Ok so I have an idea what if it was because when pinkie got the magic taken away from her it was discord who took it who his of course the owner of his own magic bug when it was taken away from cosy glow it wasn't taken away by the original owner,discord,or I'm just wrong and it has nothing to do that also discord did take his magic back after he got it back from pinkie maybe that also affects it


Was pinkiepie doing impossible things before she got magic from grogars bell?


Pinkie knows about what happened in the other world because her and her other self kept swapping


You know how when cozy glow took away all the magic and star swirl said that all to magic be be gone for good after the 3rd sun set? But doesn't celestia raise and set the sun then she could of just not set the sun until the figured out a way to fix if


Pinkie has chaos magic you are right. Or else when twilight sparklers got the crown from the other world how could pinkie know the both pinkie  in the 2 worlds  have chaos.


So basically Pinkie is the Scarlet Witch and Discord is Cthon.


what if discord turned into this creature but was actually a pony who was pinkie's brother?


Hey sawtooth, what if pinkie IS DISCORDS DAUGHTER!!!!!


My notification bell:

News, sports, etc

Me: whatever

My notification bell: My Little Pony

Me: Clicks right away to this video

Same but I react like that to Techno blade's videos too

Me when I see theory videos about anything:"I don't need sleep,I need answers"


that kinda explains how pinkypie can magicaly pull things out of her hair. Sorry for bad grammer!


There is one problem, in a episode with mod she says she says she has mod sense and it runs in the family maybe it’s something to do with when pinky was not born yet I don’t know what do you think


what if pinky pie is always on the positive side to hide the pain like a fake smile.


" Yoshi darklord" Once I have a patreon I'm gonna name me that


Well maybe its because cosy already had magic but pinkie didn't so the magic stayed


Cozy Glow when got discord power. She didn't use the power but when pinky got it ,she use the power to make chocolate rain. That's what different I think..


Maybe pinkie pie got the magic because she did the spell without a horn and cozy glow didn’t get the magic because it was activated with evil magic


What if one cosy glow steeled on The magic from Equestria pinky got magic but the magic was her pinky sense


I think pinkie pie always had caos magic on her own.


Um well Pinky had some lightning when she got bigger, but cozy did not.


I mean..cozy glow couldn't control it while pinkie could. The fact that she is chaotic already before the magic hit her is a point that I think breaks that theory.  But I'm just a kid so what do I know?


When I found out Sawtooth Waves calls Pinkie Pie a creature:

Pinkie Pie only pretends to be Pony, or it is what your eyes makes up when you can't comprehend what you see?<br>Clasical for higher beings.

Pinkie Pie only pretends to be Pony, or it is what your eyes makes up when you can't comprehend what you see?
Clasical for higher beings.


I think she got her esence from chaos magic cause she was an earth pony and earth ponys arent as magical as pegasi and before u say pegasi dont have magic they kinda do cause there flying ability’s can be removed so they have some sort of magic so since pegasi have more magic than earth ponies cozyglow was able to handle the magic more than pinky


If we never hear about him anymore we know what happened


i think the sonic rain boom its because it might have made pinkie the way she was


PLS READ THIS!!!!!
This theory could be possible but what about the human world? There is no chaos magic that I know of in the human world. I think it is just pinkie. For example, maybe she is just way smarter than the rest since she can tell that someone is watching.
For her pinkie sense, Celestia has a similar system but just you can't see it. For example, Pinkie Pie's tail wiggles when something is going to fall. Celestia just feels it like how she felt that Luna would come back soon.
For Pinkie's magic, I think the magic was her pinkie sense or maybe her craziness. And One more fact, Mood, Pinkie pie’s sister has mood sense too.

Now for my theory...
I think pinkie should be an alicorn since she is like the element of happiness or laughter maybe she should be the princess of happiness since that is a relationship-ish. maybe she could spread happiness. Pinkie should also be an alicorn because she would be the first earth pony to be an alicorn.


Yes I think it's also weird but I don't think it's from discords Magic do you remember the episode when she went crazy cuz she thought her friends didn't like her anymore and you saw those split colors due


If pinkie took all that magic and it spread why didn’t cozy have this energy and btw pinkie pie was able to control the magic so it must be something else


Maybe pinky got those powers because she is an earth pony. Did you ever hear a earth pony becoming an alicorn? Cozy Glow may have become what she was because she's a Pegasus.


In the episode the one where pinkie pie knows She was able too fall apart and put her self back together agian like discord can do


Just like what another character I konw said aubot chaos magic:

Chaos keeps everyone guessing.


DISCORD AND PINKIE PIE BROKE THE FOUTH WALL or is it the third wall?


Pinkie actually fell into discrord World after tirek stole his power and he got IT bsbk he was having ttihlne useing his power and pinke found her way into his dimseon and figured out the rules of chaos chaos magic actually has very specific rules and rewuere conctrstin


Actually you forgot that maud also had her own pinkie sense she has maud sense


Did you know that in MY little pony equestria girls at the end of one of the movies pinkie pie switched places with the pony pinkie pie so there could be something that pinkie pie already new about the portal to equestria high before twilight did


Wait cosy glow obsorbed magic and grew taller mabey this is a way alicorns work?


I think i know how she got her powers she got it from the rainbow we she was a kid / filly she was not her crazy self but when she saw the rainbow some thing happened she gang happiness she also ganged power what kind you ask chaos thats why she has pinkie sense she could she the future that's her power seeing the future that's why she wants to spread Joy  she wants to share her power but how how did one rainbow give her power discord now here me out think about it discord is the king of chaos pinkie is chaos could there be a connection between them?? You tell me do you think i am right ?


Actually no<br>She was like that before we even knew discord

Actually no
She was like that before we even knew discord


Mkay

I’m mostly “phsycic”

I can sing Gypsy bard fast

It’s like I’m on adrenaline all the time

And my friends call me pinkie

Am I pinkie!?


Pinkie pie 🥧  is my favorite character from my little pony because she is funny 😄


Sawtooth waves: I solved pinkie pie                                                                                Twilight: <b>I would like be your sister now</b>                                                                                Edit: I typed so fast that there were grammar mistakes XD

Sawtooth waves: I solved pinkie pie                                                                                Twilight: *I would like be your sister now*                                                                                Edit: I typed so fast that there were grammar mistakes XD


Can you do a video about the two sister princesses how they got the magic in the cutie mark🦄🦄


Oh and how she knows is her tail is moving like crazy😎


Ok what about Cozy absorbing Discords Chaos magic


Hi Sawtooth Waves my name is Olympia and I really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really like your videos I watch finally solving pinkie pie and How discord came to be and Flurry Hearts future and the truth about stars Swirl and finally solving alicorns and how king Sombra lost his wings will for little bit of that It was a littleToo Scary because of the music for how king sombra lost his wings I also watched Finally solving delacour The alicorn ambulance And it was so much fun and Queen chrysalis and Not a true Alcorn And How did the trail of harmony Really really died And Are there other Alicorns and did celestia release Nightmare moon And I am already watching finally solving pinkie pie right now and I'm at The white and blue swirling  eyes  part And I Am With the silly bird And your videos are getting a lot funnier Make sure to bring more new videos and I will watch them see you


After seeing pinkie

Im wondering if she's adopted from the pies
Honestly i wouldn't be suprised if she were froms ome other race of cgaos ponies


but that was before pinky absorbed discord 's magic that was in the end and that you showed was only in like the school of friendship and not close to the end end


2:50
How do you explain that the rest of her family has sense too like Maud sense and Maud teleports too


Sawtooth: Is someone watching me? <br>Me: YOUR ON YOUTUBE OFCOURSE THERE ARE PEOPLE WACTHING YOU

Sawtooth: Is someone watching me?
Me: YOUR ON YOUTUBE OFCOURSE THERE ARE PEOPLE WACTHING YOU

۞𝔾𝕖𝕠𝙱𝚕𝚘𝚡𝟓𝟕𝟒۞


What episodes at 1:44 is he talking about? I’m binging my little pony: friendship is magic for the 20th time and I don’t know what episodes he is talking about


i like the pinkie has choas magic theory its fun and understandible


No!!!!! we still don’t know the connection between Applejack Pinkie pie, I believe pinky pie is an orphan and something like discord is her parent


I thing pinkie absorbing discords magic in future is the cause for her cutie mark and her enthusiasm.<br>Because pinkie is totally different from her family. When pinkie was a filly 8n her family there was no talking and no smiling and all of a sudden she became a party pony.

I thing pinkie absorbing discords magic in future is the cause for her cutie mark and her enthusiasm.
Because pinkie is totally different from her family. When pinkie was a filly 8n her family there was no talking and no smiling and all of a sudden she became a party pony.

I love pinkie, separate thing: I saw a video saying "Chaotic and spontaneous things you can do to be spontaneous" I watched the video and went "non of that's spontaneous, I already do all that without thinking anything of it."


He asked if someone's watching me yes I'm watching you right now


but what about cheesy-sense and maud-sense??


Pinkie pie is a god that has exsisted since the beginning of time and will be the end of it


What about cheese sandwitch he also has some kinda sense


PINKIE PIE 🎈🎈🎉🎊🎊🎉🍰🎂🥞🍥

PINKIE PIE 🎈🎈🎉🎊🎊🎉🍰🎂🥞🍥


Tirek maybe a century to millenia old but pinkie is more mysterious


Sawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!?<br>Me: you our telling a theory to YouTube what do you think

Sawtooth: IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME!?
Me: you our telling a theory to YouTube what do you think


no i dont think it the magic because this magic come after a long time and the powers of pinkie or crazyness started when the show started so i do not think it is the magic


she’s not a regular poney she’s more like discord and what he is


Without her laughter she would have no magic and I mean ...NO MAGIC✨

Not really. Remember Season 8 Yakity-Sax? She turned into Pinkamena but she somehow has a weird power to make plants magically die, or make balloons deflate.
Is that magic or what?

Laughter doesn't only exists in Pinkie, they can be inside of everyone. If you're only the representative of it then why should you have magic but the others don't?


Probably pinkie is Pinkamena in a nice and crazy form


Why do only spike have a magical fire breath but not the other dragon's ?


