for everyone wondering what this is from, search "spring breakdown" on youtube! but don't forget to come back here to finish the video once you're done c:

for everyone wondering what this is from, search "spring breakdown" on youtube! but don't forget to come back here to finish the video once you're done c:

Why do you always say yoshi dark lord and syanaxx with no expression

Why do you always say yoshi dark lord and syanaxx with no expression

I don't think so, because they already know that in the 1rst movie last scene

I don't think so, because they already know that in the 1rst movie last scene

Alicorn Sunset Shimmer theory video: Princess of Harmony (yin yang cutiemark sunset version omg!!!)

Alicorn Sunset Shimmer theory video: Princess of Harmony (yin yang cutiemark sunset version omg!!!)

Well now that (MLP Friendship is Magic) has ended I guess will never know what Twilight did.

Well now that (MLP Friendship is Magic) has ended I guess will never know what Twilight did.

@Gorana Stupar He did! Check out his new video!

@Gorana Stupar He did! Check out his new video!

@[Shadow_User[ they dont know about the portal in their schools yard, big difference

@[Shadow_User[ they dont know about the portal in their schools yard, big difference

um sawtooth i hate to break this to ya but almost every one in canterlot high know about equstria.... because of tje friendship games....

um sawtooth i hate to break this to ya but almost every one in canterlot high know about equstria.... because of tje friendship games....

@Raven  yeah I agree with you now if you don't mind it's 11:30 pm I'm going to sleep now

@Raven  yeah I agree with you now if you don't mind it's 11:30 pm I'm going to sleep now

@Gorana Stupar i think her wings aren’t strong enough or she’s still learning

@Gorana Stupar i think her wings aren’t strong enough or she’s still learning

@Amanda one question..may I ask what episode this is, I never knew this was a episode lol.stay safe and ty

@Amanda one question..may I ask what episode this is, I never knew this was a episode lol.stay safe and ty

Thank you I was wonder haven’t seen this one yet thx

Thank you I was wonder haven’t seen this one yet thx

Pretty sure the storm wouldve made it worse before help could arrive. Also, that relic was returned. she probably altered the memories a Tad but that's abit

Where can you watch that? Is it an episode or movie?

Where can you watch that? Is it an episode or movie?

I literally have proof that the peeps did know about the equestrian world but they had no idea how they got back to their world. Earlier on someone questioned me that the equestrian world fluttershy mentioned about is the theme park but that's wrong, the theme park is actually called equestrian land. So it is clear enough that the human mane 6 did know about the pony world but I think twilight erased the others' memories on how they got back to avoid the complication in this video, of the humans assessing the other side of the portal.

Yeet them out  the window   screaming  YYYYYEEEEEEEEE EEEEEEEEEE  TTTTTTTTT

Yeet them out  the window   screaming  YYYYYEEEEEEEEE EEEEEEEEEE  TTTTTTTTT

All I have to say is I am a big fan and I think you’re right about the solution to twilights problems with the humans figuring out the portal

All I have to say is I am a big fan and I think you’re right about the solution to twilights problems with the humans figuring out the portal

Suniks🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩

Suniks🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩

You should make an episode where it makes sense of why there was a twilight but no sunset shimmer like there was another twilight but there was no sunset shimmer?

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar Mmm idk really! OOOOOOOOOOOO THERRRRRR FRIENDS-ZA😈 GIRL!

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar Mmm idk really! OOOOOOOOOOOO THERRRRRR FRIENDS-ZA😈 GIRL!

Hey...... I wanted to let you know something mr. Waves. I think sunset shimmer and starlight glimmer are sisters because they both where power hungry, both have last names that are in the same state, and also they were reformed ,like discord, by twilight. So I really think starlight and sunset is sisters, but that's not the only thing I have in mind. Sunset lives in the human world while starlight is in the pony world. This gets me thinking why did starlight already know how to use her hands when she went to the human world.I know you like making theories about mlp so I thought you might like for me to share this with you

unless sawtooth has a vid how to reform them

unless sawtooth has a vid how to reform them

I was just about to ask where this was from!!

I was just about to ask where this was from!!

@emily yeomans  no problem I'm a fan of mlp to

@emily yeomans  no problem I'm a fan of mlp to

The other reason Celestia was worried about damaging the balance is because she did damage the balance of a the parallel world when she was younger.

The other reason Celestia was worried about damaging the balance is because she did damage the balance of a the parallel world when she was younger.

@Artus-Tartus  there's only one sunset shimmer and 2 different twilight's

@Artus-Tartus  there's only one sunset shimmer and 2 different twilight's

Everyone saw the portal in the first movie

Everyone saw the portal in the first movie

Hi wath about that allacorn changleng quend how its become allecorn

Hi wath about that allacorn changleng quend how its become allecorn

@Isaiah R i know why we dont see her im ponyvill im just saying how the pony dimension has a pony twilight and the human word has a human twilight. Shouldnt the same be for sunset shimmer? But the only sunset we see is the pony version in the human world. We never actually see the true human sunset in the human dimension

@Artus-Tartus  Good question Llama toons so sunset shimmer does have a human and a pony form when she went b to get twilight's crown she went into the portal somehow and took it so there is not two humans just to pony s  what I am trying to say is sunset shimmer has a human form but there's only 1 human form and 2 pony for,s but for the pony in pony vill the pony can n go in to the portal and go into there human form or the humans can go to the portal the thing is that there only one sunset shimmer<br>That's why you don't see sunset shimmer in pony vill. I I hope that answers your question!

@Artus-Tartus  Good question Llama toons so sunset shimmer does have a human and a pony form when she went b to get twilight's crown she went into the portal somehow and took it so there is not two humans just to pony s  what I am trying to say is sunset shimmer has a human form but there's only 1 human form and 2 pony for,s but for the pony in pony vill the pony can n go in to the portal and go into there human form or the humans can go to the portal the thing is that there only one sunset shimmer
That's why you don't see sunset shimmer in pony vill. I I hope that answers your question!

Hey I've got two questions that I'm curious about.

1. If the human demension has human versions of every pony and Sunset Shimmer was from the pony dimension, where's the human version of Sunset?

2. Remember when you talked about the elements of disharmony? Since G4 ended and we have seen everything maybe there is more evidence that can support the theory.

I just had a thought: what happened to owlicious, you know twilight's pet?

I just had a thought: what happened to owlicious, you know twilight's pet?

Can you whach a mlp fan comic " the last adventure " just look it up on YouTube

Can you whach a mlp fan comic " the last adventure " just look it up on YouTube

Hey saw tooth have you ever thought that the storm kings staff fell into the human world I mean that would be the one cost that his magic could have opened up another portal and triggers human twilight and sunset shimmer to go insane or as I call it villain mode! But that's just my theory.

Please explain this mystery that WONT GO AWAY. Prince BLUEBLOOD. Rarity makes it clear that Prince Blueblood is Celestia's NEPHEW. Does that mean Luna is a mother??? If so, Who's the father??  Or are other sisters not being mentioned? s prince Blueblood adopted? Or is he biological? Other dimensions? Discord messing with Rarity's mind?  Or bad story writing...

I agreee with your theory. It would be logical too. If she followed your idea, she would have avoided many humans going to the pony witld

I agreee with your theory. It would be logical too. If she followed your idea, she would have avoided many humans going to the pony witld

Not only that, it would also attract attention of an interdimensional warring race.

Not only that, it would also attract attention of an interdimensional warring race.

@Sawtooth Waves two words: Pinkie promise<br>All princess twilight has to do is make them swear not tell no one or face Pinkie Pie’s wrath 🤣🤣🤣

@Sawtooth Waves two words: Pinkie promise
All princess twilight has to do is make them swear not tell no one or face Pinkie Pie’s wrath 🤣🤣🤣

@Cerys Rogers You are doing it good kid, keep up firing those neurons!

@Cerys Rogers You are doing it good kid, keep up firing those neurons!

@LEE TSZ TUNG 3B21 Yeah, if Sunset Shimmer thought of all that before she brought everyone on that cruise ship through both portals.

@LEE TSZ TUNG 3B21 Yeah, if Sunset Shimmer thought of all that before she brought everyone on that cruise ship through both portals.

@LEE TSZ TUNG 3B21 probably their version of the FBI. You know, a SWAT team surrounding the school and barging through the doors.

@LEE TSZ TUNG 3B21 probably their version of the FBI. You know, a SWAT team surrounding the school and barging through the doors.

@chocolate mint candy cookie Plus, imagine if a government agency did came in arresting both The Mane 7 and Principal Celestia and Vice Principal Luna. The Mane 7 being arrested of suspicion of being either mutants or alien. And Principal and Vice Principal Celestia and Luna being arrested of their ware abouts of the portal at CHS. And Sunset doing the ultimate sacrifice, turning herself in to the government agency if they don't arrest her friends, Principal Celestia or Vice Principal Luna. Celestia and Luna didn't know about portal at CHS, and she's the who brought magic from Equestria to the human world. Which would leave her friends and maybe even Celestia and Luna help her escape, making them fugitives of the law, laying low for a while, then probably a villains, maybe the villainous trio (Queen Chrysalis, Lord Tirek, and Cozy Glow) not only found their way to the human world, free themselves, but somehow got magic, it would lead the Mane 7 to fight against the villainous trio, it would show the government agency they're not aliens or mutations but heroes. And if they defeat the villainous trio, they might get arrested. And finally the Mane 7 would do a Presidential Conference, and Sunset explaining to the world of Equestria exists, of her being a former unicorn from there, of the portal at CHS, and her and her friends having magic abilities to help and protect people.

