I started watching and interacting with mlp very early 2012, around the end of the second season and a bit before this song was released. I miss the early times of the fandom. Not that its bad now, its just... different. All the creativity on youtube and other places surrounding the first 2 seasons were insane. You could click around on related mlp videos for hours and find hundreds of budding musicians like yourself. Now most have moved onto bigger and better things but its nice to see you're one who hasn't forgotten. (and deleted your youtube in an effort to commit brony internet suicide.. like some people...) Thank you Replacer for the nostalgia and great times

@ℕ dude please upload more music. Any fuss is fire

@Briseur De Lance It's mostly artists losing interest in ponies, and moving onto other stuff. There's also a lot less demand for pony stuff than there was a few years ago, relatively speaking, so a lot of artists don't have as much incentive to keep creating.

Why would some Brony/pegasister musicians "commit brony internet suicide"?<br>Why? I do not understand anything of the rationale that could be behind that.

Why would some Brony/pegasister musicians "commit brony internet suicide"?
Why? I do not understand anything of the rationale that could be behind that.

hey there are plenty of musicians around now. you should see the fandom now.

I actually would like to disagree here.

Yes he profited, but don't you think the others did too? There was a supply and demand, and not to mention, maybe TLT just wanted to try other things. He's done some great original music to other remixes.
And that bit about FNAF, I think that fandom in itself almost gave him a breakdown (at least that is the concencus of theory)
Youtube is or was, a good way for people that had talent, or could bring back consistent views, to gain some money. It was and still is to some, a job.
So I think you are judging too harshly, but that is just my viewpoint on that matter.

The times have changed, but our love for the songs, the music that speaks to the soul will never change <3

I totally agree with you. I could name sooo many brony musicians that committed brony internet suicide. I started watching in late season 1, learning about it from my sister, who didn't have any relations to the online community. i remember that art from the fandom was so much more scarce, so all the creations were much more valuable. now there's so much over-saturation.

+replacer That's a really cool mindset. "If it was good enough to upload in the first place it's good enough to keep around." I like that. :)

I won't delete this stuff. If it was good enough to upload in the first place it's good enough to keep around. Besides, I've got unfinished business here.


As a recording engineer, I must say that this is actually a <b>superbly</b> recorded song! Everything is extremely crisp and clean sounding, nothing overlaps anything else, there's no mud in the mix or anything. The vocals sit very nice and compliment the instrumentation spectacularly. Very good work, Replacer!

As a recording engineer, I must say that this is actually a *superbly* recorded song! Everything is extremely crisp and clean sounding, nothing overlaps anything else, there's no mud in the mix or anything. The vocals sit very nice and compliment the instrumentation spectacularly. Very good work, Replacer!

@CptScrublington I think I agree, days of silence is better

@replacer I don't know if you feel the same, but to me your recent song, "days of silence" finally topped this one as a creative masterpiece. The myriad of ways you can interpret the lyrics as well as the beautiful composition really sets it above all else in my eyes. Even six months later I still can't get enough of it!

@dropkickproductiontx thank you :) the song was very important to me at the time, and in a way it's still sitting there daring me to top it...I put a lot of thought into everything but I never considered it any sort of audio engineering triumph, so I'm really happy to hear these thoughts.


Out of every song the fandom ever produced... This is the one that has always stuck with me, and hits home with a lot of who I am. Still an absolute masterpiece.


really interesting to come back and listen to this years after hearing it the first time. i remember listening to this song in seventh grade and it hit me in such a special place back then, and it still does today, 6 years later. thank you for keeping this up, wishing you the best <3

Yeah, he is one of those creators of the fandom that will never let it die out, even when the show ends.


This came out when I was 11, and I'm 19 now. Thank you for helping me throughout my adolescence and guiding me with your music. It still means the world to me, even now.


It's been 8 years since I discovered your music, and wow what a time it has been. I'm rediscovering the fandom and falling in love with all the music again, and Replacer, it needs to be said: What you gave the fandom is so incredibly unique and inspiring. I hope you know that you were and are a shining beacon in an ocean of content.


You know a song is memorable when you remember the melody for four years..<br>WELL done, Replacer!

You know a song is memorable when you remember the melody for four years..
WELL done, Replacer!

Bacon Hamilton <br>Yes oh my god and I still remember it

Bacon Hamilton
Yes oh my god and I still remember it


I woke up to this song playing on my youtube-generated playlist and felt like I was having a heart attack while floating in the clouds.


Now you have me calling my non-brony boyfriend my "earth pony." Whatever this song is to you years from now, it is something to him and me. Thank you.


No one will, no one can replace Replacer


You know, you've always been my personal favorite out of all the brony musicians. Not just because the music you write is fantastic, but because you're also a great friend whose helped me out tremendously as an artist.
Your work is stunning and heartfelt, and it's especially evident in this. Even moreso than A Pony Like Me.
No one's gonna replace you, not in my eyes.


You know, I often come back to this era of music and videos, not only for the mild nostalgia, but because songs like this have a deeper meaning once you're older
I was 14 years old when I heard this, now I'm 20, and the lyrics took a deeper message since then
Thank you very much, Replacer, for keeping your vids up, and making these songs, you have my eternal gratitude for that.


You're still one of my favorite musicians. No one could replace you : )


God, this song is different every time I listen to it. Sometimes it's depressing as hell, but sometimes it just seems . . . hopeful.

Sup my dude! I enjoyed your language videos a lot😅. But you are into bigger things now I'm sure. Sending prayers

The show is dead asf right now am i right?


This song perfectly depicts falling in love with someone who is everything, whilst you are nothing.<br>Thank you for making this.

This song perfectly depicts falling in love with someone who is everything, whilst you are nothing.
Thank you for making this.


A bit over 5 years now. I remember when this song came out. Was beautiful. Still is. This is a song you can come back and still enjoy. Thank you for the memories.


3:07 Goosebumps dude, Jesus. I just love the way this builds and breaks down. The beat is perfect for head bobbing, and everything else is so deliciously minimal until the appropriate time comes to deliver the emotional 1-2 to the face. That time signature change too, damn. Once again I am just blown away... .... ... also is it bad that I might be developing an unhealthy attraction to your OC? ... >.>;


Hi, old school brony here who hasn’t watched avidly since like 2013 checking in

This song remains super ethereal sounding and I love it


Amazing work of art, I forget if I every gave a comment stating how much I loved this song or not. Either way it deserves two anyway. The notes hit deep into the mind, and perfect personification of a pony. Very relatable but has a sound and feeling of far away for a sense of hope. Awesome work I don't understand why you have so few subs! You deserve a full career off of this stuff.


This is where everything started for me. This is the very first song I heard and I've been listening it for years. Until I got curious about what other songs you post. Now I heard all of your songs (Including Can't Be Real). I love your songs man


I've grown away from this fandom but I do have to say it's the most productive and creative out of all others. I have about a thousand brony songs on my phone from over the years.

GigawingsVideo and what about MHA fandom?

Yarp. The great thing about the fandom is just how many great songs produced. I still have them and enjoyed them. Meanwhile current fandoms like FNAF, UTale and SU got too much anger and arguments in it rather than churning great original piece.

Right now I'm stepping into My Hero Academia fandom, I just hope this fandom doesn't fell into the horrible negativity pit like the others.

+Red Eye Raza Your name is great ... is it Death Gun?


It's been 3 years, a lot has happened since then, I've loved, I've lost everything, I've changed fundamentally as a person. But if there's anything that I can say with certainty anymore, it's this: This song is still beautiful.


Always find myself coming back to this, such a classic.


