Magic. That is the answer to everything mlp.


The horn sounds like their pineal gland idk maybe that’s just my thoughts lol

I don’t like your profile picture

Just why


Well it's a world how can that be in mind?


2:13
Tree Hugger: Woah, dude! What is that?


a Dream World?

kinda like Dragon Age's The Fade.


What if the dream world is an world that Luna created


A world that everyone enters when the fall asleep


What if celestia had her own dimension answer that ?????


Did anybody else see the Illuminati triangle in the illusion type thing? I know I did.


Ok, im getting confused with all this dreaming.


You can compare this to warrior cats right? Does that me StarClan is a dimension? Wait that just blew my mind ~ Mintstar


me: *Reads the title*
well, if to your dreamself, yeah. for example, Rose could have died if she didn't kill the monster. but, if you dreamself is dead, like the trolls, then no. it has already taken it's course and ended.
BOOM

me: **Reads the title**
well, if to your dreamself, yeah. for example, Rose could have died if she didn't kill the monster. but, if you dreamself is dead, like the trolls, then no. it has already taken it's course and ended.
BOOM


“boy to i have one heck of a theory”<br>a 4 minute heck of a theory? ok then

“boy to i have one heck of a theory”
a 4 minute heck of a theory? ok then


Plot twist what if it is happening in luna's head not the one's that are dreaming


O.K it is named spirit Science 7: dimensions!!!!!It is very good personally I think it's awesomely awesome!!!!!!!You should really watch it!!!!!!!😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀


Plot twist it's all in Lunas  head she is the one dreaming and she is a child dreaming and it turns from a nightmare (her being evil) to a wonderful dream (her being a princess)


it happen in your head and when you asleep you travel to a different diemention


I think why that you so confuse about dream world and luna's speacial power
This is what i think :
Maybe it's because that luna just can get in a pony dream at a time but when she want to defete her shadow she has to let her power to limit and i think that's what make other pony can see her in the dream world and i think it makes that other pony could see her just like in real life and the bubble that around her too ofcourse .
So this is what i think about it 😅😅😅 i don't know if you think the same as me or not but this is my advice


I think it happens in a dreamworld or else ponies would have a small dimension in their heads, so, if it does happen in their heads, the tantabus can easily posses that pony, who knows, maybe it can take form as Twilight, Luna, Celestia, or Cadence to rule a kingdom, and the pony who is possessed, the real pony would just be in the dream world, wondering where they were if they never been there. Luna has an amazing power that can go into a dream, helping ponies inside fixing their problems. Maybe Luna can replace the Cutie Mark Crusaders, since there fear is in their dreams and Luna would help them find their true selves. See where I'm going? Tell me what you think of my theory! :):):):):):):):)


Notion have you watched Gravity Falls if so what if it all happening in the mindscape or dreamscape?


Your part 1 theory is canon <br>Luna explains it watch the episode

Your part 1 theory is canon
Luna explains it watch the episode


Well he is right , there is a dreamword, but also the dreams can be inside of the pony's mind, and to can escape from a dream to real word is posible, it's like a conection between air,phyhic and real word, and I works like this:

Your brain pictures, actions and sounds are thansferd ture air in real world, like as long you are alive the dream of your is in real word and If you Die every one will be woke up and feel like that was an magical share dream, but actualz it wasn't ! ...

... Share dreams or traveling in drems and dreams is like zour brain and your heart who does alould you do enter in another mind or who combine the both minds creating a brand new big dream !


it became to real so it managed to escape there thoughts


Hello fellow changling in hiding :3 (my oc is half changling and half pegusus. She does have a horn but I don't count her as an alicorn, because all changlings need horns to do magic lol I'm so confusing I apologize lol XD)


Princess Luna into dreamworlds and she is real so it’s hard enough to say that Princess Luna actually created a shadow version of herself but the shadow version grievable and pretty much want to do skate but you’re a world tour up equestrian put it in the internal sweet


the Dream Dimension is the 'Dream Time' of aboriginal legend


Hmmm... Luna might just be creating a magical kind of bubble around her because if she was sleeping and going inside other pony's dreams, she wouldn't be able to connect everyone in ponyvi- (Equestria?)'s dreams. (I'm probably wrong). If I am wrong, please reply and correct me. Please no haters :)

+Chickedy The Drucken  luna was opening a small rift between the dream and the waking world. it was centered around her so it showed little else. it cast a image of her in the dream. my knowledge of the dream world is really extensive. i know more about the dream realm of our world than anyone should be able to know.


I think I can understand one of the real world human world that's where the Equestria Girls take place


The Tantabus could cut a temporary hole in the ponys head and escape


I just noticed something... The sene when the black thing that luna knows cut to the sky like the dimensional siccors in "starvstheforcesofevil"


Did anyone else also see the illuminati sign in the middle of the infinity triangle


My mind... I can't even... Omg that Theory...


I think the dream world is just another dimension


It’s a dream? And magic? It’s a cartoon?


But if you go to a dimension your body will disappear but I stay in my bed when I am dreaming.......


3:11 GOOOD!! BERRY PUNCH IS SUDDENLY A PEGASUS!!


I liked how you used sharkboy and lavagirl


plain so i think Luna's horn is connected to her head to give the ponies something they shall know but its what i can try to explaini think a sharing dream makes sense but I''ll try to ex


We are talking about a magical world so that means it’s all magic


Meh. Makes sense... Not life altering at all. I think you are probably right.


Ya know it's weird that twilight has a PURPLE STAR cutie mark and not a night sky and sunset shimmer has a ORANGE SUN instead  of a rising sun?


I left more confused than when I showed up... eh, at least I got the reference


So where was Luna connecting those connection thingies when he real luna was on the dreamworld...???


I think it's just a piece of life in when I have nothing


I watched the video that idk when you posted it about the illuminati in MLP. And I was scared when I heard about the up side down star summoning stuff and I NEVER wanted to see the illuminati again and you have to put a pic of it in THIS vid!


I think there dreams are connected to there magic so there is no dimension


I think it's in the brain and in a Nother dimension


Oh my gosh! It's Shark Boy and Lava Girl!


There's a dimension inside each pony's head.

XX𝓨𝓾𝓴𝓲𝓭𝓲 𝓚𝓲𝓽𝓽𝓲XX


they are transdimensional linked so both at the same time like Schrodinger cat of dimensionallynis.


1:52 Sharkboy And Lavagirl! Yes, I DO know that movie.


Why would Doremy Sweet rule over a nonexistant world?

𓀂𓀇𓀉𓀍𓀠𓁀𓁂𓀱𓁉𓀿𓀪𓁶𓂧𓂮𓂫𓃹𓃳𓄜𓄲𓄓𓅆𓅢𓅼𓆀𓆾


first I gotta say shark boy a lava girl srsly bro XDDDDDDD

NEXT I got on track with this maybe the dream world does exist and I don't think that there is a dream luna maybe when its with less ponies its easir for luna to control the dreams and keep them goin for longer but when all of ponyville had to be connected the lines actually had to be shown cuz the spell could have been somethin extreamly hard wiv all da ponies and therefore she had more trubble, just a little thought on no dream luna


Luna did NOT give you permission to call her Luna yet. Call her Molestia. Lol she's called Molestia in Friendship is Witchcraft.


Dream world is another dimension BUT is CREATED by pony's heads.


I would say the dream world isn't a dimension, it's a bridge between dimensions. Why do I think this? Because at night I dream and I am some how having fragments of other a dream constantly appearing, which probably means that I am some how being contacted be inter-dimensional beings! I now this sounds crazy, but it is the most likely theory I can think of. It's been going on for AGES!!!!!! The fragments are Celestia, Luna, occasionally Discord, Hirobrine from minecraft and for some strange reason the MLP character Vinyl Scratch. Has anything like this happened to ANYONE!!! If so please let me know by replying to this comment, and no I AM NOT TOTALLY INSANE OR CRAZY!!!!!


I think Both are true. just my opinion though


Of course it isn't real, it's just the ponies' dreams.


Well, dur, isn’t it obvious!? It’s my little pony! EVERYTHING is magical!😾😮😤


Maybe discord is from the dram dimension!😲


Um... Did you just reference your April fools day episode?


It's a demention, I know it is, it has to be


its real cuz I mean like everytime u sleep.. u go to to dream world!


i think tantabus turned luna into nightmare moon


At the mind defining shape that was shown for a second  the illuminati  was  at the middle of the shape for 1 millisecond


I think that the dream world is another dimension


ITS CALLED EQUESTRIAN MAGIC. HOW DO YOU NOT GET THAT.


Oof! This is complicated. I don’t know what I think.


I wish if I was a alicorn  my name would be crystal night


Shhhh, if you know his secret he is a changeling


No offense to princess Luna (my favourite character in MLP) but , dream


Who says shark boy and lava girl is obscure :D


i'm the only one who think about star vs the forces of evil after watching this video?


Hey Notion, I believe the dream world is a dimension, for luna couldnt possibly physicaly be in all the ponies minds, rather i think the ponnies are all controlling their dream selves.Like in a video game, and they each retreat to their own little section in the dream world, so all luna had to do was break the walls of each individual pony's section to make one giant section were they all resided.


Is it weird last night I had a dream Princess Luna was the creator of this segregated hotel (Males and Females) and finally united the hotel before I woke up?.... I watch too much MLP!!!!

LOL!!!!(and I don't even know what half of that means!!) ~ Mintstar


So many questions about this I can't think


it could be that luna is controling pony brain or going to anothe diminetion


you know, my theory is that MLP ISNT REAL! SO IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH REAL LIFE


maybe, scientist got in wriong and your therory is in are life too thats how some people have the same dream and someone controls the dream room just something in my mind


The forehead power is heeere!! And the all seeing eye for some reason o.o


I think that when they are in a dream bythemself its in thier head but when thier having a nightmare or getting a vist from luna they are in the dream dimension.


I just noticed these theories are ALL FROM A CARTOON!!!


