Sawtooth really makes everyone’s day! Whenever I feel sad I watch a vid and I forgot why I felt sad! (I hope that it isn’t something important!)


Wouldn't the Elements of Harmony be able to detect if Pinkie was the original, we can see Twilight doesn't have her wings yet, and they used the Elements on the day they discovered the Tree of Harmony. But now that I think about it, the Elements were also used on the day she got her wings, where we see the memories play through her eyes...or get transferred from her Element.


Impressive video! I'm 100% on board for this plot to take down the purple princess


I don't know if I agree with the conclusion, but I do agree that Twilight's test, even if it just gently sent them back to their own mirror realm, was torture and thus  should be forbidden under the Jennyva Convention.
I have ADHD and I had to get a pet scan and I was told I couldn't even read or watch videos while getting the contrast because if even my eyes moved too much it would hamper its ability to go to the right place. I was panicked for the whole week between hearing about it and having the test done, because I can't sit still that long at all (it was like an hour). I fidget constantly. I was on the verge of tears when I went for my scan, I was so scared... and I told them that and they said I could listen to audio books and occasionally twitch a finger/toe if I needed to move and it was much better.
If a bunch of people with ADHD were put into the same room and forced to sit perfectly still and reacted like I did with my scan, that would be horrible.
Even if Twilight didn't actually kill them or cause them direct physical pain, she needs to be held accountable for her unethical treatment of Pinkie and her clones.


One thing that you may not have taken into account, how would The Elements work if this were true, surely they would have noticed that they were being used by the wrong Pinkie.


Okay so this is about the new movie and the earth ponies having magic. You talked about this in an episode a few weeks ago and I have a theory. The earth favors them, like actually. Like if a group of earth ponies were camping somewhere and a rainstorm hit, the forest will give them a convenient path to a shelter or cave. Or if they're faming the earth will give better healthier soil. They the don't do this for unicorns because they feel as if they're always trying to change them artificially with magic and the pegasus are up in the sky so distant that the have no bond at all. The earth respects the earth because they do think naturally no artificial magic. And they're really close unlike The pegasus. This is long bye


Personally I don't think Twilight killed Pinkie, it's a pretty big stretch to make, but it's definitely a fun idea to speculate on. (Also killing the clones <b>was</b> still very inhumane).

Personally I don't think Twilight killed Pinkie, it's a pretty big stretch to make, but it's definitely a fun idea to speculate on. (Also killing the clones *was* still very inhumane).


The biggest hole in this theory is that the clones only cared about fun, where the most important thing in Pinkie's life are her friends. Everything she does is for them. For friends, the real Pinkie could have watched that paint dry, motionless, for days. The clones, however, didn't even seem to be sapient.


If you look at the original MLP clip showing them watching the paint, we can see at 1:57 one of the clones shows a realistic horse face, while the Pinkie next to her has a saddened, dark expression, resembling exactly the way the real Pinkie had looked when she was carried in. What if...that was the real Pinkie Pie?


I’m British and I love Cosine’s British voice,it’s hilarious


Nope. In the episode, Saddle Row Review (S6E9), we saw that not all the clones were perished, there was another Pinkie in the back during the interview. So clearly there was at least one stray Pinkie while the “test” was ongoing. Sunburst probably crossed paths with the wrong Pinkie when that story was brought up.


My goodness, all that Sine said actually happened and is more than plausibly true being that it actually happened <br>We’ve been watching a phony baloney this entire time!!!

My goodness, all that Sine said actually happened and is more than plausibly true being that it actually happened
We’ve been watching a phony baloney this entire time!!!


there's an episode in a later season that shows a second pinkie pie in disguise in the background while the current pinkie is being interviewed, so most likely they just didn't quite catch all the pinkie clones the first time


But what about the Elements of Harmony? It wasn’t a clone that became the Element of Laughter, it was Pinkie herself. A clone of Pinkie Pie isn’t really Pinkie Pie, like how Sine Waves isn’t really Sawtooth, so it wouldn’t have been able to use her Element. And the Elements work just fine with the Pinkie we know, so this has to be the real Pinkie Pie. I’m sure there were stragglers, but rather than barely escaping with their lives, they may have simply wandered off

But what about the Elements of Harmony? It wasn’t a *clone* that became the Element of Laughter, it was Pinkie *herself.* A clone of Pinkie Pie isn’t really Pinkie Pie, like how Sine Waves isn’t really Sawtooth, so it wouldn’t have been able to use her Element. And the Elements work just fine with the Pinkie we know, so this *has to be* the real Pinkie Pie. I’m sure there were stragglers, but rather than barely escaping with their lives, they may have simply wandered off


What about the episode where they were helping Rarity open her shop in Manehatten? There was another Pinkie in the background when Pinkie was giving her interview.


And what about the one that never even participated in the test?  What are clones even capable of?  The clones don't retain memories from before their creation, but the clones of Pinkie seem to retain the innate ability to manipulate physics.  I'm guessing this would mean that should a pegasus clone themselves, the clones could fly and manipulate clouds, and if a unicorn cloned themselves, they could perform magic.  Also, do clones biologically function the same way?  The extra Pinkie we see is at a diner in Manehattan, so I imagine clones need to eat.  The Pinkie we follow throughout the show eventually has a kid, so are clones capable of natural reproduction?  And the Pinkie we see at the diner looks concerned, so she clearly knows that she or the other Pinkie isn't supposed to exist at the same time, somehow she heard the story.  And we see Twilight use a spell to zap the Clones away and their essences fly back to the mirror pond, so does that mean you have to perform magic on the clone to remove them, or do you have to somehow coerce them into going back into the pond?  What happens if you go into the pond and don't recite the poem?  Do you fall through to the reflection world?  Why am I going off the deep end?!


Question two clones actually know what happened to you. And if they knew what they tried to get you out of the statue. Or if they didn't they probably try to look for you.


The real Pinkie is still alive. The ONLY piece of evidence to support the claim that she is dead is a single sentence from sunburst. Mendella effect could easily cause him to misremember it, or for starlight to misremember it, or they misheard it, or they forgot and had to incorrectly pick up the pieces. This theory gets a lot more traction than it deserves.

I KNOW WHERE YOU LIVE SAWTOOTH.


I don’t think the real pinkie is gone, because if pinkie that we know is a clone I don’t think her element of harmony would have worked


I'd more likely believe Twilight mistakenly destroyed the wrong Pinkie, rather than how the mirror itself works...This is really stretching things.


I'm not very sure about this situation weather if the real pinkie pie became a victim of twilight's banishment or it is actually one of the clones, your theory is very based not gonna lie but I'm sure it is still the real pinkie pie who survived this challenge, only by staring at a paint dry, if they were to stay loyal to prove themselves on which one is real to stay with the mane 5, I might say it is one of the clones, I don't know why but that's my final answer!


Maybe the first clone had obtained all of pinkie's prior knowledge and your clone to... he seems to know a whole lot about the incident....


Oh no! The Pinkie I thought I loved so much might actually be a fake Pinkie! Which means Twilight might be a murderer!

