Mayra Guzman He just started when and maybe he didint have enogh time cuase its only 1 min exactly. And can we see bettr edit or recording skills from you?
Mayra Guzman, even if you were talking to sawtooth, that was really mean! Why don’t you go try animation and theories! Why don’t you go and stop judging people just because of one short video?!?!?
@Samia Qaiss there was a decent timeframe between twilight seeing the stars align and when the celebration started. NMM likely sent her to the sun in that time.
I personally think that she was trapped somewhere else and when she escaped, she travelled through the sun. Basically like how Luna comes out from the moon when she’s dream walking.
What I think is that celestia WAS banished to the sun/moon. (It could have been either, she also could have been sent to some kind of prison too, but most likely the sun.) When nightmare moon returns, celestia is gone. That is probably because nightmare moon banished her to the sun as revenge for her banishment. When nightmare moon is defeated celestia comes down from the sun, (which means she was most theoretically sent there.) and when the stars aligned for nightmare moons escape, she landed like that somewhere in ponyville. I agree with your statement.
this makes sense, especially if you consider the 2 years difference between this and Starlight's time travel episode. Still, I think that Celestia was imprisoned somewhere by Nightmare Moon, just not in the moon yet, but knew that Twilight would discover the magic of friendship, so didn't resist for a while. As for the sun rising with her, she probably just also knew that plants and trees needed sunlight. She didn't raise the sun for the summer sun celebration, and since Nightmare Moon wouldn't lower the moon, time was stopped. Unless the sun and moon had nothing to do with time. If that's the case, (which it likely is, considering that the sun and moon have to be lowered and raised daily/nightly,) then trees, more importantly to our main cast, apple trees, would soon die and life in Equestria would cease to exist. It WOULD, anyway, if it weren't for a certain princess that raised the sun as soon as it was safe to escape from wherever she was held. I don't think Celestia was imprisoned on the moon at first, though. Nightmare didn't have long to imprison Celestia, and had to deal with destroying the Elements of Harmony. So she probably only weakened her sister and decided to deal with total banishment later.
Hey Its Star Alicorns only get sparkly flowing hair and look mature when they have a lot of magic. Luna used all her magic to become Nightmare Moon and lost it when she became her normal self.
Moonlight the shiny umbreon to be fair, they never said an alicorn had to have magic to look mature and have flowing hair. If that were the case, Luna would've looked young in Princess Twilight and both princesses would've lost their float manes. Not to mention, Flurrtheart is FULL of magic but she doesn't spontaneously mature
i think her flowy main is just a representation of magic, and i think the lighter color also represents magic ,as when ponies are stripped from there power they become lighter😉
In the Nightmare Rarity comics, Luna couldn’t handle Nightmare Rarity normally, so she gained more magic and became more powerful and with that she gets flowing hair like her sister Celestia.
@awawawa twilight became an Alicorn at the end of season 3 and it took her 6 season to get flowing hair. Luna was literally a child in episode 2, and in the next season suddenly totally grown up. Yes, Alicorns do grow “higher” and have flowy her (except cadence for some weird reason), but they still take time to grow, usually. I assume you haven’t been born as an adult either, do you?
Makes sense. I had always understood it as merely that Nightmare Moon kidnapped Celestia and somehow sealed her power, but they never said exactly how or where she was. This is a good answer for that.
Interesting thought, but I see a few problems with this. Mind you this is more of a head cannon than anything else, but take what you will.
I have thought about it, and Celestia is to strong for Nightmare moon to just banish her in underder 10 seconds. If anything I think we are looking at a much more complicated picture than that.
First of all why would Celestia not be bothered by the fact that Nightmare moon would be released, and prepare more than just sending Twilight to make friends.
Second why was Nightmare moon's attacks on the six friends so... weak. She is show to be able to stop other ponies without even full use of her magic. She should have never been stopped. As the most dangerous thing she does is destroy a cliff.
So this bring about my idea.
The Elements of Harmony, banished Celestia when they released Luna from the moon, but limited the amount of power Nightmare moon could use. Which was why they had become stone and needed fresh magic to awake them agian.
In short they are making sure that Luna would return, and Celestia will be punished.
Again this is head cannon location as to why Celestia needed punishment. Celestia while she loves her sister, is not really sure how to work with or chooses not to.
Point one being I don't think she was there enough for luna to keep their bond strong, thus never noticing luna fall into darkness. Notice in S4 E 1 and 2 she is more annoyed at her sister than anything else talking about duties she must do.
You can also see this in Luna's Eclipse. After all wouldn't Celestia have taught Luna how to speak to her subject, or even interact with other ponies. Luna says her voice style is the Royal Canterlot voice.
So if anything the Elements banished her, showing her, or at least trying to point out she was partly to blame for this mess.
Eh, pretty late to the party here, but since the sunlight doesn't go out when she enters the castle, I'm pretty sure the sun is not turning into Celestia. The sun is still behind her, but the camera moves with her so we don't get to see it. So the effect equates Celestia with the sun (makes perfect sense - it's what she does) but the light remains and Celestia is clearly not the source of it. Look at :29. The sunlight is coming from the bottom left corner of the window (where the sun should be) and not from Celestia, who is toward the right.
Also, wasn't Celestia in the beginning of the episode as well? Anyway it would be a cool idea for an episode sometime - Celestia being trapped in the sun.
I think as punishment for herself for banishing her sister she casted a spell that when her sister was aided by the stars to be free she was sent to the sun and became daybreaker
Brony I agree with your theory of celestia being banished by luna but I just have a small different opinion. Celestia and I quote said " I saw the signs of nightmare moons return". She knew all about her return. She was prepared for an attack. Maybe celestia sent herself to the sun or maybe wasn't sent to the sun at all. Maybe she disappeared during the summer sun celebration because she knew that nightmare moon would be there. Maybe she went to the secret land only she twilight and cadence had ever been, and when she sensed or saw that nightmare was luna once more she returned. But remember that this is just my opinion
When starlight used the time travel spell one of the outcomes was that nightmare moon returned. Here it was shown that Celestia was banished to the moon, and not to the Sun.
That’s scientifically impossible due to the fact that the sun can burn you if you are to close to it. But I guess it’s possible due to the fact that Luna’s still alive and the moon doesn’t have oxygen.
I noticed that too! I think it makes sense. But then it seems that Celestia would have to be very heat-resistant, and Luna very cold-resistant. They'd also both have to be able to breathe when there is no oxygen and survive without food or water. I guess they are goddesses, so maybe that means they would be okay even in extreme circumstances?
ok lets take a step back here on the whole "shouldn't she be fried?" thing. the answer is in the first episode. Nightmare iscalled the mare IN the moon not ON the moon when banished she was made one with her charge thus preserving her in her current state and protecting her from things like hunger or degredation of the body in general from lack of activity,this is also why she as not efected by lack of air or the bitter cold of space. same reason the sun dosn't turn Celestia into a giant peice ofcharred pony flesh.
Interesting thought, NightMare Moon would have had 1000 years to plot her revenge, and was said to have been released by the aid of the stars, perhaps those stars not only gave Nightmare moon the ability to break the spell that banished her, but the power to banish Celestia, after all she was going to bring about the eternal darkness, in order to do so she would have to get rid of the only other pony who could raise the sun aside from herself.
I've been wondering, if Luna was sent to the moon and lived, and the possibility Celestia was sent to the sun and lived, can alicorn breathe in space? or do equestria sun and moon each have their own atmosphere?
I feel that when Celestia banished Luna to the moon, Luna was seeking revenge and planned to return to banish Celestia to the sun. I think when she got banished to the sun she took the form of the sun. It is a good theory but it might not be the whole truth. Maybe there is more to the story or maybe this isn't the case at all.
maybe she was vanished to the moon here's my explanation :- in the episode the cutie re-mark we saw in a scene if nightmare moon wasn't defeated she said :- my sister is trapped in the moon or something like that and we was able to see the moon from the castle window she was in the moon i think when the sun rised celestia was set free with her magic the sun rised and she shined like the sun
That makes so much sense! I actually didn't notice that, but seeing what happened in this video, I now know what you are saying. When I saw the title of the video, I thought it was an idea that you had for the writers to somehow incorporate into the show.
when I watched one of ink roses video, she said that lauren faust said in a tweet that she imgges that luna went to canterlot to gain more power and she banished celestia to the sun. so your theory is pretty much canon.
Well, this is unlikely. Celestia used the Elements to banish Nightmare Moon. Unless Nightmare Moon managed to steal the Elements and use them, she probably wouldn't have the power to do so. A.) The whole episode was about finding the Elements. I don't think Nightmare Moon even touched them before she started wreaking havoc. B.) She doesn't understand friendship or show any qualities of friendliness in this state, so she wouldn't even be able to use them if she wanted to.
Unless Nightmare Moon managed to gain the power to perform that powerful of a spell without the Elements, I don't think that she could have banished Celestia to the Sun.
This may be right. In The Cutie Re Mark episode, one part shows Luna being the princess and Celestia being banished in the moon (or sun). Twilight says to Starlight, that would have happened without the Mane 6. My theory may not be right, but it was fun to just share it with you 😊 Great video!
I agree with you Brony Notion, in season 5, when Starlight Glimmer intervenes in RD's rainboom, we see what it was like if some of the villains weren't defeated. Nightmare Moon was one of them, and when Spike brings up Celestia, Nightmare Moon laughs and quotes "My sister has been locked up in the moon for years, it was no worse than she sentenced me to" so perhaps Celestia was banished, and she would've stayed there for a thousand years, if Nightmare Moon wasn't defeated.
I feel that this could be agreeable. I mean, it's very possible that maybe when Luna was still Nightmare Moon, she could have been overcome with so much anger and revenge that she would do such a thing. But let's be reasonable: I've known that alicorns aren't immortal, and that if you even go 20 miles from away from the sun, you'd probably already start to burn alive. What I DO know is that alicorns can cast the most powerful spells known to Equestria. Celestia might have put a protection spell on herself before she was sent to the sun. Or if you are too skeptical and you don't trust theories, maybe you should call up Hasbro and act like a idiot in front of them. Just saying.
I actually think that celestial was hiding in the sun from nightmare moon because she didn't have the elements of harmony to fight her back and therefore was defenceless, so that is also why she had twilight and her friends inherit the elements to banish Luna to the moon once again, since that did not happen she had no need to feel afraid and came out of hiding to greet her banished sister and teach her about the equestria of today.
ignoring season 5 there are two problems with this theory 1.how do you ban someone into fire 2. Celestia can't serve as an example in the sun because no one would see it
She used the Elements of Harmony to banish her sister to the moon free-willingly whereas Twiligh Sparkle had to have her element present to then use the rest of the elements. Clearly in SE1EP1 there is no element above the others, its just a white glowing ball. But whenever you see Princess Celestia she seems to be wearing two elements - one in her crown/tiara and one on her necklace. I suppose that Princess Celestia was able to control all of the elements alone because she had honesty. kindess. generosity, laughter and loyalty within her but what gave her the power to control such strong magic? And why does she have two elements instead of one seeing that she is just a "princess"?
And when you watch the part when Princess Luna is banished to the moon you can see Twilight Sparkles element above Princess Celestia's tiara. How could this happen unless it means that Twilight Sparkle was definitely destined to have an element before she was even born?
Could you please make a video about this but in further dept. Thanks.
My main question is: -What is her element and what of?
That would completely support the idea (by cannedcreme) that Luna never wanted to hurt anyone but just be loved equally and also have her revenge on her sister.
OK i totally agree with this video because before when i watched the 1st ep i was like "hey maybe to be all mocking and in your face to Celestia, Luna banished her to the sun" this would also be an effective way to trap Celestia because the sun would not show hence no escape for Celestia.
She must’ve been banished just that evening She was present in the day when she sent twilight to make new friends and check on the festival of summer sun celebration 🎉 with what the mane 5 are doing
i think it was because Luna appears in dreams in the moon ,so celestia appears through the sun. i think it just doesn't happen regularly.and celestia also knew that twilight could do it and she wanted her to discover friendship ,so thats why i think she was missing
Wait so a banishing spell will work as long as the caster stays in a good shape,which could mean that Luna got unbanished ,since Luna is nightmare moon,and banished celestia this all could explain how king sombra was released
I get the feeling that it would be more likely that nightmare moon didn't banish her to the sun because luna seemed surprised to see her and also because I think she would have said so when she showed up at the summer sun festival
But according to Twilight's past, for example how she became Celestia's student, it's not really possible that she was banished for one thousand years. Not mentioning the fact that someone had to raise the sun AND the moon (otherwise the world ended up like in the fanfic i got my profile pic from).
Or she felt remorseful enough that she banished her self to the moon and set it so only when luna was free she would be free as well 👀....just a theory
This is more proof if the elements if disharmony because they are opposite to the elements if harmony the elements if disharmony can probably ban a good person. As celestia said something along the lines of this "when I banished Luna to the moon she had been completely consumed by selfishness, but when you and your friends used the element there was something good inside her and the elements freed her from herself." The elements if harmony can ban evil and free the good, therefore showing that if a person is good they can be banned by the elements of harmony, and if someone is becoming selfish than they can be tired evil by the elements of disharmony. If Luna really loved celestia she wouldn't have turned against her without a push, this leads me to think that maybe someone used the elements if disharmony to make her become nightmare moon, and what if that someone was star swirl the bearded, he did dissapear without a trace with hopes if not getting caught and in trouble, which also makes me think, could starswirl the bearded be king Sombra, I mean if star swirl the bearded used the elements of disharmony than he probably became evil and tried to create an ally; nightmare moon, and since he disappeared this could mean he became Sombra and was turned into a shadow by celestia and after Luna was slowly over taken by jealousy.
I think Celestia merely hid herself within the Sun and watched Twilight undergo her tirals until Nightmare Moon was defeated and Luna clensed of the darkness that had consumed her.
i would think that too but when Nightmare Moon attacked her, Celestia was still strong so Nightmare Moon tried to banish her to the sun (which she rises) like how Celestia banished her to the moon (which Luna raised) but Celestia might have done magic to make it seem like she was but could have cast a spell for her to appear when the sun rises.
no no , celestia's banishment was to the moon you have to watch season 5 finally when nightmare moon took over equestria and banished celestia to the moon for a 1000 of years
meh, all of you who haven't watched season 4-5 entirely would be still agreeing to this theory, ENTIRELY. Yes, i'm not gonna spoil it for those who have not watched yet, so i'm just gonna say that... the elements of harmony is crucial in banishing creatures.
i think it is an cool idea but should be explored more because it wasn't for a thousand day on the thousandth year that " the stars will aid her escape", why was't it included for Celestia?
Think deeper, if she was trapped in the sun... Then who RAISED the sun during that time? Well, it can’t be Luna! She was right there when the sun was raised.
Hang on! Does celestia have a element of harmony? I mean she always wears a necklace with a gem, just like 5 of the main 6 ponies elements. Is it possible that this is true?
tia's hair became multi colored when she used the elements of harmony on luna. luna was still really young the time tia banished her in the moon. which explains why luna is a kid when twilight and the others defeated her.
Holy heck I was so little when this came out, obeying when someone said duck and getting yelled at because that's not what that means when I did just that Gosh I keep the most random of memories, and now writing this comment + watching this video will be one of them. Maybe. We'll see.
So Nightmare Moon has already won. And if it wasn't for her lame traps, the elements of harmony would never have been activated and used against her. What an incompetent mare.
I think Luna did banished tia to the sun but on an other note tia banished Luna to the moon with the elements so how would Luna be able to do that without the elements
Huh. I....never really thought about that. I know its a theory but it seems like they should explain what happened in the show to clear things up. Just an idea. :P
What an amazing theory before I thought that if luna can be banished to the moon then celestia can be banished to the sun I have another theory how luna became nightmare moon is when she replaces the sun with the moon then black rays came out zapping her and transforming her into nightmare moon so what if celestia can do the same thing if she replaces the moon with the sun it would send out heat ray's zapping her and transforming her into day breaker
I have to say know. Remember Celestia had to tuse the Elements to banish Nightmare moon. And proven nightmare Moon is no match for the Elements. So likely Celestia hanged back on the Gamble of the mare 6 doing what she could not. Get her true sister back.
Wait a minute, if Celestia was banished to the sun wouldn’t she be burning alive? Oh well shes Celestia the princess of the sun she’s probably immune lol
i’m not trying to send any hate I’m just trying to spread some laughs, Love your videos by the way🧡
Maybe The mane reflected her power , maybe she got drained of her power , because as we see in one of the episodes were twilight drinks this potion in begging of session 4 , she has sneek peeks of the past , and I you luna with her stary flowing like mane , before she became night mare moon . I believe when she returns and twilight defeats her .. Could her power could have drained ?
Because when she was turned back, some of her magic, like raising the moon was gone, and it took a whole season to get it back, since Luna's hair in Luna Exclipsed is flowing
It was just a flashy entrance, to show off. I think Celestia could have easily hung out, in the sidelines, having high confidence the girls could handle this on their own and is just waiting till the job was done. Not to interfere.
Saw a commercial for mlp before this, what are the chances! Anyway, it said something about a new pony called Starlight Glimmer in the new season. Twilight Sparkle Sunset Shimmer Starlight Glimmer :>
celestia being an older alicorn has a lot of power so she is able to banish luna to the moon and when luna returns as nightmare moon she also has a lot of power making her able to banish celestia to the sun.
It can’t be possible because Nightmare Moon couldn’t get the elements of harmony. Remember that Celestia used the elements to banish Nightmare Moon to the moon. Just saying
Well, if Luna get revenge on Celestia, she will be free in the moon. How she will get revenge if she was still in the moon? She was not banished to the sun. Maybe she needs to rise the sun first then Celestia was there. That shine thing was acually from the sun. In this case, i think that was my idea.
Well actually on the last episode of season 5 starlight glimer uses one of starswirl the bearded spells to go back in time and stop the sonic rainboom then back in the present it was night and nightmare moon was the ruler of equestria and banished celstia to the moon for a thousand years but you should watch the episode
Wowwwwoow this is so wrong i mean did you even see season 5 episode 25 and 26 in that Luna herself clearly says that she banished celestial to the moon just see but i have no idea what is wrong with their hair Tia hair is pink when she was a baby (true fact )but then how in the world did it become multi couler and Luna hair i really supposes to flow but it wasn't why
+Surbhi Sharma When Celestia used the elements of harmony against Luna, Twilight's element was too strong. Her hair was pink and normal before that event. Twilight's element caused something about her ( or her appearance ) to change. Her hair turned tri - colored and wavy.
Just go watch the lullaby for a princess animation.
+Surbhi Sharma when defeated by the mane six, Luna lost most of her magic for a short period of time. her hair, ( my theory )is only wavy and sparkly when she has all of her magic.
+Surbhi Sharma When people start talking about outdated information, please look at the date to make sure that these people aren't stupid. If it's an old video, then that's why they're saying it.
From what I get, when Luna was banished to the moon, she kept her power, along with the nightmare power. When the elements were casted onto Luna, it took away the nightmare. That flowing hair thing. It happens when someon-I mean pony has strong power. When you are a Luna who just got a nightmare substance taken out of you, you gunna need to re-charge that power. So for the first season, her hair was.. Normal. As her power regenerates, her hair flows. Atleast.. I think.
This was posted 2 years a go meaning that the episode wasn't released ALSO meaning you should check the date of the video BEFORE you start saying, "YOUR WRONG!!!!"
+Surbhi Sharma When Luna First Turned Into Nightmare Moon(When She Was Young)Celestia Used The Element Of Harmony (Twilights Cutie Mark) There Was A Big Rainbow Explosion And When Lunas Hair Didn't Flow Because She Was Young K?
Surbhi Sharma when natural Alicorns grow old, then and only then does their hair get flowey. The colors other than pink probably just appeared slowly over time.
