That's a nice theory but her talent is magic and her friends who were a earth pony a unicorn and a pegasus could've sacrificed their magic powered by twilight alicorn magic to make the artifacts. That can also be a take and she could very well be looking over the world in a place of mystical wonder after all the mlpfis pony gals is another dimension where they are human not to far fetched if she is even saving another dimension.


Ya know, put together the crystals kinda look like an arrow. Maybe in the show it'll work as a plot device leading sunny to clues about the past

That and maybe Twilight can be remade, cause if she can make the crystals then maybe the crystals can give her alicorn powers.


Even if twilight sacrificed her life to become a mortal, wouldnt Flurryheart and Princess Candace still be around? Because they still are alicorns and they would possibly still be alive in G5, unless its an alternate universe


I think it means Magic all types of plugs together would mean friendship and friendship is magic. So they probably gained there power by friendship?🤴🤷🏾♀


At 5:50 - 5:55 I think actually that’s not it, I think she sacrificed herself to make these, plus in the show they didn’t say that if they make certain things they can die. So in that matter I might be right.

At 5:50 - 5:55 I think actually that’s not it, I think she sacrificed *herself* to make these, plus in the show they didn’t say that if they make certain things they can die. So in that matter I might be right.

But also if your version of what you think is true you know how if she became a earth pony how they keep her alive for that many years? So she might die, (or get like reborn from a teenager or baby or something like that.) like if she was always just a normal unicorn, but no one knows*.. only the *creators would know*, or if they’re *not sure what it should be they can still just make one up because they’re the creators after all.

But also if *your version of what you think is true* you know how if she *became* a *earth pony* how they keep her alive for that many years? So she might *die, (or get like reborn from a teenager or baby or something like that.) like if she was always just a normal unicorn, but no one knows*.. only the *creators* would *know*, or if they’re *not sure* what it should be they can still just make one up because they’re the *creators* after all.


I'm holding on to hope that she's still out there somewhere, Perhaps trying to fix whatever happened or trapped in stone or limbo like the Pillars for some reason, But either the ponies uniting and magic returning will also cause her to come back or that the mane 5 will find her


Alicorns don't live forever as we have seen with Celestia and Luna, it just lets them live longer


woah!! its you!! I didn't recognize the channel name but the second I heard your voice I knew! Its been so long, since like 2017 at least since ive watched your stuff, gonna binge it now :)


What if Tirek came back stronger than before and was trying to take the magic of the ponies. In order to protect Equestria Twilight divided hers and the ponies magic so that Tirek couldn't take their magic. In doing so Twilight died of old age like everypony else.


Wait I have a question? After Twilight  gives up her alicornhood is she still an unicorn?


With how much time has passed I’m kinda leaning towards the fact that Luster Dawn plays a role in this story. Maybe Twilight retired in a similar way to celestia and Luna and left Luster Dawn to take her place. We also have to remember that the griffons, dragons, etc had to have also been separated somehow. My theory is the dragons or the griffons wanted their superiority back and Luster Dawn didn't have enough forces to defeat them so she took all the magic of the three tribes and put them into the crystals. Then when Argyle was a foal he and his parents found the earth pony crystal and some scripture left by someone who was affected by the memory stone so the history wouldnt get lost. Then Argyle's parents couldnt continue the mission for one reason or another so then Sunny came along.


Listen, this is just a theory but...in the end the three tribes United which brought back magic in equestria...I think the crystals purpose was accually to reunite the tribes bc after izzy mentioned that the pegasi had something to with the disappearance of unicorn magic they went trotting off to zephyr heights for answers and that where they ran into zipp who freed them and showed them the room full of old things that were from the past that we saw in generation 4 but after that they discovered the crystals they made a plan to grab the pegasi crystal from queen haven which they put to action that went unexpectedly wrong and the royals got exposed while the queen was arrested the search for the princesses began all bc izzy and sunnys sneaky plan for the crystal tied into a knot and after they got exposed after sunnys 'horn' fell off they ran away and by that time the queen got out and followed the princess which led to an argument where sunny puts an end to by exposing the fact that nopony has magic after this event where sunny disappointed returns to maritime bay she discover the third crystal and running happily her friends including alphabittle,the queen and the guards work together to stop sprout and his mother tried to stop him to and that led to great risk as a chance was sunny and izzy dieing from the fall and realizing the three ponykinds needed to be reunited not the crystals so its proof that the crystals were important bc they made this happen and all sunny  had to do was follow by the crystals hints however this is just a theory but it fits perfectly well with the purpose of the crystals anyway ty for reading <3


