I have a thought. So I have thought this through and actually my theory is either in Equestria 10 moons is a year. Why 10?  Well lets think about it both ways
If it was 10 moons equals 1 year in Equestria then that means the reunion happens every 10 years which makes sense since its an even amount of time between reunions. Enough time for it to be not a hassle for everyone to go so often but long enough so no one misses anyone for too long. It would also makes sense why Applejack was so young in the one reunion and now a grown up helping to plan it (and I will say it now the one picture with the three of them in it I call a mistake since it wouldn't be the first time they're visuals didn't match the description).
 Also lets keep in Mind Granny Smith. She was very young when Ponyville was founded so to know each detail and to have so many found memories, it would all make sense. It would also make ensue why Applebloom would be excited to see Babs since it would be their first met us since she was introduced and it would also explain how she didn't know her well before since they both are probably either just 10 in pony years or a little younger.
Another reason why it would make sense for it to be 10 months is a year would explain how imperative it was for Twilight to get in and get out. 3 years is a long time to be stuck anywhere, especially if you are royalty and are part of the first line of defense for that country. It would also explain why we never saw Sunset Shimmer before because consider this. Our cycle runs on 29,5 moon cycle system and Equestria runs on just 10. Which means each 3 years in Equestria would only be a year for Sunset Shimmer. Which means it would make it even more likely why she was gone for so long. So lets just say Sunset was in her senior year in high school when she was in Equestria girls. That means she was there for 4 years, translated for 12 years in Equestria. Of course Twilight would not have met her because she was long gone before Twilight even began studying and around the time Sunset Shimmer say came around the time of even just the 3rd year, 9 years in Equestria since she left, this would be the big rise for Twilight and thats how she found everything out.
Sorry this is lengthy but this is my theory. What do you think?

wont work. if its every 10 years. twilight would have to be for 10 years considering when she apreared the apples where just having a reunion.

@CoolioCats614 Even if it didn't, and each season was a year, that's still around 3 years between reunions.  So either way, the whole 100 moons is 10 years thing is busted.  It's either around one year, or three years.  Plus, since we saw Apple Bloom as a young filly in the first reunion, she would have to be an older teen to young adult if the second took place 10 years later, and she's still a young filly.

It did? Man I totally forgot that! Hmmm....

There's one major problem with that:  The pilot episode had an Apple Family Reunion, and then there was another in Season 3.  Season 4 episode 1 establishes that between Season 1 and Season 4 was one year.  So, since there was already 2 Apple Family Reunions in that one year, 100 moons can't be 10 years.


With this idea it would show how alot of the stuff can happen the way it does in the show and yet still only be 1 year by the time season 4 gets here


well I can tell you a bit about time in Equestria. In the first episode of my little pony it was the summer sun celebration where Celestia raises the sun. the second time it was mentioned was in episode 23 Cutie Mark Chronicles when Twilight says she saw it as a filly. A thousand years later after that episode the next Summer Sun Celebration, Twilight was a princess and Celestia now says the summer celebration is a time when we are happy that Luna is back. So I guess that can help you a bit on years in Equestria. Right now we know that ponies live for a VERY long time (thinking of Celestia and Luna) and the summer sun celebration is like the stages of a human. start as a filly,then you are like child next your a teen, I'm guessing teen because in Equestria girls Twilight had a crush on Flash and she was in a high school and when she was back in Equestria the girls were acting kinda girly talking about her crush. so a thousand years is like the stages of growing up :) I hope I helped a bit good luck ;)

but in pony time they dont go by years like us in equestria girls sure yeah shes a teenager but in ponyville shes a teenager in well how many years equals teenager for ponies

but twilight isn't 1000 years old shes a teenager...