I don't think she was banished to the sun but rather went there to see her parents spirits for advice OR letting twilight prove the power of true friendship, find the elements, and defeat nightmare moon
quick q. I always wouldve thought Celestia and Luna were twins. but when Luna is "purified" again, shes a filly, not a mare like Celestia or like her past self, NightMARE Moon. are they not tiwns or did her aging process come to a complete stop when she turned into Nightmare Moon?
Banish too the sun?! I dont thats right...if tia is at the sun she should be burning and died by now...i think celestia is at the place where twilight turn into a princess... remember the song that tia sang? "I watched you from that very first day.." shes at that place it must be..cause when twilight returns to the ground and turns into a princess her cutie was shown...when tia returns from the 2nd ep of season 1 the sun rises and she appears...thats what i think :) hope u understand ^-^
@vampirelya gaming/drawings Princess Celestia is immortal. Same thing if Luna was sent to the moon she didn't die because of loss of oxygen. Celestia would have survived. Just my opinion.
@vampirelya gaming/drawings I'm pretty sure that when Luna was sent to the moon, it was more like she was converted into a spirit, and encased in the moon, which would explain the strange apparition of "The Mare in the Moon". I believe that, for a short time, Celestia was also converted into a spirit or non-corporeal entity and trapped in the sun. But, you did bring up an interesting argument. I guess the only one who really knows is Mrs. Faust herself.
Yeah ur right :3 but..how about the song? "I watched u from the very first day" doesnt that tell us that she was there all this time? My opinion ofcoures v-v
First off: Kinda a creepy, stalker-ish song. I mean, seriously.....creepy. And I just assumed that Celestia was watching them from the sun. I also assumed that Luna was watching Equestria from the moon, but those are just my baseless assumptions.
I was thinking the same thing about celestia being on the sun... She would die of heat. Unlike how Luna was actually on a life sustainable moon. As seen in the nightmare rarity comic.
@Tayla Martin The moon.....does not sustain life. In fact, if you were on the surface of the moon without a special suit, (And somehow not suffocating) you would either burn or freeze to death, depending on which side of the moon you were on. Basically, if your not an Alicorn getting trapped on either the sun or moon means certain death.
Wait what if when luna was sent to the moon theres a jail built for her or she just goes into the moon and become one of the moon..why is the moon has a pony on it? It must be :D if im correct i just though of this so...yeah..
+karena everitt yes, I am well aware of that. Like I said, "as seen in the nightmare rarity comic" yes, I know. If the moon is sustainable then why not the sun? It wouldn't make ANY sense that Tia would be living on hot molten and a place where it's going to melt u.
@Tayla Martin I've never read the Nightmare Rarity comic (Because I despise Rarity....), but neither sun nor moon can remotely support life. Celestia surviving on the sun makes just as much sense as Luna surviving on the moon. Which is none. It's physically impossible on both. That's where I get my theory from. You can believe whatever you want to about this, though. I guess, I doesn't really make much of a difference anyway, all we know was that Tia was gone, and then she was back.............Actually, why do I even care?! I don't even like Celestia......
Yeah but she's basically an immortal sun god who has absolute power in the realm where no other person could challenge her if she wanted to take over equestria. I mean hell tirek with the power of every pony in existence was still only just equal to twilight with the power of three other alicorns. They'd stand no chance if she went crazy. So yeah I'm certain she could survive being in the sun.
+vampirelya gaming/drawings I think it was just the surface of the sun, and it didn't hurt her. Luna would be dead to since the moon would have NO oxygen and she would die from lack of oxygen!
@TaylorKarmenDoesAnimations LOL idk....we might just be wasting our time talking about this i mean...the show itself doesnt really care about logic :P even pinkie pie broke the forth wall...and remember the time pinkie's nose and mouth got deleted from trixie how the hell is she still alive without breathing... sorry if this is too long ^w^
I like the theory, but I doubt Celestia would be burned and dead. after all, she's pretty much the supreme goddess of Equestria. she's immortal, I'm sure. Luna would be dead if she was banished to the moon, no oxygen and no food = you can't live. I don't think "banishing to the moon/sun" should be taken very seriously, but metaphorically. Maybe they aren't literally ON THE PLACE THEY WERE BANISHED TO, but they were sort of.. trapped in where they were banished to. and although she could be at the place where she took twilight... I don't think its likely. she's an alicorn, so she has a shit ton of magic, so I'm sure she could see Twi anywhere she went, without having to go to a specific place. So basically saying, Celestia was sent to the sun and that is that. feel free to argue though.
Um...Sorry, but Luna and Celestia ARE NOT IMMORTAL. They just have extended life spans and grow faster then normal ponies. Its from royal blood. Twilight, though, since was changed at adulthood, does not have a extended life span.
@TaylorKarmenDoesAnimations LOL Well, you can't always trust everything the fandom says, but the wiki is usually pretty skeptical about unconfirmed information. I dunno, I kinda like the idea of them being immortal, but if the aren't, doesn't really affect me. I like knowing things but completely disregard any information that I don't really care for. I'm gonna go check the wiki now.
Hmm... Being celestia's niece I really dont think she was banished to the sun, but nice theory. I'll make sure to ask mom if she did something like that to aunt Tia.
there has been many seasons but none point to why she was banished to the sun? But how could Luna Aka. Night Mare Moon banish Celestia if she doesn't the " elements of Hamony" Good job Brony i just noticed it now keep up the great work!
Sorry but this is a very ridiculous theory. It was the only time that has happened, yes. It feels to me that was probably some sort of light spell for a grand entrance. Even in cartoons, there is logic that says you would just burn to nothing if you touched the sun. Also, the reason Celestia even sent Luna to the moon was to protect Equestria and herself from her wrath. So if Nightmare moon would have had the ability to send Celestia to the sun, then she could escape from the moon and/or attack Equestria and Celestia. Therefore, Princess Celestia banishing Princess Luna to the moon would be altered useless. Don't bring the theory that Luna did attack Equestria or her sister because in the first season of MLP, a lot of the ponies weren't even fully aware of Luna's existence. In fact, a lot of the residents thought she was just a pony-tale. Look more into it in the next theory, dude.
I thought it was interesting. If Luna didn't die from the lack of atmosphere, food, and water on the moon for a thousand years, why couldn't Celestia survive a few hours on the sun?
@Dana Baldus How do you know how physics works in Equestria , it is another dimension, and accordingly, it works quite differently from the laws of physics chemistry biology and especially astrology we know.
@משה ליאב לסרי Exactly. Do we even know what the sun and moon actually are in Equestria? Everyone keeps assuming that they're like our sun and moon, even though all the evidence from the show keeps suggesting otherwise.
Heck, I suspect the world ponies in Equestria live on might even be flat, as that's the only way something like "Raising the Sun" even makes sense.
Edit: Actually their world is not flat. Pinkie made a joke about the earth being round in the Hearths Warming Eve episode, and Twilight owns a globe.
This Line Troubles Me '''aware of Luna's existence'' Even My Little Ponies Cant Last 1000 Years (Besides Alicorns) And Celestia Would Probably Keep Luna A Secret So The Ponies Didn't Fear Celestia Since Luna Was Celestia's Sister The Residents Of Equestria Might Think Celestia Was Involved In The Evil
in season 4 twilight drink a potion Zecora gave her. and she saw the past of when Tia (celestia) banished Luna to the moon using the elements. but luna she rises the moon to eclips the sun and then she became NightMare Moon, but when she did this she looked suprised that it worked but, what if Tia rises the sun to eclips the moon, would it do the same to Tia as it did to Luna?
@msmissjordan1 I totally agree with you but I have some other theries I think Celestia got her multi-colored mane after she banished Luna and after Luna realized she made a horrible mistake turning into nightmare moon and reached her true potential of Bruner of the night she got her flowy sparkly princess mane as seen in the next episode
Ever thoutgh why there isnt a Qeeun ? I know for the first time ever starswril aberded took a earth pony made her a unicorn .They study for many years .Finaly he gave her wings used the elements of harmony to give her etrnal youth .Her name was... Hastel .Qeeun of ever free forest or something.Starswril trusted her.She is celestia older sister . He give her magic to free him.they arqewd . Starswril banised her.Celestia and starswril also studied .making her a alicorn he wanted to make her qeeun but the magic of a qeeun cannot be given twice.Luna was given a horn and a pair of wings.before she was born.making her prinses of the moon. Thats why there was prinsses
Ok, I know that this is a old video, but I have some theories about this. Yes, I think that Celestia was banished to the Sun, but in a different way. Given the time between when NMM was freed and the time she arrived at the summer sun celebration, it's not very likely that she was able to banish Celestia in that short amount of time. What I think happened is that sense the two sisters once yielded the elements together the elements were somehow connected to them (This also explains why their cutimarks are on the Tree of Harmony). When Luna was banished the connection was broken and Celestia and Luna will never Use the Elements again. However, I believe that The elements would not just let Celestia do something like that and get off Scott-free. I think that once NMM returned the Elements backfired on Celestia and banished her to the sun until Luna was returned to normal, and only then would she be able to return to Equestria. @The Brony Notion
Well maybe its different in Equestria maybe Celestia has powers that keep her from getting toasted. I think it makes total sense if u realize equestrian is a whole different world then ours!
Yah I think your right and I have evidence. Celestia used the Elements of Harmony to in prison Luna, and in part 2 when Twilight Sparkle ran into the castle and found the elements NIGHTMARE MOON WAS THERE! So she must of had the elements the whole time so it is very likely she prisond Celestia in the sun.:(
No that's not right!When the mane 6 are walking though The Everfry Forest it looks into the sky and at the stars which I noticed were in the shape of Celestia.Celestia had been banished to the stars, guys!!
0 likes
•C h o c o•2020-09-13 07:51:08 (edited 2020-09-13 07:51:21 )
Luna banished to the sun, Celestia banished to the sun (?) What's next? Twilight or Starlight banished to the stars?
Wait a dang minute, nightmare moon was not gonna be able to raise the sun (or if she could she would not want to because she wanted the night to last forever yea you know the story) then where was actually Celestia? Where was the sun? Celestia was raising the sun and the moon before Nightmare Moon came back but if nightmare moon wasn't defeated the sun wouldn't be there anymore so that means celestia just vanished? I mean no sun = no celestia
Luna got a hair change when she was nightmare moon. But Celestias hair was already shins and wavy, so did she get banished for this to happen? My theory is that equestria is really on a planet similar to the sun, and all the ponies are trapped there, but only celestia and Luna are or were banished. But how would Celestia raise the sun? Many planets have multiple moons, so it is possible for this world to have another sun.
you see if celestia was being banished to the sun she shouldn't be returning into the original sate she should be solar flare from a comic if you didn't know.
Celestia on the sun: HOLY CRAP THIS BURNS!! MAKE IT STOP!!! Luna: You were only on there for a minute, still 999 years, 11 months, 29 days, 23 hours, and 59 minutes to go. Have fun by the way. Celestia: NOOOOOOOO
In the season five last episode when evil Luna ruled she said "My sister has been banished for year" , so ya, she was banished to the sun,a d she would still be there if the mane six did not find the elements of harmony
If you watch lullaby for a princess you'll see the end the battle between Princess Luna aka Nightmare Moon vs Celestia easy. Whenever Celestia vanishes Luna to the moon she gets a blast of energy and her mane changes 😃😛
Sorry but it makes no sense that Celestia was banished to the sun. Bassicaly Celestia is the a part of the sun, so Luna is a part of the moon. Like how Luna comes from the moon everytime that she's in a dream. Besides, Celestia is stonger than Luna, the sun plays a more important role in nature, thought maybe Luna is just as strong she might be able to change the tides if she got really heated.
Sorry to say, but I think you should re-watch season 2 episode 3. Celestia travels the same way except that she come out of the sunset instead of the sunraise.
Wait so since thats the first episode to meet celestia the first time then she should raise the sun like that not like raising arms up to bring the sun. ITS A MISTAKE THEY HAVE ON THE REST OF THE EPISODES XD
No Celestia isn’t banished to the sun in the cutie remark when twilight entered a realm Nightmaremoon said Celestia was banished to the moon I think Celestia was banished to the moon
If you guys know the episode 'Magical Mystery Cure' Princess Celestia is in 'Heaven' so was she in heaven. What also explains this is the Lullaby for a Princess Anamation.
I think she did bashed to the sun becuase when starlight entered the timespell nightmare moon say ,(she been in prison for a thousand years after she bashed her to the moon for thousand years )so that might make senses
I Object your Honor! I agree with the Commentants. How do you think Celestia taught Twilight or became her mentor? Via Twitter or Facebook? Dude! You're too theory than common sense!
nahh. good theory but guys its celectia were talking about the head princess it just means shes super important and she wants to look good and cool and dramatic and speaking of dramatic , the question is answered she just wants to make a big grand dramatic entrance like she does get with it
Wait, If celestia WAS banished to the sun, wouldn't the heat burn her to a crisp? The sun must be to hot for ponys, so how did celestia survivde?!?!?!?!?
I dont believe this. If celestia was banished to the sun then wouldn't nightmare would use the elements of harmony? nightmare isn't kind which doesn't power the element of kindness nor honest,nor any but magic. i think that she vanished on purpose. she wanted to teach twilight about friendship. she knew it was coming thus she vanished so that twilight can learn about the magic of friendship and make friends. if celestia didnt vanish then twilight would still be with out friends.
I thought Luna controlled the stars then Groger since he was banished to the stars after that I think it is StarSwirl! I dont know so what do u think?🤔🤔🤔.
In the story it sayd that celestia raised the sun and moon so she became stronger don't you think? I think she got power to be the sun and she got the power to be immune to heat🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I just noticed that in the episode Princess Twilight Sparkle Twilight saw nightmare moon ( as an adult ) she was banished to the moon. But in season one when nightmare moon was defeated then luna was a little filly. This doesn't make sense!!
wait a minute. here's somethin to think about. when celestia is approaching luna there's a dark mist around her. could nightmare moon be coming back? what's the backstory behind that?
theory only: I saw when princess lunas mane was pink and it bothered me that I think when she was banshied to the sun agein theory only her man was began to flow but am just saying this all ways bothered me
u know if celestia can banish luna to the moon can luna do it and why cant they make a princess of stars cause luna is pretty much known for the moon and hardley ever the stars!
Luna was evil she was banished to moon so there she had no power when she came back her nightmare moon self came out + Luna and celestia were given these type of manes as rewards get it now
Wait,you might be right,since when Luna crashed the party she said "Your Dear Princess Is gone." Or some thing like that :p She might had gotten revenge like that and SENDED her to the SUN and then blah blah blah curse broke blah blah Celestia returns blah blah HAPPY EVER AFTER
I think that theory is true because celestia was never hurt or whatever so Luna never got free but that did happen to Luna so celestia got free. See what I mean?
If what you say in this video is true don't you think nightmaremoon should be ranked higher in the best villain video. Just think celestia had to use the element's of harmony one of the most powerful magic in equestria to banish nightmaremoon to the moon but. If it is true that nightmaremoon banished celestia to the sun then that means she had more or the same power as the element's of harmony. You would think that that should put her at least 1 more point above or the same as queen chrysalis and sunset shimmer.
Botánica Anaisa Her villain name was Daybreaker. Having her powers switched with Luna's, she either visited her own nightmare or Starlight's. The episode is called "A Royal Problem".
why is Luna's hair a single color now? because when they banished discord, Luna's hair was multicolored, and the first time they banished him it was before Celestia banished her to the moon. maybe it's a sign of power? since when Celestia was small, she must've not have that much magic, but gradually became better with magic and then her hair became the rainbow flowy hair it is now. Does this mean that twilight or cadence will get multicolor flowy looking hair in the future???
Sorry Brony Notion, but this theory is incorrect. Celestia was never banished to the sun. Celestia appeared after Nightmare Moon was defeated and became Luna once again.
she would die if she came out of the sun my theary is that she was band to the moon think about it luna means moon but celestia means star the sun is the bigist star but she would be dead by then i dont think this theary is right if you where band to the sun for a thousned years you would die just by being there so my thoughts about this is that she was bannd to the moon
How? Celestia had not the power to Banish Luna alone she needed the Elements of Harmony to do so i think that she used her Magic to do that teleportation kind of think :D i mean... S1 Trollestia FTW as we all know :D
good idea I think that's what happened, but if you've ever seen the pictures of Luna on the moon,(see Luna let it go) what would the surface of the sun look like when Celestia was on it? Wouldn't she just get burned up?:( unless the surface is different than our sun, which I don't think it is. Unless.... something "magical" was protecting Celestia, or this isn't possible sorry, Brony Notion :(
I don't think this is an accurate theory. Let's look back at when each pony told how they got their cutie mark to CMC. When Twilight was telling her story, Celestia was in the story, when Luna was banished. After Luna was banished, there was a 1000 year peace, and Twilight bought Luna back so if Celestia was banished during the 1,000 year peace, how can you explain Twilight being Celestia's student?
Nightmare Moon came back on the longest day a thousand years after being banished to the moon by her sister, Princess Celestia. Upon her return, Nightmare Moon may have banished Princess Celestia to the sun in the hopes of ruling over all of Equestria with no threat to her power (not realizing that Twilight Sparkle and her friends would be able to defeat her by acquiring the powers from the Elements of Harmony). Basically, there WAS 1,000 years of peace while Nightmare Moon was banished... Just that one day of her return was when Princess Celestia could have been banished.
nah, it’s just that there’s a negative connotation towards queens in animated media, you know, it’s sorta to do with the whole “evil stepmother” thing. celestia was actually originally meant to be called “queen celestia” but hasbro decided against it. seems like they’ve since gone against that idea with the inclusion of queen novo of the hippogriffs.
Celestia shouldve been sent to the sun when banished yet they say and say she was on the damn moon makes absolute no goddamn sense and if so then celestia should be in there for a thousand sun's like Luna? So how the fuck did she got out ???
Alyssa Canonico She was allegedly banished for 1,000 years and I guess her sentence either expired or was commuted. My question is how did she even survive for any length of time in an environment with no oxygen?
that’s the thing - nobody would “watch over” equestria, nightmare moon would be ruling equestria with an iron hoof. it’s even shown in one of the timelines twilight travels to that if nightmare moon was never defeated, celestia would be banished to the moon just like she was.
um mis surbri I know how celestia got her colorful main in a mini show I saw it says that Tia and Luna got their mains like that to show that they have their full power and means that their stronger
This is possible but celestia was there when twilight sparkle was there and didn’t the banishment with princess Luna happen before twilight sparkle was born???
If Luna was banished to the moon for 1,000 years, how is Celestia still alive to see her freed? No offense, but did she commute her sentence, did she have a time machine, or did God allow her to live that long as part of the divine right to rule or something?
The crystal ponies! They have been alive for over a thousand years! Also that is funny that you bring pinkie clones up because I just finished watching a video about how a pinkie clone (yes one didn’t die, watch the episode where rarity opens up a new shop in manehatten) is Tirek, at first it made no sense but in the end a made a little bit of sense, but thinking about it again it makes no sense
So they are still ponies, and the crystal empire is part of equestria even though it is far away from most other places in equestria, think of it like this Alaska didn’t seem like it should be part of America considering how far away it is from the rest of America but it is still part of America you could say the same thing With Hawaii
Because since the crystal empire is so far north it needs its own alicorn to keep away the cold and rule, if there is some sort of problem celestia can’t just be like oh oof gotta go, unless it was really important of corse, but with an alicorn of its own you don’t need someone traveling across the whole contry or whatever to solve a small problem boom
The Kitten Gamer The Kitten Gamer So that means she is, in essence, more of a royal governor than a princess. No offense, but why is it called the "Crystal Empire" and not the "Crystal Crown Dependency"?
I belive she is a princess and a royal governor Man just over a month ago I never knew I could have a long conversation about MLp thank you brony Notion I love mlp again
Hmm you have a good point, mabye, uh I dunno, just realized first we where talking about pony lifespans now we are talking about the crystal empire talk about changing the subject
The entire series, 1 the first time I forgot the episode name 2. Slice of life 3. The gift of maud pie, if you pause it at the exact right time when rarity is throwing a whole bunch of stuff you see twilights staff witch is pretty funny why would they be selling that
The Kitten Gamer OK, then. I just saw your comment that says you like Pinkie Pie, so I have a few questions about her, but I'm not sure whether I should ask them all here.
