Scary reminder: Pinkie has a child now, and what makes it worst is that she had it with Cheese Sandwich. What chaos have they brought upon the world?!?!

@gummy bear gamer nothing wrong with having a baby, but she’s Pinkie Pie who can pass down whatever insane genes she has

What's wrong with having a baby she's 40 years old

What's wrong with having a baby she's 40 years old

Wait if pinkie has a child does that mean maud is an ant

Wait if pinkie has a child does that mean maud is an ant

@Thomas Stump You pass on everything in Dna, not just your sex chromesomes.

@wonderhoyzz Oh because Pie is a dessert, omg

@wonderhoyzz Oh because Pie is a dessert, omg

Oh celestia sake please dont say it oh boy nuh uh 😦😶 nope please celestia no uhuh nuuh

Ok then pinkie is just being pinkie but that doesn't explain the magic that came to her what was magic that doesn't make sense how?

@Thomas Stump WHICH MEANS IN A FEW THOUSAND GENERATIONS SOME 2 PINKIE RELATIVES HAVE A CHILD AND DISCORD WILL MEET HIS MATCH

yeah, her child is called lil cheese and is yellow so..her husband is cheese sandwich.

Discord needs to boost his level it gonna soon be more chaotic

Discord needs to boost his level it gonna soon be more chaotic

Imagine  if it's actually the pure opposite of it's parents

Imagine  if it's actually the pure opposite of it's parents

Discord isn't the Spirit of Chaos,it is actually Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich's child. <b>DUN DUN DUUUUUUUN</b>

Discord isn't the Spirit of Chaos,it is actually Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich's child. *DUN DUN DUUUUUUUN*

@wonderhoyzz his name is cheese sandwich

@wonderhoyzz his name is cheese sandwich

@•☆•smol snowfall•♡• I think we all know Fluttershy and Discord is the only way to have it

Be grateful that it wasn't with discord the amount of chaos pinkie + discord = world of chaos

It's been a year. AND CHEESE SANDWICH?!😭 THAT'S LIKE THE WHOLE DESTRUCTION OF EQUESTRIA

Can someone please tell me the music of 1:16

Can someone please tell me the music of 1:16

Cheese has the party sense, it has the same symptoms as pinkie pie has, but he is not preventing disasters, he knows where to go to host the party, maybe they both are somehow magical earth ponies?

Wait so did pinkies kid inherited her powers?

Wait so did pinkies kid inherited her powers?

@Agent Isabelle discord almost lost to pijoke in his dimension that would drive almost snlypony crazy but he say pijoke might feel iHome there

thir child is going to be a pony accountant

thir child is going to be a pony accountant

@Rachel Alfarowdym? No. In season 9, pinkie pie said "It was so hard to find a fool sitter (forgot how to spell it) with a sense of humor for lil' cheese."

@Thomas Stump Too many complicated words for me to understand srry

@Thomas Stump Too many complicated words for me to understand srry

The new queen of chaos for when Discord is sick!

The new queen of chaos for when Discord is sick!

Oh like a innocent little bean like lil cheese is gonna destroy the world.

I actually backup that theory I think that would happen in season 10 but it never ever came out

Doesn't she have 3 or was I confused during the entire time during that scene?

@RichyWhistles sooooooooo just a regular child XD

@RichyWhistles sooooooooo just a regular child XD

Oh no I've watched this like 10 times and I JUST noticed this what has pinky done?!

@hannah no, maybe she doesn't want to be in a relationship with anypony, because it would make sense why there isn't a king, or maybe she isn't into guys.

AnimalLover18 Does anyone else likes animals

@• L1zziebear • yes but i think Cheesecake is a girl

@• L1zziebear • yes but i think Cheesecake is a girl

You actually made me scared and not make me go close to my computer

You actually made me scared and not make me go close to my computer

Thinking about it
Gives me chills
But yet I can't stop thinking about it
I'm happy and surprise
I can t example well
Im still thinking about it today!

@Mahilet Tekelsillasshe lil cheese is adorable

@Mahilet Tekelsillasshe lil cheese is adorable

Pinkieshy LPS I don’t think you understand what Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich are capable of and how having a child could bring more chaos then Discord ever could.

Whats so wrong with them having a kid? I ship them, and they’re kid is really cute

i think the one that they lost their magic, i think the wrong magic came to pinkie pie

The next series: MIGHTY MORPHIN' PONY RANGERS! Villain: Little Cheese.

The next series: MIGHTY MORPHIN' PONY RANGERS! Villain: Little Cheese.

London prestige ltd Tourists And services

Oh God it'll be more power full then discards kud

Oh God it'll be more power full then discards kud

@Draconic lorecraft <b>*Runs from current location to The moon*</b> AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

@Draconic lorecraft **Runs from current location to The moon** AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

Jevil: I CAN DO-<br>Pinkie's son: you were saying?

Jevil: I CAN DO-
Pinkie's son: you were saying?

Discord will be like her awesome, fun uncle XD

Discord will be like her awesome, fun uncle XD

The problem with giving characters children is that now they're the age of old grandparents and still have children that are as old, or younger, than the cmc.

wait... I haven't seen all of season nine eye-

wait... I haven't seen all of season nine eye-

THEY BROUGHT LARGE CHAOS MORE POWERFUL THEN DISCORD'S POWER

*THEY BROUGHT LARGE CHAOS* *MORE POWERFUL THEN DISCORD'S POWER*

@Mini Thakur it's not that they're married it's that the chaos may have passed to their child

Hey! It ok that she is married to Cheese sandwich they both compliment each other

Sad Reminder: Big Mac broke Marble Pies Heart

Sad Reminder: Big Mac broke Marble Pies Heart

@Thomas Stump But both parents do have it... CHEESECAKE WILL DESTROY EQUESTRIA!

Oh god no-
Pinkie, you have made both a grave mistake. And a very amazing choice.
Cheesecake is the true being of chaos, not Discord, not Pinkie, and not Cheese Sandwich. Lil Cheese is the true chaos being. He will rule the cosmos!

While it did bind with her DNA, it most likely didn’t affect her sex chromosomes just to make sure that it wasn’t passed on. But if it did, it would’ve become a homogeneous recessive gene meaning that both parents have the rare trait in order for it to show in the offspring.

A CHEESE SANDWICH!!!!!!! THIS IS CRAZYER THAN DIWCORDS KID, SCREWBALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! RUN FOR YOUR LIFE!!!!!!!!

So did Cadence and Shining Armor, Mrs and Mr Cake, Mr and Mrs Sparkle, and everyone else in the world. But our lord and savior Celestia is too pure and holy so she adopted Cadence🤣🤣

Discord has some competition for chaos lord

Discord has some competition for chaos lord

Wouldnt be surprised if that filly becomes like Maud's boyfriend

Wouldnt be surprised if that filly becomes like Maud's boyfriend


Everything makes sense in your explanation except for one occasion which wasn't considered.

When Pinkie Pie, Rarity, and Maud had that one meet-up (I believe the episode is 'The Gift of Maud Pie' - S6, E3), Maud 'sensed' and knew where the guy to whom Pinkie traded her canon was. As Rarity enquired, Pinkie answered with something along the lines of: "Yeah it goes down/through the family." and shrugged it off.

Tbf, maid could sense a person, but pinkie can sense a point in time. There's a difference between sensing the future and sensing a person

Plus, it’s also odd how pinkie got pink skin and pink curly hair while the rest of her family members seem to have a grey-ish complex with straight hair

Can someone please tell me the music of 1:16

maybe it just kept going? if it went through pinkies whole timeline, maybe it went to mom pie and dad pie too. why stop there? chaos magic is inherently un explainable.

i think rather than it being proof that discord's magic affected her past.....

pinkie sense is WHY it affected her past.

Also the only reason she was able to handle it.

Her Pinkie sense made her able to distribute magic through her timeline. Which in turn meant that when she got discord's magic she was able to handle it.

Maybe when Pinkie made the rock candy when she was a<br>filly she put her manic in it and maud ate one little piece and it got ttrafured to her

Maybe when Pinkie made the rock candy when she was a
filly she put her manic in it and maud ate one little piece and it got ttrafured to her

Maud/Pinkie sense could be the Pie family's version of earth pony magic- their "connection to the earth", as it will.
Maybe it's specifically because Pinkie has that sense, and specifically because it relates to time and predictions, that the chaos magic scattered through the timeline for her, but not for Cozy.

Maud/Pinkie sense could be the Pie family's version of earth pony magic- their "connection to the earth", as it will.
Maybe it's specifically _because_ Pinkie has that sense, and specifically _because_ it relates to time and predictions, that the chaos magic scattered through the timeline for her, but not for Cozy.

Rarity: however did you know that?
Maud: maud sense.
Pinkie: runs in the family!

@crab But I mean, Pinkie's sense seems stronger than the rest of her family.

Maybe an ancestor of Pinkie had absorbed Discord’s magic, without losing it, and it had passed through the family, slowly growing weaker? I’m unsure. Maybe discord isn’t that old to be able to have that happen.

@Puppygirlman18 Maybe it's because of the chaos magic. I think that's what happened. So she did have that pie sense, but the magic had an influence on it, which made it stronger. It would also make sense as to why Cozy Glow didn't have the effect Pinkie Pie did.

@Jamie L youve got a point there! They do have that pie family trait of rock farmers.

@Puppygirlman18 Maybe part Crystal Pony?? Would make sense why the family likes rocks lol

"Pie Sense" could be truly genetics, maybe a slightly different race of pony??? A magic earth pony? Who knows. But Pinkie Pie still has extra magic that the other Pies don't seem to have (manipulating gravity, pulling stuff out of thin air, etc)


This and, discord can be seen doing a jiggle similar to the "pinkie sense" when all the princesses gave twilight their magic to keep it safe in the episode Twilight's castle.

@Stefan Kocoski yes and he can break dimensions

Actually Discord sensed that there is magic gone

You remember when he says his ears are burning?? He can be all knowing in a way


Sawtooth Waves: so I finally solved Pinkie Pie--
Twilight: WRITE THAT DOWN! WRITE THAT DOWN!

Sawtooth Waves: so I finally solved Pinkie Pie--
Twilight: WRITE THAT DOWN! _WRITE THAT DOWN!_

@PinkiePiePlays wait...<br>If you look into the camera... CAN U SEE US!?

@PinkiePiePlays wait...
If you look into the camera... CAN U SEE US!?

@PinkiePiePlays I mean you're a fun loving horse

Pinkie pie is the most annoying horse you ever met


Sawtooth: “Pinkie’s powers came from absorbing Discord’s magic.”<br>Fauna Joy: “*Party pony magic*”

Sawtooth: “Pinkie’s powers came from absorbing Discord’s magic.”
Fauna Joy: “*Party pony magic*”

Can someone please tell me the music of 1:16

Actually he not entirely
Wrong they a
Comic when discord is having trouble using his power after tirek stole them and thwss a rift to discrird dimension left open and pinke pie fell into and learnt the rules of chaos as what ever pops into your mind happensd and pinke learnt the rules to it

what if all magic came from that bell?<br>or did he just steal it from somehere?

what if all magic came from that bell?
or did he just steal it from somehere?