I'm going back and listening to a lot of the brony music I was into ~4 years ago and this one really stands out as a song that has aged very well. Everything about it from the composition to the instrumentation to the mix is on point. I'm really curious what DAW, VSTs, synths, tools, etc. you used and in general what your writing/production process is like. I would love to hear you do an episode of song exploder on this one! :)


Not sure if you’ll see this but thank you so much for creating this song. For a decade it’s what brought me peace and happiness whenever I felt low and it’s one of the most beautiful songs I have ever heard. I hope you’re doing well 💙


I left the brony community a while back (it just simply grew tiresome) but i always find myself coming back here. Bravo 10/10

Yooo Replacer, as someone who subbed to you since your going home song, it's nice you're still around. Now I spend my night listening to your pony playlist. I hope you're doing well. Thanks for all those magical years mate.

@replacer seriously man, never stop doing what you do. You're amazing at it.


I love this song. Just like Cerulean blue, the feeling of nostalgia is incredible. thank you, Replacer for keeping this alive for us. Also, that album art is f*cking adorable. That is all. <3


Wow, this I love this song; especially your soft-tone voice against the harsher sound of the background orchestration. Nice job!


Do you know my sister, The Potato Goddess?

You must bow down to the Great and Powerful Turtle Lord!


I’m not into MLP anymore but I’m going through a break up and I found myself returning to this song five years later. The lyrics so perfectly describe my situation somehow, and it’s so nice to be able to understand my feeling through this beautiful song. “I hope that nobody replaces me” is just too real and I can’t stop crying


Coming back to this ten years later and the opening still sends me into tears. Thanks for the memories, replacer.


Just wanted to come back here to comment that.. this song is one of the few songs that got me into brony music. I remember when I was like 10 (early 2013) and I went home one day and got on YouTube (it was late at night at the time) then, as usual, watched pony videos on my family's Computer (hella cringe, ik). Instead of watching episodes, pmv's, and fanmade videos that day I searched up "pony songs" I think then, I scrolled down a bit and found this. I listened to this song and... It made me want more! Ever since I've loved the music this fandom has produced. I've been a brony since 2011 but it wasn't until late 2012 - early 2013ish that I got into the music side of this fandom (ik, I said early 2013 earlier but tbh... I don't remember whether it was late 2012 or early-ish 2013).

In general I just wanted to say thank you Replacer, that you for helping me to discover the music side of this fandom. And yes, I know that sounds really random but it's true. It didn't all start with this song but it was this song that, in a way, reeled me in more. I honestly would've thought that, before I found this fandom in 2011, that a show about colorful ponies and freindship would make such an impact on my life. And I also wouldn't have imagined that the fandom that emerged from it would mean so much to as well.


Replacer's one of the most dynamic musicians I've ever heard. Every piece is something new, and yet he executes different genres so well. This piece, to me, captures melancholic happiness - bittersweet.


Not even a Brony anymore but I love this song... Fantastic


Oh man, I still love this song, even after hearing it countless times. Great work, Replacer, you will always have a special place in my heart.


Despite being a pretty active Brony years ago, I never heard of you or your music...  And I have to say, as a complete newcomer, this song really got me.  Incredible stuff.

Subscribed & listening for more.


This song was the reason why I found the brony fandom intriguing. I started watching the show and found interest in it. After season 3 I stopped watching out of my rage of the monstrosity Alicorn. But I won't even forget this song. Love to listen to this while its raining. I also listen to it when I have a bad time. Thanks for all the things I listed, man. Was Proud To Be A Brony. My last brohoof goes to you /).


By the way, another great song! I always look forward to hearing new songs composed by you and other talented artists. I like how allot of your songs are laid back and relaxing to listen to. Keep up the good work!


years later I still come back to this song every once in a while and it's still fantastic. one of those songs I'll never forget


Replacer, I've been a listener for awhile now, but recently I've been becoming more and more hooked. Thank you for contributing more great music to this community.

Are you by any chance planning to attend any of the conventions in the near future?

@Pepper oh I would always love to go to conventions, money is always the main issue there cause I live so far away


Replacer, I truly can't tell you how much I love your music.  I've many times been down, even depressed on some days since I became a Brony.

However, your always the first Brony musician I go to, and when I listen to your music it doesn't matter whether it's your saddest song or your happiest.  Somehow, I still get the greatest feeling whenever I listen to your music.

Will always love your stuff, Replacer.  Keep it up.


Wow..It's 2020 and this song is still extremely special to me. Outstanding music, still to this very day!


It's sad that it's already 9 years later and I'm only coming to really appreciate this song now. It has such a surreal vibe but is still an extremely well made and nice song


This was really beautiful, and very meaningful. More than that, I feel like this could be on the radio, and sound completely natural (aside from, you know, being about MLP). I love your songs. Keep up the good work!


This song really is beautiful and deserves many more likes and views


You know, I loved this song since it came out [a rough time in my life (who am I kidding, it's still rough)], but after coming back to this song today, I felt like I should say something:
This is an amazing song that has touched me, I feel like it really speaks to me and it's only right to let you know what absolutely astounding work you've done.
You are an amazing artist and you have my admiration.
Keep in mind that no one can replace you.


Absolutely fell in love with this song.<br>It's something different from what I am used too. The vocals are a bit monotone with great instrumental. It's a great combination.

Absolutely fell in love with this song.
It's something different from what I am used too. The vocals are a bit monotone with great instrumental. It's a great combination.


Oh wow. I love the vocal to this, how it sounds really quiet and almost whispered. The mixture of orchestral timbres with a jungle beat is quite inspired. And sweet jesus, that piano solo in the middle. This is straight up fantastic!


This song had me on the verge of tears. Thank you for your amazing work, and damn those lyrics are sad. I hope that if this song reflects on your thoughts like most songs do, that you've worked to resolve them. Have an internet hug :) *hug*


I love all of your tracks, seriously. You converted me from the dub-electro pony genre with Luna Waited. Then I found Cerulean Blue.. then Loyalty and Crusade no More. I just got lost in your music, and today I feel like in this song I didn't get lost, I found myself. It has a wonderful instrument and meaningful lyrics. Amazing job.


It was amazing hearing this live at Ponycon AU , great performance!


I have so many sensations right now, i just can say, this is wonderful


Over one year since I heard this and I still get goosebumps. One of my favorite songs ever made right here.


Wow, I love this. I haven't written anything in a long time, but listening to this, among other pieces of yours, but this in particular, has given me a bit of inspiration to write some poetry today. Thank you for being awesome. =)


I love this song, even after all this time. Such nostalgia! Good work, Replacer. 10/10


I just have to come back to this song every few months or so. It just.. Sticks with me. Its one of the songs that made me want to make music when I was younger. The melody inspired my daydreams and the soft vocals drove me to speak through music. I love this song with all my heart as.. Cheesy as that may sound. Idk. I still love it with the same intensity that I did as a kid and it resurfaces every time I'm feeling very low. I'm very fond of it


This... this is beautiful. Songs like these make me proud to be a brony. A truly amazing song mate, keep it up!


Such a wonderful song. Its people like you that make this fandom great.


Wow, dying from the feels. This is an incredible, brilliantly directed song.


This is definitely my favorite song of 2012. Feather's art makes this song even more spectacular. I can imagine a whole story.


I still come back to this song every month. I love the soft tones


That was fantastic! The changing motifs eased in so smoothly and still carried the same intention. I loved the ending resolution too! Great work dude.


After all thede years...this song still brings me to tears


This style... this beat... those vocals... you are now my absolute favorite artist. All the others don't even compare.


I had totally forgotten this song existed.  But it might have just come back to me at just the time i needed it.


This song always precedes tragedy in my life but I can't stop listening to it because it's just too beautiful.


After all these years, this is still one of my favorite songs of all time


Thank you, united we stand and together we love. We are Bronies and I'm proud to say I'm a part of this, I know all of you are too. So keep it up guys, because without the fandom, people like me are nothing but drunken monsters. You made me who I am, thank you so very much, for all you've done.

