As someone who decided last minute not to kill myself after binge watching Season 1 and 2 in 2012, I might not really be a "brony" like in the golden days, but I will forever be grateful for this show and incredible community. This was fu**ing awesome!


The brony nation will live forever /) i will never leave this nation plus we are one huge happy family  I’m happy to be part of this family


Can you please put this Song on spotify i love it so much thanks too everypony who was working on it 😊


To anyone who tells me the fandom is dead, I will point at this animation and laugh 😄


OMFG, THAT WAS EPIC. THE RIDE NEVER ENDS


Joined this fandom a tad too late, only got a opportunity to properly watch the show only a few months ago, & now the inevitable is here. I stayed for the art , the music & the nice people of this fandom, and boy was it a good decison. It mainly helped with life & gave me a good reason to not pull the trigger on myself. And now the inevitable is here & I can't do anything about it but watch. But at least I know that I was a part of this fandom even if I was late. Thanks for this wonderful video & music man ❤😍👏🏻


It's sad, what our show is going to end. But our community was existing forever in our hearts. I I owe this show that it helped me overcome all difficulties, find many good friends, get a sea of positive, happiness.  It was the brightest and longest adventure that completely changed my boring life.  I will forever remain faithful to community and will remain brony.


I dont know how to express this properly but I wish there was some sort of community around that I could easily join for this MLP feeling of back then.
(If anyone has such a discord or anything, I'd like to join perhaps)
I did watch all of MLP but it just wasnt the same and due to many problems in my real life and I guess with my personality I started leaving groups I was in or didn't chase the right people when my groups fell apart.
This show saved my life many times over and I can not replace it, I'll also be in it until the end.


The story wont ever end as long as were all here and I'll die with the herd thanks for the freinds and memories.


By Luna has it really been a decade? I still can’t believe it. I was inducted into the Herd when I was 18 (am 27 now)  and still in high school, I think it was the best decision I ever made and I don’t regret it! I made a ton of friends, met a lot of interesting people and managed to go to the fandoms biggest con for it’s last year. I am a member of the Herd, I will always be a member of the Herd and I will die as a member of the Herd!


Ah, I missed the train! but, I'm so happy to see that bronies animators are still alive.


Remember, the ride never stops! Brony now and forever!/)


Wow that is massive collab and a good song and animation too


I really hope this thing does last forever...


Ох, как это прекрасно

Ох, как это прекрасно

Димон бурбур


Over 100?! Holy horseapples, talk about coming together for a group project.


Thanks you for the time the song and the pmv I love them


I would love a karaoke version of this song, if it’s not too much to ask for.


Великолепная работа.

Великолепная работа.


Hey, people, if I remember correctly, in season 3 Sparkle got her wings for completing some old spell Starswirl himself didn't know what was for. Do you think Prince here deserves a horn for being a beacon of harmony for as many years as he is? I think we all should practice our best cheer.

P.S. Things like this make me regret that I was unfit for the art school back in the day, regret in such a very nice way.


I cant believe you guys manage to include Fallout Equestria😁 Cheers.


Whao so amazing :0 amazing work from everyone


Happy birthday,MLP
thx,u,ponies,for the wonderful stories...

*Happy birthday,MLP*
*thx,u,ponies,for the wonderful stories...*

Макар Светлый


Вы восхитительны

Вы восхитительны


This is an awesome amazing song. Whats the name? Or is it an original????


And here I sit, with tears in my eyes.  /)


I regretted joining some of the fandoms.. but this, this i would never regret

Is the show dead? Maybe...
Is the show gone? Never


The end of G4 is not the end of this show, this fandom, not the end of Brony, fandom never die, you know that, inside your heart. I will never forget even after dead


My phone heated up while watching this video at full volume, it was crying too with me or something, but anyway this video is special and needs to be watched by anypony, so everypony will remember that the ride will never end, even if tomorrow the series does


Yeah, cool job, also just my thoughts about the fandom and me inside of it, i will still here until i alive and you making me happy that i am still not alone in this ;)

Саша Марченко


I'll always be here!! 9 years just doesn't die!


I'm just in love with 1:17 's style.. anyone knows who they are? I feel like I know it but that I'm just being dumb..


Годный ролик ... и ... грустный.

Годный ролик ... и ... грустный.

Михаил Старостенко


TOGETHER STRONGER FOREVER BECAUSE FRIENDSHIP IS MAGIC


what a ride<br>I'm going to miss this fandom so much...

what a ride
I'm going to miss this fandom so much...

I hope you're right<br>I know I'm not going anywhere :)

I hope you're right
I know I'm not going anywhere :)

the fandom will still be alive. no way in hell is it going to die off


It's not end(Это не конец), these are opportunities to start or continue by yourself(это возможности начать или продолжить самим).

Дмитрий Крыжановский


Uff the one with Wooden toaster got me ... Just all these Flashbacks its amazing. Whatever happens next... time will tell but We will never Fade/)


No se dejar el fandom brony asi no mas por que acaba la serie coml que no.

Yo seguiresiendo Brony hasta el dia que me muera


Nᴇʙᴜ's ᴇᴅɪᴛs


It's why i'm crying about the end of the show


For the herd thanks for one hell of a ride guys


Our death is almost here, we have only one more movie to watch, see you on the Tomb bronies, i'm waiting you on 2021. Thanks for everything my friends, DJ Pon-3 out. ❤💛💚💙💜♥


why i didnt discovered before these people?! OHH MY GOD, this is awsome!

Ha! going away? why in the hell i could think of saying yes? nobody is gonna move me from here, NOBODY!


Im a brony even after death.

Semper neigh


I fell kidn of bad because i hardly ever heard of most of the animators on the Fandom. Only really seen a few handful of them.


What do you mean... in memory of... MelodicPony?


Whelp littleshy just found his winner of this month top 10 fan videos


ребят мне 20 с хвостиком лет не заставляйте меня плакать


This Video is awesom and coll i love EVER pony 💖


Me sees Princes vid up watches like 8 times over agine and wishses head phones turnt up more bc always has on full blast OWO UWU


the 7 dislikes are the non bronies and who hate mlp and think its gay


SO I HAVE WAIT SO LONG TO SEE MY OWN FALL ( R.I.P MLP)


Good bye friendship is magic 2010 - 2019


I wish I could find out where Pinkie Pyro comes from, all I get are searches of pinkie and a pyro

Same, their part is amazing and adorable :D
(2:05)


I’m hic crying s-hic o much hic right n-hic ow thank you hic all to he-hic lp me know hic that I’m not alone hic we fans have to stick together

I’m *hic* crying s-*hic* o much *hic* right n-*hic* ow thank you *hic* all to he-*hic* lp me know *hic* that I’m not alone *hic* we fans have to stick together

No it’s supposed to show you I’m crying *sniffle*😢


Юрий Писанка


Грустная песенка...

Грустная песенка...


...
Where is my tissue box... tissue box?
box is currently absent
...
Nnnoooooooooooo!

...
Where is my tissue box... tissue box?
*box is currently absent*
...
Nnnoooooooooooo!


П ø л ь ш å в К ø ç м ø ç ê


Ав, заплакал.(

Ав, заплакал.(

саша вилюнов


Там была принцесса мироооов!!!!!

Там была принцесса мироооов!!!!!


I never comment on this but I think all another comments speak for me


i absolutely loved taking part in this! it was so much fun! and the group and community was amazing!


