🌅 Sunset Shimmer's BIGGEST mistake...

for everyone wondering what this is from, search "spring breakdown" on youtube! but don't forget to come back here to finish the video once you're done c:

Honestly, I'm pretty sure the existence of equestria is a VERY open secret around the school.

Starlight: changes timeline
Sunshet: “hold my drink”

Just imagine being the rescue team arriving to find nobody

Wait til the Dazzlings hear there's an open portal RIGHT THERE

A lot of them already knew about the portal, as the first movie showed us Sunset shouting at Twilight about keeping the crown and never retuning home by destroying the portal.

My theory would be that after the humans returned home, only the Mane 7 were allowed through the portal. To other humans, they'd touch the portal entrance and just feel the stone.

I just realized sci-twi has glasses but twilight doesn't when everyone else is the same

Human Lyra will definitely be obsessed with the idea of being a pony just like pony Lyra who is obsessed with the idea of being a human (I know that's technically a fan theory but it is still interesting nonetheless)

I think twilight closed the portal permanently after sending everyone back. This would explain why we haven't seen any interaction between the human and the pony world after this.

Okay so having some multiversal interactions in the past that literally EVERYONE witnessed doesn't seem like it's that big of a secret. Having seen Twilight and others go through that portal like thousands of times the fact that a portal to another universe somehow connected with the one they're living in would most likely be public knowledge by the end of the firs MLP EG movie. The reason why nobody is going through it will most likely be that they just don't feel like it. They life is based on their universe so why would they go on another universe they don't know how to survive in. Think Sunset for example she can go back in equestria at anytime but doesn't bcz she has already set a life in the human universe.

The simple solution is a memory spell, that being said, all these students, 've already been through Equestria Girls, Rainbow Rocks, Friendship Games, and I'm not sure if this is after Legend of Everfree and the Memory Stone incident, although going by the commentary, Sawtooth said the memory stone was already destroyed at this point. You would think that after all that magical stuff going on, word might have gotten out already?

Crystal Prep's entire student Body has not yet blabbed about it, otherwise, the entire population of Canterlot High would have been under investigation. So it's a good bet that the students are pretty good at keeping it a secret, so sending them back through the portal is not out of the question. As for explaining them being ponies and that their first twilight is the alicorn pony telling them to go through this mirror in her basement? That's going to be a bit of a headache.

The next thing is explaining how they were all suddenly safe and sound at the school instead of miles out to sea.

But then all the ship's crew how do you explain that without memory spells?

Also imagine the reports Alicorn twilight and Sunset are going to have to give to their respective Celestia's and Luna's?

Sunset seemed more motivated by her homesickness (which I think she might be in denial about) than logic of any kind

Sunset has a perfectly good reason for wanting to evacuate the island through Equestria: they don't seem to have gotten any food off the ship before it sank. Given their isolation, they might not have enough food and fresh water to last until a rescue even if one has already been called for- and that's not guaranteed. Considering the ship's lack of backups and failsafes and conduct of the crew (flirting with underage passengers, pressing underage passengers into service to make emergency repairs on the engine, stuff like that), there's no way that would be a legal operation in real life and I suspect it's not in EG world either. I suspect they didn't make a distress call because they didn't want the authorities involved (hell, the weird lifeboats with motors but no radios if anything suggest that this ship might be involved in piracy or smuggling), and the ship's loss of power might have prevented them from doing so anyway. This would also explain the crew being willing to go along with it, as it would be a way for them to get off the island alive without going to prison.

Theoretically, anyone on board with a satellite phone could make the call themselves- except even mundane storms can block satellite transmissions. A magic one might be even worse. This does require an explanation for how Twilight and her friends were able to make calls, but that's easy enough. They only seem to be able to call each other, which suggests whatever they're doing isn't normal cell network calls. If anyone would have a custom-built phone with a much more powerful transmitter than a normal one, it's Twilight, and with all the superhero stuff they do, having phones that can contact each other directly without going through an external relay would actually be very useful, so I can easily see her giving her friends similar phones. And it's not exactly an unreasonable level of preparation if they get into a situation that uses it.

Can we appreciate how sawtooth is still making videos despite the show is officially over?

Well, it seems that specific portals to other worlds have specific destination on the other world.

Therefore: could Twilight manage to deactivate her ` `Artificial` ` portal, so that the portal located at Canterlot High would be deactivated as well??

In turn, as the CHS portal would essentially be disabled, No human could enter Equestria
However, Sunset Shimmer would have to find an alternative route to Equestria which would be discreet.

Sunset Shimmer is a really good character for me. She never let her past hold her back but she acknowledges that she made mistakes. I still love even though she makes mistakes 😉

I'm pretty sure everyone at the school would know about the school portal by now. Also, don't forget that it can be turned on and off via the machine attached to it in the pony world.

The portal I would be worried about in this case would be the island portal. No one bothered to attach an on/off switch to that and it would have been likely that the rescue team would have found it when they went to find the passengers on the island. Who knows what would have happened after that.

the fact that they went to pony world Is something I have been craving for since I was 7 and I'm 13

The actual danger: The milltary from Sunset's side invades Equestria.

Perhaps everything is different here: Celestia then thought that this mirror would cause the same side effects as the mirror leading to Mirror Equestria.
There, because of the actions of the evil Celestia, the two universes almost joined, but this mirror leads to another dimension of one universe and it has a limitation, both transforms you and deprives you of most of your powers (there were no such restrictions when the 1st generation arrived to the 4th generation).

And by the way, if there was some kind of balance, then Sunset, being present in one of the human worlds, would have already destroyed everything, I'm not talking about Sirens and Twilight with Spike. So what: either Celestia misunderstood everything or she didn't finish.

And as for the students, they would not have told anyone, because no one would have believed them. Now massively people say that they have seen aliens, ships and life after death, but they believed someone- no. So here it is the same, and even their memory does not need to be erased, they already consider it an ordinary Tuesday.

I thought everyone already knew about the portal at Canterlot High. They just chose not to go through because they were forbidden and no one knew until then that there were more portals than that one. Which always made me wonder why Principal Celestia and Twilight didn't think to put up some kind of perimeter to keep them from going through whenever

The show: We just wanna make it funny Imao
Sawtooth Waves: Let's analyse!

3:54 this is the exact logic Twilight or Starlight would use at the beginning of an episode resulting in everything going wrong

The situation you mentioned about still having communications via cell phones would be a huge tip off that something's wrong, and even if Pony!Twi managed to erase everyone's memories, there'd still be the issue of the rescue teams showing up to the spot where all of the distress signals were coming from, and everyone is just... ...gone.

Only to be found however many miles inland Canterlot is from the downed ship, and the entire roster of passengers there all of a sudden. That's gonna bring up a LOT of questions, and if everyone that went through Equestria got their memory of the place zapped, there's gonna be a lot of investigating going on.

Sunset opened up a much bigger can of worms that just a bunch of human students getting a short tour of Equestria. Also, extremely high chance of Lyra shenanigans in this scenario.

I can totally imagine pony Lyra somehow slipping through the portal, and going nuts when she found out humans really do exist. Makes you wonder if there is some portal at your school that leads to a pony world in real life.

The portal's not open 24/7 anymore. It has to be opened by the book. So Sunset just contacts her when she needs to pass through.

The solution is easy, twilight must deactivate the mirror portal and only reactivate it when she means to use it. This would only hamper sunset shimmer coming to the pony world but she could always use her magic journal to message twilight to turn on the portal.

Respectfully, I think you actually tap on non-memory-wipe the solution a bit. As you point out, most everyone would likely want to test out the portal the next day thinking it was a dream. But, unlike the natural portal which they likely don't have the funds to reach to test out given it's obscure location, the mirror portal is not active 24/7. Instead, it's only active while Twilight has her copy of the journal attached to it. Meaning once Twilight gets everyone though the portal, she simply has to remove the journal for a few weeks. Even if others go up to the portal to test it out, as long as they don't get stupidly lucky to test it during the three days every thirty moons, all their going to find is cold stone. It'll quickly get written off by most as panic-induced mass hysteria and those few that continue to hold out a belief in a magical pony land through the base of the statue (*Cough*Lyra*Cough) while quickly just get blown off as conspiracy theorists.

This is something that immediately jumped to my mind the moment I saw that scene. And it's even worse that it wasn't just the students of Canterlot High, who have already shown that they can keep magic a secret (already a big ask for a few hundred teenagers), but the crew of the ship and other unrelated passengers. And I came to the same conclusion you did. Twilight absolutely would have had to use mind magic on everyone, probably rolling back to even before the shipwreck (to keep the human seven's magic a secret). If not she'd have to close the portal and only open it when she needed it. That's something she can do, she's already overriding the mirror to keep the portal open longer than it should be. But that wouldn't solve the sand portal problem. The island isn't exactly hard to find, it's right next to the wreck of a big cruse-liner. Human governments would definitely want to investigate that. I suppose it's possible that Twilight and/or one or more of the other alicorns closed that portal once they were aware of it. But it's still a problem. Once Sunset made that crazy decision, mind magic was the only solution other than cutting all contact. And even that latter option would end up with the human seven in a lab somewhere.

Hey wait. The students already saw Equestria when Midnight Sparkle ripped a hole in the dimensions. Wouldn't they already know it was there? Just a question. Love your videos!

Yeah, this is absolutely something Sunset would do. She never rules out high-risk plans, trusting in her own abilities to navigate to good outcomes. She's smart, but she doesn't think things through too hard if she believes in what she's doing. Sparing her schoolmates from the rigors of a real-life sea rescue would count as a noble goal in need of doing. She's a play-by-ear, keep-on-hooftips kinda mare.

I also questioned that.
However, I have my own personal headcanon on it (i know there are still holes, but I'll deal with them later):
Sunset only brought the Humane 6 and a couple of CHS students into the sand-portal, so they could go to the mirror-portal and call for rescue for the other passengers. Only CHS (and Crystal Prep) students know much about Equestria and the portal. And it could explain why we only saw a few students like Flash, Bulk, Derpy & Lyra in the end scene, and not any of the EQG-only characters.

i loved the flower in your hair sawtooth, and to answer your question from the end of the video, i would have went with the first option since i would be able to keep my conscience clear of all their memories staying intact and no possibility of some people accidentally staying behind in Equestria.

I totally agree with you of the whole memory erasing I'm pretty sure there's an easy spell for it but what happens if someone tries to go through it someone who didn't know what it was but was curious what it was. How about instead memory erasing one thing spell it was a continuous spell a spell that twilight casted that on all the pones so that if any of them came through they would not remember anything until they went back

Memories. What a strange and fragile thing that we place so much faith in. Wouldn't it be terrible if they were quite malleable?

There's one little detail that Sawtooth doesn't consider; if they could cast a spell that could take away memories, couldn't they make a spell to add in others? The collective memory gap could be pasted over with some convincing and mundane explanation, like "shortly after, a rescue boat came and picked us up." As long as it isn't too unreasonable, it probably wouldn't be questioned too much.

Those students went through a lot that day. One could expect them to miss a few detail on the ride home. Which they definitely did, after all. Anything else would be crazy.

In her defense, she was having a pretty rough day and had to think fast to save her friends. Twilight having to clean up after her was not the largest of her problems.

My counter-arguments:
1: The students already know about Equestria, including having seen it in Friendship Games.
2: They already know that the statue is a portal, given the events of the first movie, where Sunset threatened to smash it, and watching Twilight go back through it.
3: Sunset probably already knew and warned them of the gravity of the situation, being on the other side, since she had the good sense to keep Twi and RD hidden the first time around, even if that probably wasn't an option with a much larger group.
4: We've seen pretty consistently that, in this world, adults are useless. Sometimes less than useless. In other specials we see the group being the ones stopping a bank heist, and solving the mystery of movie production sabotage. A group of 17-18 y/o girls have proven more capable than "trained" law-enforcement, and adults in general.

Yeah, memory spell is most likely. Erase the minds of all of the Students except for the Humane 7.
Although it's likely the portal is closed most of the time as we only see Sunset crossing over when she gives Twilight a heads up of when she's coming. So even if there was no memory erasure, the statue would still be a statue, until the portal is open again either via book or the next 30 moon cycle

I agree. The school portal was already an open secret.
Everybody saw Princess Twilight go back through the portal. They saw the Humane 6 using magic in the fight against the Dazzlings and ponying up repeatedly in Friendship Games, not to mention seeing the pony world through the many rifts torn open by SciTwi.