Wait a minute....If Pinkie got her Pinkieness from absorbing Discord's magic, like Sawtooth suggests in another Pinkie episode, then Pinkie got her Pinkieness because a clone absorbed Discord's magic! Woah, this is some kind blowing ideas right here.🤯


Wait, so if Pinkie Pie is gone then how did the clone get the magic from Grogar’s Bell? In the video (https://youtu.be/6NHdTswd4yM) a year ago, you said the effects that Pinkie got from the bell made her this kind of creature today, so how does the Clone have the magic for the bell? Maybe the actual pinkie pie is still here, or maybe… the clone had gotten the bell and switched the original Pinkie Pie with the clone. Ok, this is getting confusing. 😅


I have a question. How did ponies get cutie marks? Because in one of the episodes when tirek took magic from all ponies there cutie also went away. That means cutie marks also required magic. I also love your videos


Okay, but there's evidence that at least one Pinky Clone had escaped the test, though You've even covered it - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prD4Y7Y_cks . We've seen bonus Pinkys since the mirror pool episode, so it's possible the cloning story COULD have come from a clone Pinky without Original Pinky having been sent to the mirror  pool.


ok but what if one of the clones DID survive and didn't attend the massacre. If no one found out then sunburst would have assumed she was the real pinkie and surviving clone pinkie could've told the story from her perspective (diving in the pool) sunburst wouldn't have questioned it as twilight would've said there were no more surviving clones. whatever happened to the clone after welllllll I dunno.


Or they simply missed one like they did back when they did the interview in Manhattan 😂


I'm not convinced at all of this theory. But, something makes a bit of sense


i learned about the different kinds of waves like a couple of days ago and it make me so happy that ur alternate form is sine wave. also now i know why you call urself sawtooth waves and u like to make digital music. Genius.


It’s actually possible that this could be true because of pinkie sense. After the clone massacre according to my knowledge we never see pinkie use pinkie sense which could mean that she doesn’t have it.


Oh, so that’s why she’s so overly happy after that season.


It is an interesting theory. Never thought of it like that.


I have some questions about my little pony a new generation that maybe you can answer in like a vid or respond to this(hopefully you see this😁) : I want to know what happened to all the different creatures like hippogriff’s dragons yachts,changelings, etc because wouldn’t they try to help all the pony’s if mayhem broke out because in Twilights school they came to work together and helped unite all the creatures and what happened to Canterlot. Also wouldn’t when mayhem happened Celestia and Luna would shave know and come help and what happened to all the creatures that were locked up in Tartarus wouldn’t with all the magic gone they might have escaped and got lose? Also do you think will happen in the next movie and do you think we will get to know what happened to the og six? I know there’s a few questions in there and it’s very long I’m sorry for that but I hope you get to see it because I’m been wondering about these for so long 🤣🤣 anyways if you don’t that’s fine and I also just want to say that I LOVE your videos and I hope you continue making them!!


If she was a mirror clone How does she age up? Tanananã....ok, here is the real question, doesn't Twilight used a spell that only kills copies, that's why she was so confident on using It?


I don’t like the depressing feeling this is giving me


Video conspiracy theory: Celestia knew twilight was gonna make friends and they will save equstria here if you re watch episode 1 somehow for all the preparation have her friends and she assigned twilight to do it  and she meets everyone and in the letter she say to make friends and twilight  said "it's not like making friends depends on thr faih of equstria" but then again it is a theory


unless it's just logic that the real pinkie actually survived

• 𝓈 𝓊 𝓏 𝒾 𝑒 •


Every story is a horror story if you think about it too much.


i think that the real pinkie survived bc she offered the test to twilight


Well that reminds me of when my oc took on a alot of artificial clones of him from a different dimension intierly and things get confusing remember that transformers crossover with my little pony that nameless mentioned well those clones where made by a relic from that dimension called the allspark and the incerdent ended was one of them still alive had escaped the carnage and was found dead the body was found in vr during a mission called a dreaded beast it was found dead with a blast through the chest and that where you get the ability to go through minds and read minds and by the way the body’s location was at cantalot castle on princess celestial throne and that massicure was mentioned by my oc friend the transformers character soundwave say that there a chance of a proper dead


Okay, but they don't actually kill the clones the just are sending them back to the mirror pool where they have presumably infinite time to sit and do nothing. Also if you can clone someone is it possible to bring a clone of someone who's dead from the pool???


OR THE ONE THAT TOLD IT LIKE THAT WAS THAT ONE PINKIE CLONE IN THE BACKGROUND OF THE RESTAURANT IN THAT ONE EPISODE LMAO


But what if it's actually start burst who's the clone telling the story from his perspective fooling us all?


Hey Sawtooth So you Know how Celestia banished Nightmare into the moon. Well tecnicly she is the first mare on the moon.


I think, the original Pinkie survived. Only original Pinkie was depressed because she was unsure she is real one (i guess clones can't think that way) and other ponies won't be friends with her. So after the test Pinkie said about her worries to ponies.

Елизавета Чудаева


This reminds me of that Red Dwarf fan theory that Lister shut off the wrong Rimmer in "Me2".


I think ours was a clone, but what about the Pinkie that had the investigator hat?


Did you notice that nopony but Pinkie created any more clones from the lake?

This means that only Pinkie has the power to create living things. Which means that Pinkie is a divine entity, and the entire surrounding world is a projection of her imagination. In short, Pinkie is the god of the pony world who does not realize that she is a god. (Or maybe she realizes, she's just having fun))) )

Nevertheless, Pinkie hast created all things; and for her will they were, and have been created!


no we all new that the sad pinkie was the real one and that she was the pinkie that lived


I’m genuinely confused as to how you get these ideas, if I were you the ideas would pop up in the middle of the night XD


-Time travel ?
-TIME TRAVEL !
- Pinkie fix now...i....think ?


What if the surviving clone telled the story


One more thing to back this claim up. Cheese sandwich

Pinkie doesn't remember cheese sandwich from when they were kids and the party she threw-

Now correct me in the replies :D


I don't think the test was right but that mostly because is was though for a kid show that had to be resolved under 30 mins.
Also there is so many plot inconsistency in the show at all that this one might just have not been notice it.
Also would Pinkie clone testify again her friend? I am not even sure she would know she is an actual clone of pinkie.
Plus if she was a clone of the original that was given all her memories she might as well be the original.
Also while clone should not have been killed off they could have spread them all over Equestria to share the laughter or something.
My biggest problem is actually to know what would really happen if the clone were to stay for long would they have poped on their own?
the miror pool should have some limitation on what it can do either time or distance even the element can't really be used at their full potential without eachother and their bearrer


Has clone considered that sunburst was just speaking metaphorically (dove into the clone making) and/or making a pun (dove into)

Not only that
But the memory thing is a very long shot
Even in a world of magic

Not only that
But the memory thing is a *very* long shot
Even in a world of magic


Statues dedicated to them? Are THEY the statues? Did they get stoned too? 🧐


Come now, don't try to make yourself an official character of the MLP universe. You're in the Fanverse that is a copy of the MLP universe but the fans stuff exist in it


then how did the elements worked on pinki? since she is a clone only pinki the original could get it, NOT the  clone pinki!


