10 years ago, this is a beautiful song, all that we acomplished, that we transform.  Its still a heart warming song.


Pinkiepieswear, though you'll never read this comment, I just wanted to thank you. I want to thank you for how much you've impacted my childhood. Ever since I joined this fandom (December 2011), I've always enjoyed the small amount of songs you out out. Listening to all your music again is- it's like a experience like no other; all your songs were and and still are so atmospheric and packed with nostalgia.. My eyes are too teary for me to even see what I'm even  typing so I'mma stop here.

I hope to whoever reads this comment, you can see where I'm coming from.

mrmannster I understand stand to; feeling the exact same way.


I've listened to this a total of 1747 times according to itunes. I listen to this when I have trouble sleeping. It's a really relaxing song and brings back feelings of nostalgia when I listen to it. Thank you for making this.


When fall starts to come on, I get this ridiculous shift in mood. I go from a hyper, talkative, headbanging, crowd-pleasing ball of energy to an incredibly reserved, mellow, and less emotionally stable guy. I don't know what it is, but it's this time of year where songs like this make me feel so at peace with everything. Thanks for this PPS.


This song is without a doubt my favorite and the most beautiful song i have ever heard.

Whenever i listen to it i want to turn out the lights and sit still letting the music flow through me. I cannot convey how amazing this song is to me. Thanks you.


Powerful and moving. This kind of music separates merely regurgitated remixes from real artists. You're moving hearts, and that's what it's all about. Thank you.


This deserves so much more acknowledgement than it's received, it's a gorgeous piece!


I listen to this song on repeat whenever I can't sleep.  It's so beautiful and pure, and it brings my mind to a place of tranquil simplicity.  Thank you so much for this song.


This song is pretty amazing, feeling like it can be in a very awesome game world, beautiful surroundings, heavenly day,etc. Fits it perfect


This is the most beautiful song I ever heard. The emotions in the rhythm is so pure and caressing, absolutely a master piece.

im going to comment so you can be reminded to hear it once more


So relaxing... what a beautiful song! Perfect for thinking about how amazing and stunning space is.


Lovely work. The main transition at 0:43 and the chorus are both very nicely layered. You rock!


This song is amazingly beautiful.  It's slow but mixed with various emotions. Happiness, but also sadness and it made me miss the people I miss the most in the world that already left or live far, far away. I'm literally crying right now. PinPie, I thanks you for making such an amazing composition. It has touched me like no other song has before.


One of the things I love the most about ponies is that they inspire people like PinkiePieSwear to create such beautiful works of art as this.


This song is so beautiful, I'm glad I found it again. It's so peaceful and ethereal, I really love it a lot.


I love this song.  it feels like i have been waiting for a song like this for years.  and i have finally found it.  its a song that can bring peace to a hurt heart.


This is the only song that I can seem to be able to concentrate while writing. Its calm and yet so full of passion. Great work!


Wow. This is really incredible. It has that sound that I love in music. It' hard to describe. I could use the word ephemeral but there are other songs that are ephemeral without this particular quality. The closest I can get it saying it has a glassy, crystal sound to it. But whatever the case, I love this song. Pretty much perfection.


Stumbled across this again after all these years. Thanks for the memories man.


This is immensely beautiful. When I try to fall asleep at night and I can't most nights, I listen to this song and look at the night sky through my window. I cry sometimes, but that's only because the beauty of the song and how I want to live in their world.


I'm having a little girl in December and I've started putting together a playlist of calming music (Her name is Celes, so of course the first song that went on the list was Celes' Theme from FFIV)  After finding this song, I have since added it to my list.  As a almost new Mommy, I thank you for a beautiful song that I've already started playing to my daughter.  :)


five years later and I still love this song.


When I close my eyes while listening to this and focus on the sounds, colors fill my inner eye.  The colors of autumn; the warm and vibrant hues of red, orange, yellow, and smidgets of cool green and blue so subtle they are barely noticed, but without them there would seem to be something significant missing.  I doze off even more to think about sunsets and the arrival of the stars staring down upon me on a cool autumn night spent the beach alone with just nature to accompany me.

Then it ends.


As soon as the first note hit my attentive ears, my mouse hit the subscribe button that was ever so near.

You got some serious skills my friend and that goes without saying. I eagerly await your next song with great anticipation.

These words I say are no understatement, thumbs up if you agree with this conversation.


Jeez, it's been so long since I last heard this song.  Man, it makes me want to get back into writing fan stories.


Why doesn't this have more views? This is by far my favorite song out of PinkiePieSwear! It's so soft and soothing, makes me think of a night sky with all the stars shimmering like the beautiful jewels they are. <3!

You are more than welcome! Even after all these years this remains my favored song out of the fandom. <3!


One of my all-time favourites. Absolutely beautiful music


Without even a shadow of a doubt, this is my most favorite song of all time.

Not even like pony song. Out of every genre of music, every piece I have heard, this is the most beautiful song I have ever.

I want to thank you for creating this.


this song... makes me think of everything beautiful that has ever existed and ever will exist. it makes me believe that life is truly precious. it is a masterpiece.


This song is just what I needed after having a rough day.
Thanks.


Listening to this song and reading some of the Luna comments, makes me think of her story in the 1st episode. All she wanted was some appreciation for the work she did on the night, maybe, just maybe. If Luna had a friend that appreciated her, like in the White Eclipse comic, then things might have been different for her.


Lovely piece, it reminds me of being around the edge of the atmosphere, where all you see is the  bright blue glint of the planet, and the endless dark sky.


Not many pieces of music make me well up with emotion, even fewer make me cry.
You didn't make me cry, Pinkiepieswear, but you came pretty damn close.


Listened to this song while looking at the full moon. This really captures the mood. serenity and peace.


This song in  particular is on my sleeping playlist. Probably shouldn't comment on each and every video you create, but I can't restrain my joy that I feel for your hard work.

ALL of your songs to date were on Equestria Daily's 'Best Of' compilation music post (5Gs worth of music); I think that's saying something.