The entire school already kind of knows and I honestly wouldn’t be surprised if Celestia made a deal with the government at one of the points at which the portal was open that ponies wouldn’t go through it as long as humans didn’t come through either (or just not to try and have a war with each other) and would only come through if either one of the worlds was in danger. Let’s be totally honest, before this there was the time everyone from an entire carnival disappeared then that time at the mall, a movie set, not to mention the giant rainbow beam the dazzlings saw. I mean come on I think a giant rainbow beam would be a very dead giveaway and yet it’s already happened before multiple times before and not even a single government agent has shown up. The only reason Celestia had only twilight go through and not the others was because she and the government are still in contact and they told her there is no other “Twilight sparkle” at the school once Celestia sent them a message about the crown. But they said the other main 6 were there and if would probably be best if only twilight came through cause it would be kinda hard to keep the other 5 of the main six from being very obviously not from here. twilight nearly gave it away before she even revealed it to the human main 6. And after the whole thing they let Sunset stay since she would probably stay in the world indefinitely and be able to stop the magic objects that could easily be used for evil for falling into bad hands. Besides Celestia probably also had to tell the government how the human world has been their magic trash can for the last few eons.

Just a thought; doesn't the portal stay open through the magic in that book (the whole sequence we saw in Rainbow Rocks)? What if Twilight removed that book unless it was necessary for someone to go through? She'd still be able to communicate with Sunset through one of her other books, and when the students can't access the portal, they might think it really was just a dream.
Idk, just thought that might be another option for Twilight to take.

I just realized that humans are probably myths to them like unicorns, alicorns and Pegasus (Pegasi?) are to us

I admire Sunset.She changed,for the better,and,as you said before,shes probably replacing the element of magic in the human world instead of Twilight.

Wait, I just noticed that when Twilight went back to equestria after defeating Sunset most if not all of the students were there to watch her go. They must have remembered where the portal is right. So this may be not as big disaster as we think cause it would only make some people know about the portal still they will have a brief look how the world works and if they like it they would want to live there. And maybe even try crazy things to do it.

Well, pretty much everyone at CHS already knows about magic and Equestria and everything. I think there's an unspoken agreement to keep silent about everything, at least out of gratitude. But yeah, Sunset made an oopsie.

"Throwing off the balance between the worlds"
So celestia tryin to tell us, if everybody in the HUMAN world goes to the PONY world. The worlds will be imbalanced and therefore there would be no portals and everybody from the human world have to stay in the pony world.






This is a crazy theory but hey, it's just my opinion.

So I was rewatching mlp and got me thinking that the dark magic stygian found was a more powerful version of nightmare moon. Because each had strong negative emotions and then transformed into into a shadow of themselves. And stygian said in his dark moments the darkness came to him. So did the darkness came to Luna in her dark moments. The both where covered in mist like magic when they transform and bother have a mist form. Maybe even king sombra because he had some of the same magic. And the difference between them is there wants desires, and their own magic. Like the nightmare in the comic in nightmare Rarity. Idk would like to hear you opinions. There where many similarities in thier dark forms. Again this just a thought but if you want you can elaborate on this thought.

Sunset likes to escalate the stakes as problem solving. This is part of her charm.

As for how I would have solved it: The portal is only open aside from all 30 moons due to Twilights machinery on the mirror. She could send them back to Canterlot High and disconnect the machines. Everyone would check it out tomorrow and the statue would just be a statue. Thus, people would think it were a dream and don't bother anymore. Sunset could just journal Twilight a message, if they need the portal again.

In my opinion one of your final theories has a big problem, if Twilight sends them through the castle's portal and erases their memories, what would the rescue team, that inevitably has been sent to the island do? And what if the authorities find out about a massive group of people disappearing and suddenly reappearing in front of the school, they would investigate it and after the events of Friendship games it has to be common knowledge that there is such a thing as magic and even if the authorities don't consider it someone will, as Sci-Twi once did, and find the portal.

I believe Twilight might of input a memory of them being saved, so there wouldn't be any mystery

I was mind blown when I saw this scene, but this, this blew my mind even more.

One issue I'm finding is that... Twilight was seen by the whole school in the first movie going through the portal.

sunset shimmer probably has the best story and arc in the show

But the Canterlot high portal only works at certain times (full moon and when Twi turns it on). Twighlight could of said that SHE activated it and set them back. The statue would only work on the off chance that someone went back at the right time. Pluss she doesn't have to tell them that it is the statue, making everyone think that they just "teleported" to that spot. Love your videos

Sunset : hihihi .....i think this is the only way back to school.
Twilight: ARE YOU CRAZY?

I find it hard to believe the portal was a secret before Spring Breakdown. It's not exactly hidden from view; surely somebody outside of the main characters has seen the portal being used at some point, and everybody at Canterlot High has seen crazier things than girls walking through statues.

I assume that Twilight generally turns the portal off when it's not in use, but even so it seems nigh-miraculous that no adventurous teen has yet managed to slip through uninvited.

If I understood the episode correctly, then the portal in the cave was caused by the Storm King's magic, and should have disappeared when that magic was absorbed by the staff, and the staff was then returned to Equestria. As for the other portal with the mirror in Twilight's castle the easiest thing for her to do would be to take the mechanism that powered it with the book off line, returning the mirror to it's natural three day open period that only happened every twenty moons when certain stars aligned. Another possibility, though it isn't discussed in the series, but which has been used in other, non pony, tales about magic mirrors is the possibility that dismantling, or even breaking, the mirror would close the portal until the mirror was repaired, or a new one was built, or forever, depending on who was being trapped inside it in the story.

I thought the students already knew about the portal. Considering the fact that Starlight and Sunset went through with everyone watching it.

Don't the students of CHS already know about the portal on the school? Demon Shimmer explicitly said she was gonna take them to equestria though the portal in the statue when she was readying her army, and after she was defeated they seem to have no memory loss of that event.

The Mane 7 should be called the Humane 7, lol. Either way, I love your work! Glad to see you’re still around and making content we love and enjoy!

It's a fun theory, but there's one thing I can't help but wonder. We do know that Twilight basically rigged the portal to be open without the moon, but there's nothing indicating that she isn't just turning it off and on as needed. After all you could easily just have some kid walking by the school lean into the statue and suddenly pony world. That would be a much larger threat. The statue is out in the open after all. I can easily see Twilight just shutting off the portal after getting them through it. And I can also imagine Twilight going to the cave afterwards for good measure and closing that too to avoid more Equestrian magic to leak through Equestria's Australia.... I mean earth.

As usual you make some good points Sawtooth, bringing all of the human counterparts of those ponies most likely would have somehow disturbed the balance between the pony world and the human world, but i think the reason nothing seemed too happen when Sunset brought them there was because maybe they weren't in Equestria long enough too do any real damage too the balance i mean sure we don't know how long it took too send everyone back through the portal to Canterlot High but still.

I think had someone called for help, they'd have told SS when she suggested the portal. It's not something you wouldn't mention.

Hey Sawtooth, what if you discussed what cultures the ancient pillars represent or think they represent?

I don't think the blame for the portal trip is on Sunset. If anything, it's more or less Rainbow Dash's fault this happened in the first place.

Think about it. She was the one who wanted to fight evil, she kept getting in the way of her friends, kept messing things up, made things worse, and just caused nothing but trouble until she got what she wanted. She ended up putting hundreds of people in danger with her actions, got the ship sunk because she got in the way of repairing the ship, and pretty much ruined everyone's vacation. Yes, she ended up right in the end, but she still ended up putting so many lives at risk and causing a near disaster. But what does Rainbow care? She got to fight evil and that's all she seemed to care about. So the whole portal trip thing isn't Sunset's fault, it pretty much was all on Rainbow Dash and her wanting to be a glory hog and play hero.

I think you're forgetting that by itself the mirror portal can only open once every 2 and something Years, and for only 2 and a half days before it closes again for another 2+ Years, and Twilight can turn the portal on & off whenever she sees fit, I'm sure that even if CHS was fully aware of that magic portal, they would just go on like that thing is normal for them, and not get involved with something they don't really understand.

Twilight probably gave Sunset a huge earfull about how she could of risked the human world mlp characters coming through the portal at Canterlot High but Starlight could of found a spell to erase the human mlp characters memories of Equestria

In my opinion, I think, "Spring Breakdown," should've been set on a train, mainly as a reference to an event that celebrated it's 150th anniversary that year, the completion of the first Transcontinental Railroad

It would be easy to block the memories though it would far better to modify said memories. They enter the portal then exit at canterlot high with no memory of what happened in between.

Loved your daisy accessory, Sawtooth, and the video, of course! :D

That would be the case, but you seem to forget something...
Remember Friendship Games? How Midnight Sparkle had opened up portals all over the place before she calmed down, with some students almost falling in, even clinging to the edges?
Yeah, pretty sure the "magic horse world is real" ship had sailed a loooong time ago. And even that point is assuming no one was paying attention when Twilight either arrived or left in the previous two movies, though speculation would obviously have been much less accurate before the Friendship Games.

BRO YOU WERE MY CHILDHOOD AND I JUST FOUND THIS CHANNEL AFTER YEARS OML 💖

Okay, so Sunset did actually put Operation Gateway in shame by introducing Equestria.

Awesome video as always, Sawtooth!😃👏

I always wondered, as the three of them needed to stay hidden when in equestria (possible cuz they didn't want to be seen as changelings), how the hay did sunset manage to get that whole group through that without grabbing attention?

I never new Sunset Shimmer, My All time Beloved Character, would make such a Mistake. Now, my brain Explodes.🤯🤯🤯

Imagine if a normal person went trough the portal to Twilight castles!?

The mane 7 will have a lot of explaining

Wouldn't the students have known about the portal from when Sunset tried to destroy it, there must have been other offscreen instances where someone came though or went through it, it's kind of hard to ignore something that big much less keep it a secret

Yeah I can see where your coming from with that. The whole to many people know =danger. But it could also protect the place if precautions are made. I mean why not move the portal or towns folk to a place that isn't as dangerous. Its possible to open new portals and close them so at least theirs that.
I can see a lot of students dedicating thier lives to understand this from a scientific angle. (Like human twilight)
I can also see pony Twilight wiping thier memories.
No matter how you look at this situation...this would cause some to need to go to therapy. I wonder what human flash thought of seeing twilight other form. Its bad enough seeing a crush you can't be with....but this just adds another layer. I don't hate him (flash) I do feel bad for him and he and sunset are cute together. Someone please make a fanfiction where either human out a and pony lyra switch places(Prince and pauper style) or pony lyra kidnaps human Lyra to take her place in the human world.

I was foolish enough to watch this before the relevant movie, but I think my response doesn’t actually hinge on that:

It’s already too late. All of Canterlot High and Crystal Prep already knows about magic and Equestria, and enough know about the statue portal that it can’t remain secret forever. Nor should it, contact between worlds is good (in show terms: more friends!), but that’s a different issue.

Hey Sawtooth! Love your vids, and I also have an idea for your next video, just in case you didn't have any. Also, I haven't seen any of the interviews of the creators, so if anyone has, please let me know ^^

Why doesn't Twilight have her own set of royal guards and servants? She was the princess of friendship. A minor princess, but a princess nonetheless. She never got any castle help. It was just her and Spike, maybe even Starlight, but still. Why though??

Yes I know the animators were just lazy, but let's look at it from the story's perspective. Don't @ me about it plz

Celestia, Luna, and the crystal family have their own set of guards, each with their own set of unique uniforms. Twilight doesn't have any of that. She doesn't have any other ponies guarding her kingdom (ponyville), or at least the castle. Why didn't Celestia give her a small portion of the guard. It doesn't make sense!

Even if Twilight didn't like having any servants or assistance, it seems like a bad idea to just leave the castle unguarded. Think about the thrives, trespassers, or anyone else entering without permission. Also, when she visits other places, not a lot of ponies seem to be fazed about a regal princess walking among them. (See the episode where Rarity has a fashion contest and the main 6 go to Manehattan)

Sorry about the long rant. This is just a big plot hole that I never got over.

What I think is that if I find any portals, I'm definitely going through even though I might have to come back and forth a bit. I promise, I'll be cautious.

