Honestly whatever her backstory was. I’m still annoyed at the fact that they put a CHILD into a stone prison for who knows how many years. Like ok she did a lot of bad stuff. But still they should of tried to reform them like Celestia did with discord.

Honestly whatever her backstory was. I’m still annoyed at the fact that they put a CHILD into a stone prison for who knows how many years. Like ok she did a lot of bad stuff. But still they should of tried to reform them like Celestia did with discord.

@ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽 if you saw my other replys i state that i have changed my mind and it was to far to turn her to stone

@ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽 if you saw my other replys i state that i have changed my mind and it was to far to turn her to stone

ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽

@Bubblepop_yt and yes i have had a lot of time to think sinces i made that reply 2 weeks ago and no she not deserve it

@Bubblepop_yt and yes i have had a lot of time to think sinces i made that reply 2 weeks ago and no she not deserve it

@Bubblepop_yt but cozy glow does not deserve it being turned to stone forever is not something she deserves

@Bubblepop_yt but cozy glow does not deserve it being turned to stone forever is not something she deserves

@night shroud96: that is completely right. There is no reason to put her into stone except for sadistic revenge. Tartarus works just fine.

@night shroud96: that is completely right. There is no reason to put her into stone except for sadistic revenge. Tartarus works just fine.

@Shadow Spector like why if she suffered abuse and that made her like this

@Shadow Spector like why if she suffered abuse and that made her like this

@_Høney Lemøn_ Honestly if they wanted to contain her to reform her later, just put her back in Tartarus.  She only got out due to Discord plucking her and Tirek out.

@_Høney Lemøn_ Honestly if they wanted to contain her to reform her later, just put her back in Tartarus.  She only got out due to Discord plucking her and Tirek out.

@alyarin9000: yeah I noticed that. It’s said there’s an issue with magic and if magic is gone, that’s what Cozy’s goal was in the season 8 finale. That would be insanely cool if Gen 5 tied into the trio.

@alyarin9000: yeah I noticed that. It’s said there’s an issue with magic and if magic is gone, that’s what Cozy’s goal was in the season 8 finale. That would be insanely cool if Gen 5 tied into the trio.

@Shadow Spector Equestria's mistake was keeping them together. The result of a slower, cautious win from them is the setting of G5 - no magic, and division between pony tribes. It's suspicious.

@Shadow Spector Equestria's mistake was keeping them together. The result of a slower, cautious win from them is the setting of G5 - no magic, and division between pony tribes. It's suspicious.

@alyarin9000: if you don’t want to have her reformed, that’s fine. But there was no reason to put her in stone when Tartarus was working just fine. As stated before, Equestria was entering its longest period of peace, and the only way Tirek and Cozy could actually get out of Tartarus was because Discord freed them in the first place. There was no reason not to put them back in the same place after they were already defeated on the ground.

@Shadow Spector If she willingly stepped down and, say, attacked Chrysalis and Tirek at the height of their power, in order to protect Twilight? Said that actually killing Twilight was too far, and helped the mane 6 escape, without demanding the largest terrorist attack in Canterlot's history? Sure, she could be reformed then, but she'd be on thin damn ice given what else she pulled.

Instead, she showed no remorse, killed thousands of people because it'd be fun, and nearly killed you. Yeah, I don't blame Discord, Celestia and Luna for imprisoning her in stone, nor Twi and the M6 for not protesting.

@Shadow Spector Would you still be sympathetic to her if we had an episode where the mane 6 have to comfort the hundreds if not thousands of husbands, wives, parents and children who lost their loved ones in the attack? A memorial to the slaughter? Out of universe, we can try to forgive any action, but in-universe, Cozy is responsible for the largest terrorist attack in recent history. The only thing that could compare is probably the storm king, but he didn't actually intentionally murder non-combatants as far as we can see (e.g. no death camps), and there wasn't long enough for him to kill ponies through overwork / process them for their horns.

@Shadow Spector Skip a few years, she escapes from the ultramax prison, and then works with two other terrorists to capture important figures in your government, along with your friends. She tells the other terrorists to destroy a building in an attack which is arguably equal to if not worse than 9/11 in-universe -- and they ACTUALLY do it.

The terrorists then chain up your friends, and she laughs as she tells them how she's gonna kill them all - how it'll be "fun" - until the other terrorists finally tell her to chill.  They just argue with her and each other for a while.

She shoots a goddamn rocket at you and your friends, and you're barely protected in time by your allies coming to save the day. The terrorists are defeated.

Is that person still worthy of being given the benefit of the doubt? Of course not. They're a hardened criminal, a terrorist on par with Osama Bin Laden. Throwing the book at them is fine, no matter their age - they know what they're doing, and they are both unrepentant and responsible for hundreds if not thousands of deaths, and heartbreak for many.

@Shadow Spector Try to picture it IRL. Someone just tried to trap you in a pit to (possibly) starve to death (or at the very least wait there until maybe a prisoner breaks out and attacks you) - not only that, but they just stole a variety of artifacts to overload your country's power supply - undoubtedly causing hundreds if not thousands of deaths of ponies relying on cloudwalking spells or magical life-support. They caused a student of yours to almost fall to her death, and beyond that, they were taking instructions from terrorists on how to do so.

Your country's military is about to become extremely weak, right after you were already reeling from your whole species being enslaved temporarily - and on top of all THAT, your tech is going to go. Your entire world will be sent into the dark ages. Cities will fall, millions will die, and it's all that one person's fault.

They knowingly did it. They were even about to hurl one of your best friends into another dimension where who-knows-what would happen to her.

You do an inquiry later, and she has belongings including (possibly) the skull of a foal who died to blunt-force trauma to the skull. Is she responsible? Perhaps tracing the skull would be possible, making her a murderer.

All of that together makes her a terrorist responsible for the largest terrorist attack in your nation's history, working with known terrorists, and she's a murderer, with great skill in manipulation - you never know if she's honest or just pretending, as she shows signs of psychopathy - it's quite possible she CAN'T genuinely care for others. Imprisonment in an ultramax prison is justified.

@alyarin9000: Twilight willingly held out her hoof to Starlight and offered alternatives for her. No one did that for Cozy. Twilight did ask why Cozy did it, but Cozy just wanted power, and Twilight stopped caring after that. No one actually tried to offer alternatives and actually help her, which is even more shocking because she was just a child and you’d think they’d have better morals than that.

@alyarin9000: Twilight willingly held out her hoof to Starlight and offered alternatives for her. No one did that for Cozy. Twilight did ask why Cozy did it, but Cozy just wanted power, and Twilight stopped caring after that. No one actually tried to offer alternatives and actually help her, which is even more shocking because she was just a child and you’d think they’d have better morals than that.

@Shadow Spector Starlight showed remorse, and willingly stepped down. Cozy had to be forced down, showed no remorse for what she did, and basically stated "I lost, but really can you blame me for trying to gain power at the expense of everyone else?"

Cozy and Starlight are not alike at all.

@Shadow Spector Starlight showed remorse, and willingly stepped down. Cozy had to be forced down, showed no remorse for what she did, and basically stated "I lost, but really can you blame me for trying to gain power at the expense of everyone else?"

Cozy and Starlight are not alike at all.

@alyarin9000: of course she would renounce friendship if the princess of friendship treated her the way she did. She’d think that if she gave herself up to friendship, she’d be supporting the ponies who treated her so harshly the first time around. The “heroes” ruined things with Cozy, and of course she would hold grudges against that. If the “heroes” actually tried to help her, things would have been different, but no one cared about her. Why is it that Starlight, who did things way worse than Cozy, could be given a chance but not the filly who isn’t a threat by herself?

Also, the “heroes” should try to help all members of the Legion of Doom, not just Cozy. If their abilities are too much of a threat, there’s an easy fix. Just use the Bell to drain their powers. This way, it’s merely a matter of who they are rather than what they can do, and there is little to no risk involved in this. But no, that’s probably too hard if it means saving a life, and it’s easier just to torture them.

@Fresh2000 ZCORD You know a manipulative mastermind is written well when her special talent bleeds into REAL LIFE lol

@Fresh2000 ZCORD You know a manipulative mastermind is written well when her special talent bleeds into REAL LIFE lol

@Shadow Spector Liked being evil "before"? She liked being evil -now-, even if deciding that she liked helping a sadistic tyrant and selfish, greedy uncaring centaur made her good, she had renounced friendship by the time she was punished - not to mention, you know, mass murder and sadistic glee at the concept of execution.

"when you use your power to help others, you can get so much more done" is one possibility of what she was going to say, but even IF it were an innocent statement, she didn't care how many people her friends hurt along the way.

If the heroes tried to help her, she'd just pretend to be good and then see how she can remove Tirek and Chryssie from stone, so she can once again fight alongside the two beings who gave her the most power she had ever experienced.

@alyarin9000: it doesn’t matter if Cozy liked being evil before. She admitted that she liked being good more than that. The purpose isn’t to see how bad they are. It’s so see if they can be helped, and Cozy confirmed she wasn’t passed redemption in the episode Frenemies. The smile she gave after she got the bell was far different than the ones she ever gave when she was experiencing power. She always gave a smirk or evil laugh but when she was discussing things with Tirek and Chrysalis, her smile was a hopeful smile, showing she was actually viewing life differently. She even said “when we helped eachother, it felt better somehow.” She wasn’t saying this just to get the benefits of friendship for power. She was actually feeling the emotions behind true friendship, and by saying “when you use your power to help others-,” she was actually making plans to be good. If Chrysalis didn’t stop the progression or if the “heroes” actually cared to help her, Cozy would’ve been reformed.

@Shadow Spector Plus, knowing Cozy, she may well have just been acknowledging the practical benefits of actually working together, rather than any emotional change.

@Shadow Spector Plus, knowing Cozy, she may well have just been acknowledging the practical benefits of actually working together, rather than any emotional change.

@Shadow Spector Chrysalis kept them from embracing friendship, true, but it was repeatedly Cozy who was the bloodthirsty murderer among them. She's the one with the most blood on her hooves, being responsible for directing practically a nuking of Canterlot. No amount of "but she's a child!" can redeem that.

Cozy is a child, but she's a psychopathic sadistic murderer who could and would slowly kill ANYONE for fun. Who decided that murdering hundreds of ponies in the castle (if it was TRULY only the castle) was a fun idea, and killed all of them with a grin, pressuring Tirek and Chrysalis to do the same. Who reveled in telling her prisoners that she's about to kill them with sadistic glee until Chrysalis of all creatures stopped her.

