Dreams are like Pinkie Pie, just dont question them

I refuse to not question all I experience. For that is the seed that when sown sprouts ignorance. Of course a rational thought process wouldn't get you anywhere, but thinking along with an irrational thing such as a dream, you may be able to get a foothold on what's happening. That's how Lucid Dreams are made. Developing a subconscious irrational thought process to tell you when you are dreaming in the first place. Like writing up a computer program for a game, and then learning to play it in the first place would be akin to the conscious mind. You don't just sputter out nonsense like some in the comments are and say it makes sense because it's so ignorant one can't grasp it enough to question it at all. You should round out the edges with these things. Make sure that it makes sense in some frame of reference for logical reasons. Not just cuz it sounds right.

@Minecraftman361- Home to all Creepers - I woke up my dad in the other room laughing XD

True, Once in a dream I asked one question to a stranger. "Is this a dream"? She didn't answer. -_-

@Minecraftman361- Home to all Creepers - so true.

This is the best thing , i read all week.


Well, Luna does refer to it as the “realm” of dreams or sleep, so I’d assume the dream world is its own separate dimension that is given form by imagination.


K so here is my theory: Dreams ARE in another dimension but not in the traditional sort of way. Think of it more like the "Fullmetal Alchemist (2003)" theory. Each person is connected to that alternate universe because there is a gate within them. In FMA, they open that gate at will to do alchemy. In this case however, the gate is opened subconsciously while asleep. Each pony has their own "room" or section of this dimension where their dreams reside. Princess Luna has the ability to pass through the gate at will while other ponies can't. She can even walk in the realm between dreams and manipulate them slightly. I assume that the reason Luna's horn doesn't glow is because a certain amount of magic is needed to hop between dreams and connect them but while talking to the Crusaders, Luna brought them out of their personal sections of the dream dimension into a different one (I think. It's been a while since I watched the episode).

Nana Asmah this is a very plausible theory! And you’re right; in that episode Luna had gathered the crusaders into one area within the dream realm separate from all their individual ones, which is probably how they remembered what happened. Which, if you think about it, is probably what she did in the Do Princesses Dream of Magical Sheep episode, since everybody in ponyville remembered the dream when they woke up. The only difference I think there was between the two is something Brony mentioned: Luna’s horn. And I think the reason why Luna was physically in the dream realm instead of sending her dream self there was because it would require her very real magic from the waking world to prevent whatever the thing was called from breaking out of the dream world.


Time to quote Dumbledore, `Of course it is happening in your head, but why should that mean it is not real?´

gimme more i need more potterheads like meh

Dumbledore’s quotes are the best Potter head in the house

Jay A mhm. I’ll maybe watch it when I’m not so busy rn

ッ!ShinShin! Overall it is a good show, watch it and you’ll know what I mean

ッ!ShinShin! I have seen it, I am now scarred.

ッ!ShinShin! You should watch it! (Warning: it has some pixelated-yeah,I don’t wanna go back noooooooooo!)

Jay A oh cool! I don’t watch total drama so I don’t know that XD

ッ!ShinShin! Fun fact: (k u may not know this show, but I do not care Lol) so the character Dawn from Total Drama’s design was based off of Luna Lovegood :3

Siri's Personal Assistant Say “uUwuUuUuU” again....

R.I.P Dumbledor... that was one sad scene :c

@natty j I think the elder wand or a Phoenix

@shed aggred, Dumbledores cutie mark would be quotes 😂


I think the real Luna only travels in a dream dimension where she can see everyone's dream and can go inside anyone's dream.<br>So when anyone gets a nightmare  she gets to know in that dream dimension

I think the real Luna only travels in a dream dimension where she can see everyone's dream and can go inside anyone's dream.
So when anyone gets a nightmare  she gets to know in that dream dimension


@Mars Bars Cassidy I completely forgot about this comment until I got a notif today, but hopefully you'll be happy to know that I read Homestuck last year and quite enjoyed it

@GamerragE khloe nope im breaking it here


Don't hate me but YES IF COURSE THE BLOODY DREAM WORLD IS REAL

@Mysterious Magic I mean u also said u don’t know so I’m not sure, but I’m just going along with it either way since either people were asking if their dreams were true if this comment was the case

So me getting stabbed on the back, attacked by a dinosaur (dreamt that when I was like 2), jumped off a cliff, ran away from my dad because he drank something, and just situations I was terrified of was real

idk if we are talking about mlp or irl. because this is on a mlp video

if dreams are real then that means the demons that jump scared me in my dreams like nothing ever before IS REAL. Also the only dreams I’ve had are bad, so I guess they’re just nightmares. Rarely get them though, like once every 6 months

Wait so bakugou sitting on a throne with a suit with firering flames surrounding him with a smirk on his face

If the dream world is real, all other ppl in my dreams(that I remember) would be evil, or confused/traumatized ._.

Since the dream worlds real i guess i meet the damelio sisters everyday

If the dream world is real I've met harry styles three times


I believe that our dreams are in a different dimension, not just the ponies because dreams sometimes mean something, so this would explain them being in a different dimension.

Meow Hiss so dose that mean the mlp universe is real since I went to ponyvill in a dream

That's what I was thinking that everyone's dreams are in a dream dimension . That's why some dreams feel so real because they are actually happening just in another demention


0:23

"Boy, do I have one heck of a theory!"

"FRIIIIIENDS!"

😅

I'll go back under my bedsheets now.

I READ THIS COMMENT WHEN IT HAPPENED WHAT LOL


I like the idea that their minds access an alternate dimension where they have a metaphysical body that they control, (it opens up a whole new set of horror fics to write) but yeah that thing with Luna's magic really does throw a wrench into the equation. I like how once again you provide enough evidence for the idea that it's difficult to deny, and yet, never confirm it. Theories are meant to be inconclusive after all.


honestly, i would think that the poney would dream, but when they awake the dimension in which they have created (by sleeping) goes away, like dissapears, and Luna can travel through demension (also , luna must cast some sort of spell o. the poney she is (u know,going into the dream) so that they cant awake, and the being that threatened to go into the real world was subseconsely replacing  luna because she herself had never physically been in the dream dimention,but only her version of herself as a dream


03:33
Omg i got a theory!
The bubble seperates Luna from the dream dimention, so it's possible that she moved the dimention in the middle of the ponyville.


Honestly, I like to believe that your theory about the dream realm being a different dimension is true, and i do believe that, like you stated in the video, it would explain your theory on almost all accounts. I Think That If Dream Beings Can Access The Real World, And real beings can gain access to the dream world, perhaps that the real worlds Luna used Part of the remaining strength she had to also connect dream Luna with the citizens of ponyville, sorry about the long comment, i just love making long comments on things like theories! I'll try to make more explanatory comments in the future!


I imagine it happens in both their minds and the dream dimension at the same time. The ponies project their thoughts into the dream world.


And here we are again, getting to the same question...

"Have you ever had a dream, Neo, that you were so sure was real? What if you were unable to wake from that dream? How would you know the difference between the dream world and the real world?"


A dream dimension certainly isn't out of the question. It's a very real possibility and does explain a lot about Luna's power. The idea that she would need the white tendrils to make a physical connection to the other ponies would also explain why she never came back in the dreams of ponies while she was banished on the moon.


1:54 I'm only 11 and I get that reference. I was really surprised when I learned that almost nobody my age had ever seen that movie :p it's a little confusing but I loved it <3

There’s a movie on Netflix now lol about the NEW heroes. Go watch it lel

@UCiXvo2jsgzrGPwb5sHqHo9A I know how u feel😭😭

@Alison H I was incredibly stupid when I wrote this comment. Do NOT advertise your age, people on the internet are not your friends and it's DANGEROUS. if you learn anything on the internet, learn not to trust people. You do not know them.

Hey, you’re 14-15 now, whats teenage life like huh?😀😀

I learned of it from the new (well not so new now) Netflix movie We Can Be Heroes

@SakyoSekai I was very dumb when I was young

SakyoSekai I know, they are just giving information away for strangers. Really smart moves

Yeah when I asked everybody in my class if they have watched Alice in Wonderland and only 2 of them watched it and I am also 11, I will turn 12 in a couple of months.

Sunny Lapis I saw that movie when I was eight

Sunny Lapis same I'm 11 and I'm surprised that I've seen the movie my self

tfw a bunch of literal fetuses mention their ages for no reason whatsoever

Sunny Lapis I’m 12 and I don’t get it either.

Sunny Lapis I’m your age and I seen this movie!

I'm younger than you and I've watched that movie Least 20 times

Sunny Lapis

I get it...

I'm not your age but, I love Sharkboy and Lavagirl.

Sunny Lapis UGH I hate that movie! very bad green screen. and yes I saw that when I was like 10 and now I'm 12

Rhi K AJ I'm almost ten and its STILL my childhood!

Are you kidding? I'm almost 12 and that movie was my childhood. XD lol!

Sunny Lapis OMG I LOVE shark boy and lava girl!

Sunny Lapis im a year older and ive seen that movie too


There may be some hint towards dreams existing in another dimension in at least the MLP:FiM multiverse, and in at least supplementary material. Specifically in the comics (inb4 someone says "the comics aren't canon"), which establishes creatures called the "Nyx" as the guardians of dreams before Luna was around. They appear to be in charge of places called "dreamscapes" which connect everypony's dreams. In one of the stories in the FIENDship is Magic comics, Nightmare Moon seeks to use these "dreamscapes" in efforts to turn everypony against Celestia, or, failing that, to convince Celestia to reduce her sentence significantly.

Just thought I'd leave this piece of input here.


I have a less confusing theory. First i want to talk about the dream stream wire things. In the video, you mention that in every dream, luna never has her server cables extending from her horn. You then mention that if we saw the real pony while luna was in their dream, they would have the wire things connecting to their forehead. I think that luna only needs those cables when she creates a shared dream, but that she used them the first time in do Princesses dream of magic sheep so she could more quickly move between the mane 6 dreams. As for the dream dimension theory, i agree with that, but i think that real luna enters this dimension and then real her enters the dreams.  As for the fact that real luna was in the real world when doing the connection thing, i think that was her consciousness in the dream that time.  So a representation of luna. And for the last bit of my theory, the shared dream, lunas dream server cables could be seen because she was literally holding the dream together. If you look closely, you can see lines criscrossing the dreamscape. In my theory, that is where the dreams being held together.  Let me know what you think please. P.S.   sorry for the bulk comment


Well, it could be that if Luna is only visiting one pony, they don't have the string connected to them. The only reason we can see the strings coming from Luna's horn in "Do princesses dream or magic sheep?" is because there is that bubble around her. It separates physical Luna and the dream dimension. In Bloom and gloom though, the reason Luna doesn't have those strings connected to the CMC is because they are in the dream dimension. Unlike in the real dimension, the ponies in the dream dimension aren't actually there. They're just a figure of the real pony.