~Edward Vocalism


Replacer, I have a few niche artists that I follow pretty closely, and even after following them closely for many years this one song is easily top three for me.

Thank you.

Keep on keeping on.


there really aren't words to express how amazing this song is, it just gives off so much emotion and you can tell that you put a lot of thought and work into this. the implied story is also very deep and not just something anyone could come up with or share. this deserves the very HIGHEST and EPICEST of brohoofs. though, i don't think even that would be enough. keep on making music... and this may sound cheesy but, thank you.


I know I'm about 10 years too late, but I utterly love this song. Seriously, you rock!


Your performance was outstanding, good sir! I don't know how else to put it. I really liked how fast paced "No Words" was played. The finale was fantastic! Perfect song to end with at Everfree!


Will always remember this, even in college I find myself secretly putting this on when I'm alone.


The impact this song has on me to this day; since I was 12 all the way up to now as a 21 year old- it's a classic 🗣🗣


Going through your channel again just cuz, maybe for a nostalgia trip or something, but I just want to tell you how much I love this song. Everything about it is beautiful. It's been a while since I last heard it, but listening to it now brings me back, as well as reminds me how good it is. I don't really now how to explain it, but it makes me feel a certain way. I love it. Idk exactly what I'm trying to get at, but thanks for this song, thanks for the music you've made, and thank you for anything you do in the future.


Absolutely masterful. What I would give to record alongside such a wonderful talent..


Yet another amazing creation from Replacer. Continue the good work!


It's been years, this was always one of my favourites.


This song reminds me of me and my sister who passed away and all the good times we had together, I just wanted to say thank you replacer for making this song for both of us.


Excellent music; as stated, the juxtaposition of serious, brooding music with thoughtful, upbeat tones & lyrics is delightful.

I'm especially a fan of your chord progression (and the instrument used to make it), especially in the beginning.  Have you, perchance, played Banjo-Tooie?  I was strongly reminded of it while listening.


OK Replacer
Literally everything you do is amazing. There is no doubt about that.

But this soars above and beyond everything I've heard from you. You can tell that it comes from a personal place. This is heartbreaking. Every time I hear it I want to cry.

This is beyond amazing.

You are beyond a musical genius.

You are an artist.


I love how your songs always sound happy and light yet can sound sad at the same time.


So nice to go back and listen in on these songs and reminisce about being a brony. Pretty chill times.


This song. It hurts me to listen, but I drag myself through it again and again. I can feel the depth that you dredged the emotion for this from. Definitely my favorite of yours so far!


This is a really emotional piece, good job! Thanks to EQDaily, you've earned yourself a subscriber as well.


Replacer, you can never be replaced. Thanks for another beautiful track.


"I know one day you're gunna fly." That line brought tears to my eyes when made the connection with the rest of the story.


Absolutely blown away!  This is just...a masterpiece keep up the great work!


This song is just beautiful, it's really deep. Great job Replacer.


I just thought I might share this, in hopes of either kindling spirits or quelling doubts. I'm a seventeen year old, and well... Life isn't fun for me, I'm also a Brony but life still ain't great. Whenever I hear one of these songs, by any Brony artist. I remember just how proud I should be, because I'm a part of the best community out there. We may be second most hated behind Furries, but by god we are creative. These people have inspire me, and I hope they inspire all of you.

~Edward Vocalism


I've always seen this "earth pony" to be representative of the somepony who is dear to Replacer. Someone he care for, but yet to find. An audience he only wish to care for.

He fears that he isn't, but hopes he's still a "down to earth" pony.


It's EXTREMELY rare that I download a song before I've given it at least one complete listen through.
This is one of those songs. I'm in love.


It's amazing how everything that comes from your channel just sounds completely fresh.


I would love to hear a full orchestra orchestral version of this.


Still a great song to listen too all these years later.


This song is magnificently beautiful, it captures the essence of a long-distance relationship really well. <3


Replacer, Your music is enchanting and you truly stand out in the brony music community thank you for your amazing service to making this life a musical one.


Replacer, thank you for giving songs to community. It really means a lot to us! :)


This song is beautiful... you did a excellent job making it. I listened to it over and over again, that's how much i loved it.


As always, your music is amazing. You will forever be my favourite!


This is really cool and I like it. That progression is super creative and the vocals are superb


Holy crap, man....earned a subscriber.
The lyrics...the song, is beautiful.
Just...wow.
Words are an injustice.


Why... Why did I EVER stop to listen to your music Replacer <3 This music give me feelings I can never have otherwise. I can't tell you how much I love it! I haven't kept with the news but I hope you're doing great out there!


the breakdown at 3:10 is one of my favorite musical sections out of all the music I've ever listened to

+rian But that leadup tho, I've become fascinated with the chord buildup that comes to that resolution, it is just pure genius.


I was 16 when I first heard this. Childhood or not, it brings back memories.


The song, the lyrics, and the manner of singing all have a catchy nature that you just can't pin down, or try at all beyond enjoying the song for what it is. And that is good music, Thank you for the song, it was a pleasure to hear, and to hope that your muse and spirit dream ever onward.


This is the first song of yours I ever heard and to this day it is still my favorite <br>But I love all your music anyways!! Keep up the amazing work Replacer!

This is the first song of yours I ever heard and to this day it is still my favorite
But I love all your music anyways!! Keep up the amazing work Replacer!


Can't stop listening to this, it's so awesome!
It's been stuck in my head since the moment I heard it, and I love it.


Replacer deserves so much more views!

Recently, I moved to London but my sister is staying back home with my mum! We've been REALLY close and through the depressingly bad household we was brought up in, we ALWAYS had each other, now I'm moving away from the bad house ... It's really upsetting for the both of us, I know she'd be happier here especially with me but she's stuck in one of the worst places ever! This song explains exactly how I feel, I really hope she'll be alright.


T.T
Wow, simply wow. This actually made me shed a tear... The lyrics are just so... heartfelt, so touching, so close to home...

Thank you.


2022, my mp3 still states june 2013, nothing beats summers of the early mlp days. i always come back this song and many of foozogz old art, it's beautiful


after all this time, still an amazing song.


I cannot even express how much I love this song.  And all of your songs, because you have never gone wrong once. But this track is chillingly beautiful.  I don't care how many subscribers you have or the views per video, in my mind you are absolutely the best there is.  <3


I was told today that my level of happiness, kindness, and hope for the world is unsustainable.  I hope not, but I sometimes wonder.  I have seen extremely kind people start to shatter a little, or turn away from the light.  I hope the bitterness never reaches you.  Even when the rush of ponies is far past, let's hold onto this.  This song's beautiful.


I have the feeling this will be on eternal repeat as soon as I get it on my iPod. Amazing song!


amazing song, so beautiful and original, love the lyrics


This song IS AMAZING well done I cant quite state how awesome it truly is


Replacer, you have amazing songs. I literally fall asleep when I listen to them late in the night (in a good way :) )


I love that you embed your album art into the mp3. Also, amazing song. :D


I was in England recently and had very limited internet access.
The day I was about to leave the only place I could access internet on I snatched an Eqd post of this song, so I downloaded it to my MP3 without listing to it first.

Then while traveling in a rental car through the country-side i played  it in my ears... It was so undescribingly glorious.
I re listened it many times then during stays on hotels, and on the airplane back.


Why can I favorite this only once? Man I really love your stuff, and while I'm sure this will be drowned in a sea of similar opinions I want you to know I really do like your stuff bud.

Here is hoping you are happy and may misfortune forever be foreign to your doorstep.


This is probably the first fan-music for mlp i have actually loved, sure others are good too but this music is just great.


Awesome awesome amazing. The beat is so catchy, the words are so meaningful, there's so much emotion, I can't stop listening!