The reason why the chaos magic didn't spread throughout cozy glow's time line was because at the time she was an Alicorn, meaning she could handle all of the magic. but pinkie is just a earth pony, so that's why it spread out through her timeline only.

@Amayah Johnson Because she was rapidly showing signs of getting drunk on that much power....  She could control it, that doesn't mean she wouldn't abuse the heck out of it much the same way Discord himself used to.... It started with chocolate rain, but sooner or later her warping reality to her whims would likely hurt those around her, regardless of her intent....

@Double Guyzer Maybe it was a difference between how they approached their use of it due to their personalities.... Cozy Glow tried to control it, as her nature was that of one who seeks dominance and control.... The magic rejected her as a result.... Pinky on the other-hand... She already had a chaotic and carefree attitude, and tendency to just do things without considering the consequences....  She didn't try to control the chaos, she embraced it and so it empowered her to act on whims she was otherwise powerless to act on.... Had Discord not siphoned off the excess of chaos magic she might well have caused just as much havoc he does when he's not reigning himself in....

ur thinking inside the chimney u smart cookie

ur thinking inside the chimney u smart cookie

? Can someone explain this to me. This sounds like it has nothing to do with canon or this theory

Good idea that makes sense mostly except she wasn’t a true real alicorn (like twilight) she was just a “fake one” because nothing happen d like it happened with twilight she might have observed but in a different way

@S K well since cozy glow already had a lot of magic, she was able to control it a little bit more than Pinkie, like probably just enough to stop it from influencing the rest of her timeline

It's also because Pinkie has a part of her which is connected to time which is her Pinkie Sense. It's hard to understand but think of it this way. Cozy had an alicorn body so it could contain the chaos magic but Pinkie has an earth pony body which can't contain all the magic on its own and her Pinkie sense acts like a hole in her time period in which chaos magic can leak out and affect Pinkie's entire essence in the past, present, and future.

@Lucretia Thomas <br>And don’t forget that at the time Pinkie absorbed the magic in the bell, it also had Princess Celestia’s and Luna’s magic in it as well as discord’s. That is a lot of magic for and earth pony to absorb all at once.

@Lucretia Thomas
And don’t forget that at the time Pinkie absorbed the magic in the bell, it also had Princess Celestia’s and Luna’s magic in it as well as discord’s. That is a lot of magic for and earth pony to absorb all at once.

Lucretia Thomas twilight was able to absorb 3 alicorn’s magic, it not getting capped. I dont think that discord’s magic could be much more than one alicorn’s magic, so cozy glow has a good chance at still the magic not getting capped.

true, not in it's entirety, but what's to say that since cozy glow already had alicorn magic, the amount of chaos magic she could absorb was capped before she absorbed discord's magic in it's entirety.

@RedPandaGirl <br>Why should we not trust him? He makes a good argument. If you don’t believe him, I would appreciate counter argument.

@RedPandaGirl
Why should we not trust him? He makes a good argument. If you don’t believe him, I would appreciate counter argument.

Hey do not trust sawtooth waves it's just a teary omg you guys don't even know that sawtooth waves is a teary

@KittyandLychee Ya i figured I just didn't want anyone else asking some question like well if Pinkie can control a bit of chaos magic than she can control the rest or something like that

P.S. I’m not saying Pinkie Pie had full control of Discord’s magic, I am just saying she had a little more control over it than Cozy did.

@Anti Social Weeb I wasn’t saying that Discord’s magic didn’t spread through Pinkie’s life, I am just saying that because Pinkie Pie had Discord’s magic in her life, it would explain how she (kind of) able to control how and where to drop the giant cupcake. My main point is that Pinkie was able to control Discord’s magic better than Cozy, because she had a lifetime of practice.

@KittyandLychee Pinkie might know how to control a % of discord's magic but does that mean she'll be able to handle the rest. In the show we have seen pinkie do stuff that normal earth ponies can't but we've never seen like the advanced stuff that discord does like turning building upside down or opening portals to other realms by herself. Say Pinkie has 10% of discords magic, she has had her entire life to master that, do we don't really know if Pinke can handle the rest. Take Twight for an example, she's an alicorn and the legit embodiment of magic yet she had trouble with containing all 4 alicorn's magic, along with hers. Chaos magic is either as strong as the 4 alicorns or stronger since in one of the timelines that Starlight made, discord took over equestria and their were 3 alicorns at the time with the entire nation. So if anyone says that pinkie is able to handle magic that is basically on par with an entire nation plus 3 alicorns as soon as she got it right off the bat, I think you need to double check your facts(I don't say this to offend anyone)

@Anti Social Weeb Also Pinkie already knew how to control a little bit of discord’s magic from he life. She probably knew how to control the whole thing to some extent.

@S K tirek absorbed his magic once which is a fact

@S K tirek absorbed his magic once which is a fact

@Surayaa Pinkie just wanted to have fun and make people laugh and cause chaos so the chaos power allowed itself to be used by Pinkie but Cozy wanted to use it to harm others and to destroy all balance and take over the planet but the chaos magic isn't supposed to do that so it didn't allow Cozy to use it's power. It's kinda like the magic has a mind of it's own and deems if the user is worthy enough to use it's power to it's full extend. Discord did take over for a sort period of time but unlike Cozy Discord made everything chaotic.

It seemed to me like Pinkie could control Discord's power to her will, making it drop a giant cupcake out of the sky when she wanted to drop a giant cupcake out of the sky. Cozy however seemed to have no control seeing as her attempts to attack Tirek and Chysalis ended in rubber chickens and sentient pineapples

@Kiran shravan voleti I mean I would assume so since she's an Alicorn as well. All the Alicorns probably can handle the amount of magic but they would n't be able to successfully use the magic in a fight, Celestia and Luna might be able to use the dimension travel magic because they already have exprience with traveling to other dimensions.

So if Luna absorbed all of that magic she could handle it

So if Luna absorbed all of that magic she could handle it

@Àíďàñ But they certainly do have potential, Just look at Twilight she had the power of all the alicorns but that never effected her. The magic of 4 alicorns should be close to the power discord contains

This is an very good theory but no Ali corn has ever seemed to have CHAOS magic it just doesn't add up

This is a pretty good idea, but my opinion is that it affected all of her timeline because she didn't want to use it for evil, only chaos, what it was intended to be used for.

Or she has no connection to a different point in time like pinky pie. Pinky pie has her pinkie sences which is not in the same time as her. Side note I think the real reason why Cozy didn't have chaos magic in her time was not because she was an Alicorn but she has not connection to a different point in time. Chaos magic is too powerful to be handled by anyone but discord so being an Alicorn wouldn't have made the difference and she was only an Alicorn for a short period of time. Another reason would be that Cozy is still just a fillie and would have probably died if it weren't for the Alicorn enhancement. Pinky was able to handle the chaos magic because she was already infused with chaos magic. I think that eventually she'll become as powerful as discord because the power would just keep stocking up as that period of time goes by.

@Double Guyzer Just because it fits in your mouth doesn't mean you can swallow the whole thing!

Intriguing theory. Not to mention making a ton of sense.

Intriguing theory. Not to mention making a ton of sense.

@Me aaaAAA that makes total sense. Also cozy glows model look more similar to a grown alicorn, where pinky's transformation is more chaotic look.

If I remember correctly during the part before Cozy Glow got discord's chaos power she said something like 'Give me a taste of the power'. I think she just gains a small amount of discord's power. While Pinky, on the other hand, gained 10 times more power than Cozy, all of it probably.
When Cozy gained the chaos magic, her surrounding was quite tame while Pinky made her surrounding turn pink and filled with balloons, ice-cream, candy and other party stuff.
I also think when they drained Cozy Glow from the chaos magic, they drained every inch of it and none was left but when Discord just took away the bell from Pinky, a tiny amount of the chaos magic could have just stuck with her.

She said Cozy’s body could handle it. She didn’t say Cozy could control it.

She said Cozy’s body could handle it. She didn’t say Cozy could control it.

If she could control it why did she have to change back?

If she could control it why did she have to change back?

And Pinkie probably absorbed the Princess’s magic because it was in the bell when Pinkie took in the bell’s magic.

Rida Fatima Khan im not saying cozy controlled the magic, she certainly didn’t, but she was at least able to contain it

Or maybe it's because Pinkie had her own sort of chaotic magic (Pinkie sense) so she was used to random bursts of power and twichy tails but I don't think it was because she was an earth pony Pinkie is different from others and I don't think anyone would be able to control such chaotic magic as Discord's other than Pinkie, Discord and maybe Cheese Sandwich?🤔💥

Ummmmmmmm<br>No creature can control discords magic.well of course apart from discord.

Ummmmmmmm
No creature can control discords magic.well of course apart from discord.

oh did you notes two things she took more than cosy glow i can tell from the surrounding lightning she has<br>and she had a decent amount of control.oh she got the alicorn powers from the magic sorry

oh did you notes two things she took more than cosy glow i can tell from the surrounding lightning she has
and she had a decent amount of control.oh she got the alicorn powers from the magic sorry


i just imagine Twilight thinking back on Pinkie Pie and realizing why Pinkie is Pinkie and she just goes "OH YOU HAVE GOT TO BE KIDDING ME!"

@o same but not only this time..

I think it has something to do remembering


Plot Twist:

Pinky is actually a unicorn but no one (or should I say no pony) can see it because it's hidden under her poofy mane XD.

Ok ok everypony.
Im actually a alicorn
I hid it
Its actually hidden in my mane and my wings lol

Can someone please tell me the music of 1:16

But When Pinkie Is Sad, Her Mane Deflates And It Shows No Horn

@EyeofArtemis818 alicorns are both with wings and horn. Unicorns have only a horn, pegasus is with wings

pinkie with straight hair reading this like: <br>👁👄👁

pinkie with straight hair reading this like:
👁👄👁

Ah but her mane deflates and donsent show a horn ... Unless she cast a spell to make her horn invisible hmmmm... I'll have to look in to that


3:30 Now that I think about it, even though Cozy Glow isn't as chaotic as pinkie, she still will sometimes pull stuff from nowhere, like when she was with the other villains planning to go up the mountain to retrieve Grogar's bell she suddenly had s'more making materials despite not bringing any.  She also is known for making over the top facial expressions, and maybe having chaos magic helps with that idk.  I think some of the chaos magic did spread through Cozy's timeline.

Is it a stretch? Yes.
Is it just a coincidence? Yes.
But will I except this as headcannon anyway?  Also yes.