Thanks !!! Really needed this I was pretty stressed out when I saw this movie that how is this possible and now it is a relief thanks ❤️❤️

Chances are twilight erased the memories of those sunburst brought to ponyville, course they likely would've thought it was nothing but a dream, hallucination or simply went along with it. It's not as though they've seen strange things happen from sunburst and the mane seven before, so traveling through an alternate dimension where they are ponies is not so strange for them.

Im pretty sure thanks to Twilight, That portal is only passable to the ones who come from the pony world. And from the Human Side only those with the geodes can go back well exception of the legit ponies because they will have magic with them one way or another.

Another possibility, Princess Twilight ordered Sunset to come back through the portal and then closed it to prevent unwanted people from snooping and coming through. It would explain why Sunset was a background pony in the series epilogue.

If nothing else, this seems exactly like the kind of mistake Sunset Shimmer would make.

I think memory erasure spell is likely what happened to all but theones who knew about it before anyway.

There is also the problem of the more you use the portal the more unstable (pun intended) the dimensions become.
This is explained in one of the earlier friendship is magic comics.

if they can keep a secret about their school mates magically turning into hybrids and them not even being jealous about it,I'm sure they can keep their curiosity away

I always thought that many of the humans in Cantelot high already knew about the portal, they already knew Twilight was from another place after the events of the 1st movie and Sunset told Flash that Twilight has her own duties where she is so it's possible they already knew about it to some degree.

You know something that still confuses me is: if there are multiple portals to these 2 dimensions, does that mean there are portals to other dimensions as well?

From the first movie everyone already knows that the portal is there. Twilight walked through it with everyone in the entire school watching.

Love how no one wondered why there was a portal on a random island or how no one actually thought to worry what would happen if a random person found it. I’d think Twilight (pony) would go back to earth to not only destroy it but to also try to find if others existed and got rid of those as well

Everyone most likely thought going to equestria was a fever dream

Also if you consider that people would have called for help, the lack of anything would make everyone presumed dead. So mass funerals would be held, families would spend unnecessary thousands of dollars to bury empty caskets, only to have their children turn up at the house by the time they get back from the funeral. That rocket in legal shenanigans to make these people legally alive again would bring supply and demand into play, so it wouldn't be all bad. But if Twilight and Starlignt didn't know how to erase memories then we would be in trouble. I'll need to get my mind back into "overthink every possible future like Dr Strange" mode, so I'll edit this comment.

Edit: I forgot I put this here and spe.ling.

okay. Theory! Princess Twilight lost her temper then used a spell to send them through then she locked the portal forever and Sunset now has to communicate with Twilight through her journal to ask if she can go to Equestria

To be fair, the portal doesn't seem to be much of a secret for CHS. Nobody is keeping magic a secret and Sunset openly talks about Twilight being a Princess in Equestria. Not to mention they frequently travel through it in broad daylight, during school hours. CHS seems to be cool with the portal. Now the ones you do have to look out for are the crew of that ship. Those guys had no idea magic was a thing, and suddenly they're caught in magical thunderstorms, thrown through a portal, turned into ponies and hustled through another portal that pops them back at a high school. Those guys are going to be drinking and talking a lot.

I totally agree and I think you’re right. By the way, love the flower on your hair.

Maybe Sunset didn’t actually make them go through the portal. Before the students are in human form you can that she’s thinking. Maybe she just imagined the last part instead of actually doing it. Maybe she thought of it then thought about the consequences so she didn’t actually do it. Instead just waited for help.
Sure this is more of an alternative ending. But I don’t think Sunset would actually do that kinda mistake

I would love to hear your thoughts on the magic gems the girls found in Legend of Everfree. Those suckers need some explaining!

Honestly, I doubt they didn't already know about the portal. That thing is right infront of the school and you cannot tell not one single student was in class and was staring through the window bored out of their minds and saw someone walk through.

I don't know whether or not they knew beforehand that it was specifically a portal to the pony dimension but they do know that there is a portal.

Even worse, if their memories where erased, the coastguard would not find them, but only the Ship’s wreck. The students would see reports on the news “Cruse ship sank, all aboard missing, assumed dead. Memorial to be held” they would wonder if they are even actually alive, and when they are found to be alive with no account of how they where rescued, chaos would unfold.
They also had a final episode planes where we would see Sunset Shimmer turn back into a pony, as Trixie’s dad takes on the role of villan and tampers with Magic, but with Hasbro’s partnership with DHX ended, that episode was never made, so perhaps they would have done something with this idea of everyone seeing the pony world

This channel never fails to amaze me

Wonder how Celestia and Luna reacted to seeing all the people on their school lawn, if they were there.

I actually think they already know about everything. I mean, they HAD to differenciate between sci-twi and the princess, as first they were confusing them. For example, Flash knows about this in the legend of everfree. The thing would be when the rescue team arrives to not be ble to see anything, but with everythimg that has happened, it would be normal (there's also this girl rampaging in the streets that seems like medusa with the magic mirror, I don't remember her name).

Sometimes I forget how bad this idea Sunset had in mind at the end of spring breakdown and why in the first eqg film celestia kinda predicted if something like this happened it wouldn't have been a good sign either in equestria or the human world.

All Princess Twilight has to do to stop people from coming to Equestria is shut down the portal (as with the exception of every thirty moons, it only works due to the magitech Princess Twilight attached to it in Rainbow Rocks), sure it would make Sunset's occasional visits to Equestria a little more annoying, but they can communicate via the linked journals and people could still use the naturally occurring portals (but since the only one we know of is on some random island, it's not confirmed a problem).

I have a theory that an infinite number of universes that are connected to equestria. So whatever magic leaks there would come to any dimension. With that kind of power it would catastrophic like we’ve seen in the series with Sunset Shimmer, Sci Twi.

celestia's mirror always lead to CHS, right? so that means that the mirror and the statue occupy the exact same co-ordinates in time and space. so each 'natural portal' must also have an exact same position in equestria.

honestly everyone in their highs school knows the portal so they keep it a secret. But cool theory though.

I think I know the meaning of sunset's cutie mark. We've never seen another sunset in the human world. And her cutie mark represents the human and pony worlds

you forget that Sci-Twi ALMOST had the yacht's electrical systems back on, but Rainbow Dash pulled the plug with one second to go, causing the yacht to keep going, out of control; even though Applejack also tried to restore the steering.

Probably a good thing that everyone on that cruise besides the Mane 7, had their memories erased of the portal from Equestria to CCHS. If rumor did spread out like wildfire, that could lead to multiple consequences.
1. Some people might have taken photos of Equestria, and the portal and post them on the internet, and be confirmed legit real.
2. It would probably would agency like the FBI or CIA do an investigation around the portal and ask questions to both the Mane 7 and Principal Celestia & Vice Principal Luna about the portal.
3. Press conference and news reports around Sunset Shimmer explaining to the world how the human world and Equestria isn't that different.

I really wonder how would OUR world (not the Equestria Girls world) react when we see a portal to another universe that is completely different from what we know. Probably the governments would be scrambling to secure the portal and maybe search far and wide for more.

Wow Sawtooth you have been doing a lot of Sunset 🌅 Shimmer theory’s ! 😆😆 btw love the video 😁🌅😁🌅😁🌅💜💜💜💜

I kind of have a theory.
People complain that Twilight grew up faster than Luna (looking more like Princess Celestia)
I think that’s because Luna was stuck on the moon and came back as her younger self (no flowing hair, like Twilight) and the reason she didn’t look like Celestia in the end was because not enough time had passed.
Twilight had been an Alicorn since season 3 (if I’m not wrong) so that’s a good time period as we see the others (the mane six) with grey streaks (rarity) and bags under their eyes (RD and AJ) and Pinkie Pie even having a kid! That’s just a small part of the theory, and if you’d like you could elaborate on it!

I feel like that maybe this happened. Like Sunset didn't think that they were in a human world with technology far beyond that of Equestria. Using the portal to bring everybody back to the school would likely draw attention to it.. Which if everybody in the school knew about it, they'd most likely tell everyone they could. Then I'm sure the government would eventually get wind of it. But I think Sunset's plan, or lack thereof, was just plain idiotic.

As we can understand, some events in EG took a different development from the pony world. It's the same here. In one reality, Sunset was born, and in another, well, apparently not, lol.

There is not a single person in that school that wasn't aware of the portal. There was nothing secret about it. What Sunset did wasn't even close to a problem, as even outside the school it was already very clear that magic wasn't being kept a secret. There simply isn't much of a point in trying to keep the existence of magic or Equestria as a whole a secret, as it was going to leak sooner or later regardless. Might as well embrace it in the open with the understanding that it will probably cause a few problems down the line. Nothing beyond what Equestria and the main 7 in the human world can handle though.

The thing is that without magic from equestria the portal doesn't work since in the friendship games when twilight took sunsets magic , she couldn't access the portal , and a few seconds before the encounter it worked perfectly fine.

Honestly, I see no reason why the existence of the pony world should be kept a secret. Equestrian magic is more or less a constant fact of life there on Earth now, so trying to cover up the portal and what's on the other side is going to be a short-lived endeavour at best 😅

i expect sunset told her friends to, "brace themselves". plus they got to see the 'equestria' they've heard so much about. i get the feeling that celestia knew more about this world than she told, and twilight met her counterpart and the universe didn't implode.

Would the memory spell take effect after ALL of them were back? Or if they just entered? If they just entered theres a chance a human would look at them and see humans coming out of the portal

You missed one way to fix the problem. All Twilight needs to do is remove the journal that powers the portal. Everyone that then tries the portal on the other side won’t find one. You can’t have lots of people exploring the portal if you control its opening.

Another option would have been for Sunset to go through the portal alone and arrange for rescue. Then just pop back to island when the time came for pick up. Would have been less messy.

Something that makes Sunset’s plan even worse is that in the comics it’s said that when there’s too much travel between universes they run the risk of fuzing the two, causing an apocalyptic event in both worlds.

I like to think the island portal is the start of what celestia warned about. And after what sunset did with a let's remember wild unsecured portal I'm not going to be supprised if in the future we see more portals pop up. Also magic comes through the statue portal and the rainbooms deal with that so who is gonna deal with the island one and whichever other ones pop up

I still think steeling twilight's crown was the biggest mistake sunset made

I agree that was crazy

I would seriously do the same but lock that Portal speaking of Portal what would twilight do if she were to find out?
And what consequences would Sunset face?

Human Flash uses the portal to see pony twilight cause human twilight doesn’t like him like that lol

Like you said I would’ve came up with a spell to erase their memories just to keep everything going smoothly

I don't know why but i get the feeling sunset got a bit dumbed down after she became good. When she was "evil" it seemed like she was just a bit smarter. Not that she isn't intelegent but it seemed like after the becoming good she also lost a bit of her wit.

I prefer the idea that they all went through the portal and the only reason we don't get to see more of the chaos you talked about is that EQG didn't get more specials. Wait did they cancel EQG or is it still going now that G5 is part of the G4 continuity?

The knowledge Sunset and Twilight (series one) trying to keep secret is not portal, is the world portal lends to.

What would I do as Twilight?
I'd get them all to AGREE to have their memory wiped.

Listening to this, all those duplicates that are usually animation errors they could be the human versions of the ponies coming through the portal and trying to hide

imagine how superior lyra felt when she turned into a unicorn in the other world and everyone else who wasnt mane 7 just had wings or nothing at all

I have a theory on what the wiped out time line is on the one episode on season 5 the people from the human world found out about the portal and started traveling to there and back but the universe got unbalanced and then it wiped out every pony and person there

technically as the portal at the school is only open every 30 moons it would be closed unless that journal was used (we do not know if all portals work that way or if it was naturally open) but if it was actually closed or if that was the last day then nobody would get through it

Is sunset’s human counterpart ever brought up? I mean she’s from the pony world, so she probably already had a counterpart. Idk if there’s already a cannon explanation or if there’s already a popular theory, but I think about it a lot

Doesn't everyone (at least in Canterlot High and maybe Crystal Prep) know about the portal and alternate versions of themselves as ponies? Twilight Sparkle made quite a spectacle when she went there twice, Starlight Glimmer was very obvious when she came to the human world, Sci-Twi opened up rifts between the pony and human worlds when she was consumed with magic, and it is common knowledge that Twilight Sparkle is not from the human world but there is also a human version of her.
This is from what I remember from the movies and EG videos, but I didn't watch this EG video yet.