This is just gorgeous. Thankyou for creating it! <3


I closed my eyes and turned this song on. I was crying about everything bad in my life. Luna came to comfort me with a soft smile. I open up to her about my whole life and how I wanted it escape and stay near her, being comforted and cared for. She tells me to look up, and when I do she paints me a beautiful night sky unlike any ive ever seen. All I can do is look at it, tears flowing down my cheeks. I hug her tightly and cry my eyes out, telling her to never leave.

I'm crying while typing this


I'll listen to this the next time I'm off to admire LUna's wondrous night sky. Thanks a thousand times for this.


Your other songs were good, but this one is beyond amazing!  Keep up the good work!


I need a hour long version of this. THIS IS AMAZING.


This song is so incredibly amazing. Next time I'm home this is getting blasted across the house.


Possibly my ABSOLUTE favorite Brony song EVER! Been listening it for years now since I first hear it on a Brony music channel. Now I whistle that song to the moon whenever I feel like it, like a prayer to Luna. :3 In my Adventure Fantasy, as a thanks.


This is hauntingly beautiful. I love it! Especially the part at the beginning. Is that supposed to be any particular instrument? Because I think I've heard something like that, but I can't remember what it's called.


a song so beautiful needs to have some lyrics to it, luna deserves such! all hail the NLR, i regret nothing!


So beautifully atmospheric... Keep on making more,  this is so elite!


This is a very beautiful song and it is very soothing!


Whenever the weather is proper and the skies are clear, I really enjoy the hobby of star-gazing. Clears the mind and relaxes you like you would never believe. Every time I do my gazing, I always play this song at least once. It feels new every time I listen to it.

Does anyone know if there's some type of genre that has songs like this one? Or perhaps point me towards an artist like PPS?


i could listen to this all day long its so relaxing


I played this and the New Lunar Republic theme during the Blood Moon Eclipse. It was amazing and it actually made me tear up a bit listening to this song again.


This song is AWESOME in a really calm kinda way. I love it.


its a calming almost haunting melody, you sir, are a genius, keep up the excellent work. +Fav


Oh Matt R, Won't you fill my empty sky again?

Lucy Logan no, she/he just meant that she/he wanted him to come back.


Good Sir... . I'm glad I stumbled across you.. if not I would have never heard this magnificent song you have created. Thank you. 🙇


Man, where i live you can occasionally see the northern lights. This is my first time hearing the song, and the lights appeared for the first time in a year just now. I'm pretty sure something magical just happened. Thanks for the most beautiful scene I have ever been a part of.


This is amazing...
so relaxing...
You have done an AMAZING job with this, brony


Watching the clear night sky with no stars and a small sliver of the moon while listening to this is amazing


Sir or Ma'am, you have won at life. All of your songs are amazing, and I love them.


How did I manage to find this only just now? And I thought you couldn't get any better in my eyes, PinkiePieSwear.
Welp, time to get some sleep to this on loop.


Yay, I found it again. I was afraid I'd lost this beautiful piece.


Idk if anyone of you have read the story "My Little Dashie," but I listened to this through the whole entire story. Oh my god it was just so emotional that I couldn't stand it. If you haven't read the story I suggest you do. PinkiePieSwear, thank you for making such a beautiful song. The music is so touching that it's hard to believe. Please, keep up the great work *bro-hoof*


This is a song of misunderstanding, sadness and hidden beauty, brings a tear ta' tha' eye it does. at least, that's what I take from it, everyone interprets what they will, but it is inspiring nonetheless.


Such beautiful serenity...
My soul ressonates...with this melody...


What a gorgeous song.  Just the thing I need to help me drift off to sleep.


No words can describe the beauty of this. No words.


As soon as this started playing I stopped everything I was doing and just relaxed, amazing music.


OMG this song is soo lovely! Sounds like new age music! Keep it up bro!


luna is by far my most favorite pony. She only shows up twice in the entire show so far..pretty sad. But for some reason for a pony that doesn't show up that much, there sure is a bunch about her that people know. I really want her to start showing up in later episodes. :l


I always thought of Luna and Nightmare Moon as two separate ponies, kind of like Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. This is why Luna was so quick to accept her sister's friendship. The hatred, anger, and jealousy caused her to transform into NMM, and because of NMM decision to try and make night last forever, Luna was trapped on the moon for 1000 years. 1000 years of solitude, save her  feelings of bitter hate and contempt. That's why I find Luna to be a victim.


I was so caught up in how amazing this song is, I almost forgot to like!!~ <br><3 Great job, PinkiePieSwear!

I was so caught up in how amazing this song is, I almost forgot to like!!~
<3 Great job, PinkiePieSwear!


Thank you. it is lovely. Now If I could only get Octavia and Lyra into the same orchestra to perform it at the Palace some evening.


When I was done with the video and it was about half way, I wanted to click the youtube homepage button but this song is so compelling, so beautiful that I just had to finish it and I literally couldn't click away from this video and I instantly clicked like and favorite.


Peacefulls songs make me happy, but this one is more special than the others i usually hear. :)


This is very beautiful and lovely sounding isn't it?


This kind of reminds me of the "Dearly Beloved" track from the Kingdom Hearts games, the one that plays in the main menus. I always thought it was very beautiful, and so is this.


Luna would be pleased, and found humming this to herself as she guides the moon and shapes the stars of the sky for those of us who love the night.


Actually, the popular fan perception is that it wasn't Luna at all. She was 'posessed' by some outside force like Discord or the Windigos that feeds on envy and insecurity. Those feelings were so strong in her that it was able to take her over and force her to do what she did. Of course the creators have wisely left out most of the details and left us to make up our own minds, but that would explain why she was so different so suddenly after being defeated as nightmare moon.


This would be a good sleepy song. It sounds so relaxing!


very good song and very relaxing. i hope you make a few more like that.


I'm listening to this 24/7 till the luna episode comes. <3


this is so gorgeous and the sky and the gorgeous music and the draw!


I totally want to play this to a non-brony, and when he asks what game or anime this is from... BAM!!! Ponies! ◔ᴗ◔

+richfiles <br>I actually did that. X3 the person did not believe me for a long time.

