but what if...twiglhit spakle conotrol the stars...?


maybe it was ... MANTICORE!!! dun dun duuun.


Think discord or one the villain Dave nightmare moon...


I really like a channel when I was five I started watching my pony now I am 10 and when I was 5 I found your channel and I loved your channel but now my little pony is finished and I am sad about it so I am telling you that I like you channel


Hey did you see that inthe tree of harmony to signs are there sun and moom both sisters. Cutie marks what can that mean


Ahem if we are talking about stars LOOK AT TWILIGHT'S CUTIE MARK MAYBE SHE DID IT TO TEST THEIR FRIENDSHIP OR SOMETHING AND FORGOT THAT SHE DID THAT SO SHE WAS SURPRISED


Uh moon is nothing like earth it just a big ball of stone(i'm saying this because you know SCIENCE🔭💉🛢)


I think no one is cotrols stars its just follows the sun and moon ? Idk


Let me guess the tree of how many somehow control Gogo because he got sent to the stars so the truth hi mini cruise control Gogo to move the stars closer to nightmare me and will leasing her


Take the pill ow planted the tree of Harmony and then the main tip use the element of Harmony and in and outside of the tree the pillow only let me know I killed it don't know who who later is nightmare Moon who walked into the night into the dream I definitely I know who walked in the drink and she accidentally come and it can't be to Lucius because they're looking only I know this one it's Luna Luna is the night of moon she she she waited the Moon and ponyville and done when she waited the moon when when she was angry and then she she became a temporary I think nightmare Moon delicia I don't still listening to the animal elementary Harmony to to put nightmare Moon back into the Moon


Maby the magic was not was visible but it was twilight


The tree of hemaney did not do anything be cause the tree of hermany was stell in the casel of the two sisters


I am absolutely sorry I am sending in voice message don't read that message I am sure who control the stars when I saw your picture in the video please Twilight was included one racing the sun so I think who are controlling the star is twilight sparkle


It is celestia is the won in the season 7 at celestia advice Wen twilight is the mist top student in the canterlot and Wen celestia SE the mane six and celestia send twilight to ponyvile to revorm luna

You guys might Ben wonder how celestia release nightmare moon of course youse starswirl speel of course i know i know starswirl is not here but the speel is like twilight swich the mane six Cutie mark


Maybe but he was in the Limbo that time.


What I think maybe 3 of hahnemanni told to read night man moon


Hey, in your video about sunset shimmer's defeat,


When I clicked the like button it made 10k likes-


The princess of the stars has controul of the <i>_</i> can controul both can u guees i know who is it to free her

The princess of the stars has controul of the ___ can controul both can u guees i know who is it to free her


maybe tıs and luna has another sıs wıch may have moved the stars. the prıncess of stars


What if she did free here but defeated her so she did free here but what she was doing was not to teach them a lesson what is she wanted to see here sister again


Lessia didn’t do nothing nobody did that for Alessia sister she controls your mom chose the stars so that may need to Splaine it what are you doing


Well there not like somebody’s name is called starlight


Celestia did not lie she saw the main six ha


Twilight she has a star cutie mark what if she did it


princesse    Celestia     blaste  Nightmare moon   too  da  moon


Why is celestia and Luna are glowing      <br>There hairs and not twilight and cadance???????????

Why is celestia and Luna are glowing
There hairs and not twilight and cadance???????????


I think celestia and Luna have a oler sister


Mama coookie meaning I think you did it changling


I know ho can control the star is..... Princess galaxia


Sam is Twilight sparkle has her cutie mark like a star she may become control of the stars to and maybe the property was in chanted to whoever read it in the thousand year well free her


Man where you will get out episode of My Little Pony like in any app you know


chew somebody has connected to the stores


Who controls the stars are you crazy probably the girl with the star cutie mark


1:06 WHY DID YOU SAY TWILA CORN PLEASE ANSWER THIS


So i understand what the creator meens so sche sed who controls the sun the moon and the stars so when she said stars i knew what they meant when luna was waniesht ssche controls the night and the day she didnt move the stars but the moon and the sun but when celestia faund the perfekt ponies she realiest  luna (night mare moon ) with the stars but all those years celestia didnt control the stars bcs that will shock everponie and celestia wated for the perfeckt time to realies luna (night mare moon)


I hate how twilight was the main character. Rainbow dash mostly made all the cutie marks. And twilight gets the be the main character when rainbow dash made the cutie marks.


But how did you do that because I'm on particular episode I said that is not the the elements of harmony doing the work the elements given the back


No she said that I waited to long bro send you to pony vill so she wait 1.00.0000 of years


i think that fluler hart  contruels the stars and she is the prinssce of light  i thik dis becaes celestia coutles the sun and luna contles the moon and then cadence rules the crystly empier she is the princess of love and then twilght sparkel is the princess of friendship and before that groger ruled the world and  then gusty the grat  stolee his bell and banish hi too the stars and the the princess moved the 3 stars  and  that the princess mane 6 and the tree of harmony relest nightmare moon


She stole the elements she is cute but she is bad


i tried joining your Patreon but I'm a kid


the star is ckntroled by star swirl celestia shine like a star but the sun is not like a star it is really hot at sun so star swirl is ckntrlling the star....and celestia banish nightmare moon but luna only returns when the movie is done. like i see luna retruns so fast when twilight and her friends deafted nightmare moon luna was there but when celestia deafited nightmare moon her sister luna is on the moon so luna only retruns when the movie is ended. :)


ummm who has the cutiemark of a starrrrrrrrrrrrrr


4:44 do you play toontown or is that a coincidence?


𝕚𝕥'𝕤 𝕞𝕖🌻{𝚛𝚘𝚊𝚍 𝚝𝚘 2𝚔 }


In netflix in mlp in the 1st season while ttwilight was walking and you see nigytmare koon i think

In the mirror thing while she was telling spike


....... Why did you do this to me creator! 😤

☾ 𝙰𝚗𝚢𝚊 𝙵𝚘𝚛𝚐𝚎𝚛 ☽


☾ 𝙰𝚗𝚢𝚊 𝙵𝚘𝚛𝚐𝚎𝚛 ☽


Sun is a star i think celestia is behind the star and realeasd him but he bunhesed him on the moon in a thoasand years and i think she is already realeised so that the episode celestia dont see in the raised the sun so nightmare moon buneshd him in the sun now so she now buneshd......


omg this vid was made so close to my birthday cause my birthday is may first


Plot Twist: LAUREN FAUST controls the stars


Star swirl i know it you dont yanna know why i tingk he is


Pizza to day I got pizza the sun is a star


Celestia you're the elemental Harmony to to Venice nightmare Moon into the Moon and Luna I think this happened and then when I don't know and some kind of more nightmare Moon is still into the Moon and then the main thing you did the elemental Harmony to the elements do they do and a quick a rainbow to the rainbow blue cool onto nightmare Moon and then it turn into a tornado of color and then that tornado of color Spanish and then she became back Luna okay that done


Watch more videos but I want to videos where is this video that that explains to the closest stores it’s princess Luna who controls the stars but she got out of practice so she had to like you know how to sew last year do it and have a bed for


Umm........ The sun is a star she controls it are you oblivious not in a mean way just a little


What do horses look like in equestrian and I mean my little PONY and I heard ponies are smaller than horses but in the show th e  ponies are horse sized??


i love you so much for the first time in the meantime  i am a kid


third sister of the rolyal familie baling her little sister


Happy summer.☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀🌦☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀☀


How to grow funny can't turn into the star


Hi That was me I'm aSpider25 also I don't know who control the stars but I do know the earth goes around the sun but I swear to god if someone did who could it be? also ty and I loves your videos Sawtooth Wavs I'm alicorn but stronger you know what I'm meant by stronger ok bye 😁


Watch the video again there sisters they have the same perents sisters!?


Celestia made nightmare moon so so they Twilight sparkle and the five good sex to learn magic of friendship so celestia mind made for that reason


1 thing the hint watch the video again the creater said


Twilight controls it she has thoose stars on her cutie mark and the stars sparkle and her name is twilight sparkle


But waht happend to groga  he was a story and discort pretent to be groga so wie have a choce taht groga move the Stars?


Is à la corn does not even real cause I’m in the wings in the sky and then whoever catch them just to catch them and they turn in to them


I just want you to know that I will get to see your next week


it is not star swirl be couse star swirl was not thare yet


Where is the universe Equestria how to go there


starswirl likes te princesses maybe its starswirl I MEAN LOL STAR IS IN THHE NAME AND HES SOME WIZARD O.O


Star  swirl  he is the   oaly  one  moves  star


there’s a problem with celestia releasing nightmare moon. In season 6 finale when starlight messed up the past you you can see in one of the presents nightmare moon took over equestria. That shouldn’t have happened because celestia would know for a fact she wouldn’t be reformed if she let her out.


In the one episode, when Tirek wanted all of the magic in the world, Celestia, Luna and Cadence gave Twilight their powers so that Tirek couldn't stell them. If there would be another huge magic that could control the stars, i'm pretty sure they would have mentioned it.


I always thought the the original spell she cast to imprison her sister had a built-in failsafe. Like, it was just on a timer from the start. I.E. the prophecy.


The troll face image made me spit out my soup literally almost every time-


I just realized something. So you know how after Luna got banished to the moon, Celestia took charge of of the Sun and the *Moon*.  Apparently, that's what the narrator said in the very beginning.  Luna wasn't unbanished yet, so Celestia still had control over the Sun, moon and stars. I think Sawtooth already covered this, but I'm not sure. :P So yes, she probably did release Luna, just like Faust said.  Or it could've been the tree, I'm not an expert at this lol. Like so Sawtooth can see!


I don’t know why but comparing Celestia to “I Am Looking 👁👁” really cracked me up


I feel like there’s a third sister who either died or went missing shortly after birth and still has control over the stars which is why they never disappear just become dull and she felt bad for her sister and let her out using the stars


The legend says she'd will come back from the moon and stars come out at night what if luna freed her self bc it was the day she comes back


I pitched this question at my family and it came up that Celestia and Luna may very well have multiple siblings, one of which could have dominion specifically over stars and being a fan of stars was probably really close with Luna. If they were living off world, however, it isn’t impossible to think that it took a thousand years for them to hear about how their favorite sibling was imprisoned on the moon, aided in her escape and proceeded to get into a fight with Celestia to prevent her from putting Luna back in the moon which is why she was not in most of the premiere


I know this will sound weird, but I think Twilight herself released Nightmare Moon. Think about it: Celestia’s cutie mark is the sun so she controls the sun, Luna’s is the moon so she controls the moon. Neither have ever been shown controlling the stars, but who has a star shaped cutie mark? Twilight Sparkle. I think the stars started moving to release Luna because Twilight read the prophecy and believed it would happen.