Maby its conected to her family if celestia can give her magic to twilight for ruling pinkies father also can look at him he weres a cap maby he is a unicorn and gave some of his magic to his daughter 🤣+🤪+🙃+😪=pinky pie


1:15 hey! I know that song that’s “Toccata and Fugue in D minor” by J.S. Bach! That’s my favorite song by Bach


What if pinkie got the powers before the show began that would explain why the magic came back and more importantly pinkie was able to use discord’s magic wich would not make sense otherwise


Am I the only one who is 16, and still watches this almost every day...? Just a question ... how old are you?


a  moment of chaos pure power distrubuted along her. and pinkies the sort like meand you, she wouldnt say it was a problem or abnormal<br>she would litterally live and work with theses powers

a  moment of chaos pure power distrubuted along her. and pinkies the sort like meand you, she wouldnt say it was a problem or abnormal
she would litterally live and work with theses powers


Is it just me or is there people out there that like both Mlp and Star Wars?


That’s just pinkie being pinkie and the pinkie sense runs in the pie family


Sawtooth: is somebody watching me??!?!?<br>Me: ern that's what a YouTube channel is

Sawtooth: is somebody watching me??!?!?
Me: ern that's what a YouTube channel is


Well I think pinkie is pinkie because she was like that before she got discords magic 🤔 I might be wrong


Have u ever nosied the birth of a pony is always lighter then the parents like star lights parents flerry heart that piney who is yellow and likes books that I forgot the name of please do a video on this :p

No XD I mean sunburst, I just when to mlp to check XD


In season 5 epidpde 7 pinkie notices discord when he'is a box and says "Hi discord!"And he is shocked so i think ypur theory is right


Thats just them pulling a deadpool and breaking the fourth wall


I think discord and pinky pie are the first changelings to be made. And they are trying to take over to land. If they make session 10.


Plot twist : <b>Pinkie Pie only use 1% of her happiness</b>

Plot twist : *Pinkie Pie only use 1% of her happiness*


I think when pinkie was born someone or discord had put chaos magic into pinkie that results in what happened inthe future


Pinkies secretly an Alicorn using magic to hide her wings and horn


But how did pinkie pie control the power not like cozy here’s my theory she already had caos like discord when she got her cutie mark so more of that caos magic will be ok that’s why cozy  could not control caos magic like pinkie oh and did you notice cozy became a giant alicorn while pinkie didn’t well i think caos magic makes the user bigger in size  but discord is like a container of the magic so he doesn’t get bigger in size


Hey, not just Pinkie have Pinkie Sense, her sister, Maud,. had Maud Sense. I think it developed from her family.


pinky did not get her weard power from the bell with discord power


Sawtooth waves-  IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME

me- YES THER IS SOMEONE WATCHING YOU WE ALL ARE WATCHING YOU TUH...!!!


Pinkie pie doesn’t look like discord because at season 2 discord can change the mane five opposite selves but pinkie can’t do that kind of stuff


Nope your going at this all the wrong way pinkie is simply an <b>almighty being</b>

Nope your going at this all the wrong way pinkie is simply an *almighty being*


When he said IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME yes we are watching u


i think pinkie got all of this power from discord


This is suspicious but I want to tell pinkie that she is the element of laughter I think she is doing this something to make us laugh


Maybe cozy glow did not get affected because she is a Pegasus and pinky got it because she was an earth pony with no magic.


Petition for Sawtooth to do a face reveal at 300k:
I
I
V


When you said: is someone watching me?
Bruh.
So many people are watching you.


I like pinkie she’s just so crazy 'n' cute


Wait remember the rocks on pinkie’s past that must be discord’s magic!

Wait so what if pinkie was cozy glow all along because they Both use discord’s magic


hwo many times you rewatch this i didn't even see that


But wait.... That could explain the pinkie sense but there was a mention of a maud sense


This is the end of the last season she can not  carry magic throo time


When u said "is someone watching me?" Well yes duh


Yay pinkie is my favorite cuz she is just so cute amazing and everything


farfetch! that's a good Pokemon you got one? I'll trade you for my Raichu


Sawtooth waves:  pinky and discord do the same thing like when they stare off to space
Like someone is watching them…… is someone watching me!?!
Me: yeah all your subscribers and probably other people who don’t subscribe and me so yes there’s probably tons of people watching you.
Lol I found that funny!


That would be true but we don’t know that pinkie or discord get there magic zapped away


Is someone watching me?!

359,013 people: No?


remember that pinkie sense is par of family


Coazy Glow use The Chaos magic to became a huge alicorn. On The other side pinkie remain an earth pony


you know i just think there is no explenation to what happened in mlp gen4


Why is None Talking about that Pinkie is pink and the rest of her family is grey? Im getting a Felling that Shes adopted...please talk about this in a video

She's like the extravert born in an introverted family. Still genetically like them, but different behavior.

Yeah she always had that crazy pink so maybe she is Mrs. Cake and Mr. Cakes daugter that got put for adoption because her parents were too young

She became pinkier after she gained her cutie mark.


Buy pinkie was always chaotic not after when she absorbd discord magic


Well why i think pinkie pie is a anomaly is no one but discord can control his magic so pinkie pie has been braking the 4th wall


If that was the case then why did Pinkie Pie say Pinkie Pie scenes and Maude said it was mod sense pinky said it ran in the family then how does that logic work


One does not simply understand Pinkie Pie


Pinkie epsorbed discord's  magic that's my theory


When Sawtooth said IS SOMEONE WATCHING ME I was like ÿEs tHus įŠ yOutÛbÊ


Sawtooth:is someone watching me?!?!

Me:Naw no one watching you 😏🍝


What do you think your right Pinky Pi is having the same Chaos magic


That happened in the last episode of the series sawtooth that dosent make any sense you did not solve pinkie pie


“Is someone watching me?!” Yes, yes indeed. Ur fans are watching u


I think she got her powers from the sonic rainbow


Everybody knows you're being watched you're on YouTube


You said wait is someone watching me? And I was like yes someone is watching you us


I really hate “I’m first” comments like nobody really cares stop bragging

Ali-Mery I don’t hold any disrespect upon people who like “oh I’m first” comments

Lisa’s hater club I love and like every single I’m first comments

@May-Nimari bruh. What if the "first" is too much on the first second? Im sure youtuber can detect the first coment using something because "first" never be 1 coment

@May-Nimari that's very kind of you but I don't understand what you're saying...

I'm sure if there were a prize you would do it.

@Michael Jacksons Biggest Fan Gacha Life and more! I was just saying. is everything okay?

I Agreed. can't we all just get along and just appreciate that we come to a video at different points of time?

I also hate these “I’m early for once comments”

everyone is early at least ONCE, so don’t even tell that lie.

I also hate these “I’m early for once comments”

*everyone is early at least ONCE, so don’t even tell that lie.*

Maddie Tha gacha lover roblox player Vlogs and fun!


You miss a clue when sunset shimmer touched pinkie and saw what was inside her head and If you don't know who sunset shimmer is she is in equestria girls


I don’t get it he just said pinky got her powers just because of that episode and that was like The second final episode😂


I think it has to be a connection with Pinkie pie’s cutie mark and laughter element of harmony so pinkie Love balloons and her cutie mark is balloons and The element has powers she is the spirit of laughter so she has Pinkie sense because ,in my little pony a new generation there is three crystals earth pony Crystal , The Pegasus crystal and the unicorn crystal so just because earth ponies don’t have the magic and can’t fly they do have a power and the only earth pony has a power is Pinkie pie


I don’t think this is true because if she got her power and season nine how did she get it on the other seasons


Remember when Discord said his fav element is pinkies in beginning of s 2?

oc Laughing would suit Discords personality but also Pinkies. May he felt the chaosmagic in Pinkie but just a theory.


forget the mane 6 and their dragon the are just not required anymore.


you know how the ever free has givein berth to whered crechers        <br>*hint: shes one

you know how the ever free has givein berth to whered crechers
*hint: shes one


Pinkie pie is already have powers in the beginning of the episode bro can you shill first bro


And acorn shining armor that's part of this big message


Does mop have a villain who’s name is lord darker


Its so satidwhen I watch random videos and hear ksp music.


I think because pinkie is just chaos alone kinda she changed the time line cuz it’s pinkie don’t question it


Pinkie absorbed princess magic 2. Cozy did not


Chocolate Rain Brings down <i>___</i> ask me on comments to do the full song

Chocolate Rain Brings down _____ ask me on comments to do the full song


NOPE I SHALL NEVER WITNESS THIS VIDEO EVER AGAIN


Twilight would go barzer she'll be like "SAWTOOTH  YOU WILL PAY FOR THIS"!!!!


In the episode where Pinkie Pie goes to Manhattan Mod says the she has Mod sense and it runs in the family. However pinkie pie has more than just pinkie sense.


I think earth ponies have magic but in different ways and pinkie’s magic is.... u know.... pinkie


Watch double rainboom it might give u some answers.


She didt because in the season where everyone gets there magic back from cozy globe she been haveing magic ether or with out her elemant or discords magic first came cozyglobe stealing magic and pinkie pie gets her magic back then she got discords magic when kingsobra broke the elemants of harmeny pinkie pie lost her happy power and when her friends said chear  us up because they were sad of the elemants of harmeny she says sorry i cant feel it there is nothing funny about these sorry and you mite not know these but in every ipisode love happyness abd hate magic can go to diferent universes and know alat about every ones lives thats all i got


The difference between pinkie and cozy is cozy was an alicorn when she got the caos magic and pinkie was and earth pony I guess earth pony’s have magic to


When pinky turns in to the crazy  & giant pinky I saw grogars bell on it


“i could transform the cosmos so everything is made of icing”<br>that is why chaos magic is the most powerful magic could ever exist

“i could transform the cosmos so everything is made of icing”
that is why chaos magic is the most powerful magic could ever exist


Haha i proved ye theory wrong my evidence is Cheese Sanswitch!