@LEE TSZ TUNG 3B21 Plus, imagine if a government agency did came in arresting both The Mane 7 and Principal Celestia and Vice Principal Luna. The Mane 7 being arrested of suspicion of being either mutants or alien. And Principal and Vice Principal Celestia and Luna being arrested of their ware abouts of the portal at CHS. And Sunset doing the ultimate sacrifice, turning herself in to the government agency if they don't arrest her friends, Principal Celestia or Vice Principal Luna. Celestia and Luna didn't know about portal at CHS, and she's the who brought magic from Equestria to the human world. Which would leave her friends and maybe even Celestia and Luna help her escape, making them fugitives of the law, laying low for a while, then probably a villains, maybe the villainous trio (Queen Chrysalis, Lord Tirek, and Cozy Glow) not only found their way to the human world, free themselves, but somehow got magic, it would lead the Mane 7 to fight against the villainous trio, it would show the government agency they're not aliens or mutations but heroes. And if they defeat the villainous trio, they might get arrested. And finally the Mane 7 would do a Presidential Conference, and Sunset explaining to the world of Equestria exists, of her being a former unicorn from there, of the portal at CHS, and her and her friends having magic abilities to help and protect people.

Also if aliens are real in my little pony how were there made? I think  that one of star swirl,s experiments of trying to make an alicorn made these aliens called irkens in my little pony and escaped into space?

Sawtooth waves, I thought that are aliens real in the pony world and mainly irkens and did irkens try to take over the pony world and in is that why in the final episode of my little pony we saw furry heart with the pure heart on a staned glass window? After all clestia said this "the only way that a new staned glass window is put up is if something manger happens.*

@Argamis (SilverComet) so she is like luna kind of when she turned into nightmare moon she kept that magic as a second cutie mark so its always been there just never showed up? Am i overthinking this-

@Standwich Ask Twilight or Starlight to shut down the portal from the other side.

@Standwich Ask Twilight or Starlight to shut down the portal from the other side.

@LEE TSZ TUNG 3B21 Yeah, this is just like both Lab Rats (You Posted What?) and X-Men Evolution (Day of Reckoning part 1/2) when the whole world finds out of their existence. I mean sure the whole school of CCHS and some from Crystal Prep Academy knows of their existence, but do you think the whole world should of Equestria existence?

Probably a good thing that everyone on that cruise besides the Mane 7, had their memories erased of the portal from Equestria to CCHS. If rumor did spread out like wildfire, that could lead to multiple consequences.
1. Some people might have taken photos of Equestria, and the portal and post them on the internet, and be confirmed legit real.
2. It would probably would agency like the  FBI or CIA do an investigation around the portal and ask questions to both the Mane 7 and Principal Celestia & Vice Principal Luna about the portal.
3. Press conference and news reports around Sunset Shimmer explaining to the world how the human world and Equestria isn't that different.

@Gorana Stupar She is not ready hate you love scootaloo and all of you hate the villains too

@Gorana Stupar She is not ready hate you love scootaloo and all of you hate the villains too

@Cerys Rogers [Kinda Offtopic] :
. "The Human Scientist, Twilight Sparkle" (Sci!Twi) original "pony up" transformation would have being WITHOUT wings [but this never happened because she was traumatized by the event of Friendship Games].
-> In Legend of Everfree she was still trying to supress her magic.

.  The evil alter_ego/persona Midnight!Sparkle was created with the acumulation of magic fragments from Sunset Shimmer (an actual unicorn born in Equestria), plus from each of the other "humane five" (who acquired them from "The Alicorn Princess, Twilight Sparkle"; who got her status from her own unicorn magic plus the "beams" of energy from her 5 pony friends).
-> Midnight!Sparkle was BORN as a alicorn_equivalent human/demon.

At the end of Legend of Everfree, Sci!Twi managed to defeat Midnight!Sparkle ALL BY HERSELF (she did got some encouragement from her friends, but unlike in Friendship Games she was not "cured" by Sunset or any other external force).
 -> Sci!Twi "absorbed" Midnight!Sparkle, acquiring both her powers, "backbone" and perhaps some of her "mad scientist" tendencies.

This is why she can "tap" into a higher pony up body when she uses her geod; but without this "arcane focus" artifact she may not get her wings when she pony_up (this scenario has never happened in the series, but Sunset Shimmer did reverted back to her "normal human" form without her geod in the music short "Cheer You On").

.  The geods are "hidden" inside the body (fused/phased) when a human goes through the portal & transformed to a pony [likely considered as "part of their clothes", just like human!Rainbow´s hat]; but they are still "active" since Sunset´s magical aura changed colors (from the original green teal of her eyes, to the fiery red of the geod).

.  Both Sci!Twi & Sunset Shimmer can probably "Super_Pony_Up" while in Equestria (the latter maybe requiring the rest of her friends to channel their magic), getting a temporary "alicorn transformation" similar to the Rainbow Power.

Sunset Shimmer is my favorite character in Equestria Girls

Sunset Shimmer is my favorite character in Equestria Girls

I have a theory what if pony tri change and erased there memory's so they thought that the mane 7 did something to get them home

I have a theory what if pony tri change and erased there memory's so they thought that the mane 7 did something to get them home

@Gorana Stupar she doesn't know how to she's too young I think

@Gorana Stupar she doesn't know how to she's too young I think

What I’m wondering is when equestrian girls was taking place, at then end once twilight gets her crown from principal celstia she and spike walk towards the portal and entered it, wouldn’t everyone that attended the fall formal notice twilight enetering the portal?

What's the name of the show your talking about?! I wanna watch it!!!!!!!!!!

What's the name of the show your talking about?! I wanna watch it!!!!!!!!!!

Does anyone know if it’s only on YouTube or if it’s on other things like Netflix Hulu etc. and if it’s only on YouTube how do I find the whole episodes because I’ve been very confused trying to figure it out for like months and just kinda gave up 😂

Maybe Twilight didn’t erase their memories she might’ve replaced the memory of Equestria with them being rescued

Maybe Twilight didn’t erase their memories she might’ve replaced the memory of Equestria with them being rescued

If sunset represent element of magic in the human world what does twilight represent in human world

If sunset represent element of magic in the human world what does twilight represent in human world

@Shadow Spectrum Swordtails (Triple S) True

@Shadow Spectrum Swordtails (Triple S) True

@Gorana Stupar cause her wings are disabled sadly

@Gorana Stupar cause her wings are disabled sadly

Of course you realize that the entire student body of Canterlot high already knew about the portal from the first time Twilight showed up. And let's not forget they all saw pieces of Equestria when Midnight Sparkle opened all those rifts. Trust me, a memory wipe wouldn't even be necessary because at this point it's pretty safe to say everyone on the boat already knew this stuff, and are more then willing Equestria a secret. It just makes.

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar I just watched the Pinkie video about her being psychic and it just connects with the theorie

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar I just watched the Pinkie video about her being psychic and it just connects with the theorie

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar there was a video that I haven't watched it yet. I think so about pinkie being  a psychic in something that I thought of will pinky being psychic is  what if  the two pinkies of the two worlds are able to communicate by mind that's probably the dumbest thing I've probably ever come up with but why not

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar let's hope Sawtooth Waves sees this and is like holy  crap I need to make a video cuz we needs answers

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar let's hope Sawtooth Waves sees this and is like holy  crap I need to make a video cuz we needs answers

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar Don't you think that maybe there was some connection with pinkie switching worlds and that episode it could also connect the Pinkie and the chaos magic theory

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar you at least gotta think about that one

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar you at least gotta think about that one

in my opinion the only strange thing about this theory is a blooper reel in Equestria girls there was a blooper reel showing pinkie well both pinkies switching worlds like it was just nothing so something didn't add up there it's either Twilight didn't know about that or maybe there's something else to it ?

Everone on the boat already knew about the other world so this wouldn't suprise anyone

Everone on the boat already knew about the other world so this wouldn't suprise anyone

Not what in the third Equestria Girls movie, Friendship Games, Midnight Sparkle opened portals in front of everyone and exclaimed that there is magic in that dimension?

I think that two Schools already know about the pony dimension

So did Human Lyra gain an obsession with Ponies from this event? to parallel the fanon of the Equine Lyra being obsessed with humans.

So did Human Lyra gain an obsession with Ponies from this event? to parallel the fanon of the Equine Lyra being obsessed with humans.

What if 3 icons in a cutie mark means sharing. Fluttershy shares kindness, rarity shares generosity through clothing, pinkie shares laughter, apple jack shares apples I guess. But ponies like rainbowdash don’t really share anything. Like rainbow doesn’t share speed and Twilight doesn’t really share magic, and Celestia doesn’t physically share the sun but I guess she shares the suns light. Like so sawtooth can see

Maybe she close the portal after they left and left it closed for sometime so that they would think that it was all a dream

Maybe she close the portal after they left and left it closed for sometime so that they would think that it was all a dream

If you think Sunset Shimmer had a big mistake, Did you know Cozy Glow also had a big mistake? It had to deal with the Tree of Harmony being active when all of the magic was being drained. maybe you can explain what went on there.

But think about this in the human world when side twigh ponies up she is allicorn right...?and in the pony world she is just a unicorn...?I just want ya to think about it also sunset in the song my past is not today she is a a sort of Phoenix allicorn but in the ponie world she is not and when they both turned evil they both had wings... am i getting somewhere...?

@The World Through My Eyes you didn't need to be rude about it.

@The World Through My Eyes you didn't need to be rude about it.

Why did the other twilight have wings in the human world but not in the other?

Why did the other twilight have wings in the human world but not in the other?

@Gorana Stupar I think its confirmed that her wings are stunned? Like a disablity, i saw a comment saying this on Instagram. its show Disablity rep?? i think.

@Herobrine is Gaming u can watch my channel if u want to

@Herobrine is Gaming u can watch my channel if u want to

Hopefully the sirens did not hear about this and I do not think that I have to explain y that would be a terrible idea

Hopefully the sirens did not hear about this and I do not think that I have to explain y that would be a terrible idea

@Amanda recent? Mlp is over that includes the eg’s

@Amanda recent? Mlp is over that includes the eg’s

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar <br>Ok it's 😎 with me

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar
Ok it's 😎 with me

The rescue choppers would look for the stranded passengers and if they did go through Equestria to Canterlot high, then the rescue mission would look for them around the island and maybe find the portal. Now the government would be involved.

