Cara Elias warriors is not mop different storys may have different ways of doing things check I've had different time and currency measures in my own writings as well. and I know other writers that do. you can theorize similarities but same series and world they are not
If someone lives on Earth's Moon and sees Earth as its Moon, then it month's length is around 24 hours or 1 day on Earth. While on Earth, a month's length is 30 days or 1 month.
Let's say this. Someone… Let's Princess Lun… er, Kaguya. Princess Kaguya was sent away from the Moon to the Earth. Before she departed, her Council say "Kaguya. Please return back in 30 months! That's 30 days on Earth!"
But when she got on Earth, she decided to extend her stay for 6 Earth months and more!
Or maybe she just plain boke plus didn't hear the '30 Moon months ≈ 30 Earth days' part, and thought 'I've only stayed here for 6 months'.
In my head I was debating on whether it was 1 day or a month (I'm only on the third book so they don't reveal much) but I always knew it was a month cuz silverstream lives for about 21 moons if it was days well... But if it was months she was around 1 year and 9 months when she died.
LPS Labrador I have no idea when applejack’s family reunion is. my logic three years ago was “ah yes, twilight said 1000 years instead of 1000 moons that one time, therefore 1 moon = 1 year and ponies live 80,000 years”
@Ayla Nassen So AJ is at least 300 years old? She's been around for at least 3 Apple Family Reunions (2 of which happened in the same year), and each Reunion is 100 moons apart, so...?
@Umbreonfan03 like he said in the video, the moon takes one whole month to make one cycle. Thats where the warrior series gets a moon from. If you think about it, cats don't know what a month is. Not in the way we do.
We The Cringe that wouldn’t make senses cause I’m pretty sure they have a gathering every moon and that wouldn’t be every week a month makes more sense
trububbleee ~three years later a 11 year old is watching mlp theories when the show basically ended and also reads warrior cats replies to ur comment~ jayfeather best boi and best gurl be leafpool
~three years later~ I have always wondered that and I read all of omen of the stars, new prophecy, power of three and the sun trail with 4/9 of thunder rising (yes very precise but idk I’m guessing 4/9)
Btw a moon cant be a year since newest episode, twighlight states that she meets the other five (since spike is still mostly with her)every Moon. So they can have waited a year, or maybe they do? I think its every month. Just a theory
My favourite has to be LeopardStar (I know she isn’t that popular but I love her story, and the fact even though she has a redemption arc, but still could be ‘mean or hostile’ which I like. Her whole entire character didn’t do a full 180, but she wasn’t considered straight up evil)
The reason why there is a big difference between those two photos is because each family reunion is not always held in ponyville. Sometimes they hold it at other places
@ChibiKittyCat What if pony ageing works differently? In ancient myths, unicorns/pegasi lived really long, like thousands of years... But I also heard somebody say that the MLP pony lifespan is 30 years... Idk...
Applejack: 23-24; Rarity: 22-23; Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash: 21-22; Pinkie Pie: 20-21 (a year younger than Fluttershy); Twilight: 18-19; The entire series so far seems to have taken a little over a year, and RD had a birthday in Pinkie Pride, so they've probably all aged a year since season 1.
idk i found this while googling... Applejack: 23-24; Rarity: 22-23; Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash: 21-22; Pinkie Pie: 20-21 (a year younger than Fluttershy); Twilight: 18-19;
theponywiththeorangebow yeah but this is a magical not real world. And this is a real world.... tbh there could be another planet with magical beings....
@tube cheese In the "Last problem" (spoiler if you didn't already see it),
they're clearly older than that XD I mean, Pinkie has a KID and her kid is clearly not a baby but a child, maybe even close to being a teenager. Some parts of Rarity's mane are grey and Twilight grew up to Celestia's size! They're clearly older than that now x)
Applejack: 23-24; Rarity: 22-23; Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash: 21-22; Pinkie Pie: 20-21 (a year younger than Fluttershy); Twilight: 18-19; The entire series so far seems to have taken a little over a year, and RD had a birthday in Pinkie Pride, so they've probably all aged a year since season 1.
@¡Allomaz! no actually , in the last episode twilight said she can't believe it's been ten years since she started ruling which means they could have been 23-26 they weren't that young , rarity had a job which means she can't be 16 she would probably be 18-26
Actually judging from Applejack’s growth I would say that 100 moons equals to 8 years. First she is seen as a baby and then as almost adult (16 years old) and the present Reunion is now so AJ must be 24 years old.
I think the mane 6 are 16 or 17 cause they're in high school and the cmc is 8 or 10 yrs old cause spur and biscuit are older than the cmc so.....the cmc are in primary school using spur and biscuit as a referance they might be in middle school ......idk tho im also pretty confused but this is my complicated theory.
@Joliet Magana i don't think that fluttershy is the oldest i think its rarity cause she does work sewing whereas fluttershy doesn't have a job until season 7
The cmc are likely 7-13 the main six 16- 20. Rarity is likely 19 twilight 17 pinkie 15.5 fluttershy 16.5 rainbowdash 16 applejack 18. CMC are all the same age
I would say that we probably can’t compare their age in equestria girls to their pony age, considering in the pony world celestia is thousands of years old, and if she was that old in the human world, she would be dead.
late teens to early adult 17-23 at the end of the show they were all like grandma or mom age but it’s confusing bc in equestria girls they were all trens
@Crystal 959 no it’s been so many more years then that at the point of season 9 i think when the first epsidoe started twilight was around 17 and the oldest was like rarity who was 23 or somthing everyone eles was in the middle and by the end of the show they were all like grandma age idk the exact so i’m just saying grandma cuz u get what i mean or maby in there 30-40 that’s probly more accurate
Personally, I believe pony’s live to be thousands of years old. Because Granny Smith was there when ponyville was founded, and ponyville was founded a LONG time ago. And at the end of season nine, twilight got her flowy/glittery main, and from the old story’s the princesses tell us, it takes pretty long to get to that stage.
Like 17-18 and the cmc is like 14/15-16 since they are in high school and the ages for high school is 14-17, the ages for middle school is 11-14 And the age for elementary school is 5-11. Correct me if I'm wrong.
@Carla ARMYxBLINK Pinkie has to 19 because in “Griffon the Brush-Off,” Fluttershy says she is a year older than Pinkie Pie, and a side note; Pinkie Pie’s canon birthday is May 3rd
I saw a website that I thought didn’t sound right but whatever I heard that applejack is 24 rarity is 23 rainbow dash is 21 flutter shy is 21 pinkie pie is 20 and Twilight is 19
The human world would work in contrast to the ponies because ponies age differently just like other animals. Twilight could still be an adult for ponies/ horses. Or fully matured. Which could easily be 17-18 in human years
Y'all I don't think they are teenagers. They writers just wanted to put them in a high school setting for EG. The age of their human self is not the same. An example of a teenager pony would be Sandbar from the student 6. Based on how the Mane 6 live their lives in Equestria, they seem like younger adults. Like early 20s. They all have full time jobs and live on their own.
Going by new evidence from season 6's Applejack's Day Off I believe one 'Moon' = one week Meaning 30 moons will be 7 and 1/2 months and 100 moons would be around two years
This also works out because, on the very very first episode the Apple's were having a family reunion Then in Season 3 they have another one
The seasons are (in our world) one year apart from each other, and one year = 52 weeks
So two years will be 104 weeks - those two yeas will be all of Season 1 and all of Season 2
We have 9 seasons now and it has been Aired for 9 years now 1 season = one year I dont think Ponies age that much 9 years apple Bloom is still a kid pony And granny Smith is a bit weird She was there when Equestria was made But she was older in one episode or so so the Reunion must have Been before equestria was made but that does not make sence
But according to Season 4 Episode 1, everything in Seasons 1-3 happened within Twilight's first year in Ponyville (S4E1 takes place on the Summer Sun Celebration directly after S1E1)
The very first episode took place on (or maybe the day before) the Summer Sun Celebration, the pony version of the summer solstice
We see another Summer Sun Celebration a few seasons later, I don't remember which season, it was either 3 or 4, but unless the show decided to skip over such an important event, that would be exactly 1 year
@james the soldier well i actually look it up and it said this That means 100 moons have passed between "Friendship is Magic" and "Apple Family Reunion" According to the S4 Premiere, the events of Seasons 1-3 all occurred within the same year. That means that 100 moons < 1 equestrian year.
@james the soldier oh sorry but like wouldn't they be dead on the first family reunion but it's a kids show though it would make more sense if it was a month but it's not so that means my conspiracy theory was right apple bloom will not grow
But in the last episode they said that the mane 6 would meet once a moon n I’m pretty sure they won’t travel from ponyville to canterlot n back every week since they r older n have their own lives now......I’m pretty sure one moon is one month
We have atleast two onscreen winters between season 1 and 4 though, first time in "Winter wrap up" and second time in "Hearth's Warming Eve"
Having only one year passing between these two would require the episodes to not be released in chronological order, which I hope is not the case.
Taking all events happened into consideration, season 1 alone would already be atleast 3 years long.
The "moon" time measurement thing does get confusing sometimes. I do wish the exact equivalent was stated somewhere, but your theory is pretty interesting too. Thanks for sharing this with us! ^_^ If Equestria relies on the princesses to raise the sun and moon, what would have happened if there hadn't been any unicorns or alicorns at all? Would the sun and moon move on their own like the clouds in the Everfree Forest? The science and logic of the MLP world is puzzling. ^_^;
The only reason why Luna would need to revolve the moon around the planet would be if the moon were too far away from its orbit. If the moon were that far away, the planet's axial tilt would have been too unstable for life to form and therefore Luna would not have been able to have been born.
Also, as I have likely mentioned somewhere else, in order for a geocentric system on a life-supporting Earth to take place, the star would need to be barely large enough for a star to form and barely inside of Earth's orbit. This means that in order for a geocentric Equus or whatever, its gravitational pull would need to be equal to or greater than that of Earth's, as any less would mean no star could form that could support life on a geocentric Equus. Adding to that, there is evidence to believe that the gravity on Equus is likely equal to Earth's gravity at most. The tree that houses the Castle of Friendship towers over the huts of Ponyville at about 6 times the height of a standard hut, meaning that it is likely to be about 180 feet in height, assuming one story is 10 feet and the huts are 3 stories high at most in the image I am referencing https://images.app.goo.gl/GtRKXrwLdE39w3rA6. Even if there were more than 3 stories on a particular hut, meaning the tree is over 180 feet high, this still means that the tree is, at least, approximately the height of a giant sequoia, which is so tall because of the lack of disease-carrying relatives in the areas they are located in. The tree housing the Castle of Friendship, however, does have to contend with the Everfree Forest, which has been known to expand into Ponyville on occasion. This means that a tree that large in an area such as Ponyville may be considered unnatural on a planet with a gravitational pull like Earth's, but on a planet with a weaker gravitational tug, where the nutrients of the tree can circulate to higher places, it may be just fine. This means that Equus's gravitational pull is likely equal to Earth's at the very most, thus likely being unable to host a life-supporting star within its orbit.
My theory could possibly be that Granny Smith, like my high school geometry teacher (and possibly Princesses Celestia and Luna), exaggerates the time between events.
Warriors logic- one moon equals one month, the reasoning for this is that they refer to the cycle of the moon, how it takes a month to cycle around, thus, one moon. That makes the most sense to me. :i
Well, it takes about a month to change through all the stages of the moon. So a moon's a month. 100 moons is 100 months. 100 months is... ahh, let's see... 8 years and 4 months.
I've thought about this for a good while. It's safe to assume that Equestria uses a lunar calendar and because the show doesn't say how long a lunar month is or how many days each phase of the moon lasts, so I'll use the cycle of our moon. Each phase of our moon lasts 3-8 days, considering that the months of most lunar calendars last between 28-30 days depending on the culture. Considering that like here on Earth, Equestria has 4 seasons with 3 full lunar phases each season. A few things the show is unclear on is how many days in a week they have, how many weeks make up a month, how long each lunar cycle is and how many months make up a year, so it would be safe to assume that 100 moons would be 2-3 years unless some official source comes out giving measurements of time.
A lunar cycle is 28 days on Earth. If things work the same way in Equestria then that's approximately 2800 days or 7 years, 8 months, and 5 days. This will vary depending on the length of a month, leap years, and whether Equestria uses a solar or lunar calendar. I assumed 30 day months, no leap year, and a solar calendar.
I personally feel that 1 moon equals approximately 2 1/2 days. 30 moons would equal 75 days, and 100 moons would be 250-ish days. This corresponds with the fact that Seasons 1 & 3 both contain Apple Family Reunions (S1E1 and S3E8), and, according to S4E1, the first 3 seasons take place during Twilight's first year in Ponyville.
This makes Rainbowdash's seperation from Tank in season five more logical, while not seeing your friend/pet for three months isn't terrible, "It's okay Rainbowdash, you'll see Tank again in another three months." (AJ) factoring this time, it's logical to assume that there are also twelve months in an Equestrian year, this means though AJ says three months, it's more like six months, half a year in our world. Suddenly Rainbow's dread of losing Tank is a lot more important.
every moon is a month. so it's 150 months old that applejack is, and since 12 years is the middle age of most ponies, i'm saying that applejack is an adult in her early 20's in human years. I'm saying that every moon is a month because there is only 1 full moon every month. This also applies to the warrior cats universe aswell
I think that an equestrian year is closer to 50 moons, since the apple family reunion would be every year with the 100 moon year, it seems highly unlikely, the 100 moon year is troublesome, especially with the seasons, either, all the seasons are about twice as long as our own (which, just think of the food stores) or there are two sets of seasons in a year, which is highly unlikely and I would probably find proof against it if I bothered to look at winter wrap up. It's more likely that they measure a year by the passing of the seasons, in ancient times they would let the seasons follow through and become a year, while now it's presice, as we see the ponies make sure that the seasons are on time.
I know I'm a newer fan to the show,for a few weeks now,first I thought moons meant years for them,cause not once I ever heard them say years,but granny smith is old and she's probably been to dozens of family reunions when she was young,so it can't mean years,it has to mean months or a few years or something similar to that
I'm sure someone must have brought this up before, but one Equestrian year is most likely determined by the seasons. The year starts and ends with the beginning of winter or the beginning of spring--or perhaps at mid-winter. And unless the seasons in Equestria are significantly longer than our own, their year is likely similar to ours in length. So 50 moons in 1 year might be a pretty good guess.
I've just thought of a potential theory, but it could be far-reaching. My theory is that an Equestrian year could be equivalent to possibly Jupiter's moon Eurydome, with the length of a year being 717 days. If you divide the number of days it takes Eurydome to orbit around Jupiter by how many days we have per year on Earth (365), we get 1.92, which is almost the exact length of time (2 years) it took in the real world for Twilight to become crowned as the next princess, but only a year in-universe. While this is completely speculative, I think that their years are vastly longer than ours. This may also explain the odd thing we see in MLP where the moon is usually full in vast majority of episodes. It could also explain the "hundreds of moons" closing of the borders in "Party Pooped". So 1 moon may equal to 717 days. It is my best assumption as some years on other moons are years long or a single orbit could last 7 hours.
One thing you forgot was that the growth of ponies by age is completely different from that of humans. So while Applebloom hasn't changed much, a few years could have passed, as each stage of pony growth lasts about 3 to 6 years, theoretically speaking.
Stage 1: 1 to 4 years - baby; Stage 2: 5 to 10 years - child; Stage 3: 11 to 16 years - teen; Stage 4: 17 to 20 years - next to adult; Stage 5: 21 years onwards - Adult.
Sorry for the late comment, I just got to know your channel now.
Heres an idea on the photo thing. Early on, photos would most likely require a unicorn who is specialized in pictures. Well there couldn’t have been too many of those walking around that long ago with how young the tech would have been. As time goes on, though you have innovations in the tech. Thus making picture taking a lot simpler and more common. Which is shown by how close together the later pictures seem to be.
100 moons have passed between "Friendship is Magic" and "Apple Family Reunion" According to the S4 Premiere, the events of Seasons 1-3 all occurred within the same year. That means that 100 moons < 1 equestrian year.
I like how we both have similar theory’s of how years works in MLP universe.
1 human year has 12 months. But one of are year equals to 2 years in Equestria. So that means one of their year is about 6 months. So let’s say Princess Celestia is 1000 years old to use that would mean she like 500 years old. MLP Pony’s lifespans probably shorter then human if this is true.
＊ I’m not at all sure how to feel about Equestria not being earth. One of my favorite dumb things about this series is how the seasons and days work. It’s cool and interesting and brings up so many questions. How did equestria even work before ponies? How did anything evolve? It makes so little sense and I love it. The idea of a regular year cycle is ridiculous in the first place when ushering spring into existence (all at once!) is halfway between a civic duty and a chore. Equestria can’t be on this planet or any planet really. And honestly I find it stupidly endearing.
Most families do family reunions once a year .. so 100 moons being 1 year kinda makes sense ... but its still hard to figure out how much time has passed when they use like 20 moons or 30 moons
An interesting theory but here's a few problems with it, bear in mind this might be a bit of a read so please bear with me.
The first episode of the series was during the Apple Family Reunion as well. Remember that in Apple Buck Season, Twilight asked Applejack why she couldn't get more of her family to help, to which AJ replied "They were all just here for the Apple Family Reunion". Meaning that if 100 moons was a year then there is a big problem because that episode was in the middle of the 3rd season, and as we know from the Season 4 Premiere, that premiere marked the 1 year anniversary for the Mane 6 as it was the same day they met and became friends one year later.
This means that 100 moons cannot equal a year but there must be more than that if every episode is released in chronological order. So unfortunately your theory is kind of destroyed by the writers themselves not being consistent XD
Another problem this causes is mainly due to the fact that of course Equestria (which is a country not a planet btw) is not in our world. Simply put, the seasons are in haywire. In our solar system every planet has their own season but it's still the four and this is all based on the orbit of the planet and where the poles are facing in correlation to the sun. Spring, Summer, Fall and Winter in that order. But see, in the course of the full three seasons that we saw in the one year for Equestria, we had two, count em, two winters. We had Winter Wrap up in Season 1 (two episodes later we had the beginning of Fall with Fall Weather Friends) and then in Season 2 we had Hearths Warming Eve. We do know that pegasi can manipulate the weather and we've seen other episodes that appear to be in the fall despite most clearly being in spring or summer. But again this is a real problem for measuring time in Equestria because their seasonal patterns do not follow any real obvious pattern that would help us identify years.
But a bigger problem also is that since when we view "moons" as lunar cycles, this would mean that the moon in Equestria would have to go through phases as well if this theory is to be correct. Unfortunately every time we see the moon it is always full and never either waxing, waning or new. So this can't be the case unless we are somehow only seeing it during the full phase. Not even in Princess Twilight Sparkle where the sun and moon were both in the sky direct next to each other. The only explanation for how the moon could still be fully illuminated from that angle would mean that the moon is somehow further away and larger than Equestria's sun and either emits light or SOMEHOW is so reflective that even with the full blaze of the sun going it doesn't blot it out.
Furthermore an interesting thing to note also. In the Family Appreciation Day episode it was made clear that Granny Smith was around when Ponyville was founded. Given hear appearance she couldn't have been too much older than the Mane 6 are now (which is really subject). Yet here's where things get very interesting. See in Winter Wrap Up, Twilight said that Ponyville had been doing it without magic "for hundreds of years". So Granny Smith has to be a few hundred years old as not only was it clear that Granny Smith wasn't lying about the events and we know Twilight studies the crap out of everything so wouldn't exactly exaggerate this point either. And if their years are twice as long this would imply that in how we view time, Granny Smith is potentially between 4000 and 1,000 years old (as exactly how many "hundreds of years" that means).
My point is basically, don't try to put logic into the show, it won't work cause it's a world of magical talking technicolor ponies. Don't get me wrong, I kinda wanna figure some of this out too but at the end of the day there's too many inconsistencies that make theories like this next to impossible to work out while taking everything into consideration.
@rautamiekka Ah but they are clearly points where there is continuity. It's when the seasonal changes like summer and winter come about that the continuity really falls apart. The only real safe thing, in my mind at least, to argue with this is that Equestria goes through strange seasons. I sort of accept this idea simply on the grounds that the weather, and thus the seasons, are dictated by the Pegasi and their weather management.
All in all, it's kinda silly to try and decifer how years and time in general passes in a world where seasons and even night and day are controlled manually.
This, and your reply to another comment below, just blew my mind. There's really a lot to consider. I don't think the writers of the show thought any of this through. Until they release a canon time conversion, we simply won't know. Especially since their seasons, weather, sun, and moon are controlled manually, as you pointed out.
@theponywiththeorangebow I don't think so either. There's a lot of other things to consider that won't come up I am certain, but what can yah do? At the end of the day it's a kids' show about magical talking technicolor ponies.
TheBelieveit1 Oh come on, I think we all know it isn't really aimed at kids anymore. I mean sure it's still appropriate for them, but the staff knows they need to please their older fans as well, and that's what they're doing.
You just proved @theponywiththerainbow's word: may still be called what it's called, but whether they wanna please the older fans doesn't mean anything before the target audience description changes, which'll take more than just changing the episodes to be less appropriate for the original target audience.
It gets really weird when you consider that when the Everfree Forest was introduced it freaked the ponies out that the weather and animals took care of themselves. Further work in that Celestia and Luna only cover Equestria but there are clear references to things beyond Equestria (and there are delegates to things from areas implicitly part of Equestria, so I think it is something of a republic) it seems all of this control is localized. What happens at the boarders? The sun must rise and set, as must the moon, in YakYakistan (beyond even the most extreme part of what could be considered Equestria) or Terik's homeland (stated explicitly to be beyond Equestria). So could the sun set in Equestria while it is mid-day in YakYakistan? What of those outlying lands when Nightmare Moon did not remove the moon/blocked out the sun with the moon?
But between what I've heard about Mz. Faust's experiences and Transformers gen. 1's Hasbro approved "you don't need a big story board fix it in editing" approach to continuity I doubt the writers have the support needed to keep track of such details.
Travis Smith Oh wow, that's true. We don't know anything of what's beyond Equestria. They could have a different way of telling time too. Not to mention a different rate at which their seasons change. Honestly everything that tries to explain logic in that show just messes logic up even more. You guys are all making really good points.
What I thought was that moons were days. Because they don't say "full moon" or " half moon" ( correct me if I'm wrong) and there are moons everyday, even if it's a new moon. Yeah :3
Maybe they don't run off of seasons to make their years? Seeing as they aren't humans and don't do everything w do it might be that seasons don't effect the way the year goes around. Any rouge pegasi could change it from winter to summer any time they want (Like in fall weather friends )so having the ability to do this would change the way they see a year.
I know it's been a LONG while since this video was uploaded but I've found solid evidence for what I beleive in. Just watched "Grannies Gone Wild" where Applejack said that their trip to Las Pegasus is annual, and just before they get into the Wild Blue Yonder while walking up the stairs to it, Goldie Delicious says that they've been going there every moon since that they can remember, so yeah the basic train of thought was right all along that 1 Moon = 1 Year.
0 likes
רוני בן עזרא2020-02-12 17:12:01 (edited 2020-02-12 17:13:20 )
Great theory and speculation, but there is a flaw in your conclusion: ages. If equestrian years are twice as long as Earth years, why did 5-years-old applebloom from that flashback looked and acted like a five years old and not like, well, a ten years old? You could say that ponies age slower than humans, but in this case, human-twilight would be a 40-years-old lady, not a goddamn teenager.
Maybe I can answer to this. I'm actually sure that 1 moon is around 1 MONTH. Let me explain: At school, in history class, I learned that Incas people use lunar calendars because they praise the Moon. My history teacher told me that they count the number of times that the Full Moon was back in ONE year (with the calendar). He also told that for the Incas people 1 moon is equal to 28 days, so about 1 month. So, we could guess that 100 moons is 100 months. And, I'm agree with the fact that Equestria isn't Earth so maybe what I say is false. Because Apple Bloom didn't changed at all since the last Apple Family Reunion: it means that at Equestria, the duration of a moon is not equal to the duration of a moon for US. But, I really don't know, nothing is confirmed, all what I'm sure, is that ONE moon is 1 month in Earth. Here is my thought about that and hope what I say is logical! c:
A moon is mostly likely a Month. So 100 moons (or months) is just over 8 years. Meaning Granny Smith could easily have been at almost/all of the reunions.
Alternitivly the lunar cycles of both "Earth" and Equestira are somewhat synchronized... (As in 100 moons on earth is 100 moons on equestira so either ponies age slower than humans or time flows differently across dimensions/planes... )
Old video, but you overlooked an obvious explanation for why Apple Bloom doesn't look much younger in the previous reunion picture. The Apples had an extra reunion when the a large number of the family was in town anyway for the Summer Sun Celebration in Ponyville. It wasn't their typical 100 moon reunion, but kind of a mini reunion they had for the occasion. That would be where the picture including Apple Bloom would have come from. Since seasons 1-3 all take place in one year; the Apple Family reunion episode would have been less than a year after the first Summer Sun celebration, but they had another reunion anyway since that was when the traditional 100 moons reunion was supposed to be. It also would explain why there weren't nearly as many in that photo, perhaps some of the family just couldn't make it to the one during the summer sun celebration and knew another reunion was less than a year away, so they didn't worry about it.
1 moon being 1 month just works too well with the EQG story line. In the first movie, Twilight's friends talk about the freshman fair as if it were the last time they were all friends, and they look obviously younger in the picture. To work with the EQG story line, including later movies and specials, I think in the first movie, they're all in their junior year. That especially makes sense to me, since in my own high school, it was the junior class that was in charge of the fall dance, while it was the seniors that put on prom in the spring. We know it was Sunset that split them apart, and in Forgotten Friendship, Pinkie even says it was in freshman year when some of it happened, which would be at least two years earlier. Assuming Sunset took some time to get herself situated and figure things out in the human world she'd probably been there since before the start of the freshman year which would be around two and a half years, or 30 months.
Most likely when she first went through the portal, Sunset arrived in the mid to late spring before their freshman year, giving her enough time to get herself set up in the world before starting school. Then two and a half years or 30 months later, the portal opens again and EQG1 happens. And I don't think the portal could have opened in between because I really doubt Sunset would have skipped the portal opening, and neither would Celestia. Really, I think Celestia had been planning to send Twilight through to find Sunset anyway, and that was the whole reason she arranged for Twilight to be there when the portal opened. She was probably going to explain that morning and ask Twilight to go and look for her, but then Sunset stole the crown and it was the perfect excuse. It's clear Celestia still cared about Sunset even then, and had likely been worried about her; after all what was the very first thing she asked when Twilight got back; "Sunset Shimmer; is she alright?"
I believe that a month is a moon because in one episode (I don't remember the name), Pinkie Pie, Maud, and Rarity were doing PSSD and the store owner that Pinke was going to visit was on a vacation. No one would vacation for two years, especially not in Manehatten. The store wouldn't exist anymore or AT LEAST have someone else running it. And a moon is usually focused on the moon's cycle, where there is a full moon every month.
the mirror portal always leads to what used to be a statue outside CHS. so that means that the Canterlot and CHS share the exact same position in time and space. when the mirror was brought to Twilight's castle, there was a shift in the time-space continuum, resulting in multiple portals being created. where's Dr Whooves when you need him?!
I think 100 moons is just under a year. Reasoning: Season 1 Episode 1) Twilight is sent to Ponyville to arrange the summer sun celebration, at this time there are many many apples. Applejack explains this in Ep4 Applebuck Season saying "They were just here for the Apple family reunion. They actually live all over Equestria..."
The next family reunion is of course Season 3 Ep 8 Apple Family Reunion. Not much to figure here, it's the next reunion.
The next Summer Sun celebration is Season 4 Ep1/2 Princess Twilight Sparkle, this is indicated by Celestia saying "I must admit that it is wonderful to actually be looking forward to the Summer Sun Celebration."
There was a reunion at beginning of season 1 and then one in 3.
In 4 there is evidence that season 1 - 3 is all one year because in 4x1 Celestia says something about how she hated the summer sun celebration because it reminded her of how she banished her sister but now it’s a Joyce occasion of how they are reunited. If there was summer sun celebration after the pilot and before 4x1 then twilight should already know that Celestia hated the summer sun celebration. Celestia wouldn’t have said “now it’s a Joyce occasion about her transformation” because if there was one before then she wouldn’t have to say that because twilight and Equestria would already know.
Anyway, I think 100 moons is 200 days meaning a moon would be two days. this would make sense based on the fact season 1-3 is a year. There isn’t any idea how long of a gap between 3-4 there is but I can assume not a lot. AB in season 3 is around 10 and 9 in season 1 so it would make sense that only 200 days have gone by and she wouldn’t have changed. I also feel the third photo in the album of reunion Is the one before the season 1 opening because there was clearly more ponies there.
1-3 seasons couldn't be one year just because they have winters both in 1 and 2 seasons (ep 11x1 and 11x2). With everything else taking place in summers, there is at least 2 years between seasons 1 and 3
Now here's a flaw. if 100 moons is a year, and a moon is X days long. then a year would be a very long time in terms of days if it was more than 4 days per moon cycle. I think it has been observed in MLP that Twilight has been in Equestria for multiple Winter rap ups, Nightmare nights, and Hearts-warmings. So let's say a moon cycle is 10 days long. gives us a year of a thousand days.
for a year in Equestria if it is 50 or 100 moon if you are right, then the CMC shouldn't need to be at school for that whole time. That equates to 500 or 1000 days a year.
Here is a different approach, that the photos are not quite right. we can maybe assume that it's photo drawn quickly without full thought. What we know is that a couple of family gatherings back AJ was just a baby, she is now a fully grown adult, so maybe we can consider that 100 moons is several years. So maybe a year is more like 20 moons with a 20-day cycle? making an equestrian year 400 days. which is not that much longer than our calendar. I am not saying that I am right, but a variation of that makes more sence.
I tend to go with the 1 Moon=1 day approach. After all, we see in Princess Twilight Sparkle that with both the Sun and the Moon in the sky, Resulting in this weird half-day half-night effect. The only way that that could be the case is if the Moon was generating its own light that had a quality of negating and matching the light of the Sun. This means that the Sun light reflecting off the moon would not actually do anything. Further, in Equestria girls, it is clear that Sunset Shimmer came through the portal knowing not only that Twilight had uncovered the Elements, but also sufficiently aware of what the element of magic would look like to bring a reasonable copy to replace it with. On top of all that, she knew that Twilight would be present, within easy striking distance, on the other side of the mirror. To me, this means that she must have come through the portal between Twilight's Coronation and the Princess Summit. This would let her know that the Summit was going on in the same castle and on the same night that the portal would be opening. As well as see Twilight in her crown. This means a length of time longer than 30 days is unlikely.
Maybe the Portal had opened a day or two before Sunset made her move, as it's open for several days at a time, giving her time to scope out the situation?
Except fluttershy saw the crown and immediately recognized it as needing to go to Celestia. If it only existed for a few days, I don't think Fluttershy would have been able to recognize it. Surely, the portal could not have been standing open for more than a week.
@Skye Silverwing I let that fall to the "parallel worlds will be inexplicably parallel" explanation, where, by pure interdimensional plot convenience, the newest crown made at Canterlot High is destined to be all but indistinguishable (minus the magic powers, obviously) from the newest crown in Equestria. Parallel world stories often tend to have the same thing showing up for different reasons and purposes in each world, so I'm just used to that by now. Maybe Sunset had advanced-level knowledge in the mechanics of parallel worlds and expected-slash-really-really-hoped that it would hold true in this case, and it just so happened that it did.
I would be far more apt to believe the "inexplicably parallel" idea if the pictures we see of Sunset in previous Princess Crowns had shown the crowns as being those of Celestia, Luna, and Cadence, giving us reason to believe that Sunset saw the progression and realized what was coming... Still doesn't explain how Sunset knew Twilight was there, or knew her way around the Chrystal Castle (Which was missing the entire time she was alive and in Equestria) well enough to find Twilight's room. Unless... I suppose it is possible that the portal could have opened a day early, and Sunset slipped in to see what was going on and saw Twilight getting ushered in, crown and all, and then recognized the crown as the Element of Harmony and a coincidental perfect match for the current High School crown and built the attempted switch into her plan to steal it. Still, it all seems very coincidental to me. I prefer the idea that she had seen all she needed to the previous month, had the crown made, and put the whole thing in motion as part of her nefarious evil scheme. Of course, I have also heard the idea that she may have had some sort of Magic Mcguffin that gave her all the information she needed up until she got involved herself.
@Skye Silverwing And then there's always the chance that the writers just didn't think this deeply into it and it's just us fans who're scrambling around trying to make sense of it all. :ponyshrug:
I hate that kind of reasoning. It is out-of-continuity reasoning. I prefer to think in-continuity. Within the world, why is this the case? you know what I mean? Sure the real reason is that the writers were rushed and not very well continuity checked, but that does not mean that there is not still continuity to consider.
@Skye Silverwing I mostly headcanon for fanfiction, but I do things a different way in each story, thereby keeping my perspectives fluid and open for new details.
There are a number of reasons why Moons should not be a month. First, it is not a Warriors reference. "Moons" on Earth are used to indicate the amount of time it takes for the Earth's Moon to go through its phases. It is well established, however, that Equestria's Moon functions nothing like this (Luna moves it, it orbits each day, it produces its own light, etc.). Second, the Apple family reunion is supposed to happen every 100 moons, and has happened twice during the series. There is no way seven years have passed in that time. Finally, the portal to the Human world opens once every 30 moons, yet somehow, Sunset Shimmer knew not only that Twilight retrieved the Elements of Harmony and become a Princess, but where she would be, and what the Element of Magic would look like. If she had had no access to Equestria for two and a half years, there is no way she could have known those things before she came through, barring some unmentioned source of Prophetic knowledge. She had to have been able to return in the time since Twilight became a Princess and the Princess Summit was scheduled. Otherwise, it is a ridiculous level of Coincidence.
Actually, my theory is that one moon is about a day, which means she was on the Moon over 300000 Moons(give or take, based on how many days are in an equestrian year).
I don't see why the Equestrian year wouldn't be roughly the same length as ours
Yes, 100 is a nice round number (to us, why would a fingerless species use base 10 to count things?) but it's also a lot
The Fahrenheit scale for temperature was originally supposed to have 360 degrees between the freezing and boiling of water (the number of degrees in a circle) but instead it has 180, because 360 is far too much
I see no reason why 50 moons wouldn't be a year, it's also a convenient number
But as I said earlier, why would ponies use base 10? Maybe 100 to them is an entire different number than 100 is to us
Don’t you remember??? In the first episode of the first season they had so many family members when twilight was at the farm and in the 4th episode of the 1st season (I think) applejack told twilight that it was her family reunion when twilight asked her if her other family members could help her with the apple bucking. But then they had another reunion! So honestly I think 100 moons isn’t that long
I’m no theorist but, maybe you can take into account that on the very first episode of mlp fim applejack has an apple family reunion, and the next known reunion is in apple family reunion. Maybe if you can somehow figure out the time line in between that, you can figure it out?
100 moons are 100 months since "The Moon" Orbits the earth once every month and in finnish --- Month = Kuukausi - Moon = Kuu - Season = Kausi so in finnish Month = Kuukausi = MoonSeason.
So... The moon on equestria is in a geosynchronous orbit? and if it is, then it should be smaller because it's in a lower orbit and it's apparent diameter should be at least 0° 33' 2.08" for it to appear as large as our own moon. Moreover, it is evident that the equestrian moon is tidally locked since it shows the same face, as is the case with our own moon. Also, the size of the moon greatly affects tides on equestrias' oceans.
Wait, if apple bloom was around the same age in the previous reunion (give or take a few years) why was granny explaining the reunion to her in the episode.🤔
I have an idea, you could count how many years 30 “Moons” go by, counting how many photos of Sunset Schimer in school.She was photographed every year as the "Queen of the School."Although it will be Earth years, but it is at least something.
У меня идея, ты мог бы посчитать сколько лет проходит 30 "Лун" , посчитав сколько фотографий Сансет Шимер в школе. Она же каждый год фотографировалась, как "Королева школы". Хотя это будут земные года, но это хоть что то.
I wonder what do you think about girls' ages relative to each other. Only canon that I know of is that Fluttershy is a year older than Pinkie. Also, it's safe to assume Shy and Dash are classmates, why else would they know each other so well?
My headcanon goes like this:
Twilight (youngest) Pinkie Pie (+1yr) Dash, Fluttershy, AJ (+2yr) Rarity (who I assume to be anywhere between 3-7yrs older than Twi, she's most 'adult' of all judging by her career and personality)
0 likes
Ben Gilhooly2021-07-01 22:06:14 (edited 2021-07-01 22:06:22 )
So if 1 moon is month, that means twilight would've had to try and survive over 2 years in the normal world if she didn't get back in time
They have a normal Earth year and I can prove it. In S1 EPS 11 "Winter Wrap Up," Rainbow Dash starts the Winter Wrap Up song with "3 months of winter..." This would not be possible unless they had an Earth year, Unless the planets angle shifts drastically ever so often. Obviously, this would be a little too much, even for MLP.
The book, Journal of the Two Sisters, states that Celestia was born as an Alicorn. She and her sister Luna would be asked by the Unicorn Starswirl the Bearded to rule the newly formed kingdom of Equestria, as Alicorns had traits of all three kinds of ponies.
Doesn't anyone remember that in applebuck season applejack said that they had their family reunion on the first episode? And on the 1st episode of season 4 it is the next summer sun celebration so it has been a year. So every reunion must happen a little bit before a year knowing that apple family reunion is in season 3!
Yes, which would mostly fit in line with his theory. It would be 100 moons between reunions, so each year is just a little more than 100 moons. Of course that's assuming the second reunion takes place chronologically before the second Summer Sun Celebration, which may not be so.
I find it rather unlikely that the summer sun celebration would be yearly and the MLP cast cast could not have been so close and go on that many adventures in 1 year and in baby cakes it's stated 1 yea month has pasted and it's not said they have done anything but of course they would have because in I don't know anymore
or maybe my little pony has a different time period. cuz they dont live on earth maybe they live on another planet or Equestria is a planet. Just like on Jupiter or Mars they have more earth nights in one day or something. Maybe Equestria is different and maybe 20 days is a month or 12 days but all I know we don't know they just probably have a different time period
I can't spell so sorry selestia said we must rid ourselves of are magic so that equstra AND the lads beound it might be saved so it is not a planet just twilights kingdom
You see, everyone forgets that from the Summer Sun Celebration in Friendship is Magic to the Summer Sun Celebration in Princess Twilight Sparkle 2 years had passed. There's no way that 2 winters had passed between the 2 Summer Sun Celebration, and since we have the end of winter in Winter Wrap-up and the winter in Hearth's Warming Eve it means that there was one Summer Sun Celebration between them. So, it means that two years would have passed from the beginning of season 1 to the beginning of season 4, this means that the Apple Family Reunion happens every 2 years (100 moons), which means that as Notion first stated, 1 years equals 50 moons.
@Peter Molitor So, basically, you believe that Hearth's Warming Eve is the only episode between Lesson Zero and Mystery on the Friendship Express that happened before Season 2? Well, have luck with that. I'll keep my theory though.
@Darien Hilmerson Quite logical, but still very strange, perhaps the summer sun celebration got pushed back. and by part the date changed? Instead of the date that Nightmare Moon was banished, it was changed to the date Princess Luna returned? It seems very odd not to hold the reunion on the same date each year, so that the family can plan around it, instead of the inverse. (Yeah I know, I doubt that Equestria would've stayed without celestia very long, as Nightmare Moon returned EXACTLY 1000 years later, and that it SEEMS that all of episode 1/2 happened in one night.)
Equestria has more than one moon so the idea of a lunar cycle is really inconsistent because no one is exactly sure which moon they're talking about but everyone is too embarrassed to admit it so they just pretend they know how long a moon is but in reality, no one in Equestria actually knows.
If there are 100 moons in a Equestrian Year and a Equestrian Year is twice the length at would make a moon roughly one Earth week, which would mean Twilight and her friends meet once a week.
100 moons = 2 of our years? That would make Celestia's statement of their being 1 year between the pilot and season 4 premiere feel like it makes more sense, given everything that's happened. But Equestria NOT being Earth also means they don't need to have all four seasons.
@Ben N This theory is now further backed up by 'Tanks For the Memories' being the first Running of the Leaves, and 'Make New Friends But Keep Discord' being the first Gala since season 1. Too much has happened for seasons 1 to 4 to be one of our years, so it stands to reason that 1 Equestrian year is more equal to two of our years than to one.
There's something very wrong in the show. The first picture in the album shows granny Smith a little foal but in another episode granny tells us that she discovered ponyville when she was at least a little younger than apple jack.
Hm true but this is equestria we are talking about here. I don't think they use 'years' there but this is just my opinion anyway. I dont think they even mentioned the word 'years' throughout the series but correct me if I'm wrong
Red Midnight Rose years are mentioned frequently. Luna was banished to the moon until “the longest day of the thousandth year”. Discord was a statue for a thousand years or more I think. Rarity says the council of friendship is how they’ve ruled together over the years.
Actually, four of our years equal to one Equestrian year. Just think about it. Season one episode one took place during the Summer Sun Celebration. Fast forward to season four episode one. Celestia said that it was Luna's first SSC since her return. Given that time remains constant between our world and theirs, and that there was one season per year, gives us one Equestrian year to one of our years.
I agree with the first part of the theory, but you said 100 moons was 2 years for the Apple family reunion. Then less than a minute later you said you thought 100 moons was 1 year??
I have a theory! even tho this is 5 years late so ponys dont age as quick as humans do so 100 moon can still be 8 years because look at an image of twilight from season 1 and then an image of twilight from season 9 twilight hasn't really gotten that big and 1 episode is 1 week because before twilight wrote reports to princess celestia she did one every episode and the reports were weekly so 26 x 9 = 234 thats 234 WEEKS and twighlight hasnt aged much and look at like rainbow dash season 1 to season 9 like all the ponys dont age that quick and 234 x 7 is 1638 then do 1638 / 365 and u get 4.4 years so twighlight doesnt age like at all through 4.4 YEARS so then that could be 50ish moons so if they went to season 18 we might've seen an apple reunion 2
Well in warriors 1 moon is a month, but as you said this is the pony world not earth. As warrior cats known it. So I'm just guessing that 1 moon is a month.
AHEM I figured it out! Season 7 episode 10 after starlight spends the evening with Luna twilight says, “The last time celestia and Luna fought, celestia had to banish her for 1000 years !” And for the rest of the series it’s referred to as 1000 moons In conclusion 1 moon = one year
One year in equestria is 3 seasons because in the first episode of season 1 it was the summer sun celebration or whatever it was called and in the first episode of season 4 Celestia said that it was the summer sun celebration since Luna came back from moon, it doesn’t have anything to do with how long a moon is but maybe someone smart can use this and measure the time between the apple family reunions.
@Sawtooth I think "moon" is a month. I also think it's the same way that the Disney Fairies movies use it. In Tinker Bell and the Lost Treasure, The calendar showed one month until the Autumn Relvery, and Terence said that equals to a moon.
If Equestria took place on the Moon (think the Lunar RPG series) and Earth is actually Equestria's Moon (rotate frame 0:26 90° to the right). Then 100 Moons is 100 Earth days, or around 3.33 Earth months.
The Apple family have a reunion around each change of a season on Earth's subtropical area, or 1/4 of an Earth year. It makes sense for them as farmers to base their reunion on each change of season on their Moon. Think of it as farmers using the whole 'Harvest Moon' method.
Daytime or Nightime for them is 15 Moons, or 15 Earth days.
Of course IF Equestria Girls took place on Earth, then 6 Moons there will be around 180 Moons on Equestria.
Example: At Manehattan. The owner of the store Pinkie Pie want to buy the Pouch for Maud Pie, left the store closed for a few Moons.
So a Moon is NOT the rough equivalent of an Earth's Month or Week. Because there's no indication that the store would be closed for a few weeks or so (the windows would be closed with curtains). Unless the store owner is just plain psycho like Pinkie Pie, or had an emergency.
Canterlot vacation for a few Moons with the grand niece.
The episode implied, if Pinkie Pie just wait a few more days, the store would open. But she doesn't have days, she's only in town for that day, and she needs the Pouch in a hurry.
So 1 Equestria Moon ≈ 1 Earth Day.
Because… who suddenly left an uncovered store for weeks?
The actual developers of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic are actually quite adept at hinting how long a Moon is. In the Pouch episode, the store is basically left quite open for a few Moons/(Days).
It's okay, right? The Pony World is a relatively safe place, right? Surely it's also protected by magic, right?
Well, there's that female cop, plus that 'Larry the Pony' who wants to touch Pinkie Pie's 'sweet party cannon'. Not so safe.
Eventhough the entire episode felt like it was taken from the Sex and the City (or Sex in the City) TV series.
And ah yes, Princess Luna said hi. She also wanted to tell you that Princess Kaguya's story was based on her own 'banishment'. Eventhough Twilight Sparkle's look and feel was based on the typical Princess Kaguya look and feel.
I remember in Warriors (This book with the clan of cats) they tell that they have 1 moon or 2 moon for their âge, the moons if i remember here are 1 moon for 1 mounth. So the moons can be in equestria the Same ?
@Kaylee Molina That is a fact that i'm not going to deny. It's just that I made that comment 3 years ago so I don't even remember what the video was about XD
@Melissa Kittelson @some abomination from another dimension Thanks you two, so I wasn't wrong in my assumption it was a month. Even tho it's now been years since I wrote this comment XD
You should remake this, because in the episode where rainbow dash tries to stop winter. Applejack mentions that winter will be over in a few months. Just an addition :)
When the writers want to mess with children's minds and instead of SIMPLY saying days, months, years etc. They went and said MOONS. ARRRRGGGHHHHH Lauren Faust WHHHHHHHHYYYYY
Have you considered that the first episode when Twilight arrived in ponyville, she meets applejack, and later on when twilight asks about "all the ponies at the farm" when they first met, AJ was like Nawww that was just the apple family reunion.
My cousin is a warrior cats fan and she tells me some stuff, so I do know moon = Month so 100 months and if you do the math... 8×12+4...so 8 years and 4 months.
I don't think the sun goes around Equestria. Celestia and Luna just lift the sun and moon up and down. Considering that, i have no idea what they mean by a "moon" or how they would measure it. So how long is an Equestrian moon? However long the writers need it to be. From Ponyville to Canterlot is far enough that it requires an overnight sleeper trip, or you can hop over and back in an afternoon jaunt. Canterlot is visible from Ponyville in some stories, and even Manehatten is close enough to see a Rainboom over Sweet Apple Acres. If distances are negotiable, why not time?
I always thought that 2 seasons = 1 human year. Because we only have a hearths warming episode every two seasons. But yeah it’s true no one really knows.
Not that you will see this but I just finished watching season 8 episode 5 Grannies Gone Wild and they said they do their trip ever moon, later in the episode they preceded to tell rainbow dash that they will see her same time next year. Conclusion a Moon = a Year. As for the ageing with Apple bloom, we all know that the ages of ponys is a little weird given celestia and Luna being over 1000 years old.
I think there are two moons in a month because the Moon is a passage of time between a new moon and a full moon every new moon a full moon is considered a different Moon so there's two moons in a month because there's always a new moon and a full moon in a month so that means that 24 moons a year that means there would be roughly 4 years before the next family reunions
But wait... the sun and moon can’t revolve around just equestria. What about the other lands, like the land of the Hippogryphs or whatever? How does the cycle work there??
Okay okay, i might sound silly, but luna raises a moon everyday! So I'm guessing 30 moons is a month therefore 100 moons is around 3 months and 10 days?!?
BUT WHAT ABOUT LUNA? SHE WAS BANISHED FOR 1000 MOONS - WHICH IS, ACCORDING TO THE THEORY 20 YEARS, BUT SOMEHOW ALMOST EVERYPONY FORGETS SHE EVEN EXSICTED IN THE FIRST PLACE.
did you know that both moon and month means "ay" in Turkish? Yeah, we call both moon and month "ay". So i mean, it makes sense that 1 moon in 1 month. But i doubt that Faust actually knows Turkish XD
I think 100 moons=3 or 4 years because the Apple Family reunion took place in season 4 and the first appearance of the Apple Family took place in the very first episode of season 1. And also most big family reunions happen every 3 or 4 years. (That is how my mom’s side of the family does it)
@Shadic I still prefer a geocentric theory of Equestria, that even though Celestia does "raise" the sun, the movement is not because she's actually moving the sun around the planet, but that's she's revolving the planet, and the primitive minds of Equestria do not know the difference.
@Henry goh One flaw in that... Well, maybe. If she is turning the planet, what is Luna doing with the moon then? Ok, probably just aligning it. Rotate a planet, move a moon. And.... HOLD UP! When Twilight had all the talents of all the princesses and forgot to raise the sun... That must've been one HECK of a wobbly tumbling of the world. And no one felt anything...?
@Henry goh Interference with that hypothesis: Season Finale Twilight's Kingdom. ************************ Watch the sun movement when it is risen in part 2. **************************** Revolving Earth? Nope.
@Henry goh Up, down, then up again in disarray? When something rotates, it requires notably more work to rotate it in different directions than in one direction only.
@RubberyCat Are you implying that the princesses don't have this power? If Celestia alone could raise the sun with ease, why couldn't Twilight do more with all the alicorn magic combined as one.
@RubberyCat I'm not, it's a rhetorical question meant to counter your previous statement. It's a very common rhetorical device in a lot of written works.
@Henry goh ...And a rhetorical question do not require an answer, at least not from anyone else than the one that asks it. And it is still not the important question.
It is indeed rhetorical, as the answer is a clear yes, but the real problem, and question is then why she rose it in disarray? The point is to make a slow and ordered rise, and any simpler form of rotating do cause a very ordered rise, not a disordered rise.
Twilight had no reason to rise it in disarray, so if she was indeed rotating the planet, it would not have risen in disarray, but ordered.
@Henry goh Take a look at the stars in that scene. They don't move along with the Sun. If Twilight was indeed rotating the Earth, they would wobble around, too, if not as much as the Sun and the Moon.
@Smilley MLK Hm.... yes. However, the planet does not do a full rotation. In Twilight's lack of control, she raises and sets the sun from the same direction, not east to west. The moment the sun goes down and the stars are shown, the rotation of the planet does not continue, thus the tars do not move as well. Twilight is focusing on the moon at that moment, not the rotation of Equestria's planet.
@Shadic where did I say in my one that you said matpat was bad 1. and 2 people make more mlp theroys then game ones and finaly if he was like matpat he would do more diging in the FNAF theories he says the rain is something no one notices or talks about but BN doesn't even look at the flipping of the pages the show shows the 3ed reunion pic not the second if he was like matpat he would bring that up but he doesn't hes more inexpirents then matpat or protomario or any other one of the people who do there job how its done
omg i have a theory !!!!!!XD ik in my little dashie thats why it was fifteen years in the human world and fifteen days in the pony world..... D: um..........
1 moon is 36.5 human days I know this because when Equestria girls came out sunset shimmer had been in the human world for 30 moons and there are three pictures of her as the queen of fall formal in principle Celestia's office therefore she had been there three human years. 30 divided by 3 is 10 so that's ten moons as one year. 365 divided by ten is 36.5
Here's what I think: 1 moon is 1 day right? If 1 moon is 1 day then 100 moons is 100 days but 100 days is not nearly as long as a year in our time. in our time a year has 365.24 days but maybe in equestria 100 Days is a year remember equestria is not earth. :)
Well, about the Apple Family Reunion, they had one in the first episode, Friendship is Magic. Ep. 1 Season 1. If that gives any information, use it. Even though this vid. is 5 years old considering the current time.
If that is the case, the we can use the following math: 29.530589 days per lunations So 100 moons = 2935. 0589 days there are (365+365+365+366)/4 = 365.25 days per year (roughly) So 100 moons = 2953.0589 days = 2953.0589/365.25 years = 8.085 years.
I just like to point out the fact that it is a possibility that the planet that Equestria is on is closer to its sun meaning that every hundred moons could be one year thank you that is all
I have to know what a year is in Equestria! As in I need a Cannon Answer! Also I wanna know how long Ponies live for compared to us. I think they have a lifespan similar to us. Also how tall is Celestia? So many questions!
I figured it out. thirty moons are thirty mondays because monday is named after the moon. Almost every day of the week is named after a planet. Eg. sunday named after sun. thats pretty obivious
Wait but wasn't Nightmare Moon banished for 1000 moons or something like that? That would mean that she was on the moon for 10 years so she would probably be around when the mane 6 were fillies. That doesn't really add up because they would remember her plus we know it was really long ago.
This was way after you posted this video but in season 8 episode 4 Grannies gone wild Goldie Delicious says this “We’ve been going to Las Pegasus every moon we can remember! And even some we don’t remember. Same time, next year?” The only problem with my theory is that you’re two examples don’t fit in. 100 years means that the apple family would seize to exist. Equestria girls doesn’t fit either since five decades (decade = ten years) is a long time to be stuck in a dimension with Pinkie Pie being creepy. Honestly though, has it never occurred to you that they use Chinese time measurement to signify a year as in Chinese New Year when a full moon is in the sky. Their year starts between 21 January and 20 February. So while I am still young I hope my theory can be confirmed at some point.
Me before video: OH BOY TIME TO GET ALL WARRIOR ON YOU. So there are 12 moons in a year (the warrior universe states that every full moon is +1 moon), 12×8=96. So, by warrior logic, if we were to complete it by adding 4, the final answer would be: 8 years and 4 months.
What about this; we have 52 weeks in a year and 52 times 2 is 104 which means one moon equals about a week in our time. This would also make sense in Equestrian Girls as 30 moons would be 30 weeks. I guess just another way to put it?
Ponies probably don't even count in Base 10. (We only do that because we have ten fingers, herp-derp.) Their number system is probably in Base 12. If nothing else, it would be more in line with the concept of Harmony being represented by 6 different people.
On a side note, I wonder if the wizards in Harry Potter count in Base 7.
Yeah I thought the same thing! I have the feeling that if I brought that up only a couple of people (including you) would get what I'm saying. Different bases are confusing to think about. XD
I get with what your saying so yea because they could be using a different base number than us but at least we know their number has the as ours due to the square root problem did in her song about no being ready for the test to save the Crystal Empire
I think that this vid is very reasonable, but would the pony dimension have the same time as the uh-er sorta human dimension? Because I'm pretty sure that Vice-Princable Luna doesn't raise the moon in the sorta human dimension. Love ur stuf The Brony Notion!
Sometimes I wish that the official can really tell all the answer of these mystery Or like where do celestia and luna come from and how cadence be alicon but weak in magic spells
Okay ... Now I know about moons. But I don't know how old is the to royal sisters? Well Brony Notion talked about when the elements of Hamony were used, but he also said nightmare moon and discord was banished for a thousand ?
There were more Apple family members introduced to Twilight in the pilot episode than there were members in the third reunion photo... Why weren't they in the picture? That kinda destroys the purpose.
@The Brony Notion but in Applebuck season, Applejack specifically says "they were just here for the Apple family reunion, they actually live all over Equestria.
@The Brony Notion Applejack seems to have a very extensive family, but just like most other families, there could be reasons as to why several members don't show up. Several members show up in Apple Family Reunion that were missing in Episode 1, and vice versa. This could be due to one obligation or another, plus we never see Aunt and Uncle Orange at the reunions. Their absence is most likely due to the fact that they are high-society ponies (the kind that Rarity would get along with) who wouldn't bother going because the reunion is on a "Dirty, old farm."
@Samantha Henney thats exactly what i wanted to say!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! when twilight became apple jack's friend all the members were there.. if u ask me its a reunion theres also an episode where apple jack wins some kind of award also she is busy helping her friends like making cupcakes with pinkie and it just made ponies sick... apple jack was really tierd and needed help but refused to take help in that same episode twilight was asking apple jack if the other members of her family cud help her in apple bucking i dont quite remember the whole scene but yea thts all i remember if possible i wub have just told u the name of episode
In the first episode of my little pony they say that Luna was on the moon for 1000 moons and then later in the episode twilight says Luna’s been trapped for 1000 years
Equestria is kind of earthy or a continent or something... since spike held a globe on his birthday as he was greedy... and the first episode, when twilight meets applejack, they had a family reunion... so it can’t be 100 moons=8 years so... yea maybe it might be 1 or 2 years.
From my perspective it’s got to be at least 13 years because if there are only three photos that means that it must’ve been a longer time and I do you think I can explain about why Apple Bloom didn’t change in the photos you see these for a long time ago the photos were for a long time ago which means since they probably didn’t decide which day they shouldThere reunion they made it like only three days but since they got older they were able to decide then
I think the ponies do live on earth just a different earth the reason I believe this is because in S2 E1 The return of harmony: part 1 Twilight said “Applejack, I need you to bring those height-strung storm clouds back to earth.”
I know there are already a bunch of comments saying this but if you don't read Warriors you are missing out on so much and a moon is everytime the full moon comes so 28 days or approximately a month.
Hmm maybe Granny Smith is from a time where they counted by moons instead of years or days just like how ancient humans did
0 likes
K Foley2021-01-24 15:31:12 (edited 2021-01-24 15:31:45 )
I wonder if celestia is the only creature in the world where equestria exists that can control the sun. We've seen creatures from the lands beyond equestria that exist (like tirek) so do they have their own way of raising the sun and moon? Or do they depend on the ponies for that.
i think that luna and celestia do not have the power to control the sun and moon but rather something else is going on, in the season 2 final canterlot has a magic bubble around it to protect its self from changelings i believe that the planet has a magic bubble around it that creates an artificial sky and therefore they could "move" the sun and moon by changing the appearance of the bubble thats is also why in the nightmare moon universe from the season 5 final is not frozen on one side and barren on the other, the bubble could also protect the planet from asteroid impacts and alien invasions
Wait just a minute I have a question about the Apple family reunion Wasn’t there an Apple family reunion when Twilight first came to Ponyville? So what’s the logic behind that?
Acctualy, moons wasn't a word created in warrior cats, it was acctualy created in medieval times to represent the so now called months; the word moons isint only used in mlp or warrior cats ita also used in various films and books
Actually Equestria is Earth. Well, not Earth exactly, but it is on Earth. In "A Hearthswarming Tail" Pinkie says, "The EARTH is round. There is no up or down." So Equestria is on Earth. This puts a different complexion on things. A lunar cycle on Earth takes about 29.5 days, which is about a month. So that's why I always thought that a moon was a month.
i think this can't be true because that means luna was trapped in the moon for 20 years and that doesn't make sense. I know this video is old but according to perfect pear (season 7 episode 13) granny smith was young and luna was in the moon. this means granny smith would be a maximum of 40 years. Like if you agree.
EDIT: i forgot to add a few spaces before 1st paragraph (sorry!)
Before i watch this, this is my estimation on how long 100 moons is: in warrior cats, (you might have heard) 1 moon means about 1 month. there are 12 months in a year, so if i divide 100 by 12, we get 8.3 (and some other 3s) which means100 moons is about 8 years and 3 months, or moons. it would be that way according to warrior cat time. I used warrior cat time because they are the only other franchise i know of that uses "moons" as time. this my be correct, it may not. but leave thoughts on if my theory is right or wrong in my replies (if you want).
Thank you, and this is MatPat Brony signing out, BRO HOOF! (hope you liked the extra bit :D)
I would say it’s once a month couse it seems pretty logical. I used to have meetings with friends from primary school once a month back in day. One week would be to small amount of time and one year would be to big. One moon = one month is just PERFECT.
100 moons is VERY LONG in Warrior Cats! I'm a Warrior Cat fan! Triggered Claw (Tiger Claw): I WILL GET YOU DERITTO PAW (Fire Paw, he was a Deritto colored pelt)!!! Lol.
2:45 but remember granny applesauce refers to an incident 6 reunions before it is possible though that all the pictures taken in front of the barn weren't shown.
But wait if one hundred moons is one year... Then one thousand moons is ten years........... Hmmmmmmm................ Luna was stuck in the moon for ten years..... That's not a very long time.