Actually this pinkie sense runs in the family maud has maud sense


idk, maybe a horn is just hiding in her puffy mane lol
jkjk
or am i ?


what if pinkie, from the other world created discord


Cool theory but in the gift of the maud pie. Maud has pinkie sense or rather maud sense. So does that mean the pie family have secret super powers


the reason cozy didn't get chaos magic is because when pinkie absorbed discords magic celestia and luna's magic was in the bell

But we're talking about chaos magic here.....which only brings us to Discord


Pinkie said that the sense runs in the family like maud sense


Think how pinkie pie might be a different tribe I mean she’s not like a usual earth pony


when all they magic was gone pinky pie was laghfing


Hi Sawtooth Waves I was too busy yesterday to text you So I'm doing it now And I really really really really really really like finally solving pinkie pie is there 1 that is called Finally solving twilight or fluttershy  or Rainbow —dash   or Applejack Well I don't know If there we are not there or not Cause I think that So what are you doing thinking Videos of something cause I don't know when They are going to come i Really really really Want new videos To come now I cannot Just watch the same ones All over and over again cause I just watched 1 video and I Don't know what it wasDon't know what it was calledDon't know what it was called But it was 1 of your Videos and It will come Next friday It already past The next friday And your videos are super duper very very very very very really really really really really really really really really Fun well When I was watching How King sombra lost his wings I was scared of it because of the music and the red circling And it happened In the alcorn Ambulance video I also watched twilight killed the real pinky it was like hilarious cause I just watched it in my mom's room on the TV We were trying to find relaxing fish music but then when we were trying to find it my sister said All of your My little pony videos that I watched And we watched The future of flurry heart and Twilight killed the real pinky It was totally hilarious Cause when we were about to click it to watch it twilight zapped the real pinky and she was like a big circle and it was super hilarious Here is a joke what do you call twilight eating a pie? Cause she went to the Lamp drum Ticket Lamp drum tickets all in 1 word It's just a joke you know Cause You should have make more videos about Flurry heart And princess cadence and I know who the secret Alcorn Princess Is She Has Dark dark dark purple and Dark pink swirl Hair and she has white and her legs are big like princess celestia And she has A. Snowflake cutie mark And A purple eye Or blue and You just have to go to search And Go to speaker and say who is the secret Alcon princess and You just have to watch it and see well I don't know Princess Cadence's Dad is cause I don't know when I'm gonna watch it Later something Cause I'm going to be texting you a big message and I'm already doing it now I know how to spell these words With this speaker that I am speaking at it makes it to Easy then Typing I just wrote then With typing It only had a few words I hope you get this message Well it has too many words Just take your time to Read it and Make a very very very good video with no villains or scary music Only with A very good ponies See you tomorrow!!!!!!!! And I am Olympia See you soon!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


but what about Maud sense see didn't absorb discords magic


Does talking ponies exist? Well I know they don't well my sister thinks everything is real


ok listen how bro come on if she can do that then how did she do it in the past huh.


I think she can see the future like she did know what all happend in Mlp eg and when twilight came back......


Know i kinda get why some people think discords favorite element was pinkie pie i though it was fluttershy but i kinda get it know and I also think that discord favorite element is pinkie pie i agree with it NOT A SHIP LIKE EWWW


What if Pinky exactly The Reincarnation of Chaos incase Discord Conan will come back the universe made Pinky chaotic future oh-so really good but that's far-fetched


omg three ponys got magic and  tripill cuti marks


I  love it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! But Pinkie did'nt seem the least bit chaotic before she got her cutie mark.


But can't you remember pinkie seanse runs in the family


Pinky pie's parents where accused of witch craft and got hung she's a gypsy or a witch 🤦♂🤦♀


Hi you now that's a very good point I thought it was true but now I don't think it's true you know why because pinky sense isn't only at Pinkie Pie we saw the same in rainbow Dash's birthday cheese sandwich has the same thing he just names it cheesy sense but it's still with a good point of view


“ like there being watched” <br>Me: crap there on to us!

“ like there being watched”
Me: crap there on to us!


It’s like they know there in a tv show 👁👄👁


We know that pinkie does things which are out of this world and theirs tooooo . There could be something linked with this event that this event made every single pinkie , pinkie clones and human pinkie magical as in Equestria girls 1 ; Pinkie guesses twilight is a princess even without magic in that world !!! This theory could be a very strong probability to pinkies pinkiness

It may also effect her family aka Maud syas she has some type of maud sense and then pinkie says " It runs in the family " I really dont know weather she was joking or she was saying it in real


But that happened when twily became an alicorn


You actually wrong she could control bescue she used in his Chris dimseon


In season 1 when pinkies mane goes not poofy we see that she has a turnip bucket. But then in mlp eg spring breakdown we see pony twilight showing human rainbow and twilight and sunset shimmer a table of mysteries stuff, And one of them was the turnip bucket, It could be that pinkies got power to make stuff go crazy like discord who made a teacup with wings.


How could chaos magic be the answer not only pinkie pie got pinkie sense but cheese sandwich have cheese sense but he did not get chaos magic inside him so then maybe pinkie is from a magic family and what about if pinkie have a long lost sister and she was a unicorn she went to the unicorn school and she tried her magic so she could get in but she made a blast and this spell she tried to do could have got in her that where it starts and she was older than pinkie and her sister that could be the truth


Yes but there’s nothing to be afraid of.


But in an episode pinkie tells us that mud also has pinkie sense our mud sense


I think it didn't affect it cuz soon after she got turned to stone and that's why pinky got a different effect but then again pinky just Pinky don't even ask


We are watching you because you’re recording remember


I like just saying Pinkie Pie <br>no other pony is mnet to be spokin of.

I like just saying Pinkie Pie
no other pony is mnet to be spokin of.


i dont think so mad has mad sens and she did not get caos magic and pinkiy said ' it runs in the family


Actuly this makes scens but are we shure pinkie only obsorbed discord’s magic what about grogars cozy probably studied more about artifacts than pinkie I mean you probably want information to drain magic with artifacts so she probably had information on the bell before realizing the artifact would be impossible to get so she was slightly more carful with the magic and what would you expect from pinkie


Can you feature in my next mlp video? We will sing a true true friend with others😀


But pinkie absurb discord magic after cozy glow almost draind magic or... and i have nothing


forget the mane 6 and their dragon their out of style.


cozy glow had alicorn majic to support discord’s unlike pinkie


Pinkie pie and discord are long lost twins.


Rainbow or pinky pie got his powers because she adored some of the magic for me


This is my theory when the student 6 released the magic pinkiea pinky sensé came to her


But pinkie said it runs in the family cus her sister also has the sence


Uhhh we are watching you, we like your videos


1:45 oh uhh yess actually they break the fourthwall and you already know we watch u =) you speak to us how are you confused there bud?


Dang the main 6 left a scine in the world  where happens and freand ship its boutifull i love that this show makes vid even if it may or not be over


It... started raining... what..?
2012 apocalypse flashbacks
chocolate rain
4 rage comics on horseback

It... started raining... what..?
*2012 apocalypse flashbacks*
*chocolate rain*
*4 rage comics on horseback*


Pinkie is just pinkie because you know pinkie!


Pinkie has magic not the one people think of just saying


yes someone is watching u it is me that is watching you.<br>yes us.

yes someone is watching u it is me that is watching you.
yes us.


pinkies a master mind she makes friendship prombleme


Because mabe pinky and discords have same craze power


Sawtooth Waves check the deleted scenes my little pony equstria girls pinkies switch places


No one can explain Pinkie pie cause she's Pinkie pie


Spoiled glou was an allacorn when she absorved the magic so her body could adjust the magic without having to spread it throughout her lifetime


Video: Discord
Caption: Dis quartz
Dis cords


Can you please do one of these videos but on....<br>FLUTTERSHY

Can you please do one of these videos but on....
FLUTTERSHY


You now how there are clones of the royal guard and how there was an alicorn guard what if that is pinky pie


Look is pinkie really a earth pony is she kind of ...

Unicorn


I have something to say.......................

PINKIE IS JUST PINKIE 🥳🤩🍭🍬🍫🍿🍩🎂


I go with you wierd power from The future cozy glow wasn’t crazy like pinky and didn’t do as much stuff as pinky


<b>*cry in mlp season 9 hasn't come to sweden's netflix yet*</b>

**cry in mlp season 9 hasn't come to sweden's netflix yet**


Finally solve pinkie:then if it that how can you explain pinkie from the human and if it was that she should have been normal the whole time

I think it her family her great parent was unicorn and that magic  could have go to pinkie bit has A earth pony


Pick it up and I have to get my hair done before you go home and get


Yes someone is watching you... Your veiwers


Maybe she got magic from her pinkie seances (sorry if I spelt it wrong auto correct)


Because of the rumors about pinkie... Everyone hates pinkie! She's just a character? Why does some toxic people always make fun of her? Why make fun of her, when you know hasbro made it


Φωτεινή Γαϊτανίδου


Yes someone is indeed watching you, in fact 597,435 that I saw, (the views) are watching you! :3


oomgs its amazing and it would explain pinky


Of course someone is watching you us the viewers you silly billy


my little pony  have so much secrets why can you tell us  thank you so much for teaching us thank you so much my little pony I love you so much teling us please make more videos po


Pinkie sense was prolly there when she was born because the ponies of ponyvile knew about it along time ago before twillight came


I always think pinky is acting pinkie and discord is discordy i belived every single WORD


Aren't you the same guy who thinks there are still bad changlings and you think you can solve pinkie pie?


I know pinkie pie's truth and it's creepy her real name is pinkamena


Oh ok...

Star swirl isn't discord...

But pinkie might be...

Oh ok...

Star swirl isn't discord...

*But pinkie might be...*


Is Some One Watching Me?<br>Me: Yes I Am LoL

Is Some One Watching Me?
Me: Yes I Am LoL


Yes she dead pinky pinky yes yes she said OK she did OK she then got your power from that one moment


I dont think thats it cause her sister has Mod sense Idk how to spell her name


Is that's why pinkie's human counter part is just like this pinkie ???


Can someone please tell me the music of 1:16


Pinkie Pie I have some really strange stuff that I didn't really know about her like physics never realize pinky with that Majestic in California. Something was wrong with her cuz she would crazy I think she was adopted or going to cuz her friends and I only have family do not look like her cuz maybe her family was like going out of business and maybe she was constipated time maybe she had like some hopefuls of some some Nair or some pony it must be her headache be guardian of the Girl doll you know where people have you no other person that they would protect the weird bad stuff what happened to them when they were little kids I bet she had it and she absorbed the magic and that's I think about you be a great queen or something maybe like she used to have some ability like she like had powers or maybe she was an Alicorn secretly but the afterwards maybe her parents had to protect her cuz she didn't want to cause drama around the world she hit her powers and her horse that's why her hair was soaked early but her powers never but she never use them that's why they were always never there you never saw her horn because it was covering her hair and she never had wings because even if she was out of course you would have kept it a secret so she didn't cause traumas stuff music when it was temporary when her friends are fat and they were her or maybe it was necessary she will use it in the show we never saw it but maybe she might be able to bring her magic back but she doesn't use it for anything else but if it family and friends will get hurt by some evil entity or feeling she might use it but her friends never realized but she was actually an Alicorn 1 her friends and family but she was not the only one in stuff she never had anything to do with it she decided she didn't want to cause drama for the world and her wings so that's why she was able to do it but she was always afraid of what happened like some new ones will come up when she hide it she was hiding it and deep down she was like she giving up hope there's no one will realize she was Alcorn or grow another one had respect for her and that's how her powers came when you are upset they come easily cuz she was depressed never had her face and she was never happy pony one day her her powers can't because she was not the one that read the matter what if we went to find her job was meant to be she was so happy she was happy she was Alec bumper she really have to hide it so people what is in the ponies will understand so that's why she had figure out time and maybe we can solve them to pinky but she was hiding it all this time and all these episode it took me a hot minute to realize she was an alicorn another dimension that she was an Alicorn but we never saw the real


Pinkie pie had this weird magic even before twilight became a princess so I don't know what you're talkin about this video makes no sense I know pinkie pie more than any for me does and I'm not even in the my Little pony universe


I think because cozy glow was an alicorn


Pinky  did not have her magic like that that was the final part you now how is pinky maybe because when she god her mask


AND RARITY SHE IS PULLING OUT HER   CHAIR

AND RARITY SHE IS PULLING OUT HER   CHAIR


The exact origin of Celestia and Luna is deliberately kept as a mystery. But it's assumed that Celestia and Luna were born as alicorns. (At least, Lauren Faust has said so, and the show and the comics didn't contradict her.)

