The Other Sunset Shimmer 🌅

The craziest theory is that Sunset killed her human counterpart and took her place. And as dark as this theory is, the scariest part is that is actually solves a lot of plot holes as to why we've never seen her human version and where Sunset was sleeping all these years.

There's something else I question about Sunset Shimmer. How did she gain a human identity, and who adopted her so she could live in the human world?

I have a headcanon that human Sunset found a natural portal when she was younger, and has been living in Equestria ever since. The "she's too far away" and "she hasn't made a big splash" arguments apply here, plus the fact that they'd be looking in the wrong place if they ever did try to locate her.

Personally, my own headcannon is more a 'When was Human Sunset?' question. We know Sunset was Princess Celestia's student before Twilight, but I don't think in the animated series we received a clear idea of how long before Twilight. Human Sunset might have been contemporaries with Shining Armor/Cadence, and has graduated from Crystal Prep. Or she may be even older. Principal Celestia vs. Princess Celestia tells us that time runs weird between the two realities, because one is thousands of years old, while the other is likely in her mid-to-late 40's (in my experience full Principals don't get that job until they're at least 40, but I could be wrong there). So Human Sunset might have been a student when Human Celestia was starting as a teacher, anywhere from fifteen to twenty-five years ago.

There was actually a scrapped equestria girls special where they finally found out why magic has been following them around everywhere, where it’s coming from, and who the human sunset was. And in the end, Sunset had to make a huge important decision, (likely going back to equestria)

I still like the funny Answer, that human Sunset is an adult who lives with her teen/pony self.
Because the Adult is secretly part of an MIB style organization focused on tracking and detecting magical problems.

Honestly, EG seems like so much wasted potential. I'd love if they ever did a more grown up version of EG where we explore Sunsets character more and her life before she became miss popular at the highschool.

There's an article on google that says one of the producer already made an hour long special to be the finale. It is about sunset's human counterpart and what really happened to her. This special was suppose to end the season and begin the season 3 but Hasbro has another thoughts. So they just go with the Holiday unwrapped shorts leaving the whole special storyboard behind. I loved the Holidays unwrapped but i think the special would've ended the series better like how mlp:fim ended so well. They also said that they were suppose to make the season 3 of eg but decided to just drop it after thinking that mlp already ended and itll be better if they end the spinoff to. But hey what do we know, maybe eg will comeback because there are rumors that if pony life will end, they'll continue the season 3 of eg because hasbro has no plans of stopping the my little pony era

I came back to this channel after a few years bc I fell back into the mlp fandom, and it's nice to see that a couple people (including Sawtooth and Nowacking) have grown into themselves. It's cool, and always great to see trans and nb people living their best lives.

The fact that brohoof is still at the end gives me happy tingles 😂
I used to watch this channel back in middle school when it first started out and it's been super fun seeing how far the channel and Sawtooth have come :)

I like your theory about her being the connection between these worlds! Her cutie mark looks like a ying yang, and cutie marks always reflect who a pony is and what their role in the world is. She’s probably a connection between there and she was always meant to go to the human world, keeping the magic in balance and the reason why magic follows the mane 6 there. It’s a good theory!

I assumed that just as pony Sunset traveled through the mirror to get to the human world, the human Sunset found a portal to the pony world.

I always wondered about that. Maybe human sunset was in a different city in another school. Human twilight was in Crystal prep, rival of Caterlot high school. So it makes sense Sunset might have been in a completly different school.

Im finally glad someone else brought this up. Its been plaguing my mind since the dawn of esquestria girls.

I always figured human Sunset would be her living as a delinquent, with her "banishment" in this world being Juvie.

What if Human Sunset was driven to Equestria in the pursuit of Magic. Kinda like string theory I guess. Human Sunset could also be in another dimension similar to the Equestria we know.

This is a personal theory of mine, and based on what I already know it could be a big IF. But I was thinking once that it could be possible based on Newton’s law of conservation of energy and mass (bare in mind I have not actually researched this myself, what little I know comes from Peabody and Sherman.) I was wondering if perhaps after the Equestrian Sunset came to Earth and met the Earth Sunset, because the Equestrian Sunset is essentially trapped on earth now. Eventually one was either going to simply fade away (insert Thanos snap reference here.) or one would absorb the other and the dominant Sunset would become the only Sunset. Yes my mind can be a hell of a dark place sometimes. Honesty I scare myself now and again!

Maybe human Sunset was a grew up woman. I've heard the theory that Sunset maybe an earlier 30 because she entered the human portal when Twilight was still young so that made possibility that Sunset's age doesn't grew up so much in human world so we can see her as a teen

I don’t really think that Sunset has to have a counterpart, not just for the reason you gave in the beginning, but also because these worlds aren’t a perfect reflection of each other, there are tons of inconsistencies, such as pony Twilight liking flash, and Human Twilight liking Timber Spruce, so maybe Sunset never existed in the human world?

I'm so happy to see this channel still active even after all these years of being out of the fandom! The more things change, the more things stay the same, huh?
(I really like the idea that sunset wasn't a scholar, but I think she might have gone into sports instead- where you can prove beyond doubt that at your best, you ARE the best. Music is pretty semantic, and I'm not sure a base sunset would have much interest in it beyond a "ha look at this cool skill I have now bow before me" hobby.)

My theory is that Sunset (before she became good), told other Sunset to not get in her way. This would give her room to fit into the human world. Maybe the Sunset before was a bully, so Sunset had to take her place as a bully.

I just always believed the human Sunset was in another city not visited in the eqg universe. I haven't put too much thought into it, but I have had an idea running through my head for another story to write where she shows up and has several confusing run ins with the rest of the group.

I have a story in my head exploring Cozy Glow and Flurry Heart and how Human Cozy banishes human Flurry to the pony world.

human Sunset however could have moved, she could have died from reasons unrelated to Sunset's actions

She could have gone to the pony world but maybe Sunset's double was a different age or gender or color so they don't look the same.

I love how the whereabouts of human Sunset Shimmer has been the one topic people have been theorizing about since EQG first started, the possibilities are literally endless!!!

doesn’t starlight glimmer not have a human counterpart either?

ive always thought that the sunset we have now is the human sunset who simply discovered the portal and adapted to the pony world quickly. maybe I missed something but do we see that much backstory for sunset other than "she was a student of Celestia"?

I’ve been wondering if there was another human Sunset or not!
I can’t believe Sunset’s story is now a cliffhanger! And there was supposed to be a Sunset Shimmer special that covers the other Sunset.

Interesting theory, very cool. You litteraly should work with creators of the show and make the plot, because your point of view is so much better than a regular show bro /)

Honestly if Hasbro didn’t cancel Season 3 and the Finale for Equestria Girls, we might’ve gotten an answer about this idea. Or at least, I hope

I imagine the human Sunset might be in juvenile prison or be a homeless runaway because the pony one broke the laws and used the portal to escape. What to say her human counterpart might not be a small-time offended at the least.

I never got around to catching up on everything EG so there being a human Starswirl is new to me. But I always figured that there being another sunset out there made sense. Although the rise of the Rainboom's music career would eventually bring her out and the 2 would be forced to confront each other. The same for Starlight, she's out there, just out there out of reach. Also whether the human starlight would be reformed or not is a whole other issue. The Human starlight though might be already good since the primary reason our starlight was the bad person was because of her confrontation with Celestia, not for other reasons.

I actually have my own personal theory. Seeing what we know now, the main cast of characters that resemble the main six act exactly like how the originals do, except they act like how they did before Twilight moved to Ponyville. So in Equestria Girls universe it looks like the character development is actually lagging behind, as Twilight is still friendless in this universe and is not in the same school as the other mane six. This leads me to believe that this universes Sunset Shimmer did in fact exist, but she too ran away from home. Unlike our Sunset Shimmer, however, this worlds Sunset was actually a top student that excelled and was even put in college level programs. Because of the high pressure that she felt from her studies, her parents, and even trying to meet Principal Celestia’s expectations, it eventually led to Sunset breaking down and deciding to run away instead. Maybe keeping in line with the main Sunset’s story, maybe the original equestrian girls sunset had done some illegal drugs to keep up with the demands and lower her stress, but she became addicted to it. This would also add embarrassment and anxiety to how this worlds sunset felt. So when our Sunset entered this world, she would be on her own for a while, until the events unfolded for the EG sunset took place. When this worlds Sunset ran away, her parents went out looking for her, only to find our sunset in her place, and after having dealt with poverty and not knowing this world, our sunset hopped on the opportunity to fit in and took this worlds sunsets place.

This theory leads into 2 or 3 possible outcomes:

1. That this worlds sunset is now struggling in this world trying to prove herself in a new location, maybe nearby or far away (much like how our sunset did)

2. This worlds Sunset dies while being out on her own, and no one would be none the wiser for it.

3. This worlds sunset was taken in somewhere and is now getting the help she needs, only waiting for a chance to come back into the canon show.

The talk about ambition and seeing Sunset's alicorn ruler reflection in the comic made me wonder if Human Sunset is at a different private school than Canterlot High or Crystal Prep, and she's getting involved in politics somehow, like volunteering with local community groups and/or preferred political party, as age-appropriate steps to gaining political power.

My dad theorized that the other student of the principal from Crystal High was the Sunset Shimmer of the human world (because she mentioned having only 1 or 2 other strongly intelligent students that had left) which to me has been something I've stuck with

Не смотря на то, что идея про судьбу Санцет мне больше симпатизирует, не могу не отметить, что теория с убийством логичнее. Думаю она убила свою альтернативную версию, а так как у Санцет никого не было, то и замены никто не заметил

Or science, you made a good point about Twilight and the stars for leading back on the other talents but I always wanted as replacing magic with science for them meaning human sunset would also excel at science

the first theory is actually the most plausible,not just cause, it's in keeping with the show's tone,but we're given pretty clear indicators that while she IS willing to use intimidation and fake evidence as well as "lol look at the new girl being dumb" screen shots,none of this puts her above the "mean bitch" level,and even at her worst she isn't willing to actually hurt puppy Spike.catch yes,vaguely threaten yes actually harm NO
Honestly I don't think she even had that stupid "teen zombie army" plan before transforming
sooo yeah if she isn't mean enough to hurt a puppy...let alone one she knows is helping her competition I think it's safe to say we can relegate Murder yo the realm of Fimfics.
here's a more grounded idea...Her counterpart is older than she is when she steps through the mirror and that;s why they never meet. she's already past highschool and given she would be a genius ;ole the pony version she's probably literally a rocket scientist or some kind of scientist at the vary least,,,but that's kist my idea for if she had a counterpart in the first place since she is afew years older than Twilight Cannonically.

I think these so much potential for fanfictions of this entire thing. If anyone can find a fimfic with each chapter being a different way Sunset meets her human counterpart, is love to give it a read!

I heard that there was a scrapped Equestria Girls finale after Sunset’s Backstage Pass that had the Human Sunset. The premise was that her life was ruined because Pony Sunset had taken her identity. However, we never got to see it and Equestria Girls ended with a bad finale in Holidays Unwrapped.

From what I could tell, Sunset shimmer probably won't meet her human counter part until she fully learns the power of friendship, unlocking her full potential. She'll meet her human counter part as a recall to who she once was and instead of resorting to anything extreme, I can see Sunset showing compassion for her human counter part inspiring the counter part to want to make the change and to learn from Sunset's greatest teacher, Twilight sparkle in the pony world and remaining there to discover her full potential in the magic that is friendship. Aaaaaand, scene.

Sawtooth's voice would be perfect for an audible book. Their voice is so calming to me...

I have a personal theory, I don't know if it helps to solve this but here it goes, both in the second movie and in the legend of everfree we see how there are 7 elements, in the case of rainbow rocks we see how the red from sunset complements the rainbow, so I have my theory that each world requires its 7 element, represented in the human world with sunset and in the pony with Starlight

I really want EG to come back. We can't just have a cliffhanger, WE NEED AN EXPLANATION!!!

now saw will admit you brought up good points but there is one theory so far no one has touched on paradox say if she came in contact with the human sunset but once they come into physical contact one would absorb the others but the dominate personality is what shows like twilight the hunman twi was shy quiet very timid while pony twi was more outgoing

I really like the idea about her fate being between the worlds, but I also I am keen on the idea that may be what a loud Sunset to use the mirror in the first place was the accidental passing of her reflection counterpart. Once she had used the mirror enabled by this passing of her counterpart, it would’ve been possible for Twilight. This theory basically puts sunset as a type of living key to the door between worlds, but you can’t try to open the lock from both sides at the same time. Which is why I suspect the other one had to pass away first. Maybe as things hit a crescendo and Sunsets life as celestia’s as student, there were some kind of other drastic event happening in the other world. An event the deprived that world of its Sunset. Allowing her to deprive her own world of a Sunset in turn.

I actually do agree with your theory on sunset not having a human counterpart since it makes more sense than her randomly leaving

“Any technology sufficiently advanced is indistinguishable from magic.” -Arthur C. Clarke.
I think that humanity’s magic is our ability to make creative solutions to seemingly insurmountable problems. So perhaps, Sunset is basically a supervillain.

These therories about Sunset are really mysterious, but I've also got a question.
"Where is the human Starlight?"
Would she also control the people like the pony Starlight, and how would she be able to do so? Think about, if there might be another Sunse who we don't know of. Shouldn't there also be a human Starlight who is just how her pony part was? Controling over the humans and maybe wanting ONE society with her as the leader. And if there is a Starlight is she also in a villlage controlling over the humans and "brainwashing" them that a society with special talents is bad.
What do you think?

I actually have an idea of my own. What if like pony sunset, she wanted either musical ability or scientific knowledge, and, Celestia or one of the caretakers denied this. She was so problematic that they may have threatened expulsion.

(Example she was moving too fast for her class an needed to wait for everyone to catch up but kept interrupting class and causing trouble)

This was the deciding factor for her so, she ran away. Due to magic, or lack therefore of, instead of going to the pony world, she runs away to another country (possibly illegally)

She does this without telling anyone, so she is declared missing. When pony sunset crosses over they declared her found, so she took the life of original sunset.

That’s just my theory anyways.

yeah I wanted to know that too on the show, I hope they eventually bring her into the human equestria show, at some point

Actually, I believe there are 2. In the first film we see sunset shimmer, her unicorn magic is teal. The next time we see her,it’s red. This makes me believe that at some point the 2 Sunsets swapped and therefore meaning their magic is different colours because they are not the same person.

Sunset Shimmer is one of the most mysterious ponies

As soon as Sawtooth mentioned a lust for power, a need to fell superior, and a want to feel important I thought of politics. Who knows she could be off somewhere purging a senator ship or something.

Honestly your right about Sunset never engaging in physical contact with anyone (unless you count almost hurting a portal😭) Which i don’t cuz she thought that was the only way to get everything she wanted so she probably didn’t resort to hurting her counterpart especially cuz it would’ve taken time to find her counterpart which would have distracted her from becoming the most powerful being of the school so i think your theory honestly is pretty good

I have a few head canons sunset met here counterpart, but Celestia's warning was something actually legitimate and not a bs excuse to not have multiple versions running around. and the two met initially they were friends living together but sunset's presence upset the balance and they either merged into a single new being, or the universe final destinationed their asses the one with the least will power the human sunset. didn't survive hc 2: they met they both exist but human sunset adopted her as a sister. but ironically the mirror had made the pony sunset into a teen to compensate for there being two people who were the same and that is why we don't see her, sunset was the equivalent age of a college student so she's currently at college. sunset met but their meeting freaked human sunset and she ran infront of a bus accidently killing her. hc three hinges on the possibility that sunset was celestia's daughter, birth during hot love making with marvel's thor(dc cinematic universe) the two gods got it on like donkey kong and sunset was created. and since there are no dimension hopping asgardians in the pony human world that celestia never had kids.

this isn't one prethought up but what if it ended up let jet li's the one or highlander and the two sunsets had to off the other one to survive.

Can we get a backstory lore theory for where Mistmane is from? They totally gloss over it, and I just HAVE to know!!! Where are her people? Are they all gone? Or just far away?

The cutie mark theory is hella possible

So I'm just going to throw this out there, 'cause why not. For a while, I had a theory that not only was Sunset a time traveler from Equestria's future, but that she was also the daughter of Starlight Glimmer and Sunburst. I went back and forth in my head about the questions that would follow with that: Why would she travel to the past? Did she know her parents? What led her to being Celestia's student?

Well, she could've been the product of an alternate timeline, where Starlight and Sunburst happen to have a kid. But it also could've been a timeline where Chrysalis was still around and trying to go after Starlight and her family. So in a desperate attempt to protect their daughter, they sent her (as a baby) to the past using magic. From there, she was brought up as an orphan, discovered by Celestia, became her student, and you know the rest.