@Raven <br>I love the pony and human version also the woman who voices Twilight also voices Raven

@Raven
I love the pony and human version also the woman who voices Twilight also voices Raven

@Raven <br>Hi I also do MLP tributes and comic dubs u can watch my channel if u want to

@Raven
Hi I also do MLP tributes and comic dubs u can watch my channel if u want to

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar <br>I also have an MLP channel u can watch my channel if u want to

@Angela Bonilla Menjivar
I also have an MLP channel u can watch my channel if u want to

I find it funny that you even have to make this comment at all. I guess quite a few people stopped watching EqG after a while. If you're one of those people, I'd at least recommend you watch Forgotten Friendship and Sunset's Backstage Pass. They're pretty good.

@The Fox Pack <br>Yeah what if Rainbowdash attacks Rainbowdash I also have an MLP channel u can watch it if you want to

@The Fox Pack
Yeah what if Rainbowdash attacks Rainbowdash I also have an MLP channel u can watch it if you want to

They know about the portal because they saw magic also in the first movie they hear the story about the portal and Luna and celesta said keep the magic in your would aka inplaing that they knew about the portal

@Miniş Dünyası That actually makes a lot of sense. Sunset is smart enough to not do that kind of mistake

@Miniş Dünyası That actually makes a lot of sense. Sunset is smart enough to not do that kind of mistake

Maybe Sunset didn’t actually make them go through the portal. Before the students are in human form you can that she’s thinking. Maybe she just imagined the last part instead of actually doing it. Maybe she thought of it then thought about the consequences so she didn’t actually do it. Instead just waited for help.<br>Sure this is more of an alternative ending. But I don’t think Sunset would actually do that kinda mistake

Maybe Sunset didn’t actually make them go through the portal. Before the students are in human form you can that she’s thinking. Maybe she just imagined the last part instead of actually doing it. Maybe she thought of it then thought about the consequences so she didn’t actually do it. Instead just waited for help.
Sure this is more of an alternative ending. But I don’t think Sunset would actually do that kinda mistake

Hi can you explain why doesn't Scootalloo fly🙂<br>PS.I love you💖

Hi can you explain why doesn't Scootalloo fly🙂
PS.I love you💖


Honestly, I'm pretty sure the existence of equestria is a VERY open secret around the school.

Yea cuz they seen incidents with this they literally have a pony (sunset shimmer) living amongst them I don’t think most people in canterlot high have thought about she being a pony

Looking at the first movie, she leaved via the portal while everyone is watching

Looking at the first movie, she leaved via the portal while everyone is watching

same, they openly talk about it and pony up in front of everyone

same, they openly talk about it and pony up in front of everyone

Honestly? I have to agree with the ones who points out friendship games. I'm sure even PONYVILLE knows about the human world. I mean in one of the portals, a unicorn? looks right at us, meaning she saw the portal and saw humans. Twilight and the others wouldn't just diss her claims at what she saw but maybe convinced her not to run rampant with the info because it's suppose to be a separate world.

Yes i also think the same, they all saw many battle, i think twilight would tell the importance of balance between worlds after the Equestria magic gone to the human world, they all could agree, and maybe the portals from the pony equestria world side could be watched, or at least a kinda of safe place where you can see what is happening in the portal room if someone transport through the portal, but also erasing the short memory could be the best

I think they know about it at this point since Twilight started destroying the human world they just don't know how to go to Equestria so it still was a mistake.

yeah in legend of everfree sunset told flash that twilight was busy in equestria

yeah in legend of everfree sunset told flash that twilight was busy in equestria

@killz0ne215 and in the first EG movie principal Celestia (to me that still sounds weird to say when I’m so used to using princess in front of her name anyway) said basically in front of everybody that twilight was from another world and said princess twilight

Yeah just not the fact of everyone know where the portals are

Yeah just not the fact of everyone know where the portals are

What I'm confused by is why human twilight has wings in the human world if she's a unicorn in equestria

But not twilights castle imagine if they all started to come during friendship misson

But not twilights castle imagine if they all started to come during friendship misson

@oOf to be honest I kinda want the series to go in a direction We're Both Worlds become United and you're able to visit from both worlds maybe not everyone but most people and ponies could visit each other's Worlds example I still want to see sunset shimmer Pony and human meeting like Twilight did and also that's a very good point could you work and sleep in different Worlds then just go through it all the time or would it have some sort of consequence.

@Alena Conrad to be honest I kinda want the series to go in a direction We're Both Worlds become United and you're able to visit from both worlds maybe not everyone but most people and ponies could visit each other's Worlds example I still want to see sunset shimmer Pony and human meeting like Twilight did and also that's a very good point could you work and sleep in different Worlds then just go through it all the time or would it have some sort of consequence.

@Lehla Quartz yeah I would believe that to be the case though come to think of it the only people who know of the portal on the side of pony land are the princesses their friends and family and the guards who guard both mirror portals in the pony land as far as I know also sunset shimmer at that too though I'm wondering how come we never saw the Equestria girls version of sunset if there is one in pony land than there has to be one in the human world? unless she died or is far away that is the only way I can think of us not seeing the human version of Sunset Shimmer

Yeah. I like to believe there are some people who occasionally switch places with their pony counterparts or meet up and chat a bit, other than Pinkie.

The thing was did you see the dekyes scene it explains that pinke pie had switched earlier somehow with the other notice and that how she had that hunch and a wink to the audience l

@French The Fennec Fox uh i believe its to power her portal in her place she would have to do something similar to the one in human world

Let’s see here they know that a girl from that world came to them they saw demon ss try to send them to the portal and they saw midnight sparkle rip holes to the world

@Kirk Lundberg until twighlight made a crazy contraption so that its active all the time

@J Blaine in equestria girls didn't they say it only activated for three days every 30 moons? In between wouldn't it just be normal?

@killz0ne215 wait what if the natural portal is like that one lake that multiplied pinkie pie like they're stuck in a different dimension

@Kevin Morris nope that amusement park is Equestria Land

@Kevin Morris nope that amusement park is Equestria Land

@Kevin Morris check carefully dude, I already gave the strongest evidence that the peeps didn't get their memories erased

Don't forget Fluttershy also knew about Equestria as well she mentioned about the trip through there in The Road Less Scheduled(Choose Your Ending Season 2)

@malowith <br>Yeah wouldn't they notice someone hopping through a piece of solid glass regularly??  😂

@malowith
Yeah wouldn't they notice someone hopping through a piece of solid glass regularly??  😂

I'm pretty sure it's also a very open secret around that world's equivalent of YouTube, TikTok and every social media platform.  Maybe not every teenager would share their experiences on online platforms, but the likelihood of absolutely zero of them doing so in any capacity is astronomically low.

Theirs a difference between knowing something and it being a good idea....agreed though that by now most of them know about equestria. It is a bit far fetched but plot convenience. Sure she's been living thier in human area (that probably has 911) but I can imagine her times as a pony made her more likely to do things on her own. Pretty sure this is a case of old habits die hard. (Her sense of adventure and not having 911 in equestria.) plus why wouldn't you use the magic way? It takes you right to the school! Instead of waiting stranded for hours. I mean thier teenagers so thier not thinking about the consequences it might have. I think the staff already established this not the basic au situation. I mean twilight saw herself on multiple occasions. Isn't that basic au number one big no no? <br>I just wish that celestia luna and cranky were thier. Can you imagine a principal and vice principle seeing that their pony counterparts are  rulers that's going to cause them to go into shock I bet. Or poor cranky seeing that of all things he's a donkey in this world! (Don't get me wrong donkeys are cute but not the best image in most media) That's even worse then spike being a dog or pufferfish.

Theirs a difference between knowing something and it being a good idea....agreed though that by now most of them know about equestria. It is a bit far fetched but plot convenience. Sure she's been living thier in human area (that probably has 911) but I can imagine her times as a pony made her more likely to do things on her own. Pretty sure this is a case of old habits die hard. (Her sense of adventure and not having 911 in equestria.) plus why wouldn't you use the magic way? It takes you right to the school! Instead of waiting stranded for hours. I mean thier teenagers so thier not thinking about the consequences it might have. I think the staff already established this not the basic au situation. I mean twilight saw herself on multiple occasions. Isn't that basic au number one big no no?
I just wish that celestia luna and cranky were thier. Can you imagine a principal and vice principle seeing that their pony counterparts are  rulers that's going to cause them to go into shock I bet. Or poor cranky seeing that of all things he's a donkey in this world! (Don't get me wrong donkeys are cute but not the best image in most media) That's even worse then spike being a dog or pufferfish.

@oOf and Lara, because the pony Version is obsessed with humans, the human Version would be obsessed with ponys and would probably already know legends of Equestria. Sunset' sudden appearance would support her theorys. She would have gone through, became friends with celestia and was like celestia's agent in the school.

So am I, tbh I was always under the impression that it would be cause for concern if you somehow didn’t know about that

True but if athorites did find out, whos to say there wont be a scp foundation type incodent?<br>So many people, ponies and portals will have to be contained. that could go very bad

True but if athorites did find out, whos to say there wont be a scp foundation type incodent?
So many people, ponies and portals will have to be contained. that could go very bad

I think not really, only Sunset and the main 6 seems to know that Twilight is a princess, the students of CHS dont even knew it has magic there. They do know that she isnt from this school, but dont know where she is from. In friendships some portals are opened but mostly of students was panickjng too much to analyzy that existed a pony world. But im pretty sure that Pinkie was already there, and maybe Bon Bon since she is a spy and she could be there to watch Sunset idk.

@Alena Conrad The Portal also be an escape route so if some shit happened in equestria the ponies of equestria can just go to the human world until it's safe again and the fact that I think every single person in cahnderlot now's about ponies they can help keep them safe from equestria, because alot of things happened on equestria and wouldn't it be cool if you can meet your pony self. I don't think the students of cahnderlot (sorry if I'm spelling this wrong) wouldn't mind because every single student have seen some werid shit form the main 7, but I think they should relocate the portal for twilight castle because it would get annoying if random people pop out of the portal, so I request them to either put it somewhere where nobody other than the citizens of equestria know about and somewhere it's kinda easy to access (sorry for my bad spelling english wasn't my first language)

Yep. Pretty sure they are aware of og twilight being a pony and the whole equestria magic bull shit going around there school. They’ve even seen twilight use the portal. Honestly surprised more haven’t tried. But like someone else said they probably still assume the portal is only activate on a rare occasion and not just on. But maybe the end result of all this is going full legend of Korra on this shit and travel between the two world eventually because common place. And you can choose between the two. Have relationship between the two worlds without consequence. Who to say two parallel people can’t interact. Twilight and twilight don’t have a problem so I don’t think there really a risk of reality collapsing. Just confusion between people and pony if they aren’t aware which one is who. Be interesting though. Wake up in the human world and then go to work in the pony one. 🤣

@J Blaine maybe it is dangerous maybe is it

@J Blaine maybe it is dangerous maybe is it

Yeah, I would be surprised if they DIDN’T know. Maybe they think it’s dangerous or needs to be activated though?

