0:48 That is an interesting detail to point out and not one I've really heard before, I believe. However, I don't take too much stock in this. It's been shown time and time again that episode writers didn't always do their research on previous episodes to understand how something worked or happened. I feel that brief conversation between Sunburst and Starlight is a result of exactly this.


It was the original Pinkie Pie that survived because while we may not have the information for how the mirror ponds magic works I doubt that if a Pinkie Pie clone survived and the original Pinkie Pie was killed the element of laughter would ever be able to be used again and thus Discord would not have come back in the tail end of the next season rather he would have stayed a statue until a thousand years after season 2


Pinkie Pie is full of mystery, and always will be.


I don't think the real pinkie was killed because the clones don't have memories but there is a pinkie clone running around manehatten I guess she could have told sunburst about the mirror pond. I doubt it though I think sunburst just misspoke.


Twilight is only cast the dispel magic. So, if the real Pinkie is strucked it just make real her feel hurts instead of being banished to mirror pool.


2:26
"and you're both Britsh" - Sawtooth waves 2021 lmao

@Whimsical *previously Cloveriie* thanks :)

It’s “you’re”

just so you know next time. 😊


Good video if your running out of ideas I got one that was on my mind for days, so we know Celestia and Luna rose the sun and moon, then Twilight rose the sun and moon, but who or what is raising the sun and moon in modern times before Sunny became an alicorn???


Have you ever realized that Sunny’s wings are the same as Sunset’s?


then again why can there be both?
I know it was a joke but wasn't there another survivor of the clone massacre?
Maybe that one is the real pinky while the clone is now in the original's place?

Its just a random idea.
Hardly any evidence.


This is my theory, if you watched the end of the episode, rainbow dash says “someponies selling balloon ponies!” Maybe she hated real pinkie so real pinkie would die. in the  episode where we first see gilda, rainbow stays with gilda for half of the episode or maybe in the pie episode pinkie thought rainbow dash hated her pies, and in reality, she did hate her pies. This theory isnt the best, but i hope you agree.


Sawtooth Waves talking with Signs Holmes and Co-Signs Watson was an amazing experience.


Gotta love a sawtooth waves video! except this made my brain hurt 😂😂


To be fair tho, I don't think if the real Pinkie Pie got hit with unicorn magic, that she would just blow up like a balloon. It would have been far more gruesome if she got hit. We've seen what it looks like when a pony is hit by unicorn magic. They often get thrown back with some smoke coming off them as if burned. We've also seen the extent of Twilight's simple beam magic in her fight with Starlight. So either one of two options would have happened. 1. Pinkie gets a hole lazered into her and flops on the ground dead or 2. She gets knocked back 10-20 ft mildly burn (and those kind of attacks aren't usually fatal) so she would have survived that option.


Or this is what story wrriters remembered about Pinkie's clones and they have not done an extra check.


he was right and your "she had to teach the clones her friends names" is wrong she did not say "this is rarity now you guys" she only got a drawing and they had to say their names she was only triyng to see if they knew her friends names and they knew


all clones except those who were made last also made clones. So almost all of the clones knew how the lake works. And the youngest ones knew that they were clones because when they came out of the lake, they saw much bigger group of ponies than their own. And if a clone could remember everything that original Pinkie knew, the clone would also remember the right way of making clones (with no diving in the lake).
But what is important, that clones were something like simple reflections and couldn't reflect deep (not obvious, hidden) peronality. That's why the test helped Twilight to find the real Pinkie whose personality is much deeper than just having fun.
So, no conspiracy theories are needed here. "Dove in" might be metaphorical or just a little mistake.


And maybe she could be thorax's adviser because he could stand to learn a lot from her.


How come no one is talking about the episode with Rarity where the whole concept is the main 6 getting interviewed on her shop in Manehattan and during Pinkie's, one of her clones are sitting behind her? Like.... was that just no longer important or?-


I think the pool is more of a limbo that magical ponies stay in until released with magic.


honestly, I was always sus even as a little kid without any critical thinking skills


i love how you fully take advantage of being a changeling 😂 just like "my clone is british, and you can't accuse me of not making sense cause they're a changeling they can have whatever accent they want"


Not convinced<br>Really the real's determination let her survive

Not convinced
Really the real's determination let her survive


I don't think a hippogriff is so great without a griffin.


Sawtooth I feel like you should make an episode about like at the end of my little pony generation four there were all sorts of different creatures not just ponies like yaks and griffins Puts at the beginning of generation five they were just ponies


Another option is Sunburst and Starlight could have talked to a clone pinke that twilight missed(considering that there have been sightings) and mistaken her for the real Pinkie  and goten the  her side of the story instead of the real pinkie.


I think pinkie lied about how the cloning works so that nopony else would clone themselves.


I haven’t watched that much of your videos yet since it’s only a couple days since I’ve seen it I love how do you have a clone


"lets not go on a tangent here prime" got me rollin


Ummm, the real pinkie was still alive, have you not seen one of the episodes with a clone of Pinkie.


Okay but what about the tree of harmony? Wouldn't it notice that the real Pinkie is gone??


iv'e seen the dark comentery before basically a pinkie clone was dressed as twilight and she had help by some pony to cast the spell while the real pinkie is banging and trying to yell and crying in the mirror pool.


I have a question, in the movie where are all the non ponies? Also they could have got the information from one of the few surviving pinkie clones like the one in mane haton


The Pinkie cave have all the history a clone would need to know would help support this theory,


See when you started using the community tab to talk and meme about this episode, I knew it was only a matter of time before we got a theory on it. I'm so ready for this.


THEORY alert! Sawtooths 'clone' has an upside-down cutie mark! Clones are supposed to be EXACTLY the same as their host, sawtooths clone could not BE a clone, I believe that this was another changling trying to take advantage of sawtooth.., but what was his plan???


Another possible idea is that one pinkie didn’t go to watch the paint dry and the original actually survived and that pinkie we see in saddle row during pinkies interview is the clone that didn’t go to watch the paint wall dry


actually pinkie values friendship for than fun its kind of like with her sister and how she would do anything for her pinkie could focus


That is an interesting Theory however there are still a couple clones of Pinky pie around so for all we know a clone of Pinkie Pie did tell how she came to be and I original pinky is still alive and just didn't say how the Clones were born


I think the original won the test, because when it comes to her friends, she will do anything for them


How would the elements of harmony work if Pinkie was a clone?


He wasn’t right. Yes, Pinkie would get distracted, but she also is shown to be able to focus when things are serious. May get distracted during talk, but when it came to taking action? (Or non-action). She didn’t want to lose her friends or die.


I love the fact that this has frickin lore


If the new generation still use cones Sawtooth could make them come back if they want by saying that the statue was them


Hi didn't know what video to put this under so I'll just put it here. I figured this out from some of your videos and also from just knowledge. Twilight's cutie mark has the symbol of magic on it. It also has 5 smaller white stars around it symbolising her friends. So I think Twilight's destiny is the magic of friends. Then she becomes the Princess of friendship. In your videos you indicate this but you never say it. Twilight's cutie mark as a whole is always seen as magic but that isn't true. Even in the show they say here cutie mark is magic (boast busters I think). Just thought I should say my thoughts.


I’ll miss your clones! 😔I hope they come back


Cosign literally cracks me up 🤣<br>They are hilarious lol

Cosign literally cracks me up 🤣
They are hilarious lol

🖤𝙺𝟷𝚈𝟶𝙼𝟷_𝚂𝚃𝙰𝚁🖤


Me: I don't get it
Me, the m o m e n t when I get where this theory is stemmed from: chills

Me: I don't get it
Me, the m o m e n t when I get where this theory is stemmed from: *chills*


Something else to add to sine waves theory is that the clones are FULLY SENTIENT


This entire theory hinges on one line from a non reliable source


i noticed something

so mlp

it's said that the main six got their cutie marks at the same time
but actually it wasn't at the same time but the same day (except pinkie pie)
rainbow got hers after the rainboom
twilight got it right after that after spike's egg hatched
apple jack said that the rainboom pointed her home but a train ride goes a few hours and she got hers as soon as she got to the barn
rarity got hers in the evening at a little costume dance thing
of course fluttershy's animals were scared right as the rainboom struck and only then when the animals all trusted her and hugged her she got her cutie mark
pinkie made a little party the day after the rainboom (it showed the sun set and the sunrise there, so in the morning)
the only true ponies who got their cutie marks at the same time were the cutie mark crucaders
and their cutie marks look rllllyy similar because of that


What about that clone of Pinkie we see during the episode where they all get interviewed about Rarity's new boutique opening? Could that have been the original that fled after suggesting the paint dry test? Or a stray clone?

@NITESH KUMAR biokos ather pinkie stol her pleice

If she was the real pinkie why didn't she return to her friends


Wouldn’t the elements of harmony stop working? And the clones had to learn the names of other ponies, Pinkie showed no struggle doing that. Sorry, but this is a flawed theory.


but if she did kill the real pinkie, wouldn't the other clones disappear too? it's vampire rules.


Sawtooth! I just found out a mistery about mlp generation 5! <br>You know how the three ponykinds went separte ways and showed hatred filled with lies about eachother...like in mlp generation 4...the fourth and rare ponykind was not in the fifth...THERE WAS NO ALICORNS! EVEN THE RULERS OF THE CITIES WERE THERE OWN PONY KINDS! I KNOW ITS SHOCKING NEWS! But one thoery tho...in mlp generation 4 the three ponykinds lived happily and together  but in the 5th generation they went separate ways so the possibility for the three ponykinds to have theyre own rulers is possible and thats what happened in the movie but could there be chances that after they lived peacefully after theyre next ruler would be an alicorn? Idk this is just i theory about this strange thing with these two generations but ill leave all the thinking up to you ;)

Sawtooth! I just found out a mistery about mlp generation 5!
You know how the three ponykinds went separte ways and showed hatred filled with lies about eachother...like in mlp generation 4...the fourth and rare ponykind was not in the fifth...THERE WAS NO ALICORNS! EVEN THE RULERS OF THE CITIES WERE THERE OWN PONY KINDS! I KNOW ITS SHOCKING NEWS! But one thoery tho...in mlp generation 4 the three ponykinds lived happily and together  but in the 5th generation they went separate ways so the possibility for the three ponykinds to have theyre own rulers is possible and thats what happened in the movie but could there be chances that after they lived peacefully after theyre next ruler would be an alicorn? Idk this is just i theory about this strange thing with these two generations but ill leave all the thinking up to you ;)


0:13 I just realized that the music note in the beginning is upside-down because sign's cutie mark is an upside-down music note


1 minute ago...

