Hmm I think that a similar thing like with Discord happened - Discord’s spell was broken once the princesses lost connection to the elements. Here, the banishment spell lasted 1000 years in a means that Celestia couldnt have used her Magic to bring Nightmare Moon back - otherwise she would have brought her back sooner and reform her herself but all the references in the show suggest that she couldnt. Now at the time of the end of the 1000 years period Celestia already had Twilight as a student and knew about her future friends and since she obviously had princessy plans for Twilight from early on she figured out that perhaps it would be better if Twilight learned to use the elements instead of just reforming Nightmare Moon herself. Now with the stars... Celestia does not control the stars directly but has access to the star realm seen in the Magical Mystery Cure episode where Twilight becomes an alicorn. When Twilight is turned into  an alicorn a bright star appears in the sky. For that reason I think that Celestia was the one who released Nightmare Moon. She said she ‘saw the signs’ but those signs were actually those 1000 years that passed which meant she could use her Magic to break the spell. So she sent Twilight to Ponyville and then entered the star realm to use her spell to free Nightmare Moon at the right moment (which appeared on the sky like a bunch of stars freeing her) and stayed in the realm watching over Twilight. When the mane 6 defeated Nightmare Moon Celestia raised the sun and returned from the star realm.


how tf was celestia so certain that she would find the one who can bear the element of magic in a thousand years time heck how did the prophecy know


Celestea-I can just waste the windows I broughted


Twilight did. And here is why; Twilight has the same cutie as the stars that surround the moon. However; I believe Luna was trapped inside of Nightmare Moon, and Nightmare Moon was trapped in the moon. And she didn’t say that she saw the signs of Nightmare Moon’s return, but rather her sister Luna’s return. Twilight’s cutie mark has stars in it, not only that; Twilight Sparkle and her friends facilitated the return of Luna be redeeming Nightmare Moon and freeing Luna from the darkness and evil within her that made her Nightmare Moon in the first place.

Lady Kimberly Rowan Delaney Hosier de Rothschild


I dont think anyone noticed this but I rewatched the episode and the second twilight arrived theres a little easter egg, the same stars were on big macs cutie mark for a second


Sawtooth Waves: "Let me explain"<br>Let Me Explain Studios: "Hippity Hoppity Get Off My Property"

Sawtooth Waves: "Let me explain"
Let Me Explain Studios: "Hippity Hoppity Get Off My Property"

All hail the oodilolie bronies; the oodleonies

@meera colourby

Ok so they are a youtuber

😂🔥😂 and 😂 and 😂 and 😀 good 😂 and 😂😂😂™😂😂😂😂


The part I saw Princess Luna doing The funny walk that I saw was so funny.


Cant we all just agree this is a show for kids and theres no backstory or odd theories lol🤣


I still could be celestia as she knew twilight didn’t want to make friends so celestia realeased nightmare moon so twilight would discover FRIENDSHIP


I think the tree of Harmony did it because they knew that the main six was at their time was like really strong and like I think the tree might have told Celestia to send Twilight to Ponyville to stop stop the madness


Many fans say that Luna controls the stars as well, due to her personality being more associated with the arts, and her night often referred to as "beautiful", which would be strange if stars were not involved at all. But many also say that Celestia didn't really touch them all that much during her sole rule, either from a lack of power (she had to handle both celestial bodies) or a lack of artistic talent. So she could be still able to control the stars without deciding to do so for thousands of years.

I still agree that the Tree instigated everything and used Celestia, and is likely the source of her visions in the first place, if you think about it.


I just had a thought. We don't know if the pony world is a planet or a flat disc, but if it were a planet like ours, when Celestia moved the sun she would move it to the other side of the planet (assuming the sun and moon move around the planet), the moon would replace it. They wouldn't be moving in a constant orbit otherwise Celestia wouldn't need to do anything, or she would be using her magic all the time, but she doesn't. This means that she literally moves it from one side to the other, so there are two quarters of the planet in between where it is always twilight (with very brief nights and days when the moon and sun is moved across them, but moving the moon and sun is seen to only take a couple of minutes). I think this 'twilight zone' could be some kind of wasteland, since there are also no ponies to control the weather or the seasons. Or it could be more like the everfree forest, where it controls the seasons and weather itself.


I think it was a tree and Celestia because Celestia controls the sun and the stars are the sun so she can control with the tree it’s alive as we all know that we saw in season eight so the tree probably was talking she has visions so she probably saw the six and the tree and Sebastian planned out reform  😏


Hang on a minute, queen Galaxia is luna and celestia’s mother right? Queen galaxia probably controls the stars . It would make sense for her own mothe to release her


Holy ravioli i just noticed: lauren said to watch the episode again and i did……and the way the stars were arranged were EXACTLY like the stars on……………………………………..STAR SWIRL’S CUTIE MARK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Interesting theory, but I don’t think that it was even something we know of that moved the stars


What if Celestia really didn’t move the stars except ponies never really realized it so they didn’t add it

Çøffī_čåkš {•_•}


Its Star Swirl He was in the group of the wizards who raised the sun and the moon and star swirl can control the stars


When it is night then it is dark then we can see the stars


Uk what i wanna know? 🤔Who the heck controlled all the celestial bodies ...raised the sun and moon before gregor came  ..before the unicorn grp ? When their were just farms and pastures....since i am pretty sure the farms are gonna need the light cycles to grow...and the inhabitants to exist for that matter..😂


it says in the 1st episode, that celestia took responsibility for both SUN AND moon And harmony remained ever since.


Unless.. A young pony had earned her cutie mark by moving those stars..what if that pony knew about nightmare moon? Dont forget twilight had a book that spoke about the details of nightmare moon so..that doesn't mean another pony couldnt have had a book either, maybe there is secretly a pony that can control stars positioned around the moon think about it if the princess said “I saw the signs of her return” She may have seen the stars move herself it makes me belive that some pony actually set nightmare moon free maybe by accident thinking she may had been turned back to her original princess luna form. Now maybe another pony also knew about the tree of harmony..or had a vision of what they need to do maybe they had a vision of the stars moving and MAYBE princess luna telling her to move the stars and set her free. Dont forget that not all of nightmare moons magic was banished to the moon with her, some pony may had earned there cutie mark by releasing her but they may have had no idea of nightmare moons return themselves. This was just a thought I had I cant remember exactly seeing any ponys with stars as there cutie marks but maybe they was 4 ponys that moved each star and got their cutie marks..


i think both of the sisters set luna free. hear me out. luna would have control of the star and moon. there both night things so i imagine it. and celestia controls the sun. she probably saw a vision of luna being free and maybe luna did to. so i sugget they worked together. thats why luna was suprised. she didnt know that she was helping.


Okay season 7 ep 1 celestial advice- I fully support the theory that celestia used twilight to harness the elements and free her sister from the moon and conform her back to good.  5 minutes and 30s from the end of the show Celestia is talking about how she’s trying to get young twilight to talk and make friends- without having to send her away. Knowing that’s something twilight could easily avoid- she looked to the nightmare” moon and sighs saying how she must send her away.  - fully support this theory that this was an orchestrated plan


Who controls the stars celestia controls the sun and the sun is a star 🌟


I have a little theory: The sun is a star too, so maybe Celestia can control stars. Maybe she helped Nightmare Moon with the stars to escape somehow, and Nightmare Moon set herself free. I mean, if you were banished to the moon, you would try to escape too, right? So Celestia couldve just helped Nightmare Moon to escape while Nightmare Moon somehow got herself free by her own Magic. Now to the line: "I saw the signs of Nightmare Moons return" i think with "signs" she meant signs that it worked. She could've seen those stars come closer to the moon or something, after she did some sort of spell.


sawtooth, some advice. watch the start of the episode carefully. where do you see stars...?


Mabye the banishing spell doesn't reverse until a thousand years <br>Think about it: when the pillers where banished to limbo they where gone for a thousand years until the mane 7 freed them

Mabye the banishing spell doesn't reverse until a thousand years
Think about it: when the pillers where banished to limbo they where gone for a thousand years until the mane 7 freed them


maybe before the tree controlled the sun moon and stars or its celestia cause sun is a star i guess.or it could be star swirll because before clestia and luna ruled star swrill took care of the things.


What if the celestial from the human world came saw the moon with a pony in it tried to protect herself by using magic but because she can't handle it she accidentally released nightmare moon because she is principle of da school so controlls Luna kind of (moon) and obviously the sun. One of the students could be a star controller as well like maybe is very interested in them so in the pony word they make a vanishing spell for day and make them come back at night!


PLEASE READ!!!! Maybe there was a third sister of the stars, keeping them in place who was younger, or even Luna making sure the stars were in place. You may try to argue that if there was a third sister of the stars, why havent we heard of her? And what about Celestia and Luna's past? Well in my book, the journal of the two sisters,(its also included in the first time the main six visited the castle of the two sisters when twilight finds the secret room and sees a book called the journal of the two sisters) it gives some info about what happend before the started ruling, plus it mentions that they knew star swirl when they were young alicorns. Even before they got there cutie marks! And if they did come from some where else, and were born alicorns, it makes sense. when Celestia said the birth of an alicorn was some thing Equestria had never seen, and luna saying that it is beyond there understanding, it probably means that they wouldnt expect to see an Equestrian pony give birth to an alicorn. Even though Rarity said she thought alicorn wings had to be earned by a princess worthy deed, (AKA creating new magic) there is no way the royal sisters' backstory or past is commonly known. Sorry its so long, i had alot to say. Please reply telling if you agree or disagree and why.

Yea I believe the two sisters did came from outside Equestria


well the sun <b>is</b> a giant star but i dont know if it is concidered one in equestria there it might as well be a giant ball of magic that celestia raises

well the sun *is* a giant star but i dont know if it is concidered one in equestria there it might as well be a giant ball of magic that celestia raises


I think Princess Celestia and Princess Luna's little sister if they have one might control the Stars and accidentally freed Nightmare Moon


I think the tree has a Connection with the moon and the sun(NO SUNNNN) so I think that the tree let Luna go.


I think  nightmaremoon release  herself  because in session 5 remark nightmare was still  got out and in the episode  the royal problem Luna said" I have your magic and your  magic  is useless  in the dream  world" so maybe her magic is useless on the stars too!


I'm seeing a lot of people say "The Sun is a star, so she can control the stars too" But that's true for our world. Perhaps the stars are totally different in the MLP world. As for who controls them, I'm still subscribed to the Grogar Theory because it still makes sense. Idk.


