Scary reminder: Pinkie has a child now, and what makes it worst is that she had it with Cheese Sandwich. What chaos have they brought upon the world?!?!
So did Cadence and Shining Armor, Mrs and Mr Cake, Mr and Mrs Sparkle, and everyone else in the world. But our lord and savior Celestia is too pure and holy so she adopted Cadence🤣🤣
While it did bind with her DNA, it most likely didn’t affect her sex chromosomes just to make sure that it wasn’t passed on. But if it did, it would’ve become a homogeneous recessive gene meaning that both parents have the rare trait in order for it to show in the offspring.
Oh god no- Pinkie, you have made both a grave mistake. And a very amazing choice. Cheesecake is the true being of chaos, not Discord, not Pinkie, and not Cheese Sandwich. Lil Cheese is the true chaos being. He will rule the cosmos!
The problem with giving characters children is that now they're the age of old grandparents and still have children that are as old, or younger, than the cmc.
Pinkieshy LPS I don’t think you understand what Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich are capable of and how having a child could bring more chaos then Discord ever could.
@hannah no, maybe she doesn't want to be in a relationship with anypony, because it would make sense why there isn't a king, or maybe she isn't into guys.
@Rachel Alfarowdym? No. In season 9, pinkie pie said "It was so hard to find a fool sitter (forgot how to spell it) with a sense of humor for lil' cheese."
Cheese has the party sense, it has the same symptoms as pinkie pie has, but he is not preventing disasters, he knows where to go to host the party, maybe they both are somehow magical earth ponies?
Everything makes sense in your explanation except for one occasion which wasn't considered.
When Pinkie Pie, Rarity, and Maud had that one meet-up (I believe the episode is 'The Gift of Maud Pie' - S6, E3), Maud 'sensed' and knew where the guy to whom Pinkie traded her canon was. As Rarity enquired, Pinkie answered with something along the lines of: "Yeah it goes down/through the family." and shrugged it off.
"Pie Sense" could be truly genetics, maybe a slightly different race of pony??? A magic earth pony? Who knows. But Pinkie Pie still has extra magic that the other Pies don't seem to have (manipulating gravity, pulling stuff out of thin air, etc)
@Puppygirlman18 Maybe it's because of the chaos magic. I think that's what happened. So she did have that pie sense, but the magic had an influence on it, which made it stronger. It would also make sense as to why Cozy Glow didn't have the effect Pinkie Pie did.
Maybe an ancestor of Pinkie had absorbed Discord’s magic, without losing it, and it had passed through the family, slowly growing weaker? I’m unsure. Maybe discord isn’t that old to be able to have that happen.
Maud/Pinkie sense could be the Pie family's version of earth pony magic- their "connection to the earth", as it will. Maybe it's specifically because Pinkie has that sense, and specifically because it relates to time and predictions, that the chaos magic scattered through the timeline for her, but not for Cozy.
i think rather than it being proof that discord's magic affected her past.....
pinkie sense is WHY it affected her past.
Also the only reason she was able to handle it.
Her Pinkie sense made her able to distribute magic through her timeline. Which in turn meant that when she got discord's magic she was able to handle it.
maybe it just kept going? if it went through pinkies whole timeline, maybe it went to mom pie and dad pie too. why stop there? chaos magic is inherently un explainable.
Plus, it’s also odd how pinkie got pink skin and pink curly hair while the rest of her family members seem to have a grey-ish complex with straight hair
This and, discord can be seen doing a jiggle similar to the "pinkie sense" when all the princesses gave twilight their magic to keep it safe in the episode Twilight's castle.
Actually he not entirely Wrong they a Comic when discord is having trouble using his power after tirek stole them and thwss a rift to discrird dimension left open and pinke pie fell into and learnt the rules of chaos as what ever pops into your mind happensd and pinke learnt the rules to it
The reason why the chaos magic didn't spread throughout cozy glow's time line was because at the time she was an Alicorn, meaning she could handle all of the magic. but pinkie is just a earth pony, so that's why it spread out through her timeline only.
oh did you notes two things she took more than cosy glow i can tell from the surrounding lightning she has and she had a decent amount of control.oh she got the alicorn powers from the magic sorry
Or maybe it's because Pinkie had her own sort of chaotic magic (Pinkie sense) so she was used to random bursts of power and twichy tails but I don't think it was because she was an earth pony Pinkie is different from others and I don't think anyone would be able to control such chaotic magic as Discord's other than Pinkie, Discord and maybe Cheese Sandwich?🤔💥
If I remember correctly during the part before Cozy Glow got discord's chaos power she said something like 'Give me a taste of the power'. I think she just gains a small amount of discord's power. While Pinky, on the other hand, gained 10 times more power than Cozy, all of it probably. When Cozy gained the chaos magic, her surrounding was quite tame while Pinky made her surrounding turn pink and filled with balloons, ice-cream, candy and other party stuff. I also think when they drained Cozy Glow from the chaos magic, they drained every inch of it and none was left but when Discord just took away the bell from Pinky, a tiny amount of the chaos magic could have just stuck with her.
Or she has no connection to a different point in time like pinky pie. Pinky pie has her pinkie sences which is not in the same time as her. Side note I think the real reason why Cozy didn't have chaos magic in her time was not because she was an Alicorn but she has not connection to a different point in time. Chaos magic is too powerful to be handled by anyone but discord so being an Alicorn wouldn't have made the difference and she was only an Alicorn for a short period of time. Another reason would be that Cozy is still just a fillie and would have probably died if it weren't for the Alicorn enhancement. Pinky was able to handle the chaos magic because she was already infused with chaos magic. I think that eventually she'll become as powerful as discord because the power would just keep stocking up as that period of time goes by.
This is a pretty good idea, but my opinion is that it affected all of her timeline because she didn't want to use it for evil, only chaos, what it was intended to be used for.
@Àíďàñ But they certainly do have potential, Just look at Twilight she had the power of all the alicorns but that never effected her. The magic of 4 alicorns should be close to the power discord contains
@Kiran shravan voleti I mean I would assume so since she's an Alicorn as well. All the Alicorns probably can handle the amount of magic but they would n't be able to successfully use the magic in a fight, Celestia and Luna might be able to use the dimension travel magic because they already have exprience with traveling to other dimensions.
It seemed to me like Pinkie could control Discord's power to her will, making it drop a giant cupcake out of the sky when she wanted to drop a giant cupcake out of the sky. Cozy however seemed to have no control seeing as her attempts to attack Tirek and Chysalis ended in rubber chickens and sentient pineapples
@Surayaa Pinkie just wanted to have fun and make people laugh and cause chaos so the chaos power allowed itself to be used by Pinkie but Cozy wanted to use it to harm others and to destroy all balance and take over the planet but the chaos magic isn't supposed to do that so it didn't allow Cozy to use it's power. It's kinda like the magic has a mind of it's own and deems if the user is worthy enough to use it's power to it's full extend. Discord did take over for a sort period of time but unlike Cozy Discord made everything chaotic.
@Anti Social Weeb Also Pinkie already knew how to control a little bit of discord’s magic from he life. She probably knew how to control the whole thing to some extent.
@KittyandLychee Pinkie might know how to control a % of discord's magic but does that mean she'll be able to handle the rest. In the show we have seen pinkie do stuff that normal earth ponies can't but we've never seen like the advanced stuff that discord does like turning building upside down or opening portals to other realms by herself. Say Pinkie has 10% of discords magic, she has had her entire life to master that, do we don't really know if Pinke can handle the rest. Take Twight for an example, she's an alicorn and the legit embodiment of magic yet she had trouble with containing all 4 alicorn's magic, along with hers. Chaos magic is either as strong as the 4 alicorns or stronger since in one of the timelines that Starlight made, discord took over equestria and their were 3 alicorns at the time with the entire nation. So if anyone says that pinkie is able to handle magic that is basically on par with an entire nation plus 3 alicorns as soon as she got it right off the bat, I think you need to double check your facts(I don't say this to offend anyone)
@Anti Social Weeb I wasn’t saying that Discord’s magic didn’t spread through Pinkie’s life, I am just saying that because Pinkie Pie had Discord’s magic in her life, it would explain how she (kind of) able to control how and where to drop the giant cupcake. My main point is that Pinkie was able to control Discord’s magic better than Cozy, because she had a lifetime of practice.
@KittyandLychee Ya i figured I just didn't want anyone else asking some question like well if Pinkie can control a bit of chaos magic than she can control the rest or something like that
true, not in it's entirety, but what's to say that since cozy glow already had alicorn magic, the amount of chaos magic she could absorb was capped before she absorbed discord's magic in it's entirety.
Lucretia Thomas twilight was able to absorb 3 alicorn’s magic, it not getting capped. I dont think that discord’s magic could be much more than one alicorn’s magic, so cozy glow has a good chance at still the magic not getting capped.
@Lucretia Thomas And don’t forget that at the time Pinkie absorbed the magic in the bell, it also had Princess Celestia’s and Luna’s magic in it as well as discord’s. That is a lot of magic for and earth pony to absorb all at once.
It's also because Pinkie has a part of her which is connected to time which is her Pinkie Sense. It's hard to understand but think of it this way. Cozy had an alicorn body so it could contain the chaos magic but Pinkie has an earth pony body which can't contain all the magic on its own and her Pinkie sense acts like a hole in her time period in which chaos magic can leak out and affect Pinkie's entire essence in the past, present, and future.
@S K well since cozy glow already had a lot of magic, she was able to control it a little bit more than Pinkie, like probably just enough to stop it from influencing the rest of her timeline
Good idea that makes sense mostly except she wasn’t a true real alicorn (like twilight) she was just a “fake one” because nothing happen d like it happened with twilight she might have observed but in a different way
@Double Guyzer Maybe it was a difference between how they approached their use of it due to their personalities.... Cozy Glow tried to control it, as her nature was that of one who seeks dominance and control.... The magic rejected her as a result.... Pinky on the other-hand... She already had a chaotic and carefree attitude, and tendency to just do things without considering the consequences.... She didn't try to control the chaos, she embraced it and so it empowered her to act on whims she was otherwise powerless to act on.... Had Discord not siphoned off the excess of chaos magic she might well have caused just as much havoc he does when he's not reigning himself in....
@Amayah Johnson Because she was rapidly showing signs of getting drunk on that much power.... She could control it, that doesn't mean she wouldn't abuse the heck out of it much the same way Discord himself used to.... It started with chocolate rain, but sooner or later her warping reality to her whims would likely hurt those around her, regardless of her intent....
3:30 Now that I think about it, even though Cozy Glow isn't as chaotic as pinkie, she still will sometimes pull stuff from nowhere, like when she was with the other villains planning to go up the mountain to retrieve Grogar's bell she suddenly had s'more making materials despite not bringing any. She also is known for making over the top facial expressions, and maybe having chaos magic helps with that idk. I think some of the chaos magic did spread through Cozy's timeline.
Is it a stretch? Yes. Is it just a coincidence? Yes. But will I except this as headcannon anyway? Also yes.
43 likes
Jaden A. Prince2021-10-15 21:20:56 (edited 2021-10-15 21:34:54 )
I love this theory, but I couldn’t help but notice something. In the Gift of Maud Pie (season 6 episode 3) we see that Maud has a MAUD SENSE, just like Pinkie has a Pinkie sense, and Pinkie comments that it, “runs in the family.” Is it possible that Maud has magic as well? Are their other members of the Pie family that have this ability ? Maybe they have some sort of magical ancestry, like Pumpkin Cake or Flurry Heart. I feel like the answer to Pinkie Pie is still out of our grasps, but if it really is Discord’s chaos magic, it might be possible it spread through Pinkie’s family (Do you really expect Discord’s magic to follow any rules?). I feel like this is a little far fetched, but hey, this is Discord we’re talking about!
A note: when Cozy Glow used discord’s magic, she turns into that monster thing- but when Pinkie uses it, Electricity crackles on her body. Cozy didn’t have the electricity. And discord’s magic is electricity so it suggests that when Pinkie Pie used it, something mysterious happened, and Discord’s magic started flowing through her veins and affecting her entire timeline. Only a note/theory Pls like so Sawtooth can see this
Well there’s one problem with your theory if discord’s magic has electricity he would have sparks around him . Cozy was an alllacorn so sh could Handel all the magic but pinkie is an earth poney not being able to Handel all that magic it spread into her entire timeline
Cozy could not control the magic, just as she could only accept it being given to her. Pinkie Pie could control the magic to do her bidding, because she had been intendd to control this magic even if it technically is not hers to begin with. For a paralel, the Alicorn is the combination of the Pony magic; but what do you get if you add the Chaos and Changeling Magic? Pinkie Pie? If you follow her history; you notice Pinkie is using all the Pony Magics at one time or the other, but she is apparntly using Chaos and Changeling Magic as well. Why is Pinkie's last known surviving Clone a Journalist? Is it a nod to Clark Kent? Though one may assume she does a grand job at the Journalism, if the Clone has as much as a Shadow of Pinkie's Qualities. Knowing where the news are, and remembering everything?
@Kiran shravan voleti well you can see discord’s magic is kinda involves electricity when he turns those three villians into stone. His magic coming out of his hands looks like electricity
@Twilluz That assumes Pinkie plays by the same set of rules? Which rarely seems to be the case. Pinkie could claim the magic for herself withapparent ease, while Cozy required another to afford her the magic. If the other were willing or able to use the magic would most likely be irrelevant?
@Lark Dash Oh yeah good point. But I am saying that because Pinky was a giant a little longer and I am thinking that because of that she was effected with discord magic.
maybe because it was a full loop. As she was already a being of chaos. It affected her past as well. Maybe with Cozy it was altered by the other magic she absorbed.
Also, cozy couldn't use the chaos magic. Everyone said that discords magic is so chaotic that he's the only one that can control it. But pinkie seemed like she could use the magic pretty easily
@Kentavritsa I also have a theory on Pinkies clones.... What if her clones weren't clones, but other Pinkie Pies from parietal universes... Perhaps one of them even being from the EG universe.... They had to learn about the world they were in from Pinkie Prime because most of them weren't even Ponies in their home dimensions to begin with....
So I've seen people in the comments talking about certain other characters that also have weird abilities like Pinkie, and I'm starting to wonder: is chaos magic REALLY unique to only Discord? Because I find it would be pretty interesting if random creatures/individuals just happened to have chaos magic, and are often randomly born with it with no rhyme or reason. The amount of power they have is also random, and sometimes they can only do a limited number of things. It would just generally be cool to get that kind of lore on chaos magic, especially if it was true that certain random individual beings just happened to have it, and some might even know more of the secrets of the universe than others.
But when cozy glow absorbed it she couldnt handle it. When I saw that scene I immediately said to myself, " ok for a fact Pinkie can handle it shes chaotic in general." And then it happened and she handled it way better!!
If Discord’s chaos magic effected Pinkie into her past and future then how come in season 6 ep. 3 when they where trying to get Pinkie’s canon back Rarity asked Maud how she knew where it was she said “Maud sense” then Pinkie said and I quote “Runs in the family” so everyone in her family has it. It’s just a talent they had since birth! Sorry if this ruins the theory and you have to delete this one although I really like it!
In season 8 when was Pinkie Pie sad, she changed colour of her skin, she made her hair straight and when she was walking down the town, flowers started to die and balloons started to burst. Her mood was literally changing things around her. That is a proof that she has some kind of magic.
I really like this theory and in a lot of ways it makes sense! I think there might be a couple of reasons why Pinkie got to keep some chaos magic and Cozy didn’t: 1) Discord was the one who removed a bunch of the chaos magic from Pinkie and might have let her keep a little bit for fun later. Tirek and Chrysalis removed all of the chaos magic in Cozy Glow after she said she was going to turn on them wielding her newfound power. 2) Pinkie was blasted by the rainboom and cozyglow wasn’t. This magically connected Pinkie to her friends and a little bit to their respective kinds of magic. Given Discord was Pinkie’s friend, a little bit of chaos magic might have stayed with Pinkie only when she was directly exposed to it. This might also explain why Cozy was unable to control the chaos magic while pinkie could.
3:29 i think its a mix of two things 1. chaos magic is well, chaotic. it doesn't follow a set pattern of what happens to those who use it. 2. it could be a causality loop, where because of that moment, it gave her the magic throughout her timeline, which in turn gave her enough of that magic that her using it strengthened her power in a way that both make her control it, and so it overflowed to throughout her timeline. meaning that, that moment, caused that moment to be able to happen.
Hey...I noticed that in the episode where Twilight fights tirek , after she gets magic from all 3 Princesses disocrd just like pinkie senses it by shaking his body...
What if when Cozy Glow absorbed Discord’s magic, it made her feel motivated to drain all the magic from Equestria and turn to the dark side? I think that’s cool
Maybe Discords magic effected Cozy's timeline too and that's why she went crazy for "Power" has no idea how to respond to friendship just like Discord didn't in the beginning and Cozy wanted to become the "Empress" of Friendship just how Discord became the Lord of Chaos, and why she's so smart and a little filly not aging even alittle when we see the Crusanders age alittle and grow through the series, maybe she's from when the ponies were still at odds and wendigos still roamed. So otherwise maybe the Discord magic twisted her and made her go "mad" and affected her growth physically but not intellectually. Just a thought.
I havet really thought this through but this theory about smt happening in the future would affect the past seems also fitting too Flurry Heart. I mean she was born alicorn, yet she hadn’t really had an interaction with any other ponies. But at her coronation she got the love of all the crystal ponies, and we’ve seen both crystal ponies with wings and without- so why not with a horn? So she basically got love(aka magic) from possibly all three tribes. I’ll set my brain aside and let someone else joke around with this theory.
It's very interesting, but on the other hoof I don't recall Discord having affected time, only space/dimensions with his powers. That said there is another detail I'm too lazy right now to check, but in the famous time loop episode with Twilight, iirc Pinkie wasn't really into Twilight's theory that something would happen and still tagged along for fun, at least she didn't take that seriously at all... if your time loop theory is correct and this one too, maybe Pinky's twitchy tail sense could "have remembered" the timeline where nothing happened after Twilight checked every potential danger...
The fact that when Cosy absorbed Discord's magic, she couldn't control it, but when Pinkie absorbed it, she was able to control it somehow concerns me for some reason.
I would like to debunk that theory. While you have some good arguments I don’t think the cause of her “godlike powers” is Discord’s magic. I personally think that it has to do with the sonic rainboom when she got her cutie mark. It is show that the sonic rainboom is magical enough to give other ponies extra power, like it did with Twilight, it gave her the magic she needed to pass her entrance exam. I think that the rainboom gave Pinkie those abilities, and I believe it is stored in her mane. When the rainboom happened, her hair puffed up, and when her hair was flat she doesn’t have those godly abilities. Her mane alone is also shown to be magical, like when she stores random objects in it or when the front would move like an extra limb. I’d love to know what you think about my theory! I know I’m pretty late to this video and I apologize for that, but I do hope you find this interesting.
I have one detail that I think can support this theory, when cozy glow absorbed the power she didn’t have the same results as Pinkie Pie did because when she absorbed the power she already had experienced Alicorn magic and Alicorn magic is powerful so Discord’s magic would only be an extend of control that Cozy Glow just couldn’t handle as for Pinkie Pie she would have never experienced magic before until that moment when she got Discord’s magic it was hard to control just like for Cozy Glow but Pinkie Pie had a greater affect on it because she never had experienced magic before until that one moment and then the rest of your theory goes on
Hey Sawtooth, just something floating around in my brain. If an alternate timeline existed in which Pinkie did not take Discord's magic, would that mean Pinkie would be normal in the alternate timeline? Imagine a Pinkie that can't break The Laws of Physics...
Interesting theory. Works even better than my own explanation years ago for Pinkie: that she was born a heavy unicorn hybrid, (unicorn with earth pony traits) but something happened as a very young foal (possibly Cake twins age) that caused the need for her horn to be removed. Or possibly was broken off duecto either an accident or abuse. (Also, in my headcanon at the time, she was adopted.) With the removal of her horn, but the carbunkle (nerve cluster atvthe horn's root) still there, her unicorn magic ends up being bottled up... causing extremely random and chaotic releases of said magic.
i love the theory :D personally, ive always thought that pinkie just has that magic naturally. we already know that ALL ponies have magic, not just unicorns; and that magic can be personalized. for example, fluttershy's ability to speak to animals, and her Stare. those arent "pegasus powers" that all pegasi have, like the ability to fly; its hers alone. pinkie's magic could just be like that, natural and unique to her. i always thought that pinkie was able to wield discord's magic so well because it was a close match to her already existing magic and personality.
I like the theory. To explain the difference between Cozy and Pinki’s reactions you could easily say it was because Cozy was an Alicorn at that point and able to contain the chaos better than an earth pony
Well, Cozy Glow with her desire for power/control is too orderly for a filly. Pinkie Pie is the opposite - she's very chaotic for an adult pony. Also, if this was something of an event that influenced her PAST before the moment-- that makes it a Circle like so many time-travel stories.
Cozy glow used magic to be powerful while pinkie used it to create crazy chaos. Maybe those moments changed both ponies. Pinkie pie became crazy pony who destroys phisics laws and cozy glow became hungry for power and obsessive.
Pinkie has her Pinkie sense, that is true.But if all magic disappeared from equestria then she might also have lost her Pinkie sense. Yes this minor detail was hard to see and 99 percent of people didn't notice this. But it is highly unlikely that one event in the future can affect the present.
If that happened in that one moment changed entire timelines, we know from the episode where Twilight time travelled to stop Starlight that different timelines in the MLP universe are a thing. Would the chaos magic effect the timelines of other Pinkies? Like if in another timeline, Pinkie did NOT absorb Discord’s magic at the time, would she still be as crazily Pinkie as we know? If it effected her whole life, was there a past before the chaos magic thing? Just her being the element of laughter, cracking jokes and visual gags, but with no physics defying stunts? Or is that past just erased because of all the chaos magic? Is it still there, in another timeline?
Maybe she wants all of us to believe that we've solved her... She does know of our existence so... could she be misleading us..? O _ O Welp, no sleep for me tonight!
hmm... I've always explained pinkie sense as one of many psychic abilities, essentially as twilight pointed out, magic and pinkie sense don't exactly work the same way. which is why she failed to understand it, my theory is that in equestria, psychic abilities are a separate thing from magic. She isn't the only one either, Fluttershy is a natural empath, but what if she's a supernatural empath as well? it would explain her ability to communicate with animals, (or at least understand their emotions and why she is so sensitive in general when she can sense the judgement of other ponies first hand not to mention her glare, imagine focusing pure fear into a target just by looking at them. Princess Luna is a telepath, in the diary of the 2 sisters she gained the ability to communicate with animals much like fluttershy, but also she is known for entering the dreams of ponies, technically we do see that she has a spell for that, but theoretically magic isn't incapable of enhancing or duplicating a psychic ability Also Izzy moonbow claims to see the auras of other ponies or their unique "sparkles" she even uses that ability despite the absence of unicorn magic or seemingly any other pony magic.
Cheese Sandwich can pull similar feats too, and as far as we know, he never got injected with a butt ton of chaos magic that made him want to turn all the stars into rubber chickens
I like to think party ponies are a small and rare sub-set of ponies or even creature that have a very slightly different type of magic, probably akin to chaos magic, that makes them more emotional and connect with feelings like joy more than the average creature as well as pull those feats
Perhaps these traits are why they're usually the ones in charge of non-formal parties around Equestria, hence the name and title of Party Pony
The only two party ponies we really know of are Pinkie and Cheese, and both are earth ponies, and that can probably just be chalked up to coincidence. But what if, as earth ponies, they don't really have the inate magic of unicorns and pegasi, their magic being alot more subtle, so this 'party pony magic' can be expressed alot more easily in earth ponies
I like your idea and i think your half right. but you forgot one detail. Grogar had said in season 9 "only a creature of pure chaos can control discords magic" Pinkie however seemed to control it PERFECTLY when she got her whooves on it. This means she has always had her OWN form chaos magic (likely chaotic good) which is why she could control it but it being a more "negative" form of chaos magic it still corrupted her slightly (not making her evil just outta control)
Laughter is a magic of the same nature as chaos. Even Dash mentioned once how random Pinkie is (episode with Gilda). That's where Pinkie sense comes from: she can feel chaos around her. Maybe that makes Pinkie so good at ordering (her secret cave). So, Pinkie has deal with chaos the whole life. And that's the explenation of Pinkie's ability to control the chaos magic (she can feel it and she have been practicing to control it during whole her life).
I truly support your belief about discord's chaos magic affecting Pinkie Pie's timeline and affecting her future and past but regarding the difference of the outcome on cozy glow and Pinkie Pie after absorbing Discord's magic is because she also absorbed Princess Celestia's and Luna's magic which was in the bell so I think this was the reason of Pinkie Pie's timeline being affected
Honestly, all this time shenanigan stuff is unneccessary. I just always theorized that Pinkie Pie was able to use chaotic magic from the start, as she is more prone to being able to do things that the rest couldn't. Things that don't involve time at all. This explains in a more simple structure why she couldn't just "read the future" and know when to touch the bell and all that. She simply always knew chaos magic. It's why she enjoyed Discord in Season 2. It's why she was able to control and harness Discord's Magic. She already knew Chaos Magic. That's why she can control it. No time shenanigans needed.
My Own Theory: What if she had gotten it from the Sonic Rainboom like how Twilight's magic activated then? Now, I know that sounds far-fetched, but think about it. When she lived on the rock farm, she was just a normal pony, not the hyperactive and physics-defying party pony we know today. When she set up that party at the rock farm, it was only a DAY (I believe) after the Rainboom. There's no way she could have gotten the supplies for the party and come back home THAT fast. The Rainboom could have done more than just puff up her mane/tail and show her how to smile. It could have awakened the chaotic good side of her that was hidden from living on the rock farm. That's all I got. Bit of a stretch, but it's still possible. Nothing is impossible when it comes to Pinkie Pie.
This all sounds plausible, but what about Maud? In the manhattan episode where Pinkie and Maud exchange gifts, Rarity asks how Maud knew where the sales pony was, and Maud replied saying," Maud sense". If what you said was true, then how did Maud get her Maud sense?
This fits with what I've been thinking, Pinkie having her own kind of chaos magic... An example of this, one scene in a harthswarming episode, where the apples stay at the pies. 19 hooves appear from the sides of the frame, and AppleJack sees them too, though the other ponies around them seem unfazed. This suggests that Pinkie isnt just making them appear where we can see, or is doing some weird trick. Applejack has no idea where they came from, and looks around her kinda terrified. Pinkie can make these things happen for specific ponies too. As well as when twilight broke the fourth wall to help Pinkie after Trixie's first appearance. This isnt happening for everyone, just specific ponies.
Actually after the season four finale discord had trouble using his power and pinke pie took over his dimrdom that how pinke could use the chaos msigc discord let pinke pie keep some mdguv in case pinke wanted a rematch discord almost lost to pinke pie
Also I think the real reasons that it spread through her timeline was because it wasn't just discords magic that she took in, remember that Celestia and Luna's magic was in there too which wasn't what cozy glow absorbed
i noticed the magic go into pinkie in that one scene, and i found it bizarre, this theory has SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much evidence that pinkie is one of 4 things 1. She is the random 4th wall character that appears in lots of shows 2. Your theory 3. she is a literal pony goddess Or my personal favorite, 4. She has the potential to become an alicorn. She never does in the show, but i really want to hold on to this theory
You forgot Her Chaos Goddess Moment in the Comics. She took over the Chaos Realm and replaced Discord as Chaos. That wasn't a brief moment, it was a whole day. Maybe even more. That more likely. To us it may have been a day, Pinkie Pie could been in there for years, centuries. In the comic, Pinkie completely rewrote the whole Infinite Chaos Realm to her liking. Your theory become more believable if you use that moment.
Woot I helped solved Pinkie Pie!!! Now I must run from Twilight Sparkle.
I also have an explanation to why Maud and Cheese Sandwich both have senses of their own too. While Pinkie was overwhelmed by the chaos magic, not only did she spread it through her OWN timeline, she also granted power across other people that she really really cares about's timelines, like Maud and the rest of the family. ('Runs in the family!') But you may be wondering, "why would Cheese have it then?" well, I mean, there IS a character that is presumably Pinkie's daughter in The Last Problem named Little Cheese who is playing with Boneless 6, soooooo
I think Cozy Glow wasn't filled with chaos for life, but evil for life, as Discord's magic is filled with chaos AND evil. He may have taken a long time to control his chaos, and the main 6 help him control the evil.
I think the simple explanation as to why cozy and pinkie reacted to discord's magic is because the magic they have is different. Cozy also has grogar's magic in her at the time she absorbed the chaos magic. It seems as though 1/3rd of grogar's power is a buffer to all that chaos. Pinkie was a regular earth pony before she absorbed all of discord's magic. All that pure chaos did change her life. I'm really convinced by the theory, if you can't tell.
My theory: I think cozy glow’s also spread across her timeline, but just needed something to activate it. I think the rainboom had ticked the magic and activated it
I agree with what you Said! Pinkie might have some secret magic! 🤔 But Also in the Castle Mane-ia episode, she was playing the organ, and the music was really creepy. When Twilight removed the "jacket" and she was playing, it sounded different 😳 That was Kinda strange 🤔
I think Pinkie Pie can also look into Discord's mind because in Season 9 episode 1 "The Beginning of the End" when Pinkie Pie was listing all the villains they have defeated, she only mentioned the one's that have returned. King Sombra, Queen Chrysalis, Tirek and Cozy Glow.
Mr. Mineblox / Daylight Twinkle XD I was just joking too but to be honest even tho I love the theory pinkie and her weirdness is probably just pinkie and weirdness lol
Thomas Hanson2022-04-16 06:05:50 (edited 2022-04-16 06:10:53 )
Unrelated to your theory, which I find fasvinating, but I always thought Pinkie was adopted by the Pie family. And that she actually is a draconequus with the body of a pony.
Honestly Pinkie is interesting.
Even though she doesnt have as many chaotic powers as Discord, her whole personality is far more chaotic than Discord who is honestly a pretty normal personality.
Pinkonquus just a thought.
And actually this can combine with your theory. That event where she picked up the bell, might have effevted Pinkie uniquely being that she already was a draconequus and the bell unlocked her chaotic potenial
Your claim in the episode would have been correct if chaos magic was also taken. In the episode, only very certain types of magic were taken. No Pegasus magic, no earth pony magic, and no cute mark magic. In my opinion, it is more likely to assume that Pinkie Pie is a descendant of another almost completely extinct pony breed with telepathic abilities. Since it is more similar to unicorn magic than chaos magic it is more likely to believe that such magic would actually take. I wasn't surprised to find out if Maud also got charmed at that moment. After all, we saw her with Boulder communicating with stones and understanding them. We don't really know the rest of Pinky's family and we can also believe that the gene for the early pony type is dormant in most of her family, after all we know that at the moment of the rainboom something happened in her mind that might have awakened these genes.
It could also be that all the applicants carry the ancient genes, they are simply dormant in all the applicants except Pinky.
I see NO plotholes in this theory that can't be filled by the following: Pinkie Pie, full name Pinkamena Diane Pie, also known in certain forms of merchandise as Ponka Po, is the Laughter Element of Harmony, and her special talent revolves around giving joy to others and making them smile and laugh. Being able to follow something known as "cartoon physics", as well as "break the 4th wall" and speak to people who live in a reality where HER reality is a work of fiction could bring quite a few individuals a LOT of joy, especially if they truly believe she's talking to THEM.
Discord’s chaos magic might’ve originally been a mix of 3 different types of magic: Chaotic Good, Chaotic Evil and Chaotic Neutral. So as far as we know, Discord’s magic may have been split into 3 bits: 1. Chaotic Good: Transferred to Pinkie Pie 2. Chaotic Evil: Transferred to Cozy Glow 3. Chaotic Neutral: Kept in Discord
Wrong ! 🙅♂️🙅♂️ everything is explainable and I think his theory is quite logic, now I think we need more evidence... perhaps we should look deeper somewhere else, like the comics ? 🧐
I have a idea when Cozy Glow absorbed Discords magic, she already used some magic to become a alicorn, so Grogars bell couldn’t add any more magic. So since pinkie is a earth pony with NO magic. It could give her a lot and I mean a LOT of magic. So much that it spread across her entire life…
Also when pinkie absorbed discords chaos magic it seemed as though she could somewhat control it, it may have been that what pinkie would do with it is very similar to what was happening when she took it but also her transformation into a giant pony being wasn’t instant like with cozy glow. Pinkies transformation was also a lot less demonic looking and more of just a giant pinkie pie, also cozy glow was already an alicorn when she took the magic so it likely just that pinkie was an earth pony.
When cozy glow got discord magic, she was evil and she had bad intentions. And, her eyes turn different colors. But when pinky pie got discords magic, her eyes stayed the same and she had good intentions. Well if you count covering everything in frosting good intentions…! So, maybe the eyecolor and the evil versus good has something to do with it?
It is actually very very confusing that pinkie actually was able to control discord's chaos magic. In the scene where Cozy,Tirek and Chrysails were talking about what to do with discord's chaos magic,
Tirek said that NO OTHER CREATURE OTHER THAN DISCORD CAN CONTROL HIS CHAOS MAGIC.
Maud/Pinkie sense could be the Pie family's version of earth pony magic- their "connection to the earth", as it will. Maybe it's specifically because Pinkie has that sense, and specifically because it relates to time and predictions, that the chaos magic scattered through the timeline for her, but not for Cozy.
Maud has a 'Pinkie Sense' of her own, and Pinkie says it runs in the family, so I think the Pie family are all secretly descendants of Discord. Pinkie got a large dose of his magic in her veins which would explain the 4th wall-breaking and defying the laws of physics, time, and space. It might also explain why she was able to control Discord's chaos magic when she absorbed it, whereas Cozy Glow summoned a rubber chicken instead of a death ray. The flaws of this? Why does Discord not know her? Wouldn't he recognize his descendant? The answer: Discord had been a stone statue for centuries so the amount of chaos magic in the Pie bloodline could have been diluted over time, and their last names have changed. It could have been just resurfacing in Pinkie, so Discord just thought she was an odd earth pony. While there are other flaws in this theory, I like it and it's a theory I've been developing for a while. If you've made it this far in my extremely long paragraph, have a wonderful day!
Here's my theory- or just personal head-cannon, since I don't really have that much to back it up haha Pinkie was born with chaos magic, she's always had it. Maybe that's why she looks so different from her family, and has such a different destiny than they all do. When cozy absorbed discord's magic she wasn't able to use it, or at least she couldn't control what it did. But pinkie kinda could. I think she dropped that huge cupcake and made it rain chocolate on purpose, she absolutely loves both of those things, so it only makes sense that that's where her instinct would go. If she already had a small amount of chaos magic, it would be believable that she would know at least a little bit about how to control it. Of course she wouldn't have been able to control it for long, but in that instant she seemed to be pretty aware of what she was doing.
But that's just my idea, like I said I only have a few bits of evidence and they could totally be interpreted differently.
I think Pinkie controlled it better and kept some magic back cuz that's just how she is. She and discord are quite similar in their bizzare approach to almost everything. But cozy glow just doesn't have that wackiness that chaos magic needs to manifest properly. But Pinkie on the other hand.......(definition of wacky) Can control it to an extent cuz it's similar to the way she works. Chaos magic would have been like "hey, this pony has the stuff in need to work,just not enough if it" or the right Kind She's not chaos, just silly which is kinda tied to chaos and the wile point if everything I've said this far
Also Cozy Glow is just a ginormousss mystery to me. What Alicorn is EVIL
Hi Sawtooth, I can agree with you but there is a difference. When Cozy Glow took the magic from the bell, it contained only Discord's magic, But when pinke pie took the magic, it contained not just Discord's magic it also contained alicorn princess magic. Pinke Pie must have also taken the alicorn princess magic. Please think about this theory. I love your videos Thank you.
Maybe Pinkie Pie absorbed some of Discord's magic permanently because of her personality. Discord's magic was, in essence, a part of Discord and perhaps it latched onto Discord's personality, so when Pinkie Pie, with a personality so similar to Discord's, absorbed Discord's magic, the magic latched onto Pinkie in a way it wouldn't latch onto Cozy Glow.
When Pinkie absorbed the magic in the Bell, she absorbed A LOT more magic than Cozy did. She also absorbed all the alicorn magic from Celestia and Luna that was in the bell.
While rewatching the series, I notced at the part where magic was restored in Equestria [School Raze], Pinkie for some reason was the only non-unicorn that got a ball of aura resembling their Magic-
so correct! ...Not to mention that no creature or pony other than discord had ever controlled his chaos magic (like when cozy glow tried to and epically failed)...and then pinkie happened...she appeared to have complete control over something nobody else could-not counting discord
🤔Maybe being family has something to do with certain different senses and Pinkie Sense just coincidentally came from the chaos magic?🤔 But I don't think so...
I don’t think it has anything to do with time, I simply think that pinkie was compatibly able to control it, perhaps she always had the same kind of magic in her all along, she just got more of it from the bell
Thats the best explanation ever, the event of Magic going back to Pinkie after cozy glow may actually be true. Not necessarily they came from discords Magic. Maybe it came from when she gained her cutie Mark, her destiny was to be like that. Just like the sonic rainboom activated Twilight's Magic it did the same with Pinkie's
I would agree cause discord mainly used his magic in party related themes with all his showing and pinky pie who was born to be a plain old rock farming pony with little to no emotion just magically feels empty on the inside until the sonic rainbow which she thought gave her the motivation to create a party But connecting the dot both discord and pinky do party and unbelievable, and impossible thing which make prefect sense to believe that, the time line of her absorbing discord magic did affect both her past, present and future timelines I mean in my eyes they are both crazy and chaotic
This theory makes sense to me pinkie seams to have held onto discord magic for longer which is why it would have further reaching effects also when pinkie describes discords magic it reminds me of the pinkie sense at least in sensation
Random theory: Pinkie was created as a lab experiment. She was created to manipulate reality so that ponies would no longer have to come to terms with the unchangeable and suit the world to their desires. This experiment went horribly wrong, or horribly right, depending on your point of view.
i have this small thought that like discord, pinkie has chaos magic, and was originally non-pony, but because chaos magic defies reality (like how discord turned into grogar), pinkie took the shape of an earth pony for eternity, and maybe, just maybe, used her magic and made her age, and stored it inside of her
My theory as to why Pinkie Pie has powers so similar to Discord's dracoequs magic is because she is actually half draconequs. I'm not saying Discord's her dad. He was turned to stone long before Pinkie was born, but the show never said there weren't other dracons. So, what if a different dracon fell in love with an earth pony and they ended up having a daughter with all the wacky powers of a dracon, but the appearance of a normal earth pony. That would explain why Pinkie's family looks nothing like her. They're not biologically related and the reason why they have the name last name Pie when their first names don't match is because they changed their family name to protect Pinkie's identity. That also explains why in the mlp app there was an alicorn version of Pinkie who was referred to as the Princess of Chaos.
Wait, if that's true, then how would the "original limeline" Pinkie would be? Like, there must be a Pinkie without all the caos powers if that happens in the lastest episodes; is hard to imagine her without all that
Yes, she did get the powers from the chaos magic, bc she started a spirit bomb out of thin air and shot it at flutter shy in the 2020 smile song, if that wasnt the exact date, sorry i havent watched MLP alot.
A problem i have with this theory is that weve already seen what chaos magic looks like when Tirek took discords magic and if it is chaos magic that gives her the abilities she has then chaos magic should have been the magic we would see not a pink orb
Did you ever think that maybe cozy didn’t have the same reaction because pinky is a happy chaotic pony and cozy is quiet the opposite? Cozy is more like twilight in the fact that cozy is calm and collective while pinkie is energetic and wild?
stick around, because I'm gonna prove this theory right. so this whole theory makes perfect sense. until you bring up the whole cozy glow thing, and everything rolls off the cliff because cozy took the same magic, and had no side effects... or did she? cozy is known for being the most diabolical villain we faced. that phsycho laugh sets you right into psychopath mode. when you put it like that, sounds pretty chaotic. but when you try to pair in cozy with the pinkie-discord duo, she sticks out. because cozy wants to take over aquestria and make it her own image where she can do whatever she wants. discord and pinkie just wanna goof off. but when you compare her to just discord, things get a little more interesting. they are both kinda crazy in the same way. they wanted the same thing. to live by they're own rules and do whatever they want. cozy never played with the laws of physics in the show like pinkie and discord. but that finalizes it for me.
My theory is that pinkie is a changeling stuck in the form we see. think about it, she can stay in the air after jumping for a long period of time, remember when it was pinkie's birthday and she was chasing rainbow? she was loads faster than a normal earth pony, she seems to be able to teleport, something we have seen time after time with changelings. also, when she felt her friends didn't care about her anymore, she either went berserk or was very depressed, it seems as if she feeds off the friendship and without it she can't survive, just like a changeling. it would show why she got magic when it came back to everyone and the Pegasus did not. it also explains the hyperactivity we see with her. you might notice the pinkie from the farm and the pinkie we know are super different, the one on the farm was a normal earth pony, the one we know is a super earth pony, maybe the pinkie from the farm is the original and the one we know killed that pinkie and took her place, i know dark side theory but it could be true.
if the chaos magic went through time to all of pinkie past, present, future, why is the pinkie from the farm not like the one we know at all? the pinkie from the farm is an ordinary earth pony while all the other pinkie timelines we see are hyperactive. just something to think about.
this comment is longer than i had anticipated so i am done.
Mk so I put this on another video, but ever notice how pinkies hair flattening and poofing up with her emotions suspiciously resembles what the Crystal ponies do?? She was definitely raised outside of the empire, but her having roots in the capital of magic would explain the weird and wonderful things she can do as well as why her magic was returned to her!! Weather or not she knows of these roots I'm nit sure.
I think I can connect the dots on why Pinkie and not Cozy Glow. Pinkie’s pinkie sense is a family trait. Maud has a maud sense and then Pinkie exclaimed that it ran in the family. So some form of esp runs in the Pie family, but Pinkie’s particular manifestation of that esp seems a bit more chaotic than Maud’s. That’s probably the chaotic magical influence on her. Also Cozy Glow doesn’t have esp of any kind so no connections outside of time for her. Voila, Pinkie’s family trait is her connection outside of time and Cozy Glow doesn’t have anything like that.
I wonder though. Does Pinkie’s chaotic tendencies get stronger the closer she is to the inciting moment? Or did it spread out more evenly over Pinkie’s timeline? What do you think?
For the cosy blow incoherence: maybe she didn't keep any of the magic, but discord have let pinky keep a tiny bit of his power. I don't why he would do that but I think it could explain. But I'm pretty sure it's just Pinky Pie being pinky
You forgeting that pinki was able to control chaos magic, but closi glow dont. I think, this had main efect on that, but what you saying dont have to be wrong. 🙂
Ondra Lopaur I'm going to help you make your point a bit clearer
i guess you're saying, Cozy Glow cannot use any of the chaos magic at all, thus no Chaos Magic will want to 'remain' in Cozy Glow.
Pinkie Pie was able to wield it, albeit concerning even Discord himself. Meaning, Chaos Magic can still reside within her, since she has been able to use said Magic anyway
@DracoSerpentisCruor yes and gathered magic then went to the all parts of her timeline, that makes loop, where pinki get more and more Chaos magic every time loop going to repeat its self.
Cosy couldn't control the Chaos magic because it was too ... well ... chaotic for her. Pinky was able to contain and "steer" ("control" is too strong a word when dealing with chaos, the words are literally antonyms) the Chaos magic because she already had a link to unpredictability, to "humor," to Laughter. Being a bearer of an Element of Harmony primed her for containing "outside" magic, so she could handle Discord's magic, which then leaked through her timeline and made her the only being (aside from Discord himself) able to break the fourth wall. If they had kept the original concept of Rarity's element being "Creativity," then she might also have been compatible enough to hold Chaos magic.
@kiralax Time travel in Equestria has been really inconsistent, from Twilight dealing with a Predestination Loop in one episode, where everything she did to prevent the future she was afraid of ended up bringing about that exact future, to all the alternate timelines from the time battle between Twily and Starlight ("Twilight uses Boring Lecture! It's SUPER EFFECTIVE!"), there's more wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey contradictions for even Doctor Hooves/Time Turner to keep track of. I have the feeling that Pinkie's timeline being infused with Chaos magic was a one-time/timeless/outside-of-time event, making the tracking of it a Predestination Paradox.
Wait wait wait. I thought Cozy Glow could control the magic but she didn’t like it because she got a huge form to contain it and the powers were....strange to say the least. She couldn’t steer the chaos magic to do what she wanted but it’s not like she couldn’t control or contain it.
@Seraphy Wang No... Did you not see her grow frustrated as she kept trying to "control" the chaos magic and make it do what she wished. And eventually started getting scared, because she was being attacked by the pineapple creatures. She wasn't able to control it. She could not make it do what she wanted. But Discord and Pinkie could.
@Book Thoughts Hmm. I guess thats correct. Technically pinkie was kinda going bonkers too but in the positive way because she was going to do something drastic but could will it to do her request. Pinkie will be pinkie.
@Seraphy Wang I am kind of going to draw lines of comparison between fandoms (hope nobody hates me for it, but I think I see a connection, so...). I think chaos magic is kind of like the wands in Harry Potter and the mirror of Erised in way. The chaos magic "chooses" who it likes to wield it. It liked Discord and Pinkie so it worked to help them and even affected Pinkie. But Cozy Glow: it didn't effect her or work for her, because it disliked her and didn't want to be controlled by her.
@Book Thoughts I'm not a very big Harry Potter fan but i get what you mean. This would be a way of explaining why the chaos magic just seems to work for the two.
Cozy Glozy may have absorbed discords magic but she wasnt able to harness it. Meanwhile pinky pie did so. It is stated by the villains that his magic is really difficult to control, one would need to be kind of chaotic just like discord is. Pinky qualifies these cretirias by default. However she is just a pony, no op, divinity or something like that. Mastering a power so tremendous, even for a few moments it is bound to cause some side effect.
If we're honest, didn't it seem inevitable that Pinkie Pie would get ahold of Discord's magic at some point?
Also, I am reminded of the Bad Wolf, who creates herself. Brief moment of transcendence...and an eternity of having always been and always will have been going to be. So much so that Rose Tyler acting as Rose Tyler or as the Bad Wolf or as the Interface of the Moment all shake reality to its core, and even locking the entire being out of the universe merely led to that being's trans-temporal interference leading to somebody saying her name to let her back in, causing the whole universe to panic.
I think Cozy wasn't affected in the same way was because when she absorbed the magic she was an alicorn at the time. She had more magic and was more used to it
I agree with you, I believe that Pinkie pie does have chaos magic, but I think I might of figured out Cozyglow too, I think that she wasn't effected the same way as Pinkie is because she used it for evil instead of the way Pinkie used it, I think evil was put in her timeline instead, the magic might have given Cozyglow her horn.
I feel like Pinkie is a different type of Earth Pony. It could’ve happened when the Sonic Rainboom happened. I don’t think When she got her powers from the bell it infused her entire life line, but could it be possible this is another form of Friendship Magic brought on by the Sonic Rainboom? When the Rainboom hit, it’s when Pinkie learned to smile, who knows what else it did to her
Clears throat You know this is Pinkie your talking about, Pinkie is literally about, She the element of laughter, and she all about the illogical actions because she knows we are watching, and does all that to keep us entertained and remember Pinkie has always had Pinkie sense, beginning at a young age when she first saw a Rainboom before all this even Cheese Sandwich and even Maud Pie it probably runs in the family Also remember that every pony lost their powers that are their essence(the rest of the Mane Six probably got that but was showed off-screen) because how would twilight be able to absorb the magic of the past, present, and future mane six to defeat Tirek, Chrysalis, and cozy glow use and The Element of Harmony to defeat villains, remember when Tirek absorbed Braeburn essence that's their essence, which made the ponies of the Apple family in which they became too weak to do anything, and they are all earth ponies like Pinkie
I think it might just be Pinkie having her own type of magic, or when she saw the rain boom the magic started pulsing through her. Aka: she has her own chaos magic, but more low-key then Discord’s.
i always knew something was really weird about pinkie lol,, i think she was just born with a bit of chaos magic and thats why she was able to control all of discord's chaos magic and cozy glow wasnt
"A hole had just appeared in the Galaxy. It was exactly a nothingth of a second long, a nothingth of an inch wide, and quite a lot of million light years from end to end. The nothingth of a second for which the hole existed reverberated backwards and forwards through time in a most improbable fashion. Somewhere in the deeply remote past it seriously traumatized a small random group of atoms drifting through the empty sterility of space and made them cling together in the most extraordinarily unlikely patterns. These patterns quickly learnt to copy themselves (this was part of what was so extraordinary of the patterns) and went on to cause massive trouble on every planet they drifted on to...." AND THAT IS HOW EQUESTRIA WAS MADE
David Williams2020-06-30 01:31:54 (edited 2020-07-04 03:04:35 )
@Pinkajou if you're talking about the one " and that's how Equestria was made" it was from TF2 analysis the one with the robot invasion Edit yay I got my reply high lighted
I solved pinkie pie! So, I’m thinking what you’re thinking, Sawtooth! And I think the time she absorbed Discord’s magic, it sent her new “powers” into the past, as well as the future. But then in the past was a chaos Pinkie Pie but only a little chaos because most of the magic contains at when she got her “new powers”. And that makes Pinkie Pie a little crazier! And then, her best friends the mane 6 just feel like she WAS crazy in the past and was always crazy in the past. And I’m not sure Pinkie Pie just is Pinkie Pie because I’m pretty sure everything has an reason just like Coronavirus.
Mister Sawtooth, there is a problem with your theory. In the episode a gift for Maud Pie, when Maud gets Pinkie Pie's cannon back, she knows exactly who took it. When Rarity asks how, she replies, "Maud Sense" and then Pinkie says, " Runs in the Family." Which ultimately means that this sense or superpower runs in the Pie family. So we can just assume that this superpower is from the Pie family instead of something only Pinke Pie has. It might be something related with her ancestors or even from Equestria's past. And about the cozy glow event, my theory says that not only Pinkie got the magic, her family did too. Thus concluding that this magic runs in the Pie family. Do you see how easily Maud can tell what rocks are, what they are made up of without doing anything except looking at it once. And her mother, remember the cutie mark chronicles? she could so easily tell that it was pinkus dianna pie aka Pinkie Pie, even though it could have been any of her daughters. Same goes for the rest of the Pie family. It fits well to what we already know about her family.
What if Pinkie got caught up in another type of magical event that left her with her chaoticness as a filly or that she’s related to a magical being of Chaos other than Discord who isn’t around anymore or Celestia gave her those abilities for some reason since Celestia seems to be pretty damn chill about Pinky being the way she is and doesn’t seem as confused as the others were
Maybe it reached out to a certain time in the past? I mean when she was a filly she always looked upset doing her rock chores with no pinkie sense 🤷♀️
of course Pinkie Pie is watching you. What's up with that? She sees all, and ceases all knowledge by virtue of being the Pinkest of all Pink (ponies)..
I thought she was just like this because it was a way of coping with her past, she sings happy songs with dark backgrounds and smiles through them all :) that might just be my opinion though haha I love pinkie she's so cool
But doesn't Maud have an almost pinkie sense too, and if the chaos magic infected her entire timeline why did she only act like pinkie after the rainboom There are some things if this theory is true, to explain cozy glow, since pinkie wasn't chaotic throughout her entire life, it could be the same with cozy glow only manifesting at a certain age with her becoming evil. It could've also been a trigger, like I said the rainbow almost caused pinkie pie to become pinkie pie. Maybe the rainbow triggered the chaos in a more silly and playful way, but cozy glow might have seen something or her own personal desire for great achievements and friends triggered it in a more evil, destructive, and obsessive way (sorry for it being so long)
I mean with the cozy glow problem I think it was because she’s an unicorn/Alicorn. You see she already had so much magic in her while pinky had none. Maybe cozy glows magic was like how vaccines fight off germs. Cozy glows magic could have fought of that little time that she had discord’s magic. Pinky’s body could have not done that because of the fact she was an earth pony and had no magic in her. I know this might be a bold stament but these puxxle pieces fit together. We’ll never know why pinky’s like this! How ever I would like to be;I’ve it was discord’s magic as u had said in the video.
The fact that Pinkie Pie can defy the laws of physics and even gravity is one of the many reason's i love her as a character!
And to think Pinkie Pie isn't the only cartoon character in history to have been shown to defy the laws of physics, i mean after all other cartoon characters such as Ed from Ed, Edd, n Eddy has been shown to defy the laws of physics from time to time.
The answer for how pinkie would have the magic still is simple in another video came another suggestion that some magic can only be give willingly whilst cosy was willing to give back the magic in a heart beat pinkie was forced
Pinkie has to already be compatible with chaos magic for her to be able to use it like that, but Discord's magic could have supercharged her Pinkie powers. Or actually, silly me, I know what it is! Dashie's first sonic rainboom!! A sonic rainboom is a massive explosion of colorful energy, and magic is just concentrated energy (which is why everypony was so weak when Tirek stole everpony's magic) so when Dashie's sonic rainboom made Pinkie all cheerful and bouncy it actually sparked a reaction with when future Pinkie got ahold of Discord's magic, making kinda an electrical connection, only with magic from opposite ends of the timeline.
This is also why Pinkie doesn't seem to have any of her Pinkie powers when she's in Pinkamena mode or in the alternate timelines Starlight made by preventing the first sonic rainboom. Maybe her frizzy mane is because of the magic? Like how your hair goes all crazy when you get electrocuted.
Discord's chaos magic is what gives Pinkie her raw power, but she can only control it when she's fueled by the joy she got from the sonic rainboom, which she loses when she feels hurt and betrayed by her friends and goes full Pinkamena. Pinkie can feel sad or hurt without going full Pinkamena and she still retains some of her powers, but when that hair goes flat, that's it, game over. Actually, if anything Pinkie's chaos magic becomes downright destructive when she's in Pinkamena mode, like in the yovidaphone episode where flowers would die and balloons would deflate when Pinkie walked by. Going full Pinkamena made Pinkie lose control of her chaos magic and it started destroying things around her
Pinkie being supercharged with two types of magic also explains where Pinkie gets all her energy from! Being a hyper cheerful party girl without chaos magic, or magic in general really, is super exhausting! Seriously, this universe has like no magic at all!! How am I supposed to spread happiness and friendship when I can't even make it half a day without crashing!?
I love this as a theory for how she gained her strange magic, but it seems like other party ponies like Cheese Sandwich and Party Favor are also capable for similar/the same things as Pinkie, and I’m not sure chaos magic makes a suitable explanation for them & other party ponies 😅
88 likes
Replies (3)
Digital Draw2020-07-25 17:07:25 (edited 2020-07-25 17:21:21 )
Yeah and if it was Pinkie Pie's family thing, there's still Sandwich and Party Flavor. (looking at the fact, that Maud also has some kind od sense) And if it is some kind of earth ponies magic, that only some of them got, that would explain the return of Pinkie's magic in that one scene with Cozy Glow.
how about running it in revers, she could manage the magic because it was within her element to wield this magic. she has after all proven that time and time again. Pinkieis not an alicorn, because she is more than an Alicorn. she can wield 2 magics even a great Alicorn can not. Aside from earth, Pegasus and Unicorn magic, she has Chaos and Changeling too.
Talking something not really related, at the part where they got their magic back, how come they were still friends? The mane six's friendship is magic (The whole point of the show) surely, that magic was taken by cozie glow's spell. That was the whole point of why she did the spell. She would need the MAGIC of friendship if she wanted to be the EMPRESS of friendship
Cozy glow had absorbed discords magic but got it taken away from her, in such a short time and pinkie pie had it for a longer period. That might be why.
In a fan fic called muffins, it says that pinkie got the pink gene, making her pink. This however makes a bit to much sence for mlp. Thinking back to prevouis Sawtooth wave viedos, he thought that maybe Celestia named all the ponies. I find this unlikly, because there are proably millions of ponies and she named every single one? I think that that parents get a peek at their childs cutie mark, and then they get to name them off that. They don't need to base off that, like putunia. Her cutie mark is bones. Putenias and bone? The parents choose putenia. If this is also the case, then this would also explain why the parents thought she was going to be a pirate. Bone, Pirate. That works. Perhaps Pinkie's parents saw her balloons on her pink flank and called her Pinkie. But that doesn't explain why she's pink.
My theory is that Pinkie was born with a genetic abnormality because of which she is the black sheep of her family. Since she was so different and her family normally named her sisters after rocks and Pinkie’s colour combination was in no way related to rocks, her parents didn’t know what to call her and just named her after her skin and mane colour.
Also, i just did some calculations if this could happen and turns out, children of any species are more related to their grandparents. This could also probably be shown in Lil’ Cheese, pinkie’s daughter. Her skin colour is a light version of pinkie’s father, but it is also the light version of cheese sandwich. So i conclude that in MLP, fillies aren’t more related to their grandparents...
Or are they? It could be possible that one of pinkie’s grandparents coat was pink. But then it clashed with their partner’s colour which made it greyish. Now this could be either her maternal grandparents who made her mother’s coat grey or paternal parents and it came out in pinkie’s father’s hair. But maybe that pink was still passed on and it came out in pinkie.
Phew! Even as a kid, i wrote a long essay about pinkie
Idk if this is correct or not but an article on google said " the name Pinkamena means "Lively, the life of the party. It also means pink and the name Pinkamena means "Insane" because Pinkamena Diane Pie is her full name!! Still dosen't explain way she's pink tho
@Shivi Srivastava wow that is so cool. I can't believe you're 11 but.... what's the point of saying you are. If I were you kid, I would keep that away from people. People are jerks and assume a lot of things from your age. They have a narrow perception of what different ages are like, (especially for children,) so when the age of someone is revealed online, people stop taking them seriously if they're a child.
@Shivi Srivastava A pilot is the first episode for a TV show most of the time. sometimes it's before the 1st episode. The guy you're replying to is talking about the first episode
Also, the fact that grandparents are more related to their grandchildren can be confirmed in MLP if you look at Granny Smith and Apple Bloom’s eye color and that neither Apple Bloom’s parents, nor her siblings have the same eye color.
0 likes
Digital Draw2020-07-25 17:18:53 (edited 2020-07-25 17:19:12 )
About that adopted theory, i don't think it would work, because Pinkie is a twin at least, looking at her comment in the episode, where families spend "Hearts and Hooves Day" together (i'm terrible at remembering episodes names qwq) "few seconds younger sister". I mean, there is a possibility that their parents made it up, but i don't think so ;^;
@Khitara Aldilla really? Huh, I guess. But my comment still stands. Just bc one pony doesn't have it, doesn't mean multiple ponies don't have the same name
Ok I have a theory: What If PinkiePie is an alicorn?
Now just hear me out, sawtooth stated that to become an alicorn you need magic from all three tribes, and they described most of the princesses getting their alicorn magic from the fact that they hold a great amount of respect and appreciation to ponies of all of the tribes. But doesn’t pinkie pie do the same? She should have appreciation from all three tribes for what she does and how she makes/tries to make everypony happy? If that’s the case when she also have magic from the three tribes? If that’s the case it could explain how come she got to keep some of the chaos magic and cozy didn’t.
i think his right when cozy absorb discord magic it was just discord magic but when pinkie absorb it was combine with alicorn magic, tirek magic, queen crisalist, and there other magic that was in the bell but thats just my theory
Wait I have a theory on how Pinkie Pie got her weird magic. One word Rainboom. Think about it. When Twilight was given magic from Celestia, Luna, and Cadence, their cutie mark vanished. If cutie marks are linked to one’s magic, would it be possible that the rainboom that came from Rainbow Dash’s magic created Pinkie Pie’s? I know this is a stretch but if we look back at Feeling Pinkie Keen, only Pinkie Pie was able to predict things right when it happened. We have never seen a character able to do that except maybe Maud. What if ponies’ magic is already within them but they have to figure out how to bring it out? The rainboom brought the mane 6’s magic out and formed a connection. Maybe it wasn’t Grogar’s bell that caused her chaotic powers rather than that one event. I know it’s a stretch but i don’t see any evidence prior to that one event that someone went back in time and did that.
@Kylan Cooper promise not to tell? Will will you zip your mouth closed🤐 then lock your mouth 🔒then dig a hole 🕳️put the key in the hole🔑🕳️ then build a house over the whole thing forget it exists and live in the house happily ever after lol🏠🏘.😄🤐
This seems likely. But it could also have something to do with her cutie mark. Because Party Favor pulled balloons from out of nowhere and even when magic was gone, Pinkie Pie still did some abnormal things, like pull cakes out of nowhere in Tarterus. But in the s4 finale, she lost her cutie mark and she never did any of those strange things (or at least I don't remember her doing them). And in s5 when she lost her cutie mark she didn't do those abnormal things. And Cheese Sandwitch also did some abnormal things (but not nearly as much as Pinkie).
When I saw that episode (totally wasn't earlier today btw) I thought it more like because pinkie was such a chaotic being she was able to harness the magic instead of it going hog wild unlike with cozy glow
Hello Sawtooth! I wanted to tell you why I personnally think that it wasnt discords magic. You said that when pinkie pie gotted all of that power, it affected all of her timeline. But as your clone telled you, the real pinkie pie was dead all along since season 3, so how could that magic get both the real pinkie and her clones? (I know that the show hasnt really explained the science of magic cloning)
As someone who is a huge fan of both My Little Pony gen. 4, and Star Trek, I think I get it even more. Q, Continuum: past-future. Q-Discord- John DeLancie.
now that i think about this i think because she absorbed alicorn magic along with discord's magic it fused into her essence but cozy only took discord's magic so it didn't effect her.
Yeah, remember the episode where pinkie pulled a whole lotta pinkies from a magic lake in a magic cave and twilight made them watch paint dry?? Two of the pinkies were talking and one of them changed her face to a gen 1 style pinkie and made the other laugh. Maybe thats an example??? Edit: I just remembered the OTHER pinkie that was with the pinkie I mentioned earlier blew into her own hoof and FINGERS CAME OUT OF IT!!!!!!
She is a new creature that they have not put in the show she is a changing a new one. What if she is a changing that take happiness instead, take love or giving love. No steal my thinking pls
You said it affected her time-line when she was a filly but cozy glow is already a filly and never see her future so it is not a problem, cozy glow she was an Alicorn at the time she absorbed discord's magic so she can handled it while pinkie is just an earth pony there is no cozy problem.
Sawtooth Waves, I know the reason why Pinkie Pie new what happened in the other world. I watched My Little Pony bloopers and there was a part that two of the Pinkie Pie's from different worlds were secretly using the portal you have to watch it. IT'S SOO AWESOME and a bit funny.
I agree with Atxqrygh0ul but another theory that I thought of is that Cozyglows’s body was already full of magic so it couldn’t embrace any of Discord’s
This is a really solid feeling, I mean, we’ve seen time travel magic, we’ve seen pinkie being psychic, we’ve also seen different universes based on a single event so why couldn’t it affect the past along with the future giving rise to a dr who theory of fixed points in time and then the unfixed points where you can change something. Pinkie absorbing the chaos magic is a fixed point- in this universe it will always happen, just as the sonic rainboom was proven to be an unfixed point as they all would’ve gotten their cutie marks at some point or another. So maybe its possible for a fixed point in the future to affect the entire past! Great theory and makes way for a ton of discussion. Or of course, it’s pinkie pie and we shouldn’t question it.
In other words “Ripples of distortion radiated our from that point of impact, shifting everything just a tiny bit...but enough. Enough for events to happen slightly differently”
Actually I think your theory works out because of one reason Remember what she said when the chaos magic Was being absorbed into her twilight said how do you feel shes said itchy tingling etc
Say what you like, you’re all just jealous that Pinkie became the true hero of MLP, she’s the one who truly defeated Cozy, Chrysalis and Tirek, albeit with help from Discord
I have one question. If this is the theory that proves pink sense, then why does maud have a maud sense? I’d really like to know an answer if anyone comes up with the theory! :)
Maybe we we're just shown the timeline where discord's chaos essence was consumed in Pinkie Pie's timeline instead of the timeline she wasn't on MLP this whole time and it just didn't work with Cozy!
@fluorescent duck Twi: Please don’t. And, sorry, that was a bad choice of words... but, how else would you explain all of those stunts you pull, I’ve seen discord preform similar stunts so it just makes sense.
I feel like earth ponies version of ‘magic’ is that rarely at birth they are born with strange abilities like pinky and cheese. possibly a rare cutie mark or something.
In season 1 ep 24 Twilight's Owl winks at the camera, probably more creatures do show that they can see the audience (us) in the show. What does this say? :3
Don't mean to debunk the idea because I like it, but I just wanted to say this.
Theory: What if Pinkie Pie was adopted. Let's bust out the fact that this might be the case. Fact 1: She's pink(I know it's obvious but hear me out). If we take a look at her family's color palette and then Pinkie's, we can see a big difference. While Pinkie's family has muted color palettes Pinkie does not. Fact 2: Her abilities. While it seems like Pinkie Pie can pull stuff from out of nowhere! Her family can't. Fact 3: She's chaotic like it said in the video. Her family seems to be calm and saner than Pinkie. Fact 4: She has magic as we saw in the second to last episode she has magic.
So here's a story I thought of. An earth pony and draconequus fell in love. However, it was forbidden and they already had a child Pinkie. Pinkie didn't have any distinct features of the draconequus parent, but she still had the chaotic magic. She was left at the Pies' doorstep the night before the parents' execution. Pinkie grew up on the rock farm never knowing her real parents. As she was getting older her magic started to appear. She could pull stuff from out of nowhere, gaining Pinkie senses and whatnot. She grew up to be the Pinkie we know today.
I just wanted to share this new theory of mine. I wanted to keep it relevant so, that's why this comment is so late.
Hey did anyone realize when cozy glow got discord magic she couldn’t control what she did but when pinky pie got discord magic she could control it why better the cozy glow so that might have a saying to do with it to because if discord and pinky pie can control the magic they might have the same bit of element in them that’s my theory to connect discord and pinky’s crazy doings together
And my thought is that to control chaos magic you need have right personality and mindset. Like pinki and discord, both naturally enjoy chaos but cozy glow don't.
But in the Christmas special pinkie asks those deer things about the perfect gift and if she could see into the future or connected to the future she would know the perfect gift to give twilight but she did not. So if this the theory were true, pinkie would have got the perfect gift from the start and would not have to ask the reindeer.
based on when discord was helping Tirek drain the magic of ponies they alsp said Tirek drained the magic of EARTH ponies. Which makes me beileve that all earth ponies have magic to some degree it is just channeled by their cutie marks. I think that it is Pinkie being Pinkie but the magical parts (teleportation and being incredibly fast) come from her cutie mark taking the magic around her and giving her new abilities.
I don’t think Pinkie got power from absorbing Discord’s magic, because that wayyy wayyy near the end of the story. I do believe she has magic powers like discord, but less powerful. Pinkie is outrageous and chaotic, I think if you are born like that you just have some hidden powers in you. If pinkie wasn’t chaotic she probably wouldn’t have powers, like discord when he tried to act normal.
Thank you I have been trying to figure this out for years also I would really like to know what your favorite episode is my favorite episode is the one where rarity opens up a boutique in Canterlot and the episode where starlight glimmer goes to Canterlot on a mission to help the royal sisters
Please Notice This Comment, Sawtooth Waves! Sawtooth, I noticed that you forgot to mention that Spike didn't get magic back in the part of the video where you pointed out who got magic back in the episode with Cozy Glow’s spell. If Spike didn't get magic, how is his ‘Magic Fire Letter Burping’ possible? I mean, if he has some magical ability that no other dragons have, then why did he not have magic? So think about it this way: if he didn't have magic, he wouldn't have the instant mail express whatchamacallit. But, he DOES. ⚠️ PARADOX ALERT ⚠️
@Jonella Magbanua So if her ting the chaos magic affected her entire family, does that mean that it also could've affected her past ancestors? Think about it. If every past family was affected, this then proves that Pinkie isn't related to Applejack
about the cozy glow thing,i think there were no side effects for cozy glow because shes a pegasus but pinkie is an earth pony or the time since cozy glow only got to absorve the magic for 1m while pinkie longer
The difference between cozy and pinkie is that pinkie used the magic she got, while cozy got turned back before she had the chance to do so. Also (like another commenter said) Alicorns can hold magic in a different way than normal ponies (fx when all the princess put theyr magic onto twilight, they probably couldn’t have done that to a normal pony) so cozy would be able to contain the magic in that moment, while pinkie wouldn’t.
speaking of chaos Izzy from the NG5 had that Pinkie vibe to her, though being a unicorn. And the most interesting fact is that she kept her "glow" unlike all other unicorns from the village. Makes me think what the fuck happened XD
If pinkie's pinkie sense can affect future timelines because of discords bell. Then how the heck does cheese sandwich have cheese sense without grogars bell?
Timeline theory is kinda dump, but connection between chaos magic(or even Discord specificly) and Pinkie it's something that was clear from early seasons.
i watched this to get more insight into the "Smile" episode where she kills all of her friends but there wasnt anything said about it! its actually only thing i saw from MLP world.
I really like that theory alot! With the cozy glow problem i thought of your other video where Cozy Glow was in the human world or even from the human world. Maby that has something to do with it?? And! In that videos comments someone said that she said something along the lines of: “you ponies wouldnt understand” so maby its because shes another kind of creature that cant have magic? Just a theory but i thought it was an interresting thought :))
How do you explain equestria girl Pinkie and her having knowledge to alternate worlds? Did the chaos magic maybe not just affect Equestrian Pinkie but travel through her to alternate pinkie pies and affect them similarly?
Pinkie pies magic was spread out through her life span because it was all of their magic. When cozy glow absorbed chaos magic she only absorbed chaos magic because the other 2 absorbed the rest but maybe pinky absorbed all of it. Making it so much for her to handle and spreading the magic across her timeline.
Cheesy sense debunks this. As does Maud sense. Or at least debunks any connection with the pinky sense. Also, Party Favour can do comparable stuff. Take a page out of twilights book on this one. You can't explain it, but somehow it just works.