I love this theory, but I couldn’t help but notice something. In the Gift of Maud Pie  (season 6 episode 3) we see that Maud has a MAUD SENSE, just like Pinkie has a Pinkie sense, and Pinkie comments that it, “runs in the family.” Is it possible that Maud has magic as well? Are their other members of the Pie family that have this ability ? Maybe they have some sort of magical ancestry, like Pumpkin Cake or Flurry Heart. I feel like the answer to Pinkie Pie is still out of our grasps, but if it really is Discord’s chaos magic, it might be possible it spread through Pinkie’s family (Do you really expect Discord’s magic to follow any rules?). <br>I feel like this is a little far fetched, but hey, this is Discord we’re talking about!

I love this theory, but I couldn’t help but notice something. In the Gift of Maud Pie  (season 6 episode 3) we see that Maud has a MAUD SENSE, just like Pinkie has a Pinkie sense, and Pinkie comments that it, “runs in the family.” Is it possible that Maud has magic as well? Are their other members of the Pie family that have this ability ? Maybe they have some sort of magical ancestry, like Pumpkin Cake or Flurry Heart. I feel like the answer to Pinkie Pie is still out of our grasps, but if it really is Discord’s chaos magic, it might be possible it spread through Pinkie’s family (Do you really expect Discord’s magic to follow any rules?).
I feel like this is a little far fetched, but hey, this is Discord we’re talking about!


A note: when Cozy Glow used discord’s magic, she turns into that monster thing- but when Pinkie uses it, Electricity crackles on her body. Cozy didn’t have the electricity. And discord’s magic is electricity so it suggests that when Pinkie Pie used it, something mysterious happened, and Discord’s magic started flowing through her veins and affecting her entire timeline.
Only a note/theory
Pls like so Sawtooth can see this

@Kentavritsa I also have a theory on Pinkies clones.... What if her clones weren't clones, but other Pinkie Pies from parietal universes... Perhaps one of them even being from the EG universe.... They had to learn about the world they were in from Pinkie Prime because most of them weren't even Ponies in their home dimensions to begin with....

In the comic pinke fell into discord dimseon, and used chaos magic as discord magic was not able to use it after the titrek stole IT

Also, cozy couldn't use the chaos magic. Everyone said that discords magic is so chaotic that he's the only one that can control it. But pinkie seemed like she could use the magic pretty easily

maybe because it was a full loop. As she was already a being of chaos. It affected her past as well. Maybe with Cozy it was altered by the other magic she absorbed.

Its vains not venis because venis is a planet

@Lark Dash Oh yeah good point. But I am saying that because Pinky was a giant a little longer and I am thinking that because of that she was effected with discord magic.

@Avery Espinoza I think that's because Chrysalis and Tirek took away the chaos earlier...

Pinkie pie  is more  powerful than  cozy duh pinkie  pie is a  god

Pinkie is a bit weird (Might be more powerful cause of pinkie sense?)

I didn't even know test that 😱 maybe it's because pinky pie is a earth pony

Also pinkie can control discords magic unlike cozy

@Kentavritsa i suppose but either works i guess.good speculating!

Wait, is it Discord's magic here?  Just because it is Chaos magic?

@Twilluz That assumes Pinkie plays by the same set of rules?  Which rarely seems to be the case.<br>Pinkie could claim the magic for herself withapparent ease, while Cozy required another to afford her the magic.  If the other were willing or able to use the magic would most likely be irrelevant?

@Twilluz That assumes Pinkie plays by the same set of rules?  Which rarely seems to be the case.
Pinkie could claim the magic for herself withapparent ease, while Cozy required another to afford her the magic.  If the other were willing or able to use the magic would most likely be irrelevant?

Also cozy was an alicorn so she could hold more magic thne pinkie

@Kiran shravan voleti well you can see discord’s magic is kinda involves electricity when he turns those three villians into stone. His magic coming out of his hands looks like electricity

Cozy could not control the magic, just as she could only accept it being given to her.
Pinkie Pie could control the magic to do her bidding, because she had been intendd to control this magic even if it technically is not hers to begin with.
For a paralel, the Alicorn is the combination of the Pony magic; but what do you get if you add the Chaos and Changeling Magic?  Pinkie Pie?
If you follow her history; you notice Pinkie is using all the Pony Magics at one time or the other, but she is apparntly using Chaos and Changeling Magic as well.
Why is Pinkie's last known surviving Clone a Journalist?  Is it a nod to Clark Kent?  Though one may assume she does a grand job at the Journalism, if the Clone has as much as a Shadow of Pinkie's Qualities.  Knowing where the news are, and remembering everything?

Wasn't pinky pie a giant a couple seconds long than cozy glow?

@Kiran shravan voleti but cozy was a Pegasus first right? Well- I guess ur right

Well there’s one problem with your theory if discord’s magic has electricity he would have sparks around him . Cozy was an alllacorn so sh could Handel all the magic but pinkie is an earth poney not being able to Handel all that magic it spread into her entire timeline

Maybe that being because cozy got her magic by you know how

@aycxia the timeline is the rainbow change


So I've seen people in the comments talking about certain other characters that also have weird abilities like Pinkie, and I'm starting to wonder: is chaos magic REALLY unique to only Discord? Because I find it would be pretty interesting if random creatures/individuals just happened to have chaos magic, and are often randomly born with it with no rhyme or reason. The amount of power they have is also random, and sometimes they can only do a limited number of things. It would just generally be cool to get that kind of lore on chaos magic, especially if it was true that certain random individual beings just happened to have it, and some might even know more of the secrets of the universe than others.

I could make so many OCs using this headcanon.


Personally I’d love to see the cosmos turned into frosting 🧁🧁🧁


But when cozy glow absorbed it she couldnt handle it. When I saw that scene I immediately said to myself, " ok for a fact Pinkie can handle it shes chaotic in general." And then it happened and she handled it way better!!


I'm pretty sure it's just Pinkie being her cartoon character self, but the magic returning to Pinkie thing could be something to look into.


The part where Pinkie has magic returned to her when none of the other non-horn having ponies is really interesting, I never noticed

@Candace Wesley but the others (pegasi and earth ponies from the mane 6) didn't get their magic back like pinkie or the unicorns

I thought everyone had the same thing happend

Wait when in this video was that, can someone give me the time?

That make sense. When Pinkie took the bell she got crazy magic!

maybe thats her super-duper strength (not physical, mental, so applejack wouldn't have it) or her pinkie sense which counts as a type of magic ig

Same! I thought I was the only one who noticed it. The magic returned to Pinkie, Rarity and Twilight.

@Candace Wesley me too also the others i thought

I did but i thought it was normal the others did not get it so its not

@BrassWing I noticed it but I thought pinkie just had magic


Cheese Sandwich: "Where theirs a party I follow."

In this case!

Magic: "Where theirs a Pinkie Pie
I follow :D"

Gravity: “Where there is a Pinkie Pie I cease to exist”


If Discord’s chaos magic effected Pinkie into her past and future then how come in season 6 ep. 3 when they where trying to get Pinkie’s canon back Rarity asked Maud how she knew where it was she said “Maud sense” then Pinkie said and I quote “Runs in the family” so everyone in her family has it. It’s just a talent they had since birth! Sorry if this ruins the theory and you have to delete this one although I really like it!

♡L̆̈ŭ̈z̆̈ N̆̈ŏ̈c̆̈ĕ̈d̆̈ă̈♡


In season 8 when was Pinkie Pie sad, she changed colour of her skin, she made her hair straight and when she was walking down the town, flowers started to die and balloons started to burst. Her mood was literally changing things around her. That is a proof that she has some kind of magic.


It was also a bit weird that pinky was just able to “calmly” and pretty easily handle discord’s chaos magic, like it just came naturally to her


I really like this theory and in a lot of ways it makes sense! I think there might be a couple of reasons why Pinkie got to keep some chaos magic and Cozy didn’t: 1) Discord was the one who removed a bunch of the chaos magic from Pinkie and might have let her keep a little bit for fun later. Tirek and Chrysalis removed all of the chaos magic in Cozy Glow after she said she was going to turn on them wielding her newfound power. 2) Pinkie was blasted by the rainboom and cozyglow wasn’t. This magically connected Pinkie to her friends and a little bit to their respective kinds of magic. Given Discord was Pinkie’s friend, a little bit of chaos magic might have stayed with Pinkie only when she was directly exposed to it. This might also explain why Cozy was unable to control the chaos magic while pinkie could.


3:29
i think its a mix of two things
1. chaos magic is well, chaotic. it doesn't follow a set pattern of what happens to those who use it.
2. it could be a causality loop, where because of that moment, it gave her the magic throughout her timeline, which in turn gave her enough of that magic that her using it strengthened her power in a way that both make her control it, and so it overflowed to throughout her timeline. meaning that, that moment, caused that moment to be able to happen.


Hey...I noticed that in the episode where Twilight fights tirek , after she gets magic from all 3 Princesses disocrd just like pinkie senses it by shaking his body...

🤔🤔🤔

It's dicord's sense!!

I would not nlike to call it discord sense I think

Discord is Discord and he’s chaotic no matter what


What if when Cozy Glow absorbed Discord’s magic, it made her feel motivated to drain all the magic from Equestria and turn to the dark side? I think that’s cool


Sawtooth: I solved Pinkie Pie

Twilight Sparkle would like to know your location

Sawtooth: I solved Pinkie Pie

*Twilight Sparkle would like to know your location*

Ok I’ll give twilight my location ONLY BECAUSE I WANT HER LIVING WITH ME

S̷σ̷ʋ̷ι̷ҽ̷ƚ̷ ̷S̷ƚ̷α̷ʅ̷ƙ̷ҽ̷ɾ̷ ̷M̷ҽ̷ɳ̷

Honestly the twilight sparkle would like to know your location thing is scary

Ooone thousandth like! But it doesn't matter!

Maybe Discords magic effected Cozy's timeline too and that's why she went crazy for "Power" has no idea how to respond to friendship just like Discord didn't in the beginning and Cozy wanted to become the "Empress" of Friendship just how Discord became the Lord of Chaos, and why she's so smart and a little filly not aging even alittle when we see the Crusanders age alittle and grow through the series, maybe she's from when the ponies were still at odds and wendigos still roamed. So otherwise maybe the Discord magic twisted her and made her go "mad" and affected her growth physically but not intellectually. Just a thought.

Twilight has been wanted to know since season 1

Amel Hana of course they didn’t explin pinkie they explained pinkie.

I thought they had a conversation some time ago that ended badly. Here: https://youtu.be/AP1ym0-hRr4


I havet really thought this through but this theory about smt happening in the future would affect the past seems also fitting too Flurry Heart. I mean she was born alicorn, yet she hadn’t really had an interaction with any other ponies. But at her coronation she got the love of all the crystal ponies, and we’ve seen both crystal ponies with wings and without- so why not with a horn? So she basically got love(aka magic) from possibly all three tribes.<br>I’ll set my brain aside and let someone else joke around with this theory.

