Alright, clearly I need to do this. WARNING: Trigger topics and unpopular opinions ahead. Long comment ahoy. Please reserve all judgement til the end, or leave if the length or topic offends you.
I have this personal, slightly unfavorable headcanon as to why Rainbow Dash doesn't often embody her element: she has serious issues trusting anyone. As we see in most flashback episodes, Dash was a reckless youth who lived life her way. As seen in human society, those types often live their lives too fast...and wind up a parent too soon. In my mind--and here is the unfavorable part--Dash is Scootaloo's mother, but gave her up. Reviewing their interactions and comparing them against how people (re)act in the same scenario, it's not unlikely. (Scootaloo's instant bond to Rainbow, Dash's standoffish-ness; Dash comforting Scoots, and instantly reeling back; etc) Keeping this to herself would require detaching from the people around her.
Then, when adding in the second part of the headcanon, it's even easier to see why Rainbow has difficulty being loyal. The episode "Flutter Brutter" lent me the rest of the information needed for this headcanon: who the father is, and why Rainbow never mentioned it to her friends. Zephyr's and Dash's interactions reminded me of the awkward, post-coital relationship I once had where the guy wanted more as well as the relationship between my cousin's mother (who was sixteen when my cousin was born) and birth father (who was barely in the picture, since he couldn't be trusted with homework--let alone an actual baby). Combining this with the Shy's remarks that Dash up and disappeared, I concluded that Zephyr and Dash had a teenage fling, Dash hid the aftermath, and never told anyone because she thought she may lose her friend(s).
Then again, I could just be overanalyzing a show meant for kids....
(But, hey, what's the fun in life if you don't overanalyze everything?)

*Alright, clearly I need to do this. WARNING: Trigger topics and unpopular opinions ahead. Long comment ahoy. Please reserve all judgement til the end, or leave if the length or topic offends you.*
I have this personal, slightly unfavorable headcanon as to why Rainbow Dash doesn't often embody her element: she has serious issues trusting anyone. As we see in most flashback episodes, Dash was a reckless youth who lived life her way. As seen in human society, those types often live their lives too fast...and wind up a parent too soon. In my mind--and here is the unfavorable part--Dash is Scootaloo's mother, but gave her up. Reviewing their interactions and comparing them against how people (re)act in the same scenario, it's not unlikely. (Scootaloo's instant bond to Rainbow, Dash's standoffish-ness; Dash comforting Scoots, and instantly reeling back; etc) Keeping this to herself would require detaching from the people around her.
Then, when adding in the second part of the headcanon, it's even easier to see why Rainbow has difficulty being loyal. The episode "Flutter Brutter" lent me the rest of the information needed for this headcanon: who the father is, and why Rainbow never mentioned it to her friends. Zephyr's and Dash's interactions reminded me of the awkward, post-coital relationship I once had where the guy wanted more as well as the relationship between my cousin's mother (who was sixteen when my cousin was born) and birth father (who was barely in the picture, since he couldn't be trusted with homework--let alone an actual baby). Combining this with the Shy's remarks that Dash up and disappeared, I concluded that Zephyr and Dash had a teenage fling, Dash hid the aftermath, and never told anyone because she thought she may lose her friend(s).
Then again, I could just be overanalyzing a show meant for kids....
(But, hey, what's the fun in life if you don't overanalyze everything?)

Rainbow dash is not Scootaloo's mom.... Just a parental figure, I mean they are not related?

Rainbow dash is not Scootaloo's mom.... Just a parental figure, I mean they are not related?

@Mario Pangan Awesome! Another person to add to my list of people I've inexplicably ticked off! I think I've just hit the hundred mark with that...

@Mario Pangan Dude, calm down.  They are simply sharing their head cannon. I honestly don't agree with it, but it's an interesting idea. I'm not gonna sit here and bash someone simply because I don't agree with them.

@Kaylee Ashley Guessing you weren't around when YouTube got rid of it's character limit for comments. I remember someone posting Romeo and Juliet in it's entirety in one comment.

@Multi-purpose account Please read the disclaimer one more time (top, bold sentence), as well as my other comments in this thread.

Rainbow Dash is too young to be Scootaloo's mother. It's canon that the mane six ponies are somewhere around their 16-20's. Scootaloo is just a young kid probably around 7-10. Rainbow can't be Scootaloo's mother, unless it was illegal birth... But so on, Scootaloo attends school. Wouldn't a plenty papers/signatures from Scootaloo's parents be needed for her to legally attend school? Also, what would happen to the horse Ranbow fucked?

Your theory is so stupid.

Alma Saon let’s say if they were humans, scootaloo would be about 7. And the main six are about 17. That would mean that she would be ten when she had scootalloo, which isn’t really logical. Still it was cool to read you comment and see you ideas

Skyla u w u But not too lazy to type a comment....?<br>I mean, in the time you finished writing that, you could have been done with the disclaimer and have begun the first sentence.

Skyla u w u But not too lazy to type a comment....?
I mean, in the time you finished writing that, you could have been done with the disclaimer and have begun the first sentence.

Alma Saon I'm sorry but I'm wayyyy to lazy to read all this 😂😂😂😂

Alma Saon I'm sorry but I'm wayyyy to lazy to read all this 😂😂😂😂

Broken Air conditioner Again, I didn't perceive us as fighting. Debating, yes. But not arguing.<br>That also doesn't shed light on what the rest of your comment means.

Broken Air conditioner Again, I didn't perceive us as fighting. Debating, yes. But not arguing.
That also doesn't shed light on what the rest of your comment means.

@Alma Saon "Clashing Swords" - a term rarely used that translates to "arguing".

@Alma Saon "Clashing Swords" - a term rarely used that translates to "arguing".

Yes but sometimes features aren’t a perfect mix of your parents for instance, you can get most looks from your dad, or most from your mom, and no one would be able to tell really if the dad is a dad without a paternity test. And sometimes your child could get a few features (such as eye color.) from your parents or your parents parents. I don’t think anyone can say for sure that the human race can COMPLETELY understand genetics.

@Isabella Ruppelt ok the dad is a deep blue with his main being darker and the mom is more of a gry then a white the only thing purple is the moms main and those are strips the one who looks more like his parents is shining

Cassandra Capodagli her mom is white and her dad is blue (pretty sure) and blue are purple are in the same color family, while to make orange from blues and greens you would need a red or at the very very least a purple which neither of those ponies have any trace of in their coats.

Broken Air conditioner I understand that you're trying to make a metaphor or something, but I don't fully understand your comment. What did others see? What do you mean by clashing swords? (I never perceived us fighting, so if it's supposed to be a metaphor, I'm afraid its meaning is lost in translation)

I actually somewhat regret being a pony if I'm gonna live to 30 instead of 80...

I actually somewhat regret being a pony if I'm gonna live to 30 instead of 80...

@Alma Saon but I didn't, and some of us even saw it, so I'm clashing swords against you in certain areas.

@Alma Saon but I didn't, and some of us even saw it, so I'm clashing swords against you in certain areas.

@Alma Saon its called Andi Mack I believe

@Alma Saon its called Andi Mack I believe

Alma Saon
This... is well thought and well written.
I do enjoy overanalyzing things, but not everything and not all of the time. :-)

Cassandra Capodagli I really appreciate hearing that! Out of curiosity, what Disney show are you referencing?

Cassandra Capodagli I really appreciate hearing that! Out of curiosity, what Disney show are you referencing?

@Isabella Ruppelt ok yes but their are ponys that dont look like their parents Twilight for example doesn't have the same coloring as her mom or dad

You know you have a point and it doesn't really matter if it is a kids show.  Shows like my little pony like to hint at stuff but never actually say any thing.  Plus I wouldnt be surprised if this did become real. Disney channel a channel "for kids" has come out with a show where a girl is excited because her big sister is coming him only to find out that her sister is actually her mother and the man and woman whod raised her were actually her grandparents.......and again this is Disney.  Another thing My Little Pony is no long for little kids only the age group has been risen from 4-6 year olds to 7-13 so its very possible as seen in The Perfect Pear for this show to be more real about relationships and secrets

Broken Air conditioner There was a warning that this was an unpopular opinion at the beginning of my original comment; you could have opted out at any point.

Rachel Johnson It's fine if you disagree with my theory, but there's no need for harsh words. I admit I can't explain away everything that disproves this idea, as it was never my intention to argue this point when I posted this originally almost a year ago--which is why I warned this was an unpopular idea. I've been trying to explain the inconsistencies away with what little evidence I have compiled, but unlike BronyNotion, this is not my skill set or profession.

@Alma Saon first of all, if you want to bring horse life spans in here, none of the ponies except the alicorns are living past thirty, so that's a stupid argument to bring up at all. Secondly, Equestria is a fictional world, thus is not constrained to human cultural practices, so teenagers may be more independent than in the human world. Lastly, you have nothing to support that they are in their twenties, while we see twilight attend a highschool and everyone buy that she's a teenager, thus she must be the same age as the human versions of the ponies, or extremely close since she is not in any way shape or form different in build or height to her native human counterpart. Thus, you are full of bullshit. Fuck off, you dipshit.

So you're saying Dash put Scoots up for adoption and banged as a teen? Your mind is screwed up... And so is your cousin.

Alma Saon

I guess just all the mane 5 don't stick to their element at points :P

Alma Saon

I guess just all the mane 5 don't stick to their element at points :P

StarFlowerKitti OwO A potentially cheap cop-out, but I blame that on poor writing and forcing conflict for the sake of the plot. None of those instances felt in character for someone known for anxiety, problems being assertive, and for sacrificing her own emotions to make others feel better.

Alma Saon

What about that episode when she said that Rarity and Pinkie pie's hobbies were pointless and that their lives were basically meaningless (it wasn't all Iron Will's fault), and that episode where she yelled at those ponies who were building her sanctuary, and even the Smooze episode when Discord tried to apologize, she slapped the flower out of his hand. That's got to hurt. And also the episode where she was running Rarity's shop, she had to dress up as different personas but was rude to other ponies and her friends.

StarFlower Kitti OwO Fluttershy was always kind--not always brave or assertive, but she was always kind. She embodied her element from the beginning.

郭富豪

Fluttershy also wasn't acting like her element before either

郭富豪

Fluttershy also wasn't acting like her element before either

Rachel Johnson Horses mature faster than humans, sexually speaking, so if we use horse maturation and age, Dash's pregnancy would fall into the expected range. Even if we're using human years and maturation, I always thought of RD and the Mane Six as adults in their early to mid twenties, given the fact they all are independent. Assuming Scoots is 8 or 9 and Dash is anywhere from 23-26, she would still be in a viable age for bearing a child. (The lowest we would go is 14, which has definitely happened through consensual sex before.)

