Always a fun surprise seeing a vector of mine in the thumbnail of one of your videos :u

محمد الفغم١١٥٦٧٧٧١٠

You’re wrong Twilight Sparkle Jeff get a little bit to the artefacts and the three trimes give her some more

محمد الفغم١١٥٦٧٧٧١٠

@Sawtooth Waves  But what happened with other alicorns? Twilight sacrificed her magic, but what about others? Where Celestia, Luna, Cadence and Flurry Heart go? What happened to them? They couldn't just disappeared

Татьяна Андрианова

@JellyPikachu and Franklin same here and I finally got a email to subscribe!!!

@JellyPikachu and Franklin same here and I finally got a email to subscribe!!!

Then I would be right about Sunny being Twilight's descendant.

Then I would be right about Sunny being Twilight's descendant.

@JellyPikachu and Franklin I think I was around the same age when I had started watching their videos, MLP was the first fandom I’d be welcomed by on the internet and I’ll always cherish it for that. :)

See in the mirror picture the each crystals have  Three triangles coloured like Twilight's cutie mark.

@Sawtooth Waves What about the sun and moon riseing by it's self?

@Sawtooth Waves What about the sun and moon riseing by it's self?

@Sawtooth Waves What about the sun riseing by it's self?

@Sawtooth Waves What about the sun riseing by it's self?

twilight must have made a morally grey choice and likely realized that things would sort themselves out even at the cost of losing Equestria. hope is never too far gone in the eyes of the beholder.

Pinned comments always have so many other random things in them, probably because they are at the top. Shoot, now I'm contributing to it....

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 Yes but what does that have to do with what anyone was talking about? Maybe I'm just tired--?

@JellyPikachu and Franklin  I think I was like 9 or 10.

@JellyPikachu and Franklin  I think I was like 9 or 10.

My mom and dad are changelings and so is my sister.

My mom and dad are changelings and so is my sister.

Kevin the changeling is ancient and legandary.

Kevin the changeling is ancient and legandary.

@Sawtooth Waves Os for muy The questions?

@Sawtooth Waves Os for muy The questions?

@Sawtooth Waves <br>Hello Sawtooth Waves. I became a new member of ur group. And I have a thought that came when u made this theory of what happened to Twilight Sparkle. We all know that Discord is the spirit of Chaos and disharmony, the spirit of the tree of Harmony represents Harmony and friendship. What if Twilight Sparkle's sacrifice made an intense connection to her, that even when she pass away physically, her spirit is still alive; waiting to encourage and help the next rising generation of ponies with her advice and experience?

@Sawtooth Waves
Hello Sawtooth Waves. I became a new member of ur group. And I have a thought that came when u made this theory of what happened to Twilight Sparkle. We all know that Discord is the spirit of Chaos and disharmony, the spirit of the tree of Harmony represents Harmony and friendship. What if Twilight Sparkle's sacrifice made an intense connection to her, that even when she pass away physically, her spirit is still alive; waiting to encourage and help the next rising generation of ponies with her advice and experience?

I think that to I think she  gave  away her all magic and she died it sounds bad I know but I think that

@Maria Alsalim not telling sorry it’s private!

@Maria Alsalim not telling sorry it’s private!

@JellyPikachu and Franklin how old r u now? 7.5?

@JellyPikachu and Franklin how old r u now? 7.5?

I am so glad you are now satisfied and not hungry or starving?

I am so glad you are now satisfied and not hungry or starving?

Sawtooth..im worid u havent bin oplouding...pleas oploud more...

Sawtooth..im worid u havent bin oplouding...pleas oploud more...

@Sawtooth Waves I think a part of your theory might be wrong. In season 4's "Twilight's Kingdom" Princesses Celestia Cadence and Luna gave up their magic, storing it in Twilight, but they didn't lose their wings OR horns. All they lost was their cutie marks. So shouldn't it have been the same for Twily? But I could be wrong. What do you think Sawtooth?

The changeling kingdom village and castle.

The changeling kingdom village and castle.

What saw tooth is a royal changeling. Changeling royalty.

What saw tooth is a royal changeling. Changeling royalty.

@Sawtooth Waves If here she sacrificed made all magic disappeared temporarily,then what about Windigos who always appears when 3 pony tribes are at in disharmony.

What about the diverse culture of Griffons,Dragons,Hippogriffs,Yaks and Changelings mixed like from the episode:"The last Problem

@Ahmedahmed1975 Ahmedahmed1975  she's dead because she was going against her mother and father and brother and sister in law and niece and nephew.

omg but she was not in the movie did she dead or sheis alive plz tell

omg but she was not in the movie did she dead or sheis alive plz tell

Because to her he was dear. He didn't mean to replace his truly  beloved mother. He just wanted this kind to be happier and himself. He just wanted his mother to be happier too.

Because she was just trying to do what was best for her son.

Because she was just trying to do what was best for her son.

I know chrysalis was not good person but I hope thorax forgives her.

I know chrysalis was not good person but I hope thorax forgives her.

Ah I don't know what is in this pie but I think I just saw king sombra. This scary.

I don't know what is in this pumpkin pie but I think I just saw queen chrysalis.

I hear king thorax cot sawtooth and took him to the hive.

I hear king thorax cot sawtooth and took him to the hive.

@Kryistel Joy Panganiban sine waves is back and badder than ever.

@Kryistel Joy Panganiban sine waves is back and badder than ever.

Sine I am wanting to tell you about prime he's in trouble thorax got him.

Sine I am wanting to tell you about prime he's in trouble thorax got him.

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 are you… are you being fake-racist to a fake persona who is a fake species…?

@Sawtooth Waves you are the best changeling ever.

@Sawtooth Waves you are the best changeling ever.

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 Ok well then tell him that he's the best My Little Pony Youtuber ever.  🦄🌈💖✨🦄🌈💖✨🦄🌈💖✨🦄🌈💖✨🦄🌈💖✨🦄🌈💖✨

The least king thorax could do is pick a female because a male can't give birth on his own.

I am just a poor changeling villager living in the changeling kingdom village.

I am just a poor changeling villager living in the changeling kingdom village.

And the nameless one is his pet alicorn. Sketchy. Countess rose. Any. And Kevin are his knights. Dr wolf canned cream and event horizon are his noble people.

He is the son of queen ocellus and king pharynx. Nephew of King thorax. Grandson of Queen chrysalis. And younger brother of princess Larynx.

Sawtooth is a prince of the changeling kingdom castle.

Sawtooth is a prince of the changeling kingdom castle.

@Unicorn Fairy I am from the changeling too but I don't serve chrissy or thorax I am a democracy changeling.

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 What do you mean

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 What do you mean

Just what I am a changeling but I am a good love giving one.

Just what I am a changeling but I am a good love giving one.

@Sawtooth Waves HER PEOPLE!!!!  You mean her ponies

@Sawtooth Waves HER PEOPLE!!!!  You mean her ponies

@Sawtooth Waves Can’t wait for your next video! 🦄🌈💖🦄🌈💖🦄🌈🦄🌈💖🦄🌈💖🦄🌈💖🦄🌈💖🦄🌈💖🦄🌈💖🦄🌈💖🦄🌈💖

@Sawtooth Waves i think i finally solved of what happened!!!!

@Sawtooth Waves i think i finally solved of what happened!!!!

@ibrahim ahmad  Nope, Sunny's dad is😏 (i think)

@ibrahim ahmad  Nope, Sunny's dad is😏 (i think)

And countess rose sketchy and any are his beloved knight and guards who keep him safe from the evil rift cafe monsters. That's the truth.

I am Ian harrison everyone i am a changeling my nickname is bug insect. I am from the hive. I am a citizen of sawtooth waves prince of the hive. I live in the lowest of the hive. I know saw tooth because he is the son of Queen ocellus and king pharynx. Nephew of King thorax. Grandson of Queen chrysalis and younger brother of princess larynx. I am a villagers. And I am  sawtooth's most loyal subject. Finally he is royal . He is the most important members of the changeling royal family. That's the truth.

@Sawtooth Waves is an ancient and legendary historical figure from earliest know point of equestria. I know because I am as old and ancient as he is.

It's OK I agree but some things in life which you have to do even if you don't want to.

@Sawtooth Waves you have to have variety in your Playlist.

@Sawtooth Waves you have to have variety in your Playlist.

@Sawtooth Waves you can't just make mlp all because no like your non mlp.

@Sawtooth Waves you can't just make mlp all because no like your non mlp.

@John Doolittle why do you agree with me.

@John Doolittle why do you agree with me.

Sawtooth I think it is time to talk about something else that is not about mlp. Because I think you need more variety in your channel.

Sometimes we do other things. It's not right for me to choose the things I want to do all the time.

@Sawtooth Waves Maybe Twilight did not die!!!

@Sawtooth Waves Maybe Twilight did not die!!!

@Sawtooth Waves this is a great concept!

@Sawtooth Waves this is a great concept!