I think both, it's a world they make and help thrive through dreams in their heads.


I think the ponys having magic of their own can access a 2 way passage to and from this dimension that exists in the conscious of the pony of equestria  and Luna having this her special talent is both the admin and server(dream Luna as the admin controlling the realm and real Luna as the physical server which the shared dreams are connected) and the tantibus lives in it like a virus. I give you my theory. PLEASE see this and build off it 😃


Could it be possible that the "alternate dimension" and "within your head" theories could be combined? As in "withing every pony's head lies another dimension" (one were the individual could enter or any other ponies via Luna's magic)?

+princessbinas That's what I just commented basicly. Only I commented that the dreams are just pocket universes inside the minds of ponies and controlled by them.

@***** i think celestia is about 35 thousand years old and luna is about 32 thousand

@Ashley Hayward<br>Yeah. As for the video, I may or may not. It will be a very rare thing since it would be technically be my second theory video and I am not good at them yet. I did make one for the third Equestria Girls movie though.

@Ashley Hayward
Yeah. As for the video, I may or may not. It will be a very rare thing since it would be technically be my second theory video and I am not good at them yet. I did make one for the third Equestria Girls movie though.

@princessbinas good! I think that he should do a video on it

WOW! That's a amazing theroy!I actually believe that!try to find him in the comments thouh,and reply to him,so he will get it in his notifications.


Remember that u mentioned Scootaloo in the dream should have had a wire if we saw her in the real world?Well,those ponies that bowed down were in a dream.Real Luna was in a dimension bubble from the real world.About the wires,they entered the real world through a portal and connected with the real ponies.That explains why we didn't see the wires from Luna connect to the ponies in the dream.Don't trust me,it's just a theory.


Well, in ancient times people DID believe dreams happen in another world. Which is also the case for most fantasy and magic-involving stories.


This is very similar to what happens in the game series "Dragon Age". In the game, it is believed by the characters that when a person dreams or dies, their soul passes though a place called "The Fade".

It is the spirits and demons in the fade which shape the environment based on what they see through the eyes of a person they posses, they can also be summoned by mages. Mages/Sorcerers in the game can maintain consciousness, and explore the fade freely (like Luna).

That's my understanding at least, good video, well thought out theory.


I love your theories on the my little pony universe. They are very interesting amd really make you think.


i can go into DEEP detail about the 'dream realm'. it dose not exist in a solid realm. it is instead a subconscious area of  existence where anyone can do anything, if they will it.
as well often dreams link lots of things (and people) together. this include past, current and future timelines. and alternate timelines as well. the dream realm is directly connected to everyone, and if enough people believe in the same thing from a dream, it has a chance of exiting the dream realm in another form.

the dream realm is more than just that tho. you have all knowledge to EVER exist in any time of your dimensions history, and future.(thus the feeling of having done something before) as will as that of other realms as well. making it the most knowledgeable place to ever 'exist'. think of it as a collection of memorys that transcend time and space.
this is based off knowledge of the dream realm of the dream realm in the human world.
most likely the same details are in mlp as well.

now, as for lunas ability. it can pull her mind into the dreams and allow her to directly alter that area of existence, or even bring a solid (or semitransparent) copy of herself into a dream. even allowing her to draw dreams together to form a dream 'hive' or collective dream. the dream realm is HER domain. she rules it, but is controlled by it at the same time.

i could have put a ton more details in this. but alas, its hard to put into words the facts about dreams.

(i have a bit of a gift with dreams. i see things in my dreams that turn up all over the solid realms of reality. however, i have never seen a lot of the things in my dreams with my own eyes. and i remember everything that happens in my dreams. i could walk down new york city in my dream and see a street  down to the addresses on the doors. and remember it perfectly. go to new york and find that location. with not one thing out of place, even tho i had never been there. thus i have knowledge of the dream realm most would not remember. i even spoke dead languages in one dream, linking the past knowledge to the present. so as i said: its hard to fully explain the dream realm because no words exist to detail it all...
i did what i could to explain it, but could not find all the words to put it all down )
hope this helps


What I think is that there are two types of dreams, or the white thing connecting to Lucas horn is different too.<br>In bloom and gloom, Luna had to access the mind. However when the white thing was there, this happened in the dream world. The bubble was used because when she had to connect everyone to the dream realm, there for had no energy to fight.

What I think is that there are two types of dreams, or the white thing connecting to Lucas horn is different too.
In bloom and gloom, Luna had to access the mind. However when the white thing was there, this happened in the dream world. The bubble was used because when she had to connect everyone to the dream realm, there for had no energy to fight.


I mean, the hallway with the doors reminds me of the dream dimension from Marvel Comic, as portrayed in the episode "Doctor Strange" in season 2 of Ultimate Spiderman. I think it's pretty easy to believe that it's another dimension just based on that ^^


I have my own theory on alternate dimensions, but I'll water it down to dreams so all you non-5.25 Bil. Year Old Mortals can keep up. All dreams are real, separate dimensions that our consciousness intrudes on when we dream, and our ability to lucid dream would come from the fact that while we dream, our consciousness is not anchored to our bodies, but tied to the flow of the dimension itself, which is also how we can occasionally see ourselves in 3rd person in dreams. And for Luna having the Dream Cables in the dream, that must be because every other time she entered a dream, she had her focus split between what she was doing in the real world and in the dream world, so with a dream that huge, doing the same thing in both worlds at the same time would allow her to focus more on maintaining the shared dream. It'd be like running a Minecraft Server: It'll work better if you're not also trying to watch Youtube on the same computer. Doing just 1 thing allows you to put more effort into that 1 thing.


Here's my theory :by what we've seen about the dream realm IT IS a deminsion and every time a pony goes to sleep it becomes a bubble In there (as we see in season 9 when starlight swaps celestia and Luna's cutie marks) this lets luna see who's in a nightmare and as we see in the same episode nopony other than luna can access them so her journey in there looks like this :
She opens a portal to the dream realm and walks through ,as the dreams revol around her she sees which one of them has a nightmare and creates a portal to enter it and kills the creature causing the nightmare talks to the pony and leaves the dream
Which means that there's no dream luna real luna does all the work I think that those wires are only there when she needs to create a shared dream


Luna may be an INTP. Our brains (the intps) function a lot like computers, and this allows us to emulate and simulate things that would be considered impossible for a normal brain.


I think it comes from there heads because if it were another dimension then Luna would only need to use her power to let every one inter then she could rest but since she kept using her power I think it was all in there heads and she was just the glue holding it together


Maybe the reason Luna was showing up in the Dream World/Dimension is because she made a projection of herself? If she can "walk" through dreams, like she did in past dream-episodes, it's likely that she can create a projection of her living self that allows her to interfere with the dream.


They're real in the dream world in which you dream them but when you wake up you leave the dream world and go back to reality.

Who understands what I said? I do.

Hi I am going home now I’m ready for a good day bye. Lol


Well my theorie is that it means astral travel. If you enter your astral body, it works like ghosts. If the nightmares were ghosts, then ghosts can get into the real world, IF the door of the afterlife has been opened, so that they can enter the real world. Luna can enter in dreams. If you are astral traveling, you can also see into others dreams. If you try to get into several ponys dreams, it takes alot of power and self control.

You should better google it if it help.


Perhaps the dream world is it's own dimension in the MLP universe as well as our own.  Bare with me on this.  While some might say that the vivid dreams we remember clearly are only lucid dreams, who's to say that there isn't more to it than that.  Think about it, how many times have you gotten physically injured in your dreams only to wake up with cuts, bruises, and other injuries in the exact same locations upon waking up the next day when you know for certain that you didn't have those injuries and bruises when you went to bed?  It's possible that the MLP universe is part of the dream world for us bronies and pegasisters, which means that it's possible that the overall connected dream universe is a real dimension both in our reality and in MLP.


WHY DID YOU REMIND ME OF SHARK BOY AND LAVA GIRL IT BRINGS BACK MEMORYS ( btw thanks i miss that show i love shark boy ............ wait what)

@Sawtooth Waves I watched sharkboy and lavagirl before. And spy kids

Yesssss I thought nobody was going to say this— I miss that show as well ಥ‿ಥ

If u see this in 2021 watch we can be heroes on Netflix if u havent. ( spoiler shark boy and lava girl are married and have a daughter!)

@Sawtooth Waves plus? Why did you use a plus?

Seriously sawtooth waves if that's even your real name 🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐🧐

@Sawtooth Waves Hi I love  your  video 😇😙😘😚😍❤❤💖💖💗💗💘💝

Yeah it is a old movie and I am not even old enough to watch pg13 movies and I watched it I was about six

I loved that movie. Too bad I can't find it anymore.

I LOVE SHARK BOY AND LAVA GIRL TOO OMG YOUR THE FIRST PERSON I MET THAT LIKES IT

I love that movie<br>Lava girl is my favorite

I love that movie
Lava girl is my favorite

Luna Gaming I LOVE SHARK BOY AND LAVA GIRL, ITS MY FAV MOVIE

I have watched a little bit.. I know the boy got raised by Sharks when he got separated from his Dad.

That’s all

Luna Gaming its ok I liked dipper from gravity falls

Actually, WHY'D YOU MENTION THE THE SOCK PUPPET DIMENSION IT BRINGS BACK MEMORIES ( <b>AND BAD MEMORIES AT THAT</b> )

Actually, WHY'D YOU MENTION THE THE SOCK PUPPET DIMENSION IT BRINGS BACK MEMORIES ( *AND BAD MEMORIES AT THAT* )

The Brony Notion
Nah I like shark boy and lava girl better
Wait
The topic on the video was almost the same topic on the movie..... FEELING A CONNECTION HERE!!!!

Morgan Wilson  I remember, it was so long ago

Did u know there is a YouTube channel called 09SharkBoy

Luna Gaming Do you mean lava boy and water girl? that game?

