Theory:Pinkies "magic" (ability to get a cutie mark) was to overpowered and when she got discord's magic it powered up that overpowered cutie mark magic and spread it throughout her whole life and she became the pony she is kinda like your theory

@Dominique Fairclough no,im saying her magic inside of her to get her cutie mark was too strong and could easily be activated by a rainbow and discord's magic and make her the random pinkie she is

But are you trying to say all party ponies are overpowered and plus what about her family they have some of her abilities eg maud pie she can teleport is super fast and strong and has maid sense among others


cozy was an alicorn and pinkie was just a pony so she couldn't handle all that magic unlike cozy


Pinky is the pony who made parties so i know that pinky has magic but to party she is the only party pony girl in the first season 1 so she has party magic but not a princess


Cheese Sandwich l’s existincw implies this is just a rarer form of earth magic. If all earth magic only helped with farming and surveying they’d be pigeonholed as a race. The cakes have implied cake magic so it’s just one of those things


i think pinkie is a unicorn because she has the power to teleport and stretch out and i bet a unicorn has a spell to do that.


I thought If pinkie pie still had discords magic wouldn't she be a unicorn?


The magic was stolen before pinkie absorbed discords magic so thats not true


Sawtooth:I just solved pinkie pie

Rainbow dash:And you live?


Wow this guy/the channels owner has eagle eyes


I wonder if pinkie pie is discord and he was caged in pinkie pie’s brain and one day he came out


Pinkie pie is breaking the fourth wall and everything she does I KEEP SCREAMING AT HER TO sToP


You give such such a look reading darklord


Maybe it's like part of Her special talent Cuting mark magic maybe it's part of that maybe that's why she so he's pulling like party cannons out of nowhere in and killer parting and evening and in season 8 in the 1st showing season 8 she says not even that teeny canning and she Pulls out at the


It's Radvile not Edmundas but I have question. What about Mood? Or... Is it Maud?.. You know Pinkie's sister. She too has a sense. Am I saing that right?


Dude she can break the fourth wall don't question it it means the human world


Wait can I tell you something might be an alicorn Pinkie pie can be an alicorn but then again what about Twilight and it's true to an alicorn so like is it impossible cuz there's been lots of fairies like the tanks you know cakes like Pinkie pie have always been a main character but not the really meanest character so sure she might be an alicorn but there's other things behind that fire and marble it's just you know different about them if they're yellow hair yellow hair


was friendship is witchcraft right after all?


Sawtooth- is someone watching me<br>Me- duh this is a video

Sawtooth- is someone watching me
Me- duh this is a video


Ya'll remember how discord shakes when sense's danger and pinkie pie shakes too when sense's danger maybe tha magic of chaos did spread in her??

consider the oposit, and the reverse connection too.
but, what if there were to pop up Chaos Ponies left and right?
s this why they shut down the show?


it affected pinkie pie because she's not supposed to have magic.


I have watched all episodes and this episode is almost the last one so


But... Pinkie isn't turn into an alicorn when she got the magic


I think the bell is the cause cause the bell May have different effects om different types of pony types


‘Is someone watching me?!?!’
Me: Yes we all watching you
(this is my mum’s acc)


Wait can pinkie pie tell the future of mlp? 🤨💅🏻
That will be weird and cool lol
Or

Pinkie and discord are the same person 😳💅🏻
Or

Pinkie is just crazy... 🤨💅🏻
Or

Ok bye 🙃💅🏻


Is someone watching me?

proceeds to look at camera

Is someone watching me?

*proceeds to look at camera*


“Is someone watching me” <br>Yt: yes yes we are

“Is someone watching me”
Yt: yes yes we are


I think she got her magic when she saw the rainboom she got her Cutie Mark and also her smile and magic


Does anyone remember when this was called bronynotion? Oh just me? Yeah that was like five years ago

Ya, me as well tho I don't remember following


Twilight: watche's This video<br>also Twilight: HOWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

Twilight: watche's This video
also Twilight: HOWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW


He’s not lying I went back to bed episode pinkie pie did get power back it was unbelievable I couldn’t believe it


If pinkie kept that magic the WORLD would be chaos-


Him: is someone watching me?<br>Me: yeah dude or you wouldn't have 322k subs

Him: is someone watching me?
Me: yeah dude or you wouldn't have 322k subs


But if pinky got her pinki sence through discords magic how comes that cheese sendwitch has a cheese sence ? Source s4. Ep 12 pinkis stolz


also, no being could handle discords magic'


Pinky pies magic is her happiness and joy


I have a question y do discord have chaos magic but y didnt he grow up like pinkie when she absorb discords magic?


You missed something out. Why didn't fluttershy and rainbow dash get the magic sparks? after all, they have their own unique abilty, the sonic rainboom and <b>stare</b> either animation error or these abilities arent magic..?

You missed something out. Why didn't fluttershy and rainbow dash get the magic sparks? after all, they have their own unique abilty, the sonic rainboom and *stare* either animation error or these abilities arent magic..?


What episode does Pinkie Pie steal his magic


They should make pinky pie a alicron     <br>Because she will be  princess of chaos 😂😂

They should make pinky pie a alicron
Because she will be  princess of chaos 😂😂


I don’t Think that pinkie pie has power 🤔🤗


How old is starlight in one video she said she is 732 can you please like explain us


Cozy whatever did get the magic but she’s has wings it’s probably something to do with that pink girl is just a horse


Remember that joke about pinkie having adhd what if she does


Je...sus...Christ.<br>I think you're but at the same time I don't due to the fact Cozy glow doesn't receive the same randomness as Pinkie does.

Je...sus...Christ.
I think you're but at the same time I don't due to the fact Cozy glow doesn't receive the same randomness as Pinkie does.


Sawtooth pinkie switch from th mirror serveral times thats how she knows everything


What about cheese sandwich he also has the sense thing


It can also be that pinkie pie has a long sibling that she doesen’t now and is a unciorn and pinkie pie have the same power but are not a unciorn


Yes someone’s watching you.......a thousand ppl are!!!!


but what about when she was younger she didn’t do that


If its about pinkie sense How about cheese sand which sense?


Even if this tearoy was not true it still would explain why pinky got her magic when apple jack and rainbow dash and fluttershy did not


someone talking about me and my best friend: 1:36


I am a biiiiiiiiiiiiiiig fan of my little pony and you of course


Pinkie is full of the chaos.. all da time


They did specifically say cozy could not control it where as pinkie could.


At the end of Equestria girls pinky pie which’s places with the human pinky maybe they which all the time and pinky got some kind of power from the portal cause she goes tho it so often??


Yes someone is watching you I'am watching you


TWILIGHT SPARKLE WOULD LUKE TO KNOW YOUR LOCATION


What if pinkie pie was discords daughter


Brony : is someone watching me

Me :  .........duh your on YouTube


if Pinkie pie has new kind of crazy magic than why isn't she an alicorn

That’s what I’ve been thinking forever from what I’ve seen she is at least princess celestial or twilight level and has all the qualities even tho a little unorthodox in her ways.


What if pinkie is not a pony because well just think about?


Pinkie has a trail that rainbow has<br>Find the episode that pinkie gets mad

Pinkie has a trail that rainbow has
Find the episode that pinkie gets mad


Wait look at pinkie pie cutie mark when she was holding the bell


How do u know this stuff it's cool but how do u know


what about maud sense? doesnt maud have it too.


Pinkie pie is crazy but I like pinkie pie 🎈


Can you do a comment reading pleeeeeeeas😇🥺🥺🥺


No offence but I dis agree it's just that she likes to party and she is happy  plus lets face it its pinkie pie we talking about if this was twighlight sure BUT SRSLY ITS PINKY


why do you have to solving these thing, it's just...mlp...and hasbro?!?


So in the other time you. Said that discord is the only derquanaqweast you lied no efwens


i have a culu pink pinkie pie is mary is that pony lost her lahfter


Wait.... cozy glow turned into alicorn but pinky didnt....


You watch pokemon what's your favorite pokemon


How its pinkie pie can contorl kaos magic hhhmmmmmm...


Wait why did only cozy become an alicorn and not pinkie


What the-what are you even you saying today?


Or maybe her magical power is 4th wall breaks. That would explain how she knows things before they happen, is able to teleport from scene to scene, and is able to talk about events from equestria girls despite it being in an entirely different universe. That would also explain why she takes pinkie promises so seriously,  bc she knows that if certain things don't happen a specific way, it could result in disaster. Being able to break the 4th wall also would explain her carefree personality. She already knows what will happen and how to get the outcome she wants... so y worry? these 4th wall breaks can also come in the form of visions in her dreams. What if princess luna gave her visons of different dimensions? Maybe its not chaos magic after all.


This actually makes perfect sense to me. Up until this I always just excused Pinkie's behavior as typical cartoon logic, plus in realm full of magic it made some sense.
But this theory actually makes the nonsense make sense!
However there is one question I have about it.
When Tirek first took over in the show, we saw him drain the magic from everypony, including pegasai and earth ponies.
Pegasai made sense a bit cause it drained their ability to fly, but what did it drain from the earth ponies then?
If this is correct, then it makes sense that she had magic drained then, but what about all the other earth ponies?


Actually, I think we do have some slight evidence that Cozy Glow's past was effected by the influx of Discord's Chaos magic. Consider this... what causes a simple pegasus filly to go full Sociopath? I'm not buying that she was innocent in the beginning of her appearance. I am pretty sure everything she did at the School of Friendship was for the sake of sewing ruination. While she may not have gained powers in the past, as such, she DID gain the mindset for causing Discord and Disharmony.


My theory is that the purpose and different type of pony handle the chaos magic differently.<br>Cozy turned into a she demon because she had evil intentions and Pinkie simply just grew bigger and wanted to turn the cosmos into food because well, Pinkie loves food.

My theory is that the purpose and different type of pony handle the chaos magic differently.
Cozy turned into a she demon because she had evil intentions and Pinkie simply just grew bigger and wanted to turn the cosmos into food because well, Pinkie loves food.


I think it would make sense that pinkie, even without the chaos magic, is predisposed to have more capacity to control chaos magic because of her other intrinsic characteristics. After all, she does represent the spirit of laughter, so perhaps chaos and laughter are distantly related. After all, laughter is a result of the unexpected, and chaos is also a subversion of expectations based on our previous experiences.


