she grew up she reversed a love-stealing spell cast by a pony called Prismia. Prismia wore a magic-enhancing necklace that amplified her evil and jealousy, but when Cadance confronted her, the necklace amplified Cadance's love. Once Prismia changed her horrible ways, Cadance was surrounded by magical energy and transported to a strange place where she met Celestia, who adopted her as her royal niece.

Queen Chrysalis was probably that princess, she may have once been very beautiful, and maybe since she fell in love through alternate means and not by true feelings she transformed into a Changeling after believing that love through true methods was a farce and force was the only option. The reason she was depicted as a pony was likely a coverup since I don't think ponies would like the fact that the Changeling queen is where Hearts and Hooves day originated.

Plot twist: All the “Animation error Alicorns” Are actual alicorns

If the princess in the story is Cadance, then the kingdom that fell to its downfall is probably The Crystal Empire, when it was being ruled by King Sombra

“The birth of an alicorn has never been seen in equestria”

A question for a future theory perhaps? :

Why does Celestia have Rarity's element on her crown and necklace??

'At least the only alicorns we know of...'

*Insert crowd gasp sound effect*

Cadence and Cadence’s mother spread love to the Crystal Empire in order to prevent the country from being corrupted by hatred.

I think that it's an entirely different alicorn. I think that it might be someone from cadence's family tree. I mean,it is easy to see those two related since they both have something to do with love like the theory you just said and you also explained how cadence would be celestia's niece. The reason in my head why we don't know about this alicorn could be because she was present a long time ago and that their next generations weren't alicorns. What if after the royal sister's started ruling the other royals started losing their power and purpose and didn't really get that much attention (by power I mean their ability to do something in equestria as they were royalty). As they didn't get much attention their families wouldn't become alicorns. And that may be the reason we don't know about this particular alicorn. But I'm not sure about cadence being related to this mystery alicorn.

Or our mystery alicorn is a changeling.

(P.S. I am using someone else's phone so don't ask questions about that.)

This is the kind of stuff I look forward to every Friday

The salt is real! My little pony had so much potential for older-age audience style lore/content that was left unsaid because the show was mainly catered towards younger children. Sawtooth does a very good job at theorizing what they left unsaid and I personally accept most of his theories. I feel that just because it's a cartoon about magic doesn't mean that Hasbro should've only catered to young kids, most people who had watched the older generation of mlp are now older (like me, I'm only 19 but I watched older gens because my mom introduced them to me) and would probably watch reboot/new gen just because they had previously enjoyed it. Steven Universe has a likehood to mlp in some sort because it's a animated cartoon about magic and it's definitely NOT for young children!

I think that the Alicorn Princess from that story was Cadence’s mother. Here’s how my story of the theory goes.
Long, long ago a unicorn princess was crowned, ruler of her kingdom. The ponies poured their loyalty and love and it absorbed into the princess turning her into an alicorn. Not long after a prince made a love potion for this princess and decided to use it on her. He took her out for a night and they drank the potion. The spell worked and they had a foal named Princess Cadence. The couple had become so tangled up in each other that they forgot about their duties and the kingdom fell apart. Cadence’s mother came out to address the crowd about the kingdom, but their hatred had grown for the princess that dragged them down. The alicorn magic was pulled away from her, transforming her back into a unicorn. This has broken the love spell due to it being mixed with her alicorn magic. The princess ran away in shame and the prince shortly vanished after. Cadence was too young to rule so the ponies fled and split up to Canterlot, PonyVille, and CloudsDale where they remained happily.

So yeah that’s my theory on what happened. Short version is basically some princess turns into an alicorn, gets a spell put on her by a prince, kingdom falls apart, child is too young to rule, they split up, yeah.

Congratulations sawtooh waves! You just made a new ship!

I saw a comment saying 'She must've been Crystal Empire royalty, seeing as how Cadence was called "the crystal princess" and her crystal heart cutie mark and how Celestia was so sure she had to participate in the rebuilding of the empire when it came back. Why else would she have sent her, right' now when Sawtooth said what happened to her I started to wonder and finally came to a conclusion maybe when Sombra took over the mother and the father would have had to give out all of her power to Sombra but they wouldn't give up so easily they took the power of the crystal ponies and from into a heart and hide or put candace into some village where the rest of the story from the book takes place. I hope Sawtooth you notice this comment.

Anyone else think Queen of the changeling herself would be this pony? That would help explain their change in look when giving love. This could possibly answer why some pony is so focused on the Crystal Empire.

The stallion in the drawing looks a bit like the prince BlueBlood, and the mare like Cadence. Maybe they are more connected more than you let on?🤔

I don't think Cadence is that old. In the flashback, we see that she looks just like a regular pegasus but with a horn in terms of her size and structure. In the present, her wingtips started turning purple, her horn was longer and pointier, and her facial structure started flattening out like Celestia and Luna's. Her wings were also longer and pointer when folded. She was larger too. She is about the same size as Shining Armor and he is bigger than Twilight and Cadence looked about the same size Twilight was in that episode in the flashback. What's more, in the final season we see Twilight presumably fully grown. This is far enough in the future that all her friends are getting old. They aren't as old as Granny Smith but they aren't young. Twilight is about the same size as Celestia in that episode. You could argue that Luna was smaller than Celestia so Cadence's full size could be similar, but you can see that she is still noticeably smaller than Luna and her face was more like that of a regular pony. I think if we saw Cadence in the final episode, she would have the same size and shape as Luna at least, maybe the same as Celestia and Twilight. I think that Cadence became an alicorn no more than a few years before Twilight was born. There is still a possibility that she is older or related to the pony in the myth, but I think it unlikely.

Hey Sawtooth I have a video idea! its about a question I always had

Why does Mist mane have wavy hair?

I mean Star swirl does not have it and I always thought it was because they had great power or you could get it for being a alicorn but Mist mane it probably not as powerful as Star swirl and she is just a unicorn. Its something I always had a question about so I decided to ask you. :)

Are we gonna get a “how did equestria become this way” theory for gen5? Since it’s set in the future.

Cadence being celestia's niece does raise some questions about celestia's and Luna's family like were there any other siblings in their family

It could have been where there used to be many alicorns but since of an alicorn falling under that big of a spell clestea could have took control and pretended that it never Happened and that’s why Celestia said that a birth of an alicorn they have never seen and cadence could of been to young to remember her mother.

the hearts and Hooves Days Alicorn is The previous Love Princess In celestia or Lunas Diary it has the words A previous Princess of love That ran away

"the birth of an alicorn is something we've never seen," said Celestia

Something weird that I’m now noticing is that since prince blue blood is celestial nephew wouldn’t that mean celestia has a sibling we haven’t met yet?

One question... If the small branches of royals became alicorns because they received admiration and praise from the 3 types of magic, then shouldn't a famous pony, say countess coloratura, also be an alicorn?

Is Blue Blood actually Celestia's nephew? The only one I remember mentioning it is Rarity during her fantasising about finding her then unnamed prince charming, but that was long before she actually met him.

I feel like royal families were a pre-Equestrian thing. In many of the ancient legends we hear, which all take place around the same time, there are different royals. Princesses, princes, empresses, pharoahs, etc.

I believe that the leadership of Maretonia are all alicorns. The only two we see in the show are completely covered up with robes and wearing elaborate hats that could easily conceal their wings and horns.

I love how he actually puts flurry heart in the thumbnail!

I had a question about wallflower in forgotten friendship I was wondering why she was specifically mad at sunset she could have been mad at everyone couldn't she why just sunset it's like sunset had done sth personal but sunset took power of the whole school nothing personal it affected everyone it didn't make sense so when I heard the song invisible a line piqued my interest "a memory forgotten" when we saw the flashbacks they only showed after sunset came everywhere it sounded like they'd never known wallflower but then that line should have been sth else I was thinking if ppl did know her but then when sunset came she became more popular so much that wallflower was no longer noticed that would be rather personal especially to her ego

I have an idea for your next video: Cadence the bringer of destruction/fall of the crystal empire
How old is cadence? Think about it, she has the crystal heart as her cutiemark yet the crystal empire was gone up until season 3, so she had to have been around before the crystal empire vanished. We also know that cadence was not banished along with the crystal ponies because she babysat twilight. She was an alicorn as far back as we can see and we know they age differently; so we she could be way older than we thought. Is it possible that cadence is a crystal pony & that when king Sombra turned bad Cadence is the one that asked the princesses to save the crystal empire? The other theory on the changelings cohabitating in the crystal empire also makes sense because when queen chrysalis was posing as cadence for the royal wedding Cadence seemed to be the one that already knew the most about them. (also Celestia, because she knew queen chrysalis' name before she had to be introduced.)
I would make a lot of sense if the princess of "love" earned her alicorn status (by creating a new type of magic "love is magic") in a society where love is an integral part of existing: the light and love charges the crystal heart, and the love that the changelings use. But wait! is it possible that the princess worthy deed that cadence did to become an alicorn was put the crystal heart system in place? Think about it. If the empire previously used a different system of keeping the winter at bay and it failed, then an extraordinary young unicorn who had just realized that love is a magic strong enough to keep the winter at bay. She carved a large crystal into the symbol of love and instructed the panicking ponies that this would work and to be strong for the ponies that they cared about. They could already see how the power their love fed the changelings. Cadence performs a love spell on the crystal heart turning it into a vessel for the strength of love that that the ponies had for each other and the cold wind of the north are blasted back. Cadence floats into the sky be magic not her own and vanished into another realm where she meets celestia for the first time. She gets her wings and reappears in front of the crystal ponies as an alicorn (and perhaps earning her cutiemark at the same time). The ponies celebrate and declare this young pony Cadence is worthy of becoming their leader someday. This puts king sombra's position at risk. But, he has bigger things to worry about: the crystal heart system seems to be working well but Sombra sees a problem. The changelings apatite for love is now a problem because the empire now runs off of love. If the changlings grow in numbers or if their apatite increases it will put the empire at risk. There is only one thing to do banish the changelings. (If my theory is correct: the mere presence of Cadence is the reason the crystal empire fell and why the changelings turned bad. Although chrysalis didn't seem to be hold any particular grudge against sombra when grogar brought them all together, maybe because cadence had a more direct hand in their banishment.)
After all this it would make sense why no one bothers to mention her past, she didn't even tell twilight. Why would she? Its even worse than (more embarrassing) than starlight's past. Think about it; her becoming an alicorn the symbol of leadership caused sombra's corruption (though it may not have changed the outcome for the changelings). This is an example of Starswirl's alicorn creation system causing negative results. If she had not become an alicorn she would simply have become something of a hero to the people as spike did & even more important not a threat to Sombra's position (especially if he wasn't an alicorn. This could've lead to him seeking different means to appear more powerful to the people to solidify his position, via the alicorn amulet that corrupts anyone who wears it)

I am bigger on the theory that cadence is the daughter that came about because of the love potion.
It would also help explain how cadence could have been twilight’s babysitter when she was still a Philly.
As well as why her magic almost seems to be like a love potion.
But this also carries the larger implication that when a potion or spell is used on somepony, the spell or potions affect can actually carry over to their offspring almost like a genetic trait if you will.
This would also explain why flurry heart was born an Alicorn.

I think the Alicorn under the spell was Luna! She had a sister, and keep in mind, prince blueblood, if I remember correctly, is celestia's nephew, so maybe Luna gave birth to prince blueblood, who did the love spell on Cadence! CADNECE is Celestia's adoptive daughter/nice, right?

What if it's Cozy Glow breaking free from stone, becoming an alicorn again, and going back in time?
Wait, no. That's waaay to complicated for ANY cartoon

Wasn't it confirmed in one of the comics that her mother was princess Amour? Or it's just my own headcannon? She was the ruler of the Crystal Empire and I think Sombra killed her.

Her name means love and Cadence is the princess of love. And in the first episode we meet Cadence we learn her full name: Mi Amour Cadence.
Edit: And the crystal ponies call her the crystal princess

I think it very well could be Cadence's mother even though I've never really seen or heard anything offer Hearts and Hooves Day and The Love Potion bottle wrong what a bluebird really is the descendants of Katy flurry heart Blue Bloods granddaughter

what did you use to do that flower peddle shower animation cycle? I am guessing blender but is there a specific tutorial that allows a seamless continuation of the cycle without rendering the whole length of the video?

I love how he makes theory's on stuff nobody pays attention too. Also what if it was princess skyla? ... Ya know. That toy back in 2010. That most people forgot about

there never was an alicorn in the story. it was just 2 unicorns. but when it was written up as a fairytale story the spell used was properly written down but the story itself was sensatinalized to be about "an alicorn princess" when it was probably a unicorn princess

If Prince blueblood is Celestia’s nephew wouldn’t that make Luna his mother?

UNLESS....there’s another sibling we don’t know about!!! 😱🤔

I'm almost confident to say there's a lot of alicorns out there but like in another dimension, hiding, or something

there is one ruler that could have a connection to the story, and its true we've never seen her..... in the show. within the comics theres a unicorn who resembles celestia in stature and was the previous ruler of the crystal empire before the whole.... sombra thing. xD she's from the comics and her name was princess amore. she's from the comics. another potential character couldve been radiant hope who was also in the comics. thats just speculation though. idk how cannon the comics are.

That perfectly explains why she has so many nephews and Nieces but no siblings aside from Luna

I had something in mind, Where is Cadance at the end??? We didn't see her anywhere in the future in the last episode, The glass stain showed Flurry Heart but nothing related to Cadence was showed in the whole episode! Tell me that!

Doesn't the Hearts and Hooves day story just mention "a princess?" Maybe whoever illustrated the book was using artistic license, and rather than depicting real individuals, they're depicting what the general population would imagine when they thought of a prince or princess. Since the most recognisable princess in the land was Celestia, of course the depicted princess would be an alicorn. It probably has nothing to do with Cadance. Probably.
I like your theory too though!😊

It's possible that a type of disease killed off the alicorn population, which would explain why they are more scarce. And only powerful unicorns and alicorns can make more alicorns (either through a spell or breeding as seen with flurry) so it's possible that disease happened when more creatures/ponies lived together, kinda like the aztecs getting killed from unknown disease. If not, then perhaps a past evil villain, more powerful then the ones we know, had destroyed the large alicorn species. Or, perhaps they gave up their power to save early equestria, the same way how the guardian of beauty gave up her youth to bring back beauty and harvest for her people.


But as for cadence's past, I agree that the past hearts and hooves day princess is cadence's mother, as it works for the story of her being adopted by a middle class family as a abandon pegasus foul. Because it states that the prince and princess was under the trance of the love potion, and couldn't focus on their duties. Which means if they had a child, they wouldn't even care about the child, meaning that cadence could slip away unnoticed and wandered into a forest, where she was adopted.