Why not? She acted bifferent than all the others


<b>*merges the "mlp g4 timeline" with the "mlp g5 timeline" for no reason at all no matter what completely permamently forever successfully. :/*</b>

**merges the "mlp g4 timeline" with the "mlp g5 timeline" for no reason at all no matter what completely permamently forever successfully. :/**


But if the pink it was a clone she wouldn’t be able to use her element of harmony it wouldn’t work the same because she’s just a clone


Did he literally forgot remember there was another Pinky in that restaurant in that city I can't remember the name of could that be the real Pinky


This is not true chrysalis made clones and tried to make them wear the elements of harmony.  After they were put on the clones faded away.  I believe Pinkie would fade away too if she was actually a clone


Na because the whole memories thing also pinkie can be serious and focused when she wants to be if she was so easily distracted she would've gotten distracted and forgotten about a pinky promise  instead of consistently chasing them

When you get distracted yoy tend to forget


If that was a clone pinky then look at the last episode somehow she knows all the friends that she had made yes this was in season one but she didn’t meet some friends along the way also known as the donkey and look what we see in the last episode a donkey in her memories either this is a coincidence or the real pinky is still live in if that was a fake pinky then how is the elements of harmony of laughter still in her possession because of that’s a fake then the element knows that so it must be the real pinky and plus pinky wouldn’t want to lose her friends and that is my theory


So the pinkie pie we all know and love is a clone


No because pinky used her magic freely and remember everything with details also in moment like this pinky will be not sure if she pulled out of water or not

شيكو بيقو tube


If the real pinkie would have died, the clones would have disapeared as well, right?


Or what if one of the clons told the story and the real pink pie is how servived


I Doubt the real Pinkie is dead that would be dark the Mare we have Known for all theses years can't have died that long ago not to Mention the way they die as they go back to the Mirrior also Twilight is kind of an Alicorn what the Hell is Equstria gonna do if she is found Guilty on killing one of her friends by mistake but in short no i don't think shes dead that just No but yeah


I got a ferry to that timeline that wasn't seeing that had no structure I think that was the windigo


Im pretty late but maybe when you unfroze after all that time they found out and twilight needed to do the three elements things ( sorry I don’t know what it’s called Right now) and after that she un–became a alicorn and wasn’t the roller anymore wich led to the tribes spreading apart !


Because twilight is the princess of equstia and being the princess of equstia it makes it hard for her friends and family to spend time together with her. Also there are many things she has to do wich she would rather not to. The only other person with her is her dragon assistant spike.


If this is true then how that the elements of harmony work ? They only work with the right pony


eh, those trig jokes were all <i>right</i>


Saw, did you forget that you made a video that showed there being two Pinkies?

Hmmm 🤔
I’m more wondering how that wasn’t mentioned. ;p

Edit was typo


Hello! I’m a big fan and I love theory’s!


Maybe I think sign is correct After allthe Clone Killing was very strange. Like it is  possible that twilight could have killed the og pinkie.


Suggestion: what happened to the timelines STARLIGHT created?

he already covered them in another video.


If twilight can murder clones why doesnt she just murder tirek or smth or all the villians


It would make sense that the original pinkey is in the mirror pool and the one that we think is real is fake .it would make sense with pinky magic.not that your theory isn’t right


It’d be funny if the pinky at the end was the real pinky


Taking too seriously do I smell a Collab😏


Yes down with the  purple pony princess.

Yes down with the  purple pony princess.


Why do you hate Twilight so much? What did she do?


I’m sorry but this Hass to be said if it is the clone pinky she would know she’s a clown and then know that The real pinky was killed improving the probability of twilight ❌


I would hate to disprove this theory but clones can’t reproduce and pinkie had a kid, it has to be the real one


Season 6 Episode 9. 6:55 and 10:44 and 12:18 . That's all I have to say on the matter🤣


your theory is considered completely incorrect basically. :/


Uh, when did this turn into a purple princess anarchy?


Pinky Pie is the best and EarthPony on My Little Pony Friendship is Magic!


Plot twist the pinky pointing at us is a clone


Which video did the beginning of this one stem from?


wait didnt pinkie pie say she switches with her equestria girl


I agree it terrible what twilight did to the clones and now wonder one the pinkes went on the run in manehatten because I the great the clones and good egutation they could have become there on pony.


So where is the original things. And how many time did Twilight do the time travel loop since the lead to the loop. How did the First Twilight look like when she travel in time?


What if their was no real pinky what if a changing pulled the pinky we know out of the mirror pool and the real "pinky pie" is one of the changlings


who else wants sawtooth waves FACE REAVEAL!!!!!!!?


Even if pinkie went into the mirror pool 🏊♀ that still did not mean she wouldn’t remember any of the thing that happened when she was on earth 🌎 this is still cool 😎 anyway but wait what if all of pinkie friends are clones of themselves soo many questions soo little timing 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻and also how could Twilight have killed the Real pinkie in the first place if all the other we’re all gone to begin with think on that!!!


Don’t worry everypony, Pinky Pie is not dead. She has survived the massacre. She is smarter than she looks. Besides I don’t think the creators of My pony friendship is magic would want to kill one of the mane six. Pinky is alive. Well in the G4 timeline anyway. My point is that Pinky survived and she was there with her friends till the end.🐴💓🥧🎉


ok. where the fk is that shotgun with anti-clone bullets???


So why didn't she just send chrysalis tirek and cozy to the mirror pool


I don’t know if your doing Pinkie Justice or just don’t like Twilight


Ahhh sorry saw but I don't think she is dead I think she is in the clones world because pinky pulled someone els so same way for the royal guards


3 hours ago? I usually watch vids of you that you made like 3 years ago🤣<br>I’m finally early 🥲

3 hours ago? I usually watch vids of you that you made like 3 years ago🤣
I’m finally early 🥲


OFF TOPIC BUT ZECORA NEEDED MORE ATTENTION😩


I love pinkie she my favorite dont do this to me


Pinkie is alive, pinkie clone in a ep. A canterlot one


Wow I seriously bought that you are still doing g4


Wait what what do you mean by pinkie dead


And u also make a video (what would be the after life of who die) pls make <br>If this comments get 30 likes then u have to make it!!!😋

And u also make a video (what would be the after life of who die) pls make
If this comments get 30 likes then u have to make it!!!😋


But the real pinkie pie is bieb o my lord I hope she was never bieb but am going to appledees and am happy to go but am sada that the real Pinkie is bieb plus why bib her clones go in the pool and why bo you make this shows about ponies tho and


Hey sense Two of are alive If won of you where dead your memory s will go to the clown


and even tho this was posted 3 days ago and then it said it was made 2 weeks ago


But when you think that pinkie clone survive wellll no becouse pinkie clone said  Pinkie clone: i just had to look at the paint icant lose my friends. So is not pinkie clone that survive is the actule pinkie that survive.


What if one pinkie pie scape
1. I see one pinkie pie clone not kill what if is here you think all pinkie pie are kill no no no if you leave one clone  behind Will be will pinkie pie ask clone help her friends her clone say yes
2. Can you make me a pony a pony is  entity have tail and legs and body and head and neck and eye one to be a indoraptor and one eye is mine eye ok
 |
V
3.i think you video all like it so please more but i have one thing who is Princess Luna boyfriend is Godzilla jr a Godzilla pony ok
4. Can you make a movie my little pony the endgame movie please make it happen


it is humourus what Americans think us british people are like


Plsssssssssss noooooooo!!!! Twilight is not a murder

🍀𝙻𝚞𝚌𝚔𝚢𝙰𝚌𝚎𝚇𝙳😆


I like dat his second channell name i sawtooth memes.