Maybe the reason it didn’t affect Cozy Glow is because she wanted to use the chaos magic for something it wasn’t meant for. She couldn’t control it at all. But Pinkie at least accepted the chaos and wanted to use it for chaotic things.


Final conclusion: Pinkie can do anything. Nothing suspicious.

....the fact that she predicted all that happened in the human/pony world calling it a hunch....


Just one slight question: What chaos entity did Maud absorb the powers of?


Hmmm... I agree. I also have something to add. Maybe pinkie was supposed to have grey skin and a droopy mane like the rest of her family, but when the chaos affected her life her mane became poofy and changed her skin color. I don’t really have evidence for the color change, but for the mane I do. You know when twilight took in all of the princesses magic? Well for a second, having that much magic made her mane flow just like the royal sisters. So when filly pinkie got the chaos magic, her mane went from droopy and dull to poofy and out of control. (Much like chaos) I also would like to say that the sparkles that form every now and then on the royal sister’s mane, might   Be shown in the form of the lighting sparks that can be seen in the very moment pinkie took in all of that chaos magic. Another thing I want to point out is that when the sisters lost their magic, their manes stopped flowing. So this is proof that magic can be shown physically like how pinkie had a color and mane change.  😯 this is a cool topic.


What if what we were watching when we were following the series was the “2nd run” of the whole timeline and the first one changed so much that if we were watching the first, both pinkie and the way friendship would be presented would be different in many ways... and maybe on that first run when she got that dose of chaotic magic she couldn’t control it very well but since it was the second time with the magic, maybe she was able to control it more


As someone mentioned, Pinkie's "sense" runs in her family so most likely inherited.

what if there was a male Pie, to pair the Mares with and see what came out?


I think the difference between pinkie and cozy is this.

Cozy was an alicorn at that time, making her used to large amounts of magic.

Pinkie is a earth pony at that time, making her not used to magic, especially large amounts of it.


this actually a perfect theory, no holes... thanks to the comment section. Sawtooth did it again. Never stop making vids


The reason why chaos magic didn’t spread throughout cozy glow’s timeline is because she only had chaos magic and 1/3 grogar’s magic <br>But pinkie pie had discord,celestia,luna and all of grogar’s magic so that’s why it spread throughout her timeline

The reason why chaos magic didn’t spread throughout cozy glow’s timeline is because she only had chaos magic and 1/3 grogar’s magic
But pinkie pie had discord,celestia,luna and all of grogar’s magic so that’s why it spread throughout her timeline


That's... actually a decent theory. I could see it working. Kinda like Clara from Dr. Who in a way...


This theory is amazing, but if we go bad and look at the PSSD episode, there is a Maud sense. And pinkie said that it runs in the family. So there is "Pinkie sense", "Maud sense", and if it runs in the family, all the family members have their own sense. So, pinkie sense might not be the evidence.


She could also be part unicorn, in the brief shot of Pinkie and Cheese Sandwich’s children her older foul is a unicorn, which means one or both of them have unicorn blood. Considering both seem to share similar characteristics (pulling things out of nowhere, having some foresight) it’s possible both have latent unicorn magic.


I think this theory is true in fact when I watched the episode where he is exhausted some of discord is Power I would, I was cooking up a theory quite similar to this but it wasn't really coming together but I think you have solved it so yeah🤗


is there a theory on why twilight got big like celestia at the end of the show even tho cadence and luna never got that big? might be connected to how both cozy and pinkie got bigger when they absorbed powerful magic (size correlating with magical ability?)


I thought immediately during that moment "oh, it's cuz Pinkie has chaos magic too!" but this makes so much sense.


One thing I want to tell you! It would not be possible that she got her powers from the bell, the episode of the chaos pinkie was AFTER the pinkie senses. She already had it when pinkie absorbed the bell


You cant "solve pinkie pie." All you can do is accept that you will never truly understand her and that's okay.


What if the reason cozy didn’t get effected too bad was because she shared the magic with the other two? Splitting it equally. Pinkie was the only one who took hold of the bell while the three villains had it go to them all at the same time while in battle. The villains also had Bad intentions while pinkie was being pinkie. Her chaos is different from evil chaos. Needless maybe discord also was changed after. Discord never said anything about him being sick before the episode “three’s a crowd” maybe him being evil protected him. Like when cozy was cold she wasn’t thinking too evil like the others. Once she did she ditched the blanket she had. Discord could of been the same. So since pinkie wasn’t planning on doing bad it gave her stronger magic. (But bad chaos comes before good chaos so it could of been doing it’s job doing something evil then being okay but I don’t think that’s right.) discord also seemed to take on the job of the elements being able to turn pony’s to stone. Before he could of done that with the two sisters but he couldn’t since the elements didnt let him before he was good. I think the first magic spark from the friendship of fire was able to help guide the pillars to plant the elements even though the elements already existed. The elements existed through the pillars then when was planted turned into artifacts. But when planning to be destroyed they gave their power of turning people to stone they gave it to the next best thing. Someone who represents all the creatures. When they channeled it to him he felt this new power and used it for good. Like the elements had done it before in the past. The elements them selves could of been stuck in a loop then they changed the destiny using the spirit of magic. But back then it still looked like twilight since twilight looks nothing like her parents the elements used their baby as the element of magic and why is made the mane six the colors of the rainbow (pinkie being the pastel red since they’re in pastel colors) the elements changed history. They were stuck and didn’t like it so they made both the main six and discord. They made the mane six to hold their other power that ponies couldn’t do. Discord for their other powers and that’s why discord doesn’t fit the normal species he is. The student six was what they used to make the loop end and take the focus off the artifacts and onto friendship. While it’s true cozy didn’t go crazy but that’s what the elements intended on happening but didn’t expect pinkie to grab the bell. When she did the spirit of magic was confused and gave pinkie her power of pinkie sense because it gave her its plan but not fully designed. So it gave pinkie the other realms if created by accident. Which the small sparkle of power went into pinkie nose is because she puts her nose where it shouldn’t be while rarity and twilight had it go to their horns.

Sorry for the long comment


Believe it or not the first ever episode of my little pony was a story kind of beginning so it would make sense if the timelines were already the plan for the future


you’re probably right. cozy’s timeline wasn’t affected because she was an alicorn when she absorbed discord’s magic and she was powerful enough to handle it??


It made me laugh when he said “ is someone watching me”


But Maud had Maud sense. Pinkie said that it ran through the family. Maud was able to easily find the guy Pinkie sold the cannon to.


For the people asking how that crazy thing effected human pinkie, the answer is: it didn't, human pinkie doesn't defy fisics, she just knows about pony pinkie, because pony pinkie and human pinkie, switch through the mirrors.


You can't explain pinkie pie, she's pinkie pie!

That's a pretty good theory

You can't explain pinkie pie, she's pinkie pie!

*That's a pretty good theory*


Sawtooth I have always wonderd why only discord is able to use chaos magic acodingly and without going nutts like it did with pinky and coasy glow or when tirek accsidentally made bunch of rubber chicken appear instead of exploding the wall. Is it because chaos magic is so complicated and unpredictable to Control that it takes very long time to master it or is it just that because discord is creature of chaos he has some kind of subconsious sense to understand how chaos magic works and that way is only one who is able to use it acordingly and in it's full extend?


Does that mean that having Discord's chaos magic makes you aware of our reality?

Dude, that reminds me about what happened to Monika in DDLC-


That would explain why she was so different from the rest of her family!


Nah, its just those amazing cupcakes she makes. I wonder if shes hiding any secret ingredients in those pastries...................................


Would that mean that cheese sandwich has also had chaos magic as his ability’s are very similar to pinkie pie’s? It seems very unlikely so I don’t think pinkie’s powers come from discord’s chaos magic


I had a feeling discord and pinkies chaos powers were connected someway somehow it’s there too similar So I’m not that shocked although I’m glad someone finally put it out in the public especially you


Sawtooth you are amazing I think you truly have solved pinkie pie


you just solved the greatest mystery of man kind


Here’s something weird pinkie knew how to control discord’s magic while cozy glow didn’t.


This kinda beats with Discord = chaos and Spirit of harmony = harmony since all of them are spirits (the mane 6) cause how can you possibly have harmony and chaos in the same body? Come to think of it how can there be a spirit of harmony if the mane 6 are already spirits of harmony


pinky is a party poney and everyone saw pinkie pie play 10 musical stuff and twilight said " its just pinkie"<br>so maybe when she came to a party pony that made a BIG difference. Even tho she can shake our view and tell what is happening in other worlds

pinky is a party poney and everyone saw pinkie pie play 10 musical stuff and twilight said " its just pinkie"
so maybe when she came to a party pony that made a BIG difference. Even tho she can shake our view and tell what is happening in other worlds


It may have something to do with Discord himself taking Pinkiey's powers, as a friend, while Cozy Glow wanted to get rid of it.


In the equestria girls bloopers, pony pinkie and human pinkie went through the portal to swap places, which explains her strange  knowledge.


Ελευθερία Θανούλη


Sawtooth: I may have solved pinkie pie...<br>Me: wait, this is BIG!

Sawtooth: I may have solved pinkie pie...
Me: wait, this is BIG!


Pinkie Pie cannot be 'solved,' mortal. Pinkie Pie is..beyond your changeling understanding. Nobody on your plane of existence can understand. Perhaps one day you will. We make no promises.


but if pinkie sense was from discords chaos magic pinkie took in at that moment then in season 6 episode 3 pinkie said that maud also had maud sense. Is it possible that when pinkie pie got all that chaos magic that affected her whole timeline it also connected to her family? That's confusing.


i think that cozy glow also had the same exprience like think about it why did cozy turn evil ? well idk, but maybe, the same thing with pinkie the one moment of cozy glow when she absorbed that magic it affected her past turning her evil just like pinkie so only discord can have his magic not any creature else thats what makes fluttercord i mean discord special and thus this can be true and sawtooth theory may be right and the 2 ponies [cozy,pinkie] can be explained


OK I know this moment in the series was just a joke referencing the older MLP art style but this IS another way that Pinkie managed to interact with time - https://youtu.be/eIo9UXSaxFI?t=115
lol


what about cheese sandwich's cheesy sense? How do you explain that?


