If Luna was banished to the moon for 1,000 years, how is Celestia still alive to see her freed? No offense, but did she commute her sentence, did she have a time machine, or did God allow her to live that long as part of the divine right to rule or something?

Alpha Wolf I've no idea. We used to be sending these things back and forth every day or so, but for some reason, we stopped.

Alpha Wolf I've no idea. We used to be sending these things back and forth every day or so, but for some reason, we stopped.

The Kitten Gamer So it may or may not be the final season... do you think the source of Pinkie Pie's powers will be revealed?

The Kitten Gamer So it may or may not be the final season... do you think the source of Pinkie Pie's powers will be revealed?

Well no matter what that is really interesting

Well no matter what that is really interesting

The Kitten Gamer It's in one of the books in the franchise, apparently, but I'm not sure whether it's canon, so I said "may be" instead of "is".

The Kitten Gamer It's in one of the books in the franchise, apparently, but I'm not sure whether it's canon, so I said "may be" instead of "is".

Maybe but r u sure that is cannon, or more like do you have anyway to prove that is cannon.

Maybe but r u sure that is cannon, or more like do you have anyway to prove that is cannon.

I'm not sure whether that would necessarily mean Cadence was always a royal, as, at least in the Commonwealth of Nations, royal governors are appointed by the monarch, so perhaps if Celestia or her PM somehow convinced Equestria's parliament to not go against her for appointing a non-royal, it's possible it could have been done.

I've also read, however, that Cadence may be Celestia's adopted niece, meaning that she could be a member of Celestia and Luna's royal house.

No idea, but that gives me an idea, saying as how you thought there could be people trying to take celestia and Luna down from the throne what if their is. What if they are trying their hardest to do that, what if they are descendants of the original rulers of the three tribes. Working separately to bring back what their ancestors started. They may still believe what others believed back then but who could be responsible for this? Who could be a descendants of the three tribe rulers. Well what if I told you it is (drum role please) spike. Or not spike himself but he could be helping in something. He could be a changing trying to help one of the three tribes. Why would a changing want this? I think because this changing dosn’t like the others for whatever reason so it is trying to ruin the changlings food sorse. And to where and back again dosn’t prove this theory wrong, they could be trying to turn life upside down for the changlings because the changlings are good friends with ponies. Ok this theory dose have more holes in it than Queen chrisles but is still a possibility

The Kitten Gamer That would explain why the rulers are alicorns, but is there a "Free Equestria" party or something that aims to restore the previous government? (Or did Celestia give each nationalist a "Pow! Right in the kisser!"?)

The Kitten Gamer That would explain why the rulers are alicorns, but is there a "Free Equestria" party or something that aims to restore the previous government? (Or did Celestia give each nationalist a "Pow! Right in the kisser!"?)

Good question, but I think the alicorn civilization because before celestia and Luna equestria was not a good place to live, if they ruled over equestria, then all of that equestrian history we know is not true.

Good question, but I think the alicorn civilization because before celestia and Luna equestria was not a good place to live, if they ruled over equestria, then all of that equestrian history we know is not true.

The Kitten Gamer I don't know whether you know the answer, but if the Friendships were a royal family before moving to Equestria, which land did they rule over?

The Kitten Gamer I don't know whether you know the answer, but if the Friendships were a royal family before moving to Equestria, which land did they rule over?

The Kitten Gamer But this does bring up an interesting question: before providing an heir to the Equestrian throne, of which kingdom were the Friendships the rulers?

The Kitten Gamer But this does bring up an interesting question: before providing an heir to the Equestrian throne, of which kingdom were the Friendships the rulers?

The Kitten Gamer I don't know about that, but I do believe that there was someone in line for the British monarchy who was taken out of line for marrying an American commoner divorcée.

The Kitten Gamer I don't know about that, but I do believe that there was someone in line for the British monarchy who was taken out of line for marrying an American commoner divorcée.

Ok that dose make twilight royal, but I’m pretty sure cadence woundn’t marry another royal just so she woundn’t look bad she isn’t that type of pony. Also how do we know cadence was royal before she was an alicorn or even celestia and Luna, based on notions theory everypony born in the alicorn civilization was destined to be an alicorn, meaning if celestia and Luna where born there, them being alicorns is common.