I think it's that period of centralization that benefitted Canterlot. The train was a massive boon to Canterlot because of it's central location.

Sawtooth in the description - Flurry Heart in the thumbnail, what crimes will she commit?
Me - She will commit crimes which are even beyond our understanding

In my theory Cadence mother would be the peice we're missing because if Candence's mother is in the picture this would make sense how Cadence got her powers and mainly i mean the power of spreading love so the one in the picture is Cadence's mother.

When Sawtooth Waves show us the photo of the prince in the story….I was thinking if Queen Haven in MLP a new generation because she is a queen of Pegasus and the prince in the hearts and hoof story is an earth pony prince so this is like almost the same
Hope this helps Sawtooth Waves 😉😄

The secret Alicorn is cadence mother and it also fits the history because after that they had foal and as they were not doing their royal duties and weren't doing any of their responsibilities so theyhad left her somewhere and that's how cadence got adopted by earthponies

Sooo... what if the "unknown prince" was actually Sombra? If you kind of consider the comics timeline, he has an established relationship with another mare, Radiant Hope. I do know she was a powerful magic user, so it's possible she became an alicorn (barring some of the comic's events, of course)! Or maybe since the comics and the show have their own separate storylines, Radiant Hope became a princess on her own, was at some point given reign over the Crystal Empire, and THEN our dark horse Sombra comes along and gives the poor mare a love potion as an attempt to control the Crystal Empire--thus kicking off the events you described in your theory. I don't remember the Crystal ponies ever giving a real explanation behind Sombra's power, but I could be totally wrong (I should probably prepare to eat hoof, just in case 😁). What do you guys think?

"flurry heart in the thumbnail, what crimes will she commit?" FSHDHJSJF I-

If you could met the maker of the My Little Pony Friendship is Magic series at a comic-con, the you could ask her a lot of questions about the unknown alicorn princess in the Hearts and Hooves day story.

I think that mysterious Alicorn might be Candice's past like that could be her grandmother or her great grandmother or might be a an unknown Alicorn princess to the world. By the way love your theories.

Well, that would explain Cadence's past a little bit more because we have some side videos that say she was abandoned and adopted by Earth ponies. So, if she was the result of that love potion then they would have abandoned her and the earth ponies would have taken her in. But in your video where you explain where Flurryheart was born an allicorn, you say that because she is the allicorn of love for one's caretaker, she was born an allicorn. Since it was a love potion, Cadence probably wouldn't have a purpose or, just because it was a love potion, she didn't end up being born an allicorn.

Here's a dark theory. The princess in the story had been an alicorn and ruled the crystal ponies and had been Cadance's mom, evidence: a crystal poney instantly called their princess as she swoops in during the crisis in the Crystal Empire episode, moms and daughters can look alike. However, as the story goes the love poison made her neglect her duties, to a point where she was killed and the Crystal Empire fell to King Sombra and its disappearance, only Cadance made it out.

Love this idea, not because I consider it particularly more likely than other ideas, but because it provides lots of interesting ideas for stories when Equestria was younger. (I've always been very interested in fanfiction for additional pony content, especially when the writers are able to flesh out the world with their own ideas.)

from the evidence of what we seen in small moments to comics in mlp many creatures were once able to use magic before the majority became pony controlled I what mean is we have seen magic artifacts from non pony races and monsters having their own innate magic power so could ancient equestria be more untamed with magic and by ancient I mean the rule before celestia and luna's age

i know this is superrr late but hear me out (if you see this)

what if the princess was past chrysalis?

it would explain how she knew about cadence (cadence still being the daughter of this partnership) and her hatred for love after a long time (also her disregard of suitors in the this day aria song) she's also presented with a horn and wings and could maybe explain why celestia was hesitant to fight her and why luna ran (they knew who she was)

it could also explain the changling magic ( if chrysalis was tainted by a love spell and then her suitor eventually died of old age becuase as an alicorn she would live longer than him, a curse may have been put into effect as a side effect of the potion which obviously would not be in the book as nopony knew about it (being ponies, if they used this spell both ponies would die at the same time hence the curse not happening for them)

this could make it possible for her to suck up others love as compensation for her love being gone (unrequited)
her ability to shapeshift may just be what caused her to become an alicorn in the first place (by creating new magic) and then that same magic was passed to her subjects

and also, what if the suitor was sombra?? he's shown as a unicorn and a powerful one at that that denies love (he tries to take the crystal heart) maybe he came back as who he is today as part of the same curse chrysalis had? it could fit into your sombra alicorn theory as he may use chrysalis to get power by making her love him.

maybe he didnt die but when he brought down the empire when he disappeared that could also have triggered the curse?

i dunno, just the first thought that came to mind :)

I thought Cadence was a pegasus first and turned alicorn through that thing she did with the locket or whatever it was with the angry old lady.

But hasn't the show outright stated that there are only 5 alicorns? That if they get defeated, Flurry Heart would be the only hope?

Here's my standing right now..

Cadence was born to the two ponies, but I believe that the Princess was the ruler of the Crystal Empire (hints at Cadences cutiemark). Think about it, how would a dark unicorn (King Sombra) takes over the empire by himself? Unless... there was something going on that prevented the rulers from doing their duties? You can probably see where im going with this, so maybe when the Prince gave the Princess the love potion and both fell in love with each other they had a baby and couldnt do their jobs cause they were souly focused on each other. Then King Sombra saw this as an oppurtunity to take over the empire he killed the rulers and enslaved the crystal ponies and kept Cadence hostage. Then finally Princess Celestia and Luna came to save the empire from Sombra and saved Cadence as well then the kingdom vanished. It makes sense since the love story talked about the fall of their kingdom.

Cadence could very well be the princess from the book and the prince looks a lot like shining armour.

The minor royal thing works, I mean the different races leaders, ie queen novo, prince Rutherford, dragon lord ember, it makes sense to have pony royals as well like king sombra/king colbolt & possibly queen chrysalis/before hand…, maybe even alternate dimensions, like where king colbolt was from, but being a massive impact like celestia raising the sun & Luna, night, it is shown to have them as the bigger royals here, heck we might have our own mlp sailor scouts, with mares like Venus or Jupiter, but my point is minor royals may have given bigger impacts on equestria, like who are lunas and celestias parents?, they could have been minor too.

There is a chance that Princess Amore (who people keep saying is the former Ruler of the Crystal Empire, don't know how accurate that is...) was the one who fell victim to the Love Poison. Perhaps Sombra (with no Royal Heritage or Title at the time) tricked a lovestruck Earth Pony into giving her the Love Poison, and in their newfound ignorance Sombra could steal the Crystal Heart and take over the Kingdom.
An unforeseen consequence however, could have been the birth of Cadence - whether as a Pegasus or Alicorn - and was sent away from the Kingdom when it was doomed to fall.

If not already an Alicorn, Cadence probably still earned her way into Alicornhood similar to the non-canon stories that have been printed IRL, as she was clearly destined to rule the Crystal Empire when it returned, and the concentrated Love Poison Magic would have been infused into Baby Cadence - like how different substances ingested by pregnant women can cause side-effects in the development of their baby.

Personally I take it as a fairy tale or exaggeration. Perhaps the “alicorn” is really a powerful unicorn

In the episode where flurry heart was born, celestia and Luna stated no ones ever been BORN an alicorn in equestria that they know of so . So maybe Cadance was the unicorn daughter of the ruling pony of the Crystal empire . Hence ‘Crystal princess’ .and as she grew older she was put incharge . Then as you said;the prince (most probably comming from smaller region) crushed on her, giving her the potion. This caused her to abandon her royal duties, causing the rise of Sombra . This where the part comes in where you said Celestia rescues her. Celestia takes care of her, as her niece so I’m assuming Celestia had a good relationship and knew the rulers of the Crystal empire(aka candance’s parents). This is where again add your idea from one of your previous videos where you said Starswirl set that alarm of turning ponies with rulling potential into allicorns (she dose something to set the alarm off and fullfiling her destiny).So then she took care of Twilight (to help recover herself) and eventually married Shining. So Celestia felt she had recovered enough to rule again. Therefore sending her back there to the empire . And we know the rest .
I hope you see this :)

you were right about natural and artaficial alicorns but in a wrong direction for example cozy glow was an artaficial alicorn becose when magic was taken away from her she become a pega*sus* and when magic was taken away from luna celestia (season 4) they were still alicorns

Ok but am I crazy or were there other alicorns sitting underneath celestia, twilight, and Luna in that one episode where spike tries to light the fire at some sort of Olympic games at the crystal heart empire but fails??
There was a pony there that reallly resembled twilight too

Maybe they could be Princess Goldlily or Sterling, remember them from the toys?

PS. love how it ended. XD

What if, the crystal princess that was shouted out in the season 3 finale was this Princess? Would make sense why the crystal heart, is, well, a heart. And the resemblance to her mother could explain why the crowd pony called cadance the "crystal princess"

He still keeps the fandom fire burning

I feel like the mystery alicorn princess is queen chrysalis, I mean imagine.. imagine if queen chrysalis once shared love with the prince in a different form, she was probably deeply in love and gave all her love to that prince, but once the prince realized that he was in love with moldy cheese he was disgusted? Which is why queen chrysalis steals love to grief over her broken heart?

It could have been Princess Sterling or Princess Gold Lily

I think the alicorn was Cadences mom ,cause the spell cast on the alicorn was like the spell cast by Cadence .she must be long gone so she is forgotten

Well what if the alicorn in the story was cadence’s mom who was also Celestia and Luna’s sister. And as a consequence of the spell gone wrong in order to free their sister they had to strip her of her alicorn power leaving her a normal unicorn. But as a result of the spell, this unknown sister had a descendent(s) who later branched off on having both Cadence and Blueblood. So they are technically related as well as niece and nephew but with a few added greats to it. So what happened to the unknown sister? She died ages ago since she became mortal

But the birth of an alicorn was never seen before Flurry Heart.🤭

on an unrelated note, the theorist OC ponies are literally their own fandom at this point and anytime there's a little teaser for them like at the end of this vid, I get SO excited

I love your work!

hear me out peeps, I am a little late to the show but I have an alicorn Idea. Like you theorized with each princess representing a bond that holds society, I think that is still true. older siblinghood, younger siblinghood, friendship, love, and parental love all have their own tier of magic. It is proven the magic of love an friendship are two of the most powerful weapons in equestria. maybe siblinghood and parental love are the same. maybe luna and celestia became alicorns after realizing the teamwork (raising the sun and moon) of sister hood. flurry was born one because of her instincts. maybe those types of magic are on a tier stronger than any magic in the whole mlp universe. maybe it takes that magic to be an alicorn. grogar's bell held the magic of a time before those were realized. it held captive the magic of those relationships. maybe it takes that much magic to become an alicorn. your starswirled invented alicorns still works. flurry just was transformed in the womb. coxy glow didn't have one because she used stolen magic. starswirled made the alicorns because of the magic they had through understanding, and his spell lasted atfer limbo. he did not understand how luna and celestia had the power. he just knew he did. his spell detected the power of cozy and made her one too. celestia wasn;t there to greet her because she didn't know what was happening somehow. that is my theory.

What if...
Prince Blueblood was the prince in the story and Cadence was the princess. Sense Cadence is adopted it wouldn't be weird.
Maybe for training for them, Celestia game them a tiny kinda to rule over and BlueBlood wanted a relationship with cadence that she didn't notice or care about.

I think that the story was just a story, that they made them for young fillies who dream big and want a prince Charming. The alicorn in the story could be to contrast importance to the story,

Maybe Mystery Mare was a third sister of the stars. Wouldn't be the first time the topic was brought up in one of your videos.

The Netflix description of A Canterlot Wedding confirms that Cadence is Celestia's niece

What if the Prince died and the princess of love lost all her love with his death. She then took on a new name, Chrisalis, and raised a army against Equestria. Why? She feels that her love was stolen by ponies, and wants to take it all back.

Maybe the Alicorn is caidence mother and caidence broke the love spell with reall love instead of an spell that forced the love. It could explain her cutie Mark and her power.

Cough Chrysalis cough
let me explain:
like you said: "Chrysalis and the changeling could have been in the crystal empire before it FELL("the kingdom fell as a result")" but what if the queen wasn't married to Sombra but to a king before Sombra. They were so in love with each other that they couldn't of notice Sombra. Sombra might have been in love with Chrysalis...
Pure Sombra: asked to take over the kingdom saying the citizens were being neglected and deserved better took over and got corrupted because he couldn't stand to see everyone with so much love while his only love was pining over the former king and destroyed an already week kingdom
Already Curupt Sombra: asks for kingdom doesn't marry keeping the old queen as queen even tho she had no control (highly unlikely)
Cunning Curupt Sombra: asks for a marriage of the queen and the kingdom and destroys the week kingdom because chrysalis wants to be with her lover.
the spell on chrysalis could have broken after the king had died but it also can leave chrysalis bitter especially if the two sisters already had warned her and took her baby (cadence) away because of neglect, she could be shameful and would not ask the two sisters for help
this bitterness from when the changelings changed and let friendship in might have opened up an old wound from her past because she might have felt betrayed if she saw Sombra as a friend. after her hive changed without her into something that what she saw made her week in the past might have made her feel lonely and of course bitter and saw it as her hive hating her and rejecting her by changing into something she saw as weak and vulnerable.

Okie I think I'm finished.

I love that theories and videos like this still exist even with the series being over <3

You know the principle in the friendship games? Can you make a video trying to talk about her. The princesses of equestria (Luna and celestia) were principle and vice priciple of their own school and Cadence was in a lower position in the other school. Yes i haven't watched it in a while so I don't really remember everything. But i'm just so curious of who she is in the pony world. If maybe, she's a secret Alicorn!

it would also explain why flurry is an alicorn. if that mare was cadence mother, cadence was born as an alicorn too. which kinda explains why flurry heart is an alicorn, maybe genetic :)

Maybe that alicorn in the story was the original princess of love but when Cadence got older, she took the title and now she’s the princess of love
I just started thinking about this while watching this seeing as we don’t know what that princess was the princess of
So maybe if that princess is cadences mother, maybe her mother taught her love spells

Do you have any theorie about how Crysalys (I don’t know how to spell😂) can be a Alicorn?

This theory is not related to the video, but what if Sunny was Lauster Dawn's daughter? Sunny's color palete looks similar to Lauster's and this explains why Sunny admirs the mane 6 and have a poster of princess celestia. Sure Lauster is a unicorn and Sunny is an earth pony, but it does makes sense... doesn't it??