Alternatively she used Star Swirl’s time traveling spell to go back in time later after she gained alicorn magic and set things in motion knowing everything would work out.


Well the elements of tree harmony sent nightmare moon to the moon, who said it can't release her as well?


Lauren Faust said "who" did it, but she didn't say "when" she did it. <br>"When" is "the last time Celestia used the elements of harmony". So the very same moment she banished her sister to the Moon. It had been a desperate and mostly instinctive move, but, maybe influenced by the tree of harmony (I don't think so. the tree of armony didn't exist when Lauren Faust wrote that episode), maybe because she couldn't bear the thought to loose her sister forever, in that very same moment she set in motion the things in a way that would have freed Nightmare Moon in 1000 years, Celestia willing or not (it doesn't even need to have control over the stars. It only needs the spell to be broken by that particular alignment that there would have been in 1000 years from then and, if the only way to prevent the alignement of the Sun was to not make it rise, Celestia has no choice anyway).

Lauren Faust said "who" did it, but she didn't say "when" she did it.
"When" is "the last time Celestia used the elements of harmony". So the very same moment she banished her sister to the Moon. It had been a desperate and mostly instinctive move, but, maybe influenced by the tree of harmony (I don't think so. the tree of armony didn't exist when Lauren Faust wrote that episode), maybe because she couldn't bear the thought to loose her sister forever, in that very same moment she set in motion the things in a way that would have freed Nightmare Moon in 1000 years, Celestia willing or not (it doesn't even need to have control over the stars. It only needs the spell to be broken by that particular alignment that there would have been in 1000 years from then and, if the only way to prevent the alignement of the Sun was to not make it rise, Celestia has no choice anyway).


Maybe the force of the stars did so, my theory is that a magical relic (similar to the one twilights uses to move the sun and moon) to move the stars, keep in mind that celestial and Luna are using alicorn magic spells not another force to move the sun and the moon, so Maybe celestia was looking for a way to bring back her sister so she searched for a spell like the one she uses to rise the moon and the sun, to bring the banished back. Suddenly she stumbles across a spell that can bring banished back with the help of the stars that form a specific way to open a gate way of magic which is activated by the spec she casted 1000 years ago. The relic would only activate after 1000 years due to the right time, when you combine that with destiny it would mean that nightmare moon and the main six were destined to meet in that time. But that would leave the question open how do they know about the 1000 years? They didn’t, it’s a myth. That’s my theory it’s not satisfying at the end but ig it’s good enough XD


Chad GMT:

ok, so I have a theory.

"Who controls the sun, moon, and stars?"

Of course, we all assume that means Celestia since she is the only one we see that is able to control the sun and moon on her own. But the stars? We've only ever seen Luna be able to control them. And I agree with The Brony Notion in that while the sun is considered a star in our world, it may not be in Equestria.

Celestia was gifted the power to move the sun, and yet we see that she can move the moon as well. As such, I don't think it would be a stretch to assume that Luna could move the sun too.

And if that's the case, then Luna is the one who controls the sun, the moon, and the stars.

And by extension, Nightmare Moon.

I'm proposing the possibility that Nightmare Moon broke herself out. After centuries of isolation in the moon, her moon, her anger would begin to grow. and she would use this anger to fuel her power enough that even in her prison she could control the stars. Ever so slightly. Until eventually, the stars would aid in her escape and she would finally have her revenge.

What do you guys think?

me: I'm reposting this comment! and I totally agree


You should make the guardian of the stars and other planets. Also is it possible that there are other universes? Pinkie could be the guardian of the stars… It makes sense because she sees things, reacts to them, but she never does say she never knew that was gonna happen…


0:43 well it kinda make sense, Celestia knows that 1000 years after nightmare moon's banishment, she will have a student who will become heir to the throne, she wrote the book to prepare twilight, the banishment spell last forever but she release her 1000 years later on purpose, to test twilight's power, and probably most of twilight's journey and foe she faced was set up by Celestia to test her strength.


I think Luna is the one who moves the night which include stars


My original thought was star swirl controls the stars cause of the Star in his name but i really quickly realized that cant be possible if he was trapped in limbo


I think it’s both the tree and Celestia <br>Just after Celestia banished her sister she said while crying “ harmony please can you give me my sister back “ or something along this lines the tree excepted it and set it up like the first episode then Celestia had vision about the first episode and helped it forward. that is just my theory

I think it’s both the tree and Celestia
Just after Celestia banished her sister she said while crying “ harmony please can you give me my sister back “ or something along this lines the tree excepted it and set it up like the first episode then Celestia had vision about the first episode and helped it forward. that is just my theory


The stars aren't moving its just blending with the light of the sun


Sawtooth I think I know who moves the stars and all lamps Star swirl it's in his name and plus he's part of the tree of Harmony 😁


If you read the book. journal of the two sisters. It says in Luna's diary entry saying that she was being taught by starswirl to move the stars. She was successful. but It took a lot of concentration. Luna said once she was able to raise the moon  she would graduate into moving the stars. with I think she mastered before her corruption. Is it possible... That nightmare moon could have freed herself?!!!


If it was the tree, how would it know, I mean, the tree was long before Luna even was jealous and dreamwalking ( watched the Daybreaker episode)how would the tree had known...


Let me fix this theory.<br>Princess Luna used to mo e the moon and the stars therefore since she was banished someone else had to take up that job. So yes princess celestia did free might nare moon but your evidence could be more accurate. Oh and how do I know princess Luna changes the stars just watch the prologue again it says; ‘princess Luna would raise the moon and stars to bring the night.’ Or something like that.

Let me fix this theory.
Princess Luna used to mo e the moon and the stars therefore since she was banished someone else had to take up that job. So yes princess celestia did free might nare moon but your evidence could be more accurate. Oh and how do I know princess Luna changes the stars just watch the prologue again it says; ‘princess Luna would raise the moon and stars to bring the night.’ Or something like that.


I think Celestia brought nightmare moon because she was must be missing her sister, must be tired of controlling sun and the moon and also twilight then realized how much friendship is important.


Maybe Lauren Faust was pointing to Luna/Nightmare Moon doing this?
Maybe all these years she was just PULLING those stars towards the moon for them to one day release her?

If she WAS pointing to Celestia then it probably has something to do with Celestia taking on Luna's duties to raise the moon after Luna was Banished... I have 2 possibilities, Maybe Celestia can't get the stars right every night because It's normally Luna that does them, Or Celestia May have PURPOSELY moved those 4 stars closer and closer to the moon each night to one day release her sister and hopefully get stopped by The Newly found Mane 6..


I have 2 theorys
First,your right.The tree tested the mane 6,and the student 6 before. So maybe the tree made it or used someone to make it

But,Celestia is the Princess of the Sun,that means,She is the Princess of the Day too.And Luna is the Princess of the Moon,so she is the Princess of the Night too. So,Luna can't move the stars,but she maybe can conect whit the stars .So maybe stars wanted to save their Queen.Or if Celestia is controling the Moon and the Sun (being the Princess of the Night and the Day at the same time),since Luna not at Equestria,maybe she conected whit the stars and sad them to save Luna!

What do you think?


Ok so this is a theory i thought of while reading the comments. So I’m season 1 we were introduced to Prince Blueblood who is apparently their nephew, implying that there is a potential long lost sibling out there somewhere. Soooo celestia controls the sun, Luna the moon, and long lost sibling.... may control the STARS! Now that raises a few questions, who, where and why. Who is this long lost sibling, where are they, and why did they free Luna. Could they predict things or get visions? WAIT ok so we’ve seen celestia is able to kinda get visions of thing that are happening presently, i mean she literally has a realm where she could watch all of the things twilight was doing, some may argue that makes her past but i don’t think so lol. So what if this sibling can predict the future? Think about it if they have a connection to the stars maybe they see these future things “in the stars” or better yet what if they CONTROL the stars so they can share with others? It would kinda make sense, Celestia is present, sibling is future and maybe Luna has extensive knowledge of the past (maybe it’s why she talks the way she does). This could also explain why she let nightmare moon out, she saw that she would be reformed by the mane six which sent off a seriös of chain reactions that is now the friendship is magic series.

Now comes the where, where is this long lost sibling. I for one think they are in the astral plane/ sky realm where Nightmare moon was and where grogar maybe resides. So  why is she there? I’m thinking three things. One maybe the burden of seeing the future is something she didn’t want her sisters to endure so maybe she self exiled herself. Two, maybe she is the keeper of the sky realm and watches over it.  Three maybe the price of seeing the future is maybe you can’t directly share it with anyone. (Something Else is that they could be imprisoned there but i don’t think so).

I guess the last question is where did prince blueblood come from? Like did the long lost sibling just drop him off and be gone? I’m not sure so I’ll leave y’all to decide. Thanks for reading 😁


I think you are right but remembering when before the six friends with Twilight (starswirl) and his friends are also part of the tree and they are connected so I think the tree used starswirl magic to free nightmare moon


It might have been the people who raised the sun and the Moon before Celeste you came along recette nightmare Moon!


But there’s no guarantee that the stars are actually controlled by someone so what if the stars are controlled by themselves. Think about it. Celestia was supposed to be In town hall by the time nightmare moon escaped therefore she saw the signs and let twilight and her friends defeat her. However, the sun is a star but another celestial body that has nothing to do with other stars so she can’t be responsible.


You remember that singing celestia Vonage nightmare moon to the moon so maybe she has control of her escape


But because Luna is banished, Celestia is controlling night and day. So... I guess she IS the one who released Night Mare Moon.


I think that the pony that controls the stars is the unknown sister of CELESTIA and LUNA


Actually Lauren Fuast wanted Twilight to Be the sucsesser of Celestia.


Did Celestia released nightmare moon or did Groger released nightmare moon?