@lightningbro Exactly. Math is also about logic and reasoning in itself. Science is basically math because it shares those aspects, and, as you said, is a bit of 'I'm bored let's do something awesome' sprinkled here and there. :)
If some pictures from the family reunion are missing. And it's between Granny being a young mare and a grandma then that means that the parents were alive for the others. So Granny likely removed those photos with the parents. Hence why they aren't there and there's a gap........ That's really sad😢
The show did mention year,like the Star Swirl episode and the one that princess Luna came back.like what Celestia said:”it has been a thousand years since I’ve seen you like this.”
Wait if celestia has been always in equestria, how many candles does she Need in her birthday cake :/ Also if princesses live forever is twilight going To live forever?
+Omni Tear Little Apple Jack is so cute!!!! And when i heard Brony Nations response to Little Apple Jack, i started crying and laughing!!!!!! Bro Hove!
DAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW! I LIKE DIS VID! DAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW!
it is one 100th of an Equestrian year. If an Equestrian year were the same as our year it could be up to 3.6 days, making 30 moons about 3 and a half months. The only real measurement of a year in Equestria is the passage of the cycle of the four seasons. but that's for the first Equestria Girls movie as it said if twilight doesn't get back in 3 days she'd be stuck for 30 moons so small time of being stuck
It's just not our Earth. And also, technically, the name of the world Equestria is in is not called Equestria. The name of their planet would be called Equestrion. At least according to me and my head-canon story on DeviantArt, which I titled "The Creation of Equestrion."
u know I love the first mlp Equestria girls but am I the only one that thinks it would be cool for twilight to get stuck in the portal u know like a fanmade one
woah woah woah buddy first of all: it says in a mlp book offical mlp book to be exact that 1,000 moons is 1,00 years its moons and years like if u agree and im not hating
Sorry but, Woah woah woah buddy, first of all: It says in the MLP book, the official book to be exact, that 1,000 moons are 100 years. It's moons and years, like if you agree, and I'm not hating.
Everything not in the show, even if official, isn't cannon. Comics, books and EqG are this overwritten by show in which 1000 moons clearly isn't a year. Case in point, Granny was in Ponyville for a much longer than 10 reunions but when she moved in Princess Luna was already long gone on the moon.
@Lavender Flower about apple bloom looking too young? if 10 years equals to 100 moons, then apple bloom looks the same for atleast the 10, maybe even 20, years. and she is still a kid til the last season, because they turn into adults once
It can't be two years because in Equestria Girls 1 Luna said the portal opens once every thirty moons. Unless you consider how long the portal stays open then that would make Sunset Shimmer over sixty years old, because she would be in the world for thirty moons. However, I have a little theory of my own to explain this. You already determined that ponies are about two feet, and usually the life span of an animal or creature is based on their size. So I think time works differently in Equestria, which explains the season confusion and why all the characters are in High School in the movies. The time goes slower so that they can have a closer to normal size life.
1 moon is 36.5 human days When Equestria girls starts sunset shimmer had been in the human world for 30 moons and in principle Celestia's office there are three pictures of sunset shimmer as princess of fall formal therefore she has been in the human world for 3 human years 30÷3=10. 365÷10=36.5 Although, I probably did the wrong math...
Moon to takes 29.5 days right so do this 29.5 X 100 = 29500 days 4 weeks every month 12 months every year 4 X 12 = 48 29500 % 48 =614.3333333 So 613.3333333 is how much 100 moons are
Starts gasping for air This took me long and I told my parents and I did to much math and I NEED AIR!!!
To all the people who says a moon is a year you know that episod where pick e pie is getting more A rock pouch the guy who sells this dated he would be at a place for 2 mins And I think he was talking about his family members WHY WOULD HE BE VISTING FOR TWO YEARS
Well 100 moons is 100 years bc in the episode when princess luna comes back from the moon celestia says "ive missed you, you've been gone for 1000 years" and almost all of us know celestia vanished luna for 1000 moons! so also in equestia girls 30 years till twilite could come out. Like if u aggree
Here’s what will happen if cameras existed way further back in time: The first photo of granny Smith would be a baby second photo would be a Child and the next photo would be the same thing and then the next photo Granny Smith will be an adult and in the next photo she would be old so that means in the photo after the current photo Apple Bloom would be an adult
A year is based on the seasons, not the sun. Why the seasons are caused, I have no idea. Oh wait, cloudsdale creates them. (Gasp) cloudsdale comes up with how long a year should be.
I figured it out one moon is one human WEEK because there is about 50 weeks in a year two years would be 100 moons because it would be one hundred weeks to
I think that a 100 moons is about 10 years but then again there is the Apple family reunion which messed up my analysis and well there u go I still think it's 10 years tho which means 30 moons could be 3 years
No, it says "She was banished to the moon forever, but on the longest day of the thousandth year, the stars would aid in her escape" Or something like that, nothing to do with moons (except for Nightmare Moon)
It was also stated in the Crystal Empire part 1 that the Empire had been gone for 1000 years but was later mentioned to be 1000 moons in the Flurry Heart episode. Coincidence? I THINK NOT. 1 Moon = 1 year so the question must be how long is a year in Equestria
For real I have always wondered how long is a moon and how long would 100 be or 30 moons be- Yet even after watching this and all 9 seasons of mlp I STILL DON'T KNOWWWWW!!!!! (I'm terrible at math (I'm only 11-))
Phases are wrong. U said equestria. Twilights map has other places outside equestria. Ponys +spike are NOT astronauts. Equestria is not a sphere. The mlp universe is. So phases can be a thing but not your idea of them.
This was purely for entertainment. PLEASE NO CRITICISM.
I think 1 moon=1 month. Not just because of warriors my friends. I think that a moon is a month because there is a new moon/full moon EVERY MONTH! So that's just my idea.
You know how in Warrior cats moons are taking as Months well maybe it’s the same in mlp and 100 months is 8.33 years and that’s why granny Smith is still alive but maybe they change how many years they wait to the the Reunion
I have a family of at least 25 people in Calgary, AB (the rest is in my country and scattered around AB) ..... We have a family reunion in Calgary almost every Sunday ;-; thank God most the time I don't go.
I think a 1000 moons is 1000 days because when night comes the moon is there and when day comes it goes and then at night it comes again and when the moon comes 1 time I think that’s like 1 day on earth
Maybe it’s more of a handoff like one ruler takes it for date and rotate over there area or kingdom and then another war takes it and moved it over there kingdom and so on so Fourth.
Let us solve this....29.530589 days per lunation....100 lunations....So 100 moons = 2953.0589 days There are (365+365+365+366)/4 = 365.25 days per year (roughly) So 100 moons = 2953.0589 days = 2953.0589/365.25 years. So the answer to this riddle is..... 8.085 years.
Wait..... so in my little pony there on a separate planet??? Or a different universe were instead of humans it was ponys and the sun and moon were created by some elder alicorn or something possibly Luna and celestias parents who passed there job onto there children. (Then we put into light the flurry hart videos telling us about alicorn history) but this pony planet must be smaller than earth because of the size of the map or there's more places and equestria is just a little bit of it on there are other places over seas witch exsplains why it only takes a train ride to get there. So I imagine a pony Tokyo were the too speak different languages and the alicorn sivlisation was on a different country or somewhere further of the map. And in equestria girls they are travelling trough dimensions not just transferring them to another planet. What do you think?
Wait, but it's said (in equestria) that Luna was banished to the moon for 1000 moons, and that that is 1000 years - meaning that one moon is one year. But that can't be right, right? I mean, it would mean Twilight is stuck in the human world for 30 years, AND Princess Celestia states that Sunset was only a bit before Twilight, and she went through the portal at the end of her studies (cause you know, she turned evil), and then it closed! She couldn't have been there THAT long. And 100 years beetween every apple family reunion just makes no sense! Granny smith was in all four of those photos, making her 400 years old! Which is no, just no. I have no idea what your doing creators of mlp!
Equestria is an establishment, a country if you will, NOT a planet. And about Celestia's and Luna's jobs, referring to another one of Sawtooth's video's it can just be something dramatic and be a "tradition" with other "traditions" on other sides of their planet
OMG I love your vidio's! And about your flurry heart vidio... I saw this other guy who says the artificial alicorns dont have flowy hair cause they dont have enouph magic or havent masterd it yet.
To help u in the first episode of mlp fim the apple reunion was going on when twilight arrived at sweet apple acres we know that because apple jack says that in the apple buck season episode
Warrior cats have moons and also my little pony so maybe my little pony knows warrior cats but never even talk about it so one pony knows them but never tell someone in the pony world.🤔🤔🤔
Equestria is a country that's why there is a bunch of places outside of Equestria like we have the place where Griffin's live that's outside of Equestria hippogriffs also live outside of Equestria so that basically makes it clear Equestria is a country like that basically makes it clear that it is a country I love MLP
celestia and luna were kids/teens when the pillars of equestria sacrificed themselves to banish stygian. 1000 years later, they were freed and celestia and luna were adults.
If u remember my little dashie the movie 15 YEARS in the human years and rarity or some pony said it was only 15 DAYS so maybe 100 moons means pony world is 100 years in the human world
Ok thpugh, just got home from a road trip and while going through a neighborhood I saw the street was called "Equestrian" I was like... TIME TO GO FIND PONY SECRETS (Im not kidding)
Sense you are talking about moons, what about the Warriors series? I know you are a mlp channel but i would like to know this, how long is a moon in the warrior cats series? If you can't answer can anyone else?
Brony nation: Its 1 year! Literally all the people who read warrior cats:ONE MONTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Me:Uhhhhhh, wings of fire is better then warrior cats. Warrior fandom: DIE DIE DIE Me: SIDAFHAISUHFASIDUHFSIAHUAIUH AHHHH This is very off topic
Wait i think 10 moons is one year cuz theres a book that says 1000 moons is 100 years.. i havnt finished school and i start it one year after all other people and just learned how to do this, sonsonen correct me if i am wrong. 🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪
This was made a year ago and there is only 6k wow I was expecting bigger I mean 6k is a big number but evan Aphmau has more (if you don't know aphmau people you should check her channel she has been doing this for 2 or 1 years/year anyway brony there is just a problem the my little pony always shows a full moon so how can the half moon quarter moon ext that we have and how if celestial never like rotates the sun around earth or in any case because to you its not at earth Equestrian (I can't spell it so I just said that)
100 moons is when like for example 1 moon is like when 1 moon phase is complete moon nail (baby moon) till full moon😕😕that was a mouth full hah I said it in one breath and rote it in one breath😁😁
Dawwww! Seriously I get u bro I am like awww screaming right into my mom's ear btw love ur vids I sub and I am 8! EdiT: oh crap I just dropped my mom's iPad on the wooden floor she’s gonna kill me 😟😧😦
Well according to me..... Oh boy how can i explain... You know like if there is a full moon maybe like when ever a full moon come is called in equestria moon just moon
Equestria is more Like America than Earth Equestria Is a country, dragons Live outside equestria Does That Mean they are from another planet? no, or Yakyakastan that is a different Country not a different Planet
Evelyn5000 Boyce-Sauer warriors is not mlp different storys may have different ways of doing things check I've had different time and currency measures in my own writings as well. and I know other writers that do. you can theorize similarities but same series and world they are not
No, all I am saying is that I am watching this in 2017, you didn't get anything wrong XD Its just a two year gap and I found it funny to place this comment XD lol
im just taking a guess cuz I don't know- well for me I'm very intelligent at math & reading but I can bearely do square root but I know division and everything behind that but I don't know much about this planet and I'm a kid.(u can see my picture thingy migigy)
100 moons is 100 years because I read a book about princess loona by G.M.Berrow and it sed every moon we have the sumer sun selebreshen and this mens every year they have it by the way it woldent mack sens if there are more thene1 summer sun seleberashen every summer. It wold also mack sens that Twilight whanted to be quick so she woldent haf to wait for 30 moons (30 years).sorry if I have spelling mistakes I am only 10 and my home countere doesn't speak English
So 2 years are 100 moons? But that would less is to how why. I now it’s different there , but Luna rasie the Moon every night/day. And their dosen’t have to be round. It can esaily be flat. Witch less is to the same question. And if you look on the Pictures Apple granny were à fullt and then a adult but not Apple something forgott name .-. So i think moons dosen’t have any typical thing
You haven't watched mlp properly apple bloom stays the same because the first episode is one reunion you know that because when apple jack is apple bucking and refusing help twilight says what about all those ponies when she first arrived in ponyville and aj replies they were here for the reunion
P well the ponies in that show how have no heat well it wasn't a treat like 100 moons 100,000 moons there might be good enough because I like everything so my cute little friends Coco the dragon had good time 🐺🐉 Coco the dragon she's my least favorite character
Well, due to fanfic/headcanon reasons, I find that at least some of the notions of the length of a moon have got to go. Personally, though, it makes the most sense to me that "moon" as a length of time once existed in Equestria before Luna's banishment, but now it no longer does. Equestria maybe used to have a lunisolar calendar like the ancient Jewish calendar; but now it's a solar calendar like our own, complete with years, months, and weeks. But from times of old, the measure of "moons" stick around, like our "fourscore and seven years ago" or "fortnights", for example--but no one really knows what they mean anymore, because they would have been based on lunar cycles.
Equestria does not currently exhibit lunar cycles, though. The moon is always full; it can be assumed that Celestia didn't honor that part of Luna's movement of the moon when she took over that responsibility, and for whatever reason it has yet to return. That's why the calendar would have been changed in the first place. And that's why really old ponies like Granny Smith, and occasionally others, try to use the "moon" as a unit of time--but they don't have a way to do so legitimately anymore. "100 moons" is then effectively shorthand (shorthoof?) for a set number of days that the Apple family has agreed upon, and it probably happens to be somewhere around a few years. Other instances of "moon" don't seem to line up because they're based on other flawed interpretations of a history forgotten to most ponies.
But the Princesses know how long a moon is. Just ask one. I dare you. (This makes the 30-moon reference for the EQG Mirror activation interval more interesting because they're the ones to explain it...)
I got another theory based on the words pronounced by Luna before Twilight enters the portal in the first EG movie : "On the Third day, when the moon reaches its peak in the night sky, the gateway will close, and once it does, it will be another 30 moons before you will be able to use it to return."
So : basically, the portal connects both worlds together, and their time is completely connected, as well as moon cycles. In the vision Luna makes, we can see the moon changing of stance, and so, a cycle would be 1 moon = 3 days, with the nights working like this : 3 days, 3 nights, full days, but 1/2 night, then 2 full nights, then 1/2 night again. So, in my opinion, a year would be either 100 or 120 moons, to have them like in our world. But I'm absolutely sure that a moon cycle is 3 days, so basically, the Apple family is meeting every year so 100 is more plausible.
I kind of figured the system Cel and Luna worked out would be based on the seasons, possibly even causing them, but I suspect it'd correlate to one of our years (if only because that makes the math easier).
I think 100 moons is one year. my reason is simple if it happens every hundred moons the last reunion they had was when Twilight first came to Ponyville which was actually one year ago because since the start of the season we have only seen to raising and lowering of the Sun and Moon. another thing we can look at is the Canterlot ball.
30 moons can't be less than a year since the portal to the human world in Equestira Girls opens every 30 moons but looking at the number of pictures Sunset Shimmer has as princess of the fall formal it shows she has been crowned three times and such events would take place once every school year meaning she would have had to have been there for at least three years. Unless of course she could have been going back and forth through the portal everytime it opened up to be caught up on what was going on in Equestria and waiting for the right moment to make her move but that is only a thought.
I'm the episode "A Gift For Maud Pie" pike said the owner of the rock pouch store was going to canterlot for a few moons... So Manehatton is pretty close to canterlot so if they were visiting I imagine it be for maybe a week or two. So I think a moon is basically one night/day (24 hours)
Actually, in one episode Twilight says something like "She must still be recovering from being trapped in the moon for 1,000 years" In the halloween episode with Pinkie dressed as a chicken. So, a moon in Equestria is actually one year. The ponies live much longer than us humans and i'm guessing they could live up to about 80,000 years or so. I have known this for a while but forgot to post the comment when i found out
@CutiePants87 MSP And Aj I was just correcting him, and also telling other people. It took me a while to write that, and its just a little info for people wondering. It does have something to do with the video, unlike alot of the other comments, so i think it does mean something
I think that 1 moon = 1 year because on the first episode of mlp season 1 the book says " on the longest night of the 1000th YEAR the stars will aid in....." and then later we here celestia say " it has been 1000 MOONS since I have seen you like this" so this could mean that 1 moon is 1 year or it could have just been a slipup to the script writers
Why are the sun & moon dependent on Magic? Equestria was founded before Celestia & Luna came to be because according to the 1st Hearthswarming episode: before Equestria was founded, Unicorns were responsible for bringing night & day. Why was the sun & moon dependent on unicorns? If that's so then how did ponies ever evolve? How were unicorns able to evolve horns if the sun & moon were supposed to be dependent on them? Unless there's an artificial sky that covers Equestria because the real Sun & moon are dead, but that's another story entirely.
I think that 30 moons would be in-between about 23 and 30 months so 100 moons would be in-between 73 and one third months and 100 months I think 1 moon is 1 full moon I base some of this on a story I read so 30 moons is about 2 and a half years so I think a reunion is about every 7 years and 9 months but we don't really know how long a season is and we know on season five twilight has been there for at least a few years and none of the characters actually age ecsept twilight becoming an alicorn and the CMC getting there cutiemarks but like I said this is all just a theory. Please let me know if I got anything wrong.
it's funny how you explained why you think a moon couldn't be equal to a month but 1/3 of the comments are "1 moon = 1 month" or "100 moons = 100 months"
i just thought that ponys age differently in mlp like they live who knows how many years in that case one moon would be one year but i havent thought about that apple family and nightmare moon thing
I mean it may sound a lot off but the modding photos could simply be fixed with they just didn't have them for the lack of ponies coming to the reunion
I found a mistake in the pictures of the Apple Family!!! In Granny Smith's sharing of her story of her and her family practically starting up Ponyville she was a adultish/teenage pony. In the picture in front of the farm for one of their family reunions she was a filly!!
You are wrong. 100 moons is less than a year. If you look at the timing of the summer sun celebration which takes place every year the apple reunion is in between.
your theroy makes sense, if I am right twilight is 24 years old, but in the human world she's like 17, so equestria must have 50 moons=1 year, while in the human world 1 year=365 like our world, you could fit a little over 7 equestria years in our year, and there is a 7 year age difference between when twilight is a human and a pony.
maybe 1 moon is 1 day as every night the moon comes but... the apple family reunion confuses me. it would make sense being stuck in a world ( equestria girls kind of world :) for 30 days, it kind of a month. maybe i could be wrong about the apple family reunion.
wait if the sun revolves the earth then in one episode when they acted out the beginning of equestria they said that the unicorns raised the sun and moon and later the earth ponies lift the sun using rope
the yaks said they would be friends with the ponies for a thousand "moons", and as u said in the video, that's not really a long time. so will they go to war like right after that short time period? that is only 10 years, but i dont think ur correct because of that. no offense but i just outsmarted u on mlp. :p also im kinda a big fan so dont be offended okie thnx
I have a video I would like you to make brony notion , why doesn't sapphire shores have a cutie mark as you said in one of your video comparing cutie msrks in equestris and in the real world.
I think it could be explanation, but... Yeah Equestria is not year, but also... ponys are not people. What I mean? Thay can grow and becoming mature at other speed than humans. We for sure know that for alicorns - at least at some age - 1000 years isn't time in which she(I would write or he, but there is no male alicorn... and I wonder why, nearly since i started watch the show) could stale... at least in perceptible extent. But as far as i know there's no specific information how it is with other type of ponies. We surely can see that one month ponies are more independent than one month baby, so definitely ponies doesn't grow up in the same pace as human's do. They seem to be faster in it... but who said that in whole live it's the same rate, and in vevery stage of life ponies grow for example maybe 1 month old pony is like 1 year old human, but 1 year old pony isn't like 12 years old human. Maybe pony's growth "slow down" much more than humans, and at some points human began to grow faster? And maybe even 30 year pony is equivalent of 10 year human? I think it could explain a lot of things. For example why they all drin punch(which is alcohol drink... or maybe in Equestria not... or maybe it was just translated into Polish...), ponies from mane six have its own work(like Rarity's shop, Twilight's library, AppleJack's farm etc.), live for their own and their parents wasn't even mentioned(at least till end of fourth season)... and on the other hand they all the time seem rather to be teenegers(their human version attend to highscool(yeah, on the other hand thei drink punch too...), after going to Earth Twilight was in such age). Maybe it's even more than two time slower grow of ponies. Especialy, that we can notice strong time dilatation between Equestria and Earth(if world in Equestria girls really is our Earth... I mean... You know colorful skin and hairs aren't popular in our world). What i mean? This what Dazzlings saw at the beginnig of "Rainbow Rocks" is defeating of Succubus Sunset... so the end of "Equestria Girls". So between first and second visit of Twilight there is only a few days... and at the same time in Equestria it passed definitely more time. Fourth season last at least 26 days, but i think that it could be two times that much, or even much more. Anyway during few days on Earth(I'm sure that Dazzlings didn't want to wait longer than few days) we have more than 26 days in Equestria. This is at least 3-4 times more. If ponies and human would grow at the same pace Earth and Equestrian mane six will be at the same age only through very short period of time. So i think, that pace of growing in Equestria and Earth aren't the same. BTW timeline of series is itself interesting topic, have You ever do some? Of course to do this it's neccessery to assume some pattern of counting time/date. I think that even if Eqestria isn't Earth still best possible solution is to assume that what could be similar is similar and this mean length of day, month, year... because why Celestia and Luna couldn't done it in such way like it is on Earth? The same is I think with seasons and such things like summer solstice. Yeah, I know it was quite long and maybe a little bit complicated, especialy with my not very good english... but i hope You get my point. If You will do some next video about this please let me know.
before watching i think its 8 days because the moon goes the eight stages from full moon to new moon and it takes eight stages for the the moon to go from full moon to new moon and new moon to full moon
though your theories of this are good I think 100 moons is 1 year please tell me if that's your speculation cause I didn't really understand your theory
Granny Smith is arround 100 human jears old because in one Episode we came to know that Sweet Apple Acres is one of the oldest Buildings in Equestria and in one of that Flashbacks was a filly Granny Smith !
6 of our years is 2 years in equestria if you ask how o know this from the 6 years of my little pony there has only been 2 warths warming eve episodes and 2 nightmare night episodes this could give you a clue of how long is 100 moons
Alfredo Sarraga Jr WE DONT CARE, maybe, if you don't understand this, you should be watching something you do understand instead of asking what we mean! Oh, and also, why are you on your dads account?!
1 who is watching this in 2016 2 who is watching in 2016 when season 6 is out 3 who remembers on the third episode "token a sodden vacation. Be back in 3 moons
Alfredo Sarraga Jr I'm sorry, "they're both animals" how stupid can someone be? That doesn't make a tenth of a difference! They're completely DIFFERENT animals!
AmestyTheKittyGamer warriors is not mlp different storys may have different ways of doing things check I've had different time and currency measures in my own writings as well. and I know other writers that do. you can theorize similarities but same series and world they are not
Did Anyone heared Zane in MyStreet Aphmau of Minecraft Diaries Said My Little Horsey/Horsy? Even though its My Little Pony And Zane said Pinkie Cake even its Pinkie Pie and Hhahaha He Called Twilight Sparkles to Twilight Sprinkles Hahahhahaha😂😂😂😂😂😂😃😃😃
the picture that u show when nightmare moon just turn back into Luna why her hair was it following like Princess Celestia and how her hair started flowing like Princess Celestia get did it just take time or it was one day is started up again because remember and season 3 I think the lunar Fest her hair was flowing so your hair
Than what's the other 12 months called? Do you know? !!! If you didn't than all you said was a big fat liye . P.S not saying you liyed P.S your a Grat youtuber !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! P.S thank you for making vid P.S I think your stunning as a you tuber you do a Grat job
Presuming 12 months in an Equestrian year, a moon could be measured by each individual phase. So given 12 months and 8 phases, a moon would be approximately 1.5 months by our time.
Thus 30 moons would be 45 months. Or 3.75 years, which lines up perfectly with the number of times Sunset is stated to have won the crown, and the fact that she was running for the next election when Twi showed up.
100 moons would then be about 12.5 years. This however brings a seeming inconsistency in the form of Applebloom's apparent non-growth between reunions.
Taking into account equine biology we know that the majority of their growth occurs in the first 2-3 years and afterwards further growth is minimal if at all. Assuming a similar growth pattern for Equestrian ponies we could then conclude that Applebloom was fairly young in the first picture and although not much changed in the second had still aged appropriately.
(Perhaps final growth stages only occur after the acquisition of a Cutie Mark? Could Applebloom already be fully grown by our standards? Maybe Equestrian ponies are taller than our ponies due to magical butt-tattoo induced growth-spurts? We may never know, but we can always guess.)
Also, since Meghan McCarthy stated that Friendship Games came 6 moons after Rainbow Rocks this system would place it about 9 months later. That would make them Seniors in their last year, which fits Twilight planning her future academia.
well, there have been two apple family reunions that we know of. The summer sun celebration is held once a year. We have also seen two of those. The first reunion was the day before the celebration in the pilot episode. The next reunion was some time before the celebration.
This leaves two possibilities: 1) the apple family has a reunion 'just about' every one hundred moons. Basically it is around the same time each year, and an Equestrian year is probably 100 moons. 2) the apple family has a reunion exactly every one hundred moons. An Equestrian year is slightly longer than 100 moons since the dates don't coincide exactly and the apple family meets slightly more than once a year (meaning every now and then they meet twice a year).
I'm guessing you got your two years from the fact that The last Apple Family Reunion was the day Twilight first showed up in Ponyville, and we've seen two seasonal cycles since then? It makes sense then, that a year in Equestria would actually be equal to 50 moons, which makes sense because it's a round number and our own year is 52 weeks. The show writers have used our world as a basis for a lot of what goes on in Equestria, i.e. the location of the different cities across the continent and such. Judging by all of this I'd say it's safe to assume that one moon=one Equestrian week.
Don't forget also that in the very first episode Twilight meets a large number of the Apple family on a reunion. We know this because in Episode 4 (Applebuck Season), Twilight asked AJ about it and AJ mentioned it was just the family reunion.
So we know 100 moons sums up the events from episode 1 and 60.
I really don't think it's only 2 years. The apple family reunion seemed like a super big thing. If it's once every two years that is way to much for all the traveling that would take place, let along way too often for the amount if work it takes to out it together. I'm not sure how often it is, but it seems a bit linger then that. Unfortunately there is certainly no way to find out. I don't take equestrian girls as canon at all. And the pictures of the apples, there is more of them that have a large jump in pony ages. So That means it is more feasible that there was something that pushed the last two closer together then normal.
If Diamond Tiara is 16 in the show it's most likely that Applebloom is either 15 or 16 so it is possible to be 8 years(and 4 months counting extra moons) considering she could have been 8 or 7 when it was taken so it's possible to be the same as our years but I don't know if that episode was out at this time so I wouldn't blame you at all for this speculation.
this theory also begs the question of how fast ponies age if its to be based off pictures then depending how fast they age determines how we'd view the time gap
I think that 10 moons is 1 year in equestria and here's my evidence 1. In equestria girls there is 3 photos of sunset winning the formal and its 30 moons, right? The humans would have the formal once a year. 2. In Apple family reunion there is 3-4 photos. Granny Smith would have aged about 10 years in each photo. 3.10 is a pretty easy number to have
i would love a comparison between how much time passed in pony land and how much time passed in equestrian girl (with is more earth like) between two episodes ^^
Equestria's moon is not lit by the sun. in season 4 episode 26 at about 4:23-4:41 Twilight is trying the raise the sun and lower the moon, and you can see that the moon's cycle doesn't correspond with where the sun is
Wait; why couldn't a moon literally be a night that shows the moon, but the night of a new moon doesn't count since the moon is no longer visible? Maybe Equestrian Years are 100 moons, but still... my point still stands.
100 moon are about 17 or 18 years. Sunset Shimmer was princess of the Fall Formal 3 years in a row. Twilight became princess on what would have been the fourth time. Baby Applejack went from baby to current age in 100 moons. So seeing as that would make her a high school senior she is 17 or 18 years old.
100 moons could be refered to as full moons which appear 12 times a year which if you do the math it would about every 8 years assuming they have 12 months like we do.
just a thought: in the Winter-Wrap up song Rainbow Dash sings, "3 months of winter coolness.." Is moon the same as month? Does this mean that there are only 3 moons of winter in 100 moons? That surely explains why everypony is so excited about winter 'cause it's so short O_o
3 18 It's actually possible Equestria revolves around the sun, and that Celestia is just moving Equestria and the moon. This could be caused by magic being emitted from Equestria, or something like that. shrug
didnt applejack have a lot of members of her family when twilight first met her?,and a couple of episodes(4 or 5) later she said that they are only for their reunion!?
I think there is a time difference between our world and the pony world because in rainbow rocks the sirens come a couple days after sunsets defeat but in the pony world there has been enough time to arrange and carry out twilights coronation and discover her castle because I don't think power craving sirens would wait that long for well powerthis or the staff had a continuity problem cough cough spike
The First episode in the series was the last Apple Family Reunion (that we know of) so if it is the last Apple Family Reunion before the Episode Apple Family Reunion, then if we find out how many days went by then we will know how many days are in 100 Moons!
i started to read the text books today, where they talk about about the moons and stuff like taht, without explaining at all how long it is, its more than a day though,
may i ask a question you know how nightmare moon/luna was sent to the moon as a prison for 1000 years if it was 1000 years wouldnt celestia probably be dead or like granny smith?
Ok I couldn't reply to myasthenia comment but I did some calculations and 3/10's of 365 days is 109.5 days which would mean on Earth 30 moons is 109.5 days but in Equestria which TheBronyNotion suggests has years that are twice as long 3/10's of 365 days would be 219 which = 30 moons so it is actually a big deal that Twilight got back through the portal before it closed or she would be missing from Equestria for 219 equestrian days also I have to point out as a girl who has been doing horse riding for almost 4 years I know that something that is equestrian has something to do with horses eg equestrian sports is it just a coincidence that it's called Equestria. Tell what you think. Later guys
I think there is some mistakes in the family reunion photos because as you said why would Granny Smith age so much and applebloom not age all visual wise but 30 couldn't be 3/10 of a year(I'll so the math in a moment and reply to this if possible) it seems like it's way to short for Luna and Celestia to stress about warning Twilight that she kinda has to get back coz thirty moons is a long time is obviously something they need to do because 3/10 of a year isn't that's long is it? I don't know you tell me. Later guys
In one of my books known as cat warriors by Erin hunter the cats uses the moon to messer the time and in the book and once a every full moon they have a gathering and the author explains that it's every month. I'm not sure if that is the same as mlp but that is my thoughts on the theory
+Minecraft LovePlayer awesome I love them too such a great series. I can't wait until the new book comes out lol I forgot the name but who is your favourite character 😁
+Minecraft LovePlayer I do have three of them but I haven't read them yet I need to start thanks for that reminder. Ok instead of saying who is your favourite cat. I will ask who is your favourite dog lol😄
You know, if Equestria wasn't fake, the probably wouldn't use the base 10 numeric systems. Maybe you should dig into that. Check out numberphile's video on this topic.
that makes since because we celebrated the second nightmare night in equestria when its been about 4 years since the Luna reformed nightmare night episode idk but its a good theory
Wait so if 100 moons is only 1 year, and princess luna was sent away from 100 moons (from what I remember) then why 100 like being grounded for a year is not enough time for twilight to be born n stuff it's confusing isn't it
the theory doesn't really make sense as in the first episode the apples had a reunion and then later in the apple family reunion comes and it really doent add up...
One hundred moons are a year BECAUSE if the apple family has their reunion every one hundred moons then basicallly each season is a year and they have it I forgot which season they had it in but the next season they had another one
omg the baby applejack killed me with cuteness it was so cute cute is not enough all I could say about baby applejack is DAW I'm going to die of cuteness please call a ambulance
moons might be days like this 100 moons 100 days not to long so apple family reunion is 100 days not long and in equstria girls they are being dramatic and well you saw how long it takes a villan to destroy equstria.... and that must be it
In equestria girls rainbow rocks when they hav the sleepover there is a crescent moon so i think when luna says 30 moons she means every 30 full moons so twilight would of got stuck there for 15 years!!!! Well that's my theory x
mlp earth dose not move or obit it stands still and Luna and Cunlister move the sun and moon so the earth does not at all this is my theory to you brony notion
i also think that the animators do a thing the thing is the make you focus on stuff happening and the never bother to put in details and babs was met that year an 2 years back is well not in time!
I don't get wants up with the episode nightmare night and the first episode why does everybody think Luna is still nightmare moon even pinkie and she was there when they turned nightmare moon back to luna
hi the brony notion well I know ur probs not gonna read this comment but how old could be the four princesses and the main six? in episode 26 and 25 seanson 5 small rainbow dash says twilight a full grown pony but how come the other alicorns are bigger and taller than her????????????? even tho ur probs not gonna read this well if u do u should DEFFERENTLY make a vid!!
+Heated Small kids Rainbow Dash's age like to over exaggerate ages of anyone who is even a little bit older then they are. They think 20 to 30 year old's are ancient. Just my thought on the matter. :D
You're forgetting that YEARS aren't just measured by solar position. It's also measured by seasons. And we know Equestria goes through the Summer-Autumn-Winter-Spring cycle. One full set of seasons (manually changed) is one year.
Majority of episodes seem to take place during the Spring/Summer days though unless there's some plot specific need for it to be Autumn or Winter.
I have a theory that expands yours: the family bash seen in Episode 1 was a reunion based on the fact that the Summer Sunrise was celebrated in Ponyville. It wasn't one of the "100 moons" reunions, but they were still together and so took a photo in front of the barn. It'd explain why Applebloom is already as old as she is and why the other photos have more time passing in between them. That would make the 1 moon = 1 month theory plausible again.
Moons are also used in warriors. Six moons to become an apprentice from a kit (kitten) and every full moon is a gathering (all four clans meet at the island (current) or fourtrees (past) and every courter moon is the medicane cat meeting at the moolpool (current) or moonstone (past) Any way, I dunno I just wanted to point that out.
Could you do a theory on how old Granny Smith is? In the beginning of the episode Winter Wrap Up, Twilight states, that for centuries the ponies of Ponyville didn't use magic to bring spring. And Granny Smith was the one who essencaly founded Ponyville. I think it might just be a little mix up in the script but I think it's an interesting thing to think about.
I have a different theory: Pony mathematics is actually base 4. Think about it. 10 isn't exactly a very good base for mathematics, 12 or 16 would be better, but we use base 10, because we have 10 fingers. Ponies don't have fingers, but they have 4 hooves, so it is reasonable to assume their math is base 4.
Now I know what you are thinking, they are constantly talking about the "Six Elements of Harmony". But we are not saying "Oneteen and twoteen", we say "Eleven and Twelve", so we can assume the first twelve pony numbers have individual names too. They count ...ten, eleven, twelve, thirty one, thirty two, thirty three, one hundred...
That means 100 pony moons would be 16 human moons. And while I am at it, this also explains how Granny Smith was already alive when Ponyville was founded hundreds of years ago.
In other merchandise, I've seen the term "One moon" meaning a month, aswell as a "Half moon" meaning 2 weeks, and a "Quater Moon" meaning a week. So for now, I guess this is what I'll believe. Although it does bring up questions.. So confusing! D: Great vid tho :3
I think every 5 moons is 2 months in our time, so every 100 moons is every 20 years in our time, but Apple Bloom's ageing would be off the grid and not make scents. Perhaps Doctor Whoves went forward in time and grabbed this aged Apple Bloom and want back and swapped Apple Blooms?
if you read "warriors" you will know that a moon is a month. Also, i think that maybe your right. this was a very well put together theory, and i know this is an old video and im referencing a newer one, but in "is the dream world real?" you talked about dimensions. does earth have dimensions to? that could be likely, as ive always thought there were some connections from video games to our world. that could easily be a dimension, who says it cant be the same with us to equestria? here is the video game line: Legend of Zelda OOT- Super Mario- Mike Tyson's Punch Out- Our world In legend of zelda ocarina of time in the castle garden were you first meat zelda, you can look in windows to see pictures of Mario characters. Mario connects to Mike Tyson's punch out because in Mike Tyson's Punch out, the refery looks so much like Mario that people on line actually call him Mario. Mike Tyson's punch out connects to us because.. well.. its Mike Tyson. Who says this can't be the same for equestria? maybe equestria is a dimension on earth, and we can get there by.. idk... geneticly mutating horses to look like twilight and become unicorns? we have the technoligy. anyways, i haven't found any links to our world, but what am i saying? im not a reveiwer. i watch this stuff for fun.
Didn't Twilight say in the very first episode that NMM would escape on the 1000th day of the 1000th year? That would mean that an Equestrian year would have to be more around the length of three Earth years.
I'm guessing 100 moons is 100 months. Let's see how that could be true. 100 years is way too long, because as brony notion said Luna told Twilight that on the third day of the vist, the portal will close, making Twilight wait 30 moons. But 30 days could also work.
Tanks for the Memories confirmed that the events from season 1 to season 5 have taken place in the span of a year. So 100 moons has to be less then a year considering that the Apple Family had a reunion in the very first episode of Friendship is Magic. They also had a second reunion in Season 3
The last apple family reunion actually happened in the pilot episodes of mlp. In the episode: Applebuck Season, Twilight asks, "What about all those relatives I've met when I first came to Ponyville? Can't they help?" And Applejack promptly replies, "They were just here for the Apple family reunion. They actually live all over Equestria and are busy harvestin' their own orchards. So, uh, I'm on my own." This means a reunion can't happen every 2 years or even every year because the apple family reunion happened in season 3 and it wasn't until season 4 episode 1 when a whole year had passed since the first episode of season 1. In season 4 Celestia says, "For this celebration now represents not the defeat of Nightmare Moon, but the return of my sister, Princess Luna." Which I think she would only say the year after the last summer sun celebration.
According to Erin Hunter, the author of the Warriors series, a moon is a month, half moon 2 weeks and a quarter moon is 1 week. However its quite noticeable that MLP is not the Warriors series.
To the target audience, time is: Wake up, go to school, recess, lunch, school's out, go to sleep, weekend, summer. The show doesn't focus on explaining time even though it is important to the characters in some way. It may just be left as a hole in the plot. Try explaining the use of time in the Star Wars universe.
The equestrian sun doesn't really have to orbit Equestria, it could be that the planet doesn't spin, and the princess grabs the sun with her magic to move Equestria.
Here's what I think. With the Applebloom and 8 years part- the animators got lazy. Also, Equestria is a representation of America, not Earth. We have Saddle Arabia (Saudi Arabia) and YakYakistan (Pakistan). In Equestria, we've got Manehattan, and other city cameos. Equestria itself is a cameo if America. They even sound similar.
I'm not sure that the reunion is every two years since all of seasons 1-4 all take place in one year (first episode Summer Sun Celebration, S4E1 Summer Sun Celebration). I think they all take place around once a year, but it probably took a while for a system to be made up. The Apple family started out to be very small, but they probably made up an exact time for it when it started to get larger and fan out across Equestria. And for some they couldn't have taken pictures for them. We never saw a group photo that included baby AJ, even though we saw a flashback of her.
I'm confused. If the the apple family reunion happens every 2 years and there was a reunion in the Season 1 premiere, does that mean 2 years passed in between the series premiere and the episode "Apple family reunion?" That doesn't make sense because the Season 4 premiere seems to take place only 1 year after the Season 1 premiere because Celestia implies that it's the first summer sun celebration since Nightmare moon's transformation back into Princess Luna.
3:40 I FOUND A CONTRADICTION! "An equestrian year is twice as long as ours." Yet on the screen it says 2 equestrian years = One earth year. Wouldn't that make an equestrian year half an earth year?
I think that hasbro made the moons just to sound more fantasy like, i mean a tv show wouldnt spend loads of time figuring out a new version of time personally i think a hundred moons is 3 or 4 years!
But Discord is 1000 moons old meaning he is about 100 years old. In the show he states the the ponies are the most fun he's had in eons so I think that kind of messes up your theories. Sorry.
According to The Journal of the Two Sisters, Dash turned 10 years old on her birthday. Just thought it'd be helpful information since I haven't seen anyone point it out yet.
I think 100 years is the equivalent amount to 6 years in equestria. I think this cuz, at time 2:52, The Brony Notion shows 2 photos of Granny Smith side by side. The first photo looked like she was 6, and the second pic looked like she was 12. Therefore, I believe there was 6 yrs in between the family reunions. This isn't as detailed and has a bunch of facts supporting this theory, but it's mine ok so plz don't hate on this and get all technical.
If an Equestrian year is two of our years, that would mean that Rainbow Dash's 10th birthdayversary was her really her 20th birthdayversary. Assuming that ordinary ponies age at the same rate as us and they usually get their cutie marks between the ages of eight and 12 in our years and Rainbow moved to Ponyville after she got her cutie mark, that would make all of the Mane 6 at least 28 in our years. That's ridiculous. And look at how much time has passed in the show! I think that, in the show, it's been between one and two years since the first episode (things just aren't in the right order). Any more is ridiculous since the CMC are already late getting their cutie marks.
I just discovered something when I saw the pictures of the apple family reunion Granny Smith was smaller than when we saw in the story of family apreciasion, if you still don't understand, read this to explain better: when we hear the story of Granny smith, we can see that her family was one that founded ponyville but she looked as Applejack's age, but in the first picture that they're building the barn, she looked smaller than in the story, but when we see the next picture this as in history
I like to use the fact that each day is 20 minutes long but that got confusing. And because of the fact solving a friendship problem takes 20 minutes as established in Slice of life I figure the minutes of Equestria and Earth could be equal. So I officially give up.
This brings a question to my mind (which oddly enough does not involve this video) who's AJ's parents? Is GS her Grandma from AJ's dam's side or sire's? This would totally make an interesting video! :)
I never saw AJ's parents, but I don't saw every episode. I think they are dead or something, but I want the question answered where they are or what happend to them. I hope we will see it in an episode.
For warriors fans after analysis it is decided that a moon=a month, and ponies age quicker than humans, unless ponie logic doesn't work that way. This is before watching the video
odd thing to say is in "its about time" twilight holds up a calendar with only and if i remember correctly it only had 15 days also in the first episode there is a reunion going on
I'm gonna guess 2 years. Why? because in Applebuck season, she said the family had a family reunion, so they were only there for a little period of time. Also, Apple family reunion came out almost two years after Applebuck season. But then again, it's a show that could take place at any time.... so.... :P.
If a 100 moons = 2 years to the apple family then how does it then equal 1 year(you said this later in the video after your first statement). You stated 2 completley different ideas in 2 minutes please explain if I missed something or he just screwed up his script..
It's just like if you add up from the first episode of twilight moving to ponievill on the rising of sun till the next time it happens in season 4 that has to be a year and if we say every episode is what happens in a day then that would make it 66 days or round about there when you count the first movie in a year.
well eg (eqeustria girls) takes place after season 3 due to her trying to get used to her new wings and rr (rainbow rocks) takes place after season 4 so is that 30 moons?
I have a belief that in Equestria, things don't actually work like they do in ours. Like, at all. The land that Equestria rests upon may not be a planet, it may literally be flat. Yes, I do realize our world doesn't work that way, but Equestria is in a completely different universe, so it shouldn't be too much of a stretch for the Sun and Moon to be moved by the two main Princesses. Expanding upon that, it is entirely possible that the Sun and Moon in the MLP universe aren't as massive as they are in ours, and that while the sisters' power may be great, it isn't THAT powerful.
I thought that a moon was a day, like you could, not go throught the portal for a month, for in rainbow rocks it is shown that it was not a long time since twilight's first vist the the other world, for season four was not a full year in equestria, at least of what we know.
wow! that was amazing I love how you talk about cutie marks and bla bla bla but anyway keep making these great videos please (new watcher qistyna adam chia's dauther )
wait wait wait! there was an apple reunion on the very day that twilight came to ponyville. the very next one was in season three... a few episodes before twilight became an alicorn. so twilight has only been living in ponyville for one year? she did a lot of stuff in only one year time!!
If thats true.. 1000moons (the amount of time luna was imprisoned in the moon) would be only 10 years... why would everyone in ponyvill forget about Luna? You theory has been debunked i think.
i think 100 moons is 10 months... bc i just finished watching arthur and the invisibles, and acxording to the movie, 10 moons is 1 month... (not saying that anyone is dumb or anything...) 10x10=100. 😋
100 is moons could possibly be 100 years, but ponies in equestria dont age like us. After all Celestia is 1000 moons old right? She seems pretty young too, showing that 100 years for them, is still 100 years, but they have a longer life to live, because, they are part of a tv show and they are unicorns and pegasus's XD And earth, but they all talk o3o
celestia and luna: well luna dont move the moon i think she moves there earth what ever they call there earth, celestia moves the earth on morning up and luna moves the earth down at night.. i know it seans crazy but i think that is how it works
OK. Here's my theory. Luna and celestial don't have a plan, why would they? Honestly if they had a plan then y would the moon always stay the same? If I'm correct 100 moons could just be 100 days. But u r right, equestria is not earth. Maybe 100 moons is 1 year? We know that we rarely have a different sized filly or mare so it is possible granny smith just was becoming a made and so her size was changing. This theory has lots of loop holes but wut if its correct?
20 moons + 20 moons + 20 moons + 20 moons + 20 moons = 100 moons 100 moons = 1 year they have 5 months in one year there are 4 weeks in a month and 5 days in a week any questions?
Ever heard of native people you know like cree here's a word tansi :translation: hello every moon is like a month maybe it was like this maybe Lauren Faust was cree?
Of course Equestria isn't earth. There's two whole movies about going to a different world without the same magic and as humans where as in Equestria they are magical skittle colored ponies with wings and horns that make magic. I won't go on unless you want me to continue this.
Look at the pic of the real moon It looks like NM is on it Wait... NM on are moon means that Mlp could have exited long ago and we used to be ponies and radiation turned us to humans as magic faded away forever!!!!!????!!! 😧
Didnt the same time pass in equestria then the time that canterlot high because if I recall they have the same time. Twilight said she should be gone for 2 days and when she arrived they knew it had been 2 days so that means that the time in equestria is the same in canterlot high
great idea but........ in the episode the Wonderbolt Academy applejack says to pinkie pie " rainbow dash hasn't even been gone for 24 hours give some time to settle in first" so..............
I KNOW ok you see I found out that one day in equstrea it a year in real life so if you compare about 30 years is 1 moon so it would be a long long time you'll have to take my word for it if you dont want to get confused.
I watcht something.. it was about rainbow dash in the real world.. in equestria she was an older.. in the real world she was a filly.. someone was taking care of her.. she grew up in 15 years in the real world.. but when the mane six pick her up and the person that was taking care of her ask: how long was she gone.. celestia awnserd 15 days.. so 1 year in the normal world is 1 day in equestria
8.33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333(it just keeps going) years
I really need help I can't comment on some YouTube videos and I don't know why. its saying comments blocked even on channels like this one. Please help.
I think a moon is actually 10 days and for one simple reason, Well 10 reasons. Those 10 are as follows : New Moon, Young Moon, Waxing Crescent, Waxing Quarter, Waxing Gibbous, Full, Waning Gibbous, Waning Quarter, Waning Crescent, Old. What are those? The 10 PHASES of a MOON.
well, you still have to take in to account that the apple family grew a lot since the last reunion. Even assuming that some didn't show up for the one in the first episode, there is evidence that the family grew larger between the 2
At 2:17 when you were talking about the sun moving and casting shadows on the moon, the sun re-positioned itself three times to get back to a full moon. Since earth years are around 300- some odd days, I predict that if there are 100 days in a pony year, you can times it by three to get 300 pony days in a year- depending on the shadows casted on the moon.
I've just come to the conclusion that a moon is is an inconsistent amount of time as Granny Smith stated that a Ponyville snail can hibernate for 48 moons, while an earth snail can sleep up to 3 years, yet 100 moons is about a year as there were Apple family reunions in the first episode and in season 3.
I always thought 2.5 years for a portal was kind of long... though now there's the question: if the length of a year was arbitrarily decided to be 100 moons, and that results in about 2 MLP years to our 1... does that mean their SEASONS are twice as long too? Because that would probably mess all KINDS of things up...
At the end of the journal of the two sisters, when it switches to the journal of friendship, Pinkie mentions that the birth-aversary we see in Pinkie Pride is Rainbow's tenth birthday in one of her entries. This makes sense with his theory because it implies that if one Equestrian year is two earth years, Rainbow would be 20 earth years old (which is a reasonable age for her). I'm assuming the main six are all around the same age, so, in a way he just explained not only how long 100 moons would be, but also how old the main six are.
Good thought, but I think there is a way to roughly estimate the number of days (or at least weeks) in an Equestrian year. In "Lesson Zero" Twilight goes nuts trying to get her friendship letter sent by the end of the week, implying that each episode is spaces approximately a week apart, their time. In "Princess Twilight Sparkle" it is relieved that a single year has passed since Nightmare Moon. Counting out season primers and finals which don't include friendship letters, you get 55. Thats almost identical to the number of weeks in an Earth year (52.1775). This difference is well within excepted deviation, and can be attributed to a few busy weeks. Therefore, I conclude that, assuming week lengths are the same, an Equestrian year is approximately equivalent to an Earth year.
This is a very interesting topic, after all. As seen in S2E10, we can calculate that about one human year passed between S1E01 and S2E10, given that Spike has his one year anniversary of being in Ponyville. Using this logic, we can calculate that about ten days pass between each episode. Of course this is only a rough estimate, and we can ultimately see that since Spike arrived in Ponyville on the same date that the Apple family reunion was happening (100 moons does not equal a year) and S3E8 (Apple Family Reunion) apparently equates to 100 moons from that date. Using the equation from earlier that 365 / 36 = 10.1 (which we'll round to 60), we can establish that 10 x 60 = 600 days. This means that 100 moons is about 1.65 years if my estimate is correct.
I would have compared the episode Apple Family Reunion with the only known previous reunion: Friendship is Magic Parts 1 & 2. I then would analyze how much time passed between those two events. There are pretty good other sources for this. For example, RLYoshi has a pretty good analysis of what the correct chronological order of the Season 1 episodes is. You could have used that to figure out some stuff about the seasons in Equestria. Not sure where I would go from there, though. It still seems preferable to pulling the equation "1 year = 100 moons" (or is that a function?) out of my hat.
I'm just going to say this. I know 1 moon as a month, I know 1 moon as a few day (however long you said) So I can't really say what time length 100 pony moons is. Let's say 3 days =1 moon. So 365 days is about 121 moons. Until a leap year. If the pony world and the human world worked the same way for 3 years then a leap year, you would have 1 extra moon. So total there are just over 120 moons a year. This means over 4/5 of a year, there is an apple family reunion. Hope this doesn't sound crazy.
I would mostly go with the ancient ways of the moon faces. 1 moon = 1 month. And judging by the photos, we don't really know how old the Mane 6 are, let alone the Cutie Mark Crusaders. For all we know, Apple Bloom could have been 4 years old in the previous photo. So there's my hypothesis.
One problem though. We know from the season 4 opener that it's only been 1 year since the season 1 opener. AJ said the Apples were having a family reunion that day, so it had been less than a year between then and the next reunion covered in Apple Family Reunion
According to the season 4 opener, Twilight had only been in Ponyville 1 year (if their is 1 Summer Sun Celebration each year) so 100 moons is less than the time between Summer Sun Celebrations.
The whole 1 year equaling 100 moons may seems intuitive to us, but that is because we are human. The whole 100 thing seems easy and simple to use because our society has made our number system base 10. It is doubtful that Equestria would have a base 10 number system because their anatomy is different. humans have ten fingers and ten toes, so it makes sense for us to count in tens, but pony's don't have fingers and toes so it would make more sense for them to count in base four (four hooves) or some other base that would make sense with how younger pony's could easily learn.
you are forgetting that in episode one when Twilight met applejack, her entire family was there. It's safe to assume that that was a family reunion. So from that episode to this one would give you your time period
The moon cycle is actually 27 days, 7 hours and 43 minutes. on to my theory.
Princess Luna actually believes in Lyra's theory of humans. She used a spell to transport herself and her sister to Earth and studied the moon cycle. When they travelled back, she channeled her moon cycle into that so the night could have an equal time to the day. THE END!some one notice me
i believe you are very close to the answer to this. however i believe that it's not quite right. i did some quick comparisons and math and came up with an eqiuestrian year as 2.83 years long. i did this by dividing the average age of old folk, to that of the average age of old horses. 85 and 30 respectively. a horse/pony reaches maturity {17-18 for humans} at age 5-6 so since granny smith is DEFIANTLY in her 80's human wise, that means that she is actually been in ponyville for 30 years. This is based in part on how old the pony human counterparts are. The human counterparts of the main six are about 17-18 and in highschool, since the ponies age at the same time but the years are different that means that an equestrian moon is actually 0.983 days AKA. one moon is 1 day. { because luna raises it every night} but years are counted the same. so 30 moons is 30 days in equestria {but the ponies age faster to keep up with the humans} so 30 moons { days} in equestria is ACTUALLY the same in the human world even though they seem different. see in fact, equestria IS earth, and ALTERNATE earth where there are only ponies.
This note/theory is before watching this video: From a fan of Erin Hunter's Warrior Cats, I had read them for three years and find out they use the term moons as of being apprenticed at 6 moons old- From going over that I finally came with the theory, Moons= Months But that's Warrior Cats, this is MLP FIM would they different terms? I will have to watch your theory, Brony Notion
This isn't about the moon, remember when there was a cycle of twilight, I've watched enough doctor who to know this. When Twilight and the others snuck into the castle, the guards must have seen them a resonable amount of times just didn't do anything because of celectias orders eg. Here Twilight I'll open my "secret no one aloud room of books by starswirl" said celestia. She has known twwilight for about 10 years but letting her wonder around? Celestia must have gone to the future to make twilight get her nervos overe-worried scene on then the cycle started!
The whole equestrian year is double ours thing is a theory I use! It explains why The main six are in high school in equestria girls and in equestria (fan based) they are around 20-30
Equestria isn't a Planet, it's a Country. Where do you think the other types of ponies come from? Throughout the series some of the ponies talk about different species, an example is the Dragons. The dragons wouldn't be able to fly around the planet for a migration, only a certain area of the country.
I still hold on the 1 Moon = 1 Month formula. Why? MLP has included many references and such to various entertainment, from fantasy games like D&D (griffins, minotaurs, chimera, etc) to westerns like Gunsmoke (Pinkie Pride and The Last Roundup). Across various forms of entertainment one thing was pretty common, that they used one moon to mean one month. Why change that?
This is really easy to answer. The ponies said thirty moons, but twilight (or some other pony) said 2 and 1/2 years. Judging by the count of 2 and 1/2 also being called 30 moons, one moon is one month ;P
Before I share my opinion, I'm just going to warn you now that I will be off subject for the start. In the book series WARRIOR CATS, every moon a gathering of all four clans is held. In the books, a moon meant 1 month, since every month there is one full moon. So for example in Equestria girls, when Luna says that Twilight would be in another world for thirty moon, it would probably mean 30 months, which would be about 2-3 years. That's all I have to say about it, bro hoof ~<3~
While I do agree with 1 moon = 1 day, I must call out a fault in 100 moons = 1 year. In the first episode of season 1, we see the Apple family having a reunion. We know this because in Applebuck Season, when Twilight asked AJ why her relatives aren't helping AJ said that they were having a reunion. So the Apple family reunion should happen the day before Celestia raises the sun for the Summer Sun Celebration every year. But as we know, the Apple family reunion in Season 3 happened before the day before the Summer Sun Celebration in Season 4. So 100 moons isn't 1 year.
There are also cases of multiple reunions, such as with my family we attend 3 different reunions. This is because our family is actually split between 3 larger families. Fisher, Wall, and Scarborough with a few smaller families such at Mitchel, Brandt, and Brown. which all lived in the same town since it was founded in the 1700's. We would have a lot of smaller reunions but every few years we would have the large reunion which everyone would attend. I have a feeling the Apple family might be doing the same thing as they have a obviously more than one group that makes up the Apple family.
Bear in mind please, Equestria is not the name of the planet, but rather the name of the country that Celestia and Luna rule over. Or at least, that's how it was before Cadence and Twilight.
Anyhow, do you think you could do a video on where exactly the Crystal Empire is?
Much like @Darien Hilmerson commented.. In the first episode of MLP they had an family reunion then in season 3 episode 8 they had another one. At the begging of season 4 Twilight mentions that it was that day that they all met and destroyed Nightmere Moon and got the element suggesting it has been only a year plus they did their summer sun celebration. So if it's only been one year then maybe it is not two years but two months. Lets say every season is a month s1= 1 month s2= 2 months s3=3 months s4= 4 months. The Apples had a reunion season 1 and 3 so if they have it in season 5 it could be pretty likely every season is a mouth. But 4 months is not a year so my theory is gone before it began 12 divided by 4 is 3 so maybe every season is three months meaning that the Apples have there reunion every 6 months. But that's just a theory a pony theory!
I did the math and you were very close briny notion. 100 moons = 2 years and 8 months. Also thank you Samantha Henney! You realy helped me figure that out. :)
Every Villian except for chrysalis had been or has been banished for 1000 years which means that equestria still has years and if twilight left at the last moon and had three days to get back to equestria that means 1 moon is 3 days. Since there are 8 stages of the moon changing that means an equestrian month is 24 days.that means if twilight was stuck in the real world she would be stuck for almost 4 months.
How are you certain 100 moons is the equivalent to an Equestrian year? I mean you figure two years have passed between the pass two Apple Family reunions. Why can't fifty moons be an Equestrian year so it lines a little better with a terrestrial year?
"How long is 100 moons?" Well let's line up 100 stallions flank to flanks, stare at their backsides a while, and then measure it out... Oh wait, you meant something else...
1 Moon = The Amount of time in between an episode with Luna. So around a Season. If 3 Seasons of MLP equate to a a year in MLP time, (If you want an explanation, just ask) then 100 Moons is 33 Years.
So Nightmare MOON was on the MOON for 333 MOONS. What.
By 1 moon I'm guessing they mean every full moon, which would be intact a month. but then again if its 100 moons for an apple family reunion maybe its 15 days a moon or its just one day
Well, I assume it to be like warriorcats, every moon, or month even, there is one full moon, and assuming that there is only one full moon and one new moon a month, id say a 'new moon' is the start of, well, the next moon. so in other words, each moon would be a month, or a new moon,
I actually wondering: Granny Smith came to "not created" land of Ponyville when she was a young adult mare, so how can it be, that in the photo near the barn she is a filly? And I cannot say, that this photo was made in a different place, cause in the "Family Day" episode, Granny Smith told, that the Apple family didn't have a home... I can't see the logic.
Why couldn't they just use days and months? Seeing as how the span of time between Season 1 and Season 4 was one year, my idea is that every season is equal to four months.
Considering how season 1 and 2 was only 1 year, its isnt hard to believe that equastria has a longer year. Maybe the seasons occur twice in one year having 8 seasons each year. Especially since two episodes featured winter season though only one year pass. But then again is the sequence of the episodes another factor that could crush this theory.