Well when discord regains his magic he doesn’t grow maybe when a creature gains magic it spreads out differently for different creatures


Maybe its earth pony magic but its extremely powerful


2:14 HOW DID I NOT NOTICE THAT!!!
welp time to look back and see it for myself


this is just a thought but what if pinkie was adopted by the pies? i mean look at her skin and her hair she looks noting like her family, and i know that at the start when she was a kid she did look " dull " but imagine your the only one in your family with such a piculuar skin tone and she somehow has magic in her blood, so maybe her bialogical parents, relatives, siblings etc have come from some kind of powerfull lands like where the alicorns come from and her parents probably died when she was just a baby. im not sure but that my theorie


Yeah your right. But Cozy got Discords power too but we didn't see her doing something crazy. Someone saying it's because Cozy is an alicorn. But it's posible if Cozy alredy has chaos magic.But alicorns doesn't have chaos magic so i don't think Pinky got her powers from that moment.


i dont think they were thinking of season 9 when they made season 1...


My theory:pinkie was suposed to be a alicorn but she got affected by discords magic unleashing herself to loose it somehow being crazy all her life so when she was born discord was there and when pinkies parent's left the room discord made her hold that evil thing to give her magic affecting her future if pinkie was alicorn she'd be princess of happiness or partying but most likely being happiness cause she brings people happiness if they are sad straight away so thats why pinkie bugs her friends with being crazy all the time and got replaced by twilight the main six somehow put up with her and her weirdness for example when pinkie was depressed she was all dark and there are other theories saying "pinkie is a murderer behind the sences she turns her friends into cupcakes" or "she steals there cutie marks" or mabye the 3 princesses inclueding twilight know pinkie has mental disorders but hides it from everyone or shes a traiter to the ponie town and so on but she got so conected to the ponie town that she stayed until she woukd betray the town and her friends she was depressedas a kid probably cause of that evil magic


But Pinkie said that the “ sense ” things runs in the family ( I don’t exactly remember which episode though) like the Maud sense sooo ya.


I think she is just a earth pony with some <b>interesting</b> characters.

I think she is just a earth pony with some *interesting* characters.


Chotlate rain from pinkie pie when cozy glow took all magic away when the mane 6 her magic is from her brain I think she was like that from the bell I think some didn’t get out so case solved


In the video ask pony's pinkie pie had wings on her hair and she was a unicorn which makes her an alicorn but that makes sense because if she was bouncing and pulling off tricks and possible maybe she was using magic or rather flyiy


But in one episodes they told that in Pinkie's full family had Pie-Sense


SHE IS A CHANGELING she makes people love her she is able to bring other effects she makes holes in time yes or is she discord creation😱


Why do we need to solve Pinkie Pie??? 🎉 🎈 🎊


u forget about maud sense.
and i think the reason that cosy glow isn't crazy
is because she is an alicorn,
sort of LOL
and because pinky like this magic and traped some of it in her, for her entire timeline


pinkie can control discord magic?it looks like she did it


That's a good theory but I think it could just be Pinkie


I think pinkypie is a alicorn and her horn is hiding under her hair and she accidentally cast an unknown spell on her horn which made it thin as paper or she accidentally cast an unknown spell which makes her horn invisible or made her horn vanish into thin air ( same with her wings)but she is still able to use her horn and is secretly the princess of good chaos .


but what about cheese sandwhich? they're practically the same


i wonder.. could pinkie just be, like, discords sister or something, but she just always keeps her pony form??


Cake for the Pink God!<br>Frosting for the Party Throne!!!!!

Cake for the Pink God!
Frosting for the Party Throne!!!!!


Okay but can you explain cheese sandwich’s cheesy sense


Maybe she a unicorn and has a spell to hide it😱


This Theory makes sense but I think it’s pinkie pie being pinkie pie because if you think about it all this magic stuff makes no sense in the human world but pinkie pie acts pretty much exactly the same as pony pinkie pie I don’t think someone took the bell into the human world and gave it to the human pinkie pie for 20-30 second than took the magic right back and without anyone noticing but who knows maybe that’s just want happened


Video: Finally Solving Pinkie Pie<br>Me: Wait, that's illegal.

Video: Finally Solving Pinkie Pie
Me: Wait, that's illegal.


him (Im too nervous to say da name): is someone watching me?

me: you break the fourth wall all the time..... why are you asking.. WHY


It's just a show, there for pinkie is just pinkie.<br>Maybe they were going to give magic to all the ponies but then got lazy🤷

It's just a show, there for pinkie is just pinkie.
Maybe they were going to give magic to all the ponies but then got lazy🤷


I think Pinkie pie is the mad hatter but in pony form. 😀


pinkie knows about the dimention because she swichs with the other pinkie.
i know because i saw it in a mini movie
😑


wait a minute cozy tried to use discords magic but it fail every time she tried to break something  nothing hapen but when pinkie pie pick the caos magic she used and didn't fail<br>in fact she use the magic like discord like she sumon a cake from nowere

wait a minute cozy tried to use discords magic but it fail every time she tried to break something  nothing hapen but when pinkie pie pick the caos magic she used and didn't fail
in fact she use the magic like discord like she sumon a cake from nowere


I think she was just born with these abilities


Maybe discord’s magic made cozy glow evil?


Sawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?!
Me: Everybody
Edit:Get it?
Edit 2:I do

Sawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?!
Me: *Everybody*
Edit:Get it?
Edit 2:I do


That is a good way but I believe that pinkie is adopted because when you adopt the baby changes last names.pinkie is more excited and proud and loves everyone but with the rest mod pie she is a chill person. I have one more thing to add pinkie is pink all over and the pies are either gray or a Gary is purple and white


Maybe pinky is chaotic good discord is obviously chaotic neutral and if you think about it cozy glow could very easily be chaotic evil


Well said she is Pinkie Pie and she is the element of laughter that means well she's naturally strange in that is her magic


I think that she has magic is Because she must has a hiding horn in her hair


you can nevver solve her loll mom i got my craziness from mom bcs in school i actually get my party cannon and made a surpise party for 4 minutes bcs our teacher got back from vacation- thanks mom (pinkie)


She get her magic there and affected her time life


She did not get it craziness from the chaos magic


The real thing thats bugging me is how did cadence be a alicorn pls tell me ......how is pinky so energetic do u think its bc of all the cakes mabey she should live in a non cake house


you should play the game of MLP that their is a character named chaos princess that looks like <br>pinkie pie that is an alicorn

you should play the game of MLP that their is a character named chaos princess that looks like
pinkie pie that is an alicorn


The reason why Cozy glow Is different then pinkie pie it’s because that she Only took the Discord is magic pinkie pie took discord Magic and the princesses magic


I think Pinkie Pie is secretly an Alicorn or a unicorn. She has big poofy mane, who knows what could be hiding in there? From season 8 school raze, only the unicorns and Alicorns got there magic back and  so did pinkie!


No she has been wild forever so I think sense flutter shy can basically talk to animals pinky pie must have a weird ability to but sense she has more than one and apple jack doesn’t and pinky pies family isn’t a thing like her but she might actually have chaos in her blood but it never came from when we saw discord pinky I think Pinky pie is adopted because she doesn’t look a thing like her family <br>Also please make a video about how pinky pie might be adopted

No she has been wild forever so I think sense flutter shy can basically talk to animals pinky pie must have a weird ability to but sense she has more than one and apple jack doesn’t and pinky pies family isn’t a thing like her but she might actually have chaos in her blood but it never came from when we saw discord pinky I think Pinky pie is adopted because she doesn’t look a thing like her family
Also please make a video about how pinky pie might be adopted


pinky with chaos: unlimited <del>power</del> frosting!

pinky with chaos: unlimited -power- frosting!


Discord and Pinkie Pie stop breaking the fourth wall


Someonetimes she owns a Meth lab in sugar cub corner ngl


No it’s just pinkie pie and discord can break the fourth wall that’s all


Theres a theory by ConspiraPon3 that explains pinkies chaos because she a changling. The episode is called The Pinkie Predicament.


Who is always weird not that one moment she was always really not that one moment changed everything she was always weird in the beginning to the end how could possibly happen if pinky was magically transformed from only that one moment she was crazy and weird and think he sensed everywhere in every episode not that just one mom and changed everything how could we even know from episode one


Who else wished the mlp creators watched these so then the q can be a


pinkies powers has something to do with her cutiemark/destiny.


Is it me or did pinkie look stoned or drunk?


OMG UR SO Adorable!!!!. I thought the pony w fandom was dead!. glad it's not u won a sub btw I was wondering so are u currently a brony lol if so neat lol i got into my little pony cus of a brony lol he was also my boy friend at the time sadly i had to move so our love was not to last but our love for mlp will last forever!!!! or at least till the fandom die's XD


The part where pinky got magic was i think her punkt sence


You know when sawtooth said is someone watching me yes us!


What about discord... What job could discord do?


I think pinkie only revied the pinkie sence


this.. scared me.. idk why but its creepy


ye ur right maybe her tail shivers cuze theres somthing coming in the future :0


Different. Faces you can make 1. :3
2. T.T
3. O.O
4.;-;
That’s all


I think she turn into an à la corn deep inside


Pinkie pie is pinkie pie and dash has wings but how was apple jack flying in that one episode lol


well i think that pinkie pie has party power beacause its pinkie,s ciutiemark


I say Pinkie is well.....Pinkie but she's NOT a EATH PONY 🐴  But I will say that in one of my videos 💗


People are watching you because on YouTube right now you know that it's kind of funny you said that my name is Leah Marie King and my life is actually super crazy at first my mom just freaked out I have no idea why do then only if you want to talk about the rest


Yes we are watching you sawtooth I am to and I always will be hahaha


I dout the Bell gave Pinki her odd ablittys because what a bout Cheeze  Sence?