@alyarin9000: her punishment is not justified. The same result could have been achieved if she was placed in Tartarus. There is no reason why that didn’t happen other than for the “heroes” to turn into sadists so they could practically murder a child. The princesses literally said that Equestria was entering its longest period of peace when Cozy and Tirek were in Tartarus, so if they were placed there, everything would still be solved but in a more humane way. Chrysalis is a still a bad influence on Cozy too though since Cozy was actually giving herself over to the idea of friendship and basically finding a different way to be happy, one that actually helped others. But before Cozy could actually be redeemed, Chrysalis yelled for her to stop, even when she was actually being gotten through to. Starlight did things that were way worse than what Cozy did and Starlight still got a second chance and turned her whole life around. Meanwhile Cozy is just a child and her brain is still developing. While it seems she knew what she was doing, she still had a chance to change if anyone actually cared about her. It could have turned out so much differently for her if the “heroes” actually behaved like heroes and not like the villains they had been fighting against the whole time.

@Shadow Spector Cozy was the one suggesting to "redecorate" by nuking Canterlot, killing at best hundreds of ponies. Cozy was the one who took glee in the idea of destroying (e.g. killing) their prisoners. The truth is, Cozy is the most murderous and evil of the trio. Sure, Chryssie's sadistic, but even SHE was like "chill Cozy, let's NOT immediately kill all of our prisoners of war ok?" - arguably, Cozy was a bad influence on Chryssie and Tirek, not the other way around.

Literally, if Chrysalis wasn't around to reign Cozy in, the mane 6, Pillars, Starlight and (depending on their immortality) princesses would have been dead while Twi was hiding in the Empire. She's murderous, she knows what she's doing, and she takes GLEE in telling ponies she's about to murder them. She has a cracked foal's skull as a possession of hers, who knows if that skull was her first kill!? Her punishment is justified.

@Shadow Spector She did the equivalent of nuking a city. No sympathy.

@Shadow Spector She did the equivalent of nuking a city. No sympathy.

@Ramy I would agree with a real life kid as they wouldn't be completely aware of what there doing, but cozy glow is definitely fully aware and smart enough and enjoys it she states "were villains duh" in part 1 of the finale.

And ironically despite being given the most sympathy by the fandom of the trio, cozy can be argued to be the least redeemable not because she has committed more bad actions than say chrysalis, but because out of the trio she has had the most chances as she was literally at a school of friendship learning friendship, had students and teachers who treated her with nothing but kindness/ like a friend and yet she still betrayed all of them and tried to forcibly enslave there country without ever having any remorse.

 Like i said maybe there punishment should have been less even tho one can argue, whether there conscious or not as its never truly specified but she is as unreptantantly evil and remorseless as tirek and chrysalis.

@Ramy: that’s EXACTLY the biggest problem I had. While the act itself is horrendous, the only thing that made it worse was the fact that everyone agreed with it. If a show wants to do something like what they did, you can say it’s their choice but if the writers don’t even know that what they’re doing is wrong, that’s where it gets really frustrating. If there would’ve been at least one character looking at what happened and went “what? This isn’t good,” then it wouldn’t have been as bad as it was, but the fact that everyone was smiling and the triumphant music played when they were torturing a child, that’s just morally disgusting.

@Fresh2000 ZCORD and honestly Discord is such a hypocrite and a liar. He said he wouldn’t betray them again and he did. Even if it was fir twilight’s training. He still helped villains which is still considered traitorous behavior even if he had good attention. And he’s a hypocrite because he out of all people should know that stone prisons aren’t easy. Why would he give it to someone when he faced it himself? Whats worse is that all of equestria and all the creatures were literally cheering them instead of calling them out for it.

@Fresh2000 ZCORD Ok. Listen If it was only tirek and chrisalis then Yeah I guess it’d be ok. But Not COZY. Bruh She’s a damn child. Even if she hurt a lot of people. A child doesn’t deserve to be put in eternal suffering.

@Fresh2000 ZCORD Ok. Listen If it was only tirek and chrisalis then Yeah I guess it’d be ok. But Not COZY. Bruh She’s a damn child. Even if she hurt a lot of people. A child doesn’t deserve to be put in eternal suffering.

yeah ponies really don't understand how children work apparently

yeah ponies really don't understand how children work apparently

@_Høney Lemøn_: thank you. It’s nice that after so long, I could get through to someone. It just feels so unnecessary what happened to her and they could’ve achieved the same result more humanely. I’ve been disgusted in the decision ever since the finale.

@_Høney Lemøn_: thank you. It’s nice that after so long, I could get through to someone. It just feels so unnecessary what happened to her and they could’ve achieved the same result more humanely. I’ve been disgusted in the decision ever since the finale.

@Shadow Spector I'm actually starting to agree with you that Cozy being turned to stone is a harsh punishment, she should have been sent to Tartarus again

@Shadow Spector I'm actually starting to agree with you that Cozy being turned to stone is a harsh punishment, she should have been sent to Tartarus again

@Blue it would be more interesting for Cozy to have a backstory since it would reveal why she did all the things she did and it wouldn't seem like she just wants to rule equestria

@Blue it would be more interesting for Cozy to have a backstory since it would reveal why she did all the things she did and it wouldn't seem like she just wants to rule equestria

There’s a theory that she’s an adult pony who has a physical disability making her look like a child, which is honestly a very plausible theory considering she’s partially based upon Babydoll, a Batman villain who was an adult that looked like a child.

There’s a theory that she’s an adult pony who has a physical disability making her look like a child, which is honestly a very plausible theory considering she’s partially based upon Babydoll, a Batman villain who was an adult that looked like a child.

@Ramy she might actually be. Remember the video where sawtooth stole the statue?

@Ramy she might actually be. Remember the video where sawtooth stole the statue?

@Shadow Spector well I wasn't saying it was heroic per say just very understandable considering all the trio have done to them. The trio decided to come to Equestria by themselves in attack first, which is what they did in there first appearances it wasn't revenge driven when they first attacked, they just wanted to enslave others attack there homes simply for power and control, they weren't horribly treated with tragic backstories and then decided to attack as if there tragic villains the fandom seems to want them to be so its not the same.

@Fresh2000 ZCORD: every show before (at least in the mainstream) that have had their heroes be driven to the point of murder have made their heroes feel some form of remorse for their actions. These “heroes” doing what they did and it being celebrated is not something that should be considered heroic. And if you’re going on the idea that you can’t blame the “heroes” for wanting to commit murder, then why is it any different for how poorly Equestria treated the villains and them being so angry to want revenge? Is it just because the princesses and Discord are on the good side so that’s why it’s understandable?

And you’re insisting that sometimes, getting revenge by torturing a child is sometimes just how life goes?

And yes, I somewhat agree with that last paragraph. With some people I’ve talked to, they’ve claimed that the people they’ve debated with were trying to make it sound like the villains did nothing wrong. Of course the villains did bad things, but how they were disposed of was despicable. If the “heroes” were forced to turn them into stone/ kill them in order to stop them (like what they did with Discord or Sombra respectively), then it would’ve been relatively acceptable since they had no choice. But the fact that when they were already defeated on the ground and the “heroes” still decided that they haven’t suffered enough, that was just moral disgusting.

@Shadow Spector tbh tho how much remorse do u expect them to have to have for being who tried to harm them and even kill them in some cases multiple times like i mean yeah there the good guys but there still living breathing beings this is honestly the most realistic option.

 Which I guess is the core of the problem others have as the series is about forgiveness which is understandable if u feel a series breaks it own rules.
But to be honest I think its a good lesson to teach that even some of the most kindhearted people or uh creatures aren't going to forgive everything especially if they have no remorse, sometimes people will bite u back if u bite them.

Just my take on it tho but I dont completely disagree with the complete core of what your saying just wish the fandom would give them a lot more accountable instead of making them out to be complete victims and deciding to demoralize the cast for not being overtly friendly for once to those who wish to hurt them but yeh.

@Fresh2000 ZCORD: you misunderstand. The princesses and Discord didn’t torture the villains because they had to. They did it because they wanted to. While they’re not bad in the other categories like the villains were, they still made a villainous decision and didn’t even feel any remorse for it afterwards.

@Fresh2000 ZCORD: you misunderstand. The princesses and Discord didn’t torture the villains because they had to. They did it because they wanted to. While they’re not bad in the other categories like the villains were, they still made a villainous decision and didn’t even feel any remorse for it afterwards.

@Shadow Spector the princesses and discord aren't bad like the trio they actually care about others which is why i said they didn't do it just to be bad, didn't u see how they were pride of twilight and bowed to her soon after

@Shadow Spector the princesses and discord aren't bad like the trio they actually care about others which is why i said they didn't do it just to be bad, didn't u see how they were pride of twilight and bowed to her soon after

@Fresh2000 ZCORD: being scared may not be the same as having remorse for every action they’ve committed, but Chrysalis still adamantly said she’d never be good while the other two were scared. Besides morals, fear is another motivator to make sure that people stay in line, and if Cozy and Tirek were afraid, that was something to work with.

And while Cozy may have been cruel before, at least she wasn’t posing as a hero. The only difference between what she did and what the “heroes” did was the perception the writers tried to make the audience see. What the “heroes” did isn’t right just because they call themselves the heroes.

And you say the princesses and Discord weren’t doing it just to be bad but that’s exactly why they did it. Didn’t you see the smiles on their face as they found a way to get their sadistic revenge? It was completely unnecessary, and just like Discord returned from stone, the trio could return as well. It’s got the same escape rate as Tartarus has except Tartarus was shown not to take too much of a toll on its prisoners’ sanity as we see in the season 9 premiere. Discord suggested the endless torture which was completely immoral of him. The best option would’ve been to attempt to help the Legion of Doom since they actually showed before that they wanted to be good, so they are not passed redemption. And if the princesses and Discord wanted to make sure they never came back, they would’ve killed them, which still would’ve been more merciful than what they got.