I actually really like that idea! Think about it. Pinkie, unlike her family, has never really shown much connection to the earth. I'm not sure what she would be, but if someone finds a folklore creature that matches pinkie put it in the replies
I think pinkie and discord were siblings let me explain
The time line from both the wizard and grogar are different but let me explain mine,what if discord was a normal pony? I will tell it with a story
Long ago there were two little fillies of the pie family pinkie pie and corndie pie As the grew up they became really good siblings until...grogar came in that family He wanted to turn pinkie into a powerful being Their parents tried to protect them but...pinkie went outside and almost got hit by grogar but corndie saved his little sister and became discord
Cozy was an alicorn when she absorbed discords chaos magic but pinkie was just an earth pony , maybe only alicorns can handle that magic without spreading it throughout their whole timeline unlike unicorns , pegasi , or earth ponies aka pinkie pie
To be honest, I think Pinkie Pie was once a Unicorn but in a spell gone wrong, she accidentally got rid of her horn and forever to be a earth pony until a unicorn brings it back.
If we solve Pinkie Pie, there will no longer be any more parties and the citizens of Ponyville will be unhappy all day, just like Pinkie's family. Without Pinkie Pie, Ponyville will have a big difference. Please don't solve Pinkie Pie.
hmm well theirs definitely a magic aspect lets not forget cheese sandwich has also shown the same abilities as pinkie... question is, why do they have this magic and why does it seem genetic? even in the equestria girls human world pinkie seems to have the same abilities so its not limited to equestrian magic either since human pinkie had some minor power similarities prior to the first time they ponied up, so its both magical and genetic at the same time... but perhaps pinkies chaotic abilities stem more from the timeline when discord was the ruler of equestria since he obviously isn't tied to a singular timeline and the comic where discord makes pinkie princess of chaos? never read it just heard about it... so she's had exposure to chaos magic long before that event, but at this point I'm just listing things that might put her exposure to chaos magic to before that episode, though what about grogar? what if one of pinkie's ancestors was one of his creations and a small scale attempt at taming chaos magic? last theory likely not the case but hey ya never truly know with pinkie
Maybe the problem with cozy glow can be solved by saying that that She wanned to use the power of evil and didnt even know from the start that it was Discords magic, but you know im just a simple kid so what do i know
Very believable speaking of ponies that aren't unicorns I'd like to mention that there was a vampire pony without a horn but wings it would be able to you know pull off telekinesis despite not having a horn but that's probably just my theory
ConspiraPon3's theory could tie into this if pinkie is a changeling who grows powerful through love than she would have her own magic already and the encounter with discord's magic might have reacted with her magic, her changeling biology, or both and that would explain the different experience cozy glow had; they're two different species
I got a other theory about Pinkie. I'm almost sure that she was adopted by the Pie family. The evidence : Everyone in the Pie family are greyish but her.
Maybe the element of laughter had something to do with it. I mean it does make sense cause cozy glow was and evil characters and pinkie pie is one of the elements of harmony so maybe because of her element it might have had a different effect on her.
One problem with this theory...CUTIE MARKS! All three Equine tribes MAGICALLY obtain flank symbols upon finding their proclivity OR talent! Earth Pony's and Pegasi are therefore JUST as compatible with wielding Magic as Unicorns are. It's just that it likely manifests in different ways! Take Applejack, SHE's an Earth pony yet she AND Pinky Pie bear one of the elements of harmony. Now let's look at their traits. Apple Jack is strong, athletic, and has HIGH Stamina and endurance and Pinkie Pie is an anomaly of reality. Applejack herself wasn't exposed to chaos magic, but Pinky's reaction to it highlights, for ME at least, Earth pony's as bearers of LATENT Magic pertaining to their innate talents. Had Applejack been exposed to discord's magic instead, I'm inclined to believe we would have gotten the Pony equivalent of the incredible HULK.
Pegasi are a similar case. Alongside their magic flank symbols, THEY gain not "Magic" per say but SUPERPOWERS. Every Pegasi, if trained, gains SOME capacity to manipulate the weather for example. Then there's the special cases! Fluttershy doesn't manipulate the weather but is instead an ANIMAL WHISPERER and can be seen in THAT way as "influencing nature"! Rainbow Dash is a speedster and can go faster than sound with the Sonic rainboom. Elements of Harmony AREN'T a necessity to gain powers like these EITHER it would seem. Rainbow Dash AND Derpy Hooves, a commoner Pegasi, have been shown to have the power of HEAT VISION! THEN we have Cozy Glow...SEEMINGLY a Pegasus...gaining the ability to harness PRIMARY Pony Magic and gaining a HORN!
The Cutie Marks say it all. They are evidence of Magic in not just Unicorns but ALL Pony Kind. THAT's why Starlight Glimmer, A MASTER of Pony Magic, was able to control the people of her village through her Cutie Mark "nixing equity spell". If Pinkie Pie's case WERE so special, it would have ONLY worked on other Unicorns, NOT Pegasi and Earth Pony's. Friendship is Magic for NOT just Unicorns, but ALL Equine tribes afterall. How they GET that Magic is the REAL trick! But that's My theory. What do you think?
i think that pinkie pie is just that fun character to break all known rules. she's just being pinkie pie. plus if pinkie got chaos magic from the bell in her blood then why does her sister Maud have a Maud sense? that just doesn't add up. no i believe that Pinkie inherited her magic.
I dont know if this was before or after EQG but, this might solve mlp Pinkie Pie, but it doesn't solve EQG pinkie pie, since she's just as hyper and un-logical as mlp pinkie pie, an example would be a brief moment in eqg friendship games where she teleported everywhere in the hallway, so, if that pinkie pie could do it without taking in the magic of the bell, I don't think that solves mlps pinkie pie since there was no magical bell in that world
Hey, in the episode 'one where pinkie knows' at the end we see pinkie pie break into pieces... literally in pieces as in pieces. And we know just one being that can do that. Our dear Discord
i think, that pinkie pie, and human pinkie pie are two, but also the same. i know it sounds confusing, but what if theyre both using the portal, and they knew about, longer than twilight? that would explain the ,,i know everything about everyone" things
pinkie was only able to control discords magic bc she already had chaos magic in her all earthponies still have magical abilities connected to their special talent
Maybe it's part of her cutie mark magic Maybe when she got her cutie mark It gave her Some Help To throw a party Like being able to Pull up party canon out of thin air
Okay so, I love this theory but I am not very sure about pinkie sense, we have seen other kinds of sense like pinkie's, Maud sense in the Psstd and cheesy sense too. so if I donnt include pinkie sense then I love this theory!!
Here’s my theory: Pinkie Pie absorbed Discord’s chaos magic, found out she could do the stuff she does even after the Magic was taken from her, traveled back in time, so she could do all that stuff when she was a baby, filly, and even a teen.
I know why they stare into existance as if somebody watches them, if you look at pinkie pie on Netflix or YouTube you can tell she is talking to you or to twilight sparkle as in magic duel she muffles for her mouth to come back and kinda stares at you and gasps and the video ends on Netflix, but what if the case was pinkie pie did get the chaos magic and it did spread through timelines, family, and also cheese sandwich since in the future had a wedding with Pinkie pie, but I think since pinkie was full of joy and fun, it turned into JOY MAGIC.... This still means chaos magic, but discord hasn't appeared in the black asking for something like how pinkie did, yeah maybe the pinkie sense is half chaos magic but danger sense magic for some reason because pinkie pie keeps herself safe by using pinkie sense, so pinkie pie isn't an earth pony practically because she has joy magic and danger sense magic but she was just classically what the future earth ponies are with magic now but pinkie was the first to gain this so did cheese, maud, but this proves my point that this is danger and joy magic but one more thing to say the teleporting, breaking the fourth wall, and pulling stuff out of existance, coming out of the show at the end and all of that is strange, yeah we can explain twilight but not pinkie.
I think your theory is part right? Maybe Pinkie didn't return all of the magic, maybe a fraction is left behind! But changing the past is something I'm gonna think about.
Apart from the ruler of The crystal empire Twilight wasn’t the first Alicorn Remember that episode where in clouds well Rainbow Dash Need extra support But flatter shy was too quiet TwilightTurned Rarat In to an alicorn Before she was turned
So few years ago before season 9 was aired I actually had a theory that Pinkie Pie was part darconequus! But not in the way that you explained it actually it that somewhere back in Pinkie Pie's family tree There Was a darconequus Like way way back in her family tree and somehow the genetics only came back to her and no one else in her immediate family it's pretty far-fetched but I still think it's a pretty good theory. Ps I love your Channel! <3
i think ur right that also explains why pinkie pie had the chaos lightning when she absorbed discord's magic and cozy glow didn't have the lightning when she absoebed the chaos magic
I think pinkie somehow allways had that Power, because when ponies have full energy/magic they become alicorns, but pinkie did not, so maybe shes more powerfull then we think!
Electric Heart that has not been proven. We just have never heard of one becoming an alicorn. If pegasus and unicorns can become alicorns why not earth? One day in the future an earth pony might become an alicorn.
The reason pinkie pie knew what was happening in the human world and other in the pony is because they been switching places. Evidence just watch the bloopers
Mario Torres2020-12-07 01:38:18 (edited 2020-12-08 06:36:47 )
I have a theory : Before Discord have a little sister but he never meet her. Their parents die when discord is already transform in stone. So they put Pinkie Pie in Foster Home, thats why Pinkie Pie have chaotic power.
maybe because discord is behind so many other events he knowingly left a piece of magic behind in pinkie pie whereas the others took all of the chaos magic back from cozy glow
According to me there must be something in the rainboom that did this or else why did discord's bell not affect pinkie's childhood before she got her cutie mark. She wasn't like that when she was at the rock farm before she got her cutie mark. It just doesn't add up.
0 likes
Art Ur2022-11-26 17:41:54 (edited 2022-11-26 17:44:30 )
I think Pinkie have most of her's powers from rainboom. When rainboom happened her mane changed. We all know that magic can be connected with magic.
well the pinkie sense probably wouldn't have anything to do with this, even if your theory was right. Maud also has a sense, and pinkie says it runs in the family so
Maybe the reason discord’s magic didn’t have an effect on cozy glow is because she is an alacorn and has the means to hold all that power while pinkie doesn’t since she is just an earth pony. Like so sawtooth can see this.
I've had the theory for a while that pinkie is somewhat evil because of the way she acts sometimes. The best way I think I can explain is if you rewatch the series with the perspective that she's a villain hiding in plain sight you'll see clues that point to her wanting to affect others in a negative way and getting joy from it. Kind of similar to a much more convincing cozy glow that acts sweet but sometimes her evil slips through. I haven't seen anyone talk about it (besides non canon creepypastas or stories).
I mean maybe, I think shes more of a Chaotic Hero Shes more of a balance of good and evil doing both at once, it makes her happy to see other people happy. She did make friends with the entire town of ponyville and got so confused when One person didn't want to be friends with her and didn't enjoy her joyful craziness.
Ofc you have a point but all I want to know is, what would pinky be if she didn’t grab the bell and how did she get to the point of grabbing the bell and how
Sure, that explains pony Pinkie. But what about Canterlot High Pinkie Pie? How did she get so...um...enthusiastic in the human world? Maybe it had something to do with Discord? I mean, he was about to send Tree Hugger to OUR REALM! it must be possible for him to open a portal to the human world, right? And, if you think about it, we haven’t seen anything of the Canterlot High girls since the season 9 epilogue. What if the same thing happened to the E.G. Pinkie Pie? It would have probably gone down something like this. Discord decides to go the the human world, (probably because he was board) and does something that causes the girls to “Pony Up” and take care of Discord’s boredom. Discord sees potential in Pinkie, and gives her some of his magic. But then takes it back, and like Sawtooth said, that one moment effected her entire timeline.
i think maybe pinkie was born as a unicorn, let me explain. in the episode where pinkie and applejack found out they maybe are cousins they told us the family was really really big! maybe there was a unicorn far away in their family like by pound cake and pumpkin cake. Maybe pinkies parents parents wanted her to be a earthpony like the rest of the family. Unicorns can get wings, but can they also maybe lose there horns? maybe pinkies parents took her to princess Celestia and asked her to make her a earthpony! But i dont think u can loose being a unicorn completely away so she still had a little of her magic but not in her horn, the magic is inside her! I think there also is one other way: Pinkie pie maybe isn't a pie! i mean she doesnt look a little bit like the rest of her family! Her birthparents maybe didn't want her and removed her horn with hulp of Celestia and then gave her to the pies!
i think it's true because her coat and mane aren't even a vibrant pink, you can see when she gets depressed, her coat goes to her natural colour, a greyish pink, or just gray, like her sisters, and she used her magic to make her hair fluffy and hair and coat pink. when she's depressed, she doesn't use her chaos magic at ALL and that's why her hair is long, straight, and grey, that's my take on it!!
Hi Sawtooth Waves I kind of have 2 small theories that Pinkie is Adopted! If U Notice the Pie's All have the grey shade except pinkie ..... Except Pinkie nopony else in the family is like her. Even tho Marble and Pinkie are twins, I just had this theories. Thank U
I think pinkie and discord have the same magic because both of them have a sense in which they can predict the future.this is my example: In the episode twillight's kingdom tirek was stealing magic in canterlot and dicord began to shake as if he sensed something like pinkie. in an episode(i do not know name)pinkie began to shake like discord They both share the magic of sensing what will happen in the next few minutes
I think pinkie pie secretly has wings in a horn Somewhere in her main And it might be true And Around super fast and pulls out a canon out Out of nowhere
Wait y'know how u made a vid on the end of the next gen movie on how the earth pony left magical hoof prints? Maybe pinkie's "pinky sense" has something to do with it?
Re Cosy and pinkie reacting differently to the extraction of the chaos. Discord did the extraction on Pinky and it would just be like him to leave just a little for shits and giggles :)
If u watch the episode *Pinkie Keen* and the episode *Pinkie Pride* u will see there is no difference between them so..... As u solved *Pinkie Pie* u should also solve *Cheese Sandwich* .....
I’m guessing that cozy glow was a little pony and her age might’ve made it so that she wouldn’t have powers forever or it’s just because of pinkie sence
Ok. Im VERY late in commenting but... that theory could actually be correct!
Here's my reason: ok so you said that it needed something to do with past and future. Pinkie pie had pinkie sense, but cozy glow doesnt have such a thing! Though they got it the same way, If cozy was lacking the sense similar to pinkie, she could never been chaotic. another thing to back this theory up: Her DESTINY, she's destined to be wacky, goofy, and just so different. Maybe-JUST MAYBE, thid means pinkie sense would still be unsolved if it wasnt part of the chaos magic thing, think about it, Maybe pinkie pie was born with that kinda sense bc her whole fam had it! And then she got chaos magic then the magic just spreads to her entire lifetime. Who knows...maybe she also got discord's immortality, i mean, it is CHAOS magic so maybe theres also other parts of the magic that just doesnt follow normal magic rules.
I 110% like the idea of this one e moment causing pinkie to be ya-know pinkie, but I have an idea of why cozyglow wasn't effected the same way (go to reply for that because I need to take a nap and it's really early in the morning)
When she got her curly mane and tail by the Rainboom, some random bug got into it and the bug had crazy magic which was Pinkie’s magic but it transferred over to Pinkie so now she is crazy
Yeah and showed up in deferent media like as a alicorn during the final battle in the transformers bumblebee movie during a ridiculous boss fight in batman arkhamknight and finally the last evidence is recent were she inside the zero point when it about to blow
Ok I think k this is the video where you say pinkies discord magic got spread throughout the timeline. But cheese sandwich also has a pinkie sense of sorts. That’s how he knows to go to pony color next for a party. So maybe they just have party magic or something. Her magic things are usually visual gags
No pinkie is discords half sister and her "parents" adopted her living in a rock farm claiming to be her parents then pinkie moved out in a young age that made her crazy self she is
What? She was not adopted, it is stated in Hearthbreakers that she is the twin sister of Marble Pie, although they don’t look alike so she was not adopted
When Pinkie took discords power she was able to control the chaos magic/power, but look what happened when cozy took discords power.. She wasn't able to control his Magic..this is why cozy isn't like pinkie.
I don't know if it makes scene, but it makes scence😅🤷♀️
I can't agree with you. It doesn't make any sense. You can say: It's Pinkie we're talking about, but hold It right there. It doesn't make sense even if it involves Pinkie. If it IS true then we'd had to have a timeline where is Pinkie normal . But without Pinkie, her welcoming party for Twilight And her craziness She couldn't be the element of laughter And therefore She couldn't get the mane 6 together. That's just my oppinion, i'm not saying that this is a bad theory or something
In the gift of Maud Pie Muad also has pinky Sence or Maud Sence and only said it ran in the family maybe the chaos magic went further and in to the pie family and not the apples because the apples are another huge tree connected to the pie tree so only the pies where infected with chaos magic
I just saw something interesting that I just now noticed do you not have Pegasus patrons because you show off the earth ponies the unicorns and the Alcorns but not the Pegasus do you not have Pegasus patrons? Just curious
On the gift of the maud pie Pinkie said that sense runs into their family even her sister has one Pinkie sense=danger Maud sense=finding some pony/someone
but did cozzy use her powers when she got them temporaily from discord? pinkie went full blown change everything. while i dont think cozzy did anything rly.
Actually you kind of wrong she could use chaos msigc caused she used in the past before in the comics, and to use chaos msigc you have to understand that what ever pops into your mind comes out There are certain rules to the chaos dimensions and magic that why pinke pie could use discord msigc bescude she used it before he said to the mane five and spike most poines alone in his dimseon would be driven mad but this is pinke pie she might be right at home and in the comics he makes a nod that he doesn't understand pinke pie
Must say, the knowledge Pinkie Pie knows from another dimension is from a deleted scene. Watch the equestria girls deleted scenes of Pinkie and Pinkie going in and out from the portaI.
hi I am moonlight sparkle, I think pinkie is an unicorn and she has some hyper magic , she can teleport into different places and I think pinkie has visit to the human world before twilight .the reason pinkie is not a pegasus pony because rainbow dash is the first pony whom pulled of a sonic rainboom
pinkie and discord have a similar crazy personality, cozy does not. chaos magic has been seen to act with a mind of its own somewhat, mabey it chooses based off of who it likes more?
I have a crazy theory, you had posted a video about how scootaloo can't fly and how Sunny has astral wings, right? So maybe, just maybe, Pinkie Pie is actually an Alicorn. And, you forgot about somepony, Cheese Sandwich. How can you explain him!? He has a cheesy sense ,too. He may be an Alicorn without wings and a horn, too.
1. I already don't like the events during the "present" affecting the past 2. The Magic returning to Pinkie could be just an animation choice, Pinkie is the 3rd most "magical" of the group naturally so she would get it, or it could just be the drew straws and she was up. This is your best point though. 3. The Pinkie Sense isn't evidence that a part of her is connected to a different time. It's like if I predicted the winner in a sports match, you wouldn't say that I have a part of me connected to the future, I'd just be lucky. Also if Pinkie really had a part connected to the future where has it been when they could actually use it. 4. PINKIE IS JUST PINKIE
Maybe because it was pinkie who had absorbed the chaos magic then, and not being able to contain all of the magic within her vessel some was released and wandered existence finding the first sonic rainboom which may have acted as a beacon attracting the extra chaos magic wandering through existance and entered pinkie pie
But maybe solving villains like I may have a reason why Chrysalis fooled everypony by being Cadence so Chrysalis was a pretty alicorn and the day she saw Shinning armour she fell in love with him but Shinning armour did not take intrest in her he took his love and respect to Cadence and Chrysalis was heartbroken so when it consumed her with sadness and Anger she became Evil and thought of her plan to trap Cadence and Deytsroy her something so she became Cadence's form trapped her and Twilight in the Caves Under Canterlot Then beated of shinning armours love for Cadence and then Celestia wanted a Fight To Protect Every Pony but she failed Chrysalis hat Beaten to much love and then she was to and so OP and then Shinning armour's protection spell wore off while Celestia was on the ground with the tip of her horn black That's why Chrysalis wanted to take over Equestria Buy Chrysali's return is sure to happen would she battle all four Princesses? And take their magic and Deytsroy Equestria? She may do it? Or will she beat Luna and Celestia's love next? With Cadence and Twilight too? Just Sayin she may do it dare it Evil it the only way to reform her to her true self is hard mystery her changeling new form may be the only thing witch works like maybe we must reform her like the other Changelings and Find a sort of spell or crystal and make her her True Pony Self my thought Sawtooth !
Actually it is not discord power because the episode was after Twilight figured out Pinkie pie has pinky sense so it must’ve done something with The element of harmony ,she laughs a lot and also a cutie mark
S5 E8 pinkie might be conected to ones whom have and still are in stone so maby discord hade a bit of that stone magic in him so it got into grogars bell and pinkie got his magic so she can talk to ones in stone and the last episode in S9 discord helps put them in stone and pinkie talked to the last grifin kings stachue and maby it WAS HIM in stone and at the end his eye shimered or glowed
Sawtooth waves I kind of know something about Twilight and the royal family and the main 6When twilight was big and she had a floating man She had it 2Baby unicorns she just Married a orange pegasus With blue Up line hair and blue eyes and twilight had 2 baby unicorns They were orange orange oranges Purple or blue Well it's Purple and When the baby unicorns grow up both of them were alicorns Cause 1 Of the unicorn twins was older and the other 1 was younger the big 1 had Big legs when she was a grown up like her mom and she had a horn and wings she And Her sister was also an alcorn Well a little Younger And They both have the same Cutie mark With the star well They have the same star on the cutie mark but they're different cause their mom represents the elements of magic and she has it on the Crown her crown And When2 of Her kids1 had a Crown and 1 had a necklace With A Gem Or A. Element Cause I saw a video okay I saw The Royal families flurry heart had a Sister and it was a pegasus and If they're not born At the same time They are still sisters And Guess what something hilarious happened Princess celestia married discord and they had it Chaos baby's And Discord also married Fluttershy It was actually out of my mind and Princess Luna Marry A unicorn it was like king sombra but good A black and blue Lineed Maine and Red eyes it look like king sombra
You make a compelling argument, but I wouldn’t be me if I didn’t counter it what you’re saying can’t be true, because in a gift for mud pie, pinkie says that the pinky sense or pie sense runs in the family
Sawtooth Wave s Guess what a bad record recorded the new episode of sunny star scout I think it has been her mother all along Well you'll see in the last part So make A video about it Well There is a bad Unicorn with wings Eyelashe's was green and The bad unicorn with wings said I will take what's mine that's what the bad out corn said so Figure it out
I always saw pinkie pie being pinkie pie when she did unexplainable things, but oh boy when she said “hey discord!” when discord was hiding that even he got surprised and made a wtf face. I was like hold up pinkie pie what are you?? A secret pony goddess wtf
This pinky has chaos magic theory might also explain why when Discord was freed the first time and it started raining chocolate and stuff Pinky loved it but that could have just been classic Pinkypie
If Pinkie Pie did have her magic stretched out through her timeline, it would explain why Cozy Glow became an alicorn for taking all of the magic at once while Pinkie didn't.
When Cozy Glow was transformed, she begin an Alicorn, but when Pinkie Pie absorbed caos, she remain a Pony. Also, pinkie pie is how discord, they have the same though and powers. Favourite element of harmonybof discord is laugh.
It's pretty obvious that pinkie pie is the most op earth pony there is. People are missing the fact how pinkie pie was able to control discord's magic even when cozy glow, tirek and chrysalis couldn't.
So she couldn't use inponie abilitys and she was normal through out the whole series, but when she absorbed that magic,not change the past so pinkie in the past was able to do crazy things???? Idk if I understand
Now I feel like someones watching ME Bc I hear noises evey night, now im terrified
0 likes
Lord Kairos2021-06-05 22:55:37 (edited 2021-06-05 22:56:00 )
discord is a creature made of pure chaos what if the reason why he can control his magic is his chaotic personality because when he tries to act normal he begins to lose his ability to use his magic and begins to fade, is thanks to fluttershy that acts in a chaotic way that discord can recover thanks to the small chaos that fluttershy made and if we apply that same logic to a being that is even a little chaotic and it takes discords magic that could make possible to that being to control discord s chaotic magic and taking the magic of discord this could make it possible for that being to be able to control the chaotic magic of discord and if equestria has the same origin as our world that could explain why pink pie is able to do things that defy logic because the moment she takes the magical abilities of discord it became a paradox in which the versions of pink pie that we know they are able to do things that ignore logic in their entirety and by this pink pie made her own future becouse that makes her be her and pink pie didnt show up that kind of abillites until rainbow dash performs sonic rainboom that pink pie was able to use unconsciously a little bit of discord chaotic magic
I love that this dude used the warhammer chaos star as a representation of discords magic. That makes me want to go back and reread one of those Warhammer fortythousand x My Little Pony Friendship is Magic crossovers.
I don’t really know how to explain it but in a summer sun setback discord literally pulls up the fabric of their reality and stuffs a storm cloud in there soooooooooooo
you know that pinkie pie is a special erath pony she is part of a dracon and her mom is a earth pony but her dad is a dracon her mom name is triple berry pie and her dad name is rhubarb
They both do that thing where they stand up in space like someone’s watching iS sOmEoNe WaChInG mE!? Me:yEs We AlL r! Also I noticed everyone who absorbs the chaos magic gets BIG!!and it’s weird that pinky got magic!
I don't actually agree on this theory as in the episode in season six the gift for maud pie even maud will get the maud sense that doesn't actually mean that even maud had the chaotic power
Or pinky pies element is humor. And humorous logic from a cartoon viewpoint! That’s why she talked to “audience” through the screen or when she notices or when someone notices she did something wierd all of a sudden it stops. Like Tom and jerry the car run on the sky then notices it’s defied gravity and falls. Pinky has her own powers from the power of friendship which is cartoon humor!
BUT WAIT,you said pinkie sense is part of her ‘powers’, but in The Gift Of Maud Pie, Maud says their ‘senses ‘ run in the family when she was looking for the pony Pinkie traded her cannon with... so it’s family thing! Just me? Welp.
Maud had the same, but it is different depending on the Pony. I think I recall that being Cheezy sense and Maud sense respectively. Just too bad we never see another unrelated case, though.
Discord has reality bending powers over all universes since discord him self is a embodiment of chaos in the mlp wold being able to do anything and well pinkie has well 4wall powers which means she could just do anything knowing that she a cartoon being able to what ever she whats btw I think 4wall powers and chaos powers are different is a different think initially
When pinkie got her magic back she does'nt have magic its just her cutie mark in that episode every pony had no cutie mark and when pinkie pie got her magic returned to her it was her cutie mark and get her colors back and if she does'nt get that magic back she will be super slow and does'nt blend in to other ponys
“When you’re rife with devastation, there’s a simple explanation; you’re a toy makers creation trapped inside a crystal ball. And whichever way he tilts it, know that we must be resilient. We won’t let them break our spirits as we sing our silly song!”
"when I was a little filly a galloping blaze overtook my city! So they shipped me off to the orphanage said 'ditch those roots if you wanna fit in' so I dug one thousand holes and cut a rug with orphan foals-"
I noticed that when rarity and Twilight have there Magic back, maybe pinkie pie has a secret magic and the weirdest thing is when she jumped in the water she like slowy dont splash, maybe she has a gravity magic
I know why cozy wasn’t effected by the chaos magic it’s because she didn’t want it think about she wanted it taken away but pinkie didn’t she wanted to keep it
But wait, if that magic spread through Pinkie’s entire timeline, then that means that she absorbed the magic twice within her lifetime. Once when the future pinkie did it, and the second time when the actual present pinkie did it.
Yes all of us are watching you everyone on YouTube is watching you... how did it take that long to figure it out?! And you remind me of someone but I don't know who.
She can fly but has convinced herself that she can't. Her magic obeys her will. It's much like how if someone truly thinks they're blind, they won't see no matter how healthy their eyes really are. When she gives up the lie, then she will fly.
She can't fly. It's most likely a physical issue, not a magic issue. We see that she can hover, but only when highly excited. Her magic works like normal otherwise: walking on and manipulating clouds like any other pegasus. If her issue were magic based, she would not be able to do that either. When she becomes an adult, her wings don't grow in proportion to the rest of her. This detail leads me too believe that, for whatever reason, her wings are stunted and that's why she can't fly. Maybe it's genetic, or the result of an accident, or some unknown disease.
@J. C. We can that regardless of the way the wings develope that a pegasus can fly regardless of their shape. Look at Bulk Biceps. There is no way according to the laws of physics he can fly but not only does he fly, he's able to contribute to the creation of a tornado. This proves it is the magic from within making this possible. The wings act as a foci much like a wand or an incantation does for a hermetic mage. Also there's no way RD can reach the speeds that she does through the laws of physics. She does this through magic and I would say she has a lot of it. I wonder if she'll develop the infinite hoof punch like the Flash?
But if something is wrong with a wand, if it's broken or damaged in some way, then it won't cast magic like normal. I believe the same principle applies to wings in my little pony. Bulk Biceps can fly with magic because his wings aren't stunted, they only look that way. Presumably before he got so buff, his wings were normal.
It's just not believable that Scootaloo not believing she can fly would actually effect her ability to do so. Pegasi can fly as babies, so we know it's not an age thing. Scootaloo, were she able to fly, would've been doing so since before she could remember. There is simply no way a school aged pegasus would believe themselves unable to fly without some kind of evidence. If she was born like that, she's probably tried multiple times before going to a doctor and learning she can't fly. If it's the result of an accident, she may remember a time when she could fly, and if she was in denial, she'd keep trying to fly before learning she really couldn't anymore.
Plus, we have evidence that she believed she could fly. In flight to the finish.
Chessking E4 She can’t fly cause her wing aren’t stronger and don’t grow like they have to grow I think that why she don’t live in cloudstale or go whit her parents
Cloudstale: Because she couldn’t fly to get there Go whit her parents: Because they are constantly in danger and they fly if scottalo go whit they she could probably die
Look like pinkie pie and discord really have a connection. When pinkie pie absorbed discord's magic there's a lighting thing around her which cozy glow didn't have, like cozy glow absorbed the magic but didn't connect to her but when pinkie pie absorbed the magic it really connected into her.
Pinkie does has some type of power cuz when we see her in the future see is still the same pinkie where the other ponies have changed like rarity have some white strapes on her tail and hair and all the others changed and were not that hygenic where pinkie still was soooooooooooooo happy excited its like she did not grow at allllll and when we see her on the movie where twillight loses her crown the human pinkie knows everything and when twillight comes back the "PONY" pinkie knew everything from the human world the human pinkie and the pony pinkie have some type of connection and both of them have some connection with the past and future too.
That explains everything about her but she came from a family with grayish color and she is pink so I don’t understand why she is the only person in her family that is pink and the rest is grayish it might have to do with something with the magic she might have.
I think pinkie got her powers from the rainboom because everyone did twilight got very powerful,rainbow dash got speed powers,rarity got her diamond powers,apple jack got strength and fluttershy got speaking to animals power so pinkie got pinkie powers
I support your thinking but in the episode ticket master when they get the tickets at the end the tikets float over their heads but not for spike can you make a video about that please.
Hi i'm milka. The first time i see this video, i was shock. I agree about this pinkie pie sense, but i think pinkie pie sort way back discord magic. Thats just my theori about pinkie pie and discord magic.
Kinda late and u probably won’t see this but if I remember correctly during a episode maud shows that she has her own maud sense proving that this theory couldn’t be possible
I personaly dont agree buts its a great theory. my theory is that there is soe type of chaos like discord inside her, that she was just born with like discord. she has some of the same powers. :3
0 likes
Sophie Noob2021-03-30 20:16:57 (edited 2021-03-30 20:17:40 )
I know this took a lot of effort but what about when pinkie pie traded her party cannon and mod found the pony and rarity asked how she found him she said "mod scenes" pinkie said it runs in the faimly
You may have noticed already bur im gonna say it anyways, 1:31 , true but in the episode where spike becomes greedy and its his birthday (i think its season 2? Idk), he and rarity was floating in mid air! 1:49 , in the episode mare do well, rainbow dash winked at us, knowing we r there. 2:18, maybe its a mistake? I honestly think pegasus and earth ponies should have that thing too. Pinkie sense is prob a genes (or what ever) from the family. Im saying that pinkie pie is prob made like that to show humor and extra ordinary/exaggeration from what you can do irl. Honestly, if i was a creator of a series, i could make many mistakes. Sometimes i forgot what happened to the characters i created! Its just an opinion btw! Thanks for reading!
Pinkie is completely weird by herself.First,her family not so energetic like Pinkie.Kinda negative and spends time with stones.Why did Pinkie didn't spend time with stone?Just a rainbow can't change her.Also her family generally have faded colors.Except for Pinkie.She is pink.Her hair goes fluffy when she's happy when she's sad her hair go straight.I think she was having a little power maybe when born.But we can't know more.Why she was having power when born,not another pony?Can we say why Fluttershy can communicate with plants and animals but not another pony.What caused Pinkie to have powers?Maybe something happened,so much positive energy uploaded in Pinkie?Maybe...But I think Pinkie's power get crazier when she take discords all power.
Three actually a comic that pinke pie fall into the chaos world and was able to control and to be honest cesltia seems a little bit too friendly with discrord she likes exvtiment and to be honest I mean discrord wasn't that evil he didn't want to kill anyone even in his first appearance twkigt said he didn't play fair but he did and what would be more chaotic then controlling chaos its self and useig it for a force for good
It's a family thing, I think perhaps Pinkie Sense was a family thing BUT maybe it was amplified to a more adavanced version of Pinkie Sense with Discord's magic. My theory, if you have your own comment it.
I love your YouTube channel I love your theories but some of your theory for Philly some people think that Pinkie Pie is actually a changeling working for Christmas to take down the others but would that be true no
Pink and green colours for the hair and a lot 😍on her hair and the second 😍💖✨her eyes 👀the first of her 😍and the first interview went well I think she is fine 🙂I hope it goes OK 👌I will share it with her 😊she will reveal 😊her back to me with the best possible outcome 😊☺💖and I will call 📞tomorrow to arrange for them 😊...
Ok so I have an idea what if it was because when pinkie got the magic taken away from her it was discord who took it who his of course the owner of his own magic bug when it was taken away from cosy glow it wasn't taken away by the original owner,discord,or I'm just wrong and it has nothing to do that also discord did take his magic back after he got it back from pinkie maybe that also affects it
You know how when cozy glow took away all the magic and star swirl said that all to magic be be gone for good after the 3rd sun set? But doesn't celestia raise and set the sun then she could of just not set the sun until the figured out a way to fix if
Pinkie has chaos magic you are right. Or else when twilight sparklers got the crown from the other world how could pinkie know the both pinkie in the 2 worlds have chaos.
There is one problem, in a episode with mod she says she says she has mod sense and it runs in the family maybe it’s something to do with when pinky was not born yet I don’t know what do you think
Cozy Glow when got discord power. She didn't use the power but when pinky got it ,she use the power to make chocolate rain. That's what different I think..
I mean..cozy glow couldn't control it while pinkie could. The fact that she is chaotic already before the magic hit her is a point that I think breaks that theory. But I'm just a kid so what do I know?
I think she got her esence from chaos magic cause she was an earth pony and earth ponys arent as magical as pegasi and before u say pegasi dont have magic they kinda do cause there flying ability’s can be removed so they have some sort of magic so since pegasi have more magic than earth ponies cozyglow was able to handle the magic more than pinky
PLS READ THIS!!!!! This theory could be possible but what about the human world? There is no chaos magic that I know of in the human world. I think it is just pinkie. For example, maybe she is just way smarter than the rest since she can tell that someone is watching. For her pinkie sense, Celestia has a similar system but just you can't see it. For example, Pinkie Pie's tail wiggles when something is going to fall. Celestia just feels it like how she felt that Luna would come back soon. For Pinkie's magic, I think the magic was her pinkie sense or maybe her craziness. And One more fact, Mood, Pinkie pie’s sister has mood sense too.
Now for my theory... I think pinkie should be an alicorn since she is like the element of happiness or laughter maybe she should be the princess of happiness since that is a relationship-ish. maybe she could spread happiness. Pinkie should also be an alicorn because she would be the first earth pony to be an alicorn.
Yes I think it's also weird but I don't think it's from discords Magic do you remember the episode when she went crazy cuz she thought her friends didn't like her anymore and you saw those split colors due
If pinkie took all that magic and it spread why didn’t cozy have this energy and btw pinkie pie was able to control the magic so it must be something else
Maybe pinky got those powers because she is an earth pony. Did you ever hear a earth pony becoming an alicorn? Cozy Glow may have become what she was because she's a Pegasus.
Pinkie actually fell into discrord World after tirek stole his power and he got IT bsbk he was having ttihlne useing his power and pinke found her way into his dimseon and figured out the rules of chaos chaos magic actually has very specific rules and rewuere conctrstin
Did you know that in MY little pony equestria girls at the end of one of the movies pinkie pie switched places with the pony pinkie pie so there could be something that pinkie pie already new about the portal to equestria high before twilight did
I think i know how she got her powers she got it from the rainbow we she was a kid / filly she was not her crazy self but when she saw the rainbow some thing happened she gang happiness she also ganged power what kind you ask chaos thats why she has pinkie sense she could she the future that's her power seeing the future that's why she wants to spread Joy she wants to share her power but how how did one rainbow give her power discord now here me out think about it discord is the king of chaos pinkie is chaos could there be a connection between them?? You tell me do you think i am right ?
Hi Sawtooth Waves my name is Olympia and I really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really like your videos I watch finally solving pinkie pie and How discord came to be and Flurry Hearts future and the truth about stars Swirl and finally solving alicorns and how king Sombra lost his wings will for little bit of that It was a littleToo Scary because of the music for how king sombra lost his wings I also watched Finally solving delacour The alicorn ambulance And it was so much fun and Queen chrysalis and Not a true Alcorn And How did the trail of harmony Really really died And Are there other Alicorns and did celestia release Nightmare moon And I am already watching finally solving pinkie pie right now and I'm at The white and blue swirling eyes part And I Am With the silly bird And your videos are getting a lot funnier Make sure to bring more new videos and I will watch them see you
but that was before pinky absorbed discord 's magic that was in the end and that you showed was only in like the school of friendship and not close to the end end
What episodes at 1:44 is he talking about? I’m binging my little pony: friendship is magic for the 20th time and I don’t know what episodes he is talking about
I thing pinkie absorbing discords magic in future is the cause for her cutie mark and her enthusiasm. Because pinkie is totally different from her family. When pinkie was a filly 8n her family there was no talking and no smiling and all of a sudden she became a party pony.
I love pinkie, separate thing: I saw a video saying "Chaotic and spontaneous things you can do to be spontaneous" I watched the video and went "non of that's spontaneous, I already do all that without thinking anything of it."
no i dont think it the magic because this magic come after a long time and the powers of pinkie or crazyness started when the show started so i do not think it is the magic
Not really. Remember Season 8 Yakity-Sax? She turned into Pinkamena but she somehow has a weird power to make plants magically die, or make balloons deflate. Is that magic or what?
Laughter doesn't only exists in Pinkie, they can be inside of everyone. If you're only the representative of it then why should you have magic but the others don't?
Maby its conected to her family if celestia can give her magic to twilight for ruling pinkies father also can look at him he weres a cap maby he is a unicorn and gave some of his magic to his daughter 🤣+🤪+🙃+😪=pinky pie
What if pinkie got the powers before the show began that would explain why the magic came back and more importantly pinkie was able to use discord’s magic wich would not make sense otherwise
a moment of chaos pure power distrubuted along her. and pinkies the sort like meand you, she wouldnt say it was a problem or abnormal she would litterally live and work with theses powers
Have u ever nosied the birth of a pony is always lighter then the parents like star lights parents flerry heart that piney who is yellow and likes books that I forgot the name of please do a video on this :p
But how did pinkie pie control the power not like cozy here’s my theory she already had caos like discord when she got her cutie mark so more of that caos magic will be ok that’s why cozy could not control caos magic like pinkie oh and did you notice cozy became a giant alicorn while pinkie didn’t well i think caos magic makes the user bigger in size but discord is like a container of the magic so he doesn’t get bigger in size
Sawtooth waves: pinky and discord do the same thing like when they stare off to space Like someone is watching them…… is someone watching me!?! Me: yeah all your subscribers and probably other people who don’t subscribe and me so yes there’s probably tons of people watching you. Lol I found that funny!
Why is None Talking about that Pinkie is pink and the rest of her family is grey? Im getting a Felling that Shes adopted...please talk about this in a video
If that was the case then why did Pinkie Pie say Pinkie Pie scenes and Maude said it was mod sense pinky said it ran in the family then how does that logic work
@May-Nimari bruh. What if the "first" is too much on the first second? Im sure youtuber can detect the first coment using something because "first" never be 1 coment
You miss a clue when sunset shimmer touched pinkie and saw what was inside her head and If you don't know who sunset shimmer is she is in equestria girls
I think it has to be a connection with Pinkie pie’s cutie mark and laughter element of harmony so pinkie Love balloons and her cutie mark is balloons and The element has powers she is the spirit of laughter so she has Pinkie sense because ,in my little pony a new generation there is three crystals earth pony Crystal , The Pegasus crystal and the unicorn crystal so just because earth ponies don’t have the magic and can’t fly they do have a power and the only earth pony has a power is Pinkie pie
In the episode where Pinkie Pie goes to Manhattan Mod says the she has Mod sense and it runs in the family. However pinkie pie has more than just pinkie sense.
She didt because in the season where everyone gets there magic back from cozy globe she been haveing magic ether or with out her elemant or discords magic first came cozyglobe stealing magic and pinkie pie gets her magic back then she got discords magic when kingsobra broke the elemants of harmeny pinkie pie lost her happy power and when her friends said chear us up because they were sad of the elemants of harmeny she says sorry i cant feel it there is nothing funny about these sorry and you mite not know these but in every ipisode love happyness abd hate magic can go to diferent universes and know alat about every ones lives thats all i got
The difference between pinkie and cozy is cozy was an alicorn when she got the caos magic and pinkie was and earth pony I guess earth pony’s have magic to
Hi Sawtooth Waves I was too busy yesterday to text you So I'm doing it now And I really really really really really really like finally solving pinkie pie is there 1 that is called Finally solving twilight or fluttershy or Rainbow —dash or Applejack Well I don't know If there we are not there or not Cause I think that So what are you doing thinking Videos of something cause I don't know when They are going to come i Really really really Want new videos To come now I cannot Just watch the same ones All over and over again cause I just watched 1 video and I Don't know what it wasDon't know what it was calledDon't know what it was called But it was 1 of your Videos and It will come Next friday It already past The next friday And your videos are super duper very very very very very really really really really really really really really really Fun well When I was watching How King sombra lost his wings I was scared of it because of the music and the red circling And it happened In the alcorn Ambulance video I also watched twilight killed the real pinky it was like hilarious cause I just watched it in my mom's room on the TV We were trying to find relaxing fish music but then when we were trying to find it my sister said All of your My little pony videos that I watched And we watched The future of flurry heart and Twilight killed the real pinky It was totally hilarious Cause when we were about to click it to watch it twilight zapped the real pinky and she was like a big circle and it was super hilarious Here is a joke what do you call twilight eating a pie? Cause she went to the Lamp drum Ticket Lamp drum tickets all in 1 word It's just a joke you know Cause You should have make more videos about Flurry heart And princess cadence and I know who the secret Alcorn Princess Is She Has Dark dark dark purple and Dark pink swirl Hair and she has white and her legs are big like princess celestia And she has A. Snowflake cutie mark And A purple eye Or blue and You just have to go to search And Go to speaker and say who is the secret Alcon princess and You just have to watch it and see well I don't know Princess Cadence's Dad is cause I don't know when I'm gonna watch it Later something Cause I'm going to be texting you a big message and I'm already doing it now I know how to spell these words With this speaker that I am speaking at it makes it to Easy then Typing I just wrote then With typing It only had a few words I hope you get this message Well it has too many words Just take your time to Read it and Make a very very very good video with no villains or scary music Only with A very good ponies See you tomorrow!!!!!!!! And I am Olympia See you soon!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Know i kinda get why some people think discords favorite element was pinkie pie i though it was fluttershy but i kinda get it know and I also think that discord favorite element is pinkie pie i agree with it NOT A SHIP LIKE EWWW
What if Pinky exactly The Reincarnation of Chaos incase Discord Conan will come back the universe made Pinky chaotic future oh-so really good but that's far-fetched
Hi you now that's a very good point I thought it was true but now I don't think it's true you know why because pinky sense isn't only at Pinkie Pie we saw the same in rainbow Dash's birthday cheese sandwich has the same thing he just names it cheesy sense but it's still with a good point of view
We know that pinkie does things which are out of this world and theirs tooooo . There could be something linked with this event that this event made every single pinkie , pinkie clones and human pinkie magical as in Equestria girls 1 ; Pinkie guesses twilight is a princess even without magic in that world !!! This theory could be a very strong probability to pinkies pinkiness
It may also effect her family aka Maud syas she has some type of maud sense and then pinkie says " It runs in the family " I really dont know weather she was joking or she was saying it in real
In season 1 when pinkies mane goes not poofy we see that she has a turnip bucket. But then in mlp eg spring breakdown we see pony twilight showing human rainbow and twilight and sunset shimmer a table of mysteries stuff, And one of them was the turnip bucket, It could be that pinkies got power to make stuff go crazy like discord who made a teacup with wings.
How could chaos magic be the answer not only pinkie pie got pinkie sense but cheese sandwich have cheese sense but he did not get chaos magic inside him so then maybe pinkie is from a magic family and what about if pinkie have a long lost sister and she was a unicorn she went to the unicorn school and she tried her magic so she could get in but she made a blast and this spell she tried to do could have got in her that where it starts and she was older than pinkie and her sister that could be the truth
I think it didn't affect it cuz soon after she got turned to stone and that's why pinky got a different effect but then again pinky just Pinky don't even ask
Actuly this makes scens but are we shure pinkie only obsorbed discord’s magic what about grogars cozy probably studied more about artifacts than pinkie I mean you probably want information to drain magic with artifacts so she probably had information on the bell before realizing the artifact would be impossible to get so she was slightly more carful with the magic and what would you expect from pinkie
Because of the rumors about pinkie... Everyone hates pinkie! She's just a character? Why does some toxic people always make fun of her? Why make fun of her, when you know hasbro made it
my little pony have so much secrets why can you tell us thank you so much for teaching us thank you so much my little pony I love you so much teling us please make more videos po
Pinkie Pie I have some really strange stuff that I didn't really know about her like physics never realize pinky with that Majestic in California. Something was wrong with her cuz she would crazy I think she was adopted or going to cuz her friends and I only have family do not look like her cuz maybe her family was like going out of business and maybe she was constipated time maybe she had like some hopefuls of some some Nair or some pony it must be her headache be guardian of the Girl doll you know where people have you no other person that they would protect the weird bad stuff what happened to them when they were little kids I bet she had it and she absorbed the magic and that's I think about you be a great queen or something maybe like she used to have some ability like she like had powers or maybe she was an Alicorn secretly but the afterwards maybe her parents had to protect her cuz she didn't want to cause drama around the world she hit her powers and her horse that's why her hair was soaked early but her powers never but she never use them that's why they were always never there you never saw her horn because it was covering her hair and she never had wings because even if she was out of course you would have kept it a secret so she didn't cause traumas stuff music when it was temporary when her friends are fat and they were her or maybe it was necessary she will use it in the show we never saw it but maybe she might be able to bring her magic back but she doesn't use it for anything else but if it family and friends will get hurt by some evil entity or feeling she might use it but her friends never realized but she was actually an Alicorn 1 her friends and family but she was not the only one in stuff she never had anything to do with it she decided she didn't want to cause drama for the world and her wings so that's why she was able to do it but she was always afraid of what happened like some new ones will come up when she hide it she was hiding it and deep down she was like she giving up hope there's no one will realize she was Alcorn or grow another one had respect for her and that's how her powers came when you are upset they come easily cuz she was depressed never had her face and she was never happy pony one day her her powers can't because she was not the one that read the matter what if we went to find her job was meant to be she was so happy she was happy she was Alec bumper she really have to hide it so people what is in the ponies will understand so that's why she had figure out time and maybe we can solve them to pinky but she was hiding it all this time and all these episode it took me a hot minute to realize she was an alicorn another dimension that she was an Alicorn but we never saw the real
Pinkie pie had this weird magic even before twilight became a princess so I don't know what you're talkin about this video makes no sense I know pinkie pie more than any for me does and I'm not even in the my Little pony universe
The exact origin of Celestia and Luna is deliberately kept as a mystery. But it's assumed that Celestia and Luna were born as alicorns. (At least, Lauren Faust has said so, and the show and the comics didn't contradict her.)
Flurry Heart is the first alicorn born in more than a thousand years; and genetically, neither of her parents is an alicorn (Shining Armor is a unicorn, and Cadance was originally a pegasus). That's why Celestia and Luna were so surprised about her birth. (Was it some residual effect of the magic of love that transformed Cadance into an alicorn? Did the transformation also alter Cadance's genetic code? Was the Crystal Heart involved somehow?) Plus, they said that birth of an alicorn is something that Equestria hasn't ever seen, and this is true - Celestia and Luna are older than the Principality of Equestria itself.
pinky's chaos energy is very powerful she is only using 0.00000000000000000000000000000000000001% of her power good thing she doesn't snap easily...............but I think some one said cupcakes are the worst thing in history so get into your bunkers
Is the main six good well I don't think so maybe the good people aren't good and the bad people is not bad because maybe the bad people are right and the good people are wrong
If you think about because the cosy glow Had a look on magic it does give Cody go to Halle Halle called magic as you’re dead the dead piggy pie just use chaos magic without any other magic with it so I think pick up I did up Cales magic but I close the client had it like Alacon bad because he’s just gonna go suck it up girl grow Godspell a little times two powers of Case close
But....how she get chaos power her mom and dad don't have chaos is the rain boom did??? there is 1 you guy didn't see season 8 episode 26 she still have it she didn't bake cake just there
That has magic bc pinkie said herself that she and cheese sandwich r the same and the original pinkie pie would have the pinkie senses like cheese sandwich
pinkie pie 's child will be just like pinkie , chaos and crazy bc pinkie is related to her child ofc then she will be chaosic or crazy like pinkie pie AHHHH PINKIE PIE WHAT HAVE YOU BROUGHT IN THIS WORK CHAOSIC NESS AND DISCORD U TO
Biggest thing ki is so after is the element of the laughter so this is what is a paint NH7 Sohar then every is the craziness or what is the craziness of the memories that there is just got this magic and seek a more powerful than ever
I saw tooth Waves Can you make any more videos that are fun but no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no scary things cause it really really really scares me like it's cause when I hear the music on how kings someone lost his wings and The alicorn ambulance music it was so scary I just stopped watching that And never ever ever ever ever watch that type of episode again cause it was too scary you Should Sombra episode with no scary music it scares me too much It really really does it very it does Cause where do you even get the music from? My sister isn't a fan But I am me my sister Olivia Are twins And was 7
Know what the think of things purchases a mystery character that I don't understand about pinky Pie she has no problems of Manhattan house her but we have a lot of Secrets about her. We don't know what's a tummy a hot minute realize that she was a look corn because actually I knew it all I just was my brain was dumb but anyways maybe we'll be able to say maybe we can get a game or something don't know something I think it will make make a game that was playing her tragedy maybe all the characters will have the wrong special story and stuff maybe think about had drama with her a real parents house maybe her dad was reading out of business is in her mom was trying to make money but she didn't in before her in a orphanage then her like family came first up parents so much never hold a nap or whatever she was like she was always press abused by Gucci hadn't he was abused and stuff with the other owners of the Ganahl the mayor's and stuff being her up she was abused and never even the small she has bruises for years and she was always tormented and she was never a house before your like she was second a timely then at the woods her friends started bawling her being a life torture to cost flies her house her brain mentally as I can trust she never talk back this you didn't want to to be so on the little the word but she was always beat up tap use and never liked all these kids made fun of her cuz she was not popular that girl the other ones were she she got beat up your other rest I think she had drama parents whenever liked to do like abuse her guitar kid baby her siblings bite be 10 she was like beating them up for maybe that's how she got trouble then she was abused and she was always accusing to was child attitude it be her up into a pink then her eyes with bleeding coming crying tears in stuff parents never cared about her that's why she was abused she had a lot of drama with her parents using her making her feel like she was at to call me a question that house she was trying to hide it in the episodes like it it has she was going to different the mentioned she never mentioned it I'll her story cuz we never knew what about her that I knew about everything is I am the smart penis but anyways I think she you was trying to hide it from the camera s*** bruises all over the state she put makeup the planet with her skin that's why she was never allowed to know what's you probably could make up on her skin so she can not to be around so stupid praying that Bob on that she went she goes home she calls the curtains then she cries and cries and cries how a lot she cries and cries and cries have her all birthday party went her parents will her real pads hated her and sing ever sell big heart birthday and as a shoe was sad never allowed to have she was crying her room Walker heard door and cry cry and cry like to doors and stuff this is cake whenever heard parents live she had to tantrum cuz she wanted to see her siblings but they will always never around Zulu to different countries so that's why she should she was crying wash Mr siblings and she was married and everything was perfect but she will want to her husband was shooting ahead and she had a divorce then she lost some of her kids I love you never saw her but she's out of think if I met when they were in college a nice selling love but sex before she real
And yes she is just pinkie but with powers and I think is her big sis cuz she knew everything even the cutiemarks that can take you cutiemarks mmm..... but yeah I this her big sis
Someone named Letupita725HD has a yt channel, that's where I watch all the episodes. If you go on their channel and look at playlists you should find a playlist for each season
Bad twilight sparkle silly pinkie pie Pinkie) ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo twilight sparkle you are bad go to your room now Twilight)noooooooooooooooooooooooooo
I actually had a theory (well, less theory and more head canon) that Pinkie sense is essentially a supernatural understanding of butterfly effects: she can look at any random occurrence and immediately know what it will cause. I dunno, it just helped me connect her chaotic nature and her apparent psychic ability.
I think Pinkie Pie may have adhd. I say not only because I have it, but because I notice behaviors she and I share. One example is during the episode Yakity-Sax when Pinkie gets rid of her instrument, she seems fine at first. However, we then get a glimpse showing exactly how upset she truly is. Whenever I feel upset being told I’m not good at something, it discourages me from being myself since I always seem so excited about it. In addition, we know that her friends constantly agree that she is a little strange, but I know that ppl think that about me too. We also got a glimpse of Pinkie’s past and how she earned her cutie mark. When she saw the rainbow it was like she was inspired to be herself. Maybe at some points during her childhood, she wanted to be her but stopped herself from doing so worried what others may think of her. The rainbow gave her that push she needed to be herself and it never changed the way others saw her. I hope one day I too am pushed by a rainbow to be confident of who I am. Well, a metaphorical one at least.
You also gotta think about personality traits. Both Discord and Pinkie Pie have a certain randomness, especially if chaos(aka Discord) is attributing in a good way... Sounds awfully like Pinkie pie during her antics. Cozy glow can't relate in that way, so that's a way to explain that line of reasoning.
There’s something that must have started the loophole, just like Future Twilight first wanted to tell Twi to not worry about her schedule, but then it changed into her worrying about the message Future Twilight sent (theory.). How did Pinkie even absorb the magic of this bell in the first place? Was she not the element of laughter, but a different element, and when the chaos corrupted her timeline, she turned into the element tif laughter? Or, did she turn into a villain and steal the chaos magic that then corrupted her timeline and bla bla bla
I think pinkie never had earth pony magic, but always had chaos magic, in a small quantity, allowing her to bend reality, but only a very limited sense. this also makes sense as pinkie was the only other entity to use chaos magic (although she lost control of herself to a degree, it was very different to how cozy glow's use backfired), meaning she might be chaotic enough to use the magic.
When comparing cosi to pinkie, think about... when cosi got discord’s magic, that plus regular pony magic was all that was there... but when pinkie was exposed to the magic not only discord’s magic and other regular pony magic was given too her, but also Luna and celestias magic as well, so when saying that... your theory makes sense sawtooth
This confirms that earth ponies not only have a connection to nature but also has a connection to time itself since there are different versions of the Pinkie sense seen in other earth ponies.
I know this video is 3 months old, but I would like to point out another example as to why this theory makes sense. In season 7, episode 18 "Daring done?", she picks up one of Daring Do's artifacts, the artifact reacts differently than when its in Daring's hand. For pinkie, it glows brightly and has sparks coming off it, but when daring has it all of that stops. Idk, that just seemed interesting to me..
Sawtooth: Pinkie is always does random things,pulls out stuff out of nowhere and her pinkie sense is because she has bits of future memories in her from when she absorbed discord's chaos magic Cheese Sandwich:am i a joke to you?
she also could have done it herself as she had a limited but not impossible amount of control over the magic. sensing that she could lose it she may have infuse it within her across time.
Although this theory could be true, if you remember when pinky was telling her background story. She could not pull anything out of the blue or appear out of nowhere, until the rainboom happened. If u remember the same kinda thing happened to Twilight. She couldn’t use her magic until the rainboom happened and she used her magic that no one else could do. Now not saying this applies to all of them but the Rainboom could have had affect on Pinky’s life and not event happening in the future
Guys I just had a revelation, Pinkie gets her magic from friendship. We’ve seen time and time again that friendship is magic, from hearths warming to the elements to the main six themselves, but nopony has as many friends as Pinkie.
Expand on this idea as you will, I was just rewatching season 2 and had a lightbulb moment.
Yeah, but in that case then Applejack should be stronger than she is correct? She is the same type as pinkie and is friends with lots of ponies doing her business yet all she has is super strength you'd think Rarity would be the weakest since she is a fashionista and not the most likeable to some right?
Pinkie may be the only other creature in Equestria that is able to use Discords magic. If you think about Queen Chrysalis said no one can control chaos magic and that was proven with Cozy Glow having a very hard time controlling the chaos magic, but when Pinkie absorbed Discords magic she was able to control it. She successfully made chocolate rain and balloons float behind her when she was massive. I also think that the reason why Pinkie may be able to control chaos magic is that Discord and Pinkie have similar tastes and interests. They both can use the same type of magic, but it would make more sense for Discord to use it. Even though he tried to take over Equestria several times he still knows when he draws the line. He makes pranks and gags that are more or less harmless to the other creatures around him, but when Pinkie had the chaos magic her first thought was turning the entire cosmos into icing.
I just thought of this; what if pinkie, along with getting Discords magic infused with her, also (accidentally) got a tiny bit of grogar’s magic as well. (I can’t be the only one who thought of this)
i actually noticed when the magic went into her forhead, but i thought it was an error because earlier that episode she ran off screen and came back with some pizza,and how would she do that without magica
She is the combination of all magics seen in the form of an Earth Pony. It is more Powerful, since there is no way of drawing her as anything more. Giving her wings or horn would merely detract. ..
What if pinky’s abilities to themselves was magic? What if pinky isn’t just a pony? After all, peering through time and space, and causing changes to the future that end up leading to the past... means she’s either doctor who or a part of Norse mythology. Btw, in Norse mythology, part of it is that the world tree represents the past, present, and future, and that water from above flows down below to nurture the tree. This is meant to show that somehow the future affects the past.
My theory: discord and pinkie are quite similar, so what if discord’s past has something to do with pinkie, like in discord’s origins, he was a experiment, but what was experiment what did he start as? What if he was part of pinkie’s family, I mean both pinkie pie and discord both have two forms. Pinkie has deflated form and discord has grogard. But how did they get them? And plus, discord’s colour scheme matches with her family, but weirdly, pinkie doesn’t. And in her backstory, she started as a filly on a rock farm, but why did she look so different from her family, unless that wasn’t her family at all. And maybe it could be to do with discord. If so, maybe there is a piece of discord’s timeline that we missed. And if so, what is it? And could it be connected with Pinkie pie?
Well if that’s true....... If it messed up her whole past and her future what does that mean? It means....
Discord and her would have to try to make friends like Discord did
so if it affected the past it does mean it affected her future But there’s a slight problem....
It’s the connection between Chaos and Pinkie
AND THE BRAIN no I mean Pinkamena Diane Pie Pinkie Pie was born into a rock family when she saw the rainbow and made her go all happy and made her go all excited and ever since she saw a rainbow she gets excitement she’s always excited and the chaos that Discord has does not match that And pinky getting magic whenever the magic was stolen she only got it back because she has a different type of earth pony magic it’s more different than a regular earth pony it’s only because her excitement it’s what makes her Well her
I a sorry to bring your theory to pieces, but there is one thing that changes everything. In Pinkie Pride Cheese Sandwich has a cheesy sense, and later on in The Gift Of Maud Pie, Rarity asks Maud how she knew that the guy with the party cannon was there, and Maud said, Maud sense, only later to explain, "it runs in the family." So, Pinkie didn't get it from future Pinkie, she got it from DNA. If it runs in the family, it would also mean that all Pies had it. Oh, and what about Cheese, how did he get his sense?
I agree with you and I also still think she has magic that's not pinkie sense ( because pinkie sense is a genetic ), like how she can teleport sometimes and make party supplies out of nowhere and pull of amazing stunts that defy the laws of physics. I also think that she is connected to discord because of the bell.
I think I got it.Pinkie is in her earluly 20's,But cozy is a filly,Like twelve or something.Maybe the age has something to do with it,Like the older you get the more magic enters your past and future,or once you reach somewhere over twleve,that happens.
I don’t know if anyone said this already but I just thought of this:
What if in that one episode where there were a billion pinkies, they didn’t choose the right pinkie? What if they chose a different pinkie? I might be dumb but maybe that pinkie they chose was just trying to stay so she wouldn’t have to go back to the water.
To back it up when the unicorns got there magic back pinkie pie in the episode didnt seem like her funny annoying self it was like if it was on a 50% scale and not on a 100% scale.
in an episode (not a serie one just side ones ) pinkie drinks a potion from her chaos take an new level and she can travel in time dimension and spaces (that episode was created by lauren faust so it is related ) she was more powerful then discord and twilight cause they cant travel time in the blink of an eye
There’s one thing I have to say that doesn’t make sense though because pinky only exorbitant magic after season eight and you’re saying that all that magic went all the way back to season one
maybe she just is the way she is regardless of what or how she came to be in the future or present. but seriously she is WEEEEIRD
0 likes
Min Zhuo2020-10-16 20:56:22 (edited 2020-10-16 20:56:59 )
There’s a hole in ur theory: you said that pinkie sense was bc of the chaos magic BUT when pinkie gets the present for maud and maud finds the pony that took pinkies cannon maud undoubtedly said “ maud sense” and pinkie said “... runs in the family”
Wait but what about Cheese Sandwich? He’s practically pinkie 2.0. Sure, Pinkie could have more of the.. uh.. craziness I guess, but Cheese is still pretty strong.
I know why Cozy glow did not get the consequences pinky pie did it's because she was an alicorn at the time and was powerful enough to hold the power in the one time
I think that pinkie pie infusing chaos magic into herself is true because in the human world the duplicate of her is still chaotic but doesn't do any breaking the fourth wall things all she does is be goofy
I think she did I mean she liked it raining chocolate milk and that happened and all the sugary food floating around and the cupcakes in her eyes it was like she could control the chaos
No I don’t solved pinkie pie because that was season 9 and the creators most likely did not think sooo far ahead to why pinkie is pinkie so I don’t think she got those wired powers from that event the creators probably just thought it would be a good sense to season 9 but that does not explain why pinkie is like how she is but it’s just my opinion and you have your own opinion and I’m ok with that I love this channel but I don’t think pinkie is strange because of that 1 event
Sawtooth Waves, Cheese Sandwich also has A Chessy Sense? So, the pinkie sense doesn’t explain anything, but if it did, could Cheese Sandwich have something too?
In the PPSTD episode I think that’s how you spell it, rarity does what pinkie should be doing but pinkie is sad and can’t do it. Maybe any pony can do it if they have the right amount of energy?
Pinkie is a forth wall character.......their is no real logic behind anything she does.....it's there just for the heck it.....that's the best i can come up with where such characters are concerned anyways....they r made so the writers can do anything....just because they can...and it isn't made into a big deal because ....well in this case...it's just pinkie being pinkie right?
Makes no sense let me say something in the episode When Muad pinkie pie and rarity went to Manhattan muad Knew where the guy that gave pinkie pie the Rock holder and Raritysaid how did you know where the guy was and muad said muad Sense in Pinky said runs in the family
I sort of agree but in that episode Were cozy glow stole magic.and we noetest she had magic.but when cozy glow had the magic pinkie was the same which means its not magic.
Wait wait wait, I solve IT the right way, so pinky does not have magic it’s her personality, well I don’t if this is right but, pinky pie does not have magic, it’s her silly personality, well, I know it does not make any sense.
I pinkie kept the magic everything would be desserts 🍨🍩🍪🍰🎂🧁🍭🍬🍫🍮🍯🥮... ALL OF THEM. Also what about Cheese sandwich 🤔
0 likes
AJ Plays2020-11-25 03:29:58 (edited 2020-12-29 02:09:20 )
I agree on the Chaos magic effecting Pinkie Pie past and you know thinking about it give me another idea about her strange magic and that is her cutie mark think about it never happened until Pinkie Pie got her cutie mark it’s not the first time we seen pony’s have powers with there cutie marks what If Rainbow Dash rainboom did more it gave her what I will call Party powers like Rainbow Dash gave her the power to do the rainboom and the others got special powers Twilight magic, FlutterShy talking to animals, Rarity and finding gems, and Apple Jack amazing bucking skills so Rainbow Dash could have gave Pinkie Pie her Party powers and the others special powers.
I know how Magic wind Into pinky pie After the students Defeated cozy grove to Because of a pinky Senses I don't know the rest that's the only thing I know so that you have to figure on your own sorry I can't tell you anything else I don't know the rest
um so wait she can maybe warp to the real universe our universe multi universe or what imma make some my alicorn or maybe the god alicorn what is that god or maybe who is he or she can you upload a theory of it plz
what if this happenned because of the fact pinkie pies familly was sooo dull then she got her cutie mark because they drove her crazy and thats why she turned a lil bit crazy ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Yay and yes we are watching u your ON A VIDEO I think look pinky is a party pony and on the video we’re cheese sandwich sang why is his cutie mark a cheese sandwich??? Anyways pinky I’d a party pony a party pony would go crazy and she laughed even if the tree was scary u know on the video when they are geting Luna back the time when they defeated nightmare moon
Hey hey why isn't Rainbow dash included just think about it she and her father have rainbow hair what about her mother and why is Rainbow dash the only one who can do the sonic rainboom and Fluttershy was so well shy until she burst out in applause whne she saw Rainbow dash do the sonic rainboom
Ok, but are we going to talk about the fact she's the only other creature that could handle his magic properly in the first place?
Edit: This might be a paradox though, because you could say Pinkie could take in Discords chaos magic because she already had some, when she got it from taking Discords chaos magic, which she could handle since already has some when she got it from taking Discords chaos magic, which she could handle since already has some and you get the point.
Edit 2: at 2:15 when Pinkie got her magic, it isn't that insane pattern like Discords chaos magic. What if it's a whole new kind of magic? Party Magic. Hasn't Cheese Sandwich been shown to do similar things? What if the 2 of them have party magic?
Why do not solve pinky she is one thing that not should be solve like discord and technically since they have the same magic in there veins like the exact same magic like how family’s have the same type of blood
WELL WE AINT NOT ORRRR CANT FIGURE OUT Pink pie NOW RIGT 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😒🙁😒😒😒😒🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁😞😞😞😞😞😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😭🤣😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😤😤😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I think one reason that the chaos magic didn’t spread through Cozy Glow’s timeline is because at that time, there wasn’t any alicorn magic (Celestias’s and Luna’s magic) inside Grogar’s bell, but when Pinkie Pie absorbed the magic, there was the alicorn magic inside it too, and it was too much for her to contain in that moment and spread through her whole timeline
On the Cozy Glow question, we see it almost immediately drives her mad with power. If we are to assume Chaos magic trancends time and effects your being completely, couldn't that explain her master manipulation and power hungry tendencies? After all, we're never given a real origin for her.
I definitely like the chaos magic theory, and I think that maybe chaos magic affecting people differently is the reason why it didn't affect Cozy Glow. The only problem would be that the first run of the timeline would have pinkie pie not have all of the craziness that made her Pinkie Pie, resulting in her probably not representing her element. Then again, time events never make sense, and a lot of things like this don't follow that logic flaw anyway.
I'm a little late to the party here but I'll throw in my two cents.
I've suspected for a while now that Pinkie's abilities were magical in nature. The detail about her getting magic back along with Twilight and Rarity would seem to prove that. I'm not sure I buy that it came from her interaction with Grogar's bell though. The point about Cozy Glow having absorbed Discord's magic as well is the key here. Cozy Glow absorbed the chaos magic but *could not wield it*. Pinkie COULD. That tells me that chaos magic was in her nature, regardless of her interaction with the bell.
i may be late but the interaction between chaos magic and harmony magic could be the explanation. harmony is described as balance and chaos unbalance however not many see that chaos is a tool of harmony to bring balance. if creatures evolved to be balanced within themselves and not the environment they either destroyed the landscape or died themselves. seeing as how pinkie is directly linked to harmony that harmony would need to balance chaos in a way that would keep harmony. sending chaos magic back and forth into time to keep balance could be the reason why she didn't temporarily become an alicorn. this would also partially explain why discord didn't fade when his magic was stolen from him, his magic causes him to fade if he is orderly.
the question about how cozy glow wasn't affected has already been explained in one of these comments [at the time she was an alicorn and could handle it but pinkie was just an earth pony], so the chaos magic makes sense. plus it explains how when the magic had returned pinkie was also hit. BUT the one thing confusing me is that if pinkie didn't have that happen, she wouldn't have absorbed the magic. unless the loop of time just started when pinkie absorbed some magic, it doesn't add up. i can't really explain it in words- hopefully someone understands what i mean-
Wait, I just had another theory. What if there are still pinkies throughout equestria from that season 3 Episode? What if there are still many pinkies out there spreading discord’s magic to other pinkies. Does that make sense?
What if pinkie the one who absorbed discord’s magic was the original pinkie, but she spread it to one of her clones. And with that magic, they could travel through time and have been since the beginning of the series. Either by finding it in the star swirl hallway in canterlot, or by some other Discord magic feature.
What if one of those pinkies traveled back in time and have been since season 1, and another one could’ve travelled to the human world and told the pinkie in the original world and that’s how she knew what happened to twilight when she traveled there for the first time. I mean, it does kinda make sense since equestria girls came out after season 3 and pinkie got all her clones in the 3rd episode of season 3. So basically, during that time, other pinkies could’ve absorbed that magic that another pinkie did in the future (season 9) cause it spread throughout her entire timeline and other pinkies as well. This was just a theory that cane out my mind but I guess we’ll never know the true secret of Pinkie Pie, unless Pinkie is just Pinkie...