Luna Gaming I also like that movie I wish thane was apart two

oh my god i love that movie even though when i first saw it to 2015 it brouht memories like mr.electeric and lava girl when i saw it in 2015 i told my mom that i remember this

♡ 𝒶 𝓁 𝒷 𝑒 𝒹 𝑜 ♡

+The Brony Notion and silly and that's why I love your vids

We are the only three that get this reference. RIP Sharkboy & Lavagirl  (I only watched the movie but I was like 6. Still tho, nice reference X3

+Luna Gaming Almost as dope as Spy Kids.


Okay, here's my theory. The dream world IS inside the phone's heads, but shared dreams of even dreams in general create small dimensions which are just a rip in the real worls. Thus magic of the tantapus would be able to pull out of that rip created out of pure magic, and thus able to access the real world.


SHARKBOY AND LAVAGIRL. HOLY CRAP I FREAKING LOVED THAT MOVIE.

AND PRINCESS BRIDE. YOU, SIR, ARE ON A ROLL.

ahem Dreams are actually our subconscious tapping into our lives in another reality; we all live multiple lives, but only when we're sleeping.

SHARKBOY AND LAVAGIRL. HOLY CRAP I FREAKING LOVED THAT MOVIE.

AND PRINCESS BRIDE. YOU, SIR, ARE ON A ROLL.

*ahem* Dreams are actually our subconscious tapping into our lives in another reality; we all live multiple lives, but only when we're sleeping.


I think the white strings didn't connect to the Ponies' foreheads in the shared dream because Luna was physical, but the other ponies were the dream versions of themself.


I think you're right about physical Luna being in the dream dimension but remember, those are dream ponies, meaning the physical body of those ponies are in the physical world and would have the white stream connected to their physical foreheads. You touched this on the beginning of the video but forgot it at the end.<br>XD

I think you're right about physical Luna being in the dream dimension but remember, those are dream ponies, meaning the physical body of those ponies are in the physical world and would have the white stream connected to their physical foreheads. You touched this on the beginning of the video but forgot it at the end.
XD


After reading Nana Asmah's comment, I remembered one thing that has always disturbed me a bit. I was asleep a couple years ago and I had a crazy vision of the future. There was this voice... and it was Princess Luna herself!
I know what you are all thinking: This can't be real, this is just another dream people have everyday. Actually, It was more than that. There was an earthquake that happened in 2019 that went along the west coast. And in the quaking area was a little bit of my hometown. SOMEHOW Luna spoke to me (and she showed herself) and said it was gonna happen. And it happened!
On top of that, My parents were having issues with each other, and I was warned that something terrible was going to happen, and it did! BTW I wonder if mlp exists now. It was really weird


I use three criteria to define "real".
1. Shared experience.  Check.  Ponies sharing a dream experience the same things.

2. Interactive.  Check.  Ponies interact with the dream world environment.
3. Of consequence.  Check.  Everyone was fighting because what happened in that shared dream mattered.
So yes, even if the world was virtual, it was also very real.


Well, I think that when Luna returned from the moon, she used her magic to create the dream dimension, so that she never gets jealous of Celestia again and meets every pony every night.


My theory: it happens in a ponies head with dreams thy can't control but when Luna is there they can mindfully snap into sense or something. Luna is controlling all minds to think of a dream but she is too busy to actually go in the dream and instead remains in her bubble


Definitely another dimension, on my thought, another one of those wirey things just connects us to that dimension that the dream scape has planned on brining us to. Also, my brain hurts from thinking


It makes sense to me. Luna goes to some other dimension, (where twilght was turned into an alicorn?) and visits dreams. When the shadow thing got more power, and since she made it, she had to pull a part of herself into the dream, but larger then normal, explaining why her physical


i think that indeed there is a dream dimension. we each have our personal dimension though so we don't have the same dream as everyone else. in these dimensions the laws of physics can be broken so it must also be another world. once though my friend and i had the exact same dream plot line (we know this because we both said some of the details and all where correct) so i guess we also get  a starter place and memories in a dream but we make it how it is. sometimes though u can get the same starter dream with someone else.


This is great, but I have an idea. Ponies are magical creatures, and the dream monster has access to the shared magic of all of pony vale. Maybe that much energy is enough to create it in the real world?


i think the cause of one measly pony can summon the dimension, causing the ability of ponies being able to visit dreams. the more dreams that are happening the more doors appear in the dimension. The rest you technically said.


I only saw it as a metaphoric thing, like... if you let your nightmares overwhelming you, they might affect your real life, and then people around you, and so on...<br>Anyway I like the (confusing) idea you put forward

I only saw it as a metaphoric thing, like... if you let your nightmares overwhelming you, they might affect your real life, and then people around you, and so on...
Anyway I like the (confusing) idea you put forward


The dream world and the world where Twilight was turned into (ascended into being) and alicorn look a lot alike don't they?  Would that not at least imply that they might well be the same and therefore just as Is suggested? An alternate dimension defined, not by the rules of physics and magic but by thoughts?


still to this day one of my favorite episodes


I realize this video is two years old and there are no recent comments... but I just have to say that I disagree with you, Notion. The Tantabus only threatens the real world because it is a creation of Princess Luna and her Alicorn Magic. She created this super powerful magic beast as a way to punish herself for what she had done. The nightmare of a regular pony is not as powerful, nor does it have sentience. So Scootaloo's Headless Horse is just something she dreamed up. It's only a simple image and doesn't have magic or sentience, therefore it cannot threaten the real world.


Another universe/dimension, how I see things is that anything that you imagine is a dream, and when that idea dies, the world where that dream exists irl dies with it


My mind is just turning so much!!!!

I think that it is for sure a entire different dimension, and that you got everything spot on!!!

Sadly, I'm such a geeky nerd that I totally kept up!xD

Can't wait till your next video!!!<3

DOCTOR WHO!!!!!!030

My mind is just turning so much!!!!

I think that it is for sure a entire different dimension, and that you got everything _spot on!!!_

Sadly, I'm such a geeky nerd that I totally kept up!xD

Can't wait till your next video!!!<3

*-DOCTOR WHO!!!!!!030-*


It's because, Luna can easily hold like 3 dreams and have dream Luna be in it but since it was like 100 dreams Luna will have no choice but to go into the real world.


My theory; based off many other plots in many others series and just pure logic a universe has all the dimensions and worlds in it. My theory is when anyone dreams they travel universes which means the dream world should be reassured as a dream universe where everypony’s dream is a dimension but as you may know all dimensions, worlds, universes and so on are all connected. By ripping a tear in the dream universe it’s like every connection petween universes and dimensions are train rides, so by going through that tear you are riding the connections between universes which can get you to the real world.


Dreams are probably a primitive, subconscious form of magic, in my opinion. If you think about how a unicorn does magic, it seems most likely that they are willing their imagination into reality, and that would mean that dreams, to some extent, would probably be magical. If you're about to say that would mean only unicorns could dream, all ponies HAVE magic, because the mane six can all funnel their magical energy into the elements, aka magic wands of harmony, but only unicorns have magic wands perma-glued to their heads.


I think that the dream dimension can only be entered at an intuitive level, aka the mind is the portal.


I just had a thought. The mirror in EG goes to the human  dimension or world and it closes and  re opens every 30 moons. What if during the timeframe it is closed there are also certain moons that it opens to another dimension.


I think it just happens in the mind and when the giant galaxy pony escapes the dream world the pony would wake up in real life and now what happened let me explain let's say a pony is ready to go to sleep then when it goes to sleep and can't feel anything but it can see stuff from the Brian now it may be weird but yes think when you are sleeping you can't fell but you can see your dream in your head now when the giant Galaxy pony escapes the ponds will wake up and see the Galaxy pony in real life it is not in the dream world with the pony anymore so that's why Luna got those white strings from her head to make sure EVERYONE is connected well except for princess celestia I guess anyways that's what I think thanks for reading


In season 7 episode “a royal problem”, Celestia mentions a dream realm. It is on Luna’s to-do list for the night


i think what happened, was the dream beast opened a rift between the real world, and the dream world, where a non physical being could pass through unharmed and enter reality


I think of the Dream World more as a Realm IN the dimension, rather than a different dimension altogether.

Similar to in Dragon Age, the game. All dreams are within the Fade, which is where Magic comes from. Mages are able to physically enter the Fade, similar to Luna, but they are vulnerable to Demons because of this.

Similarly, Demons from the Fade are able to enter the normal world, but only via a Mortal/Mage. In MLP, all the ponies are mages, they all have magic, they all can physically enter the Fade, they all are vulnerable. However, Luna, being the caretaker of Dreams, stops Demons from exiting the Fade.

The Tantibus was one such Demon. Luna created the Tantibus using a Demon as a template. So, like any Demon, the Tantibus used ponies to pave its way to the real world. However, due to the fact that no pony has ever actually physically entered the Fade, the Tantibus cannot touch them. It can only, instead, draw power from them.

Now, with this in mind, we go back to Nightmare Moon. Luna is the caretaker of dreams as stated above, so she has physically entered the Fade before, which means she is vulnerable to demonic posession. However, she is strong, able to fight off demons not only from herself, but from the Fade itself.

But, at that time, she was weak. The Nightmare took advantage of this weakness and took Luna.

Butt that's just my theory.


I think whenever a pony is dreaming it creates a portal so that those dreams in their heads transfer to the dream dimension


What would you just said about other dimensions might be correct I like to think otherwise because when Luna uses her magic the streams from her horn connect to the ponies hat and vest size that they're connecting to the right what you had about the PC servers and all of that was really good until you started messing with other dimensions with that I actually think is that a dream is kind a like their own powers think of every pony having Easter in large power in their dream now if that dream had the power to escape or they had any idea that they could escape they probably would do it but apparently right now they think Luna is the only pony strong enough to going to dreams that actually. So can creams the area about the whole Celeste Dia and Luna war thing maybe actually there is one thing about the dimensions theory that might be correct the dreams that Luna makes it's almost like she's creating the server just like how his server is made of any mistake is in the server she has the only technology to fix that server otherwise she has the power to actually travel through that server sure that might be a fake character in that dream or server as we are still talking about it but even though Luna still has the power to create things and other people's dreams though this all seems like a lot of talking very far-fetched and makes a lot of sensewhen you're not speaking a lot


I think it is a mix of memory and magic. so here's my theory yes there is a dream dimension but it's not just that it is also  a place were luna (and anypony who knows how to get there) can access the memories of other ponies or maybe even make dreams and to get there luna will meditate anyways thats what i think in Magical Mystery Cure at the end that is were Twilight and Celestia are


5 years later

And I still wanna be a lucid dreamer

No idea how this relates to the video


So I was looking at this and the dream world makes a world of sense. However, where do you think it would be? We know of two other dimensions as of right now: the human world and Tartarus, if that even counts as a dimension. Is there a way this "dream world" connects to Tartarus in a deeper way? Possibly, could the thing threatening to enter the real world be a demon of Luna's past coming back to make Luna into nightmare moon once more as well?