My brain hurts after I watched this.

Why, just, Why.

I like your purple bow :D


A pinkie clone could’ve gotten memories when twilight in the ep where twilight became a princess when she gave the memory’s back


I just got an idea. I don't know if it's corect. So, there's G5 and we know about G3, right? Well, then what if the g4 wasn't trained well enough and that's how everything fell apart, until, maybe many moons later, G5 appeared and then the history repeats(new elements, new tree, new harmony etc). What do you think?


Rip Sign and Cosign you will forever be missed.


Well I really think that it is a clone because you can clearly see before the test that she is sad and when you pan back to the test one of the pinkies we're sad and a clone forced her to look at her hooves with it taking the real pinkie


Wait a minute no sawtooth is right other guy that looks like him not so much pinky did not die at the end she said I couldn’t I just couldn’t leave my friends that proves that’s the real pinky 😑😊🤣

Also, you already made a video about a pinkie clone that survive. She could tell to sunburst who it happen.


I also have a theory how is the spirit of harmony created <br>The pillars didnt create them friendship did, Look how the spirit of harmony is still alive without the elements after all the spirit is connected to the tree the tree is connected to the elements and the elements is connected to the mane six and the mane six is connected to friendshipp(well their friendship connects each of them together), Something comes to my mind that i think friendship or the pillar didn't create the spirit , I think it just existed on itself as long as theres light or good the spirit will exist. I hope u notice this.......

I also have a theory how is the spirit of harmony created
The pillars didnt create them friendship did, Look how the spirit of harmony is still alive without the elements after all the spirit is connected to the tree the tree is connected to the elements and the elements is connected to the mane six and the mane six is connected to friendshipp(well their friendship connects each of them together), Something comes to my mind that i think friendship or the pillar didn't create the spirit , I think it just existed on itself as long as theres light or good the spirit will exist. I hope u notice this.......


Ok but Pinkie also knew of the lake, so maybe just Starbust saw a book on it and just stated it as he had read it?


The original copy was a lot closer to Pinkie than the copies of copies.  I could see the original pinkie clone being all mopey because of what happened when the clones were unleashed.  I could also see the actual pinkie running off, potentially in part due to pinkie sense(If she KNEW by pinkie sense that she was going to be sent into the pool, she might run).  Personally I think what Twilight did was completely wrong, and there was also simply too much risk involved.


Aha, so Ultra Fast Pony was right! Sure in their version the original was a LOTR fan while the survivor was a minion of Darkness with no awareness of LOTR, making them easier to tell apart, plus they didn't much care whether they had the original or not because they're entertainingly horrible ponies, but still.


I love your videos sawtooth waves your theories are so interesting


The second pinkie in Manehattan could be the original hiding from a dangerous clone


In my fanfiction the first clone we see, changes her identity, gets a dragon girlfriend named after Rainbow Dash, and becomes a colossus in the colossus world while rainbow dish the dragon becomes a rainbow deity.


Pinkie's probably alive, given how she breaks the 4th wall so many times


Hi, I just want to say if this could be possible.. What if the Real Pinkie Pie escaped and survived, and was the one Which when the  clone was talking about the Mirror pool  in Saddle Row Review..  Maybe the real Pinkie was also the Neon pony in the dance club just trying to blend in and not go back to the mirror pool!! Well this MIGHT be an option, I don't  know but just giving you another possibility.


Reminds me of that old video showing the real pinkie trapped in the pool with all the other clones except for the one that survived. I love dark stories


hol up, you see your kind of counteracting your own theory, if the clone had all the memories she would have also remembered pulling the clone out


wait... why are you represented withsome kind of zigzag/curved line? while your clones are too but their's is slightly different... IS THIS SOME LORE? ON YOUR CHANNEL?


and the pinky clone wouldn't know they were a clone, they all thought they were the real one so she wouldn't think anything of it.


"Lets not go on a tangent here, Prime" - Sine, next to Cosine


If you had noticed that scene  where rainbow dash told twilight rainbow had found another pinkie drawing sad face with her hoof rainbow dropped the real pinkie in the hall full of clones  in the same place we see pinkie after the test. When there was 2 pinkie left the further back pinkie is the real pinkie who won . This is my thought


Holy goodness<br>A simple choice of words has changed my thought process

Holy goodness
A simple choice of words has changed my thought process


if the real pinkie had survived, the clones wouldn't have died, maybe they went to her dimensions?


I think you were right in the beginning of the video that the current pinky we have is the real one


Good idea to make all new Gen 4 theories flashbacks. Also I liked the Sine takeover for Nightmare Night season!


Ngl I thought the twist of that Pinkie Pie episode was gonna be the first Pinkie to get distracted would’ve been deemed the true Pinkie Pie just because of how her nature is.


Twilight could not have killed the original pinkie because pinkie loves her friends so much, and the challenge was not to talk for the pinkies.. and pinkie would want to stay with her friends.. the real pinkie would not talk no matter what distracted her... the clones would <br>proof is here

Twilight could not have killed the original pinkie because pinkie loves her friends so much, and the challenge was not to talk for the pinkies.. and pinkie would want to stay with her friends.. the real pinkie would not talk no matter what distracted her... the clones would
proof is here


I personally think it is the real Pinkie, and someone else, not a clone, but an outsider who perhaps snuck in, or had already heard the legend of the mirror pool, but didn’t actually know how it worked. If Pinkie does have ADHD, there is something you forgot. People with ADHD do get distracted easily, but there is also something called hyper focus, where they can be extremely focused on something that is interesting or important to them. For Pinkie, that may have been the paint, as it was important that she stayed with her friends. Please tell me if there’s anything I may have forgotten, or anything I got wrong or forgot to add about ADHD.


This is a very easy theory to make, and not an easy one to prove.

רוני בן עזרא


That's how the pool works.  It may also be able to be used for time travel.

So what he is saying is that Pinkie Pie has always been a clone?  Well, that would not actually be a problem because the clone would be the original...<br>This is obviously why the mirrior pool was closed and abandoned.

So what he is saying is that Pinkie Pie has always been a clone?  Well, that would not actually be a problem because the clone would be the original...
This is obviously why the mirrior pool was closed and abandoned.


Sorry to say not putting you down bud but in all hind sight the real pinkie was upset for her mistake and stayed still and followed orders to show she was the real pinkie. Not only that she also felt guilty that she couldn't fill in for her friends since she was all only but one. Usually when she gets upset she doesn't make and chance of getting distracted. As you can tell by some of the videos that showed how sad she was. These clones were part of her from her goofy personality. The real pinkie may have that yes but, she has more to it than the clones. The clones were mainly ones who got distracted and was obliterated and taken out when the real pinkie which I have high positivity on is still alive. I wasn't saying this about your theory being wrong which I still somewhat agree but since I observed and payed more close attention on how she was through the seasons up to the real pinkie test she is still around. Just saying and throwing this out there.


A pretty complicated possibility is If a pony jumped in the mirror pool nothing would happen they would soon become a reflection and one of the reflection of the pony would come out, Time  dose not do anything , The pinkie clones had to be taught to live that's why the two pinkies were fine living they had to disguise them self's to not get seen , They all had a laugh since that was pinkies most common felling.


Obsession. All the pinkie clones were Obsessed with fun, while the real Pinkie knew that this "Fun" was getting on peop-err, sorry, PONIES Nerves. And there are plenty of times after the incident where Pinkie stopped focusing on fun and started Focusing on what was ACTUALLY important, Like Rainbow dashes feelings. ("The Super Duper Party Pony" anyone?)


"let's not go on a tangent here" underrated joke


I'm sure that when sunburst and starlight was talking at the mirror pool it could've been a clones pov


"would u rather be called square waves? <b>pause.</b> or triangle w-" LMFOAOAOA I LOVE UR COMEDIC TIMING

"would u rather be called square waves? *pause.* or triangle w-" LMFOAOAOA I LOVE UR COMEDIC TIMING


*_But what about the 2nd Pinkie we see in the diner in "The Saddle Row Review"?_*


Sawtooth I know that sign is right because 1 Pinky always gets distracted 2 The clones having memories of pinkes live . See that’s all the evidence Twilight is guilty!


Signs Holmes: Twilight killed Pinkie!<br>Me: I refuse to believe that Pinkie was killed by Vegeta's Technique TM!

Signs Holmes: Twilight killed Pinkie!
Me: I refuse to believe that Pinkie was killed by Vegeta's Technique TM!


You forgot one thing if Twilight killed the real Pinkie then all of the clones would be gone


I think I may have a way on how the portal works you see pinkie dived into the pool making herself a clone so which means they're reflection is not their reflection its themselves who have the same thoughts as them same movements until they finally chose to dive in and meet themselves you know what that means inside the mirror pool there might be thousands of clones inside it including all of the ponies in equestria or is that just silly


Wait, so the real pinkie JUMPED in and came out with wiped memory that was passed onto the clone. Then she saw the clone and started being happy like the regular pinkie. So the pinkie that was sad was clearly the clone. Am I making sense or making nothing 😅? For example: Twilight DID kill the real pinkie and the clone was left with the memory of the real pinkie. Poor real pinkie.... Goodbye 😢.


In the episode with Rarity having a newspaper entry don't we see a Pinkie clone sitting at the booth behind Pinkie? Maybe the clone is who told Sunburst about the mirror pool and he thought she was the original when in fact the original was probably in the castle or the sweet shop or even off with the Mane 6 on some adventure or something. In other words, I think the original Pinkie DID survive, but so did a single clone who was never found by the Mane 6, therefore not present at the test. Remember how Apple Jack or Rainbowdash (forgot which one) said "I think that's all of them..."? Key word, THINK. Even they didn't know if all the clones were captured! Who's to say there isn't a Pinkie clone left?


That's what I was scared about all the time during this episod. Even after the end I felt like something got lost. Hopefully not, but it could realy be.


I don't think Twilight was killing them...just sending them back to the pool...I don't think the real Pinkie could have been sent back.

If Twilight could just kill them...she would be super OverPowered....just a poof and anyone would die.

Seems way too easy...