Maybe nightmare moon herself? <br>I mean she does control the Moon.

Maybe nightmare moon herself?
I mean she does control the Moon.


What if, what if it was twilight, the tree did take form of twilight  when leading the other students in season 8 or 9. And Twlight knows alot about the stars but she probably didnt do it intentionally


To be clear it was the rainboom that made the mane 5 going to ponyville but it was celestia who sent twilight to ponyville


I've always had this theory, so even if it's not 100% canon, I'm glad Lauren Fausts thinks the same :')


I heard that celestia and lunas father controlled the stars and the moon before Luna did, but that wouldn’t make sense because Luna controlled the moon after he did and didn’t control the stars...


I actually created a princess that controls the stars 😂


Celestia Could have been the one Who release nightmare moon because The sun is also a star and she said who controls the sun moon and stars 😑😑😑


Now, I know that Luna doesn't control the Sun. But her cutie mark tells us she controls the moon and stars... She can move both the moon AND the STARS... Maybe, she set herself free


Do you remember that thing about how discord was created as a counteract to harmony well if this theory is true and the spirit of harmony did set nightmare moon free then wouldn’t that cause at least a little chaos 🤷♀🤔


I think grogar are realeased nightmare moon. Because he sent cozy,sombra,and chrysalis to attack equestria. I think grogar wanted to do the same with nightmare moon.


if u see the tree of harmony theres sun moon and star in middle does twilight or starlight can control stars if there will be season 10 so it means yes


Aren’t the stars the same thing as the sun so it could be celestia controlling them


Nope it was another alicorn who... well it was starlight with time travel. She is going to be an alicorn. I know from a rip in the space time continuem. She uses time travel in the future when she was trying to mess up the main six, this attempt changed nothing. But obviously Starlight as an alicorn controls stars. She help nightmare moon escape. This is what happened


Unless this is some sort of next-level typo, could Luna possibly have (somehow) released herself? Considering both the 'Sun and moon and stars' were mentioned, Wouldn't Luna have control over the stars? During the series, Celestia and Luna a strictly bound to raising/lowering the sun/moon for their specific part of day. Of course, Celestia had to either assume the role of raising/lowering the moon while Luna was imprisoned, or maybe she'd (Luna) been doing it herself? Also, bonus; If I remember correctly, In 'A Royal Problem, Celestia seems blatantly unaware of Luna'd duties as if she'd never assumed her roles before?? Ignore this I guess lmao)

And I saw a few comments mentioning that the sun is a star, but this is Equestria we're talking about; The sun might not even classify as a star because logic doesn't exist??

Unless this is some sort of next-level typo, could Luna possibly have (somehow) released herself? Considering both the 'Sun and moon and stars' were mentioned, Wouldn't Luna have control over the stars? During the series, Celestia and Luna a strictly bound to raising/lowering the sun/moon for their specific part of day. Of course, Celestia had to either assume the role of raising/lowering the moon while Luna was imprisoned, or maybe she'd (Luna) been doing it herself? Also, bonus; If I remember correctly, In 'A Royal Problem, Celestia seems blatantly unaware of Luna'd duties as if she'd never assumed her roles before?? Ignore this I guess lmao)

And I saw a few comments mentioning that the sun is a star, but this _is_ Equestria we're talking about; The sun might not even classify as a star because logic doesn't exist??

Quantum Production Studios omg I just thought of something. What if Nightmare Moon got help from Celestia on the thousandth year too get out of the moon?!

Did you think the case of Luna ,  same parts similar stygian ?
Stygian seems have able to communicate and think even make a move inside pony of shadow , so maybe Luna still have  abilities to do something during nightmare moon
And that's how I consider about it.


Well sun is the closest star to us and Celestia controls the sun so technically she could control the stars too?


Maybe the tree of harmony controls the stars the pony's the used to rise<br>The sun and moon maid the tree of harmony maybe they made it to rise the stars star swirl maybe had the idea his name is"star" swirl maybe just a suggestion what do you

Maybe the tree of harmony controls the stars the pony's the used to rise
The sun and moon maid the tree of harmony maybe they made it to rise the stars star swirl maybe had the idea his name is"star" swirl maybe just a suggestion what do you


Could it be Starswirl that control the stars?


You came oh my God people keep missing details in the story of Celestia it says when she banished her sister to the Moon she became the bear of the moon and sun which means she controlled night and day if she controls night it means she controls the Stars


I also tought of Starlight, beacuse there IS a star in her cutie mark, AND in her name, but why WOULD Starlight care about that?

Also, you can make a video about Starlight and Cadences future!

Well then twilight would have been  able to control twilight


So if Luna was on the moon, does that take her powers away? No it doesn't. So maybe she freed herself by moving the stars. Think about it.

Maybe... I DON'T KNOW OKAY I'M ONLY 10 I'M A YOUNG CHILD I DON'T KNOW THINGS I HAS A SMALL BRAIN

But why wouldnt she let her self free faster?


It might be celestia because the book was written already someone like celestia must have freed her


I think it is starlight glimmer who set night mare moon (princes luna) free because her name starts with starlight. Sure she came out in a different season but I think its her who let night mare moon (princes luna) free


Every time the sun goes up in my little pony the stars go away I think no one really knows who controls the stars but when The moon goes up The stars comes!


Before luna got banished she controlled the moon and stars.
After she was banished Celestia took all of lunas duties which means she also controlled the stars.
So YOU'RE the false one!


starlight could be the one that is useing the stars


I think it is Celesta because the sun is a star


Celestian is actully moving the stars or just one cause the sun is a star

Actually, in our world, sun is a star but different in equestria, sun is not a star in equestria. So Celestia not controlling the stars.

I was about to comment that. Thank God someone pointed.


I have an answer to that! And drumroll please.... Astra! AKA my OC. Yeah Ik Ik she's not ACTUALLY in the show, but she's the lost sister of Celestia and Luna who's job is to move the stars around. She's from the alicorn civilization (as which you theorized in another video) and she looks a lot like her mother but in black and purple, close to Luna but not quite bc she's not just this blueish black, she is PITCH black with a purple fade on her horn, legs, wings and mane and tail. She with-holds a lot of power in order to move billions of stars. In equestria, it's shown that the sun is about the same size as the moon, compare that to every star we can see on the sky and Astra looks like a Goddess compared to the princesses. Why so overboard? You may ask, I mean she's not just a side character, she plays a huge role, even though she's just an OC, well, if I'm gonna have an original character that I can make however I want, I'd rather go <b>big</b> or go home!

I have an answer to that! And drumroll please.... Astra! AKA my OC. Yeah Ik Ik she's not ACTUALLY in the show, but she's the lost sister of Celestia and Luna who's job is to move the stars around. She's from the alicorn civilization (as which you theorized in another video) and she looks a lot like her mother but in black and purple, close to Luna but not quite bc she's not just this blueish black, she is PITCH black with a purple fade on her horn, legs, wings and mane and tail. She with-holds a lot of power in order to move billions of stars. In equestria, it's shown that the sun is about the same size as the moon, compare that to every star we can see on the sky and Astra looks like a Goddess compared to the princesses. Why so overboard? You may ask, I mean she's not just a side character, she plays a huge role, even though she's just an OC, well, if I'm gonna have an original character that I can make however I want, I'd rather go *big* or go home!


Maybe grogar! I think he was imprisoned in the stars he might have enough magic to move them and


I think Nightmare Moon control the star to escape but I am not sure yet but I think the sun control the star to unleash Nightmare Moon so I predict that Nightmare Moon found magic so if twilight accidentally unleash Nightmare Moon because twilight cutie mark is a pink star and her cutie mark is like the star at night time . People might ask why do you comment this because I think this is the problem for the video that Sawtooth Waves is doing.


If I’m being honest I think it was STARlight glimmer or STARswirl. We know that starlight holds a lot of unicorn power and Starswirl has stars all over him (just a theory tho)


Sawtooth: how come she knew everything about this? Meh: Celestia bows everything

Did you mean knows? You wrote bows instead if you wanted to right knows


We can see stars at night but not morning because morning has lots of light


Wait I have 2 theories its either star swirld (unlikely) or Daybreaker (Likely)
I choose daybreaker more since she is also a VILLIAN aka evil celestia she can also control the sun but you may ask
"But what about the stars??" Well heres what I think Day = Light = Heat = Heated Gases = Stars but celestia wouldnt really set a villian but a villian would free another villan now back to the stars daybreaker never appeared on the show but she could have been banished WAYYY before if there was a place where the sisters came from there is a possibility daybreaker was banished there instead but daybreaker would want to set night mare moon free since probably making an apperence wouldnt really make much sense since if she went all the ponies wouldnt know her or if she was a villian at first but she probably just set night mare moon to do it since she wasnt banished to the moon  so somehow they would meet and get along then thats when the plan comes she will control the stars and set night mare moon free as she will do most of the work and free her after but WHAT HAPPENED? She got reformed and daybreaker was stuck there as for when miss I WANT ALL THE CUTIE MARKS OF MY TOWN  dreamt about her in the night realm as she more of a evil celestia she would be able to move stars so THATS BASICLY AN ANSWER

ⁿⁱᶜᵏⁱɴɴ𝐆𝐃𝐈꧂ ❤


Remember how laruen said it was a pattern it's a diamond! and look at Celestias crown its has a diamond! it all makes sense! ♢


Twilight accidentally released her Twilight released Nightmare Moon she did not realize that she accidentally used her magic remember when Twilight took over the Royal sister's place and they fused there crowns and what is the Sun a star and when do you See Stars the night and what is also present in the night the Moon Twilight controlled the Stars accidentally she had the power to but that was only a little so she could only move 4 stars what happens after she takes over the sister's place she can move the Stars perhaps helping the Dream Team which you have theorized about before


4:47hopefully not a big one since we’ve seen how bad of an actress she is...


