I love this as a theory for how she gained her strange magic, but it seems like other party ponies like Cheese Sandwich and Party Favor are also capable for similar/the same things as Pinkie, and I’m not sure chaos magic makes a suitable explanation for them & other party ponies 😅

how about running it in revers, she could manage the magic because it was within her element to wield this magic.  she has after all proven that time and time again.<br>Pinkieis not an alicorn, because she is more than an Alicorn.  she can wield 2 magics even a great Alicorn can not.  Aside from earth, Pegasus and Unicorn magic, she has Chaos and Changeling too.

how about running it in revers, she could manage the magic because it was within her element to wield this magic.  she has after all proven that time and time again.
Pinkieis not an alicorn, because she is more than an Alicorn.  she can wield 2 magics even a great Alicorn can not.  Aside from earth, Pegasus and Unicorn magic, she has Chaos and Changeling too.

Or maybe the chaos magic just enhances her pinky pie-ness maybe

Yeah and if it was Pinkie Pie's family thing, there's still Sandwich and Party Flavor. (looking at the fact, that Maud also has some kind od sense)<br>And if it is some kind of earth ponies magic, that only some of them got, that would explain the return of Pinkie's magic in that one scene with Cozy Glow.

Yeah and if it was Pinkie Pie's family thing, there's still Sandwich and Party Flavor. (looking at the fact, that Maud also has some kind od sense)
And if it is some kind of earth ponies magic, that only some of them got, that would explain the return of Pinkie's magic in that one scene with Cozy Glow.


You said whole timeline, would that mean her twin could possibly have powers as well?


Talking something not really related, at the part where they got their magic back, how come they were still friends? The mane six's friendship is magic (The whole point of the show) surely, that magic was taken by cozie glow's spell. That was the whole point of why she did the spell. She would need the MAGIC of friendship if she wanted to be the EMPRESS of friendship


"Well, this is quite the combination of secondary characters."<br>-Discord

"Well, this is quite the combination of secondary characters."
-Discord


Cozy glow had absorbed discords magic but got it taken away from her, in such a short time and pinkie pie had it for a longer period. That might be why.


I know I'm not the only one who notice this

She is the only pink in her family

@Khitara Aldilla ok. good we got that sorted :)

@Khitara Aldilla really? Huh, I guess. But my comment still stands. Just bc one pony doesn't have it, doesn't mean multiple ponies don't have the same name

@Khitara Aldilla that’s exactly what I said 😑 MY WHOLE COMMENT WAS ABOUT HOW ONLY THE <i>PIES</i> HAVE THE SAME LAST NAME

@Khitara Aldilla that’s exactly what I said 😑 MY WHOLE COMMENT WAS ABOUT HOW ONLY THE _PIES_ HAVE THE SAME LAST NAME

@Ramilda Marble Pie
Limestone Pie
Pinkie pie
 Igneous Rock Pie
Cloudy Quartz
Maudileena Daisy Pie

@Khitara Aldilla I’m not talking about ponies with last names. I’m talking about a whole family having the <i>same</i> last name.

@Khitara Aldilla I’m not talking about ponies with last names. I’m talking about a whole family having the _same_ last name.

@Khitara Aldilla my reply was literally about the pie family. also give me actual ponies w the same last name who aren't the pies then

@Ramilda ok u need to watch the episodes again also i forgot to put the pie family

@Khitara Aldilla wdym, the whole family doesn’t have the same last name

@Ramilda shy? Sparkle? Dash? Apple!?

What are those!?

What if one of pinkies parents cheated on the other and had pinkie

Lovieca her family doesn’t seem like the lying type tho. Very very straight forward and dead (in a way)

About that adopted theory, i don't think it would work, because Pinkie is a twin at least, looking at her comment in the episode, where families spend "Hearts and Hooves Day" together (i'm terrible at remembering episodes names qwq)
"few seconds younger sister".
I mean, there is a possibility that their parents made it up, but i don't think so ;^;

Also, the fact that grandparents are more related to their grandchildren can be confirmed in MLP if you look at Granny Smith and Apple Bloom’s eye color and that neither Apple Bloom’s parents, nor her siblings have the same eye color.

Diego Productions oh, i didn’t know that. Thanks for telling and subscribing

I think she adopted, or got from a grandparent

@Shivi Srivastava A pilot is the first episode for a TV show most of the time. sometimes it's before the 1st episode. The guy you're replying to is talking about the first episode

@Shivi Srivastava wow that is so cool. I can't believe you're 11 but.... what's the point of saying you are. If I were you kid, I would keep that away from people. People are jerks and assume a lot of things from your age. They have a narrow perception of what different ages are like, (especially for children,) so when the age of someone is revealed online, people stop taking them seriously if they're a child.

That's where the theory that she got pink cuz she used to be somepony who died and Steven Universe brought her back with his tears

I have actually now written a whole speech on these possibilities and will probably upload my first video in my channel about this

@DUCKS IS FLOOFY i don’t know what ‘the pilot’ is but i just randomly thought of this and told it to you guys

Idk if this is correct or not but an article on google said " the name Pinkamena means "Lively, the life of the party. It also means pink and the name Pinkamena means "Insane" because Pinkamena Diane Pie is her full name!! Still dosen't explain way she's pink tho

In her song from the pilot didn't she mention an aunt with pink in her name too?

Also, i just did some calculations if this could happen and turns out, children of any species are more related to their grandparents. This could also probably be shown in Lil’ Cheese, pinkie’s daughter. Her skin colour is a light version of pinkie’s father, but it is also the light version of cheese sandwich. So i conclude that in MLP, fillies aren’t more related to their grandparents...

Or are they? It could be possible that one of pinkie’s grandparents coat was pink. But then it clashed with their partner’s colour which made it greyish. Now this could be either her maternal grandparents who made her mother’s coat grey or paternal parents and it came out in pinkie’s father’s hair. But maybe that pink was still passed on and it came out in pinkie.

Phew! Even as a kid, i wrote a long essay about pinkie

@Hey Eaglet thnx. This was just my guess, it just came into my head. BTW I’m 11 yrs old

@Shivi Srivastava ill believe in your headcanon lol

True that is destiny and is your real surname Dupain-cheng

@•StormysideUP• dragontrainer something i think

My theory is that Pinkie was born with a genetic abnormality because of which she is the black sheep of her family. Since she was so different and her family normally named her sisters after rocks and Pinkie’s colour combination was in no way related to rocks, her parents didn’t know what to call her and just named her after her skin and mane colour.

@Myrrh Park Unless they can see the future that doesn't work. Ponies aren't born with Cutie Marks, remember

In a fan fic called muffins, it says that pinkie got the pink gene, making her pink. This however makes a bit to much sence for mlp. Thinking back to prevouis Sawtooth wave viedos, he thought that maybe Celestia named all the ponies. I find this unlikly, because there are proably millions of ponies and she named every single one? I think that that parents get a peek at their childs cutie mark, and then they get to name them off that. They don't need to base off that, like putunia. Her cutie mark is bones. Putenias and bone? The parents choose putenia. If this is also the case, then this would also explain why the parents thought she was going to be a pirate. Bone, Pirate. That works. Perhaps Pinkie's parents saw her balloons on her pink flank and called her Pinkie. But that doesn't explain why she's pink.

Once again the chaos magic doing its work

Once again the chaos magic doing its work

Fun fact: The Pies are the only family with the same last name


Ok I have a theory: What If PinkiePie is an alicorn?

Now just hear me out, sawtooth stated that to become an alicorn you need magic from all three tribes, and they described most of the princesses getting their alicorn magic from the fact that they hold a great amount of respect and appreciation to ponies of all of the tribes. But doesn’t pinkie pie do the same? She should have appreciation from all three tribes for what she does and how she makes/tries to make everypony happy? If that’s the case when she also have magic from the three tribes? If that’s the case it could explain how come she got to keep some of the chaos magic and cozy didn’t.


But Pinkie kept her "chaos" in Tartarus, when she convinced Tirek to give Twillight his rest of magic.


i think his right when cozy absorb discord magic it was just discord magic but when pinkie absorb it was combine with alicorn magic, tirek magic, queen crisalist, and there other magic that was in the bell but thats just my theory


Wait I have a theory on how Pinkie Pie got her weird magic. One word Rainboom. Think about it. When Twilight was given magic from Celestia, Luna, and Cadence, their cutie mark vanished. If cutie marks are linked to one’s magic, would it be possible that the rainboom that came from Rainbow Dash’s magic created Pinkie Pie’s? I know this is a stretch but if we look back at Feeling Pinkie Keen, only Pinkie Pie was able to predict things right when it happened. We have never seen a character able to do that except maybe Maud. What if ponies’ magic is already within them but they have to figure out how to bring it out? The rainboom brought the mane 6’s magic out and formed a connection. Maybe it wasn’t Grogar’s bell that caused her chaotic powers rather than that one event. I know it’s a stretch but i don’t see any evidence prior to that one event that someone went back in time and did that.


Nobody can solve pinkie Pie not even pinkie

@Kylan Cooper promise not to tell? Will will you zip your mouth closed🤐 then lock your mouth 🔒then dig a hole 🕳put the key in the hole🔑🕳 then build a house over the whole thing forget it exists and live in the house happily ever after lol🏠🏘.😄🤐

That is true cross my heart and hope to fly stick a cupcake in my eye


This seems likely. But it could also have something to do with her cutie mark. Because Party Favor pulled balloons from out of nowhere and even when magic was gone, Pinkie Pie still did some abnormal things, like pull cakes out of nowhere in Tarterus. But in the s4 finale, she lost her cutie mark and she never did any of those strange things (or at least I don't remember her doing them). And in s5 when she lost her cutie mark she didn't do those abnormal things. And Cheese Sandwitch also did some abnormal things (but not nearly as much as Pinkie).


When I saw that episode (totally wasn't earlier today btw) I thought it more like because pinkie was such a chaotic being she was able to harness the magic instead of it going hog wild unlike with cozy glow


Pulling things out of thin air is literally normal for all of them.


Hello Sawtooth! I wanted to tell you why I personnally think that it wasnt discords magic. You said that when pinkie pie gotted all of that power, it affected all of her timeline. But as your clone telled you, the real pinkie pie was dead all along since season 3, so how could that magic get both the real pinkie and her clones? (I know that the show hasnt really explained the science of magic cloning)

Because the pool was act like a mirror and copying all about Pinkie Pie


Sawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?!<br>His FBI Agent: buck

Sawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?!
His FBI Agent: buck


I don't have enough words to thank you for using the THX sound.  Glad people haven't forgotten it.


As someone who is a huge fan of both My Little Pony gen. 4, and Star Trek, I think I get it even more.  Q, Continuum: past-future.  Q-Discord- John DeLancie.


now that i think about this i think because she absorbed alicorn magic along with discord's magic it fused into her essence but cozy only took discord's magic so it didn't effect her.