Training it's pouring the old man story he can't wake up at morning. 😳❤🧡💛💚💙💜


Every thing does happen in the ponies heads but idis executed in the dream realm I know you're probably not see my idea but if you do I think you can make a video on it again


𝙻𝚒𝚝𝚝𝚕𝚎𝙲𝚑𝚒𝚕𝚕𝚊𝚡


Wtf ive seen the tantabus in MY DREAMS  yes it was a nightmare


the one you are right yeah you are right pretty sure Anya my love, I forgot to say Derby rules that sucks we'll answer the question exactly last one I watched was how would you exactly the same speed as that and Rainbow Loom like they're pushing on there's probably going the other way so that probably made her some time she was going so fast and when the color of her hair probably blew up into the world and made up Sonic color boom that looks like fire


i think its in another dimension becouse otherwise how would i dream of a dragon when i did nothing that day to make me dream of one


OMG I KNEW MLP WAS ILLUMINATI ALL ALONG (only the most advanced shows have such an age range)


I have 1 heck of a statement "its a kid show"


DID ANYONE SEE WHAT I SAW?!?! IN THE RED TRIANGLE DID ANYONE ELSE THE THE ILLUMINATI EYE?!! IM SURE I SAW IT BECAUSE I WENT BACK AND SAW IT!!!!!!!!!!! I'm not actually saying this in real life to myself... But in my brain I'm yelling it... And it's made me tired.... lol but did anyone else see that? BTW can you please respond to this The Brony Notion? If you are able too?


its probably a demension because if it was in the ponys head then wouldnt that whispy thing go in like what the hell am i saying i am so comfused!


I know this is not part of the mlp but god is in charge of dreams really science😐😒😇😄😉😁😎😜


The brain always is growing and gives energy to our body .but there's still so much things we don't know about brain,GOD is big and we are the creation of GOD .there's so much we don't understand now but we're going to know theme in future+your dream world thing,maybe it is a dimension or only the things in our brain.we're humans the biggest creations of GOD and can do anything and our lives demands to us and our GOD


Bro i know it's late,but in bloom and gloom Luna went to another demension so theory is true


Honestly, the tantabus is basically just a sadist.


Let me put it this way.  A Nightmare on Elm Street.  Freddy Krueger.


Ok so you mean real Luna controls dream Luna magic and the real world is inside dream Luna's heart but how


"A dream dimension" <br>me: HOMESTUCK all over again

"A dream dimension"
me: HOMESTUCK all over again


who saw the Illuminati symbol in the impossible triangle?!


I think The dreams happen in Luna's head.


REALLY? ILLUMINATI ON 4:04? And yes, its a good theorie.


“Boy do I have one heck of a theary” makes you twilight (aka: 📖📚boooookie boooookie booooook📚📖)


K remember when Twilight became an alicorn? Well basically I think that was in the dream dimension!


I hope there is no place my night terrors are real. Freddy Kruger would run crying like a little girl.


How come your background is always apple trees?


Am I the only one or did I have to wach it a few times to understand


was i the only one that saw the iluminaty in the triangle thing


Does Luna have some pony to fight her nightmares


look this is the answer to anything ever: MAAAAAAGIC


yeah by the way its the dreaming dimenshin


The Illuminati is invading all your theories. You should probably do something about that. I have an idea! Grabs Illuminati Spray and sprays it The Brony Notion disappears Uh oh, I think I accidently got the Brony Notion spray instead.... Well, I guess this is The Illuminotion now.
R.I.P.
The Brony Notion 2017 April 17th

The Illuminati is invading all your theories. You should probably do something about that. I have an idea! *Grabs Illuminati Spray and sprays it* *The Brony Notion disappears* Uh oh, I think I accidently got the Brony Notion spray instead.... Well, I guess this is The Illuminotion now.
R.I.P.
The Brony Notion 2017 April 17th


Well i had a cool dream that me and dashie got married in mine and dashie dream


It's so confusing!!!!!!!?!?!!!!!!!!!😵😵😵😵😵😵😵😵but it does make sense😊


Hey hello anybody seen the movies twitches and twitches too what kind of relates the princess Luna and Princess Celeste Dia Apolla/Cameron is the princess of the sun ☀ and Artemis/Alex is the princess of the moon 🌙 and also in twitches their mother has both of the necklace put together so that mean she's the queen of the sun and the moon also my thing is that Artemis/Alex is just like Luna except for when Luna turned is nightmare moon and a Aollia/Cameron is like princess Celeste and the other thing is that do the mother of princess Luna and princess Celeste have both of their powers put together


I just watched it over again I was a little bit rong it is dementions.You should still watch it!I hope.?🤔


Overtime you say main six i think of mane six


Did any one catch that Illuminati in the optical illusion that few frames


And also... there is no dream Luna. Normal Luna dream walks into OTHER ponies dreams. When she hosts it, THEY are in HER dream, so that’s why the cord thingies show up.


I think inside the bubble is the really world where Luna is but outside is the dream world that's why she can't move in the dream world and I think they made a mistake because if all the strings went outside the bubble then where are the strings going anyways?


There is one explination that makes the most sense but it has nothing to do with making sense.


but this is just a theory, a show theory and I'm out of ideas to what I'm going to say sooooo...


when twilight went in the place to meet luna's sister is the place of dream are


so is this like derse and prospit in skaia but more complicated? but how can something be more complicated than homestuck???


2 mins in the vid
Me: not that complicated...
rest of the vid
Me: MiNd EXpL0dEz

*2 mins in the vid*
Me: not that complicated...
*rest of the vid*
Me: *MiNd EXpL0dEz*


A royal problem. season 7. this was all made before season 7


3:39  Did anyone else see the Illuminati 😂


OMG I SAW ILLIMANOTI IN THE MIDDLE OF THE INFINITE TRIANGLE!!!!!!!!!


My head hurts from watching this one video...


I like to think all thouts are made in a different dimension


how about when twilight became a princess where was she?


Then is it a demension here? or my mind?


Can you talk about what the equestria girls have at the end of there legs


they all came from that one pony- PRINCESS LUNA! >:D


When rainbow dash does the sonic rainboom the white thing touching her hoof is like the 3 princess' magic essence so is the white circles when she has done the rainboom.


Well a dream can not came to the real world because its not real even


I don't think we'll ever know for sure, but u think what u think and I think what I think


3;58 think just a secret somewhere in castle that lead her to dream world


the demenson (sorry I can't spell well) is in the head


Uhhhhhhhh I feel like derpy right now....🙃


Sawtooth: Boy do I have one heck of a theory
Theme song:FFRRRIIIIEEEEENNNNNNDDDDDDDSSSSSSSS
Lol that was one good theory


The  Dream world  might  be  real  in  Eqeastria  because  Luna  goes  there  alot  and  the  Dream world  might  be  a  Demention.☺😊😀😁😄😸💗💘💝💞💛💜💙


At about 3:37 if you look in the middle of that triangle, the Illuminati I'd there!!! Illuminati confirmed!  🔼👁🔺👁🔼

I just- Oh nvm, but next time last me, make sure you get the timing right


There is a dream world when I'm  a sleep my dream firend come and host me in middle of the night she tell what in the dream world . Once there was a war and nightmare won then the dreams won the 2 war or world war 6 .


If there is a twilight in the human world then why isn't there another sunset


MY wacky theory #10-   princess luna is basically the queen of the night right? (that was not supposed the rhyme ) anyway she created the 'tantabus', and since she can walk into people's dreams (sorry ponies dreams -), so, to me it makes since that the tantabus could Live and.......ABIDE IN THE DREAM WORLD! Almost like..... it.... INHERITED, LUNA'S ABILITY TO WALK INTO THE DREAM WORLD AND STAY THERE FOR A WHILE! (but the tantabus can't really get into the WAKING WORLD! LIKE OF COURSE: LUNA CAN!)


Who else understood this...cuz I did and idk how other ppl don’t


OMG I LOVE SHARK BOY AND LAVA GIRL!!!!!!!!!!


Guys when he said mind boggling there was illuminati!!!!!!THERE WAS ILLUMINATI!!!!


My theorie is

MY LITTLE PONY LOGIC!!!  ○~○


Lol then i'm not crazy WOOT I like this video


Other people might be in people's dreams!!!!!!!!🙄🙄🙄🙄


sunset shimmer aka twighlight sparkle people dont have dtems in their head people share dre as ms sometimes happened at school how can they  share something in their head


"as  mind boggling as this is--" Iluminati timmeeee


i real life the dream comes from the brain


Do us humans dreams are they in another dimension


Uh...  I’ve never really thought about this


Did you actually put the illuminati in the center of the triangle XD


what was that episode name where was Luna and CMC?


there was an illuminati in the impossible triangle


+TheBronyNotion    You must be a Doctor Who fan as well as MLP


Think its happening in another dimensiom


Emerald Dream and the thing that Luna created is the Emerald Nightmare, and Luna is Ysera......

But then if Luna is Ysera then she'll get corrupted.... Wait, Luna already has been corrupted, but then saved, but we had to Kill Ysera


All I know is... Illuminati confirmed!!!!!!!!!


I mean Luna did say that she made a nightmare for herself to punish her, maybe that’s her dream?


of course dream world exist!! :-) I have a head and  my own dream world


I think all happens in ponies heads but doesen't mean that is not real


In the video is dream world real I got really really really confused briny nation


I just realized that the triangle that brony just showed was an Illuminati inside of an Illuminati!?):()


Look at the middle of that triangle 3:39


This is my little pony they have magic not real life


This is like some Vaermina type shit from the Elder Scrolls.


Hold it hold it hold in the video the other pony's did not have a line on there heads


I belie e that sleeping may be a portal between the to worlds.


those noodle things make me crave for phò


It the ponies dreams a portal that leads to the dream dimension see I know it


omg if you look close enogh (and long enogh) at the triangle: ILUMANATI CONFIRMED


What If the ponies heads are different dimensions and Lina has the power to make it one dimension 😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱


3:39 anyone see the illunartiati? (Srry for my bad spelling)


Skip to 3:39 and look at the triangle inside


In my little ponies dream happens in another dimension


The dream demention is very real it is the 35368263486 demention


twilights name is based on vampires.the movie twilight is the name of a vampire movie and there is a vampire in that movie called vampire sparkle-twilight sparkle and that's probably  why she is purple

Or it's a name based off of the earlier stages of mlp.


i think that the white lines in Luna horn is in the ponies forehead but i think that the ponies are in the dream are the ponies imagination but the ponies are sleeping


Eg er norsk men skjønte alt du sa likevel xD


umm.... mabye it's nightmare luna helping cause as i said about the 1st epesode theroy: who bailed out nightmare moon" LUNA CONTROLL'S THE STAR'S WITCH MEAN'S LUNA BAILED OUT NIGHTMARE MOON CAUSEING A CLONE SO THERE IS TO LUNA'S


DEMENTION definatly becouse you cant enter someone elses dream inless DEMENTION TIME


No that's not True If your Brain is Sleeping for Real it can Becuase You Sleep when your brain Shuts down And Try's to Sleep And they can Sleep about anything , Anything!