Isabella Ruppelt Sorry for such a late reply; I just rewatched this video and realized how many comments Youtube had failed to tell me about. With the colors, Fluttershy and her mother are both yellow, so it wouldn't be far off to assume that it's possible for Scootaloo to have inherited that warm coloring. When comparing the RGB percentages of the Shys, the Dashes, and Scoots, it also shows there's a probability. <br>Again, this is just a head canon, so I may be grasping a bit at straws here.

Isabella Ruppelt Sorry for such a late reply; I just rewatched this video and realized how many comments Youtube had failed to tell me about. With the colors, Fluttershy and her mother are both yellow, so it wouldn't be far off to assume that it's possible for Scootaloo to have inherited that warm coloring. When comparing the RGB percentages of the Shys, the Dashes, and Scoots, it also shows there's a probability.
Again, this is just a head canon, so I may be grasping a bit at straws here.

This is my new favorite thing, I’m going to go draw things about it now.

This is my new favorite thing, I’m going to go draw things about it now.

Alma Saon that’s a good head canon... for an adult show. 🙇♀

Alma Saon that’s a good head canon... for an adult show. 🙇♀

actually we see Twilight as a 'teen' yes but it shows her in highschool but some are adults in Highschool

actually we see Twilight as a 'teen' yes but it shows her in highschool but some are adults in Highschool

what are u doing saying things like that i told rinbow what u said

what are u doing saying things like that i told rinbow what u said

Kaylee Ashley I made an even longer comment on one of DanTDM's videos and I ran out of space in it

Kaylee Ashley I made an even longer comment on one of DanTDM's videos and I ran out of space in it

Skyla The Unicorn she's basically saying there's a change Scatoloo (excuse me for the terrible spelling) and Rainbow Dash are related

Kaylee Ashley <br>Whats the fun of the reply section other than making people read the thoughts.

Kaylee Ashley
Whats the fun of the reply section other than making people read the thoughts.

Idrk so it's just a theory by someone who likes to overanalyze.

Idrk so it's just a theory by someone who likes to overanalyze.

Alma Saon <br>This theory is very interesting. Considering how Rainbow Dash and AppleJack was raised could be a very important factor as to why they can or cannot represent their elements as well as they can with each others. Rainbow dash's life was the factor of why she isn't loyal all the time and is always so brutally honest about everthing. Being raised on the farm like AppleJack where family and dedication and loyalty would be the main gactors for responsibility on a huge orchard, loyalty would be the main factor.

Alma Saon
This theory is very interesting. Considering how Rainbow Dash and AppleJack was raised could be a very important factor as to why they can or cannot represent their elements as well as they can with each others. Rainbow dash's life was the factor of why she isn't loyal all the time and is always so brutally honest about everthing. Being raised on the farm like AppleJack where family and dedication and loyalty would be the main gactors for responsibility on a huge orchard, loyalty would be the main factor.

That would actually make sense to why rainbow and flutter shy are so close

That would actually make sense to why rainbow and flutter shy are so close

Alma Saon can someone give me a summary? I'm not reading this whole thing

Alma Saon can someone give me a summary? I'm not reading this whole thing

dragon -_- Wings
 Theories are supposed to have some place in canon. And Rainbow Dash would have to have been Scootaloo's current age to be her mother. Hell, she's currently a teenager, and Scootaloo can't be less than eight or nine years old. She's just too developed in motor skills, maturity, and intelligence to be any younger, and we know Rainbow Dash is a teenager, because she's Twilight's age and when Twilight was in the human world, she was a teenager.

And while it is possible for a young child to become pregnant, usually that suggests sexual abuse and rape. I mean, either this theory suggests Rainbow Dash was a sexually active preteen, or a rape victim. And neither is something a show aimed at children is going to make the background for one of it's main characters. It can be a headcanon, but it's not a "theory". Because, I repeat, a valid, viable theory would require that it can fit into the theme of the show. Preteen pregnant Rainbow Dash would never fit into the show.

Alma Saon remember that this is a channel only for theories he is not saying hes right so.....CHILL OUT... i mean did u see how much you wrote it's like you think you are in Court-_-

Alma Saon rather interesting though the one gap I’m seeing in it is scootaloo’s coloring is nothing like either of those two ponies or a mix. Rainbow is blue and zephyr is a seafoam, so when you look at pony genetics, they are always similar colors (yea even pinkie pie they look different but they have similar color roots) blue and orange are complementary colors and since zephyr isn’t orange or very close to orange I find it hard to accept that that could have happened, if indeed scootaloo is rainbow’s daughter I think it happened with a different pony... you know that brown stallion that has always called rainbow dash rainbow crash? If we go by this theory I think that pony would be the most likely candidate. After all brown is kind of a really dark orange, you can see when you look a color wheel or color swatch. Look for any of those things that have the slider that let you choose a color and you’ll find you can go from orange to brown by just sliding the blackness bar.
using what I’ve noticed from the color patterns within genetics this is the most likely circumstance in accordance with this theory.
Also I’m an artist so I know colors that’s why I feel qualified to talk about them.

Lauren Faust has said Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo aren’t related

Lauren Faust has said Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo aren’t related

tbh, the show needs to elaborate character development in terms of elements of harmony concept
rarity, applejack, and even pinkie pie werent really acting like their elements either
it feels like the show is sorta ignoring or neglecting the elements, and everyone else in the main 6 are just like supporting characters while twilight is a carry

Alma Saon nah. just see the episode of rainbow's parents ugh.

Alma Saon nah. just see the episode of rainbow's parents ugh.

<b>she is dead from your amazing headcanon</b>

*she is dead from your amazing headcanon*

I'm... 100% certain this isnt canon, but SWEET CELESTIA IS IT A GOOD HEADCANON. TYSM FOR WRITING THIS

I'm... 100% certain this isnt canon, but SWEET CELESTIA IS IT A GOOD HEADCANON. TYSM FOR WRITING THIS

Alma Saon
"Then again, I could just be overanalyzing a show meant for kids....
(But, hey, what's the fun in life if you don't overanalyze everything?)"
You... I like you.


"Rainbow dash is love, rainbow dash is life....."<br>                                                                 -GOD 2010

"Rainbow dash is love, rainbow dash is life....."
                                                                 -GOD 2010

RAIBOW DASH SUCKS SHES A FUCKING BITCH! >:C

@***** you're just twelve, but you cuss like a sailor. What has the world come to? V.V

@***** The fuck is wrong with you? I didn't even said a word to you i was speaking with AV R you should shut the fuck up for a moment. Cause you're just making yourself look so stupid.

Shy? Fluttershy?? Oh whatever. Don't be shy. I'm not shy... am i shy? I'm Fluttershy? Ah we're all shy in the inside... or cool. Depends how you're from the outside.

@***** Thanks you, you're making me so shy

@Rainbow Animations yes English is not my native language , and i don't know that it's was bad ? )':

@AV R Wow your grammar is really bad. I hope you're not from a place that speaks english. No offense

@***** I believe she was telling @i want a tank gaming to shut up for calling Dashie a bitch. Not you.

Did you mean: "Rarity is love, Rarity is life."

yyeess she is )": , i Really love Rainbow Dash so much , and i hate the way When people talking about her that she is not loyalty , but i can see that Rainbow Dash is LOYALTY ,THE ELEMENT OF LOYALTY NOT FAIL ! ,please Rainbow Dash is the best pony in my opinion i Really love her almost than the others she is the one i Really care about , Rainbow Dash's fan where are you !!!!!!!!!!!!


Spike should totally be the element of loyalty. he honestly is way more loyal too the mane six then Dashy.

I'd have to disagree with you there. Although Spike may be a lot of things, loyal isn't one of them. I honestly don't care too much to write an essay-like comment which includes evidence supporting my opinion and such, but I'd just like to state that RD is more than worthy of the element.

BE the element of loyalty? No offense, but unless there is some process of consubstantiation at work here, how can one BE an element of harmony?

you know if spike was one of the main character and rainbow dash wasn't you would all crazy about spike

wow are you like just staying at this video 24 7

@Night Burst spike is dull as fuck. RD is a way better character. She actually has to struggle with her loyalty, unlike spike, because he's a pampered ass.

i agree plus, Spike has way more story opportunity like who his family is and why he doesn't have wings and so on.

+rainbow “alina” dash TWILIGHT IS LOVE TWILIGHT IS LIFE

I am the most clueless person on the planet, haven't you HEGHKED?

@SodaMining That's the target audience, fucktard. God, I am laughing my ass off at this right now. Could you be any more clueless?

If you are 12+ and learn any social skills from this show... I just can't put it it any nice way.

@SodaMining If you find the concept of learning from the characters in this show to be weird, then you have no fucking clue how this show works. God you're dumb.

You should really hear yourself right now.

You should really hear yourself right now.

@SodaMining Maybe it's because she teaches them to be confident and to work hard to achieve your goals.

@Frank Poole<br>If she is a fucking idol to some people then they need mental help or something. And that's a lot coming from a hardcore brony like me.

@Frank Poole
If she is a fucking idol to some people then they need mental help or something. And that's a lot coming from a hardcore brony like me.

Wow. She's a fictional character btw, just in case you forgot. Bigot.

People who  hate Rainbow Dash are hypocrite assholes. All the mane 6 do bad things sometimes. Nobodies perfect. Quit freaking out and bitching about Dash everytime she makes an small mistake. She's a million times better than any of you losers will ever be.

Everyone, calm down....
Please...
Your making Fluttershy cry :(

@***** Can Nightmare get off the internet for eternity? Because she's annoying as hell.

Spike does not deserve the element of loyalty

Spike does not deserve the element of loyalty

@***** \<br>BUT I DO CAREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

@***** \
BUT I DO CAREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

@*****
But it's TRUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

Spike became too annoying after that one episode where he saved the Nazi Empire or something like that

<b>dont talk to people in the heavens bro...</b>

*dont talk to people in the heavens bro...*

@*****<br>Lol Imma do that Hasbro is horrible

@*****
Lol Imma do that Hasbro is horrible

@*****<br>I WILL SUE HASBRO BUT I CANT... I CANT!!!!

@*****
I WILL SUE HASBRO BUT I CANT... I CANT!!!!