One thing I don’t understand is what happened to the other creatures when we left Equestria it was a happy place were ponies and other creatures like hippogriffs and changeling and dragons etc. could come together what happened to the other creatures


YOU DID NOT TALK ABOUT THE ARCH WITH WINGS, or PORTAL IN THE LOWER RIGHT SIDE OF THE MURAL.
THIS COULD BE AN INDACATION THAT THE MAGIC LEAK IS TRUE.
(cap locks on, grown).
Above the Star it looks like an Alicorn and to the lower left, if I am wrong, pardon.
dose only two, indicate the others killed by the magic drain.
Is this why Twilight made the artifacts, to keep magic from draining and killing all ponies.


I hate when shows cut off at the point where they’ve matured, why couldn’t they make a series continuing their adult lives and show us the hidden lore up until the movie?? I would’ve loved to see alicorn twilight and her friends as well as appledash discovering their love for eachother. LIKE WHY DIDNT WE GET A SERIES BEFORE THE MOVIE??

Same happened with avatar the last airbender, they missed out on creating an entire series of the adult gaang and instead skipped right away to korra leaving us wondering about all the hidden lore/life that happened during that time.

Why don’t companies understand that we want a mature and older version of our beloved characters before we venture off to an entirely new plot


My theory: The deaths of so many important ponies (Shining Armor, the main 6, the pillars, the young 6 minus Smolder) most likely caused a depression in the world, which would cause love and friendship to fade. Candance and Flurry Heart would be very devasted as they both lost Shining Armor. This would make the Crystal Ponies lose hope causing the crystal heart to shatter.

In a effort to save it Candance and Flurry Heart called the other alicorns to help them try to repair it like they did during the crystaling. But they wouldn't have somepony to give the Ponies hope, so instead they tried to save it with a different spell. Though this would save the Heart it would destroy them, this spell transformed the heart into the magical gems that soon became the only source of magic as FRIENDSHIP IS MAGIC.

This would make Spike really angry as he lost the only thing he had left of his family, Twilight. He would run away to the other dragons where he would ease into life. He would start to think like they did and eventually hate ponies when the dragons new emperor started a war against them. The dragons would destroy the ponies homes and once their world was destroyed start moving in. They would be destroyed by the rulers of the new 3 tribes with the Magical Stones each taking one of them as a token of peace. But soon enough the ponies would just spilt apart and without direct contact they would start to hate eachother.

The Ponies would create their communities with the mindsets of the 3 saviors of the world. This would create the cites of ponies we know today. A couple years after that Sunny and Friends were born and the story of the movie would start.


I see what your talking about but maybe she used her alicorn magic to create these and then she could've gone missing maybe in Tartarus or she could be at the crystal empire with cadence


Or maybe queen qrycalist,tirek,and cozy glow are back before mlp new generation and make everypony fight and tirek are stoling pegasi and unicorn magic,and twylight defeat them and banissed them in seperated crytal,unicorn crytal are tirek,pegasus crytal are queen qrytalis,and earth pony are cozy glow,IDK,what do you guys think?😱😱🧐


I like to think that Twilight and friends gave up her physical form to protect Equestria from a greater evil, but not before transferring her alicorn magic (and friendship magic) to the crystals, in order to help future generations. Similar to how Star swirl  the bearded defeated the pony of shadows by trapping Himself  (and others) with the evil, but not before planting the tree of harmony to also help in the future.  So no pony died and Twilight wasn’t left alone to rule. EDIT: Wrote this before watching the video, lol.