One of my biggest questions about her, though, is how does she perform her cartoonish stunts? Is she some sort of a magician who knows a lot about magic tricks or is she simply a really successful physicist?
The Kitten Gamer Possibly. I'm still somewhat skeptical about the "Pinkie sense."
What I'm really asking about is how she is seemingly bound by completely separate laws of physics ("cartoon physics") than those that apply to the rest of the characters.
She is secretly from spongebob!!!! Dun dun duuuuun. Ok ok idk it’s very confusing because it’s like she knows she is on a TV show, and she can just fall apart and then put herself back together (you saw that episode right) It’s like pinkie pie is just not from MLP wait! That gives me an idea, what if she isn’t well she obisly is but what if she is from a different dimension, and she came to equestria using, magical thingy stuff, and in that world most ponies, people or whatever lives there (who knows mabye she changed her appearance to fit in) has that confusing logic. Dunno just a theory, but if she is from another dimention then maybe she went there to send a distress signal but soon realized she woundn’t be able to tell her “parents” and “sisters” the truth so she decided to stay in this land of equstria because of everything she has done there and knew how everyone would feel if she left
The Kitten Gamer One of my ideas actually was that she is a diplomatic ambassador from a universe where different laws of physics apply and, as such, has been granted diplomatic immunity from MLP's laws of physics.
The theory that I've come up with and find most plausible, however, is that all of this is simply just a set of magic tricks/illusions. (This would mean that the multiple slices of her are simply from a variant on the "saw someone in half" trick, for example.) If not that, however, my next go-to explanation is that she has an extensive knowledge of physics that even surpasses Twilight's.
I have not watched enough of the series to know where she got her powers for sure, but it's sometimes cool to think about. Speaking of which, I also like to think about whether or not she could fool Penn and Teller on "Fool Us" if she somehow came to this world. They, too, have tested the laws of physics, but have been baffled before by equally as sorcerous feats. Do you think she could fool them? I'm personally uncertain.
The Kitten Gamer OK, then. I'm just glad that the boundary between reality and fiction is impossible to breach, otherwise we should expect far worse to happen than a pink pony sorceress fooling Penn and Teller more than Shawn Farquhar did. (Funnily enough, though, there is a video that may have been made by some of the VA's from the show about Pinkie breaking out of a computer screen.)
By the way, does it seem as though there is a canonical explanation as to her mysterious abilities?
I just thought of an idea!!! What if pinkie was going to tell ponyville the truth but then twilight cane so she decided to put it off to throw a party, but then she discovered she had to be the bearer of the element of laughter and she thought telling everybody the truth would make them not want to be her friend, making it so the Elements of harmony wound’t work because you need harmony to use the elements of harmony you need, well harmony
I just thought of something different, remember that pinkie pie in castle-mania well what if that is a clone pinkie, pinkie has a great memory but that pinkie playing the organ didn’t know she could play the organ. The real pinkie can play every instrument ever and she has a great memory so she should know if she could play the organ, but this pinkie didn’t know she could,
The Kitten Gamer As a student of the piano, it was rather easy for me to learn how to play the organ, so that isn't surprising at all because she already knows how to play the accordion, so all she really needs to learn is how to use the pedals and the drawbars. She may not have known it was so easy to learn because there aren't many full-fledged organs to go around there, but that's just my opinion.
The other theory may sound pretty interesting, but I believe something like it actually happened in the "Equestria Girls" movie with Twilight.
No offense, but my question is whether you know the canonical explanation is if there even is one yet.
Also the thing with pinkie pie falling apart and putting herself back together she really did fall apart because she didn’t just do it to show everypony it just happened
The Kitten Gamer Perhaps either she always wanted to learn the organ and that was the only place she knew that had one or she did whatever it was she did to predict where Rainbow Dash would be.
No offense, but would there be any particular reason as to why she would fall apart without wanting to show off her ability to perform parlor tricks or something like that?
She just fell apart no one was even paying attention to her they where paying attention to cadence and Shining armour because they just said they where having a baby
The Kitten Gamer OK, but I'm not sure how to explain it if she did it without her own knowledge. If that's the case, we may have bigger problems.
To your point, though, it seems as though it's impossible for it to merely be stage magic because it would ruin the plot. I actually did have a thought, though: what if, in the style of Monty Python and Deadpool, the so-called "fourth wall" does not exist (i.e. the characters know we are watching)? That could possibly explain how she could pull off such magic tricks: they are entirely for our amusement and have no practical purpose in their universe, but I'm not sure about this.
Your theory dose make sense, but I have to disagree only pinkie and twilight know about us watching them, I have proof, watch the end of boast busters as the screen is becoming black pinkie opens it and climbs in then twilight teleports in and gives pinkie her mouth back, and in the one where pinkie pie knows at the end she shakes her head at the audience and maybe she fell apart to entertain the audience. I think we might be on to something!
The Kitten Gamer That may be a pretty good explanation as well, but we'd still then be missing out on how she does it for practical effect and when others are watching (e.g. chasing Rainbow Dash by appearing out of nowhere, slowing her fall to not make as much noise, and disappearing into Applejacks's apple bucket).
I belive pinkie for whatever reason has the magic of an alicorn except trapped in the body of an earth pony and even without a horn or wings this excessive magic affects her in different ways, gives her too much energy, makes her run crazy fast, gives her an amazing memory, and all that stuff that only the one and only pinkie can do, oh and also pinkie sense. Ether that or she is from a different dimention or other headcannos that u can think of
The Kitten Gamer No offense to you, but I think I have been told that Earth ponies have naturally superior physical strength, so her speed may be simply explained by the fact that she's the pony equivalent of a world-class track star. I don't know whether this is true, though.
That explanation could make sense, but I'm not sure how that could be possible.
I have an idea of what could have happened. She was in the fields of the rock farm and found a little pink rock she took to it her room to look at later. When she was in her room later that night She picked it back up and showed her parents. Her parents took it from her, knowing it was a magical gem and they knew a little filly should not have such magic, but when her parents took it away she got zapped. A zap of magic, because that Little Rock was connected to the element of laughter, and was on the rock farm because of destiny trying to find the future bearer of its magical properties. It zapped her because the gem knew it was this pink filly that would become the future bearer of the event of laughter and when it zapped her it gave her magic, too much of it. If she gained that magic slowly it woundn’t effect her as much but she got the magic from an element of harmony in just a few seconds this was too much magic for her to take in within just a few seconds. Yet she couldn’t use this magic and she felt fine soon afterward. The next day she was working on the fields wondering about what happened until she saw the sonic rainboom looking at it gave her the ability to unlock this magic, and figure out the meaning of life (ok not really) but it did unlock the magic she gained the night before, the tree of harmony gave her the idea to plan a party starting the journey of her getting her cutie mark and become the element of laughter’s future bearer.
The Kitten Gamer You're welcome. Another thought I had is that as the most successful physicist in Equestria, she spends a lot of time researching higher (4 or more) dimensional solid figures, which could explain how she knew Discord was hidden in a box. (Her advanced knowledge of physics would also likely explain a lot more...)
I thought of more when it zapped pinkie it gave her magic only the element of laughter itself should have part of this magic connects it to the tree of harmony whitch means pinkie herself is connected to the tree of harmony with whitch is by pinkie sense may work because the tree can sense the future I think
No because if twilight got the elements of Magic’s magic then her abilities will be a lot better, and think about it. Without all her energy and crazy stuff whitch always makes me laugh would you or other ponies laugh at her as hard? I have some evidence that she has Pegasus magic. In secrets and lies she was walking on clouds, sure twilight just used her spell. NO pinkie pie had balloons attached to her but she could still walk on the clouds. The balloons where just there so rainbow doesn’t question how she is walking on clouds. If rainbow asks twilight about the whole situation twilight would have no idea and then rainbow could possibly figure out what happened to her on the rock farm.
I also think the elements contain stronger than alicorn magic. Could six alicorns defeat discord or nightmare moon or any villain who they used the elements of harmony on. No so the elements must be stonger than alicorns. Also I have evidence that pinkie could have some of the elements of laughters magic. When pinkie didn’t feel like she had friends (party of one) she was really messed up. Without the other elements the element of laughter proves useless and with pinkie feeling alone the magic could drain from her, changing how she acts, of corse she will always love parties and that kind of thing, but without the elements of laughter’s magic she won’t be the same. Also
when the tree sensed pinkie didn’t feel normal, being connected to her it tried to help her, but that “help” gave her the bright idea to try to become friends with objects the tree probably could have just taken over her body and brain (maybe) to fix it but if the tree did do that it would use to much of its magic and cause the events in princess twilight sparkle to happen sooner. This would also, give her long term effects and also mess her up after it left her, and being the tree of harmony it knew all of this, and yes we know for sure that the tree of harmony has a mind of its own watch season 8 episode 16 I think I will check later.
Also, I get that this is a public forum, but isn't it weird that almost all of our responses have at least one like? Is it possible that these are all from the same person? If so, the "like" button seems to have lost its value here (no offense). If not, we must be really coming up with some great theories!
But I think she only had those balloons to make sure rainbow didn’t suspect anything, I still think that and I think she could have still walked on the clouds without the balloons because of what I think happened to her as a filly
I did it because the more likes means more people will see it and if many people see it and like it the brony notion might see it and make a video on it.
The Kitten Gamer That sounds very interesting, but that would likely mean there'd need to be a "real" Pinkie for the changeling Pinkie to base his/her disguise on.
What my head cannon from before is why only twilight became an alicorn. If pinkie had something to manipulate with her magic then the things logic defying things she dose won’t be possible. She would also become more like her family (no offense to maud she is awesome) The worst part is she woundn’t have the confidence to use the element of laughter and fulfill her destiny. Also she would still be connected with the tree of harmony she won’t need that magic to fly or use a horn.
If they all became alicorns except pinkie they would want to know why and then pinkie would have to tell her friends the truth witch is exatly what pinkie knew she was not ready. The reason why twilight became an alicorn is because she is ready, physically and mentally. Pinkie is physically ready but not mentally.
No wait I mean if celestia turned all of them into alicorns she would have to give everyone extra magic to really have alicorn magic, but if she made pinkie into one she woundn’t need extra magic
The Kitten Gamer I don't come from a country with a monarchy, so here's the best thing I've come up with: a royal house is not an actual house one would see on a street, but rather a family of royals (e.g. Windsor and Hapsburg). This would mean that the House of Friendship essentially consists of Twilight's family.
The Kitten Gamer But didn't Shining Armour marry Cadence before then? She'd likely look bad in front of both her parliament and Equestria's if she didn't marry another royal.
Ok that dose make twilight royal, but I’m pretty sure cadence woundn’t marry another royal just so she woundn’t look bad she isn’t that type of pony. Also how do we know cadence was royal before she was an alicorn or even celestia and Luna, based on notions theory everypony born in the alicorn civilization was destined to be an alicorn, meaning if celestia and Luna where born there, them being alicorns is common.
The Kitten Gamer I don't know about that, but I do believe that there was someone in line for the British monarchy who was taken out of line for marrying an American commoner divorcée.
The Kitten Gamer But this does bring up an interesting question: before providing an heir to the Equestrian throne, of which kingdom were the Friendships the rulers?
The Kitten Gamer I don't know whether you know the answer, but if the Friendships were a royal family before moving to Equestria, which land did they rule over?
Good question, but I think the alicorn civilization because before celestia and Luna equestria was not a good place to live, if they ruled over equestria, then all of that equestrian history we know is not true.
The Kitten Gamer That would explain why the rulers are alicorns, but is there a "Free Equestria" party or something that aims to restore the previous government? (Or did Celestia give each nationalist a "Pow! Right in the kisser!"?)
No idea, but that gives me an idea, saying as how you thought there could be people trying to take celestia and Luna down from the throne what if their is. What if they are trying their hardest to do that, what if they are descendants of the original rulers of the three tribes. Working separately to bring back what their ancestors started. They may still believe what others believed back then but who could be responsible for this? Who could be a descendants of the three tribe rulers. Well what if I told you it is (drum role please) spike. Or not spike himself but he could be helping in something. He could be a changing trying to help one of the three tribes. Why would a changing want this? I think because this changing dosn’t like the others for whatever reason so it is trying to ruin the changlings food sorse. And to where and back again dosn’t prove this theory wrong, they could be trying to turn life upside down for the changlings because the changlings are good friends with ponies. Ok this theory dose have more holes in it than Queen chrisles but is still a possibility
I'm not sure whether that would necessarily mean Cadence was always a royal, as, at least in the Commonwealth of Nations, royal governors are appointed by the monarch, so perhaps if Celestia or her PM somehow convinced Equestria's parliament to not go against her for appointing a non-royal, it's possible it could have been done.
I've also read, however, that Cadence may be Celestia's adopted niece, meaning that she could be a member of Celestia and Luna's royal house.
I think that. Celestial and Luna are princesses and their parents were the king and queen .like even though queens are usually bad. Not all queens are. Look at raven queen from everafterhigh she was suppose to be the new queen but she Chose to be a good queen.Notice?
i think what happened was that as soon as nightmare moon was released, she faced her sister and banished her - i don’t think they mean she was banished for a thousand years.
Since you didn't watch the video clearly he said for all of part two so basically when nightmare moon escaped she sent Celestia to the sun but once the mane six defeated Nightmare Moon the spell was broken.
Celestia is banished in the sun look at the last episode of season 5 The Cutie Re-Mark when twilight came at the two sisters' old castle Nightmare Moon said Celestia was banished in the moon
no no no no you dont understand do you even get it the thing is that when the princess was gone (I mean the princess of the sun) that was because that she was where twilight got to become a princess thats also to try to time traval to stop luna from becoming evail. Oh and the hair is because the princess (again I mean the princess of the sun) was holding the elements and if the elements where broken then her hair would become pink DAAAAA he he he :)
Without even going into the fact the moon has no atmosphere, Luna being sealed in the moon would've put her at risk for any number of illnesses linked to asbestos, which moon dust is a great deal like, and yet she survived a thousand years no worse for wear health-wise. So why is it unusual for a pony to possibly been magically sealed away within a star without burning to a crisp?
@Jana Lybarger trust me, better your brain exploded in no atmosphere and tumors because of the UV rays exposition than your brain exploded in no atmosphere, tumors because of the UV rays exposition, being crushed by the gravity, evaporated (or more likely "ionized") by the temperature and many other bad things... but, you know, MAGIC!
Hey what is up with Luna's hair why is it light blue but in other episodes twilight goes to a flashback before nightmare moon came to be and she had her hair like normal, all flowy, sparkly, and however else her hair normally is idk what's going on did becoming nightmare moon change her hair for a bit?
i thinki get it, nightmare moon wanted have equestria to herself, and banish celestia into the sun, but while celestia was banishing nightmare moon, nightmare moon must have put a spell that when she returns celestia will be banished into the sun. Then nightmare moons evil spell broke and she transformed back into luna, celestia returned from the sun. Nightmare moon wanted to have equestria on the 1000th year when she returned.
@INDIGO BLUEoO ponies never die on the show that's why they did not let Celestia die when she got hit by nightmare moon witch was still kinda funny LOL XD darkness in a kids show ha LOL XD
Emmm brony notion please say Bro hoof slowly not like "this is the brony notion sining out Bro hoof! More like this is the brony notion sining out... Bro hoof!
well i have the most stupidest theory..........if celestia banished to the sun who puts her there she put luna to the moon so if celestia banished to the sun nightmare moon did it and its stupid and for me luna escaped in the moon in nightmare night (facepalm) wait no but still i need somepony to reply to me and help me to this
this is your day off does episode 4 where is the last year when one discovered to nightmare moon when she was a sister 3 that dude with the big who's that drains Pony energy Susie where is she all this disaster happen
i don’t think they get banished “on” the moon, i think they just become “merged” with it, for a lack of a better term. the same could be said about luna - if celestia would burn from being banished to the sun, luna would easily die on the moon from lack of oxygen. so i think it’s more that their essence gets trapped inside the moon and not their physical bodies
@Bright New Future Unless Luna was teleported beneath the moon’s surface where there could be oxygen, by there’s nowhere Celestia could survive on the sun.
+Barba Johannesen and your point is? If you click his name to go to his page and view his videos, his most recent uploads were 3 videos each 3 months ago. Ya, they were in 2015, but that doesn't mean they were uploaded a year ago.
Lauren Faust said she was trapped in the sun. I think it was in a comment on DeviantART.
834 likesReplies (14)
Dr Shaym your a brony ?
14 likesDaddy Shaym
10 likesWHAT! That is like soooo short! You are so lazy!!!😑😑😑😑😣😣😣😣😣😕😕😕😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😬😬😬😬😡😠😡😠😡😈👿👹👺👺😾😾Boo boo but you are right
7 likesSorry I was not talking to you I was talking to brony notion
4 likesi see you everywhere even in minty root's video
3 likesMayra Guzman He just started when and maybe he didint have enogh time cuase its only 1 min exactly. And can we see bettr edit or recording skills from you?
6 likesNightmare moon RUUUULLLEEES
1 likeDoes she have a DeviantArt gallery? If so:
6 likes1) Does she create her own fanfiction?
2) Is she open to questions from those of us who are trying to understand the meme world?
oof
2 likesMayra Guzman 5 year old
2 likesDr Shaym who r u?
3 likesDr shaym are u a bronyv
1 likeMayra Guzman, even if you were talking to sawtooth, that was really mean! Why don’t you go try animation and theories! Why don’t you go and stop judging people just because of one short video?!?!?
1 likeA banishment came with a another banishment
1 likeCelestia was either banished to the Sun or she was out getting some cake. Yes our head canons align here.
668 likesReplies (8)
jason hartley xD
7 likesIf celestia was banished to the sun then how did she teach twilight
8 likesIn the sun
3 likesShe was eating cake in the sun
11 likesYES 100% HaHaHaHaHa😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
1 like@Samia Qaiss there was a decent timeframe between twilight seeing the stars align and when the celebration started. NMM likely sent her to the sun in that time.
2 likesI like thinking she was getting some cake
1 likeYes
0 likesI personally think that she was trapped somewhere else and when she escaped, she travelled through the sun. Basically like how Luna comes out from the moon when she’s dream walking.
80 likesshortest. theory. video. ever.
1166 likesReplies (26)
ikr
8 likes+theblastofheat andbutter Very short.
4 likesLike THIS DIIIiiii..... on second thought, never mind
6 likes..?
0 likesSo short!!!
1 likeTrue, and it was pretty boring too.
3 likesIt was a min!😐
3 likesyee Ikr
1 likeYa
1 likeIkr
0 likesYeah it's just a minute
0 likesAll of his old vids where short wernt they
2 likesAll of his videos used to be like that. Now his theory videos are as long as they need to be. They’re like 7 or 8 minutes, or 6.
2 likesand most of it was a clip from the show
0 likesTrueee
0 likes666th like
0 likesAnd the oscar goes to...
0 likesYep
0 likesLmao 5 years later
0 likesIkr
0 likesFr
1 like1 minute long.
0 likesYup
0 likesTrue
0 likes@Zero Ending On Thirty ?
0 likes@Katie Dervan ?
0 likesWhat I think is that celestia WAS banished to the sun/moon. (It could have been either, she also could have been sent to some kind of prison too, but most likely the sun.) When nightmare moon returns, celestia is gone. That is probably because nightmare moon banished her to the sun as revenge for her banishment. When nightmare moon is defeated celestia comes down from the sun, (which means she was most theoretically sent there.) and when the stars aligned for nightmare moons escape, she landed like that somewhere in ponyville. I agree with your statement.