The Kitten Gamer But didn't Shining Armour marry Cadence before then? She'd likely look bad in front of both her parliament and Equestria's if she didn't marry another royal.

The Kitten Gamer But didn't Shining Armour marry Cadence before then? She'd likely look bad in front of both her parliament and Equestria's if she didn't marry another royal.

But that would be after twilight became a alicorn

But that would be after twilight became a alicorn

The Kitten Gamer I don't come from a country with a monarchy, so here's the best thing I've come up with: a royal house is not an actual house one would see on a street, but rather a family of royals (e.g. Windsor and Hapsburg). This would mean that the House of Friendship essentially consists of Twilight's family.

The Kitten Gamer It's in Twilight's title; she's the "Princess of Friendship".

The Kitten Gamer It's in Twilight's title; she's the "Princess of Friendship".

Seriously what is the house of friendship I watched all the episodes and it never mentions the house of friendship

Seriously what is the house of friendship I watched all the episodes and it never mentions the house of friendship

The Kitten Gamer Aren't she and Shining Armour both members of the House of Friendship, though?

The Kitten Gamer Aren't she and Shining Armour both members of the House of Friendship, though?

The Kitten Gamer I know she never was, but I'm just asking would there ever be a pony turned into an alicorn who does not come from royal blood?

The Kitten Gamer I know she never was, but I'm just asking would there ever be a pony turned into an alicorn who does not come from royal blood?

What I never said she was turned into an alicorn

What I never said she was turned into an alicorn

The Kitten Gamer OK, then. I'm just wondering why she ever would be turned into an alicorn if she isn't royalty.

The Kitten Gamer OK, then. I'm just wondering why she ever would be turned into an alicorn if she isn't royalty.

No wait I mean if celestia turned all of them into alicorns she would have to give everyone extra magic to really have alicorn magic, but if she made pinkie into one she woundn’t need extra magic

No wait I mean if celestia turned all of them into alicorns she would have to give everyone extra magic to really have alicorn magic, but if she made pinkie into one she woundn’t need extra magic

The Kitten Gamer So what you're telling me is she has enough magic to change her own DNA to put herself into a royal bloodline.

The Kitten Gamer So what you're telling me is she has enough magic to change her own DNA to put herself into a royal bloodline.

I mean she has enough magic to become one.

I mean she has enough magic to become one.

The Kitten Gamer Isn't alicorn status only given to royals, though?

The Kitten Gamer Isn't alicorn status only given to royals, though?

If they all became alicorns except pinkie they would want to know why and then pinkie would have to tell her friends the truth witch is exatly what pinkie knew she was not ready. The reason why twilight became an alicorn is because she is ready, physically and mentally. Pinkie is physically ready but not mentally.

What my head cannon from before is why only twilight became an alicorn. If pinkie had something to manipulate with her magic then the things logic defying things she dose won’t be possible. She would also become more like her family (no offense to maud she is awesome) The worst part is she woundn’t have the confidence to use the element of laughter and fulfill her destiny. Also she would still be connected with the tree of harmony she won’t need that magic to fly or use a horn.

The Kitten Gamer I like yours better as well.

The Kitten Gamer I like yours better as well.

The Kitten Gamer That sounds very interesting, but that would likely mean there'd need to be a "real" Pinkie for the changeling Pinkie to base his/her disguise on.

The Kitten Gamer That sounds very interesting, but that would likely mean there'd need to be a "real" Pinkie for the changeling Pinkie to base his/her disguise on.

https://youtu.be/-Sym1h72K2c this is interesting, I don’t belive it for a second but tell me what you think

https://youtu.be/-Sym1h72K2c this is interesting, I don’t belive it for a second but tell me what you think

The Kitten Gamer This doesn't explain everything I'd like to know, but here's his theory on her psychic abilities: https://youtu.be/JUavdDD0_oA

The Kitten Gamer This doesn't explain everything I'd like to know, but here's his theory on her psychic abilities: https://youtu.be/JUavdDD0_oA

The Kitten Gamer I'm sorry about that remark, then. The others were from me.