The day twilight first came to ponyville was the last apple family reunion so the time between the day twilight showed up and the apple family reunion applejack plans is 100 moons. Now just to figure out how to calculate the exact amount of time between the two
Hm... Has it actually been 2 (EQ) years since Twilight came to Ponyville and the Reunion for Season 3? In S1E4 Apple Buck Season, Twilight asks about the rest of the Apple Family, and Apple Jack says they were just here for the reunion... Which just happened to be on the same day as the Summer Sun Celebration, which I'm guessing is to celebrate another (EQ) year of the sun coming up. So if the Reunion happens every other (EQ) year, how many Summer Sun Celebrations have we... Wait, Season 4, Celestia called this, or at least hinted at that this Summer Sun Celebration is the first one where one also celebrated the return of her sister Luna. And no Apple Family Reunion... Someone at Hasbro ought to put together a (proper) Pony Calender.
you know the entire phases of the moon thing only works if Equestria is a globe. Sure there have been plenty of globes shown in the show but until somepony spins it and points a place out Equestria could be flat with the sun and moon just being hidden under it. Unlikely? yeah. but there dont seem to be any time shifts when crossing large distances so the one year summer sun celebration may just be celebrating the anniversary of when Celestia first rose the sun. Or rose it so that it lined up perfectly with the little statue thing
i think that 100 moons is a little less then a year due to what the show shows. in applebuck season s1e4 applejack does say that in the first episode it was a family reunion ( the first summer sun celebration) - then the apple family reunion happens s3e8 - then you have the magical mystery cure s3e13 - starting season 4 ( e. princess twilight sparkle) it is the second summer sun celebration, this is stated when celestia say that it is no longer celebrating the defeat of nightmare moon but the return of princess luna.
In my opinion. I possibly think the moons count off to half of day. lets think 6 to 6 is 12 hours, a day would = half a moon. (day) 30 days would be 60 full moons in general.
you contradicted yourself in the video. you said during the reunions that 100 moons was 2 years yet when talking about luna and celestia 100 moons was 1 year
The fact that it seems that between the two Summer Sun celebration only A YEAR HAS PASSED and 100 moons passed SOONER that that... So 100 moons is... a year maybe?
When I say "a year" let's have it like humans seen the year in olden times - repeat of the seasons. Thing that Celestia has definite power about - she just keeps sun in more distance for some time.
How long is 100 moons? Well, EQG goes off of Majoras Mask logic with Twilights 3 day time limit, and 1 month is (usually) 30 days, so im gonna go with...7
30 moons is 60 days because 1 moon is 3 days! It says in equestrian girls, that Twilight goes to humans world and she had time 3 days! Think little bit!
maybe you can tell how long 100 moons is by looking at how many episodes are in between equestria girls and equestria girls rainbow rocks because in the beginning of equestria girls rainbow rocks, before and after the intro, it seemed like one day at canterlot high is the same time as the time in equestria between the equestria girls movies.
Well what got me thinking is that luna always seem to rise a full moon everynight you never see the moon cycle happen and so if there is one full moon every month then 30 moons would equal 1 month but I have no idea about 100 moons
I heard that 1 moon= 1 month!?!?! But the princesses bring up the seasons. MAYBE the friend ship fire is hidden in a box or something and it powers the moons and stuffs
In the Warriors book it seems that a moon is equal to a year cause they age in moons so perhaps it is the same in mlp so it would be 100 years? No i dont think so so is it days or mabey every time there is a full moon
Well I read warrior cats and the cats say that a moon is a year so if it's 100 moons then it's 100 years. But that would be when a pony probably dies because it lives too long. But every 100 moons applebloom would be older and have her cutie mark. But that would also mean Granny Smith would die. So I'm confused.
Equestria is a country, not a planet but that's just a technicality. And a year can be determined by the passing of the four seasons when they're as regular as they are. Like another poster said, the Apples had two reunions in what was apparently less than a year...but that's kind of weird. Usually when ponies use the word moon, they seem to be referencing an amount of time similar to an Earth month, or at least a couple of weeks. I'm just gonna call inconsistencies. -_-
One flaw... One year is S1-S3 (give or take some offscreen things...) Apple Reunion first shown: S1E1 Apple Family Reunion focus episode: S3E8 or E60 overall... So... Thoughts anypony? Just saiyan!!
what if equestria is flat and not round like earth. celestia raises and lowers the sun and only has to do this once to start and end the day. If she had to revolve it around a circular planet wouldn't she be costantly working and constantly moving the sun?
I just presumed it was a month since I'm pretty sure it takes a month for the moon to make an entire cycle, (so from new moon and back again). 🌑🌒🌓🌔🌕🌖🌗🌘 <-- like that if you can see the emojis :P
You forgot about what was said in Apple buck season, which would help you significantly. In apple buck season, applejack said that so many family members where there during the summer sun celebration because they was there for a family reunion.
Rather than all this [insert picture of vice squeezing head, with an extremely pained look on the face], I prefer to say "Equestrian time is f**ked up, and we'll never understand it." In fact, you could substitute "time" with "economy"... it's a children's show, it's not supposed to be analysed to this degree. ... whatever, I guess you're entitled to your own pastimes. To each their own.
Me and my friends( Sophie,Leah and Kennedy) watched equestria girls and when Luna said twilight chould not return for anuther 30 moons we thought that 30 moons many 30 FULL moons so we said around 4 years twighligt would be stuck at C.H.S
100 moons is 100 months in Hasbros Monster High movie Frights Camera Action they say that 1 month is 1 moon since it's the same company I would assume it would be the same for all the shows
I don't think the Sun revolves around their planet. I think this is how heavenly bodies move on Equestria. The star is fixed, and the planet they live on revolves around their parent star BUT the planet has no natural spin. What Princess Celestia does is she causes the spin on their planet. We here on Earth say, "The sun is rising" because from our standpoint, that is what it looks like. But our sun isn't doing anything, the planet is - it's spinning. So, when ponies say, "Celestia raises the sun" they are saying that because that is what it looks like from their point of view, when in fact, she is giving the planet it's daily spin. On Earth, both the sun and the moon "rise" wink wink in the east and set in the west - only Luna revolves the moon around their planet.
There's probably not a right answer. The creators of MLP most likely didn't assume that people would look so much into it, so they porbably just did whatever. Maybe. :P
1 moon is 1 month. If you take an example from warrior cats quarter of a moon is 1 week, half a moon is 2 weeks, 3 quarters of a moon is 3 weeks and 1 moon is 4 weeks(or pretty much 1 month) though.... Equestria isn't warrior cats...
But granny Smith said that they have the apple family reunion at the sweet apple acres every 100 moons could they have the apple family reunion somewhere else?
one question : on the 11th episode of season of M.L.P how is the big fire ball still there. It confuses me and my 2 brothers. IT IS A BIG HELP TO US !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! THANK YOU !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OH. Two Equestrian years is one in our world? Between season 1 and 4 is it supposed to be one year. And we can see episode in winter(or the end of winter) twice Between s1 and s4 . So 1 Equestrian year are two ours.
facehoof Didn't you just say that 50 moons was a year because 100 moons was 2 years? Now you're saying 100 moons is 1 year? DERP you are awesome, but you just went Derpy Hooves on us there.
But Equestria is earth or is on a planet named earth as Pinkie pie or captain pudding head or whatever said "The earth is round" in the hearth warming eve episode.
You are not right because when Nightmare Moon was banished to the moon well it took a hundred years right? well you said that a hundred years and a hundred days or something was I don't know anyway well when she was banished Luna took 1000 years for her chest get released!!!
WEll so what about celestia line about all of season 1-3 up till tiwlight alicornship being ONE year! yup 80ish epsides all in one year...okay..i'm lost
Well in bucking season Apple jack said that the only reason that they were there because its the apple reineun and it caud be like a leep year its random
Think back in one episode se says im supost to sent every week one letter to princess celestia just look how manny weeks there are between the pilot episode en apple reunin***
wow just wow now this is good your waerning a party hat that party hat is cute will you see i have nothing about the mlp a.k.a. my little pony moon but i do have a qeschen i said qeschen wrong so can sunset shemmer stay in the humaen world or can sunset shimmer walk very easy i maen i know her back story and all but can sunset shimmer's rael home is in the humaen world or not because i have no idea how can her home be the humaen world its so strange its hard to answer it but how can she walk in that miorr and knowed it was magical and ddddddeeeeerrrrrpppp oh sorry i got carid away so thats my qechen bye bbbbbyyyyyeeeee dddddeeeerrrrrrpppppppppp ;3
I don't have a theory about it but I do know this is a stupid baby show on the people who made it didn't expect for older people to be watching this making weird assumptions about something that really doesn't matter because little kids are going to be watching this thing and they really don't care one way or another they just think it's a tv show with horses saying words
I can't argue with your theory, but it brings up an interesting question regarding the ages of the ponies and how old Lauren Faust said they were- that Pinkie was around 14 and Twilight around 19, and they reach adulthood at 14. I was going to pose the possibility that these could be equestrian ages and 14 there would mean 28 here, but then she said it was because 'they age faster than humans' so I suppose that would be their ages in human years, and Pinkie's age in Equestrian years would be 7. This also throws off some of my assessment of what their ages are, since Fluttershy said she was a year older than pinkie so I had put her at 15, but if that's one Equestrian year then her earth age would be 16, though if they reach maturity at 14 then she's still the equivalent of around 20 because Pinkie would be the equivalent of about 18. I would have to say for certain that they don't follow our birthday cake tradition of one candle per year, because assuming all of RD's candles were on one side of the cake and only the ones we could see were there, she had 21 candles. I had thought this would work with one season = one year, making Dash 21 now but 17 in season one but it had been said that the whole show thus far has been within one year which would likely make Dash's current age 18. Likely the candles went all the way around though because why wouldn't they, so the cake probably had about 40 candles on it and they had nothing to do with her age. Wait her birthday wouldn't mark one of our years passing but one of theirs, and they would celebrate birthdays every 2 earth years and if she was 17 earth years at the start would she then be 19 but is the show within one earth year or one Equestrian year? Or would 17 earth years old be 8.5 Equestrian years and this was her 9th birthday making her 18 in earth years... yea that makes sense.
This is the only video I have seen on this subject. I have considered how long a moon would be in equestria, but couldn't figure out any way to measure it. There hasn't been enough focus on time (It's about time XD) to be able to calculate it, or even get all that close. While you have an interesting theory, I'm hoping that information brought up in season 5 will help us to figure out how long a moon, and an equestrian year is.
BTW, this makes me wonder if an Equestrian week is only five days, because I don't recall anyone ever mentioning a saturday or sunday, and in Lesson Zero, the Twilights, (best pony) calendar only has five days on it. You should bring this up at some point, I may do a video on it as well. (Once I'm done my season 5 predictions vid)
Figuring out how time works and is recorded in Equestria would be a useful tool in finding out a lot of things, such as how old Celestia and Luna are, knowing that they are indeed way older than 1,000 moons. Do they go by human days, or something else?
Well, if Celestia and Luna somehow set the calender using the moon. then maybe one lunar cycle was equal to one week of the Equestria Calender. As for the theory on them having a different base counting system, it would make perfect sense. Being a furry, I have read a comic series where the evolved animals had a base 8 system of counting since they all had 3 fingers and thumb. or each hand.
I am so glad to have you back. You're, just...Awesome. Nothing more needs to be said, lots more could be said about your amazing-ness, but as they say "less is more".
On the topic of how long a year is, I don't know. I mean they said on the first episode of season 4 that all of the episodes had been one year, but that just seemed like a whole TON of things to happen in a year, also they had Winter Wrap-Up soon after the Summer Sun Celebration, and then the end of fall had come. So in Equestria winter is after summer and before fall? But what about Hearths Warming Eve? that looked like winter to me, so all in one year they had one summer, two winters, one fall and no spring episode to speak of? Argh, ponies why you so hard to understand!?
Also I saw a few people posted saying that they had a family reunion in the very first episode, so it would be less than a year between the two so that's why Apple Bloom doesn't look any different. I don't, ponies don't seem to care if we can make sense of their world or not.
How me and my friend thought of the time conversion, we took the approximate average lifespan of a human to a horse, and plugged the ratio into equestrian time, which if i remember correctly,equestrian time is three times (serious rounding) larger than ours in the same span. which means their time passes by quicker, meaning they have shorter years than us, by what i assume is 66% of our years.
I think your overlooking the fact that the lifespan of the ponies is greatly extended. Granny smith helped found ponyville, but in the episode where they are getting ready for spring, they have been preparing the same way since ponyville was founded, which twilight says, was hundreds of years ago. Therefor I believe it that there it is possible for them to have a reunion every 8 years, especially since the show indicates granny smith is hundreds of years old.
Didn't we see a calender with four day weeks in lesson zero? Judgeing by the number of the episode (wich is a nice 60) we could say that between this reunion and the one in the pilot episode and Twilight's mention that she has to send celestia her letter every week we could say that around 55 weeks (because of the pilot episodes,the premiers and the finales) have passed so according to my theory we could say that around 55 weeks is a year in equestria.
If you look at it like "when the moon is the same shape twice" thing, it would take about a week. So, it would be about a year if it happened 100 times. Mabe they were thinking of a specific day when the moon stays longer then normal. Then it could take a lot longer period of time. Night is longer in the winter, mabe there talking about a "moon" being the winter solstice.
I have a thought. So I have thought this through and actually my theory is either in Equestria 10 moons is a year. Why 10? Well lets think about it both ways If it was 10 moons equals 1 year in Equestria then that means the reunion happens every 10 years which makes sense since its an even amount of time between reunions. Enough time for it to be not a hassle for everyone to go so often but long enough so no one misses anyone for too long. It would also makes sense why Applejack was so young in the one reunion and now a grown up helping to plan it (and I will say it now the one picture with the three of them in it I call a mistake since it wouldn't be the first time they're visuals didn't match the description). Also lets keep in Mind Granny Smith. She was very young when Ponyville was founded so to know each detail and to have so many found memories, it would all make sense. It would also make ensue why Applebloom would be excited to see Babs since it would be their first met us since she was introduced and it would also explain how she didn't know her well before since they both are probably either just 10 in pony years or a little younger. Another reason why it would make sense for it to be 10 months is a year would explain how imperative it was for Twilight to get in and get out. 3 years is a long time to be stuck anywhere, especially if you are royalty and are part of the first line of defense for that country. It would also explain why we never saw Sunset Shimmer before because consider this. Our cycle runs on 29,5 moon cycle system and Equestria runs on just 10. Which means each 3 years in Equestria would only be a year for Sunset Shimmer. Which means it would make it even more likely why she was gone for so long. So lets just say Sunset was in her senior year in high school when she was in Equestria girls. That means she was there for 4 years, translated for 12 years in Equestria. Of course Twilight would not have met her because she was long gone before Twilight even began studying and around the time Sunset Shimmer say came around the time of even just the 3rd year, 9 years in Equestria since she left, this would be the big rise for Twilight and thats how she found everything out. Sorry this is lengthy but this is my theory. What do you think?
There's one major problem with that: The pilot episode had an Apple Family Reunion, and then there was another in Season 3. Season 4 episode 1 establishes that between Season 1 and Season 4 was one year. So, since there was already 2 Apple Family Reunions in that one year, 100 moons can't be 10 years.
@CoolioCats614 Even if it didn't, and each season was a year, that's still around 3 years between reunions. So either way, the whole 100 moons is 10 years thing is busted. It's either around one year, or three years. Plus, since we saw Apple Bloom as a young filly in the first reunion, she would have to be an older teen to young adult if the second took place 10 years later, and she's still a young filly.
well I can tell you a bit about time in Equestria. In the first episode of my little pony it was the summer sun celebration where Celestia raises the sun. the second time it was mentioned was in episode 23 Cutie Mark Chronicles when Twilight says she saw it as a filly. A thousand years later after that episode the next Summer Sun Celebration, Twilight was a princess and Celestia now says the summer celebration is a time when we are happy that Luna is back. So I guess that can help you a bit on years in Equestria. Right now we know that ponies live for a VERY long time (thinking of Celestia and Luna) and the summer sun celebration is like the stages of a human. start as a filly,then you are like child next your a teen, I'm guessing teen because in Equestria girls Twilight had a crush on Flash and she was in a high school and when she was back in Equestria the girls were acting kinda girly talking about her crush. so a thousand years is like the stages of growing up :) I hope I helped a bit good luck ;)
but in pony time they dont go by years like us in equestria girls sure yeah shes a teenager but in ponyville shes a teenager in well how many years equals teenager for ponies
You just made it more confusing for me... I think the Equestrian moons are the same as earth moons: 29.5 days. After all, it would make more sense in two of the episodes in which it was used:
"I still can't believe it's been almost one hundred moons since our last family reunion!" - Granny Smith; Apple Family Reunion
"This is no ordinary mirror. It is a gateway to another world. A gateway that opens once every thirty moons." - Princess Luna; Equestria Girls
"My plunderseeds should have stolen the magic from the Tree of Harmony and captured Princess Celestia and Princess Luna thousands of moons ago." - Discord; Princess Twilight Sparkle
These are the only three instances of the term "moons" (unless I'm missing some) in My Little Pony, and the latter two make sense. We don't know how long ago Sunset Shimmer went through the portal that's just been introduced, so it could have been 2.4-year intervals, and 12,000 moons qualifies more as "thousands of moons" than 200,000 moons. However, the discontinuity lies in Apple Family Reunion, right? No, it technically lies in the previous reunion in Friendship is Magic - Part 1, and it's a different type of discontinuity. The thing is... I can clear up this mystery using only two words: Extraneous Reunion. Kind of like "Extraneous Solutions" on a graph to represent discontinuity, the Apples had an "Extraneous Reunion" especially for the Summer Sun Celebration. From what we've seen thus far, the Summer Sun Celebration usually takes place in Canterlot, and Celestia set it up in Ponyville to get Twilight to meet the rest of the Mane 6. However, one unintended side-effect was Applejack. The Apple Family Reunions usually take place at Sweet Apple Acres, from what we've seen, so this would be the perfect occasion to host one. It didn't count toward the 100-moon cycle however, because the main reason it existed was the Summer Sun Celebration. That was the main event, and likely the reason all of those relatives even came (also the reason Granny Smith didn't count it as an official reunion). We don't see very many of them there after all, and they aren't distinguishable from each other like in Apple Family Reunion. However, that doesn't mean they couldn't take the photo in front of the barn and it doesn't mean some of the Apples, like Apple Rose and Apple Fritter, weren't in the barn or off sleeping somewhere when AJ was introducing Twilight to everyone. So, yeah. Extraneous Reunions.
In the Warriors book series, a gathering is held every time the moon is full. The cats' ages are known by moons. A moon is told apart from the gatherings, one moon is the time between two gatherings. Just thought I should say. Also, you should do "Is Commander Hurricane a mare or stallion?"
I'm thinking that ponies age slower than humans (MAGIC, duh) and by that their years are a bit longer than ours. I do agree that 100 moons lead up to a year, but that year might be longer than just 365/366 days for ONE reason..... All the festivals that happen in Equestria. There must be SO many of them, and they wouldn't fit into the year time-span that we have, There's just not enough time for all that planning, then setting it up, and then having the festival before the next one comes up. So, I'm thinking that a year lasts at least...maybe around 500 days. So, what about the seasons? Yep, they last longer too. But I think that summer/spring are the longest seasons as ponies do control the weather year-round (although I think in some years they laze off which makes them last a bit longer). ....And that's all I got. ^u^
During the first episode, the apple family reunion was during the Summer Sun Celebration, so, assuming that the Summer Sun Celebration occurs once every year, shouldn't the apple family reunion also be once a year, or did the apple family reunion happen during the Summer Sun Celebration in the first episode just for plot convenience?
Between season 1 episode 2 and season 4 episode 2 is exactly a year which means the apple family reuions are one year apart. So 100 moons are roughly and equestrian year.
the Summer sun celebration interferes with your theory. in season 1 episode 1&2 this is the time of the summer Sun Celebration. it marks the meeting of the heroes, applefamily reunion and the return of Princess Luna. in season 3 episode 8 we see another Applefamily reunion. and at the end of season 4 episode 2 we see the Summer Sun Celebration. these lines are proof:
In apple Family reunion Granny Smith stated that they do it every 100 moons. and in the two part premiere of season 4 this lines happens:
Celestia: Now I can look forward to the Summer Sun Celebration.
Twilight: Why?
Celestia: For my Subjects it is for defeating Nightmare moon, for me it is a reminder that I had to banish my own sister.
Twilight: I never thought of it that way.
Celestia: it is her first one back.
So that proves the summer sun celebration is 1 year. and it is after the applefamily reunion. I think one year is 150 moons. because if you look throughout all the episodes there are pages of a days and every time we seen them. there are 30 squares. this means a year has to be divisible by 30. 100 isn't. but 150 is. 120 just seems to even.
I know they said from the End of the 1st Movie to the Sirise coming to the School in Rainbow Rock was just 6 Moons So Season 4 had to take place in a total of 5 to the 6 Moons Lets go back to Season 3 for a sec we had 2 Eps that took place at the same time. The Eps Spike took care of the Pets and the Eps were the girls were in the Crystal Empire showing the inspector for the Equestian Games (Olypics) around. So some Eps could took place at the same time in Season 4. But that a streatch. We know in Season 2 a Week is 7 days long. Because Twilight had to send a letter ever week but she missed this week and at sun set Princess Celestria showed up.
Also when asked one of the people workes on the show says Equestian Moon can not be told in Human Time.
So a Moon could a Month. We know the last time the mirror open up was 30 Moons ago when Sunset shimmer used it she left shortly before Twilight because PCs student so figure out how long she been her student and that is how long 30 Moons is then we can figure out how long a Moon is.
But again they said it can not be told in human time
here's an idea. in one of the comics optimus prime from transformers is visible (regular mlp comics). and flash sentry's car looks like an erbona 500. a car from transformers prime. is it possible that these 2 universes are connected?
No celebrations are repeated in MLP until episodes 4.1 & 4.2 & " princess twilight sparkle" with the summer sun celebration. They do not outright say it but to me it is heavily implied that this was their first anniversary of those events. This means, to me, that all of the events in the show up to the beginning of season 4 take place within 1 year. This would mean Apple family reunions happen fairly frequently. Again, no other holidays or celebrations seem to repeat until season 4.
Just saying what if 100 moons was 100 years so each moon was a years and crystal ponies lived for maybe 1000 or more so maybe normal ponies would have the same age span so that is why they change so much over those 100 years . Also Apple Bloom was just a mistake that the show always makes
I think it was just a logic mix up. Mlp does that a lot, like for example when celestia said blue blood was her nephew, but that means blue blood would have to be luna's son or there would have to be a third royal sister, which the show downs suggest at all. See, mlp doesn't always watch their logic, like with the moon theory.
Keep in mind that there is a theory that Equestria is Earth after an apocalypse (look in to it, it's kinda complicated for a comment) so maybe there's another viable system for 'moons' based on real earth.
I see one moon as one month ( mostly because i am used to it in the Warrior cats book series). But in that case, it would be 12 moons = one year, and 100 moons would be....... a veeeery long time. But, it maybe is one month anyways, since ponies live alot longer than humans. Im not smart, so this post is pretty wierd xD
In MLP the fourth season started off as it being once year since Luna returned from the moon, which in our time was 4 years ago. So one year there=4 years here.
You changed mywhole perspective, i Read warrios and they refer to moons as well, in equestria, i always thought moons where months. In warrios, they say that a kit or kitten has to be 6 moons old to become an apprentice,so i was thinking 6 moons is 6 months, but i could be wrong (i know you may not have a clue what im talking about with this warriosr thing it was an example
Well I like your theory because based on our past cultures the consep of time was changed like Stonehenge people beleave it was made to calculate time using the sun and moon and where on the planet you are could change how you see days go by so yes I think there idea of time could be different
So would the theory that 50 moons would be when Zap Apples are harvested? Since they only can be harvested once when the moon is at its highest? Anyone care to explore this theory?
Maybe 100 moons is just a year, in our time. Because in some Native American tribes, (mine included) it is believed that each month has 3 moons in it. Event though it is only 36, it might explain something.
I guessed that 100 moons was one Equestria year myself. If one Equestria year equals 2 normal earth years then that explains why Equestrian years seem longer.
Well when I watch mlp, I usally act like every episode is two weeks to make more sense because really a bad thing happens everytime it would be weird to have one every week so why not every 2?
If the sun is only moving around equestria then, is there more than one sun? I mean, equestria is'nt the whole world... it's probably just a continent right?...right?
how old is granny smith? wasn't she there for the founding of ponyvile? also what about celestia and luna? and finally thanks for the video. thats a common question that my brother and i ask
Well no the summer solsice celbration happened in season one episode 1 and then again in season4 episode 1 so each season is a season 3 months to be exact and also there was a reunion in the pilot then later on so thats the time period of each reunion about 10 months or so , making 10 moons each month showing 1/3 of each season is a month and is ten moons so a hundred moons is about in our time 3 an 1/3 mlp seasons and there anout ten months
Maybe just maybe... in equestria 30 moons are 3 months and 100 moons is 1 year and on earth 30 moons are 30 days and 100 moons is 100 days because earth doesn't work like equestria because 1. Equestria is on a mythological - like world in a different universe and a TV show so it Clearly doesn't exist obviously. 2. Even though equestria doesn't exist it does have magical and mythological ponies and creatures that can happen on earth despite before we we're even born there could've been strange and mythological things that were somehow defeated, reformed or resolved by magic just like how the mane 6 use magic for all 3 of those things. So clearly earth doesn't really do the same balance as in equestria.
Wow!! This makes sense now..... But... How could Granny Smith age that fast... Well Equestria is NOT earth so... And ponies do age faster so this makes sense
The Brony Notion, you may have shown Apple Jack's mother and father ( In 1:18 ) Because I went back and looked at Granny Smith's age. One showed her very young, older and older. And Apple Jack and Apple Bloom look younger in the picture in 1:18. But, Big Mac. It looks like he doesn't age, so I could be wrong. But, the the two ponies on -> that side looks like her mother and father but, that baby looks like it's theirs' so. And the two ponies on <---- that side could be it too. So its a fact I have been thinking about.
In this case , it says in equestria girls, she has 3 days to get the crown and luna said when the moon is at its peek on the 3day the portal will close that shows that 1moon = 1day or 1day = 1moon so 100 moons is 100 days and so is 30 moons to 30 days
Do you want to do a collab?~ No really though, I wanna get your ideas and thoughts on an interesting story. Because MLP has a lot to do with greek mythology, I wanted to see if I could share theories on the subject "The story of fenrir" Edit: Dammit I forgot it's called Collab, not cameo! I'm a dunce
Which begs the question, why didn't Granny Smith said "It's been a year since the last Reunion", it's like if I said "Come back 4 weeks after today" instead of "Come back next month".
I think it's deliberately vague as to what she meant by one-hundred moons. Either DHX want's the fanbase to build Equestria themselves, or they themselves have no idea how their own world works. Speaking of vague events that god won't tell us about, what DO ponies do on Hearths Warming Eve?
What about the pilot there was a family reunion and there are less family members in the pitcher then when twilight arrived on her first day at ponyville.
Hey don't mean to be hating but the first episode of season 4 said that only one year had passed after the first episode so maybe the moons really are just days?
well what if they did it every two years but apple bloom rally wanted to see babs again so the changed the days of the reunion to every hundred moons. it makes a bit more sense that none of them aged in the picture but there were a lot more so it still doesn't so much sense to me how so many more were in that last picture, Now i know that not all of came to the reunion every year because they were busy but HOW ARE THERE SO MANY APPLES THAT I CAN'T EAT!!! :( :( :( :)
the moon moves in the moon calendar so if you can see the first night the moon is nether full or new moon.so the portal is like a cell phone it has to charge of 30 day or month's so the portal is solar and lunar powered but how did starswirl now this portal thing so the book that sunset had uses limitless power when twilight uses the other book the portal was limitless.
nothing to do with moons but i saw mlp eg and HAD to ask this question. what if pinkie got through the portal? would one pinkie die or would they both stay. i mean you cant stay with yourself if u came from the future or past right? so something will happen and most likely to human pinkie.
Previous vid: Does Twilight have OCD? Next should be: Where does Rainbow Dash live? Hint: to know where she lives, check the episode with "Singing Telegram" song.
I know this video is about the moon and how long is a 100 moons but after watching this video I started going back to your old videos just to see the ones more so that being said I went to the video that was said " who is the shadow pony" wean it got to the part wean you talked about zecora may be the shadow pony but you also said star swirl could be the shadow pony but then Leeds me to an another video that you said discord could be star swirl know "WHAT IF?" You are right discord is star swirl what comes back to zecora and star swirl they both rim in a way one rims as for wisdom a making wis moves (zecora) as for star swirl is to rim for casting a spell and the both tie to gather but back to the shadow pony in my mind zecora can not be the shadow pony but star swirl can but going back to discord and star swirl they both have the same looks but in my mind "WHAT IF" star swirl was working on the spell and as he was he's mind was then corrupted bye something that want wrong and his body was then turned into discord's body but comes back to the shadow pony what if it's not a pony at all "WHAT IF" it's the spirit of star swirl looking for a way to get back his body and the day that something want wrong was way he did not Finnish the spell that is just my thought on the shadow pony I would love to see what you have to say and see ya :3 :3 :3 :3 :3
I know this video is about the moon and how long is a 100 moons but after watching this video I started going back to your old videos just to see the ones more so that being said I went to the video that was said " who is the shadow pony" wean it got to the part wean you talked about zecora may be the shadow pony but you also said star swirl could be the shadow pony but then Leeds me to an another video that you said discord could be star swirl know "WHAT IF?" You are right discord is star swirl what comes back to zecora and star swirl they both rim in a way one rims as for wisdom a making wis moves (zecora) as for star swirl is to rim for casting a spell and the both tie to gather but back to the shadow pony in my mind zecora can not be the shadow pony but star swirl can but going back to discord and star swirl they both have the same looks but in my mind "WHAT IF" star swirl was working on the spell and as he was he's mind was then corrupted bye something that want wrong and his body was then turned into discord's body but comes back to the shadow pony what if it's not a pony at all "WHAT IF" it's the spirit of star swirl looking for a way to get back his body and the day that something want wrong was way he did not Finnish the spell that is just my thought on the shadow pony I would love to see what you have to say and see ya
Yes, all that makes sense in my mind. Maybe some photos were lost.... Pleeeeease do Does Pinkie Pie have ADHD??? I would luv it! Btw nice job earning 20,000 subs! I am proud to be in that number! :)
I've got a bit of an complaint with your thearoy because every episode seems to be everyday and the family reunions mite only have a few weeks apart!that explains why apple bloom looks the same from the second last family photo!
20000?? What?? Then that means since I first subscribed to ur channel (around 6 MONTHS ago) ur amount of subs has multiplied by 10!! TELL ME UR SECRETS
I might not be understanding this right but, in the video you said that the family reunion happens every hundred moons and that the reunion equals to every two years. But then you said that every hundred moons equals a year. So doesn't that mean that the reunion is every year or that fifty moons is a year. I might of miss heard you and I'm probably misunderstanding you so I apologize if I offend you in anyway.
100 moons 1 year it might be a little hard but it might be it because they cant have it every 2-5 months thats to much and they cant have it every 5-6 years thats to long and it might be a family reunion every 1 year to celebrate here family on the first day they had it ust like Christmas and other holidays
Hello the brony notion:)I wanna be an analytist JUST LIKE YOU!Im sorry I asked, but how do you do your videos?:)On instagram you saw my cat Albert. OMG, OMG I cant belive im writingto my FAVORITE ANALYTIST!!!!!!!!!
Albert is cute :3 For my videos I always write the script and then record it. I use a program called audacity to edit the rough recording. Then I edit the video part in another program called Adobe Premier Elements. One that's done I upload it. The whole project takes an average of 10 so it's a lot of work. I'm glad I've inspired you! :)
Hey BN i was looking at the episode Apple family Reunion and When it shows all 6 ponies when They are talking about the 7 legend race IT shows à ponie on the tight töat looks an AUFAUL LOT like applebloom could IT possibly be her mot
May i say, "equestria is NOT earth", so how do you know exactly how big the sun is, AND the the affects of gravity on equestria? Exactly. YOU DONT, Their sun could be a lot different from ours, as well as the landscape there, changing the sun's approach. Besides, if the CLOUDS there can't move, how is the SUN supposed to move by itself? Celestia does it, after all, that is her cutie mark, and I'm PRETTY sure you can't get a cutie mark for a fake talent? as you said, you claim Celestia is faking her whole "raises the sun everyday thing".
@taylor marie hayton Okay, can you proof read that sentence? it makes no sense.. what does "actually, there has first there was a like...." make any sense?
What about the story behind Snails cutie mark? And if u go back to G1 there is a girl version of snips and snails. And do u think the cutie mark cuasaders will ever get there cutie mark I mean siriousely!!!!!
Dear mister my theory is that've the Sumer sun selebration is an anule thing and apple famaly reonyon hapend in seson 3 so it hopes every year and the pictorial that are missing are because they went to the other famaly farms
hello this is triple tank one also this is my personal channel I also admire your admiration in your phone s for your brownie Nation channel I hope you the best of luck for you and yeah this is giving you a shout up
Ok u keep saying moon not full moon so that would more so mean in 24 hours 1 moon and 1 sun would happen an in 30 days 30 moons and 30 suns will happen so it's more so saying now correct me if am wrong but I do not remember it saying a specific face of the moon so it would not be talking about the specific moon an the portal is just open for a certain amount of days correct?
............................................................ I don't get this at all how am I going to do this :I so one moon = a day right? soooooo...... I DONT KNOW WHAT TO TELL YA K???? K im done so see u in a other video lol bye :)
But what about what Pinkie said in "Hearths Warming Eve" in their play? Applejack : The map is upside down Pinkie : Well i got a news flash for you cookie. The Earth is round, there is no upside down
SHE SAID "EARTH" WHY ISN'T ANYONE BRINGING THIS UP? O_o
@Indonesian Brony Well, that's before even Celestia and Luna, and we know both are over 1000 years old. The ponies in the play were the founders of Equestria, meaning that Earth was the name of the planet at THAT time, but it could've been changed over time.
you are not a changeling!!!!!!!!!!! but you are a human and you go to highschool !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! bumer!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I'll bet everybody who reads warriors can answer that right off the bat.
3443 likesA moon is a month.
Replies (283)
Yep XD I was just about to say that
121 likes1 moon is 1 year actually. Well, in Equestria it is
165 likesFriend of Nature I don't remember any of the names, but my favorite was called, like, lionpaw or something.
50 likesMy favorite character is Squirrelflight
44 likesCara Elias warriors is not mop different storys may have different ways of doing things check I've had different time and currency measures in my own writings as well. and I know other writers that do. you can theorize similarities but same series and world they are not
19 likes@Friend of Nature
36 likesI'm going old-fashion.
Greystripe.
Yes, Moon ≈ Month. But its length varies.
18 likesIf someone lives on Earth's Moon and sees Earth as its Moon, then it month's length is around 24 hours or 1 day on Earth. While on Earth, a month's length is 30 days or 1 month.
Let's say this. Someone… Let's Princess Lun… er, Kaguya. Princess Kaguya was sent away from the Moon to the Earth. Before she departed, her Council say "Kaguya. Please return back in 30 months! That's 30 days on Earth!"
But when she got on Earth, she decided to extend her stay for 6 Earth months and more!
Or maybe she just plain boke plus didn't hear the '30 Moon months ≈ 30 Earth days' part, and thought 'I've only stayed here for 6 months'.
Cara Elias yup
1 likeIn my head I was debating on whether it was 1 day or a month (I'm only on the third book so they don't reveal much) but I always knew it was a month cuz silverstream lives for about 21 moons if it was days well... But if it was months she was around 1 year and 9 months when she died.
8 likesyesss
1 likeMistystar is the greatest
2 likesyep. I was like read warriors and you shall understand, the whole video.
3 likesOne moon is 28 days
2 likesI read that, Jayfeather is amazing
7 likesYES! XD
0 likesHEY I THOUGHT IT WAS A WEEK AND I READ WARRIORS
3 likesYep! According to Erin Hunter, it’s a month!
3 likesYes I read Warriors.
Kerfuffle it could be different in equestrian though
0 likesFriend of Nature it's a tie between Ivypool, Graystripe, Squirrelflight, and Leafpool
4 likesYep yep yep
0 likesI wuv Fallen Leaves
0 likesYES BOI
0 likesFriend of Nature alderheart
0 likesAyla Nassen so that mean granny smith is over 100 yrs old
2 likesLol yeah!
0 likesFinally! Someone gets me!
0 likesKerfuffle new prothesy Told me a moon a month
1 likeI read familiars
0 likesKerfuffle Same
0 likesI don’t even know what that is and if I’m asked that then my answer is
0 likesA MONTH!
Lol yes
0 likesYep.
0 likesTie between Mapleshade and Squirrelflight!!!
0 likesYep
0 likesYES!!!!!
0 likesyeah lol i just wanted to watch this to see if he was right
0 likesKerfuffle true that
0 likeslol same!!!!
0 likesYup
0 likesWhat Tyde of warriors warrior cats?
0 likes@KaiWasHere it's the Warriors series by Erin Hunter
0 likesHello on my warrior friends out there which is your favorite by the way?
0 likesYas
0 likesWARRIORS FANS UNITE
2 likesgrabs Kerfuffle and screams “WARRIORS IS THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!”
4 likesYup
1 likewarriors = earth
2 likesmlp = equestria
whose your favourite character? i like Cloudtail and Leafpool
Kaito Ajin my favorites are shadowpaw rootpaw bristlefrost briarlight jayfeather and scourge
1 like@Ed Sweet i wonder why everyone likes scourge and jayfeather
0 likesLol, yeah
0 likesAs soon as I saw this, I was like, " I read Warriors, and usually a moon is a month " XD
0 likes🐱WARRIORS🐱
0 likesyepper
0 likesI love that book series
0 likesOof
0 likesYep that’s what I said
0 likesLol yep
0 likesyes
0 likesIn Czech, my native language, we have the same word for the moon and a month
0 likesI read Warriors! Lol
0 likesTrububble mines Rain whisker pls don’t ask
0 likesAyla Nassen every 100 years? I don’t think so, when Twilight came to Ponyville for the first time, there was a family reunion.
0 likesYess!
0 likesMy favourite warriors characters are Squirrelflight and Cloudtail
0 likes@Ayla Nassen But then Aple's reunion would be only ones in 100 years wich is impossible :D
0 likessunnyflowers Zero One I have no idea man, I left that comment 3 years ago
0 likesLPS Labrador I have no idea when applejack’s family reunion is. my logic three years ago was “ah yes, twilight said 1000 years instead of 1000 moons that one time, therefore 1 moon = 1 year and ponies live 80,000 years”
1 likeYep
0 likesYup
0 likesyep
0 likeswarrior cats for life
0 likestrububble mine are Leafpool and Dovewing
0 likestrububble nope, its totally bramblestar
0 likesOwO
0 likes@trububbleee Mine is Squirrelflight!
0 likesYep
0 likesI- I was just going to comment that. Wow! I am not surprised, the first thought that came to my head when I saw the title is 1 month
1 likeWouldn't it be 2 moons for a month though?
0 likesGathering = 1 Moon
Most, if not all, months have atleast 2 full moons
@Hog More I don't know you're probably right. I mean it is logical but everyone else thinks it's 1 month.
0 likesLikes this comment
0 likesIt will be embarrassing to tell my fav....one hint a main character in some books.
0 likes@nirock 25 okay tell me who! (IF you want to do that) Just do this then do read more so the people who want to read, read it :)
0 likesKerfuffle
0 likesYep
Just thinking that
0 likesAlso my favorite cat is Hollyleaf or Ravenpaw. (Lil nervous boi
trububble Mines IvyPool because her story is so interesting to me anyway XP
0 likesHello fellow warrior fan
0 likesKerfuffle yup
0 likes@Ayla Nassen So AJ is at least 300 years old? She's been around for at least 3 Apple Family Reunions (2 of which happened in the same year), and each Reunion is 100 moons apart, so...?
0 likes@Matt TOB i have no idea dude
0 likesNow i kinda wanna get into warriors cats (if thats what your talking about) i wonder if my fam as books of it hmm i think so
0 likesAyla Nassen but they call a year a year in the show tho-
0 likesSerella & BitterJoy they do! I haven’t watched the show in a fair while since it ended! I have no idea anymore!
1 likeNice
0 likesYup
0 likesYeah I already knew it and I was just making annoyed noises the entire time
0 likesOh ok
0 likesYep.
0 likesSliverstream rip her T^T
2 likesYep, meh lovely Graystripe
0 likesYe
0 likesKerfuffle that makes sense
0 likesUm welll idk if im late but Bramblestar and rootpaw is my favorite character
0 likesKerfuffle hahahah that’s what I thought instantly
0 likesYeah
0 likesKerfuffle Literally exactly what I thought lmao
0 likesyes
0 likesWarriors is so goooooooooooooooooooooood
0 likesIt's been three years and this comment thread is still going, oh boy–
0 likesKerfuffle yes
0 likesYup :3
0 likesMy favourite is leafpool
1 liketrububble Same! Jayfeather is also my favorite XD
0 likesFirestar
0 likes@trububbleee Brightheart :)
0 likesI thought I’d was a day
0 likes100.......
0 likesMONTHS!?
warrior cat fans intensify time for another gathering
0 likesOmg the nostalgia
0 likesThats what I thought as soon as the question was asked
0 likesOMG I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY WARRIORS FAN HERE
0 likes@trububbleee My favourite is Firestar
0 likesLiterally my brain screaming it.
0 likesexactly
0 likes;)
0 likesYep glad to see another warriors fan
0 likes😂
0 likesYeep
0 likesYa it is
0 likesI like
0 likesPurdy
@Shsy7573 my favorite is Rusty
0 likes@Chirps I like rusty
0 likesFor warriors it is, but as he said, the moon cycles would be very different in equestria. Because you know, IT ISN’T EARTH.
0 likestrububbleee same!
0 likesKerfuffle yep.
0 likesKerfuffle lmao except this is accurate
0 likesMEME studio I mean it’s ur opinion... and technically if u don’t like it (or hate it) go complain to the authors, instead of saying this-
0 likesWell I don’t mean to be rude
0 likesMEME studio k
0 likesYupppp
1 likeYeah this is simple if you have read it.
0 likesKerfuffle same cuz a gathering occurs every moon
0 likes@Saachi Varshney Squirrelflight is sooo cute, but sometimes just too anoying. Still love her though
0 likes28 days XD
0 likesHell yeah
0 likesIts roughly 1 year
0 likesMy favorite cat is Leafpool but I haven’t read all the books yet I am only on power of three
1 like@Aaron Sanchez cool but why are here on mlp do you have pony town?
0 likesMr. Cup Alderheart for life-
0 likesKerfuffle Yup that's true
0 likesSo 3 months
0 likesNever thought that in the comments of a mlp video would be where I find people talking about Warriors.
0 likes(Warriors is my favorite book series)
AYYY WARRIOR CATS FANS! In case you're wondering, I'm a Sorreltail fan.
0 likes😂 WARRIORS IS THE BESTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesHeyIt'sHarley yeppers
0 likesOr muslims
0 likesSo, 100 months?
1 likeSame here
1 likeYeah pretty much... I was about to say the same thing
0 likes100 months
0 likes@Ayla Nassen r/woooosh
0 likesTabbyCat 210988 this is my first woooosh!! thank you!!
0 likesI really love Moth wing-
0 likesI don't read warriors and i knew that
0 likesWow you read my mind 3 years ahead lol
0 likesO come on! what does that have to do with anything.
1 like@Voe Creative because in the warriors series. They use the term a lot as well. But it refers to a month
0 likesStill didn't understand after reading the entire series.
0 likes@Umbreonfan03 like he said in the video, the moon takes one whole month to make one cycle. Thats where the warrior series gets a moon from. If you think about it, cats don't know what a month is. Not in the way we do.
0 likesAm I the only one who likes Bluestar ;-;
0 likesWarriors is the best
0 likesSaachi Varshney yes squirrel flight is awesome
0 likesWe The Cringe that wouldn’t make senses cause I’m pretty sure they have a gathering every moon and that wouldn’t be every week a month makes more sense
0 likesyep
0 likesI thought a moon was a metaphor for a day.
0 likesYup! I read warrior cats and i know 100 moons means 100 months.
0 likesYep
1 likeI think its a bit more than a month because in the sob discontinued series twi and her friends meet every one moon and...
0 likestrububbleee ~three years later a 11 year old is watching mlp theories when the show basically ended and also reads warrior cats replies to ur comment~ jayfeather best boi and best gurl be leafpool
1 like~three years later~ I have always wondered that and I read all of omen of the stars, new prophecy, power of three and the sun trail with 4/9 of thunder rising (yes very precise but idk I’m guessing 4/9)
0 likesNight_Wolf 377 I prefer raven paw he is like the fandoms gay son
0 likestrububbleee Mine are Fire’Star, Blue’Star, Jay’Feather, Maple’Shade, and Scourge. :3
0 likesDuh
0 likesYes.
0 likesWow, so true!
0 likesMy fave character is bluestar and totally was gonna say that
0 likesOmg I did not notice that wow
0 likesObVIOUSLY
0 likesBtw a moon cant be a year since newest episode, twighlight states that she meets the other five (since spike is still mostly with her)every Moon. So they can have waited a year, or maybe they do? I think its every month. Just a theory
0 likesZuzanna Eitner
0 likesI
I
I
Cat bOOKS
Yassssssssssssssssss
0 likesWarriors forever
Yep I was going to say that too
0 likesMy favorites are Crowfeather, Leafpool, Blossomfall, and Ivypool.
1 likeYea, I thought it was obvious
0 likes@Ayla Nassen then how would granny still be alive?
0 likesbabyLinax •_• my dude I have no idea!!
0 likesTigerclaw... Sorry lol. Maybe Bluestar.
1 likeEquestria is Not earth- and equestria isn't warriors (not hating just saying tho)
0 likes@Ayla Nassen no, not really if thats the case applejack would over 100 years old
0 likes@Ayla Nassen they couldn't have done every 100 years
0 likesHello fellow warriors reader! :D
0 likes@Ayla Nassen
0 likesApple Bloom's over a century old-?!
That's what I waa thinking-
0 likesYeah I was gonna comment that, including the warrior cats stuff
0 likesYEP XD
0 likesAyla Nassen, Granny Smith would’ve been 100yrs old if that was true.
0 likes@——xEclipse ♡🌙 Bruh- following Brony's logic, it would have been 1 year- did you not watch the video-
0 likesI was just about to comment that XD
0 likes@trububbleee No. Nononono, NO.
0 likesYea
0 likesOmg was just about to say it
0 likesI’ve read only 3 books from the prophecies begin but I’m obsessed!
If a moon is a month,then the finale doesn't make ANY sense
0 likesYASS I love Warriors and I knew it from the start
0 likesKerfuffle YES
0 likes@trububbleee I think yall mean Feathertail
0 likesYep
0 likesYa ya ya Imao
0 likes@trububbleee
0 likesMy favourites are Feathertail, Alderheart, Squirrelflight and Jayfeather ^^
Yep
0 likesI STAN BLUESTAR
0 likesHaha, I was about to comment that and saw someone did it for me!
0 likes@Crowcutx I love Turtle Tail and Briarlight and Jayfeather. I also kinda ship Briarlight and Jayfeather. Brairfeather? Jaylight?
0 likesThat’s actually where the word “month” comes from. In the Old English calendar, one month was equal to exactly one full lunar cycle.
0 likesI made that before I saw that he literally said that in the video. My bad.
0 likesThanks for exposing me Kerfuffle
0 likes@trububbleee
0 likesMy favorite is sol!
Yes every full moon they gather at the gathering place
0 likesYep same here
0 likesYES
0 likesMy favorite charecter is squirrel flight!
0 likes@Ayla Nassen, that doesn’t make too much sense...
0 likes@*Aura_Flower* thanks for telling me! really doesn't!
0 likesMy favorite warrior cat is Twigbranch.
0 likesyup
0 likes@trububbleee ravenpaw he looks like my cat
0 likesaaaaaaaa yes.
0 likes1 moon is a lot more then 1 year because of fake grogare's talking
0 likesmhm
0 likes@trububbleee mine's Rusty/Firestar
0 likes(Bat sounds) I REALIZED I CAN BE ANYTHING SO I BECAME A BAT GIRL
0 likes@Ayla Nassen so the apple family throws a reunion once every 100 years?
0 likes🥺 I am happy now, I finally found someone who reads Warriors! Even if it is popular
0 likesAnd yes moon = month in Warriors
In our world or Equestria
0 likesI like Scourge
0 likesLol- yep xd
0 likesAgreed. 1 moon is 1 month. Even in real life.
0 likesyep
0 likesI’m not into warrior cats but I still knew that. I mean it’s obvious, the moon takes 28 days to cycle through, so obviously.
0 likesWARRIORS READER SOUNDS
0 likesYup
0 likesYup
0 likesYep I actual playing is right now
0 likesI can’t right now. I only have the first book :P
0 likesNO ITS 100 DAYS
0 likes@trububbleee mine’s Feathertail
0 likesY e s
0 likesIkr
0 likesMy favourite has to be LeopardStar (I know she isn’t that popular but I love her story, and the fact even though she has a redemption arc, but still could be ‘mean or hostile’ which I like. Her whole entire character didn’t do a full 180, but she wasn’t considered straight up evil)
1 likeYup
0 likesYes
0 likesYup
0 likes@Bruno Carter instablaster ;)
0 likes@Damon Dallas it worked and I actually got access to my account again. I am so happy!
0 likesThank you so much, you saved my ass !
@Bruno Carter Glad I could help :D
0 likesyes
0 likesI-
0 likesYEEEEES
0 likesI saw : warrior-
Me: YEEEES OF CORSE I KNOW THAT HEHHEHEHHEHEHHEHEHEHE
ONE MOON IS ONE MONTH
I have to stop reading this heheHeheHEHEHHEHEHEHHEHEHHEHEHEHEHHEEH-
Its a month because theres one full moon every month and in warrior cats theres one gathering in each month 🙂👍
1 likeI want I,m 6
1 like@Zeauxas🤔😊
0 likes🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔want
0 likesI
@trububbleee Bluestar
0 likesHehe
0 likesWelcome to mlp wc where horses live in stables and cats live in clans
Guess theres a pony-cat connection
@Spirited _ Cry meh too
0 likes@hello no!
0 likesWarriors = catland
Mlp= equestria
The moon is not a month
0 likesYES MONTHS-
0 likesI seriously thought that one moon in Warriors was 14 days or two weeks yes I’m stupid I know
0 likes@trububbleee Mine is Shadowsight!
0 likesI was gonna say that
0 likesfax
0 likes...I totally did not think it was just a day.
0 likesLol I was thinking of that
0 likesYeah i read it
0 likesNo one:
1392 likesMe: * watching this 5 years later*
😐
EDIT
I did not expect to get so many likes and replypies on this comment 😂😂
Replies (90)
Cutenetic_QwQ same and this was in my recommended
20 likesCutenetic_QwQ same 😔🤚
8 likesI just watched this for the first time today. 4-23-20
7 likesHello person who is WRONG
2 likes@HopeTheWolf hello person who I DONT CARE THE OPINION OF
2 likes@Cutenetic_QwQ Dude it's a joke chill
2 likeswhy the no one? i dont even get the joke anymore, it adds nothing :(
4 likes@hello xD same tbh
1 like@Cutenetic_QwQ btw ur pfp is really nice-
1 like@hello thx ^^
1 likeI was 8 when this came out
2 likessame hahah and I’ve never even watched mlp, just some songs/animatics made around it.
1 likeYes.😌😌
1 likeMe too
0 likesCutenetic_QwQ (WOW)
1 likeLMAO same
0 likesNot the only one
1 likeYeah Quartine is making me rewatch mlp even tho I'm a teenager now...
3 likesSame-a-rooni
0 likesCutenetic_QwQ literally me rn and i love these
0 likesSame
0 likesSame here
0 likesWow, so true!
0 likesYea me to ;-; XD
0 likesSame lol
0 likesHaha
1 likeThis is my first time watching this
1 likeMe too
1 likeSame
0 likesSame
0 likessame xd
0 likesSame
0 likesI was pretty sure one moon is one month, but after i watched the finale i was really confused and back to zero
2 likesSame •__•
0 likesBut like I just started watching this channel again
Lol same, same.
0 likesMe: reads this 6 months later
0 likesDo yOu meAn 5 YeaRs anD 6 moNtHs?
Same, idk why 😐
0 likesMe to
0 likesSame
1 likeSame
0 likesSame
0 likes@Bl4cK_p1nK I was 7
0 likesSame
0 likesHa same
0 likesHey me too!
0 likesSomeone write another comment in this comment five years later
0 likesSi
0 likesI'm watching in 2020 😭
0 likesSame
0 likesWho’s watching this six years later (2021)?!?!! lmao
0 likesI'm waiting this in 2021
0 likesMe too
0 likes@kat sameeee
0 likesI'm 6 years late
0 likesSame tho
0 likes6
0 likesWell I'm watching this is 6 years later
0 likesSame 😀🖐
0 likesSame
0 likes6 years for me
1 like@Êrrør.éxę same
0 likes6 years..
0 likes6
3
6
Same lol
0 likesMe being 6 years later: 😶
0 likes6 years....for me.....
0 likesMee too I am watching it 6 years later 😅😅
1 likeNow 6 :D
1 likeSame
0 likesupdate
0 likesI found the video in my recommended on April 3 2021
1 likeMe sixs years
0 likesI’m watching this 6 years later
0 likes6 years
0 likesI am in watching this in 2021
0 likesMe too but 6 years
0 likesNo one:
0 likesMe watching this 6 years later:
6 years later for me haahhha
0 likes+1
0 likesMe watching this 6 years later
0 likes6 years
0 likesIts been 5/60 moons...
0 likes6 years later ;-;
0 likesNo one:
0 likesMe watching this 6 years later:😐
Me reading ur comment 1 year later:😶
SAME
0 likes@kat same
0 likesWatching this 7 years later
0 likesme watching this 7 years later, lol
0 likes6 years for me
0 likes7 :D
0 likesMe watching it 7 years later lol
0 likesThe reason why there is a big difference between those two photos is because each family reunion is not always held in ponyville. Sometimes they hold it at other places
27 likesBrony: "How long is a"
1241 likesFRIENDS
Me: "uh, I don't think that matters"
Replies (19)
Omg XD
13 likeslol
11 likesFluttercord through out the series be like
15 likesXD
6 likesHahahahahahahahAAAAAAAAAAAA
5 likes6
4 likes)
6
Wow, so true!
2 likesWho is brony
2 likes@Rihanna this was before he became sawtooth waves.
4 likes@poptart cat oh ok thank you
2 likes@poptart cat i subbed you for no reason
2 likes@Rihanna ok. Thanks!
2 likesU meant FRieNdsSSsSssss
2 likesWhat a coincidence i read this at the same time as it played haha
4 likesFFRRRIEEEEEEEEEEEEEENNNNNNNNNNNDS
2 likes4 seconds I think
1 likeWhen
0 likesIts 7 letters long
0 likesXD
0 likesI'm curious about the mane 6, how old are they?
1280 likesReplies (186)
Disney Magic Toys probably mid 20s since they all have jobs
261 likesDisney Magic Toys I'm assuming 15-18 (cmc being 13 or 14) since in the equestria girls movies they're all in high school
274 likesOld
55 likesI heard that Twilight was 16 yrs old around the time of season 1...
120 likes@ChibiKittyCat What if pony ageing works differently?
169 likesIn ancient myths, unicorns/pegasi lived really long, like thousands of years...
But I also heard somebody say that the MLP pony lifespan is 30 years...
Idk...
17 - 20 yrs
40 likes20-30. I know that Twilight is 26-28.
62 likesAll I know is that Fluttershy is tje oldest.
59 likes@ChibiKittyCat
26 likesHumans life longer, and time can be different in Equestria, so they arent 15 years old
ChibiKittyCat but don’t they all have jobs
9 likesChibiKittyCat there no way the cutie mark crusaders are 13 in the pony world! They look and act like kids they are probably 7-10
41 likes@Llamas and penguins Forever definitely not 7
12 likesWell In Equestria Girls They Are In High School So Prob Like 16-20
9 likesWell according to reddit....
45 likesApplejack: 23-24; Rarity: 22-23; Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash: 21-22; Pinkie Pie: 20-21 (a year younger than Fluttershy); Twilight: 18-19; The entire series so far seems to have taken a little over a year, and RD had a birthday in Pinkie Pride, so they've probably all aged a year since season 1.
Twilight is like 25 what do you guys mean Bruh
14 likes@shaoshao yeah
2 likes20s maybe
0 likesThey are in high school as in equestria girls they are in high school so probably about 15-17
5 likesThey're all between the ages of 19 and 25.
5 likesI know that rainbow dash is actually 14 years old
4 likes@ChaoticBlueee nope, she's 17-19.
9 likesI believe they’re in their early 20s at the beginning of the show, late 20s by season 9
5 likesMaybe like 16-20?
1 likeSame!!!
0 likeswe'll now they are like 60-1000 since Twilight is like Celestia and 60 since the other mane six aren't
2 likesidk i found this while googling... Applejack: 23-24; Rarity: 22-23; Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash: 21-22; Pinkie Pie: 20-21 (a year younger than Fluttershy); Twilight: 18-19;
9 likesYou can search it up
0 likesThey are 1999999999999999999999999 million yep
0 likesIn the vid wehn rainbow dash had her birthday she turned 21
1 likeTwighlight-18
3 likesPinke pie-15
fluttershy-16
rainbow dash-15
rairty-16
Applejack-15 1/2
Its "main" =)
1 likeWe may need to ask celestia
2 likes@Estatic actually its mane when it comes to mlp, thats a pun
6 likestheponywiththeorangebow yeah but this is a magical not real world. And this is a real world.... tbh there could be another planet with magical beings....
1 likeThey are 9 years old
0 likesGoogle it lol
0 likes@tube cheese In the "Last problem" (spoiler if you didn't already see it),
5 likesthey're clearly older than that XD I mean, Pinkie has a KID and her kid is clearly not a baby but a child, maybe even close to being a teenager. Some parts of Rarity's mane are grey and Twilight grew up to Celestia's size! They're clearly older than that now x)
@Marie yeah, obviously? I didn't say they didn't grow older, in the show they're around that age
1 likeApplejack: 23-24; Rarity: 22-23; Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash: 21-22; Pinkie Pie: 20-21 (a year younger than Fluttershy); Twilight: 18-19; The entire series so far seems to have taken a little over a year, and RD had a birthday in Pinkie Pride, so they've probably all aged a year since season 1.
4 likes5000000000000000 moons
0 likesItz.HP_fan Gaming Celestia is a grown adult in the human world
0 likesWow, so true!
0 likesI think 18 -19
0 likesfrom all i know twilight is 27 and fluttershy is older than pinkie .
0 likes@¡Allomaz! no actually , in the last episode twilight said she can't believe it's been ten years since she started ruling which means they could have been 23-26 they weren't that young , rarity had a job which means she can't be 16 she would probably be 18-26
7 likesEevee Productions! Yeah, didn’t she confirm it herself?
0 likesI mean Princess Celesta and Luna are over 1000 years old
0 likes@ChibiKittyCat Likely
0 likes@theponywiththeorangebow Maybe
0 likes@shaoshao How U Know Tho?
0 likes@Kaswi85 , @Jasmine Brook just said that.
0 likes@Chicken strips you just copy pasted, didn't you?
0 likesAddydoesGacha YT Thats def not true I have no idea where you got that from. They’re in their 20s.
1 likeI'd say 18 or so...
1 like@ChibiKittyCat not likely considering how each species age differently.
0 likesEh, they must be teenagers then?
0 likesquaroshi I assumed she was 19 — Fluttershy being youngest and rainbow being the oldest.
1 like@Joliet Magana actually no, applejack is the oldest, just look it up :)
0 likes26 28ish I guess
1 like16 or 17 years old
0 likesAround 16 or 17
0 likessince their in highschool in equestria girls, they may be a uhhh- 15-18
0 likesA lizard granny is old doe
0 likesGuys you can Google it
1 likeActually judging from Applejack’s growth I would say that 100 moons equals to 8 years. First she is seen as a baby and then as almost adult (16 years old) and the present Reunion is now so AJ must be 24 years old.