Lauren Faust Never said it was Celestia who did it is someone that controls the sun moon and the stars but we have no proof that she was meaning Celestia!


i think twilight did because her cutie mark is an star and she was detsitn to do that but unconuisly she controlls the stars


I think princess Celestia control the stars since she is a sun princess when you put all the stars together and makes the sun


But isnt the stars a sun itself too? And a sun is a star itself? After it becomes a medium sized star it becomes a red giant.isnt it possible that celestia setted nightmare moon free?


Celestia only released nightmare moon and Discord released 3 villains Queen Chyrasils, tirek and cozy glow by pretending to be grogar.Celestia didn't pretend to be someone else like discord. So Celestia  know's what's she is doing!!👩👩👩


I guess princess celestia have waited for twilight to make friends and be ready once she thought twilight was ready she must have freed nightmare moon.


Idk who controlled the stars but celestia did that bc she missed her sister so she wanted somepony to free her from the darkness


When I watched mlp for the first time and watched the one about nightmare moon I was actually terrified... Welp thats 5 year old me...


I know this is VERY far fetched, but does anyone know where Starlight was at this point in time?


I think it's Celestia and maybe the tree of Harmony literally look at this thing it is a tree it could be alive or it could be a normal tree just with magic powers those powers are putting the Elements of Harmony in the tree so I think it's just Celestia letting her sister Escape because she knew this was going to happen and I think she lied about her sister's return made her sister return she didn't really say that the way you explained it just doesn't make sense


i read a few other and it seemed that you all presume celesta or nightmare moon herself or the tree of harmony
But I have another theory- what if it was someone that ruled  equestria that was powerful and ancient who else would that be???
ANS.:THE REAL GROGAR!!!!!!!
When gusty the great took his bell he might have a little power so he went to the future (looked in his crystal ball to) see Luna(nightmare moon) being banished peeps he used his last bit of magic to transport him to another land like scorpan went back to his homeland and wait till nightmare's anger to grow upand use a bit more of  he might have restored over time and move those stars .


I think it is twilight’s mom because her cutie mark is the stars ✨🌚🌚


If I was the owner I would make a princess of stars and make a villain <br> That took her power

If I was the owner I would make a princess of stars and make a villain
 That took her power


Ther might be a reason because the stars can also be suns or moons that are far away


Celestia is the pony who put lyna in the moon for a thousand years but it is not her she just put her there because she wanted to protect everypony


The star's Luna escaped  from  the  moon her self  by controlling the  them


I discovered a thing all of you watch the actual episode and you see Nightmare moon when twilight is reporting to celestia about it is the Thousand Year and Nightmare moon is gonna come and you see Nightmare moon as a reflection on the time thing you know that sand thing


I think when Luna and celestia said that even an alicorn birth was even out of their understanding I think they meant that they don’t completely under stand the science behind their own birth. Think about it when your a baby you don’t just pop out and know why and how you where born you need to be taught that. Celestia and Luna where most likely taken from there parents when they where young and their parents never got the chance to teach them about alicorn birth. All I’m saying is that there is still a chance that Luna and celestia where born alicorn s plzzzzz read this comment I think it would makes a lot of sense even with the fact that flurry heart is the alicorn of light because sisters are related like one is related to ones family. Them being the alicorns of sibling hood would mean that from birth they would be together and that them being the alicorns of sibling hood would apply right away. Well any ways I loveeee your videos byeeee.


Maybe Starswirl was the one who controls the stars


You all are wrong. Star swirl was vanishes over a 1000 years when he and the other send the shadow to the limbo he just appeared in Season 7.


what if flurry heart controls the stars and the crystal heart could be connected


Twilight sparkle her name makes sense to the stars and also she was the one to actually see it and also she was reading frisky like she read a spell she actually did on the stars


Twilight's cutie maek are 4 stars so it might be her and also she knew nightmare moon than anybody else (exexpt celestia


She released nightmare moon , because  she missed her


Well i think a unicorn was doing practice and her cutey mark is stars so she was practecing and by accident control the star and free who ever is it (i forgot)  and i'm curious if its a new training alicorn because no one is stronger than that


Celestia kind of freed nightmaremoon daybreaker freed her because she did say she should of destroyed her so she freed her because she was gonna destroy her after


What if twilight did something to the stars and did not know it


the sun is a star, maybe celestia control not only the sun, but all the other suns


I think the person that controls the stars is the mother of Celestina and luna,Queen Galaxia.First,If Queen Galaxia died then Celestia would have been Queen,but like she is still a princess,Galaxia is still alive,plus it’s galaxy,And what is in a galaxy,So many Stars,So that is what I think


I think starlight is there long lost sister and when she was younger she had a short temper and when Luna and Celestia got there wings or horn starlight was gone to her grandmas house or something but when she returned she realized she missed her sisters getting there wings or horn so because she had a short temper and her parents promised they would wait until she came home but they didn’t and Luna was aways there for her so when she was sent to the moon she was still to know what was going on or to get her wings and when she realized she was set to the moon she was mad but knew there was a reason so she brought her back when the time was right but when she went to say hi again she was so excited but then when she said hello Luna and celesta forgot about her so with out no one not even her best friend so without anyone to calm her down she became crazy but then twilight calmed her down........about the lost of her best friend she thought no one would believe her if she said she is the princess’s sister


Well twis has a star cutie mark so she’s it


Wait the sun the moon and the stars aren't those all things that light up and I remember when you said furly heart was The Princess Of Light and remember that episode that twilight went to the past. Well Fury heart could have gone to the past and move the stars because the stars are light. So Fury heart could have moved the stars and she would know that she had to do it because she all ready did.


I want to say starwirl but hes in limbo... or somehow he found his way to use his magic :/

I don’t love you more than my home town 😍


Luna is controller of the moon AND STARS so Luna broke her self free


Sorry I was late for my comment but it’s obvious it was twilight because if you watch the last sun celebration Twilight was using her magic I think she controls the stars but who moves the clouds???


The star can do it equestria starts are able to move so can you see


Maybe there is a secret Alicorn who is the princess of the stars


I think that she was saying that it was Starsworld, if I'm spelling that right. I mean he did help raise the sun, and his name has to do with stars, also what if he didn't want Luna, one of his dear pupils stuck in the moon! Now I know what your thinking, but he wouldn't have been able to do that considering where he was, well my answer to that is... I don't know, this is just my theory you know? Maybe Sawtooth can fix it in some way to make it work.


Wait celestia could have she still controls the moon


The creator says celestia freed nightmaremoon SawtoothWaves:Bet


I think furry heart is the priness of light


What if twilight is controlling the stars


Celestia and Luna,s cutie mark are related to the sun and moon what if twilight does the stars


Starlight She’s has a horn star is in her name and she’s a princess


BECAUSE ITS NOT THE DAMN SAME WITHOUT DASHIE


I mean celestia banish nightmare moon to the moon so maybe celestia has control of her escape


Okay I need to tell you something it's very important and I think it's a theory that you will want to post a video about so on the grand Galloping Gala video when My Little Pony Rarity said that the blue bell  was Celestia's nephew so either Luna had a baby or they have another sister and who would that sister be the one that controls the Stars


Excuse me this is a normal show not related to real life this is craziness Jesus this is made by Lauren Faust not crazy hooman


I think she did it beacuse she new that they were the right six ponnies that would save her sister. And she even looked on pinkie, appeljack, dash, rarity and fluttershy before twilight come. AND she said that twilight should check everything is ok were 2/3 of them were at. And with the tree, the tree didn’t have the harmony at that time


Maybe it was luna did luna still have her powers


Who controls the stars? Nobody yet <br>Me : the sun is a star -._-.

Who controls the stars? Nobody yet
Me : the sun is a star -._-.


Eu não entendo a língua de vocês mas sou uma grande fã de my little pony


1:50- I thought she was dipping him lol.


Wait...stars...TWILIGHT not on purpose. It what if she triggered it by going to pony ville? The tree felt her and the others presence all together and then that is what aet nightmare free. Celestia saw the signs as twilight rejected friendship until that moment.


WAIT A  SEC the sun  is  a  star so  is  the  sun  person


well this might help a little but celestia is a princess of the sun so she is tierd all day and when starlight switched their marks luna is tired so celestia feel what her sister feel, s and if she realisd night mare moon her thout, s will be like day breaker


Dude twilighs name is twilight sparkle and her cute Mark is a star fun fact when I first watched it I thought that Luna controlsthe moon celestial controls the sun and twilight controls the strs😐


I think it’s twilight sparkle because twilight as in the time that’s when the stars start to come out


I know this doesn’t really make any sense aaand I’m here too late but what about Twilight is able to control stars in the future ya know her other ”form” would be <b>The Princess Of Stars</b> well it doesn’t answer a question who controllet them before- maybe Star Swill like the other comment said? Ps: she has stars on her cutie mark.

I know this doesn’t really make any sense aaand I’m here too late but what about Twilight is able to control stars in the future ya know her other ”form” would be *The Princess Of Stars* well it doesn’t answer a question who controllet them before- maybe Star Swill like the other comment said? Ps: she has stars on her cutie mark.


What if it was night mare moon that did it


Princesses Luna did it she controls the stars because she is the princess of the night


.... what and maybe it was Star swirl Bearden that pony is pretty powerful!!!???!!??!?


Luna controls the stars like her mother i wacth it


Changed my mind its star swirl his name is STAR


Wildlife of controlled stars Twilight sparkle


วรยุทธ กิตติอุดม


AHHH LUNA AND NIGHTMARE MOON ARE THE SAME PERSON MEANS THEIR SISTER AKC


No one controll the stars sun or the moon ok it’s just common sense


Who raised the sun and moon when celestia and luna Weren't alive And didn't u forget The sun is a star 👁👄👁

@Fruity Snacks but in the play they said before and raising the sun and moon is how. They got both there wings and Cutie marks

• YuiiBoo • I’m very sure that unicorns from generations and generations raised the sun and moon. And plus,Celestia was probably alive when the empire first began

@Mohamed Youseff Still,Even before starswirl was alive who did raise the sun and moon??


Luna controll's the star's SO LUNA AND NIGHTMARE MOON ARE DIFFRENT PONY'S!!!!!!!!!!!!


I think there's another alicorn that controls the stars or maybe its celestia and Luna mom I was so dying who is there mom so I think there mom is still alive


i thing the perinses of the moon controls them.