I think "who controls the sun moon and stars" We know celestia controls the sun luna controls the moon right? no other princess we have seen has controlled a natural time BUT there are 5 "known" princesses in Equestria known there might be other princesses that we have not seen so maybe the princess of the stars "we've never seen" could have bailed nightmare moon out you guys might say that there can only be 5 princesses because celestia and luna said that but there might be other alicorn princesses that they have not heard of just like the tale in the episode "hearts and hooves day" the CMC's tried to get Big mac and there teacher together but then they found a love potion and gave it to their teacher and big mac but then the found out it was a love poison because they got all goo-goo on each other. there was a prince that had a crush on a princess and gave her a love potion, but it was a love poison the princess in that story was an alicorn this proves that there are other alicorns beside the 5 so maybe there is a princess of the stars that we haven't seen in the show that bailed nightmare moon out you guys might be like Jax if we haven't seen them in the show it means they don't exist guys just because we haven't seen them in the show doesn't mean they don't exist take gro gar for an example we saw he was discord we haven't seen the real gro gar in the show but he certainly exists in the world of friendship is magic so i like my theory but i like your theory the brony notion


Theory:Midnight moon was a normal alicorn she wanted to be a queen she followed every step she controlled the stars When Luna found out she banned midnight moon from the castle she went to cadence's castle cadence said no she went to the moon to go see the stars but.. When she went there she got sucked into the moon no one saw her again except s1 e1 no one talked about her it was like she wasn't here in equistia anymore then the moon faded then that spot on the moon was made she was trapped over thirty years and more and when she got kicked out she was a young pony Celestia told every pony to keep it a secret expect to tell the main six.. Well that's my theory bye every pony and every human!


I have a theory of what may have happened its a stretch and kind if out there but it could be possible

Luna helped nightmare Moon escape

The Shadow pony may have existed before Nightmare Moon did, instead of Nightmare moon creating the Shadow pony by remnants of her dark magic what if the dark magic created Nightmare Moon.

Maybe the Shadow Pony just needed a willing host and since Luna wanted revenge on Celestia she indirectly became a willing host for the shadow pony. The two if them stayed separated beings, the Shadow Pony only needing control over a physical body and when it got it Luna was held captive like The Pony of Shadows and Stygian.

When the elements of Harmony banished her to the moon some of the Shadow Pony detached and remained in equestria. Which is why the second time the Elements were used Luna was able to be freed. Unlike the first time when the Shadow Pony was still a fully in control of her the redemption wouldn't have worked. The spell was too strong for Luna or the Shadow Pony to break but I the 1000th year is when the spell finally weakened enough for Luna, the princess of the night as She told Scootaloo, who controlled the Moon and as the princess of the night the stars too, to help herself escape.

Also when the elements removed the darkness it wouldn't remove the past trauma and anger that caused Luna to give in to begin with. Removing the darkness won't make someone happy again with Stygian he had to be convinced to finally move on and forgive before he was saved. Over the years Luna had time to think and see the damage that giving into hate caused which is why when she was finally free of the Shadow Pony she was willing to work alongside her sister again, but when she first returned the darkness of the Shadow Pony still had control over her until the Elements of Harmony was able to seperate it from Luna


She released Luna like she did with discord so the mane 6 could reform her

☀ 𝓟𝓮𝓪𝓬𝓱𝓮𝓼 𝓾𝓷𝓲𝓿𝓮𝓻𝓼𝓮 ☀


Celestia always knows everything, but she never did anything useful...<br>Like always.

Celestia always knows everything, but she never did anything useful...
Like always.


if it's the tree of harmony it makes sense， there is sun， moon，and star on the tree🤪


what if twilight traveled through time and freed nightmare moon


I mean the sun is a star so she moves at least one.


HE CONTROLED THE STARS, MOON AND SUN AND HE PROABALY LET NIGHT MARE MOON OUT OF THE MOON


I bet Celestia was laughing hard when she saw every pony be terefide when Nightmare moon said;: The night will last forever! Hahahahaha! And Celestia is like: not under Twilight's hooves!😀😎


Honestly,I think it’s celestia did it bc she wants to test the mane 6


Celestia probably controls the stars because the stars are suns


The sun, moon, and stars are controlled by someponys magic


Tbh I think that she wanted to take a test of mane 6 and twilight passed it see the season 9 again that princesses retired she said the whole life was a test of you


I think it was Starlite shimmer because she was evil and she was probably powerful enough


I just wanna ask this…is there a pony god?


Maybe there's a secret alicorn that celestia tought to become the princess/prince of the stars


I think Luna released herself because she controls the moon and STARS


Well, the sun is star, Isn't it mean CELESTIA released Nightmare Moon.  Lauren Faust is not wrong at all


I THINK IT'S STAR SWIRL!!!!! HE'S THE ONE WHO WOULD HAVE KNOWN IT WOULD TURN OUT GOOD!!! and think about it the one who controls the STARS. STAR swirl! Only me?? Really.


May I say that yea there is no pony that controls stars Equestrian is a mysterious land but still Celestia could have did this to free Luna we know she missed her also I feel bad for the pony’s in the past because when Luna was in the moon who gave pony’s good dreams


in season 9, twilight replaced the princesses and controlled both the sun and moon, and her cutie mark is a star


Who controls the Stars? No one. So the answer is no one. No one helped her escape. The alignment of the Stars gave her the power to escape. It’s that simple.


I think it's ✴ because she has a star cutemark


Not all that glitters is gold.
Not all that twinkles are stars.

Consider.
Magic and Space have always intertwined. From the most powerful unicorns having stellar names, to magic itself representing itself as both aura and sparkles.

When Nightmare Moon was imprisoned, she became a literal feature on the moon. All the extra mass and magic has to go somewhere. Perhaps, as "stars" that surrounded the moon? Or perhaps, those "stars" were merely magic gathered over a thousand years, in order to pull herself out of her "imprisonment".

Perhaps, this is a case of Nightmare Moon literally pulling herself together again.

(Blasts of powerful magic against Darkness based beings, in show, have this habit of blasting them into pieces. The "lunar sea" that was Nightmare Moon was both her portrait, prison and her impact zone. Kinda of a dark and yet humorous image)

(... this could also mean that she was still "fragmented" on her return. Definitely not powerful enough to take Equestria, like in Starlight's timeline (yet), which is probably why she fled instead of outright invaded. (Also indicated by "low power" (Season 1) Luna, post EoH.) Luna's rescue could be a blunt force version of how Stygian was saved. If she had been at full power, it probably wouldve ended in another impact zone, and another thousand years)


hmm well if i had to guess i would say twilight even though her whole thing is friendship her cutie mark is a star, could she maybe have triggered it accidentally?

Probably not. My theory is that as soon as Luna/Nightmare Moon was sent to the moon, a 1000 year timer started and the stars would move little by little every year, until she was finally freed. So it’s still sorta Celestia who did it because she sent her up there and when she was sent up there she accidentally started a timer, which was the stars getting closer and closer.

Probably not, the stars were set to release her in a 1000 years as soon as she was brought up there, and Twilight definitely wasn’t born yet.

@Jocelyn Gilbey Who is the book writer, why did the book writer knew that the stars will release Luna in 1000 years?

Lol like reading the prophecy would release nightmare moon.


Sawtooth I think both groagar and celestia released nightmare moon think of it celestia moved the stars and groagar did the nessesary magic to release her and probaly celestia knew groagar was up there


What if Celestia and Luna had another sibling that controlled the stars. And maybe Celestia made a deal with that sibling and that Luna would be released when the time comes.


I think its Celestia becaues if Celestia and Luna can both ries the sun and moon they can control the stars to


I am sure celestia release nightmare moom to test twilight and I think star swirl contral the star because he's name also matched


Hmmm, StarSwirl? Maybe he's the one behind it all?
MAYBE he's the one controlling the stars?
Sorry I'm in the middle of the video


I might say Twilight continues the stars or straight, I think straight conttrolls the starsthe stars


The tree of the 5 elaments because we have not seen anyone control the stars also they appear when luna raises the moon.


I think Nightmare Moon set herself free tbh I mean the stars come out at night with the moon and nightmare moon is luna and luna has moon power sooo 🤨


But aren’t planets or the sun/moon usually referred stars

☆ 𝒮𝓁𝑒𝑒𝓅𝓎𝐻𝑒𝒶𝒹 ☆


I think star swirl is the key because his name has star in it


Celestia: releases Nightmare
Nightmare: traps her in her place
Celestia: surprised pikachu face

Celestia: *releases Nightmare*
Nightmare: *traps her in her place*
Celestia: *surprised pikachu face*

I think Celestia let herself get captured.


Wait isn’t she supposed to come out in the 1000 year /: I lost brain sails


Who controls the moon sun and stars? The sun is technically a star


crazy theory but i think celestia controls the star bc the sun is a star so it means all the stars are controlled by celestia the only problem is celestias cutie mark is just the sun so how can she control the stars i think its bc she has the power to raised the sun and the moon so it give her a chance to raised the stars too its in between.


What if groagar did her escape? Celestia banished her and she woundnt let her go. Groagar escaped first and then released nightmare moon. It could be like that. The stars, they are the trap to groagar. He found a way to escape and released her.


maybe luna controlled the star ok so she waits a thousand years because she didnt have that much power yet sa i think she waited a thousand years to gain enough power and controlled the stars so that she can escape but i think she can only use it once so ye i dont think its celestia


Princess Celestia released Nightmare Moon to turn her back into Princess Luna.


I think I know how she turned into nightmare Moon

She was in despair as she was sad of her punishment and her soul fell into a demons hoofs!


I want to know this a sun is a star Celestia must have done it cuz technically in a way a sun is a star


But what if Celestia and Luna have a younger sister that controls the stars. Maybe she was not sent from the Alicorn civilisation to restore peace between the three tribes because she was too young. Celestia  and Luna might have forgotten all about her. When Celestia was still the only ruler her younger sister must have herd about this. So when the legend said the stars would free her she used her magic to free her and new that a new ruler would step up and her two sisters would come back to the Alicorn civilisation.


Since the creator of mlp did tweet there are no toilets and they poop on the ground it can be already be proven wrong because I remember at sweet apple acres The Episode called The Perfect Pear Granny Smith Goes into an out house


Maybe its the tree of harmony,  but don't you think Lauren Faust meant princess luna because the sun is a star?


Maybe celestia released night mare moon because she thought that twilight and the mane six would succeed and she was right and I think celestia may new that twilight would be alive the time when night Mare moon would be released


me: - sees video -
me: I WAS RIGHT?!
me: - watches video -
me: oh... nevermind...


Maybe STAR swirl's essence in the tree of harmony did it


(DISCLAIMER): This is quite literally an essay on my theory! (Like 5-6 paragraphs). Be prepared for a long read!

I'm finding quite a few things that contradict your theory from watching the show alone. (Sorry i've been doing this lately).