1 likeYeah me toooo
0 likes@ChibiKittyCat I think they might be 10 cause if they were 13 or 14 they would look older and wouldn't be treated so young
0 likesMe too
0 likesAt the very end of the series they have to be around 35
1 likeApplejack: 28
2 likesFluttershy: 25
Pinkie Pie: 24
Rarity: 21
Rainbow Dash: 19
Twilight: 16
I M O R T A L
1 likeThey all have jobs so I’m guessing like young adults Anna older adults at the end
0 likes@Joliet Magana but fluttershy said that pinkie is a year younger than her and pinkie must be the youngest. I mostly think rarity is the oldest
1 likeHi
0 likesOld enough.
0 likesYes Me too!
0 likesIdk but I know that’s rainbow is 14
0 likes@ChaoticBlueee Are you kidding me!? She's like 20!
4 likesI think the mane 6 are 16 or 17 cause they're in high school and the cmc is 8 or 10 yrs old cause spur and biscuit are older than the cmc so.....the cmc are in primary school using spur and biscuit as a referance they might be in middle school ......idk tho im also pretty confused but this is my complicated theory.
1 like@Joliet Magana i don't think that fluttershy is the oldest i think its rarity cause she does work sewing whereas fluttershy doesn't have a job until season 7
0 likesLet me tell you: Twilight=18-21 ,Pinkie=16-20, Aplejack=17-22, Rarity=15-19, Rainbow Dash=13-23, Flutershy=17-20 . There you have it
0 likes@𝑊𝑜𝑙𝑓𝑖𝑒 𝑋𝑦🤍 Fair estimate, but I'd say thay Rarity is definitely the oldest.
1 likeThey might be 18-25
0 likes@ChibiKittyCat I think the ponies are older
0 likesinternet twilight is the youngest at 17
0 likesTwilight: 17
0 likesRarity: 24
Rainbow dash: 18
Applejack: 28
Fluttershy: 20
Pinkie: Somewhere around 20 years old
The cmc are likely 7-13 the main six 16- 20. Rarity is likely 19 twilight 17 pinkie 15.5 fluttershy 16.5 rainbowdash 16 applejack 18. CMC are all the same age
0 likesGood point
2 likes@Multi-purpose account your right
0 likesprobably 17+
0 likesMe too
0 likesI googled it said their were 13 the cutie mark crusaders are from 6 to 10
0 likes@Estatic no no.......its "mane"
1 likeI would say that we probably can’t compare their age in equestria girls to their pony age, considering in the pony world celestia is thousands of years old, and if she was that old in the human world, she would be dead.
0 likesWell I know that Twilight is 27
0 likesTwilight is 27 years old
0 likes@ChibiKittyCat nah like the cmc are probably 9-11 bc tbh with them being called little kids at 14 is kinda a bit....
0 likesYou can look on google
1 likeI think in the beginning of the series they are about 18-20,, so by the end of the series they would be about 28-30
0 likes500 pony years
1 likeAbout mid 20s
( I think MLP time is faster )
So am I Twilight has got to be a young adult which means about somewhere in here twentys
0 likes@ChibiKittyCat this is late but- Celestia is said to be older than 1000 years. Time and age is different in the new universe
0 likes@Joliet Magana no twilight is
0 likes@Joliet Magana but shes older than the mane four. Not twilight
0 likes@CJ Wintch PERIODT!!😂😂
0 likesLauren Faust said they age like humans, but it doesn't really match up.
0 likesI think glutyershy is 27?
0 likes@Jasmine Brooke I think you did some promising research so I’m believing you
0 likesEarly 20's i assume
0 likes@Llamas and penguins Forever I think they are like 9 yr old but scootalo(pretty sure that's not how u spell it) 10
1 likelate teens to early adult 17-23 at the end of the show they were all like grandma or mom age but it’s confusing bc in equestria girls they were all trens
0 likes@Crystal 959 no it’s been so many more years then that at the point of season 9 i think when the first epsidoe started twilight was around 17 and the oldest was like rarity who was 23 or somthing everyone eles was in the middle and by the end of the show they were all like grandma age idk the exact so i’m just saying grandma cuz u get what i mean or maby in there 30-40 that’s probly more accurate
0 likesthey don’t live whith there parents anymore there’s no way there 9
0 likesMhhmmh
0 likesseven- there are seven of them- spike-
0 likesMaybe 15 16
0 likesI’m guessing in their 20s
0 likesLikely early to mid-twenties since they all seem to be about the same age and their qualified to own businesses
0 likesI'm curious about celestia how old is she
0 likes18/19 in beginning and unknown tbh at end
0 likesVery?
0 likes10000999
0 likesPropably on their thirtys
1 like@theponywiththeorangebow wait but people(ponies)could get jobs in high school
0 likes26 I saw that in a comic
0 likesMaybe 100 months
0 likes@shaoshao shes not because fluttershy is the oldest and theyre all teenagers
0 likes10000000000001
0 likesTwilight = 27
0 likesPinkie Pie = 19
Fluttershy = 20
Rainbow Dash = 21
Applejack = 19
Rarity = 26
@Estatic you don’t get the joke it’s actually “mane”
0 likes@Michael Jacksons Biggest Fan Gacha Life and more! nope
0 likesFluttershy is a year older than Pinkie Pie.
0 likesThat's the only canon I know of...
My own headcanon is that Twilight's the youngest, followed by Pinkie, Dash, AJ, Flutters and lastly Rarity
@ChibiKittyCat cmc are in primary school tho
0 likesTwilight is confirmed to be 27
0 likesFluttershy is about 32 but I'm not sure about the others
@Michael Jacksons Biggest Fan Gacha Life and more! No
0 likesAsk the google
0 likesFluttershy is the youngest (im pretty sure), shes 20 years! but all of them are in their 20s
0 likesMe too
0 likesSame
0 likes1000 yrd :D
0 likesPersonally, I believe pony’s live to be thousands of years old. Because Granny Smith was there when ponyville was founded, and ponyville was founded a LONG time ago. And at the end of season nine, twilight got her flowy/glittery main, and from the old story’s the princesses tell us, it takes pretty long to get to that stage.
0 likesLike 17-18 and the cmc is like 14/15-16 since they are in high school and the ages for high school is 14-17, the ages for middle school is 11-14
0 likesAnd the age for elementary school is 5-11. Correct me if I'm wrong.
@ChibiKittyCat in the equestria cmc is 8-10 years old
0 likesAbove 18 so dont worry
0 likes@Llamas and penguins Forever they’re taking about in eg
0 likes@learn to do —— change your name
0 likes@Carla ARMYxBLINK Pinkie has to 19 because in “Griffon the Brush-Off,” Fluttershy says she is a year older than Pinkie Pie, and a side note; Pinkie Pie’s canon birthday is May 3rd
0 likesApple Bloom is actually 7, it says that on the script from Applebuck Season and Griffon the Brush Off
0 likesI’m assuming that it is 20 to 23
0 likesI saw a website that I thought didn’t sound right but whatever I heard that applejack is 24 rarity is 23 rainbow dash is 21 flutter shy is 21 pinkie pie is 20 and Twilight is 19
1 like@Eden st4rlight oaky
0 likesTwilight is 27
0 likesProbably 16 -20s
0 likesTwilight should be around 27 I think
0 likesEqustria girls are younger
0 likesBut I only know Twilight's age 27
0 likesthere 17-16
0 likesI'm sure rainbo dash is about 16 and fluttershy is 13 alpple jack is 18 rarirty is 19 pinkie 15 twilight 20 she most oldest😂🤣
0 likesSomewhere around 23
0 likesyea im curious how old are they???
0 likes20
0 likesOver 1000 moons at least
0 likesCurrently there 28 30
0 likesIn 20
0 likesi know fluttershy is one year older then pinkie pie
0 likes@Multi-purpose account 16 yrs old seriously
0 likesThe human world would work in contrast to the ponies because ponies age differently just like other animals. Twilight could still be an adult for ponies/ horses. Or fully matured. Which could easily be 17-18 in human years
0 likes@Llamas and penguins Forever yes they’re still foals maybe not days old, but probably a few weeks
0 likesThey might be 16 or 20
0 likes@theponywiththeorangebow im thinking 11-14
0 likes27
0 likesTrue
0 likes@Nilima Begum 365 ...
0 likes@theponywiththeorangebow yes that works
0 likesI'm pretty sure they're teenagers
1 like@GNDraws they look 5
0 likes@Ukiyo Karoshi uhm your user means death exhaustion of the floating word....
0 likes6 0 0 0 Y E A R S O L D (joke)
0 likes@Joliet Magana probably 30-40
0 likesThe CMC's and Spike-8
0 likesPinkie and Rainbow-16
Flutters-17
Twilight and Rarity-18
Applejack-19
Well the mane 6 is 20 years
0 likesY'all I don't think they are teenagers. They writers just wanted to put them in a high school setting for EG. The age of their human self is not the same. An example of a teenager pony would be Sandbar from the student 6. Based on how the Mane 6 live their lives in Equestria, they seem like younger adults. Like early 20s. They all have full time jobs and live on their own.
0 likesim not seeing them in a new generation
0 likes@ChaoticBlueee rainbow is an adult she literally said it in one episode 💀
0 likestheyre most likely in their early to late 20s. they said it in like 2 episodes that theyre grown ups and adults
0 likes@JELLY Cherry The Cat theyre adults bro they said it in multiple episodes
0 likesGoing by new evidence from season 6's Applejack's Day Off
1079 likesI believe one 'Moon' = one week
Meaning 30 moons will be 7 and 1/2 months
and 100 moons would be around two years
This also works out because, on the very very first episode the Apple's were having a family reunion
Then in Season 3 they have another one
The seasons are (in our world) one year apart from each other, and one year = 52 weeks
So two years will be 104 weeks - those two yeas will be all of Season 1 and all of Season 2
Replies (39)
I think 1 moon is 1 month
15 likes100 moons is 100 years in Equestria
2 likesNope. I personally believe that one month equals one moon. Like he said in the video, fam.
7 likesSeason one through season four is one year.
8 likeswow alot of shit happens to equestria in one year....
15 likesWe have 9 seasons now and it has been Aired for 9 years now 1 season = one year
6 likesI dont think Ponies age that much
9 years apple Bloom is still a kid pony
And granny Smith is a bit weird
She was there when Equestria was made
But she was older in one episode or so so the Reunion must have Been before equestria was made but that does not make sence
@Rainbow Cookie Do you mean when PonyVille was founded? Because I don't think Grannysmith is thousands of years old.
10 likes@Apino yeah i was a bit confused in those episodes
3 likes@Rainbow Cookie Ah, that explains it!
2 likesToo much math
1 likeMonths
1 likeBut according to Season 4 Episode 1, everything in Seasons 1-3 happened within Twilight's first year in Ponyville (S4E1 takes place on the Summer Sun Celebration directly after S1E1)
7 likesThe very first episode took place on (or maybe the day before) the Summer Sun Celebration, the pony version of the summer solstice
3 likesWe see another Summer Sun Celebration a few seasons later, I don't remember which season, it was either 3 or 4, but unless the show decided to skip over such an important event, that would be exactly 1 year
What did AJ's day off say about moons?
0 likes@MetalGearPony As Twilight, Rarity and Spike head to Sweet Apple Acres, Rarity tells them that she and Applejack haven't had a spa day in 'moons'
2 likes1 moon is 1 month
1 likeUgly-Duckling 123
1 likeThat’s actually a good theory
a new moon is formed every month
1 likeNope its 1 year
0 likes@BaseSPEEDPAINT yt how is it a year
0 likes@james the soldier its roughly a year so every year they take photos but as theorized they must of lost some
0 likes@BaseSPEEDPAINT yt it just seems like a moon is a month
0 likes@james the soldier well i actually look it up and it said this That means 100 moons have passed between "Friendship is Magic" and "Apple Family Reunion" According to the S4 Premiere, the events of Seasons 1-3 all occurred within the same year. That means that 100 moons < 1 equestrian year.
0 likes@BaseSPEEDPAINT yt ok sorry
0 likes@james the soldier its fine u just wanted me to explain
1 likeNo see a moon is a a full moon and every month there is full moon so a moon would be month
0 likes@Lisa Dann ya i said that to but it means years in mlp apperintly
0 likes@Lisa Dann its actually a yr in mlp not a month
0 likes@james the soldier oh sorry but like wouldn't they be dead on the first family reunion but it's a kids show though it would make more sense if it was a month but it's not so that means my conspiracy theory was right apple bloom will not grow
1 like20 yrs for Luna's imprisonment?
0 likes@eatornator3000 depends on how many moons she was locked up
0 likes@BaseSPEEDPAINT yt 1000 years or moons, idk
0 likesMakes sense
0 likesBut in the last episode they said that the mane 6 would meet once a moon n I’m pretty sure they won’t travel from ponyville to canterlot n back every week since they r older n have their own lives now......I’m pretty sure one moon is one month
0 likesBut if each season is another year in their world, it doesn't make sense for CMC to still look the same
0 likesWe have atleast two onscreen winters between season 1 and 4 though, first time in "Winter wrap up" and second time in "Hearth's Warming Eve"
0 likesHaving only one year passing between these two would require the episodes to not be released in chronological order, which I hope is not the case.
Taking all events happened into consideration, season 1 alone would already be atleast 3 years long.
Just because one season was published once a year doesn’t mean that in their world 1 year also happened. It’s probably way shorter.
1 like@Ayla Nassen If 100 moons is 100 years how can they do a family reunion every 100 years and applebloom be at 2 reunions and still be a filly???
1 like@Mx. Phoenix (They\he\it\neos) not sure! that was four years ago!
0 likesThe "moon" time measurement thing does get confusing sometimes. I do wish the exact equivalent was stated somewhere, but your theory is pretty interesting too. Thanks for sharing this with us! ^_^
2 likesIf Equestria relies on the princesses to raise the sun and moon, what would have happened if there hadn't been any unicorns or alicorns at all? Would the sun and moon move on their own like the clouds in the Everfree Forest? The science and logic of the MLP world is puzzling. ^_^;
So here is my take:
3 likesThe only reason why Luna would need to revolve the moon around the planet would be if the moon were too far away from its orbit. If the moon were that far away, the planet's axial tilt would have been too unstable for life to form and therefore Luna would not have been able to have been born.
Also, as I have likely mentioned somewhere else, in order for a geocentric system on a life-supporting Earth to take place, the star would need to be barely large enough for a star to form and barely inside of Earth's orbit. This means that in order for a geocentric Equus or whatever, its gravitational pull would need to be equal to or greater than that of Earth's, as any less would mean no star could form that could support life on a geocentric Equus. Adding to that, there is evidence to believe that the gravity on Equus is likely equal to Earth's gravity at most. The tree that houses the Castle of Friendship towers over the huts of Ponyville at about 6 times the height of a standard hut, meaning that it is likely to be about 180 feet in height, assuming one story is 10 feet and the huts are 3 stories high at most in the image I am referencing https://images.app.goo.gl/GtRKXrwLdE39w3rA6. Even if there were more than 3 stories on a particular hut, meaning the tree is over 180 feet high, this still means that the tree is, at least, approximately the height of a giant sequoia, which is so tall because of the lack of disease-carrying relatives in the areas they are located in. The tree housing the Castle of Friendship, however, does have to contend with the Everfree Forest, which has been known to expand into Ponyville on occasion. This means that a tree that large in an area such as Ponyville may be considered unnatural on a planet with a gravitational pull like Earth's, but on a planet with a weaker gravitational tug, where the nutrients of the tree can circulate to higher places, it may be just fine. This means that Equus's gravitational pull is likely equal to Earth's at the very most, thus likely being unable to host a life-supporting star within its orbit.
My theory could possibly be that Granny Smith, like my high school geometry teacher (and possibly Princesses Celestia and Luna), exaggerates the time between events.
Warriors logic- one moon equals one month, the reasoning for this is that they refer to the cycle of the moon, how it takes a month to cycle around, thus, one moon. That makes the most sense to me. :i
66 likesReplies (3)
BEEEEEEEEEEEEEFFFFFFFFFFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOREEEE you comment, "omg no equestria is a different universe", I said it makes most sense to me. So ye.
3 likesAgreed. Before I watched this video, I honestly just assumed one moon was one month because of our moon cycle
0 likesI always assume 1 month too tbh
0 likesWell, it takes about a month to change through all the stages of the moon. So a moon's a month. 100 moons is 100 months. 100 months is... ahh, let's see... 8 years and 4 months.
18 likes"I'm Applejack, More apple fritter?"
454 likesMe : Awwwwwwwwwwweeeeeee
Replies (5)
Baby Applejack steals the show :')
23 likesAwww that’s adorable, that touched my heart🥰
7 likesThat so cuteeeeee!
2 likesAwww
1 likeThat. Was. Adorableeeeee!
0 likesI've thought about this for a good while. It's safe to assume that Equestria uses a lunar calendar and because the show doesn't say how long a lunar month is or how many days each phase of the moon lasts, so I'll use the cycle of our moon. Each phase of our moon lasts 3-8 days, considering that the months of most lunar calendars last between 28-30 days depending on the culture. Considering that like here on Earth, Equestria has 4 seasons with 3 full lunar phases each season. A few things the show is unclear on is how many days in a week they have, how many weeks make up a month, how long each lunar cycle is and how many months make up a year, so it would be safe to assume that 100 moons would be 2-3 years unless some official source comes out giving measurements of time.
0 likesA lunar cycle is 28 days on Earth. If things work the same way in Equestria then that's approximately 2800 days or 7 years, 8 months, and 5 days. This will vary depending on the length of a month, leap years, and whether Equestria uses a solar or lunar calendar. I assumed 30 day months, no leap year, and a solar calendar.
1 likeI personally feel that 1 moon equals approximately 2 1/2 days. 30 moons would equal 75 days, and 100 moons would be 250-ish days. This corresponds with the fact that Seasons 1 & 3 both contain Apple Family Reunions (S1E1 and S3E8), and, according to S4E1, the first 3 seasons take place during Twilight's first year in Ponyville.
0 likesThis makes Rainbowdash's seperation from Tank in season five more logical, while not seeing your friend/pet for three months isn't terrible, "It's okay Rainbowdash, you'll see Tank again in another three months." (AJ) factoring this time, it's logical to assume that there are also twelve months in an Equestrian year, this means though AJ says three months, it's more like six months, half a year in our world. Suddenly Rainbow's dread of losing Tank is a lot more important.
33 likesevery moon is a month. so it's 150 months old that applejack is, and since 12 years is the middle age of most ponies, i'm saying that applejack is an adult in her early 20's in human years. I'm saying that every moon is a month because there is only 1 full moon every month. This also applies to the warrior cats universe aswell
1 likeI think that an equestrian year is closer to 50 moons, since the apple family reunion would be every year with the 100 moon year, it seems highly unlikely, the 100 moon year is troublesome, especially with the seasons, either, all the seasons are about twice as long as our own (which, just think of the food stores) or there are two sets of seasons in a year, which is highly unlikely and I would probably find proof against it if I bothered to look at winter wrap up. It's more likely that they measure a year by the passing of the seasons, in ancient times they would let the seasons follow through and become a year, while now it's presice, as we see the ponies make sure that the seasons are on time.
1 likeI know I'm a newer fan to the show,for a few weeks now,first I thought moons meant years for them,cause not once I ever heard them say years,but granny smith is old and she's probably been to dozens of family reunions when she was young,so it can't mean years,it has to mean months or a few years or something similar to that
2 likesI'm sure someone must have brought this up before, but one Equestrian year is most likely determined by the seasons. The year starts and ends with the beginning of winter or the beginning of spring--or perhaps at mid-winter. And unless the seasons in Equestria are significantly longer than our own, their year is likely similar to ours in length. So 50 moons in 1 year might be a pretty good guess.
0 likesI've just thought of a potential theory, but it could be far-reaching. My theory is that an Equestrian year could be equivalent to possibly Jupiter's moon Eurydome, with the length of a year being 717 days. If you divide the number of days it takes Eurydome to orbit around Jupiter by how many days we have per year on Earth (365), we get 1.92, which is almost the exact length of time (2 years) it took in the real world for Twilight to become crowned as the next princess, but only a year in-universe.
0 likesWhile this is completely speculative, I think that their years are vastly longer than ours. This may also explain the odd thing we see in MLP where the moon is usually full in vast majority of episodes. It could also explain the "hundreds of moons" closing of the borders in "Party Pooped". So 1 moon may equal to 717 days. It is my best assumption as some years on other moons are years long or a single orbit could last 7 hours.
so luna was traped on the moon for 1000 years is actualy 2000 earth years
60 likesReplies (1)
No, it's actually half of our time (500yrs), not double. You got the equation wrong.
4 likesOne thing you forgot was that the growth of ponies by age is completely different from that of humans. So while Applebloom hasn't changed much, a few years could have passed, as each stage of pony growth lasts about 3 to 6 years, theoretically speaking.
0 likesStage 1: 1 to 4 years - baby;
Stage 2: 5 to 10 years - child;
Stage 3: 11 to 16 years - teen;
Stage 4: 17 to 20 years - next to adult;
Stage 5: 21 years onwards - Adult.
Sorry for the late comment, I just got to know your channel now.
Heres an idea on the photo thing. Early on, photos would most likely require a unicorn who is specialized in pictures. Well there couldn’t have been too many of those walking around that long ago with how young the tech would have been. As time goes on, though you have innovations in the tech. Thus making picture taking a lot simpler and more common. Which is shown by how close together the later pictures seem to be.
0 likes8 years would be way too long for horses though. A horse is considered old by age 12 so this would be applebloom’s first ever reunion as a fillie.
1 like100 moons have passed between "Friendship is Magic" and "Apple Family Reunion" According to the S4 Premiere, the events of Seasons 1-3 all occurred within the same year. That means that 100 moons < 1 equestrian year.
1 likeI like how we both have similar theory’s of how years works in MLP universe.
0 likes1 human year has 12 months. But one of are year equals to 2 years in Equestria. So that means one of their year is about 6 months. So let’s say Princess Celestia is 1000 years old to use that would mean she like 500 years old. MLP Pony’s lifespans probably shorter then human if this is true.
"I'm Applejack! Mowe apple fwittew?"
174 likesMe: AHHHHHHHHHHhH
Replies (2)
Wow, so true!
3 likes🥰😍😘
1 like100 moons could refer to 100 lunar cycles (about 10 years).
3 likes"How long is a hundred moo-FRIEEEEEEEEEEEEEENDSSSSS"
149 likesReplies (5)
Wow, so true!
1 likeinfinite
1 likeApple S ??
0 likesMooooo cow 🐄🐄🐄🐄🐄
0 likes🐄
0 likes＊ I’m not at all sure how to feel about Equestria not being earth. One of my favorite dumb things about this series is how the seasons and days work. It’s cool and interesting and brings up so many questions. How did equestria even work before ponies? How did anything evolve? It makes so little sense and I love it. The idea of a regular year cycle is ridiculous in the first place when ushering spring into existence (all at once!) is halfway between a civic duty and a chore. Equestria can’t be on this planet or any planet really. And honestly I find it stupidly endearing.
0 likesMost families do family reunions once a year .. so 100 moons being 1 year kinda makes sense ... but its still hard to figure out how much time has passed when they use like 20 moons or 30 moons
0 likesAn interesting theory but here's a few problems with it, bear in mind this might be a bit of a read so please bear with me.
139 likesThe first episode of the series was during the Apple Family Reunion as well. Remember that in Apple Buck Season, Twilight asked Applejack why she couldn't get more of her family to help, to which AJ replied "They were all just here for the Apple Family Reunion". Meaning that if 100 moons was a year then there is a big problem because that episode was in the middle of the 3rd season, and as we know from the Season 4 Premiere, that premiere marked the 1 year anniversary for the Mane 6 as it was the same day they met and became friends one year later.
This means that 100 moons cannot equal a year but there must be more than that if every episode is released in chronological order. So unfortunately your theory is kind of destroyed by the writers themselves not being consistent XD
Another problem this causes is mainly due to the fact that of course Equestria (which is a country not a planet btw) is not in our world. Simply put, the seasons are in haywire. In our solar system every planet has their own season but it's still the four and this is all based on the orbit of the planet and where the poles are facing in correlation to the sun. Spring, Summer, Fall and Winter in that order. But see, in the course of the full three seasons that we saw in the one year for Equestria, we had two, count em, two winters. We had Winter Wrap up in Season 1 (two episodes later we had the beginning of Fall with Fall Weather Friends) and then in Season 2 we had Hearths Warming Eve. We do know that pegasi can manipulate the weather and we've seen other episodes that appear to be in the fall despite most clearly being in spring or summer. But again this is a real problem for measuring time in Equestria because their seasonal patterns do not follow any real obvious pattern that would help us identify years.
But a bigger problem also is that since when we view "moons" as lunar cycles, this would mean that the moon in Equestria would have to go through phases as well if this theory is to be correct. Unfortunately every time we see the moon it is always full and never either waxing, waning or new. So this can't be the case unless we are somehow only seeing it during the full phase. Not even in Princess Twilight Sparkle where the sun and moon were both in the sky direct next to each other. The only explanation for how the moon could still be fully illuminated from that angle would mean that the moon is somehow further away and larger than Equestria's sun and either emits light or SOMEHOW is so reflective that even with the full blaze of the sun going it doesn't blot it out.
Furthermore an interesting thing to note also. In the Family Appreciation Day episode it was made clear that Granny Smith was around when Ponyville was founded. Given hear appearance she couldn't have been too much older than the Mane 6 are now (which is really subject). Yet here's where things get very interesting. See in Winter Wrap Up, Twilight said that Ponyville had been doing it without magic "for hundreds of years". So Granny Smith has to be a few hundred years old as not only was it clear that Granny Smith wasn't lying about the events and we know Twilight studies the crap out of everything so wouldn't exactly exaggerate this point either. And if their years are twice as long this would imply that in how we view time, Granny Smith is potentially between 4000 and 1,000 years old (as exactly how many "hundreds of years" that means).
My point is basically, don't try to put logic into the show, it won't work cause it's a world of magical talking technicolor ponies. Don't get me wrong, I kinda wanna figure some of this out too but at the end of the day there's too many inconsistencies that make theories like this next to impossible to work out while taking everything into consideration.
Replies (20)
She said it has been ALMOST 100 moons
4 likeswow long comment
2 likes@justlike fire There's a lot to point out.
4 likesThe episodes are in no particular order: in one ep it's summer and in the next one a winter.
9 likes@rautamiekka Ah but they are clearly points where there is continuity. It's when the seasonal changes like summer and winter come about that the continuity really falls apart. The only real safe thing, in my mind at least, to argue with this is that Equestria goes through strange seasons. I sort of accept this idea simply on the grounds that the weather, and thus the seasons, are dictated by the Pegasi and their weather management.
7 likesAll in all, it's kinda silly to try and decifer how years and time in general passes in a world where seasons and even night and day are controlled manually.
TheBelieveit1 THAT IS TOO MUCH,I REPEAT TOO MUCH
3 likesThis, and your reply to another comment below, just blew my mind. There's really a lot to consider. I don't think the writers of the show thought any of this through. Until they release a canon time conversion, we simply won't know. Especially since their seasons, weather, sun, and moon are controlled manually, as you pointed out.
8 likes@theponywiththeorangebow I don't think so either. There's a lot of other things to consider that won't come up I am certain, but what can yah do? At the end of the day it's a kids' show about magical talking technicolor ponies.
2 likesTheBelieveit1 Oh come on, I think we all know it isn't really aimed at kids anymore. I mean sure it's still appropriate for them, but the staff knows they need to please their older fans as well, and that's what they're doing.
3 likes@theponywiththeorangebow They're still the targetted demographic and is still classified as a children's animated fantasy television series.
1 likeYou just proved @theponywiththerainbow's word: may still be called what it's called, but whether they wanna please the older fans doesn't mean anything before the target audience description changes, which'll take more than just changing the episodes to be less appropriate for the original target audience.
2 likesIt gets really weird when you consider that when the Everfree Forest was introduced it freaked the ponies out that the weather and animals took care of themselves. Further work in that Celestia and Luna only cover Equestria but there are clear references to things beyond Equestria (and there are delegates to things from areas implicitly part of Equestria, so I think it is something of a republic) it seems all of this control is localized. What happens at the boarders? The sun must rise and set, as must the moon, in YakYakistan (beyond even the most extreme part of what could be considered Equestria) or Terik's homeland (stated explicitly to be beyond Equestria). So could the sun set in Equestria while it is mid-day in YakYakistan? What of those outlying lands when Nightmare Moon did not remove the moon/blocked out the sun with the moon?
6 likesBut between what I've heard about Mz. Faust's experiences and Transformers gen. 1's Hasbro approved "you don't need a big story board fix it in editing" approach to continuity I doubt the writers have the support needed to keep track of such details.
Travis Smith Oh wow, that's true. We don't know anything of what's beyond Equestria. They could have a different way of telling time too. Not to mention a different rate at which their seasons change. Honestly everything that tries to explain logic in that show just messes logic up even more. You guys are all making really good points.
3 likesWhat I thought was that moons were days. Because they don't say "full moon" or " half moon" ( correct me if I'm wrong) and there are moons everyday, even if it's a new moon. Yeah :3
1 like@Ditb Aj That's true but it's not what they typically mean. A moon is a full moon cycle.
0 likesI opened it and Went "OH MAH GOD"
1 likehow long did it take you to write this..
1 likeMaybe they don't run off of seasons to make their years? Seeing as they aren't humans and don't do everything w do it might be that seasons don't effect the way the year goes around. Any rouge pegasi could change it from winter to summer any time they want (Like in fall weather friends )so having the ability to do this would change the way they see a year.
0 likesHOW LONG DID IT TAKE TO WRITE THAT!!! jk ----> YOU DOING AN ESSAY O.o
0 likes( lol but 4 real that a lot O.o )
Can someone summarize is because it was TL:DR
0 likesI know it's been a LONG while since this video was uploaded but I've found solid evidence for what I beleive in. Just watched "Grannies Gone Wild" where Applejack said that their trip to Las Pegasus is annual, and just before they get into the Wild Blue Yonder while walking up the stairs to it, Goldie Delicious says that they've been going there every moon since that they can remember, so yeah the basic train of thought was right all along that 1 Moon = 1 Year.
0 likesGreat theory and speculation, but there is a flaw in your conclusion: ages. If equestrian years are twice as long as Earth years, why did 5-years-old applebloom from that flashback looked and acted like a five years old and not like, well, a ten years old? You could say that ponies age slower than humans, but in this case, human-twilight would be a 40-years-old lady, not a goddamn teenager.
0 likesMaybe I can answer to this. I'm actually sure that 1 moon is around 1 MONTH. Let me explain:
0 likesAt school, in history class, I learned that Incas people use lunar calendars because they praise the Moon. My history teacher told me that they count the number of times that the Full Moon was back in ONE year (with the calendar). He also told that for the Incas people 1 moon is equal to 28 days, so about 1 month. So, we could guess that 100 moons is 100 months.
And, I'm agree with the fact that Equestria isn't Earth so maybe what I say is false. Because Apple Bloom didn't changed at all since the last Apple Family Reunion: it means that at Equestria, the duration of a moon is not equal to the duration of a moon for US. But, I really don't know, nothing is confirmed, all what I'm sure, is that ONE moon is 1 month in Earth.
Here is my thought about that and hope what I say is logical! c:
"and we know a year couldnt possibly be one day"
2 likesall the planets whose year is less than a day: am i a joke to you?
A moon is mostly likely a Month.
33 likesSo 100 moons (or months) is just over 8 years.
Meaning Granny Smith could easily have been at almost/all of the reunions.
Replies (1)
Anonymous Candle WHY CAN'T UNDERSTAND ENYTHING COMMENT'S ARE SAYING!?!?!??btw i'm useing my dad's acount
0 likesAlternitivly the lunar cycles of both "Earth" and Equestira are somewhat synchronized... (As in 100 moons on earth is 100 moons on equestira so either ponies age slower than humans or time flows differently across dimensions/planes... )
0 likesSawtooth waves said “ how long is 100 moon”
3 likesLona “ 100 nights is 100 moons”
The moon “ yes she is correct”
Old video, but you overlooked an obvious explanation for why Apple Bloom doesn't look much younger in the previous reunion picture. The Apples had an extra reunion when the a large number of the family was in town anyway for the Summer Sun Celebration in Ponyville. It wasn't their typical 100 moon reunion, but kind of a mini reunion they had for the occasion. That would be where the picture including Apple Bloom would have come from. Since seasons 1-3 all take place in one year; the Apple Family reunion episode would have been less than a year after the first Summer Sun celebration, but they had another reunion anyway since that was when the traditional 100 moons reunion was supposed to be. It also would explain why there weren't nearly as many in that photo, perhaps some of the family just couldn't make it to the one during the summer sun celebration and knew another reunion was less than a year away, so they didn't worry about it.
0 likes1 moon being 1 month just works too well with the EQG story line. In the first movie, Twilight's friends talk about the freshman fair as if it were the last time they were all friends, and they look obviously younger in the picture. To work with the EQG story line, including later movies and specials, I think in the first movie, they're all in their junior year. That especially makes sense to me, since in my own high school, it was the junior class that was in charge of the fall dance, while it was the seniors that put on prom in the spring. We know it was Sunset that split them apart, and in Forgotten Friendship, Pinkie even says it was in freshman year when some of it happened, which would be at least two years earlier. Assuming Sunset took some time to get herself situated and figure things out in the human world she'd probably been there since before the start of the freshman year which would be around two and a half years, or 30 months.
Most likely when she first went through the portal, Sunset arrived in the mid to late spring before their freshman year, giving her enough time to get herself set up in the world before starting school. Then two and a half years or 30 months later, the portal opens again and EQG1 happens. And I don't think the portal could have opened in between because I really doubt Sunset would have skipped the portal opening, and neither would Celestia. Really, I think Celestia had been planning to send Twilight through to find Sunset anyway, and that was the whole reason she arranged for Twilight to be there when the portal opened. She was probably going to explain that morning and ask Twilight to go and look for her, but then Sunset stole the crown and it was the perfect excuse. It's clear Celestia still cared about Sunset even then, and had likely been worried about her; after all what was the very first thing she asked when Twilight got back; "Sunset Shimmer; is she alright?"
I believe that a month is a moon because in one episode (I don't remember the name), Pinkie Pie, Maud, and Rarity were doing PSSD and the store owner that Pinke was going to visit was on a vacation. No one would vacation for two years, especially not in Manehatten. The store wouldn't exist anymore or AT LEAST have someone else running it. And a moon is usually focused on the moon's cycle, where there is a full moon every month.
0 likesthe mirror portal always leads to what used to be a statue outside CHS. so that means that the Canterlot and CHS share the exact same position in time and space. when the mirror was brought to Twilight's castle, there was a shift in the time-space continuum, resulting in multiple portals being created. where's Dr Whooves when you need him?!
0 likesI think 100 moons is just under a year. Reasoning: Season 1 Episode 1) Twilight is sent to Ponyville to arrange the summer sun celebration, at this time there are many many apples. Applejack explains this in Ep4 Applebuck Season saying "They were just here for the Apple family reunion. They actually live all over Equestria..."
0 likesThe next family reunion is of course Season 3 Ep 8 Apple Family Reunion. Not much to figure here, it's the next reunion.
The next Summer Sun celebration is Season 4 Ep1/2 Princess Twilight Sparkle, this is indicated by Celestia saying "I must admit that it is wonderful to actually be looking forward to the Summer Sun Celebration."
There was a reunion at beginning of season 1 and then one in 3.
0 likesIn 4 there is evidence that season 1 - 3 is all one year because in 4x1 Celestia says something about how she hated the summer sun celebration because it reminded her of how she banished her sister but now it’s a Joyce occasion of how they are reunited. If there was summer sun celebration after the pilot and before 4x1 then twilight should already know that Celestia hated the summer sun celebration. Celestia wouldn’t have said “now it’s a Joyce occasion about her transformation” because if there was one before then she wouldn’t have to say that because twilight and Equestria would already know.
Anyway, I think 100 moons is 200 days meaning a moon would be two days. this would make sense based on the fact season 1-3 is a year. There isn’t any idea how long of a gap between 3-4 there is but I can assume not a lot. AB in season 3 is around 10 and 9 in season 1 so it would make sense that only 200 days have gone by and she wouldn’t have changed. I also feel the third photo in the album of reunion Is the one before the season 1 opening because there was clearly more ponies there.
I’m probably just talking nonsense.
Replies (1)
1-3 seasons couldn't be one year just because they have winters both in 1 and 2 seasons (ep 11x1 and 11x2). With everything else taking place in summers, there is at least 2 years between seasons 1 and 3
0 likesNow here's a flaw. if 100 moons is a year, and a moon is X days long. then a year would be a very long time in terms of days if it was more than 4 days per moon cycle. I think it has been observed in MLP that Twilight has been in Equestria for multiple Winter rap ups, Nightmare nights, and Hearts-warmings. So let's say a moon cycle is 10 days long. gives us a year of a thousand days.
0 likesfor a year in Equestria if it is 50 or 100 moon if you are right, then the CMC shouldn't need to be at school for that whole time. That equates to 500 or 1000 days a year.
Here is a different approach, that the photos are not quite right. we can maybe assume that it's photo drawn quickly without full thought. What we know is that a couple of family gatherings back AJ was just a baby, she is now a fully grown adult, so maybe we can consider that 100 moons is several years. So maybe a year is more like 20 moons with a 20-day cycle? making an equestrian year 400 days. which is not that much longer than our calendar. I am not saying that I am right, but a variation of that makes more sence.
I tend to go with the 1 Moon=1 day approach. After all, we see in Princess Twilight Sparkle that with both the Sun and the Moon in the sky, Resulting in this weird half-day half-night effect. The only way that that could be the case is if the Moon was generating its own light that had a quality of negating and matching the light of the Sun. This means that the Sun light reflecting off the moon would not actually do anything.
18 likesFurther, in Equestria girls, it is clear that Sunset Shimmer came through the portal knowing not only that Twilight had uncovered the Elements, but also sufficiently aware of what the element of magic would look like to bring a reasonable copy to replace it with. On top of all that, she knew that Twilight would be present, within easy striking distance, on the other side of the mirror. To me, this means that she must have come through the portal between Twilight's Coronation and the Princess Summit. This would let her know that the Summit was going on in the same castle and on the same night that the portal would be opening. As well as see Twilight in her crown. This means a length of time longer than 30 days is unlikely.
Replies (14)
Maybe the Portal had opened a day or two before Sunset made her move, as it's open for several days at a time, giving her time to scope out the situation?
0 likesExcept fluttershy saw the crown and immediately recognized it as needing to go to Celestia. If it only existed for a few days, I don't think Fluttershy would have been able to recognize it. Surely, the portal could not have been standing open for more than a week.
0 likes@Skye Silverwing
2 likesI let that fall to the "parallel worlds will be inexplicably parallel" explanation, where, by pure interdimensional plot convenience, the newest crown made at Canterlot High is destined to be all but indistinguishable (minus the magic powers, obviously) from the newest crown in Equestria. Parallel world stories often tend to have the same thing showing up for different reasons and purposes in each world, so I'm just used to that by now. Maybe Sunset had advanced-level knowledge in the mechanics of parallel worlds and expected-slash-really-really-hoped that it would hold true in this case, and it just so happened that it did.
I would be far more apt to believe the "inexplicably parallel" idea if the pictures we see of Sunset in previous Princess Crowns had shown the crowns as being those of Celestia, Luna, and Cadence, giving us reason to believe that Sunset saw the progression and realized what was coming... Still doesn't explain how Sunset knew Twilight was there, or knew her way around the Chrystal Castle (Which was missing the entire time she was alive and in Equestria) well enough to find Twilight's room.
0 likesUnless... I suppose it is possible that the portal could have opened a day early, and Sunset slipped in to see what was going on and saw Twilight getting ushered in, crown and all, and then recognized the crown as the Element of Harmony and a coincidental perfect match for the current High School crown and built the attempted switch into her plan to steal it.
Still, it all seems very coincidental to me. I prefer the idea that she had seen all she needed to the previous month, had the crown made, and put the whole thing in motion as part of her nefarious evil scheme.
Of course, I have also heard the idea that she may have had some sort of Magic Mcguffin that gave her all the information she needed up until she got involved herself.
@Skye Silverwing
0 likesAnd then there's always the chance that the writers just didn't think this deeply into it and it's just us fans who're scrambling around trying to make sense of it all. :ponyshrug:
I hate that kind of reasoning. It is out-of-continuity reasoning. I prefer to think in-continuity. Within the world, why is this the case? you know what I mean? Sure the real reason is that the writers were rushed and not very well continuity checked, but that does not mean that there is not still continuity to consider.
0 likes@Skye Silverwing
0 likes1) Realize the writers weren't thinking of the continuity.
2) Headcanon it anyway.
3) ????
4) Profit!
I don't headcanon for Profit. I headcanon for fun, and for my own sense of Continuity.
0 likes@Skye Silverwing
0 likesI mostly headcanon for fanfiction, but I do things a different way in each story, thereby keeping my perspectives fluid and open for new details.
Oh I didnt even bother to read the rest xD
0 likes@Natalie Cain omg yes dem warriors
0 likesThere are a number of reasons why Moons should not be a month.
0 likesFirst, it is not a Warriors reference. "Moons" on Earth are used to indicate the amount of time it takes for the Earth's Moon to go through its phases. It is well established, however, that Equestria's Moon functions nothing like this (Luna moves it, it orbits each day, it produces its own light, etc.).
Second, the Apple family reunion is supposed to happen every 100 moons, and has happened twice during the series. There is no way seven years have passed in that time.
Finally, the portal to the Human world opens once every 30 moons, yet somehow, Sunset Shimmer knew not only that Twilight retrieved the Elements of Harmony and become a Princess, but where she would be, and what the Element of Magic would look like. If she had had no access to Equestria for two and a half years, there is no way she could have known those things before she came through, barring some unmentioned source of Prophetic knowledge. She had to have been able to return in the time since Twilight became a Princess and the Princess Summit was scheduled. Otherwise, it is a ridiculous level of Coincidence.
Does anyone realise that if 100 moons is 1 year, then Princess Luna was banished to the Moon for 100000 moons.
1 likeActually, my theory is that one moon is about a day, which means she was on the Moon over 300000 Moons(give or take, based on how many days are in an equestrian year).
2 likesI don't see why the Equestrian year wouldn't be roughly the same length as ours
0 likesYes, 100 is a nice round number (to us, why would a fingerless species use base 10 to count things?) but it's also a lot
The Fahrenheit scale for temperature was originally supposed to have 360 degrees between the freezing and boiling of water (the number of degrees in a circle) but instead it has 180, because 360 is far too much
I see no reason why 50 moons wouldn't be a year, it's also a convenient number
But as I said earlier, why would ponies use base 10? Maybe 100 to them is an entire different number than 100 is to us
Don’t you remember??? In the first episode of the first season they had so many family members when twilight was at the farm and in the 4th episode of the 1st season (I think) applejack told twilight that it was her family reunion when twilight asked her if her other family members could help her with the apple bucking. But then they had another reunion!
0 likesSo honestly I think 100 moons isn’t that long
I’m no theorist but, maybe you can take into account that on the very first episode of mlp fim applejack has an apple family reunion, and the next known reunion is in apple family reunion. Maybe if you can somehow figure out the time line in between that, you can figure it out?
1 like100 moons are 100 months since "The Moon" Orbits the earth once every month and in finnish --- Month = Kuukausi - Moon = Kuu - Season = Kausi so in finnish Month = Kuukausi = MoonSeason.
1 likeIn my language moon and month are the same word (it's měsíc for anyone wondering), so I suppose one moon is one month?
12 likesSo... The moon on equestria is in a geosynchronous orbit? and if it is, then it should be smaller because it's in a lower orbit and it's apparent diameter should be at least 0° 33' 2.08" for it to appear as large as our own moon. Moreover, it is evident that the equestrian moon is tidally locked since it shows the same face, as is the case with our own moon. Also, the size of the moon greatly affects tides on equestrias' oceans.
0 likesWait, if apple bloom was around the same age in the previous reunion (give or take a few years) why was granny explaining the reunion to her in the episode.🤔
3 likesWoah imagine being in-prisoned in the moon for 10 years
2 likesI have an idea, you could count how many years 30 “Moons” go by, counting how many photos of Sunset Schimer in school.She was photographed every year as the "Queen of the School."Although it will be Earth years, but it is at least something.
0 likesУ меня идея, ты мог бы посчитать сколько лет проходит 30 "Лун" , посчитав сколько фотографий Сансет Шимер в школе.
Она же каждый год фотографировалась, как "Королева школы".
Хотя это будут земные года, но это хоть что то.
I wonder what do you think about girls' ages relative to each other. Only canon that I know of is that Fluttershy is a year older than Pinkie. Also, it's safe to assume Shy and Dash are classmates, why else would they know each other so well?
0 likesMy headcanon goes like this:
Twilight (youngest)
Pinkie Pie (+1yr)
Dash, Fluttershy, AJ (+2yr)
Rarity (who I assume to be anywhere between 3-7yrs older than Twi, she's most 'adult' of all judging by her career and personality)
So if 1 moon is month, that means twilight would've had to try and survive over 2 years in the normal world if she didn't get back in time
0 likesGeez
“How long is a moon?”
42 likes*warriors fandom comments intensified*
Replies (5)
I wandered too!
0 likesSame
0 likesMeow! Im s*n0wk!t
0 likesYes im snowkit im alive i know moons but mostly snow and snow snow snow and snow
@민빠답 omg a wc cat oc commented
0 likesMeow Im Pumkin'Kit 🐈
0 likesThey have a normal Earth year and I can prove it. In S1 EPS 11 "Winter Wrap Up," Rainbow Dash starts the Winter Wrap Up song with "3 months of winter..." This would not be possible unless they had an Earth year, Unless the planets angle shifts drastically ever so often. Obviously, this would be a little too much, even for MLP.
0 likesIt goes off the moon cycle. Every new full/new moon( I can’t remember) a new moon starts.
1 likeAh yes. Back in happier times
3 likesThe book, Journal of the Two Sisters, states that Celestia was born as an Alicorn. She and her sister Luna would be asked by the Unicorn Starswirl the Bearded to rule the newly formed kingdom of Equestria, as Alicorns had traits of all three kinds of ponies.
0 likesDoesn't anyone remember that in applebuck season applejack said that they had their family reunion on the first episode? And on the 1st episode of season 4 it is the next summer sun celebration so it has been a year. So every reunion must happen a little bit before a year knowing that apple family reunion is in season 3!
114 likesReplies (41)
Yes, which would mostly fit in line with his theory. It would be 100 moons between reunions, so each year is just a little more than 100 moons. Of course that's assuming the second reunion takes place chronologically before the second Summer Sun Celebration, which may not be so.
6 likesGood point dude
1 likeI totally agree with you Darien
1 likeSince full moons occur every 28 days. I always thought 100 moons meant several years, in human time
0 likesWhile I do agree, who says there is consistency, the Apple family can't get the schedlaling right every time.
0 likesThat confused me too... Check out my video called "Apple Family Reunion Mess Up"
1 likeBut then again, maybe Equestrian year isn't the same time as the earth year
1 likebut the summer sun celebration happens every hundred thousand years not every year remember Twilight said that in the first episode
0 likesphew I thought I was the only one and know one else thought it
0 likes@Bella Daisy
0 likesUhh...? "Every hundred thousand years"? The Summer Sun Celebration has been seen happening three times so far in Twilight's life, so...
I find it rather unlikely that the summer sun celebration would be yearly and the MLP cast cast could not have been so close and go on that many adventures in 1 year and in baby cakes it's stated 1 yea month has pasted and it's not said they have done anything but of course they would have because in I don't know anymore
0 likesor maybe my little pony has a different time period. cuz they dont live on earth maybe they live on another planet or Equestria is a planet. Just like on Jupiter or Mars they have more earth nights in one day or something. Maybe Equestria is different and maybe 20 days is a month or 12 days but all I know we don't know they just probably have a different time period
0 likesI can't spell so sorry selestia said we must rid ourselves of are magic so that equstra AND the lads beound it might be saved so it is not a planet just twilights kingdom
0 likesThe summer sun festabel is like the summer solstes and new year
0 likesYou see, everyone forgets that from the Summer Sun Celebration in Friendship is Magic to the Summer Sun Celebration in Princess Twilight Sparkle 2 years had passed. There's no way that 2 winters had passed between the 2 Summer Sun Celebration, and since we have the end of winter in Winter Wrap-up and the winter in Hearth's Warming Eve it means that there was one Summer Sun Celebration between them. So, it means that two years would have passed from the beginning of season 1 to the beginning of season 4, this means that the Apple Family Reunion happens every 2 years (100 moons), which means that as Notion first stated, 1 years equals 50 moons.
4 likes@dlegofan
0 likesThat makes pretty good sense, actually.
I wouldn't know, math and science are my two absolute WORST subjects
so true
0 likes@the shadowlink ninja And who exactly tells us how much time runs past between Seasons (or even episodes)?
0 likesI think that is a good guess if you forget that the episodes are not in any order roughly before season 4
1 likeDo a video of favorite relative
1 like@Peter Molitor So, basically, you believe that Hearth's Warming Eve is the only episode between Lesson Zero and Mystery on the Friendship Express that happened before Season 2? Well, have luck with that. I'll keep my theory though.
0 likesso every 3 years?
0 likes@RAUL SANCHEZ I'll think about it...
1 likeThat's exactly what I was about to say! (Just found this channel hence the late reply...)
0 likesNope :3
0 likesyea something like dat xD
0 likes@Zoe Trend The pony browny? whats a browny?
0 likesbrownies are persons who are loving mlp
0 likesyea right dat
0 likesBosnia and Hercegovina
0 likesxD did u have google maps?
0 likesfound there Croatia,and near Croatia,there is Bosnia and Hercegowina
0 likesSO,NOW U NOW WHERE I COME FROM :D
0 likes;)
0 likes@Darien Hilmerson I hoped someone would say that.
0 likes@dlegofan your explanation sounds the most right so far and has some good evidence.
0 likes@Darien Hilmerson Quite logical, but still very strange, perhaps the summer sun celebration got pushed back. and by part the date changed? Instead of the date that Nightmare Moon was banished, it was changed to the date Princess Luna returned? It seems very odd not to hold the reunion on the same date each year, so that the family can plan around it, instead of the inverse.
0 likes(Yeah I know, I doubt that Equestria would've stayed without celestia very long, as Nightmare Moon returned EXACTLY 1000 years later, and that it SEEMS that all of episode 1/2 happened in one night.)
Oh yeah, thats right.
0 likesWow.
0 likes😓
Yeah! Great connection!
1 like@Bella Daisy She says "It's the thousandth year of the Summer Sun Celebration" meaning that it's the thousandth time the celebration has happened.
2 likesEquestria has more than one moon so the idea of a lunar cycle is really inconsistent because no one is exactly sure which moon they're talking about but everyone is too embarrassed to admit it so they just pretend they know how long a moon is but in reality, no one in Equestria actually knows.
0 likesIf there are 100 moons in a Equestrian Year and a Equestrian Year is twice the length at would make a moon roughly one Earth week, which would mean Twilight and her friends meet once a week.
1 likeThe CMC are just eternally... whatever age they are. I wish they had gotten at least a little physical growth in the show.
0 likesMe: wits wittier cats?
12 likesBaby applejack: cuteness
Me: eyes as big as lemons going ‘’AWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW’’
100 moons = 2 of our years? That would make Celestia's statement of their being 1 year between the pilot and season 4 premiere feel like it makes more sense, given everything that's happened. But Equestria NOT being Earth also means they don't need to have all four seasons.
4 likesReplies (2)
@Ben N This theory is now further backed up by 'Tanks For the Memories' being the first Running of the Leaves, and 'Make New Friends But Keep Discord' being the first Gala since season 1. Too much has happened for seasons 1 to 4 to be one of our years, so it stands to reason that 1 Equestrian year is more equal to two of our years than to one.
1 like??????? S
0 likesI always thought that moons meant years. It’s used in Warriors, too.
1 likeReplies (1)
So granny Smith is 200 yrs old?
0 likesThere's something very wrong in the show. The first picture in the album shows granny Smith a little foal but in another episode granny tells us that she discovered ponyville when she was at least a little younger than apple jack.
0 likesI feel like 100 moons wouldn’t equal a year. Why not just say “we have a family reunion every year” then?
2 likesReplies (2)
Hm true but this is equestria we are talking about here. I don't think they use 'years' there but this is just my opinion anyway. I dont think they even mentioned the word 'years' throughout the series but correct me if I'm wrong
0 likesRed Midnight Rose years are mentioned frequently. Luna was banished to the moon until “the longest day of the thousandth year”. Discord was a statue for a thousand years or more I think. Rarity says the council of friendship is how they’ve ruled together over the years.
0 likesjust wanna point out that during a play, applejack names the new land 'earth' 3:45
2 likesActually, four of our years equal to one Equestrian year. Just think about it. Season one episode one took place during the Summer Sun Celebration. Fast forward to season four episode one. Celestia said that it was Luna's first SSC since her return. Given that time remains constant between our world and theirs, and that there was one season per year, gives us one Equestrian year to one of our years.
3 likesHim “ an equestrian yer is twice as long as one of our yer”
1 likeThe earth “ no if an equestrian yer is 100 days and our yer is 365 then our yer is longer”
I agree with the first part of the theory, but you said 100 moons was 2 years for the Apple family reunion. Then less than a minute later you said you thought 100 moons was 1 year??
0 likesI have a theory! even tho this is 5 years late so ponys dont age as quick as humans do so 100 moon can still be 8 years because look at an image of twilight from season 1 and then an image of twilight from season 9 twilight hasn't really gotten that big and 1 episode is 1 week because before twilight wrote reports to princess celestia she did one every episode and the reports were weekly so 26 x 9 = 234 thats 234 WEEKS and twighlight hasnt aged much and look at like rainbow dash season 1 to season 9 like all the ponys dont age that quick and 234 x 7 is 1638 then do 1638 / 365 and u get 4.4 years so twighlight doesnt age like at all through 4.4 YEARS so then that could be 50ish moons so if they went to season 18 we might've seen an apple reunion 2
1 like"How long is a 'moon'"
1 likeThe endless UFP debate, I see
Well in warriors 1 moon is a month, but as you said this is the pony world not earth. As warrior cats known it. So I'm just guessing that 1 moon is a month.
1 likeTypically, a moon is a month, as in a full cycle of the moon making a month.
0 likesAHEM I figured it out!
1 likeSeason 7 episode 10 after starlight spends the evening with Luna twilight says,
“The last time celestia and Luna fought, celestia had to banish her for 1000 years !”
And for the rest of the series it’s referred to as 1000 moons
In conclusion 1 moon = one year
One year in equestria is 3 seasons because in the first episode of season 1 it was the summer sun celebration or whatever it was called and in the first episode of season 4 Celestia said that it was the summer sun celebration since Luna came back from moon, it doesn’t have anything to do with how long a moon is but maybe someone smart can use this and measure the time between the apple family reunions.
0 likesHow long is a moon? Simple! Find Luna, pull out a ruler, measure her width, and there's your answer!
23 likesReplies (4)
genius!
0 likes@GlitchyShadow13 "How long is the moon?"Eleventeen. o~0
1 likelol
0 likes+brian solorzano you mean "B-Bleven...teen"
0 likes@Sawtooth I think "moon" is a month. I also think it's the same way that the Disney Fairies movies use it. In Tinker Bell and the Lost Treasure, The calendar showed one month until the Autumn Relvery, and Terence said that equals to a moon.
0 likesSo if 100 moons is 1 year then they have a family reunion every year?
3 likesIf Equestria took place on the Moon (think the Lunar RPG series) and Earth is actually Equestria's Moon (rotate frame 0:26 90° to the right). Then 100 Moons is 100 Earth days, or around 3.33 Earth months.
0 likesThe Apple family have a reunion around each change of a season on Earth's subtropical area, or 1/4 of an Earth year. It makes sense for them as farmers to base their reunion on each change of season on their Moon. Think of it as farmers using the whole 'Harvest Moon' method.
Daytime or Nightime for them is 15 Moons, or 15 Earth days.
Of course IF Equestria Girls took place on Earth, then 6 Moons there will be around 180 Moons on Equestria.
Example: At Manehattan. The owner of the store Pinkie Pie want to buy the Pouch for Maud Pie, left the store closed for a few Moons.
So a Moon is NOT the rough equivalent of an Earth's Month or Week. Because there's no indication that the store would be closed for a few weeks or so (the windows would be closed with curtains). Unless the store owner is just plain psycho like Pinkie Pie, or had an emergency.
Canterlot vacation for a few Moons with the grand niece.
The episode implied, if Pinkie Pie just wait a few more days, the store would open. But she doesn't have days, she's only in town for that day, and she needs the Pouch in a hurry.
So 1 Equestria Moon ≈ 1 Earth Day.
Because… who suddenly left an uncovered store for weeks?
The actual developers of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic are actually quite adept at hinting how long a Moon is. In the Pouch episode, the store is basically left quite open for a few Moons/(Days).
It's okay, right? The Pony World is a relatively safe place, right? Surely it's also protected by magic, right?
Well, there's that female cop, plus that 'Larry the Pony' who wants to touch Pinkie Pie's 'sweet party cannon'. Not so safe.
Eventhough the entire episode felt like it was taken from the Sex and the City (or Sex in the City) TV series.
And ah yes, Princess Luna said hi. She also wanted to tell you that Princess Kaguya's story was based on her own 'banishment'. Eventhough Twilight Sparkle's look and feel was based on the typical Princess Kaguya look and feel.
one moon = one year!
2 likesI've been watching MLP on serbian,
And when they would say "moon" it automatically would be "year"
I remember in Warriors (This book with the clan of cats) they tell that they have 1 moon or 2 moon for their âge, the moons if i remember here are 1 moon for 1 mounth. So the moons can be in equestria the Same ?
203 likesReplies (14)
Ps: Sorry if my english is wrong, i'm french x3
3 likesMei t a hundred years? Really? 😑🙄
0 likes@Meilline no, maybe more like 1 year per moon?
0 likes@Kaylee Molina I don't really recall to be honnest, I didn't read any of those books in a long time.
0 likes@Meilline i do not read those books, but even tho i think that maybe a moon is a year.
0 likes@Kaylee Molina It also sounded like they count the full moon, plus in Warriors, they are cat, which would understand why it's maybe not years
1 like@Meillineidk how long a moon is, but your is your opinon and my opinon is my opinon.
0 likes@Kaylee Molina That is a fact that i'm not going to deny. It's just that I made that comment 3 years ago so I don't even remember what the video was about XD
1 like@Meilline i just rewatched it.
0 likes@Kaylee Molina i think a moon in warriors is one month,remember they have gatherings in full moons and i'm pretty sure they dont do it once a year lol
1 like@some abomination from another dimension oh.
0 likesA moon in warriors is a month, it marks the start and end of the moon's cycle
2 likesIm just lazy to actually state this as a wc and mlp world
0 likes@Melissa Kittelson @some abomination from another dimension Thanks you two, so I wasn't wrong in my assumption it was a month. Even tho it's now been years since I wrote this comment XD
0 likesYou should remake this, because in the episode where rainbow dash tries to stop winter. Applejack mentions that winter will be over in a few months. Just an addition :)
1 likeWhen the writers want to mess with children's minds and instead of SIMPLY saying days, months, years etc. They went and said MOONS. ARRRRGGGHHHHH
1 likeLauren Faust WHHHHHHHHYYYYY
Have you considered that the first episode when Twilight arrived in ponyville, she meets applejack, and later on when twilight asks about "all the ponies at the farm" when they first met, AJ was like Nawww that was just the apple family reunion.
0 likesDoctor: you have 5 more to live.
1 likeTeacher: 5 what? 5 apples? 5 bananas?
Doctor: 4...3...
Teacher: ...
My cousin is a warrior cats fan and she tells me some stuff, so I do know moon = Month so 100 months and if you do the math...