Okay but the fake pinky's only say I am the real pinky and the real one would have said something else except that the pink is were having fun except one which was probly Pinky by because she get sad like the time when blah blah blah shadow Monster took over ponyvill she cried because of the take looking so ugly  so the one who was digging with her hope was the real one because the real Pinky would never fail to get back with her friends why would she even want to leave her friends anyways


You’re a chain Celine why did it happen would you rather just like it’s toilet just ask pinky what he did and he said just ask pinky pinky


🍀𝙻𝚞𝚌𝚔𝚢𝙰𝚌𝚎𝚇𝙳😆

🍀𝙻𝚞𝚌𝚔𝚢𝙰𝚌𝚎𝚇𝙳😆


Happy birthday to me 🎂🎉🎂🎉 November 17   7 years old Birthday 🎂🎉🎉🎊🎉🎊🎂🎉🎊🎉🎉🎊🎉


Sawtooth want a very special idea I can say u


Great Video! I do agree that the Pinkie massacre was not the best idea, but they might know the clone's perspective, because simply one of the clone Pinkies told it and the original Pinkie was too distracted to correct them.


The fact that Sawtooth decided it necessary to do an entire changeling transformation to change the hair accessory


You have made mlp so much better and mysterious for me! I love your theories and videos.


In my opinion when a clone is made it is still the person or in this case pony. The only difference is that they were not the original. Twilight should be in court just for the murder of at least a hundred lives.<br>Loved this video by the way.

In my opinion when a clone is made it is still the person or in this case pony. The only difference is that they were not the original. Twilight should be in court just for the murder of at least a hundred lives.
Loved this video by the way.


I literally can't when someone brings this up-

It takes me back to the era of when I read tons of angsty fanfic about Twilight and the Pinkies she had killed


I just started watching MLP G4 and ended up skipping that episode entirely once I heard about the Pinkiecide. Pinkies exploding everywhere was just too much😣


Yeah, I don't know, this all implies that Sunburst accurately knows how the mirror pool works and/or heard Pinkie's story. He was Starlight's friend first and was being shown the pool for the first time, so I doubt he'd already heard Pinkie's story. Considering Pinkie knew it and not Twilight initially, I'm going to guess the mirror pool is one of those "old mare's tales" rather than well established magical information. Sunburst is book smart too, so I don't think he'd accurately know how the pool works either.


fun video. a few things to unpack tho. did the Pinkies really die? I thought they were just magically sent back to the pool. So I'm not convinced the spell twilight used was a murder spell so much as a counter spell of sorts. Second is the question of how the pool worked and what it actually does. Is the pool a gate to parallel worlds or timelines? Are the reflections merely divisions of the same original ponies spirit losing strength in each copy? does Mod's secret cave have any connection with it?


I think you both forgot, there were still clones alive. Not just the one that survived the test. If It was a clone, then they could easily be switching information as to deal with certain people or events. Or been switching out if one got distracted or tired. Or the clone we saw could have been the real pinky, and the reason she never intervened was because she was scared twilight would rid of her.


2:37
"what kind of a name is cosine anyway?"
"would you rather me call them square waves?
"..."
"or triangle wav-"
"ok good point"
😂😂

I get it but there name could be record and jukebox


Can you do a video about theories of where did Princess_Celestia find Spike as an Egg so that it could explain who his parents are and why they never came back for him along with why she gave him to Twilight Sparkle instead of returning him to the Dragon_Land?


I mean, it also depends on if the clones were technically alive and if they were killed or their magic just returned to the mirror pool


A'right ima take this theory down! (As a joke of course) If you remember the episode when Crystalis made the main 6 clones, The Tree of Harmony destroyed them BECAUSE they were clones and were causing disharmony. Of course, you can argue that pinkies clones weren't "evil" and could have very well worked as a replacement for her element, but i highly doubt that.

I don't think it destroyed them because they were clones, I think it makes more sense that it killed them because they had their hooves all over the elements, it probably would have done it to anypony it believed had bad intent


I’ve Always Thought That The Pinkie With The Hat Was The Real Pinkie And She’s Been Keeping Tabs On The Clone Pinkie For The Whole Time She Was Alive


While I agree the current pinkie is definitely a clone, I believe that there is a handful of them running around. I think the one we regularly see now is standing in for the original while she’s doing her own thing, essentially allowing her to be in more than one place at once, which would cover the memory inconsistencies. There also appear to be very similar ponies to pinkie, like the dancing pony in that rarity episode. It’s most likely pinkie worked with a few clones after that incident to do this, and it’s possible a few ran away to have their own lives.


Um clone Sawtooth said “Au Revoir” as “oh-rev-war ”

As a fluent French speaker I can testify that this is not the correct pronunciation. You don’t pronounce the “re,” so it’s simply “oh-vwar”

This is a common mistake that non-French-speakers make, and if you were to say it to someone from France they’d know what you mean, but it would be clear to them that you are not a native French speaker.


Not all the Pinkies were destroyed, we know at least one has survived from a different episode... I think it was saddle row? So we know at least 2 Pinkies still exist. As for this theory, its 99% a continuity error found in some very unimportant dialogue.


I think everypony here agrees that "Too many Pinkies" was a rather controversial and confusing episode.


But would they really add death in a show for a younger audience?

Yes sombra did "die" but he came back in season 9


so we passed from "twilight killed the real pinkie" to "clone rigths"....seems about right


Wait so we’ve been living for the fake pinkie for 6 seasons?…….also the fake pinkie has suffered trying to use the elements of harmony, meeting discord, and fighting chrysalis, cozy glow, and discord? And so much more?


There is one fatal flaw in this theory. A clone of Pinkie Pie does not represent the Element of Laughter. She would not be able to wield her element OR have the map call her to solve friendship problems as she isn't tied to it. Given the fact that Pinkie Pie is connected to the map and her element, we can conclusively say that our Pinkie is the real Pinkie.


Couldn't they find some spell? Some spell that could tell who of which is a clone? If there's a spell for literally giving someone wings, or a portal to being a human, blah blah blah, surely there could be a spell of some sort to tell of which is a clone. Also, do you think that that one 'clone', of Pinkie that one time when they were in the restaurant thing, may have been the REAL Pinkie? She could have fled the scene, scared that she would be killed? Pinkie Pie could be anywhere.. Who knows, Pinkie can be anywhere now.

Anyways, love the accent of your clones lol. They're just as smart too. Luckily it's easy to tell who's who though!


Ok, so I don't believe that we have/had a clone of Pinky, but something Sine said made me realize something: only 2 of the clones were made from Pinky herself. So the clones from the clones would have been even more ADHD. So, my guess is that the last clone left in the room with the real Pinky was the first clone she made, because it was the least ADHD out of all of them.