@Shadow Spector to be honest tho being scared isn't enough i mean they didn't care about the fear and suffering on Equestria. They didn't regret anything they backed down like bullies often do when overpowered if they still had power or if they were to regain it they would have immediately attacked. Cozy glow planned to have the mane 6 in tartarus forever so I wouldn't claim there less cruel especially considering the princesses and discord aren't doing bad things just to do bad things like the trio wanted to do to EQ , there doing it as retribution against beings who wish to harm there home and those they care for and also a surefire way to make sure they never return. Like i said maybe they should have gotten a lighter sentence but I don't think its fair how certain parts of the fandom have completely demoralized discord and in some cases the entire cast while whitewashing/downplaying the trio.

@Fresh2000 ZCORD: Chrysalis doesn’t speak for the other two. If you notice when they’re stoned, Chrysalis is the only one who has an angry expression while the other two are scared. Chrysalis is also the one who stirred the other two out of redemption in the first place so it’s not fair that she gets to speak on behalf of them. If the “heroes” actually wanted to act humanely (if they didn’t want to try and help them at all), they would’ve put the three in Tartarus since that was shown to work. Celestia even confirmed that Equestria was experiencing its longest period of peace and Cozy and Triek were shown to not be too upset at the conditions they were in, so it’s a better option if the “heroes” wanted to act somewhat humanely. But no, they just wanted revenge on the villains, which is what we criticized the villains for doing in the first place.

@Shadow Spector discord lose his magic, had everyone pissed and called him out, was dragged around on a chain by the trio and wasn't forgiven until he put himself in danger to help make things right. What led to these events was discord having the noble intention of helping twilight be a great leader of Equestria. The trio was turned to stone after being defeated because chrysalis made it known they will always return and this is despite them knowing how great friendship can be. Im not saying discord is a saint and maybe they should have got a lesser sentence but ultimately they did it to themselves.

@Fresh2000 ZCORD: because the trio were already defeated when the “heroes” decided to basically execute them. And then after the battle, nothing happened to Discord. In fact, he was rewarded by getting to decide the villains’ fate. It’s double standards that are being pointed out, and it’s extremely frustrating.

@Fresh2000 ZCORD: because the trio were already defeated when the “heroes” decided to basically execute them. And then after the battle, nothing happened to Discord. In fact, he was rewarded by getting to decide the villains’ fate. It’s double standards that are being pointed out, and it’s extremely frustrating.

@User so if discord is inexcusable for doing what he did to help his friends how are the trio not inexcusable for doing for they did for power

@User so if discord is inexcusable for doing what he did to help his friends how are the trio not inexcusable for doing for they did for power

@Amelia Segan discord isn't a villain he just didn't think things through considering he was trying to help twilight be a good leader and he later had remorse for his actions and put himself in danger to help save Equestria. He is actually just misguided.

@Amelia Segan discord isn't a villain he just didn't think things through considering he was trying to help twilight be a good leader and he later had remorse for his actions and put himself in danger to help save Equestria. He is actually just misguided.

@Ryderboycolor9: yes, Discord was still for 1,000 years which is still really messed up but he’s the strongest being in existence and it seemed to be the only way to contain him (which still didn’t work after a while.) Discord confirmed he was still conscious when he said “being turned to stone doesn’t stop me from hearing everything Celestia says.” This was far too horrible for Cozy, a child who is extremely easy to apprehend since she has no magical abilities. Of course she deserved something to make it so she wouldn’t do the same thing in the future, but this wasn’t a punishment. This was a death sentence.

@_Høney Lemøn_ Not all villains need backstory to tell their intentions.

@_Høney Lemøn_ Not all villains need backstory to tell their intentions.

@Shadow Spector i mean what im trying to say is No she should have been turned to stone and maybe should could have been reformed well i don't think that can ever happen now whitch is pretty dark to think about...

@Shadow Spector i mean what im trying to say is No she should have been turned to stone and maybe should could have been reformed well i don't think that can ever happen now whitch is pretty dark to think about...

@Shadow Spector well maybe not turned to stone she deserved something thats for sure she had her chance and wasted it also i thought they were alseep when being turned to stone now that i know that thare awake it was not a good idea at all does this mean Discord was just standing thare for 1000 years doing Nothing or did he not go crazy becaues hes the the lord of chaos either way your right and the way discord says together forever makes it all the more chilling

@Ryderboycolor9: of course turning her to stone was way too harsh. No one in Equestria deserves such a fate. It’s not just containing them for a small amount of time (which Tartarus was doing just fine with). It’s not suspending their consciousness either. They are confirmed to be frozen in one place, fully conscious, for all eternity (even Bill Cipher from Gravity Falls pointed out that this was too harsh). Sure she might be angry for the first couple of weeks or months but pretty soon, she’s going to begin wishing she killed herself before. And then she’s going to begin begging for something to happen that could let her die. She’ll be screaming out in stone and no one is going to be able to hear her. She’ll be only able to hear the beautiful sounds of life but never able to join in. She’s literally a child and the “heroes” should’ve taken this into consideration. But no, they just wanted to torture her because it made them feel good. There should be no question as to what happened to Cozy Glow was morally outrageous.

@Ryderboycolor9 No offence, but your first phrase is long and does not have any punctuation sign. These make your phrase difficult to read.

@Ryderboycolor9 No offence, but your first phrase is long and does not have any punctuation sign. These make your phrase difficult to read.

@Shadow Spector Your sentence " she was just describing the excuse as to why she lost " have made me to think that she has meant to say " I was to younger to confront them ". My initial thought was by " I am just a kid, so ... " she has meant to say " I am to inexperienced to identify the causes of my defeat ".

@Shadow Spector Your sentence " she was just describing the excuse as to why she lost " have made me to think that she has meant to say " I was to younger to confront them ". My initial thought was by " I am just a kid, so ... " she has meant to say " I am to inexperienced to identify the causes of my defeat ".

@JC J starlight would, in season 5 premier she almost blasted them with a huge spell if it wasn’t for twilight. And her actions did kill but she didn’t realize it. By changing the timeline she caused hundreds of ponies to die. Remember the king sombra war? She should of thought about the consequences. And you can’t judge Cozy glow when we don’t actually know her canon backstory. She’s bad I’ll give you that. But no one deserve a punishment that is as bad as eternal prison. Like If I were in her place I’d rather be killed.

@:pine:pomegranete: yes I agree. I don't think discord should be turned to stone but he should face some punishment for his actions.

@:pine:pomegranete: yes I agree. I don't think discord should be turned to stone but he should face some punishment for his actions.

@Ramy yeah but cozy was willing to KILL Starlight wouldn’t have gone that far

@Ramy yeah but cozy was willing to KILL Starlight wouldn’t have gone that far

@JC J Still. She’s a CHILD. why can’t anyone understand that?  Starlight is a full grown adult who almost destroyed equestria’s timeline for Honestly a really dumb reason. Like bruh a lot of my friends left me too. But you don’t see me trying to destroy our world’s timeline. Meanwhile we never got an actual backstory for the villains.

@JC J Still. She’s a CHILD. why can’t anyone understand that?  Starlight is a full grown adult who almost destroyed equestria’s timeline for Honestly a really dumb reason. Like bruh a lot of my friends left me too. But you don’t see me trying to destroy our world’s timeline. Meanwhile we never got an actual backstory for the villains.

@Ramy also lets look at what Cozy did she tried to drian all the magic of Equstria she then helped the Villians learn friendship she also stole grogars bell she also took the magic of Celstia and Luna the two rulers she also tried to take over all of Equstria and did some other things shes a pretty Evil Filly and deserves a lot more then a cage but maybe being turned to stone is too far

@Ramy also lets look at what Cozy did she tried to drian all the magic of Equstria she then helped the Villians learn friendship she also stole grogars bell she also took the magic of Celstia and Luna the two rulers she also tried to take over all of Equstria and did some other things shes a pretty Evil Filly and deserves a lot more then a cage but maybe being turned to stone is too far

@Shadow Spector so what im trying to say is your both right in your own ways

@Shadow Spector so what im trying to say is your both right in your own ways

You do realize she was basically the pony version of young Mike Myers from Halloween

You do realize she was basically the pony version of young Mike Myers from Halloween

@Shadow Spector yes i agree also maybe i was wrong about Cozy glow turned into stone my god she does not even get to live her life or change in anyway i just realised that maybe turning her to stone was a bit too far

@Shadow Spector yes i agree also maybe i was wrong about Cozy glow turned into stone my god she does not even get to live her life or change in anyway i just realised that maybe turning her to stone was a bit too far

@Ramy yeah starlight should have been Punished too i hate starlight fior what she did in fact it seems like every villian thats been reformed did not get punished in anyway Tempest is free out thare so is Discord Discord allmost got the mane 6 killed by letting Sombra take over if anything discord should be the one turned to stone not Cozy glow and the others he the reason thare even stone right now maybe Cozy glow should not have been turned to stone but what else could they have done? Reform her? Maybe

@Ryderboycolor9: she’s not going to be there for 1,000 years. She’s going to be there forever as confirmed by Discord. And if she deserved to be stoned then Discord and Starlight also deserve to be stoned.

@Ryderboycolor9: she’s not going to be there for 1,000 years. She’s going to be there forever as confirmed by Discord. And if she deserved to be stoned then Discord and Starlight also deserve to be stoned.

@Ryderboycolor9 It doesn’t matter when she’s still a CHILD. She doesn’t know what she’s doing. Her brain is still forming. How dare you think like that. What about Starlight? Didn’t she like almost destroy equestria’s timeline ? And how was she punished ? She wasn’t punished in any way.

@Ryderboycolor9 It doesn’t matter when she’s still a CHILD. She doesn’t know what she’s doing. Her brain is still forming. How dare you think like that. What about Starlight? Didn’t she like almost destroy equestria’s timeline ? And how was she punished ? She wasn’t punished in any way.

@Shadow Spector she deserved to be turned to stone shes just as bad as the others i think 1000 years is a long time for her to think about what shes done

@Shadow Spector she deserved to be turned to stone shes just as bad as the others i think 1000 years is a long time for her to think about what shes done

@Shadow Spector I guess that"s why they're not continuing It in G5..

@Shadow Spector I guess that"s why they're not continuing It in G5..