Princess Twilight sparkle is my favourite pony in the world

Princess Twilight sparkle is my favourite pony in the world

Sawtooth I was wondering what happened to Cozy Glow,Christialias and Terek

Sawtooth I was wondering what happened to Cozy Glow,Christialias and Terek

Hey sawtooth maybe Twilight is sunny's mom

Hey sawtooth maybe Twilight is sunny's mom

So where is celetian and luna them is immortal to

So where is celetian and luna them is immortal to

@Sawtooth Waves what happened to disc.ord they know of him in the news movie

@Sawtooth Waves what happened to disc.ord they know of him in the news movie

@Sawtooth Waves  friendship can't change who you are or take away your roots or change where you came from.

You know who you are and diversity can't change that.

You know who you are and diversity can't change that.

@Sawtooth Waves I’m a huge fan of you I’ve watched you since I was 7 years old!

@Sawtooth Waves I’m a huge fan of you I’ve watched you since I was 7 years old!

@Sawtooth Waves I love seeing what people do with my vectors, so thank you too!!

i was so excited when i found that art and saw the permission to use badge!! your work is super great and sparks the imagination!!! thank you <333


I'm actually crying and honestly the only thing I see is that I don't think Twilight became a mortal I think she sacrificed herself completely the last form being an earth pony. Each crystal took an element her wings her horn and finally her strength as an earth pony - the day she made those crystals was the last day she lived. Thank You for this video

PLS THIS IS SO SAD : '( twily is my fav pony :(

I think that’s not what happened but I doubt she was being selfish

as much as i hate to admit it, it makes sense. but if hasbro ever confirms this theory, i think they'll just go with Sawtooth's version, since yours might be a bit too dark 💔

Same, Ive been watching MLP since I was six or seven, and now that I know this, I am kinda sad 😔 all those memories are coming back...

Jose Torres Im sorry but i don't understand your theory

@Abbi You're replying a little too aggressively to a few people here. Maybe chill a little...

Jose Torres uhm.. were just theorizing....

Jose Torres uhm.. were just theorizing....

@Nysa Singh  NOW HE'S WRONG READ MY STORY AT THE BOTTOM

@Cynical Blossom  READ MY STORY AT THE BOTTOM

@Jewel Aleksey Santillan  READ MY STORY AT THE BOTTOM

@FroppyFan:D READ MY STORY AT THE BOTTOM

@FroppyFan:D READ MY STORY AT THE BOTTOM

@Bruh  YES SHE MOVED READ MY STORY AT THE BOTTOM

@Ewonders  READ MY STORY AT THE BOTTOM TWILIGHT IS NOT DEAD

@Jaycee Irby  READ MY STORY AT THE BOTTOM

@Jaycee Irby  READ MY STORY AT THE BOTTOM

@Sassy Smores  READ MY STORY AT THE BOTTOM

@Sassy Smores  READ MY STORY AT THE BOTTOM

@Olivia Gomez IT'S NOT WHAT HAPPENED THO

@Olivia Gomez IT'S NOT WHAT HAPPENED THO

@Sundaystorms read mine all the way at the bottom "miss"................

Or maybe twilight isn't even any type of pony maybe somehow she got telaported to the human realm and was a human like the my little pony plp in the high school and the portal broke causing all the main six to stay in the human realm but since spike kinda was the reason for Twilights whole future maybe spike isn't a dog in the human realm and maybe he's not a human either maybe HE got the power as pony and became one of the new ponys but the thing is what pony did he transform into? That's hard but if I'm right I think he transferred into a new Twilight as he technically has her soul but I don't really know there might be two Twilights bc just as midnight moon was trapped in the moon forever maybe Twilight is trapped in the Crystal's forever bc in the show her cutie mark but in the sky and when Twilights new student put the crown on her head she turned into monster right? But Twilight got inside her cutie mark and she went inside the human realm without the REAL portal bc it's broken at that time but Twilight saw the past as she was no longer a part of the future that's why there eyes light up rainbow it wasn't bc there the main six it's bc it's a sign a sign meaning that Twilight came back as they were forced to help the plp being pulled down the pony portals but I think that pony village if no longer a thing bc it's been about 100 year and when Twilight's enemy was going back in the past to not make them the main six anymore maybe when Twilight went into the past she may have been going into the future since no one knows if it's only the past since Twilights done it in one of her spells so pony village is gone and all the main six are now humans but Twilight and her friends know what's happening and as she was the new princess and she had to do that she was doing all of the main six's things to save the whole pony world actually and to save the more future future and the ponys in the future future now are still there but since no one is exactly like Twilight magic is gone and it's like not even a thing anymore Twilight went to the camp but she wasn't afraid to turn into evil her again she was afraid of what ponys would do in the future future and her evil ponys we're going to be just like evil Twilight was and Twilight thought there was going to be a war with nice and mean but then it turned into God and devil like so all theain six are human forever and the new portal is built they are now going to be normal like the other high school students but if they go back to pony village it would be all gone and it would glitch and they all would be inside the Crystal's forever or all the ponys would not see her like she's invisible they would only see the other five not Twilight then if they would go back it would be the same it's a 50/50 chance that that would ever happen but still Twilight would be stuck in the future all over again and the same cycle to all of the main six would happen untill the sixth try bc all of the main six would bc into different time loops and soon they would bc into the future future back where they belong as Twilight the new qween and the new princesses the other five would be that so text me back to learn more

I wish this theory is true since it would be perfect ending for Twilight. But after a long rule of course so she lived her life well.

@Jaycee Irby I feel like that is a possibility if they have their magic back why wouldn't they be able to bring her back like they did the original 6? hmm XD

@Sundaystorms Yeah but remember that now the crystals are gone. just like starswirl they ended up in a purgatory to plant the seeds and harness a certain power that still wasn't completely reliable because the tree of harmony needed the crystal back to stay alive. And the school wasn't made out of the crystals so the school should be irrelevant for this matter.  And because she was making something that is harnessing ALL magic it would make sense that it took her entire body to do it because relic still run out they are just the last thing to run out, so in order for her to make sure it wouldn't run out I think it is reasonable to think that she had to lay down her life in order to ensure that one day magic would return once they put the relics together and harnessed friendship again. Which would act as 'the spark' as stated in s1 e2, when she is explainign the elements to nightmare moon. This would also explain why sunny became an alicorn so easily becuase there wasn't anything required other than prioritizing friendship where as before it was based off of needing all elements of magic whereas sunny still needs to learn all about it.

I'm also agreeing I also thought she died after she made those crystals

Twilight gave her horn and wings and earth pony thing then she would be dead

Actually because it's a kids show I think that's less likely. Kids finding out that Twilight Sparkle of all characters diying would upset them. Hasbro would prolly avoid that.

@Sundaystorms we’re talking about two different sets of magical crystals

Yes and no pls say that’s not true 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

I think she sacrafised herself just to share her magic before she died...or just moved to a new place

Same this show is my comfort show and this theory sounds like it definitely could have happened and it just makes me sad.

Twilight is still a alicorn if she isn't then why did we saw the last one she is still a alicorn don't believe him

I agree, it would explain why the ponies grew apart,  deciding that it's not right to be friends without twilight and grew apart with their respective tribes.

I agree too, and if you look on the mural where the crystals are.. it looks like the magenta triangles around the crystals form twilight's cutiemark when put together too

@Sundaystorms But we're not talking about the Elements of Harmony, these are entirely new crystals.

That's the same thing I thought, twilight killed herself for the crystals giving up all the magic she contained

No she did not make the “crystals” or should I say,- “elements.” A thousand years ago, Starswirk the bearded and his 5 other loyal friends planted a seed. That seed grew into the Tree Of Harmony. The Tree Of Harmony grew the elements. The elements were connected to Celestia And Luna at that time. Those elements helped turn Discord into stone (before he was reformed 1k years later.) When Twilight started making friends, those elements we suddenly connected to herself and her friends, which connected together, and, right after she completed StarSwirl The Bearded’s spell, the elements gave her own wings, earth pony strength and alicorn magic. That started the chest, the keys, which grew a castle- then her school, and now she took Celestia’s place and is currently ruling Equestria.

I agree making the crystals took her life

I agree making the crystals took her life

she sacrificed herself to ensure the return of grogar will not happen, either discord turned rogue, or another sort of super villlan of some sort defeated people

I also have to agree it makes the most sense

I also have to agree it makes the most sense

I agree. It looks to me like she sacrificed all of herself; horns, wings, body. ; _ ;


What if she turned herself into the gems, thus she became the embodiment of the friendship and magic between the races. That’s why the gems only worked when the three races came together. To everyone else, Twilight simply disappeared, but she lives on through the magic of friendship.

Wait....she <i>became</i> the spirit of harmony?! Is that why the spirit takes her form earlier?!

Wait....she _became_ the spirit of harmony?! Is that why the spirit takes her form earlier?!

no one said any thing about the rest of the elements only we have been talking about twilight like what about the rest of the elements

Like the tree? (Like the whole living on through the magic of friendship)

The Special Interest Show! with Jupiter August


I think the most painful part of the "Twilight sacrificed her physical and magical being to create the crystals" is that around the crystals are the white bubbles with three rays each that when combined would be a star the same colour as Twilight's, which makes it more likely that she literally split herself apart rather than metaphorically

I think you're right I think that they could probably bring her back by "forcing" her together in some way.