Something interesting is that Cozy Glow can’t control Discord magic but Pinkie Pie can.

Just a comment.


Pinkie might not even be a pony, she could be a creature that can change like a changling or a new creature.

Well if her whole family is like that it would explain why pinky sense runs in the family

magically genetic mutation ? idk it’s just a fun thing to say

Elias Powlison  O-O too much information for my brain

She is a new creature that they have not put in the show she is a changing a new one. What if she is a changing that take happiness instead, take love or giving love. No steal my thinking pls

What if she’s also Nikki from Camp Camp? She just went through a intergalactic portal and jump through fandoms???

Yeah, remember the episode where pinkie pulled a whole lotta pinkies from a magic lake in a magic cave and twilight made them watch paint dry?? Two of the pinkies were talking and one of them changed her face to a gen 1 style pinkie and made the other laugh. Maybe thats an example???<br>Edit: I just remembered the OTHER pinkie that was with the pinkie I mentioned earlier blew into her own  hoof and FINGERS CAME OUT OF IT!!!!!!

Yeah, remember the episode where pinkie pulled a whole lotta pinkies from a magic lake in a magic cave and twilight made them watch paint dry?? Two of the pinkies were talking and one of them changed her face to a gen 1 style pinkie and made the other laugh. Maybe thats an example???
Edit: I just remembered the OTHER pinkie that was with the pinkie I mentioned earlier blew into her own  hoof and FINGERS CAME OUT OF IT!!!!!!


You said it affected her time-line when she was a filly but cozy glow is already a filly and never see her future so it is not a problem, cozy glow she was an Alicorn at the time she absorbed discord's magic so she can handled it while pinkie is just an earth pony there is no cozy problem.


Sawtooth Waves, I know the reason why Pinkie Pie new what happened in the other world. I watched My Little Pony bloopers and there was a part that two of the Pinkie Pie's from different worlds were secretly using the portal you have to watch it. IT'S SOO AWESOME and a bit funny.


I agree with Atxqrygh0ul but another theory that I thought of is that Cozyglows’s body was already full of magic so it couldn’t embrace any of Discord’s


They also constantly break the fourth wall by talking to the audience.


This is a really solid feeling, I mean, we’ve seen time travel magic, we’ve seen pinkie being psychic, we’ve also seen different universes based on a single event so why couldn’t it affect the past along with the future giving rise to a dr who theory of fixed points in time and then the unfixed points where you can change something. Pinkie absorbing the chaos magic is a fixed point- in this universe it will always happen, just as the sonic rainboom was proven to be an unfixed point as they all would’ve gotten their cutie marks at some point or another. So maybe its possible for a fixed point in the future to affect the entire past! Great theory and makes way for a ton of discussion. Or of course, it’s pinkie pie and we shouldn’t question it.

Maybe she is a party pony a sub type of earth pony

In other words “Ripples of distortion radiated our from that point of impact, shifting everything just a tiny bit...but enough. Enough for events to happen slightly differently”


I'm not too sure one can ever "figure out" pinky pie, ya know


slight problem in a episode Maud said that she had Maud sense. Pinkie also stated that it runs in the family.<br>But still could be true.

slight problem in a episode Maud said that she had Maud sense. Pinkie also stated that it runs in the family.
But still could be true.


Actually I think your theory works out because of one reason Remember what she said when the chaos magic Was being absorbed into her twilight said how do you feel shes said itchy tingling etc


Say what you like, you’re all just jealous that Pinkie became the true hero of MLP, she’s the one who truly defeated Cozy, Chrysalis and Tirek, albeit with help from Discord


“But that’s just Pinkie Pie being Pinkie. You can’t explain it... or can you?”               <b>Vsause music plays</b>

“But that’s just Pinkie Pie being Pinkie. You can’t explain it... or can you?”               *Vsause music plays*

Empire Cross <b>normal is defined as the characteristic or trait to not be abnormal or different from a just group or society.</b>

Empire Cross *normal is defined as the characteristic or trait to not be abnormal or different from a just group or society.*


I think the difference is that pinkie's "energy/spirit" matches with discord's magic


1:50
-puts on spikes hat, jacket and sunglasses and backs out of the door-

1:50
--puts on spikes hat, jacket and sunglasses and backs out of the door--


Knowing what we know now, and seeing the Earth ponies do have some kind of magic, maybe pinky was the start of this?


I think I've heard this theory before or at least one very similar. I don't remember where it was from though.


Who had the chaos magic longer? Maybe the magic was revoked from Cozy Glow before it had a chance to take effect?


I have one question. If this is the theory that proves pink sense, then why does maud have a maud sense? I’d really like to know an answer if anyone comes up with the theory! :)


I think pinky being a rock farmer exposed her to raw magic and she constantly consumed it and was constantly around it


Maybe we we're just shown the timeline where discord's chaos essence was consumed in Pinkie Pie's timeline instead of the timeline she wasn't on MLP this whole time and it just didn't work with Cozy!


twilight sparkle: sees video
also her: whats this?
her after watching it: q u a k i n g

Pinkie:wait,didn't cozy used the bell as well?.....should we worry?

@fluorescent duck<br>Twi: Please don’t. And, sorry, that was a bad choice of words... but, how else would you explain all of those stunts you pull, I’ve seen discord preform similar stunts so it just makes sense.

@fluorescent duck
Twi: Please don’t. And, sorry, that was a bad choice of words... but, how else would you explain all of those stunts you pull, I’ve seen discord preform similar stunts so it just makes sense.

@Kentavritsa Pinky: I’m wanna get the bell again

@- Nahida Ch. - Pinkie: I am not crazy.. not right now, but that is too subjective for you to comprehend.

Twi: So you basically have chaos magic inside of you even though your an earth pony. Explains why you are crazy.

Twilight: PINKIE!!!! WE NEED TO TALK RIGHT NOW!!!


pinkie is just the spirit of spontaneity, doesn't have to be chaotic


now the things that the pinkie clones did in to many pinkie pies, when they where watching paint dry makes sense


Simple, Pinkie (thanks to begin comic relief) has chaos powers like breaking the 4th wall


I feel like earth ponies version of ‘magic’ is that rarely at birth they are born with strange abilities like pinky and cheese. possibly a rare cutie mark or something.


In season 1 ep 24 Twilight's Owl winks at the camera, probably more creatures do show that they can see the audience (us) in the show. What does this say? :3

Don't mean to debunk the idea because I like it, but I just wanted to say this.


maybe its a bootstrap pradox, I mean, maybe pinkie can handle chaotic magic because she already had been exposed to that, in the future. Mind blow


I love how the rule books name was "Da Rules" 🤣


I just thought of this.

Theory:
What if Pinkie Pie was adopted.
Let's bust out the fact that this might be the case.
Fact 1: She's pink(I know it's obvious but hear me out). If we take a look at her family's color palette and then Pinkie's, we can see a big difference. While Pinkie's family has muted color palettes Pinkie does not.
Fact 2: Her abilities. While it seems like Pinkie Pie can pull stuff from out of nowhere! Her family can't.
Fact 3: She's chaotic like it said in the video. Her family seems to be calm and saner than Pinkie.
Fact 4: She has magic as we saw in the second to last episode she has magic.

So here's a story I thought of.
An earth pony and draconequus fell in love. However, it was forbidden and they already had a child Pinkie. Pinkie didn't have any distinct features of the draconequus parent, but she still had the chaotic magic. She was left at the Pies' doorstep the night before the parents' execution. Pinkie grew up on the rock farm never knowing her real parents. As she was getting older her magic started to appear. She could pull stuff from out of nowhere, gaining Pinkie senses and whatnot. She grew up to be the Pinkie we know today.

I just wanted to share this new theory of mine. I wanted to keep it relevant so, that's why this comment is so late.


Hey did anyone realize when cozy glow got discord magic she couldn’t control what she did but when pinky pie got discord magic she could control it why better the cozy glow so that might have a saying to do with it to because if discord and pinky pie can control the magic they might have the same bit of element in them that’s my theory to connect discord and pinky’s crazy doings together

@Lost Pony Yes, but it's chaos magic. Even Tirek admitted it its impossible to control

Cozys a child, ponks an adult.  Makes a difference in capability overall.  Oops already been said.

Cozy glow couldn't control it bcz she is just a child/filly?

And my thought is that to control chaos magic you need have right personality and mindset. Like pinki and discord, both naturally enjoy chaos but cozy glow don't.

Additionally the chaos magic must of leaked into her timestream meaning she could control it better when the time came.

I agree! It would make sense that since the same magic is flowing through them would make pinkie in control of the chaos magic.

He did say in his first appearance that Pinkie’s element of laughter was the one he had most affinity to.

I did notice that but didn't think anything of it

She may have always had A lesser version all along


i think pinkie had a lot of chaos magic in the first place. Cheese sandwich has the same type of magic so I think its natural


But in the Christmas special pinkie asks those deer things about the perfect gift and if she could see into the future or connected to the future she would know the perfect gift to give twilight but she did not. So if this the theory were true, pinkie would have got the perfect gift from the start and would not have to ask the reindeer.


In my opinion, your theory is definitely true.


based on when discord was helping Tirek drain the magic of ponies they alsp said Tirek drained the magic of EARTH ponies. Which makes me beileve that all earth ponies have magic to some degree it is just channeled by their cutie marks. I think that it is Pinkie being Pinkie but the magical parts (teleportation and being incredibly fast) come from her cutie mark taking the magic around her and giving her new abilities.


I don’t think Pinkie got power from absorbing Discord’s magic, because that wayyy wayyy near the end of the story. I do believe she has magic powers like discord, but less powerful. Pinkie is outrageous and chaotic, I think if you are born like that you just have some hidden powers in you. If pinkie wasn’t chaotic she probably wouldn’t have powers, like discord when he tried to act normal.


Thank you I have been trying to figure this out for years also I would really like to know what your favorite episode is my favorite episode is the one where rarity opens up a boutique in Canterlot and the episode where starlight glimmer goes to Canterlot on a mission to help the royal sisters


Please Notice This Comment, Sawtooth Waves!<br>Sawtooth, I noticed that you forgot to mention that Spike didn't get magic back in the part of the video where you pointed out who got magic back in the episode with Cozy Glow’s spell. If Spike didn't get magic, how is his ‘Magic Fire Letter Burping’ possible? I mean, if he has some magical ability that no other dragons have, then why did he not have magic? So think about it this way: if he didn't have magic, he wouldn't have the instant mail express whatchamacallit. But, he DOES. ⚠ PARADOX ALERT ⚠

Please Notice This Comment, Sawtooth Waves!
Sawtooth, I noticed that you forgot to mention that Spike didn't get magic back in the part of the video where you pointed out who got magic back in the episode with Cozy Glow’s spell. If Spike didn't get magic, how is his ‘Magic Fire Letter Burping’ possible? I mean, if he has some magical ability that no other dragons have, then why did he not have magic? So think about it this way: if he didn't have magic, he wouldn't have the instant mail express whatchamacallit. But, he DOES. ⚠ PARADOX ALERT ⚠

Maybe that’s just a spell twilight put on him


Pinkie sense has nothing to do with chaos magic! In one of the episodes, it is explained that her sister, Maud Pie, also has a Maud sense!!!