@User ikrrr i mean maybe not ston because he was tring to help but he should get some kind of punishment

@User ikrrr i mean maybe not ston because he was tring to help but he should get some kind of punishment

@_Høney Lemøn_ me too that would be a nice bonus ep

@_Høney Lemøn_ me too that would be a nice bonus ep

@_Høney Lemøn_ maybe but there is no more seasons they have pony life now

@_Høney Lemøn_ maybe but there is no more seasons they have pony life now

@Book Thoughts: there are thoughts as to Cozy Glow lying about being a kid but there is no reason for her to lie there. She normally tells lie in order to manipulate others into doing what she wanted, but there wasn’t anything Cozy was trying to work towards there. She was just describing the excuse as to why she lost.

Now for her getting such a harsh punishment, that’s also absolutely ridiculous. Starlight Glimmer doomed Equestria several times and killed everyone in Equestria during the last one, but Twilight still held a hoof out to her. Unfortunately, she didn’t do this out of the kindness of her heart but she did this as a last ditch effort to get her to stop. Cozy didn’t understand what friendship was supposed to be used for, and she still got life in prison because of it. She had every right to be angry but everyone just excuses that as her being evil. It’s despicable.

@Shadow Spector Ok.  I didn't know about that.  I mean I saw that episode, but I think around that time something happened to my computer and I didn't get to listen to her say that. And though there is a possibility she lied, I'll except that as canon since it came from her.  But why they literally give a child with no backstory and imprisonment in pony heck and a statue is literally beyond me if they canonically made her a child.  I mean take Undertale for instance, Sans kills the playermany times on genocide, because they commit murder.  However, although Cozy has done horrible deeds, she has never committed murder, as far as we know.  So to summarize: she commits crimes on par with discord and Starlight with no one bothering to explain her actions and half-a**ing explanations on Starlight's part and leaving the other entirely unexplained, while locking her and the other villains up with no backstory to explain why they couldn't be changed.  And one of the reformed villains HAS NO BACKSTORY! MMMMMMM.  My point is they should have made canon backstory for, at least, anyone reformed, all the villains, or none. And I hope they do a better job in G5 than G4.  High high hopes, but no great expectations at this point.

@Book Thoughts: Cozy is just a child as she confirmed this in the season 9 premiere: “well, I’m just a kid, so . . .”

@Book Thoughts: Cozy is just a child as she confirmed this in the season 9 premiere: “well, I’m just a kid, so . . .”

I'm mad because I don't know anything about almost any of the villains!  Like even if you don't reform them that doesn't mean that they shouldn't have a backstory.  And Discord was reformed and he doesn't have a canon backstory!?  He's just DISCORD!  And Starlight's backstory can barely be called an "attempt." I hope they do better on continuity and backstory in G5.  Because G4 was just sad. . .  And is it REALLY canonical that Cozy is a child?  That's the thing I have been wondering most about.  What if she's just a short adult?  I mean there are plenty in the our world!  Why not in equestria as well?  She could be mistaken for a child.  But I'm not going to argue.  My main point is G4 done.  We can come up with theories and headcanons all we want at this point, but it's over.  Let's just hope G5 is better.  I don't have HIGH HIGH HOPES, but I'm hoping. . .

@Shadow Spector I do agree it's wrong but I just can't get mad about it like everyone else, it would have been nice to see Cozy Glow be reformed and use her powers and talents for good

@Shadow Spector I do agree it's wrong but I just can't get mad about it like everyone else, it would have been nice to see Cozy Glow be reformed and use her powers and talents for good

@_Høney Lemøn_: I can understand that. It’s easy to forget about something like that if you never cared for them in the first place. But it still feels objectively wrong to treat someone that way, and it shouldn’t just depend on whether you like said person or not.

@_Høney Lemøn_: I can understand that. It’s easy to forget about something like that if you never cared for them in the first place. But it still feels objectively wrong to treat someone that way, and it shouldn’t just depend on whether you like said person or not.

@Shadow Spector yes, you are correct and I can understand where you are coming from, but I didn't really mind Cozy Glow being turned to stone because I never really liked her, and maybe they were planning on reforming her later and for now she should be encased in stone, but It's hard to argue with your comment since you are right, I just don't like Cozy much which is why I don't mind her punishment

@Shadow Spector yes, you are correct and I can understand where you are coming from, but I didn't really mind Cozy Glow being turned to stone because I never really liked her, and maybe they were planning on reforming her later and for now she should be encased in stone, but It's hard to argue with your comment since you are right, I just don't like Cozy much which is why I don't mind her punishment

@_Høney Lemøn_: she is extremely likable, yes, but that is far from the reason why we’re mad. Even though Cozy did bad things, no one even tried to give her a chance like everyone else who came before her (besides the rest of the Legion of Doom). They just put her in Tartarus the first chance they got and she was still there three months later so it’s obvious no one was ever going to do anything about it. She was put in the same spot Tirek was and he had been there for over a thousand years, so it’s likely that they were planning on keeping Cozy there for that long too. Then to make matters worse, when she was defeated in the series finale, she was not a threat at all anymore and the “heroes” still smiled as they subjected her to torture. This was sadism at its finest. If she would have still been a threat then maybe the stoning would have been necessary (maybe) but she was vulnerable on the ground. They couldn’t wait to practically murder her except murdering her would’ve been merciful compared to what she got. Now she’s stuck in one place, fully conscious (since Discord confirmed that you remain conscious) and probably begging for someone to kill her. This is quite literally the worst fate I can ever imagine someone getting.

What cozy glow did was about equal to what starlight did, so why does she get a redemption and cozy does not? What tempest did was only as bad as what the storm king did, so why does she get a redemption while he doesn't? Discord is the enabler of the trio's  crimes and told them to do what they did. He is a terrible friend to ttwiligh.  So why does he get a second chance and the trio does not!? And he punishes them?! What?! Especially since they all showed potential to become good. My issue with my little pony is that they are not fair and give double standards to some villains over others in a way that makes no sense.

Discord is the real villain of season 9. I am so upset that after all trouble he caused he got off without any punishment and gets to roam free. His "reason" for why he did what he did was terrible. And inexcusable. I hate how it was him who chose the trio's punishment, he should be punished along with them! Discord is the only character in this show who is never held accountable for anything he does.

Discord is the real villain of season 9. I am so upset that after all trouble he caused he got off without any punishment and gets to roam free. His "reason" for why he did what he did was terrible. And inexcusable. I hate how it was him who chose the trio's punishment, he should be punished along with them! Discord is the only character in this show who is never held accountable for anything he does.

But I am annoyed that Hasbro didn't give her a backstory for her intentions

But I am annoyed that Hasbro didn't give her a backstory for her intentions

I think people are just mad because she is a cool villain and character and people like her a lot, they also might eventually try to reform her but decide to put her in stone for now until they find out how to reform her, and I don't think the fact that she's a child is an excuse anymore for what she did, and like in real life some people can't be reformed

I think people are just mad because she is a cool villain and character and people like her a lot, they also might eventually try to reform her but decide to put her in stone for now until they find out how to reform her, and I don't think the fact that she's a child is an excuse anymore for what she did, and like in real life some people can't be reformed

And discord off all people should know what it's like and remember discord said that he could hear every thing that was going on around him

And discord off all people should know what it's like and remember discord said that he could hear every thing that was going on around him

Of course it’s unfair. She’s a literal child, not even a preteen yet. If she’s the same age as the cmc and the cmc were shown to be younger than those teenagers in the season 9 episode, then Cozy is even younger than we thought.

It wasn’t enough that the “heroes” didn’t want to help her though. They actively enjoyed torturing her as they subjected her to the stone prison. “Who knows how many years.” We do know how many years, because of the child murderer’s words: “together forever. I can’t imagine anything they’d want less.” This was sadism at its finest.


I've always had the theory that she was the equivalent of a villain from Batman the animated series called "baby doll"

she was in adult trapped in the body of a child because she was born with a very rare condition (one that exists in real life albeit in a different name)


I believe this theory may hold more water than expected.
I remember a particular line from the first MLP Equestria girls movie where Sunset Shimmer says

"...not like that other girl that thought she could challenge me...."

I think Cozy Glow was that same girl, and the logic would make sense.

Think about it; Imagine that before Sunset Shimmer defected to the human world after abandoning her role as Celestias star pupil before Twilight, Cozy Glow was already that manipulative, power hungry high school girl that wanted to rule the school....until Sunset showed up, who over time managed to upstage Cozy Glow; The two may have been bitter rivals for a time.
So Cozy Glow was dethroned as Canterlot High School's "mean girl" and her last act against Sunset Shimmer was pulling the strings necessary to manipulate Flash Sentry to break up with Sunset Shimmer, which in turn led Sunset to resorting to stealing Twilight's crown, kickstarting the event's of the first movie.

Then, after Sunset was defeated by Twilight at the Fall Formal and the knowledge that an equestrian world had existed became public knowledge, then having also experienced the events of Rainbow Rocks and the Friendship Games, Cozy Glow, rationalizing that beings from Equestria and Equestrian Magic in general were a threat, went from being curious to opportunistic.

Perhaps during the Climax event of the Friendship Games, Cozy Glow was one of the students that had fallen into one of the portals, where she had remained trapped ever since; But instead of trying to return home, she decided to blend in and eliminate Equestrian magic from within.
Its like Cozy Glow said "I think big".