Something still needs to be explained Candance Flurry Face and what the catastrophe was that pushed Twilight to do this and what happened to the other alicorns it also seemed like a long enough period that twilight would have chosen a successor and that successor would've become an alicorn by that point in time with twilight Candance flurry heart and whatever other pony was chosen what catastrophe caused them all to loose hope or sacrifice themselves I mean by that point the three alicorns we know of for a fact would've been fully grown all of them probably choosing ponies to continue there rule afterwards so what happened what scared them all so much was it a tirek situation where the princesses passed there magic on to a newer princess but then she failed think of the student we see twilight mentoring at the end of the show (forgot her name) she just then learned about friendship but what if she then betrayed her friends because she thought that was what was right I imagine she only had Candance's and Flurry Hearts magic because of the relics but her magic combined would have been enough to match whatever was threatening them on top of that what happened to the student 6 what happened to the massive alliance with the Griffins dragons yaks changelings and every other species they wouldve been there to help just leaves more questions then answers in my opinion but still it is a great theory

Oh another thing I forgot Discord where is he, he doesn't need a body to exist and I doubt that he wouldn't take this opportunity to take back his rule yes he was reformed but that was mainly because of fluttershy and as much as I hate to say it all the ponies from gen 4 are definitely no longer living he wouldn't have a reason to not take rule as an act of revenge or just pure anger


Does anyone know the artist of the center piece on the glass mural? Or like have a link to the original image?


I think that this fits on the forgotten word Theory because Princess Twilight Sparkle doesn't know how to make it or how to put Magic into it


A thing i still wonder about and why no one has brought it up yet: There is no magic in G5 but the ponies still have cutie marks. In G4 the cutie marks appeared through magic so with no magic left wouldn't it be impossible for the ponies to get a cutie mark? <br>Also they only have their CMs on one side not on both like in G4. And the foals clearly show the ponies are not born with their CMs. So how do/did they acquire them?

A thing i still wonder about and why no one has brought it up yet: There is no magic in G5 but the ponies still have cutie marks. In G4 the cutie marks appeared through magic so with no magic left wouldn't it be impossible for the ponies to get a cutie mark?
Also they only have their CMs on one side not on both like in G4. And the foals clearly show the ponies are not born with their CMs. So how do/did they acquire them?

I don’t think they lost all their magic just a majority of it like unicorns ability to weld magic, the pegasi abilities to fly and thought clouds. They seem to have enough magic to have cutie marks and enough to pick things up with their hooves


But what if twilight never became a regular pony again? What if the magic is all she is and that her own body and spirit are the crystals. Think about it; the crystals are powered by friendship, Twilight was (or is) the literal princess of that. So she must be inside the crystals themselves. Alicorn magic is just raw magic derived from the three tribes put together, not really friendship itself. Which means that she tore herself apart into three crystals to protect the magic. Either that, or because of the way she became an alicorn in the first place (through friendship) is why the magic dies if there's no harmony between all ponies, because her magic is special and runs on friendship. If there's no friendship there's no magic because her magic is literally friendship itself and more than just raw power. Friendship is magic means it is the magic she and her friends run on, and giving that away takes literally all she is. What do you think?


Hey sawtooth even though it’s been 11 months I some now I just seen this video :,) anyway I have theory/prediction here we go I think  in the middle or close to the end of the series a huge villain is gonna come in to the show shattering the crystals with this happening twilight returns regaining her alicorn magic bringing the main the other five back (some how Idk) and they defeat the villain twilight steps down giving her magic to sunny and stepping down from the throne Equestria goes back to how it used to be while the main six existing in the show existing in it like the pillars did in mlp g4 thx for reading this your my favorite mlp theory channel. :)


What about the mane six? Did they die before Twilight? But this is a really good theory, it does make sense.


Can you explain the post credit scene at the end of a new generation


This is better than a lot of your other theories, though I don't think there's nearly enough to say this is Twilights transformation in reverse, while it could explain why Twilight isn't around there would still be the other alicorns.

Something I'm disappointed you didn't mention however is the S10 comics where Danu talks about how Equestria will eventually fall due to conflicts similar to what we see between the tribes and Twilight accepts that this kind of infighting would happen and confirms she'll be prepared and goes onto align with other kingdoms outside of Equestria to defend everyone. So I think a massive threat that could endanger everyone or those other kingdoms going to war is the most likely conclusion.