I havet really thought this through but this theory about smt happening in the future would affect the past seems also fitting too Flurry Heart. I mean she was born alicorn, yet she hadn’t really had an interaction with any other ponies. But at her coronation she got the love of all the crystal ponies, and we’ve seen both crystal ponies with wings and without- so why not with a horn? So she basically got love(aka magic) from possibly all three tribes.
I’ll set my brain aside and let someone else joke around with this theory.


It's very interesting, but on the other hoof I don't recall Discord having affected time, only space/dimensions with his powers.<br>That said there is another detail I'm too lazy right now to check, but in the famous time loop episode with Twilight, iirc Pinkie wasn't really into Twilight's theory that something would happen and still tagged along for fun, at least she didn't take that seriously at all... if your time loop theory is correct and this one too, maybe Pinky's twitchy tail sense could "have remembered" the timeline where nothing happened after Twilight checked every potential danger...

It's very interesting, but on the other hoof I don't recall Discord having affected time, only space/dimensions with his powers.
That said there is another detail I'm too lazy right now to check, but in the famous time loop episode with Twilight, iirc Pinkie wasn't really into Twilight's theory that something would happen and still tagged along for fun, at least she didn't take that seriously at all... if your time loop theory is correct and this one too, maybe Pinky's twitchy tail sense could "have remembered" the timeline where nothing happened after Twilight checked every potential danger...


The fact that when Cosy absorbed Discord's magic, she couldn't control it, but when Pinkie absorbed it, she was able to control it somehow concerns me for some reason.


I would like to debunk that theory. While you have some good arguments I don’t think the cause of her “godlike powers” is Discord’s magic. I personally think that it has to do with the sonic rainboom when she got her cutie mark. It is show that the sonic rainboom is magical enough to give other ponies extra power, like it did with Twilight, it gave her the magic she needed to pass her entrance exam. I think that the rainboom gave Pinkie those abilities, and I believe it is stored in her mane. When the rainboom happened, her hair puffed up, and when her hair was flat she doesn’t have those godly abilities. Her mane alone is also shown to be magical, like when she stores random objects in it or when the front would move like an extra limb.
I’d love to know what you think about my theory! I know I’m pretty late to this video and I apologize for that, but I do hope you find this interesting.

I would like to debunk that theory. While you have some good arguments I don’t think the cause of her “godlike powers” is Discord’s magic. I personally think that it has to do with the sonic rainboom when she got her cutie mark. It is show that the sonic rainboom is magical enough to give other ponies extra power, like it did with Twilight, it gave her the magic she needed to pass her entrance exam. I think that the rainboom gave Pinkie those abilities, and I believe it is stored in her mane. When the rainboom happened, her hair puffed up, and when her hair was flat she _doesn’t_ have those godly abilities. Her mane alone is also shown to be magical, like when she stores random objects in it or when the front would move like an extra limb.
I’d love to know what you think about my theory! I know I’m pretty late to this video and I apologize for that, but I do hope you find this interesting.


HA! Jokes on you! You can’t solve Pinkie Pie, she’s Pinkie Pie!

Okay, that’s actually a good theory.

Pinkie is able to go into dimensions in another body/spirit, how do you think ancient earth ponies built equestria, witchcraft.

That’s not magic, that’s just pinkie pie.


I have one detail that I think can support this theory, when cozy glow absorbed the power she didn’t have the same results as Pinkie Pie did because when she absorbed the power she already had experienced Alicorn magic and Alicorn magic is powerful so Discord’s magic would only be an extend of control that Cozy Glow just couldn’t handle as for Pinkie Pie she would have never experienced magic before until that moment when she got Discord’s magic it was hard to control just like for Cozy Glow but Pinkie Pie had a greater affect on it because she never had experienced magic before until that one moment and then the rest of your theory goes on


Hold up, what about cheese sandwich? When he came to pony villle, didn’t he say he had a cheese sense? Please correct me if I’m wrong hahah


Hey Sawtooth, just something floating around in my brain. If an alternate timeline existed in which Pinkie did not take Discord's magic, would that mean Pinkie would be normal in the alternate timeline? Imagine a Pinkie that can't break The Laws of Physics...


Interesting theory. Works even better than my own explanation years ago for Pinkie: that she was born a heavy unicorn hybrid, (unicorn with earth pony traits) but something happened as a very young foal (possibly Cake twins age) that caused the need for her horn to be removed. Or possibly was broken off duecto either an accident or abuse. (Also, in my headcanon at the time, she was adopted.) With the removal of her horn, but the carbunkle (nerve cluster atvthe horn's root) still there, her unicorn magic ends up being bottled up... causing extremely random and chaotic releases of said magic.


Pinkie's full of surprises. Metaphorically and literally.

Wait so IF I BREAK HER OPEN LIKE A PIÑATA WILL SHE DROP CANDY?!

Michael Jacksons Biggest Fan Gacha Life and more!


i love the theory :D<br>personally, ive always thought that pinkie just has that magic naturally. we already know that ALL ponies have magic, not just unicorns; and that magic can be personalized. for example, fluttershy's ability to speak to animals, and her Stare. those arent "pegasus powers" that all pegasi have, like the ability to fly; its hers alone. pinkie's magic could just be like that, natural and unique to her. i always thought that pinkie was able to wield discord's magic so well because it was a close match to her already existing magic and personality.

i love the theory :D
personally, ive always thought that pinkie just has that magic naturally. we already know that ALL ponies have magic, not just unicorns; and that magic can be personalized. for example, fluttershy's ability to speak to animals, and her Stare. those arent "pegasus powers" that all pegasi have, like the ability to fly; its hers alone. pinkie's magic could just be like that, natural and unique to her. i always thought that pinkie was able to wield discord's magic so well because it was a close match to her already existing magic and personality.


I like the theory. To explain the difference between Cozy and Pinki’s reactions you could easily say it was because Cozy was an Alicorn at that point and able to contain the chaos better than an earth pony


Cozy Glow is chaotic by being crazy and stuff


Well, Cozy Glow with her desire for power/control is too orderly for a filly. Pinkie Pie is the opposite - she's very chaotic for an adult pony. Also, if this was something of an event that influenced her PAST before the moment-- that makes it a Circle like so many time-travel stories.


Sawtooth: Pinkie Pie, she is a weird creature.
Pinkie Pie: Am I a joke to you? tells Fluttershy to do the stare
Fluttershy: STARING INTENSIFIES

Sawtooth: Pinkie Pie, she is a weird creature.
Pinkie Pie: Am I a joke to you? *tells Fluttershy to do the stare*
Fluttershy: *STARING INTENSIFIES*


Cozy glow used magic to be powerful while pinkie used it to create crazy chaos. Maybe those moments changed both ponies. Pinkie pie became crazy pony who destroys phisics laws and cozy glow became hungry for power and obsessive.


Sawtooth Waves: Is someone watching me?<br>Me: Yeah, we are because this is a YouTube video.

Sawtooth Waves: Is someone watching me?
Me: Yeah, we are because this is a YouTube video.


Another theory-

Pinkie has her Pinkie sense, that is true.But if all magic disappeared from equestria then she might also have lost her Pinkie sense. Yes this minor detail was hard to see and 99 percent of people didn't notice this. But it is highly unlikely that one event in the future can affect the present.

Hope this helps


If that happened in that one moment changed entire timelines, we know from the episode where Twilight time travelled to stop Starlight that different timelines in the MLP universe are a thing.
Would the chaos magic effect the timelines of other Pinkies? Like if in another timeline, Pinkie did NOT absorb Discord’s magic at the time, would she still be as crazily Pinkie as we know?
If it effected her whole life, was there a past before the chaos magic thing? Just her being the element of laughter, cracking jokes and visual gags, but with no physics defying stunts? Or is that past just erased because of all the chaos magic? Is it still there, in another timeline?


Maybe she wants all of us to believe that we've solved her...
She does know of our existence so... could she be misleading us..? O _ O
Welp, no sleep for me tonight!

Maybe she wants all of us to believe that we've solved her...
She does know of our existence so... could she be misleading us..? O ___ O
Welp, no sleep for me tonight!


hmm... I've always explained pinkie sense as one of many psychic abilities, essentially as twilight pointed out, magic and pinkie sense don't exactly work the same way. which is why she failed to understand it, my theory is that in equestria, psychic abilities are a separate thing from magic. She isn't the only one either,
 Fluttershy is a natural empath, but what if she's a supernatural empath as well? it would explain her ability to communicate with animals, (or at least understand their emotions and why she is so sensitive in general when she can sense the judgement of other ponies first hand not to mention her glare, imagine focusing pure fear into a target just by looking at them.
 Princess Luna is a telepath, in the diary of the 2 sisters she gained the ability to communicate with animals much like fluttershy, but also she is known for entering the dreams of ponies, technically we do see that she has a spell for that, but theoretically magic isn't incapable of enhancing or duplicating a psychic ability
 Also Izzy moonbow claims to see the auras of other ponies or their unique "sparkles" she even uses that ability despite the absence of unicorn magic or seemingly any other pony magic.


Cheese Sandwich can pull similar feats too, and as far as we know, he never got injected with a butt ton of chaos magic that made him want to turn all the stars into rubber chickens

I like to think party ponies are a small and rare sub-set of ponies or even creature that have a very slightly different type of magic, probably akin to chaos magic, that makes them more emotional and connect with feelings like joy more than the average creature as well as pull those feats

Perhaps these traits are why they're usually the ones in charge of non-formal parties around Equestria, hence the name and title of Party Pony

The only two party ponies we really know of are Pinkie and Cheese, and both are earth ponies, and that can probably just be chalked up to coincidence. But what if, as earth ponies, they don't really have the inate magic of unicorns and pegasi, their magic being alot more subtle, so this 'party pony magic' can be expressed alot more easily in earth ponies


I like your idea and i think your half right. but you forgot one detail. Grogar had said in season 9 "only a creature of pure chaos can control discords magic"
Pinkie however seemed to control it PERFECTLY when she got her whooves on it. This means she has always had her OWN form chaos magic (likely chaotic good) which is why she could control it but it being a more "negative" form of chaos magic it still corrupted her slightly (not making her evil just outta control)

:) hope you like my take on it!


Laughter is a magic of the same nature as chaos. Even Dash mentioned once how random Pinkie is (episode with Gilda). That's where Pinkie sense comes from: she can feel chaos around her. Maybe that makes Pinkie so good at ordering (her secret cave). So, Pinkie has deal with chaos the whole life.<br>And that's the explenation of Pinkie's ability to control the chaos magic (she can feel it and she have been practicing to control it during whole her life).

Laughter is a magic of the same nature as chaos. Even Dash mentioned once how random Pinkie is (episode with Gilda). That's where Pinkie sense comes from: she can feel chaos around her. Maybe that makes Pinkie so good at ordering (her secret cave). So, Pinkie has deal with chaos the whole life.
And that's the explenation of Pinkie's ability to control the chaos magic (she can feel it and she have been practicing to control it during whole her life).