While this idea is vary plausible, and would explain a lot. Through I don't think it goes as deep as you implied. While it does explain the moments were Pinkie could predict future events, and he fourth wall bracing ability, it doesn't explain why those specific abilities aren't an every day thing. The other aspect that you need to account for is Pinkies personal and willingness to embrace the crazy and weird. That could be the reason why she shows symptoms of it through out her life while Cozy didn't. And would explain how she was able to control Discords magic better then Cozy Glow too.
Nah, I don't think that's true. When Cozy took it in, it didn't spread. Pinkie probably just had chaos magic in her when she was born, but not strong enough or very usable to be like Discord's. Maybe her family members have it too, splitting what little magic they inherited into small amounts that can only be used subconsciously. Maud can teleport, and all of the Pies seem to have 'senses.'
Don't forget Earth Ponies and Pegasi have their own kind of magic.
Cozy wasn’t effected as much as pinkie because she was already an Alicorn and using Grogars magic, which may have have stopped it from causing larger effects. also when the element toke away the magic from cozy, it may have also stopped any chaos magic from having the same effects.
Pinkie however was still pure earth Pony and although she represents an element, that’s still only one of them that connects to the others, so it would have a different effect than having all 6 used against her.
But again just a theory
Also this might explain Pinkamina Like when discord started acting normal his magic and he slowly started to fade away, if Pinkie did keep some of his chaos magic and it traveled through her lifetime it would explain a similar thing with Pinkie. So when she’s upset and not acting like her element, the magic starts to fade causing her to act differently (Hence pinkamina)
Great theory as usual, but when you mentioned her pinkie sense i thought about something....like what about maud sense? Even Cheese Sanwich mentioned having cheese sense
Pinkie Pie can not just control it, but she ould extract it from the bell on her own. Going by all previous examples; the bell was intended to give magic to someone else, preferably by Grogar. But, why should Pinkie Pie be bothered by such petty details?
I feel like you’re right about pinkie, but the reason it didn’t effect cozy glow was because she’s not as chaotic as pinkie, Since pinkie pie is naturally chaotic the chaotic energy must have messed up her already existing chaotic energy.
actually, i do agree, and i do think it is an interesting concept. The netflix series (i think it was like, hill's hesidense? hills house???) spoilers ahead has the same thing. The girl sees a broken neck woman from time to time, wich its just her when she dies with a broken neck and revisitis her old self.
But Sawtooth, what about the Pinkie in the equestria girls dimension? There is certainly no Discord or his magic in that dimension, or are you saying that because his magic is so powerful, it is spread across dimensions?
i think its a mixture of discord's magic and the explosion of magic from the sonic rainboom which definitely contains magic since its where twilight got most of her's she was a very weak unicorn before the sonic rainboom
Maybe it didn't effect cozy glow because she tried to use it for something else instead of chaos. She tried to do something unrelated to chaos, pinkie on the other hand, well, I think you would know
I believe than because Discord was petrified that the magic of chaos found a new receptacle in Pinky. This magic was activated only when she got her cutie mark. Fun is Chaos in a good way.
chaos magic is chaos just like it says in the name so possibly when is affected Pinkie pie it affected all of her changing her past and future but actually making it so everyone remembers it as just Pinkie pie knowing everything but it didn’t to clozy because it’s pure chaos like you said we can’t expect it to follow a path on what it will do when someone beholds it. Also we only have one example of a creature being born with chaos magic,but two of someone taking it and using it. No not just using it,almost like there injecting it into their blood/soul (if it was her soul that could explain why she was given back magic back some magic could stay with her making sure it affects her past and future as well as her being)
Me: I don’t believe you, no one can solve Pinkie Pie, it’s just Pinkie Pie being Pinkie Pie, don’t question and don’t even try to.
1. Pinkie Pie has being like that since the first MLP episode and at that time no one knew discord, ever since she made her first party she turned into who she is today.
2. Pinkie Pie is not the only one who breaks the laws of physics, you just showed an image of Twilight talking to Pinkie Pie literary floating without any wings, and almost everyone in the show.
3. Pinkie Pie knows stuff about other world because she travels through the portal there a little video about bloopers and there is a part that shows how Pony Pinkie Pie comes through the Canterlot High portal and the human Pinkie Pie goes to the portal where she came from and the Pony Pinkie Pie just pretends that nothing is wrong and keeps living her life happily in Canterlot.
4. I don’t think Pinkie Pie absorbed discord’s magic, she would have way more power and maybe even other abilities, the breaking laws of physics can be seen from anyone, Pinkie Pie it’s a special pony, a happy pony, she’s always full of energy and no one can figure her out so don’t try.
Maybe when they gave cozy glow the magic they held some back because they still had trust issues if you look at there faces before and after they have the look of a knowing parent
My theory has been that she was the offspring to two powerfully magical unicorns who wanted an ideal child. However, realizing that Pinkie wasn't a unicorn, they cast her aside. Hence why Pinkie was adopted by the Pie family.
@Dominique Fairclough I don't recall her being a twin, and there's a good amount of evidence that she could have been adopted. Either way, it's a silly, fun, fan theory.
Kry Butterworth she said in Heartbreakers story . Her “twin” is her sister Marble Pie she said they were born just a few seconds apart but yeah it’s just fun
What if pinkie pie is somehow, someway is like Discord? Like she’s chaostic and insane and then the fact that she knows random info and can brake the laws of physics on a dime- a lot like discord but more controlled, more held back or even less powerful
What if when cozy glow adsorbed the magic it stuck with her a little as well, maybe that is he reason she was able to become an alicorn in the first place. It affected her past and future.
I always wondered why did pinkie just turn but when absorbing the magic from the bell and cozy glow grew big and celestia-like size, and pinkie didn’t turn into a alicorn
Pinkie Pie is my favorite character. I approve of Sawtooth's theory. Your welcome. XD (I'm kidding you don't need mah approval :P Love your channel! <3)
there is this random short called "double rainboom" where Rainbow Dash wentto the Powerpuff girls dimension. But, Pinkie drank an enhancement potion where she could manipulate the multiverse!
Pinkie Pie has the same magic like Discord!!Ok let it be! BUT there's my theory.Pinkie has magic!! I DIDN'T noticed before I watch it.But (look carefully Pinkie Pie);even pinkie doesn't have magic she can say "Pizza Delivering"and held pizza!!where is that pizza come from!!And She can spring (when twilight holding the door)quickly without magic!!!NO Earth pony can't do!!Ok Pinkie and Discord have same magic ok! Then when Tirek absorb discord magic;discord's magic colour is look like purple and black!! But Pinkie's magic colour is Pink!!!SO Their magic are not the same I guess.But I think Pinkie's magic is just her love I guess!! You know It may be strange ! But she can make everypony joyful and cheerful!!That is why she has magic!!Her magic is only her love and making joyful things.The real magic is her Cutie Mark!!Even she has no magic but she can still do things that no Earth pony can't do and of course joyful things too.But when Starlight Glimmer took her Cutie Mark; she can't do anything joyful and cheerful!Because of that her magic is just her love of making joys.But even she has no magic but still can do jokes and joyful things if she has her Cutie mark! But her name is Pinkie Pie; you can't explain everything!!
Would you please make a video on the real reason behind night mare moon .See the theory goes like this If you remember the tale of the 2sisters was after Luna was banished to the moon celestia took in charge of both sun and moon if you think about it how did celestia get the power to reach the moon? although there are 2 explanations Explanation number 1- after Luna was banished to the moon celestia use the elements of harmony to gain the power of raising the moon too Explanation number 2 - celestia had the ability to raise the moon long before Luna was banished. Luna might have gotten to know that celestia had this power and become jealous and felt like a spare . celestia would have probably give in that position the Luna for raising the moon because she was her sister. this explains a lot and makes a lot more sense for Luna to become jealous of celestia and turn into a nightmare moon
I told you about this theory invite of you videos of yours. If you think me during make sense then please make a video about it
I know why pinkie pie could’ve had this happen to her and not just cozy glow because there’s also Celestia and Luna’s allegory magic in the bell with discord so I did see that happening
maybe the cauos magic affected cozy diffrently because she was a filly and was going to be turned to stone so she had a smaller timeline for it to spread across? or maybe it has to do with the fact shes a pegasis
Your channel is about you being a detective of mlp and solving everything about it. You solved Pinkie Pie, why don't you solve Apple Jack's cutie mark purpose?
She definitely has her own magic. Not sure if its from the chaos magic though. The magic you see return to her is pink, after all. Not black/yellow/white/etc.
I’m glad you solved Pinky pie but I also have a theory a pony THEORY pinkie is a draconaqus she represents parties surprise party she’s surprising birthday party what she looks like any holiday party I don’t know any adult party when she’s very very weird any formal party like galas weddings anniversaries family reunions is when she’s very serious or sad any celebration like New Year’s Eve is how she remembers everybody kind of doesn’t make sense though It’s the only thing I could think of
My little pony logic makes no sense somebody wakes up starts singing and they all know a dance routine somebody starts singing and suddenly there is a parade! I don’t think my little pony even has logic don’t get me wrong I love the show it is just...MY LITTLE PONY HAS NO LOGIC!!!
Wait i will clear your cosy glow when pinkie consumed the magic look at the background everything has balloons this and that which means that pinkie used a lot of the magic but cosy glow did nothing but pop out pineapple 🍍 monster 👹
Or somehow when Discord was a baby somehow his mom had a little daughter Pinkie Pie but she couldn't raise two kids so she gave Pinkie Pie off to a rock Farm as soon as she was born so does carbon have no idea that there are actually related that explains the chaos Magic
Theory:Pinkies "magic" (ability to get a cutie mark) was to overpowered and when she got discord's magic it powered up that overpowered cutie mark magic and spread it throughout her whole life and she became the pony she is kinda like your theory
But are you trying to say all party ponies are overpowered and plus what about her family they have some of her abilities eg maud pie she can teleport is super fast and strong and has maid sense among others
@Dominique Fairclough no,im saying her magic inside of her to get her cutie mark was too strong and could easily be activated by a rainbow and discord's magic and make her the random pinkie she is
Pinky is the pony who made parties so i know that pinky has magic but to party she is the only party pony girl in the first season 1 so she has party magic but not a princess
Cheese Sandwich l’s existincw implies this is just a rarer form of earth magic. If all earth magic only helped with farming and surveying they’d be pigeonholed as a race. The cakes have implied cake magic so it’s just one of those things
Maybe it's like part of Her special talent Cuting mark magic maybe it's part of that maybe that's why she so he's pulling like party cannons out of nowhere in and killer parting and evening and in season 8 in the 1st showing season 8 she says not even that teeny canning and she Pulls out at the
It's Radvile not Edmundas but I have question. What about Mood? Or... Is it Maud?.. You know Pinkie's sister. She too has a sense. Am I saing that right?
Wait can I tell you something might be an alicorn Pinkie pie can be an alicorn but then again what about Twilight and it's true to an alicorn so like is it impossible cuz there's been lots of fairies like the tanks you know cakes like Pinkie pie have always been a main character but not the really meanest character so sure she might be an alicorn but there's other things behind that fire and marble it's just you know different about them if they're yellow hair yellow hair
consider the oposit, and the reverse connection too. but, what if there were to pop up Chaos Ponies left and right? s this why they shut down the show?
You missed something out. Why didn't fluttershy and rainbow dash get the magic sparks? after all, they have their own unique abilty, the sonic rainboom and stare either animation error or these abilities arent magic..?
At the end of Equestria girls pinky pie which’s places with the human pinky maybe they which all the time and pinky got some kind of power from the portal cause she goes tho it so often??
That’s what I’ve been thinking forever from what I’ve seen she is at least princess celestial or twilight level and has all the qualities even tho a little unorthodox in her ways.
No offence but I dis agree it's just that she likes to party and she is happy plus lets face it its pinkie pie we talking about if this was twighlight sure BUT SRSLY ITS PINKY
Or maybe her magical power is 4th wall breaks. That would explain how she knows things before they happen, is able to teleport from scene to scene, and is able to talk about events from equestria girls despite it being in an entirely different universe. That would also explain why she takes pinkie promises so seriously, bc she knows that if certain things don't happen a specific way, it could result in disaster. Being able to break the 4th wall also would explain her carefree personality. She already knows what will happen and how to get the outcome she wants... so y worry? these 4th wall breaks can also come in the form of visions in her dreams. What if princess luna gave her visons of different dimensions? Maybe its not chaos magic after all.
2 likes
2020-08-07 22:05:01
This actually makes perfect sense to me. Up until this I always just excused Pinkie's behavior as typical cartoon logic, plus in realm full of magic it made some sense. But this theory actually makes the nonsense make sense! However there is one question I have about it. When Tirek first took over in the show, we saw him drain the magic from everypony, including pegasai and earth ponies. Pegasai made sense a bit cause it drained their ability to fly, but what did it drain from the earth ponies then? If this is correct, then it makes sense that she had magic drained then, but what about all the other earth ponies?
Actually, I think we do have some slight evidence that Cozy Glow's past was effected by the influx of Discord's Chaos magic. Consider this... what causes a simple pegasus filly to go full Sociopath? I'm not buying that she was innocent in the beginning of her appearance. I am pretty sure everything she did at the School of Friendship was for the sake of sewing ruination. While she may not have gained powers in the past, as such, she DID gain the mindset for causing Discord and Disharmony.
My theory is that the purpose and different type of pony handle the chaos magic differently. Cozy turned into a she demon because she had evil intentions and Pinkie simply just grew bigger and wanted to turn the cosmos into food because well, Pinkie loves food.
I think it would make sense that pinkie, even without the chaos magic, is predisposed to have more capacity to control chaos magic because of her other intrinsic characteristics. After all, she does represent the spirit of laughter, so perhaps chaos and laughter are distantly related. After all, laughter is a result of the unexpected, and chaos is also a subversion of expectations based on our previous experiences.
Maybe the reason it didn’t affect Cozy Glow is because she wanted to use the chaos magic for something it wasn’t meant for. She couldn’t control it at all. But Pinkie at least accepted the chaos and wanted to use it for chaotic things.
Hmmm... I agree. I also have something to add. Maybe pinkie was supposed to have grey skin and a droopy mane like the rest of her family, but when the chaos affected her life her mane became poofy and changed her skin color. I don’t really have evidence for the color change, but for the mane I do. You know when twilight took in all of the princesses magic? Well for a second, having that much magic made her mane flow just like the royal sisters. So when filly pinkie got the chaos magic, her mane went from droopy and dull to poofy and out of control. (Much like chaos) I also would like to say that the sparkles that form every now and then on the royal sister’s mane, might Be shown in the form of the lighting sparks that can be seen in the very moment pinkie took in all of that chaos magic. Another thing I want to point out is that when the sisters lost their magic, their manes stopped flowing. So this is proof that magic can be shown physically like how pinkie had a color and mane change. 😯 this is a cool topic.
What if what we were watching when we were following the series was the “2nd run” of the whole timeline and the first one changed so much that if we were watching the first, both pinkie and the way friendship would be presented would be different in many ways... and maybe on that first run when she got that dose of chaotic magic she couldn’t control it very well but since it was the second time with the magic, maybe she was able to control it more
The reason why chaos magic didn’t spread throughout cozy glow’s timeline is because she only had chaos magic and 1/3 grogar’s magic But pinkie pie had discord,celestia,luna and all of grogar’s magic so that’s why it spread throughout her timeline
This theory is amazing, but if we go bad and look at the PSSD episode, there is a Maud sense. And pinkie said that it runs in the family. So there is "Pinkie sense", "Maud sense", and if it runs in the family, all the family members have their own sense. So, pinkie sense might not be the evidence.
She could also be part unicorn, in the brief shot of Pinkie and Cheese Sandwich’s children her older foul is a unicorn, which means one or both of them have unicorn blood. Considering both seem to share similar characteristics (pulling things out of nowhere, having some foresight) it’s possible both have latent unicorn magic.
I think this theory is true in fact when I watched the episode where he is exhausted some of discord is Power I would, I was cooking up a theory quite similar to this but it wasn't really coming together but I think you have solved it so yeah🤗
is there a theory on why twilight got big like celestia at the end of the show even tho cadence and luna never got that big? might be connected to how both cozy and pinkie got bigger when they absorbed powerful magic (size correlating with magical ability?)
One thing I want to tell you! It would not be possible that she got her powers from the bell, the episode of the chaos pinkie was AFTER the pinkie senses. She already had it when pinkie absorbed the bell
What if the reason cozy didn’t get effected too bad was because she shared the magic with the other two? Splitting it equally. Pinkie was the only one who took hold of the bell while the three villains had it go to them all at the same time while in battle. The villains also had Bad intentions while pinkie was being pinkie. Her chaos is different from evil chaos. Needless maybe discord also was changed after. Discord never said anything about him being sick before the episode “three’s a crowd” maybe him being evil protected him. Like when cozy was cold she wasn’t thinking too evil like the others. Once she did she ditched the blanket she had. Discord could of been the same. So since pinkie wasn’t planning on doing bad it gave her stronger magic. (But bad chaos comes before good chaos so it could of been doing it’s job doing something evil then being okay but I don’t think that’s right.) discord also seemed to take on the job of the elements being able to turn pony’s to stone. Before he could of done that with the two sisters but he couldn’t since the elements didnt let him before he was good. I think the first magic spark from the friendship of fire was able to help guide the pillars to plant the elements even though the elements already existed. The elements existed through the pillars then when was planted turned into artifacts. But when planning to be destroyed they gave their power of turning people to stone they gave it to the next best thing. Someone who represents all the creatures. When they channeled it to him he felt this new power and used it for good. Like the elements had done it before in the past. The elements them selves could of been stuck in a loop then they changed the destiny using the spirit of magic. But back then it still looked like twilight since twilight looks nothing like her parents the elements used their baby as the element of magic and why is made the mane six the colors of the rainbow (pinkie being the pastel red since they’re in pastel colors) the elements changed history. They were stuck and didn’t like it so they made both the main six and discord. They made the mane six to hold their other power that ponies couldn’t do. Discord for their other powers and that’s why discord doesn’t fit the normal species he is. The student six was what they used to make the loop end and take the focus off the artifacts and onto friendship. While it’s true cozy didn’t go crazy but that’s what the elements intended on happening but didn’t expect pinkie to grab the bell. When she did the spirit of magic was confused and gave pinkie her power of pinkie sense because it gave her its plan but not fully designed. So it gave pinkie the other realms if created by accident. Which the small sparkle of power went into pinkie nose is because she puts her nose where it shouldn’t be while rarity and twilight had it go to their horns.
Believe it or not the first ever episode of my little pony was a story kind of beginning so it would make sense if the timelines were already the plan for the future
you’re probably right. cozy’s timeline wasn’t affected because she was an alicorn when she absorbed discord’s magic and she was powerful enough to handle it??
For the people asking how that crazy thing effected human pinkie, the answer is: it didn't, human pinkie doesn't defy fisics, she just knows about pony pinkie, because pony pinkie and human pinkie, switch through the mirrors.
Markku Ilomäki2020-08-01 15:37:00 (edited 2020-08-01 15:39:13 )
Sawtooth I have always wonderd why only discord is able to use chaos magic acodingly and without going nutts like it did with pinky and coasy glow or when tirek accsidentally made bunch of rubber chicken appear instead of exploding the wall. Is it because chaos magic is so complicated and unpredictable to Control that it takes very long time to master it or is it just that because discord is creature of chaos he has some kind of subconsious sense to understand how chaos magic works and that way is only one who is able to use it acordingly and in it's full extend?
Would that mean that cheese sandwich has also had chaos magic as his ability’s are very similar to pinkie pie’s? It seems very unlikely so I don’t think pinkie’s powers come from discord’s chaos magic
I had a feeling discord and pinkies chaos powers were connected someway somehow it’s there too similar So I’m not that shocked although I’m glad someone finally put it out in the public especially you
This kinda beats with Discord = chaos and Spirit of harmony = harmony since all of them are spirits (the mane 6) cause how can you possibly have harmony and chaos in the same body? Come to think of it how can there be a spirit of harmony if the mane 6 are already spirits of harmony
pinky is a party poney and everyone saw pinkie pie play 10 musical stuff and twilight said " its just pinkie" so maybe when she came to a party pony that made a BIG difference. Even tho she can shake our view and tell what is happening in other worlds
Pinkie Pie cannot be 'solved,' mortal. Pinkie Pie is..beyond your changeling understanding. Nobody on your plane of existence can understand. Perhaps one day you will. We make no promises.
but if pinkie sense was from discords chaos magic pinkie took in at that moment then in season 6 episode 3 pinkie said that maud also had maud sense. Is it possible that when pinkie pie got all that chaos magic that affected her whole timeline it also connected to her family? That's confusing.
i think that cozy glow also had the same exprience like think about it why did cozy turn evil ? well idk, but maybe, the same thing with pinkie the one moment of cozy glow when she absorbed that magic it affected her past turning her evil just like pinkie so only discord can have his magic not any creature else thats what makes fluttercord i mean discord special and thus this can be true and sawtooth theory may be right and the 2 ponies [cozy,pinkie] can be explained
OK I know this moment in the series was just a joke referencing the older MLP art style but this IS another way that Pinkie managed to interact with time - https://youtu.be/eIo9UXSaxFI?t=115 lol
this is just a thought but what if pinkie was adopted by the pies? i mean look at her skin and her hair she looks noting like her family, and i know that at the start when she was a kid she did look " dull " but imagine your the only one in your family with such a piculuar skin tone and she somehow has magic in her blood, so maybe her bialogical parents, relatives, siblings etc have come from some kind of powerfull lands like where the alicorns come from and her parents probably died when she was just a baby. im not sure but that my theorie
Yeah your right. But Cozy got Discords power too but we didn't see her doing something crazy. Someone saying it's because Cozy is an alicorn. But it's posible if Cozy alredy has chaos magic.But alicorns doesn't have chaos magic so i don't think Pinky got her powers from that moment.
My theory:pinkie was suposed to be a alicorn but she got affected by discords magic unleashing herself to loose it somehow being crazy all her life so when she was born discord was there and when pinkies parent's left the room discord made her hold that evil thing to give her magic affecting her future if pinkie was alicorn she'd be princess of happiness or partying but most likely being happiness cause she brings people happiness if they are sad straight away so thats why pinkie bugs her friends with being crazy all the time and got replaced by twilight the main six somehow put up with her and her weirdness for example when pinkie was depressed she was all dark and there are other theories saying "pinkie is a murderer behind the sences she turns her friends into cupcakes" or "she steals there cutie marks" or mabye the 3 princesses inclueding twilight know pinkie has mental disorders but hides it from everyone or shes a traiter to the ponie town and so on but she got so conected to the ponie town that she stayed until she woukd betray the town and her friends she was depressedas a kid probably cause of that evil magic
Chotlate rain from pinkie pie when cozy glow took all magic away when the mane 6 her magic is from her brain I think she was like that from the bell I think some didn’t get out so case solved
In the video ask pony's pinkie pie had wings on her hair and she was a unicorn which makes her an alicorn but that makes sense because if she was bouncing and pulling off tricks and possible maybe she was using magic or rather flyiy
u forget about maud sense. and i think the reason that cosy glow isn't crazy is because she is an alicorn, sort of LOL and because pinky like this magic and traped some of it in her, for her entire timeline
I think pinkypie is a alicorn and her horn is hiding under her hair and she accidentally cast an unknown spell on her horn which made it thin as paper or she accidentally cast an unknown spell which makes her horn invisible or made her horn vanish into thin air ( same with her wings)but she is still able to use her horn and is secretly the princess of good chaos .
This Theory makes sense but I think it’s pinkie pie being pinkie pie because if you think about it all this magic stuff makes no sense in the human world but pinkie pie acts pretty much exactly the same as pony pinkie pie I don’t think someone took the bell into the human world and gave it to the human pinkie pie for 20-30 second than took the magic right back and without anyone noticing but who knows maybe that’s just want happened
wait a minute cozy tried to use discords magic but it fail every time she tried to break something nothing hapen but when pinkie pie pick the caos magic she used and didn't fail in fact she use the magic like discord like she sumon a cake from nowere
That is a good way but I believe that pinkie is adopted because when you adopt the baby changes last names.pinkie is more excited and proud and loves everyone but with the rest mod pie she is a chill person. I have one more thing to add pinkie is pink all over and the pies are either gray or a Gary is purple and white
you can nevver solve her loll mom i got my craziness from mom bcs in school i actually get my party cannon and made a surpise party for 4 minutes bcs our teacher got back from vacation- thanks mom (pinkie)
The real thing thats bugging me is how did cadence be a alicorn pls tell me ......how is pinky so energetic do u think its bc of all the cakes mabey she should live in a non cake house
The reason why Cozy glow Is different then pinkie pie it’s because that she Only took the Discord is magic pinkie pie took discord Magic and the princesses magic
I think Pinkie Pie is secretly an Alicorn or a unicorn. She has big poofy mane, who knows what could be hiding in there? From season 8 school raze, only the unicorns and Alicorns got there magic back and so did pinkie!
No she has been wild forever so I think sense flutter shy can basically talk to animals pinky pie must have a weird ability to but sense she has more than one and apple jack doesn’t and pinky pies family isn’t a thing like her but she might actually have chaos in her blood but it never came from when we saw discord pinky I think Pinky pie is adopted because she doesn’t look a thing like her family Also please make a video about how pinky pie might be adopted
Who is always weird not that one moment she was always really not that one moment changed everything she was always weird in the beginning to the end how could possibly happen if pinky was magically transformed from only that one moment she was crazy and weird and think he sensed everywhere in every episode not that just one mom and changed everything how could we even know from episode one
OMG UR SO Adorable!!!!. I thought the pony w fandom was dead!. glad it's not u won a sub btw I was wondering so are u currently a brony lol if so neat lol i got into my little pony cus of a brony lol he was also my boy friend at the time sadly i had to move so our love was not to last but our love for mlp will last forever!!!! or at least till the fandom die's XD
People are watching you because on YouTube right now you know that it's kind of funny you said that my name is Leah Marie King and my life is actually super crazy at first my mom just freaked out I have no idea why do then only if you want to talk about the rest
Are we even sure pinky is a normal pony maybe it is your theory but what if she is a different type like we have seen hipogrifs and every thing but maybe not every thing there world is big and they only exsplore a lil maybe there are others that look like earth pony’s but have som strange magic and maybe they like to stay hidden like a lost tribe of whatever they are and they hav strange abblites yes that theory might be good but what about cozy glow the magic was hard for her but she did not have the chaos spread she was fine except from those pineapples the might have left a mark but pinky might be from somewhere else she might be pony but not a earth pony or any other we have herd like a very old species not hating on the vid but what if just think about it why is she the only pink one in her faimly even be four her cutie mark and remeber pinky could control most of it like she loved the chock late rain when they first met discord and all of a shunned it starts to rain when she has it a person with magic would know how to use it but pinky could not really control what happened it’s like an instinct like how every one and thing has different instincts just think about it
I got a question soon soon pinkie pies it's the question is there's so many episode of My Little Pony and and Pinkie Pie bye why was got something her magic back of the others didn't
Dude ur wrong cuz when pinkie got the magic it’s when the villains were not in stone cuz cozy glow was the one who drained all the magic wait am I wrong or not cuz I don’t remember lol plz say I’m wrong or not in the comments of this comment
I just thank you bye I don’t know I hope that broker a hole by three guys they are never chocolate rain that mean is if only they are have magic in this box is chilling with it it’s steals have magic not so much interested this one OK I’m really
Not to say anything but she did a lot more then her kids she has to do her work and her family is not in school 🏫 was her day to do the work for me that was a lot better and I will have a great 👍 I would be very very good I will only need a few friends that she has to pay for the house she has told her she wants her and her family she is so sorry to pay 💰 she was so I was wondering if you were going home 🏠 is that time for her kids I would like to go to school 🏫 I love 💓 it all I know is I am a little sister I can not tell if I have her family and her family💸💳💷💶💴💵🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄
I have a great day at school this week I have been a long day of work for the kids is that we have a new one in our home tomorrow night we are all in our family so I will have a good night tomorrow and I have to go home and get to the kids is that we can give her her name so I know what I can see she told her she would have to go to get the kids her I told you I was wondering if you would have a chance if she would have been there she can get it she told you that I told you I 🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚
A very good and reasonable theory. I never saw the little detail that Pinkie also got some magic back. But, I don't now if that makes sense, when the chaos magic infected Pinkie in the past too, shouldn't the magic also infected Discord while he was powerless? He would've managed some chaotic things, because his magic influenced him from the future, when he got his magic back? Like Pinkie and her abilities? Or maybe she realizes that she's in a cartoon, because she broke the fourth wall more than one time. It's like when you are realizing that you are dreaming, you can control the dream (okay, mostly you just wake up). That's why Pinkie can use simple cartoon tricks. O^O Okay, that would be too far fetched. XD A crazy idea, I know. XD
I think that you are right about pinkie and discord’s chaos magic, however I think the reason that it affected pinkie differently than cozy is that pinkie also absorbed the princesses magic. I think that princess magic and chaos magic might have been so much that it spread out, but chaos magic on its own wasn’t enough, hence why cozy wasn’t affected.
A while back, I came to the same conclusion; Pinkie had somehow been infused with Chaos magic. I didn’t know how, but thanks to your vid, I can see a good picture
As much as I like this theroy and I do believe Pinkie has magic unlike unicorns, alicorns, pegesai and normal earth ponies I don't think it is discord's. I also don't think Pinkie is meant to be solved. She is unique and random and can break phisics apparently But maybe Pinkie Pie has as many layers to her magic as an onion or she is just as confusing and weird as a cross between an orange and a frog. As fun as it is to theorise maybe in this case the best answer is the simplest one: Pinkie is Pinkie and that's how it's supposed to be.
I think that the reason Pinky took Discored’s magic so well is because there related. If one of Discord’s relatives married someone and one of their kids didn’t have chose magic they probably wouldn’t talk to them kinda like in Harry Potter with pure bloods and skwibs. Since women take a men’s sr name when they marry the pie family could be related to Discored but since Pinky was the only one who absorbed Discores magic she is the only one with those qualities and that might be why she looks so different.
I think you theory right, and the reason it only affected Pinkie and not CozyGlow is because the magic may have been more unstable without Discord to contain it. I can’t remember if this is true or not but alicorn magic may have been in the bell when Pinkie used it.
Cozy Glow could also been effected by cauose magic but instead of making her have reality breaking powers from the bell she was led down a very unusual path becoming evil and all that stuff. Because of these different reactions too the magic could have made them go down paths that made them have said reactions to the magic in the bell. But that’s just my theory!
she couldn’t teleport out of tartarus or literally defy gravity in there or anything that pinkie does normally, so when it showed she got magic that might have just been what she always uses. as for pinkie sense, i think she’s being honest about her not knowing how it works, it’s natural.
I mean, pinkie did seem pretty in control of that chaos magic, so it is very possible she had been dealing with it her whole life, or at least a very large portion of it, and it is raw chaos magic, so there is literally no predicting how it will react to different ponies.
As much as i love this theory, there's one problem. Pinkie Sense. I mean, sure, she can kinda predict future, but then... What about Maud Pie and Cheese Sandwich? They have their senses too. Cheese has a sense that lets him know where parties are going to happen and Maud... Okay, i'm not fully sure how her sense works, but she found the guy in that one episode, so yeah. And it is possible that some earth ponies have that kind of magic with them, looking at the fact, that we saw only earth ponies have this kind of... Do i call it magic or sense? X3 If it is magic, that would explain why Pinkie "got her magic back" in that one scene and AJ didn't. And one more. Cheese Sandwich is practically, almost the same as Pinkie Pie, so how did he get... The way he is??? So i'm still gonna go with "It's Pinkie Pie, don't question it" ^^
What I want to know is why couldn't Cozy Glow or her friends absorb the alicorn magic in the bell? Tirek said that they couldn't use their magic until they learned how to handle Discord's magic inside the bell. Later on, however, Discord was able to take back his Chaos magic while leaving the alicorn sisters magic inside the bell. If they could have left Discord magic in the bell while only absorbing the alicorn magic, was plot convenience the only thing preventing them?
Also, why was Pinkie able to use the bell? We had a whole episode dedicated to the villains sneaking into the Canterlot archives to figure out how to use the bell, to begin with.
I don’t like the time travel thing in this context. What happened to the timeline where Pinkie DIDN’T do all the crazy stuff she does? I think Discord may have *ahem* “bonded” with one of Pinkie’s ancestors, and the magic just skipped a couple thousand generations. It’d even be too many “great-“s to consider them related
I had a theory that all ponies have magic inherent to them, it's just that unicorns have a way of channelling it easily through their horns. It can be harder for pegusai and earth ponies to access their magic, but there is some evidence of them using magic, such as fluttershy inherently being able to understand any animal, rainbow dash being able to perform a sonic rainboom (with the rainbow element of that not really making sense without magic), the apple family with their higher than average strength (this is the weakest link I admit, but there is something to be said for earth ponies always being referred to as the best at growing and tending to plants, maybe their magic helps this), and pinkie pie with her.... everything. I feel like she is much more in tune with her magic than any other earth pony or pegasus, maybe even some unicorns, and this could be explained by the chaos magic theory! This is just an idea though! I feel like it fits a little better with the initial intent behind the show, since the beginning wasnt written with the end in mind!
0 likes
my mom2020-07-25 23:25:45 (edited 2020-07-25 23:25:55 )
sir, pinkie getting a thing of magic when it came back explains everything, period
I love this theory but I don't think she is as powerful as discord or the power she absorbed took away from discord's. I would like to believe its just pinkie. She is the comedic but secretly deep and smart character.
TL;DR WARNING Maybe it's because Cozy Glow was already a very gifted unicorn and was an Alicorn at the time of partaking of the chaos magic, so being a creature that was already familiar with magic and had princess level magical capabilities, the chaos just blinded her judgment and messed up her magic. Pinkie Pie, being an Earth Pony, only had enhanced strength from the magic in the atmosphere. Since she never had an affinity for any other form of basic magic, the chaos magic, being as powerful as it was, had a much more drastic effect on her. It probably exposed the 4th Wall to her and several (not all) of her alternate counterparts across the multiverse at a very young age (like her human and comic book counterparts). It might have also allowed her to see past the 4th Wall and break it like Discord can on occasion. It probably also affected her physiology, giving her minor access to the fictional phenomenon that usually, only Looney Toons character are capable of; Toon Force, which is how she is able to summon multiple pony hooves around the screen and literally shatter herself after hours of repressed excitement. But these feats can be performed (as Roger Rabbit explains) " only when it's funny". I say "minor" because although she is capable of the aforementioned feats, she is definitely can't do anything akin to sawing the country in half or lassoing the moon (without assistance).
I sorta have a link on to this theory about the part about cozy glow and pinkie pie. 1. Pinkie had the magic of friendship while cozy did not accept the concept (well not entirely) 1. Pinkie may not be a fully grown pony but I’m pretty sure she was older than cozy glow and cozy is just a filly. So maybe being younger made here less powerful or something?
the flaw with this theory is that cheese sandwich has a cheesy sense, yet he hadn't ever gotten chaos magic, unless he got in an outbranching alternative timeline..
I think that the reason Pinky's chaos magick when all through the timeline is because she actually used the magic and new what she could do and cozy glow to use the magic it was in her bloodline but it didn't stay in it because she didn't know how to use it so maybe chaos magic intently takes one use of it to have it go through your entire bloodline and for it to stay that way
It's the creators of My Little Pony just wanting to have someone in the series who can break the forth wall. Oof. Most series have this sorta thing ya know?
It seems like she would've gotten her abilities from that moment, But it also may have been Rainbow Dash's Sonic Rainboom, All that rainbow energy, Pinkie MUST'VE had to get special abilities to earn her cutie mark and fufill her destiny!
If it effects her entire lifespan, than each time she gets more chaotic than the last right? It is really hard to word it so it isn't confusing
0 likes
The Peanut2020-07-23 04:46:18 (edited 2020-07-23 04:46:49 )
Crazy part is when pinkie pie absorbed the magic she seem to be able to control it "no one can control discords magic"proving that pinkie pie is in some way different than the others
I do love pinky pie but I do think this theory which you just brought up is correct! I do have a doubt of my own too it is like this: Everyone has to die in one movement of time and if that really happened then the mane 5 (not twilight ) would die and TIREK, CHRESOLES, and COZY GLOW would be set free even if the young 6 can handle it they never fought with them (except for the end) so Equestria will be doomed with no heroes to save !!! If that really comes then what will happen???
This is true, but in one of the early episodes, twilight actually gives pinkie an enhancing potion and pinkie says it, 'allowed me to see through space and time' SPACE AND TIME! So maybye, she managed to go into her future, not her past?
An explanation for why th chaos magic didn't effect cozy th same is probably simply because she's so young that it didn't hv far to go n her past wich actually might also explain why she's "evil" in that that was th effect of chaos magic on her past from that point but her future is far more vast especially since she is now trapped n stone so yeah if they do get released one day n future generation maybe we'll see that effect and that would b interesting
I DID MU Research! according to many sights it says that the energy of the porson (in this case pony) that possesses the magic depends wether the magic is dark or for good e.x pinky did not use the magic to hurt someone but cosyhooves did so it may effect how long the magic last and some say it can even stay for a lifetime. so yes, more than likely its bc discord.
Yeah your kind of wrong but doesn't explain the other world Pinky so here's what I think he's an interdimensional party God incarnated as Pinkie and yeah that would make a lot of sense because party gods are usually chaos users
Remember the episode pinkie, maud, and rarity went to manehatten? When maud was looking for the pony that had pinkies cannon, she found him instantly. Pinkie said it was maud sence, which runs in the family...
I've been watching ur channel since I was like twelve and now I'm almost an adult and was finally able to find ur channel again UGH SAME GOOD VIDEOS I LOVE U
Shouldn't Pinkie Pie be the one who is Princess? Because she brings happiness to everyone and she brings everyone together too. And makes Friendship also happened too.
In the comic, pinkie goes into the chaos dimension and becomes the ruler of chaos. They have to "defeat" her. Maybe she sent back some magic from there to when she was a filly
i might be the only one to see it but something got my eye for one pinky has way more control over the magic than cosy glow and she absorb more magic by the lightning cold mean she took more magic than she did
This theory dosent work i mean think about it. Maud says that she has a maud sense to and then pinkie pie said that it runs in the family, so unless maud also touched grogars bell then it wouldn't be possible for this to be true. Also human pinkie. She didn't touch the bell either.
Hmmm idk cause if pinkie pie got all of discord’s magic from the bell then all the other times she could predict the future and break the fourth wall would happen after she got his powers but it all happened before so at least that’s my theory but I also like your theory but I do have a question if pinkie got discord’s magic near the finale only for a minute than how was she able to break the fourth wall and predict the future in previous episodes?
it think pinky may have accidentally infused her time line not knowing about magic as she is a earth pony and did not know the danger of effecting your own time line she was the one to dress up like Marty when twilight what to relive some she did not go to suggest she has a fascination with it and cozy know about magic would like not risk any thing that might mess with the time line
Idk but for the cozy glow thing she already had alaicorn magic inside of her so maby she had enough magic inside of her that it controlled the chaos magic time wise through out her life idk just a hunch like if u agree
gacha atmosphere2020-07-14 07:30:30 (edited 2020-07-14 07:31:27 )
Wait. The Equestria Girls the time loop episode if this theory is correct she could've predicted the future and the past without her acknowledging just like the part when Twilight Sparkle trying to confess she's from another world. I am confused.
I think her crazyness came with her cutie mark. Think about it went she had no cutie mark she was miserable but when it came she went crazy (⊙_◎) just like discord. And that progress along in the years. Also when balloons pop it makes them go crazy and not act like themselves. Helloo that is pinkie pie.
I’m sure you don’t need any but: here’s a video idea! What is starswirl the bearded’s cutie mark? He’s always hid it under his starry blue cloak! Edit: never mind you can see it in an episode
I think that could be possibe and that could happen or it is just pinkie being pinkie pie otherless we will find out and mabye future videoes your theorie could be correct
What about the Pinkie Pie in the human world??? And what about the Discord magic????? The thing about the discord thingy thing didnt showed up at at Season 1-5 tho...
Pinky wouldn't have even taken the magic if this didn't take the magic before she took the magic, Your also saying she didn't get her cutie mark until she took the magic, Your saying equestria was taken over by night mare moon and all the other villans cause pinkie moved to pony ville to use her talents for better than distracting her family, all I'm saying is this doesn't make sense, just my very long opinion I hope this did not make you feel bad if it did I am very sorry.
She is a new creature that they have not put in the show she is a changing a new one. What if she is a changing that take happiness instead, take love or giving love. No steal my thinking pls
Haven't started the video yet, but I'm gonna say it's gotta be chaos magic. How else could she have not only handled Discord's chaos magic in the finale, but also was able to use it to create chocolate rain? It's because she DOES know how to control some of it, because she already does use chaos magic to some degree.
3:48 Okay, so it was definitely related, but it's definitely different. My theory implies that pinkie was always able to use chaos magic by sheer chance(or genetic mutation?), rather than by her gaining all this chaos magic. Anyways, here's my theory in full.
The reason why pinkie acts the way she does is because she already has chaos magic. It wasn't given to her by some future event, it was always with her, even since birth. How does the pinkie getting chaos magic event tie into this? Well, it's because of Cozy Glow. When Cozy Glow got Discord's chaos magic, she tried hard to control it. But, chaos magic, by it's nature, is impossible to control unless you have experience. I'm pretty sure Discord said this, or that it was said at some point, but I can't remember when. Anyways, the takeaway from that is that *chaos magic is impossible to control unless you have experience in using it*. So, why is it that Pinkie is able to create a very specific thing(chocolate rain) when she has chaos magic? The reason for this is simple, it's because she already has had experience using chaos magic, and is hence able to control it now.
As for the Pinkie sense? Well, that's one problem with this. No, the problem isn't that chaos magic can't allow for predicting the future, it's that we don't know for sure if it can. I don't remember seeing Discord use chaos magic to predict the future ever, or anyone using magic for the matter, so I can't know for sure. If someone can point out an instance where any type of magic has predicted the future(even if it was unsuccessful), then that would make pinkie sense being powered by chaos magic a possibility.
Okay so, I have another theory. The Young 6 all do represent the elements of harmony. If you look at the last episode where at the end when they sang the song magic of friendship and at the end showed all Characters that resembles too the mane 6 chacters. So SilverStream represents the element of laughter, this actually makes total sense because In a lot the episodes You can see, how she wants everyone to be happy and always makes everyone laughs, just like pinky. Yona represent honesty, she is always honest with he group and in ever episode we have seen in her, she always never afraid to speak the truth. Smolder represents loyalty, the way she’s loyal within In the group and in most of the episodes when some one gets in trouble, she’s the first one to Volunteer to pay the same price as them, and just go back to the episodes and you can see her loyalty. Sandbar represents kindness, I’m School Daze he was the one, the only pony In the school you really wanted to be with the other creatures, and also just go back to all the other episodes he acts literally just like flutter shy. Ocellus represents Generosity, I’m one episode you can see her giving her friends notes 📝 for the hw, and always helping them study and etc, u can see in the episodes how she resembles rarity. Well, the last one I don’t have a clue, the last one points to Gallous idk how he represents magic, but he’s some one resemblance to Twilight. Please give to a like so He can see it! Edit: In School Daze II, you can see sandbar is glowing in Fluttershy color, Smolder Rainbowdash color, Yona Apple Jacks color, Siverstream as pinky color, Ocelous as Rarity color, Galleous as twilight color! :)
Interesting theory. I've always assumed, as it has been proven that all ponies have some magic in them, that some just have more magic in them than others. The Mane Six in general are freaks of nature, and Pinkie is just an example of an earth pony mare with exceptional magic levels. Really exceptional levels in Pinkie's case, which does seem to run in the Pie family to an extent. I could be mistaken though.
I always had the theory that someone has to be chaotic in some way to harness Chaos Magic without stealing it from someone else. Discord is physically chaotic, I mean just look at the guy. However, I believe Chaos Magic can be harnessed by someone who's MENTALLY chaotic, or rather, insane in some way. People who are mentally unwell tend to appear detached from the real world. It wouldn't be too much of a stretch that the wandering sanity of a broken mind can find itself in places beyond reality, and possibly tapping into a power that is truly impossible to understand, just like it's impossible for us to truly understand Pinkie Pie.
It could be that Pinkie Pie, already being pretty chaotic in personality, was simply more attuned to the chaos magic than Cozy Glow. Perhaps she truly became one with chaos for that moment, whereas Cozy Glow just had strange power within her for a moment. That closer connection that Pinkie Pie establishes could be what causes the magic to leave lasting effects throughout her timeline as you suggest.
This is a great theory and all, but then how would you explain Maud sense when they go to Manehattan?Pinkie Pie says it runs in the family so I would like to assume that maybe a little chaos spread to the first people she spent the most time with.But that doesn’t really make sense, because that’s the only other chaotic thing about her family and Maud in general. You could count there weird obsessions with rocks, but I feel like that was there before Pinkie.
well chaos magic interacted with two different beings, pinkie has chaotic good intentions, while cozy glow had evil intentions, the magic then reflected that on the outside, while still both crazy, they had much different personalities and intentions. , just a thought
it does make sense because in a way she had an even more understanding of how to use it. With Cozy Glow, all she saw and used (well wanted too) it for was power. but Pinkie being the way she is and the fact that she was friends with Discord had understanding on how to just "go with the flow" to use his magic. This could have cause the Magic of Chaos to... Merge with Pinkie's spirit, effecting it through out all time but hey that's..... JUST A THEORY... A PONY THEORY...... ok im done imitating TGT xD
Ive watching your channel for some time (I like theory channels) but one thing that has never been explained in MLP is how can spike send messages to Celestia's and back no other creature seems to have this ability. Did Spike inheritance some twilight magic to so he do this?
I actually figured this out. The elements were found in the tree of harmany. The geods are found in a cave in camp everfree. Even the tree is in a small cave beneath the catsle. What im trying to say is that the geods are the elements of HARMANY.
I think more then likely pinkie got her powers from when twilight was a child and the rainboom unleashed her powers and it traveled with the rainboom to pinkie first and gave her some strange connection to twilight magic.
It fits the order and we see pinkie get hit with the rainboom aftershock full on.
You have to take into account that the writers would not of thought this far ahead to the end they came too so the end with pinkie getting that power was just a throw away thing and has nothing to do with her powers.
I JUST thought of something about this video that wasn't explained..... if Pinkie got her Pinkie Sense while she held Discord's Chaos Magic..... what about Cheese Sandwich and how did he get his Cheesy Sense? And to expand upon that, we know they have a foal together. Does Little Cheese inherit mom's Pinky Sense, or dad's Cheesy Sense? or will she inherit both, having an ultimate Cheesy-Pinkie Sense?!
Think of it this way; a being's mental state can alter the potency of chaos magic like when discord tried to throw a tea party for fluttershy and made himself too "normal" therefore diminishing his powers and existence. Pinkie's mental state is a constant wild party, and though the theory of pinkie getting chaos magic at that one moment seems to be a paradox as without it to begin with she would have been extremely different and probably would have never been there to attain said magic but chaos magic is just that; chaotic; anything and/or everything impossible and/or paradoxical can and/or will become possible possibly, maybe, it's a possibility and at the same time not
This could make sense but she could just have a stronger connection to magic than most earth ponies do. All ponies have magic to an extent, they all have cutie marks. Unicorns and Alicorns have the strongest connection to magic by default but that doesn't mean other ponies or creatures for that matter, can't tap into it or even use it to the same extent or greater if they went far enough. That might be taboo in Equestria or just very hard to achieve though so very few go for it. I think of Equestrian magic as kind of like the speed force from The Flash and The Force from StarWars. Its there, however difficult it might be to do so it can be manipulated for better or worse, it can be given to someone, it can be taken away, it's just drawn to some individuals and some are drawn to it, it can probably be killed, and it can probably be manufactured. Some individuals can just tap into it more than most can or even bother to. It's flowing through their world like air. Its everywhere. Someone is bound to be able to use it.
I have said it before and I'll say it again. Pinkie is the most powerful being in Equestria. Here's a new way to look at it. Her 4th wall breaking means she is in touch with the dimension of her universe's creators. That would put her in the category of angel/demon in our world. Crazy...
Okay. I'll try too fit as much of this as I can into this comment so bear with me. Here is my extended version of that theory.
Yes. Pinkie was infused with chaos magic through her timeline, but how does chaos magic work? I think it's tied to emotions. Discord does what he wants, when he wants until he makes friends! Pinkie herself could barely control it before discord took it back, and cozy couldn't at all with the emotional Turmoil of being a villain. That being said, pinkie was affected directly, but the ponies she cared about were also indirectly affected. I got this from the cheese sense and Maud sense left unexplained. Ponies have pickaxes. They dont normally drill through solid rock with their hooves or EAT THEM. But discord eats whatever. From paper to phones. And Maud being seemingly her closest sister, showing up a lot more and bsff stuff got the Maud sense. Cheese sandwich later determined pinkies canon romantic partner also has a special bond with her affecting him In a similar way. Heck he even opens a gag factory! And after being stuck being bored, loses his laugh like discord was fading when he invited fluttershy over to his house. This happens to pinkie too, in party of one, and with her yak instrument that I can't spell! Cheese and pinkie had bonds but Maud only had boulder until mudbriar so she turned out different chaotic? The mane 6 could also have been affected, but their direct connection to the tree of harmony allowed them to control it better, like how discord's vine seeds wouldn't grow right away. But fluttershy having the close bond with discord gave her a little more power, where her stare came from, that can out stare cockatrices!!!
In the same episode where Pinkie Pie gets "her magic" her food rots and twlight says that it's because there's no magic protecting it but none of the cakes have magic so either it's Pinkie or a different Unicorn or maybe a spell done by Celestia
pinkie has VERY chaotic nature, maybe, because of that, when pinkie drowned discords magic, chaotic magic matched on pinkie's nature... and this explains why she could (somehow) control discords magic but cozy couldn't
I like your theory and events in the future affecting the past is actually not beyond the laws of physics in thus world even if when dont have that massive example like pinkie pie.
But if the magic itself is not bound to time then I could see this. Some holes in the theory though. Wouldn't discord still have some level of magic after it was absorbed if it floods the time line of the soul getting it? Even if it was just small things like pinkie does. Though i can also explain this away with discord being a creature of chaos that NEEDS chaos to exist. Proven in the episode where he forces himself to be normal so my thinking is the chaos that keeps him alive is all that's left but pinkie is a pony and never needed chaos magic. Since it flooded her timeline later in her life the chaos magic in her I guess you would say life force had the ability to spread out in both directions. This gave pinkie pie time to learn to use the chaos magic. Those abilities you were showing. And while she STILL would not have been able to control ALL of it she had enough of a handle on it to control it a bit when she was flooded with the magic since her only real time travel was a sense that this or that was going to happen. Meanwhile, cozy glow being a younger pony had mostly only one direction in her life force to travel. To her future. She didn't get the training time with it that pinkie did. But that's just a theory!
The word you're looking for is "retrocausality": future events causing past events. One possible way for the world to have retrocausality is for it to have a "blocky" time. Basically, it's an alternative view of time. The future and past exists as surely as the present, and for the future to influence the past is as natural as the past influencing the future. It's as if the past and the future are the left and right sides of a giant mural. There is an internal logic to the mural: it's not random. This internal logic constrains the left side and the right side to not break away from each other's influence. In the same way, the past and the future are bound by a logic beyond time, and the future can constrain the past just like the past constrains the future..
Cozy Glow wanted the magic to be put back in the bell Pinkie did not so maybe for that split second she spread that magic through her timeline willingly.
Maybe the Cosy Glow theory is that the chaos magic can tell if you are going to use it for good or evil. If it could, it would only change pinkie's past because she wasn't going to be evil with her rare power.
Hey sawtooth, what would happen if equestria had to deal with every villain they ever had at once. yknow like they all come back at the same time and joined forces against equestria. Just curious to know.
After a week of thinking about this video I have finally figured it out so what I think is pinkie pie and other earth pony’s like cheese sandwich have a special kind of magic passes through there family like when we found out Maud has Maud sense she’s pinkies sister after all anyway, this magic givers her a special pinkie sense and allows her to teleport define the laws of physics and other things she has done that is completely separate from discord’s chaos magic so far the only pony’s with these abilities are earth pony’s you said in a video a long time ago all pony’s are born with magic maybe so earth pony’s are born with those magical abilities this is why pinkie pie gets a pink dot through her that’s her pinkie sense so please read this 👍🥳 and take it into consideration 👍👍
What mystery? Everypony knows she’s made of giggles and gumdrops Oven mitts and out-takes Doodles and donuts Fairytales and fruitcake Chaos and cupcakes Lots and lots of batter Sugar and sunshine Lollipops and laughter. 😄
HEY! What's up! I'm your biggest fan, and I know this has no relation to Pinkie, but I think that Rainbow Dash DOES deserve her element. I mean, yeah sure she hasn't been TOO loyal from the beginning of the series, but that's the thing about my theory. I think that she has been Building Up her loyalty. You know like character development, and that stuff. So I hope you read my comment on that theory of yours, and maybe change your mind about that. I find Rainbow very interesting.... WITHOUT THE EGO OF COURSE! I can give you some more theories to think about because I'm a big fan of MLP. Bye!
You just had to include stuff from "FPK". I really hated that episode. Seeing my favorite character get punished to no end really wasn't all that funny to me. Sure it was supposed to be a throwback to classic "Looney Toons" slapstick but doesn't it really only work if a character is unlikable enough to deserve it? Opinion: Twilight was just trying to observe Pinkie Pie's behavior.
I’m not saying your wrong. Because you stand a pretty good point my friend, But I bet it’s just 70% Discord’s magic and 30% of Pinkie just being Pinkie 😋
just my opinion on why the magic had a more permanent state with pinky and not cozy glow is because cozy glow was trying to use the magic in a structured way and not chaotically like the magic is intended where as for pink when she used the magic she en-braised the chaos and didn't try to put any rules or structure to it there for the magic ended up staying with her because it felt like it belonged there in a way sorry if this doesn't make sense just what i was thinking of why it effected them in different ways
I do believe she can tap into chaos magic I just don't think it's from that event because cheese sandwich while only in 1 episode could also do stuff that defies logic what if all party ponys can use chaos magic
I think the only person to rival Pinkie Pie or even be close to being her, is a character name Jyushimatsu-san from the anime Osomatsu-san. If you watch the anime which is a literal comedy and anything random can happen. The character Jyushimatsu-san can literally do anything with a smile on his face!
0:10 you should watch the video titled Eqestria Girls (bloopers compared to actual scenes) and whenever you see the one involving pinkie pie where she holds the purple lollipop you’ll understand it all well for the Otherworld knowledge part
Pinkie Pie is a Toon. A fourth waller. A super sane. No, it isn't a typo. Super sane. Smarter than your average character to the point of knowing they are fictional. That's it.
I think the reason Pinky Pie was affected and Cosy wasn’t is because Cosy wanted to dominate, while Pinky wanted it so she can be with it, one wanted control, the other just wanted it for fun
Where do the Kirin's come in? They have an episode but how did they come to be? Who are the Kirin's? What are the Kirin's and why can they be lit on fire? I have many questions but they may be answered by the series I haven't finished it
i want to say a theory about mlp so when sombra broke the elements its magic escaped to sunsets world so i think thats how the magic hit that cave in the everfree forest and that solves question sunset said that "where did the magic came that hit this cave ;
0 likes
Alfred Lekstakaj2020-07-05 11:41:07 (edited 2020-07-05 11:44:33 )
Not relating to this video but I was rewatching the finale of the show and i noticed when you see flurry hearts glass window a few frames before you see sweetie bell and some yellow I imagine the yellow would be apple bloom and off screen would be scootaloo what did the quite mark crusaders do to earn a stained glass window. Out of context in this in the same episode when twilight is reading they news paper you see (I think) Lyra and bonbon getting married THEY ArE MARRIED And 8 think doctor hooves has a wife during the coronation idk
BUTT if that one moment of chaos affected pinkies entire life what about cheese sandwich? He can do the exact same as pinkie including pulling things out of thin air so why are they so simular?
wait but it may affected Cozy glow because we dont really go fully in depth with her past or at least not what i remember so she might have had the same affects and as the show went on pinkie was still crazy so if Cozy glow didnt get turned to stone then we may of seen the chaos unfold i her
I just realised in the song ( the magic of friendship grows ) when twilight made a rainbow with the horn every single teacher had 1 of the student 6 so maybe thats their element??
That means that Pinkie Dayamana Pie is still out there waiting for her chance to replace PP here and I think that when Pinkie got her Cuite Mark her evil twin came out of her and I think she will definitely come in Pony Life that is the new Sieris that Hasbro will release soon
I never noticed taht pinkie got thay lil' pink ball thing. I think you're right. I mean she does have pinkie sense but she said it only interacts with instint things. like a falling flower pot.
I have little thing to say. It might help. But the magic what came to Pinkies nose wasnt maybe some special sort of magic just the pinkie sense come back. The thing that she have experiences from another dimension is showed in equestria girls shorts where Pinkies from both world just go through portal. They even saw themself. Than we know that Pinkie have a lot of things hiden through ponyville( if someone know that she pulled something out of nowhere and she wasnt in ponyville just say it). The braking of 4 wall well i havent for explained that yet.
Oh wait i have it ,maybe the pinkie sense and braking 4 wall really came from discord magic. We know that when she was only a filly she was same as her sisters but thanks to the rainboom she sawed that day die felt happy and that everyone should fell this happines its impossible that she got her sense and abylity to break 4 wall just from seeing big rainbow.
i don't know about the pinkie sense part but i have a theory about the part of how cozy glow did not get the magic as well so i think it matter is how the pony uses the magic cozy glow used it for evil evil and sense discord does not use his magic for evil anymore (well i think) and pinkie used it for chaos like it was meant to be used so it stuck longer with pinkie pie but that's my theory
I have a theroy about the episode pinkie apple pie. When the part about pies and apple being related was sumged, I think it might have ment pear scince they are related kinda, even though they are related from apple Jack's parents not apple sauce applejacks great great granny. I hope you use this theroy in one of your videos, or at least read it and consider using it in one of your videos, thank you.
Because her magic was too weak. Princess Celestia is really strong, you see, and futuristic Twilight, too. They are already used to their powers, and their at it's peak. Luna wasn't yet used to her magic yet.
Ok i get what hes trying to say, but when he said "thats why she can Break All the fission" Im Like wait didnt she take all his magic On the VERY last Ep?!
Also ppl Take these way to sirously! xD Its A Kids Show ment for kids xD
Twilight after watching this: pinkie com here I need to monitor you. Pinkie: twilight I don’t think that is nessesery you know I was (says what you said in 1 sentence)
Okay just hear me out how cadence became an alicorn but more canon because canon what if she got here wings or horn or both st the same time she got her cutie mark for spreading love between others or CREATING romantic love between others because she is the princess of romantic and motherly love and we know she wasn’t a mother or had fallen in love with shining armor at the time she had met twilight unless shining armor and her dated secretly for a few years before even meeting but it seems a little off so I’m gonna assume that they started dating afterwards also I feel like twilight velvet I Bilieve that’s her name also could have gotten an opportunity to become the princess of motherly ness maybe she reaches it to twilight to reconnect more after spending so long away from eachother with all the princess stuff and cadence could be the princess of love for all because she shows a lot of love to her subjects more than she does for shining armor even tho there love if definitely strong I donno I’d have to plan it out more and not just ramble like this but I have no clue what this was originally about
Pinkie Pie she has been confuseing me after I saw her manners she has magic that no other Earth Pony hase remember when Pinkie Pie is sad she turns into her evil twin Pinkie Dayamana Pie you know when Pinkie got upset in the episode Party Of One I notesed something right before turning into Pinkie Dayamana Pie I saw her mane get even for poofy and suddenly her mane and tale got flat at that acsact second her colour went dark and grayish pink and when Rainbow Dash came Pinkie was angry and she had a pile of rocks there to
Brony can u make a vid about the princesses hair because in season nine without there magic it became normal... As soon as discord gives There magic there hair became all wavy and pretty again like 🤔🤔🤔 and if it's alicorn magic why does cadence not have it.......and what does cadence look like In the end...And in the song This is where the magic happens if u look closely the stain glass windows flurry heart and the young six are on there What happened? What did they accomplish? All of us know that to go on the stain glass windows Is IMPORTANT and where are the princesses did they die did cadence die? What is flurry hearts cutey mark? SO MANY QUESTIONS Please answer the hair question if you only want to do 1
Do you have a different channel? I feel like I used to watch your videos a long time ago, but wasn’t your name something else? Your oc is really familiar to my brain.
I know this vid is not for cutie marks but remember when you posted 6 years ago why cutie come in three THREE IS THE MAGICAL NUMBER!!! I fund the resin!!! I think?
I have a theory that could explain mlp it’s goes like this humans evacuated the earth due to a meteor but stray animals hid a few years later pints start coming if you agree reply
Remember when u made the vid four years ago and said why are other crystal more powerful then others spike could of ate one then he got his magic of how he can send letters to the Princesses but if u don’t remember then WELP IM OUT BYEEEE
I think you can't solvd pinkie , she is just a gag and the magic who got back to her is just an error and pinkie is just pinkie 🤗 sorry for not belive in you 😔
This Editor2020-07-08 07:37:29 (edited 2020-07-08 07:46:27 )
I think there's something wrong with my Netflix the next season is not coming out for me 😭 so I have to watch your old videos so it's not bloopers for me and I have to wait for season 9 to come out 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
It’s not that because that was in season 9 when she did and all that stuff like that happened it’s just pinkie not discoed I mean they both are the same but It’s prob when Discord did that thing where he made the applejack a lier fluttershy rude rainbow dash selfish rarity idk and pinkie just got some thing more than the others
Has anyone who watches "My Little Pony Friendship is Magic" that Pinkie Pie is the most odd pony in the series. Well I've notice this a lot, Pinkie Pie maybe the element of Laughter but she is so oblivious when it comes to knowing her own familys. Her friends see them as odd becausae of their personality and obesses with rocks but Pinkie Pie sees them as normal especially her own sister Maud. In The "Maud Couple" Pinkie Pie think that Mudbriar is super weird but Starlight Glimmer point out that Maud is the same way too but once again Pinkie Pie continued to be so oblivious that Starlight Glimmer is telling the truth and to acknowledge the facts about Maud. So in my opinion Pinkie Pie is the weirdest in her family because she doesn't see anything wrong with them. Which I may have a theory why Pinkie Pie is not like her family because she maybe adopted rather be born in the family because she's the only pony who is pink while the rest of her family are grey.
Scary reminder: Pinkie has a child now, and what makes it worst is that she had it with Cheese Sandwich. What chaos have they brought upon the world?!?!
3180 likesReplies (132)
THE MEANING OF TRUE CHAOS
322 likesOh god-
138 likesWouldnt be surprised if that filly becomes like Maud's boyfriend
157 likesDiscord has some competition for chaos lord
173 likesDiscord might have met his match
120 likesOH MY GOD----
57 likesOh no
44 likesHis name is Cheesecake!
61 likesSo did Cadence and Shining Armor, Mrs and Mr Cake, Mr and Mrs Sparkle, and everyone else in the world. But our lord and savior Celestia is too pure and holy so she adopted Cadence🤣🤣
59 likesA CHEESE SANDWICH!!!!!!! THIS IS CRAZYER THAN DIWCORDS KID, SCREWBALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! RUN FOR YOUR LIFE!!!!!!!!
43 likesWhile it did bind with her DNA, it most likely didn’t affect her sex chromosomes just to make sure that it wasn’t passed on. But if it did, it would’ve become a homogeneous recessive gene meaning that both parents have the rare trait in order for it to show in the offspring.
36 likesNo JUST no
7 likesAHH OMG
9 likesOH MAH GOSH NOW THEY ARE 3 CRAZY PEOPLE
14 likes@Sam yep
4 likesAnna. G oh no
4 likesconspiracy
7 likesOh danggg
6 likesOh god no-
24 likesPinkie, you have made both a grave mistake. And a very amazing choice.
Cheesecake is the true being of chaos, not Discord, not Pinkie, and not Cheese Sandwich. Lil Cheese is the true chaos being. He will rule the cosmos!
@Thomas Stump But both parents do have it... CHEESECAKE WILL DESTROY EQUESTRIA!
6 likesSad Reminder: Big Mac broke Marble Pies Heart
11 likesItz _ Kawaii _ Calico poor Marble :’(
5 likesa new god is the awnser
3 likesDiscord: "Can you spell 'apprentice'?"
6 likesHey! It ok that she is married to Cheese sandwich they both compliment each other
1 like@Mini Thakur it's not that they're married it's that the chaos may have passed to their child
3 likesAnd discord baby sits pinkies child
6 likeswait wha i- i didnt knew that
1 likeYjajmsnsaisbkahebsnsnabsysba0wgsbak9qgwkagsiwgeiwgwna8scdidvwoegeja9sgdiegekskapabsna9vsbsao
3 likesoh my gosh.
2 likesCough cough (Screwball) Cough Cough
2 likesWatch her grow up to be a draconeqquis
3 likesTHEY BROUGHT LARGE CHAOS MORE POWERFUL THEN DISCORD'S POWER
3 likesOh no-
0 likesDiscord can't compare
0 likeswait... I haven't seen all of season nine eye-
2 likesThe problem with giving characters children is that now they're the age of old grandparents and still have children that are as old, or younger, than the cmc.
2 likestheir kid looks like fluttershy
0 likesDiscord will be like her awesome, fun uncle XD
5 likesOh...no...
1 likeJevil: I CAN DO-
3 likesPinkie's son: you were saying?
Sam, that’s Mudbrier!
0 likesWATH 😱
0 likesOH NO
0 likes@Draconic lorecraft *Runs from current location to The moon* AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
2 likes@Thomas Stump Im bad at maths
0 likesOh God it'll be more power full then discards kud
1 likeI don’t understand :dun dun dun
0 likes@wonderhoyzz no
0 likesOh no...
0 likesThe next series: MIGHTY MORPHIN' PONY RANGERS! Villain: Little Cheese.
3 likesikr
0 likesOh nu
2 likesI think ponyville is cake now
Anna. G uh ho
0 likesOooh! I get it now...
0 likesi think the one that they lost their magic, i think the wrong magic came to pinkie pie
1 likescreeches
0 likesWhats so wrong with them having a kid? I ship them, and they’re kid is really cute
1 likePinkieshy LPS I don’t think you understand what Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich are capable of and how having a child could bring more chaos then Discord ever could.
2 likes@Mahilet Tekelsillasshe lil cheese is adorable
1 likeThinking about it
2 likesGives me chills
But yet I can't stop thinking about it
I'm happy and surprise
I can t example well
Im still thinking about it today!
Sam That’d be hilarious omg
0 likesBUT HE'S A LIZARD
0 likesYou actually made me scared and not make me go close to my computer
3 likesShe will have in future hah
0 likes:0
1 like@Sam u no watch season 8
0 likesA bruh moment indeed
2 likes@• L1zziebear • yes but i think Cheesecake is a girl
1 likePinkie: Oops!
1 likeUh oh
0 likes@hannah no, maybe she doesn't want to be in a relationship with anypony, because it would make sense why there isn't a king, or maybe she isn't into guys.
0 likesOh no I've watched this like 10 times and I JUST noticed this what has pinky done?!
1 like@RichyWhistles sooooooooo just a regular child XD
0 likes@Rachel Alfaro it's her baby
0 likesHuh oh no
0 likes@Sam Lol
0 likes😔
0 likesOh goodness- NO.
1 likeDoesn't she have 3 or was I confused during the entire time during that scene?
0 likesI actually backup that theory I think that would happen in season 10 but it never ever came out
0 likesStay safe too
0 likesOh like a innocent little bean like lil cheese is gonna destroy the world.
2 likesThe new queen of chaos for when Discord is sick!
1 like@Thomas Stump Too many complicated words for me to understand srry
0 likes@Minodh De Sylva PONIES
0 likesSWEET CELESTIA
1 like@Rachel Alfarowdym? No. In season 9, pinkie pie said "It was so hard to find a fool sitter (forgot how to spell it) with a sense of humor for lil' cheese."
1 likemmm cheese cakes
1 like@Sam WHAT
0 likesthir child is going to be a pony accountant
0 likesIts that own dude the Accordian
0 likesNo don't thank for likes aa the cringe
0 likes@Agent Isabelle discord almost lost to pijoke in his dimension that would drive almost snlypony crazy but he say pijoke might feel iHome there
0 likesWait so did pinkies kid inherited her powers?
0 likesCheese has the party sense, it has the same symptoms as pinkie pie has, but he is not preventing disasters, he knows where to go to host the party, maybe they both are somehow magical earth ponies?
0 likes@Sam %
1 likemy DAUGTHER HAS A CHILD?!?!?!?!?
0 likesCan someone please tell me the music of 1:16
0 likesIt's been a year. AND CHEESE SANDWICH?!😭 THAT'S LIKE THE WHOLE DESTRUCTION OF EQUESTRIA
0 likesBe grateful that it wasn't with discord the amount of chaos pinkie + discord = world of chaos
0 likes@•☆•smol snowfall•♡• I think we all know Fluttershy and Discord is the only way to have it
0 likesTrue chaos
1 likeYaasssd
0 likesThe world is doomed
0 likes@wonderhoyzz his name is cheese sandwich
0 likesDiscord isn't the Spirit of Chaos,it is actually Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich's child. DUN DUN DUUUUUUUN
0 likesI think Discord just meant his match!
0 likesImagine if it's actually the pure opposite of it's parents
0 likesWhen
0 likesCheese pie
1 likeDiscord needs to boost his level it gonna soon be more chaotic
0 likesyeah, her child is called lil cheese and is yellow so..her husband is cheese sandwich.
1 likeuh oh
0 likesDiscord should run
0 likesGAH!
0 likesUhhhh ohhh nooo
0 likes@Thomas Stump WHICH MEANS IN A FEW THOUSAND GENERATIONS SOME 2 PINKIE RELATIVES HAVE A CHILD AND DISCORD WILL MEET HIS MATCH
0 likesLol
0 likesLoL
0 likes@Thomas Stump ok
0 likes@Rose_Akira poor Marble :(
0 likesOk then pinkie is just being pinkie but that doesn't explain the magic that came to her what was magic that doesn't make sense how?