No wait I think I meant moves the clouds


It could be star swirl abearded bc...yah


I think that celestia myght have rilst night mer moon so she can eat all the cackes ;]


twillite controls the srars because here cutie merk is a star


Sun its not yello its white BC the thing idk what called and is celetia


Wait what if everything is a lie and it is just a test and nobody is evil ahm I mean nopony XD


Do you know who I have to start cutie mark


Celastya rools the stars becus in won video that it was celastya seid I will help you weth the stars and you doo the moon and you will help me weth the sun


I don't know princess celestia do with princess luna


Ok this is easy star swirl did u forget abut him it seems like they free her because they new the main six will bring Luna back I’m on my moms phone


Star light star light Star light Star light GLIMMER

She did it if you think about it it all makes sense , she is a very very very powerful unicorn


so I dont know what season nine is because my tv doesn't  have that season but I think starswirl controls  the stars and luna the moon celesta I dont if I splet that right  sorry anyway she the sun honestly I think those student that saved the school have something to with nightmare  moon anyways bye


Yeah you are right yes yeah but the main 6 defeat  bye ok your welcome ok by


I hate you so much for telling me what about the show


Twilit becose the cutemark loke like a star!


Who can Cantorlrlthe starts you now starts come at night time so who can control moon prinsses Lunu she still part of night mare moon🌙 whood Be Day breaker no there fighting they dont like eack other hmhmhmhm so confuosing


Hi it's kartiki  a big fan of my little pony


Luna kontrols der stars DC ets af part of der naite


I can’t even get notified if I press the bell button but if I don’t press the bell button I still Don’t get notified


Is another burger is a pound of the chef henry the today night name is a star anise princess twilight sparkle sanders picking him back my name


( it twuyluit dro
do you no her litrl qtmark
it a star)


Ì think the controler was ďddddddiii discord


When she says "I saw the signs of her return " what she ment was "I saw you and your friends emerging as the bearers of the elements and I knew it was time to release her"


By "I saw the signs" I could interpret that as she had the vision that this was time to reform Luna.


Maybe when the 4 stars touched the moon, we're the stars already released and then slowly headed towards the moon for a 1000 years?


I died when he put the picture of an actual dinner roll 😂😂😂


Lauren Faust : sees Sawtooth's video
Also Lauren Faust : time to debunk some theories
Sawtooth : seeing he got debunked again


If I had to guess who released Nightmare moon, I'd have to argue Cozy Glow. Since friendship is magic, and magic is connected to the sonic rainboom winch is connected to destiny, magic IS destiny.<br>The event, -like said in the video was orchestrated by the tree of harmony. Nightmare moon was released the first episode, it was only about half a year to get to the season 8 finale (in the show's time) Meaning, Cozy Glow was still around, around to research and prepare to drain equestria's magic. I have two possibilities. A: Cozy Glow was researching for her spell and came across nightmare moon, and in an attempt to drain/gain her powers, she accidentally weakened Celestia's spell. B: Cozy Glow tried,-and failed at a smaller version of the spell we see in season 8. And when trying this spell, she weakened Celestia's spell keeping Nightmare Moon prisoner, allowing her to escape. But that's just my theory.

If I had to guess who released Nightmare moon, I'd have to argue Cozy Glow. Since friendship is magic, and magic is connected to the sonic rainboom winch is connected to destiny, magic IS destiny.
The event, -like said in the video was orchestrated by the tree of harmony. Nightmare moon was released the first episode, it was only about half a year to get to the season 8 finale (in the show's time) Meaning, Cozy Glow was still around, around to research and prepare to drain equestria's magic. I have two possibilities. A: Cozy Glow was researching for her spell and came across nightmare moon, and in an attempt to drain/gain her powers, she accidentally weakened Celestia's spell. B: Cozy Glow tried,-and failed at a smaller version of the spell we see in season 8. And when trying this spell, she weakened Celestia's spell keeping Nightmare Moon prisoner, allowing her to escape. But that's just my theory.


I guess it's Starswirl as in another video it's mentioned that Starswirl took Celestia and Luna "under his wing" and made them alicorns,thus making him connected to them.He knew everything about them, including Luna's banishment. When he "found" the right ponies to reform Luna, he would unite them and when the time was right, gave Celestia a vision of what was going to happen who would send the united ponies (Mane 6) to reform Luna. Then, he would rotate the stars, allowing Luna to "escape" and the Mane 6 to reform her. (Not quite familiar with the lore and the older episodes, so there might be some mistakes. :P )


Read the tweet again, Sawtooth. Lauren Faust stated that "the stars aligned in a perfect pattern that allowed her escape." I doubt it was the spirit of harmony. If anything, it was a unicorn. Has anypony's cutie mark ever had a design like that. I don't know for sure, but listen to this. Rewatch the "Unlocking Grogar's True Past" video and listen to what you said. "... Grogar may still have been banished to the stars..." Who banished him? Gusty the Great. This is just a theory, but if Gusty can banish someone to the stars, then she can possibly free someone already banished. Please make your next video on this. Thank you.


was luna able to use magic to escape? if so, I think that she would controll the stars to get revenge on her sister but was defeted. But I also think that she was able to set Nightmare Moon free.


1:43

Different mental capacity or not, they still did the exact same thing on different scales. Or at least they would have
Alternate Timelines exist, someone in as high a position as her is bound to know that

Also I feel like the Tree of Harmony is Chaotic Harmonious Neutral. It uses bad people to do good things, and good people to do bad things, all for the sake of what it thinks is meant to happen, when really it has ultimate choice ofer what happens

1:43

Different mental capacity or not, they still did the exact same thing on different scales. Or at least they would have
Alternate Timelines exist, someone in as high a position as her is bound to know that

Also I feel like the Tree of Harmony is -Chaotic- Harmonious Neutral. It uses bad people to do good things, and good people to do bad things, all for the sake of what it thinks is meant to happen, when really it has ultimate choice ofer what happens


she was actually banished for 100 years. she was waiting and when the day arrived, she came back.


I believe celestia controls the sun and stars are just suns extremely far away so all the evidence adds up to celestia although it does seem that Luna has more of a reputation of controlling space objects rather than celestia and Luna can block the sun using the moon but I still believe celestia moves the stars


I think it’s the tree that released nightmare moon bc remember
All: ..Move all on their own!

So maybe the tree controls the stars like the forest controls the clouds?


I assumed Faust meant that Celestia knew when the imprisonment spell would be broken.  If their stars move in predictable manner it wouldn't be that hard.  However on reading her tweet again it does look like she's saying it was deliberate...


I have an extremely weird feeling that Celestia and Luna have a third sister that controls the stars, but nobody knows about her existence except (Maybe!) their faint and distant memories of her, and their parents obviously; but we never see the parents in the show so they couldn't tell anyone about the third alicorn sister. Or I could be wrong, I don't know.


Where do you think Twilight inherited her biasness? CELESTIA😂 So why not be biased towards her evil sister🤷


In the comics,it's Luna who controls the stars,but Luna is the one trapped in the moon,so there's no way for her to free herself.


A sun is a star, and I think celestia can also somewhat control the moon, soooo...


You’re really interesting and I really love your videos!!!


Going back to your celestia setting her free theory, maybe she wanted her sister back and knew that with new bairers of the elements with the main focus as friendship, celestia knew that this time, Luna would get reformed, not defeated like how she would have had to been if celestia tried to bring Luna back herself.


Or perhaps that the spell of celestia was gone by years so she knew that she will be released this day


Maybe Celestia saw the signs that the stars would eventually let Luna out and she just sped up the process lol.


In the episodes season one episode one they said that Celestia controls the sun and they said that Luna controls the moon and stars so she made her own escape


It could be twilight she has a star but also Starlight seems more to control the stars


CELESTIa  is the sun right but the sun is a Big Star ⭐


Okay. In real life, the stars are too dim to be seen in daylight. No one controls the stars in the MLP universe. They never set. They're always just there.


i think it is either Celestia or the tree of harmony or BOTH but i know that the stars converged together


I feel this is a little obvious but, Starswirl used to control the sun which kinda counts as I star ( at least in our world) and his name is STARswirl, maybe that’s the reason. Unless you wanna say the 4-stars swirled there way on over to the moon and help nightmare moon escape, but, it’s just a theory.


You saw it wrong, twilight accidentally released Luna from the moon, something that controls the stars? Twilight cutie mark is stars.


Celestia controls the stars Celestia is the princess of the Sun the sun is just a star that is the closest to Earth are also known as Equestria I think she may have released Nightmare Moon aligning the stars in place I think the tree of Harmony played a very big role in the 9 seasons of My Little Pony friendship is Magic.


It could might be starswirl... Like stars are in his name... So it could really be him...setting a test for the other ponies.


Maybe the stars don't move because of the sun's light


well that luna/nightmare moon was sent to the moon doesn't mean that she didn't exist. Plus Celestia ruled only earth rotation so that means luna can accumulate power and herself back. I think stars weren't the ones who moved. Luna waited on the perfect position of moon and Earth. Something like an eclipse of sun or moon. I think that Celestia had a theory that Twilight can be one of the spirits of elements of harmony because of her cutie mark. And as we know Twilight was sent to ponyville to find other spirits. It was luck or destiny. Well, Celestia was teached by Starswirl so he could tell her about the spirits. BUT also he and other pillars were surprised when they noticed that the main six is connected to elements of harmony. Maybe he teached her the spell "predict future". So no magic just physics


Mabye Celestia's secretly corrupt and released nightmare as part of a complicated plan for world domination.


I've always thought that
Celestia = sun
Luna = moon
Cadence = planets
Twilight = stars
She does have stars as a cutie mark....... 🤔🤔
But maybe its Shining Armour. He has stars on his flank but he's not an Alicorn. Maybe..... 🤔🤔
Are there planets in equestria?? Probably not......


she was gonna be released if you remember the first episode


well, we still don't know if Clestia did it or didn't but on the other hand it could have done it? We still don't know, what if the creaters of my little pony are hiding something from us!


But the Shadowbolts were just a shapeshifted Nightmare Moon


What if it wasnt the tree but the star swirld and his group? To be fair they where never actually gone in the first place. If i watch the episodes closely u can some parts where his group came into play without having to be there. He is known as one of the best unicorns in my little pony. But i do have one question.... How did the tree get there in the first place and gain so much intelligent? How are the elements created at all? how long is the tree been there? How does it know who is going to use it the elements next? .... Ok so mb more then one question but still if a tree Harmony has a big role in this whole show how did it get to where it was in the first place to gain these roles?