Here’s my theory, and I think it’s a lot simpler: when alicorns “die”, their magic becomes automatic in a way.

Also to preface I know in the IDW Comics Twilight is tasked with raising the sun after Celestia and Luna “leave” but the comics have always had questionable canonicity. I think that alicorns live longer, by a lot, but they still die in the end. When Celestia and Luna died, their power went into the sun and moon so the cycle would be powered automatically. But... friendship? That’s not a natural process like day and night. So how do you make that run naturally?

When Twilight died, her alicorn magic went into the crystals to unite all ponies as friends. The crystals are kinda like Excalibur; not just anyone can wield them. But they’re symbols of peace above all else, just something to represent unity among ponies long after Twilight has been forgotten as all but seemingly myth. They’re just waiting for the right pony to come along IF things go awry to put things back in order as the new princess of friendship.

Here’s my theory, and I think it’s a lot simpler: when alicorns “die”, their magic becomes automatic in a way.

Also to preface I know in the IDW Comics Twilight is tasked with raising the sun after Celestia and Luna “leave” but the comics have always had questionable canonicity. I think that alicorns live *longer,* by a lot, but they still die in the end. When Celestia and Luna died, their power went into the sun and moon so the cycle would be powered automatically. But... friendship? That’s not a natural process like day and night. So how do you make that run naturally?

When Twilight died, her alicorn magic went into the crystals to unite all ponies as friends. The crystals are kinda like Excalibur; not just anyone can wield them. But they’re symbols of peace above all else, just something to represent unity among ponies long after Twilight has been forgotten as all but seemingly myth. They’re just waiting for the right pony to come along IF things go awry to put things back in order as the new princess of friendship.

I dont think so if you seen the vido where you now that there is a land for alacorns and thats where thay com from

Omg I adore this theory. It covers so much! The idea of celestia and Luna still raising and lowering the sun and moon is beautiful to me in a sad sort of way 😭 it’s like they’re still with us <br>And the theory about the crystals being twilights last way of spreading friendship to pony kind like a last huha sounds like a very twilight thing to do.

Omg I adore this theory. It covers so much! The idea of celestia and Luna still raising and lowering the sun and moon is beautiful to me in a sad sort of way 😭 it’s like they’re still with us
And the theory about the crystals being twilights last way of spreading friendship to pony kind like a last huha sounds like a very twilight thing to do.


I honestly agree with your theory that twilight sacrificed herself for the future generations of MLP, and I honestly think that her sacrifice what the most powerful sacrifice that she could have ever done. Not for the sake of magic itself, but for the long lasting friendship that will continue for generations to come and go


Suddenly, Hasbro saying that twilight wouldn't outlive her friends has a whole new context.

You know I don’t think twilight is going to give up all her magic,she would find another way to solve magic problems,or she just sacrificed herself to save the ponies,unicorns,Pegasus or Alicorns because there is no another way to solve the magic problem,and I think that is Twilights purpose,she’s the main character at MLP ...

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 I’m not being mean you just don’t seem to understand no one asked if you were an alicorn and it doesn’t contribute to the conversation.

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 vanish child, go do your homework and eat your mommies dinner

I am a changeling villager from changeling village.

it must have happened really soon after where we left off then. so much missing lore I want to know.


What makes this even more sad, is that if twilight turned back into a mortal, presumably the same age as before she mecame immortal, then all of her friends would have been much older than her, and would die before her, leaving her alone in her final years alive, having sacrificed literally everything only to be forgotten


My theory was that after Twilight outlived her friends, she saw no point in continuing and channeled all of her magic into the crystals, where she never even lived afterwards. Many didn't understand what happened that day and thought it was the cause of someone else. This is what formed the rift between everyone and eventually, it erupted into a deadly war destroying much of Equestria, leaving only three cities to remain.


This is certainly a (sad) possibility. Although I like to think that Twilight, always enthusiastic about space and stargazing, went off to found a new pony colony on a different planet and left this triple artifact so that Equestrians would still have access to alicorn magic.

celestia came back and banished her to the moon


I might have an idea.

At 3:58 it shows the three parts of the new gem right? Well each picture of the gem has a part of Twilight's mark. Look. The one in the middle  has one going up and two diagenonly down. The one on the right has the same but turned sideways. Same with the one on the left. If you put them together it makes Twilight's cutie mark.
Could that have something to do with it? Maybe Twilight seperated her magic into each gem!


"Did you get what you wanted?"
Twilight: "yes"
"What did it cost?"
Twilight: "everything..."

@Garrett Viewegh  spike is a lizard twilight is a horse.

I’m sure this new generation may have stories and characters just as memorable. But I can’t help but feel unraveling how things went so wrong from g4 to the present disunity may be a sub plot that will be unraveled.

@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 I hope we get to see some new villians

I wonder what new villians we would have in the gen5

@N.C. Pictures ooo ok and stay tune for epesode of  ''stalion do well''

@dyandra dragon pony I think I had a stroke trying to read this, the only thing I understood is the mane six part, sorry 😂

@N.C. Pictures it spells mane six not main six also or is it maybe there is some is eater eggs and there a epesode name stalion do well is similar to mare do well

@dyandra dragon pony that would be pretty cool but tbh, it wouldn't be the same without the old main 6. I haven't watched gen 5 yet, but judging from what I've seen and heard so far I really don't think Hasbro will bring back old characters other than in stories or flashbacks

@N.C. Pictures i want the vilain reform in gen 5

@dyandra dragon pony I doubt it. They're probably as magic-less as everyone else

i wonder will cozy glow, sombra,tirek,and will reform in gen5

Twilight: I can’t go to Germany, I got homework!

Grogar: “I am inevitable.”<br>Twilight: “And I...am...Twilight Sparkle princess of friendship”

Grogar: “I am inevitable.”
Twilight: “And I...am...Twilight Sparkle princess of friendship”

@Save My Little Pony She didn't seem too eager to reject lordship.

@Save My Little Pony I wasn't even referring to the throne but whatever

Twilight didn't <i>want</i> the throne of Equestria. They basically forced her to accept it.

Twilight didn't _want_ the throne of Equestria. They basically forced her to accept it.


You have a brilliant mind to put this all together, and I'd like to see what you can create with it, because I highly doubt the writers had this much forethought and that this was their actual intention.

Despite that, your interpretation is most satisfying and most acceptable.

Also, it reflects highly on Twilight Sparkles name.
Twilight, the briefest moment of the day, a mix of day and night.
Sparkle, a flash of light, brief in its brilliance,, and beautiful if seen, and highly regarded as a magical moment.
Twilight Sparkle, always meant to be the queen to Day and Night...always meant to rein...for just a moment.

This makes me happy...because if this calamity happened shortly after the end of the series...
She might have both lived and died... along with her friends...
Thus...she didn't lose the "magic"...she still had what truly mattered...friendship.

That...would have been a great final movie to this show, leading into this one.


I find it hard to believe that Equestria would fall under Twilight's rule, knowing her. And I don't think Twilight could un-alicorn herself. Plus, I like her better as an alicorn.


Well Twlkght didn’t die completely. I believe when the magic was released, it sought out its original host Twilight. When it couldn’t find her, it sought a pony that was similar to her which ended up being Sunny. That is why Sunny turned into an Alicorn. I don’t think Twilight made it past the reverting stage. It most likely killed her. I honestly believe that Twilights power is the key to finding a way to bring back magic without the use of artifacts. Twilight most likely didn’t have time to figure out how to use her power to bring back magic the old fashioned way and so went with Plan B: distributing her magic to earth pony’s, unicorn pony’s, and Pegasus pony’s.

Another thing that I’m using to back up my claim is Sunny’s Alicorn form is not normal. Her horn and wings shouldn’t disappear like they did in Make Your Mark. They should be solid. They shouldn’t look the way they do. The magic hasn’t really bonded to her completely. Maybe it’s cuz she is not the original host and so the magic is having a hard time sticking, or maybe it’s cuz Sunny hasn’t found a way to bring back magic without artifacts and the magic is semi stuck in the artifacts


I had a random bathroom thought to complement your theory... Here me out, what if, the reason the three tribes had to separate wasn't out of raised tension or fighting, but out of protecting themselves and each other? Say like, a new catastrophic and Deadly creature or villain came around that thrived/gained power off the three tribes being In the same place? So this creature(s) could individually absorb the three different magics together and grow stronger/use THAT against them? And so to protect themselves, they made three new separate colonies so this villain couldn't utilize this power. And that would also explain why twilight (perhaps joined by all other existing alicorns) would feel the need to sacrifice herself and split her three tribe magics into these artifacts for each race to take with them as a reminder to stay connected even as they're separated, so this villain couldn't take advantage of alicorns already having all three magics. Perhaps this villain would eventually be defeated by the young six or the friend group that luster dawn creates for herself, as this would take place after twilights friends have passed away and thus she's no longer strong enough to create a magical friendship rainbow laser all on her own. But by the time it's defeated the three tribes have already made new lives for themselves and don't want to risk going back to the way things were, but did still visit each other from time to time, which is why they had that station with the stained glass in the pegasus colony. But over the hundreds or thousands of years time, they eventually grew apart, and rumors and hearsay started spreading about the other tribes, and that's what brings us to the beginning of gen5. It would also explain why the wendigos were not present as tensions would rise only after they were already separated so there was no fighting to provoke the wendigos. what do you think?