0 likesOh celestia sake please dont say it oh boy nuh uh 😦😶 nope please celestia no uhuh nuuh
0 likesOh celestia sake please dont say it oh boy nuh uh 😦😶 nope please celestia no uhuh nuuh
0 likes@wonderhoyzz Oh because Pie is a dessert, omg
0 likes@Thomas Stump You pass on everything in Dna, not just your sex chromesomes.
0 likesWait what
0 likesWait if pinkie has a child does that mean maud is an ant
0 likesWhat's wrong with having a baby she's 40 years old
0 likes@gummy bear gamer nothing wrong with having a baby, but she’s Pinkie Pie who can pass down whatever insane genes she has
0 likesthe chaos of sex
0 likesEverything makes sense in your explanation except for one occasion which wasn't considered.
697 likesWhen Pinkie Pie, Rarity, and Maud had that one meet-up (I believe the episode is 'The Gift of Maud Pie' - S6, E3), Maud 'sensed' and knew where the guy to whom Pinkie traded her canon was. As Rarity enquired, Pinkie answered with something along the lines of: "Yeah it goes down/through the family." and shrugged it off.
Replies (18)
"Pie Sense" could be truly genetics, maybe a slightly different race of pony??? A magic earth pony? Who knows. But Pinkie Pie still has extra magic that the other Pies don't seem to have (manipulating gravity, pulling stuff out of thin air, etc)
162 likes@Puppygirlman18 Maybe part Crystal Pony?? Would make sense why the family likes rocks lol
86 likes@Jamie L youve got a point there! They do have that pie family trait of rock farmers.
44 likes@Puppygirlman18 Maybe it's because of the chaos magic. I think that's what happened. So she did have that pie sense, but the magic had an influence on it, which made it stronger. It would also make sense as to why Cozy Glow didn't have the effect Pinkie Pie did.
35 likesMaybe an ancestor of Pinkie had absorbed Discord’s magic, without losing it, and it had passed through the family, slowly growing weaker? I’m unsure. Maybe discord isn’t that old to be able to have that happen.
18 likes@crab But I mean, Pinkie's sense seems stronger than the rest of her family.
19 likes@Miint_Tea hm,, you’re right.
8 likesRarity: however did you know that?
7 likesMaud: maud sense.
Pinkie: runs in the family!
Maud/Pinkie sense could be the Pie family's version of earth pony magic- their "connection to the earth", as it will.
4 likesMaybe it's specifically because Pinkie has that sense, and specifically because it relates to time and predictions, that the chaos magic scattered through the timeline for her, but not for Cozy.
Maybe when Pinkie made the rock candy when she was a
2 likesfilly she put her manic in it and maud ate one little piece and it got ttrafured to her
i just got done wathching that eposode
1 likei think rather than it being proof that discord's magic affected her past.....
0 likespinkie sense is WHY it affected her past.
Also the only reason she was able to handle it.
Her Pinkie sense made her able to distribute magic through her timeline. Which in turn meant that when she got discord's magic she was able to handle it.
maybe it just kept going? if it went through pinkies whole timeline, maybe it went to mom pie and dad pie too. why stop there? chaos magic is inherently un explainable.
0 likesCan someone please tell me the music of 1:16
0 likesCan someone please tell me the music of 1:16
0 likesCan someone please tell me the music of 1:16
0 likesPlus, it’s also odd how pinkie got pink skin and pink curly hair while the rest of her family members seem to have a grey-ish complex with straight hair
0 likesTbf, maid could sense a person, but pinkie can sense a point in time. There's a difference between sensing the future and sensing a person
0 likesThis and, discord can be seen doing a jiggle similar to the "pinkie sense" when all the princesses gave twilight their magic to keep it safe in the episode Twilight's castle.
265 likesReplies (4)
You remember when he says his ears are burning?? He can be all knowing in a way
6 likesActually Discord sensed that there is magic gone
2 likes@Stefan Kocoski yes and he can break dimensions
5 likesoooohhh! nice catch!
2 likesSawtooth Waves: so I finally solved Pinkie Pie--
211 likesTwilight: WRITE THAT DOWN! WRITE THAT DOWN!
Replies (13)
i'm cackling omg
6 likesPinkie pie is the most annoying horse you ever met
1 likeLol twi being a bruh moment
2 likes@Cool Kidd ahem?
5 likes@PinkiePiePlays I mean you're a fun loving horse
5 likes@Cool Kidd hmm
2 likesOkie dokie lokie👌👌✨✨✨
@PinkiePiePlays wait...
3 likesIf you look into the camera... CAN U SEE US!?
@1vx1x3 yep✨✨✨
3 likes@PinkiePiePlays holy fuc-
3 likes@PinkiePiePlays I’m scared now-
3 likes@1vx1x3 and you don't look like a pony-
1 like@Cool Kidd she's a pony not a horse
0 likes@brianna hilaman same diff.
0 likesSawtooth: “Pinkie’s powers came from absorbing Discord’s magic.”
476 likesFauna Joy: “*Party pony magic*”
Replies (4)
what if all magic came from that bell?
6 likesor did he just steal it from somehere?
Pinkie scenes magic
2 likesActually he not entirely
2 likesWrong they a
Comic when discord is having trouble using his power after tirek stole them and thwss a rift to discrird dimension left open and pinke pie fell into and learnt the rules of chaos as what ever pops into your mind happensd and pinke learnt the rules to it
Can someone please tell me the music of 1:16
0 likesThe reason why the chaos magic didn't spread throughout cozy glow's time line was because at the time she was an Alicorn, meaning she could handle all of the magic. but pinkie is just a earth pony, so that's why it spread out through her timeline only.
1817 likesReplies (63)
good piont
62 likesoh did you notes two things she took more than cosy glow i can tell from the surrounding lightning she has
68 likesand she had a decent amount of control.oh she got the alicorn powers from the magic sorry
True
10 likesUmmmmmmmm
18 likesNo creature can control discords magic.well of course apart from discord.
Or maybe it's because Pinkie had her own sort of chaotic magic (Pinkie sense) so she was used to random bursts of power and twichy tails but I don't think it was because she was an earth pony Pinkie is different from others and I don't think anyone would be able to control such chaotic magic as Discord's other than Pinkie, Discord and maybe Cheese Sandwich?🤔💥
36 likesRida Fatima Khan im not saying cozy controlled the magic, she certainly didn’t, but she was at least able to contain it
13 likesYeah I thought so too
3 likesAnd Pinkie probably absorbed the Princess’s magic because it was in the bell when Pinkie took in the bell’s magic.
9 likesIf she could control it why did she have to change back?
3 likesShe said Cozy’s body could handle it. She didn’t say Cozy could control it.
10 likesOh wow someone bought s9 like me XD
1 likeWoah dude that deep😑😳
1 likeHow are you so smart!?!
3 likesIf I remember correctly during the part before Cozy Glow got discord's chaos power she said something like 'Give me a taste of the power'. I think she just gains a small amount of discord's power. While Pinky, on the other hand, gained 10 times more power than Cozy, all of it probably.
15 likesWhen Cozy gained the chaos magic, her surrounding was quite tame while Pinky made her surrounding turn pink and filled with balloons, ice-cream, candy and other party stuff.
I also think when they drained Cozy Glow from the chaos magic, they drained every inch of it and none was left but when Discord just took away the bell from Pinky, a tiny amount of the chaos magic could have just stuck with her.
@Me aaaAAA that makes total sense. Also cozy glows model look more similar to a grown alicorn, where pinky's transformation is more chaotic look.
13 likesIntriguing theory. Not to mention making a ton of sense.
3 likesThat's exactly what I thought!
2 likesYep
2 likes@Me aaaAAA it makes a lot sense
2 likes@Double Guyzer Just because it fits in your mouth doesn't mean you can swallow the whole thing!
5 likesOr she has no connection to a different point in time like pinky pie. Pinky pie has her pinkie sences which is not in the same time as her. Side note I think the real reason why Cozy didn't have chaos magic in her time was not because she was an Alicorn but she has not connection to a different point in time. Chaos magic is too powerful to be handled by anyone but discord so being an Alicorn wouldn't have made the difference and she was only an Alicorn for a short period of time. Another reason would be that Cozy is still just a fillie and would have probably died if it weren't for the Alicorn enhancement. Pinky was able to handle the chaos magic because she was already infused with chaos magic. I think that eventually she'll become as powerful as discord because the power would just keep stocking up as that period of time goes by.
8 likesThis is a pretty good idea, but my opinion is that it affected all of her timeline because she didn't want to use it for evil, only chaos, what it was intended to be used for.
2 likesThis is an very good theory but no Ali corn has ever seemed to have CHAOS magic it just doesn't add up
1 like@Àíďàñ But they certainly do have potential, Just look at Twilight she had the power of all the alicorns but that never effected her. The magic of 4 alicorns should be close to the power discord contains
3 likes@Kauzu Zeon I guess your right
1 likeYES
1 likeSo if Luna absorbed all of that magic she could handle it
1 like@Kiran shravan voleti I mean I would assume so since she's an Alicorn as well. All the Alicorns probably can handle the amount of magic but they would n't be able to successfully use the magic in a fight, Celestia and Luna might be able to use the dimension travel magic because they already have exprience with traveling to other dimensions.
2 likesGood point
1 likeTrue
1 likeIt seemed to me like Pinkie could control Discord's power to her will, making it drop a giant cupcake out of the sky when she wanted to drop a giant cupcake out of the sky. Cozy however seemed to have no control seeing as her attempts to attack Tirek and Chysalis ended in rubber chickens and sentient pineapples
2 likes@Surayaa Pinkie just wanted to have fun and make people laugh and cause chaos so the chaos power allowed itself to be used by Pinkie but Cozy wanted to use it to harm others and to destroy all balance and take over the planet but the chaos magic isn't supposed to do that so it didn't allow Cozy to use it's power. It's kinda like the magic has a mind of it's own and deems if the user is worthy enough to use it's power to it's full extend. Discord did take over for a sort period of time but unlike Cozy Discord made everything chaotic.
0 likesyOU ARE CORRECT
0 likes@S K tirek absorbed his magic once which is a fact
1 like@Anti Social Weeb Also Pinkie already knew how to control a little bit of discord’s magic from he life. She probably knew how to control the whole thing to some extent.
0 likes@KittyandLychee Pinkie might know how to control a % of discord's magic but does that mean she'll be able to handle the rest. In the show we have seen pinkie do stuff that normal earth ponies can't but we've never seen like the advanced stuff that discord does like turning building upside down or opening portals to other realms by herself. Say Pinkie has 10% of discords magic, she has had her entire life to master that, do we don't really know if Pinke can handle the rest. Take Twight for an example, she's an alicorn and the legit embodiment of magic yet she had trouble with containing all 4 alicorn's magic, along with hers. Chaos magic is either as strong as the 4 alicorns or stronger since in one of the timelines that Starlight made, discord took over equestria and their were 3 alicorns at the time with the entire nation. So if anyone says that pinkie is able to handle magic that is basically on par with an entire nation plus 3 alicorns as soon as she got it right off the bat, I think you need to double check your facts(I don't say this to offend anyone)
0 likes@Anti Social Weeb I wasn’t saying that Discord’s magic didn’t spread through Pinkie’s life, I am just saying that because Pinkie Pie had Discord’s magic in her life, it would explain how she (kind of) able to control how and where to drop the giant cupcake. My main point is that Pinkie was able to control Discord’s magic better than Cozy, because she had a lifetime of practice.
0 likesP.S. I’m not saying Pinkie Pie had full control of Discord’s magic, I am just saying she had a little more control over it than Cozy did.
0 likes@KittyandLychee Ya i figured I just didn't want anyone else asking some question like well if Pinkie can control a bit of chaos magic than she can control the rest or something like that
0 likes@Anti Social Weeb 👍🏼
0 likesWOW 😳 I never thought it that way
0 likesHey do not trust sawtooth waves it's just a teary omg you guys don't even know that sawtooth waves is a teary
0 likes@RedPandaGirl
0 likesWhy should we not trust him? He makes a good argument. If you don’t believe him, I would appreciate counter argument.
true, not in it's entirety, but what's to say that since cozy glow already had alicorn magic, the amount of chaos magic she could absorb was capped before she absorbed discord's magic in it's entirety.
0 likesLucretia Thomas twilight was able to absorb 3 alicorn’s magic, it not getting capped. I dont think that discord’s magic could be much more than one alicorn’s magic, so cozy glow has a good chance at still the magic not getting capped.
0 likes@Lucretia Thomas
0 likesAnd don’t forget that at the time Pinkie absorbed the magic in the bell, it also had Princess Celestia’s and Luna’s magic in it as well as discord’s. That is a lot of magic for and earth pony to absorb all at once.
Omg your so smart
0 likesThat what I thing to!!
0 likesThat exlpanes EVERYTHING!
0 likesOh...
0 likesHey!...
0 likesTrue story
0 likesIt's also because Pinkie has a part of her which is connected to time which is her Pinkie Sense. It's hard to understand but think of it this way. Cozy had an alicorn body so it could contain the chaos magic but Pinkie has an earth pony body which can't contain all the magic on its own and her Pinkie sense acts like a hole in her time period in which chaos magic can leak out and affect Pinkie's entire essence in the past, present, and future.
1 like@S K well since cozy glow already had a lot of magic, she was able to control it a little bit more than Pinkie, like probably just enough to stop it from influencing the rest of her timeline
0 likesGood idea that makes sense mostly except she wasn’t a true real alicorn (like twilight) she was just a “fake one” because nothing happen d like it happened with twilight she might have observed but in a different way
0 likes? Can someone explain this to me. This sounds like it has nothing to do with canon or this theory
0 likesur thinking inside the chimney u smart cookie
0 likesNot real stubit😤🤬😑
0 likesWoah *mind blown
0 likesI was gonna say the same thing
0 likes@Double Guyzer Maybe it was a difference between how they approached their use of it due to their personalities.... Cozy Glow tried to control it, as her nature was that of one who seeks dominance and control.... The magic rejected her as a result.... Pinky on the other-hand... She already had a chaotic and carefree attitude, and tendency to just do things without considering the consequences.... She didn't try to control the chaos, she embraced it and so it empowered her to act on whims she was otherwise powerless to act on.... Had Discord not siphoned off the excess of chaos magic she might well have caused just as much havoc he does when he's not reigning himself in....
0 likes@Amayah Johnson Because she was rapidly showing signs of getting drunk on that much power.... She could control it, that doesn't mean she wouldn't abuse the heck out of it much the same way Discord himself used to.... It started with chocolate rain, but sooner or later her warping reality to her whims would likely hurt those around her, regardless of her intent....
0 likesCan someone please tell me the music of 1:16
0 likesi just imagine Twilight thinking back on Pinkie Pie and realizing why Pinkie is Pinkie and she just goes "OH YOU HAVE GOT TO BE KIDDING ME!"
160 likesReplies (4)
I even read that in her voice. XD
14 likes@o same 😂
9 likesYou should be an mlp writer
8 likes@o same but not only this time..
4 likesI think it has something to do remembering
Plot Twist:
681 likesPinky is actually a unicorn but no one (or should I say no pony) can see it because it's hidden under her poofy mane XD.
Replies (19)
Ah but her mane deflates and donsent show a horn ... Unless she cast a spell to make her horn invisible hmmmm... I'll have to look in to that
77 likespinkie with straight hair reading this like:
60 likes👁👄👁
@Alex Le Panpan did she hear me
16 likes@Isabelle Brush yes she said
17 likes👁👅👁
That's actually a good theory
11 likesOmg that could be true
7 likesNot a univorn, alicorn
8 likesNope
3 likesnahhhh that’s funny but nah
4 likesDUN DUN DUUUN DUNUNUNUNNN
6 likes@EyeofArtemis818 alicorns are both with wings and horn. Unicorns have only a horn, pegasus is with wings
5 likes@EyeofArtemis818 no
2 likesBut When Pinkie Is Sad, Her Mane Deflates And It Shows No Horn
6 likesHer mane has gone flat before
3 likesI Agree
2 likesPossible
1 likeHer mane is her horn
0 likesCan someone please tell me the music of 1:16
0 likesOk ok everypony.
0 likesIm actually a alicorn
I hid it
Its actually hidden in my mane and my wings lol
3:30 Now that I think about it, even though Cozy Glow isn't as chaotic as pinkie, she still will sometimes pull stuff from nowhere, like when she was with the other villains planning to go up the mountain to retrieve Grogar's bell she suddenly had s'more making materials despite not bringing any. She also is known for making over the top facial expressions, and maybe having chaos magic helps with that idk. I think some of the chaos magic did spread through Cozy's timeline.
43 likesIs it a stretch? Yes.
Is it just a coincidence? Yes.
But will I except this as headcannon anyway? Also yes.
I love this theory, but I couldn’t help but notice something. In the Gift of Maud Pie (season 6 episode 3) we see that Maud has a MAUD SENSE, just like Pinkie has a Pinkie sense, and Pinkie comments that it, “runs in the family.” Is it possible that Maud has magic as well? Are their other members of the Pie family that have this ability ? Maybe they have some sort of magical ancestry, like Pumpkin Cake or Flurry Heart. I feel like the answer to Pinkie Pie is still out of our grasps, but if it really is Discord’s chaos magic, it might be possible it spread through Pinkie’s family (Do you really expect Discord’s magic to follow any rules?).
22 likesI feel like this is a little far fetched, but hey, this is Discord we’re talking about!
A note: when Cozy Glow used discord’s magic, she turns into that monster thing- but when Pinkie uses it, Electricity crackles on her body. Cozy didn’t have the electricity. And discord’s magic is electricity so it suggests that when Pinkie Pie used it, something mysterious happened, and Discord’s magic started flowing through her veins and affecting her entire timeline.
1664 likesOnly a note/theory
Pls like so Sawtooth can see this
Replies (35)
Yikes
7 likesHum
7 likes@aycxia the timeline is the rainbow change
7 likesOh ty
3 likesMaybe that being because cozy got her magic by you know how
5 likesWell there’s one problem with your theory if discord’s magic has electricity he would have sparks around him . Cozy was an alllacorn so sh could Handel all the magic but pinkie is an earth poney not being able to Handel all that magic it spread into her entire timeline
15 likes@Kiran shravan voleti but cozy was a Pegasus first right? Well- I guess ur right
8 likesYou are so right!
2 likesWasn't pinky pie a giant a couple seconds long than cozy glow?
2 likesCozy could not control the magic, just as she could only accept it being given to her.
8 likesPinkie Pie could control the magic to do her bidding, because she had been intendd to control this magic even if it technically is not hers to begin with.
For a paralel, the Alicorn is the combination of the Pony magic; but what do you get if you add the Chaos and Changeling Magic? Pinkie Pie?
If you follow her history; you notice Pinkie is using all the Pony Magics at one time or the other, but she is apparntly using Chaos and Changeling Magic as well.
Why is Pinkie's last known surviving Clone a Journalist? Is it a nod to Clark Kent? Though one may assume she does a grand job at the Journalism, if the Clone has as much as a Shadow of Pinkie's Qualities. Knowing where the news are, and remembering everything?
@Kiran shravan voleti well you can see discord’s magic is kinda involves electricity when he turns those three villians into stone. His magic coming out of his hands looks like electricity
4 likesAlso cozy was an alicorn so she could hold more magic thne pinkie
2 likes@Twilluz That assumes Pinkie plays by the same set of rules? Which rarely seems to be the case.
0 likesPinkie could claim the magic for herself withapparent ease, while Cozy required another to afford her the magic. If the other were willing or able to use the magic would most likely be irrelevant?
Wait, is it Discord's magic here? Just because it is Chaos magic?
0 likes@Kentavritsa i suppose but either works i guess.good speculating!
0 likesAlso pinkie can control discords magic unlike cozy
1 likeI didn't even know test that 😱 maybe it's because pinky pie is a earth pony
1 likePinkie is a bit weird (Might be more powerful cause of pinkie sense?)
1 likeBecause she is conectd to him
0 likesJust a theory...A GAME THEORY!
1 likePinkie pie is more powerful than cozy duh pinkie pie is a god
0 likes@Avery Espinoza I think that's because Chrysalis and Tirek took away the chaos earlier...
1 like@Lark Dash Oh yeah good point. But I am saying that because Pinky was a giant a little longer and I am thinking that because of that she was effected with discord magic.
0 likes@Avery Espinoza Oh, ok!
0 likesIts vains not venis because venis is a planet
0 likesmaybe because it was a full loop. As she was already a being of chaos. It affected her past as well. Maybe with Cozy it was altered by the other magic she absorbed.
0 likesAlso, cozy couldn't use the chaos magic. Everyone said that discords magic is so chaotic that he's the only one that can control it. But pinkie seemed like she could use the magic pretty easily
1 likeHmmmm that just might be true
0 likesIn the comic pinke fell into discord dimseon, and used chaos magic as discord magic was not able to use it after the titrek stole IT
1 likeit makes sense I agree with you aycxia
0 likes^^ yeauh
0 likes@Kentavritsa I also have a theory on Pinkies clones.... What if her clones weren't clones, but other Pinkie Pies from parietal universes... Perhaps one of them even being from the EG universe.... They had to learn about the world they were in from Pinkie Prime because most of them weren't even Ponies in their home dimensions to begin with....
1 likeCan someone please tell me the music of 1:16
0 likesThats what sawtooth said
0 likes@IVLunar MelodyVI how
0 likesSo I've seen people in the comments talking about certain other characters that also have weird abilities like Pinkie, and I'm starting to wonder: is chaos magic REALLY unique to only Discord? Because I find it would be pretty interesting if random creatures/individuals just happened to have chaos magic, and are often randomly born with it with no rhyme or reason. The amount of power they have is also random, and sometimes they can only do a limited number of things. It would just generally be cool to get that kind of lore on chaos magic, especially if it was true that certain random individual beings just happened to have it, and some might even know more of the secrets of the universe than others.
0 likesI could make so many OCs using this headcanon.
Personally I’d love to see the cosmos turned into frosting 🧁🧁🧁
44 likesReplies (2)
Me to
2 likesme too!!!
1 likeBut when cozy glow absorbed it she couldnt handle it. When I saw that scene I immediately said to myself, " ok for a fact Pinkie can handle it shes chaotic in general." And then it happened and she handled it way better!!
16 likesI'm pretty sure it's just Pinkie being her cartoon character self, but the magic returning to Pinkie thing could be something to look into.
12 likesThe part where Pinkie has magic returned to her when none of the other non-horn having ponies is really interesting, I never noticed
1771 likesReplies (22)
ikr?
17 likes@BrassWing I noticed it but I thought pinkie just had magic
14 likesI did but i thought it was normal the others did not get it so its not
2 likes@Candace Wesley me too also the others i thought
2 likesMe too!!
1 likeSame! I thought I was the only one who noticed it. The magic returned to Pinkie, Rarity and Twilight.
13 likes?
2 likesMe too
1 likemaybe thats her super-duper strength (not physical, mental, so applejack wouldn't have it) or her pinkie sense which counts as a type of magic ig
5 likesThat make sense. When Pinkie took the bell she got crazy magic!
2 likesMe neither
0 likesSame!
0 likesSame
0 likesWait when in this video was that, can someone give me the time?
1 likeI thought everyone had the same thing happend
0 likesSame! 😲
0 likes🙂
0 likesYa...
0 likes@Candace Wesley but the others (pegasi and earth ponies from the mane 6) didn't get their magic back like pinkie or the unicorns
1 likeThis actually makes sense
1 likei noticed and was very confused
2 likessame
0 likesCheese Sandwich: "Where theirs a party I follow."
23 likesIn this case!
Magic: "Where theirs a Pinkie Pie
I follow :D"
Replies (1)
Gravity: “Where there is a Pinkie Pie I cease to exist”
3 likesIf Discord’s chaos magic effected Pinkie into her past and future then how come in season 6 ep. 3 when they where trying to get Pinkie’s canon back Rarity asked Maud how she knew where it was she said “Maud sense” then Pinkie said and I quote “Runs in the family” so everyone in her family has it. It’s just a talent they had since birth! Sorry if this ruins the theory and you have to delete this one although I really like it!
11 likesIn season 8 when was Pinkie Pie sad, she changed colour of her skin, she made her hair straight and when she was walking down the town, flowers started to die and balloons started to burst. Her mood was literally changing things around her. That is a proof that she has some kind of magic.
4 likesIt was also a bit weird that pinky was just able to “calmly” and pretty easily handle discord’s chaos magic, like it just came naturally to her
2 likesI really like this theory and in a lot of ways it makes sense! I think there might be a couple of reasons why Pinkie got to keep some chaos magic and Cozy didn’t: 1) Discord was the one who removed a bunch of the chaos magic from Pinkie and might have let her keep a little bit for fun later. Tirek and Chrysalis removed all of the chaos magic in Cozy Glow after she said she was going to turn on them wielding her newfound power. 2) Pinkie was blasted by the rainboom and cozyglow wasn’t. This magically connected Pinkie to her friends and a little bit to their respective kinds of magic. Given Discord was Pinkie’s friend, a little bit of chaos magic might have stayed with Pinkie only when she was directly exposed to it. This might also explain why Cozy was unable to control the chaos magic while pinkie could.
1 like3:29
2 likesi think its a mix of two things
1. chaos magic is well, chaotic. it doesn't follow a set pattern of what happens to those who use it.
2. it could be a causality loop, where because of that moment, it gave her the magic throughout her timeline, which in turn gave her enough of that magic that her using it strengthened her power in a way that both make her control it, and so it overflowed to throughout her timeline. meaning that, that moment, caused that moment to be able to happen.
Hey...I noticed that in the episode where Twilight fights tirek , after she gets magic from all 3 Princesses disocrd just like pinkie senses it by shaking his body...
62 likes🤔🤔🤔
It's dicord's sense!!
Replies (2)
Discord is Discord and he’s chaotic no matter what
0 likesI would not nlike to call it discord sense I think
0 likesWhat if when Cozy Glow absorbed Discord’s magic, it made her feel motivated to drain all the magic from Equestria and turn to the dark side? I think that’s cool
5 likesSawtooth: I solved Pinkie Pie
3010 likesTwilight Sparkle would like to know your location
Replies (43)
This is why I am not smart
63 likesThis needs more likes
60 likesLmfao
20 likesI thought they had a conversation some time ago that ended badly. Here: https://youtu.be/AP1ym0-hRr4
17 likestrue
10 likesLol that’s hilarious
14 likesYou didnt explin pinke
5 likesElyse Zhou me.
5 likesAmel Hana of course they didn’t explin pinkie they explained pinkie.
5 likesYep
5 likesLol true
4 likesYou gave me nightmares🥺
4 likesLOL
3 likesTwilight has been wanted to know since season 1
6 likesMaybe Discords magic effected Cozy's timeline too and that's why she went crazy for "Power" has no idea how to respond to friendship just like Discord didn't in the beginning and Cozy wanted to become the "Empress" of Friendship just how Discord became the Lord of Chaos, and why she's so smart and a little filly not aging even alittle when we see the Crusanders age alittle and grow through the series, maybe she's from when the ponies were still at odds and wendigos still roamed. So otherwise maybe the Discord magic twisted her and made her go "mad" and affected her growth physically but not intellectually. Just a thought.
3 likesThats a true terroirs
1 likeXD
0 likesOoone thousandth like! But it doesn't matter!
0 likes...hahahaahahaahaha
0 likesHonestly the twilight sparkle would like to know your location thing is scary
2 likesI miss season 1 twilight tho...
1 likeMe: f*ck the sh*t im out
1 likeWhy
0 likesTrue
0 likesTrue haha
0 likesLol
0 likesyes
0 likesthis yes
0 likes@✨Høllyberry Cøøkie✨ ha
0 likesLOL I love this comment.
0 likesHmm....
0 likes@aaron snuggs is 2.1K likes not enough
0 likesLol
0 likesPinkie is changling ;D
0 likes@Christal GG. KH. woah. That was insane
0 likesLol
0 likes*shares location to twilight *
0 likesOk I’ll give twilight my location ONLY BECAUSE I WANT HER LIVING WITH ME
0 likesSo right XDD
0 likesTwilight: TELL! ME! EVERYTHING! NOW!
0 likes🤣
1 like@✨Høllyberry Cøøkie✨ lol
0 likes@Elyse Zhou me
0 likesI havet really thought this through but this theory about smt happening in the future would affect the past seems also fitting too Flurry Heart. I mean she was born alicorn, yet she hadn’t really had an interaction with any other ponies. But at her coronation she got the love of all the crystal ponies, and we’ve seen both crystal ponies with wings and without- so why not with a horn? So she basically got love(aka magic) from possibly all three tribes.
1 likeI’ll set my brain aside and let someone else joke around with this theory.
It's very interesting, but on the other hoof I don't recall Discord having affected time, only space/dimensions with his powers.
1 likeThat said there is another detail I'm too lazy right now to check, but in the famous time loop episode with Twilight, iirc Pinkie wasn't really into Twilight's theory that something would happen and still tagged along for fun, at least she didn't take that seriously at all... if your time loop theory is correct and this one too, maybe Pinky's twitchy tail sense could "have remembered" the timeline where nothing happened after Twilight checked every potential danger...
The fact that when Cosy absorbed Discord's magic, she couldn't control it, but when Pinkie absorbed it, she was able to control it somehow concerns me for some reason.
2 likesI would like to debunk that theory. While you have some good arguments I don’t think the cause of her “godlike powers” is Discord’s magic. I personally think that it has to do with the sonic rainboom when she got her cutie mark. It is show that the sonic rainboom is magical enough to give other ponies extra power, like it did with Twilight, it gave her the magic she needed to pass her entrance exam. I think that the rainboom gave Pinkie those abilities, and I believe it is stored in her mane. When the rainboom happened, her hair puffed up, and when her hair was flat she doesn’t have those godly abilities. Her mane alone is also shown to be magical, like when she stores random objects in it or when the front would move like an extra limb.
1 likeI’d love to know what you think about my theory! I know I’m pretty late to this video and I apologize for that, but I do hope you find this interesting.
HA! Jokes on you! You can’t solve Pinkie Pie, she’s Pinkie Pie!
623 likesOkay, that’s actually a good theory.
Replies (6)
That’s not magic, that’s just pinkie pie.
21 likesYep
3 likesPinkie is able to go into dimensions in another body/spirit, how do you think ancient earth ponies built equestria, witchcraft.
0 likesIkr
0 likesDont do hate !
0 likes@Rose Warren kyra
0 likesI have one detail that I think can support this theory, when cozy glow absorbed the power she didn’t have the same results as Pinkie Pie did because when she absorbed the power she already had experienced Alicorn magic and Alicorn magic is powerful so Discord’s magic would only be an extend of control that Cozy Glow just couldn’t handle as for Pinkie Pie she would have never experienced magic before until that moment when she got Discord’s magic it was hard to control just like for Cozy Glow but Pinkie Pie had a greater affect on it because she never had experienced magic before until that one moment and then the rest of your theory goes on
1 likeHold up, what about cheese sandwich? When he came to pony villle, didn’t he say he had a cheese sense? Please correct me if I’m wrong hahah
9 likesHey Sawtooth, just something floating around in my brain. If an alternate timeline existed in which Pinkie did not take Discord's magic, would that mean Pinkie would be normal in the alternate timeline? Imagine a Pinkie that can't break The Laws of Physics...
1 likeInteresting theory. Works even better than my own explanation years ago for Pinkie: that she was born a heavy unicorn hybrid, (unicorn with earth pony traits) but something happened as a very young foal (possibly Cake twins age) that caused the need for her horn to be removed. Or possibly was broken off duecto either an accident or abuse. (Also, in my headcanon at the time, she was adopted.) With the removal of her horn, but the carbunkle (nerve cluster atvthe horn's root) still there, her unicorn magic ends up being bottled up... causing extremely random and chaotic releases of said magic.
1 likePinkie's full of surprises. Metaphorically and literally.
253 likesReplies (4)
You guys stuffed Pinkie OH.MY.GOD
5 likesI agree!
3 likesWait so IF I BREAK HER OPEN LIKE A PIÑATA WILL SHE DROP CANDY?!
5 likesPinkie VORED Surprise!
3 likesi love the theory :D
0 likespersonally, ive always thought that pinkie just has that magic naturally. we already know that ALL ponies have magic, not just unicorns; and that magic can be personalized. for example, fluttershy's ability to speak to animals, and her Stare. those arent "pegasus powers" that all pegasi have, like the ability to fly; its hers alone. pinkie's magic could just be like that, natural and unique to her. i always thought that pinkie was able to wield discord's magic so well because it was a close match to her already existing magic and personality.
I like the theory. To explain the difference between Cozy and Pinki’s reactions you could easily say it was because Cozy was an Alicorn at that point and able to contain the chaos better than an earth pony
0 likesCozy Glow is chaotic by being crazy and stuff
0 likesWell, Cozy Glow with her desire for power/control is too orderly for a filly. Pinkie Pie is the opposite - she's very chaotic for an adult pony. Also, if this was something of an event that influenced her PAST before the moment-- that makes it a Circle like so many time-travel stories.
1 likeSawtooth: Pinkie Pie, she is a weird creature.
212 likesPinkie Pie: Am I a joke to you? tells Fluttershy to do the stare
Fluttershy: STARING INTENSIFIES
Replies (2)
🤣🤣🤣
1 like71 likes?!?!?!
1 likeCozy glow used magic to be powerful while pinkie used it to create crazy chaos. Maybe those moments changed both ponies. Pinkie pie became crazy pony who destroys phisics laws and cozy glow became hungry for power and obsessive.
2 likesSawtooth Waves: Is someone watching me?
27 likesMe: Yeah, we are because this is a YouTube video.
Another theory-
2 likesPinkie has her Pinkie sense, that is true.But if all magic disappeared from equestria then she might also have lost her Pinkie sense. Yes this minor detail was hard to see and 99 percent of people didn't notice this. But it is highly unlikely that one event in the future can affect the present.
Hope this helps
If that happened in that one moment changed entire timelines, we know from the episode where Twilight time travelled to stop Starlight that different timelines in the MLP universe are a thing.
0 likesWould the chaos magic effect the timelines of other Pinkies? Like if in another timeline, Pinkie did NOT absorb Discord’s magic at the time, would she still be as crazily Pinkie as we know?
If it effected her whole life, was there a past before the chaos magic thing? Just her being the element of laughter, cracking jokes and visual gags, but with no physics defying stunts? Or is that past just erased because of all the chaos magic? Is it still there, in another timeline?
Maybe she wants all of us to believe that we've solved her...
175 likesShe does know of our existence so... could she be misleading us..? O _ O
Welp, no sleep for me tonight!
Replies (5)
And for me too
2 likesToo me for and
1 likeToo for me and
0 likesOh-
0 likes@Beep Beep Oh to and me for
0 likeshmm... I've always explained pinkie sense as one of many psychic abilities, essentially as twilight pointed out, magic and pinkie sense don't exactly work the same way. which is why she failed to understand it, my theory is that in equestria, psychic abilities are a separate thing from magic. She isn't the only one either,
0 likesFluttershy is a natural empath, but what if she's a supernatural empath as well? it would explain her ability to communicate with animals, (or at least understand their emotions and why she is so sensitive in general when she can sense the judgement of other ponies first hand not to mention her glare, imagine focusing pure fear into a target just by looking at them.
Princess Luna is a telepath, in the diary of the 2 sisters she gained the ability to communicate with animals much like fluttershy, but also she is known for entering the dreams of ponies, technically we do see that she has a spell for that, but theoretically magic isn't incapable of enhancing or duplicating a psychic ability
Also Izzy moonbow claims to see the auras of other ponies or their unique "sparkles" she even uses that ability despite the absence of unicorn magic or seemingly any other pony magic.
Cheese Sandwich can pull similar feats too, and as far as we know, he never got injected with a butt ton of chaos magic that made him want to turn all the stars into rubber chickens
0 likesI like to think party ponies are a small and rare sub-set of ponies or even creature that have a very slightly different type of magic, probably akin to chaos magic, that makes them more emotional and connect with feelings like joy more than the average creature as well as pull those feats
Perhaps these traits are why they're usually the ones in charge of non-formal parties around Equestria, hence the name and title of Party Pony
The only two party ponies we really know of are Pinkie and Cheese, and both are earth ponies, and that can probably just be chalked up to coincidence. But what if, as earth ponies, they don't really have the inate magic of unicorns and pegasi, their magic being alot more subtle, so this 'party pony magic' can be expressed alot more easily in earth ponies
I like your idea and i think your half right. but you forgot one detail. Grogar had said in season 9 "only a creature of pure chaos can control discords magic"
1 likePinkie however seemed to control it PERFECTLY when she got her whooves on it. This means she has always had her OWN form chaos magic (likely chaotic good) which is why she could control it but it being a more "negative" form of chaos magic it still corrupted her slightly (not making her evil just outta control)
:) hope you like my take on it!
Laughter is a magic of the same nature as chaos. Even Dash mentioned once how random Pinkie is (episode with Gilda). That's where Pinkie sense comes from: she can feel chaos around her. Maybe that makes Pinkie so good at ordering (her secret cave). So, Pinkie has deal with chaos the whole life.
0 likesAnd that's the explenation of Pinkie's ability to control the chaos magic (she can feel it and she have been practicing to control it during whole her life).
I truly support your belief about discord's chaos magic affecting Pinkie Pie's timeline and affecting her future and past but regarding the difference of the outcome on cozy glow and Pinkie Pie after absorbing Discord's magic is because she also absorbed Princess Celestia's and Luna's magic which was in the bell
1 likeso I think this was the reason of Pinkie Pie's timeline being affected
Honestly, all this time shenanigan stuff is unneccessary. I just always theorized that Pinkie Pie was able to use chaotic magic from the start, as she is more prone to being able to do things that the rest couldn't. Things that don't involve time at all. This explains in a more simple structure why she couldn't just "read the future" and know when to touch the bell and all that. She simply always knew chaos magic. It's why she enjoyed Discord in Season 2. It's why she was able to control and harness Discord's Magic. She already knew Chaos Magic. That's why she can control it. No time shenanigans needed.
1 likeMy Own Theory:
0 likesWhat if she had gotten it from the Sonic Rainboom like how Twilight's magic activated then? Now, I know that sounds far-fetched, but think about it. When she lived on the rock farm, she was just a normal pony, not the hyperactive and physics-defying party pony we know today. When she set up that party at the rock farm, it was only a DAY (I believe) after the Rainboom. There's no way she could have gotten the supplies for the party and come back home THAT fast. The Rainboom could have done more than just puff up her mane/tail and show her how to smile. It could have awakened the chaotic good side of her that was hidden from living on the rock farm. That's all I got. Bit of a stretch, but it's still possible. Nothing is impossible when it comes to Pinkie Pie.
This all sounds plausible, but what about Maud? In the manhattan episode where Pinkie and Maud exchange gifts, Rarity asks how Maud knew where the sales pony was, and Maud replied saying," Maud sense".
1 likeIf what you said was true, then how did Maud get her Maud sense?
This fits with what I've been thinking, Pinkie having her own kind of chaos magic...
229 likesAn example of this, one scene in a harthswarming episode, where the apples stay at the pies. 19 hooves appear from the sides of the frame, and AppleJack sees them too, though the other ponies around them seem unfazed. This suggests that Pinkie isnt just making them appear where we can see, or is doing some weird trick. Applejack has no idea where they came from, and looks around her kinda terrified. Pinkie can make these things happen for specific ponies too.
As well as when twilight broke the fourth wall to help Pinkie after Trixie's first appearance. This isnt happening for everyone, just specific ponies.
Replies (2)
That is one big comment😦
1 likeActually after the season four finale discord had trouble using his power and pinke pie took over his dimrdom that how pinke could use the chaos msigc discord let pinke pie keep some mdguv in case pinke wanted a rematch discord almost lost to pinke pie
4 likesAlso I think the real reasons that it spread through her timeline was because it wasn't just discords magic that she took in, remember that Celestia and Luna's magic was in there too which wasn't what cozy glow absorbed
1 likeMaybe she just always had a little bit of chaos energy in her.
4 likesi noticed the magic go into pinkie in that one scene, and i found it bizarre, this theory has SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much evidence that pinkie is one of 4 things
1 like1. She is the random 4th wall character that appears in lots of shows
2. Your theory
3. she is a literal pony goddess
Or my personal favorite,
4. She has the potential to become an alicorn. She never does in the show, but i really want to hold on to this theory
You forgot Her Chaos Goddess Moment in the Comics. She took over the Chaos Realm and replaced Discord as Chaos. That wasn't a brief moment, it was a whole day. Maybe even more. That more likely. To us it may have been a day, Pinkie Pie could been in there for years, centuries. In the comic, Pinkie completely rewrote the whole Infinite Chaos Realm to her liking. Your theory become more believable if you use that moment.
1 likeWoot I helped solved Pinkie Pie!!! Now I must run from Twilight Sparkle.
I also have an explanation to why Maud and Cheese Sandwich both have senses of their own too. While Pinkie was overwhelmed by the chaos magic, not only did she spread it through her OWN timeline, she also granted power across other people that she really really cares about's timelines, like Maud and the rest of the family. ('Runs in the family!') But you may be wondering, "why would Cheese have it then?" well, I mean, there IS a character that is presumably Pinkie's daughter in The Last Problem named Little Cheese who is playing with Boneless 6, soooooo
0 likesI think Cozy Glow wasn't filled with chaos for life, but evil for life, as Discord's magic is filled with chaos AND evil. He may have taken a long time to control his chaos, and the main 6 help him control the evil.
1 likeI think the simple explanation as to why cozy and pinkie reacted to discord's magic is because the magic they have is different. Cozy also has grogar's magic in her at the time she absorbed the chaos magic. It seems as though 1/3rd of grogar's power is a buffer to all that chaos. Pinkie was a regular earth pony before she absorbed all of discord's magic. All that pure chaos did change her life. I'm really convinced by the theory, if you can't tell.
0 likesMy theory: I think cozy glow’s also spread across her timeline, but just needed something to activate it. I think the rainboom had ticked the magic and activated it
2 likesReplies (1)
Underrated
1 likeAnother thing is, when cozy got the chaos magic, she couldn't control it. But when pinkie got it. She could use it pretty easily🤔
2 likesI agree with what you Said! Pinkie might have some secret magic! 🤔 But Also in the Castle Mane-ia episode, she was playing the organ, and the music was really creepy. When Twilight removed the "jacket" and she was playing, it sounded different 😳 That was Kinda strange 🤔
1 likeIt's the other way around. Because she has the chaos element inside her as a natural feature, she is able to wield the chaos power unlike Cozy Glow.
1 likeI think Pinkie Pie can also look into Discord's mind because in Season 9 episode 1 "The Beginning of the End" when Pinkie Pie was listing all the villains they have defeated, she only mentioned the one's that have returned. King Sombra, Queen Chrysalis, Tirek and Cozy Glow.
2 likesReplies (1)
True and at that time only Discord knew.
0 likes“it’s Pinkie Pie Don’t Question It” lol
3379 likesReplies (45)
Woah I didn’t expect this thanks
55 likesBut then there is no theory only facts cause that’s the truth
30 likesfob equestria
14 likesYip
4 likesYaaaaaaaas you watch fob equestria too
5 likesGhastlyCreeper Plays it’s just a common thing the bronies say I was joking about it cause I love This theory
5 likesMr. Mineblox / Daylight Twinkle XD I was just joking too but to be honest even tho I love the theory pinkie and her weirdness is probably just pinkie and weirdness lol
3 likesLOL
2 likesWhy not tho?
2 likesWhy not tho?
2 likes@Ruby yes*
2 likesAgreed
2 likesTrue
2 likesPink character with two identites..being associated with a green creature used as communication.. Are you implying what I think you are?
2 likesSTOP SENDING
1 likeI dont konw pinkie pie is wiED (lazy)
1 likeYes.
1 likeexactly what I thought after reading the title
2 likespinkie being pinkie
1 likeOk
1 likeLoooool
1 likeI guest soo your right Mr.Mineblox she is just pinkie being pinkie 😊
1 likeExactly what apple geek said
2 likesYES!!😄🤗😊😆
1 likeDumb!!!!!!
1 like@Mr. Mineblox / Daylight TwinkleI agree just let pinkie be pinkie even though she breaks the fourth wall
1 likeYes
1 likeI mean its true
1 likeI WILL QUESTION AS I PLEASE! XD
1 likeLol
1 likeLol
1 likeYou will never understand Pinkie.
1 likeTrue lol
1 likeI don’t want to question pinkie
0 likes@Isabella Nassar yep
0 likesI am an alicorn🌈
0 likesNever disagree with sawtooth.😠
0 likesYeah
0 likesI agree sawtooth waves
1 like@Fróði Kjaran Does art and stuff Pinkie can not be killed, and she can not per se die either.
0 likesYup
0 likesYeah
1 likeHa ha
1 like:3c
0 likeslol
0 likesUnrelated to your theory, which I find fasvinating, but I always thought Pinkie was adopted by the Pie family. And that she actually is a draconequus with the body of a pony.
0 likesHonestly Pinkie is interesting.
Even though she doesnt have as many chaotic powers as Discord, her whole personality is far more chaotic than Discord who is honestly a pretty normal personality.
Pinkonquus just a thought.
And actually this can combine with your theory. That event where she picked up the bell, might have effevted Pinkie uniquely being that she already was a draconequus and the bell unlocked her chaotic potenial
Your claim in the episode would have been correct if chaos magic was also taken. In the episode, only very certain types of magic were taken. No Pegasus magic, no earth pony magic, and no cute mark magic. In my opinion, it is more likely to assume that Pinkie Pie is a descendant of another almost completely extinct pony breed with telepathic abilities. Since it is more similar to unicorn magic than chaos magic it is more likely to believe that such magic would actually take. I wasn't surprised to find out if Maud also got charmed at that moment. After all, we saw her with Boulder communicating with stones and understanding them. We don't really know the rest of Pinky's family and we can also believe that the gene for the early pony type is dormant in most of her family, after all we know that at the moment of the rainboom something happened in her mind that might have awakened these genes.
0 likesIt could also be that all the applicants carry the ancient genes, they are simply dormant in all the applicants except Pinky.
Your explanation is surprisingly lucid. I approve.
0 likesI see NO plotholes in this theory that can't be filled by the following: Pinkie Pie, full name Pinkamena Diane Pie, also known in certain forms of merchandise as Ponka Po, is the Laughter Element of Harmony, and her special talent revolves around giving joy to others and making them smile and laugh. Being able to follow something known as "cartoon physics", as well as "break the 4th wall" and speak to people who live in a reality where HER reality is a work of fiction could bring quite a few individuals a LOT of joy, especially if they truly believe she's talking to THEM.
1 likeIf pinkie pie does something weird. Just don't question it. She is pinkie pie. Pinkie is pinkie. She is the meaning of unsolved and solved...
591 likesReplies (6)
She's pinky (the insane lab mouse.)
4 likesLol
2 likesI will anyways:
4 likesDiscord’s chaos magic might’ve originally been a mix of 3 different types of magic: Chaotic Good, Chaotic Evil and Chaotic Neutral. So as far as we know, Discord’s magic may have been split into 3 bits:
1. Chaotic Good: Transferred to Pinkie Pie
2. Chaotic Evil: Transferred to Cozy Glow
3. Chaotic Neutral: Kept in Discord
Just a hunch though :)
@Guardian Of Peace I am still holding onto my goddess theory but that does make Sense
0 likesWrong ! 🙅♂️🙅♂️ everything is explainable and I think his theory is quite logic, now I think we need more evidence... perhaps we should look deeper somewhere else, like the comics ? 🧐
0 likes@MrMemeZilla 198 Makes me think of; "The Hitch-hiker's guide to the Galaxy" ..
0 likesI have a idea when Cozy Glow absorbed Discords magic, she already used some magic to become a alicorn, so Grogars bell couldn’t add any more magic. So since pinkie is a earth pony with NO magic. It could give her a lot and I mean a LOT of magic. So much that it spread across her entire life…
0 likesPinkie is a powerful and super cute earth pony with tons of amazing quantities. End of story.
2 likesAlso when pinkie absorbed discords chaos magic it seemed as though she could somewhat control it, it may have been that what pinkie would do with it is very similar to what was happening when she took it but also her transformation into a giant pony being wasn’t instant like with cozy glow. Pinkies transformation was also a lot less demonic looking and more of just a giant pinkie pie, also cozy glow was already an alicorn when she took the magic so it likely just that pinkie was an earth pony.
0 likesEdit: spelling
Finally an explanation. Always wondered this. Pinkie Pie stands apart from all the others.
0 likesWhen cozy glow got discord magic, she was evil and she had bad intentions. And, her eyes turn different colors. But when pinky pie got discords magic, her eyes stayed the same and she had good intentions. Well if you count covering everything in frosting good intentions…! So, maybe the eyecolor and the evil versus good has something to do with it?
72 likesReplies (1)
Well maybe it you think that covering the world in frosting is good intentions then I see it
3 likesIt is actually very very confusing that pinkie actually was able to control discord's chaos magic.
1 likeIn the scene where Cozy,Tirek and Chrysails were talking about what to do with discord's chaos magic,
Tirek said that NO OTHER CREATURE OTHER THAN DISCORD CAN CONTROL HIS CHAOS MAGIC.
Crazy if u think about it
This man is to powerful to be left alive
2 likesMaud/Pinkie sense could be the Pie family's version of earth pony magic- their "connection to the earth", as it will.
0 likesMaybe it's specifically because Pinkie has that sense, and specifically because it relates to time and predictions, that the chaos magic scattered through the timeline for her, but not for Cozy.
Maud has a 'Pinkie Sense' of her own, and Pinkie says it runs in the family, so I think the Pie family are all secretly descendants of Discord. Pinkie got a large dose of his magic in her veins which would explain the 4th wall-breaking and defying the laws of physics, time, and space. It might also explain why she was able to control Discord's chaos magic when she absorbed it, whereas Cozy Glow summoned a rubber chicken instead of a death ray. The flaws of this? Why does Discord not know her? Wouldn't he recognize his descendant? The answer: Discord had been a stone statue for centuries so the amount of chaos magic in the Pie bloodline could have been diluted over time, and their last names have changed. It could have been just resurfacing in Pinkie, so Discord just thought she was an odd earth pony. While there are other flaws in this theory, I like it and it's a theory I've been developing for a while. If you've made it this far in my extremely long paragraph, have a wonderful day!
0 likesNope, she's still unsolved, no one can solve her
337 likesReplies (10)
Diamonds Music yep she is pinkie pie no one Can beat her
7 likesDiamonds Music Stop being mean
0 likes@Hanoi Paula how was that mean in anyway?
2 likesAzra Yeliz Dalcı Everyone keep saying that Pinky is unsolved but she is! It’s so mean to say that he didn’t solve pinky
2 likesIf she was mean, then why Sawtooth hearted that comment?
2 likesGood question @Twinkle The Pink Kitty.
1 likeYa ikr😹
1 like@Hanoi Paula Its not mean because 1.Sawtooth waves liked it and 2. She said it as a joke
3 likesHi everyone! Haven't seen you guys in two weeks
1 likeI love that you guays are not fighting
0 likesAs applegeek once greatly said.
1 like"It's Pinkie, don't question it"
Here's my theory- or just personal head-cannon, since I don't really have that much to back it up haha
0 likesPinkie was born with chaos magic, she's always had it. Maybe that's why she looks so different from her family, and has such a different destiny than they all do.
When cozy absorbed discord's magic she wasn't able to use it, or at least she couldn't control what it did. But pinkie kinda could.
I think she dropped that huge cupcake and made it rain chocolate on purpose, she absolutely loves both of those things, so it only makes sense that that's where her instinct would go. If she already had a small amount of chaos magic, it would be believable that she would know at least a little bit about how to control it. Of course she wouldn't have been able to control it for long, but in that instant she seemed to be pretty aware of what she was doing.
But that's just my idea, like I said I only have a few bits of evidence and they could totally be interpreted differently.
I think Pinkie controlled it better and kept some magic back cuz that's just how she is. She and discord are quite similar in their bizzare approach to almost everything. But cozy glow just doesn't have that wackiness that chaos magic needs to manifest properly.
0 likesBut Pinkie on the other hand.......(definition of wacky) Can control it to an extent cuz it's similar to the way she works. Chaos magic would have been like "hey, this pony has the stuff in need to work,just not enough if it" or the right Kind
She's not chaos, just silly which is kinda tied to chaos and the wile point if everything I've said this far
Also Cozy Glow is just a ginormousss mystery to me. What Alicorn is EVIL
Wow this thing is long
Hi Sawtooth,
0 likesI can agree with you but there is a difference. When Cozy Glow took the magic from the bell, it contained only Discord's magic, But when pinke pie took the magic, it contained not just Discord's magic it also contained alicorn princess magic. Pinke Pie must have also taken the alicorn princess magic.
Please think about this theory.
I love your videos
Thank you.
"Is someone watching me?!"
525 likesYes this is a video
Replies (15)
Yep
4 likesHaha 😂
4 likesLOL YEUP
4 likesLol
3 likesI was going to comment this!
3 likesSofizzy you are righ🧚🏼♂️🧚🏼♂️🧚🏼♂️🧚🏼♂️🧚🏼♂️🧚🏼♂️
3 likesYep
4 likesYea
2 likesLOL
2 likesHahahahah
1 likeSo true
1 likeLol x3
1 likeYesh me right now
1 likeThat's the joke ;-;
2 likesLol 😂
0 likesMaybe Pinkie Pie absorbed some of Discord's magic permanently because of her personality. Discord's magic was, in essence, a part of Discord and perhaps it latched onto Discord's personality, so when Pinkie Pie, with a personality so similar to Discord's, absorbed Discord's magic, the magic latched onto Pinkie in a way it wouldn't latch onto Cozy Glow.
0 likesWhen Pinkie absorbed the magic in the Bell, she absorbed A LOT more magic than Cozy did. She also absorbed all the alicorn magic from Celestia and Luna that was in the bell.
0 likesWhile rewatching the series, I notced at the part where magic was restored in Equestria [School Raze], Pinkie for some reason was the only non-unicorn that got a ball of aura resembling their Magic-
0 likesso correct! ...Not to mention that no creature or pony other than discord had ever controlled his chaos magic (like when cozy glow tried to and epically failed)...and then pinkie happened...she appeared to have complete control over something nobody else could-not counting discord
1 likeI can disprove this in one probably a bit off direct quote from Maud.
142 likes'Maud sense. It's a family thing.'
Replies (12)
Mayhaps all her family has a form of magic we don't know about?
25 likesbird266 that would explain how they can digest rocks XD
32 likes@bird266 I like that theory actually. I think we should all look into it.
16 likesAlso Cheezy Sense
3 likes🤔Maybe being family has something to do with certain different senses and Pinkie Sense just coincidentally came from the chaos magic?🤔 But I don't think so...
1 like@Clo Animations Unlikely
0 likes@Clo Animations It affects her abilities but not her being a pony with no magic directly.
0 likesTHATS WHAT I SAID
0 likes( I don’t mean to scream at you in a bad way )
When did she say this?
0 likesand cheese sandwich has the party sense thingy REEEEEEEEE
0 likeshowever the rest is very intriguing XD
0 likesKayden Clarke nah horses can eat rocks
0 likesI don’t think it has anything to do with time, I simply think that pinkie was compatibly able to control it, perhaps she always had the same kind of magic in her all along, she just got more of it from the bell
0 likesThats the best explanation ever, the event of Magic going back to Pinkie after cozy glow may actually be true. Not necessarily they came from discords Magic. Maybe it came from when she gained her cutie Mark, her destiny was to be like that. Just like the sonic rainboom activated Twilight's Magic it did the same with Pinkie's
0 likesI would agree cause discord mainly used his magic in party related themes with all his showing and pinky pie who was born to be a plain old rock farming pony with little to no emotion just magically feels empty on the inside until the sonic rainbow which she thought gave her the motivation to create a party
0 likesBut connecting the dot both discord and pinky do party and unbelievable, and impossible thing which make prefect sense to believe that, the time line of her absorbing discord magic did affect both her past, present and future timelines
I mean in my eyes they are both crazy and chaotic
This theory makes sense to me pinkie seams to have held onto discord magic for longer which is why it would have further reaching effects also when pinkie describes discords magic it reminds me of the pinkie sense at least in sensation
0 likesRandom theory: Pinkie was created as a lab experiment. She was created to manipulate reality so that ponies would no longer have to come to terms with the unchangeable and suit the world to their desires. This experiment went horribly wrong, or horribly right, depending on your point of view.
86 likesReplies (2)
@Verserer Gred But then.. Where did the legend of the pond come from? Dun dun dunnn
2 likesShe is basically bc shes a horse/ earth pony
0 likesi have this small thought that like discord, pinkie has chaos magic, and was originally non-pony, but because chaos magic defies reality (like how discord turned into grogar), pinkie took the shape of an earth pony for eternity, and maybe, just maybe, used her magic and made her age, and stored it inside of her
0 likesMy theory as to why Pinkie Pie has powers so similar to Discord's dracoequs magic is because she is actually half draconequs. I'm not saying Discord's her dad. He was turned to stone long before Pinkie was born, but the show never said there weren't other dracons. So, what if a different dracon fell in love with an earth pony and they ended up having a daughter with all the wacky powers of a dracon, but the appearance of a normal earth pony. That would explain why Pinkie's family looks nothing like her. They're not biologically related and the reason why they have the name last name Pie when their first names don't match is because they changed their family name to protect Pinkie's identity. That also explains why in the mlp app there was an alicorn version of Pinkie who was referred to as the Princess of Chaos.
0 likesWait, if that's true, then how would the "original limeline" Pinkie would be? Like, there must be a Pinkie without all the caos powers if that happens in the lastest episodes; is hard to imagine her without all that
1 likeI always thought it was because of her element. I also thought it was because of her element that made her be able to control Discords magic
0 likes"Is someone watching me?"
228 likesMe: Uh... PEOPLE WE'VE BEEN DISCOVERED
Replies (11)
This is so unnderated XD
4 likes@Annwyl Yeah thats what I was thinking
0 likesSCATTER!
0 likes@3r0de don't you mean scammer?
0 likes@• Itz_Pastel • No? Did you know that theres something called scatter, or are you 6? G e e z
0 likes@wiz no I knew something called scatter but I was really confused and yes I am 6.
0 likesGET YOUR GUNS BEFORE HE TELLS THE OTHER'S!
0 likesye there is pepole watching us FROM EVERY where cuze renember? up above :0
1 likeOH YEAH
1 likeTAKE YOUR BAGS EVERYONE
1 likeRUN!
0 likesKinda interesting how none of the others saw the magic returning to Pinkie, too.
0 likesYes, she did get the powers from the chaos magic, bc she started a spirit bomb out of thin air and shot it at flutter shy in the 2020 smile song, if that wasnt the exact date, sorry i havent watched MLP alot.
1 likeA problem i have with this theory is that weve already seen what chaos magic looks like when Tirek took discords magic and if it is chaos magic that gives her the abilities she has then chaos magic should have been the magic we would see not a pink orb
0 likesDid you ever think that maybe cozy didn’t have the same reaction because pinky is a happy chaotic pony and cozy is quiet the opposite? Cozy is more like twilight in the fact that cozy is calm and collective while pinkie is energetic and wild?
0 likesDisney: Stitch
308 likesMarvel: Deadpool
MLP: Pinkie
Replies (8)
Dark Horse comics: The mask
15 likes@Clo Animations
6 likesTrivago
TRIVAGO!!!!!!!
2 likesAnd Discord! Somehow people never do seem to count Discord.
3 likes@Book Thoughts i know right
1 likeDerpy is pretty popular!
1 likeDon't forget about gwenpool?
0 likesUndertale: Sans
0 likesstick around, because I'm gonna prove this theory right. so this whole theory makes perfect sense. until you bring up the whole cozy glow thing, and everything rolls off the cliff because cozy took the same magic, and had no side effects... or did she? cozy is known for being the most diabolical villain we faced. that phsycho laugh sets you right into psychopath mode. when you put it like that, sounds pretty chaotic. but when you try to pair in cozy with the pinkie-discord duo, she sticks out. because cozy wants to take over aquestria and make it her own image where she can do whatever she wants. discord and pinkie just wanna goof off. but when you compare her to just discord, things get a little more interesting. they are both kinda crazy in the same way. they wanted the same thing. to live by they're own rules and do whatever they want. cozy never played with the laws of physics in the show like pinkie and discord. but that finalizes it for me.
0 likesMy theory is that pinkie is a changeling stuck in the form we see. think about it, she can stay in the air after jumping for a long period of time, remember when it was pinkie's birthday and she was chasing rainbow? she was loads faster than a normal earth pony, she seems to be able to teleport, something we have seen time after time with changelings. also, when she felt her friends didn't care about her anymore, she either went berserk or was very depressed, it seems as if she feeds off the friendship and without it she can't survive, just like a changeling. it would show why she got magic when it came back to everyone and the Pegasus did not. it also explains the hyperactivity we see with her. you might notice the pinkie from the farm and the pinkie we know are super different, the one on the farm was a normal earth pony, the one we know is a super earth pony, maybe the pinkie from the farm is the original and the one we know killed that pinkie and took her place, i know dark side theory but it could be true.
1 likeif the chaos magic went through time to all of pinkie past, present, future, why is the pinkie from the farm not like the one we know at all? the pinkie from the farm is an ordinary earth pony while all the other pinkie timelines we see are hyperactive. just something to think about.
this comment is longer than i had anticipated so i am done.
Mk so I put this on another video, but ever notice how pinkies hair flattening and poofing up with her emotions suspiciously resembles what the Crystal ponies do?? She was definitely raised outside of the empire, but her having roots in the capital of magic would explain the weird and wonderful things she can do as well as why her magic was returned to her!! Weather or not she knows of these roots I'm nit sure.
0 likesI think I can connect the dots on why Pinkie and not Cozy Glow. Pinkie’s pinkie sense is a family trait. Maud has a maud sense and then Pinkie exclaimed that it ran in the family. So some form of esp runs in the Pie family, but Pinkie’s particular manifestation of that esp seems a bit more chaotic than Maud’s. That’s probably the chaotic magical influence on her. Also Cozy Glow doesn’t have esp of any kind so no connections outside of time for her. Voila, Pinkie’s family trait is her connection outside of time and Cozy Glow doesn’t have anything like that.
0 likesI wonder though. Does Pinkie’s chaotic tendencies get stronger the closer she is to the inciting moment? Or did it spread out more evenly over Pinkie’s timeline? What do you think?
For the cosy blow incoherence: maybe she didn't keep any of the magic, but discord have let pinky keep a tiny bit of his power. I don't why he would do that but I think it could explain. But I'm pretty sure it's just Pinky Pie being pinky
96 likesReplies (12)
You forgeting that pinki was able to control chaos magic, but closi glow dont.
12 likesI think, this had main efect on that, but what you saying dont have to be wrong. 🙂
Ondra Lopaur I'm going to help you make your point a bit clearer
13 likesi guess you're saying, Cozy Glow cannot use any of the chaos magic at all, thus no Chaos Magic will want to 'remain' in Cozy Glow.
Pinkie Pie was able to wield it, albeit concerning even Discord himself. Meaning, Chaos Magic can still reside within her, since she has been able to use said Magic anyway
@DracoSerpentisCruor yes and gathered magic then went to the all parts of her timeline, that makes loop, where pinki get more and more Chaos magic every time loop going to repeat its self.
5 likesCosy couldn't control the Chaos magic because it was too ... well ... chaotic for her. Pinky was able to contain and "steer" ("control" is too strong a word when dealing with chaos, the words are literally antonyms) the Chaos magic because she already had a link to unpredictability, to "humor," to Laughter. Being a bearer of an Element of Harmony primed her for containing "outside" magic, so she could handle Discord's magic, which then leaked through her timeline and made her the only being (aside from Discord himself) able to break the fourth wall. If they had kept the original concept of Rarity's element being "Creativity," then she might also have been compatible enough to hold Chaos magic.
10 likes@kiralax Time travel in Equestria has been really inconsistent, from Twilight dealing with a Predestination Loop in one episode, where everything she did to prevent the future she was afraid of ended up bringing about that exact future, to all the alternate timelines from the time battle between Twily and Starlight ("Twilight uses Boring Lecture! It's SUPER EFFECTIVE!"), there's more wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey contradictions for even Doctor Hooves/Time Turner to keep track of. I have the feeling that Pinkie's timeline being infused with Chaos magic was a one-time/timeless/outside-of-time event, making the tracking of it a Predestination Paradox.
6 likesWait wait wait. I thought Cozy Glow could control the magic but she didn’t like it because she got a huge form to contain it and the powers were....strange to say the least. She couldn’t steer the chaos magic to do what she wanted but it’s not like she couldn’t control or contain it.
2 likes@Seraphy Wang No... Did you not see her grow frustrated as she kept trying to "control" the chaos magic and make it do what she wished. And eventually started getting scared, because she was being attacked by the pineapple creatures. She wasn't able to control it. She could not make it do what she wanted. But Discord and Pinkie could.
3 likes@Book Thoughts
2 likesHmm. I guess thats correct. Technically pinkie was kinda going bonkers too but in the positive way because she was going to do something drastic but could will it to do her request. Pinkie will be pinkie.
@Seraphy Wang I am kind of going to draw lines of comparison between fandoms (hope nobody hates me for it, but I think I see a connection, so...). I think chaos magic is kind of like the wands in Harry Potter and the mirror of Erised in way. The chaos magic "chooses" who it likes to wield it. It liked Discord and Pinkie so it worked to help them and even affected Pinkie. But Cozy Glow: it didn't effect her or work for her, because it disliked her and didn't want to be controlled by her.
2 likes@Book Thoughts
0 likesI'm not a very big Harry Potter fan but i get what you mean. This would be a way of explaining why the chaos magic just seems to work for the two.
@Seraphy Wang That's why I made that connection. Cause it's not like we can interview chaos magic for an answer.
0 likesTrue
0 likesCozy Glozy may have absorbed discords magic but she wasnt able to harness it. Meanwhile pinky pie did so. It is stated by the villains that his magic is really difficult to control, one would need to be kind of chaotic just like discord is. Pinky qualifies these cretirias by default. However she is just a pony, no op, divinity or something like that. Mastering a power so tremendous, even for a few moments it is bound to cause some side effect.
0 likesIf we're honest, didn't it seem inevitable that Pinkie Pie would get ahold of Discord's magic at some point?
0 likesAlso, I am reminded of the Bad Wolf, who creates herself. Brief moment of transcendence...and an eternity of having always been and always will have been going to be. So much so that Rose Tyler acting as Rose Tyler or as the Bad Wolf or as the Interface of the Moment all shake reality to its core, and even locking the entire being out of the universe merely led to that being's trans-temporal interference leading to somebody saying her name to let her back in, causing the whole universe to panic.
I think Cozy wasn't affected in the same way was because when she absorbed the magic she was an alicorn at the time. She had more magic and was more used to it
0 likesI agree with you, I believe that Pinkie pie does have chaos magic, but I think I might of figured out Cozyglow too, I think that she wasn't effected the same way as Pinkie is because she used it for evil instead of the way Pinkie used it, I think evil was put in her timeline instead, the magic might have given Cozyglow her horn.
0 likesShe is quite an odd one, isn’t she.
704 likesReplies (52)
Even celestia thinks she's strange.
84 likesYh when she does all the stuff
24 likesWAIT IS PINKIE A GILLAN SPY
?
Villan*
10 likesYes she is, princess 😊
29 likesIndeed
11 likespinkie is the worst
43 likesAt being Normal
Hey Celestia!
18 likesThis Is Me UwU who cares at being normal unique I think
10 likesIs better
This Is Me UwU I can relate to pinkie the most cause she deos behaviour that I do I can relate to that so yeah she’s my favourite character
11 likes@Lolypop 123 Sorry to ruin you childhood but MLP match They Pride Flags
5 likes@This Is Me UwU why would that ruin it- it makes it better lmao
12 likesOMG
7 likesPrincess celestia
The weird is strong with this one.
6 likesWait, Principal Celestia IS HERE!!!
3 likesCELESTIA O_O
3 likesI wish you showed more of your power, celestia.
2 likesPRINCESS CELESTIA-
3 likes-BOW FOR THE PRINCESS
Hi clelesta
2 likesYou retired
2 likesOMG PRINCESS CELESTIA
3 likesPrincess Celestia thinks she is weird as well......now I know this is serious
5 likesWHERES LUNA
2 likesCELESTIA?????
2 likesyes, yes she is celestia
2 likesI thought celestia retired
2 likesPRINCESS CELESTIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1 likeNo she's not
1 like:0 Celestia u-u
1 likeI agree with you princess
1 likeYour Highness. She should be a princess. But.... I think she has enough magic lol.
1 likeCelestia how did you become a pegacorn?
0 likesLps Pinkish In the episode
0 likesHorse Play Season 8 she say it
Meh 😒
0 likesI love you profile pic!!
0 likesYes
0 likesOH MY GOD YOU ARE REAL CELESTIA TURN ME TO A UNICORN PLEEEEAAAASE
0 likes@• Evil Slime 😈 Frog • she's a creepy pasta pony if you didnt know search ut up to see the truth
0 likes@This Is Me UwU Yes I think pinkie pie is pansexual
0 likesHello, sister.
0 likesShe is really odd
0 likesPrincess 👸
0 likesHi mom day dream here the half changling
0 likes@• Evil Slime 😈 Frog • Celestia not a villain
0 likes@This Is Me UwU booooooooo.
0 likes😠😡
@Jeff Ealy It was a joke jeez
0 likes@This Is Me UwU she is ubnormal
0 likesYep.
0 likesYou’re my favorite character princess Celestia!
0 likesHey tia I am your sister but I am under cover did you eat my cake
0 likes@This Is Me UwU I am luna and I think you should stop ruining pony/humans childhood
0 likesYup
0 likesHello Celestia
0 likesI feel like Pinkie is a different type of Earth Pony. It could’ve happened when the Sonic Rainboom happened. I don’t think When she got her powers from the bell it infused her entire life line, but could it be possible this is another form of Friendship Magic brought on by the Sonic Rainboom? When the Rainboom hit, it’s when Pinkie learned to smile, who knows what else it did to her
0 likesThat's a fun theory. I wonder what the creators would say.
0 likesToo bad their story won't expand anymore since it ended...
Great theory! It makes a lot of sense!
0 likesVery late, but what if farming all those rocks do a number on the Pie Family?
2 likes“Is someone Watching me?”