Well you're not wrong, Twi literally went inside the portal at the end of Equestria Girls in front of almost everybody

Well, the friendship games DID have holes between the dimensions in full view of everyone. They all saw it. The pony world is very well known at that school.

The only real question is, does everyone know about the portal to the land and where it's located. I would say, possibly to more probable.. But, the harder can of worms to hide would be Coast Guard investigation into the entire incident and HOW they got off the ship and HOW they mysteriously made it back home with out any outside rescue. I'm sure the authorities would be quite interested in this pony land. Assuming of coarse they weren't aware already. But, a uncontrolled portal to this land on a deserted island might be a great opportunity for some intelligence agencies to exploit.


Starlight: changes timeline
Sunshet: “hold my drink”

Starlight: *changes timeline*
Sunshet: “hold my drink”

@Raddled Fluffy But what if tanks in equestria world become Magic cannons?
But Ok, maybe you're all right. They wouldn't have any chance.
By the way It's not the human world that have the Princess of friendship. Even if she couldn't stop their intentions, she can turn them all to stone using friendship magic. Or let the Discord snap his fingers. 😅

@Haxior if the soldiers get in equestria  they will be nothing but naked Ponies unable to use their guns and weapons because all they have is hooves instead of Regular human hands

@Haxior HAVE YOU SEEN THE AMOUNT OF MAGIC AQUESTRIA HAS.NOTHING TWILIGHT,STARLIGHT AND DISCOARD CANT HANDEL,sorry idk how to spell

I think timeline is still worse (I am watching Dark already)<br>But Sunset fucked up too. What if human will start attack Equestria with Army, guns and Tanks? GG EZ

I think timeline is still worse (I am watching Dark already)
But Sunset fucked up too. What if human will start attack Equestria with Army, guns and Tanks? GG EZ


Just imagine being the rescue team arriving to find nobody

@Andrew Greeb And then they jump in to the portal...

All they find is the sand portal and a sunken boat

@Medicmist I feel bad for the emergency team

@Waffle Weirdo but then they find out they are back at their school like nothing happened

everyone would probably be reported dead

Rescue:we did this for nothing what a waste of time.....what a waste of air!


Wait til the Dazzlings hear there's an open portal RIGHT THERE

@Lucy Randomness its been a year, how do you feel about this 💀

@Quanashia B. YASSS ITS ME GO BUY MY PRODUCTS 😍💅🏽

Also one other thing,imagine your 70 in human world and go to ponny and live a longer life lmao

Cant they manually close and open it tho?Twilight and Celestia

I'm pretty sure it's locked for them since they were "banished"

@Filipino Jiafei 🇵🇭 EDIT YOUR REPLY NOW!!! I’M A CHILD!!!!

@Filipino Jiafei 🇵🇭 I’m a member of the Dazzlings (not really, if I was an mlp character)

@T3RR0R Not necessarily, it would more than likely BE there, but would be cracked where they could not use it as they had before.

but can they really go back to equestria when they're banished from there?

@Argamis (SilverComet) ok but isn’t the red gem apart of their siren forms anyway so it would just come back

@SBF / DarkSaviour remove or edit that before I report this

@Argamis (SilverComet) not my headcannon but ok

If they came out as ponies, it’d be chaotic to see sirens living in my house otherwise I’d go back to the human world and move in with them so I can be one of the Dazzlings. I’d miss out on Battle, Under our Spell, Welcome To The Show and Rainbooms Battle, and Find the Magic though, but maybe we can preform them, again!

Wow, imagine if they did! Imagine if I lived in ponyville as a pony, imagine if I saw them! New roomies, although I’d break their necklace and make tacos daily for Sonata, though, she is addicted!

@chokii ツ the blue girl in the Dazzlings is Sonata Dusk

@chokii ツ Yeah I did get that part about it. And by it I do mean the sirens

@chokii ツ I meant to type DrWolf. He's another YouTuber which is oc is literally a Bipedal wolf that can talk. And yes there is a backstory to his oc

@ChristinewhoYT I already noticed it was a fanart. And yes the next will be Generation 5. And I don't know who the heck is DrWorld. But my points still stands that The Sirens still can fly but can't do hypnotizing.

@chokii ツ And your comment is only 3 weeks old and I guess you might not watch DrWold in this case.

@chokii ツ actually this MLP Movie 2 turned out to be fake since the Next Mlp movie is the My little pony: A new generation

@abner ruan NOOOOOOOOOOO HAHHAHAHAHA THAT WOULD BE CURSED

omg in equestria the sirens amulets are part of their body,if they ever come back they will have a literal hole in their chests

@Argamis (SilverComet) (this is my opinion btw) I think the sirens still can fly but they cant use their "draining bad vibes" magic anymore. They still can sing  but it wont hypnotize everyone/pony as in the "Sunset's Backstage Pass" series. The Dazzlings are now a band. Also I don't know if this is true or not but there's a rumor spread saying there will be MLP Movie 2 and there's a leak of a scene in the movie. There's Sunset Shimmer, Starlight and the blue character in The Dazzlings right beside Sunset Shimmer. So I'm pretty sure it won't be pointless if they know there's a portal to Equestria right there. They still can just visit and do apologizing and friendship things I guess.

@Argamis (SilverComet)<br>thats a good statement👌

@Argamis (SilverComet)
thats a good statement👌

It would be POINTLESS.
-> Their superpowers (including the abiltiy to fly) depended on their red gemstones (that were shattered in "Rainbow Rocks" and now only work as weak light sources).

Since they are sirens, without magic they would barely be able to move around; likely having to remain swimming on the big pond in between Twilight´s Castle & the School of Friendship; or to venture into the Everfree Forest to reach the same river were Steven Magnet (the Sea Monster) was crying in the second episode [so they can eventually reach the ocean & be free].

Then what? (more than 1000 years had passed since Starswirl sent them to the human world, everyone they knew is likely dead by now).

In the human world they at least have their own vehicle, some electronic audio equipment & a plausible career as "professional singers".
Also  -> They have better chances at recognizing & controling "random magic" than most other people [without getting controled by it].


A lot of them already knew about the portal, as the first movie showed us Sunset shouting at Twilight about keeping the crown and never retuning home by destroying the portal.

My theory would be that after the humans returned home, only the Mane 7 were allowed through the portal. To other humans, they'd touch the portal entrance and just feel the stone.

@Anaïoa Yudoku ecstasy apart from the msne seven

@Koala From Tomorrow i know, but i said the students thought it was closed forever

@Anaïoa Yudoku No not for ever just for 30 days

Your theory about the portal entrance having an "invisible barrier" that non_magical humans & animals can not cross is CANON.
  At the begining of EQG3: "Friendship Games" Sci!Twi touches the portal with her left hand 3 times, but it is unable to cross it (it even flashes briefly in the place she press it, with a sound effect).
  -> This was before she made a device designed to attract & contain the specific energies her "electromagnetic reading device" detected in the area around the portal [the pendant that "steals magic" throughout the movie].

Even Sunset (who is a naturally born unicorn from Equestria, plus whatever amplification magic brought by her Empathy Geod) has to porpously "push" through the portal to be able to cross it.
-> By comparison, Princess Twilight Sparkle (The Alicorn) could place her (human) arm through it without any effort on the first EQG movie [it also instantly becomes a pony leg, confirming that the "species translator" is installed on the "side" of the CHS world, not Equestria or in_between].

@Anaïoa Yudoku they'd probably know that it was opened again because Twilight made it through the portal. Both in Rainbow Rocks and at the end of Friendship Games. Especially at the end of the latter as Sci Twi was legally ripping holes between dimensions.

And This makes sens because people could have gone through the portal by mistake

Yes, but the students though that the portal was closed forever since twilight is gone, pinkie pie tried following her but couldn't cuz the portal was closed. So the students didn't know that the portal was open again

@ILikeDinosaurs we see starlight go to the human world in one of the specials

Like by magic pony twilight cast or the magic that is generally in the human and pony world?
Also can starlight still travel in this theory?
And can the mane 6 From the pony world and the mane 7 from the human world both travel?
Can both the Spikes travel?


I just realized sci-twi  has glasses but twilight doesn't when everyone else is the same

@Limaic Ri because in the human world she used equestrian twilights magic, like the rest of them. But when she went to equestrian she didn’t

and it makes no sense that she gets wings when she pony-ups but isn’t an alicorn like pony twi

@Violet Kitbull that would be too dark tho, maybe we havent really discovered human sunset - maybe human sunset goes in another school like how sci twi was in an another school until she moved to canterlot high

@Abu Kamanda pretty sure sci twi ONLY got blended with pony magic in the human world unlike the other five who was meant to have the magic - since she only blended then her pony version will be from what shes just supposed to be , a unicorn

Probably an accident involving a laser light when she was young. Since I'm pretty sure cat laser lights don't exist in Equestria, so... yeah.

@Horseling S also we don't see the actual human world sunlight shimmer. The one we see got there from the pony world

@Limaic Ri I think it's because the girls draw their power from the pony-world versions of themselves. Pony Twilight is an alicorn, which is reflected by Sci-Twi's wings when she ponys up. However, Sci-Twi doesn't have that magic from the 3 tribes, so when she goes through the portal, she only had the horn but no wings.

@Limaic Ri I think it's because the girls draw their power from the pony-world versions of themselves. Pony Twilight is an *alicorn,* which is reflected by Sci-Twi's wings when she ponys up. However, Sci-Twi *doesn't* have that magic from the 3 tribes, so when she goes through the portal, she only had the horn but no wings.