I agree with Sawtooth and well stuff gets mixed up and changed in communication


I dont think our pinkie is a clone
1 based on the surviving Pinkys reaction to passing (the Clone Pinky's wouldn't have wanted to hold on to a friend that they didn't have as much as she did)
2 all of the Clones were made when Pinkie Pie was thinking about fun so they all act on fun but out pinkie is able to show more emotion than fun
3 Pinky has her memories
4 she can activate the elements of harmony
5 we know there was at least one surviving Pinky which means there could be more so even if the Clone won pinky could still be alive and I wouldn't put it past her to come back and smother the clone pinky at night or to let the clone go and they make a deal where really pinkie stays and clone pinkie goes to have fun in manehatten


clone or not, when Twilight started killing all those Pinkies it broke my heart


How did Sunburst hear it as Pinkie diving into the pool?

Saddle Row Review showed us one Pinkie clone lived, now living with a secret identity in Manhattan, she could've spread that knowledge for all we know.


I am pretty sure that the spell twilight cast can only effect clones so if she tried on the real pinkie no thing would happen .

in that case, why the paint test? why not zapp every pinkie they see and the real one would stay either way


Objection! The real pinkie the sad pinkie who came up with the test. if she did come up with a idea for the test she could have prepared. then because her friendships were on the line she could have pushed through it. also i also thought the clones were blank slates who knew nothing, because they were just created. they would have no memory like you said.


I don’t think this question CAN ever be answered, pinkie is so chaotic that either outcome is just as likely as the last


I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE THAT THOUGHT THIS!!!! I was like "wait what if she got the wrong pinkie..?"


“No better than a saw game.” Me who just finished watching Jigsaw “Wait a damn minute.-“


Hmmmm, but the tree of harmony was shown to be able to tell if something was a copy. The 'clone' could have ended up like the fakes that Chrysalis made.


Or another plausible theory is that the well was meant to create a body for the main conciousness to go into once the original body dies so it could be that her current body isn't her original but is still the original conciousness so it didn't matter as long as 1 pinkie clone was alive. But if the clones live long enough then they would develop their own conciousness like your clones and the mind transfer would not work since the clone body was not empty


2:44

I just finished a trimester of precalculus/trigonometry. I found this way too funny.


Well, in the test og pinkie( original pinkie)seemed determined and nervous, we could see it but pinkie does get distracted but still


Only one pony can be element of harmony. It's way stronger magic than cloning and tree woudn't be fooled by a clone...


How about the clonning method that Starlight used ?


Technically it shouldn’t matter either way, if a clone is an exact copy of the original. I mean, if you have a book, it’s just a copy, but it has all of he same information as every other copy, so who cares? And anyway, she stared at paint for an hour, she earned it


I hope you see my comment @sawtooth waves but in Manhattan  when they were all helping Rarity with the store you could see another pinky "clone pinky probably"  there while the  Pinky they know was eating and explaining the story .


“you're taking this too seriously..?”
“y- NO!!”

“you're taking this too seriously..?”
*“y- NO!!”*


what if the pony of shadows caused the sepperation of the tribes in G5? we know it's still around from when it appeared in the castle of the 2 sisters in G4 ... so what if he was the reason that twilight made the stones? to save everyone from the pony of shadows (who i think also had posessed luna and that helper of starswirl (i forgot his name) )


also, in the ending of season 8 Pinkie gets her "magic" back, maybe that was just magic from the pool? 💀


Twilight said that this spell will make glones go back to the pool, not kill them. Twilight is smart, she would know what this spell does and she is incapable of murder. This spell prapably brought them back to the mirror dimention. Or maybe not because they don't have memory about mirror Twilight's friends. Magic is complicated, who knows that actually happened to clones


I bet we all had this dark Question for years!


OMG THIS QUESTION WAS IN MY HEAD ALL MY LIFE SINCE MY FIRST TIME BEING A BRONY....


i think that what you're saying somewhat makes ense, but i still have a problem with it. remember how spike tried to use Rainbow Dash's element of harmony, and it didn't work. that means that only the real mane six are meant to use those elements, yet if the Pinkie Pie we know later on was one of the clones, then how could she be able to use real Pinkie's element of Laughter? this is all bbased on the assumption that the elements don't work on clones


the pinkie that survived can not be a clone because she can use the element of laughter but she is not worthy of such relic..also all clones look the same when they age because they don't and the pinkie we saw aged so theory busted i guess


Well, it sounds just like Bobba Fett with extra steps


i guess your right... i was watching the video earlier you were telling or something when i watched it somethings not right.... last year i always feel like the pinkie is not the real one. i think its a clone but pinkie said she will never leave her friends she will do anything i was so confused.... ig lol


but what about the other pinkie sitting in the booth in the episode about rarity's store's reviews? is that just another clone, or the original pinkie who could've escaped twilight's massacre?


So what I'm hearing is basically Team Starkid's Forever and Always but with Cheesepie.


No the real Pinkie was showing negative emotions at the time.


The original pinkie could have also just weren’t there, maybe she was far away were the main six couldn’t find her but she returned and found the other pinkie so maybe she hud her in a place no one could find here but sometimes where time was precise, she would escape for enough time for a person to know her perspective. And about twilight maybe um if they ask they would may ask when the other pinkie is out.

!! - - 𝙋𝙖𝙩𝙩𝙮 𝙏𝙝𝙚 𝙒𝙚𝙞𝙧𝙙𝙤 ★


it had to be the real pinky cause remember in the one episode where queen cristales clowned the main six they blew up when they tried to use the elements of harmony and if we follow that logic then wouldn't pink clone who u say is alive blow up to so that would alertly debunk your theory and would mean that the real pinky pie alive and all the clones died


Like even thinking about it it made me like sad lol, like twilight literally obliterated the clones, and pinkie tried not to die, and then what if she did? Pinkieeeee


I realized that when the tow clones were there two 2 things appeared


Everything about pinkie pie is a complete mystery


What if sunburst bumped into the clone and she told the story to him


How could Spike and the other ponies tell who is the real Pinkie Pie and who is a clone since she acts like Discord without the chaos magic?


Whatever happened to the Yaks, Dragons, Changelings, Hippogriffs and other creatures from the FIM universe when the ponies divided?


it was the real pinkies idea and at the end, pinkie said I will do anything to be with my friends and it was the real pinkie


No hate but, why in the wide wide world of Equestria would you wanna get rid of the Princess of Friendship, Ruler of Equestria, Bringer of Harmony, Wielder of the Element of Magic? Also,, the real Pinkie would want to prove herself real and so suggested the contest and resisted all the distractions to be with her friends so she is the Pinkie we saw after the episode with the Mirror Pool ( I forgot the name XD). Her friendships were at risk and she could lose them forever, so that's what motivated her to win this contest. But that's my theory. There are way more possibilities. Anyway, can't wait for the next video!


I think it is the real pinkie coz she loves her best friends more that anything and her bffs know her better then anyone even us💖


The real Pinkie is dead??? Heh... Twilight didn't know. :)


Ok but it all makes perfectly sense :O!!


DID HE CHANGE HIS PROFILE TO THE BRITISH ONE 🤣


If this is true then why did the Pinkie clone have an identity crisis when the others didn’t?


What sawtooth? are going to try and make me believe you slept through all of this?