So to get started, you state that a response from the creator hinting at Celestia may or may not be true. This is a valid thought since it can and has been done before, but what if there is something deeper going on in this situation? But before I go deeper than that, I also wanted to state that you said the Tree Of Harmony set her free? Well, I can see why you think that and it is a pretty good theory, but there are multiple problems and variables that contradict that theory as well. For example, much later in the series when the school of friendship is made and the group of misfit "elements" meets the tree of harmony, it specifically states that "my power grows stronger over time" and that it "now has the ability to do this". Now this made me wonder: If the tree of harmony wasn't that powerful before, how could it possibly be powerful enough to release the banishment of a pony on its own, especially since the elements weren't directly powering the tree since Celestia and Luna took them all those years ago?? It just seems pretty farfetched to me and honestly hard to believe. However, I do think it had some influence. Now to the whole "not moving stars" thing, Celestia may have simply chose not to! From what I heard, the stars DO move on their own (quoted from the hippogryphs voyage) and that can be linked to physics like our world! However, this doesn't mean we can just count Celestia out too! In fact, the stars may be easier for Celestia to move with them actually being as small as depicted in the show like how most cartoonists use those physics! Now going on to my actual theory.

I think Celestia DID bring Nightmare Moon back, but not on purpose. I believe, just like discords banishment, there is a set amount of years that banishment can be upheld before it is interrupted. I believe with Celestia's long line of experience with the Elements, she knew that was true! She would still have reason to grieve over the loss of her sister for a thousand years but even then, when Luna comes back, Celestia is not surprised by the fact that her sister is no longer Nightmare Moon! This means that Celestia definitely had planning behind this and, as you said, it was indeed "safe" or at least a high chance of success! I think the key to releasing Luna does fall on the elements, though. I think it relies on triggers because, when discord escaped, Celestia said: "I believe that, since the elements are now tied to you, the banishment spell I once put on him is no longer in effect." But, wait... If they are connected to the elements right at the start, why is discord escaping just then? That's where my trigger theory comes in. I think that Twilight meeting her friends at that exact moment in time, as depicted and brought on by Celestia, produced a trigger that allowed Lunas escape on the 1000th year. Of course, this could be completely wrong and the stars were just moving slowly over time but that would contradict what the creator said and discords release from his banishment!

So from a set perspective on the three key moments that I believe caused a chained reaction letting luna escape, you have to look further into the power of the elements themselves. So, Celestia's Banishment has a time limit, the banishment is released upon triggering, but the 3rd key is the elements of harmony themselves. Being forged from the Tree Of Harmony, almost like a super battery, saved Equestria on its own a thousand times and was "programmed" by the Pillars to represent certain elements! This further proves my trigger theory that them coming together created a link between them and the Elements Of Harmony and thus creating a chain reaction. This was also more related to Celestia's and Luna's conflict themselves as they did not represent the Elements Of Harmony on their own over time! This prompted the Tree Of Harmony to seek a new magic source for the elements which, when it did, caused an extreme burst of power (shown at the end of the 2nd show season 1 when they embraced their elements), but that doesn't mean their link started there! Many chain reactions are caused accidentally throughout the series such as Rainbow Dashes rainboom causes them to find their special talents and link them in the long term! But the elements didn't link to them until they found each other! I think it was similar to Luna's release but the beginning starting with Luna's banishment. Just like Discord release was a shred of chaos after they linked together.

In conclusion, I think there are 3 very key aspects in forcibly releasing a pony from banishment: 1) A background behind the banishment. 2) An immense amount of power (specifically from the elements.) 3) The Mane 6's friendship. However, we do come to an impasse at some point. This is because when Twilight travels back in time, Nightmare moon was able to come back without their friendship! This doesn't mean that she came back on the 1000th year without a trigger, though. I think Nightmare Moons escape failed at first since when they travel back in time, Nightmare Moon says: " My sister has been imprisoned in the moon for years!" Now, why do you guys think that came to pass? Well, nightmare moon didn't transform back so no friendship magic was involved most likely. In the best-case scenario, like what Twilight did to bring the Pillars back to Equestria and to banish the Pony Of Shadows, powerful magic was used to bring her back! This most likely means Celestia was involved. After Twilight failed to meet her friends, Celestia was left to deal with things on her own which probably took longer than what came to pass back when Nightmare moon came back! This is because when they travel back in time, Nightmare Moon lives in the Castle Of The Two Sisters instead of in Canterlot with a whole new Castle! This most likely represents a more recent defeat of Celestia, especially since none of the other mane 6 are under her command which I believe she would recognize at the other elements which I believe she would still discover on her own!

So Nightmare Moon does eventually escape but in terms of my theory, it was most likely Celestia (with the help of powerful magic) or a trigger that went off that was set like an alarm clock for 1000 years! This would explain so much about Celestia's behavior on that day telling Twilight, "You simply must stop reading those dusty old books!" Even though it is what Twilight has always taken pride in and expected Celestia to do the same! So what was different for that day? Even Twilight didn't know! I think Celestia did, though, having that contribute to her decision to send Twilight away. I rest my case. (Of course I can always be wrong but we'll leave that up to the avid readers. :))

twilight never met celestia because she didn’t pass the test

Wow, you must have a lot of dedication to this series, I admire that. Also after reading through all of it I understand your points and agree with you.

Dear G O D this is so long-and you end like every other sentence with an exclamation mark i stg


I wonder if it was starlight cause she had powerful magic and she was kinda evil but then again why would starlight wanna free nightmare moon


luna planed her own escape! she controls the moon and stars! :( !


Think I know if she controls the Sun and the sun's a star doesn't that mean she can control both and celestia's just keeping a secret from Twilight and everybody else do what theory this is actually huge


Dear sawtooth, I am a good friend of Luna, she often visits my galaxy home and is a friend to the wolves who live there. I have recently heard about her bansishment and her reform, and I can explain it. When the spell wears of, it sends a sort of signal if you will, to the stars around it telling them to release her, why not the spell itself? It’s too weak. Remember it just worn off so it’s natural that it would sent a sort of s.o.s to the stars. It couldn’t use celestia because she isn’t the one wielding the Elements so in the gap between twilight making friends and her defeat the stars do their bit. I hope that explains it,

Galactia blast.
Ps: don’t click read more!

Oh, you clicked it? What did I tell you? Like if your a galaxy wolf too 😉


Sun=Star <br>Yes, this is my logic. A big star is a sun.

Sun=Star
Yes, this is my logic. A big star is a sun.


;) nope! the answer IS CELESTIA. Because when she was gone, she raised the moon AND sun. while, she raised the stars because the sun is a star. and also when the moon comes up, we see stars. so It was her who set her sister free. u can look up on google if u want ;)


Umm… twilight raised and moved the stars in season 9 with Celestia and Lunas power…


I feel like a changeling was transforming into Luna because this changeling has known Luna since the day it was born because for a long time ago this changeling has heard a lot of the stories of princess Luna turns into nightmare moon so that’s what I think


Yeah I heard that Lauren confirmed that celestia let her sister out on purpose.....CELESTIA IS THE REAL VILLAIN!


Remember the luna  said she controlled moon and stars


starlight is part of twilight's family so they all have star cutie marks so let me tell you the story about starlight starlight is twilight's sister she did something unforgivable so her pearants put a memory spell on twilight so she could forget starlight.


In my little pony magic princess games, descripiton of characters princess celestia is "princess celestia is the ruler of equestria. Responsible for raising the sun, moon and the stars"😌


I think it can be Luna's dad as Luna is the princess of moon her dad must be star but before Luna birth her dad must be control of moon and star's


I think I have the reason to do this you know the sun is a star so she can probably control the stars


If you were to look through the episode do you would see Princess Luna spare controls the moon correct so yeah go she is so controlling


You see it wasnt celestia or the tree it was the oldest of the three sisters queen ingrid the snow queen look her up on the internet


I think I know who controls the stars ,star swirl.it’s in his name


Where did queen novo actually get the pearl  that helped her kingdom change species so they could hide from the storm king I’m so confused and I hope you can help me understand


I don’t know what I’m coming for I want to be in the series you can call me a nightlight I love your videos❤


technically the sun is a star that's just closer.


It must be rarity she was the first one to know that celestial was gone she must have been mad at her for not letting her stay at canterlot high but let her friend twillinght stay Rarity must have knew that ' nightmare moon appears celestia disappears ' this makes rarity the culprit but from who did she learn to control the stars ?…? ……. Star swirl Maybe because when we saw the flash back. We had enough info to blame starswirl  to teach rarity to control the stars what do you think ? Do u agree with me


Short do I think celestia and Luna had a long lost father control the stars


"That would make celestia a lair"

Boi, she is a lair.


In Celestias hair there are some stars <br> I could be wrong but i just got this feeling🤫🤔

In Celestias hair there are some stars
 I could be wrong but i just got this feeling🤫🤔


The Sun is also a star, so mabye it WAS Celestia! (Or i think thats how u spell it).


I think that maybe celestial could see the future or the tree of hormany but i think it's celestial because she does everything comly as if see knows what will happen


Well celestia controls the sun and stars yes and moon but did we ever see lunas potential we only saw he raise the moon but remember when Luna and celestia changed marks now celestia reacted like she has never raised the moon or did any of lunas tasks well who ever said she was the one raising the moon all those years and it was Luna well yes she was vanished to the moon but when chrysalis was turned to stone her throne pieces worked fine on the castle so her magic could still work so what if nightmare got the practice and that’s why Luna was so existed after being reformed


Celestia:Sun
Luna:Moon
Cadance:Crystals
Twilight: Friendship
Flurryheart: Stars???

SockTime Gacha flurryheart was born after nightmare moons escape. I think flurryheart would be family.

I feel flurryheart is a representation of..

Combined
Love and magic

Not a necromancer nothing close

Nah. Flurry Heart is the Princess of Merchandise.<br>Also, Cadance is the Princess of Love, not Crystals.

Nah. Flurry Heart is the Princess of Merchandise.
Also, Cadance is the Princess of Love, not Crystals.


The girl name is Luna when she was staying there for 100 years in the moon


Maybe nightmare moon made herself escape because Luna controls the moon


"Who controls the stars?" isn't the sun a star? ;)


maybe luna cause it might of took her a thousand years to move the stars to freedome cause if luna controls the moon and celestia controles the sun that must mean that luna was moving the stars to freedome.