@Jaiden YEAH!!!! THIS IS WHAT HASBRO WAS MADE FOR !!!!!!

@Jaiden YEAH!!!! THIS IS WHAT HASBRO WAS MADE FOR !!!!!!

Did anybody think about the geos when Sci Twi got her wings?

Did anybody think about the geos when Sci Twi got her wings?

It isn’t just plain old hasbro stuff. It is because of the geos.

It isn’t just plain old hasbro stuff. It is because of the geos.

well if we used that logic sunset would have wings too, they both have a horn in equestria BUT they only got wings in the human world which from what i think wouldnt give them wings in pony world!

wAiT nO aCtUaL pOnIeS hAvE gLaSsEs Do ThEy?

wAiT nO aCtUaL pOnIeS hAvE gLaSsEs Do ThEy?

Actually, sci twi had wings when they ponyd up

Actually, sci twi had wings when they ponyd up

I don't think they've discovered human starlight yet but if they haven't were the neck is she?

maybe she just likes wearing them and has gotten soo used to wearing them that it would take a few hours maybe days to return to her normal eyesight

@Neetu Gupta pony sunset could have killed human sunset, I wouldn't put it past her since at the time she was pure evil

Yeah and  they both looks different because of it everyone else are the same but there powers are not like pony pinkie don't have any magic and human pinkie have <br>Not just it  pony rarity have unicorn magic but she don't know shield spell and pony apple jack is strong like human A.J so these girls are same but pony flutter shy and human flutter shy are the same too pony rainbow dash has super speed in flying and human rainbow dash has super speed in running isn't it cool

Yeah and  they both looks different because of it everyone else are the same but there powers are not like pony pinkie don't have any magic and human pinkie have
Not just it  pony rarity have unicorn magic but she don't know shield spell and pony apple jack is strong like human A.J so these girls are same but pony flutter shy and human flutter shy are the same too pony rainbow dash has super speed in flying and human rainbow dash has super speed in running isn't it cool

I guess it's to distinguish between formal nerd (Sci-Twi) and just formal but lowkey nerdy (Twilight)

Actually it exists some changes in the coubterpart of each world, mostly because a event that occours in a world dont occour in another. Sci Twilight was probably affected by something when a kid and in the pony world that thing just dont exist or never happened. A example of that is howbSci Twi acts exactly as Season 1 and 2 Twilight, while pony Twilight dont act like that anymore because her friends helped her.

Or ponys dont need glasses (yes i know that existbponys qith glasses but if you look well mostly of them are just for fashion and they dont really need to use them for eyesight. I mean, Rarity uses her glasses while doing her designs but does she REALLY needs those?

Another option is that Twilight needs glasses but dont wear them or she "cured" it with her magic.

I mean, Sci Twi is show to be frequently in the dark, and somehow addicted to technology, would not be a surprise if she needed glasses

@Limaic Ri I think it’s because she has not earned them in the pony world.

@Limaic Ri I think it’s because she has not earned them in the pony world.

@Felisyen Feiderica I know the aria blaze thing was a joke. I realize know I should've made that clearer.

No I think maybe its showing what would happen to twilight if she didn't discover friendship  my proof is becuase when she went to pony twilight she didn't have wings becuase she didn't under stang friendship YET

@kando_ kreations Here is 4 opinions where the human Sunset Shimmer can be;
- Human Sunset lives in a whole other place in the human world
- Human Sunset accually met her countrepart and she moved to the magical world but not Equestria, somewhere else like the yack land , Seaquestria or the Equestrian countrepart to Africa  (where Zecora comes from )
- Human Sunset lived BEFORE pony Sunset because did you notice? Princesse Celestia and Luna are thousand old but the principals are not. If the two doesn't became alicorns, they will be already dead and their countreparts would live ages after them. It could be the same for human Sunset. Maybe she lived in Middle Age and her countrepart is born centuries later.
- Human Sunset doesn't exist because relations can be different in the alternate world. Like Sci Twi and Timber Sprouts's children won't have a countrepart because Princesse Twilight doesn't even know a pony Timber. Maybe in the human world, Sunset's parents never married and had childs. Same for human Starlight, Sunburst, Moondancer and a couple more characters

And she was a unicorn and not a alicorn.

And she was a unicorn and not a alicorn.

@Limaic Ri I think because the geodes hasa connection to their pony countrrparts. Like Rainbow Dash has super speed and pony Rainbow Dash is also very fast. Apple Jack has super strenght and pony AJ definitely show us her strenght in Shadow Play. Fluttershy can talk to animals and pony Fluttershy can comunicate too. Rarity has a crystal shield and Rarity revealed that she had this power all the time in the Endingof the end. Sci Twi has telekhinesi cus every unicorn has. Pinkie Pie can trow confetti pop and pony Pinkie Pie is able to take canons out of nowhere. Sunset Shimmer can read minds because maybe she can do mind reading spell in Equestria. I also notice that the geodes disapear when they go to Equestria. So the geodes has a connection to the ponies.

@DorianDaxivader I don't know about it. She doesn't have magic to do something like that and what gives her motivation to do that at the first place.

@Horseling S Did you see the real human Sunset? Pretty sure that they are at some corner of the human world.

@Limaic Ri That always kept me thinking.

@Limaic Ri That always kept me thinking.

@Felisyen Feiderica tell them it's dream, they teleported them and close the portal

@Limaic Ri that's because sci-twilight didn't EARN her wings . The wings that appear are just a replica of the real pony twilight, who ACTUALLY has wings

UMM remember there are other people on the ship that didn't know anything about equestria.well same as the other student but they still know that there a portal into another demension

@DorianDaxivader Aria Blaze is a completely different character who also originates from Equestria and is a siren. The primary possibility for Starlight is that she simply lives outside of town somewhere, I doubt she’d be running a whole village since she is technically around 17 based off of EQG, the next best thing would probably just be running a cult.

@Horseling S well she's probably still incharge of that village think about it sci-twi wanted nothing to do with friendship just like s1-3 twilight until sci-twi met the human mane 6.either that or she' s aria blaze.

Actually she does notice it. I noticed the black thingy and realised they were glasses

@Horseling S same place as Pony Cinch...

@Horseling S same place as Pony Cinch...

What about Starlight? The one we see is from the pony world. Where is the human world Starlight?

@Limaic Ri that is two-fold. And on a side-note, I disagree about Sci-Twi getting wings, but Hasbro is a toy company, so that’s how they will market it.
Back on topic...
One: Sci-Twi hasn’t earned Alicorn Status in accordance with the Magic of Equestria (because Celestia didn’t force the transformation, Twilight’s own Magic transformed her), thus in Equestria, she is a Unicorn like her counterpart was throughout S1-3.
Two: Because Pony Twilight IS an Alicorn and the Elements that allow Transformation since the Rainbow Powers, that carried over into Sci-Twi for the transformation only due to the Necklaces.

@Limaic Ri say it with me  ✨extremely  annoying bad animating idea ✨ also its hasbro their all about buying stuff

What about why does sci twi keep having wings when she powers up but when she is in her pony form, she doesn't?

Because Sci-Twi didn’t have Magic to prevent eyesight damage. That’s what happened to me, only I watched tv instead of reading books.


Human Lyra will definitely be obsessed with the idea of being a pony just like pony Lyra who is obsessed with the idea of being a human (I know that's technically a fan theory but it is still interesting nonetheless)

Omg yes!! Also human lyra sounds a lot like me lol

𝐀𝐝𝐨𝐫𝐞𝐬𝐄𝐥𝐢𝐳𝐚 🤍🎄

Human Lyra: Help! A horse is booping me!
Pony Lyra: I am a Unicorn Pony!

H Lyra: Horse!
P Lyra: Pony!
Twilight: Lyra you got to stop doing this

Both lyras: It wasnt me!

@Jan Nowak so Human Lyra is a horse girl?

Human Lyra officially has obsession with horses.
But creators don't tell Lyra want be pony.
Maybe she is jokey.


I think twilight closed the portal permanently after sending everyone back. This would explain why we haven't seen any interaction between the human and the pony world after this.

Maybe not permanent, but probably back to the moon cycle it used to work with


Okay so having some multiversal interactions in the past that literally EVERYONE witnessed doesn't seem like it's that big of a secret. Having seen Twilight and others go through that portal like thousands of times the fact that a portal to another universe somehow connected with the one they're living in would most likely be public knowledge by the end of the firs MLP EG movie. The reason why nobody is going through it will most likely be that they just don't feel like it. They life is based on their universe so why would they go on another universe they don't know how to survive in. Think Sunset for example she can go back in equestria at anytime but doesn't bcz she has already set a life in the human universe.


The simple solution is a memory spell, that being said, all these students, 've already been through Equestria Girls, Rainbow Rocks, Friendship Games, and I'm not sure if this is after Legend of Everfree and the Memory Stone incident, although going by the commentary, Sawtooth said the memory stone was already destroyed at this point.  You would think that after all that magical stuff going on, word might have gotten out already?

Crystal Prep's entire student Body has not yet blabbed about it, otherwise, the entire population of Canterlot High would have been under investigation.  So it's a good bet that the students are pretty good at keeping it a secret, so sending them back through the portal is not out of the question.  As for explaining them being ponies and that their first twilight is the alicorn pony telling them to go through this mirror in her basement?  That's going to be a bit of a headache.

The next thing is explaining how they were all suddenly safe and sound at the school instead of miles out to sea.

But then all the ship's crew how do you explain that without memory spells?

Also imagine the reports Alicorn twilight and Sunset are going to have to give to their respective Celestia's and Luna's?

@Syke Unsent ok but they did play a major role like actually saving rainbow Dash from that plant thingy and everyone else from the sinking ship

@Neetu Gupta I honestly, couldn't remember if they had their geodes in this story or not.