I think I can explain the difference in eye color and hair color/desighn; this might have been an early desighn for cozy glow, before they finalized the story and what was going to happen.


i was always suspicious of that story about the unicorns and starswirl raising the sun. theres no way they had that many unicorns for so long losing their magic. but maybe they did. i think the unicorns who gave up their magic were the same ones we see in rags in "a hearthswarming eve" they exhibit similar symptoms to victims of tirek. maybe not all, but this is probably a different kind of losing magic. we se only a few of them using magic, most of them don't. also, it would explain their stuck-up attitude. in the past, when most unicorns had their magic, unicorns believed themselves superior to earth ponies and pegasi, but suddenly they are on a level playing field with few exceptions. i also wondered how so many unicorns would be capable of this. i couldnt believe a regular unicorn could raise the sun if it was that difficult, even if they lose their magic. what if starswirl put a spell on them, allowing them to concentrate all their magical potential for their entire future timeline into one superpowerful, condensed spell? and once they cast it, all there future magic would be gone. this would explain both the fact that they lose magic afterwards (we've never seen an instance before where ponies are capable of performing a spell big enough that it takes their magic away) and the amount of ponies. most unicorns would have just been able to perform a few spells for their own talents (which i also doubt. its mostly just one KIND of magic, telekinesis, any  set of magic for their "talent" is basically being able to move stuff around. they might be able to perform spells, but only ones that relate to the unicorn's talent like in inspiration manifestation) so how could there be enough unicorns whos talent WAS magic to possibly raise the sun and then the moon every single DAY AND NIGHT? without my theory, the numbers don't add up. But also, making day would not just be raising the sun. let me explain. when rainbow dash describes the everfree forest, she mentions eerie goings ons such as well...regular stuff that happens every day. if that doesnt naturally happen on its own, then raising the sun wouldnt have changed if its day or night by itself. sure it would be light, but animals wouldnt know to wake up (winter wrap up) and birds wouldnt start singing, it wouldn't get warmer ect. (yes im aware the sun makes things warm, but im not sure thats how it works in the mlp universe) i think starswirl could raise the sun himself, he needed the others to cast spells that did all the other "changing it from day to night stuff" normal this might not be a big magical feat, but its all of Equestria we're talking about here. there was probably not just unicorns, but pegasi and earth ponies too giving up their magic. i doubt it would have been mentioned because of equestrias history of unicorn supremacy. thats right, this whole rant is a part of my conspiracy theory about my little pony racism. this probably makes no snese bc i didnt plan out what i was going to say. oh well


I didn’t even see her in the movie!<br>Now when I watch it again I’ll have my eyes looking for her in the movie!

I didn’t even see her in the movie!
Now when I watch it again I’ll have my eyes looking for her in the movie!


I don't see how she could be the human Cozy, because the logic of her being wanting ponies to no longer have magic because humans don't doesn't really work by the time season 8 is going.

By that point, in Equestria Girls, magic is becoming more commonplace in their world.

I'm sure, if our Cozy was the Human Cozy, she would've found a more useful way of manipulating the EQG world with magic than all the effort she'd have to put in to make her Equestria plan work instead.

I can definitely agree she could've wanted all Equestria's magic gone to stop spellcasters from having magic... but shows her ignorance there and how she really didn't do her research when Tirek is involved.

Season 4 should us Pegasi cannot fly without their own magic, which Cozy was also draining away.

If her plan was to put Pegasi above unicorns, her plans fail even they succeed, because Pegasi wouldn't be able to fly, manipulate clouds or control the weather anymore.

In this way, her plans were as simultaneously brilliant and unbelievably stupid as Cheese Legs' season 6 finale plan and Mean 6 plan.


I'm happy that u have made a theory about this because eversince I've re watched the first EG Movie, I was always keeping an eye on the girl in the background but as the next season of friendship is magic just came out I just realized that Cozy Glow might have a human counterpart (at first)


Can we all agree that Sawtooth’s thumbnails are iconic?


The human version of her (or rather, what we believe to be her) appears older than the Cutie Mark Crucaders, however, yet, as mentioned in the video, is clearly a filly in the show.


the sad thing is that this is probably the closest we'll get to a proper explanation of Cozy's motives


Studio: That's a cool color palette. Let's use it again.<br>Sawtooth Wave: HAH!! IT'S ALL CONNECTED!!

Studio: That's a cool color palette. Let's use it again.
Sawtooth Wave: HAH!! IT'S ALL CONNECTED!!


Hey Sawtooth! I have a theory for ya!
Remember season 9 episode 2 when Discord was pretended to be hurt? Who's to say that it was the only time he did it? What if the whole season 9 finale was his "grand plan"?

So here's what I think. Discord knew that the 3 villains stole the bell, and that they were plotting a backstab. When they used the bell to steal his powers, he just bent reality, making them think that hey stole his magic, then he pretended to be powerless the whole time, like with Sombra.

When they used the bell to give Cozy Discord's power, he knew they would be too powerful, so he bent reality (again) so that they can't use it. This would explain how Tirek could use Discord's powers back in season four, but not this time.

There was this one scene that nobody understood. The 3 villains blew a BIG hole in the side of the caslte, but they couldn't destroy that small rock that Rarity threw until Twighlight teleported? I smell lord of chaos training wheels here!

Then there was this scene, where Discord made Tirek angry, he shot a laser, and Discord misdirected it with a crystal. You are saying that after the lasers bounced everywhere, they missed everything, but it conveniently destroyed that ONE rock, making Starlight escape? Idon't belive you!

A lot of people were confused with chaos Pinkie. How did she know the spell for the bell? I think she didn't know it. Discord was just having fun.

So what do you think? Leave you toughts below in the replies!


I have a question that is not related to Cozy Glow. What would happen if a mythical creature, like the cerberus or tirek,  went Through the mirror? Would they be humans or animals ? What would happen if discord went Through the mirror?<br>Great video by the way!😜

I have a question that is not related to Cozy Glow. What would happen if a mythical creature, like the cerberus or tirek,  went Through the mirror? Would they be humans or animals ? What would happen if discord went Through the mirror?
Great video by the way!😜

Discord would basically die because the human world is too normal for him and his magic to co-exist, it would overwhelm him and well,,,bye-bye discord.


if you look closely,you can see that the "human"  cozy is the same height as the other people sitting at the sable,while the crusaders are a bit shorter. also in the human realm, people seem to wear their cutie marks as accessories and i feel like that star pin is her cutie mark


Ok please take me seriously when I say Cozy’s rise to power would have been the same way Hitler rose to power. Cozy was going to take advantage of the chaos that removing magic would cause and use it to become ruler of equestria. Hitler took advantage of the poor state Germany was in after WWI to rise to power. They both took advantage of the public in chaotic & hard times.


That's so smart! I never would've thought of that!!


Even though I don't watch my little pony any more I still love to watch these


honestly, i dont know how,, but i needed this video


Maybe cozy glow was good but the evil human came into the school of friendship instead of her...after seeing evil sunset shimmer


This was an interesting theory. It works out in two ways. However, I believe that this is the human Cozy Glow who traveled to equestria. The fact that she wants to remove magic to make things equal between ponies and humans makes so much sense, given her cutie mark as well because it's a chess board. She's leveling the board to make things equal. That's why she became an alicorn after getting evil magic. She wanted what they had but instead of bringing magic to the human world, she wanted to destroy magic in Equestria. She got angry once she realized that humans didn't have magic like ponies did, they lived in a ordinary world but Equestrians lived happily, making their dreams come true with magic. She wanted Equestria to suffer like how the human world suffered for a long time not having magic. Where's the original Cozy Glow? Probably hanging out with Human Sunset and human Starlight at a beach in Australia.


She actually looks beautiful like a human


I love your flower!

It’s pretty
Can I have one? 🥺

Btw I’m Fox nice to meet you


Studio: use same color palette<br>Sawtooth: THIS MEANS SOMETHING!!!!

Studio: use same color palette
Sawtooth: THIS MEANS SOMETHING!!!!

Ikr the hair doesn't have the white lines

@Coralline  right? The human doesn't have freckles either

They don’t even have the same eye color 😂

@Dejan Rajsic I know. Just pointing it out.

@The Weirdo Channel I know, but it was funnier to say it this way

Different eye colors hairstyles, a marron hair tie instead of a ribbon, and no freckles. Lots of differences he didn't point out.

The hair color is off too but I think he has a point

I stan too many groups! Check em out in my about


I want another video unpacking Cozy Glow’s past.


I swear I miss cozy glow they need to bring her back to the show


Why is Sawtooth Waves so downtrodden whenever he says Syannax and Farefallen's names?


It's entirly possible that the human "Cozy Glow" is Cozy Glow's older sister because the human "Cosy Glow" does not have freckles under her eyes and her hair is straight, as far as I can tell. Also she looks about the same age as Twilight also the fact that the human "Cosy Glow" has a star broach that is probably her cutie mark.
<br>Thanks for all the other comments, I put them all together for an idea for Sawtooth Waves.

It's entirly possible that the human "Cozy Glow" is Cozy Glow's older sister because the human "Cosy Glow" does not have freckles under her eyes and her hair is straight, as far as I can tell. Also she looks about the same age as Twilight also the fact that the human "Cosy Glow" has a star broach that is probably her cutie mark.
Thanks for all the other comments, I put them all together for an idea for Sawtooth Waves.


There might be good in her. 🎵Inside of every demon is a rainbow. Inside every sinner is a shiny smile. Inside of every creepy hatchet-wielding maniac is a jolly happy cupcake-loving child. We can turn them `round. They'll be heaven-bound. With just a little time down at the Happy Hotel.🎵

@MotherEater True, but that is multiple times.

@The Weirdo Channelyou’ve only seen 2 of them.

You always say the same thing in comment sections twice.

Actually, it was "devious, yet adorable"


I think the kingdom ruled before by cadance WAS the crystal empire and once princess celestia helped her and freed her from the love poison, celestia took over her kingdom. In the crystal empire episode when cadance came with the crystal heart a stallion yelled "here comes the crystal princess"

Please read @Sawtooth Waves


While cool I like the fact there were actual evil ponies. Like she was an antagonist as a pony very heart warming.


Sawtooth: have you ever looked at someone and wondered what’s going on inside their head?
Me: no-
Sawtoooth: thinks of crazy theory
Animators: we just thought the color scheme was nice-
THIS ISNT A HATE COMMENT I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS

Sawtooth: have you ever looked at someone and wondered what’s going on inside their head?
Me: no-
Sawtoooth: *thinks of crazy theory*
Animators: we just thought the color scheme was nice-
*THIS ISNT A HATE COMMENT I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS*


I think since our Cozy is the crusaders size the human one should've been a bit smaller, its possible she is Cozy' mother or aunt


Human cozyglow isn't real, she can't hurt you<br>Human cozyglow:

Human cozyglow isn't real, she can't hurt you
Human cozyglow:

The greatest lie the human Cozy Glow ever told was to convince the world she wasn't real.

@Shonade Malik I wasn't sure what to think of the :|.

@KingRaikou When did I say it was? I was just asking.

@Shonade Malik Do you think this is a problem?

@Shonade Malik I was making a follow-up to TheLord KingSim's use of the Skull Cow therapist meme. Nothing more.

@KingRaikou When you said: "Nah, just kidding," I thought the comment you replied on was your comment. Or is it?

@Shonade Malik No, this is my main. Why?

@KingRaikou Is this your other account you're talking with? Lol.