I never can hold back tears when I hear this song. You all made this the best 9 years of my life. Thank you so much.


Oh the FEELS! So overwhelming I can't put it into words! This show and the people in the fandom have brighten up so many of my days. I can only hope one day there be another amazing generation of MLP (a girl can dream no?). Nonetheless I hope the fandom lives on, and on, and on :) <3


I've been listening to the album on repeat for the last couple of weeks now that I've received the physical copy. I missed the feeling of reading a lyrics leaflet to learn songs, so this made me quite nostalgic, and this song even more. Making a collaborative video clip was a great idea, and the animators did an amazing job too! Wherever you guys end up after this FiM finale, I hope you'll apply the lessons we've learned in this community everywhere you go, spreading a message of acceptance, passion and creativity. This fandom helped me find and accept myself and made me meet so many wonderful people. I'll always feel grateful for the precious moments we've shared thanks to a silly cartoon about ponies. 💗


Ahh Prince, you and your lot did it again. A masterpiece as always. Never the less, a message from the mlp ani stream, we are far from gone. More so than anything, we are here once more, and will continue to carry on  for many moons to come. Prince you inspired me to make pony  music in the future (among other things), and I fully intend to see to it. So keep poni poni poni'ing guys, and us mad lads will make sure we keep the content  rolling. Happy birthday FIM. To 9 years, and many more to come. Mr Bones's wild ride never ends! Because on this day, the ride will last forever!


I'm so glad that my precious baby boys are in this. Makes me proud to be a brony and a soldier :)


Hermoso... <br>Estuve esperando desde hace tiempo el videoclip y la verdad vale la pena. Brony de Corazón, claro que estaré con la manada aunque pasen 20 años, toda la vida. Amo esta canción, y es un excelente trabajo de los animadores. Un saludo a toda la manada brony los quiero hermanos🤙👍....

Hermoso...
Estuve esperando desde hace tiempo el videoclip y la verdad vale la pena. Brony de Corazón, claro que estaré con la manada aunque pasen 20 años, toda la vida. Amo esta canción, y es un excelente trabajo de los animadores. Un saludo a toda la manada brony los quiero hermanos🤙👍....


This is sooo incredible and emotional! It’s the perfect video to represent not only this song, but the fandom itself. I love it so much! Great job, all of you! :)


All around the world, this show reached  levels never ever imagined before. Teaching about friendship, love and harmony. This show changed lives, create bounds that will never cease to exist. Thanks fandom, thanks mlp... For let me be part of this awesome family. The ride never ends. /)


I don't regret having been involved with such a wonderful community, I owe a lot to this show, happiness, laughs, tears, and even experiencing love for first time thanks to this!!!, it was and is wonderful, we're not going anywhere, the ride never ends, beautiful collaboration, ponies4ever <3!!!!


This made me cry, this fandom is absolutely beautiful. Keep being awesome everyone. The show may be ending but the passion we all share of the fandom won't end.


Just joined this fandom last year. It's so amazing that I found this fandom. You and the animator make me want to cry 😭


This fandom has changed my life, and not just because of the wonderful show, but the community surrounding it. it's helped me through the worst time in my life, gave me great memories, and people I've been honored to meet, some even in person. and fan works that have inspired me to pursue passions I never thought I would have. I will always be a part of this fandom, one way or another. and it will always hold a special place in my heart no matter where life takes me. Thank you all.


I’m really glad this was made clearly with the golden age style vibe of the fandom to it. With 24 hours left, this was really nice. Its been an indescribable pleasure everyone, thanks for the 9 years. I’ll see you on the other side tomorrow

/)


Even though I haven't actually watched the show since season 6, I've stayed around the music scene of MLP.  This is an amazing thing to see, an amazing song paired with so many people who still have such passion for a great show.  /) to all who are and were apart of the fandom


This community is the best. Let the ride continue for many, many more years to come.


This brought back so many great memories of this lovely family we're all apart of. Truly happy to be down this trip with you all! <3


Esto es lo que mas me gusta de este fandom, su creatividad y talento, por eso me uni a el fandom brony, si bien ya no es lo mismo de antes, debo decir que fue una bonita experiencia. Buen video <3


This is a perfect representation of the creativity and devotion that has brought this fandom to where it stands today, I'm really honored that I was allowed to participate in such an Important project, Thanks to everyone involved an thanks to all the fandom, It's been a great journey, lets keep it rolling!


It was a great experience being a part of this! Knowing this was shown at BronyCon is the icing on the cake. Even though I never got to go to one, knowing something I made and was apart of was shown at one is super cool.


I remember the day I discovered MLP:FiM and the fandom behind it. It was 2012 and my older brother was already into it and he had me watch the season 2 finale episodes. I became obsessed with it because I was bullied in school at the time and the show got me through it. I never really got into the fandom and regret now that the show is at its end. I drifted away from the show around 2015 but watched the occasional episode. I should have made more of an effort and now I may never get to meet new friends from it and Bronycon is having it's last year with me not being able to afford going so I'll never get to experience it. I recently got into watching vids here on YouTube about the show and I feel like I abandoned the community before I was even part of it.


I really want to cry right now because I remember all of the things FiM has pulled me through. From all my failures through the years, MLP and all the fan-work the community has made has kept me going from the lessons i have learned from when i first saw the show when i was 12, to the fanfictions like FoE, On a cross and an arrow, Five-Score, and many others which have influenced my choice in college to pursue storytelling through the medium of film. This fandom has definitely been one of the most influential things in my life right after my parents and the people around me.

Thank you everypony


DUDE I GOT CHILLS, so many familiar faces! So many new faces!

I've been here since the very start and this fandom has been the best thing to happen to me, its helped me bond with so many people, it lifted me up when others pushed me down.

I know I would not be where I am today without this show, and it makes me happy to see others the same. We're all here together, because really,

Friendship is magic!


I've been out of the fandom for a while now.. almost 2 years.. but I might just come back
This fandom has given me so much and ultimately made me who I am
I hope to one day perform this song in front of a crowd of thousands of people, to keep the fire of friendship burning bright
Thank you everypony, you have made me something I could've never dreamed
And thank you PrinceWhatever
Your music and your voice, your guitar and drum, has made this world a better place for so many..
I have the REINVENT CD 2nd edition and its wonderful
Im hoping to buy your REIMAGINE CD as well soon

Thank you.. I really can't thank you enough for giving me this
You made appreciate metal more, gave me something new and exciting

So heres to us, heres to Prince, heres to the bronies of the past, the now, and the future!
>w<
Raise the cider and give me a brohoof!

"Follow Your Dreams and Brohoof To All"- Atom O.


IDW- Beautiful... It makes me want to do a thing!
creates season 10
But seriously, I think the reason FiM is continuing through 2020, even if it is in a new form, is because of the passion of us, the fanbase.  So here is to another decade!  Another decade of friendship!  Another decade of ponies!  Another decade of being the most passionate fandom the internet has ever seen!

IDW- Beautiful... It makes me want to do a thing!
*creates season 10*
But seriously, I think the reason FiM is continuing through 2020, even if it is in a new form, is because of the passion of us, the fanbase.  So here is to another decade!  Another decade of friendship!  Another decade of ponies!  Another decade of being the most passionate fandom the internet has ever seen!


It's for things like this that remind me why I love this community.