@***** Hasbro
BUY OUR TOYS AND WE WILL SWITCH
JUST BUY THEM ;-;

@*****<br>Seriously, she almost ditched one of her friends, all because she didn't wanna go somewhere that she was supposed to help save from misery. What a jerk

@*****
Seriously, she almost ditched one of her friends, all because she didn't wanna go somewhere that she was supposed to help save from misery. What a jerk

in the new episode, rd tried to ditch pinkie from the map quest they had to do.

FLUTTERS FTW!!!!@TGM - Minecraft playing and others!

@rainbow dash What's wrong with twilight? ALSO FLUTTERS IS BEST PONEH

If spike was the element of loyalty, though, his moments of loyalty would outshine rd's. think about that.

@TGM - Minecraft playing and others! yes he can. you can fuck off if you can't handle it.

@rainbow dash twilight is not the worst. u can't share ur opinion kid, people can make u cry... :/

@Chase Cooper But RD's moments of loyalty outshine his. He's never done anything on her level.

SHUT UP!!!!! Your just jealous of rainbow dash P.S twilight is the worst!!!!!!!!!!

@moe flo Brony notion has a point, as well as mitsy. indeed there are very few episodes of rainbow dash's loyalty. Spike has a lot more.


I agree if you say it like that but I agree


Dashie deserves the Element of Loyalty ok

Even if Rainbow Dash was rude sometimes she is still Loyal on her Friends and on the Wonderbolts

She is just a Pony she makes mistakes everyone makes mistakes and so she is

You had a point in Your Theory but I am not going to Agree with this Sorry if I was acting Like this but all I want to say is

Dashie is Loyal and she deserves the Element of Loyalty

wait... I don’t remember commenting this sht-

Yea I'm on your side rainbow dash is my fav character on mlp and I think you are right

I liked that comment gurl you're the best

Jeez it was just a video. You're all overreacting about nothing.

Zak2899's VeryWeirdGamingchannel Really? She's loyal more than once. Go watch the show again.

Theres only ONE time when shes loyal in the show.

EclipseWolf88 RD didn't abandon Pinkie for Gilda. She hadn't seen Gilda in years, and wanted to spend alone time with her old friend. How is that wrong? And she sided with Flim and Flam because they had cider, and they didn't know the two brothers were going to try to take over the farm. As soon as they knew that, RD was more than happy to help the Apple family.

I Love Jeremy Shada And I am His Wife 100% agree

This doesn’t explain why Rainbow abandons Pinkie Pie to be with Gilda, abandon Applejack’s family to side with Flim and Flam, and abandon her friends to potentially join the Wonderbolts, though!

I Love Jeremy Shada And I am His Wife but he was just saying that all the other characters are MORE loyal than her, especially apple jack

Well that's too many mistakes to count. Sorry but its true.

tbh, the show needs to elaborate character development in terms of elements of harmony concept
rarity, applejack, and even pinkie pie werent really acting like their elements either
it feels like the show is sorta ignoring or neglecting the elements, and everyone else in the main 6 are just like supporting characters while twilight is a carry

I Love Jeremy Shada And I am His Wife I like your style, and I aggre with you


Dashie is my favorite character so I don't agree with you.

I also do think you're being too hard on her

@Raptor Zeraora they were saying that RD is tomboyish, not a male

@Junrey Dimpas actually rainbow dash is a female

Alot of Boys Like Rainbow Dash Bc Rainbow Dash is Boyish a bit or a lot


Well rainbow dash doesn’t care not apple jack


Rainbow is so loyal! She’s always loyal to the princess and her friends! And don’t even try, everyone is going to be against you. -_-


@Russell Ramilo no it doesn't. Loyalty doesn't mean she has to be their fucking lapdog.

Artemis Letta

I didn’t called everyone stupid, I just called Lela McGuffin stupid, and RD can get the key even if she didn’t betray her friends, she can just show loyalty at the first place, like Twilight.

And yes, Rarity doesn’t show much generosity to her friends but she shows much to others, that’s the meaning of generosity; giving help or being generous to your friends and not just your friends, everyone, that’s why she doesn’t really show generosity to her friends cuz she also shares it with others and that’s very different from loyalty, loyalty means being loyal to someone, like you’re friends. You can’t just be loyal to everyone, that would be hard if you had to choose.

And no, I’m not a brony. I’m actually a girl.

@Russell Ramilowhat you like is the worst

Zak2899's VeryWeirdGamingchannel shut up you ugly jerk you're heartless😠😡😠😡😠

Lela McGuffin. Lol he has a point. I hate rainbow crash. Her ego is bigger them the sun.

Vaporeon the lucario one 2344 yay💎💍💫💜💙💟💌🖤💟💚💗🙂💕💖

Vaporeon the lucario one 2344 thanks for understanding 💎👑💍💫💜💜💛💙💟❣💌🖤💝💞❤💘💗🙂🤗🙄🎈🎉💕💖

I agree it’s a little to harsh she was pretty loyal to her turtle,friends will her home and still like that loyalty does not have to mean friends it really mean your loyal to anything like things and will you know what I mean

Lissette Colon NO HE ISN'T I LIKE RAINBOW BUT SERIOUSLY HE ISN'T.

Raysa I am not a fan of rainbow dash either. But that is no reason to call everyone stupid. And you know what?? At first IF she hadn't betray her friends. After the wonder bolts episode with the race she couldn't get the key to open the box. And rarity doesn't always shows her generosity to her friends. And brownie, if you are here to blame rainbow dash.I just wanted to know that this is no use

Lissette Colon I know but RD is pretty rude<br>Just because shes  cool doesnt mean shes nice

Lissette Colon I know but RD is pretty rude
Just because shes  cool doesnt mean shes nice

Lela McGuffin

No you shut up, stupid.

Just because you’re a Rainbow Dash fan doesn’t mean you have to disagree with it.
This is very true, she doesn’t really show her loyalty to her friends. Her first step is always betraying her friends then after awhile she realises her mistake! She always do that!
What part of that is loyalty? she can’t even learn it!

Rainbow Dash is lame, fans only like her because she’s “cool”. Her ego is the size of a whale!
If you compare her to the Mane 5, she’s the least representation of her element.

If you’re putting me on Rainbow Dash’s shoes, I would say sorry and never leave my friend’s side.
That’s the meaning of loyalty, always supporting and being there for your friends or family.

Raysa Shut up what if someone did that to you! HU!! Someone did that because u liked one thing

Lissette Colon

Stupid Rainbow Dash Fans

Lissette Colon

Stupid Rainbow Dash Fans


Rd is 20%cooler then twilight
Twilight is an egghead even though she is an alicorn
She reads to much


Small jealousy avarage jealousy
self image self image

Giant jealousy
SELF IMAGE

Small jealousy avarage jealousy
_self image_ self image

Giant jealousy
*SELF IMAGE*


Give Rainbow a break. Her loyalty is high in my standards and that's all that matters. That, and she's the best character in the series besides Twilight, Luna and Starlight.

All these butthurt dash haters can't handle people loving and defending her. Fuck them.

He can say she's the best if he wants. He doesn't have to prove a damn thing.

Kaala Estralla Your standards are all that matter? Also you can't just say she's the best with no evidence whatsoever -_-

Frank Poole Stop commenting on every thing that is different from your opinion; Get a grip.

pokeshipping deer fox moon kitty Ladynior 36

Kaala Estralla  no Fluttershy is the best pony

Wow, you really are rude aren't you.

I was only telling you that might be the case, no need to get all crabby.

Please don't be so rude in your reply, it makes me think lowly of you, and people will think you are rude and obnoxious and you might not be in person.

+Cinders-and-Ashes I don't even know why I'm watching this, I hate my little pony...

Anyway, they said her loyalty is high to THEM, and that's all that matters. By that they mean Rainbow's loyalty is all that matters, not the opinion.

@Frank Poole You said he never said that and I'm proving you wrong. That's obviously what

@Frank Poole "Her loyalty is high in my standards and that's all that matters." She said her standards are all that matters.

Cinders-and-Ashes he never said that, you butturt pansey.

So your opinion is all that matters? No one else's?


3:11 is OMG!!!!! too scary. She kinda looks like a ghost or something


I love rainbow dash she's my favorite pony

yo I was watching this video and see a comment I posted 5 years ago LMFAO

Make MLP great again love your name so here's a free subscriber

LEGEND WARRIOR mine too! and fluttershy do you like fluttershy

8 Ball Pool mine is rainbowdash and fluttershy

8 Ball Pool omg she was the pony the totaly describrs my personality not the bragy part but i love her rainbow mane and tail

8 Ball Pool
shes regardles
and is called rainbow crash

to hard on rainbow dash 😦😦😐😐😯😯😈😈😣😣😣😮😮😮😲😲😲😟😰😰😰😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😲😲😲😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😞😭😭😭😭😭😭😞😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😼😼😼😼😾😾😾😾😾😾😾😾😾

8 Ball Pool flutter shy is my favorite she is to much like me but, that's what I like not to be out there or something 😐

Mini Militia she's my favourite pony too!

+pinkhedgehogs forever  that is why shes my favorite she soo cool like me for some reason all the guys adore me to be their friend do they adore u

+lemonhoney_games youtube  and poor rainbow did u know her mom is dead!! ; (

rainbow is my favorite thanks fr ruining my favortite pony!! =( I hate u dang internet

you like her because of her rainboom just that ?

I love rainbow dash. She is my favourite pony mainly because she can make a sonic rainbow

MLP is my favourite show i watched each episode like 10 times i know ok

u know there can be reasons that the writer writes things even though ur looking in the show not writers booo

I think she does not deserve her element. I think Apple Jack deserves's it.

me too I think she deserves her element😡

I love rainbow dash she my fav she was the first pony I ever heard of

Fluttershy  is da best cuz she's nice to everyone and she can be mean but in a nice way plus she's sooooo cute!!!!!!

My fav is rainbow dash because she is fast and can fly

Can you not? I don't like words being put in my mouth.


Diamond Tiara, you need the cutie mark crusaders to straiten you out like they did with the real Diamond Tiara in season 5 episode 12, Crusaders of the lost mark.

Foxy the pirate fox is my senpai FOREVER

@***** jk early April foolz!!! Hahahhahha

"...I can't belive ....too many.....why....."(flies far far away) 'it is time' (picks up gun )  BANG!!!!! ..... (life flashes before eyes)

+Zontickles you are right she's the best pony

+sandra murphy thanks rainbow dash is BEST PONY!!!!

+Zontickles I'm glad you love her <b>hugs Aj plush</b>

+Zontickles I'm glad you love her *hugs Aj plush*

+Frank Poole RAINBOWDASH IS BEST PONY EVER!!!!!!!!