Yes i think pinkie has been killed by twilight :c

i mean like this theory proves everything unless we miss something

My Emotions : NUUU WHY PINKIE 🤧


Wow I actually know why their names are sin and cosine. For once Algebra 3 is becoming useful in the real world


I don’t think so
Becouse every pinkie was happy and saying “I’m the real pinkie!” “No I’m the real pinkie!” And that is a thing pinkie would say yeah but there was one,only one that was not like that,she was the opposite of “pinkie pie” she was not like any other pinkie pie and was like “wait-what if I’m not the real pinkie pie-“ “I don’t even know myself” that must mean that she knows what they actually are (I think) so she knows they are clones as perfectly as ever so she must be the real pinkie pie,she also suggested the test,then she said this after the test “I’m so happy that I’m the real pinkie,I missed you girls” and that means she was anxious of not being the real pinkie pie,and also that specific one that said that she doesn’t know herself who the real pinkie pie
And if the sad pinkie pie is the real pinkie pie
It means that the one who won the testy is the real pinkie pie


Broo why do ur theories always make sense


2:18 Celestia No! I can't... XDDD
I am literally choking on laughter! XDDDD
This video so gets a like! XDDD
I literally needed to pause the video to get my breath back XD

2:18 Celestia No! I can't... XDDD
I am literally choking on laughter! XDDDD
This video _so_ gets a like! XDDD
I literally needed to pause the video to get my breath back XD


I think it’s just the writrers of the story who took wrong


F for the og pinkie<br>And the other clones

F for the og pinkie
And the other clones


Being back the mirror pool for G5. Sprout wants to be charge again but he can't get in with anybody. So he makes clones but they all want to be in charge. He can't even got on with himself.


This was my theory tooooo, it literally scare me right now that people have the same theoryyyy


one last quetion where did your clone lived


If Twilight sparkle found out pinkie was a clone she would go nuts


Still Noone is talking about the gen 5 cutie marks being only on one side while blank on the other side.


What if sunburst heard the story from the clone we see of pinky in the restaurant in manehatten


why would the elemants of harmony work if pinkie was not real ?


EXPLAIN THE SUN AND MOON CYCLE IN MY LITTLE PONY NEW GENERATION


“…and you’re both British” <b>gasp</b> why are brits villains I am✨🇬🇧insulted🇬🇧✨

“…and you’re both British” *gasp* why are brits villains I am✨🇬🇧insulted🇬🇧✨


your clones are part of g5 and im proud...


I’ve thought about this many, manyyyy times


i don't believe your clone

edit:
me: sees title*
also me: nope, not at all


Maybe the real pinkie did die but maybe the real pinkie's soul went to the clone pinkie's body


Why not mention twighlight Controlling discord to bring her down a Bigger peg


Get the veritaserum out and ask pinkie, after she drank it. Easy as that


I don't think that Pinkie was a clone.
There are many major sci fi universes that have something to do with cloning and also some real world examples.
Most if all says the same:
Clones have a shorter living time as normal grown up people because of some kind of "gen Defect" or something else.
Depending on how fast they grown up in the tubes, this can be a time betrween one and 10 years in which their bodys mature and / or  get older pretty fast. in some cases, they lived only for a few hours to days, because their bodies consumed them self.
And often are clones sterile.

Pinkie cloned herself in a mere Second, her livetime would be very very short, even if this is a magical clone.
Her Body would "Burn" that magic that created her in only a few days... maybe a little longer with all that magic around her.
But before she would get all kinds of Health Problems, including Cancer.

But the result would be the same: A Graveyard full with dead pinkies or they would pop and begone in a little magical explosion..

For the real Pinkie speaks, that she is still alive 20 years later and have a healthy daughter.
Because even IF clones could reproduce, their Childs often have health problems because of one or both parents were clones.

But, this is a TV show for kids, so the background of cloning was pretty simplified without all the dangers and other problems in it.
(And the Pinkie Army became a well known meme :D )

But I must agree that the Methode of Twilight was a little drastic... even if other Methodes were not less drastic but needed more time.
Like asking each Pinkie about her Past, the names of her Family members and so on and THAN zap them to oblivion or go back to the hidden lake, change it's magic so it would take all clones back and only let the real pinkie back out... but than, what if ALL pinkie, including the original were erased?

So much from me to that theme.
Have Fun in the Future... and please tell us what you finds when you get back to the old place, were Sweet apple Acres, Ponyville and old Canterlot should be. ^^

p.s.: We know that at least one clone escaped twilights Pinkie Geno. (Youtube not like this word.)
Look at the Episode were Rarity opens up a fashion Store in Manehattan and the part with the Inverviews. ^^

@【 ▶ ! ! • 𝑨𝑴𝑩𝑬𝑹 • ! !◀ 】 don't worry, no offends taken. ;-)<br>Am not a Scientist or so, only someone that consumed allot of Media to this Theme. ^^

@【 ▶ ! ! • 𝑨𝑴𝑩𝑬𝑹 • ! !◀ 】 don't worry, no offends taken. ;-)
Am not a Scientist or so, only someone that consumed allot of Media to this Theme. ^^

@ThePink SpacePone Sry I wasn't trying to be rude lol. And it's cool that u like sci-fi! I do too.

【 ▶ ! ! • 𝑨𝑴𝑩𝑬𝑹 • ! !◀ 】

@【 ▶ ! ! • 𝑨𝑴𝑩𝑬𝑹 • ! !◀ 】 uhm... I have 40 years on my shoulders and am at least 34 of them a sci fi and fantasy fan... so I readed, watched and heared alot. ^^<br>Also I watch alot of Documentations to several Themes and cloning was one of them. ^^

@【 ▶ ! ! • 𝑨𝑴𝑩𝑬𝑹 • ! !◀ 】 uhm... I have 40 years on my shoulders and am at least 34 of them a sci fi and fantasy fan... so I readed, watched and heared alot. ^^
Also I watch alot of Documentations to several Themes and cloning was one of them. ^^

【 ▶ ! ! • 𝑨𝑴𝑩𝑬𝑹 • ! !◀ 】


[!]G5 Spoiler[!]
(I am gonna mark this as G5 spoiler just to be sure)

Grogar's bell is in Sunny's lighthouse. Is there gonna be a video on it?


Still waiting for that sunny is the princess of Reunity theory-
..
Oh heck I have nothing else to do, (my animations be like: 👁👄👁)
Might as well pull a theory video for my channel


Ayo if that's the truth then why are there other clones of Pinkie Pie


Maybe the Mean three turn everyone in stone because revenge


Maybe twilight accedently kicked pinkie pie to death


if your next video is about G5  looking in future our main question should not be where is twilight or other princesses are it should be where is twilights castle her school or the the students treehouse I thought it was kept for safe keeping  for all the things they have done and where is cloudsale  canterlot  castle or the crystal empire and I do not think twilight created the crystals twilight is known as even older than thousand year almost fictional so there might have been at least three to four rulers after her. it is possible that twilight school might have got destroyed but her castle and treehouse can not it has came from the tree of  harmony ! and where the heck is everfree forest


I really want to see what the pinkie says


AAaaaaahhhh!!! I missed the upload! I used a bucking timezone converter and set myself an external alarm clock for the upload only to find out I somehow still got it wrong by 1 hour! Why?!<br>(lol)

AAaaaaahhhh!!! I missed the upload! I used a bucking timezone converter and set myself an external alarm clock for the upload only to find out I somehow still got it wrong by 1 hour! Why?!
(lol)


I know it if sine Was taking the channel it was going to be a video about clones


But how can pinkie know who is maud and care about so much


Are you now just gonna make Theorys out of yourself?