0 likes8×12+4...so 8 years and 4 months.
2015 feels like yesterday I watched this come out 😖
1 likeWhat if the princesses instead of moving the sun and moon they move equestria(planet) around
2 likesI don't think the sun goes around Equestria. Celestia and Luna just lift the sun and moon up and down. Considering that, i have no idea what they mean by a "moon" or how they would measure it.
0 likesSo how long is an Equestrian moon? However long the writers need it to be.
From Ponyville to Canterlot is far enough that it requires an overnight sleeper trip, or you can hop over and back in an afternoon jaunt. Canterlot is visible from Ponyville in some stories, and even Manehatten is close enough to see a Rainboom over Sweet Apple Acres.
If distances are negotiable, why not time?
Thank you The Brony Notion for helping with this issue. It's bothered me for some time. I kind of wish I had seen this sooner.
0 likeswhen Twilight returned to Equestria, all her friends are still there. have they really been there for three days? or was it only a few hours to them?
0 likesI always thought that 2 seasons = 1 human year. Because we only have a hearths warming episode every two seasons. But yeah it’s true no one really knows.
0 likesNot that you will see this but I just finished watching season 8 episode 5 Grannies Gone Wild and they said they do their trip ever moon, later in the episode they preceded to tell rainbow dash that they will see her same time next year.
0 likesConclusion a Moon = a Year. As for the ageing with Apple bloom, we all know that the ages of ponys is a little weird given celestia and Luna being over 1000 years old.
I think there are two moons in a month because the Moon is a passage of time between a new moon and a full moon every new moon a full moon is considered a different Moon so there's two moons in a month because there's always a new moon and a full moon in a month so that means that 24 moons a year that means there would be roughly 4 years before the next family reunions
0 likesI used to think it meant days. like, 30 days and 30 nights. And you see the moon at night?
9 likesI was 6
But wait... the sun and moon can’t revolve around just equestria. What about the other lands, like the land of the Hippogryphs or whatever? How does the cycle work there??
0 likesStars are involved a lot in the mlp, in a WHOLE LOT of cutie marks, npseveral names, and celesta and she controls the sun wich is a big star.
0 likesYa' know what's bigger than 20,000? 162,320...Great job! :D
100 likesReplies (28)
+supersmilyface1 SSF1 Thank you so much :)
10 likesYour welcome :)
0 likesnow 4 days later its 169,382
1 likeNUUUPE!! 170,090 NOW!!! 🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂ITZ CAKE TIME🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂
0 likesNow it's 172,302 very close weird
0 likesLol XD mlp brony notion
0 likesyeah!
0 likesIt's now 172,885 update
0 likes:P
0 likesNope it's 173,996
0 likesWoah 0.0
0 likesnope now 175,238 subs
1 likeNope now 176,688
0 likessupersmilyface1 SSF1 no no what's bigger is 177,144 NICELY DONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesWorrier Wolf you know what's bigger than that? 177,213
0 likesJeff Cooper 100000000000000000000 NOPE over 9000!!!
0 likesWhy are you guys doing this?
0 likesLittle kitty plays 1
0 likesSomeone actually answered me! 😱
0 likesnow it's 178,392
0 likesFriend of Nature no its 179,501
0 likeswell she posted 2 months ago :D:D:D:D
0 likesJosefina Egg SHE? It's a HE
0 likesjust to let you know you did a major burn there
0 likes+Alice Martinez The Potato Pig all of those numbers are over 9000...
0 likessupersmilyface1 SSF1 20,001
0 likesnow 243,000
0 likesYou know what else is bigger than 20,000?
0 likes20,001.
Okay okay, i might sound silly, but luna raises a moon everyday! So I'm guessing 30 moons is a month therefore 100 moons is around 3 months and 10 days?!?
0 likes“How long is a moon?”
0 likesMy mind:how long is a month?
BUT WHAT ABOUT LUNA?
0 likesSHE WAS BANISHED FOR 1000 MOONS - WHICH IS, ACCORDING TO THE THEORY 20 YEARS, BUT SOMEHOW ALMOST EVERYPONY FORGETS SHE EVEN EXSICTED IN THE FIRST PLACE.
AN EXPLANATION HERE
Well one moon is a month, as theres a full moon once a month, so 12 moons is 12 months, so 100 moons is equal to 8.333 years
0 likesI solved it in the first 55 seconds. 29.5 days is a moon. 1 moon is equal to 1 full moon wich is one every 29.5 days.
0 likesdid you know that both moon and month means "ay" in Turkish? Yeah, we call both moon and month "ay". So i mean, it makes sense that 1 moon in 1 month. But i doubt that Faust actually knows Turkish XD
0 likesI think 100 moons=3 or 4 years because the Apple Family reunion took place in season 4 and the first appearance of the Apple Family took place in the very first episode of season 1. And also most big family reunions happen every 3 or 4 years. (That is how my mom’s side of the family does it)
0 likes6 years later and I am still telling myself I will watch it later
0 likesThe Brony Notion
398 likesThe Brony version of MatPat
Replies (63)
But in bitesize
2 likes@Shadic tis true!
2 likes@Breezie Cake Yup :3
2 likes@Shadic and the brohoof comes from pewdiepie!
6 likes@Breezie Cake yup :3
2 likes@Shadic I still prefer a geocentric theory of Equestria, that even though Celestia does "raise" the sun, the movement is not because she's actually moving the sun around the planet, but that's she's revolving the planet, and the primitive minds of Equestria do not know the difference.
0 likes@Shadic MatPat vs The Brony Notion: DEADLOCK! :D
2 likes@Henry goh One flaw in that... Well, maybe. If she is turning the planet, what is Luna doing with the moon then? Ok, probably just aligning it. Rotate a planet, move a moon. And....
1 likeHOLD UP! When Twilight had all the talents of all the princesses and forgot to raise the sun... That must've been one HECK of a wobbly tumbling of the world. And no one felt anything...?
@Edward256 Everything is relative. Throw some magic in there and it's possible that bringing the day is much, much harder than we thought.
0 likes@Henry goh Interference with that hypothesis: Season Finale Twilight's Kingdom. ************************ Watch the sun movement when it is risen in part 2. **************************** Revolving Earth? Nope.
0 likes@RubberyCat Why not. If you move the planet around in different ways, you'd get different effects, including an abnormal shift in the sun's movement.
0 likes@Henry goh
0 likesUp, down, then up again in disarray?
When something rotates, it requires notably more work to rotate it in different directions than in one direction only.
@RubberyCat Are you implying that the princesses don't have this power? If Celestia alone could raise the sun with ease, why couldn't Twilight do more with all the alicorn magic combined as one.
0 likes@Henry goh
0 likesYou are trying to change the question.
Nice try, but it doesn't work.
@RubberyCat I'm not, it's a rhetorical question meant to counter your previous statement. It's a very common rhetorical device in a lot of written works.
0 likes@Shadic omg sooooooo true
0 likes@***** ... oh my god.. yes...
0 likes@Shadic Not quite, but the similarities are there..... And Notion isn't uploading from his closet.
0 likes@Henry goh
0 likes...And a rhetorical question do not require an answer, at least not from anyone else than the one that asks it.
And it is still not the important question.
It is indeed rhetorical, as the answer is a clear yes, but the real problem, and question is then why she rose it in disarray?
The point is to make a slow and ordered rise, and any simpler form of rotating do cause a very ordered rise, not a disordered rise.
Twilight had no reason to rise it in disarray, so if she was indeed rotating the planet, it would not have risen in disarray, but ordered.
@Shadic Meh, not as smart though
0 likes@RubberyCat It's not as if Twilight had control over how she raised the sun, she was still new at all the different powers she gained.
0 likes@Henry goh
0 likesExactly, so if she was rotating the planet, it would have been the basic kind of rotation, meaning a far less erratic way than was shown.
However, if she did instead move the sun, then lack of control or focus would indeed give the erratic movement that happened.
@RubberyCat She could also screw up the rotation as well. Rotating a planet can be very difficult.
0 likes@Henry goh
0 likes* sighs and decides to ignore the reply *
@Henry goh Take a look at the stars in that scene. They don't move along with the Sun. If Twilight was indeed rotating the Earth, they would wobble around, too, if not as much as the Sun and the Moon.
0 likes@Smilley MLK Hm.... yes. However, the planet does not do a full rotation. In Twilight's lack of control, she raises and sets the sun from the same direction, not east to west. The moment the sun goes down and the stars are shown, the rotation of the planet does not continue, thus the tars do not move as well. Twilight is focusing on the moon at that moment, not the rotation of Equestria's planet.
0 likesStill, as I said, some movement should be visible, especially when moving toward "morning".
0 likes@Shadic YUP
0 likes@Smilley MLK The night sky would be stuck at just an hour or so into the night, so perhaps we simply cannot notice the movement.
0 likes@Shadic where did I say in my one that you said matpat was bad 1. and 2 people make more mlp theroys then game ones and finaly if he was like matpat he would do more diging in the FNAF theories he says the rain is something no one notices or talks about but BN doesn't even look at the flipping of the pages the show shows the 3ed reunion pic not the second if he was like matpat he would bring that up but he doesn't hes more inexpirents then matpat or protomario or any other one of the people who do there job how its done
0 likes@mrmaster plush Come reply to me when you can grammar, otherwise I wont reply to you.
0 likes@Shadic that's a reply you spineless foo;
0 likes@Mr.Kitty Kat I know that. And I'm not going to get in this giant-ass fight about something stupid.
0 likesDa fuck
0 likesIs it okay to watch even if I am a girl. Though a lot of people call me a tomboy and I am okay with that because I kinda am
0 likes@Daniela Cardenas pfft, of course! If ur a fan, ur a pegasister!
0 likestrue dat
0 likesTrue
0 likesYap!
0 likesYAA!!!! (my guess is because they DONT have horns OR WINGS just like humans!) BUT RLLY
0 likes@Shadic YAS!!!!
0 likesomg i have a theory !!!!!!XD ik
0 likesin my little dashie thats why it was fifteen years in the human world and fifteen days in the pony world.....
D: um..........
DX so.... the whole mlp thing has 105 episodes which
0 likesin pony time are a day long..... so........ it is
1 005 years....... 😷 i need an air bag
to say the truth i didn't see his hat at all
0 likestrue but I like thoerys
0 likeswut
0 likesyou confuse
0 likes@Laura Gullick Engrish
0 likes+Shadic cool
0 likesYAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2 likesShadic
0 likesHello my theorists friends!!! I just came from binge watching all theories from both channels.
Shadic yas
0 likesTHE AWESOME m better*
1 likeYeah I can agree with that
0 likes...
0 likesShadic lol true
0 likesLozza 5477 YOU DON'T KNOW HIM?! I think you live under a rock...
0 likes1 moon is 36.5 human days
0 likesI know this because when Equestria girls came out sunset shimmer had been in the human world for 30 moons and there are three pictures of her as the queen of fall formal in principle Celestia's office therefore she had been there three human years. 30 divided by 3 is 10 so that's ten moons as one year. 365 divided by ten is 36.5
Shadic yep! Pretty accurate...
0 likesShadic true!
0 likesShadic has ocd
0 likesShadic
0 likesyes
Matpat here I sued him MAT PAT STOP
0 likesHere's what I think: 1 moon is 1 day right? If 1 moon is 1 day then 100 moons is 100 days but 100 days is not nearly as long as a year in our time. in our time a year has 365.24 days but maybe in equestria 100 Days is a year remember equestria is not earth. :)
7 likesA moon cycle lasts for a month, so a moon is a month
0 likesAnd 100 months are about eight years, i guess
Well, about the Apple Family Reunion, they had one in the first episode, Friendship is Magic. Ep. 1 Season 1. If that gives any information, use it. Even though this vid. is 5 years old considering the current time.
1 likeMy Prediction Of What A 100 Moons Is:
1 likeSo, Moons In Warriors Are The Full Moon Cycle (I Think).
Well, About Twelve Moons Are A Year, 100 Moons Are Probably (Excuse My Spelling) A Few Years
Just To Clear This Up I Am 8 Years Old.
The "moon" is as long as the plot requires it to be.
0 likesWhen he said "How long is a moon?" I screamed in my head: A MOON IS A MONTH
0 likesIf that is the case, the we can use the following math: 29.530589 days per lunations So 100 moons = 2935. 0589 days there are (365+365+365+366)/4 = 365.25 days per year (roughly) So 100 moons = 2953.0589 days = 2953.0589/365.25 years = 8.085 years.
0 likesSo your answer is 8.085 years
Well, ponies obviously age differently to humans. I think they are classified as adults after a few years.
0 likesI have a question: who raised the sun and the moon before Celestia and Luna existed?
0 likesI just like to point out the fact that it is a possibility that the planet that Equestria is on is closer to its sun meaning that every hundred moons could be one year thank you that is all
0 likesi want a Video about how old are the Elements of harmony and how old are the princeses
41 likesReplies (4)
so do i
0 likesWow, so true!
0 likesThe pillars ( Star swirl Group) grow the tree of harmony
0 likesApple S....
0 likesI have to know what a year is in Equestria! As in I need a Cannon Answer! Also I wanna know how long Ponies live for compared to us. I think they have a lifespan similar to us. Also how tall is Celestia? So many questions!
1 likeI figured it out. thirty moons are thirty mondays because monday is named after the moon. Almost every day of the week is named after a planet. Eg. sunday named after sun. thats pretty obivious
1 likeIf only he knew that 6 years later he’d have nearly 400k subs
0 likesmy guy it's been five years and your still in the 20k's, you really deserve so many more subs!
0 likesWait but wasn't Nightmare Moon banished for 1000 moons or something like that?
0 likesThat would mean that she was on the moon for 10 years so she would probably be around when the mane 6 were fillies. That doesn't really add up because they would remember her plus we know it was really long ago.
This was way after you posted this video but in season 8 episode 4 Grannies gone wild Goldie Delicious says this “We’ve been going to Las Pegasus every moon we can remember! And even some we don’t remember. Same time, next year?” The only problem with my theory is that you’re two examples don’t fit in. 100 years means that the apple family would seize to exist. Equestria girls doesn’t fit either since five decades (decade = ten years) is a long time to be stuck in a dimension with Pinkie Pie being creepy. Honestly though, has it never occurred to you that they use Chinese time measurement to signify a year as in Chinese New Year when a full moon is in the sky. Their year starts between 21 January and 20 February. So while I am still young I hope my theory can be confirmed at some point.
1 likeReplies (1)
Someone please reply!
0 likesMe before video: OH BOY TIME TO GET ALL WARRIOR ON YOU. So there are 12 moons in a year (the warrior universe states that every full moon is +1 moon), 12×8=96.
0 likesSo, by warrior logic, if we were to complete it by adding 4, the final answer would be: 8 years and 4 months.
What about this; we have 52 weeks in a year and 52 times 2 is 104 which means one moon equals about a week in our time. This would also make sense in Equestrian Girls as 30 moons would be 30 weeks. I guess just another way to put it?
0 likesWhen you're watching in 2019 and hear that 20,000 subs is a lot... Then you look at how many subs he has now 😏
5 likes"This is my first upload of 2015" Me: Watching it on the 1st of January 2016
522 likesReplies (98)
Lol Me too
0 likes+Cosmic Fox I am watching on 20 of January 2016
0 likesYour not the only one watching in 2016
1 likeYa
0 likes+Yandere_ chan I'm watching in February😐
0 likes@Yandere_ chan never said I wasnt
0 likes+
0 likeshehe
0 likesHahahah same bro
0 likes+amellia rosetta I'm watching this in July
0 likesOf 2016
0 likes+Farida Sabet The third? It says you posted.this comment on the 25.
0 likes+Ricksrollin Posted on March 24.
0 likes+Frost Sparky Posted on the 22.
0 likes+Ayame San Says you posted on the third.
0 likes@***** Says you posted 2 days ago. This is August third.
0 likesI'm in August lol
0 likesXD
0 likesMe: watching at 7:27 in the morning before school :)
1 likeXD
0 likesWatching on 20th January 2017 :")
1 likeyes
0 likesDAYM
0 likesineedfoodandanime March 2017
0 likesapril 2017
0 likesApril 2017
1 likeMay 2017 ;)
2 likesSomeone Who isn't revealing their true identity yup
0 likesme:watching in 2017
1 likeineedfoodandanime me watching on june 30 2017
0 likesSophia Garcia me July 3
0 likesAyesha Ambreen time goes by too fast...
0 likesineedfoodandanime I'm watching on 7/12/17
1 likeRainbawBC me too
0 likesTHE AWESOME m jul 24 2017
0 likesGrace Wojciechowska July
0 likesGrace Wojciechowska Me... August 2017
8 likesmlp2be4ever Me too
0 likesmlp2be4ever me tooooooooooo
0 likesMe watching it in December 2017 XD
0 likesineedfoodandanime watching it on January 2018
0 likesI'm watching January 15 2018. I'm late.
0 likesineedfoodandanime 2017 for me
0 likesI’m watching in 2018...
0 likesMe watching in 2018
0 likesxPastelic me wacthing 2018
0 likesLmao, I am watching in 2018 :>
0 likesWhere da heck did you get that profile picture because I think some other YouTuber created that
0 likescandy_p4p Candy who me?
0 likesineedfoodandanime lol
0 likesI'm watching 2018
0 likes17.2.2018
0 likesineedfoodandanime Me:watching this in 2018 XD
0 likes2018
0 likesineedfoodandanime
0 likesineedfoodandanime I have it even worse IM IN 2018 JUNE SOMETHING
0 likesineedfoodandanime Im watching in 2018
0 likesineedfoodandanime watching is July 24 2018
0 likesI'm watching it (And commented this) on November 5th, 2018... ...XD
0 likesWatching on December 3, 2018
0 likesI'm watching Wednesday December 12th 2018 haha I beat you
0 likesHxj 2018
0 likesme watching on the 1st of january 2019
0 likesWatching on the 3rd day of 2019..... ;-;
0 likesI'm watching on the first of january 2019
0 likesme watching this on the 1st of January 2019
0 likes2019 man
0 likesineedfoodandanime I’m watching May 5th 2019 ;-;
0 likesIt's 2019 for me xD
0 likesWatching on the first September 26th of 2019
0 likesIt's 2020 now...
1 likeWatching on February 2020
2 likesGracie ha! I’m 5 days after you! Beat that
0 likesYo I’m from the future and it sucks here man, 2020 of March, this came out half a decade ago :/
0 likesVengo del futuro y el inglés se ha extinguido
0 likesJokes on you I'm watching in 2020
2 likesSquishy Winni Same
1 like@WORORORO lol we super late
0 likesoh nuh uh
0 likesim watching this in march
2020
I was 7 when this comment was posted 😂
0 likesineedfoodandanime me watching this April 1 2020 in my bed on lockdown
2 likesMe watching it in March 2020
1 likeJust Talia you are 11
0 likesJust Talia you like gl
0 likes6th April 2020 here lol
1 likeIm watching in april 2020
0 likesineedfoodandanime me in 2020
1 likeMe watching in 2020
1 like2020
1 likeAprill 22 2020
0 likesineedfoodandanime I’m watching in 2020
2 likesI'm watching in 23 April 2020
0 likesMe watching this in 1463
0 likesMe : rewatching in May 2020
0 likesIts 2020 now and we have corona viruse
0 likesWelcome to the future where quarantine is a thing.
1 likeMe watching it May 16th 2020
0 likesme watching this in march of 2021
0 likesI dont think 100 moons is one year. I feel like its much longer. Maybe 10 moons / year.
0 likesWell every year is pretty much every season of this show so that should be a hundred moons
0 likesI like how Celestia can kill everyone on pony earth instantly if she wants
0 likesMath Problem: If one moon is one month and one month is 30 days how many days will it take for 100 moons?
0 likesPonies probably don't even count in Base 10. (We only do that because we have ten fingers, herp-derp.) Their number system is probably in Base 12. If nothing else, it would be more in line with the concept of Harmony being represented by 6 different people.
3 likesOn a side note, I wonder if the wizards in Harry Potter count in Base 7.
Replies (3)
Yeah I thought the same thing! I have the feeling that if I brought that up only a couple of people (including you) would get what I'm saying. Different bases are confusing to think about. XD
2 likesI get with what your saying so yea because they could be using a different base number than us but at least we know their number has the as ours due to the square root problem did in her song about no being ready for the test to save the Crystal Empire
1 like@The Brony Notion Fair enough. ^.^
0 likesA moon is a month because there is one full moon every month. Though i guess to put it more scientifically, it's one moon cycle.
0 likesReplies (1)
Though of course that does not mean an Equestria moon cycle is the same length as one on Earth.
0 likesI think that this vid is very reasonable, but would the pony dimension have the same time as the uh-er sorta human dimension? Because I'm pretty sure that Vice-Princable Luna doesn't raise the moon in the sorta human dimension. Love ur stuf The Brony Notion!
0 likesGranny Smith’s ages in each Reunion seems a bit off.
0 likesReunion 1: Around 4-6
Reunion 2: Around 12-15
Reunion 3: 80..?
100 moons = 8.3333333 years (💯 months)
1 likeBut isn’t Equestria in earth? Teletubbyland is on earth and Teletubbyland is in equestria.
I thought that a moon meant that the moon went around equestrian 1 time so wouldn't 100 moon's be 100 hundred day's?
0 likesSometimes I wish that the official can really tell all the answer of these mystery
0 likesOr like where do celestia and luna come from and how cadence be alicon but weak in magic spells
I learned that math is useful in cannon. I’m gonna pay attention in school this year.
3 likesOkay ...
1 likeNow I know about moons.
But I don't know how old is the to royal sisters?
Well Brony Notion talked about when the elements of Hamony
were used, but he also said nightmare moon and discord was
banished for a thousand ?
@The Brony Notion don't forget, when Twilight first met the Apple family, the were having a reunion.
8 likesReplies (6)
There were more Apple family members introduced to Twilight in the pilot episode than there were members in the third reunion photo... Why weren't they in the picture? That kinda destroys the purpose.
0 likes@The Brony Notion as you said, some photos were lost.
0 likes@The Brony Notion but then the book was {around} A4 size and they zoomed in to the photos at the top of the page
0 likes@The Brony Notion but in Applebuck season, Applejack specifically says "they were just here for the Apple family reunion, they actually live all over Equestria.
1 like@The Brony Notion Applejack seems to have a very extensive family, but just like most other families, there could be reasons as to why several members don't show up. Several members show up in Apple Family Reunion that were missing in Episode 1, and vice versa. This could be due to one obligation or another, plus we never see Aunt and Uncle Orange at the reunions. Their absence is most likely due to the fact that they are high-society ponies (the kind that Rarity would get along with) who wouldn't bother going because the reunion is on a "Dirty, old farm."
0 likes@Samantha Henney thats exactly what i wanted to say!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likeswhen twilight became apple jack's friend all the members were there.. if u ask me its a reunion
theres also an episode where apple jack wins some kind of award also she is busy helping her friends like making cupcakes with pinkie and it just made ponies sick... apple jack was really tierd and needed help but refused to take help in that same episode twilight was asking apple jack if the other members of her family cud help her in apple bucking i dont quite remember the whole scene but yea thts all i remember if possible i wub have just told u the name of episode
I think they didn't thought how does time works in Equestria. So it's random. I hope G5 will give us some math.
0 likesI think it means 30 weeks since a full moon comes once a week and multiplication 1 and 30 and it is still 30 so there is one moon in a week
0 likesI think ponies might have different lifespan than humans do in mlp
0 likes2:55 Are we forgetting that the two ponies next to Granny Smith BARELY look different?
0 likes1 Moon = Month. ( Often a Month Is a Full Cycle Aka: Quarter Moon, Half Moon, Full Moon. Each Full Moon Is 1 Moon.
0 likesI always just thought that eg.30 moons is 30 full moons and a full moon comes every 2 weeks so about 60 days I think...Idk I’m terrible at maths 😂😂😂
0 likesI always thought moons ment years in the Equestria world 💙💙
1 likeMaybe the real moon is friends we made along the way?
1 likeIn the first episode of my little pony they say that Luna was on the moon for 1000 moons and then later in the episode twilight says Luna’s been trapped for 1000 years
0 likesMoons=years
1 likeMoons=Months
So confusing
i have an intriguing question:
1 likeis equestria a flat planet?
I love when he showed apple jack as a baby she was adorable
0 likesso it took around 200 moons to build the barn but 'raised this barn' in a few minutes/hours!!!!!?
0 likesDid you ever think about animal years? How long would a pony year be compared to a human year?
0 likesEquestria is kind of earthy or a continent or something... since spike held a globe on his birthday as he was greedy... and the first episode, when twilight meets applejack, they had a family reunion... so it can’t be 100 moons=8 years so... yea maybe it might be 1 or 2 years.
0 likesIf 30 moons is equivalent to 29.5 days, then the world of Equestria is ZOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOM-
0 likesMaybe "moon" means "month", like in the warrior's series!
0 likesI believe that one moon is one day!
2 likesFrom my perspective it’s got to be at least 13 years because if there are only three photos that means that it must’ve been a longer time and I do you think I can explain about why Apple Bloom didn’t change in the photos you see these for a long time ago the photos were for a long time ago which means since they probably didn’t decide which day they shouldThere reunion they made it like only three days but since they got older they were able to decide then
0 likesand they can change the seasons themselves so would they be twice as long as ours?
0 likesGEEZ. Happy 2015? It's 2017 as I'm typing this! (For anyone reading this in 2018 or a later year, 2015 was still a while ago!"
6 likesI think the ponies do live on earth just a different earth the reason I believe this is because in S2 E1 The return of harmony: part 1 Twilight said “Applejack, I need you to bring those height-strung storm clouds back to earth.”
0 likesI know there are already a bunch of comments saying this but if you don't read Warriors you are missing out on so much and a moon is everytime the full moon comes so 28 days or approximately a month.
0 likes"1st video of 2015"
2 likesHoly heck its 2020 now.
well in the first video in the mlp series when twilight meets aj the entire apple fam was there like she was interuppting a fam reinion
5 likesHow long is an Equestria day? It seems like in the episodes they get a lot done in a single day.
0 likesHmm maybe Granny Smith is from a time where they counted by moons instead of years or days just like how ancient humans did
0 likesI wonder if celestia is the only creature in the world where equestria exists that can control the sun. We've seen creatures from the lands beyond equestria that exist (like tirek) so do they have their own way of raising the sun and moon? Or do they depend on the ponies for that.
0 likesOr we could calculate the time from the pilot episode to Apple Family Reunion, because according to Apple Jack, that was a family reunion, remember?
0 likes"This is my first upload of 2015", I'm watching this is 2020😅
48 likesReplies (6)
Im here in 2021
0 likesI am watching this in 2021
0 likesI’m watching this in 2021
0 likes2021. Don’t give up! We will survive COVID!
0 likes@Bell's Art YAY!
0 likesIm Here In 2022
0 likesRemember the apples had a reunion early in the beginning of season 1. In episode 1 actually
1 likei think that luna and celestia do not have the power to control the sun and moon but rather something else is going on, in the season 2 final canterlot has a magic bubble around it to protect its self from changelings i believe that the planet has a magic bubble around it that creates an artificial sky and therefore they could "move" the sun and moon by changing the appearance of the bubble thats is also why in the nightmare moon universe from the season 5 final is not frozen on one side and barren on the other, the bubble could also protect the planet from asteroid impacts and alien invasions
0 likesI think the apple family is immortal. Look at Granny Smith and all the apples.
1 likeWait just a minute
0 likesI have a question about the Apple family reunion
Wasn’t there an Apple family reunion when Twilight first came to Ponyville?
So what’s the logic behind that?
Well
0 likesOne of the show writers said that there is no human equivalent to an Equestrian Moon, so-
If Luna raises the moon everyday that means 100 moons is 100 days
0 likesAll the kids that thought the sun and moon revolves around us after watching this be like: 👁👄👁
0 likes“This is My first upload of 2015”
4 likesAnyone watching in 2020? Lmao
Replies (1)
excuse me im watching in 2021 o_o
0 likes100 moons is literally 100 full moons that have passed I think
0 likes"Equestria is not earth"
0 likesPERIODT!!😂
i think 1 moon is 1 day as in the episode last problem rainbow says " this time EVERY 10 MOONS" so ten years or ten months is a lot
0 likesA moon is a month so 30 moons is 5 years.
0 likesI literally yelled 'U DONT SAY' and I was like omg I'm psychic Vv insert pro rage face here vV
3 likesa moon is a day every moon is every night.
1 likeSo if 100 moons is one year does that mean Luna was only banished for 10 years. How long was she actually banished
0 likesApplejack was so cute when she was a baby 🐥🍼🐥🐥🍼🍼
1 likeTHANK YOU IVE BEEN WONDERING THIS EVER SINCE I SAW THE EPISODE OMG
1 likeOmg, moons. LIKE IN WARRIOR CATS!!!
366 likesReplies (22)
Omg is that you Lexi?
1 like+norm vids Nope! Your probably thinking of someone else cuz my name starts with a Z. But anyways, I am a huge warriors fan :)
2 likes@***** :DD!!
0 likesOMG Warriors Cats is love
4 likes+ThatRandomGal YYAASS WARRIORS!!! I LOVE DAT SERIES!
2 likes+Yuno gasai Yay!
0 likes+Alicorn Kitty 😄!
0 likesjelli-demon
1 likeI was thinking about that too!!!
YEAH!!!
1 likeWho's your favorite cat? (Mine is spottedleaf
0 likesI made it 100 :3
0 likesstarzie WARRIORSS
1 likestarzie, who is your favorite?
1 likeWarrior cats for life!!!!
1 likeWarrior cats!
1 likeYes.
1 likeI don't really know but I'm gonna say I like Bramble boi (xD) and Jayfeather (the grumpy cinnamon roll) . I also like Dovewing and Ivypool qwp
1 like:0 OH MAH GAWWWW ANOTHER WARRIOR FAN!!!
1 likeEdit: my fav chars are Spottedleaf, Firepaw, and Bluestar! I’m only on the first book ;-;
@ʟɪᴏɴᴄᴏʀᴅ oof XD
0 likes@ʟɪᴏɴᴄᴏʀᴅ Spottedleaf good character.
0 likesAcctualy, moons wasn't a word created in warrior cats, it was acctualy created in medieval times to represent the so now called months; the word moons isint only used in mlp or warrior cats ita also used in various films and books
0 likesWow, so true!
1 likeIt’s the year 2020 and some people still don’t seem to understand it simply means a month because of how the month slowly does the curve thing :/
0 likesThe intro didn't let him finish 🤣
0 likesTo make things complicayed, they actually months. Evidence? "Three months of winter coolness and awesome holidays... " (winter wrap up)
0 likesI died at how cute this is 1:28
0 likesBrony Notion:This is the first video in 2015
19 likesMe:*Watching in 2017*.
Replies (3)
And then there's me, watching in 2020-
4 likesi am also watching in 2020
0 likesWow, so true!
0 likesI feel that in Equestria girls time is slower.
2 likeswell the only Equestrian timeframe I have come up with is 4 seasons of the show is 1 full year in Equestria.
0 likesyeah a moon is a month so 100 moons is*intense thinking time* 52 years
0 likesActually Equestria is Earth. Well, not Earth exactly, but it is on Earth. In "A Hearthswarming Tail" Pinkie says, "The EARTH is round. There is no up or down." So Equestria is on Earth. This puts a different complexion on things. A lunar cycle on Earth takes about 29.5 days, which is about a month. So that's why I always thought that a moon was a month.
0 likesReplies (1)
And everyone thinks it's from Warrior Cat, well, it's actually because there's a scientific explanation behind this theory.
0 likesi think this can't be true because that means luna was trapped in the moon for 20 years and that doesn't make sense. I know this video is old but according to perfect pear (season 7 episode 13) granny smith was young and luna was in the moon. this means granny smith would be a maximum of 40 years. Like if you agree.
14 likesReplies (3)
yassymoo Mooch No Princess Luna trap in moon for 1,000 years
2 likes1000 YEARS not moons
0 likesWow, so true!
0 likesEDIT: i forgot to add a few spaces before 1st paragraph (sorry!)
0 likesBefore i watch this, this is my estimation on how long 100 moons is: in warrior cats, (you might have heard) 1 moon means about 1 month. there are 12 months in a year, so if i divide 100 by 12, we get 8.3 (and some other 3s) which means100 moons is about 8 years and 3 months, or moons. it would be that way according to warrior cat time.
I used warrior cat time because they are the only other franchise i know of that uses "moons" as time. this my be correct, it may not. but leave thoughts on if my theory is right or wrong in my replies (if you want).
Thank you, and this is MatPat Brony signing out, BRO HOOF! (hope you liked the extra bit :D)
3️⃣0️⃣ moon sounds like month so 30 is two and a half year .
1 likeI always assumed that a moon=a month. Why? My sister is a Wariors mega fan
0 likesI think 1 moon is 1 year. Moon must be another name for Moon in Equestria.
0 likesacording in real life 100 moons is 100 months
9 likes100 moons is one hundred days I believe...
0 likesSo, when the Council of Friendship happens once a moon, how long is that?
0 likesReplies (1)
I would say it’s once a month couse it seems pretty logical. I used to have meetings with friends from primary school once a month back in day. One week would be to small amount of time and one year would be to big.
0 likesOne moon = one month is just PERFECT.
100 moons is Tallstar's life minus 3 months my dudes
0 likesReplies (1)
Im warriors a moon is a month
0 likesI believe you're correct about that. Wait. So......does that mean that the apple family has a family reunion every year?
0 likeshow long is 100 moons If your a warrior cat fan then you know
74 likesReplies (57)
@ThePsycoHyena WARRIOR CATZ FOREVER!
3 likesXD
3 likesAmber claw: wanna roleplay with some kitty pets?
3 likesBlazestar:Well sure! Thoughs Kittypets are always wonding in ShadowClan teratory *-_-
2 likesAmberclaw: heh im amberclaw. Top spy from leaf clan, sent back in time to Handle a mission
1 likeBlazestar: What kind of mission?
1 likeAmber claw:Trying to kill a clan named nightmare clan
1 likeBlazestar:NightmareClan?
1 likeAmberclaw: yes they are bad. Fooling our ancestor clans plans
1 likeBlazestar: Are they disrupting prophesies and destinies like that?
1 likeBlazestar:Tell me there whereabouts and we will plan an attack soon
1 likeAmberclaw: they hide in a cave down east its by that huge rock with claw marks digged in
1 likeBlazestar:Ok you can stay in the warriors den and Ill get my warriors trained up
1 likeAmberclaw: one question. Are you going to fool my plan cause that would be bad
0 likesBlazestar:No I'm trying to get trusted by all the clans again so no
0 likesAmber claw: good we attack by the end of the month
0 likesBlazestar:Ok we should get some sleep its almost Moonhigh. Brownpelt take her to the warriors den.
0 likesBrownpelt:Ok.
Please if your going to role play do it somewhere other than in the comments.
1 likeNot really cuz Equestria isn:t earth and wc takes place on earth
0 likeswell think what u want
0 likesMmk :3
0 likes:O rhen wc is based off of mlp or mlp is based off of wc xD rrandom thing
0 likesL
0 likes@Gamer RDash nope it's based in Europe ya know :P
0 likesYESSS
0 likes@Jade Cipher WARRIOR CATZ RULEZ
0 likesAaand its still going :3
0 likesYeah I was wondering that cause I just started the series and then I saw it was each full moon so can someone please tell if this is right?
0 likesI'm a warrior cat fan but I still don't understand.
0 likeswarriors are the best!
0 likes+Bonnietelo Cole one moon in the warrior cat books is one month
0 likes@Dusk Apple OOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHH! How could I have been so stupid! I AM JUST A PUP! (I'M FEMALE)!
0 likesyup that's how I knew before I watched :3
0 likesOMG!!!! I'm OBSESSED with Warriors!!!! 😋😆🐱🐈
4 likes+Eloise Cope
0 likesI'm a fan of Warriors, too.
😉<3
0 likesI've barely read a warriors book; however, I know 100 moons=100 months.
2 likesJade Cipher yep
0 likes100 months, duh
0 likesMail Cipher YES WARRIOR CATS FOREVER
2 likesMail Cipher oh lol I'm a cat hater so idk XD
0 likesMail Cipher 100 Moons = 100 Months in warriors.
0 likesWARRIOR CATS RULEZ but... the warrior cat world is not the same as the mlp world...
0 likes100 months warrior cats rock
0 likesTheAnimationStation / Aurora Yey
0 likesMail Cipher I LOVE WARRIOR CATS!!!!
0 likesYesSSS
0 likesWarriors is life!
1 likeYeS!
0 likesMail Cipher 100 months
0 likesMail Cipher I know right, warriors forever
0 likesA hundred months! Warriors FTW!
0 likesI am a warrior fan but I haven't been long enough to know
1 like100 moons is VERY LONG in Warrior Cats! I'm a Warrior Cat fan! Triggered Claw (Tiger Claw): I WILL GET YOU DERITTO PAW (Fire Paw, he was a Deritto colored pelt)!!! Lol.
0 likesMail Cipher hell YEAH
0 likesLook at my username WHEEZE
0 likes100 moons= 100 months c:
0 likes2:45 but remember granny applesauce refers to an incident 6 reunions before it is possible though that all the pictures taken in front of the barn weren't shown.
0 likesA book series called warrior cats and when a kit is 6 MOONS old they become a apprentice
1 like(they are technically training adults)
Replies (1)
Bruh
0 likes1 Moon is 1 month so 100 moons is equal 8 years and 4 month!
0 likesI read one of the MLP books and it said a moon was a year it might not be canon.
0 likesWow, look at your subs now, not only 20k, but 378k 😮🥳
3 likesBut wait if one hundred moons is one year... Then one thousand moons is ten years........... Hmmmmmmm................ Luna was stuck in the moon for ten years..... That's not a very long time.
0 likes"Happy New Year, this is my first upload of 2015"
0 likesMe: cries in 2021
Well a single moon is a single month so a hundred moons would be a hundred months...
0 likesIf you’re a warrior cat fan, moons are months :)
0 likesI'm too lazy to do the math. XD
8 likesReplies (9)
it is science, not math
0 likes@Thunder Storm fine. I am too lazy to do the science. Happy?
1 like@Thunder Storm Science basically is math.
0 likesnot really, science is basycally phisics, but is a little bit of math too!
0 likesHave you taken Physics? Physics is basically math, too.
0 likesScience is at it's core Math, Logic, and Fine Reasoning, with a little "I'm bored let's do something awesome" sprinkled here and there.
1 like@lightningbro .-.
0 likes@lightningbro Exactly. Math is also about logic and reasoning in itself. Science is basically math because it shares those aspects, and, as you said, is a bit of 'I'm bored let's do something awesome' sprinkled here and there. :)
0 likes+Kim Cliffrock And that is why i fall asleep in biology while going through notes..
0 likesIf some pictures from the family reunion are missing. And it's between Granny being a young mare and a grandma then that means that the parents were alive for the others. So Granny likely removed those photos with the parents. Hence why they aren't there and there's a gap........ That's really sad😢
0 likesThe show did mention year,like the Star Swirl episode and the one that princess Luna came back.like what Celestia said:”it has been a thousand years since I’ve seen you like this.”
0 likesWait if celestia has been always in equestria, how many candles does she Need in her birthday cake :/
0 likesAlso if princesses live forever is twilight going To live forever?
Why is AppleJack the only one with a southern accent if the all have lived in the same place (except Twighlight) for all their lives?
0 likesLike if u like baby applejack
3724 likesReplies (109)
More Apple fwitter?
275 likesDaww
38 likesSO CUTE :3
24 likes@***** I'm currently seeing 135 likes for RiZe and you're comment is also 1:35...
16 likesCoincidence? I THINK NOT!!!
(P.S. baby AJ is incredibly cute)
More apple fwittle? Sooooo cute :3
13 likes@Trinity Gillispie (me doing really good baby applejack impression)
6 likesI'm applejack! Moaw awpul fwittew?
@Juliette Lorek wow x3
1 likeIkr baby Applejack is soooooooo cute!!!
3 likesHonest orange apple horse is best pony
3 likes@Jaime Navarro
2 likesfacepalm@Omni Kai it must of been SO hard for the voice actor to read it the first time
2 likes@sukit ghoulgul that's true
2 likesummmmmm
0 likes@Omni Kai HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG
0 likesr u trying to poop
0 likes@Omni Kai no its like this:LIKE DAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAW EVERY MOMENT BABY JACK APPEARS!
1 likeWell damn didn't expect 284 people to like this 0_o
0 likesHi, I'm Applejack, (do you got) more apple fritter??
2 likes@Omni Kai 285
0 likes+Omni Kai You mean you like infant Applejack.
1 likeyep
1 likeLike if you cringe in how much you want to get a baby applejack but cant she doesnt exists
1 likeIm apple Jack AWWW
0 likesI don't like applejack I love her and derpy
0 likesLIEKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK she too adorable and cute!
1 likeDamn now 330 likes I'm amazed
0 likesMore Apple likes for baby applejack Dawww
0 likes+Omni Tear 370 now!
0 likes+Ever Forever hey we got the same profile pic as me
0 likes+Omni Tear Little Apple Jack is so cute!!!! And when i heard Brony Nations response to Little Apple Jack, i started crying and laughing!!!!!! Bro Hove!
0 likesBaby AJ is so so cute
1 like400 likes 0_o I did not think this would happen!
0 likesLol so many likessss
1 likeIKR!!!
0 likesBaby apple jack is senpooo
0 likesDAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW! I LIKE DIS VID! DAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW!
0 likesShe is so cute
2 likes+TeaR 37 (Nightfall shade) ikr
0 likes😯
0 likesAlmost 500 likes are you kidding me!?
0 likeswe all like baby apple jack even my mom does for real
0 likes+Style TeaRz 500th like
0 likesmore apple fwiterz?
0 likesDamn it's already been a year since I posted this? Time flies.
0 likes+The Brony Notion when I watched the show I was like "😭😭 DATS SO FWIKIN ADORABOL!"
1 likeYay
2 likes100 1/2 cute baby apple jack
0 likes+The Brony Notion can we pwease have more lwittle fillies of thwee group its swo cute
0 likeshmm. true😞
0 likesHi im appwe jack, more appwe fritter pwease! Dawww
3 likesBro, she's soo cute!!!
0 likestoo cute!
0 likesWay too cute.
0 likes👍
0 likesI'm appejak,mow appe fwitter" aw su kyute 😍
0 likesBaby Applejack:Im Appojack.Mor apple fwitter?
0 likesMe:AWWWWWWW!!
Sooooooooooo adorbs! !
0 likesIt's Trzy I 💜 baby apple jack she is sooooo cute
5 likesoh I am a follower
1 likeThe Brony Notion pin its trzy
1 likeLiity
0 likesIt's Trzy ya
1 likeI like or ra di
2 likesIt's Trzy 980 likes!
4 likesSuper cute 😍
1 likeIt's Trzy 1 Like.
1 likeG'job YouTube
It's Trzy 
1 likeMore apple fwitter..?
0 likeshey i just subscibe to u prativa
1 likeThx
0 likesIt's Trzy I
0 likesOmgrd really 1.2K likes REALLY
2 likesmore apple fwitters
4 likesagreed, so true
0 likesFLOWER THE FLOWER, NOW THERE IS 1.4K!!!!!!!
0 likesThe Brony Notion yes of coures
0 likesI'm Apple Jack! Mowe appwe fwitters??
0 likesThey don’t have all of them maybe because they took the ones with there parents out so no one knew AJs mom was a pear
0 likesThat was ment to be a comment
0 likesMore Apple Twitter
0 likesDAWWWW
0 likesTTTTTOOOOO CCCCCCUUUUUUTTTTTTTEEEEEE
0 likesI don’t like baby applejack. I LOVE BABY APPLEJACK
3 likesHewwo son of a god AM IN 2020 LOSER AHAHAHHA Also gick you past person
1 like@Sawtooth Waves That's so oofy
0 likesMe want an apple fwitter
0 likesDaww
0 likesDAWWWWWWWW!!!!
1 like@Sawtooth Waves yes
0 likesApple Fwitter
0 likesI love her voice its so cute omg!
0 likesDawwww
0 likesIt's Trzy U ONLY WANT LIKES >:(
0 likesHe he! yup
1 likeGuess Ima dislike
0 likesSawtooth Waves just just XD
0 likesSo cute!!!!!!!
0 likesShe’s so cute
0 likesWow, so true!
0 likesI’m Apple jack more Apple fwitter
0 likesSawtooth Waves dawwww 😍
0 likesI. CAN'T. STOP.WATCHING. BABY. APPLEJACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11
0 likesAwwwwwwww
2 likesJinnta M. She’s absolutely adorable! Can’t believe it’s been 5 years already. This was such a good time in my life mlp will forever be in my heart
0 likes@Sawtooth Waves lol
0 likesur to smart
0 likes:3
0 likesSoooooooooooooooo cute
A 1992 (the year when she was born) milestone: 3760 Baby Applejack fans!
0 likes@Sawtooth Waves aww
0 likesperhaps ponies age a lot faster than we think? oh wait i get what you mean now.
0 likesif luna was banished for a 1000 years that is 83 years and yeah the warriors series is really good
0 likesThis man predicted one of the among us hats (party hat)
0 likesWell, I think 100 moons is 100 weeks.
0 likesFriggin warrior cats up in here
3 likesmoons couldn't be a year because we hear fluttershy say she's "I'm a year older than you" to pinkie when pinkie pie has a party for gilda
0 likesit is one 100th of an Equestrian year. If an Equestrian year were the same as our year it could be up to 3.6 days, making 30 moons about 3 and a half months. The only real measurement of a year in Equestria is the passage of the cycle of the four seasons. but that's for the first Equestria Girls movie as it said if twilight doesn't get back in 3 days she'd be stuck for 30 moons so small time of being stuck
0 likesA moon = slightly less than a month. Yknow the moon cycle
0 likesWait... if this goes by normal time there’s about 300 days in a year so there would be 3 FAMILY REUNIONS 0-0
1 likeHAHAHAAH for me it's 2016!! Becus this video is old to me! Edit:2017!
11 likesReplies (3)
2019
0 likes2020
0 likesWow, so true!
0 likesIt's just not our Earth. And also, technically, the name of the world Equestria is in is not called Equestria. The name of their planet would be called Equestrion. At least according to me and my head-canon story on DeviantArt, which I titled "The Creation of Equestrion."
0 likesits possible to the moon be one week
0 likeslike every day different types of the moon
in that case 100 moon will be about 2 years
I think you shouldn't over think it it probably means 100 times the moon is in the sky. Who's with me?
0 likesBut if you look into the future the main 6 meet up every 1 moon but if you said 100 moons=1year how much is 1 moon?
0 likesThis is my first video upload on 2015
3 likesMe:................. IM watching this in 2019
one month is one moon its how our ancestors tell time
0 likesu know I love the first mlp Equestria girls but am I the only one that thinks it would be cool for twilight to get stuck in the portal u know like a fanmade one
0 likes"This is my first upload of 2015"
2 likesMe:*watches it in 2018*
Maybe they do this every year but don't always take the reunion picture
0 likesluna and celestia are more than 1000 years old
24 likeslike if you agree
A moon is a month bc a a full moon comes every month.
0 likesI looked up something so for anyone wondering.....
0 likes28 days=1 moon
I think a month = a moon! It means 100 months.. which means a lot months.. or Apple family reunion... probably they skipped a few apple reunions..
0 likesThe intro:
2 likesBut how long is a moo-FRIENDSSSSS!!!
woah woah woah buddy first of all: it says in a mlp book offical mlp book to be exact that 1,000 moons is 1,00 years its moons and years like if u agree and im not hating
98 likesReplies (7)
1000 moons is 1 year?
1 likeSorry but, Woah woah woah buddy, first of all: It says in the MLP book, the official book to be exact, that 1,000 moons are 100 years. It's moons and years, like if you agree, and I'm not hating.
11 likesEverything not in the show, even if official, isn't cannon. Comics, books and EqG are this overwritten by show in which 1000 moons clearly isn't a year.
8 likesCase in point, Granny was in Ponyville for a much longer than 10 reunions but when she moved in Princess Luna was already long gone on the moon.
Valkerie your comment is very confusing
2 likes@Lavender Flower applebloom doesnt look as old as she should then
0 likes@Lavender Flower about apple bloom looking too young? if 10 years equals to 100 moons, then apple bloom looks the same for atleast the 10, maybe even 20, years. and she is still a kid til the last season, because they turn into adults once
0 likesWow, so true!
0 likesIt can't be two years because in Equestria Girls 1 Luna said the portal opens once every thirty moons. Unless you consider how long the portal stays open then that would make Sunset Shimmer over sixty years old, because she would be in the world for thirty moons. However, I have a little theory of my own to explain this. You already determined that ponies are about two feet, and usually the life span of an animal or creature is based on their size. So I think time works differently in Equestria, which explains the season confusion and why all the characters are in High School in the movies. The time goes slower so that they can have a closer to normal size life.
0 likesPretty sure from my knowledge it’s every new moon
1 like1 moon is 36.5 human days
0 likesWhen Equestria girls starts sunset shimmer had been in the human world for 30 moons and in principle Celestia's office there are three pictures of sunset shimmer as princess of fall formal therefore she has been in the human world for 3 human years
30÷3=10. 365÷10=36.5
Although, I probably did the wrong math...
i mean they do have years in the first episode the legend said “on the thousandth day or the thousandth year”
0 likesHey I'm from the futureeee
5 likesGOT THE ANSWER!!!!!
0 likesThis is how I did it:
Moon to takes 29.5 days right so do this
29.5 X 100 = 29500 days
4 weeks every month
12 months every year
4 X 12 = 48
29500 % 48 =614.3333333
So 613.3333333 is how much 100 moons are
Starts gasping for air
This took me long and I told my parents and I did to much math and I NEED AIR!!!
in season 1 luna looks different then other seasons
0 likes100 days duh well except when the sun didnt hit the moon so that the moon cant appear
1 likeWhen apple jack get her cutie mark, grandma smith still old everytime
0 likesWho is here is 2020 quarantine?
4 likesTo all the people who says a moon is a year you know that episod where pick e pie is getting more A rock pouch the guy who sells this dated he would be at a place for 2 mins And I think he was talking about his family members WHY WOULD HE BE VISTING FOR TWO YEARS
0 likesOr maybe 100 moon must be 50 years, why? 1 moon= 6 month
0 likesEASY FOR A WARRIOR Fan to know how long a moon is! Moon is month
0 likesi was thinking that a moon is a day because everynight the moon rises in equestria i was thinking that 100 moons could be 100 days
0 likes1:38 awww
3 likesReplies (1)
i wanna cry shes so cute
0 likesWell 100 moons is 100 years bc in the episode when princess luna comes back from the moon celestia says "ive missed you, you've been gone for 1000 years" and almost all of us know celestia vanished luna for 1000 moons! so also in equestia girls 30 years till twilite could come out. Like if u aggree
0 likesBut in a hearthswarming eve Pinkie said, “The EARTH is round,” so Equestria is on Earth.
0 likesI have a theory
0 likesHere’s what will happen if cameras existed way further back in time: The first photo of granny Smith would be a baby second photo would be a Child and the next photo would be the same thing and then the next photo Granny Smith will be an adult and in the next photo she would be old so that means in the photo after the current photo Apple Bloom would be an adult
1:39 MY HEART IS EXPLOADING MUST ADOPT YOUU
2 likesbaby applejack is to cute!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... like if u agree
5 likesReplies (1)
I liked
0 likesWait- if Celestia and Luna raise the sun and moon does that mean there are multiple suns and moons- because Equestria is a country- not their world—
0 likesI cant have been the only one who didnt notice the hat until he pointed it out, right?
0 likesThis is the question that has existed for 100 moons..
0 likesHey isn't that party hat familiar???!!???!
23 likesReplies (21)
Eeyup, I wore the same one celebrating 10000 subs!
0 likesNo I mean I've seen it before but not on your channel hmmmm.....
0 likesOhhhh now I remember it's party hat from brawl of the objects you should definitely credit that Ya' know
0 likes@Nutella krayzay Omg it looks like the beta hat from Club Penguin 0__0
0 likes@Nutella krayzay It's Party Hat's asset from Brawl of the Objects!
0 likesYa thats what I thought too XD
0 likes@☮Glitterglamz101☮ OMG that's what I thought!
0 likesPinkie Pie perhaps?
0 likes@Bonnietelo Cole //Shrug
0 likes@Nutella krayzay derp
0 likes@Bonnietelo Cole herp derp
0 likesderpity derp derp derp (derp)
0 likes+Bonnietelo Cole Herpity derp derp.
0 likes@Purple Productions derpity derp derp derp derp derp derp derp derpity derp derp derp derp derp derp derp (derp)
0 likes@Bonnietelo Cole
0 likes*bows down to new derp king*
All hail derp king bows
0 likes@Nutella krayzay derp?
0 likesdun dun duuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuun
0 likes+Hasti Sojjani hi . do you do vidios
0 likesYes the cp (club penguin) beta hat
0 likesYa
0 likesI really wanted to know this for so long
0 likesIt's easy 1 moon=1 year because it was a long long time sense luna was captured for 1000 years/moons
0 likesbased upon my knowledge of Warriors (CAAAATOOOOS) 1 moon means 1 month. I love cats and mlp
0 likesPeople who play wolf games, cat games will know .
0 likesI always thought
1 moon = when the moon rises then when the sun rises the night is done right?
So I think every night is every moon they mean ;-;.
Welp me being the Warrior Cats Fan I am.
11 likesOne moon = One month
So I would say 30 Months
and 100 months for the title
Replies (1)
Blizzard Z yup, that makes sense :D
0 likesOne moon is one month so 100 moons are 10O months and a moon is the same as One month
0 likesActually,a moon is a month,I got that from a book fact trust me brony
0 likesA year is based on the seasons, not the sun. Why the seasons are caused, I have no idea. Oh wait, cloudsdale creates them. (Gasp) cloudsdale comes up with how long a year should be.
0 likesI have a request: how long is '4 cores and 7 seeds'
0 likes2021 anyone
3 likesJust me okay
I learned about the moon today,coincided?
0 likesWhat if celestia didn’t control the sun but the rotation of earths axis
0 likesCan lauren faust answer this VERY interesting question??
1 like;w;
Seasons are caused by the rotation of earth around the son and the earth’s tilt, however in equestria that isn’t the case, is equestria flat?!
0 likesWho still finds this funny in 2018
4 likesReplies (1)
Twilight Sprinkle yea
0 likesIn the book series wings of fire 1 moon is two years and three months
0 likesI figured it out one moon is one human WEEK because there is about 50 weeks in a year two years would be 100 moons because it would be one hundred weeks to
0 likesI think I have an estimate 100 moons is 100 weeks I mean there’s 57 weeks in a year so am I right ?
0 likes600 moons=50 years/moons=nights
0 likesWho else is in 2018?????
4 likesReplies (1)
Unicorn 129 meeee
0 likesin Rainbow Rocks, they changed that so Sunset can go back and forth
0 likesI'm binge watching this going through my mlp phase and is crushing on sunset shimmer ye I'm defo alt
1 likethis is so old ah the good old days
0 likesI think that a 100 moons is about 10 years but then again there is the Apple family reunion which messed up my analysis and well there u go I still think it's 10 years tho which means 30 moons could be 3 years
0 likesBUT NIGHTMARE MOON WAS BANISHED FOR 1000 moons
43 likesReplies (20)
OMG YOU RIGHT WHY DIDNT WE SEE THAT BEFOREHAND THAT MAKES NO SENCE
1 like:O
0 likesGot a point
0 likesÖ DUN DUN DUNNNNN
0 likesDUN DUN DUUUUUUNNNNN
0 likes+fluffy “cute kitten 303” pup DUNN DUNNNN DUNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
0 likesNo, it says "She was banished to the moon forever, but on the longest day of the thousandth year, the stars would aid in her escape" Or something like that, nothing to do with moons (except for Nightmare Moon)
6 likesI don't get it
2 likeslol
0 likesI'm going on with the 4. I have a great day, and the rest, but I think the best.
0 likesHELLO RD!!
0 likesyears
1 like"...ON THE LONGEST DAY OF THE 1000th YEAR..."
It was also stated in the Crystal Empire part 1 that the Empire had been gone for 1000 years but was later mentioned to be 1000 moons in the Flurry Heart episode. Coincidence? I THINK NOT. 1 Moon = 1 year so the question must be how long is a year in Equestria
0 likesRainbow Dash ya she was banished for 1000 years so one moon should be 1 year
1 likeRainbow Dash get back to you cloud busting
0 likesWasn’t it 1000 years?
0 likesDUN DUN DUUUUUUUNNNNNNNN XD
0 likesYeah a 1000 years right
0 likesLuna was banished for 83.333 years. Wow.
2 likesPretty sure that we're not here to talk about Nightmare Moon.
0 likes100 moons is like 10 years and 30 moons is three years
0 likesThe moon is my creation. Literally.
0 likesA year is one season of MLP
0 likesA moon could be a moon cycle
1 likeoop youtubes recommending me your old videos lol, most of your videos still hold up today, though id love to see some theories revisited!
0 likesWho else rewatched baby applejack too many times?
0 likesa moon is 27 days 100 moons would be about 8 years and 4 months
0 likesFor real I have always wondered how long is a moon and how long would 100 be or 30 moons be- Yet even after watching this and all 9 seasons of mlp I STILL DON'T KNOWWWWW!!!!! (I'm terrible at math (I'm only 11-))
0 likeswarrior fans will say "A moon is a month"
0 likesA moon is a month.
1 likeI got it from Warriors and a moon cycle is 1 month.
Replies (1)
Warrior cats yassss queen.
1 likeFor me I think 100 moons is like 100 years
0 likes2.15 you mentioned that granny Smith ages alot but you dint see the other ponies on either side of her...
0 likesTHEY DONY AGE AT ALL
The Mane 6 reunite every moon, and if 100 moons = 1 pony year or 2 human years, would that mean they visit every human week or am I horrible at math?
0 likesIf Luna can move the moon...... she can just move the moon 100 times!!! Tadaaa!!!! Answer😅!!
0 likesI think it is every two years how family reunions work thanks just my fairy
0 likesThe apple jack thing like when you said "Daww!" I died of cuteness so adorabke
0 likesI googled it and i got 20 years
2 likesone moon = 15 days , every full moon
1 likePhases are wrong. U said equestria. Twilights map has other places outside equestria. Ponys +spike are NOT astronauts. Equestria is not a sphere. The mlp universe is. So phases can be a thing but not your idea of them.
0 likesThis was purely for entertainment. PLEASE NO CRITICISM.
I was dividing the 100 moons and the three photos do I belive it is about 8.085 years.
0 likesEvery time the moon rises is called moons
0 likesI think 100 moons is a hundred months because in Chinese the word for month and moon are the same character
0 likesA PONY moon is the same as a moon in warrior cats. A month. Cause... lore.
0 likesold video but he just said 100 moons= 2 years and then said 100 moons = 1 year..?
1 likeNo one:
0 likesMe: Watching this 6 years later
I was literally thinking about what question for so long
0 likesI think 1 moon=1 month. Not just because of warriors my friends. I think that a moon is a month because there is a new moon/full moon EVERY MONTH! So that's just my idea.
0 likesReplies (1)
Kitty Corner that's interesting but it does make calculations a bit wierd
0 likesA moon usually is a generation.
0 likesIf 100 moons is to years for some people why is it different to other people
0 likesYou know how in Warrior cats moons are taking as Months well maybe it’s the same in mlp and 100 months is 8.33 years and that’s why granny Smith is still alive but maybe they change how many years they wait to the the Reunion
0 likesBut during king sombra every ponies said that they can’t remember cause it’s been thousands of years have passed
0 likesAh yes. The feeling of wondering why the heck this was in my recommendations
0 likesI just always thought that 1 moon was one month
0 likesAccording to season 8 episode 5 a moon is a year lol.
0 likesThe very first episode was an apple reunion day.