Then, at the end, the crowd erupts into a huge roar of cheers, and you see everyone's favorite ponies staring with wide smiles, touched by the song, as Replacer stares back at them with a wistful smile of his own.....


This is music at his finest. This would put a lot of musicians playing on the radio to shame. Really. It's incredible we have composers this talented in our fandom.

People should make listen this song to their close friend(s) who still don't get it about MLP. That would give them the idea how much we love those ponies. How far we go to show it. Musically.


Just found this song after having the aviator's remix come up in my huge playlist; love both versions <3


This is just... wow. I listened to this when it first came out, but listening to it with this meaning... it's just beautiful. Well, MORE beautiful, anyways.


I hate and love this song, I can't hear it without threatening an emotional breakdown, but I also refuse to remove it from my playlist. If emotional responds is what you wanted to create with this song, A+, might not have made any baby pandas cry, but a grown man.


Man, I need to learn how to make music like this... It's just so beautiful...


You my good sir, deserve way more attention then you're getting


Replacer, the pony who continues to defy the notion of musical genres. Keep up the good work.


this song is amazing!! its definitely one of my new favorites! :D


You give me goosebumps. It's an amazing song, thank you !


This was though, my first brony song I heard a little under a year ago.  I've almost hit my anniversary!


I never really got into mlp but man the fan music is really good you are amazing at what you do


This song really reminds me of the fragility of long distance relationships, It's such a touching song. When he starts talking about hoping to get to see you, I hope I get to see you smile..I just want to cry at that point.


Heard this for the first time at Everfree. I really love it. :)


I really did enjoy listening to this song no matter where I am. The singing and lyrics Appeal to the heart. In my opinion that's the best type of song.


This song broke a two week long period of writers' block.

Thank you, more than you can imagine, thank you.


After I thought about it I think that your song would defienatly be one of  the most sweet and soft spoken original songs from a brony I 've heard thanks


Your music is unique, maybe that is why it draws to my attention. I love it!


The love already shines my friend, but I agree. Any and all of us should be more upfront and proud of our wonderful fandom, our wonderful family. We are united by love of either want or kindness, not unlike those brought together by the need to call of arms, the want to keep family safe. No matter what love will shine from all of us, because we are Bronies. Be we in blood or in love but we here are all family, and I hope we can all say that we're proud.

~Edward Vocalism


Coming into the brony music community line that is excellent


Your songs.. they are filled with so much feel... Feel overload...

Its..so..wonderful :)


The section starting at 3:48 makes me think of Pete Townsend's 70s and 80s synth layering on Who albums and solo work.


Congrats on getting into the Bronies documentary! The credits say "'Song for an Earth Pony' Written, performed by, and courtesy of Ben Grey McKenzie"


I saw this and was like, "Hey. I like earth ponies, my OC is an earth pony, maybe this will be about how awesome we are." No.  This was soul crushing for like 3 different simultaneous reasons. Made worse by the song still being very nice. so now there's not even anything to blame. R.I.P my powderized soul.


Hey man, your very talented, and your songs are great!


God, this is terrific. Reminds me of the Jonsi song at the end of How to Train Your Dragons. Terrific work all across the board.


3:45 that melody just melts your heart :)


When I first heard this song it made me feel like fighting. Fighting to defend against something, not to attack something.


I'm not sure why I wasn't subbed, but that problem was quickly corrected. This is a wonderful piece that provokes actual emotional responses, unlike much of the music out there today. Thank you for writing and recording this song.


This really is a great song. Very beautiful


I usually do not like brony music with original vocals, I rarely rarely do. But hot damn, this is great!


Earth ponies don't get enough lovin in this fandom.
Thank you, irreplaceable Replacer.


i have no words that can give this song justice, its just that good.


You should take the part between "I know one day you're gonna fly" and "we could retire to the stratosphere" and mix it into its own stand alone instrumental piece


This has taken the #200 spot on my pony music playlist.


I absolutely love this song, but I can't seem to listen to it as much as I'd like, as it always seems puts me to sleep >~<<br>At least it's rather helpful ^^;

I absolutely love this song, but I can't seem to listen to it as much as I'd like, as it always seems puts me to sleep >~<
At least it's rather helpful ^^;


Another great song. Replacer, you are a musical master.


You astound me, you honestly do. And I hate to say this, but if you were to do some non-pony tracks I honestly think you could be a successful independent artist and sell your work.


I can't help but imagine to this song a packed house in a stadium at canterlot, which in flashing lights outside says REPLACER LIVE. And on the inside, you see a stadium full of cheering ponies, including the Mane six and everyone's favorite backgrounders. As smoke comes out on the stage, they chant "RE-PLACE-ER! RE-PLACE-ER!" Then Repalcer comes out and starts singing, and everything goes quiet. As the sogn palys, unicorns light up their horns and swing along to the music.


Still listening 9 years later lol<br>you made one hell of a banger dude ;3

Still listening 9 years later lol
you made one hell of a banger dude ;3


damn when was the last time I listened to this<br>never really liked mlp but this song is freaking amazing

damn when was the last time I listened to this
never really liked mlp but this song is freaking amazing


Best song by you since Cerulean Blue. Great job.


20th time listening to this and it is still beautiful


When I heard this one and then Elie Monty's/Sim Gretina's song Again my mind combined them into a story. This one would take place after Again. I mean the peguses is blue in both songs and they both feature an earth mare. In Again it would be her pov, but afterwards something happens to her and then Song for an Earth Pony happens. It's from his perspective and he's mourning her. The lyrics even fit. In Again she says she wasnt to fly then here, he says he hopes she'll fly one day. Idk just me...


Before, I was looking deep into the brony music community, but I always got too distracted by other musicians to check out your channel. Though I'm still hunting for more musicians, I was able to get here some time ago. Only just now was I able to notice how low the views are. Don't get me wrong, a hundred thousand is great, but I always thought of this song as more of a brony classic, and expected to see this close to a million. Regardless; to anyone who's ever heard it, this is a classic.


Best music to draw to, you're really inspiring :D


This is my first time hearing this song. And it's amazing!


As long as it's not one of those sad songs with a despicably happy tune....


I don't know how you do it, but you've got some of the coolest drum sequences I've ever heard!
And you're lyrics! D:
How do you do it!? I must know~....


I love this song KEEP MAKING GOOD MUSIC!!!!


Now that I know of the replacement phase in narcissistic relationships that Sam Vaknin talked about (happening along with the discard phase) I'm dead certain that somebody will <b>gulp</b> replace me.

Now that I know of the replacement phase in narcissistic relationships that Sam Vaknin talked about (happening along with the discard phase) I'm dead certain that somebody will *gulp* replace me.


I feel like Happy, because Im always searching for my friends. and i always feel abandoned by the people I love. except for me its the opposite. like im the earth pony, and i don't deserve friends like the ones i have, who leave me out, like im the one whose with go first in a hunger games. even though i stick up for all of them, and face the bullies. I am the only one who knows pain out of them. i still  hope, they will realize what they do to me. Nice song, really lovely. :) I love it.


You always deliver dude. This is awesome.


Replacer songs will always make me fondly remember my time in Minecraft. So many hours of tedious digging made a breeze by these perfectly paced songs.


This is the first vocal music within the fandom I've ever taken a liking to. Thank you, dominian42.


I love the beat of this.  Are those little beeps a synth?  Because I love the sound of them.


This is great! In fact, I'd say it is one of your best.


you will never be replaced, at least in my heart :,3


My take: he's been watching Pinkie from above and sees her inner sadness, falls for her at some point. He desires to save her but feels unworthy of her. Conflicted, he hopes nopony replaces him while he builds his resolve to confront his fears.

More likely it's inspired by a real girl though. Good luck!


This song is so sad!  But, at least there's hope within.  Best wishes, Replacer.