@Frank Poole I didn't say I disliked Rainbow Dash o.O

+Azelf1011 Dash is best pony. you can't prove otherwise.


I think apple jack doesn't deserve it either because she actually lies alot. ;-;


Applejack lied😏😏😫😫☹☹☹☹😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

Applejack lied😏😏😫😫☹☹☹☹😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯


You can't forget that that is the writers fault not the characters fault.

+rainbow dash I know I'm not rainbow. Can't I just like a certain character?

+Rainbow Dash i hate rainbow <br>Twilight is more better

+Rainbow Dash i hate rainbow
Twilight is more better


look I like your videos but leave rainbow dash alone she my favorite loyal or not

BASILGARRAD so you're <b>loyal</b> to her 😸

Just because she is your favorite pony doesn't mean you can't face the fact. I agree with this theory 100/100. She is not my favorite pony Fluttershy is. However, I am not saying that I agree with this theory because she is. I am saying that I agree with this because I believe it is true. Not because Rainbow is not my favorite.


Rainbow Dash IS loyal.. She is loyal to her friends and the Wonderbolts.

GummyFishSticks - This comment section has given me airborne diseases

PuppyDog Lover no she can go to the wonderbolts for a bit and be loyal to her bffs

GummyFishSticks - yeah she can have more than one groups of friends

and all the other ponies in equestria????

Queen Star Ruler of The evil little club

+PuppyDog Lover no she's part of the wonder bolts and is still loyal to her friends. Do u even watch the show?!?


No rainbow dash is the only one bot spike


You know what it's been so mean GPS song so mean and variance Rude University Sweet like that my big sister just married Alice and stunting you me her


there are more than 2 times that rainbow dash has been LOYAL!!!!!!!In fact there is more than FOUR!!!<br>!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

there are more than 2 times that rainbow dash has been LOYAL!!!!!!!In fact there is more than FOUR!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

@cɷɷkɩҽ cѧtร well not every episode is about her having to be loyal so 4 times is a lot. You stupid kid.

@Shehzaani Khandaker that's more times than rarity has been generous, more times than applejack has been honest, and WAY more times than Pinkie has been even remotely funny. So she deserves her element more than those 3 easily.

くまKumiKo  wow you are totally right dude

くまKumiKo  wow you are totally right dude

You guys are all JERKS and you guys probably should know it
The times rainbow being loyal
1. Rainbow Dash choose to be friends with the mane five rather than being a shadowbolt (Friendship is magic S1)
2. Rainbow Dash saved Rarity (Sonic Rainboom S1)
3. Rainbow choose not to be wonderbolt because of her friends (The Wonderbolt Academy S1)
4. Rainbow Dash being loyal to cloudsdale (S2 ep 1-2)
5. Rainbow Dash saved Rarity and Spike (Secret of my excess S2)
6. Rainbow Dash comforts Fluttershy (Hurricane Fluttershy S2)
7. Rainbow Dash choose the ponyville team rather than wonderbolt team aka HER BIGGEST DREAM (Rainbow Falls S4)
And there's still TONS of scene RD being loyal

Blair the cat That was posted 3 years ago.

Blair the cat 4? Wow, THATS A REALLY BIG NUMBER ...COOOL


rainbow dash is loyal you are not the brony notion


Rainbow splash tru sonic rainbom into the grund


no ur not being too hard on her i mean u have so much stuff to prove Ur point 😉

yeah, this video REALLY doesn't hold up anymore. it never really did to begin with, but now it's just flat-out laughable.

+Hithere136 AJ why report this? he said "if I'm going too hard on Rainbow Dash" he is giving us "info" that he believes in, also called "Theorys" learned any of this? no? well, you did now, your welcome! >:D

wolf girl907 join the pack and have a free subscriber!

Yeah... He was being too hard on Dash, I mean she picks people to be loyal to, and becomes loyal to them. Especially her friends and the Mane 6. I wish that this video will get reported with a ton of users unsubscribing and dislikes to make this video hurt, just like how TBN was hurting Dash.

Not really... Half of the youtubers who upload regularly film many different games/subject... anyway, why are we talking about this still? didn't this all started by somebody calling themself "Aphmau fan"?

Red8mint AJ a lot of youtubers focuse only on 1 or 2 different games

Dynamite Diamondz bet she deos more than you

+ Dynamit Diamondz if you think what she is doing isnt hard work, then you dont know anything about hard work, like literally Aphmau is probably the most hard working minecraft roleplay creator here on youtube

Everyone has their own opinion, but to be honest.. Dynamite is right, she doesn't do too much work for her roleplays.. and she barely plays any other games than minecraft on her channel.. she plays sims but... To be honest she should do individuality on her channel.. so I see dynamites point...

+Dynamite Diamondz  look, just if you find an Aphamu fan, just don't say anything, that way there will be not fights! Peace and Love!

+Aimee Sheather listen, I am hating on Aphmau, she barely does any work to create roleplays all she does is write and voice act. She dosent do animating or anything so yea she don't work hard.

+Aimee Sheather <br>Well she needs to think before she creates vids

+Aimee Sheather
Well she needs to think before she creates vids

@***** didn't read. Lol. U wasted your time.

+Cookie Cat <br>Nice essay corrupted 9 year old girl.

+Cookie Cat
Nice essay corrupted 9 year old girl.


She has a dream that she is carrying on for her mom so she's tencnl just being loel to her mom

But now episode Parental Glideance came out and this theory is disproved since we know Rainbow had even enough of her parents' proudness

I'm sorry but i's loyal* and technically* XD


and in cider 600 she also was mean to pi like and said she get none


I have one question, is Rainbow Dash's mom dead?

Katarina Ilic good question but, in season 7 it shows that both of rainbow dashes parents are alive and well

Watch parental glidedence.all questions answered 😉

I don't think so, well Rainbow Dash is just a teenager so I think her Mom is not dead


' rainbow does not like you enymore i talked with her

Jackson Wedderburn Liar. There is no way that you talked to the girl who voiced Rainbow Dash.

Jackson Wedderburn srsly I’m starting to think ur a baby cause first there is no was YOU would meet the girl that voices rainbow dash if u can’t even spell right this is how u spell anymore

... what about the girl who voices her? that kinda makes her real


I dont think ya have 100 subs anymore m8 hehe


That... was... AWESOME! Spike is better than rainbow! I can here the negative replys  already.

spike is a shitty comic relief character.

@Tyson Hills I don't.
He's my favorite character because each of the mane 6 has an obnoxious flaw (or flaws) I can't stand. This video summed up RD's. Applejack has lied before and after breaking a Pinkie Promise NEVER apologized, Rarity is anything but generous since she mainly only cares for what she likes in a design rather than her friends' opinions, Fluttershy is one of those cliché 'acts all cute and shy but is really a monster' characters, Twilight Sparkle is an OCD control-freak and Pinkie Pie has been made so damn annoying.
I don't watch a lot of MLP, but I have been able to see the bad sides of the ponies through videos, YTPs and clips.

@Tabitha Roenneburg Only dumbasses like spike. he's useless. RD is a hero of Equestria. Spike is a useless errand boy. He should be removed from the show. Everyone wants him gone.

@Tabitha Roenneburg Spike is useless. And his fans are retards. Dash is objectively better than him.


Twilight don't deserve her element! She failed more than ones the magic spell 😱

Lol characters or ppl need to fail to learn, otherwise it wouldnt be realistic


Have you seen We're not Flawless? Season seven? Might wanna check out rainbow's part

shelbie cain I know, I’m just giving something for him to see because it explains what he is doubting.

ibrahim Reaz <br>Ya, but I would like to see a new video talking about her

ibrahim Reaz
Ya, but I would like to see a new video talking about her

u do know this was made A LOOOOOONG time before that episode was made


Ok, so I make a lot of mistakes in a lot of episodes but I'm the most loyal pony EVER, can't u give a pony a break.

@Frank Poole
THANK GOD
I CAN BE FRREEEEEEEE

@TrueVenturianGirl I've actually never seen a Twilight fan freak out to be honest, even though she gets a lot of hate too.

@Frank Poole
XD
I don't have much experience with any other character fanbases...
I'm scared to see Twilight's, because I'm not a huge fan of her too
:p

@TrueVenturianGirl So does every other pony pony fanbase. AJ fans will go fucking apeshit when you make background pony jokes.

@Frank Poole
Oh, she's overrated alright
With her own crazy fanbase that will track you on all videos if you state that you don't like her and give you hate comments on EVERY VIDEO
(This has REALLY happened to me
I'm not making it up)
There are fans that are actually SANE though

+LPS HamsterTV She isnt' the most loved pony though. fluttershy is. Dash is underrated. Just because she acts mean sometimes doesn't make her a bad pony.

+Lilac LIlac Agreed. RD is kinda overrated. She is the most loved mainly because she's the only tomboy of the Mane 6. But she acts really horrible most of the time.

@clivinator baitor <br>The comments you make tell everyone how butthurt you get over a PONY FROM A LITTLE GIRL SHOW.

@clivinator baitor
The comments you make tell everyone how butthurt you get over a PONY FROM A LITTLE GIRL SHOW.

cough You're overrated as hell cough**cough

*cough* You're overrated as hell *cough**cough*

@***** Rainbow is that stereotypical cool kid that everybody likes and everybody will burn the corpses of those who like other ponies. My opinion is proven with Nightmare's series of comments and others.

@Rainbow Dash You are my 2nd fav pony.  #1 is Celestia.

@Rainbow Dash Your'e overrated and you suck.


Rainbow dash is my favourite pony so no I do not agree sorry

Chessking E4 NO I'M NOT YOU RELIZE I'M HEAR

LxnaKxtty MSP I LIKE RAINBOW BUT I TOTALLY AGREE.