It make sense for Celestia to free luna bc not only she wants her sister back and she knew the elements of harmony is fitting for the mane 6 maybe celestia wanted to test the mane 6 friendship


Hi I have a suggestion about who could have controlled those stars maybe it was some magical creature or it’s more about the spell so here’s how I think it might’ve went with the spell maybe a spell word last for 100 years because we know that discord was trapped there for 100 years I think and a bunch of other villains so I think it’s at the time about whoever was stuck in prison for only a certain amount of time before they can be released in maybe their own saying that what they do will represent and three of them that could be worth when the spell was off those star is moved to show nightmare moon was returning so yeah that’s my theory and yeah bye


The sun is had Star Power so it Could be Celestia


Every Brony Notion videos is beyond science


If Celestia saw the signs of night mear moon then Celestia had to of told twilight


Apparently I know Science ...
So...

The Sun is a Star itself and Celestia maybe can control the Stars :)

BECAUSE THE SUN IS A STAR ASK GOOGLE


Stars?.. when twilight became princess a huge firework of something came up but resembled a star to me


Can you make a vid on were rain comes from? Like we see the Pegasi “create” rain by jumping on a storm cloud but how does the rain get there in the first place. We are told that the everfree forest is the only place with natural weather. We have seen the weather factory make clouds and rainbows ( but I can’t remember if they make rain) and without rain shouldn’t there be a drought. In one of starlights time lines we see a deserted and dry equestria meaning without pony’s somehow water goes away wich begs the question if they make water falls and stuff and if Pegasi make the weather how are they supposed to make rain/water? Without a horn how do they make it ? Is there a special kind of Pegasi? And if that were true how come they didn’t fix the hypogrif problem sooner? They would have to keep in touch to keep the ocean well the ocean lol. Idek what I’m talking about at this point lol.


If the mane five failed and Luna took over. Celestia: 😖 I’m joining the dark side.


I think Celestia just wanted to reform her sister


Well the princess of stars scared be their mom their dad could even be a sister we don’t know about


What if Celestia can't control the stars maybe Luna set herself free but the true question is where did Celestia gone missing like it's only been a few seconds since Nightmare Moon came so where did she run off to? This was always in my brain for quite awhile so can you find out this?


Where was Princess Celestia after when Nightmare Moon returned?


4:45 "How much of a roll did celestia play"
Oh, you know, it was a-BUN-dant.

4:45 "How much of a *roll* did celestia play"
Oh, you know, it was a-BUN-dant.


If you see very carefully Twilight Sparkle has a star cutie mark I was thinking I think it was Twilight Sparkle release Nightmare Moon but if toilet Sparkle did it just because of her cutie mark what I think I think it's a little bit true I've been looking at the Cutie Mark 4 hours and I've been observing all of the power it's just because of the cutest part is color pinkish purplish and it kind of makes sense and I'll look it emerges actually like a star the other one is like just like Rainbow – just a cloud with a rainbow and Rarity is versus a gemstones and Pinkie Pie are balloons and all the pony cutie mark that I know that has a star is Twilight Sparkle don't think it was Twilight Sparkle toys for girl riding nude going to come out he might be someone someone controls the star someone has been trapped in star no way is going to be some Celestia because she's nice and everything I think 100% think it might be grow guard or it might be the most amazing sorcerer Star Swirl you know it might be very very obvious because grow guard is Liv and trapped with the Stars like it's really obvious but the one thing about Star Swirl is the first name is actually a star and then it goes swirl it didn't make any sense. But I have a 100% it's actually starts world or grow guard


I think is twilight who did it. She controls the stars!!


Think about this it said that they control the sun MOON and stars twilight herself


but if celestia had visions about what will happen in the future then he should knew the mane 6 would deafeat cozy t rek and chrysalis


Last time I was this early, men still had fins.

Does that mean you existed when men still had fins?


I think that Princess Celestia released Nightmare Moon to test Twilight Sparkle


Well technically. Princesses Celestia controls ONLY the sun and moon in the beggening THEN Princesses Luna controlled the moon. But who controlled the stars? STARSWIRLS! It has it in his name so he probably controls it?


Of course celestia can raise the moon, remeber that part that nightmare moon vanished and locked up in the moon?, That was that time celestia needs to do lunas duty.


Hi am this is just my theory I'm kind of answering your questions I have 3 options for you number one twilight sparkle like she kind of has a like a star on her being and star does not mean friendship so maybe it means she can secretly control the stars without knowing too a could be Luna but Luna couldn't free herself because she controls the night and the final third one could be so last year guys she does control the sun and the sun is technically a star a big ball of fire technically she could control the dog out even knowing it also she took in Luna's power by raising the sun and moon when Luna was entrapped in the moon so technically she would have more power to oh yeah whatI said, Luna on the thing where they said she could control the sun, I don't think I said, do the right, but anyways, yes, that's my 3 answers for you


Maybe I did, maybe I didn’t!<br>I guess you’ll never know :)

Maybe I did, maybe I didn’t!
I guess you’ll never know :)


Doesn't celestia have a nephew? Doesn't his cutie mark resemble a star? Isn't he also a unicorn? Maybe the parent that connects him to celestia is in control of the stars. If celestia and luna were once unicorns maybe they had more siblings.


I mean either it was a 1000 year spell or celestia just wanted her sister back but knew she couldn’t reforme her so litterly sent 6 random ponies to save the day- or celestia didn’t do anything and star swirl did or as no 1 it was a 1000 year spell ;-;


Did you know there is a Queen named Queen Pastelle


I think starlight she WAS evil before the main 6 took her too the light


Starswirle can control the stars because his name has the word STAR in it. (Sawtooth YOU are my idle. Your senserly Zuzanna krasny.


I think always luna controls the stars before she was trapped in the moom I think that who controls the moon also controls the stars so I think that celestia controls the stars


Oh my god! You know how there was 4 stars to nightmare moons escape....There was also 4 stars on twilights cutely mark! Forget the pink star  I just mean the 4 stars around the pink star

Edit: wait nvm XD

☆ 𝒮𝓁𝑒𝑒𝓅𝓎𝐻𝑒𝒶𝒹 ☆


FIRST!!!!!!! Hi
And also 1:39 I mean she always did that, all the returns of vilans until the end of season 3 were orchestrated by her so twilight would be ready to become a princess, I mean in season 3 premiere celestia even says that this was her test, and in the ending of the episode she says to Luna that twilight has now only one more test which is the season 3 finale, she send the book on purpose so all of it could happened, thats why she loosed her fight with crystalis and never helps the mane six.


Dude the sun is technically a star so so last year did set a nightmare moon three technically


It think Celestia controls the stars and the moon because stars are sun's billions of miles away but that would mean Celestia is very powerful that she can control the stars and sun and it spreads miles away so that means that she has very big power so it makes it a little different


star swirl might have released nightmare moon


Maybe Twilight sparkle ones the stars because look closely at her ciute Mark it is a big star and has got smaller ones around the biggest star it makes sense do you think


I may be late, but did Luna’s father bail out Nightmare Moon?  Maybe it her dad did something like that in the past, and wanted to bail Luna.  I also think that since Luna’s dad has magic, he added the plan for her to escape in the book.  For Daybreaker, maybe it was her mom who enabled her. Maybe in the dream, her Mom showed her if she was ever going to become jealous.


Luna got herself out of the Moon I mean think the moon and the stars are basically the same thing connected to the same thing


what if shining armor released nightmare moon to get twilight for friends? Besides u said he might be an alicorn, and he has multiple stars on his cutie mark like twilight


Celestia - Sun! Luna - Moon! Star Swirl - Stas!


Celestial,Luna And cadence but twilight sparkles name has to do with her cutie mark But Celestial, Luna and cadence have nothing to do with their cutie mark. Define the word twilight it possibly could be the stars and twilight sparkle controlled the stars and that was a hidden talent and she wanted to bring Luna back to remake a friendship


Just a theory: Just because Nightmare moon is in the Moon doesn’t stop ponies from having nightmares! We all know how powerful starlight glimmer is so it wouldn’t be a surprise if Nightmare moon found a way into a powerful ponies dream. She could have manipulated Starlight so she could begin learning how to control stars! Her cutie mark never told us anything about her how about it controls the stars? (Or at least some) I think starlight glimmer did it and the tree of harmony did have a part to play. I think the tree sensed Starlight and told Celestia about it. Then Celestia made sure it happened and put it in books for ponies to read.

Just mah little theory

@4 player split screen For cod2024 I am a female brony


Half of my brain thinks it's twilight and half of my brain thinks it's star swirl idk why.<br>Wait I think it actually luna because when mlp tells us the story of why luna turned into nightmare moon it said: "Celestia was greatly appreciated by the ponys in equestria for bringing the sun to rise every day but luna was not greatly appereciated by the ponys of equestria for raising the moon and the STARS"  See ? The text said luna can raise the moon and the stars!

Half of my brain thinks it's twilight and half of my brain thinks it's star swirl idk why.
Wait I think it actually luna because when mlp tells us the story of why luna turned into nightmare moon it said: "Celestia was greatly appreciated by the ponys in equestria for bringing the sun to rise every day but luna was not greatly appereciated by the ponys of equestria for raising the moon and the STARS"  See ? The text said luna can raise the moon and the stars!


all the alicorns cutemark relate to what thay control well twilight  cute mark look like magic or starts . her cute mark relate back to the tree if you look at the tree the big star is in the midel and the other stars are on the outsied like her cutemark .


My theory is twilight's mother, think again she can't have this cutie mark without meaning. Also the same with the father


I’m sure she did because she’s her sister and im sure she missed Luna so she released her from the moon because she banned her to the moon. Why she can’t release her from the moon?


Well the stars went in pattern I bet that you did not notice because you were only focused on who bailed her out so here are my theories. well first my theory was that twilight sparkle could bailed her out because like any unicorn she would want to see night mare moon in person but that got debunked. So then I searched one sawtooth wave videos that about did celestia bailed night mare moon and what lauren faust said in twitter was amazing ( sorry if I spelled it wrong) said this "Watch the episode again ------ the stars align in perfect pattern and who controls the sun moon and stars" sawtooth replied that celestia bailed her out but that is debunked. Then she said "who controls the stars" And I think I know who has the power to control the equastria and it is star swirl abearded now here is my theory. in season 4 apple jack said this about the pony of shadow "Some his magic escaped" now does that mean also some of star swirls magic escaped and tried stopping the pony of shadows magic to escape then by accident it could have bailed night mare moon so then tree took action of it to bring the main six to reform her. oh and stars aligned in a way that looked like star swirls cutie mark.