Are we even sure pinky is a normal pony maybe it is your theory but what if she is a different type like we have seen hipogrifs and every thing but maybe not every thing there world is big and they only exsplore a lil maybe there are others that look like earth pony’s but have som strange magic and maybe they like to stay hidden like a lost tribe of whatever they are and they hav strange abblites yes that theory might be good but what about cozy glow the magic was hard for her but she did not have the chaos spread she was fine except from those pineapples the might have left a mark but pinky might be from somewhere else she might be pony but not a earth pony or any other we have herd like a very old species not hating on the vid but what if just think about it why is she the only pink one in her faimly even be four her cutie mark and remeber pinky could control most of it like she loved the chock late rain when they first met discord and all of a shunned it starts to rain when she has it a person with magic would know how to use it but pinky could not really control what happened it’s like an instinct like how every one and thing has different instincts just think about it


Pinky and Discord could be cousins!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME???

oh of course not sawtooth ;I


I got a question soon soon pinkie pies it's the question is there's so many episode of My Little Pony and and Pinkie Pie bye why was got something her magic back of the others didn't


Pinky  pie  just   likes   partys   but  I  think  your   right


Dude ur wrong cuz when pinkie got the magic it’s when the villains were not in stone cuz cozy glow was the one who drained all the magic wait am I wrong or not cuz I don’t remember lol plz say I’m wrong or not in the comments of this comment


What does cosyglow cutie mark mean 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔


<b>Princess Twilight would like to know your location</b>

*Princess Twilight would like to know your location*


Brony :  is someone watching me<br>Me :  duh u r on YouTube

Brony :  is someone watching me
Me :  duh u r on YouTube


NeW tHeArY  dIsCoRd Is PiNkYs DaD iN a WaY


Maybe you can try to find the truth about Pokémon just any Pokémon would be good cheers my suggestion is that you can do mew mimiyu and  oh ho


You can’t solve pinkie pie she like  discord


Yeah we are all watching you after all this is a video🎂👍💐🌹🎵🎶🥰🎁!ho yes and the video was very nice to and  bye-bye.😃❤👍


(pinkie pie) i dont have wierd powers i mean look t chease sanbwich i now youre talking about me


I do you like this But what about maud sense


Pinkie pie is crazy but, I like pinkie........


I just thank you bye I don’t know I hope that broker a hole by three guys they are never chocolate rain that mean is if only they are have magic in this box is chilling with it it’s steals have magic not so much interested this one OK I’m really


Yes we do watch you and u are a cartoon tell pinkie pie that maybe THAT she won't handle ;>


Yes but i do not like pinkecord but wen cozy glow dose not stile all the magic cuz thay still have thar cutie mark


Wait wait wait there is a roblox guy called “imnotequonox” and Im his friend soooo is he/she the real<br>Youtuber????????????????

Wait wait wait there is a roblox guy called “imnotequonox” and Im his friend soooo is he/she the real
Youtuber????????????????


Okay I think she have to have it the magical goes back into her because she has is that happiness 😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀

I have a great day at school this week I have been a long day of work for the kids is that we have a new one in our home tomorrow night we are all in our family so I will have a good night tomorrow and I have to go home and get to the kids is that we can give her her name so I know what I can see she told her she would have to go to get the kids her I told you I was wondering if you would have a chance if she would have been there she can get it she told you that I told you I 🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚

Night time and I am not going home tomorrow morning and then I have a couple more days of work tomorrow so we will

Not to say anything but she did a lot more then her kids she has to do her work and her family is not in school 🏫 was her day to do the work for me that was a lot better and I will have a great 👍 I would be very very good I will only need a few friends that she has to pay for the house she has told her she wants her and her family she is so sorry to pay 💰 she was so I was wondering if you were going home 🏠 is that time for her kids I would like to go to school 🏫 I love 💓 it all I know is I am a little sister I can not tell if I have her family and her family💸💳💷💶💴💵🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄


Stop asking  for us to coment you tell us!!


Idk maybe pinky is gust her ? Oh now I’m not


Pinkie pie is not a unicorn or a pegasus she is just a plain Old earth pony


Wait doesn’t pinkies sister mod have…mod sense


U solving pinky <br>Is mat Pat solving fnaf


Are You aaaaaaaa………………………………………Peper?!😛😃😃🤨🤨🤨


A very good and reasonable theory. I never saw the little detail that Pinkie also got some magic back. But, I don't now if that makes sense, when the chaos magic infected Pinkie in the past too, shouldn't the magic also infected Discord while he was powerless? He would've managed some chaotic things, because his magic influenced him from the future, when he got his magic back? Like Pinkie and her abilities? Or maybe she realizes that she's in a cartoon, because she broke the fourth wall more than one time. It's like when you are realizing that you are dreaming, you can control the dream (okay, mostly you just wake up). That's why Pinkie can use simple cartoon tricks. O^O Okay, that would be too far fetched. XD A crazy idea, I know. XD


I think that you are right about pinkie and discord’s chaos magic, however I think the reason that it affected pinkie differently than cozy is that pinkie also absorbed the princesses magic. I think that princess magic and chaos magic might have been so much that it spread out, but chaos magic on its own wasn’t enough, hence why cozy wasn’t affected.


A while back, I came to the same conclusion; Pinkie had somehow been infused with Chaos magic. I didn’t know how, but thanks to your vid, I can see a good picture


As much as I like this theroy and I do believe Pinkie has magic unlike unicorns, alicorns, pegesai and normal earth ponies I don't think it is discord's. I also don't think Pinkie is meant to be solved. She is unique and random and can break phisics apparently But maybe Pinkie Pie has as many layers to her magic as an onion or she is just as confusing and weird as a cross between an orange and a frog. As fun as it is to theorise maybe in this case the best answer is the simplest one: Pinkie is Pinkie and that's how it's supposed to be.


I think that the reason Pinky took Discored’s magic so well is because there related. If one of Discord’s relatives married someone and one of their kids didn’t have chose magic they probably wouldn’t talk to them kinda like in Harry Potter with pure bloods and skwibs. Since women take a men’s sr name when they marry the pie family could be related to Discored but since Pinky was the only one who absorbed Discores  magic she is the only one with those qualities and that might be why she looks so different.


I think you theory right, and the reason it only affected Pinkie and not CozyGlow is because the magic may have been more unstable without Discord to contain it. I can’t remember if this is true or not but alicorn magic may have been in the bell when Pinkie used it.

theres also the comics in which contain a alicorn pinkie.


Cozy Glow could also been effected by cauose magic but instead of making her have reality breaking powers from the bell she was led down a very unusual path becoming evil and all that stuff. Because of these different reactions too the magic could have made them go down paths that made them have said reactions to the magic in the bell. But that’s just my theory!


she couldn’t teleport out of tartarus or literally defy gravity in there or anything that pinkie does normally, so when it showed she got magic that might have just been what she always uses. as for pinkie sense, i think she’s being honest about her not knowing how it works, it’s natural.


I mean, pinkie did seem pretty in control of that chaos magic, so it is very possible she had been dealing with it her whole life, or at least a very large portion of it, and it is raw chaos magic, so there is literally no predicting how it will react to different ponies.


To me the fact that Cozy Glow had Chaos Magic too is a definite dealbreaker on this theory.


As much as i love this theory, there's one problem.
Pinkie Sense.
I mean, sure, she can kinda predict future, but then... What about Maud Pie and Cheese Sandwich?
They have their senses too.
Cheese has a sense that lets him know where parties are going to happen and Maud... Okay, i'm not fully sure how her sense works, but she found the guy in that one episode, so yeah.
And it is possible that some earth ponies have that kind of magic with them, looking at the fact, that we saw only earth ponies have this kind of... Do i call it magic or sense? X3
If it is magic, that would explain why Pinkie "got her magic back" in that one scene and AJ didn't.
And one more.
Cheese Sandwich is practically, almost the same as Pinkie Pie, so how did he get... The way he is???
So i'm still gonna go with "It's Pinkie Pie, don't question it" ^^


very clever! I believe in theories, not its just the way it is. Nice!! this is my favorite of your theories!


What I want to know is why couldn't Cozy Glow or her friends absorb the alicorn magic in the bell? Tirek said that they couldn't use their magic until they learned how to handle Discord's magic inside the bell. Later on, however, Discord was able to take back his Chaos magic while leaving the alicorn sisters magic inside the bell. If they could have left Discord magic in the bell while only absorbing the alicorn magic, was plot convenience the only thing preventing them?

Also, why was Pinkie able to use the bell? We had a whole episode dedicated to the villains sneaking into the Canterlot archives to figure out how to use the bell, to begin with.


I think your theory is right. It would explain so much, and is like that last peice of a puzzle. It fits perfectly


I don’t like the time travel thing in this context. What happened to the timeline where Pinkie DIDN’T do all the crazy stuff she does? I think Discord may have <b>*ahem*</b> “bonded” with one of Pinkie’s ancestors, and the magic just skipped a couple thousand generations. It’d even be too many “great-“s to consider them related

I don’t like the time travel thing in this context. What happened to the timeline where Pinkie DIDN’T do all the crazy stuff she does? I think Discord may have **ahem** “bonded” with one of Pinkie’s ancestors, and the magic just skipped a couple thousand generations. It’d even be too many “great-“s to consider them related


I had a theory that all ponies have magic inherent to them, it's just that unicorns have a way of channelling it easily through their horns. It can be harder for pegusai and earth ponies to access their magic, but there is some evidence of them using magic, such as fluttershy inherently being able to understand any animal, rainbow dash being able to perform a sonic rainboom (with the rainbow element of that not really making sense without magic), the apple family with their higher than average strength (this is the weakest link I admit, but there is something to be said for earth ponies always being referred to as the best at growing and tending to plants, maybe their magic helps this), and pinkie pie with her.... everything. I feel like she is much more in tune with her magic than any other earth pony or pegasus, maybe even some unicorns, and this could be explained by the chaos magic theory! This is just an idea though! I feel like it fits a little better with the initial intent behind the show, since the beginning wasnt written with the end in mind!


sir, pinkie getting a thing of magic when it came back explains everything, period


I definitely believe in this theory ,especially because of the small hint where she gets her magic back as well


I love this theory but I don't think she is as powerful as discord or the power she absorbed took away from discord's. I would like to believe its just pinkie. She is the comedic but secretly deep and smart character.


TL;DR WARNING
Maybe it's because Cozy Glow was already a very gifted unicorn and was an Alicorn at the time of partaking of the chaos magic, so being a creature that was already familiar with magic and had princess level magical capabilities, the chaos just blinded her judgment and messed up her magic. Pinkie Pie, being an Earth Pony, only had enhanced strength from the magic in the atmosphere. Since she never had an affinity for any other form of basic magic, the chaos magic, being as powerful as it was, had a much more drastic effect on her. It probably exposed the 4th Wall to her and several (not all) of her alternate counterparts across  the multiverse at a very young age (like her human and comic book counterparts). It might have also allowed her to see past the 4th Wall and break it like Discord can on occasion. It probably also affected her physiology, giving her minor access to the fictional phenomenon that usually, only Looney Toons character are capable of; Toon Force, which is how she is able to summon multiple pony hooves around the screen and literally shatter herself after hours of repressed excitement. But these feats can be performed (as Roger Rabbit explains) " only when it's funny". I say "minor" because although she is capable of the aforementioned feats, she is definitely can't do anything akin to sawing the country in half or lassoing the moon (without assistance).