What a surprise! Manly tears are shed tonight. (Proud) Brony here since Season 1. Thanks to all of you, no matter the end of the series this weekend our beloved community, our pony fandom will last forever.


Great. Just, great. This makes me feel proud to be a part of this wonderful Fandom


I definitely wasn't in this from start to finish. I joined in 2011-2012 and left sometime in late 2017. But it's still saddening to me to see the series end soon. Those 5-6 years mean so much to me; escaping from my depression, making new friends, etc. So even though I don't fully consider myself a part of the fandom anymore, it's bittersweet to see the fandom has come this far.


A wonderful capstone to an era, and a great start for the rest of our time here as more than just a bunch off dweebs watching a show about colorful horses, but as friends and family. It's been one hell of a ride these past 9 years and I wouldn't trade any of the friendships I've made for anything. The show may be (almost) over, but we're still here so let's keep it up guys.


This animation is amazing! Also this song still brings a tear to my eye every time I listen to this song.


I love this fanbase so much. I'm never leaving it. I'll be along for the ride until eternity.


The talent in this fandom is hard to miss. Well done!!!


this brought tears to my eyes XD<br>everyone did such an amazing job, and this song just hits home TxT

this brought tears to my eyes XD
everyone did such an amazing job, and this song just hits home TxT


Exactly the ending that we all needed, this touches my heart to see it end so soon but this make me happy for all the people in loved I'm making it great. Thank you to everyone and I hope we all live on.never let the heard die


i would never forget the show, the people, and anyone on the fandom, my friend, thank you for everysingle one of you who have been tighten the Fandom spirit!


This was absolutely awesome. Thank you to everyone who worked on this!


I'm so happy that you made not only Solidarity but also this video with so many amazingly talented people. I'm proud to say that this video made me cry tears of joy, tears of sadness but most importantly tears of Friendship thank you Princewhatever


I just got home from a long day at work and this brought tears to my eyes. MLP : FiM has helped me through some rough patches and I'm proud to call myself a brony since season 1.


Why can't I like this video twice. <br>This is amazing! I love this fandom

Why can't I like this video twice.
This is amazing! I love this fandom


This was amazing!<br>Great job everyone.


thank you Prince, and all who worked over this, I in another times convinced that fandom can provide more vivid emotions than any other!

роман осминин


Though I've only been a brony for ten months, this show and community has changed my life for the better and I will always be greatful for that. Here's a bro hoof for all you awesome people /)


So many feels. I have to say that this show meant to me more than any show I've ever watched because this show helped me meet my husband and some of my close friends.


Fucking amazing piece of music work, Prince! And for everyone else animating the video, I cannot begin to describe the feeling this huge collaboration sparked in me, knowing that I left the fandom a couple years ago and never thought I'd be missing out. For all those saying that the fandom is dead, everyday I see that it really isn't and that makes me so happy. Because this fandom is so much more than just a fanbase of a TV show. I love you all.<br>PS your drum samples still suck. XD Production is epic but the booming kick and snare are getting old man. Only complaint, I promise. Other than that, it is an eargasm.

Fucking amazing piece of music work, Prince! And for everyone else animating the video, I cannot begin to describe the feeling this huge collaboration sparked in me, knowing that I left the fandom a couple years ago and never thought I'd be missing out. For all those saying that the fandom is dead, everyday I see that it really isn't and that makes me so happy. Because this fandom is so much more than just a fanbase of a TV show. I love you all.
PS your drum samples still suck. XD Production is epic but the booming kick and snare are getting old man. Only complaint, I promise. Other than that, it is an eargasm.


I've become a lurker in the fandom in the last couple of years, but I'm still here after so long.<br>This was a beautiful video, good work, everyone.

I've become a lurker in the fandom in the last couple of years, but I'm still here after so long.
This was a beautiful video, good work, everyone.


Love all the work that went into this video. Just fantastic what you all accomplished together.


this made my day... thank you so much. I love this community a lot. I have less toxic people here than others like warhammer 40k. I used to dislike the idea of mlp then I decided to watch the show. I fell in love with it. I have seen so much grim darkness everywhere that I want to some wholesome and uplifting, with some funny on the side. I am glad to find a community like this.


You know what they say... The  Ride Never Ends!!!<br>It's beautiful, great work everyone!

You know what they say... The  Ride Never Ends!!!
It's beautiful, great work everyone!


I have loved the mlp community, what it has brought, shared and become.  Even with the end in sight of this version of mlp, we as a fan base; as a community will continue and thrive.  To forever carry on the lessons and love this show has brought to our hearts~


Just brings a tear to ones eye to see the fruition of all this talent and hardwork I was a part of.


When ever I here you music it always fills me with so much joy and happiness and it makes me really miss the fandom/friends I made from it.


Fantastic and stunning job.  Lots of talent came to make this collab here amazing!


This really pulled at my heartstrings hard and so many talented people come together to make this makese proud to be in this fandom especially and G4 will never die for as long as we remember them and all the friendship they brought to us


OMG, THAT WAS SOOOOO AWESOME!!! THANK ALL OF YOU GUYS FOR EVERYFING YOU'VE DONE TO FANDOM AND MLP!!!


Damn this got me in my feelings, probably because the fact that I was young when I joined the Fandom and now it makes me feel old that it's coming to an end


This year has been my rekindling with the fandom after being all but absent for two years, but looking back I never wanted to leave and now I will never leave after this year experience with the last BronyCon.

Long live the Herd, Long Live the Brony Fandom!!


Love all the people you've got working together Prince. Got your Reimagine album and I don't know why but it made me so happy going through that little booklet and reading all the names of the people who helped make that album, and again I am feeling that right here with this song and video.

Also, love that moment in the video with your OC and and The Wooden Toaster. "Rainbow Factory" was the first pony song I heard.


So glad to have been a part of this crazy fandom for the last 5 years. And I dont know where I'll be in 20 years from now. But I know I'm not going anywhere anytime soon. Thank you guys.


What you've all created will continue. Even if the show ends... which I doubt: I'm waiting for the official announcement of G5.


This is so cool ! Awesome to see so many talents in a single video !


Nothing can but into words how much I love this fandom and the people in it. I am certainly never going anywhwre. <br>Truly awe inspiring work done by everyone. Thanks to all of you.

Nothing can but into words how much I love this fandom and the people in it. I am certainly never going anywhwre.
Truly awe inspiring work done by everyone. Thanks to all of you.


Oh my gosh I love you all so much, all of the talented creators, all of the community members, everypony. I love you all so much. Let's not let this ride end, I'll see you all once Gen 5 is here. I know I'll die with the herd. <3


It was magnificent, congratulations.  A great journey and more to do, always together.  I loved, kisses Bye.


We are in this together and we ain’t going anywhere we burn up and disappear when humanity goes extinct we will always and forever be here love the video outstanding job to all the artists I loved all the animations


First time using this page since G+ publicly shut down, but I just want to say thank you to everyone involved for this video. The fandom isn't as active or as big as it was back in 2011/12, but I think we'll be fine. /)


So glad to see this finally out! Love the song, and love yall guys! -FirePetalFox


Prince, it's Drake. This was worth the wait. I am so happy for this song. Thank you so much for this wonderful tribute for 9 years of pony.


This is amazing everybody that animated in this did awesome!