I truly support your belief about discord's chaos magic affecting Pinkie Pie's timeline and affecting her future and past but regarding the difference of the outcome on cozy glow and Pinkie Pie after absorbing Discord's magic  is because she also absorbed Princess Celestia's and Luna's magic which was in the bell<br>so I think this was the reason of Pinkie Pie's timeline being affected

I truly support your belief about discord's chaos magic affecting Pinkie Pie's timeline and affecting her future and past but regarding the difference of the outcome on cozy glow and Pinkie Pie after absorbing Discord's magic  is because she also absorbed Princess Celestia's and Luna's magic which was in the bell
so I think this was the reason of Pinkie Pie's timeline being affected


Honestly, all this time shenanigan stuff is unneccessary. I just always theorized that Pinkie Pie was able to use chaotic magic from the start, as she is more prone to being able to do things that the rest couldn't. Things that don't involve time at all. This explains in a more simple structure why she couldn't just "read the future" and know when to touch the bell and all that. She simply always knew chaos magic. It's why she enjoyed Discord in Season 2. It's why she was able to control and harness Discord's Magic. She already knew Chaos Magic. That's why she can control it. No time shenanigans needed.


My Own Theory:<br>What if she had gotten it from the Sonic Rainboom like how Twilight's magic activated then? Now, I know that sounds far-fetched, but think about it. When she lived on the rock farm, she was just a normal pony, not the hyperactive and physics-defying party pony we know today. When she set up that party at the rock farm, it was only a DAY (I believe) after the Rainboom. There's no way she could have gotten the supplies for the party and come back home THAT fast. The Rainboom could have done more than just puff up her mane/tail and show her how to smile. It could have awakened the chaotic good side of her that was hidden from living on the rock farm. That's all I got. Bit of a stretch, but it's still possible. Nothing is impossible when it comes to Pinkie Pie.

My Own Theory:
What if she had gotten it from the Sonic Rainboom like how Twilight's magic activated then? Now, I know that sounds far-fetched, but think about it. When she lived on the rock farm, she was just a normal pony, not the hyperactive and physics-defying party pony we know today. When she set up that party at the rock farm, it was only a DAY (I believe) after the Rainboom. There's no way she could have gotten the supplies for the party and come back home THAT fast. The Rainboom could have done more than just puff up her mane/tail and show her how to smile. It could have awakened the chaotic good side of her that was hidden from living on the rock farm. That's all I got. Bit of a stretch, but it's still possible. Nothing is impossible when it comes to Pinkie Pie.


This all sounds plausible, but what about Maud? In the manhattan episode where Pinkie and Maud exchange gifts, Rarity asks how Maud knew where the sales pony was, and Maud replied saying," Maud sense".<br>If what you said was true, then how did Maud get her Maud sense?

This all sounds plausible, but what about Maud? In the manhattan episode where Pinkie and Maud exchange gifts, Rarity asks how Maud knew where the sales pony was, and Maud replied saying," Maud sense".
If what you said was true, then how did Maud get her Maud sense?


This fits with what I've been thinking, Pinkie having her own kind of chaos magic...
An example of this, one scene in a harthswarming episode, where the apples stay at the pies. 19 hooves appear from the sides of the frame, and AppleJack sees them too, though the other ponies around them seem unfazed. This suggests that Pinkie isnt just making them appear where we can see, or is doing some weird trick. Applejack has no idea where they came from, and looks around her kinda terrified. Pinkie can make these things happen for specific ponies too.
As well as when twilight broke the fourth wall to help Pinkie after Trixie's first appearance. This isnt happening for everyone, just specific ponies.

Actually after the season four finale discord had trouble using his power and pinke pie took over his dimrdom that how pinke could use the chaos msigc discord let pinke pie keep some mdguv in case pinke wanted a rematch discord almost lost to pinke pie


Also I think the real reasons that it spread through her timeline was because it wasn't just discords magic that she took in, remember that Celestia and Luna's magic was in there too which wasn't what cozy glow absorbed


Maybe she just always had a little bit of chaos energy in her.


i noticed the magic go into pinkie in that one scene, and i found it bizarre, this theory has SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much evidence that pinkie is one of 4 things
1.  She is the random 4th wall character that appears in lots of shows
2.  Your theory
3.  she is a literal pony goddess
Or my personal favorite,
4.  She has the potential to become an alicorn. She never does in the show, but i really want to hold on to this theory

𝔦𝔪𝔭𝔢𝔯𝔣𝔢𝔠𝔱𝔩𝔦𝔤𝔥𝔱𝔰𝔬𝔲𝔯𝔠𝔢


You forgot Her Chaos Goddess Moment in the Comics. She took over the Chaos Realm and replaced Discord as Chaos. That wasn't a brief moment, it was a whole day. Maybe even more. That more likely. To us it may have been a day, Pinkie Pie could been in there for years, centuries. In the comic, Pinkie completely rewrote the whole Infinite Chaos Realm to her liking. Your theory become more believable if you use that moment.

Woot I helped solved Pinkie Pie!!! Now I must run from Twilight Sparkle.


I also have an explanation to why Maud and Cheese Sandwich both have senses of their own too. While Pinkie was overwhelmed by the chaos magic, not only did she spread it through her OWN timeline, she also granted power across other  people that she really really cares about's timelines, like Maud and the rest of the family. ('Runs in the family!') But you may be wondering, "why would Cheese have it then?" well, I mean, there IS a character that is presumably Pinkie's daughter in The Last Problem named Little Cheese who is playing with Boneless 6, soooooo


I think Cozy Glow wasn't filled with chaos for life, but evil for life, as Discord's magic is filled with chaos AND evil. He may have taken a long time to control his chaos, and the main 6 help him control the evil.


I think the simple explanation as to why cozy and pinkie reacted to discord's magic is because the magic they have is different. Cozy also has grogar's magic in her at the time she absorbed the chaos magic. It seems as though 1/3rd of grogar's power is a buffer to all that chaos. Pinkie was a regular earth pony before she absorbed all of discord's magic. All that pure chaos did change her life. I'm really convinced by the theory, if you can't tell.


My theory: I think cozy glow’s also spread across her timeline, but just needed something to activate it. I think the rainboom had ticked the magic and activated it


Another thing is, when cozy got the chaos magic, she couldn't control it. But when pinkie got it. She could use it pretty easily🤔


I agree with what you Said! Pinkie might have some secret magic! 🤔 But Also in the Castle Mane-ia episode, she was playing the organ, and the music was really creepy. When Twilight removed the "jacket" and she was playing, it sounded different 😳 That was Kinda strange 🤔


It's the other way around. Because she has the chaos element inside her as a natural feature, she is able to wield the chaos power unlike Cozy Glow.


I think Pinkie Pie can also look into Discord's mind because in Season 9 episode 1 "The Beginning of the End" when Pinkie Pie was listing all the villains they have defeated, she only mentioned the one's that have returned. King Sombra, Queen Chrysalis, Tirek and Cozy Glow.

True and at that time only Discord knew.


@Fróði Kjaran Does art and stuff Pinkie can not be killed, and she can not per se die either.

@Mr. Mineblox / Daylight TwinkleI agree just let pinkie be pinkie even though she breaks the fourth wall

I guest soo your right Mr.Mineblox she is just pinkie being pinkie 😊

exactly what I thought after reading the title

Pink character with two identites..being associated with a green creature used as communication.. Are you implying what I think you are?

Mr. Mineblox / Daylight Twinkle XD I was just joking too but to be honest even tho I love the theory pinkie and her weirdness is probably just pinkie and weirdness lol

GhastlyCreeper Plays it’s just a common thing the bronies say I was joking about it cause I love This theory

But then there is no theory only facts cause that’s the truth


Unrelated to your theory, which I find fasvinating, but I always thought Pinkie was adopted by the Pie family.  And that she actually is a draconequus with the body of a pony.

Honestly Pinkie is interesting.

Even though she doesnt have as many chaotic powers as Discord, her whole personality is far more chaotic than Discord who is honestly a pretty normal personality.

Pinkonquus just a thought.

And actually this can combine with your theory. That event where she picked up the bell, might have effevted Pinkie uniquely being that she already was a draconequus and the bell unlocked her chaotic potenial


Your claim in the episode would have been correct if chaos magic was also taken. In the episode, only very certain types of magic were taken. No Pegasus magic, no earth pony magic, and no cute mark magic. In my opinion, it is more likely to assume that Pinkie Pie is a descendant of another almost completely extinct pony breed with telepathic abilities. Since it is more similar to unicorn magic than chaos magic it is more likely to believe that such magic would actually take. I wasn't surprised to find out if Maud also got charmed at that moment. After all, we saw her with Boulder communicating with stones and understanding them. We don't really know the rest of Pinky's family and we can also believe that the gene for the early pony type is dormant in most of her family, after all we know that at the moment of the rainboom something happened in her mind that might have awakened these genes.
<br>It could also be that all the applicants carry the ancient genes, they are simply dormant in all the applicants except Pinky.

Your claim in the episode would have been correct if chaos magic was also taken. In the episode, only very certain types of magic were taken. No Pegasus magic, no earth pony magic, and no cute mark magic. In my opinion, it is more likely to assume that Pinkie Pie is a descendant of another almost completely extinct pony breed with telepathic abilities. Since it is more similar to unicorn magic than chaos magic it is more likely to believe that such magic would actually take. I wasn't surprised to find out if Maud also got charmed at that moment. After all, we saw her with Boulder communicating with stones and understanding them. We don't really know the rest of Pinky's family and we can also believe that the gene for the early pony type is dormant in most of her family, after all we know that at the moment of the rainboom something happened in her mind that might have awakened these genes.
It could also be that all the applicants carry the ancient genes, they are simply dormant in all the applicants except Pinky.


Your explanation is surprisingly lucid. I approve.


I see NO plotholes in this theory that can't be filled by the following: Pinkie Pie, full name Pinkamena Diane Pie, also known in certain forms of merchandise as Ponka Po, is the Laughter Element of Harmony, and her special talent revolves around giving joy to others and making them smile and laugh. Being able to follow something known as "cartoon physics", as well as "break the 4th wall" and speak to people who live in a reality where HER reality is a work of fiction could bring quite a few individuals a LOT of joy, especially if they truly believe she's talking to THEM.


If pinkie pie does something weird. Just don't question it. She is pinkie pie. Pinkie is pinkie. She is the meaning of unsolved and solved...

@MrMemeZilla 198 Makes me think of; "The Hitch-hiker's guide to the Galaxy" ..