You just made it more confusing for me... I think the Equestrian moons are the same as earth moons: 29.5 days. After all, it would make more sense in two of the episodes in which it was used:

"I still can't believe it's been almost one hundred moons since our last family reunion!"
   - Granny Smith; Apple Family Reunion

"This is no ordinary mirror. It is a gateway to another world. A gateway that opens once every thirty moons."
   - Princess Luna; Equestria Girls

"My plunderseeds should have stolen the magic from the Tree of Harmony and captured Princess Celestia and Princess Luna thousands of moons ago."
   - Discord; Princess Twilight Sparkle

These are the only three instances of the term "moons" (unless I'm missing some) in My Little Pony, and the latter two make sense. We don't know how long ago Sunset Shimmer went through the portal that's just been introduced, so it could have been 2.4-year intervals, and 12,000 moons qualifies more as "thousands of moons" than 200,000 moons. However, the discontinuity lies in Apple Family Reunion, right? No, it technically lies in the previous reunion in Friendship is Magic - Part 1, and it's a different type of discontinuity. The thing is... I can clear up this mystery using only two words: Extraneous Reunion. Kind of like "Extraneous Solutions" on a graph to represent discontinuity, the Apples had an "Extraneous Reunion" especially for the Summer Sun Celebration. From what we've seen thus far, the Summer Sun Celebration usually takes place in Canterlot, and Celestia set it up in Ponyville to get Twilight to meet the rest of the Mane 6. However, one unintended side-effect was Applejack. The Apple Family Reunions usually take place at Sweet Apple Acres, from what we've seen, so this would be the perfect occasion to host one. It didn't count toward the 100-moon cycle however, because the main reason it existed was the Summer Sun Celebration. That was the main event, and likely the reason all of those relatives even came (also the reason Granny Smith didn't count it as an official reunion). We don't see very many of them there after all, and they aren't distinguishable from each other like in Apple Family Reunion. However, that doesn't mean they couldn't take the photo in front of the barn and it doesn't mean some of the Apples, like Apple Rose and Apple Fritter, weren't in the barn or off sleeping somewhere when AJ was introducing Twilight to everyone. So, yeah. Extraneous Reunions.

You just made it more confusing for me... I think the Equestrian moons are the same as earth moons: 29.5 days. After all, it would make more sense in two of the episodes in which it was used:

"I still can't believe *it's been almost one hundred moons* since our last family reunion!"
   - Granny Smith; Apple Family Reunion

"This is no ordinary mirror. It is a gateway to another world. A gateway that opens *once every thirty moons*."
   - Princess Luna; Equestria Girls

"My plunderseeds should have stolen the magic from the Tree of Harmony and captured Princess Celestia and Princess Luna *thousands of moons ago*."
   - Discord; Princess Twilight Sparkle

These are the only three instances of the term "moons" (unless I'm missing some) in My Little Pony, and the latter two make sense. We don't know how long ago Sunset Shimmer went through the portal that's just been introduced, so it could have been 2.4-year intervals, and 12,000 moons qualifies more as "thousands of moons" than 200,000 moons. However, the discontinuity lies in Apple Family Reunion, right? No, it technically lies in the previous reunion in Friendship is Magic - Part 1, and it's a different type of discontinuity. The thing is... I can clear up this mystery using only two words: *Extraneous Reunion*. Kind of like "Extraneous Solutions" on a graph to represent discontinuity, the Apples had an "Extraneous Reunion" especially for the Summer Sun Celebration. From what we've seen thus far, the Summer Sun Celebration usually takes place in Canterlot, and Celestia set it up in Ponyville to get Twilight to meet the rest of the Mane 6. However, one unintended side-effect was Applejack. The Apple Family Reunions usually take place at Sweet Apple Acres, from what we've seen, so this would be the perfect occasion to host one. It didn't count toward the 100-moon cycle however, because the main reason it existed was the Summer Sun Celebration. That was the main event, and likely the reason all of those relatives even came (also the reason Granny Smith didn't count it as an official reunion). We don't see very many of them there after all, and they aren't distinguishable from each other like in Apple Family Reunion. However, that doesn't mean they couldn't take the photo in front of the barn and it doesn't mean some of the Apples, like Apple Rose and Apple Fritter, weren't in the barn or off sleeping somewhere when AJ was introducing Twilight to everyone. So, yeah. Extraneous Reunions.


In the Warriors book series, a gathering is held every time the moon is full. The cats' ages are known by moons. A moon is told apart from the gatherings, one moon is the time between two gatherings.
Just thought I should say.
Also, you should do "Is Commander Hurricane a mare or stallion?"