Interesting theory. But it makes you wonder what happened to the other alicorns. Surely, Flurryheart and Cadance would continue her legacy right? Unless the Crystal Empire disappeared again.

@Nasira Quddoos but flurry heart was born a alicorn so she never had the transformation like cadence so how will she lose the magic is she is born one

@ριɠαƈԋυ👑🎗 well, Celestia and luna probably would have but, they must have thought it through and figured that without them the sun and moon couldn't rise/set and thier alicorn magic didn't dissapear because it was too strong, they decided to not help twilight because it would be night/day forever

You are right but if twilight's gone then it will make sense if Celestia or Luna or even flurry heart we're gone because if twilight's gone that it would make sense if the rest of the alicorns were gone maybe there was I don't know what an attack or something like that

@GreenScorpion37 But does that stop me? Of course not

@GreenScorpion37 But does that stop me? Of course not

@Kalan son erkek mlp fanı. I think they are. I typed the sources you mentioned into Google and it directly correlated to a chapter in a fanfic.

@GreenScorpion37 Are these fan-fiction? If so, my whole theory will collapse.

@GreenScorpion37 Are these fan-fiction? If so, my whole theory will collapse.

@Nasira Quddoos they probably use artifacts to make the sun and moon auto maticaly rise and set

@Nasira Quddoos they probably use artifacts to make the sun and moon auto maticaly rise and set

@Kalan son erkek mlp fanı. Any source that is officially canon and not fanfics?

@Kalan son erkek mlp fanı. Any source that is officially canon and not fanfics?

@GreenScorpion37 She has appeared in Queen Galaxia and King Cosmos Alicorn Sister In Life and The Snow Queen's Threat and has been hinted at in many places.

@Kalan son erkek mlp fanı. When were their parents ever mentioned?

@Kalan son erkek mlp fanı. When were their parents ever mentioned?

@UnicornFlowBFF The Crystal Empire is protected from the cold Northern air thanks to a powerful source of magic such as the crystal heart or Sombra. So when the magic is gone, the Empire may be buried in the snow and ruined, or the Cadense people may be taken to another place, to a deserted place.
I have a theory that is unlikely. Since I am Turkish, I could not reach most content. Try to do something with what I know.
 There is something called the Spirit of Harmony. It takes place in many places. Harmony derives its strength from friendship. So how does the Crystal Empire stand with the power of love? I think there's something called the Spirit of Love. This power is from another dimension, the Crystal Dimension. In the land of Equestria, where love is minimal, it manifested itself as the Crystal heart near the Crystal Mountains. The first known Crystal pony is Rose Quartz and, as far as we know, has a companion named Orion. Brother of Orion Luna and Celestia. All three of his sisters are Alicorns. My guess is that Orion felt unnecessary and went to distant places. Here he met Rose
Crystal Heart understood their love and pushed the cold and snow for them. Over time, the ponies, who fell in love with each other, gathered around them. When they stay there long enough, they become "Crystal Pony". in the cartoon
With the power of love, the Crystal Festival had both defeated Sombra and transformed everyone into a crystal form.
This proves that the Crystal Heart works with love. While Orion and Rose Quartz were alive, there were arguments and fights from time to time. In cartoons, everything has an opposite. Thinking with this logic, the opposite of the Crystal Empire could be the Black Crystal Empire. Here Sombra was the king here and was empowered by the magic of bad events. According to a popular theory, she found interdimensional magic one day and couldn't help herself and 'went bad' just like Luna.
He cast a reincarnation spell and was defeated a second time before being defeated by Celestia and Luna. The final season was brought back to life by Discord posing as Grogar. Last time and truly defeated. What I want to convey is this; Cadense or Heart may have sensed danger and gone with their people to the Crystalline Dimension.

@GreenScorpion37 I have a theory. From them as far as we know  before them, the Moon and the sun were ruled by their parents. Galaxsia and Cosmos may have renounced this magic and passed it on to their children before handing over the throne to them.

@Nasira Quddoos well, Twilight turned the next ruler of equestria, the question is not if Celestia and Luna are raising the sun and moon, but maybe is Twilight raising the sun and moon. She was the ruler at the end and she had the ability to rise and lower the sun and moon.

Perhaps they were annoyed by the things around and hid the kingdom until the magic of friendship returned.

Perhaps they were annoyed by the things around and hid the kingdom until the magic of friendship returned.

maybe it's simpler than that. it's magic that gives alicorns their longevity, so without magic they just died of old age..

maybe it's simpler than that. it's magic that gives alicorns their longevity, so without magic they just died of old age..

Or probably this was many years later and after flurry, her kids continued the carry on he legacy but later drifted away and everyone started fighting and then it all ended the friendship was lost

Since she is born an alicorn, and some of you are not sure how she can retransform, it could be that the duty is up to Flurry but some kind of tragic event happened and Flurry was not able to face it on her own so she decided to hide

What if every alicorn except Flurry sacrificed themselves and Flurry is the one hiding and rising the sun and moon?

What if every alicorn except Flurry sacrificed themselves and Flurry is the one hiding and rising the sun and moon?

Well surely Celestia and Luna still alive technically.Since they are like 1000 years old.I mean if sunny said that the mark on the stain glasses is like a really long time.I think it must be around 1000 years old

@GreenScorpion37 Perhaps they gave up their bodily essence?

@GreenScorpion37 Perhaps they gave up their bodily essence?

@Yamaho Estella but that's the thing... there was no evidence of a war per say after twilight supposedly made these crystals, this new movie has us all bamboozled

@Nasira Quddoos That's SO true! There's so many answers we need 😭😭

@Nasira Quddoos That's SO true! There's so many answers we need 😭😭

@Nasira Quddoos But the interesting thing was that flurryheart was born an Alicorn which can ultimately change things. Twilight had to reverse her Alicorn transformation. Plus Cadence would never sacrifice her daughter. It's like she just vanished!

Yeah I was thinking the same thing. What happened to flurryheart was my big question while watch this...

Yeah I was thinking the same thing. What happened to flurryheart was my big question while watch this...

@Nasira Quddoos sawtooth has introduced a theory on that too

@Nasira Quddoos sawtooth has introduced a theory on that too

Ikr I still have so many questions to this day 😭

Ikr I still have so many questions to this day 😭

@Nasira Quddoos Yes, but Flurryheart was a natural born alicorn so woundn't be different for her?

@Nasira Quddoos Yes, but Flurryheart was a natural born alicorn so woundn't be different for her?

@・Jelly family•🦋 I just watched a video from dr wolf, and apparently not even the writer's currently know.

@・Jelly family•🦋 I just watched a video from dr wolf, and apparently not even the writer's currently know.

I still need to know how the ailcorns disappears

I still need to know how the ailcorns disappears

@Nasira Quddoos Maybe the crystals hold enough alicorn magic to raise the sun and moon

@Nasira Quddoos Maybe the crystals hold enough alicorn magic to raise the sun and moon

@Piy God it’s like a piece of glitter it’s there one day and the next it isn’t

@Piy God it’s like a piece of glitter it’s there one day and the next it isn’t

@Nasira Quddoos True but what about Flurry? She was born an Alicorn, not made one by magic.

@Nasira Quddoos True but what about Flurry? She was born an Alicorn, not made one by magic.

@GreenScorpion37 Well their parents cause celestia and luna are the alicorns of the sun and moon we can assume their parents are the alicorns of the star and sky so if they die it's easy to think that turn into what they represent

Regarding the raising of Sun and Moon, Twilight have did it before when Celestia and Luna went missing being trapped within the vine near the Tree of Harmony and also before Celestia and Luna did it, it was the duty of five great Unicorn which used to be lead by the Starswirl the Bearded to raised the moon and the sun but it's really exhausted their magic and stamina so finding two Alicorn who could raised the moon and the sun like they're eating a pie was unexpected to Starswirl the Bearded which is how Celestia and Luna was invited by the Starswirl the Bearded to became their ruler due to their great magic and potential. Remember the story of the alliances between the three pony tribe whose hate each other but eventually lead to the founding of Equestria, the Pegasi provided a good weather, the Unicorn provided day and night while the Earth Ponies provided food. This question you have to asked, how did the Unicorn received such an important role and did they have been doing it for centuries since the beginning of time ? If the G5 decided to explore this opportunity to explained what happened to the Sun and the Moon, it could lead to the origin of how the Unicorn was able to received an important role to raise the Sun and the Moon and manipulate the Sun and the Moon to their advantage for better or for worse.