So, just a thought here but..... about 5 years ago Sawtooth made a theory that maybe chrysalis had once been an alicorn or at the very least the ruler of something other than just the hive, now we have a theory that the mare in the hearts and hooves day story was an alicorn we haven't met. Well.... what if chrysalis had been and allicorn and the prince that used a love potion on her was a prince version of King Sombra. Maybe he wasn't really in love with her, but was more so in love with her power. He could have made the alicorn amulet by stealing chrysalis's magic using dark majic. This would not only take her majic, but the heart break could have lead to her need to feast on love. There may have been a group of changlings around the same time that needed a new queen. They could have then seen her already part way to being like them and changed her into a changling. Then over time she would have ran the hive and pushed her hatred for love and ponies onto the other changelings, both of which would be founded from Sombra having broken her heart. Then we have the events of the mlp series wherein she would have seen her home changed by the very kind that she had once abandoned after what Sombra did. That very may well bring even more to the story than her just being an average changeling that was randomly chosen to be queen. This past would also explain how she would have the knowledge necessary to have been able to make all of those protections around the hive and all of those majic blocking bariers. One final deeper tie is that Celestia and Luna may have been related to her and encouraged her to mary the aforementioned prince version of Sombra. This could also make her Cadance's mother, and it is possible that Celestia took in her then orphaned neice as Sombra would have ignored her as he descended further into the awful tyrant he became, and her mother would have been mia. So she was exposed to love from her aunts which is how she knew how powerful that emotion was. Plus with this theory Sombra could havé been from a weaker kingdom, and Crysalis could have been the princess of the crystal empire. After all the name crysalis is very close in speel in to the word crystal. You just add a t and drop the ending is. And it is clear that names of rulers and others tend to tie in to who they are, were, or are to be. Then following this theory, putting chrysalis in stone for the 1000 years actually makes sense. Since when she eventually breaks out or is freed it would be Twilight in charge and not Luma and Celestia. Which is good since cyrsialis wouldn't have any direct anger rooted with twighlight. Then you bring in Sawtooth's recent theory on how to reform chrysalis, and once reformed she may actually return to her original pony form from before she was an alicorn, supposed to turning into a new changling form. And if the alicorn amulet could he purified and the majic given back to chrysalis after she is fully reformed, she could work things out with retired lunar and celestia in her original alicorn form and tell them what all happened. After which she could meet her daught and grandaughter and be allowed a title of queen as a cutesy title being the true former queen of two different groups and being the mother of the princess currently ruling over the crystal empire.

And there you have my long-winded theory/head canon of how cyrsalis goes full circle, good to bad to good.

Okay , not related to the video, but i wanna explain why alicorns always have wavy hair that is kinda transparent.
You see, Celestia and Luna have wavy hair but Cadance doesn't. Celestia and Luna are the main rulers so they pocess a lot of power
But cadance is more of a assistant alicorn. So...that means Celestia and Luna have wavy hair representing their power
But cadance doesn't have wavy hair because she has less power than the rulers
Same for twilight, for as long celestia and luna were there, Twilight had less power and didn't have wavy hair. But the last episode means that twilight gained all the power Celestia and Luna had. Thats why she had the long body and wavy hair!

Maybe the tall pony Fleur de Lis was also a descendant of these alicorn royal families.

That’s rly sad for cadence as she would’ve felt slightly unwanted as she was an accident..

Maybe somthing or someone caused a large disappearance of all alicorns
Maybe they destroyed the knowledge of how to become an alicorn to make sure that being an alicorn was seen as royalty
Maybe to get celestia and Luna into power

I really hope we get some answers in G5, since it is a continuation of the same world.

I think Cadance is celestias neice but I don’t know who is that princess in the book. A forever mystery.

If that alicorn was Cadence’s mother, and Cadence had Flurry Heart with Shining Armor, how come Cadence wasn’t born with wings? Or was she..

This is related to the video but I remember you talking about how long a moon is in Mlp. And I believe I figured it out.
So in the Apple Family Reunion, Granny Smith says that the reunion takes place every 100 moons, and since the days would probably be different in Mlp, since it’s a whole different universe we know that it wouldn’t be our normal 100 months (or moons)
Anyways, during the part where they’re looking through the book we’ll see That at the last reunion AppleJack was a foal. And from what we can guess (and from what Google says) we can say that Apple Jack is in her late twenties, so I believe that a 100 moons is about 30 years

If the mysterious alicorn IS Cadence mother, and Cadence is Celestias niece, doesn’t that mean that the mysterious alicorn is Celestias sister?

It's mentioned in the Show that flurry heart was the FIRST born alicorn so I don't understand how cadence would be born one... wouldn't Luna and Celestia have heard of it?

I still think that the woman is cadences mother. Possibly the reason why we haven’t meet her is because in the book it says due to the love potion the kingdom fell down. Maybe cadences mother as well as her father didn’t survive the down fall but cadence did.

But the sad part is these theory’s can’t really become confirmed due to the end of the series.
And sawtooth you should react to the gen 5 trailer :)

This theory is probably true. Why? Because in the crystalling episode the images on the vase used to explain what exactly the crystalling was depicted a mother alicorn. (If I remember correctly.) This could easily have been Cadence's mom. While we do know Flurry is the first naturally born alicorn, that doesn't mean that Cadence couldn't be the unicorn daughter of a disgraced alicorn princess (possibly needing to earn her wings to attone for her mother's mistake? In the hearts and hooves story we're told the kingdom fell. We know the crystal empire fell to Sombra. Maybe that's how? Just a thought.

What if instead of them dieing or losing there magic… what if they went into hiding? Or left to another land? Just a thought

I doubt that Cadence is the princess from the myth or that the princess is her mother. I posted another comment explaining why I think Cadence is young. The myth is old. It was said multiple times that no alicorn had ever been born before, so Cadence wouldn't have been an alicorn just because her mother was one if her mother was the pony from the myth. Also, I think Celestia would try to avoid making the child of a princess an alicorn. It would likely be close enough to when she made the mother an alicorn that ponies would remember that she became an alicorn. Making her daughter a princess could be fine as long as she had no real power like Prince Blueblood, but making her an alicorn could be seen as giving a lot of power to one family and that could cause some outrage or at least frustration among ponies. There is still the possibility that Cadence became an alicorn and her mother was one, but I find it unlikely.

What about the crystal empire? When Cadence toke over after it reappeared it clearly became a client state of equestria but how can an empire be a client of a kingdom?

Ahhhhhh shoot but what about "the birth or an alicorn is something we've never seen" thing. This while royal thing has so many ways it could go. I hope there'll be more vids on it!

What if it the future Flurry heart found a way to remake starswerlls time spell. She could've gone back in time and became friends with the prince and he could've gained a crush on her, infuaniceing him to create the love spell. And once the spell was used there was no turning back untill some pony(Twilight) found the spell plan flurry left behind. and having to go after her and save her.

I thought that perhaps the unknown princess was queen chrysalis? Maybe before she became a changeling? And maybe her becoming a changeling was a result of the prince giving her the live potion

Okay, just checked the episode. No indication other than the illustration in the book that it was an ALICORN princess. And by Prince Blueblood's example, you do not need to be larsoned to be a prince/princess. Maybe the prince & princess in the story were both non-alicorn types, but when the book was written, the author/illustrator took liberties and drew the princess as an Alicorn.
It's either that, or a whole ass-ton of alicorns got killed off, and MLP:FiM just hit George R. R. Martin levels of dark lol

I clicked faster then Celestia could say "CAKE"

I think that the Hearts and Hooves Day story might never have even happened. Just a story, not something that actually happened.

I'm just waiting on you to cover in the first episode a red apple is pit in twilghts mouth but she spits out a green apple it's when shes at sweet apple acres for the summer sun celebration

You know, that male pony kinda looks like doughnut Joe and also maybe the alicorn he had a crush on was a changlling (I don’t know how to spell changelling). Changellings can turn into anything you know.

All right I’m back. So I know this is from a different video but when you said there might be other alicorns that we don’t know of. YOU WERE RIGHT!!! In my book called “the journal of the two sisters” Luna says “ the alicorns thought it was important” so ya.

Luna got younger because she got her short hair when she breaks out of Nightmare moon. The same short hair that she had when she was a Filly. But we see her wavy hair when she defeats Discord so how did she get younger?!

C was an alicorn when she used to take care of T S so she may have been royalty and she must have been the child of the couple.

She may be related to the royal sisters like an aunt or something maybe even a hidden sister

Maybe the time that the kingdom failed because of that love spell is what give sombra the chance to take over the cristal empire

sombra did want power so mabey if he took the other alicorns and then use the memory stone to make others forget them then by the time anyone figured anything out he could have taken what he wanted from them (immortality and magic as he does have a above avarage ammount of magic and lived a long time). and after that if celestia figured it out then mabey she took the others familys in as hers out of guilt? would explane why they arent mentiond as anything pointing to who they were is likely long gone ornow hidden due to the horror of being able to have your family forgoten and not knowing it.

I had a hunch about it being her mother, it’s interesting to see others thought this was possible too

If there is already a princess of Day/Sun, princess of Night/Moon, princess of Love/Family and the princess of Friendship... shouldn’t we have a princess of Nature or something like? Or maybe the princess of Magic or something...

Whatever it it. I accept Sawtooth as an Alicorn.

I guess the Alicorn in the story is Cadence's mother?

HEYY!!! I rewatched the episode and when sweetie bell was explaining what happened with the princess she said “there’s something here about a dragon...... kingdom falling...... CHAOS REIGNING”

maybe cadence was around as a young princess since discord took over ??

The princess in the story could also be Chrysalis, and after her prince died, (since alicorns age slower???) she became hateful as a backfire of the potion, which is why she is hateful and scared of love now

Cadence was born as a pegasus. Also for the Crystal Empire from my little pony books, I think there was a ruler that really looks a lot like Cadence but some people says she is not her mother before Sombra became evil & took over the empire. Sombra also likes a crystal pony named Hope.

Im torn on this one because I low-key believe cadence is the alicorn princess from the hearts and hooves story. Primary because it was confirmed that the princess adopted her as their niece. Which leads me to believe one of the two princesses ( probably celesta ) broke the spell and helped her get to the place she is now and find real love.

At the same time it could be her mother. All though it’s left a mystery of who her mother is ,as cadence is a mystery herself. The first part of her name is Mi Amor translates to my love. Just as Celesta guided twilight she guided cadence in a different way. Once twilight met the princess she got her cutie mark. Maybe it worked the same way. It is said that cadence got her wings after confronting Princess platinum after stealing the magic from the other ponies she used what little she had and that’s when she became an alicorn.

I love your videos and I want to become like you your theories are awesome I hope I can be as good as you
BTW I had a theory maybe the alicorn in the thingy knew about alicorns being associated with royalty and just wanted to live a normal life. They could be one of those ponies who you always see wearing clothes in the background to hide their wings so they can be normal and not royal.

Perfect for my name Maria I think she's the new alcorn from the movie but not sunny I'm talking about the other alicorn

One thing, then why would flurry be beyond Celestia and Luna’s understanding if cadence born to an alicorn mother was an alicorn, also would what happened in the Crystal heart spell not have happened? As she’s shown as a Pegasus there

So what I'm hearing from this is that all the "animation errors" we see are actually real alicorns that for some reason have left their royal status behind them to live normal lives.

The Alcorn in the story is one we don’t know of.But cadence might have freed them though.

In the crystalling pt.2 (or 1) spike comes into the room with this sort of vase showing the history of the crystalling, there were some drawings there that had a few unicorns and pegasi, so maybe one of those pegasi or unicorn was that princess! After all its not told in what part of Equestria it was! Maybe when one of those ponies turned into princesses (so they turned into alicorns) went to Canterlot for some sort of royal event ,THAT prince that made the love poison liked her!!

what if king sombra used the alicorn amulet to steal all the lesser royals' alicorn magic?

Did u read the Crystal siege comic? There was another alicorn: princess Amore mentioned. She was shattered by Sombra, so maybe thats why we never heard of that.

okay here me out. daybreak got rid of all the other alicorns. she has the influence to get rid of the past say she's the only alicorn (ponies forgot here sister). tia also said I will never become you again meaning she did at some point. bit of a stretch but I like the idea of it.

Could you do one on Prince Blueblood because it’s always been a mystery to me he is Princess Celestia and princess Luna’s nephew but who are his parents?

no. See, the alicorn is Queen Chrysalis. I didn't watch the video yet so you may have said this.

Love is the thing that brought her down. She used to rule her kingdom of changelings as the bug creatures we know and love today. Once the potion was used, she was trapped in love.

and now she can only feed off of the love of others...
It would make sense. Literally all the other villains got backstories. Tirek got his, Discord had his, Starlight got hers.
I believe that we also got Chrysalis's backstory. But in a nonchalant, foreshadowing way.
This is your answer. This is the truth.

Since he is a changeling he can easily morfe into the winner of the alicorn raffle.

The birth of an alicorn is something Equestria has never seen

I don't know but one thing's for sure I definitely want to see a male alicorn. There are zero. I want one. Please Hasbro, please.

She reminds me of principal cinch- because do you know how princesses, Luna and celestie are principals??
(Friendship games)

Can you do a video on the stain glass of the student six? My imagination has not gone very far.

Clicked so fast I missed Rainbow Dashs' sonic rainbow..

So, theory request please! If Blueblood is Celestias nephew, who are his parents?

Another question is: Why did Equestria make an event, that destroyed the kingdoms of two rulers, a holiday?

Heres a theory:
What if the princess from the story used to rule the crystal empire? The prince from another kingdom fell in love with her and made the love potion. The potion resulted in Cadance, who was destined to rule. But her parents were so distracted in love, Sombra took over the empire. The kingdom fell, and Sombra killed her parents. Celestia saw the state of the empire but could only save one thing, Cadance. She tokk her in as her niece, and the rest is history. Maybe somepony remembered Cadance, which is why they yelled, “Behold the crystal princess!“ When she saved the heart.