Wow! What solid reasoning! You know, the reason i left this fandom is because its full of children who are as stupid as this girl over here

oh yeah, just because you like something you can't agree, even though someone made a huge point... kids like you shouldn't be allowed to use internet...

kittycheshire29 playsMSP me too I hate this guy (not really) for this she was loyal she just had to learn like the rest of them

Also these stories we immerse ourselves in teach us it is okay not to be perfect 24/7. We all have hurdles to overcome in this life and we will make mistakes along the way. A friend once shared this wisdom with me. All a mistake is, is an opportunity to Try again. No matter how many yrs. we have under our belt, we are always learning and growing. Don't be afraid to make mistakes but rather be receptive to learning from them. :-)

When I think of Rainbow Dash, I see her as one of the first to get into a fight when there is a threat to her friends. She is impulsive but while she may not admit it openly, she would lay down her life for them. Keep in mind she is still growing and learning and will make mistakes. She is also saddled with a lot of responsibilities. Aside from being an element bearer, she is responsible for weather management for Ponyville meaning if she does not perform her duties crops will fail and ponies will starve. I am only up to the beginning of season 4 but I noted in the episode where Scootaloo (sorry if i misspelled her name) was dealing with her fears when Rainbow told some scary stories while camping, she ran off in the night away from the campsite. It wasn't Rarity or Apple Jack that went looking for her rather it was Rainbow Dash. Seeing how scared Scootaloo was, Rainbow lowered her guard to let her know she got scared hearing those stories the first few times. Rainbow demonstrated her element perfectly.
         Each of the Mane 6 have quirks that can block their connection to their elements.
Rarity is hardly generous when she is thinking about how she will look during a crisis.
Apple Jack had a hard time being honest about asking for help when her brother could not help on the farm due to injuries.
Fluttershy gets too timid to help her friends even though it would be a kind thing to do.
Pinkie Pie dials it up to maximum trying to make someone happy by force instead to inspiring them to feel the joy in their hearts.
Twilight lets herself get overwhelmed by her fears and anxieties eroding her will. Will and desire are needed for magic to work.
Rainbow was discussed earlier.
          Despite these hurdles, they rise up to the challenge with each other's support through the bond of their friendship.

I don't hate Rainbowdash, however she can be real self-centered and that's really something I don't like. This is also why she's not one my favorites.

Sahara Peters I agree she’s still cool but she’s not loyal she is hardly honest though


actually I agree with 1000% on this, to be honest.  rainbow dash is selfish.

@FrootiDragon you don't know what actual selfishness is. Also thetoptens is full of butthurt haters who make stuff up because they're butthurt about a character being popular and will make up whatever lies they can to discredit her.

Frank Poole oh my God. She is selfish, deal wit it dude. Go to TheTopTens.

Sølv Rive no shes llust likes to be cool theres noting wrong with that ok

Sølv Rive hey rainbow dash is my faborite pony 😈😼

BOSS Potter Wow... then think about our fanpony twilights. It is got also haters... and people say "she don't deserve to be a princess". And i can live with it... it is hurt me... but this is they're opinion. TS is best pony for me!

being the element of loyalty and having it conflict with her personality is brilliant writing. it makes her more compelling than someone who just automatically does the right thing. people don't know how to fucking look deeper into thing with this show. they base their inane opinions on surface level shit.

Sølv Rive Rainbow Dash is not selfish,she is loyal,So please think about her fans.<br>How would you feel?😟

Sølv Rive Rainbow Dash is not selfish,she is loyal,So please think about her fans.
How would you feel?😟

Being loyal doesn't mean doing and being EVERYTHING and EVERYWHERE for her friends. I respect your opinion but it's highly offensive, rainbow dash always wanted to be a wounderbult

Sølv Rive you got that right I have been see yo kai watch and i think that jibnayn does  the   deserve the element of loyalty after all he very loyal   to Nate    😺

Frank Poole <br>hey it's my opinion. I know ur trying to protect her but I have to be honest. she doesn't deserve to be the element of loyalty.  I like her but she can be real desperate sometimes.

Frank Poole
hey it's my opinion. I know ur trying to protect her but I have to be honest. she doesn't deserve to be the element of loyalty.  I like her but she can be real desperate sometimes.

Sølv Rive bullshit. there's nothing selfish about her wanting to do well in life.


I guess you could say Rainbow's sometimes...

out of her element

@Patra D no need to be harsh you dumb as brick sycophant

Frank Poole Its a pun you dumb as bricks sycophant


Honestly, I don't know why so many bronies love RD so much.. She's so narcistic, brutal, mean and, as Notion said in this video, she doesn't deserve her element..<br>Edit: I'm not oversensitive, she can be really harsh in some episodes. I realise you can be honest and tell someone the truth, but you don't have to do it in rude way; Speaking out the truth is possible in a gentle way most of the time. Also, I think she is narcistic, just look at how high her ego is; But then again, now I kinda understand why - Bc of her parents who raised her in overappreciation, so I don't count it as her fault anymore.

Honestly, I don't know why so many bronies love RD so much.. She's so narcistic, brutal, mean and, as Notion said in this video, she doesn't deserve her element..
Edit: I'm not oversensitive, she can be really harsh in some episodes. I realise you can be honest and tell someone the truth, but you don't have to do it in rude way; Speaking out the truth is possible in a gentle way most of the time. Also, I think she is narcistic, just look at how high her ego is; But then again, now I kinda understand why - Bc of her parents who raised her in overappreciation, so I don't count it as her fault anymore.

Rainbow Dash is none of those things. She isn't mean, she's honest, she isn't narcissistic, she's driven, and she's only brutal to those who deserve it.


You are so right bike would be so perfect anyway so what would happen to rainbow dash make her what she turn into the score but this woman he was Evil like you but she won't be regained that she would join Christmas colours go and see right maybe in the future video if that's a good idea for you bye


maybe you should give rainbow dash another chance


Ur right Rainbow Dash isn’t loyal at ALL


Now hang on just a minute, just because Rainbow Dash has had patterns does not mean she doesn't deserve the element of loyalty. For example, in the episode where Twilight publishes the book of how the main 6 learned less lessons each and every day, they all said that the whole point in the book was so that way other ponies could learn from their mistakes. That doesn't make it any different from the main 6. Just because Rainbow Dash is the element of loyalty doesn't mean she has to be perfect she does deserve her element whether everyone think so or not. Sure she's had a few Misfits here and there but haven't we all no one's perfect whether we think so or not. And I know it's your opinion, everyone has a right to their own opinion but you also have to look through every single detail. Just because Rarity had a few mistakes in the hole TV show doesn't mean she doesn't deserve her element


In my opinion RD should have the element of loyalty and sometimes not she was full of herself in Rainbow Rocks but she should have the element of determination because she is up for a challenge and never stopped giving up on being a wonder bolt so that is what I think


I agree more with the theory that the two elements should have been switched. While the writers have been making Applejack more honest, it feels way too forced, as though Applejack MUST be honest because that is her element, and not because its a character trait.


Rainbow Dash does fit her element yes she is honest and loyal to what SHE WANTS she does often feel like its less loyal to her loyalty to her friends some people don't get attached to people and are loyal to her dreams she DID deserve her mark


Rainbow Dash is like a teen and doesn't know who she is quite yet and is trying to figure it out so while she is in the stage she cant produce the loyalty element until the can figure out who she is and who she wishes to be friends with. I want to think the rest of the main six will go through a similar stage in there life seeming as they are around that age. But its really unclear until more information is turned up in the show.


four years late but... there are two types of loyalty, to ones self or to ones 'master', rainbow dash doesn't have a 'master' so she is loyal to herself, what her instincts tell her is the right choice, as a result she is both loyal and honest... to herself


This is a 4 year old video but I feel the need to add my view. In the episode with the griffin which I don’t remember she does spend time with Gilda, but she still asks about pinkie when Gilda breaks her helicopter thing. Also, at this point Gilda is a friend too, and one who has traveled a long way to see rainbow, she probably feels obligated to hang out with her. When she learns that Gilda is being mean to her friends, she is quick to tell Gilda that if she can’t be nice to her friends, she should go find new friends. Also while she considers flying with the wonderbolts, she is having a hard time deciding between her biggest idols and her friends, wonderbolts would guarantee her a win, and we know she “hates losing” from the episode with applejack and the fall run thing (sorry not great on names) so this would have been a hard decision to make, when she finds out that soarin was able to fly and spitfire wasn’t letting him because she was worried they wouldn’t win with him flying, she is quick to decide she would rather be with her friends, who would never abandon her like that, and helps soarin get his spot back.

Just my analysis of rainbow’s element. I think the important thing is the choice she makes at the end, since she did concider joining the shadowbolts in s1 e2 until she realized it was them or her friends, I’d argue it was the same with Gilda, while with the wonderbolts it was the question of living her dream or competing with her friends, which is a hard choice for anyone.

As for mare-do-we’ll I think dash started with good intentions and then let it go to her head. Which is when her friends stepped in. In the dragon episode I think she isn’t being unloyal, just inpatient because rainbow dash loves to go fast and isn’t scared of anything, while fluttershy is taking forever. I feel like they all got a little annoyed with fluttershy, except maybe pinkie pie. I don’t fault her loyalty for either of those. I fault her ego and love to go fast.


i do agree.....but you might have forgotten that applejack was way more honest in the episode where the shady business brothers were selling a special potion to cure age and broken bones. applejack was honest when it came to it. though i have to admit she was not as blunt as rainbow dash would have been. (also no idea if this was before or after that episode)


I think Brony Notion only pointed out all Rainbow Dash's flaws. These flaws make the characters of MLP interesting. Because if we tie these characters to what they really are and represent, the show will be tad boring as Maud Pie. Come to think of it, all of our characters have disadvantages. Twilight Sparkle is excellent in magic but she often times overthink and over analyze causing uncontrollable panicked actions. Fluttershy is too shy, borderline coward beyond her kindness. Rarity is though generous, very vain and overly dramatic. And Apple Jack is very stubborn as well as she's honest. These characters are layered like onions and that made them interesting. Even Spike the Dragon is layered. Even though we can agree that he is very loyal, he still have the tendencies to be selfish and struggles with self control when given too much freedom. Rainbow Dash might not be very showy with her Loyalty, but I think she deserve the element more than anypony else. :) Stay pony. :)


You're so right man. Rainbow is being a traitor to her element. And they say she is the element of loyalty.


Actually I do agree that she is not completely loyal but actually she is. Before I get killed think about it, no one not even the most loyal can be loyal. This comes greatly because loyalty goes to most people. After all loyalty isn’t just a one person thing it goes to multiple. So she is not perfect in loyalty but she is a more truthful idea of what loyalty is.


Rainbow Dash is loyal but in her childhood she didn't have many friends and sometimes she could be showoff but she is loyal if she wasn't she would be with the Shadowbolts


What if she does something loyal in the future one day


I have to agree because sometimes Apple jack would
Lie and spike is very loyal
And rainbow dash isn't as very loyal as we thought so maybe rainbow dash and Apple jack should have a different element .

Spike should have the element of loyalty.


I think I agree with you. Not just because of the evidence provided, but because of future elements shown from rainbow dash. She ks more deserving of the element of honesty that the element of loyalty

The elements were a mistake if the fans now seem to believe that they have to be the sole defining trait of their respective characters. apparently the fans don't want any conflict whatsoever, even though conflict is the essential lifeblood of every fictional story ever. No conflict = no story.