Not only could that answer why there's no human Sunset, but also why she was so willing to go to the human world in the first place. She didn't leave much behind in Equestria, and she could have hoped to know where she came from and who she is.

At one point, a long time ago, I started to write an MLP/Star Wars Rebels fanfic that had the original Sunset Shimmer kidnapped as a child and raised by Mandelorians, under the name of Sabine Ren. At least, Sabine's original hair and skin color seemed to match up pretty well.
Sadly, that fic was in my laptop when its OS decided that the latest update was too much to handle, and the only repair was to completely wipe the drive. Also, I fell out of MLP around Season 6 due to a show wall.
Too bad, too. I think Darth Sombra would have made a solid villain.

another theory I have is that Sunset's counterpart was cinch's student. In the song "Unleash the Magic"
She mentions having 1 or maybe 2 smart students, and looking back and seeing that a few counterparts like starswirl and twilight are scientists in the human world (human twilight was also in crystal prep, where she studied science and tech mostly. possibly where starswirl studied too, so it would make sense) since there used to be no magic to study, maybe Sunset's counterpart was BECOMING a scientist (in the process of studying) Then the pony world sunset took her identity through some sort of system (Foster care or orphanage?) and put her under the radar by possibly making everyone believe she was the human sunset, never to be seen again.

My sister always wanted the Sunset from the human world to move to Equestria. Like, there was some sort of imbalance with 2 Sunsets in the same world, and the 7 would have to find her and introduce her to the other world, and she would eventually want to stay in Equestria.

Random theory: Human Sunset came to the pony world when Pony Sunset came to the Human world. She could have gotten lost, or started exploring Equestria, and not know how to get back, and she could be living as a pony somewhere on the borders of Equestria, or even outside Equestria.

love how he just casually begins the vid with "sunset shimmer is a nexus being" and then just kinda moves on to "or she's a failed musician"

I was talking with friends a month or so back about a thery that sunset was ment to be in the human relm from the beginning, and by that thinking I though maybe sunsets pony counterpart is supposed to be starlight (part of why I kinda like it is that is can be used as a trans metaphor but there really isn't proof for this) but considering how their lives are similar but not exact like all the rest of the counter parts I think there is room for this theory.

but alternatively there could just not be a counterpart for her, alot of crystal prep and some from canterlot high don't have a counterpart.

She was evil when she first stepped in the human world. Guessing she killed her human part or maybe she didn’t

I think what really happened to Sunset's human version was that maybe she knew she had to get rid of the human version when she first came so she killed her??? Wouldn't it be possible? And no one ever suspected anything, since Sunset's pony-self was still there. This unlocks a world of possibilities!

The first thing I thought when I saw Sunset's cutie mark was "Yin/Yang?" And then nothing came of it.

I like your "she IS the connection" theory the best.

I think you were right on with the failed musician part about Sunset but if you're thinking like that you need a export for it. Think of it like human Sunset was an music artist that was trying to make her goal reality but whenever she asked different producers they don't accept her at all. What I'm thinking is that from her failure of music and no producers wanting to produce her music she runs away to a far place so she can play her music to herself and even keeping her identity hidden from everyone else such as wearing a hoodie and a mask to cover her face whenever she is out in public, but like I said this is just a theory on her musical talent.

In another video , waves says that sunset is older than twilight and the others so she might still be in college or a university. Maybe pursuing the goal of being a musician as sawtooth said by trying to learn more about it just like her pony counterpart was attending a school to learn more about magic.

Dear Sawtooth waves,
there is one mystery that i wanted to know for a long time.
How Sci Twi get her wings? Like how and why did she earn them?
She has wings in the human world when she ponies up but when she
goes to the human world she is not an alicorn.
To me, being an alicorn in the pony world is a very big deal
as it is usually destined for Rulership or royalty.
Hopefully you can make a wonderful theory and tell me the answer cus
sometimes i cant sleep not knowing.
From: One of your fans:)

Saw tooth needs to make more theoriesss I lovee them💞 there just so good could you do about mlp new gen I'd love to hear your fanstastic thoughts on why magic has disappeared and Pegasus lost their feathers and stuff maybe someone pulled a mega cozy glow 🤭

If she did have a human counterpart she would have been very confused when the one we know became famous by both being in a movie and being part of a famous band. So why didn't she seek the one we know out after all that stardom.

My theory: The sunset we all know is actually the human counterpart and she knew about the other world before the rest of the human counterparts. The pony counterpart is somewhere deep in equastria

There's also a strong chance that she was alive but died bwfore all this. From cancer to a car accident, we have no idea. For all we know, she could have been a victim of human trafficking and lives on a while other continent. There's so much going on in our basic world that so many things could have killed her off or kept her away from everything before now

I'be been asking the same question so many times but there wasn't a clear answer from people until sawtooth gave us an answer from him.

Actually, it was confirmed that there was originally going to be a human Sunset, but they scrapped the idea or something, there's a Dr. Wolf video about that :)

always love your videos, keep it up!

Is no one gonna talk about how Starlight has two different magic auras? In the original Equestria girls, she has a sea foam green aura, but when she goes to the pony world in the cruise ship movie, she heads to the pony world through the quicksand portal and uses a red aura. May just be inconsistency, but something to think about

Sunset originally lives in Canterlot or somewhere else. She just used the mirror to travel in the human world in order to escape with the crown. She has been there before since she wasn't surprised when the crown went through the mirror. There's only one sunset

I had a pet theory for awhile that, like EqSunset, HuSunset kind of ran away from home. But without knowledge of magic, she stole a boat, got caught in a storm, and has been Professor-ing it up on some uncharted island somewhere.

This also raises more questions! What about chrysalis? Or discord? Or literally any of the non pony or dragon characters?

I like the idea of Sunset being the Avatar bringing the spirit...
Whoops, wrong universe. The point is I like the idea of her not even having a counterpart

I have a theory that the human sunset found a natural portal, and went to live on as a pony from a young age and pony sunset went on to live as a human (which weirdly enough also ties in with her cutie mark like, in a "they switched worlds" kinda way)

The idea that Sunset stole her counterpart's life was disproven when we got to see where she lives in the music video. No parents. She's squatting in an abandoned commercial space that she's fixed up to be livable. And Celestia's high school is weirdly accommodating to mysterious teenagers who show up out of nowhere with no educational records, almost as if they know they're sitting on an interdimensional portal and are prepared to cover for the occasional immigrant.

Sunset has living parents, she just hates them. I speculate that they are part of the Canterlot aristocracy and their snobbery and demands that she be successful and perfect are what drove her away and meant that losing her apprenticeship means that instead of returning to them she instead ran as far away from them as she possibly could. Which could explain why we don't see Sunset's counterpart. Like pony Sunset, after she failed at something she ran. She ran so far away. She had to get away. She's not in Equestria though. Given her magic talent and pride and ambition she would have ended up as one of the villains that the Mane 6 have to deal with. But she will be as far as she can possibly get from where she was born. I like to imagine her as the mysterious foreign student in some Japanese cartoon we've never heard of.

Here’s what I’ve always thought: sunset never actually belonged in equestria, she was always meant to be in the human world, but being born in Equestria, it made that difficult, when she rebelled against Celestia and went to the human world, she found where she was meant to be, and found where she was supposed to call her home, it might sound like a stretch, but that’s what I think.

I'd like to think that Sunset scared the other Sunset off, and she went to homeschooling until she graduated, and the moved away as soon as she could because she was still afraid of Sunset finding her, and wasn't aware of how Sunset was nice and reformed now. I'd also like to think she reinvented herself so no one would confuse her for Sunet. Maybe some hairdye and a new fashion sense. My headcanon new name for her that she chose is Sunshine Rise. Or Sunshine Days, inspired by the G3 pony Sunny Daze

I cant wait to see what Sawtooth does with the new gen of mlp but there are still so many possible things and questions we still have in gen 4 will those be answered in gen 5? I highly doubt it though

My Theory on human Sun Shim was always that maybe she was in Juvi. Think about it.
When we first meet sunset, she’s evil. What would the human counterpart be?
A criminal.
I at least always thought that would make a pretty cool plot line.

My theory is that Sunset came to the human world and was homeless for a few years until she turned 15/16 (when she was able to be rented to legally). But about the facts — in order to get into school those few years, she would’ve had to either be adopted or make fake legal documents. We know she lives alone, and has never mentioned adoptive system etc, so that’s why I assume she was homeless (living in an abandoned building or something) and she definitely had to make fake legal documents for fake parents/etc.
That’s the only way I could see around it, it’s not really related to this video, but I do believe personally in the "link" theory!

Pony sunset had a rebellious nature and was banished to the human world. Perhaps human sunset had a rebellious nature and is frequently in juvie.

Sería genial que este video tuviera subtítulos en español para poder entenderlo :"D

There was a video of yours that didn't even have access to the comments... I will comment that I prefer your hinge theory because of Sunset's complex character. She's literally one of a kind. That doesn't change her friendship with both Twilight's, (and I'm sorry, even if she is the hinge between the two worlds, I still ship her and human Twilight, because of their chemistry)

Two theories I have is that a sunset in the human world went to crystal prep like twilight did, but got expelled for going to extremes in pursuit of her academic goals, or something similar like pony sunset that made her power hungry and get kicked to somewhere else. Maybe she even had to move away?

Second one is that when human sunset was real little she wandered through the portal somehow, or a different one(?) And was deemed missing. She grew up in Equestria possibly at an orphanage or something and led a separate and different life from our sunset, and when our sunset went to the human world she was deemed a found missing child, so it solves where she's been living this whole time.

They both have horrible plot holes but then again the movies are kinda living contradictions in a way, they're a huge mess plot-wise.

I have no idea! This question has been pondering my mind since the equestrian games movie came out! It’s all so confusing and well if sunset traveled to the human world when she was young then why would the human one not have? The next problem would be sunset should have been living in canterlot and maybe she would’ve been a self-centered unicorn like Trixie? Gah there’s to many unanswered questions! I like your “Sunset in the link” idea best

I just always thought that the Human World Sunset just traveled to Equestria because the normal Sunset did the reverse lol

Theory: Human Sunset probably wanted to try getting smarter in school getting higher grades, but when she started to fail more and more, she raged and just quit, running off to celestia knows where. She'd probably find an alternate portal to equestria and head there and live in the shadows throughout the rest of her days, never being seen from or heard from again, enclosed in her own anger and self-pity in a corner of the world no one would ever find her.

Ok here is a kind of spooky theory: Did you notice that Sunset Shimmer's hair color slightly changed between Rainbow Rocks and the Friendship-Games? It went from a strong yellow to a paler shade of yellow. At first I thought that it was made intentionally as a kind of symbolism: Sunsets personality has gotten a loooot softer over time. But here starts my theory: What if somehow the human Sunset replaced pony sunset between the second and third movie. I know it maybe seems far-fetched, but that would explain her haircolor and the fact why she was so careless and thought that DELIBERATELY inviting her human friends to ponyville was a good idea in one of the movies (I can't remember which one sorry >_<)

imagine the regular sunset we know wasnt actually born in equestria and was actually born in the human world who at a young age traveled to equestria for a while but then was sent back by celestia oh em gee

New viewer💗🇨🇦😎So, given your OC pony... I take it you’re into synth waves when it comes to making music??? Do you make your own remixes???

I like how alternative sunsets ambitions don't really matter if the reason she's on the down low is because she failed at something then of course her pride would keep her going until she burnt out.

I’m just thinking, could it be that because she would go to the human world so often, her human counterpart just faded away along with anyone’s memories of her?

honestly when I was young I thought the true human sunset was in prison somewhere in the human world, given the pony sunset's original destructive and self-serving nature. I swear Im not crazy LOL

Could you please do a video about the necklaces the human six wear specifically how those stones have magic? I love your videos this one is very well done . please consider my request

I like your idea of only one sunset but as said this is highly unlikely. As we see every other character seems to have a human counter part. SEEMS to.

Finally someone actually asks this question that I’ve wondered

We know that Sunset is Celestia’s ex-student. Interpret that into human knowledge. An expelled student. What if Sunset is working a job somewhere in the show? Like as a waitress?

i feel like the human sunset studied the magic of singing in CHS and fell through the portal one of the 30 moons and fell into magic . I really wish it was Adagio i have this feeling they are connected...

I personally feel like human SS might've been killed but not by pony SS, possibly magic
Pony SS got so distraught by her death that she began to rebel and hated magic to the point she was willing to use it as a weapon to show how dangerous it could be but took it too far

Fun theory, sunset is actually an orphan from the human world that somehow was sent into equestria. Therefore the "other" sunset could still be somewhere in equstria

"Perhaps her pride and ambition would latch on to something else"

My wierdly crime-driven mind: A gang leader or a Mafia Boss!

There's something else you should know by now; the mirror which leads to both Equestria and our world? It'll leave one naked without an extra pair of clothes. Don't go through without a second pair, your's will rip if you have them on.

Here’s a theory. I don’t think the original versions just disappear as Princess Celestia makes it seem to the Mane 6 ( minus T.S. ). I think they’re still there. What Celestia meant was that if the originals, the ones we see in Ponyville, and their human versions see each-other, that something will happen. Presumably dark magic? Maybe.

true true absoloutely true! And yeah, we just actually never saw a human counterpart of sunset!Maybe they will show us her later in the show.It might even be that sunset HAS a human counterpart and they know eachother which they keep swapping around with the mane six.I just hope they actually reveal one cause that would make an exciting story!:)

Ok I just wanted to say this, a pony going to the human world and trying to use a phone would probably be like a 75 year old trying to use a modern phone. 😂

Well, when we see that Sci-Twi was originally at a different school in the same city and only met the rest of her world's mane 6 because of a long standing interschool rivalry, plus shenanigans around the newly emerging magic, it is more than possible that EQG world Sunset is simply also elsewhere in her world, whether she's a failure or not. If another world copy of any of us popped into existence anywhere but near where we lived, and didn't become famous, or infamous, enough to draw world wide attention to themselves would we even know, except by the rarest of chance meetings? Look at when someone becomes famous, say by being elected to high office, and the media finds a doppelganger. No one knew until one was elected president or something that the other existed. If Sunset becomes that famous her human world double may appear, if she doesn't reach that level of infamy, we may never know. Unless Hasbro, because toys, lol.

(Sorry for this being long it was just a lot of stuff to say)
I once saw a fan art with I believe it was she-demon painted on Sunset's locker and her running away crying. This lead me to think human Sunset is avoiding people in Canterlot because no matter what kind of bullying it is there will always be people who think it's wrong and openly called out that person. I think happened was all of the hate that Pony Sunset gained was put on her human counterpart. I think this is likely because we see from the pictures of Sunset as Princess of the Fall Formal she looks so nice in the first picture even if it was an act why would pre-reform Sunset act nice if it didn't benefit her in someway. So if she was acting like her nice human counterpart imagine how her human counterpart felt all of a sudden all of your friends and the people you go to school with start calling you names and saying you're a horrible person and you have no way of knowing why. You'd want to leave and tell no one so they have no way of finding you.

It's really unknown to weather Sunset Shimmer even has a human world Counterpart, it's probably to make Sunset more unique but it would be interesting to see.
Also I don't really think Sunny was evil enough to Kill someone prior to the first EQG so therefore Human world Sunset is still alive.

I love this theory. I believe the sunset shimmer in human world could be regular girl with some pride, has musical talent of her own and attends a different school. What would happen if the two meet and sunset shimmer feels she's fulfilled her duty between the world's. Does she plan to go back to Equestria and let her human counterpart take over as new member to learn more about friendship. Since she has been with human counterparts for so long. Is it possible just like Twilight and good deeds done in human world She has means to be an Alicorn as and continue duty to protect both worlds from Equestria side? but visit human world from time to time help in battle against any villans?

What if Human Sunset went to the Pony Realm and want to stay there just like the Sunset we know? If she is then she probably lives somewhere that is neither Ponyville nor Canterlot, somewhere like Manhattan or other places in Equestria

i absolutely love how you're STILL making conspiracy theories about MLP even after its finished. not to be sentimental, but i still cannot believe you're still so dedicated to this, ive known/watched you create this stuff since like 2015 and you're still here and stuff jawnhetihahiawhtiuwtaw

If sunset was forgetful and kept saying "what are you talking about, I never did that. Then I would say she never did anything and her human version did everything her friends thought she did which would explain a lot like why we haven't seen her before but she doesn't say that and isn't forgetful.