I think that the alicorn from the Hearts & Hoofs day story isn't Cadance but rather her mother,somepony we know very little about like The lost Princess Amore.It is likely that Princess Amore was Cadance's mother and Cadance was born after the "Unnamed Prince" gave that potion to Princess Amore that's why she inherited those love powers from the potion,that explains the similarity between the love potion and Cadance's spell.The fallen kindom in that story must have been the Crystal Empire.One reason why is that when "Spike was falling down with the Crystal heart & Cadance flew majestically and grabbed the heart & Spike,one Crystal pony shouted out 'There's the Crystal princess (Sorry i don't remember the exact dialogue) which means there was or must have been a Crystal princess before Cadance who was also an Alicorn,most likely Princess Amore as she fits the description perfectly and as Cadance being her daughter she was the heir to the throne and the title of the Crystal princess!Another reason is Cadence's cutie mark,if we have a closer look,we see the Crystal heart as her Cutie mark and we know that the Crystal heart is linked or connected to Cadance.I think that her if her mother a.k.a Princess Amore was the Crystal princess,then that would mean she was also connected to the Crystal heart like Cadance is &Cadance might have inherited this connection from her mother,in simple words this "connection" to the Crystal heart is passed on down from one Crystal princess to the next Princess or heir and then the next one and so on and on.....which means Princess Amore was Cadance's mother and the previous Crystal princess.
The " fallen empire" must have "fallen" when Sombra took over and invaded the empire since Princess Amore was too busy in love with that "Unnamed Prince' to protect the Crystal heart and thus the empire "fell' and the Crystal ponies were enslaved by Sombra.Cadance must've been rescued by Princess Celestia or she must've escaped the empire somehow and then Princess Celestia found Cadance and adopted Cadance as her niece.Princess Amore might have died or captured and so must have the "Unnamed Prince".Celestia and Luna might have tried to save them maybe but it was too late.There first priority must've been to rescue Cadance as she was the next Crystal princess and that she was connected to the Crystal heart through her cutie mark and her righful position as the new Crystal princess.Princess Amore must've been too occupied by the love potion that she wasn't capable of ruling anymore or that the potion had some severe and permanent consequences.(And after that the Crystal empire vanished and Sombra captured in North artic snow of Equestria.Cadance would have babysitted Twilight when she was just a filly studying in Celestia's Magic school for gifted Unicorns.Then later Cadance married Shining armor and some time later returned to the Crystal empire when it reappeared after a 1000 years getting her rightful position as the Crystal princess and then stopping Sombra and fullfilling her destiny).And the rest is history ( This other part in the brackets as well.) So how did you guys like my theory,do tell me and plz don't hate me or anything.Whoever that alicorn Princess might be,it is likely she is long gone and if my theory is correct and she IS Princess Amore and Princess Amore is Cadance's mother and the previous Crystal princess then that certainly explains alot!

The bewitching bell might have something to do with the theory. Perhaps Grogar’s victims were members of royalty hence why Celestia and Lu a are the only two.

In other words the former Alicorn princesses died before they got their magic back.

I think the mysterious alicorn princes could have been Cadence’s ancestor. And I think she disappeared with the Crystal Empire. (Or before the Crystal empire). I think she was the ruler of the empire at some point. I think this because in the episode, when the Crystal Empire returns, at the end the crystal ponies recognize Cadence as the Crystal Princess (or something like that). So I think these 3 things (Crystall Princess, Mysterious Alicorn, Cadence) is connected somehow.

You should analyze Cozy Glows cutie mark.

Okay hear me out: maybe if the alicorn in the story is Cadence’s mother, maybe Cadence was born an alicorn. (I don’t think it says otherwise) and maybe that’s why Flurry was also born an alicorn.

what if that unknown alicorn was the mystery identity of Chysalis?

I think that alicorn in the story is Chrysalis a lobg forgotten sister of luna and celestia.
In the madness of love she become a changelin and try to take over equesrtia.
But like Nightmare moon she was defeated and she became only a story for hearts and hooves day.

Sawtooth! If you are reading this that's great!
Well, I was thinking you could do a video on gen 5! because I'm sooooooooooooooooooo hyped for it ! (Call me pinkie ;))
And I want to hear you ideas about it because you really inspirational. I hope to see EXTRODINARY content in the future.
From Crafted Gamer (aka Golden Midnight)

and now you gave me the idea that the next movie might show this one unknown alicorn

My theory is that since cadence is the princess of love I think that she was born on hearts and hooves day and the alicorn in the picture is cadences mother.

In the FiM Wiki Celestia & Luna are addopted Aunts of Cadance, not direct.
Lauren Faust had planed just Tia and Luna to be Alicorns, just this 2.
Cadance was not planed as Alicorn.

I know no Alicorn in G1-3.5, the Princess in that Generations usual was Unicorns.
In the whole Franchise are just 3 real Alicorns (Tia, Luna, Flurry) and 3 winged Unicorns (Cadance, Twilight, Cozy).

Maybe Cadence is a Love Poison, I mean wouldn't it make sense that Chrysalis to replace Shining Armor than Cadence? Cadence is literally a giant food source of love for Chrysalis, and yet Chrysalis only trapped her underground... In a secluded place....so no one would be near her....to drain her love

Maybe raising the sun and moon took the other alicorns power and they had to become non alicorns then the royal sisters came and they simply ended up the only Alicorns🤔

Maybe since G5 is linked to G4, we‘ll be able to piece together little bits of information! :D

Flurry heart, the first alicorn born an alicorn

I gotta watch many times Almost every Sawtooth’s video

The Alicorn in the book has Luna's bang/fringe so in a way I think it's Luna before she got sent to the moon

Maybe there are many alicorns but only some live longer like celestia and Luna others have normal lifespan and they aren't known much as they rule small parts. Maybe Twilight lifespan was small too but as soon as she became the ruler of equestria her lifespan extended

I am sure the new alacorn is caden’s mom😍🥰😍

Cadance is an alicorn even when she was born and thats why she is not only the daughter of the two ponies in the tale but because she inherited the poison into an ability from her horn amaizing idea!

the journal of the two sisters has a character named princess amore and she is the ruler of the crystal empire.

Quacks
Good now i have your attention

The crystal heart had to come from somewhere and we know Candance was meant to rule... right? perhaps... her mother created or became the crystal heart

Maybe the children of Alicorn’s didn’t have a enough praise from the pony’s to turn them in to alicorn like there parents . Except a few alicorn .

I think it's her mother only because when her father and mother drink the love potion and they got married, Cadence was born as their daughter and the potion got in her DNA...and that's why she can do the spell without the potion.

Hold up, if the mare was a princess then it could be the daughter of the unicorns, you know the hearts warming eve story when the three tribes sent their leaders. The female pony could possibly be the leader of the unicorn but she was a regular unicorn when Rarity was dressing as her. But what if she got her wings after hearts warming eve and a male pony fell in love with her since she is royal she could be the pony.

I figured it out I finally figured it out what if the Alcorn princess in the story and the Prince were celestial and Luna’s parents
The potion the prince made may have been in how the Royal sisters came to be I mean sure they were born Alcorns but two unicorns kind of makes sense please tell me what do you think

I think her mother might have died in the war against king zombra ( I think it did happen in the history of equestria at one point ) or hid for her safety.

Ok, this doesn’t have to do with the video but I was drawing and a theory came to mind. So, we know Luna turned into Nightmare Moon out of jealousy and hate right? Now, although Daybreaker was just in Starlights dream, what if that is her evil-pony version? Which leads me to my theory, despite the comics, what if only ponies that are born alicorns can transform and have a evil version of themselves? Like, when Flurry Heart was born, Celestia and Luna said they hadn’t seen a pony born an alicorn in the Equestrias, because the alicorn ‘herd’ that the two pony sisters came from was the only alicorn-born herd. So when they saw Flurry they were worried, a little confused but more worried, because they know since Flurry Heart was born an alicorn, she has an evil-pony version of herself. This is a random theory, and I know the portal makes it so this couldn’t be true because of Sunset Shimmer and Midnight Twilight, but it made me really think about the evil-versions of the ponies, and how that exactly works. Last thing to add, we’ve seen ponies be jealous of other ponies, like Sweetie Belle, but they didn’t transform, maybe even Celestia saying Luna transformed because of jealousy was a cover-up. Anywho, love your videos!!

I do have a theory of why there are no male alicorns, I was thinking that is something that only follows the female chromosomes, so any mare could have alicorn genetics, but it takes something special involvement that relates to magic, to become one and that offspring of two ponies even if it was an alicorn, could not be born as both a colt and an alicorn... I mean, have we ever seen any male alicorns in the show that really existed? the pony of shadows being a possible magic parasite that could have had two separate hosts (one unicorn and one pegasus) and alicorn big mac... well it was a dream of his but never something that truely happened, it would also explain why so many mares can go back and forth becoming alicorns... it's genetically part of them...

Ok what if the alicorn from hearts and hooves day was the original leader of the crystal empire? It was around before King Sombra, it just disappeared under his rule. So what if the original leader was killed because of Sombra? It would make sense, he wouldn’t want anything to ruin his rulership. And cadence was still the daughter of that couple! But before the empire went completely under attack, the alicorn gave her away to someone to take care of her? It would make sense because her cutie Mark directly revolves around the crystal heart, plus being the princess of love and just coincidentally a kingdom made of love just appears? I think there’s more to that than what meets the eye

the king has posted 😔✋🏻

I think chrysalis might of been a alicorn till something happened turning her into the changing queen

The reason we don’t know about the other Alcorns I think it’s because starswirl when the two main princesses became Alcorns he probably put a timer spell on them so they would live long time

She is princess amore . She is cadence's mother. you can research about her . You can read her story in the destiny of flurry heart ch 2.

I still want an explanation for the fact that Blueblood is Celestia’s nephew

Lookin at you luna

Here's something to say something the alicorn princess looks wayyyyy to old for it to be Cadence also I think that the alicorn princess is someone entirely else because if the alicorn princess was Cadence's mom and the story says "They got so lost in each others eyes that they stopped doing there royal duties " then that had to be enough to stop loving a philly and if the cystal emprire still had royals that did their duties and love each other and 𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐢𝐫 philly than for the alicorn princess to be her mom Cadence would've known better in the first place not to cast that spell and before adopting a freaking princess wouldn't Celestia asked her parents what if Celestia asked Cadence where parents lived but she said I live alone because my parents dont love me and maybe thats exlacty why Celestia adopted Cadence as her niece also if you said Cadence was a princess than wouldnt she be in a castle welp thats all I have to say bye!!!!!!

I think you should find out who was cozy glows parents because other creaters have parents and ponys but were was cozys parents?🤔

Dude, you know, it's obviously Princess Amore.

It’s not like every unicorn has love power so cadence must be a decendence from the pony’s in the book to inherit that

We are now forming a Sawtooth Universe. Where all of Sawtooth's theories are interconnected.

It is cool. I really like watching history and stuff

I have a theory maybe flury heart is the alicorn but from the future possibly because starlight opened other allterate universes could have caused flury heart to be older.

Just cuz Princess Luna can walk in dreams it doesn't mean that she can't walk in human dreams

The secret alicorn could also be queen chrysalis because if the alicorn had an accident with the potion it could be if it is queen chrysalis and if the potion did something bad to har it could explain why she feeds on love since it is a love potion

What if other alicorns lived on different planets. In the comics, we do see that their are different planets in space. So who to say alicorns started their own little colonization on a whole other planet.

The secret Alicorn Princess is someone that we don't know entirely because Princess Kayden was born a Pegasus and princesses Cadence mom was a Pegasus tow

what if the alicorn from the story is chryslis?

and she takes love now as revenge?

He fell in the portal...


Sawtooth, please tell me that wasn't a one-way?

0:01- Corn 1
0:08- Corn 2
0:27- Corn 3
0:31- Corn 4
1:07- Corn 5
1:23- Corn 6
1:27: Corn 7
1:32- Corn 8
1:34- Corn 9
1:40- Corn 10
1:45- Corn 11
1:50- Corn 12
1:58- Corn 13
2:28- Corn 14
2:34- Corn 15
2:44- Corn 16
2:46- Corn 17
2:50- Corn 18
4:04- Corn 19
4:12- Corn 20
4:28- Corn 21
4:31- Corn 22
4:43- Corn 23
5:02- Corn 24
5:14- Corn 25

Its a whole field of corns.

You could say it is a-maize-ing

Other alicorns ? Mmmmh...maybe those animation errors were not errors after all...maybe the alicorns that we can see sometimes in the background are the rulers (or their descendance) of those minor kingdoms too ?

And maybe Fleur de Lys WAS an alicorn (since her body design is similar to Cadence's), ruler of one of those minor kingdoms...and when the power was centralized in Canterlot, she gave up her title, and her alicorn wings ?

I think the alicorn in the book is Cadence s mom and cadences mom fell way too in love with the prince because of the potion and that's how the crystal empire fell and king sombra saw that and used it as a target and destroyed them but didn't know there was Cadence who escaped from the help of celestia

Don't forget Princess Tempus. I think she was acknowledged as a possibly canon Princess by Faust??

Saw toot I am so proud of you.

I snorted when he said "Or Luna?" Because I can't imagine her in a scenerio like this

Great vid

I personally think it's crysilas when she hypnotized shining armor

This is not 100% related to this video, but I commented my theory on an older video, that Chrysalis was an alicorn before and something happend to her, or she got cursed, or something, and she became a changeling, and she can't change to any other creature because of that, that is why she refused to change to a good changeling. (I gave a lot more reasons in my original comment)
And how it relates to this video is that other alicorns that we don't know about yet existing just makes this even more possible.

Its not right as cadence s mom and parents even ruled the crystal empire when sombra attacked her mom gave him magic and she went to a earth pony village as she had no energy she left her to the pony there she deafeted prismia by the power of love and she went to the realm where she becomes an alicorn and Princess celestia makes her royal niece and she babysitter twilight and married shining armor had a baby princess flurry heart

heres what i think what happend there were alicorns but due to looseing power they lost there horn/wings im just basing that off of cozy glow and how she turned into an alicorn but lost it

Maybe the other Alicorns had to go into hiding 🙃

Hasbro can get sooooo many ideas from sawtooth 🤔

Hey I have a question what's the future of My Little Pony like is there going to be anything else even if it's just in a different timeline?

Err I think the secret alicorn princesses is

Queen alerga who is the mother of cadence, the father is king Eros :3 I hope this helps

BUT IF Cadance had been born an alicorn then birth of Flurry Heart wouldn't have been a surprise at ALL!

But if Cadence was actually bord an alicorn, why did Celestia and Luna confirm when they first saw Flurry Heart, that the birth of an Alicorn is something that Equestria, and themselves have never seen before ?🧐

Actually there probably was minor royals cause in a episode(I don’t remember the name) it says that the FIRST queen started a tradition

I wanna say she could be a different alicorn where wasn't the story of the potion that was way before the Mane 6 were even born? It could be Celestia and Luna's mother and father or just a alicorn lost in time and forgotten by ponies

I got idea who it is.
When the Crystal empire returns and Twilight is searching for history book, after she finds it she brings it to Cadence and Shining armor (sorry if I spelled it bad) she says anything about queen of the Crystal empire if she was there before King Sombra (wich she probably was) she cloud have died in fight with him, and if every leader in equestria is an alicorn there is big chance she was an alicorn too.

my personal headcanon is that potion from the Hearts and Hooves Day story creates changelings in the long run

This is almost the same for flory heart because her mother is an alicorn but her father is an unicorn but in the picture the prince is an earth pony maybe if Cadence was there daughter she must be an alicorn just like flory but when celestia said the birth of an alicorn is something that equastria has never seen that tell Cadence was not an alicorn

This is almost the same for flory heart because her mother is an alicorn but her father is an unicorn but in the picture the prince is an earth pony maybe if Cadence was there daughter she must be an alicorn just like flory but when celestia said the birth of an alicorn is something that equastria has never seen that tell Cadence was not an alicorn

the princess must be a familiar of cadence because the younger cadence looks like the princess but the princess in the book is older

Sawtooth can you take a look at Blue Blood and then the prince from the Hearts and Hooves day legend thing.