The Kitten Gamer I'm sorry about that remark, then. The others were from me.

But I think we did get a few likes from others in there.

But I think we did get a few likes from others in there.

I did it because the more likes means more people will see it and if many people see it and like it the brony notion might see it and make a video on it.

I did it because the more likes means more people will see it and if many people see it and like it the brony notion might see it and make a video on it.

But I think she only had those balloons to make sure rainbow didn’t suspect anything, I still think that and I think she could have still walked on the clouds without the balloons because of what I think happened to her as a filly

But I think she only had those balloons to make sure rainbow didn’t suspect anything, I still think that and I think she could have still walked on the clouds without the balloons because of what I think happened to her as a filly

Also, I get that this is a public forum, but isn't it weird that almost all of our responses have at least one like? Is it possible that these are all from the same person? If so, the "like" button seems to have lost its value here (no offense). If not, we must be really coming up with some great theories!

The Kitten Gamer I guess that explains why Pinkie had so many balloons attached to her in "Secrets and Pies".

The Kitten Gamer I guess that explains why Pinkie had so many balloons attached to her in "Secrets and Pies".

Only Pegasi can walk on clouds though, and yes in the school raze part 1 and sonic rainboom.rafity falls through the clouds after her wings melt away

Only Pegasi can walk on clouds though, and yes in the school raze part 1 and sonic rainboom.rafity falls through the clouds after her wings melt away

The Kitten Gamer Your theory still seems interesting to me, but have we ever seen a pony fall from a cloud because of a lack of the proper abilities?

The Kitten Gamer Your theory still seems interesting to me, but have we ever seen a pony fall from a cloud because of a lack of the proper abilities?

when the tree sensed pinkie didn’t feel normal, being connected to her it tried to help her, but that “help” gave her the bright idea to try to become friends with objects the tree probably could have just taken over her body and brain (maybe) to fix it but if the tree did do that it would use to much of its magic and cause the events in princess twilight sparkle to happen sooner. This would also, give her long term effects and also mess her up after it left her, and being the tree of harmony it knew all of this, and yes we know for sure that the tree of harmony has a mind of its own watch season 8 episode 16 I think I will check later.

I also think the elements contain stronger than alicorn magic. Could six alicorns defeat discord or nightmare moon or any villain who they used the elements of harmony on. No so the elements must be stonger than alicorns. Also I have evidence that pinkie could have some of the elements of laughters magic. When pinkie didn’t feel like she had friends (party of one) she was really messed up. Without the other elements the element of laughter proves useless and with pinkie feeling alone the magic could drain from her, changing how she acts, of corse she will always love parties and that kind of thing, but without the elements of laughter’s magic she won’t be the same. Also

No because if twilight got the elements of Magic’s magic then her abilities will be a lot better, and think about it. Without all her energy and crazy stuff whitch always makes me laugh would you or other ponies laugh at her as hard? I have some evidence that she has Pegasus magic. In secrets and lies she was walking on clouds, sure twilight just used her spell. NO pinkie pie had balloons attached to her but she could still walk on the clouds. The balloons where just there so rainbow doesn’t question how she is walking on clouds. If rainbow asks twilight about the whole situation twilight would have no idea and then rainbow could possibly figure out what happened to her on the rock farm.

The Kitten Gamer That's also an interesting thought, but would the other elements have similar powers?

The Kitten Gamer That's also an interesting thought, but would the other elements have similar powers?

I thought of more when it zapped pinkie it gave her magic only the element of laughter itself should have part of this magic connects it to the tree of harmony whitch means pinkie herself is connected to the tree of harmony with whitch is by pinkie sense may work because the tree can sense the future I think

The Kitten Gamer You're welcome. Another thought I had is that as the most successful physicist in Equestria, she spends a lot of time researching higher (4 or more) dimensional solid figures, which could explain how she knew Discord was hidden in a box. (Her advanced knowledge of physics would also likely explain a lot more...)

Wait lol the event of laughter I can’t spell

Wait lol the event of laughter I can’t spell

I thought of it! Thanks for the complement!

I thought of it! Thanks for the complement!

I thought of it, but thanks for the complement!

I thought of it, but thanks for the complement!