Or maybe it should be "when". I mean think about it, it isn't impossible for her human form to be in a different time. But it may be rare. As you said, yes her cutie mark may mean that. But as we all know everyone has a human counterpart. It can't be that sunset just doesn't have a counterpart. So she could possibly be in a different timeline.

There was actually a cancelled one-hour long special that focused on why magic has been following the Equestria Girls everywhere and what happened to the human Sunset. However, that special was changed to the Holidays Unwrapped shorts.

My theory is that the human sunset passed away due to a sickness or accident or maybe she travelled somewhere else and it was a perfect opportunity for this sunset to continue human sunset’s life, especially since in the mlpeg movie there were photos that had sunset as a kid when pony sunset left at a bit of an older age.

If I recall correctly, I think the writers did have plans to bring human world Sunset Shimmer into canon, but unfortunately Equestria Girls got the short end of the stick and was canceled before those ideas could see the light of day.

There must be 2 theories: 1. She is in the unique circle, I'm asking where is pony timberspruce; aria blaze; sonata dusk and human starlight, sunburst. Some of the characters only exist in one world. Those two worlds can't be a copy of each other, so there must be some unique figures.
2. Your picture has already show that, in s2, we noticed sunset has something different, that could be real human sunset. And that one also gains memories reader ability! Or maybe just because sunset reaches teen age. So i like theory 1

I have a head cannon that sunset shimmer forced herself into the human world for a long time, and this over time upset the balance of the worlds until the worlds decided to correct themselves and swallowed human sunset to equestria as a consequence of pony sunset staying in the human world for too long.

what if sunset from the human world did the same thing as sunset from equestria? travel to somewhere else? we never know if there's magic outside where the story is based on, maybe the sunset from the human work discovered magic somehow and travelled to another dimension just as sunset from equestria.

Look at twilight in the human world, loved by Celesta and ends up one of the most popular students in the school, my theory is is that it was the same for sunset, but She was over took by the love and attention she was getting from others, she eventually grew selfish and mean and started taking affection that she didn’t deserve. Look at the first movie and the pictures of sunset, I think the last one is OUR sunset but all the others are the human sunset. As to where she is I have a theory for that to, like sunset in Equestria, I think sunset left and tried to get power and attention somewhere else, like another school or something, so with the original sunset leaving a year prior, our sunset cloud learn about everyone and etc. 😀

“Perhaps her pride and ambition would latch onto something else”
Me: politics
“Music”
Me: oh

I didn’t recognize Sawtooth until I realized “hey wait The Brony Notion got a revamp”

Perhaps she is like the Twilight from Crystal Prep-all studious, sciency and not knowing magic

I think that copy of sunset in human version without mane 6 would be too much of a threat. 2 sunsets would be threat to society, so directors decided to leave one Shimmer in space-time 😩

There has been talk about maybe a 2 part story of human counter Sunset Shimmer, but she turns out to be evil at first and nearly kills Sunset Shimmer. Then later on after the human turns good, she asks to go to Equestria and Sunset gets to graduate with her friends. Sunset DID NOT kill her human counterpart because this is too violent to comprehend and that is not what the show is about.

Imagine Sunset Shimmer cutie mark represents a moon inside a sun… I would rather have her in the royal problem than Starlight, but that’s just my opinion! Love the video👍✨

I would think there was one. Mainly because we’ve seen human counterparts for everyone else, but here’s what I’m thinking. I have 2 theories. The first one is pretty whacked out but what if at one point human Sunset Shimmer came to Equestria to live a life. She found a portal and went through it to find there was magic in this new world. She decided travel all throughout this new world and see what it was about, but at the same moment Pony Sunset went through the portal to the human world. It’s a bit of a messy theory but it would explain how no one has mentioned another Sunset and why we haven’t seen a human Sunset. The other theory makes a bit more sense. The other Sunset simply goes to another school. We don’t know exactly where Sunset is from but my thinking is she isn’t from Ponyville, Canterlot, or the Crystal Empire. It’s more likely she’s from a small town like Starlight was. So thinking that, the human Sunset might go to another school in a different town unaware of anything that’s going on at Canterlot High. I think since she didn’t have Magic to corrupt her, I would think she would be in a position of wanting to help people like a counselor or like Sawtooth said, a musician. Both theories are pretty out there, but it might give a little insight on what our human Sunny is up to!

Well we know that Sunset is from Equestria and she lived in Canterlot. After, she moved in the human world and that's her new place now, so if there's a human Sunset, maybe she did something similar ? Maybe she was in CHS a long time ago, but she moved far away ? Perhaps even in an another world (but I don't think so personally and mostly not in Equestrian world because the Mane 6 would've known about that, certainly).

Honestly, I think It starts with her parents
No one has seen them yet or have been introduced, and it wouldn't be impossible for someone from the pony realm to fall in love with another in the human realm.

We'll call the parents Flick (Pony royal guard) and Daisy ( a young adult training to be a nurse). I'm gonna make the theory somewhat quick though-
Flick is guarding a room (assigned by Celestia), of which he doesn't know the reason why, and then proceeds to sneak in to find out. He finds the mirror, falls in, then meets Daisy who was walking by. She offers to help him and he accepts. She checks him over and confirms he's ok- but the stories he tells about a pony world makes her worry. He leaves, letting her help him back, and promises to return, to which he enters the portal. She becomes baffled at the sight, then assumes she's going crazy. This thought is erased however as he returns the next day. They converse, and to her surprise, other people see him too. His short and brief moments in her life makes her happy- as her private and social life are not the best and she considered going away from it all. She tells this all to flick, to which he offers to bring her to his world. She accepts and follows him into his realm. She feels lighter there, and then begins to visit him instead. After a while, she chooses to stay in equesteria, and flick holds no obligations. no one was told about this continuous back and forth of the two, as she was welcomed into the community without even being known as a human. After a while, they have Sunset, who would have the bonds from the human world, and the pony world and therefore have no alt of herself as she would be the creation of both sides.

It wouldn't explain who took her in, but Daisy and Flick could have had some slip ups on where she use to live or have Flick rest as the two conversed about his home realm as the two decided not to let anyone else know about it.

now if I put a ton of details in- it'd be much longer lol.

Perhaps the human Sunset exists, but lives in another place or another city. Unfortunately, too few episodes were released on Equestria Girls. I would like to see more EG seasons. Perhaps we would then have opened the story of human Sunset. I think generation 4 MLP and EG turned off too early. How many different stories we could see about our loved characters!

Okay, so we know human Twilight wouldn't have ended up in Canterlot if magic wasn't brought into their world and pony Twilight was there before her, building a reputation. We also know Sunset was a student of Celestia before Twilight, to the point where Twilight didn't even know Sunset. I think it's plausible to think human Sunset is probably older than the main six, and/or could also just live nowhere near there. I don't think human Sunset could have gone to Canterlot, though, since Celestia would definitely notice if she had two of the same looking students with the same names. She could have also gone to Crystal Prep, like Twilight, and graduated before Twilight met her, but then wouldn't the principal or vice principal notice pony Sunset at the Friendship Games?

With all this information, I think either the first theory brought up in the video, which is that there is only a pony Sunset, is true or that the human Sunset simply doesn't live near the main six. The murder theory seems far-off, considering it's a children's show and I don't think Sunset could even pull it off with how little she probably knew about the human world at first. There's also a possibility that the other Sunset could just not exist since the creators of Equastria Girls didn't consider it or have any intention of introducing/hinting at her existence.

Ever since MLP:Equestria girls Movie came out I wondered where Sunset Shimmer was living and where could her human self be but I am pretty sure she didn't really kill her human self
Hopefully we will see human Sunset Shimmer soon

Such good theories!! all of them. But honestly I think you nailed the first one and that might be the truth

Theory: since sunset was most likely the first pony to go to the human world Mabye the balence broke and caused the other sunset to stop existing and the only reason sci twi exists is because the balence is already broken.

Might as well rename this channel "The pony theorist" and call the day. Jokes aside, I think another possibility is that Human Sunset died, but not by the hands of pony Sunset, instead, she could've died by accident. Or, like for Twilight, she simply lives elsewhere, only much further away

i once read a fan-story where Human Sunset tried to become a Daring Doo/Indiana Jones style "archeologist-adventurer"...
but died to a booty-trap in a tomb.

that was in "it's a screwed-up life", where the protagonist is a random fan who somehow got turned into Screwball.

I randomly think abaout this when the song release the magic was playing in my head on loop in 5am and the line "to find a student like you,i have one or maybe two,but the good ones disapear before i blink" make me think about sunset that sunset might have been in the same school as twilight before and then magically disapear,but then again when i think abaout it if sunset was in twilight school the teacher should have remember her but the fact that she isn't sure herself that she has a genius student once make me think that is not completly imposible for sunset to be in twilight school and the teacher just forgets about her ,and about twilight not knowing about sunset make me think like sunset was a senior or at least twilight has not come or entered the school before and when she does enter sunset had dissapeard a long time ago and so noone remembered her anymore,and human starlight might have been there as well since the teacher said she had one or maybe two,by watching in one of the episode when sunset and starlight get along very well make me think that human sunset and starlight might have been bestfriend and when sunset dissapeard starlight maybe start looking on why her friemd suddenly dissapeard and still trying to find out why till to this day

Maybe if the pony sunset found the way to the human world, the human sunset found the way to Equestria 🤷🏻‍♀️ or maybe she end up lost in the other not so pretty places we saw on the movie.

For me, I think Sunset's human counter part lived in the different country so I guess that's why we didn't see her in the show

Sunset is the best writing we'll ever get out of eqg, she's shrouded with mystery, and that gives us multiple variables to what happened in her life or what happened before she showed up. I think human sunset would be like that, except maybe her goal is to get her identity back from pony sunset after the she demon incident, it must've spread somewhere

and congrats on 400k :D

This is a kinda simple theory, but since the Equestria Sunset is not from around ponyville or since she doesn’t have anything to do with the maincharacters of the show… I think that the human Sunset doesn’t either if that makes sense. She is probably somewhere living her life having nothing to do with the main characters who live in both world in some way ‘near’ eachother.

I had a theory where what if the sunset that was introduced as a pony, was actually apart of the human world? And there’s a sunset in the pony world that we dont know abt? But there is many possibilities 😅

My theory is she exists in another time period

This is based on the fact that in the human world Celestia is an adult where as in the pony world she’s lived over 1000 years. This means that for a long time she only existed in the pony world.

2:49 A version from another world where be was a wizard
... sounds like a writing prompt

I’ve always wondered how many humans came to the pony world and lived as ponies. Would that be possible?

My theory:

Sunset was a amazing and hardworking student, so celestia showed her a secret thing for the school's staff, she wanted to use it but celestia told her she can't, she got greedy, when the SUN SET she went to the school with an all black outfit and took the thing, when they caught her they sent her to the death penalty and killed her, celestia was heartbroken but she couldn't stop the police since she's just the principal

(Really close to the pony sunset's backstory)

If Hasbro didn't make Equestria Girls the way they did with these Shorts and Later Specials, I'm sure we would've gotten a Definitive Answer on where Human Sunset is.

Theory:
Since she wanted power, then she either went into government or business, and I will only talk about the governmetn part, since business is to varied. And if we look at the main ways of getting government power, then they are:

Birth (Monarchy)
Military
Politics (Suport of the people)
Oligarchy (Getting a possition in government)

She is not royal, and unless she became an African warlord, then these two are ruled out. If she was a public politician, then she is not very known, since people would notice that there was another Sunset, which is the one from the pony world. And if it is oligarchy, then she is either not very known, not very powerfull and thus not very known, or powerfull enough to keep herself a secret and then might even know about the otehr Sunset.

And if you think this sounds like a stretch, then remember what pony Sunset was willing to do.

Since so far, it seems like everyone still lives around the same people in both worlds, it seems like OG Sunset would be a Canterlot High as she was Celestia’s student. Maybe she left Canterlot High around the same time that pony Sunset left Equestria (maybe even went to ANOTHER dimension) and our Sunset just plugged herself into the hole she left. Or maybe it’s like how human Twilight was at Crystal Prep despite human twilight not living in or near the Crystal Empire and she’s just at another school

Can we appreciate that effort for Sawtooth wave for posting videos for us to enjoy and they makes amazing content for us and they spend time making these videos and they makes our day even better and congrats on 400K subscribers! Keep it up 🎉

I know this theory might not be true but i like to think it's possible: sunset shimmer was originally from the human world. (It would explain why there isn't another sunset, it's because we've already seen the human sunset.)

To properly figure this one out, we would first need to know the origins of PONY sunset and cross-reference that with the human world. Like with human twilight, it's probably most likely that human sunset is just somewhere else in the human world since human sunset didn't get the same opportunities pony sunset had to actually get to the human world and canterlot high. Maybe pony sunset shimmer isn't even from canterlot like starlight glimmer so the chances of her coming across her human version is very minimal. At least thats my take on it lol EDIT: after watching the video what I mean is pretty much what was said lol

I love how Sawtooth's comment section is full of scientific facts and questions which are about a cartoon of ponies😆

Not like an insult to my little pony or anything

I have an video idea:
How did mane six (+ Starlight) solve everything in episode "Fame and misfortune", because episode ended with them just huging and angry crowd was still outside the castle? Maybe Twilight and Starlight time traveler to fix everything.

My theory: In her past life (I’m going of reincarnation), she was a powerful unicorn who studied in dangerous fields of magic. Because of that, she ran an underground operation of sorts, passing as a librarian. She studied for a long time and had a high ambition to become an alicorn along side Luna and Celestia. Eventually, she looked at Star Swirls studies for guidance and remembered how he sent the sirens to another realm. She went to find any remain of the realm, and she did. A mirror. She jumped in and eventually got used to living there. She became a very respected woman in her town and became a sort of minor goddess of sort for them, before dying a little before Sunset came through the portal.

We have to remember that Celestia banished Sunset Shimmer to that world as she said in the first movie, so I think Celestia holds the answer to the other Sunset Shimmer

I've got my idea: what if pony sunset is actually human sunset, and we should look for the original pony instead of original human sunset? I know it's crazy but still...

I think that since pony sunset ran away to the human world, human sunset ran away to Equestria and might be living in secret. Maybe she did go to canterlot high but met pony and they discussed swapping places. Sunset originaly from the human world might be travelling around Equestria!😊

I always thought that every alternative Sunset Shimmer was in a alternative world. Like pony Sunset went to the human would while human Sunset went to another alternative universe.

I’ve been binging MLP after years and watching some of your videos on the side, and I just want to say thank you for the years of entertainment you provided.

I imagine that considering in the pony world where ponies can be hundreds of years old, and how humans cant, that the sunset in the human world would have just peacefully lived a full life and died. Because clearly, sunset is supposed to be older yet her and twilight are the same age when transferred to the human world so there's clearly some aging stuff involved.,

I’ll admit that I’m honestly not a crazy fan of MLP. But after watching this video I have a question that I must ask. But does the show really have it’s own multiverse?

If sunset shimmer did become ruler of equestria she would of been a very pretty pony with the ever flowing mane and tail.

I talked to my sister about what you said and she thinks Sunset Shimmer in the human world doesn't necessarily look like our Sunset. Maybe it's someone else I've already seen. How about Addagio ? She could be Sunset from Equestria Girls. The same about the purple haired girl with blue streaks could be Starlight Glimmer in Equestria Girls. 🤔 I don't know what to say. It seems silly to me. 😅

Well... I have always thought that, if they are infinite alternate realities, not every person of the world would have a counterpart in those realities, or they wouldn't be able to meet because they were born in different times... If every choice of us makes those realities different, and if we take into account the decissions of rest of the world, there may be even a world where there's no internet, where there's not a certain item or a certain person in there.
Let's not get too far: if your parents met by some sort of accident or coincidence, for example, if your dad spilled over something on your mom, what would have happened if he hasn't spilled anything on your mom, or if he spilled it over other person? Or if your mom came from the countryside and was exploring the city, what if she turned left, instead of right, and never encountered your dad? Exactly: You won't exist. And there may also be a chance that they met, but gave birth to a girl, instead of a boy, or viceversa...
There are infinite possibilities of what other realities may look like. So, it wouldn't be strange if there wasn't born a human version of Sunset Shimmer, or she WAS alive, or she will be born. I mean, Celestia is there, and she's supposed to be WAY older than every pony in Equestria, along with Luna, so, maybe she's older or younger than the Equestria Girls... Or maybe she lives at the other side of the world.