Someday, I'm gonna remix this. Downloading the song and acapella now. This is so good X3


all i have to sat about this song is thank you. i find this beautiful


This is magic and will be played forever! I AM IN THE PRESENCE OF AMAZING IN ESSENCE! Sorry, just had to caps-love for a moment there. This is amazing and should be more well known.


SOON THE GLORIOUS PROLETARIAT WILL RISE TO A RED DAWN OF BLOODSH-

I mean, I just think earth ponies can be a bit underrated sometimes.

I'm the only one of my friends to have an earth pony oc

@6GameandWatch19 That's false actually, nice try though ^_^

When you say, "BLOODSH-" (pause then refrain to false statement) you should really type or cut off at, "BLOODISH-". But you could be saying bloodshed, then that means trying to create a sense of in-completion in your liking means I have failed, and my true purpose , (engineering,correction,innovation) isn't what I'm meant for.

That's a theory I heard somewhere about MLP Tales. The Earth Ponies were tired of the oppression from Pegasi and Unicorns, so they slaughtered all of them, and years later, they're just going to highschool and doing Jazzercize and wearing leggings, forgetting the genocide of their oppressors generations before.


Ah... I'm in literal tears. I need to hug your OC, stat. And/or you, as I really feel like this came from the heart. AH ALL THESE TEARS.


Psst!
IT's almost 2020 and I still listen to this song
Talk about good stuff <3


Still one of the best brony songs, if not number one.


Really cool.  I came here from the top 25 songs of 2012, so congratulations for getting in.  But this...I think it was my favourite.  =)


That really means a lot...Thank you for supporting me since day one :)


Replacer makes the BEST vocal music in this fandom alongside Mandopony, and Coconeru.


I have a motto you know... It's quite a funny one, I made it when I was five.

I see life like a game of cricket,
Some people are players,
Some on the sidelines,
Some people get bored half way through.
But it comes down to this:
Doesn't matter what you aim for,
Everyone's just trying to get the biggest score.

Neat isn't it?

~Edward Vocalism


Just found this song because of Paleo's top 7, absolutely love it.


The music sounds upbeat and yet... it's not. I love it.


I love 2:39 - 3:01 the best. The whole song is great that is just my favorite part


This song is so good :D It makes me sad and happy at the same time.


Now I feel lame for not creating an awesome video in my mind to this beatiful song.


You could try downloading the midi and seeing which notes are being played by putting it through synthesia or a DAW like FL studio. I think since it's a midi you'll be able to see each note played by each instrument. A word of warning though, the Midi sounds horrible since it uses the same instrument for each channel, but you can probably figure out which channel should be which instrument by comparing it to the original track!

...

I mean, that's how I'd do it, I guess you could do it by ear!


I herd this in saberpark's brony music 2012 countdown, I can't stop listening to it. Thanks for your wander full talent, please make more. Bro Hoof /)


You better watch out Replacer. If you keep making songs like this, someone's going to end up writing love songs about YOU.


There is something about this song that triggers all of my kind emotions all at once...


What genre of music is it? It's so relaxing and catchy! I'd really love to know the answer.


i think this is the only song EVER i cried to. because it's so beautiful. i think it's the first time i cried from beauty, thank you Replacer


Hey dude, there's something wrong with the MP3 download link that you have in the description. I just tried downloading another one of your amazing songs and for some reason it only gave me the first 2 minuets of the 6 1/2 min song. The other weird thing is that the waiting time for it to download said that it would take an hour and it took half an hour when usually it only takes a few seconds or a min or two to download one of your songs. If you could check it out I'd really appreciate it.


Hey man, just found your channel, love your music, subbed and stuff. Thought that might be nice to hear. :3


No. It's not mainstream enough. Do you think a radio station would add any pony related song to their playlist? Maybe, but probably not. I mean no offense.

I say this, of course, as a huge brony myself. That's how I found Replacer, and his awesome music! ^^ Keep rockin', Replacer.


You are now my favorite brownie musician.

@survivRAWRR Vasquez Me three! why do we find the same vids surviv?


This song goes so deep if you think about it........ Talk to someone who is well known and they are humbled about it. When they start to see how big they are they panic....


Such a good song, on top 100 brony song list and the best songs of 2012, happy new year


Looking at the comments here, I find it interesting how much people's interpretations diverge. I always thought it pretty obvious that this was a song about fame, and how it doesn't make you better but it makes people treat you like you're better than them. It's about feelings of inadequacy that you can't express to the people who look up to you, isn't it?

I mean, "sometimes I think it's all I'm good for" seems pretty blatant. And flight is clearly being used as a metaphor for fame. The only thing I've never been able to decide is whether that earth pony for whom you do not think you are good enough represents a real person.


i still listen to this song now that my pony is now a pegasus ^_^ i like how your voice is so soft as you sing this keep up the good work =D ~ Saga


This song may be one of the greatest things my ears have been raped with countless times <3

 Replacer, Keep being amazing <3


i am an earth pony and i am proud to be one! =D also i love the song ^^ ~ Starshine

>has alicorn oc as profile pic<br>seems legit.

>has alicorn oc as profile pic
seems legit.


Edward vocalism, you are actually amazing and I look up to you


i feel like im having an out of body experience to brony music


Man I can't stop listening to this!
Did anyone find out the chords?
I think the bass is B  G  F#, but it sounds wierd


wow, beautiful... it kind of makes me sad though. but thoughtful too.


why do you keep writing songs about my life??
any ways this is amazing like always keep up the awesome work!


I have to say I love your song and the best luck to you I listen to all your songs I hope the future ones great!


thanks for releasing a instrumental for us I'm hoping to make a cover of this.


I like the song, it just seems like its only got one layer throughout the song. No disrespect meant, this is an amazing song, my siggestion would be a bass/tenor/alto instrument line. Overall a great job in your part Replacer.


I listened to this after a huge arguement with my "friend" you don't know how much this soothed me.


I love all of your work they are amazing this was so somber if kinda just flowed.into me :D I loved it


holy crap, good job dude! it reminds me of nine inch nails :)


ALL THE AWARDS /)
Does anyone agree with my view of the story?: The pegasus had a special somepony who was an earth pony and was caught in an accident and died. The pegasus, which I dub Falling Notes, wasn't there when the accident occured and tried to find the earth pony, while subconciously realizing from the start that she was dead, but searched anyway.


I just always kind of imagined it was a meta song.


I really want to know what the story of these two characters are. I get a lot of it, but not all. I NEED TO KNOW, REPLACER.


This is great.
Subscribed after 2 mins of listening.


Hey, Replacer! Are you ever going to put this song and any others that aren't on your Bandcamp up there? It would be nice to have a place where all your music can be bought at once haha.


Usually I just walk everywhere and I work from home so I have no reason to drive. But yesterday I went to visit a family member and listened to the radio in the car. After about 20 seconds I shut it off and took out my iPod so I could listen to this song instead.


This song made me cry the first time I heard it and it's making me cry the 20th time around.


Dude this song, brought tears to my eyes ;-; <3


The amount of times I have listened to this is ridiculous!


i swear i feel so bad when it seems like its over and then it resumes and i just restart living all over again


AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA more replacer! definitely worth the wait, sire


this is just........ugh right in the feels


Came here from DrDissonance. Absolutely brilliant song. Subbed and keep up the amazing work.


This song gives me chills... cause for some reason, it's so creepy...


why can't I stop listening to this?  Good job Replacer!


this song made me kry its amazing and so r u keep up the good work


i luv ur voice =3 i always sing this song while im listening to it =3


the part around 4:00 I can just hear a deep and resonant marimba doing beautifully.  Can someone please mix this up?  cont. from previous comment.


I showed my parents your music, and they though you were some ABBA + Beach Boys style singer. I asked them if they knew you, and they were like OH YEAH, listened to his stuff back in the Cold War days studying in Moscow. LOL! xD

(they don't know english too well :3)


I know this is for the fans. But every once in awhile i'm just hoping you do something for your self and relax.