Rainbow should have the element of awesome


And Applejack isn't as honest as we thought she'd be. There's a list of Applejack's lies.


Well, now Spike got wings and he probably can be a princess of loyalty :D


Rainbow Dash is my favorite pony but I agree with you.


You kind of are being too hard on rainbow that can change the whole show! Dont ruin this


What about rarity?  I think she doesn’t deserve her element ._.


this is actually a really good theory ppl need to chill omg


Even if it could, Spike wasn't sure;that would mess up the "spark".


People, people, people, PEOPLE! Why are you getting mad at TBN all he was doing was saying HIS opinion! And also he makes a GOOD point RD really doesn’t come off as loyalty, yes she’s had her moments, but the other like pinkie, Fluttershy, and Twilight really live their elements. Applejack, Rainbow Dash, and Rarity just go on and off with their elements. Because Rarity isn’t always generous and I think that fine cause it’s relatable-ish. But with RD and AJ it’s not you’d think that Rainbow ( since her element is loyalty) would Always be loyal to the ponies closet to her. ( yes her being the girl that was always sticking to her friends even if they were wrong would get annoying) BUT! She left her team ( for the winning one), she chooses not to stick with applejack’s cider and goes with the Flim Flam bothers NEW cider, instead of sticking with her friend. Look I know this is a lot to read, and I mean a lot, but RD could actually live with her element, like when she gets the chance, she will choose what’s more important like her friends. I’m just saying.


Well, Atleast she learned at the end. sort of. And one thing, isn't brutal too much? 😑😐


You could be right ya know🤔 BUT RAINBOW IS STIL MY FAVORITE!!!!!!!!!


I do get that Rainbow doesn't really do loyal stuff, and I agree that AJ is more fit for this role, but I wouldn't agree with the theory that RD could be the honesty element. There were so many episodes where she just straight up lied or twisted the truth a little bit, whereas AJ doesn't do that except for episodes where it was needed (aka when she was corrupted by Discord and when she discovered her key). And it would be super easy to show RD as loyal all the time, but the writers decided to screw it up and make her be more into the "20% cooler" kind of image than the loyal one. Even though both could be manageable at the same time.<br>To anyone that thinks the author of the video is simply butthurting cause "no one can be perfect" - yeah, it is true that there's no perfect person/pony/whatever, but the Elements have other weaknesses which make them not perfect, and the point of this is to make their main traits visible all the time. Where do you see that in RD's case? :))))))) Of course, I get she has fans who want to protect her, I also used to adore her years ago, but this guy has a serious point here.

I do get that Rainbow doesn't really do loyal stuff, and I agree that AJ is more fit for this role, but I wouldn't agree with the theory that RD could be the honesty element. There were so many episodes where she just straight up lied or twisted the truth a little bit, whereas AJ doesn't do that except for episodes where it was needed (aka when she was corrupted by Discord and when she discovered her key). And it would be super easy to show RD as loyal all the time, but the writers decided to screw it up and make her be more into the "20% cooler" kind of image than the loyal one. Even though both could be manageable at the same time.
To anyone that thinks the author of the video is simply butthurting cause "no one can be perfect" - yeah, it is true that there's no perfect person/pony/whatever, but the Elements have other weaknesses which make them not perfect, and the point of this is to make their main traits visible all the time. Where do you see that in RD's case? :))))))) Of course, I get she has fans who want to protect her, I also used to adore her years ago, but this guy has a serious point here.


I AGREE WITH APPLEJACK AND RD SWITCHING THEIR ELEMENTS

Η ΣΤΡΟΦΗ ΤΟΥ ΓΙΩΡΓΗ


Rainbow dash deserves her element for the people who think she doesn't deserve her element I sorry to say but you have a problem


My favorite character is RD but I have to agree... She shows little loyalty


Loyalty:
1.The quality of being faithful in your surrport of something/somebody.
2.A strong feeling that you want to be loyal to something/somebody.

Loyalty:
1.The quality of being *faithful* in your *surrport* of something/somebody.
2.A strong feeling that you want to be loyal to something/somebody.


I think a littl3...every pony in the mane 6 is trying their best to learn who hey truly are....goodness...that's sounded a lot better in my head....


They put her to have that element so deal with it  and stop ruining the my little pony  series!!!!!!


noo applejack is always honest though. and brutal honesty is not the trait theyre talking about. brutal honesty is bad.


You would give up rainbow dash for spike?!Come on! He's not even a pony OR a girl!🐴✖➡🐉NO!🐴keeps⚡yes.


your being to hard on her but ya kind of have a point but In the episode one  she was given a chance to fly with the wonder blots she at first thought about it but she did not want to upset anypony so she lied and ended up portending to be hurt but she told the truth and chose her friends over the wonder bolts and of cruse  she was loyal in episode 1 but like I said ya have a point


not at all! I think she sucks big time. she's the most selfish of the group, the least likeable (in my opinion) and relies on other's loyalty to her more than the other way around. I don't think she puts up with much when it comes to the other ponies, she's too self-centered and ambitious to be the kind of person that puts other's first or remembers them.

That being said I don't think Twilight is a good princess of friendship and think that title should have gone to Pinkie Pie or Fluttershy as they tend to be more agreeable with others and try to make nice with others. Pinkie Pie, may seem overbearing at times when parties are involved, but she also tries to reach out with others and involve the things they like as well and blend their interests with her own.
Fluttershy is is patient with others and allows them the spotlight, and will try to be as agreeable as possible with them. And she's able to find the good in many characters. However her shy, non-communicative (what we see as her fear of confrontation) habits do keep her from forming close relationships to other characters. Maybe she'd be a good princess of politeness?


You are really hard on dash and just because she isn't always supporting her element dosent meat she doesn't deserve it😒


Your being too harsh on Dashie she is loyal but when she avoids pinkie it's bcuz she has not seen Gilda in a long time she's does deserve the elment just bcz she's rude at some points does not make her loyal


Rainbow dash was loyal when discord returned.  And she was loyal to prinnses celestya


Well teckneckly she's the main character because she s the reason that they all became friends so......... Shoudnt she have the element of magic twilight should have loyalty because she is very loyal


I think there is another element the element of sport cause shes good at sport Spike should have hers


I thought I was the only one who didn't think she deserved her element. I honestly really don't like rainbow dash sometimes or even half of the time for being jerk and mostly putting herself first than others until the end of the day she decides to finally stick with others and not her ambitions.


rainbow dash was loyal to pinkie pie because she stood up for pinkie pie when she found out how her griffin friend was


𝖑𝖊𝖔𝖓'𝖘 𝖐𝖆𝖗𝖒𝖆


You are to hard on rainbow dash she is one of my favorite character in my little pony so stop being so hard on her get it!!!!!!!!!!!!! She represents the element of loyalty!!!!!!👿👿


Rainbow dash is my favorite out of the main six, but spike fits in better than rainbow dash for the element of loyalty


Maybe the wrighters are going to make an element switch episode after the ponies realize that they have the wrong element?


can we get the people work on switching the elements between AJ and Dashie please?


Yes! Make applejack and rainbow dash switch elements!!!!


Twilight gives spike the loyal element in the episode were they are the opposite of it


Last night I watched magical mystery cure,the "spark"didn't work because the real Rainbow dash wasn't there


Rainbow dash makes mistakes and your being too hard on her


I thought you said Royalty instead of Loyalty


Rainbowdash helped her friends get their cutie marks if it wasn’t Rainbowdash who would it be cause she even helped twilight get her cutie mark


2:38 What is Rainbow Dash leaning on? Where is the support on the pole?


Thee Jordan May You understand her better than most.

Haha, yeah she can be one heck of an asshole. I think thats why I like her. Especially when her emotion really shows through her ego.


Was that Nichols cage being hugged by Twilight, Fluttershy, Applejack, Rarity and Pinkie at the end? 😂😂


“However, in Season 4’s episode Rainbow Falls, RAINBOW FALLS back into her pattern.”

I see what you did there.
And I slowly applaud you.

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

“However, in Season 4’s episode Rainbow Falls, *RAINBOW FALLS* back into her pattern.”

I see what you did there.
And I slowly applaud you.

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏


Rainbow dash can bragg a lot I personally like applejack the best 👍💯

尸人 田卜日廿 戈 木人 ，人廿 女日口水

尸人 田卜日廿 戈 木人 ，人廿 女日口水

Kimberley Bicknell applejack brags a lot too.


for about dash as the element of honest , wellllll..... she lied a lot , for example about pinkie''s pies ...and as the element of loyalty , it''s the righters prob...

Good point. She was quite loyal to Pinkie though for not wanting to hurt her.


I said that on the episode when twi gave spike the element of loyalty :0


I love how triggered some people are getting 😂

Frank Poole maybe he is a bit wrong but he’s not that. He’s a person with opinions and feelings. But I feel like people are getting worked up when in reality it’s just his opinion. No one would want to be hated on because he feels he can trust his viewers with his opinions. Not trying to argue and sending love ❤

Nobody is triggered. They're proving this douchebag wrong.


That's because you were much smarter than this guy and understood the show better. Don't be manipulated by his willful misunderstanding.


She is loyal now don't come in the middle of My Little Pony it is the director's thing😠😡😤😬


As a huge RD fan, I agree to these points. <br>I do wish the writers would work on her character more. Also, I noticed that the Rainbow Dash from Equestria Girls is a lot more loyal than the pony RD. Why is this?

As a huge RD fan, I agree to these points.
I do wish the writers would work on her character more. Also, I noticed that the Rainbow Dash from Equestria Girls is a lot more loyal than the pony RD. Why is this?


Yeah I knowrainbow dash goes back to the wonder bolts instead of pony ville but she goes back to ponie ville.


Rd should have the honesty and aj should have rd’s


Yes you are being too hard on Rainbow dash


To harsh on dash bro we're still cool though


What rainbow dosent deserve but no! Beacuse without rainbow meeting fluttershy doing the rainboom than none of the 6 mane would have been well them -_- my case is closed 😑


spike replacing rainbow with loyalty acctualy happened...

And it didn't work, so I guess that kind of invalidates this theory. lol


This is when he hit 100 and now he’s at 1,000,000 heeeeelllll yeah


And if ya pause the video at the right time SPIKE is WEARING RAINBOW DASH’S element 😲😤😡😭


Lol he has 229k subs and he's saying thanks for 100 lol


Or laughter aka hope before season 6(when did she become. A wonderbolt again)


Wow looking through these comments rainbow dash fans are so butt hurt about your opinion and is trying their hardest to change your view and thoughts on rainbow dash. I have to agree with you rainbow dash loyalty been slacking ....