My Theory:
Remember in equestrian games, sunset shimmer unleashed the magic to get twilight out of the evil trance, but remember the glow outline of the wings and a horn she had, twilight had physical horns and but sunset didnt. Okay now think about sunny, the orange earth pony in new generation, she had the same glow outline that sunset had: maybe sunny belongs in the pony world and sunset belongs in the human world. I know sunny lives a thousand years after sunset but maybe that’s just magic fixing a wrong of forgetting the pony sunset. And yes, I also do know sunset was originally from the pony world but maybe her destiny was the human world and sunny’s Was the pony world?

Well. The guitar thing was done by pony sunset. We do know she wanted power so she could have gone for a politial route to that power.

Honestly my first theory was that sunset killed her human counterpart.

Or, what if the human sunset was having a horrible life and wanted to permanently get away from it all, so sunset granted her wish? And human sunset moved to Africa or something

Well, they were gonna make an hour-long winter special that would introduce us to Human Sunset and would lead to se. 3, but they just made the "Holidays Unwrapped" instead...

well I like to think there is three theories behind this question one she doesn't exist or two she's dead.
or three she existed but in a different timeline.

i heard that theory about sunset killing her human counterpart, and the whole her human counterpart was a failed musicians might be true since if you look at sunset outfit, she does wear a rock type jacket and the fact she once

my only question is does how long was sunset ben in the human world, and if she i guess took her human self away, was the human sunset still dated flash or was her sunset doing?

You took this question out from my own mind I mean I wonder that since we saw sunset go in the human world I even asked but I guess you did not see it also, I think the human world is really big just like equestria, so maybe the human sunset is out there somewhere out and maybe we did not see her because the movies and episodes didn't show the world out there instead, they only showed canterlot high. So now you know my suggestion, hope you like it

When I compared to Charlie Evans from Star Trek, he was completely lost in different worlds.

I think she would go into politics instead of music. Nothing better to satisfy her lust for power.

This just came to me. What if the pony Sunset is actually the Sunset from the human world and the pony Sunset didn't live in Equestria. The pony Sunset just lives somewhere to be unnoticed. Human Sunset went to Canterlot School and discovered the magic mirror that connects the 2 world and saw what it does. She became Celestia's student and turned evil and tried to take over Equeatria and so on.

Necesito subtitulos al español 😭😭😭🙌🏻

Remember that ponyvill and Canterlot were not the only places in equestria just like how there won't be just the town in human world so original human sunset could be in another part of the world because we don't hear about anyone else in another place from the human world... if that makes any sense

What if the sunset we know IS the human version of her but she found the gateway to equestria and stayed for a bit, then she became princess celestia's pupil because she could sence that sunset wasn't like other ponys.
Then I believe sunset started to get power hungry so when she left, she needed to come back to bring magic with her to the human world

First of all, death will never be straight up confirmed in MLP. Even when it's heavily hinted at, like with Bright Mac and Pear Butter, it isn't actually stated, thus no theory about death will ever be confirmed.

That said, my head canon is still that human Sunset is dead. While I find the idea that pony Sunset killed her to be laughable, that doesn't mean that human Sunset didn't meet her unfortunate end. After all, pride and ambition often leads one to their own end.

There is a partial answer to this that most aren't looking at. and that is its believed that Sunset was late teens when she left. if humans and ponies age the same that means human sunset would already done with high school. Which means she'd be gone by the time pony sunset entered the human world, or human sunset could have gone to a different school like human Twi did.

Well, personally, my hypothesis is that most likely Sunset from the world of people lives in another city, so we did not see her ,but the most logical explanation is that the creators simply did not need another Sunset ,so they thought that Sunset from the world of ponies is the only one of its kind . But the version of the murder of another Sunset is also not a bad explanation .

Hey I have a question for ya sawtooth that you can use, if the event with Luna happened in Equestria, ya know by being banished to the moon, do you think that something even similar happened with celestia and Luna in the human work? Like did she get jealous about not being principal and was fired or something and then something happened and now she’s a vice principal and happy with it? Ide be happy if you used my idea on a vid! 😁

So based off of the plot holes Sunset had to had a human counterpart, otherwise where would Sunset live, where did she get her clothes, her home, her money, her everything. Someone had to have taken her in, the most logical idea would be human Sunset’s family. True we never see the human mane six’s families but we do know they have them.

On top of that sure it’s possible Sunset killed her counterpart but she never goes for physical violence until she turns into a demon. This suggests she wouldn’t go for that. So Sunset must have done something else. There are many options. Sunset drove her human counterpart off and took over. Sunset found the human Sunset’s family after said Sunset left home and severed their relationship. Maybe the human one left her family and Sunset convinced them she was the original. Or there’s the possibility that there was an accident when the original did die and Sunset arrived in time to take her place. Or Sunset simply just did identity theft and ruined former Sunset’s life

I think what sunset shimmer might have done is she may have sent the human sunset shimmer into the pony world may have kept her prisoned where tirex and the queen of changelings were. Also I think the moment sunset shimmer wore twilights crown may have erased some of her memories of what she did to the human sunset that might be the reason why she was crying so much…maybe from the guilt of her twin versions death

I'm late to the debate but I have a few ideas and I'm not sure they count as a theory, but....

We know that Sunset was Princess Celestia's student before Twilight, and when Sunset arrived in the human world, Twilight came after. But no one really knows how long, and since the Twilight from the human world transferred to CHS long after Sunset did, it could be indicating what happened with pony Twilight and Sunset in the first place. They start as enemies, end as friends.

idk man I'm losing my trail of thought

can we talk about how come one sunset shimmer is brighter than the other isn't it bit strange

I think the pony sunset was actually the human sunset. I mean it may be a stretch but think about it now the pony counter part of sunset human sunset could've just poofed her away or teleported with magic or somehow erased her memory and sent her somewhere else no killing. Now how she got I'm not very sure but human sunset could've just been playing as a child and accidentally went through the portal never to be seen again until ya know the show but think about it human sunset was much more comfortable in the human world then twilight was when she first got there. Also the people in the human world seem to be familiar with her as if she lives there. So most likely she visits her home town and know how the portal works so well remembering it as a child.

This was one of my personal theories, too. I always wondered what happened to the Sunset Shimmer or if there even was one. I never thought maybe there actually is a human Sunset Shimmer, I just had the idea of it.

I think maybe there is an original Sunset, and I do agree with the idea of her not pursuing anything academically related, manily just because I don't see that for her character, but I don't necessarily agree with the idea of failed musician or have an actual idea for what she would do. Still, this was a really cool thought that makes me wanna go back and watch the mlp movies all over again.

Also, a completely not on topic theory/headcanon (I say that because I do have evidence to back this up, though I might be stretching it thin) Rainbow Dash has separation anxiety, and Tank is a of support animal (not officially). There's more to this theory, but I can't remember it right now😅

i want to say something that when zakora gave twilight a potion she saw night mare moons vanish but then she saw discord turn to stone luna was there with celestia but when star light sent twilight to a place where night mare moon was not defeated night mare moon said she did not knew where the elements of hormany was but when discord was turned to stone celestia show where the tree of hormany was but how did she did not remember you can make a video with this

Very interesting and I understand everything 😁 Because I come from Germany and still learning I often don't watch englisch Videos oder Films but yours are ready nice 👌

If Equestrian Sunset really did kill Human Sunset, then She would have eventually told everyone that she isn't "their" sunset. My other theory is that Human Sunset is in another part of the human world. It is a very low chance that you'll meet yourself from another dimension unless you intentionally want to meet yourself. Equestrian Sunset probably got adopted or something, while Human Sunset is with her parents somewhere.

So here's a theory... The human Sunset actually went to ANOTHER universe. Okay I get that this isn't the best but hey this is a theory. In the human universe there can be magic, this is showed through the show, and in the episode with the whole multiverses and changing the timelines, they show that different timelines can change a lot. This could lead to even more universes then pony and human. In all the human world Sunset could have went to another universe.

I have a theory and possibly an answer.It could be that sunset already killed the original from Equestria (The world), But there are other ponies that too we have not seen in the pony world or that have been in far away lands like Manehattan or just travelers, But it also could be that they are in unseen cities like Philadelphia.

My Theory:
Human Sunset exists but the script-writers may may not have written a place for her.
And now that Mlp is over

It's kinda like with Isaacus Maximus: We have never met him before but he is out there somewhere. Even if I made him up, there is possible potential that Isaacus Maximus might actually exist. You could say that, maybe he's human Sunset's emotional support and has been at side since they were young. Truth be told, if Isaacus Maximus does indeed exist, he could potentially make a significant difference to the story or theory.

Just because our sunset wasn't the cause of human sunset stuff that doesn't mean she isn't dead, it can't be proven just like the theory that there is no human sunset but still possibility

I love that Ponytail Sunset design. I dunno why, but she looks so adorable, even more so than Sci-Twi.

As for my theory on Human Sunset, I've two theories I fall back on to explain where she is whenever I'm writing a fanfic.

1. (which I don't use too often, especially after your Sunset Origins videos) Our Sunset IS her human counterpart who somehow ended up in Equestria as a baby and was adopted into a unicorn family (in this case, Sunny Flare's).

2. Human Sunset is part of the Everton Project like Sci-Twi wanted to be so has been off studying whatever subject she's most passionate about.

Most logic is that she either got expelled, dropped out, or switched schools, because that would equal out the fact that sunset left equestria, but I think she was more of a special student, there's one loop hole in it tho that principal celestia doesn't remember sunset, but we can cover it that eighter 1 sunset lied that she knew she had been there when she really didn't, or 2 it was so long ago that celestia didn't remember, again, the school is HUGE remembering 1 student is impossible unless they did something great, but that would mean she(the human sunset) probably dropped out and our new sunset replaced her, probably came back way more rebeliouse then the human counterpart, wich is why celestia woulnt remember her, she used to be just a bit burned out sleepy student that is most of the students, maybe like that one girl (ironically I don't remember her name) that would erase people's memories, she wasn't memorable for a reason, the stone she used, but what if sunset was just too boring and ordenary to remember? It's just a theory lmao

I always used to wonder if there's a human sunset and I thought that there is because in rainbow rocks I didn't really think there's a human twilight but when we met human twilight I thought that there is a human sunset because why wouldn't there be one but my question was were is she and why she never appeared in any episode.

I thought pf a theory of when Sunset was going through the portal to the human world, the human world sunset was also going at the same time and maybe in the big portal we see Twilight going through to get to the human world, they maybe bumped into eachother and maybe combined into 1 sunset that had the goals of the pony world sunset. It's a bit of a stretch but it could be possible!

what if human sunset is actually in the pony realm and is hiding away from the main 6? what if the fact that she was a magician made her study the portal from the pony world to the human world? and once finally seeing the pony sunset come out of it, she secretly walked out and ran away from the main 6 secretly without them knowing?

Do you have any idea why mistmane has wavy hair, SHE'S A UNICORN?!!

Human Sunset Shimmer almost happened... Nick Confalone posted on Twitter his pitch for an EqG series finale that was ultimately scrapped in favour of Holidays Unwrapped...

Maybe human!Sunset ran away from home. I mean, it would make sense how our Sunset lives in a nice house (as seen in the Monday Blues music video) if human!Sunset's parents mistook her for their missing daughter. Kinda messed up, but not as bad as her killing her counterpart.

We’ll never since Hasbro ended G4 and cancelled Equestria Girls 😔

i like all of the theories but its also equally likely that the human sunset shimmer does exist somewhere out there in the wide human world but we will never see her because she is living a regular life as just one among literally millions of humans.

Sawtooth: Another area where she feels superior...
Me: murder?!
Sawtooth: maybe musical talent maybe shes the next sapphire shores.
Me: ok good.

One thing Mr. Sawtooth Waves. If Twilight & her friends have human versions, why doesn't STARLIGHT GLIMMER, SUN BURST, DISCORD, PRINCIPLE SINCH/ CINCH FROM THE FRIENDSHIP GAMES, THE VILLAN FROM THE MOVIES WHO WANTED TO BE A STAR, WALL FLOWER & STARSWIRL AND THE PILLARS not have pony or human versions of themselves.

I think like, if the equestria's sunset moved to other place (human place), the other also moved to another place as well. not in a magic way, but just like you said.

I always thought she was human originally and then found Pony world herself.

One of the writers revealed that there were supposed to be an hour long special at the end of season 2..they will finally found out why the magic keeps following them and what happened to the human sunset shimmer.. Sadly the movie was cancelled and we get a shit ending of the series-

Human Sunset lives in Japan. She owns the company that has all the vending machines everywhere. Basically, she runs the country.

I really want to human Sunset shimmer she's one of my favorite Equestria girls. It's ashamed that never happened and I want Equestria girls to come back with a third season with more episodes and specials I still hope this will happen. And I subscribed today. I wonder if human Sunset came will she be evil just like Sunset used to be ?

I considered the possibility that maybe human Sunset Shimmer crossed into the pony universe before the pony Sunset Shimmer crossed into the human universe. Maybe the mirror was in transit on a train and human Sunset Shimmer entered the portal at Canterlot High School as a child. Human Sunset Shimmer has been living as a pony in a small town somewhere ever since. They though she was crazy talking about her old life, so they taught it out of her as a childhood fantasy.

The most likely explanation, however, is that the human counterparts to pony Sunset Shimmer's parents never had the child. Sunset might meet the counterparts of her parents, but not her own counterpart. [Precedent in other franchises: Benjamin Sisko mirror and Jennifer Sisko mirror never had a child, so there is no Jake Sisko mirror.]

We've never met Sunset Shimmer's parents at all.

I like to think she was made for both worlds. Basically the first theory.

I am still AMAZED by Sawtooth's observation skill. Anyway, we don't know anything Sunset's life before becoming Celestia's student. If we did then we could have theoriezed where human Sunset lives. But I think that human Sunset is in another country. She is probably a popular and nice student. And the best musician in the school, also an apprentice of a professional musician. But just like Sawtooth said, she destroyed her chances and ran away to become better.


That's my theory. But I'd love to hear any of your suggestions that could improve my theory 😊😊😊

Here is a theory! Sunset is from the human world originally, and there is a Pony version of her in equestria, not in the human world, I mean it could be a possibility, and Solestia owned the Mirror, plus it would explain her sudden appearance.

I appreciate your theories, but could you please start talking about G5. It is coming this September.

Instead of asking where is the other Sunset Shimmer, maybe it would be a when. Like her counterpart could exist at a different point in time.

Sunset has a real human life but we have never seen sunset in the equestria. So maybe when she was evil she killed her pony self and took it as her place and so on she spreads evil all around the human world

Dr Wolf did a video a while back talking about a planned EQG finale that would address human Sunset and possibly end with pony Sunset saying goodbye to her friends and returning to Equestria permanently to maintain the balance between the two worlds.
Kind of a sad story, but at least it would make for a better ending than the one we got.

Sunset shimmer it’s much older than the Maine six. Like late 20s early 30s
So you wouldn’t find her reflection in a school if anything the appropriate adaptation from her would be her dropping out of school at an early age hint her leaving the school to pursue a different life.

I always thought that
If pony Sunset find her place, happiness and friends in the human world,
Human Sunset will find the same in the pony world.

People are saying that the original finale had Sunset meeting Human Sunset and Human Sunset said she ruined her life.

If this is the case I can see this happening. Sunset did ruin her life to be honest. Sunset turned into a demon that almost killed a few people also the yacht cruise where the whether went crazy due to magic (not her fault). Every incident that involves Sunset goes back to Human Sunset. So becoming a demon that nearly destroyed a school and almost killed people might stop her from getting friends and jobs.

Hopefully Human Sunset is doing well but her social life is probably horrible.

I have three theories.
First one is that Sunset is from the human world but she was an orphan and she slipped into a portal leading to Equestria. Now you may be asking where is pony sunset than and that's were it gets interesting. I think that she was killed in a forest by Timberwolves and the sunset we know was spat out in that forest and later found by the ponies she calls family. I'd like to point out that in the anon a miss story she says she was never close to her family and I think her starting out as an orphan then being transported to another world with talking horses would definitely causes some sort of gap. Which led to her estrangement with her family and the ambition for magic and power.