I thinks Nightmare moon was trying to make the elements


The sun is a star and it moves so a star does move!


Star swirl did it.even tho he was in limbo we saw that limbo is sort of in stars, a powerful unicorn Like him might be able to cast a spell like that.and take a look at the book “the journal of the two sisters” in the book star swirl talks to Luna about moveing the stars!!!they r probably related??!( or starry told his pet tree to do it ;) ).


But the sun is a star.. So if she can control THAT star, she can control every star right..?


i think maybe it was a creature similar to the tantabus that turned princess luna into nightmare moon!


Twilight did
The ‘stars’ will aid in her escape
Twilight Did this without noticing
This was the elements Doing aswell,
They Use A part of twilights magic
And release her,To Grab her attention and take
Their new owners for a spin


mmm its rlly obvious that celestia did it tho, I actually rewatched episode 1 and the fact that spike said that celestia was real busy but was celestia busy and ready to release Luna/Nightmare Moon? She also wanted Twilight to make friends in order to stop Nightmare moon, the only thing im getting at is that Celestia is a hypocrite, on discord. Celestia was testing and hoping and trusted Twilight to make friends and defeat Luna, I hope that makes sense ;-;


PAARAGRAPH THEORY ALERT!

I saw a comment about blueblood and it got me thinking. If the starswirl alicorn transformation theory is correct, maybe their sibling got overlooked because stars dont move. I was gooing to say that maybe he died off but blueblood is a bit toor ecent for that. AND the stars alligned. But it is very possible that a third sibling would control the stars.
Thrid siblings for sun and moon gods/goddesses are not uncommon. Though what they control varies. Like how Eos, (Sibling of Helios and Sselene in greek myths.) controls sunsets and sunries, I would  not be suprised at all if a third more secretive sibling shows up. Maybe that sibling is even starswirl? Though he is older and doesnt appear to have wings, he might be the people's alicorn aswell as the Alicorn of the sars, just got transformed later on and hides the wings to fiit in more with the average pony? You might think it disproves the starswirl theory, but it doesnt. I think that starswirl was acctually the oldest siblings and always dabbled in magic. But his ounger sisters, being his siblings were clumsy and accidentally got affected by the potions, making them the first Alicorns. Starswirl wanted to live a normal life for as long as possible but eventually he had to become an alicorn in order nott to die and leave his sisters in grief. He made the spell to make more Alicorns to ake the people's Alicorn not be in. His sisters acknowledged and respected him wanting to live a normal life and abiding by his wishes did not feature him in the history books. Starswirl even has the word star in his name! And about blueblood, nothing ever said he had to be an immediate nephew, he could be extended family.
Hope you like my gramatically incorrect crazy heory! :)

(You probably wont but if you do use this comment please screenshot it and use it in the video talking about it. I would love to see this theory taken in or debunked.)
(This would also explain why starswirl is such a mysterious figure.)


Lunas cutie mark is a moon,Celestias cutie mark is a sun,and Twighlights cutie mark is a star,which means,Twilight controls the stars......I Guess?


Its the Tree of Harmony! The Spirit/Tree of Harmony is the real villain here!


Maybe Star Swirl was the pony who release Nightmare Moon.


I think Fransiscorn,Queen galaxia or king cosmos can control the stars.


Well I have a suspicion about something else. There is a twilight zone in the ocean. Right? Maybe twilight is a sea pony maybe that’s why she was so interested in the Chrystal that turned them into mer pony’s . Maybe there is another race of pony’s. Plz make a video on that


When the mane six defeat nightmare moon the elements were big stone balls when celestia banished luna the elements were jewels now did the elements turn into stone ball???


Celestia is connected to the sun. The sun is  a star


I think Celestia and Luna have a third sister and she set nightmare moon free and Celestia informed that third sister to release her


Star swirl planted the tree of harmony the elements stayed in the tree when celestia banished Luna elements were in their castle now did the elements get there???


Star light glimmer is who I think is moving the stars like think about it she has a star in cutie mark plus her name is STAR light glimmer and see how the stars glimmered more then the others just like her name applies and she does know a lot of magic!To think more about the cutie mark there is magic under the star in the cutie mark seeming to push it down kinda like when nightmare moon came too the series doesn't it make sense?...Or maybe I'm just over thinking....


Wait so this means…

THE MOON ISNT A SOLID


Yes but she still had no right to scold discord if anything went arie discord could just fix it


There could be a other pony that controle the stars and that maybe has banished into space or something like that yeah that’s my theory


Do you think laurn has an oc if so she in univers could have set both nightmare and Luna free


Maybe StarSwearl can control the stars hes name have a thought moon stars


I like that funny song at the beggining, it makes I laugh😂😂😂


Luna controls the moon I think because I've heard


What if there were a big twist and night mare moon was controlling the woods stars...


The moon comes with stars who raises the moon but it wouldn't make send


You do realize that the sun is a star right


Ok so I know that this is booty but I have always thought that twi had a connection to the stars


I think Twilight Sparkle controls the stars she knew it was the longest day of the 1000 years


"I'm not just some dinner roll to hold you over"


I saw an episode with Luna moving the stars


I think that princess celestia has a power she does not know (stars and sun)because they both have s in the beginning.


I know why she released nightmare moon remember how the title is called friendship is magic well so last year‘s friendship for Princess Luna made her her stronger for that day So she used her magic to move the stars and booM!!!'!'!!!!!!!!!!!'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


I think it was Nightmare Moon how helped herself escape. Bc the book said "the stars will help her ecsape" and Luna escepa in NM. I think she haved to wait then after 1000 years can her escepa. I dont have more anwers srry :( but if somone like this then thx.


In the tweet it sayed who controls the sun moon and stars the only pony who has stars as a cutie mark istwilightssparkle.


Sun is a STAR! so celestia could control 🌟 s


Can you make a video about how Twilight , Dash,Fluttershy, Rarity, Applejack, Pinkie came together


I think Princess Luna and Princess Celestia's dad raises the Stars


I think Celestia and Luna have a third sister and she set nightmare moon free


I think she done that because she felt bad and she missed her sister


At 2:22 you can see celestia's eyes all black... thought that looked cool


Nobody controls the stars it was decteny.  Because nightmare moon had to be out of the moon so that twilight would be friends with the  mane 6 so the tree of harmonys elements would have bares a bit like the rainboom🌈 .   Come on tree of harmony you have your name all over your self.


Twilights cutie mark has star’s around it so she can control the stars but she dose not know YET


I have a theory maybe it was star swrill because in his name there is star so


I know who controls the Stars it is Twilight Sparkle


Bruh you can’t just make theories out of not much proof.


the pony of shadows   as his maicge still  is there


But what is the sun...a star 🌟 that might help idk


It was twilight sparkle who released nightmare moon yes  sparkle and twilight is in her name and her cutie mark is a star


I think it is really Twilight Sparkle!!!!!


The star are contol by twilight cuz she had a star cuti marks


Maby we can get some information about all of the Mane 6 maybe their secrets there's things that we don't know about the Mane 6 maybe we could try uncovering the secrets


I’m crying ;-; I Watch sawtooth when he was brony and now that I have found him I cryed he didn’t Change one single bit c:


I think it was clestia because she missed her sister .


Think about twilight name. Her last name is sparkle, and what sparkles? 😁😁😁😁


Iv done Alot of reserch on this topic and all i know is Celesta And Luna Parents, Were alicorns, of coarse but From what iv seen and herd from The father-Was Able to control Stars And galaxy/Moon- And her Mother Controls Well the sun And so on {I cant remember what she conrols Other then The sun!} And anyways-Celesta Is like 1000 Years old, There for, Dont alicorns Live Infantry? I mean It could be her Dad-Could Have moved them and controlled them- I mean It Makes sense to me...What do you all think?


I think possibly it was nightmare her self if not many luna or star swirl


I think Star swirl the bearded baid Out Night mare moon 🧐🧐🧐😐


to me, i have a feeling that starswirl the bearded was behind this, i mean his cutie mark does consist of 4 stars


HER mother why you ask? well  luna rises the moon and her sister the other but im not sure but they say there mother  rise the sun and moon befor  them right .       THE repliy said who rise the sun AND THE moon AND the stars thats what i think. the sisters only play one part only so im not sure


If you everything it’s Luna she couldn’t do it because she was in the moon well actually nightmare moon


If Celestia trapped nightmayormoon she can releas her


Idk grogar? Discord? The sky the moon? Stars?


Twilight her cutiemark has some stars on it


Luna is Celestias sister she want her to come back and she knew 6 ponies  Will turn her into luna.


Starlight control the star cuz her name from star


I KNOW WHO IT IS IF LUNA CONTROLS THE MOON AND CELESTIA CONTROLS THE SUN AND WHO CONTROLS THE STARS ITS FREAKING TWILIGHT SPARKLE LOOK AT HER CUTIE MARK I dont know if im right but I think its twilight sparkle


Maybe it’s true that Celestia is it ? 😑😑😑😑😑


I think Celestia and Luna mom control le stars mening she is the queen of the univers?... idk im just gussing


Stars are not moving (Sun is a star to🌝🌝🌝.)