I think the stars nightmare moons army so maybe the stars released their leader nightmare moon now I think that makes sense


Maybe we do have a sister of the stars because in ticket master rarity mentioned celesta’s royal niece so either Luna had a child or a different sister maybe one of the stars did which could mean cadence did not be the first allicorn to give birth<br>But I really don’t think so

Maybe we do have a sister of the stars because in ticket master rarity mentioned celesta’s royal niece so either Luna had a child or a different sister maybe one of the stars did which could mean cadence did not be the first allicorn to give birth
But I really don’t think so


I think I know who controls the stars celestia has a cutie mark of the sun Luna has moon and twilight has a star maby without knowing she realised nightmare moon I think


Soooooo early yeah

I love these theory videos

😍😂❤😊😘🌺😅😁👍😙😚


the sun is a star. her name celestia references celestial bodies.


can you put in the link where I can find and watch season 9 please?


Celestia control the stars because the sun is a star


Yeah, the sun is a star so could it be Celestia who set Nightmare Moon free?? :\

Celestia sus!!


Ok so isn't doing a council sure that's the end and I dreamland so that means I left you can control the song and something else and the song is a medium-sized star so that means she could control the stars but just like Lauren valves and controls the song the one the stars went I left in Spanish that she's controlling the sun the moon and stars because of stars is a son actually more like a fun so so you're her back because not because number one 120 want to make sense so it's nice and warm and lots and let down all the main six me to gather friendship number 2 of course you'll miss her sister because it's her sister childhood so does she have to release her because you shouldn't like seem like they're more than 1000 Years died so because I will of course be more than unicorns


It's kinda impossible for this to be it but what about star swirl?


the tree used twilight it explains her cutie mark and<br>why she was worried about it

the tree used twilight it explains her cutie mark and
why she was worried about it


Tbh, this is didn't know when I watched it but my theory is that it was twilights test for friendship.


Well twilight does have a star cutie mark or is it a tree of harmony I have no idea


Wait, the preson who controls the stars might be Celestia and Luna's mom Queen Galaxy!


I think it was sunset she does not do the sun or moon and she can move the stars if she wants I think it was like a revenge thing


I think twilight did it but she didn’t know that she did it


After I watched this video I am thinking it makes much more sense


Maybe celestia knew that twilight is so special cause twilight cutie mark and twilight harmony jem thingy looks the same and celestia know that its a sign to make nightmare moon back what she was lunar<br>Or maybe its twilight look at her cutie mark🤣

Maybe celestia knew that twilight is so special cause twilight cutie mark and twilight harmony jem thingy looks the same and celestia know that its a sign to make nightmare moon back what she was lunar
Or maybe its twilight look at her cutie mark🤣


Celestial: dumbledor
Luna: Pr Lupin
Twilight sparkle: Harry Potter


HOW DID I ONLY JUST GET THIS NOTIFICATION THIS WAS LIKE AGES AGO WHAT


I think luna set her self free i mean luna controlls the moon  and the Stars are Seen only at night


What if there's a Prince Blueblood The Princesses nephew wouldn't that mean there's a third sister or a brother?


I think it was the stars cuz when I watched it again and saw nightmare moon in the knight statue when twilight was walking by it


this is the 8th time i seen this vid and i understand what happened so if the 2 alicorns which is the Sun and moon then what if there really is a princess of stars? well MLP never spoke of it and we fans never seen it . that “Pony” can be like the young 6 different species and that “Pony” raises the stars befor the moon get raced and after the sun is here? i really hope u can reply about what do you think of this theory?


I’m not first, I’m not last, and this comment is overused anyways

SudoWoofie Animations! 🍉🍑🥭🍇🍓🍆🍐🍎🍊🍓🍋🍈🍏🍌🍒🥝🍑🍅🥭🍆🍍🥑🥥🥦

Yes, indeed it is.

I also wonder why everyone wants to be first... Like as if they would've won an award or something if they were the first to comment. I really don't get it.


I think starlight is the who freed nightmare moon (luna)


wanna know what starts are?

Suns

celestia just wanted to meme on us

wanna know what starts are?

*Suns*

celestia just wanted to meme on us


I think it is Pony of Shadows

Am i silly?


Isn't a whole lot of ponies or a lot of people have been strange about that question i know what question it is all the empires had been controlling the sun and the moon the moon had been controlling the stars are being in the 1 billion even the stars


I think that Twilight moves the stars, because of her cutie mark


Doesn’t twilight control the stars it’s on her cutie mark?


Oh me gerd, Am I actually first!?! No views, no likes/dislikes (besides mine), and no comments. I MIGHT ACTUALLY BE FIRST!!!

Jessica The Iceberg Just let meh have this :P

꧁ Moonlight Skies ꧂ no, you aren’t first.


maybe it was celestia or luna's mother or father?


celestia controls the sun but the sun is a massive star so


Celestia controls the moon and the stars


The sun is a star and the sun is Celestia controlling the sun and moon so possibly the stars 🌟 ✨ 🎶 😎 😉 😄 🌟 ✨ 🎶 😎 😉

_•𝓜𝓪𝓭𝓭𝓲𝓮•_          𝐏𝐬: 𝐢𝐦 𝐬𝐭𝐮𝐩𝐢𝐝


What is Celestia took the Stars to The elements of Harmony I mean and before into all those Stars until May stars and returned her sister back to normal just so they can learn about and listen just to get you know


Celestia is the sun the sun is a star ,the moon has stars around it and if you put that together it might make the stars ,twilight has a cutie mark of a star magic and those star where magic it’ll make perfect sense Twilight sparkle my ruler the stars maybe the tree?


i think star swirl is behind it as its his name and he also has experience with portals . Now i know he never believed  in friendship but may be celestia and star swirl did it all together after all they knew each other since a thousand years. if u think this theory might be true do like


I would still think Cel did it. She worded it misleadingly because if ponies knew she <b>LITTERALY LET A DANGEROUS PONY OUT</b> it wouldn't be good.

I would still think Cel did it. She worded it misleadingly because if ponies knew she *LITTERALY LET A DANGEROUS PONY OUT* it wouldn't be good.


If you don't want so many problems from a princess? How about a Mary Sue?


The person who controls sister Princess Twilight sparkle's is on her cutie mark she has stars and then the sparkles look worksman smaller stores


0:55 Wait, Hogwarts didn't have toilets back then? And... relieving urself wherever they stood...

the fuq?


Sawtooth waves : who the heck controls the stars<br>Me: ?

Sawtooth waves : who the heck controls the stars
Me: ?


Mine is weird but I think the tree of harmony gave Celestia a vision of her return in her words "I saw the sign's"so she hade twilight come and new she was the one and the tree of harmony new what to do bc it's wise.

I ment the tree of harmony and Celestia when I said she new sorry.


How about the matrix how they have the powers everything has been change spin the wheel to the two of the sisters have ruling crystal empire for a very long time that means the crystal empire has been in equestrian impression that means from ruling the world of equestria new abilities to change to another power


Since wait I am asking about a different video so since Twilight actually I realized that she had killed the tree before she got her castle 🏰 she said that the tree and the elements of harmony will never bee broken so she lied can you make a video about it


my theory but idk the person controlling the stars is the maker of the book how? Well how would the book know the stars would aim her escape if it never happened in the past so someone could've made an escape plan and before luna was imprisoned luna gave someone 500+ years to live so one the person can break her free.


maybe there is a secret star alicorn that Celestia and luna have no idea about or a person that controls the treee


I think nightmare moon Really hates her sister because she really does


I heard that luna also controls the stars


I have a question. If Luna is the only one who can raise the moon, and Celestia the sun. This bring the question how did Celestia raise the moon? We have seen that twilight needed a magic artefact, cause her magic wasn't strong enough. This bring be also the question, how is Twilight raising both sun and moon now she rules Equestria? Here is my theory, Celestia raise the sun in front of the moon, cause the moon was in the same place Luna left it when she became Nightmare moon. This means that Celestia never rules the night, in facto Lunas job was there, the moon never left the spotlight.


Who Controls the Sun, Moon AND Stars

The Sun IS a Star itself

The True Culprit behind Nightmare Moon's escape is……None other then ………Princess Celestia !!

When she said

"I saw the signs of Nightmare Moon's return."

Perhaps she saw herself letting her go cause she ALSO for saw Twilight and her friends reform Luna.

Which means when she Scolded Discord for his "Misjudgement"

SHE didn't for see those Villians return at that point in time they where supposed to be free later then they where in the show

Discord prematurely freed those Villains


STAR SWIRL! HE MESSAGED THE TREE WITH HIS MAGIC AND CONTROLED THE STARS! sorry caps


If I'm right the stars are burning balls of gass far away and if I'm correct the sun is also one


Maybe nightmaremoon do the stars and the moon


Did you see that element that look like a star maybe that is what controls the stars stars


What if starswirl the bearded controlled the stars


so I think twilight controls the stars because it go's with Luna moon celesta sun twilight sparkle stars see what i mean? but that wouldn't make since of she wasen't a alicorn back in season one plus she's not the type to do that, so my only guess is star swirl because he probably did it by accident but what if nightmare moon let herself out, maybe she was waiting this long just for the perfect time?


Who raises the stars?  Princes celesta does.


maybe someone with star in their name did it

like STARlight


This is rough to say but what if a villan in the stars controled the stars yep you hear ALIENS!!!!


What if celestia bailed out nightmare moon to get the Mane Six connected to the elements to get them ready for what was to come....


I think celestia put a timer and when the timer end 🔚 nightmare moon realised


or when she put Luna into the Moon it might of meant temporally like only 1,000 years
because it is her sister and you probably wouldn't send you sister to the moon temporally even if they're mean
I mean I have sisters and I wouldn't banish them to the moon or like jail in Earth since that makes more sencse then the moon


I think the TREE and celestia, Because celastia USED to control the tree, maybe she wanted one last time using the tree's magic? That is my theory! PS Love ur vids!


celestia's mother princess galexia controls the stars


My theory is twillight who freed nightmare moon because twillight has stars in her cutie mark so she controls the stars because shes"twillight sparkle''


maybe celestia freed her because she felt like she really mised her


Luna because she’s the queen of the moon I mean it Hass to be her don’t you think

𝓘𝓽'𝓼 𝓡𝓲𝓵𝓮𝔂!!!