Wait, so if Pinkie got the Pinkie Sense from Discord's magic, then how did Cheese Sandwich get HIS Cheese Sense?

@Jonella Magbanua So if her ting the chaos magic affected her entire family, does that mean that it also could've affected her past ancestors? Think about it. If every past family was affected, this then proves that Pinkie isn't related to Applejack

Not Just Cheese Her Whole Family Had Senses

@Ribbuns 🤯yeah okay, that... doesn't make sense to me 😅

If it affects by time, maybe by being connected to pinkie pie from their child, li'l cheese, affected his timeline, too.

oh and maud sense... idk maybe it's genetic? or, maybe they're somehow copying her... 🤔😂 no that's weird


about the cozy glow thing,i think there were no side effects for cozy glow because shes a pegasus but pinkie is an earth pony or the time since cozy glow only got to absorve the magic for 1m while pinkie longer


The difference between cozy and pinkie is that pinkie used the magic she got, while cozy got turned back before she had the chance to do so. Also (like another commenter said) Alicorns can hold magic in a different way than normal ponies (fx when all the princess put theyr magic onto twilight, they probably couldn’t have done that to a normal pony) so cozy would be able to contain the magic in that moment, while pinkie wouldn’t.


speaking of chaos Izzy from the NG5 had that Pinkie vibe to her, though being a unicorn. And the most interesting fact is that she kept her "glow" unlike all other unicorns from the village. Makes me think what the fuck happened XD


pinkie is actual god, having cloned herself and having almost altered the entire state of the universe.


I believe she is a pony god, but she doesn't know it...

she knows, she knows that she knows, but since it is not relevant at the time she does not know.

She does state at the end of explaining to the Cutie Mark Crusaders about how she got how cutie mark. "And that's how Equestria was made."


If pinkie's pinkie sense can affect future timelines because of discords bell. Then how the heck does cheese sandwich have cheese sense without grogars bell?


I love the theory. But you're breaking the rule: Just don't question the Pink Eldritch Abomination... Err Pinkie Pie.


Either way or other, Pinkie Pie is my favorite character. She's funny, cute, energetic and random.


Timeline theory is kinda dump, but connection between chaos magic(or even Discord specificly) and Pinkie it's something that was clear from early seasons.


i watched this to get more insight into the "Smile" episode where she kills all of her friends but there wasnt anything said about it! its actually only thing i saw from MLP world.


I really like that theory alot! With the cozy glow problem i thought of your other video where Cozy Glow was in the human world or even <b>from</b> the human world. Maby that has something to do with it?? And! In that videos comments someone said that she said something along the lines of: “you ponies wouldnt understand” so maby its because shes another kind of creature that cant have magic? Just a theory but i thought it was an interresting thought :))

I really like that theory alot! With the cozy glow problem i thought of your other video where Cozy Glow was in the human world or even *from* the human world. Maby that has something to do with it?? And! In that videos comments someone said that she said something along the lines of: “you ponies wouldnt understand” so maby its because shes another kind of creature that cant have magic? Just a theory but i thought it was an interresting thought :))


Ok wow I clearly need to watch further into the show for this


How do you explain equestria girl Pinkie and her having knowledge to alternate worlds?  Did the chaos magic maybe not just affect Equestrian Pinkie but travel through her to alternate pinkie pies and affect them similarly?


"Is someone watching me?"

Nope. Nopony is watching you. Not at all. Whistles.


Its been 7 months but i think had something too.

Pinkie pies magic was spread out through her life span because it was all of their magic. When cozy glow absorbed chaos magic she only absorbed chaos magic because the other 2 absorbed the rest but maybe pinky absorbed all of it. Making it so much for her to handle and spreading the magic across her timeline.


Cheesy sense debunks this. As does Maud sense. Or at least debunks any connection with the pinky sense. Also, Party Favour can do comparable stuff. Take a page out of twilights book on this one. You can't explain it, but somehow it just works.


Her time lines jumbled because of the effects and thats why pinkie pie is my favorite pony


I actually really like that idea! Think about it. Pinkie, unlike her family, has never really shown much connection to the earth. I'm not sure what she would be, but if someone finds a folklore creature that matches pinkie put it in the replies


This doesn't explain Party Favor's or Cheese Sandwich's similar abilities, or Maud's, for that matter.

Also all earth ponies, interestingly enough~


Wait what if the reason Cozy glow didn't absorb Discord's magic the same way Pinky pie did was because she was a pegasus.<br>Just an idea.🤪

Wait what if the reason Cozy glow didn't absorb Discord's magic the same way Pinky pie did was because she was a pegasus.
Just an idea.🤪


I think pinkie and discord were siblings let me explain

The time line from both the wizard and grogar are different but let me explain mine,what if discord was a normal pony? I will tell it with a story

Long ago there were two little fillies of the pie family pinkie pie and corndie pie
As the grew up they became really good siblings until...grogar came in that family
He wanted to turn pinkie into a powerful being
Their parents tried to protect them but...pinkie went outside and almost got hit by grogar but corndie saved his little sister and became discord

I think what happened what do you think?


Cozy was an alicorn when she absorbed discords chaos magic but pinkie was just an earth pony , maybe only alicorns can handle that magic without spreading it throughout their whole timeline unlike unicorns , pegasi , or earth ponies aka pinkie pie


Sawtooth:is someone watching me?<br>Me:you made this public😆

Sawtooth:is someone watching me?
Me:you made this public😆


To be honest, I think Pinkie Pie was once a Unicorn but in a spell gone wrong, she accidentally got rid of her horn and forever to be a earth pony until a unicorn brings it back.


I think it was different since Pinky is an earth pony and Cozy Glow was an alicorn when she absorbed the magic


I could add up that, by the time cozy glow absorbed Discords's magic, she was a alicorn, while pinkie, well, is an earth pony-


If we solve Pinkie Pie, there will no longer be any more parties and the citizens of Ponyville will be unhappy all day, just like Pinkie's family. Without Pinkie Pie, Ponyville will have a big difference. Please don't solve Pinkie Pie.


"She dont needs discord magic..."
She all ready crazy as it is-
|o-0|

*"She dont needs discord magic..."*
*She all ready crazy as it is-*
|o-0|


hmm well theirs definitely a magic aspect lets not forget cheese sandwich has also shown the same abilities as pinkie... question is, why do they have this magic and why does it seem genetic? even in the equestria girls human world pinkie seems to have the same abilities so its not limited to equestrian magic either since human pinkie had some minor power similarities prior to the first time they ponied up, so its both magical and genetic at the same time... but perhaps pinkies chaotic abilities stem more from the timeline when discord was the ruler of equestria since he obviously isn't tied to a singular timeline and the comic where discord makes pinkie princess of chaos? never read it just heard about it... so she's had exposure to chaos magic long before that event, but at this point I'm just listing things that might put her exposure to chaos magic to before that episode, though what about grogar? what if one of pinkie's ancestors was one of his creations and a small scale attempt at taming chaos magic? last theory likely not the case but hey ya never truly know with pinkie


Maybe the problem with cozy glow can be solved by saying that that She wanned to use the power of evil and didnt even know from the start that it was Discords magic, but you know im just a simple kid so what do i know


I read someone else's suggestion that "Pony Life" is a pocket universe created by Pinkie Pie when she briefly absorbed the chaos magic.


Sawtooth: "Is someone watching me?"

Me: "Please don't stare at me like that. You do know what a YouTube video is, right?"


Me seeing the title: (Thanos voice) “impossible”


No pony knows how to use discords magic, however pinkie pie did. I assume she's some kinda mega minded pony.


the real question is, how did pinkie take discords magic in the first place? don’t you need a spell for that?


Very believable speaking of ponies that aren't unicorns I'd like to mention that there was a vampire pony without a horn but wings it would be able to you know pull off telekinesis despite not having a horn but that's probably just my theory


Pinkie Pie (from My Little Pony Friendship is Magic) is always a mystery.


Maud has a maud Sense and pinkie said  :" it is in the family. "

@NaoLucille♪Random ehem applejack,apple bloom and more;<br>( it must be a pie thing )

@NaoLucille♪Random ehem applejack,apple bloom and more;
( it must be a pie thing )

I think the Sense is an earth pony thing.


ConspiraPon3's theory could tie into this if pinkie is a changeling who grows powerful through love than she would have her own magic  already and the encounter with discord's magic might have reacted with her magic, her changeling biology, or both and that would explain the different experience cozy glow had; they're two different species


I got a other theory about Pinkie.  I'm almost sure that she was adopted by the Pie family.  The evidence : Everyone in the Pie family are greyish but her.


lets not forget that "nopony can control Discord chaotic magic" but apparently pinky can?


"Everyone wants an impact. An impact that would shake the ground below out feet"

The ad I watched before this said that xD
Fit perfectly


Maybe the element of laughter had something to do with it. I mean it does make sense cause cozy glow was and evil characters and pinkie pie is one of the elements of harmony so maybe because of her element it might have had a different effect on her.


One problem with this theory...CUTIE MARKS! All three Equine tribes MAGICALLY obtain flank symbols upon finding their proclivity OR talent! Earth Pony's and Pegasi are therefore JUST as compatible with wielding Magic as Unicorns are. It's just that it likely manifests in different ways! Take Applejack, SHE's an Earth pony yet she AND Pinky Pie bear one of the elements of harmony. Now let's look at their traits. Apple Jack is strong, athletic, and has HIGH Stamina and endurance and Pinkie Pie is an anomaly of reality. Applejack herself wasn't exposed to chaos magic, but Pinky's reaction to it highlights, for ME at least, Earth pony's as bearers of LATENT Magic pertaining to their innate talents. Had Applejack been exposed to discord's magic instead, I'm inclined to believe we would have gotten the Pony equivalent of the incredible HULK.

Pegasi are a similar case. Alongside their magic flank symbols, THEY gain not "Magic" per say but SUPERPOWERS. Every Pegasi, if trained, gains SOME capacity to manipulate the weather for example. Then there's the special cases! Fluttershy doesn't manipulate the weather but is instead an ANIMAL WHISPERER and can be seen in THAT way as "influencing nature"! Rainbow Dash is a speedster and can go faster than sound with the Sonic rainboom. Elements of Harmony AREN'T a necessity to gain powers like these EITHER it would seem. Rainbow Dash AND Derpy Hooves, a commoner Pegasi, have been shown to have the power of HEAT VISION! THEN we have Cozy Glow...SEEMINGLY a Pegasus...gaining the ability to harness PRIMARY Pony Magic and gaining a HORN!