I'm pretty sure everyone at Canterlot High knows about the portal already and are good at keeping a secret. I mean this is the same town where we have 7 girls who magically transform and fight evil on a daily basis, a talking dog who has his own Youtube unboxing channel, and all the other nonsense that happens on a daily basis. At this point, all of this is considered normal. I don't think anyone's going to bat an eye at going to Equestria and becoming a pony for a few minutes before going back home.

twi could of erased everyones memorys but i think she had to of left the mane 7's memorys as they were because if not it could leave huge gaps in their memorys.

I saw this episode, and I'm very sure that they were in the BERMUDA TRIANGLE on one of the islands and that's how you get to Equestria. On the other island was the HIDDEN UFO that nobody ever saw.

In Spring Break, it was Rainbow Dash ruining for everyone TBH. Yet it's wack that Twilight and Sunset think it was their fault.

How Twilight dealt with it: Imprisoning every student of Canterlot High, then sending a legion of changelings to the other side to take their places.

here’s my question:why is sci-twi’s wings small but when princess twilight went in the human worlds twice,her wings were big???

Well it seems very clear that everyone from their school know about magic, I mean they remembered Sunset using magic, they remembered human Twilight trying to tear open the veil between the two worlds. They all knew about magic. At the point that she chose to do this they were all aware Equestria existed. Simple.

Twilight most likely, politely, allowed them to pass through the portal but gave Sunset an earful.
Afterwards she closed down the portal, only activating it when Sunset wrote to her and requested to come to Equestria.

I think Sunset could y'know when she and her friends go through the portal she compromised and said "this never happened" and "You shall not speak of this to anyone" 🤨

I think it would be interesting if the new mlp gen 5 events that coside disharmony and suspicion between ponys was coside by humans going through the portal into equestria trying to live there or even government of humans trying to experiment on equestria most likely not but it would be interesting

I'm pretty sure that the students at CHS know about the portal.. But like Sunset said, its kind of weird also bc they've never been in the pony world and CHS is basically all of ponyville so I dont know how they hid them all in that bush-

I know I'm late to this but I bet a few students know of this portal infront of the school. Takeing consideration that they leave infront of Snip, Snails, and Luna possible. In the second movie they leave in the middle of the day. You can't tell me someone saw this. Then the 3rd movie literally opened up portals everywhere. A few people may have fallen through. So even if she removed those memories of that short. I think it is interesting that natural portals exist. Which means that these worlds are possibly needed to balance each other out somehow or maybe when Star Swirl the Bearded sent the The Sirens through the connection was made. Anyways although I don't see this as a major issue cuse if it was a problem Twilight would cut the link and the portal would close.

Honestly, the only thing I really noticed was that Sci-Twi has wings when she ponies up in the human world, but is only a unicorn in Equestria.

But Twilight can just de-activated the portal because it's powered by her book

I simply thought it was supposed to be a comedic ending, didn't know this was much more than that.

Maybe they can move the portal to another side of the school and write in the news that somehow many people share the same dream last night. This story makes me think of minecraft portal to travel fast from place to place.

Oh, the answer to this is simple.





Make them swear on their life to never go through the portal again without permission and to never tell anyone else about it.

I think by the first movie everyone at school knew about the portal. Twilight goes into the portal while Sunset, Snips and Snails repair the entrance of the school, and I doubt Snips and snails can keep a secret.

Or can it be like while sending them through the castle portal she must have erased their memory about and filled the blank with that rescue team theory of yours.

This is a bit unrelated but I really wished people would acknowledge sunset's skill with magic and scientific knowledge.

I wonder what Discord would look like if he went through the portal...

Well Sawtooth at least you were right about Sci-Twi being only a Unicorn when she entered Equestria.

Can’t wait to watch this! Sunsets one of my favourite characters :D have a good weekend everyone! Also Do you think there are other portals to the human world? Maybe other people have gone through and possibly trapped

I think twilight can also close the portal forever after sending everyone home. Then no one can come.

At least one of your earlier theories was confirmed.
The human world Twilight was a unicorn when she went through the portal, as she has not discovered the magic of friendship just yet.

There is also the problem if there were emergency ships and helicopters on their way to save everyone and how they would react to find literally no one in the water or island even though someone either called or signaled for help.

What if discord would one day visit twilight, and that would "coincidentally" be the same day the first human came through the portal? I bet he would show them around and then travel back to see the human world, search for himself...... But once he realised that the portal being common knowledge in the human world, i bet he would find a way to erase that knowledge, so no one would know except the main seven.

Question: What if... Twilight Sparkle meet the Dazzlings first, instead of Sunset Shimmer? (Alternate Timeline?)

I don't know how Celestia would react but I definitely think Twilight kept the Mane six's memories considering they know about Equestria

Slight issue they already know Equestria exists and the portal (granted they don't know it's perma active now) they were there when twilight left the first time and were there when nightmare sparkle ripped the universe a new one. So yeah nothing new happened to them.

ok but.. when we see a Twillight in the human world in a WHOLE new school.. where was Sunset`s human self? we never seen her in Crystal prep

Imagine WE actually had to go through that mess!

I've seen and done some crazy plans in my line of work but something THAT risky? Hay to the no.

Citizens who live near Canterlot high: Tells eye witnesses about interdimensional portals, magical artifacts, demons, rainbow explosions and getting turned into talking sapient horse

Human Governments and UN: Oh no.. Anyway we have stuff to do like stopping Climate change, Shoot cars in the space, wage war and fight against global flu pandemic.

I do think that you're second theory of erasing their memories is what twilight would have,So a yes to that one I guess.

I like how he uses his brain wisely 🤣

imagine when your on your way in pony form confused as hell and see your self... or the original pony version of you following the croud and coming through the portal. Now that would be interesting

I think it was only an idea. Like some others, they're theory is that Sunset Shimmer was just thinking about it. I agree, Sunset is an inteligent pony/person. So I think she was thinking of possibilities

Why doesnt sawtooth waves collaboration with other youtubers more often? It would be much more fun
IT'S fun already so why not more fun?

Twillight isn't the smartest pony so I would say that she let the students use the portal without do anything

Let's be real for a second here... Everyone at Canterlot High knew about that portal

Students have long seen how Twilight comes and goes through the portal. Most likely princess Twilight just closes the portal when not needed.

Reason why theres no 2nd part of spring breakdown: timeline erased and now she has variants.

It's been like forever, I've watch MLP theories. Happy to see The MLP Fandom, the Brony Fandom still surving. Great vid

Pena não ter legendas em português ou espanhol :(

hey everyone~ i see what this theory is trying to suggest but, i can't help but notice it has some flaws... oh dear... i don't mean to sound huffy when i say this i just really wanted to state something i thought was important and should be considered. you see, this doesn't make sense to me since the students at canterlot high have already been exposed to the magic of equestria, and had no real visable issues with it going forward with it. not only that but they have literally seen the ponies in equestria from their world when midnight sparkle started to break their dimensions, you could argue that they witnessed it all, if the pony ears tails and wings and magic wasn't enough to imply something going on. heck, even the girls upon knowing straight up that twilight is a pony princess from another world, they not once went through the portal when it was open again. I've seen the students take video of the pony magic and even then not much has happened. No one from Crystal prep even knew. And it seems that more than likely as human celestia pointed out, that no one would even believe them if they saw this to begin with. That's why i really don't think the students would cross over to equestria any time soon. If they hadn't acted any differently in the three past movies and the series even when magic was in their faces, then I really don't think they'll be compelled to come to the pony world even now. But, even if they do, which I still think isn't that likely, i believe it can be assumed that they wouldn't get too far. They'd have to know what they're doing and get past the ponies to cause any real harm or problems. We did see some humans get into trouble in some special episodes, but they were never looking for it and had to get their hands on the magic items in the first place. They could learn, but again they'd have to even know they're looking for something and then get to it, past the ponies and the pony guards and princesses. It's possible, but i actually think the odds are just about as high as the pony Trixie but not anything the ponies of equestria aren't already good with dealing with. But that's what i thought. I could say more but this has gotten pretty long ^^ I think Sunset shimmer is just fine. Thanks so much for reading~ :)

Sawtooth: To erase their memory Men in Black style
SCP Foundation: Am I a joke to you?

The fact that anyone in canterlot high could easily just walk past the statue and touch it and just be like oh dang there’s a portal here I wanna go through it-

Or they could just..turn off the now magic-machine based mirror portal unless Sunset asks via journal she needs something and thereby leaving anybody unsavory without evidence/means like they did with Cinch. Or say screw it and put up some border guards while finally establishing formal diplomacy with the aliens.

Besides I thought Rainbow Rocks where Twilight used, "It might be confusing if there were two of all of you" as the new excuse and this special, showed Pony-Celestia was while reasonably cautious, wrong in her guess and there was no magical imbalance problem, just a border/tourist/immigration/lack of interest in establishing formal diplomacy issue. Frankly with the portal being open, it's a miracle no new student or drunken bystander accidentally fell in already.

Also, didn't the time where Starlight came in while plenty of civilians (including talking about it in front of Juniper at the end who isn't even a student there and has movie industry connections) were around at various visible angles show they don't really care that much?

I know this won't happen but..
What if the portal (in another timeline) got revealed? Somehow someone got away with knowing about Equestria and spread it? To friends to friends.. To people to the final phase: investigators.. And even if they wouldn't belive first, they could find out when the portal open. They could get proof if they are patient.

Which would lead to scientists and cops would close the area in Canterlot High and later remove the portal to a secret lab base. You would never know what the government would do with the portal, either shut it down or.. Most likely explore and see if Equestria and the portal can come to use. Take advantage of Equestria's resources and knowledge.

It was like when Twilight got forced using her magic in the Friendship Games, her school wanted her to cheat, to win. They took advantage of Equestria's power. We have seen both Twilight and Sunset adoring the power they got from Equestria. They felt the magical power and only wanted more by coming to Equestria.

Bad and greedy people, they are everywhere and good ones can also be inspired doing the same. So yes many people from EG would probably want to suck Equestria's magic on every drop, but would get resistance too.

Mane 7 maybe would even have to destroy the portal for citizens of Equestria's safety. Cutting the band to save nations in Equestria. Yes, if it would have gone that far.

Actually I would like reading a fanfic about Equestria being revealed to the EG world and then it would be a war between the worlds, what if that timeline would lead to another which would end up like doomsday? Like when we saw possible futures when Starlight messed with time traveling.

Equestria sure has alot magic to use if danger arrives but since EG is a whole another world (similiar to our world) they should have deadly weapons. And I am talking about those heavy stuff, bombs, guns, and they can use technology like drones, robots.

(Yes again this would only be happening in a fanfic, which would be very cool at the same time terrifying, upgrades people, upgrades!)

Also I have almost never been this early on your vids Sawtooth, this was surely Sunset's biggest mistakes. Even before she became friends with the mane six and was evil, she kept the portal as secret before thinking of invading it.

Thank you if you are reading this! =)

The flower in your hear is really cute 🌼

Ooooohhh what did she do??? Love your channel ❤️❤️❤️

Edit:Wow thanks for the heart by the way made some great points in the video.I would’ve erased their memories and make up some story or send them back through the portal then erase their memories so they wouldn’t even know equestria exists

I think erasing the memories of being a pony, and in Equestria would be the best option if when through the mirror.

Yo, sci-twi had 4 full fucking bars and thought "eh, lets just bring everyone through a poorly understood, interdenominational portal, into a world filled with the doppelgangers of everyone, hoping no one wanders off, or eaten by a dragon or something." And, likely having given it full though (she's Twilight after all), went through with it. I- dear god.

I only now realised that their outro is Flurry’s part and it’s been like that before they even released it 👀

Doesn't the portal only work when the journal is making it work?

So no one would be able to get to equestria without either been lucky, or with permission

... you really think the students didn't know about the portal since the first film? I figured they all were informed of the situation for a while. They should, really.

it didnt matter! EVERYONE at the school saw the pony twilight go back through the portal. i dont necessarily know if they think the portal was still closed because the human six tried it but it didnt work....but after a while twilight got her portal to work permanently.

You know when human world Twilight took the magic and turned into a crazy, power hungry demon? She was creating rifts between the pony world and the human world, and people were falling through the courtyard thing and they weren’t turning into ponies. But also, maybe one of the smaller portal things survived even when they re-formed human world Twilight. But if one of the smaller portal things did survive, where would it go? And if anyone found it, that might be a big problem, because if it even was a portal they would probably go through it and go into the pony world as a human. But would they even know it was a portal? (Comment from Athena, Age 7)

Hmm, I wonder, is it possible that these natural portals indicate that maybe... once loooong ago, in a time forgotten, the Pony world and the human world were once the same world and they somehow were separated due to some event???