6 YEARS LATER, I FIND THE ILLUMINATI SYMBOL!


I am one of your fans and I just want to know whats the name of it


I saw that, you know what I'm talking about


Did anyone beside me saw the iluminati sign????


Go to 3:39 and spot the illuminati in the middle of the red impossible triangle.


3:39
...AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO SAW ILLUMINATI...


Uhhhh... she better not see my oc's dreams......


Hey how Luna get moving hair in first episode Luna don't have moving hair only celestia have moving hair


oh. oh no. nonononono. YOU MISSED SEASON 6. I TELL YOU SIX!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

𝙻𝚒𝚝𝚝𝚕𝚎𝙲𝚑𝚒𝚕𝚕𝚊𝚡


Oh and one more thing i think the dream world is  fake. but its real too


I go thru dinentions already I know it's a dimention


I'm Luna I will know after the dream world or not there are is Dreamworld


So where are the white stings going then....🤔🤔


Around 3:39 paused
#ILLUMINATI CONFIRMED
Edit 1:It goes quick so watch out.


Prince big macthosin the prince of the "yep"


<b>screaming irl</b> QUOTE DUMBLEDORE THAT TYME HARRY DIED!!! "YES THYS IS ALL IN YOUR HEAD BUT WHY EVER DOES THAT MEAN IT CANT BE REAL?" sorry i could quote that better but my brain isnt functionin rn.

*screaming irl* QUOTE DUMBLEDORE THAT TYME HARRY DIED!!! "YES THYS IS ALL IN YOUR HEAD BUT WHY EVER DOES THAT MEAN IT CANT BE REAL?" sorry i could quote that better but my brain isnt functionin rn.


look very carefully between 3:39 and 3:40
x files music will blare through your mind
#illuminaticonfirmed


3:36 and look in red triabgle and you will soon see an illuminati eye


3.39 DID U JUST THINK I COULD MISS THE ILLUMINATI?? #ILLUMINATICONFIRMED


In that video dream world video the black thing is the nightmare moon shadow or part that what's to destroy equestia.


was i the only one who noticed the Illuminati in the middle of the triangle?  3:38


i really love princess luna so so much lunas cool too me lunas so so power full right ???


You think I didn’t see the illuminati sign… dude… 🤦🏻♀ why are you obsessed with the illuminati so much??


Am I the only one who saw the Illuminati in the video?🤔


The tantibus ripes open ponys heads lol😈


I have a question whoes mind was the magic coming out pls make vid


PRINCESS BIG MAC IS DA BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Why Soemthing can go to the real world some brain is crazy and there is no magic that will never come to life but some brain is the one who can control the demension and they can still be possible that magic throught brain like scine tist can do it


another dimension the 4th like our dreams


my mind during this video whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa my normal mind I WANT A HORSE!!!!!!!!!!!LOLOLOLOLOL


I watched shark boy and lava girl yesterday


😰SO MUCH CONFUSION 😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰

😰SO MUCH CONFUSION 😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰


i think... ha ha ha  you fell for it because i didn't know anything! ^^<br>                                                                                \/

i think... ha ha ha  you fell for it because i didn't know anything! ^^
                                                                                \/


Title: is the dream world real.
Me: is a blackhole real

Friendship is magic 🌈


hi... this at the end of the EP that drems ar in a nother dimention maby just maby its like that in RL * the real world * cuz im a lusid dremer and ya it dos seem like that...A LOT. ( my reaction wen i herd that drems might be in a nother dimention:  😲  😲  😲 omg )


In the triangle did any one see the Illuminati  #illuminaticomforemed


1:26 does anyone find this relatable to ROBLOX


I have a theory about sunset family and that is they died after sunset was born sawtooth


3:39 i saw that alluminati symbol!
i have a quick eye ya sneaky youtuber.


≋•ꪜꪖρꪮ᥅᭙ꪖꪜꫀᦓ•≋


I think its both watch the adventures Sharkboy and lava girl


At 1:28, I thought of ROBLOX. For those who don't know what ROBLOX is, it's a game where you play games others have created; and you create other games, join groups, create group, etc. Whoever joins a server, on a game, on ROBLOX, everybody experiences the same thing happening in that game. This comment will probably get dislikes because they're probably going to say, "What the heck is ROBLOX?! Bad explainer, Madison!" or something like that. But bear with me here, don't dislike this just because you don't know what it is. Ever heard the saying, "Don't talk about a girl you haven't met?" You probably never even played the game! So please, like this comment if you picture ROBLOX when your at 1:28, and don't be rude if you reply to me.


When you pause,me:illuminati!! Omgomgomgomgomgomgomgomgomgomgomgomgomg ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh


fantasy is its own reality but without fantasy there is no reality you are everything and yet nothing your body is a chrysalis and when you come out you will be in another dimension and prepare for your next cocoon to another dimension and never return to the previous world forever changing forever traveling forever dreaming in a new dimensional plain wherever you are in a strange field of life or death


Illumati Confrimed Sorry I spelled it wrong


I love you I love your videos I wish you can sleep mode


DUDE YOU SHOULD BUILD ON THIS VIDEO ( even though it's like 5 yo ) AND USE "A Royal Problem"  TO HELP YOU!!!!!

Key setance 5 years old: the royal problem wasnt out then


DREAMS HAPPEN IN DREAM DIMENTION REALITY CRAFTED(BY THE PEOPLE/CREATURES IN HTHIS DIMENTINON

THE FOREHEADS , THE PSYHIC CONNECTION AS ANTENNA . PSYONICS?


god... you've reminded me of the different fan made universes for undertale... im gonna puke!


I'm really RunawyRusionBlue.

IT'S OBVIOUSLY ANOTHER DIMENSION PEOPLE!!!!!🙀🙀🙀🙀🙀🙀🙀🙀🙀🙀🙀


Umm she is the princess of night sleep time dream nightmares makes sence!?!?!?


Are you a real talking pony or a person ars you a pony?


It's a good thing i copied the link so i could replay the thing A MILLION TIMES WITHOUT BREAKING THE PLAY BUTTON! (Like if that was funny)


U CANT HIDE DA ILLUMINATI FROM ME SO I'M A EXTREME SPOTTER


waıt ıs dıscord a part of thıs? ı mean the dream was full of chaos DISCORD!


poooooooooonnnnnnnnnddddddddddddddddddd *cough cough angels take Manhattan *cough

-by reading this comment you legally agreed to the feels.


LOL!!! I didn't notice the first time I watched it but U SYMBOLIZE THE ILLUMINATIIII!!!!


I do not hear. Or talk. I am mute and deaf. I do see. Tho.


ponies do not have brains they have hay brains


Pinky had a beed but the bam she whent to apple jack and the bed is gone does nobody see that


illuminati is confirmed.     O-O ummm wow

illuminati is confirmed.     O-O ummm wow


Why is ur background on Apple Jacks farm if she’s ur least favorite character!?


also sorry if I spelled illumanati wrong


Illuminati Symbol Confirmed Hahahahha you cant hide from me

Your also can't hide it from me mister brony


mybe the Dream comes from someponys head


man i dont have time to coment on all of your vids they are awsome. ive got smilar ideas and i could go on and on about them  but keep these theries going, they are great.


Their is illuminati on 3:39 in the triangle


i did i was ganna say if anyone saw it too


1:31 just relized hiw small lunas ear is


Good Vide... wait

DID I JUST SEE SHARK BOY AND LAVAGIRL!?!?!?!?!?!!?!?!?!!!!!!????????

wow lol


i saw iluminati, i dont think i like those now


O M F G DID ANYONE SEE DA ILLUMINATI OR W A S I T J U S T ME


do you know that human twilight got her skirt pulled down by kye somar


+po3mon gam3rz you spelled ilumini wrong it is spelled illuminate


hi San jacinto news headlines everyone stream all connected into lumezzane gone and then she spreads in or out and then she becomes of one in their dreams in the Night Live wherever they have in a minute comes into the first person to hit a hawk like her majesty like this one to the head and then if they're doing that everyone's connected to


if i was there i wil spwan 900000 dogs, ponies,food,house and pools


GUY'S GUY'S IN THE LAST VIDEO I SAW CANOBIONE


That bubble is real life that why that thing when go to the real life is was white


Can someone hide me cuz I just am bored I hate when i have to say when I'm doing stuff I mind can someone push me to knock all the Pins down


another illumanati ):D this is the second time that i saw that illumanati in this channel


When si have all thous lines she is conected in uif all thous poneis and when she dont she is just oif one ponei


Mai dream ish nawt just bein big i also want too bee mufin men!


I like the theory of a dream dimension

btw i jest copyed that from lorraine767s comment -^-


wat if the tantubus was not luna's cration its star swirl i know hes in limbo still but his spell that twilight finshed  was it wich his magic did it oh no aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa


is it my little pony is just a cartoon is not<br>real it not real....?....?

is it my little pony is just a cartoon is not
real it not real....?....?


1:53 me:WHY DO YOU HAVE TO BRING UP SHARK BOY AND LAVA GIRL IT DOSENT EVEN MATCH WITH THIS (or maybe it does) I just don't like or watch it anymore (LOL)


3:38 Lol
I L L U M I N A T I  C O M F I R M E D


wel magic is comon in dis world so  good toiry


ur voice is diffrent than last episode i watched.


I think luna can enter the dream world because she is the princess of the night

and since they said tantabus was created by her and the more she felt guilty of herself the more powerful it gets , so tantabus can get to the real world


me and my friend cara think thet ther is a planet in rel life thet is cold the dream werld


sorry type o .I ment dream walking is rude!!📜


Real relm  it is real and I lrdy know this


add comes up for youtube

IM WATCHING THIS ON YOUTUBE, STUPID ADD!!

*add comes up for youtube*

IM WATCHING THIS ON YOUTUBE, STUPID ADD!!