Flurry Heart is the first alicorn born in more than a thousand years; and genetically, neither of her parents is an alicorn (Shining Armor is a unicorn, and Cadance was originally a pegasus). That's why Celestia and Luna were so surprised about her birth. (Was it some residual effect of the magic of love that transformed Cadance into an alicorn? Did the transformation also alter Cadance's genetic code? Was the Crystal Heart involved somehow?) Plus, they said that birth of an alicorn is something that Equestria hasn't ever seen, and this is true - Celestia and Luna are older than the Principality of Equestria itself.


pinky's chaos energy is very powerful she is only using 0.00000000000000000000000000000000000001% of her power good thing she doesn't snap easily...............but I think some one said cupcakes are the worst thing in history so get into your bunkers


Yes we are watching you 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂


Is the main six good well I don't think so maybe the good people  aren't  good and the bad people is not bad because maybe the bad people are right and the good people are wrong


Well i believe everything else but pinkie sence doesn't explain it cause maud has maud sence


If you think about because the cosy glow Had a look on magic it does give Cody go to Halle Halle called magic as you’re dead the dead piggy pie just use chaos magic without any other magic with it so I think pick up I did up Cales magic but I close the client had it like Alacon bad because he’s just gonna go suck it up girl grow Godspell a little times two powers of Case close


Maybe pinkie pie got magic because of... PINK AMINA


Imagine if this did not happen pinkie woulf probably be a maud #2


Did anyone look at the fact that pinky has so much hair and she might just be a unicorn anyone think of that


Pinkie Pie's real name is Pinkamena Dianne Pie. Is Pinkie Pie a serial killer that kidnappe every ponies?


But....how she get chaos power her mom and dad don't have chaos is the rain boom did??? there is 1 you guy didn't see season 8 episode 26 she still have it she didn't bake cake just there


Pinkie must already had chaos magic before she had discords magic

Because it looks like she knows how to use discords chaos magic.


That still don't explain why is she pink and her family is dark


Maybe thats why she pink? Everyone looks like their family so pinky doesn't?


I mAy HaVE JuUst SolVEd PinKIe PiE:

FRIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENNNNNNNNNNNNDDDDSSSSSSS


Pinkie is so crazy but she is so a mistary. But we  have seen where pinkie get ball 🏀 from all over ponyvill. But hi love your videos 😉


Wait a minute....THIS WAS POSTED 11 MONTHS AGO?????


Wait so this is how discord gots its name not the dragon the app


what if she took magic from the elements of harmany think about

and look when it was the future the magic was like gone

because how would she get the power before that happened


Cosy was an alicron but pinki pie was not


Ya but we’re are twilights wings in the pinkie senses


Ahh is someone watching me oh Pinky has a child now


But how was PINKIE pinkie from the past?


Sawtooth is the best sawtooth sawtooth sawtooth


PINKY CREATED DISCORD!

 Also, 535 968 people are watching you >:D


It looks like pinkie knows how to use discords magic

But pinkie has also that chaos magic so the clone must have gotten that magic from the mirror pool

That has magic bc pinkie said herself that she and cheese sandwich r the same and the original pinkie pie would have the pinkie  senses like cheese sandwich

Wait remember your video on the real pinkie died then what if it’s the


Maybe that’s why she Pink and her family is gray


She is not a problem to be the best and I have questions


But wait cheese sandwich has a cheesy sense but he has no caous i dont belive


Seriously what is his Deal with  Yoshi dark Lord


She she’s just a alicorn with wings and a horn in her head in her mane just don’t quisten


But in episode green isn’t your colour she was in the mirror and twilight was a unicorn but pinkie held the lamp when twilight was a alicorn.


Pinkei lost her pinke sence  when magie was take


U forgot 1  thing about pinkie pie her pinkie sense

Oh nvm and what u mean pinkie pie takes discords magic


How are you sooooooooooooo smart at thissssssss


in the other world is morning and it is night time in the Pony world what happened if pinkie pie switch with the other pinkie pie


Her laughter from pizza pie pinky pie I mean the wider the dirt to read a peek for her


I think pinkie pie is the way the way she is because of pinkie sense but pinkie sense is because of the rainboom.


When I saw the title I was like wwwwwwaaaaaaa


pinkie pie 's child will be just like pinkie , chaos and crazy bc pinkie is related to her child ofc then she will be chaosic or crazy like pinkie pie AHHHH PINKIE PIE WHAT HAVE YOU BROUGHT IN THIS WORK CHAOSIC NESS AND DISCORD U TO


Pinkie pie is the sister of discord from different timelines and Worlds Equestria girls

Or Real life check your donkeys and your horses


You read to much into a show for girls 3-8


I dont know but make a video of how pinkie became an alicorn!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Here's the link of the video https://youtu.be/NXqkTscjxwk


I like the theory, but..

💕ie

is

💕nkie

I like the theory, but..

💕ie

is

💕nkie


but  cozy  was a alicorn   she   is a pegisi   ramang  magic


Biggest thing ki is so after is the element of the laughter so this is what is a paint NH7 Sohar then every is the craziness or what is the craziness of the memories that there is just got this magic and seek a more powerful than ever


How do ponies get their names By shaanvika


Pinkie breaks law of fisicks like dicord and looking at us veirs


I’m watching you sawtooth your on YouTube  😈


There is nothing special about pinkie pie she is just a silly party pony


I saw tooth Waves Can you make any more videos that are fun but no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no scary things cause it really really really scares me like it's cause when I hear the music on how kings someone lost his wings and The alicorn ambulance music it was so scary I just stopped watching that And never ever ever ever ever watch that type of episode again cause it was too scary you Should Sombra episode with no scary music it scares me too much It really really does it very it does Cause where do you even get the music from? My sister isn't a fan But I am me my sister Olivia Are twins And was 7


Pinkies just is just being pinkie pie 😆😅


Yes someone is waching you... Maw ha ha ha ha maw ha ha👀😈


Really that happened in the last video and pinki has bean pinki before that


Oh no this... can't.... oh.. boy.... your kidding right


Know what the think of things purchases a mystery character that I don't understand about pinky Pie she has no problems of Manhattan house her but we have a lot of Secrets about her. We don't know what's a tummy a hot minute realize that she was a look corn because actually I knew it all I just was my brain was dumb but anyways maybe we'll be able to say maybe we can get a game or something don't know something I think it will make make a game that was playing her tragedy maybe all the characters will have the wrong special story and stuff maybe think about had drama with her a real parents house maybe her dad was reading out of business is in her mom was trying to make money but she didn't in before her in a orphanage then her like family came first up parents so much never hold a nap or whatever she was like she was always press abused by Gucci hadn't he was abused and stuff with the other owners of the Ganahl the mayor's and stuff being her up she was abused and never even the small she has bruises for years and she was always tormented and she was never a house before your like she was second a timely then at the woods her friends started bawling her being a life torture to cost flies her house her brain mentally as I can trust she never talk back this you didn't want to to be so on the little the word but she was always beat up tap use and never liked all these kids made fun of her cuz she was not popular that girl the other ones were she she got beat up your other rest I think she had drama parents whenever liked to do like abuse her guitar kid baby her siblings bite be 10 she was like beating them up for maybe that's how she got trouble then she was abused and she was always accusing to was child attitude it be her up into a pink then her eyes with bleeding coming crying tears in stuff parents never cared about her that's why she was abused she had a lot of drama with her parents using her making her feel like she was at to call me a question that house she was trying to hide it in the episodes like it it has she was going to different the mentioned she never mentioned it I'll her story cuz we never knew what about her that I knew about everything is I am the smart penis but anyways I think she you was trying to hide it from the camera s*** bruises all over the state she put makeup the planet with her skin that's why she was never allowed to know what's you probably could make up on her skin so she can not to be around so stupid praying that Bob on that she went she goes home she calls the curtains then she cries and cries and cries how a lot she cries and cries and cries have her all birthday party went her parents will her real pads hated her and sing ever sell big heart birthday and as a shoe was sad never allowed to have she was crying her room Walker heard door and cry cry and cry like to doors and stuff this is cake whenever heard parents live she had to tantrum cuz she wanted to see her siblings but they will always never around Zulu to different countries so that's why she should she was crying wash Mr siblings and she was married and everything was perfect but she will want to her husband was shooting ahead and she had a divorce then she lost some of her kids I love you never saw her but she's out of think if I met when they were in college a nice selling love but sex before she real


And yes she is just pinkie but with powers and I think is her big sis cuz she knew everything even the cutiemarks that can take you cutiemarks mmm..... but yeah I this her big sis


She got her powers from a group of outside entities, the Voidwalkers, one of them was discord, and the other one was my OC


Pinkies a pony not a creature -_-
Discord is my favorite character
Discord x Fluttershy is my favorite ship


i am watching you sawtooth YOUR RECORDING AND   LITTLE FAMOUS?