I have never seen so many mlp fan animators all in one video. 100 of them.....this video is truly amazing and one of the most outstanding things that this fandom do. I am very happy that I am still a brony and always will be. 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼


Thats what this song needed! Hands down my favorite song, now my favorite video. If Join The Herd was an anthem for the fandom, this is the war cry.


Joined the herd in 2017 after watching the MLP Movie then tried binge watching all the seasons. But what brought me to the this amazing show and fandom was just some self motivation to watch an episode and give it a try. Secrets and Pies was the first episode hit hard and I was hooked since.


This is how you end MLP with a bang and nothing but hope and friendship


My love goes out to all that where involved and to you reading this comment <3 /)


I am at a loss for words. Prince Whateverer, you the many many people who collaborated with you on this have blown me away.


thank you MLP and all the fandom to be part of this ride


This bloody fandom got me through high school so thank you all of you horse lovers, you’ve saved lives


That...was......AMAZING I LOVE IT yes no matter what year it is everypony will stay strong through the hardships and the good times and no matter what happens we'll be in this together


Great now im crying.. I love this fandom too much


Can't believe this show is ending 😢. I will remember this show FOREVER! 💪🔥❤


This one always makes me feel warm and fuzzy


No matter how long a show lasts, its fandom lasts exponentially longer.


This is so awesome 😍😍 i really like it . You all are very talented


PrinceWhatevever you have always been my favorite idol on pony tracks! Thank you ! Thanks to you, I'm happy. P.s sorry if there are a lot of mistakes I do not know English.


After watching this, I cried. RIP MLP FIM 2010-2019, but we’re not fucking going anywhere, we got a future ahead of us and our fandom is not dead. We got G5 and a movie to watch. Whatever happens our friendship will keep us strong. Why, because WERE IN THIS TOGETHER!


Im not going to lie this video brought a few tears to my eyes. Thanks


I hope Hasbro and the people who work on the show see this and see how the fandom is grateful for MLP they have given us through the years and give them a sense of pride, and great big thanks to Lauren Faust who started it all... Here to hoping Hasbro don't do a dick move by copyright it.


/)

EDIT  tbh, this was the only thing I could think of posting.  To how many other people in the world outside of this fandom does this actually mean anything?  I'm so glad to be a part of this feel train.  I love this fandom and I love all of you who made this fandom what it is :)

/)

*EDIT*  tbh, this was the only thing I could think of posting.  To how many other people in the world outside of this fandom does this actually mean anything?  I'm so glad to be a part of this feel train.  I love this fandom and I love all of you who made this fandom what it is :)


Would like us all Brony people to live like a long time ^w^🎉❤


Holy fuck I'm so emotional. I'll be honest and say, that at one point I considered leaving the herd. I was dealing with a lot of unnecessary drama this past year (people using my oc without permission, making inappropriate art of her w/o permission, causing issues when I said no, etc. I could be here all day if I went on.) I was considering only sticking around and making some final art pieces, then leaving in 2020, deleting my accounts, etc. But when this song popped up in my recommended a few months ago, and my love for the fandom was reinvigorated. I was reminded that the fandom isn't all toxic and full of drama, that there's more to it. After watching this MAP, I know for sure, I won't go anywhere, I'll die with the herd.

Thank you PW and all the amazing and talented people within the fandom. You all have encouraged me to stay and also improve on my own works. I'm a long way from being any good, but someday I hope to get away from bases and do things right. And someday I'll get better at doing voice acting and covers.

Thank you everyone! /)

PS: I teared up a little when MelodicPony was listed at the end. I miss their works. I'm sure they'd be proud of this MAP as well as the fandom!


HAPPY BIRTHDAY MLP FIM!!!!! AND TO ALL THE BRONIES IN THIS FANDOM, I SALUTE ALL OF U AWESOME ASS MAGNIFICENT BASTARDS!!!!


Keep the fire bright my brothers ans sisters, we carry the torch now, just because the show has ended, doesnt mean its the end if the road

We will pave our own


its sad this song cant ring true to me, as long as if been in the community i always felt the same...alone dont help meeting bronies aint an easy thing to do these days if anything i guess this comment is a effort to make a friend


Данил Захаров


The Memory Lane of this fandom has gone so far...


This is awesome. I saw this on Tumblr( the cancer that that site is) and I simply have to say no... to quote Shakespearicles. I'm riding this ride until the wheels fall off and Catch Fire and then I'm going to get out and start pushing.


This is so good omg!!!! Thank you so much for the video!! You can feel the love ;u;!! Happy birthday MlP!!!


I know you're going to do something I knew it I'm so happy you did thank you thank you so much all of you being the best people and ponies and creatures and yeah right behind but thank you all for being the best fandom of I ever joined and I am going no were too


Anyone else crying rn? I promise there are mostly tears of joy.


The show will be end, but the ride... THE RIDE NEVER END EVERYPONY, THIS IS THE BEST COMMUNITY IN THE TIME OF INTERNET.


im so happy to see my friends animation in here!


Aaah, I saw Snapai in there! :D That was incredible!


Three words I have say about this video

POSITIVELY EPIC BRO!


Not even the end times will get me to leave the herd i found myself in.


I loved so much this video ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😆👏👏👏👏👏


I shall see all you bros and sisters on the next road map.

BRONY4EVER!!!

~Brohoof


The mlp community is alot like the tf2 community, bad in some parts, but really supportive and really kind to one abother, all for the purpose of whatever..
Heh, was that your purpose
To just do whatever, PrinceWhatever?


Tell you one thing every pony. I ain’t going nowhere!! 🌈🔥I’ll die with the herd!!!


6:19 Excelsior every bronies and pegasisters! Excelsior!


Omg this song always gets me hyped up before work


probably a stupid question, but where can i find the song that plays for the credits? or is it just a slow version that isn't available anywhere. (i know the main song is why were all here but i couldn't help but enjoy the credit song as well. love ya'll.)


So are you going to send this to Tara Strong or Big Jim via their twitters?


Been here since 10/2011 thank for this , I see some OG's in here


принцесса миров / princess of the worlds

Интересно твоя анимация там есть просто я там не видел.


Gave me fucking chills<br>Guess I'll sie with the heard

Gave me fucking chills
Guess I'll sie with the heard


Greetings from Bronies @ Belgium (we have a Discord, Facebook and website, stay in touch with friends!)


Nooooo!!!! Why hadnt I heard of this? I should've been in there!!! I AM a good animator, y'all just can't see it!!! :(

One of the amazing things about this fandom is that there are EASILY as many animators missing from the crew as there are in it! Plenty who have moved on who might have come back for it too! MrPoniator, Pikapetey, Tiarawhy, Zedrin and the SFS crew, etc. This is just one big bucketful of awesome people who animate or have animated ponies; out of many! No-one missing should feel it was a reflection on their quality, just keep being awesome!!


who else will see this again after the final episodes?

Im be drowning from the tears but i will for sure


0:56 is that "she who shalt not be named?"


100 out of 10. This shouldn't get any dislikes by the fandom. Only people to dislike this has watched the show, and are just immature adults


Ого даже на русский язык перевели

Ого даже на русский язык перевели


Еб*ть это ох*енно !!!

Еб*ть это ох*енно !!!


Description error.  :P<br>"if this project has taught* us anything, it is* that."

Description error.  :P
"if this project has taught* us anything, it is* that."