See this is after legend of everfree as they had their geods


Sunset seemed more motivated by her homesickness (which I think she might be in denial about) than logic of any kind


Sunset has a perfectly good reason for wanting to evacuate the island through Equestria: they don't seem to have gotten any food off the ship before it sank. Given their isolation, they might not have enough food and fresh water to last until a rescue even if one has already been called for- and that's not guaranteed. Considering the ship's lack of backups and failsafes and conduct of the crew (flirting with underage passengers, pressing underage passengers into service to make emergency repairs on the engine, stuff like that), there's no way that would be a legal operation in real life and I suspect it's not in EG world either. I suspect they didn't make a distress call because they didn't want the authorities involved (hell, the weird lifeboats with motors but no radios if anything suggest that this ship might be involved in piracy or smuggling), and the ship's loss of power might have prevented them from doing so anyway. This would also explain the crew being willing to go along with it, as it would be a way for them to get off the island alive without going to prison.

Theoretically, anyone on board with a satellite phone could make the call themselves- except even mundane storms can block satellite transmissions. A magic one might be even worse. This does require an explanation for how Twilight and her friends were able to make calls, but that's easy enough. They only seem to be able to call each other, which suggests whatever they're doing isn't normal cell network calls. If anyone would have a custom-built phone with a much more powerful transmitter than a normal one, it's Twilight, and with all the superhero stuff they do, having phones that can contact each other directly without going through an external relay would actually be very useful, so I can easily see her giving her friends similar phones. And it's not exactly an unreasonable level of preparation if they get into a situation that uses it.


Can we appreciate how sawtooth is still making videos despite the show is officially over?


Well, it seems that specific portals to other worlds have specific destination on the other world.

Therefore: could Twilight manage to deactivate her ` `Artificial` ` portal, so that the portal located at Canterlot High would be deactivated as well??

In turn, as the CHS portal would essentially be disabled, No human could enter Equestria
However, Sunset Shimmer would have to find an alternative route to Equestria which would be discreet.

Pretty sure equestrian twilight made the portal able to work all the time rather than the moon cycles it normally works, so short of breaking it the portal will still work for the moon cycles


Sunset Shimmer is a really good character for me. She never let her past hold her back but she acknowledges that she made mistakes. I still love even though she makes mistakes 😉

@DorianDaxivader I also think the magical means for Sunset's Reformation might play a part. Sunset was kinda blasted good. We don't know what the rainbow power did to her.

Starlight had a classic reformation, turned her self around on her own, but I think that it may be why it took longer to iron out her evil tendencies.

Yeah I really like and love sunshet shimmer she is the main character ♥ she should be an alicorn princess 👸

@Applesauce Lord They Are And All Because Writter Wanna Humane 6 Looks Good And Fans Love Them

@Sparkle Time | Lego Review | Other Stuff ik it’s always weird they are trying to villify sunset which we all know is stupid ,evident in sunsets backstage pass when all the pinkie fans started crying out loud, and peeps like smurfvlogs clearly dun understand wtf is going on , and forcing sunset to awknoledge that she is on the wrong , which in reality should be where pinkie is I honestly can’t think of any ep where pinkie has to actually learn anything <br>As for the sunset and pinkie thing I wouldn’t actually call it “simping for pinkie” after thinking about it but sunset being forced to yk be with pinkie is the writers fault they have done some pretty stupid things after all.

@Sparkle Time | Lego Review | Other Stuff ik it’s always weird they are trying to villify sunset which we all know is stupid ,evident in sunsets backstage pass when all the pinkie fans started crying out loud, and peeps like smurfvlogs clearly dun understand wtf is going on , and forcing sunset to awknoledge that she is on the wrong , which in reality should be where pinkie is I honestly can’t think of any ep where pinkie has to actually learn anything
As for the sunset and pinkie thing I wouldn’t actually call it “simping for pinkie” after thinking about it but sunset being forced to yk be with pinkie is the writers fault they have done some pretty stupid things after all.

@SomeoneElse Is Here sunset has been pissed multiple times but the ones where she got rlly angry was in sunset’s backstage, forgotten friendship and roller coaster of friendship when she and twi couldn’t win a carnival game were the big ones , there were small little scene here her anger still stayed the same there are just too many to list

@Violet Regnier There's actually a video on it

@Violet Regnier I still disagree I don't think Sunset is one-sided at all. Just like Applejack isn't honest all the time and Fluttershy isn't shy all the time. Sunset isn't angry all the time. Plus she's had more than 3 bursts of anger

@SomeoneElse Is Here you also can't be one thing all the time apple jack isn't always honest and fluttershy isn't always shy sunset has only had three burst of anger she's very one sided

@SomeoneElse Is Here have seen the time loop special they were looking at each other like this 😍😍

@Violet Regnier  Sorry I disagree. When she reformed her personality didn't leave, she didn't just become a boring goody two shoes imo. And simping for Pinkie Pie?? Yeah, I don't think so. I think she's still sassy and she clearly still has anger issues. And I am confused on how the reason the original comment likes Sunset is the same reason you dislike her. It doesn't make sense to me because it seems like you think Sunset not having a bit of evil in her is a bad thing while I see that as a good thing, but to each their own

@Applesauce Lord  And That Why Sunset Is The Best One, Not Olny Sunset Backstage Pass Try Make Everyone Feel Bad For Pinkie And Rest Special Try Make Humane 6 Looks Good,  In Forgotten Friendship They Try Make Sunset Looks Bad For Mean At Trixie And Wallflower And In The Final Battle Is Just Try Make Humane 6 Beng Good While Sunset Being Nothing But Kinda There, In Rollercoaster Of Friendship They Try Make Sunset A Joke Character And Rarity And Applejack Looks Like A Good Character, In Spring Breakdown They Try Make Everybody Sympatize With Rainbow And Make Sunset Being Bad Person In Ending Scene.

@Violet Regnier well ig u can look at it that way , tho I just feel like starlight should know better when it comes to making rlly bad mistakes, like I said some of starlight’s mistakes don’t let her learn anything but ok I can see ur point in starlight trying to control herself she dies show some effort (like in a bottle of emotions trying to hold her frustration until it rlly can’t be held in ) tho some of the things she does still bothered me when I rewatch certain episodes like how she reacted there is no slight in change in her response when things don’t go her way ( ofc that’s just me) in instance liek blasting discord just over his mockery to selling her friends house so long after her reformation , sure sunset has done things similar to her but the scale of her actions is almost inocuous compared to some to starlight’s even if she didn’t have  magic she probably would have gotten some one hurt,so that’s my view and opinion (so pls not argueing just saying what I think)on starlight’s character in the topic of making mistakes and actually learning from them. I think it’s hard for me to relate to starlight often for this one.

@Applesauce Lord starlight to me is like fluttershy she has a ton of progress but it's hard to see starlight trys the best to control her magic and emotions but that physically drains her it's like when discord stop being himself he started to fade away if starlight was fully good she'd become a background pony her magic is the only way to fix her issues because magic broke off her only friendship she went off the rails so it's no wonder she uses her magic so much from a physiological stand point

@Violet Regnier that is pretty much the writers fault I wasn’t enjoying sunsets backstage pass becuz they always make everyone feel bad for pinkie which was annoying so I agree with You about the simping part , and at least sunset retained some of her anger issues it shows she hasn’t really changed too much to affect her personality, by season 8 I just feeel like the writers are just biased more towards starlight which I had disliked(and one of the reasons why I get annoyed by the show) but I can see why u said it was taking her personality away that was a problem. Tbh it’s just better that sunset start didn’t start out as a villain she was pretty underwhelming no one can disagree with that. Even with probably the best reformation in the franchise her “evil personality” that almost fully evaporated almost instantly is still one of the minor problems with her ( for starlight it’s the total opposite), it is still there she has her flaws but sunset has other enjoyable elements to her as well not just her old mean self but also her being nice ( like what she was doing in rainbow rocks ) etc. Sunset still has as much development as discord and the cmc and more so than starlight but that’s just my opinion. Just becuz starlight makes mistakes doesn’t mean her arc is automatically better , I mean starlight made mistakes that are rlly fucking stupid like selling Trixie wagon house and age regressing sunburst these mistakes don’t let her learn anything that’s relevant to the main theme of the ep. In contrast sunset actually makes mistakes idk y you called her goody to shoes , while I don’t like sunsets backstage pass at least sunset learnt a lesson of controlling anger when a friend messes things up( tho it may not be the lesson that should be there) at least it’s still something most of her lessons are meaningful in a way I’m not saying starlight hasn’t had any of these lessons but she has made way worse mistakes than sunset did and some ppl are just biased for starlight. So no sunset isn’t completely a goody to shoes and when compared to starlight she also learns probably about as much as starlight does ,sunset is still learning too she isn’t a Mary Sue hell some starlight had more potential to than sunset.

I also love Sunset even though she was bad at the beginning

@Violet Regnier I guess you have a point there her reformation did go a little bit too fast.(I know this is gonna sound stupid but what does dumping mean?😅)

@DorianDaxivader yeah but when they took the evil they also took her personality away she was more sarcastic and sassy now she's just a goody to shoes gamer who's simping for pinkie

@Violet Regnier yes I agree with you but they don't have the same story I mean look at how long sunset has been reformed and how long starlight has been reformed sunset has been reformed for longer right? So clearly she would not make that many mistakes since she knows more about friendship than starlight.

But that's why i don't like her . starlight and sunset have the same kind of  story but sunset doesn't have a tint  of  evil she has yelled at people being good but that was like once or twice starlight is crazy  she uses her magic all the time and she isn't a goody  to  shoes   she's  still learning


I'm pretty sure everyone at the school would know about the school portal by now. Also, don't forget that it can be turned on and off via the machine attached to it in the pony world.

The portal I would be worried about in this case would be the island portal.  No one bothered to attach an on/off switch to that and it would have been likely that the rescue team would have found it when they went to find the passengers on the island.  Who knows what would have happened after that.


the fact that they went to pony world Is something I have been craving for since I was 7 and I'm 13


The actual danger: The milltary from Sunset's side invades Equestria.

@LG_hatake I was just about to comment about this.

An anime called GATE has a similar plot to this

well they can actıally destroy the tanks, humwees, even some rockets maybe and attach them later then. but I think if the military found out about it. it would not end well. for eatier side.

@Argamis (SilverComet) I didn't read all of its but that's is good point

HOW? (exactly)
If trained soldiers go through the portal, they will emerge in Equestria as naked ponies, unable to use their weapons efectively [with some luck their military bulletproof clothes MAY be "translated" into some kind of armor, but firearms would not become "precharged magic wands"].