0 likesin 6 years you have almost 20 times the number of followers, good for you.
0 likesMaybe a century. A hundred years is a century so wouldn't a 100 moons be a century.
0 likesIt could be that 100 moons could be 100 FULL moons!
0 likesI just googled it and 100 moons is 8.085 years!!!!🙀😱
0 likesseasons 1-3 are 100 moons cause the pilot was an apple family reunion
0 likesI asked my father and he said that 1moon is 1 day 😐
0 likesThis reminds me of warrior cats
1 likeWait what if 30 moons is 2 years in the real world(equestria girls) so that would mean ever 7 years they would have apple family reunion
0 likesMoon = month
0 likesMy favorite character is good ol’ spotted leaf
Yeah, and this is my first day of 2019.
0 likesNo actually. Happy new year, everyone!
i thought equetria was flat.. can you make a video about that?
1 likeOK here is the CORRECT date.
0 likes1 moon= 1 Month
10 moons= 1 year
So how much is 6 moons?
please Like so that Brony sees this! and also reply and show me your calculations!
100 moons Means = 100 years/months Thats why ponies ages Longer then humans.
0 likesI've been wondering this ever since watching 'Apple Family Reunion'
0 likesI have a family of at least 25 people in Calgary, AB (the rest is in my country and scattered around AB) ..... We have a family reunion in Calgary almost every Sunday ;-; thank God most the time I don't go.
0 likesI remember watching you when you had around 1,000 subscribers...
0 likesI think a 1000 moons is 1000 days because when night comes the moon is there and when day comes it goes and then at night it comes again and when the moon comes 1 time I think that’s like 1 day on earth
0 likes100 moons is how long ago this was made lol
0 likesMay be 100 moons = 10 years?
0 likesMaybe it’s more of a handoff like one ruler takes it for date and rotate over there area or kingdom and then another war takes it and moved it over there kingdom and so on so Fourth.
0 likesI actually thing that each Family reunion is seven human years.
0 likesthe fact that i watch this video in 2020 is funny
0 likesThis video: exists
0 likesWarriors fans: ye its big brain time
In my country, Moon is Mesec, but month is mesec too.
0 likesLet us solve this....29.530589 days per lunation....100 lunations....So 100 moons = 2953.0589 days There are (365+365+365+366)/4 = 365.25 days per year (roughly) So 100 moons = 2953.0589 days = 2953.0589/365.25 years. So the answer to this riddle is..... 8.085 years.
0 likesI’m 5 years late, but in reality, 100 moons is just about 100 months. To be more specific, it would be more like maybe... 95-99 months
1 likeReplies (3)
No worries. I was 8 years late to the fandom.
0 likesLovelyLioness Oh I mean I’m 5 years late to the movie. I was here with the fandom from the start
0 likes@Queen Perry The Platypus Ah, nice.
0 likesMaybe the moon is the WHOLE MOON
0 likesSo thats why its soooooooo long
Its my theory
Don't judge
reads title and looks at warrior books
0 likesA MONTH
oh please btw
nightmare moon was banished for roughly 83 years
Wait.....
0 likesso in my little pony there on a separate planet???
Or a different universe were instead of humans it was ponys and the sun and moon were created by some elder alicorn or something possibly Luna and celestias parents who passed there job onto there children. (Then we put into light the flurry hart videos telling us about alicorn history) but this pony planet must be smaller than earth because of the size of the map or there's more places and equestria is just a little bit of it on there are other places over seas witch exsplains why it only takes a train ride to get there. So I imagine a pony Tokyo were the too speak different languages and the alicorn sivlisation was on a different country or somewhere further of the map. And in equestria girls they are travelling trough dimensions not just transferring them to another planet.
What do you think?
What about the finale Twilight said they would meet every moon 🌙?
0 likesWait, but it's said (in equestria) that Luna was banished to the moon for 1000 moons, and that that is 1000 years - meaning that one moon is one year. But that can't be right, right? I mean, it would mean Twilight is stuck in the human world for 30 years, AND Princess Celestia states that Sunset was only a bit before Twilight, and she went through the portal at the end of her studies (cause you know, she turned evil), and then it closed! She couldn't have been there THAT long. And 100 years beetween every apple family reunion just makes no sense! Granny smith was in all four of those photos, making her 400 years old! Which is no, just no. I have no idea what your doing creators of mlp!
0 likesThey also said “H
1 likeThat will take 100 moons to melt!
100 moons if lunar moons Is 8 years but if literal moons it’s 3 months
0 likesHmmm when i grow up i wish to discover space too😍😍😍
0 likesIt's 2018! YAY!
2 likesMy family reunions are every two years. 😃
0 likesSooo....1 Moon is...1 year?
0 likesok i watched the video and i have to admit my theory is really bad now XD i never doubt you will come up with something better than me :)
0 likesJust a theory but in the Philippines a month is called a moon so 30 moons is 30 months
0 likesA moon is almost a month 😁
0 likesevery time we see luna rise the moon it is full!
0 likesA moon is probably a month
1 likeso like january would be 2 months? or they actually have new names for the rest of the months
0 likesAnd now you have earned 255K with your hard work! Yaaaaay!!!
0 likesWait what would flurry heart look like in the human world?
0 likesLove your videos! Funny and edcuctanoil
0 likesA 100 moons are 100 days tell me how many moons do you see in one day
0 likesIn ponyland they see ever moon a day and in human world they see every year
0 likesI'm not sure but I think that in Finnish mlp equestria girls that time was 1000 moons... or years... not sure but still.
0 likesEquestria is an establishment, a country if you will, NOT a planet. And about Celestia's and Luna's jobs, referring to another one of Sawtooth's video's it can just be something dramatic and be a "tradition" with other "traditions" on other sides of their planet
0 likesIn my language we use "moon" as month
0 likesAge in Equestria is pretty irrelevant considering the cake twins are babies for like at least five years
0 likes100 moons is 8 years and four months (if i am right)
0 likesBUT WAIT! You FORGOT! When twilight first came to ponyville, Applejack said that they were having an apple family reunion (Season 1) Soooooooooo...
0 likesOne moon is when the moon is full
0 likes100 moons are 100 months I think.
0 likesA moon is a month.
0 likes#Science
Usually a moon would be a month
0 likesThis is basically the mlp version of MatPat
0 likeswhat if it was like moons in warrior cat btw one moon is basically one month
0 likesThat’s probably why ponies age so slow
0 likes1 Moon = 1 Months
0 likesBoom
Solved
maybe it does mean that when the moon rotate around the earth
0 likesyou know ur a fan of warrior cats when u can say what a moon is immediately
0 likesReplies (1)
Yup a month but this is different
0 likes100 moons is 100 DAYS or night. they don't say it does not say it has to be a full moon
0 likesFIRST episode of MLP they had a reunion.
0 likesWho else is watching three years later?
3 likesOMG I love your vidio's! And about your flurry heart vidio... I saw this other guy who says the artificial alicorns dont have flowy hair cause they dont have enouph magic or havent masterd it yet.
1 like1:37 ; the TRUE reason we watched this video.
1 likei love you dont say memes, so i loved it
0 likesSo basically..celestia an Luna control time...woah
0 likesI recognize that hat...It's Party Hat from BOTO!
0 likesCelesta is the morning sister
0 likesLuna is the night sister
Wait a minute... Equestria is geocentric?
0 likes100mmoons 100 months = 8.3 years
0 likesOr, it's just a kids show... And y'all thinking AB this too hard instead of just accepting any watching the show
0 likesIf your warrior cats and then you know how many how long a moon is :^
0 likes0:28 is that Party Hat from Brawl Of The Objects asset?
0 likesObject show assets roll out :)
I think its most likely moon = month
1 likeI thought a moon was a night.
0 likesI thought it would be 100000 years because 1000 years is how long luna was banished times 100
0 likesbut then why did luna have younger hair and then natral alicorn hair? it was only 1 day! so that dosent explain the hair of luna.
0 likeswen he said "its my first upload on 2015"I forgot that it was 2018
2 likesBrony: talkng math stuff
0 likesMe: mutes volume
Me watching 5 years later
0 likesHuh. . . Completely forgot he was calmed brony notion
0 likes100 weeks true mlp fans know
0 likes"But how long is-" FRIEEEEEEEEENDS
0 likesI found OUT IT'S EVERY TIME IT'S A FULL MOON LIKE EVERY WEEK OR MONTH
0 likesthose are good theorys...they are so good idk witch one is right! srry i do alot of typos
0 likesIn the last problem they say they see each other every moon
0 likesI thought a moon is a day-
0 likesThe answer for how long is 100 moon is friends c:
0 likesIn the pilot when twilight first visits ponyville wasn’t there a reunion?
0 likesI believe it would be every time the moon’s phase changes. So ye
0 likesi think one moon is like one full moon
0 likeslemme ask u something,why does gummy(pinkie's pet alligator)have no teeth? and why do dragons eat gems?
0 likesIn warrior cats, 1 moon is 1 month
0 likesTo help u in the first episode of mlp fim the apple reunion was going on when twilight arrived at sweet apple acres we know that because apple jack says that in the apple buck season episode
0 likesWarrior cats have moons and also my little pony so maybe my little pony knows warrior cats but never even talk about it so one pony knows them but never tell someone in the pony world.🤔🤔🤔
0 likesI don’t know how Granny Smith aged a lot maybe she hit puberty I guess
0 likesHow long is a moon? 3 500 kilometers.
0 likesI think granny smith is immortal i also think she is either an alicorn or someone in her family is.
0 likesI love it
1 likeEquestria is a country that's why there is a bunch of places outside of Equestria like we have the place where Griffin's live that's outside of Equestria hippogriffs also live outside of Equestria so that basically makes it clear Equestria is a country like that basically makes it clear that it is a country I love MLP
0 likesThis means... Rainbow Dash could be 11 in Equestria but 22 here?
0 likesMaybe pony’s age less than humans
0 likesLong story short, a very long time.
0 likesMOONS (throws warrior cats books at everyone)
0 likescelestia and luna were kids/teens when the pillars of equestria sacrificed themselves to banish stygian. 1000 years later, they were freed and celestia and luna were adults.
0 likesahem
100 moons is...100 moons?
0 likes3:44 actualy about one MLP year is = to about 1/3 earth year
0 likesOr maybe the 30 moons are 30 days because of the moon turns around equestria den 30 moons are 30days
0 likes1:39 AW FIRST PRIZE FOR MOST KAWAII! ... 1:42 AW SECOND PRIZE FOR MOST KAWAII
0 likesIf the moon go's around the earth each month maybe in the pony world the moon go's around 9.9 around the pony🐎 world 👩💻🤷♀️🗺.
0 likes”But..how long is 100FRIEEENNDDDSSSSSS”
0 likesin warrior cats, a moon is a month
0 likesI already know the answer but, why not?
3 likes100 moons=100 years
0 likesJan to April 19. Thats 100 moons so basically a 100 moons is 3 months and 19 days
0 likesIf u remember my little dashie the movie 15 YEARS in the human years and rarity or some pony said it was only 15 DAYS so maybe 100 moons means pony world is 100 years in the human world
0 likesWhen the princesses Lost their magic their hair stopped floating?
0 likesWhat's bigger than 20,000? 20,001! YAYAYAYAYAYAYAYA!
0 likesOk thpugh, just got home from a road trip and while going through a neighborhood I saw the street was called "Equestrian" I was like... TIME TO GO FIND PONY SECRETS (Im not kidding)
0 likesu gotta admit baby applejack is sooo cute right or is it just meh 🤔😋😋
0 likes3 weeks. I think. I didn’t do the math. No, 2 weeks.
0 likesThis video is the age of a first grader. That’s old for a video.
0 likesUsually one moon is one month
0 likesyou didn't take luna's time out into account
0 likesI always thought it was thirty years but idk it can't be
0 likesAlmost at 200K great job
0 likes1:38 so cute!
0 likesthat makes sense 😁
0 likesThe missing pics are cuz of AJ’s parents
0 likesIn one month there is one moon therefore one moon is one month
0 likesThe direct translation of what we call months in latvia mēneši but it transelates to months not moons
0 likesSense you are talking about moons, what about the Warriors series? I know you are a mlp channel but i would like to know this, how long is a moon in the warrior cats series? If you can't answer can anyone else?
0 likesIts a Tv-Show :D
0 likesWhat if one moon is the time between full moons
0 likesReplies (1)
*two full moons
0 likesMaybe Apple bloom has age powers XD
0 likesdidn't you say it was TWO years but then you said it was 1 im confused???
1 like100 moons I think maybe 100 full moons ????????????
2 likesNightmare moon was banished for 10 years
0 likeshow long does it take for a changeling to grow up ????????????????????
0 likesThe difrents between the 2 pitcures is because i think granny smith took out the foto where applejack parents are out of it so they wouldnt get sad
0 likesE Q U E S T R I A
0 likesI S
N O T
E A R T H
FINALLY A VIDEO FROM THE BRONY NOTION THATS TRUE!!!! OML
0 likesHave you released that are monn(the shadow) looks like nightmare moon
0 likesYou say that Equestria is not Earth... but what if it is?
0 likesponies age fast
0 likes8.33 years
0 likesIs 100 moons.
Happy 2015
0 likesMore like happy 2020 lol
1moon equal to 1day becuase at night their will be a moon.
0 likesahem According to Warrior Cats, 100 moons would be 100 months.
0 likes“How long is a moon”
0 likesFREINDSSSSSSSSSD
I think 100 moons is 50 days because 100 moon raises is 50 days
0 likesimma bet 1 moon is 10 days
0 likes100 moons mean 100 days for Equestria 😏
0 likesEvery moon they gather like the apple family
0 likesHis old oc looks so weird
1 likeUgh, all dem old ponies kinda ruin the immersion. I mean COME ON!! You have magic, but can't stop aging or at least the terrible appearance of it.
0 likesBrony nation: Its 1 year!
0 likesLiterally all the people who read warrior cats:ONE MONTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Me:Uhhhhhh, wings of fire is better then warrior cats.
Warrior fandom: DIE DIE DIE
Me: SIDAFHAISUHFASIDUHFSIAHUAIUH AHHHH
This is very off topic
I'm seeing this in 2017 so I feel very weird for some reason... Sorry
0 likesMaybe Apple Bloom has dwarfism
0 likesApplejack is so cute and how the heck does she speak
0 likes1:41 LMAO
1 likeWe have 365 days in one year so 100 days for one year is shorter restaurant here is shorter than earths years by 265 days changeling
0 likesSO CUTE :)
0 likes"but how long is a m- *FRRIIEEEEEEENNNDDDSSS*"
1 likeDid u know that the sun moves around us cool right
0 likesI think a moon is a month like a full moon
0 likesWatching this in 2020 XD
0 likesGood job!
0 likesIt’s a 100 nights
0 likesWhich is one day of sleep
If 100 moons is a year luna was gone for a year
0 likesEquestria gets endangered every two weeks
0 likesmoon is 1 day so 100 moons would be 100 days
0 likesYou deserve another sub.
0 likes100 moons means (I think) 100 days you :/
0 likes100 full moons maybe?
0 likes100 moons=100 days theory
0 likes2015: YAY 20K SUBS
1 likeJuly 2017: Ohh, 193k subs...
1:48 yeah but equestria isn't a planet, it's a country ;-;
0 likesA hundred moons are a hundred days or a year
0 likesOk I’m doing this off of Warriors the books A moon is a month AKA I shortened down this episode
0 likesYa know whats my fav Ali corn>?>
0 likesShining armor
We never seen him in teh future . He could be an alicorn now
Wait i think 10 moons is one year cuz theres a book that says 1000 moons is 100 years.. i havnt finished school and i start it one year after all other people and just learned how to do this, sonsonen correct me if i am wrong. 🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪
0 likesMonths wait Quick maths 100÷12 = 8 years or so
0 likesHey I have something for u
0 likesIn ep1 season 1 lunas hair was short and not weavy Next ep2 lunas hair was weavy what happend?
DUDE!!! It's 2019 and NOT 2015!!!
0 likesFirst upload of 2015,
0 likesDamn 2 years later
I thought you were gonna say 20000 moons
0 likes10 moons= 1 year
0 likes100 ,Moons is 100 fase of the moon
0 likesbaby Applejack: i aplwjack want a awpl friddle Me ADOREABLE
0 likesi honestly wouldn't be able to figure that out because I suck at math
0 likesHey everyone have you all see the background he is in the sweet apple acers so why doesn't he just ask granny Smith?
1 likeReplies (1)
ha. ha. ha.
0 likesAnd now,is 2019!!!
0 likesIn short: 8.3 years
0 likesSo Princess Luna wuz banished to the moon for 10 years?
0 likesVideo on my BIRTHDAY?
0 likesOOOOH
YES!
2015 wow nearly 5 years...
0 likesA moon is a month.
0 likesMe watching this in 2017
0 likes100 moons is 100 moons long ofc!
0 likesIt's like over thinking 1+1 and then it is wrong he said i moon is each day so...1 month anyone?
0 likescelebrating for 20-19!
0 likesyou are the game theory of mlp
0 likesMoons means nights don't over think it
0 likesAnd now it's 2017
0 likesIts probably 100 full moons
0 likesMaybe Granny Smith skip through the book because there are so many Barn pictures
0 likesWhat if...
0 likesEquestria is flat??????
One moon one year two more 2 years 100 more 100 years 😆😆😆😆😆
0 likesOMG its already 4 years cause this vid is 7 Jan and I just watched this now in this DATE NO JOKE WOWW
0 likesThe moon was 30days
1 likeHeh.. it’s been a while since this video was posted.. 😏
0 likesThis was made a year ago and there is only 6k wow I was expecting bigger I mean 6k is a big number but evan Aphmau has more (if you don't know aphmau people you should check her channel she has been doing this for 2 or 1 years/year anyway brony there is just a problem the my little pony always shows a full moon so how can the half moon quarter moon ext that we have and how if celestial never like rotates the sun around earth or in any case because to you its not at earth Equestrian (I can't spell it so I just said that)
0 likesWarrior cat fanz be like: 100 MONTH BRUH DO YOU EVEN READ O3O
0 likes'according to granny smith the apple family has a family reunion every 100 moons but how long is-' intro
2 likesmy man got cut off tho xD
just saying a moon is 28 days
0 likes20 moons is a year
0 likesah the pinkie pies birthday for ds music..... nostalgia
0 likesI'm curious about the apple family how old are the apples??
0 likeslaughing in fighting wild cats
0 likesIn the picture there are two apple blooms
0 likesHow long are 100 moons?
0 likesFRIENDDDDDDDDDDDDSSSSS
1:39 hugs soo cute
0 likesI think 100 moons is one year
0 likesCelestia and Luna, Twilight and her friends. Cadence and shining armour flurry heart and cadence!
0 likesI love bawby appolejawk!! Dawwwww, so cute.
0 likesGood god I need the answer to this!😫
0 likesUnrelated, but, does anyone else hear wind??
0 likesPlease make a vid on Granny Smith’s name because when she was little was she still Granny Smith? If so that’s a kinda weird name for a filly
0 likesI thought it was just 1 month was 1 moon xD
0 likesIt's 2019 now.. And also now you have 246k subs..
3 likesReplies (1)
Time flies!
0 likesHello, I love your videos so much
0 likesGranny smith has got more than 200 years acording that i think..
0 likesI’m pretty sure equestria is flat
1 likeI automatically thought it was a year
0 likes100 moons is when like for example 1 moon is like when 1 moon phase is complete moon nail (baby moon) till full moon😕😕that was a mouth full hah I said it in one breath and rote it in one breath😁😁
0 likesSawtooth: Equastria is not eartth
0 likesme: ya dont say?
lol its 2017 for me xD
0 likesthe first awnser that cam to mine was 50 years
0 likesbut apple bloom is nowhere near to 50 years old
I wonder how old the cantorlot students are
0 likesSo twilight was in earth for three months
0 likesMe watching this in 2019
0 likesIs Sawtooth Waves a girl or boy?
0 likesI'm Apple jack more Apple fritters
0 likesMe: OMG SO CUTE IM DIEING ITS SO CUTE!!! THUD
I like the baby in the last pic in the apple family book it's like 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
0 likesHello brony I'm also a pony my name is Lola I'm the princess of time no need to bow
1 likeSo many warrior fans~~~ including mE!
1 likeAnd 30 moons are a month
0 likesDawwww! Seriously I get u bro I am like awww screaming right into my mom's ear btw love ur vids I sub and I am 8! EdiT: oh crap I just dropped my mom's iPad on the wooden floor she’s gonna kill me 😟😧😦
2 likes1:41 yes yaya am apajack dam... thats so cute
1 like30 moons is a 30 month
0 likes0:30 is that part of the episode
0 likesMy guess was 50 days
0 likes20k... its damn near 200k
0 likesUh- I thought a moon meant a year ;-;
0 likes1moon is 27 ⅓ days
1 like1:42 😂
0 likes100 moons=100 days😐
0 likesIn my country we celebrated full moon it’s called poya day
0 likesomygawd little applejack is so cute
0 likesAww 😍
0 likesa moon is a month!!!!
0 likesWell according to me..... Oh boy how can i explain... You know like if there is a full moon maybe like when ever a full moon come is called in equestria moon just moon
0 likesReplies (1)
Yup
0 likesI think 100 moons are 100 days in ponyvill
0 likesits 30 years!!!
0 likesI think 30 moons are 30 days
0 likesThere almost immortal XD
0 likeshe looks so different-
0 likesApplejack was soooo cute
0 likesI been watching you since 5 years old and im 8
0 likesTWO WORDS.........WARRIOR CATS
0 likesLil Applejack is so cute!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesAll the warrior cats comments""
0 likesNot trynna diss y'all but just cause it's that in warrior cats doesn't mean it's gonna be the same for ponies
30 moons is 3 days
0 likesMeep peep we rarely have family reunions meep.
0 likes1 moon = 1 night...
0 likesLOOK AT DAT THICC LEG
1 likeI GOTTA EXPLANATION!
0 likesNEVER , EVER put LOGIC into the friken SHOW
In Warriors a moon is a month
0 likes100 moons is 101 days
0 likesI am apple jack , more apple fritter?
0 likesSawtooth : aww
Me omg!!!!!
“This is my first upload in 2015”
0 likesWHOS WATCHING THIS IN 2020 ANYONE?!?
Why am I just finding this page🥰🥰
0 likesHey Sawtooth Waves you think when they ment 30 moons they ment 30 FULL moon's 0:33
0 likesMaybe 100 moons is 100 days
0 likeshey! congrats on 189k subs!
0 likesBaby applejack is so cute
0 likesBaby Apple jack is adorable
0 likes20k? More like 444k!
0 likes1:50 if you Pusey here you’ll get the you don’t say meme 1:45 if you want a head start
0 likesFor him its 2015
0 likesMe watching this in 2021
OvO
Equestria is more Like America than Earth Equestria Is a country, dragons Live outside equestria Does That Mean they are from another planet? no, or Yakyakastan that is a different Country not a different Planet
0 likeshow old was mane six?
0 likesI think Aplebloom before 2 years she was 5 now she have like 7
0 likesHey at the beginning of the series there was a Reunion
0 likesmabye 1 moon is a differnet amountof time evry N moons
0 likes(N=number)
please make a thoery on the mlp movies
0 likesA moon=a month READ WARRIOR CATS AND YOULL UNDERSTAND
1 likeReplies (1)
I understand already
0 likesThat is why the days are so long
0 likesi thought 100 moons is 100 years but i am wrong 😣😵😵😥😥
0 likesIt's probably 100 days
0 likesIt’s probably 100 days
0 likesSTAHP YOUR TOO SMART
1 like(jk just make more videos I like your videos)
duhhhh im commenting before warching and i just wanna hear his or her thoughts. a moon is one complete moon phase set
0 likesmaybe those pictures are only family reunions at apple acres
0 likesIf you read warriors
0 likesa moon is a month
a moon means a day
0 likes@ the comment section
0 likesMOONS WAS A WAY TO MEASURE TIME BEFORE WARRIORS
Replies (1)
But in Warriors they use that method. :)
0 likesthey just don't age
0 likesI say one moon=one month because that's how it works is the Warrior cats world!
0 likesReplies (2)
Evelyn5000 Boyce-Sauer warriors is not mlp different storys may have different ways of doing things check I've had different time and currency measures in my own writings as well. and I know other writers that do. you can theorize similarities but same series and world they are not
0 likesthetruemasterofgames I am a wear that's they are not the same world. Just let me have my imagination.
0 likesI think that 100 moons is one year
0 likesNo one:
0 likesME 6 YEARS LATER: Bruh
Im just gonna..... steals baby Applejack
0 likes"This is my first upload in 2015"................... Its 2017 bruh
0 likesReplies (2)
PomyPlaysAll LikeABoss Are you saying I got it wrong? Lol
0 likesNo, all I am saying is that I am watching this in 2017, you didn't get anything wrong XD Its just a two year gap and I found it funny to place this comment XD lol
1 like*Answer to question in the title: 100 nights.*
0 likesReplies (1)
No! 100 months
0 likesSorry, I read Warriors qwp
I think a moon is a month
0 likes0:48
0 likesXD My name's Mona !
About 100 moons long
1 likewhose watching this in 2016 I am
2 likesOMG 100 moons
0 likes8942...And so cute and the first half of a new one for me.
0 likesIts 2 and half years!!!
0 likesAnd now, no longer 2,000. ITS 264K Subs
0 likesgreat vid!!!!!!!!
0 likesBaby Applejack: U'm Appejack, mow appe frittur?
0 likesAt first I thought it was a day then I thought it was year now I don’t know
0 likesHow long is a hu-
2 likesFFRRRIIIEEEEEENDDDDDDDDSSSSSSSSSS
It’s already 2019
0 likes1 moon = 1 day
0 likesOh sweet 2015
1 likeI think 1 moon is 1 night
0 likesOoowwww AJ was sooo cute
0 likesThe princesses can sleep in celestia dosent have to rasie the sun and no one is going to tell her to do it
0 likesmy cutie mark is a musical note too!
0 likes1 moon is a year
0 likesHAHAHAHAHAAHHA I didn’t get a single thing you just said
0 likesone moon is one year
0 likesA moon is a day
0 likesFull moons is a moon
0 likesyou said 20000 but now its 344K
0 likesAt first I thought you meant warrior cats
0 likesThis video was posted on my birthday lol
0 likesIts a show for kids don't mess with it.
0 likes100 months/8.33334 years
0 likesDUDE ITS 2018!
0 likesA moon is a month (I read warriors)
0 likesReplies (1)
I also read Warriors uwu
0 likesThank me later 😎 1:38
0 likes1:39 So 😍
0 likesA moon is a day
0 likesNo one:
0 likesMe: watching it on october
ᵂᵒʷ
0 likesEquestria is mostly like a country
0 likes100 moons is 100 days
0 likesim just taking a guess cuz I don't know- well for me I'm very intelligent at math & reading but I can bearely do square root but I know division and everything behind that but I don't know much about this planet and I'm a kid.(u can see my picture thingy migigy)
0 likesReplies (1)
oh yea and I forgot to say my guess witch is:every 6 moons cuz well 12 divide by 2=6
0 likesJust saying has anyone noticed that Equestria looks like America? (plus they rhyme)
0 likesReplies (1)
Though the company is American so that's not really surprising
0 likesIsn’t a moon a month
0 likes100 years old man
0 likesI think equestria is flat...
1 likeRefrnce to warrior cats.... Moons: Aka month
0 likesWhat happened to Apple Jacks parents
1 likeomg ADORABLE 1:38
0 likesbut how long is 10-FRRRREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENDS
0 likesI think it is every solar eclipse
0 likesYou say that you are a chanceling in pony world and you say our wrold?
0 likesAlso I have a family reunion every year
0 likesi think the main 6 are all 27
0 likes1 month= 1 moon
0 likeslol who else is watching in 2017 and their like Brony.. it's not 2015..
0 likesGUYS WHAT IF EQUESTRIA IS FLAT?!?!?
0 likesJk Rowling: aCtUaLlY tHe MoOn iS gAy
0 likes1:38 aww
0 likesthe amount of time it is between Notion's posts
0 likesI'm from the future it's not 2015 it's 2016
0 likesIts 100 FULL moons
0 likeso l d v i d e o
0 likes100 nights 101 days
0 likes100 moons is 2 and a half years
0 likesReplies (1)
i comment befor my gusse we have the same gusse cool
0 likesA moon is a month
0 likesa moon is a month
0 likesI love evs ( since) so I love this vid
0 likes1:37 AWWWWWW
0 likesMona=month huh mona you need to watch this
0 likesHalf these comments are screaming about warrior cats
0 likesMoons = months
0 likesThe pictures= ILLUMINATI CONFIRMED
0 likes😄😄😄😄😍😍😍😍
0 likesLol he says he has 20k but when o watch this vid he has 312K 🤩
0 likesIf you want to know look at Malaysian calender
1 likeA moon is very time a full moon
0 likesit's 2016 bro
0 likesEquestria is not earth
0 likesEarth ponies:
cool video 😎😎😎
0 likes1day=1moon so 100day
0 likesNow it's over 206k subscribers
0 likesIt might mean a years
0 likesMaybe granny smith only showed her a few photos
0 likesOOF
0 likesHe only got 64k sense 2015.....
BRONY NEW YEAR 2O15 STARLIGHT BROKE DESTINY AND TWLIGHT HELP HER TO FIX IT
0 likesSTARLIGHT DONT FOLLOW THIS PATTERN
a moon is a month
0 likesfor me its 2018 now
0 likesReplies (1)
really
0 likesıɬ ŋơɬ 2015 ıɬ’ʂ 2018
0 likes100 moons in 100 days
0 likesMe watching watching this when he has 301k
0 likes100 moons is 3 months
0 likeswhat is your right about the Earth lunar cycle
0 likesI enjoyed this video thanxs i like baby applejack
0 likes100 years
0 likesIt's a 100 nights :p
0 likes1 moon is 1 year
0 likesAh, 2015, 2022 is soon to be
0 likes8 Years.
0 likes2,400 hours
0 likesequestria is a place on earth because the episode A Bird In Hoof, celestia said where on earth
0 likesReplies (1)
oh yeah
0 likes9000 centimeters
0 likesOh I thought you were celebrating it
0 likesIt's been five years
0 likes2015? I’m watching this on 2021
0 likesHow old are the ponies and the little ponies like apple bloom
0 likes1 day 30 moons
0 likesSo if ya think about it.
0 likesEQUESTRIA IS FLAT
It means 100 nights
0 likes100 moons is 100 years because I read a book about princess loona by G.M.Berrow and it sed every moon we have the sumer sun selebreshen and this mens every year they have it by the way it woldent mack sens if there are more thene1 summer sun seleberashen every summer. It wold also mack sens that Twilight whanted to be quick so she woldent haf to wait for 30 moons (30 years).sorry if I have spelling mistakes I am only 10 and my home countere doesn't speak English
0 likes1:39 aww squeee
0 likesIts 100 years
0 likesEarth and eqesteria Both Start With E
0 likesIm reading the comments and warroirs atm but please.. stop time can be different in other shows and stuff
0 likesWarrior cats. Case closed
0 likes20000 in 2015 now its 276k+
1 likeYay!
0 likesI saw the "You don't say" sign in the video
0 likes2015 : nope
1 like2016: nope
2017: nope
2018: nope
2019: nope
2020 : Here you go!
it's 2016 😐
0 likesWatching it on 26th Jan 2017
0 likesI think moons are days
0 likeswho is watching this in 2017? i am
0 likesIsn't 1000 years a moon qvq
0 likes1:39 X3
0 likesIT'S 2018
0 likesDead of brony notion
0 likesduh 100 moons is 100 days
0 likes100 years
0 likesThis comment used to be cringy so its better now <3
0 likesi chose 30 day because if it is 30 moon sooooo shoud be 30 days !!!!!!!
0 likesI fortnite is a moon in my theory
1 likea month
0 likeswarrior cats fam where you at
1 like = 1 coreless apple
0 likesa month. easy.
0 likesUmmm dude it's 2017
0 likesI swore this was uploaded yesterday
0 likesSo 2 years are 100 moons? But that would less is to how why. I now it’s different there , but Luna rasie the Moon every night/day. And their dosen’t have to be round. It can esaily be flat. Witch less is to the same question. And if you look on the Pictures Apple granny were à fullt and then a adult but not Apple something forgott name .-. So i think moons dosen’t have any typical thing
0 likesWrong a moon is a day
0 likesWait in year “2120”.
0 likesInteresting. I suppose so.
0 likes100 monts acording to warriors
0 likesHappy 20000 subscriber day
0 likes100 m00ns means 100 days .
0 likesMaybe pony They take 183 to grow up so that's why they the same
0 likesYour a pony you should know!? Right.......!??
0 likesWho are the mane 6 parents
0 likes100 months
1 likeWho's watching this video in 2017
0 likesWho's watching this in December 2016
0 likesWhen i saw im little applae jack, AWWWW😶😶😶👶👶👶
1 likeWho's watching in 2017?
0 likeswhy is your cutie mark a music note
0 likesMy first video in 2015 me watching it in September 2 2019
0 likesit's already 2021 how
1 likeMaybe is because grandy Smith only showed some pictures
1 likeMoon=month
0 likesMoon=month
0 likesWow this is old
0 likesBut there was sun and moon in the show from the vines
0 likesFrom
Madihah
Omg I'm late. I'm watching in 2017
0 likesBABY APPLEJACK ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
0 likessionle answer it means 100 full moons gone by for us that is
0 likesmoons are nights
0 likes100 moon are 100days
0 likesI'm not kidding but this vid has 666k views....;-;
0 likesNot a hater but 100 moon's mean 100 days
0 likesI think 100 months
0 likes6 YEARS AGO?!?!
0 likesYou haven't watched mlp properly apple bloom stays the same because the first episode is one reunion you know that because when apple jack is apple bucking and refusing help twilight says what about all those ponies when she first arrived in ponyville and aj replies they were here for the reunion
1 likeMine is every year
0 likesWho else is watching in 2018!
0 likesI'm country and a city girl
0 likesCan people in my little pony die?
0 likesWell 100 days
0 likes2020ights assemble
0 likesNot our earth but eqestria is on an earth ever heard of EARTH ponies
0 likesmoon = month
0 likesI meant 3 decades
1 like100 daysssss
0 likesit is 2018 and i just wacthed this ( sorry can not spell today)
0 likes100 nights
0 likesNobody cares that party hat sawtooth is wearing looks like a brawl of the objects person (party hat)
0 likesAnyone watching in 2020? Only me? Ok..
0 likesjust ask luna smh
0 likesThey are days.
0 likesIt's 2018
0 likesCUTE BABY APPLEJACK
0 likesDAWWWWWWWWWW DAWWWWWWWWWWW
0 likesCool dude
0 likes5 years later
0 likespause at 1:49 Like seriously SPLIT SECOND YOU CAN SEE THAT
0 likesReplies (1)
you dont say?
0 likesI think the other pictures were somewhere else
0 likesUm...2018 now.....
0 likes100 days so a years
0 likesWho's watching in 2017
0 likes296k in just a few years
0 likes100
0 likesBritain exists in mlp world as rarity says in the episode where trixie is introduced 'stop with your British ways'
2 likesI have a family reunion in 5 days
0 likes#Brony Notion
0 likesMMM... Dates
0 likesI remember the rasist barn 1...2...3...4... Song
0 likesWhat.... It sounds like apple jack says rasist barn
And this is a kids show what the Hay hasbro
💯 days
0 likesWhat is the baby apple jack episode??
0 likesWho else watching this in 2020 corona virus
0 likesWhos watching 2017?
0 likesXd
1 likenice
0 likesApplejack:hi Im applejack more applefritter? Notion:dawwww me:awwwwwwwwwwww
0 likesGuys this is downloaded lights going to go
0 likeswhy are they sooooooo many thumbs downs they are 318
0 likesA moth then WarriorCats ansred your question
0 likes2018 next to 3059 yay!
0 likesIt’s doubled
0 likesI'm watching this Feb 11 2017
0 likesIs equestria planet 🌏?
1 likeDates not like that dates calendar dates!
0 likesshows the food dates
Correction 191K Subs
0 likesits 2022 :))))
1 likeplease tell us lauren faust.
0 likesIt’s 2020
0 likesWatch gravity falls!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesIs this SCHOOL?!?!!
0 likesA week?
0 likesBut i was 5 in 2015......
0 likes100 years duuuuu
0 likesI’m watching this in 2021 feb
0 likes100
0 likesya mean 257K subs?
0 likesYour first upload was are there alicorns hehe
0 likesthe first epsode was in apal famly ruyin and thares another in seasa 3
0 likesIs Warrior Cats Wrong or does time work differently?
0 likesReplies (4)
Warriors is.. Warriors. Mlp is well mlp, it has a different lifespan. Warriors is not wrong :)
0 likesYou have to remember- warriors is our world. It is set on earth, the actual earth, and it doesn't have magical beings controlling the day/night cycles
0 likesWarriors = Like our Earth
Equestria × Not like our earth
@A Random Person OK, your right fellow Random
1 like@mxddie yay
0 likesIt's 2018😐😑
0 likesIt is 30 weeks
0 likesApril 2017 yay
0 likes100 days if i mean days nights
0 likesI don't do math
0 likesBECAUSE WARRIOR CATS
0 likes1:38
1 like:)
YouTube algorithm YouTube algorithm
0 likesThis theory is not true
0 likes2020 anyone?
1 likeDude it's 2020
0 likes30 days
0 likeshippy nu yeer
0 likesLol👶🏻
0 likes:)
0 likesi think that it is still 2 years not meny pics not all came so not all got pics
0 likes10 months
0 likesit's a year
0 likesWho watching in 2020
0 likes5 years ago....
0 likes1:50 YOU DONT SAY
0 likes30 days
0 likes5 years ago....
0 likes2019? warriors fam?
0 likesit 3 and a half month
0 likesxd
dhuuuu its 100 years
0 likesthe 🌚
0 likesSo i gues it is 1 year or 1 mouth
0 likes666k views
0 likesI'm applejack more apple pie
0 likesThe video was uploaded on January 7th...
1 likeI am watching this in October 27 2018
0 likesCc has no cutie mark !!!!
0 likescedence is true alicorn or not true????
0 likesReplies (1)
not true qiu...
0 likes2022 is ending
0 likesOoh 666k views and its 3am
0 likesSup I am from the future.
2 likesequestria is flat.
0 likes*27.3 days
0 likes2017 anyone?
0 likes30 days
0 likes347,420km
0 likesP well the ponies in that show how have no heat well it wasn't a treat like 100 moons 100,000 moons there might be good enough because I like everything so my cute little friends Coco the dragon had good time 🐺🐉 Coco the dragon she's my least favorite character
0 likesIt's years
0 likesGuys this is 2020 the Corona virus wort year ever
0 likesAnyone 2020?
1 like1:50 You don’t say lol
0 likes2019 anyone?
0 likes2019 anyone?
0 likes1 year
1 likeAsk luna
0 likesEquestria is FLAT!!!!
0 likes10 Minunten
0 likesAnyone in 2020 ??
1 likeHow old is princess cadence imean cadance
0 likes1 MONTH
0 likesHello I'm from the future
0 likesJust read warriors
0 likesWhat is the planet where I live on the planet
0 likesWhat the fuck is this background music I’ve heard it in so many places help
0 likesCan I tell something to you are you busy break her and then my sparkle they are friends of sisters
0 likesit is 2021
0 likeshello I consider from the future. 2 years to be exact.
0 likes1:50
0 likesIM FROM THE FUCHER
0 likesLed is how and why i mean
0 likesWhy have luna 2 Haars
0 likesis 2019
0 likesu post this the day after my birthday
0 likes🦄is me.
0 likesI honestly thought it was ur b day
1 likeI'm from 2018
0 likes1:41
0 likesdantdm has 14000 subscribers so get wrecked!
0 likesmy name is kate and l,m 8 and l,m using my mom phone
0 likeshehehe 1:41
0 likesDude your subscribers dropped when you stop making videos
0 likespony world is not even true
0 likesYou are a Human not a pony so SHOW yoour real face
0 likesim watch on 2018 :/
0 likesA month
0 likes9000th like! I’m serious guys, I was the 9000th like
0 likesEquestriaIs not earth
0 likesAnyone in 2020...???
0 likesComment if you're watching in 2017
0 likesReplies (2)
Julie Amezcua hi
0 likesrhianna duffin Murphy hello
0 likesI love you
0 likesEclipses
0 likesAw
0 likesBACK TO SCHOOL
0 likesSo much math and numbers and years why
0 likes🍩
0 likesMy little brony notin
0 likesYOUR WELCOME FOR SOOOO MENE SUBSCRIBERS
0 likes2018.
0 likesWhat happen to applejakack mom and dad
0 likes1 year
0 likesi have no idea what you're saying.
0 likesThis is good vid potato im a kid
0 likesMoons is months
0 likesReplies (1)
WARRIOR CATS
0 likesIt’s 2020 😳😳😳
0 likesReplies (1)
👌😔✨
0 likeswhy so mean I have no Friends~
0 likes2020
0 likes2020
0 likesA year
0 likesya lost me
0 likescome on it's a show stop trying to make it all nerdy I'm not a hater I'm just telling you capiche
0 likesReplies (1)
Mieka Winslow it's fun to theorize sometimes
0 likes1:39
0 likesEquestria is not me
0 likes800 today ok 800 today's
0 likesApplejak
1 likeWell, due to fanfic/headcanon reasons, I find that at least some of the notions of the length of a moon have got to go. Personally, though, it makes the most sense to me that "moon" as a length of time once existed in Equestria before Luna's banishment, but now it no longer does. Equestria maybe used to have a lunisolar calendar like the ancient Jewish calendar; but now it's a solar calendar like our own, complete with years, months, and weeks. But from times of old, the measure of "moons" stick around, like our "fourscore and seven years ago" or "fortnights", for example--but no one really knows what they mean anymore, because they would have been based on lunar cycles.
1 likeEquestria does not currently exhibit lunar cycles, though. The moon is always full; it can be assumed that Celestia didn't honor that part of Luna's movement of the moon when she took over that responsibility, and for whatever reason it has yet to return. That's why the calendar would have been changed in the first place. And that's why really old ponies like Granny Smith, and occasionally others, try to use the "moon" as a unit of time--but they don't have a way to do so legitimately anymore. "100 moons" is then effectively shorthand (shorthoof?) for a set number of days that the Apple family has agreed upon, and it probably happens to be somewhere around a few years. Other instances of "moon" don't seem to line up because they're based on other flawed interpretations of a history forgotten to most ponies.
But the Princesses know how long a moon is. Just ask one. I dare you. (This makes the 30-moon reference for the EQG Mirror activation interval more interesting because they're the ones to explain it...)
Replies (1)
Mahaveez second most long cmment i see in the comments so plz peaple do not make your comments long btw i'm useing my dads acount
0 likesI got another theory based on the words pronounced by Luna before Twilight enters the portal in the first EG movie : "On the Third day, when the moon reaches its peak in the night sky, the gateway will close, and once it does, it will be another 30 moons before you will be able to use it to return."
0 likesSo : basically, the portal connects both worlds together, and their time is completely connected, as well as moon cycles. In the vision Luna makes, we can see the moon changing of stance, and so, a cycle would be 1 moon = 3 days, with the nights working like this : 3 days, 3 nights, full days, but 1/2 night, then 2 full nights, then 1/2 night again. So, in my opinion, a year would be either 100 or 120 moons, to have them like in our world. But I'm absolutely sure that a moon cycle is 3 days, so basically, the Apple family is meeting every year so 100 is more plausible.
I kind of figured the system Cel and Luna worked out would be based on the seasons, possibly even causing them, but I suspect it'd correlate to one of our years (if only because that makes the math easier).
0 likesI think 100 moons is one year. my reason is simple if it happens every hundred moons the last reunion they had was when Twilight first came to Ponyville which was actually one year ago because since the start of the season we have only seen to raising and lowering of the Sun and Moon. another thing we can look at is the Canterlot ball.
0 likes30 moons can't be less than a year since the portal to the human world in Equestira Girls opens every 30 moons but looking at the number of pictures Sunset Shimmer has as princess of the fall formal it shows she has been crowned three times and such events would take place once every school year meaning she would have had to have been there for at least three years. Unless of course she could have been going back and forth through the portal everytime it opened up to be caught up on what was going on in Equestria and waiting for the right moment to make her move but that is only a thought.
0 likesI'm the episode "A Gift For Maud Pie" pike said the owner of the rock pouch store was going to canterlot for a few moons... So Manehatton is pretty close to canterlot so if they were visiting I imagine it be for maybe a week or two. So I think a moon is basically one night/day (24 hours)
0 likesActually, in one episode Twilight says something like "She must still be recovering from being trapped in the moon for 1,000 years" In the halloween episode with Pinkie dressed as a chicken. So, a moon in Equestria is actually one year. The ponies live much longer than us humans and i'm guessing they could live up to about 80,000 years or so. I have known this for a while but forgot to post the comment when i found out
0 likesReplies (3)
Ayla Nassen That means nothing
0 likes@CutiePants87 MSP And Aj I was just correcting him, and also telling other people. It took me a while to write that, and its just a little info for people wondering. It does have something to do with the video, unlike alot of the other comments, so i think it does mean something
0 likesLuna being trapped on the moon doesn't actually mean anything in terms of how long moons are. Luna was trapped there for literally 1,000 years
0 likesI think that 1 moon = 1 year because on the first episode of mlp season 1 the book says " on the longest night of the 1000th YEAR the stars will aid in....." and then later we here celestia say " it has been 1000 MOONS since I have seen you like this" so this could mean that 1 moon is 1 year or it could have just been a slipup to the script writers
0 likesOnly one problem. In the FIRST EPISODE applejack's WHOLE family is together, and in the next episode she said it was just the reunion.
0 likesWhy are the sun & moon dependent on Magic? Equestria was founded before Celestia & Luna came to be because according to the 1st Hearthswarming episode: before Equestria was founded, Unicorns were responsible for bringing night & day. Why was the sun & moon dependent on unicorns? If that's so then how did ponies ever evolve? How were unicorns able to evolve horns if the sun & moon were supposed to be dependent on them?
0 likesUnless there's an artificial sky that covers Equestria because the real Sun & moon are dead, but that's another story entirely.
I think that 30 moons would be in-between about 23 and 30 months so 100 moons would be in-between 73 and one third months and 100 months I think 1 moon is 1 full moon I base some of this on a story I read so 30 moons is about 2 and a half years so I think a reunion is about every 7 years and 9 months but we don't really know how long a season is and we know on season five twilight has been there for at least a few years and none of the characters actually age ecsept twilight becoming an alicorn and the CMC getting there cutiemarks but like I said this is all just a theory. Please let me know if I got anything wrong.
0 likesit's funny how you explained why you think a moon couldn't be equal to a month but 1/3 of the comments are "1 moon = 1 month" or "100 moons = 100 months"
0 likesUmmm I found a mistake. If the reunion is every 100 moons, and every year is 100 moons, wouldn't the reunion be every year, not every two years?
0 likesi just thought that ponys age differently in mlp like they live who knows how many years in that case one moon would be one year but i havent thought about that apple family and nightmare moon thing
0 likesA moon is when the moon gets to its higher point
0 likesListen to Luna when she explains the portal time
If it were 2 years, apple bloom would be 6 on the third photo, and somehow granny's position is the same in the third and forth photo
0 likesMaybe one moon is a whole moon passed by?Like the moon starting tearing apart and starts back as a whole moon?
0 likesI think that a moon is actually equal to each phase of the moon as in 2 days
0 likesReplies (1)
I mean it may sound a lot off but the modding photos could simply be fixed with they just didn't have them for the lack of ponies coming to the reunion
0 likesI found a mistake in the pictures of the Apple Family!!! In Granny Smith's sharing of her story of her and her family practically starting up Ponyville she was a adultish/teenage pony. In the picture in front of the farm for one of their family reunions she was a filly!!
0 likesYou are wrong. 100 moons is less than a year. If you look at the timing of the summer sun celebration which takes place every year the apple reunion is in between.
0 likesI think that 1 moon = 1 month. So that means that 30 moons = about 2 1/2 years for us. But that is just what I think. So there. ;)
0 likesyour theroy makes sense, if I am right twilight is 24 years old, but in the human world she's like 17, so equestria must have 50 moons=1 year, while in the human world 1 year=365 like our world, you could fit a little over 7 equestria years in our year, and there is a 7 year age difference between when twilight is a human and a pony.
0 likesIm sure 1 month is one moon! So twilight would be trapped for 30 months and 100 moons is a few years
0 likes1 moon= 1 month
1 like30 moons= 30 months
100 moons= 100 months
You're welcome
maybe 1 moon is 1 day as every night the moon comes but... the apple family reunion confuses me. it would make sense being stuck in a world ( equestria girls kind of world :) for 30 days, it kind of a month. maybe i could be wrong about the apple family reunion.
0 likesa moon is a week so 100 moons would be 700 days so about 2 and a half years
0 likeswait if the sun revolves the earth then in one episode when they acted out the beginning of equestria they said that the unicorns raised the sun and moon and later the earth ponies lift the sun using rope
0 likes3rd episode season 6. When the sign says gone for a few moons, pinkie screams " the owners gone for a few months. Maybe they have shorter months?
0 likesBaby Apple Jack creates a cuteness overload!
0 likesI think it has to do something with the Moon phases
0 likesIn a series of books I read (warriors) 1 moon is equal to 1 month
0 likesthe yaks said they would be friends with the ponies for a thousand "moons", and as u said in the video, that's not really a long time. so will they go to war like right after that short time period? that is only 10 years, but i dont think ur correct because of that. no offense but i just outsmarted u on mlp. :p also im kinda a big fan so dont be offended okie thnx
0 likesI think it's after 100 moons are over they have a reunion I think
0 likesum you know if that's right than Luna would have only been trapped for 10 years
0 likeshmm...100 moons? 12 x 100 = you need to figure that out yourself!
0 likesbecause in equestria girls 30 moons, twilight says two and half years, and its 30 months
0 likesis it just me or did the theme start before he said 'moons'
0 likesequstria is half the size of earth so that means the days are half as long. i say a moon is lke 2-3 days
0 likesIn Apple Family Reunion,
0 likesthe picture above Granny Smith when the picture book is being read is based off a painting in Chicago.
I realized that the first two family pictures Granny Smiths parents never aged
0 likesWait wait wait. Luna and sombra was banished 1000 moons. So your saying that they were banished only...lets see...20 years?
0 likesI think 100 moons is 100 years except a lots of the pics went missing
0 likesWell, in the Warriors series a moon is every new Moon.
0 likesReplies (1)
I love Warrior cats! I read that and i knew that 1 moon is 1 month.
0 likesone moon is one day at earth so 100 moons is 100 days
0 likesmy science class told me shadows are NOT the cause of the moons phases... help me.... im confused ;-;
0 likesI have a video I would like you to make brony notion , why doesn't sapphire shores have a cutie mark as you said in one of your video comparing cutie msrks in equestris and in the real world.
0 likesdo one about twightlight sparkle not being an element of harmony in our world, because magic doesn't exist. please?
1 likeReplies (1)
marshmallow unikitty the RAINBOW friendship
0 likesI think it could be explanation, but... Yeah Equestria is not year, but also... ponys are not people. What I mean? Thay can grow and becoming mature at other speed than humans. We for sure know that for alicorns - at least at some age - 1000 years isn't time in which she(I would write or he, but there is no male alicorn... and I wonder why, nearly since i started watch the show) could stale... at least in perceptible extent. But as far as i know there's no specific information how it is with other type of ponies. We surely can see that one month ponies are more independent than one month baby, so definitely ponies doesn't grow up in the same pace as human's do. They seem to be faster in it... but who said that in whole live it's the same rate, and in vevery stage of life ponies grow for example maybe 1 month old pony is like 1 year old human, but 1 year old pony isn't like 12 years old human. Maybe pony's growth "slow down" much more than humans, and at some points human began to grow faster? And maybe even 30 year pony is equivalent of 10 year human? I think it could explain a lot of things. For example why they all drin punch(which is alcohol drink... or maybe in Equestria not... or maybe it was just translated into Polish...), ponies from mane six have its own work(like Rarity's shop, Twilight's library, AppleJack's farm etc.), live for their own and their parents wasn't even mentioned(at least till end of fourth season)... and on the other hand they all the time seem rather to be teenegers(their human version attend to highscool(yeah, on the other hand thei drink punch too...), after going to Earth Twilight was in such age). Maybe it's even more than two time slower grow of ponies. Especialy, that we can notice strong time dilatation between Equestria and Earth(if world in Equestria girls really is our Earth... I mean... You know colorful skin and hairs aren't popular in our world). What i mean? This what Dazzlings saw at the beginnig of "Rainbow Rocks" is defeating of Succubus Sunset... so the end of "Equestria Girls". So between first and second visit of Twilight there is only a few days... and at the same time in Equestria it passed definitely more time. Fourth season last at least 26 days, but i think that it could be two times that much, or even much more. Anyway during few days on Earth(I'm sure that Dazzlings didn't want to wait longer than few days) we have more than 26 days in Equestria. This is at least 3-4 times more. If ponies and human would grow at the same pace Earth and Equestrian mane six will be at the same age only through very short period of time. So i think, that pace of growing in Equestria and Earth aren't the same.
0 likesBTW timeline of series is itself interesting topic, have You ever do some? Of course to do this it's neccessery to assume some pattern of counting time/date. I think that even if Eqestria isn't Earth still best possible solution is to assume that what could be similar is similar and this mean length of day, month, year... because why Celestia and Luna couldn't done it in such way like it is on Earth? The same is I think with seasons and such things like summer solstice.
Yeah, I know it was quite long and maybe a little bit complicated, especialy with my not very good english... but i hope You get my point. If You will do some next video about this please let me know.
Celestia said Luna was the one who created the phased of the moon
0 likesbefore watching i think its 8 days because the moon goes the eight stages from full moon to new moon and it takes eight stages for the the moon to go from full moon to new moon and new moon to full moon
0 likesits sounds like it means days.. hear me out, every day has a moon so, say 20 moon-20 days... but then the evidence says otherwise |(
0 likesReplies (1)
The cycle of a moon is a month so 1 moon is 1 month
0 likesthough your theories of this are good I think 100 moons is 1 year please tell me if that's your speculation cause I didn't really understand your theory
0 likesA moon is a month because there is a full moon every month
0 likesI think it's 100-110 months long
0 likesIn Warrior Cats a moon is a month, so that's what I go off of XD
0 likesReplies (1)
Cats : i see that
0 likesGranny Smith is arround 100 human jears old because in one Episode we came to know that Sweet Apple Acres is one of the oldest Buildings in Equestria and in one of that Flashbacks was a filly Granny Smith !
0 likesThese videos are so intresting!!
0 likes100 months=8 years, two months
0 likes1 moon is 1 month im very sure so every few years =D
0 likesI think each moon is a day so 100 moons is a year. But one thing is are year is 365 days so a year for us is like 3.5 years in eqestria
0 likesBaby AJ is just Awwww😍😍😍
0 likes100 months
0 likesevery Apple family reunion is 8 years
I THINK 100 moons is 8 year and the animators forgot to make applebloom little....
0 likesHow do you turn centimeters into meters?
0 likestake out the 'centi'
Maybe the Apple family only keeps the most important photos.
0 likesMaybe do a theory on back stories? For instance, does fluttershy or rainbow dash have parents? And what about scootaloo? What do you think?
0 likeswhat if 30 moons is 60 years I mean well 30 + 30 is 60 I may me wrong but it may be true
0 likes" I'm Apple jack more apple fritter." * squee* lol
0 likes"I'm Appwjack! Mowe appwe fwitter?" DAWWW
1 like1 equestria day is one human age.
0 likesOMG Brony notion! plz do a theory on twilights element....Why is twilight sparkle the ELEMENT of magic but is the PRINCESS of FRIENDSHIP?!
0 likes6 of our years is 2 years in equestria
0 likesif you ask how o know this from the 6 years of my little pony there has only been 2 warths warming eve episodes and 2 nightmare night episodes this could give you a clue of how long is 100 moons
Replies (1)
Lance P Pillay no,please tell me
0 likesEvery moon= every month.
0 likes100 days,because you see moon every day~.Dah!
0 likesawww baby apple jack is so cute I need one I want one
0 likes30 ∂αуѕ ¢υz ѕнє яєνσℓνєѕ ιт єνєяу ∂αу ѕσ 30 мσσиѕ ιѕ 30 ∂αуѕ
0 likesDon't want to be rude but wasn't Luna stuck on the moon for 1000 moons
0 likesummm.... 2 equestrian years = 1 earth?? even though... 100 moons = 1 (eq) year... or 50 = 1 (ea) year?!! wouldn't it be 2 EARTH year = 2 equestrian years??
0 likesReplies (4)
1 equestrain not 2 sorry!!
0 likesSo.. 100 years would be 100 moons in Equestria? FINALLY! I CAN AGREE WITH SOMEONE!
0 likesi don't get it...CAN SOMEONE EXPLANE TO ME WHAT THEY MEAN?!?!?!? btw i'm useing my dad's acount
0 likesAlfredo Sarraga Jr WE DONT CARE, maybe, if you don't understand this, you should be watching something you do understand instead of asking what we mean! Oh, and also, why are you on your dads account?!
0 likesI think 1 moon's is 3 days
0 likesNo if u say 10 moons in realty that would mean there was a full moon 10 times
0 likesWhat do u edit with
0 likes1 moon is 1day so 100 moon is 100days
0 likesis that the beta hat from club penguin?
0 likesCould you do a video on the picture that is in the background of the apple
0 likesbaby apple jack is so cute!!!!!
0 likesI think 100 moons is 100 months
0 likesi think moons are eclipses.
0 likesnice video thanks for telling me. if you to know some burning questions of then watch or meet super planet dolan :-)
0 likesUh a moon is pretty much a month or another way a day
0 likes1 who is watching this in 2016
0 likes2 who is watching in 2016 when season 6 is out
3 who remembers on the third episode "token a sodden vacation. Be back in 3 moons
I love you Brony
0 likesI love you Brony
0 likesWe do reign once a year
0 likesI think one moon is one day
0 likeswhat if it was Earth?
0 likes1 full moon every year
0 likesHow long is a hundred moons?
0 likes215.900 miles long.
Replies (3)
1 year I think
0 likes+snowflake storm That anti-joke flew over your head.
0 likesoh dammit it always gets me with tricks
0 likesDid you hear him say "guestimates" in 2:30?
1 likeMy mom siad maybe moons are months like everytime they have a full moon.
0 likes100 moons are 100 months
0 likesso time in our world doesn't esces. you set your time ahed and next year you set it ahed again see my point
0 likesso time in our world doesn't esces. you set your time ahed and next year you set it ahed again see my point
0 likeswhen u did the dawww it was funny!!!!-star crystal gaming 101( her daughter)
0 likesor look at warrior cats. a moon is a month in the warriors time
0 likesand in my littel dashy princess celestia said it's been 15 days in mlp and in our world it's been 15 years
0 likesReplies (1)
Fanfic = Not canon
0 likes30 moons 30 days
1 likei think it full moons 30 moon
0 likesi love your vidz
0 likes1 moon= 1 month
0 likesBaby Apple jack is so cute
0 likesWarrior Cat fans know how long 100 moons are.
0 likesi cant remember if i stole this comment idk ive seen this video five months agoYou need to make a video about you and how your life as a pony I know you have a pony style but plz do it!!!!!!!!!
0 likesWhere is discord I've been looking for him all day if you find him TELL ME PLS!!!
1 like(after watching) well everyone i was wrong
1 like100 is 1000 days.
0 likesa moon is a month i learned that from warrior cats so ya its not that long 100 moons 100 months.
0 likesReplies (3)
Talia Willson cats and ponys,they are both animals
0 likesAlfredo Sarraga Jr I'm sorry, "they're both animals" how stupid can someone be? That doesn't make a tenth of a difference! They're completely DIFFERENT animals!