+richfiles
I actually did that. X3 the person did not believe me for a long time.


Beautiful, good sir.  Simply beautiful.  I can picture the night sky and the many stars so vividly.  *Big Brohoof*


PinkiePieSwear: 20% more creativity, love, and sweat per track than any other Brony musician.


This has to be one of my favorite songs of all time.


wow, I haven't listened to this in years, nostalgic happiness


This song, along with Flutterwonder and derpidety's "The final fall of the lunar republic (solemn century edition)", are proof of how awesome the brony community is.


This song reminds of the rare moments of peace in dark times long past.
Y'see, my dad is technically my stepfather. My REAL father was a jerk. As in, wife-beating, child-beating jerk. Anyway, those times were not pleasant. But, there were times when my Mom would draw at her art table. While she drew, she would play Yanni or Enya CDs. My sisters and I would sit underneath the table when she did this because we felt safe there.
Thank you for this song, this reminder of hope in the darkness.


This one is really nice. Makes me wish I was a Pegasus so I could sit on a cloud and stare at the moon.


This is my new favorite song to fall asleep to :)


I'm crying because this is so beautiful... You are very talented.


I'm glad i'm not the only one crying when I listen to this song


Amazing It's just so amazingly breath-taking and I always love the Asian inspired music


Ya, she's my favorite of the "background" ponies, outclassing even Derpy... I'd love love to see her in another episode..


This is amazing Brony. Incredibly amazing, great job.


I feel like this should be about 10 minutes longer :D


I love this song. It feels like something you'd hear in Clannad.


This is so beautiful. Reminds me of the Observatory from Majora's Mask.


This is one of the few songs that hasn't made me feel sad in relation to Luna. c:


Sooooooooo beautiful!
So gonna put this on my iPod! I just love relaxing songs.


if they ever make a MLP movie, I want PinkiePieSwear to score it


It sounds like a Legend of Zelda temple... Absolutely beautiful.


This song is so beautiful, and I fee represents Luna so well...

Now to wait until October 22nd! Not that far away now! :D


Beautiful. It's like the music of Kingdom Hearts. Omigosh, that makes it even more correct because Luna is of royalty.


this is really amazing, your songs are trully awesome!


For some reason, this was always my favorite of his songs...


This is just breathtakingly beautiful.  This is an original composition?


This is so awesome. I feel like, if I was more emotional right now, it would make me cry for real. ;o;


I love this song. It's inspired lot's of my artwork. ^.^


I've been waiting to find the perfect sleep music.
I just found it.


last week i went to the atacama desert (im in Chile), we were right there watching the stars while i was listening this song. Let me tell you... i cried for all the happy feelings in that moment, an experience that i never had TT^TT


sounds like music from PWI without so much of the asian theme =D great job keep it up...in fact your mixes have inspired me to try some of my own.


I was hoping for a Luna dialogue remix, but this is quite pretty.


Since (at least for what i seen) nobody said it, I'll do it... You're song is magnificent...


Honestly, I just wanted people to be awake to see the beauty.  I am not sure why the sun is loved more than the moon, but I suppose it is all right - my dear sister is the eldest anyhow, and deserves more of the attention.  She is more fit to be a ruler than I.


Wow! I had this amazing vision of shooting stars, flying pegasi and being high above the clouds. It was like a dream.


Has this been on EQD yet? It really needs to be.


damn... just listening to this song makes my eyes teary for some reason


Do you have any sheet music lying around for this song. It's such a beautiful song and all I want to do is play it on my piano at night.


I know man I've recently gone through a break up and I've been so panicky and couldn't get any sleep but last night was so beautiful and clear and that made me so relaxed that I stayed awake the entire night just looking at the stars just thinking and resting and I felt so calm and collected the next day


Its just... Wonderful... I can barely find words.. Thank you Pinpie..


-Having a crappy day
-Plays this song
-All is right with the world


I never thought I could fall in love with a song... This just happened to this song.
Love it, love it, LOVE IT!!!!!
(no homo, btw.)


The melody .. I love it.. it makes me wanna cry ... :')


If somepony were to make a 1-hour loop of this song, I would die a happy man ;-;


Man, i just love this song, so great, like you make amazing songs like this and its pretty cool :D


It sounds like a song from Bejeweled. So relaxing.


i listened to this over and over while reading my little dashie....the crying has been doubled


At least for those thousand years, I spent it on something I loved.
The moon was and still is one of my only salvations in the land of Equestria.  The only thing else I am able to think of is Twilight Sparkle and her wonderful friends.  I could not believe, however, that my sister would do such a terrible thing for such a small crime.. though I have learned.  And thanks to the little ponies of Ponyville, I have learned to accept her faults... and mine.


Thanks for reminding me puttin' this song on my Mp3-player. So when i go outside tonight for a little midnightwalk i will listen to this song when i lie down on the way and look up in the stars.


sounds like something Nobuo Uematsu would compose. Good job bro!


When bronies make music that isn't overarchingly techno, I am spellbound.

Bravo.


I can actually imagine laying beneath a starry sky that is just filled with mystery and wonder when I listen to this song.  Awesome, more songs for calm nights.


Luna rejected her sister and tried to bring never-ending night. She was jealous that while the ponies of Equestria played and laughed during the day, during her night they simply slept through it, not appreciating it. However, instead of working anything out, she turned from her sister; and consumed with jealousy, refused to lower the moon to allow the sun to rise. She turned into Nightmare Moon, and was only stopped after Celestia harnessed the most powerful magic possible. It wasn't small.


Man this feeling in my ears can only be one thing! SEX... You are now my new favorite artists on YT.


When I die, I want my ashes do be dumped over a cliff in Scotland under the starry night sky during a full moon. And I want an orchestra to play this song. I will most likely be bawling my eyes out where ever I will be. Either in heaven, or in hell, I will be happy to know that this is the way I was to go.