The S-s-s Storm king is A-a-a Alive(*faints *)
Sand Portal? Equestria? Twilight's Portal? Canterlot High? Great?
Twilight can use a piece of the Memory Stone and a Equestrian Memory spell to erase their Memory, Right?If I were Twilight, I'd do this.

Idk if you made a video about this at some point but Im very curious about this. There was a second version of Twilight right? There were also second versions of the other 5 and spike. Well, what about starlight and sunset? We have never seen a second version of those two. We know that sunset and starlight learned their lessons and turned to friendship... but I doubt that the second versions of them ever got the chance. What destruction could they cause? Just imagine the possiblities...

Hordika Matau: I don't believe Sunset send any 260 persons at the time in the PONY WORLD!? WHAT'S THE MATTER, SEND EVERYONE TO KNOW WHAT IS FREAKING FORMS!?
Sunset: I'm through making my plans!

I remember in some episodes that Twilight and few other unicorns orsomething that there is a spell that deleted there memories, so she will use it when they one by one get to the portal to the human world @Sawtooth Wase

I never liked the ending of Spring Breakdown...
I mean it should be a no-brainer that bringing all humans to Equestria is a no-go.
What was the writer thinking?

I sincerely hope Twilight came up with some kind of spell to erase their memories....as far as the universes did not explode because of this, that is.
Maybe SB is the real ending of Equestria Girls and everything after is their after life. .<.

This theory could have been true IF the Starlight Glimmer was made BEFORE, so Sunset could be made more careless decisions. But it is just my thoughts.

Did you know that in the episode “call of the cutie” sweetie belle originally had yellow main and blue skin and scootaloo had dark blue skin and mane? plus that blue scootaloo already had a cutie mark

1:41 if we look at her past she doesn't have patience. She wants everything's process to be fast. That's why she abandoned her studies and went to the human world in the first place. Though she has been reformed she still doesn't have patience

Or... twilight could close the portal and when they go back at try to find out about the portal in their lawn they won’t!

It's strange hearing you talking about Equestria Girls again after all this time.

Oh no. She probably erased people’s memories of when they were in Equestrian. If she erased nothing else, the shared memory of events would be going through the portal directly to school. People would think the portal led to a topical island.

Sawtooth waves:she start erasing memory and I know it's a stretch.
Me: your not wrong twilight was willing to erase starlight glimmers memory after accidentally using the canterlot voice in her presence, remove some trauma that she assumed was effective on starlight during her apology freakout momemts.

They should have made a movie about how they got home!!! Hasbro disappointed me!!!

You know how scary not knowing how they got thier would be? For them and thier loved ones? People are going to ask and wonder. That would also be scaring. Why not just take thier memory about where the second portal is? Or an illusion spell so they don't see it or just say I'm making a one time temporary portal to thier. Close it off for a bit then once things die down bring it back up.

One thing I know is that in the first movie of equestria girls, at the end of the movie, twilight went into the portal when everyone was around? If I can remember correctly. They already knew she was from equestria so wouldn’t they know the portal leaders there already?

Um.... But there is STILL one mystery unsolved.

Sunset Shimmer is not the really Sunset Shimmer. Sunset is from Pony World's Equestria and we didn't get to see the Human World's Sunset.

Like The Main 7 needs to be in the Pony world too, right? But in Pony World there is only Main 6 not Sunset Shimmer.

There would be a Human Sunset too. But we didn't know where she really is. And cause the show came to the end, we didn't know about Human Sunset.

Let's take a look in the elements Of Harmony, there were totally six elements and then Sunset also become one the element which wasn't in the past, but let's just leave it now.

But then, in Pony World, there was six elements even after we found out that Sunset will also have the power of a new element. And in Human World, there are seven.

It means that Sunset of the Pony world should be In Pony World to maintain the balance and The Human Sunset should be found out.

Well, although we didn't get to see the Human world after the last episode, and we don't know what happened in there when The elements of harmony was all broken by Sombra.

So, please tell you thoughts about this thing 😅.

to be honest I kinda want the series to go in a direction We're Both Worlds become United and you're able to visit from both worlds maybe not everyone but most people and ponies could visit each other's Worlds example I still want to see sunset shimmer Pony and human meeting like Twilight did

I haven’t watched EG in awhile but when Sunset was evil didn’t
everyone
see her threaten to destroy the portal or at least talk about the portal or see pony Twi go home?

I’m not rlly sure if this was supposed to happen but when sci-twi went to equestria, she was not an alicorn. But when she was saving everyone with everyone else in the human world, she had wings was she a secret Alicorn or something?

Wait, but didn't most of the students see Twighlight leave through the portal back to her world in the first movie, and if I remember correctly there was multiple times Sunset said something along the lines of "remember highlight is a princess in equestria, she has her own responsibilities to worry about now" cause I'm pretty sure like half the school saw her leave through the portal in the first movie

The sirens could also try out the portal and find their own way back to equestria if the word spreads

I have a small theory, Princess celestia, luna and nightmare moon have flowing hair but twilight and cadence do not. But when we fast forward to twilight being the ruler of equestria she has flowing hair. So it appears that flowing hair comes from being the ruler. But at twilights coronation she still has normal hair so its not the crown or the title. It is also obviously not alicornism. So what is it. Maybe its the sheer power. Maybe its ruler reaching full power.

Celestia said it could destroy the balance of that world (read human world). Stuff like that is more common in Equestria but the Human world is more fragile.

Wait the portal was a secret? I thought everyone at Canterlot High knew about it and were just really chill about keeping it hush hush

Don’t ask me I think the first one would’ve been the best decision ever!😜

WE NEED MORE SAWTOOTH WAVES!!!

A thing: In Equestria girls 1, Sunset shimmer's color of magic was Cyan. But in Spring breack down it was red!

The people in Canterlot High already know about the portal, though I mean, Twighlight DID go back through it eventually. And everyone knew that she was obviously not from their world.

what a coincidence, I actually finished the spring special an hour ago

Starlight: change timelines
Sunset:i can do that

I feel like rainbow should get an apologize
From the others ,
If they believed rainbow dash
They could have reacted fastly
Aaaaand could've prevent the ship from
Sinking
None knew exept rainbow

Riiiiiight

Well the demon really wasn't her she was only in a possessed statement some unsuch and repeated that everything else in the 1st movie was her and as a change of twipping a better person with no reward for her actions

the real life answer is that the makers of this film wanted to do a little fun at the end of the movies

I'm kinda surprised you didn't mention anything about Sci-Twi's lack of wings, basically confirming at least part of what you thought was gonna happen when you covered the Friendship Games' Trailer. XD

My big question is how did all of the others didn't get noticed by everyone

no anyone who leaves from equestria and goes to the human will have no recollection of ever being there there will be a instant mind wipe after you go through

im still wondering what element sunset shimmer represent, i mean... on the episode of the legend of everfree, those necklaces they got, they got it from the tree of harmony and there are only 6 elements of harmony

yet sunset shimmer got one, and i dont know what element it is or maybe it is a hidden element????

I’m just surprised no human hasn’t just tripped and through the portal straight to horse land-

They already knew about the portal. Besides, they probably don't wanna go to Equestria when they have seen all the crazy magic. They probably think it's more corrupt than it actually is.

Imagine this didn't happen any everyone actually knew-

Just saying I am pretty sure there has 2 at least be 1 person in the human world who knows that the statue is a portal because it is in the middle of public eyes n there is always people around when people come out of the portal or when people go in so wether twilight erased their memories or not it wouldn't matter because the statue portal is in the middle of the public where everyone can see who goes in n who comes out

Plot hole: exists
Theorists: Hold my pen

Portal can be opened and closed at will now. Just keep it closed, and Sunset just have to write to Twilight to open it for her when she needs to get to Equestria.

My question is

How did she convince everyone to fall into a magic portal?

Don't forget the Friendship Games. The students have already seen Equestria for themselves. They've already been keeping the multiverse under wraps. No, it's everyone else you have to worry about. After all, Sunset wouldn't just leave the crew and other passengers on that desert island, would she?

the episode ended like a joke but it’s prime theory material lol

Humans learn about equrstria
Also Humans: It's colonization time!

There’s too much… in my head… to accurately put into words.

Yo My Guy I'm New Here And I Got Some Questions For You
Does Equestria have anything to do with Earth?

How exactly does Celestia/Luna move the sun and the moon

Was Luna asleep or awake during her 1000 years on the moon

Where did the Ever Free Forest come from?


Just at what tech level is Equestria?

In the idw comic 20/20 celestia knows a spell to erase memories. So it's possible that she taught twilight or twilight called celestia to erase everyone's memories

I didn’t even think about the implications of a group of look alike ponies running around maybe ponies thought they were Changings or something and I feel like twilight probably did erase there memories or maybe they were convinced it was a dream also I still find it werid we never saw a human sunset

If twilight erased their memories then how would they have and remember what the staff is?

Things I'm sad about is human and pony twilight at the end of friendship games didn't get on screen interaction and the end of this were everyone showed up in Teilights castle

How were they even able to use the portal at the school? I thought the first movie established a time crunch. Or are these instances all conveniently during full moons?

I dont like that movie: spring breakdown cause applejack was seasick the entire time on cruise ship and I felt really bad of her at least she got better😔 when they were stranded in a deserted island

"Oh yeah that's just the portal in front of the school that sends you to the horse dimension that gives some girls superpowers, never mind it"

Probably got their memories taken but i think it would of caused an unbalanced between the world's because they are the same but different realities so twilight proubly got stressed out but solved the problem
-A

You're thinking as a human of this world. Everyone in the MLP and MLP: Equestria Girls are more easy going and accepting. They would simply chalk it up to another "magical" adventure and go on with their lives. :)

I know this is off topic but I’ve always seen calestia as a fraud and with sunset shimmer calestia might have banned sunset shimmer for twilight! And every pony makes mistakes so...

How many times have the protagonists screamed that everything is Equestrian Magic?, Wouldn't that call somenones attention?

It's said that the portal closes every 30 moons, so it's likely that you can't go back into the portal, that or it's common knowledge that there is a portal there, because remember, they saw her walk through the portal at the end of the first equestria girls movie. Additionally, that same side affect would've already have been caused since everyone now knows of 1 portal and rarity has a GPS, so she could probably get the location of the portal back on her phone. GPS allow you to retrace your step i'm pretty sure, so the secret is already pretty open.

The dazzilings could have told everyone about the portal but in time they got deafeted so it is still a secret

Ok ok I think twilight would put them all through a portal.
Because, sending them back would be weird. They would all be stuck on an island with no help. But maybe in wrong!
If they had cell service, then maybe they could call for help. I wonder if they saw they’re pony counterparts. I mean I would love to see that-

Wouldn’t there be another sunset in the human world sine sunset was really a pony can u pls clarify that for me Bc I’m trying to figure it out still. U are my fav therorist ❤️

Portal toggle. Since the journal gives the portal the "ip address" of CHS, no no journal means no connection, which means no portal untill P!Twi opens it up again. No portal, no confirmation of theories. Simple.

i think i got a good theory instead of erasing there memory's.... twilight allowed them to pass through the main portal back to canterlot now here is where things get interesting if you remember the movie my little pony friendship is magic Equestria girls movie where sunset shimmer was the main Vilnian/bad guy of the movie she put the crown on her head and opened up portals to Equestria and this also happen with sci twi when she absorbed all the magic in her corrupting her for a while many portals opened up show Equestria

as apart of that if celestia and luna new of the portal then the 2 parrel worlds need balance if you where to say or end up in a alt timeLine / parrel world let's put MLP in it you would be opening a gate way to a new reality and a new start in life but at the same time this is unknown territory

even for the human version of the mane 6 + SunSet Shimmer
and plus if the magic came through after what happen in the MLP MOVIE against the storm king think of what else could go to the human world of equestria/canterlot high


as for the memory wipe i think it never happened i think the remember but choose to keep it a secret.... they don't show and form of memory loss confusion ETC ill half to watch that episode at some point to see

If the haven't done it already, I'm pretty sure the comics will EVENTUALLY bring up something about Celestia's concerns about portal magic. Like this one time they made the My Little Pony/Transformers crossover.