I think Sunny is related to Twilight? Btw awesome vid!
Here is some proof:
1. Sunny's dad necklace
2. The journal
3. Sunny becomes an alicorn just like Twilight!
I hope you use this!💗


He forgot that all the clones that were zapped returned to the pool instead of exploding


One doubt,<br>Imagine the mane 5 going through the mirror of eqg. You see, people say that in the future people will be like totally all robotic and everything will be only tech. Soooooooo, if they went through the mirror then what will they see the tech world or the normal world of chs. I would love it if u answer 🙂

One doubt,
Imagine the mane 5 going through the mirror of eqg. You see, people say that in the future people will be like totally all robotic and everything will be only tech. Soooooooo, if they went through the mirror then what will they see the tech world or the normal world of chs. I would love it if u answer 🙂


Feb 12 2021. The video posted that day was about a clone that escaped and survived. Say that clone ended up talking to Starlight or sunburst and they ask about the clone incident and say “I dived into the pool” that is how they’d think that the cloning happened that way with the original Pinkie still being alive


Except she didn't kill the Clone's she sent then back into the pool so technically that just means the original pinkie is trapped behind the pool. Alternate Universe?

Exactly that's where the pinkies might have been born from. returning them would totally not kill them it would just make them unalive


Hahaha you're living as a statue, this is funny as f*** I am tempted to binge watch all of your videos but I'm not going to can't wait to meet you. Looking forward to interviewing you.


I really hope the real pinkie isn’t dead. I actually don’t think she died because can Twilight kill a real/original pinkie…?

Hold up, what if she did because, when she blew up a pinkie that got distracted, her horn turned red!!! THAT WAS PROBABLY THE CAUSE OF HER KILLING PINKIE PRIME… orrrr it Twilight’s horn was red because of how much pinkies she blew up at the time. :l


OMG YOU MISSED SOMETHING THERE IS STILL ONE CLONE LEFT IN ONE OF THE EPISODES SEE IF YOU CAN FIND IT!!!!😏


Ok she is the real pinkie pie bc how could she use the element of harmony laughter other wise and I’m still not convinced that even if there was a clone in her place that clone has her memories and makes the same life choices as you can clearly see in the episode when pinkie made the clones that all of the clones are way wilder than her thus they would not be able to stand still or even walk normally reply if you disagree or agree thanks


"Let's not go on a tangent here prime"

That was genius

"Let's not go on a _tangent_ here prime"

That was genius


To be fair it is pinkie were talking about here she can easily forget some important facts so either story could necessarily be true yes you do have to go to the source to find the answer but sometimes not even the source has the answer your looking for I could have forgotten about when it happened or how it happened in my opinion ask Celestia for a look into pinkie pies time stream I know she can do it thought you are just an earth pony you can still do it alicorns are immortal right ask somepony about princess cadence and see if you can find her or something on the young six or discord in fact where was he during the time of a new generation


Wouldn't a reflection answer "theyd pulled me out of the pool" though?


And this is why season 1 was the most conspriacy-free season.


what if that didn't happend and the original pinkie pie survived :/


If Pinkie was a clone how can she connect to her element?😀


When the cloning army thing happened pinkie pie was rlly sad so she'd pay more attention to things and win the test and imagine after the cloning episode pinkie pie has to wear the element if the fake one wears it then whatever villian they were fighting the villian prob succeed his/her plan if the real pinkie pie wears the necklace then the villian would be defeated


Well, actually, it's like Pinky reborn, because when Twilight killed the other Pinkys, all of the memory come back to the last Pinky, I think. So, this Pinky is like the first. But I don't know, why Twilight didn't just ask, who went first to the lake, or who didn't get pull out the lake, but it's never mind now.


yep thats true i watch it along time ago and i still remmber it  the rest of the pinkies not gave the memory up as u can see the real pinkie put int the mirror pool and her memory was give a way cause the pink thing went up and the rest did not so yea she killed the real one :/


Sawtooth having a british accent is nightmare fuel.

@Serenity the Siren everyone has an accent though

@Sawtooth Waves I agree (despite the fact I'm British.)<br>I'm still sad I don't have an accent.

@Sawtooth Waves I agree (despite the fact I'm British.)
I'm still sad I don't have an accent.


The cloning happened the real ones pull the clones from the mirror pool


My theory: Soo i think that if twilight is not in G5 then what about her successor? We have come to believe that at the end of Mlp that luster dawn will be twilights successor but in my idea that is not the case i believe that twilights being herself will pick someone else who has been on the path of friendship the only problem with luster being twilights successor is that she should be around in G5  if she was twilights successor the whole history of G5 changes! i believe that twilight following your other theory 'What happened to twilight?' Since she trapped her magic.Equestria has been out of hand so twilight has no reason to look for a successor  of course there are ups and downs with this theory Like: What id twilight had found a successor before she did her sacrifice? Or What if twilight was still looking for a successor even after her magic was drained? I Simply don't know..But i'll keep researching and report back to you!


I don't think twilight was reasonable in pinkie's death because if you noticed twilight and everyone else could see that the original pinkie was sad because she felt like she was making her friends miserable from all of the clones so when twilight decided to do the test she knew that the original pinkie would be the only sad one so no matter what they tried the sad original pinkie would be the only one left.


We don’t actually now she could of literally killed the real one!


I'm wondering who Principal Cinch could be in the pony world.


and look at argyle's home. one of zecora facemasks are there. I think he went to the everfree forest to know about the Mane 6


This is a kids show and Hasbro wouldn't put children through the trauma of losing a beloved character Remember that


I have a question where was cadence and flurry heart when the pony separated they are immortal aren't they.


"let's not go on a tangent" how dare you make math funny


or is the original Pinkie hiding out? like in the episode where Rarity's friends get interviewed we see a 2nd Pinkie


The spell was a clone killing spell, if the real Pinkie did get distracted the spell wouldn’t work.


This might sound stupid but maybe if twilight asked every single pinkie the same question, she will eventually the one pinkie with a different answer, she could probably kill the ones who say the same thing but keep the odd ones


how would a clone know about celestia or that she's supossed to write her letters with freindship lessons.


Paint : Hello sine
Ink : WHY DO I HAVE A CLONE ASWELL NOW-
Pen : 2 clones~!
Ink : WHAT THE-
Acquarello: I exsist aswell XD
Ink : WHO MADE CLONES OF ME
Error : uh....

@IdaInnit
Error just going around “killing Ink” rampage

@IdaInnit
*Error just going around “killing Ink” rampage*

@UCub2lIsg7g8142qXf9haG3w <br>Boredom, couldn’t actually kill you so I made duplicates to kill

@UCub2lIsg7g8142qXf9haG3w
Boredom, couldn’t actually kill you so I made duplicates to kill

@IdaInnit <br>I accidentally opened the portal to another universe that was NOT made by you, and while you were sleeping I threw you in a magical water that can duplicate you.

@IdaInnit
I accidentally opened the portal to another universe that was NOT made by you, and while you were sleeping I threw you in a magical water that can duplicate you.

ERROR COULD YOU EXPLAIN FIRST?-

I hope this will wont have 72 responses-

Error : time to erase the mistakes <b>:)</b>


I didn't  know pinkie pie was a clone all this time


This is to complex for my head to wrap around but you may have a point but hopefully she didn’t


it would explain why pinky got magic back after it was taken then given back because the pool must be magic


my theory is that pinkie is not a clone its because the tree might feel that something is wrong with pinkie so then the tree sends a message to twighlight saying that pinkie is a clone so basically that didnt happen<br>the tree didnt say anything to twighlight about pinkie is a clone so yeh thats my theory

my theory is that pinkie is not a clone its because the tree might feel that something is wrong with pinkie so then the tree sends a message to twighlight saying that pinkie is a clone so basically that didnt happen
the tree didnt say anything to twighlight about pinkie is a clone so yeh thats my theory


Now we have 3 of him?<br>"This is getting out of hand, now there is 2 of them." is probably what the original thought

Now we have 3 of him?
"This is getting out of hand, now there is 2 of them." is probably what the original thought


I know how to get the real pinkie back…

Just don’t watch that episode


I think not because pinke was one of the main. 6 so if they did do that in the show it would have been more longer of how they had to get pinke back and Evan I’d she was gone that would mean that the clone aka the new pinke that u say would die at the pont that pinke diead


Memories do not spread into other people then they will remember when they were born which the real pinkie does not and she still does not


Me: Do you know that she said she was pulled out of the pool or were you just guessing?


YASSSSSSSSSSS
i had this theory the second i saw the episode when i was 12 XD
turns out its a common theory

the elements of harmony would not work since shes a clone and is not really friends with the others


yall remember in the episode where rarity opened her shop in manehattan and pinkie pie was interviewed and he talked abt he cloning and then behind her sat ANOTHER pinkie pie and looked back at her shocked


SIGN SIGN! If you look at one further episode I forgot which but there was another Pinkie alive. Some say it's a clone but if this theory is correct...maybe THAT is the REAL PINKIE PIE!


Sawtooth I have a question for you if princess Celestia has a nephew didn’t that mean Luna had to have a baby? And if so with who?


I think princess celestia would understand. Plus twilight didn’t kill them. She sent them back to the mirror pool.


I remember thinking this- now it’s confirmed…. Shit


I HAVE A THEORY!!!!: IN SAWTOOTH'S VIDEO: ' Who is "Kevin"?! ' he talked about hiding in plain sight, and then he talked about the ' Pinkie paradox '. BUT... WHAT IF.. KEVIN HAS BEEN PINKIE THIS WHOLE. TIME!!!

Hear me out, I know what you're thinking: " oh but pinkie was at the wedding that Kevin was spotted at!" - I don't really have an explanation for that... :| but I think the chances are HIGH that "Kevin" simply avoided the ' Pinkie paradox ' by COMPLETELY BECOMING IT!!!

Sawtooth also says: " Who knows how long ' Kevin ' has been hiding in Pony Ville." Yes, it's true that he could be the two that he theorised about.
but pinkie wasn't on the card called 'Blending In' with: 'Kevin' as the name at the top of the card. but anyways,

I think this makes sense, if only pinkie was on the card..  anyways  what do you think sawtooth? :D I hope you see this !!!

P.S: I still watch you from when your channel used to be called "The Brony Notion" !! love ur content and keep up the good work! <3


If the pinkie pie really was a clone then how did she age? Do the clones age? This doesn’t really make sense but at the same time it does


Yeah, I noticed this way before this episode came out. The Real pinkie is gone because the real one has a brighter tone of colours then the other clones. If you watch closely the last two pinkies were the real one and the fake one. The fake one didn't disappear, the real pinkie did


… Then How DID TWILIGHT FRICKING SPARKLE IS STILL IN THE MAIN STORY AFTER


Hi everyone 👋. I am Mayuri Chatterjee from India. I am an mlp fan. I have been watching this show since two years. I love it. I agree with you because, the pinkie we have might say 'yes' if we ask her "were you pulled out of water?". And that's going to spoil Twilight's reputation. The theories are relevant and have weight in them. Talking about the previous video, I want to say something. That is twilight may have sacrificed her life for making those gems. And that's quite sad well. I love you and your videos. Thank you


I swear pinkie got way too mature and understanding for well pinkie after too many pinkie pies


Oh god my My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic childhood is destroyed 🥺
dun dun dun

Oh god my My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic childhood is destroyed 🥺
*dun dun dun*


Hi everyone hope you're having an amazing day stay safe! :)


maybe, your clones did test out that pinkie is a clone and forced Twilight to commit suicide, or aging, and made the crystal


There is one plot hole because in another episode there was a scene of a pinkie clone.