Or maybe rather each time pony dreams he/she creates some new dream-world(or each time recreated the same dream world, in this case it's not important detail), which really is other world/dimension, into which pony's consciousness/mind is send. In normal circumstances such dream-world couldn't interract with reall world or other dream-worlds. And naturally after end of the dream pony's consciousness/mind is returning into its body.
Alicorn magic is something really special, and in case of Luna this magic is connected with dreams and can break previous rules. She can create something like interworld, a connection between dream worlds, her intervetion also always make pony remember its dream(just because she could use her power to do this and she always visit others dream to tell her/him something what she/he should know... yaeh now I write really obvious things), but still dreams are just dreams and in them there is just consciousness/mind of pony and sometimes her... but Tantabus which is created by her magic surely has part of her magic, so when he(i know why don't know its sex, but assume Tantabus if male, just for convenience) posses enough force he could use this power, inherited ahter his creator, to escape to the other world. And because he was a dream creature he could be not  awere of existance of the real world, the only "foothold"(I'm not sure if i use correct world i think about any information/data which he could use to find way to other worlds) was firstly mane six, so he could find only their dream-worlds. Then he probably could get some knowledge from his victims, and this way he get to know about real world. What more - as You said - Luna was fully transferred into world of this shared dream, which i think also was more difficult than just sendind there only her mind. So I think that barrier beetwen dream-words is weaker than barier between any dream-world and reall world, so he need to gain more power than is need to go from one dream-world to another, and this could be the reason why stopping him from this was aesier than stopping him from changing worlds.
To summarize - if the dream-worlds are real, but just more separated from real world Tantabus surely could go to the real world.


I think their dreams are from their heads but their dreams also make a dimension so i think its a mix of both


Request for a video: Why is there not already a Human Sunset Shimmer in the human world? (I requested this in the last video)

But she couldn't have been that old because fleur still goes to school

Yeah I just asked that before I saw ur comment

+StewiebossFTW  Well, my guess is that, ok, wall of text ahead.
my theory as to why there is no human Sunset Shimmer is heavily influenced by my theory as to why Sunset Shimmer is named similar to Twilight Sparkle in the first place. the reason is: she isnt. its the other way around.
when Celestia took Sunset under her wing, Twilight wasnt even born. and when her parents got her, they named her similar to Sunset, hoping that she will become Celestia´s student one day as well. then Sunset disappeared and Twilight´s parents were afraid this could also happen to Twilight, which would explain the weird looks on their faces during Twilight´s entrace exam. this would mean that human Sunset Shimmer is older than the mane six, so she doesnt go to school anymore. as to why pony Sunset got to CHS if that was the case, well, they took 3 random strangers without any means of identification whatsoever (btw they are about 1000 years old, so yeah).


all ponies have magic, right? maybe the dream world is a pocket dimension that is more easily manipulated by magic, so that even earth ponies (like big Mac) can change it subconsciously. Luna, with more powerful magic, would be able to conscientiously manipulate the dimension. and maybe she started opening that dimension at night so everyone would like the night more. and when she was banished it became a subconscious habit for ponies to enter it while sleeping.


We live in the multiverse there are different dimensions that contain different things to get to most of  you would have to travel through the space Time continuum but the dream dimension is accessible by slumber whereas the others would probably rip the fabric of space time


The connections are in the shared dream because Luna might prefer not to show the wires. In the shared dream having each wire visible would then make more sense as she would know if she lost anyone


This one time i when i went to sleep i had a dream where my two friends Damien and Frank came to my house to have a sleep over
And when i went to day camp the next day and told Frank "hey would't it be cool to have a sleep over?" and he said "yeah it sounds cool" I think on a friday i told me friend Damien about the dream and he said "i had the exact same dream and when i woke up he called Frank and told him that he had a dream where they where at my house and frank said he did to
So that is the time me and my friends had the same dream


I think its an actual place. Luna her self calls it "the realm of dreams"


3:56 I feel like Pinkie's brain would look all wibbly-wobbly and timey-wimey too. I mean, she can break the fourth wall, she makes references of our world, AND she referred to a past version of herself (3rd generation Pinkie Pie) in "Too Many Pinkies".


I think that it happens in the ponies heads.<br> he reason they could connect is because all ponies have some level of magic which lets them connect if Luna does the spell she did. Its kinda like as if ponies are the computers and Luna is the internet. If Luna imagines Tantabus will turn into a real thing in the dreams making him semi real. But Tantabus needs more magic to become actually real soo it will travel from pony to pony collecting magic. Tantabus is kinda like a virus it could travel from pony to pony except there is no one controlling it.

I think that it happens in the ponies heads.
 he reason they could connect is because all ponies have some level of magic which lets them connect if Luna does the spell she did. Its kinda like as if ponies are the computers and Luna is the internet. If Luna imagines Tantabus will turn into a real thing in the dreams making him semi real. But Tantabus needs more magic to become actually real soo it will travel from pony to pony collecting magic. Tantabus is kinda like a virus it could travel from pony to pony except there is no one controlling it.


Maybe Luna creates a gateway to the dream dimension with every string she attaches but normally, anypony's dream acts like a LAN connection, not an online connection and Luna can access these through getting the frequency(don't know what else to call it)to herself only(like if you were to create a private game and invite others to it,you may be online but not to everyone),allowing herself to access all the magical dimensions each independent pony has.


To be honest, the dream dimension sounds like a good theory.


i love ur theory about the server, but how is everypony able to see each other in their dreams while have the same actions while not knowing whats going on outside of the dream world. doesnt add up, does it? in order for luna to go through everyponies dream to make one big dream, they would have to all dream the same thing, sence everypony was in ponyvil.


The answer is simple. The big... blob thingy gains power from luna’s guilt. Once strong enough, it becomes too big for just a dream, so it tries to enter the real world.


Technically, there is a dream dimension seen in 'A Royal Problem', where on Luna's duties it says 'Enter the Dream Realm'.


I'll have a horse mask.
pukes
Ew it's the recurring gag again...

I'll have a horse mask.
*pukes*
Ew it's the recurring gag again...

And don't forget the princess bride reference @ 02:29! Yay

@dragonflyzMC Shark boy and lava girl! I GOT IT!

@dragonflyzMC shark boy and lava girl is an amazing movie! :DDD

I LOVE the movie that the reference came from!

@***** probably most people my age wouldnt get the reference though :P

@dragonflyzMC any one who didnt has no life


I didn't think other people came up with such "complicated" headcannon. XD I thought myself to be the only one.


If you can dream of anything, just dream of the tantabus never entering the real world. And dream of some anti-tantabus.


is it possible that since Luna can access the other ponies dreams that the second she does it turns their dreams into reality by connecting them to another dimension... in which case does it mean that no Ponies are in danger in their dreams if Luna doesn't access their dreams


The multiverse exists, right? What if every time a pony has a dream they enter a pocket dimension which they can control. Luna would then basically be connecting to the ponys to access said dimensions and gain some control over the dimensions. She could then progect herself into these dimensions, since she can't go there herself because she needs to maintain the connection. This means that in this episode Luna is weaving together the pocket dimensions of every pony in ponyville and controlling the dream so someone like pinkie wouldn't just bounce into a different dream. It makes sense that if she's concentrating this hard she wouldn't have time to notice details like the fact that her progection still showing the strings. (Man, I wish I could do this for essays).


Omg Sharkboy and Lavagirl! I loved that movie! Now I feel old for remembering that.

@Ray OF Happiness yay! It gives me a nostalgic feeling. A good one.

@supergamer985  OMG I FLIPPING LOVED THAT MOVIE


yes a dream dimension must exist even in real life, now i have a theory,  ok  know the bermuda triangle has nothing to do with MLP, but do you think maybe the bermuda triangle might be a portal to a rl dream dimension? think about it, when planes and ships go missing there, there is never even the slightest trace ever seen of them again and the reason no one ever makes an attempt to come back is because in the dream dimension their dreams are a reality and no matter what they don't wanna leave it behind, think about it, so yes i agree with brony notion here, yes a dream dimension may exist in real life too, when you think about it, it all makes perfect sense


You’re making this way more complicated than it has to be. When the ponies dream, their dreams happen in the dream world. So, their physical body is sleeping but they’re dreaming in the dream world. Which is a natural way to go to the dream world. But  when Luna dream walks, she doesn’t go to the dream world naturally. She uses magic. That’s why when she dream walks, she goes into the dream world WITH her physical body. And when she sleeps, she goes there just like the ponies do, without magic. And just like them, her physical body is sleeping and she is dreaming in the dream world.

And those white threads that magically comes out of her horn, is actually used to connect one’s dream with another’s. She doesn’t have to use them when she is dream walking. Cuz you can’t use them to dream walk, you can only use them to connect dreams together.


maybe the tantabus is sort of like a virus rather than something that exists only inside the mind and somehow infects other ponies you see in your dreams


I think it’s all about magic Luna is the princes of the night so it do make sense that she can  enter the dream world as a real pony and for individual there are doors to the pony dram in the dream realm it not confusing at all it’s magically logical


1:53 I KNOW WHO those 2 PEEPS I LOVE THE MOVIE !!!!!

<b>*Flashbacks to Lavagirl saving everyone*</b>

**Flashbacks to Lavagirl saving everyone**


To me I often appear in the same spot in my dreams so maybe they are other dimensions controlled by the pony so yeah😊.


I think the dreams aren't in our head but we see them like the real world


Dream is just our imagination, or sometimes,our fears or nightmares.Dream can be and something what will happen in the future.If we did something wrong in the past.


Actually I think because of dream sharing Luna is controlling the dream. Basically,she brings everyone to one's dream. That is why we can see the magic on her horn


>:D did i just see the all seeing eye for a split second?