What if pinkie isnt anf never was a normal earth pony


pinke got magic sesoan 8 not 9 sesoan 9     ant out yet


Wait doesn’t mod pinkies sister have…mod sence


I think pinkie pie is just a normal pony


yes someone is watching you. me! im watching ur vidio now


Yes someone is watching you your subscribers


How do i watch this where fo i find the mlp episodes I haven’t seen this

Someone named Letupita725HD has a yt channel, that's where I watch all the episodes. If you go on their channel and look at playlists you should find a playlist for each season


Pinky is not a pony she is whatever creature discord is


I love your videos so much I'm prince Rayno


Thousands of people are watching you you have a chanle


Rainbow dash, applejack doesn't got power pinkie got her smile


Bad twilight sparkle silly pinkie pie
Pinkie) ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo twilight sparkle you are bad go to your room now
Twilight)noooooooooooooooooooooooooo


Pinkie pie is just pinkie pie she is just crazy or she has some illness that makes her do what crazy things she does


Like there someone watching them.....creepy sounds.............stop being creepy ur making pinkie more creepier


In a youtuber she has pinky sence and nkows when danger is coming pinky sence😎😎


I actually had a theory (well, less theory and more head canon) that Pinkie sense is essentially a supernatural understanding of butterfly effects: she can look at any random occurrence and immediately know what it will cause. I dunno, it just helped me connect her chaotic nature and her apparent psychic ability.


I think Pinkie Pie may have adhd. I say not only because I have it, but because I notice behaviors she and I share. One example is during the episode Yakity-Sax when Pinkie gets rid of her instrument, she seems fine at first. However, we then get a glimpse showing exactly how upset she truly is. Whenever I feel upset being told I’m not good at something, it discourages me from being myself since I always seem so excited about it. In addition, we know that her friends constantly agree that she is a little strange, but I know that ppl think that about me too. We also got a glimpse of Pinkie’s past and how she earned her cutie mark. When she saw the rainbow it was like she was inspired to be herself. Maybe at some points during her childhood, she wanted to be her but stopped herself from doing so worried what others may think of her. The rainbow gave her that push she needed to be herself and it never changed the way others saw her. I hope one day I too am pushed by a rainbow to be confident of who I am. Well, a metaphorical one at least.


You also gotta think about personality traits. Both Discord and Pinkie Pie have a certain randomness, especially if chaos(aka Discord) is attributing in a good way... Sounds awfully like Pinkie pie during her antics. Cozy glow can't relate in that way, so that's a way to explain that line of reasoning.


There’s something that must have started the loophole, just like Future Twilight first wanted to tell Twi to not worry about her schedule, but then it changed into her worrying about the message Future Twilight sent (theory.). How did Pinkie even absorb the magic of this bell in the first place? Was she not the element of laughter, but a different element, and when the chaos corrupted her timeline, she turned into the element tif laughter? Or, did she turn into a villain and steal the chaos magic that then corrupted her timeline and bla bla bla


I think pinkie never had earth pony magic, but always had chaos magic, in a small quantity, allowing her to bend reality, but only a very limited sense. this also makes sense as pinkie was the only other entity to use chaos magic (although she lost control of herself to a degree, it was very different to how cozy glow's use backfired), meaning she might be chaotic enough to use the magic.


When comparing cosi to pinkie, think about... when cosi got discord’s magic, that plus regular pony magic was all that was there... but when pinkie was exposed to the magic not only discord’s magic and other regular pony magic was given too her, but also Luna and celestias magic as well, so when saying that... your theory makes sense sawtooth


This confirms that earth ponies not only have a connection to nature but also has a connection to time itself since there are different versions of the Pinkie sense seen in other earth ponies.


The last problem with Cozy Glow I can solve, Pinkie Pie absorbed Discord’s magic, while Cozy absorbed unicorn, earth pony and Pegasus magic.


I know this video is 3 months old, but I would like to point out another example as to why this theory makes sense. In season 7, episode 18 "Daring done?", she picks up one of Daring Do's artifacts, the artifact reacts differently than when its in Daring's hand. For pinkie, it glows brightly and has sparks coming off it, but when daring has it all of that stops. Idk, that just seemed interesting to me..


Authors: Hm, let´s make this one horse crazy, why not.

Sawtooth: So, she had this colision with chaos magig that offected her whole life but maybe not....


Sawtooth: Pinkie is always does random things,pulls out stuff out of nowhere and her pinkie sense is  because she has bits of future memories in her from when she absorbed discord's chaos magic
Cheese Sandwich: am i a joke to you?

*Sawtooth:* Pinkie is always does random things,pulls out stuff out of nowhere and her pinkie sense is  because she has bits of future memories in her from when she absorbed discord's chaos magic
*Cheese Sandwich:* *am i a joke to you?*


she also could have done it herself as she had a limited but not impossible amount of control over the magic. sensing that she could lose it she may have infuse it within her across time.


How about "Time Lord", going by all the contraptions she has access to in any off situation?


Although this theory could be true, if you remember when pinky was telling her background story. She could not pull anything out of the blue or appear out of nowhere, until the rainboom happened. If u remember the same kinda thing happened to Twilight. She couldn’t use her magic until the rainboom happened and she used her magic that no one else could do. Now not saying this applies to all of them but the Rainboom could have had affect on Pinky’s life and not event happening in the future


Guys I just had a revelation, Pinkie gets her magic from friendship.  We’ve seen time and time again that friendship is magic, from hearths warming to the elements to the main six themselves, but nopony has as many friends as Pinkie.

Expand on this idea as you will, I was just rewatching season 2 and had a lightbulb moment.

Yeah, but in that case then Applejack should be stronger than she is correct? She is the same type as pinkie and is friends with lots of ponies doing her business yet all she has is super strength you'd think Rarity would be the weakest since she is a fashionista and not the most likeable to some right?


Guess what I found out, u can use a gum wrapper(with the gum still in it) to scroll, cool right?


Pinkie may be the only other creature in Equestria that is able to use Discords magic. If you think about Queen Chrysalis said no one can control chaos magic and that was proven with Cozy Glow having a very hard time controlling the chaos magic, but when Pinkie absorbed Discords magic she was able to control it. She successfully made chocolate rain and balloons float behind her when she was massive. I also think that the reason why Pinkie may be able to control chaos magic is that Discord and Pinkie have similar tastes and interests. They both can use the same type of magic, but it would make more sense for Discord to use it. Even though he tried to take over Equestria several times he still knows when he draws the line. He makes pranks and gags that are more or less harmless to the other creatures around him, but when Pinkie had the chaos magic her first thought was turning the entire cosmos into icing.


I just thought of this; what if pinkie, along with getting Discords magic infused with her, also (accidentally) got a tiny bit of grogar’s magic as well. (I can’t be the only one who thought of this)


i actually noticed when the magic went into her forhead, but i thought it was an error because earlier that episode she ran off screen and came back with some pizza,and how would she do that without magica

only Pinkie can pick up anything from of screen.<br>She brought a cupcke from Maretropolis in Power Ponies?

only Pinkie can pick up anything from of screen.
She brought a cupcke from Maretropolis in Power Ponies?


"Pinkie Pie is the most confusing creature in Equestria."<br>Ah, I see, so she's not a pony.

"Pinkie Pie is the most confusing creature in Equestria."
Ah, I see, so she's not a pony.

She is the combination of all magics seen in the form of an Earth Pony.
It is more Powerful, since there is no way of drawing her as anything more.  Giving her wings or horn would merely detract.
..


What if pinky’s abilities to themselves was magic? What if pinky isn’t just a pony? After all, peering through time and space, and causing changes to the future that end up leading to the past... means she’s either doctor who or a part of Norse mythology. Btw, in Norse mythology, part of it is that the world tree represents the past, present, and future, and that water from above flows down below to nurture the tree. This is meant to show that somehow the future affects the past.


My theory: discord and pinkie are quite similar, so what if discord’s past has something to do with pinkie, like in discord’s origins, he was a experiment, but what was experiment what did he start as? What if he was part of pinkie’s family, I mean both pinkie pie and discord both have two forms. Pinkie has deflated form and discord has grogard. But how did they get them? And plus, discord’s colour scheme matches with her family, but weirdly, pinkie doesn’t. And in her backstory, she started as a filly on a rock farm, but why did she look so different from her family, unless that <b>wasn’t</b> her family at all. And maybe it could be to do with discord. If so, maybe there is a piece of discord’s timeline that we missed. And if so, what is it? And could it be connected with Pinkie pie?

My theory: discord and pinkie are quite similar, so what if discord’s past has something to do with pinkie, like in discord’s origins, he was a experiment, but what was experiment what did he start as? What if he was part of pinkie’s family, I mean both pinkie pie and discord both have two forms. Pinkie has deflated form and discord has grogard. But how did they get them? And plus, discord’s colour scheme matches with her family, but weirdly, pinkie doesn’t. And in her backstory, she started as a filly on a rock farm, but why did she look so different from her family, unless that *wasn’t* her family at all. And maybe it could be to do with discord. If so, maybe there is a piece of discord’s timeline that we missed. And if so, what is it? And could it be connected with Pinkie pie?


Well if that’s true.......
If it messed up her whole past and her future what does that mean?
It means....

Discord and her would have to try to make friends like Discord did

so if it affected the past it does mean it affected her future
But there’s a slight problem....

It’s the connection between Chaos and Pinkie

AND THE BRAIN
no I mean Pinkamena Diane Pie
Pinkie Pie was born into a rock family when she saw the rainbow and made her go all happy and made her go all excited and ever since she saw a rainbow she gets excitement she’s always excited and the chaos that Discord has does not match that
And pinky getting magic whenever the magic was stolen she only got it back because
she has a different type of earth pony magic it’s more different
than a regular earth pony it’s only because her excitement
it’s what makes her
Well her


I a sorry to bring your theory to pieces, but there is one thing that changes everything.  In Pinkie Pride Cheese Sandwich has a cheesy sense, and later on in The Gift Of Maud Pie, Rarity asks Maud how she knew that the guy with the party cannon was there, and Maud said, Maud sense, only later to explain, "it runs in the family." So, Pinkie didn't get it from future Pinkie, she got it from DNA.  If it runs in the family, it would also mean that all Pies had it.  Oh, and what about Cheese, how did he get his sense?

I agree with you and I also still think she has magic that's not pinkie sense ( because pinkie sense is a genetic ), like how she can teleport sometimes and make party supplies out of nowhere and pull of amazing stunts that defy the laws of physics. I also think that she is connected to discord because of the bell.


0:21 sawtooth : i may have just solved pinkie pie
me: someone get the novel prize of the best theorist in the world please


"Is someone watching me?!"<br>           -Sawtooth 2020

"Is someone watching me?!"
           -Sawtooth 2020


maybe the element of harmony amplified the effect of the chaos magic


I think I got it.Pinkie is in her earluly 20's,But cozy is a filly,Like twelve or something.Maybe the age has something to do with it,Like the older you get the more magic enters your past and future,or once you reach somewhere over twleve,that happens.


I don’t know if anyone said this already but I just thought of this:

What if in that one episode where there were a billion pinkies, they didn’t choose the right pinkie? What if they chose a different pinkie? I might be dumb but maybe that pinkie they chose was just trying to stay so she wouldn’t have to go back to the water.