Something is wrong with Youtube. I can click the 👍 only once


Mungkin Cuman Saya Yang Dari Indonesia,Kita Bersama Ada Disini Selamanya....


There is so many pony in dis<br> universe how did you draw

There is so many pony in dis
 universe how did you draw


Duuuude.  Where is the link to all the animators?  The Brony Backup Project wants to know....  Actually we want alot of things to accomplish our mission.  I am just here because I just really want you to post that so we can archive it and keep it available if it is lost for others in the future.  Nice vid though.

Actually thinking about that...  is there a discord channel or meet up location (digital or not)  you have been using?  I am sure we can make a mutual meetup of back ups happen.  In other words  COPPA and disaster insurance.

This is mostly for posterity and for the future.  NOT a replacement for funds.  Just memories funded by our funders wallets.  DM if interested please.  Otherwise.  Well.  We gotcha.  We will back up what we can because we must.

Don't worry though.  We won't mess with your advertising funds.  We will just be here.

you can try messaging his Twitter about this; he might've forgotten or was busy with other things.


Ahhhh...... Read this hurry! Khmm....:
 • My Little Pony: The Movie 2 | RELEASE AROUND 2021!)
 • MLP Comics (Which started in 2012!)
 • A coming soon new series called 'Pony Life' what product the Mane 6's everydays! (I'M DO NOT RECOMMEND
   THIS... THIS... THIS CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY, THIS MORAL ANAL-ORGY, THIS CEREBRAL HOLOCAUST, THIS...
                 [We have some technical difficulties]
                                [Please stand by]
Khmm...
 • And a plasticine stop-motion series, what started. So... Y'all can watch It!

Edit:
Oh and:
 • MY LITTLE PONY GENERATION 5!!!!!!!!!

Ahhhh...... Read this hurry! Khmm....:
 • My Little Pony: The Movie 2 | RELEASE AROUND 2021!)
 • MLP Comics (Which started in 2012!)
 • A coming soon new series called 'Pony Life' what product the Mane 6's everydays! (I'M DO NOT RECOMMEND
   THIS... THIS... THIS CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY, THIS MORAL ANAL-ORGY, THIS CEREBRAL HOLOCAUST, THIS...
                 *[We have some technical difficulties]*
                                *[Please stand by]*
Khmm...
 • And a plasticine stop-motion series, what started. So... Y'all can watch It!

*Edit:*
Oh and:
 • MY LITTLE PONY GENERATION 5!!!!!!!!!


1:26 on the top SCREWBALL AND MOTHBALL :D!


As a kind of movie with My little pony and happy tree Friends with celestia and moon tired of retirement traveling to the other side of the sea discovering that there is an Equestria for two discovering the world of happy tree Friends seeing a castle in the city to rule the king shadow good characters and that his friends are those of happy tree Friends the villains that neozor and Big BOSS and that they have an army of purple bears and that they are the mane 6 of the future and that neozor and Big BOSS end Jan be their friends saying them that celestia and luna were planning to be princesses again the shadow castle called why he was thinking of withdrawing and giving his place to celestia and luna and Twitlit and her friends travel to happy tree Friends just the day they were planning their coronation when they realized They canceled his presence only until he left and in the end he found a war battle, just try it, I'll just give you an idea and I open it with great respect, but just try


Тот самый создатель


Увидела принцессу миров

Увидела принцессу миров

Цветик самоцветик


꧁༼V͜͡l͜͡a͜͡d͜͡ P͜͡a͜͡s͜͡t͜͡e͜͡r͜͡M͜͡L͜͡P͜͡𖤓𓅓༽꧂


why in this video is not warpout >:v, pd: I loved this video, I cried with the video, I't the best video that I seen <3


Андрей Дранченко


Thanks everyone who made all this possible the animations, the song and so much heart <3 This project alone shows what the community can achive together :3 i love you all so much im super thankful im alive in this time period with all of you :3 FOR THE HERD!


It was so great to be in this together with all these other amazing animators!


This is amazing, and to see so many people still going with the show over.  I hope that everyone is still around when the next generation comes out, bless you all. An thank you for being a part of this fandom


This is amazing! I can't believe its been so long sense the fandom formed. <3


I may not have been apart of the fandom for long but this brings tears to my eyes, excellent Job to everyone.


This has to be one of the best videos from the fandom. Im amazed to see so many artists and animators brought together to do something spectacular.

Everyone always say that the fandom is dying, i would like to disagree. We are strong and we will continue like that forever! All thanks to a show that brought us all together. Thanks MLP FIM and thanks to everyone on this community. Love you all!


It was amazing being in this project. Thank you all. ^^


It has been a honour being in this beautiful community,<br>Thank you.

It has been a honour being in this beautiful community,
Thank you.


Absolutely blown away by this one!  Folks like you are who help keep the herd together, Prince! Thanks for all of your hard work!


<b>EVERYPONY DID A GREAT JOB MAKING THIS!! I'M SO PROUD OF YOU GUYS!!</b>

*EVERYPONY DID A GREAT JOB MAKING THIS!! I'M SO PROUD OF YOU GUYS!!*


Aaah I love you all! So happy to be a part of this and to be a part of this fandom!


This was so amazing!  I haven't let myself feel sad about the finale yet but this legit made me tear up.  It's been so amazing and I hope it will continue like other big fandoms.  It can happen!


No matter how old I am I’ll always be thankful for what Friendship is Magic has given me.


I'm glad to see so many other people who are still invested in this fandom. I've got too many ideas for songs and videos to give up on it now.


The show maybe ending, but with things like this still happening. Amazing songs, art, animations, the cons we all meet up at and us the fandom. It will live on through us till the end of time! As you say Whateverer “Were in this Together!”


so much memories I love the show and the community, WE'RE IN THIS TOGETHER!


I am proud to consider myself a Brony. I am proud to identify with people with talent, optimism, and above all: friendly and caring community. I love seeing the talent everypony has, especially to those who contributed to this video.

Thank you everypony, for making this community what it is, whether you're here for the majority of these 9 years, or just a newcomer. I Pinkie Promise to help keep the fire of friendship burning bright, cross my heart and hope to fly, stick a cupcake in my eye! Here's for the future! /)

#I'llDieWithTheHerd


I thought that one of your best songs cannot become even better, but here it is - with stunning visual works of many other artists it's just became legendary, I'm serious. Congrats for becoming history now, PrinceWhateverer.<br>PS <3 u all guys, thx for the nine life-changing years, stay awesome for the whole life.

I thought that one of your best songs cannot become even better, but here it is - with stunning visual works of many other artists it's just became legendary, I'm serious. Congrats for becoming history now, PrinceWhateverer.
PS <3 u all guys, thx for the nine life-changing years, stay awesome for the whole life.


This is what i love to see out of a community. This video is spewing love and Unity.💗


this MAP has me in tears.<br>It's so beautiful.

this MAP has me in tears.
It's so beautiful.


This really made my day after it went to shit. Thanks all of you legends. This is why I can't ever leave the fandom even if I never finished half the series. The fandom is filed with so many amazing things and people<br>PS no I'm not crying you're crying ;u;

This really made my day after it went to shit. Thanks all of you legends. This is why I can't ever leave the fandom even if I never finished half the series. The fandom is filed with so many amazing things and people
PS no I'm not crying you're crying ;u;


That took my breath away and made me so emotional <3


Fantastic! Y'all did a great job on this!! <3 <3 <3


End of an era... Looks and sounds awesome - great jobs!