The Cutie Marks say it all. They are evidence of Magic in not just Unicorns but ALL Pony Kind. THAT's why Starlight Glimmer, A MASTER of Pony Magic, was able to control the people of her village through her Cutie Mark "nixing equity spell". If Pinkie Pie's case WERE so special, it would have ONLY worked on other Unicorns, NOT Pegasi and Earth Pony's. Friendship is Magic for NOT just Unicorns, but ALL Equine tribes afterall. How they GET that Magic is the REAL trick! But that's My theory. What do you think?


My theory (whch actually I've had since about season 3!) was that she was just born with a ltitle bit of chaos magic haha


i think that pinkie pie is just that fun character to break all known rules. she's just being pinkie pie.
plus if pinkie got chaos magic from the bell in her blood then why does her sister Maud have a Maud sense?
that just doesn't add up. no i believe  that Pinkie inherited her magic.


"IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?!"

-Yeah, Pinkie is watching you from the beginning of all eternity, heh...


It was chaos magic so it could be an event in the future affecting the past.


I would like to say: I pretty sure when pinkie has her pinkie senses that's before she inhaled the power.


My theory about Cozy Glow

it did affect her past.
it made her a malevolent megalomaniac bent on world domination.


I dont know if this was before or after EQG but, this might solve mlp Pinkie Pie, but it doesn't solve EQG pinkie pie, since she's just as hyper and un-logical as mlp pinkie pie, an example would be a brief moment in eqg friendship games where she teleported everywhere in the hallway, so, if that pinkie pie could do it without taking in the magic of the bell, I don't think that solves mlps pinkie pie since there was no magical bell in that world


Hey, in the episode 'one where pinkie knows' at the end we see pinkie pie break into pieces... literally in pieces as in pieces. And we know just one being that can do that. Our dear Discord


I was sceptical at first but you know what? Headcanon accepted.


i think, that pinkie pie, and human pinkie pie are two, but also the same. i know it sounds confusing, but what if theyre both using the portal, and they knew about, longer than twilight? that would explain the ,,i know everything about everyone" things


He has just solved the unsolvebole, OMG!


“Is someone watching me?”<br>That cracked me up 😹

“Is someone watching me?”
That cracked me up 😹


Pinkie was still able to pull a pizza costume from nowhere when magic was gone


I know how Pinkie Pie get her magic.<br>Long time ago when she was a child, Pinkie got her power from rainboom and inflated her hair.

I know how Pinkie Pie get her magic.
Long time ago when she was a child, Pinkie got her power from rainboom and inflated her hair.


pinkie was only able to control discords magic bc she already had chaos magic in her all earthponies still have magical abilities connected to their special talent


what ab the rest of the pie family with their senses?

“maud sense”

pinkie: “it runs in the family”

@Khitara Aldilla I remember that episode with Raritey

Lol ur problally the only one who remembered maud sense else then me


Maybe it's part of her cutie mark magic Maybe when she got her cutie mark It gave her Some Help To throw a party Like being able to Pull up party canon out of thin air


Maybe since pinkie is a earth pony she had a greater effect since she probably had more room for magic unlike cosy glow


Okay so, I love this theory but I am not very sure about pinkie sense, we have seen other kinds of sense like pinkie's, Maud sense in the Psstd and cheesy sense too. so if I donnt include pinkie sense then I love this theory!!


Here’s my theory: Pinkie Pie absorbed Discord’s chaos magic, found out she could do the stuff she does even after the Magic was taken from her, traveled back in time, so she could do all that stuff when she was a baby, filly, and even a teen.

@Blueberry Pie  UWU UWU UWU UWU UWU UWU UWU

@Blueberry Pie Pinkie's Brew intensifies
I see ur a person of culture too

@Blueberry Pie *Pinkie's Brew intensifies*
I see ur a person of culture too

@chikorita PKMNFG lol I think u made them mad

She's going to bake a portal, Open it and jump in.


2:07 Reminds me of when the Wifi returns after hours of a blackout 😂


Also something else to add to this is that Maud (Pinkies sister) has Maud sense so maybe Pinkie really is just Pinkie


I know why  they stare into existance as if somebody watches them, if you look at  pinkie pie on Netflix or YouTube you can tell she is talking to you or to twilight  sparkle  as in magic duel she  muffles for her mouth to come back and kinda stares at you and gasps and  the video ends on Netflix, but what if the case was pinkie pie did get the chaos magic and it did spread through  timelines, family, and also cheese sandwich since in the future had a wedding with Pinkie pie, but I think  since  pinkie was full of  joy and fun, it turned  into JOY MAGIC....<br>This  still means chaos magic,  but discord hasn't  appeared  in the black asking for something like how pinkie did, yeah maybe the pinkie sense is half chaos magic but danger sense magic for some reason because pinkie pie   keeps herself safe by using pinkie sense,  so pinkie pie isn't an earth pony practically  because  she has joy magic  and danger sense magic but she was just classically   what the  future  earth ponies are with magic now but pinkie was the  first to gain this so did cheese, maud, but this proves my point that this is danger and  joy magic   but   one more thing to say the teleporting, breaking the fourth wall, and pulling stuff out of existance, coming out of the show at the end and all of that is strange, yeah we can explain twilight but not pinkie.

I know why  they stare into existance as if somebody watches them, if you look at  pinkie pie on Netflix or YouTube you can tell she is talking to you or to twilight  sparkle  as in magic duel she  muffles for her mouth to come back and kinda stares at you and gasps and  the video ends on Netflix, but what if the case was pinkie pie did get the chaos magic and it did spread through  timelines, family, and also cheese sandwich since in the future had a wedding with Pinkie pie, but I think  since  pinkie was full of  joy and fun, it turned  into JOY MAGIC....
This  still means chaos magic,  but discord hasn't  appeared  in the black asking for something like how pinkie did, yeah maybe the pinkie sense is half chaos magic but danger sense magic for some reason because pinkie pie   keeps herself safe by using pinkie sense,  so pinkie pie isn't an earth pony practically  because  she has joy magic  and danger sense magic but she was just classically   what the  future  earth ponies are with magic now but pinkie was the  first to gain this so did cheese, maud, but this proves my point that this is danger and  joy magic   but   one more thing to say the teleporting, breaking the fourth wall, and pulling stuff out of existance, coming out of the show at the end and all of that is strange, yeah we can explain twilight but not pinkie.


God, I had to relearn the multiverse to understand this


I think your theory is part right? Maybe Pinkie didn't return all of the magic, maybe a fraction is left behind! But changing the past is something I'm gonna think about.


what if pinkie managed to keep some of the magic from the bell


Pinkie is also an alternate universe chaos princess so I think this lends to your theory.


Woah, woah, woah, don’t put Pinkie sense into this. She said, “It runs in the family,” and don’t forget Muad sense.


The Pinkie from this moment is interconnected to the infinite pinkies from every moment through time and space.


That would be Discord and Fluttershy’s kid. (Remember the final episode?  Flutter came from the realm of Chaos?)


Sawtooth: Did someone Watch me?
The Viewer: Am Joke to You?

Sawtooth: *Did someone Watch me?*
The Viewer: *-Am Joke to You?-*


Maybe when the rainboom happened, pinkie somehow accidentally consumed chaos magic.


Ummm I think that her defying gravity and pulling out party canons out of thin air, is just cartoons in action


Apart from the ruler of The crystal empire Twilight wasn’t the first  Alicorn Remember that episode where in clouds well Rainbow Dash Need extra support But flatter shy was too quiet TwilightTurned Rarat In to an alicorn Before she was turned


So few years ago before season 9 was aired I actually had a theory that Pinkie Pie was part darconequus!
But not in the way that you explained it actually it that somewhere back in Pinkie Pie's family tree There Was a darconequus Like way way back in her family tree and somehow the genetics only came back to her and no one else in her immediate family it's pretty far-fetched but I still think it's a pretty good theory.
Ps I love your Channel! <3

i think ur right<br>that also explains why pinkie pie had the chaos lightning when she absorbed discord's magic and cozy glow didn't have the lightning when she absoebed the chaos magic

i think ur right
that also explains why pinkie pie had the chaos lightning when she absorbed discord's magic and cozy glow didn't have the lightning when she absoebed the chaos magic

Maybe maud pie got somewhat of that gene, seeing as she can pretty much teleport on the spot


Nice theory and yes chaos magic is the only way I can see to fit pinkies craziness


The first time I saw that pinkie could handle Chao's magic I thought she was gonna be the next discord 😂


I also watched finally solving the royal gard It's pretty silly That's part of this big message to you


You missed something though. What about the human version of Pinkiepie?


I think pinkie somehow allways had that Power, because when ponies have full energy/magic they become alicorns, but pinkie did not, so maybe shes more powerfull then we think!

@Dark Cyan cozy did not, when she had chaos magic

Isn't the rule that you become an Alicorn by inventing a new type of magic?

Does anyone remember that IDW comic, I believe #57? Pinkie became an alicorn: https://mlp-gameloft.fandom.com/wiki/Chaos_Princess_Pinkie_Pie

Electric Heart that has not been proven. We just have never heard of one becoming an alicorn. If pegasus and unicorns can become alicorns why not earth? One day in the future an earth pony might become an alicorn.

Problem... earth ponies can't become alicorns.


I don't remember but... Can't Cheese Sandwich do the same impossible stuff? Or not??


The reason pinkie pie knew what was happening in the human world and other in the pony is because they been switching places. Evidence just watch the bloopers


Bruh after watching season 1 (I'm on season 5) I came with the theory that she's a God


DOESN"T DISCORD HAVE A SENSE TOo CAUSE WHEN HE WAS WITH TIREK< HE FELT THAT MAGIC WAS BEING TRANSFERED

ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽

@Kentavritsa Wouldn't it just be Discord Sense?


I have a theory :<br>Before Discord have a little sister but he never meet her. Their parents die when discord is already transform in stone. So they put Pinkie Pie in Foster Home, thats why Pinkie Pie have chaotic power.

I have a theory :
Before Discord have a little sister but he never meet her. Their parents die when discord is already transform in stone. So they put Pinkie Pie in Foster Home, thats why Pinkie Pie have chaotic power.


maybe because discord is behind so many other events he knowingly left a piece of magic behind in pinkie pie whereas the others took all of the chaos magic back from cozy glow


According to me there must be something in the rainboom that did this or else why did discord's bell not affect pinkie's childhood before she got her cutie mark. She wasn't like that when she was at the rock farm before she got her cutie mark. It just doesn't add up.


I think Pinkie have most of her's powers from rainboom. When rainboom happened her mane changed. We all know that magic can be connected with magic.


well the pinkie sense probably wouldn't have anything to do with this, even if your theory was right. Maud also has a sense, and pinkie says it runs in the family so

@wolf lion wild prides That's a possibility too o.o

@Emily Rain I’d have to go back and look but they I’m pretty sure they mentioned in the episode where they’re exchanging gifts

Emily Rain i think a sense that helps her locate things??? Idk

@Ann-Marie Wightman probably xD or she could have the sense that tells when Pinkie is in danger or something


I like your theory Sawtooth Waves but I have a better one a one that connects the whole Pie family to chaos magic.