The Kitten Gamer That sounds like something they'd write! Where did you get it?

The Kitten Gamer That sounds like something they'd write! Where did you get it?

I have an idea of what could have happened. She was in the fields of the rock farm and found a little pink rock she took to it her room to look at later. When she was in her room later that night She picked it back up and showed her parents. Her parents took it from her, knowing it was a magical gem and they knew a little filly should not have such magic, but when her parents took it away she got zapped. A zap of magic, because that Little Rock was connected to the element of laughter, and was on the rock farm because of destiny trying to find the future bearer of its magical properties. It zapped her because the  gem knew it was this pink filly that would become the future bearer of the event of laughter and when it zapped her it gave her magic, too much of it. If she gained that magic slowly it woundn’t effect her as much but she got the magic from an element of harmony in just a few seconds this was too much magic for her to take in within just a few seconds. Yet she couldn’t use this magic and she felt fine soon afterward. The next day  she was working on the fields wondering about what happened until she saw the sonic rainboom looking at it gave her the ability to unlock this magic, and figure out the meaning of life (ok not really) but it did unlock the magic she gained the night before, the tree of harmony gave her the idea to plan a party starting the journey of her getting her cutie mark and become the element of laughter’s future bearer.

The Kitten Gamer So she could've been born an alicorn and turned into an Earth pony because she was adopted by a family of Earth ponies?

The Kitten Gamer So she could've been born an alicorn and turned into an Earth pony because she was adopted by a family of Earth ponies?

The Kitten Gamer No offense to you, but I think I have been told that Earth ponies have naturally superior physical strength, so her speed may be simply explained by the fact that she's the pony equivalent of a world-class track star. I don't know whether this is true, though.

That explanation could make sense, but I'm not sure how that could be possible.

I belive pinkie for whatever reason has the magic of an alicorn except trapped in the body of an earth pony and even without a horn or wings this excessive magic affects her in different ways, gives her too much energy, makes her run crazy fast, gives her an amazing memory, and all that stuff that only the one and only pinkie can do, oh and also pinkie sense. Ether that or she is from a different dimention or other headcannos that u can think of

The Kitten Gamer That may be a pretty good explanation as well, but we'd still then be missing out on how she does it for practical effect and when others are watching (e.g. chasing Rainbow Dash by appearing out of nowhere, slowing her fall to not make as much noise, and disappearing into Applejacks's apple bucket).

Your theory dose make sense, but I have to disagree only pinkie and twilight know about us watching them, I have proof, watch the end of boast busters as the screen is becoming black pinkie opens it and climbs in then twilight teleports in and gives pinkie her mouth back, and in the one where pinkie pie knows at the end she shakes her head at the audience and maybe  she fell apart to entertain the audience. I think we might be on to something!

The Kitten Gamer OK, but I'm not sure how to explain it if she did it without her own knowledge. If that's the case, we may have bigger problems.

To your point, though, it seems as though it's impossible for it to merely be stage magic because it would ruin the plot. I actually did have a thought, though: what if, in the style of Monty Python and Deadpool, the so-called "fourth wall" does not exist (i.e. the characters know we are watching)? That could possibly explain how she could pull off such magic tricks: they are entirely for our amusement and have no practical purpose in their universe, but I'm not sure about this.

She just fell apart no one was even paying attention to her they where paying attention to cadence and Shining armour because they just said they where having a baby

She just fell apart no one was even paying attention to her they where paying attention to cadence and Shining armour because they just said they where having a baby

The Kitten Gamer  Perhaps either she always wanted to learn the organ and that was the only place she knew that had one or she did whatever it was she did to predict where Rainbow Dash would be.

No offense, but would there be any particular reason as to why she would fall apart without wanting to show off her ability to perform parlor tricks or something like that?