I miss twilight but I have to leave it in the past


I wish this was canon it makes so much more sense than the canon explanation that the ponies “hurt” other ponies so she created the crystals so they would stop fighting which is so not like her. :|


I think there’s a point to be made that the earth pony looks a lot like twilight’s pupil


These theory are amazing but who  raised the sun and moon I haven't watched the movie it was just the end my baby cousin was watching it and that is how I saw it as well as how did everypony in equestria forget about Twilight and the others as we saw even thousands of years later ponies still knew about the pillars in the show so


That does make sense. But I guess Twilight ended up magic-less, just like she was when Tirek has absorbed her alicorn magic in Season 4 G4. It was either that or she herself divided into 3 parts & each of them ended up in one of the crystals. In the latter case, she is actually living as the crystal ever since. Perhaps that's why the crystals make up the shape of an alicorn. They together signify Princess Twilight Sparkle herself. Maybe since Sunny is an Alicorn now, that Alicorn magic that was stored in the crystals is now a part of Sunny Starstout. Maybe, then of Twilight's alicorn magic is now Sunny's. That would make Sunny the princess of friendship, too. The title does seem suiting, considering the role she played in bringing the pony-kinds back together. I still have hope that perhaps when the crystals were put together Twilight re-appeared somewhere else.

By the way, Sunny isnt an actual alicorn. If you look at the new upcoming toys, you can see she doesnt have wings or a horn but she does have the rainbow streak in her hair still

@Viktória Krivosudská The magic of the crystals would still be there, only in the form of Twilight again. I am sure there must be some old pony tales about princess Twilight & I think the ponies would be happy to have a common ruler, who has achieved great things in the past. Also, they now know that not crystals, but friendship is what contains real magic (just like Sunny said). They all saw how their coming together led to the return of magic. I think they should be happy to have a ruler who has 'friendship-magic' & 'magic-magic'. Though, it will be difficult for Twilight to live without her friends.<br>EDIT: I just noticed that if Twilight reappeared, that would go against Hasbro's statement that "Twilight will not outlive her friends."

@Viktória Krivosudská The magic of the crystals would still be there, only in the form of Twilight again. I am sure there must be some old pony tales about princess Twilight & I think the ponies would be happy to have a common ruler, who has achieved great things in the past. Also, they now know that not crystals, but friendship is what contains real magic (just like Sunny said). They all saw how their coming together led to the return of magic. I think they should be happy to have a ruler who has 'friendship-magic' & 'magic-magic'. Though, it will be difficult for Twilight to live without her friends.
EDIT: I just noticed that if Twilight reappeared, that would go against Hasbro's statement that "Twilight will not outlive her friends."

so bassically
1. when sunny put the crystals together it ultimetly unknowingly brought twilight back
2. sunny is basically "borrowing" twilight magic hence the literal magic horn and wing and rainbow streak of hair
so in a way i hope two of this theory are true

I would say that it would be interesting when G5 would bring all of the crystals back and I don't know this part but maybe destroyed them so all of the magic would once again unite in the word and maybe twilight would appear right in front of them. But that would be cruel to do to Twilight. Or as we could see many times in the crystal empire the ponies united and did their little thingy to unite their magic that mainly worked when they were happy or believed in something. So maybe if every kind of ponies (unicorn, pegasus and earth pony) came together and believed that and the three crystals or monents are not functional anymore so their trust and belief will fill them to the point that they can bring back Twilight after all her magic and maybe life is in them. (Sorry for any grammar mistakes it's just that I am trying to write this fast and I am tired)

Why does this feel like this theory is copying off of ATLA(Avatar)?

That would definitely become such a huge, but interesting surprise that everyone would love to see.


In the future the pony that asks twilight about friendship looks just like sunny


Twilight sparkle actually didnt sacrifice her alicorn-hood or so she might have sacrificed it with the princessess they are also alicorns and they have stronger magic but tho it only shows her cutie mark in the sky look closely to her cutie mark there are 4 princessess and the sparkles that are little may have been the princcesses but tho the other princessess did not survive the crisis because they have been living for a 1000 years so they would turn into ashes for example princcess candace she had the crystal heart as the pegasus crystal but if u dont understand why i said the crystal heart and the pegasus crystal are like the same look closely to both crystals they have kinda have the same color so she might have cut the crystal heart to make a pegasus crystal for the earth crystal it was celestia who did it so she might have made a crystal from the crystal empire the earth crystal and for the unicorn crystal it was luna so she may also grabbed a crystal from the crystla empire before it dissapeard and with Twilight's alicorn magic they put the crystals together and the crystals but people would say what would happen to flurry heart and the crystal empire's people they had to evacuate theirhome and made new ones somehwere we dont know. but the princcesses costed their lives for equestria to have magic though the magic will be 100& since they put crystals together but the human world still has 50% of equestria's magic but does the human world have the crystals of the eup if so i would like to see a video if the human world had the crystals so this is my theory except for the percent of equestria's magic to the human tho i might have think twilight's friend also included in this situation...