The second one is a little more simple but equally possible. And that's that human Sunset is a runaway like Sunset. She could have left her home and essentially is travelling around the world and is staying under the radar because that's what runaways do. They stay hidden. The proof is comparing human Twilight to pony twilight. While the difference of what they are after is magic and science the fact remains that they study it feverishly. I think that maybe she ran away to prove something to those she ran away from much like Sunset did. What that something is remains up for debate. It could be art/painting, or it could be music based. Again no one really knows.
The third is much like the first but instead it follows what we know so far with the sunset we do know. So she would be a pony. There we can now focus on human Sunset. In this theory not just human Sunset but her entire family is killed/lost in some sort of accident. While no real proof exists, I would like to point out that if either a human sunset does exist and shes as estranged from her family as pony Sunset than why haven't we seen anything about a missing sunset or have a family member like human sunsets parents or sibling run up to her or something similar in all this time. It's not like Sunset is hiding herself. Shes in a popular band, was in a movie, and was at a rock concert and sung with the idols on stage. That's hard to miss. Which is why it's possible for human sunset and her family to be dead. As well as if she did take over human Sunsets role as found daughter why would she be living in her cheap somewhat rundown apartment alone?
Anyways those are my thoughts on human sunset. Sorry for the long read.

We also don't know whereabouts of human-world Starlight Glimmer. Both of these characters share the similar history of becoming bitter for not getting something or losing something and looking extreme measures to get what they once had. Starlight most likely would pursue the world of politics or education, trying to make everyone "equal". Sunset could have been similar to how Human-Twilight was. Lack of friends and interest in anything else, she pursued science. But her ambitions making her bitter, for not getting anywhere. She is the kind of character that would become a mad, secluded scientist.
Also, both of these characters ended up going far from their homes. One finding an empty area on the far reaches of Equestria and other on whole different world. So both Human Starlight and Sunset would likely be on way different countries.

You all know Sunset wanted to be the "only" Sunset Shimmer and wamted to rule the school and she was a bully. Maybe She did something bad to the human Sunset because Sunshim started to be good. Just turned mean, and in the first EQG movie she said: "Bring me something i could use just like you did to that last girl, who thought she could challenge me.".

I think that human sunset is already an adult. Think about it. Our Sunset was Celestia's student before Twilight therefore she must be older because Twilight has been Celestia's apprentice since she got her cutie mark. Twilight and Sunset would have met before Equestria girls if they were both Celestia's personal students at the same time. Also there's probably a time difference between the two worlds because the mane 6 are young adults during the series. Rarity having her own business and Rainbow Dash being part of a military team definitely makes them all over 18. But they are still in Highschool in the human world. The human world isn't on the same time as Equestria.

I feel it was sunsets destiny to connect the two worlds

1. The original human version of Sunset Shimmer is probably studied very well until she has cross reached the university level. without high school
2. Sunset Shimmer Pony was still a bad person before, so she might have come up with a plan to combine the human Sunset Shimmer with herself and unite her memories.
3. original human Sunset Shimmer was Missing when the Sunset Shimmer Pony appeared. The Sunset Shimmer human parents were delighted and thought this was real Sunset Shimmer

Can we just appreciate the fact that there are so many theories yet Sawtooth analyzed most of them in approximately 5 mins.

My friend’s mom works on friendship is magic and said ‘ sunset was a bad person at first but her of human is lost in the woods’.

My theory of her cutie mark is there are different colors of her mark, so just like you said they are putten as human world and equestria or i dont know how to spell it.



I'm actually curious what cutie mark talent it is 😳

you're missing one simple question it's not where is human Sunset it is when is human Sunset you are forgetting that there's at least a 10 year gap between when's sunset disappeared and when Twilight became Celestia student and now is sunset and Twilight are around the same age there is obviously some kind of time dilation

the "equestrian" sunset is actually sunset from the human world and the real equestrian sunset has just not been seen or spoke about yet?
just theory

I like to think that human sunset goes (or has a chance to go) to equestria to restore the balance. If she's ever found, that is.

okay these is stated briefly in the shows first movie she went to a land where she doesn't exist where magic existence is out of it how ever since twilight was original part of both worlds there are two versions of her but not sunset.

Oh my goodness sawtooth I have been away from your lovely videos for way too long I am finally watching them and I love all of them

I guess Sunset Shimmer didn't have a human counterpart just like Starlight Glimmer. Or their counterparts exists but doesn't live in North America like the others do. Maybe Sunset's human counterpart is European and Starlight's Australian. In that case no lives are ruined or doubled. They both exists but they just doesn't know about each other existence. Unless some student of CHS filmed the Spring Formal incident and posted this video. And when it went viral then....

i feel like im going insane because i have this distinct memory of this extra thing where the actual human sunset shimmer showed up, sorta like how sci-twi did at the end of rainbow rocks, it was just a quick and short thing, but i never saw it again and now that im actually looking for it, it just doesnt exist??

I think it's fun imagining the emphasis of ambition in her character going towards either her graduating high school early and going to college for politics OR as a darker turn she drops out and becomes a crime boss

Theory, imagine if the human one is ironically in the pony one all that time.

That would be hilarious if Equestrian sunset pulled a whole John Carpenter's The Thing

I have a theory that Starlight & Sunset are connected somehow, seeing as neither of them have a otherworld counterpart.

There may be a simpler explanation. Like maybe human Sunset went to live in a different city for example.

Human sunset then the theory that Celestia if she goes into the human realm there's a chance that she won't be able to actually get out of it therefore the thing with the human sunset is she probably did exist but since sunset decided to stay into the human realm instead of the equestrian realm it's probably a side effect of her staying there that her human counterpart is not existent or maybe they just merged together considering the fact that she can stay in both rounds with no problems but when Twilight was in that room she really couldn't do much since she's reliant on her pony form and how she was in her human form yes she was still had some a little bit of magical abilities but considering the fact that her cutie mark is magic you can't really like amp up the power of magic yeah you can just put the crown on yeah that'll give you your magical powers back but it wouldn't really explain how sunset shimmers able to stay there for so long without seeing her counterpart unless her counterpart is her unless she is not just one sunset but two she probably merged with the other sunset just so the state so the universe could stay stable since when the two twilight saw each other they couldn't both be in the same universe so they had to so the Twilight from the from Equestria had to go back and since you can't send a pony into the human realm because they would see their counterpart it probably became unstable for sunset originally therefore I think that the original sunset and the human counterpart of sunset must have merged together so they can stay there at the same time or she's just doesn't exist because or she just died

Failed music career while living in a large active city... ?

Yeah, Sunset probably overdosed on street drugs in a fit of despair and self-pity.

One question..

Is the loop from its about time still going? Could it be that the loop keeps and keeps on creating the same timeline?

Was the question to "where does Sunset live in the human world?" eve been answered?

I'd love it if Isaac Newton the wizard came back from the dead. Physicists would go nuts.

"she does have a nice voice"
sunset : " was that a compliment wow ty ty ikr"

What if they fell into each other's worlds, and this Sunset Shimmer is hiding in Equestria in some corner scared out of her damn mind?

I should have said this a long time ago.
But it was confirmed not everyone in equestria or the human world has a counterpart.
So Sunset most likely doesn’t have a counterpart there.

They should’ve brought her back to Equestria for the season 9 finale......

Or maybe that sunset was the one from the HUMAN world and there's actually no pony world sunset. Think about it, sunset knew about the human world already when she took twilights crown. She knew what the human world was, where the portal was, everything! The mane 6 from the human world even said that sunset was a bully there, so obviously sunset has known about the world for awhile. And in the movie about i think it was the memory stone, when sunset came through the portal to the pony world she was standing on her hind legs trying to hug twilight like a human. Also even if sunset WAS originally from the pony world, you would think we would've seen her around more/met her earlier than In that first movie when she stole the crown right?

And I can't wait to see those two together(if the human one even existed ofc)

wait this channel still exists? oh hell yeah!

You said why would she need a human counter part if she's the hinge between the two worlds, and to that I say every hinge has two parts.

There is a fan fic on wattpad called scars of a last and it sounds like it fits well with this it takes place after the first

It's a shame eqg was cancelled thx to has hasbro since we were very close to see a proper ending with the human sunset shimmer in it but of course hasbro had to cancel it and sadly the only way we'll get a proper ending if it's made by a fan. At least the show had a good fun when it lasted.

Here's what I think when sunset went to the human world she found the house of her human counterpart and convinced her to let her stay and to go to her school for her the human sunset agrees seeing a opportunity to stay at her house and be lazy

We don’t even know most of the Humans from the Human realm such as the light green Girl wearing Stars with purple Shoes 👠 I mean she makes several appearances but will still don’t know her name. I mean do all the Humans have Pony counterparts? This actually rises more Questions than Answers.

Who else thinks it's weird that they keep their Pony colours and it doesn't turn into a normal skin color?

I thought I was the only one that the human sunset will be wearing glasses 🕶️

0:35
Technically, magic came when the portal opened

I’m not sure if there’s the real human Sunset Shimmer or not.

It feels like you just posted yesterday
^_^
I love the weekly upload schedule
:)

I think if there’s another sunset she participates in politics because of her ambitions & strive for power

My theory is that when a pony enters human world and stays for too long, either the pony or human gets deleted from the world

This got me thinking of what if Sunset was originally from Earth but went to ponyville as a child and was so ecstatic by the magic she stayed there and forgot about her human life

If there is a human Sunset, you have to ask about human Starlight Glimmer.

This makes so much scene
Equestria is at realm of magic while Earth (or at less this Earth like realm) is the realm of science and both are two half’s of the same hold, both are connected to each other and share the same yet different inhabitants

God bless you guys, rejoice there’s always something to be happy because, for me it’s Jesus!❤️

Creators of the e.g.: * Forgetting to add Sunset *
Sawtooth: It could be a theory..

RW:there was a movie in the making for hasbro to have another Equestria Girls movie that would've showed The Human Sunset,but sadly the idea was scrapped.😔(couldve been cool though)

She probably ran away from home and found a new life for herself.

Maybe application for the whole episode could be jamming the rest of the weekend Minecraft

Can you please make "Finally solving Derpy" :D

Well the human world doesn't have all of Equarias creatures like Starlight glimmer, Sunburst, Moondancer, the wonderbolts Angelwins,Vaper trail and Sky stinger, Lightning dust and Flurry heart.💖

“That was like if issac newton came back from the dead except it wasn’t him because he was from an alternate world as a wizard.” “Oh that’s about right actually” 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Well, Sunset seems to be in the human world longer than Equestria. What if human Sunset went to Equestria?
This could also explain why she has an unnamed element of harmony...

Can you figure out something about human flurry? We have seen cadence and shinning armour but what about flurry heart?

actually... the crew already ask hasbro if they can make S3 and the ending but hasbro declines idk why tho

I have a little bit of a theory of my own. In equestria, sunset shimmer is/was a student of celestia. What if its the same thing in the human world? What if human sunset shimmer is/was a student of canterlot high? And she got kicked out of the school for doing something wrong just like equestria sunset did? Mabye human sunset discovered the portal and went through to equestria. I propose that human sunset is in equestria AS WE SPEAK plotting her revenge on the human world. There are many flaws to this theory and it's probably not true but it is something fun to think about and kinda builds a suspense and something to look forward to. Mabye the friends will have to battle human sunset in equestria?

Y’all know that the human world isn’t just those 2 schools, it’s like real life. Meaning that the human sunset could be somewhere else in the world

I'm glad that I'm not the only one who still thinks of this. Personally I think Human Sunset does exists, just in a different part in of the Human world. This would make sense, because no one has heard or saw Human Sunset in their known location or the two schools. But it could be possible that there was another school we haven't heard about.

I think maybe the human sunset shimmer lives in a diffrent part of the human world,so that's the reason why we don't see her and only see the equestrian sunset.

To be fair. I just think that "other" human sunset never existed. Maybe just like the dazzlings, she doesn't have a human counterpart. Yes, other theories like she's a runaway, she killed her human counterpart* or her human counterpart is hiding ,make alot of sense but maybe she just didnt have one? or i'm just being dumb and forgetting things-

*this theory is suprisingly believeable, but it scares me since sunset is my 3rd favourite character so i don't like to believe it xD

I have a huge theory. Its not necessarily related to this alot but it is with sunset. Me and my friends used to wonder why sunset wasn't a alicorn but, in the friendship games when she was trying to stop twilight she was a alicorn? I think that Princess Celeste was originally going to make her a alicorn. But since she abandoned her studies she never got that option but it was still within her for the good.

I wonder if she is secretly in the background of one of the equestria girls shorts

I heared that the ending of the Equestria Girls seires was supposed to end with a movie where we meet the original Sunset, and pony Sunset must face that she stole the life of someone!

I have a question
if celestia and luna are sisters then it's love that keeps them together...THEN WHY DID THEY'RE CROWNS MAKE FRIENDSHIP? Shouldn't it be love?

The cutie mark theory sounds the most logical to me becuse look at her cutie mark change the brightest to white and the darkest to black the colur is the black and white make the same form as hers and you got ying and yang when u think about that or good versus evil they both need each other and take that with her mark it fits well human and eqeustria one canot exist with the other in the friendship games i bet eqeustria got destroyed a bit too i bet so makes sense to me.

Another point in this question where is Human Starlight Glimmer? We saw her come to the Human world in EQ Girls: Magic Mirror where Sunset states she never seen her there

Wasn't there a short where she actually meets her human version

Hey sawtooth,
I asked this question on Google and it said that since sunset shimmer took human sunset's place in the human world human sunset is trying to make pony sunset's life as miserable as possible.....

Are we not going to bring up how we have seen Sunsets room and house? When Twight light came she left in the library so where did she get this house?

It has already been confirmed that the sounset slimmer of the human world is still alive and hiba will appear on season 3 of equestria girls before being canceled

I think that sunset's life is a musician and being smart at any project and i think she dropted out of school just like the equestria sunset....

Why does Human Twilight have wings when in the pony world she's a unicorn. She might as well lose the wings since she's technically not an alicorn.

I've been thinking this too! Like shes the only one without another form of herself.

yes just like twilight met her human form maybe she also is a crystal prep student and intends to look all that is more out there maybe she is also inocent oo or maybe the pony sun set is actualy a human who goes to equestrian world

Well maybe the human sunset was once in crystal prep even before Twilight and when she didn't get what she want probably into being a student president or something. And she decided to abandon her study and went to canterlot high and fell into the portal by accident or found another portal and when she was there she transferred to another school and try to conquer that one. I say this because in the first Equestria girls movie, the storyline is pretty similar from MLP S1 on how Twilight met the other mane 5

Idk why but this is my thought;
Ya'll know how starlight and twilight are close, well so is sunset and twilight and both sunset and starlight seem kinda the same from my pov. So what I think is that sunset might be starlight human version. Ik it sounds stupid because like we already saw a human version of starlight and pony version of sunset but what if sunset was always a human? And it may be that sunset is a AU of starlight that just happens to join the original star light's world and they just happen to not notice that. Idk but this is just my thought

I’ve always wondered the answer to this question and I’m glad the video answers it.

So now I’m just wondering, in the first movie sunset’s aura was teal and in spring breakdown her aura was red

What if the Equestria Sunset was there long enough for them to like- merge together as one-

Going back to Sunset killing her human self. Yes she didn't use physical harm on anyone but she caused a lot of mental harm. This is just little dark, but if the possibility of Sunset killing her human self is there... could she have bullied her into suicide?

Wow...I miss Sunset.

i like the theory that there is no second Sunset, i like to see her as Connection between the worlds. It matches so perfectly to her cutie mark

I questioned this for YEARS AND NOW I HAVE A ANSWER

sunset is the only pony that doesn't have a human version ,she connects both of the worlds together , so there's only one sunset shimmer between two worlds there can't be two.( think that's what EQG means before

I don't really know but i would think maby her counter part would be a failed musician like you said. But if she is she is not a failed one she may have just lived in a country with not much communication but you may be right on her not having a counter part.

There is no way that the human sunset was killed!
Where did you come up with that idea anyway?

1. pony sunset killed her human counterpart? if she did, she'll have a HUGE regret and probably told the humane 5 that she already killed the human her during or before "rainbow rocks" when she beginning to redeem herself.

2. i assume the human sunset would have been in high school like the humane 7 as of the last one aired.

what i think is that the human sunset shimmer is in a different location near or far from the cusd (canterlot unified school district) and go to a different school district and probably your average smart teen girl.

the human starswirl might have been real and live long to make a impact on science.

the thing about "friendship is magic" and "equestria girls" connecting to each other - is that hasbro and the creators never reference the mirror portal on both series, but in books only.

assume that pony starswirl created the mirror, he might have used to eavesdrop on the sirens (from rainbow rocks) in the human world after their banished by the pillars of equestria - some how transport any creatures in modern equestria to modern earth, right where canterlot high is at.

in the "fall of sunset shimmer", the mirror was already there and was never explain it's origins much either.

so in my ending, human sunset show up at the end of junior year at CHS as a average transfer student, pony sunset feel homesick for equestria, give her magic ability to her human counterpart and says "goodbye" (not a "goodbye" goodbye but a goodbye until next time (like pony twilight said once) to her human counterpart and the humane 6 and also give the magic book she has to them, so they can "chat" with her and their own pony counterparts (which i'm thinking of a actual 30 minute tv series with a 1 hr. special of themselves acting like their counterparts (humane 7 in equestria acting like their pony counterpart while the mane 7 (yes, i consider pony sunset as a 7th member, even she doesn't have a element - act like the human counterparts) in each other's universe, act kind of badly until night time and switch back, but have fun doing so.