0 likesAmestyTheKittyGamer warriors is not mlp different storys may have different ways of doing things check I've had different time and currency measures in my own writings as well. and I know other writers that do. you can theorize similarities but same series and world they are not
0 likesA moon is evre 60 months m'kay
0 likes8 years.
0 likesA moon is a month
0 likes100 moons is 10 days 30 days I'd 3 days
0 likes1:49 Meme: You dont say?
0 likescute
0 likesWow !
0 likesIt's 2016 now
0 likesIt's 2016 now
0 likes100 moons is a yare🦄
0 likes5 moons probly right.?
0 likesApple blom is gonna stay yunge forever
0 likes100 full moons
0 likesI how long is a moon ya wanna know oh well. Jk it's a month.
0 likesdoes it make me wierd that i thought i saw nightmare moon in the moon
0 likesReplies (1)
+Courtney Brown should i consider that good news or bad news ;-)
0 likesMoon=Months
0 likesin the end of the video ur tail is not lined up
0 likesIt showed 1million not 1thousend
0 likesI know about the fazzes of the moon
0 likesnice
1 likeA billion years
0 likesWait.....Umm... Princess Luna DOESN'T Have Wavy Hair.....
0 likesReplies (1)
That is when she was young.
0 likesMoon = months
0 likesI like baby Applejack
0 likesWhat's a guesstimate?
0 likesponyvill and more is earth. watch smile hd its a mlp one
0 likesWhat my little ponys drink?
0 likesok 1 moon is 1 sicle of the moon. duh im 8 and i figurd that out in 2 mn
0 likesthe magical world where there are only 73 comments. wonderful to think about
0 likesyes it is
0 likesGUESSTIMAAAAAATES!
0 likesDid Anyone heared Zane in MyStreet Aphmau of Minecraft Diaries
0 likesSaid My Little Horsey/Horsy? Even though its My Little Pony
And Zane said Pinkie Cake even its Pinkie Pie and Hhahaha He Called
Twilight Sparkles to Twilight Sprinkles Hahahhahaha😂😂😂😂😂😂😃😃😃
the picture that u show when nightmare moon just turn back into Luna why her hair was it following like Princess Celestia and how her hair started flowing like Princess Celestia get did it just take time or it was one day is started up again because remember and season 3 I think the lunar Fest her hair was flowing so your hair
0 likesIs Equestria a planet
0 likesThat is so confusing
0 likeshe seemed to lose subbies
0 likesman am i back in school lol
0 likes100 days
0 likesDates from Saudi Arabia XD
0 likesif you read warrior cats you would'v known a moon is a month XD like this comment all of you warrior cat fans?
0 likesI'm a new subscriber
0 likesThan what's the other 12 months called? Do you know? !!! If you didn't than all you said was a big fat liye .
0 likesP.S not saying you liyed
P.S your a Grat youtuber !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
P.S thank you for making vid
P.S I think your stunning as a you tuber you do a Grat job
The first vid in 2015 huh im watching march 2016
1 likeReplies (8)
Same!
0 likesYeah I was like huh??,, oh wait this is old
0 likesIkr
0 likesShyeah
0 likesI'm wach in in april 2016
0 likes+Saira Naeem Me too!
0 likes+Bff Channel ME TOO
0 likes+Hanneah B Haha
0 likesi have no idea what hes talking about XD
0 likesi think 3 days
0 likesit's not a year or more
0 likesPleas tell me I need to show you my pony
0 likesi have just subscribed
0 likeswhat is the baby applejack from
0 likesReplies (1)
Apple family reunion.
0 likescan you make one about yourself?
0 likesIs granny smith there mom
0 likesanybody watching in 2016
0 likes30 days
0 likeswhen is your birthday?
0 likesyou now have 154,641
2 likessubs
yay u
i am one of them
what's you number? mister pony?
0 likesmy birthday is on January 1
0 likesDuh! cetrys
0 likesYea!
0 likesI'm confused
0 likesbeta hat!
0 likesdid twilight sparkle is not real princess of freindship
0 likesSorry it is 2016 now mwahawhaw 😂😋😐😐🤔😑😮😌🙁
0 likeswhoooooo
0 likeswhat's earth
0 likes2015?????????????????????????? im watching this in 2020
0 likesHi I'm apple jack more pie plz
0 likesdo you have an instagram
0 likesMmmmmmmmmmmm haa
0 likes2020?
0 likes2020?
0 likes2020?
0 likesUm....sawtooth its 2021
0 likesReplies (1)
no silly, it's 2022!!
0 likes2021
0 likesWhy are we talking about this it doesnt matter
0 likeswhen is were birth day
0 likesUmm who's els is waching this on messed up 2020
0 likes2018
0 likes🙋🏼👭👨👧👦👩👩👦👦
0 likesWhat is vV?&vV
0 likes2018
0 likes2018
0 likesI'm in 2198
0 likesstupid it just it's just a hundred nights
0 likesPresuming 12 months in an Equestrian year, a moon could be measured by each individual phase. So given 12 months and 8 phases, a moon would be approximately 1.5 months by our time.
1 likeThus 30 moons would be 45 months. Or 3.75 years, which lines up perfectly with the number of times Sunset is stated to have won the crown, and the fact that she was running for the next election when Twi showed up.
100 moons would then be about 12.5 years. This however brings a seeming inconsistency in the form of Applebloom's apparent non-growth between reunions.
Taking into account equine biology we know that the majority of their growth occurs in the first 2-3 years and afterwards further growth is minimal if at all. Assuming a similar growth pattern for Equestrian ponies we could then conclude that Applebloom was fairly young in the first picture and although not much changed in the second had still aged appropriately.
(Perhaps final growth stages only occur after the acquisition of a Cutie Mark? Could Applebloom already be fully grown by our standards? Maybe Equestrian ponies are taller than our ponies due to magical butt-tattoo induced growth-spurts? We may never know, but we can always guess.)
Also, since Meghan McCarthy stated that Friendship Games came 6 moons after Rainbow Rocks this system would place it about 9 months later. That would make them Seniors in their last year, which fits Twilight planning her future academia.
well, there have been two apple family reunions that we know of. The summer sun celebration is held once a year. We have also seen two of those. The first reunion was the day before the celebration in the pilot episode. The next reunion was some time before the celebration.
0 likesThis leaves two possibilities:
1) the apple family has a reunion 'just about' every one hundred moons. Basically it is around the same time each year, and an Equestrian year is probably 100 moons.
2) the apple family has a reunion exactly every one hundred moons. An Equestrian year is slightly longer than 100 moons since the dates don't coincide exactly and the apple family meets slightly more than once a year (meaning every now and then they meet twice a year).
#1 seems the most likely.
I'm guessing you got your two years from the fact that The last Apple Family Reunion was the day Twilight first showed up in Ponyville, and we've seen two seasonal cycles since then? It makes sense then, that a year in Equestria would actually be equal to 50 moons, which makes sense because it's a round number and our own year is 52 weeks. The show writers have used our world as a basis for a lot of what goes on in Equestria, i.e. the location of the different cities across the continent and such. Judging by all of this I'd say it's safe to assume that one moon=one Equestrian week.
0 likesDon't forget also that in the very first episode Twilight meets a large number of the Apple family on a reunion. We know this because in Episode 4 (Applebuck Season), Twilight asked AJ about it and AJ mentioned it was just the family reunion.
0 likesSo we know 100 moons sums up the events from episode 1 and 60.
I really don't think it's only 2 years. The apple family reunion seemed like a super big thing. If it's once every two years that is way to much for all the traveling that would take place, let along way too often for the amount if work it takes to out it together. I'm not sure how often it is, but it seems a bit linger then that. Unfortunately there is certainly no way to find out. I don't take equestrian girls as canon at all. And the pictures of the apples, there is more of them that have a large jump in pony ages. So That means it is more feasible that there was something that pushed the last two closer together then normal.
0 likesIf Diamond Tiara is 16 in the show it's most likely that Applebloom is either 15 or 16 so it is possible to be 8 years(and 4 months counting extra moons) considering she could have been 8 or 7 when it was taken so it's possible to be the same as our years but I don't know if that episode was out at this time so I wouldn't blame you at all for this speculation.
0 likesthis theory also begs the question of how fast ponies age if its to be based off pictures then depending how fast they age determines how we'd view the time gap
1 likeI think that 10 moons is 1 year in equestria and here's my evidence
0 likes1. In equestria girls there is 3 photos of sunset winning the formal and its 30 moons, right? The humans would have the formal once a year.
2. In Apple family reunion there is 3-4 photos. Granny Smith would have aged about 10 years in each photo.
3.10 is a pretty easy number to have
I asked my science teacher and he says that 100 moons is 100 months, which would be like 8-10 years I think, a long time.
0 likesi would love a comparison between how much time passed in pony land and how much time passed in equestrian girl (with is more earth like) between two episodes ^^
0 likesI think that 1 moon=2 or 3 of our days because During the show, I only saw 3 major differences in moon phases, but 2 looked kinda similar so..
0 likesEquestria's moon is not lit by the sun. in season 4 episode 26 at about 4:23-4:41 Twilight is trying the raise the sun and lower the moon, and you can see that the moon's cycle doesn't correspond with where the sun is
0 likesI think its around 6 years. Applebloom is 16. Ponies from 8 - 16 generally look the same.
0 likesYeah, actually, in romanian:
1 like"Moon" translates "Luna"
"Luna" translates both "Moon" and "Month" , so yeah.
Replies (1)
And the Moon is also Called Luna
0 likesOur moon on Earth
Wait; why couldn't a moon literally be a night that shows the moon, but the night of a new moon doesn't count since the moon is no longer visible? Maybe Equestrian Years are 100 moons, but still... my point still stands.
0 likes100 moon are about 17 or 18 years. Sunset Shimmer was princess of the Fall Formal 3 years in a row. Twilight became princess on what would have been the fourth time. Baby Applejack went from baby to current age in 100 moons. So seeing as that would make her a high school senior she is 17 or 18 years old.
0 likes100 moons could be refered to as full moons which appear 12 times a year which if you do the math it would about every 8 years assuming they have 12 months like we do.
0 likesjust a thought: in the Winter-Wrap up song Rainbow Dash sings, "3 months of winter coolness.." Is moon the same as month? Does this mean that there are only 3 moons of winter in 100 moons? That surely explains why everypony is so excited about winter 'cause it's so short O_o
0 likesbased on what the show has told us 100 moons is less than a 365 days or less than a year.
0 likes3 18 It's actually possible Equestria revolves around the sun, and that Celestia is just moving Equestria and the moon. This could be caused by magic being emitted from Equestria, or something like that. shrug
0 likesdidnt applejack have a lot of members of her family when twilight first met her?,and a couple of episodes(4 or 5) later she said that they are only for their reunion!?
0 likesA moon is a month
0 likesIt means full moons which come around every month
I was thinking it could be 100 days. So 1 moon is equivalent to 1 day
0 likesI think there is a time difference between our world and the pony world because in rainbow rocks the sirens come a couple days after sunsets defeat but in the pony world there has been enough time to arrange and carry out twilights coronation and discover her castle because I don't think power craving sirens would wait that long for well powerthis or the staff had a continuity problem cough cough spike
0 likesThe First episode in the series was the last Apple Family Reunion (that we know of) so if it is the last Apple Family Reunion before the Episode Apple Family Reunion, then if we find out how many days went by then we will know how many days are in 100 Moons!
0 likesThank you for clarifying something I have been puzzling over for quite a while.
0 likesi started to read the text books today, where they talk about about the moons and stuff like taht, without explaining at all how long it is, its more than a day though,
0 likesHe got 100,000 more subs since this vid, about 10 months ago. Wow. Awesome dude
0 likesmay i ask a question you know how nightmare moon/luna was sent to the moon as a prison for 1000 years if it was 1000 years wouldnt celestia probably be dead or like granny smith?
0 likesWhen I first saw Applejack as a baby, I said aww and thought I was going to die of adorabietes
0 likesI think that either years are short or ponies live redicoulously long
0 likesOk I couldn't reply to myasthenia comment but I did some calculations and 3/10's of 365 days is 109.5 days which would mean on Earth 30 moons is 109.5 days but in Equestria which TheBronyNotion suggests has years that are twice as long 3/10's of 365 days would be 219 which = 30 moons so it is actually a big deal that Twilight got back through the portal before it closed or she would be missing from Equestria for 219 equestrian days also I have to point out as a girl who has been doing horse riding for almost 4 years I know that something that is equestrian has something to do with horses eg equestrian sports is it just a coincidence that it's called Equestria. Tell what you think. Later guys
0 likes•RedPandaProductions•
in warrior cats that would be interesting basicly in warriors 1 moon= 1 month meaning it would be 3100 days
0 likesI think there is some mistakes in the family reunion photos because as you said why would Granny Smith age so much and applebloom not age all visual wise but 30 couldn't be 3/10 of a year(I'll so the math in a moment and reply to this if possible) it seems like it's way to short for Luna and Celestia to stress about warning Twilight that she kinda has to get back coz thirty moons is a long time is obviously something they need to do because 3/10 of a year isn't that's long is it? I don't know you tell me. Later guys
0 likes•RedPandaProductions•
Moons most likely means "month", twolegs.
0 likesa moon is one month. so, it would be every 100 months
0 likesIn one of my books known as cat warriors by Erin hunter the cats uses the moon to messer the time and in the book and once a every full moon they have a gathering and the author explains that it's every month. I'm not sure if that is the same as mlp but that is my thoughts on the theory
0 likesReplies (8)
Moon=month was explained in the video.
0 likesyes I just readthat
0 likes+Spirithart
1 likeI LOVE ERIN HUNTER'S BOOKS
+Minecraft LovePlayer awesome I love them too such a great series. I can't wait until the new book comes out lol I forgot the name but who is your favourite character 😁
0 likes@Spirithart
1 likewell, i don't read that much of that book. I do love the last dogs series way more, though. You should read it if u haven't.
+Minecraft LovePlayer I do have three of them but I haven't read them yet I need to start thanks for that reminder. Ok instead of saying who is your favourite cat. I will ask who is your favourite dog lol😄
0 likes@Spirithart
0 likesprobaly Gizmo or Rocky and Max
@Minecraft LovePlayer cool cant wait to read the books :D
0 likesI thought 1 season is one year...but it is not the best theory
0 likesSo if a 100 moons a year then what is a 1000 moons is that 10 or 20 years?
0 likesHow long is a moon in real life?ABOUT A MONTH.So how long is 100 moons?100 months.I ANSWERED YOUR QUESTION
0 likesYou forgot that the very first episode of MLP:FIM that there was a apple family reunion at Applejack's.
0 likeswell, a moon is a month, because im from turkey and the moon in turkish is "ay" and also month in turkish is "ay"
0 likesAnd I think that Celestia and luna are using age spell from that episode when Trixie and twighlith were battling ^-^
0 likeshow about every time a full moon is out that's consider 1 moon
0 likesDon't forget that the last Apple family reunion was in first episode of first season.
0 likesApplebloom won't grow so much because she's around 10 right now!
0 likes100 moons= 1 Equestrian year
0 likes100 moons= 2 Earth years
100 moons= ??? equestrian days
100 moons=720 earth days
100 Moons is like 100 Nights at once Maybe
0 likesHi! I think I figured out what 100 moons are! 1 moon is 1 full lunar circle! I think...
0 likesI LOVE baby Applejack, she is so CUTE!!😍😍😍😍😍
0 likes"Im appa jack, more apple bwittle?"
0 likesOMFG so cute!!! 😍😙
You know, if Equestria wasn't fake, the probably wouldn't use the base 10 numeric systems. Maybe you should dig into that. Check out numberphile's video on this topic.
0 likesYay I got my little pony merchandise for Christmas! :D im a young 9 year old brony
0 likesI always thought they measured months..
0 likesthat makes since because we celebrated the second nightmare night in equestria when its been about 4 years since the Luna reformed nightmare night episode idk but its a good theory
0 likeshow long does the moon go in the Summer Sun celebration cuz the Sun and Moon were up at the same time?
0 likesWait so if 100 moons is only 1 year, and princess luna was sent away from 100 moons (from what I remember) then why 100 like being grounded for a year is not enough time for twilight to be born n stuff it's confusing isn't it
0 likes"Equestria is not Earth"
1 like"You don't say?"
XD That face!
OMG BABY APPLEJACK EVEN SOUNDS ADORABLE
0 likes3 reasons why the photos have a big gap
0 likes1 broken camera
2 no ponies
3 burnt photo album
wat do you think of these answers
but how she control the sun if it was a place?
0 likesI personally think every moon is one month and it's just a cartoon so we don't know their lunar cycle and they aren't even in earth so how do we know
0 likesthe theory doesn't really make sense as in the first episode the apples had a reunion and then later in the apple family reunion comes and it really doent add up...
0 likesThe first episode was an apple reunion and then there was the next after that
0 likesomg! I LOVE the picture of smoosh in another dimention!!! :3
0 likesI think 30 moons is 2.5 years
0 likesOne hundred moons are a year BECAUSE if the apple family has their reunion every one hundred moons then basicallly each season is a year and they have it I forgot which season they had it in but the next season they had another one
0 likesomg the baby applejack killed me with cuteness it was so cute cute is not enough all I could say about baby applejack is DAW I'm going to die of cuteness please call a ambulance
0 likesmaybe every full moon is one moon
0 likesMaybe it's actually 100 moons
0 likesAm I the only one who thought that 30 moons was 30 days when they said that in mlp eg
0 likes100 moons is 100 months! Also the beginning i heard " how long is 100 FRIEEEEEND"xD
0 likescutest thing ever
0 likesmoons might be days like this 100 moons 100 days not to long so apple family reunion is 100 days not long and in equstria girls they are being dramatic and well you saw how long it takes a villan to destroy equstria.... and that must be it
0 likesevery hallaween in equestria theres a full moon so that means it is 100 years-♡♥☆★♡♥☆★□■◇◆°•
0 likesBaby Applejack looks so cute
0 likes"This is my first video in 2015" watching in 2016 .....
0 likesApple Jack is so cute I'm gonna die!!!
0 likesIt's probably 1 moon = full moon
0 likesApple Jack is cute when she is like a baby aw!
0 likesIf 20000 is so big,then that means 124000 is gargantuan
0 likes4 years on earth is 1 year in Equestria
0 likes30 moon's in Equestria would 15 in the human world
0 likes100 MOONS IS 100 MONTHS MOONS=MONTHS
0 likesWhat episode has the little Applejack? I need to watch!
0 likesReplies (1)
Apple family reunion season 3 episode 9
0 likeshe is wearing party hat from BOTO in this episode
0 likes100 moons = 100 months.
0 likesI just realized something, why are all members of the apple family earth ponies?
0 likesI go with 100 moons=one year
0 likesmoons= every full moon
0 likesIn Warrior Cats, a moon is a month.
0 likesReplies (1)
+Jazzy Legend Well, if Equestria is NOT earth, it can't be like in Warrior Cats, because the Clans are living on the earth and NOT in Equestria
0 likesMy theory is 1 moon= 1 month
0 likesI think it would. be years. months and days aren t that long
0 likesIn equestria girls rainbow rocks when they hav the sleepover there is a crescent moon so i think when luna says 30 moons she means every 30 full moons so twilight would of got stuck there for 15 years!!!! Well that's my theory x
0 likesReplies (1)
I don't think that's how long 30 full moons is...
0 likesThis was uploaded on my brothers birthday :3
0 likes8 years,4 months.
0 likesmlp earth dose not move or obit it stands still and Luna and Cunlister move the sun and moon so the earth does not at all this is my theory to you brony notion
0 likes100 MOONS ARE..............................100........................DAYS
0 likes12 moons = 1 year
0 likesCan't you ask people who is a expert on mlp
0 likes1:42 Dawn XD so cute
0 likesBABY APPLE JACK IS SO CUTE
0 likesDAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAW! ZO KYUT! DAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAW! ZO KYUT!
1 likeApple jack isn't an adult. she's an young adult.
0 likes100 moons=1 year
0 likes+Brony Notion
0 likesmaybe the summer sun celebratsion is equestrias new year like our 1st january
Why is princess Lunas hair diffrent when the mane six defeet her. her hair is flowing now but when they defeet her her hair was normal.
0 likesmaybe 100 moons is 100 days
0 likesi think its like half moon, full moon cycle, this would mean 30 months.
0 likesThis is the first YouTube video I have watch in 2016
0 likesNO NOT THE MOLESTER MOON!
0 likesI love baby Apple jack!!!!!!
0 likesI agree with brony
0 likes(baby apple jack) I'm baby apple jack. can I have more apple fritter?
0 likes(me) dawwwwww...
Warriors just warriors (cats) 1 moon is 1 month
0 likesone day in mlp is 1 yr in earth
0 likesPlease make a video oh and also happy 2016!!!
0 likes78 people hate baby Applejack:(
0 likes78 people hate baby Applejack:(
0 likesA moon is one year
0 likes1 moon = 1 month
0 likesI just got an add for a pinkie pie party popper batteries not included and it looks very wired
0 likesAnd like my other comment if you thought you where going to die from Applejack being a baby or a least over whelmed with adorableness
0 likesi also think that the animators do a thing the thing is the make you focus on stuff happening and the never bother to put in details and babs was met that year an 2 years back is well not in time!
0 likesLooks at title for this video "100 months bro" like if you know what im talking about
0 likesgreat info
0 likes'20,000 subscribers'.... now has 134,000 subscribers....
0 likesI can guess it! ummm 9 month's?
0 likesHey why did Brony Notion flash a picture of Molester Moon? I DON'T HAVE A PHONE SO HE CAN'T SEND ME MOLESTER MOON 3 TIMES! I'M SAFE! HECK YEAH!
0 likesdude 200,00 is big
0 likesnow who cares about 2015 ITS 2016 YEAAAAAAAAA!!!!
0 likesReplies (1)
+Adrian Corona lol
0 likesa moon is a month
0 likesa moon is a month
0 likesMmm good!
0 likesI think you should stop searching for logic.
0 likescool video
0 likesno no no 30 moons is 1 mounth
0 likesthey have 30 days is 30 moons
0 likesI'm I watching this video too early?
0 likesapple jack : im apple jack .....! More apple frodawl?
1 likeReplies (1)
SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO CUUUUUUUUUUUUUUTTTTTTTTTEEEEEEEEEEE yes more apple friders
0 likes100 years
0 likesSo Kool :p
0 likesit men's how foll moons that are
0 likesyou look like your wearing the Club Penguin beta hat... look it up
0 likesin the first eoisode twilight arrive at a apple family reunion
0 likesThat to cute
0 likes100 is good
0 likesa handred moons a handred yers
0 likes2 DAYS AND I LIKE BABY APPLEJ
0 likesThe sun orbits equstia
0 likes10 years
0 likesYOU KNOW BOTO ?!?
0 likesI love the way you put the baby applejack vid in 💖💖💖💖💖💖hay im applejack😇😇😇😇😇😇
0 likesYour explanation for things are sooooo confusing....I DONT GET IT(LOL)
0 likesOh geez... Math...
0 likesI don't get wants up with the episode nightmare night and the first episode why does everybody think Luna is still nightmare moon even pinkie and she was there when they turned nightmare moon back to luna
0 likesequestia is not a world because pinkypie leaves equestria in season 5
0 likesTry everrything to discord to 30 moon to the beard pony whatever and so on try everything together
0 likesi want to see more changeling you
0 likeslook at his hat then go to boto
0 likesto much MATH
0 likesWhat if celestia doesn't raise the sun but moves the planet /(•o•)\
0 likes/ \
Replies (5)
+Nathan Wright I had a theory but it was destroyed by "Twilight's Kingdom".
0 likes+Nathan Wright my brain just exploded.
0 likes+dontrequest what was the theory out of curiosity?
0 likes@Nathan Wright
0 likesWell, that it is only making a legend and demontrating power, but would run without them as well.
+Nathan Wright Maybe the moon can't orbit on its own which is why it needs someone to move it?
0 likesI am a new subscriber yay
0 likesHmmmm hmmmm hmmm huh I GOT NOTHING! sorry brony notion
0 likeswho else is watching in 2016
0 likesBRO HOVE!
0 likesit is 99 days
0 likes1 year I think
0 likes02.17 what happen to luna's hairstyle????? ?????
0 likes3 months?
0 likesYou ruined my fimfics.
0 likesIs granny smith going to die
0 likeshi the brony notion well I know ur probs not gonna read this comment but how old could be the four princesses and the main six? in episode 26 and 25 seanson 5 small rainbow dash says twilight a full grown pony but how come the other alicorns are bigger and taller than her????????????? even tho ur probs not gonna read this well if u do u should DEFFERENTLY make a vid!!
0 likesReplies (2)
The mane 6 are around 17-18 and twilight would probs be 19-20 now and Celestial and Luna are over 1000 years old and Cadence is, well, I dunno
0 likes+Heated Small kids Rainbow Dash's age like to over exaggerate ages of anyone who is even a little bit older then they are. They think 20 to 30 year old's are ancient. Just my thought on the matter. :D
0 likesmore Apple fwiter
0 likesomigosh club penguin beta hattt!!
0 likesIt is 2016
0 likesMoon is month
0 likesEVERYONE WHO WANTS TO KNOW THE ANSWER DOWNLOUD THE WARRIOR CATS APP IN UR IPAD THEN GO TO THE GLOSSARY BOOM
0 likesComment if you watch this in 2016
0 likeswho watch this in 2016
0 likeswho seeing this on 2016
0 likesReplies (1)
+Rexy the Trex jurassic world me
0 likes20,000 20,000
0 likesIt is an anamation error
0 likesWear I live they kol it a Mon is a month 😊
0 likesIm sorry WUT? PS you need to check out this fnaf vid called balloons its AWESOME (: (; KK signing off
0 likesIt's aj dad
0 likesim my little dashie theh said 15 days in equstria is 15 years in our wprld
0 likesI'm confused egg head
0 likesReplies (1)
I'm replying on my own decision
0 likesHayyy.. Ya lost me..
0 likesin equestria is not earth maybie the days are longer
0 likesA year
0 likesit is2016
0 likes.........................what
0 likesstupid math!!!!!kl
0 likesI am confused
0 likesReplies (1)
Angel Gomes why
0 likes2018?
0 likes2019
0 likesit 2016
0 likesjan 1-7
0 likes2020?
0 likesYou're forgetting that YEARS aren't just measured by solar position. It's also measured by seasons. And we know Equestria goes through the Summer-Autumn-Winter-Spring cycle. One full set of seasons (manually changed) is one year.
0 likesMajority of episodes seem to take place during the Spring/Summer days though unless there's some plot specific need for it to be Autumn or Winter.
I have a theory that expands yours: the family bash seen in Episode 1 was a reunion based on the fact that the Summer Sunrise was celebrated in Ponyville. It wasn't one of the "100 moons" reunions, but they were still together and so took a photo in front of the barn. It'd explain why Applebloom is already as old as she is and why the other photos have more time passing in between them. That would make the 1 moon = 1 month theory plausible again.
0 likesMoons are also used in warriors. Six moons to become an apprentice from a kit (kitten) and every full moon is a gathering (all four clans meet at the island (current) or fourtrees (past) and every courter moon is the medicane cat meeting at the moolpool (current) or moonstone (past) Any way, I dunno I just wanted to point that out.
0 likesCould you do a theory on how old Granny Smith is? In the beginning of the episode Winter Wrap Up, Twilight states, that for centuries the ponies of Ponyville didn't use magic to bring spring. And Granny Smith was the one who essencaly founded Ponyville. I think it might just be a little mix up in the script but I think it's an interesting thing to think about.
0 likesI have a different theory: Pony mathematics is actually base 4.
0 likesThink about it. 10 isn't exactly a very good base for mathematics, 12 or 16 would be better, but we use base 10, because we have 10 fingers. Ponies don't have fingers, but they have 4 hooves, so it is reasonable to assume their math is base 4.
Now I know what you are thinking, they are constantly talking about the "Six Elements of Harmony".
But we are not saying "Oneteen and twoteen", we say "Eleven and Twelve", so we can assume the first twelve pony numbers have individual names too. They count ...ten, eleven, twelve, thirty one, thirty two, thirty three, one hundred...
That means 100 pony moons would be 16 human moons.
And while I am at it, this also explains how Granny Smith was already alive when Ponyville was founded hundreds of years ago.
In other merchandise, I've seen the term "One moon" meaning a month, aswell as a "Half moon" meaning 2 weeks, and a "Quater Moon" meaning a week. So for now, I guess this is what I'll believe. Although it does bring up questions.. So confusing! D: Great vid tho :3
0 likesI think every 5 moons is 2 months in our time, so every 100 moons is every 20 years in our time, but Apple Bloom's ageing would be off the grid and not make scents. Perhaps Doctor Whoves went forward in time and grabbed this aged Apple Bloom and want back and swapped Apple Blooms?
0 likesif you read "warriors" you will know that a moon is a month.
0 likesAlso, i think that maybe your right. this was a very well put together theory, and i know this is an old video and im referencing a newer one, but in "is the dream world real?" you talked about dimensions. does earth have dimensions to? that could be likely, as ive always thought there were some connections from video games to our world. that could easily be a dimension, who says it cant be the same with us to equestria? here is the video game line:
Legend of Zelda OOT- Super Mario- Mike Tyson's Punch Out- Our world
In legend of zelda ocarina of time in the castle garden were you first meat zelda, you can look in windows to see pictures of Mario characters. Mario connects to Mike Tyson's punch out because in Mike Tyson's Punch out, the refery looks so much like Mario that people on line actually call him Mario. Mike Tyson's punch out connects to us because.. well.. its Mike Tyson.
Who says this can't be the same for equestria? maybe equestria is a dimension on earth, and we can get there by.. idk... geneticly mutating horses to look like twilight and become unicorns? we have the technoligy. anyways, i haven't found any links to our world, but what am i saying? im not a reveiwer. i watch this stuff for fun.
3:40
0 likesDidn't Twilight say in the very first episode that NMM would escape on the 1000th day of the 1000th year? That would mean that an Equestrian year would have to be more around the length of three Earth years.
I'm guessing 100 moons is 100 months. Let's see how that could be true. 100 years is way too long, because as brony notion said Luna told Twilight that on the third day of the vist, the portal will close, making Twilight wait 30 moons. But 30 days could also work.
0 likesTanks for the Memories confirmed that the events from season 1 to season 5 have taken place in the span of a year. So 100 moons has to be less then a year considering that the Apple Family had a reunion in the very first episode of Friendship is Magic. They also had a second reunion in Season 3
0 likesThe last apple family reunion actually happened in the pilot episodes of mlp. In the episode: Applebuck Season, Twilight asks, "What about all those relatives I've met when I first came to Ponyville? Can't they help?" And Applejack promptly replies, "They were just here for the Apple family reunion. They actually live all over Equestria and are busy harvestin' their own orchards. So, uh, I'm on my own." This means a reunion can't happen every 2 years or even every year because the apple family reunion happened in season 3 and it wasn't until season 4 episode 1 when a whole year had passed since the first episode of season 1. In season 4 Celestia says, "For this celebration now represents not the defeat of Nightmare Moon, but the return of my sister, Princess Luna." Which I think she would only say the year after the last summer sun celebration.
0 likesAccording to Erin Hunter, the author of the Warriors series, a moon is a month, half moon 2 weeks and a quarter moon is 1 week. However its quite noticeable that MLP is not the Warriors series.
0 likesTo the target audience, time is: Wake up, go to school, recess, lunch, school's out, go to sleep, weekend, summer. The show doesn't focus on explaining time even though it is important to the characters in some way. It may just be left as a hole in the plot. Try explaining the use of time in the Star Wars universe.
0 likesThe equestrian sun doesn't really have to orbit Equestria, it could be that the planet doesn't spin, and the princess grabs the sun with her magic to move Equestria.
0 likesHere's what I think. With the Applebloom and 8 years part- the animators got lazy. Also, Equestria is a representation of America, not Earth. We have Saddle Arabia (Saudi Arabia) and YakYakistan (Pakistan). In Equestria, we've got Manehattan, and other city cameos. Equestria itself is a cameo if America. They even sound similar.
0 likesWell, in one month the moon has 8 cycles. If it's 30 moons wouldn't it be 3 month. So if it's 100 moons wouldn't it be 10 months?
0 likesI'm not sure that the reunion is every two years since all of seasons 1-4 all take place in one year (first episode Summer Sun Celebration, S4E1 Summer Sun Celebration). I think they all take place around once a year, but it probably took a while for a system to be made up. The Apple family started out to be very small, but they probably made up an exact time for it when it started to get larger and fan out across Equestria. And for some they couldn't have taken pictures for them. We never saw a group photo that included baby AJ, even though we saw a flashback of her.
0 likesI'm confused. If the the apple family reunion happens every 2 years and there was a reunion in the Season 1 premiere, does that mean 2 years passed in between the series premiere and the episode "Apple family reunion?" That doesn't make sense because the Season 4 premiere seems to take place only 1 year after the Season 1 premiere because Celestia implies that it's the first summer sun celebration since Nightmare moon's transformation back into Princess Luna.
0 likesA "moon", I think, represents a full moon, basically saying a month
0 likesWhat if the moons were like the names of monthly moons on our planet? Like the flower moon, the wolf moon, etc.
0 likes3:40 I FOUND A CONTRADICTION! "An equestrian year is twice as long as ours." Yet on the screen it says 2 equestrian years = One earth year. Wouldn't that make an equestrian year half an earth year?
0 likesI think that hasbro made the moons just to sound more fantasy like, i mean a tv show wouldnt spend loads of time figuring out a new version of time
0 likespersonally i think a hundred moons is 3 or 4 years!
But Discord is 1000 moons old meaning he is about 100 years old. In the show he states the the ponies are the most fun he's had in eons so I think that kind of messes up your theories. Sorry.
0 likesMy question: Why does the sun and moon need to be MANUALLY moved? Shouldn't gravity take care of it? Is Equestria even in a solar system?
0 likesWell, in my Warriors books, one moon is a month, so I went off of that for this.
0 likesAccording to The Journal of the Two Sisters, Dash turned 10 years old on her birthday. Just thought it'd be helpful information since I haven't seen anyone point it out yet.
0 likesI think 100 years is the equivalent amount to 6 years in equestria. I think this cuz, at time 2:52, The Brony Notion shows 2 photos of Granny Smith side by side. The first photo looked like she was 6, and the second pic looked like she was 12. Therefore, I believe there was 6 yrs in between the family reunions. This isn't as detailed and has a bunch of facts supporting this theory, but it's mine ok so plz don't hate on this and get all technical.
0 likesThnx😇
I think a moon is a month because if our moon changes all of its phases every month maybe the equestrian moon works the same
0 likesIf an Equestrian year is two of our years, that would mean that Rainbow Dash's 10th birthdayversary was her really her 20th birthdayversary. Assuming that ordinary ponies age at the same rate as us and they usually get their cutie marks between the ages of eight and 12 in our years and Rainbow moved to Ponyville after she got her cutie mark, that would make all of the Mane 6 at least 28 in our years. That's ridiculous. And look at how much time has passed in the show! I think that, in the show, it's been between one and two years since the first episode (things just aren't in the right order). Any more is ridiculous since the CMC are already late getting their cutie marks.
0 likesI just discovered something when I saw the pictures of the apple family reunion Granny Smith was smaller than when we saw in the story of family apreciasion, if you still don't understand, read this to explain better: when we hear the story of Granny smith, we can see that her family was one that founded ponyville but she looked as Applejack's age, but in the first picture that they're building the barn, she looked smaller than in the story, but when we see the next picture this as in history
0 likesI always thought that 1 moon was just one day. But I think ur theory is a good explanation.
0 likesI like to use the fact that each day is 20 minutes long but that got confusing. And because of the fact solving a friendship problem takes 20 minutes as established in Slice of life I figure the minutes of Equestria and Earth could be equal. So I officially give up.
0 likesAs in warrior cats, I would like to say a month.
0 likesAlso, a moon would mean full moon. do the math.
This brings a question to my mind (which oddly enough does not involve this video) who's AJ's parents? Is GS her Grandma from AJ's dam's side or sire's? This would totally make an interesting video! :)
0 likesReplies (1)
I never saw AJ's parents, but I don't saw every episode. I think they are dead or something, but I want the question answered where they are or what happend to them. I hope we will see it in an episode.
1 likeLittle Applejack made me lose it and I kept replaying that part of the episode xD
0 likesFor warriors fans after analysis it is decided that a moon=a month, and ponies age quicker than humans, unless ponie logic doesn't work that way. This is before watching the video
0 likesodd thing to say is in "its about time" twilight holds up a calendar with only and if i remember correctly it only had 15 days also in the first episode there is a reunion going on
0 likesI'm gonna guess 2 years. Why? because in Applebuck season, she said the family had a family reunion, so they were only there for a little period of time. Also, Apple family reunion came out almost two years after Applebuck season. But then again, it's a show that could take place at any time.... so.... :P.
0 likesI actually think they had more reunions, but they only showed the prominent ones.
0 likesWell in Warrior Cats a moon means a month so maybe that's what it means in the pony world too.
0 likesWas I the only one who kept replaying the Applejack part? Its so CUTEEE! :D
0 likesIf a 100 moons = 2 years to the apple family then how does it then equal 1 year(you said this later in the video after your first statement). You stated 2 completley different ideas in 2 minutes please explain if I missed something or he just screwed up his script..
0 likesJust a thought your videos are great don't stop.
It's just like if you add up from the first episode of twilight moving to ponievill on the rising of sun till the next time it happens in season 4 that has to be a year and if we say every episode is what happens in a day then that would make it 66 days or round about there when you count the first movie in a year.
0 likes"Im applejack more apple fritter?" I DIED.... CUTENESS OVERLOAD
0 likesYou literally just disproved your own theory, if the apple reunion is every two years and 100 moons as Granny Smith said, How can 100 moons be a year?
0 likeswell eg (eqeustria girls) takes place after season 3 due to her trying to get used to her new wings and rr (rainbow rocks) takes place after season 4 so is that 30 moons?
0 likesI have a belief that in Equestria, things don't actually work like they do in ours. Like, at all. The land that Equestria rests upon may not be a planet, it may literally be flat. Yes, I do realize our world doesn't work that way, but Equestria is in a completely different universe, so it shouldn't be too much of a stretch for the Sun and Moon to be moved by the two main Princesses. Expanding upon that, it is entirely possible that the Sun and Moon in the MLP universe aren't as massive as they are in ours, and that while the sisters' power may be great, it isn't THAT powerful.
2 likesReplies (3)
Makes sense.
1 like(pinky pie) thats what i was gonna say!
0 likes(pinky pie) thats what i was gonna say!
0 likesI think it could mean 1 moon is a full moon or a month...
0 likesThis is a pretty sound theory. Nice job.
0 likesIn equestria girls luna says twilight would be stuck there for 30 moons so maybe 1 moon is 1 day and 30 moons is about 1 month
0 likesmaybe "a moon" has nothing to do with the moon? like how ballrooms have nothing to balls
0 likesI thought that a moon was a day, like you could, not go throught the portal for a month, for in rainbow rocks it is shown that it was not a long time since twilight's first vist the the other world, for season four was not a full year in equestria, at least of what we know.
0 likeswow! that was amazing I love how you talk about cutie marks and bla bla bla but anyway keep making these great videos please (new watcher qistyna adam chia's dauther )
0 likesWait, first you said the reunion is once every 100 moons and that's two years, then you said 100 moons is one year
0 likeswait wait wait!
0 likesthere was an apple reunion on the very day that twilight came to ponyville.
the very next one was in season three... a few episodes before twilight became an alicorn.
so twilight has only been living in ponyville for one year?
she did a lot of stuff in only one year time!!
If thats true.. 1000moons (the amount of time luna was imprisoned in the moon) would be only 10 years... why would everyone in ponyvill forget about Luna? You theory has been debunked i think.
0 likesi think 100 moons is 10 months... bc i just finished watching arthur and the invisibles, and acxording to the movie, 10 moons is 1 month... (not saying that anyone is dumb or anything...) 10x10=100. 😋
0 likesWhat if Apple bloom will grow in season 6. I agree with 2 Years.
0 likes100 is moons could possibly be 100 years, but ponies in equestria dont age like us. After all Celestia is 1000 moons old right? She seems pretty young too, showing that 100 years for them, is still 100 years, but they have a longer life to live, because, they are part of a tv show and they are unicorns and pegasus's XD And earth, but they all talk o3o
0 likesI don't know. I think the planet spins. and the sun and moon just sit still verticle and they littarally just raise them.
0 likesmoons is like, every full moon, like in warrior cats they have a gathering every moon, which means full moon
0 likesMaybe for example if two days pass and two nights pass each night would count as a moon or every full moon
0 likesBut... That can't be right... It hasn't been a full year since the Season 1 premier... What?
0 likescelestia and luna: well luna dont move the moon i think she moves there earth what ever they call there earth, celestia moves the earth on morning up and luna moves the earth down at night.. i know it seans crazy but i think that is how it works
0 likesduh a moon is a month, considering every full moon in warriors (A book series) is a month and they call it a moon
0 likes100 MOONS! Maybe it means that it is 100 full moons? So that also explains why no one really ages but the barn does?????
0 likesto sum it all up (from what info I have gathered here today) Equestria time is half our time.
0 likeswhy not simply ask one of the people who make My Little Pony? they need to know.
0 likesThis was made before my dads b-day:-)
0 likes1:42 was my exact reaction CUTENESS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
0 likesAh-... I forgot where I was gonna go with this... Nevermind
0 likesOK. Here's my theory. Luna and celestial don't have a plan, why would they? Honestly if they had a plan then y would the moon always stay the same? If I'm correct 100 moons could just be 100 days. But u r right, equestria is not earth. Maybe 100 moons is 1 year? We know that we rarely have a different sized filly or mare so it is possible granny smith just was becoming a made and so her size was changing. This theory has lots of loop holes but wut if its correct?
0 likesHere is a question ! How come Granny smith isn't a horse if she's already old ?
0 likes1 moon = 1 month.. 100 moons = 100 months :/
0 likesA moon means a month in warrior cats :3
0 likesWell done The Brony Notion
0 likesI think i know what a hungred moons IS I think its hungred years
0 likes100 moons would be about maybe 5 or 6 years? Idk nut Warrior Cat time to me XD
0 likes20 moons + 20 moons + 20 moons + 20 moons + 20 moons = 100 moons
0 likes100 moons = 1 year
they have 5 months in one year
there are 4 weeks in a month
and 5 days in a week
any questions?
Replies (1)
@name less dont bother
0 likesive found multiple errors in my theroy
Brony notion can you do a theory about luna here's my answer if She raises the stars and the moon and the sun is one big star why doesn't raise that?
0 likesDoesn't moon equal close to a month?
0 likesIn my languange we use the same word moon and month (Měsíc), so i thing 10 moons are 10 months.
0 likes1:42 too cute!!!
0 likes100 moons is 100 years!
0 likesI think 1 moon is 1 month Because in Turkey we say ay (it's reading like i) to both them.
0 likesOh cmon u haven't figured it out by now?! I ALREADY DID IN LIKE A FEW MINS.1 MOON=1 MONTH!
0 likes100 moons are 8 years and that is all and i think that no pony came after the 2nd meeting and after 16 they meet again
0 likesReplies (1)
1 moons is 29.5 days
0 likesA moon is a full moon, so every month
0 likes"Equestria is not Earth" YOU DON'T SAY
2 likesReplies (1)
XD
0 likesThis was made on my birthday :3
0 likesactually 50 moons = 1 year
0 likes30 moons 300days 50moons 500 and 100moons 1000 days and 10 monts
0 likesI think that it means 100 full moons
0 likesI have considered a moon equals a day, but I may be wrong. Tell me what you think.
0 likes1:37-1:42 I died from ECD (Eternal Cutified Disorder)
0 likesYou could have just read the Warrior Cats series and not have to go through the trouble of editing a video.
0 likesIsn't a moon like... 3. Something something months?
0 likes1:38-1:42 So cute! D'aww!
0 likesSo you can only tell the time at night?
0 likesEver heard of native people you know like cree here's a word tansi :translation: hello every moon is like a month maybe it was like this maybe Lauren Faust was cree?
0 likesMLP generations = 100 moons (in mlp world) Because Summer Sun Celebration is coming in 100 moons. Fillies body is like G3.5 ponies
0 likesI can't help notice how your back legs keep getting larger, and then skinner, it bugs me... ;-;
0 likesSo 100 moons is about 10 years wow that's so cool thanks a lot I got to thing about this hand a cookie to everyone here take these
0 likesshe rises the moon every single night* not day
0 likesOf course Equestria isn't earth. There's two whole movies about going to a different world without the same magic and as humans where as in Equestria they are magical skittle colored ponies with wings and horns that make magic. I won't go on unless you want me to continue this.
0 likesParty Hat Asset from BOTO FTW!
0 likesBut…But… Yep I'm speechless
0 likesmaybe when ponies say moons like in equestria girls when they say 30 moons maybe they mean 30 FULL moons
0 likesI thought 100 moons means 100 days
0 likesWhy is The Brony Notion's cutie mark is a pixelated musical note? Huh... Korean ppl use the lunar chart so New Year is in April!
0 likesI stumbled on your channel and wached all your videos and cant wait. Till you post new ones
0 likesthat's a very extra long long long time to be stir in a defrent world!!!!!!!!!
0 likesLook at the pic of the real moon
0 likesIt looks like NM is on it
Wait...
NM on are moon means that Mlp could have exited long ago and we used to be ponies and radiation turned us to humans as magic faded away forever!!!!!????!!! 😧
Didnt the same time pass in equestria then the time that canterlot high because if I recall they have the same time. Twilight said she should be gone for 2 days and when she arrived they knew it had been 2 days so that means that the time in equestria is the same in canterlot high
0 likesSince I read warrior cats 30 moons should mean 30 months but this isn't warriors though.
0 likesEquestria IS Earth. RLYoshi made a video about it... so that would make time really weird.
0 likesA little before 2:18 but I remeber a pony saying 'what on earth is going on ' so.......can someone please explain that I'm confused now
0 likesa 100 moons is a 100 months moons was the old fashioned why of saying month
0 likesOn my iPod sometimes after a video it keeps on going and extends the time of the video, happen to anyone else?
0 likesA 100 moons = 100 Months
0 likesWait.....WHAT ABOUT THE FIRST EPISODE?!
0 likesi think 100 moons is the 100th time u see the moon
0 likesbaby applejack is so cute.
0 likes1+1=2+2=4+4=8+8=16+16=32+32=64+64=128+128=256+256=512+512=1,024. So i think its 1,024
0 likesJust an opinion. 😅😓😅😓
Can you do a video with ink rose maybe even you could do another one with cc I would like that alot
0 likesI think a moon is new and full moon
0 likesA moon = a month
0 likesgreat idea but........ in the episode the Wonderbolt Academy applejack says to pinkie pie " rainbow dash hasn't even been gone for 24 hours give some time to settle in first" so..............
0 likesGood video!
0 likesthan how long was luna on the moon ?
0 likesI KNEW IT 100 YEAR BOOO YAH!!!!!
0 likesThis answer so much thank you
0 likesBaby applejack is... so.... CUUUUUUUUUUUTE!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesA moon is a month #spoileralert
0 likesThen Why Did Rainbowdash Have 41 B-Day Candles
0 likesI KNOW ok you see I found out that one day in equstrea it a year in real life so if you compare about 30 years is 1 moon so it would be a long long time you'll have to take my word for it if you dont want to get confused.
0 likesscrew years, screw life, screw 2015, screw everything
1 likeReplies (2)
You a grumpy cat LOL
0 likes+Ali Mari
0 likesScrew MLP? D:
or Apple bloom wasn't growing fast
0 likesOR your just looking to much into a lil girl show.
0 likesAh the math...
0 likesI watcht something.. it was about rainbow dash in the real world.. in equestria she was an older.. in the real world she was a filly.. someone was taking care of her.. she grew up in 15 years in the real world.. but when the mane six pick her up and the person that was taking care of her ask: how long was she gone.. celestia awnserd 15 days.. so 1 year in the normal world is 1 day in equestria
0 likesMabe 1 moon = to 1 full moon
0 likesI agree with Shela Nguyen
0 likesmaybe it is a different world that has not been found yet
0 likes100moons is a year
0 likesNow you've hit 64,774 subscribers WOOHOO
0 likesI didn't pay attention in science class so I got only have of wut u were saying about the moon.
0 likesPARTY HAT FROM BRAWL OF THE OBJECTS!!!
0 likesThis is posted after my birthday!
0 likesJanuary 6
U R a genius !
0 likes1:40 D'aaawww meter went boom
0 likesYou uploaded this on ma b day <3
0 likesYes equestria is not earth but is in earth and in TV!
0 likesBABY APPLEJACK: I'm Appojack! Mow appa fittews?
0 likesI thinking that a full moon = 1 pony moon
0 likesa moon is a month
0 likesit's molster moon
0 likesAND A HAPPY NEW YEAR!!!!!! jk! It's in the middle of april...I think
0 likesWe could guess-timate. Ok.
0 likesBrony Notion have u even READ Warriors???????
0 likesSee one of the guides I can't remember which one.Anywho... Moons are months!!!!!!!!😐😐😐😐😐
.....my brain hurts
0 likesOMG YOU HAD MOLESTER MOON IN THE VIDEO...Okay.
0 likesi think a moon is a month. sooo 100 moons is like.., a century???
0 likesReplies (3)
@Pink Unicorns Im bad at math lol
0 likesIf you are right it would be each 8.3 years
0 likes@Little Flower i think thats good timing.
0 likesawww baby apple jack
0 likesIt's easy only 30 days
0 likesmoon = day
0 likes8.33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333(it just keeps going) years
0 likes100 Moons is 8 yrs and 4 months
0 likesReplies (1)
that is way… too long... look at applebloom..
0 likesEquestria is not earth. So what do they call there "world" then hu?
0 likesits over 90000 over 90000 uh 90000
0 likes100 months
0 likesI subscribed
0 likesLol my birthday was on January 1st
0 likes:I so much math!!!!!!!!!
0 likesYea but its also a little kids show and not rocket science😒
0 likesmy famlie reunuion is once a year
0 likesCute applejack!!!!!!!😝😝😝😝😝
0 likesoh derp and p.s what is your fav backround charecter
0 likesWAIT BRONY NOTION DO YOU LIKE OBJECT SHOWS! BECAUSE THAT PARTY HAT IS FROM THE OBJECT SHOW BRAWL OF THE OBJECTS ON OF THE MANY OBJECT SHOWS!
0 likesWhere is equestria?
0 likesI'm also stupid at math so yah I'm only in 4th grade kk? Also I'm very sassed up
0 likesLIKE TOTALLY BABY APPLEJACK SSSSOOOO CCCUUTTEE
0 likesDon't you mean that 2000 is not real I think that you got it mixed up with 2000 comments
0 likesuhh maby i 1 moon is a full moon
0 likesWhy did he disabled the comments 😢😐
0 likesI'm gona celebrate ten subs when I get ten subs
0 likesEquestria is NOT earth. Instead over you don't say, do no shit Sherlock!
0 likesI really need help I can't comment on some YouTube videos and I don't know why. its saying comments blocked even on channels like this one. Please help.
0 likesI think a moon is actually 10 days and for one simple reason, Well 10 reasons. Those 10 are as follows : New Moon, Young Moon, Waxing Crescent, Waxing Quarter, Waxing Gibbous, Full, Waning Gibbous, Waning Quarter, Waning Crescent, Old. What are those? The 10 PHASES of a MOON.
1 likeI don't get it.😐
0 likesI'm sorry. but can u change the music cause I have asma and wen I hear I thing I'm wheezing and panic
0 likesOne month=one month
0 likesReplies (2)
Typo
0 likesOne moon=one momth
Another typo
0 likesmy name is sami
0 likesHiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!!
0 likesOkay I am a new person to help you
0 likes😛😉hi
0 likesi want to love you
0 likes+It'sTrzy yea
0 likes8126 days
0 likeswell, you still have to take in to account that the apple family grew a lot since the last reunion. Even assuming that some didn't show up for the one in the first episode, there is evidence that the family grew larger between the 2
0 likesAt 2:17 when you were talking about the sun moving and casting shadows on the moon, the sun re-positioned itself three times to get back to a full moon. Since earth years are around 300- some odd days, I predict that if there are 100 days in a pony year, you can times it by three to get 300 pony days in a year- depending on the shadows casted on the moon.
0 likesI've just come to the conclusion that a moon is is an inconsistent amount of time as Granny Smith stated that a Ponyville snail can hibernate for 48 moons, while an earth snail can sleep up to 3 years, yet 100 moons is about a year as there were Apple family reunions in the first episode and in season 3.
0 likesI always thought 2.5 years for a portal was kind of long... though now there's the question: if the length of a year was arbitrarily decided to be 100 moons, and that results in about 2 MLP years to our 1... does that mean their SEASONS are twice as long too? Because that would probably mess all KINDS of things up...
0 likesAt the end of the journal of the two sisters, when it switches to the journal of friendship, Pinkie mentions that the birth-aversary we see in Pinkie Pride is Rainbow's tenth birthday in one of her entries. This makes sense with his theory because it implies that if one Equestrian year is two earth years, Rainbow would be 20 earth years old (which is a reasonable age for her). I'm assuming the main six are all around the same age, so, in a way he just explained not only how long 100 moons would be, but also how old the main six are.
0 likesGood thought, but I think there is a way to roughly estimate the number of days (or at least weeks) in an Equestrian year. In "Lesson Zero" Twilight goes nuts trying to get her friendship letter sent by the end of the week, implying that each episode is spaces approximately a week apart, their time. In "Princess Twilight Sparkle" it is relieved that a single year has passed since Nightmare Moon. Counting out season primers and finals which don't include friendship letters, you get 55. Thats almost identical to the number of weeks in an Earth year (52.1775). This difference is well within excepted deviation, and can be attributed to a few busy weeks. Therefore, I conclude that, assuming week lengths are the same, an Equestrian year is approximately equivalent to an Earth year.
0 likesThis is a very interesting topic, after all. As seen in S2E10, we can calculate that about one human year passed between S1E01 and S2E10, given that Spike has his one year anniversary of being in Ponyville. Using this logic, we can calculate that about ten days pass between each episode. Of course this is only a rough estimate, and we can ultimately see that since Spike arrived in Ponyville on the same date that the Apple family reunion was happening (100 moons does not equal a year) and S3E8 (Apple Family Reunion) apparently equates to 100 moons from that date. Using the equation from earlier that 365 / 36 = 10.1 (which we'll round to 60), we can establish that 10 x 60 = 600 days. This means that 100 moons is about 1.65 years if my estimate is correct.
0 likesFuck this shit. There's some magic going on here.
I would have compared the episode Apple Family Reunion with the only known previous reunion: Friendship is Magic Parts 1 & 2. I then would analyze how much time passed between those two events. There are pretty good other sources for this. For example, RLYoshi has a pretty good analysis of what the correct chronological order of the Season 1 episodes is. You could have used that to figure out some stuff about the seasons in Equestria. Not sure where I would go from there, though. It still seems preferable to pulling the equation "1 year = 100 moons" (or is that a function?) out of my hat.
0 likesI'm just going to say this. I know 1 moon as a month, I know 1 moon as a few day (however long you said) So I can't really say what time length 100 pony moons is. Let's say 3 days =1 moon. So 365 days is about 121 moons. Until a leap year. If the pony world and the human world worked the same way for 3 years then a leap year, you would have 1 extra moon. So total there are just over 120 moons a year. This means over 4/5 of a year, there is an apple family reunion. Hope this doesn't sound crazy.
1 likeI would mostly go with the ancient ways of the moon faces. 1 moon = 1 month. And judging by the photos, we don't really know how old the Mane 6 are, let alone the Cutie Mark Crusaders. For all we know, Apple Bloom could have been 4 years old in the previous photo. So there's my hypothesis.
0 likesOne problem though. We know from the season 4 opener that it's only been 1 year since the season 1 opener. AJ said the Apples were having a family reunion that day, so it had been less than a year between then and the next reunion covered in Apple Family Reunion
0 likesAccording to the season 4 opener, Twilight had only been in Ponyville 1 year (if their is 1 Summer Sun Celebration each year) so 100 moons is less than the time between Summer Sun Celebrations.
0 likesThe whole 1 year equaling 100 moons may seems intuitive to us, but that is because we are human. The whole 100 thing seems easy and simple to use because our society has made our number system base 10. It is doubtful that Equestria would have a base 10 number system because their anatomy is different. humans have ten fingers and ten toes, so it makes sense for us to count in tens, but pony's don't have fingers and toes so it would make more sense for them to count in base four (four hooves) or some other base that would make sense with how younger pony's could easily learn.
0 likesyou are forgetting that in episode one when Twilight met applejack, her entire family was there. It's safe to assume that that was a family reunion. So from that episode to this one would give you your time period
0 likesThe moon cycle is actually 27 days, 7 hours and 43 minutes.
0 likeson to my theory.
Princess Luna actually believes in Lyra's theory of humans. She used a spell to transport herself and her sister to Earth and studied the moon cycle. When they travelled back, she channeled her moon cycle into that so the night could have an equal time to the day. THE END!
some one notice mei believe you are very close to the answer to this. however i believe that it's not
0 likesquiteright. i did some quick comparisons and math and came up with an eqiuestrian year as 2.83 years long. i did this by dividing the average age of old folk, to that of the average age of old horses. 85 and 30 respectively. a horse/pony reaches maturity {17-18 for humans} at age 5-6 so since granny smith is DEFIANTLY in her 80's human wise, that means that she is actually been in ponyville for 30 years. This is based in part on how old the pony human counterparts are. The human counterparts of the main six are about 17-18 and in highschool, since the ponies age at the same time but the years are different that means that an equestrian moon is actually 0.983 days AKA. one moon is 1 day. { because luna raises it every night} but years are counted the same. so 30 moons is 30 days in equestria {but the ponies age faster to keep up with the humans} so 30 moons { days} in equestria is ACTUALLY the same in the human world even though they seem different. see in fact, equestria IS earth, and ALTERNATE earth where there are only ponies.I study quantum physics... ^^;;;;;
This note/theory is before watching this video: From a fan of Erin Hunter's Warrior Cats, I had read them for three years and find out they use the term moons as of being apprenticed at 6 moons old- From going over that I finally came with the theory, Moons= Months
0 likesBut that's Warrior Cats, this is MLP FIM would they different terms? I will have to watch your theory, Brony Notion
This isn't about the moon, remember when there was a cycle of twilight, I've watched enough doctor who to know this. When Twilight and the others snuck into the castle, the guards must have seen them a resonable amount of times just didn't do anything because of celectias orders eg. Here Twilight I'll open my "secret no one aloud room of books by starswirl" said celestia. She has known twwilight for about 10 years but letting her wonder around? Celestia must have gone to the future to make twilight get her nervos overe-worried scene on then the cycle started!
0 likesThe whole equestrian year is double ours thing is a theory I use! It explains why The main six are in high school in equestria girls and in equestria (fan based) they are around 20-30
0 likesEquestria isn't a Planet, it's a Country. Where do you think the other types of ponies come from? Throughout the series some of the ponies talk about different species, an example is the Dragons. The dragons wouldn't be able to fly around the planet for a migration, only a certain area of the country.
0 likesI still hold on the 1 Moon = 1 Month formula. Why? MLP has included many references and such to various entertainment, from fantasy games like D&D (griffins, minotaurs, chimera, etc) to westerns like Gunsmoke (Pinkie Pride and The Last Roundup). Across various forms of entertainment one thing was pretty common, that they used one moon to mean one month. Why change that?