I'm putting this here so you will see it but I have a theory about alicorns
so I think the more the element they represents grows so do they in both power and size

Well sence you asked I think Twilight's reacion whoud go like this:
"Oh my Celestia, ok let's go to the mirror. Goodbye"

I think the reason why nobody called 911 is because they have a very big secret. All the entire school have so much trust to Sunset.

I think you’re right Saul because if she did that that will be impossible but Twila can’t do that she can let the secret out

I say to me, Princess Celestia called Queen Hippolyta of Paradise Island (Wonder Woman's home) and got the element used to make the ones not supposed to know Equestria to forget.

Hmm, my thoughts here is this


They do use the Portal but after that well

Twilight in Equestria just used magic to keep people from going through

I think the memory part is what really happened i mean when they get to the portal twilight was actually there wich means they might gone to the past by a really short time not the past that it was already too far from all the equestra girls thing happens but before that by just some time so maybe twilight had time to cast a spell on them to make them forgot all about it when they actually go back to their world.

i think that thing with the memory destroying is the best idea

I think sunset is a nice character, and was just lost!

Honestly, I like to think the students kept quiet for the most part out of an honor system to Princess Twilight and the HuMane 6, even Sunset after they came around to forgiving her. Sure that’s... asking a bit much, but when you think about it, Sunset and the others have these amazing powers. You would think someone would have told people about this, and using Video Footage, would have someone up in arms about this, but no one is making a fuss. Sure they were grumpy with Sunset for months, but they never really turned her over to the police.
It’s weird, but I believe the students and teachers kept the secret, despite not being obligated to doing so. Even those as Crystal Prep kept the secret as well, and they had even less obligation to do so, leaving Cinch by herself with an admittedly crazy story without several others confirming it.

That, or the writers intentionally left out anything that would be regarded as backlash to their continuing stories for this world.

Thoughts??

Heres the thing there's a cannon death said in a defrant series called pacific rim where apex brings a dead kaiju carcus and newt immediately identified it as a category 1 kaiju codename shattered shadows who had a birthday gift of equestrian magic and died by a category 7 codename heleros who sat on her head and heleros died by 1 of the storm bolts and the only thing left was of heleros was his brains and heres the thing a shattered shadows had a baby girl which was armed to the teeth and made a friend flurry heart and the kaiju then got fully grown when the storm ended

i cant help but think SOMEONE fell through the portal atleast once, because you see people sitting at the portal a lot
so what if someone just so happened to be there while it was open??

Technically Sci-Twi's phone only had three bars.

one scenario of chaos provoked by this mistake could be easily the following: human army go trough the portal to start a invasion for resources. gl using swords vs machineguns 🤣

I wanted this topic for ever and the fact that u did it makes it even better

Hey I may just be not catching on, but were does the magic leak? Does in leak from the natural portals? If so, does this mean there was a natural portal in the ocean that Rainbow say? My head is spinning with questions.

Every one:*watching the video*

Me:*stares at flower intensely*

It makes me so mad that in the same episode as sci-twi becomes a pony WITHOUT WINGS she pony’s up and gets wings

I should start to watch the Equestria Girls series, I haven't yet and I think I'm starting to miss some things :DD

Pinkie Pie could just party with them all until they get drunk, then they could get sent through the portal. They’d still wake up not knowing anything about Equestria.

I have a theory that is completely different from this but, how could the pilars plant the tree of harmony if the elements were in the castle of the two sisters. Was there a point where the princesses took the elements from the tree and hid them in the castle?

Lol i just realised... i thought everyone just went through the portal and then rested and then went back to the island, i forgot there was a portal to the CHS in twilight's castle...lmao

You saw that side twi was a unicorn in Equestria but she gets wings in the human world. Is it a mistake from Lauren Faust? Or is it the creator of side twi made a mistake?

i don’t even watch mlp anymore but this is still dang interesting

tbh I have noticed this a bit but like whenever human Twilight pony's up she'll have a pair of wings but when she goes through the portal she doesn't have a pair of wings. So like, I'm wondering whether or not you're going to make a theory about it

I remember when I was like nine
I was in timeout in my room
And I was on my bed
And I watched(I was obsessed with mlp)
Your twilight sparkle is the anti Christ vid
It rly scared me
Theeeeeenn, now , three yrs later, it popped up on my home page
Thank you for the nostalgia

She possibly just closed the portal and made sunset just have to ask her to open it through her book

Apart from the ruler of The crystal empire Twilight wasn’t the first Alicorn Remember that episode where in clouds well Rainbow Dash Need extra support But flatter shy was too quiet TwilightTurned Rarat In to an alicorn Before she was turned 😱😱😱

At the end of the friendship games Celestia or Luna said “and the magic portal between realms” or something like that, so they knew about the portal since then..

1:01 "Who knew there was a Natural Gateway between worlds".

I think we know someone who would have found it no problem.

Loki: Ta Da.

I'm pretty sure that students in canterlot high are very aware that there is a portal in front of their school.

Se que tal vez no entiendas este comentario, pero.. Lo que mas me indicgo a mi, fue que Twilight no reaccionara ante la presencia de Flash UnU.

I think that when Twilight saw Sunset and the others, she went to Starswirl and Starswirl made a portal back home, because Starswirl is an expert and he is the only one that made the portal (I think Unless Luna did)

Who thought spring breakdown would be such a mess

Sawtooth I don’t understand ever since Twilight was an alicorn her wings kept changing like a alicorn wings and then Pegasus wings I need to know why

thats why i absolutely love sunset

It such a cliffhanger and it bothers me so much and I'm bothered to this day. They didn't do even anything with it. But still wouldn't that spell have left there memories from when they walked into the portal?

Also I wonder why Sci-Twi has wings in the human world but when she is in equestria she is only a unicorn,can ya explain that?

It's rather simple the X-Files division of the FBI from the EqG world. What you think they would've just sit around doing nothing this whole time? All the crazy events going on at Canterlot High. Smells heavily of government involvement to me honestly. But I could be wrong. Though that's my headcanon to explain everything.

Soooo....I mean....didn't they all see Princess Twilight go through the portal in the first movie? And Sunset threatened to destroy it in front of the entire school. Plus, it's not like Equestria is some big secret. Everyone at the school, and post Rainbow Rocks, people in other places, too, knows that there is a portal to Equestria in easy distance from the school. Sooooo there really wouldn't be any problem with bringing everyone through the portal to shortcut things--and the shortcutting would make things so much easier on a lot of people.

The Rainbow Dash in the thumbnail is PERFECT meme material right there! XD

Better question how did twilight deal with flash 💜

Don't forget the boat crew. And the civilians from other world regions. Who now know about two magic portals. - - - - As for what I would have done as Twilight? (Me: Yay! Now we can have official First Contact! And open up trade for all sorts of neat human technology!).

I think that she should have called her actual friends and then did the rainbow lasers, that makes them forget??

sunset shimmer's biggest mistake was when she got created just like any other mlp character

Hey guys ! I have a question : If the dazzlings enter the portal, will they become ponys or dragons ( their original form in Equestria )

I love this video
No matter how many times I won't feel bored

I mean, the existence of magic didn't spread around the world, so is them passing through Equestria really that much of a problem?

I was actually thinking the same thing what sunset did was a very big mistake imagine you as a human being going through that not knowing what is magic in equestria and how it works what will you do then found out that you are a pony and found another person that looks like you what will you do? See?

I was actually thinking the same thing what sunset did was a very big mistake imagine you as a human being going through that not knowing what is magic in equestria and how it works what will you do then found out that you are a pony and found another person that looks like you what will you do? See?

i would go
"okey Sunset, we gonna send everyone, except you back & then destroy that mirror, you are clearly not suitable for that world"

wouldnt she just... deactivate the portal after sending them to school? just. take off the book. boom. portal gone until she needs to use it again

Are you kidding me. This was the dumbest theory I have ever seen. Everyone in Canterlot High already knew that this world existed. I mean they never saw it with their own eyes but they did know it existed.

I have a theory about sunset shimmer:the sunset shimmer we know is from the pony world but everyone has a human counterpart so sunset shimmer has one too I wish we could see something like that in equestria girls

Hi, I was just watching one of your video about discord and I think that discord and tirek are from the same home, possibly even knew eachother or were friends because of how quickly they recognised each other in the video were they meet, they act like old friends.

Sawtooth u should do a recap of the history and future of equestria but including all of ur theories

let's be honest the existence of equestria can't possibly remain a secret all it takes in one guy thinking he's cool and leaning on the statue then boom

I think all the houses around Canterlot high belong to the students and they tell their parents to not talk about magical things they saw

no, no, not what mistake? sunset shimmer has done nothing wrong in the following movies or in the specials. the only ones who made mistakes are the directors who said things that didn't affect the show.

I realized something, when human twilight pony up she has wings but when she becomes a pony she has no wings

Wait a sec, when si-twi went throught the portal her pony version did not have wings but when she pony upped she had wings......hmmmmm

no one's going to talk about Twilight from the human world literally a unicorn but somehow powers up to be an Alicorn okay

S: if it was us we would have gone through that portal, deep into equestria and never retuned.

O: honestly being crushed to death by any amount of things would be better than the boring world of man!

evryone already knows about it
twilight literally goes went through it in front of people

I’m wondering what happened to Sunset at the of a Friendship is Magic.

Have you done a video on sunset shimmer? If not then you should because she is pretty strange. Like you know how all the ponies have human forms? Well sunset shimmer was a pony that went there threw a portal. But we haven’t seen her as a human in that universe or at least I don’t remember. So that’s all I got to say.

Well I think that the portal was a total secret. So, of course, the whole school knew about it.

Hi in my previous comment I told you starlight is luster dawns mother because sunburst has known starlight for a long time more than Trixie also luster dawns hair pattern and hair color pattern is the same as starlight

twilight can just lock off the portal with out supplying the power to unlock it they would have to wait until the full moon

Good, this was “Bugging” me

In a way Sunset DID bring the humans into Equestria as she mentioned in the first EG movie

i mean the students didn't say anything about the magic, sooo idk why this would be too hard to keep

And now i have another reason to dislike Spring Breakdown. Thanks a bunch.
Good video, though.

What I noticed was when sci twi pony’s up, she gets wings, but when they get to ponyville sci twi didn’t have wings

Still waiting for Sunset Shimmer to meet her canterlot high counterpart.

How the hell has no one accidentally tripped in front of the portal and fell through and got the twilight castle

You forgot that the HOLE SCHOOL ALREADY KNOWS ABOUT SUNSET! THE HORSE MAGIC! TWILIGHT BEING TURNED INTO A "SHE-DEMON", WHERE HER PRINCIPAL ORDERED HER TO USE THE MAGICAL POWER TO WIN A COMPETITION! AND LET'S DO NOT FORGET ABOUT THE DAZZLINGS INCIDENT!

I always wondered how the students do not mess with those events AT ALL! I guess they love the rainbooms that much, since they voted for two and helps them in all other way... Maybe since the Changeling high was so miserable they don't even care since they have won the games.

Also, friendship is magic so they could have trust magic into that and we're able to get their trust through It

I’ve had dreams where I’m at canterlot high and I can go in the portal it was awsome if you wanna dream like that watch mlp over again

Love your videos homie! this was a great topic

Imagine the interaction pony Twilight and human Flash would have.

Haven’t we seen Pinkie Pie do weird things in the past your old video called ''Finally Solving Pinkie Pie'' should help us understand that she is just using her ''magic'' that she got. What do you think?

When sunset shimmer went evil and twilight went home I'm pretty sure that already know about the secrets but this is interesting to watch. NO HATE!!

Huh, so she found a way to bring people to other sides of the world

Pinkie pie would've been fine, since the whole switching through portals scene

Woah-ive never thought about it that way-XD

Couldn't twilight just make the portal go back to how it used to be for a couple of weeks and then turn it back

So wait..now that it’s confirmed that human Twilight is a unicorn, how come when they pony up she gets wings?🤨 if she’s a unicorn where the wings come from? It’s not like Sunset has wings and she’s just as powerful as twilight even more, I mean Sunset has better control of her magic, and has learned more about friendship, things Alicorns need to transform, Twilight isn’t really there yet (and it’s confirmed that that is the case since she wasn’t an alicorn) so why how come when she pony ups she has wings????

Wait......I just realized that the only ones we saw go through the mirror portal were sunset, spike, and twilight. Does that mean that only equestrians can go through the mirror portal?