@Kira No you're not, Twilight have did it before when Celestia and Luna went missing being trapped within the vine near the Tree of Harmony and also before Celestia and Luna did it, it was the duty of five great Unicorn which used to be lead by the Starswirl the Bearded to raised the moon and the sun but it's really exhausted their magic and stamina so finding two Alicorn who could raised the moon and the sun like they're eating a pie was unexpected to Starswirl the Bearded which is how Celestia and Luna was invited by the Starswirl the Bearded to became their ruler due to their great magic and potential. Remember the story of the alliances between the three pony tribe whose hate each other but eventually lead to the founding of Equestria, the Pegasi provided a good weather, the Unicorn provided day and night while the Earth Ponies provided food. This question you have to asked, how did the Unicorn received such an important role and did they have been doing it for centuries since the beginning of time ? If the G5 decided to explore this opportunity to explained what happened to the Sun and the Moon, it could lead to the origin of how the Unicorn was able to received an important role to raise the Sun and the Moon and manipulate the Sun and the Moon to their advantage for better or for worse.

@UnicornFlowBFF Even if it was, it could have lost its magic like everything else did.

@UnicornFlowBFF Even if it was, it could have lost its magic like everything else did.

@Hannah Schultz maybe? I mean, it activates with friendship, while the crystal heart activates with love

@Hannah Schultz maybe? I mean, it activates with friendship, while the crystal heart activates with love

What if the new crystals are made out of shards of the shattered crystal heart 🤔🤔🤔

What if the new crystals are made out of shards of the shattered crystal heart 🤔🤔🤔

@SmokeDrake Equestria Next Generation? Where?

@SmokeDrake Equestria Next Generation? Where?

There's actually a map shown during the movie of "current" Equestria. While the railroad that leads to the Empire is still there, the Empire isn't shown at all. So, it could have disappeared.

Before everything, sorry for my bad english :')

But guys, this is to everyone saying the things about Celestia and Luna. Did you guys forgot that in the mlp movie there was that artifact that could change night and day, that one the goat guy got and stuff. I think there might be something similar. And not only Celestia and Luna can rise the sun and moon, because when Luna was trapped in the moon, Celestia was the one rising the moon too because there was still night times. If only Luna could be able to rise the moon, there would be only mornings since Celestia trapped her.
It's been a time since i watched so i don't remember much. But if i'm not wrong, there was an episode that somepony other than Celestia or Luna was raising the sun and moon, i don't remember if it was actually a thing or i'm just creating false memories.
Anyways, i think there might be some magic thing, or artifact, that makes the day changes. I doubt Celestia and Luna would hide in a crisis.

@L maybe celestia and luna got re-encarnated into the the sun and the moon. We've all seen luna being banished to the moon so it could be possible

Maybe all the alicorns sacrificed their magic to let the ponys have magic longer....

Maybe all the alicorns sacrificed their magic to let the ponys have magic longer....

@JadePlayzSide Maybe the 5 alicorns participate to the crystal. Maybe, ex-Princess Luna and ex-Princess Celestia are not a alicorn, but in crisis they could be back for helping the 3 other Princesses. They think abt a way to save everyone without damaging anyone but not finding a solution. all of 6 put their alicorn magic and lost it. we seen in MLP : The Movie, all of the alicorns participate to recovered the castle and i think thats the same for Equestria

My headcanon is that Cadence would die of a broken heart when Shining dies. The fanfic “The bitterness of mortality” really captures this in my opinion.

@Nasira Quddoos I read about this in another theory where it explained that Celestia and Luna where the sun and moon sent down to find a ruler for equastria so that they can go back and continue their duties, and once they were there maybe something stopped them from returning again to help. Made sense to me, though don't know how accurate it is

@Varianfortunate Actually, I think they can now, being that the mane 6 have essentially become the elements of harmony.

@Varianfortunate Actually, I think they can now, being that the mane 6 have essentially become the elements of harmony.

@GreenScorpion37 I suppose so yes that could be an alternative, but these are all just theory’s really 😅

@GreenScorpion37 I suppose so yes that could be an alternative, but these are all just theory’s really 😅

remember that she can only banish people to the moon with the elements of harmony tho

remember that she can only banish people to the moon with the elements of harmony tho

@October_needsc0ff3e Assuming they are in there. But why would they be? I have no doubt they passed their powers to someone or something else when they retired.

@ριɠαƈԋυ👑🎗 well they wouldn’t necessarily be alive on account that they are in the moon and sun if that makes any sense 😅

@ριɠαƈԋυ👑🎗 well they wouldn’t necessarily be alive on account that they are in the moon and sun if that makes any sense 😅

@October_needsc0ff3e wait but if celestia and luna are still alive shouldnt they like helped twiligth with the magic thingy then just hiding

@Breezes Melody <br>No, that's not what I meant. I mean that if someone WANTED to TRY to break it, they don't really HIDE it.

@Breezes Melody
No, that's not what I meant. I mean that if someone WANTED to TRY to break it, they don't really HIDE it.

@Yamaho Estella I don't quite think thats true. remember, flurry is still an alicorn and she had unstable alicorn magic. I honestly think that the power surge she had that caused it to break was specifically because it was concentrated powerful alicorn magic which could probably be the only thing to break the crystal heart. at least, that's my take on it

@GreenScorpion37 <br>Definitely would be easier to take down the Crystal Empire seeing as the crystal heart is out on display 24/7

@GreenScorpion37
Definitely would be easier to take down the Crystal Empire seeing as the crystal heart is out on display 24/7

@Yamaho Estella It wouldn't take much. All one would have to do is destroy the Crystal Heart, as Flurry Heart once did.

@Yamaho Estella It wouldn't take much. All one would have to do is destroy the Crystal Heart, as Flurry Heart once did.

I have a theory. I think the Crystal Empire was first to fall. They hadn't been expecting it at all, afterall, no Villain was left to harm them. They collapsed like dominos, and soon, the tribes outside of Equestria will follow. Magic from all species started dying out, and Twilight, realizing what was going to happen, and as the last Alicorn, gave up everything.

@L that is a good possibility, but if you think about it celestia clearly has the power to “banish” people into the moon, and realistically we don’t actually know where they came from because in the castle we only see pictures of them and not their parents if they had any, therefore leading me to think they themselves are legitimately the sun and moon which would explain why they rise and set with out magic 🙃

@Nasira Quddoos i thought about that too but i realised what if they were in hiding? since they said the legacy was forgotten maybe luna and celestia are still alive ? they just raise the sun/moon in secret

my opinion is that they are most likely in hiding..

my opinion is that they are most likely in hiding..

@October_needsc0ff3e I don’t get this tho. In mlp we see that Celestia and Luna are the only ones able to rise the sun and moon. In the movie, it doesn’t explain why the sun/moon is rising itself in the movie. Why IS the sun and moon rising? In mlp, they said they needed magic to do that. Are the two sisters doing it? How did they make the sun/moon rise WITHOUT magic…. Are they still alive? Even if some other pony got the power or magic to raise the sun and moon, they shouldn’t have been able to in the movie WITHOUT magic.

@Nasira Quddoos that actually would make a lot of sense due to the fact that they would want to help twilight so all of the gave up their alicorn magic to give the ponies of the future more magic, also it would be their friendship that combines into the crystals as well since they would be doing it together. So really great factor🙃

Maybe they lost their magic too and unbecame alicorns. Without their Ali corn magic, they would be regular ponies and die.

Maybe they lost their magic too and unbecame alicorns. Without their Ali corn magic, they would be regular ponies and die.

It's not really an empire, more like a city state

It's not really an empire, more like a city state


Wasn't able to comment on your previous video, but watching this one as well made me put more detail into my theory. What if G5 is actually an alternate universe? When the 3 villains separated the tribes, the young 6 weren't able to bring everyone together, leaving the mane 6 unable to overpower them. Twilight decided to create an artifact that contained the magic of each tribe and even transferred her own essence of the 3 to create an artifact that could stop the 3 villains. It worked, but the three tribes were still separated and they actually split the artifact into 3 to keep the magic of each tribe for themselves, destroying the magic of unity and friendship. As each piece remained separate and the three tribes kept each other in isolation, magic no longer had a positive source of energy and as such, disappeared. what remained of Twilight's essence, the elements of harmony and the magic that fed off unity was stuck inside 3 artifacts that, separated, had no purpose. Was this a good theory?


When watching the new G5 version, I kept pausing and saying outlaid, "did I actually miss something? What the hell happened? How long has it been?" -- I did enjoy the new film a lot, a lot more than I expected, but I felt they didn't do the best job of explaining the gap between G4 and G5. The creators cannot be that stupid, they HAVE to know G4 fans are going to at minimum see the first movie.


This explanation makes a lot of sense, though I'm personally someone who hasn't been able to make herself watch the new show. The only questions I have are what happened to the other alicorns (Luna and Celestia as well as Flurry Heart, etc.), to the other races (changelings, etc.), and why Sunny didnt actually become an alicorn


This theory makes a lot of sense tbh, though there is something I’m still wondering. What was the crisis? What made all the innate magic disappear from equestria??? Why did everypony lose their innate magic that twilight had to make such a sacrifice?


But this begs the question: What happened to the Crystal Empire, Changelings, Yaks, and all the species and sub species we were introduced to in gen 4? And what's what with Zacora, now that I think about it?

wait in gen 4 they did’nt need the crystles so why do they need it in gen 5

Most likely, each kept to their areas/countries and just did not leave them long after gen 4.