62 likesthis makes sense, especially if you consider the 2 years difference between this and Starlight's time travel episode. Still, I think that Celestia was imprisoned somewhere by Nightmare Moon, just not in the moon yet, but knew that Twilight would discover the magic of friendship, so didn't resist for a while. As for the sun rising with her, she probably just also knew that plants and trees needed sunlight. She didn't raise the sun for the summer sun celebration, and since Nightmare Moon wouldn't lower the moon, time was stopped. Unless the sun and moon had nothing to do with time. If that's the case, (which it likely is, considering that the sun and moon have to be lowered and raised daily/nightly,) then trees, more importantly to our main cast, apple trees, would soon die and life in Equestria would cease to exist. It WOULD, anyway, if it weren't for a certain princess that raised the sun as soon as it was safe to escape from wherever she was held. I don't think Celestia was imprisoned on the moon at first, though. Nightmare didn't have long to imprison Celestia, and had to deal with destroying the Elements of Harmony. So she probably only weakened her sister and decided to deal with total banishment later.
6 likes"The Sun Rises, and Becomes Celestia."
143 likesCelestia probably used teleportation
Replies (2)
No the sun rises then celestial comes.
4 likes@Wafa Rahman yeah telportation
0 likesWhat's up with Luna in the first episode she looks like a child but if you look at her in the other seasons she looks mature and has flowing hair..
200 likesReplies (23)
Hey Its Star You're kidding right?
4 likesMoonlight the Shiny Umbreon what..?
5 likesHey Its Star Alicorns only get sparkly flowing hair and look mature when they have a lot of magic. Luna used all her magic to become Nightmare Moon and lost it when she became her normal self.
46 likesMoonlight the shiny umbreon to be fair, they never said an alicorn had to have magic to look mature and have flowing hair. If that were the case, Luna would've looked young in Princess Twilight and both princesses would've lost their float manes. Not to mention, Flurrtheart is FULL of magic but she doesn't spontaneously mature
23 likesarianella I think she grew
2 likesH Fang um yeah ik that now😭 i didn’t understand a few years ago but now i do
0 likesI think the older you get and your an alicorn your hair flows
8 likesLost her power from being banished for so long ^^'
1 likeBecause yes and yed
0 likesShe grew
0 likesspells
0 likesIt’s in the Nightmare Rarity comic. Yes they ARE canon . Does nobody but me read the comics?
4 likes@Chaitanya Saxena another person still responding to an old comment after ive already said i get it😭🤚 does no one read the replied anymore
5 likesi think her flowy main is just a representation of magic, and i think the lighter color also represents magic ,as when ponies are stripped from there power they become lighter😉
2 likesher flowing hair is actually a piece of her trauma when she becomes nightmare moon when you think about it
0 likesIn the Nightmare Rarity comics, Luna couldn’t handle Nightmare Rarity normally, so she gained more magic and became more powerful and with that she gets flowing hair like her sister Celestia.
2 likes@Chaitanya Saxena I’ve read the N. Rarity comics, heck, I’m still on Big Mac-needs-a-nail-or-something comics.
1 like@arianella sorry
1 like@awawawa twilight became an Alicorn at the end of season 3 and it took her 6 season to get flowing hair. Luna was literally a child in episode 2, and in the next season suddenly totally grown up.
1 likeYes, Alicorns do grow “higher” and have flowy her (except cadence for some weird reason), but they still take time to grow, usually. I assume you haven’t been born as an adult either, do you?
@Tanirika Velpula doesnt make sense cause celestia and Luna didn’t look younger when cozy glow drained all of equestria’s magic
0 likesAnd in the flashback of the season 4 premiere, Luna's hair is flowing, so how did she get younger after a thousand years-
0 likestbh idk why? maybe she started ageing backwards when she was banished to the moon...
0 likes@arianella No, they do not. The replies don't exist in stuff like this. How's your day going?
0 likesMakes sense. I had always understood it as merely that Nightmare Moon kidnapped Celestia and somehow sealed her power, but they never said exactly how or where she was. This is a good answer for that.
5 likesInteresting thought, but I see a few problems with this. Mind you this is more of a head cannon than anything else, but take what you will.
4 likesI have thought about it, and Celestia is to strong for Nightmare moon to just banish her in underder 10 seconds. If anything I think we are looking at a much more complicated picture than that.
First of all why would Celestia not be bothered by the fact that Nightmare moon would be released, and prepare more than just sending Twilight to make friends.
Second why was Nightmare moon's attacks on the six friends so... weak. She is show to be able to stop other ponies without even full use of her magic. She should have never been stopped. As the most dangerous thing she does is destroy a cliff.
So this bring about my idea.
The Elements of Harmony, banished Celestia when they released Luna from the moon, but limited the amount of power Nightmare moon could use. Which was why they had become stone and needed fresh magic to awake them agian.
In short they are making sure that Luna would return, and Celestia will be punished.
Again this is head cannon location as to why Celestia needed punishment. Celestia while she loves her sister, is not really sure how to work with or chooses not to.
Point one being I don't think she was there enough for luna to keep their bond strong, thus never noticing luna fall into darkness. Notice in S4 E 1 and 2 she is more annoyed at her sister than anything else talking about duties she must do.
You can also see this in Luna's Eclipse. After all wouldn't Celestia have taught Luna how to speak to her subject, or even interact with other ponies. Luna says her voice style is the Royal Canterlot voice.
So if anything the Elements banished her, showing her, or at least trying to point out she was partly to blame for this mess.
Just an idea
Yes, In the book "The Elememnts Of Harmony" it proves Celestia was banished to the sun. Revenge! lol
41 likesEh, pretty late to the party here, but since the sunlight doesn't go out when she enters the castle, I'm pretty sure the sun is not turning into Celestia. The sun is still behind her, but the camera moves with her so we don't get to see it. So the effect equates Celestia with the sun (makes perfect sense - it's what she does) but the light remains and Celestia is clearly not the source of it. Look at :29. The sunlight is coming from the bottom left corner of the window (where the sun should be) and not from Celestia, who is toward the right.
2 likesAlso, wasn't Celestia in the beginning of the episode as well? Anyway it would be a cool idea for an episode sometime - Celestia being trapped in the sun.
I think as punishment for herself for banishing her sister she casted a spell that when her sister was aided by the stars to be free she was sent to the sun and became daybreaker
6 likesBrony I agree with your theory of celestia being banished by luna but I just have a small different opinion. Celestia and I quote said " I saw the signs of nightmare moons return". She knew all about her return. She was prepared for an attack. Maybe celestia sent herself to the sun or maybe wasn't sent to the sun at all. Maybe she disappeared during the summer sun celebration because she knew that nightmare moon would be there. Maybe she went to the secret land only she twilight and cadence had ever been, and when she sensed or saw that nightmare was luna once more she returned. But remember that this is just my opinion
5 likesWhen starlight used the time travel spell one of the outcomes was that nightmare moon returned. Here it was shown that Celestia was banished to the moon, and not to the Sun.
4 likesThat’s scientifically impossible due to the fact that the sun can burn you if you are to close to it. But I guess it’s possible due to the fact that Luna’s still alive and the moon doesn’t have oxygen.
2 likesI noticed that too! I think it makes sense. But then it seems that Celestia would have to be very heat-resistant, and Luna very cold-resistant. They'd also both have to be able to breathe when there is no oxygen and survive without food or water. I guess they are goddesses, so maybe that means they would be okay even in extreme circumstances?
2 likesok lets take a step back here on the whole "shouldn't she be fried?" thing. the answer is in the first episode.
2 likesNightmare iscalled the mare IN the moon not ON the moon when banished she was made one with her charge thus preserving her in her current state and protecting her from things like hunger or degredation of the body in general from lack of activity,this is also why she as not efected by lack of air or the bitter cold of space.
same reason the sun dosn't turn Celestia into a giant peice ofcharred pony flesh.
Interesting thought, NightMare Moon would have had 1000 years to plot her revenge, and was said to have been released by the aid of the stars, perhaps those stars not only gave Nightmare moon the ability to break the spell that banished her, but the power to banish Celestia, after all she was going to bring about the eternal darkness, in order to do so she would have to get rid of the only other pony who could raise the sun aside from herself.
2 likesI've been wondering, if Luna was sent to the moon and lived, and the possibility Celestia was sent to the sun and lived, can alicorn breathe in space? or do equestria sun and moon each have their own atmosphere?
1 likeBut wait...
22 likesNotion used to be a changeling? Or is he still a changeling?
And... Why does he have Kanaya's horns?
Replies (1)
He still is a changling.
1 likeI feel that when Celestia banished Luna to the moon, Luna was seeking revenge and planned to return to banish Celestia to the sun. I think when she got banished to the sun she took the form of the sun. It is a good theory but it might not be the whole truth. Maybe there is more to the story or maybe this isn't the case at all.
1 likemaybe she was vanished to the moon
3 likeshere's my explanation :- in the episode the cutie re-mark we saw in a scene if nightmare moon wasn't defeated she said :- my sister is trapped in the moon or something like that and we was able to see the moon from the castle window she was in the moon i think when the sun rised celestia was set free with her magic the sun rised and she shined like the sun
That makes so much sense! I actually didn't notice that, but seeing what happened in this video, I now know what you are saying. When I saw the title of the video, I thought it was an idea that you had for the writers to somehow incorporate into the show.
0 likeswhen I watched one of ink roses video, she said that lauren faust said in a tweet that she imgges that luna went to canterlot to gain more power and she banished celestia to the sun. so your theory is pretty much canon.
3 likesCelestia trapped in the sun? Oh the irony
69 likesReplies (2)
She would either get a pretty good tan or be baking to a crisp
5 likesLuNA TrAPpEd iN tHe MOoN oH THe iRo- yeah that's the point, good job for getting it.
1 likeWell, this is unlikely. Celestia used the Elements to banish Nightmare Moon. Unless Nightmare Moon managed to steal the Elements and use them, she probably wouldn't have the power to do so.
1 likeA.) The whole episode was about finding the Elements. I don't think Nightmare Moon even touched them before she started wreaking havoc.
B.) She doesn't understand friendship or show any qualities of friendliness in this state, so she wouldn't even be able to use them if she wanted to.
Unless Nightmare Moon managed to gain the power to perform that powerful of a spell without the Elements, I don't think that she could have banished Celestia to the Sun.
This may be right. In The Cutie Re Mark episode, one part shows Luna being the princess and Celestia being banished in the moon (or sun). Twilight says to Starlight, that would have happened without the Mane 6. My theory may not be right, but it was fun to just share it with you 😊 Great video!
0 likesI agree with you Brony Notion, in season 5, when Starlight Glimmer intervenes in RD's rainboom, we see what it was like if some of the villains weren't defeated. Nightmare Moon was one of them, and when Spike brings up Celestia, Nightmare Moon laughs and quotes "My sister has been locked up in the moon for years, it was no worse than she sentenced me to" so perhaps Celestia was banished, and she would've stayed there for a thousand years, if Nightmare Moon wasn't defeated.
0 likesBut there's something missing... The fact she rises the sun every morning! 🔆☀️🌞
0 likesI feel that this could be agreeable. I mean, it's very possible that maybe when Luna was still Nightmare Moon, she could have been overcome with so much anger and revenge that she would do such a thing. But let's be reasonable: I've known that alicorns aren't immortal, and that if you even go 20 miles from away from the sun, you'd probably already start to burn alive. What I DO know is that alicorns can cast the most powerful spells known to Equestria. Celestia might have put a protection spell on herself before she was sent to the sun. Or if you are too skeptical and you don't trust theories, maybe you should call up Hasbro and act like a idiot in front of them. Just saying.
0 likesReplies (1)
I think that in their world the sun isn’t a big ball of flaming gas so it won’t hurt her, and plus she is technically the goddess of the sun in a way
0 likesI actually think that celestial was hiding in the sun from nightmare moon because she didn't have the elements of harmony to fight her back and therefore was defenceless, so that is also why she had twilight and her friends inherit the elements to banish Luna to the moon once again, since that did not happen she had no need to feel afraid and came out of hiding to greet her banished sister and teach her about the equestria of today.
0 likesignoring season 5 there are two problems with this theory 1.how do you ban someone into fire
0 likes2. Celestia can't serve as an example in the sun because no one would see it
What is Princess Celestia's element?
0 likesShe used the Elements of Harmony to banish her sister to the moon free-willingly whereas Twiligh Sparkle had to have her element present to then use the rest of the elements. Clearly in SE1EP1 there is no element above the others, its just a white glowing ball. But whenever you see Princess Celestia she seems to be wearing two elements - one in her crown/tiara and one on her necklace. I suppose that Princess Celestia was able to control all of the elements alone because she had honesty. kindess. generosity, laughter and loyalty within her but what gave her the power to control such strong magic? And why does she have two elements instead of one seeing that she is just a "princess"?
And when you watch the part when Princess Luna is banished to the moon you can see Twilight Sparkles element above Princess Celestia's tiara. How could this happen unless it means that Twilight Sparkle was definitely destined to have an element before she was even born?
Could you please make a video about this but in further dept. Thanks.
My main question is:
-What is her element and what of?
That would completely support the idea (by cannedcreme) that Luna never wanted to hurt anyone but just be loved equally and also have her revenge on her sister.
0 likesOK i totally agree with this video because before when i watched the 1st ep i was like "hey maybe to be all mocking and in your face to Celestia, Luna banished her to the sun" this would also be an effective way to trap Celestia because the sun would not show hence no escape for Celestia.
0 likesShe must’ve been banished just that evening
1 likeShe was present in the day when she sent twilight to make new friends and check on the festival of summer sun celebration 🎉 with what the mane 5 are doing
i think it was because Luna appears in dreams in the moon ,so celestia appears through the sun. i think it just doesn't happen regularly.and celestia also knew that twilight could do it and she wanted her to discover friendship ,so thats why i think she was missing
0 likesWait so a banishing spell will work as long as the caster stays in a good shape,which could mean that Luna got unbanished ,since Luna is nightmare moon,and banished celestia this all could explain how king sombra was released
0 likesI get the feeling that it would be more likely that nightmare moon didn't banish her to the sun because luna seemed surprised to see her and also because I think she would have said so when she showed up at the summer sun festival
0 likesBut according to Twilight's past, for example how she became Celestia's student, it's not really possible that she was banished for one thousand years. Not mentioning the fact that someone had to raise the sun AND the moon (otherwise the world ended up like in the fanfic i got my profile pic from).
0 likesthis makes a whole lot of sense she wasn't even shown once during the whole episode of part 2 i have to agree on this theory
0 likesMe watching this in 2020:man he improved a lot
0 likesHonestly, I don't think this is just a thought. I'm not surprised, I believe this ever since my first viewing of the episode
0 likesThis makes so much sense😱
2 likesOr she felt remorseful enough that she banished her self to the moon and set it so only when luna was free she would be free as well 👀....just a theory
1 likeI think in order to banish Luna to the moon she had to simultaneously banish herself in order for the spell to work. Just a thought.
0 likesIf she was banished the evil powers of darkness was using her and since they were so strong she was able to over power her
0 likesThe only problem is when would she have been banished
You would know
This is more proof if the elements if disharmony because they are opposite to the elements if harmony the elements if disharmony can probably ban a good person. As celestia said something along the lines of this "when I banished Luna to the moon she had been completely consumed by selfishness, but when you and your friends used the element there was something good inside her and the elements freed her from herself." The elements if harmony can ban evil and free the good, therefore showing that if a person is good they can be banned by the elements of harmony, and if someone is becoming selfish than they can be tired evil by the elements of disharmony. If Luna really loved celestia she wouldn't have turned against her without a push, this leads me to think that maybe someone used the elements if disharmony to make her become nightmare moon, and what if that someone was star swirl the bearded, he did dissapear without a trace with hopes if not getting caught and in trouble, which also makes me think, could starswirl the bearded be king Sombra, I mean if star swirl the bearded used the elements of disharmony than he probably became evil and tried to create an ally; nightmare moon, and since he disappeared this could mean he became Sombra and was turned into a shadow by celestia and after Luna was slowly over taken by jealousy.
0 likesI stand by my headcanon that Celestia was hiding from her sister after what she did to Luna 1000 years ago, hiding in her own regret.
1 likeI think Celestia merely hid herself within the Sun and watched Twilight undergo her tirals until Nightmare Moon was defeated and Luna clensed of the darkness that had consumed her.
0 likesi would think that too but when Nightmare Moon attacked her, Celestia was still strong so Nightmare Moon tried to banish her to the sun (which she rises) like how Celestia banished her to the moon (which Luna raised) but Celestia might have done magic to make it seem like she was but could have cast a spell for her to appear when the sun rises.
0 likesI agree with you
0 likesOn her being banished to the sun because when she returned at the end when I first saw it that was the first thing I thought of.
I think it was her rising the sun and then immediately going over to where they were to basically congradulate them.
0 likesso if luna makes the moon rise, how did it keep coming up for the 1000 years she was banished?
0 likesno no , celestia's banishment was to the moon you have to watch season 5 finally when nightmare moon took over equestria and banished celestia to the moon for a 1000 of years
1 likeThey say Luna was forgiven and now everypony is super nice to her, yet she's played a significant roll in only 2 or 3 episodes.
1 likeif this video was one second longer, it would be a minute
0 likesBut Celestia can't raise the sun while IN/ON the sun. You never hear of Nightmare moon raising the moon while in/on the moon.
0 likesmeh, all of you who haven't watched season 4-5 entirely would be still agreeing to this theory, ENTIRELY. Yes, i'm not gonna spoil it for those who have not watched yet, so i'm just gonna say that... the elements of harmony is crucial in banishing creatures.
0 likesNo, this is just Celestia just glows and rises like the sun.
0 likesThis needs to happen me and my friend started playing where celsetya was banished to the sun it needs to be a villain
0 likesi think it is an cool idea but should be explored more because it wasn't for a thousand day on the thousandth year that " the stars will aid her escape", why was't it included for Celestia?
0 likesOuch. Being banished to the Sun gotta hurt. I mean, think of the heat!
0 likesThink deeper, if she was trapped in the sun... Then who RAISED the sun during that time? Well, it can’t be Luna! She was right there when the sun was raised.
1 likeHang on! Does celestia have a element of harmony? I mean she always wears a necklace with a gem, just like 5 of the main 6 ponies elements. Is it possible that this is true?
0 likesThe sun didn't rise, dude! That's just Celestia making a grand enterance 'cause she was glowing!☀️😒
0 likesIf nightmare moon switchs with Celestia and Celestia turns into Daybreaker. I wonder if Celestia could just burn everyone in equestria
0 likesShe should be! Banish her to the sun for 1000 years. I’ll try it when I manage to create a portal to Equestria.
0 likestia's hair became multi colored when she used the elements of harmony on luna. luna was still really young the time tia banished her in the moon. which explains why luna is a kid when twilight and the others defeated her.
0 likesHoly heck I was so little when this came out, obeying when someone said duck and getting yelled at because that's not what that means when I did just that
0 likesGosh I keep the most random of memories, and now writing this comment + watching this video will be one of them. Maybe. We'll see.
So Nightmare Moon has already won. And if it wasn't for her lame traps, the elements of harmony would never have been activated and used against her. What an incompetent mare.
0 likesI think Luna did banished tia to the sun but on an other note tia banished Luna to the moon with the elements so how would Luna be able to do that without the elements
9 likesReplies (10)
@Aliyah Gamble Who Is Tia?
0 likes@***** just like luna has a nickname, lulu, or woona
0 likes@***** I didn't no how to spell celestia at the time so I just used tia
0 likes@***** what book
0 likesOK I guess people mostly use tia
0 likesThe elements if disharmony
0 likes@Anime Pony Princess the element of disharmony that nightmare moon poseces
0 likesTia is celesTIA
0 likesCrystal _ Shine with her nightmare moon power!