Be great see ponie meeting humans in same demention.

My headcanon is a bit boring but logical nonetheless. She was a student to Princess Celestia prior to Twilight so maybe she's a bit older in the human world (and maybe the pony world too). Since Sunset Shimmer was a student of Princess Celestia, I like to think she is naturally smart and the human version of her got into a very prestigious college somewhere far away. This headcanon will only work if she studied in Crystal Prep and never met Principal Celestia and human Twilight, of course.

What is the name of the music at the very beginning? It sounds super familiar.

What about the human version of Queen Chrysalis🤔🤨

Personally, I've always thought Sunset was pretty bad even pre-reformation. Given what we've seen in Equestria, ambition and lust for power can lead to some pretty nasty things. Especially because demon sunset, if I remember correctly, said she had planned on conquering Equestria. Compared to that, killing a single person is not really a big deal, as I don't think she'd act like Tirek did and just yeet the princesses into Tartarus. Besides, it seems likely to me that she's been involved in shady human world dealings as her job is as the waitress of a sushi place, yet she owns a pretty nice looking house and appears to have plenty of money.

Also, it just occurred to me that human world Gummy is a plush toy...yet he's a living animal in Equestria who speculates on the nature of life and the reason of existence...????

literally been wondering this all of my life

maybe she could've just merge with her human counterpart.

I always thought that the human Sunset went to the pony world, just like Sunset from the pony world went to the human world.

Human Sunset Shimmer probably went somewhere in Equestria and hid there, like how Pony Sunset Shimmer hid in the human world idk

We rarely see parents and their children together. You know why?
IT'S BECUSE PARENTS DON'T WATCH OR CAN'T IMAGINE THEMSELVES IN THE SHOW!! BRUHHHH!!!!

My theory is that the human sunset goes missing before our sunset goes in, so the pony took the place of the human one and gone more mad only for the comparations betwen them

There’s another problem to we never see glamorous glimmer as well if that’s how you spell it we see her pony self but not her counter part I mean we did see how she would look like but that still was just her pony self turned into her counter part same goes for sun set shimmer maybe they are STILL THERE but aren’t in the same place as the other counter parts are

Well Sunset is probably older than main Twilight by at least a year in Equestria. I had just assumed human Sunset was older than the Equestria Girls and in college.

I think we already have met human sunset! My guess is that the human sunset is on the videos of eg (postcrush episodes, etc…)

You forgot to mention that scene where Pinkie told Sunset she saw someone like her in a different town.

I think the first idea about her basically being the life of the human world and without her human world is… dead world or whatever

😍 love it

There was actually confirmed to be a scrapped special focused on Sunset Shimmer and what happened to the human Sunset, and what happened was actually very sad, but of course, it was a scrapped idea so it isn't entirely canon, if you want to find it it was a post by one of the producers named Nick Confalone

I honestly think, since Sunset is from the pony world but lives in the human world, human Sunset is now living in the pony world

Maybe she somehow ended up in equestria. Hahaha there’s soooooo many possibilities

My question is how is human Luna and Celestia still alive, if the human and pony counterparts are the same age

Well as far as i know the EQG series has not offically been ended so maybe one day we might find out.

If Sunset was good at magic in Equestria, I don't think Human Sunset would be good at music. Maybe she would be a mad scientist because pony Sunset was a rogue magic student.

Pony world Sunset was a student of Celestia at the magic school & then jumped into a magic mirror & went to the human world where she found herself just outside a human high school. However I should be noted that Twilight never met Sunset at the school, it may have been because she always had her nose in a book however what is Sunset was several years older? Maybe humen Sunset has graduated high school & gone on to take a job or is in college? That would suggest a few things
Either pony Sunset did not enroll in high school right away or the mane 5 (of both worlds) are a little older then the Twilights (that would be why human Twilight took so long to take the stage)
Just my thoughts & probably full of holes

maybe sunsets original counterpart found out about Equestria so she travled there and is secretly plotting revenger for bing mistreated in the human world

I like to think that the human sunset is just dead... makes sure questions don't bother me.

Does Exiled Kingdom allow its sounds track as freeware? Loved the video and the Exiled Kingdom sounds track.

FINALLY SOMEONE WHO DID THIS I WAS WAITHING FOR THIS FOR 5 YEARS

Theorie: Maby the human sunset one day discoverd the magical World. Orverwelmed by the magic she wanted to Also have the magic in the human World. That's when she discoverd pony Sunset, even tho human sunset didnt know anything about her Powers she challanged pony sunset to a duel. Pony sunset Was confused seeing herself and she lost the duel. That night human sunset stole twilights crown. And everything begann like that.

Sucks the series was canceled 'cause we woulda gotten the answer to this question. No, seriously, look it up. They were gonna end "Equestria Girls" Season 2 with a special with the main plot being finding out what happened to Human Sunset.

She’s one of my waifus

What if the human sunset shimmer is the sunset shimmer we see.? Maybe a while ago human sunset shimmer went into equestria to steal some magic to take back home. But, she gets caught going back to the human world, and you know the rest. But I guess then that brings up the question: where’s pony sunset shimmer? I don’t really know. I guess she could be somewhere in equestria where she can have as much power and magic as she wants. Maybe like a starlight glimmer situation with a village? Then she could keep and control the magic there.

Maybe Human Sunset died of something ? Idk \
Or maybe she was in hiding after seeing Sunset's mistake in the EQG 1st part.
She might not wanna be called a doppelganger

Well, let's think logic...
Sunset traveled between the 2 worlds... but if there is a 3rd world were the human Sunset lives... this theory may change the hole mentality about my little pony...

Can you do a video on the unseen lands in MLP?

But imagine the real human sunset was learning to go to equestria and she did just like her other self.

I have a question!!! How come when the girls transform Fluttershy and Rainbowdash get their wings but Rarity and Twilight don't get their horns?!?!? I have theories but it still doesn't make sense🤔

so sunset is the avatar of the mlp universe? i like that theory ahaha

What about a human discord?
Could he be around somewhere
If so what would he look like? 🤔

Blopsie. Let’s see. Maybe if we dig into the human world Twilight, who might know the unknown Sunset, we could find her. Please have a video like this, Sawtooth.

I have a theory but it was proven wrong in the friendship games ending

Do you think it's like the time travelling rule where seeing your past could cause disappearing not death but maybe teleporting to a void I mean tawog uncle grandpa and regular show have a void

Maybe she's hiding in Tokyo ,where she's living with a person with the same name as hers and the she's the lead vocalist of a band while being in a relationship with the a guitarist that plays for another band.

Hint Hint: Anime Series, Rebecca Shoichet and Kelly Sheridan

yk what i thought at first,that human sunset came to equestria.but then i thought that wouldnt we see her?so i threw that thought away.
now i think this..
we only met human twiliight because her school and the school of main six had a connection.
otherwise we would have never seen her,maybe thats the case?that where human sunset lives,theres no connection between the school of main six,thus we havnt seen her.
so basically,we havent seen her because she dosent live near,or has any connection with the main six./thier.

I soo wish there was a human sunset. The question that I didn't get an answer is how did sunset knows this much about the human world 🤔🤔supious 😕

in that question " what would her life look like?" i might have a guess i think it is like Sci-Itiw's life

I think is that in one of the shows when she goes back goes back to ponyville grill quick she gets the book but she's like human human still cause she doesn't know how to walk as pony homie so I think that's the solution she probably gave the Crown to the real human version of themselves but the other version just goes back

I think there's one more probability. I think that human sunset know about alternative world too. And both of Sunsets go through the portal at the same time. And they're be one Sunset only.

Pretty sure I saw something on Google about a Equestria Girls Sunset Horizon two-parter and supposed to focus on human world sunset

It could also be possible that the human sunset shimmer is a ambitious gamer since the pony sunset shimmer loves playing video games so there could be a connection there.

If sunset killed the real one wouldn’t they have thought oh no sunset was into studying wasn’t she cause of the glasses and book and how come she doesn’t need glasses also when u said she killed her was she nice kind or was she rude and selfish wouldn’t they notice the difference between them? Ok bye now thank u for listening

Let me introduce fan fiction. Also I think maybe the human world sunset was principal celestias daughter but she died when sunset came to the human world, as for how she died. Leave it up to imagination.

I knew that the at least one theory was that evil Sunset murked her reflection lmao

video idea:do you think king sombra could be reformed??

She actually is a princess in her other life & look for her lost little sister Sunrise Glitter The Sunrise Princess.

She must be looking like half twilight and half sunset

the theory that our sunset killed human sunset is so messed up and i love it

Also, the way the description was worded.

"Where is she hiding...?


My PATREON!"

If she was celestia's pupil when Twilight was still a kid wouldn't that make her way older than Twilight.
If so why is she the same age in the human world?????

Im probably going to sound stupid for this but my question is, Starswirl banished the sirens to the human world, so naturally there would be another sunset, she introduced magic, yes, but shouldnt she still have a counterpart, considering how long the world existed? Please correct me if Im wrong btw

I have a theory that maybe there can only one Sunset exist in the same world. Maybe after a long time when Sunset was in the human world, the one that truly belonged in human world disappeared or something? Maybe universe thought that they can be only one of them in the same world and deleted the first one from existence? We know that Pony Twilight and Human Twilight met, but there weren't 2 Twilights in one world for a long time

Everyone has waited so long for this, great video!

Wow I like the human style of sunset

Then does Starlight Glimmer have a human counterpart?

What if Sunset Shimmer went through the portal to Equestria? In the movie it never explained how Sunset Shimmer knew about the portal to another world. Maybe human Sunset Shimmer found out about it before human Twilight did & she went to Equestria. Plus the mane 6 are literally the same ppl from Equestria & the human world with the same personality & mindset so if Sunset Shimmer went to the human world then why wouldn't human Sunset go to Equestria. I can't come up with a better theory but what if the answer is just so simple

TO BE HONEST I ALWAYS WONDER IS THERE IS A HUMAN VERSION OF SUNSET SHIMMER AND I THINK THERE IS THAT WE HAVE NEVER SEEN BEFORE

2:40 - 2:56 made me laugh so much my family thinks im crazy btw love the video^^

So shes a non-elemental avatar, the one that bridge the two world -the four elements

Well like maybe Human Sunset was like well there but not entirely so here’s my guess what if the sunset was in a different place but when sunset leaves there’s only one sunset left so yeah but Sawtooth just might be right about human Sunset

I don’t think the theory about sunset killing the human version of her would be true because this is a show mainly made for kids
(Not saying it’s not for everyone I’m just saying that kids watch the show too probably more than older people do)

K but like how could you even consider the possibility of Sunset killing her human counterpart? This is a kids show. They literally couldn’t make that canon.

"Is there a human Sunset Shimmer?"

OH MY GOD someone finally said it! Thank you! I was thinking I was the only one!

If she did have a counter part wasnt a part of her pony info that she was celestias student BEFORE Twighlight so wouldn't human sunset have possibly gone to crystal prep (like twighlight?) and then just graduated and possibly moved out of town or just lives somewhere. Unless human sunset took pony sunset IN and thats where she has been living. This would also explain all the timeliine differences between the world?
But thats just another theory XD

The only logical explanation is that her human counterpart is somewhere out there in the human world or maybe Hoboken

Biggest plot hole for me is she’s supposedly older then twilight as celestia says sunset was her original student, then he banished her to the human world and twilight came a few years later. Sunset was already older, plus twilight was a kid when she started learning under celestia. Buttttttt somehow she’s only in high school..? Wouldn’t she be well into college or even out of college by the time twilight shows up in the human world??! That’s the biggest thing to me that doesn’t make sense is the aging thing!

She could have moved to a different country or place 🤷‍♀️

And since your doing a video on this: where is starlight glimers counter part, she should have a human form, heck she's even more powerful then twilight past the whole " frenship" .In other words
She has more magic that doesn't come from friendship. And why is sunset, twilight and starlight have similar names, cute marks, and personalities? Do they have some sherd destiny or something. and have you watched the new mlp trailer, and what do you think?

i have a theory that sunset shimmer was actually from the human world, and theres a pony counterpart to human sunset, not a human counterpart to pony sunset

I think the other sunset shimmer is studying in the other school, and i think she has the personality as same as original sunset shimmer, maybe (sorry about my English because I'm Vietnamese ).

who says that other sunset shimmer couldn't be in equestria?

Possibly an unpopular opinion but- I feel like sunshine shimmer is a way more important character than anyone realizes. Sometimes she feels more important than the mane six. But here me out first- Throughout all of the EG movies except the first where shimmer went all she-demon, she tends to be the one friend who has everyone's back even when being treated like shit, always the one to be the most understanding of all characters, and seems to have the most empathy out of them all. And as a matter of fact while watching Rainbow Rocks and Legend of Everfree, I even thought to myself how I feel like Sunset Shimmer is the one who truly harnesses the magic of friendship. She's the one they needed to help defeat the sirens. She was the one to follow human Twilight to see what was bothering her when she was worried about the magic she was experiencing. She was always there at every step when something went awry. What are your thoughts?
Edit: I just remembered something after posting but, in Rainbow Rocks, even though the mane six together have the magic of friendship, I remember finding it so odd that Sunset Shimmer out of all of them- (especially after once being a one of the meanest people) was the only one to see that they were all falling for the sirens' tricks and trying to make them all bicker with each other and spread negative magic. She was the only one to notice the energy rising to the sirens. Shimmer is definitely super powerful imo. Even though she says she still has a lot to learn about friendship, I think the characters have a lot to learn from her.

You should turn your Ninth Timeline video into a fanfic where future Twilight, Starlight & Spike discover this.

The sunset pony version is starlight glimmer and they make this obivious in a soft way, she is the day, starlight the night, sunset is more like celestia, starlight like luna, they don't have human versions and she is human and starlight pony

Sawtooth chill- getting kinda deep there 😳

My thoughts are sense the universes sense yes without magic to influence her life like our sunset she could have been science or magic

But take in mind are sunset had a fall out with celectia and ran away but ares was a pony turned to human through the magic portal mirror, but real original human sunset wouldn't have the advantage of magic and portals so she simply left the school hence like are sunsets running away and or she moved away

Are sunset is in reality actually a pony not really a human (but can be) she had a very magical redemption Ark but the difference between are sunset and actual human sunset was that are twilight and human main 6 were there to guide her in the right direction and help her
Human sunset wouldn't have that because again the human main 6 were involved with are sunset which in a way changed human sunsets fate and or destiny to some degree

Maybe our sunset convinced the other one to take her place in equestria lol

Alt take: whoever they are probably adapted a different name and transitoned. You never know ;)

Fun Fact🦄!The MlP country Equestria is the name of the Equestria girls show world.

She might live in another city and would probably be like demon sunset

What if Human Sunset is actually in Equestria and found one of those portals like that one in the cave on the island

I've read there was supposed to be the third season of EQG featuring the human Sunset Shimmer, but it didn't get off the ground.

If Sunset Shimmer likes to feel superior and is full of pride than I think she would be in a gang like Mafia or at least the leader of one

Or Sunset Is the human one!
She traveled to Equestria and lived there came back and wanted to unite both worlds cause..
(Cutiemark) defines human world and Equestria.
I mean, she Told about the human world to the ponies.

What if star swirl the bearded the protogue of gusty the great like
1 celestia and luna with star swirl
2 twilight with celestia
3 luster dawn with twilight
Now we have a full line of mentors and succession and it perfectly fit equestria's time line and history we don't know much about grogar it is ironic that gusty banished grogar thought star swirl .start swirl thought celestia and banished pony of shadows celestia banished night mare moon and

The cutie mark theory is ✨ A big possible and might be the answer 😍➕💪

one day they will make a episode of the other Sunset Shimmer

the theory of pony sunset killing her human self is a bit of a shock to some but it fills all the dark holes in the question of it...

When he said “maybe he killed the other sunset” but then I just thought omg 😱 sunset shimmer was prom queen for years but how could that happened didn’t she just go through the portal I mean maybe once or twice but for years what if the human sunset did die

2015 Swatooth explaing how to close human world portal by placing both Twilights opposite realm as the Sunsets.

I'm confused on how Twilight didn't upset the balance like how Celestia said the main 6 couldn't go with her because of their human counterparts was it because Twilight's human counterpart wasn't friends with the human main 6????