Maybe the reason discord’s magic didn’t have an effect on cozy glow is because she is an alacorn and has the means to hold all that power while pinkie doesn’t since she is just an earth pony. Like so sawtooth can see this.


Maud pie has maud sense, it runs in the family. But I think when pinkie got her magic back when cozy glow, it certainly explain everything


I've had the theory for a while that pinkie is somewhat evil because of the way she acts sometimes. The best way I think I can explain is if you rewatch the series with the perspective that she's a villain hiding in plain sight you'll see clues that point to her wanting to affect others in a negative way and getting joy from it. Kind of similar to a much more convincing cozy glow that acts sweet but sometimes her evil slips through. I haven't seen anyone talk about it (besides non canon creepypastas or stories).

@Dominique Fairclough i wouldn't say VILLAIN, but yeah sometimes they're sus

EmeraldFlowerz all of the main 6 do they all have negative tendencies and sorta villain behavior if you analyze it hard enough

We all act toxic or suspicious sometimes.

Shes just pinkie pie. And pinkie pie is evil fun?

I mean maybe, I think shes more of a Chaotic Hero Shes more of a balance of good and evil doing both at once, it makes her happy to see other people happy. She did make friends with the entire town of ponyville and got so confused when One person didn't want to be friends with her and didn't enjoy her joyful craziness.


All ponies have magic. Terak (or Terek), and other factors prove all ponies have magic<br>I mean earth ponies and pegasus also have magic.

All ponies have magic. Terak (or Terek), and other factors prove all ponies have magic
I mean earth ponies and pegasus also have magic.


Sawtooth: is someone watching me<br>Me: yes me and the viewers are watching you

Sawtooth: is someone watching me
Me: yes me and the viewers are watching you


Ofc you have a point but all I want to know is, what would pinky be if she didn’t grab the bell<br>and how did she get to the point of grabbing the bell and how

Ofc you have a point but all I want to know is, what would pinky be if she didn’t grab the bell
and how did she get to the point of grabbing the bell and how


Well this confuses me, <br>A new theory of yours is that twilight killed the real pinkie-

Well this confuses me,
A new theory of yours is that twilight killed the real pinkie-


Me realizing how much sense this theory actually makes-

“This wasn’t a mess! It was organized chaos!”

It makes happy seeing Ami in the comments borahae!


Sure, that explains pony Pinkie. But what about Canterlot High Pinkie Pie? How did she get so...um...enthusiastic in the human world? Maybe it had something to do with Discord? I mean, he was about to send Tree Hugger to OUR REALM! it must be possible for him to open a portal to the human world, right? And, if you think about it, we haven’t seen anything of the Canterlot High girls since the season 9 epilogue. What if the same thing happened to the E.G. Pinkie Pie? It would have probably gone down something like this. Discord decides to go the the human world, (probably because he was board) and does something that causes the girls to “Pony Up” and take care of Discord’s boredom. Discord sees potential in Pinkie, and gives her some of his magic. But then takes it back, and like Sawtooth said, that one moment effected her entire timeline.

But what do you think?


Sawtooth waves:i think I finally solved pinky pie

Every pony in equestria watched it

Sawtooth waves:i think I finally solved pinky pie

*Every pony in equestria watched it*


i think maybe pinkie was born as a unicorn, let me explain. in the episode where pinkie and applejack found out they maybe are cousins they told us the family was really really big! maybe there was a unicorn far away in their family like by pound cake and pumpkin cake. Maybe pinkies parents parents wanted her to be a earthpony like the rest of the family. Unicorns can get wings, but can they also maybe lose there horns? maybe pinkies parents took her to princess Celestia and asked her to make her a earthpony! But i dont think u can loose being a unicorn completely away so she still had a little of her magic but not in her horn, the magic is inside her! I think there also is one other way: Pinkie pie maybe isn't a pie! i mean she doesnt look a little bit like the rest of her family! Her birthparents maybe didn't want her and removed her horn with hulp of Celestia and then gave her to the pies!

I hope ur making another video for this! byeee!


i think it's true because her coat and mane aren't even a vibrant pink, you can see when she gets depressed,  her coat goes to her natural colour, a greyish pink, or just gray, like her sisters, and she used her magic to make her hair fluffy and hair and coat pink. when she's depressed, she doesn't use her chaos magic at ALL and that's why her hair is long, straight, and grey, that's my take on it!!


My life just ended. Thanks! I’m so confused!


Hi Sawtooth Waves I kind of have 2 small theories that Pinkie is Adopted!
If U Notice the Pie's All have the grey shade except pinkie .....
Except Pinkie nopony else in the family is like her.
Even tho Marble and Pinkie are twins, I just had this theories.
Thank U


I think Pinkie is a chaos pony, that's why she could handle Discords chaos magic they are magically the same or similar.


I think pinkie and discord have the same magic because both of them have a sense in which they can predict the future.this is my example:
In the episode twillight's kingdom tirek was stealing magic in canterlot and dicord began to shake as if he sensed something like pinkie. in an episode(i do not know name)pinkie began to shake like discord
They both share the magic of sensing what will happen in the next few minutes


Pinkie pie is discord’s older sister “change my mind”

The weird Squad well, discord is very old, soo.....

I haven't watched it yet but maybe this? https://youtu.be/cAqYTjovXo8


I think pinkie pie secretly has wings in a horn Somewhere in her main And it might be true And Around super fast and pulls out a canon out Out of nowhere


Wait y'know how u made a vid on the end of the next gen movie on how the earth pony left magical hoof prints? Maybe pinkie's "pinky sense" has something to do with it?


Re Cosy and pinkie reacting differently to the extraction of the chaos.  Discord did the extraction on Pinky and it would just be like him to leave just a little for shits and giggles :)


But the pinkie sense part, Maud also has it. On the sister gift swap episode, Maud found pinkie's canon with Maud sense. It just runs in the family


I’m still watching these to this day even if the show ended, I do not regret watching these


If u watch the episode *Pinkie Keen* and the episode *Pinkie Pride* u will see there is no difference between them so..... As u solved *Pinkie Pie* u should also solve *Cheese Sandwich* .....

If u watch the episode **Pinkie Keen** and the episode **Pinkie Pride** u will see there is no difference between them so..... As u solved **Pinkie Pie** u should also solve **Cheese Sandwich** .....


I’m guessing that cozy glow was a little pony and her age might’ve made it so that she wouldn’t have powers forever or it’s just because of pinkie sence


I didn‘t know pinkie pie has discord magic o.o now I know She keeps taking out the party canon out of nowhere


Ok. Im VERY late in commenting
but...
that theory could actually be correct!

Here's my reason:
ok so you said that it needed something to do with past and future.
Pinkie pie had pinkie sense, but cozy glow doesnt have such a thing!
Though they got it the same way,
If cozy was lacking the sense similar to pinkie, she could never been chaotic.
another thing to back this theory up: Her DESTINY, she's destined to be wacky, goofy, and just so different.
Maybe-JUST MAYBE, thid means pinkie sense would still be unsolved if it wasnt part of the chaos magic thing, think about it, Maybe pinkie pie was born with that kinda sense bc her whole fam had it! And then she got chaos magic then the magic just spreads to her entire lifetime.
Who knows...maybe she also got discord's immortality, i mean, it is CHAOS magic so maybe theres also other parts of the magic that just doesnt follow normal magic rules.

(Pls notice this)

꧁☃𝙵𝚛𝚘𝚜𝚝𝚆𝚊𝚏𝚏𝚕𝚎☃꧂


I 110% like the idea of this one e moment causing pinkie to be ya-know pinkie, but I have an idea of why cozyglow wasn't effected the same way (go to reply for that because I need to take a nap and it's really early in the morning)


Tirek and Chrysilis looking at cozy glow absorbing Discords magic: What?


I think how Pinkie Pie is crazy

When she got her curly mane and tail by the Rainboom, some random bug got into it and the bug had crazy magic which was Pinkie’s magic but it transferred over to Pinkie so now she is crazy


Ok that's kind of weird though, all earth pony also have magic.


My theory: the show wants someone doing impossible stuff to make us have more fun😂😂😂😂😂


Pinky pie was able to  break the fourth wall and the laws of physics before she even heard of crogars bell


Sawtoooth: Is someone watching me?<br>Me: WE ALL ARE!!

Sawtoooth: Is someone watching me?
Me: WE ALL ARE!!

Fun Activities and Entertainment with Sophia! :3


Him:Is someone watching me?<br>Me:Yes that person is me.

Him:Is someone watching me?
Me:Yes that person is me.


Yeah and showed up in deferent media like as a alicorn during the final battle in the transformers bumblebee movie during a ridiculous boss fight in batman arkhamknight and finally the last evidence is recent were she inside the zero point when it about to blow


"Is someone watching me?"

162,738 people: YES

☆𝒞𝓊𝓇ℯ ℱ𝓁ℴ𝓇𝒶 ☆

☆𝒞𝓊𝓇ℯ ℱ𝓁ℴ𝓇𝒶 ☆


Him: Is someone watching me!?<br>Me: Yeah, ME.

Him: Is someone watching me!?
Me: Yeah, ME.


Also note that somehow she is the only known phoney  and or creature to be able to control chaos magic


if pinkie lost her magic then how did she brought out the cake when she tried to convince tirek


Ok I think k this is the video where you say pinkies discord magic got spread throughout the timeline. But cheese sandwich also has a pinkie sense of sorts. That’s how he knows to go to pony color next for a party. So maybe they just have party magic or something. Her magic things are usually visual gags


<b>when TV characters becomes an equation</b>

*when TV characters becomes an equation*


Ah yes, the 4 tribes of the ponies
- Earth ponies
- Pegasi
- Unicorns
- Pinkie Pie


I think the reason cozy glow didn’t have any after effects is because pinkies energy is so .. pinkie that some magic stayed inside her


No pinkie is discords half  sister and her "parents" adopted her living in a rock farm claiming to be her parents then pinkie moved out in a young age that made her crazy self she is

Nope mAkes no logical sense

What? She was not adopted, it is stated in Hearthbreakers that she is the twin sister of Marble Pie, although they don’t look alike so she was not adopted


I search your theory!

When Pinkie took discords power she was able to control the chaos magic/power, but look what happened when cozy took discords power..
She wasn't able to control his Magic..this is why cozy isn't like pinkie.

I don't know if it makes scene, but it makes scence😅🤷♀


Ya well some funny things of her are getting cakes out of thin air and making her hair work like a drilling machine


Sawtooth:I solved pinkie

Twilight:HOW DID YOU!?!??!

Credit To Silver Wing for giving me this idea


Well you see she also absorbed the alicorn magic where cozy only chaos so...