Honestly, I was scrolling through my notifications and I saw the title to this video and I got so confused, but worried lmao


Not the REAL Pinkie. You once made a video about a 9th world or something the FORGOTTEN one. The REAL Pinkie is in THAT world.


Your clones British accent is just PERFECT💯

Edit : 10 hours and dis much likes


Twilight:look at da paint wall<br>Also twilight:I killed the real pinkie pie

Twilight:look at da paint wall
Also twilight:I killed the real pinkie pie


Me: just coming to see they evidence he has


ok, levando que essa teoria seja realmente verdade, se a memoria da pinkie antiga tivesse sido transportada para o clone, meio que o clone seria a pinkie original de qualquer forma. Pensa só, se tudo o que fez a pinkie ser a pinkie, tudo que ela viveu, todos os aprendizados as conquistas, TUDO, então o clone se tornaria a pinkie original, já que seria a mesma pinkie, tanto de mente quanto de corpo. Sei la brisei mto nessa teoria ai.


I think the real pinkie survived.
Reason- How can a clone give birth
                 LIL' CHEESE


I’m going to agree that marking Chemically imbalanced pony’s watch paint and not get distracted or else they DIE! Is cruel. It just brings flash backs of my abusive teacher. Or squid game. Either way killing a pony who gets distracted is EVIL! DOWN WITH TWILIGHT!!!

im pretty sure squid game was based off of this episode of mlp


If she was a clone how would she use the element


6:42-7:03 guess I’m not the only one who doesn’t like twilight. sliently claps

6:42-7:03 guess I’m not the only one who doesn’t like twilight. *sliently claps*


But later in one episode it shows there is still another pinkie in ponyville


Then why did pinkie said "I couldn't leave my friends I just couldn't" then..??? She is the real pinkie😒🙄


i think the original pinkie survived , cause she would do  anything for her friends


Damn, I can’t believe someone uploaded Us to YouTube


Wait what was that about being turned to stone? You alright Sawtooth?


Okay so how do you explain the fact that the tree and the elements of harmony knows which one is the real person and not like chrysalis clone but for this pinkie they stay the same like they would for the original pinky AKa she is the real pinky besides I know pinky gets distracted easily when discord was loose but she is a newbie saving the world and everything she doesn't like taking things seriously but she still does it and also why twilight make that test is because pinky might not like being serious but she'd do anything to stay with her friends and  like one of the comments said the other pinkies were more into "fun" then staying with her friends and that pinky was who survived was the only one who didn't terrorize the town cuz its her home town that's why she's so sad at that time the others lived stress free when they terrorize the town and she is the only one who is the odd one out of the others and also twilight spell wouldn't work on the real pinkie cuz that spell was only to send the clone back to the world they came from it would only work for the clones because it's their world and not the real pinkys world so one fact you can't say twilight killed the clones either cuz she just send them back to the world they're from I know you're gonna read this but look I'm not arguing with you I was just pointing out the 5 facts u didn't see and I would like for you to consider them in actualy a big fan of you it's just that I don't if u see ur self but when ever you say something about twilight your kind of blinded by the fact you think she's bad and you done see facts like these anymore so I'm pointing them out for u oh gosh I sound serious anyways I like all ur videos except the opposite of bias ones like these you have theories that I would never thought of anyways Pls read this again just pointing out some facts that's all


Ah yes…
Sawtooth waves and his sophisticated self…
Two heads are truly more chaotic then one…


I'm not sold. If it had come from pinkie's mouth, maybe, but secondhand information is as reliable or worse than speculation


Notice how phyllis cloverleaf calls sprout, "sugarcube". I think applejack and phyllis are related


Paint Dry Test: ok. i have something. so we all know this:
1. Rainbow dash came in before the test of paint dry started
2. Rainbow said she found another pinkie (that we know was the real one) drawing said face on the ground
3. Rainbow put the last pinkie found in the crowd
Perhaps if we look at the position the pinkie was put down on and the posititon that the last pinkie stayed in, we will know if she was the REAL pinkie..... i gave some thought to this , but i have a feeling (im not sure really not sure at all) that there is something that can rip apart this theory..........

(i meant to say put ur thoughts in the replies )


I think the real pinkie still lives because magic as far as we know cant be created or destroyed and going off of another Thierry that pinkie has discords magic it wont work even if the ma gh ic went to the last pinkie we would see a blob of pinkies magic floa floating to her like every other one of these scenarios


British Sawtooth Waves is best Sawtooth Waves. But seriously, sin und cosin are awesome!!


Wait are you saying that I could in fact be a clone? How can that be possible? If I know things my clones don't even know. My clones doesn't even know my family or my siblings. Nor my twin brother Octavio Pie. My clones barley even knows about my friends.


i got a question. why havent we seen teenagers ponies?(except princess cadence because when we saw her with small twilight she was already an alicorn )


yay<br>can we have your charcter analysis video again but g5 edition maybe start with villians or something idk

yay
can we have your charcter analysis video again but g5 edition maybe start with villians or something idk


He’s one fact they may have killed the little pinky because one of the Pinkys made the face of the very 1st my little pony where they don’t even look like the things we have the new generation and the generation you’re talking about


Her future can still look bring as sawtooth said.


I do believe twilight dose not deserve to be the princess of Equestria


Again presented us with a wonderful video sawtooth 😘😘😄😍


I wonder if that wasn’t the real pinkie wouldn’t her element of harmony not work, it can sense when the wrong people are using it so could it sence if this is a clone or not.


To bo honest i thought the same thing when i watched it. Maybe not so specificaly but i deffinitely had a feeling something wasn't right


What doesn't make sense with the story is you got turned to stone, but what about Dr. Wolfe? Mad Munchkin?


EvenTiwiltes words on the spell she cast to get rid of the clones. Warning you may kill your friend.


The whole pinkie being a by is very believable but, I just wonder, why? Why would the creators of the series do that? It just seems, a little off- idk maybe I’m wrong but yeah..


How about if your right what happened to the real pinkie pie? I think she was send to another dimension or now is staying with her clones.


That makes sense she never went into the pool


This comment is for the windigos theory on where are they in mlp new generation. I haven't watched all of it yet but another theory I'm dying to know is where are all the other creatures. Griffin's, hippogrifs. Also what the green sky was about at the start of the mlp generation movie when Rarity says the magic shall all be mine and when the red horse sprout goes evil.


I haven’t even watched it yet but <b>gasp</b>

I haven’t even watched it yet but *gasp*


Weren’t the clones sent back not killed?


I know people like making theories but guys…. That’s LITERALLY THE Pinkie Pie… why the hell would the show focus on the feelings and pov of some random ass Pinkie Pie and not the original since the episode was literally about Pinkie Pie and the mistake she made…


Maybe , if the real pinky did expire what if the real Pinky's soul went into the cone's body and now their souls are intertwined?


In season 8 ep 5 there is an guy who has wings and I horn I think they made a mistake with the characters


But come on the mane five used different ways to identify the real Pinkie Pie.


Oh, I've seen this theory floating around before! :D I click!


no hate but I sort of disagree wasn’t pinkie pie the one who suggested the test in the first place? Why would she request a test if she knew she could easily fail it?


You're right let's forgot about chrysalis tirek and cozy glow. For they are equestria's bitter past.


Except for that was clearly the real one.


I don't think a European dragon would be so welcoming toward a Asian yak.


and that the other pinkie you see is the real pinkie in her new party life style still keeping track her old life but enjoying her new life new friends etc


OH MY GOD SAWTOOTH HEARTED MY COMMENT
or was it Sine? ;)
I accept all of these theories as canon
And would you like to hear about my MLP OC?


Ok sawtwo this is to much you don't have enough evidence. Hasbro must have just made a mistake.


Wait, have you read the MLP Comics? Because I'm still reading it.


Sawtooth, I NEED your opinion. It is not Pinkie related but listen. Why didn't Terek steal Discord's magic when it was in the bell? Is the bell a little more special that meets the eye? As we see in FIM S4 E26- Twilight's Kingdom, he took Discord's magic after using him. Nothing happened. He could still use magic on Twilight. Even Cozy Glow herself said why not take it because their is Alicorn magic in there too. We all know Terek doesn't mind a little Alicorn magic. Has the bell somehow strengthened Discord's magic? Hmmmmmmm... Discord did say that they have the REAL GROGAR'S MAGIC TOO. So was his magic left in the bell?! Is this why he could take his magic from him but not from the bell without Chaos? Please make a video about this!! PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!


“Twillight killed the real Pinky!”
Me: appears IM HERE

“Twillight killed the real Pinky!”
Me: *appears* IM HERE


This would explain why some magic flow into Pinkie Pie at the end of school raze (Season 8)


Btw pinkie pie used to have wings In one of the generations


Wasn't Pinkie the one who suggested the test, because if that's the case then sh would've had o force herself to watch paint dry.


If Twilight realised this: <b>All gloomy and black and white and grey colours only on her 😢😢</b>

If Twilight realised this: *All gloomy and black and white and grey colours only on her 😢😢*


Just one thing to say.. plot.armor and.. Magic


The real pinkie could've actually died, but to think of it the real pinkie was afraid her friends won't know her, so it might have pinkie died maybe she lived

eeh- I'm too dumb to understand anything-


I could be very wrong but I think I figured out exactly how long a moon is in equestria!!!


Then how would the clone have pinkie sense I understand that pinkie is pinkie but a clone is just a recreation of the original it’s not going to have all of the qualities of the original so is it a clone or not


i didn't kill them... i sent them to the clone realm....


So You might be right but it depends if pinkie was in the middle then that’s the original pinkie if pinkie was on the edge then she gone I’ll edit it later. I think your right cuz it looks like pinkie pie was drop in the front.


Wouldn't the main six know if it was a Pinckie clone?


Wait... what happened to the changelings? How come they aren't around in the newest series?


So why could zipp fly when we met her when there is no magic?? And no one could fly?