521 likesThe 650K+ viewers:
Replies (18)
*laughs in mute*
10 likes+9= 499K
4 likes512*
1 like513*
1 like515*
0 likes518*
0 likes529k
0 likes531*
0 likes532
0 likesLMAOOAOAOAOA
0 likes539*
0 likes542*
0 likes544*
0 likesLOL yea
1 likeTrue you made me laugh
0 likes582k*
0 likesIt’s over 650k now lol
0 likesSawtooth: Is someone watching me?
0 likesShe was destined to be the element of laughter and that may have given her those abilities at birth.
1 likeClears throat You know this is Pinkie your talking about, Pinkie is literally about, She the element of laughter, and she all about the illogical actions because she knows we are watching, and does all that to keep us entertained and remember Pinkie has always had Pinkie sense, beginning at a young age when she first saw a Rainboom before all this even Cheese Sandwich and even Maud Pie it probably runs in the family
0 likesAlso remember that every pony lost their powers that are their essence(the rest of the Mane Six probably got that but was showed off-screen) because how would twilight be able to absorb the magic of the past, present, and future mane six to defeat Tirek, Chrysalis, and cozy glow use and The Element of Harmony to defeat villains, remember when Tirek absorbed Braeburn essence that's their essence, which made the ponies of the Apple family in which they became too weak to do anything, and they are all earth ponies like Pinkie
I think it might just be Pinkie having her own type of magic, or when she saw the rain boom the magic started pulsing through her. Aka: she has her own chaos magic, but more low-key then Discord’s.
0 likesi always knew something was really weird about pinkie lol,,
0 likesi think she was just born with a bit of chaos magic and thats why she was able to control all of discord's chaos magic and cozy glow wasnt
"A hole had just appeared in the Galaxy. It was exactly a nothingth of a second long, a nothingth of an inch wide, and quite a lot of million light years from end to end. The nothingth of a second for which the hole existed reverberated backwards and forwards through time in a most improbable fashion. Somewhere in the deeply remote past it seriously traumatized a small random group of atoms drifting through the empty sterility of space and made them cling together in the most extraordinarily unlikely patterns. These patterns quickly learnt to copy themselves (this was part of what was so extraordinary of the patterns) and went on to cause massive trouble on every planet they drifted on to...." AND THAT IS HOW EQUESTRIA WAS MADE
325 likesReplies (4)
Wait what’s that a quote from again...
2 likes@Pinkajou Star Trek, i'm pretty sure.
3 likes@Pinkajou if you're talking about the one " and that's how Equestria was made" it was from TF2 analysis the one with the robot invasion
1 likeEdit yay I got my reply high lighted
No! Equestria was made with song! Hugs Background Pony book This is my equestrian bible! Away with your different stories!
0 likesI solved pinkie pie! So, I’m thinking what you’re thinking, Sawtooth! And I think the time she absorbed Discord’s magic, it sent her new “powers” into the past, as well as the future. But then in the past was a chaos Pinkie Pie but only a little chaos because most of the magic contains at when she got her “new powers”. And that makes Pinkie Pie a little crazier! And then, her best friends the mane 6 just feel like she WAS crazy in the past and was always crazy in the past. And I’m not sure Pinkie Pie just is Pinkie Pie because I’m pretty sure everything has an reason just like Coronavirus.
0 likesMister Sawtooth, there is a problem with your theory.
0 likesIn the episode a gift for Maud Pie, when Maud gets Pinkie Pie's cannon back, she knows exactly who took it. When Rarity asks how, she replies, "Maud Sense" and then Pinkie says, " Runs in the Family." Which ultimately means that this sense or superpower runs in the Pie family.
So we can just assume that this superpower is from the Pie family instead of something only Pinke Pie has. It might be something related with her ancestors or even from Equestria's past. And about the cozy glow event, my theory says that not only Pinkie got the magic, her family did too. Thus concluding that this magic runs in the Pie family. Do you see how easily Maud can tell what rocks are, what they are made up of without doing anything except looking at it once. And her mother, remember the cutie mark chronicles? she could so easily tell that it was pinkus dianna pie aka Pinkie Pie, even though it could have been any of her daughters. Same goes for the rest of the Pie family. It fits well to what we already know about her family.
What if Pinkie got caught up in another type of magical event that left her with her chaoticness as a filly or that she’s related to a magical being of Chaos other than Discord who isn’t around anymore or Celestia gave her those abilities for some reason since Celestia seems to be pretty damn chill about Pinky being the way she is and doesn’t seem as confused as the others were
0 likesMaybe it reached out to a certain time in the past? I mean when she was a filly she always looked upset doing her rock chores with no pinkie sense 🤷♀️
0 likes“Is someone watching me?!”
687 likesThousands of people = Uh, no?
Replies (26)
Yes
4 likesYASSSSS
0 likes200th like
0 likesYES
0 likesHailey Heart
0 likesTOTALLY not hehehehe
Let's be honest here Pinkie Pie is just a kid friendlier version of Deadpool!
1 likeTrue true
0 likesNope
1 likeI am an artist
0 likesAther people: no your not an artist 🙄
Me: yes I am.
I don't think so
0 likes@Hari Radhakrishnan are you talkin to me?
0 likesbruh we are his viewers!
0 likesYou'd be surprised how many people don't think that way, and are wrong.
0 likes10000000000 % yes
0 likesTHAT'S WHAT I SAID I LITTERLY SAID
0 likesSawtooth waves : IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!?
Me : ya me duh
why is everyone saying yes-
0 likes😂
1 likeY-E-S! Mr sawtooth is not that smart.
0 likesI am the 666th like
1 like666 likes :OOOOOOOOOO
1 like@Katherine Howard yep
0 likesDont question it
0 likesYes
0 likesof course Pinkie Pie is watching you. What's up with that? She sees all, and ceases all knowledge by virtue of being the Pinkest of all Pink (ponies)..
0 likesI’m watching him
0 likes@Bubblepop_yt Yes, we are ALL watching him.
0 likesBut Pinkie Pie observes all(everything), just as Twilight instructed her.
I thought she was just like this because it was a way of coping with her past, she sings happy songs with dark backgrounds and smiles through them all :) that might just be my opinion though haha
0 likesI love pinkie she's so cool
But doesn't Maud have an almost pinkie sense too, and if the chaos magic infected her entire timeline why did she only act like pinkie after the rainboom
0 likesThere are some things if this theory is true, to explain cozy glow, since pinkie wasn't chaotic throughout her entire life, it could be the same with cozy glow only manifesting at a certain age with her becoming evil. It could've also been a trigger, like I said the rainbow almost caused pinkie pie to become pinkie pie. Maybe the rainbow triggered the chaos in a more silly and playful way, but cozy glow might have seen something or her own personal desire for great achievements and friends triggered it in a more evil, destructive, and obsessive way (sorry for it being so long)
''Sloving pinkie is impossible''
1 likeSawtooth:nothing is impossible to sloved
I mean with the cozy glow problem I think it was because she’s an unicorn/Alicorn. You see she already had so much magic in her while pinky had none. Maybe cozy glows magic was like how vaccines fight off germs. Cozy glows magic could have fought of that little time that she had discord’s magic. Pinky’s body could have not done that because of the fact she was an earth pony and had no magic in her. I know this might be a bold stament but these puxxle pieces fit together. We’ll never know why pinky’s like this! How ever I would like to be;I’ve it was discord’s magic as u had said in the video.
1 likeThe fact that Pinkie Pie can defy the laws of physics and even gravity is one of the many reason's i love her as a character!
45 likesAnd to think Pinkie Pie isn't the only cartoon character in history to have been shown to defy the laws of physics, i mean after all other cartoon characters such as Ed from Ed, Edd, n Eddy has been shown to defy the laws of physics from time to time.
Replies (3)
How do u edit?
0 likes@• Evil Slime 😈 Frog • There's three dots on your comment. Click on that and then you get the option to edit your comment.
1 likeCan someone please tell me the music of 1:16
0 likesSawtooth: “I may have just solved Pinkie Pie!”
1 likeMe: “Impossible!”
Replies (1)
posable?
0 likesThe answer for how pinkie would have the magic still is simple in another video came another suggestion that some magic can only be give willingly whilst cosy was willing to give back the magic in a heart beat pinkie was forced
0 likesAlso remember that Pinkie took the royal sisters' magic on top of Discord's, enhancing her chaotic reach and power beyond Discord's
0 likesPinkie has to already be compatible with chaos magic for her to be able to use it like that, but Discord's magic could have supercharged her Pinkie powers. Or actually, silly me, I know what it is! Dashie's first sonic rainboom!! A sonic rainboom is a massive explosion of colorful energy, and magic is just concentrated energy (which is why everypony was so weak when Tirek stole everpony's magic) so when Dashie's sonic rainboom made Pinkie all cheerful and bouncy it actually sparked a reaction with when future Pinkie got ahold of Discord's magic, making kinda an electrical connection, only with magic from opposite ends of the timeline.
0 likesThis is also why Pinkie doesn't seem to have any of her Pinkie powers when she's in Pinkamena mode or in the alternate timelines Starlight made by preventing the first sonic rainboom. Maybe her frizzy mane is because of the magic? Like how your hair goes all crazy when you get electrocuted.
Discord's chaos magic is what gives Pinkie her raw power, but she can only control it when she's fueled by the joy she got from the sonic rainboom, which she loses when she feels hurt and betrayed by her friends and goes full Pinkamena. Pinkie can feel sad or hurt without going full Pinkamena and she still retains some of her powers, but when that hair goes flat, that's it, game over. Actually, if anything Pinkie's chaos magic becomes downright destructive when she's in Pinkamena mode, like in the yovidaphone episode where flowers would die and balloons would deflate when Pinkie walked by. Going full Pinkamena made Pinkie lose control of her chaos magic and it started destroying things around her
Pinkie being supercharged with two types of magic also explains where Pinkie gets all her energy from! Being a hyper cheerful party girl without chaos magic, or magic in general really, is super exhausting! Seriously, this universe has like no magic at all!! How am I supposed to spread happiness and friendship when I can't even make it half a day without crashing!?
I love this as a theory for how she gained her strange magic, but it seems like other party ponies like Cheese Sandwich and Party Favor are also capable for similar/the same things as Pinkie, and I’m not sure chaos magic makes a suitable explanation for them & other party ponies 😅
88 likesReplies (3)
Yeah and if it was Pinkie Pie's family thing, there's still Sandwich and Party Flavor. (looking at the fact, that Maud also has some kind od sense)
7 likesAnd if it is some kind of earth ponies magic, that only some of them got, that would explain the return of Pinkie's magic in that one scene with Cozy Glow.
Or maybe the chaos magic just enhances her pinky pie-ness maybe
5 likeshow about running it in revers, she could manage the magic because it was within her element to wield this magic. she has after all proven that time and time again.
5 likesPinkieis not an alicorn, because she is more than an Alicorn. she can wield 2 magics even a great Alicorn can not. Aside from earth, Pegasus and Unicorn magic, she has Chaos and Changeling too.
You said whole timeline, would that mean her twin could possibly have powers as well?
1 likeTalking something not really related, at the part where they got their magic back, how come they were still friends? The mane six's friendship is magic (The whole point of the show) surely, that magic was taken by cozie glow's spell. That was the whole point of why she did the spell. She would need the MAGIC of friendship if she wanted to be the EMPRESS of friendship
0 likes"Well, this is quite the combination of secondary characters."
1 like-Discord
Cozy glow had absorbed discords magic but got it taken away from her, in such a short time and pinkie pie had it for a longer period. That might be why.
0 likesI know I'm not the only one who notice this
375 likesShe is the only pink in her family
Replies (48)
A guy solved this with RBG
21 likes@•𝐃𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐦• what's his name
5 likesits true
6 likesFun fact: The Pies are the only family with the same last name
67 likesOnce again the chaos magic doing its work
8 likesIn a fan fic called muffins, it says that pinkie got the pink gene, making her pink. This however makes a bit to much sence for mlp. Thinking back to prevouis Sawtooth wave viedos, he thought that maybe Celestia named all the ponies. I find this unlikly, because there are proably millions of ponies and she named every single one? I think that that parents get a peek at their childs cutie mark, and then they get to name them off that. They don't need to base off that, like putunia. Her cutie mark is bones. Putenias and bone? The parents choose putenia. If this is also the case, then this would also explain why the parents thought she was going to be a pirate. Bone, Pirate. That works. Perhaps Pinkie's parents saw her balloons on her pink flank and called her Pinkie. But that doesn't explain why she's pink.
25 likesReccessive pink gene
7 likes@Ramilda there is the cake family
5 likes@Myrrh Park Unless they can see the future that doesn't work. Ponies aren't born with Cutie Marks, remember
10 likesMy theory is that Pinkie was born with a genetic abnormality because of which she is the black sheep of her family. Since she was so different and her family normally named her sisters after rocks and Pinkie’s colour combination was in no way related to rocks, her parents didn’t know what to call her and just named her after her skin and mane colour.
16 likes@•StormysideUP• dragontrainer something i think
0 likesTrue that is destiny and is your real surname Dupain-cheng
0 likes@Ramilda yes true
0 likes@Shivi Srivastava ill believe in your headcanon lol
1 like@Hey Eaglet thnx. This was just my guess, it just came into my head. BTW I’m 11 yrs old
0 likesdelenasqt true lmao
0 likesAlso, i just did some calculations if this could happen and turns out, children of any species are more related to their grandparents. This could also probably be shown in Lil’ Cheese, pinkie’s daughter. Her skin colour is a light version of pinkie’s father, but it is also the light version of cheese sandwich. So i conclude that in MLP, fillies aren’t more related to their grandparents...
5 likesOr are they? It could be possible that one of pinkie’s grandparents coat was pink. But then it clashed with their partner’s colour which made it greyish. Now this could be either her maternal grandparents who made her mother’s coat grey or paternal parents and it came out in pinkie’s father’s hair. But maybe that pink was still passed on and it came out in pinkie.
Phew! Even as a kid, i wrote a long essay about pinkie
In her song from the pilot didn't she mention an aunt with pink in her name too?
0 likesIlluminati confirmed
1 likeOr maybe she’s just adopted
0 likes😆
0 likesIdk if this is correct or not but an article on google said " the name Pinkamena means "Lively, the life of the party. It also means pink and the name Pinkamena means "Insane" because Pinkamena Diane Pie is her full name!! Still dosen't explain way she's pink tho
3 likes@DUCKS IS FLOOFY i don’t know what ‘the pilot’ is but i just randomly thought of this and told it to you guys
0 likesI have actually now written a whole speech on these possibilities and will probably upload my first video in my channel about this
0 likesOop yeah
0 likesAnyone else got better ideas?
0 likesThat's where the theory that she got pink cuz she used to be somepony who died and Steven Universe brought her back with his tears
0 likes@Shivi Srivastava wow that is so cool. I can't believe you're 11 but.... what's the point of saying you are. If I were you kid, I would keep that away from people. People are jerks and assume a lot of things from your age. They have a narrow perception of what different ages are like, (especially for children,) so when the age of someone is revealed online, people stop taking them seriously if they're a child.
0 likes@Shivi Srivastava A pilot is the first episode for a TV show most of the time. sometimes it's before the 1st episode. The guy you're replying to is talking about the first episode
0 likesEveryone Kinda Notice That
0 likesI think she adopted, or got from a grandparent
1 likeDiego Productions oh, i didn’t know that. Thanks for telling and subscribing
1 likeAlso, the fact that grandparents are more related to their grandchildren can be confirmed in MLP if you look at Granny Smith and Apple Bloom’s eye color and that neither Apple Bloom’s parents, nor her siblings have the same eye color.
0 likesAbout that adopted theory, i don't think it would work, because Pinkie is a twin at least, looking at her comment in the episode, where families spend "Hearts and Hooves Day" together (i'm terrible at remembering episodes names qwq)
2 likes"few seconds younger sister".
I mean, there is a possibility that their parents made it up, but i don't think so ;^;
Lovieca her family doesn’t seem like the lying type tho. Very very straight forward and dead (in a way)
2 likesWhat if one of pinkies parents cheated on the other and had pinkie
0 likes@Ramilda shy? Sparkle? Dash? Apple!?
0 likesWhat are those!?
@Khitara Aldilla wdym, the whole family doesn’t have the same last name
0 likes@Ramilda ok u need to watch the episodes again also i forgot to put the pie family
0 likes@Khitara Aldilla my reply was literally about the pie family. also give me actual ponies w the same last name who aren't the pies then
0 likes@Ramilda uuumm twilight sparkle ;-;
0 likes@Khitara Aldilla I’m not talking about ponies with last names. I’m talking about a whole family having the same last name.
0 likes@Ramilda Marble Pie
0 likesLimestone Pie
Pinkie pie
Igneous Rock Pie
Cloudy Quartz
Maudileena Daisy Pie
@Khitara Aldilla that’s exactly what I said 😑 MY WHOLE COMMENT WAS ABOUT HOW ONLY THE PIES HAVE THE SAME LAST NAME
0 likes@Ramilda pinkies mom doesnt ;-;
0 likes@Khitara Aldilla really? Huh, I guess. But my comment still stands. Just bc one pony doesn't have it, doesn't mean multiple ponies don't have the same name
0 likes@Ramilda ok?
0 likes@Khitara Aldilla ok. good we got that sorted :)
0 likesOk I have a theory: What If PinkiePie is an alicorn?
0 likesNow just hear me out, sawtooth stated that to become an alicorn you need magic from all three tribes, and they described most of the princesses getting their alicorn magic from the fact that they hold a great amount of respect and appreciation to ponies of all of the tribes. But doesn’t pinkie pie do the same? She should have appreciation from all three tribes for what she does and how she makes/tries to make everypony happy? If that’s the case when she also have magic from the three tribes? If that’s the case it could explain how come she got to keep some of the chaos magic and cozy didn’t.
But Pinkie kept her "chaos" in Tartarus, when she convinced Tirek to give Twillight his rest of magic.
0 likesi think his right when cozy absorb discord magic it was just discord magic but when pinkie absorb it was combine with alicorn magic, tirek magic, queen crisalist, and there other magic that was in the bell but thats just my theory
2 likesWait I have a theory on how Pinkie Pie got her weird magic. One word Rainboom. Think about it. When Twilight was given magic from Celestia, Luna, and Cadence, their cutie mark vanished. If cutie marks are linked to one’s magic, would it be possible that the rainboom that came from Rainbow Dash’s magic created Pinkie Pie’s? I know this is a stretch but if we look back at Feeling Pinkie Keen, only Pinkie Pie was able to predict things right when it happened. We have never seen a character able to do that except maybe Maud. What if ponies’ magic is already within them but they have to figure out how to bring it out? The rainboom brought the mane 6’s magic out and formed a connection. Maybe it wasn’t Grogar’s bell that caused her chaotic powers rather than that one event. I know it’s a stretch but i don’t see any evidence prior to that one event that someone went back in time and did that.
0 likesNobody can solve pinkie Pie not even pinkie
433 likesReplies (5)
That is true cross my heart and hope to fly stick a cupcake in my eye
18 likesAW YEAAAAA
6 likes🤔
1 likeEven Celesta can't solve it
0 likes@Kylan Cooper promise not to tell? Will will you zip your mouth closed🤐 then lock your mouth 🔒then dig a hole 🕳️put the key in the hole🔑🕳️ then build a house over the whole thing forget it exists and live in the house happily ever after lol🏠🏘.😄🤐
1 likeThis seems likely. But it could also have something to do with her cutie mark. Because Party Favor pulled balloons from out of nowhere and even when magic was gone, Pinkie Pie still did some abnormal things, like pull cakes out of nowhere in Tarterus. But in the s4 finale, she lost her cutie mark and she never did any of those strange things (or at least I don't remember her doing them). And in s5 when she lost her cutie mark she didn't do those abnormal things. And Cheese Sandwitch also did some abnormal things (but not nearly as much as Pinkie).
0 likesWhen I saw that episode (totally wasn't earlier today btw) I thought it more like because pinkie was such a chaotic being she was able to harness the magic instead of it going hog wild unlike with cozy glow
0 likesPulling things out of thin air is literally normal for all of them.
0 likesHello Sawtooth! I wanted to tell you why I personnally think that it wasnt discords magic. You said that when pinkie pie gotted all of that power, it affected all of her timeline. But as your clone telled you, the real pinkie pie was dead all along since season 3, so how could that magic get both the real pinkie and her clones? (I know that the show hasnt really explained the science of magic cloning)
0 likesReplies (1)
Because the pool was act like a mirror and copying all about Pinkie Pie
0 likesSawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?!
150 likesHis FBI Agent: buck
Replies (3)
Did you notice the THX music?
1 likeThat moment gave me the creeps.
1 likeHaha
0 likesI don't have enough words to thank you for using the THX sound. Glad people haven't forgotten it.
0 likesAs someone who is a huge fan of both My Little Pony gen. 4, and Star Trek, I think I get it even more. Q, Continuum: past-future. Q-Discord- John DeLancie.
0 likesnow that i think about this i think because she absorbed alicorn magic along with discord's magic it fused into her essence but cozy only took discord's magic so it didn't effect her.
0 likesSomething interesting is that Cozy Glow can’t control Discord magic but Pinkie Pie can.
0 likesJust a comment.
Pinkie might not even be a pony, she could be a creature that can change like a changling or a new creature.
295 likesReplies (8)
Yeah, remember the episode where pinkie pulled a whole lotta pinkies from a magic lake in a magic cave and twilight made them watch paint dry?? Two of the pinkies were talking and one of them changed her face to a gen 1 style pinkie and made the other laugh. Maybe thats an example???
33 likesEdit: I just remembered the OTHER pinkie that was with the pinkie I mentioned earlier blew into her own hoof and FINGERS CAME OUT OF IT!!!!!!
hey a changling hybrid maybe
7 likesWhat if she’s also Nikki from Camp Camp? She just went through a intergalactic portal and jump through fandoms???
3 likesShe is a new creature that they have not put in the show she is a changing a new one. What if she is a changing that take happiness instead, take love or giving love. No steal my thinking pls
0 likesI don’t agree
0 likesElias Powlison O-O too much information for my brain
1 likemagically genetic mutation ? idk it’s just a fun thing to say
0 likesWell if her whole family is like that it would explain why pinky sense runs in the family
0 likesYou said it affected her time-line when she was a filly but cozy glow is already a filly and never see her future so it is not a problem, cozy glow she was an Alicorn at the time she absorbed discord's magic so she can handled it while pinkie is just an earth pony there is no cozy problem.
1 likeSawtooth Waves, I know the reason why Pinkie Pie new what happened in the other world. I watched My Little Pony bloopers and there was a part that two of the Pinkie Pie's from different worlds were secretly using the portal you have to watch it. IT'S SOO AWESOME and a bit funny.
0 likesI agree with Atxqrygh0ul but another theory that I thought of is that Cozyglows’s body was already full of magic so it couldn’t embrace any of Discord’s
0 likesThey also constantly break the fourth wall by talking to the audience.
0 likesThis is a really solid feeling, I mean, we’ve seen time travel magic, we’ve seen pinkie being psychic, we’ve also seen different universes based on a single event so why couldn’t it affect the past along with the future giving rise to a dr who theory of fixed points in time and then the unfixed points where you can change something. Pinkie absorbing the chaos magic is a fixed point- in this universe it will always happen, just as the sonic rainboom was proven to be an unfixed point as they all would’ve gotten their cutie marks at some point or another. So maybe its possible for a fixed point in the future to affect the entire past! Great theory and makes way for a ton of discussion. Or of course, it’s pinkie pie and we shouldn’t question it.
10 likesReplies (2)
In other words “Ripples of distortion radiated our from that point of impact, shifting everything just a tiny bit...but enough. Enough for events to happen slightly differently”
2 likesMaybe she is a party pony a sub type of earth pony
0 likesI'm not too sure one can ever "figure out" pinky pie, ya know
1 likeslight problem in a episode Maud said that she had Maud sense. Pinkie also stated that it runs in the family.
0 likesBut still could be true.
Actually I think your theory works out because of one reason Remember what she said when the chaos magic Was being absorbed into her twilight said how do you feel shes said itchy tingling etc
0 likesSay what you like, you’re all just jealous that Pinkie became the true hero of MLP, she’s the one who truly defeated Cozy, Chrysalis and Tirek, albeit with help from Discord
0 likes“But that’s just Pinkie Pie being Pinkie. You can’t explain it... or can you?” Vsause music plays
413 likesReplies (5)
What’s normal? Are you normal?
3 likesEmpire Cross normal is defined as the characteristic or trait to not be abnormal or different from a just group or society.
3 likesYah
0 likes@Adam Jackson YAH!!!
0 likes😂😂😂i laffed wayyyyy too hard at this
0 likesI think the difference is that pinkie's "energy/spirit" matches with discord's magic
0 likes1:50
2 likes-puts on spikes hat, jacket and sunglasses and backs out of the door-Knowing what we know now, and seeing the Earth ponies do have some kind of magic, maybe pinky was the start of this?
0 likesI think I've heard this theory before or at least one very similar. I don't remember where it was from though.
1 likeWho had the chaos magic longer? Maybe the magic was revoked from Cozy Glow before it had a chance to take effect?
0 likesI have one question. If this is the theory that proves pink sense, then why does maud have a maud sense? I’d really like to know an answer if anyone comes up with the theory! :)
1 likeI think pinky being a rock farmer exposed her to raw magic and she constantly consumed it and was constantly around it
0 likesMaybe we we're just shown the timeline where discord's chaos essence was consumed in Pinkie Pie's timeline instead of the timeline she wasn't on MLP this whole time and it just didn't work with Cozy!
0 likestwilight sparkle: sees video
263 likesalso her: whats this?
her after watching it: q u a k i n g
Replies (9)
Twilight: PINKIE!!!! WE NEED TO TALK RIGHT NOW!!!
13 likes@MyNameIsn'tYourBusiness lol
3 likesLet’s turn this into a comment chain!
4 likesPinkie: what is it twi?
5 likesTwi: So you basically have chaos magic inside of you even though your an earth pony. Explains why you are crazy.
5 likes@- Nahida Ch. - Pinkie: I am not crazy.. not right now, but that is too subjective for you to comprehend.
5 likes@Kentavritsa Pinky: I’m wanna get the bell again
3 likes@fluorescent duck
4 likesTwi: Please don’t. And, sorry, that was a bad choice of words... but, how else would you explain all of those stunts you pull, I’ve seen discord preform similar stunts so it just makes sense.
Pinkie:wait,didn't cozy used the bell as well?.....should we worry?
1 likepinkie is just the spirit of spontaneity, doesn't have to be chaotic
0 likesnow the things that the pinkie clones did in to many pinkie pies, when they where watching paint dry makes sense
1 likeSimple, Pinkie (thanks to begin comic relief) has chaos powers like breaking the 4th wall
0 likesI feel like earth ponies version of ‘magic’ is that rarely at birth they are born with strange abilities like pinky and cheese. possibly a rare cutie mark or something.
0 likesIn season 1 ep 24 Twilight's Owl winks at the camera, probably more creatures do show that they can see the audience (us) in the show. What does this say? :3
0 likesDon't mean to debunk the idea because I like it, but I just wanted to say this.
maybe its a bootstrap pradox, I mean, maybe pinkie can handle chaotic magic because she already had been exposed to that, in the future. Mind blow
0 likesI love how the rule books name was "Da Rules" 🤣
1 likeI just thought of this.
0 likesTheory:
What if Pinkie Pie was adopted.
Let's bust out the fact that this might be the case.
Fact 1: She's pink(I know it's obvious but hear me out). If we take a look at her family's color palette and then Pinkie's, we can see a big difference. While Pinkie's family has muted color palettes Pinkie does not.
Fact 2: Her abilities. While it seems like Pinkie Pie can pull stuff from out of nowhere! Her family can't.
Fact 3: She's chaotic like it said in the video. Her family seems to be calm and saner than Pinkie.
Fact 4: She has magic as we saw in the second to last episode she has magic.
So here's a story I thought of.
An earth pony and draconequus fell in love. However, it was forbidden and they already had a child Pinkie. Pinkie didn't have any distinct features of the draconequus parent, but she still had the chaotic magic. She was left at the Pies' doorstep the night before the parents' execution. Pinkie grew up on the rock farm never knowing her real parents. As she was getting older her magic started to appear. She could pull stuff from out of nowhere, gaining Pinkie senses and whatnot. She grew up to be the Pinkie we know today.
I just wanted to share this new theory of mine. I wanted to keep it relevant so, that's why this comment is so late.
Hey did anyone realize when cozy glow got discord magic she couldn’t control what she did but when pinky pie got discord magic she could control it why better the cozy glow so that might have a saying to do with it to because if discord and pinky pie can control the magic they might have the same bit of element in them that’s my theory to connect discord and pinky’s crazy doings together
466 likesReplies (11)
She may have always had A lesser version all along
5 likesI did notice that but didn't think anything of it
5 likesHe did say in his first appearance that Pinkie’s element of laughter was the one he had most affinity to.
17 likesI agree! It would make sense that since the same magic is flowing through them would make pinkie in control of the chaos magic.
7 likesAdditionally the chaos magic must of leaked into her timestream meaning she could control it better when the time came.
3 likesGood point
0 likesAnd my thought is that to control chaos magic you need have right personality and mindset. Like pinki and discord, both naturally enjoy chaos but cozy glow don't.
7 likesCozy glow couldn't control it bcz she is just a child/filly?
4 likesCozys a child, ponks an adult. Makes a difference in capability overall. Oops already been said.
0 likes@Lost Pony Yes, but it's chaos magic. Even Tirek admitted it its impossible to control
2 likes@꧁Wooshbait꧂ Really??
0 likesi think pinkie had a lot of chaos magic in the first place. Cheese sandwich has the same type of magic so I think its natural
0 likesBut in the Christmas special pinkie asks those deer things about the perfect gift and if she could see into the future or connected to the future she would know the perfect gift to give twilight but she did not. So if this the theory were true, pinkie would have got the perfect gift from the start and would not have to ask the reindeer.
0 likesIn my opinion, your theory is definitely true.
0 likesbased on when discord was helping Tirek drain the magic of ponies they alsp said Tirek drained the magic of EARTH ponies. Which makes me beileve that all earth ponies have magic to some degree it is just channeled by their cutie marks. I think that it is Pinkie being Pinkie but the magical parts (teleportation and being incredibly fast) come from her cutie mark taking the magic around her and giving her new abilities.
0 likesI don’t think Pinkie got power from absorbing Discord’s magic, because that wayyy wayyy near the end of the story. I do believe she has magic powers like discord, but less powerful. Pinkie is outrageous and chaotic, I think if you are born like that you just have some hidden powers in you. If pinkie wasn’t chaotic she probably wouldn’t have powers, like discord when he tried to act normal.
0 likesThank you I have been trying to figure this out for years also I would really like to know what your favorite episode is my favorite episode is the one where rarity opens up a boutique in Canterlot and the episode where starlight glimmer goes to Canterlot on a mission to help the royal sisters
0 likesPlease Notice This Comment, Sawtooth Waves!
1 likeSawtooth, I noticed that you forgot to mention that Spike didn't get magic back in the part of the video where you pointed out who got magic back in the episode with Cozy Glow’s spell. If Spike didn't get magic, how is his ‘Magic Fire Letter Burping’ possible? I mean, if he has some magical ability that no other dragons have, then why did he not have magic? So think about it this way: if he didn't have magic, he wouldn't have the instant mail express whatchamacallit. But, he DOES. ⚠️ PARADOX ALERT ⚠️
Replies (1)
Maybe that’s just a spell twilight put on him
0 likesPinkie sense has nothing to do with chaos magic! In one of the episodes, it is explained that her sister, Maud Pie, also has a Maud sense!!!
1 likeWait, so if Pinkie got the Pinkie Sense from Discord's magic, then how did Cheese Sandwich get HIS Cheese Sense?
28 likesReplies (5)
oh and maud sense... idk maybe it's genetic? or, maybe they're somehow copying her... 🤔😂 no that's weird
7 likesIf it affects by time, maybe by being connected to pinkie pie from their child, li'l cheese, affected his timeline, too.
11 likes@Ribbuns 🤯yeah okay, that... doesn't make sense to me 😅
2 likesNot Just Cheese Her Whole Family Had Senses
0 likes@Jonella Magbanua So if her ting the chaos magic affected her entire family, does that mean that it also could've affected her past ancestors? Think about it. If every past family was affected, this then proves that Pinkie isn't related to Applejack
0 likesabout the cozy glow thing,i think there were no side effects for cozy glow because shes a pegasus but pinkie is an earth pony or the time since cozy glow only got to absorve the magic for 1m while pinkie longer
0 likesThe difference between cozy and pinkie is that pinkie used the magic she got, while cozy got turned back before she had the chance to do so. Also (like another commenter said) Alicorns can hold magic in a different way than normal ponies (fx when all the princess put theyr magic onto twilight, they probably couldn’t have done that to a normal pony) so cozy would be able to contain the magic in that moment, while pinkie wouldn’t.
0 likesspeaking of chaos Izzy from the NG5 had that Pinkie vibe to her, though being a unicorn. And the most interesting fact is that she kept her "glow" unlike all other unicorns from the village. Makes me think what the fuck happened XD
0 likespinkie is actual god, having cloned herself and having almost altered the entire state of the universe.
0 likesI believe she is a pony god, but she doesn't know it...
139 likesReplies (4)
That examples a lot
0 likesShe does state at the end of explaining to the Cutie Mark Crusaders about how she got how cutie mark. "And that's how Equestria was made."
7 likesMe to
0 likesshe knows, she knows that she knows, but since it is not relevant at the time she does not know.
1 likeIf pinkie's pinkie sense can affect future timelines because of discords bell. Then how the heck does cheese sandwich have cheese sense without grogars bell?
1 likeI love the theory. But you're breaking the rule: Just don't question the Pink Eldritch Abomination... Err Pinkie Pie.
0 likesEither way or other, Pinkie Pie is my favorite character. She's funny, cute, energetic and random.
0 likesTimeline theory is kinda dump, but connection between chaos magic(or even Discord specificly) and Pinkie it's something that was clear from early seasons.
0 likesi watched this to get more insight into the "Smile" episode where she kills all of her friends but there wasnt anything said about it! its actually only thing i saw from MLP world.
0 likesI really like that theory alot! With the cozy glow problem i thought of your other video where Cozy Glow was in the human world or even from the human world. Maby that has something to do with it?? And! In that videos comments someone said that she said something along the lines of: “you ponies wouldnt understand” so maby its because shes another kind of creature that cant have magic? Just a theory but i thought it was an interresting thought :))
0 likesOk wow I clearly need to watch further into the show for this
0 likesHow do you explain equestria girl Pinkie and her having knowledge to alternate worlds? Did the chaos magic maybe not just affect Equestrian Pinkie but travel through her to alternate pinkie pies and affect them similarly?
0 likes"Is someone watching me?"
121 likesNope. Nopony is watching you. Not at all. Whistles.
Replies (1)
Yes we are silly
1 likeThis actually makes a lot of sense
0 likesIts been 7 months but i think had something too.
0 likesPinkie pies magic was spread out through her life span because it was all of their magic. When cozy glow absorbed chaos magic she only absorbed chaos magic because the other 2 absorbed the rest but maybe pinky absorbed all of it. Making it so much for her to handle and spreading the magic across her timeline.
Cheesy sense debunks this. As does Maud sense. Or at least debunks any connection with the pinky sense. Also, Party Favour can do comparable stuff. Take a page out of twilights book on this one. You can't explain it, but somehow it just works.
0 likesHer time lines jumbled because of the effects and thats why pinkie pie is my favorite pony
1 likePinke is a race all in her own
142 likesReplies (2)
I actually really like that idea! Think about it. Pinkie, unlike her family, has never really shown much connection to the earth. I'm not sure what she would be, but if someone finds a folklore creature that matches pinkie put it in the replies
12 likesi like that theory :)
4 likesThis doesn't explain Party Favor's or Cheese Sandwich's similar abilities, or Maud's, for that matter.
0 likesAlso all earth ponies, interestingly enough~
Wait what if the reason Cozy glow didn't absorb Discord's magic the same way Pinky pie did was because she was a pegasus.
1 likeJust an idea.🤪
I think pinkie and discord were siblings let me explain
0 likesThe time line from both the wizard and grogar are different but let me explain mine,what if discord was a normal pony? I will tell it with a story
Long ago there were two little fillies of the pie family pinkie pie and corndie pie
As the grew up they became really good siblings until...grogar came in that family
He wanted to turn pinkie into a powerful being
Their parents tried to protect them but...pinkie went outside and almost got hit by grogar but corndie saved his little sister and became discord
I think what happened what do you think?
Cozy was an alicorn when she absorbed discords chaos magic but pinkie was just an earth pony , maybe only alicorns can handle that magic without spreading it throughout their whole timeline unlike unicorns , pegasi , or earth ponies aka pinkie pie
0 likesSawtooth:is someone watching me?
76 likesMe:you made this public😆
Replies (1)
That is sooooooooo true
0 likesTo be honest, I think Pinkie Pie was once a Unicorn but in a spell gone wrong, she accidentally got rid of her horn and forever to be a earth pony until a unicorn brings it back.
0 likesI think it was different since Pinky is an earth pony and Cozy Glow was an alicorn when she absorbed the magic
0 likesI could add up that, by the time cozy glow absorbed Discords's magic, she was a alicorn, while pinkie, well, is an earth pony-
0 likesIf we solve Pinkie Pie, there will no longer be any more parties and the citizens of Ponyville will be unhappy all day, just like Pinkie's family. Without Pinkie Pie, Ponyville will have a big difference. Please don't solve Pinkie Pie.
0 likes"She dont needs discord magic..."
132 likesShe all ready crazy as it is-
|o-0|
hmm well theirs definitely a magic aspect lets not forget cheese sandwich has also shown the same abilities as pinkie... question is, why do they have this magic and why does it seem genetic? even in the equestria girls human world pinkie seems to have the same abilities so its not limited to equestrian magic either since human pinkie had some minor power similarities prior to the first time they ponied up, so its both magical and genetic at the same time... but perhaps pinkies chaotic abilities stem more from the timeline when discord was the ruler of equestria since he obviously isn't tied to a singular timeline and the comic where discord makes pinkie princess of chaos? never read it just heard about it... so she's had exposure to chaos magic long before that event, but at this point I'm just listing things that might put her exposure to chaos magic to before that episode, though what about grogar? what if one of pinkie's ancestors was one of his creations and a small scale attempt at taming chaos magic? last theory likely not the case but hey ya never truly know with pinkie
0 likesMaybe the problem with cozy glow can be solved by saying that that She wanned to use the power of evil and didnt even know from the start that it was Discords magic, but you know im just a simple kid so what do i know
0 likesI read someone else's suggestion that "Pony Life" is a pocket universe created by Pinkie Pie when she briefly absorbed the chaos magic.
0 likesSawtooth: "Is someone watching me?"
0 likesMe: "Please don't stare at me like that. You do know what a YouTube video is, right?"
Me seeing the title: (Thanos voice) “impossible”
74 likesNo pony knows how to use discords magic, however pinkie pie did. I assume she's some kinda mega minded pony.
0 likesthe real question is, how did pinkie take discords magic in the first place? don’t you need a spell for that?
0 likesVery believable speaking of ponies that aren't unicorns I'd like to mention that there was a vampire pony without a horn but wings it would be able to you know pull off telekinesis despite not having a horn but that's probably just my theory
0 likesPinkie Pie (from My Little Pony Friendship is Magic) is always a mystery.
0 likesMaud has a maud Sense and pinkie said :" it is in the family. "
93 likesReplies (4)
I think the Sense is an earth pony thing.
7 likesWhat about other things
0 likes@NaoLucille♪Random ehem applejack,apple bloom and more;
2 likes( it must be a pie thing )
Cheese also has one
0 likesConspiraPon3's theory could tie into this if pinkie is a changeling who grows powerful through love than she would have her own magic already and the encounter with discord's magic might have reacted with her magic, her changeling biology, or both and that would explain the different experience cozy glow had; they're two different species
0 likesI got a other theory about Pinkie. I'm almost sure that she was adopted by the Pie family. The evidence : Everyone in the Pie family are greyish but her.
0 likeslets not forget that "nopony can control Discord chaotic magic" but apparently pinky can?
0 likes"Everyone wants an impact. An impact that would shake the ground below out feet"
0 likesThe ad I watched before this said that xD
Fit perfectly
Maybe the element of laughter had something to do with it. I mean it does make sense cause cozy glow was and evil characters and pinkie pie is one of the elements of harmony so maybe because of her element it might have had a different effect on her.
0 likesOne problem with this theory...CUTIE MARKS! All three Equine tribes MAGICALLY obtain flank symbols upon finding their proclivity OR talent! Earth Pony's and Pegasi are therefore JUST as compatible with wielding Magic as Unicorns are. It's just that it likely manifests in different ways! Take Applejack, SHE's an Earth pony yet she AND Pinky Pie bear one of the elements of harmony. Now let's look at their traits. Apple Jack is strong, athletic, and has HIGH Stamina and endurance and Pinkie Pie is an anomaly of reality. Applejack herself wasn't exposed to chaos magic, but Pinky's reaction to it highlights, for ME at least, Earth pony's as bearers of LATENT Magic pertaining to their innate talents. Had Applejack been exposed to discord's magic instead, I'm inclined to believe we would have gotten the Pony equivalent of the incredible HULK.
0 likesPegasi are a similar case. Alongside their magic flank symbols, THEY gain not "Magic" per say but SUPERPOWERS. Every Pegasi, if trained, gains SOME capacity to manipulate the weather for example. Then there's the special cases! Fluttershy doesn't manipulate the weather but is instead an ANIMAL WHISPERER and can be seen in THAT way as "influencing nature"! Rainbow Dash is a speedster and can go faster than sound with the Sonic rainboom. Elements of Harmony AREN'T a necessity to gain powers like these EITHER it would seem. Rainbow Dash AND Derpy Hooves, a commoner Pegasi, have been shown to have the power of HEAT VISION! THEN we have Cozy Glow...SEEMINGLY a Pegasus...gaining the ability to harness PRIMARY Pony Magic and gaining a HORN!
The Cutie Marks say it all. They are evidence of Magic in not just Unicorns but ALL Pony Kind. THAT's why Starlight Glimmer, A MASTER of Pony Magic, was able to control the people of her village through her Cutie Mark "nixing equity spell". If Pinkie Pie's case WERE so special, it would have ONLY worked on other Unicorns, NOT Pegasi and Earth Pony's. Friendship is Magic for NOT just Unicorns, but ALL Equine tribes afterall. How they GET that Magic is the REAL trick! But that's My theory. What do you think?
My theory (whch actually I've had since about season 3!) was that she was just born with a ltitle bit of chaos magic haha
0 likesi think that pinkie pie is just that fun character to break all known rules. she's just being pinkie pie.
0 likesplus if pinkie got chaos magic from the bell in her blood then why does her sister Maud have a Maud sense?
that just doesn't add up. no i believe that Pinkie inherited her magic.
"IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?!"
29 likes-Yeah, Pinkie is watching you from the beginning of all eternity, heh...
It was chaos magic so it could be an event in the future affecting the past.
0 likesI would like to say: I pretty sure when pinkie has her pinkie senses that's before she inhaled the power.
0 likesMy theory about Cozy Glow
0 likesit did affect her past.
it made her a malevolent megalomaniac bent on world domination.
I dont know if this was before or after EQG but, this might solve mlp Pinkie Pie, but it doesn't solve EQG pinkie pie, since she's just as hyper and un-logical as mlp pinkie pie, an example would be a brief moment in eqg friendship games where she teleported everywhere in the hallway, so, if that pinkie pie could do it without taking in the magic of the bell, I don't think that solves mlps pinkie pie since there was no magical bell in that world
0 likesHey, in the episode 'one where pinkie knows' at the end we see pinkie pie break into pieces... literally in pieces as in pieces. And we know just one being that can do that. Our dear Discord
0 likesI was sceptical at first but you know what? Headcanon accepted.
0 likesi think, that pinkie pie, and human pinkie pie are two, but also the same. i know it sounds confusing, but what if theyre both using the portal, and they knew about, longer than twilight? that would explain the ,,i know everything about everyone" things
0 likesHe has just solved the unsolvebole, OMG!
1 like“Is someone watching me?”
17 likesThat cracked me up 😹
But what about “Maud Sense?”
2 likesPinkie was still able to pull a pizza costume from nowhere when magic was gone
0 likesI know how Pinkie Pie get her magic.
0 likesLong time ago when she was a child, Pinkie got her power from rainboom and inflated her hair.
pinkie was only able to control discords magic bc she already had chaos magic in her all earthponies still have magical abilities connected to their special talent
0 likeswhat ab the rest of the pie family with their senses?
67 likes“maud sense”
pinkie: “it runs in the family”
Replies (3)
Lol ur problally the only one who remembered maud sense else then me
2 likes@Khitara Aldilla I remember that episode with Raritey
1 like@Penny Rose pssd
1 likeMaybe it's part of her cutie mark magic Maybe when she got her cutie mark It gave her Some Help To throw a party Like being able to Pull up party canon out of thin air
0 likesBut, can you please solve Pinkamena?
1 likeMaybe since pinkie is a earth pony she had a greater effect since she probably had more room for magic unlike cosy glow
0 likesOkay so, I love this theory but I am not very sure about pinkie sense, we have seen other kinds of sense like pinkie's, Maud sense in the Psstd and cheesy sense too. so if I donnt include pinkie sense then I love this theory!!
0 likesHere’s my theory: Pinkie Pie absorbed Discord’s chaos magic, found out she could do the stuff she does even after the Magic was taken from her, traveled back in time, so she could do all that stuff when she was a baby, filly, and even a teen.
82 likesReplies (8)
She's going to bake a portal, Open it and jump in.
9 likes@Blueberry Pie .. UwU
0 likes@chikorita PKMNFG lol I think u made them mad
0 likes@Blueberry Pie
1 likeUwU
@Blueberry Pie Pinkie's Brew intensifies
1 likeI see ur a person of culture too
@Blueberry Pie UWU UWU UWU UWU UWU UWU UWU
0 likes@Ilașcu Flavia tru
0 likesEr I just had that same idea too
0 likes2:07 Reminds me of when the Wifi returns after hours of a blackout 😂
0 likesAlso something else to add to this is that Maud (Pinkies sister) has Maud sense so maybe Pinkie really is just Pinkie
0 likesI know why they stare into existance as if somebody watches them, if you look at pinkie pie on Netflix or YouTube you can tell she is talking to you or to twilight sparkle as in magic duel she muffles for her mouth to come back and kinda stares at you and gasps and the video ends on Netflix, but what if the case was pinkie pie did get the chaos magic and it did spread through timelines, family, and also cheese sandwich since in the future had a wedding with Pinkie pie, but I think since pinkie was full of joy and fun, it turned into JOY MAGIC....
1 likeThis still means chaos magic, but discord hasn't appeared in the black asking for something like how pinkie did, yeah maybe the pinkie sense is half chaos magic but danger sense magic for some reason because pinkie pie keeps herself safe by using pinkie sense, so pinkie pie isn't an earth pony practically because she has joy magic and danger sense magic but she was just classically what the future earth ponies are with magic now but pinkie was the first to gain this so did cheese, maud, but this proves my point that this is danger and joy magic but one more thing to say the teleporting, breaking the fourth wall, and pulling stuff out of existance, coming out of the show at the end and all of that is strange, yeah we can explain twilight but not pinkie.
God, I had to relearn the multiverse to understand this
0 likesI think your theory is part right? Maybe Pinkie didn't return all of the magic, maybe a fraction is left behind! But changing the past is something I'm gonna think about.
29 likeswhat if pinkie managed to keep some of the magic from the bell
0 likesPinkie is also an alternate universe chaos princess so I think this lends to your theory.
0 likesWoah, woah, woah, don’t put Pinkie sense into this. She said, “It runs in the family,” and don’t forget Muad sense.
0 likesThe Pinkie from this moment is interconnected to the infinite pinkies from every moment through time and space.
0 likesIMMA CALL IT
57 likesDEMIGOD OF CHAOS
Replies (4)
OMIGOD!
2 likesOMG YAS
2 likesThat would be Discord and Fluttershy’s kid. (Remember the final episode? Flutter came from the realm of Chaos?)
5 likespinkie has Dionysus energy
0 likesSawtooth: Did someone Watch me?
0 likesThe Viewer:
Am Joke to You?Maybe when the rainboom happened, pinkie somehow accidentally consumed chaos magic.
0 likesUmmm I think that her defying gravity and pulling out party canons out of thin air, is just cartoons in action
0 likesApart from the ruler of The crystal empire Twilight wasn’t the first Alicorn Remember that episode where in clouds well Rainbow Dash Need extra support But flatter shy was too quiet TwilightTurned Rarat In to an alicorn Before she was turned
0 likesSo few years ago before season 9 was aired I actually had a theory that Pinkie Pie was part darconequus!
132 likesBut not in the way that you explained it actually it that somewhere back in Pinkie Pie's family tree There Was a darconequus Like way way back in her family tree and somehow the genetics only came back to her and no one else in her immediate family it's pretty far-fetched but I still think it's a pretty good theory.
Ps I love your Channel! <3
Replies (5)
Maybe maud pie got somewhat of that gene, seeing as she can pretty much teleport on the spot
19 likesYes!
3 likesThat's interesting
1 likei think ur right
1 likethat also explains why pinkie pie had the chaos lightning when she absorbed discord's magic and cozy glow didn't have the lightning when she absoebed the chaos magic
Good theory
0 likesNice theory and yes chaos magic is the only way I can see to fit pinkies craziness
0 likesThe first time I saw that pinkie could handle Chao's magic I thought she was gonna be the next discord 😂
0 likesI also watched finally solving the royal gard It's pretty silly That's part of this big message to you
0 likesYou missed something though. What about the human version of Pinkiepie?
0 likesI think pinkie somehow allways had that Power, because when ponies have full energy/magic they become alicorns, but pinkie did not, so maybe shes more powerfull then we think!
69 likesReplies (7)
Problem... earth ponies can't become alicorns.
2 likesElectric Heart that has not been proven. We just have never heard of one becoming an alicorn. If pegasus and unicorns can become alicorns why not earth? One day in the future an earth pony might become an alicorn.
14 likesimagine that. Pinkie the alicorn.
6 likesDoes anyone remember that IDW comic, I believe #57? Pinkie became an alicorn: https://mlp-gameloft.fandom.com/wiki/Chaos_Princess_Pinkie_Pie
6 likesIsn't the rule that you become an Alicorn by inventing a new type of magic?
2 likes@Dark Cyan cozy did not, when she had chaos magic
2 likes@Davi Animations BR I mean permanently
2 likesI don't remember but... Can't Cheese Sandwich do the same impossible stuff? Or not??
0 likesThe reason pinkie pie knew what was happening in the human world and other in the pony is because they been switching places. Evidence just watch the bloopers
0 likesBruh after watching season 1 (I'm on season 5) I came with the theory that she's a God
0 likes3:42
1 likeBreaking the fourth wall
DOESN"T DISCORD HAVE A SENSE TOo CAUSE WHEN HE WAS WITH TIREK< HE FELT THAT MAGIC WAS BEING TRANSFERED
115 likesReplies (3)
so is that a "Discord-ed Sense" then?
4 likes@Kentavritsa Wouldn't it just be Discord Sense?
5 likesOmg
0 likesI have a theory :
0 likesBefore Discord have a little sister but he never meet her. Their parents die when discord is already transform in stone. So they put Pinkie Pie in Foster Home, thats why Pinkie Pie have chaotic power.
maybe because discord is behind so many other events he knowingly left a piece of magic behind in pinkie pie whereas the others took all of the chaos magic back from cozy glow
0 likesAccording to me there must be something in the rainboom that did this or else why did discord's bell not affect pinkie's childhood before she got her cutie mark. She wasn't like that when she was at the rock farm before she got her cutie mark. It just doesn't add up.
0 likesI think Pinkie have most of her's powers from rainboom. When rainboom happened her mane changed. We all know that magic can be connected with magic.
0 likeswell the pinkie sense probably wouldn't have anything to do with this, even if your theory was right. Maud also has a sense, and pinkie says it runs in the family so
66 likesReplies (8)
Wait what's Maud's sense? 🤔
0 likesEmily Rain
5 likesrocks
@Ann-Marie Wightman probably xD or she could have the sense that tells when Pinkie is in danger or something
0 likesEmily Rain i think a sense that helps her locate things??? Idk
1 like@Emily Rain I’d have to go back and look but they I’m pretty sure they mentioned in the episode where they’re exchanging gifts
1 like@Beerroots oh okay 🤔
0 likes@ItsMeAgain Hmmm 🤔
0 likes@wolf lion wild prides That's a possibility too o.o
0 likesI like your theory Sawtooth Waves but I have a better one a one that connects the whole Pie family to chaos magic.
0 likesMaybe the reason discord’s magic didn’t have an effect on cozy glow is because she is an alacorn and has the means to hold all that power while pinkie doesn’t since she is just an earth pony. Like so sawtooth can see this.
0 likesI live for these MLP theories like omg
0 likesMaud pie has maud sense, it runs in the family. But I think when pinkie got her magic back when cozy glow, it certainly explain everything
0 likesI've had the theory for a while that pinkie is somewhat evil because of the way she acts sometimes. The best way I think I can explain is if you rewatch the series with the perspective that she's a villain hiding in plain sight you'll see clues that point to her wanting to affect others in a negative way and getting joy from it. Kind of similar to a much more convincing cozy glow that acts sweet but sometimes her evil slips through. I haven't seen anyone talk about it (besides non canon creepypastas or stories).
11 likesReplies (5)
I mean maybe, I think shes more of a Chaotic Hero Shes more of a balance of good and evil doing both at once, it makes her happy to see other people happy. She did make friends with the entire town of ponyville and got so confused when One person didn't want to be friends with her and didn't enjoy her joyful craziness.
3 likesShes just pinkie pie. And pinkie pie is evil fun?
0 likesWe all act toxic or suspicious sometimes.
0 likesEmeraldFlowerz all of the main 6 do they all have negative tendencies and sorta villain behavior if you analyze it hard enough
2 likes@Dominique Fairclough i wouldn't say VILLAIN, but yeah sometimes they're sus
0 likesAll ponies have magic. Terak (or Terek), and other factors prove all ponies have magic
0 likesI mean earth ponies and pegasus also have magic.
Sawtooth: is someone watching me
1 likeMe: yes me and the viewers are watching you
Ofc you have a point but all I want to know is, what would pinky be if she didn’t grab the bell
1 likeand how did she get to the point of grabbing the bell and how
Well this confuses me,
0 likesA new theory of yours is that twilight killed the real pinkie-
Me realizing how much sense this theory actually makes-
9 likes“This wasn’t a mess! It was organized chaos!”
Replies (2)
It makes happy seeing Ami in the comments borahae!
1 likeAnny 💜
0 likesSure, that explains pony Pinkie. But what about Canterlot High Pinkie Pie? How did she get so...um...enthusiastic in the human world? Maybe it had something to do with Discord? I mean, he was about to send Tree Hugger to OUR REALM! it must be possible for him to open a portal to the human world, right? And, if you think about it, we haven’t seen anything of the Canterlot High girls since the season 9 epilogue. What if the same thing happened to the E.G. Pinkie Pie? It would have probably gone down something like this. Discord decides to go the the human world, (probably because he was board) and does something that causes the girls to “Pony Up” and take care of Discord’s boredom. Discord sees potential in Pinkie, and gives her some of his magic. But then takes it back, and like Sawtooth said, that one moment effected her entire timeline.
0 likesBut what do you think?
Sawtooth waves:i think I finally solved pinky pie
0 likesEvery pony in equestria watched it
i think maybe pinkie was born as a unicorn, let me explain. in the episode where pinkie and applejack found out they maybe are cousins they told us the family was really really big! maybe there was a unicorn far away in their family like by pound cake and pumpkin cake. Maybe pinkies parents parents wanted her to be a earthpony like the rest of the family. Unicorns can get wings, but can they also maybe lose there horns? maybe pinkies parents took her to princess Celestia and asked her to make her a earthpony! But i dont think u can loose being a unicorn completely away so she still had a little of her magic but not in her horn, the magic is inside her! I think there also is one other way: Pinkie pie maybe isn't a pie! i mean she doesnt look a little bit like the rest of her family! Her birthparents maybe didn't want her and removed her horn with hulp of Celestia and then gave her to the pies!
0 likesI hope ur making another video for this! byeee!
i think it's true because her coat and mane aren't even a vibrant pink, you can see when she gets depressed, her coat goes to her natural colour, a greyish pink, or just gray, like her sisters, and she used her magic to make her hair fluffy and hair and coat pink. when she's depressed, she doesn't use her chaos magic at ALL and that's why her hair is long, straight, and grey, that's my take on it!!
0 likesMy life just ended. Thanks! I’m so confused!
0 likesHi Sawtooth Waves I kind of have 2 small theories that Pinkie is Adopted!
0 likesIf U Notice the Pie's All have the grey shade except pinkie .....
Except Pinkie nopony else in the family is like her.
Even tho Marble and Pinkie are twins, I just had this theories.
Thank U
I think Pinkie is a chaos pony, that's why she could handle Discords chaos magic they are magically the same or similar.
0 likesI think pinkie and discord have the same magic because both of them have a sense in which they can predict the future.this is my example:
0 likesIn the episode twillight's kingdom tirek was stealing magic in canterlot and dicord began to shake as if he sensed something like pinkie. in an episode(i do not know name)pinkie began to shake like discord
They both share the magic of sensing what will happen in the next few minutes
Pinkie pie is discord’s older sister “change my mind”
101 likesReplies (3)
I haven't watched it yet but maybe this? https://youtu.be/cAqYTjovXo8
3 likesThe weird Squad well, discord is very old, soo.....
0 likesDon't you mean younger sister?
0 likesI think pinkie pie secretly has wings in a horn Somewhere in her main And it might be true And Around super fast and pulls out a canon out Out of nowhere
0 likesWait y'know how u made a vid on the end of the next gen movie on how the earth pony left magical hoof prints? Maybe pinkie's "pinky sense" has something to do with it?
1 likeRe Cosy and pinkie reacting differently to the extraction of the chaos. Discord did the extraction on Pinky and it would just be like him to leave just a little for shits and giggles :)
0 likesBut the pinkie sense part, Maud also has it. On the sister gift swap episode, Maud found pinkie's canon with Maud sense. It just runs in the family
0 likesI’m still watching these to this day even if the show ended, I do not regret watching these
13 likesIf u watch the episode *Pinkie Keen* and the episode *Pinkie Pride* u will see there is no difference between them so..... As u solved *Pinkie Pie* u should also solve *Cheese Sandwich* .....
1 likeI’m guessing that cozy glow was a little pony and her age might’ve made it so that she wouldn’t have powers forever or it’s just because of pinkie sence
0 likesI didn‘t know pinkie pie has discord magic o.o now I know She keeps taking out the party canon out of nowhere
0 likesOk. Im VERY late in commenting
0 likesbut...
that theory could actually be correct!
Here's my reason:
ok so you said that it needed something to do with past and future.
Pinkie pie had pinkie sense, but cozy glow doesnt have such a thing!
Though they got it the same way,
If cozy was lacking the sense similar to pinkie, she could never been chaotic.
another thing to back this theory up: Her DESTINY, she's destined to be wacky, goofy, and just so different.
Maybe-JUST MAYBE, thid means pinkie sense would still be unsolved if it wasnt part of the chaos magic thing, think about it, Maybe pinkie pie was born with that kinda sense bc her whole fam had it! And then she got chaos magic then the magic just spreads to her entire lifetime.
Who knows...maybe she also got discord's immortality, i mean, it is CHAOS magic so maybe theres also other parts of the magic that just doesnt follow normal magic rules.
(Pls notice this)
I 110% like the idea of this one e moment causing pinkie to be ya-know pinkie, but I have an idea of why cozyglow wasn't effected the same way (go to reply for that because I need to take a nap and it's really early in the morning)
0 likesTirek and Chrysilis looking at cozy glow absorbing Discords magic: What?
0 likesI think how Pinkie Pie is crazy
0 likesWhen she got her curly mane and tail by the Rainboom, some random bug got into it and the bug had crazy magic which was Pinkie’s magic but it transferred over to Pinkie so now she is crazy
Ok that's kind of weird though, all earth pony also have magic.
0 likesMy theory: the show wants someone doing impossible stuff to make us have more fun😂😂😂😂😂
86 likesPinky pie was able to break the fourth wall and the laws of physics before she even heard of crogars bell
0 likesSawtoooth: Is someone watching me?
0 likesMe: WE ALL ARE!!
Him:Is someone watching me?
0 likesMe:Yes that person is me.
Yeah and showed up in deferent media like as a alicorn during the final battle in the transformers bumblebee movie during a ridiculous boss fight in batman arkhamknight and finally the last evidence is recent were she inside the zero point when it about to blow
1 like"Is someone watching me?"
212 likes162,738 people: YES
Replies (8)
253.149 people now: YES
5 likes254,481 people now: YES
3 likes324,474 people now: YES
2 likes340,874 people now: YES
2 likesNow: 3,65,676
0 likesactually its 374,693 saying that
0 likesNow 1A 1M 1T 1B LOL
0 likesNow 999,999,99,9999, 9999,9,99,9999
0 likesHim: Is someone watching me!?
0 likesMe: Yeah, ME.
Also note that somehow she is the only known phoney and or creature to be able to control chaos magic
0 likesif pinkie lost her magic then how did she brought out the cake when she tried to convince tirek
0 likes"is someone watching me?" Me: bruh-
4 likesOk I think k this is the video where you say pinkies discord magic got spread throughout the timeline. But cheese sandwich also has a pinkie sense of sorts. That’s how he knows to go to pony color next for a party. So maybe they just have party magic or something. Her magic things are usually visual gags
0 likeswhen TV characters becomes an equation
0 likesAh yes, the 4 tribes of the ponies
0 likes- Earth ponies
- Pegasi
- Unicorns
- Pinkie Pie
I think the reason cozy glow didn’t have any after effects is because pinkies energy is so .. pinkie that some magic stayed inside her
0 likesNo pinkie is discords half sister and her "parents" adopted her living in a rock farm claiming to be her parents then pinkie moved out in a young age that made her crazy self she is
93 likesNope mAkes no logical sense
Replies (2)
What? She was not adopted, it is stated in Hearthbreakers that she is the twin sister of Marble Pie, although they don’t look alike so she was not adopted
18 likes@Puddle Slime 10,000! Lol I was joking
9 likesI search your theory!
0 likesWhen Pinkie took discords power she was able to control the chaos magic/power, but look what happened when cozy took discords power..
She wasn't able to control his Magic..this is why cozy isn't like pinkie.
I don't know if it makes scene, but it makes scence😅🤷♀️
Ya well some funny things of her are getting cakes out of thin air and making her hair work like a drilling machine
0 likesSawtooth:I solved pinkie
0 likesTwilight:HOW DID YOU!?!??!
Credit To Silver Wing for giving me this idea
Well you see she also absorbed the alicorn magic where cozy only chaos so...
0 likesIt's funny at 1:43, pinkie is just casually in the background of the discord image
13 likesI think it's because Pinkie Pie actually used her her magic but cosy glow didn't, you know her chocolate rain
1 likeI can't agree with you. It doesn't make any sense. You can say: It's Pinkie we're talking about, but hold It right there. It doesn't make sense even if it involves Pinkie. If it IS true then we'd had to have a timeline where is Pinkie normal . But without Pinkie, her welcoming party for Twilight And her craziness She couldn't be the element of laughter And therefore She couldn't get the mane 6 together. That's just my oppinion, i'm not saying that this is a bad theory or something
0 likesHow did pinkie control it when cozy glow couldn't?
1 likeMaybe the chaos magic that cozy absorbed what made her so evil
0 likesWhen was this early, he was still called The Brony Notion.
54 likesReplies (4)
thanks, I was trying to remember his previous name
6 likesmatthew olson oh no not already!!!!
2 likesI didn't even notice he changed it i literally thought man he uses his private username for patreon o my stars
1 likewait omg
0 likesIn the gift of Maud Pie Muad also has pinky Sence or Maud Sence and only said it ran in the family maybe the chaos magic went further and in to the pie family and not the apples because the apples are another huge tree connected to the pie tree so only the pies where infected with chaos magic
1 likeI agree pinkie has some kind of magic but I don't think it came from the chaos magic
0 likesI just saw something interesting that I just now noticed do you not have Pegasus patrons because you show off the earth ponies the unicorns and the Alcorns but not the Pegasus do you not have Pegasus patrons?
0 likesJust curious
On the gift of the maud pie
0 likesPinkie said that sense runs into their family even her sister has one
Pinkie sense=danger
Maud sense=finding some pony/someone
but did cozzy use her powers when she got them temporaily from discord? pinkie went full blown change everything. while i dont think cozzy did anything rly.
22 likesReplies (2)
She made pineapples appear. I think it’s a matter of if they can use it effectively they keep a bit and if they can’t it dissapeared compleatly
3 likesCozy*
0 likesMaybe Pinkie had a Unicorn Grandparent and it just passed down to Pinkie Pie.
1 likeActually you kind of wrong she could use chaos msigc caused she used in the past before in the comics, and to use chaos msigc you have to understand that what ever pops into your mind comes out There are certain rules to the chaos dimensions and magic that why pinke pie could use discord msigc bescude she used it before he said to the mane five and spike most poines alone in his dimseon would be driven mad but this is pinke pie she might be right at home and in the comics he makes a nod that he doesn't understand pinke pie
0 likesMust say, the knowledge Pinkie Pie knows from another dimension is from a deleted scene. Watch the equestria girls deleted scenes of Pinkie and Pinkie going in and out from the portaI.
0 likesPlot twist:
0 likespinky actually has hidden horn and wings in her hair. So when shes falling she can slow the fall with her wings and she teleports with her horn.
(This is a joke don't think about this to much)
This video: exists
43 likesMe: wait thats illegal
My theory: Pinkie pie is actually a character from my hero academia that had that power (quirk) and she got stuck in the pony world
0 likesPinkie pie: *HAS A INSANE SMILE*
2 likessence she’s so fun and animated everyone just brushes her of as wierd and animated and funny but she’s acttauly rlly powerful
0 likesI like the way you showed the actual Pokémon farfetched
0 likesVideo:Finally Solving Pinkie Pie
13 likesTime:5 Minutes
Me:5 minutes!? You need years to solve Pinkie
Replies (1)
I can do it in 1,91 seconds
0 likeshi I am moonlight sparkle, I think pinkie is an unicorn and she has some hyper magic , she can teleport into different places and I think pinkie has visit to the human world before twilight .the reason pinkie is not a pegasus pony because rainbow dash is the first pony whom pulled of a sonic rainboom
1 likewhats the most embarrassing thing you have ever done?
1 likefor me one time i accidentily farted and the speaker view ai in zoom spotlighted me and i got hella embarressed. ;-;
When pinkie absorbed magic she had alicorn and more magic, but cozy glow only had chaos magic
0 likesPinkie could be the pony equivalent to a member of Yardrat from dragon ball z.
0 likesYou have learned too much.
33 likesReplies (6)
if I'm never heard from again, you know what happened
19 likesPinkie pie is coming for him
4 likesHi Ami borahae💜
0 likesMaria Tivanova Shes coming for us all!!!
0 likesAlso don’t mind my Jungkook pfp-
0 likes@Sawtooth Waves do you think that tambelon, bray the donkey and grogar guards exist in G4 ?
0 likesShe did get magic from discord magic it is so much clearer now
0 likessawtooth waves: i solved pinkie pie
0 likesme: * immeadietly clicks*
THE IMPOSSIBLE HAS BECOME POSSIBLE
pinkie and discord have a similar crazy personality, cozy does not. chaos magic has been seen to act with a mind of its own somewhat, mabey it chooses based off of who it likes more?
0 likesPinky isn't an earth pony
0 likesShe had two magic parents
I have a crazy theory, you had posted a video about how scootaloo can't fly and how Sunny has astral wings, right? So maybe, just maybe, Pinkie Pie is actually an Alicorn. And, you forgot about somepony, Cheese Sandwich. How can you explain him!? He has a cheesy sense ,too. He may be an Alicorn without wings and a horn, too.
0 likesSabooth: I’ve solved pinkie
0 likesMe: Not possible
Sorry Bro, this is one of your worst theories.
1 like1. I already don't like the events during the "present" affecting the past
2. The Magic returning to Pinkie could be just an animation choice, Pinkie is the 3rd most "magical" of the group naturally so she would get it, or it could just be the drew straws and she was up. This is your best point though.
3. The Pinkie Sense isn't evidence that a part of her is connected to a different time. It's like if I predicted the winner in a sports match, you wouldn't say that I have a part of me connected to the future, I'd just be lucky. Also if Pinkie really had a part connected to the future where has it been when they could actually use it.
4. PINKIE IS JUST PINKIE
Sawtooth: I may have just solved pinke!
0 likesMe: Waaaa!?! Is there such a thing?
Lol
Now the real question, where does that put lil cheese
30 likesReplies (1)
Neoma Dreamz they are talking pinkie pie and cheese sandwich’s child
0 likessawtooth: i solved pinkie pie
0 likespinkameana: I WILL HAUNT YOU
Maybe because it was pinkie who had absorbed the chaos magic then, and not being able to contain all of the magic within her vessel some was released and wandered existence finding the first sonic rainboom which may have acted as a beacon attracting the extra chaos magic wandering through existance and entered pinkie pie
0 likesBut maybe solving villains like I may have a reason why Chrysalis fooled everypony by being Cadence so Chrysalis was a pretty alicorn and the day she saw Shinning armour she fell in love with him but Shinning armour did not take intrest in her he took his love and respect to Cadence and Chrysalis was heartbroken so when it consumed her with sadness and Anger she became Evil and thought of her plan to trap Cadence and Deytsroy her something so she became Cadence's form trapped her and Twilight in the Caves Under Canterlot Then beated of shinning armours love for Cadence and then Celestia wanted a Fight To Protect Every Pony but she failed Chrysalis hat Beaten to much love and then she was to and so OP and then Shinning armour's protection spell wore off while Celestia was on the ground with the tip of her horn black That's why Chrysalis wanted to take over Equestria Buy Chrysali's return is sure to happen would she battle all four Princesses? And take their magic and Deytsroy Equestria? She may do it? Or will she beat Luna and Celestia's love next? With Cadence and Twilight too? Just Sayin she may do it dare it Evil it the only way to reform her to her true self is hard mystery her changeling new form may be the only thing witch works like maybe we must reform her like the other Changelings and Find a sort of spell or crystal and make her her True Pony Self my thought Sawtooth !