Come back after watching Tenet, this video makes even more sense now


To back it up when the unicorns got there magic back pinkie pie in the episode didnt seem like her funny annoying self it was like if it was on a 50% scale and not on a 100% scale.


In the comics, Pinkie pie became the "Princess of Chaos" for a while, maybe that help make her body able to wield the chaos magic.


in an episode (not a serie one just side ones ) pinkie drinks a potion from her chaos take an new level and she can travel in time dimension and spaces (that episode was created by lauren faust so it is related ) she was more powerful then discord and twilight cause they cant travel time in the blink of an eye


One question if she has chaos magic im confused whether she can control it  or it just comes out


There’s one thing I have to say that doesn’t make sense though because pinky only exorbitant magic after season eight and you’re saying that all that magic went all the way back to season one


maybe she just is the way she is regardless of what or how she came to be in the future or present. but seriously she is WEEEEIRD


There’s a hole in ur theory: you said that pinkie sense was bc of the chaos magic BUT when pinkie gets the present for maud and maud finds the pony that took pinkies cannon maud undoubtedly said “ maud sense” and pinkie said “... runs in the family”


ADHD EVERYBODY SING IT WITH ME A-D-H-D<br>Honestly she represents me pretty well she is like the manifestation of the core of ADHD

ADHD EVERYBODY SING IT WITH ME A-D-H-D
Honestly she represents me pretty well she is like the manifestation of the core of ADHD


Sawtooth waves - and they both do that thing when they stair in to space as if someone was watching them......... is someone watching me!


That can’t be possible that chaos happened way before that moment


The reason she got magic back is because under that Xtremely bouncy mane of hers THERE’S A HORN HIDDEN UNDER THERE! THATS THE REASON!


Wait ...  What about when cozy glow absorbed discords magic?


Wait but what about Cheese Sandwich? He’s practically pinkie 2.0.  Sure, Pinkie could have more of the.. uh.. craziness I guess, but Cheese is still pretty strong.


I solved Pinkie Pie years ago. ... THE WRITERS.


I know why Cozy glow did not get the consequences pinky pie did it's because she was an alicorn at the time and was powerful enough to hold the power in the one time


0:47 Pinkie Pie discovered her Gigantamax form!


1:50
Sawtooth: Is someone watching me?
Me: y e s

1:50
Sawtooth: Is someone watching me?
Me: *y e s*


No it's that she a pony pasta (creepypasta) but she just hides it meaning even if she always smiles doesn't mean that actually she's not always happy


cozy was an alicorn at the time so maybe she could handle it and she did not use the chaos magic


I think that pinkie pie infusing chaos magic into herself is true because in the human world the duplicate of her is still chaotic but doesn't do any breaking the fourth wall things all she does is be goofy


1:13   HANG ON A SECOND I RECOGNIZE THAT BACKGROUND MUSIC!


I think she did I  mean she liked it raining chocolate milk and that happened and all the sugary food floating around and the cupcakes in her eyes it was like she could control the chaos


I like the idea of Pinkie just being Pinkie, but your theary makes alot of sense...


pinkie pie is the only creater in the mlp universe that can control the magic of discord there equaly chaotic


Pinkie is that crazy from the beginning of the series and she Absorbed Discords Magic in the last season


My theory is that she have the power of cartoon characters, yes


tbh i think pinkie is the most powerful pony. ngl.


No I don’t solved pinkie pie because that was season 9 and the creators most likely did not think sooo far ahead to why pinkie is pinkie so I don’t think she got those wired powers from that event the creators probably just thought it would be a good sense to season 9 but that does not explain why pinkie is like how she is but it’s just my opinion and you have your own opinion and I’m ok with that I love this channel but I don’t think pinkie is strange because of that 1 event


The season 6 ( the gift of Maud pie) the part when Maud says: Maud sence .<br>Pinkie pie says: thats in the family.

The season 6 ( the gift of Maud pie) the part when Maud says: Maud sence .
Pinkie pie says: thats in the family.


Sawtooth Waves, Cheese Sandwich also has A Chessy Sense? So, the pinkie sense doesn’t explain anything, but if it did, could Cheese Sandwich have something too?

Hmm.. Good theory! It definitely makes sense

In the PPSTD episode I think that’s how you spell it, rarity does what pinkie should be doing but pinkie is sad and can’t do it. Maybe any pony can do it if they have the right amount of energy?


I think this is true cuz its the only reason to her pinkyness and the pink magic that she got when the spell was realised.


Pinkie is a forth wall character.......their is no real logic behind anything she does.....it's there just for the heck it.....that's the best i can come up with where such characters are concerned anyways....they r made so the writers can do anything....just because they can...and it isn't made into a big deal because ....well in this case...it's just pinkie being pinkie right?


If she had got those crazy powers after she absorbed the magic so how she uses her power in past because she absorbed discords magic in last season


Just the unicorns and the Pinkie Pie got magic<br>Lol 🤣

Just the unicorns and the Pinkie Pie got magic
Lol 🤣


Check out Death Battle. Pinky Pie vs. Deadpool. It ends the way you think <br>The only losers the forth wall.

Check out Death Battle. Pinky Pie vs. Deadpool. It ends the way you think
The only losers the forth wall.


Makes no sense let me say something in the episode When Muad pinkie pie and rarity went to Manhattan muad Knew where the guy that gave pinkie pie the Rock holder and Raritysaid how did you know where the guy was and muad said muad Sense in Pinky said runs in the family


Sawtooth : PINKIE SENSE

Me : *WHAT ABOUT MAUD SENSE ?? *

Me : Did maud get discord's magic too??


Sawtooth: is someone watching me?!?!<br>Me:yes a million people

Sawtooth: is someone watching me?!?!
Me:yes a million people


This theory makes sense but...how did cheese sandwich get his powers?unless...


She didn't get power from the emulet she was always like starting from the when she got her cutie mark she started acting like that


I think you should stop questioning pinkie pie I stopped ages ago..... and still haven't got an answer


I'm actually scared right now she has to do. Wall breakers I don't know?


Bruh no one , LiTErary no one can solve pinkie pie 😂😋


Fine theory but how do we explain cheese sandwich


Now when u said the part someone watching u know what I've been watching my little pony all over and all over again now I felt creep out-


Pinkie pie is light my fav character, she’s sweet, and in bad situations she looks on the bright side!<br>💝🌸🌷🎀💕💞💓💗💖💘🩰🎟🍧🍥🍬🍭🍫🍕🍉🍓🍒🍇🌺🌹🦄👛👚👄👅🥳

Pinkie pie is light my fav character, she’s sweet, and in bad situations she looks on the bright side!
💝🌸🌷🎀💕💞💓💗💖💘🩰🎟🍧🍥🍬🍭🍫🍕🍉🍓🍒🍇🌺🌹🦄👛👚👄👅🥳


Well she saw a rainbow from which she got these sence humour


Pinkie just might be part draconoquis. Not saying she's related to discord but maybe another draconoquis.


Pinkie is the product of a crossbreeding between a fifth dimensional eldrich being and a sentient balloon.


I sort of agree but in that episode Were cozy glow stole magic.and we noetest she had magic.but when cozy glow had the magic pinkie was the same which means its not magic.


Wait wait wait, I solve IT the right way, so pinky does not have magic it’s her personality, well I don’t if this is right but, pinky pie does not have magic, it’s her silly personality, well, I know it does not make any sense.


I don’t even get how u can solve the biggest mystery.....

Pinkie


When pinky got chaosity ,it was AFTER cozy defeat


One sec the villains did a spell to get the magic how did pinky get it?


Omg I want to meet the nameless one 😭😭😭😭


I pinkie kept the magic everything would be desserts 🍨🍩🍪🍰🎂🧁🍭🍬🍫🍮🍯🥮... ALL OF THEM.  Also what about Cheese sandwich 🤔


I agree on the Chaos magic effecting Pinkie Pie past and you know thinking about it give me another idea about her strange magic and that is her cutie mark think about it never happened until Pinkie Pie got her cutie mark it’s not the first time we seen pony’s have powers with there cutie marks what If Rainbow Dash rainboom did more it gave her what I will call Party powers like Rainbow Dash gave her the power to do the rainboom and the others got special powers Twilight magic, FlutterShy talking to animals, Rarity and finding gems, and Apple Jack amazing bucking skills so Rainbow Dash could have gave Pinkie Pie her Party powers and the others special powers.


Maybe she was born that way or the rain boom when the six all got their cutie marks


Ok then explain why cheese sandwhich has CHEESY SENSE just like Pinkie has Pinkie sense.


So I was just thinking about the video and I think that cozy glob was ment to be evil and some how that change her


Applejack should have got magic back because she has too what if she lost her strength because of that 🙄 just saying well she should have


Maybe the magic in pinkie is pinkie sense?


But when she got her magic back it was before c exorb chaos


Pinkie pie is just having fun and just baking cakes and cupcakes :) party


mabye because choas magic likes choatic things like pinkie pie, Discords favorite


I always wondered, why is pinkie pie pink if none of her parents are pink


I know how Magic wind Into pinky pie After the students Defeated cozy grove  to   Because of a pinky Senses I don't know the rest that's the only thing I know so that you have to figure on your own sorry I can't tell you anything else I don't know the rest


Pinkie is strange especially with her pinkie sense


it's obvious that SHE AND DISCORD ARE SIBLINGS!!!!! DUN DUN DUH


Wait cozy glow was an alicorn when she took grogars bell maybe pinkie got magic cause she was an earth pony


As if someone was watching them…IS SOMEONE WHACHING ME … um YES about 1000000 fans.


pinki got it because of the people that made the mlp vids  made pinki like weird


can you make a video called finally solving rainbow dash


But that happened in the future and she's Ben like these


Or pinkie is still the dark pinkamena Dian pie she was


𝕀 𝕥𝕙𝕚𝕟𝕜 𝕡𝕚𝕟𝕜𝕪 𝕚𝕤 𝕛𝕦𝕤𝕥 𝕥𝕣𝕪𝕚𝕟𝕘 𝕥𝕠 𝕙𝕒𝕧𝕖 𝕗𝕦𝕟 𝕘𝕚𝕧𝕖 𝕙𝕖𝕣 𝕒 𝕔𝕙𝕒𝕟𝕔𝕖


now wait a minute this is like teen titans the episode called the forth wal


But your right Maud sense and pinky sense are different


i think that why cozy glow is so amotinle is becows of the cayos magic just my thots