I'm thinking that ponies age slower than humans (MAGIC, duh) and by that their years are a bit longer than ours.
I do agree that 100 moons lead up to a year, but that year might be longer than just 365/366 days for ONE reason.....
All the festivals that happen in Equestria. There must be SO many of them, and they wouldn't fit into the year time-span that we have, There's just not enough time for all that planning, then setting it up, and then having the festival before the next one comes up. So, I'm thinking that a year lasts at least...maybe around 500 days.
So, what about the seasons? Yep, they last longer too. But I think that summer/spring are the longest seasons as ponies do control the weather year-round (although I think in some years they laze off which makes them last a bit longer).
....And that's all I got. ^u^


During the first episode, the apple family reunion was during the Summer Sun Celebration, so, assuming that the Summer Sun Celebration occurs once every year, shouldn't the apple family reunion also be once a year, or did the apple family reunion happen during the Summer Sun Celebration in the first episode just for plot convenience?


8 YEARS AND 6 MONTHS!!!! I did it on my own without the video, and with a little help with a calculator.


Between season 1 episode 2 and season 4 episode 2 is exactly a year which means the apple family reuions are one year apart. So 100 moons are roughly and equestrian year.


the Summer sun celebration interferes with your theory. in season 1 episode 1&2 this is the time of the summer Sun Celebration. it marks the meeting of the heroes, applefamily reunion and the return of Princess Luna. in season 3 episode 8 we see another Applefamily reunion. and at the end of season 4 episode 2 we see the Summer Sun Celebration. these lines are proof:

In apple Family reunion Granny Smith stated that they do it every 100 moons. and in the two part premiere of season 4 this lines happens:

Celestia: Now I can look forward to the Summer Sun Celebration.

Twilight: Why?

Celestia: For my Subjects it is for defeating Nightmare moon, for me it is a reminder that I had to banish my own sister.

Twilight: I never thought of it that way.

Celestia: it is her first one back.

So that proves the summer sun celebration is 1 year. and it is after the applefamily reunion. I think one year is 150 moons. because if you look throughout all the episodes there are pages of a days and every time we seen them. there are 30 squares. this means a year has to be divisible by 30. 100 isn't. but 150 is. 120 just seems to even.


Have you guyz ever spotted how Luna met everyone during the ceremony, and on Nightmare Night everyone still runs from her.


I have always wondered that, but was to lazy to research it myself. Great video! ;)


you don't swear, you make good points, and you post a lot! i am subscribing!


It would be cool if you made a episode focused on your OC being a changling.


I know they said  from the End of the 1st Movie to the Sirise coming to the School in Rainbow Rock  was just 6 Moons   So  Season 4 had to take place in a total of 5 to the 6 Moons    Lets go back to Season 3 for a sec    we had 2 Eps that took place at the same time.   The Eps Spike took care of the Pets and the Eps were the girls were in the Crystal Empire  showing the inspector for the Equestian Games (Olypics) around.   So  some Eps could took place at the same time in Season 4.    But that a streatch.  We know in Season 2  a Week is 7 days long.  Because Twilight had to send a letter ever week  but she missed this week and at sun set  Princess Celestria showed up.

Also when asked one of the people workes on the show says  Equestian Moon can not be told in Human Time.

So a Moon could a Month.  We know the last time the mirror open up was 30 Moons ago when Sunset shimmer used it   she left  shortly before Twilight because PCs  student   so figure out how long  she been her student and that is how long 30 Moons is  then we can figure out how long a Moon is.

But again they said it can not be told in human time


here's an idea. in one of the comics optimus prime from transformers is visible (regular mlp comics). and flash sentry's car looks like an erbona 500. a car from transformers prime. is it possible that these 2 universes are connected?

also let's not forget pinkie pie's optimus costume


There's also the fact that the apples had family reunion on the first episode when twilight first met them, so could that play a part?


No celebrations are repeated in MLP until episodes 4.1 & 4.2  & " princess twilight sparkle" with the summer sun celebration. They do not outright  say it but to me it is heavily implied that this was their first anniversary of those events. This means, to me, that all of the events in the show up to the beginning of season 4 take place within 1 year. This would mean Apple family reunions happen fairly frequently. Again, no other holidays or celebrations seem to repeat until season 4.


Just saying what if 100 moons was 100 years so each moon was a years and crystal ponies lived for maybe 1000 or more so maybe normal ponies would have the same age span so that is why they change so much over those 100 years . Also Apple Bloom was just a mistake that the show always makes


I think it was just a logic mix up. Mlp does that a lot, like for example when celestia said blue blood was her nephew, but that means blue blood would have to be luna's son or there would have to be a third royal sister, which the show downs suggest at all. See, mlp doesn't always watch their logic, like with the moon theory.