Fame isn't something easy to deal with. Don't let it rule you.

"You are your self, no matter how life changes around you." -Unknown Author


Earth pony for FTW!
Cant believe I just now subscribed, I have liked every song of yours iv heard but just now started looking for them


well ur on my mind. i was drawing and listening to this and i didnt know what i was drawin til it was over and guess what it was? ... replacer <3


thank you you are the type of brony every brony should know now all puns aside thanks for responding you made my day :D


You do not have the will to fight us. In the end, all will fall before the Pegasus Council.


So sad yet I can't stop listening. I need to go watch something funny to feel better.


It's custom where I live, down here in Oxfordshire we all sing things with our own names. Like how when you write a card, you put a name and some little x's down bottom. Only we do it on all business and/or public things, without the kisses. I hope that clears up any doubts or concerns you may have had.

~Edward Vocalism


I think this represents moving on From the loss of a friend.


This is very pretty. Thank you very much.


Oooooo! I only just saw the blue version of the MLP logo at the end! That looks pretty nice!


as far as I know it was not made into a full fanfic, just something these guys came up with for the song.


What are all the instruments used in this song?


my Ponified self is an earthpony, and i love this song so much <3


More addicting than Neapolitan Dreams(Nilow Remix)


You got your own EQD post for this and it was completely deserved!


i was wondering why i like this so much and i realize its a narrative of current events


i think its him who got in an accident and wants to be there to support the earth pony in her time of need and grieving for him. if you look at the lyrics a little closer it seems like he wishes he could be there but all he can do is watch from above and hope she finds someone new without ever losing him from her memories. thats what im getting from this song. i think you guys have it backwards.


If this is not in the top 25 songs of 2012 I am going to be pissed.


Hell, I already dream about him at night.


Just listened to. love! Subscribed! Love it.


Wonderful song as usual. :)

Do you have a Bandcamp?


i was a furry before I was a brony, in fact i was looking at furry music videos when i first found the video that made me a brony


That second part makes me think that you've never watched Friendship is Witchcraft.


I'm surprised that I still have words to speak but they are few and they are "That song is amazing".


After giving it much thought I went outside the box and called him Happy.


not sure if you remember me, but it's poni from FJ :D
I always listen to some of your stuff to calm my mind, it's beautiful <3


Thank you, I really went all out on this one, all these comments mean a great deal :) As for my OC....well as long as you're gentle? >.>


Why does it feel like he's personally singing this song to me?


This song reminds me of something Big Audio Dynamite might have made!


Hay ya think you can make an instrumental for this? I would love it


Sounds pretty intense. I am going to have to listen to this with my ganja goggles on... This will rape my mind.


YOUR VOICE.
It's like listening to satin c:


I tried to import the midi in my Guitar Pro (which normally works) but it failed.
I'll check out those programs, thanks!


sounds like somepony got into the friendzone
I don't understand how such a happy melody can be filled with so much sadness


I've sent out the message! my most hopeful animator is BronyDanceParty, they are known for animated music videos!


I think, a good song or melody, you shouldn't be able to pause.
And even tough this song has alot of parts where there is no primairy voice, I could simply not pause this song.
In other words, I love this video :D
and I peed my pants...


I hope you inspired a Brony animator, because that would be epic. I am going to tell EVERY Brony animator I know of about this. o_o


OKAY GUYS.

I've been a brony since G1 and a furry since... I dunno, a couple years ago? But day one, guys, you learn, yiff (or yiffy) is furry sex, or furry porn for some people.

Yiff is also categorized as the fabled noise that arctic foxes make when mating. But that's not important. Thing is, it's not as bad as they're portraying it. Quite obviously virgin eyes. :/


Ohmygosh! bloody marvelous song comrade! ;D


keep that passion flowing the love will shine


I checked it out... the download seemed to go ok, and I don't notice any problems with the mp3. Perhaps Mediafire screwed up temporarily? You could also get the song from my soundcloud (link in description) if you keep having issues.


lolz, i cant help but feel that this song is deticated to me <3 (only because my ponified self is an earth pony)


Hmm... This song makes me feel a sense of guilt.
Good job anyway.


u r good for SO manny things. u hav a perfect voice, ur world wide, and DOUNRIGHT AWESOME! what more do people want then for u to be urself?


This is scarely accurate at this point at time, and have gone all sentimental and shizz, thanks :)


I was 11 when I fist heard this song and now I'm coming 18 wtf


I'm really bad at interpreting songs... I really enjoy the song but don't understand who it's meant for. The first part seems to be to us your fans, but the other part, I can't figure it out. Anyhow, keep up the great music!


it's a good vid, deserving of the views it has


One shoulde simply enjoy and foretell about its wonder and amusement to fellow mares and stallions from all over.


From what I can gather in the lyrics, the Earth Pony isn't quite dead yet.  It seems like she's in some sort of coma, maybe.  He talks about how he hopes one day, and other things like they could retire to the stratosphere, as if she hasn't done that already.


I've listened to this song quite a few times now, and wow.

All I can decipher is that said pony speaking, is dead?


i am a eart pony and i like the way i am

your song is great BRAVO!!! :3


well said my brother, im with u all the way


16 people do, and will NEVER be one of them :D THIS SONG IS AWESOME!!!!!!


"sometimes I think its just too big for me" thats what he says. So, youre correct!


I realy really really liked this and i was wondering if you could do a song for a unicorn? PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!


What an adorable sounding song. You sound adorable.


Hey, Replacer, like makkon06 said, you could sell this stuff. Pony and non-pony alike. I'd pay some cold, hard cash for this. Part of me really wants to.


Some how.. This reminds me of banjo tooie...


I meant it's the 200th song I've added to my music playlist. I don't actually think of it as that low. I only just found it.


Hey, I'm really sorry, but could someone please explain to me the story behind the song? I'm not good at interpreting lyrics.... :P


At least you're open minded about music. That's pretty cool. :3


Whomever those two people are that disliked this...
I don't even know what they deserve. Something terrible.
Suggestions, anypony?


I have been listening to this non-stop someone help me! Just, help me in a way that doesn't involve not listening to the song.


I am sorry if this impugnes upon your artistic integrity, but is this song a cover? It sounds kind of familiar to me. Sounds fantastic, and all props to you either way.


Geez my first fandom song is two years old ;-;


im an alicorn pony and proud ^^ i love the song too ^^ ~ Saga


Add to:playlist, add to: favorites, liked!!!!!


And then he is willing to drop everything he have just to meet here again and he don't know if she reciprocate his feeling.

He thinks that it will be easier if they end up being enemy (hate each other) rather than want to be with her but cannot.

But, in the end, he is not giving up to find his most dearest friends he love so much.

And finally, he hopes no one takes his place in her life.... yet.


"I know one day you're gonna fly" ? I though this was a song for en Earth pony........


Good God! Bronies make music that is far better then normal music!
BRONIES WE ARE ONE


I... I cried at this song at Ponycon. ;-;


Oh god those awsome vocals of your's you gotta teach me them...

~paws


this song for me is the little blue break inbetween the clouds right now


I'm not crying my eyes are just sweating


It's a quote they always do that with quotes like
 A good mind and a good heart are a formidable combination
 -Nelson Mandela


Chuck Norris is a brony? Awesome.....just.....awesome.


I think this is about a pegasus whose lose a certain earth pony he care.

The pegasus is a popular musician who respect and care for the earth pony because of her support before he is popular. But, with his popularity rising, he gain distance to the earth pony. Then after a long time of his busy activity which makes him hasn't meet the earth pony for a long time, he can't find her.