I like you and the animal is real hpw can it do that why<br>


Ethans Gaming,Recation Education and more  Channel


hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm (I could've put 70 more!)


i think both bran and difrent world be cause it makes sence thay are a like


Lol illuminati I saw u seeking that in the middle of the triennial


hey man who is the best way to get to know you


it was about to  enter the real world but Luna sucked it


sparkle its illumanauti do u know what that is?????????/


what is that on the triangle???!!!😒😓😨😰😥😲

Brandy Borunda which is.. ( drumroll pls) LLUMINATI.

Its not an eye its a triangle with an eye😁^_~

+GalaxyKat Gaming Productions oh....thanks☺☺☺

+GalaxyKat Gaming Productions no i mean what is in the center of the triangle

cutie doll its the impossible triangle, I've drawn one


Soul Wolf [Has Voices] [Part Unipup][Part Unikit]


All the fucking ppl of ponyville XD wtf Pinkie why did you have to dream of almost every pony in ponyville lol pinks


i thing the world when luna sister is the some well place


I think:<br>Your write i alwase come up with my theres bit your write

I think:
Your write i alwase come up with my theres bit your write


Oh and brony I say that eye I am not dumb it was at a blink of an eye😒😐😔😣😠😢😞😐😐😡😡


Ooooooo me likey this name can me call you toothy


hmmm there no to prinncess luna there only oneLuna look i think your Right oh star light frist come to come from futrcare the luna ascaped


more bad things 🚬📘📙📚📔📒📑💊📓📕📖📰✂💺💔📎📌📍📤📥📮📬📭✉📨📩


did you know, sometimes at a near-death experience, you can (sometimes) see your body from the outside. a theory is that your soul exits the body and you can actually see your body from the outside. what if the tantabus was actually Luna's soul? :3


The Brony Notion, Thank you for this video! Someone who has a correct theory about the dream realm/dimension(whatever you prefer to call it). Everything was real and happening in both dimensions but only one had a solid presence of everyone and the Tantabus. The real world had a phantom Tantabus that the dream version would have to occupy in form. Sorry if your brain hurts from reading that. Explaining or trying to understand time, magic, or multiple dimensions does that to you. But, anyways, I whole heartedly agree with you.


Surprisingly I was able to keep up with your theory. It makes perfect sense! I think that it's simply, well magic. Possibly a combination of another dimension and what goes on in the pony's head along with magic. Anypony can manipulate things within the dimension with magic. That's my theory after hearing yours anyway.


This is a wonderful theory, and I think it holds quite well. Great job.

Here's a small elaboration on it. I would love to hear your thoughts on this: If pony minds wake up in the Dream World when they dream, then that raises the question of how they are actually connected to this Dream World in the first place. Why do ponies wake up in the Dream World when they fall asleep in the mortal one?

As you've said, the Dream World is a separate dimension, and to gain this kind of connection with living minds and even physical bodies means it is also very closely linked to the Mortal World. I believe this can suggest one of two things -
First, that the Dream World is simply a product of the pony world, as in, say, the magic of the world simply created it over a certain period of time. It's a natural thing, and so it's closely linked to the evolutionary/magical development of everything on the planet.
Secondly, that ponies didn't actually dream before Luna existed. She's the master of dreams and the night, so it might make some sense if she created the network of the Dream World in the first place (how she gained her Cutie Mark?). Either that or she simply took over from whoever handled dreams before her.

Now here's another thing: If the Dream World is so closely connected to the Mortal World, does that mean that if a pony were to somehow be sent to another world entirely, let's say the pony-equivalent of Mars, would they be able to dream at all...?

This is a wonderful theory, and I think it holds quite well. Great job.

Here's a small elaboration on it. I would love to hear your thoughts on this: If pony minds wake up in the Dream World when they dream, then that raises the question of _how_ they are actually connected to this Dream World in the first place. _Why_ do ponies wake up in the Dream World when they fall asleep in the mortal one?

As you've said, the Dream World is a separate dimension, and to gain this kind of connection with living minds and even physical bodies means it is also very closely linked to the Mortal World. I believe this can suggest one of two things -
First, that the Dream World is simply a product of the pony world, as in, say, the magic of the world simply created it over a certain period of time. It's a natural thing, and so it's closely linked to the evolutionary/magical development of everything on the planet.
Secondly, that ponies didn't actually dream before Luna existed. She's the master of dreams and the night, so it might make some sense if she created the network of the Dream World in the first place (how she gained her Cutie Mark?). Either that or she simply took over from whoever handled dreams before her.

Now here's another thing: If the Dream World is so closely connected to the Mortal World, does that mean that if a pony were to somehow be sent to another world entirely, let's say the pony-equivalent of Mars, would they be able to dream at all...?


I think the fact that the Tanabis was born from the spell of someone who has the innate ability to not only shift in between the waking and dreaming worlds, but to also affect them directly is what allowed the Tanabis to go from world to world.  In summery, the Tanabis is an exception to regular nightmares because it is an extension of Luna herself.


Other dimension, definetly. Strangely enough I have used this for a fanfiction for a different fandom! In that fanfiction you could be pulled into a dream (literally) by someone who has a lucid dream and found a way into the hall that connects all dreams. You can then open any dream you like (well, not dream then, but hear me out). When that person isn´t dreaming or asleep, you will appear in reality, or at least a more ghost-like version of yourself, you can´t be seen, heard, or touched (you will appear behind that person in real life). Then you  can grab them and pull them towards you to pull them into the same "dimension" as you. On the outside it will look like they suddenly fell asleep or unconscious.


In "do princesses dream of magic sheep" I was wondering  if ponies go into another dimension every night and walk around in their dreams, but somehow still get plenty of sleep or do they have regular dreams like we do where there's just pictures moving in our minds to entertain us while we sleep? Luna has the power to move across from dream to dream and though I like the example of the online server I think it's a bit different than that. Yes the dreams are connected, but notion you did mention they all have the same experiences well they really don't because they can't see each other's dreams. So that begs the question of how does Luna keep the dreams separate? She travels from dream to dream and so does the tantabus, but how come twilight or anypony else just enter the other's dream?


Personally, I think it's both.
Lemme explain:
We can imagine just about everything, and, if we work hard enough, we can make those things come true. Magic helps a lot as well since this is MLP we're talking about. I think that dreams are created in the mind, and, as we are talking about ponies and spacey-wacey stuff here, they're all little dimensions. Because they're so similar they share a common connection: the dream world, or in my opinion universe, we see with Luna. That also leads to the doors. The doors are each portals of sorts to our 'dream dimension' so any pony who has access to the dream universe can access any one of them. BUT the dreams are created in our minds and can change as easily as a channel.
If you don't get it it's okay. I'm not entirely sure I do either XD


I want to say everything that happens in the dream world's does happen the ponies heads. But I feel as though that statement only stands in the fact that we reference their heads to their consciousness. I also feel as though there isn't one single dream dimension, but that everyone has their own separate dimension that they travel too as they sleep, and their mind is the only gateway, hence explaining why Luna has to use those wire like tendrils to enter ponies dreams separately, and that would explain why having multiple connections would connect her with those separate dreamscapes. I think that when Luna entered everyone's mind she had to connect with all of their conscious minds, then put herself in her own dream dimension, and  teleport all of their conscious' there all while keeping the connection. This would explain why the connections were inside her dream world, because she was in her own dream world, rather than being in someone else's. But that's just my head-cannon.


I just assumed that the dream world was a dimension all on it's own and that Luna's power was to travel into and influence this dimension as to keep the minds of dreaming ponies intact so that their "dream self" wouldn't cause any damage to or accidentally leave their "real self" by getting lost in the dream world.


A possible explanation to Luna showing the strings when all of Ponyville we're together, is that Luna could of created a dimension herself or used her own dream dimension like the one we see at the beginning of the episode. Taking all of the dreams from the ponies and combining it into that one single dream. The real Luna, having to enter this dimension to try and hold off all of the dreams together from inside of it to be able to achieve such thing. When she connected the strings from the outside into the mane 6, is only the dream Luna that entered, individually into each one of them. If she wanted to combine the mane 6's dreams together, she would have to enter herself into the dream and combine the six of them from the inside, thus creating sorta like a pocket dream dimension. She made those connections from the outside, so it's easier to jump from one's dream to another individually. Now this is somewhat debatable, 'cause in the episode where the cutie mark crusaders meet each other in the dream dimension, Luna doesn't show any signs of her strings.

As for where the ponies dream, if it's from the head or a dimension, it could be a combination of both. But this brings up to one thing: magic. Everypony has magic, not just unicorns or alicorns. If you go to Season 4's finale, you can see Tirek taking the magic out of everypony, including Earth Ponies and Pegasus. As they do so, they cannot perform what they can do. Unicorns, being magic from their horn (magic for them is heavily focused on their head and horn area compared to the rest of their body); Pegasus, being using their wings to fly (their magic more focused around the wings and a bit around their hooves); and Earth Ponies, for their strength (their magic spread all across their body). Alicorns, of course, a combination of all (mostly noticeable a combination of unicorn and pegasi). So it's possible that their dream could be somewhat of their magic. Between head (for imagination) and a small dimension of their own (a pocket dimension) crafted by their magic.

I loss count of how many times I said magic and dream xD. But anyways, that's just my hypothesis. If I did any mistakes (spelling or content-based) please do clarify x3.

A possible explanation to Luna showing the strings when all of Ponyville we're together, is that Luna could of created a dimension herself or used her own dream dimension like the one we see at the beginning of the episode. Taking all of the dreams from the ponies and combining it into that one single dream. The real Luna, having to enter this dimension to try and hold off all of the dreams together from inside of it to be able to achieve such thing. When she connected the strings from the outside into the mane 6, is only the dream Luna that entered, individually into each one of them. If she wanted to combine the mane 6's dreams together, she would have to enter herself into the dream and combine the six of them from the inside, thus creating sorta like a pocket dream dimension. She made those connections from the outside, so it's easier to jump from one's dream to another individually. Now this is somewhat debatable, 'cause in the episode where the cutie mark crusaders meet each other in the dream dimension, Luna doesn't show any signs of her strings.