What makes the most sense about this is that, just like in Equestria, Human Sunset could have dropped out of school. I feel like murder is too far for a kids show lol

Well Starlight Glimmer doesn’t have a human counterpart, so mabey Sunset Shimmer doesn’t have one either?

I could've sworn there was an episode of her literally kidnapping her human self and just leaving her someplace. I think it was just a weird ass dream though, but it makes sense 2 me

Now, I' m scared for this character...

Sawtooth: Another area where she feels superior...
Me: murder?!
Sawtooth: maybe musical talent maybe shes the next sapphire shores.
Me: ok good.

There's only one sunset,mainly because she's not from Equestria but from earth

I never even thought one time if there was a human sunset shimmer

more likely biological human sunset shimmer is far enough away that we hadn't encounter the biological human sunset shimmer

I’ve always thought about the other sunset but I thought maybe she’s dead or maybe her human self lives in a different country.

I read somewhere that some people don’t have a Human Counterpart, I’m not sure if it was confirmed or not but I’m sure it explains something,I’m really not sure, it was ages ago it was from the mlp
Wiki fandom

I think that the real human sunset is like pony sunset shimmer, maybe she was in another school far away she was a very good student and loved her studies. But then just like pony sunset human sunset wanted power and so she ran away and ‘till this day she is hiding somewhere where no one can ever find her trying to find a way to get all the magic in power in the world but unlike pony sunset human sunset has not changed her bad ways and has no friends………over time she has been forgotten by all humanity but human sunset promised herself one day she would return into the actual human world and out of hiding seeking revenge……..


But that’s just my theory but in my opinion it would be a good one

I dunno about Sunset and killing, but I think that Sunset could be keeping her human self locked in a jail or something

maybe she moved away, similar to how pony sunset moved away from equestria?

What if…? Human sunset is in the pony world? Like she passed through the same that sunset passed and find a way to equestria? The other possibility is that considering that the human world is a little bit in the past (idk if someone apart of me realized that) maybe human sunset is on school and all that equestria sunset passed haven’t pass to her yet?

The possibilities really are endless, but I have a theory that human Sunset might be in jail for something. I know it doesn't really make sense lmao

So…is Starlight similar to Sunset that she has no human counterpart? Or is she a homeschool human?

Human sunset could have been trying to make magic and a experiment went wrong and killed her.

Could she be in the government, state governor, or principle assistant? As you said she is power hunger and pony Sunset Shimmer was close to Celestia. So could see be a retired vice president, state governor, or principle assistant.

Ok so this might be crazy but one thing that is connected to sunset it well the sunset in one of the movies there’s twilight and there’s also a sunset I think sunset might not have killed human sunset but she might have captured her and hidden her so no one could ever hear from human sunset just a theory

2:13 you forgot someone named
Starlight glimmer

I think, just like the original sunset shimmer, she maybe ran away from her home to another city, maybe even country. because I think there is a sunset shimmer like everyone else.

if Sunset has no human counterpart then she is not the only one I mean baby Flurry and Starlight Glimmer don't have a human counterpart

Maybe when sunset turned into a demon she became a part of the human sunset and they became one person

Magic = knowledge

Ooh! I never thought about this!

this is what I asking myself when I started to watch the Equestria girls .,.

Maybe there is I am not sure but I believe if I saw every movie with her in it I think there would be a human sunset

Love that possible Mirai Nikki reference

I knew this literally as I watched it I never really questioned that

There was a finale planned with Human Sunset being the focus and we see how her life was unintentionally ruined by Pony Sunset and after they meet and clash, Pony Sunset, filled with regret, would return to Equestria, the portal would be closed and magic removed from the human world. All of which happening permanently. But since the show was ending, S9 their sole focus and G5 production soon in full swing, this big finale was scrapped. So the best we fans can get is to put the finale together ourselves. But who knows?

They should totally find the other sunset shimmer but she’ll be evil and she captures someone and turns them evil that would be amazing

Idea for video: Is there a sun𝗥𝗜𝗦𝗘 shimmer?

I guess, as this sunset belongs to equestria and came to human world then the sunset of the human world would have came to equestria!

Part os sunset is her drive to break barriers. I'm sure human realm sunset is in the pony realm somehow

1. Do why Human Twilight has wings when she ponys up but as a pony she’s a unicorn and
2. Human Sunset is probably from Crystal Prep, or she just goes to another school. Another possibility is Sunset Shimmer was just a normal person that’s definitely not Sunset Shimmer but she saw a pretty girl in the school who was the original human Sunset and that was from Sunset’s first ever visit to the human world. She wanted to look so much like the pretty girl so she tried to take her place. She got so mad on how pretty she was and how Sunset was so plain and boring so she did some science and their bodies swapped and now she was living the the human Sunset’s body and she wanted to see the effects on her in the pony world so she went there and she was just like the original Human Sunset. Here’s probably another one. She was at the human world and saw someone who was her, basically. She was nice and friendly but mean pony Sunset was mad she looked like her so she got her kicked out by pretending to be her and she had to stay at her house but she decided to go to Crystal Prep and met some other ones but the bus crashed and everyone on the bus were never to be seen again. Those were some of the original students at crystal prep who don’t appear in the Friendship Games movie because of their disappearance. Pony sunset stole twilight’s crown and all of the things that happened from the EG movies happened.

I feel like I have seen both of the sunsets in the thumbnail I think the one on the left is the movie one and the one on the right is maybe another version of her from a different movie and the tv show idk both of them seem familiar and that’s not just bc there the same person

what if sunset was actually only human? and maybe we should actually be asking if there is a pony sunset?

I have a theory that same as pony sunset, the human sunset is in the other world.

maybe sunset is like starlight since she also doesn't have a human counterpart in the human world

And question. Where's is human starlight? where is the original human starlight?

i like to think that she's older and moved to another city

SO FOR ANSWERING THE QUESTION!! (Sorry little hyped up. Some things might not make sense cause of ideas bouncing at each other) So I think if there is a original Sunset Shimmer in the human world. I just think she will be just...either a one rockstar with alot of energy and curiosity.Or She will be a bully delinquent. (i can't do fashion sorry.) Also.The Cutie mark thing was very clever. I didn't realize it but just now! Sunset Shimmer is the one who DISCOVERED the whole new world. Because she was that curious. Okay i am done bYEe

I mean pony sunset left celestia’s school, so perhaps the human sunset also left. This could be why we’ve never seen her.

She knew that pinkie pie had the portal behind the scenes cartoon, I think sunset and the other sunset shimmer were constantly swapping places in the pony world

I’ve been eating for a whole week for him to post

My theory is that the other Sunset Shimmer is in the pony world but grew up in the human world. Opposte to our Sunset Shimmer

Ok all the theories tha sawtooth made is really making soo much sense to me

Maybe hear me out, what if human Sunset died of illness, like the killed theory it solves many plot holes, and she could also live far away, like how we don't know, where our Sunset grew up maybe that is where she lived and died

This is a stretch i know
But what if
Human sunset IS pony sunset
Human sunset made a life in the pony and convinced everyone she was from the pony world and when she went to “another” world she actually went to her home world
We just dont know where the pony sunset is

WOW FINALLY !!!!

What if the sunset we know is actually from the human world and she found her way to the pony world and pretended to be a pony and learn magic and the real pony sunset lives somewhere in equestria

HOLY SWEET CELESTIA YOUR RIGHT!!!

Wasn't she originally from the human world?

Can you make a video about what happens to twilight's owl?

I never even think about it 😩

Idk if anyone remebers but in the song release the magic song the professor say somthing about only having a few students like twilight and they always but the good ones always leave, maybe one of those was sunset

If you look at the equestria shorts it's shown a human counter parts I saw in a YouTube video of sun set other than her pony self

Maybe she is in other dimension,like she traveled before

Is there gonna be any more Equestria Girls episodes or movies??

Finally another video

One thing I am thinking about (I know I am late here) is that is the pony version of sunset killed the human version, would it some how make a ripple affect in a time line some how. (Don't know if some one or a group brought this up in any way, as I said I am sorry if I'm late)

What about Starlight Glimmer's human counterpart? 🤔

Hasbro: Write that down write that down

Or what if we are asking the wrong question maybe we should be asking where is the pony version of her what if the one we knew was originally the human version 🤔

Well enter dimensional traveler with only one counterpart that's technically impossible because every dimension must have another counterpart that's how the multiverse works

one question i have is if the human pony are there pony counter parts then why are the human pony alot more younger and if the pony version of the main six have kids then does those that mean the human version have kids to? and if twilight is immortal then does that mean human twilight is immortal since we know that the human world also has magic ;-;

Sunset is a little stubborn. FREINDSHIP IS TRUE. It is very IMPORTANT, Twilight Deserves to be the queen of equestria.

I think she lives in another Town and is more like a young cutthroat business person. They’ll all about money and power.

The max brain level: 100. sawtooths brain level: 10000

Video request: Why is human Twilight an alicorn? Netflix posted new equestria girls episodes named canterlot high tales, in the episode 1: dance magic, Twilight turns into human-pony which makes her have ears and ALICORN wings. So your telling me that if for example Applejack turns into an alicorn her human version will to? Or did human Twilight actually did something to earn those wings? And why wasn't she an alicorn when in that cruce thing movie she want to equestria?Please copy paste my comment se cause it's interesting to think that a human Twilight and pony Twilight are different

Let’s be honest we guys watched my little pony 😂

I want to ask how would ponies communicate if a pony is born deaf or mute

wait what about the question if sunset IS her human form?

Sawtooth: Theirs an idea floating around that the equestrian sunset killed the human sunset and took her place
Me:……..yeah I don’t think her evil self would do that, sure she bullied/terrorized an entire school but I don’t think she went as far as killing anybody

I Agree Because There Might Have Been A Original Sunset (H) And I Have A Theory: What If Original Sunset And Original Twilight Sparkle GoTo The Same School Together Because I Saw A Crystal Prep Unform On Original Sunset

What if... Twilight Sparkle meet the Dazzlings first instead of Sunset Shimmer?

Heh I was honestly thinking a gamer for Sunset. It would fit her angry and stuck up mindset and pony sunset is known to love playing video games with Dash so…

This was also my question in my head for a long time now good thing i saw ur video

First❤️

Edit: have a good day everyone❤️

edit 2: whos wondering if a another sunset exist?

Pues a veces pienso que no hizo un viaje a otra dimensión si no un viaje en el tiempo donde los ponis evolucionaron

Everyone has a different home the same might be for human Sunset

Maybe she doesn't have a human counterpart because she was originally human and one day she discovered the mirror and just got wrapped up into the pony world

Ima just say it there might be four tribes earth,sky,magic and the crystal ponys!!!!!!!!

Fun fact ~everyone is Early here until the refresh

I honestly thought that there wasn't a human sunset because she WAS the human sunset I'm not sure probably not

Of course there's an human sunset

Do you remember the the movie of the games between the schools and ,her powers got sucked up through the portal which means that is her cutie mark

I think she IS the orginal, i mean the world has never had a person come from another world before.

1:30 that got dark😭

what if the sunset shimmer from the human world found a portal to a different world other than equestria.

🧡💛❤️🌅

i agree with the fact that pony sunset wouldn't kill human sunset but i wouldn't put it past her to therein human sunset maybe she threaten to do something mager if human sun set didn't move away so she did and pony sunset took her place

people always ask wheres human sunset but never hows human sunset 😔😔😔

Did anyone else see the "my little pony next-generation official trailer"LIKE WHAT DID THEY DO TO MLP

I WAS THINKING THIS FOR 1 DAY AGO AND AFTER I WATCH THE MOVIE "Mirror Magic" I JUST REALIZED THAT SUNSET DONT HAVE A HUMAN SIDE LIKE STARLIGHT🤨?

Human Sunset may not even live on the same continent. Who knows

FINALLY!! SOMEONE SAID IT--

Human twilight is based on his past, studying

There's a chance she's in another country

Sawtooth Waves I have a conclusion so you know how twilight got into celesta school sunset wanted to do it to so let me explain twilight is trying to hatch the egg rainbow dash does a sonic rainboom shocks twilight and sunset to try out there thing twilight does it and gets its cutie mark sunset gets her cutie mark the shock on her she almost makes it but messes up cause her shock was bigger which made it worse but twilight had the perfect amount to get her to work so sunset had to try all the things all over again this happened for a long time of hard work she failed and failed but didn't stop her the time when twilight was asked to make new friends this is the time when sunset gave up she thought that knowledge was useless and thought power is what she needed but the other half of her didn't accept don't stop now we can make it just give it a try this is the same thing is happening in the human world this is the time when they splited up the human sunset choosed knowledge while sunset pony choosed power they haved got what they wanted now the next thing that pony sunset was planning for is twilight crown cause she knew that she would probably get it so she planned for weeks until she got it 2 weeks and then when it was night time she swapped out the crown with a fake one but when she got into the portal she known that there was a human of herself so she pretended to be her so she made a fake picture of her exam to get in the school she saw celesta and showed her she thought it was real so she got rolled in but she lost the crown so maybe her crown was to celesta she thought i have to get it so i can be powerful now twilight realized her crown was fake so she knew that someone took it but where then she remembered that she woke up and saw a shadow but when't back to sleep now she thought of something the portal was opened last night someone have been through thats probably why i woke up so she planned that she will go into the portal but the rest of the main six wanted to come but she said that theres probably 2 of you guys so she said that I will be back she went through now she was human she was scared of herself and realized spike is a dog now she went into the school and saw something she signed up so she could get her crown back later on she made friends and when she told them that she needs help to get that crown back they planned to get it and when the day arrived she did her thing when the accounments we're about to be told celesta said twilight sparkle so sunset shimmer that wasn't true she thought if i can't earn it i will take it she wen't up to twilight to snatch her crown she got it put it on her head and transformed into sunset demon but the power of the main six she got defeated by them she said sorry and didn't actually know what friendship was now she cleaned up her mess and starting learning friendship but after that she forgot what she decided and pretend that she was the human sunset shimmer she left behind what she while the other sunset shimmer is keep trying to make it and learned friendship thats all sawtooth waves

Alicorn Sunset Shimmer theory video: Princess of Harmony (yin yang cutiemark sunset version omg!!!)

Okay but what if human Sunset went to the pony world-

after a while i been think of it i been realise some couples in the two world are not the same SO maybe the human sunset never been born i gonna take a non canon exemple in the pony world a.j and r.d are such a couple compare to the human world where instead a.j and rarity are such a couple (again this is not canon this was just an exemple) so if some couples are different in the both world this could mean maybe sunset never been exist in the human world what do you think ?

Hi

What if the world was created due to sunset coming there that’s why she’s the one and only.

Day 5 of asking sawtooth to talk about zecora and a possible zebra society

Theory- I think that there is no human sunset, I mean.. look at all the humans in the school and the ponies in equestria! Not all humans have a pony counter-part. Sunset could be one of the ones who doesn't have a HUMAN counter-part. Or perhaps she lives far away from the human main six. BUT HEY, THAT'S JUST A THEORY.

Isn't magic a bit like science in away

i always thought that she would be jail as she was never reformed.

I think the switched places.human Sunset could be in somewhere of Equestria.

I’m pretty sure the there is a human sunset cause when I watch the third equestria girls movie when twilight looked at sunset her face made me think the she was saying “how is sunset shimmer at CHS” and that made me think that there is a human sunset

Originally they said they were gonna do an episode on the original Sunset Shinmer but it never happened which is sad

So basically she's the avatar

OK so from the very beginning and your headcanon that she tied the worlds together that is complete bullshit. There is confirmed by Starswirl to be an infinite amount of worlds, some having the same characters but different, others having completely different characters. That is all.

There is no Starlight Glimmer either so maybe Starlight is the pony version of Sunset and Sunset is the human version of Starlight

What if real human sunset shimmer did the exact same thing as the pony sunset. Like what if the human sunset did the opposite like she went through a portal to Equestria and chooses to live there

Did you know there are two other alicorns?

I wanted all movies of my little pony

... the original Sunset Shimmer human was already dead... She just told me. But the pony version is looking for her sometimes. I hope you're not too scared from the idea of a car crash taking the life of the human version, then Sunset Shimmer pony version coming out of Equestria being part of plans for the future of both worlds. I'm sorry Sunset, it's just what happened if you find this.

I like the first theory better. Also start using the comics for help.

Hey do you ever wonder why the wonderbolts aren't even in equestria girls?