But two ponies have stars as cutie Marks twilight and shining armor but twilight is the princess of friendship so wut if she controls the stars or shinning armor I don't wut I'm thinking😭😭


This came out on my birth day thx sawtooth


So luna is her sis so she has free nightmare moon


Who is celestias parents amd who is controling sun and moon before luna and celestia


Also who I think controlled the stars is well pinkie pie I mean she's like a pony vers of discord right so maybe alocorn or not what if it wasn't the tree that brout the mane 5 together what if it was pinkie pie think about it ever since pink saw the sonic rainboom she got he magic and happyness in her life but what about before when she wasn't happy


And why is star swirl cutie mark moon and stars


Hello Sebastian does technically control the store because their dad was the protector of the galaxy stars am I am I getting something connected


Ohh i know the real answer nightmare moon was the one the one grogar maybe true but maybe nightmaremoon/luna control grogar's chamber so grogar free her/nightmare moon to destroyed equstria remember that l the episode of begining of the end the about creatures running wild destroying equstria yeah maybe grogar did it . Remember cozy glow sucks magic that was grogar's chances to escape from the moon. Case close. Bro hoof

And btw am ten years soo pls like pretty pls


I think princess salestia did free luna bicous the criator seas who controls the stars...   If the stars in our world is like fier bols what if they are eswell in the MLP world and princess salestia is capabe in contoling the sun what diference woud it be if she woud control the stars exept for it to  be night


What if it's twilight she haves stars on her cutie mark and she can control the stars but she never new that she can release nightmare moon I was just guessing but I have another thing that can explain how the stars moved the tree of harmony it haves a star in the middle and released nightmare moon to let the 6 twilight sparkle pinkie pie rarity rainbow dash flutters shy and apple jack to become friends maybe maybe or it could be that old man I forgot his name the one who planted the tree oh and watched this video late bye love you all


T hgt e sun is a star therefore celestia can control the stars


Where do you store so I stay in the room and dad controls the stars and galaxy


Pls make video of starlight and cadence future


Maybe its just destiny or mother nature wait... FLUTTERSHY! jk haha lol ( ya know mother nature ..come on!


i know who move it it's [ 3:40 ] in that all times but the [ Element Magic Tools  ] what that moves LOL XD


Wait wait wait why is twilight sparkles cutie mark stars


i tink that starlihgt glimer moeft the stars  becais look at her quti mark


I have just noticed that you changed the channels name


Star's ar suns and hu haw a sunchin in The name Sunchinsimer and was a studen in princess chelestias class. Sooooooo if sunchan if she cant haw sun or moon then stats and then was she a villen. 🎆


i have a theory SPIKE let her free heehehehe jk jk


She did it coz she belive twilith do not mind.          That will turn here back coz yeah its been years duh oh yeah hi hahahaa


My guess is: (spoilers)

So since celestia knew that twilly would make friends she knew discord would take the gamble with tirek and the others and she knew starswirl would come back so she went to limbo (can’t take that name seriously) and asked starsswirl in secret to control the stars (continuing to iistarxp) starswirl released nightmare moon and since celestia knew all the stuff that would happen she didn’t do anything welp that’s my theory >:3


I will be there at nine I only see eight


I think because she was tired of doing both jobs and she must've  missed her sister who wouldn't  miss her own sister


I always thought it was pretty suspicious of Celestia to not care or be that surprised of nightmare moon coming back


Honestly it could have been Zecora! There is so little known about the Zebra lands and what powers they might possess. Zecora seems to always know what to do and why. Perhaps this is because she has visions or something similar to Celestia. It's possible that she and other Zebras chanted something and did some sort of magic, after all she does seem to have vudu stuff in her house so I wouldn't put it past her. (I don't know much about vudu so this could be completely wrong sorry.)

Ok but if she did do this with other Zebra then where are they? Well it's possible Zecora hadn't moved away from her home land quite yet, wait... Why DID she move?? Hmm let me think.... To keep an eye on twilight perhaps? Maybe because she in fact knew of her future?

Ok so say that zebras can possibly do this, how and why would she have visions anyway? Its said zebras live in a far away land, and seemingly very different. What if Star swirl and his team got the seed for the tree of harmony FROM ZEBRAS?! Think about it; they planted it but with what seed? From where?

My idea may be flawed but its at least worth considering.


I think the stars lining up and freeing Nightmare moon was none other than the tree of harmony! But Celestia also did play a role in this. She knew that the tree was doing this because she has a connection with the tree. That’s why she said she saw the signs of Luna’s return. Also, she has been waiting for 1000 years to find twilight who can control the element of magic! That’s why she made the school of magic. And somehow, she was psychically working with the tree and not knowing it but also knowing it!? ( sorry that’s a lot!!!!)


Well it’s either Luna controls the moon & the stars or there might be another alicorn princess that controls the stars that they never mentioned in the show!


One headcannon in fanfiction i liked was that Luna and Celestia do have the power to move stars, but moving both sun and moon Celestia could not spear the energy , and by the time Luna returns ponies have learned to use the stars as is, moving them would have been a problem.


I love the Tree of Harmony theory. Also it could have been true that it was just a fake Lauren Faust account and not actually the true creator of MLP.


I think I understand how Lauren Faust meant it and how Celestia did see the sign afterall.
Celestia saying she saw the signs of Nightmare Moons return would not mean that she watched the stars move to aid in her return, I say Celestia did move them by her magic.
The signs Celestia saw would be the young mane 6 growing up and being ready to deal with and reform Nightmare moon to be her little sister Luna again.
Also we know Twilight was Celestias best student and Celestia always worked on preparing her to become the new leader of Equestria some day.
So Celestia freeing Nightmare Moon to test Twilight and as next step on Twily's way to becoming a Princess is a logical step to take imo.
And about that book Twilight read in episode 1:
Who says that it wasnt Celestia who wrote that book to give it to her chosen student when they are ready to take on the task? :P


I think Celestia controls the star as sun is also a star. However this time it was not Celestia.It was something more powerful that could control em.

ʟɪʟɪᴍᴇᴏᴡᴇᴛʜ❣


I can follow faust :3 since the sisters can control the sun and moon it makes sense that they might hold power over the stars specially Tia since the sun itself is a star


one of the animated episodes it shows that Celeste told Luna that she was going to raise the stars for her so Luna did it an And in a episode it’s said the that some of nightmare moons magic stayed so she can use that magic to aid the stars to her escape


Well, she asked who controls the moon and stars and technically Luna does but is there a possibility that she did it from outside the moon or before she got imprisoned?


What if Discord trapped in stone somehow gathered enough energy to release Nightmare Moon? Think of it like this. He controls reality and can change the land and the sky at will, so it would not be a stretch that after 1,000 years without Luna could have given him some control back. And he can hear so he would know what happened to Luna and Celestia being alone. It took both sisters to seal him and then the Mane Six to redo the spell, but what if having one be gone weakened the spell just a bit to allow him some magic. All he needed to do was wait for Chaos to come to him and release him from stone.


I think Celestia is  telling a white lie: She saw the signs, as in, she recognized the unicorn that was fit to become her successor, and just in the time, the prophecy foretold. We know, that she later specified, that she knew Twilight needed other ponies with whom to wield the elements, and that's why she sent Twilight to Ponyville. <br>In controlling the heavenly bodies, I think the stars are a part of that. I truly believe, that Celestia set Nightmare Moon free, because she knew, that the ponies, who could do, what she had been unable to, had emerged.

I think Celestia is  telling a white lie: She saw the signs, as in, she recognized the unicorn that was fit to become her successor, and just in the time, the prophecy foretold. We know, that she later specified, that she knew Twilight needed other ponies with whom to wield the elements, and that's why she sent Twilight to Ponyville.
In controlling the heavenly bodies, I think the stars are a part of that. I truly believe, that Celestia set Nightmare Moon free, because she knew, that the ponies, who could do, what she had been unable to, had emerged.


She probely assumed that enough time would have passed that she had calmed down and could work out there problems ...i mean i guess it worked


I think your right about Celestia, I believe that Celestia really let Nightmare Moon escape because as you can see in the comment of the creator of MLP he personally EMPHASIZES the ability that the pony have who let Nightmare Moon escape and It just lead to one pony and that is CELESTIA.


If the stars can be only seen at night but need the sun to be seen then a supporter of Luna and Celestia or a Protege of Luna and Celestia must be on the thrown also it must be an alicorn and that role could go to Flurry Heart or Twilight


i believe that Twilight Sparkle controls the stars. just at the time of  the first episode Twilight doesn't know she does. Think about it, Celestia controls the sun, Luna controls the moon, so why can't Twilight control the stars?


I think it's possibel that Celestia bringed back Nightmare Moon. I mean the creator said „who controls the sun, the moon and the stars?" and the sun is a star too.


remember the ram got trapped in the stars well maybe celestia managed to communicate with him and ask specifecly this “its time” also explains the fact when she said “i saw the signs”


I believe that no being caused the stars to align, and it was all through a calculation of astrology that determined that the pattern and Nightmare Moon's escape would happen after 1000 years.<br> My proof: in the episode where Starlight Glimmer goes back and stops Rainbow Dash from preforming the Sonic Rainboom, the Mane 6 never met and never became friends. One of the times Twilight comes back to the present, Nightmare Moon was ruler of Equestria. Why would Celestia or the Tree of Harmony cause the stars to align and help Nightmare Moon escape if they know there would be no Mane 6 to stop her?

I believe that no being caused the stars to align, and it was all through a calculation of astrology that determined that the pattern and Nightmare Moon's escape would happen after 1000 years.
 My proof: in the episode where Starlight Glimmer goes back and stops Rainbow Dash from preforming the Sonic Rainboom, the Mane 6 never met and never became friends. One of the times Twilight comes back to the present, Nightmare Moon was ruler of Equestria. Why would Celestia or the Tree of Harmony cause the stars to align and help Nightmare Moon escape if they know there would be no Mane 6 to stop her?


I KNOW!
lets put some logic here
The sun IS a "star" but its very close to us and we can see it clearly, so all the other millions of stars are suns. So my opinion is that celestia was always able to move the stars but she never did so they disappears at the day before sun gives ups light like the reality etc. so when she had to release nightmare moon she used those 4 stars.
What do you think about my opinion?


This might sound crazy but what if  TWIGHLIGHT accidentally freed Nightmare moon that night she was looking up at the sky? OwO


Wait what if there was an alicorn living Secret Who could control the stars. Who was asked by Celestia to show a sign on that very day.


I have a theory, Umm there was a official book published called the journal of the two sisters (yes that one) and in it it said that starswirl moved the stars, so maybe it was starswirl who released her?


What if Discord freed Nightmare Moon?After all,He's the lord of chaos.It makes sense that he would be able to control the stars,


I like to think it's either starswirl or it's sunset shimmer. It's easy to rule out starswirl because he was trapped in limbo but what about sunset? Her name kinda relates to the stars as when the sunsets there are shimmers in the sky. Sunset shimmer might've done this to over through Celestia or to win her over. Also, I think this explains her cutie mark, why it's a sun like Celestia's but not quite. This world may be mythological, but that doesn't mean that the science remains. They're still sun's, but different versions of their sun. So, in short, Celestia controls our sun's while sunset controlled the stars before going to the human world.