0 likesMy theory: Pinkie is a secret alicorn who disguises herself as an earth poney.
0 likesI’ve always agreed with the idea that Party Ponies have their own breed of magic. They are rare, as is their magic. Look at Cheese.
3 likesPINKIE PIE AND DISCORD ARE BREAKING THE 4TH WALL, PROVE ME WRONG
0 likesEveryone knows that magic is just Binky being Pinky
0 likesWhen cozy took the magic it was only discord’s magic but when pinkie took it celestia and Luna’s magic are also there
0 likesPinkie’s sister also has Pinkie sense (Mod sense) remember? So that cant be part of Discord’s magic.
0 likesActually it is not discord power because the episode was after Twilight figured out Pinkie pie has pinky sense so it must’ve done something with The element of harmony ,she laughs a lot and also a cutie mark
0 likesThat means that pinkie pie doesn’t have pinkie sense after that very moment which to me is cool.
0 likesS5 E8 pinkie might be conected to ones whom have and still are in stone so maby discord hade a bit of that stone magic in him so it got into grogars bell and pinkie got his magic so she can talk to ones in stone and the last episode in S9 discord helps put them in stone and pinkie talked to the last grifin kings stachue and maby it WAS HIM in stone and at the end his eye shimered or glowed
0 likesEveryone is watching you... ( Creepy laughter and creepy finger positions)
1 likeSawtooth waves: I think I finally figured out Pinkie pie.
14 likesMe: You can’t figure out Pinkie pie, she’s illogical.
Also me: finishes video ohhhhhhhhhhh
Pinkie said that Maud had her own sense as well. Maud had Maud sense and Pinkie had Pinkie sense. So she didn’t get Pinkie sense from Discord’s magic.
0 likesTheory: pinkie is some how related to discord like many from her Nana Pinkie
0 likesITS JUST ✨CARTOON LOGIC✨
0 likesBUT, she did absorbs his chaos until the final episode 😂😅😅
0 likesI think the reason cozy didn't get chaos magic is because she couldn't control it
5 likesI think you're wrong cuz pinky was already crazy before this happened so maybe it was something to do with her past or maybe her future 🤔
0 likesSawtooth waves I kind of know something about Twilight and the royal family and the main 6When twilight was big and she had a floating man She had it 2Baby unicorns she just Married a orange pegasus With blue Up line hair and blue eyes and twilight had 2 baby unicorns They were orange orange oranges Purple or blue Well it's Purple and When the baby unicorns grow up both of them were alicorns Cause 1 Of the unicorn twins was older and the other 1 was younger the big 1 had Big legs when she was a grown up like her mom and she had a horn and wings she And Her sister was also an alcorn Well a little Younger And They both have the same Cutie mark With the star well They have the same star on the cutie mark but they're different cause their mom represents the elements of magic and she has it on the Crown her crown And When2 of Her kids1 had a Crown and 1 had a necklace With A Gem Or A. Element Cause I saw a video okay I saw The Royal families flurry heart had a Sister and it was a pegasus and If they're not born At the same time They are still sisters And Guess what something hilarious happened Princess celestia married discord and they had it Chaos baby's And Discord also married Fluttershy It was actually out of my mind and Princess Luna Marry A unicorn it was like king sombra but good A black and blue Lineed Maine and Red eyes it look like king sombra
0 likes1:49 Ahh yes breaking the forth wall
0 likesOmg you're a genius
0 likesThe part that pinky got magic and AJ and rainbow and FSH didn't makes perfect sense but I think it's more then that
You forget about Moud sense. Pinkie says that the sense runs in her famili. Sorry about my english, I know it's messy 😅
13 likesShe can also survive falling with no scrach
0 likesThere was actually a blooper from equestrian girls, where pony pinkie and human pinkie switched places. Maybe look into that?
0 likesYou make a compelling argument, but I wouldn’t be me if I didn’t counter it what you’re saying can’t be true, because in a gift for mud pie, pinkie says that the pinky sense or pie sense runs in the family
0 likesThe time tag you wanted: 1:41.
0 likes"Is someone watching me?"
23 likesMUHAHAHA
No of course not why would you ever think that 😏
Replies (1)
Only 107,373 people watching him 😂
1 likePinkie also has broken the fourth wall a couple times
0 likesSawtooth Wave s Guess what a bad record recorded the new episode of sunny star scout I think it has been her mother all along Well you'll see in the last part So make A video about it Well There is a bad Unicorn with wings Eyelashe's was green and The bad unicorn with wings said I will take what's mine that's what the bad out corn said so Figure it out
1 likeWhen you said “is someone watching me?”
0 likesI felt like someone watching me I always feel like someone is watching me but even more ever since my cat died I think my dead cat is watching me :O
Replies (1)
Welldone, now I feel like im being watched.........
0 likes...
Is this why I hear strange noises in the night?!!
Now im very scared
Soo pinkie will have a long life like twilight because she has magic?
2 likespinkie was always like that
0 likesthe time she took discord's magic was in season 9
pinkie was crazy from season 1!
I always saw pinkie pie being pinkie pie when she did unexplainable things, but oh boy when she said “hey discord!” when discord was hiding that even he got surprised and made a wtf face. I was like hold up pinkie pie what are you?? A secret pony goddess wtf
0 likesSawtooth:is someone watching me?
0 likesGuys is he talking about us
This pinky has chaos magic theory might also explain why when Discord was freed the first time and it started raining chocolate and stuff Pinky loved it but that could have just been classic Pinkypie
0 likesIf Pinkie Pie did have her magic stretched out through her timeline, it would explain why Cozy Glow became an alicorn for taking all of the magic at once while Pinkie didn't.
6 likes1:51
0 likesLiterally all your subscribers, Sawtooth!
Sawtooth keep In mind cozy glow only took discords magic and pinkie pie took the Royal sisters magic as well as discords
0 likes3:42 sure could be aswell but i'm still conserned of 2:13. it can't be an animation error
0 likesI saw the title for the video and I was like what the heck how do you fix pinkie pie
0 likesWhen you theorize a theory before someone else does:
48 likesMe: No fair! I made a headcanon on this! (O~O)
Replies (3)
Seriously, though. I thought of it months ago.
3 likespoor child
1 likeOh boo hoo, someone had their own ideas seperate from yours
2 likesWhen Cozy Glow was transformed, she begin an Alicorn, but when Pinkie Pie absorbed caos, she remain a Pony. Also, pinkie pie is how discord, they have the same though and powers. Favourite element of harmonybof discord is laugh.
0 likesIt's pretty obvious that pinkie pie is the most op earth pony there is. People are missing the fact how pinkie pie was able to control discord's magic even when cozy glow, tirek and chrysalis couldn't.
0 likesOk but what about maud sense. She said it runs through the family.
0 likesIve never seen the last season but im getting like a clovefield paradox vibe..hmmm.. Why pinkie?
0 likes1:50 "Is someone watching me?"
19 likes* looks at the number of subs *
Na, only 200k people are. It's not a lot.
Replies (1)
Almost 300k already
1 likeDiscord and Pinky know that they’re on the TV!!
0 likesSo she couldn't use inponie abilitys and she was normal through out the whole series, but when she absorbed that magic,not change the past so pinkie in the past was able to do crazy things???? Idk if I understand
0 likesNow I feel like someones watching ME
0 likesBc I hear noises evey night, now im terrified
discord is a creature made of pure chaos what if the reason why he can control his magic is his chaotic personality because when he tries to act normal he begins to lose his ability to use his magic and begins to fade, is thanks to fluttershy that acts in a chaotic way that discord can recover thanks to the small chaos that fluttershy made and if we apply that same logic to a being that is even a little chaotic and it takes discords magic that could make possible to that being to control discord s chaotic magic and taking the magic of discord this could make it possible for that being to be able to control the chaotic magic of discord and if equestria has the same origin as our world that could explain why pink pie is able to do things that defy logic because the moment she takes the magical abilities of discord it became a paradox in which the versions of pink pie that we know they are able to do things that ignore logic in their entirety and by this pink pie made her own future becouse that makes her be her and pink pie didnt show up that kind of abillites until rainbow dash performs sonic rainboom that pink pie was able to use unconsciously a little bit of discord chaotic magic
0 likesI love that this dude used the warhammer chaos star as a representation of discords magic. That makes me want to go back and reread one of those Warhammer fortythousand x My Little Pony Friendship is Magic crossovers.
8 likesI don’t really know how to explain it but in a summer sun setback discord literally pulls up the fabric of their reality and stuffs a storm cloud in there soooooooooooo
0 likesmaybe Pinky is hiding her horns under her curly and crazy hair! haha
0 likesAs soon as I heard this I thought to myself well this better be good
0 likesIt makes total sense!
0 likesHoly crud well This is the most earliest for me to click on a video!
23 likesNew Achievement unlocked! XD
Pinkie also didnt turn into an alicorn where Cozy Glow did.
0 likesPinkie is pony discord.
You make the greatest point ever in mlp
0 likesyou know that pinkie pie is a special erath pony she is part of a dracon and her mom is a earth pony but her dad is a dracon her mom name is triple berry pie and her dad name is rhubarb
0 likesSawtooth: Is someone watching me? Me: You’re a YouTuber!
0 likesBut how did she get her costume in tardiness when Terkeck said he wouldn’t help them get out
0 likesBut every member of the Pie family has Pinkie sense Maud shows it in that one Manehatten episode. :<
0 likesNo because in an episode reveals that pinkie sense runs in the family
1 likeThey both do that thing where they stand up in space like someone’s watching iS sOmEoNe WaChInG mE!?
0 likesMe:yEs We AlL r!
Also I noticed everyone who absorbs the chaos magic gets BIG!!and it’s weird that pinky got magic!
The ancient secret has been revealed.
9 likesI don't actually agree on this theory as in the episode in season six the gift for maud pie even maud will get the maud sense that doesn't actually mean that even maud had the chaotic power
0 likesI never noticed that pinkie pie got a bit of magic back
0 likesDon't forget the fact that Pinkie Pie was able to control Discord's Choas
0 likesMaybe it didnt effect cozy because for some reason pinkie was able to control it
0 likesEveryone: Pinkie is pinkie, she will always be mysterious!
10 likesSawtooth Waves: Hold my theories. (Or is it)
Or pinky pies element is humor. And humorous logic from a cartoon viewpoint! That’s why she talked to “audience” through the screen or when she notices or when someone notices she did something wierd all of a sudden it stops. Like Tom and jerry the car run on the sky then notices it’s defied gravity and falls. Pinky has her own powers from the power of friendship which is cartoon humor!
0 likesBUT WAIT,you said pinkie sense is part of her ‘powers’, but in The Gift Of Maud Pie, Maud says their ‘senses ‘ run in the family when she was looking for the pony Pinkie traded her cannon with... so it’s family thing! Just me? Welp.
0 likesI just remembered that cheese sandwich also has “pinkie sense” do you think that’s just a script thing or is there a theory for this too? :0
0 likesReplies (1)
Maud had the same, but it is different depending on the Pony.
1 likeI think I recall that being Cheezy sense and Maud sense respectively.
Just too bad we never see another unrelated case, though.
Discord has reality bending powers over all universes since discord him self is a embodiment of chaos in the mlp wold being able to do anything and well pinkie has well 4wall powers which means she could just do anything knowing that she a cartoon being able to what ever she whats btw I think 4wall powers and chaos powers are different is a different think initially
0 likes🤔 If the chaos magic were to effect Pinkie's timeline to give her pinkie powers it might have effected cozy glow's timeline to make her turn evil! 👀
3 likesWhen pinkie got her magic back she does'nt have magic its just her cutie mark in that episode every pony had no cutie mark and when pinkie pie got her magic returned to her it was her cutie mark and get her colors back and if she does'nt get that magic back she will be super slow and does'nt blend in to other ponys
0 likeswhy would you care about ponies breaking the laws of physics when ponies with horns can teleport and time travel
0 likesPinkie Pie is the best character besides rarity ❤️
0 likesshe already had magic
0 likesPrepare to get hit with a nostalgia train-
4 likes“When you’re rife with devastation, there’s a simple explanation; you’re a toy makers creation trapped inside a crystal ball. And whichever way he tilts it, know that we must be resilient. We won’t let them break our spirits as we sing our silly song!”
Replies (1)
"when I was a little filly a galloping blaze overtook my city! So they shipped me off to the orphanage said 'ditch those roots if you wanna fit in' so I dug one thousand holes and cut a rug with orphan foals-"
0 likesI noticed that when rarity and Twilight have there Magic back, maybe pinkie pie has a secret magic and the weirdest thing is when she jumped in the water she like slowy dont splash, maybe she has a gravity magic
0 likesI know why cozy wasn’t effected by the chaos magic it’s because she didn’t want it think about she wanted it taken away but pinkie didn’t she wanted to keep it
0 likesPinky pie: I know what’s happening in the other world.
0 likesmy dad said "it is just a kids show, the creators definitely did not put this much thot in to it"
0 likesBut wait, if that magic spread through Pinkie’s entire timeline, then that means that she absorbed the magic twice within her lifetime. Once when the future pinkie did it, and the second time when the actual present pinkie did it.
4 likesReplies (2)
Which is why I don’t think this theory would be correct
2 likesI am so confused my brain hurts from reading that
0 likesSolving Pinkie Pie: She's a gemini
0 likesYes all of us are watching you everyone on YouTube is watching you... how did it take that long to figure it out?! And you remind me of someone but I don't know who.
0 likesThere’s just one problem… cheesey sense
1 likePinkie cannot be explained or solved, Pinkie is Pinkie and will forever be Pinkie UwU
0 likesBut also I like your theory
and why does scootaloo flap her wings when she scooters, and somehow can get lifted into the air with that? mlp concluded that they she can't fly.
131 likesReplies (11)
she can't fly , but flapping her wings helps her ride her scooter
32 likes@MaskedRedstonerProZ she can give more air time like early birds
13 likesShe can fly but has convinced herself that she can't. Her magic obeys her will. It's much like how if someone truly thinks they're blind, they won't see no matter how healthy their eyes really are. When she gives up the lie, then she will fly.
5 likes@Chessking E4
9 likesShe can't fly. It's most likely a physical issue, not a magic issue. We see that she can hover, but only when highly excited. Her magic works like normal otherwise: walking on and manipulating clouds like any other pegasus. If her issue were magic based, she would not be able to do that either. When she becomes an adult, her wings don't grow in proportion to the rest of her. This detail leads me too believe that, for whatever reason, her wings are stunted and that's why she can't fly. Maybe it's genetic, or the result of an accident, or some unknown disease.
@J. C. We can that regardless of the way the wings develope that a pegasus can fly regardless of their shape. Look at Bulk Biceps. There is no way according to the laws of physics he can fly but not only does he fly, he's able to contribute to the creation of a tornado. This proves it is the magic from within making this possible. The wings act as a foci much like a wand or an incantation does for a hermetic mage. Also there's no way RD can reach the speeds that she does through the laws of physics. She does this through magic and I would say she has a lot of it. I wonder if she'll develop the infinite hoof punch like the Flash?
0 likes@Chessking E4
3 likesBut if something is wrong with a wand, if it's broken or damaged in some way, then it won't cast magic like normal. I believe the same principle applies to wings in my little pony. Bulk Biceps can fly with magic because his wings aren't stunted, they only look that way. Presumably before he got so buff, his wings were normal.
It's just not believable that Scootaloo not believing she can fly would actually effect her ability to do so. Pegasi can fly as babies, so we know it's not an age thing. Scootaloo, were she able to fly, would've been doing so since before she could remember. There is simply no way a school aged pegasus would believe themselves unable to fly without some kind of evidence. If she was born like that, she's probably tried multiple times before going to a doctor and learning she can't fly. If it's the result of an accident, she may remember a time when she could fly, and if she was in denial, she'd keep trying to fly before learning she really couldn't anymore.
Plus, we have evidence that she believed she could fly. In flight to the finish.
I think she flap her wings because that help her to go faster
0 likesChessking E4 She can’t fly cause her wing aren’t stronger and don’t grow like they have to grow
1 likeI think that why she don’t live in cloudstale or go whit her parents
Cloudstale: Because she couldn’t fly to get there
Go whit her parents: Because they are constantly in danger and they fly if scottalo go whit they she could probably die
It adds speed and when she jumps it gives her a bit of height.
1 likeYea but it will increase speed
0 likesCreator Kid the speed she's going at will put wind under her scooter and it will float
0 likesSpoken like a true FOB Equestria/Fiery Joker fan
0 likesShe can go in creepypasta dimension if she want to relax
0 likesnah, she's just built different
0 likesBut, Cheese Sandwhich has a Cheesy Sense????
0 likes0:07 don't they all Pull objects out of thin air?
0 likesIf this is true when how did it happend in the first place 🤔
1 likeI think it’s because pinkie could control the magic and cozy couldn’t wich is actually better and is going through the time line
0 likesMaybe discord left a lil bit of his magic in her....
0 likesLook like pinkie pie and discord really have a connection. When pinkie pie absorbed discord's magic there's a lighting thing around her which cozy glow didn't have, like cozy glow absorbed the magic but didn't connect to her but when pinkie pie absorbed the magic it really connected into her.
8 likesYes, someone is watching you. Us.
0 likes[INSERT EVIL LAUGH]
Pinkie does has some type of power cuz when we see her in the future see is still the same pinkie where the other ponies have changed like rarity have some white strapes on her tail and hair and all the others changed and were not that hygenic where pinkie still was soooooooooooooo happy excited its like she did not grow at allllll and when we see her on the movie where twillight loses her crown the human pinkie knows everything and when twillight comes back the "PONY" pinkie knew everything from the human world the human pinkie and the pony pinkie have some type of connection and both of them have some connection with the past and future too.
0 likesCheese sandwich had cheese senses, i think party ponies has their own senses like pinkie and cheese.
0 likesI need a video why party ponies have senses 🧐
That explains everything about her but she came from a family with grayish color and she is pink so I don’t understand why she is the only person in her family that is pink and the rest is grayish it might have to do with something with the magic she might have.
0 likesI personally think that wasn't intentional. but i REALLY like the idea and feel like it should be true, so i'm gonna treat it like it is. :3
6 likesI think pinkie got her powers from the rainboom because everyone did twilight got very powerful,rainbow dash got speed powers,rarity got her diamond powers,apple jack got strength and fluttershy got speaking to animals power so pinkie got pinkie powers
1 likeI think think that pinkly pie had nowhere to store discord’s caous magic because she is a earth pony
0 likesShe also gets the alicorns power in that bell
0 likesI support your thinking but in the episode ticket master when they get the tickets at the end the tikets float over their heads but not for spike can you make a video about that please.
0 likesSawtooth: is some one watching me!!
31 likesMe: YES! where WaTcHiNg YoU SaWtOoTh
Replies (2)
We’re?
3 likes:Thx sound gets louder
0 likesI believe that pinkie pie is a anomaly that can control chaos essence
0 likesSawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?!
0 likesMe: yes. Infect if no one is watching you than why are you saying your theories out loud?
Hi i'm milka. The first time i see this video, i was shock. I agree about this pinkie pie sense, but i think pinkie pie sort way back discord magic. Thats just my theori about pinkie pie and discord magic.
0 likes1:50 Yes. Over 430,000 people were watching you.
0 likesI just love pinkie pie. We need more people like her. Oops I mean ponies 😌
5 likesReplies (1)
Me to Pinkie pie is my favorite character
1 likeBut didn't pinkie pie take discord magic at the last episode before Twilight become the ruler
0 likesSeason 10: Pinkie's Magic
1 like0:04
0 likes4 seconds in and im laughing
some years ago:
0 likesdad: your just like her
me: ok
Me now: watching this video
oh wow, i really am like her.
It's actually My Little Pony Equestria Girls bloopers. Hope you watch it. It might help you.
0 likesKinda late and u probably won’t see this but if I remember correctly during a episode maud shows that she has her own maud sense proving that this theory couldn’t be possible
0 likesThen how does Maud pie do the same thing
0 likesPinkie even said that it runs in the family
Bro the writers just made a mistake
0 likes"Is someone watching me?!?!?!"
64 likesYeah
100k people to be exact
Replies (2)
300K to be fully exact
0 likes393k To be exact
0 likesI personaly dont agree buts its a great theory.
0 likesmy theory is that there is soe type of chaos like discord inside her, that she was just born with like discord. she has some of the same powers. :3
I know this took a lot of effort but what about when pinkie pie traded her party cannon and mod found the pony and rarity asked how she found him she said "mod scenes" pinkie said it runs in the faimly
0 likes0:08 Um did u forget that she can break the fourth wall?
0 likesYou may have noticed already bur im gonna say it anyways, 1:31 , true but in the episode where spike becomes greedy and its his birthday (i think its season 2? Idk), he and rarity was floating in mid air! 1:49 , in the episode mare do well, rainbow dash winked at us, knowing we r there. 2:18, maybe its a mistake? I honestly think pegasus and earth ponies should have that thing too. Pinkie sense is prob a genes (or what ever) from the family. Im saying that pinkie pie is prob made like that to show humor and extra ordinary/exaggeration from what you can do irl. Honestly, if i was a creator of a series, i could make many mistakes. Sometimes i forgot what happened to the characters i created! Its just an opinion btw! Thanks for reading!
0 likesSawtooth, you broke one of the most important rules! That is Pinkie Pie shall not be questioned.
3 likesOf course pinkie would have her own magic, she is one of the only characters that break the fourth wall.
0 likes(Discord)
I thought you were gonna say pinkie was a god lol
0 likesThe reason why cozyglow may have not got the magic is because she already had magic or only earth ponies can absorb magic
0 likesIdk UwU
Pinkie is completely weird by herself.First,her family not so energetic like Pinkie.Kinda negative and spends time with stones.Why did Pinkie didn't spend time with stone?Just a rainbow can't change her.Also her family generally have faded colors.Except for Pinkie.She is pink.Her hair goes fluffy when she's happy when she's sad her hair go straight.I think she was having a little power maybe when born.But we can't know more.Why she was having power when born,not another pony?Can we say why Fluttershy can communicate with plants and animals but not another pony.What caused Pinkie to have powers?Maybe something happened,so much positive energy uploaded in Pinkie?Maybe...But I think Pinkie's power get crazier when she take discords all power.
0 likesShe isn’t a pony she’s a creature
50 likesReplies (2)
Pony’s are still creatures
3 likesAlso, don’t whoosh me. I know this wasn’t that type of joke.
@Ur local sociopath Yeah I expected that.
0 likesI like pinkie pies mysterious craziness but sure explain it
0 likescozy glow was never chaotic to begin with tho think about pinkie is so chaotic with actions and in her mind but cozy never had that
0 likesHim trying to explain Pinkie:
0 likesMe: oh no, NO IF U DO DAT THE UNIVERSE WILL EXPLODE
Three actually a comic that pinke pie fall into the chaos world and was able to control and to be honest cesltia seems a little bit too friendly with discrord she likes exvtiment and to be honest I mean discrord wasn't that evil he didn't want to kill anyone even in his first appearance twkigt said he didn't play fair but he did and what would be more chaotic then controlling chaos its self and useig it for a force for good
0 likesIt would explain the way Discord can sense when there is a magical imbalance, thats where the Pinkie sense came from.
4 likesPinkies just this one character that breacks the 4th wall just like sans from undertale or william/glichtrap from fnaf im not sure about it tho
1 likewait...but didn't the discord magic absorbing thingi happen in the last episode?
0 likesi know why pinkie had the magic spread throw out her time line
1 likepinkie pie is a teen or an adult
while
cozy glow is a child
the age makes a diferance
Replies (1)
yet this is my sub theory
0 likesMaybe she got these powers cause she got power of discord AND the alicorn power. Maybe thats why?
0 likesOr she's a rogue changeling who feeds on smiles instead of love.
5 likesReplies (2)
Lol
0 likesShe spreads smiles not feed on them,but it is interesting 🤔🤔🤔
0 likesRemember cheese sandwiche’s cheesy sense
1 likei used to think that pinkie pie was a pszchic since she knows when things ae going to happen
0 likesOk i get it. But did you forgot about the rainbow..... The six ponies ware conected by it, so it coud affact pinky some how . Think about it 😉
0 likesPinkie pie secretly a unicorn? .-. CONSPIRACIES!!!!! GET OUT OF MY BRAIIIIN!!!!
0 likesIt's a family thing, I think perhaps Pinkie Sense was a family thing BUT maybe it was amplified to a more adavanced version of Pinkie Sense with Discord's magic. My theory, if you have your own comment it.
3 likesmaby pinkie pie has an in grown horn or a tumor. some tumors can grow there own teeth and organs. or pinkie is the story teller.
0 likesBut what about spike when he pulled out an umbrella out of thin air when he save the crystal empire the second time and it disappeared
1 likeI love your YouTube channel I love your theories but some of your theory for Philly some people think that Pinkie Pie is actually a changeling working for Christmas to take down the others but would that be true no
0 likesPink and green colours for the hair and a lot 😍on her hair and the second 😍💖✨her eyes 👀the first of her 😍and the first interview went well I think she is fine 🙂I hope it goes OK 👌I will share it with her 😊she will reveal 😊her back to me with the best possible outcome 😊☺💖and I will call 📞tomorrow to arrange for them 😊...
0 likesFinally, some creature solves the mystery behind Pinkie Pie.
7 likesIm gonna cry this makes me so happy
0 likesPinkie pie is the real lord of chaos and I refuse to believe otherwise
0 likesDoes anyone realize that in the time that pinky does not have magic she does not defy logic
0 likessawtooth please talk about zicorah's home land
0 likeshehehehe she knew us when nopony else did.
72 likesAND in season 6 episode 3 maud showcases similar abilities
0 likesYes I am watching you
0 likesPinkie all ready got the magic because when she got discord magic it was in the future not long befor twilight became a princess
0 likesHim: Wait...IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!!???
0 likesMe: yes Us
"I accidentally created an alternate timeline!"
7 likesOk so I have an idea what if it was because when pinkie got the magic taken away from her it was discord who took it who his of course the owner of his own magic bug when it was taken away from cosy glow it wasn't taken away by the original owner,discord,or I'm just wrong and it has nothing to do that also discord did take his magic back after he got it back from pinkie maybe that also affects it
0 likesWas pinkiepie doing impossible things before she got magic from grogars bell?
0 likesPinkie knows about what happened in the other world because her and her other self kept swapping
0 likesYes sawtooth. We are watching you
0 likesYou know how when cozy glow took away all the magic and star swirl said that all to magic be be gone for good after the 3rd sun set? But doesn't celestia raise and set the sun then she could of just not set the sun until the figured out a way to fix if
3 likesPinkie has chaos magic you are right. Or else when twilight sparklers got the crown from the other world how could pinkie know the both pinkie in the 2 worlds have chaos.
0 likesSo basically Pinkie is the Scarlet Witch and Discord is Cthon.
0 likeswhat if discord turned into this creature but was actually a pony who was pinkie's brother?
0 likesHey sawtooth, what if pinkie IS DISCORDS DAUGHTER!!!!!
1 likeMy notification bell:
35 likesNews, sports, etc
Me: whatever
My notification bell: My Little Pony
Me: Clicks right away to this video
Replies (3)
So relatable
0 likesMe when I see theory videos about anything:"I don't need sleep,I need answers"
0 likesSame but I react like that to Techno blade's videos too
0 likesthat kinda explains how pinkypie can magicaly pull things out of her hair. Sorry for bad grammer!
0 likesThis pony is adorable
0 likesThere is one problem, in a episode with mod she says she says she has mod sense and it runs in the family maybe it’s something to do with when pinky was not born yet I don’t know what do you think
0 likeswhat if pinky pie is always on the positive side to hide the pain like a fake smile.
0 likes" Yoshi darklord" Once I have a patreon I'm gonna name me that
5 likesWell maybe its because cosy already had magic but pinkie didn't so the magic stayed
0 likesCozy Glow when got discord power. She didn't use the power but when pinky got it ,she use the power to make chocolate rain. That's what different I think..
0 likesMaybe pinkie pie got the magic because she did the spell without a horn and cozy glow didn’t get the magic because it was activated with evil magic
0 likesWhat if one cosy glow steeled on The magic from Equestria pinky got magic but the magic was her pinky sense
1 likeI think pinkie pie always had caos magic on her own.
4 likesUm well Pinky had some lightning when she got bigger, but cozy did not.
1 likeI mean..cozy glow couldn't control it while pinkie could. The fact that she is chaotic already before the magic hit her is a point that I think breaks that theory. But I'm just a kid so what do I know?
0 likesWhen I found out Sawtooth Waves calls Pinkie Pie a creature:
0 likesReplies (1)
Pinkie Pie only pretends to be Pony, or it is what your eyes makes up when you can't comprehend what you see?
0 likesClasical for higher beings.
I think she got her esence from chaos magic cause she was an earth pony and earth ponys arent as magical as pegasi and before u say pegasi dont have magic they kinda do cause there flying ability’s can be removed so they have some sort of magic so since pegasi have more magic than earth ponies cozyglow was able to handle the magic more than pinky
0 likesIf we never hear about him anymore we know what happened
5 likesi think the sonic rain boom its because it might have made pinkie the way she was
0 likesPLS READ THIS!!!!!
1 likeThis theory could be possible but what about the human world? There is no chaos magic that I know of in the human world. I think it is just pinkie. For example, maybe she is just way smarter than the rest since she can tell that someone is watching.
For her pinkie sense, Celestia has a similar system but just you can't see it. For example, Pinkie Pie's tail wiggles when something is going to fall. Celestia just feels it like how she felt that Luna would come back soon.
For Pinkie's magic, I think the magic was her pinkie sense or maybe her craziness. And One more fact, Mood, Pinkie pie’s sister has mood sense too.
Now for my theory...
I think pinkie should be an alicorn since she is like the element of happiness or laughter maybe she should be the princess of happiness since that is a relationship-ish. maybe she could spread happiness. Pinkie should also be an alicorn because she would be the first earth pony to be an alicorn.
Replies (1)
#sawtoothwaves @sawtoothwaves
0 likesYes I think it's also weird but I don't think it's from discords Magic do you remember the episode when she went crazy cuz she thought her friends didn't like her anymore and you saw those split colors due
0 likesYeah!! GODS watching you always
0 likesjust a hunch.
32 likesIf pinkie took all that magic and it spread why didn’t cozy have this energy and btw pinkie pie was able to control the magic so it must be something else
0 likesMaybe pinky got those powers because she is an earth pony. Did you ever hear a earth pony becoming an alicorn? Cozy Glow may have become what she was because she's a Pegasus.
0 likesIn the episode the one where pinkie pie knows She was able too fall apart and put her self back together agian like discord can do
1 likeWhat if sawtooth had changeling sense
0 likesJust like what another character I konw said aubot chaos magic:
6 likesChaos keeps everyone guessing.
DISCORD AND PINKIE PIE BROKE THE FOUTH WALL or is it the third wall?
0 likesYour research is more than twilight
0 likesPinkie actually fell into discrord World after tirek stole his power and he got IT bsbk he was having ttihlne useing his power and pinke found her way into his dimseon and figured out the rules of chaos chaos magic actually has very specific rules and rewuere conctrstin
0 likesActually you forgot that maud also had her own pinkie sense she has maud sense
0 likesDid you know that in MY little pony equestria girls at the end of one of the movies pinkie pie switched places with the pony pinkie pie so there could be something that pinkie pie already new about the portal to equestria high before twilight did
3 likesI think Pinkei got magic from that bell
0 likesWait cosy glow obsorbed magic and grew taller mabey this is a way alicorns work?
0 likesI think i know how she got her powers she got it from the rainbow we she was a kid / filly she was not her crazy self but when she saw the rainbow some thing happened she gang happiness she also ganged power what kind you ask chaos thats why she has pinkie sense she could she the future that's her power seeing the future that's why she wants to spread Joy she wants to share her power but how how did one rainbow give her power discord now here me out think about it discord is the king of chaos pinkie is chaos could there be a connection between them?? You tell me do you think i am right ?
1 likeActually no
1 likeShe was like that before we even knew discord
Mkay
9 likesI’m mostly “phsycic”
I can sing Gypsy bard fast
It’s like I’m on adrenaline all the time
And my friends call me pinkie
Am I pinkie!?
Pinkie pie 🥧 is my favorite character from my little pony because she is funny 😄
0 likesSawtooth waves: I solved pinkie pie Twilight: I would like be your sister now Edit: I typed so fast that there were grammar mistakes XD
0 likesCan you do a video about the two sister princesses how they got the magic in the cutie mark🦄🦄
0 likesOh and how she knows is her tail is moving like crazy😎
0 likesFINALLY you did it.
9 likesOk what about Cozy absorbing Discords Chaos magic
0 likesHi Sawtooth Waves my name is Olympia and I really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really like your videos I watch finally solving pinkie pie and How discord came to be and Flurry Hearts future and the truth about stars Swirl and finally solving alicorns and how king Sombra lost his wings will for little bit of that It was a littleToo Scary because of the music for how king sombra lost his wings I also watched Finally solving delacour The alicorn ambulance And it was so much fun and Queen chrysalis and Not a true Alcorn And How did the trail of harmony Really really died And Are there other Alicorns and did celestia release Nightmare moon And I am already watching finally solving pinkie pie right now and I'm at The white and blue swirling eyes part And I Am With the silly bird And your videos are getting a lot funnier Make sure to bring more new videos and I will watch them see you
0 likesAfter seeing pinkie
0 likesIm wondering if she's adopted from the pies
Honestly i wouldn't be suprised if she were froms ome other race of cgaos ponies
but that was before pinky absorbed discord 's magic that was in the end and that you showed was only in like the school of friendship and not close to the end end
0 likes2:50
13 likesHow do you explain that the rest of her family has sense too like Maud sense and Maud teleports too
Sawtooth: Is someone watching me?
0 likesMe: YOUR ON YOUTUBE OFCOURSE THERE ARE PEOPLE WACTHING YOU
What episodes at 1:44 is he talking about? I’m binging my little pony: friendship is magic for the 20th time and I don’t know what episodes he is talking about
0 likesi like the pinkie has choas magic theory its fun and understandible
0 likesNo!!!!! we still don’t know the connection between Applejack Pinkie pie, I believe pinky pie is an orphan and something like discord is her parent
0 likesI thing pinkie absorbing discords magic in future is the cause for her cutie mark and her enthusiasm.
5 likesBecause pinkie is totally different from her family. When pinkie was a filly 8n her family there was no talking and no smiling and all of a sudden she became a party pony.
Replies (2)
Two words Rain boom
2 likesI love pinkie, separate thing: I saw a video saying "Chaotic and spontaneous things you can do to be spontaneous" I watched the video and went "non of that's spontaneous, I already do all that without thinking anything of it."
1 likeHe asked if someone's watching me yes I'm watching you right now
0 likesbut what about cheesy-sense and maud-sense??
0 likesPinkie pie is a god that has exsisted since the beginning of time and will be the end of it
0 likesWhat about cheese sandwitch he also has some kinda sense
0 likesPINKIE PIE 🎈🎈🎉🎊🎊🎉🍰🎂🥞🍥
10 likesTirek maybe a century to millenia old but pinkie is more mysterious
0 likesSawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!?
0 likesMe: you our telling a theory to YouTube what do you think
no i dont think it the magic because this magic come after a long time and the powers of pinkie or crazyness started when the show started so i do not think it is the magic
0 likesshe’s not a regular poney she’s more like discord and what he is
0 likesWithout her laughter she would have no magic and I mean ...NO MAGIC✨
10 likesReplies (1)
Not really. Remember Season 8 Yakity-Sax? She turned into Pinkamena but she somehow has a weird power to make plants magically die, or make balloons deflate.
4 likesIs that magic or what?
Laughter doesn't only exists in Pinkie, they can be inside of everyone. If you're only the representative of it then why should you have magic but the others don't?
Probably pinkie is Pinkamena in a nice and crazy form
0 likesWhy do only spike have a magical fire breath but not the other dragon's ?
0 likesMaby its conected to her family if celestia can give her magic to twilight for ruling pinkies father also can look at him he weres a cap maby he is a unicorn and gave some of his magic to his daughter 🤣+🤪+🙃+😪=pinky pie
0 likes3 words Pinkie secretly alicorn
0 likes1:15 hey! I know that song that’s “Toccata and Fugue in D minor” by J.S. Bach! That’s my favorite song by Bach
8 likesWhat if pinkie got the powers before the show began that would explain why the magic came back and more importantly pinkie was able to use discord’s magic wich would not make sense otherwise
0 likesAm I the only one who is 16, and still watches this almost every day...? Just a question ... how old are you?
0 likesa moment of chaos pure power distrubuted along her. and pinkies the sort like meand you, she wouldnt say it was a problem or abnormal
0 likesshe would litterally live and work with theses powers
Yeah it does make sense
1 likeIs it just me or is there people out there that like both Mlp and Star Wars?
5 likesReplies (1)
I do
1 likeYes Saw....I’m watching you 👁u👁
0 likesThat’s just pinkie being pinkie and the pinkie sense runs in the pie family
0 likesSawtooth: is somebody watching me??!?!?
0 likesMe: ern that's what a YouTube channel is
Well I think pinkie is pinkie because she was like that before she got discords magic 🤔 I might be wrong
0 likesHave u ever nosied the birth of a pony is always lighter then the parents like star lights parents flerry heart that piney who is yellow and likes books that I forgot the name of please do a video on this :p
18 likesReplies (3)
Do you mean moon dancer?
0 likesNo XD I mean sunburst, I just when to mlp to check XD
0 likes@Tayylorr ohhhh gotcha
0 likesIn season 5 epidpde 7 pinkie notices discord when he'is a box and says "Hi discord!"And he is shocked so i think ypur theory is right
0 likesThats just them pulling a deadpool and breaking the fourth wall
0 likesI think discord and pinky pie are the first changelings to be made. And they are trying to take over to land. If they make session 10.
0 likes2:19 that was her pinkie sense
0 likesPlot twist : Pinkie Pie only use 1% of her happiness
3 likesReplies (1)
No way...
0 likesShe actually used it early
0 likesI think when pinkie was born someone or discord had put chaos magic into pinkie that results in what happened inthe future
0 likesPinkies secretly an Alicorn using magic to hide her wings and horn
0 likesBut how did pinkie pie control the power not like cozy here’s my theory she already had caos like discord when she got her cutie mark so more of that caos magic will be ok that’s why cozy could not control caos magic like pinkie oh and did you notice cozy became a giant alicorn while pinkie didn’t well i think caos magic makes the user bigger in size but discord is like a container of the magic so he doesn’t get bigger in size
0 likesCheese Sandwich who has cheese sense: 👀
3 likesHey, not just Pinkie have Pinkie Sense, her sister, Maud,. had Maud Sense. I think it developed from her family.
0 likespinky did not get her weard power from the bell with discord power
1 likeSawtooth waves- IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME
0 likesme- YES THER IS SOMEONE WATCHING YOU WE ALL ARE WATCHING YOU TUH...!!!
pinkie pie: am I a joke to you?
0 likesPinkie sense runs in pinkie's family
0 likesPinkie pie doesn’t look like discord because at season 2 discord can change the mane five opposite selves but pinkie can’t do that kind of stuff
0 likesDude you are a fucking legend
0 likesNope your going at this all the wrong way pinkie is simply an almighty being
0 likesWhen he said IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME yes we are watching u
10 likesReplies (1)
Same
0 likesi think pinkie got all of this power from discord
0 likesThis is suspicious but I want to tell pinkie that she is the element of laughter I think she is doing this something to make us laugh
0 likesMaybe cozy glow did not get affected because she is a Pegasus and pinky got it because she was an earth pony with no magic.
0 likesAwesome and cool!
0 likesPetition for Sawtooth to do a face reveal at 300k:
3 likesI
I
V
When you said: is someone watching me?
0 likesBruh.
So many people are watching you.
I like pinkie she’s just so crazy 'n' cute
0 likes2:19 I DIDNT REALISE THAT
1 likeWait remember the rocks on pinkie’s past that must be discord’s magic!
0 likesReplies (1)
Wait so what if pinkie was cozy glow all along because they Both use discord’s magic
0 likeshwo many times you rewatch this i didn't even see that
5 likesBut wait.... That could explain the pinkie sense but there was a mention of a maud sense
0 likesThis is the end of the last season she can not carry magic throo time
0 likesFor Your Question The Answer is yes
0 likesWhen u said "is someone watching me?" Well yes duh
0 likesYay pinkie is my favorite cuz she is just so cute amazing and everything
3 likesfarfetch! that's a good Pokemon you got one? I'll trade you for my Raichu
0 likesSawtooth waves: pinky and discord do the same thing like when they stare off to space
0 likesLike someone is watching them…… is someone watching me!?!
Me: yeah all your subscribers and probably other people who don’t subscribe and me so yes there’s probably tons of people watching you.
Lol I found that funny!
She is awesome
0 likesThat would be true but we don’t know that pinkie or discord get there magic zapped away
0 likesIs someone watching me?!
3 likes359,013 people: No?
remember that pinkie sense is par of family
0 likesPinkie is god
0 likesThe animator
Coazy Glow use The Chaos magic to became a huge alicorn. On The other side pinkie remain an earth pony
0 likesyou know i just think there is no explenation to what happened in mlp gen4
0 likesWhy is None Talking about that Pinkie is pink and the rest of her family is grey? Im getting a Felling that Shes adopted...please talk about this in a video
5 likesReplies (3)
She became pinkier after she gained her cutie mark.
3 likesYeah she always had that crazy pink so maybe she is Mrs. Cake and Mr. Cakes daugter that got put for adoption because her parents were too young
0 likesShe's like the extravert born in an introverted family. Still genetically like them, but different behavior.
0 likesBuy pinkie was always chaotic not after when she absorbd discord magic
0 likesWell why i think pinkie pie is a anomaly is no one but discord can control his magic so pinkie pie has been braking the 4th wall
0 likesIf that was the case then why did Pinkie Pie say Pinkie Pie scenes and Maude said it was mod sense pinky said it ran in the family then how does that logic work
0 likesOne does not simply understand Pinkie Pie
0 likesHi! [Insert fluttershy/pinkie yay]
7 likesPinkie epsorbed discord's magic that's my theory
0 likesWhen Sawtooth said IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME I was like ÿEs tHus įŠ yOutÛbÊ
0 likesSawtooth:is someone watching me?!?!
0 likesMe:Naw no one watching you 😏🍝
What do you think your right Pinky Pi is having the same Chaos magic
0 likesThat happened in the last episode of the series sawtooth that dosent make any sense you did not solve pinkie pie
3 likes“Is someone watching me?!” Yes, yes indeed. Ur fans are watching u
0 likesI think she got her powers from the sonic rainbow
0 likesEverybody knows you're being watched you're on YouTube
1 likeYou said wait is someone watching me? And I was like yes someone is watching you us
0 likesI really hate “I’m first” comments like nobody really cares stop bragging
70 likesReplies (18)
Agreed
5 likesSameee
3 likesAnd none reads them
3 likesCos there to far down
1 likeSAME
0 likesI also hate these “I’m early for once comments”
3 likeseveryone is early at least ONCE, so don’t even tell that lie.
I Agreed. can't we all just get along and just appreciate that we come to a video at different points of time?
0 likesthey're not even first.
0 likesSmithsonian smith AMEN 🙏🏽
0 likes@Avatar Korra yes, auto get-likes
0 likes@Michael Jacksons Biggest Fan Gacha Life and more! I was just saying. is everything okay?
0 likesMeh
0 likesI'm sure if there were a prize you would do it.
0 likes@May-Nimari that's very kind of you but I don't understand what you're saying...
0 likes@May-Nimari bruh. What if the "first" is too much on the first second? Im sure youtuber can detect the first coment using something because "first" never be 1 coment
0 likesLisa’s hater club I love and like every single I’m first comments
0 likes@Albino Python r you a youtuber? huh.
0 likesAli-Mery I don’t hold any disrespect upon people who like “oh I’m first” comments
0 likesYou miss a clue when sunset shimmer touched pinkie and saw what was inside her head and If you don't know who sunset shimmer is she is in equestria girls
0 likesI don’t get it he just said pinky got her powers just because of that episode and that was like The second final episode😂
0 likesIs nobody gonna talk about her past?
0 likesBut she cant be solved :/
0 likesI think it has to be a connection with Pinkie pie’s cutie mark and laughter element of harmony so pinkie Love balloons and her cutie mark is balloons and The element has powers she is the spirit of laughter so she has Pinkie sense because ,in my little pony a new generation there is three crystals earth pony Crystal , The Pegasus crystal and the unicorn crystal so just because earth ponies don’t have the magic and can’t fly they do have a power and the only earth pony has a power is Pinkie pie
0 likesI don’t think this is true because if she got her power and season nine how did she get it on the other seasons
0 likesRemember when Discord said his fav element is pinkies in beginning of s 2?
0 likesReplies (1)
oc Laughing would suit Discords personality but also Pinkies. May he felt the chaosmagic in Pinkie but just a theory.
0 likesforget the mane 6 and their dragon the are just not required anymore.
0 likesI guess I’m a sheep now
0 likesyou know how the ever free has givein berth to whered crechers
1 like*hint: shes one
Pinkie pie is already have powers in the beginning of the episode bro can you shill first bro
1 likeWell, literally, no, technically, yes
0 likesAnd acorn shining armor that's part of this big message
0 likesDoes mop have a villain who’s name is lord darker
0 likesbut pinkie is still good
0 likesIts so satidwhen I watch random videos and hear ksp music.
0 likesI think because pinkie is just chaos alone kinda she changed the time line cuz it’s pinkie don’t question it
0 likesI love your videos
0 likesPinkie absorbed princess magic 2. Cozy did not
1 likeChocolate Rain Brings down ___ ask me on comments to do the full song
1 likeNOPE I SHALL NEVER WITNESS THIS VIDEO EVER AGAIN
1 likeTwilight would go barzer she'll be like "SAWTOOTH YOU WILL PAY FOR THIS"!!!!
0 likesIn the episode where Pinkie Pie goes to Manhattan Mod says the she has Mod sense and it runs in the family. However pinkie pie has more than just pinkie sense.
0 likesI think earth ponies have magic but in different ways and pinkie’s magic is.... u know.... pinkie
0 likesWatch double rainboom it might give u some answers.
0 likesShe didt because in the season where everyone gets there magic back from cozy globe she been haveing magic ether or with out her elemant or discords magic first came cozyglobe stealing magic and pinkie pie gets her magic back then she got discords magic when kingsobra broke the elemants of harmeny pinkie pie lost her happy power and when her friends said chear us up because they were sad of the elemants of harmeny she says sorry i cant feel it there is nothing funny about these sorry and you mite not know these but in every ipisode love happyness abd hate magic can go to diferent universes and know alat about every ones lives thats all i got
0 likesThe difference between pinkie and cozy is cozy was an alicorn when she got the caos magic and pinkie was and earth pony I guess earth pony’s have magic to
0 likesWhen pinky turns in to the crazy & giant pinky I saw grogars bell on it
0 likesI love my little pony💕😊
0 likes“i could transform the cosmos so everything is made of icing”
0 likesthat is why chaos magic is the most powerful magic could ever exist
I love this
0 likesHaha i proved ye theory wrong my evidence is Cheese Sanswitch!
0 likesActually this pinkie sense runs in the family maud has maud sense
1 likeidk, maybe a horn is just hiding in her puffy mane lol
0 likesjkjk
or am i ?
what if pinkie, from the other world created discord
0 likesPinkie PIE is the Psychic RULER-
1 likeCool theory but in the gift of the maud pie. Maud has pinkie sense or rather maud sense. So does that mean the pie family have secret super powers
0 likesthe reason cozy didn't get chaos magic is because when pinkie absorbed discords magic celestia and luna's magic was in the bell
0 likesReplies (2)
But we're talking about chaos magic here.....which only brings us to Discord
0 likes@Mag i guess so
0 likesPinkie said that the sense runs in the family like maud sense
0 likesNow solve Maud sense
1 likeThink how pinkie pie might be a different tribe I mean she’s not like a usual earth pony
0 likesPINKIE PIE IS A GOD
0 likeswhen all they magic was gone pinky pie was laghfing
1 likeHi Sawtooth Waves I was too busy yesterday to text you So I'm doing it now And I really really really really really really like finally solving pinkie pie is there 1 that is called Finally solving twilight or fluttershy or Rainbow —dash or Applejack Well I don't know If there we are not there or not Cause I think that So what are you doing thinking Videos of something cause I don't know when They are going to come i Really really really Want new videos To come now I cannot Just watch the same ones All over and over again cause I just watched 1 video and I Don't know what it wasDon't know what it was calledDon't know what it was called But it was 1 of your Videos and It will come Next friday It already past The next friday And your videos are super duper very very very very very really really really really really really really really really Fun well When I was watching How King sombra lost his wings I was scared of it because of the music and the red circling And it happened In the alcorn Ambulance video I also watched twilight killed the real pinky it was like hilarious cause I just watched it in my mom's room on the TV We were trying to find relaxing fish music but then when we were trying to find it my sister said All of your My little pony videos that I watched And we watched The future of flurry heart and Twilight killed the real pinky It was totally hilarious Cause when we were about to click it to watch it twilight zapped the real pinky and she was like a big circle and it was super hilarious Here is a joke what do you call twilight eating a pie? Cause she went to the Lamp drum Ticket Lamp drum tickets all in 1 word It's just a joke you know Cause You should have make more videos about Flurry heart And princess cadence and I know who the secret Alcorn Princess Is She Has Dark dark dark purple and Dark pink swirl Hair and she has white and her legs are big like princess celestia And she has A. Snowflake cutie mark And A purple eye Or blue and You just have to go to search And Go to speaker and say who is the secret Alcon princess and You just have to watch it and see well I don't know Princess Cadence's Dad is cause I don't know when I'm gonna watch it Later something Cause I'm going to be texting you a big message and I'm already doing it now I know how to spell these words With this speaker that I am speaking at it makes it to Easy then Typing I just wrote then With typing It only had a few words I hope you get this message Well it has too many words Just take your time to Read it and Make a very very very good video with no villains or scary music Only with A very good ponies See you tomorrow!!!!!!!! And I am Olympia See you soon!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesShe is scary because she’s crazy 😝
1 likebut what about Maud sense see didn't absorb discords magic
0 likesDoes talking ponies exist? Well I know they don't well my sister thinks everything is real
0 likesI love Pinkie pie 🥧
0 likesok listen how bro come on if she can do that then how did she do it in the past huh.
0 likesI think she can see the future like she did know what all happend in Mlp eg and when twilight came back......
0 likesKnow i kinda get why some people think discords favorite element was pinkie pie i though it was fluttershy but i kinda get it know and I also think that discord favorite element is pinkie pie i agree with it NOT A SHIP LIKE EWWW
0 likesWhat if Pinky exactly The Reincarnation of Chaos incase Discord Conan will come back the universe made Pinky chaotic future oh-so really good but that's far-fetched
0 likesYou can't solve Pinkie.
0 likesomg three ponys got magic and tripill cuti marks
0 likesI love it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! But Pinkie did'nt seem the least bit chaotic before she got her cutie mark.
0 likesBut can't you remember pinkie seanse runs in the family
0 likesPinky pie's parents where accused of witch craft and got hung she's a gypsy or a witch 🤦♂️🤦♀️
0 likesReplies (1)
The witch craft runs in her family
0 likesHi you now that's a very good point I thought it was true but now I don't think it's true you know why because pinky sense isn't only at Pinkie Pie we saw the same in rainbow Dash's birthday cheese sandwich has the same thing he just names it cheesy sense but it's still with a good point of view
0 likes“ like there being watched”
0 likesMe: crap there on to us!
It’s like they know there in a tv show 👁👄👁
0 likesis there really a pony world????
0 likesWe know that pinkie does things which are out of this world and theirs tooooo . There could be something linked with this event that this event made every single pinkie , pinkie clones and human pinkie magical as in Equestria girls 1 ; Pinkie guesses twilight is a princess even without magic in that world !!! This theory could be a very strong probability to pinkies pinkiness
1 likeReplies (1)
It may also effect her family aka Maud syas she has some type of maud sense and then pinkie says " It runs in the family " I really dont know weather she was joking or she was saying it in real
0 likesBut that happened when twily became an alicorn
0 likeswelp what if she is a secret Unicorn?
0 likesBut cheese sandwich has cheesy sense
0 likesPinky and discord can break the 4th!?
0 likesYou actually wrong she could control bescue she used in his Chris dimseon
0 likesIn season 1 when pinkies mane goes not poofy we see that she has a turnip bucket. But then in mlp eg spring breakdown we see pony twilight showing human rainbow and twilight and sunset shimmer a table of mysteries stuff, And one of them was the turnip bucket, It could be that pinkies got power to make stuff go crazy like discord who made a teacup with wings.
0 likesPinkie pie has here own magic
0 likesHow could chaos magic be the answer not only pinkie pie got pinkie sense but cheese sandwich have cheese sense but he did not get chaos magic inside him so then maybe pinkie is from a magic family and what about if pinkie have a long lost sister and she was a unicorn she went to the unicorn school and she tried her magic so she could get in but she made a blast and this spell she tried to do could have got in her that where it starts and she was older than pinkie and her sister that could be the truth
1 likeYes but there’s nothing to be afraid of.
0 likesvery cool theory
0 likesBut in an episode pinkie tells us that mud also has pinkie sense our mud sense
0 likesI think it didn't affect it cuz soon after she got turned to stone and that's why pinky got a different effect but then again pinky just Pinky don't even ask
0 likesWe are watching you because you’re recording remember
0 likesI like just saying Pinkie Pie
0 likesno other pony is mnet to be spokin of.
i dont think so mad has mad sens and she did not get caos magic and pinkiy said ' it runs in the family
0 likesmakes sense to me
0 likesIs someone watching me
0 likesMe: yes
Actuly this makes scens but are we shure pinkie only obsorbed discord’s magic what about grogars cozy probably studied more about artifacts than pinkie I mean you probably want information to drain magic with artifacts so she probably had information on the bell before realizing the artifact would be impossible to get so she was slightly more carful with the magic and what would you expect from pinkie
0 likesCan you feature in my next mlp video? We will sing a true true friend with others😀
0 likesBut pinkie absurb discord magic after cozy glow almost draind magic or... and i have nothing
0 likesforget the mane 6 and their dragon their out of style.
0 likesI thought it was her cutie mark but ok.
0 likescozy glow had alicorn majic to support discord’s unlike pinkie
0 likesYou’re into Pokémon!?!?
1 likePinkie pie and discord are long lost twins.
0 likesRainbow or pinky pie got his powers because she adored some of the magic for me
0 likeswe are watching you…
0 likesI agree with is theory it makes sense
0 likesThis is my theory when the student 6 released the magic pinkiea pinky sensé came to her
0 likesTHE COSMOS AROUND HER!!!!!!
0 likeshow do you explain maud sense?
1 likeReplies (1)
lol I said that as well
0 likesBut pinkie said it runs in the family cus her sister also has the sence
0 likesUhhh we are watching you, we like your videos
1 like1:45 oh uhh yess actually they break the fourthwall and you already know we watch u =) you speak to us how are you confused there bud?
0 likesDang the main 6 left a scine in the world where happens and freand ship its boutifull i love that this show makes vid even if it may or not be over
0 likesIt... started raining... what..?
0 likes2012 apocalypse flashbacks
chocolate rain
4 rage comics on horseback
Pinkie is just pinkie because you know pinkie!
0 likesPinkie has magic not the one people think of just saying
0 likesyou are right how do you do this
0 likesHey sawtooth I agree with u
0 likesPinkie sence is that not magic?
0 likesyes someone is watching u it is me that is watching you.
0 likesyes us.
pinkies a master mind she makes friendship prombleme
0 likesBecause mabe pinky and discords have same craze power
0 likesSawtooth Waves check the deleted scenes my little pony equstria girls pinkies switch places
0 likesNo one can explain Pinkie pie cause she's Pinkie pie
0 likesPinkie pie is my favorite 🍓😁😁
0 likesSpoiled glou was an allacorn when she absorved the magic so her body could adjust the magic without having to spread it throughout her lifetime
0 likesBecause of the mirror pool :/
0 likesI think your right
0 likesIt's Pinkie Pie don't question it.
0 likesVideo: Discord
0 likesCaption: Dis quartz
Dis cords
Can you please do one of these videos but on....
0 likesFLUTTERSHY
You now how there are clones of the royal guard and how there was an alicorn guard what if that is pinky pie
1 likeAll the pie family has pie sense
0 likesLook is pinkie really a earth pony is she kind of ...
0 likesUnicorn
I have something to say.......................
0 likesPINKIE IS JUST PINKIE 🥳🤩🍭🍬🍫🍿🍩🎂
I go with you wierd power from The future cozy glow wasn’t crazy like pinky and didn’t do as much stuff as pinky
1 likethis was before pinke was crazy
0 likesOh she had a secret horn
0 likesHa ha pinky is at the end 😂
0 likesPinkie pie reminds me of me.
0 likes1:50 yes yes there is
0 likesI like your videos
0 likes*cry in mlp season 9 hasn't come to sweden's netflix yet*
0 likesyou cannot solve my favourite character
1 likeReplies (1)
😲
0 likesFinally solve pinkie:then if it that how can you explain pinkie from the human and if it was that she should have been normal the whole time
0 likesReplies (1)
I think it her family her great parent was unicorn and that magic could have go to pinkie bit has A earth pony
0 likesThey say “FUCK RULES!! RULES SUCK”
0 likesPick it up and I have to get my hair done before you go home and get
0 likesYes someone is watching you... Your veiwers
1 likeMaybe she got magic from her pinkie seances (sorry if I spelt it wrong auto correct)
0 likesBecause of the rumors about pinkie... Everyone hates pinkie! She's just a character? Why does some toxic people always make fun of her? Why make fun of her, when you know hasbro made it
0 likesDo not question the Pink pie
0 likesYes someone is indeed watching you, in fact 597,435 that I saw, (the views) are watching you! :3
0 likesoomgs its amazing and it would explain pinky
0 likesOf course someone is watching you us the viewers you silly billy
0 likesmy little pony have so much secrets why can you tell us thank you so much for teaching us thank you so much my little pony I love you so much teling us please make more videos po
0 likesPinkie sense was prolly there when she was born because the ponies of ponyvile knew about it along time ago before twillight came
0 likesI always think pinky is acting pinkie and discord is discordy i belived every single WORD
0 likesAren't you the same guy who thinks there are still bad changlings and you think you can solve pinkie pie?
0 likesEpilepsy warning warning
0 likesOr pickle pie as a secet
2 likesPinkey is a god
0 likesI know pinkie pie's truth and it's creepy her real name is pinkamena
0 likesOh ok...
0 likesStar swirl isn't discord...
But pinkie might be...
Is Some One Watching Me?
0 likesMe: Yes I Am LoL
Maybe Pinkie Pie is a unicorn.
0 likesI’m gonna question to pinkie
0 likesYes she dead pinky pinky yes yes she said OK she did OK she then got your power from that one moment
0 likesI dont think thats it cause her sister has Mod sense Idk how to spell her name
0 likesMe get the guns someone broke the law
0 likesIs that's why pinkie's human counter part is just like this pinkie ???
0 likesCan someone please tell me the music of 1:16
0 likesits a shame but i think i agree
0 likesPinkie Pie I have some really strange stuff that I didn't really know about her like physics never realize pinky with that Majestic in California. Something was wrong with her cuz she would crazy I think she was adopted or going to cuz her friends and I only have family do not look like her cuz maybe her family was like going out of business and maybe she was constipated time maybe she had like some hopefuls of some some Nair or some pony it must be her headache be guardian of the Girl doll you know where people have you no other person that they would protect the weird bad stuff what happened to them when they were little kids I bet she had it and she absorbed the magic and that's I think about you be a great queen or something maybe like she used to have some ability like she like had powers or maybe she was an Alicorn secretly but the afterwards maybe her parents had to protect her cuz she didn't want to cause drama around the world she hit her powers and her horse that's why her hair was soaked early but her powers never but she never use them that's why they were always never there you never saw her horn because it was covering her hair and she never had wings because even if she was out of course you would have kept it a secret so she didn't cause traumas stuff music when it was temporary when her friends are fat and they were her or maybe it was necessary she will use it in the show we never saw it but maybe she might be able to bring her magic back but she doesn't use it for anything else but if it family and friends will get hurt by some evil entity or feeling she might use it but her friends never realized but she was actually an Alicorn 1 her friends and family but she was not the only one in stuff she never had anything to do with it she decided she didn't want to cause drama for the world and her wings so that's why she was able to do it but she was always afraid of what happened like some new ones will come up when she hide it she was hiding it and deep down she was like she giving up hope there's no one will realize she was Alcorn or grow another one had respect for her and that's how her powers came when you are upset they come easily cuz she was depressed never had her face and she was never happy pony one day her her powers can't because she was not the one that read the matter what if we went to find her job was meant to be she was so happy she was happy she was Alec bumper she really have to hide it so people what is in the ponies will understand so that's why she had figure out time and maybe we can solve them to pinky but she was hiding it all this time and all these episode it took me a hot minute to realize she was an alicorn another dimension that she was an Alicorn but we never saw the real
0 likesPinkie pie had this weird magic even before twilight became a princess so I don't know what you're talkin about this video makes no sense I know pinkie pie more than any for me does and I'm not even in the my Little pony universe
0 likesPINKIE IS AN EQUATION
0 likesI think because cozy glow was an alicorn
0 likesPinky did not have her magic like that that was the final part you now how is pinky maybe because when she god her mask
0 likesNo mod also has mod sentence
0 likesI danced to your intro
1 likeAND RARITY SHE IS PULLING OUT HER CHAIR
0 likesDidthe Royal sisters earn their wing's?
0 likesReplies (1)
The exact origin of Celestia and Luna is deliberately kept as a mystery. But it's assumed that Celestia and Luna were born as alicorns. (At least, Lauren Faust has said so, and the show and the comics didn't contradict her.)
0 likesFlurry Heart is the first alicorn born in more than a thousand years; and genetically, neither of her parents is an alicorn (Shining Armor is a unicorn, and Cadance was originally a pegasus). That's why Celestia and Luna were so surprised about her birth. (Was it some residual effect of the magic of love that transformed Cadance into an alicorn? Did the transformation also alter Cadance's genetic code? Was the Crystal Heart involved somehow?) Plus, they said that birth of an alicorn is something that Equestria hasn't ever seen, and this is true - Celestia and Luna are older than the Principality of Equestria itself.
pinky's chaos energy is very powerful she is only using 0.00000000000000000000000000000000000001% of her power good thing she doesn't snap easily...............but I think some one said cupcakes are the worst thing in history so get into your bunkers
0 likesYes we are watching you 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
0 likesIs the main six good well I don't think so maybe the good people aren't good and the bad people is not bad because maybe the bad people are right and the good people are wrong
0 likesTell me who is pinkie married to
0 likesWell i believe everything else but pinkie sence doesn't explain it cause maud has maud sence
0 likesI am confused about the past???????
0 likesIf you think about because the cosy glow Had a look on magic it does give Cody go to Halle Halle called magic as you’re dead the dead piggy pie just use chaos magic without any other magic with it so I think pick up I did up Cales magic but I close the client had it like Alacon bad because he’s just gonna go suck it up girl grow Godspell a little times two powers of Case close
0 likesMaybe pinkie pie got magic because of... PINK AMINA
0 likesPinkie Pie time Magic
0 likesImagine if this did not happen pinkie woulf probably be a maud #2
0 likesDid anyone look at the fact that pinky has so much hair and she might just be a unicorn anyone think of that
0 likesReplies (1)
Like her hair could cover her horn
0 likesI think that magic was her pinkie sense
0 likesPinkie is broken now...
0 likesPinkie Pie's real name is Pinkamena Dianne Pie. Is Pinkie Pie a serial killer that kidnappe every ponies?
0 likesI thought pinkie pie is tranquility.
0 likesSo true🙂
0 likesThat happened at season 9
0 likesIS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!?!?!??!
0 likesPlease follow the name of the game
0 likesPinkiy is buying her self 🤔
0 likesBut....how she get chaos power her mom and dad don't have chaos is the rain boom did??? there is 1 you guy didn't see season 8 episode 26 she still have it she didn't bake cake just there
0 likesPinkie must already had chaos magic before she had discords magic
0 likesReplies (2)
Because it looks like she knows how to use discords chaos magic.
0 likesDoes she know it’s there?
0 likesI think pinkie is just being pinkie
0 likesThat still don't explain why is she pink and her family is dark
0 likesMaybe thats why she pink? Everyone looks like their family so pinky doesn't?
0 likesI mAy HaVE JuUst SolVEd PinKIe PiE:
1 likeFRIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENNNNNNNNNNNNDDDDSSSSSSS
Pinkie is so crazy but she is so a mistary. But we have seen where pinkie get ball 🏀 from all over ponyvill. But hi love your videos 😉
0 likesMaybe pinky was born with chaos magic.
0 likesPrincess of Chaos Pinkie Pie
0 likesPinky pie is an earth pony
0 likesI think pinkie is just... pinkie
0 likesYesss good job
0 likes0:19 it can be ture !!
0 likesAnd yes I do believe you
0 likesWait a minute....THIS WAS POSTED 11 MONTHS AGO?????
0 likesHey cheese sandwich has cheese sense
0 likesWait so this is how discord gots its name not the dragon the app
0 likeswhat if she took magic from the elements of harmany think about
1 likeReplies (3)
because how would she get the power before that happened
1 likeIts future not past
1 likeand look when it was the future the magic was like gone
1 likeCosy was an alicron but pinki pie was not
0 likesYa but we’re are twilights wings in the pinkie senses
0 likes0:04 what,s that face
0 likesLol good joke bro
1 likeAhh is someone watching me oh Pinky has a child now
0 likesBut how was PINKIE pinkie from the past?
0 likesSawtooth is the best sawtooth sawtooth sawtooth
0 likesYes pinkie pie did
0 likesPINKY CREATED DISCORD!
0 likesAlso, 535 968 people are watching you >:D
It looks like pinkie knows how to use discords magic
0 likesReplies (4)
Wait remember your video on the real pinkie died then what if it’s the
0 likesClone
0 likesThat has magic bc pinkie said herself that she and cheese sandwich r the same and the original pinkie pie would have the pinkie senses like cheese sandwich
0 likesBut pinkie has also that chaos magic so the clone must have gotten that magic from the mirror pool
0 likesMaybe that’s why she Pink and her family is gray
1 likeShe is not a problem to be the best and I have questions
0 likesBut wait cheese sandwich has a cheesy sense but he has no caous i dont belive
0 likesNOT TRUE ,,PINKIE US ALWAYS PINKIE,,
0 likesSeriously what is his Deal with Yoshi dark Lord
0 likesshe's just pikcy
0 likesShe she’s just a alicorn with wings and a horn in her head in her mane just don’t quisten
0 likesBut in episode green isn’t your colour she was in the mirror and twilight was a unicorn but pinkie held the lamp when twilight was a alicorn.
0 likesINFINY GROUNDED!×INFINY
0 likesI don't think that pinkie has power's
0 likesPinkei lost her pinke sence when magie was take
0 likesU forgot 1 thing about pinkie pie her pinkie sense
0 likesOh nvm and what u mean pinkie pie takes discords magic
How are you sooooooooooooo smart at thissssssss
0 likessaw toooth waves
0 likesin the other world is morning and it is night time in the Pony world what happened if pinkie pie switch with the other pinkie pie
0 likesPinkie is pinkie don’t question it
0 likesHer laughter from pizza pie pinky pie I mean the wider the dirt to read a peek for her
0 likesPut pinkie was pinkie even before that
1 likeI think pinkie pie is the way the way she is because of pinkie sense but pinkie sense is because of the rainboom.
0 likesI believe it
0 likesYes I am watching you.
0 likesWhen I saw the title I was like wwwwwwaaaaaaa
0 likes🎈🎈🎈
0 likespinkie pie 's child will be just like pinkie , chaos and crazy bc pinkie is related to her child ofc then she will be chaosic or crazy like pinkie pie AHHHH PINKIE PIE WHAT HAVE YOU BROUGHT IN THIS WORK CHAOSIC NESS AND DISCORD U TO
0 likesPinkie pie is the sister of discord from different timelines and Worlds Equestria girls
1 likeReplies (1)
Or Real life check your donkeys and your horses
1 likeYou read to much into a show for girls 3-8
0 likesI dont know but make a video of how pinkie became an alicorn!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesthey are diffent kind of poneys
0 likesshe has chaos to!
0 likesI love Pinkie Pie
0 likesYou can’t solve pinkie
0 likesTHE TİME LİNE OH GOD
0 likesHere's the link of the video https://youtu.be/NXqkTscjxwk
0 likesI like the theory, but..