This theory cannot be true because the Elements of Harmony only work with the real Mane 6. In “The Return of Harmony”, Twilight is too frustrated to go find Rainbow Dash and so she puts the element of loyalty on Spike. It is seen that without the real Rainbow Dash, the element does not work. Therefore, if the real Pinkie had been banished to the pool, the element of laughter would not work again, but that is not the case, therefore proving that Pinkie Pie is real throughout the entire series.


I always think of that cause I'm a little bit suspicious about pinkie


Me watching this nine months later: only notices the upside down cutie mark in the intro


Nah that's the real pinkie 100% there are so many factors that prove iy


OR maybe pinkie pie just chated with her clones , they all would have agree that they dove into the pool and were pulled out by another pinkie , so after hearing all that , the original pinkie ,with her simple mindedness would have agree upon it as well. so when after the test , when her friends  asked her about it ,then it would be no surprise if she told them that she ,  just like her clones also dove into the pool , and was pulled out by another pinkie ( her new clone).


I think it's just pinkie being pinkie ya know she'd probably told the story wrong by accident


its possible that the clone pinkie could have stumbled apon pinkie's cave, where she doccuments e v e r y t h i n g


Sawtooth your clone is right the real pinkie pie is in the mirror pool


wait as we know, there ARE other pinkies out there! what if one of the pinkies that were in the rarity’s Manhattan shop episode was the real pinkie?! i believe that pinkie knew she couldn’t pass the test so she escaped and is now simply living undercover so that twilight doesn’t find her and think she is a clone so twilight will make her disappear! or maybe pinkie is just being pinkie! she might be spying on her clone because she wants to be silly by watching herself rather than BEING herself! as you said pinkie is often known to be silly in a serious situation! SUPER SERIOUS.

although, pinkie could be just pinkie and we should just listen mlp makers 😅😅

also since the elements did still work before they got destroyed by sombra that means that the real pinkie is still alive! it might be that when the clone pinkie is using the element of laughter the real pinkie is simply just giving the element the power without wearing to make it look like the clone pinkie is using it!


I swear I always thought that possibly this happened


What if she didn’t show up to the test and is the pinking in the background of the episode where they fix up rarity’s shop and are in the paper


@Sawtooth Waves  so you think twilight killed the original pinkie? How dark.


The Real Pinkie never die... Because she has a other magic but I don't know what's that magic's name


Or they just want to have twilight in prison


<b>Plot Twist: The pinkie from saddle row is the REAL ONE</b>

*Plot Twist: The pinkie from saddle row is the REAL ONE*


Still ignoring the other pinkie fr9m one of the scenes, when pinkie was in an interview and a pinkie in the background


So they hive still has a place for Chrissy once she's reformed there she can live at hive bringing back the best of what used to be while leaving the worst behind.


how is the pinkie pie clone still use magic let see u think that


There is a simple answer-the element of harmony


if there was comformed lore/story line it would probly be true


The real Pinkie doesn't really focused only at that she want fun that's all


So the show took place before sawtooth was born.


Wait when cozy glow took the magic then she could be a clone because of that that’s why pinkie had magic


but pinkie can focus if her life LITRELLY DEFENDED ON IT


If she was a clone the elements would not work as the original  had the element before the cloning


Aren’t you going to make a theory about that weird moment where pinkie pies saw a half orange and frog in this episode: https://youtu.be/eIo9UXSaxFI it’s honestly the weirdest critters I’ve ever saw in the whole mlp episodes


Do Luna and Celestia still rise the moon and sun? (Video idea)


Ever notice how celestial cutie mark looks like the sun symbol were rapunzel lives and why did rapunzel in the series not get the power to make people look young


Can an identical version of pinkie activate the elements harmony?


Twilight: I DIDN'T DO ANYTHING!
Me: zzzzz
Twilight: we should sleep

Twilight: I DIDN'T DO ANYTHING!
Me: *zzzzz*
Twilight: we should sleep


Hey can you do a theory on how in the episode where starlight travels through time and appple jack is at home? I mean didn't she stay at mainhaten? OK ok I know she might have missed home and gone back without the rainbow but.......... pinkie pie stayed at the rock farm right?? Well in the zombra universe we see her cutiemark and it IS BALLONS?? I thought that the rain boom stopped the main six from getting there cutiemark soo wouldn't the cutiemarks be different? Also in the changing timeline pinkie hair is...... fluffy....... but I thought it would be straight?? Do a theory pls


A question I had since the episode was here


Leave my child hood alone it fading like without pinkie is a disaster


Seeing this in my notifications gave me flashbacks of that one fan animation


...But how do we even know Twilight spell was able to normal ponies disappear instead of clones


I think Sign was correct because this could be a case like shadow clones in Naruto were they get the memories if one pops but in Vice versa and that the Final Pinkie clone survived because we know Pinkie is smart and her clones wouldn’t be that different so the final Pinkie clone looked for what not to look for like a game but the others didn’t get the hint and popped leaving her with the tortured memories of her fallen comrades. I rest my case. #Clonelivesmatter


What happens if Izzy or sunny go’s through the mirror to the equestrian girls! What would they be? What would they look like?


No. As you can see when the clone pinkies get zapped the spirits of them go into the pinky and it could be possible that there’s some of the memories from that clone pinky could go on into her brain and messed it up thinking that she got pulled out so she got confused answered but she got pulled out.sorry for the wording I am tierd


The real pinky lived because the pinky pie that lived was still sad like the real won was so the pinky that lives it not 1 of the clones


Oh my God it’s like Sherlock Holmes and Waterson with your clones


But what if the clones weren’t killed but only sent back to the mirror so if the pinkie we know now we’re to go back to the mirror pool it is possible that the real pinkie can be revived orrrrr the pinkie we know now is actually the real pinkie indeed🤷♀


"many moons ago" your saying it like it was years ago


Yes,because there was another sad pinkie in there that got eliminated


Youre theory is possible<br>The pinkie that we know and love could be gone but it doesnt reallt matter if youre theory on MLP's forgotten world is true then everyone we know is gone and we know for shure were with fakes. And it doesnt matter anymore because theres no going back. Unless technically the pinkies that came from the mirror pools came from other worlds theres a theory that there multiple universes and that what ever you do in this one youre other universe self does the same so  techniaclly those were orginal pinkies from other worlds but if the real pinkie from our world did get sent back into the mirror pool she is not gone she is still alive in unkown world being forced to take moves because she controlled by th so called "Pinkie pie" they just need to go back to the mirror pool and pull the orginal pinkie from our world it seems like a long shot but it makes sense. We just need to keep looking for our pinkie pie hoping she is doing good and staying happy.

Youre theory is possible
The pinkie that we know and love could be gone but it doesnt reallt matter if youre theory on MLP's forgotten world is true then everyone we know is gone and we know for shure were with fakes. And it doesnt matter anymore because theres no going back. Unless technically the pinkies that came from the mirror pools came from other worlds theres a theory that there multiple universes and that what ever you do in this one youre other universe self does the same so  techniaclly those were orginal pinkies from other worlds but if the real pinkie from our world did get sent back into the mirror pool she is not gone she is still alive in unkown world being forced to take moves because she controlled by th so called "Pinkie pie" they just need to go back to the mirror pool and pull the orginal pinkie from our world it seems like a long shot but it makes sense. We just need to keep looking for our pinkie pie hoping she is doing good and staying happy.


Wait is this why pinkie has magic during the starlight period


Twilight did not kill the real pinkie pie.


I don't want pinkie to be dead. I mean she still seems like the same old pinkie.


Batpony soldier:  Mr. Salttooth my name is general Leonard I'm here to inform you that nightmare moon still lives on and the Equestria has been conquered it now called the lunar empire


give clones rights I myself am a clone of someone who drowned in the mirror pool and the mirror pool reacts uniquely to that kind of thing and even more importantly than that stop killing us


I mean, This could be right but, It still doesn't make sense that that clone pinkie would have the real pinkie's memory's. But I'm not saying that it couldn't be true, maybe that pinkie clone just knows.


Holy smokes mam I don't know what is in this party food but I think I just saw a pinkie pie clone?


And the fact that they say that means they hate twilight


🙋🏻♀I think that twilight didn’t kill the real pinky pie but remember in that episode rarities boutique when you saw 2 different people that looks like pinkie pie I think they’re one person and I think sometimes when pinkie pie is like a sleep you’re going to the bathroom where do ponies go to the bathroom anyway I think there is that pony that place and so that’s the one who told him about that so yeah I think that is it


What do you think Sunny from the my little pony movie is the princess of?


Wait something doesn't make sense if a clone of pinkie pie lived how does the clone possess pinkie's harmony crystal the clone should've only gotten pinkie's memories not her harmony crystal so that means the original pinkie lived because only the original can possess what pinkie has

☆ 𝙮𝙖𝙨𝙝𝙞𝙧𝙤 nene ☆


He is possibly wrong because some pinkie pies did survive in one of the episodes there were 2 pinkie pies one talking the other in a drench coat in the back


* watches twilight testing the pinkies scene *<br>me: squid game but mlp

* watches twilight testing the pinkies scene *
me: squid game but mlp


could it be pinkie just didn't want to be friends so she let a clone take her place as she slipped away to start anew we all know pinkie has mood swings she might just slipped into a mood she never came back from and left a clone in her place just encase she ever wanted to come back no one would know that she left


If the pinkie clone was true the elemants wood have stop  working and detect that it is a clone and there friendship wood end.


I think the pinkie we know is still alive so I don't believe in this theory


He could have just misheard pinkie or pinkie of just told it wrong as we know pinkie isn't always specific or slow when she speaks


No no no no, if the real pinkie was zapped into the pool how would clone pinkie know real pinkies past because when real pinkie was explaining her friends names to clone pinkie she did not  even remember what there names were even just being told them so. If a clone pinkie stayed how would she know real pinkies past and or everyone she knows so that means real pinkie did win and to this day real pinkie remains. But like she is dead though


5:03 Worst possible time for churros, anyone?


I think there is no real Pinkie, and has never been one.


This man acting like the pinky clones didn’t almost destroy the entirety of ponyville


Im sorry but this can't be true.. I respect your opinion and I like your videos though.


But can the spell work on the Origanal Pinkie Pie


can you please make a video about sunny becoming an alicorn?


I believe that pinkie pie was the real pinkie pie


no. youre basing it all on one line. granted its an obvious line but he couldve misremembered, read it somewhere, hell it can be a common rumor. who knows?


i swaer i love how you hate on twilight and dont want her to be princess, it sooo entertaing


Plot twist: A LONG time ago when mlp wasn't hear the pinkie made a clone and died and the clone pinkie went back im the pool and HER clone survived?