Pls make longer videos sawtooth waves .....i Love your videos alot :)

What if it was chrysalis ,yeah she's considered a queen now but that would imply she had been a princess at some point ,she also has a horn and wings , her whole thing is feeding on love and love potions in most stories can cause a person to lose the ability to feel love ,their soul or even change them physically most often making the victim become undesirable in appearance , Not to mention a mistake could have disastrous effects especially if powerful magic is at play .

What about the comment that Flurry Heart was the first recorded instance of a newborn alicorn?

Could you make a behind the scenes how you make your video's?

WAIT WAIT WAIT it could be cadence actually! cause i remember terek saying THAT HE KNEW THERE WERE 3 PRINCESSES, who were celestia, luna, and cadence. and he was put in tartatus how long ago? thousands of years ago. so he would 1 be unaware of not only twilight being a princess but also. it would mean cadence WAS THERE WHEN HE WAS FIRST PUT IN TARTARUS! i really hope you consider this as a theory cause seriously. the princess DOES look like cadence, and with terek already knowing about her, she would be thousands of years old, maybe more. and again. we dont have proof to say when the story took place, only a long time ago. so i hope you open this theory back up, cause now we have proof saying she would probably be the princess in the story. and they say she was made into an alicorn by celestia and she was born of pegesi im pretty sure somewhere in the series(or one of the comics). so it couldnt be her mother. so please please please open this theory back up. i really want to know what you think about all of this.

I have rewatched the episode "Bats" from Season 4 and guess what? when Apple Jack was having a flashback I think I saw Cozy Glow's Grandmother 😱

I think the Alicorn in the story is different. Why? Because cadence wasn't born an alicorn but her daughter was. Going by genetics and from the one example there is a good chance that if the alicorn in the story was cadences mother cadence probably would've been born an alicorn

It makes a lot of sense for it to be her bc of the lack of other alicorns and how they come to be etc. but at the same time it wouldn’t answer the burning question why it was never mentioned by cadence I mean she had plenty of times where she could’ve said something but then u think it was to painful I wouldn’t have talked abt it either and then you question why she would use the same magic that was used on her there for u want to think she is the product of those to ponies it would’ve been the influence of her father that caused her to use such magic or have such magic but then again with how alicorns work we don’t know for sure if it even would be possible then again all they need is a lot of love and Admiration soo in the end idk which to believe but I 100% with out a doubt know that old ponies tail has something to do with princess cadence

Blossoms!
Anyways it’s possible to have more than five alicorns as princess celestia and Luna should be daughters of alicorns to be alicorns in future or as your previous theory that celestia and Luna were alicorns because of star swirl, but with this video I guess my theory could also be true.

He is clearly the only one who can debunk his own theories 🤣🤣🤣

i have a theory. maybe this stallion earth pony king is celestia and Luna's brother because we don't know if they r the only two in there family. this price must have done something to make them embarrassed to even mention him to anypony so he was never bought up. we also know very little about the two's past so they very well could have a little brother that they tried wiping out of the history books for the potion problem. this alicorn could have been a every day earth pony, unicorn or Pegasus that did a big deed, like twi did a big deed, and became a princess and this stallion could have fell in love with her but she didn't love him back which made him think he had to cast a love poison on her (not realizing it's a poison and not a potion) to make her fall in love with him as well making them married eminently and having a alicorn foal that was dubed the alicorn of love so ponies could remember this event and hearts and hoofs day could be the day that cadence was born because she was the spawn of a love poison. and her love spell i can agree could be from her dad's bad influence that she thought was a good thing and was casting it on a lot of ponies. her father could have tried to make himself sound like the good guy and her mother could possibly have not said otherwise because she would have most likely gotten every bad thing about him erased from her memory by him making them a "happy family". but soon after she met celestia she could have been told by celestia when her father wasn't around about the love poison. cadence's father could have also taught her this love spell in a attempt to keep the poison a thing long after he is gone. therefore lying to cadence her whole life but anyway, after celestia tells cadence this cadence could have vowed to use the spell he taught her for good and on ponies she thinks would need it not fallowing in her father's hoof steps making her existence worth more then just being alive because of a poison. sorry that was so long but that's my theory. i clearly get too into theories. but again sorry. what do u think

if thats the story then cadence's daughter flurryheart might be the explanation of why shes born an alicorn cause cadence had a mother who is one, did celestia lie about not seeing an alicorn born??

This is probably a stretch but heres my theory.
What if the alicorn princess that the love potion was used on was actually chrisalis before she became a changeling? And once she broke free from the spell she became one, wich would allow her to birth the rest of the changelings. This probably isnt true its just a random theory that popped up in my head while watching this lol

Hold up!!!!!!! If Prince Blue Blood is Celestia’s nephew, does that mean Luna is his mother?!?

Actually when we saw the future of mlp, when celesia and Luna were leaving they said "we are leaving to our home (id remember the name)
Maybe that's were the small ruling alicorns live

I think the alicorn from the story is Chrisalis (sorry if i spelled her name wrong

I feel like it's Flurry Heart or Cadence.

imagine if the secret alicorn was chrysalis

I was not Expecting this!! when I saw the title I FREAKED OUT!!

actually, theres something i didn't notice before, blue blood is celestials nephew right? Does that mean she has other siblings? i mean i know she has family but all we here about are the TWO sisters. Then again i might just be overthinking

Luna theory: what if there was an other worldly creature that fed off of jealousy, regret and anger like bad emotions. What if they came across Luna and fed of her jealousy and turned her into to nightmare moon. And the black splotch on her cutie mark could be some of the darkness that didn't escape OR it is a symbol of nightmaremoon, a cutie mark represents a pony and the splotch represents night mare moon. anyways bye (:

Theory:Celestia is the Princess and had Cadence but lied so no one knew Luna stops them she gets so mad someone made a love potion for Celestia and people sleep through the night and play during the sun she turns nightmare moon Cadence is brought up as someone else in the royal family Cadence not knowing Celestia is her mother. Celestia and Luna have long life spans so this could be a contender. But Cadence looks nothing like Celestia so I'm thinking she may have changed her look or Cadence's because in the past she has pink hair. Also the prince is a changing that lives in Equestria and is trying to put a potion on her to steal her love and acts like a descendant prince but kidnaps the real one. I think once the mane 6 rescued Luna Celestia had a nightmare about it all again and in that dream Luna promised to never speak of it again and would never forgive herself until the episode where all ponyville dreams the same thing.

I remembered something from harry potter- if you fall under a love spell your child cant feel love- or is it just a universe or cadance is faking all of the love stuff-

Mlp has come to an ending
Sawtooth: I'm still suspicious about something mystery...🤔🧐

In the diary of the two sisters (the real life one) its said that there was another princess named Amore, maybe its her?

Anyway, no matter who she is, the person’s probably related to Cadence.
But, I think that Cadence would have just past the arguing people. Since she did use her magic, ( I mean, isn’t it a waste when she will need to use it for important-er times?) Maybe the Mayor is the princess!

It’s like Cadance Flurry and Shining
They rule the Crystal Empire
But Celestia and Luna rule over Equestria

Could there be history before what we know of and something that drew the tribes apart

These videos are the only thing keeping me going

Cadence was born a pegasus, there's a book that details this

Okay there I a HUGE question that has been in my head for years..... Is Princess Luna a mom or is there a third royale sister or brother??? Because prince Bluebloods is Princess Celestia's nephew..... you can't have a nephew or niece with out siblings. Could you make a theory on this please???

i had a theory that chrysalis is the alicorn on the hearts and hooves day story

4:13. Correction, 6. Cozy glow

I think it's weird
most of the Alicorns in the show are royalty unlike the other creatures only 1 of them is royalty
like
King Thorax
Queen Novo
Princess SilverStream
like these creatures :/

What if all of the other Alicorns lost to history are just there chilling at Silver Shoals and nobody cares lol.

Also how is prince blueblood celestia's nephew when he isnt the offspring of princess luna who happens to be celestia only sibling?


There's also princess skyla and lullaby moon though skyla was supposedly going to be the orginal daughter of cadence before it was changed to flurry heart


Because flurry =winter rather than sky since you know Celstia =sky or the heavebs which is usually related to or referncing the sky

For a normal pony to become a princes she needs to have the qualities of all three tribes I guess that is the same for the prince too but the prince in the picture has no horns or wings he is just an earth pony so I think it's back then that the tribes were separated like earth ponies Pegasus and unicorn maybe he was the the prince of the earth ponies so I guess that was the first alicorn princess or maybe celestia

Hi, there is an real alicorn hidden in newbie dash, wonderbolt show
https://mlp.fandom.com/wiki/Rose#Alicorn
In her profile: if you go to temporary ---> there is picture of her as an alicorn
I think you should really look into it

Have you heard there's a My Little Pony Gen5 coming out! 😄😄❤️❤️

I still like the thought that Pinkie Pie is Cadences lost sister. I mean think about it. Pinkie looks very similar to her and looks nothing like her family.

Okay, this might make sense but that would only make sense if Cadence earned her wings after doing something major. She looked like a young foal when she was with Twighlight maybe a teenager because she was old enough to babysit. But either way, that means that she did something major as a young foal which is still possible. However, she wouldn't be born an alicorn because Celestia and Luna are seen saying that Flurryheart is the first alicorn that was born. Just a plothole I noticed idk if anyone else said this already.

Think about the time when Chrysalis hypnotized shining armor and what Cadence did😉😁❤ sawtooth if you see this think about it😉 I also wanted for you to do a video about sweety bell and sugar bell same name look a bit a like 🤔hmmm 😂think about it im sure if you see thia sawtooth you will find more evidence! 😁👍 think about it...😉

Maybe king somra and queen chrysalis they got in love by the potion but like you said in another vdo that after Luna and Celestia Sombra got jealous and became evil....I think that's why chrysalis also became evil changeling and gave birth to evil army and the prince and princess who drank the potion became a mystery.

What if the two ponies from the story are Prince Blueblood's parents? 🤔

1: cadence was a Pegasus when she was young 2: Princess Celestia turned her into an À la corn I think that’s how you spell à la corn

Y’all remember on season one ep 3 of mlp rarity talked about celestias nephew!!! We need an explanation

Sawtooth: maybe I should put Flurry Heart in the-
Youtube: DONT YOU DARE
and that's how he got lost in Youtube :)

I have to agree that does raise a lot of questions but it's also kind of scary.

The Alicorn kinda looks like Lyra

Luv your videos they are so amazing when I saw it in the notification I freaked out like OMG!!

What if Chrysalis is the alicorn in the story?

Omg this makes so much sense now
🤯🤯🤯

If your theory about flurry heart being born an alicorn because her mother (cadence) is an alicorn is true, that would mean that cadence would have been born an alicorn too, which isn't the case since flurry heart if the firat pony to be born an alicorn according to luna and celestia

I think hearts and hooves day was founded outside equestria and made its way in

My daughter has a Alcorn that I have never Sean be for

I Think it could be possible That its caydens mom but i Think we dont see her in our future its because as the story says they became too obsessed with eachother That she could not Care for the kingdom so maybe she lost her alicorn magic because of That?

What do you guys Think?

I keep on forgetting that he is a changeling 😁

Celestia and Luna are clearly at least long-lived, if not immortal, but that doesn't seem to be the case for all alicorns. Cadance is the one who demonstrates this; she was visibly younger when she was Twilight's foalsitter than she is in the present, and in the epilogue she seems to be either retired or dead, judging by the window commemorating Flurry Heart's ascent to the Crystal Throne. Maybe she feel victim to a non-aging-related fate, or maybe she's just lazy, but most likely she's getting old. And if alicorns are mostly not immortal, then it's hardly surprising that most of the alicorns over the course of the last millennium or more are long since dead.

It could have been celestial as a younger version

“Perhaps the 6th alicorn is just lost to history....”
Me screaming mentally at the screen: “AMOREEEEEEEE”





And yes i know Amore isn’t canonically an alicorn in the comics but Sawtooth once made a theory that Sombra used to be an alicorn, so Amore could’ve been one at some point!!

me after watching the beginning of story: age spell

@Sawtoooth Waves
Well not much is known about Celestia and Luna's parents to. Who were their parents? What happened to them. And brings the question of Cadence's parents. We know of them now thanks to one of the episodes. But not who is the mysterious Alicorn Princess whom could be Cadence's birth mother. Funny thing jf that Prince that used a love potion on Cadence's mother. End up becoming King Sombra. Just my speculation of the origins of King Sombra. Maybe King Sombra was good at one time. And something or someone attacked the Crystal Empire. Making King Sombra to dwelve ino and using dark magic. And that dark magic made Sombra into the evil King of the Crystal Empire. And forcing Celestia and Luna defeating him to save the Crystal Empire. But Sombra put a curse on the Empire vanishing it for one thousand years. Only to reappear in the 3rd season of My Little Pony Friendship is Magic. Then theirs still Spike's origins too. Like how did Celestia come to find his egg. What happen to Spike's parents. Did something killed them or did they abandoned his egg for his safety, if something was after him. And his patents abandoned him to Celestia and they fled. Never to be heard of again. And what if Celestia knew Spike's parent themselves. And only Celestia knows what became of them.

You're missing one, Sawtooth.

So birth of a very important alicorn could have been a mistake????

5:33 Hold it! did someone saw that rock that sawtooth tripped over?!? 😲😲😲

Bro
Am l the only one who catched that cliffhanger at the end of the video?

I don't see any comments about it..
ω༼'͡•-͡•༽ω

When my baby brother watch the oldest mlp I saw princess celestia was almost spread her wings does that mean she also like twilight that doesn’t know how to control her wing?watch the oldest intro u will see her wing almost spread it’s the oldest intro when she look at twilights picture before she have students

I think that alicorn princess's alicorn magic was stored in the grogar's bell

This channel makes me fascinated

I think the alicorn mare looks like future Derpy hooves/dipsy hooves, am i right or wrong?

me: interesting theory
* deep rumble*
me: what the?...oh...its just fan-fictions

Maybe the alicorn from that story is princess Luna and I think those are her kids that's what I think I know I'm not a good My Little pony analyst but I'm a good analyst nonetheless

I think that the pony in the story of Hearts and Hooves Day is Cadence's grandmother and just like he said instead of cadence is that was the product of this love story but it was her mother so can her mother blah blah blah she found true love and Cadence was made but the influence of a grandfather love potion might have been affected to Cadence genetically that's my theory

I think that um...
Well, maybe the alicorn with the love potion is cadence's grandma
That's possible
right?