Sorry I meant to say "which the show doesn't suggest at all


Keep in mind that there is a theory that Equestria is Earth after an apocalypse (look in to it, it's kinda complicated for a comment) so maybe there's another viable system for 'moons' based on real earth.


I see one moon as one month ( mostly because i am used to it in the Warrior cats book series). But in that case, it would be 12 moons = one year, and 100 moons would be....... a veeeery long time. But, it maybe is one month anyways, since ponies live alot longer than humans.<br>Im not smart, so this post is pretty wierd xD

I see one moon as one month ( mostly because i am used to it in the Warrior cats book series). But in that case, it would be 12 moons = one year, and 100 moons would be....... a veeeery long time. But, it maybe is one month anyways, since ponies live alot longer than humans.
Im not smart, so this post is pretty wierd xD


In MLP the fourth season started off as it being once year since Luna returned from the moon, which in our time was 4 years ago. So one year there=4 years here.


Well.... Someone did their homework. I've thought a lot about this same subject for...reasons.

It's possible that Equus itself rotates very slowly, or wobbles, and that that is what constitutes a year.


A moon is one full cycle of all the stages of the moon. Like, cresent, full, half, new, etc.


Yay! Happy 20,000 subscribers! That's a pretty nice way to start a new year off.


You changed mywhole perspective, i Read warrios and they refer to moons as well, in equestria, i always thought moons where months. In warrios, they say that a kit or kitten has to be 6 moons old to become an apprentice,so i was thinking 6 moons is 6 months, but i could be wrong (i know you may not have a clue what im talking about with this warriosr thing it was an example


Happy 20,000 subs!! And it makes since that 100 moons is one year in Equestian time.  Your guess is as good as mine. It just seems easiest to me. lol


Well I like your theory because based on our past cultures the consep of time was changed like Stonehenge people beleave it was made to calculate time using the sun and moon and where on the planet you are could change how you see days go by so yes I think there idea of time could be different


So would the theory that 50 moons would be when Zap Apples are harvested? Since they only can be harvested once when the moon is at its highest? Anyone care to explore this theory?


my theory is the lunar cycle as you said i was just thinking in our time so i thought every moon was a month


I guessed 100 moons was basically 100 days or so, a new moon each night. It's not like it said 100 full moons


Maybe 100 moons is just a year, in our time. Because in some Native American tribes, (mine included) it is believed that each month has 3 moons in it. Event though it is only 36, it might explain something.


Congrats for 20,000 subscribers! Sucessful new year is a foot! (or a leg)


AMAZING!!!!!!! very good calculation!!!👍👍👍👍👍


Equstra years are 3 times longer from the first episode to the first episode of season 4 was abought 3-4 people years.

And am I the only one who remembers that season 5 comes out this year


I guessed that 100 moons was one Equestria year myself. If one Equestria year equals 2 normal earth years then that explains why Equestrian years seem longer.


Could you do a video about why there is a guillotine in Equestria.

It's in the episode 'May the best pet win'.

Just curious.


applebloom barely looks younger but still does in the picture


Well when I watch mlp, I usally act like every episode is two weeks to make more sense because really a bad thing happens everytime it would be weird to have one every week so why not every 2?


If the sun is only moving around equestria then, is there more than one sun? I mean, equestria is'nt the whole world... it's probably just a continent right?...right?


100 moons? So 1 year? But Granny Smith is 1 year before wasn't that young! I think 100 moons=10 years.


i feel stupid cus mostly everyone are saying good theory's, same w/the brony notion... and im just sitting here trying to create a theory.


Wait, in two years twilight, defeated nightmare moon, then discord, then sombra, became a human, got her crown back and became an alicorn?