I don’t think that twilight killd pinkie pie because any blood didint come out and if pinkie is a clone how did all the magic work?


In generation5 of mlp they suddenly don’t have cutiemarks any more how strange it just disappeared


7:01 – "no more purple pony princess"

Whyyyy, I like the purple pony princess! 😭


the other guy sounded like the asparagus from veggietales
he even had the spectacle
just sayin


The beginning: “Many moons ago…”
Me a warrior cats fan: NANI

The beginning: “Many moons ago…”
Me a warrior cats fan: *NANI*


Uhm I'm confused if thereal pinkie was trapped in the pool that means the elements of harmony probably noticed it and stopped working and they'd find out


No it is not possible for pinky pie to be a clone because one of your videos of pinky absorbing discord magic happen before the cloning started so it must of stretch to her timeline so that means that the clone couldn’t absorb all of her magic


Yes, there is a small bit of evidence, but it's a kids show, come on.


How could pinkie be dead she would try to ace the test so I disagree


Or maybe the real pinkie pie just got in the clone


it's called to many pinkie pies alternate ending :3


This video could be right because the real pinkie has pinkie sense And after that episode we never saw her don’t think you sent before so it’s true that the real pinkie is in the mirror pool


This is the first video I've ever watched I'm not watching another, one day I'm going to meet you and you're going to hate me, the day that we meet you might love me uncontrollably. The possibilities are cat s*<b>*****</b> crazy.

This is the first video I've ever watched I'm not watching another, one day I'm going to meet you and you're going to hate me, the day that we meet you might love me uncontrollably. The possibilities are cat s******** crazy.


pinky is still alive the pinky that eat the pancake was a clone the pinky that was in back of her was the real one and she was spying on her clone


I think that maybe the real pinkie pie is still alive but anything is possible and I love all of your videos


No cuz I was just thinking of this ep like did she kill the real pinkie? Then you popped up. Thank You.


I don't think pinkie is a clone there is no real proof


Ya but clones cant use the elments and pinkie used them til the beginning of season 9


Honestly, you’ve inspired me to make a ponysona


Before I clicked on the video I said "Sawtooth, What in the everloving Celestia are you talking about"


The creator just wanted to make a kids show <br>👁💧👄💧👁

The creator just wanted to make a kids show
👁💧👄💧👁

꧁3𝕔𝕝𝕚𝕡𝕤𝕖_𝕎𝕠𝕝𝕗𝕚𝕖3꧂


But clones don't act the same as the original.


If you pay attention the clones have a problem with the cutie marks  but the surviving pinkie didn’t have a problem so this theory is WRONG!


Hey completely unrelated to ur video but what if the generations 4 and 5 are tied because when they put the villians into the statue a few years later a small group of unreformed change lings that may of became an independent small hive from the reformed changelings finally found their queen but she was forever froze in stone and heard how her tirek and cozy glow drove the tribes apart for a temporary small time and they took off from there splitting ponies up over the years and the tribes drifted apart and many years later sunny was one of the few that didn't fall for all that mind you I havent completely seen the new  mlp movie I could have flaws


Sawtooth cadence baby was the fire heart as being  at the crystal cadence cutie mark is a heart!


hmm so pinkie pie might have went through the portal and it brought her back  and she saw herself  and she went through a portal twice


my sister watch alot of pony and i watch it and i wanted to see the truth


Still didn’t explain the memory thing lol


It’s implied that the crying pinkie was the original yet twilight killed her


Regarding your last video I think starlight turn into those crystals


he was not right caz how I belive clones can't have children


just think about it how many people at one point or another been so mad or sad or upset that they wish they could pack up and leave there life behind but dont because if the people you care about missing you now have a magic mirror pool tha clones you how many of you would clone your self teach your other self some things and let them take over as you slip away and start anew but still have the option to come back if it dosent work out just kill your clone and slip right back into your own life at any point you like or not no one would know you could just play i hit my head and dont remember some things plz fill me in on what i cant seem to remember from such to such time


That was the real pinkie pie because twilight will never kill pinkie and she would've never became a princess


All the changelings were corrupted allicorns


I may have an idea think the mirror pool is a CP you copied a word= pinkie. And applied it to a (blank space)= mirror pool . Then the mirror pool makes the clone which means the word is pasted . Then you want to copy that word again then the word would still be saved. So after pinkie dived into the pool the reflection of pinkie is saved so the clones pull out the reflection thus the word which is the original pinkie will be cloned again please do comment below if the theory is wrong.


I really think that she killed the real pinky


Syne, if you are reading this, you should make your own YouTube channel


Why is sunset shimmer's magic first blue and after Red please explain in the next video


Sawtooth you will be in trouble if kind get thorax finds you.


omg the real pinky is the one that would want the most to stay so its wrong


Purple pony princess? More like Purple pony prisoner.


Idk why but I like their content so much


I do not agree because the elements of harmony can only work with the mane 6 and if it was a clone pinkie could never work for anyone eles


No I didn’t because here’s something pinkie pie has patients you should’ve watch that in the before episodes when this happened and that’s how I can prove that I didn’t kill her/make her disappear to another realm


If she was pulled out of the pool I know that pinky is the real pinky or else she will already said one of her name is wrong because she said flutter shy and that was right


Sawtooth can you please make a video where you go to princess Sunny and tell about your situation and ask for help


Show them pinky we all know and love is gone forever


No magic = no windigos.  Pretty sure windigos powers steam from magic.  Couldn't comment on the windigos video.


I really really hope it is not a clone! I really like Pinkie!


Sawtooth Waves, the pinkie pie is the real pinkie that is real + the ponies never asked pinkie pie what happened?


But if the real pinkie pie is dead how dose the clone of pinkie pie control the element of lafter?


and thats why the elemts broke and sent sombra to destroy em
theyve felt it
because u never know if something that diesnt talk might fell something


WHY WHY THATS WHY MY WHOLE FAMILY WAS LIKE...... ARE YOU SURE THATS THE REAL PINKIE??????????????????


The real pinkie pie didn't die because the copy pinkie pie wouldn't be able to uh see the elements of harmony and real pinkie pie wouldn't give up on her friends


Literally I sorry that I didn't believe you 😔 I feel so bad please forgive me for not believing you your clone was right bye for now and say thank you to your clone


But I have A question if that would have been the fake pinkie you remember she was sad and rainbow dash found her right?, The survived Pinkie was where rainbow dash put the “sad” Pinkie and you saw all the clones None of them were sad about having clones and only the real pinkie was sad about clones bc her friends didn’t who was real and she really wanted her friends to believe her for being the real one, also when she said she was the real pinkie, all of her clones said it to, like they are following her not Wanting to stay badly


Im not really convinced tgat the real pinkie us dead tho…


I dont think so because after that the elements still worked as you can see in the ep where 🤣+🤪+🙃+😪=pinkie pie stol discords magic before that twilight said;now I now that the elements were JUST SIMBLES! the real magic has always been with me! so that means the real 🤣+🤪+🙃=pinkie pie surwiwed and I WILL SAY THAT YOU LOOK LIKE THIS🐒AND OFCOURSE I LOOK THIS🦄❤🧡💛💚💙💜🍎


Pinkie get distracted she could've got distracted during the clone process and got loss and is in some other town


<b>Well i came here for a solid now i leave with a clouded brain.</b> 🧠

*Well i came here for a solid now i leave with a clouded brain.* 🧠


What about your theory about the Pinkie sense?


But the pinkie pie clones wouldn't know who Princess celestia was because the pinkie clones didn't know who the rest of the mane six and pinkie sent a message to Princess celestia at the end


I lost a brain cells while watching this


The “apple bottom jeans x bruno” guy is also a brony. Nice


I don't agree with him because the pinky pie was the upset one and survive.


ok, possible spoiler or new theory for g5, is mirror pool still around?


When twilight is gone I will take over as the changeling king and take over all of eqastrea


Twilight didn't kill the other Pinkies, she teleported them back into the mirror pool, and the real Pinkie ended up in Canterlot High.

she returned them to their state of non being


Celestia : oh no pinkie is dead people : what should we do God : revives pinkie


finlly the perfect princese will get the punichment she deseves


OR that one glow stick dancing pinkie clone told sunburst the story


how dare  Twilight KILLED the Real Pinkie.


If it’s a mirror there is the same world but in the reflection so each time the same thing happened in the original pinkies world in the reflection world…


Well that explains why Pinkie made Fluttershy cry


I think the pinkies were all from versions like equestria girls (da pinkie with F I N G E R S) and basically one of the old versions of mlp (The pinkie that said "I BET YOU CANT MAKE A FACE CRAZIER THAN.. THIS!"


the spell work only on those Clone, Twilight Stupid, she know of the Mirror pool and know the trouble is can make! Twilight know those clone are like the real Pinkie but she know the real Pinkie will past the test because she know the clone will be more easy distracted more then the real one, and those clone like use shadow clone but stronger but a spell to annulated the spell of the clone and return to the mirror pool, none are real pony and the more the clone create more clone the more less perfect copy of Pinkie pie, the Only clone who live is the one see in Manehatown, but those Clone are made of magic, if Tirak drain their magic those clone will die, the Mirror pool clone are not perfect as a clone create in genetic lab, this is why clone who we see in Manehatown a evade Tirak because she know if her magic is drain by him, is the end. plus if Twilight kill the real one, a dead body will be on the floor but every clone be hit blow up in magical energy and return where all come from, not be kill like a real living bean, plus if the clone be kill by any weapon is will destroy their body and return to the mirror pool and I believe the Pool is be create by Star swirl himself for create army to protect equestria way before Celestia and Luna be born, Star swirl a use this Pool to make clone of the most Loyal and trust Royal guards and the reason why he do is because the number of guard be really low and many be too scare to face the treat is coming, and many those clone die as true warrior ready to Protect Equestria, but even the real one Die as a hero but when them die of their wound, alter all those Star swirl a seal the place but with time the land as slowly make new path the Mirror pool, but what the treat is attacking Equestria, I do not know but I do believe is when Pony started to be United but not many be ready to fight to protect their new home, I am sure Star swirl be still very young adult Wizard but still very powerful. and If he meet Pinkie and she a one of those like your clone say, Star swirl will know it because he can sense magic like Discord and is his magic, so Star swirl cancel the spell but he do not, plus Tree of Harmony will sense is not the real Pinkie, the Element of Laughter is tie to the real Pinkie pie, not the Clone! Plus I believe Celestia know one of the Pinkie Clone is alive and is because she come to her ask to hide her and she will do anything be alive, why? she is the very First Clone of Pinkie and she the Perfect Copy and she now Work as a Spy for the Royal family and the Day Pinkie pie be in the same room with her Clone but do not know, her clone be break day but she be Surprise to see her Original


wait i just got something if you think pinkie pie has the lughter of hamrony sure a clone can esayly make people lugha like pinkie can but they have nothing with the eleaments of hamrony


fun video but since magic is back now shoudnt you be turned to stone?


