I know this is kind of grasping at strings here, but do you think there could be some connection to the surreal dimension where Discord lives? If it's the ponies' minds that are influencing what we see in the dimension, maybe what we saw in 'Make New Friends and Keep Discord' was some kind of residue from when there were dreams there? I assume the mail man in that episode was there in his physical form/waking self, like Luna probably was when being the 'server'. <br>Idk, you're the expert! Oh, I'd also love to hear people's thoughts about Luna's dream at the very end of 'Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep?'.

I know this is kind of grasping at strings here, but do you think there could be some connection to the surreal dimension where Discord lives? If it's the ponies' minds that are influencing what we see in the dimension, maybe what we saw in 'Make New Friends and Keep Discord' was some kind of residue from when there were dreams there? I assume the mail man in that episode was there in his physical form/waking self, like Luna probably was when being the 'server'.
Idk, you're the expert! Oh, I'd also love to hear people's thoughts about Luna's dream at the very end of 'Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep?'.


I wonder if Luna can go into the Astral Plain. Or if it's a place only Celestia can go. I mean, from what we've seen, the Relm of Sleep or "Dream Demention", looks a lot like the Astral Plain. Only Luna can go into it though (or at least have power in). So I wonder if it's the same with Celestia and the Astral Plain?


It seems very possible for the dreams to be in another dimension and I think that if that really is true then because Luna is connecting so many dreams so has to physically be there to keep the dream together


I do agree with the idea that the Dream world I another dimension; makes sense. However, the dream is another world that exists within the mind. Reason being: anything can happen in the dream world. There are no limits so it is a world controlled by thought whereas the real world I controlled by science and equestrian magic. The tentabus can enter the other world due to the power it gained. It and Discord can travel through other dimensions because of the strength of their magic. Otherwise, interesting video and I can't wait for your next theory.


I believe in your theory because its logical and is possible!<br>Way to go!

I believe in your theory because its logical and is possible!
Way to go!


WAIT A FEATHERY MOMENT! If the Tentapus made a portal to the real world from the dream from the amount of power it has, can't the ponies GIVE themselves the same power to open the rift in time and have whatever power he/she had in the dream?!?!


Well I think it is in the pony's heads and the tantipus feeds off of negitive energey. It probably converts it into dark magic and then uses that magic to fisicly put itself into the real world


I think it is both hear me out as we saw in the dream ep of cmc(forget name)there are doors. I think the doors are the minds(what's inside)and the corridor(the hallway of doors)is the dimsion but if there's a shared dream the doors dissaper so...there has to be a conntion to a dimssion (hits real Luna with the magic white streaks)


I think this ulter dimension and dream escape could actually play a role in the Equestrian Games sense season 5 has been building that up. Especially with the recent trailers.


Their minds could be connected to the dream world and from there Luna can access individual dreams and small joint dreams though it explains her struggle to maintain a large amount of ponies dreams there fore not making her not able to use dream Luna.


I believe in a dream world and this theory was all awesome I love princess Luna and how her magic works wow I'm looking forward to more on this awesome channel Ty


Notion. The bubble was explained by Luna in the episode. It was the tatabus draining her power in order to leave the dream world.


I think the "Dream Dimension" is like a blank piece of paper that the ponies shape with their thoughts.


Isn't that exactly what all magic is though? Taking something that exists in the mind and transferring it to the real world?


I think it is another dimension but I think it it's kind of like in For Whom the Sweetie Bell Toils where they were in that space with all the doors. I think Lunna herself can visit this space and is how she is able to just happen upon dreams.


This is big. Well...I think you could be correct about the dream dimension. Maybe the dimension and the thoughts of other ponies are connected or one in the same! Luna can travel to other ponies minds with the dimension gate way to the dream world so...which dose mean she can enter their minds. I don't really know but I think they could be one in the same!


maybe dreaming is just your consciousness in another body in another universe, meaning that your consciousness has to be bound by no dimension. Meaning that luna is bound by 2 or more dimensions... and magic is also bound by no dimension... hmmm... sort of like how a graviton is not bound by dimensions in string theory!


Personal I think dreams show what we wish for or fear, but I have a problem where I don't dream and when I do its of the past or the next day. This leads me to believe that dreams might be connected to so form of nexus of sort. I say this because one time I dreamed a dream of an ancient battle of samurais that where speaking perfect japenses but I truly only know a handful of words, so those with strong wills or powerful minds can see other's dreams, and maybe this nexus records all dreams that take place. But that's just a personal theory.


I GOT IT!
Luna puts the dreams together and. When your in a dream you made you have to power it.
:3


True but I have another idea (please notice me) Luna is so powerful she accidentally created a creature that could (from the dream world) enter the real world. That's another way to explain I'm not saying your theory is bad.


Yo más bien pensaba al ver el episodio que como Luna es la unica que tiene el poder de entrar en los sueños de otros y ayudarlos tambien puede afectarlos de mala manera solo que en este caso todo se salio de control, imaginen que la pesadilla hubiera sido no de Luna sino de Applejack, es solo un ejemplo, no hubiera surtido el mismo efecto amenos que Luna tubiera algo que ver, creo nose solo digo.

If you don't understand spanish go to Traductor Google pls


If you do enough astral traveling or lucid dreaming the answer is quite clear there are many other dimensions... well accordi g to some researchers.


My guess is that the dream world is a bunch of pocket universes controlled by the pony's mind, accessible by only sleep (and Luna's magic). What Luna did was she simply strung those many pocket dimensions together while they were available in a form of "internet connection", as you were saying.

@HeroOfTimelord Also, I understood the obscure reference, and I'm 14.


I guess you do still have some more of my secretes to give away;
I might as well tell you Equestria has 42 interconnected dimensions.
(please don't ask about 23 or 37)


The dreams have there own place that is connected to  life


I think that the dream world is in a different dimension and that dream luna is only used to fix emotional problems.I also think real luna can warn ponies about threats,in their dreams.That might be why we saw luna, in the orb thing, with the strings still being used.

<b>one year later</b> wow no replies....


They dream in their heads but that's how they enter the alternative dimension!


Well if the real world is somehow connected to the dream world doesn't that mean that people can miraculously be brought to the real world? Commence the fanfics! Every universe in conceivability is connected and the dream world is a Hub. Ha, obscure references to a channel no longer existing! So anything can happen to the dream world and that means that lucid dreaming means we're IN the dream world!


1:52 I love that movie! X3 Shark Boy and Lava Girl (nearly types Llama Girl) is a super good movie


I think that everything in that bubble is real and luna is just in between the two dimensions so she can communicate with the ponies in the dream


I think the dream realm is a prety clever way to explane it


that is really something to think about also what if the whole pony world is just one big dream that is made up by some person's mind and each episode is each night and i saw that flash of illuminate


I think that it would happen in there heads because the string connects to there forehead and not a hole or mirror.


Well... I got lost keeping up. Wait... Doesn't Luna control the dreams? Ok... This is complicated. I need to write it down...


I was wondering if u (Brony) could make a video sometime about prince Blue blood. See, in the gala episode, the song "At The Gala" rarity's part, a portion of her part describes how prince Blue blood is her nephue (sorry for bad spelling) so if prince blue blood is her nephue, then does princess celestial and luna have third sibiling or is he princess lunas daughter?<br>


i am really surprised that i could keep up and understand everything he just said


My theory: Since she is the Princess <br>Night so she would be able to do this with her power.