Wrong ! 🙅♂🙅♂ everything is explainable and I think his theory is quite logic, now I think we need more evidence... perhaps we should look deeper somewhere else, like the comics ? 🧐

@Guardian Of Peace I am still holding onto my goddess theory but that does make Sense

I will anyways:

Discord’s chaos magic might’ve originally been a mix of 3 different types of magic: Chaotic Good, Chaotic Evil and Chaotic Neutral. So as far as we know, Discord’s magic may have been split into 3 bits:
1. Chaotic Good: Transferred to Pinkie Pie
2. Chaotic Evil: Transferred to Cozy Glow
3. Chaotic Neutral: Kept in Discord

Just a hunch though :)


I have a idea when Cozy Glow absorbed Discords magic, she already used some magic to become a alicorn, so Grogars bell couldn’t add any more magic. So since pinkie is a earth pony with NO magic. It could give her a lot and I mean a LOT of magic. So much that it spread across her entire life…


Pinkie is a powerful and super cute earth pony with tons of amazing quantities. End of story.


Also when pinkie absorbed discords chaos magic it seemed as though she could somewhat control it, it may have been that what pinkie would do with it is very similar to what was happening when she took it but also her transformation into a giant pony being wasn’t instant like with cozy glow. Pinkies transformation was also a lot less demonic looking and more of just a giant pinkie pie, also cozy glow was already an alicorn when she took the magic so it likely just that pinkie was an earth pony.

Edit: spelling


Finally an explanation. Always wondered this. Pinkie Pie stands apart from all the others.


When cozy glow got discord magic, she was evil and she had bad intentions. And, her eyes turn different colors. But when pinky pie got discords magic, her eyes stayed the same and she had good intentions. Well if you count covering everything in frosting good intentions…! So, maybe the eyecolor and the evil versus good has something to do with it?

Well maybe it you think that covering the world in frosting is good intentions then I see it


It is actually very very confusing that pinkie actually was able to control discord's chaos magic.
In the scene where Cozy,Tirek and Chrysails were talking about what to do with discord's chaos magic,

Tirek said that NO OTHER CREATURE OTHER THAN DISCORD CAN CONTROL HIS CHAOS MAGIC.

Crazy if u think about it


This man is to powerful to be left alive


Maud/Pinkie sense could be the Pie family's version of earth pony magic- their "connection to the earth", as it will.
Maybe it's specifically because Pinkie has that sense, and specifically because it relates to time and predictions, that the chaos magic scattered through the timeline for her, but not for Cozy.

Maud/Pinkie sense could be the Pie family's version of earth pony magic- their "connection to the earth", as it will.
Maybe it's specifically _because_ Pinkie has that sense, and specifically _because_ it relates to time and predictions, that the chaos magic scattered through the timeline for her, but not for Cozy.


Maud has a 'Pinkie Sense' of her own, and Pinkie says it runs in the family, so I think the Pie family are all secretly descendants of Discord. Pinkie got a large dose of his magic in her veins which would explain the 4th wall-breaking and defying the laws of physics, time, and space. It might also explain why she was able to control Discord's chaos magic when she absorbed it, whereas Cozy Glow summoned a rubber chicken instead of a death ray. The flaws of this? Why does Discord not know her? Wouldn't he recognize his descendant? The answer: Discord had been a stone statue for centuries so the amount of chaos magic in the Pie bloodline could have been diluted over time, and their last names have changed. It could have been just resurfacing in Pinkie, so Discord just thought she was an odd earth pony. While there are other flaws in this theory, I like it and it's a theory I've been developing for a while. If you've made it this far in my extremely long paragraph, have a wonderful day!


Nope, she's still unsolved, no one can solve her

Hi everyone! Haven't seen you guys in two weeks

@Hanoi Paula Its not mean because 1.Sawtooth waves liked it and 2. She said it as a joke

If she was mean, then why Sawtooth hearted that comment?

Azra Yeliz Dalcı Everyone keep saying that Pinky is unsolved but she is! It’s so mean to say that he didn’t solve pinky

@Hanoi Paula how was that mean in anyway?

Diamonds Music yep she is pinkie pie no one Can beat her


As applegeek once greatly said.<br>"It's Pinkie, don't question it"

As applegeek once greatly said.
"It's Pinkie, don't question it"


Here's my theory- or just personal head-cannon, since I don't really have that much to back it up haha
Pinkie was born with chaos magic, she's always had it. Maybe that's why she looks so different from her family, and has such a different destiny than they all do.
When cozy absorbed discord's magic she wasn't able to use it, or at least she couldn't control what it did. But pinkie kinda could.
I think she dropped that huge cupcake and made it rain chocolate on purpose, she absolutely loves both of those things, so it only makes sense that that's where her instinct would go. If she already had a small amount of chaos magic, it would be believable that she would know at least a little bit about how to control it. Of course she wouldn't have been able to control it for long, but in that instant she seemed to be pretty aware of what she was doing.

But that's just my idea, like I said I only have a few bits of evidence and they could totally be interpreted differently.


I think Pinkie controlled it better and kept some magic back cuz that's just how she is. She and discord are quite similar in their bizzare approach to almost everything. But cozy glow just doesn't have that wackiness that chaos magic needs to manifest properly.
But Pinkie on the other hand.......(definition of wacky) Can control it to an extent cuz it's similar to the way she works. Chaos magic would have been like "hey, this pony has the stuff in need to work,just not enough if it" or the right Kind
She's not chaos, just silly which is kinda tied to chaos and the wile point if everything I've said this far

Also Cozy Glow is just a ginormousss mystery to me. What Alicorn is EVIL

Wow this thing is long


Hi Sawtooth,
I can agree with you but there is a difference. When Cozy Glow took the magic from the bell, it contained only Discord's magic, But when pinke pie took the magic, it contained not just Discord's magic it also contained alicorn princess magic. Pinke Pie must have also taken the alicorn princess magic.
Please think about this theory.
I love your videos
Thank you.


"Is someone watching me?!"<br>Yes this is a video

"Is someone watching me?!"
Yes this is a video

Sofizzy you are righ🧚🏼♂🧚🏼♂🧚🏼♂🧚🏼♂🧚🏼♂🧚🏼♂

Sofizzy you are righ🧚🏼♂🧚🏼♂🧚🏼♂🧚🏼♂🧚🏼♂🧚🏼♂

{ѕσρнιє ℓєє}


Maybe Pinkie Pie absorbed some of Discord's magic permanently because of her personality. Discord's magic was, in essence, a part of Discord and perhaps it latched onto Discord's personality, so when Pinkie Pie, with a personality so similar to Discord's, absorbed Discord's magic, the magic latched onto Pinkie in a way it wouldn't latch onto Cozy Glow.


When Pinkie absorbed the magic in the Bell, she absorbed A LOT more magic than Cozy did. She also absorbed all the alicorn magic from Celestia and Luna that was in the bell.


While rewatching the series, I notced at the part where magic was restored in Equestria [School Raze], Pinkie for some reason was the only non-unicorn that got a ball of aura resembling their Magic-


so correct! ...Not to mention that no creature or pony other than discord had ever controlled his chaos magic (like when cozy glow tried to and epically failed)...and then pinkie happened...she appeared to have complete control over something nobody else could-not counting discord


I can disprove this in one probably a bit off direct quote from Maud.

'Maud sense. It's a family thing.'

and cheese sandwich has the party sense thingy  REEEEEEEEE

THATS WHAT I SAID<br>( I don’t mean to scream at you in a bad way )

THATS WHAT I SAID
( I don’t mean to scream at you in a bad way )

@Clo Animations It affects her abilities but not her being a pony with no magic directly.

🤔Maybe being family has something to do with certain different senses and Pinkie Sense just coincidentally came from the chaos magic?🤔 But I don't think so...

@bird266 I like that theory actually. I think we should all look into it.

bird266 that would explain how they can digest rocks XD

Mayhaps all her family has a form of magic we don't know about?


I don’t think it has anything to do with time, I simply think that pinkie was compatibly able to control it, perhaps she always had the same kind of magic in her all along, she just got more of it from the bell


Thats the best explanation ever, the event of Magic going back to Pinkie after cozy glow may actually be true. Not necessarily they came from discords Magic. Maybe it came from when she gained her cutie Mark, her destiny was to be like that. Just like the sonic rainboom activated Twilight's Magic it did the same with Pinkie's


I would agree cause discord mainly used his magic in party related themes with all his showing and pinky pie who was born to be a plain old rock farming pony with little to no emotion just magically feels empty on the inside until the sonic rainbow which she thought gave her the motivation to create a party
But connecting the dot both discord and pinky do party and unbelievable, and impossible thing which make prefect sense to believe that, the time line of her absorbing discord magic did affect both her past, present and future timelines
I mean in my eyes they are both crazy and chaotic


This theory makes sense to me pinkie seams to have held onto discord magic for longer which is why it would have further reaching effects also when pinkie describes discords magic it reminds me of the pinkie sense at least in sensation


Random theory: Pinkie was created as a lab experiment. She was created to manipulate reality so that ponies would no longer have to come to terms with the unchangeable and suit the world to their desires. This experiment went horribly wrong, or horribly right, depending on your point of view.

She is basically bc shes a horse/ earth pony

@Verserer Gred But then.. Where did the legend of the pond come from? Dun dun dunnn


i have this small thought that like discord, pinkie has chaos magic, and was originally non-pony, but because chaos magic defies reality (like how discord turned into grogar), pinkie took the shape of an earth pony for eternity, and maybe, just maybe, used her magic and made her age, and stored it inside of her


My theory as to why Pinkie Pie has powers so similar to Discord's dracoequs magic is because she is actually half draconequs. I'm not saying Discord's her dad. He was turned to stone long before Pinkie was born, but the show never said there weren't other dracons. So, what if a different dracon fell in love with an earth pony and they ended up having a daughter with all the wacky powers of a dracon, but the appearance of a normal earth pony. That would explain why Pinkie's family looks nothing like her. They're not biologically related and the reason why they have the name last name Pie when their first names don't match is because they changed their family name to protect Pinkie's identity. That also explains why in the mlp app there was an alicorn version of Pinkie who was referred to as the Princess of Chaos.


Wait, if that's true, then how would the "original limeline" Pinkie would be? Like, there must be a Pinkie without all the caos powers if that happens in the lastest episodes; is hard to imagine her without all that


I always thought it was because of her element. I also thought it was because of her element that made her be able to control Discords magic


"Is someone watching me?"

Me: Uh... PEOPLE WE'VE BEEN DISCOVERED

ye there is pepole watching us FROM EVERY where cuze renember? up above :0

GET YOUR GUNS BEFORE HE TELLS THE OTHER'S!

@wiz no I knew something called scatter but I was really confused and yes I am 6.

@• Itz_Pastel • No? Did you know that theres something called scatter, or are you 6? G e e z


Kinda interesting how none of the others saw the magic returning to Pinkie, too.


Yes, she did get the powers from the chaos magic, bc she started a spirit bomb out of thin air and shot it at flutter shy in the 2020 smile song, if that wasnt the exact date, sorry i havent watched MLP alot.