I think its star swirls since um.. idk but it  kinda make sense for stars dont you think?


is logic to celestia control stars. THE SUN IS A STAR


I think I know it may seem dum, but~~ <br>There were only 2 known pricesses celestia and Luna Witch are kinda like queens what im saying is the 2 princesses or maybe even queens raise the sun n moon tho in the mlp movie we meet queen novo, the pricesses all have duties what about queen novo, and queen novo has something the other hippogriffs don't a wobbly glowstick thing on her head like a horn, could that be a source of power? Maybe novo realised her ?

I think I know it may seem dum, but~~
There were only 2 known pricesses celestia and Luna Witch are kinda like queens what im saying is the 2 princesses or maybe even queens raise the sun n moon tho in the mlp movie we meet queen novo, the pricesses all have duties what about queen novo, and queen novo has something the other hippogriffs don't a wobbly glowstick thing on her head like a horn, could that be a source of power? Maybe novo realised her ?


Breaking news

Notion changed his intro because we used to include friendssszzzzzzz

😂😂


Starlight Glimmer corntrols the stars! I think...


Idk(meaning I don’t know in short form)<br>Idk why the sun god banished her sister to the moon

Idk(meaning I don’t know in short form)
Idk why the sun god banished her sister to the moon


The sun is a star so it is still possible


i FEEL LIKE IT WAS TWILIGHT- since she had sparks could twilight release nightmare?? didnt notice it ??


The sun is a star so celestia controls it


Yes,does that mean celestia relased luna?


no luna did it it just took soooooo long because her magic is week


What if.. Celestia did that to get twilight to make friends and make them use tbe elements


Moon means night sun means day is control by Celestia night is control by Luna or nightmare moon stars can be seen only in the night means only Luna can do that just trashed your theory filled with holes


You saw that a explosion happened when luna came back when the moon explosion happened she came back


make a video if you ever find out if discord moved the stars leading to the escape of nightmare moon/princess luna


Star princess might be gusty the great or starlight glimmer  bcoz they both have stars in their cutie marks


It’s still Groger to me that theory awesome


Nightmare Moon was free by stars world the beer deck


i think twillght would control the star caues as her name says twillight sparkle star appear after twillight in the human world and sparkle means sparkly star so that s my theory


the tree of Harmony spirit control the star


I know we’re not talking about Bendy but maybe Sammy has released the ink demon because you know the ink demon is Sammy‘s boss


wait isnt the sun is a star-
and celestia controls suns so does that means that celestia is controlling the stars
(moon is a rock from earth qwq)well thats what i heard ;-;


How about star hunter he also has a constellation cutie mark which is very similar.


just a theory but twilight sparkle could have done it I mean think about it<br>with her expeirence from the school she could have

just a theory but twilight sparkle could have done it I mean think about it
with her expeirence from the school she could have


Sawtooth:the stars were animated but by who<br>Me:the animators

Sawtooth:the stars were animated but by who
Me:the animators


mabye it was just a consiadince, 1000 years later mabye the elements can let people out of the moon the same way other animals and dicord always get off stone?


Why is Starswirls name Starswirl? Maybe he controls the stars.


I got one if you look closely at twilight (at the last summer sun celebration) look Celestia and Luna's horn they are not using magic and twilight is.Maybe she got a bit.Cary a way because.I mean look at her at the first episode 😂 and her cutie mark is stars and Celestia's is a sun Luna's is a moon think about it-_-.


Wait a sun is a star so it might be celestia


I see the star and moving we all know but...if someone control it is mean is the harmony....?


I think discord moved the stars cuz he is the god of chaos


I think it's twilight because she had a
Star on her city mark#its a family member of luna and selestia
And twilight


Stars can be planets to whoever controls planets is the one who made the Stars do that if they were planets maybe it's coming out in another season who cares right now we have full seasons so all we can do is wait


the stars go   to the moon  because  celestia  love her sister


I think ca;estia had a vision befor nightmair moon and her sister would refuse to bring down the moon and in 1000 years  there would be 6 ponys that defets nightmair moon so when luna refused to bring down the mooon celestia cast a spell that lasted 1000 years


I don’t know why but I think that star swirl controls the stars I mean it’s in this name


I think twilight controls the stars or night mare moon


Do you actually realize that on the Summer sun celebration at Twilight Sparkle set and then look at the Moon you see those four stars are starting to moving and trying to do something that you said from the other video can you make another video the One like this like this


what if lonor tried to free her self she mit control the stars sins she controls the moon


Princess twilight have 4 star in her cutie mark so maybe princess twilight controls the star


I think luna she is nightmare moon at a long time right


But in all times Luna is the moon  The stars


I think Twilight did it because she has a cutie monster just and maybe she’s a princess that race to stars


I think star did it because he has i horn and sometimes that the satrs will move


Star for the bearded free Nightmare Moon


Twilight control the Stars I mean just look at her cutie mark and she's an alicorn let me explain you're talking about who controls the Stars well one Chas Seven Stars on her cutie mark 2 she's an alicorn 3 she likes reading books 4 why did she control the stars because you wanted to see nightmare moon or something


celestia was like: make sister normal random frens


IT WAS CELESTIA AND GROGAR WHO DID IT (maybe it was a bet )


Celestia did not release night mare moon so who is?


But Cilestia is princess of sun so she controls the stars


I think a misterius alicorn control the stars


What if flurry hart controls the stars 👑


there was a plan that discord was one of a million someting dracoses  dont know why it was removed it woud have been cool does discord have any relatives beacause remember of celestia and luna tey we were told that they were born alicorn but well changed bad writing.


I think twilight moved the stars cuz her mark are stars.


Hi heard that Luna rises the moon AND STARS but when Luna became nightmare moon and Celestia took over Luna duty’s so Celestia was controlling SUN MOON AND STAR


I think celestia controls the sun
Sun is a Star remember? :)

Wait I just saw the original comment, no hate comment pls :')


yeah hi celestia does not control the stars mlp only said that she had taken over raising the moon not the stars


i think it's star swirl because the word star


Watch all the videos again Calestia’s job is raising the sun and Luna’s job is to raise the moon there cutie marks also mach there jobs and Twilight’s job is to control  the stars her cutie mark also has stars


Luna probably moo the Stars cos she is the princess of the night afterall


Wut about nightmare moon herself she controls the night soo she finally figured out to control the stars maybe?


first thing why whould the spirit of harmony free nightmare moon and then lets come onto your qustion or lauren fausts who controlls the stars, I really think that princess twilight does like seriosly even look at her cutie mark...


I think daybreaker set nichtmare moon free


Princess Luna controls the Stars or Nightmare Moon


maybe one of the ponies with a star cutie mark(star cutie mark= star related destiny?)


maybe... SHE DID IT TO ON PURPOSE TO MAKE TWILIGHT A PRINCESS?! TO GET HER SISTER BACK?! who knows...


I think it was the person that stole grogars bell


But she said she saw The return of night mare moon its pointless


Meh :p
I’ll tell mah theory
If u look back in that episode, Twi sent a scroll to Celestia saying that nightmare moon is gonna come back
And u know what happened next right? Celestia told Twi to go to ponyville,
And turns out that Twi defeated Nightmare Moon with her friends, what a coincidence…….Like Celestia knew it was going to happen obviously!
When Twilight turned into an alicorn by Celestia….She revealed that she could technically see the future
Some of u might see it as “No she watched over Twilight” well ofc she did, do u think she’s a stalker?
Celestia knew she needed to send Twi away, and one of the reasons she was getting overwhelmed is cuz the day she’d send her away is the day Nightmare moon is gonna come back. It’s not only bc she doesn’t wanna send her student away, celestia is the one who literally BANISHED Luna to the moon, She’s obviously gonna know when she comes back. And when she did banish Luna, she was in control of the
Elements Of Harmony
Am meh right? well…The elements could’ve been a signal for celestia to send her away. Or maybe that’s when the Elements lost control of her..So she could’ve sent twilight away for her friends to take over the elements. So in this conclusion…?
Celestia did not release Luna. But she knew she would get released, and controlled twilight to meet friends and defeat her. Cuz…….

She wasn’t in control of the elements anymore.. :p


It think Celestia controls the stars and the moon because stars are sun's billions of miles away but that would mean Celestia is very powerful that she can control the stars and sun and it spreads miles away so that means that she has very big power so it makes it a little different in your therioy


Φωτεινή Γαϊτανίδου


I think DISCORD or star swirl control the stars.


It coudent been celestia or star swirl or anothet creture but it could of been GUSTY THE GREAT!! She sended grogar to the stara so it could of been her :o


I Dont Think Its Celestia Look Who Has Stars In There Cutie Mark


ᴀᴍʜᴇʀsᴛɪᴀ ɢᴇᴍ ᴊ. ᴀʀʙᴏʟᴏɴɪᴏ


True can you do a video about the third stained glass cause it shows the sum the moon and inbetween is there another princess that we don't know about?


I likd how he produces to mention J.K. Rowling lol


Star light control the stars because she came pony will because she know about the luna . She help that smoke like of you about when 6 main chracter have same dream them you can see that somje like of princess seletia killed the nightmare moon when luna is normal so what she kept on moon she kept that smoke like of thing .


its twillit she has the cutimac of the stars


I think ⭐ beredo here created Luna escape because he made the tree of harmony and the tree 🌲 of harmony made Luna escape from the moon 🌙  🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩


well if YOU say that............. IS CELESTIA A VERSION OF THE CUTIE MAP WHICH KNOWS LITERALLY EVERYTHING? (Like ponies names, things, and a FUTURE ALICORN????)


I can say star swirl did that he first name is Star so because you know he has stars on his clothes and his cutie mark is also a star or luna could have done that


I have a theory, Luna is the princess of the night but not the moon, nightmare moon to! Nightmare moon has the control over night so in the moon, NIGHTMARE MOON HERSELF MOVED THE STARS AND ESCAPED! I find this likely but... why did she wait so long to do it...?