@The Brony Notion You should do a video on what happens when one of the pony's from the crusaders get there cutiemark.


how old is granny smith? wasn't she there for the founding of ponyvile? also what about celestia and luna? and finally thanks for the video. thats a common question that my brother and i ask


Well no  the summer solsice celbration happened in season one episode 1 and then again in season4 episode 1 so each season is a season 3 months to be exact and also there was a reunion in the pilot then later on so thats the time period of each reunion about 10 months or so , making 10 moons each month showing 1/3 of each season is a month and is ten moons  so a hundred moons is about in our time 3 an 1/3 mlp seasons and there anout ten months


I think a hundred moons is a year. Like in June that would be twelve moons


If you can find more evidence can you do a star-swirl the bearded episode


Maybe just maybe... in equestria 30 moons are 3 months and 100 moons is 1 year and on earth 30 moons are 30 days and 100 moons is 100 days because earth doesn't work like equestria because
1. Equestria is on a mythological - like world in a different universe and a TV show so it Clearly doesn't exist obviously.
2. Even though equestria doesn't exist it does have magical and mythological ponies and creatures that can happen on earth despite before we we're even born there could've been strange and mythological things that were somehow defeated, reformed or resolved by magic just like how the mane 6 use magic for all 3 of those things. So clearly earth doesn't really do the same balance as in equestria.


Wow!! This makes sense now..... But... How could Granny Smith age that fast... Well Equestria is NOT earth so... And ponies do age faster so this makes sense


The Brony Notion, you may have shown Apple Jack's mother and father ( In 1:18 ) Because I went back and looked at Granny Smith's age. One showed her very young, older and older. And Apple Jack and Apple Bloom look younger in the picture in 1:18. But, Big Mac. It looks like he doesn't age, so I could be wrong. But, the the two ponies on -> that side looks like her mother and father but, that baby looks like it's theirs' so. And the two ponies on <---- that side could be it too. So its a fact I have been thinking about.

The Brony Notion, you may have shown Apple Jack's mother and father ( In 1:18 ) Because I went back and looked at Granny Smith's age. One showed her very young, older and older. And Apple Jack and Apple Bloom look younger in the picture in 1:18. But, Big Mac. It looks like he doesn't age, so I could be wrong. But, the the two ponies on ---> that side looks like her mother and father but, that baby looks like it's theirs' so. And the two ponies on <---- that side could be it too. So its a fact I have been thinking about.

That One Eyeshadow No Uses In The Palette


Claudis Ptolemy was right! Um... in a way. For a little girls show that came around 2000 years later...


This lost a lot of its credibility to me after he revealed this is based on the assumption their system is Geocentric.


THANK YOU SO MUCH for not just saying 1 moon = 1 month!


Ok the first apple reunion was in season 1 and the other one was in season  4 so that means that 100 moons is 3 seasons  in my little pony


In this case , it says in equestria girls, she has 3 days to get the crown and luna said  when the moon is at its peek on the 3day the portal will close that shows that 1moon = 1day or 1day = 1moon  so 100 moons is 100 days and so is 30 moons to 30 days


Do you want to do a collab?~
No really though, I wanna get your ideas and thoughts on an interesting story. Because MLP has a lot to do with greek mythology, I wanted to see if I could share theories on the subject "The story of fenrir"
Edit: Dammit I forgot it's called Collab, not cameo! I'm a dunce


Which begs the question, why didn't Granny Smith said "It's been a year since the last Reunion", it's like if I said "Come back 4 weeks after today" instead of "Come back next month".

Also what about seasons? Months? etc...

@Jordan Heath<br>Where's Santa? He's in G3 (no, seriously, he is).

@Jordan Heath
Where's Santa? He's in G3 (no, seriously, he is).

@BioniclesaurKing4t2 But where' the presents? Where's Santa Pony?

They may have established how it was established but they didn't explain the celebration. Yet?

@Jordan Heath<br>They put on plays and sing carols. And get their tongues stuck on 8-foot candy canes.

@Jordan Heath
They put on plays and sing carols. And get their tongues stuck on 8-foot candy canes.

I think it's deliberately vague as to what she meant by one-hundred moons. Either DHX want's the fanbase to build Equestria themselves, or they themselves have no idea how their own world works. Speaking of vague events that god won't tell us about, what DO ponies do on Hearths Warming Eve?


In Warrior Cats a moon is equivalent to a month


What about the pilot there was a family reunion and there are less family members in the pitcher then when twilight arrived on her first day at ponyville.


Hey don't mean to be hating but the first episode of season 4 said that only one year had passed after the first episode so maybe the moons really are just days?<br>


Make more videos like one a day and what program did you use?

I like you vids hey every body like this if they liked this video. thank you for the awesome videos and please keep uploading them. Thank you!!!