So because people don't agree with him, that automatically makes them butthurt? Fuck off. You don't even have to be a Dash fan to know this guy is full of shit. He couldn't give a single valid argument to prove his point. I don't even think he saw the full episodes, otherwise he would've known she was always loyal in the end, and always had a valid reason for struggling with it in the first place.

But hey, I guess you just like mary sue's or something.


Litterly she does not deserve it i honestly hated her on one episode only


I noticed this the first time I saw rainbow dash...

you couldn't have known that at the time.


The amount of time of the video won't load. It just says 404.
*insert laughter track here*

The amount of time of the video won't load. It just says 404.
**insert laughter track here**


No you're wrong . Rainbow dash was loyal to everyone but she can't be the element of honesty cause there was an episode that we see rainbow dash was lying to pinkie pie . She told her she loves her pancakes but she wasn't .


Can you make a show about pinkie pie like why is pinkie pie too happy?


Rainbow dash & Applejack should switch element


Why are you using pony slang? I know you're a fan, but you're not actually a pony


You can’t say stuff about that that is just wrong


Rainbow Dash doesn't deserve her element?? Haha, have you people seen <i>Rarity</i>?

Rainbow Dash doesn't deserve her element?? Haha, have you people seen _Rarity_?

+Lorena Diaz <br>I haven't opened this chain in about a year I've been done.

+Lorena Diaz
I haven't opened this chain in about a year I've been done.

@MLP Sky Rush <br>Wow that's kinda sad considering inspiration would be a lot more fitting for her.

@MLP Sky Rush
Wow that's kinda sad considering inspiration would be a lot more fitting for her.

+DIPPΣЯ ᄃIPΉΣЯ ™ rarity's real element was inspiration but hasbro changed it to generosity cause the little children would not understand what inspiration is -_-

bruh rarity does 4 times better than RD.
her element is harder to keep too I'd think. people take advantage of generosity, seen in rarity goes to manehatten which is literally about a realistic attack against who she is vs how the world works.

RD would only have to just pick being with her friends to keep strong in her element yet it is often and fairly hard shaken by smaller things.

rarity on the other hand will take shit trying to give and backs down until she is driven crazy by it. literally when she is not being taken advantage of all she wants to do is do what she lives most for her friends, make outfits. she always wants to make sure thy look good for whatever they are doing even if it is less important to them than her, she is still tryin to give them what she believes is important.

omg i can't name the episode where she gets a shop in manehatten, but even than she was taken advantage of by someone but still basically gave them an entire boutique to rub and continued to sell discounted attire even after she decided to have the store stay open. and compared to the princess dress she was probably just getting enough back for materials, though I'm not sure how the fashion industry compares to the realistic clothing in cost of the equestrian economy. but rarity rarely is ever selfish when not pissed by chaos/dark magic.

I even kind of understand apple pony's need to lie. and even she looks like she is having a hard time lying (all the times she does).

but RD enjoys the easy life with the Bolts and basically is struggling hiding the fact that she is training with them. making her a liar, and unloyal.
I'm not sure what would have happened had book horse not said anything.
coughNoPonyvilleInGamescough

bruh rarity does 4 times better than RD.
her element is harder to keep too I'd think. people take advantage of generosity, seen in rarity goes to manehatten which is literally about a realistic attack against who she is vs how the world works.

RD would only have to just pick being with her friends to keep strong in her element yet it is often and fairly hard shaken by smaller things.

rarity on the other hand will take shit trying to give and backs down until she is driven crazy by it. literally when she is not being taken advantage of all she wants to do is do what she lives most for her friends, make outfits. she always wants to make sure thy look good for whatever they are doing even if it is less important to them than her, she is still tryin to give them what she believes is important.

omg i can't name the episode where she gets a shop in manehatten, but even than she was taken advantage of by someone but still basically gave them an entire boutique to rub and continued to sell discounted attire even after she decided to have the store stay open. and compared to the princess dress she was probably just getting enough back for materials, though I'm not sure how the fashion industry compares to the realistic clothing in cost of the equestrian economy. but rarity rarely is ever selfish when not pissed by chaos/dark magic.

I even kind of understand apple pony's need to lie. and even she looks like she is having a hard time lying (all the times she does).

but RD enjoys the easy life with the Bolts and basically is struggling hiding the fact that she is training with them. making her a liar, and unloyal.
I'm not sure what would have happened had book horse not said anything.
*coughNoPonyvilleInGamescough*

+DIPPΣЯ ᄃIPΉΣЯ ™ (My Religion is McGuckian) Yeah, she's way more greedy than generous. She's maybe done one or two generous things the whole show.

Though... Faust did want her to be inspiration instead.

Though... Faust did want her to be inspiration instead.

well..this is about RE.. not rarity... huh?

well..this is about RE.. not rarity... huh?

Yep.... I have seen her, she fell on the brat list! Now Rarity is with RD, being a brat. So true! :)

Your picture is amazing but I just wanted to say that rarity just gives away dresses ( sometimes she sells them but you get what I mean )

+panda- kinq (Panda)
see THAT makes much more sense to me characterwise
but I agree that "generosity" as being a core to a good frienship is more understandable. even for most adults too

Rarity's element was inspiration but the creators thought that the children that watch the show wouldn't understand

+LPS HamsterTV
I dont want to just fight, but you came off as if you did want to fight.  So yea...
and NEITHER of us are right.  You are not right, and I am not right.  this is a matter of opinion. There is no right.

@0MidnighttheDragon0 Dude. If you just want to fight, I'm gonna go. You don't always have to be right, so get over it.

+LPS HamsterTV
"And, I'm sorry hun but your argument is very invalid."

that nearly instantly makes your entire comment "fuck you you're wrong and I'm right"
an opinion isn't about being invalid or valid, it's an OPINION. it's how someone feels PERSONALLY.
I personally find many of your points "invalid" and feel I could counter them but I'm not just telling you you're wrong.

@0MidnighttheDragon0 I'm sorry I don't quite understand your point. You stated your opinion I stated mine. If they're different, we can agree to disagree.

+LPS HamsterTV
ah the youtube comments section <3
someone stated their opinion!  And it was in a mannor that made it clear it was an opinion and they clearly said they dont like them as  a PERSON not a CHARACTER.
QUICK SOMEONE RAGE AND FLAME AT THEM FOR HAVING AN OPINON!

When is rarity ever rude omfg I hate these comment bye .

When is rarity ever rude omfg I hate these comment bye .

@LPS HamsterTV thank you FINALLY! I understand bronies pretty much took over MLP now but we have to all remember kids still watch this show and they're gonna make characters over dramatic and stereotyped. Rarity in real life seems like she would be so kind and nice

@DIPPΣЯ ᄃIPΉΣЯ ™ then you must be blind if you think rarity isn't generous.

@0MidnighttheDragon0 So what? She's obsessed with her beauty. How does that make her not generous? And, I'm sorry hun but your argument is very invalid. Generosity is about doing something even when it doesn't benefit you, so your point is?  Rarity is constantly being generous.

Here are the times she was generous:
-When she cut off he tail for the sake of the sea serpent's "fabulousity"
-When she took Aj's place in the sisterhooves special to be there for her sister
-When she did everything her friends wanted their dresses to be even though she worked very hard
-Giving an old man her scarf
-Letting a man use the binoculars first
-Giving the doorman extra money
-Giving a grumpy pony a flower
-Rarity gives Suri her fabric for edges
-She supports Fluttershy(even though she is secretly jealous) when she gets the career instead of rarity
-etc.

 I hate how people just say Rarity's just a dramatic, sassy, rude b*tch. She's dramatic yes, but is very generous and everyone has their downsides. You can't expect her to perfect. Rarity is super generous and works hard. See? Rarity is plenty generous!!!

What they actual...? Do you even watch the show?!!

What they actual...? Do you even watch the show?!!

+DIPPΣЯ ᄃIPΉΣЯ ™
THANK you, someone else agrees.  When discord changed her I was like:
"...so what's different?" I see her as greedy, selfish, and just wanting herself to look pretty and flawless.  she's only generous when it ALSO benefits her.  Does that make her a bad character? no...see my point below:
oh no, Rainbow isn't 100% loyal all the time!  how DARE she have a character outside of her element, how DARE she be relatable and be more of someone we can actually BELIEVE rather than being just a "character" defined by her element!"
I think Silver Quill makes a good point in the fact that the mane 6 dont need to be defined by their element

+Dipper Cipher™ Rarity knows her place and is doing her best to show it. In several episodes she is seen doing generous actions. No matter if it hurts, she gives a rightful amount of generosity. She even sings about it. Rainbow Dash on the other hand is constantly pushy, and rude. Though most people like her, she doesn't know her place, and doesn't know when to be loyal.

+Lpsfireworkfilms Sorry to burst your bubble, but she deserves all she works for. She is constantly working on hard at her boutique. She isn't a brat, she can be dramatic but she isn't bratty.

+Unown Apparently, there is a difference between generous and kind, so I think Fluttershy takes it fine.

Well yeah rarity is like um CRAZY FOR PRETTY STUFF LIKE DIMONDZ

Well yeah rarity is like um CRAZY FOR PRETTY STUFF LIKE DIMONDZ

+Fnaf Pringles yeah i also do like rainbowdash shes my favorite

+Fnaf Pringles yeah i also do like rainbowdash shes my favorite

WHAT RAINBOW DOES DESERVE HER ELEMENT SO MEAN SHES MEH FAV

WHAT RAINBOW DOES DESERVE HER ELEMENT SO MEAN SHES MEH FAV

mmm... I feel like rarity is more forgotten but she has done TONS of stuff for them... it's generosity not girliness like made billions of dresses she has gone out of her way tons and tons of times and she has not complained once while doing so she has also given her BEST fabrics and stuff to someone she did not even know.. come on.. but fluttershy is my favorite :3

I don't want to butt in but, Rarity is generous but abused two times: the one where she made dresses for the Grand Galloping Gala, and the one with the rainbow thread.

IK BUT SERIOUSLY, WHY YOU GOTTA MAKE THE MOST OP OC THATS A MARY SUE AND ADD WOLVE IN HIS NAME AND YOU KNOW WHAT!? THE WHOLE SHOW IS ABOUT PONIES! OMG DID YOU KNOW THAT!? NOT WOLVES!