0 likesUno reverse cars :v
0 likesHuh. I....never really thought about that. I know its a theory but it seems like they should explain what happened in the show to clear things up. Just an idea. :P
0 likesWhat an amazing theory before I thought that if luna can be banished to the moon then celestia can be banished to the sun I have another theory how luna became nightmare moon is when she replaces the sun with the moon then black rays came out zapping her and transforming her into nightmare moon so what if celestia can do the same thing if she replaces the moon with the sun it would send out heat ray's zapping her and transforming her into day breaker
0 likesI thought maybe Celestia WAS ACTUALLY the sun. Because that kinda was her talent. And, the sun came up by itself. So maybe she was just the sun.
0 likesI have to say know. Remember Celestia had to tuse the Elements to banish Nightmare moon. And proven nightmare Moon is no match for the Elements. So likely Celestia hanged back on the Gamble of the mare 6 doing what she could not. Get her true sister back.
1 likeOh wow, I never thought about that!
7 likesYour videos are short but I still love it
0 likesThis is the first time I actually noticed that the sun rose when she appeared.
0 likesactually celestia rised with the sun not in the sun she went up and the sun followed she actually has done this a few times
0 likesWait a minute, if Celestia was banished to the sun wouldn’t she be burning alive? Oh well shes Celestia the princess of the sun she’s probably immune lol
1 likei’m not trying to send any hate I’m just trying to spread some laughs, Love your videos by the way🧡
It did show her hair flowing when she became nightmare moon sooooo did she age down wards?
10 likesReplies (8)
hmmmmmm
1 likeMy headcannon is that the flowing mane is just a spell the cast to look pretty.
1 likeILoveKimPossibleALot has a video on that. you should check it out.
0 likes@hifivedolls Wait... I watch her all the time... HOW HAVE I NOT SEEN THAT ONE?!?! WHAT IS IT CALLED
0 likesMaybe The mane reflected her power , maybe she got drained of her power , because as we see in one of the episodes were twilight drinks this potion in begging of session 4 , she has sneek peeks of the past , and I you luna with her stary flowing like mane , before she became night mare moon . I believe when she returns and twilight defeats her .. Could her power could have drained ?
2 likes@kekoa howls You are correct.
0 likesits because the magic nightmare moon was useing off of her. so when luna returned her magic was very low which caused her mane to not flow
2 likesBecause when she was turned back, some of her magic, like raising the moon was gone, and it took a whole season to get it back, since Luna's hair in Luna Exclipsed is flowing
1 likeit was part of twi's element she used magic to set celestia free
0 likesBut if Celestia was banished, then who was controlling the rise of the Sun and Moon, since that was Celestias job after she banished Luna to the moon?
0 likesThis May Make Sense.If Luna Was Banish In The Moon Then Celestia Can Be Banish In The Sun
0 likesIt was just a flashy entrance, to show off. I think Celestia could have easily hung out, in the sidelines, having high confidence the girls could handle this on their own and is just waiting till the job was done. Not to interfere.
0 likesSaw a commercial for mlp before this, what are the chances!
64 likesAnyway, it said something about a new pony called Starlight Glimmer in the new season.
Twilight Sparkle
Sunset Shimmer
Starlight Glimmer
:>
Replies (9)
I saw it too, can't wait for April 4th!
1 likeYup and she is evil and posses people by stealing there cutie marks and forcing throes to Smile! Ugh shivers creepy
2 likes@Aubrey Clark Twilight Sparkle + thesaurus = foil to Twilight Sparkle.
6 likes@***** LOL MY GAWSH
1 likeAnd then Seafood Dinner
2 likesIt’s actually gonna happen :D ( even tho it already did )
0 likesYeah. Now Gen 4 mlp has ended so every single season has finished. Starlight was evil at first but then was nice after that.
0 likes6 years later thats the best episode
0 likesI-
0 likesI never thought of it that way. Luna banished to the Moon and Celestia banished to the Sun 🤨🤨🤨
0 likescelestia being an older alicorn has a lot of power so she is able to banish luna to the moon and when luna returns as nightmare moon she also has a lot of power making her able to banish celestia to the sun.
0 likesIt can’t be possible because Nightmare Moon couldn’t get the elements of harmony. Remember that Celestia used the elements to banish Nightmare Moon to the moon. Just saying
0 likesAll people saying she was banished on the moon but in this episode it was an alternate universe and not the "real equestria".
0 likesYOU DIDN’T EVEN DO YOUR “BRO HOOF” OUT-TRO!!! I’M SOOO MAD
3 likesWell, if Luna get revenge on Celestia, she will be free in the moon. How she will get revenge if she was still in the moon? She was not banished to the sun. Maybe she needs to rise the sun first then Celestia was there. That shine thing was acually from the sun. In this case, i think that was my idea.
0 likesWhen the nightmare moon became Luna again, her hair wasn't flowing.Does it mean if she has was banished, her age would down grade or something?
0 likesIn my fanfics, the mane 6 have an orbital friendship cannon. I think they should make that. Canon. 030
0 likesI think when Nightmare moon got free, she took Celestia and banished HER to the Sun. Makes sense right?
0 likesokay okay but if celestia did get banished to the Sun would her name be daydream sun
3 likesReplies (1)
twili sparkie daybreaker
0 likesThat's a good point!
2 likesNever thought of it that way!
XD
in the time travel episode Luna says that she has been bashed to the moon for years
0 likesCelestia went to the sun herself because she knew the main six could do it alone.
0 likesShe raises the sun and quickly flies down to Twilight's place. Theory down. (Celestia knows where Twilight is since she's her faithful student)
0 likeshhmm I'm gonna say not good I'm sorry meow~
3 likesMaybe Celestia brings the day with her like Luna does in season 3
0 likesHang on a sec, I just noticed the beginning and... is your OC actually a Changling!?
1 likePoor Luna being banished to the moon for a thousand years, while celestia is only banished for mere hours. LUNA WILL RULE ALL!!!!!
0 likesCelestia was just glowing.
0 likesMagiccc
Twilight Sparkle
4 likesSunset Shimmer
Starlight Glimmer
Has something to do with each other!
They everyone have aleast a S in their Name or lastname!
Replies (1)
GASP GUESS WHAT ELSE ! There all mess stuff (LOL Like Sparkle,Shimmer,)
0 likesI have a question what happens if there would be a lunar eclipse?
0 likesNote that the music in Celestia's return here is the same melody as "love is in bloom" from a canterlot wedding...
0 likesReplies (1)
@ObamaoZedong No. It isn't...
0 likesI love it! But one question? Who are Applejack's parents? Can you make a video and tell us who are her parents.
0 likesWell actually on the last episode of season 5 starlight glimer uses one of starswirl the bearded spells to go back in time and stop the sonic rainboom then back in the present it was night and nightmare moon was the ruler of equestria and banished celstia to the moon for a thousand years but you should watch the episode
0 likesWowwwwoow this is so wrong i mean did you even see season 5 episode 25 and 26 in that Luna herself clearly says that she banished celestial to the moon just see but i have no idea what is wrong with their hair Tia hair is pink when she was a baby (true fact )but then how in the world did it become multi couler and Luna hair i really supposes to flow but it wasn't why
29 likesReplies (37)
I posted this two years before that episode came out. I was pretty close with the revenge idea though.
19 likes+Surbhi Sharma When Celestia used the elements of harmony against Luna, Twilight's element was too strong. Her hair was pink and normal before that event. Twilight's element caused something about her ( or her appearance ) to change. Her hair turned tri - colored and wavy.
3 likesJust go watch the lullaby for a princess animation.
That was a completely different episode, and this video was made way before the season five finale
1 like+Surbhi Sharma when defeated by the mane six, Luna lost most of her magic for a short period of time. her hair, ( my theory )is only wavy and sparkly when she has all of her magic.
2 likes+Surbhi Sharma watch lullaby for a princess when she uses the elements her hair was pink before then it was multi -colored
0 likes+Surbhi Sharma yea nightmare moon said that she was banished to the moon
0 likes@Katie_Kat DeMello u have to see the vid about celestia using the elements on luna her hair is already not pink her hair is pink when she was young
0 likes+Surbhi Sharma When people start talking about outdated information, please look at the date to make sure that these people aren't stupid. If it's an old video, then that's why they're saying it.
0 likesStupid, Season 5 didn't get released yet
0 likes@SkyxxMLP Videos um yes it did...
0 likes+Trinity Taylor what Skyxx is saying is that, when THIS video was uploaded, season 5 hadn't been released yet.
1 like+Ian Hall ya
0 likesSeason 5 hasn't been released when this vid came out.
0 likesCelistia wasn't in the moon anywhere near as long as luna so she didn't lose as much magic therefore her hair is still wavy
0 likes+Surbhi Sharma i dont remember luna saying that she banished celestia to the moon 0-0
0 likesTWIGLIGHT TRAVLED IN TIME, STUPID!
3 likes+SkyxxMLP Videos i am not stupid and second i did not know it came before season 5
0 likesThis video was before that dude
1 likethis was made in 2013 so he couldnt
1 likeI predicted there was going to be a comment saying that ._.
0 likesCALLED IT!
From what I get, when Luna was banished to the moon, she kept her power, along with the nightmare power. When the elements were casted onto Luna, it took away the nightmare. That flowing hair thing. It happens when someon-I mean pony has strong power. When you are a Luna who just got a nightmare substance taken out of you, you gunna need to re-charge that power. So for the first season, her hair was.. Normal. As her power regenerates, her hair flows. Atleast.. I think.
0 likesHow do you know Tia's hair was pink?
0 likesWell in some books in the show you see Tia's hair pink!
0 likes@Huong Dang Artistic choices, Luna's hair is light blue and curly when really it's wavy,dark blue,and has stars in it
0 likeslook at the date befor you watch a vid is called using ur eyes
0 likesI agree
0 likesWhen this video was made season 5 didn't exist m8 also why u hatin
0 likesThis was posted 2 years a go meaning that the episode wasn't released ALSO meaning you should check the date of the video BEFORE you start saying, "YOUR WRONG!!!!"
0 likes+Surbhi Sharma When Luna First Turned Into Nightmare Moon(When She Was Young)Celestia Used The Element Of Harmony (Twilights Cutie Mark) There Was A Big Rainbow Explosion And When Lunas Hair Didn't Flow Because She Was Young K?
0 likeswow
0 likesSurbhi Sharma when natural Alicorns grow old, then and only then does their hair get flowey. The colors other than pink probably just appeared slowly over time.
0 likesthis video was made before season 5 was realeased!
0 likes#CheckTheDate
Ok
0 likes##########Wow......
0 likesBut do you have a theory of what the reason might be now? You know with all the extra information?
0 likesAparri meanie
0 likesSurbhi Sharma At the time of this video, that episode hadn't come out yet
2 likesIn the season 5 finale, Nightmare Moon said that she banished Celestia to the moon. (And yes I know that this video was uploaded before season 5)
0 likesmumbles if only she stayed on moon for a thousand years
0 likesI don't think she was banished to the sun but rather went there to see her parents spirits for advice OR letting twilight prove the power of true friendship, find the elements, and defeat nightmare moon
0 likesthat was a short video
8 likeswhat I've been thinking is that, nightmare moon returned then banished celestia after she had returned
0 likess e e i n g t h i s u n d e r m i n u t e v i d e o n o w s a w t o o t h
1 likeCan we please see a revamp of this video, either disproving, saying there's not enough evidence, or actually saying it could happen?
quick q. I always wouldve thought Celestia and Luna were twins. but when Luna is "purified" again, shes a filly, not a mare like Celestia or like her past self, NightMARE Moon. are they not tiwns or did her aging process come to a complete stop when she turned into Nightmare Moon?
0 likesBanish too the sun?! I dont thats right...if tia is at the sun she should be burning and died by now...i think celestia is at the place where twilight turn into a princess... remember the song that tia sang? "I watched you from that very first day.." shes at that place it must be..cause when twilight returns to the ground and turns into a princess her cutie was shown...when tia returns from the 2nd ep of season 1 the sun rises and she appears...thats what i think :) hope u understand ^-^
17 likesReplies (29)
@vampirelya gaming/drawings Princess Celestia is immortal. Same thing if Luna was sent to the moon she didn't die because of loss of oxygen. Celestia would have survived. Just my opinion.
5 likesBut the rest of it is kinda good reasons too right?
0 likes@vampirelya gaming/drawings Not sure.
0 likesI'm not really an expert on the subject.
Wait..this is mlp we are talking to..everthing is magic :D lel
1 like@vampirelya gaming/drawings I'm pretty sure that when Luna was sent to the moon, it was more like she was converted into a spirit, and encased in the moon, which would explain the strange apparition of "The Mare in the Moon". I believe that, for a short time, Celestia was also converted into a spirit or non-corporeal entity and trapped in the sun. But, you did bring up an interesting argument. I guess the only one who really knows is Mrs. Faust herself.
1 likeYeah ur right :3 but..how about the song? "I watched u from the very first day" doesnt that tell us that she was there all this time? My opinion ofcoures v-v
0 likesFirst off: Kinda a creepy, stalker-ish song. I mean, seriously.....creepy. And I just assumed that Celestia was watching them from the sun. I also assumed that Luna was watching Equestria from the moon, but those are just my baseless assumptions.
1 likeI was thinking the same thing about celestia being on the sun... She would die of heat. Unlike how Luna was actually on a life sustainable moon. As seen in the nightmare rarity comic.
0 likes+Tayla Martin right? i like my opinion more cause...it make sense
0 likes@Tayla Martin The moon.....does not sustain life. In fact, if you were on the surface of the moon without a special suit, (And somehow not suffocating) you would either burn or freeze to death, depending on which side of the moon you were on. Basically, if your not an Alicorn getting trapped on either the sun or moon means certain death.
0 likes@vampirelya gaming/drawings If Luna was banished to the moon, she would ultimately frozen up and died, so...
0 likesWait what if when luna was sent to the moon theres a jail built for her or she just goes into the moon and become one of the moon..why is the moon has a pony on it? It must be :D if im correct i just though of this so...yeah..
0 likes@vampirelya gaming/drawings .............Isn't that basically what I said in my first comment.....
0 likes@karena everitt oh .-. Sorry didnt..understand that in the first place...now i read it back it make sense to me now...SORRY
0 likesNo, that's okay. Sorry that I confused you, sometimes I get a little carried away with technicalities and such. But I guess now you can see my point.
0 likes+karena everitt yes, I am well aware of that. Like I said, "as seen in the nightmare rarity comic" yes, I know. If the moon is sustainable then why not the sun? It wouldn't make ANY sense that Tia would be living on hot molten and a place where it's going to melt u.
0 likes@Tayla Martin I've never read the Nightmare Rarity comic (Because I despise Rarity....), but neither sun nor moon can remotely support life. Celestia surviving on the sun makes just as much sense as Luna surviving on the moon. Which is none. It's physically impossible on both. That's where I get my theory from. You can believe whatever you want to about this, though. I guess, I doesn't really make much of a difference anyway, all we know was that Tia was gone, and then she was back.............Actually, why do I even care?! I don't even like Celestia......
0 likesYeah but she's basically an immortal sun god who has absolute power in the realm where no other person could challenge her if she wanted to take over equestria. I mean hell tirek with the power of every pony in existence was still only just equal to twilight with the power of three other alicorns. They'd stand no chance if she went crazy. So yeah I'm certain she could survive being in the sun.
1 likeyou know?, i'm sorry, I think it's a pretty smart and thoughtful headcannon and I respect that, I'm just rud, SOS :-) no hard feelings :-)
0 likes+vampirelya gaming/drawings I think it was just the surface of the sun, and it didn't hurt her. Luna would be dead to since the moon would have NO oxygen and she would die from lack of oxygen!
0 likes@TaylorKarmenDoesAnimations LOL idk....we might just be wasting our time talking about this i mean...the show itself doesnt really care about logic :P even pinkie pie broke the forth wall...and remember the time pinkie's nose and mouth got deleted from trixie how the hell is she still alive without breathing... sorry if this is too long ^w^
0 likes@vampirelya gaming/drawings How everyone reacts to Pinkie Pie and this shows logic "SCREW LOGIC, DIS SHOWS PERFECT WITHOUT IT!!!"
0 likes@TaylorKarmenDoesAnimations LOL lol
0 likesIt seams legit/
0 likesI like the theory, but I doubt Celestia would be burned and dead. after all, she's pretty much the supreme goddess of Equestria. she's immortal, I'm sure. Luna would be dead if she was banished to the moon, no oxygen and no food = you can't live. I don't think "banishing to the moon/sun" should be taken very seriously, but metaphorically. Maybe they aren't literally ON THE PLACE THEY WERE BANISHED TO, but they were sort of.. trapped in where they were banished to. and although she could be at the place where she took twilight... I don't think its likely. she's an alicorn, so she has a shit ton of magic, so I'm sure she could see Twi anywhere she went, without having to go to a specific place. So basically saying, Celestia was sent to the sun and that is that. feel free to argue though.
0 likesUm...Sorry, but Luna and Celestia ARE NOT IMMORTAL. They just have extended life spans and grow faster then normal ponies. Its from royal blood. Twilight, though, since was changed at adulthood, does not have a extended life span.
0 likes@TaylorKarmenDoesAnimations LOL
0 likesWhere'd you get that from? Not sayin' it isn't true, I just actually wanna know.
I think its osmewere is the MLP wiki, or the MLP fandom
0 likes@TaylorKarmenDoesAnimations LOL
0 likesWell, you can't always trust everything the fandom says, but the wiki is usually pretty skeptical about unconfirmed information. I dunno, I kinda like the idea of them being immortal, but if the aren't, doesn't really affect me. I like knowing things but completely disregard any information that I don't really care for. I'm gonna go check the wiki now.
Hmm... Being celestia's niece I really dont think she was banished to the sun, but nice theory. I'll make sure to ask mom if she did something like that to aunt Tia.
0 likesDaybreaker.
0 likesDay.
Breaker's.
Banishment.
'Nuff said.
I think she (clestea) can tell a port through the sun
0 likesthere has been many seasons but none point to why she was banished to the sun?
0 likesBut how could Luna Aka. Night Mare Moon banish Celestia if she doesn't the " elements of Hamony"
Good job Brony i just noticed it now keep up the great work!
Sorry but this is a very ridiculous theory. It was the only time that has happened, yes. It feels to me that was probably some sort of light spell for a grand entrance. Even in cartoons, there is logic that says you would just burn to nothing if you touched the sun. Also, the reason Celestia even sent Luna to the moon was to protect Equestria and herself from her wrath. So if Nightmare moon would have had the ability to send Celestia to the sun, then she could escape from the moon and/or attack Equestria and Celestia. Therefore, Princess Celestia banishing Princess Luna to the moon would be altered useless. Don't bring the theory that Luna did attack Equestria or her sister because in the first season of MLP, a lot of the ponies weren't even fully aware of Luna's existence. In fact, a lot of the residents thought she was just a pony-tale. Look more into it in the next theory, dude.
7 likesReplies (8)
I thought it was interesting. If Luna didn't die from the lack of atmosphere, food, and water on the moon for a thousand years, why couldn't Celestia survive a few hours on the sun?
4 likes@Dana Baldus How do you know how physics works in Equestria , it is another dimension, and accordingly, it works quite differently from the laws of physics chemistry biology and especially astrology we know.
4 likes@משה ליאב לסרי Exactly. Do we even know what the sun and moon actually are in Equestria? Everyone keeps assuming that they're like our sun and moon, even though all the evidence from the show keeps suggesting otherwise.
2 likesHeck, I suspect the world ponies in Equestria live on might even be flat, as that's the only way something like "Raising the Sun" even makes sense.
Edit: Actually their world is not flat. Pinkie made a joke about the earth being round in the Hearths Warming Eve episode, and Twilight owns a globe.
Why are you telling me that? That's what I'm saying!
0 likes@Dana Baldus I assume he was agreeing with you.
0 likes+Andrew Meyer I wasn't sure either. Didn't sound like it.
0 likesBy that logic, Luna couldn't be sent to the moon because she would freeze and suffocate.