Okay so this might be a stupid theory but here goes, since Celestia has always been day and Luna night, I think that Luna has a part in NightMare Moons escape. She somehow saw that Celestia United the main 6 so she used her powers of night to use the stars in order to aid nightmare moons escape


do you think they will be making a season 9? i cause i really hope so !!


this is my theory. while nightmare moon was on the moon, it studies how to move the star. then she wait's for the longest day of the year to escape. because i think thr four stars only appears on that day. #imnotreallysure


Why do I feel like it's starlight glimmer or stars swirl the bearded.I mean I just have a feeling that starlight glimmer is the 5th alicorn.And surely starswirl is powerful enough to control the stars.not forgetting he also tutored the sisters meaning he could have slight intention.We know starswirl was like a father or a mentor to the sisters.He could have decided luna had enough punishment for a sin her true self didn't even commit.Also a theory suggests that starswirl witnessed this fight between the sisters but didn't stop them cuz it was destiny and all.so do u agree? Also starlight must be an alicorn.She if my starswirl theory was wrong then she must be the Princess of stars.i mean all of the other ones are kinda occupied ya know. Sun,moon,love,friendship,and probably stars. Also I really need a season 10 or a u know... a continuation series.WHO AGREES?!!.THANK YOU FOR URGENT TIME AND PATIENCE
EDIT:I just forgot he was in limbo but after all he isn't famous for nothin. Maybe he was so powerful he bent the rules of limbo?Or who said anything about no power in limbo, maybe u have power except it's not normal it's discord style maybe? I dunno do u think my theory is correct?


If the sun and moon were moved by celestia and luna and before that a powerful group of unicorns. But who were moving these two celestial objects before that time frame? If nothing were moving them, then something must have happened to let them have lost that power to move by themselves, but the stars have not lost that power. So what power has the stars have to be able to move be themselves and not with magic power?


Shanessa:I'm pretty sure it was twilight because the sun is a star and her dad's cutie mark is a christen moon. If someone had one of these ideas just know we had the same idea


I think the reason why Celestia ‚helped‘ her sister out of the moon was..

First theory: it was something like Luna was grounded?
Or...
second theory:  celestia is the queen and she knows everything about her kingdom and so she did it on purpose because she knew twilight was ready and found her magic I mean I can’t explain but isn’t that just orfjjoejedjkwjhfkjeckhdckjd she found her friends and that is the magic she needed for the elements to trigger 🤷🏼♀

I am very bad at explaining but yeah bai bai ^^


It's Celestia because she wanted her sister back and she also said that I knew you had the magic inside to defeat her


Think of somebody that causes chaos and was turned to stone but was released that is who put the stars in the right place


Guys I think I kind of get it going to the fact he thought of the tree of Harmony did it could be the Twilights came the tree set her free to see if they were the right one to rule Equestria


But luna also controls the sun and the moon so luna couldve done it but took a long time to realize how to align them


I think A lost princess of the stars set her free because mabye they used to work together to control the night


I just like to think that there is maybe a 3rd sister (or brother) that can control the stars


I think the stars were actually angels, they set nightmare moon free


The flag of the sun and moon had thousands of stars allingend in a row


the real reason is because celestial banishment spell was 1000 years of lasting so It wore of and celestia could see what's about to happen


I have a my little pony game were you can get the ponies and you can get the princesses and when you click Celestia it says “Princess Celestia is the ruler of Equestria,responsible for  raising the sun,moon, and STARS” but this was a long time ago before they changed it so I hope this is helpful.


Remeber, we dont know who Celestia and Luna'a parents are. If Celestia is the princess of of her worlds star then there could be a possibility there are other ponies who look after other stars. Remeber Earth is the only place we've found that can be habitable naturally without implantation. Equestria is Earth in their world. So in other galaxies their could be a possibility there are ponies who make sure those stars do what they do. Keep their galaxies in line, keep balance in the universe, create new planets due to the gravitational pull and cause gasses or plants to combine making new ones. And most stars are made up of star dust, the remnants of past stars. The moon was made of debri from when Earth was first being made. Hence so, they have to have a relitive that would allow Luna to be the Moon Princess instead of a star like Celestia. So perhaps their mom is another star? And their dad/partner is a meator creature? That's why Celestia knew about the signs with the stars, shes made of the remnants of past stars, so why cant see be able to communicate in some way with past stars? All stars are connected. So maybe she could even communicate with present stars that set Luna free? Maybe the tree of harmony is made of left over star dust that couldnt be manifested into a host. So it absorbed into a tree and became the tree of harmony, so latching onto brony notions theory, it could know and was able to set in motion the elemants of harmony.
(This is minor and isnt important.)
With prince blueblood, he is their nephew. So they need a sibling to be able to give them a nephew. But if their sun and moon how could they have a son? And why would his name be blueblood that doesnt fit the theme of the princesses? Their sibling could be the pony that keeps nature alive. Like plants and stuff. And itd fit the theme because Luna imade of debri. That made the earth. Making Celestia the oldest the missing sibling the middle child and Luna the youngest. Prince bluebloods name has nothing to do with plants it seems but remeber nature made the first little parasites that turned into our animalls now with the cambrian explosion and stuff. So he could very well just be a simple prince representing what his mother made. He is simply just there to observe and report back to his mother whom Im guessing is floating around Earth/Equestria.


Maybe Luna freed herself?? Think about it, stars only appear at night, which is when Luna does her part in being a princess. Another example : If you look at the dream world, where Luna can walk into any dream, the paths are made of stars, and she can walk on the star-paths. So, she could have just used the stars to get out of the moon


DUDE. IT WAS TWILIGHT FROM THE FUTURE. she is given the ability to control the sun, the moon, and the stars.


I  didn't know celestia controled the stars


Or the new princess flurry heart the princess of the stars


I think when celesta said I saw sighs of nightmare moons return she meant twilight and her friend


Since twi becoming the mane six member  was her destiny  than celestia did this she plan to release nightmare moon  to bring the mane six together  since  she can't do it because she tried bu she just put her on the moon and she knows that the mane six control the elements of harmony  so she can't


Celestia did free nightmare moon because the sun is a star so she controls the stars too.


Hold on..... What will happen to the counselling a friendship after twilight's friends die? Because don't normal ponies tend to die quicker then<br>Alicorns? .-_-.

Hold on..... What will happen to the counselling a friendship after twilight's friends die? Because don't normal ponies tend to die quicker then
Alicorns? .-_-.


Celestia can control the star in the my little pony mobile game in the celestia line say she control the sun,noon and the star


Didnt you se that the stats wear formed like Twilights cutie mark? But why wod Twilight Control the stars?


but how did nightmare moon escape even if Celestia dident find a group yet.


Starswirl he created the tree, and controlled the sun stars and moon at one time.


Isn't the sun a star? So celestia would have been just moving a star.


It could be twilight becuase she has no exact role of controlling anything.sure she is the princess of friendship but it could be more to here abillitys than just friendship


I think that celestia did control the stars, because maybe in the day the makes the stars disappear and everybody knows that she missed her sis... but I guess that would make her a liar... she does has some secrets anyway... so why just not deep that a secret? And also she went away somewhere whe nightmare moon came back, and maybe she needed to be somewhere private to move the stars because it had a lot of power and some guard would have noticed. Idk... what do you think?


Or well she cast some sort of  spell to make them last longer?


Celestia is really just so I believe that since she did banish her sister only 1000 years so she must free her after Luna's time was served


But think about it.. when celestia vanished Luna to the moon.. she controlled BOTH moon, stars, and sun..


What if Starlight released Nightmare Moon i mean her cutie mark is technically a shooting star


maybe someone is controlling the stars and they don't know that they are


Who controls le stars..?!<br>(Im wondering it's twilight LoL)

Who controls le stars..?!
(Im wondering it's twilight LoL)


the sun is a star so maybe it was selecctia after all


I have a theory what if each star represents a dream no one kontrols them but there there


But Luna is the princess of the night so even though Celestia couldn’t control the night she still sung a lullaby to Luna every night for the past 1000 years could she give luna enough power to still control the night with the moon and starts but enough to escape her sisters trapping spell but with the that particular night being what’s considered a powerful one have given Luna enough power combined with her anger have given help in her escape and able to come back and seek revenge on her own sisters blindness in not realising that luna’s work for a making such a beautiful night for them to enjoy but they just slept through it instead like it was irrelevant to them <br> It’s just my theory

But Luna is the princess of the night so even though Celestia couldn’t control the night she still sung a lullaby to Luna every night for the past 1000 years could she give luna enough power to still control the night with the moon and starts but enough to escape her sisters trapping spell but with the that particular night being what’s considered a powerful one have given Luna enough power combined with her anger have given help in her escape and able to come back and seek revenge on her own sisters blindness in not realising that luna’s work for a making such a beautiful night for them to enjoy but they just slept through it instead like it was irrelevant to them
 It’s just my theory


I mean the sun is a star. And sense no one is mentioned to control the other stars in the sky it could allud to that


I think the stars were.... Might be an Angel😅


Tbh celestia is the right way because it makes sense. She wanted to her sister back and when she knew there was a mane 5 and sending twilight would help so it just makes sense for celestia seeing as the tree of harmony didn't have the elements at that time


Sawtooth waves: who could have controlled the Stars?<br>Me: is there a secret other alicorn!!!???!!!???

Sawtooth waves: who could have controlled the Stars?
Me: is there a secret other alicorn!!!???!!!???


I think that a secret pony or fan made released nightmare moon to teach the mane six maybe.like a god of the ponys.


I think Luna freed her self,cause remember the time when applejack said granny used to tell her not alll nightmaremoons magic was gone I think that was the group of stars

And if u ask why just in the thousand years she was free maybe there's a magical lock that prevented her escape until the thousand year


The Tree of Harmony, The Princess of Stars


it points to Celestia because stars are basic the Sun


Well I know I am late to answer but  celestia Maybe waited until someone was able to change her sister back not banishing her so and when nightmare moon it wasn't long after twilight came to pony vel so celestia was one of the pony's who know so it is just my thoughts


I feel like star swirl controls the stars...


I know who control the stars it’s Starlight Starlight or Twilight at Starlight or toilet because they have started cutie marks Veranda totally speaking but not the life she has like a blue stone medium or something and Twilight go to many stars that’s why she should be


Bronynotion:who controls the stars<br>Me: it's starlestia

Bronynotion:who controls the stars
Me: it's starlestia


The show ended but theres still a lot of question


Maybe it's stars swirl the bearded

I guess 😅💫


Celestia:sun
Luna:moon
Twilight:sun and moon (because the word twilight means both day and night)
Starlight:Stars???