Nah, just kidding. She can totally hurt you. You're boned! Nyahahhahahahahahahaha! Heheheheh, ha, and I am so fired. But it was WORTH IT!

Nah, just kidding. She can totally hurt you. You're boned! Nyahahhahahahahahahaha! Heheheheh, ha, and *I* am *so* fired. But it was WORTH IT!


We've seen freckles are transdimensional. The human you claimed to be Cozy Glow didn't have the freckles, and yes, she looked older than the crusaders.


I was rewatching mlp season 9 episode 24 and noticed cozy's eye twitching at the timestamp 18:54. At first i thought it was an error in animation, but now I believe it was intentional. Maybe this proves your theory that Cozy hates magic?


I believe that it’s a bit too much of a stretch. Not mentioned she looks older than even the human CMC. I do think you’re right there behind her motivation and I love the depth that’s you’ve revealed. I love this theory even though I do not agree with it. Can’t wait to see more. ⭐❤⭐


one of my friends putted "im thirsty for human cozy glow" as their custom status in Discord and im worried


Given that for humans that young to act like this, you need your parents to treat you abhorrently up until around age 5, I'm guessing her parents are cruel beyond measure. Gaining power is her outlet to release all the betrayal and hurt from her younger self.


Do you think you could ever explain the young six’s respective elements?


Hey Sawtooth, can you go back on your video “the truth about FlurryHeart” and explain a new theory maybe because you said that they were artificial alicorns (cadence and Twilight) seeing as her hair flows in the last episode?

i don't think artificial alicorns are a thing anymore! check out my "alicorns!" playlist to see more recent takes


I may be four months late, and someone might've stated this before but
Cozy Glow, as said in the video, is supposedly still the same age as the Cutie Mark Crusaders, however most people bet that the CMC didn't help her get her cutie mark
Because as shown, Cozy Glow's cutie mark is a chess piece, and sure maybe she's just excellent at chess but there is more to that.
Chess is a game where you need to use wits and skills, try to interpret what your opponent's next move is. Of course the CMC wouldn't have known how to help with that kind of problem. Cozy Glow already planned this out, using trial and error, and who knows how many years that might've took, maybe she used the tactic Starlight used to cover up her cutie mark because she already mastered it even at a young age.
But that's beside the point, again, Cozy Glow's cutie mark is a chess piece and she purposely used her opponent's pawns against them, meaning she used the ponies to go against the Young Six and Starlight, and you may say it was because of her charms and it failed shortly after, but she planned more.
If this theory is correct (even if it may not) Cozy Glow in the human world might've looked prim, perfect and proper but as we said, it can all be part of her charms, meaning she may still be the crazily devious Cozy Glow we know and after finding out the magic exists through Sunset Shimmer she might have took after Twilight with her never ending curiosity and the video explains the rest.


I strongly agree. she even has a star saying "oh yeah i did good in class" anyone remember that in elamentry? you get a star?


Well in gen 5, Equestria lost its Magic somehow....can stone statues stay without magic? Perhaps Cozy had a ‘deadman’s switch’? And zipp and pipp were....royal.... Pegasi....


Part of me has to wonder tho. Since pony sunset  was evil do to the gain of magical power, would human sunset go evil too? With out the ability to use magic, what would human sunset turn out to be?


Yay YouTube isn’t broken. Great video sawtooth


All 3 races of ponies have magic though. While unicorns have the most obvious one (using their horns to cast spells), earth ponies have the most muscular strength out of the three and pegasi can't fly without magic as seen in the episode where Tirek steals magic.


She’s wearing a star, meaning that she’s most likely part of a student government. Rising to the top, just like in the pony world.


Did anyone notice that Cozy Glow's cutie mark is a chess piece, which symbolizes strategy, and that's exactly what Cozy's good at. Being strategic.


Now that I think about it.. I have a philosophical question.  How do ponies transform into a human (or from a human to a pony)once they enter a portal?  And what if.. They couldn't?


Expanding on Cozy being the anti Sunset. Since Sunset is said to displaced human Sunset causing her to be stuck in Equestria, its likely that Cozy caused her pony self to be teleported to the human world.


An interesting idea. But how would the supposed human Cozy have even learned about the School of Friendship's existence (let alone managed to enroll in it)?


So there's a good cozy glow in equestria...and the evil one.....I wish I can see the good one she could be adorable 🤍✨🧁


Let's suppose that cozy is from the human world, and you're right the similarities are too big to ignore but so are the differences. I think that cozy is from the human world the girl we saw is her SISTER and since sunset was defeated she wanted too know more about Equestria learning more about it she wanted to go there and that was the easy part since there was a portal to Equestria just in her schools front lawn, as you said if she got caught she could just charm herself out of the situation and then when she entered it would take a while for her to get used to it and once she did she got out of the castle and I don't know what could situation could go from here but I can say that my theory makes sense. Oh! and this is my first theory by the way, and I love your videos everything makes a lot of sense in them, keep up the good work!


i cant stop looking at the star pin/badge.. it just makes me think that if thats human cozy.. she could be part of some school counsil and thats why she come to the conclusion of friendship being power, like the school counsil could have the same view in things


Here me out! What if the human “cozy “ and pony cozy aren’t the same pony....BUT rather sisters who got separated cozy, cozy got banished to equestria like how sunset was banished to the human world, cozy became obsessed with magic trying to find a way back to the human realm to be with her sister but as time went on cozy became more and more obsessed with magic causing her to want to drain magic from equestria, OR keeping with that same theory that the human and cozy are sisters, cozy out of sadness for losing her sisters goes crazy wanting revenge and to rid everyone of the magic that banished her from her sister, NOW her sister on the other hand has no real memories of cozy (hence why she seems to not be interested in magic or power or anything)

How can we tell their sisters? Well they look almost identical to each other despite the hair and eye color


I'm not too fond of the late FIM villains. They just seemed a little too silly and self-aware.<br>Early MLP villains felt more like a genuine threat and were taken more seriously. Discord might be doing a lot of silly things but that was entirely by choice and he never described himself as evil. He kept to his own character and his silliness made him even more infuriating yet also more powerful.

I'm not too fond of the late FIM villains. They just seemed a little too silly and self-aware.
Early MLP villains felt more like a genuine threat and were taken more seriously. Discord might be doing a lot of silly things but that was entirely by choice and he never described himself as evil. He kept to his own character and his silliness made him even more infuriating yet also more powerful.


After watching this it gave me an idea, cozy’s plan was to rid all the ponies of equestria well in the gen 5 mlp (from what i currently know) the 3 pony races are split up and with no magic. What if cozy won and got rid of magic?


She wanted to go to equestria to become a unicorn and wield powerful magic, but crossed the border and found herself only a Pegasus. She was determined to find a way to be powerful in a world where she wouldn’t have raw magical ability.


when you think about it, Chancellor Neighsay was right, non-ponies DID use the magic of friendship as a weapon against a pony; just not in the way he thought. unicorns can be arseholes, at times, but he was summat else.


Cozy Glow is literally my favourite  pony (other than Pinkie and Twilight)


That is a really good theory Sawtooth, <br>There is one problem the human version of Cozy glow has a star badge and doesn't have frekles but the pony Cozy glow does? Pretty evil if you ask me and as you pointed out before this human version has a different hairstyle not only that their hairbands are different as well, this can't be Cozy glow because she has a chess cutie mark I tried searching the internet for Cozy's breed of mane but no luck... I think this human version could be Cozy's sister a twin sister perhaps?

That is a really good theory Sawtooth,
There is one problem the human version of Cozy glow has a star badge and doesn't have frekles but the pony Cozy glow does? Pretty evil if you ask me and as you pointed out before this human version has a different hairstyle not only that their hairbands are different as well, this can't be Cozy glow because she has a chess cutie mark I tried searching the internet for Cozy's breed of mane but no luck... I think this human version could be Cozy's sister a twin sister perhaps?


As a counterpoint, cause I like doing that,  in the episode “marks for effort”, she did seem genuinely sad for getting the crusaders in trouble, even though no one was watching her. (unless you want to say that she’s just keeping up her character) In contrast, this theory would require cosy glow to have basically already have a plan. How did her crying outside the crusaders treehouse (pretty sus tho) help further her plans? I know her whole thing is about making friends, but I feel like she had a much easier way of doing it than making this whole plan of how to get the crusaders into the school of friendship.


she’s the one who tried to take over eqestra how would she know how much the power of friendship has remember when twilight used then power of friendship


I agree with the fact that cozy is jelous of the power unicorns have thus turning herself Alicorn, perhaps the human 'cozy glow' is just the cost glow in the human world. I am still intrigued as though where human sunset is??


Yeah yeah that's interesting and all, but have you thought about Aria looking so similar to Starlight? They are exactly the same even un hairstyle (well, Starlight's hair tails were there when she was a filly so...)


I feel like she found the human world after sun set shimmer But how would she know about the human world And the eyes look the same colour and the hair is the same colour but not the same style

@Elizabeth Hutchinson thanks for the complement. 😊😊😊

@Rosella that is a good theroy wow I never thought of that

Hey, maybe Cozy Glow changed her hair or mane style in purpose, to avoid getting caught by Twilight. After all, Twilight is familiar with the similarities of the two worlds.

I just wish we can see the full out fit to see what the clothes look like but....if u look at cozys cutie mark then look at "human cozy* the clothes kinda look like the same colour as her cutie mark

The different style isn't really that strange, considering Sci-Twi having a ponytail and even wearing glasses.


3 comments)
1) I highly doubt that one human we saw in the cafeteria was Cozy Glow.
2) As for what drove her to do what she did in the season 8 finale she tried to get rid of magic because of obvious reason.  Creature like Unicorn, Alicorn, Centaurs or Changeling don't need army just to gain power.  They can just make their magic more powerful through something (like absorbing something or training).
3) As for Cozy Glow's origin story, I somehow think hers is very similar to most human origin stories in history or in many fictions or who know how many characters in the MLP FIM world.  As in maybe;
     a) She was probubly raised to be spoiled (like Veruca Salts from "Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory")
     b) She had family issues (like Diamond Tiara or Tirek).
     c) She probubly lost someone/something she was very close to (like how Starlight Glimmer thought she lost Sunburst or like how Tempest Shadow lost her horn) but that certain something from death.
     d) She gave into bad influences or misunderstood something (like Discord did to Tirek, Tempest Shadow did to the Storm King, or like how Stygian became the Pony of Shadows or how Luna became Nightmare Moon)
     e) Or I somehow think the most likely theory is she was from a society that treated her like trash just for existing (like how the locals from Cloudsdale treated Fluttershy, or how the Changelings treated Thorax, or how Rudolf was treated by "all of the other reindeers.")