1 likeThis Line Troubles Me '''aware of Luna's existence''
0 likesEven My Little Ponies Cant Last 1000 Years (Besides Alicorns) And Celestia Would Probably Keep Luna A Secret So The Ponies Didn't Fear Celestia Since Luna Was Celestia's Sister The Residents Of Equestria Might Think Celestia Was Involved In The Evil
in season 4 twilight drink a potion Zecora gave her. and she saw the past of when Tia (celestia) banished Luna to the moon using the elements. but luna she rises the moon to eclips the sun and then she became NightMare Moon, but when she did this she looked suprised that it worked but, what if Tia rises the sun to eclips the moon, would it do the same to Tia as it did to Luna?
0 likes@msmissjordan1 I totally agree with you but I have some other theries I think Celestia got her multi-colored mane after she banished Luna and after Luna realized she made a horrible mistake turning into nightmare moon and reached her true potential of Bruner of the night she got her flowy sparkly princess mane as seen in the next episode
0 likesYou know how the camera looks up to the stars well I saw celestial in the stars so she got banished to the stars.
0 likesBanished to the sun? That's got to hurt
0 likesYeah,maybe this happened because celestia came from the sun when luna was free
0 likesEver thoutgh why there isnt a Qeeun ? I know for the first time ever starswril aberded took a earth pony made her a unicorn .They study for many years .Finaly he gave her wings used the elements of harmony to give her etrnal youth .Her name was... Hastel .Qeeun of ever free forest or something.Starswril trusted her.She is celestia older sister . He give her magic to free him.they arqewd . Starswril banised her.Celestia and starswril also studied .making her a alicorn he wanted to make her qeeun but the magic of a qeeun cannot be given twice.Luna was given a horn and a pair of wings.before she was born.making her prinses of the moon. Thats why there was prinsses
0 likesSo that's why Celestia disappeared when luna tried to bring about eternal night.
1 likeLuna actually did put Celest in the sun (you know) as payback for the whole my older sister trapped me in da moon situation 😐😑😕 ! 😊
0 likesOk, I know that this is a old video, but I have some theories about this. Yes, I think that Celestia was banished to the Sun, but in a different way. Given the time between when NMM was freed and the time she arrived at the summer sun celebration, it's not very likely that she was able to banish Celestia in that short amount of time. What I think happened is that sense the two sisters once yielded the elements together the elements were somehow connected to them (This also explains why their cutimarks are on the Tree of Harmony). When Luna was banished the connection was broken and Celestia and Luna will never Use the Elements again. However, I believe that The elements would not just let Celestia do something like that and get off Scott-free. I think that once NMM returned the Elements backfired on Celestia and banished her to the sun until Luna was returned to normal, and only then would she be able to return to Equestria. @The Brony Notion
1 likemy brain is on fire from this video
0 likesWell maybe its different in Equestria maybe Celestia has powers that keep her from getting toasted. I think it makes total sense if u realize equestrian is a whole different world then ours!
0 likesBut do you have a theory of what the reason might be now? You know with all the extra information?
0 likesNight mare moon made it night forever so the sun finally rises when she's defeated
0 likesWhat if she fled to the sun?
1 likeI agree that was an awesome theorie sorry I spelled it wrong
0 likesIn the lullaby for a princess animation, after Celestia banishes Luna to the moon her mane becomes multicolored. Make a video on reasons why please.
0 likesThat is so Sad! But AMAZING!!!!!
0 likesYah I think your right and I have evidence. Celestia used the Elements of Harmony to in prison Luna, and in part 2 when Twilight Sparkle ran into the castle and found the elements NIGHTMARE MOON WAS THERE! So she must of had the elements the whole time so it is very likely she prisond Celestia in the sun.:(
0 likesReplies (1)
@Freddy Fazbear THAT MAKES SO MUCH SENSE flips table (/._.)/ |__|
0 likesYou make a pretty good point
0 likesNo that's not right!When the mane 6 are walking though The Everfry Forest it looks into the sky and at the stars which I noticed were in the shape of Celestia.Celestia had been banished to the stars, guys!!
0 likesLuna banished to the sun, Celestia banished to the sun (?) What's next? Twilight or Starlight banished to the stars?
0 likesI've never thought about it that way!!
0 likesWait a dang minute, nightmare moon was not gonna be able to raise the sun (or if she could she would not want to because she wanted the night to last forever yea you know the story) then where was actually Celestia? Where was the sun? Celestia was raising the sun and the moon before Nightmare Moon came back but if nightmare moon wasn't defeated the sun wouldn't be there anymore so that means celestia just vanished? I mean no sun = no celestia
0 likesWouldn't Celestia get burnt if she was banished to the sun?
0 likesLuna got a hair change when she was nightmare moon. But Celestias hair was already shins and wavy, so did she get banished for this to happen? My theory is that equestria is really on a planet similar to the sun, and all the ponies are trapped there, but only celestia and Luna are or were banished. But how would Celestia raise the sun? Many planets have multiple moons, so it is possible for this world to have another sun.
0 likesCelestia Pov: Oh this Hot out there
0 likesthe sun is too hot for even a pony like Celestia to go on
0 likesBut Princess Celestia’s alright now and Nightmare Moon is reformed, so don’t worry.
0 likesyou see if celestia was being banished to the sun she shouldn't be returning into the original sate she should be solar flare from a comic if you didn't know.
0 likesSERIOUSLY, THAT"S IT! Just dont give the answer but prove why it is true.
0 likesI think your right! If I were sent to the moon I will want revenge!😡
0 likesok this is how it works/ part1- raises sun/ pasrt2- TELEPORT
0 likesCelestia on the sun: HOLY CRAP THIS BURNS!! MAKE IT STOP!!!
0 likesLuna: You were only on there for a minute, still 999 years, 11 months, 29 days, 23 hours, and 59 minutes to go. Have fun by the way.
Celestia: NOOOOOOOO
that theroy could be true
0 likesit all makes sense to me
actually it is really real I saw it before and the evil Celestia is call Solar Flare
0 likesEven if Celestia was banished to the sun, it only last hours instead of 1,000 years. I doubt she would have been overly stressed by it.
0 likesCelestia is like god
0 likesWell celestia was not banished to the sun but banished to the moon in the season five ending
0 likesAnd in dreams - moonrise and luna comes...
0 likesWouldn't the banishment last 1000 years like Luna was?
0 likesI was nervous when I saw Princess Celestia
0 likesno she finally got to raise the sun
0 likesThe reason why Celestia came out the sun is because she is the sun
0 likesIn the season five last episode when evil Luna ruled she said "My sister has been banished for year" , so ya, she was banished to the sun,a d she would still be there if the mane six did not find the elements of harmony
0 likesReplies (1)
opps, I meant years
0 likesWhat would Celestial look like if she was evil like Luna?
0 likesIt is True Celestia was trapped in the Sun and one of the videos of Time travel
1 likeFun fact this video is 1 minute long exactly
0 likesMy crying in 2020😂😭
1 likeIf you watch lullaby for a princess you'll see the end the battle between Princess Luna aka Nightmare Moon vs Celestia easy. Whenever Celestia vanishes Luna to the moon she gets a blast of energy and her mane changes 😃😛
0 likesSorry but it makes no sense that Celestia was banished to the sun. Bassicaly Celestia is the a part of the sun, so Luna is a part of the moon. Like how Luna comes from the moon everytime that she's in a dream. Besides, Celestia is stonger than Luna, the sun plays a more important role in nature, thought maybe Luna is just as strong she might be able to change the tides if she got really heated.
0 likesshe was banished to the sun bye her sis and could only come back when the sun came up so also when the spell was broken
0 likesI wish you would post videos weekly
0 likesThe finale for season 5 will explain this.
1 likeReplies (1)
season 9 is already out
0 likesSorry to say, but I think you should re-watch season 2 episode 3. Celestia travels the same way except that she come out of the sunset instead of the sunraise.
0 likesReplies (1)
KawaiiDevil 15 This Was A Old Video From 2013
0 likesI think that Celestia was in front of the sun but they didn't know she was there because of how bright it is.
0 likesReplies (1)
@purple zebra productions nah just Lunas revenge |:) LOL
0 likesWait so since thats the first episode to meet celestia the first time then she should raise the sun like that not like raising arms up to bring the sun. ITS A MISTAKE THEY HAVE ON THE REST OF THE EPISODES XD
0 likesjsyn in kids movies the queen always has some kind of special appearance to the "new" person/creature
0 likesLuna can get revenge just sending her sister into the sun, like Celestia banished luna, its that simple
0 likesNo Celestia isn’t banished to the sun in the cutie remark when twilight entered a realm Nightmaremoon said Celestia was banished to the moon I think Celestia was banished to the moon
0 likesIf you guys know the episode 'Magical Mystery Cure' Princess Celestia is in 'Heaven' so was she in heaven. What also explains this is the Lullaby for a Princess Anamation.
0 likesI think she did bashed to the sun becuase when starlight entered the timespell nightmare moon say ,(she been in prison for a thousand years after she bashed her to the moon for thousand years )so that might make senses
0 likesI Object your Honor! I agree with the Commentants. How do you think Celestia taught Twilight or became her mentor? Via Twitter or Facebook? Dude! You're too theory than common sense!
0 likescelstia is like: i look epic bow to me
0 likesnahh. good theory but guys its celectia were talking about the head princess it just means shes super important and she wants to look good and cool and dramatic and speaking of dramatic , the question is answered she just wants to make a big grand dramatic entrance like she does get with it
0 likesif celestia was sent to the sun wouldnt she burn to death like hell?
0 likesWhat if Luna actually did this.......maybe they were banished at the same time.....
0 likesI knew it! I knew it !!!!
0 likescelestia still looks weird from the front
0 likesShe was banished Celestia to the moon. Is shown in Cutie-Remark Part 2
0 likesYour video: Celestia Banished to the Sun
2 likesMe: WHAT!!!????
after I watched it.
Me: Oh yeah that makes a point
Wait, If celestia WAS banished to the sun, wouldn't the heat burn her to a crisp? The sun must be to hot for ponys, so how did celestia survivde?!?!?!?!?
0 likesYou forgot about the episode it's about time where nightmare moon sends celstia to the moon
0 likesThat can't be correct after she banshes Luna she's still there for the rest of that and then she's gon
0 likesThe intro sounds like my phone ringing
1 likeNo she lockedCelestia in the sun 🌞
0 likesShe -night mare moon 🌙
😊
I dont believe this. If celestia was banished to the sun then wouldn't nightmare would use the elements of harmony? nightmare isn't kind which doesn't power the element of kindness nor honest,nor any but magic. i think that she vanished on purpose. she wanted to teach twilight about friendship. she knew it was coming thus she vanished so that twilight can learn about the magic of friendship and make friends. if celestia didnt vanish then twilight would still be with out friends.
0 likesYes!,celestia burn to the sun!
0 likesIt would be really warm up on the sun.
0 likesSo if Celestia was banished to the- OH MY FRIGGN' GOSH!!! MOLESTIA!!!! RUUUUUUN UNLESS YOU WANNA GET MOLESTED!!!! And enjoy the nightcore:)
0 likesIf celestia was banished to the sun then how did she teach twilight magic
0 likeswith pegasister4life but landing on to it Luna was just as shocked as the mane six when celestia arrived
0 likesCelestia trapped in the sun?
0 likesMiss Celestia! Miss Celestia?
Aw, she fuckin dead
No celestia was banished to the moon because when nightmare moon returned she defeated first celestia then on the moon there was a picture of a her
0 likesnot me watching this 8 years later
1 likeREALLY SAME THING I THINKED!HOW CAN CELESTIA DISSAPEARS???????
0 likesThat's just the glow behind her.
0 likesI think you where rushing towards the end there...
0 likesI thought Luna controlled the stars then Groger since he was banished to the stars after that I think it is StarSwirl!
1 likeI dont know so what do u think?🤔🤔🤔.
0:06 What Luna is doing can be done by real horses when panicked or scared, sadly I can't tell the name can someone tell me?
0 likesIn the story it sayd that celestia raised the sun and moon so she became stronger don't you think? I think she got power to be the sun and she got the power to be immune to heat🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
0 likesReplies (1)
Like Elsa she is immune to ice
0 likesI just noticed that in the episode Princess Twilight Sparkle Twilight saw nightmare moon ( as an adult ) she was banished to the moon. But in season one when nightmare moon was defeated then luna was a little filly. This doesn't make sense!!
0 likesBut Nightmare moon said she was trapped somewhere and that was the sun
0 likesThat's not right because at the beginning of the episode, Celestia wrote a letter to Twilight to go to Ponyville.
0 likesWell Luna was banished to the moon so why was not Celestia banished to the sun?
0 likeswait a minute. here's somethin to think about. when celestia is approaching luna there's a dark mist around her. could nightmare moon be coming back? what's the backstory behind that?
0 likesReplies (1)
0:53 IT'S RIGHT THERE
0 likesif celestia was banished to the sun who raises it and the moon???
0 likesNo way celestia couldn't be banished to the moon if she had been then who wuz raining the sun and the moon in those thousand years
0 likestheory only: I saw when princess lunas mane was pink and it bothered me that I think when she was banshied to the sun agein theory only her man was began to flow but am just saying this all ways bothered me
0 likesu know if celestia can banish luna to the moon can luna do it and why cant they make a princess of stars cause luna is pretty much known for the moon and hardley ever the stars!
0 likesI have never seen a short mop theory before
1 likeCelista was there at the begin of season 1telling Twilight to go to Ponyville
0 likesThat makes more sense!!!😀
0 likesWhen You watch this in 2021 be like: 1. WHY IS THE VIDEO SO SHORT, 2. WHY IS THE ARTWORK BAD, 3. WHY IS THERE BARELY ANY EXPLAINGING.
0 likesTwilight, sun, moon, stars, sunset... Midnight?
0 likesIf the stars aid in Luna's escape then what would aid in celastias escape if she was locked away in the sun
0 likesReplies (1)
The stars! the sun IS a star after all
0 likesWouldn't Celestia become.... err.... Fried chicken? Or Fried horse?
0 likesMaybe she just made a cool entrance
0 likesWe'll u might be right but who says she
0 likesRise the sun then appeared with magic or just flew down but she
DOSE have magic,
Luna was evil she was banished to moon so there she had no power when she came back her nightmare moon self came out + Luna and celestia were given these type of manes as rewards get it now
0 likesO_O.... That begging... GOD
0 likesYes she did. You are right.
0 likesCelestia: AAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IT BURNS!!!!!!!!
0 likesI think that Celestia teleport through the sun
0 likesEPIC!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesWait,you might be right,since when Luna crashed the party she said "Your Dear Princess Is gone." Or some thing like that :p She might had gotten revenge like that and SENDED her to the SUN and then blah blah blah curse broke blah blah Celestia returns blah blah HAPPY EVER AFTER
0 likesI think that theory is true because celestia was never hurt or whatever so Luna never got free but that did happen to Luna so celestia got free. See what I mean?
0 likesEven if celestial got banished to the sun how did she survive? I don't think any pony can even survive on the sun not even princess celestia.
0 likesWouldn't celestial burn to ash if she was banished to the sun
0 likeswhen sunset shimmer went into time how come celestial was banished to the moon
0 likesomg this was before i dressed up a candy corn for halloween
0 likesIf what you say in this video is true don't you think nightmaremoon should be ranked higher in the best villain video. Just think celestia had to use the element's of harmony one of the most powerful magic in equestria to banish nightmaremoon to the moon but. If it is true that nightmaremoon banished celestia to the sun then that means she had more or the same power as the element's of harmony. You would think that that should put her at least 1 more point above or the same as queen chrysalis and sunset shimmer.
0 likesthat theory was a short one but its stall good
0 likesYou have a point there
0 likesI believe this is true
0 likesOr maybe Celestia hide in the sun to escape Luna because she knew she was no mach for her without the elements of Harmony.
1 likeDUDE NIGHTMARE MOON SAYS SHE BANISHED CELESTIA TO THE SUN
0 likesgood thinking or it was a test and the suns light was a portal
0 likesLuna looks just like she was when she was a filly when she became Luna again so I'm guessing that her age stay when she's been is to the Moon
0 likesthat's wut I thought that nightmare moon banished celestia to the sun as revenge for trapping her in the moon
0 likesthe sun can kill anyone
0 likesthat was literally ONE.MINUTE.LONG.WTH
0 likesthat makes sense!
0 likesnobody seen a "MARE IN THE SUN"
0 likesHave you watched the episode that Celestia was a villain named I forgot the name so I think that's why she was going into the going into the sun
0 likesReplies (1)
Botánica Anaisa Her villain name was Daybreaker. Having her powers switched with Luna's, she either visited her own nightmare or Starlight's. The episode is called "A Royal Problem".
0 likesShortest theory ever.
0 likesI though she just grab a cake from sugarcube corner
1 likeIt changes how learners does episode to episode ex lunas mane is solid but is later seen like nighmare moons
0 likeswhy is Luna's hair a single color now? because when they banished discord, Luna's hair was multicolored, and the first time they banished him it was before Celestia banished her to the moon. maybe it's a sign of power? since when Celestia was small, she must've not have that much magic, but gradually became better with magic and then her hair became the rainbow flowy hair it is now. Does this mean that twilight or cadence will get multicolor flowy looking hair in the future???
0 likesPrincess Celestia is the sun!
0 likes:)
Banished to the sun?!
0 likesMe:I NEED TO PUT MORE SOUND
0 likesSound:🔈🔉🔊
Video:END TIME
Me:NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!
Wow... that was,... super short
0 likesYes Luna banished her to the sun when she went missing
0 likesoh god the audio THE AUDIO MAKE IT STOP MAKE IT STOP!!!
2 likesShe probably came out from the sun lkke luna does at night with the moon ( ͠° ͟ʖ ͡°)
0 likesI think she is not fire proof so she wasn't banished to the sun if She was why is she alive
0 likesBruh if celestia was banished to the sun she would be burning alive man
0 likesSHE SAID THAT LUNA DID BANISH HER TO THE SUN
0 likesIt's really in the moon
0 likesshe was banished this told the real story about that.
0 likesAhhhhh! I never noticed that! Nice!
0 likesI don't think that princess celestia was banished to the sun.
0 likesAwesome vid!!!! But one thing... Why is Luna so young?😐😐😐😐🙂
0 likeshe's a changling!?! gasp
0 likesSorry Brony Notion, but this theory is incorrect. Celestia was never banished to the sun. Celestia appeared after Nightmare Moon was defeated and became Luna once again.
2 likesReplies (1)
Lauren actually confirmed that she was
0 likesAnd yes I know this comment is 5 years old
But this video came up in my reccomendations
The music is a slowed down version of love is in bloom without vocals
0 likesDuh that's what everyone thought right?😳
0 likesWow....never noticed that before. that would make sense though. :)
0 likesI want to agree you so much with this
1 likeWouldn't she like
0 likesImmediately disintegrate
Not really possible XDDD
0 likesWow, that was..... short?
0 likesWho enjoyed S5 ep 1+2? I think it was a bit based off of Cupcakes...
0 likesShortest bid ever XD
0 likesshe would die if she came out of the sun my theary is that she was band to the moon think about it luna means moon but celestia means star the sun is the bigist star but she would be dead by then i dont think this theary is right if you where band to the sun for a thousned years you would die just by being there so my thoughts about this is that she was bannd to the moon
0 likesWait... How many times did Season 5 ruined the videos.
0 likesMe: Seeing how many years has been.
0 likesOld me: This vid came in 1minute ago
That was fast I did not learn anything this time
0 likeswish they would have made it obvious waht happened
0 likesHow? Celestia had not the power to Banish Luna alone she needed the Elements of Harmony to do so i think that she used her Magic to do that teleportation kind of think :D i mean... S1 Trollestia FTW as we all know :D
0 likesgood idea I think that's what happened, but if you've ever seen the pictures of Luna on the moon,(see Luna let it go) what would the surface of the sun look like when Celestia was on it? Wouldn't she just get burned up?:( unless the surface is different than our sun, which I don't think it is. Unless.... something "magical" was protecting Celestia, or this isn't possible sorry, Brony Notion :(
0 likesWoah... this is old
0 likesMakes sence:)
1 likeI don't think this is an accurate theory. Let's look back at when each pony told how they got their cutie mark to CMC. When Twilight was telling her story, Celestia was in the story, when Luna was banished. After Luna was banished, there was a 1000 year peace, and Twilight bought Luna back so if Celestia was banished during the 1,000 year peace, how can you explain Twilight being Celestia's student?