What about the fact in your latest alicorn video u said flurry heart got her wings and horn from cadence, so cadence would have been born an alicorn

Imagine if that was celestia 👀 /j

Well, there's books from the creator of MLP. So the books are a bit cannon.

Is a mistake on the drawing staffs part and the thought no one would notice.




Sawtooth: It's a "heart and hoof" story time

if this pony was her mother i do have my own theory that every pony that is a alicorn and gives birth they will give birth to a alicorn the only proof of this is flurry heart or is it? What if cadence is a born alicorn herself? I could not find anything of her in the show or canon that shows her getting wings remember just because i didn't find any doesn't mean there isn't any. Anyway and i also haven't found anything about any pony saying she earned her wings even if any pony did it could just be a lie that she tells people. but i don't know just a little thought

Dear Sawtooth Waves,
Me and my sister think we know who Cadence's mother is!We think her mom is the person in equestria girls who runs crystal prep. In equestria games, we see the principal, it is not Cadence. Not sombra but, her mom. Running the school together as principal and vice principal. We also think her dad is the storm king because the principal, has the storm kings logo on the back of her chair, look at the bloopers for evidence. Thank you so much and please tell us what you think about our ideas. (We are using our mom's computer by the way) - Your fans!

Hear me out what if the princess who got given the potion was Chrysilists and when the potion broke she turned to hatred and that's why she feeds on love

Flurry heart. If cadence was born an alicorn, witch she would have been, then celestia and Lina’s line when they see flurry would not make sense. Because they would have DEFFINETLY been around to see cadence as a foal.
Correct me if I’m wrong, but it just doesn’t line up.

Okay random thing I just thought of- what if that was crystilis (sorry I can’t spell her name) in disguise as that alicorn. She could have cocooned..Him..? (Idk how else to put it) Or maybe another changeling- or maybe another hives ruler. Also- simalar to bees, are there other hives of changelings? How were changelings created? And what hive was Queen cystalist originally apart of?

I think it is another alicorn that was in love potion story.

i deff love the "edit" i was trying to
"edit" like this and its "ugly"😞😭

I think that's maybe princess amore she's in the history of the crystal empire she's not alicorn she's a unicorn she's old ruler of there , but I think she was alicorn but somehow she lost her wings and she's kind caring just like cadence so she could be .

It was Princess cadence Mom also somebody said about the crystal heart Why isn't it Drawing your allure It's very very mysterious

OMG when flurry heart was born celestia said the birth of an alicorn is something EQUESTRIA has never seen, not the Crystal Empire! Maybe that princess was a alicorn since she was born!
Or maybe she was born in the crystal empire, like that other comment i made!

My head hurts trying to figure out that mystery lol

Hey there! I'm early. Whoever found this comment, have a good day :3 (I never got one comments to get 12 likes, Ty!)

Celestiasl's mom is the alicorn princesses in the picture

"MAYBE THERE ALL IN SOME ALICORN CIVILISATION"

(see what I did there)

Although this theory is a possibility, there is a much easier theory that is said in My Little Pony form. If you read 'Twilight Sparkle And The Crystal Heart Spell' Cadence says that she was just a Pegasus as well as an Orphan. She took on an evil pony who was jealous of love and used a gem (which is passed on to twilight from Cadence) to take love from others. But Princess Cadence stops her and shows her love (which also leads to her cutie mark) and then became Princess Celestia's pupil resulting with becoming an Alicorn.

Ok off topic:

I'm pretty old but I still never got my answer qwq

I'm actually confused when human twilight went to ponyville. Like why was she a unicorn and not an alicorn like in the human world? Like she gets wings but in ponyville, she's only a unicorn?

I Imagine celestia and lungs family were looked up to What if the alicorns opposed celestia after she rid of her sister thinking she was a tyrant and celestia took the magic of those alicorns putting it in the amulet leaving her supporter cadence and this is what solidified celestia as a ruler

What if that Alicorn is the first queen of the crystal empire that Twilight talked about in season 3 episode 1

What about the kingdoms ponies like Princess Platinum came from?

I think that happened for the crystal princesse and smobra take over the crystal empire
You know cadence doesn't look crystal

There is proof of another sibling to Luna and Celestia b/c neither of them have a love interest and the prince that treats rarity horribly is cannonly her nephew so who are his parents?

lmao love all of your theories there so interesting




lol hi to everyone who clicked so fast-

Sad dark plot twist : that was Cadences mother.... And father.... Cadence was a mistake that was loved her father and mother were never taken apart and had Cadence by mistake until the father only loved his "wife" and Cadence as a filly mangeged to get her mother away from her father for long enough here's the story.... (Cadences mother will just be called mother and her father will just be called father)
Cadence : daddy!-
Father : HONEY! *runs to Candences mom and bumps into Cadence like she doesn't exist*
Cadence : daddy?
Mother : *see's Cadence and starts to break out of spell a little* honey your child.
Father : what child?
Cadence : I don't.... Exist?
When Cadence was about 10 but not a fillysitter yet
Cadence : mother lets have a girls day!
Mother : ok!
A while later the mother broke out of the spell faster the Cherrlie and Big Mac because she was already slowly breaking out of the spell then she left the father

Like, I'm in the middle of the video when a thought pops into my head, when the entrance into my head clearly says, "UNWELCOME THOUGHTS KEEP OUT!" anyhoo here's my thought. Cadence is Celestia's niece, right? maybe that mare in the story was: dun dun DUUUNNNNNNNN! Celestia's cousin/sister! I hope you look into that.

Also, As I said, This is in the middle of the video, so if im repeating what you said, sry.

1:27 but the alicorn ur talking about might just be a pony cause the rest of her body is not showned so she might not have wings

Him: Is an alicorn that we- Me: DID YOU EVER THINK SHE MIGHT OF DIED!?!

Not first but I will say it anyway. FIRST!! To be real I love you’re vids I am always exited for them❤️❤️❤️❤️

What if celestia took away their alicorn hood or they gave it up to the sisters could be the central power

I kinda want to know how you can become someones nephew or neice when theior siblings dont have any children does this mean there are other suiblings of Celestai and Luna we dont know about?

Celestia only has a sister. Luna, so how?

What if that Alicorn princess was Crisalis maybe when the spell was broken she got so angry that she kill him and became a changeling and when she says that they have no hearts because she had her heart stolen from her

First and sawtooth waves I’m one of your biggest fans

What if to free the alicorn she had to become a unicorn and then just got lost in history

I think it is the first princess of the Crystal empire

Now we know there is also a alicorn🦄🦄🦄

It would be nice if you made a video of Equestria Girls, not so long ago, you made one of Pinkie's clone. In her video, "The 5 lines you need to stand in" she went to a hotdog stand, and it's pretty easy to notice a person who looks like Celestia, and at the end, someone who looks like Luna. Are there clones in the human world too?????

Same pony and alicorn's age when the start to they get flowy mane

Okay so like. We know that the prince and princess became to lovey dovey bc of the love potion and twilight also said that bc of that the kingdom fell. Maybe thats why we dont see much royal families anymore?

If it was from back then on different tribes do you think it has to be Celestia and Luna's mom

What about that one paid dlc from the game loft game— I think her name’s like “Princess Amore”. I’m pretty sure she was in the the IDW comics but then again those probably aren’t canon

I disagree because Princess Celestia says that no pony has been born an alicorn in equestria before Flurry

I was making a video but this is more important 🗿

The only power Prince Blueblood has is the power of ultimate rizz 3:32

I personally think it's just a made up story. Ponys have only seen their princess as an alicorn, so they makeup a story about a princess, they make it an alicorn because that's what they think signifys royalty

In the episode "a royal problem" what if Princess Celestia had turned into day Breaker or something along those lines?

I have a question, if Celestia has a niece and Nephew, doesn't Luna have the same niece and Nephew?

❤️

What I think is yes in the picture it is Cannes mom but the 6 allecorn is lost because she does not have wings

Maybe you think about it for a sample if Kayden the floor feels nice then who is cadences mother that’s probably is her mother maybe Celeste had a secret sister

why are the alicorns/rulers always PRINCENSESS/QUEENS why not KINGS/PRINCES (except King Sombra)

Skews me is it okay if next time you can talk about that window where the students six and The space robot thing because it’s bugging me that no ones trying to unravel the mystery

;3 hi hoomanz-

It isnt her mom in twilight and the crystal heart spell it said “she was a pegasus a infant alone “

Heres an idea from an old tumblr comic.
A Dragon Came
The Kingdom Fell (Could be the Crystal Empire?)
Chaos Reigned (Discord)

About alicorns ageing, Celestia and Luna were born alicorns, which explains why they live so long cause of some alicorn shenanigan. But Cadence wasn’t a born alicorn but that leaves Flurry Heart a mystery unless Cadences mum was a born alicorn. Cadence was a Pegasus and was adopted after her parents mysteriously disappeared. If Cadences mum was an alicorn, a princess in royal line, then her descendants were also alicorns. But in the book neither her parents were pegasi. There is a slight chance Flurry’s alicorn-ness wasn’t from Cadences mum, but a descendant from before Cadences mum. Do you suppose it… skipped? But then someone else in Cadences line made her mum an alicorn. Cadences dad was a unicorn, unless we suppose Cadence was an alicorn after her line of princesss’ husbands. But it isn’t fully direct at all. Unless her mum was a born Pegasus too and got that from one of the first princesses of the line.

Remember the MLP toys of the two alicorns no one knew? maybe it’s one of them.

Fun fact: 8 people can't be first

When you realise mlp ended without celestia or luna getting a bf

We have seen luna became nightmare moon before so what is the possibility that chrysalis was the unknown alicorm who became wicked?

You know, or it could have just been a story =)

The problem with her being cadances mother is then shouldnt cadance have been born Alicorn like flurry heart

Early!

I personally think that it's a new alicorn we dont know

The alicorn in the story is probably dead as a result of her kingdom falling...woah.

I think her mother is Princess Radiant Hope Sombra's crush I assume this because we don't really have Sombra's backstory he might have also been an earth pony you know.

Maybe the princess is chrysalis but before she became what she is maybe because of the love potion she needed more love so she asked a unicorn or some kind of witch docter to make it happen and thats why chrysalis is they way she is

Early

Have you seen other videos on YouTube it's definitely Cadence's mom

donut joe look alot like the prince and maybe Fleur-de-lis was an alicorn but like Sombra got down graded

What if the daughter of the unicorn tribe was the secret Alicorn princess i think she found the Alicorn amulet and put it on and she became an Alicorn for years until star swirl took her magic away.

I read the title as the secret corn and thought that the picture was a piece of corn

Hi

1:11 there are now 7 known alicorns in equestria

ok so get this in seseon 4,terek took magic from ponies ,but he got magic from all the tribes ,so what I'm saying is that Tereck had enoght magic to be a alicorn!

If Cadence is her neice. There had to be a third sister... Since Luna or Celestia doesn't seem to act motherly towards Cadence.

I think it is Luna they look the same and if cadence is celestias neese
well for what we all know Luna is celestias only sis and this might be a frozen situation in frozen Anna is used by Hans so he could have a throne and then he would kill the queen so if this was before the royal sisters rolled over all of ecaestry they could of had there own kingdom and celestias was Queen so this unnamed pony would plan to kill celestia after him and Luna where married but the really of this was the birth of the real first born Alacorn because in the baby sitting send she was really young I think Luna did not tell her sister that cadence was her dauter

Hi

Princes Celestial and Luna has an older sister.

So the dad should have been a Pegasus?
Cause it is said that no baby has been born as an alicorn but flurry heart

what if the secret princess is a unicorn?

Well my theory is that maybe we know the alicorn princess what if...................



The princess is chrysalis, it could explains why she feeds on love and perhaps its why she knew about cadances whereabouts and maybe just maybe the prince is king sombra aka king cobalt,in the hearts warming story he had a daughter that was a unicorn maybe that was cadence that could explain her "urge" to spread love

YOOOOOOO

IF CADANCE IS CELESTIA’S ADOPTED NEICE, THEN SHE’S LUNAS ADOPTED DAUGHTER

If Cadance (sorry if I spelled her name wrong) was born an alicorn, then I think the genes when on to flurry heart sense flurry heart was born an alicorn

but like didn't they say that flurry heart was the first pony born an alicorn??

What is there where alicorns who controlled Things like
Ice
Fire
Air
Night
Day, but most of them died?

FÜST

What if the princess in that picture was Luna and her sisters mom when she was younger and before she met their father

You forgot to mention that sunny is an alicorn

I though Flurry Heart was yelling in the thumbnail because of the other pony.
👁👄👁

Sawtooth has now become one with the Youtube algorithm

E

Why is Luna much smaller than Celestia? Or is she just small? I know she did become tiny when released from the moon but got bigger again soon. Also, why was she filly like when released? And when Twilight got bigger, did Cadance and Luna get bigger?

I think if Prince blue blood and Princess kadience are celestias Nephew and Niece wouldn`t Celestia know there parents? It asks it bit more then it answers.
But also what is the connection between Prince blue blood and kadience?

Why do I feel like king sombra (somba?) Is the prince and the princesswe see got got her obsorbed from him years later after the hearts (cough crystal heart) and hooves day, king got overwhelmed cause the power wasnt his and now he's a red an grey villain king? Idk just a thought I had

I think that actually IS Cadence!!!

First,

Queen Chrysalis was around that time in fact she was a young pony

In a fan comic, Cadence's mom is a princess named Esmeralda

Hold on what if sombra is the boy from the picture while cadince is the alicorn?

Idk about this theory but it might be the fact that the alicorn that we saw might be princess ingrid the eldest sister of celestìa and luna.....

if prices celesta have ness and nephews do that mean luna is their mom or is it a nother sibling?

YES FINALLY I WAS LOOKING FOR THIS

What about Blue blood though? He looks like the male pony in the picture . . .

Maybe the alicorn princess is the crystal princess

Okay I have one question in season 1 rarity mentioned celestia's nephew Prince something is that Prince Princess Luna son I could he be celestia's nephew from another sibling and if he is lunas sun who is the father???

Okay I have one question in season 1 rarity mentioned celestia's nephew Prince something is that Prince Princess Luna son I could he be celestia's nephew from another sibling and if he is lunas sun who is the father???

Once it comes out you should make some videos on MLP generation 5

if prince blue blood is celestia's nephew she must have another sister or brother because it can't be princess luna ?