>:D did i just see the all seeing eye for a split second?

Random Ending I’ve never seen someone that uses “:3”so many times it hurts my eyes. It’s Bill Cypher and Illuminati.

Random Ending it's not from gravity falls

Random Ending it's not from gravity falls

dude I managed to pause the video at the exact moment it happened

The Brony Notion you have so many videos with that in there.

Can you get ur OC changed PLSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

Can you get ur OC changed PLSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

did someone saw the tantivers turned a night mare moon shape ahh it could go in real Lunas body and turn her to night mare moon prudently and no one could stop her not even the elements of harmony if it got out haaaaaaa so should anyone be scared

i was just watching and my phone glitched right at that moment haha. i thought it was funny at first, but should i be scared now 😰

I saw it too and I was really freaked out.

I saw it too and I was really freaked out.

😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲 SAW IT!!!!!

😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲 SAW IT!!!!!

+SJHill Shrewsbury another one of his videos in the end he was a chanchling so be chaned into pic perfect what its called and said "I go"

THERE'S 104 COMMENTS AND I NOW HAVE 104 EMAILS ABOUT THIS ONE COMMENT..... DDDDDDDDD'XXXX

Ok! Its oviouse. Im sure EVERYONE saw the Thing for a split second. Can we stop with the comments? I have probably 389-500 emails about this one comment and Im sure the dude that made this video does too....

XXDDD I didnt read 100 comments and i dont want to! XD When I get free time I might LOL

Can you type when he put it up? I didn't see it.

Can you type when he put it up? I didn't see it.

Yeah, don't worry ur not going crazy we all saw it

Yeah, don't worry ur not going crazy we all saw it

+The Brony Notion I saw you put the Luminati sign there don't think you can get away with it

You saw it too I thought I was just seeing things. It was the illuminati sign

Yeah i was like OMG did i just saw that!? And than inwent searching for it but i could n't find it so i wachted that part six times trying to stop the video on the right part xD

+Foxeythefoxpirate AJ um... you wernt the only one to see the illuminati in the mind bogaling moment XD     :D

Gasp! Illmiati comfirmed ad I cold ear wid blowig sorry for spellig

+Roanna Ighekpe you have to go to your channel and look for your profile image and you can change it by pressing the pencil thing works if u are on computer

+Hollie Yue (Gardeveor'z Vids) i just made account how o u change name and put picture

+Queen Awsome XX I agree illuminati confirmed

+Queen Awsome XX I agree illuminati confirmed

+Sgt.brony   The illuminati used the all seeing eye of God.<br>Jerks

+Sgt.brony   The illuminati used the all seeing eye of God.
Jerks

@Waterdrops66 AJ Il- luna -nati confirmed!
HAHAHAHA

...I'm so bad at puns...

@Waterdrops66 AJ Il- *luna* -nati confirmed!
*HAHAHAHA*

*...I'm so bad at puns...*

oh so I'm not going crazy?.......yes!....lunate confirmed?!?!..maybe.... we don't know until it happiness

@Waterdrops66 AJ you saw that too RIGHT?

@Waterdrops66 AJ you saw that too RIGHT?

@DIANA Castine yep warriors refense confirmed.

@DIANA Castine yep warriors refense confirmed.

@XxtpgthepixelgamerxX you made a reference in a reference gg m8

@Waterdrops66 AJ illumnintait refrence confirmed. Also why in this?! great starclan why?! also AJ FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!!

@The Brony Notion(talks like patrick) I LOVE YOU! (talks normally now) That sounded stupid and creepy at the same time...

@Hailey McAllister YEEEEES!!! Gravity Falls reference!

@Hailey McAllister YEEEEES!!! Gravity Falls reference!

you'll see it if u rewatch it you can only see it for a second thou :P

:BASHOOOOOOO: EVERYBODY'S MIND IS BLOOOWN X3

:BASHOOOOOOO: EVERYBODY'S MIND IS BLOOOWN X3

@Hailey McAllister  Bubbles from the spongebob movie is the illuminati

@The Brony Notion STOP HURTING MY BRAIN IT ALREADY EXPLODED TWICE!

@Waterdrops66 AJ  ol illuminati iswatching u lol XD

@Waterdrops66 AJ  ol illuminati iswatching u lol XD

>"D we have all been converted welcome to the illuminati

>"D we have all been converted welcome to the illuminati

:P its not like the illuminati will kill us for making jokes millions of pp ldo it everyday :3

@Echo Luvs-Echoing Thats what I thought but was worried about commenting it

Aww, to bad :( give it a try if you want though, it's surprisingly fun :3

@Foxy Pirate Fox Lawlllllllll :3 do you play animaljam Foxy/Rarity? if you do Wanna be buddiessss? :3

I'm a girl :3 (Aka Lass) FOXY TELL ALL THE KIDS A STORY :3

Yarr that be right lass? or lad? o_o i'll just shut up now

@Foxy Pirate Fox  All hail Bill Chyphier! (The Illuminauti from Gravity Falls) :3!!


the strings somehow flow into the real world does that explain anything?


I believe that creature Luna created was residue from the shadow pony .
What is the shadow pony?
It's part of Nightmare Moon's dark magic which some it fled out of the way of Celestia's Magic.


now I agree with you for the pony side but what if its what's happening in the real world too?


I think that it's her magic that's keeping it all in check I think that she actually makes dreams and without her dreams but fade away and it would just be memories that pony is would have four dreams not their imagination


That’s literally the end of the video -_-


If dreaming happens in another dimension then how can a pony be in the same dimension as another pony without seeing that pony or being able to interact with them?

I think the dream dimension is a deme soon with other smaller separate dimensions in it


How about this? The dream world is a reflection through a prism of the real world? Breaking the prism or creating another to reflect the dream to cross the real world


It’s also really weird how people are not freaked out at all that the princess Luna is there, if celestia visited then they would bow and be all shocked- however when Luna just appears they don’t care and go on with their lives.. lmao


I know, this video was posted in 2015, and I'm writing this in 2017, but I was thinking, what if the ponies use the magic inside of them to travel to the Dream dimension? Just a thought.


did enyone see the illuminati? brony noton!was that a joke?


Tbh, i think that Luna is more powerful than Celestia, the whole reason that she managed to defeat Nightmare Moon she used the Elements of Harmony which is not actually her own magic, she combined it, I think if she actually used her own magic she couldn't have even defeat her, after all, the Elements of Harmony's magic is from the Tree of Harmony..


I think that pony's have a connection to the dream world but it only happens when they dream


Luna is like a brige from real to dream world.


I think the little strings are just how she makes joint dreams, but for individual dreams, she doesn’t need all that magic


Him:science and theories!<br>The real answer:Magic

Him:science and theories!
The real answer:Magic


If the Tantabus went out without Luna knowing, and comes to the real world, what would happen?


but if it is another dimension, then they could leave through the rips too! but what would happen then? would come out with the powers that they dreamed having? would there be 2 big Macs only one is an alicorn?


The tantebus wasn’t created in a dream. It was created by Luna and she put it in her dreams to punish herself . Technically it isn’t a part of the dream in the same way as other things because it’s a purposefully created form of magic. But that’s just my theory


I managed to capture an image of the Illuminati in the middle


Short form for my explanation : When   lunar enters dreams individualy she does not have white strings in the dream but un reality she has . But when lunar enters everyponys dreams all at once there are white strings in the dream world. ( sorry for the mistake this isn't short form )


It's actually both. I'm mean mlp is all about magic so it's not really surprising or complicated. There's over 5 dimensions another dimension doesn't make a different. The brain control the dream of ur own and the dimension OF dreams was the key to Luna to enter the dream, string was only for choosing which ponies dream she's gonna enter. In conclusion, it's dimension of dreams and the dreams is from the brain.


Dreams happen within a realm...... If something within one realm is powerful enough, it can go into a different realm. Realms happen within dimensions but can and do cross over into other dimensions. The brain can even remember everything and log it n other dreams and bring you back to it at any point of night or day even days or months later. Believe cuz it's happened to me alot. Your thoughts create a rift or affect in life. I've only had nightmares my entire life.... N I remember all of them. I found out that if I conquer a challenge in one I no longer have that dream...... It's as if I was sent to another dimension in the dream realm cuz it's the only possible way to do so..... In order to not only solve a problem in the dimension..... But to also solve an inner conflict and pass a test.....


I think that in our world it's in our heads, but in the mlp world it's a different dimension. But idk, I just LOVE to theorize! :D


And you once again remind me why I originally subscribed to your channel, Notion. Your videos, theories, and reasons all make sense as well as bring up some very reasonable thought trains. Keep it bro

@Matthew Addams Luna vs Freddy anyone?

The closest thing I have is a chapter from a Fimfiction where a human OC has a movie night with Rainbow Dash and they watch Nightmare on Elm Street, Rainbow has a nightmare about Freddy and Luna intervenes and absolutely curb-stomps him.

I think the story was called Project Sunflower: Side Stories, by Hoopy Mcgee.
-It's an excellent series with a unique twist and premise on the Human in Equestria troupe that isn't wish fulfilment.

In the pony's heads or different demission definitely demission cuz doctor who I think it was

@The Brony Notion i agree with you 100 percent the tantabus kind of reminds me of freddy krueger

@The Brony Notion Yes, your insightful breakdowns of every aspect of the show lighten up my day! It feels beautiful to have everything make sense, within the world of My Little Pony. Keep up the great work!


Dreams are DEFINITELY in another dimension.

except in actual non pony world real life sort of thing.


Maybe Luna was dreaming herself and it represented over coming some obstacle with help from others


Me and my friends actually had several dozen shared dreams until we graduated from high school


Maybe when ponys sleep, they can go to the dream dimension because Luna can use the magic on their brains while they don't use them and from there she takes them to the dream dimension


Is shining armor an alicorn???? And also anyone 2019??!


I feel like that thing was apart of nightmare moon. Nightmare moon could travel in dreams which explains how that thing could escape.


I'd say it is another dimension why cuz when you wake up a few seconds or minutes after you forget your dream you just end up taking what ever form you feel like anywhere but as long as it's in the dream world if you have questions just put in replys


Since it's a fantasy world, I do think that it's in another dimension.


Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

+InazumaEleven that's normal. when you see something that stands out from everything else, your brain thinks it was there for 1 minute when it was there for 1 second.

oh god, why. this joke is getting annoying.