Also  the thing with pinkie pie falling apart and putting herself back together she really did fall apart because she didn’t just do it to show everypony it just happened

Also  the thing with pinkie pie falling apart and putting herself back together she really did fall apart because she didn’t just do it to show everypony it just happened

That makes sense, but why was she in the castle at that time, playing the organ at that time framing everypony out

That makes sense, but why was she in the castle at that time, playing the organ at that time framing everypony out

There isn’t I don’t think, but I won’t be responding to anything else you say till tommorow I’m with my family so yea cya

There isn’t I don’t think, but I won’t be responding to anything else you say till tommorow I’m with my family so yea cya

The Kitten Gamer As a student of the piano, it was rather easy for me to learn how to play the organ, so that isn't surprising at all because she already knows how to play the accordion, so all she really needs to learn is how to use the pedals and the drawbars. She may not have known it was so easy to learn because there aren't many full-fledged organs to go around there, but that's just my opinion.

The other theory may sound pretty interesting, but I believe something like it actually happened in the "Equestria Girls" movie with Twilight.

No offense, but my question is whether you know the canonical explanation is if there even is one yet.

I just thought of something different, remember that pinkie pie in castle-mania well what if that is a clone pinkie, pinkie has a great memory but that pinkie playing the organ didn’t know she could play the organ. The real pinkie can play every instrument ever  and she has a great memory so she should know if she could play the organ, but this pinkie didn’t know she could,

I just thought of an idea!!! What if pinkie was going to tell ponyville the truth but then twilight cane so she decided to put it off to throw a party, but then she discovered she had to be the bearer of the element of laughter and she thought telling everybody the truth would make them not want to be her friend, making it so the Elements of harmony wound’t work because you need harmony to use the elements of harmony you need, well harmony

The Kitten Gamer OK, then. I'm just glad that the boundary between reality and fiction is impossible to breach, otherwise we should expect far worse to happen than a pink pony sorceress fooling Penn and Teller more than Shawn Farquhar did. (Funnily enough, though, there is a video that may have been made by some of the VA's from the show about Pinkie breaking out of a computer screen.)

By the way, does it seem as though there is a canonical explanation as to her mysterious abilities?

The Kitten Gamer One of my ideas actually was that she is a diplomatic ambassador from a universe where different laws of physics apply and, as such, has been granted diplomatic immunity from MLP's laws of physics.

The theory that I've come up with and find most plausible, however, is that all of this is simply just a set of magic tricks/illusions. (This would mean that the multiple slices of her are simply from a variant on the "saw someone in half" trick, for example.) If not that, however, my next go-to explanation is that she has an extensive knowledge of physics that even surpasses Twilight's.

I have not watched enough of the series to know where she got her powers for sure, but it's sometimes cool to think about. Speaking of which, I also like to think about whether or not she could fool Penn and Teller on "Fool Us" if she somehow came to this world. They, too, have tested the laws of physics, but have been baffled before by equally as sorcerous feats. Do you think she could fool them? I'm personally uncertain.

What if, she is from the same dimention as discord dun dun duuuuuun

What if, she is from the same dimention as discord dun dun duuuuuun

She is secretly from spongebob!!!! Dun dun duuuuun. Ok ok idk it’s very confusing because it’s like she knows she is on a TV show, and she can just fall apart and then put herself back together (you saw that episode right) It’s like pinkie pie is just not from MLP wait! That gives me an idea, what if she isn’t well she obisly is but what if she is from a different dimension, and she came to equestria using, magical thingy stuff, and in that world most ponies, people or whatever lives there (who knows mabye she changed her appearance to fit in) has that confusing logic. Dunno just a theory, but if she is from another dimention then maybe she went there to send a distress signal but soon realized she woundn’t be able to tell her “parents” and “sisters” the truth so she decided to stay in this land of equstria because of everything she has done there and knew how everyone would feel if she left

The Kitten Gamer Possibly. I'm still somewhat skeptical about the "Pinkie sense."

What I'm really asking about is how she is seemingly bound by completely separate laws of physics ("cartoon physics") than those that apply to the rest of the characters.

What do you mean, like pinkie sense and all that?

What do you mean, like pinkie sense and all that?

The Kitten Gamer OK, then. I just saw your comment that says you like Pinkie Pie, so I have a few questions about her, but I'm not sure whether I should ask them all here.

One of my biggest questions about her, though, is how does she perform her cartoonish stunts? Is she some sort of a magician who knows a lot about magic tricks or is she simply a really successful physicist?