If possible, put on headphones (not earphones)
Play at a high, but comfortable level
get nice and relaxed in chair/lay down
close eyes and think of nothing but the music being played
we'll be right here when you get back


@PinkiePieSwear There's nothing wrong with peaceful music. In the raging torrent of spastic techno (house, etc) and ear bleeding rock remixes, this is an island of tranquility.


i've always been sensitive to sunlight, hence the username and vampire jokes made about me. to me, daytime means school and work. nighttime, however, brings beauty. you can't see meteor showers, the northern lights, or the stars during the day. i've always found darkness inspiring. what i'm really getting at is, though, i would have been the one nocturnal pony that was sad to see luna banished. i don't think i would have minded eternal night, or maybe just a very long one.


Is this official? Luna's my favorite Pony, so I hope to God (and Celestia) that this is true and that there will be more Luna.


That's just one way of looking at one specific event. That's the beauty it. There's almost an unlimited amount of depth.


This has a HUGE Clannad ring to it.....

And I love it :D


Damn, this song is AWESOME!!! Kinda Pink Floyd Esq.....As hard as this song is to compair to the greatness of Floyd, its just... It has got that feeling, the sound... Sounds like in instrumental that would be on the Devision Bell, Their final album......


This has a Ryuchi Sakamoto feel to it.

Merry Christmas, Mr. Lawrence!


this is a good tune for the night and I like the night as well


How would you react if you were banished for a thousand years?
Besides, the best parties are at night. Imagine all the awesome Pinkie Pie Parties we could have!


This needs to be in a game, right now. The game doesn't have to have anything to do with ponys.


so good at soul... and at heart... so good...


Where did Matt R go? At least we still have the memories.


PinkiePieSwear, Y u no make more songs? You're so talented. I must hear more. :(


I spent last midnight walking to a nearby hill.

Just standing at  the summit, gazing at the moon and the clear starry sky while listening to this song made me feel a calm I've not felt for a long time.

Simply amazing


This is so relaxing..

It sounded a bit like Skyrim at 1:44 o-o But this is still an awesome piece.


...oh wow...

I would also like to thank Octavia. I think my ears have a crush on her cello.


Think of it this way though; say you had an older sibling (if you do use them) and they played an instrument, lets say guitar, and you also played an instrument, piano. You both can play your respective instrument very well but everyone pays attention to your sibling because the guitar is cooler. So in spite you set out to destroy the guitar. This is the thinking of Luna, she is tired of being cast in the shadow of her sister even though she also does something amazing.


This reminds me of Phantasy Star Online for some reason... IDK why.

It's very beautiful. I love it. So much...


Princess Luna is absolutely epic!
Need mor of this!


Wao. It's all...astral-ee and stuff. Such a peaceful melody.


I really want to learn the violin/viola part for this, whichever it is.


BUT SHE'S SO ADORABLE!  I know where you're coming from, but you must keep in mind the theory some bronies have of NMM being an entirely different pony than Luna.


I realized I was making a playlist entirely of your songs, so I sub'd.


god, can i please oh god please get some sheet music for this?  I WANT TO PLAY THIS ON MY PIANO!


Thank you. It's always nice to know the big guy upstairs is watching.


OMG I THOUGHT THIS GOT DELETED! PLZ NEVER TAKE IT DOWN!


So i have to ask because there's looming nostalgia over this piece for me, was it in any way inspired by something from Kingdom Hearts? 0:55 to 1:14 just reminds me so much of a moment from Kingdom Hearts.


while that may be, i will still forever be awake through the night. luna is best princess :D


Not really. It's sort of like a good book in English class. You read it once and enjoy it. Then you go over it again and discover the deeper meanings in it. Animal Farm is a perfect example of a book like that. Even if the developers didn't intend this deep meaning, it's still there just unintentinally waiting to be found.


One thing i really want to see them do with this show is make a episode showing back when luna turned into nightmare moon. That would make me so happeh :3


@johnbs7

If you like bittersweet you might want to check out Past Sins. It is more mature than your average MLP story but still sticks very close to the original.


whoa man. that's deep. if only pony haters could realize that they could appreciate us more instead of insulting us for our likes. instead of arguing, we should be working together.


the night is much better than the day, the only bright color i enjoy are the moon and the stars, i care not for the yellow rays the earth is bathed in during the day. LUNA YOU ROCK!!!


I know. She was justly punished, but it's similar to the way that people were so enticed by Ted Bundy or how some people are obsessed with Charles Manson or something like that. I do love Luna, but that's because I love psychology and she's just full of unstable tendencies, much like Trixie(who is another favourite of mine). I do pity her for the fact that she felt the need to do that and I know how much it sucks being punished and looked down upon, even after you've repented from your "sins".


This goes with... about every brony hater, and hypocrite as well. It's a very complicated topic that's connected to society and everyone's beliefs. I know that all too well... glad someone else sees stuff I see sometimes. :3


(Ran out of space) It wasn't a small crime at all. Think of all the things that rely on the Sun,   and you get an idea of how very "big" deal it was the Luna was trying to rid Equestria of it forever. Combine this with the fact that Celestia did seem to be "gotten rid of", and only returned with the rising of the sun when Nightmare Moon's power was broken, and It seems pretty clear she had something to do with Celestia's dissapearance.


the night I pant the glow in the dark stars on my wall I will play this on loop and fill my empty skies :)


i am listening to this in the morning and this is make sleepy but it is lovely


this feels like it should be on Hearts of Space


Sup bro! I come back to this song a lot when im thinking and im mostly a nocturnal creature sooooo... fitting :P. Anyway I was wondering what you would call this kind of music. I wana have a playlist of stuff that sounds like this for when im thinking to myself and I don't know what words to use to start my search. Can you maybe point me in a direction or some names or even other piece like this?


In the IV remix war I might remix this if that's alright? I love the lead part. It could become a great metalcore riff!


poor luna. she gets such a bad rep. if you remember correctly, she just wanted the ponies to appreciate the night more. this wasn't gonna happen so she got jealous. how would you feel if you made something absolutely beautiful and nobody appreciated it? that is how luna felt. if only people could see that luna isn't all that bad...


in the show, she is very hated on. in real life she is very loved.