Yes pinkie got it from that true u r the biggest genius


Can you have the same cutimark what would happen if you did


Nah ur wrong in the begening she had her power she just being pinky


SOOO your saying what happened in the future is what was happening in the past


I no matter the truth and you can make a decision and I can make you a good job and you can make it work


um so wait she can  maybe warp to the real universe our universe multi universe or what imma make some my alicorn or maybe the god alicorn what is that god or maybe who is he or she can you upload a theory of it plz


yOU CAN NEVER SOLVE PINKY PIE SHES TO CRAZY AND she can break the fort wall and she is the most powerful pony ever OoOoOoo


Discord has discord sense and pinkie has pinkie sense I would say that to but what about maud sense


pinkie pie has a sister maud pie and she also has senses like the pinkie sense  pinkie pie said it runs in the family


what if this happenned because of the fact pinkie pies familly was sooo dull then she got her cutie mark because they drove her crazy and thats why she turned a lil bit crazy<br>ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

what if this happenned because of the fact pinkie pies familly was sooo dull then she got her cutie mark because they drove her crazy and thats why she turned a lil bit crazy
ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo


YOU ARE MAKIN MEH HIPERVENULATE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Pinkie pie did handle the caos magic better than cosy glow


Yay and yes we are watching u your ON A VIDEO<br>I think look pinky is a party pony and on the video we’re cheese sandwich sang why is his cutie mark a cheese sandwich??? Anyways pinky I’d a party pony a party pony would go crazy and she laughed even if the tree was scary u know on the video when they are geting Luna back the time when they defeated nightmare moon

Yay and yes we are watching u your ON A VIDEO
I think look pinky is a party pony and on the video we’re cheese sandwich sang why is his cutie mark a cheese sandwich??? Anyways pinky I’d a party pony a party pony would go crazy and she laughed even if the tree was scary u know on the video when they are geting Luna back the time when they defeated nightmare moon


So that he pinkie pie telpotes pull party cannon out of thin air and has super speed


Hey hey why isn't Rainbow dash included just think about it she and her father have rainbow hair what about her mother and why is Rainbow dash the only one who can do the sonic rainboom and Fluttershy was so well shy until she burst out in applause whne she saw Rainbow dash do the sonic rainboom


He thinks hes solved pinkie but the day that is o pinkies sens


I think pinky and discord are siblings from the same eag Yah both burn on a thaterday and maby someone toke pike in the futer


Feeling rainbow dash is Akikorn in sikres!


Yes we are watching you why did you post this if you don’t want me to see it


Ok, but are we going to talk about the fact she's the only other creature that could handle his magic properly in the first place?

Edit: This might be a paradox though,  because you could say Pinkie could take in Discords chaos magic because she already had some, when she got it from taking Discords chaos magic, which she could handle since already has some when she got it from taking Discords chaos magic, which she could handle since already has some and you get the point.

Edit 2: at 2:15 when Pinkie got her magic, it isn't that insane pattern like Discords chaos magic. What if it's a whole new kind of magic? Party Magic. Hasn't Cheese Sandwich been shown to do similar things? What if the 2 of them have party magic?


Your fans are waching you; silly! # like, plot hole


Like fucking showed up in Fortnight when chapter 1 Island is going out with a bang


What is pinkies pies name was actually supposed to be this pie Bruh 0_0


Pinkie is from difrend demantion .w.<br>😹😹😹😹😹

Pinkie is from difrend demantion .w.
😹😹😹😹😹


Why is floter shy and rainbow dash didn't get there power's


DONT TALK LIKE THAT TO MY FRIEND LIKE DAT!!! Oops sry -_-


what are you talking about maybe pinkie pie was born like that


This is canon now nobody can convince me otherwise


You’re crazy as are the bath I wish I can’t I don’t have my own high


Is somebody watching you yeah some people are watching you because you are on YouTube


O my thats true only bothe of them talk to the one that watched them

🍀𝙻𝚞𝚌𝚔𝚢𝙰𝚌𝚎𝚇𝙳😆


Yes I’m watching you sawtooth get it like if you get it


Hey yo you on YouTube we all watching you


Why do not solve pinky she is one thing that not should be solve like discord and technically since they have the same magic in there veins like the exact same magic like how family’s have the same type of blood


WELL WE AINT NOT ORRRR CANT FIGURE OUT Pink pie NOW RIGT 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😒🙁😒😒😒😒🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁😞😞😞😞😞😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😭🤣😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😤😤😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭


I think one reason that the chaos magic didn’t spread through Cozy Glow’s timeline is because at that time, there wasn’t any alicorn magic (Celestias’s and Luna’s magic) inside Grogar’s bell, but when Pinkie Pie absorbed the magic, there was the alicorn magic inside it too, and it was too much for her to contain in that moment and spread through her whole timeline


On the Cozy Glow question, we see it almost immediately drives her mad with power. If we are to assume Chaos magic trancends time and effects your being completely, couldn't that explain her master manipulation and power hungry tendencies? After all, we're never given a real origin for her.


I definitely like the chaos magic theory, and I think that maybe chaos magic affecting people differently is the reason why it didn't affect Cozy Glow. The only problem would be that the first run of the timeline would have pinkie pie not have all of the craziness that made her Pinkie Pie, resulting in her probably not representing her element. Then again, time events never make sense, and a lot of things like this don't follow that logic flaw anyway.


I'm a little late to the party here but I'll throw in my two cents.

I've suspected for a while now that Pinkie's abilities were magical in nature. The detail about her getting magic back along with Twilight and Rarity would seem to prove that. I'm not sure I buy that it came from her interaction with Grogar's bell though. The point about Cozy Glow having absorbed Discord's magic as well is the key here. Cozy Glow absorbed the chaos magic but *could not wield it*. Pinkie COULD. That tells me that chaos magic was in her nature, regardless of her interaction with the bell.


i may be late but the interaction between chaos magic and harmony magic could be the explanation. harmony is described as balance and chaos unbalance however not many see that chaos is a tool of harmony to bring balance. if creatures evolved to be balanced within themselves and not the environment they either destroyed the landscape or died themselves. seeing as how pinkie is directly linked to harmony that harmony would need to balance chaos in a way that would keep harmony. sending chaos magic back and forth into time to keep balance could be the reason why she didn't temporarily become an alicorn. this would also partially explain why discord didn't fade when his magic was stolen from him, his magic causes him to fade if he is orderly.


the question about how cozy glow wasn't affected has already been explained in one of these comments [at the time she was an alicorn and could handle it but pinkie was just an earth pony], so the chaos magic makes sense. plus it explains how when the magic had returned pinkie was also hit. BUT the one thing confusing me is that if pinkie didn't have that happen, she wouldn't have absorbed the magic. unless the loop of time just started when pinkie absorbed some magic, it doesn't add up. i can't really explain it in words- hopefully someone understands what i mean-


Wait, I just had another theory. What if there are still pinkies throughout equestria from that season 3 Episode? What if there are still many pinkies out there spreading discord’s magic to other pinkies. Does that make sense?

What if pinkie the one who absorbed discord’s magic was the original pinkie, but she spread it to one of her clones. And with that magic, they could travel through time and have been since the beginning of the series. Either by finding it in the star swirl hallway in canterlot, or by some other Discord magic feature.

What if one of those pinkies traveled back in time and have been since season 1, and another one could’ve travelled to the human world and told the pinkie in the original world and that’s how she knew what happened to twilight when she traveled there for the first time. I mean, it does kinda make sense since equestria girls came out after season 3 and pinkie got all her clones in the 3rd episode of season 3. So basically, during that time, other pinkies could’ve absorbed that magic that another pinkie did in the future (season 9) cause it spread throughout her entire timeline and other pinkies as well. This was just a theory that cane out my mind but I guess we’ll never know the true secret of Pinkie Pie, unless Pinkie is just Pinkie...


While this idea is vary plausible, and would explain a lot. Through I don't think it goes as deep as you implied. While it does explain the moments were Pinkie could predict future events, and he fourth wall bracing ability, it doesn't explain why those specific abilities aren't an every day thing. The other aspect that you need to account for is Pinkies personal and willingness to embrace the crazy and weird.  That could be the reason why she shows symptoms of it through out her life while Cozy didn't.  And would explain how she was able to control Discords magic better then Cozy Glow too.


Leave it to the last episodes of the series to explain all the nonsense Pinkie has been up to since the beginning. A solid theory.


i honestly like to imagine that Pinkie could in fact control Discord's chaos magic


Nah, I don't think that's true. When Cozy took it in, it didn't spread. Pinkie probably just had chaos magic in her when she was born, but not strong enough or very usable to be like Discord's. Maybe her family members have it too, splitting what little magic they inherited into small amounts that can only be used subconsciously. Maud can teleport, and all of the Pies seem to have 'senses.'

Don't forget Earth Ponies and Pegasi have their own kind of magic.


Just a theory (even tho it’s late)

Cozy wasn’t effected as much as pinkie because she was already an Alicorn and using Grogars magic, which may have have stopped it from causing larger effects. also when the element toke away the magic from cozy, it may have also stopped any chaos magic from having the same effects.

Pinkie however was still pure earth Pony and although she represents an element, that’s still only one of them that connects to the others, so it would have a different effect than having all 6 used against her.

But again just a theory

Also this might explain Pinkamina
Like when discord started acting normal his magic and he slowly started to fade away, if Pinkie did keep some of his chaos magic and it traveled through her lifetime it would explain a similar thing with Pinkie.
So when she’s upset and not acting like her element, the magic starts to fade causing her to act differently (Hence pinkamina)


"Pinkie Pie has been one of the most confusing creatures in Equestria"
Me : Yeah... And the creepiest...

"Pinkie Pie has been one of the most confusing creatures in Equestria"
Me : Yeah... *And the creepiest...*


Great theory as usual, but when you mentioned her pinkie sense i thought about something....like what about maud sense? Even Cheese Sanwich mentioned having cheese sense


Didn’t someone said that only Discord could control chaos magic, so how would Pinky be able to? I think they are spiritually collected in some way

Pinkie Pie can not just control it, but she ould extract it from the bell on her own.
Going by all previous examples; the bell was intended to give magic to someone else, preferably by Grogar.
But, why should Pinkie Pie be bothered by such petty details?


”Is someone watching me?”
Well, sawtooth. Yes, through a screen we are watching you.