So, in Equestria are 8 seasons per year?


well what if they did it every two years but apple bloom rally wanted to see babs again so the changed the days of the reunion to every hundred moons. it makes a bit more sense that none of them aged in the picture but there were a lot more so it still doesn't so much sense to me how so many more were in that last picture, Now i know that not all of came to the reunion every year because they were busy but HOW ARE THERE SO MANY APPLES THAT I CAN'T EAT!!! :( :( :( :)


You should do a video about why daring do and rainbow dash look almost exactly alike.


the moon moves in the moon calendar so if you can see the first night the moon is nether full or new moon.so the portal is like a  cell phone it has to charge of 30 day or month's so the portal is solar and lunar powered but how did starswirl now this portal thing so the book that sunset had uses limitless power when twilight uses the other book the portal was limitless.


I got a question. Think about it. What is it with Princess Gold Lilly and Princess Sterling in the new Hasbro toys?


I disagree, I think that Equestria is solar centric


wasn't there a reunion in the first episode? if I remember clearly?


nothing to do with moons but i saw mlp eg and HAD to ask this question. what if pinkie got through the portal? would one pinkie die or would they both stay. i mean you cant stay with yourself if u came from the future or past right? so something will happen and most likely to human pinkie.


And also they had 2 reunions in one year so 100 moons cannot be 1 year


moons means year cause I saw this one episode where discord was baished a thousand moons but another episode said it  was a thousand years


YAY glad to see you back i missed you soo much


but in applebuck season (hehe "buck") didn't aj say that twilight came to ponyville during one of the apple family reunions?


According to Granny Smith, the Apple family has a reunion every hundred moons. But how long exact-FFRREEIINNDDSS


in the Warriors series, 1 moon is 1 month.


Happy New Yeear! You know what this calls for? A Party!!!!!!!!!!


Previous vid: Does Twilight have OCD? Next should be: Where does Rainbow Dash live? Hint: to know where she lives, check the episode with "Singing Telegram" song.


i think that theory is awesome it makes so much sence love your videos


Awsome crap dude, I totally subscribed (:!!!!


i love how ur wearing the hat the WHOLE TIME! lololololololololol


I know this video is about the moon and how long is a 100 moons but after watching this video I started going back to your old videos just to see the ones more so that being said I went to the video that was said " who is the shadow pony" wean it got to the part wean you talked about zecora may be the shadow pony but you also said star swirl could be the shadow pony but then Leeds me to an another video that you said discord could be star swirl know "WHAT IF?" You are right discord is star swirl what comes back to zecora and star swirl they both rim in a way one rims as for wisdom a making wis moves (zecora) as for star swirl is to rim for casting a spell and the both tie to gather but back to the shadow pony in my mind zecora can not be the shadow pony but star swirl can but going back to discord and star swirl they both have the same looks but in my mind "WHAT IF" star swirl was working on the spell and as he was he's mind was then corrupted bye something that want wrong and his body was then turned into discord's body but comes back to the shadow pony what if it's not a pony at all "WHAT IF" it's the spirit of star swirl looking for a way to get back his body and the day that something want wrong was way he did not Finnish the spell that is just my thought on the shadow pony I would love to see what you have to say and see ya :3 :3 :3 :3 :3


This was uploaded on my freaking birthday!!!


I think that the moon is nothing like equestrian because there are way to many ponies


I know this video is about the moon and how long is a 100 moons but after watching this video I started going back to your old videos just to see the ones more so that being said I went to the video that was said " who is the shadow pony" wean it got to the part wean you talked about zecora may be the shadow pony but you also said star swirl could be the shadow pony but then Leeds me to an another video that you said discord could be star swirl know "WHAT IF?" You are right discord is star swirl what comes back to zecora and star swirl they both rim in a way one rims as for wisdom a making wis moves (zecora) as for star swirl is to rim for casting a spell and the both tie to gather but back to the shadow pony in my mind zecora can not be the shadow pony but star swirl can but going back to discord and star swirl they both have the same looks but in my mind "WHAT IF" star swirl was working on the spell and as he was  he's mind was then corrupted bye something that want wrong and his body was then turned into discord's body but comes back to the shadow pony what if it's not a pony at all "WHAT IF" it's the spirit of star swirl looking for a way to get back his body and the day that something want wrong was way he did not Finnish the spell that is just my thought on the shadow pony I would love to see what you have to say and see ya


It's simple really the summer sun celebration is the longest day of the year could it be the new year for my little pony?