My theory: Since she is the Princess
Night so she would be able to do this with her power.


wait, wait, wait a second, those white string thingies connected to the foreheads of the ponies for a reason? and if not, the "real" luna was in the bubble bcuz she's "real" then why were the white string thingies going upwards, where were they pointing to, more like, where were they? when luna was dream jumping (literally through the mane 6's dreams) they didnt have the white strings either, and luna didnt have the strings, but in the joined dread, since it was probs the real luna since the bubble and everything, the strings were there like the first time she did it to the mane 6 wherein it was the real her, in reality that had the lines, but where did the lines go in the joined dream? im pretty sure it was there


Well in shark boy and lava girl it was said dreams can become so powerful they become real. (or something like that) so if that's true then case solved? Idk.


"of course it's all happening in your head but why does that make it any less real."


It is probably both. In their minds and in another dimension. A place that exist only because of the dreamers mind as it is given shape by the sleeping ponies. It might be just another form of magic and since equestria is full of it... maybe thats why its posible for the dream parasite to exist in both realities as they both share magic as an energy source. Dunno... HAHAHAHAHA!


I think only shared dreams are in a separate dimension and single dreams are not


There has to be a dream demension. Otherwise, Luna would be the ultimate brain doctor XD


How is it that I get almost all of your references, but hardly any for some youtubers? Doctor Who, the Princess Bride, Rhett and Link, even Shark Boy and Lava Girl.


1:20 I was thinking that same thing. Does this mean Gamer Luna is canon?


Maybe the tangabis (don't mind the spelling please) is moving from the dream to reality like Luna douse? But instead of connecting it's self to other ponies it's pulling away


Well if the dream Luna can go into the real world and the real Luna can go into the dream world then shouldn't dreams b in dimensions? But then again Luna is the princess of the night so it would make sense for her....


When Luna is in the dream world she does have the wires, but they aren't connected to any of the ponies in the dream. So what were the wires connected too?


I got the obscure reference. that's pretty similar to this


It makes more sense for it to Be another dimension


it's probably a dream, luna did create it


I actually got the lava girl and shark boy reference


Can you please do a flash sentry video!! @The Brony Notion thank you


YES FINALLY SOMEONE KNOWS ABOUT SHARKBOY AND LAVAGIRL


This episode reminds me of Bill Cipher for some reason XD he is a dream demon after all


What was that thing I saw for a frame behind the impossible triangle?


The Dream Realm, is like the fade in Dragon Age


It's not complicated. It's the animators and writers getting lazy as they focus more on Brony references for $$$ rather than the damn story. I've been seeing a disturbing amount of that lately.


I think the dream world is a whole separate dimension


If there is a Dream Dimension  then  why does only Luna access it?


Wait...<br>SO PRINCESS BIG MAC IS REAL!?!?!?

Wait...
SO PRINCESS BIG MAC IS REAL!?!?!?


Easy, the dream world acts like another dimention as a big Bubble of dream, the mind of ponies is like a little Bubble with ah individual dream, they can Connect to each other if Luna desires, a dream inside another dream, or a few dreams inside a big dream Bubble, and all the dream bubbles can get inside the dream world, as a huge dream Bubble with a lot of dreams inside


SHARKBOY AND LAVA GIRL! also, I agree with the dimension Theory. ;)


??? I didn't actually understand anything, but I understood a bit, but I have a question
The share dream in "Bloom in gloom" when Luna made a share dream for scotaloo Apple bloom and sweetie belle she wasn't the real Luna, but in "Do princesses dream of magic sheep?" The real Luna was in the share dream, why? Why Luna in this episode was real in the dream and not real in bloom and gloom? Make sense?


So saying that this was actually what happened and the dream world is a dimension then if Pony Luna went into the dream then how did the mane six already know this was a dream? Where there Pony Side in the dream as well with Luna?


I think she connects it to someone's brain then brings it to the dream world.


really hard to believe but it is a bit cool


I'm just wondering,how come you never get brony hate on your channel?i never see any comments about it.


One word: MAGIC

And I totally saw that Illuminati symbol in the red triangle....


Oh I was thinking the same thing about the dream and the real world but kinda different from yours


Interresting thoughts but I really can't make much out of it


OMG YASSS THE DREAM WORLD IS SOOOOOOOO REAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

@Renita Perrone also i freaked out with the princess bride reference and shark boy and lava girl


Separate dimension and do you think this  old be how we humans have dreams


You thought we wouldn't see that split second frame. I DID. YOU PROVED ILLUMINATI (or at least just showed it.) I SAW IT!!!!!!!!!! I'M NOT CRAZY!!!!!


Sharkboy and Lavagirl. I win.<br>Also, I think your theory is pretty much bang on. Yay headcanon ^^

Sharkboy and Lavagirl. I win.
Also, I think your theory is pretty much bang on. Yay headcanon ^^


My friend had this idea that button mash was the son of discord i was hopping uou could do a video on this like the things in comin like the coat the hat eyes why buttons train caught on fire so could bottom be the son of discord and adopted by pony?


I say it's real but is a subdivision like Tartarus, Chaos Central and the Alicorn Nexus


Also did anyone else see the Illuminati symbol?Bill get out of the pony Dreamscape!How many Gravity Falls references are we packing in this episode.Oh and I bet your really happy that Rainbows favorite dream beating up changelings.Sarcasm you gotta loveit.


There is a Mario game called "Mario and Luigi Dream Team" and it does some cool dream things in there, check it out. Spoiler alert. Mario enters dreams through a portal thingy.


Cant cranky get his hair back from zacora potions


my ideal is that both dimension are conneted to gother


Mlp should make "Sharkcolt and Lavamare"! XD


Maybe when Luna is sleeping, she can go to Pony's Dream but, she was not asleep she was a wake that's why she was crying and tired that magic means she's forcing her self to go to their dreams without making herself asleep... or maybe?


I died from sharkboy and lava girl. Best movie ever


Sharkboy and Lavagirl is an obscure reference. Dang.


But just think about it... Its a show for kids nothing is deeply thought in this show (3:24 reference lol)


.....

Did any of you catch all of that?

.....

Did any of you catch all of that?


I have a question: where the hoof are twilight's parents


Ahhh I hate Netflix the new mlp episodes haven't come out yet and I keep getting spoilers :c


The horn mlp fim is magic right and they have unicorns maybe the dream is like a diemenion but inside the cause is well horn have magic but how about sweetie bell well sweetie bell can use magic to levite <br>objects right.

The horn mlp fim is magic right and they have unicorns maybe the dream is like a diemenion but inside the cause is well horn have magic but how about sweetie bell well sweetie bell can use magic to levite
objects right.


0:57
Frickin Amy Pond in the Pandorica!
After that my attention span to anything else got real small.


If she cratied the tantebus to have the same nightmare why did she dream of the main 6 Sarah


it happen sin dimesion that Luna created so she could talk to ponies personaly. thats why nopony else can acsess the dreams.


Who else saw the Illuminati symbol for that one frame?


ILLUMINATI FLASH<br>+The Brony Notion can you do a vid on why Starlight appeared in amending fences

ILLUMINATI FLASH
+The Brony Notion can you do a vid on why Starlight appeared in amending fences


I'm like a dream to mention all your day going on probably a pleasant dreams to mention do makes you like it


um, well. uuuuuuh, i didn't see this episode, but i am confused as fuck. you are brilliant!


Am I the only one who saw the flash of the illuminate????


well....if you start clicking on 6:40 you will see a quick animation of illuminati...AWESOME :D


Sorry if I ask, but can you make at least one video without using your OC and do like a webcam or something?