The entire series, 1 the first time I forgot the episode name 2. Slice of life 3. The gift of maud pie, if you pause it at the exact right time when rarity is throwing a whole bunch of stuff you see twilights staff witch is pretty funny why would they be selling that

The Kitten Gamer 3 times in this video or 3 times in the entire series?

The Kitten Gamer 3 times in this video or 3 times in the entire series?

Hey! Did you know twilights staff appears 3 times? Cause I didn’t! (SORRY I just like pinkie pie)

Hey! Did you know twilights staff appears 3 times? Cause I didn’t! (SORRY I just like pinkie pie)

Hmm you have a good point, mabye, uh I dunno, just realized first we where talking about pony lifespans now we are talking about the crystal empire talk about changing the subject

Hmm you have a good point, mabye, uh I dunno, just realized first we where talking about pony lifespans now we are talking about the crystal empire talk about changing the subject

I belive she is a princess and a royal governor Man just over a month ago I never knew I could have a long conversation about MLp thank you brony Notion I love mlp again

I belive she is a princess and a royal governor Man just over a month ago I never knew I could have a long conversation about MLp thank you brony Notion I love mlp again

The Kitten Gamer The Kitten Gamer So that means she is, in essence, more of a royal governor than a princess. No offense, but why is it called the "Crystal Empire" and not the "Crystal Crown Dependency"?

The Kitten Gamer The Kitten Gamer So that means she is, in essence, more of a royal governor than a princess. No offense, but why is it called the "Crystal Empire" and not the "Crystal Crown Dependency"?

Because since the crystal empire is so far north it needs its own alicorn to keep away the cold and rule, if there is some sort of problem celestia can’t just be like oh oof gotta go, unless it was really important of corse, but with an alicorn of its own you don’t need someone traveling across the whole contry or whatever to solve a small problem boom

The Kitten Gamer In that case, why does the Crystal Empire have its own monarchy?

The Kitten Gamer In that case, why does the Crystal Empire have its own monarchy?

So they are still ponies, and the crystal empire  is part of  equestria even though it is far away from most other places in equestria, think of it like this Alaska didn’t seem like it should be part of America considering how far away it is from the rest of America but it is still part of America you could say the same thing With Hawaii

The Kitten Gamer OK, but don't the crystal ponies live in the Crystal Empire, not Equestria?

The Kitten Gamer OK, but don't the crystal ponies live in the Crystal Empire, not Equestria?

The crystal ponies! They have been alive for over a thousand years! Also that is funny that you bring pinkie clones up because I just finished watching a video about how a pinkie clone (yes one didn’t die, watch the episode where rarity opens up a new shop in manehatten) is Tirek, at first it made no sense but in the end a made a little bit of sense, but thinking about it again it makes no sense

The Kitten Gamer I haven't seen enough of the series to know for sure whether any pony dies of natural causes.

The Kitten Gamer I haven't seen enough of the series to know for sure whether any pony dies of natural causes.

Have you ever seen a pony die in equestria except sombra of corse, but he didn’t die for natural reasons

Have you ever seen a pony die in equestria except sombra of corse, but he didn’t die for natural reasons

The Kitten Gamer OK, then, but what in Equestria makes it possible to literally be as old as Methuselah?

The Kitten Gamer OK, then, but what in Equestria makes it possible to literally be as old as Methuselah?

Both actually because I was going to write more than I was like nahh

Both actually because I was going to write more than I was like nahh

The Kitten Gamer No offense, but was that supposed to be a comma or a period?

The Kitten Gamer No offense, but was that supposed to be a comma or a period?


He put this up at 2013. He didn't see this episode yet.!..!


I think that Luna didn't banish celestia because she didn't have the elements of harmony so where did Luna banish celestia


Was Princess Celestia Banish to the sun? Cause even tho she knew that Nightmare moon is coming bk she never appear xd


I think that. Celestial and Luna are princesses and their parents were the king and queen .like even though queens are usually bad. Not all queens are. Look at raven queen from everafterhigh she was suppose to be the new queen but she Chose to be a good queen.Notice?


She was wearing her 2 million sunblock.  Just kidding -- it's a good theory.


That was an ok ? you should do who is apple jacks mom and dad?!