Yes, all that makes sense in my mind. Maybe some photos were lost.... <br>Pleeeeease do Does Pinkie Pie have ADHD??? I would luv it! Btw nice job earning 20,000 subs! I am proud to be in that number! :)

Yes, all that makes sense in my mind. Maybe some photos were lost....
Pleeeeease do Does Pinkie Pie have ADHD??? I would luv it! Btw nice job earning 20,000 subs! I am proud to be in that number! :)


you should do a video with Canned Cream.


I've got a bit of an complaint with your thearoy because every episode seems to be everyday and the family reunions mite only have a few weeks apart!that explains why apple bloom looks the same from the second last family photo!


WAIT WAIT WAIT I JUST REALIZED WHERE IN TH WORLD IS APPLEJACK'S PARENTS IN THE PHOTOS!!?!??! <del>Sorry Caps</del>

WAIT WAIT WAIT I JUST REALIZED WHERE IN TH WORLD IS APPLEJACK'S PARENTS IN THE PHOTOS!!?!??! -Sorry Caps-


20000?? What?? Then that means since I first subscribed to ur channel (around 6 MONTHS ago) ur amount of subs has multiplied by 10!! TELL ME UR SECRETS


This doesn't really change anything but Celestia and Luna did not create years system but unicorns


I might not be understanding this right but, in the video you said that the family reunion happens every hundred moons and that the reunion equals to every two years. But then you said that every hundred moons equals a year. So doesn't that mean that the reunion is every year or that fifty moons is a year. I might of miss heard you and I'm probably misunderstanding you so I apologize if I offend you in anyway.

he's saying that it would two earth years


True but applebloom may have a problem to grow and can you use this as a episode


30 moons 1 month <br>100 moons 4-5 years i think

30 moons 1 month
100 moons 4-5 years i think

100 moons 1 year it might be a little hard but it might be it because they cant have it every 2-5 months thats to much and they cant have it every 5-6 years thats to long and it might be a family reunion every 1 year to celebrate here family on the first day they had it ust like Christmas and other holidays


So that means ponies are older than we think and fluttershy is like two human years old than pinkiepie. Do they even have new years in equestria?


Who is your favorite Brony/Pegasister Youtuber?<br>I'm just wondering cause @Sparkle Lunafire is going to start this question Very soon

Who is your favorite Brony/Pegasister Youtuber?
I'm just wondering cause @Sparkle Lunafire is going to start this question Very soon


We'll in a famous book series called warriors about cats surviving in groups in the wild 1 moon is a mouth


Fillies without a cutie mark dont grow yet


Oh and dear princesses celesta I don't now how to spell that, do A episode every time a new MLP episode comes out please?


I have a idea
Let's talking about another pony!!
Trixie or derpy or more
yay~


Oh my god this js so awsome I just keep on waching all the time!!!!!!


Hello the brony notion:)I wanna be an analytist JUST LIKE YOU!Im sorry I asked, but how do you do your videos?:)On instagram you saw my cat Albert. OMG, OMG I cant belive im writingto my FAVORITE ANALYTIST!!!!!!!!!

Albert is cute :3 For my videos I always write the script and then record it. I use a program called audacity to edit the rough recording. Then I edit the video part in another program called Adobe Premier Elements. One that's done I upload it. The whole project takes an average of 10 so it's a lot of work. I'm glad I've inspired you! :)


Who is best FILLY of CMC and three other fillies, Brony Notion's choice.


Its similar to the book Warrior Cats (I don't read it btw my friends do)  in warrior cats they say "moons" instead of years.

Actually...a moon in the Warriors series is actually a month...sorry..

OMG I LOVE WARRIOR CATS!!! Whos ur favorite? Mine's Scourge.


You are the best do more videos I love you.


How do you come up with topics for your videos?


Why don't you do how old is celestia and Luna


Hey BN i was looking at the episode Apple family Reunion and When it shows all 6 ponies when They are talking about the 7 legend race IT shows à ponie on the tight töat looks an AUFAUL LOT like applebloom could IT possibly be her mot


May i say, "equestria is NOT earth", so how do you know exactly how big the sun is, AND the the affects of gravity on equestria? Exactly. YOU DONT, Their sun could be a lot different from ours, as well as the landscape there, changing the sun's approach. Besides, if the CLOUDS there can't move, how is the SUN supposed to move by itself? Celestia does it, after all, that is her cutie mark, and I'm PRETTY sure you can't get a cutie mark for a fake talent? as you said, you claim Celestia is faking her whole "raises the sun everyday thing".