A problem i have with this theory is that weve already seen what chaos magic looks like when Tirek took discords magic and if it is chaos magic that gives her the abilities she has then chaos magic should have been the magic we would see not a pink orb


Did you ever think that maybe cozy didn’t have the same reaction because pinky is a happy chaotic pony and cozy is quiet the opposite? Cozy is more like twilight in the fact that cozy is calm and collective while pinkie is energetic and wild?


Disney: Stitch
Marvel: Deadpool
MLP: Pinkie

And Discord! Somehow people never do seem to count Discord.


stick around, because I'm gonna prove this theory right. so this whole theory makes perfect sense. until you bring up the whole cozy glow thing, and everything rolls off the cliff because cozy took the same magic, and had no side effects... or did she? cozy is known for being the most diabolical villain we faced. that phsycho laugh sets you right into psychopath mode. when you put it like that, sounds pretty chaotic. but when you try to pair in cozy with the pinkie-discord duo, she sticks out. because cozy wants to take over aquestria and make it her own image where she can do whatever she wants. discord and pinkie just wanna goof off. but when you compare her to just discord, things get a little more interesting. they are both kinda crazy in the same way. they wanted the same thing. to live by they're own rules and do whatever they want. cozy never played with the laws of physics in the show like pinkie and discord. but that finalizes it for me.


My theory is that pinkie is a changeling stuck in the form we see. think about it, she can stay in the air after jumping for a long period of time, remember when it was pinkie's birthday and she was chasing rainbow? she was loads faster than a normal earth pony, she seems to be able to teleport, something we have seen time after time with changelings. also, when she felt her friends didn't care about her anymore, she either went berserk or was very depressed, it seems as if she feeds off the friendship and without it she can't survive, just like a changeling.  it would show why she got magic when it came back to everyone and the Pegasus did not. it also explains the hyperactivity we see with her. you might notice the pinkie from the farm and the pinkie we know are super different, the one on the farm was a normal earth pony, the one we know is a super earth pony, maybe the pinkie from the farm is the original and the one we know killed that pinkie and took her place, i know dark side theory but it could be true.

if the chaos magic went through time to all of pinkie past, present, future, why is the pinkie from the farm not like the one we know at all? the pinkie from the farm is an ordinary earth pony while all the other pinkie timelines we see are hyperactive. just something to think about.

this comment is longer than i had anticipated so i am done.


Mk so I put this on another video, but ever notice how pinkies hair flattening and poofing up with her emotions suspiciously resembles what the Crystal ponies do?? She was definitely raised outside of the empire, but her having roots in the capital of magic would explain the weird and wonderful things she can do as well as why her magic was returned to her!! Weather or not she knows of these roots I'm nit sure.


I think I can connect the dots on why Pinkie and not Cozy Glow. Pinkie’s pinkie sense is a family trait. Maud has a maud sense and then Pinkie exclaimed that it ran in the family. So some form of esp runs in the Pie family, but Pinkie’s particular manifestation of that esp seems a bit more chaotic than Maud’s. That’s probably the chaotic magical influence on her. Also Cozy Glow doesn’t have esp of any kind so no connections outside of time for her. Voila, Pinkie’s family trait is her connection outside of time and Cozy Glow doesn’t have anything like that.

I wonder though. Does Pinkie’s chaotic tendencies get stronger the closer she is to the inciting moment? Or did it spread out more evenly over Pinkie’s timeline? What do you think?


For the cosy blow incoherence: maybe she didn't keep any of the magic, but discord have let pinky keep a tiny bit of his power. I don't why he would do that but I think it could explain. But I'm pretty sure it's just Pinky Pie being pinky

@Seraphy Wang That's why I made that connection.  Cause it's not like we can interview chaos magic for an answer.

@Book Thoughts <br>I'm not a very big Harry Potter fan but i get what you mean. This would be a way of explaining why the chaos magic just seems to work for the two.

@Book Thoughts
I'm not a very big Harry Potter fan but i get what you mean. This would be a way of explaining why the chaos magic just seems to work for the two.

@Seraphy Wang I am kind of going to draw lines of comparison between fandoms (hope nobody hates me for it, but I think I see a connection, so...). I think chaos magic is kind of like the wands in Harry Potter and the mirror of Erised in way.  The chaos magic "chooses" who it likes to wield it. It liked Discord and Pinkie so it worked to help them and even affected Pinkie.  But Cozy Glow: it didn't effect her or work for her, because it disliked her and didn't want to be controlled by her.

@Book Thoughts <br>Hmm. I guess thats correct. Technically pinkie was kinda going bonkers too but in the positive way because she was going to do something drastic but could will it to do her request. Pinkie will be pinkie.

@Book Thoughts
Hmm. I guess thats correct. Technically pinkie was kinda going bonkers too but in the positive way because she was going to do something drastic but could will it to do her request. Pinkie will be pinkie.

@Seraphy Wang No... Did you not see her grow frustrated as she kept trying to "control" the chaos magic and make it do what she wished. And eventually started getting scared, because she was being attacked by the pineapple creatures. She wasn't able to control it. She could not make it do what she wanted.  But Discord and Pinkie could.

Wait wait wait. I thought Cozy Glow could control the magic but she didn’t like it because she got a huge form to contain it and the powers were....strange to say the least. She couldn’t steer the chaos magic to do what she wanted but it’s not like she couldn’t control or contain it.

@kiralax Time travel in Equestria has been really inconsistent, from Twilight dealing with a Predestination Loop in one episode, where everything she did to prevent the future she was afraid of ended up bringing about that exact future, to all the alternate timelines from the time battle between Twily and Starlight ("Twilight uses Boring Lecture! It's SUPER EFFECTIVE!"), there's more wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey contradictions for even Doctor Hooves/Time Turner to keep track of.  I have the feeling that Pinkie's timeline being infused with Chaos magic was a one-time/timeless/outside-of-time event, making the tracking of it a Predestination Paradox.

Cosy couldn't control the Chaos magic because it was too ... well  ... chaotic for her.  Pinky was able to contain and "steer" ("control" is too strong a word when dealing with chaos, the words are literally antonyms) the Chaos magic because she already had a link to unpredictability, to "humor," to Laughter.  Being a bearer of an Element of Harmony primed her for containing "outside" magic, so she could handle Discord's magic, which then leaked through her timeline and made her the only being (aside from Discord himself) able to break the fourth wall.  If they had kept the original concept of Rarity's element being "Creativity," then she might also have been compatible enough to hold Chaos magic.

@DracoSerpentisCruor yes and gathered magic then went to the all parts of her timeline, that makes loop, where pinki get more and more Chaos magic every time loop going to repeat its self.

Ondra Lopaur I'm going to help you make your point a bit clearer

i guess you're saying, Cozy Glow cannot use any of the chaos magic at all, thus no Chaos Magic will want to 'remain' in Cozy Glow.

Pinkie Pie was able to wield it, albeit concerning even Discord himself. Meaning, Chaos Magic can still reside within her, since she has been able to use said Magic anyway

You forgeting that pinki was able to control chaos magic, but closi glow dont.<br>I think, this had main efect on that, but what you saying dont have to be wrong. 🙂

You forgeting that pinki was able to control chaos magic, but closi glow dont.
I think, this had main efect on that, but what you saying dont have to be wrong. 🙂


Cozy Glozy may have absorbed discords magic but she wasnt  able to harness it. Meanwhile pinky pie did so. It is stated by the villains that his magic is really difficult to control, one would need to be kind of chaotic just like discord is. Pinky qualifies these cretirias by default. However she is just a pony, no op, divinity or something like that. Mastering a power so tremendous, even for a few moments it is bound to cause some side effect.


If we're honest, didn't it seem inevitable that Pinkie Pie would get ahold of Discord's magic at some point?

Also, I am reminded of the Bad Wolf, who creates herself. Brief moment of transcendence...and an eternity of having always been and always will have been going to be. So much so that Rose Tyler acting as Rose Tyler or as the Bad Wolf or as the Interface of the Moment all shake reality to its core, and even locking the entire being out of the universe merely led to that being's trans-temporal interference leading to somebody saying her name to let her back in, causing the whole universe to panic.


I think Cozy wasn't affected in the same way was because when she absorbed the magic she was an alicorn at the time. She had more magic and was more used to it


I agree with you, I believe that Pinkie pie does have chaos magic, but I think I might of figured out Cozyglow too, I think that she wasn't effected the same way as Pinkie is because she used it for evil instead of the way Pinkie used it, I think evil was put in her timeline instead, the magic might have given Cozyglow her horn.


@This Is Me UwU I am luna and I think you should stop ruining pony/humans childhood

Hey tia I am your sister but I am under cover did you eat my cake

You’re my favorite character princess Celestia!

@• Evil Slime 😈 Frog  • Celestia not a villain

Hi mom day dream here the half changling

@This Is Me UwU Yes I think pinkie pie is pansexual

@• Evil Slime 😈 Frog  • she's a creepy pasta pony if you didnt know search ut up to see the truth

OH MY GOD YOU ARE REAL CELESTIA TURN ME TO A UNICORN PLEEEEAAAASE

Lps Pinkish  In the episode <br>Horse Play Season 8 she say it

Lps Pinkish  In the episode
Horse Play Season 8 she say it

Your Highness. She should be a princess. But.... I think she has enough magic lol.

Princess Celestia thinks she is weird as well......now I know this is serious

PRINCESS CELESTIA-

-BOW FOR THE PRINCESS

I wish you showed more of your power, celestia.

@This Is Me UwU why would that ruin it- it makes it better lmao

@Lolypop 123 Sorry to ruin you childhood but MLP match They Pride Flags

This Is Me UwU I can relate to pinkie the most cause she deos behaviour that I do I can relate to that so yeah she’s my favourite character

This Is Me UwU who cares at being normal unique I think<br>Is better

This Is Me UwU who cares at being normal unique I think
Is better

Yh when she does all the stuff

WAIT IS PINKIE A GILLAN SPY

?


I feel like Pinkie is a different type of Earth Pony. It could’ve happened when the Sonic Rainboom happened. I don’t think When she got her powers from the bell it infused her entire life line, but could it be possible this is another form of Friendship Magic brought on by the Sonic Rainboom? When the Rainboom hit, it’s when Pinkie learned to smile, who knows what else it did to her


That's a fun theory. I wonder what the creators would say.<br>Too bad their story won't expand anymore since it ended...

That's a fun theory. I wonder what the creators would say.
Too bad their story won't expand anymore since it ended...


Very late, but <b>what if farming all those rocks do a number on the Pie Family?</b>

Very late, but *what if farming all those rocks do a number on the Pie Family?*


“Is someone Watching me?”

The 650K+ viewers:

ʍou ʇɥƃᴉɹ pᴉdnʇs ʞooʅ no⅄

ʍou ʇɥƃᴉɹ pᴉdnʇs ʞooʅ no⅄

ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽


She was destined to be the element of laughter and that  may have given her those abilities at birth.