At first he is accepting the fact that he won't meet here again but then he really hopes he will meet her. [CONT]


I'll never understand the "Sometimes I think that's all I'm good for" mentality. What, that's not enough for you? Some of us don't even have that much.
I think a lot of people don't realize how good they have it in life.
Reminds me of the year some hackers took down Xbox Live for a while on Christmas Day. "People should be spending time with their families."
"Yeah well some of us don't have that privilege. Now please just let me have my games back."


If I had a dollar for every time I hated this song, I would have negative $1 million.


Hey, I'm a pegasister!
I don't have an MLP based icon and I won't change it..
Doesn't mean I'm not a fan of the series :3
(Or this artist)


Every time I see that picture I think of P-21. I'm not sure if its the tone of the song or the fact that he looks just like your OC but without the wings.


Yeah. I wish I could see my sister, the reason I changed. I used to be a pegasus. :)


artist  bronies are more then capable of being a talented one why not beat your song to a whimsical play


Somehow I managed to forget to subscribe when I heard Cerulean Blue.

I'm glad to finally right this wrong.


I always thought that the song ended with; '"I hope nopony misses me"


I assume so, you would have to bow down to him if he did exist.


It sounds to me like there was an accident, or something where the two of them just split up.  idk.  That's a really good view, actually now that I think of it


the mediafire download isnt working for me, can you fix it please? I really love this song :) thank you sir


He ran under the name Bron-ee, but I assured him, that existence is not for him.


I always have felt bad for earth ponies. They don't have the ability to fly in the clouds or do magic spells. They just stay on the ground.


Hey, Replacer, what's the name of the blue pegasus? I like him...


By the by, how do I give you money? For all the music of yours I listen to, it would be remiss of me if I didn't at least ask if I could express my gratitude in a more meaningful way than the verbal.


Don't usually reply to people on YouTube, but dude you awesome


I just love the grass block cutie mark of yours :D


Hey well thanks for taking the time out of your busy day to answer my concern. I think Mediafire might have glitched like you said. I also noticed that another person experienced the same problem so I'm glad that it just wasn't me. I'm wondering if the "Flash-Back" virus has to do anything with it since the news said that it wouldn't take affect till monday. Well anyways, I re-downloaded the song and it works perfectly now!


I was wondering to whom this song is dedicated to. Is it a personal thing? Or is it something else?


not necessarily, you don't need a pony avatar to be a brony, though I bet he gets a lot of hate for that avatar, being a furry and now a brony.


im like in love with this song I cat stop playing it


I love you and this is amazing and makes me smile :D


I think he was in a relationship and they were seperated and he's wishing he could be there for her and if he's even on her mind. That's sort of what I'm seeing.


now though since i draw oh so good, i feel that way because noone actually knows me and its well into the school year


Kinda like Andrew WK, but happy/sad instead of happy/totallyfuckin'crazy.


Lilo: This is you, this red line is your kindness level.  As you can see it is unnaturally high for someone your size.  we need to be careful not to let it get any higher or you might explode from kindness overload.


I used to be a pegasus. :) My boyfriend is just a dolt who doesn't think and I clean up after his destruction usually. I am sorry about all that he has done. He found me and liked me still. IDK why to this day.


to me this song says that this guy likes his pony so very much he wants go to equestria and see him. But he slowly looses his sanity in the process.


I font know what it's about but : con grades : the base and treb are just right


There are 2 possiblities for me. 1. The story you tell, but with the diffrence that the "accident" was suicide. Verses 4/5/8 indicate that for me.

Or it's a failed relationship, indicated by Verses 2/3/6 and the last line.


God I can't believe the ridiculous amount of bullshit in the comments section about how pegasi are stupid and alicorns and all kinds of disappointing, non-tolerant crap. Well, at least it gives this song the extra comments and views it deserves, right?

By the way, beautiful song, Replacer. You're amazing.


This song as a good mix of a dark and happy side i tip my hat 4 u
and i almost forgot /)


oh hey lupine, love your tracks as well ^.^


I have to agree with Makkon there. You can be the next, like, Of Montreal, but your style is very different and unique.


Replacer: If he did not exist, it would be necessary to invent him.


brought here by d.notive. Stayed and subbed for great music!


Yeah I know i just always get my music off of iTunes.


lmao the MIDI version sounds like a ragtime song. xD


All I can think about is the freindzone. WHY DOES THIS MAKE ME THINK OF THE FREIND ZONE?!


Listening to it again, the accident sounds like HE died. And that his earth pony friend will die one day (I know one day you're gonna fly).


Trust me, my boyfriend just USED to hate pegasi until I met him. Now, I have changed and so has he. He wan born alicorn. He doesn't think much either. Don't tell him :p


who every your singing this about is a very lucky pony :}


one of my friends lied to me..... he said he was a brony but he was just another spoiled kid


after song....<br> WANT TO LEARN THIS XD


I'm studying to be a paramedic, so i guess it's because i've seen worse.


Oh my god... Some pony animate that right now.


/) for the Earth Ponies!<br>Sadly my OC is a Pegasus.

/) for the Earth Ponies!
Sadly my OC is a Pegasus.

@***** And yes I did steal that from you, but my part was the subtitles :) haha

@***** From what I heard the oc's are
Earth Pony - Strong and Hardworking (Unless you're Pinkie Pie)
Pegisi - Really Athletic and Outgoing (Unless you're Fluttershy)
Unicorn - Very Intellectual

@replacer my oc is a unicorn, i like pegisi better in my own opinion, but my friend said i was most like a unicorn, for e.g.

earth ponies=hard workers like to help other ponies
pegisi=mostly athletic, could be hard workers to
unicorns=wise and very smart

@replacer True, I just wanted to point out that I appreciate the Earth Ponies but I am not one, I guess I am not really "Sad" about it... anyways. Great song! You make some really really good songs! Keep it up :)


At least the pegasi know how to use proper grammar.


Don't you mean a little "Yiff"-y?
HAHAHAHAHAHA
I'll go home now


This good this good this good this good this good this good this good this good this good this good this good...


Derp forgot to mention that it took 45 minutes to download it too lol on a super slow internet connection, I just barely completed the download right before leaving for Brighton, from a village called Woodbury.


Well only one thing comes to mind for this. Song you just speak to me, can anyone say best song ever? (Pinkie pie) "BEST SONG EVER!"


I JUST realized that the last line in this song is "I hope nopony replaces me" and that your name is Replacer. O_o


dont you love it how brony music is better than all the popular music at the moment


Eeyup didn't take that long for me to change mine.

Bronies forever. /)


it confuses me that bronies and furries are hated so much.  are we hurting anybody?  it seems as though the very fact that we are not hurting anybody is what makes people hated.


I want to thank you for inspiring me, I shouldn't lie when truth will serve


they make food, and are wonderful none the less


Seems like you are already getting the hang of it.


That's a thought, I'll see what I can do.


um, not all unicorns consider themselves roayal, and not all pegasai are ruled by the same government.  flawed logic is flawed.


even less here in West Virginia.
>only brony within 100mi.
>only homestuck fan in the county
>know those feels well


Also doesn't speak much that you honor what the show is about: Love and Tolerance.  All this hate doesn't really sound like a good MLP fan. :|


Pinkie will be your therapist.Yes!She has a lot of experience with therapy.


Me 5 minutes ago~ Why not? It can't be...

Now~...shit!!!! Mother of God, SIMBA! What did they do to you?!!!!!


It seems to me that all of the pictures/of/to/music you create all resemble feelings of being/to distress. And of that I question your ability of making people happy. So this all begs the question, what troubles you?


I don't think you know furries all to well. but neither do I so I guess this whole conversation is void.


16 people just didn't like the video or enjoy it.


Yiffy is that one scary part of the furry fandom that is into funrry pornography.


THATS who you remind me of in this song. Jonsi!