0 likesThis is really easy to answer. The ponies said thirty moons, but twilight (or some other pony) said 2 and 1/2 years. Judging by the count of 2 and 1/2 also being called 30 moons, one moon is one month ;P
0 likesBefore I share my opinion, I'm just going to warn you now that I will be off subject for the start. In the book series WARRIOR CATS, every moon a gathering of all four clans is held. In the books, a moon meant 1 month, since every month there is one full moon. So for example in Equestria girls, when Luna says that Twilight would be in another world for thirty moon, it would probably mean 30 months, which would be about 2-3 years. That's all I have to say about it, bro hoof ~<3~
0 likesWhile I do agree with 1 moon = 1 day, I must call out a fault in 100 moons = 1 year. In the first episode of season 1, we see the Apple family having a reunion. We know this because in Applebuck Season, when Twilight asked AJ why her relatives aren't helping AJ said that they were having a reunion. So the Apple family reunion should happen the day before Celestia raises the sun for the Summer Sun Celebration every year. But as we know, the Apple family reunion in Season 3 happened before the day before the Summer Sun Celebration in Season 4. So 100 moons isn't 1 year.
0 likesThere are also cases of multiple reunions, such as with my family we attend 3 different reunions. This is because our family is actually split between 3 larger families. Fisher, Wall, and Scarborough with a few smaller families such at Mitchel, Brandt, and Brown. which all lived in the same town since it was founded in the 1700's. We would have a lot of smaller reunions but every few years we would have the large reunion which everyone would attend. I have a feeling the Apple family might be doing the same thing as they have a obviously more than one group that makes up the Apple family.
0 likesBear in mind please, Equestria is not the name of the planet, but rather the name of the country that Celestia and Luna rule over. Or at least, that's how it was before Cadence and Twilight.
0 likesAnyhow, do you think you could do a video on where exactly the Crystal Empire is?
Much like @Darien Hilmerson commented.. In the first episode of MLP they had an family reunion then in season 3 episode 8 they had another one. At the begging of season 4 Twilight mentions that it was that day that they all met and destroyed Nightmere Moon and got the element suggesting it has been only a year plus they did their summer sun celebration. So if it's only been one year then maybe it is not two years but two months. Lets say every season is a month s1= 1 month s2= 2 months s3=3 months s4= 4 months. The Apples had a reunion season 1 and 3 so if they have it in season 5 it could be pretty likely every season is a mouth. But 4 months is not a year so my theory is gone before it began 12 divided by 4 is 3 so maybe every season is three months meaning that the Apples have there reunion every 6 months. But that's just a theory a pony theory!
0 likesI did the math and you were very close briny notion. 100 moons = 2 years and 8 months. Also thank you Samantha Henney! You realy helped me figure that out. :)
0 likesEvery Villian except for chrysalis had been or has been banished for 1000 years which means that equestria still has years and if twilight left at the last moon and had three days to get back to equestria that means 1 moon is 3 days. Since there are 8 stages of the moon changing that means an equestrian month is 24 days.that means if twilight was stuck in the real world she would be stuck for almost 4 months.
0 likesHow are you certain 100 moons is the equivalent to an Equestrian year? I mean you figure two years have passed between the pass two Apple Family reunions. Why can't fifty moons be an Equestrian year so it lines a little better with a terrestrial year?
0 likes"How long is 100 moons?" Well let's line up 100 stallions flank to flanks, stare at their backsides a while, and then measure it out... Oh wait, you meant something else...
0 likes1 Moon = The Amount of time in between an episode with Luna. So around a Season.
0 likesIf 3 Seasons of MLP equate to a a year in MLP time, (If you want an explanation, just ask) then 100 Moons is 33 Years.
So Nightmare MOON was on the MOON for 333 MOONS.
What.
By 1 moon I'm guessing they mean every full moon, which would be intact a month. but then again if its 100 moons for an apple family reunion maybe its 15 days a moon or its just one day
0 likesThis explains so much, I mean three disasters happening simultaneously all listed in 1000 years ago, if the years were longer that does make sense.
0 likeshonestly, i think that every time the moon goes through all of its phases, is considered one moon in equestria, i might be wrong though, :p
0 likesWell, I assume it to be like warriorcats, every moon, or month even, there is one full moon, and assuming that there is only one full moon and one new moon a month, id say a 'new moon' is the start of, well, the next moon. so in other words, each moon would be a month, or a new moon,
0 likesYour videos are so much better than what they used to be
0 likesI guess having a geocentric universe could be different from our heliocentric...
0 likesI think it would better connect if we knew how long a pony's life span was.
0 likesYou beat me to it. I wanted to do a video on how time is told on Equestria's planet.
0 likesI actually wondering:
0 likesGranny Smith came to "not created" land of Ponyville when she was a young adult mare, so how can it be, that in the photo near the barn she is a filly?
And I cannot say, that this photo was made in a different place, cause in the "Family Day" episode, Granny Smith told, that the Apple family didn't have a home... I can't see the logic.
Why couldn't they just use days and months? Seeing as how the span of time between Season 1 and Season 4 was one year, my idea is that every season is equal to four months.
0 likesConsidering how season 1 and 2 was only 1 year, its isnt hard to believe that equastria has a longer year. Maybe the seasons occur twice in one year having 8 seasons each year. Especially since two episodes featured winter season though only one year pass. But then again is the sequence of the episodes another factor that could crush this theory.
0 likesThe day twilight first came to ponyville was the last apple family reunion so the time between the day twilight showed up and the apple family reunion applejack plans is 100 moons. Now just to figure out how to calculate the exact amount of time between the two
0 likesFrom what I know, one moon is also known as one month.
0 likesPersonally, I think moon = month.
1 likeGo check out Warriors, and you'll see what I'm talking about.
Hm... Has it actually been 2 (EQ) years since Twilight came to Ponyville and the Reunion for Season 3? In S1E4 Apple Buck Season, Twilight asks about the rest of the Apple Family, and Apple Jack says they were just here for the reunion... Which just happened to be on the same day as the Summer Sun Celebration, which I'm guessing is to celebrate another (EQ) year of the sun coming up. So if the Reunion happens every other (EQ) year, how many Summer Sun Celebrations have we... Wait, Season 4, Celestia called this, or at least hinted at that this Summer Sun Celebration is the first one where one also celebrated the return of her sister Luna. And no Apple Family Reunion... Someone at Hasbro ought to put together a (proper) Pony Calender.
0 likesyou know the entire phases of the moon thing only works if Equestria is a globe. Sure there have been plenty of globes shown in the show but until somepony spins it and points a place out Equestria could be flat with the sun and moon just being hidden under it. Unlikely? yeah. but there dont seem to be any time shifts when crossing large distances so the one year summer sun celebration may just be celebrating the anniversary of when Celestia first rose the sun. Or rose it so that it lined up perfectly with the little statue thing
0 likesi think that 100 moons is a little less then a year due to what the show shows. in applebuck season s1e4 applejack does say that in the first episode it was a family reunion ( the first summer sun celebration) - then the apple family reunion happens s3e8 - then you have the magical mystery cure s3e13 - starting season 4 ( e. princess twilight sparkle) it is the second summer sun celebration, this is stated when celestia say that it is no longer celebrating the defeat of nightmare moon but the return of princess luna.
0 likesIn my opinion. I possibly think the moons count off to half of day. lets think 6 to 6 is 12 hours, a day would = half a moon. (day) 30 days would be 60 full moons in general.
0 likes"How Long is 100 Moons?"
0 likesWell, I'd say it's about 100 moons long.... XD
you contradicted yourself in the video. you said during the reunions that 100 moons was 2 years yet when talking about luna and celestia 100 moons was 1 year
0 likesThe fact that it seems that between the two Summer Sun celebration only A YEAR HAS PASSED and 100 moons passed SOONER that that... So 100 moons is... a year maybe?
1 likeReplies (2)
When I say "a year" let's have it like humans seen the year in olden times - repeat of the seasons. Thing that Celestia has definite power about - she just keeps sun in more distance for some time.
1 like100 moons is 2 years and 8 months
0 likesHow long is 100 moons? Well, EQG goes off of Majoras Mask logic with Twilights 3 day time limit, and 1 month is (usually) 30 days, so im gonna go with...7
0 likesi like the friendship is witchcraft theory, where every moon is 12 seconds ;3
0 likesThat's some deep stuff nice job! I could not have thought of that! :D
0 likes30 moons is 60 days because 1 moon is 3 days! It says in equestrian girls, that Twilight goes to humans world and she had time 3 days! Think little bit!
0 likesPersonally, I think 30 moons would be 30 FULL moons. Just my opinion.... :)
0 likesI think a year would be the same as ours cuz they make their own seasons remember winter wrap up.
0 likesMaybe one cycle from the day to night is 1 moon?
0 likesmaybe you can tell how long 100 moons is by looking at how many episodes are in between equestria girls and equestria girls rainbow rocks because in the beginning of equestria girls rainbow rocks, before and after the intro, it seemed like one day at canterlot high is the same time as the time in equestria between the equestria girls movies.
0 likesWell what got me thinking is that luna always seem to rise a full moon everynight you never see the moon cycle happen and so if there is one full moon every month then 30 moons would equal 1 month but I have no idea about 100 moons
0 likesThe time would be so much different if we used Warriors logic...
0 likesI heard that 1 moon= 1 month!?!?! But the princesses bring up the seasons. MAYBE the friend ship fire is hidden in a box or something and it powers the moons and stuffs
0 likesAnother piece of evidence, it took three seasons for a whole year to pass in show time.
0 likesIn the Warriors book it seems that a moon is equal to a year cause they age in moons so perhaps it is the same in mlp so it would be 100 years? No i dont think so so is it days or mabey every time there is a full moon
0 likesWell I read warrior cats and the cats say that a moon is a year so if it's 100 moons then it's 100 years. But that would be when a pony probably dies because it lives too long. But every 100 moons applebloom would be older and have her cutie mark. But that would also mean Granny Smith would die. So I'm confused.
0 likesEquestria is a country, not a planet but that's just a technicality. And a year can be determined by the passing of the four seasons when they're as regular as they are. Like another poster said, the Apples had two reunions in what was apparently less than a year...but that's kind of weird. Usually when ponies use the word moon, they seem to be referencing an amount of time similar to an Earth month, or at least a couple of weeks. I'm just gonna call inconsistencies. -_-
0 likesOne flaw... One year is S1-S3 (give or take some offscreen things...)
1 likeApple Reunion first shown: S1E1
Apple Family Reunion focus episode: S3E8 or E60 overall...
So... Thoughts anypony?
Just saiyan!!
what if equestria is flat and not round like earth. celestia raises and lowers the sun and only has to do this once to start and end the day. If she had to revolve it around a circular planet wouldn't she be costantly working and constantly moving the sun?
0 likesA moon is a month from my understanding, divide 100 by 12..
0 likesOMG! I looked up Equestrian in the dictionary... MIND BLOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1 likeI think it should be a moon is a month according to Erin Hunter
0 likesI just presumed it was a month since I'm pretty sure it takes a month for the moon to make an entire cycle, (so from new moon and back again). 🌑🌒🌓🌔🌕🌖🌗🌘 <-- like that if you can see the emojis :P
0 likesWhy did you have your mouth open for the almost whole episode, The Brony Notion?
0 likesYou forgot about what was said in Apple buck season, which would help you significantly. In apple buck season, applejack said that so many family members where there during the summer sun celebration because they was there for a family reunion.
0 likesRather than all this [insert picture of vice squeezing head, with an extremely pained look on the face], I prefer to say "Equestrian time is f**ked up, and we'll never understand it." In fact, you could substitute "time" with "economy"... it's a children's show, it's not supposed to be analysed to this degree.
0 likes...
whatever, I guess you're entitled to your own pastimes. To each their own.
The year is based on seasons. In roughly 1,460,000 years Easter will be in Halloween
0 likesSoo... You're saying 2 years passed between Season 1's prior episodes and Apple Family Reunion?
0 likesA moon is a month really? how didn't you know that?!?!
0 likesBest pony is luna
0 likesLuna moves the moon around equestria everyday so
1 day=2 moons
Me and my friends( Sophie,Leah and Kennedy) watched equestria girls and when Luna said twilight chould not return for anuther 30 moons we thought that 30 moons many 30 FULL moons so we said around 4 years twighligt would be stuck at C.H.S
0 likesBut how would one year be 100 moons if Granny Smith said "Every 100 moons" they had the family reunion? Eh, enoguh conspiring today. Time to get to HW
0 likes100 moons is 100 months in Hasbros Monster High movie Frights Camera Action they say that 1 month is 1 moon since it's the same company I would assume it would be the same for all the shows
0 likesI don't think the Sun revolves around their planet. I think this is how heavenly bodies move on Equestria. The star is fixed, and the planet they live on revolves around their parent star BUT the planet has no natural spin. What Princess Celestia does is she causes the spin on their planet. We here on Earth say, "The sun is rising" because from our standpoint, that is what it looks like. But our sun isn't doing anything, the planet is - it's spinning. So, when ponies say, "Celestia raises the sun" they are saying that because that is what it looks like from their point of view, when in fact, she is giving the planet it's daily spin. On Earth, both the sun and the moon "rise" wink wink in the east and set in the west - only Luna revolves the moon around their planet.
0 likesThere's probably not a right answer. The creators of MLP most likely didn't assume that people would look so much into it, so they porbably just did whatever. Maybe. :P
0 likesThat wouldnt make sense ill make a video on my thoughts but grany smith didnt go from apple blooms age to her current age in 12 years
0 likes1 moon is 1 month. If you take an example from warrior cats quarter of a moon is 1 week, half a moon is 2 weeks, 3 quarters of a moon is 3 weeks and 1 moon is 4 weeks(or pretty much 1 month) though.... Equestria isn't warrior cats...
0 likesI once was reading a book about the moon that was nonfiction and saw nightmare moon on it X3
0 likesI think that 100 MOONS is like 100 full moons.
0 likesOne moon is a full moon so 100 moons are 100 months
0 likesmoon= month
0 likesevery warrior cat fan knows that
1 moon is 1 week cause theres seven stages and sevan days so it would be 100 weeks
0 likesOKAY i think 100 moons is 1 year.. because you have a family reunion every YEAR
0 likesIf they say 30 moons it means every full moon
0 likesSince Luna travels the moon every night I would say it's 100 days but it's doesn't make sense for Granny Smith but it would make sense for Apple bloom
0 likesummm. i may have heard this wrong but did you just say that first the equestrian 2year time is 100 then towards the end say that 100 is only 1 year?
0 likesI think that full moon is count as one moon
0 likeshey
0 likeshey
hey
so a moon is as long as a sweep?
troll-pony headcanon accepted
I see the moon every morning.
0 likesi think thats reasonable considering a horse year is (human year= h, horse/pony=p) h2=p
0 likesthe answer to your title, 100 months, about 8 years because, normally, their is a full moon roughly every month
0 likesReplies (1)
btw i havn't watched the video yet
0 likesA moon is a month as stated in Warriors
0 likesI wish you put the soviet Russia meme when you said the moon revolves around equestria
0 likesWow it has not even been a half of a year yet but you already have twice as many subscribers.
0 likes30 moons = 2.5 years. Like 2.5 seasons of show. >_>
0 likesReplies (1)
Season 1-4 is 1 year
0 likesBut granny Smith said that they have the apple family reunion at the sweet apple acres every 100 moons could they have the apple family reunion somewhere else?
0 likesI thought that 100 moons = 100 days...
0 likesone question : on the 11th episode of season of M.L.P how is the big fire ball still there. It confuses me and my 2 brothers.
0 likesIT IS A BIG HELP TO US !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! THANK YOU !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Question why don't they age please record a video on this question😊
0 likesIn 3 months you have got an additional 30k subs wow!
0 likesOne sentence: Molester Moon.
1 likeget it?
NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1 likeTHE TIME BETWEEN S1 AND S4 IS 1 YEAR
that would mean celestia is over 2000 in our years.
0 likesAnd WHAT About MY Little Dashie?? 5 Days in Rquestria with 15 Years in Reality.
0 likesthe first applebloom is an error she wasnt meant to be the same age
0 likes12 years because on the second picture no applebloom and on the third applebloom was there so she was born between the M. (12 YEARS)
0 likesActually our moon is 27.3 days
0 likesOH. Two Equestrian years is one in our world? Between season 1 and 4 is it supposed to be one year. And we can see episode in winter(or the end of winter) twice Between s1 and s4 . So 1 Equestrian year are two ours.
0 likesThat party hat was also Party hat from B.O.T.O brawl of the objects
0 likesI'm taking after history and Warriors and say moons are months and that the animators where just being lazy.
0 likesI L L U M A N A T I C O N F I R M E D
0 likesDAT party hat!! sqee
2 likesIt's a kids show.
0 likesThere's your answer.
A moon is a month.
0 likes100 month means 9 years
0 likes30 days in equestria is 30 years in real life. I know because that cause i watched my little dashie mini movie.
0 likesWrong 1moon=full moon so 100 full moons
0 likesfacehoof Didn't you just say that 50 moons was a year because 100 moons was 2 years? Now you're saying 100 moons is 1 year? DERP you are awesome, but you just went Derpy Hooves on us there.
0 likesMaybe smthin happen and ponies stopped to get old?
0 likes:v
Oh hey! That's the Party Hat Asset from Brawl of the Objects!
0 likesReplies (1)
+katyj98 kat, are you a brony?
0 likesIN EPISODE1 SEASON 1 WAS A APPLE FAMILY REUNION, AND IN SEASON 3 WAS ANOTHER... NOPONY ELSE SEE'S THIS ;C!
0 likesOkay befour the vid starts im guessing a month cuz a moon in warrior cat years is a month
0 likesYou scared me on the 2015 part o-o
0 likesBut Equestria is earth or is on a planet named earth as Pinkie pie or captain pudding head or whatever said "The earth is round" in the hearth warming eve episode.
0 likesDays in a year ( Earth)-365/366
0 likesDays in equestria
Congratulations!
0 likesThe thing though is that I don't recal Equestria ever showing anything else thena Full Moon
0 likes100 moons=100 moons
0 likesFor 1 day you get 4 equstria days :)
0 likesHey brony notion since you love flutter chord so much make a reaction video of bride of discord on disneyfnatics channel!!!
0 likesBecause every hindered days of a full moon as 100 moons
0 likes1 moon = 2 weeks
0 likesYou are not right because when Nightmare Moon was banished to the moon well it took a hundred years right?
0 likeswell you said that a hundred years and a hundred days or something was I don't know anyway well when she was banished Luna took 1000 years for her chest get released!!!
Just got one new sub! :)
0 likesSIMPLE MATH PLEASE?
0 likesOne moon = one month
0 likesOh i think thats how they got the name for Equestria cuz it rhymes with America that makes sense
0 likesWEll so what about celestia line about all of season 1-3 up till tiwlight alicornship being ONE year! yup 80ish epsides all in one year...okay..i'm lost
0 likesif u look up my little dashie u might find a seane that shows Earth Year = MLP Day
0 likesMoons = months
0 likes1 moon = 1 month (i think...)
0 likesAwwwwww Baby AJ!
0 likesa moon is a month
0 likesA moon is a month
0 likes100 moons is 100 month serisily read warrior cats D:
0 likesits 20 years
0 likeswhoa
0 likesi like how deep you go
i was thinking about prince blue blood and rarity familiar relashonship
0 likesI never relised the hat tillmyou mentioned it
0 likesbut there is EARTH PONYS
0 likes10 years
0 likesMan so much math
0 likesI'm applejack! More apple fwitter?
0 likes30 years
0 likesBring Notion? You are smart!
0 likesWell in bucking season Apple jack said that the only reason that they were there because its the apple reineun and it caud be like a leep year its random
0 likesIt's a year smart one
0 likesMY B-DAY WAS JAN 7🎂🎁🎆🎇🎉🎊
0 likesthis is confusing💧
0 likesThis was uploaded on mah birthday...
0 likesInstersting!
0 likesI'm Applejack more apple puddle?
0 likesThink back in one episode se says im supost to sent every week one letter to princess celestia just look how manny weeks there are between the pilot episode en apple reunin***
0 likesXOXO ~ME~
1 moon = 1 night :l
0 likes100 months
0 likeswow just wow now this is good your waerning a party hat that party hat is cute will you see i have nothing about the mlp a.k.a. my little pony moon but i do have a qeschen i said qeschen wrong so can sunset shemmer stay in the humaen world or can sunset shimmer walk very easy i maen i know her back story and all but can sunset shimmer's rael home is in the humaen world or not because i have no idea how can her home be the humaen world its so strange its hard to answer it but how can she walk in that miorr and knowed it was magical and ddddddeeeeerrrrrpppp oh sorry i got carid away so thats my qechen bye bbbbbyyyyyeeeee dddddeeeerrrrrrpppppppppp ;3
0 likesAnd I'm celebrating 20 subscribers!
0 likesits over 19,000!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesdo a thing on lungs mom and dad
0 likesmoonemoji
0 likesI don't have a theory about it but I do know this is a stupid baby show on the people who made it didn't expect for older people to be watching this making weird assumptions about something that really doesn't matter because little kids are going to be watching this thing and they really don't care one way or another they just think it's a tv show with horses saying words
0 likesGood hat...
0 likesMabey the summer sun celebrashon is new year
0 likes4.5
2 likesMore
1 likeOk space hard cartoon simple
0 likesits cartoon and i dont tink that i matters that much...just "layze raiderz"
Do you always have to yous that pony!Xoe
0 likesbig help
0 likesyou siad a 100 was 2 yaer then at the end you siad 1 witch is it
0 likes🌚
0 likesWhy is everyone talking about Mlp and please never show you face or say a real word or I will cry till I have finished making green tea
0 likeshai brony
0 likesUggghhh! Brony! Not briny sorry :)
0 likesoh oh oh don't forget rainbow dashes bithaversery
0 likesOr hasbro make errors that not the firs time
0 likesEight or nine
0 likesYou don't say :D
0 likesYour pony oc is drawn terribly..
0 likesReplies (1)
Can you do better? NO.
0 likesWHY DO PEOPLE OVER THINK THIS STUFF?!😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
0 likesReplies (1)
WHY DO PEOPLE OVERUSE EMOTOCONS?I MEAN SERIOUSLY,ONE IS ENOUGH
3 likesI can't argue with your theory, but it brings up an interesting question regarding the ages of the ponies and how old Lauren Faust said they were- that Pinkie was around 14 and Twilight around 19, and they reach adulthood at 14. I was going to pose the possibility that these could be equestrian ages and 14 there would mean 28 here, but then she said it was because 'they age faster than humans' so I suppose that would be their ages in human years, and Pinkie's age in Equestrian years would be 7. This also throws off some of my assessment of what their ages are, since Fluttershy said she was a year older than pinkie so I had put her at 15, but if that's one Equestrian year then her earth age would be 16, though if they reach maturity at 14 then she's still the equivalent of around 20 because Pinkie would be the equivalent of about 18. I would have to say for certain that they don't follow our birthday cake tradition of one candle per year, because assuming all of RD's candles were on one side of the cake and only the ones we could see were there, she had 21 candles. I had thought this would work with one season = one year, making Dash 21 now but 17 in season one but it had been said that the whole show thus far has been within one year which would likely make Dash's current age 18. Likely the candles went all the way around though because why wouldn't they, so the cake probably had about 40 candles on it and they had nothing to do with her age. Wait her birthday wouldn't mark one of our years passing but one of theirs, and they would celebrate birthdays every 2 earth years and if she was 17 earth years at the start would she then be 19 but is the show within one earth year or one Equestrian year? Or would 17 earth years old be 8.5 Equestrian years and this was her 9th birthday making her 18 in earth years... yea that makes sense.
1 likeThis is the only video I have seen on this subject. I have considered how long a moon would be in equestria, but couldn't figure out any way to measure it. There hasn't been enough focus on time (It's about time XD) to be able to calculate it, or even get all that close. While you have an interesting theory, I'm hoping that information brought up in season 5 will help us to figure out how long a moon, and an equestrian year is.
1 likeBTW, this makes me wonder if an Equestrian week is only five days, because I don't recall anyone ever mentioning a saturday or sunday, and in Lesson Zero, the Twilights, (best pony) calendar only has five days on it. You should bring this up at some point, I may do a video on it as well. (Once I'm done my season 5 predictions vid)
Great job on the 20 000!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Figuring out how time works and is recorded in Equestria would be a useful tool in finding out a lot of things, such as how old Celestia and Luna are, knowing that they are indeed way older than 1,000 moons. Do they go by human days, or something else?
0 likesWell, if Celestia and Luna somehow set the calender using the moon. then maybe one lunar cycle was equal to one week of the Equestria Calender. As for the theory on them having a different base counting system, it would make perfect sense. Being a furry, I have read a comic series where the evolved animals had a base 8 system of counting since they all had 3 fingers and thumb. or each hand.
1 likeI am so glad to have you back. You're, just...Awesome. Nothing more needs to be said, lots more could be said about your amazing-ness, but as they say "less is more".
0 likesOn the topic of how long a year is, I don't know. I mean they said on the first episode of season 4 that all of the episodes had been one year, but that just seemed like a whole TON of things to happen in a year, also they had Winter Wrap-Up soon after the Summer Sun Celebration, and then the end of fall had come. So in Equestria winter is after summer and before fall? But what about Hearths Warming Eve? that looked like winter to me, so all in one year they had one summer, two winters, one fall and no spring episode to speak of? Argh, ponies why you so hard to understand!?
Also I saw a few people posted saying that they had a family reunion in the very first episode, so it would be less than a year between the two so that's why Apple Bloom doesn't look any different. I don't, ponies don't seem to care if we can make sense of their world or not.
How me and my friend thought of the time conversion, we took the approximate average lifespan of a human to a horse, and plugged the ratio into equestrian time, which if i remember correctly,equestrian time is three times (serious rounding) larger than ours in the same span. which means their time passes by quicker, meaning they have shorter years than us, by what i assume is 66% of our years.
0 likesI think your overlooking the fact that the lifespan of the ponies is greatly extended. Granny smith helped found ponyville, but in the episode where they are getting ready for spring, they have been preparing the same way since ponyville was founded, which twilight says, was hundreds of years ago. Therefor I believe it that there it is possible for them to have a reunion every 8 years, especially since the show indicates granny smith is hundreds of years old.
0 likesDidn't we see a calender with four day weeks in lesson zero? Judgeing by the number of the episode (wich is a nice 60) we could say that between this reunion and the one in the pilot episode and Twilight's mention that she has to send celestia her letter every week we could say that around 55 weeks (because of the pilot episodes,the premiers and the finales) have passed so according to my theory we could say that around 55 weeks is a year in equestria.
0 likesIf you look at it like "when the moon is the same shape twice" thing, it would take about a week. So, it would be about a year if it happened 100 times. Mabe they were thinking of a specific day when the moon stays longer then normal. Then it could take a lot longer period of time. Night is longer in the winter, mabe there talking about a "moon" being the winter solstice.
0 likesI have a thought. So I have thought this through and actually my theory is either in Equestria 10 moons is a year. Why 10? Well lets think about it both ways
1 likeIf it was 10 moons equals 1 year in Equestria then that means the reunion happens every 10 years which makes sense since its an even amount of time between reunions. Enough time for it to be not a hassle for everyone to go so often but long enough so no one misses anyone for too long. It would also makes sense why Applejack was so young in the one reunion and now a grown up helping to plan it (and I will say it now the one picture with the three of them in it I call a mistake since it wouldn't be the first time they're visuals didn't match the description).
Also lets keep in Mind Granny Smith. She was very young when Ponyville was founded so to know each detail and to have so many found memories, it would all make sense. It would also make ensue why Applebloom would be excited to see Babs since it would be their first met us since she was introduced and it would also explain how she didn't know her well before since they both are probably either just 10 in pony years or a little younger.
Another reason why it would make sense for it to be 10 months is a year would explain how imperative it was for Twilight to get in and get out. 3 years is a long time to be stuck anywhere, especially if you are royalty and are part of the first line of defense for that country. It would also explain why we never saw Sunset Shimmer before because consider this. Our cycle runs on 29,5 moon cycle system and Equestria runs on just 10. Which means each 3 years in Equestria would only be a year for Sunset Shimmer. Which means it would make it even more likely why she was gone for so long. So lets just say Sunset was in her senior year in high school when she was in Equestria girls. That means she was there for 4 years, translated for 12 years in Equestria. Of course Twilight would not have met her because she was long gone before Twilight even began studying and around the time Sunset Shimmer say came around the time of even just the 3rd year, 9 years in Equestria since she left, this would be the big rise for Twilight and thats how she found everything out.
Sorry this is lengthy but this is my theory. What do you think?
Replies (4)
There's one major problem with that: The pilot episode had an Apple Family Reunion, and then there was another in Season 3. Season 4 episode 1 establishes that between Season 1 and Season 4 was one year. So, since there was already 2 Apple Family Reunions in that one year, 100 moons can't be 10 years.
0 likesIt did? Man I totally forgot that! Hmmm....
0 likes@CoolioCats614 Even if it didn't, and each season was a year, that's still around 3 years between reunions. So either way, the whole 100 moons is 10 years thing is busted. It's either around one year, or three years. Plus, since we saw Apple Bloom as a young filly in the first reunion, she would have to be an older teen to young adult if the second took place 10 years later, and she's still a young filly.
0 likeswont work. if its every 10 years. twilight would have to be for 10 years considering when she apreared the apples where just having a reunion.
0 likesWith this idea it would show how alot of the stuff can happen the way it does in the show and yet still only be 1 year by the time season 4 gets here
0 likeswell I can tell you a bit about time in Equestria. In the first episode of my little pony it was the summer sun celebration where Celestia raises the sun. the second time it was mentioned was in episode 23 Cutie Mark Chronicles when Twilight says she saw it as a filly. A thousand years later after that episode the next Summer Sun Celebration, Twilight was a princess and Celestia now says the summer celebration is a time when we are happy that Luna is back. So I guess that can help you a bit on years in Equestria. Right now we know that ponies live for a VERY long time (thinking of Celestia and Luna) and the summer sun celebration is like the stages of a human. start as a filly,then you are like child next your a teen, I'm guessing teen because in Equestria girls Twilight had a crush on Flash and she was in a high school and when she was back in Equestria the girls were acting kinda girly talking about her crush. so a thousand years is like the stages of growing up :) I hope I helped a bit good luck ;)
1 likeReplies (3)
Fair enough
0 likesbut twilight isn't 1000 years old shes a teenager...
0 likesbut in pony time they dont go by years like us in equestria girls sure yeah shes a teenager but in ponyville shes a teenager in well how many years equals teenager for ponies
0 likesYou just made it more confusing for me... I think the Equestrian moons are the same as earth moons: 29.5 days. After all, it would make more sense in two of the episodes in which it was used:
0 likes"I still can't believe it's been almost one hundred moons since our last family reunion!"
- Granny Smith; Apple Family Reunion
"This is no ordinary mirror. It is a gateway to another world. A gateway that opens once every thirty moons."
- Princess Luna; Equestria Girls
"My plunderseeds should have stolen the magic from the Tree of Harmony and captured Princess Celestia and Princess Luna thousands of moons ago."
- Discord; Princess Twilight Sparkle
These are the only three instances of the term "moons" (unless I'm missing some) in My Little Pony, and the latter two make sense. We don't know how long ago Sunset Shimmer went through the portal that's just been introduced, so it could have been 2.4-year intervals, and 12,000 moons qualifies more as "thousands of moons" than 200,000 moons. However, the discontinuity lies in Apple Family Reunion, right? No, it technically lies in the previous reunion in Friendship is Magic - Part 1, and it's a different type of discontinuity. The thing is... I can clear up this mystery using only two words: Extraneous Reunion. Kind of like "Extraneous Solutions" on a graph to represent discontinuity, the Apples had an "Extraneous Reunion" especially for the Summer Sun Celebration. From what we've seen thus far, the Summer Sun Celebration usually takes place in Canterlot, and Celestia set it up in Ponyville to get Twilight to meet the rest of the Mane 6. However, one unintended side-effect was Applejack. The Apple Family Reunions usually take place at Sweet Apple Acres, from what we've seen, so this would be the perfect occasion to host one. It didn't count toward the 100-moon cycle however, because the main reason it existed was the Summer Sun Celebration. That was the main event, and likely the reason all of those relatives even came (also the reason Granny Smith didn't count it as an official reunion). We don't see very many of them there after all, and they aren't distinguishable from each other like in Apple Family Reunion. However, that doesn't mean they couldn't take the photo in front of the barn and it doesn't mean some of the Apples, like Apple Rose and Apple Fritter, weren't in the barn or off sleeping somewhere when AJ was introducing Twilight to everyone. So, yeah. Extraneous Reunions.
In the Warriors book series, a gathering is held every time the moon is full. The cats' ages are known by moons. A moon is told apart from the gatherings, one moon is the time between two gatherings.
0 likesJust thought I should say.
Also, you should do "Is Commander Hurricane a mare or stallion?"
Replies (1)
I'm only on the 4th book LOL
0 likesI'm thinking that ponies age slower than humans (MAGIC, duh) and by that their years are a bit longer than ours.
0 likesI do agree that 100 moons lead up to a year, but that year might be longer than just 365/366 days for ONE reason.....
All the festivals that happen in Equestria. There must be SO many of them, and they wouldn't fit into the year time-span that we have, There's just not enough time for all that planning, then setting it up, and then having the festival before the next one comes up. So, I'm thinking that a year lasts at least...maybe around 500 days.
So, what about the seasons? Yep, they last longer too. But I think that summer/spring are the longest seasons as ponies do control the weather year-round (although I think in some years they laze off which makes them last a bit longer).
....And that's all I got. ^u^
During the first episode, the apple family reunion was during the Summer Sun Celebration, so, assuming that the Summer Sun Celebration occurs once every year, shouldn't the apple family reunion also be once a year, or did the apple family reunion happen during the Summer Sun Celebration in the first episode just for plot convenience?
0 likes8 YEARS AND 6 MONTHS!!!! I did it on my own without the video, and with a little help with a calculator.
1 likeBetween season 1 episode 2 and season 4 episode 2 is exactly a year which means the apple family reuions are one year apart. So 100 moons are roughly and equestrian year.
0 likesthe Summer sun celebration interferes with your theory. in season 1 episode 1&2 this is the time of the summer Sun Celebration. it marks the meeting of the heroes, applefamily reunion and the return of Princess Luna. in season 3 episode 8 we see another Applefamily reunion. and at the end of season 4 episode 2 we see the Summer Sun Celebration. these lines are proof:
0 likesIn apple Family reunion Granny Smith stated that they do it every 100 moons. and in the two part premiere of season 4 this lines happens:
Celestia: Now I can look forward to the Summer Sun Celebration.
Twilight: Why?
Celestia: For my Subjects it is for defeating Nightmare moon, for me it is a reminder that I had to banish my own sister.
Twilight: I never thought of it that way.
Celestia: it is her first one back.
So that proves the summer sun celebration is 1 year. and it is after the applefamily reunion. I think one year is 150 moons. because if you look throughout all the episodes there are pages of a days and every time we seen them. there are 30 squares. this means a year has to be divisible by 30. 100 isn't. but 150 is. 120 just seems to even.
Have you guyz ever spotted how Luna met everyone during the ceremony, and on Nightmare Night everyone still runs from her.
1 likeI have always wondered that, but was to lazy to research it myself. Great video! ;)
0 likesyou don't swear, you make good points, and you post a lot! i am subscribing!
1 likeIt would be cool if you made a episode focused on your OC being a changling.
1 likeI know they said from the End of the 1st Movie to the Sirise coming to the School in Rainbow Rock was just 6 Moons So Season 4 had to take place in a total of 5 to the 6 Moons Lets go back to Season 3 for a sec we had 2 Eps that took place at the same time. The Eps Spike took care of the Pets and the Eps were the girls were in the Crystal Empire showing the inspector for the Equestian Games (Olypics) around. So some Eps could took place at the same time in Season 4. But that a streatch. We know in Season 2 a Week is 7 days long. Because Twilight had to send a letter ever week but she missed this week and at sun set Princess Celestria showed up.
0 likesAlso when asked one of the people workes on the show says Equestian Moon can not be told in Human Time.
So a Moon could a Month. We know the last time the mirror open up was 30 Moons ago when Sunset shimmer used it she left shortly before Twilight because PCs student so figure out how long she been her student and that is how long 30 Moons is then we can figure out how long a Moon is.
But again they said it can not be told in human time
here's an idea. in one of the comics optimus prime from transformers is visible (regular mlp comics). and flash sentry's car looks like an erbona 500. a car from transformers prime. is it possible that these 2 universes are connected?
0 likesReplies (1)
also let's not forget pinkie pie's optimus costume
0 likesThere's also the fact that the apples had family reunion on the first episode when twilight first met them, so could that play a part?
0 likesNo celebrations are repeated in MLP until episodes 4.1 & 4.2 & " princess twilight sparkle" with the summer sun celebration. They do not outright say it but to me it is heavily implied that this was their first anniversary of those events. This means, to me, that all of the events in the show up to the beginning of season 4 take place within 1 year. This would mean Apple family reunions happen fairly frequently. Again, no other holidays or celebrations seem to repeat until season 4.
0 likesJust saying what if 100 moons was 100 years so each moon was a years and crystal ponies lived for maybe 1000 or more so maybe normal ponies would have the same age span so that is why they change so much over those 100 years . Also Apple Bloom was just a mistake that the show always makes
0 likesI think it was just a logic mix up. Mlp does that a lot, like for example when celestia said blue blood was her nephew, but that means blue blood would have to be luna's son or there would have to be a third royal sister, which the show downs suggest at all. See, mlp doesn't always watch their logic, like with the moon theory.
0 likesReplies (1)
Sorry I meant to say "which the show doesn't suggest at all
0 likesKeep in mind that there is a theory that Equestria is Earth after an apocalypse (look in to it, it's kinda complicated for a comment) so maybe there's another viable system for 'moons' based on real earth.
0 likesI see one moon as one month ( mostly because i am used to it in the Warrior cats book series). But in that case, it would be 12 moons = one year, and 100 moons would be....... a veeeery long time. But, it maybe is one month anyways, since ponies live alot longer than humans.
0 likesIm not smart, so this post is pretty wierd xD
In MLP the fourth season started off as it being once year since Luna returned from the moon, which in our time was 4 years ago. So one year there=4 years here.
0 likesWell.... Someone did their homework. I've thought a lot about this same subject for...reasons.
0 likesIt's possible that Equus itself rotates very slowly, or wobbles, and that that is what constitutes a year.
A moon is one full cycle of all the stages of the moon. Like, cresent, full, half, new, etc.
0 likesYay! Happy 20,000 subscribers! That's a pretty nice way to start a new year off.
0 likesYou changed mywhole perspective, i Read warrios and they refer to moons as well, in equestria, i always thought moons where months. In warrios, they say that a kit or kitten has to be 6 moons old to become an apprentice,so i was thinking 6 moons is 6 months, but i could be wrong (i know you may not have a clue what im talking about with this warriosr thing it was an example
0 likesHappy 20,000 subs!! And it makes since that 100 moons is one year in Equestian time. Your guess is as good as mine. It just seems easiest to me. lol
0 likesWell I like your theory because based on our past cultures the consep of time was changed like Stonehenge people beleave it was made to calculate time using the sun and moon and where on the planet you are could change how you see days go by so yes I think there idea of time could be different
0 likesSo would the theory that 50 moons would be when Zap Apples are harvested? Since they only can be harvested once when the moon is at its highest? Anyone care to explore this theory?
0 likesmy theory is the lunar cycle as you said i was just thinking in our time so i thought every moon was a month
1 likeI guessed 100 moons was basically 100 days or so, a new moon each night. It's not like it said 100 full moons
0 likesMaybe 100 moons is just a year, in our time. Because in some Native American tribes, (mine included) it is believed that each month has 3 moons in it. Event though it is only 36, it might explain something.
0 likesCongrats for 20,000 subscribers! Sucessful new year is a foot! (or a leg)
1 likeAMAZING!!!!!!! very good calculation!!!👍👍👍👍👍
0 likesEqustra years are 3 times longer from the first episode to the first episode of season 4 was abought 3-4 people years.
0 likesAnd am I the only one who remembers that season 5 comes out this year
I guessed that 100 moons was one Equestria year myself. If one Equestria year equals 2 normal earth years then that explains why Equestrian years seem longer.
0 likesCould you do a video about why there is a guillotine in Equestria.
0 likesIt's in the episode 'May the best pet win'.
Just curious.
applebloom barely looks younger but still does in the picture
0 likesWell when I watch mlp, I usally act like every episode is two weeks to make more sense because really a bad thing happens everytime it would be weird to have one every week so why not every 2?
0 likesLove you videos can't wait to see more
0 likesIf the sun is only moving around equestria then, is there more than one sun? I mean, equestria is'nt the whole world... it's probably just a continent right?...right?
0 likes100 moons? So 1 year? But Granny Smith is 1 year before wasn't that young! I think 100 moons=10 years.
0 likesi feel stupid cus mostly everyone are saying good theory's, same w/the brony notion... and im just sitting here trying to create a theory.
2 likesWait, in two years twilight, defeated nightmare moon, then discord, then sombra, became a human, got her crown back and became an alicorn?
0 likes@The Brony Notion You should do a video on what happens when one of the pony's from the crusaders get there cutiemark.
0 likeshow old is granny smith? wasn't she there for the founding of ponyvile? also what about celestia and luna? and finally thanks for the video. thats a common question that my brother and i ask
0 likesWell no the summer solsice celbration happened in season one episode 1 and then again in season4 episode 1 so each season is a season 3 months to be exact and also there was a reunion in the pilot then later on so thats the time period of each reunion about 10 months or so , making 10 moons each month showing 1/3 of each season is a month and is ten moons so a hundred moons is about in our time 3 an 1/3 mlp seasons and there anout ten months
0 likesI think a hundred moons is a year. Like in June that would be twelve moons
0 likesI love this ! Its so cool
0 likesbaby applejack is adorable! 😍
0 likesIf you can find more evidence can you do a star-swirl the bearded episode
0 likesMaybe just maybe... in equestria 30 moons are 3 months and 100 moons is 1 year and on earth 30 moons are 30 days and 100 moons is 100 days because earth doesn't work like equestria because
0 likes1. Equestria is on a mythological - like world in a different universe and a TV show so it Clearly doesn't exist obviously.
2. Even though equestria doesn't exist it does have magical and mythological ponies and creatures that can happen on earth despite before we we're even born there could've been strange and mythological things that were somehow defeated, reformed or resolved by magic just like how the mane 6 use magic for all 3 of those things. So clearly earth doesn't really do the same balance as in equestria.
Wow!! This makes sense now..... But... How could Granny Smith age that fast... Well Equestria is NOT earth so... And ponies do age faster so this makes sense
0 likesThe Brony Notion, you may have shown Apple Jack's mother and father ( In 1:18 ) Because I went back and looked at Granny Smith's age. One showed her very young, older and older. And Apple Jack and Apple Bloom look younger in the picture in 1:18. But, Big Mac. It looks like he doesn't age, so I could be wrong. But, the the two ponies on
0 likes-> that side looks like her mother and father but, that baby looks like it's theirs' so. And the two ponies on <---- that side could be it too. So its a fact I have been thinking about.Claudis Ptolemy was right! Um... in a way. For a little girls show that came around 2000 years later...
0 likesThis lost a lot of its credibility to me after he revealed this is based on the assumption their system is Geocentric.
1 likeTHANK YOU SO MUCH for not just saying 1 moon = 1 month!
0 likesOk the first apple reunion was in season 1 and the other one was in season 4 so that means that 100 moons is 3 seasons in my little pony
0 likesIn this case , it says in equestria girls, she has 3 days to get the crown and luna said when the moon is at its peek on the 3day the portal will close that shows that 1moon = 1day or 1day = 1moon so 100 moons is 100 days and so is 30 moons to 30 days
0 likesA moon is a month. Well, technicaly.
0 likesDo you want to do a collab?~
0 likesNo really though, I wanna get your ideas and thoughts on an interesting story. Because MLP has a lot to do with greek mythology, I wanted to see if I could share theories on the subject "The story of fenrir"
Edit: Dammit I forgot it's called Collab, not cameo! I'm a dunce
Which begs the question, why didn't Granny Smith said "It's been a year since the last Reunion", it's like if I said "Come back 4 weeks after today" instead of "Come back next month".
0 likesAlso what about seasons? Months? etc...
Replies (4)
I think it's deliberately vague as to what she meant by one-hundred moons. Either DHX want's the fanbase to build Equestria themselves, or they themselves have no idea how their own world works. Speaking of vague events that god won't tell us about, what DO ponies do on Hearths Warming Eve?
0 likes@Jordan Heath
0 likesThey put on plays and sing carols. And get their tongues stuck on 8-foot candy canes.
@BioniclesaurKing4t2 But where' the presents? Where's Santa Pony?
0 likesThey may have established how it was established but they didn't explain the celebration. Yet?
@Jordan Heath
0 likesWhere's Santa? He's in G3 (no, seriously, he is).
In Warrior Cats a moon is equivalent to a month
0 likesCongrats on the 20,000 subs ! ;D
0 likesWhat about the pilot there was a family reunion and there are less family members in the pitcher then when twilight arrived on her first day at ponyville.
0 likesHey don't mean to be hating but the first episode of season 4 said that only one year had passed after the first episode so maybe the moons really are just days?
0 likesMake more videos like one a day and what program did you use?
0 likesI like you vids hey every body like this if they liked this video. thank you for the awesome videos and please keep uploading them. Thank you!!!
So, in Equestria are 8 seasons per year?
0 likesYay! Another great video!!! :3
0 likeswell what if they did it every two years but apple bloom rally wanted to see babs again so the changed the days of the reunion to every hundred moons. it makes a bit more sense that none of them aged in the picture but there were a lot more so it still doesn't so much sense to me how so many more were in that last picture, Now i know that not all of came to the reunion every year because they were busy but HOW ARE THERE SO MANY APPLES THAT I CAN'T EAT!!! :( :( :( :)
0 likesYou should do a video about why daring do and rainbow dash look almost exactly alike.
0 likesthe moon moves in the moon calendar so if you can see the first night the moon is nether full or new moon.so the portal is like a cell phone it has to charge of 30 day or month's so the portal is solar and lunar powered but how did starswirl now this portal thing so the book that sunset had uses limitless power when twilight uses the other book the portal was limitless.
0 likesI got a question. Think about it. What is it with Princess Gold Lilly and Princess Sterling in the new Hasbro toys?
0 likesI disagree, I think that Equestria is solar centric
0 likeswasn't there a reunion in the first episode? if I remember clearly?
0 likesnothing to do with moons but i saw mlp eg and HAD to ask this question. what if pinkie got through the portal? would one pinkie die or would they both stay. i mean you cant stay with yourself if u came from the future or past right? so something will happen and most likely to human pinkie.
0 likesAnd also they had 2 reunions in one year so 100 moons cannot be 1 year
0 likesmoons means year cause I saw this one episode where discord was baished a thousand moons but another episode said it was a thousand years
0 likesYAY glad to see you back i missed you soo much
0 likesbut in applebuck season (hehe "buck") didn't aj say that twilight came to ponyville during one of the apple family reunions?
0 likesAccording to Granny Smith, the Apple family has a reunion every hundred moons. But how long exact-FFRREEIINNDDSS
0 likesin the Warriors series, 1 moon is 1 month.
0 likesPlz do a remix of the theme!
0 likesIn real life I think a moon is 1 month
0 likesHappy New Yeear! You know what this calls for? A Party!!!!!!!!!!
0 likesPrevious vid: Does Twilight have OCD? Next should be: Where does Rainbow Dash live? Hint: to know where she lives, check the episode with "Singing Telegram" song.
0 likesi think that theory is awesome it makes so much sence love your videos
0 likesAwsome crap dude, I totally subscribed (:!!!!
0 likesi love how ur wearing the hat the WHOLE TIME! lololololololololol
0 likesI know this video is about the moon and how long is a 100 moons but after watching this video I started going back to your old videos just to see the ones more so that being said I went to the video that was said " who is the shadow pony" wean it got to the part wean you talked about zecora may be the shadow pony but you also said star swirl could be the shadow pony but then Leeds me to an another video that you said discord could be star swirl know "WHAT IF?" You are right discord is star swirl what comes back to zecora and star swirl they both rim in a way one rims as for wisdom a making wis moves (zecora) as for star swirl is to rim for casting a spell and the both tie to gather but back to the shadow pony in my mind zecora can not be the shadow pony but star swirl can but going back to discord and star swirl they both have the same looks but in my mind "WHAT IF" star swirl was working on the spell and as he was he's mind was then corrupted bye something that want wrong and his body was then turned into discord's body but comes back to the shadow pony what if it's not a pony at all "WHAT IF" it's the spirit of star swirl looking for a way to get back his body and the day that something want wrong was way he did not Finnish the spell that is just my thought on the shadow pony I would love to see what you have to say and see ya :3 :3 :3 :3 :3
0 likesThis was uploaded on my freaking birthday!!!
0 likesor they just counted the moon that past
0 likesI think that the moon is nothing like equestrian because there are way to many ponies
0 likesi love your videos
0 likesI know this video is about the moon and how long is a 100 moons but after watching this video I started going back to your old videos just to see the ones more so that being said I went to the video that was said " who is the shadow pony" wean it got to the part wean you talked about zecora may be the shadow pony but you also said star swirl could be the shadow pony but then Leeds me to an another video that you said discord could be star swirl know "WHAT IF?" You are right discord is star swirl what comes back to zecora and star swirl they both rim in a way one rims as for wisdom a making wis moves (zecora) as for star swirl is to rim for casting a spell and the both tie to gather but back to the shadow pony in my mind zecora can not be the shadow pony but star swirl can but going back to discord and star swirl they both have the same looks but in my mind "WHAT IF" star swirl was working on the spell and as he was he's mind was then corrupted bye something that want wrong and his body was then turned into discord's body but comes back to the shadow pony what if it's not a pony at all "WHAT IF" it's the spirit of star swirl looking for a way to get back his body and the day that something want wrong was way he did not Finnish the spell that is just my thought on the shadow pony I would love to see what you have to say and see ya
0 likesIt's simple really the summer sun celebration is the longest day of the year could it be the new year for my little pony?
0 likesGreat Theory!
0 likesYes, all that makes sense in my mind. Maybe some photos were lost....
0 likesPleeeeease do Does Pinkie Pie have ADHD??? I would luv it! Btw nice job earning 20,000 subs! I am proud to be in that number! :)
you should do a video with Canned Cream.
0 likesI've got a bit of an complaint with your thearoy because every episode seems to be everyday and the family reunions mite only have a few weeks apart!that explains why apple bloom looks the same from the second last family photo!
0 likesThis... expains a lot actually.
0 likesWAIT WAIT WAIT I JUST REALIZED WHERE IN TH WORLD IS APPLEJACK'S PARENTS IN THE PHOTOS!!?!??!
1 likeSorry Caps20000?? What?? Then that means since I first subscribed to ur channel (around 6 MONTHS ago) ur amount of subs has multiplied by 10!! TELL ME UR SECRETS
0 likesThis doesn't really change anything but Celestia and Luna did not create years system but unicorns
0 likesI never thought about it that way
0 likesI might not be understanding this right but, in the video you said that the family reunion happens every hundred moons and that the reunion equals to every two years. But then you said that every hundred moons equals a year. So doesn't that mean that the reunion is every year or that fifty moons is a year. I might of miss heard you and I'm probably misunderstanding you so I apologize if I offend you in anyway.
0 likesReplies (2)
he's saying that it would two earth years
0 likesOh ok. Thanks.
0 likesTrue but applebloom may have a problem to grow and can you use this as a episode
0 likes30 moons 1 month
0 likes100 moons 4-5 years i think
Replies (1)
100 moons 1 year it might be a little hard but it might be it because they cant have it every 2-5 months thats to much and they cant have it every 5-6 years thats to long and it might be a family reunion every 1 year to celebrate here family on the first day they had it ust like Christmas and other holidays
0 likesSo that means ponies are older than we think and fluttershy is like two human years old than pinkiepie. Do they even have new years in equestria?
0 likesWho is your favorite Brony/Pegasister Youtuber?
0 likesI'm just wondering cause @Sparkle Lunafire is going to start this question Very soon
Replies (1)
...Don't take my ideas Lunar
0 likesHappy New Year! :)
0 likesWe'll in a famous book series called warriors about cats surviving in groups in the wild 1 moon is a mouth
0 likesFillies without a cutie mark dont grow yet
0 likesOh and dear princesses celesta I don't now how to spell that, do A episode every time a new MLP episode comes out please?
1 likeI have a idea
0 likesLet's talking about another pony!!
Trixie or derpy or more
yay~
Oh my god this js so awsome I just keep on waching all the time!!!!!!
0 likesHello the brony notion:)I wanna be an analytist JUST LIKE YOU!Im sorry I asked, but how do you do your videos?:)On instagram you saw my cat Albert. OMG, OMG I cant belive im writingto my FAVORITE ANALYTIST!!!!!!!!!
1 likeReplies (1)
Albert is cute :3 For my videos I always write the script and then record it. I use a program called audacity to edit the rough recording. Then I edit the video part in another program called Adobe Premier Elements. One that's done I upload it. The whole project takes an average of 10 so it's a lot of work. I'm glad I've inspired you! :)
1 likeWho is best FILLY of CMC and three other fillies, Brony Notion's choice.
0 likesIts similar to the book Warrior Cats (I don't read it btw my friends do) in warrior cats they say "moons" instead of years.
0 likesReplies (3)
OMG I LOVE WARRIOR CATS!!! Whos ur favorite? Mine's Scourge.
0 likesActually...a moon in the Warriors series is actually a month...sorry..
0 likesik
0 likesIn warrior cats 1 moon is 1 month
0 likesYou are the best do more videos I love you.
0 likesHow do you come up with topics for your videos?
0 likesWhy don't you do how old is celestia and Luna
0 likesHey BN i was looking at the episode Apple family Reunion and When it shows all 6 ponies when They are talking about the 7 legend race IT shows à ponie on the tight töat looks an AUFAUL LOT like applebloom could IT possibly be her mot
0 likesWhy moons and not Suns?
0 likesMay i say, "equestria is NOT earth", so how do you know exactly how big the sun is, AND the the affects of gravity on equestria? Exactly. YOU DONT, Their sun could be a lot different from ours, as well as the landscape there, changing the sun's approach. Besides, if the CLOUDS there can't move, how is the SUN supposed to move by itself? Celestia does it, after all, that is her cutie mark, and I'm PRETTY sure you can't get a cutie mark for a fake talent? as you said, you claim Celestia is faking her whole "raises the sun everyday thing".
0 likesReplies (6)
it's a continent on earth though
0 likes@taylor marie hayton how do YOU know? there's nothing in the show, or anything that says its on EARTH? prove it.
0 likesactually there has first there was a line in a song that was supposed to be the end song for EQG second they've actually said it in the show
0 likes@taylor marie hayton Okay, can you proof read that sentence? it makes no sense.. what does "actually, there has first there was a like...." make any sense?
0 likesMaybe she just spins true earth.
0 likes@Ruth Turner I don't know.. We'll never know :l
0 likesExactly 21k hype!
0 likesI like your theory
0 likes(Noting to do with this vid)
0 likesGuy you know in season 4 ep 1 MLP IS A YEAR SO FAR
if this was appleblooms first family reunion then why isent she only 2 earth years old
0 likesThe problem is applefamily reunion and season 4 premiere.
0 likesIf 100 moons =1 E yr....
0 likesThat 30 moons = 4 E months....
Fuqqqqqqqq Im so confused
The story behind the sonic rain boom
0 likesWHERE IS THE NEW EPISODE!
0 likesAnd HAPPY NEW YEAR TO U 2!
0 likesHAPPY NEW YEAR
0 likesyou should get a lot of subs your a awesome anaylist
0 likesAppawl frittewz? UMG SO KEWT <Explodes>
0 likesit was u, i saw one of your oplder videos and u were the guy with the changeling OC. why dont u make that anymore? it was fun.
0 likeshappy new yearrrrrrrrrrrrrrr throws glitter at everyone
13 likes:3
Replies (2)
Yaaaayyy
2 likesThe New Year Eve wasn't special, this year was not special at all
1 likeThat was so confusing...
0 likesWhy don't we make a video why discord like fluttershy or princess celestia? XD
0 likesEquestria is on earth they mention France in the cutie pox
0 likesHey it's Party hat from B.O.T.O
0 likesCan you answer why pegesi can get flight taken! Plz! And magic and strength! By tirek!
0 likesman you need to change your graphics on your pony back to normal
0 likesYou are awesome
0 likesI like your videos thay are all about mlp and like mlp the show do you
0 likesI mean fifty moons
0 likesOh pls pls pls do a vidoe on king sombra's backstory
0 likesWhat about the story behind Snails cutie mark? And if u go back to G1 there is a girl version of snips and snails. And do u think the cutie mark cuasaders will ever get there cutie mark I mean siriousely!!!!!
0 likesDear mister my theory is that've the Sumer sun selebration is an anule thing and apple famaly reonyon hapend in seson 3 so it hopes every year and the pictorial that are missing are because they went to the other famaly farms
0 likesBaby apple jack= 3= + 😍 × 10000 = awwwwww over load
0 likeshello this is triple tank one also this is my personal channel I also admire your admiration in your phone s for your brownie Nation channel I hope you the best of luck for you and yeah this is giving you a shout up
0 likesCLUB PENGUIN BETA HAT REFERENCE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 likeshave you thought about making a video about pinkemina
0 likesSorry i meant could it possibly be her mom
0 likesCan u do an ep about derpy
0 likesApple bloom I suppose to be apple jacks age in he first picture
0 likesAlmost 21000
0 likesPleas talk about pinky pie having ADHD
0 likes#1. can I call you BN for short
1 like#2.can u do an episode on the mane 6 #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 worst to best
Ok u keep saying moon not full moon so that would more so mean in 24 hours 1 moon and 1 sun would happen an in 30 days 30 moons and 30 suns will happen so it's more so saying now correct me if am wrong but I do not remember it saying a specific face of the moon so it would not be talking about the specific moon an the portal is just open for a certain amount of days correct?
0 likesOh I am still waching this (: (:
0 likesYou are 1 subscriber away from 21000 OMG
0 likesHappy new year first video to u !
0 likesSo my little dashie whaaaaaa
0 likesThis vid help me
0 likeswhat is your real name the brony nation
1 likeReplies (1)
my name is anna stover
1 likeWFERE WAS NICHOLAS CAGE???????!??!?!??
0 likes21,254 sub's now!
0 likesI dont get it ? -_-
0 likesHE HAS BETA HAT
0 likesHACKER
REPORTING
Lol.you don't say?!
0 likesYou don't say?
0 likes⊙ω⊙⊙ω⊙⊙ω⊙
............................................................ I don't get this at all how am I going to do this :I so one moon = a day right? soooooo...... I DONT KNOW WHAT TO TELL YA K???? K im done so see u in a other video lol bye :)
0 likesOf course equestria isn't the same as earth
0 likesReplies (6)
But what about what Pinkie said in "Hearths Warming Eve" in their play?
0 likesApplejack : The map is upside down
Pinkie : Well i got a news flash for you cookie. The Earth is round, there is no upside down
SHE SAID "EARTH" WHY ISN'T ANYONE BRINGING THIS UP? O_o
A mistake
0 likesAre you sure? Don't tell me they live in Equestria. Okay, sure they live in Equestria, but Equestria is only a continent
0 likesactually equestria isn't the name of the world it's only a continent
0 likesThat's what i said
0 likes@Indonesian Brony Well, that's before even Celestia and Luna, and we know both are over 1000 years old. The ponies in the play were the founders of Equestria, meaning that Earth was the name of the planet at THAT time, but it could've been changed over time.
0 likesMonth*
0 likesHmmm
0 likesAre you a changling
0 likesHi everybody
0 likeswut
0 likesReplies (1)
I-
0 likesWhy did I comment this?
you are not a changeling!!!!!!!!!!! but you are a human and you go to highschool !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! bumer!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1 likeyou dont say???
0 likeshi im apple jack more appwle fwitters?
0 likesFour months and 7days= 100 moons mathematics I am. 9 sucka
0 likesYou dont say?
0 likes