Clears throat You know this is Pinkie your talking about, Pinkie is literally about, She the element of laughter, and she all about the illogical actions because she knows we are watching, and does all that to keep us entertained and remember Pinkie has always had Pinkie sense, beginning at a young age when she first saw a Rainboom before all this even Cheese Sandwich and even Maud Pie it probably runs  in the family
Also remember that every pony lost their powers that are their essence(the rest of the Mane Six probably got that but was showed off-screen) because how would twilight be able to absorb the magic of the past, present, and future mane six to defeat Tirek, Chrysalis, and cozy glow use and The Element of Harmony to defeat villains, remember when Tirek absorbed Braeburn essence that's their essence, which made the ponies of the Apple family in which they became too weak to do anything, and they are all earth ponies like Pinkie

*Clears throat* You know this is Pinkie your talking about, Pinkie is literally about, She the element of laughter, and she all about the illogical actions because she knows we are watching, and does all that to keep us entertained and remember Pinkie has always had Pinkie sense, beginning at a young age when she first saw a Rainboom before all this even Cheese Sandwich and even Maud Pie it probably runs  in the family
Also remember that every pony lost their powers that are their essence(the rest of the Mane Six probably got that but was showed off-screen) because how would twilight be able to absorb the magic of the past, present, and future mane six to defeat Tirek, Chrysalis, and cozy glow use and The Element of Harmony to defeat villains, remember when Tirek absorbed Braeburn essence that's their essence, which made the ponies of the Apple family in which they became too weak to do anything, and they are all earth ponies like Pinkie


I think it might just be Pinkie having her own type of magic, or when she saw the rain boom the magic started pulsing through her. Aka: she has her own chaos magic, but more low-key then Discord’s.


i always knew something was really weird about pinkie lol,, <br>i think she was just born with a bit of chaos magic and thats why she was able to control all of discord's chaos magic and cozy glow wasnt

i always knew something was really weird about pinkie lol,,
i think she was just born with a bit of chaos magic and thats why she was able to control all of discord's chaos magic and cozy glow wasnt


"A hole had just appeared in the Galaxy. It was exactly a nothingth of a second long, a nothingth of an inch wide, and quite a lot of million light years from end to end. The nothingth of a second for which the hole existed reverberated backwards and forwards through time in a most improbable fashion. Somewhere in the deeply remote past it seriously traumatized a small random group of atoms drifting through the empty sterility of space and made them cling together in the most extraordinarily unlikely patterns. These patterns quickly learnt to copy themselves (this was part of what was so extraordinary of the patterns) and went on to cause massive trouble on every planet they drifted on to...." AND THAT IS HOW EQUESTRIA WAS MADE

No!  Equestria was made with song! <b>Hugs Background Pony book</b> This is my equestrian bible! Away with your different stories!

No!  Equestria was made with song! *Hugs Background Pony book* This is my equestrian bible! Away with your different stories!

@Pinkajou if you're talking about the one " and that's how Equestria was made" it was from TF2 analysis the one with the robot invasion<br>Edit yay I got my reply high lighted

@Pinkajou if you're talking about the one " and that's how Equestria was made" it was from TF2 analysis the one with the robot invasion
Edit yay I got my reply high lighted


I solved pinkie pie! So, I’m thinking what you’re thinking, Sawtooth! And I think the time she absorbed Discord’s magic, it sent her new “powers” into the past, as well as the future. But then in the past was a chaos Pinkie Pie but only a little chaos because most of the magic contains at when she got her “new powers”. And that makes Pinkie Pie a little crazier! And then, her best friends the mane 6 just feel like she WAS crazy in the past and was always crazy in the past. And I’m not sure Pinkie Pie just is Pinkie Pie because I’m pretty sure everything has an reason just like Coronavirus.

꧁𝕎𝕠𝕝𝕗𝕪 𝔸𝕟𝕟𝕒𝕝𝕚𝕤𝕒꧂


Mister Sawtooth, there is a problem with your theory.
In the episode a gift for Maud Pie, when Maud gets Pinkie Pie's cannon back, she knows exactly who took it. When Rarity asks how, she replies, "Maud Sense" and then Pinkie says, " Runs in the Family." Which ultimately means that this sense or superpower runs in the Pie family.
So we can just assume that this superpower is from the Pie family instead of something only Pinke Pie has. It might be something related with her ancestors or even from Equestria's past. And about the cozy glow event, my theory says that not only Pinkie got the magic, her family did too. Thus concluding that this magic runs in the Pie family. Do you see how easily Maud can tell what rocks are, what they are made up of without doing anything except looking at it once. And her mother, remember the cutie mark chronicles? she could so easily tell that it was pinkus dianna pie aka Pinkie Pie, even though it could have been any of her daughters. Same goes for the rest of the Pie family. It fits well to what we already know about her family.


What if Pinkie got caught up in another type of magical event that left her with her chaoticness as a filly or that she’s related to a magical being of Chaos other than Discord who isn’t around anymore or Celestia gave her those abilities for some reason since Celestia seems to be pretty damn chill about Pinky being the way she is and doesn’t seem as confused as the others were


Maybe it reached out to a certain time in the past? I mean when she was a filly she always looked upset doing her rock chores with no pinkie sense 🤷♀


“Is someone watching me?!”
Thousands of people = Uh, no?

“Is someone watching me?!”
*Thousands of people* = *Uh, no?*

@Bubblepop_yt Yes, we are ALL watching him.<br>But Pinkie Pie observes all(everything), just as Twilight instructed her.

@Bubblepop_yt Yes, we are ALL watching him.
But Pinkie Pie observes all(everything), just as Twilight instructed her.

of course Pinkie Pie is watching you.  What's up with that?  She sees all, and ceases all knowledge by virtue of being the Pinkest of all Pink (ponies)..

THAT'S WHAT I SAID I LITTERLY SAID
Sawtooth waves : IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!?
Me : ya me duh

You'd be surprised how many people don't think that way, and are wrong.

@Hari Radhakrishnan are you talkin to me?

I am an artist
Ather people: no your not an artist 🙄
Me: yes I am.

Let's be honest here Pinkie Pie is just a kid friendlier version of Deadpool!


I thought she was just like this because it was a way of coping with her past, she sings happy songs with dark backgrounds and smiles through them all :) that might just be my opinion though haha<br>I love pinkie she's so cool

I thought she was just like this because it was a way of coping with her past, she sings happy songs with dark backgrounds and smiles through them all :) that might just be my opinion though haha
I love pinkie she's so cool


But doesn't Maud have an almost pinkie sense too, and if the chaos magic infected her entire timeline why did she only act like pinkie after the rainboom <br>There are some things if this theory is true, to explain cozy glow, since pinkie wasn't chaotic throughout her entire life, it could be the same with cozy glow only manifesting at a certain age with her becoming evil. It could've also been a trigger, like I said the rainbow almost caused pinkie pie to become pinkie pie. Maybe the rainbow triggered the chaos in a more silly and playful way, but cozy glow might have seen something or her own personal desire for great achievements and friends triggered it in a more evil, destructive, and obsessive way (sorry for it being so long)

But doesn't Maud have an almost pinkie sense too, and if the chaos magic infected her entire timeline why did she only act like pinkie after the rainboom
There are some things if this theory is true, to explain cozy glow, since pinkie wasn't chaotic throughout her entire life, it could be the same with cozy glow only manifesting at a certain age with her becoming evil. It could've also been a trigger, like I said the rainbow almost caused pinkie pie to become pinkie pie. Maybe the rainbow triggered the chaos in a more silly and playful way, but cozy glow might have seen something or her own personal desire for great achievements and friends triggered it in a more evil, destructive, and obsessive way (sorry for it being so long)


''Sloving pinkie is impossible''

Sawtooth:nothing is impossible to sloved


I mean with the cozy glow problem I think it was because she’s an unicorn/Alicorn. You see she already had so much magic in her while pinky had none. Maybe cozy glows magic was like how vaccines fight off germs. Cozy glows magic could have fought of that little time that she had discord’s magic. Pinky’s body could have not done that because of the fact she was an earth pony and had no magic in her. I know this might be a bold stament but these puxxle pieces fit together. We’ll never know why pinky’s like this! How ever I would like to be;I’ve it was discord’s magic as u had said in the video.


The fact that Pinkie Pie can defy the laws of physics and even gravity is one of the many reason's i love her as a character!

And to think Pinkie Pie isn't the only cartoon character in history to have been shown to defy the laws of physics, i mean after all  other cartoon characters such as Ed from Ed, Edd, n Eddy has been shown to defy the laws of physics from time to time.

Can someone please tell me the music of 1:16

@• Evil Slime 😈 Frog  • There's three dots on your comment. Click on that and then you get the option to edit your comment.


Sawtooth: “I may have just solved Pinkie Pie!”

Me: “Impossible!”


The answer for how pinkie would have the magic still is simple in another video came another suggestion that some magic can only be give willingly whilst cosy was willing to give back the magic in a heart beat pinkie was forced


Also remember that Pinkie took the royal sisters' magic on top of Discord's, enhancing her chaotic reach and power beyond Discord's


Pinkie has to already be compatible with chaos magic for her to be able to use it like that, but Discord's magic could have supercharged her Pinkie powers. Or actually, silly me, I know what it is! Dashie's first sonic rainboom!! A sonic rainboom is a massive explosion of colorful energy, and magic is just concentrated energy (which is why everypony was so weak when Tirek stole everpony's magic) so when Dashie's sonic rainboom made Pinkie all cheerful and bouncy it actually sparked a reaction with when future Pinkie got ahold of Discord's magic, making kinda an electrical connection, only with magic from opposite ends of the timeline.

This is also why Pinkie doesn't seem to have any of her Pinkie powers when she's in Pinkamena mode or in the alternate timelines Starlight made by preventing the first sonic rainboom.  Maybe her frizzy mane is because of the magic? Like how your hair goes all crazy when you get electrocuted.

Discord's chaos magic is what gives Pinkie her raw power, but she can only control it when she's fueled by the joy she got from the sonic rainboom, which she loses when she feels hurt and betrayed by her friends and goes full Pinkamena. Pinkie can feel sad or hurt without going full Pinkamena and she still retains some of her powers, but when that hair goes flat, that's it, game over. Actually, if anything Pinkie's chaos magic becomes downright destructive when she's in Pinkamena mode, like in the yovidaphone episode where flowers would die and balloons would deflate when Pinkie walked by. Going full Pinkamena made Pinkie lose control of her chaos magic and it started destroying things around her

Pinkie being supercharged with two types of magic also explains where Pinkie gets all her energy from! Being a hyper cheerful party girl without chaos magic, or magic in general really, is super exhausting! Seriously, this universe has like no magic at all!! How am I supposed to spread happiness and friendship when I can't even make it half a day without crashing!?