0 likesReplies (3)
Nightmare Moon came back on the longest day a thousand years after being banished to the moon by her sister, Princess Celestia. Upon her return, Nightmare Moon may have banished Princess Celestia to the sun in the hopes of ruling over all of Equestria with no threat to her power (not realizing that Twilight Sparkle and her friends would be able to defeat her by acquiring the powers from the Elements of Harmony). Basically, there WAS 1,000 years of peace while Nightmare Moon was banished... Just that one day of her return was when Princess Celestia could have been banished.
0 likesAFTER Luna came back THEN she banished Celestia
0 likes@Aureja Stankeviciute exactly.
0 likesat 2013 his name was the notion
0 likes"Is Celestia banish to the Sun?" Nope
0 likesReplies (2)
Actually is supposedly canon.
1 like@Kalyx Maybe i dunno
1 likeNo cause in the new episode in the past Nightmaremoon said I banished Celestia into the moon
0 likesYeah when nightmare moon came that's why celestial did not come one stage arvise she would of helped so she went to the sun
0 likesNightmare Moon Banished Celistea to the Sun
0 likescelestia banned to the sun = she burns to death
1 likeits logic even in mlp
Replies (1)
she is an immortal being
0 likesI TOTALLY AGREE
0 likescelestia was banished to the moon
0 likesNo she was banished to the Moon by NGHTMRE moon
0 likesit was a bubble of sun the sun was in the sky.!!!!!!!
0 likeswell my universe is daybreaker was real
0 likesI tihink you are right💗
0 likesor Luna / night mare moon got set free and then vanished Celestia.
0 likesbefore celestia and luna were born who was controlling the sun and moon
0 likesTHATS WHAT I THOUGHT TOO !!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesThat makes sense
0 likesLuna in Latin means The moon
0 likesGod bless you!
0 likesAre you have a good day?
0 likesONE MINUTE WHAT THE ACTUAL BUCK
0 likesShortest theory video ive seen on yt
0 likesI think that a great thought.
0 likesWait so was there nighttime when luna was banished??
0 likesWhy is Celestia"s name PRINCESS Celestia?,
0 likesis there someone who is higher up than her in the royal chain?
Replies (1)
nah, it’s just that there’s a negative connotation towards queens in animated media, you know, it’s sorta to do with the whole “evil stepmother” thing. celestia was actually originally meant to be called “queen celestia” but hasbro decided against it. seems like they’ve since gone against that idea with the inclusion of queen novo of the hippogriffs.
0 likesno she wasn't it was the moon its definate
0 likesshe vanished to the sun
0 likesno Celestia Banished to the Sun Celestia Banished to the moon
0 likesNot down graded defieded. Go to past sins the spell is exsplend
0 likesCelestia shouldve been sent to the sun when banished yet they say and say she was on the damn moon makes absolute no goddamn sense and if so then celestia should be in there for a thousand sun's like Luna?
1 likeSo how the fuck did she got out ???
Replies (1)
Alyssa Canonico She was allegedly banished for 1,000 years and I guess her sentence either expired or was commuted. My question is how did she even survive for any length of time in an environment with no oxygen?
0 likesin cutie-re mark celista was banishied to the moon
0 likesyou're a changeling too?! I thought I got rid of you all?
0 likesI like that description
0 likesTHAT WAS RLLY SHORT
0 likesMy opinion is,the sun is too hot.So that is my super short opinion.
0 likesCool theory. . .wait a minute..your a changling!?!
0 likesNgl I kinda miss the fact that Celestia used to be depicted as fearce and gracefull. now she’s just a troll that loves cake
2 likesor...SHE.WAS.THE SUN! (DUN DUN DUN!) ILLUMINATI CONFIRMED!
0 likesI don't think she was banished to the sun. She would need the elements of harmony. And at the time, she did not have it :|
0 likesThe brony notion is a changeling look at his intro
0 likesHAHA, YEEEEEEAH!
0 likesHey Luna's mane changed after the first episode did nobody realise that? i mean how did it change so fast?!
0 likesReplies (1)
She regained her magic power.
0 likesPublished 2013? Such a chad
2 likesWhat time was it when the sun came up because that is really important. because. what if it too late to raise the sun
0 likesno celestia didn't banished to the sun because she rayses the sun and she cwn connect at the sun
0 likesBANANA CAKE IS QUEEN
0 likesWait a second you are a changeling!?!
0 likesB hill Celestial took that over they explain that in the first episode of the first season!!!
0 likesI think she was banished to the sun
0 likesno, she could'nt have been banished to the sun then who would watch over equestria
0 likesReplies (1)
that’s the thing - nobody would “watch over” equestria, nightmare moon would be ruling equestria with an iron hoof. it’s even shown in one of the timelines twilight travels to that if nightmare moon was never defeated, celestia would be banished to the moon just like she was.
0 likesShe come from the sun
0 likesThis would make some sense, and since celestia is princess of the Sun, she wouldn't burn up... would she??? DUN DUN DUUUUUN!!!!!
0 likesWouldn't it burn celstia
0 likesoooh! Good pointy point!
0 likesbut, unless she was using magic to survive the heat of a class B star, celestia would have burnt to a crisp in 1 millisecond.
0 likesReplies (2)
+Joshua Slocombe but yet Luna breathed in space.....
0 likes@Regina Becerril well, maybe they can only live forever, but can still die of injury
0 likesI think that she got so mad and she nock her out did she so she trapped her on the sun for revenge and to get her out of her way.
0 likesYo watch the intro in 0.25 speed to see someones else eyes
0 likeswhat is the title of the episode?
0 likesum mis surbri I know how celestia got her colorful main in a mini show I saw it says that Tia and Luna got their mains like that to show that they have their full power and means that their stronger
0 likesuhhh no it was the the MAIN 6 met when it was the sun festival
1 likeThis is too short
1 likeSo she wasn't burned into a crisp
0 likesThis is possible but celestia was there when twilight sparkle was there and didn’t the banishment with princess Luna happen before twilight sparkle was born???
0 likesshe deserved it
0 likesNEW LUNAR REBUBLIC
This was to short !!!!but nice vid.I guess...
0 likesIf Luna was banished to the moon for 1,000 years, how is Celestia still alive to see her freed? No offense, but did she commute her sentence, did she have a time machine, or did God allow her to live that long as part of the divine right to rule or something?
1 likeReplies (106)
It’s equestria,
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer No offense, but was that supposed to be a comma or a period?
1 likeBoth actually because I was going to write more than I was like nahh
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer OK, then, but what in Equestria makes it possible to literally be as old as Methuselah?
1 likeHave you ever seen a pony die in equestria except sombra of corse, but he didn’t die for natural reasons
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer I haven't seen enough of the series to know for sure whether any pony dies of natural causes.
1 likeThe crystal ponies! They have been alive for over a thousand years! Also that is funny that you bring pinkie clones up because I just finished watching a video about how a pinkie clone (yes one didn’t die, watch the episode where rarity opens up a new shop in manehatten) is Tirek, at first it made no sense but in the end a made a little bit of sense, but thinking about it again it makes no sense
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer OK, but don't the crystal ponies live in the Crystal Empire, not Equestria?
1 likeSo they are still ponies, and the crystal empire is part of equestria even though it is far away from most other places in equestria, think of it like this Alaska didn’t seem like it should be part of America considering how far away it is from the rest of America but it is still part of America you could say the same thing With Hawaii
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer In that case, why does the Crystal Empire have its own monarchy?
1 likeBecause since the crystal empire is so far north it needs its own alicorn to keep away the cold and rule, if there is some sort of problem celestia can’t just be like oh oof gotta go, unless it was really important of corse, but with an alicorn of its own you don’t need someone traveling across the whole contry or whatever to solve a small problem boom
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer The Kitten Gamer So that means she is, in essence, more of a royal governor than a princess. No offense, but why is it called the "Crystal Empire" and not the "Crystal Crown Dependency"?
1 likeI belive she is a princess and a royal governor Man just over a month ago I never knew I could have a long conversation about MLp thank you brony Notion I love mlp again
1 likeHmm you have a good point, mabye, uh I dunno, just realized first we where talking about pony lifespans now we are talking about the crystal empire talk about changing the subject
1 likeHey! Did you know twilights staff appears 3 times? Cause I didn’t! (SORRY I just like pinkie pie)
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer 3 times in this video or 3 times in the entire series?
1 likeThe entire series, 1 the first time I forgot the episode name 2. Slice of life 3. The gift of maud pie, if you pause it at the exact right time when rarity is throwing a whole bunch of stuff you see twilights staff witch is pretty funny why would they be selling that
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer OK, then. I just saw your comment that says you like Pinkie Pie, so I have a few questions about her, but I'm not sure whether I should ask them all here.
1 likeOne of my biggest questions about her, though, is how does she perform her cartoonish stunts? Is she some sort of a magician who knows a lot about magic tricks or is she simply a really successful physicist?
What do you mean, like pinkie sense and all that?
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer Possibly. I'm still somewhat skeptical about the "Pinkie sense."
1 likeWhat I'm really asking about is how she is seemingly bound by completely separate laws of physics ("cartoon physics") than those that apply to the rest of the characters.
She is secretly from spongebob!!!! Dun dun duuuuun. Ok ok idk it’s very confusing because it’s like she knows she is on a TV show, and she can just fall apart and then put herself back together (you saw that episode right) It’s like pinkie pie is just not from MLP wait! That gives me an idea, what if she isn’t well she obisly is but what if she is from a different dimension, and she came to equestria using, magical thingy stuff, and in that world most ponies, people or whatever lives there (who knows mabye she changed her appearance to fit in) has that confusing logic. Dunno just a theory, but if she is from another dimention then maybe she went there to send a distress signal but soon realized she woundn’t be able to tell her “parents” and “sisters” the truth so she decided to stay in this land of equstria because of everything she has done there and knew how everyone would feel if she left
2 likesWhat if, she is from the same dimention as discord dun dun duuuuuun
2 likesThe Kitten Gamer One of my ideas actually was that she is a diplomatic ambassador from a universe where different laws of physics apply and, as such, has been granted diplomatic immunity from MLP's laws of physics.
1 likeThe theory that I've come up with and find most plausible, however, is that all of this is simply just a set of magic tricks/illusions. (This would mean that the multiple slices of her are simply from a variant on the "saw someone in half" trick, for example.) If not that, however, my next go-to explanation is that she has an extensive knowledge of physics that even surpasses Twilight's.
I have not watched enough of the series to know where she got her powers for sure, but it's sometimes cool to think about. Speaking of which, I also like to think about whether or not she could fool Penn and Teller on "Fool Us" if she somehow came to this world. They, too, have tested the laws of physics, but have been baffled before by equally as sorcerous feats. Do you think she could fool them? I'm personally uncertain.
Honestly I dunno
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer OK, then. I'm just glad that the boundary between reality and fiction is impossible to breach, otherwise we should expect far worse to happen than a pink pony sorceress fooling Penn and Teller more than Shawn Farquhar did. (Funnily enough, though, there is a video that may have been made by some of the VA's from the show about Pinkie breaking out of a computer screen.)
1 likeBy the way, does it seem as though there is a canonical explanation as to her mysterious abilities?
I just thought of an idea!!! What if pinkie was going to tell ponyville the truth but then twilight cane so she decided to put it off to throw a party, but then she discovered she had to be the bearer of the element of laughter and she thought telling everybody the truth would make them not want to be her friend, making it so the Elements of harmony wound’t work because you need harmony to use the elements of harmony you need, well harmony
1 likeI just thought of something different, remember that pinkie pie in castle-mania well what if that is a clone pinkie, pinkie has a great memory but that pinkie playing the organ didn’t know she could play the organ. The real pinkie can play every instrument ever and she has a great memory so she should know if she could play the organ, but this pinkie didn’t know she could,
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer As a student of the piano, it was rather easy for me to learn how to play the organ, so that isn't surprising at all because she already knows how to play the accordion, so all she really needs to learn is how to use the pedals and the drawbars. She may not have known it was so easy to learn because there aren't many full-fledged organs to go around there, but that's just my opinion.
1 likeThe other theory may sound pretty interesting, but I believe something like it actually happened in the "Equestria Girls" movie with Twilight.
No offense, but my question is whether you know the canonical explanation is if there even is one yet.
There isn’t I don’t think, but I won’t be responding to anything else you say till tommorow I’m with my family so yea cya
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer I hope you have fun.
1 likeTHX
1 likeI’m baaaaack!!
1 likeThat makes sense, but why was she in the castle at that time, playing the organ at that time framing everypony out
1 likeAlso the thing with pinkie pie falling apart and putting herself back together she really did fall apart because she didn’t just do it to show everypony it just happened
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer Perhaps either she always wanted to learn the organ and that was the only place she knew that had one or she did whatever it was she did to predict where Rainbow Dash would be.
1 likeNo offense, but would there be any particular reason as to why she would fall apart without wanting to show off her ability to perform parlor tricks or something like that?
She just fell apart no one was even paying attention to her they where paying attention to cadence and Shining armour because they just said they where having a baby
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer OK, but I'm not sure how to explain it if she did it without her own knowledge. If that's the case, we may have bigger problems.
1 likeTo your point, though, it seems as though it's impossible for it to merely be stage magic because it would ruin the plot. I actually did have a thought, though: what if, in the style of Monty Python and Deadpool, the so-called "fourth wall" does not exist (i.e. the characters know we are watching)? That could possibly explain how she could pull off such magic tricks: they are entirely for our amusement and have no practical purpose in their universe, but I'm not sure about this.
Your theory dose make sense, but I have to disagree only pinkie and twilight know about us watching them, I have proof, watch the end of boast busters as the screen is becoming black pinkie opens it and climbs in then twilight teleports in and gives pinkie her mouth back, and in the one where pinkie pie knows at the end she shakes her head at the audience and maybe she fell apart to entertain the audience. I think we might be on to something!
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer That may be a pretty good explanation as well, but we'd still then be missing out on how she does it for practical effect and when others are watching (e.g. chasing Rainbow Dash by appearing out of nowhere, slowing her fall to not make as much noise, and disappearing into Applejacks's apple bucket).
1 likeI belive pinkie for whatever reason has the magic of an alicorn except trapped in the body of an earth pony and even without a horn or wings this excessive magic affects her in different ways, gives her too much energy, makes her run crazy fast, gives her an amazing memory, and all that stuff that only the one and only pinkie can do, oh and also pinkie sense. Ether that or she is from a different dimention or other headcannos that u can think of
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer No offense to you, but I think I have been told that Earth ponies have naturally superior physical strength, so her speed may be simply explained by the fact that she's the pony equivalent of a world-class track star. I don't know whether this is true, though.
1 likeThat explanation could make sense, but I'm not sure how that could be possible.
She adopted
1 likeWell I mean she probably is
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer So she could've been born an alicorn and turned into an Earth pony because she was adopted by a family of Earth ponies?
1 likeI have an idea of what could have happened. She was in the fields of the rock farm and found a little pink rock she took to it her room to look at later. When she was in her room later that night She picked it back up and showed her parents. Her parents took it from her, knowing it was a magical gem and they knew a little filly should not have such magic, but when her parents took it away she got zapped. A zap of magic, because that Little Rock was connected to the element of laughter, and was on the rock farm because of destiny trying to find the future bearer of its magical properties. It zapped her because the gem knew it was this pink filly that would become the future bearer of the event of laughter and when it zapped her it gave her magic, too much of it. If she gained that magic slowly it woundn’t effect her as much but she got the magic from an element of harmony in just a few seconds this was too much magic for her to take in within just a few seconds. Yet she couldn’t use this magic and she felt fine soon afterward. The next day she was working on the fields wondering about what happened until she saw the sonic rainboom looking at it gave her the ability to unlock this magic, and figure out the meaning of life (ok not really) but it did unlock the magic she gained the night before, the tree of harmony gave her the idea to plan a party starting the journey of her getting her cutie mark and become the element of laughter’s future bearer.
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer That sounds like something they'd write! Where did you get it?
1 likeI thought of it, but thanks for the complement!
1 likeI thought of it! Thanks for the complement!
2 likesWait lol the event of laughter I can’t spell
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer You're welcome. Another thought I had is that as the most successful physicist in Equestria, she spends a lot of time researching higher (4 or more) dimensional solid figures, which could explain how she knew Discord was hidden in a box. (Her advanced knowledge of physics would also likely explain a lot more...)
1 likeI thought of more when it zapped pinkie it gave her magic only the element of laughter itself should have part of this magic connects it to the tree of harmony whitch means pinkie herself is connected to the tree of harmony with whitch is by pinkie sense may work because the tree can sense the future I think
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer That's also an interesting thought, but would the other elements have similar powers?
1 likeNo because if twilight got the elements of Magic’s magic then her abilities will be a lot better, and think about it. Without all her energy and crazy stuff whitch always makes me laugh would you or other ponies laugh at her as hard? I have some evidence that she has Pegasus magic. In secrets and lies she was walking on clouds, sure twilight just used her spell. NO pinkie pie had balloons attached to her but she could still walk on the clouds. The balloons where just there so rainbow doesn’t question how she is walking on clouds. If rainbow asks twilight about the whole situation twilight would have no idea and then rainbow could possibly figure out what happened to her on the rock farm.
1 likeI also think the elements contain stronger than alicorn magic. Could six alicorns defeat discord or nightmare moon or any villain who they used the elements of harmony on. No so the elements must be stonger than alicorns. Also I have evidence that pinkie could have some of the elements of laughters magic. When pinkie didn’t feel like she had friends (party of one) she was really messed up. Without the other elements the element of laughter proves useless and with pinkie feeling alone the magic could drain from her, changing how she acts, of corse she will always love parties and that kind of thing, but without the elements of laughter’s magic she won’t be the same. Also
1 likewhen the tree sensed pinkie didn’t feel normal, being connected to her it tried to help her, but that “help” gave her the bright idea to try to become friends with objects the tree probably could have just taken over her body and brain (maybe) to fix it but if the tree did do that it would use to much of its magic and cause the events in princess twilight sparkle to happen sooner. This would also, give her long term effects and also mess her up after it left her, and being the tree of harmony it knew all of this, and yes we know for sure that the tree of harmony has a mind of its own watch season 8 episode 16 I think I will check later.
1 likeIt’s season 8 episode 22
0 likesThe Kitten Gamer Your theory still seems interesting to me, but have we ever seen a pony fall from a cloud because of a lack of the proper abilities?
1 likeOnly Pegasi can walk on clouds though, and yes in the school raze part 1 and sonic rainboom.rafity falls through the clouds after her wings melt away
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer I guess that explains why Pinkie had so many balloons attached to her in "Secrets and Pies".
1 likeAlso, I get that this is a public forum, but isn't it weird that almost all of our responses have at least one like? Is it possible that these are all from the same person? If so, the "like" button seems to have lost its value here (no offense). If not, we must be really coming up with some great theories!
1 likeBut I think she only had those balloons to make sure rainbow didn’t suspect anything, I still think that and I think she could have still walked on the clouds without the balloons because of what I think happened to her as a filly
1 likeJust saying it was me lol.
1 likeI did it because the more likes means more people will see it and if many people see it and like it the brony notion might see it and make a video on it.
1 likeBut I think we did get a few likes from others in there.
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer I'm sorry about that remark, then. The others were from me.
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer This doesn't explain everything I'd like to know, but here's his theory on her psychic abilities: https://youtu.be/JUavdDD0_oA
1 likehttps://youtu.be/-Sym1h72K2c this is interesting, I don’t belive it for a second but tell me what you think
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer That sounds very interesting, but that would likely mean there'd need to be a "real" Pinkie for the changeling Pinkie to base his/her disguise on.