Also don't know if anyone has mentioned it but Zecoras fate is explored in season 10 comics

I honestly hope the other species continued being friend and now are the ones who will help the ponies but who knows

Perhaps, as before Celestia and Luna, all living things live far from one and into hostilit

Theres gonna be a series from what i know of gen 5 so

I realllly how they don't bring in the other species sorry not worry. I want my little PONY back. But for sure I love Zecora she's dope and she's an OG. However we won't see her in the new generation she gone like the rest of em.

Magic was the only thing keeping back the blizzard and making their land habitable was my take from it. If magic ceased to exist, then I imagine they moved on.

The changelings went underground and into the mountain caves to the parts of the world were ponies never play. To sit in Shadows and darkness keeping a watchful eye over the ever ignorant ponies ensuring they never stumble into things that were far beyond their Keen

@Cadence Silverforest most likely I think my theory suits the information we have and also others theory’s aswell

We have also seen this before. In Twilights Kingdom, Celestial, Luna, and Cadence transfer their magic to Twilight. Perhaps something similar happened?

Maybe after twilight left and or died they separated because no pony really tried to keep every creature togethor

Maybe because ponies couldn't keep peace, between themselves they couldn't keep peace between other creatures too?

The movie takes place on the East coast doesn’t it?

Previous shows and movies were in the central west

I’m pretty sure the “magic crisis” that might’ve occurred affected the others species as well

I was thinking that maybe it is a similar situation to Pangea, how some part of land were split apart. Or maybe they decided to leave the ponies after Twilight passed (I'm probably wrong but that's all I coukd think of)

I was wondering about that too. I hope we get to see those characters in the new mlp series or the history on what happened to them.


I think this also makes sense as to why Sunny is given transparent alicorn features. If the magic within the crystals were limited, then they might not have enough magic to fully transform her into an alicorn like when Twilight became one.


Just a couple of things: What happened to all of the other species in Equestria? AND What happened to Luna,Celstia,Cadence, and Flurry Heart. Flurry was just a baby so being an alicorn (with long lifespan) where is she now?


Sawtooth: When it çomes to connecting future eq with the past , this is all there is.<br>Ayrgle who spend all his life studying the artifacts: Am I joke to you.

Sawtooth: When it çomes to connecting future eq with the past , this is all there is.
Ayrgle who spend all his life studying the artifacts: Am I joke to you.


Is it bad I only want a second Movie of Mlp: a new generation to not only watch the characters, but also discover other plot events that happened after Mlp:  Friendship is Magic ended? Like, I’m generally curious as to what happened after the show’s conculsion, and I think it would be an interesting thing to see the mane six, and/or the princesses give them a sort of “vision.”


I have a theory that Sunny's dad was somehow related to Twilight's honorary family member in Once Upon a Zeppelin

This is also what I said two because they look so alike it would make tons of sense

@Ryan Sarabia or he  was one of the students otherwise why would he be so stuck on  teaching the friendship once taught by twilight.

@idontknow I'd like to think they're descended from Twilight, not really sure who she would've paired with to have any children with though. (I like TwilightxSunset Shimmer, and I'm willing to say magic babies happened to explain how they would've had kids lmao) and as time went on the lineage became more Earth Pony from the younger generations.

You mean Startracker
And yeah it's possible perhaps
I mean they both have similar color palette

I went as far as to say that Argyle is a descendant of twilight herself based off his design

I think twilight had kids then one of them mated with a earth pony and it kept happening.

@Ryan Sarabia i dont think princesses of equestria gets married (not cadsnce)

What if in the years Princess Twilight Sparkle and Startracker secretly  had a affair but with Equestrian society keeping it between them and there descendant was Argyle who if Startracker being mortal  Twilight could of tooken the foil under her wing giving this knowledge in study which Argyle gave to her daughter sunny???

I think what OP meant was Argyle starshine is related to Starchaser,  the twilight fanboy character in once upon a zeplin,  I mean, they even have similar names "starshine" and "starchaser"  even sunny "starscout" starchaser must have told his children how amazing twilight was,  so the stories past down from generation to generation

I agree because in the beginning in his work space there's a purple feather in a glass container with some extra things like twilights picture or something and nearly no one else knows or talks about twilight at all so how would he have gotten the feather from who I assume is twilight

At the very start of the movie I yelled that- "SUNNYS FATHER IS RELATED TO TWILGHT! HE'S RELATED TO HER! I'M <b>NOT</b> WRONG!"

At the very start of the movie I yelled that- "SUNNYS FATHER IS RELATED TO TWILGHT! HE'S RELATED TO HER! I'M *NOT* WRONG!"

Princess👸 Twilight Sparkle♀🦄💜🌟 of Friendship👩❤👩 doesn't give up⬆

@Ryan Sarabia More like his niece or long relative

I honestly suspected him to be a veeeeery distant descendant! But this is cool too!

Or luster drawn was a related to sunnys dad

No they are not related cause that would be dumb

LOVE that idea! It could match with my idea, I Belice Sunny is a descendant of starlight and sunburst, so maybe her mother was and her parents come together because of their love for the G4 history

Omg u thought so too!!! 🥳🙌 Star Tracker was his name I think

@catqueenxoxo ok then sunny mother<br>I guess

@catqueenxoxo ok then sunny mother
I guess

That would actually ve a really cool detail! Maybe because he was so close to twilight and such a huge fan, he dedicated his life to teaching the next generation twilight's lessons.

@Gacha penny plays who’s her grandmother???

Sunny has a grand mother <br>What her grandmother is will shock you 😱

Sunny has a grand mother
What her grandmother is will shock you 😱

He musht be twightlihts son and he got old


I have a feeling that the artifacts were created by Twilights body.
the Pegasus piece was made from her wings, the Unicorn piece from her horn and the Earth pony piece from her Earth pony strength.

Twilight, in the split moment before her use of unicorn magic faded, injected the pieces with the magic from which she drained from herself, most likely for its protection against an enemy of Equestria, then her friends gifted the artifacts to the designated tribes and entrusted them to protect the pieces until the time comes where they can be safely reunited and bring back magic once again.

The elements of Harmony and their tree probably shriveled away, resulting in the Everfree Forest taking over.
But pony-kind hid and survived the overtake, and when the chaos settled, they emerged into a landscape that ran completely automatically, no more would the clouds need the Pegasus or the sun need the unicorn, the world now took care of itself.

But they, just like you said, began to view the relics as more important then what their former ruler envisioned, which was the nurturing of friendship. as the years went by they started to look down on the other tribes and in return started mass-producing propagandist reasons for why their tribes are better, strongly influencing the ideologies of the common folk and even the future rulers themselves.

In time the relics original values started to get questioned, then it dwindled and soon became forgotten, but the ponies were so influenced by the propaganda that was shoved down their throats their whole lives that they refused to believe that they were even of the same species with the other tribes, so they slinked away into isolation, rewrote their histories and kept their distance ever since.

For the other Alicorns, its possible that Celestia, Luna, Cadence and Flurry Heart sealed themselves within the Crystal Empire and  used their combined magic to make it disappear again in order to protect both their magic and the magic within the empire itself, all under the orders to Twilight Sparkle. at the end of the movie, the lights in the sky could indicate that the spell the Princesses put on the Crystal Empire was broken, revealing it to the world and allowing the princesses to return and re-establish their positions as the reigning monarchs of pony-kind once more.

but hey, that's just a theory, a PONY THEORY!
(Guys this is literally what I imagined what could've happened don't kill me-)

I have a feeling that the artifacts were created by Twilights body.
the Pegasus piece was made from her wings, the Unicorn piece from her horn and the Earth pony piece from her Earth pony strength.

Twilight, in the split moment before her use of unicorn magic faded, injected the pieces with the magic from which she drained from herself, most likely for its protection against an enemy of Equestria, then her friends gifted the artifacts to the designated tribes and entrusted them to protect the pieces until the time comes where they can be safely reunited and bring back magic once again.

The elements of Harmony and their tree probably shriveled away, resulting in the Everfree Forest taking over.
But pony-kind hid and survived the overtake, and when the chaos settled, they emerged into a landscape that ran completely automatically, no more would the clouds need the Pegasus or the sun need the unicorn, the world now took care of itself.

But they, just like you said, began to view the relics as more important then what their former ruler envisioned, which was the nurturing of friendship. as the years went by they started to look down on the other tribes and in return started mass-producing propagandist reasons for why their tribes are better, strongly influencing the ideologies of the common folk and even the future rulers themselves.

In time the relics original values started to get questioned, then it dwindled and soon became forgotten, but the ponies were so influenced by the propaganda that was shoved down their throats their whole lives that they refused to believe that they were even of the same species with the other tribes, so they slinked away into isolation, rewrote their histories and kept their distance ever since.