Let’s not go on a tangent here

MATH JOKE MATH JOKE MATH JOKE


If pinkie is dead and the current one is a clone explain how pinkie was able to even know her older sister maud pie and arrange a visit to exchange rock candy the clone would have to know maud already an  have memories of them as kids if I remember correctly she even draw a picture of her and maud as fillies exchanging rock candy she know all her sister names by heart in the episode when her family is introduced and has a memory of her being a few seconds older then marble pie and it complete bullshit to say that the clone over time she got pinkie pie memories unless when the original dies all the memories of the host go to the surviving clone but come on that make way to much sense to be true right, Right


But how 🤔  can the  Clone now every  bodys name? And im not saying  im right but how would  she have  her element would the tree of  Harmony now thats not the real  Pinky pie? and she only  told the Clones her friends like apple jack  and her name  and twilight sparkles name  and   Raritys name   Flutter shy  Rainbow dash.so how would  she kill the real  Pinky pie?


Wait wait what about hat clone pinkie theory where there was another pinkie pie what if that one was the real one


Can confirm sitting still with adhd is suck


and sign you are wrong because you didn't remember any of sawtooth memory hahahahahaahah the truth is reaveled


OMG my childhood is ruined even worse I AM A cHILD:C😩


lets not go on a tangent here HAHAHA HELP


wrong wrong wrong amd why well i have a quetion for only sawtooth waves only why did you say no more purple pony princess i think the real pinkie survived because of your clone sawtooth you are wrong wrong wrong


whats with the sound wave and the heart beat wave


Um guys do you see sawtooth's pfp and channel banner...


His twin is taking over look at his profile


Wait really what happend 5o the mirror pool? Or crystal empire? Or flurry heart she become an princess after all we saw it?


hi what if the pool pinkie was in to fun as she loves parties and does not like getting board


Me : its sad if you think about it..-

But as he said :
"We must celebrate the clone that lives"

[Because she holds the memories of the element of laughter aka the original Pinkie pie]


How did sunset shimmer know to split up Fluttershy, Rainbow Dash, Applejack, Rarity and pinkie pie


I mean if ya think back to equestrian girls there's those small little shorts?  And one shows pony pinky highfiving human pinky and switching places so human gose to pony world and pony gose to human


My thoughts are NO
My brain hurts
no offense


7:04 TWILIGHT IS NOT A PRINCESS!!!! 🤬🤬🤬🤬

7:04 *TWILIGHT IS NOT A PRINCESS!!!! 🤬🤬🤬🤬*

You be like: oh a single skipped frame let's comment....
The comment: WHAT THE CUSS 🤬🤬A SKIPPED FRAME YOU IDIOTIC- 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

You be like: oh a single skipped frame let's comment....
The comment: *WHAT THE CUSS 🤬🤬A SKIPPED FRAME YOU IDIOTIC- 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬*


ミ♫ 𝙑 𝙚 𝙣 𝙩 𝙞 !
彡


It would be funny and disturbing if the statues are both of them

Or at least could be a rumor spread that the statues are both changelings Frozen in time kind of like that Walt Disney Theory


I'm not convinced. I think the test Twilight gave them was specifically made so that only the real Pinkie Pie would be able to pass. Pinkie Pie loves fun and parties and all things happy, but there's something she loves more than that. Her friends and family. She'd do anything for either, and it's safe to assume a clone wouldn't, at least not for long. Pinkie was always willing to go to great lengths for her friends, and it wouldn't be a stretch to say that she'd even watch paint dry on a wall for days at a time if it meant she would get to be with her friends.

Also it was established in season 8 that the elements of Harmony wouldn't work for clones, be it created from wood pictures and hair like Chrysalis made or the mirror pool. In fact, the tree of Harmony destroyed the clones of the mane six that attempted to take them, the same would likely have happened if the "clone" Pinkie tried to use hers with Twilight and the others.


Im think this posibole bat not confirmed


Can you make a video about cute mark diarndo do

سيرين  ابو داود


I need answers where is all the othere  creatures where did they all go we do see eny of them what happened to the otheres


Your dedication to your own continuity never ceases to amaze me


Nice video! But i think the MLP creators meant that the real Pinkie survived. They accidentally made a mistake while doing the animation of the mirror pool.


yes twilights way of testing them was barbaric but all Sawtooth's points make more scenes.


Ok, so for me, I think he's a lil off the mark. I'm thinking that indeed a fee clones did survive, but they didn't replace the true Pinkie they just went on to become unique like all those clones we saw stray in the show?


personally this could just be mouth to mouth storytelling inaccuracies manifesting over time


I feel like they're now rewatching every mlp episode while reading the script for the next season


Sawtooth makes me question everything I’ve ever watched on mlp. But not in a bad way lol. ❤


But we know the real pinky was the last one to go to that room and if u see closly she is the one who won. And also if the one that survived was a clone she wouldn't have said at the end that she couldn't loose her friends bc she wouldn't have known abt them or the memories they had together


wait, how do we know <b>pinkie</b> told the story? it is a legend

wait, how do we know *pinkie* told the story? it is a legend


I have another theory. The real Pinky survived but also, one clone. And that clone told sunburst her point of view. We never see who told sunburst and we know at least one clone survived.


Too late, since she is the queen, she can erase all evidence of what happen there, also Pinky itself being a clone, to save his own life she actually helps Twilight to cover the story, plus there is others clones who manage to escape (Like the one in Saddle Row & Rec Episode), and start to investigate this case could put in danger these clones again.


I live in basically in the other side of the world so i always watch these theory’s at night that keep me up sometimes I even delayed it till morning.


THATS EXACTLY WHAT I THOUGHT I THOUGHT TWILIGHT SPARKLE ACTULY KILLED HER FOR SOME REASON


do you know the differnce between a perfect clone and the original... nothing... they are the same person until theyre acumulated experiances diverge significantly, they are identical, in looks, memory, and thought patterns, saying one is any less than the other would be like saying one hemosphear of your brain is less you than the other, its an idea based in the ego that individualisim has people wrapped up in, which is fine, be proud of yourself, but dont be diluded.


The original will have the original traits, so by that logic the first one might be the real pinkie


I wouldn’t be surprised if he was Albert Einstein-


i think the original pinkie survived since the all of the clones have upside down cutie marks


Wait but if the pinkie remaining was a clone, that would she age? I think not. Maybe twilight didn’t kill the real pinkie!


7:04
I mean, isn't she already dead? or is it just from the generation 5(or is it 6?)?


No if you remember one clone did survive and made a name for herself the clone was original shown behind her at the other table


Cristal made clones of the mane six and they couldn't use the elements of harmony so that means only the original pinkie pie can use the element of lafter


I haven’t watched it yet, but I know it’s gonna be so great!


I was LITERALLY about to post this theory on twitter last week!!!