This is kind of messy but great. It's almost like if it was a fabulous representation of the best part of the fandom.


Ahhh, the feels in this video. This has to be one of if not the best videos in the mlp fandom. I also want to get a poster of the art at the end! Great work everypony involved it it and you!


Woah so many talented members we have within this amazing community!!


Happy Birthday MLP! It's been a hell of a run. But this community isn't even close to being over


Aaa! It's amazing! Everyone did a great job!


Adding to my favorite to listen forever, THANK YOU ALL for this wondderful gift! XD


MLP made me meet awesome people throughot the years, awesome content, music and friends. I owe this little serires so much. uwu


So much references, so much memories, so much...  feels !


Even though i've just been in the Fandom for a year I get nostalgic about things i didn't even witness myself


This is amazing bro just inspiring. I'm out here Prince!!


I saw Lightning Dust on the cover. That officially makes this song twice as good.


Man this was dope we will never die I hope no one will lose there way if gen 5 sucks. I love everyone equal I wouldnt never be the person I am now if it wasn't for gen 4 mlp. :3


This Community is too awesome we are bronies forever.


Clicked on the video as fast as I could and it was just amazing I will never forget the show.


Yeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhh boiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii. Had fun being a part of this project! Met some amazing people along the way, too!


Damn what a journey we have taken sadly it has come to an end


Wow, this is pretty fucking fantatic. Nice job everyone.


My little pony me enseño las increíbles cosas que podemos lograr si todos nos unimos a trabajar por un bien en común: La amistad.<br>Por darme de los mejores momentos de mi vida, y por las personas que he conocido, gracias MLP

My little pony me enseño las increíbles cosas que podemos lograr si todos nos unimos a trabajar por un bien en común: La amistad.
Por darme de los mejores momentos de mi vida, y por las personas que he conocido, gracias MLP


My favorite song by you got an amazing music video this is amazing!


Acá está el comentario en español que buscabas
Increíble chicos ❤
De un brony chileno que sigue la serie desde el 2011
¿Algún brony latino por acá?


This one got me crying and I always cry from inside so


Absolutely legendary!

I've always wanted to create an animation for this fandom, but I haven't found the time to do unfortunately. What I have in mind is a SFM animation of "The Man I Used to Be" from the musical "The Count of Monte Cristo", with my OC, Slide Fortissimo, as the Count of Monte Cristo respectively. It would extremely grateful and legendary if SFM animators in this fandom can help me with this animation. This fandom thrives on collaboration and I can agree that this was a huge example it.

Please send me a note on Deviantart if you're interested. Thank you very much, well done, and stay awesome! ^^


Aaaa help this is so amazing im gonna cry xD


holy shit prince...this is incredible...


Love video and I no matter what be brony fandom and community still watch this


Just bought a shirt, already the best investment I have ever made XD


9 years. Ups and lows but were still here.


Much of the time the beautiful video ^_^


THIS IS FUCKING EPIC!!!!!!  <b>ultimatly obliterates like button</b>

THIS IS FUCKING EPIC!!!!!!  *ultimatly obliterates like button*


¡¡¡Cool video!!!!😊😊😊👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻


EYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY this slaps my dude.


Ya hecking wanker couldnt get enough with the original song yeah? ya gotta make a new version that got more feels yeah? well let me tell u this m8

its freaking working quite well ;w;


What do you mean in memory did they pass away


Where Stalliongrad and Equestria at War? Ehhh...


Generation 5 is still coming in the future.


Ребят не как не могу найти музон этот подскажите как называется

Это они сделали сами этот музон это и есть оригинал

саша вилюнов


Somebody can tell me who is cobalt flash and the other bronies that i saw in the memory credits?

they're still remembered for the content they've made; some of which is still being used by fans today, like Melodic's songs.

So they are dead, so sad to think a fandom brother is dead

But if i search their names Google give me another results

they're members of the community who have passed away; members who made amazing music, art and content.


Unfortunitly for my group, 2019 con is across the couctry, so we will not see you there.


Rock is not what mlp is. That's where this went wrong.

@Reese bro where? Tell me where IN THE SHOW there are actual rock songs.

did you forget the MANY rock songs in the show? kids don't care if there's rock music in the show. do research.


all have so good i have not so good Friends


yes, those people in the "In Memory Of" part passed away over the course of the community's existence.


he's not part of the community anymore due to what he's done in the past.


we sent you ethereum why are you fooling people to return our money back


What is that background ponies about sunset shimmer and tempest shadow and also screwball what is it is it brutalweather or what is that name called about mlp animation about sunset shimmer and tempest shadow and also screwball


How the fuck Is this 2 years old already

Because we are old. O.o And The HERD has still survived everything the Wasteland has thrown at Us.


sweet but where is discord my fav character

this is a celebration of the mane 6 and the community.


Александр Арнаутов


Im geting  bulied att school  for liking my lithel ponny but i will love it to the end of time

Sorry for my bad vriting bad att it bekus personel resans


I just have one question where is discord

this was about the main cast. Discord is a side character.


@PrinceWhateverer Thanks, mate, even if you are the only one, it still warms my heart :) (there is a hella lot of positive comments coming in so can't blame anyone for missing some :P)


Wish at 11:11 o’clock alternate moment even better for a chance please and turn back last time along with moment and still keeped


Hey i see Minecraft animation
Why don't u tell me
Im a animator to


саша вилюнов


кто нибудь из русских 2022 аа

кто нибудь из русских 2022 аа


What do you mean in memory did they pass away

@amarion2098 what on earth were you not understanding then?

@9CWAI yea I know what generation stands for I ain't dumb

@amarion2098 g4 means generation 4 because there have been 4 different series of MLP g4 is MLP:FiM.

@Reese  JUST YOU KNOW WHAT DON'T EXPLAIN ANYTHING TO ME. IM AGGRESSIVE AND HAVE MENTAL ISSUES

@amarion2098 they literally explained it to you. the 4th generation of the My Little Pony series ended.

@Mandy Idema OK tell me when you're ready about this series. I might not answer in a few because I play roblox

@Mandy Idema are you going to tell me???

@Mandy Idema and also you a boy that watch it

@Mandy Idema what series I don't<br> watch mlp

@Mandy Idema what series I don't
 watch mlp

Amarion Arthur the generation 4 of the series my little pony has ended. The best generation yet :’)


What is that a background ponies about sunset shimmer and tempest shadow and also screw ball tell me that background ponies about sunset shimmer and tempest shadow and also screw ball


applegeek littleshyfim and more why not here


Рашн федерашен на месте?

Рашн федерашен на месте?

саша вилюнов


Почему вы обманывайите людей где наши деньги

Какие деньги на дружбу

Какие деньги на дружбу

саша вилюнов


Кстати, а млп уже все? Ото я новостей то не смотрю

Да млп умер как и дружба новый млп выходит но он может быть хуже чем классик млп так все будут называть старое млп

саша вилюнов

@DN_ _SG Сейчас старые авторы уходят, а новых что-то не появляется.

@Avtomatićeskij Razdatćik Gusej ну, как знаеш. ИМХО даже есле ВСЕ авторы исчезнут, из-за большого объема уже готовых материалов найдутся новые потребители, а среди них могут появится и художники/писатели/аниматоры/музыканты и прочее..<br>А по телику могут и в разнобой пускать серии.