As for where the ponies dream, if it's from the head or a dimension, it could be a combination of both. But this brings up to one thing: magic. Everypony has magic, not just unicorns or alicorns. If you go to Season 4's finale, you can see Tirek taking the magic out of everypony, including Earth Ponies and Pegasus. As they do so, they cannot perform what they can do. Unicorns, being magic from their horn (magic for them is heavily focused on their head and horn area compared to the rest of their body); Pegasus, being using their wings to fly (their magic more focused around the wings and a bit around their hooves); and Earth Ponies, for their strength (their magic spread all across their body). Alicorns, of course, a combination of all (mostly noticeable a combination of unicorn and pegasi). So it's possible that their dream could be somewhat of their magic. Between head (for imagination) and a small dimension of their own (a pocket dimension) crafted by their magic.

I loss count of how many times I said *magic* and *dream* xD. But anyways, that's just my hypothesis. If I did any mistakes (spelling or content-based) please do clarify x3.


Dreams happen because of the brains connection to what your eyes saw that day so it would make sense for Luna to be able to create a sustainable dream looking like them selves due to the fact that she has probably seen everybody in ponyville any way so it's very possible that it was just in every bodies head but it makes more sense if it were to be in another dimension because of what happened with discord I don't know this videos old but I figured I would go back to it and see any new theories


IMO, dear Brony Notion, I do think too that the dream realm is another dimension somehow connected to the mind of everypony in Equestria (like the Dream World from H. P. Lovecraft literature or the Hunter's Dream from Bloodborne) in which they enter each time they go to bed. But one thing I've noticed,as shown in the CMC's dreams episode, is that this dimension has its own space or room for everypony dreaming.
Now to the interesting slice of the cake: Luna as Princess of the night, and thus dreams, can visit everypony's dream (as she usually does) or forcely create a common dream for more than 2 ponies at the same time. But this consumes a lot of strenght/magic power/whatever due to the fact of having to maintain everypony dreaming about the same thing, instead of the usual individual dream for each pony (which is also created by each pony's mind and not hers).
So why the Tantabus can exit the Dream Realm. Does this mean that space is another plane of existance?Well I think the Tantabus could've scape to the "real world" because it was something pretty real and not a product of a dream. I was Luna's remorse and sense of guilt which had grown stronger over time (which is something that actually happens to those who don't forget themselves and/or express their fealing of guilt). This combined with the fact that she's one of the most powerful magic-user ponies in Equestria gave the Tantabus power since Luna came back from being Nightmare Moon.
And the thing about the Dream Realm. As I said before, I think it isn't something as we usually think as just something inside our head but more like a different reality where ponies travel to each time they free their minds and subconscious (which is what happens when we sleep).

Hope you read this comment, Brony Notion, I really liked this video :) brohoof

IMO, dear Brony Notion, I do think too that the dream realm is another dimension somehow connected to the mind of everypony in Equestria (like the Dream World from H. P. Lovecraft literature or the Hunter's Dream from Bloodborne) in which they enter each time they go to bed. But one thing I've noticed,as shown in the CMC's dreams episode, is that this dimension has its own space or room for everypony dreaming.
Now to the interesting slice of the cake: Luna as Princess of the night, and thus dreams, can visit everypony's dream (as she usually does) or forcely create a common dream for more than 2 ponies at the same time. But this consumes a lot of strenght/magic power/whatever due to the fact of having to maintain everypony dreaming about the same thing, instead of the usual individual dream for each pony (which is also created by each pony's mind and not hers).
So why the Tantabus can exit the Dream Realm. Does this mean that space is another plane of existance?Well I think the Tantabus could've scape to the "real world" because it was something pretty real and not a product of a dream. I was Luna's remorse and sense of guilt which had grown stronger over time (which is something that actually happens to those who don't forget themselves and/or express their fealing of guilt). This combined with the fact that she's one of the most powerful magic-user ponies in Equestria gave the Tantabus power since Luna came back from being Nightmare Moon.
And the thing about the Dream Realm. As I said before, I think it isn't something as we usually think as just something inside our head but more like a different reality where ponies travel to each time they free their minds and subconscious (which is what happens when we sleep).

Hope you read this comment, Brony Notion, I really liked this video :) *brohoof*


I wonder if Luna will ever use her power to build a massive matrix-like machine that replicates her powers, but connects all ponies except her when they go to sleep, that would be mutch more efficient than taking equestria by force


I certainly believe that dreams happen in another dimension, even here in the human world our dreams are actually on the spiritual plain because we are able to travel back in time, and sometime we even observe our younger selves dreaming, which I have done in a few of my own dreams over the course of my life.  Some theorize that this is simply astral projection, which could also occur in the pony world of Equestria.  Actually, I have my own theory about Equestria now that I've mentioned it.  Who's to say that the creators of My Little Pony aren't actually in Equestria in their dreams as they come up with the plot lines for each episode and movie?  I mean, it's possible that they know something that we don't know and what if they decide to add a fan based character they've never even heard of.  I'd certainly be surprised if my OC, Princess Stormfly ended up in a future episode of My Little Pony without the creators of the show ever hearing or reading about her anywhere.  Think about it, if Equestria and our world are actually connected in the dream dimension, then perhaps we actually are our Pony characters in reality.  So yes, in short, I believe that it is possible that dreams don't actually occur in our minds like scientists think they do and that we're actually traveling in other dimensions as we dream about certain events be it in history, the present, or at some point in either the near or distant future.


Here's another thing to support your theory: When Discord made that connection to another dimension, it was blue. Just like the room with all the doors to the other dreams. Blue. However, this would contradict your theory that Discord lives somewhere between the dimensions, since its home place isn't blue.
But wait: What would have happened if Scootaloo had run away from Luna and then entered a random door? Scootaloo would then have entered a dream of a random pony, thus having a shared dream without Luna having prepared any sort of connection. So if it really was an actual dimension which is the only logical explanation as to how it can enter the real world which is already a paradox in itself since the dream world would then by definition also be real, making the word "real world" meaningless, it would not require any power to be kept up, since all the dreams are already connected via doors, anyway!
Conclusion: I don't know! It does not make any sense! Or does any of you have an idea?


I like the whole idea of a dream dimension. I wish we had this in the real world XD


ok my guess is that with all of the strain on Luna's power she had to show the lines because she does not have enough power to conceal those lines and remember those lines are meant to connect dreams Luna probably just jumps from dream to dream to check everything is ok and with all of her magical energy being used to hold the dream together she will not be able to appear in dream Luna form but with the main 6 I just blame writers


Dreaming happens in another dimention where the mind goes but the body can't enter it, that's why the mind goes alone.Luna just knows how to enter that dimention with her body.


All an interesting, yet complex theory. What if the answer was simpler than that? What if she created the Tantabus in the real world and then trapped it into her personal dream dimension? This theory is a little less out there because, as stated, Physical Luna can actually enter into the Dream Realm. Another interesting idea arises from that; why did Physical Luna have a bubble shield and not the Tantabus. Well, either she was protecting herself from the Tantabus so it couldn't just smack her down and force her to return to hopping individual dreams, OR the bubble shield protected Physical Luna from becoming trapped in the Dream Realm.


What if everypony's mind is an alternate or sub-dimension?<br>Both existing simultaneously, but perspective shifting based on relative consciousness?

What if everypony's mind is an alternate or sub-dimension?
Both existing simultaneously, but perspective shifting based on relative consciousness?


if the dreams are happening in a alternate detention why would it be that Luna isn't in her dream form when all other pony's are? also wouldn't using her real body use more energy than a dream one even if the body is of a weaker state?


Hey Sharkboy and Lavagirl!
I'm surprised there weren't any inception references.

What if the pony (human) body exists on many dimensions and dreaming us focusing perception onto other plains and Luna projected her body into those dream plains.
Write a response if you like the idea.


Well if i can be 100 percent real about my own odd theory which is basically all of what you said but then end is lightly different, i believe yes the dream world is it's own dimension but not like it's own whole universe more like sub-dimension that is directly influenced by the ponyville dimension and for the most part luna is able to tread that dimension freely do to her being nightmare moon I.E. she originally was able to tread the dreams causing nightmares and the such but ones she turns back to luna she is able to keep her power but due to her power being amplified because shes good once more shes abel to not only tread nightmares but visit dreams directly. she can see dreams through windows and such but needs her magic to makes the physical connection in the real world that can link her directly to the other ponies. luna is able to exist in both planes but in the sense of her visiting so many dreams at once it would most likely conserve energy for her physical body to stranfer to the dream world so that she can become the anchor to keep all those dreams together while with just the three crusaders all she needed was enough magic or strength to hold fast three easy dreams together


i think you're onto something with this one! i think you may be right with the ream land being another dimension... but in real life could our dreams really come into the rel world? hmmm now I'm wondering...


my theory kinda links with your theory, so yeah.

well, my theory is that discord created all the alternate dementions as a way of creating chaos, but   luna uses the dream dimension to help ponies, kind of like the dimension celestia used when she made twilight an allicorn.


I totally agree that the dream world MUST be another demension, but as to where the real luna has the white streams coming from her horn and her not having those when she connects to ponies' dreams... well, i would say that she uses her magic to connect herself to the dream, but she also makes a projection if you will, of herself so that she can communicate with the ponies in the event of a nightmare, like what happened with Scootaloo's dream. But, when all the ponies had to stop the dream creature, Luna was using too much of her magic to creat a projection of herself, either that, or she had to be inside the dream world in order to use the least amount of her magic possible.


Because Luna can enter peoples dreams, it must be another dimension. Because serousely, how can Luna make one big dream when you can really enter one mind at a time? It also makes sense, from those portals you talked about. In addition, there's also a pretty high posibility that, this is Luna running a huge server on a game, as you mentioned. And the single dreams are the ponies in smaller server, and that concludes that, possibly the ponies dream place, or dimension, is like a Nowdays computer. Like, there dream world is the computer, atleast that would be the only way that it would make sense today.

Now this is just my Theory, you don't have to believe it.

Because Luna can enter peoples dreams, it must be another dimension. Because serousely, how can Luna make one big dream when you can really enter one mind at a time? It also makes sense, from those portals you talked about. In addition, there's also a pretty high posibility that, this is Luna running a huge server on a game, as you mentioned. And the single dreams are the ponies in smaller server, and that concludes that, possibly the ponies dream place, or dimension, is like a Nowdays computer. Like, there dream world is the computer, atleast that would be the only way that it would make sense today.

*Now this is just my Theory, you don't have to believe it.*


well, for your last question, what I dream off ALWAYS happen in the future. like it's your destiny and you already know what you would do because you've seen it already. sorry to the ones who can't understand this.