Uliuminness of night, shown in the peacefulness of Bronys and the lovelyness of luna. Truely beutieful, welldone fellow brony, peaceful brohoofs all around. /)


@donpingwin It all depends on size. If we go off human sized instruments and pony sizes, it's a Cello, but if we adjust sizes of instruments, its a Double Bass. But whatever it doesn't really matter that much...


This actually brought a tear to my eye the first time I heard it...and the second...and the tenth...


Our school is actually so stuffed with bronies that our student council created "The Canterlot Celebration Party" for Oct. 10, which was the day when the first episode of Friendship is Magic aired.


Somepony please make a piano version.  Oh god, I'll do it myself if I have to.


Yarp. That's a cameo. For example the Royal Wedding episodes. She appears about 4 times very briefly and has about two lines of dialogue.


I don't know why, but this song reminds me alot of the music you'd hear in Bejeweled. o_o.


Holy shit, thank you for Sonic Rainbooming my brain. Now I can't look at Celestia the same again. . . .


...how come I haven't heard these sooner...my youtube downloader is getting loving tonight


I guess Luna represents My Little Pony as a whole. I mean look at the similarities, Luna used to be good but she turned into Nightmare Moon, then ponies became scared of her. MLP was good, then came G3, and its "apparent" bad rep (being targeted towards little girls), now some frown upon it. Gladly though, some were able to see things for what they truly are. I guess we bronies are like Twilight...


She was under attack by, as far as I can tell, and evil spirit, driven by her need to be as good as her elder sister, who, as I see it, was probably ignoring Luna due to work.


But the ponies of Ponyville have not complained about very much - they are happy as is!


Well then according to your theory, it was Nightmare Moon who spent the 1,000 years on the moon, which was justice. It's not like she converted back to Luna and spent it feeling sorry for herself and miserable. She was plotting revenge, because evil has no concept of justice; only getting ahead.


I've associated this song with the fanfic "Claro De Luna"...
Made so much sense together that... on my iPod... I changed the title of the song to "Claro De Luna"...
Tell me if I'm not aloud to do that...


I think night is more beautiful than day, because there other things to look at. Like planets, stars, the nebula clouds, all of that. :)


This reminded me of Kingdom Hearts. Just awesome.


First few seconds: "Space. The final frontier. These are the voyages of the Starship Enterprise, to seek out new life and to boldly go where no man has gone before" -Capt. Jean Luc Picard


Word of Faust says that Luna was still NMM while on the moon. The image of the dancing luna on the moon is cute fanon, but she was still the bitter resentment filled Nightmare during those thousand years. If anything she grew in hatred of her sister and ponies during that time.


As a a Ponyvillian, dear Luna I love your night. My name is Hartzell Kandy and if you ever need a friend I'm there for you. :)


Sounds like something that would be in The Last unicorn.


I made up what it would be called if Luna did a sonic rainboom, a Melancholy Night Boom.


@sharppoint8 It's also amazing to sit down with a good mlp fanfic and listen to this while you read.


for some, the best way to move on, is to share their troubled past with others.


This song strongly reminds me of 16bit RPG gaming for some reason.


I hate to do this to such an old comment...
But that was beautiful.


I'm not aware that I implied that there wasn't. I was just saying, she's repented and wants to be accepted back into the society. She knows that it isn't an easy task and probably often gets frustrated that things aren't accelerating the way she wants them to; many of the ponyfolk are still afraid of her-- which they have reason to be. Just because there is reason for the fear and dislike, doesn't mean she has to like it. She's now seen as 'alone', and that's where the "pity party" comes from.


This reminds me of "Moonsong" from Cave Story.


This always reminds me of Kingdom hearts.


@ALXXMaXX No, I totally understand. Jarre and Oldfield are some of my favorite composers of all time.


I agree that there's hope in the darkness. Just remember, no matter what happens, God loves you and he can carry you through to the end. Knowing that has helped me through the dark times, too. My family has our arguments, and a long, long lasting stretch of financial issues. He's always somehow pulled us through the hard times, and he can help you too. =)


Todo la vida pasa rapido
En una estas mirando un video tranquilo feliz, y al otro dia muere tu papá, tus 2 perros y queda el vacio en nuentro sentimientos, no se puede cambiar esas cosas ya que nunca mas van a volver una vez que se van para siempre. Me acuerdo que era horrible ver a mamá llorando, es una de las cosas que te quedas pensandi y la verdad no entiendes  porque te toco a vos y no a otro.
Terminas queriendo volver a estar en esos tiempos donde solo estabas feliz mirando la pantalla de tu celular, cuando eras inocente, cuando la vida era normal y simplemente normal.

Talven nadie ñea esto pero me dara nostalgui y yo lo se, pronto pasaran años y este comentario seguira y asi hasta que muera . Porque pasa esto tan rapido :'(  te extraño papá.

9/02/22

It happens dude just keep moving forward


Am I the only one that wants to play Dynasty Warriors after hearing this?


This song makes me want to go out side at night and stare at the stars.


If you can, go outside on a clear night and play this song.

Make sure all the lights are off and look up at the stars and listen to this.

Come back and post what you felt.


Got to agree with you there but technically "Luna" Didnt do it. Once her Crushed sense of importance snapped she became Nightmare moon. So technically she is like 60% Evil and 40% Victim. But hell who doesn't like a character with a brooding back story i mean we all loved Zuko.


You're very welcome! I know from experience that's it's nice to have reminders about him. ^^


@Jazmillenium i tried this and, even tho i live near LA so the sky dosnt have many stars, it was a full moon and it was just peacefull. thx for the idea :)


*fanboyrage* She doesnt play cello its a bass >_< you must sit to play a cello, bass is the standing instrument *fanboyrageend* Great song :3


I wish to congratulate you with THE ROYAL CANTERLOT SPEAKING VOICE!!


Love it love it love it love it love it love it love it love it


there never was a conversation....only a statement, a good statement that I agree with.


Well no they explained she completely snapped and thus became nightmare moon. If it was the same person and Luna was just straight evil The elements of harmony would have just destroyed her or whatever.