@Sparkle Glitter good I wasn't the only one who saw it (you know what 'it' is)

@Sparkle Glitter OMG thx for saying it for me no one would pay attention to it xD

@Sparkle Glitter I don't care if there is a triangle that was a bit cheesy

bu dum psh

i'm not going to even get involved with this one, i'm just going to go back to crashing people's games

@Sparkle Glitter [insert illuminati joke here]

@Sparkle Glitter MIND FREAKIN BLOWN ALL OVER THE WALL!!!!!

@Sparkle Glitter FUCK

YOUR OVERUSED

MEMES

@Sparkle Glitter illuminati illuminati confirmed, lluminatiception

i think he has prooved... several times.. that he is.

HAHAHA yes I saw it too I thought for a second that it was just there for a whole minute or something

I SAW ILLUMINATI FOR A SPLIT SECOND BUT I DID

Yeah i know it's illuminati in a triangle

@Lui Panda did you see the illuminati in the impossible triangle

@The Brony Notion  longer episodes please   I am  you  biggest  fan   I waching your  videos  at the beginning

@Sparkle Glitter He always flashes the illuminati symbol XD . He might be illuminati... o.o


I think Professor Dumbledore said it best. Just because it's in your mind doesn't make it any less real. Princess Luna can walk in my dreams anytime!


I think that it's both, the brain has a effect called the Mandira effect.Wich can either be your brain making stuff up, or seeing other worlds, so the brain, is like a computer, a central server like you said.The brain and the magic of an alicorn, might be connected, I don't know some sort of anatomy.But anyways the brain is the key to the other world.

does that make sense?I don't know I'm just rambling at this point


Maybe its both each pony could have their own dimension in their own dream and the dream world could be a dimension of its own or something


Luna didn’t just create a shared but she also created a lucid dream. The pony’s could do anything they imagined. Now if that’s not lucid dream then I’m done researching dreams


@ShadowDashBrony everyone did duh. i did c:

We did this at school sooooo... #illuminaticonfurmed


Another way look at this theory is watch an old anime called Yumeria. It has a Dream World too. Heck! The 2012 (8 episodes) Black Rock Shooter anime has something similar as well.


Imagine ALL the ponies and villains and others teamed up to battle some demon clones, even the equestria girls kids are in the pony world.One heck of an episode...


It happens on both  head and dream world  the brain makes the dreams that teleports them to the dream world


My theory is that the entire episode was a dream


Am I the only one who saw the illuminati??!

No. And the illuminati can see you. ILLUMINATI! ILLUMINATI! ILLUMINATI!

No.. But I'm sure it was A joke right? RIGHT!?

@Twilight mask no. i saw it too. #illuminaticonfirmed

I saw it to and remembered another episode


i think that it still happens in the pony's' minds, but am still confused about the reasons.


My mind is blown... How on earth do you come up with these theories?


Spirits can exist with ease in either the physical world or a virtual one.  Luna's construct is a tulpa.  By definition, it's a spirit.  It's just a spirit which originally existed within Luna.<br>I'm an alter.  I basically live in a virtual reality when I'm not working out here.  I share a world with over a hundred different alters, all generated by one brain.  It actually isn't that hard.  That part wouldn't have drained Luna.  What's hard is maintaining a telepathic connection to hundreds of people at once.

Spirits can exist with ease in either the physical world or a virtual one.  Luna's construct is a tulpa.  By definition, it's a spirit.  It's just a spirit which originally existed within Luna.
I'm an alter.  I basically live in a virtual reality when I'm not working out here.  I share a world with over a hundred different alters, all generated by one brain.  It actually isn't that hard.  That part wouldn't have drained Luna.  What's hard is maintaining a telepathic connection to hundreds of people at once.


I acually agree with ur theory abut different diemsions cuz when I have a vivid dream, I don't feel like I'm in my mind but rather somewhere else.


ummmmmm....... I didn't catch any of that...


The reason why the lines weren't connected was because those ponies were the dream versions of the regular ponies


I'm gonna go with dream world because that could equal new episodes!


Well then all of there combined imaginations with Luna’s help creates its own dimension, the Dream Dimension, cool.


I think the dimesion thing is a good theory but they don't have the white wire attached to them because they all have there own dream dimensions that disapear when they wake up and Princess Luna jumps through dimensions


Real Luna comes to dream dimension and all other ponies aren't real they are controled by real ponies and when you control something you can do anything. Exactly as in that episode


This is a magical world of talking ponies, unicorns, pegasi, alicorns, and other magical, mythical creatures that still have the essence of science.  Of course, it's gonna be both.


Wait one second...... can a male pony become an alacorn? Can you do a theory on it? And also can fillys become alicorns?


Wait, what if the ponies dreams make up the dimension within their dreams?


anyone else saw the illminati

                🔺
             🔺  🔺
           🔺🔺 🔺
         🔺          🔺
       🔺🔺🔺🔺🔺
Do you see it!? 😈

That's not the illuminati. I just dropped my dorito!

What do u think your trying to say ya weird wannabe Illuminati member?

@Betty Vides me lol he's so weird and funny

@Betty Vides  IKR?! and I thought I was going crazy!!

@shadowLatias Nah, I'm an atheist. (No offense to religious people, I respect you)

@Lightningwing AJWarriors you mean the eye of providence, which is meant to represent the all seeing eye of God if you belive in that.

It's actually the watching eye, which is supposed to look for danger and repel it


YES! PRINCESS BRIDE REFERENCE! MY LIFE IS COMPLETE! Well, Fluttercord makes it complete, too. :) I'm sure you would agree, Brony Notion.


Dreams really do happen in the dream world


Did anyone see the shape of the tantabus in 3:4
I thought it was supposed to take the form of Luna's or anypony's fear
Who is fearing mistmane?
At least that is what it looks like to me


The dream world is a different dimension. Because of luna's magic she was able to be in the dream with the mane six and the whole of Ponyvile. but wait if the mane six were able to use magic in the dream dimension then it should've made luna collapse right?


The dream world may just be another dimension. The way the Tantabus ripped open the dream world looks just like the way Midnight Sparkle ripped open the human world.


Real life dreams are in the head and my little pony dreams are another dimension.


What if our heads were another dimension? Or the access to another dimension :)


Whoever knows the email address of "The Brony Notion" tell him that there was a comic that somewhat introduces how dreams are made and controlled.  I think it was titled "My Little Pony FIENDSHIP is Magic #4 Nightmare Moon."


Saw tooth, How are you? <del>I know I'll probably never get a reply cuz I'm irrelevant but a girl can dream</del>

Saw tooth, How are you? -I know I'll probably never get a reply cuz I'm irrelevant but a girl can dream-

Edgardo Domingo <br>He sees them in his notifications!

Edgardo Domingo
He sees them in his notifications!

what how did you cross some of your comment lol


I don't get how a dream is only in your mind but Luna was connecting it


considering the fact we have seen multiple demencions before including discords heckick nonsense world where the pore male pony got lost I'm sure without a doubt the dream world is anouther demencion all together.


"Of course it is happening in your head, but why should that mean it is not real?"


it seems possible that dream world is an dimention but theres a hole in your theory: how could the ponies enter the dream world or how could their minds enter it


Maybe that wasn't a dream, maybe all of Ponyville is just insane.

@Clare Nicke YEP ITS TRUE i just looked it up LAWL

@Clare Nicke "Every pony in this town is Crazy"

Maybe the writers didn't think of what this meant and just wished that people would just stop over theorising. That's how there different to me.

This could be foreshadowing Rainbow Dash's future insanity in the C.W.C. (Rainbow Factory)


If how you described Luna's bubble and how she was in it was actually the real the tantabus could be using the magic from the bubble and with enough of it at it's hooves it can create a door way to the waking world (or non dreaming world) but what of the string that I might be able to explain with how she can go through the dream demension back and forth using magic my theory is that the lines are slowly dissolving into the Skye cause they technically Peirce through the bubble so apart of them connected to the real world heads that way while the other strings go up and the certain string connected to the pony in the waking world keeps track of that certain pony now how Luna becomes tired she must be keeping the doorway open between the waking world and the dreaming world and that is the bubble formed around her now tantabus the giant killer monster now.....tantabus before Luna connected everyone in ponyville she made a connection with all the main 7 but not in the same dream and with her magic the tantabus can use it to hop from dream to dream now the ponyville full dream instead of her going to each dream separately I'll have to agree with you she made all the ponys in ponyville dreams connected so tantabus had nowhere to hide......there's one more thing tantabus it's self how the mane moves and the coloring I suggest that Luna was never fully separated from nightmare Moon some backup for that is that in the show she use the words "we, us " and much more suggesting that it is still there with her and how everyone describes it the tantabus is nightmare Moon or what she originally was a nightmare or a being of the dark Wich if listened to can turn you into a power crazed monster Luna felt alone that how it is described and in her nightmare form she wants everyone to make her there leader no matter the cost of life and that's what happened with sunset shimmer and twilight (equastria girls) but the nightmare can't take the host fully understand control it will urge the host into accepting it's deal to make the hosts life better


I think the answer is both of them because they could have a whole dimension inside of all of their heads that all that she’s doing is combining all of the dimensions into one so then all of those dimensions is what she is latching onto


All dreams are but another reality, never forget.


I guess you're right with dimension dream theory!
Its another dimansion but with the difference that when you die you get kicked out.
Or after a random time
That's my theory


I like the idea of dreams happening in another detention


I just saw  an animation flaw.  You know that purple pegasus with the fruit cutie mark on the left of the screen where luna  is in that bubble thing?  Well in the next scene, she is Shown without wings.


it come in another dimension cause I've tried it with my friends and talk about it , as we talk it was the same thing happened when we dreamed


Obscure reference: Shark boy and Lava girl. That was actually a pretty good movie


This is what I think<br>Ponies own dreams are in their own heads but there is a dream relm that allows luna to tack thier minds to, to connect them

This is what I think
Ponies own dreams are in their own heads but there is a dream relm that allows luna to tack thier minds to, to connect them


I think the when they sleep a dimension gets formed and of course luna is the only person getting into that dimension. Her physical body can go into that dimension with her magic.And when she sleeps she is like other ponies living in the dream world


it may be Luna created the dream world dimension. this is how she can access it and how she see into other pony's dreams. maybe when they enter the dream world, they are entering Luna's mind and imagination. you know, your basic wibbly-wobbly timey-whimey stuff!