What if it was Princess cadence we didn't see her maybe she because she controlled the crystal empire stars are like crystals right maybe she moves the stars to to the moon to not free nightmare moon  but to prove that the legend isn't true


don't you get it you said it with your mouth she controls  the sun and moon the moon makes the stars and she might moved the stars


Twilight control the Stars I mean just look at her


well the sun is technically a star so...


when you realise at 1:02 there is an alicorn


celestia was trying to rescue her sister


I think tree of harmony set night mare moon free it might know that the mane 6 can defeat Night mare moon it is a magcial tree idk but I think tree of harmony freed Night mare moon....but we might never know who accually did that it might not be Grogar, Celestia or the Tree of harmony because if Celestia or Grogar would do it how would it be in the book Twilight read before leaving Cantarlot I just have a feeling its the tree of harmong. Btw love your vids


I think nightmare moon found a way to get out and like did that


if doesn't some has or how will they appear at night..?? I mean some one has to do/take the responsibility don't they


No  it is luna Remer season 7 she controlled the sun


Princess Celestia race is the sun and the moon and stars so that makes no sense because Luna stars and the moon so yeah


I don't think Celestia baildout nightmare moon. That is impossible.


im late but
after lunas banishment celestia took over both duty of raising the sun and the moon and the sun is technically a star (i know u said the sun isnt a star in the mlp world but i think it still it yes the mlp is not our world but that doesnt mean the sun cant be a star and who else u think lauren meant, the only characters that has raised the sun and moon was storm king, starswirl the bearded and the other unicorns, twilight, celestia and luna. Starswirl was in limbo the other unicorns, well we don't even know them, storm king well we dont really know his backstory and he didn't had magic to control the sun and the moon he got that magic from the princesses. Twilight had the magic temporary from the princess)
or it could be nightmare moon who controls the stars to release herself out bc if celestia can raise the sun and the moon im guessing luna can do it too

but who was the writer of the book that says the star will make nightmare moon return thing, how did they know, plus nightmare moon was banished for 1,000 years and people forgot there was a 2nd princess

 celestia took twilight under her wings so im guessing celestia made a book saying nightmare moon will return and gave it to her then told twilight to make friends

i think thats why celestia opened a magic school

to find a student that can reform luna/nightmare moon

after celestia found twilight and gave her some guidance she knew twilight was ready to ignite the spark and find the 6th element and defeat nightmare moon bringing back luna

the way celestia went missing, she was probably observing since she heard what the mane 6 said
but why didnt celestia change nightmare moon to luna when she had the element though that keeps bugging me out


WHAT IF THERE IS a another lost princess controlling the stars!!!!!!!!!!!


Well, If Celestia controls the sun, Luna controls the moon... If anyone will question, "Who controls the stars?" It must be somepony powerful like an Alicorn cuz Celestia Is an Alicorn, Luna is an Alicorn.. the one that might be a Alicorn bc Celestia and Luna are both alicorns so the power of moving the stars maybe Alicorn Worthy? The night NightMareMoon escaped, the stars, MOVED.. and there must be somepony that moved them?! What do u guys think??


This is just a theory but what if the tree didn't vanish all of Luna to the moon like If the tree left luna`s thing that almost escaped into the real world and made it a living nightmare .... maybe that's the thing that controls the stars?


wait if nightmaremoon is in The moon Then when Princess celestia makes The Sun who makes The moon


Maybe twilight sparkle is the one controling the stars just look at her name or cutie mark


Maybe starlight it does make sense because her name is starlight


Celestia saw sign of nightmare moon was that the mane 6 is going to come together


Maby there is a princes of the stars is there?


Why do you always say Yoshi Darklord so begrudgingly?


Ummm... I'm a pegasus  born to alicorn parents  so am I still counted? Also love your vids!


I think that Celestia did not do it I think the leader of the team that used  to set the sun and moon did it because he is powerful      and  I think it would help the test sooo Celestia did 1part and he did the other aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaand i'm in 2nd grade


Sawtooth who controlled the stars

Me The editors duh

BOO


what's your halloween costume sawtooth waves?


There’s only one answer starlight Shimmer


why did starlight try to thitroy her sister in clouldstale


who had a roll  in making all those memes?


WAIT! im sorry, but isn't twilight the one with her CUTIE MARK AS A STAR!!!!???? my theory doesn't make a lot of sense since twilight IS the one that was worried and knew about nightmare moon's return. but just think about it, maybe, by mistake, she was the one that released NIGHTMARE MOON


Ok the tree set luna free but the question is the tree wasn't ther went the main six pony defited nightmare moon how did it luna free seriously thought


Lol😂idk the control the star😂but I guess twilight is controling it😂


Hey sawtooth can you make a video about if ponies can go to the bathroom I know they probably can take a shower and brush their teeth but can they go to the bathroom


you are a grown man who watches my little pony


Hmm I think there is a clue im episode 21 season 8 "a Rockhoof and a hard place twilight says and I quote "  oh no stars can move slowly over time they must look different now over 1000 years ago." End quote


maybe it can happened princess celestia Miss princess Luna  and think princess Twilight sparkle and her friend can handle this I don't know about the star but I think princess on princess Luna when she was locked in moon


Twilight sparkle or tree of harmony look at that cutie mark of Twilight sparkle it’s a spark like stars and The tree of harmony it’s like in season nine twilight and her friends found out a chest inside the chest she got her new castle and the center of the castle the spark if you like this hit the like button


Twilight Sparkle who controls the stars because you could just look at her cutie mark is Stars


The tree conected her and the sun is e star so she maybey used the sun ty control ty stars


Sawtooth ‐ what do you guys think how much of a role ...<br>Me ‐ you put a picture of a roll im hungry

Sawtooth ‐ what do you guys think how much of a role ...
Me ‐ you put a picture of a roll im hungry


DID YOU KNOW THAT STARS ARE VERY VERY VERY VERY VERY VERY FAR AWAY SUNS???????


I'M CALLIN IT! IT'S FLIPPING THE DARK SHADOW HORSE PERSON!!!!!! TmT


well celestia moves the sun put the sun is a star so.


Twilight did had a cutie mark and then the cutke mark has stars dont know who knows if twilight is doing it


Twilight control the Stars I mean just look at her cutie mark


Grogar is the father of monsters well nightmare moon is a vilian  it is grogar


I dont think thet Twighlight set nightmer moon free, but she kuld be the princess who kontrols the stars. I mean she didnt have any roal but friendship. And look at her cuty mark


Who is the strongest and chaotic person you know dis.....cord...... maybe he had enough power to do it


2:49 Please do not make ugly face of the Princess


I think it's twilight sparkle bc when she bc the new rolery of equstra she  Conchos the sun and the moon and her cutey mark is  a star


It is Twilight Sparkle she has a star as her cutie mark


I think the luna always job to rising the moon because I have seen episode then the celestia defective Luna means nightmare moon and the nightmare moon is anywhere I think so because she is locked anywhere in the celestia tell the Twilight sparkle full history of nightmare moon and she said the nightmare moon is free I think so the Luna is also have a castle on the moon because I see that video so I think the Luna is rising moon and the   moon set


Ok I have a guess.Eho in My Little Pony has a star in there cutie mark that we knew of? Here's the article Twilight Sparkle I mean look at t huh at cutie mark


Can you make a video about *Who are Princess Celestia and Luna parents*, please!!!!!!!


Befor the tree of harmony get shattered a had a theory that grogar was imprisoned in the roots


Starlight glimmer control the stars 😂😂😂kiding


I want to know I really want to know the truth who control the stars


Maybe celestia and luna mother control the star


Is it it the rainbow that gave them a city make


i know who Control the stars is luna😋😋✅💜


Lunas dad  controls the stars or maybe star swirl or maybe STARLIGHT idk


Wait look at the stars then princess twilight cutie Mark align one of the stars with the other four take away the one in the middle and the one next to it then put the moon in the middle of the four stars then you know who let nightmare moon out


I think it was star swirl yes and he planted it the tree what if he was trying to communicate with the pony’s in equestria because he was stuck in limbo

Or it was king sombra because if y’all watch when princess celestia and Luna fight him Luna transform for the first time


k so if  Celestia brought them together it would be the same it is today<br>like if you agree

k so if  Celestia brought them together it would be the same it is today
like if you agree


I think that prinnces celest accidently put the wrong spell idk???


STARswirl I mean the guy is more powerful than the alicorns he could have done it by simply looking into the future


luna controls the stars buut celestia can too caus the sun and the stars are same


so that twilight becomes attached to her friends and then stay learn how to be the princess of friendship and season 9 spoilers


Four stars : four razem
All of the three ponies i mean for example Rainbow, pinky and rarity
And alicorns
So : one pegas, one unicorn, one earth pony and one alicorn who can bez Celestia
???


WAIT WAIT WAIT STARswirl the bearded?!?! :0


wasnt the magic that made the fake ponies and other obstetricals  NMM???


So maybe the Tree of harmony connect to a Celestia and let's the let's you control the song and someone and sisters but was out we saying it but also letting the Tree of harmony control this the start Swan Princess Celestia needs to go out of the moon actually is there a bathroom in the moon😁


No one controls the stars when it goes morning pony’s can’t see the stars


i see sun and moon at the tree of hormany


I came here right after watching your recent video 😎


luna herself beacouse the stars and moon are two things we see in the night the sun is only in the sky when its day but celestia controls the sun and luna controls the moon butwe do not know about the stars discord could of free luna  with his magic but he was stone so the real answer ur looking for is finding out the mother the real real real real mother of celestia and luna hope my informatoin helps im no creator from mlp but i am a fan and i hope u see my coment


My daughter party cannon aka abigale and me cuddle fart aka vijay. Think that the tree of harmony sent the visions to celestia making her send twilight to ponyvile and to make friends. Cool channel we love your videos


i saw this theroy and was unbelieved and I coul'dnt sleep


If the sun is a star in our world but what about in their world.And maybe she saw the signs but maybe the tree of harmony.And you should get your canen


Luna or nightmaremoon is her sister it makes sense


Maybe the tree might have moon, sun, and star rising powers because the tree has luna and celestia's cutie mark etched on the trunk


Me: OMG I KNOW WHY SHE WANTED HER SISTER TO BE REFORMED!


I still beleived the theory of gogor who did released nightmare 🌕 but if you see in the a video called luna' cutie mark Celestia she has to raised the star some night and when she is out of practice celestia doing for

And I don't think yhe that tree of harmony will cause starlight stop the rainboom nightmare 🌕 was released when the friend were not connected yet like the tree was smart so it has no reason to and you can't argue with the Creator


Doesn't luna raise the moon TOOOOOOOOOOOOO????????????????<br>RIGHT ......

Doesn't luna raise the moon TOOOOOOOOOOOOO????????????????
RIGHT ......


The tree of harmaony was dead Remember from discord


Guste the. Great. Mabye. Controls. The. Star. She. Was. The. One who. Got. Groger.to the stars


I think it might be star swear if I spelled something wrong just tell me