@PinkiePieSwear  Of course its a good thing a song about luna should always be Lullaby esque  its for the nighttime


i just realised there is a reaction box now
can i react to the reaction box?
also song is so peaceful
awesome work


Did I try to get rid of her?  No.  I only wanted my night to be appreciated - I was a little jealous of all the attention the Sun received in comparison to my pale yet elegant Moon.


@OmiPlus I could imagine Luna listening to that kind of music--the sort of spacey, ambient synthpop, you know, stuff in the vein of Jarre, Mike Oldfield, maybe a little bit of Wayne Lytle's stuff. IDK. I think WAY too much about stuff like this. XD


@johnbs7

Just finished reading "Tears of a Goddess" and dear god thats one hell of a stab to the hearth.

If you can recommend anything similiar please let me know. :)


the stars in the night sky give their love the moon princess we will always be behind you Luna
Long live the lunar republic
Down with the sun tyrant


she is definitely not a victim but we really shouldn't hate her for it either. Its obvious she was corrupted by some not so sane thoughts and whims but to hold her to it after she was righted but holding that against her now is just cruel. I can only imagine she looks back on what happened with some level of self loathing or disgust.


But night is still beautiful, like you! :)


True, yet you often cannot see that that is closest to you except in the lightest of nights.  The darkness hides the things that you enjoy, revealing things above that you could never reach.  What is the use of seeing what you cannot touch, if those you love cannot be seen in turn?  I believe that that must be the reason many prefer the day.


it reminds me of pokemon rescue dungeon at the end
i love this song


Troubling and dark times is what shapes us all, it is not something to simply let go. He was not just telling some sob story, if you think that was childish than you clearly have not experienced such times,
most likely cause you haven't lived as long, making you childish.


I love my night too.  Thank you for your offer - it won't be disregarded.


0:15 in that litle bit where the violin plays it reminded me of the max payne theme, sounded similar somehow


I'm not trying to say that what she did was right, but trying to give insight to why people victimize her as they do. And I'm not trying to say that she wasn't appreciated at all, however, since Luna's duty takes place during the night when everyone is supposed to be sleeping, she probably felt under-appreciated due to the fact that people probably openly came to Celestia during the day and threw grand celebrations for her and whatnot, whereas, Luna got none of these things from the ponyfolk.


70's can headphones, a good hard cider, a comfortable chair, and this song......

*mmmmmmmmmmmmm*


Luckily, the Brony community likes Luna more. XD


Why should I feel bad? It wasn't me who tried to shroud Equestria in eternal night.
Αμαρτίες γονέων παιδεύουσι τέκνα.


They were connected, but the Elements of Harmony separated them


Sure, it would have killed everyone, but think about it. Luna didn't get the praise her sister did, and Luna wanted that. Jealousy is one hell of a thing, lad. Don't you think it is possible that she was just so blinded by jealousy and loneliness that it caused her ability to see logic and reason to just disappear? She just wanted the relationship with her subjects that her sister had, and thought that if the roles were switched, she could get it. At least, that's my theory on how things went.


Well, how would you feel if nobody valued and recognized your work? Having your sibling receive all the love and credit while you were there in second plan still doing your job?
I'm not saying Luna did the right thing, but I'm pretty sure she was blind with envy and frustration, which led her to commit such lunacy. She wanted others to apreciate her and the night, but she didn't do things the right way and ended up paying a high price for her actions.

We all can see how nice normal Luna is.


Yes, it was. Celestia banished, her prior to her jealousy, which we can assume is the point at which she became nightmare moon. What reason is there to believe that it wasn't NM on the moon?


This song comes after Rainbow Factory in the playlist I'm listening to...


it all started with the big bang. it was a saturday night and luna and her room mate chugs where arm wrestling.
Chugs: your going down!
*luna farts*
Chugs: aww that is sick!
*luna wins*
Luna: AWW YEA! undefeated! oh hold on, here comes another one, quick hand me your lighter!
*luna lights the fart on fire*
*big bang*
Luna: aww yea... you smell that?

... thats what i though of when i saw the pic... great song tho


Wasn't really a "small" crime. You tried to rid the world of your sister, the God of the Sun, and bring everlasting night. Not what you'd exactly call a petty crime.


I get a kingdom hearts vibe from this for some reason.


@johnbs7

Wow you really kept me busy there. Started reading and liked it so far. Thanks again for the pointer.


I instantly heard a connection to Jean Michel Jarre.


That was different... um... uh....  Either way, I forgive Luna.  You have valid points, but you must keep in mind Luna is adorable.  trololol.  In all seriousness, you have me beat there, but I still forgive Luna.  It's just a theory many a brony I have come across have.


I'm pointing out the fact that when people use their difficult pasts to get attention for themselves, instead of moving on and not letting it define you, is childish.


Few know of the truth. How Luna was given control of all night, moons and stars (including the Sun...since it's a star). Then feeling bad for her sister gave her the gift of the Sun. Celestia imposed a harsh dry world using the Sun incorrectly, and Luna eclipsed it to protect the ponies.

Then Celestia used the elements she stole to seal Luna, and acquire the rest of her powers. Luna must now wait until Celestia let's her guard down. Remember; History is written by who's left...not who's right.


fucking hell, this is something else, man...


They were 2 different entities. Luna, whom we know to now be a benevolent ruler, was consumed by darkness. An split personality doesn't change your appearance, voice, demeanor, or abilities. Luna can't be held responsible for what Nightmare Moon did. And quit looking so far into things--there's no mental illness in the show


You don't need telescopes or science to appreciate the stars. There's a reason for there being so many: to strike awe, to glorify their creator. Humanity has always wondered about the stars. The development of telescopes and astronomy came about BECAUSE humanity was interested in the stars and wanted to know more. And this happened a couple thousand years ago for humanity. Assuming ponies are about 100 years behind humanity, they would have had astronomy during the time of Luna.


She wasn't banished to the Moon.  She was banished into the Moon.  She was combined with it.  Hence the lack of aging and her picture on the moon (when she was there), as well as not being completely insane after 1000 years of lonliness.