Yeah, she would be burnt in less than a sec.....


so I didn't got banished from Luna because you didn't miss her sister much of that


Celestia wouldn't be in the sun cos Luna didn't the want sun so......


no it was a flourish for her arrival simply, and nothing more.


Wow, not explaining the theory at all. At least he does in his "newer" vids cuz he's dead


If she was banished to the sun she would have died because the sun is so hot.


She is such a troll she banishises her sister to the moon then makes her apologize. Why didn't she just break the spell in the first place?


i think Celestia Princess Celestia is like tangled the little piece of the Sun


Then uh who raised the sun for a thousand years???

i think what happened was that as soon as nightmare moon was released, she faced her sister and banished her - i don’t think they mean she was banished for a thousand years.


This sooo has to be true because if not were in Equestria was princess Celestia!Oh right, the sun!this is soo true I knew it when I saw the episode.


in the sun for a thousand years? nopony noticing? I think not.

@The Godly Brony oooh ok thanks for pointin' that out :P guess add kicked in again lol xP

Since you didn't watch the video clearly he said for all of part two so basically when nightmare moon escaped she sent Celestia to the sun but once the mane six defeated Nightmare Moon the spell was broken.


Possible, in this future little brony.. In this future


Celestia is banished in the sun look at the last episode of season 5 The Cutie Re-Mark when twilight came at the two sisters' old castle Nightmare Moon said Celestia was banished in the moon

This was uploaded in 2013. Season 5 hadn't been released then.


that quick what the heck you must atleast have a theory because you can not just say that you thought she was banished


I can't believe this was posted on my birthday


DO PONYS EVEN DIE OF OLD AGE!!!!!!!!!!!!


What's up with all of Luna's mane does???


@The Brony Notion 0:00 You'r a changeling??????!!!!!!


SHE IS A PRINCESS

She could use a spell to sheild herself from the sun's intense heat, because she has alicorn magin and not a typical unicorn with regular magic.


What happened to flash sentry after the last episode


Hey b.n can you do q&a's pls for a change


I think u are right!!!!but celestia was there when she vanished Luna so how!!???????????? I am confused???????????Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh


About Princess Luna here's the th like somthing magic evil in like it was like a poison but just kept expanding like like something a bad guy


0:00 you r a changeling? I didn't know that,..


If Celestia was banished to the sun, she would be burned to death already


in our world the  Ifyou were walking on the sun you will die <br>is it the same for the MLP

in our world the  Ifyou were walking on the sun you will die
is it the same for the MLP


What if daybreaker was the one vanished to the sun?


no no no no you dont understand do you even get it the thing is that when the princess was gone (I mean the princess of the sun) that was because that she was where twilight got to become a princess thats also to try to time traval to stop luna from becoming evail. Oh and the hair is because the princess (again I mean the princess of the sun) was holding the elements and if the elements where broken then her hair would become pink DAAAAA he he he :)


well, since the Moon is quite safer than the Sun, why isn't Celestia died? I know she's an immortal alicorn and bla bla bla... but... oh dear...

@Jana Lybarger<br>trust me, better your brain exploded in no atmosphere and tumors because of the UV rays exposition than your brain exploded in no atmosphere, tumors because of the UV rays exposition, being crushed by the gravity, evaporated (or more likely "ionized") by the temperature and many other bad things... but, you know, MAGIC!

@Jana Lybarger
trust me, better your brain exploded in no atmosphere and tumors because of the UV rays exposition than your brain exploded in no atmosphere, tumors because of the UV rays exposition, being crushed by the gravity, evaporated (or more likely "ionized") by the temperature and many other bad things... but, you know, MAGIC!

Without even going into the fact the moon has no atmosphere, Luna being sealed in the moon would've put her at risk for any number of illnesses linked to asbestos, which moon dust is a great deal like, and yet she survived a thousand years no worse for wear health-wise. So why is it unusual for a pony to possibly been magically sealed away within a star without burning to a crisp?


you mean put Solar Flare that means is Celestia in to the sun because she is princess of the sun


what about twligth hair relating to her cutie mark


Hey what is up with Luna's hair why is it light blue but in other episodes twilight goes to a flashback before nightmare moon came to be and she had her hair like normal, all flowy, sparkly, and however else her hair normally is idk what's going on did becoming nightmare moon change her hair for a bit?