The entire time I'm watching this, I cannot- I repeat- CANNOT stop expecting a Gravity Falls reference...

Every time he says: "Dream World", I think of Dreamscape or MindScape.

I can't be the only one-


Wow, I never knew Pinkie Pie's brain was that huge, why, she is probably smarter than Twilight (assuming of course that all the sugar she eats didn't ultimately rot her intellectual potential), but I think Luna actually created a shared location among all the ponies as opposed to a shared dream as each pony still appeared to have full control to influence their own desires within their respective dreams.


Maybe it is like bill cipher physics where it exists in the mind scape but given the power it can escape to reality?


It's either separate dementions or I have one hell of an imagination to unlock. Who makes flashlights out of surfboard key chains? Or uses a swing set for means of travel run away from a tornado full of aliens? Meh.


Well. MLP is owned by hasbro, and Hasbro owns Wizards of the Coast, and Wizards of the Coast is D&D.

Notice how many D&D monsters show up on MLP?

My theory...

MLP is a facet of the many worlds within D&D.

In several D&D  and D&D inspired settings there is a dimension of dreams.


i think that the bubble is a spell to make it so they can see her and listen to her because she doesnt have the energy to control a REPLICA of herself


What if there was a portal inside every creature in equestria, and that was the reason they can dream? :3


The answer, is both. The dreamworld is not a full dimension but a sub- dimension, a dimension on the same level as our own but on a different wavelength. Think of it as your computer, everything you do on your computer is inside of it, but, when you connect to the Internet you connect to a kind of "cyberspace" composed of energy. I theorizes the same thing with dreams, they are connected into a kind of dreams space but for the most part it's still inside of the ponies heads. The only exception is when something much more powerful gives you a much stronger connection, i.e. Luna. When Luna connected to every resident in the town she created a very powerful pocket of dream Space. This also explains to white threads she uses in that she was using a much stronger connection than usual.

Now whether or not Luna herself can enter into this dream space is still unknown


The dream world is the reality we want to happen in other life or something that might happen


Basically Luna made that thing so it's a real thing it lives in dreams but it can go into the real world only Luna knows


Actually I thought about it real quick but what if for the shared dream they were in Luna's dream and the way the tandibus would escape we be the secretion of magic through the ponies brains as a way to form a physical body?

Oh and just In case someone or pony says that still in other dreams she should have this then I still say Ha because this is the only real time she needs to keep a bit of control on their dreams as in other dreams she only influences them but in this one she required more she needed to make sure the tandibus couldn't'to escape so easily which in my opinion would explain Luna having the connections in the dream so as to protect the concisuss of the ponies in the dream other wise why didn't the tandibus use the tethers to the ponies to escape I mean if it was in another dimension or not the tandibus could still escape let's say by hitching a ride halfway out I mean sure the bubble covers Luna but couldn't it just hitch a ride on the lines anyway. Please I'd like to hear your thoughts on this so reply or make a video I don't know

Oh and I nearly forgot about the tear but what if the tear is really Luna's (or all the ponies minds) normal function of staying in check of the magic and when it split open the barriers between worlds that was it bypassing the ponies natural control on magic and that was the rift. Also I have a theory on why the streams were present in the dream, since she is the "server" she may appear only this way to show the ponies that there is trouble or it is not her choice but maybe to do this shared dream she is holding not just onto the ponies brains but she is trying to keep the magic secretion in check during the dream because if you think about it that probably in the end would be the only way without the shared dream to reform in physical.Just food for thought😊


Princess bride reference!!! Love it!!!!! ^-^


Now that I realize that real Luna is put there, because she doesn't have any power left to become put into a dream. She is using up all the strength she can to keep the magic going. And now I realize why they all dreamed. Because they desire something mainly. So, all of their minds CREATED 1 dream while Luna kept it going. If my head cannon can just think far enough to space, there may be some theory how all this happened. I even realized I don't dream. So, sleep is faster for me. Dang my brain doesn't want to dream


I would assume what you said is right about dramworld would be andother demension, even though this is a game im going to refer too it holds the same concept that the dream world is in another demension. In nights Jorney of dreams its the same concept.


I recommend reading Fiendship Is Magic issue 1. it touches on this a little


"Is the Dream World Real?"
MULTIVERSE THEORY SOLVES ALL!
HAIL THE MULTIVERSE THEORY!


I think this one is just a style change on the art directors part!! :D


wait a second probaly something in your mind opens a portal into the real world but its has to be a spirit i guess but if its open a part of your body but you don't feel it maybe thats how it can get to the real world i think I'm right if i am I'm a nerd


Was Martin Luther able to cross dimensions, and is dreaming in a dream making you open dimensions inside dimensions ?<br>You have 2 hours.

Was Martin Luther able to cross dimensions, and is dreaming in a dream making you open dimensions inside dimensions ?
You have 2 hours.


Dreams happen in separate dementions Luna just taps into this detention by .means of the doors we see in "do princesses dream of magic sheep"
      that's my theory anyway
                                                    ~hoofbump~


It's both because it's a dimension in Luna's mind  cause  she is the pony of dreams she has a whole dream dimension in her head and she had a hard time dreaming about every pony because she had to think about everything and she did not have trouble in the cmcs dream because it was there thoughts


Btw love the cutie mark. You should make a parody of how you got it.


I agree it happens in da mind cuz in inside out it shows us where


Who else noticed the Tantalus looked like NMM in shadow form?


well since this is a show about rainbow flying magical talking horses, theres probably a dream dimension.


and I got the sharkboy and lavagirl reference! I swear I have seen that movies 100 times. and I am honestly not exaggerating.


OMG i just wrote a long ass comment about my pocket demention in the demention theroie and for some reason when i clicked backspace it took me to the last page i was on so im going to summerize instead
basicly it would take less energy to make the pocket versus connecting the white wire to herself because
A)thats another dream she has to create witch takes up energy
B)if she created her own dream it would most liklyt be castrophic cause the tantabus would be able to see her
C)she created her own pocket demention
the tantibus would be able to attack her within the dream if she didnt make a pocket demntion connected to the real world so basicly shes off the radar within this demention. and it would take less energy because well she controls the demention and taking a small amount of the demention she is physicly in cause she dosnt have to control it
and have u ever noticed when to many people are on a server it can cause lag?
somthing to think about :3
i appologize for the terrible grammer


Ok so lunas magic (the white strings) went straight into there pineal gland( third eye ) which the pineal glad is what lets is dream and what flouds are brians when we die everything in the whole damn world has dmt which dmt is ( dimethyl tryptamine) and what that is is pretty much the key to everything ;) so luna has pretty much the key to the universe there she has to know all !!!


maybe the mind is connected to the dreamworld that is just another dimension.


Pauses the video 26 seconds in- SEASON FIVE ITS FINALLY OUT YAYYYYYYYYYYY!


Turns out My Little Pony is actually just a dream from a human from the "human world"


Dimension. My dear changeling. As a Pegasus. I watch and monitor many things in the night. I do my best works at night. The dream world is simply another dimension not in the mind.


You basically just explain the Mindscape from Gravity Falls. Any did anyone else see the eye cough Bill Cipher cough ?

You basically just explain the Mindscape from Gravity Falls. Any did anyone else see the eye *cough* Bill Cipher *cough* ?


wait does this go for real life too? (I'm not the smartest)


Lol this guy knows ALOT about mlp my new idol


It is kind of like the dream beavers from tmnt


Princess Luna shows the ponies a hologram of her while the real Luna is still in the real world.


I think it happens in a dimension because the background is not at all different from Sweetie belle's and Appleblooms


what if the dream demition is controlled by the ponys mind


my be there's a limited amount of connections dream Luna can handle until real Luna needs to enter the dream and needs to hold together the extra dreams because there are less connections to Luna in the dream   are less than the amount of pony's in Ponyville


my theroy is that the tantabis is real.Like luna it creates dreams but only for her and it wanted to escape luna's dream and make living nightmares


I don't think you should think too much about it, but just beleve.


Do androids dream of electric sheep? Lol<br>When they charge they dream of that?

Do androids dream of electric sheep? Lol
When they charge they dream of that?


Some times our dreams come true. But why?Ask Princess Luna!Just kidding....I have no theories about that but i will soon write something.


The dream world is a dimension that ponies can enter by falling asleep but luna uses her horn too get inside the dream but she makes herself kind of invisible beacause there c'ant be somedy else in a dream of one pony my reason is there has to be a stream connected to one pony so luna can enter the dream world for somedy else to enter luna has to make a seconde stream and put on her/his forhead.But for discord he can probably just the name scratch the air there it is.<br>The dream world only apears when à creatrure of equestria is asleep

The dream world is a dimension that ponies can enter by falling asleep but luna uses her horn too get inside the dream but she makes herself kind of invisible beacause there c'ant be somedy else in a dream of one pony my reason is there has to be a stream connected to one pony so luna can enter the dream world for somedy else to enter luna has to make a seconde stream and put on her/his forhead.But for discord he can probably just the name scratch the air there it is.
The dream world only apears when à creatrure of equestria is asleep


I think dreams happen in another dimension


What about Celestias's nephew? Luna's son? Lost sibling's son? Doesn't have to do with episode but whatever XD


totally happens in the head luna can go in and out of peoples dreams she is afraid that the black dream thingy can too so it does she is afraid it can go into the real world so it can its her night mare


Can we share Dreams? or Dose The Dream World/Realm Real? Maybe it is. But sometimes I get nightmares! 😧☁ Do someone get nightmares Sometimes like me? 🌙 I like The night also Luna but Nightmares are the worst!


all seeing eye at exactly 3:39 has to be there


There is no dream Luna. There is only one Luna.


For some kinda reason I got jumpscared at the end of that brohoof


I was actually able to keep up quite well you were just over complicating things


you are so smart when it comes to mlp!!!


Spoiler!

If dream can enter the real world could alicorn big macintosh be brought out of the dream world.


The brony nation should ask bill cypher about this one lol


Nice refrence to shark boy and lava girl!