Sorry, its just, plz, YOUTUBE WASN'T MADE TO HAVE SHITTY MARY SUE OCS AND ROLEPLAYERS

@Dipper Cipher™ Rarity is my favorite character. She seems pretty generous to me and I think she deserves her element. I respect your opinion though.

@Dipper Cipher™ rarity is my fave pony but you do kinda have a point... but every tv show needs a sassy person in it.

I think Rairity is VERY kind and genorous.

                    PS i know i spelt it wrong

I think Rairity is VERY kind and genorous.

                    PS i know i spelt it wrong

Yeah. Rarity doesn't deserve ANYTHING. she is a brat with nothing. (Dont hate rarity fans )

@Dipper Cipher™ Actually, she is very generous when is comes to her time, funds, and possesions. She has a temper with Sweetie Belle and her friends, but it's because they're sisters, and they worry about each other. Me and my sis are like this as well.

Yeah and it's weird how it ends up worming out both of those for rarity @Unown

She is generous, although I think fluttershy can probably take raritys element better, but rarity is generous, just that she is a drama queen. They are two different things

@ErikaVictoria Medrano <br>You're very correct, and yes, BillDip is great! Glad to see another like me!!

@ErikaVictoria Medrano
You're very correct, and yes, BillDip is great! Glad to see another like me!!

@Dipper Cipher™ Okay, before I fangirl over the shipping...
Parity does make and sell clothes with gems that have been once or twice shown to be currency. She still doesn't male it up to her element though. Okay, now...
OMG BILLDIP! YOU TOO! I LOVE THAT SHIPPING!

@***** <br>Neither do I, but in no way was I hating on my favorite pony.

@*****
Neither do I, but in no way was I hating on my favorite pony.

@***** <br> I'm not judging her, Rainbow Dash is my favorite character

@*****
 I'm not judging her, Rainbow Dash is my favorite character

I know right rarity doesnt exactly deserve hers either

I know right rarity doesnt exactly deserve hers either

@Dipper Cipher™ she is so not her element only one or two episodes

@Dipper Cipher™ she is so not her element only one or two episodes


YOU BEING SO MEAN TO RAINBOW DASH anyway spike is not even a pony and I don’t think all her friends would agree to give the element of loyalty to spike because any moment he could go and and eat it because spike lies gems and the elements of harmony are well kinda Gems or he could go do life with his so called dragon friends well to be fair he wound not do that because he lives in ponyville and the other drangons make fun of him because he lives with ponies BUT still I think Rainbow dash should keep the element of loyalty because I’d see didn t it would mess the whole connection Of the mane 6

But  Spike DIDN'T do that! He DOESN'T EVEN CONSIDER IT!

Please, check your spelling and grammar.


No no no this not fair cuz that time I was learning lessons OK I will unsub u 🙅

@Chuck Starn yes she does. Nothing in this video proved anything. So fuck all you trash haters.

@ETERNITY WTF ARE U TALKING ABOUT BITCH SHE AINT LIV IN DUH BLUH SEH

Kailee Graydon I'M REAL! READ ALL MY REPLIES, WAAAAAAAAH I'M 20% LAME NOW

Brony notion said he didn't WANT to offend you,

With your element comes reasonable responsibilities, your character doesn't seem to have learned THAT yet have they?

Hatem Abo-Zena. Lol idiot. Its a Fake account.

I DON'T think in my generally opinion rainbow would be THIS much upset.

Omg I'm talking to (THE FAKE) rainbow dash stop fooling people

How come you never trust anyone and you never spend so much time with your friends and you go do cool things your not really their friends.

Rainbow Dash You aren’t the real Rainbow Dash.. It’s fine if you want to make an account named after your favorite character,  but don’t act like you ARE the actual character and make up stuff.

Rainbow Dash I'm sure no one could hate you . But wait I can't believe that I'm talking to my favorite character . OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG

hey rainbow dash sticking up for yourself i see please calm down also check out a comment that says u are scootaloos mom someone actually made a comment like that on this video start from top scroll down u will find them

Rainbow Dash
Lol you so salty
Where did you come from?
The dead sea? I bet you we're born there.
Get a life dude

Rainbow Dash ummm your not the real Rainbow Dash your just someone who made an account that has that name.

Then do it  he doesn't care it's true rainbow dash doesn't deserve it


Salty Rainbow Dash Fans.
I'm not really that in MLP, Gah- I'm not that interested in this.
Blep-- Fricking ass.

Nobody is salty. They're giving their fucking opinions. You don't deserve on frankly. Because you're an obvious troll.


Yeah spike is more loyal than rainbow especially cause his worst nightmare is twilight sending him away cause she doesn't need him but he's probably going to be the element of loyalty just not yet. (EDIT: I've changed my opinion, read the replies before responding please. Or at least my replies)

bro knee 1st off. WHAT THE HECK IS WRONG WITH YOU?! 2nd. Don't say you hope someone gets gang raped whatever that means. It's a horrible thing NOBODY should say so I really hope you're not a monster anymore. 3rd, please get rid of the profanity's.

Sorry since it was 2 years ago, but I really wanted to say something. (still think I'm mean/rude now fayaz hussain and 2 galek gik?!?! lol but seriously please don't call me mean becaue I shared an opinion. There's a difference between being mean and saying something stupid. All I said was that he was more loyal than Rainbow which technically is true, and that I (for some reason) thought he was going to be the element of loyalty. Don't call me mean just because you dissagree ;-;. BTW I'll remove your names if you were upset, I just added them as sort of a joke. IDK, I thought it would be funny)

someone youdontknow How can you have an opinion on me if you don't even know me? At sports sure, but you can't say she will be better than I'll ever be based on one stupid comment I commented 2 years ago.

Emily Lynn oh If thats your opinion my opinion is that rainbowdash will be better than you'll ever be

First off. To everyone who was horrible about opinions... why? If there's any reason to be horrible about ANYTHING, having seperate opinions is not one of them.

Second, I wasn't being mean or rude by saying I think Spike was going to become the element of loyalty, I was just being stupid.

Third, I've actually changed my opinion. After thinking about it for a second, I don't think anymore that the mane six (or some of them anyway) became the elements of harmony because of the amount they show of that element, rather because of how they are able to stick with their element when it's most important (and there isn't an evil chaos spirit corrupting them.) Rainbow isn't loyal all the time, and sometimes she can be really un-loyal, but when it's most important for her to be loyal, she's able to come through. That, in my opinion, is what makes Rainbow the element of loyalty. Not because of the amount she is loyal.

And the reason why Spike couldn't replace Rainbow as the Element of Loyalty, is because Spike is more of a helper. He's not the kind of person to be one of the main people battling. Or maybe it's because he's not a pony. Take your pick.

Why won't anybody just shut up and stop fighting you didn't write the story so stop arguing😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😤NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

@bro knee Take your hate elsewhere, just because someone has a different opinion than you it doesn't make them autistic, or a waste of life. Also I suggest you update your insults, since there's nothing wrong in being autistic.

I agree. Spike is Loyal to Twilight on a regular basis but Rainbow Dash has had a few moments of great Loyalty. When she gave up her dreams of being a wonderbolt to for her friends twice. (I think the writers might want to sort this out. Give Rainbow Dash a tad more loyalty next episode they write.

@moe flo he is "loyalty" and your an idiot its a opinion.

@Emily Lynn Never. RD will always be better than him.


And I am loyal that the main thing if I was not their without the sonicrainboom my friends won't get their cutie mark so this is most loyal thing to my friends

@Bri Mac  @Bri Mac  I'm not saying she isn't a good person, I'm saying that she couldn't have been loyal to and event that would happen in the future. It doesn't make sense if she knew that her rainbow would make everyone else get their special talents. But the only way she could be loyal is if she knew it was going to happen. <b>But she didn't.</b> So it couldn't have been an act of loyalty if she didn't know it was going to happen. So sure, it was nice she stood up for someone she didn't know. But it wasn't an act of loyalty for her to do the rainbow in the first place.

@Bri Mac  @Bri Mac  I'm not saying she isn't a good person, I'm saying that she couldn't have been loyal to and event that would happen in the future. It doesn't make sense if she knew that her rainbow would make everyone else get their special talents. But the only way she could be loyal is if she knew it was going to happen. *But she didn't.* So it couldn't have been an act of loyalty if she didn't know it was going to happen. So sure, it was nice she stood up for someone she didn't know. But it wasn't an act of loyalty for her to do the rainbow in the first place.

@Anonymous Frog bullshit. She wanted to stick up for a pony she didn't even know. That makes her a good person.

It wasn't an act of loyalty! SHE just wanted to WIN THE RACE

Broken Air conditioner They kinda have a point though, because some people could actually believe that this person is the real Rainbow Dash.

@Zak2899's VeryWeirdGamingchannel also, you should shut up, you can't control anyone.

But you did destroy Ponyville with an almost NUCLEAR blast, so you could've killed hundreds if not thousands, and that isn't very "loyal" at all.

Lmao. Get a life. Stop acting like the 'real' rainbowdash. Is that the only way you can get recognised.

And "Rainbow dash" sorry but I'm Rainbow dash at all

You didn't even know they would be your friends. That's just what the creators did to give a backstory on how they all got their cutie marks.


don't blame RD she is just the cool one so don't be jelly

@Mahir Uddin
He isn't jelly
She is just way too sure of herself


I Love Rainbow dash and i think she is very loyal

Yes, she is. Nobody in the mane 6 has to be perfect at the elements. Atleast for once they did generous, honesty, laughter kindness and loyalty. Face fluttershy. She's sometimes not kind!


Honestly you're right Spike works a lot better than rainbow dash

spike is just shitty comic relief. Dash is a way better character.

@SinOfDisaster How is that brainwashing? He's doing his job, and he only tries to fit in... He knows he's different.

+LPS HamsterTV I don't know can you really say he is loyal if it's a small form of Brainwashing? If I remember right Twilight had spike since he was a baby or even an egg can't remember right now. Even in that one episode where Spike saves an egg that hatched into a Phoenix. He tells it he will teach it how to be a pony. That statement has so many things wrong with it, i'm not even gonna start.

+Ava Smith I think so too. He is just always so loyal toward his friends, even though he does SO much, and gets given back so little. He's even different. But he is still awesome and loyal towards Twi.


You are being too hard on Rainbowdash you are mean a lot 😡😡😡😠


Hinata Hajim8 fuck no. rainbow deserves it more than him #keeprainbowdash
#fuckspike


Hey it's her friends rainbow is cool boo boo