To the next video put why do princesses wear shoes


Wow I thoughtSunset shimmer was the sun but so last year is the sun what the heck


i thinki get it, nightmare moon wanted  have equestria to herself, and banish celestia into the sun, but while celestia was banishing nightmare moon, nightmare moon must have put a spell that when she returns celestia will be banished into the sun. Then nightmare moons evil spell broke and she transformed back into luna, celestia returned from the sun. Nightmare moon wanted to have equestria on the 1000th year when she returned.


No cause in cutie 're Mark nightmare moon says her SISTER is banished to the moon


Celestia was banished to the sun? Thats hot

@INDIGO BLUEoO ponies never die on the show that's why they did not let Celestia die when she got hit by nightmare moon witch was still kinda funny LOL XD darkness in a kids show ha LOL XD


Emmm brony notion please say Bro hoof slowly not like "this is the brony notion sining out Bro hoof! More like this is the brony notion sining out... Bro hoof!


You are almost right.She for banished but in the moon just like nightmare moon.Season 5 finale!

Δήμητρα Αβραάμ

+Δήμητρα Αβραάμ except that this is an old video. So the information is just outdated.

Δήμητρα Αβραάμ


thats why the ponies ask nightmare moon where is princess celestia


why did you even make this a video? its not even 1 min long!


Wow. This vid is so bad compared to the ones ur making now XD


Season 5 is out now?!?!?!?!?<br>Why did no pony tell me?!?!?

Season 5 is out now?!?!?!?!?
Why did no pony tell me?!?!?

yeah it isn`t out yet.it comes out at on april 4th at 11am/10 central.


Eh. . . the sun is very hot. . . so celestia is dead. . .


So rainbow tornadoes can defeat evil villans

sonia deguzman Check out Bill Wurtz's "History of Japan".


I Have Something To Say!! Well Its Just Pinkie Soo Yeh She Pinkie Ok And Pinkie Is Mad


well i have the most stupidest theory..........if celestia banished to the sun who puts her there she put luna to the moon so if celestia banished to the sun nightmare moon did it and its stupid and for me luna escaped in the moon in nightmare night (facepalm) wait no but still i need somepony to reply to me and help me to this


Sorry if i say it wrong im from spanish :(

I dont think it
I think when Celestia Banished Luna,she dont feel cold
so Celestia it dont feel the hot. O.O That is weird


@Trinity Southway  It was so close into being a 1 minute video :P


yea celestia was on the moon becuz on the sun she woyld be dead


this is your day off does episode 4 where is the last year when one discovered to nightmare moon when she was a sister 3 that dude with the big who's that drains Pony energy Susie where is she all this disaster happen


Dislike just because it only took like a minute


Celestia would have melted to death if she was banished to the sun.

@Bright New Future Unless Luna was teleported beneath the moon’s surface where there could be oxygen, by there’s nowhere Celestia could survive on the sun.

i don’t think they get banished “on” the moon, i think they just become “merged” with it, for a lack of a better term. the same could be said about luna - if celestia would burn from being banished to the sun, luna would easily die on the moon from lack of oxygen. so i think it’s more that their essence gets trapped inside the moon and not their physical bodies


i need to do therioy vedios ... (im smart so dont judge me by mu voice

@Katelyn Thomas AGH ... u know what I mean


OMG I DIDNT SEE WHEN THIS VIDEO WAS PUBLISHED AND YOU VOICE AND INTRO IS SO WEIRDDDDD


DUH! Didn't u see that vid after the winter wrap up notion remix?


YES I AM THE FIRST ONE TO COMMENT IN 2021 IT THINK-


No dont subscribe he hasent uploded a vidio in like forever and its 2016 now

So? Subscribing lets you know when he DOES upload.

+Barba Johannesen and your point is? If you click his name to go to his page and view his videos, his most recent uploads were 3 videos each 3 months ago. Ya, they were in 2015, but that doesn't mean they were uploaded a year ago.

+Barba Johannesen forever = 2 months... apparently


The sun mother is Celestia Celestia was PREGNANT lol


Banished to the sun? That would be painful.