Well if you're going to bring Science into it then how about this: Causing the moon to rise has nothing to do with day and night, we can only see the moon at night thanks to there being no sun to blot it out with light pollution.
So in fact Luna never had the power to bring about eternal night and Trollestia was just trolling everybody into thinking she could.


Which, incidentally, is a concept that is not-quite-subtly hinted at in that very episode, not long after that moment...


Is is ok that I put it on my iPod, then changed the title to "Claro De Luna"?
I read the fanfic "Claro De Luna" and I thought it would fit so well.
Tell me if I couldn't change it.


kinda made me mad when I found out where this song originated from lol.


>Cameos

That's like saying that every time Princess Celestia is seem for a few seconds it's a cameo.


yup ur right i like the song by the way, and the background irs beautiful i love princess luna


Hey PinkiePie, I love the song but something is really weird with the tindeck download option for this song, everytime I try to download it the site gives me something called weak by Jojo, not sure if that's a site error :(


Some humans are said to be "heartless" and, therefore, have no heart. In its place are a bunch of rocks.


this sounds like it could be in the spiral knights ost. i mean, whoa, when i listened to this i thought spiral knights had ripped this off from you holy fuck


For some reason, this song reminds me of Bejeweled.

+Hope the Anthro Unicorn Hey, i was thinking of that too!<br>Well, great minds think alike!

+Hope the Anthro Unicorn Hey, i was thinking of that too!
Well, great minds think alike!

+Hope the Anthro Unicorn Lol I know same!! XD

Ponysparkle3 Twilight Ice Well, I meant to write just Bejeweled, but then, poof, auto-correct. I'm always betrayed by auto-correct. XD

+Hope the Anthro Unicorn I've got Bejeweled


I tried to close the tab to listen to something else.... I couldn't until the song was done.


Corona virus and still love this masterpiece


@PinkiePieSwear if i find a good song i download it, and most are your songs because there so fucking good!!!


@PinkiePieSwear If you don't mind, what key is this in?


hey, 6 people liked this so much they flipped their computer screens around and liked it again! XD


@destroyer4253 Maybe in the pony world the instrument sizes are different, but going off size alone it's most likely a cello. I played strings for 3 years, I know what I'm talking about.

Either that or it shouldn't really matter and it's a cartoon.


@ICouldBeAnyPony pinkiepieswear videos should just have "like" and "love" buttons on them. it just makes a lot more sense to me.


@ICouldBeAnyPony The simple anwser is: Haters gonna hate.

Ther more complicated one is: for every large fan base there is an minority of people who know of the fan base but hate the TV show that the fan base is fans of. so they try to feebly and stupidly dislike videos in the faint hope that people will see the dislikes on it and assume it to be junk. this of course only works when the video is first released and fails once the amount of likes majorly outweighs the dislikes. Happened to me too.


the image I get is being traped inside a snowglobe on a mountain with the years first snowfall and the aurora.


@AmimikaMoon everyone has a type of music they like or a variety they enjoy listening to and all music is art in itself there is no need to be so close minded about it. of course u dont have to like what other people enjoy listening to but that does not mean u need to go hatin other people taste in music.


@KeroDono Heck no, Homestuck is a great webcomic! Where do you think this piece would fit in?


This song reminds me of the star room in myst.


You are now subscribed to PinkiePieSwear.


Im the only Brony at my school. Damn proud and not ashamed.


Well, guess who showed up again in the finale? :P


@TheMarinePlanet That's alright.  I used to be the only one at my school, but I talked about it to my friends about it all the time.  They were so sick of me talking about it that some of them finally caved and watched an episode.  There are now five bronies at my school.


Luna, Please fill my empty sky,

Everything seems so blank...

I feel, like I'm going to cry,

So please, Fill my empty sky...


Can i use this in a room i made on Whirled?


PinkiePieSwear in my subscription inbox?!? EVERYPONY GET OUT OF MY WAY!


@emilysgotcurls Great... Now I'm going to have to take this song, take some rain samples, overlay it, and THEN put it on my iPod now.


Now, now, don't be a bad pony.
I do believe that is my job, from your view.


@LoveTheMess I already did. I turned on Flutterwonder to help me relax before starting and said "I gotta study after this finishes"....That was a 1 o'clock....I don't remeber that song being 4 hours long. It knocked me out for 4 HOURS!


This music made me go bananas! ON THE MMMMMOOOOOOOOOOONNNNNNNNNAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH!!!! BEEEEEEYIIIITCHH!!!!


thanks on both the hug and the compliment.


Luna farts and a new part of space is born.


This really reminds of one the songs from Clannad, except that this is better.


THAT 1 DISLIKE SHOULD BE SENT TO THE MOON!!!!


@ICouldBeAnyPony  the people who disliked this are all probably punk-rock heavy metal addicts who can't appreciate true music


The start of season 3 hasn't even be announced, how is it possible that THAT info was released?


look at derpidety's dash's empty sky now the title of this, Luna, please fill my empty sky. Sounds like some kind of ship


@TheMarinePlanet Not a problem for me.
Made my friend one, and several teens at my school are bronies.
Not sure who they are, but I've heard about kids bringing their ponies to our school.


Could I use this music for a background video on the City of Venice Italy?


Judging by the picture in the video, it might just be the Big Bang.


1. This song
2. Hubble Telescope Gallary
3. ?????
4. Profit!


This is weird. I just finished watching a bunch of Clannad clips.


1.) Open rain*ymood*.c*om in new window
2.) Play "Luna, Please Fill My Empty Sky".
3.) Relax.


Well their is always this guy who gave you a thumbs up


Hahaha rofl. My plan has been achieved :D


or maybe the hulk and bruce banner make it relevant for the people


I don't know what you said, but take the "like"!


@MightyQuinn2021 ah, 2001 a space odyssey... i highly approve of this.


i subed just cuz you had one on luna but the rest are good too.

luna love!


Nah, he's just using the royal "we", and "us". You'll find that in history many royals referred to themselves like that.


I think you're looking a little to deep into this.


My girlfriend brought me here.. I'm just walking by.


She was a victim because she couldn't understand people are tired at night.


there *was* that book that she had at the end of the episode...