For the other Alicorns, its possible that Celestia, Luna, Cadence and Flurry Heart sealed themselves within the Crystal Empire and  used their combined magic to make it disappear again in order to protect both their magic and the magic within the empire itself, all under the orders to Twilight Sparkle. at the end of the movie, the lights in the sky could indicate that the spell the Princesses put on the Crystal Empire was broken, revealing it to the world and allowing the princesses to return and re-establish their positions as the reigning monarchs of pony-kind once more.

*_but hey, that's just a theory, a PONY THEORY!_*
(Guys this is literally what I imagined what could've happened don't kill me-)


This also makes me have an idea of another movie concept: at the beginning, Celestia, Luna and the other alicorns are shown to be on another (unknown) island but the other ponies don’t know, then there is a sudden crisis that rises (idk what crisis) and only the most powerful alicorn that ever existed can phase the crisis (I assume Twilight is the most powerful alicorn), then the ponies soon discover that Twilight actually existed and she created the artifacts, so then Sunny and the others (Mane 5 as I call them) try to bring back Twilight by trying to merge all the artifacts together, but they can’t do that, so they journey across the world to find at least 1 small thing for a clue on how to merge the artifacts together, and in the middle of that, they discover the island where all the other alicorns live, and they meet them. I’m gonna try to continue this on a later day


"We had such potential, such promise. But we squandered our gifts, our harmony. Our blind embrace of hatred and ignorance, only sped us down a single path which would ultimately lead to the downfall of our land. Equestria, is ending. But the Magic of Friendship, must go on."


Usually, I find your theories far fetched while just enjoying them, but this one sounds like it could actually be canon.


"Is everyone safe?"
Twilight: "yes"
"But what did that safety cost you?"
Twilight:"everything"

Pinkie Pie: Twilight?! Is that really you?!
Applejack: What happened?!
Rarity: What happened to your wings?!
Fluttershy: ...They're... gone....

@Twilight Sparkle its like why do you care its a good comment that's I care about

@Sunnyesir 67 I have no idea what copied means.

@Seige Drakonera I have no idea what copied means.

@Stephen Byrne yeah. it's "from what?". I would have the same question.

@♡•Arix•♡ I have no idea what copied means. But I don't care about it though.

@underlove ryz if it wasn't me and the other five... Well then who was it?

@Dominika D it's probably okay, I'm here!

@Lightning it's okay I'm still here though.

@Fudgéy-ø what's wrong? I know you're okay.

@Victorious Plays it's okay I'm here by your side!

@Holly C well, u are in a crisis. in crisis, generrally the rep of country must have to sometimes sacrfices their life. thats the same thing in the mlp world like for Princess Cadance. Princess Cadance in The Crystal Empire - Part 1, she was sacrfices her life to protect the Crystal Empire. If there was not the Mane 6 to save the day, she could've die of tiredness (seems pretty dark but that could probably true if she continued)


This theory is great, but I think the crystals are what's left of Twilight. Since she was born a unicorn, I don't think she could lose it. I also don't believe she became an earth pony because there was magic in it too. I rather believe that she split herself into three, three crystals. The reason she would have done this could simply be that she was made too old and had no one to replace her. This theory would explain why the pony tribes all split up, no longer having a leader capable of unifying them all. I just wonder who are the ponies to whom she entrusted the crystals and which can be seen on the stained glass windows.


I had a feeling that something like this had happened between the MLP series and the movie.<br>This is something that is interesting to think about, though. Twighlight taking all her magical powers, and seperating them into 3 atrifacts for the rest of the Pony world to rely on for generations, in hope that everypony could learn the meaning and importance of unity between earthponies, unicorns and pegagyses.

I had a feeling that something like this had happened between the MLP series and the movie.
This is something that is interesting to think about, though. Twighlight taking all her magical powers, and seperating them into 3 atrifacts for the rest of the Pony world to rely on for generations, in hope that everypony could learn the meaning and importance of unity between earthponies, unicorns and pegagyses.


I agree with this theory only partially, I think the antiques(or however you spell it) are right. However, I think Twilight realized the evil trio was going to come back soon so Twilight imprisoned the magic in those antiques


My theory to the crystals is that in time as Twilight's friends passed away, she felt so alone and hurt. Huge void slowly destroyed her soul. I have always imagined that after her friends died, Twilight would become evil, dark version of herself 'cause the sorrow and pain. She doesn't want to live without her dear friends. But Sawtooth Waves theory about the crystals makes sense to me. So after all Twilight can't get over her friends death and she sees away out by creating the crystals and sacrificing her alicorn magic by doing so. After being mortal again, she could finally end her days and go there where her friends have been waiting for her. <br>But that's just my theory.

My theory to the crystals is that in time as Twilight's friends passed away, she felt so alone and hurt. Huge void slowly destroyed her soul. I have always imagined that after her friends died, Twilight would become evil, dark version of herself 'cause the sorrow and pain. She doesn't want to live without her dear friends. But Sawtooth Waves theory about the crystals makes sense to me. So after all Twilight can't get over her friends death and she sees away out by creating the crystals and sacrificing her alicorn magic by doing so. After being mortal again, she could finally end her days and go there where her friends have been waiting for her.
But that's just my theory.


I think that the artefacts were a way for ponies to come together. In the first 2 episodes of MLP G4, the mane 6 looking for the Elements of Harmony brought them together. They wanted Princess Celestia back and for Nightmare Moon to be defeated. In G5, the mane 5 looking for the crystals also helped bring them together whilst making them have hope that they could have their magic.

@GP Winner meh, he could fall into the background like Diamond Tiara post-CMC cutie marks.

I agree. If one looks at Twilight's cutie mark not in a literal meaning but a symbolic one, you can see the miral is saying the elemens of harmany, the one that gave the princess of friendship her power, these are what the new elements took like now. + the elements are canonically known for changing their shape and sizes, I never known them to change in number but I think they changed to reflect he promblem at hand. Besides, the main 5 already embody the spirits of the main 6. The only reason we had a show was because Twilight needed to learn friendship. The main 5 have no need for this, as the show clearly established they already know how to be good friends and despite the rumors by the end of the movie just about everypony quit being racist. ++ Considering weather Sprout will play future villain reformed villain or interestingly enough he could be our new twilight sparkle, learning how to like everyone.... The latter two are lame ideas because Sprout was lame as a character. He would be the weakest reformed villain ever. I would like to see Sprout kicked out, forcing him on his own adventure, he finds some dark magic and turns into an alicorn and he comes back all decked out with some like shadow ponies and maybe he gets his own Susanoo.

I agree. If one looks at Twilight's cutie mark not in a literal meaning but a symbolic one, you can see the miral is saying the elemens of harmany, the one that gave the princess of friendship her power, these are what the new elements took like now. + the elements are canonically known for changing their shape and sizes, I never known them to change in number but I think they changed to reflect he promblem at hand. Besides, the main 5 already embody the spirits of the main 6. The only reason we had a show was because Twilight needed to learn friendship. The main 5 have no need for this, as the show clearly established they already know how to be good friends and despite the rumors by the end of the movie just about everypony quit being racist. ++ Considering weather Sprout will play -future villain- -reformed villain- or interestingly enough he could be our new twilight sparkle, learning how to like everyone.... The latter two are lame ideas because Sprout was lame as a character. He would be the weakest reformed villain ever. I would like to see Sprout kicked out, forcing him on his own adventure, he finds some dark magic and turns into an alicorn and he comes back all decked out with some like shadow ponies and maybe he gets his own Susanoo.

@Rin 🌙 they knowed each other they were sisters

I’m also wondering what happened to flurry heart, cadence and the royal sisters, where did they go? How did they die? Die they die?

So the artifacts are basically the elements of harmony that represent the pony tribe rather that aspects of friendship? Makes sense since when g4 was still alive, the ponies where more harmonized with each other and just needed the aspects of friendship to unite them while in g5 they are segregated and all needed to be united together, that explains why the magic is rainbow, cuz its always rainbow when the elements of harmony is involved

This kinda reminds me of the Dragon Gem from Rays and the Last Dragon

@DarkChocolateMuffins well butter my biscuits and call me a 1700s colonial guess I have to revoke me bi'ish licence

@British Guy who makes bad content  artefact is the British version of artifact

Noooo what about the two sisters Luna and Celestia


From the way you depicted her after you concluded her un-alicorning, and your theory on how alicorns are made, she probably didn’t die of old age, but of making the crystals. From time stamp 5:31-5:42 you said she split the unicorn, pegasus, and earth pony magic apart and put them into the crystals. Then you depicted her as an earth pony, without the magic from all three tribes. But if her physical figure changed after the de transformation, and she didn’t have any of the magic, and her wings (pegasus), her horn (unicorn) disappeared, and she was left with the earth pony form, but no earth pony magic, then her entire physical form must’ve disappeared.


I love sawtooth theories, because he adds a story into them


This also explains where the wendigos are, or the other magical creatures. As magical creatures, when the magic was destroyed, they would eventually be decayed into their most basil forms.


For a second I thought the conclusion you were going to come to is that Twilight sacrificed her own existence in order to make the crystals. I feel like that makes sense since an alicorn contains unicorn magic, pegasus magic and earth pony magic, so what's left of Twilight if she sacrifices all three?