The "portal" itself is limited to the shape & size of the mirror in Twilight´s Castle (the "stone portal" in the cave at "South Everfree Forest" has about the same height but it is at least as wider); this makes impossible to send most vehicles [no tanks or fighter jets, that could not be piloted without hands anyways...]
-> Sending autonomous drones would be a bad idea [there is no way to know how tech & A.I. may interact with the ambient magic], plus without a GPS satellite constellation in place (or even maps), those would had to be remote_controlled locally anyways (again, without hands).

In the Season 8 finale we could see how the army of Canterlot would act against an enemy that lacks access to any magic spells [they also did not had magic, but reasoned that nopony else did it either].
With the help of magic on their side, everything could end quickly (by force) in a matter of hours after the "invasion" was discovered.
-> The only useful thing "The Military" can do is try to steal magical artifacts without anypony noticing it (like how it happened with the Time Twirler in "Sunset´s Backstage Pass", that is still a mystery).


Perhaps everything is different here: Celestia then thought that this mirror would cause the same side effects as the mirror leading to Mirror Equestria.
There, because of the actions of the evil Celestia, the two universes almost joined, but this mirror leads to another dimension of one universe and it has a limitation, both transforms you and deprives you of most of your powers (there were no such restrictions when the 1st generation arrived to the 4th generation).

And by the way, if there was some kind of balance, then Sunset, being present in one of the human worlds, would have already destroyed everything, I'm not talking about Sirens and Twilight with Spike. So what: either Celestia misunderstood everything or she didn't finish.

And as for the students, they would not have told anyone, because no one would have believed them. Now massively people say that they have seen aliens, ships and life after death, but they believed someone- no. So here it is the same, and even their memory does not need to be erased, they already consider it an ordinary Tuesday.


I thought everyone already knew about the portal at Canterlot High. They just chose not to go through because they were forbidden and no one knew until then that there were more portals than that one. Which always made me wonder why Principal Celestia and Twilight didn't think to put up some kind of perimeter to keep them from going through whenever


The show: We just wanna make it funny Imao <br>Sawtooth Waves: Let's analyse!

The show: We just wanna make it funny Imao
Sawtooth Waves: Let's analyse!


3:54 this is the exact logic Twilight or Starlight would use at the beginning of an episode resulting in everything going wrong


The situation you mentioned about still having communications via cell phones would be a huge tip off that something's wrong, and even if Pony!Twi managed to erase everyone's memories, there'd still be the issue of the rescue teams showing up to the spot where all of the distress signals were coming from, and everyone is just... ...gone.

Only to be found however many miles inland Canterlot is from the downed ship, and the entire roster of passengers there all of a sudden. That's gonna bring up a LOT of questions, and if everyone that went through Equestria got their memory of the place zapped, there's gonna be a lot of investigating going on.

Sunset opened up a much bigger can of worms that just a bunch of human students getting a short tour of Equestria. Also, extremely high chance of Lyra shenanigans in this scenario.


I can totally imagine pony Lyra somehow slipping through the portal, and going nuts when she found out humans really do exist. Makes you wonder if there is some portal at your school that leads to a pony world in real life.

@luv.sofiiiia—! Another thing to think about! What if the portal leads to an alternate universe of the world we already live in? BUT the world is so similar to ours that you would never notice. Maybe it's already happened

ur gonna make me look stupid running into every single wall thinking its a magic portal to another universe

I think that will never happen i only know if you make you're own pony and make stories that's the only way

It just occurred to me that human Lyra is probably a horse girl.

Imagine a different universe where instead of ponies we were a horde of spider demons living in an apocalyptic aftermath version of civilization-

@alaria smiss I must admit this is just crazy yet I think lets start to say like to are viewers as pinkie and discord. This will give them a prespective on us being magical.

@ChristinewhoYT I mean it is totally possible. Like sawtooth's video on Starlight Glimmer's Multiverse in the MLP universe, why could that be real in our universe through a portal of our own? In some MLP AU, there is My little Human and we are the cartoons ponies watch.


The portal's not open 24/7 anymore.  It has to be opened by the book.  So Sunset just contacts her when she needs to pass through.


The solution is easy, twilight must deactivate the mirror portal and only reactivate it when she means to use it. This would only hamper sunset shimmer coming to the pony world but she could always use her magic journal to message twilight to turn on the portal.


Respectfully, I think you actually tap on non-memory-wipe the solution a bit. As you point out, most everyone would likely want to test out the portal the next day thinking it was a dream. But, unlike the natural portal which they likely don't have the funds to reach to test out given it's obscure location, the mirror portal is not active 24/7. Instead, it's only active while Twilight has her copy of the journal attached to it. Meaning once Twilight gets everyone though the portal, she simply has to remove the journal for a few weeks. Even if others go up to the portal to test it out, as long as they don't get stupidly lucky to test it during the three days every thirty moons, all their going to find is cold stone. It'll quickly get written off by most as panic-induced mass hysteria and those few that continue to hold out a belief in a magical pony land through the base of the statue (*Cough*Lyra*Cough) while quickly just get blown off as conspiracy theorists.


This is something that immediately jumped to my mind the moment I saw that scene.  And it's even worse that it wasn't just the students of Canterlot High, who have already shown that they can keep magic a secret (already a big ask for a few hundred teenagers), but the crew of the ship and other unrelated passengers.  And I came to the same conclusion you did.  Twilight absolutely would have had to use mind magic on everyone, probably rolling back to even before the shipwreck (to keep the human seven's magic a secret).  If not she'd have to close the portal and only open it when she needed it.  That's something she can do, she's already overriding the mirror to keep the portal open longer than it should be.  But that wouldn't solve the sand portal problem.  The island isn't exactly hard to find, it's right next to the wreck of a big cruse-liner.  Human governments would definitely want to investigate that.  I suppose it's possible that Twilight and/or one or more of the other alicorns closed that portal once they were aware of it.  But it's still a problem.  Once Sunset made that crazy decision, mind magic was the only solution other than cutting all contact.  And even that latter option would end up with the human seven in a lab somewhere.


Hey wait. The students already saw Equestria when Midnight Sparkle ripped a hole in the dimensions. Wouldn't they already know it was there? Just a question. Love your videos!

Yes but the don't know how to get there and probably forgot <br>They might still remember that they had a tie with cp(crystal prep)

Yes but the don't know how to get there and probably forgot
They might still remember that they had a tie with cp(crystal prep)

@Ayasha Putri Nugroho Except, didn't they actually <i>see</i> Twilight go back through the portal at the end of the first movie?

@Ayasha Putri Nugroho Except, didn't they actually _see_ Twilight go back through the portal at the end of the first movie?

I swear, if Midnight knew about the many MANY portals, that would be INCREDIBLY DANGEROUS!! We don't want Midnight Sparkle coming back and running around Equestria! And in Legend of Everfree, my mom made it PRETTY CLEAR that she doesn't like Midnight Sparkle, mostly because she's a demon, and demons are freaky and scary XD

to be honest I kinda want the series to go in a direction We're Both Worlds become United and you're able to visit from both worlds maybe not everyone but most people and ponies could visit each other's Worlds example I still want to see sunset shimmer Pony and human meeting like Twilight did.

Wich makes me wonder if anypony saw the big portal to another dimension in the sky that day..

@𓂀•𝕆𝕦𝕥𝕔𝕒𝕤𝕥•𓂀 XD

@𓂀•𝕆𝕦𝕥𝕔𝕒𝕤𝕥•𓂀 XD

yes, but they don't know about the portal

They would know it’s there I think what the fear is that they don’t know how to get there and that there’s a portal right outside there school.


Yeah, this is absolutely something Sunset would do.  She never rules out high-risk plans, trusting in her own abilities to navigate to good outcomes.  She's smart, but she doesn't think things through too hard if she believes in what she's doing.  Sparing her schoolmates from the rigors of a real-life sea rescue would count as a noble goal in need of doing.  She's a play-by-ear, keep-on-hooftips kinda mare.


I also questioned that.
However, I have my own personal headcanon on it (i know there are still holes, but I'll deal with them later):
Sunset only brought the Humane 6 and a couple of CHS students into the sand-portal, so they could go to the mirror-portal and call for rescue for the other passengers. Only CHS (and Crystal Prep) students know much about Equestria and the portal. And it could explain why we only saw a few students like Flash, Bulk, Derpy & Lyra in the end scene, and not any of the EQG-only characters.


i loved the flower in your hair sawtooth, and to answer your question from the end of the video, i would have went with the first option since i would be able to keep my conscience clear of all their memories staying intact and no possibility of some people accidentally staying behind in Equestria.


I totally agree with you of the whole memory erasing I'm pretty sure there's an easy spell for it but what happens if someone tries to go through it someone who didn't know what it was but was curious what it was. How about instead memory erasing one thing spell it was a continuous spell a spell that twilight casted that on all the pones so that if any of them came through they would not remember anything until they went back


Memories. What a strange and fragile thing that we place so much faith in. Wouldn't it be terrible if they were quite malleable?

There's one little detail that Sawtooth doesn't consider; if they could cast a spell that could take away memories, couldn't they make a spell to add in others? The collective memory gap could be pasted over with some convincing and mundane explanation, like "shortly after, a rescue boat came and picked us up." As long as it isn't too unreasonable, it probably wouldn't be questioned too much.

Those students went through a lot that day. One could expect them to miss a few detail on the ride home. Which they definitely did, after all. Anything else would be crazy.


In her defense, she was having a pretty rough day and had to think fast to save her friends. Twilight having to clean up after her was not the largest of her problems.


My counter-arguments:
1: The students already know about Equestria, including having seen it in Friendship Games.
2: They already know that the statue is a portal, given the events of the first movie, where Sunset threatened to smash it, and watching Twilight go back through it.
3: Sunset probably already knew and warned them of the gravity of the situation, being on the other side, since she had the good sense to keep Twi and RD hidden the first time around, even if that probably wasn't an option with a much larger group.
4: We've seen pretty consistently that, in this world, adults are useless. Sometimes less than useless. In other specials we see the group being the ones stopping a bank heist, and solving the mystery of movie production sabotage. A group of 17-18 y/o girls have proven more capable than "trained" law-enforcement, and adults in general.