0 likes💕ie
is
💕nkie
Yea someone is watching you us viewers
0 likesbut cozy was a alicorn she is a pegisi ramang magic
0 likesBiggest thing ki is so after is the element of the laughter so this is what is a paint NH7 Sohar then every is the craziness or what is the craziness of the memories that there is just got this magic and seek a more powerful than ever
0 likesHow do ponies get their names By shaanvika
0 likesPinkie breaks law of fisicks like dicord and looking at us veirs
0 likesbut maud also have maud sense as pinkie
0 likesSpike:ummmm... may i have a gem!?pls
0 likesYep I agree
0 likesI’m watching you sawtooth your on YouTube 😈
0 likesThere is nothing special about pinkie pie she is just a silly party pony
0 likesI saw tooth Waves Can you make any more videos that are fun but no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no scary things cause it really really really scares me like it's cause when I hear the music on how kings someone lost his wings and The alicorn ambulance music it was so scary I just stopped watching that And never ever ever ever ever watch that type of episode again cause it was too scary you Should Sombra episode with no scary music it scares me too much It really really does it very it does Cause where do you even get the music from? My sister isn't a fan But I am me my sister Olivia Are twins And was 7
0 likes😱
2 likesPinkie pie!😊
0 likesPinkies just is just being pinkie pie 😆😅
0 likesI think pinkie is just being pinkie
0 likesYes someone is waching you... Maw ha ha ha ha maw ha ha👀😈
0 likesReally that happened in the last video and pinki has bean pinki before that
0 likesOh no this... can't.... oh.. boy.... your kidding right
0 likesKnow what the think of things purchases a mystery character that I don't understand about pinky Pie she has no problems of Manhattan house her but we have a lot of Secrets about her. We don't know what's a tummy a hot minute realize that she was a look corn because actually I knew it all I just was my brain was dumb but anyways maybe we'll be able to say maybe we can get a game or something don't know something I think it will make make a game that was playing her tragedy maybe all the characters will have the wrong special story and stuff maybe think about had drama with her a real parents house maybe her dad was reading out of business is in her mom was trying to make money but she didn't in before her in a orphanage then her like family came first up parents so much never hold a nap or whatever she was like she was always press abused by Gucci hadn't he was abused and stuff with the other owners of the Ganahl the mayor's and stuff being her up she was abused and never even the small she has bruises for years and she was always tormented and she was never a house before your like she was second a timely then at the woods her friends started bawling her being a life torture to cost flies her house her brain mentally as I can trust she never talk back this you didn't want to to be so on the little the word but she was always beat up tap use and never liked all these kids made fun of her cuz she was not popular that girl the other ones were she she got beat up your other rest I think she had drama parents whenever liked to do like abuse her guitar kid baby her siblings bite be 10 she was like beating them up for maybe that's how she got trouble then she was abused and she was always accusing to was child attitude it be her up into a pink then her eyes with bleeding coming crying tears in stuff parents never cared about her that's why she was abused she had a lot of drama with her parents using her making her feel like she was at to call me a question that house she was trying to hide it in the episodes like it it has she was going to different the mentioned she never mentioned it I'll her story cuz we never knew what about her that I knew about everything is I am the smart penis but anyways I think she you was trying to hide it from the camera s*** bruises all over the state she put makeup the planet with her skin that's why she was never allowed to know what's you probably could make up on her skin so she can not to be around so stupid praying that Bob on that she went she goes home she calls the curtains then she cries and cries and cries how a lot she cries and cries and cries have her all birthday party went her parents will her real pads hated her and sing ever sell big heart birthday and as a shoe was sad never allowed to have she was crying her room Walker heard door and cry cry and cry like to doors and stuff this is cake whenever heard parents live she had to tantrum cuz she wanted to see her siblings but they will always never around Zulu to different countries so that's why she should she was crying wash Mr siblings and she was married and everything was perfect but she will want to her husband was shooting ahead and she had a divorce then she lost some of her kids I love you never saw her but she's out of think if I met when they were in college a nice selling love but sex before she real
0 likesAnd yes she is just pinkie but with powers and I think is her big sis cuz she knew everything even the cutiemarks that can take you cutiemarks mmm..... but yeah I this her big sis
0 likesshe is odd
0 likesShe got her powers from a group of outside entities, the Voidwalkers, one of them was discord, and the other one was my OC
0 likesI think pinkie is just funny
0 likesI mean it’s just a cartoon
0 likesI love pinkie
0 likesPinkies a pony not a creature -_-
0 likesDiscord is my favorite character
Discord x Fluttershy is my favorite ship
Replies (1)
Ahem
0 likesDa RuLeS
i am watching you sawtooth YOUR RECORDING AND LITTLE FAMOUS?
0 likesPinky pie real name is pinkamena
0 likesWhat if pinkie isnt anf never was a normal earth pony
0 likesThere is not a really pinky pie
1 likeImpossible
1 likepinke got magic sesoan 8 not 9 sesoan 9 ant out yet
0 likesWait doesn’t mod pinkies sister have…mod sence
0 likesThis is clickbait.
0 likesi have a theory
0 likesI have seen Something similar,
0 likesI think pinkie pie is just a normal pony
0 likesI mean the Alcorn
0 likesyes someone is watching you. me! im watching ur vidio now
0 likesYes someone is watching you your subscribers
0 likes😂😂😂😂
0 likesHow do i watch this where fo i find the mlp episodes I haven’t seen this
1 likeReplies (1)
Someone named Letupita725HD has a yt channel, that's where I watch all the episodes. If you go on their channel and look at playlists you should find a playlist for each season
1 likeI sync pinky pies pinky thanks is Magic
0 likesPinky is not a pony she is whatever creature discord is
0 likesI love your videos so much I'm prince Rayno
0 likesI have happy eyes
0 likesThousands of people are watching you you have a chanle
0 likesRainbow dash, applejack doesn't got power pinkie got her smile
0 likesBad twilight sparkle silly pinkie pie
0 likesPinkie) ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo twilight sparkle you are bad go to your room now
Twilight)noooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Pinky pie is crazy
0 likessomeone IS watching u
0 likesCosy is smaller then Pinkie
0 likesNow whos better? Derpy or pinkie pie
0 likesPinkie pie is just pinkie pie she is just crazy or she has some illness that makes her do what crazy things she does
0 likesyes yes yes yes
0 likesYes someone is watching u
0 likesAhhhhh help me
0 likesfluttershy?
0 likesI am Skunk Bunk
0 likesLike there someone watching them.....creepy sounds.............stop being creepy ur making pinkie more creepier
0 likesIn a youtuber she has pinky sence and nkows when danger is coming pinky sence😎😎
0 likesThat song named Chocolate Rain
0 likesI actually had a theory (well, less theory and more head canon) that Pinkie sense is essentially a supernatural understanding of butterfly effects: she can look at any random occurrence and immediately know what it will cause. I dunno, it just helped me connect her chaotic nature and her apparent psychic ability.
0 likesI think Pinkie Pie may have adhd. I say not only because I have it, but because I notice behaviors she and I share. One example is during the episode Yakity-Sax when Pinkie gets rid of her instrument, she seems fine at first. However, we then get a glimpse showing exactly how upset she truly is. Whenever I feel upset being told I’m not good at something, it discourages me from being myself since I always seem so excited about it. In addition, we know that her friends constantly agree that she is a little strange, but I know that ppl think that about me too. We also got a glimpse of Pinkie’s past and how she earned her cutie mark. When she saw the rainbow it was like she was inspired to be herself. Maybe at some points during her childhood, she wanted to be her but stopped herself from doing so worried what others may think of her. The rainbow gave her that push she needed to be herself and it never changed the way others saw her. I hope one day I too am pushed by a rainbow to be confident of who I am. Well, a metaphorical one at least.
2 likesYou also gotta think about personality traits. Both Discord and Pinkie Pie have a certain randomness, especially if chaos(aka Discord) is attributing in a good way... Sounds awfully like Pinkie pie during her antics. Cozy glow can't relate in that way, so that's a way to explain that line of reasoning.
1 likeThere’s something that must have started the loophole, just like Future Twilight first wanted to tell Twi to not worry about her schedule, but then it changed into her worrying about the message Future Twilight sent (theory.). How did Pinkie even absorb the magic of this bell in the first place? Was she not the element of laughter, but a different element, and when the chaos corrupted her timeline, she turned into the element tif laughter? Or, did she turn into a villain and steal the chaos magic that then corrupted her timeline and bla bla bla
0 likesI think pinkie never had earth pony magic, but always had chaos magic, in a small quantity, allowing her to bend reality, but only a very limited sense. this also makes sense as pinkie was the only other entity to use chaos magic (although she lost control of herself to a degree, it was very different to how cozy glow's use backfired), meaning she might be chaotic enough to use the magic.
0 likesWhen comparing cosi to pinkie, think about... when cosi got discord’s magic, that plus regular pony magic was all that was there... but when pinkie was exposed to the magic not only discord’s magic and other regular pony magic was given too her, but also Luna and celestias magic as well, so when saying that... your theory makes sense sawtooth
0 likesThis confirms that earth ponies not only have a connection to nature but also has a connection to time itself since there are different versions of the Pinkie sense seen in other earth ponies.
0 likesThe last problem with Cozy Glow I can solve, Pinkie Pie absorbed Discord’s magic, while Cozy absorbed unicorn, earth pony and Pegasus magic.
0 likesI know this video is 3 months old, but I would like to point out another example as to why this theory makes sense. In season 7, episode 18 "Daring done?", she picks up one of Daring Do's artifacts, the artifact reacts differently than when its in Daring's hand. For pinkie, it glows brightly and has sparks coming off it, but when daring has it all of that stops. Idk, that just seemed interesting to me..
0 likesAuthors: Hm, let´s make this one horse crazy, why not.
0 likesSawtooth: So, she had this colision with chaos magig that offected her whole life but maybe not....
Sawtooth: Pinkie is always does random things,pulls out stuff out of nowhere and her pinkie sense is because she has bits of future memories in her from when she absorbed discord's chaos magic
0 likesCheese Sandwich: am i a joke to you?
she also could have done it herself as she had a limited but not impossible amount of control over the magic. sensing that she could lose it she may have infuse it within her across time.
0 likesHow about "Time Lord", going by all the contraptions she has access to in any off situation?
0 likesAlthough this theory could be true, if you remember when pinky was telling her background story. She could not pull anything out of the blue or appear out of nowhere, until the rainboom happened. If u remember the same kinda thing happened to Twilight. She couldn’t use her magic until the rainboom happened and she used her magic that no one else could do. Now not saying this applies to all of them but the Rainboom could have had affect on Pinky’s life and not event happening in the future
0 likesGuys I just had a revelation, Pinkie gets her magic from friendship. We’ve seen time and time again that friendship is magic, from hearths warming to the elements to the main six themselves, but nopony has as many friends as Pinkie.
0 likesExpand on this idea as you will, I was just rewatching season 2 and had a lightbulb moment.
Replies (1)
Yeah, but in that case then Applejack should be stronger than she is correct? She is the same type as pinkie and is friends with lots of ponies doing her business yet all she has is super strength you'd think Rarity would be the weakest since she is a fashionista and not the most likeable to some right?
0 likesGuess what I found out, u can use a gum wrapper(with the gum still in it) to scroll, cool right?
1 likePinkie may be the only other creature in Equestria that is able to use Discords magic. If you think about Queen Chrysalis said no one can control chaos magic and that was proven with Cozy Glow having a very hard time controlling the chaos magic, but when Pinkie absorbed Discords magic she was able to control it. She successfully made chocolate rain and balloons float behind her when she was massive. I also think that the reason why Pinkie may be able to control chaos magic is that Discord and Pinkie have similar tastes and interests. They both can use the same type of magic, but it would make more sense for Discord to use it. Even though he tried to take over Equestria several times he still knows when he draws the line. He makes pranks and gags that are more or less harmless to the other creatures around him, but when Pinkie had the chaos magic her first thought was turning the entire cosmos into icing.
0 likesI just thought of this; what if pinkie, along with getting Discords magic infused with her, also (accidentally) got a tiny bit of grogar’s magic as well. (I can’t be the only one who thought of this)
0 likesi actually noticed when the magic went into her forhead, but i thought it was an error because earlier that episode she ran off screen and came back with some pizza,and how would she do that without magica
0 likesReplies (1)
only Pinkie can pick up anything from of screen.
0 likesShe brought a cupcke from Maretropolis in Power Ponies?
"Pinkie Pie is the most confusing creature in Equestria."
0 likesAh, I see, so she's not a pony.
Replies (1)
She is the combination of all magics seen in the form of an Earth Pony.
0 likesIt is more Powerful, since there is no way of drawing her as anything more. Giving her wings or horn would merely detract.
..
What if pinky’s abilities to themselves was magic? What if pinky isn’t just a pony? After all, peering through time and space, and causing changes to the future that end up leading to the past... means she’s either doctor who or a part of Norse mythology. Btw, in Norse mythology, part of it is that the world tree represents the past, present, and future, and that water from above flows down below to nurture the tree. This is meant to show that somehow the future affects the past.
0 likesMy theory: discord and pinkie are quite similar, so what if discord’s past has something to do with pinkie, like in discord’s origins, he was a experiment, but what was experiment what did he start as? What if he was part of pinkie’s family, I mean both pinkie pie and discord both have two forms. Pinkie has deflated form and discord has grogard. But how did they get them? And plus, discord’s colour scheme matches with her family, but weirdly, pinkie doesn’t. And in her backstory, she started as a filly on a rock farm, but why did she look so different from her family, unless that wasn’t her family at all. And maybe it could be to do with discord. If so, maybe there is a piece of discord’s timeline that we missed. And if so, what is it? And could it be connected with Pinkie pie?
1 likeWell if that’s true.......
1 likeIf it messed up her whole past and her future what does that mean?
It means....
Discord and her would have to try to make friends like Discord did
so if it affected the past it does mean it affected her future
But there’s a slight problem....
It’s the connection between Chaos and Pinkie
AND THE BRAIN
no I mean Pinkamena Diane Pie
Pinkie Pie was born into a rock family when she saw the rainbow and made her go all happy and made her go all excited and ever since she saw a rainbow she gets excitement she’s always excited and the chaos that Discord has does not match that
And pinky getting magic whenever the magic was stolen she only got it back because
she has a different type of earth pony magic it’s more different
than a regular earth pony it’s only because her excitement
it’s what makes her
Well her
I a sorry to bring your theory to pieces, but there is one thing that changes everything. In Pinkie Pride Cheese Sandwich has a cheesy sense, and later on in The Gift Of Maud Pie, Rarity asks Maud how she knew that the guy with the party cannon was there, and Maud said, Maud sense, only later to explain, "it runs in the family." So, Pinkie didn't get it from future Pinkie, she got it from DNA. If it runs in the family, it would also mean that all Pies had it. Oh, and what about Cheese, how did he get his sense?
1 likeReplies (1)
I agree with you and I also still think she has magic that's not pinkie sense ( because pinkie sense is a genetic ), like how she can teleport sometimes and make party supplies out of nowhere and pull of amazing stunts that defy the laws of physics. I also think that she is connected to discord because of the bell.
0 likes0:21 sawtooth : i may have just solved pinkie pie
0 likesme: someone get the novel prize of the best theorist in the world please
"Is someone watching me?!"
0 likes-Sawtooth 2020
maybe the element of harmony amplified the effect of the chaos magic
0 likesI think I got it.Pinkie is in her earluly 20's,But cozy is a filly,Like twelve or something.Maybe the age has something to do with it,Like the older you get the more magic enters your past and future,or once you reach somewhere over twleve,that happens.
0 likesI don’t know if anyone said this already but I just thought of this:
0 likesWhat if in that one episode where there were a billion pinkies, they didn’t choose the right pinkie? What if they chose a different pinkie? I might be dumb but maybe that pinkie they chose was just trying to stay so she wouldn’t have to go back to the water.
Come back after watching Tenet, this video makes even more sense now
0 likesTo back it up when the unicorns got there magic back pinkie pie in the episode didnt seem like her funny annoying self it was like if it was on a 50% scale and not on a 100% scale.
0 likesIn the comics, Pinkie pie became the "Princess of Chaos" for a while, maybe that help make her body able to wield the chaos magic.
0 likesin an episode (not a serie one just side ones ) pinkie drinks a potion from her chaos take an new level and she can travel in time dimension and spaces (that episode was created by lauren faust so it is related ) she was more powerful then discord and twilight cause they cant travel time in the blink of an eye
0 likesOne question if she has chaos magic im confused whether she can control it or it just comes out
0 likesThere’s one thing I have to say that doesn’t make sense though because pinky only exorbitant magic after season eight and you’re saying that all that magic went all the way back to season one
0 likesmaybe she just is the way she is regardless of what or how she came to be in the future or present. but seriously she is WEEEEIRD
0 likesThere’s a hole in ur theory: you said that pinkie sense was bc of the chaos magic BUT when pinkie gets the present for maud and maud finds the pony that took pinkies cannon maud undoubtedly said “ maud sense” and pinkie said “... runs in the family”
0 likesADHD EVERYBODY SING IT WITH ME A-D-H-D
0 likesHonestly she represents me pretty well she is like the manifestation of the core of ADHD
Sawtooth waves - and they both do that thing when they stair in to space as if someone was watching them......... is someone watching me!
0 likesThat can’t be possible that chaos happened way before that moment
0 likesThe reason she got magic back is because under that Xtremely bouncy mane of hers THERE’S A HORN HIDDEN UNDER THERE! THATS THE REASON!
0 likesWait ... What about when cozy glow absorbed discords magic?
1 likeWait but what about Cheese Sandwich? He’s practically pinkie 2.0. Sure, Pinkie could have more of the.. uh.. craziness I guess, but Cheese is still pretty strong.
0 likesI solved Pinkie Pie years ago. ... THE WRITERS.
0 likesI know why Cozy glow did not get the consequences pinky pie did it's because she was an alicorn at the time and was powerful enough to hold the power in the one time
0 likes0:47 Pinkie Pie discovered her Gigantamax form!
0 likes1:50
0 likesSawtooth: Is someone watching me?
Me: y e s
No it's that she a pony pasta (creepypasta) but she just hides it meaning even if she always smiles doesn't mean that actually she's not always happy
0 likesThat would actually make sense.
0 likescozy was an alicorn at the time so maybe she could handle it and she did not use the chaos magic
0 likesI think that pinkie pie infusing chaos magic into herself is true because in the human world the duplicate of her is still chaotic but doesn't do any breaking the fourth wall things all she does is be goofy
0 likes1:13 HANG ON A SECOND I RECOGNIZE THAT BACKGROUND MUSIC!
0 likesI think she did I mean she liked it raining chocolate milk and that happened and all the sugary food floating around and the cupcakes in her eyes it was like she could control the chaos
0 likesYes Sawtooth someone is watching you.
0 likesI like the idea of Pinkie just being Pinkie, but your theary makes alot of sense...
0 likespinkie pie is the only creater in the mlp universe that can control the magic of discord there equaly chaotic
0 likesPinkie is that crazy from the beginning of the series and she Absorbed Discords Magic in the last season
0 likesMy theory is that she have the power of cartoon characters, yes
0 likestbh i think pinkie is the most powerful pony. ngl.
0 likesNo I don’t solved pinkie pie because that was season 9 and the creators most likely did not think sooo far ahead to why pinkie is pinkie so I don’t think she got those wired powers from that event the creators probably just thought it would be a good sense to season 9 but that does not explain why pinkie is like how she is but it’s just my opinion and you have your own opinion and I’m ok with that I love this channel but I don’t think pinkie is strange because of that 1 event
1 likeThe season 6 ( the gift of Maud pie) the part when Maud says: Maud sence .
1 likePinkie pie says: thats in the family.
Sawtooth Waves, Cheese Sandwich also has A Chessy Sense? So, the pinkie sense doesn’t explain anything, but if it did, could Cheese Sandwich have something too?
1 likeReplies (2)
In the PPSTD episode I think that’s how you spell it, rarity does what pinkie should be doing but pinkie is sad and can’t do it. Maybe any pony can do it if they have the right amount of energy?
0 likesHmm.. Good theory! It definitely makes sense
0 likesI think this is true cuz its the only reason to her pinkyness and the pink magic that she got when the spell was realised.
0 likesPinkie is a forth wall character.......their is no real logic behind anything she does.....it's there just for the heck it.....that's the best i can come up with where such characters are concerned anyways....they r made so the writers can do anything....just because they can...and it isn't made into a big deal because ....well in this case...it's just pinkie being pinkie right?
0 likesIf she had got those crazy powers after she absorbed the magic so how she uses her power in past because she absorbed discords magic in last season
0 likesJust the unicorns and the Pinkie Pie got magic
0 likesLol 🤣
Check out Death Battle. Pinky Pie vs. Deadpool. It ends the way you think
1 likeThe only losers the forth wall.
Makes no sense let me say something in the episode When Muad pinkie pie and rarity went to Manhattan muad Knew where the guy that gave pinkie pie the Rock holder and Raritysaid how did you know where the guy was and muad said muad Sense in Pinky said runs in the family
0 likesSawtooth : PINKIE SENSE
1 likeMe : *WHAT ABOUT MAUD SENSE ?? *
Me : Did maud get discord's magic too??
Sawtooth: is someone watching me?!?!
0 likesMe:yes a million people
This theory makes sense but...how did cheese sandwich get his powers?unless...
0 likesShe didn't get power from the emulet she was always like starting from the when she got her cutie mark she started acting like that
0 likesI think you should stop questioning pinkie pie I stopped ages ago..... and still haven't got an answer
0 likesI'm actually scared right now she has to do. Wall breakers I don't know?
0 likesBruh no one , LiTErary no one can solve pinkie pie 😂😋
0 likesFine theory but how do we explain cheese sandwich
0 likesNow when u said the part someone watching u know what I've been watching my little pony all over and all over again now I felt creep out-
0 likesPinkie pie is light my fav character, she’s sweet, and in bad situations she looks on the bright side!
0 likes💝🌸🌷🎀💕💞💓💗💖💘🩰🎟🍧🍥🍬🍭🍫🍕🍉🍓🍒🍇🌺🌹🦄👛👚👄👅🥳
Well she saw a rainbow from which she got these sence humour
1 likeMaybe party ponies have magic?-
0 likesPinkie just might be part draconoquis. Not saying she's related to discord but maybe another draconoquis.
0 likesWhat! That’s nuts in a good way😊
0 likesPinkie is the product of a crossbreeding between a fifth dimensional eldrich being and a sentient balloon.
0 likesI sort of agree but in that episode Were cozy glow stole magic.and we noetest she had magic.but when cozy glow had the magic pinkie was the same which means its not magic.
0 likesWait wait wait, I solve IT the right way, so pinky does not have magic it’s her personality, well I don’t if this is right but, pinky pie does not have magic, it’s her silly personality, well, I know it does not make any sense.
0 likesPinkie pie is just ✨Diffrent✨
0 likesI don’t even get how u can solve the biggest mystery.....
1 likePinkie
When pinky got chaosity ,it was AFTER cozy defeat
0 likesOne sec the villains did a spell to get the magic how did pinky get it?
0 likesOmg I want to meet the nameless one 😭😭😭😭
0 likes1:50 is someone watching me?
0 likesMe: yes
I pinkie kept the magic everything would be desserts 🍨🍩🍪🍰🎂🧁🍭🍬🍫🍮🍯🥮... ALL OF THEM. Also what about Cheese sandwich 🤔
0 likesI agree on the Chaos magic effecting Pinkie Pie past and you know thinking about it give me another idea about her strange magic and that is her cutie mark think about it never happened until Pinkie Pie got her cutie mark it’s not the first time we seen pony’s have powers with there cutie marks what If Rainbow Dash rainboom did more it gave her what I will call Party powers like Rainbow Dash gave her the power to do the rainboom and the others got special powers Twilight magic, FlutterShy talking to animals, Rarity and finding gems, and Apple Jack amazing bucking skills so Rainbow Dash could have gave Pinkie Pie her Party powers and the others special powers.
0 likesOMG I can't believe it!
0 likesMaybe she was born that way or the rain boom when the six all got their cutie marks
0 likesOk then explain why cheese sandwhich has CHEESY SENSE just like Pinkie has Pinkie sense.
0 likesShe has magic cus of her happiness
0 likesSo I was just thinking about the video and I think that cozy glob was ment to be evil and some how that change her
0 likesApplejack should have got magic back because she has too what if she lost her strength because of that 🙄 just saying well she should have
0 likesMaybe the magic in pinkie is pinkie sense?
0 likesBut when she got her magic back it was before c exorb chaos
0 likesWait how pinkie can control kaos?
0 likesPinkie pie is just having fun and just baking cakes and cupcakes :) party
0 likesthat makes seats
1 likemabye because choas magic likes choatic things like pinkie pie, Discords favorite
0 likesImpossible
0 likesHACKS CONFIRMED
I always wondered, why is pinkie pie pink if none of her parents are pink
0 likesI know how Magic wind Into pinky pie After the students Defeated cozy grove to Because of a pinky Senses I don't know the rest that's the only thing I know so that you have to figure on your own sorry I can't tell you anything else I don't know the rest
1 likePinkie is strange especially with her pinkie sense
0 likesit's obvious that SHE AND DISCORD ARE SIBLINGS!!!!! DUN DUN DUH
0 likesWait cozy glow was an alicorn when she took grogars bell maybe pinkie got magic cause she was an earth pony
0 likesAs if someone was watching them…IS SOMEONE WHACHING ME … um YES about 1000000 fans.
1 likewell pinkie is just being pinkie right?
0 likespinki got it because of the people that made the mlp vids made pinki like weird
0 likesI think that pinkie was an ex unicorn.
0 likescan you make a video called finally solving rainbow dash
0 likesor she's a looney tune. haha.
0 likesBut that happened in the future and she's Ben like these
0 likesOr pinkie is still the dark pinkamena Dian pie she was
1 likeLike their age and they're working mind
0 likesThis was right after my birthday
1 like𝕀 𝕥𝕙𝕚𝕟𝕜 𝕡𝕚𝕟𝕜𝕪 𝕚𝕤 𝕛𝕦𝕤𝕥 𝕥𝕣𝕪𝕚𝕟𝕘 𝕥𝕠 𝕙𝕒𝕧𝕖 𝕗𝕦𝕟 𝕘𝕚𝕧𝕖 𝕙𝕖𝕣 𝕒 𝕔𝕙𝕒𝕟𝕔𝕖
0 likesnow wait a minute this is like teen titans the episode called the forth wal
0 likesBut your right Maud sense and pinky sense are different
0 likesi think that why cozy glow is so amotinle is becows of the cayos magic just my thots
0 likes1:57 pokemon meme time
0 likesYes pinkie got it from that true u r the biggest genius
0 likesCan you have the same cutimark what would happen if you did
0 likesNah ur wrong in the begening she had her power she just being pinky
0 likesSOOO your saying what happened in the future is what was happening in the past
0 likesNoli I think she is unexplainable
0 likesI no matter the truth and you can make a decision and I can make you a good job and you can make it work
0 likesum so wait she can maybe warp to the real universe our universe multi universe or what imma make some my alicorn or maybe the god alicorn what is that god or maybe who is he or she can you upload a theory of it plz
0 likesmaybe pink is discourt family
0 likesYES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesyOU CAN NEVER SOLVE PINKY PIE SHES TO CRAZY AND she can break the fort wall and she is the most powerful pony ever OoOoOoo
0 likesbut she's very weird and cocoon
1 likeDiscord has discord sense and pinkie has pinkie sense I would say that to but what about maud sense
0 likespinkie pie has a sister maud pie and she also has senses like the pinkie sense pinkie pie said it runs in the family
0 likesMaud has Maud sense to
1 likewhat if this happenned because of the fact pinkie pies familly was sooo dull then she got her cutie mark because they drove her crazy and thats why she turned a lil bit crazy
0 likesooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Yes we are watching you
0 likesYOU ARE MAKIN MEH HIPERVENULATE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesPinkie pie did handle the caos magic better than cosy glow
0 likesYay and yes we are watching u your ON A VIDEO
1 likeI think look pinky is a party pony and on the video we’re cheese sandwich sang why is his cutie mark a cheese sandwich??? Anyways pinky I’d a party pony a party pony would go crazy and she laughed even if the tree was scary u know on the video when they are geting Luna back the time when they defeated nightmare moon
So that he pinkie pie telpotes pull party cannon out of thin air and has super speed
1 like1:51 Yes
0 likesHey hey why isn't Rainbow dash included just think about it she and her father have rainbow hair what about her mother and why is Rainbow dash the only one who can do the sonic rainboom and Fluttershy was so well shy until she burst out in applause whne she saw Rainbow dash do the sonic rainboom
0 likesya we are watching you-r videos 😂🤣
0 likesPinky Pinky Pinky you can song 😭
0 likesdiscord picture pinkie staring
0 likesWait what year is your cutie mark mean
0 likesHe thinks hes solved pinkie but the day that is o pinkies sens
0 likesOmg......just tell twilight..
0 likesI think pinky and discord are siblings from the same eag Yah both burn on a thaterday and maby someone toke pike in the futer
0 likesFeeling rainbow dash is Akikorn in sikres!
0 likesYes we are watching you why did you post this if you don’t want me to see it
0 likesI think pinkei and discord are siblings
1 likeReplies (1)
Fatima Noor Are you crazy? 🤯
0 likesOk, but are we going to talk about the fact she's the only other creature that could handle his magic properly in the first place?
1 likeEdit: This might be a paradox though, because you could say Pinkie could take in Discords chaos magic because she already had some, when she got it from taking Discords chaos magic, which she could handle since already has some when she got it from taking Discords chaos magic, which she could handle since already has some and you get the point.
Edit 2: at 2:15 when Pinkie got her magic, it isn't that insane pattern like Discords chaos magic. What if it's a whole new kind of magic? Party Magic. Hasn't Cheese Sandwich been shown to do similar things? What if the 2 of them have party magic?
Your fans are waching you; silly! # like, plot hole
0 likesPinkie pie has to have majic we all saw
1 like😍
0 likesBut cheese sandwich
0 likesLike fucking showed up in Fortnight when chapter 1 Island is going out with a bang
1 likeWhat is pinkies pies name was actually supposed to be this pie Bruh 0_0
0 likesPinkie is from difrend demantion .w.
0 likes😹😹😹😹😹
Why is floter shy and rainbow dash didn't get there power's
0 likesDONT TALK LIKE THAT TO MY FRIEND LIKE DAT!!! Oops sry -_-
0 likesPoor Pinkie pie
0 likesYou hade to Question that
0 likeswhat are you talking about maybe pinkie pie was born like that
0 likesdose pinkie pie have a brother?????
0 likesWho is princes celestial parents
0 likesWhat abt maud sense lol
0 likesThis is canon now nobody can convince me otherwise
1 likeYou’re crazy as are the bath I wish I can’t I don’t have my own high
0 likesPinkie Pie has weird things in her hair
0 likesIs somebody watching you yeah some people are watching you because you are on YouTube
0 likesO my thats true only bothe of them talk to the one that watched them
1 likeWhat about human pinky pie
0 likesPinkie crazy.
0 likesYes I’m watching you sawtooth get it like if you get it
0 likesNah I don't think so....
0 likescool
0 likesHey yo you on YouTube we all watching you
0 likesIs someone watching me YES 1000
0 likeswe r watching you
0 likesWhy do not solve pinky she is one thing that not should be solve like discord and technically since they have the same magic in there veins like the exact same magic like how family’s have the same type of blood
0 likesno because she is just pinki
0 likesWELL WE AINT NOT ORRRR CANT FIGURE OUT Pink pie NOW RIGT 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😒🙁😒😒😒😒🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁😞😞😞😞😞😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😭🤣😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😤😤😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
0 likesShe is funny ok
0 likesIts not pinkie who made me... me cry!
0 likesNew sub who this 😎
0 likeshow?
0 likes😲😲😲😲
0 likesI don’t know if I am a ep p u
0 likesFarfeche’d da Pokémon
0 likesShe is just her
0 likesit was pinkie sense
0 likesWe are watch you.
0 likesI think one reason that the chaos magic didn’t spread through Cozy Glow’s timeline is because at that time, there wasn’t any alicorn magic (Celestias’s and Luna’s magic) inside Grogar’s bell, but when Pinkie Pie absorbed the magic, there was the alicorn magic inside it too, and it was too much for her to contain in that moment and spread through her whole timeline
2 likesOn the Cozy Glow question, we see it almost immediately drives her mad with power. If we are to assume Chaos magic trancends time and effects your being completely, couldn't that explain her master manipulation and power hungry tendencies? After all, we're never given a real origin for her.
1 likeI definitely like the chaos magic theory, and I think that maybe chaos magic affecting people differently is the reason why it didn't affect Cozy Glow. The only problem would be that the first run of the timeline would have pinkie pie not have all of the craziness that made her Pinkie Pie, resulting in her probably not representing her element. Then again, time events never make sense, and a lot of things like this don't follow that logic flaw anyway.
0 likesI'm a little late to the party here but I'll throw in my two cents.
0 likesI've suspected for a while now that Pinkie's abilities were magical in nature. The detail about her getting magic back along with Twilight and Rarity would seem to prove that. I'm not sure I buy that it came from her interaction with Grogar's bell though. The point about Cozy Glow having absorbed Discord's magic as well is the key here. Cozy Glow absorbed the chaos magic but *could not wield it*. Pinkie COULD. That tells me that chaos magic was in her nature, regardless of her interaction with the bell.
i may be late but the interaction between chaos magic and harmony magic could be the explanation. harmony is described as balance and chaos unbalance however not many see that chaos is a tool of harmony to bring balance. if creatures evolved to be balanced within themselves and not the environment they either destroyed the landscape or died themselves. seeing as how pinkie is directly linked to harmony that harmony would need to balance chaos in a way that would keep harmony. sending chaos magic back and forth into time to keep balance could be the reason why she didn't temporarily become an alicorn. this would also partially explain why discord didn't fade when his magic was stolen from him, his magic causes him to fade if he is orderly.
0 likesthe question about how cozy glow wasn't affected has already been explained in one of these comments [at the time she was an alicorn and could handle it but pinkie was just an earth pony], so the chaos magic makes sense. plus it explains how when the magic had returned pinkie was also hit. BUT the one thing confusing me is that if pinkie didn't have that happen, she wouldn't have absorbed the magic. unless the loop of time just started when pinkie absorbed some magic, it doesn't add up. i can't really explain it in words- hopefully someone understands what i mean-
0 likesWait, I just had another theory. What if there are still pinkies throughout equestria from that season 3 Episode? What if there are still many pinkies out there spreading discord’s magic to other pinkies. Does that make sense?
2 likesWhat if pinkie the one who absorbed discord’s magic was the original pinkie, but she spread it to one of her clones. And with that magic, they could travel through time and have been since the beginning of the series. Either by finding it in the star swirl hallway in canterlot, or by some other Discord magic feature.
What if one of those pinkies traveled back in time and have been since season 1, and another one could’ve travelled to the human world and told the pinkie in the original world and that’s how she knew what happened to twilight when she traveled there for the first time. I mean, it does kinda make sense since equestria girls came out after season 3 and pinkie got all her clones in the 3rd episode of season 3. So basically, during that time, other pinkies could’ve absorbed that magic that another pinkie did in the future (season 9) cause it spread throughout her entire timeline and other pinkies as well. This was just a theory that cane out my mind but I guess we’ll never know the true secret of Pinkie Pie, unless Pinkie is just Pinkie...
While this idea is vary plausible, and would explain a lot. Through I don't think it goes as deep as you implied. While it does explain the moments were Pinkie could predict future events, and he fourth wall bracing ability, it doesn't explain why those specific abilities aren't an every day thing. The other aspect that you need to account for is Pinkies personal and willingness to embrace the crazy and weird. That could be the reason why she shows symptoms of it through out her life while Cozy didn't. And would explain how she was able to control Discords magic better then Cozy Glow too.
0 likesLeave it to the last episodes of the series to explain all the nonsense Pinkie has been up to since the beginning. A solid theory.
0 likesi honestly like to imagine that Pinkie could in fact control Discord's chaos magic
0 likesNah, I don't think that's true. When Cozy took it in, it didn't spread. Pinkie probably just had chaos magic in her when she was born, but not strong enough or very usable to be like Discord's. Maybe her family members have it too, splitting what little magic they inherited into small amounts that can only be used subconsciously. Maud can teleport, and all of the Pies seem to have 'senses.'
0 likesDon't forget Earth Ponies and Pegasi have their own kind of magic.
Just a theory (even tho it’s late)
0 likesCozy wasn’t effected as much as pinkie because she was already an Alicorn and using Grogars magic, which may have have stopped it from causing larger effects. also when the element toke away the magic from cozy, it may have also stopped any chaos magic from having the same effects.
Pinkie however was still pure earth Pony and although she represents an element, that’s still only one of them that connects to the others, so it would have a different effect than having all 6 used against her.
But again just a theory
Also this might explain Pinkamina
Like when discord started acting normal his magic and he slowly started to fade away, if Pinkie did keep some of his chaos magic and it traveled through her lifetime it would explain a similar thing with Pinkie.
So when she’s upset and not acting like her element, the magic starts to fade causing her to act differently (Hence pinkamina)
"Pinkie Pie has been one of the most confusing creatures in Equestria"
1 likeMe : Yeah... And the creepiest...
Great theory as usual, but when you mentioned her pinkie sense i thought about something....like what about maud sense? Even Cheese Sanwich mentioned having cheese sense
0 likesDidn’t someone said that only Discord could control chaos magic, so how would Pinky be able to? I think they are spiritually collected in some way
1 likeReplies (1)
Pinkie Pie can not just control it, but she ould extract it from the bell on her own.
0 likesGoing by all previous examples; the bell was intended to give magic to someone else, preferably by Grogar.
But, why should Pinkie Pie be bothered by such petty details?
”Is someone watching me?”
0 likesWell, sawtooth. Yes, through a screen we are watching you.
I feel like you’re right about pinkie, but the reason it didn’t effect cozy glow was because she’s not as chaotic as pinkie, Since pinkie pie is naturally chaotic the chaotic energy must have messed up her already existing chaotic energy.
0 likesactually, i do agree, and i do think it is an interesting concept. The netflix series (i think it was like, hill's hesidense? hills house???) spoilers ahead has the same thing. The girl sees a broken neck woman from time to time, wich its just her when she dies with a broken neck and revisitis her old self.
0 likesBut Sawtooth, what about the Pinkie in the equestria girls dimension? There is certainly no Discord or his magic in that dimension, or are you saying that because his magic is so powerful, it is spread across dimensions?
1 likeI strongly support this theory and accept it as cannon
0 likesi think its a mixture of discord's magic and the explosion of magic from the sonic rainboom which definitely contains magic since its where twilight got most of her's she was a very weak unicorn before the sonic rainboom
0 likesMaybe it didn't effect cozy glow because she tried to use it for something else instead of chaos. She tried to do something unrelated to chaos, pinkie on the other hand, well, I think you would know
0 likesI believe than because Discord was petrified that the magic of chaos found a new receptacle in Pinky. This magic was activated only when she got her cutie mark. Fun is Chaos in a good way.
0 likeschaos magic is chaos just like it says in the name so possibly when is affected Pinkie pie it affected all of her changing her past and future but actually making it so everyone remembers it as just Pinkie pie knowing everything but it didn’t to clozy because it’s pure chaos like you said we can’t expect it to follow a path on what it will do when someone beholds it. Also we only have one example of a creature being born with chaos magic,but two of someone taking it and using it. No not just using it,almost like there injecting it into their blood/soul (if it was her soul that could explain why she was given back magic back some magic could stay with her making sure it affects her past and future as well as her being)
0 likesIsn't Fluttershy's stare magic, or Rockhoof's strength?
1 likeYou: I think I think solved Pinkie Pie.
1 likeMe: I don’t believe you, no one can solve Pinkie Pie, it’s just Pinkie Pie being Pinkie Pie, don’t question and don’t even try to.
1. Pinkie Pie has being like that since the first MLP episode and at that time no one knew discord, ever since she made her first party she turned into who she is today.
2. Pinkie Pie is not the only one who breaks the laws of physics, you just showed an image of Twilight talking to Pinkie Pie literary floating without any wings, and almost everyone in the show.
3. Pinkie Pie knows stuff about other world because she travels through the portal there a little video about bloopers and there is a part that shows how Pony Pinkie Pie comes through the Canterlot High portal and the human Pinkie Pie goes to the portal where she came from and the Pony Pinkie Pie just pretends that nothing is wrong and keeps living her life happily in Canterlot.
4. I don’t think Pinkie Pie absorbed discord’s magic, she would have way more power and maybe even other abilities, the breaking laws of physics can be seen from anyone, Pinkie Pie it’s a special pony, a happy pony, she’s always full of energy and no one can figure her out so don’t try.
5. Still don’t believe you.
Jessica, age 7, says: "I like your videos and I agree with you. I think she did get that craziness from Chaos!"
0 likesMaud also has maud sense
0 likesShe can easily get to the pony she wants to go to. She knows the way. It happened in the episode The Gift Of Maud Pie.
Maybe when they gave cozy glow the magic they held some back because they still had trust issues if you look at there faces before and after they have the look of a knowing parent
0 likesMaybe that's why cozy is the way cozy is, maybe it's a time loop of chaos magic that made her the manipulative megalomaniac she is
0 likesMy theory has been that she was the offspring to two powerfully magical unicorns who wanted an ideal child. However, realizing that Pinkie wasn't a unicorn, they cast her aside. Hence why Pinkie was adopted by the Pie family.
0 likesReplies (3)
But she is a twin
0 likes@Dominique Fairclough I don't recall her being a twin, and there's a good amount of evidence that she could have been adopted. Either way, it's a silly, fun, fan theory.
0 likesKry Butterworth she said in Heartbreakers story . Her “twin” is her sister Marble Pie she said they were born just a few seconds apart but yeah it’s just fun
0 likesI just knowdist that when Cozy got the magic she couldnt control it, yet when Pinky did it seemed like she was in full control of it.....
0 likesWhat if pinkie pie is somehow, someway is like Discord? Like she’s chaostic and insane and then the fact that she knows random info and can brake the laws of physics on a dime- a lot like discord but more controlled, more held back or even less powerful
0 likesWhat if when cozy glow adsorbed the magic it stuck with her a little as well, maybe that is he reason she was able to become an alicorn in the first place. It affected her past and future.
0 likesWhen was there ever a problem with pinkie? How have i never heard about this?
0 likesHonestly pinkie pie is that one character that always breaks the fourth wall
0 likesTheory number 1
0 likesChaos magic:this happen in last episodes
Pinkie:starts from 20 years ago
My question is about cheese sandwich. He has cheese sense... so you explained pinkie sense because of absorbing discord’s magic but what about him
1 likeI always wondered why did pinkie just turn but when absorbing the magic from the bell and cozy glow grew big and celestia-like size, and pinkie didn’t turn into a alicorn
1 likeReplies (1)
She turn into the queen of chaos
0 likesPinkie Pie is my favorite character. I approve of Sawtooth's theory. Your welcome. XD (I'm kidding you don't need mah approval :P Love your channel! <3)
0 likesthere is this random short called "double rainboom" where Rainbow Dash wentto the Powerpuff girls dimension. But, Pinkie drank an enhancement potion where she could manipulate the multiverse!
1 likeIt's just pinkie being pinky don't question it. She is what makes the show interesting
0 likesOMG... It REALLY makes sense! :o
0 likesPinkie Pie has the same magic like Discord!!Ok let it be! BUT there's my theory.Pinkie has magic!! I DIDN'T noticed before I watch it.But (look carefully Pinkie Pie);even pinkie doesn't have magic she can say "Pizza Delivering"and held pizza!!where is that pizza come from!!And She can spring (when twilight holding the door)quickly without magic!!!NO Earth pony can't do!!Ok Pinkie and Discord have same magic ok! Then when Tirek absorb discord magic;discord's magic colour is look like purple and black!! But Pinkie's magic colour is Pink!!!SO Their magic are not the same I guess.But I think Pinkie's magic is just her love I guess!! You know It may be strange ! But she can make everypony joyful and cheerful!!That is why she has magic!!Her magic is only her love and making joyful things.The real magic is her Cutie Mark!!Even she has no magic but she can still do things that no Earth pony can't do and of course joyful things too.But when Starlight Glimmer took her Cutie Mark; she can't do anything joyful and cheerful!Because of that her magic is just her love of making joys.But even she has no magic but still can do jokes and joyful things if she has her Cutie mark! But her name is Pinkie Pie; you can't explain everything!!
1 likeWould you please make a video on the real reason behind night mare moon .See the theory goes like this
0 likesIf you remember the tale of the 2sisters was after Luna was banished to the moon celestia took in charge of both sun and moon if you think about it how did celestia get the power to reach the moon? although there are 2 explanations
Explanation number 1- after Luna was banished to the moon celestia use the elements of harmony to gain the power of raising the moon too
Explanation number 2 - celestia had the ability to raise the moon long before Luna was banished. Luna might have gotten to know that celestia had this power and become jealous and felt like a spare . celestia would have probably give in that position the Luna for raising the moon because she was her sister. this explains a lot and makes a lot more sense for Luna to become jealous of celestia and turn into a nightmare moon
I told you about this theory invite of you videos of yours. If you think me during make sense then please make a video about it
I know why pinkie pie could’ve had this happen to her and not just cozy glow because there’s also Celestia and Luna’s allegory magic in the bell with discord so I did see that happening
0 likesMy head cannon? Simple, Pinkie isn’t from equestria, she’s from beyond...
0 likesthe 4th wall!
When he said that sounds a little far-fetched and the picture of farfetch came on I started lmbo ( laughing my butt off )
0 likesWhat I think is that pinky will always be the best pony
0 likesSawtooth: is someone watching ME???
1 likeMe: yes I am!
okay,but can we talk about how pinkie's personality changes with her hair?like everybody gangsta untill her hair turns straigth lmao
0 likesTheory: pinkie is her own species
0 likesSawtooth waves: I SOLVED PINKIE PIE!!!!!
1 likeTwilight sparkle has joined the chat
Replies (1)
No, you can't solve Pinkie Pie, but what if she is (dis)solving you?
0 likesMaybe she’s connected to the tenth season?
0 likesThey need one anyways
maybe the cauos magic affected cozy diffrently because she was a filly and was going to be turned to stone so she had a smaller timeline for it to spread across? or maybe it has to do with the fact shes a pegasis
0 likesFun theory. I like the perspective-check at the end. Ur pretty gud.
0 likesYour channel is about you being a detective of mlp and solving everything about it. You solved Pinkie Pie, why don't you solve Apple Jack's cutie mark purpose?
0 likesShe definitely has her own magic. Not sure if its from the chaos magic though. The magic you see return to her is pink, after all. Not black/yellow/white/etc.
0 likesso, pinkie pulled a secret ending of henry stickmin?
0 likes“Is someone watching me!?”
0 likesAll 323k of us:yuh us who do you think you were talking to?
It’s all fun and games until pinkies hair goes straight
1 likeI’m glad you solved Pinky pie but I also have a theory a pony THEORY pinkie is a draconaqus she represents parties surprise party she’s surprising birthday party what she looks like any holiday party I don’t know any adult party when she’s very very weird any formal party like galas weddings anniversaries family reunions is when she’s very serious or sad any celebration like New Year’s Eve is how she remembers everybody kind of doesn’t make sense though It’s the only thing I could think of
0 likesMy little pony logic makes no sense somebody wakes up starts singing and they all know a dance routine somebody starts singing and suddenly there is a parade! I don’t think my little pony even has logic don’t get me wrong I love the show it is just...MY LITTLE PONY HAS NO LOGIC!!!
0 likesBeing inherited to her kids lol
1 likeSawtooth Waves:Is anyone watching me? Me:Yes probably half the world is watching you
0 likesGreat. Now there are 2 chaos spirits.
0 likesif her hair is strait shes insane
0 likesthis dud my childhood
0 likesand i found him again.
Somebody remembers that in the first episode when discord appears he mentioned that pinkie was his favorite?
0 likesReplies (1)
he did? wonder why?
1 like"Takes one, to know/recognize one!"
Wait i will clear your cosy glow when pinkie consumed the magic look at the background everything has balloons this and that which means that pinkie used a lot of the magic but cosy glow did nothing but pop out pineapple 🍍 monster 👹
1 likeOr somehow when Discord was a baby somehow his mom had a little daughter Pinkie Pie but she couldn't raise two kids so she gave Pinkie Pie off to a rock Farm as soon as she was born so does carbon have no idea that there are actually related that explains the chaos Magic
0 likesTheory:Pinkies "magic" (ability to get a cutie mark) was to overpowered and when she got discord's magic it powered up that overpowered cutie mark magic and spread it throughout her whole life and she became the pony she is kinda like your theory
0 likesReplies (2)
But are you trying to say all party ponies are overpowered and plus what about her family they have some of her abilities eg maud pie she can teleport is super fast and strong and has maid sense among others
0 likes@Dominique Fairclough no,im saying her magic inside of her to get her cutie mark was too strong and could easily be activated by a rainbow and discord's magic and make her the random pinkie she is
0 likescozy was an alicorn and pinkie was just a pony so she couldn't handle all that magic unlike cozy
0 likesPinky is the pony who made parties so i know that pinky has magic but to party she is the only party pony girl in the first season 1 so she has party magic but not a princess
0 likesCheese Sandwich l’s existincw implies this is just a rarer form of earth magic. If all earth magic only helped with farming and surveying they’d be pigeonholed as a race. The cakes have implied cake magic so it’s just one of those things
0 likesi think pinkie is a unicorn because she has the power to teleport and stretch out and i bet a unicorn has a spell to do that.
0 likesI thought If pinkie pie still had discords magic wouldn't she be a unicorn?
0 likesMaybe cozy glow is more powerful
0 likesThe magic was stolen before pinkie absorbed discords magic so thats not true
0 likesSawtooth:I just solved pinkie pie
0 likesRainbow dash:And you live?
Wow this guy/the channels owner has eagle eyes
1 likemy theory:
0 likesshe is god
I wonder if pinkie pie is discord and he was caged in pinkie pie’s brain and one day he came out
1 likeWell,Moade has moade sense
0 likesPinkie pie is breaking the fourth wall and everything she does I KEEP SCREAMING AT HER TO sToP
0 likesYou give such such a look reading darklord
1 likeMaybe it's like part of Her special talent Cuting mark magic maybe it's part of that maybe that's why she so he's pulling like party cannons out of nowhere in and killer parting and evening and in season 8 in the 1st showing season 8 she says not even that teeny canning and she Pulls out at the
0 likesIt's Radvile not Edmundas but I have question. What about Mood? Or... Is it Maud?.. You know Pinkie's sister. She too has a sense. Am I saing that right?
0 likesDude she can break the fourth wall don't question it it means the human world
0 likesWait can I tell you something might be an alicorn Pinkie pie can be an alicorn but then again what about Twilight and it's true to an alicorn so like is it impossible cuz there's been lots of fairies like the tanks you know cakes like Pinkie pie have always been a main character but not the really meanest character so sure she might be an alicorn but there's other things behind that fire and marble it's just you know different about them if they're yellow hair yellow hair
0 likeswas friendship is witchcraft right after all?
0 likesi THINK THAT YOU FINALLY SOLVED PINKIIE
0 likesSawtooth- is someone watching me
0 likesMe- duh this is a video
I think that is sprinkle magic 😋😋
1 likeYa'll remember how discord shakes when sense's danger and pinkie pie shakes too when sense's danger maybe tha magic of chaos did spread in her??
1 likeReplies (1)
consider the oposit, and the reverse connection too.
0 likesbut, what if there were to pop up Chaos Ponies left and right?
s this why they shut down the show?
she has magic
1 likeit affected pinkie pie because she's not supposed to have magic.
0 likesI have watched all episodes and this episode is almost the last one so
0 likesBut... Pinkie isn't turn into an alicorn when she got the magic
0 likesI think the bell is the cause cause the bell May have different effects om different types of pony types
0 likes‘Is someone watching me?!?!’
0 likesMe: Yes we all watching you
(this is my mum’s acc)
Wait can pinkie pie tell the future of mlp? 🤨💅🏻
1 likeThat will be weird and cool lol
Or
Pinkie and discord are the same person 😳💅🏻
Or
Pinkie is just crazy... 🤨💅🏻
Or
Ok bye 🙃💅🏻
That's my Pinkie.
1 likeIs someone watching me?
0 likesproceeds to look at camera
“Is someone watching me”
0 likesYt: yes yes we are
I think she got her magic when she saw the rainboom she got her Cutie Mark and also her smile and magic
0 likesDoes anyone remember when this was called bronynotion? Oh just me? Yeah that was like five years ago
1 likeReplies (1)
Ya, me as well tho I don't remember following
0 likesTwilight: watche's This video
1 likealso Twilight: HOWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW
He’s not lying I went back to bed episode pinkie pie did get power back it was unbelievable I couldn’t believe it
0 likesIf pinkie kept that magic the WORLD would be chaos-
0 likesHim: is someone watching me?
1 likeMe: yeah dude or you wouldn't have 322k subs
But if pinky got her pinki sence through discords magic how comes that cheese sendwitch has a cheese sence ? Source s4. Ep 12 pinkis stolz
0 likesalso, no being could handle discords magic'
0 likesPinkie: Frick it I create my own rules
0 likes1:47: THX INTENSIFIES
0 likesPinky pies magic is her happiness and joy
0 likesI have a question y do discord have chaos magic but y didnt he grow up like pinkie when she absorb discords magic?
0 likesYou missed something out. Why didn't fluttershy and rainbow dash get the magic sparks? after all, they have their own unique abilty, the sonic rainboom and stare either animation error or these abilities arent magic..?
0 likesWhat episode does Pinkie Pie steal his magic
0 likesGetcher hoofs off my Ponka!
0 likesThey should make pinky pie a alicron
0 likesBecause she will be princess of chaos 😂😂
I don’t Think that pinkie pie has power 🤔🤗
0 likesHow old is starlight in one video she said she is 732 can you please like explain us
0 likesO SHIT you’re right 😨😥
0 likesCozy whatever did get the magic but she’s has wings it’s probably something to do with that pink girl is just a horse
0 likesRemember that joke about pinkie having adhd what if she does
0 likesJe...sus...Christ.
0 likesI think you're but at the same time I don't due to the fact Cozy glow doesn't receive the same randomness as Pinkie does.
let the shipping start!!!1
0 likesSawtooth pinkie switch from th mirror serveral times thats how she knows everything
0 likesWhat about cheese sandwich he also has the sense thing
0 likesIt can also be that pinkie pie has a long sibling that she doesen’t now and is a unciorn and pinkie pie have the same power but are not a unciorn
0 likesYes someone’s watching you.......a thousand ppl are!!!!
0 likesbut what about when she was younger she didn’t do that
0 likesIf its about pinkie sense How about cheese sand which sense?
0 likesEven if this tearoy was not true it still would explain why pinky got her magic when apple jack and rainbow dash and fluttershy did not
0 likesSo you have chosing the death
1 likeNah she is hiding a horn in her hair
0 likessomeone talking about me and my best friend: 1:36
0 likesI am a biiiiiiiiiiiiiiig fan of my little pony and you of course
0 likesPinkie is full of the chaos.. all da time
0 likesThat is so real
1 likeThey did specifically say cozy could not control it where as pinkie could.
0 likesAt the end of Equestria girls pinky pie which’s places with the human pinky maybe they which all the time and pinky got some kind of power from the portal cause she goes tho it so often??
1 likeYes someone is watching you I'am watching you
0 likesTWILIGHT SPARKLE WOULD LUKE TO KNOW YOUR LOCATION
0 likesWhat if pinkie pie was discords daughter
0 likesBrony : is someone watching me
1 likeMe : .........duh your on YouTube
Replies (1)
It's updated
0 likesif Pinkie pie has new kind of crazy magic than why isn't she an alicorn
1 likeReplies (1)
That’s what I’ve been thinking forever from what I’ve seen she is at least princess celestial or twilight level and has all the qualities even tho a little unorthodox in her ways.
0 likesWhat if pinkie is not a pony because well just think about?
0 likesclosy glow is a allicorn
0 likesWow good poin :3
0 likesPinkie is my favortie pony
0 likesPinkie has a trail that rainbow has
0 likesFind the episode that pinkie gets mad
It’s a CARTOON
0 likesWait look at pinkie pie cutie mark when she was holding the bell
0 likesMaybe she herself is chaos
0 likesPinkie pie is unsolvable
0 likesHow do u know this stuff it's cool but how do u know
1 likeOh my godddddd!!!
0 likesya it is pinky pie 🥧
0 likeswhat about maud sense? doesnt maud have it too.
0 likesThe rainbow blast
0 likesIt's 2020....
0 likesPinkie pie is crazy but I like pinkie pie 🎈
0 likespinky is pink. ok?
0 likesCan you do a comment reading pleeeeeeeas😇🥺🥺🥺
0 likesPinkie being pinkie
0 likesNo offence but I dis agree it's just that she likes to party and she is happy plus lets face it its pinkie pie we talking about if this was twighlight sure BUT SRSLY ITS PINKY
0 likesYes I am watching you
0 likesMaud sense
0 likesThis is way too much pinkie
0 likeswhy do you have to solving these thing, it's just...mlp...and hasbro?!?
0 likesReplies (1)
@Summer Sparkle have you reply me?????
0 likesSo in the other time you. Said that discord is the only derquanaqweast you lied no efwens
1 likeHow to become an alicorn n your videos?
0 likesi have a culu pink pinkie pie is mary is that pony lost her lahfter
0 likesYEA
1 likeWait.... cozy glow turned into alicorn but pinky didnt....
0 likesyes were watching you
0 likesYou watch pokemon what's your favorite pokemon
0 likesPinkie is all .
0 likesHow its pinkie pie can contorl kaos magic hhhmmmmmm...
0 likesWait why did only cozy become an alicorn and not pinkie
0 likesYes there is some one whating you
0 likesIgnore that message
0 likesi am like younger then you
0 likesNein Magi
0 likesPinkie is just pinkie
0 likesWhat about pinkie sense
0 likesyou also know farfetcd pokemn
0 likesomg
0 likesDass ich Magie
0 likesWhat the-what are you even you saying today?
0 likesPinkie sense UwU
0 likesAm watching you 👀👀👀
0 likesWe are watching u
0 likesNo one silly!
0 likesIs pinkie pie always like that
0 likesTexas, can ewe
0 likespinkie is just beeing pinkie du
0 likesPinkie pie is gone
0 likesOr maybe her magical power is 4th wall breaks. That would explain how she knows things before they happen, is able to teleport from scene to scene, and is able to talk about events from equestria girls despite it being in an entirely different universe. That would also explain why she takes pinkie promises so seriously, bc she knows that if certain things don't happen a specific way, it could result in disaster. Being able to break the 4th wall also would explain her carefree personality. She already knows what will happen and how to get the outcome she wants... so y worry? these 4th wall breaks can also come in the form of visions in her dreams. What if princess luna gave her visons of different dimensions? Maybe its not chaos magic after all.
2 likesThis actually makes perfect sense to me. Up until this I always just excused Pinkie's behavior as typical cartoon logic, plus in realm full of magic it made some sense.
0 likesBut this theory actually makes the nonsense make sense!
However there is one question I have about it.
When Tirek first took over in the show, we saw him drain the magic from everypony, including pegasai and earth ponies.
Pegasai made sense a bit cause it drained their ability to fly, but what did it drain from the earth ponies then?
If this is correct, then it makes sense that she had magic drained then, but what about all the other earth ponies?
Actually, I think we do have some slight evidence that Cozy Glow's past was effected by the influx of Discord's Chaos magic. Consider this... what causes a simple pegasus filly to go full Sociopath? I'm not buying that she was innocent in the beginning of her appearance. I am pretty sure everything she did at the School of Friendship was for the sake of sewing ruination. While she may not have gained powers in the past, as such, she DID gain the mindset for causing Discord and Disharmony.
0 likesMy theory is that the purpose and different type of pony handle the chaos magic differently.
1 likeCozy turned into a she demon because she had evil intentions and Pinkie simply just grew bigger and wanted to turn the cosmos into food because well, Pinkie loves food.
I think it would make sense that pinkie, even without the chaos magic, is predisposed to have more capacity to control chaos magic because of her other intrinsic characteristics. After all, she does represent the spirit of laughter, so perhaps chaos and laughter are distantly related. After all, laughter is a result of the unexpected, and chaos is also a subversion of expectations based on our previous experiences.
0 likesMaybe the reason it didn’t affect Cozy Glow is because she wanted to use the chaos magic for something it wasn’t meant for. She couldn’t control it at all. But Pinkie at least accepted the chaos and wanted to use it for chaotic things.
1 likeFinal conclusion: Pinkie can do anything. Nothing suspicious.
1 like....the fact that she predicted all that happened in the human/pony world calling it a hunch....
Just one slight question: What chaos entity did Maud absorb the powers of?
0 likesHmmm... I agree. I also have something to add. Maybe pinkie was supposed to have grey skin and a droopy mane like the rest of her family, but when the chaos affected her life her mane became poofy and changed her skin color. I don’t really have evidence for the color change, but for the mane I do. You know when twilight took in all of the princesses magic? Well for a second, having that much magic made her mane flow just like the royal sisters. So when filly pinkie got the chaos magic, her mane went from droopy and dull to poofy and out of control. (Much like chaos) I also would like to say that the sparkles that form every now and then on the royal sister’s mane, might Be shown in the form of the lighting sparks that can be seen in the very moment pinkie took in all of that chaos magic. Another thing I want to point out is that when the sisters lost their magic, their manes stopped flowing. So this is proof that magic can be shown physically like how pinkie had a color and mane change. 😯 this is a cool topic.
0 likesWhat if what we were watching when we were following the series was the “2nd run” of the whole timeline and the first one changed so much that if we were watching the first, both pinkie and the way friendship would be presented would be different in many ways... and maybe on that first run when she got that dose of chaotic magic she couldn’t control it very well but since it was the second time with the magic, maybe she was able to control it more
0 likesAs someone mentioned, Pinkie's "sense" runs in her family so most likely inherited.
2 likesReplies (1)
what if there was a male Pie, to pair the Mares with and see what came out?
0 likesI think the difference between pinkie and cozy is this.
0 likesCozy was an alicorn at that time, making her used to large amounts of magic.
Pinkie is a earth pony at that time, making her not used to magic, especially large amounts of it.
this actually a perfect theory, no holes... thanks to the comment section. Sawtooth did it again. Never stop making vids
0 likesThe reason why chaos magic didn’t spread throughout cozy glow’s timeline is because she only had chaos magic and 1/3 grogar’s magic
0 likesBut pinkie pie had discord,celestia,luna and all of grogar’s magic so that’s why it spread throughout her timeline
That's... actually a decent theory. I could see it working. Kinda like Clara from Dr. Who in a way...
0 likesThis theory is amazing, but if we go bad and look at the PSSD episode, there is a Maud sense. And pinkie said that it runs in the family. So there is "Pinkie sense", "Maud sense", and if it runs in the family, all the family members have their own sense. So, pinkie sense might not be the evidence.
0 likesShe could also be part unicorn, in the brief shot of Pinkie and Cheese Sandwich’s children her older foul is a unicorn, which means one or both of them have unicorn blood. Considering both seem to share similar characteristics (pulling things out of nowhere, having some foresight) it’s possible both have latent unicorn magic.
0 likesI think this theory is true in fact when I watched the episode where he is exhausted some of discord is Power I would, I was cooking up a theory quite similar to this but it wasn't really coming together but I think you have solved it so yeah🤗
0 likesis there a theory on why twilight got big like celestia at the end of the show even tho cadence and luna never got that big? might be connected to how both cozy and pinkie got bigger when they absorbed powerful magic (size correlating with magical ability?)
0 likesI thought immediately during that moment "oh, it's cuz Pinkie has chaos magic too!" but this makes so much sense.
0 likesOne thing I want to tell you! It would not be possible that she got her powers from the bell, the episode of the chaos pinkie was AFTER the pinkie senses. She already had it when pinkie absorbed the bell
0 likesYou cant "solve pinkie pie." All you can do is accept that you will never truly understand her and that's okay.
0 likesWhat if the reason cozy didn’t get effected too bad was because she shared the magic with the other two? Splitting it equally. Pinkie was the only one who took hold of the bell while the three villains had it go to them all at the same time while in battle. The villains also had Bad intentions while pinkie was being pinkie. Her chaos is different from evil chaos. Needless maybe discord also was changed after. Discord never said anything about him being sick before the episode “three’s a crowd” maybe him being evil protected him. Like when cozy was cold she wasn’t thinking too evil like the others. Once she did she ditched the blanket she had. Discord could of been the same. So since pinkie wasn’t planning on doing bad it gave her stronger magic. (But bad chaos comes before good chaos so it could of been doing it’s job doing something evil then being okay but I don’t think that’s right.) discord also seemed to take on the job of the elements being able to turn pony’s to stone. Before he could of done that with the two sisters but he couldn’t since the elements didnt let him before he was good. I think the first magic spark from the friendship of fire was able to help guide the pillars to plant the elements even though the elements already existed. The elements existed through the pillars then when was planted turned into artifacts. But when planning to be destroyed they gave their power of turning people to stone they gave it to the next best thing. Someone who represents all the creatures. When they channeled it to him he felt this new power and used it for good. Like the elements had done it before in the past. The elements them selves could of been stuck in a loop then they changed the destiny using the spirit of magic. But back then it still looked like twilight since twilight looks nothing like her parents the elements used their baby as the element of magic and why is made the mane six the colors of the rainbow (pinkie being the pastel red since they’re in pastel colors) the elements changed history. They were stuck and didn’t like it so they made both the main six and discord. They made the mane six to hold their other power that ponies couldn’t do. Discord for their other powers and that’s why discord doesn’t fit the normal species he is. The student six was what they used to make the loop end and take the focus off the artifacts and onto friendship. While it’s true cozy didn’t go crazy but that’s what the elements intended on happening but didn’t expect pinkie to grab the bell. When she did the spirit of magic was confused and gave pinkie her power of pinkie sense because it gave her its plan but not fully designed. So it gave pinkie the other realms if created by accident. Which the small sparkle of power went into pinkie nose is because she puts her nose where it shouldn’t be while rarity and twilight had it go to their horns.
0 likesSorry for the long comment
Believe it or not the first ever episode of my little pony was a story kind of beginning so it would make sense if the timelines were already the plan for the future
0 likesyou’re probably right. cozy’s timeline wasn’t affected because she was an alicorn when she absorbed discord’s magic and she was powerful enough to handle it??
0 likesIt made me laugh when he said “ is someone watching me”
2 likesBut Maud had Maud sense. Pinkie said that it ran through the family. Maud was able to easily find the guy Pinkie sold the cannon to.
0 likesFor the people asking how that crazy thing effected human pinkie, the answer is: it didn't, human pinkie doesn't defy fisics, she just knows about pony pinkie, because pony pinkie and human pinkie, switch through the mirrors.
0 likesYou can't explain pinkie pie, she's pinkie pie!
1 likeThat's a pretty good theory
Sawtooth I have always wonderd why only discord is able to use chaos magic acodingly and without going nutts like it did with pinky and coasy glow or when tirek accsidentally made bunch of rubber chicken appear instead of exploding the wall. Is it because chaos magic is so complicated and unpredictable to Control that it takes very long time to master it or is it just that because discord is creature of chaos he has some kind of subconsious sense to understand how chaos magic works and that way is only one who is able to use it acordingly and in it's full extend?
0 likesDoes that mean that having Discord's chaos magic makes you aware of our reality?
2 likesDude, that reminds me about what happened to Monika in DDLC-
Replies (1)
Just Monika.
0 likesThat would explain why she was so different from the rest of her family!
0 likesNah, its just those amazing cupcakes she makes. I wonder if shes hiding any secret ingredients in those pastries...................................
0 likesWould that mean that cheese sandwich has also had chaos magic as his ability’s are very similar to pinkie pie’s? It seems very unlikely so I don’t think pinkie’s powers come from discord’s chaos magic
0 likesI had a feeling discord and pinkies chaos powers were connected someway somehow it’s there too similar So I’m not that shocked although I’m glad someone finally put it out in the public especially you
0 likesSawtooth you are amazing I think you truly have solved pinkie pie
0 likesyou just solved the greatest mystery of man kind
0 likesHere’s something weird pinkie knew how to control discord’s magic while cozy glow didn’t.
0 likesThis kinda beats with Discord = chaos and Spirit of harmony = harmony since all of them are spirits (the mane 6) cause how can you possibly have harmony and chaos in the same body? Come to think of it how can there be a spirit of harmony if the mane 6 are already spirits of harmony
0 likespinky is a party poney and everyone saw pinkie pie play 10 musical stuff and twilight said " its just pinkie"
0 likesso maybe when she came to a party pony that made a BIG difference. Even tho she can shake our view and tell what is happening in other worlds
It may have something to do with Discord himself taking Pinkiey's powers, as a friend, while Cozy Glow wanted to get rid of it.
0 likesIn the equestria girls bloopers, pony pinkie and human pinkie went through the portal to swap places, which explains her strange knowledge.
1 likeThis is probably too accurate...
1 likeSawtooth: I may have solved pinkie pie...
0 likesMe: wait, this is BIG!
Pinkie Pie cannot be 'solved,' mortal. Pinkie Pie is..beyond your changeling understanding. Nobody on your plane of existence can understand. Perhaps one day you will. We make no promises.
0 likesbut if pinkie sense was from discords chaos magic pinkie took in at that moment then in season 6 episode 3 pinkie said that maud also had maud sense. Is it possible that when pinkie pie got all that chaos magic that affected her whole timeline it also connected to her family? That's confusing.
0 likesi think that cozy glow also had the same exprience like think about it why did cozy turn evil ? well idk, but maybe, the same thing with pinkie the one moment of cozy glow when she absorbed that magic it affected her past turning her evil just like pinkie so only discord can have his magic not any creature else thats what makes fluttercord i mean discord special and thus this can be true and sawtooth theory may be right and the 2 ponies [cozy,pinkie] can be explained
0 likesOK I know this moment in the series was just a joke referencing the older MLP art style but this IS another way that Pinkie managed to interact with time - https://youtu.be/eIo9UXSaxFI?t=115
0 likeslol
what about cheese sandwich's cheesy sense? How do you explain that?
1 likeWell when discord regains his magic he doesn’t grow maybe when a creature gains magic it spreads out differently for different creatures
0 likesMaybe its earth pony magic but its extremely powerful
1 like2:14 HOW DID I NOT NOTICE THAT!!!
1 likewelp time to look back and see it for myself
this is just a thought but what if pinkie was adopted by the pies? i mean look at her skin and her hair she looks noting like her family, and i know that at the start when she was a kid she did look " dull " but imagine your the only one in your family with such a piculuar skin tone and she somehow has magic in her blood, so maybe her bialogical parents, relatives, siblings etc have come from some kind of powerfull lands like where the alicorns come from and her parents probably died when she was just a baby. im not sure but that my theorie
1 likeYeah your right. But Cozy got Discords power too but we didn't see her doing something crazy. Someone saying it's because Cozy is an alicorn. But it's posible if Cozy alredy has chaos magic.But alicorns doesn't have chaos magic so i don't think Pinky got her powers from that moment.
0 likesi dont think they were thinking of season 9 when they made season 1...
1 likeMy theory:pinkie was suposed to be a alicorn but she got affected by discords magic unleashing herself to loose it somehow being crazy all her life so when she was born discord was there and when pinkies parent's left the room discord made her hold that evil thing to give her magic affecting her future if pinkie was alicorn she'd be princess of happiness or partying but most likely being happiness cause she brings people happiness if they are sad straight away so thats why pinkie bugs her friends with being crazy all the time and got replaced by twilight the main six somehow put up with her and her weirdness for example when pinkie was depressed she was all dark and there are other theories saying "pinkie is a murderer behind the sences she turns her friends into cupcakes" or "she steals there cutie marks" or mabye the 3 princesses inclueding twilight know pinkie has mental disorders but hides it from everyone or shes a traiter to the ponie town and so on but she got so conected to the ponie town that she stayed until she woukd betray the town and her friends she was depressedas a kid probably cause of that evil magic
0 likesBut Pinkie said that the “ sense ” things runs in the family ( I don’t exactly remember which episode though) like the Maud sense sooo ya.