@Avtomatićeskij Razdatćik Gusej ну, как знаеш. ИМХО даже есле ВСЕ авторы исчезнут, из-за большого объема уже готовых материалов найдутся новые потребители, а среди них могут появится и художники/писатели/аниматоры/музыканты и прочее..
А по телику могут и в разнобой пускать серии.

@Avtomatićeskij Razdatćik Gusej ИМХО фендом еще жив здоров.

@Lope Zard Хуеха. Если ты не видишь, что фэндом мёртв, то наверное стоит открыть глаза.

Нет ещё это не конец

Нет ещё это не конец

да, всё<br>окончательно и бесповоротно

да, всё
окончательно и бесповоротно


I wish i can learn how to animate or do song's or whatever i wish i hade friends that liked mlp i dont have the tools to do anything and I'm pretty stupid 😔im so depressed I'm not sure why o even try anymore

my dude, we all started out with not knowing how to draw/ make music or animations. but we learn as time goes on, and we meet people who can help. you just gotta look around! you're not alone


Did any one made a nine tails fox in mlp fandom ? No then im will be frist


Was listening to powerwolf and this autoplayed. I am not amused

@Doomskull that's what I call hater spirit

@JondroI shan't. There are things that I want to be destroyed, that is true, but not everything can bend to my will. But there are also things I wish to be expunged from existence entirely; flattened, purged and redacted. <b>This</b> is one of those things. Frankly, I sometimes throw dubious looks at the floor, wondering as to why it has not yet opened up in order to swallow this into the very bowels of hell it appears to have manifested in.

@JondroI shan't. There are things that I want to be destroyed, that is true, but not everything can bend to my will. But there are also things I wish to be expunged from existence entirely; flattened, purged and redacted. *This* is one of those things. Frankly, I sometimes throw dubious looks at the floor, wondering as to why it has not yet opened up in order to swallow this into the very bowels of hell it appears to have manifested in.

@Doomskull Hope you didn't forget to smash dislike and leave comment that "all bronies are zoophiles"

@Reese I have, and with great haste and disgust


hola mucho gusto como estas Mi nombre es una see monkey do not I mean to video Monsanto for me Indian when we are most amused. And see if money in this video I mean I get a d s k they were possible. They was that a yes Alison arngrim Persona in Persona Como tu Dan dolor de Cabeza de Dias de Fondo Midwest on WeChat video full movies. Or from Lindo Dario nombres de luna Jose bye


Imagine submitting sfm animation when other animators did actual hard work

Imagine submitting sfm animation when other animators did actual hard work

@PrinceWhateverer This appears to be brain damage before it's an opinion to be honest. This man is too daft to be reasoned with.

You know what yeah, I did misread that and I can admit it. But if you're telling me you made an earnest attempt at finding the material I referenced and were unable to, you are either lying or don't know how to use Google.

But here, since it seems the feat really was beyond you for whatever reason - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source_(game_engine)#Games_using_Source
As for your other points, there were none, so I don't know what you're referring to. Merely personal opinion and petty insults, which you're welcome to make. Though they betray your position.

@PrinceWhateverer Reread it if you think I didn't ask for source. I also see you didn't respond to my other points so i'm just gonna assume shit.

@Avery Flatt He doesn't need to provide sources because I did that for him.
Go to google and simply search for "what engine does insert game use?" use any of the game examples he gave.
Not going to agree to disagree because that'd imply subjectivity. Which is a compromise that benefits you and no one else. You are objectively wrong, own up to it or heck off.

@Avery Flatt He doesn't need to provide sources because I did that for him.
Go to google and simply search for "what engine does *insert game* use?" use any of the game examples he gave.
Not going to agree to disagree because that'd imply subjectivity. Which is a compromise that benefits you and no one else. You are objectively wrong, own up to it or heck off.

You didn't ask for a source, you only asked for me to name them. You can look up the source yourself. Literally just look at the source engine Wiki page man. Christ is this feat really beyond you?

PrinceWhateverer cause you didn’t provide sources.  You can’t sit here and tell me that some dude to close to camera screaming the lyrics is good animation and isn’t in fact sad.  Clearly this isn’t going anywhere and neither of us will ever change our opinions (though that is to be excepted)  so I propose to agree to disagree. Really I’m growing tired of rolling my eyes everytime I open up youtube

@Avery Flatt You absolutely can find sources for all of those. "what engine is <b>insert game</b> in?" and all the info is there. You know this though, you're just in denial.

@Avery Flatt You absolutely can find sources for all of those. "what engine is *insert game* in?" and all the info is there. You know this though, you're just in denial.

Also you failed to keep your word and shut up. Double sad. :c

Also you failed to keep your word and shut up. Double sad. :c

Just look at the games wikis man, it isn't hard.
"it dosnt take the [fact] away that everything sfm in here was just sad."
Your opinion is not fact I'm sorry to say.

PrinceWhateverer I can’t find any sources when googling the list you mentioned combined with sfm or anything to do with sfm and careers (the only things that kept popping up was just reddit and steam requests) but fuck it, why don’t I take your word on it. Even if sfm could accomplish amazing things witch i have yet to see, it dosnt take the fact away that everything sfm in here was just sad.

@PrinceWhateverer To add onto that, you're also wrong about commissions not counting as a career. Freelance careers are careers. Go on and tell me why the dictionary is wrong this time?

Despite you being unable to answer my questions, sure. I'll oblige. Respawn, as stated with games like Apex Legends and Titanfall, New World Interactive with Insurgency and Day of Infamy, Activision with Vampire: the Masquerade. Microsoft with Hybrid.<br>For your next pair of points; You don't know how much work each animator put into their part. SFM animation can look amazing when given to the right person, whereas 2D/tradition can look awful. You seem to think the worst examples of SFM animation are the rule where the opposite is true for 2D/traditional. It's such a narrow viewpoint based on personal bias.

Despite you being unable to answer my questions, sure. I'll oblige. Respawn, as stated with games like Apex Legends and Titanfall, New World Interactive with Insurgency and Day of Infamy, Activision with Vampire: the Masquerade. Microsoft with Hybrid.
For your next pair of points; You don't know how much work each animator put into their part. SFM animation can look amazing when given to the right person, whereas 2D/tradition can look awful. You seem to think the worst examples of SFM animation are the rule where the opposite is true for 2D/traditional. It's such a narrow viewpoint based on personal bias.

@Avery FlattDude clear your cataracts, I did give you an example, Respawn Entertainment.<br>On top of that, Valve is still a valid response whether they made it or not. A company is a company.

@Avery FlattDude clear your cataracts, I did give you an example, Respawn Entertainment.
On top of that, Valve is still a valid response whether they made it or not. A company is a company.

@Certedia If you're trying to offend me you're doing a shit job. Valve is not valid in this case because they created it so of course there gonna want people who know how to use it. Would a game designer hire a programmer someone who doesn't know the style of code the game uses? . Also I see you can't give any examples. If you have a career that isn't off youtube and make money off of sfm you'd be able to list a company. (before you start commissions from randoms doesn't count as a career)

@Avery Flatt SFM is actual 3D animation. That's an objective fact. It's animated, and in 3D.
You can't ask people to give examples of something only to say "but you can't use these examples because I say so" Valve is an example and a valid one at that, but to add to that, Respawn Entertainment uses the Source Engine for games like Apex Legends. Hence why the game as a similar character style to that of TF2.
To further invalidate your point, you've yet to acknowledge or disprove my argument about animation prowess largely carrying over from program to program.
SFM absolutely can take as long to work on as the 3:09 clip, Argodaemon is a good example of that.
If he's offended merely based on the length of his message, then so are you, for responding to my "cute" with a message 10 times its length.
You're a walking strawman, get a grip.