Celestia helped luna escape bc celesta controls sun but the sun is a star.


I think that the old ruler of the crystal empire  we didn't really get much of the crystal empire past before king sobra took over or there could be the princess of distraction


Maybe it was starlight glimmer and Sun set shimmer since they we both evil before twilight became an alicorn and they are both very powerful?


Or it's possible that Nightmare Moon set herself free, since Celestia can raise the sun and moon, wouldn't it make sense that Luna could raise the sun? So as time passed, the magic holding her on the moon got weaker, and she was eventually able to free herself. Or Celestia was reinvigorating the spell each day/year at the sSummer Sun and when she found twilight, she stopped reinvigorating it, waiting for the spell to wear off, allowing nightmare moon to escape.

She may have also known, 1000 years ago, what to look for in the bearers of the elements, and written that book herself. So she would have known when it would be time to let the spell holding moon die.

I mean, it DOES happen on the summer sun, so Celestia just. Didn't do anything. She always saw these signs, every year, but each year she prevented it UNTIL twiilight and her future accomplices were found and able to be brought together. This year, she just didn't stop anything. She didn't release or promote anyone's escape, so she would have seen the signs as well as anyone, without doing anything. But she knew that the true elements of Harmony would have a more permanent fix, as well as bringing back her sister.


I think:
It was
Rock sand
Oringe🍊
Garden flower
Apple
Rock band
Devel and 😇
CODE UNLOCK


I think Princess Celestia did it because she knew that Princess Twilight can do it but she had to find out so she did that I think she's cuckoo or she was sleepwalking or Nightmare Moon took control of her body


Am I the only one who thinks that twilight is the one one controls the stars cause of her city mark


This is just a Theory but what if it was Celestia and Lunas Dad? Or it could be star swirl the bearded


DUH ITS  MAGIC THE MOON MIGHT HAVE BEEN MOVING AND NOT THE STARS OR IT MUST HAVE PULLED THE STARS TOWARDS IT AND WHO WAS IN THE MOON LUNA AND TECHNICALLY ITS MAGIC! EQUASTERIA ISNT IN EARTH ITS IN A COMPLETE DIFFERENT GALAXY CAUSE FOR ONCE NO AIR IN SPACE HOW COULD SHE BREATH !


maybe is controlling the stars is flurry harts  destiny


Him: says J.K. Rowling

Me: Wait wait wait wait wait wait - WHAT


Actually Grogar was discord...watch the Ending of the end episode


The sun is a star <br>Thats the queston who controls the stars well celestia

The sun is a star
Thats the queston who controls the stars well celestia


It was Celestia because what is the what is the sun a star so it makes sense that Celestia did it


Celestia controlled the stars cause is the sun a star yep


Twilight did it sun moon and twilight would've stars


sun is a star and luna controls the stars and moon


I hate it cause on Apple TV u have to pay for EACH episode of mlp (my little pony)


Wait are stars not Sun's just far away? And who control sun???


Star swirl the bearded controlled the stars!


Wait, Twighlight Sparkle ;-; I feel like that rings a bell somewhere

Edit: I feel like this goes somewhere sense Twighlight helped Luna and Celestia raise the sun and set the moon in season 9 and the stars are smaller than the moon and sun, and Twighlight is shorter than Luna and Celestia. But it doesn’t make much sense but it fits somewhere :>


Luna reformed herself not the mane six and celestia did not reform for luna either


I know who did that Luna dad he has stares for a cutie mark too


Starlight glimmer controls the stars !!!


I don't think so. I think Grogar Realeased Night mare moon


"There are no toilets in equestria"
insert Apple Jack coming out of an outhouse in 'The last Roundup'

"There are no toilets in equestria"
*insert Apple Jack coming out of an outhouse in 'The last Roundup'*


Luna is the princess of the night stars are a part of the night she is not only controlling the moon


This is really dumb but I think twilight did it


If that mane six  defeated nightmare moon with the elements of harmony why didn’t nightmare moon become Princess Luna when Princess celestial used the elements of harmony


Luna  control  the  moon.and  stars. but when she was  sent to the moon celestial ruled day and night. WATCH cantersoft video of  luna


I think luna free her self think obout it we only see stars when the moon rises which mean luna is kinda controlling the stars so she is the queen of stars so to speak and she said to her dear freinds when she was traped GET ME OUT OF HERE  and they listen to there queen and free her

Or onother thing she said LOK AT THE PATTERN OF THE STARS  who has stars on there mark? Four to be exact in the axect pattern?


The pillars and the leader of the pillars fact they planted the tree


Maybe it was night mare moon bc she Co trols the night and what is with the night? THE STARS so that means Luna/nightmare moon controlled the stars and uses them to open the door to the pony world ist that obvious nobody but nightmare moon or Luna did it with her last power Luna controls the night the night has stars so it could mean that Luna freed nightmare moon so she gets help from the fried s of equrestria or???


Could it be their parents I mean anything is possible


I'm going to correct you on that Luna in what episode the episode the episode but video call far away it's Celestia and Luna singing the Stars Luna says I have to do the stars to is the first time that you've raised the Moon in the in one video the fall in the fall of the Crystal Empire Celeste this is the first time we ever see Nightmare Moon in a video Goosebumps actors about Nespresso she says to the person to King Sombra the same power you were the same power you were gifted with the same power I was in born with so why would it just stopped at the Moon why did have the Moon is Darth 2 do yes learn does control the Stars


Wait a minute something isn't right maybe Lunas controlling the stars ksos one night is there the stars are always there


Please sun is a star....... if you know Luna....wait a minute does that mean .........can star swirl be controlling stars....till now because no one was there..... make a video about theories who might control stars......there is huge confusion maybe star swirl is strong enough to control....THE STARS .....maybe just a theory


For the stars i fink that starsfill is that Who bring nightmer moon to ponyvile but how? He was in limbo


ok, I know it's late but 0:42 or 45 what if starlight glimmer or twilight controlled the stars? think of it starlight glimmer and twilight have the star mark...
I am confused but another is cadences husband he also has a star mark...


Luna's mom if you thont know Luna's mom you thont know her name well if you thont know her name well her name is ...... Queen galaxia in galaxy ther r stars so luna 's mom freed Luna 🌙⭐🌌


I think twilight did look at the episode again and see w


TWILIGHT CONTROLS THE STARS CUZ SHE HAS THE STAR CUTIE MARK AND SHE RELEASED NIGHTMARE MOON!!!!!!!!!!!!


IT WAS DESTINYYYYYY (reference to another video :D)


If.you knew mlp.you would know rainbow dash brought them all to pony Ville with her sonic rain boom


Think which pony has a ✨ cutymark I think it was the princess of frends tuielity sparkl


The keretel berring the setar
Ther de olni wan The
Powerpole enap
Thek kecorel
Th setae;)


Wait     Who controls the stars?   Isn’t that Twilight’s Sparkles CUTIE MARK? STARSssssss!?! Just a theory I made ;) Edit sorry  I just scrolled through the comments and saw someone with the same idea as me ;-:


I think is who controls the stars and maybe toilet because if she is to visit friendship she might have controlled the whole friendship even are you tomorrow is the star


What if the Pokemon GOD Arceus set Luna free or even the Pokemon of death did it yes I mean yveltal or maby the got of transformers primus did it UvU we will never know


UK 'star'swirl <br>Idk I just tot of that for some reason TwT

UK 'star'swirl
Idk I just tot of that for some reason TwT


lol i love the thumbnail (I'm 13 and i love mlp is this normal TwT)

☆ɢᴀᴄʜᴀᴇᴍɪ_ᴇᴅ☆


What song are you using in the background


Queen Galaxia or King Cosmos there parents


Idk why bit i think starswirl controls the stars bahahahaha. I cant watch all of the mlp episodes so idk. I want starlight to be the princess of stars butttttttt nope.


Know one sorry bro but didn't you know stars move over years and it has been 1000 years of nightmare moons vagueness thing  and that's along time so the 4 stars might of moved over knowing that cellestea knew as a lot of people know this fact I think any way still love your thinking but we still need to thing in knowledge and things that can happen in the move and in real life so think about it and make a video about your thinking now that I've told you


Twilight sparkles future child that what i think


Hey Luna control moon and  star and if Luna is  gone  soo ......


No I didn’t have time for a long day and I didn’t know you had a good time and I’m sure you’re going to have a good time with your family or friends or whatever else I can do to you guys


I know selestia did it so twilite can learn friensip she did not wan friend and we all know thet twilite can not do it alone to bit nite mare moon she need friend to bit her but selestia know thet she dont want them so


Why do they yeah it's only say the small words they don't talk very much just like the guy that says yep I don't remember what his name is in My Little Pony


Star swirll control stars if you saw that when


Nowaan knchrool th staars luna doo wan she raays th moon th staars raays wath thmoon


What about sunset shimmer the human world what happen to her


I just want to say that I’m not going to make you happy ***gg


XD didint even now ti hint contol the stars second hint enpier


That's actually a good question I always assume that whoever was controlling the main celestial bodies could control the stars as well but maybe just maybe while Luna is controlling the move someone else is controlling the night.


Right in the last episode (I think) the three villains took discords magic, after wards they tried to use the magic. We can see how that went out, Cozy glow went absolutely crazy.
Tirek then said that "no one can use discords magic" but when we first met tirek he betrayed discord and took his magic. He didnt go crazy so why couldnt he do it again.
And when we first met him he took it straight from him, does the bell do something to the magic to make it impossible to use?

I know this could just be bad writing but I think it is still rather interesting

G̸͇̓l̸̲̈́i̷͚̽t̷͎̓ċ̴̞h̸̻͋_Animations

I think based on what we’ve seen Tirek absorbs up magical ENERGY while the more powerful Grogar’s Bell absorbs magical ESSENCE.


Like you said that Grogar actually turned into the constellation Aries (love that theory btw), what if the other constellations like Scorpio cancer or Virgo were actually people banished into the stars? Maybe even people who are famous in the equestrian history that died and now formed in constellations. Hell they can even be the pillars of Equestria. I like the idea of beauty being Virgo. And how every event that takes plays has six character, example the student six and pillars of equestria. And we AND Equestria have 12 astrological constellations.