What about cadence flurry heart Celestia and Luna?


When  night mare moon  was  on the  moon  she  gave  ponies  night  mares


It could be why pinkie doesn’t use/have pinkie sense


If she killed the real pinky how would pinkys magic stil be working


It does make sense though because what if the original pinkie swapped worlds with the equestria girls world and pinkie's clone stayed in ponyvile and thats how in equestria girls human pinkie pie knew about twilight being a princess pony alicorn and living in a castle!


Well I'm not aggreeing Twilight killed Pinkie pie because Pinkie pie can be a serious one and a funny one well when I watched that episode I realize twilight did not killed the real pinkie well pinkie was like regretting what she did with that magic pond and she was the one who made twilight a idea to make a challenge so maybe she was not been killed by the way she likes the color purple that include twilight at the challenge she likes it because it was the color the mane of her bestie (Rarity) And also Pinkie was serious when she has clones she was no longer funny anymore.


I think the ordinary is right plus magic can’t be that strong Canet it


The start of the video: dark
The intro: LETS MAKE SOME THEROIESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSs

The start of the video: *dark*
The intro: LETS MAKE SOME THEROIESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSs


this pinkie pie is the real pinkie pie! why else would she care about her freinds? the clones didnt seem to care at all! Irest my case.


Did you know that Izzy was wearing numberblock 2s glasses coz I know that the first sight of Izzy’s glasses


Sawtooth, remember me when you hit 1 million :) 🤝


That episode shot me, too many pinkie pies was a horrible episode


BRO THEY SHOULDVE SAID WHAT HAPPENED AT THE POOL AND HOW DID THEY GET OUT


I think the clone lived cuz t the end of that episode pinkie said "Am I me? Yeah I am" e


We need poeple to make the mane 6 reqct to this :3


DONT DO IT he trying to trick you sawtooth!


I think pinky pie was 100% killed (My opinion no hate) maybe the editors must have made a mistake luckily my little pony isnt in real life (maybe there are)
But 100% I think pinkie pie in that pony tail is from Equestria girls

No hate but TWILIGHT HOW COULD YOU!!!😡


but what if Sunburst was a clone then hmmm?? X3


I OBJECT
Now look at it like this.
Pinkie Pie Element of laughter  Which is one of the elements of harmony,
If one doesn't work them none of them do.
the Elements all represent the Magic of Friendship.
If the pinkie pie were a clone, she wouldn't even know the the others just their names. She wouldn't be friends with them.
Thus, rendering the Elements of Harmony USELESS.


Prime waves:pony’s with 80-HD<br>Me:triggered(cause I have 80-HD

Prime waves:pony’s with 80-HD
Me:triggered(cause I have 80-HD


do think king thorax will be mad at sawtooth?


If twilight killed pinkie they could have find a spell .....


The 3rd one has a side ways Cutie mark…………


SAWTOOTH SAWTOOTH SAWTOOTH WHAT IF THE PRINCESS FROM THE LOVE STORY POTION THING WAS CHRISILIS?!?!?!?


Twilight didn't kill pinkie bcs there will blood and pinkie know the power of friendship the fake pinkie does know but doesn't feel and why will fake pinkie know so much about that alligator so that's why twilight didn't kill the real pinkie pie


Wait a minute was there a theory thaa pinky clone survive does that mean not one pinky clone survive but two


Nope, the pinkies have the same cutie mark unlike your clones.


Omg- Chloe pinkie pie is- why are you crying?
Chloe: I found out Pinkie pie died a long time ago ;-;
Me: but- I just- how do you always know right before I tell you??
Chloe: …
Me: …
Chloe: I’m going to their world.
Me: wait-
Chloe: becomes a pony and goes to the world
Chloe: “Twilight watch this.”
Twilight: “when did this happen?”
Me: “wait what’s happening now?”
Twilight: “The gala-“
Me: “oh this happens in the future”
Twilight: “I killed Pinkie Pie??”
Me: “sadly ;-; I’ll help find her”
(Day comes)
Me: looks for depressed pinkie pie
“Found her”

Omg- Chloe pinkie pie is- why are you crying?
Chloe: I found out Pinkie pie died a long time ago ;-;
Me: but- I just- how do you always know right before I tell you??
Chloe: …
Me: …
Chloe: I’m going to their world.
Me: wait-
Chloe: *becomes a pony and goes to the world*
Chloe: “Twilight watch this.”
Twilight: “when did this happen?”
Me: “wait what’s happening now?”
Twilight: “The gala-“
Me: “oh this happens in the future”
Twilight: “I killed Pinkie Pie??”
Me: “sadly ;-; I’ll help find her”
(Day comes)
Me: *looks for depressed pinkie pie*
“Found her”


Also maybe it just sends them back to the pound and it is just another world


hey about the harmony i know it discord is one of the dis harmony when the main 6 retrive the elements of harmony and discord borrow them likely said but princess celestia called discord dis harmony


I'm sorry b-but i can't seem to follow and understand your theory. It sounds, a bit farfetched...


I dont Think pinkie is an clone. It’s a kid serie!!


Maybe the real pinkie did survived tho but already alest one clone survived we saw her behind supposedly pinkie in a booth what I'd they pony was seeking around pony vill and ran into sunset and she had just heard something about the cloning so ask the pinkie she thought was real ans she told her that she walked into the pool


Nonono she did not kill the real pinkie pie because only the real pink pie will suggest doing a test because if she looked at the paint for very long and impossible that memory would go inside a clone it makes no sense at all


Ummm but the elements of Harmony I’m connected to the real pinkie pie I wish if was a clown she wouldn’t be able to use her element


Well... what happened to Equestria? Does it still exist??  Or what?


Tbh, friendship tests in this universe bear a striking resemblance to saw tests.  Seriously, that episode where the Tree of Harmony 'tests' the young six by showing then their worst fear?  I mean the Tree almost killed some of them like gees Tree, you're gonna traumatize them.

Edit: also I love how all Sawtooth's clones are British, great video.


What if there was a clone that survived as, seen before, that gave starburst that info


She's not a clone here is some reasons why. First she would do anything to be with her friends second twilight didn't kill the fake pinkys she just made a spell she found to make them go back to the mirror pool, Lastly how is pinky gone if she's still in the human world?


im sure pinkie pie was NOT a clone she was so sad she cloned her-self and she realy did not khow what to chose so she cloned her-self.


This is not cannon this is just a theory


Okay so the pinky that survive in the pinkies I had to go back to the pool the pinky that survived was a clone but but but before the clowning happened the real Pink's got to survive but the pinky that survived that didn't go back to the pool was actually a freaking phone


🧁What if a clone did survive and helps Pinkie with all her shenanigans?🎠


I have a theroy on Luna Celestias parents but u prob won’t like it,it’s about more likely where and why Luna celestia can turn into daybreaker and nightmare moon


She didn’t kill the clones she sent them back into the mirror world and pinkie at the end she said I couldn’t leave my friends or something like that pinkie loves chocolate milk and stuff like that so she wanted to eat Cotten candy I understand I wouldent want to stop that either and she still did it anyway to defeat discord and I don’t like how you said no more purple princess I just hate

And twilight DID NOT KILL HER OR THE CLONES!!!!!!!!THEY WONT CARE IF ITS JUST WELL I GUESS BUT PINKIE DID NOT DIE YOU you ugh whatever


OKAY EXCEOT I THOUGHT THE SAME THING WHEN I WAS A KID


Hi you know that pinke that’s from Manhattan that we saw was it was it a changeling or was it a colne


Hey Sawtooth , why isn’t Discord in MLP A New Generation? Isn’t Discord have eternal life like Princesses ?

Also where is the changelings and all the other creatures that were introduced in the mlp ?


I’m pinkie I get distracted Super duper ultra omega easily


Me looking for music

This:want to know some random stuff?


It's rainbow dash fault maybe the second that last is the real one and rainbow dash distracted her because pinkie has adhd


No one:.......<br>Me: both of you are clones you know if you dive in the pool or not why are you questioning if you dive in the pool

No one:.......
Me: both of you are clones you know if you dive in the pool or not why are you questioning if you dive in the pool


No pinky pie is real deal Twilight did not kill pinky pie


I don't even whatching my little pony anymore but I love you videos


why is sweetie bell and scootaloo in the old mlp show has a mark but in the new dosent have a mark so what happend?<br>and in the old mlp there is spike with scorpan,so is the mlp show is not in order?

why is sweetie bell and scootaloo in the old mlp show has a mark but in the new dosent have a mark so what happend?
and in the old mlp there is spike with scorpan,so is the mlp show is not in order?


What type of cutie mark dous sawtooth waves have


That is the craziest thing I’ve ever here


It doesn't make any sense how can the pinkie now can be a clone look sawtooth i get that you Investigate everything but seeing that pinkie is gone thats sad is like the element of laughter is just gone the one who's holding the element of laughter is just a clone😟


You're supposed to taking a break from pony videos. What are doing?


Btw the part when twilight just like k!ll the clone is lijid like squid game ren light green light


Can you do a video for the mlp g5 what happened to the equestria girls is the mirror probably still exists?


help remember season 8 when there like when the sun sets on the third day all magic will be gone how will the sun set without princess clectia and lunas magic?


Bro every single little you have might just be really fake and it might just be a glitch that they made no need to ruin the fun but that's my opinion


The "character makes clones of themselves, hijinks ensue" plot has always been kinda weird to me because the narrative treats the destruction of the clones as a desired and unproblematic goal. Even if they aren't the real one, they give every indication of being their own person with their own consciousness. Is that worth nothing?

Of course, in the case of Pinkie Pie, you have to kill all but one, for the greater good.