*”Is someone watching me?”*
*Well, sawtooth. Yes, through a screen we are watching you.*


I feel like you’re right about pinkie, but the reason it didn’t effect cozy glow was because she’s not as chaotic as pinkie, Since pinkie pie is naturally chaotic the chaotic energy must have messed up her already existing chaotic energy.


actually, i do agree, and i do think it is an interesting concept. The netflix series (i think it was like, hill's hesidense? hills house???) <b>spoilers ahead</b> has the same thing. The girl sees a broken neck woman from time to time, wich its just her when she dies with a broken neck and revisitis her old self.

actually, i do agree, and i do think it is an interesting concept. The netflix series (i think it was like, hill's hesidense? hills house???) *spoilers ahead* has the same thing. The girl sees a broken neck woman from time to time, wich its just her when she dies with a broken neck and revisitis her old self.


But Sawtooth, what about the Pinkie in the equestria girls dimension? There is certainly no Discord or his magic in that dimension, or are you saying that because his magic is so powerful, it is spread across dimensions?


I strongly support this theory and accept it as cannon


i think its a mixture of discord's magic and the explosion of magic from the sonic rainboom which definitely contains magic since its where twilight got most of her's she was a very weak unicorn before the sonic rainboom


Maybe it didn't effect cozy glow because she tried to use it for something else instead of chaos. She tried to do something unrelated to chaos, pinkie on the other hand, well, I think you would know


I believe than because Discord was petrified that the magic of chaos found a new receptacle in Pinky. This magic was activated only when she got her cutie mark. Fun is Chaos in a good way.


chaos magic is chaos just like it says in the name so possibly when is affected Pinkie pie it affected all of her changing her past and future but actually making it so everyone remembers it as just Pinkie pie knowing everything but it didn’t to clozy because it’s pure chaos like you said we can’t expect it to follow a path on what it will do when someone beholds it. Also we only have one example of a creature being born with chaos magic,but two of someone taking it and using it. No not just using it,almost like there injecting it into their blood/soul (if it was her soul that could explain why she was given back magic back some magic could stay with her making sure it affects her past and future as well as her being)


Isn't Fluttershy's stare magic, or Rockhoof's strength?


You: I think I think solved Pinkie Pie.

Me: I don’t believe you, no one can solve Pinkie Pie, it’s just Pinkie Pie being Pinkie Pie, don’t question and don’t even try to.

1. Pinkie Pie has being like that since the first MLP episode and at that time no one knew discord, ever since she made her first party she turned into who she is today.

2. Pinkie Pie is not the only one who breaks the laws of physics, you just showed an image of Twilight talking to Pinkie Pie literary floating without any wings, and almost everyone in the show.

3. Pinkie Pie knows stuff about other world because she travels through the portal there a little video about bloopers and there is a part that shows how Pony Pinkie Pie comes through the Canterlot High portal and the human Pinkie Pie goes to the portal where she came from and the Pony Pinkie Pie just pretends that nothing is wrong and keeps living her life happily in Canterlot.

4. I don’t think Pinkie Pie absorbed discord’s magic, she would have way more power and maybe even other abilities, the breaking laws of physics can be seen from anyone, Pinkie Pie it’s a special pony, a happy pony, she’s always full of energy and no one can figure her out so don’t try.

5. Still don’t believe you.


Jessica, age 7, says: "I like your videos and I agree with you. I think she did get that craziness from Chaos!"


Maud also has maud sense<br>She can easily get to the pony she wants to go to. She knows the way. It happened in the episode The Gift Of Maud Pie.

Maud also has maud sense
She can easily get to the pony she wants to go to. She knows the way. It happened in the episode The Gift Of Maud Pie.


Maybe when they gave cozy glow the magic they held some back because they still had trust issues if you look at there faces before and after they have the look of a knowing parent


Maybe that's why cozy is the way cozy is, maybe it's a time loop of chaos magic that made her the manipulative megalomaniac she is


My theory has been that she was the offspring to two powerfully magical unicorns who wanted an ideal child. However, realizing that Pinkie wasn't a unicorn, they cast her aside. Hence why Pinkie was adopted by the Pie family.

Kry Butterworth she said in Heartbreakers story . Her “twin” is her sister Marble Pie she said they were born just a few seconds apart but yeah it’s just fun

@Dominique Fairclough I don't recall her being a twin, and there's a good amount of evidence that she could have been adopted. Either way, it's a silly, fun, fan theory.


I just knowdist that when Cozy got the magic she couldnt control it, yet when Pinky did it seemed like she was in full control of it.....


What if pinkie pie is somehow, someway is like Discord? Like she’s chaostic and insane and then the fact that she knows random info and can brake the laws of physics on a dime- a lot like discord but more controlled, more held back or even less powerful


What if when cozy glow adsorbed the magic it stuck with her a little as well, maybe that is he reason she was able to become an alicorn in the first place. It affected her past and future.


When was there ever a problem with pinkie?    How have i never heard about this?


Honestly pinkie pie is that one character that always breaks the fourth wall


Theory number 1

Chaos magic:this happen in last episodes

Pinkie:starts from 20 years ago


My question is about cheese sandwich. He has cheese sense... so you explained pinkie sense because of absorbing discord’s magic but what about him


I always wondered why did pinkie just turn but when absorbing the magic from the bell and cozy glow grew big and celestia-like size, and pinkie didn’t turn into a alicorn


Pinkie Pie is my favorite character. I approve of Sawtooth's theory. Your welcome. XD (I'm kidding you don't need mah approval :P Love your channel! <3)


there is this random short called "double rainboom" where Rainbow Dash wentto the Powerpuff girls dimension. But, Pinkie drank an enhancement potion where she could manipulate the multiverse!


It's just pinkie being pinky don't question it. She is what makes the show interesting


Pinkie Pie has the same magic like Discord!!Ok let it be! BUT there's my theory.Pinkie has magic!! I DIDN'T noticed before I watch it.But (look carefully  Pinkie Pie);even pinkie doesn't have magic she can say "Pizza Delivering"and held pizza!!where is that pizza come from!!And She can spring (when twilight holding the door)quickly without magic!!!NO Earth pony can't do!!Ok Pinkie and Discord have same magic ok! Then when Tirek absorb discord magic;discord's magic colour is look like purple and black!! But Pinkie's magic colour is Pink!!!SO Their magic are not the same I guess.But I think Pinkie's magic is just her love I guess!! You know It may be strange ! But she can make everypony joyful and cheerful!!That is why she has magic!!Her magic is only her love and making joyful things.The real magic is her Cutie Mark!!Even she has no magic but she can still do things that no Earth pony can't do and of course joyful things too.But when Starlight Glimmer took her Cutie Mark; she can't do anything joyful and cheerful!Because of that her magic is just her love of making joys.But even she has no magic but still can do jokes and joyful things if she has her Cutie mark! But her name is Pinkie Pie; you can't explain everything!!


Would you please make a video on the real reason behind night mare moon .See the theory goes like this
If you remember the tale of the 2sisters was after Luna was banished to the moon celestia took in charge of both sun and moon if you think about it how did celestia get the power to reach the moon? although there are 2 explanations
Explanation number 1- after Luna was banished to the moon celestia use the elements of harmony to gain the power of raising the moon too
Explanation number 2 - celestia had the ability to raise the moon long before Luna was banished. Luna might have gotten to know that celestia had this power and become jealous and felt like a spare . celestia would have probably give in that position the Luna for raising the moon because she was her sister. this explains a lot and makes a lot more sense for Luna to become jealous of celestia and turn into a nightmare moon

I told you about this theory invite of you videos of yours. If you think me during make sense then please make a video about it


I know why pinkie pie could’ve had this happen to her and not just cozy glow because there’s also Celestia and Luna’s allegory magic in the bell with discord so I did  see that happening


My head cannon? Simple, Pinkie isn’t from equestria, she’s from beyond...

the 4th wall!


When he said that sounds a little far-fetched and the picture of farfetch  came on I started lmbo ( laughing my butt off )


What I think is that pinky will always be the best pony


Sawtooth: is someone watching ME???<br>Me: yes I am!

Sawtooth: is someone watching ME???
Me: yes I am!


okay,but can we talk about how pinkie's personality changes with her hair?like everybody gangsta untill her hair turns straigth lmao


Sawtooth waves: I SOLVED PINKIE PIE!!!!!

Twilight sparkle has joined the chat

Sawtooth waves: I SOLVED PINKIE PIE!!!!!

*Twilight sparkle has joined the chat*

No, you can't solve Pinkie Pie, but what if she is (dis)solving you?


Maybe she’s connected to the tenth season?

They need one anyways


maybe the cauos magic affected cozy diffrently because she was a filly and was going to be turned to stone so she had a smaller timeline for it to spread across? or maybe it has to do with the fact shes a pegasis


Fun theory.  I like the perspective-check at the end.  Ur pretty gud.


Your channel is about you being a detective of mlp and solving everything about it. You solved Pinkie Pie, why don't you solve Apple Jack's cutie mark purpose?


She definitely has her own magic. Not sure if its from the chaos magic though. The magic you see return to her is pink, after all. Not black/yellow/white/etc.


so, pinkie pulled a secret ending of henry stickmin?


“Is someone watching me!?”

All 323k of us:yuh us who do you think you were talking to?


It’s all fun and games  until pinkies hair goes straight


I’m glad you  solved Pinky pie but I also have a theory a pony THEORY pinkie is a draconaqus she represents parties surprise party she’s surprising birthday party what she looks like any holiday party I don’t know any adult party when she’s very very weird any formal party like galas weddings anniversaries family reunions is when she’s very serious or sad any celebration like New Year’s Eve is how she remembers everybody kind of doesn’t make sense though It’s the only thing I could think of


My little pony logic makes no sense somebody wakes up starts singing and they all know a dance routine somebody starts singing and suddenly there is a parade! I don’t think my little pony even has logic don’t get me wrong I love the show it is just...MY LITTLE PONY HAS NO LOGIC!!!


Sawtooth Waves:Is anyone watching me? Me:Yes probably half the world is watching you


this dud my childhood <br>and i found him again.

this dud my childhood
and i found him again.


Somebody remembers that in the first episode when discord appears he mentioned that pinkie was his favorite?

he did?  wonder why?<br>"Takes one, to know/recognize one!"

he did?  wonder why?
"Takes one, to know/recognize one!"


Wait i will clear your cosy glow when pinkie consumed the magic look at the background everything has balloons this and that which means that pinkie used a lot of the magic but cosy glow did nothing but pop out pineapple 🍍 monster 👹


Or somehow when Discord was a baby somehow his mom had a little daughter Pinkie Pie but she couldn't raise two kids so she gave Pinkie Pie off to a rock Farm as soon as she was born so does carbon have no idea that there are actually related that explains the chaos Magic