The dream world is a dimension that ponies can enter by falling asleep but luna uses her horn too get inside the dream but she makes herself kind of invisible beacause there c'ant be somedy else in a dream of one pony my reason is there has to be a stream connected to one pony so luna can enter the dream world for somedy else to enter luna has to make a seconde stream and put on her/his forhead.But for discord he can probably just the name scratch the air there it is.
The dream world only apears when à creatrure of equestria is asleep

i'm a 9 years old girl and that's my treory


that might be true because people have had the same dreams so it could actually be they were in another dimension tell me what u think im 9😃😃😃😃


sharkboy and lavagirl..... i'm probably the only one who gets that reference


Shark boy and lava girl was on my tv when I was watching this.


Or just say..

LUNA ENTERS DREAMS. SO WHY NOT LUNAS CREATION ENTER THE REAL WORD AND DREAMS M8


I mean, if the real Luna is in the real world, and all the others are in the dream world, does this mean that the dream Luna is in the real world at the moment? And also I didn't see the whit wire thingy on the ponies' foreheads in the dream world Luna has created. The real Luna can control the dream Luna, and the dream Luna is not here, because we can still see the wire coming out of her horn, but not on the ponies' forehead??? And BTW, Luna's wire thingy has to be the real Luna, but the wires are coming OUT of the bubble that keeps her out of the dream world. Doesn't this mean that the dream world can also exsist in the real world, since dream Luna is not here, and we can still see the wires outside of the alternate-demension bubble??

+Violet Choi OK, I do not understand a single thing regardless that I wrote it


so, do I get a cookie because I got the reference?


if this is real I can get into your dreams!


I think your right thier is a dream demention


Wait big mac dreams of being a princess hahahaha


but the tantabuis really looks like lunas hair


if  rainbow dashes favorite dream is beating up changelings, and ur  a changeling, dose that mean her favorite dream is beating up you?


am i the only one who could follow? nd that is strange because i'm dutch and that is harder to understand (bad spelling xD)


Illu-mane-ati confirmed
*x files theme starts playing*

Illu-mane-ati confirmed
**x files theme starts playing**


I saw the eye in the triangle  it is a bad  thing


HEY! ILLUMINATI! Pause and Play quickly as you can on 3:39 and let me know if you see it!
Hint: In between the triangle


when the ponies know go dimension why I can not go through dimensions also fit into the dimensions ???


Well maybe it is another demontion we know that demintion jumping is a thing so I could be a whole other relem and that bubble explains it to


The dream world is probaly couse you day dream and then you sleep dream


am i the only one who saw tge lumanati or was i just dreaming again?


OMG SHARKBOY AND LAVAGIRL XD MY FAV MOVIE OF PLANET DROOL!


Anyone eles see that triangle in side that mind illusion?


Did anyone else notice the illuminati in the double triangle?


wait do you watch doctor who because tht was a picture of amy pond


um how is that mlp episode called? and...ILUMINATTI CONFIRMED 😮🔺❗


Different dimension. That's the only way that all of this crap makes any sense at ALL!!!!!!


Are you mad, there is kids watching this and you show the Iluminyty symbol? Are you crazy?


WHAT HAPPENED TO EPISODE 14!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IS IT JUST MY DVR NOT RECORDING IT?

@Smilley MLK Oooh thank you some much i got worried lol

+Kaylie Caston Two more weeks. Episode 14 airs on Sept. 12th.


I had a small theory, but I forgot laughs at bad joke

Princess Forgotten (of)- poker face shut up :I

I had a small theory, but I forgot *laughs at bad joke*

Princess Forgotten (of)- *poker face* shut up :I


I Saw The Illuminati Pop Up Really Brony Notion?


Did anyone notice the illuminati somewhere in that video?


guys dont judge me but dreams cantvbe in yur head people sometimes share dreams if its in their brain how can they share it right something too think about😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐hmmmmmmm.......tell me what u think


<b>sigh</b> i saw the illuminati sign...SHAME ON YOU.

*sigh* i saw the illuminati sign...SHAME ON YOU.


3:40 ITS ILLUMINATI :0000000000 U have to pause and un pause.


Who else think's that the dream world's true? Like this then


BERRY PUNCH WAS A PEGESUS WHEN SHE WAS SUPOSE TO BE AN EARTH PONY! in do princess dream of sheep!!!!! dun dun dunnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!XD


you keep using that word, I do not think it means what you think it means


+The Brony Notion I agree on that, but like otherwise; you are idiot for watching something I don't understand.. Because screw logic that's why. :)

Okay, I'm sorry you don't find value in my videos, but lots of people do. You can't judge people for enjoying things that you don't enjoy. Was clicking on a video that didn't interest you all that bad?

+Curiosity Science2 Apply cold water on burned areas my friend lol XD

+Curiosity Science2 I respect your opinion, but as I do, you must do the same... Hating something and sticking your hate on someone doesn't make sense, you might clickbait-ed, even though the maker of this video didn't mean... Even so, how did got to you home page of youtube? You might be a subscriber or watched a few vidoes... Even notice the picture of the video... What is rude as I guess that you define something is done by someone who loves to do is a complete waste... If it is a complete waste of your time.. Then why do you even waste your time commenting here? Happy you apologized. Thanks for understandingZ

+The Brony Notion <br>r u still updating?!

don't see how any of them would make a difference but ok

wow. everyone is like, so supportive round here.

+Curiosity Science2 SHUTUP hater. If u dont like it why r u even on this channel? So stop bullying and watch something useful to YOU, like a tutorial on being nice.

+The Brony Notion My apologies for not being comprehensible in my sarcasm, what i actually intended to bring attention to was how shockingly time wasting that video was. You make videos about animated ponies, the video title mislead me to believe it was actually worth clicking on. Disappointment to many people I'm sure.

A video called "Is the Dream World Real?" posted by The Brony Notion on July 16th, 2015.


Dreems ar your sub conchns in a world were any think is posibl.....its confyzing i now


In my thoughts it happens in another dimension, but Even though it's in another dimension it is accessed thorough the mind making it easy to access through sleep, so (in my theory) Luna "sleeps" to enter this dimension and between it and the main dimension of the show she can choose a dream to watch and,if necessary, to help others through it. Even in this particular episode she just used those string to connect the 4 of them at the same time to make it easier to navigate between those said dreams, or in the other case with the whole Ponyville, create a shared dream


Love that idea with the dimensions! And every dream is a new dimension. And you enter every dimension in another form than yourself. The magic mirror that brougth Twi into EG world was different than "dream entering", since she no lenger was in equestria, and there was two Twis in EG world. But maybe if she knew the rigth way, she would take form as the Twiligth in EG world! :)


I've honestly thought something similar to this for a long time, just not necessarily with ponies. I've wanted to write fanfictions and such where characters have dreams that show them glimpses of another dimension. So... I buy the theory. <br>(Also, I love how deeply you think about things like this. Most people would just see a cartoon and think "Eh, it's a cartoon. There's no real substance to a cartoon." But theorists and people like you look so far into it and make connections that help you and everyone you share them with love the show that much more. Thanks for helping me appreciate MLP:FiM.)

I've honestly thought something similar to this for a long time, just not necessarily with ponies. I've wanted to write fanfictions and such where characters have dreams that show them glimpses of another dimension. So... I buy the theory.
(Also, I love how deeply you think about things like this. Most people would just see a cartoon and think "Eh, it's a cartoon. There's no real substance to a cartoon." But theorists and people like you look so far into it and make connections that help you and everyone you share them with love the show that much more. Thanks for helping me appreciate MLP:FiM.)


The ponies may even have their own dream dimensions, that would explain luna's bubble as the gap between all the dimensions combined. To access one pony's own dream dimension as a pony, you would sleep. That's the key to the door. To access that externally, AKA Luna, you would do what luna would do. Making a synthetic form of sleep, forming the dream Luna. If that didn't make sense, heres another one for you. Since the "server" concept is a great application for this concept, lets go with that. The server box itself is Luna. Real Luna. It is connected both ways from ponies to Luna, and Luna to ponies. To create a shared dream the ponies are able to connect with other ponies through the actual server box (real Luna) to all the other ponies. Same with all the other ponies to the others. So the actual Luna, not dream Luna, is doing all that work to create a shared dream. The server box, or the exact connection point of all the ribbons, is the space between all of the other ponies' dimension. If she is combining all of the ponies' dimensions together there has to be a connection point. THATS the gap between the real world and the dream world. Or, dream worlds*. But how can one escape through the dream world? Well, luna obviously can, and has. So can that "thing".

BOOM.
Did I miss something?
Probably.
Did I get it all wrong?
Most likely.
What do you guys think?


I've often played with the idea that magic comes in different forms which originate from different dimensions or places in the pony universe. In my theory dreams would be a result of a sleeping pony's mind coming into contact with (or going to) the realm where Chaos magic originates, Luna (and to a tiny extent Pinkie Pie) would have the ability sense and/or manipulate Chaos magic, and Discord's immense power and control over it would allow him to bring the world of dreams to bear on the real world.

You also mention Discord perhaps using the same or similar magic. Would this mean that his little chaos home we see in his episode is actually in the realm of dreams? And if so, how did the mail pony get there? O.o


Hmm, I have found a flaw in your plan. So, if luna is as proactive in assisting her subjects through dream scaping as we are lead to believe, then white tendril's covering large distances across the sky must be rather common place in equestria, especially when luna is doing shared dreams like with the cmc because she can't be next to all 3 of them.

This does not at all seem like a way an alicorn would conduct their actions. Especially considering the odd privacy interactions, and if she was for example entering the dreams of one of the cake's and the other is like 'omg he's being attacked by a tendril (bad anime joke)'

I do however have a similar counter proposal;

In the 3 cmc episodes luna directly enters the dream plane, as i'll call it, entering the dreams of each seperatly, these having potentially very strange co-ordinates not allowing for quick exchange. That is until the latest one, where, luna pulled each of the cmc out of their own dreams into a small or perhaps empty dream area for their little intervention.

When it came to the most recent episode luna required instant access to each of the mane 6's dreams. So she connected them, like ethernet instead of using wi-fi.

The most complicated part is when it came to the town wide dream. Interestingly I think this is not at all like any of the previous types of dream. What I propose is that instead of connecting everypony into the dream scape via tendril. What luna instead did was create a massive, area of effect' dream as you will, merely using the tendril's as guidance to find all ponies. If you watch they don't actually go into any ponies homes.

As a result luna is not actually in the dream plane herself, but has created it is all around herself, with all of the ponies with her. (notice that the area inside the dream is roughtly the same as what she covers with her magic before hand.)

This is the reason that she is in a bubble.