Trailer 2 for friendship games is out cadence is in it watch it plz :-/)


I'm way to confused to even think,u know?!i'm gonna stop doing YouTube related things now


I thout it was night meat moon because I herd that she was coming back so I though that was her... :(


Dang it i came here for a freddy Kruger reference


Idk it's  probably a 50 50 chance it's possible there is a dream dimension but it is also a possibility that it is just something to do with are brain


The head because dreams come from that<br>


Ever since you posting a video of illuminati on mlp fim <br>It begins to haunt you LOL :0

Ever since you posting a video of illuminati on mlp fim
It begins to haunt you LOL :0


i blacked out after 3 minutes from confusion


Who's knows, you lost me a long time ago.


Why is everyone talking about the illuminati a lot now ( is it cuz of gravity falls coming bak out)


* how prince Blue blood is princess celestia's nephue <b>,</b> sorry :P

* how prince Blue blood is princess celestia's nephue *,* sorry :P


someone help illuminati is invading [spelled wrong] youtube


Ha. You think that Sharkboy and Lavagirl is an obscure reference.


Running comment chain from last vid has a disabled comment section. Continuing with it here. Just wanted to get my thoughts out to @Raspberries Rrandom

My two best friends ever ended up trying to destroy my reputation. I totally know how you feel. In more ways than one. Actually, this isn't the only example - my entire family deals with that sort of thing a lot.

I can't answer whether or not to continue being a brony. Watch the show's most recent episodes, and decide if you still like the show for yourself. However, I d o have some advice for you.

Honesty is the best policy; don't pretend to like or dislike something, just be yourself. Just say what you feel and be honest about who you are. In a nice way - being honest and rude are different - but don't just lie because you think others won't like the answer. There's always going to be the bullies, and they're going to be looking for a person to pick on and a reason to pick on them, but there's always going to be the nice people too. Those people will respect you fxor who you are, so long as you take the time to let them know who you are, and choose to be honest about it. There's no way around encountering opposition, it's how you handle it that matters most.

The best way to handle cruelty is with kindness. I know this seems counterintuitive, and I'm not saying give them a present for their actions. No, I'm saying the worst way to handle bullies is to be a bully back. If they get out of hand, you should stand up to them, but if they're just picking on you, show them it doesn't phase you, and don't let it phase you. Part of bullying is allowing yourself to BE bullied. Just let it fall off your shoulder, and if the bully doesn't stop, your friends and family will be there for you. If a bully, someone who you don't like, genuinely needs help or advice, give it to them, even if they're your worst annoyance. "A friend can make a great enemy but an enemy can make an even greater friend." - no idea who the quote is by, sorry :/. If they need help, help, if they aren't bothering you any, you just shouldn't care, if they are bothering you than people can help you handle it, and you can usually just tell them to stop - firmly but not rudely, in a respectful manner - and they will. If someone you don't like genuinely needs help, just help them. Finally, if a bully is mean "in a nice way", smile and all, just smile and be nice back. Trust me, this works.

The past is what brought you here, but it's not a definition of who you are right now. Don't dwell on the past, and don't harp on the future. Whatever's already happened has already happened, all that matters is what you do now. Don't let the past bind you. Don't spend so much time preparing for the future that you never live in the present. Sure, there is always things you can prepare for, and should, but in the end you really can't predict what happens and you really can't change what has already happened. What matters most is that you try in the right here and now. Just do your best, and whatever happens, happens. If you don't achieve the goals you set out for yourself, you haven't failed. Nobody will blame you for trying - they will praise you for it, and try to help you through whatever problems you face. But I have no doubt that your short term goals, make new friends and a new, better existence for yourself. In everything you do - school, relationships, what you like, purely random events - all you can ever do is try, but that's all you really should do.

I can't say how your friend was, or who she was, or what she felt, or what you felt, or really what happened, but I can say one thing, right now. You got to have this experience, and it will only serve you well in the future. Don't get yourself into a situation like that again, sometimes the most helpful thing you can say to someone is a simple no. However, you both learned and grew from it, and you'll both come out all the better for it. Embrace your time with your friend, and be glad it's over now. I can't claim to know anything about her or you, but I know that the experience will serve you both very well, and I give you both the best wishes for your future.

I can't claim to follow this advice myself - I haven't told much of anyone about my brony status, and I'm awful at making friends, and I dwell on things a bit much myself, but very often the best people to give advice are those who need it themselves. I can't tell you where to go or what decisions to make, but I have no doubt you'll make the right ones. I'm going into college in the fall myself, so it'll be a time of change for me too. I'm anxious about what might come in my way, but I'm too excited about what will come next to worry about what I didn't achieve in my past. I wish you the best of luck in your new high school, and in everything you do. I can see you have the capability to become a wonderful person, and I'm glad I got to be a part if that.

@Raspberries Rrandom


Do yoh can make video: Who is most popular qirl in canterlot high.... Rarity, Rainbow dash, Aplejack, Fluthershy, Pinky pie, or Sunet Shimmer... Please anwser..... 😅😊😀😁


Nothr demenshon sorry for my bad righting


?????????????????? What a worrying what are you talking about


As I see the way dimensions work in the mlp verse is that all the "reality" dimensions exist above the even larger dream dimension.  The dream dimension would act like a lower dimension to all that enter it.  Essentially making all of them pseudo gods  (Maybe discord comes from a higher dimension then) and manipulate the own small piece of the world.  I think that is where twilight went when she ascended so she could bypass the natural laws of magic in her world.


Cool theory! This really helps explain some things referring to dreams. Thanks for another great video!


I like to think of it as a big giant dream dimension where everypony has there own bubble. Inside those bubbles, everpony has there own patch of the dimension where anything can happen. Luna can combine bubbles (dreams), so that ponies can have shared dreams. There can also be wacky ways to transport from one dream to another as shown in "sweetie bell toils".


This was a cool video to go along with a pretty good episode.<br>The only thing is, I'm not sure the writers thought this far ahead, because remember back to the season 4 finale, the first part to be precise, We see Celestia sleeping for a moment, tossing and turning and then waking up and Luna rushes in, we know that Luna was watching her dream and that's why there's a big fuss because some old Jedi Centaur dude is coming to suck. But the actual point I'm making is that Celestia didn't have a white string thing on her forehead when Luna was watching her dream. So I do believe your theory, I just don't think it was always true, but I'm fine if the cannon of the show changes every now and then.

This was a cool video to go along with a pretty good episode.
The only thing is, I'm not sure the writers thought this far ahead, because remember back to the season 4 finale, the first part to be precise, We see Celestia sleeping for a moment, tossing and turning and then waking up and Luna rushes in, we know that Luna was watching her dream and that's why there's a big fuss because some old Jedi Centaur dude is coming to suck. But the actual point I'm making is that Celestia didn't have a white string thing on her forehead when Luna was watching her dream. So I do believe your theory, I just don't think it was always true, but I'm fine if the cannon of the show changes every now and then.


I still think that it's in our heads, considering that the connection reached their foreheads, and that it's been scientifically proven that only certain areas of the brain can participate in dreams, and not the entire brain.  Although this would seem to interfere with the actions which you can do in the "Dream World", all you're doing is imagining yourself doing that action.