It would also explain why Sunny turned into an Alicorn in the end, because she shared the same ideals as Twilight and brought unity and friendship to people, which ultimately made the artifacts glow and return the world's magic.

@HazbinOtakuSimp21 well the streak in her hair really did nothing so I don’t think it is a power up

It’s also possible that when the magic was released it sought a pony similar to its host cuz the first thing the magic would want to do is seek out its host. Once it couldn’t sense the host, it sought someone it could coexist with. Twilight is the key. Her magic is the key in my opinion. If Sunny can figure out how to harness the power completely, she might be able to find a way for pony’s to have magic without the artifacts.

@Lunalia  Sunny is an earthen pony in the Tell Your Tale miniseries set in the time after the movie

@Casa de Adoracion Vino Nuevo (Austin) Sunny is the Magical heir to Twilight, in the same kind of way that the main 6 were predestined to be friends and much more. And I'm not so sure that Argyle was, knowingly or not, destined to possess the Earth Pony Crystal. Add in that Sunny's aura (?) is lavender and I'd have to consider this video as good as cannon.

@Casa de Adoracion Vino Nuevo (Austin) A Reincarnation? Oooh that could be fun

@Sister's Diaries how do you know that? She still had them at the end of the movie right?

But sunny's wings and horn arent permanent, there just there for that one moment

Twilight had to go through a full magical ritual to be imbued with Alicorn magic, i think with Sunny it was like "Finally someone who gets it" and it manifested on her.

I think that was a power-up like the Mane Six had when they used the Elements of Harmony or the magic of friendship. The rainbow explosion, the hair change, the glowing wings and horn, all that stuff

Sunny isn't actually a alicorn. If you look at the new upcoming toys from mlp, you can see she doesn't have wings or a horn anymore but she does still have the rainbow streak


Yes, there is a comic which says that twilight made the crystals, because one pony wanted to break apart all of equestrian and discord shows up he's pretty old. I was curious what happened to him, but he's still alive because he's immortal, I guess please check out this comic it's really cool and I think another one will be a release, the same one just part 2 I guess?


Its a pretty interesting theory, but there are a few things that you forgot to discuss. There was a war. Could that have been what caused Twilight to create the artifacts? And if she did give up her horn and wings, wouldn't that mean she also gave up her pony side too? Maybe her spirit was split into three pieces- unicorn, pegasai, and pony- and those spirits became the crystals. Could that mean when the crystals were joined together, allowing magic to return, Twilight's spirits could reawaken? Could we possibly see the return of Twilight Sparkle?

I honestly hope we do.


There is precedent for the ruling alicorn(s) transferring magical power to another vessel to protect it from theft or destruction. Twilight herself was that vessel at least twice, for all three of the other adult alicorns, most notably when Tirek was first introduced to G4.

So there's merit, here. Though why this was so desperate she did it this way, rather than entrusting the magical power to an ally or friend, is another question.

Also, the movie itself was...badly designed/written. The lack of trust between the tribes was shallow and superficial in a way that is unrealistic, and doesn't do justice to FiM's example of how to tell a story. The distrust between groups was, in all but one case I can think of, at least rooted in some real concerns that had to be resolved. It was almost never, "Er, uh, just 'cause they're not like us, and we made up some fake scare thing." (I mean, I kept wondering why the Earth Ponies weren't all wearing their masks to protect themselves from the unicorn-spread disease.)

The one time in G4 FiM we saw something that shallow, it was Chrysalis spreading really stupid rumors that nevertheless seemed to work. I figure she must've been lacing it with her Changeling Charm magic to make it be like D&D's suggestion spell: even though it's stupid, it was worded "reasonably enough" to magically be convincing.

Does that suggest that an evil Changeling is responsible for the tribes splitting up, since the reason was so incredibly shallow?

There is precedent for the ruling alicorn(s) transferring magical power to another vessel to protect it from theft or destruction. Twilight herself was that vessel at least twice, for all three of the other adult alicorns, most notably when Tirek was first introduced to G4.

So there's merit, here. Though why this was so desperate she did it this way, rather than entrusting the magical power to an ally or friend, is another question.

Also, the movie itself was...badly designed/written. The lack of trust between the tribes was shallow and superficial in a way that is unrealistic, and doesn't do justice to FiM's example of how to tell a story. The distrust between groups was, in all but one case I can think of, at least rooted in some real concerns that had to be resolved. It was almost never, "Er, uh, just 'cause they're not like us, and we made up some fake scare thing." (I mean, I kept wondering why the Earth Ponies weren't all wearing their masks to protect themselves from the unicorn-spread disease.)

The one time in G4 FiM we saw something that shallow, it was Chrysalis spreading really stupid rumors that nevertheless seemed to work. I figure she must've been lacing it with her Changeling Charm magic to make it be like D&D's _suggestion_ spell: even though it's stupid, it was worded "reasonably enough" to magically be convincing.

Does that suggest that an evil Changeling is responsible for the tribes splitting up, since the reason was so incredibly shallow?


I was worried about the same thing(twilight imploding into the artifacts)

I had an idea that this was kinda like a new colony of the horses, twilight had a crisis at Equestria’s mainland- and transported a population offshore to a new continent/dimension as a fail safe just in case Equestria fell completely

The crystals are what she supplied( maybe in the same way as this video ) to keep their magic strong without an alicorn in the area

Like how they had the big transport area( the harbor, the ‘airport’ in the sky city ) I wonder if those were meant to help them travel back and forth- but they stopped traveling for some reason(magic running out, or equestrian just being forgotten after a few generations without magic, seen as a fairy tail

Possibly the crystals were a way to concentrate the magic of all of that species just in case they were invaded/as a last line of magical defense— but after they lost that element of friendship that tied them together, they lost the magic it supplied them, (but the crystals kept pulling magic- leaving their inert magic unusable)

This was fun to type out:)) these theory videos are so cool to see/compare notes with from when I saw the movie months ago, thanks for making the videos✨


This is such an inspiring story, and has such a moral too. Someone should really make a full story of Twilight Sparkle, beginning from childhood all the way to the years after her memorable sacrifice. (hint hint Sawtooth)

@MLP_G5_Updates it's just a matter of thinking up a plot

@Sandra Brannon  i assuming that it is "agree"? am i right, Sandra Brannon

Now I'm tempted to write fanfiction on this


I feel like all the ponies had greater power at some point in the past and for some reason they had to band all their power together creating the first Alicorn and or corns.  This could tie into the nature magic of surrounding ponies getting weaker over time cause maybe the alicorns were still drawing magic to maintain.  The more alicorns there were the weaker the general population became.  The key was the different populations bonds to one another but the magic was always there alicorns became like a deadbolt to lock up an abundance of magic.  When celestia and luna removed themselves from the board the magic of the population suffered.  If magic in general started bottoming out and Twilight figured out why she might have down graded herself and made a point to give each "tribe" as it were an equal portion of the magic she had contained and the key to accessing that power was the bond of friendship aka "Friendship is Magic".  Noting the fact that we only see an alicorn again AFTER they bring all the pieces back together in a budding friendship among each tribe.  Sadly I only think about it this way cause I have a 4 year old lil girl and we watch all the shows and movies together.  I also watch Dragonball and Dragonball Super.  I see Alicorns like Super Sayians mixed with Spirit bombs they absorb.  And the reasoning why they're aren't more super sayians is cause theres a key to access it.  Goku and Vegeta have to show others how to access it but before that they have to build them up to it and then unlock it through an event of serious anger rage.  With the Spirit bomb and goku he's taking power from the local global or universal population and either using it to blow stuff up or taking it into him and juicing himself up.  I get that comparing My Little Ponies to DBS is a far stretch and maybe weird but it's a concept I see.  Notice theres only ever a few alicorns cause they don't naturally occur and they only show up under extreme situations. Flurryheart can be explained the same way in DBZ, S explain gohan, trunks, bra, gotan having an easier time transforming.  Once it's unlocked its easier for the next generation to tap it and unlock it.  Were Celestia and Luna Maintaining Alicorn through the magic stockpile they were given when they became Alicorns or were they slowly drawing from the population over time to keep it?  I could be completely wrong and junk I don't consider myself a brony I just watch the shows and movies with my daughter she loves and I absorbed the storyline.  Ok people of the internet rip me apart LOL...

This is why I became a fan of the show in the first place. FIM stands out among the best with Regular show, Adventure Time, Gravity Falls, etc.


I wonder if they would higher you if you applied to work for the show. You have a excellent way of story telling.


This might be an odd suggestion, but what if Twilight IS the crystal. Let me explain.

Some event was draining all the magic from Equestria so she separated her magics out, as you said. BUT now she has no magic what so ever. We've seen what no magic looks like in equestria twice, when Tirek/Cozy glow was draining it, and when Twilight herself drained the magic further from the creatures of Tartarus. If it is a truly dire situation that they are in, I could easily envision Twilight giving what is truly her all as a solution. So she would seperate her magic the same way she did with the creatures of Tartarus, separating not just the magic, but herself into her constituent parts; Earth pony, Pegasus, and Unicorn.


After watching the series I still think that’s the true story