It's funny at 1:43, pinkie is just casually in the background of the discord image


I think it's because Pinkie Pie actually used her her magic but cosy glow didn't, you know her chocolate rain


I can't agree with you. It doesn't make any sense. You can say: It's Pinkie we're talking about, but hold It right there. It doesn't make sense even if it involves Pinkie. If it IS true then we'd had to have a timeline where is Pinkie <b>normal</b> . But without Pinkie, her welcoming party for Twilight And her craziness She couldn't be the element of laughter And therefore She couldn't get the mane 6 together. That's just my oppinion, i'm not saying that this is a bad theory or something

I can't agree with you. It doesn't make any sense. You can say: It's Pinkie we're talking about, but hold It right there. It doesn't make sense even if it involves Pinkie. If it IS true then we'd had to have a timeline where is Pinkie *normal* . But without Pinkie, her welcoming party for Twilight And her craziness She couldn't be the element of laughter And therefore She couldn't get the mane 6 together. That's just my oppinion, i'm not saying that this is a bad theory or something


How did pinkie control it when cozy glow couldn't?


Maybe the chaos magic that cozy  absorbed what made her so evil


When  was this early, he was still called The Brony Notion.

I didn't even notice he changed it i literally thought man he uses his private username for patreon o my stars

thanks, I was trying to remember his previous name


In the gift of Maud Pie Muad also has pinky Sence or Maud Sence and only said it ran in the family maybe the chaos magic went further and in to the pie family and not the apples because the apples are another huge  tree connected to the pie tree so only the pies where infected with chaos magic


I agree pinkie has some kind of magic but I don't think it came from the chaos magic


I just saw something interesting that I just now noticed do you not have Pegasus patrons because you show off the earth ponies the unicorns and the Alcorns but not the Pegasus do you not have Pegasus patrons?<br>Just curious

I just saw something interesting that I just now noticed do you not have Pegasus patrons because you show off the earth ponies the unicorns and the Alcorns but not the Pegasus do you not have Pegasus patrons?
Just curious


On the gift of the maud pie
Pinkie said that sense runs into their family even her sister has one
Pinkie sense=danger
Maud sense=finding some pony/someone


but did cozzy use her powers when she got them temporaily from discord? pinkie went full blown change everything. while i dont think cozzy did anything rly.

She made pineapples appear. I think it’s a matter of if they can use it effectively they keep a bit and if they can’t it dissapeared compleatly


Maybe Pinkie had a Unicorn Grandparent and it just passed down to Pinkie Pie.


Actually you kind of wrong she could use chaos msigc caused she used in the past before in the comics, and to use chaos msigc you have to understand that what ever pops into your mind comes out There are certain rules to the chaos dimensions and magic that why pinke pie could use discord msigc bescude she used it before he said to the mane five and spike most poines alone in his dimseon would be driven mad but this is pinke pie she might be right at home and in the comics he makes a nod that he doesn't understand pinke pie


Must say, the knowledge Pinkie Pie knows from another dimension is from a deleted scene. Watch the equestria girls deleted scenes of Pinkie and Pinkie going in and out from the portaI.


Plot twist:

pinky actually has hidden horn and wings in her hair. So when shes falling she can slow the fall with her wings and she teleports with her horn.

(This is a joke don't think about this to much)


This video: exists
Me: wait thats illegal

This video: exists
Me: *wait thats illegal*


My theory: Pinkie pie is actually a character from my hero academia that had that power (quirk) and she got stuck in the pony world


sence she’s so fun and animated everyone just brushes her of as wierd and animated and funny but she’s acttauly rlly powerful


I like the way you showed the actual Pokémon farfetched


Video:Finally Solving Pinkie Pie
Time:5 Minutes

Me:5 minutes!? You need years to solve Pinkie


hi I am moonlight sparkle, I think pinkie is an unicorn and she has some hyper magic , she can teleport into different places and I think pinkie has visit to the human world before twilight  .the reason pinkie is not a pegasus pony because rainbow dash is the first pony whom pulled of a sonic rainboom

Goddess Galactic Swirls Luxury(road to 200)


whats the most embarrassing thing you have ever done?

for me one time i accidentily farted and the speaker view ai in zoom spotlighted me and i got hella embarressed. ;-;


When pinkie absorbed magic she had alicorn and more magic, but cozy glow only had chaos magic


Pinkie could be the pony equivalent to a member of Yardrat from dragon ball z.


@Sawtooth Waves do you think that tambelon, bray the donkey and grogar guards exist in G4 ?

Maria Tivanova Shes coming for us all!!!

if I'm never heard from again, you know what happened


She did get magic from discord magic it is so much clearer now


sawtooth waves: i solved pinkie pie

me: * immeadietly clicks*
THE IMPOSSIBLE HAS BECOME POSSIBLE


pinkie and discord have a similar crazy personality, cozy does not. chaos magic has been seen to act with a mind of its own somewhat, mabey it chooses based off of who it likes more?


Pinky isn't an earth pony

She had two magic parents


I have a crazy theory, you had posted a video about how scootaloo can't fly and how Sunny has astral wings, right? So maybe, just maybe, Pinkie Pie is actually an Alicorn. And, you forgot about somepony, Cheese Sandwich. How can you explain him!? He has a cheesy sense ,too. He may be an Alicorn without wings and a horn, too.


Sabooth: I’ve solved pinkie<br>Me: Not possible

Sabooth: I’ve solved pinkie
Me: Not possible


Sorry Bro, this is one of your worst theories.

1. I already don't like the events during the "present" affecting the past
2. The Magic returning to Pinkie could be just an animation choice, Pinkie is the 3rd most "magical" of the group naturally so she would get it, or it could just be the drew straws and she was up. This is your best point though.
3. The Pinkie Sense isn't evidence that a part of her is connected to a different time. It's like if I predicted the winner in a sports match, you wouldn't say that I have a part of me connected to the future, I'd just be lucky. Also if Pinkie really had a part connected to the future where has it been when they could actually use it.
4. PINKIE IS JUST PINKIE


Sawtooth: I may have just solved pinke!
Me: Waaaa!?! Is there such a thing?
Lol


Now the real question, where does that put lil cheese

Neoma Dreamz they are talking pinkie pie and cheese sandwich’s child


sawtooth: i solved pinkie pie<br>pinkameana: I WILL HAUNT YOU

sawtooth: i solved pinkie pie
pinkameana: I WILL HAUNT YOU


Maybe because it was pinkie who had absorbed the chaos magic then, and not being able to contain all of the magic within her vessel some was released and wandered existence finding the first sonic rainboom which may have acted as a beacon attracting the extra chaos magic wandering through existance and entered pinkie pie


But maybe solving villains like I may have a reason why Chrysalis fooled everypony by being Cadence so Chrysalis was a pretty alicorn and the day she saw Shinning armour she fell in love with him but Shinning armour did not take intrest in her he took his love and respect to Cadence and Chrysalis was heartbroken so when it consumed her with sadness and Anger she became Evil and thought of her plan to trap Cadence and Deytsroy her something so she became Cadence's form trapped her and Twilight in the Caves Under Canterlot Then beated of shinning armours love for Cadence and then Celestia wanted a Fight To Protect Every Pony but she failed Chrysalis hat Beaten to much love and then she was to and so OP and then Shinning armour's protection spell wore off while Celestia was on the ground with the tip of her horn black That's why Chrysalis wanted to take over Equestria Buy Chrysali's return is sure to happen would she battle all four Princesses? And take their magic and Deytsroy Equestria? She may do it? Or will she beat Luna and Celestia's love next? With Cadence and Twilight too? Just Sayin she may do it dare it Evil it the only way to reform her to her true self is hard mystery her changeling new form may be the only thing witch works like maybe we must reform her like the other Changelings and Find a sort of spell or crystal and make her her True Pony Self my thought Sawtooth !


My theory: Pinkie is a secret alicorn who disguises herself as an earth poney.


I’ve always agreed with the idea that Party Ponies have their own breed of magic. They are rare, as is their magic. Look at Cheese.


PINKIE PIE AND DISCORD ARE BREAKING THE 4TH WALL, PROVE ME WRONG


Everyone knows that magic is just Binky being Pinky


When cozy took the magic it was only discord’s magic but when pinkie took it celestia and Luna’s magic are also there


Pinkie’s sister also has Pinkie sense (Mod sense) remember?  So that cant be part of Discord’s magic.


Actually it is not discord power because the episode was after Twilight figured out Pinkie pie has pinky sense so it must’ve done something with The element of harmony ,she laughs a lot and also a cutie mark


That means that pinkie pie doesn’t have pinkie sense after that very moment which to me is cool.


S5 E8 pinkie might be conected to ones whom have and still are in stone so maby discord hade a bit of that stone magic in him so it got into grogars bell and pinkie got his magic so she can talk to ones in stone and the last episode in S9 discord helps put them in stone and pinkie talked to the last grifin kings stachue and maby it WAS HIM in stone and at the end his eye shimered or glowed


Everyone is watching you... ( Creepy laughter and creepy finger positions)


Sawtooth waves: I think I finally figured out Pinkie pie.
Me: You can’t figure out Pinkie pie, she’s illogical.
Also me: finishes video  ohhhhhhhhhhh

Sawtooth waves: I think I finally figured out Pinkie pie.
Me: You can’t figure out Pinkie pie, she’s illogical.
Also me: *finishes video*  ohhhhhhhhhhh


Pinkie said that Maud had her own sense as well. Maud had Maud sense and Pinkie had Pinkie sense. So she didn’t get Pinkie sense from Discord’s magic.


Theory: pinkie is some how related to discord like many from  her Nana Pinkie


BUT, she did absorbs his chaos until the final episode 😂😅😅


I think the reason cozy didn't get chaos magic is because she couldn't control it


I think you're wrong cuz pinky was already crazy before this happened so maybe it was something to do with her past or maybe her future 🤔


Sawtooth waves I kind of know something about Twilight and the royal family and the main 6When twilight was big and she had a floating man She had it 2Baby unicorns she just Married a orange pegasus With blue Up line hair and blue eyes and twilight had 2 baby unicorns They were orange orange oranges Purple or blue Well it's Purple and When the baby unicorns grow up both of them were alicorns Cause 1 Of the unicorn twins was older and the other 1 was younger the big 1 had Big legs when she was a grown up like her mom and she had a horn and wings she And Her sister was also an alcorn Well a little Younger And They both have the same Cutie mark With the star well They have the same star on the cutie mark but they're different cause their mom represents the elements of magic and she has it on the Crown her crown And When2 of Her kids1 had a Crown and 1 had a necklace With A Gem Or A. Element Cause I saw a video okay I saw The Royal families flurry heart had a Sister and it was a pegasus and If they're not born At the same time They are still sisters And Guess what something hilarious happened Princess celestia married discord and they had it Chaos baby's And Discord also married Fluttershy It was actually out of my mind and Princess Luna Marry A unicorn it was like king sombra but good A black and blue Lineed Maine and Red eyes it look like king sombra


Omg you're a genius <br>The part that pinky got magic and AJ and rainbow and FSH didn't makes perfect sense but I think it's more then that

Omg you're a genius
The part that pinky got magic and AJ and rainbow and FSH didn't makes perfect sense but I think it's more then that


You forget about Moud sense. Pinkie says that the sense runs in her famili. Sorry about my english, I know it's messy 😅


She can also survive falling with no scrach


There was actually a blooper from equestrian girls, where pony pinkie and human pinkie switched places. Maybe look into that?