I don’t remember the name of the reference but I love the movie! And I’m a kid!


i am a tad bit confused but i think that theres different dimensions for every dream


Maybe Luna brings there dreams to a dimension when she is connected to them.


if the pony wakes up would they disappear in the dream world or would they still be there but as a shell or AI?


I think that just like Luna's dream lines entered everypony's foreheads the tantapus can exit into the real world that way


Yes it is very real. At least to me 😊😇 I love my dream world 🤗


maybe its Luna's spiritual  self traveling through the ponies dreams


I dreamed my most incredible dream ever which was a dream when l went into a haunted hotel.


you know i feel like it does come from the head or other dimension because on time when i was having a nightmare when i woke up i had those you know the dream bubble floating over my head that white cloud that has your dream in it so when i woke i saw it and i woshed it away so maybe dreams do come from other dimensions.


also sometimes my dreams come true like what happens in my dream happend I think it was a vision


Maybe its a dimension that only we can enter asleep and the portal    <br>can be opened through the brain

Maybe its a dimension that only we can enter asleep and the portal
can be opened through the brain


so dreams are in a dream dimesion and luna can enter it mentally and phisacly? cool


Yes but sometimes what we dream at night we do in the morning so I guess thats it


The world of the dreams is called Onirique. I think that the dream's Luna are in reality her "âme" (French, don't know alternatives in english~) Because of the equilibre Corps Spirite "âme" ^^


You watched Sharkboy and Lavagirl too?! I loved that movie when I was a kid!


I think that the dream world is a magical dimension with portals inside the ponie's heads


Ya know I've always wondered if the dream world was real, if it was I WOULD BE DA NEXT POTATO.


Luna doesn't have a string when she is alone with only one other pony in their dream. Why? Because she is IN their dream! In the episode where she is holding everyone's dreams together, she is HOLDING the dream, and not JOINING it. That is why.


It's not another dimension but a realm. I don't know how to describe it. But it's sort of in their heads and sort of not.


What if it's like the Hindu Idea of the lower Astral? The dreams ARE happening in their heads, but a sort of copy is manifestated on to a dimensional plane that only slightly overlaps our own. The show DOES seem to be centered around old mythology and spirituality. It's not a bad theory. But, hey maybe I'm wrong, I'm just really philosophical trying to link my spirituality with a fucking kids show. What am I even going on about? Just a thought that maybe we can make a more cannon and reasonable connection to the world Equestria seems to be mimicking. It just makes more sense in that frame of reference.


Does Luna have to go into the dream dimension during the day? because you know I'm sure ponies take naps


I somehow understood that. I think th ponies have a separate dream relem but we create all our dreams in our heads


dreaming takes place both in a different dimension and in the ponies heads at the same time


Princess Big Mac was defo the highlight of that episode tho!


Wait so we can enter another selection while unconscious but while we are awake we can't get further than the moon lol


is it just me or is this guy becoming the game theorist for mlp? lol


I don't understand how a dream can be something from another dimension.. IT MAKES NO SENSE! Dreams are just stuff thought up by your brain to make a movie in your head while you sleep :P


there's tons of dimensions in my little pony so it doesn't surprise me if dreams have their own dream dimension world


if luna is in real life in this dream dimenision with a bubble round her, would the dream dimension version of her be in her bed in the real world or would she disappear in the real world altogether until she came out of dream dimension?


the tantabus scares me. I never thought I would say that about something in MLP.


My question is if it’s a dimension wouldn’t the pony have to be in the dimension for dreams to work? Yet they are asleep in bed


I MISS THEM! (I wish there was more lava girl and shark boy) MAN PLEASE MAN BRING THEM BYE THE BRONY NATION!


<b>coughs</b> It's called the Dream Realm-a synonym for realm is dimension. The Dream Realm is a dimension within the everyday-dimension the ponies of Equestria live in.

*coughs* It's called the Dream Realm-a synonym for realm is dimension. The Dream Realm is a dimension within the everyday-dimension the ponies of Equestria live in.


Where she visits a single pony it's in the head when shared dreams it's in a dream dimension


I think it's in the ponies heads but luna transports them to a different dimension


in the brain their is a part where the dreams are kept maybe each part of the ponys brain join together to make a dream planet<br> i love mlp

in the brain their is a part where the dreams are kept maybe each part of the ponys brain join together to make a dream planet
 i love mlp


I think the dream world is another dimension but it's in everyponys brain and Luna knows how to get in there and because equestria is full of magic the ponys can remember their dreams


Obscure reference that I actually get. Awesome! (Sharkboy and Lava Girl)


Maybe she was using strings to go to a mirrored dimension! So that's why the tante pus could go to the reality diamonsion!


Did anyone else see that when the clip of discord ripping open a portal it is actually had the same colour of the portal the tantabus ripped open! Did anyone else see it? Well I did!


I think dream world is Luna's mind. If in her mind "that" can go to real world, it will happen realy.


I think that Luna is just connecting to the ponies from the real world, but nice theory.


The “obscure reference” isn’t so obscure, since I get it!


That's the magical world of Equestria anything can happen there.  It's a mystery


Also... every time the intro makes sense. Like, is the dream world just another dimension, FRIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENDSSSSSSSS?


I think it's a dream dimension because like Discord (apparently) tore a hole to the sock puppet dimension (whatever that is lol)...wait, maybe this creepy shadow Luna thingy is somehow connected with Discord?...1. weird things happening 2. ripping holes between dimensions...and let's not forget the human Twilight demon thing, cause she was making holes between dimensions too. (I never saw that episode either) so..maybe the three are connected somehow... (except for Twilight cause she turned normal right?) oh well who knows. :3 just a very strange idea. (I dunno how I came up with my theory so I said strange)


It's a dimension that leads to doors to the ponies dreams!<br>Edit:Or just a dimension. It depends on you

It's a dimension that leads to doors to the ponies dreams!
Edit:Or just a dimension. It depends on you


Maybe she didn't have enough magic to create dream lunar


I'm ganna go with the dream world.. And I have a theory! Is Luna an actual pony?! Or is she from the dream world?? How else would she know how or what a teturis( spelled it wrong) is??!!!


I think they are connected to the heads and minds because why else would the magical wires be connected to the head


devoun: I would lose my mind if I saw mr stitchy staring at me.<br>Me: How about a creepy humanoid owl?

devoun: I would lose my mind if I saw mr stitchy staring at me.
Me: How about a creepy humanoid owl?


When luna is about to make her white dream connection string things you see starlight glimmer's star part of her cutie mark in white on the tip of luna's horn and when she is about to travel into the dream world the white wisps around her looks like twilight's magic essence coming out of her chest in magical mistic cure and cadence's magic essence on her cuite mark in the crystal heart episode.They all happen when they fullfill their destiny


Uh, this magic of the dream dimension is real because if you think of any super rare abilities then you could do anything you wanted. Like, for example, I heard from my dad mentions that he was being chase by robbers then he temporary thinks of me in his dream as Batman and me saving his life. And me, I was dreaming dropping super deep underground(not bottomless) then I levitated myself out of the deepest underground and I was back to Jr High and I can shoot spider webs like Spider-Man.


Remember when lunar entered the mane 6 dreams individualy ??? She was not using the white strings when she enters dreams individualy which explains the cutie mark cursaders dreams individualy but when everypony ( or more than 1 pony ) has the same dream .... the white strings apear


I think if the dream realm as the monster world in Pixar's Monsters Inc. Luna transports into the dream realm and has this 7th sence when a pony is going through something and needs assistance. I do not believe that when this happens there is a string going through their head it is just their dream selves stepping out of their dream. Like when Sweetie Belle does after having that dream showing what really happened before/after her 5th birthday party and what will happen to Rarity if the headdress fell apart on Sapphire Shores head and ruin her career.


I think that the dream had to be in the dimensions because if it wasn't, wouldn't it hurt the ponies brains if the tantipus cut out of them??


I literally just watched that episode yesterday-


one part of this episode reminds me of star vs the forces of evil and her dimensional scissors


I'm pretty sure you just said, "Dream" A 100 times... lol my brain hurts too much to count XD


I think there's a dream planet far below earth that's why you feel a falling sensation and the reason you say falling asleep you're falling off earth and onto this dream planet where you control everything with your mind


in the dream world you can see THE SAME LAMP POST as in threes a crowed maybe some of those things are hapining because of discord! maybe discord is even in the dream. he dose have some pretty crazy powers (that is kind of obvious though


maybe the real Luna generates dream Luna like a hologram or something but in the shared dream of ponyville she doesn't have enough energy to generate that hologram


I think that the dream world is in the ponys heads. and that the tantrbus (don't know if that's how u spell that) is exiting through a pony's mind just as princess Luna can enter and exit a pony's mind from and how she enters is a spell, and if say it's all of ponyvill u can see it's a spell if that makes sense. theories I'm I right?


I just don't know...WTF?!...Oh, I know! That is just MAGIC! Pony world, not human world, Remember!


Six of one half a dozen of another. It's not entirely impossible that much as certent beliefs hold the moon hold sway over our dreams so it could be that it's inside everyone's heads but also connected to this Universal subconscious


I could keep up and I agree with you completely


I get the reference because I grew up on movies from the 90s/Early 200s


I wonder... If I have a nightmare but it's MLP themed would Luna be there? 🌑


But wasn't the creature connected to luna so her suffering and darkness was coming out into physical something like nightmare moon but in this scenario luna will still exist separated from that creature


Boy do I have one heck of a theory.
FRIENDS!!!!
Friends helped him with the theory


It couldn't of been in the dream world because remember Magical Misery Cure? At the end when she became a Princess that's where she went and that wasn't a dream.


Well the show is about magic so what if dreaming only starts when princess luna starts her duty and that is when the tentabus appears


think about it, a lot of parody things that us fans created was imputed into the tantabis episode, like big Mac wanting to be an alicorn °-°


but how are ponies supposed to go in the dimension if they are sleeping?😞


I want to believe this real because I'm writing a book on it.


Well luna did infact say realm. Think of minecrafts dimensions. They are known as realms. Realms such as the nether have diffrent looks but is connected to our world. As long as there is a connection you can enter and leave the nether dimension. So if we take that to the fact then luna is infact the portal for her mind to come into dreams.