Me: sees title*

Also me: "what'd she do this time?"

Next thing you know, the pony world is becoming an scp and all the ponies are being experimented on and tortured by the scp foundation. Because trust me, they have a lot more than magic. I should know because I work for them!

Uhhh Didn’t everyone already see Twilight go back to Equestria After the whole sunset demon thing?

I suppose Twilight may begin to keep that portal deactivated in the future.

The Stargate Iris comes to mind (probably softer though)

Me wandering

Wait won't flash sentry be pumped to see twilight again?

If there are any mcyt fans here then–

“He's in bet but i am in your Twitch chat”

Why did I say this?—

I was thinking that too before you said it the Princess Twilight Sparkle should erase their memories when they were at the pony world it is probably the best.

.... did you forget the sirens? They could find the portal due to everyone being taken via horse twi portal if derpy or someone where to remember just food for thought

How would Twilight make the Mane 7 or at least Sunset exempt from the spell? Oh wait... they’d remember anyway

I think ya forgot ONE THING: Friendship Games, when SciTwi took SunSet's magic, she could not access the portal. That leads me to believe that only certain individuals infused with Equestrian Magic can open the portal...

In pony world:
Pinkie: So tired when she is started in pony world (before the blooper scene why double Pinkie)
Rarity: Get's naked
Applejack: Cover's the naked body with her hat
fluttershy: she's excited to an animal
Sentry: Meets princess twilight
trixie: using her magic horn
derpy: i just don't no what went wrong
lyra: i do become an animal now
bon bon: get's vomit
ragamuffin: trying to sex with rarity
ETC ETC ETC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
PLEASE SUNSET!!! Go alone! And the Humans build another boat now!!!!!!!

Haha Sunset is smart but reckless but I want to know what Twilights reaction to Flash was cause like they were a thing haha

Honestly I think twilight shouldve scold sunset shimmer after that

Welp...

At least Storm King didn’t actually appear....



Let the island explain about that and it will/should tell everybody why it is has a portal and or why it had a connection to Storm King idk

The fact that Doctor Whooves is an earth pony in the show 😅

wh

WH-
what movie is this from ive seen all mlp ones?????

Everyone at Canterlot High already knows the existence of the statue portal as they were all standing around it in the first movie when Twilight and Spike went back home and then Pinkie Pie tried to run in after but the portal already closed...

Lol the reason why the main six wasn’t aloud with twilight was because it will overdo the balance and sunset 🌅 took everyone from the world and brought them to the pony world and was UPSETTING the BALANCE

Just imagine walking in the school lawn then falling into the statue and the first thing, your a horse

Wouldn't sunburst know that his sister was back in equestria if so why didn't he go see her

I hoped there would be more comments to read but lmao it's been 2 minutes

I think I might figure it out Alcorn history when cadence Celestia and Luna give twilight their Magic celestia And Luna they Lost sparkles but cadence only lost her cutie mark so is Cadence A natural Alcorn

Do u remember what princes Celestia says when twilight go into the portal for the first time 😏

was this before or after the storm king was defeated?

The students already saw equestria when midnight sparkle riped the dimentions and they knew there was portal to equestria in thier school cause they have seen princess twilight go through it many times.

Who is principle chinch in the pony world . I have been asking for ages there is no available answer😾😿

I know it would be absolute chaos but don’t you wanna see what would happen if the ones from the human world went to equestria and vise versa?

FYI it not her who in my dream fussed both universe into 1 it novamos did by his rift gun causing flurry heart to go unstable and then 5 seconds later all of us where knocked out then woke up and saw are pony counter parts here and a staterlite photo shows are universe where combined and then 2 seconds later the imagine order showed up and then thanks to novamos stupidity a deferent portal opened by the statue blow up and this guy named gladius showed up and took on novamos and the my equestrian counter part ( whos both female and a changeling hybrid thanks to the loverload she has kaiser and alicorn dna and magic) showed up and killed all of the armed io guards

Fun fact: human Rainbowdash and Twilight are the only two humans to go through the portal. It was unprecedented territory for any of the movies prior.

Hey I have a theory ,if there's a human version of every pony and there was also a human ver of twilight wouldn't there already be a human sunset shimmer ?🤔🤔

Ok, every single Comment is "first" or "second" or "early"

This action could have destroyed the magical balance of the equinverse and the humanverse will be erased from extinction

different question where did the portals originally come from?

I don't know how that portal is still a secret. No one ever went to lean on that pedestal and then found themselves falling backwards and out of a mirror?

Hey saw tooth I hate to say it but I'm going to rip your entire theory out of the ground considering the fact that I'm pretty sure everyone at canterlot high and even Crystal prep knows about the portal to Equestria

First!

I love MLP it’s my favorite show

Nice theory, wana hear one even crazier? What if the future twilight is actually Chrisalis? Now hear me out on this, in the opening of that episode we clearly see a statue of the mane six and the bronies react crew said that that is not a statue but the real deal petrified because they f-ed up badly, admittedly it was a joke, but what if it wasn't?

If a memory erase happens image this: The whole boat thing happens and everyone got their memory erase but it doesn't work on you, the next day you headed to the statue and see if real and you found out it's real you have two options: 1 tell everyone or 2 don't tell, how about that.

Twilight controls when the portal is on and off in Equestria,so its probably not always on

I think they all know about portals to pony worlds, but my question is how did they not get confused with ponies and how did the actual ponies not get confused-?

I haven't thought about MLP in ages...but yes, that was dumb on Sunset's part.

My solution? The students are smart and have an unspoken agreement to not mess with magic, I mean they kept it a secret from the rest of the world.

Oh my Celestia you are so smart Sawtooth!!

That's why i want part two of that episode???

I've got a question for you how did celestia know about the castle😏

I mean, sunset has been seen screwing up, a lot.

I find it weird that the other twilight isn’t an alicorn when she turns into a pony only a unicorn

If you say another portal to the equestria must be the cause of different locations where midnight sparkle planted into any other places making having easier way to get more magic?

She did really messed up with that and i was so confused what was going to happen

But i think the portal opens every new/full moon im not really sure which one exactly it was so they dont have a lot of time to think about what happened to the portal

Changeling Queen feeds on to much love from the Cristal empire.

Uh sawtooth? Remember when human twilight geared holes and stuff? Yeah the pony’s and humans know about each other. THEY BOTH SAW EACH OTHER THEY KNOW OF THEIR EXCISTANCE

I'm wondering if there's another sunset shimmer, one in Equestria and one in the human world, well the sunset we have now was from Equestria. Since Celestia said that she was her former student.

(I swear if I jinx) Imagine in like a future installment of Equestria Girls where the students find the portal between worlds.

One possible explanation: the portal is already closed on the next day so...

But i think everyone knows about the portal. Twilight literally went to her world through the portal in front of everyone. But.. no-one REALLY SEEMS TO CARE! NON ARE EVEN A BIT CURIOUS..

One thing that doesn’t make sense to me is how human world twilight has wings. But when she goes through she suddenly loses them, it does make more sense chaos wise for her not the have the powers of an alicorn but logically? She should have!

Has anyone noticed that
Human twilight was just a normal unicorn in Equestria
But has wings when they pony up?
Idk just thought it was odd

No she didn't make a mistake because she and the others were on a island with a sand portol even if she use the the portol she can make them unconscious so they didn't knew

And what would be the worst? Is the changelings would be blamed by the ponyville, since a stallion can be seen talking with pony rd and fainted, so everypony will probably report it to the mayor.

hey at least Flash finally got to see Princess Twi again... its been a while

OMG I love your videos please make a new one soon!

So... You're saying this action could have brought chaos... Maybe... Disharmony?... Maybe... DISCORD?

could this be the event to allow another discord to exist in the human world?

Oh gosh I can already here Twilight shouting at Sunset

Heres what i wouldve done for if sunset sent the entire school to equestria to go back to the school. I wouldve given an earful and lecture and whip up a spell to make them forget. And also yeet everyone with unicorn magic thorugh the portal

Everyone already knew about equestria because of the friendship games even the shadow bolts know

Sci-twi had no wings during her pony form but had wings during her "pony up" form 🤔🤔🤔

But The Mane (human) 6 already see Twilight n Sunset going back to Equestria for about at least 2-3 times....and a WHOLE STUDENTS from Crystal Prep + CHS already saw it when Midnight destroyed the statue n the dimension rifts torn the fabrics of Time & Space infront of them revealing Equestria!!
Do you thik it still not an Out-Off-Ballance problems?

What I even mumbling run

can it be part of the backstory to the new generation?

I love your videos!

Well the Canterlot high students looked pretty tired and beat. So the next day they probably olney had small memories of the portal and pony's and twilight's castle

Can you please make a video about where chrysalis, sombra ,tirek ,cosy glow,discord,Grogan in the human world please 🙏 😊

Heh imagine if celestias guards aka kinda clones went through that portal without her knowing like even I wouldn't notice that one of them were missing😂

twilight could simply take off the book so the portal won't open unless she and spike were going through

Sawtooth they already knew of the portal cause I bet people saw Twilight come through the second and third time she went to the human world.

Pffft that wasn't mistake... That was the best moment ever xD

9 months late but
couldn't princess twilight just let everyone back home and 'turn off' her portal? I mean, That would mean Sunset couldn't go to the pony world when she needed, but she has a book to communicate with princess Twilight, she can just tell her to open it when she needs

Starlight is genius

Nothing starlight couldn’t whip up lol and btw I agree you made a good point :D but what about if twilight did nothing and they went through the portal? What will celestial do? 🤔🤔 edit: at 3:18 look at spikes face XD

Doesnt everyone know already? When twilight went by herself with spike didn't she go threw the portal infront of everyone when she got her crown back? Everyone knows already.

In the first movie didn’t they all watch twilight go back through the portal into her own world?

i think twilight will bring them to the portal and before bringing them in she will erase there memories and immediately bring them back to the island from where they came from and they will be back in the island like nothing have happen

Sunset does this...
Discord be like am I a joke to you?

can I ask you something remember the video where 8-9 different time lines in the 8 time lines what happened to the human world , because the times change before sunset shimmer left so what do you think happened to human world

They already know about the portal underneath the horse because they watched twilight grow through it in the first times we saw equestria girls

Ooh, Beauty and the Beast music.
Nicely done.

Sad... we couldn't see what accually happens after THAT CRAAAZY thing

Optimus Prime: I know you are a sterner stuff!
Sunset: NO!

Not talking about her whole mistake but, Flash Sentry and Twilight could actually meet each other and talk again :>

sawtooth waves how did you know that you are a max leveled genius

it’s so funny seeing people try to fill in the plot holes of badly written shows

I JUST rediscovered your channel! (love it btw)

... but isn't the portal to the school only open when Twilight wants it to be? So, it would be off again as soon as they make it back through, so when they check later, it would be closed...

Twilight Spell book 7: There's a spell for that.

I think the last video is how the changling Queen crilsise would make a army so all she would need to do is to wait until one changlin is grown up then she can use the mirror pool then she would have an army!

i have a threoy okay here me out what if when sunset made this huge mistake of bringing everyone to equestia and in ur resent video u said that cozy glow was from the human world so when sunset brougth them in the mirror cozy was still in equestia and tried to take over the world

I wouldn't mind going though the portal I would become horse to use magic. Of all the worlds with magic this one seems the best

WAIT WHAT. She did go back! I don't usually watch EG but I tihnk I'm going to have find this online now

Digging that flower, Sawtooth.

What if human Twilight remembered the magic she stole and figured it out?

sun set: we’re back. twilight: are you crazy!?

Heres A Theory You should do:
"What Happened to the Mean 6? Could they still be Alive?"

I WANNA KNOW WACHA YALL THINK
Pls Sawtooth

I think twilight gave them all amnestic




(Amnestic is a compound that cause memory loss

Everyone should have known about that place by now😓😑

Now why does human twilight have wings when she pony-ups in the human world but is a regular unicorn in the pony world?

Probably off-topic but- if princess Celestia and princess Luna has lived for over a 1000 years, what would it be like? Wouldn't it just be painful to make a friend and see them fade away overtime knowing that you are immortal-

I think that wallflower blush would earese the memories of the students

Sawtooth you have just saved or fixed sunsets mistake

Yeah I'm pretty sure 100% that pinkie used that portal

Wait a minute
Princess Twilight went to the human world for her crown
And there was no other Twilight
Then where did the other Twilight with the glasses came from as u can see there was two Twilight ಠ_ʖಠ

Could this be a clown of Twilight or did i miss something about creating a new Twilight

Yeah lol I’d assume she had to cast a spell on them

Alicorn Sunset Shimmer theory video: Princess of Harmony (yin yang cutiemark sunset version omg!!!)