For me this is easy to keep track of (I watch game theory so that is why xD) I will say that all dreams happen in another dimension. It seems the most "logical" and would explain a lot of different things in my opinions. Nice video btw :)


I just wanna say that I love your channel and how much I love your theory's but this one really made me think......  While I was watching the video I started to really thinkin about what you said,  it all made sense.  I did feel like you missed a less literal piece. When you think about it, the way dreams get in the real world is if you did it your self,  for example : many artist such as TV show creators dream things and find them so amazing, they decide to actually incorporate it with the show, which I think makes sense to the world we live in right now but how ever for what you were talking about during the video, made total sense to me and and gives me a such deeper meaning of this show so THX.  😊


I actually thought of this before. There are several dimensions (we also saw the one discord opened at the gala) and just a few magical creatures have the ability to switch between these dimensions.
The dream Dimension is a place that is copied from a pony's mind that's why most Dreams arw forgotton when the pony wakes up, because it wasn't physically there.
Luna has the ability to connect them and enter them. To See a physically existing pony with a strong bond to the real world, a pony is able to remember the dream.
My OC's magic works the exact opposite way than Luna's. She can't enter the dream world herself, she can just see it and take things out of it like we can for example print a data that only exists on our computer.


Also note that in shared dreams, the location thus far seems to be a shared location. I am thinking that when luna creates shared dreams she draws the dream world closer to the depicted location. And since so many strings were drawn, perhaps the worlds were drawn to a point in which they overlap in some places. Thus Luna was both in the physical world and the dream world.


Okay, if I mention some points of your theory here, don't mind it. I'm just trying to keep track of what you're saying and add some points of my own theory.

Luna entering dreams is what I might call astral projection, I think. I don't think she had to keep track of everypony's actions during the shared dream and I also doubt that made her tiring. In fact, dreaming itself is tiring because it keeps the brain active even in sleep.

In real life dreaming, lucid dreaming can be done to control nightmares. If someone experiences a nightmare and and gets very frightened, the experience will increase in intensity so that means he/she is literally feeding the nightmare fear. That might be the cause of why the nightmare thingy in the episode gets stronger and stronger.

But then the ponies were sharing the SAME DREAM and that means they might be ASTRAL TRAVELLING. Astral travelling is when a person enters the spirit realm. I think this is how the nightmare ripped through the realms and entered the real world because the spirit realm and reality are connected. For example, people experiencing supernatural events.\

How can something in a dream pass in real life? I think it's because some people can actually PROPHETIC DREAM.

Your dream-dimension can make sense but then, like I have mentioned earlier, this might we what we call astral travelling. Now, you said that the real physical Luna might be the Luna with the connecting wires things in her horn during the shared dream. For me, it's unlikely because you can't PHYSICALLY enter a dream or the spirit realm. Luna controls her dreamself like any other pony does and it just may be the dream luna who is Lucid Dreaming to keep the connections active.

//Ey! ILLUMINATI

Anyways, to answer your final question, there are two kinds of dreaming we can classify into either happening in individual ponies' heads and the spirit realm where spirits can connect to each other like a server: Ordinary dream [with individual lucid dreaming] is classified into an individual's dream, astral travelling and prophetic dreaming which is classified into the spirit realm. One type of dreaming can mix and connect the two types: LUCID DREAMING.


Everything begins as mere thought, until we make it real. If the tantibus was simply the result of a spell that affected dreams then the tantibus, by accessing the magic of enough ponies, could copy itself into another spell and make itself manifest in physical space.

The stuff around Luna are artistic, things look different in dreams than they do IRL. As such, perhaps Luna couldn't help but manifest herself as she actually looked at that moment, took too much concentration to manifest otherwise. Thus we see Luna without the glow and stuff when she doesn't need to concentrate all that hard, and we do see it when she does need to concentrate.

Also, I suspect that Luna wanted a more... secure connection... when connecting to the mane-six, so that's why there were all those lines. Otherwise the only reason she could have known that AB, SB and Scootaloo were having nightmares at all was if she was already connected to them before they started having them.

And that just starts getting REALLY creepy.


With the proper existence of magic in the MLP canon, I would say that dreams residing in another dimension is entirely plausible.


My favorite part of the episode was when huge derpy meowed. That, and when S.A.S.D. and Lyra were one pony. It was literally the most (and loudest!) I'd laughed while watching an episode ever.


I would say, expanding the SB&LG reference, "Some dreams are so powerful that they become real."  Buddhism would support this belief with the concept of emptiness.  In a nutshell, emptiness means that reality, as we know it, is just the collective sum of our thoughts.  When you focus on a thought hard and long, it often becomes reality.  That's why the tantabus threatened to escape into the real world, because it was a mystical manifestation of Luna's fear and guilt, which she had been focusing on and nurturing for years.


I always wondered that about dreams. I think that maybe dreams are actually another world and we control a small part of it. And the reason we wake up in the morning feeling better than before we went to sleep (if we had a good sleep) is that we got energy from that world.  I like your thearoy! ;)


I think it's a combined effort because our thoughts become what we call dreams as we sleep but then what we think as we sleep go into a dream dimension and that is how we are able to say fly through the air without wings or do stunts you could never do unless you were professionally trained or had the proper equipment.

That's my take on this week's theory, I hope it helped you Brony Notion and anyone out there get a slightly better understanding.


I think that the pony actually leaves their body and go to the dream realm, and they also gain the ability to defy logic.


One thing that irked me about the episode was how empty the 'shared dream' seemed, considering all the ponies we saw. There was at least one fully grown pony, and a multitude of different personalities.  Even taking into account that this is a kids show, I would expect there to be more than just a giant derpy, a Lyra - bon bon thing and flying muffins.


This episode reminded me of Inception. Dreamshare. Luna is taking the roe of the PASIV Devce and linking them all. You have no idea how many story ideas invaded my mind when watching the actions of the ponies in the dream Big Mac an alicorn? Forging. Filthy Rich flying on coins? Creating tools.<br>Now, excuse me. I must go and write this crossover and never finish it due to more ideas for new stories.

This episode reminded me of Inception. Dreamshare. Luna is taking the roe of the PASIV Devce and linking them all. You have no idea how many story ideas invaded my mind when watching the actions of the ponies in the dream Big Mac an alicorn? Forging. Filthy Rich flying on coins? Creating tools.
Now, excuse me. I must go and write this crossover and never finish it due to more ideas for new stories.


Everypony has its own dimension of dreams, so maybe the "ultimate shared dream" that luna created was going on on her own dream dimension, that maybe explains why she had the glowing ball around her, because she connected everypony's minds to her own creating a shared dream really hard to keep on.<br>


It does make sense that it would be in another dimension but also the rules of this dimension seem to be drastically different from the rules of our world. It the Dream Dimension you can create anything from you imagination whereas in the real world you cannot. Also the Tantibus could be an alternate version of Luna to emphasise this point there is a scene where the Tantibus returns to Luna and becomes part of her. My theory is that the Tantibus is just Lunas guilt manifested in the form of the blue smoke. This would also explain why it gets bigger when she feels more guilt but also why it is in the form of blue smoke. The blue smoke could be reference to the blue smoke that Nightmare Moon transformed into in episodes 1 and 2. It would also explain why in the forest scene why she was able to turn the trees into something scary. So what I believe is that the Tantibus is just a part of Nightmare moon that was either left over or re-created.


What if every dream had it's own separate dimension? I mean, I haven't watched this episode yet, but would it be possible?


Well the Blue Smoke Thing ( Forgot what it's called) started out in Luna's dream because of her fear of nightmare moon. But in Luna's dream she sees the mane 6 so it makes all 7 dream the same dream.
And most of the time when we have dreams or nightmares it's usually something in the real world. And since Nightmare Moon is or was real the dream could escape into the real world. In the episode "Sleepless in Ponyville" Luna says that you have to face your fears or the nightmares will continue, and since Luna lives in fear of Nightmare Moon she could only stop the Blue Smoke by forgiving herself for her past self. But if Luna were to continue fearing Nightmare Moon then the Blue Smoke would grow stronger and stronger until it could escape the real world and affect the ponies in all equestria.
(This is just a thought don't hate)


Whoa whoa whoa, hold on a second. Do you guys recall the forest clearing from Applebloom's dream in Bloom and Gloom? And do you recall that same clearing appearing in the trailer for the new Equestrian Girls movie, apparently through the portal discovered by human Twilight? Is the perhaps some kind of connection here, especially if dreams really are alternate dimensions?