*TL;DR WARNING*
Maybe it's because Cozy Glow was already a very gifted unicorn *and* was an Alicorn at the time of partaking of the chaos magic, so being a creature that was already familiar with magic and had princess level magical capabilities, the chaos just blinded her judgment and messed up her magic. Pinkie Pie, being an Earth Pony, only had enhanced strength from the magic in the atmosphere. Since she never had an affinity for any other form of basic magic, the chaos magic, being as powerful as it was, had a much more drastic effect on her. It probably exposed the 4th Wall to her and several (not all) of her alternate counterparts across  the multiverse at a very young age (like her human and comic book counterparts). It might have also allowed her to see past the 4th Wall and break it like Discord can on occasion. It probably also affected her physiology, giving her minor access to the fictional phenomenon that usually, only Looney Toons character are capable of; Toon Force, which is how she is able to summon multiple pony hooves around the screen and literally shatter herself after hours of repressed excitement. But these feats can be performed (as Roger Rabbit explains) " *only* when it's funny". I say "minor" because although she is capable of the aforementioned feats, she is definitely can't do anything akin to sawing the country in half or lassoing the moon (without assistance).


This just makes me love Pinkie even more 💕💕


I sorta have a link on to this theory about the part about cozy glow and pinkie pie.
1. Pinkie had the magic of friendship while cozy did not accept the concept (well not entirely)
1. Pinkie may not be a fully grown pony but I’m pretty sure she was older than cozy glow and cozy is just a filly. So maybe being younger made here less powerful or something?


the flaw with this theory is that cheese sandwich has a cheesy sense, yet he hadn't ever gotten chaos magic, unless he got in an outbranching alternative timeline..


Pinky seems to actually be able to control chaos magic, where Cozy couldn't.


To be honest, your theory makes sense to me, but I doubt writters were thinking on that xD


I think that the reason Pinky's chaos magick when all through the timeline is because she actually used the magic and new what she could do and cozy glow to use the magic it was in her bloodline but it didn't stay in it because she didn't know how  to use it so maybe chaos magic intently takes one use of it to have it go through your entire bloodline and for it to stay that way


It's the creators of My Little Pony just wanting to have someone in the series who can break the forth wall. Oof. Most series have this sorta thing ya know?

Yes I am a very literate person


It seems like she would've gotten her abilities from that moment,<br>But it also may have been Rainbow Dash's Sonic Rainboom, All that rainbow energy, Pinkie MUST'VE had to get special abilities to earn her cutie mark and fufill her destiny!

It seems like she would've gotten her abilities from that moment,
But it also may have been Rainbow Dash's Sonic Rainboom, All that rainbow energy, Pinkie MUST'VE had to get special abilities to earn her cutie mark and fufill her destiny!


If it effects her entire lifespan, than each time she gets more chaotic than the last right? It is really hard to word it so it isn't confusing


Crazy part is when pinkie pie absorbed the magic she seem to be able to control it "no one can control discords magic"proving that pinkie pie is in some way different than the others


I do love pinky pie but I do think this theory which you just brought up is correct!<br>I do have a doubt of my own too it is like this: Everyone has to die in one movement of time and if that really happened then the mane 5 (not twilight ) would die and TIREK, CHRESOLES, and COZY GLOW would be set free even if the young 6 can handle it they never fought with them (except for the end) so Equestria will be doomed with no heroes to save !!!  If that really comes then what will happen???

I do love pinky pie but I do think this theory which you just brought up is correct!
I do have a doubt of my own too it is like this: Everyone has to die in one movement of time and if that really happened then the mane 5 (not twilight ) would die and TIREK, CHRESOLES, and COZY GLOW would be set free even if the young 6 can handle it they never fought with them (except for the end) so Equestria will be doomed with no heroes to save !!!  If that really comes then what will happen???


This man is the mat pat of the mlp fandom


I like this theory
It makes sense
LONG LIVE OUR PINK OVERLORD!


This is true, but in one of the early episodes, twilight actually gives pinkie an enhancing potion and pinkie says it, 'allowed me to see through space and time' SPACE AND TIME! So maybye, she managed to go into her future, not her past?


An explanation for why th chaos magic didn't effect cozy th same is probably simply because she's so young that it didn't hv far to go n her past wich actually might also explain why she's "evil" in that that was th effect of chaos magic on her past from that point but her future is far more vast especially since she is now trapped n stone so yeah if they do get released one day n future generation maybe we'll see that effect and that would b interesting


The whole future affecting the past concept is reminding me of Aot and honestly its so scary and confusing


I DID MU Research! according to many sights it says that the energy of the porson (in this case pony) that possesses the magic depends wether the magic is dark or for good <b>e.x pinky did not use the magic to hurt someone but cosyhooves did</b> so it may effect how long the magic last and some say it can even stay for  a lifetime. so yes, more than likely its bc discord.

I DID MU Research! according to many sights it says that the energy of the porson (in this case pony) that possesses the magic depends wether the magic is dark or for good *e.x pinky did not use the magic to hurt someone but cosyhooves did* so it may effect how long the magic last and some say it can even stay for  a lifetime. so yes, more than likely its bc discord.


When she got the magic she could control it and do whatever she wants but cozy glow couldn't.


"I may have just solved Pinkie Pie!" IMPOSSOBLE! Don't question her XD.


I love this dude.  You need to work for Hasbro!


Wait.... So has the cycle always been there or what happened when Pinkie first absorbed the magic.... Would the whole series be different?


I approve this as headcanon, your theory is possible. I mean how did she know how to control Discord's Power without experience.


2:11 I NEVER NOTICE IT BEFORE WHAAAAAAT(๑⊙д⊙๑)
You know, this makes sense🤔
Tbh, I didn't expect that someone can solve Pinkie Pie. Wow


Yeah your kind of wrong but doesn't explain the other world Pinky so here's what I think he's an interdimensional party God incarnated as Pinkie and yeah that would make a lot of sense because party gods are usually chaos users


I think that when she saw the rainbow,she got much more power,she got magic when she saw the rainbow,that must have been the reason her mane puffed up


Remember the episode pinkie, maud, and rarity went to manehatten? When maud was looking for the pony that had pinkies cannon, she found him instantly. Pinkie said it was maud sence, which runs in the family...


THIS IS THE BEST THEORY IVE EVER HEARD OMF

I've been watching ur channel since I was like twelve and now I'm almost an adult and was finally able to find ur channel again UGH SAME GOOD VIDEOS I LOVE U


Shouldn't Pinkie Pie be the one who is Princess? Because she brings happiness to everyone and she brings everyone together too. And makes Friendship also happened too.

(This is my opinion and a joke too.)


Meanwhile at My little pony HQ:Let's make some nonsense and let them make logic.


Pinkie: The only pers...uh pony who can take Discord's magic

2:32 ehh I don't think so Pinkie's just well...Pinkie and they don't plan for the last episodes on the ones in the series before...


haha im a big fan of mlp, but havent watched a mlp vid since 2013. you having me thinking about the show in 2020. good job :D nice video.


Honestly now you mention this i think it could be true , it makes sense!


Woah! So many spoilers! I guess I need to catch up with the story first.


In the comic, pinkie goes into the chaos dimension and becomes the ruler of chaos. They have to "defeat" her. Maybe she sent back some magic from there to when she was a filly


“ I might have just solved pinkie pie” me: IMPOSSIBLE!


It’s pinkie pie, even if she somehow has chaos powers from a certain event, how would you explain in past before her cutie pie?


i might be the only one to see it but something got my eye for one pinky has way more control over the magic than<br>cosy glow and she absorb more magic by the lightning cold mean she took more magic than she did

i might be the only one to see it but something got my eye for one pinky has way more control over the magic than
cosy glow and she absorb more magic by the lightning cold mean she took more magic than she did


If you watch the Equestria Girls (Bloopers Compared To Actual Scenes) It kind of explains what pinkie is a psychic.


Twiglight: I have the magic of friendship!

Pinkie pie: yo I can travel in time

Twiglight: I have the magic of friendship!

Pinkie pie: *yo I can travel in time*


I saw Pinkie get magic, but I just thought they all got magic back. 😌

Oof

Also, Cheese Sandwich has a Cheesy sense. Soooooo...


But what about Cheese sense and Maud sense? Pinkie says it runs in the family


Wait a second... I havent seen any episode where  PinkiePie Had Chaos Magic and i have watched all episodes 10 times


Congrats Sawtooth! You hit 300K! Pls make a 300K sub special


Tfw you come to a conclusion looooooooong before the quickest to jump the gun theorist

And still gain no cred for it


This theory dosent work i mean think about it. Maud says that she has a maud sense to and then pinkie pie said that it runs in the family, so unless maud also touched grogars bell then it wouldn't be possible for this to be true. Also human pinkie. She didn't touch the bell either.


"Is someone watching me?"

(148k people) : Uhhh...


I think that pinki was born with a tiny bice of chaos      and discord might have taken that away when he used grogars bell on pinki pie


there are three things you don't question in this world
1.the sky is blue
2.kingdom heart is life
3. and finally pinkie pie shall not be questioned


Hmmm idk cause if pinkie pie got all of discord’s magic from the bell then all the other times she could predict the future and break the fourth wall would happen after she got his powers but it all happened before so  at least that’s my theory but I also like your theory but I do have a question if pinkie got discord’s magic near the finale  only for a minute than  how was she able to break the fourth wall and predict the future in previous episodes?


it think  pinky  may have accidentally  infused her time line not knowing about magic as she is a earth pony and did not know the danger of effecting your own time line she was the one to dress up like Marty when twilight what to relive some she did not go to suggest she has a fascination with it   and cozy  know about magic would like not risk any thing that might mess with the time line


Maybe it’s because pinkie didn’t use it for the purpose to attack at her like cozy glow but in the purpose of bringing chaos instead.


Your theory couldn't have been right pinky got the magic after she got the magic back from cozy glow


Wait I thought you were brony notion! Now your sawtooth waves? Ok ok I get it


2:53 sawtooth  maud has pinkie/maud sense too!