Awesome keep it up and...don't kill your self please :D


We need a new top comment here! Somepony! Write something good! This video deserves it.


oh cool! i was really surprised for a bit!


came over here to give this to everypony : /)


It's rude to ask for someones name, when you havn't introduced yourself, yourself..


3:17 reminded me of UP for some reason...


YOU KNOW 1T >:]. Glad to see another homestuck. don't have many here in Manchester.


I find it odd how I found this one well song from going through one of sorianflight's song


Silly Replacer! Nopony will EVER replace you! =D


Aaaaand 2 days later you have about 9,500 views. xD That didn't take long at all!


Wow, this I didn't expect to see.  Good answer, BTW.


Sir, do i have to get Mr.Lee. Or better yet do i have to get IP pony.


that seems a lot like racial discrimination, you can't judge everypony based on what they are.


GOD THIS SONG I GIVE IT ALL MY INTERNETS and this song obviously has a story but what i have so far is your friend has gotten lost in some freak accident and you tried and failed to find him?


It varies; this pic was made by my friend Feather~


By look that some, i am a pegasus and i make my bf a pegasus. How? ... Magic x)


guys just get off the topic of "Yiffy" it may be disgusting but PUT UP WITH IT
The Internets weird so what?
Just listen to this song and find out how awesome it is :3


I think the c mark is a cloud and 2 half notes


(/
Other names: Skyward Song, Cloud Harmony, Skybeat, or Cumulous Chords.(Forget the last one. It sounds stupid.)


Shoulda used urban dictionary. *facehoof*


There are only 2 men in the world i would go gay for. Replacer is only second to jon gooch.


well never heard of you so don't know if your one of the handful of trust worthy ones. death to pegasi and glory to the alicorn empire


um so what happened to love and tolerance? lol


i wouldn't say its hate. its just a different point of view that they say out lout! :3


Wait, is he singing to Fluttershy?   /derp


Read the description; there's a link at the bottom.


You may try, but you are few, and we are many!


Something like that.

But yeah, somepony is dead.


Your icon gives me suspicion that you are not really Chuck Norris, eh, AppleJack!


Doesn't even faze me anymore. God I'm jaded.


holly shit he responded. that's a first from any creator of a video actually looking in there comments section.


You just doomed me, and countless others.


so, it's not you that hates pegasai, it's your oc, is this correct?


Why did you sign it at the bottom?

-Skyler


i honestly dont know, just not enough time or internets at home i guess.


Also doesn't speak much that you honor what the show is about: Love and Tolerance. All this hate doesn't really sound like a good MLP fan. :|


But you can switch to like by clicking like....


well here is a explanation why i hate pegasi. now my pony logic stems from this the world my oc lives in theres mult worlds (example their are 4 known dr hooves the professor ,twi and the doc ,derpy and the doc and discorded hooves) the one mine lives in he was one of the few to escape the rainbow factory and grew a ever lasting hatred for pegasi and try every thing in his power to kill them and for unicorns i just hate them out of pure racisam


You are right about that. :) Even porn in this fandom is a disturbance to my mind. Okay all porn is. XD


I was wondering, why is that his name? :)


realy? huh any way glory to the alicorn empire and it's ruler golden emperor


If your a furry i suppose its not gross.... But we are not so its a tad bit odd.


I love the places people go when they interpret this song

Well, it sort of sums up a earth ponies life back when. You know how they were basically slaves. The song I think show what they think....(lol idk XD)


Its  about Pinkie Pie? If it true, this song 20% coller! (bad english :<)


This music isn't horrible, it doesn't make my ears bleed, it doesn't even make me wanna kill my family! gr8 job m80!


argument invalid.
Terezi Pyrope (best troll) has spoken.


I am a guy who doesn't believe any music is better than any other music, but it's really hard not to think this is way better than my music ever will be. XD


No offense was taken AT ALL. I was just pondering the choice of words.


But if he is one of the greatest martial artists that ever lived and kicked chuck norris's ass , wouldn't that make everyone who isnt bruce lee a pussy.

I am assuming he is the one who won all the firs place ribbons at the rodeo


Your popular enough for the Youtube view glitch and 218 likes - 0 dislikes WOOO


But seriously, I see this comment like two times a day :D


So... What were you trying to state there?


idk if thats the same as yiff but for ur eyes dont google that :P


Tztztz, haven't you learned by now that one does not simply google imagesearch things one doesn't know?


The MIDI sounds horrible since it uses the same instrument for each channel. Would you mind reuploading a better version of it? It'd be super cool to hear it properly.

Ah, okay. Well I'd still be happy if you put up a version for listening, but of course it's up to you :)

the midi file was not really meant for listening, it's just note input data for producers who might've wanted to do something with the song :)


BWÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁÁ
No moar please xD


Wow this is amazing.
lazy comment is lazy


So sorry but I warned you... the internet is a dangerous place.


@EgonGausley (Awkward; Accidentally posted) ANYWAY... At 4:45 what does the singer say? I know the lyrics say "too big for me" but every time I replay it, I hear something else...


cant figure out what its about can ya'll fill me in?

I thought that it was perhaps about an earth pony who was unhappy with their race, the fact they were an earth pony, and so life is hard for them, but he is trying to convince them they are better than what they think and that just because they are an earth pony doesn't mean they aren't special.


Also, what the heck is going on in the comment section. Seriously...just...I dont understand...


Applejack is Chuck Norris. Do not reverse it.


Haha, 301 views and 298 likes. The way it should be.


WARNING: If you're not into furry, do NOT click (show the comment). If you are, then continue with this comment chain.
YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED.


OH MY GOD I google imagesearched it do NOT do that. >.< My eyes....


get an ad-blocker-- im not sure if adblock will do it, but i have a bunch of extensions up for my web browser and done ever see ads, even for vevo videos.


CHUCK NORRIS IS A BRONY?! lolz, *brohoof*


I'm sorry! :O Maybe Urban Dictionary search it guys, words can't hurt as much as pictures.


You shouldn't, iTunes give shit to the artist and takes big margins, it's better to use bandcamp which is much more just to the ones actually making the music! ^^


true you may have a contanent and we have 1 town thats built over the trator god castle we may have a very low population but we have tech to reach other dimensions we have mechs the size of buildings 50% of the pop are alicorns and we have hundreds of timber wolfs ursa major and minors allys of zebras from a other world and a royal family that has many replacements for the emperor a new luner republic vassles stong and young your so called council will fall


CONGRATULATION I KNOW FOLOW YOU BECAUSE YOU SEEMS COOL...

\(^o^)/ \[°_°]/ *PARTAY* WIZ* *DA* *ROBOTS*


I saw things I shouldn't have        ;-;

I saw things I shouldn't have        ;-;


yea it was the video to "You're Gonna Go Far Kid" by SlutFox


Supid Mediafire is freezing that dl link. 8*(

I can't live without your tunage!


Or probably the one that he is talking about is dead.


it was just a joke about an 'iffy' profile pic. no offense meant


The first word; i like comment & subscribe :) °•∞ all at tah sames time ∞•°


Did you do the piano instrumental yourself?

replacer That's super! You're very talented! Beautiful song, thank you for sharing it with us.


And *cough* *cough* Applejack more *cough* *cough*


I just wish you would learn to enunciate "big" properly.


Oui. Unless you want to see some disturbing material.


extra charecter or rainbow dash lavel T.I.D


this was my first comment to be blocked for too many bad votes. ^_^


Why your comment was marked as spam I'll never know..


NNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO You changed your profile picture!!!!


I do a favor for you and act like I did not see that comment :D


don't you even f***ing dare death to pegasi


i said county. as in local population group? like Raleigh County West Virginia.


... why... why u no have bandcamp... WANNA BUY TO SUPPORT YOU!!

I do have a bandcamp, I just didn't at the time this song was finished :)

http://replacer.bandcamp.com/


ya but i still think the idea of pegasi is stupid