You make a compelling argument, but I wouldn’t be me if I didn’t counter it what you’re saying can’t be true, because in a gift for mud pie, pinkie says that the pinky sense or pie sense runs in the family


"Is someone watching me?"
MUHAHAHA

No of course not why would you ever think that 😏


Pinkie also has broken the fourth wall a couple times


Sawtooth Wave s Guess what a bad record recorded the new episode of sunny star scout I think it has been her mother all along Well you'll see in the last part So make A video about it Well There is a bad Unicorn with wings Eyelashe's was green and The bad unicorn with wings said I will take what's mine that's what the bad out corn said so Figure it out


When you said “is someone watching me?”

I felt like someone watching me I always feel like someone is watching me but even more ever since my cat died I think my dead cat is watching me :O

Welldone, now I feel like im being watched.........

...
Is this why I hear strange noises in the night?!!
Now im very scared


Soo pinkie will have a long life like twilight because she has magic?


pinkie was always like that
the time she took discord's magic was in season 9
pinkie was crazy from season 1!


I always saw pinkie pie being pinkie pie when she did unexplainable things, but oh boy when she said “hey discord!” when discord was hiding that even he got surprised and made a wtf face. I was like hold up pinkie pie what are you?? A secret pony goddess wtf


Sawtooth:is someone watching me?

Guys is he talking about us


This pinky has chaos magic theory might also explain why when Discord was freed the first time and it started raining chocolate and stuff Pinky loved it but that could have just been classic Pinkypie


If Pinkie Pie did have her magic stretched out through her timeline, it would explain why Cozy Glow became an alicorn for taking all of the magic at once while Pinkie didn't.


1:51

Literally all your subscribers, Sawtooth!


Sawtooth keep In mind cozy glow only took discords magic and pinkie pie took the Royal sisters magic as well as discords


3:42 sure could be aswell but i'm still conserned of 2:13. it can't be an animation error


I saw the title for the video and I was like what the heck how do you fix pinkie pie


When you theorize a theory before someone else does:

Me: No fair! I made a headcanon on this! (O~O)

Oh boo hoo, someone had their own ideas seperate from yours

Seriously, though. I thought of it months ago.


When Cozy Glow was transformed, she begin an Alicorn, but when Pinkie Pie absorbed caos, she remain a Pony. Also, pinkie pie is how discord, they have the same though and powers. Favourite element of harmonybof discord is laugh.


It's pretty obvious that pinkie pie is the most op earth pony there is. People are missing the fact how pinkie pie was able to control discord's magic even when cozy glow, tirek and chrysalis couldn't.


Ok but what about maud sense. She said it runs through the family.


Ive never seen the last season but im getting like a clovefield paradox vibe..hmmm.. Why pinkie?


1:50 "Is someone watching me?"

* looks at the number of subs *

Na, only 200k people are. It's not a lot.


Discord and Pinky know that they’re on the TV!!


So she couldn't use inponie abilitys and she was normal through out the whole series, but when she absorbed that magic,not change the past so pinkie in the past was able to do crazy things???? Idk if I understand


Now I feel like someones watching ME<br>Bc I hear noises evey night, now im terrified

Now I feel like someones watching ME
Bc I hear noises evey night, now im terrified


discord is a creature made of pure chaos what if the reason why he can control his magic is his chaotic personality because when he tries to act normal he begins to lose his ability to use his magic and begins to fade,  is thanks to fluttershy that acts in a chaotic way that discord can recover thanks to the small chaos that fluttershy made and if we apply that same logic to a being that is even a little chaotic and it takes discords magic that could make possible to that being  to control discord s chaotic magic and taking the magic of discord this could make it possible for that being to be able to control the chaotic magic of discord and if equestria has the same origin as our world that could explain why pink pie is able to do things that defy logic because the moment she takes the magical abilities of discord it became a paradox in which the versions of pink pie that we know they are able to do things that ignore logic in their entirety and by this pink pie made her own future becouse that makes her be her and pink pie didnt show up that kind of abillites until rainbow dash performs sonic rainboom that pink pie was able to use unconsciously a little bit of discord chaotic magic


I love that this dude used the warhammer chaos star as a representation of discords magic. That makes me want to go back and reread one of those Warhammer fortythousand x My Little Pony Friendship is Magic crossovers.


I don’t really know how to explain it but in a summer sun setback discord literally pulls up the fabric of their reality  and stuffs a storm cloud in there soooooooooooo


maybe Pinky is hiding her horns under her curly and crazy hair! haha


As soon as I heard this I thought to myself well this better be good


Holy crud well This is the most earliest for me to click on a video!

New Achievement unlocked! XD


Pinkie also didnt turn into an alicorn where Cozy Glow did.

Pinkie is pony discord.


you know that pinkie pie is a special erath pony she is part of a dracon and her mom is a earth pony but her dad is a dracon her mom name is triple berry pie and her dad name is rhubarb


Sawtooth: Is someone watching me?            Me: You’re a YouTuber!


But how did she get her costume in tardiness when Terkeck said he wouldn’t help them get out


But every member of the Pie family has Pinkie sense Maud shows it in that one Manehatten episode. :<


No because in an episode reveals that pinkie sense runs in the family


They both do that thing where they stand up in space like someone’s watching iS sOmEoNe WaChInG mE!?
Me:yEs We AlL r!
Also I noticed everyone who absorbs the chaos magic gets BIG!!and it’s weird that pinky got magic!


I don't actually agree on this theory as in the episode in season six  the gift for maud pie even maud will get the maud sense that doesn't actually mean that even maud had the chaotic power


I never noticed that pinkie pie got a bit of magic back


Don't forget the fact that Pinkie Pie  was able to control Discord's Choas


Maybe it didnt effect cozy because for some reason pinkie was able to control it


Everyone: Pinkie is pinkie, she will always be mysterious! <br>Sawtooth Waves: Hold my theories. (Or is it)

Everyone: Pinkie is pinkie, she will always be mysterious!
Sawtooth Waves: Hold my theories. (Or is it)


Or pinky pies element is humor. And humorous logic from a cartoon viewpoint! That’s why she talked to “audience” through the screen or when she notices or when someone notices she did something wierd all of a sudden it stops. Like Tom and jerry the car run on the sky then notices it’s defied gravity and falls. Pinky has her own powers from the power of friendship which is cartoon humor!


BUT WAIT,you said pinkie sense is part of her ‘powers’, but in The Gift Of Maud Pie, Maud says their ‘senses ‘ run in the family when she was looking for the pony Pinkie traded her cannon with... so it’s family thing! Just me? Welp.


I just remembered that cheese sandwich also has “pinkie sense” do you think that’s just a script thing or is there a theory for this too? :0

Maud had the same, but it is different depending on the Pony.
I think I recall that being Cheezy sense and Maud sense respectively.
Just too bad we never see another unrelated case, though.


Discord has reality bending powers over all universes since discord him self is a embodiment of chaos in the mlp wold being able to do anything and well pinkie has well 4wall powers which means she could just do anything knowing that she a cartoon being able to what ever she whats btw I think 4wall powers and chaos powers are different is a different think initially


🤔 If the chaos magic were to effect Pinkie's timeline to give her pinkie powers it might have effected cozy glow's timeline to make her turn evil! 👀


When pinkie got her magic back she does'nt have magic its just her cutie mark in that episode every pony had no cutie mark and when pinkie pie got her magic returned to her it was her cutie mark and get her colors back and if she does'nt get that magic back she will be super slow and does'nt blend in to other ponys


why would you care about ponies breaking the laws of physics when ponies with horns can teleport and time travel


Pinkie Pie is the best character besides rarity ❤


Prepare to get hit with a nostalgia train-

“When you’re rife with devastation, there’s a simple explanation; you’re a toy makers creation trapped inside a crystal ball. And whichever way he tilts it, know that we must be resilient. We won’t let them break our spirits as we sing our silly song!”

"when I was a little filly a galloping blaze overtook my city! So they shipped me off to the orphanage said 'ditch those roots if you wanna fit in' so I dug one thousand holes and cut a rug with orphan foals-"


I noticed that when rarity and Twilight have there Magic back, maybe pinkie pie has a secret magic and the weirdest thing is when she jumped in the water she like slowy dont splash, maybe she has a gravity magic


I know why cozy wasn’t effected by the chaos magic it’s because she didn’t want it think about she wanted it taken away but pinkie didn’t she wanted to keep it


Pinky pie: I know what’s happening in the other world.


my dad said "it is just a kids show, the creators definitely did not put this much thot in to it"


But wait, if that magic spread through Pinkie’s entire timeline, then that means that she absorbed the magic twice within her lifetime. Once when the future pinkie did it, and the second time when the actual present pinkie did it.

I am so confused my brain hurts from reading that

Which is why I don’t think this theory would be correct


Yes all of us are watching you everyone on YouTube is watching you... how did it take that long to figure it out?! And you remind me of someone but I don't know who.


Pinkie cannot be explained or solved, Pinkie is Pinkie and will forever be Pinkie UwU

But also I like your theory


and why does scootaloo flap her wings when she scooters, and somehow can get lifted into the air with that? mlp concluded that they she can't fly.

Creator Kid the speed she's going at will put wind under her scooter and it will float

It adds speed and when she jumps it gives her a bit of height.

Chessking E4   She can’t fly cause her wing aren’t stronger and don’t grow like they have to grow
I think that why she don’t live in cloudstale or go whit her parents

Cloudstale: Because she couldn’t fly to get there
Go whit her parents: Because they are constantly in danger and they fly if scottalo go whit they she could probably die

I think she flap her wings because that help her to go faster

@Chessking E4

But if something is wrong with a wand, if it's broken or damaged in some way, then it won't cast magic like normal. I believe the same principle applies to wings in my little pony. Bulk Biceps can fly with magic because his wings aren't stunted, they only look that way. Presumably before he got so buff, his wings were normal.

It's just not believable that Scootaloo not believing she can fly would actually effect her ability to do so. Pegasi can fly as babies, so we know it's not an age thing. Scootaloo, were she able to fly, would've been doing so since before she could remember. There is simply no way a school aged pegasus would believe themselves unable to fly without some kind of evidence. If she was born like that, she's probably tried multiple times before going to a doctor and learning she can't fly. If it's the result of an accident, she may remember a time when she could fly, and if she was in denial, she'd keep trying to fly before learning she really couldn't anymore.