Idk but for the cozy glow thing she already had alaicorn magic inside of her so maby she had enough magic inside of her that it controlled the chaos magic time wise through out her life  idk just a hunch like if u agree


<b>Wait. The Equestria Girls the time loop episode  if this theory is correct she could've predicted the future and the past without her acknowledging just like the part when Twilight Sparkle trying to confess she's from another world. I am confused.</b>

*Wait. The Equestria Girls the time loop episode  if this theory is correct she could've predicted the future and the past without her acknowledging just like the part when Twilight Sparkle trying to confess she's from another world. I am confused.*

<b>She could've known with her Pinkie sense.</b>

*She could've known with her Pinkie sense.*


Silly changy boy, pinkie pie is obviously a benevolent eldritch entity from across space and time that likes ponies!


I think her crazyness came with her cutie mark. Think about it went she had no cutie mark she was miserable but when it came she went crazy (⊙_◎) just like discord. And that progress along in the years. Also when balloons pop it makes them go crazy and not act like themselves. Helloo that is pinkie pie.


I’m sure you don’t need any but: here’s a video idea! What is starswirl the bearded’s cutie mark? He’s always hid it under his starry<br> blue cloak! Edit: never mind you can see it in an episode

I’m sure you don’t need any but: here’s a video idea! What is starswirl the bearded’s cutie mark? He’s always hid it under his starry
 blue cloak! Edit: never mind you can see it in an episode


Wait if you solved pinkie pie then what about cheese sandwich he is also like ps starlights cutie mark is sort of shaped like a kite just so you know


it doesn't apply to cheese sandwich who has cheesey sense


Pinkie is just a new creature
Not a changeling or a pony
Just.......

Keep going

💗Pinkie Pie💗

*Pinkie is just a new creature*
*Not a changeling or a pony*
*Just.......*

Keep going

💗Pinkie Pie💗


Pinkie pie got her powers from the giant rainbow.


:o pinkie pie is one of my favorite characters


Even though pinkie is a earth pony she still has magic

Well every earth pony does.<br>It's just a different kind of magic.

Well every earth pony does.
It's just a different kind of magic.


i think so the magic is her pinkie sense so she got that magic back


Punkte pie is wired right? Think about it, she think's different Team cozy glow


Maybe that didnt happen to cozy glow becuase she is evil.


pinkie pie and cozy glow use it discord magic.  Twilight sparkle: pinky you use it discord magic?


Who wants to know how does the human and pony pinkie pie know whats going on and the movie is equestria girls

They switched places


Sawtooth Wave, are you a fan , OF my little pony?


Cozy glow is not compatible with chaos magic but pinky is


Pinkie Pie isn’t a pony, she’s the only one of her kind, ‘Silly Pudding’


2:13ES LA MAGIA DE LA CUARTA PARED JAJAJAAJAJAJAJJA
XD

luciano craft z comics animatic studiosPerro


Maybe pinky = Celestia what if celestia  is useing a spell to see Through pinky ?


What about cheese sandwich he has the cheesy sense?


Pink and cosy glow a different so I had hair loss and alicon magic while cosy glow had only this discord magic


@sawtoothwaves I got a theory for you. About cadence and flurry heart just reply and I'll tell you.


Eh.....i don't think so <br>That happened near the ending yet pinkie had that shit the entire serie's 😂😂😂😉

Eh.....i don't think so
That happened near the ending yet pinkie had that shit the entire serie's 😂😂😂😉


Monika:Just Monika! <br>Pinkie:just pinkie!


I think that could be possibe and that could happen or it is just pinkie  being pinkie pie otherless we will find out and mabye future videoes your theorie could be correct


Wait why is pinkle pink while the rest of her family brown or gray.....?


Well pinkie pie have soem discord magic in side her that means discord and pinkie is now the same its true pinkie have magic bc of discord


Pinky pies. Is my friend’s  favorite pink and  can you make a video. If your a pony


She use to have horn I think so she is unicorn I think


Pinkie said mod sense it run through the family


pinkie pie is just a far cousin of discord

Time to throw you a bone, what if Pinkie is Discord's mother or something to that effect?


What about the Pinkie Pie in the human world??? And what about the Discord magic????? The thing about the discord thingy thing didnt showed up at at Season 1-5 tho...


Oh yeah, the video was from naseema been.  Check that out


I have seen half of the vidio so i think...PINKEY IS DISCORDS SISTER DON DON DON🤣🤣


Umm..  Naseema something something name made a video for you in which nightmare moon was visible in twilight's old house. Do see that video


When the elements of harmony were destroyed she still had laughter in her


pinkie pie is just...pinke pie. she's different. and that's that.


Just don’t watch cupcake with pinkingpie


Ofcours someone  is watching  you sawtooth like dont you want  views


Only way that would be possible is prob that pinky pie is discord’s daughter


Pinky wouldn't have even taken the magic if this didn't take the magic before she took the magic, Your also saying she didn't get her cutie mark until she took the magic, Your saying equestria was taken over by night mare moon and all the other villans cause pinkie moved to pony ville to use her talents for better than distracting her family, all I'm saying is this doesn't make sense, just my very long opinion I hope this did not make you feel bad if it did I am very sorry.


aishlyn ʕ⁎̯͡⁎ʔ༄


She is a new creature that they have not put in the show she is a changing a new one. What if she is a changing that take happiness instead, take love or giving love. No steal my thinking pls


Bruh he said "IS SOMEONE QATCHING ME!?!??!"lol im watching u ur a youtuber ;-;


Do you think spike lothers sunset shimmer


Umm no hate. But it's a vid soo we r watching 😑


Haven't started the video yet, but I'm gonna say it's gotta be chaos magic. How else could she have not only handled Discord's chaos magic in the finale, but also was able to use it to create chocolate rain? It's because she DOES know how to control some of it, because she already does use chaos magic to some degree.

3:48 Okay, so it was definitely related, but it's definitely different. My theory implies that pinkie was always able to use chaos magic by sheer chance(or genetic mutation?), rather than by her gaining all this chaos magic. Anyways, here's my theory in full.

The reason why pinkie acts the way she does is because she already has chaos magic. It wasn't given to her by some future event, it was always with her, even since birth. How does the pinkie getting chaos magic event tie into this? Well, it's because of Cozy Glow. When Cozy Glow got Discord's chaos magic, she tried hard to control it. But, chaos magic, by it's nature, is impossible to control unless you have experience. I'm pretty sure Discord said this, or that it was said at some point, but I can't remember when. Anyways, the takeaway from that is that *chaos magic is impossible to control unless you have experience in using it*. So, why is it that Pinkie is able to create a very specific thing(chocolate rain) when she has chaos magic? The reason for this is simple, it's because she already has had experience using chaos magic, and is hence able to control it now.

As for the Pinkie sense? Well, that's one problem with this. No, the problem isn't that chaos magic can't allow for predicting the future, it's that we don't know for sure if it can. I don't remember seeing Discord use chaos magic to predict the future ever, or anyone using magic for the matter, so I can't know for sure. If someone can point out an instance where any type of magic has predicted the future(even if it was unsuccessful), then that would make pinkie sense being powered by chaos magic a possibility.

Haven't started the video yet, but I'm gonna say it's gotta be chaos magic. How else could she have not only handled Discord's chaos magic in the finale, but also was able to use it to create chocolate rain? It's because she DOES know how to control some of it, because she already does use chaos magic to some degree.

3:48 Okay, so it was definitely related, but it's definitely different. My theory implies that pinkie was always able to use chaos magic by sheer chance(or genetic mutation?), rather than by her gaining all this chaos magic. Anyways, here's my theory in full.

The reason why pinkie acts the way she does is because she already has chaos magic. It wasn't given to her by some future event, it was always with her, even since birth. How does the pinkie getting chaos magic event tie into this? Well, it's because of Cozy Glow. When Cozy Glow got Discord's chaos magic, she tried hard to control it. But, chaos magic, by it's nature, is impossible to control unless you have experience. I'm pretty sure Discord said this, or that it was said at some point, but I can't remember when. Anyways, the takeaway from that is that *chaos magic is impossible to control unless you have experience in using it*. So, why is it that Pinkie is able to create a very specific thing(chocolate rain) when she has chaos magic? The reason for this is simple, it's because she already has had experience using chaos magic, and is hence able to control it now.

As for the Pinkie sense? Well, that's one problem with this. No, the problem isn't that chaos magic can't allow for predicting the future, it's that we don't know for sure if it can. I don't remember seeing Discord use chaos magic to predict the future ever, or anyone using magic for the matter, so I can't know for sure. If someone can point out an instance where *any* type of magic has predicted the future(even if it was unsuccessful), then that would make pinkie sense being powered by chaos magic a possibility.


Okay so, I have another theory. The Young 6 all do represent the elements of harmony. If you look at the last episode where at the end when they sang the song magic of friendship and at the end showed all Characters that resembles too the mane 6 chacters. So SilverStream represents the element of laughter, this actually makes total sense because In a lot the episodes You can see, how she  wants everyone to be happy and always makes everyone laughs, just like pinky. Yona represent honesty, she is always honest with he group and in ever episode we have seen in her, she always never afraid to speak the truth. Smolder represents loyalty, the way she’s loyal within In the group and in most of the episodes when some one gets in trouble, she’s the first one to Volunteer to pay the same price as them, and just go back to the episodes and you can see her loyalty. Sandbar represents kindness, I’m School Daze he was the one, the only pony In the school you really wanted to be with the other creatures, and also just go back to all the other episodes he acts literally just like flutter shy. Ocellus represents Generosity, I’m one episode you can see her giving her friends notes 📝 for the hw, and always helping them study and etc, u can see in the episodes how she resembles rarity. Well, the last one I don’t have a clue, the last one points to Gallous idk how he represents magic, but he’s some one resemblance to Twilight. Please give to a like so He can see it! Edit: In School Daze II, you can see sandbar is glowing in Fluttershy color, Smolder Rainbowdash color, Yona Apple Jacks color, Siverstream as pinky color, Ocelous as Rarity color, Galleous as twilight color! :)


Interesting theory.  I've always assumed, as it has been proven that all ponies have some magic in them, that some just have more magic in them than others.  The Mane Six in general are freaks of nature, and Pinkie is just an example of an earth pony mare with exceptional magic levels.   Really exceptional levels in Pinkie's case, which does seem to run in the Pie family to an extent.  I could be mistaken though.


I always had the theory that someone has to be chaotic in some way to harness Chaos Magic without stealing it from someone else. Discord is physically chaotic, I mean just look at the guy. However, I believe Chaos Magic can be harnessed by someone who's MENTALLY chaotic, or rather, insane in some way. People who are mentally unwell tend to appear detached from the real world. It wouldn't be too much of a stretch that the wandering sanity of a broken mind can find itself in places beyond reality, and possibly tapping into a power that is truly impossible to understand, just like it's impossible for us to truly understand Pinkie Pie.