I have given quite a bit of thought to the Cozy Glow arc as it is full of plot holes.  Your idea is a good one as to her origin.

However, I disagree with your version of her "plot" as it still does not make sense.   The problems not addressed are how was she able to correspond with Tirek?  Tirek stated he never met his protégé and it was done over several letters.  Also,  Celestia/Luna have a very loyal army and there is just no getting around that.   Even the ponies in Ponyville would have joined Celestia rather then her.   You could do a video on just trying to figure out how her "plot" actually works!

Here is the only one that seems to make sense with the facts and is pretty dark:

Per Tirek he carried out a pen-pal relationship with Cozy Glow, and since Tirek never met her before, someone else was delivering them. This could not be done through "normal" means as Tirek was in Tartarus.  To get the messages to Tirek would require action by someone of very strong magical power.  If you eliminate Celestia/Luna for obvious reasons (who would let anyone send letters to Tirek without reading them much less a child) then who is left?

Discord.

It makes sense.  He proved in season 9 he can access Tartarus.  Cozy Glow has no magic to lose and Discord could be conveniently absent when all the magic is sucked out of Equestria.  His backing would also answer the major problem of how Cozy Glow obtains rule.   Discord could return and pretty much do whatever he wanted (including fulfilling any sort of promise he made to Cozy Glow for her cooperation such as giving her a kingdom).

It would also explain why Discord suggested turning the villain's to stone for all eternity.  Cozy Glow can never point the finger (or hoof in this case) at Discord.


not to mention the "human" cozy has a star badge on her jacket<br>also is similar to pony cozy's when she was working in the school.

not to mention the "human" cozy has a star badge on her jacket
also is similar to pony cozy's when she was working in the school.


I don't think that the background character is Cozy Glow, they're too different. The only things they share are the same gender, blue hair and pink skin/coat.


Still, if you look closely, the eyes color is different, the human one is amber while cozy glow real eyes is red


You know maybe Cozyglow tried makeing friends in the past. But do to her being so  intelligent she has hard time  connecting with other poneys her age. So she feels isolated and alone. She feels that the only way to gain attention/"Freinds" is to manipulate and Control others.


Yep<br>Cozy is definitely that one unborn soul XD

Yep
Cozy is definitely that one unborn soul XD


I just want to tell Cozy the for the "get rid of magic" plan and the "drive earth ponies, pegasi and unicorns apart (which unleached windigos)" plan: what do you intend to eat afterwards?


Is the “intensely opportunistic” soul from Soul actually Cozy Glow? 🤔


Me to if only she was given a better story and nobody knows her back story or her parents are like why


She wanted more power so cute she came so she knew more fresh in the twilight and became more powerful break of now but she wanted to make friends and friends so she could be twilight and other Alacon that’s what I think she wanted


It's very possible that that is indeed Cozy as a human because how do you spell tends to make their Equestria girl characters look kinda different from their pony forms.

The most noticeable probs being Luna and Big Mac but most of there colour palettes are change slightly


If Cozy became an Alicorn, I think she'd be the princess of improvement/second chances


Regardless of whether that's human Cozy Glow or not, I still think your interpretation of her plan makes a lot of sense. I mean, she's just a Pegasus filly with no magic, but a lot of intelligence and charisma, so getting rid of all magic in Equestria would make it easy for someone like her to gain power...especially if she was in charge of Twilight's School of Friendship and ponies started to see her as Twilight's successor.


There is another scene of cozy from equestria girls. Its when they do that dance with pony ears and tails at the cafeteria. You can see her sitting next to DJ pon 3 when applejack takes off her glasses


i am 100% convinced the cozy is the reason gen 5 Equestria has no magic and why the pegasi have a queen now. If she can't be an alicorn, she can be the queen of the pegasi.


What about this idea? She tried to sneak out of the castle and was caught by the guards, but they were forced to let her go because of unfavorable press from both at home and abroad.


The thing I like about her is that she actually is not dumb like other villains, like she had everything planned out, I mean she can solve 22/7<br>(Pie) 😅😅😂😂😂😂

The thing I like about her is that she actually is not dumb like other villains, like she had everything planned out, I mean she can solve 22/7
(Pie) 😅😅😂😂😂😂


Cozyglow really was a human being, infact- she went to the pony world to take the magic, and bring to the human world so everyone in the human world would bow to her royalty and the cozyglow that is in the pony world, is a clone from the lake. This is the real story of cozyglow, she wasn't going to rule only Equestria, but she also wanted the human world so she will be known at both dimensions.

Soon after the clones of pinkie were back at the lake, I feel like cozyglow found out that the lake existed. After her defeat, I feel like she wanted the magic more than anything. So she went to the lake, then cloned herself, then one stayed in Equestria and the other to the human world. Pls pin this


Hang on a second...

In the alternate timelines Starlight Glimmer made in the episode “The Cutie Re Mark”, the mane 6 have the sane cutie marks as they do in the main timeline (In the Queen Chrysalis timeline, you can see all of them). But if the mane 6 got their cutie marks at the same time due to the sonic rainboom, which i believe supposedly never happened in this timeline, how do the mane 6 have the same cutie marks??


If she were from the human world, another layer of motivation could be that she expected to be a unicorn or creature capable of using magic and spellcasting, but instead came out a pegasus. This would prompt her to have to level the field for any semblance of real power, and gives her hatred of others having what she lacks a little more depth. She came here just to use magic and have power, and if she can't have it, then she'll make these creatures suffer without it as well.


backup for my theory:<br>cozy glow had a deal with chrysalis, which is not a reformed changeling. Chrysalis would enter equestria, with cozy glow commanding her, so what she says, how she acts, everything, (maybe through some sort of ear piece or spell) while Real cozy glow would be spying on twilight and the mane 6 in general. but, canterlot happend WAY before cozy glow, so i think that chrysalis was that pinkie pie clone, in rarity's manehattan shop.she could have been a different pony, but, nevertheless, pinkie has the easiest job from all the mane 6, and she was only known in ponyville, NOT in manehattan. cozy glow, in the human world, might have started searching for other people that were powerfull ponies in equestria, but her plan was ruined by sunset shimmer and everything. so, cozy cut her deal with chrysalis, leaving her empty handed, and returning to the pony world a while later. That also sort of explains why when cozy glow and chrysalis teamed up, they were rlly mean & sort of, distant, maybe bcs they knew each other....

backup for my theory:
cozy glow had a deal with chrysalis, which is not a reformed changeling. Chrysalis would enter equestria, with cozy glow commanding her, so what she says, how she acts, everything, (maybe through some sort of ear piece or spell) while Real cozy glow would be spying on twilight and the mane 6 in general. but, canterlot happend WAY before cozy glow, so i think that chrysalis was that pinkie pie clone, in rarity's manehattan shop.she could have been a different pony, but, nevertheless, pinkie has the easiest job from all the mane 6, and she was only known in ponyville, NOT in manehattan. cozy glow, in the human world, might have started searching for other people that were powerfull ponies in equestria, but her plan was ruined by sunset shimmer and everything. so, cozy cut her deal with chrysalis, leaving her empty handed, and returning to the pony world a while later. That also sort of explains why when cozy glow and chrysalis teamed up, they were rlly mean & sort of, distant, maybe bcs they knew each other....


Maybe Cozy Glow was originated from the Human World and saw what Sunset Shimmer did, and might've seen Twillight go through the portal to Equestria. When the portal was open, Cozy Glow went through the portal without anyone knowing and acted nice. When it was the right time to show her dark side, she did what Sunset Shimmer wanted to do.

My peanut sized brain! ;-;


A good theory. I also think that she's from another dimension, because she said to Starlight "You ponies..." She didn't include herself with. I also don't think that she is a child. Diamand Tiara is an example of a mean child, but she wasn't evil. We never saw an evil filly in MLP before. I think that she took the form of a cute filly to seem innocent and harmless. I like your theory, it's sounds plausible. ^^


Here is another theory does anyone else remember when the sirens where in the human world but they originally came from equestria? This could mean the opposite for cozy she could've came to equestria after the sirens were destroyed  wich would make sense since she saw how the sirens were able to control people giving cozy motivation to do the same!!


If she was meant to be Cozy Glow, she would look more simillar.


That girl from the human world had a few more scenes. I also agree with you.


I could see that adorable little filly in the human world causing mischief


I just realized that Cozy Glow is a FILLE who is evil. Adorable but Deadly. Fun fact: I think that is Cozy Glow because of how similler they look. Also I want to know Cozy Glow's origin like why did she became evil in the first place.


The eye color wouldn’t be an issue, considering how different Big Mac’s skin is between the two realms


Cozy in the human world what could go wrong....Absolutely everything


If the fan character Snowdrop was in the show How could her story fit in?


So many things bothered me with Cozy Glow. Not her character, but just how she was treated.

I was so bothered they locked her in tartauras, we never got a backstory from her, and in the end, they turned a literal child into stone. I mean, yeah she did bad things, but yeah, let’s trap the child in stone. I feel like Cozy Glow should have at least gotten a chance.

I can tell I’m not the only one who thinks this.


Honestly I don't think Cozy Glow originally wanted to drain the magic and throw it away I think that originally she wanted to take all of the magic and use it for herself but Starlight getting trapped in the magic messed it up and Cozy just acted like she wanted magic gone


i actually like villains when they dont have a redemption arc

@Black Swan ohhhh yah. Sorry YouTubes notif.

@Hailey Johnson She didn't need a redemption arc. I was replying to the original comment, not yours.

@Black Swan no she didn’t what? Get frozen in stone? Yah. Yah she did in the final episode?

Tbh I love how devious and evil she is. Not all villains in this show need to be saved. So even with her being frozen in stone being kinda sad and cruel, some villains not being saved is pretty real


What if in G5 cozy glow actually succeeded in draining all the magic? And G5 is an alternative universe.


This video majorly helps out a theory I'm working on.