A little extra support for this is that, as regardless of how, she was able to bring 3 ponies together and herself with literally no problems, scaling it up to holding a dream scape the size of a town with 30 ponies, seams like it would really take it out of a princess.

If you made it through that, I'm impressed.


You know how some say each and every one of our minds contain another universe? What if Luna connected those universes inside the ponys' heads? So, it's both to me. Each pony has a universe inside their heads, which they enter when dreaming.


I actually think this villain is one of the best I've seen from the series, right behind Discord (and probably when Queen Chrysalis was first revealed at the wedding). I mean, when the Tantabus becomes a giant shadowy Alicorn, you just get chills.

it makes sense the Tantabus turned into an alicorn because luna was the one who created it, and SHES an alicorn, 🦄🐦


I actually have a similar theory that I believe could be used (once refined and supported with facts or at least observations) that instead of Dreams being a simulation in the mind, that one's own dreams are located inside a small micro-dimension in the mind.

I like to think that the micro dimension of dreaming is more or less just a constantly shifting state and when we dream or daydream, we are simply looking into this dimension. I also like to think it's where imagination also comes from, where one gets inspiration to create things via certain dreams.

In the episode the Tantibus does seem to be more of a real thing than just some concept or idea put into some simulation. It would also make a bit more sense this way as sometimes when you are having Nightmares, you have difficulty waking up or stopping the dream.
If dreaming was just a mental simulation, there would be nothing really stopping a person from ending a dream, but if it were a dimension that either we view like a sort of very focused god, or a dimension that once we dream, we literally occupy space inside of it, it'd make sense why some people have nightmares that last entire nights due to being unable to wake from them without external help.

That's just my opinion on the subject, but if Dreams were located inside of a micro-dimension located in the brain, it would be reasonable to assume that one would never see inside another's dreams until we could see inside other dimensions.


The Dreamscape is Luna's domain, a central hub from which she can go from dream to dream, which is from Luna's dreamwalking abilities.

 On that, I agree but I don't think it's "real" in a separate dimension way but rather Luna is the server rather than the domain itself being the server.

The Tantabus is the manifestation of Luna's guilt and self-loathing. It was a piece of her, which would naturally have the same dreamwalking abilities that Luna herself has. However, it was only a piece of her that originated in her own dream. It could only cause nightmares in Luna's own dream. After many nights of feeding off Luna's guilt, it eventually gained the power to access the dreamscape and traverse to another's dream. The limitation of dream walking is that it would need to know the dreamer before it can go into the dream.

The Tantabus continued to grow in power as Luna felt worse about herself while the Tantabus caused nightmares to more and more ponies. It eventually became strong enough to the point where it could manifest itself in reality. Her worst fear was the Tantabus becoming the next Nightmare Moon and causing eternal night and suffering throughout all of Equestria.

The one point that should be emphasized is that Celestia and Luna are basically gods, with great power over their respective domains.

The Tantabus is a manifestation from her subconscious as it took the shape of Nightmare Moon.  Luna doesn't want to become Nightmare Moon again but still carries the guilt as well as the fear of the possibility that she might make the same mistake again of becoming Nightmare Moon. So she punishes herself with nightmares night after night. So the Tantabus escaping into the real world isn't because the dream world is a dimension but rather Luna's own darker powers. If you recall back in the Season 1 premiere, Nightmare Moon's powers include some reality-bending, like the Shadowbolts, although not to the same extent as Discord. Nightmare Moon could split herself into three Shadowbolts that acted like real ponies. Based on that as well as the fact that the Tantabus is a part of Luna, it wouldn't be too far-fetched that it could manifest itself into reality.

The Tantabus was only stopped once Luna truly accepted that she wasn't the same as she was in the past and that she wouldn't make the same mistake of becoming Nightmare Moon. Once she forgave herself, the Tantabus became docile and returned to Luna.

The connection that was shown in the dream world is to illustrate that she is exerting all of her strength to maintain the shared dream, that she can't do anything else but stand there. In the mane 6's shared dream, it didn't show that because she still had strength to interact in the shared dream. Not that big of a contradiction.


For those who kept up, my theory is that the white streams from lunas horn is how she connects to ponies whos minds are in the dream dimension, and only in a shared dream do they show up. if the dream isn't shared, in the dream there is no lines. ABOUT THE DREAM DIMENSION<br>Yes, all ponies' minds are transported to a pocket dimension that is created when comatose. the mind leaves some of itself behind, as to find its way back to the right pony. the part of mentality left behind is most often the knowledge that the dreamer IS comatose. if this is learn't within a dream, than all memory of the dream is removed, explaining mostly forgetting dreams. Luna has the ability to sift through the dreams\pocket dimensions and view them from the outside. the other bit of mind residue left behind when sleeping alerts the comatose majority when there has been an audio\physical disturbance and the louder the sound or harder the touch, the stronger the signal. If the signal is strong enough, it instantly retrieves the mind. because of the abrupt dimension deletion, the dream doesn't  have time to delete itself, therefore drifting away into Princess Luna's magic inter-reality pocket that cant much be called a dimension. When this happens, Luna has to personally delete them to keep the reality permanent dimension from being altered. Not even Celestia knows what could happen if a dream escaped. I feel like i'm forgetting something. Please reply if there's any plot holes in this, or if there's any questions

For those who kept up, my theory is that the white streams from lunas horn is how she connects to ponies whos minds are in the dream dimension, and only in a shared dream do they show up. if the dream isn't shared, in the dream there is no lines. ABOUT THE DREAM DIMENSION
Yes, all ponies' minds are transported to a pocket dimension that is created when comatose. the mind leaves some of itself behind, as to find its way back to the right pony. the part of mentality left behind is most often the knowledge that the dreamer IS comatose. if this is learn't within a dream, than all memory of the dream is removed, explaining mostly forgetting dreams. Luna has the ability to sift through the dreams\pocket dimensions and view them from the outside. the other bit of mind residue left behind when sleeping alerts the comatose majority when there has been an audio\physical disturbance and the louder the sound or harder the touch, the stronger the signal. If the signal is strong enough, it instantly retrieves the mind. because of the abrupt dimension deletion, the dream doesn't  have time to delete itself, therefore drifting away into Princess Luna's magic inter-reality pocket that cant much be called a dimension. When this happens, Luna has to personally delete them to keep the reality permanent dimension from being altered. Not even Celestia knows what could happen if a dream escaped. I feel like i'm forgetting something. Please reply if there's any plot holes in this, or if there's any questions


I think your right about dreams being in a different dimension. However if dreams had a dimension to themselves wouldn't we see other people's dreams? My theory is that all dreams have thier own dimensions. Each dimension being an extent of the person's mind and in a way their body. If Luna was able to connect all the dreams in Ponyvill she will have had to know everypony in Ponyvill and have gone inside each of their dreams. The way Luna was in the dream inside the sphere of light makes me think that she may have teleported into the dream from the real world. Who knows death may work the same way.


To expand on your example of computers connected to each other via the internet, I believe the glowing horn tethers form the equivalent to a Local Area Network. That is how should would be able to sculpt so many dreams at once and sense them all simultaneously.

Normally, she would use the hall of doors in her dreamscape plane to peak into various dreams without the need of the tether, as she couldn't possibly tether the entirety of Equestria every night if doing so to one small town was so difficult.

I think she created the shared dream to place some limitations on Tantebus. You'll notice that everyone in town was a dreamer rather than someone being dreamed about... nobody was actually dreaming of someone who should not have been in PonyVille. They could do amazing things, but they were limited to altering themselves rather than bringing new ponies into the dream.


I would have to say it happens in a different dimension. Once I had a shared dream with my friend in a totally different state. BUT..... I would have to say it's also all in our minds, Imagination is an example. My sister says our imagination is awake dreams, kinda like day dreams, easy way to connect. Our imagination is a day dream. So I can be on both sides. All just me.


Dreams are indeed in or are a different dimension. I have been keeping track of my dreams, and I realize that I happen to know everything that is happening, or happened, and sometimes what will happen. There is a reason for that.

Imagine yourself being given the power to create anything you want by God (pretty much becoming a minor deity). You decide to create a world of your own, with all kinds of creatures and plants and so on. Then, you decide that, since you remember how to live like a mortal, you give yourself a mortal body and enter that world as one of the normal inhabitants and experience life there for yourself.

I believe there is a dimension for dreams, and the dreams you have are on a world that you've made.


This isn't exactly mind-boggling a concept, or anything new in fiction land. In Warhammer 40,000, we have the Warp/Immaterium, a parallel dimension of psychic energy overlapping reality where all sentient life's emotions, dreams and thoughts flow into, and is the source of all of the setting's psychic powers and the primary means of faster-than-light travel. Of course, the unfortunate implications of having all of our subconsciousness - including all of our darkest impulses and desires - gathering in one place where they could coagulate and become reality is explored, as the Warp is also the realm of all of humankind's feelings of hatred, lust, despair and ambition are made manifest as malicious psychic entities, called daemons, which regularly invade physical reality from warp rifts to cause havoc and ruin.

And that's not the only example. There's also Alice in Wonderland, the Dream Land from Cthulhu Mythos, the Astral Realms from Mage: The Awakening, Dal Quor from D&D Eberron, etc. Essentially, the idea has existed as long as mankind had consciously or unconsciously wished for dreams to become reality.

In short, a dimension in MLP FIM where all of ponies' dreams are real, and could be accessed from both ways, is nothing really new or weird.


I think dreams happen in another dimension. The dimension in which the ponies live, is constricting. It only alows for limited things to happen. When ponies dream, their consciousness travels to the "dream" dimension. That dimension alows for more to happen. Think of it as the first dimension, second dimension, third dimension, fourth dimension, and so on. Each is less constricting than the last. Perhaps it's possible for your consciousness to travel between them. It's all just theory, but think about it.


What would happen if something other than the tantabus went through the crack between the real world and the dream world?
Maybe the dream version of the pony would take on a life of its own while the real pony is awake or maybe the real pony would fall into a coma to sustain the form of the living dream.
What do you think?


That would make so much sense! After all, the area with all the doors between random dreams had the same ethereal background as when twi was alicornified!


I think it was able to get into the real world because it was gathering magic from the negative emotions of nightmares. Once it had enough magic to sustain a physical form, all it needed to do was create a way out of the mass of minds.