0 likesI think she is just a earth pony with some interesting characters.
0 likesChotlate rain from pinkie pie when cozy glow took all magic away when the mane 6 her magic is from her brain I think she was like that from the bell I think some didn’t get out so case solved
1 likeIn the video ask pony's pinkie pie had wings on her hair and she was a unicorn which makes her an alicorn but that makes sense because if she was bouncing and pulling off tricks and possible maybe she was using magic or rather flyiy
0 likesBut in one episodes they told that in Pinkie's full family had Pie-Sense
1 likeSHE IS A CHANGELING she makes people love her she is able to bring other effects she makes holes in time yes or is she discord creation😱
0 likesWhy do we need to solve Pinkie Pie??? 🎉 🎈 🎊
0 likesu forget about maud sense.
0 likesand i think the reason that cosy glow isn't crazy
is because she is an alicorn,
sort of LOL
and because pinky like this magic and traped some of it in her, for her entire timeline
pinkie can control discord magic?it looks like she did it
0 likesThat's a good theory but I think it could just be Pinkie
0 likesI think pinkypie is a alicorn and her horn is hiding under her hair and she accidentally cast an unknown spell on her horn which made it thin as paper or she accidentally cast an unknown spell which makes her horn invisible or made her horn vanish into thin air ( same with her wings)but she is still able to use her horn and is secretly the princess of good chaos .
0 likesbut what about cheese sandwhich? they're practically the same
0 likesi wonder.. could pinkie just be, like, discords sister or something, but she just always keeps her pony form??
0 likesCake for the Pink God!
0 likesFrosting for the Party Throne!!!!!
Okay but can you explain cheese sandwich’s cheesy sense
0 likesyes this makes a lot of sence
1 likeMaybe she a unicorn and has a spell to hide it😱
0 likesThis Theory makes sense but I think it’s pinkie pie being pinkie pie because if you think about it all this magic stuff makes no sense in the human world but pinkie pie acts pretty much exactly the same as pony pinkie pie I don’t think someone took the bell into the human world and gave it to the human pinkie pie for 20-30 second than took the magic right back and without anyone noticing but who knows maybe that’s just want happened
0 likesVideo: Finally Solving Pinkie Pie
1 likeMe: Wait, that's illegal.
Replies (1)
Omg XD
1 likehim (Im too nervous to say da name): is someone watching me?
0 likesme: you break the fourth wall all the time..... why are you asking.. WHY
It's just a show, there for pinkie is just pinkie.
0 likesMaybe they were going to give magic to all the ponies but then got lazy🤷
I think Pinkie pie is the mad hatter but in pony form. 😀
0 likesI'm with you sawtooth
0 likespinkie knows about the dimention because she swichs with the other pinkie.
0 likesi know because i saw it in a mini movie
😑
wait a minute cozy tried to use discords magic but it fail every time she tried to break something nothing hapen but when pinkie pie pick the caos magic she used and didn't fail
0 likesin fact she use the magic like discord like she sumon a cake from nowere
I think she was just born with these abilities
0 likesMaybe discord’s magic made cozy glow evil?
0 likesSawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?!
1 likeMe: Everybody
Edit:Get it?
Edit 2:I do
That is a good way but I believe that pinkie is adopted because when you adopt the baby changes last names.pinkie is more excited and proud and loves everyone but with the rest mod pie she is a chill person. I have one more thing to add pinkie is pink all over and the pies are either gray or a Gary is purple and white
0 likesMaybe pinky is chaotic good discord is obviously chaotic neutral and if you think about it cozy glow could very easily be chaotic evil
0 likesWell said she is Pinkie Pie and she is the element of laughter that means well she's naturally strange in that is her magic
0 likesI also solved Pinkie Pie.👍❤😄
1 likeI think that she has magic is Because she must has a hiding horn in her hair
1 likeyou can nevver solve her loll mom i got my craziness from mom bcs in school i actually get my party cannon and made a surpise party for 4 minutes bcs our teacher got back from vacation- thanks mom (pinkie)
0 likesShe get her magic there and affected her time life
0 likesSolving pinkie pie is impossible.
0 likesMaybe her parents were magical
0 likesShe did not get it craziness from the chaos magic
0 likesI never thought of it that way
0 likesThe real thing thats bugging me is how did cadence be a alicorn pls tell me ......how is pinky so energetic do u think its bc of all the cakes mabey she should live in a non cake house
0 likesI think she did get magic from Discord
0 likesyou should play the game of MLP that their is a character named chaos princess that looks like
0 likespinkie pie that is an alicorn
The reason why Cozy glow Is different then pinkie pie it’s because that she Only took the Discord is magic pinkie pie took discord Magic and the princesses magic
0 likesI think Pinkie Pie is secretly an Alicorn or a unicorn. She has big poofy mane, who knows what could be hiding in there? From season 8 school raze, only the unicorns and Alicorns got there magic back and so did pinkie!
1 likeMaybe her pinkie sense is her magic
1 likeNo she has been wild forever so I think sense flutter shy can basically talk to animals pinky pie must have a weird ability to but sense she has more than one and apple jack doesn’t and pinky pies family isn’t a thing like her but she might actually have chaos in her blood but it never came from when we saw discord pinky I think Pinky pie is adopted because she doesn’t look a thing like her family
1 likeAlso please make a video about how pinky pie might be adopted
pinky with chaos: unlimited
0 likespowerfrosting!Discord and Pinkie Pie stop breaking the fourth wall
0 likesSomeonetimes she owns a Meth lab in sugar cub corner ngl
0 likesPinkie pie is my Spirit animal
0 likesNo it’s just pinkie pie and discord can break the fourth wall that’s all
0 likesTheres a theory by ConspiraPon3 that explains pinkies chaos because she a changling. The episode is called The Pinkie Predicament.
0 likesWho is always weird not that one moment she was always really not that one moment changed everything she was always weird in the beginning to the end how could possibly happen if pinky was magically transformed from only that one moment she was crazy and weird and think he sensed everywhere in every episode not that just one mom and changed everything how could we even know from episode one
0 likesWho else wished the mlp creators watched these so then the q can be a
0 likesi love ❤️❤️❤️ this channel 😁😁😁
0 likespinkies powers has something to do with her cutiemark/destiny.
0 likesIs it me or did pinkie look stoned or drunk?
0 likesIt all makes sense.....
0 likesYou will never Solve Pinkie pie! Never!
0 likesOMG UR SO Adorable!!!!. I thought the pony w fandom was dead!. glad it's not u won a sub btw I was wondering so are u currently a brony lol if so neat lol i got into my little pony cus of a brony lol he was also my boy friend at the time sadly i had to move so our love was not to last but our love for mlp will last forever!!!! or at least till the fandom die's XD
0 likesThe part where pinky got magic was i think her punkt sence
0 likesYou know when sawtooth said is someone watching me yes us!
0 likesWhat about discord... What job could discord do?
0 likesI think pinkie only revied the pinkie sence
0 likesthis.. scared me.. idk why but its creepy
0 likesye ur right maybe her tail shivers cuze theres somthing coming in the future :0
0 likesDifferent. Faces you can make 1. :3
0 likes2. T.T
3. O.O
4.;-;
That’s all
Eh, seems legit
0 likesI think she turn into an à la corn deep inside
0 likesPinkie pie is pinkie pie and dash has wings but how was apple jack flying in that one episode lol
0 likesIt's her her normal self
0 likeswell i think that pinkie pie has party power beacause its pinkie,s ciutiemark
1 likeOMG i was looking for this 😮😮
0 likesMaid pie also have pinkie sense
0 likesI say Pinkie is well.....Pinkie but she's NOT a EATH PONY 🐴 But I will say that in one of my videos 💗
0 likesPeople are watching you because on YouTube right now you know that it's kind of funny you said that my name is Leah Marie King and my life is actually super crazy at first my mom just freaked out I have no idea why do then only if you want to talk about the rest
0 likesYes we are watching you sawtooth I am to and I always will be hahaha
1 likeReplies (2)
Love your vids keep doing this :)
0 likesSorry this comment is cringe
0 likesYou know when sawtooth Said
0 likesI dout the Bell gave Pinki her odd ablittys because what a bout Cheeze Sence?
0 likesAre we even sure pinky is a normal pony maybe it is your theory but what if she is a different type like we have seen hipogrifs and every thing but maybe not every thing there world is big and they only exsplore a lil maybe there are others that look like earth pony’s but have som strange magic and maybe they like to stay hidden like a lost tribe of whatever they are and they hav strange abblites yes that theory might be good but what about cozy glow the magic was hard for her but she did not have the chaos spread she was fine except from those pineapples the might have left a mark but pinky might be from somewhere else she might be pony but not a earth pony or any other we have herd like a very old species not hating on the vid but what if just think about it why is she the only pink one in her faimly even be four her cutie mark and remeber pinky could control most of it like she loved the chock late rain when they first met discord and all of a shunned it starts to rain when she has it a person with magic would know how to use it but pinky could not really control what happened it’s like an instinct like how every one and thing has different instincts just think about it
0 likesReplies (1)
Sorry it is so long
0 likesPinky and Discord could be cousins!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesIS SOMEONE WATCHING ME???
0 likesoh of course not sawtooth ;I
I got a question soon soon pinkie pies it's the question is there's so many episode of My Little Pony and and Pinkie Pie bye why was got something her magic back of the others didn't
1 likePinky pie just likes partys but I think your right
0 likesDude ur wrong cuz when pinkie got the magic it’s when the villains were not in stone cuz cozy glow was the one who drained all the magic wait am I wrong or not cuz I don’t remember lol plz say I’m wrong or not in the comments of this comment
0 likesYour right
0 likesWhat does cosyglow cutie mark mean 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
0 likesPrincess Twilight would like to know your location
0 likesPinkie and discord are maybe related
0 likesBrony : is someone watching me
0 likesMe : duh u r on YouTube
NeW tHeArY dIsCoRd Is PiNkYs DaD iN a WaY
0 likesToo creepy
0 likesWhat about cheese sandwich
1 likeMaybe you can try to find the truth about Pokémon just any Pokémon would be good cheers my suggestion is that you can do mew mimiyu and oh ho
0 likesReplies (1)
Omg I found my comment
0 likesI have so many questions
0 likesWhat if there relatives
0 likesYou can’t solve pinkie pie she like discord
0 likesYeah we are all watching you after all this is a video🎂👍💐🌹🎵🎶🥰🎁!ho yes and the video was very nice to and bye-bye.😃❤👍
0 likes(pinkie pie) i dont have wierd powers i mean look t chease sanbwich i now youre talking about me
0 likesI do you like this But what about maud sense
1 likePinkie pie is crazy but, I like pinkie........
0 likesI just thank you bye I don’t know I hope that broker a hole by three guys they are never chocolate rain that mean is if only they are have magic in this box is chilling with it it’s steals have magic not so much interested this one OK I’m really
0 likespinkie pie = discord
1 likedid you watch the mare do well episod
0 likes#pinkypool shes pretty much deadpool
0 likestalk about cheec sanbwich
0 likesYes we do watch you and u are a cartoon tell pinkie pie that maybe THAT she won't handle ;>
0 likesWow man
0 likesShe is just being pinkie
0 likes.......BOOMMMMMMMMM
0 likesYes but i do not like pinkecord but wen cozy glow dose not stile all the magic cuz thay still have thar cutie mark
0 likesNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0 likesWait wait wait there is a roblox guy called “imnotequonox” and Im his friend soooo is he/she the real
0 likesYoutuber????????????????
Okay I think she have to have it the magical goes back into her because she has is that happiness 😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀
1 likeReplies (3)
Not to say anything but she did a lot more then her kids she has to do her work and her family is not in school 🏫 was her day to do the work for me that was a lot better and I will have a great 👍 I would be very very good I will only need a few friends that she has to pay for the house she has told her she wants her and her family she is so sorry to pay 💰 she was so I was wondering if you were going home 🏠 is that time for her kids I would like to go to school 🏫 I love 💓 it all I know is I am a little sister I can not tell if I have her family and her family💸💳💷💶💴💵🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄
1 likeNight time and I am not going home tomorrow morning and then I have a couple more days of work tomorrow so we will
1 likeI have a great day at school this week I have been a long day of work for the kids is that we have a new one in our home tomorrow night we are all in our family so I will have a good night tomorrow and I have to go home and get to the kids is that we can give her her name so I know what I can see she told her she would have to go to get the kids her I told you I was wondering if you would have a chance if she would have been there she can get it she told you that I told you I 🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚
1 likeStop asking for us to coment you tell us!!
0 likespinkie pie is silly
0 likesDo you read comments...?
0 likesNo ones watching you don’t worry......😬
0 likesIdk maybe pinky is gust her ? Oh now I’m not
0 likesSame
0 likesYes
1 likePinkie pie is not a unicorn or a pegasus she is just a plain Old earth pony
0 likes😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱
0 likesOar can ewe??
0 likespinky is coo coo cachoo
0 likesWait doesn’t pinkies sister mod have…mod sense
0 likesU solving pinky
0 likesIs mat Pat solving fnaf
Text you later!!!
0 likesBut cheese
0 likesI am candice is the impostter
0 likesI am a changeling
0 likes🥳🥳🥳🥳💕💕💕💕🤪🤪🤪
0 likesUwU
0 likesPinkie is just pinkie a very weird pony
0 likesAre You aaaaaaaa………………………………………Peper?!😛😃😃🤨🤨🤨
0 likesI am pinky but a unicorn
0 likesit s pinkie sense that went to pinkie
0 likesWaaaaaaaaaaaaaat
0 likesI will write you tomorrow
0 likes😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱
0 likesF
1 likenope nope nopety nope
0 likesYes
0 likesShe is weird
0 likesA very good and reasonable theory. I never saw the little detail that Pinkie also got some magic back. But, I don't now if that makes sense, when the chaos magic infected Pinkie in the past too, shouldn't the magic also infected Discord while he was powerless? He would've managed some chaotic things, because his magic influenced him from the future, when he got his magic back? Like Pinkie and her abilities? Or maybe she realizes that she's in a cartoon, because she broke the fourth wall more than one time. It's like when you are realizing that you are dreaming, you can control the dream (okay, mostly you just wake up). That's why Pinkie can use simple cartoon tricks. O^O Okay, that would be too far fetched. XD A crazy idea, I know. XD
2 likesI think that you are right about pinkie and discord’s chaos magic, however I think the reason that it affected pinkie differently than cozy is that pinkie also absorbed the princesses magic. I think that princess magic and chaos magic might have been so much that it spread out, but chaos magic on its own wasn’t enough, hence why cozy wasn’t affected.
2 likesA while back, I came to the same conclusion; Pinkie had somehow been infused with Chaos magic. I didn’t know how, but thanks to your vid, I can see a good picture
1 likeAs much as I like this theroy and I do believe Pinkie has magic unlike unicorns, alicorns, pegesai and normal earth ponies I don't think it is discord's. I also don't think Pinkie is meant to be solved. She is unique and random and can break phisics apparently But maybe Pinkie Pie has as many layers to her magic as an onion or she is just as confusing and weird as a cross between an orange and a frog. As fun as it is to theorise maybe in this case the best answer is the simplest one: Pinkie is Pinkie and that's how it's supposed to be.
2 likesI think that the reason Pinky took Discored’s magic so well is because there related. If one of Discord’s relatives married someone and one of their kids didn’t have chose magic they probably wouldn’t talk to them kinda like in Harry Potter with pure bloods and skwibs. Since women take a men’s sr name when they marry the pie family could be related to Discored but since Pinky was the only one who absorbed Discores magic she is the only one with those qualities and that might be why she looks so different.
1 likeI think you theory right, and the reason it only affected Pinkie and not CozyGlow is because the magic may have been more unstable without Discord to contain it. I can’t remember if this is true or not but alicorn magic may have been in the bell when Pinkie used it.
2 likesReplies (1)
theres also the comics in which contain a alicorn pinkie.
0 likesCozy Glow could also been effected by cauose magic but instead of making her have reality breaking powers from the bell she was led down a very unusual path becoming evil and all that stuff. Because of these different reactions too the magic could have made them go down paths that made them have said reactions to the magic in the bell. But that’s just my theory!
1 likeshe couldn’t teleport out of tartarus or literally defy gravity in there or anything that pinkie does normally, so when it showed she got magic that might have just been what she always uses. as for pinkie sense, i think she’s being honest about her not knowing how it works, it’s natural.
0 likesI mean, pinkie did seem pretty in control of that chaos magic, so it is very possible she had been dealing with it her whole life, or at least a very large portion of it, and it is raw chaos magic, so there is literally no predicting how it will react to different ponies.
0 likesTo me the fact that Cozy Glow had Chaos Magic too is a definite dealbreaker on this theory.
0 likesAs much as i love this theory, there's one problem.
0 likesPinkie Sense.
I mean, sure, she can kinda predict future, but then... What about Maud Pie and Cheese Sandwich?
They have their senses too.
Cheese has a sense that lets him know where parties are going to happen and Maud... Okay, i'm not fully sure how her sense works, but she found the guy in that one episode, so yeah.
And it is possible that some earth ponies have that kind of magic with them, looking at the fact, that we saw only earth ponies have this kind of... Do i call it magic or sense? X3
If it is magic, that would explain why Pinkie "got her magic back" in that one scene and AJ didn't.
And one more.
Cheese Sandwich is practically, almost the same as Pinkie Pie, so how did he get... The way he is???
So i'm still gonna go with "It's Pinkie Pie, don't question it" ^^
very clever! I believe in theories, not its just the way it is. Nice!! this is my favorite of your theories!
2 likesWhat I want to know is why couldn't Cozy Glow or her friends absorb the alicorn magic in the bell? Tirek said that they couldn't use their magic until they learned how to handle Discord's magic inside the bell. Later on, however, Discord was able to take back his Chaos magic while leaving the alicorn sisters magic inside the bell. If they could have left Discord magic in the bell while only absorbing the alicorn magic, was plot convenience the only thing preventing them?
0 likesAlso, why was Pinkie able to use the bell? We had a whole episode dedicated to the villains sneaking into the Canterlot archives to figure out how to use the bell, to begin with.
I think your theory is right. It would explain so much, and is like that last peice of a puzzle. It fits perfectly
0 likesI don’t like the time travel thing in this context. What happened to the timeline where Pinkie DIDN’T do all the crazy stuff she does? I think Discord may have *ahem* “bonded” with one of Pinkie’s ancestors, and the magic just skipped a couple thousand generations. It’d even be too many “great-“s to consider them related
1 likeI had a theory that all ponies have magic inherent to them, it's just that unicorns have a way of channelling it easily through their horns. It can be harder for pegusai and earth ponies to access their magic, but there is some evidence of them using magic, such as fluttershy inherently being able to understand any animal, rainbow dash being able to perform a sonic rainboom (with the rainbow element of that not really making sense without magic), the apple family with their higher than average strength (this is the weakest link I admit, but there is something to be said for earth ponies always being referred to as the best at growing and tending to plants, maybe their magic helps this), and pinkie pie with her.... everything. I feel like she is much more in tune with her magic than any other earth pony or pegasus, maybe even some unicorns, and this could be explained by the chaos magic theory! This is just an idea though! I feel like it fits a little better with the initial intent behind the show, since the beginning wasnt written with the end in mind!
0 likessir, pinkie getting a thing of magic when it came back explains everything, period
1 likeI definitely believe in this theory ,especially because of the small hint where she gets her magic back as well
0 likesI love this theory but I don't think she is as powerful as discord or the power she absorbed took away from discord's. I would like to believe its just pinkie. She is the comedic but secretly deep and smart character.
1 likeTL;DR WARNING
0 likesMaybe it's because Cozy Glow was already a very gifted unicorn and was an Alicorn at the time of partaking of the chaos magic, so being a creature that was already familiar with magic and had princess level magical capabilities, the chaos just blinded her judgment and messed up her magic. Pinkie Pie, being an Earth Pony, only had enhanced strength from the magic in the atmosphere. Since she never had an affinity for any other form of basic magic, the chaos magic, being as powerful as it was, had a much more drastic effect on her. It probably exposed the 4th Wall to her and several (not all) of her alternate counterparts across the multiverse at a very young age (like her human and comic book counterparts). It might have also allowed her to see past the 4th Wall and break it like Discord can on occasion. It probably also affected her physiology, giving her minor access to the fictional phenomenon that usually, only Looney Toons character are capable of; Toon Force, which is how she is able to summon multiple pony hooves around the screen and literally shatter herself after hours of repressed excitement. But these feats can be performed (as Roger Rabbit explains) " only when it's funny". I say "minor" because although she is capable of the aforementioned feats, she is definitely can't do anything akin to sawing the country in half or lassoing the moon (without assistance).
This just makes me love Pinkie even more 💕💕
2 likesI sorta have a link on to this theory about the part about cozy glow and pinkie pie.
0 likes1. Pinkie had the magic of friendship while cozy did not accept the concept (well not entirely)
1. Pinkie may not be a fully grown pony but I’m pretty sure she was older than cozy glow and cozy is just a filly. So maybe being younger made here less powerful or something?
the flaw with this theory is that cheese sandwich has a cheesy sense, yet he hadn't ever gotten chaos magic, unless he got in an outbranching alternative timeline..
0 likesPinky seems to actually be able to control chaos magic, where Cozy couldn't.
0 likesTo be honest, your theory makes sense to me, but I doubt writters were thinking on that xD
1 likeI think that the reason Pinky's chaos magick when all through the timeline is because she actually used the magic and new what she could do and cozy glow to use the magic it was in her bloodline but it didn't stay in it because she didn't know how to use it so maybe chaos magic intently takes one use of it to have it go through your entire bloodline and for it to stay that way
0 likesIt's the creators of My Little Pony just wanting to have someone in the series who can break the forth wall. Oof. Most series have this sorta thing ya know?
1 likeYes I am a very literate person
It seems like she would've gotten her abilities from that moment,
0 likesBut it also may have been Rainbow Dash's Sonic Rainboom, All that rainbow energy, Pinkie MUST'VE had to get special abilities to earn her cutie mark and fufill her destiny!
If it effects her entire lifespan, than each time she gets more chaotic than the last right? It is really hard to word it so it isn't confusing
0 likesCrazy part is when pinkie pie absorbed the magic she seem to be able to control it "no one can control discords magic"proving that pinkie pie is in some way different than the others
0 likesI do love pinky pie but I do think this theory which you just brought up is correct!
0 likesI do have a doubt of my own too it is like this: Everyone has to die in one movement of time and if that really happened then the mane 5 (not twilight ) would die and TIREK, CHRESOLES, and COZY GLOW would be set free even if the young 6 can handle it they never fought with them (except for the end) so Equestria will be doomed with no heroes to save !!! If that really comes then what will happen???
This man is the mat pat of the mlp fandom
2 likesI like this theory
1 likeIt makes sense
LONG LIVE OUR PINK OVERLORD!
This is true, but in one of the early episodes, twilight actually gives pinkie an enhancing potion and pinkie says it, 'allowed me to see through space and time' SPACE AND TIME! So maybye, she managed to go into her future, not her past?
0 likesAn explanation for why th chaos magic didn't effect cozy th same is probably simply because she's so young that it didn't hv far to go n her past wich actually might also explain why she's "evil" in that that was th effect of chaos magic on her past from that point but her future is far more vast especially since she is now trapped n stone so yeah if they do get released one day n future generation maybe we'll see that effect and that would b interesting
0 likesThe whole future affecting the past concept is reminding me of Aot and honestly its so scary and confusing
0 likesShe is a god of breaking physics
1 likeI DID MU Research! according to many sights it says that the energy of the porson (in this case pony) that possesses the magic depends wether the magic is dark or for good e.x pinky did not use the magic to hurt someone but cosyhooves did so it may effect how long the magic last and some say it can even stay for a lifetime. so yes, more than likely its bc discord.
0 likesWhen she got the magic she could control it and do whatever she wants but cozy glow couldn't.
1 like"I may have just solved Pinkie Pie!" IMPOSSOBLE! Don't question her XD.
0 likesI love this dude. You need to work for Hasbro!
0 likesWait.... So has the cycle always been there or what happened when Pinkie first absorbed the magic.... Would the whole series be different?
0 likesI approve this as headcanon, your theory is possible. I mean how did she know how to control Discord's Power without experience.
0 likesReplies (1)
that's what i say thank you
0 likes2:11 I NEVER NOTICE IT BEFORE WHAAAAAAT(๑⊙д⊙๑)
1 likeYou know, this makes sense🤔
Tbh, I didn't expect that someone can solve Pinkie Pie. Wow
Yeah your kind of wrong but doesn't explain the other world Pinky so here's what I think he's an interdimensional party God incarnated as Pinkie and yeah that would make a lot of sense because party gods are usually chaos users
1 likeI think that when she saw the rainbow,she got much more power,she got magic when she saw the rainbow,that must have been the reason her mane puffed up
0 likesRemember the episode pinkie, maud, and rarity went to manehatten? When maud was looking for the pony that had pinkies cannon, she found him instantly. Pinkie said it was maud sence, which runs in the family...
0 likesthe puzzle is finally solved!
0 likesTHIS IS THE BEST THEORY IVE EVER HEARD OMF
0 likesI've been watching ur channel since I was like twelve and now I'm almost an adult and was finally able to find ur channel again UGH SAME GOOD VIDEOS I LOVE U
Shouldn't Pinkie Pie be the one who is Princess? Because she brings happiness to everyone and she brings everyone together too. And makes Friendship also happened too.
0 likes(This is my opinion and a joke too.)
Meanwhile at My little pony HQ:Let's make some nonsense and let them make logic.
0 likesTHIS MAKES SO MUCH SENSE NOW! WOW
0 likesPinkie: The only pers...uh pony who can take Discord's magic
1 like2:32 ehh I don't think so Pinkie's just well...Pinkie and they don't plan for the last episodes on the ones in the series before...
haha im a big fan of mlp, but havent watched a mlp vid since 2013. you having me thinking about the show in 2020. good job :D nice video.
0 likesHonestly now you mention this i think it could be true , it makes sense!
0 likesI really REALLY like this theory
0 likesWoah! So many spoilers! I guess I need to catch up with the story first.
0 likesIn the comic, pinkie goes into the chaos dimension and becomes the ruler of chaos. They have to "defeat" her. Maybe she sent back some magic from there to when she was a filly
0 likes“ I might have just solved pinkie pie” me: IMPOSSIBLE!
0 likesIt’s pinkie pie, even if she somehow has chaos powers from a certain event, how would you explain in past before her cutie pie?
0 likesi might be the only one to see it but something got my eye for one pinky has way more control over the magic than
1 likecosy glow and she absorb more magic by the lightning cold mean she took more magic than she did
Replies (1)
sorry for my bad grammar
0 likesIf you watch the Equestria Girls (Bloopers Compared To Actual Scenes) It kind of explains what pinkie is a psychic.
0 likesokay i actually really like this theory
0 likesTwiglight: I have the magic of friendship!
1 likePinkie pie: yo I can travel in time
Replies (1)
LOL
0 likesI saw Pinkie get magic, but I just thought they all got magic back. 😌
1 likeOof
Replies (1)
Also, Cheese Sandwich has a Cheesy sense. Soooooo...
1 likeBut what about Cheese sense and Maud sense? Pinkie says it runs in the family
1 likeWait a second... I havent seen any episode where PinkiePie Had Chaos Magic and i have watched all episodes 10 times
0 likesCongrats Sawtooth! You hit 300K! Pls make a 300K sub special
0 likesTfw you come to a conclusion looooooooong before the quickest to jump the gun theorist
0 likesAnd still gain no cred for it
This theory dosent work i mean think about it. Maud says that she has a maud sense to and then pinkie pie said that it runs in the family, so unless maud also touched grogars bell then it wouldn't be possible for this to be true. Also human pinkie. She didn't touch the bell either.
0 likes"Is someone watching me?"
2 likes(148k people) : Uhhh...
I think that pinki was born with a tiny bice of chaos and discord might have taken that away when he used grogars bell on pinki pie
0 likesI hope this is canon!!!
0 likesthere are three things you don't question in this world
0 likes1.the sky is blue
2.kingdom heart is life
3. and finally pinkie pie shall not be questioned
Hmmm idk cause if pinkie pie got all of discord’s magic from the bell then all the other times she could predict the future and break the fourth wall would happen after she got his powers but it all happened before so at least that’s my theory but I also like your theory but I do have a question if pinkie got discord’s magic near the finale only for a minute than how was she able to break the fourth wall and predict the future in previous episodes?
0 likesit think pinky may have accidentally infused her time line not knowing about magic as she is a earth pony and did not know the danger of effecting your own time line she was the one to dress up like Marty when twilight what to relive some she did not go to suggest she has a fascination with it and cozy know about magic would like not risk any thing that might mess with the time line
0 likesMaybe it’s because pinkie didn’t use it for the purpose to attack at her like cozy glow but in the purpose of bringing chaos instead.
0 likesYour theory couldn't have been right pinky got the magic after she got the magic back from cozy glow
0 likesWait I thought you were brony notion! Now your sawtooth waves? Ok ok I get it
0 likes2:53 sawtooth maud has pinkie/maud sense too!
1 like"Is someone watching me?"
2 likes(148k people) : Uhhh...
It’s pinkie don’t question it 😉
1 likeIdk but for the cozy glow thing she already had alaicorn magic inside of her so maby she had enough magic inside of her that it controlled the chaos magic time wise through out her life idk just a hunch like if u agree
0 likes1:46 its called the fourth wall 😁
0 likesLaughter is her power
1 likeBut that actually makes sense
0 likesFirst minute, and headcanon accepted. 😁
0 likesWait. The Equestria Girls the time loop episode if this theory is correct she could've predicted the future and the past without her acknowledging just like the part when Twilight Sparkle trying to confess she's from another world. I am confused.
1 likeReplies (2)
She could've known with her Pinkie sense.
0 likesI don't think its just a HuNcH.
0 likesSilly changy boy, pinkie pie is obviously a benevolent eldritch entity from across space and time that likes ponies!
1 likeI think her crazyness came with her cutie mark. Think about it went she had no cutie mark she was miserable but when it came she went crazy (⊙_◎) just like discord. And that progress along in the years. Also when balloons pop it makes them go crazy and not act like themselves. Helloo that is pinkie pie.
1 likeI’m sure you don’t need any but: here’s a video idea! What is starswirl the bearded’s cutie mark? He’s always hid it under his starry
0 likesblue cloak! Edit: never mind you can see it in an episode
Wait if you solved pinkie pie then what about cheese sandwich he is also like ps starlights cutie mark is sort of shaped like a kite just so you know
1 likeit doesn't apply to cheese sandwich who has cheesey sense
0 likesGUYS I THINK HE'S ON TO US
0 likesPinkie is just a new creature
0 likesNot a changeling or a pony
Just.......
Keep going
💗Pinkie Pie💗
Then how do you explain maud sense?
0 likesPinkie pie got her powers from the giant rainbow.
1 likeOr Pinkie is Discord’s secret child
0 likes:o pinkie pie is one of my favorite characters
2 likesEven though pinkie is a earth pony she still has magic
1 likeReplies (1)
Well every earth pony does.
0 likesIt's just a different kind of magic.
i think so the magic is her pinkie sense so she got that magic back
0 likesI can picture it now, Pinkord
0 likesPunkte pie is wired right? Think about it, she think's different Team cozy glow
0 likesMaybe that didnt happen to cozy glow becuase she is evil.
0 likesCould Pinkie be a alicorn
0 likesAnd she laughs like .......ANYTIME.....
1 likeAsk pinkie pie about her magic
0 likespinkie pie and cozy glow use it discord magic. Twilight sparkle: pinky you use it discord magic?
0 likesWho wants to know how does the human and pony pinkie pie know whats going on and the movie is equestria girls
0 likesThey switched places
Sawtooth Wave, are you a fan , OF my little pony?
0 likesCozy glow is not compatible with chaos magic but pinky is
0 likesPinkie Pie isn’t a pony, she’s the only one of her kind, ‘Silly Pudding’
0 likes2:13ES LA MAGIA DE LA CUARTA PARED JAJAJAAJAJAJAJJA
0 likesXD
Maybe pinky = Celestia what if celestia is useing a spell to see Through pinky ?
0 likesWhat about cheese sandwich he has the cheesy sense?
0 likesI love all your theories
0 likesReplies (2)
Sawtooth The theories you make thing
0 likesOof
0 likesPink and cosy glow a different so I had hair loss and alicon magic while cosy glow had only this discord magic
0 likes@sawtoothwaves I got a theory for you. About cadence and flurry heart just reply and I'll tell you.
0 likesEh.....i don't think so
0 likesThat happened near the ending yet pinkie had that shit the entire serie's 😂😂😂😉
You are now my mentor
0 likesMonika:Just Monika!
0 likesPinkie:just pinkie!
I’ll try😊
0 likesSolved
1 likeI think that could be possibe and that could happen or it is just pinkie being pinkie pie otherless we will find out and mabye future videoes your theorie could be correct
0 likesi think your right
0 likes1:49
0 likesYes. We are.
Replies (1)
We all are.
0 likesPinkie is the embodyment of pinkie
0 likesPinkie Pie's sister has a sense too.
0 likesWait why is pinkle pink while the rest of her family brown or gray.....?
0 likesYes someone is watching you
0 likesWell pinkie pie have soem discord magic in side her that means discord and pinkie is now the same its true pinkie have magic bc of discord
0 likesPinky pies. Is my friend’s favorite pink and can you make a video. If your a pony
1 likeShe use to have horn I think so she is unicorn I think
0 likesWhat if pinkie pink is evil?!
0 likesPinkie pie is my Favorite tho
0 likesThis vid creeped me out the first time
0 likesPinkie said mod sense it run through the family
0 likespinkie pie is just a far cousin of discord
2 likesReplies (1)
Time to throw you a bone, what if Pinkie is Discord's mother or something to that effect?
0 likesWhat about the Pinkie Pie in the human world??? And what about the Discord magic????? The thing about the discord thingy thing didnt showed up at at Season 1-5 tho...
0 likesReplies (1)
WAIT SORRY I WAS WRONG
0 likesOh yeah, the video was from naseema been. Check that out
0 likesI have seen half of the vidio so i think...PINKEY IS DISCORDS SISTER DON DON DON🤣🤣
0 likesUmm.. Naseema something something name made a video for you in which nightmare moon was visible in twilight's old house. Do see that video
0 likesYah some body is washing you
0 likesShe is not a earth pones I think
0 likesWhen the elements of harmony were destroyed she still had laughter in her
1 likeReplies (1)
How is that relevant though?
0 likesWe are watching you
1 likepinkie pie is just...pinke pie. she's different. and that's that.
0 likesJust don’t watch cupcake with pinkingpie
0 likesI think she Gwen pool or dead pool
0 likesOfcours someone is watching you sawtooth like dont you want views
0 likesPinkie is lafter discord is chaos
1 like1:58 u like pokemon Sawtooth?!?!
0 likesOnly way that would be possible is prob that pinky pie is discord’s daughter
0 likesPinky wouldn't have even taken the magic if this didn't take the magic before she took the magic, Your also saying she didn't get her cutie mark until she took the magic, Your saying equestria was taken over by night mare moon and all the other villans cause pinkie moved to pony ville to use her talents for better than distracting her family, all I'm saying is this doesn't make sense, just my very long opinion I hope this did not make you feel bad if it did I am very sorry.
1 likeReplies (2)
Pinkie will never make sense
1 likeEVER
0 likesYo Shi dark lord what a good name
0 likesCONFUSING LMAOO
0 likesUmmm suspicious
1 likePeople not pie is a gypsy
1 likeShe is a new creature that they have not put in the show she is a changing a new one. What if she is a changing that take happiness instead, take love or giving love. No steal my thinking pls
0 likesReplies (2)
Beryl effie Cabading smart
0 likesThank you
0 likesOh Reffwr it’s pinkie lol
0 likesBruh he said "IS SOMEONE QATCHING ME!?!??!"lol im watching u ur a youtuber ;-;
0 likes...WHAT!
0 likesLike Deadpool
0 likes:o
0 likesPinkie pie is illegal
0 likesReally?🧐
0 likesI’m watching you
0 likesI don't know pinkie pie
0 likesYa everyone’s watching u
0 likessee pinkie is gone
0 likesHahaha
1 likeReplies (1)
😀😁😶😗🙄😙😏😏😥🙂🙂☺😑😋😋😍🙄😙🙂🙂
1 likepinkie pie is not good at all
0 likesYes
0 likesDo you think spike lothers sunset shimmer
0 likesYes
0 likesshe is coco
0 likesYes
0 likesYes
0 likesYes I am watching u
0 likesUm pinkie swich in the other pinkie
0 likesWhat are broines
0 likes#orecanyou
0 likesWhy pic of sheep
0 likes>:(
0 likesyes
0 likesyes
0 likesyes
0 likesWho is pinkies daughters father
0 likesUm......ya we are watching you du
0 likesyes
0 likesHi auntie pinkie
0 likesyes
0 likesWe are whaching yoi
0 likesIs someone is watching haha of course
0 likespAw
1 likeShe is just pinkie
0 likescozwy
0 likesUmm no hate. But it's a vid soo we r watching 😑
0 likespinkie is sepical for idk
1 likeReplies (1)
ok
0 likesI don't think so
1 likeHaven't started the video yet, but I'm gonna say it's gotta be chaos magic. How else could she have not only handled Discord's chaos magic in the finale, but also was able to use it to create chocolate rain? It's because she DOES know how to control some of it, because she already does use chaos magic to some degree.
1 like3:48 Okay, so it was definitely related, but it's definitely different. My theory implies that pinkie was always able to use chaos magic by sheer chance(or genetic mutation?), rather than by her gaining all this chaos magic. Anyways, here's my theory in full.
The reason why pinkie acts the way she does is because she already has chaos magic. It wasn't given to her by some future event, it was always with her, even since birth. How does the pinkie getting chaos magic event tie into this? Well, it's because of Cozy Glow. When Cozy Glow got Discord's chaos magic, she tried hard to control it. But, chaos magic, by it's nature, is impossible to control unless you have experience. I'm pretty sure Discord said this, or that it was said at some point, but I can't remember when. Anyways, the takeaway from that is that *chaos magic is impossible to control unless you have experience in using it*. So, why is it that Pinkie is able to create a very specific thing(chocolate rain) when she has chaos magic? The reason for this is simple, it's because she already has had experience using chaos magic, and is hence able to control it now.
As for the Pinkie sense? Well, that's one problem with this. No, the problem isn't that chaos magic can't allow for predicting the future, it's that we don't know for sure if it can. I don't remember seeing Discord use chaos magic to predict the future ever, or anyone using magic for the matter, so I can't know for sure. If someone can point out an instance where any type of magic has predicted the future(even if it was unsuccessful), then that would make pinkie sense being powered by chaos magic a possibility.
Okay so, I have another theory. The Young 6 all do represent the elements of harmony. If you look at the last episode where at the end when they sang the song magic of friendship and at the end showed all Characters that resembles too the mane 6 chacters. So SilverStream represents the element of laughter, this actually makes total sense because In a lot the episodes You can see, how she wants everyone to be happy and always makes everyone laughs, just like pinky. Yona represent honesty, she is always honest with he group and in ever episode we have seen in her, she always never afraid to speak the truth. Smolder represents loyalty, the way she’s loyal within In the group and in most of the episodes when some one gets in trouble, she’s the first one to Volunteer to pay the same price as them, and just go back to the episodes and you can see her loyalty. Sandbar represents kindness, I’m School Daze he was the one, the only pony In the school you really wanted to be with the other creatures, and also just go back to all the other episodes he acts literally just like flutter shy. Ocellus represents Generosity, I’m one episode you can see her giving her friends notes 📝 for the hw, and always helping them study and etc, u can see in the episodes how she resembles rarity. Well, the last one I don’t have a clue, the last one points to Gallous idk how he represents magic, but he’s some one resemblance to Twilight. Please give to a like so He can see it! Edit: In School Daze II, you can see sandbar is glowing in Fluttershy color, Smolder Rainbowdash color, Yona Apple Jacks color, Siverstream as pinky color, Ocelous as Rarity color, Galleous as twilight color! :)
2 likesInteresting theory. I've always assumed, as it has been proven that all ponies have some magic in them, that some just have more magic in them than others. The Mane Six in general are freaks of nature, and Pinkie is just an example of an earth pony mare with exceptional magic levels. Really exceptional levels in Pinkie's case, which does seem to run in the Pie family to an extent. I could be mistaken though.
0 likesI always had the theory that someone has to be chaotic in some way to harness Chaos Magic without stealing it from someone else. Discord is physically chaotic, I mean just look at the guy. However, I believe Chaos Magic can be harnessed by someone who's MENTALLY chaotic, or rather, insane in some way. People who are mentally unwell tend to appear detached from the real world. It wouldn't be too much of a stretch that the wandering sanity of a broken mind can find itself in places beyond reality, and possibly tapping into a power that is truly impossible to understand, just like it's impossible for us to truly understand Pinkie Pie.
0 likesI wanna know a moment where Pinkie finds out about her magic secrets
2 likesLike pulling things out of thin air and stuff, that would be awesome
It could be that Pinkie Pie, already being pretty chaotic in personality, was simply more attuned to the chaos magic than Cozy Glow. Perhaps she truly became one with chaos for that moment, whereas Cozy Glow just had strange power within her for a moment. That closer connection that Pinkie Pie establishes could be what causes the magic to leave lasting effects throughout her timeline as you suggest.
0 likesThis is a great theory and all, but then how would you explain Maud sense when they go to Manehattan?Pinkie Pie says it runs in the family so I would like to assume that maybe a little chaos spread to the first people she spent the most time with.But that doesn’t really make sense, because that’s the only other chaotic thing about her family and Maud in general. You could count there weird obsessions with rocks, but I feel like that was there before Pinkie.
1 likewell chaos magic interacted with two different beings, pinkie has chaotic good intentions, while cozy glow had evil intentions, the magic then reflected that on the outside, while still both crazy, they had much different personalities and intentions. , just a thought
1 likeit does make sense because in a way she had an even more understanding of how to use it. With Cozy Glow, all she saw and used (well wanted too) it for was power. but Pinkie being the way she is and the fact that she was friends with Discord had understanding on how to just "go with the flow" to use his magic. This could have cause the Magic of Chaos to... Merge with Pinkie's spirit, effecting it through out all time
0 likesbut hey that's..... JUST A THEORY... A PONY THEORY...... ok im done imitating TGT xD
Ive watching your channel for some time (I like theory channels) but one thing that has never been explained in MLP is how can spike send messages to Celestia's and back no other creature seems to have this ability. Did Spike inheritance some twilight magic to so he do this?
1 likeI actually figured this out. The elements were found in the tree of harmany. The geods are found in a cave in camp everfree. Even the tree is in a small cave beneath the catsle. What im trying to say is that the geods are the elements of HARMANY.
1 likeI think more then likely pinkie got her powers from when twilight was a child and the rainboom unleashed her powers and it traveled with the rainboom to pinkie first and gave her some strange connection to twilight magic.
1 likeIt fits the order and we see pinkie get hit with the rainboom aftershock full on.
You have to take into account that the writers would not of thought this far ahead to the end they came too so the end with pinkie getting that power was just a throw away thing and has nothing to do with her powers.
You cant say that pinky sense is related to this because in an episode there was a line that said.
2 likesRarity: “ How did you know where he was? “
Maud: “ Maud-sense. “
So that is not proof
(No hate love your theories)
The staring off into space thing, it’s not them watching you.
0 likesIt’s called “fourth-wall awareness.”
It’s a power few yw characters have
I JUST thought of something about this video that wasn't explained.....
1 likeif Pinkie got her Pinkie Sense while she held Discord's Chaos Magic..... what about Cheese Sandwich and how did he get his Cheesy Sense?
And to expand upon that, we know they have a foal together. Does Little Cheese inherit mom's Pinky Sense, or dad's Cheesy Sense?
or will she inherit both, having an ultimate Cheesy-Pinkie Sense?!
Think of it this way; a being's mental state can alter the potency of chaos magic like when discord tried to throw a tea party for fluttershy and made himself too "normal" therefore diminishing his powers and existence. Pinkie's mental state is a constant wild party, and though the theory of pinkie getting chaos magic at that one moment seems to be a paradox as without it to begin with she would have been extremely different and probably would have never been there to attain said magic but chaos magic is just that; chaotic; anything and/or everything impossible and/or paradoxical can and/or will become possible possibly, maybe, it's a possibility and at the same time not
0 likesThis could make sense but she could just have a stronger connection to magic than most earth ponies do. All ponies have magic to an extent, they all have cutie marks. Unicorns and Alicorns have the strongest connection to magic by default but that doesn't mean other ponies or creatures for that matter, can't tap into it or even use it to the same extent or greater if they went far enough. That might be taboo in Equestria or just very hard to achieve though so very few go for it. I think of Equestrian magic as kind of like the speed force from The Flash and The Force from StarWars. Its there, however difficult it might be to do so it can be manipulated for better or worse, it can be given to someone, it can be taken away, it's just drawn to some individuals and some are drawn to it, it can probably be killed, and it can probably be manufactured. Some individuals can just tap into it more than most can or even bother to. It's flowing through their world like air. Its everywhere. Someone is bound to be able to use it.
0 likesI have said it before and I'll say it again. Pinkie is the most powerful being in Equestria. Here's a new way to look at it. Her 4th wall breaking means she is in touch with the dimension of her universe's creators. That would put her in the category of angel/demon in our world. Crazy...
0 likesOkay. I'll try too fit as much of this as I can into this comment so bear with me. Here is my extended version of that theory.
0 likesYes. Pinkie was infused with chaos magic through her timeline, but how does chaos magic work? I think it's tied to emotions. Discord does what he wants, when he wants until he makes friends! Pinkie herself could barely control it before discord took it back, and cozy couldn't at all with the emotional Turmoil of being a villain. That being said, pinkie was affected directly, but the ponies she cared about were also indirectly affected. I got this from the cheese sense and Maud sense left unexplained. Ponies have pickaxes. They dont normally drill through solid rock with their hooves or EAT THEM. But discord eats whatever. From paper to phones. And Maud being seemingly her closest sister, showing up a lot more and bsff stuff got the Maud sense. Cheese sandwich later determined pinkies canon romantic partner also has a special bond with her affecting him In a similar way. Heck he even opens a gag factory! And after being stuck being bored, loses his laugh like discord was fading when he invited fluttershy over to his house. This happens to pinkie too, in party of one, and with her yak instrument that I can't spell! Cheese and pinkie had bonds but Maud only had boulder until mudbriar so she turned out different chaotic? The mane 6 could also have been affected, but their direct connection to the tree of harmony allowed them to control it better, like how discord's vine seeds wouldn't grow right away. But fluttershy having the close bond with discord gave her a little more power, where her stare came from, that can out stare cockatrices!!!
In the same episode where Pinkie Pie gets "her magic" her food rots and twlight says that it's because there's no magic protecting it but none of the cakes have magic so either it's Pinkie or a different Unicorn or maybe a spell done by Celestia
2 likesI absolutely love your theory! <3
0 likespinkie has VERY chaotic nature, maybe, because of that, when pinkie drowned discords magic, chaotic magic matched on pinkie's nature... and this explains why she could (somehow) control discords magic but cozy couldn't
0 likesI like your theory and events in the future affecting the past is actually not beyond the laws of physics in thus world even if when dont have that massive example like pinkie pie.
0 likesBut if the magic itself is not bound to time then I could see this. Some holes in the theory though. Wouldn't discord still have some level of magic after it was absorbed if it floods the time line of the soul getting it? Even if it was just small things like pinkie does. Though i can also explain this away with discord being a creature of chaos that NEEDS chaos to exist. Proven in the episode where he forces himself to be normal so my thinking is the chaos that keeps him alive is all that's left but pinkie is a pony and never needed chaos magic. Since it flooded her timeline later in her life the chaos magic in her I guess you would say life force had the ability to spread out in both directions. This gave pinkie pie time to learn to use the chaos magic. Those abilities you were showing. And while she STILL would not have been able to control ALL of it she had enough of a handle on it to control it a bit when she was flooded with the magic since her only real time travel was a sense that this or that was going to happen. Meanwhile, cozy glow being a younger pony had mostly only one direction in her life force to travel. To her future. She didn't get the training time with it that pinkie did. But that's just a theory!
So in other words Pinky Pie created a temporal causality loop for herself? that's actually pretty epic.
0 likesThe word you're looking for is "retrocausality": future events causing past events.
0 likesOne possible way for the world to have retrocausality is for it to have a "blocky" time.
Basically, it's an alternative view of time. The future and past exists as surely as the present, and for the future to influence the past is as natural as the past influencing the future. It's as if the past and the future are the left and right sides of a giant mural. There is an internal logic to the mural: it's not random. This internal logic constrains the left side and the right side to not break away from each other's influence. In the same way, the past and the future are bound by a logic beyond time, and the future can constrain the past just like the past constrains the future..
Cozy Glow wanted the magic to be put back in the bell Pinkie did not so maybe for that split second she spread that magic through her timeline willingly.
0 likesMaybe the Cosy Glow theory is that the chaos magic can tell if you are going to use it for good or evil. If it could, it would only change pinkie's past because she wasn't going to be evil with her rare power.
0 likesi haven't been to this channel in so long, i forget why i stopped watching the videos! there amazing, keep being great
0 likesHey sawtooth, what would happen if equestria had to deal with every villain they ever had at once. yknow like they all come back at the same time and joined forces against equestria. Just curious to know.
1 likeSawtooth,I have a theory. In Season 2 Episode 2 or 1 Screwball makes an appearance. Does that mean she’s considered canon?
0 likesAfter a week of thinking about this video I have finally figured it out so what I think is pinkie pie and other earth pony’s like cheese sandwich have a special kind of magic passes through there family like when we found out Maud has Maud sense she’s pinkies sister after all anyway, this magic givers her a special pinkie sense and allows her to teleport define the laws of physics and other things she has done that is completely separate from discord’s chaos magic so far the only pony’s with these abilities are earth pony’s you said in a video a long time ago all pony’s are born with magic maybe so earth pony’s are born with those magical abilities this is why pinkie pie gets a pink dot through her that’s her pinkie sense so please read this 👍🥳 and take it into consideration 👍👍
0 likesYOU CAN’T SOLVE PINKY PIE NO MATTER HOW HARD YOU TRY!
2 likesWhat mystery? Everypony knows she’s made of giggles and gumdrops
0 likesOven mitts and out-takes
Doodles and donuts
Fairytales and fruitcake
Chaos and cupcakes
Lots and lots of batter
Sugar and sunshine
Lollipops and laughter. 😄
Yeah, she’s my favorite mystery 😉
HEY! What's up! I'm your biggest fan, and I know this has no relation to Pinkie, but I think that Rainbow Dash DOES deserve her element. I mean, yeah sure she hasn't been TOO loyal from the beginning of the series, but that's the thing about my theory. I think that she has been Building Up her loyalty. You know like character development, and that stuff. So I hope you read my comment on that theory of yours, and maybe change your mind about that. I find Rainbow very interesting.... WITHOUT THE EGO OF COURSE! I can give you some more theories to think about because I'm a big fan of MLP. Bye!
0 likesYou just had to include stuff from "FPK". I really hated that episode. Seeing my favorite character get punished to no end really wasn't all that funny to me. Sure it was supposed to be a throwback to classic "Looney Toons" slapstick but doesn't it really only work if a character is unlikable enough to deserve it? Opinion: Twilight was just trying to observe Pinkie Pie's behavior.
1 likeBefore watching the video I thought that it was because she ALWAYS possessed some Chaos Magic.
0 likesAfter watching: Yeah.
3:31 well yeah, cozy glow was an alicorn at the time, Pinky, though, was an earth pony.
0 likesI’m not saying your wrong. Because you stand a pretty good point my friend,
0 likesBut I bet it’s just 70% Discord’s magic and 30% of Pinkie just being Pinkie 😋
just my opinion on why the magic had a more permanent state with pinky and not cozy glow is because cozy glow was trying to use the magic in a structured way and not chaotically like the magic is intended where as for pink when she used the magic she en-braised the chaos and didn't try to put any rules or structure to it there for the magic ended up staying with her because it felt like it belonged there in a way sorry if this doesn't make sense just what i was thinking of why it effected them in different ways
0 likesI do believe she can tap into chaos magic I just don't think it's from that event because cheese sandwich while only in 1 episode could also do stuff that defies logic what if all party ponys can use chaos magic
0 likesI think the only person to rival Pinkie Pie or even be close to being her, is a character name Jyushimatsu-san from the anime Osomatsu-san. If you watch the anime which is a literal comedy and anything random can happen. The character Jyushimatsu-san can literally do anything with a smile on his face!
0 likesWho knew BIG lore was in a show for any age
0 likes0:10 you should watch the video titled Eqestria Girls (bloopers compared to actual scenes) and whenever you see the one involving pinkie pie where she holds the purple lollipop you’ll understand it all well for the Otherworld knowledge part
1 likePinkie Pie is a Toon. A fourth waller. A super sane. No, it isn't a typo. Super sane. Smarter than your average character to the point of knowing they are fictional. That's it.
0 likesSolving Pinkie Pie? INCONCEIVABLE!
0 likesSo... How'd she get the magic from the bell? She's an Earth Pony!
0 likesShe didn’t have her powers when she was born, but later on she had them when she was born.
0 likesI think the reason Pinky Pie was affected and Cosy wasn’t is because Cosy wanted to dominate, while Pinky wanted it so she can be with it, one wanted control, the other just wanted it for fun
0 likeswell one thing is it seems other pies have their own senses, but i do like this idea.
0 likesChaos magic DOESN'T operate under string theory!
0 likesWhere do the Kirin's come in? They have an episode but how did they come to be? Who are the Kirin's? What are the Kirin's and why can they be lit on fire? I have many questions but they may be answered by the series I haven't finished it
0 likesThis the best theory ever makes so much sense
0 likesso Cozy was turned into an allicorn so maybe instead of pinkie becoming an allicorn, the chaos spread throughout her life
1 likei want to say a theory about mlp so when sombra broke the elements its magic escaped to sunsets world so i think thats how the magic hit that cave in the everfree forest and that solves question sunset said that "where did the magic came that hit this cave ;
0 likesNot relating to this video but I was rewatching the finale of the show and i noticed when you see flurry hearts glass window a few frames before you see sweetie bell and some yellow I imagine the yellow would be apple bloom and off screen would be scootaloo what did the quite mark crusaders do to earn a stained glass window. Out of context in this in the same episode when twilight is reading they news paper you see (I think)
0 likesLyra and bonbon getting married
THEY ArE MARRIED
And 8 think doctor hooves has a wife during the coronation idk
If you see this dont show my name thankyou
BUTT if that one moment of chaos affected pinkies entire life what about cheese sandwich? He can do the exact same as pinkie including pulling things out of thin air so why are they so simular?
1 likewait but it may affected Cozy glow because we dont really go fully in depth with her past or at least not what i remember so she might have had the same affects and as the show went on pinkie was still crazy so if Cozy glow didnt get turned to stone then we may of seen the chaos unfold i her
0 likesHow can you solve perfection?
0 likescan you plz tell me why in the world most unicorns shoot fireworks? Like tempest shadow? or trixie? like come on! why can't they do something else?
1 likeGrunkle Stan while watching this video: I think I need more coffee for farther coffee spits!
0 likesI just realised in the song ( the magic of friendship grows ) when twilight made a rainbow with the horn every single teacher had 1 of the student 6 so maybe thats their element??
0 likesThat means that Pinkie Dayamana Pie is still out there waiting for her chance to replace PP here and I think that when Pinkie got her Cuite Mark her evil twin came out of her and I think she will definitely come in Pony Life that is the new Sieris that Hasbro will release soon
0 likesI never noticed taht pinkie got thay lil' pink ball thing. I think you're right. I mean she does have pinkie sense but she said it only interacts with instint things. like a falling flower pot.
0 likesSawtooth Waves: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!!!!! me: yes
3 likesMe now when I'm typing this: XD
I have little thing to say. It might help. But the magic what came to Pinkies nose wasnt maybe some special sort of magic just the pinkie sense come back. The thing that she have experiences from another dimension is showed in equestria girls shorts where Pinkies from both world just go through portal. They even saw themself. Than we know that Pinkie have a lot of things hiden through ponyville( if someone know that she pulled something out of nowhere and she wasnt in ponyville just say it). The braking of 4 wall well i havent for explained that yet.
1 likeReplies (1)
Oh wait i have it ,maybe the pinkie sense and braking 4 wall really came from discord magic. We know that when she was only a filly she was same as her sisters but thanks to the rainboom she sawed that day die felt happy and that everyone should fell this happines its impossible that she got her sense and abylity to break 4 wall just from seeing big rainbow.
1 likeSawtooth: is someone watching me? me: yeah, us
0 likesThis guy is so smart :)
0 likesi don't know about the pinkie sense part but i have a theory about the part of how cozy glow did not get the magic as well so i think it matter is how the pony uses the magic cozy glow used it for evil evil and sense discord does not use his magic for evil anymore (well i think) and pinkie used it for chaos like it was meant to be used so it stuck longer with pinkie pie but that's my theory
1 likeReplies (1)
woooooow i ffeel Big brain (not) ;-;
0 likesSomething tells me that I have my eye on Pinkie Pie
0 likesI think the student six have a combination of the pillars element and the mane six maybe
1 likeI have a theroy about the episode pinkie apple pie. When the part about pies and apple being related was sumged, I think it might have ment pear scince they are related kinda, even though they are related from apple Jack's parents not apple sauce applejacks great great granny. I hope you use this theroy in one of your videos, or at least read it and consider using it in one of your videos, thank you.
0 likesI love this theory
1 likeit's both just her craziness got amplified
0 likesBut what about Maud sense? Pinkie did say it "runs in the family."
0 likesHere’s a question about Princess Luna. WHY does her hair NOT flow when she is reformed back from being Nightmare moon in season one?
2 likesReplies (2)
Because her magic was too weak. Princess Celestia is really strong, you see, and futuristic Twilight, too. They are already used to their powers, and their at it's peak. Luna wasn't yet used to her magic yet.
1 like@Naila Nigar also not to mention she was young what do you expect she didn't hit puberty until season 2 which is kind of strange
0 likesSawtooth:Is someone watching me ?
0 likesMe:Ya it’s your job
i think that magic was something to do with her laughter maybe
1 likeYou will never solve Pinkie pie
0 likesNever I tell you
NEVER
We won't know until we see how Pinkie's child acts
0 likesSawtooth: Is someone watching _me_?
0 likesViewers: No- well yes.
Wait, but didn’t pinkie say that her six sense runs in the family?
0 likesCould you plaese do a video about what happens if two different ponytyps get children,for example an earthe pony and a pegasus?😁🧡
0 likesOk i get what hes trying to say, but when he said "thats why she can Break All the fission" Im Like wait didnt she take all his magic On the VERY last Ep?!
3 likesAlso ppl Take these way to sirously! xD Its A Kids Show ment for kids xD
Replies (1)
that's never an excuse and i'm a kid and i do it i don't care
0 likesok you got it?
Twilight after watching this: pinkie com here I need to monitor you.
0 likesPinkie: twilight I don’t think that is nessesery you know I was (says what you said in 1 sentence)
I think Pinkie is simply just Pinkie
0 likesand Pinkie doesn't care about cartoon rules
Doesss he know that pinkie and discord is just breaking the 4rth wall?
0 likesi think differently becauce maud has the same pinky sense maud sense so it was not chaos magic
0 likesbut something else entirely
Pinkie:hi I'm insane and funny also chaotic
2 likesMe: STEALS PINKIE FROM HER PLANET AND BRINGS HER TO MINE Now pinkie
Solve world hunger
Gonna tell my kids this is the story of jesus
0 likesOkay just hear me out how cadence became an alicorn but more canon because canon what if she got here wings or horn or both st the same time she got her cutie mark for spreading love between others or CREATING romantic love between others because she is the princess of romantic and motherly love and we know she wasn’t a mother or had fallen in love with shining armor at the time she had met twilight unless shining armor and her dated secretly for a few years before even meeting but it seems a little off so I’m gonna assume that they started dating afterwards also I feel like twilight velvet I Bilieve that’s her name also could have gotten an opportunity to become the princess of motherly ness maybe she reaches it to twilight to reconnect more after spending so long away from eachother with all the princess stuff and cadence could be the princess of love for all because she shows a lot of love to her subjects more than she does for shining armor even tho there love if definitely strong I donno I’d have to plan it out more and not just ramble like this but I have no clue what this was originally about
0 likesOk not really a brony anymore, but that was kinda cool !
0 likesShe's Pinkie Pie the party-planning pony no explanation needed we all know Pinkie Pie will forever remain a mystery and how she do it on stuff you do
0 likesReplies (1)
No we have to start figuring this out it's our destiny
0 likesoh my god you’ve done it holy shit
0 likesSees title:
0 likes"Wait thats illigal."
Pinkie Pie she has been confuseing me after I saw her manners she has magic that no other Earth Pony hase remember when Pinkie Pie is sad she turns into her evil twin Pinkie Dayamana Pie you know when Pinkie got upset in the episode Party Of One I notesed something right before turning into Pinkie Dayamana Pie I saw her mane get even for poofy and suddenly her mane and tale got flat at that acsact second her colour went dark and grayish pink and when Rainbow Dash came Pinkie was angry and she had a pile of rocks there to
0 likesCould be that pinkie got those power when the rainboom happened and could be the magic she received was her pinkie sense
0 likesThis is smart and all... but you broke the golden rule. ITS PINKIE PIE. DONT QUESTION IT.
0 likesIt doesn't effect Cozy glow because she already became an alicorn and pinkie pie was a earth pony alicorn magic can control it but pinkie pie cant
0 likesSawtooth Waves: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!!!!! me: yes
0 likesMe now when I'm typing this: XD
Maybe twilight was haunted by the the spirit of harmony
0 likesBrony can u make a vid about the princesses hair because in season nine without there magic it became normal... As soon as discord gives There magic there hair became all wavy and pretty again like 🤔🤔🤔 and if it's alicorn magic why does cadence not have it.......and what does cadence look like In the end...And in the song This is where the magic happens if u look closely the stain glass windows flurry heart and the young six are on there What happened? What did they accomplish? All of us know that to go on the stain glass windows Is IMPORTANT and where are the princesses did they die did cadence die? What is flurry hearts cutey mark?
1 likeSO MANY QUESTIONS Please answer the hair question if you only want to do 1
Pinky wanted to discord to stay bc of chocolate rain so there so related
1 likeRemember pinkies pinkie sense that's what landed on her when magic was realeased
0 likesPinkie pie is like quantum mechanics. If you think you understand pinkie than you dont understand pinkie
0 likesDo you have a different channel? I feel like I used to watch your videos a long time ago, but wasn’t your name something else? Your oc is really familiar to my brain.
0 likesThe 6 yr olds just wanting to watch ponies singing and dancing: 👁👄👁
0 likesBefore she got her chaos magic how did she get the bell? Without pinkies magic the mane 6 woul be defeated already.
0 likesalso, the equestria girls thing where both pinkies know what happened in the other universe
0 likesHow did pinkie know about the cloning thing
0 likesI know this vid is not for cutie marks but remember when you posted 6 years ago why cutie come in three THREE IS THE MAGICAL NUMBER!!! I fund the resin!!! I think?
0 likesI thought it could have been her pinkie sense.
0 likesWhen you said creature I WAS LIKE:
0 likesBRUH SHES A PONY!!!
I have a qUESTION...
0 likesAre they ponies like, 1000 years old? ._.
Can you create a pony, a EG that is a boy and a changeling OC of me?
0 likesBut even her sis Maud also has a sense that's weird
0 likes2:03 sawtooth; so did pinky pie her magic
0 likesme; OMG HE RIGHT
I have a theory that could explain mlp it’s goes like this humans evacuated the earth due to a meteor but stray animals hid a few years later pints start coming if you agree reply
0 likesPinkie and Discord break the fourth wall
0 likesCan you do luna ghost friend from her childhood :)
0 likesI think that Pinkie was born with some helth conditionand her parants took her to Selestia and she gave har majic to save her life
0 likesPinkie HAS THE POWER
1 likeShe is the Deadpool of Mlp well obviously she doesn’t kill but she does break the fourth wall and has broken a lot of rules.
0 likesShe's the kid friendly version of Deadpool shhhhhhh-
0 likesAND YES I KNOW... that was 6 years ago, so please don't judge me for a slight time difference!
0 likesWhy is there FBI at my door
0 likesthats soo fascinating
0 likesRemember when u made the vid four years ago and said why are other crystal more powerful then others spike could of ate one then he got his magic of how he can send letters to the Princesses but if u don’t remember then WELP IM OUT BYEEEE
0 likesWhy not i think she got a little of discord magic
1 likeNext do About Sunset Shimmer and StarLight Glimmer
0 likesIT'S PINKIE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT SHE IS CRAZY
0 likesUm guys she didnt took only chaos magic she took
0 likesAllicorn magic to guys!!she took celestia and luna's magic guys look watch the ending of the end seriously.like if agree
You can't solve pinkie pie. It's impossible
0 likesNO ONE CAN SOLVE THE PIE OF THE PINKIES!
0 likesuh actually its..wrong if only pinkie affected past then why this scene is a thing.
0 likesscene:wait let me get it(Wait..)
Just search the maud sense scene in youtube.and Pinki says "Runs in the family"
Gypsy magic friendship is witch craft
0 likesThese video always gave ne head aches😁
0 likesMy little pony ban in India 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 how I see My Little Pony in Hindi
1 likeOr maybe, just maybe Pinkie and Discord are related!🤯
0 likesReplies (1)
Samsuna Mohamed Hussain maybe not related but somehow similar
0 likesWhat are the Crystal Prep students cutie marks?
0 likesI think you can't solvd pinkie , she is just a gag and the magic who got back to her is just an error and pinkie is just pinkie 🤗 sorry for not belive in you 😔
0 likesPinkie pie will become pinky queen of cupcakes and happiness because she’s picky
0 likesMy Little Pony season 10 lounch? You think love from India
1 likeIs king sombra a unicorn?
0 likesNow for some reason now i think discord is related to pinkie pie ●~●
1 likemaby it infected more then cozy glow is that she alrady had a fun personality
0 likesTheres 2 of every pony or person in the human world and in equestrian but where is sunset shimmer in human world ?
1 likeHim:IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?
0 likesMe:rn 89 million yes
Stop being silly because pinkie represents laughter and because of her element she us the way she is
0 likesyour right!😶
0 likesYou will find him on my dear luna song
0 likesboi its pinkie dont question it you fool you shouldnt question it also maud has maud sense all pinkies siblings have their sense of sorts
0 likesPinkie should be out of the mane 6
0 likesi have the answer she is a god
0 likesRainboom + Chaos = pinkie pie.
0 likesWhat about Cheese Sanwich
0 likesWill you for more videos???? Please say yea
0 likesYes I'm watching you Watch me watch you watch mlp
0 likesi watched one video now i have mlp on my reccommended again, oh no
0 likesPlease solve Discord
0 likesCan u pls do a face reveal?
0 likesI think there's something wrong with my Netflix the next season is not coming out for me 😭 so I have to watch your old videos so it's not bloopers for me and I have to wait for season 9 to come out 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
0 likes0:4 nightmares xd
1 likeIt’s not that because that was in season 9 when she did and all that stuff like that happened it’s just pinkie not discoed I mean they both are the same but It’s prob when Discord did that thing where he made the applejack a lier fluttershy rude rainbow dash selfish rarity idk and pinkie just got some thing more than the others
0 likesNo one can solve pinky pie
0 likes1:50 yes..
1 likeWhy did Pinki pie get magic!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesHas anyone who watches "My Little Pony Friendship is Magic" that Pinkie Pie is the most odd pony in the series. Well I've notice this a lot, Pinkie Pie maybe the element of Laughter but she is so oblivious when it comes to knowing her own familys. Her friends see them as odd becausae of their personality and obesses with rocks but Pinkie Pie sees them as normal especially her own sister Maud. In The "Maud Couple" Pinkie Pie think that Mudbriar is super weird but Starlight Glimmer point out that Maud is the same way too but once again Pinkie Pie continued to be so oblivious that Starlight Glimmer is telling the truth and to acknowledge the facts about Maud. So in my opinion Pinkie Pie is the weirdest in her family because she doesn't see anything wrong with them. Which I may have a theory why Pinkie Pie is not like her family because she maybe adopted rather be born in the family because she's the only pony who is pink while the rest of her family are grey.
2 likesYAS PINKIEEEEE
0 likesWhat about cheese sandwich
1 like#MYFAVORITEYOUTUBER
0 likesI don’t have a question About this but something About mlp do pony’s die?
0 likesCozy is a child cozy's future????? We don't know what is cozy's future
0 likesI got cHiLlS
1 likeI solved pinky pie
0 likes1:50 no I’m reading the comments..... jk
1 likeInteresting
0 likesPinkie pie is Discord.
0 likes🍫😋
1 likeYes we are
0 likesSincethe all apeared once already
0 likeshay i have a queshton becuse pinky pie has to fams the one at the bacory and the rock plz find out why??
0 likeswow
0 likesHey uhm, you might not respond but where can I watch mlp season 9 I’ve been waiting so long to watch it
1 likeReplies (1)
Hulu
0 likesIs someone watching me? Me and another 88 111 people: Uhhhhhhhhhmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.....
0 likesShes the most- nevermind
0 likesReplies (1)
*questionable*
0 likesYes
0 likesPinkie senses?
0 likesReplies (1)
It's like Spider Senses but in Equestria
0 likesShe haves pinkie Senace
0 likesno pinky is pinky
0 likesHi I'm an alicorn
0 likespinkie pie
0 likespinkie pie
0 likesTrue
0 likesWait I now what fluttershy magic talk to animal ok
1 likeBut what about pinkie s3es
0 likesoar can ewe
0 likesum ok
0 likesThat is becas cosigloo is wings
0 likesSo Ture
0 likesoo cool
0 likes