I think shared dream Luna allowed herself to be seen with the dream strings so the rest of Ponyville could understand what was happening. Think about it:

The Mane 6 knew in advance of what was going to happen regarding Luna and the dreams, so no explanation was necessary. Ponyville, on the other hoof, didn't. Appearing like this would give the other ponies a better idea of what was happening (as well as expedience).

Maybe that's also why Luna couldn't defeat the Tantabus in the Mane 6's dreams. So much effort was going into monitoring the dreams, coupled with the fact that she didn't want help, that she wasn't strong enough. And by the time we got to the shared dream and the Mighty Morphin' Power Ponies were helping it had gotten too strong.

Anyway, that's my take on it.

Bro Hoof


You're 3/4 right.  The dream world isn't another dimension, but a different level of the same universe.  Sort of like a pocket dimension, but, different slightly.
It's like the rungs of a ladder.  The ladder being the dimension and the rungs being different levels.  they live in the waking world on one rung of the ladder, but when they fall asleep, it's like they're reaching up to a higher rung without being able to fully step to it.
The reason things could pass from the dream world to the real one is that if they have enough power they can step from one rung to the next, though the higher up the ladder you go, the bigger the spacing and more energy required to go from one to the next.

This does raise a question.  If beings of higher power can go from one level to the next, could they use that ability to travel large distances?  Time doesn't need to be linear in the dream world, it can slow down so much that it could be an instant in the real world.
so, in theory, luna/celestia could go to the dream world and make it so that time moves differently and think out decisions that would take a really long time.

I don't know, but it sure is a good idea.


i think that the doors apple bloom saw in her dreams were doors that lead to other pony's dreams. Luna creates shared dreams buy removing the doors so they all see the same things. that is why it's hard for her to keep the dream together, the doors want to come back and divide the dreams again


Silly Notion, don't you get it that it's both!! When we are asleep, our minds are constantly sending out neural transmissions signifying that we definitely have activity going on while we are asleep. Our connection to the 'dream dimension' is WITH our brains (which are inside our heads!!), not unlike how Luna connected herself to the Dreams of the Mane Six so her Dream self could move about them individually. However, connecting dreams is something much more difficult to do with just the human mind(s). Luna's connection to every dream means she must have an anchor point, I.E. her bubble AND the energy strings she's using. Having everypony in town connected to the same dream, she needed to BE the anchor point, and as such, a Dream Luna couldn't be possible to manifest... she was utilizing a good majority of her power just to keep the ponies connected, let alone being able to do anything herself against the tantabis, which I like to call NMM's spirit. It's a theory shared by many that Luna and NMM are two separate consciousnesses, and this episode doesn't do much to debunk it. Remember the shape it was taking on as it grew? That was NMM's shape, and thus could be the manifestation of NMM THROUGH Luna's guilt and self-blame.
Just a theory!!
Later,
RDF2


i think its real. i mean, that would be awesome, because every pony with enough knowledge and power could enter other pony´s dreams.
or just use a sould traveling spell and follow them the way they took, so it doesnt cost that much energy. :)
anyway, does anyone here know how to animate? i may need an animator for a project of mine. its called Steam Ponies: Bearers of the Elements, and takes place in Equestria 2000 years from now. the mane six fused with the element of harmony gems and cant use them anymore, so the OCs of everyone who is involved need to find the new bearers. it is pretty cool, one hell of a adventure and im pretty sure by the end of the first episode, u gonna be incredibly confused. well, here is the point: because i dont wanna be sued, i dont use any canon characters, allowing everyone´s OC to be part of this. mostly just background characters because i already got the mane cast, but u know.


Well I think this is more simple to be honest... the tentabus was originally created by luna... the real one, so it was a creature created in the real world... so maybe luna sealed in its dreams to accomplish its primary function... but been a part of luna itself means they have the same abilities as luna... ergo... have more energy... create more nightmares... more nightmares more energy...and so on they create the big one mother of all nightmares... but first they need to free itself from the dreams realm and that is only possible with the power of a alicorn or something as powerfull as them...they have the lunas remorse so they gather enough energy to break the sealed from the dream realm, and then they can give nightmares to everyone else... not like the tentabus is bad...its neither good but it is they function... so i see this little thing more like a machine or well... a spell... a summon for be more precise with a primitive inteligence... who goes overloaded by luna...lesson of the day, always be more specific when you create a entity and remember, do not give your skills to travel between dreams...it can become a ture nightmare


I think that the ponies enter the dream world through their minds and end up creating their own room in the dream world were they can have their separate dream, But if the walls are broken then they have a shared dream. But what if the walls have to rebuild themselves therefore the reason Luna was having trouble maintaining the connection because it wasn't a connection of natural causes and she had to keep breaking those walls when they have to be rebuilt. To the ponies they are just in a dream together.


has any one ever heard of tulpa they are an entity that you make using your mind aaaannnd once strong enough (the more that people/ person believes in it the stronger it gets) it can effect physical objects  this would make more sense with this episode and luna seems more of a dream weaver


Yes Notion. This very well could be another dimension where ponies imagined realities come true. BUT! It also could be all imaginary. It IS very mindboggling.


@The Brony Notion  this is actually a very interesting theory you had but like you said:its complicated.<br>Your theories are very logical that it is difficult to argue about them ^^'

@The Brony Notion  this is actually a very interesting theory you had but like you said:its complicated.
Your theories are very logical that it is difficult to argue about them ^^'


The triangle..... Never mind no time for that.<br>The dreams are actually in a dream dimension because if you carefully paid attention the the show Phineas and Ferb, in one of their movies (I think) they travel trough different dimensions. Through every dimension they travel in, the world in there have different perspectives, personalities, and properties. Otherwise know as the 3 p's. So basically it was a dimension of dreams. Wait, is this cannon, idk. Hope you enjoy reading this comment. Or not. Lol.

The triangle..... Never mind no time for that.
The dreams are actually in a dream dimension because if you carefully paid attention the the show Phineas and Ferb, in one of their movies (I think) they travel trough different dimensions. Through every dimension they travel in, the world in there have different perspectives, personalities, and properties. Otherwise know as the 3 p's. So basically it was a dimension of dreams. Wait, is this cannon, idk. Hope you enjoy reading this comment. Or not. Lol.


The dream dimension is a good and easy explaination :)


I think you are right, that there is another dimension like dream dimension, only because whenever I go to sleep I tell myself to try to misbehave, or do another crazy thing because it is just a dream. But I can never do that. Here all the ponies could control themselves in a way, e.g spike becoming big and powerful, Big Mac became an alicorn, etc. I know that what I'm saying is complicated, but just as you said, I'm just as confused as you are.


I agree with notion here, except I think she only does the head string thing when she is trying make her energy use efficient.


also to answer your question i think a dream is a dimension in itself for example i think a story/fanfic or whatever we create is a dimension we can only access with our minds with the exception of Luna and others with possibly some similar magic,psychic ability, technology, or a magic mirror and like the Tantibus  if we give it enough power it could come to our world but that's my theory


The tantabus could be a form of poltergeist , poltergeist are spirits formed by psychokinetic energy' aka mind energy,specifically anger and anxitey , they also need this to feed this energy to keep , keep a metaphysical form in the real world , so the tantabus could be a poltergeist trying to keep a metaphysical form by creating nightmares and anxitey in order to enter our world.