Maybe og sunset went to pony world and changed her identity.. if anything i think it may make sense cuz in the 5th gen of mlp or the most recent movie involving the newest ponies there is no magic in their world, maybe cuz of an imbalance or a outlier that came in and interracted and maybe mixed genetics with a pony in that world which caused an event that took magic from one side and gave it to the other. Or maybe the genetics mixed more than enough times to take out the magic.. or even the ideas and history and even current writings of magic were taken and destroyed so noone could teach or learn to do magic.

So that means… Sunset is not like other girls, she’s a rare baddie 🙄💅

It's funny to think how Sunset is technically older then the she actually is considering her pony form is presumably an adult where as in the human world she's in high school

The human sunset would be a true villain in human world. Believe me, Sunset is reformed but how about Human Sunset. Whould she be reformed

Narrator: Where is the original
Sunset Shimmer????

Me(5secsBeforeTheVidEvenStarts)
: PROLY DEAD AS HEK

Since I only see mlp content only once in a while I just find it so odd how your editing looks like other video easseys like yo good job but it just took me by surprise

WHAT IF SUNSET KILLED THE HUMAN SUNSET?

If sunset shimmer has a canterpart in this world. Big question is where is she. Or sunset shimmer knows she's there but avoid her counterpart. So do the other girls.so they won't get confused by who is who.

Maybe the day pony sunset arrived something happened to her like maybe she got in an accident or ran away and while running away from home she found another portal to equestria and ended somewhere in that universe and while that happened pony sunset bumped into her human parents and that's how she's been living in the human world

I think that she did lived in the human world then she went into the pony world
if it was this then she would know about the crown she attempted to steal
So I think she would use the magic from the pony world (except the magic of harmony and friendship)
She is a student at the school
Cause sunset has a house in the human world
And then she lived in the pony school

I’m James’s daughter and I think that the human world sunset possibly traveled to Equestrian and then went back home and so there’s the pony sunset still in Equestria.

"Instead of "where is human Sunset?" maybe we should be asking-"
WHY IS HUMAN SUNSET????
"is there a..?"
oh.

In the main picture which one is the real Sunset Shimmer I have a feeling it’s the one gasping and the other is equestrian Sunset Shimmer

I just realized when I was watching equestria girls when starlight goes to the human world i was like there most be another starlight glimmer

Ooor the human Sunset lives somewhere else in the world who knows she could be in a place similar to France, England, Italy, Spain, Europe or Africa which is why we never saw her.

Uh oh, I’m going back into my mlp phase

Hey sawtooth umm I was wondering can u do a vid about how Twilight got that flowing mane in the future

I kinda think sunset from the human world and sunset from pony bill are one you can see her cutie mark both worlds are connected on her hands

when start a complex lore in the mdl of a franchise like mlp doom zelda and other things

The original sunset might be living at a beach weve never seen i mean her pony cutie mark is a sun so it makes sence and what if she has Another clone? From another world? Like maybe an alien sunset? Twilight and so on, what if there 3 speachies human pony and alien?

Maybe I know when twilight got there take her crown back to eqestria her counterpart was out somewhere to study maybe sunset shimmer's counter part moved somewhere else and never came back

I think The human sunset went through the portal, And got lost in the pony world

Sawtooh:(says that the sunset form the pony world killed the sunset of the human world)
Me:why do I hear the man behind the slaughter

RIGHT you know how the sirens were banished to the human realm so they don't have human alter egos what if sunset is in a similar situation

EXACTLY IVE BEEN TRYING TO FIGURE THIS OUTTTT

What if the sunset we know is the human sunset shimmer and she found the portals and way between worlds and hence how she met our Celestia learned magic and why she's the only one who goes back and forth between both worlds cause she is the only one of herself maybe

i mean if there was an originall im sure shed show herself by now mainly because the sunset we know and her friends have formed a band and they even were shown on television its wat gives them at least one enemy who uses a mirror or was it a phone to trap the friends ??? i mean this is just my thoughts and i doubt u will take notice but i find this to be a very interesting factor if she is real why hasnt she confronted our sunset ?? for taking the fame that the other sunset always wanted ??

Plot twist: the human Sunset Shimmer went to Equestria and got lost so we didn't see her

There’s one of everyone at the high school 😊

What if because Sunset Shimmer went to the human world and stayed there, because she stayed there the other one never came back

Og pony Sunset left her Equestria...
Og human Sunset left her Earth...
Wait. Did og human Sunset leave Earth? Not so much so as to go to the pony world, but maybe another world entirely... another dimension. Only implication is she can't return and go back as easily as with the mirror.
Maybe she found herself in one of the alternate realities we saw during the Twilight/Starlight time travel episode? Maybe she came to this world and is currently locked up for being batshit crazy?
"I HAVE YELLOW SKIN!! I HAVE BLONDE AND RED HAIR GROWING NATURALLY OUT OF MY HEAD!! I'M NOT CRAZY!! I'M NOT CRAZY!! NO!! I DON'T WANT ANYMORE NEEDLES!!I'LL BE GOOD!! I'LL STAY QUIET!! PLEASE!! I DON'T WANT TO FORGET ANYMORE.."


Ahem. Sorry. It got away from me there for a minute.

But the Sparkle was in the crystal Academy, maybe Sunset was in another country altogether😅

Her cutie mark is like yin and yang.

She probably doesn't have one because pinkie pie knows everybody and when she met twilight she said "do u have a twin sister" or something like that. she probably would've said the same to sunset if sunset did have one. but it would be cool if she did have one

i think her cutie mark has something to do with balance, but im not sure lol. if her cutie mark does mean that then maybe it's just that there is no human sunset and sunset was made to introduce magic to the human world.
NVM I REALISED THE WHOLE THING FOR ONE OF UR THEORIES IS LITERALLY THAT

Uhhhh... yk that she probably is just a normal person right? I mean, what made her want to “prove” herself is that her friend got token away

I think sunset is a person from both Dimensions.

So say human Sunset got kicked out of school, same as the pony one. She now has nothing left in that world that matters to her, no idea what to do next. Pony Sunset comes in, and tells her of a magical place she can get a fresh start. So human Sunset goes to the pony world, to find a new place to live and start a new life

I am also thinking, there’s a human starlight glimmer right?

She's basically Yin and Yang my guy

My brothers and I have a theory that sunset killed his self from that universe, I know very well xd but it came to us out of nowhere and also because I said "a corpse appears with a xd"

maybe human sunset discovered a portal to another world

I think she’s coming in season three?

Wah!! He sounds like kouru from ouran highschool host club

Well saw two players if you want my thing on it I just think that the human sunset might be dead like that theory on the human cozy glow I mean it's a possibility like that human star squirrel so maybe you should think about that being a possibility or something bigger

I think starlight glimmer is the sunset shimmer of the pony world and some that shimmer is the starlight glimmer of the human world, and forgotten friendship we see that sunset shimmer is friends with Trixie and starlight glimmer is friends with Trixie and pony world also they are both very similar so

I’ve litterly been asking myself since we met human world twilight

what if human sunset never actually appeared what if shes just in another school that didnt participate in the school event in the equestria games or something

Maybe she's too famous To be seen around there parts Of the world😘Might be She is traveling The world🛬🛫✈🛳🚁🚄🌆🎡🎠🎢🍾🍷

i love my little pony

I always thought that where is human Sunset Shimmer.

the real human sunset

And what about human world Glim-Glam?

i think human sunset had to move in the human world becouse she was kicked out all of the schools. since sunset was also sent to tho another world and kinda got kicked out :)

and one more question, is there another starlight glimmer bc they both has the same thing

Just like the pony sunset shimmer would travel to another world far away from people the human sunset shimmer left her home to far away place

I always wondered that because all ponies and girls have same dna so what if ss did have a pony twin

I think sunset is the breach between the 2 worlds

1:26 I’ve been thinking that for years

I think she's in the shadows bolts but she is never seen

I like your first theory the best

Me when I have crush on SunSet......No really. Hehe. You know both worlds????? I would pick either. Sunset Shimmer is also Legend!!!!!!!!!

Wait what about Starlight Glimmer? What if there’s a original human Starlight Glimmer

it’s always where is human sunset and never how is human sunset 😔

Unless Sunset was the human, who found equestria. And has been pretending to be a pony. Who wanted to steal the crown to make chaos

3:11 I SAID POLITICS OUT LOUD I THOUGHT SHE WOULDVE BEEN INTO POLITICS

Just a theory, what if the original human sunset shimmer died by a freak accident?

She died
She gets killed
Shes doomed

I believe that the human sunset never existed. Or if she did. The pony sunset stay in the human world to long to the point where the human sunset slowly disappeared.

Sunset Shimmer "Mirai Nikki'd" her variant.😈

Yes there has to be an human sunset if there hes to be two of the same a human and a pony and they both like the same so there has to be a human and pony sunset you get what i am saying right

I believe i thought that she originally came from the human world but yet again i was 7 at the time and i didnt question much

There is but probably not in that world because the pony sunset was put into the human dimension right? Which means the original human sunset could be in another dimension... I mean it is the only thing that makes sense currently!

Real question is where the hell is human starlight

My headcanon, while dark, is that the Human sunset killed herself.

Hey have a another theory about the two worlds what if something happened in the human world used something that created an Alternate world, that would be Equestria. Again just a Theory I had.

there is no way she could have killed her i mean would she go that far

There’s a theory that sunset shimmer is still in equestria they just don’t know that

what about starlight glimmers human form?? isn't there only one of HER??

Something definitely happened to her

What about starlight we saw her went through the portal but not her human counter parte

I HAVE A THEROY when you talking about sunburt and trixe beeing dawns parents i thought that mabye it could have been sunsets daughter or sister because dawn is that same as sunrise and sunset is the opisite of sunrise. Their cutie marks are similar kind of because of the sun but the point of their cutie marks and the names are whats the lead. I dont know if its true but sunset seems to be the same age as twilight and the group and pinkie had a kid. So sunset could be her mom or her sister ( i also commented this on your other video )

Actually I have a question questionIs sunset shimmer Princess Celesta and princess Luna Sister it is Pretty obviousCause her name starts with sunset

Well you were talking about that pony sunset killed human sunset ? , but isn’t possible that pony-sunset used a sort of spell to trap the human sunset and still took her place

Wow i never thought of this😢😧 this is deep

In the music theory one its not really the same thing i mean sci-twi is completely diffenert from our twily in attitude ( and slightly in appearance)

Like with what pinkie pie said do you have a sister who lives in the city?

It could be that there is another version of sunset as we later found out that there was more the one portal to equestria


( though o thibk personally that the writers just didnt really think that far ahead , like sunset is meant to be the main character in equestria girls and be its own thing but becauseade Twilight aka Twily is

Just wanted to ask you where do you watch my little pony season 6 to 9?

That what I want to know too 😼

More like "where is human Sunset buried" lol

is there human starlight Glimmer into EG ?

Actually she didn't bring magic to the human world, the windigos did, remember thats where they went when they were banishes

What if there isn't a pony sunset?

I think that pony sunsets made human sunset go through the portal and now she’s in a Questria

1:30 i disagree mlp is a show for kids most definetlely meaning that it would not involve killing.

I know we’re human world sunset is because I made a Wikipedia page about her so basically human world sunset shimmer didn’t get along with anyone because she thought she was weird so she decided to leave The town and start a new life on her own

My thinking that we might be able to base this on human twilight she went to a different school so human sunset probably went to a different school and like you said probably she did music so probably music school but I don’t think she is evil otherwise she probably would have heard that there’s magic in this world now from the second human world movie she probably would have heard and be ready to go to the school and gang power for herself so what I think is that the only reason why she began evil because she was good at magic but since there’s no magic in the human world she move to music and maybe writing music change her motive of power in the future but a humble human sunset wanting to become an idol and inspiration to other people.

Sunset works in some kind of lab maybe

I think there are two of them because One color is light and one is dark

I think that there isn't a human Sunset shimmer. I mean she is the connection between both worlds. maybe it was her destiny to bring the worlds together. IDKK

I had a teory that Sunset has one parents from pony's wold and one from a human's.

i think that when ponies or humans are born its similar to tinkerbell where they split into two but maybe sunset didnt split?

Instead of kill maybe the human sunset captured the nice pony sunset then she got free

She goes to crystal prep and didn't go to the friendship games.

I'm here only for music from the Arcana

This video took like 5 sharp left turns but I'm not complaining XD

My thought maybe she is just in a different place like Las Vegas or something I mean we have never been that far out of counterlot highs zone

I mean everypony in equestria as their human counterpart sunset can't be any different

@Sawtooth Waves the payment for the membership is 5 dollars so in the Philippines is 250 pesos can you make the price lower😟

Get this. Sunset is the original from the human world and found a way to equestria when she was little and her pony version was far away like in the town that had no cutie marks or further. And sunset just went back to the human world eventually. Just a thought

What if sun came FROM THE HUMAN WORLD

You know I’ve always wondered

what if human sunset and pony sunset was the same person

Another crazy theory what if pinky pie travels between worlds and that's why she knows everything when she claims she wasn't there

How about Starlight Glimmer?

I think if the pony and the human Sunset is like the rest that would mean human sunset some how found her way over to the pony world not sure how but it is possible that pony sunset is human sunset

How about how you go to the human world in modern equestria??????

maybe the original human sunset lives with her parents maybe she also got greedy maybe her teacher kicked her out and she was never able to earn money so she goes to her parents and lives with them ...hiding in her home town (edit) and maybe she thought she was to smart to be a normal student maybe she wanted to be pushed up a few grades but never did

Me listening to his Alicorn members

Sawtooth - PetrolHead02,Syannax,Princess Starglow, ALLISON H,etc

Me - I have a Allison H that goes to my school and he's my friend too.

Not me slowly going back into mlp fandom o,0





That damn airplane that could be schooting stars-

мы не видели и человека старлайт. Она тоже была показана пришедшей из мира пони. человеческую версию не видели

Wait. I thought sunset is from the human world?

🌄🌅

Well I just saw sunset is in Hooman world and starlight is taking her place in pony world lol

what if tirek was human?

Well sunset is from equestria. But where is the human?

maybe she was like human twilight

I love your voice

Not only sunset is there missing out in human world but Starlight glimmer is also only in one world right😏🤔

Actually considering Sunset is from Canterlot and most of the characters in the human world are from Ponyville it makes sense we’ve never seen human Sunset or Starlight.
That said, this is an excellent idea for a fanfic. The Sonic Rainbooms get famous online and are scheduled for a gig on TV and Human Sunset wants to abduct and replace out Sunset on stage.

The actual truth is that there isn’t another sunset shimmer

if twilight in the pony world is a student of celestia in the human world she is also a student, sunset shimmer betrayed princess celestia "broke the law" then maybe in the Human world she is in this in jail for a crime she committed?

Starlight Glimmer also don't have human version. Because she is from another city.
I think that human sunset shimmer live in another city.

No, she never resulted to physical harm, but its a kids show. She probably would of, tbh

Stars world just enters the human realm and dies will just be the funniest thing ever

My theory is sun set is actually from the human world and found the portal and went through meeting celestial and ect

Is my theory good?

This was randomly recommended by YouTube for me.

Thanks. I guess?

It is sad that the Human Sunset had an untimely demise. But, it wasn't Equestria Sunset that killed her human counterpart. Human Sunset was killed...BY ME!!! Muhahahahaha! And on top of that: I have been behind all the darkness in the Pony World, and will continue to do so, in the hopes of creating enough chaos to open a Master Oblivion Gate for my agents to bring even more havoc on Equestria so that I can return to the Mortal Realm in my true form, and destroy all of my little brother's creation back to the basic atoms of which they came, and remake Time & Space into what it was really meant to be!

Now where’s human starlight

don’t consider the possibilities, they also have actors, they have their own ideas, or register does have! there human sunset is seen! you’re like saying that you want to animators do for your will the cartoon!

Human sunset be like:man im ded

I was wondering the same thing before I saw this vid!

Wait yes she dose when I used to watch this she had that wee seen her in a movie.

That was in my mind where is the human sunset Shimmer

I think that's actually the human version I think that's actually And she let the other pony go and she did it and actually that's how the human version's like and she knows how My Little Pony road in the world works but she doesn't but she stands up for a ponyville she stands she doesn't know how to walk like ponies so I think that's the real one

Bro the mlp subject to the art on is over gotta keep up with the trends

😍🥰😊👍🏻✨

Theory idea: Is principal chinch Chrysalis

How do you have a picture of her

But like what if its the other way around like what if we are looking for her human form when we should be looking for her pony form-