I thought that rainbow dash put the real pinkie in the back of the room. The last clone to be banishied was closer to the middle.


It has finally come, to know the real truth behind the mirror pool and pinkie, I ha e been waiting for this for my entire life.


it dont think they would put something this dark in a kids show


This title looks like a theory MatPat would come up with


Love this theory sawtooth and great British accent


If this happened than I know how to fix (my theory)
Use terack he always suck magic
Than if he trys to suck those pony's all clones turned into magic and get sucked to terack and real pinkie will survive


Why are they planing twilights execution.


british accent
I love not having a clear British accent being British.
Also can’t tell which part of Britain the second clone is from, though going to guess scotland since I can made their accent if I try hard enough.

*british accent*
I love not having a clear British accent being British.
Also can’t tell which part of Britain the second clone is from, though going to guess scotland since I can made their accent if I try hard enough.


Twilight killed the Real Pinkie? Mabye not, did the Apples miss at least one or two clones? Definitely.


Woh seriously that actually makes sense I never realized the pinkie never dove in??!!


YESSSS I KNEW IT! PINKY PIE IS DEAD! Oh wait yeah pinky is dead :(


Maybe he's right I mean I watch little pony like a 1k, time and to say he is kinda right let me check again but  it must be true Or not


I have a question how do you change things change into other PONYS


hey there were two pinkie Clones left after twilight's massacre. What if the other one is the real pinkie in hiding lol.


Plot Twist: The Pinkie Pie in Saddle Row Review is the actual Pinkie.


this is so unrelated but i love your voice


I was literally just watching the episode 😭


No no I refuse to believe that the original pinkie pie is dead


The clones have rights to live sure they look like us they don't have the memory of us butter living being just like you and me sure it's like play God to made the clones but they all have rights to live just like the game Detroit become human

hmm.. im only familiar with the game "Detrot: Become Pony"


7:34 well that's too bad becouse this clone of your's makes great chats


Sawtooh u used In the hall of the mountain king as the background music<br>BTW you should be a Voice actor , your voice is very cool!

Sawtooh u used In the hall of the mountain king as the background music
BTW you should be a Voice actor , your voice is very cool!


I don’t think pinkie  was a clone because she didn’t ask about her husband cheese sandwich the real pinkie never say anything about cheese sandwich so how does that pinkie know plus cheese sandwich never even question it so even if he knew how come that pinkie he didn’t ask him his name then to sandwich would’ve been a little suspicious


Well she doesn't have to problem this now cuz she is now a princess and ded in heaven cuz g5 is out 😶


The real Pinkie wouldn't go back to the pool as the others. Simple.


What if the Real Pinkie was the dopple ganger one from the Opening of Rarity's Shop at Manehatten?😬

And maybe that explains why the dopple ganger is wearing a detective hat. It was the real Pinkie examining the clone Pinkie.<br>╰(＾3＾)╯

And maybe that explains why the dopple ganger is wearing a detective hat. It was the real Pinkie examining the clone Pinkie.
╰(＾3＾)╯

From season 5 i think, the part where Rarity is stressed at renovating the shop and there's a disco that Pinkie deals with on the upper floor


Oh really then so if the Pinkie pie that is with the main six is a clone then can clones have babies because at the end of my little pony pinkie pie is a mother so can clones have babies


Am I the only one who forgot that most of this video is in the past?


Im sooo confuse why do you want to take down twilight what did she do wrong to deserve this ? And also can you do another equestria girls video if you can of coures


That makes so much sense and dosen't at THE SAME TIME


Is this why your profile picture is your clone?


you are really reaching with these old theories


The title wanted me to press it so I did


Its a deep theory but you could be on to some thing


Yasss time to ruin my childhood let's goooooo!!


4:39

Wait. Isn’t there still other clones alive in the real world anyway?
That one episode where the mane 6 are getting interviewed kinda proves that. doesn’t it?
That means they didn’t get them all anyway so I don’t think this point is valid.

I don’t think the show would kill off Pinkie Pie anyway. If it was a clone then maybe (Even then I’m pretty sure they were just sent back and not killed). But the show has never gotten as dark as murder became a subject.

This is an interesting topic to think about though. Keep up the good work dude 😊👍🏻


Can we get a vid of is human twilight an alicorn


No just no. Pinkie pie would do anything to be with friends


I think shin is still alive becuase he desided to change your profile pic and do some posts


Is this why your YouTube pic had a pic of your clone instead


Poor little Cheesie(Fake Pinkie’s kid), but she had to know of the sad truth of her mother actually being an imposter(pun unintended).. Oh yeah, Twilight’s getting cancelled on Twitter. I’m glad to hear Sine and his assistant continued with their own lives. Speaking of Sine’s assistant, how do you spell his name?


just becuse your Sawtooth's clone it does not mean you own this channel


Hi, I love listening to ur pony theory's. Please pin me its my birthday and itll be a dream come true to get pinned my my favorite youtuber


British Empire has colnised Equestria....

the sunset never shimmers on the british empire


Soooo thats how sine was here that was from the past
Oooooooooohhhhhhh
NOW I get it


Why didn't you make videos for last 2 weeks


I am 10 yrs <br>I was waiting for ur video


Theo animz ⚡テオ・アニムズ🔥


@Sawtooth Waves 5 months later and you notice the comment after I've posted it on Twitter lol XD


Have you accepted Jesus Christ into your heart as Lord and Savior? He died for our sins and rose from the dead on the third day. If you accept Jesus into your heart, He will wash you clean from all sin and impurity. You don't have to say anything in particular or be anywhere special; just ask For Jesus and for His forgiveness😁 It's that simple.


Hey what are you saying I have ADHD and ODD


Plz tell sawtooth ways then what happend to spike plz plz tell plz plz z plz plz


Sawtooth love your videos and yors Sine. Hahahaha ha ummmm....🤨


No no rainbow dash put  pinkie pie same place pinkie pie sevieved


can i pls get a shout out the next video


You are plain evil you just want twilight to be gone the creator would never do such a thing


All they were doing was just having fun.

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 hell no it wasn't it was kinda shit lol just my opinion. I think g5 will be better than PONY LIFE

@Breathing Is Pog  pony life was pretty cool.

But now we new friends in a new generation g5.

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 lol don't be so dramatic now. It was hella fun while it lasted

@Breathing Is Pog bit we don't have to worry about the mean 3 anymore.


But the pinkie clone wouldn’t have the memories of her friends or else the og pinkie wouldn’t have to teach the pinkie clones names to them


No<br>🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄


Nope. Hate this theory lol. I don't want to and won't belive it. I do support nearly all your other theories, they're just amazing!!!


I am one of the first comments to me the first comment is somewhere around 100 and I will come by for 100


No the pinkie who survived was the real pinkie because the clones would just be like fun fun fun!


{ • I N N E X / E X I N N creepypasta • }


Kiara  Moses TikTok videos  singer dancer actress


محمد الفغم١١٥٦٧٧٧١٠


⁽⁽ଘ( ˊᵕˋ )ଓ⁾⁾


As much as I hate Twilight, I have to say no because, all the Pinkie's looked the same, so it was an accident.


If that was the real clone of Pinkie Pie then she wouldn't be able to use Elements of Harmony and certainly gummy would know her little alligator