My counter-arguments:
1: The students already know about Equestria, including having seen it in Friendship Games.
2: They already know that the statue is a portal, given the events of _the first movie,_ where Sunset threatened to smash it, and watching Twilight go back through it.
3: Sunset probably already knew and warned them of the gravity of the situation, being on the other side, since she had the good sense to keep Twi and RD hidden the first time around, even if that probably wasn't an option with a much larger group.
4: We've seen pretty consistently that, in this world, adults are useless. Sometimes _less_ than useless. In other specials we see the group being the ones stopping a bank heist, and solving the mystery of movie production sabotage. A group of 17-18 y/o girls have proven more capable than "trained" law-enforcement, and adults in general.


Yeah, memory spell is most likely. Erase the minds of all of the Students except for the Humane 7.<br>Although it's likely the portal is closed most of the time as we only see Sunset crossing over when she gives Twilight a heads up of when she's coming. So even if there was no memory erasure, the statue would still be a statue, until the portal is open again either via book or the next 30 moon cycle

Yeah, memory spell is most likely. Erase the minds of all of the Students except for the Humane 7.
Although it's likely the portal is closed most of the time as we only see Sunset crossing over when she gives Twilight a heads up of when she's coming. So even if there was no memory erasure, the statue would still be a statue, until the portal is open again either via book or the next 30 moon cycle


I agree. The school portal was already an open secret.<br>Everybody saw Princess Twilight go back through the portal. They saw the Humane 6 using magic in the fight against the Dazzlings and ponying up repeatedly in Friendship Games, not to mention seeing the pony world through the many rifts torn open by SciTwi.

I agree. The school portal was already an open secret.
Everybody saw Princess Twilight go back through the portal. They saw the Humane 6 using magic in the fight against the Dazzlings and ponying up repeatedly in Friendship Games, not to mention seeing the pony world through the many rifts torn open by SciTwi.


The entire school already kind of knows and I honestly wouldn’t be surprised if Celestia made a deal with the government at one of the points at which the portal was open that ponies wouldn’t go through it as long as humans didn’t come through either (or just not to try and have a war with each other) and would only come through if either one of the worlds was in danger. Let’s be totally honest, before this there was the time everyone from an entire carnival disappeared then that time at the mall, a movie set, not to mention the giant rainbow beam the dazzlings saw. I mean come on I think a giant rainbow beam would be a very dead giveaway and yet it’s already happened before multiple times before and not even a single government agent has shown up. The only reason Celestia had only twilight go through and not the others was because she and the government are still in contact and they told her there is no other “Twilight sparkle” at the school once Celestia sent them a message about the crown. But they said the other main 6 were there and if would probably be best if only twilight came through cause it would be kinda hard to keep the other 5 of the main six from being very obviously not from here. twilight nearly gave it away before she even revealed it to the human main 6. And after the whole thing they let Sunset stay since she would probably stay in the world indefinitely and be able to stop the magic objects that could easily be used for evil for falling into bad hands. Besides Celestia probably also had to tell the government how the human world has been their magic trash can for the last few eons.


Just a thought; doesn't the portal stay open through the magic in that book (the whole sequence we saw in Rainbow Rocks)? What if Twilight removed that book unless it was necessary for someone to go through? She'd still be able to communicate with Sunset through one of her other books, and when the students can't access the portal, they might think it really was just a dream.<br>Idk, just thought that might be another option for Twilight to take.

Just a thought; doesn't the portal stay open through the magic in that book (the whole sequence we saw in Rainbow Rocks)? What if Twilight removed that book unless it was necessary for someone to go through? She'd still be able to communicate with Sunset through one of her other books, and when the students can't access the portal, they might think it really was just a dream.
Idk, just thought that might be another option for Twilight to take.


I just realized that humans are probably myths to them like unicorns, alicorns and Pegasus (Pegasi?) are to us

No they are not cause if we went through the portal to their world we would have recognized us as a pony rather than thinking what are we but twilight thought what is she and knew nothing about them.


I admire Sunset.She changed,for the better,and,as you said before,shes probably replacing the element of magic in the human world instead of Twilight.

Her element is redemption, this is on the wiki.

Swi twi replaced twilight levation is more magical that reading people's minds if anything I believe that sunset is the element of forgiveness

@Autum Breeze It's still magic, Sunset's element is forgiveness

I personally think that Sunset’s element is forgiveness based on her empathy geode powers.

Though, that begs the question what Sci-Twi's element is 🤔


Wait, I just noticed that when Twilight went back to equestria after defeating Sunset  most if not all of the students were there to watch her go. They must have remembered where the portal is right. So this may be not as big disaster as we think cause it would only make some people know about the portal still they will have a brief look how the world works and if they like it they would want to live there. And maybe even try crazy things to do it.


Well, pretty much everyone at CHS already knows about magic and Equestria and everything. I think there's an unspoken agreement to keep silent about everything, at least out of gratitude. But yeah, Sunset made an oopsie.


"Throwing off the balance between the worlds"
So celestia tryin to tell us, if everybody in the HUMAN world goes to the PONY world. The worlds will be imbalanced and therefore there would be no portals and everybody from the human world have to stay in the pony world.

This is a crazy theory but hey, it's just my opinion.

I think what she ment was if there is a counter part for everyone or ever creature. There would 2 of them in whatever world they entered.  So say Discords counter part entered Equestria. That would be a problem big time. This makes me wonder though. Changelings, the Sea ponies, and the countless other species of Equestria and further out. Who are they in the Human world. I have seen people speculate Discords counter part is the head of schooling in the area but the others... like Queen Chrysalis and other rare sights. I love these mind games. That make a person imagine just the craziest things. To think someone in the Equestria Girls is a Queen of the Changelings in  Equestria. I could see her being a person studying insects or something along that line.

Maybe she just doesn't want an immigrant crisis


So I was rewatching mlp and got me thinking that the dark magic stygian found was a more powerful version of nightmare moon. Because each had strong negative emotions and  then transformed into into a shadow of themselves. And stygian said in his dark moments the darkness came to him. So did the darkness came to Luna in her dark moments. The both where covered  in mist like magic when they transform and bother have a mist form. Maybe even king sombra because he had some of the same magic. And the difference between them is there wants desires, and their own magic. Like the nightmare in the comic in nightmare Rarity. Idk would like to hear you opinions. There where many similarities in thier dark forms.  Again this just a thought but if you want you can elaborate on this thought.


Sunset likes to escalate the stakes as problem solving. This is part of her charm.

As for how I would have solved it: The portal is only open aside from all 30 moons due to Twilights machinery on the mirror. She could send them back to Canterlot High and disconnect the machines. Everyone would check it out tomorrow and the statue would just be a statue. Thus, people would think it were a dream and don't bother anymore. Sunset could just journal Twilight a message, if they need the portal again.


In my opinion one of your final theories has a big problem, if Twilight sends them through the castle's portal and erases their memories, what would the rescue team, that inevitably has been sent to the island do? And what if the authorities find out about a massive group of people disappearing and suddenly reappearing in front of the school, they would investigate it and after the events of Friendship games it has to be common knowledge that there is such a thing as magic and even if the authorities don't consider it someone will, as Sci-Twi once did, and find the portal.


I believe Twilight might of input a memory of them being saved, so there wouldn't be any mystery


I was mind blown when I saw this scene, but this, this blew my mind even more.


One issue I'm finding is that... Twilight was seen by the whole school in the first movie going through the portal.


sunset shimmer probably has the best story and arc in the show

Starlight is my favorite character I love her.


But the Canterlot high portal only works at certain times (full moon and when Twi turns it on). Twighlight could of said that SHE activated it and set them back. The statue would only work on the off chance that someone went back at the right time. Pluss she doesn't have to tell them that it is the statue, making everyone think that they just "teleported" to that spot. Love your videos


Sunset : hihihi .....i think this is the only way back to school.<br>Twilight: ARE YOU CRAZY?

Sunset : hihihi .....i think this is the only way back to school.
Twilight: ARE YOU CRAZY?


I find it hard to believe the portal was a secret before Spring Breakdown. It's not exactly hidden from view; surely somebody outside of the main characters has seen the portal being used at some point, and everybody at Canterlot High has seen crazier things than girls walking through statues.

I assume that Twilight generally turns the portal off when it's not in use, but even so it seems nigh-miraculous that no adventurous teen has yet managed to slip through uninvited.


If I understood the episode correctly, then the portal in the cave was caused by the Storm King's magic, and should have disappeared when that magic was absorbed by the staff, and the staff was then returned to Equestria. As for the other portal with the mirror in Twilight's castle the easiest thing for her to do would be to take the mechanism that powered it with the book off line, returning the mirror to it's natural three day open period that only happened every twenty moons when certain stars aligned. Another possibility, though it isn't discussed in the series, but which has been used in other, non pony, tales about magic mirrors is the possibility that dismantling, or even breaking, the mirror would close the portal until the mirror was repaired, or a new one was built, or forever, depending on who was being trapped inside it in the story.


I thought the students already knew about the portal. Considering the fact that Starlight and Sunset went through with everyone watching it.


Don't the students of CHS already know about the portal on the school? Demon Shimmer explicitly said she was gonna take them to equestria though the portal in the statue when she was readying her army, and after she was defeated they seem to have no memory loss of that event.


The Mane 7 should be called the Humane 7, lol. Either way, I love your work! Glad to see you’re still around and making content we love and enjoy!


It's a fun theory, but there's one thing I can't help but wonder. We do know that Twilight basically rigged the portal to be open without the moon, but there's nothing indicating that she isn't just turning it off and on as needed. After all you could easily just have some kid walking by the school lean into the statue and suddenly pony world. That would be a much larger threat. The statue is out in the open after all. I can easily see Twilight just shutting off the portal after getting them through it. And I can also imagine Twilight going to the cave afterwards for good measure and closing that too to avoid more Equestrian magic to leak through Equestria's Australia.... I mean earth.