I wanna know a moment where Pinkie finds out about her magic secrets

Like pulling things out of thin air and stuff, that would be awesome


It could be that Pinkie Pie, already being pretty chaotic in personality, was simply more attuned to the chaos magic than Cozy Glow. Perhaps she truly became one with chaos for that moment, whereas Cozy Glow just had strange power within her for a moment. That closer connection that Pinkie Pie establishes could be what causes the magic to leave lasting effects throughout her timeline as you suggest.


This is a great theory and all, but then how would you explain Maud sense when they go to Manehattan?Pinkie Pie says it runs in the family so I would like to assume that maybe a little chaos spread to the first people she spent the most time with.But that doesn’t really make sense, because that’s the only other chaotic thing about her family and Maud in general. You could count there weird obsessions with rocks, but I feel like that was there before Pinkie.


well chaos magic interacted with two different beings, pinkie has chaotic good intentions, while cozy glow had evil intentions, the magic then reflected that on the outside, while still both crazy, they had much different personalities and intentions. , just a thought


it does make sense because in a way she had an even more understanding of how to use it. With Cozy Glow, all she saw and used (well wanted too) it for was power. but Pinkie being the way she is and the fact that she was friends with Discord had understanding on how to just "go with the flow" to use his magic. This could have cause the Magic of Chaos to... Merge with Pinkie's spirit, effecting it through out all time<br>but hey that's..... JUST A THEORY... A PONY THEORY...... ok im done imitating TGT xD

it does make sense because in a way she had an even more understanding of how to use it. With Cozy Glow, all she saw and used (well wanted too) it for was power. but Pinkie being the way she is and the fact that she was friends with Discord had understanding on how to just "go with the flow" to use his magic. This could have cause the Magic of Chaos to... Merge with Pinkie's spirit, effecting it through out all time
but hey that's..... JUST A THEORY... A PONY THEORY...... ok im done imitating TGT xD


Ive watching your channel for some time (I like theory channels) but one thing that has never been explained in MLP is how can spike send messages to Celestia's  and back no other creature seems to have this ability. Did Spike inheritance some twilight magic to so he do this?


I actually figured this out. The elements were found in the tree of harmany. The geods are found in a cave in camp everfree. Even the tree is in a small cave beneath the catsle. What im trying to say is that the geods are the elements of HARMANY.


I think more then likely pinkie got her powers from when twilight was a child and the rainboom unleashed her powers and it traveled with the rainboom to pinkie first and gave her some strange connection to twilight magic.

It fits the order and we see pinkie get hit with the rainboom aftershock full on.

You have to take into account that the writers would not of thought this far ahead to the end they came too so the end with pinkie getting that power was just a throw away thing and has nothing to do with her powers.


You cant say that pinky sense is related to this because in an episode there was a line that said.

Rarity: “ How did you know where he was? “

Maud: “ Maud-sense. “

So that is not proof

(No hate love your theories)


The staring off into space thing, it’s not them watching you.
It’s called “fourth-wall awareness.”
It’s a power few yw characters have


I JUST thought of something about this video that wasn't explained.....
if Pinkie got her Pinkie Sense while she held Discord's Chaos Magic..... what about Cheese Sandwich and how did he get his Cheesy Sense?
And to expand upon that, we know they have a foal together. Does Little Cheese inherit mom's Pinky Sense, or dad's Cheesy Sense?
or will she inherit both, having an ultimate Cheesy-Pinkie Sense?!


Think of it this way; a being's mental state can alter the potency of chaos magic like when discord tried to throw a tea party for fluttershy and made himself too "normal" therefore diminishing his powers and existence. Pinkie's mental state is a constant wild party, and though the theory of pinkie getting chaos magic at that one moment seems to be a paradox as without it to begin with she would have been extremely different and probably would have never been there to attain said magic but chaos magic is just that; chaotic; anything and/or everything impossible and/or paradoxical can and/or will become possible possibly, maybe, it's a possibility and at the same time not


This could make sense but she could just have a stronger connection to magic than most earth ponies do. All ponies have magic to an extent, they all have cutie marks. Unicorns and Alicorns have the strongest connection to magic by default but that doesn't mean other ponies or creatures for that matter, can't tap into it or even use it to the same extent or greater if they went far enough. That might be taboo in Equestria or just very hard to achieve though so very few go for it. I think of Equestrian magic as kind of like the speed force from The Flash and The Force from StarWars. Its there, however difficult it might be to do so it can be manipulated for better or worse, it can be given to someone, it can be taken away, it's just drawn to some individuals and some are drawn to it, it can probably be killed, and it can probably be manufactured. Some individuals can just tap into it more than most can or even bother to. It's flowing through their world like air. Its everywhere. Someone is bound to be able to use it.

Ꮪꭵꮮꮙꭼꭱ Ᏸꭹꭲꭼꮓ


I have said it before and I'll say it again. Pinkie is the most powerful being in Equestria. Here's a new way to look at it. Her 4th wall breaking means she is in touch with the dimension of her universe's creators. That would put her in the category of angel/demon in our world. Crazy...


Okay. I'll try too fit as much of this as I can into this comment so bear with me. Here is my extended version of that theory.

Yes. Pinkie was infused with chaos magic through her timeline, but how does chaos magic work? I think it's tied to emotions. Discord does what he wants, when he wants until he makes friends! Pinkie herself could barely control it before discord took it back, and cozy couldn't at all with the emotional Turmoil of being a villain. That being said, pinkie was affected directly, but the ponies she cared about were also indirectly affected. I got this from the cheese sense and Maud sense left unexplained. Ponies have pickaxes. They dont normally drill through solid rock with their hooves or EAT THEM. But discord eats whatever. From paper to phones. And Maud being seemingly her closest sister, showing up a lot more and bsff stuff got the Maud sense. Cheese sandwich later determined pinkies canon romantic partner also has a special bond with her affecting him In a similar way. Heck he even opens a gag factory! And after being stuck being bored, loses his laugh like discord was fading when he invited fluttershy over to his house. This happens to pinkie too, in party of one, and with her yak instrument that I can't spell! Cheese and pinkie had bonds but Maud only had boulder until mudbriar so she turned out different chaotic? The mane 6 could also have been affected, but their direct connection to the tree of harmony allowed them to control it better, like how discord's vine seeds wouldn't grow right away. But fluttershy having the close bond with discord gave her a little more power, where her stare came from, that can out stare cockatrices!!!


In the same episode where Pinkie Pie gets "her magic" her food rots and twlight says that it's because there's no magic protecting it but none of the cakes have magic so either it's Pinkie or a different Unicorn or maybe a spell done by Celestia


pinkie has VERY chaotic nature, maybe, because of that, when pinkie drowned discords magic, chaotic magic matched on pinkie's nature... and this explains why she could (somehow) control discords magic but cozy couldn't


I like your theory and events in the future affecting the past is actually not beyond the laws of physics in thus world even if when dont have that massive example like pinkie pie.

But if the magic itself is not bound to time then I could see this. Some holes in the theory though. Wouldn't discord still have some level of magic after it was absorbed if it floods the time line of the soul getting it? Even if it was just small things like pinkie does. Though i can also explain this away with discord being a creature of chaos that NEEDS chaos to exist. Proven in the episode where he forces himself to be normal so my thinking is the chaos that keeps him alive is all that's left but pinkie is a pony and never needed chaos magic. Since it flooded her timeline later in her life the chaos magic in her I guess you would say life force had the ability to spread out in both directions. This gave pinkie pie time to learn to use the chaos magic. Those abilities you were showing. And while she STILL would not have been able to control ALL of it she had enough of a handle on it to control it a bit when she was flooded with the magic since her only real time travel was a sense that this or that was going to happen. Meanwhile, cozy glow being a younger pony had mostly only one direction in her life force to travel. To her future. She didn't get the training time with it that pinkie did. But that's just a theory!


So in other words Pinky Pie created a temporal causality loop for herself? that's actually pretty epic.


The word you're looking for is "retrocausality": future events causing past events.
One possible way for the world to have retrocausality is for it to have a "blocky" time.
Basically, it's an alternative view of time. The future and past exists as surely as the present, and for the future to influence the past is as natural as the past influencing the future. It's as if the past and the future are the left and right sides of a giant mural. There is an internal logic to the mural: it's not random. This internal logic constrains the left side and the right side to not break away from each other's influence. In the same way, the past and the future are bound by a logic beyond time, and the future can constrain the past just like the past constrains the future..


Cozy Glow wanted the magic to be put back in the bell Pinkie did not so maybe for that split second she spread that magic through her timeline willingly.


Maybe the Cosy Glow theory is that the chaos magic can tell if you are going to use it for good or evil. If it could, it would only change pinkie's past because she wasn't going to be evil with her rare power.


i haven't been to this channel in so long, i forget why i stopped watching the videos! there amazing, keep being great


Hey sawtooth, what would happen if equestria had to deal with every villain they ever had at once. yknow like they all come back at the same time and joined forces against equestria. Just curious to know.


Sawtooth,I have a theory. In Season 2 Episode 2 or 1 Screwball makes an appearance. Does that mean she’s considered canon?


After a week of thinking about this video I have finally figured it out so what I think is pinkie pie and other earth pony’s like cheese sandwich have a special kind of magic passes through there family like when we found out Maud has Maud sense she’s pinkies sister after all anyway, this magic givers her a special pinkie sense and allows her to teleport define the laws of physics and other things she has done that is completely separate from discord’s chaos magic so far the only pony’s with these abilities are earth pony’s you said in a video a long time ago all pony’s are born with magic maybe so earth pony’s are born with those magical abilities this is why pinkie pie gets a pink dot through her that’s her pinkie sense so please read this 👍🥳 and take it into consideration 👍👍


YOU CAN’T SOLVE PINKY PIE NO MATTER HOW HARD YOU TRY!


What mystery? Everypony knows she’s made of giggles and gumdrops
Oven mitts and out-takes
Doodles and donuts
Fairytales and fruitcake
Chaos and cupcakes
Lots and lots of batter
Sugar and sunshine
Lollipops and laughter. 😄

Yeah, she’s my favorite mystery 😉


HEY! What's up! I'm your biggest fan, and I know this has no relation to Pinkie, but I think that Rainbow Dash DOES deserve her element. I mean, yeah sure she hasn't been TOO loyal from the beginning of the series, but that's the thing about my theory. I think that she has been Building Up her loyalty. You know like character development, and that stuff. So I hope you read my comment on that theory of yours, and maybe change your mind about that. I find Rainbow very interesting.... WITHOUT THE EGO OF COURSE! I can give you some more theories to think about because I'm a big fan of MLP. Bye!