In the Crystal heart spell song cadence said she was a Pegasus infant alone. Maybe they we so in love with each other they left her alone so she wasn't in the way

Theory time so I think that it's someone else bcz after your previous video I checked what was Cadence's age in season 9 so it told that it was around 200 it means when she was twilight's foalsitter her age can be around 45 or 35and the alicorn Princess we saw in the hearts and hooves day book she looked that she is 150 or something then blah blah blah and then cadence got born but somehow her mother got lost or something else and according to Cadence's backstory comic she was adopted by earthponies and then blah blah blah bcz according to the out skirts of a modest town line bcz she was sent there by a pony who wanted to rule instead of cadence's mom but she got defeated by celestia and luna but then celestia and luna looked for cadence so she could rule instead of her mother I think that place is crystal empire and then celestia took her to be her niece but she thought she was not ready at that time bcz she didn't knew Cadence's age when she was looking for her and she wanted someone bcz she banished luna bcz she said that she raised cadence up under luna 's name that your true mommy will return one day so the end

Technically 6 alicorns if you include the bad one

I think it could be queen chrysalis , because in my opinion she was first ruler maybe the one before Amore . And I think in the book of hooves and hearts day the mare is chrysalis and the stallion by be even sombra or possible don't true shining . I think chrysalis liked him . That's what I think.

what if the mother was part of the older main six.

Ok ok hear me out what if crysilis (sorry if I didn’t spell it right) was that princess but then she learned never to trust love again and that’s why she eats it

Celestia and Luna's mother is a alicorn and her name is Galaxia.

But do earth pony's even have magic? The only one that got magic back when it was returned was pinky pie

Maybe the prince and princess in the picture are the parents of celestia and luna

Hi sawtooth waves I think the alicorn is cadences mother but maybe its not it might be a different alicorn.

Remember that Queen in the movie or something in the play in Canterlot that Queen might have had Prince Blueblood or another Prince maybe not a prince at all

What if it was Celestia & Luna's parents?

What if cadens mom IS christalis? 🤔

So, if blue blood is celestias nephew. Does that mean that he is lunas son???😳

I think it might be parents or an Aunt maybe even grand parents

This got me thinking, what if it’s chrysalis? I know this sounds dumb but she does have wings and a horn. Sure she’s not a pony but what if she was once? The Alicorn was put under a LOVE spell and the spell can easily go very wrong so maybe the alicorn got addicted to the love it gave her? Turning her into a love hungry creature, chrysalis. Maybe when the alicorn started consuming love from other ponies it turned her into a changeling because the power the love gave her was too much? In the movies the villains always turned into a creature from too much power so maybe it could happen to the ponies in the world the magic came from. It would explain why she was the ruler and why the changelings were only able to feel full with love from other creatures. Now another thing is how the changelings became a whole hive. Maybe the alicorn wasn’t the only one consumed by the love, maybe the guy got consumed too. Them together would probably make babies...? But the hard part about this is where would he be now? I was thinking maybe he couldn’t handle the power and eventually died from it leaving no trace of him... another way to go about this theory is maybe chrysalis wasn’t evil at one point...but when the guy died she became even more love hungry, since she didn’t get love from him anymore. This theory sounds kinda far fetched but it was fun to think about:)

Can you do some theory about princess larva? We only had a toy of her

What if king sombra was the prince in the story 🤔?

I know What is the secret alcorn princess's name It's princess Amore

Pony revolution. Pony guillotine. wham bam no more royals ✨

Okay, this is super random, but I can't find season 9 anywhere except amazon, where you have to pay like 40 dollars us or something. If any of my fellow Canadians know where to find it, can you please tell me? I need to know exactly what happens, not vague spoilers!!!!!

yes it does Sawtooth which is sad for Cadance's family :(

Can you please do the Seventh element theory please there is lore behind and everyone is saying that it is spike that is representing acceptance.

has there ever been a male alicorn?

Eden’s mother is a unicorn princess

what if the princess in the story is no alicorn but a unicorn

what if the secret princess.. turned into Chrysalis ? It might have been a curse or aftereffect of the love potion. What if it corrupted the alicorn, turning her into Chrysalis and thats why Changelings feed off love or why chrysalis is so aggressive towards friendship and royalty...?

OI heres a question for you to answer, how is Celestia prince BlueBlood's nephew. The only sister Celestia has as far as we know, is Princess Luna. EXPLAIN!

Right when he said secret alicorn I got a add about my little pony saying new princess alicorns in the all new pack XD

The question is.. If the story is true..

This stuff is soooooooo cool❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

That makes it sound like Equestria was the holy roman empire all over again

Man this allicorn stuff and royalty stuff just sorta throws my oc out the window lols

Maybe a huge earthquake or something happened because of some ponies trying to oearn more but it sent wrong And created a huge disaster witch caused a lot of the royals to protect their subjects but die in doing so but some survived and continued to rule but over fewer subjects because they fear if there are to many ponies another crazy pony will start another disaster.

I think it’s a secret our coin because if you pay attention to the show you will realize something well if you seen the movie but there’s something interesting like that and tell you I might be the most clumsiest pony

What if that alicorn was queen chrysalis!

I think the pony in the story is dundundun celestia but the prince in the story died years ago because he wasn't immortal

if cadence is celestials neice, that means cadences mother is celestials sister and lunas sister

Cozy glow was the 6TH allicorn

Just saying the alicorn in the heart's warming tale story is definitely not cadence I don't have any evidence of that. * Sorry*

Sawtooth you are royalty.

I think that the mother maybe d- by giving birth or the love potion worked off

She could be princess amora cadence mother she ruled crystal Empire as u said the love potion made them forgot about their royal duites

Okay so I think you're correct on it could be kittens is mother and father but what I'm thinking is that the princesses retire so maybe the father mother retired and are in the show

Someone help, you know that we have 2 twilights,but why we dont have sunset shimer

The ancient princess cant be cadances mother because her mother is the lost crystal princess she is princess amore surprisingly she is not an alicorn she is a tall and elegant unicorn

I think it’s The queen chrysalis Past time in the love before coming an evil Psycho

Wait wait no flurry heart. Celestia and Luna said that a birth of an alicorn is something they never saw so there can’t be previous alicorns

I believe it was Cadence's mother because Cadence was a Pegasus so she can't be a alicorn back then either she could only be a full back then because how would she be a alicorn right now

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH, This is awesome 😍💕❤️😘😍💋🌹💖

THAT'S WAT MY MIND SAID WHILE WHATCHING THAT VIDEO


I was like "hm her mother maybe I mean the power that cadence has so maybe it must be he mom"

Their actually is another alicorn her name is kauane

Hi Sawtooth I love your channel but I have to disagree but I have a new answer it is pause for dramatic effect dun dun dun dun Luna you heard me right I think this because Luna and Celestia are thousands of years old and what made me think that is Luna is… That is why she is never noticed and hides herself in the shadows (Meaning she is sort of secretive.) Well that’s my disagreement.❤️❤️ your channel please please please reply and if you think I’m rong prove it if you think i’m right explain.🌑🌑🌑🌑🌑✨✨✨🌟🌟🌟🌌🌌🌌.(these things represent Luna byyyyyye.)

Here is a funny fact princess amore was the first princess of the cristal empire 🤔🤔

Ok this is my second comment

I did watch many of ur Alicorn videos maybe even all of them
And yes my first comment said that Luna was still nightmare moon in the moon
So this is how I think the alicorn royal families rose and fell


For the basics this would take place during the celestial era which began after nightmare moons defeat and ended when nightmare moon returned

What we only know is that 1. The summer sun celebration and wonderbolts were created
2. Apple smith and her family was the key to founding ponyville
3 the rainboom happened causing twilights magic to activate making 5 others cutie mask + celestia taking in twilight

Because of these two big gaps in the timeline This means that royal families existed before twilight came into the mix
So here’s the full story (spoiler warning: I did made some stuff that could have happened but just let that sink in)





After nightmare moon was banished to the moon and the summer sun celebration+wonderbolts were created
Some powerful ponies had the idea of getting lots of support becoming alicorn and soon royalty and families

One pony named waterfall droplet a popular female unicorn married with a male unicorn and after marriage
They got real popular, getting exposed to all magic from all different tribes soon they became alicorns

Soon this idea spread throughout equestria and alicorn populations started to grow

Soon there were now 120 alicorns during the year of 1629
Some even made nations of their own

But then ponyville came in and celestia had more popularity (not because she founded ponyville :/ )
Some royal families had to learn that celestia resign was,ore important to the others

Soon there were 54 alicorns left

And then one alicorn drank a potion made by her husband they fell madly in love until it took control of them

Celestia had to separate them in order to break the spell

Soon royal families realized they had lost popularity due to what happened to the couple
Soon all royal families were separated and their alicorn magic faded away and due to their longer life span going away they lived until death from old age

Soon twilight came in taken in by celestia, made some friends, defeated nightmare moon and did all those those other stuff making her and cadence an alicorn

The end.





Until cadence gave birth to an alicorn named flurry heart who soon made it confused

And that’s how the alicorn royal families rose and fell

EQuestria sure it’s full of mystery

I think it’s the pony from my dear Luna

i think we are missing someone AKA Queen of the cristal empire

I think the alicorn princess might be katence mum

what about the queen and king character that only showed up once in mlp? I don't remember the episode but they were right next to the two princesses at the time. If I remember correctly that episode was before Twilight was a princess, but I mgiht be wrong

why do you always say two particular people angrily when mentioning alicorn tier

What do you use for your Oc? I have been watching you channel sence 2015

Or maybe the pony in the story couldve been a Pegasus and when flurry was born thats why everyone was shocked maybe cadance couldve been born with wings and a horn aswell, but idk maybe im talking non sense but couldve happened who knows 😅

It's chrysalis, Celestia is the shows true villan

Now then gen is out I wonder if this mysterious pony is the origin of villain opline

what if starlight is twilights sister because they have strong magic

There are or use to be Tribe of alicorns not in Equestria. Which is why Celestia and luna were shocked flurry was born IN Equestria. It's rare.

Hold up Luna and celestia we think don’t have foals but if they have nieces and nephews that means they have other siblings.What if they had 2 brothers!I can imagine the one closest to Luna would be midnight (he might be a bit quite but friendly).The one closer to celestia would be called ray(a selfless colt).that’s how I imagine it at least, but it is a bit weird.

I think the prince is the prince from the gala. When Rarity saw the prince

Cozy glow ! If celestia didn't give her wings or a horn how come before she met grogare shevwas an alicorn

Really? maybe its princess cadence although I love this theory

Awesome and cool!

Well we’ll never know ‘cause season 9 ended like 2 years ago... so we’ll have to find it out our selves

maybe cadence is not the princess in the hearts and hoof day but maybe just a thought the princess in the hearts and hoof tale is cadance, great great great grandmother because sweetie belle did say '' a long time ago'' so we don't know how long was the long time ago just a thought

it could've been Princess Amore

But bye this theory candence was born a allacorn but from the sisters we know that flurry heart is the first one

Why didn't the mare have a horn?
I think the mare is a Pegasus

Nice hey can you add that unicorns and Pegasus are earth ponies too

NOOOO SAWTOOTH PLEASE READ THIS.

Cadence is princess Celestia's and Luna's niece. Meaning that PCelestia and PLuna had a sister who is the alicorn. I think that because they are both alicorns so they could have been born as them along with the extra sister. I think the extra sister fell in love with the stallion and had Cadence.

PLEASE I HOPE YOU READ THISSSS I BEG OF YOU.

you said that Celeste ya could have the princess of love as her as her niece, but that would mean that she would have more than one sister that would mean Loona gave birth to the princess of love, Luna's moon, which has no connection to love so technically you're wrong, but I still take your theory, but it would have to be someone of celestial bloodlike her sister, maybe she had up well, there you don't know a unless it's Michael, but now I like twice, I was a baby with you was like, 15 so technically yeah

HiIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII! i have watched you for a while now but i have a question when the storm kings magic escaped equestria and entered the human world and rainbow sunset and twilight went to the pony world human twilight discovered the magic of friendship and had wings in the human world but when she entered the pony she had none does this have something to do with her roles a a student not a principal ? or the time difference in the moon cycle? what does this mean for the people that have wings in the human world like rainbow and fluttershy? are pony twilight wings artifical or something? I NEED TO KNOW

WOOOW! The Game of Thrones in MLP XDXDXD

can only female ponies be alicorns?

I realized while watching this that prince whatever his name is because I don’t know how to spell it is not just celestial’s nephew so he must either be princess Luna’s offspring or Luna and Celestia have other siblings!!!!!!lol

Its queen chrysalis thats how she became bc it kinda look’s like it :3

I think that when luna and celestia were still little ther were multiple royals, and one of them were cadence's mother and hr father was from a diffrent royal, as she grew up cadence had a rough childhood, so when celestia and luna where older they went to cadence's place and took care of her, and cadence parents kingdom went down and the other kingdom was very near too so canter lot was the last royal place left and celestia and luna helped buuld the kingdoms with cadence, they decided too not let the other old kingdoms to have a ruler and just be a normal town. And thats my theory so yeah sorry if its long

Maybe but Celestia said that flurry heart is first born alicorn so i don't think Celestia would not remmember that she born Cadents

But the mare can't be the mother of cadence because no pony has been born as alicorn

I personally think its prince blueblood and cadence since when they were young LOOK AT THOSE SIMALARITIES

I think I know who Cadance’s mom is




ITS PRINCESS PLATEN/Rarity when she played at the play
I saw the video when u said that King (forgot his name) lost his wings and that his daughter was princess platen what if he gave his wing to





PRINCESS PLATEN

My theory about alicorn become alicorn : because equestria need it . Like princess celestia and princess luna. they become princess sun and moon because when the princess siblings age there's still a problem about sun and moon raising even star swirl have a problem about it to he need seven unicorn to help him. The alicorn of hearts and hooves day maybe once a princess of love in celestia and luna where they still young era and in that era's she became an alicorn because she can solve love problem in that era and maybe because she's dead or something cadance replace it as the second princess of love and how she become an alicorn is the same as the alicorn hearts and hooves they solving live problem. I mean twilight became a princess because she solving the mystery from star swirl with friendship and flurry became an alicorn because crystal empire need more light.

I really bad at English

IT WAS ME! I WAS THE ALICORN ALL ALONG!

I think that celestia and luna are immortal because they used to be connected to the elements of harmony such as the pillers and maybe even the mane 6 and spike and young 6. So cadence may not be immortal. But if she were that would be quite sad since she wouls lose shining armor. So that alicorn might be dead. And now that the mane 6 has been connected to the elements fot a while, they might have felt their own connection disappear and so their immortality. That s why they retired, they might feel their end coming up. After all, why would they retire just to spend the whole eternity doing nothing?