I actually like this theory but,since she looks a little too old so, I see her maybe as a sister or relative lol <3


I don't think we saw her in EG since she would have had shown signs of being manipulative and influent already, which doesn't appear to be the case, since that's Sunset's thing. Doesn't mean she can't still be from there, though.


Cozy glow would easily outsmart Sunset Shimmer


So Cozy Glow successfully remove magic until now in G5?


i mean. this does grant us alot of awnsers. especially if you take into account her saying AND I QUOTE   Cozy "that's the problem with all you magic users, your so reliant on your special powers you forget to use your brain!" in this light, we can see that cozy had a different idea of a "better equestria"/"her type" of equestria. listen for a moment, no matter what world our cozy is from, they both seen magic. they both had the opertunity to see a magic user get defeated. thinking it was because they were reliant on magic, she formed a strategy to get rid of magic. when that didnt work. she started to use magic to overpower the other magic users. again, thinking first, and not just flying in with power. i quote again "now i have more power than all of you" i dont think she was just talking about tirek and queen chrysalis. but i think ive said to much. just think about that when you try and figure out her backstory and her motive.


I feel like that person would be cozyglows older sister since the cutie mark crusaders are a bit smaller then the others humans, and that would also explain the slight differences. Unless they are twins.


I wont even be surprised if Crazy Glow was some other realm creature that came to Equestria as an innocent looking child (probably to gain the ponies's trust) to rule that realm


Maybe Cozy Glow was from CHS and after seeing(Demonic Sunset Shimmer,The magic of Twilight Sparkle's crown,The Magic of Friendship, And the Portal)and how much Attention Twilight got for knowing about it, And got a little Jealous and Manipulative, So with the knowledge of Magic and the Portal,She would want to follow her Rival/Twilight Sparkle, and got more knowledge of Magic <br>Booya(

Maybe Cozy Glow was from CHS and after seeing(Demonic Sunset Shimmer,The magic of Twilight Sparkle's crown,The Magic of Friendship, And the Portal)and how much Attention Twilight got for knowing about it, And got a little Jealous and Manipulative, So with the knowledge of Magic and the Portal,She would want to follow her Rival/Twilight Sparkle, and got more knowledge of Magic
Booya(


Your Videos are great plus your pony shape is great


How cozy became rogue theory:

Her parents are a father pegasus, and a mother unicorn, and she has a sister older than her, her sister is a unicorn, with blue straight hair, yellow eyes, and a yellow star cutie mark. Her parents would notice her sister more than she was notice, this causes her to hate magic slowly becoming the cozy we know. All because of her parents not noticing her.

Her sister has a talent in magic and performs amazing magic tricks.


Hey swatooth waves i have a theory that might finally solve the age old question on why twilight sparkle and moon dancer look so simaler. Would you mind when i make my video if i mention you for sorta sparking my thearoy of this years ago?


Last thing you said about original pony Cozy just gave me crazy idea... what if not everypony has their human version? Could they be clones or some of them just died or lived AGES ago???


one minute in and I can all ready debunk Cozy being the human in the cafeteria but lets see where you go whit this.

ok having seen this to the end, I reiterate: the human in the cafeteria in NOT Cozy Glow.
Motivation presanted: vary good
Hair/mane stile: changeable
Color palet: the one flaw, dismissable
The ONE thing that canot be dissmised and is in fackt imutable is her cuti mark.
The human in the cafeteria promanatly display a button whit a five pointed yellow star. Not a brown rook.
Every human display their cutie mark on thier clothe trough ether embroyded or a button.


Is she Cozy Glow?
Simple answer: No.
The Human and Pony Versions of the Characters look different, because they are different Species, but you always can see the Pony in them.
There are some simple Rules for every Char in Equestria Girls:
1. Similar or identical Hairstyle
2. Identical Colors for Hair/Mane, Skin/Coat and Eyes
3. Visible Cutiemark

The 3. is the most important, often the only Way to Identify a Char.
Every Char has the Cutiemark somewhere on the Outfit, as Belt, as Button, as Patch, Hairpin or Print.

Lets look on this Girl:
Same Hairstyle: No
Same Haircolor and Shading: No (the Dark Stripes are missing:
Same Skincolor: Yes
Same Eyecolor: No (Cozys Eyes are described as "Moderate Scarlet" or Red, the Girl has more Apple Blooms "Brilliant gamboge" or Orange)
Cutiemark visible: Not the Same (Cozys CM is a Rook, The CM of the Girl is a yellow Star, easy visible on her Button)

The MLP Wiki identify her as "Unnamed Girl #1" with this Description:

Has a character design similar to that of "Sophisticata" and a color scheme similar to those of Cozy Glow, "Candy Floss", Zappityhoof, S04E22 Unnamed Earth Mare #11, and Issue 40 Unnamed Filly - Heart Flower.

https://mlp.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_Equestria_Girls_characters#Unnamed_Girl_.231

So with this, your Theory is refuted.
That Girl is just a unnamed Background Char, like so many other too.

The only the Girl has in common are the bright Blue of the Hair- and the Skincolor.
Everything else is different.
A Girl like in your Video at 1:30 would be a Look who would fit, maybe with a Button with her CM and Cess as her Talent.

It is a bit like Sunset Shimmer.
As we know, there's no human Counterpart of her or she couldn't stay in that World (like Twilight said, a World can't have 2x the same Person).
So theres maybe no Cozy in this human World or Human Sunset and Cozy are in an different Part of the World.

The Explainations of Cozys Mind is nice, but the Girl just is eating a Burger.
As Cozy, she would act more like Sunset Shimmer at the Begin of EQG.
She would act like a Bully, not sitting there like Fluttershy.

I don't think too, she is an Human in Equestria.
The most don't know there's a Portal, so maybe just Sunset can activate the Portal with her "Key" (the Journal she use to write with Twilight).
I don't think the Portal is active all the Time, or any Person could just fall in it by accident.
Sunsets Book contact the Journal, Twilight has on the Portal Device and activate the Portal from the Equestria Side.
Until the Machine is running, the Surface is just solid Stone, not a Portal.


While I don't think that is Cozy in that frame. The possibility is interesting, maybe she feel through one of the tears Midnight Sparkle ripped open and caused her to fall into it. She could remember what happen during the first movie and Rainbow Rocks and being thrown into the other world by what she thinks is one could just be the last straw for her.


“Her goal being to drain all of the magic in equestria.”

wait. In the new gen 5, didn’t it say the same thing? There is no magic in equestria? What if it had something to do with Cozy Glow? It’s kind of a dumb theory, but at the same time it makes sense.. other than the fact that Cozy was turned to stone, and gen 5 is supposed to be waaaayyyy in the future.

BUT! What if it IS cozy!!! What if she was just in stone for a very long time, then turned back just like discord was! The only difference being that Cozy got her way and now equestria has no magic 🤔

“Her goal being to drain all of the magic in equestria.”

*wait.* In the new gen 5, didn’t it say the same thing? There is no magic in equestria? What if it had something to do with Cozy Glow? It’s kind of a dumb theory, but at the same time it makes sense.. other than the fact that Cozy was turned to stone, and gen 5 is supposed to be waaaayyyy in the future.

BUT! What if it IS cozy!!! What if she was just in stone for a very long time, then turned back just like discord was! The only difference being that Cozy got her way and now equestria has no magic 🤔


Sawtooth: posts top tier theory
Me: adds content of theory to mental folder labelled "canon until proven otherwise"

Sawtooth: *posts top tier theory*
Me: *adds content of theory to mental folder labelled "canon until proven otherwise"*


the theory is interesting <br>i want to learn more about gozy glow

the theory is interesting
i want to learn more about gozy glow


Hey Sawtooth.
I'm wondering about the reboot. Are you going to be CGI?! That will be crazy how are you going to deal with it. or is it a multi verse thing... Oh I support you on Patreon as well!
Maybe you should a video on that! (Or not if your busy doing other thing)
Happy to here a reply as well!(Don't have to its your choice)
From Hand Crafted Gamers


i actually think both cozy and sunset killed their other selves. Sunset may have thought the other sunset was a shapeshifter, and cozy may have wanted to take the place of the real cozy glow. these are just some of my theories tho. I have others that are more backed up by the lore of the show :l


When you said it would be the perfect playground for cozy it’s just like discord if he was still evil but here’s a question is discord’s evil side all gone because he did mess up with bringing crisilis tereck and cozy together and partnering up with tereck in the first place and what if there is a human or dog or other kind of animal discord in the human world but we don’t know it?


If Cozy Glow met Principal Cinch, they'd prove to be a disastrous, tyrannical duo.


I always thought cozy was kind of a strange villain because unlike the others she didn't really have any problem to decide to be evil but this theory explains it😁. Thanks for that and I love your vedios🤩


I don't think that cozy glow but at least we got to knew her motives great job👍🏼👍🏻👍👍🏿👍🏾


One thing I noticed is that the ages of ponies aren’t consistent with their human counterparts (ex: twilight being a teenager despite in equestria her being around early 20s) so cozy glow being too young doesn’t make it wrong, just ages in the portal change


I have a question not a thought when gen five comes out are you going to do therorys on them to or are you just going to stick with gen 4? I love you theories btw! Just wondering


Wait but the other cozy glow got turned into stone. You would think we saw missing people paper on equestria on the series...


Your videos are always such a new view into the MLP universe! How do you come up with these things?


I think that some of the reformed villains Are each other in a way. The ones with similar stories could be the other world equivalent I'm I'm going mad!


It would be awesome if cozy glow was a human


actually

I watched the video where you spotted the “human cozy glow” sawtooth thinks. And I’m that video before she appeared eating a burger, I saw someone the same like human cozy glow, same hair stable and there’s also that star badge on her jacket, but different colors.

Then today I watched my little pony equestria girls rainbow rocks shorts (dj pon 3) at 0:18 and there was the “human cozy glow “ sitting at an outdoor table and chewing on her burger with a blue hair guy there too. And I also found out the exact like “Human cozy glow “ with brown hair , and their name is sophisticata.


What’s weird is that when I first watched rainbow rocks for some reason human cozyglow really stuck out to me


That is possible. Though I think there might be more going on. Where are her parents? It's explained how each child is being taken care of except her. I think that she might have wanted to level the playing field because her parents were killed by a magical explosion that occurred when Sunset became a she-demon. Maybe she was planning this all along and didn't mention it because she didn't want to feel weak.