My personal headcanon is that Luna and Celestia are able to travel in and out of a specific dimension (or it's an in between the worlds sort of dimension, I haven't determined). This dimension is the dimension of the mind. I always thought that the place Celestia met Twilight in Magical Mystery Cure (and where we got the illustrious Twilicorn) looked a lot like where Luna took the CMC in their dreams (well, at least Sweetie Belle and Apple Bloom). So that vast starry dimension is, in my head, the dimension of the mind. Celestia used it to show Twilight her memories, and Luna uses it to show people their dreams (past vs future, possibly?). Both dreams and memories are products of the mind.


Damn that's hell of a weird yet still brilliant theory !


@The Brony Notion What if especially vivid dreamers could travel within the dream dimension the way Luna does, even to the point of accessing the Rift-like hallway? Of course, there should be a certain level of vividness required. Even though, for example, I have vivid dreams, I still know them as dreams because of the way they feel and progress. And also because, as I say here (http://www.fimfiction.net/blog/513334/spotlight-review-on-dreams-do-princesses-dream-of-magic-sheep) I tend to have powers or unlikely tech in my dreams. But if we could travel to others' dreams as long as we had enough brain power and dreamed vividly enough, then we might become transcended beings similar to Luna. Suddenly I feel very thankful that none of us do.


I like your theory at 2:00. that could be referred to as The Celestial plane in the fan animation Dinky's Destiny (Prologue). "The plane of existence, between reality and imagination, the plane where Luna enters dreams of ponies." Like another dimension.


I think it's more a bit of both. Luna could have slammed all the dreams of the ponies together and formed a more solid pocket dimension where normally the dreams would run individually into each pony's head. That's not saying that shared dreams itself doesn't exist.

When they was all fighting the tanabus (spelling?) in Ponyville and Luna had a bubble around her I think that was her in the "Real World" using a bubble shield to break into this "Dream World" to keep open communications and keep an eye on the situtation probably because she didn't have enough power to project herself.

The reason for the bubble is more of a firewall/shielding type thing so the dimensions don't bleed into each other. This is much like how you'd have to have a shield to jump into hyperspace with warp drive otherwise you'd blow the ship apart.

As for the white wires and strings I think she doesn't need them exactly. I think she is like a computer with a wifi antenna and a ethernet port. She can connect over wifi but for a really good solid connection which is what she need had to use a "wired" connection.


If you're gonna think about it as a whole new dimension thingy going in there then maybe it is true. I have this headcanon that the ponies have like these dream-selves and they only wake up in the dream-dimension when the real body is asleep and vice versa. But like what you said it is possible to create a rip in space to travel between dimensions.


Am I the only one that thought the...blue wisp thing with a name I can't spell, was a fragment of Nightmare Moon that survived(at least until Luna explained what it was)?


Hold it!
Are you saying that if something lethal happens in that alternate dimension, those ponies could have actually died?

*Hold it!*
Are you saying that if something lethal happens in that alternate dimension, those ponies could have actually *died*?


I think it may be both.<br>The ponies' heads could be a gateway to another dimension, like the dream dimension. It's happening in their heads, but at the same time in another dimension.

I think it may be both.
The ponies' heads could be a gateway to another dimension, like the dream dimension. It's happening in their heads, but at the same time in another dimension.


the writers never thought of that idea and cause of that its hard to think of what it is in that world unlike other theories.


Well i don't know about luna but i think its just that it escapes into the real world by, well... escaping from the dream, the the tantipus isn't just something that the ponies are dreaming about, well i guess it kinda is but the tantipus is an actual creature that luna actually created not from her dreams but just by creating it but your theory about how luna enters dreams is good.


I think the ponies dream in another dimension. Think about it: In the Bloom And Gloom, Luna and Apple Bloom were walking IN a Dream Dimension. Each door represents a dream. That means all the ponies in ponyville walked into the same door. Without the Dream Dimension, nopony could ever dream in Equestria. No Dreams, no Nightmares, and No Day-Dreaming. Then probably, their will be no moon and always day because nopony will ever sleep.


well do hear that some dreams are so powerful they become real so i think there is a dream world or dimension in this world too.


Maybe a little of both? Hear me out. "The dream world" is like a corridor filled with doors, all the doors lead to the minds of ponies, but only if they are sleeping. Or maybe it's like a room/sky filled with stars that represent minds/dreams. Either way, all this is possible because all the ponies have magic. Now, when Luna makes a shared dream she makes a new room/star, then creates a path to that room/star that only her chosen ponies can go. However, since the room/star isn't natural it can disappear even if the ponies in it are still asleep. The more ponies in that room the more likely it is to fall apart.


it happens in another dimesion made by teh pony's minds like u said but, Luna could have created this dimesion to look after the ponies in equestria personaly. this would explain how Luna can easily travel through dreams, its her dimesion.


Anybody else noticed that the Mane Six didn't think to summon the Elements of Harmony or use Rainbow Powa within the dream?<br>Even though they had it in the beginning scene of the episode.

Anybody else noticed that the Mane Six didn't think to summon the Elements of Harmony or use Rainbow Powa within the dream?
Even though they had it in the beginning scene of the episode.


In Equestra, dreams could very well be a means of dimension traveling. But what if it all was in their heads? Then the Tantabus would've ripped multiple holes in all of their subconsciouses! Ahh! 😱 Mind ripped up and blown to pieces!


Well, it doesn't conflict with current cannon, but that leaves this open: why can't Celestia do it?

If the comics are to be believed, in a great arc we have Starswirl and Celestia dimension-hopping to their heart's content. If the dreamworld was a normal dimension, wouldn't they have tried on Luna's ability for size?

Or, perhaps, it is in their minds, but instead of her going to all of them in the shared dream; she's pulling /them/ to /her/, so the real her is manifested.

Shrugs Fun tidbit, bro, as always.

Well, it doesn't conflict with current cannon, but that leaves this open: why can't Celestia do it?

If the comics are to be believed, in a great arc we have Starswirl and Celestia dimension-hopping to their heart's content. If the dreamworld was a normal dimension, wouldn't they have tried on Luna's ability for size?

Or, perhaps, it is in their minds, but instead of her going to all of them in the shared dream; she's pulling /them/ to /her/, so the real her is manifested.

-Shrugs- Fun tidbit, bro, as always.


I think it's both, like in the brain there is a dimension to the dream world, so when Luna goes into the dreams she goes into the dimension to get into the mind-just a theory


each ponies have their own dream dimension(the reason why there's so many doors leading to other dreams) when luna made the wire conection thingy she made all the dream dimensions of everypony in ponyville

as for why was the real world luna was visible in the dream well i would say it would have taken more magic to keep her dream form

idk if i made sense


I have a theory, reality is a dream and a dream is, well, a dream. And when you die, you are mature enough to go into the real world.


If the dream world is another dimension, then why would Luna need those strings on the pony's foreheads to see their dreams? I think it's a mix of both, a dimension and part of the pony's head. The dream world is in the pony's head, so if there is no pony, the dimension is gone.That's why Luna was in the same dream world with Ponyville. She was asleep as well. So to control the dream world, Luna needs to sleep as well.


i think there's a diffrent dimension for the dream world, seems more possible than just being in a pony's head.


I think all of this happened inside Lunas' head. She just connected everyone through herself. Remember, it became harder to keep up with everyone giving themselves new powers?


Okay. In the very beginning,it was just celestia. She ruled but day and night. She was not meant to rule the night so that's when luna came along. She created the dream world and ruled it throughout the night. When she was nightmare moon, she could give ponies nightmares.