Him and the royalty in the ep Twilights kingdom part 1, those royals weren't alocorns

Ok this isnt relevant to the hearts and hooves storys but all the principals in equestria girls was alicorns so where is principle cinch she would in this logic be a alicorn in the pony world wich means there is alicorns we have never seen but since most of the personalitys is the same with both human and pony i dont think that princess cinch (sounds wrong in my mind) is the alicorn in the story but cinch is probebly an alicorn and my or my not be out there (i will say i got this theory on a picture i saw on insta that pretty much said that cinch would be an alicorn so shout out to that post)

Celestia mother is Queen Galaxia and cadance mom is princess Amore

okay but isnt Cadince (idk how to spell) Twlights cousin or Aunt? (I cant remember) I mean, how would that affect the Famliy tree of this theory and timline? 👁️👄👁️

Edit: Lol babysiter I am dumb. Nothing would affect the timeline nor Family tree...

Completely unrelated to this video but since it is something to do with mlp,
Is anyone else excited for mlp G5 to come out?!

I have some dogs that are married and I know that they have not had a wedding they are just married same for other animals like horses. Horses are like ponies and ponies are like Pegasus and Pegasus are like unicorn and Alcorns are like Pegasus and unicorn so I don’t think any of them have had a wedding it’s just the two of them love each other A lot

I have one idea that we could theories

So you know that scootaloo is rainbow dash’s sister. In the show we not only see rainbow dash parents, we saw scootaloo’s parents too.
We met rainbow dash’s parents but scootaloo didn’t notice that they were rainbow dash parents.If scootaloo was rainbow dash’s sister then she would notice that it was her and rainbow dash’s parents a lot quicker.We also saw scootaloo’s parents which is a different colour. So why are they sisters even tho they have separate parents?

if cadance is celestas neice then that means that celesta has another sister

It's obviously cadence's mother 👩👑

4:00 if this is true, Twilight is related to Celestia. Twilight:😯😮😀😃😆

i dont think cadens and luna or celestia was the secret alicorn i think all princesses known her exept twighlight cuz in google i shearched is there a secret alicorn? and it says the missing princess so can it be her and she was missing!

or maybe that alicorn is princess Admore?

Princess Cadence is the adopted daughter of Princess Luna and the sister of Prince BlueBlood. So there is no way that she is Princess Luna’s real daughter.

What about the old princess from the crystal empire before sombra

I found Princess Cadence mother her name is Princess Amore😀💓💖💗

Im kinda curious what would happen if the equinox ponies tryied to invade equeastria who would win and why

It could be Celestia mom

How is Cadence Celastia’s niece? Who are Cadence parents then?

Hmmm I think its Celestia's mom.

Wasn't Cadence born a Pegasus?

Twighlight Also earnd wings

Thinking about something and I got it another Creacher are the king and queen like queen nova she look like cadance mom she is hiding it because king sombra can't find her she is sooo powerful and celestia ' mom is powerful too you know

six! If we are including Cozy glow. but techinally she isnt a true Alicorn

and I think that those royals are Celestia Luna Admore Chrysalis and Sombra

2 questions: 1-Do Aliens exist in MLP? if so then 2-is Cosmos an alien? This character from the mlp comics because she comes from space off the planet so you think.

I think that if Cosmo is the closest to an alien seen in mlp because there are time lines and dimensions with many species, it seems strange to me that an alien has not been seen or is that only Cosmo is the closest to an alien.

It could be the mother of Luna and celestia ?

Imagien if the people who drew mlp just accidently drew wings and this guy makes two 16min vids

Celestia's lost sister! (No...)

I think cadence and prince blue blood might be siblings

Maybe it was twilight on hearts and HoopsBut heart and Hops day WasaLong time ago so Maybe it was princess Celeste Tia or princess Luna but the secret it’s too deep so baby it’s twilight

The secret alicorn is Chrysalis

Could apple jack parents still be alive im mean they could just be lost in unknown lands in equestria

But if Cadance is that old then her relationship with Shining Armour is wrong on SO. MANY. LEVELS.

Cadence was Originally a Pegasus

I think it cadence mother since cadence gave birth to an Alicorn, Cadence could have been born an alicorn.

i think that the princess could be cadences mom and the prince her dad maybe but like the prince looks like the donut pony alicorn fan made thingy

Wait so if Prince Blueblood and Cadence are the niece and nephew of Celestia, then are they brother and sister? Or did Celestia and Luna have another sister/brother that had kids in resulting to the birth of Bluebloodn and Cadence??

Ok same question is flurry heart still alive during the new gen Is she I mean it’s a gud question

Celestia just have another sibling other than Luna if she has a nephew (Prince blueblood)

Princess amore the original ruler of the chyristal empire

Who is blue blood? Nephew? 🧐

Mom of the galaxia is the mom the daughtur is luna and celestia

It kinda makes sense now of cadence giving birth of an alicorn

It could be her mother and her dad

it can be if cadance's mother it makes a mystry but the alicorns can lose majic what if they where banished in a world like limbo and more

I think Discord likes Princess Celestia

How did cadence get her cutie mark also when did she get it and why is it the crystal hart?

what if the alicorn was princess chrysalis and the spell somehow turned her evil bcs if im sure she's know as the princess of love and bcs the spell she was madly in love and thats why she feeds herself with other ponies love

When you used to think that mlp was just a little kid show you watched when you were 5 👁👄👁

or its chrysalis how she used to look in the past

like Hasbro has to make many portals to many other dimensions, unknown lands, past, future
So that Hasbro can continue the season of my little pony friendship is magic again
And don't forget Luna and Celestia returned to being queens and Twilight became evil characters many times so Luna and Celestia returned to being queens and promised their people
Luna & Celestia won't stop being queens forever
And so also flurry heart Dan Cadance together rule the crystal heart kingdom

Sawtooth waves actually may be eaten it is princess cadence the blue bro good with the print it’s

Or maybe queen chrysalis used to be a pony before and she pay different time

What if chrisallis was that alicorn like maybe she has been seperated from Her love and noqw tries to find it

What if the princess was chrysalis and and because of her alicorn blood she out live the prince and after he died because of the love potion she no longer could love so she started to steal love to try and eventually became the changeling queen.

Could cadence be born an allicorn

It Could Be Accurate For That To Be Her Mom Or Where Else Would She Get Her Make People All Goo Goo On Eachother Magic

Maybe twilights new taker to be a new her might be sunny mom in the new mlp g5 movie that’s why sunny became a alicorn

I love Alcorn🦄👑

Cadence,s mother is the one who is there.

Hello I am a little and I was just thinking what if you have the magic from two tribes Like to be a unicorn or a Pegasus

What if cadance time traveled

IT'S HER MOTHER!

Flurry what are you hiding??!!

If you think about it in one of the episodes regarding the Galla, rarity wants to meet queen Celestia's NEPHEW!!!!! But it's not Luna's son!!!!! So they have another sister!!!!!!!!

Well it could be her mother

Well I mean- Prince Blueblood and Princess Cadence are apparently Celestia's nephew and niece.. But uh- Has anyone actually wondered how that works? I mean- They're obviously not Luna's kids, right? So.. Maybe there is another alicorn sister we're unaware of. Or brother. Who knows.

Well the mystery princess can only be…. PRINCESS STERLING AND PRINCESS GOLDLILY they wher mention in the cutie mark magic toys mlp

I’m VERY late :> but my theory is that it’s cadence’s mom that died long ago in the history of MLP maybe the heart and hoof day was just a celebration for people in love and not just some . Crazy love potion who knows maybe cadence’s mom is still alive and well and from cadence’s oldest home but I think she is dead and cadence’s mom is celestia’s and luna’s sister and they broke the love potion for the kingdom of course cadence’s mom had a kingdom for herself far away from her child’s one who knows what gibberish MLP is hiding
and I think that cadence’s mom was not “in love” with the person who gave the love potion maybe it was just him who was in love and not cadence’s mom I think cadence had been an alicorn all her life because I never really understood why she came an alicorn I think she was born naturally with it her mother was an alicorn and if her husband had been a unicorn or . Pegasus then her daughter would be one naturally born just my theory tho sorry for some miss spelling

Ok we have nightmare moon and we have daybreaker and we have midnight sparkle the evil version of human Twilight Sparkle how about Heartbreaker I mean cadence

your channel is awsome!!!!

Are you gonna talk about G5 on this channel too?

Why is there a flower in his mane?

Queen Chrysalis is a alicorn has a home and awings. your eyes!

Why do I feel like since furry heart is a new born so before she was born she was the princess who fell in love and then the king killed her? Or she might have died from old age

I think it’s a alicorn that you mite not know but I think it’s the mother of celestia and maybe caydence doesn’t have a mom

But cadence was a filly when twilight was so this makes no sense at all.

celestia is most likely to be the pony

I think the secret alicorn is cadasese mother

Can you do one of princess cadence mom

What if chrysalis was her mother, chrysalis would have ruled a land of her kingdom where ponies and changelings lived in peace. But one day a colt prince from a different kingdom is going around equestria to find a bride, he eventually comes along chrysalis kingdom. They meet and chrysalis does not feel it necessary for her to have a partner when she has shown she can be a strong leader, so the prince keeps trying and trying with no success. Untill he finds the love potion. He uses it on chrysalis and she unwittingly is in love with him, and the out come of that would be cadance. I think that at this time chrysalis and celestia where friends, so once cadance was born chrysalis gave her to celestia to raise as her niece. Chrysalis try's to gain back her kingdom with no aval, well except for the loyal changelings they get banished from the kingdom. That's what I think.

i think the book's princess is princess cadance.

Who else love princess cadense

I think the secret alicorn is actually not a princess but she was queen chrysalis before she turned evil

What if that’s a princess who had a future but then she didn’t because she was not in love with the prince it was because of a spell.

what if big mac was the prince they look a little simular.

Cadence was abandoned and adopted by earth ponies also check out the comments Sathwooth same topic

It can't be blue blood he is a unicorn and the horse in the pic is a earth pony

But chrishlalus has wings and a horn so is chrysalus an alicorn?

She is flurry hearts grandmother

what if it were luna that makes sense cuz celestia just happens to be cadence's aunt

I mostly think that the alicorn we see on the book is cadences grandma why i think that well i fell like it and i am very positive whitnit

It's cadence mother and now she is a legend and cadence father is legend too now

It says Equestria so Luna and celestia can be an alicorn in birth

So Is She Truly 100 Princess Cadence's Mother?

In my opinion i think cadence has a sister and not shining armors sister but i think cadence has a sister

oh oh i know who is the secret alicorn it should be queen amour she ruled crystl empire before cadence

I don't know because the prince just to make a love potion if you keep them away from each other the spell will break

Princess amore was the heart & hoof day story alicorn and cadence complete mane is princess cadence mi amore + princess amore was real crystal empire princess

I think it princes miya Mora cadnsa's
Mother

Queen chrysalis is a Alicorn

Princess Gold Lily or Princess sterling ?? There was a Yellow and light purple princess G4 toy released

There is one more alicron. There are 6 not 5 the alcorn

Celestia and Luna‘s mother Galaxy and their father which I don’t remember the name

Tey 8 Alicorns in Equestria : Celestia, Luna ,The Alicorn we dont know, Twilight, Flurry Heart, Me Shine Star,Delta Brony and Luster Dawn but Cadence is NOT a Alicorn because in Day aria we not see real Cadence ’s Crown so Cadence is a pegasus.

I think it’s not an Alcorn I think it’s a Pegasus or a unicorn but definitely I think it’s 19 and says she passed away thank you and so so family so I guess that he gets his mama gave her wings actually so nice to give her wings to graduate from high school and and so on so Takumi she was a family and she was I thought she was one left that was a

did we see timber's dad?

I completely forgot that you're a changeling😳

its maybe the first ruler of the cristel empire

What if the princess wasnt an alicorn at all that would make other new stories

Ok now you aren't even trying to hide it, whats with the flurry heart in the thumbnail.

Am I the only one who think that pony princess from the story may bee Queen Chrysalis? and that may bee why she is the way she is in the series? You know that the two of them wanted so bad to be closer, so that she got another potion so they could become one or the potion did it somehow. She does sing in "This day aria" "In my heart there is no room" be course that somehow the prince is part of her?

is princess cadance born as a alicorn?

what if the princess was starlight

Mabey those are Luna's and Celestiia's parents

I have a theory my theory is about cadence mom here my theory: if there is a secret Ali oen princess and as he said it might have been her mom ( or did he? ) I think there is a has ro game called my little pony in where 5ere is this unknown princess I don’t remember her name but she and pink hair purple fade and a snowflake type cutie mark what if that unknown Alicorn princess / queen is candace mom and she is the princess in the story could it be possible? Let me know what u think it was nice sharing my comment wiht you!?

Cadence's mom maybe?

Who says she was a alicorn?

Hey Crystal spell fit this cadance mother and father were lost and didn't take care of their child then cadance got lost and then the crystal heart story

It could be cadence's mom as you said that it is not the other princess and cadence was not there as you said it could have happened before her birth.

TWIGHLIGHT IS AN ALICORN

What about the ones in the game XD yup totally cannon alicorns XD

I think that his parents have government job in Equestria like mayor mare and why it said he's a prince

Cadence started as a Pegasus.. she wasn't born an alicorn

trick question what if it's amore, the original one from the comics

The princesses in the picture is a alicorn we don't know but the alicorn is a princesses

What if the alicorn in the story is not a alircorn but a missing tribe not in the story??

Do luna and celestia call each other sister because they are real sisters or because they are both alicorns so they just call each other sister.

The prince have a same coler hair as cadace

Can you pls make a video about Luna

I think it was her parents but they divorced and vanished..so that’s why cadence love helping love

I think it was her mom

It was Pinkie Pie she dreesed up as an Alicorn don't question me I'm positive

Ok ok but. What about the prince...

She could be cadens mother princess amore

What would happen if discord went into human world?

Lol in that time Luna was wasn’t there so it was just celestia

Luna was still nightmare moon in the moon



I know it’s just an error

Don’t get mad

The princess cadence is daughter of Amore

I love 😘 your videos

if cadance was born with wings AND horn i think its like a gen thing i mean flurry heart was born with them

Could discord and chrysalis where candice parents to the heRthsday

My Giant Human: Warship is Magic

Not blueblood . The pony in the picture does not have a horn

I have somthing that might help you do another vidio. When the Crystal Empire redurend Princess Luna keept insisting to help Twilight and her friends save the empire. Why did princess Luna wanted to help them so badly? (Sorry i don't speak English so good)

I. Love ponies❤️🌷🌺🌹

If it’s true cadence isn’t the first Alicorn to give birth.

You're queen chrysalis's grandson.

but cadance was born as ad pagsis

Umm have anyone realized that there were 7 elements of harmony

Princess Goldlilly and the other pink one

and prince blue blood is cadence's brother