Rodimus: So you got Twilight, Rainbow Dash & the Mane 5 and the 25 humans entered to the Pony World
Sunset: No! 260 almost...
(TRIGGERED RODIMUS TO SUNSET!)

How come in EQG the students dont go through the stature's portal as its not locked and reserved fotr the mane 7 ? Is nobody curious ?

One risk that sunset took is a run in with their poney counterparts

but the real question is: why doesn't human twilight turn into an alicorn in Equestria, if she's laters clearly seen to have wings when she ponies up?

what id like to know is why there isn’t two sunset shimmers.a pony,and human. when twilight goes through the portal later on it’s discovered there’s another version of her in that world. but we never see another version of sunset shimmer.but we do however see all the other characters as another version of themselves.

So am I the only one who wonders where's the Sunset Shimmer of the human world?

They know about the portal because they saw magic also in the first movie they hear the story about the portal and Luna and celesta said keep the magic in your would aka inplaing that they knew about the portal

Human Lyra: I wanted to be a Pony but this too much!

Pony Lyra: Come on Bon Bon! We got to go on a trip, accidently release the storm king so i can become a Hooman! It like that show i watched on the Hooman Tube!

Bon Bon: N o O o

Hey, maybe you could do a Collab with somepony, I'd like to see you and Firebrand or Silver Quill have some joking fun over MLP.

I choose to ignore these side stories honestly XD

Could discord would've notice the dimensional imbalance?

Maybe they will pull a gravity falls have a rule that no one talks about it with outsiders. Or never mentions it at all because its so strange.
Gasp maybe this town will become like gravity falls where the inhabitants accept it and don't think to much about the weird happenings. As well as hide it from outsiders.
Could we get a gravity falls mlp crossover? In fanfics I mean thier is a mabel pony in the comics. (Pretty sure at least)

I think sunset is being stupid for doing that
Seeing sci-twi as a pony is hilarious

Don't let this distract you from the fact that NEITHER Sunset Nor Twilight MADE ANY EFFORT to BEFRIEND THE DAZZLINGS after the end of Rainbow Rocks! Even PINKIE of all people didn't even made a move to BEFRIEND SONATA even though SHE WAS SUPPOSED TO BE THE MOST APPROACHABLE OF THE HUMANE 6!!

With the life boats rarity created they could have sailed directly to thier school if they dont know the way they could have use gps in the phone to get back
What doyou guys think?

Maybe they just used memory orbs.

Curious humans always trying to come through your magic portal? "Close the Iris!"

Sawtooth Waves :"How do we deal with this crazy situation? "
Me: Just kill them... Wait... Maybeeee that ain't the best idea after all >~<

Hey Sawtooth i hope this isnt a bad question but i wanted to know: Did you create your mlp character (Or changeling) on a website? Can you tell me what website please i'm thinking of making a channel like yours (i'm so sorry if it seems like i'm copying you) and i want to have an amazing pony like yours! (Also i'm subscribed your videos are amazing!! The only thing i'm ashamed of is that i havent seen all the seasons but i will by the time i start the channel :))

Yes she did… Well they had to learn the truth!

two words. they knew.
hey knew the portal was there in the first movie EVERONE SAW TWLIGHT GO IN THE PORTAL

Hey, did you see? When sunset shimmer take humans in ecvestria there was flash too. We all knows twilight sparkle has crush on flash and flash has crush on twilight. They did not even touch each other, this time they usually had to look at each other alone. Why?

Did he not think of turning off the portal and she had to make it a year around one.

Speculations for Equstria Girls 5: To Equestria and Beyond

But they already know that there is a secret portal don't you remember when twilight visits cantorlot high school and they sees twilight goes through the portal

The simple answer of everything is: this ia a KİD SHOW and we don't have to over complicate thingd like if people saw those magical stuff

Did they just leave the other passengers and crew members on the island 💀

so, if there is ONE alternate world, there could be more, right? Maybe THATS why there are so many clones...











or the animator is just lazy.

but you never know .....its possible...

i do not think she erased their mind and let them go knowing they could not come back because at the friendship games when twlight sucked the magic out of sunset shimmer she felt the portal was not there

Hold on at the end of the first mlp film they all saw twilight leave throught the portal they already new about the magic that was there

I'll make a movie:
During the Spring Breakdown. Rodimus and the Magnificent 6 travels to the island so they will blow up the TNT into a magical quicksand. But somethings not right. Jazz light up the fire and the TNT starting to explode. Rodimus gets down into Magnificent 6. And they traveled to the Pony world. And they transformered into Ponies. When the Magnificent 7 get's stucked. With the help of the Maximal named Mach Kick into another time. For this mission go back to the human world and back to normal

What if they kept the memories of going through the portal but then wake up outside school

So how does magic act like an EMP (Electromagnetic Pulse) and destroys all electronics but not a phone?

Has anyone noticed that sunset kinda has yin and yan (sorry if I spelled it wrong) in the middle of her cutie mark?
What if it means something

I was waiting for a new video.. but I was late.. i think twilight sparkle erased everyone's memory of the middle..

I just realise, Flash Sentry was in that pony crowd. If Celestia give to temptation of seeing good Sombra until it was too late, wouldn't he and Twilight? It was quite obvious he never really move on so for him idea of seeing her throught portal, or even staing in Equestria and maybe replacing somepony who already looks like him? Or like Pinkie clone just starting his own life? Sunset get away with it for years before and theres no implications she ever even met human Sunset.

Do a video on if Celestia in dreams when Luna was banished to the moon.

I think twilight would throw bricks at everyone

All the students at the school know about the portal and almost all the the people there were students so I think there safe.😉👍🏼

I think Twillight closed the portal after this event

What happened on the island and with the portals are a complete secret. So, naturally, the whole school knows. -Dumbledore..maybe?

i think twilight must have cast a spell on them and the next sun rise they forgot just everything what happen....

Maybe Sunset is only pretending to be reformed and is still looking for ways to rule Equestria? Like "Obey me or I'll destabilise the worlds, Mwahahahahaha..." etc.

Off topic but I feel like Flash Sentry is a descendant of Flash Magnus

New title of video sunset is turning back to evil

Yo, this is random but i just thought about it, what the hell is Tempest's cutie mark, like would she have one or not?

Awesome!!

Sawtoon had a point if she bringer everyone in human world at equestria in another portal what made them passed all those ponies walking around?

I love your Alcorn Alcorn Morphe sawtooth waves

I still think the storm king was a ghost in the spring break special

So what ur saying is that not a single student in canterlot high has ever even touched the base of that statue, and that’s why nobody’s discovered a portal there, huh

Did spike have wings during this scene???
Or did it happen before the events of 'Molt Down' episode???

Maybe Twilight got food, water, and beds for everyone?

I wanna see what happend after they got back and the EP ended

Did nobody realize that Sunset left the staff on the island?

I like how you showed lyra

Or maybe she made the main 6 guard the secret

HOW THE FRICK DID SCI TWI HAVE FULL BARS WHEN I ONLY HAVE TWO!!!

WAS the portal a secret, though?

That's how gen 5 happened. All us humans imported racism to Equestria.

No cause remember when sunset was threatening to break the portal infront of the school, and remember in the first movie twilight went back home infront of anyone when she said this isn’t goodbye this is goodbye till next time

the school all ready knows about the portal to equestria because twilight went through it in the first movie and the school was watching😀

I think that scitwis phone was destryed in when they got into equestria

have you done a video on where sunset shimmers alternate human version is?? 😭

I cant believe my little pony ended there are so many questions left .

Welp,this makes SO much sense

Didn't twilit go in and out of the school portal in front of everybody in the human and star light

doesnt twilight got through the portal in front of the entire school every single movie tho

Your telling me no one ever fell in to the portal on accident? I mean its on a public place in front of the school

What is your outro song? It's so catchy :D 🔥

Ummmm doesn’t the book power the portal twilight should just send them back and take away the book and when sunset needs to come through just place back the book

WHY WOULD SUNSET DO THAT?

She move the castles porter to a mountain so they be confused

3:54 they woukd go through the portal, With Twi, And she would…Put on a pair of sunglasses, ig tell sunset to stay away or put on some, change the thing so its a few minutes ago, and act like they just got back to school from their boat trip

Hi sawtooth I discovered a weird thing you should do a video about so basically side twie is not an allicorn in mlp pony world but when she becomes the ponied up version she was an allicorn pretty sus don’t you think?

If only Equestria Girls wasn’t canceled. I could really go for another movie.

They all went to the portal to give the staff and I think the went to the island again and called for help I think and the never went to that place again so that is my theory😅

wait, don't the CHS students already know about the portal?

Somewhere I can tell that discord is slowly clapping and crying tears of joy

I think everyone already knows about the portal at school,so its not a secret anymore

i'm thinking sunset did that to save them from a sinking cruise ship then they went in that portal then went to twilight she probably explained the situation then twilight accepts it then showed them to the mirror where they went home and possibly when they got back they were fascinated with what happened but do remember the humane 6 was with princess twilight before sci twi joined the group and they became the humane 7

There is no season ten! The last season 9 episode was called the last problem the end of the song has the book closed which means it’s the end of the series

You have seen that in Equestria girls the movie pony Sunset was have blue magic like her eyes but in equestria girls clip as we have seen her as pony,she was have red magic

Everyone alreeady knew about the portal since they were talking about it during the fight with sunset shimer in the first one

I agree with you Sawtooth

All u have to do is touch the statue I’m sure loads of people have been through the portal pretty crazy right?

i have a question is princess twilight sparkle still in love with human flash sentry or did she forgot about all about him because she has to stay in the pony world

off topic and i dont know if you covered this already but do you think rainbow dash is fast enough to reverse time without magic? she might not deserve her element (i disagree) but can she travel around the world multiple times fast enough to reverse time? what do you think?

5:04 I have a question, that’s been bothering me for a bit- why do you always say their names like that? I don’t understand it

How many episodes am I missing.😢

sometimes you are spoiling the show

She really made the worst mistake XD

Maybe since Twilight went there for something and ya she remembered her pony and human times there but everyone else nah

Actually the portal at school is not a secret cuz from the first movie everyone at the fall dance saw twilight walk thru and even watched pinkie try after and just smack her face into it. So I'd say the students at canterlot high are good with secrets

Can you do a video over Tempest broken horn

If I was Twilight I would just say dont you dare think about yesterday

Uh, I think everyone knows Sunset’s biggest mistake is stealing Twilight’s crown and trying to use its Magic to take over Equestria. Now she’s reformed, you don’t have to make a video about it.

The same plan but after everyone ween through turn it off and if sunset needs to go back message twilight to open it up again.

Wait a minute, where's Yoshi Darklord?

Canterlot....world...is an experimental Yahoo colony where humans are seeing if Yahoo can be civilized enough to be called humans. With pony interference the experiment isn't going very well.
Where was that crew from? The Gilligan school of nautical skill?

Awesome and cool video,wow.

She use a spell that erase the memory of that the island and of the portal

This is just me but I would have them fallow me one bye one or two extras and take them to princess Twi's castle for the portal or make them wait.

Or maybe they made them promise to not to say anything except if it was the only option.

So Sunset basically invented Nether Travel XD

I glad my little pony fandom is still alive

Oh wow another mistake bye sunset that makes like three right? Like who’s counting
Love the vids

Also what about the other sunset from the human world.

Where do you get all these episodes?

What whould Discord be if he went to the human world??

Wait, how when ci twie phoneys up she has the large alicorn wings, but when she enters the phoney world she dose not the Evan have wings?!

Boy howdy, this whole balance between worlds schtick needs to go perish in a fire, because if not, LIFE'S SCREWED FOR FUN REGARDLESS.

I think they basically go trought the portal and people promised that they would never talk about the portal. Sci Twi's phone was working but the others couldn't. Because you know, Twi is a technologie expert and maybe she created a special communication to the mane 7 for urgence. And seriously!? No other one then Sci Twi and the Dazzling saw those giant rainbow lasers? They tought these are special effects and only Sci Twi secretly went to search that school?