Dreams happen in the dream world, a world that is beyond ours.


i thought of your theory before i got in to the show but i'm glad i'm not the only one who thought of it :)


I also thought because Luna believed it would enter the real world it might not have we never saw it actually go into the real world just exiting through a hole. Also one question would be why did the tantalus just give up once Luna came to acceptance if it actually stored power. Unless the tantalus was somehow connected to Luna magically like a dream Luna? Idk anyone wanna pitch in?


If I could control my dream, I would never wake up and if I did, I would drink night quil to fall back asleep.


Isn't a theory: It said in the episode that Luna created the monster thingy to punish her self for what she did as nightmare moon, but why would she give it the power to jump into other dream, or jump into the real world and destroy everything, she kinda brought it upon herself


I think there's a dream dimensions, that we can connect it. Anyway, MIND BLOW!!!  :)


@The Brony Notion Celestia Also Controls A Different World That's when twighlight got her wings then if luna controls The Dream World That Means That when the creature that luna created could go to the real world because it fed off of luna's guilt so it just got bigger when luna felt bad she made it but she was the only one to stop it but yes the dream world is another world so there are more worlds then equestria maybe other creatures are in the dream world that can ruin ponyville and equestria.


Some dreams are so powerful they became real


MLP wouldn't be the first to introduce dreams as another dimension I know for a fact that the show Ultimate Spider-Man has the same thing with dreams as a dimension.


How can something from the mind get into real life? The Matrix.


me and my friend had the same dream once. and we both remeber the conversation


"Of course it is happening in your head, Harry, but why on earth should that mean that it is not real?" -Dumbledore


Maybe the inherent magic every pony in Equestria is what allows them to have a presence in the dream dimension o3o


I have a question if Luna can walk through dreams whenever ponies r sleeping then what can celestia do


I think the dreams happen just how you said in an another dimension also you should do a video about the trailers of the 3rd my little pony equestria girls I think its called friendship games but the trailers look awesome


Ever pony has magic, and the mind uses that magic to make dream version of the pony.


The dream world is another dimension. Not all in the ponies mind. My question: how are they brought there every night?


But if the string thingies were present in the dream shouldn't there have been a portal to constantly connect them to the real world? And if so, why didn't the Tantabus use that portal?


Alternate dimensions are cool, so that's what i'm going with


it's klefky and darkrai
one remember what i said about Giratina Palkia and Dialga it's the same as discord
two i realised that Klefky can hold different keys i saw pikachu's adventures and can unlock different doors
three darkrai can send anyone to the nightmares and can see what happens in the future and the present
and four i believe it's the sea crown i saw one the same thing

Moonstone silver diamond team Mr. M the top heroes


With all of that, I think it could be both.


Ya I agree tbn I think it is in the dream word

P.S awesome theory lol


Can anyone tell me what that eye flash in the triangle was?<br>Details please!

Can anyone tell me what that eye flash in the triangle was?
Details please!


Magic. If everything else in Equestria has some connection to magic, why not dreams?  An alteration on your dimension theory is that every dreamer's dream exists within its own magical realm external to normal reality.  Perhaps there is a realm within which all dreams exist in pockets or bubbles, each new night of dreaming or even each new dream making a new bubble, and that bubble "popping" once the dream is over.  Luna has the ability to pass (or project an avatar) into this dream realm and access a dream bubble, but must use her "dream door directory" before she can target another dream bubble unless the dreams were linked before she went in.  The Tantabus, however, being a creature made in and for the dream realm, can pass between dream bubbles through the link of a thought about somepony else.  It can also, (being a piece of Tim Taylor Technology) with more power, pass backwards out of the dream realm in a similar manner to Luna entering it.

Magic. If everything else in Equestria has some connection to magic, why not dreams?  An alteration on your dimension theory is that every dreamer's dream exists within its own magical realm external to normal reality.  Perhaps there is a realm within which all dreams exist in pockets or bubbles, each new night of dreaming or even each new dream making a new bubble, and that bubble "popping" once the dream is over.  Luna has the ability to pass (or project an avatar) into this dream realm and access a dream bubble, but must use her "dream door directory" before she can target another dream bubble unless the dreams were linked before she went in.  The Tantabus, however, being a creature made in and for the dream realm, can pass between dream bubbles through the link of a thought about somepony else.  It can also, (being a piece of Tim Taylor Technology) with _more_ _power_, pass backwards out of the dream realm in a similar manner to Luna entering it.


Here's something: what if the tantabus was never real in the first place? It never actually entered the real world. So we can never be sure. And I wouldn't made an inception reference in ur video.


yay! I got the "obscure reference time"picture! Sharkboy and Lavagirl!


i think the dream world is like the dream scape in gravity falls


I believe that the dream world is another dimension. I also think that is the same for us in our world.


@The Brony Notion   think it would most likely be a new dimension as Luna did say she was the only one able to go into other ponies minds to see their dreams, so the ponies couldn't have had them in their heads because of this reason. <br>Also when i saw this video, the dream world weirdly reminded me of the episode where Celestia took Twilight when she became a princess with all her memories....... Any explanations?

@The Brony Notion   think it would most likely be a new dimension as Luna did say she was the only one able to go into other ponies minds to see their dreams, so the ponies couldn't have had them in their heads because of this reason.
Also when i saw this video, the dream world weirdly reminded me of the episode where Celestia took Twilight when she became a princess with all her memories....... Any explanations?

@Anna Rivaille Ackerman McFadden Magical Mystery Cure . . . I don't think that was a dream world.


“Of course it is happening inside your head, Harry, but why on earth should that mean that it is not real?” - Dumbledor


i think its a dif dimension that would be awesome luna is my fave and would love 2 c an ep for that


What if some pony's dream version went through the portal and ended up in ponyville? Like for The Brony Notion to do a theory!


The dream dimension is called the Dreamscape


Can't be in there minds because when the tantivis cut through the dream world that means it's cutting through there minds which would hurt a lot <br>


It's in another dimension, why? Luna said herself that Celestial had no power in... "DA REALM OF SLEEP!"


Why didn´t they just wake everyone in ponyville,and have one pony sleeping so Luna could catch the..thing


@The Brony Notion i guess  u are right. the dream world must be another dimension<br>   i mean just look at all the other dimensions if those exist then why not a dream dimension? the thing that really is stuck in my mind is that luna is a server and all the ponies the string thing was attached to was a player having a computer :3

@The Brony Notion i guess  u are right. the dream world must be another dimension
   i mean just look at all the other dimensions if those exist then why not a dream dimension? the thing that really is stuck in my mind is that luna is a server and all the ponies the string thing was attached to was a player having a computer :3


Im sorta worried that the Tantabus might be with the changelings! Because Rainbow Dash dreamed about them.


This episode in mlp is like the episode dreamscapes from gravity falls


I think they all were in Luna's dream not in their individual dream


Dreams occur in a different dimension. And the  Tantabus is created in that dimension.