Try and remember that this Luna isn't the real one. Gosh that sounds mean, but when I realise anyone with the ability to make a new gmail account can say there any of the ponies of the show, this assuming their identities thing gets old faster then it should have.


i take it that you are one of those people, seeing as your name has star watcher in it.


@TheMarinePlanet i was too at first but i told my closest friends to at least watch the first two episodes...if they didnt like it ...i woulden't ask them again but if they did and  they didnt want anyone to know i would keep his or her secret..they all loved it... and soon they did the same to their friends...


nightmaremoon is like the golem to lunas smeagle


Men don't cry...
men don't cry...
don't...cry...


@KeroDono Yeah, I agree with you. but it's the webcomic/ flash/ story thingy that they don't like. It's the rather rabid fanbase.


I know but its still nice to hope right?


No, you.
I've already felt bad about it before.


i often wonder if people dislike videos for the sake of disliking videos


Your comment made me smile. Here! -huggles-


@ZenozaProject Some ponies just want to watch the world burn


@L337pony correction, WE wish to congratulate you with THE ROYAL CANTERLOT SPEAKING VOICE!!!!!!


@Korefox4 You rock, I downloaded it asap. I WOULD upload it to YouTube, but it'd be plagiarism of your work and PPS's work.


is that the one with nightmare night and she is trying to have fun with everypony? i no good with remembering episode titles.


I'm the only brony in my country, it would seem. I haven't found a single Turkish brony apart fromy myself...


pro luna cause she is just to sweet ;)
and nopony make her a victim...we just think that she shouldnt be punished any longer

and just btw: check wiki to Chemosynthesis


@ICouldBeAnyPony
Yes, they do.
Luckily they are in an extreme minority.
of over 60 000 people, only 6 so far has disliked it, that means 1 in 10 000 people do it.
(The numbers will probably increase now that I mentioned it, or they may also not because I mentioned that I mentioned it.)
YOU GET IT.


No; But the noob way to do it is to put it in a playlist by itself and turn autoplay on :p (thats the way i do it because I can be kind of a noob sometims)


Please add a link for the picture PWEETY PWEASE?!


Conversation?...
Oh great by saying that I created a conversation! Damnangit!!!


cool, ill be sending this song to the moon... ipod, sorry


But that's still selfish. Her actions still came from selfish reasons.


Wow weird 00:15 sounds just like max pane


@TheMarinePlanet Props dude. I'm the only Brony at work. Now THAT is cause for celebration.


well you could say that but then I would say it's a cartoon with a single moral.


@L337pony it's the TRADITIONAL CANTERLOT SPEAKING VOICE.


@TheMarinePlanet There's quite a few at mine. My friend and I make up only 2 of them. I wish I knew the others...


i know this was a long time ago but it was on my bd


@whoneedsskittles You're the best at space!


Hm..........It sounds like a track from The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess...


Thats an ad. Some sites make it hard to find the real thing among all the ads


@animelovingbagpiper I completely thought the same thing!


"As seen on: The Gang Garrison 2 Forum"
dafuq


@ICouldBeAnyPony Looks like 5 times out of 943


now i come to a fork in the road, i have just found you and your videos but i have to go to work

which on which one...... this one is tough d-_-b i do like money but......


Yeah, but by your own definition it was NMM who was on the moon for 1k years, not Luna.


@ICouldBeAnyPony there must be dislike ghost that will not rest until it dislikes every video


BOB FRECKLESTEIN THE THIRD!!!!  jk i was pretty happy to see luna xD


What happened to you I wonder 6 years since any activity on this channel at all I have to ask if your still there if your still alive please awnser my call to know are you ok ?


wow.... ok this is quite the comment chain conversation......


@ColbaltColt Im working on my friend right now too


@kellyroy651 indeed, American Bronies are often proud and shameless! LIKE ME!


@TheMarinePlanet I doubt that. There's a lot more of us than you think.


+Power PoNy CZ yeah ur right it does go by fast

+Power PoNy CZ yeah ur right it does go by fasr

+MHvids And now you are 4 years older, Time go really fast don't you think ? :)


@ubernoob11 I shall make you all proud:)


1) See URL bar
2) See "Youtube" in the URL bar
3) change "Youtube" to "Yourepeat"
4) LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOPS!!!


@swirlingabyss *sigh* just personal opinion, that's all. and besides, i said probably. and besides, if you like this music, you're probably not in the category "can't appreciate true music" therefore, i was not referring to you.


@jokiu4 This is a fine practice, but really, aloud? allowed is a bit better...


@typoded trust me, im trying. got me some promising candidates


@emilysgotcurls More like brony ice cream soup.


She planned to block the sun before being sent to the moon however. And she had no reason to plan that other than so the ponies could watch the beautiful moon which she raised. In another word: Selfish.


Forgive me, but I do not know what exactly a 'Korea' is, but from the way you speak, it must be a region.  It does not sound a lot like Equestria in any sense..


@ICouldBeAnyPony I just dislike videos when i see a comment about the dislike bar and its actually correct. just for shits and gigs


luna is the best, then applejack, then EVERYPONY ELSE, then celestia.


@TheMarinePlanet not ashamed? you should be ashamed that you haven't turned anyone else into a brony >:(


As in, you don't have enough faith in God


lol good music but it looks like luna shit out the universe :D
- just sayin'


No always like this video, it's suck i'm  gonna do a better with rock Luna are in that rock video i gonna take on youtube! luna was'nt sing! how do you know whats the song is called for? do you now at my dream are crazy in your music and now is the sing in my brain! but this song it's suck i will at that song must be singed.. rocked.. remember and that wadh i say! do you gonna do a better! 100 million years  waiting for luna gonna sing! that always is just music! OHH! you can't better? my life!


Your actions were bad and you should feel bad.


You really need to not bring religion into a video about PONIES.


Don't worry of me! Don't talk to me! i talk on this video and that video is sooo boriing!!!! can PinkiePieSwear do a better! OHH! Remember at this song with luna sing! Do a better i'm waiting on 3 weeks. On that video is not leavin! i gonna rapport that youtube video! IN MY RIGHT!!