Plus, we have evidence that she believed she could fly. In flight to the finish.

@J. C. We can that regardless  of the way the wings develope that a pegasus can fly regardless of their shape.  Look at Bulk Biceps.  There is no way according to the laws of physics he can fly but not only does he fly, he's able to contribute to the creation of a tornado. This proves it is the magic from within making this possible.  The wings act as a foci much like a wand or an incantation does for a hermetic mage. Also there's no way RD can reach the speeds that she does through the laws of physics. She does this through magic and I would say she has a lot of it. I wonder if she'll develop the infinite hoof punch like the Flash?

@Chessking E4

She can't fly. It's most likely a physical issue, not a magic issue. We see that she can hover, but only when highly excited. Her magic works like normal otherwise: walking on and manipulating clouds like any other pegasus. If her issue were magic based, she would not be able to do that either. When she becomes an adult, her wings don't grow in proportion to the rest of her. This detail leads me too believe that, for whatever reason, her wings are stunted and that's why she can't fly. Maybe it's genetic, or the result of an accident, or some unknown disease.

She can fly but has convinced herself that she can't. Her magic obeys her will. It's much like how if someone truly thinks they're blind, they won't see no matter how healthy their eyes really are. When she gives up the lie, then she will fly.

@MaskedRedstonerProZ  she can give more air time like early birds

she can't fly , but flapping her wings helps her ride her scooter


Spoken like a true FOB Equestria/Fiery Joker fan


She can go in creepypasta  dimension  if she want  to relax


But, Cheese Sandwhich has a Cheesy Sense????


0:07 don't they all Pull objects out of thin air?

ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽


If this is true when how did it happend in the first place 🤔


I think it’s because pinkie could control the magic and cozy couldn’t wich is actually better and is going through the time line


Maybe discord left a lil bit of his magic in her....


Look like pinkie pie and discord really have a connection. When pinkie pie absorbed discord's magic there's a lighting thing around her which cozy glow didn't have, like cozy glow absorbed the magic but didn't connect to her but when pinkie pie absorbed the magic it really connected into her.


Yes, someone is watching you. Us.<br>[INSERT EVIL LAUGH]

Yes, someone is watching you. Us.
[INSERT EVIL LAUGH]


Pinkie does has some type of power cuz when we see her in the future see is still the same pinkie where the other ponies have changed like rarity have some white strapes on her tail and hair and all the others changed and were not that hygenic where pinkie still was soooooooooooooo happy excited its like she did not grow at allllll and when we see her on the movie where twillight loses her crown the human pinkie knows everything and when twillight comes back the "PONY" pinkie knew everything from the human world the human pinkie and the pony pinkie have some type of connection and both of them have some connection with the past and future too.


Cheese sandwich had cheese senses, i think party ponies has their own senses like pinkie and cheese.<br>I need a video why party ponies have senses 🧐

Cheese sandwich had cheese senses, i think party ponies has their own senses like pinkie and cheese.
I need a video why party ponies have senses 🧐


That explains everything about her but she came from a family with grayish color and she is pink so I don’t understand why she is the only person in her family that is pink and the rest is grayish it might have to do with something with the magic she might have.


I personally think that wasn't intentional. but i REALLY like the idea and feel like it should be true, so i'm gonna treat it like it is. :3


I think pinkie got her powers from the rainboom because everyone did twilight got very powerful,rainbow dash got speed powers,rarity got her diamond powers,apple jack got strength and fluttershy got speaking to animals power so pinkie got pinkie powers


I think think that pinkly pie had nowhere to store discord’s caous magic because she is a earth pony


She also gets the alicorns power in that bell


I support your thinking but in the episode ticket master when they get the tickets at the end the tikets float over their heads but not for spike can you make a video about that please.


Sawtooth: is some one watching me!!<br>Me: YES! where WaTcHiNg YoU SaWtOoTh

Sawtooth: is some one watching me!!
Me: YES! where WaTcHiNg YoU SaWtOoTh


I believe that pinkie pie is a anomaly that can control chaos essence


Sawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?!<br>Me: yes. Infect if no one is watching you than why are you saying your theories out loud?

Sawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME?!
Me: yes. Infect if no one is watching you than why are you saying your theories out loud?


Hi i'm milka. The first time i see this video, i was shock. I agree about this pinkie pie sense, but i think pinkie pie sort way back discord magic. Thats just my theori about pinkie pie and discord magic.


1:50 Yes. Over 430,000 people were watching you.


I just love pinkie pie. We need more people like her. Oops I mean ponies 😌

Me to Pinkie pie is my favorite character


But didn't pinkie pie take discord magic at the last episode before  Twilight become the ruler


some years ago:
dad: your just like her
me: ok

Me now: watching this video
oh wow, i really am like her.

some years ago:
dad: your just like her
me: ok

Me now: *watching this video*
oh wow, i really am like her.


It's actually My Little Pony Equestria Girls bloopers. Hope you watch it. It might help you.


Kinda late and u probably won’t see this but if I remember correctly during a episode maud shows that she has her own maud sense proving that this theory couldn’t be possible


Then how does Maud pie do the same thing<br>Pinkie even said that it runs in the family

Then how does Maud pie do the same thing
Pinkie even said that it runs in the family


"Is someone watching me?!?!?!"

Yeah

100k people to be exact


I personaly dont agree buts its a great theory.<br>my theory is that there is soe type of chaos like discord inside her, that she was just born with like discord. she has some of the same powers. :3

I personaly dont agree buts its a great theory.
my theory is that there is soe type of chaos like discord inside her, that she was just born with like discord. she has some of the same powers. :3


I know this took a lot of effort but what about when pinkie pie traded her party cannon and mod found the pony and rarity asked how she found him she said "mod scenes" pinkie said it runs in the faimly


0:08 Um did u forget that she can break the fourth wall?


You may have noticed already bur im gonna say it anyways, 1:31 , true but in the episode where spike becomes greedy and its his birthday (i think its season 2? Idk), he and rarity was floating in mid air! 1:49 , in the episode mare do well, rainbow dash winked at us, knowing we r there. 2:18, maybe its a mistake? I honestly think pegasus and earth ponies should have that thing too. Pinkie sense is prob a genes (or what ever) from the family. Im saying that pinkie pie is prob made like that to show humor and extra ordinary/exaggeration from what you can do irl. Honestly, if i was a creator of a series, i could make many mistakes. Sometimes i forgot what happened to the characters i created! Its just an opinion btw! Thanks for reading!


Sawtooth, you broke one of the most important rules! That is Pinkie Pie shall not be questioned.


Of course pinkie would have her own magic, she is one of the only characters that break the fourth wall.<br>(Discord)

Of course pinkie would have her own magic, she is one of the only characters that break the fourth wall.
(Discord)


I thought you were gonna say pinkie was a god lol


The reason why cozyglow may have not got the magic is because she already had magic or only earth ponies can absorb magic

Idk UwU


Pinkie is completely weird by herself.First,her family not so energetic like Pinkie.Kinda negative and spends time with stones.Why did Pinkie didn't spend time with stone?Just a rainbow can't change her.Also her family generally have faded colors.Except for Pinkie.She is pink.Her hair goes fluffy when she's happy when she's sad her hair go straight.I think she was having a little power maybe when born.But we can't know more.Why she was having power when born,not another pony?Can we say why Fluttershy can communicate with plants and animals but not another pony.What caused Pinkie to have powers?Maybe something happened,so much positive energy uploaded in Pinkie?Maybe...But I think Pinkie's power get crazier when she take discords all power.


@Ur local sociopath Yeah I expected that.

Pony’s are still creatures

Also, don’t whoosh me. I know this wasn’t that type of joke.


I like pinkie pies mysterious craziness but sure explain it


cozy glow was never chaotic to begin with tho think about pinkie is so chaotic with actions and in her mind but cozy never had that


Him trying to explain Pinkie:
Me: oh no, NO IF U DO DAT THE UNIVERSE WILL EXPLODE

Him trying to explain Pinkie:
Me: *oh no, NO IF U DO DAT THE UNIVERSE WILL EXPLODE*


Three actually a comic that pinke pie fall into the chaos world and was able to control and to be honest cesltia seems a little bit too friendly with discrord she likes exvtiment and to be honest I mean discrord wasn't that evil he didn't want to kill anyone even in his first appearance twkigt said he didn't play fair but he did and what would be more chaotic then controlling chaos its self and useig it for a force for good


It would explain the way Discord can sense when there is a magical imbalance, thats where the Pinkie sense came from.


Pinkies just this one character that breacks the 4th wall just like sans from undertale or william/glichtrap from fnaf im not sure about it tho


wait...but didn't the discord magic absorbing thingi happen in the last episode?


i know why pinkie had the magic spread throw out her time line

pinkie pie is a teen or an adult
while
cozy glow is a child
the age makes a diferance


Maybe she got these powers cause she got power of discord AND the alicorn power. Maybe thats why?


Or she's a rogue changeling who feeds on smiles instead of love.

She spreads smiles not feed on them,but it is interesting 🤔🤔🤔


Remember cheese sandwiche’s cheesy sense


i used to think that pinkie pie was a pszchic since she knows when things ae going to happen


Ok i get it. But did you forgot about the rainbow..... The six ponies ware conected by it, so it coud affact pinky some how . Think about it 😉


Pinkie pie secretly a unicorn? .-. CONSPIRACIES!!!!! GET OUT OF MY BRAIIIIN!!!!


It's a family thing, I think perhaps Pinkie Sense was a family thing BUT maybe it was amplified to a more adavanced version of Pinkie Sense with Discord's magic. My theory, if you have your own comment it.


maby pinkie pie has an in grown horn or a tumor. some tumors can grow there own teeth and organs. or pinkie is the story teller.


But what about spike when he pulled out an umbrella out of thin air when he save the crystal empire the second time and it disappeared


I love your YouTube channel I love your theories but some of your theory for Philly some people think that Pinkie Pie is actually a changeling working for Christmas to take down the others but would that be true no


Pink and green colours for the hair and a lot 😍on her hair and the second 😍💖✨her eyes 👀the first of her 😍and the first interview went well I think she is fine 🙂I hope it goes OK 👌I will share it with her 😊she will reveal 😊her back to me with the best possible outcome 😊☺💖and I will call 📞tomorrow to arrange for them 😊...


Finally, some creature solves the mystery behind Pinkie Pie.


Pinkie pie is the real lord of chaos and I refuse to believe otherwise


Does anyone realize that in the time that pinky does not have magic she does not defy logic


sawtooth please talk about zicorah's home land


hehehehe she knew us when nopony else did.


AND in season 6 episode 3 maud showcases similar abilities


Pinkie all ready got the magic because when she got discord magic it was in the future  not long befor twilight became a princess


Him: Wait...IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!!???<br>Me: yes Us

Him: Wait...IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!!???
Me: yes Us


"I accidentally created an alternate timeline!"