@PrinceWhateverer lmao to compare sfm to an actual 3d animators, also i'm very calm believe it or not. Name a company ( thats not valve sense they made the thing obv. also im talking a real company not just steam or random people) that would hire sfm people and a  reliable source than i'll shut up.  Go ahead and tell me that sfm takes just as hard work as something like 3:09. If you're offended by my comments so much as to make an essay on it go ahead and delete it. Clearly no one here is going to change there mind, as per the usual with opinions on the internet.

Your grammar was never my argument, I merely pointed it out. Calm down.
You didn't answer my first or third questions (I can't imagine why),  and your answer to the second question is anemic and holds no water. You act as though large companies like Pixar and Dreamworks are the only studios that pay for 3D animation. There are plenty of small online channels and creators who make their living on platforms like YouTube using animation tools like SFM. All your argument boils down to is "I don't like SFM animation because I have some negative preconceived notions that I cannot objectively prove."
I never argued a case for the assets themselves, only the source. In this context (ironically, your context) the people who make them. The assets themselves are too widely varied in quality for a case to be made about them specifically. Some are awful, some are amazing, so on that topic you're talking into the void. You should pay attention and reply to what people actually say.
You're free to dislike SFM all you want, but again, you have not made a single coherent argument as to why. You think it doesn't take hard work to create in SFM? I would challenge you to create something on the level of someone like Argodaemon and prove it. Do you think it's somehow impossible for people to make bad animations in Blender?

@PrinceWhateverer damn bro isn't there an old internet saying where you know the person lost when they correct peoples grammar?  Also people care about the source when it directly affects the quality. Like most people don't use Yahoo when they have a much better option like chrome, and yes the assets do affect the outcome especially when others are doing it from scratch.

@PrinceWhateverer Dad has spoken. Begone underling.

@PrinceWhateverer Dad has spoken. Begone underling.

"Any sensible company would hire an actually hard working animator and not someone who works on sfm".
Can you provide evidence that all SFM animators work less than any other animators?
"try to tell me that sfm has any competition on [can compete with*] people who make there [their*] own models and backgrounds."
As if the source of the assets has any bearing on the outcome. Where's the line? Should guitarists build their own guitars? Should writers manufacture their own pens and paper? This is a total non argument.
"There’s nothing wrong with doing sfm for fun, but when others are doing actual hard work[,] don’t sit there and tell me you are to [too*]."
But there is, in contrast, something wrong with doing it professionally? Again with the "actual hard work" argument, which you have still provided zero evidence of.
Let me learn you something big. Not a single (broadly speaking) client of 3D animators cares what program is used to create an animation. Just like how you don't care who wrote the code for the YT comment system you've been making use of. It's only the end product that matters. You haven't made a single objective argument against SFM as an animation platform beyond some nebulous statement about "actual hard work" (which btw, I would love to see the metrics on), and petty insults.
If you want a conversation about the topic, make a point.

@Avery Flatt Implying Valve isn't a company? Implying that careers require you to work under a company?
Implying that animation skills in one program do not convert to another?
Valve is a company.
Careers can be built independtly.
And as someone who works in several different 3D animation programs, I can assure you it transfers over. If I wanted to do what I do, in Blender, or Maya, I could. It'd take a bit to learn the layouts if it's a program I am new to, but besides that the vast majority of concepts carry over directly.
Just because you don't like an art style, that doesn't make it wrong. But go on, sis.

Certedia Any sensible company would hire an actually hard working animator and not someone who works on sfm (that’s why anything animated out there dosnt have sfm animation besides Valve) Go ahead and try to tell me that sfm has any competition on people who make there own models and backgrounds. There’s nothing wrong with doing sfm for fun, but when others are doing actual hard work don’t sit there and tell me you are to.

@Avery Flatt Animation obviously.<br>Where are these good arguments at? You're just throwing lame insults now. Go on, tell me how the dictionary definition of "career" does not apply to someone making a living making animations. Do it lad.

@Avery Flatt Animation obviously.
Where are these good arguments at? You're just throwing lame insults now. Go on, tell me how the dictionary definition of "career" does not apply to someone making a living making animations. Do it lad.

Certedia okay than what job do you have that you use sfm in? Hm? Also lmao “objectively wrong.” You talk like you where  that one smart kid in class that nobody liked.

@Avery Flatt Objectively wrong. It's by definition a career. It can pay the bills and it takes a significant amount of time. The dictionary disagrees with you. But let me guess, the dictionary has bad arguments?

Certedia who calls someone buster lmao? Also sfm can’t win you a career. Not to mention that I only said that because you said yes I am talking to my look whose talking like what? You want me to respond in agreement that you are in fact talking?

@Avery Flatt When did I say my career was on YouTube?  Oh right, never. Look around, buster.
What good arguments have you had? Was it when you said "congratulations would you like a trophy?"?
Or "Would you like a trophy?"?
Hard to decide, both are absolutely stunning arguments.

Certedia sir (or lady I don’t judge) your “profitable career” has lead you to 111 subscribers and one video with sfm.  If you think that that’s career worthy take a double take and spare me your overblown ego. Not to mention atleast I’ve been making points while your reply’s while your just saying stuff like cute. Like what?

@Avery Flatt Ironic. You've literally been repeating yourself.<br>Did my consistently profitable career hurt your frail body? Try a painkiller.

@Avery Flatt Ironic. You've literally been repeating yourself.
Did my consistently profitable career hurt your frail body? Try a painkiller.

@Certedia Well you just made it obvious you ran out of stuff to say. Start talking crap (though you should get better at that to cause it feels like i'm talking to a bot) when you learn real animation.

Certedia congratulations would you like a trophy?

Certedia congratulations would you like a trophy?

@Avery Flatt Yes. I am talking. This is indeed a thing that is happening.

@Avery Flatt Yes. I am talking. This is indeed a thing that is happening.

@Avery Flatt You cared so little that you went to the comment section to tell everyone about how little you care lmao

Certedia imagine caring about winning or loosing an internet fight and claiming the other person is salty when in reality they really don’t care

@Avery Flatt Imagine getting salty over losing an internet argument. Would you like a hobby?

@Avery Flatt Imagine getting salty over losing an internet argument. Would you like a hobby?

Certedia imagine thinking you’ve “won” an Internet argument.  Would you like a trophy?

Certedia imagine thinking you’ve “won” an Internet argument.  Would you like a trophy?

@Avery Flatt Imagine thinking people are offended simply because they've got better arguments than you.

Certedia imagine getting offended by a YouTube comment

Certedia imagine getting offended by a YouTube comment

Imagine submitting a YouTube comment when other commenters took the time to actually write something people might care about.


@Christian Contreras SO WHY ARE YOU HERE IF YOU HATE IT? Leave if you hate it so much.

If it was banned, <b>then why is it still up?</b>

If it was banned, *then why is it still up?*


So why did you comment <b>on a MLP video?</b>

So why did you comment *on a MLP video?*