@Ruth Turner I don't know.. We'll never know :l

@taylor marie hayton Okay, can you proof read that sentence? it makes no sense.. what does "actually, there has first there was a like...." make any sense?

actually there has first there was a line in a song that was supposed to be the end song for EQG second they've actually said it in the show

@taylor marie hayton how do YOU know? there's nothing in the show, or anything that says its on EARTH? prove it.


(Noting to do with this vid)<br>Guy you know in season 4 ep 1 MLP IS A YEAR SO FAR

(Noting to do with this vid)
Guy you know in season 4 ep 1 MLP IS A YEAR SO FAR


if this was appleblooms first family reunion then why isent she only 2 earth years old


The problem is applefamily reunion and season 4 premiere.


If 100 moons =1 E yr....
That 30 moons = 4 E months....
Fuqqqqqqqq Im so confused


you  should get a lot of subs your a awesome anaylist


it was u, i saw one of your oplder videos and u were the guy with the changeling OC. why dont u make that anymore? it was fun.


happy new yearrrrrrrrrrrrrrr throws glitter at everyone
:3

happy new yearrrrrrrrrrrrrrr *throws glitter at everyone*
:3

The New Year Eve wasn't special, this year was not special at all


Why don't we make a video why discord like fluttershy or princess celestia? XD


Equestria is on earth they mention France in the cutie pox


Can you answer why pegesi can get flight taken! Plz! And magic and strength! By tirek!


man you need to change your graphics on your pony back to normal


I like your videos thay are all about mlp and like mlp the show do you


Oh pls pls pls do a vidoe on king sombra's backstory


What about the story behind Snails cutie mark? And if u go back to G1 there is a girl version of snips and snails.    And do u think the cutie mark cuasaders will ever get there cutie mark I mean siriousely!!!!!


Dear mister my theory is that've the Sumer sun selebration is an anule thing and apple famaly reonyon hapend in seson 3 so it hopes every year and the pictorial that are missing are because they went to the other famaly farms


Baby apple jack= 3= + 😍 × 10000 = awwwwww over load


hello this is triple tank one also this is my personal channel I also admire your admiration in your phone s for your brownie Nation channel I hope you the best of luck for you and yeah this is giving you a shout up


CLUB PENGUIN BETA HAT REFERENCE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


have you thought about making a video about pinkemina


Sorry i meant could it possibly be her mom


Apple bloom I suppose to be apple jacks age in he first picture


#1. can I call you BN for short <br>#2.can u do an episode on the mane 6 #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 worst to best

#1. can I call you BN for short
#2.can u do an episode on the mane 6 #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 worst to best


Ok u keep saying moon not full moon so that would more so mean in 24 hours 1 moon and 1 sun would happen an in 30 days 30 moons and 30 suns will happen so it's more so saying now correct me if am wrong but I do not remember it saying a specific face of the moon so it would not be talking about the specific moon an the portal is just open for a certain amount of days correct?


You are 1 subscriber away from 21000 OMG


You don't say?<br>                                             ⊙ω⊙⊙ω⊙⊙ω⊙

You don't say?
                                             ⊙ω⊙⊙ω⊙⊙ω⊙


............................................................ I don't get this at all how am I going to do this :I so one moon = a day right? soooooo...... I DONT KNOW WHAT TO TELL YA K???? K im done so see u in a other video lol bye :)


Of course equestria isn't the same as earth

@Indonesian Brony Well, that's before even Celestia and Luna, and we know both are over 1000 years old. The ponies in the play were the founders of Equestria, meaning that Earth was the name of the planet at THAT time, but it could've been changed over time.

actually equestria isn't the name of the world it's only a continent

Are you sure? Don't tell me they live in Equestria. Okay, sure they live in Equestria, but Equestria is only a continent

But what about what Pinkie said in "Hearths Warming Eve" in their play?
Applejack : The map is upside down
Pinkie       : Well i got a news flash for you cookie. The Earth is round, there is no upside down

SHE SAID "EARTH" WHY ISN'T ANYONE BRINGING THIS UP? O_o


Four months and 7days= 100 moons mathematics  I am. 9 sucka