So the one pinky in the diner is the original


i belivie twilight did not kill the real pinkie


😭😭😭😭😭😭 pinkie is gone she is mY 2nd favorite character the others is flutter


twilight has a small brain pinkie likes party stuff nobody whould like the blue solid wall thingie


Bruh I thought he's a girl bc he's hair is like a girl


WHY DID YOU MAKE THIS VIDEO I LOVE MY LITTLE PONY Y-Y


me being the scaredy person i am and always looking behind me if someone is gonna stab me most liekly to be dead pinky pie x_x


what about mlp a new generation? if you look closely only one or two ponies actually had cutie marks? could you do a theory about that. And Please DO NOT RESPOND as i am using my brother's account. please and thank you.


noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Pinkie is my favorite out of the mane six, now i hate Twilight


found ur channel after u left a comment on shaun,

good vids


Why don't you use the time thinging and go back in time and live there forever


The real Pinki is hear becouse she is 1 of the Mane 6


uhhhhhhhhhh there was another pinkie under cover and the real one is alive


i think she is a clone but the real pinkie would feel so bad she would run away and ceep a low profile and i thick diring the ithervue with the clone the real pinke was the one with the hat


I̷t̷z̷C̷o̷o̷k̷i̷e̷M̷o̷o̷n̷l̷i̷g̷h̷t̷


Oh celestia............... Im crying now....


Wait… then who is the girl that I’m datin- I MEAN, uh, my friend! Yeah! My friend!

But really who the hell is who

If you ain’t got the real pinkie then- yeeeeaaaahhh 😅


Well I need to talk so I don’t think so she killed a real pinkie pie twilight never killed her friend only bad people dares&#


However you can talk who make my little pony to say where in the real pinkie pie or he say the real pinkie pie is be all season.


sketchy and Kevin will be your servants and any will be your butler and countess rose will be your maid and nameless will be your pet and Dr wolf canned cream and event horizon will be your most loyal subjects. that would be nice toot i mean prince toot.


Actually I think she kill the real pinkie pie


I don't really believe this... Sorry but I have watched all 9 seasons of MLP but this is just impossible.


That one momment when you realize you have adhd to 👁👄👁💅🏾


Where's the next video I want next video Now now he's dead this point


If you’re the real Pinkie Pie then please stand up please stand up. If you’re the real Pinkie Pie then please stand up please stand up


Correct me if I'm wrong but they have mentioned Pinkie sense multiple times before that episode and, I'm not 100% sure if they have ever mentioned it after that episode. But when we saw the pinkies get eliminated, I'm pretty sure we saw one of their tails shake. Which could have been indicating Pinkie sense such as something falling from the sky. I don't remember if clones have the same amount of a magic ability as the original, or if they have it cut in half? But I don't think you would classify Pinkie sense as a magical ability. I'm pretty sure you would classify that as intuition so do you think that the Clones could inherit that? ( please correct me if I'm wrong )

I'm sure the clones can have there tail moving but I would not classified it to be the real pinkie. Her clones can probably have pinkie senses to but, the real pinkie would be paying attention to the paint, and for a fact pinkie remembers the past which that would comfirm pinkie is real, so to answer your question, yes the other pinkies can have senses.


This is like that video he did.What is the name?


It is silly that he isn’t understand😂😂😂😂😂


and bc  pinky can   not be dead  bc   after the  the clones left   an she went to rainbow dash  leving she got to go  to apple jack  and she runed out after all of them  so shes still alive and bc she was giult of creating all the  clones and bc of thethings  they clones did


can you make a vid about flurry heart pls


Idk if this is true or not. But I'm pretty sure not.

1. Shouldn't the "fake/real" pinkie repetitively say "FUN" afterwards twilight banished the second to the last pinkie?

2. The town should be destroyed.

3. If she is the clone, wouldn't she not known her past memories of her friends?

4. How would she know Maud then?

yeah that's what I was thinking. Pretty sure this is just a theory.


Holly site pinki is not livin 😱 and i love my lita pony 😭


Wait wait wait wait wait what happened to the changelings also does the form to you doing I think they maybe keep the bucket or still here


Don't care. Superposition of the Quantum Ponk propagates regardless.


OMG MY BROTHER IS ALICORN OF THE WEEK I didn’t know he was


ummmm idk if it's true sawtooth but i think pinky pie has adhd bc she's alwas hyper sometimes mad sad and weird


I think it's half right half not right btw love u vids


I kind of green because the real pinkie pie would I have gotten distracted because have you ever seen pinkie pie stare at the the purple paint I’m not even move at all so like I think the last one was actually the real pinkie pie


Doesnt the mirror pool still exist make him again.


dude this is cringe. But honestly wither it was the real one or not doesn't matter because it clone or not it changes nothing.


Do you hate twilight or something I just wanted you channel and I m starting to think that you do


im sorry you never speak your clone friends and i dont think pinkie orgin ben killed


bro just told us about the pinkie pie squid games


Umm real pinkie is totally did not survived because went the last one who said that "really I survived yes" and the last episode I seen pinkie is look like not good that's it


this not real the 2 pinkie was the first one who said it bruh thats why they are sowething


but- but- but-

us british people dont talk like that-


🍀𝙻𝚞𝚌𝚔𝚢𝙰𝚌𝚎𝚇𝙳😆


what about pinkie sence only the real pinkie has that and the other pinkies are all im the real pinkie they would never act like the real pinkie and they yes loike sawtooth waves mentioned dont have her memories  and she renembers them like yesterday and they dont get her memory cause if ur clone doesnt why should pinkies clone and lastly but not least its just a cartoon


omg she killed the fake pinkie stop making up rumors


what about the og pinkies timeline would of something terrible happoned?


No she not a clowen she was sad when she count play woth her freands and when pincky loss her spung he hair flaten so it the real pinky


ponk is ponk and sawtooth has problems wth ponk


What it intentionally that you make a pun with pi and pinkie pie


I just realised this theory is kinda stupid, but that's just my opinion.


no,I just said no becosue I dont want to have depression


Hahhahahahahaha🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣😂😂🤣🤣

Hahhahahahahaha🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣😂😂🤣🤣


Can do the truth about what happened too apple jack apple bloom and big maltose(idk know how to spell Big Macs name) parents pls and can I get a shoutout pls


i am know this sound lame but don't get mad but do you miss your hive?


Pinkie pie in episode the return of harmony pinkie pie wanted chocolate rain


what happend to gozy glow  tirek and queen chrysalis


HOLD UP— theory time. Based on a previous video Sawtooth posted, the one called “Finally Solving Pinkie Pie”, the theory they presented was that Pinkie, after absorbing all of Discord’s chaos magic from Gorgar’s bell, was affected magically throughout her timeline. Now, we have new information, from this video. Considering this event occurred after the mirror pool episode, I think CLONE Pinkie Pie’s timeline was affected. Meaning that clone Pinkie has been the one in possession of incredibly powerful chaos magic ever since. With that in mind, how does this affect the timeline of her “childhood”? Does clone Pinkie even <i>have</i> a childhood, since she was generated from the pool? Would things still be the same if original Pinkie had survived? So many questions. Anyways, great video!

HOLD UP— theory time. Based on a previous video Sawtooth posted, the one called “Finally Solving Pinkie Pie”, the theory they presented was that Pinkie, after absorbing all of Discord’s chaos magic from Gorgar’s bell, was affected magically throughout her timeline. Now, we have new information, from this video. Considering this event occurred after the mirror pool episode, I think CLONE Pinkie Pie’s timeline was affected. Meaning that clone Pinkie has been the one in possession of incredibly powerful chaos magic ever since. With that in mind, how does this affect the timeline of her “childhood”? Does clone Pinkie even _have_ a childhood, since she was generated from the pool? Would things still be the same if original Pinkie had survived? So many questions. Anyways, great video!


Quite a tangent my friend. WOAH WAIT!!! I just realized something. In the episode where Rarity sets up her shop in Manehatten, Pinkie eats a stack of pancakes and reveals another clone that was left there. What if that clone were to start talking and spread rumors about how the mirror pool actually worked and created her OWN stories/destiny?

But to be fair, I think they could be on to something. I'm not sure that was the right test to use (I have a few ideas about this), however I suppose on the other hoof that Starlight could've been so caught up with hanging out with Sunburst that she would've agreed with ANYTHING he said.

Quite a *tangent* my friend. WOAH WAIT!!! I just realized something. In the episode where Rarity sets up her shop in Manehatten, Pinkie eats a stack of pancakes and reveals another clone that was left there. What if that clone were to start talking and spread rumors about how the mirror pool actually worked and created her OWN stories/destiny?

But to be fair, I think they could be on to something. I'm not sure that was the right test to use (I have a few ideas about this), however I suppose on the other hoof that Starlight could've been so caught up with hanging out with Sunburst that she would've agreed with ANYTHING he said.


This whole channel is turning into "Sawtooth Waves gets into voice acting and has way too much fun with it"<br>...and I'm not exactly complaining—

This whole channel is turning into "Sawtooth Waves gets into voice acting and has way too much fun with it"
...and I'm not exactly complaining—


4:28 But Pinkie has a Party Planning cave where she records many things such as every single pie she's gifted, what her friends like, etc. The clone would have easily found out many things about the original pinkie. We also don't know what other things Pinkie taught the clones for them to be like her.


Now that I think about it the clone makes sense because of 1 detail, the magic that was given to pinkie when all the magic was returned to Equestria, think about the clones were created MAGICALLY meaning they would have some kind of magic


I actually always wondered that as a little kid, Pinkie pie was always my favorite character and I kinda had a slight feeling that maybe, just maybe the real Pinkie pie could have actually been sent away. 0_0


Interesting as that theory is, I just don't believe it. The test was legitimately about friendship. Pinkie cares about fun, yes, she loves it, needs it to function. But we've seen time and time and time again that losing her friends would be WORSE. WAY worse. Pinkie has expressed her fear of losing her friends time and time and time again, and if sitting for hours on end watching paint dry is what it took to not lose them, I'm sure she could do it.


Honestly, after that episode, I think we can never know 100% for sure if the Pinkie Pie we have is <b>the</b> Pinkie Pie and that all on itself is extremely dark...

Honestly, after that episode, I think we can never know 100% for sure if the Pinkie Pie we have is *the* Pinkie Pie and that all on itself is extremely dark...


Yeah, no. This is still Pinkie Pie we're talking about. The chances of her giving an accurate retelling of what happened when it doesn't result in a comical situation are just about 0. And that is ignoring the fact that the chances of Pinkie telling how the cloning happened in the first place are already close to 0. After all, we never saw her tell it to anyone on-screen and after what happened I'm pretty sure that she is smart enough to not explain to anyone how they can recreate the mess she caused. So Sunburst almost certainly simply assumed that diving in creates a clone and Starlight knowing nothing other than what she was most likely told by Twilight (already a second hand account) just went with it.


To give a bit more to this theory it's also possible that the first clone of Pinky retained all of Pinky's memories where the others were mostly clones of clones so they didn't