You might be right cause only discord can access that sock puppet world well maybe also pinky but ya I'm not thinking to hard on that part cause I will go brain dead but in this episode luna does say to the mane six that Celestia can't not help or enter the dreams of others like she can so I believe it is another dimension that only Luna can enter at will then with that bubble I think cause she is connecting so many dreams to one big dream that possibly could mean there be multiple Lunas in that big dream so that bubble is keeping all them to one body instead of being in multiple places which might cut Luna's magic in half so she be weak and not  be able to hold the dreams together and for all those that say what about discords home dimension (aka chaos dimension) that the mail pony got in that could be cause of a special door that discord made for mail to get to his chaos world home that or discord did get the invite from Celestia so she might have been able to send him with discord reformed if celestia needed discord or needed to check on him in that world she was probably able to go back and for therefore sending the mail pony in there with the invite to the gala


oh just great, thanks to you @The Brony Notion NOW MY MIND IS BLOWN


I think tht it is in another demission because luna did say in tht episode tht its another realm tht celestia would have no power in so if its another realm i would believe it's in another demission to


Was it just me or was it really easy to understand not confusing at all


i think when a pony dreams they enter a dream dimension. this dimension can be accessed by luna and maybe she created this dream world so she could watch over and protect every pony <br>idk its my gues @The Brony Notion

i think when a pony dreams they enter a dream dimension. this dimension can be accessed by luna and maybe she created this dream world so she could watch over and protect every pony
idk its my gues @The Brony Notion


Nice reference to Shark boy and Lava Girl. That is a very obscure reference.<br>


It happens in there heads but they dream in the other dimension


Yay you referenced shark boy and lava girl 😀


I some how kept up WOW!!!????!!!! your theory is (to me) is right mostly because of the luna thing.


I fell like luna made the dream world so that why she can switch between the real world and the dream world


I think that it might be in another dimension


"Of course this is happening in your head Harry. Why does that have to mean that it's not real?" Professor Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore


the dream world is real but mental engery from the mind is stronger in that world that why your mind can effect


2 things
1. I agree with you :3
2. I saw that illuminati in the triangle >:)


And what ever they think will come true in the episode dreamscapers from gravity falls


Luna just made it up xD But that blue magic is real I think...


So what you're saying is that ponies enter the Fade? (DRAGON AGE REFERENCE)


That makes 6 dimensions
Ours
Ponies
Pomans? Hunies?
Sock puppets (possibly our dreams?)
Pony dreams
PomanHuny dreams


How can luna dreaming? Wich pony(creature) controll her dreams?

@The Brony Notion I don't understand anything of you're videos, BUT I look it (I speak germany and russian)! XD


@The Brony Notion Do you have any thoughts on Rainbow Factory? Because I think there is quite a big possibility that it is real (of course never shown in a kids show) +1 this comment if you agree.

Yes because I wanna kill the Pegasus XD °V° today will be der doom °#° XD


Tantibu... tanibis... How do you spell it? I'm trying to get as much information on this creature and been looking since the episode aired but can't find anything. Not counting a comic book publisher. Is this a new creature created for the mlp universe or is there a lore of it somewhere I can't find? I know mlp mostly uses creatures from Greek mythology but nothing other than Anubis and Hermanubis. I've gotta be missing something, but what?

@Original_NoLifeGamer<br>Tantabus was created by Luna's sub-conscious as a form self punishment. That's about it. While I enjoy the inspirations of classical mythologies, I do like that this is, at least, something original and brand new.

@Original_NoLifeGamer
Tantabus was created by Luna's sub-conscious as a form self punishment. That's about it. While I enjoy the inspirations of classical mythologies, I do like that this is, at least, something original and brand new.

@Zminator1986 How did I miss that I thought I looked at everything... huh. Unfortunately there's no lore on it :/ just the episode description lol I was hoping for something like <i>originated in ancient Greek mythology as a daemon that'll kill you in your sleep like freddie kruger</i> or something. Thank you tho :) glad to see there's something on it :D

@Zminator1986 How did I miss that I thought I looked at everything... huh. Unfortunately there's no lore on it :/ just the episode description lol I was hoping for something like _originated in ancient Greek mythology as a daemon that'll kill you in your sleep like freddie kruger_ or something. Thank you tho :) glad to see there's something on it :D

@Original_NoLifeGamer
Translate "nightmare" in latin. At least that's what I heard. Also there is a blurb on the Tantabus on the MLPwiki ->

http://mlp.wikia.com/wiki/Creatures#Tantabus

@ijones36 I did and couldn't find anything. I think I might have spelled it wrong... either way I'll keep looking into it but I'm beginning to think that they created it for the show.

My advice? Check the mlp wiki ( yes theres an unoffical wiki for the show)<br>If its based on anything from mythology someones bound to have listed it there

My advice? Check the mlp wiki ( yes theres an unoffical wiki for the show)
If its based on anything from mythology someones bound to have listed it there


I'm pretty sure there are some servers called Luna out there.


In real life our soul or our ghost inside our body is travelling to its own world and we see it as dream. But in pony ville or in equestrian I don't have aaaaaaaaannny idea :D. Don't feel like I hurt your mind brony notion if it does I'm sorry


pause at 3:12 anyone notice berry punch has wings?


I think that the dreams do happen in po ies heads. Necause thats Equestria not real life. Your explabation make too much sense for oir world, and in a few videos you said that Equestria isnt real life. And the dream realm<br>/dimension is in the ponies heads. The parts of the dimension/realm are separeted within small parts between every single pony. So this means that your explanation and mine collide with eich other. Yeah that makes sense in Equestria.

I think that the dreams do happen in po ies heads. Necause thats Equestria not real life. Your explabation make too much sense for oir world, and in a few videos you said that Equestria isnt real life. And the dream realm
/dimension is in the ponies heads. The parts of the dimension/realm are separeted within small parts between every single pony. So this means that your explanation and mine collide with eich other. Yeah that makes sense in Equestria.


Like there magic lets them go to the other dimension. Because there mind cast a spell to make them go to the dimension


perhaps its mot a dream i mean luna has magic and all but we would she go in a another dimension, but my theory is that she probably make illusions for ponies so they THINK they are dreaming >>.<<


I think another dimension. I mean, come on its mlp anything can happen.


cue inception music 3:39 Ilu Imari controls dreams XD

*cue inception music* 3:39 Ilu Imari controls dreams XD


Bring notion, I was wondering, why is your background always the apple orchard .


dimsenoin mlp eg 5 should be about human sunset entering dreams XD


In the triangle there was an eye for a second


It could happen in another dimension because mlp


Well luna is the only one who can enter the dream dimension be cause she is the pony of the night but to every poky els it's in there mind that's why Lina had to connect to the head


maybe it's a dimension or it came from pony's heads who knows i certianly don't :(

sorry


The brony notion's cutie mark represents a " minecraft?" Music note


IT WAS BOB THE BUILDER

I'm not a fan of btb...first thing that popped in my mind


Really?! I saw that freakin illuminati symbol!


if you haven'y already looked in the discussion box on your chanel.. maybe.. i said that  i have a idea for the new song that came out from SDCC this year and wanted to know if you wanted to hear it.  respond back please so i know its alright to tell you... k?


Please don't use anymore Tim and Eric awesome show great job clips or references, or anything related to it. Because it really is a terrible show.


:goes two tailed beast state: COME AT ME TANTABUS


Witch episode and season tell me pleaze?


um dude if theres dream luna in sweety belles dream right princess luna come to sweaty belle to fix the hat


3:39 was i the only one that saw illuminati


I don't really think so about the strings when the threes kids sorry I forgot there names but she can do this when she sleep to you know

—【ヴァドス】Vadosu

this was weird! still people need to explain the being that took over luna

Illuminati for one second in the red triangle!...mind blown jajaja


Ha, everyone else is pointing out the Illuminati refrance while I point out the Doctor Who refrance.


Well i agree whith u cuss i didnt know what whas happing


During the ambiance big big message with 110 industries dennis dillon 27 francis file i was in texas princess luna plindustrial avengers at night maryland nightmare molasses the process walmart in her ham to the mall and the highgate get back sam's well nice name againtwilight another homemade you there and processes last time that is the morn is back to the keswick to the slave again