Well realm of dreams or sleep ofc is what i mean


maybe just maybe it's both a demenstion and the mind of a pony the demenstion is for loads of ponies so luna had to go there herself unlike the mind where she is dream luna


i agree but if that is another dimension then wouldn't  it be connecting to all of Equestria just a theory


Stupid answer: the dream tantabus gets the sleeping ponies to Magic a real tantabus into the real world. Just my dont cents. I don't believe it either, or rather don't prefer it. I like the idea of a dream dimension


ok, your DW references are making me so happy!


and answering your question, both! The dream realm is a dimension that exists in the ponie’s head.


My theory the dream thing whold come out of Luna's horn as bad magic and take the form of the big pony monster it takes in the shard dream. Luna is there because the monster is trying to come out of her horn so this puts streas on her and she's there as a last resort to get a second chance but after that the monster can go threw the portal to get to the real world. It's in the ponys head but the danger is still real


my theory is that when luna does the wiser thing to the ponies heads it tp's them to the dream world.


I think when she males everyone share the same dream that bean shows since normaly its just one person having the dream


there was a split second of the lumniation (how do u spell it) eye thingy in the optical elusion triangle


But I'm think the Dream World is real, just all that in our dream we can control with our head.


I think the wire things only appear when it is a shared dream


dream world is 1 of the dimentsions, ( i hope i spelled it right) ponys teleport to there when they sleep and that big luna thing made portal out of there , Luna can make same thing. Bubble around Luna project Luna.


This is a great theory and even though i live in equestria even i domt know how this works 😑😑😑


When the cutie mark crusaders get their cuitie marks it uses the same magic essence again like with the other 5 ponies [4 ponies 1 human]


“Magic is as magic does, just funny that way”–Granny Smith


I think the dreaming happens in one dimension


I think the ponies minds LEAD to the dream dimension (wow such wow)


It is another dimension called the Dreamscape.


Nightmare Realm or Dreamscape... Bill Cipher will tell you...


Of course this is happening in your head Harry! But why should that mean that it is not real?
Dumbledore's confusing wisdom 101

Edit: that's kinda what the book says, not word for word, I ain't got the book in front of me 😆


I thought that too. It may not be that it will be a living nightmare, they just will never wake up.


Idk why I’m wasting so much of my brain for understanding cartoon than working hard on my homework instead


It took so long but i remember that reference to the show (lava girl and lava girl)


maybe it’s just the blue smoke escaping your head


I think it happens in the dream dimension


the pony's mind is a dimension in itself


maybe Luna's magic turns its self into brain waves :0


How about inside and outside both exist?


I have a feeling that its both. both in their head and in a different dimension


so person told me that the dimension of dreams can become real someday that one dream you had could have been the future


Probably everyone: cool theory! <br>Me: OMG SHARKBOY AND LAVAGIRL!! I love that movie!

Probably everyone: cool theory!
Me: OMG SHARKBOY AND LAVAGIRL!! I love that movie!


I'm willing to admit that this is a little far-fetched, but, I mean, seriously, this is mlp, for gods' sake.🤗


as far as I know it's possible that the dream girl in My Little Pony but I doubt it this sounds more like a Doctor Who parody if you ask me in fact even talk to who did a parallel universe with David Tennant so that's how I know about that Yep this is more like this another time period or another paradox that's what I think this is Rose what is signing out


When sunset shimmer turns into a pheonix in friendship games the yellow magic essence is the same magic essence that the 4 ponies had


Whats that... the All Seeing Eye in the 'mind boggling as this is' sentence + picture?


What if Luna is the pyhical form of the giant dream pony


I think of it like if your brain some how changes your vision to see your thoughts in a brain demention


the dream world? do not know! all I know is that the dream world is in a different dimension! and it is magic! that is how the "thing" can go into the real world.also how it explains NIGHTMARE moon.mabye.


This video may be old but dream pony all the way.


why would the string attach to their heads if it wasn't in the minds??


Magic essence again when shining armor and cadence join their horns in the episode where crysallis comes.


since the dream realm is Controled by luna,it is Just a sight or a Vision that makes ponies create there Dreams that what happend at the real world.


i think its dream luna , because in the end of the episode she was sleeping and dreaming another dream


i think u have a good point maybe there is a dream demishon for real


i LOVE the brony nation is sooo cool and now i understand all of mlp


I think that the dream world is another dimension like the crystal mirror in Equestria girls


wait sharkboy and lavagirl was obscure? holy shit, I used to love that movie


Me when I was 4 : wow I'm glad the my little pony's stopped the tantapus or else I would have had bad dreams forever Me when I became 8 and watching MLP equestria girls and looking back into my memory: wow I was so stupid back then they meant the equestria girls when Luna said it would enter the real world she meant equestria girls not our world she meant the equestria girls world


Their brain magic makes the dimension stuff!!!!


Is Princess Luna more powerful than Celestia?


I really liked this episode when I was in the fifth grade. Probably because I’m a huge lesbian who has a thing for angsty girls who can do magic.


i think it is a dimention that is only able to go in at luna's night


I think that there is a dream world which connects to the ponies mindes and the tentacus came there then exited it (only if luna lost with it also the illuminati thing it was weird)


What if when ponys sleep they go to a different roam ??


it is in a dream but see the bubble around luna notice how no one touched her that's a rip in the sleep real dimensiens that luna was in and holding open,those streams were going to the sleeping ponies luna wasn't struggling to get the ponies in it was her keeping that rift open

Note I'm only ten don't judge


Wait... ISN'T HIS OWN YOUTUBE CHANNEL IN THE DREAM WORLD!? Just think about it! We've seen a hallway with doors in the dream world. And in the dimension that the Brony Notion lives in, there is another sparkly hallway of doors! And each door leads to a different Youtube Channel! Wait... HAVE THE MLP THEORISTS TAKEN OVER THE HALLWAY OF DREAMS!?!?!?!??!?!?!?!?!?!


This episode of my little pony is funny because of rainbow dash'a dream so I was wondering if u can probably make a video of how it might have been scary to her


Why not: Every dream is it's own dimension? and magic allows luna to cross in between them. and even allow ponies to have the same dream by putting them in the same dimension. How about them carrots?


I miss Lava Girl and Shark Boy ;-; I watched the movie 24 times


I had a dream that I was nightmare FredBear and it was in my mind not behind hundreds of doors my dream was sooooooo cool


Did you know this is my little pony I think the creators just created a series full of cotton candy colored horses I don’t think it really matters


so I agree what if it is a different dimension I really don't like bringing anything into this so I'm just not but my mom believes in heaven as it gets to be whatever you want to be and if a dream is like how you want it to be so what is a dream is supposed to be like your version of heaven like a  preview and since its like your perfect version of whatever so why didn't they just wish the tantabus away? so what if what we all think is going to be heaven will actually be a new dimension where we had our dreams?


I think that’s why you can’t tell if you dreamt something or if it was real


So the dream diemechtion is not in the mind but in a diemechtion were luna can be in but most of the time it is like a luna puppet but luna can control her own puppet so any living thing in the dream diemechtion can easily go to the real world.

For people who did not keep up


maybe Luna uses power to make herself look normal.


anything that has strong enough magic in the dream world can build up magic in the real world even if i has no physical form in the real world, and if it has enough magic in the real word but no physical form then and only then it will be able to create a phyisical form for itself in the real world. to bad this is only in mlp though because it would be very cool if it wasn't, AND I WOULD HAVE A UNICORN THAT MAKES MONEY!!XDXDXD

i was only 25 seconds in to the video when i typed this


"Boy Do I have one heck of a theory" FRIENDSSSSSSSSSSSSS


Brony guy: but how could something that is in mind enter the real world?<br>Me: dude...... ANYTHING CAN HAPPEN IN EQUESTRIA

Brony guy: but how could something that is in mind enter the real world?
Me: dude...... ANYTHING CAN HAPPEN IN EQUESTRIA


First off not very confusing and second off it is in another dimension but the ponys are making up the world around them with there own minds it's basically just a dream world where anything is possible


well ya that's true but in one video can you make your next video about why is Luna in the cutie mark crusaders dreams cuz there are two reason's 1. cuz Luna is a sibling ans 2 cuz Luna is a dream pony


are minds are connections to the dream realm we each have are own area but we can only access this area when are unconscious minds are active and since there are those who can control their dreams it means the are controlling the dream realm


I think it is another dimension that your soul/subconscious/self-conscious


I think the dream dimension is the best answer.


Wait though Luna in the 1st so had a guards that were pony so does that mean she has he own planter?


I love Princess Luna<br>ALSO Did u know Luna means Moon?

I love Princess Luna
ALSO Did u know Luna means Moon?


the real world is the pony world.  remember that this is a dream not the real world and OMG I SAW THE ALL SEEING EYE FOR A SPLIT SECOND IN THAT RED TRIANGLE SPOOKY MAN!  Luna had some sort of spell so she could be in the dreams of ponies. so if the spooky blob thing escaped the dream work it would have gone into the pony world not another demention


I'm sure glad Sharkboy and Lavagirl is on Netflix!


Όλοι ξέρουν πως ο κόσμος του ονείρου, δεν είναι αλειθινός!!! Χωρίς δεύτερη σκέψη!!!


i think the ponies mind and consionceness goes to the dream dimension but the actual pony stays in bed


those lines help it to where they can ither share a dream or she can watch multiple dreams faster and easrier its just it makes her tired and doesnt last for long


well. according to perfessor dumbledoor in the 7th harry potter book it would all be in the pony's head


I think that if Tantabus would of escaped frim the dream server that Luna made i dont think the ponies would had seen him beacause he is basicale a ever lasting nightmare that can get defeated with cute kittens and cotton candy. Tantabus basically does not exist. Well for magical/dream dimentions yeah he would but in our worl no beccause we have no magic. And its pretty obvious that Luna was real because in Applebloom's, Scootaloo's and sweetybell's dream she did not have the glowing string coming out of her horn....


“Luna did just tie the mane six, she created A shared dream so the tantibus would have no where to go or hide with ALL OF PONYVILLE”<br>Uhm hello? From the crystal empire and canterlot? Manehatten anyone?

“Luna did just tie the mane six, she created A shared dream so the tantibus would have no where to go or hide with ALL OF PONYVILLE”
Uhm hello? From the crystal empire and canterlot? Manehatten anyone?


Wow nice also I watch this over and over again and I just left it because I am a big fan of Luna


The rip in the gala was in the night sky so was it in the dream world.