You just had to include stuff from "FPK". I really hated that episode. Seeing my favorite character get punished to no end really wasn't all that funny to me. Sure it was supposed to be a throwback to classic "Looney Toons" slapstick but doesn't it really only work if a character is unlikable enough to deserve it? Opinion: Twilight was just trying to observe Pinkie Pie's behavior.


Before watching the video I  thought that it was because she ALWAYS possessed some Chaos Magic.
After watching: Yeah.

Before watching the video I  thought that it was because she ALWAYS possessed *some* Chaos Magic.
After watching: Yeah.


3:31 well yeah, cozy glow was an alicorn at the time, Pinky, though, was an earth pony.


I’m not saying your wrong. Because you stand a pretty good point my friend,<br>But I bet it’s just 70% Discord’s magic and 30% of Pinkie just being Pinkie 😋

I’m not saying your wrong. Because you stand a pretty good point my friend,
But I bet it’s just 70% Discord’s magic and 30% of Pinkie just being Pinkie 😋


just my opinion on why the magic had a more permanent state with pinky and not cozy glow is because cozy glow was trying to use the magic in a structured way and not chaotically like the magic is intended where as for pink when she used the magic she en-braised the chaos and didn't try to put any rules or structure to it there for the magic ended up staying with her because it felt like it belonged there in a way sorry if this doesn't make sense just what i was thinking of why it effected them in different ways


I do believe she can tap into chaos magic I just don't think it's from that event because cheese sandwich while only in 1 episode could also do stuff that defies logic what if all party ponys can use chaos magic


I think the only person to rival Pinkie Pie or even be close to being her, is a character name Jyushimatsu-san from the anime Osomatsu-san. If you watch the anime which is a literal comedy and anything random can happen. The character Jyushimatsu-san can literally do anything with a smile on his face!


Who knew BIG lore was in a show for any age


0:10 you should watch the video titled Eqestria Girls (bloopers compared to actual scenes) and whenever you see the one involving pinkie pie where she holds the purple lollipop you’ll understand it all well for the Otherworld knowledge part


Pinkie Pie is a Toon. A fourth waller. A super sane. No, it isn't a typo. Super sane. Smarter than your average character to the point of knowing they are fictional. That's it.


So... How'd she get the magic from the bell? She's an Earth Pony!


She didn’t have her powers when she was born, but later on she had them when she was born.


I think the reason Pinky Pie was affected and Cosy wasn’t is because Cosy wanted to dominate, while Pinky wanted it so she can be with it, one wanted control, the other just wanted it for fun


well one thing is it seems other pies have their own senses, but i do like this idea.


Chaos magic DOESN'T operate under string theory!


Where do the Kirin's come in? They have an episode but how did they come to be? Who are the Kirin's? What are the Kirin's and why can they be lit on fire? I have many questions but they may be answered by the series I haven't finished it


This the best theory ever makes so much sense


so Cozy was turned into an allicorn so maybe instead of pinkie becoming an allicorn, the chaos spread throughout her life


i want to say a theory about mlp so when sombra broke  the elements its magic escaped to sunsets world so i think  thats  how the magic  hit that cave in the everfree forest and that solves question sunset said that "where did the magic came that hit this  cave ;


Not relating to this video but I was rewatching the finale of the show and i noticed when you see flurry hearts glass window a few frames before you see sweetie bell and some yellow I imagine the yellow would be apple bloom and off screen would be scootaloo what did the quite mark crusaders do to earn a stained glass window. Out of context in this in the same episode when twilight is reading they news paper you see (I think)
Lyra and bonbon getting married
THEY ArE MARRIED
And 8 think doctor hooves has a wife during the coronation idk

If you see this dont show my name thankyou


BUTT if that one moment of chaos affected pinkies entire life what about cheese sandwich? He  can do the exact same as pinkie including pulling things out of thin air so why are they so simular?


wait but it may affected Cozy glow because we dont really go fully in depth with her past or at least not what i remember so she might have had the same affects and as the show went on pinkie was still crazy so if Cozy glow didnt get turned to stone then we may of seen the chaos unfold i her


can you plz tell me why in the world most unicorns shoot fireworks? Like tempest shadow? or trixie? like come on! why can't they do something else?


Grunkle Stan while watching this video: I think I need more coffee for farther coffee spits!


I just realised in the song ( the magic of friendship grows ) when twilight made a rainbow with the horn every single teacher had 1 of the student 6 so maybe thats their element??


That means that Pinkie Dayamana Pie is still out there waiting for her chance to replace PP here and I think that when Pinkie got her Cuite Mark her evil twin came out of her and I think she will definitely come in Pony Life that is the new Sieris that Hasbro will release soon


I never noticed taht pinkie got thay lil' pink ball thing. I think you're right. I mean she does have pinkie sense but she said it only interacts with instint things. like a falling flower pot.


Sawtooth Waves: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!!!!! me: yes

Me now when I'm typing this: XD


I have little thing to say. It might help. But the magic what came to Pinkies nose wasnt maybe some special sort of magic just the pinkie sense come back. The thing that she have experiences from another dimension is showed in equestria girls shorts where Pinkies from both world just go through portal. They even saw themself. Than we know that Pinkie have a lot of things hiden through ponyville( if someone know that she pulled something out of nowhere and she wasnt in ponyville just say it).  The braking of 4 wall well i havent for explained that yet.

Oh wait i have it ,maybe the pinkie sense and braking 4 wall really came from discord magic. We know that when she was only a filly she was same as her sisters but thanks to the rainboom she sawed that day die felt happy and that everyone should fell this happines its impossible that she got her sense and abylity to break 4 wall just from seeing big rainbow.


Sawtooth: is someone watching me? me: yeah, us


i don't know about the pinkie sense part but i have a theory about the part of  how cozy glow did not get the magic as well so i think it matter is how the pony uses the magic cozy glow used it for evil evil and sense discord does not use his magic for evil anymore (well i think) and pinkie used it  for chaos like it was meant to be used so it stuck longer with pinkie pie but that's my theory

woooooow i ffeel <b>Big brain</b>  (not) ;-;


Something tells me that I have my eye on Pinkie Pie


I think the student six have a combination of the pillars element and the mane six maybe


I have a theroy about the episode pinkie apple pie. When the part about pies and apple being related was sumged, I think it might have ment pear scince they are related kinda, even though they are related from apple Jack's parents not apple sauce applejacks great great granny. I hope you use this theroy in one of your videos, or at least read it and consider using it in one of your videos, thank you.


it's both just her craziness got amplified


But what about Maud sense? Pinkie did say it "runs in the family."


Here’s a question about Princess Luna. WHY does her hair NOT flow when she is reformed back from being Nightmare moon in season one?

@Naila Nigar also not to mention she was young what do you expect she didn't hit puberty until season 2 which is kind of strange

Because her magic was too weak.  Princess Celestia is really strong, you see, and futuristic Twilight, too.  They are already used to their      powers, and their at it's peak.  Luna wasn't yet used to her magic yet.


Sawtooth:Is someone watching me ?<br>Me:Ya it’s your job

Sawtooth:Is someone watching me ?
Me:Ya it’s your job


i think that magic was something to do with her laughter maybe


You will never solve Pinkie pie
Never I tell you
NEVER


We won't know until we see how Pinkie's child acts


Sawtooth: Is someone watching _me_?<br>Viewers: No- well yes.

Sawtooth: Is someone watching _me_?
Viewers: No- well yes.


Wait, but didn’t pinkie say that her six sense runs in the family?


Could you plaese do a video about what happens if two different ponytyps get children,for example an earthe pony and a pegasus?😁🧡


Ok i get what hes trying to say, but when he said "thats why she can Break All the fission" Im Like wait didnt she take all his magic On the VERY last Ep?!

Also ppl Take these way to sirously! xD Its A Kids Show ment for kids xD

that's never an excuse and i'm a kid and i do it i don't care

ok you got it?


Twilight after watching this: pinkie com here I need to monitor you.<br>Pinkie: twilight I don’t think that is nessesery you know I was (says what you said in 1 sentence)

Twilight after watching this: pinkie com here I need to monitor you.
Pinkie: twilight I don’t think that is nessesery you know I was (says what you said in 1 sentence)


I think Pinkie is simply just Pinkie<br>and Pinkie doesn't care about cartoon rules

I think Pinkie is simply just Pinkie
and Pinkie doesn't care about cartoon rules


Doesss he know that pinkie and discord is just breaking the 4rth wall?


i think differently becauce maud has the same pinky sense maud sense so it was not chaos magic<br>but something else entirely

i think differently becauce maud has the same pinky sense maud sense so it was not chaos magic
but something else entirely


Pinkie:hi I'm insane and funny also chaotic

Me: STEALS PINKIE FROM HER PLANET AND BRINGS HER TO MINE Now pinkie

Solve world hunger

Pinkie:hi I'm insane and funny also chaotic

Me: *STEALS PINKIE FROM HER PLANET AND BRINGS HER TO MINE* Now pinkie

Solve world hunger


Gonna tell my kids this is the story of jesus


Okay just hear me out how cadence became an alicorn but more canon because canon what if she got here wings or horn or both st the same time she got her cutie mark for spreading love between others or CREATING  romantic love between others because she is the princess of romantic and motherly love and we know she wasn’t a mother or had fallen in love with shining armor at the time she had met twilight unless shining armor and her dated secretly for a few years before even meeting but it seems a little off so I’m gonna assume that they started dating afterwards also I feel like twilight velvet I Bilieve that’s her name also could have gotten an opportunity to become the princess of motherly ness maybe she reaches it to twilight to reconnect more after spending so long away from eachother with all the princess stuff and cadence could be the princess of love for all because she shows a lot of love to her subjects more than she does for shining armor even tho there  love if definitely strong I donno I’d have to plan it out more and not just ramble like this but I have no clue what this was originally about


Ok not really a brony anymore, but that was kinda cool !


She's Pinkie Pie the party-planning pony no explanation needed we all know Pinkie Pie will forever remain a mystery and how she do it on stuff you do

No we have to start figuring this out it's our destiny