1 likeI still like mine better:)
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer I like yours better as well.
1 likeWhat my head cannon from before is why only twilight became an alicorn. If pinkie had something to manipulate with her magic then the things logic defying things she dose won’t be possible. She would also become more like her family (no offense to maud she is awesome) The worst part is she woundn’t have the confidence to use the element of laughter and fulfill her destiny. Also she would still be connected with the tree of harmony she won’t need that magic to fly or use a horn.
1 likeIf they all became alicorns except pinkie they would want to know why and then pinkie would have to tell her friends the truth witch is exatly what pinkie knew she was not ready. The reason why twilight became an alicorn is because she is ready, physically and mentally. Pinkie is physically ready but not mentally.
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer Isn't alicorn status only given to royals, though?
1 likeI mean she has enough magic to become one.
1 likeIf my head cannon is correct that it.
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer So what you're telling me is she has enough magic to change her own DNA to put herself into a royal bloodline.
1 likeNo wait I mean if celestia turned all of them into alicorns she would have to give everyone extra magic to really have alicorn magic, but if she made pinkie into one she woundn’t need extra magic
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer OK, then. I'm just wondering why she ever would be turned into an alicorn if she isn't royalty.
1 likeWhat I never said she was turned into an alicorn
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer I know she never was, but I'm just asking would there ever be a pony turned into an alicorn who does not come from royal blood?
1 likeTwilight didn’t have royal blood.
1 likeGoodnight!
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer Aren't she and Shining Armour both members of the House of Friendship, though?
1 likeThe house of friendship?
1 likeSeriously what is the house of friendship I watched all the episodes and it never mentions the house of friendship
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer It's in Twilight's title; she's the "Princess of Friendship".
1 likeOk but what is the house of friendship.
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer I don't come from a country with a monarchy, so here's the best thing I've come up with: a royal house is not an actual house one would see on a street, but rather a family of royals (e.g. Windsor and Hapsburg). This would mean that the House of Friendship essentially consists of Twilight's family.
1 likeBut that would be after twilight became a alicorn
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer But didn't Shining Armour marry Cadence before then? She'd likely look bad in front of both her parliament and Equestria's if she didn't marry another royal.
1 likeOk that dose make twilight royal, but I’m pretty sure cadence woundn’t marry another royal just so she woundn’t look bad she isn’t that type of pony. Also how do we know cadence was royal before she was an alicorn or even celestia and Luna, based on notions theory everypony born in the alicorn civilization was destined to be an alicorn, meaning if celestia and Luna where born there, them being alicorns is common.
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer I don't know about that, but I do believe that there was someone in line for the British monarchy who was taken out of line for marrying an American commoner divorcée.
1 likeIDK how to respond to that
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer But this does bring up an interesting question: before providing an heir to the Equestrian throne, of which kingdom were the Friendships the rulers?
1 likeWhat do you mean by of whitch kingdom
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer I don't know whether you know the answer, but if the Friendships were a royal family before moving to Equestria, which land did they rule over?
1 likeGood question, but I think the alicorn civilization because before celestia and Luna equestria was not a good place to live, if they ruled over equestria, then all of that equestrian history we know is not true.
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer That would explain why the rulers are alicorns, but is there a "Free Equestria" party or something that aims to restore the previous government? (Or did Celestia give each nationalist a "Pow! Right in the kisser!"?)
1 likeNo idea, but that gives me an idea, saying as how you thought there could be people trying to take celestia and Luna down from the throne what if their is. What if they are trying their hardest to do that, what if they are descendants of the original rulers of the three tribes. Working separately to bring back what their ancestors started. They may still believe what others believed back then but who could be responsible for this? Who could be a descendants of the three tribe rulers. Well what if I told you it is (drum role please) spike. Or not spike himself but he could be helping in something. He could be a changing trying to help one of the three tribes. Why would a changing want this? I think because this changing dosn’t like the others for whatever reason so it is trying to ruin the changlings food sorse. And to where and back again dosn’t prove this theory wrong, they could be trying to turn life upside down for the changlings because the changlings are good friends with ponies. Ok this theory dose have more holes in it than Queen chrisles but is still a possibility
1 likeI'm not sure whether that would necessarily mean Cadence was always a royal, as, at least in the Commonwealth of Nations, royal governors are appointed by the monarch, so perhaps if Celestia or her PM somehow convinced Equestria's parliament to not go against her for appointing a non-royal, it's possible it could have been done.
1 likeI've also read, however, that Cadence may be Celestia's adopted niece, meaning that she could be a member of Celestia and Luna's royal house.
Maybe but r u sure that is cannon, or more like do you have anyway to prove that is cannon.
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer It's in one of the books in the franchise, apparently, but I'm not sure whether it's canon, so I said "may be" instead of "is".
1 likeWell no matter what that is really interesting
1 likeThe Kitten Gamer So it may or may not be the final season... do you think the source of Pinkie Pie's powers will be revealed?
0 likesAre you guys friends yet?
0 likesAlpha Wolf I've no idea. We used to be sending these things back and forth every day or so, but for some reason, we stopped.
0 likesThis is only 59 seconds so short
0 likesDAMN it Hasbro do better at this shit !
1 likeNo she hasn’t been.
0 likeswow that makes so much easy since
0 likesHe put this up at 2013. He didn't see this episode yet.!..!
0 likesI think that Luna didn't banish celestia because she didn't have the elements of harmony so where did Luna banish celestia
0 likesWas Princess Celestia Banish to the sun? Cause even tho she knew that Nightmare moon is coming bk she never appear xd
0 likesTHE BUBBLE PONY!!
0 likesI. Think she just rose the sun
0 likesI think that. Celestial and Luna are princesses and their parents were the king and queen .like even though queens are usually bad. Not all queens are. Look at raven queen from everafterhigh she was suppose to be the new queen but she Chose to be a good queen.Notice?
0 likesShe was wearing her 2 million sunblock. Just kidding -- it's a good theory.
0 likesThat was an ok ? you should do who is apple jacks mom and dad?!
1 likewow "longest" video ever
0 likesYeah, she would be burnt in less than a sec.....
0 likesso I didn't got banished from Luna because you didn't miss her sister much of that
0 likeswow this is so old
0 likesCelestia wouldn't be in the sun cos Luna didn't the want sun so......
0 likesWow just wow
0 likesI think you are right
0 likesDude the video was way too short
0 likeshaven you herd of a grand entress
1 likeThat would be soooo hot (pun intended)!
0 likesWow Lannie that makes sense too
0 likesausome theory dude
0 likesw-wait what?
0 likesno it was a flourish for her arrival simply, and nothing more.
0 likesso short! wow
0 likesWow, not explaining the theory at all. At least he does in his "newer" vids cuz he's dead
0 likesThat was so short
0 likesThat was so short
0 likesreally logic
0 likesIf she was banished to the sun she would have died because the sun is so hot.
0 likesShe is such a troll she banishises her sister to the moon then makes her apologize. Why didn't she just break the spell in the first place?
0 likesi think Celestia Princess Celestia is like tangled the little piece of the Sun
0 likesThen uh who raised the sun for a thousand years???
0 likesReplies (1)
i think what happened was that as soon as nightmare moon was released, she faced her sister and banished her - i don’t think they mean she was banished for a thousand years.
0 likesThis sooo has to be true because if not were in Equestria was princess Celestia!Oh right, the sun!this is soo true I knew it when I saw the episode.
0 likesmy brain hurts
0 likesin the sun for a thousand years? nopony noticing? I think not.
0 likesReplies (2)
Since you didn't watch the video clearly he said for all of part two so basically when nightmare moon escaped she sent Celestia to the sun but once the mane six defeated Nightmare Moon the spell was broken.
0 likes@The Godly Brony oooh ok thanks for pointin' that out :P guess add kicked in again lol xP
0 likeswait what banshed
0 likesWhat's with no bro hoof? =(
0 likesPossible, in this future little brony.. In this future
0 likeswow that was a short video XD
0 likeslol so true
0 likesWhen will Celestia and Luna die?
0 likesCHANGELING
0 likesCelestia is banished in the sun look at the last episode of season 5 The Cutie Re-Mark when twilight came at the two sisters' old castle Nightmare Moon said Celestia was banished in the moon
1 likeReplies (2)
This was uploaded in 2013. Season 5 hadn't been released then.
2 likesit is
0 likesI think he is right mybe
0 likesWHAT AHE BANNASHE
0 likesthat quick what the heck you must atleast have a theory because you can not just say that you thought she was banished
0 likesThat was quick.
0 likesI can't believe this was posted on my birthday
0 likesshes back luna
0 likesIt's nightmare moon
0 likesShe would burn to a crisp
0 likesDO PONYS EVEN DIE OF OLD AGE!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesWhat's up with all of Luna's mane does???
0 likes@The Brony Notion 0:00 You'r a changeling??????!!!!!!
0 likesShortest.Video.EVER!!!!!!!!
0 likesi like it
0 likesThat might’ve burned.....
0 likesReplies (1)
SHE IS A PRINCESS
2 likesShe could use a spell to sheild herself from the sun's intense heat, because she has alicorn magin and not a typical unicorn with regular magic.
That was Short
0 likesYou’re Correct
0 likesI don't believe him.😾
0 likesWhat happened to flash sentry after the last episode
1 likeReplies (1)
What happens
0 likesWHAT!
0 likesHey b.n can you do q&a's pls for a change
0 likesI think u are right!!!!but celestia was there when she vanished Luna so how!!???????????? I am confused???????????Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
0 likesYou are a changeling!
0 likesHow short was that
0 likescould be true
0 likesAbout Princess Luna here's the th like somthing magic evil in like it was like a poison but just kept expanding like like something a bad guy
0 likesbecause the moon.
0 likes0:00 you r a changeling? I didn't know that,..
0 likesSO.SHORT.
0 likesIf Celestia was banished to the sun, she would be burned to death already
0 likesReplies (1)
Celestia is the sun.
4 likesI ♥ your vidoes Brony Notion♥♡♥♡♥♡♥♡♥♡♥
0 likesYour right
0 likesThis is 7 years late 😭
0 likesLuna is the name of earth's moon
0 likesReplies (1)
Sharareh Nouri ...
0 likesYup
0 likesin our world the Ifyou were walking on the sun you will die
0 likesis it the same for the MLP
That was quick
0 likesWow what a long video lol
0 likesWhat if daybreaker was the one vanished to the sun?
0 likesReplies (1)
@Alvin Yeoh it would make more sense
0 likesIt could be?
0 likesno no no no you dont understand do you even get it the thing is that when the princess was gone (I mean the princess of the sun) that was because that she was where twilight got to become a princess thats also to try to time traval to stop luna from becoming evail. Oh and the hair is because the princess (again I mean the princess of the sun) was holding the elements and if the elements where broken then her hair would become pink DAAAAA he he he :)
0 likeswell, since the Moon is quite safer than the Sun, why isn't Celestia died? I know she's an immortal alicorn and bla bla bla... but... oh dear...
0 likesReplies (2)
Without even going into the fact the moon has no atmosphere, Luna being sealed in the moon would've put her at risk for any number of illnesses linked to asbestos, which moon dust is a great deal like, and yet she survived a thousand years no worse for wear health-wise. So why is it unusual for a pony to possibly been magically sealed away within a star without burning to a crisp?
1 like@Jana Lybarger
0 likestrust me, better your brain exploded in no atmosphere and tumors because of the UV rays exposition than your brain exploded in no atmosphere, tumors because of the UV rays exposition, being crushed by the gravity, evaporated (or more likely "ionized") by the temperature and many other bad things... but, you know, MAGIC!
I ment to say adding not landing
0 likesThe shortest video everrrrrrr
0 likesBanished
1 likeyou mean put Solar Flare that means is Celestia in to the sun because she is princess of the sun
0 likes... Changeling?
0 likesgoing willh pegasister4life
0 likeswhat about twligth hair relating to her cutie mark
0 likes🥳🎂
0 likesHey what is up with Luna's hair why is it light blue but in other episodes twilight goes to a flashback before nightmare moon came to be and she had her hair like normal, all flowy, sparkly, and however else her hair normally is idk what's going on did becoming nightmare moon change her hair for a bit?
0 likesyup
0 likesTo the next video put why do princesses wear shoes
0 likesOh wow that was fast
0 likesA video on princess celestia
0 likesLuna=moon
0 likesWow I thoughtSunset shimmer was the sun but so last year is the sun what the heck
0 likesO.O woah
0 likesNon of us did!!!!
0 likesuhhh.... WHAT!!
0 likesnot even a minute
0 likesyou sounds like Grian
0 likesi thinki get it, nightmare moon wanted have equestria to herself, and banish celestia into the sun, but while celestia was banishing nightmare moon, nightmare moon must have put a spell that when she returns celestia will be banished into the sun. Then nightmare moons evil spell broke and she transformed back into luna, celestia returned from the sun. Nightmare moon wanted to have equestria on the 1000th year when she returned.
0 likesReplies (1)
Wow that makes sense anyone with me?
0 likesthat was short...
0 likesLune is French it meens moon
0 likesinteresting take....
0 likesWhen did your voice change
0 likesNo cause in cutie 're Mark nightmare moon says her SISTER is banished to the moon
0 likesInteresting. I suppose.
0 likesCelestia was banished to the sun? Thats hot
0 likesReplies (1)
@INDIGO BLUEoO ponies never die on the show that's why they did not let Celestia die when she got hit by nightmare moon witch was still kinda funny LOL XD darkness in a kids show ha LOL XD
0 likesI don't think that is true
1 likeEmmm brony notion please say Bro hoof slowly not like "this is the brony notion sining out Bro hoof! More like this is the brony notion sining out... Bro hoof!
0 likesYou are almost right.She for banished but in the moon just like nightmare moon.Season 5 finale!
0 likesReplies (2)
She got banished.stupid auto correct
0 likes+Δήμητρα Αβραάμ except that this is an old video. So the information is just outdated.
0 likesIs this in 2015?
0 likesoh its working now
0 likesShe was
0 likesthats why the ponies ask nightmare moon where is princess celestia
0 likesNope LOL
1 likeYea maybe 📜📜📜
0 likesYOUR VIDEOS ARE TO SHORT!!
0 likesThis is the shortest video
0 likeswhy did you even make this a video? its not even 1 min long!
0 likesIrony
1 likehawt discord
0 likestoo short
0 likesWut? no bro hove?
0 likesmakes todle sence
1 likeReplies (1)
totally
0 likesthats it
0 likesI mean the moon
0 likesSuper quick.
1 likeWow. This vid is so bad compared to the ones ur making now XD
0 likesSeason 5 is out now?!?!?!?!?
0 likesWhy did no pony tell me?!?!?
Replies (2)
It isn't
0 likesyeah it isn`t out yet.it comes out at on april 4th at 11am/10 central.
0 likesYeah right
0 likescool
0 likescool
0 likesWorst yet best video ever
0 likesU just messed the story of two sisters
0 likesI think so
0 likesI MENT TO SAY BUCK
0 likesITS SO HOT ON THE SUN!!!!!!!!
1 likeYes it is oveust
0 likeslunas back
0 likesi spelt a few words wrong )XP
0 likesThatd hurt
0 likesMy sister says make a longer video
0 likesdo lunas hair
0 likesWhat??????????
0 likesDo you know about Princess amora
0 likesEh. . . the sun is very hot. . . so celestia is dead. . .
0 likesÀre you a pony?
0 likesYour videos seem kinda plain now
0 likesMaybe I don't know??✌️💬
0 likesWho else is watching 6 years later
0 likes😋?
0 likesSo rainbow tornadoes can defeat evil villans
0 likesReplies (1)
sonia deguzman Check out Bill Wurtz's "History of Japan".
0 likesI Have Something To Say!! Well Its Just Pinkie Soo Yeh She Pinkie Ok And Pinkie Is Mad
0 likesHello from the other side!
0 likesy u p
0 likeswhat in the world 😒
0 likeswell i have the most stupidest theory..........if celestia banished to the sun who puts her there she put luna to the moon so if celestia banished to the sun nightmare moon did it and its stupid and for me luna escaped in the moon in nightmare night (facepalm) wait no but still i need somepony to reply to me and help me to this
0 likeswAt
0 likesthat must of been hot
1 likeReplies (2)
I dont think it
0 likesI think when Celestia Banished Luna,she dont feel cold
so Celestia it dont feel the hot. O.O That is weird
Sorry if i say it wrong im from spanish :(
0 likeswhat the monetized
0 likesMore
0 likesAre u a changeling??
0 likes🐯
0 likesman no Internet
0 likesR u a homestuck
0 likesone night
0 likesummmmm what ?
0 likesO agree
0 likesokay???????
0 likesyour most shortest video
0 likesReplies (1)
@Trinity Southway It was so close into being a 1 minute video :P
0 likesok that was a short 1 does any 1 no why
0 likes#omg I love u
0 likesWow fast video
0 likesPoor, luna I hate celi
0 likesyea celestia was on the moon becuz on the sun she woyld be dead
1 likeReplies (3)
You spelt would wrong
0 likesyou spelld spelld wrong XDDD
0 likesno, she didn't. its spelt "spelt".
0 likesthis is your day off does episode 4 where is the last year when one discovered to nightmare moon when she was a sister 3 that dude with the big who's that drains Pony energy Susie where is she all this disaster happen
0 likesmabe?
0 likesreally
0 likesY U MAKE DOS VIDIOS SO SHORT?!??!?!?!?!
0 likesDislike just because it only took like a minute
0 likesI mean this
0 likesUr wrong
0 likesCelestia would have melted to death if she was banished to the sun.
0 likesReplies (2)
i don’t think they get banished “on” the moon, i think they just become “merged” with it, for a lack of a better term. the same could be said about luna - if celestia would burn from being banished to the sun, luna would easily die on the moon from lack of oxygen. so i think it’s more that their essence gets trapped inside the moon and not their physical bodies
0 likes@Bright New Future Unless Luna was teleported beneath the moon’s surface where there could be oxygen, by there’s nowhere Celestia could survive on the sun.
0 likes3short5me
0 likesi need to do therioy vedios ... (im smart so dont judge me by mu voice
0 likesReplies (2)
*me
0 likes@Katelyn Thomas AGH ... u know what I mean
0 likesPeanut
0 likes2019?
0 likesOMG I DIDNT SEE WHEN THIS VIDEO WAS PUBLISHED AND YOU VOICE AND INTRO IS SO WEIRDDDDD
1 likeHello! -June 18, 2021 1:11pm
0 likesshort .3.
0 likes...idk what to comment...
1 likehi I am moonlight sparkle
0 likesHow is ther only 9k likes
0 likesAre you a changeling
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes he is
0 likesDUH! Didn't u see that vid after the winter wrap up notion remix?
1 likeYES I AM THE FIRST ONE TO COMMENT IN 2021 IT THINK-
0 likesUm are u a changeling
0 likesNo
0 likesWa
0 likesR u a changling??????
0 likesReplies (1)
yah he is
0 likesNo
0 likesI hate celestia
0 likes2021 anypony?
1 likebbbboooo
0 likesNo dont subscribe he hasent uploded a vidio in like forever and its 2016 now
0 likesReplies (5)
+Barba Johannesen forever = 2 months... apparently
0 likes+Ian Hall no its 2016
0 likes+Barba Johannesen and your point is? If you click his name to go to his page and view his videos, his most recent uploads were 3 videos each 3 months ago. Ya, they were in 2015, but that doesn't mean they were uploaded a year ago.
0 likes+Ian Hall idk
0 likesSo? Subscribing lets you know when he DOES upload.
1 likeThe sun mother is Celestia Celestia was PREGNANT lol
1 likeBanished to the sun? That would be painful.
1 like12
0 likes6
0 likesDon't see what comment???
0 likesWhy is evebody comment a long time
0 likesHi
0 likesHei
0 likesDamn i the thousandth comment
1 likeReplies (1)
Congrats lol
0 likesboring who cares
0 likes