Honestly I think that what’s said in this video is true but I think that maybe twilight didn’t come back cause if she had lost her unicorn <br>Magic along with her horn that she had to begin with and her wings from the Pegasi magic then what does she lose from the earth ponies or does not lose anything at all like all horn and wings no magic

Honestly I think that what’s said in this video is true but I think that maybe twilight didn’t come back cause if she had lost her unicorn
Magic along with her horn that she had to begin with and her wings from the Pegasi magic then what does she lose from the earth ponies or does not lose anything at all like all horn and wings no magic


Maybe She wanted to teach them the future ponys same lesson She learned


I kind of think that Argyle might be a descendant of Twilight, after all with the loss of her alicorn magic she'd be an earth pony, right?
It would explain why he knew about the main 6 and why he believes that the three tribes can be united again.
Plus Starshine sounds similar to Twilight Sparkle, and it is his last name.
It would also explain why he had the earth pony crystal.


If twilight put magic from all species of pony including earth pony then she wouldn't have had any magic and would have ceased to exist


just like the tree of harmony that predicted twilight becoming princess

there must have been a prophecy showing ponies deciding and twilight did what she thought was right

at the corner of the mural with twilight's cutie mark there's a grave stone with wings I think


I think she survived, but she still kept most of her alicorn magic cuz you can’t undo being one and she’s still immortal she’s probably with celestia and her sister maybe she just wasn’t mentioned


i feel like argyll might be a descendent of twilight he was similar colors to her


I'm embarrassed to admit that only today I realized the crystals looked like an alicorn.


Omg I love your theory’s they all could be so true !!!!


is it possible all the magic drained into equestria girl's world?


Ok major question. Where is everyone else? what happened to all the kingdoms and other species. Even after the main 6 were gone. The tree of harmony had picked new leaders to carry on this tradition. Why didnt it pick more after. The school of friendship? where are all the other towns


The "Oh My MoThEr oF CeLeCtIa" was the best part I think do you agree it was just funny


It's probably worth noting that there is precedent for this sort of thing: Celestia, Luna, and Cadance gave up their alicorn magic to Twilight in Twilight's Kingdom. <br>Although. . . what of Flurry in all this?

It's probably worth noting that there is precedent for this sort of thing: Celestia, Luna, and Cadance gave up their alicorn magic to Twilight in Twilight's Kingdom.
Although. . . what of Flurry in all this?

I wish we knew what happened to Cadence and Flurry.

I like to think that Flurry had a normal pony lifespan, because she didn't become an alicorn in the traditional way, but that's just me


I'm guessing twilight was part of a proficy writen not by pony hooves but the leaves of a tree twilight was carrying a torch of destiny archestrated by the tree of harmeny set in motion by princess celestia and ended with twilights sacrifice.
End of one proficey start of the next.
Theres more but I forget.
Oh yeah now I remember your wrong about alicorns being imortal they're actual long liveing not imortal.
If they were imortal why would celestia be so desperet for a warthy air if she thought she would be equestrias ruler forever.


My theory the mane 6 tried to live forever to by freezing themselves in an ice box and twilight joined them


Ummm ok so I have a conclusion twilight created the 3 crystals is because they  would protect equestria in case the 3 tribes would ever grow apart again


What if Twilight sparkle found a magical person and traded herself in to save the world


i didn’t plan to cry. g4 is such a legend, and i’m not ready to let it go, even though i don’t watch mlp anymore. i want the days back of celestia and twilight, where it all began


Is it just me or is Sawtooth’s voice changing


The big questions is, what about the other races, changlings, dragons, griffons and hippogriffs. And most of all, what happened to discors


She also must have sacrificed her life to for the earth pony gem.


She did not gave up her wings or horn bc on C2 she showed on a hologram but maybe she gave up her Half magic and the other half is used to her self mainting herself but when that didint work she used her magic all of her turning her into an hologram of the unity crystal (this is just the theory)


Amazing again! You never disappoint us Sawtooth💕


1:20 shes the princess of friendship, the crystals give magic to all if all tribes are united, boom, friendship


But what about Flurry Heart? We known nothing about her. Why did she born as an Alicorn? We never got an explanation.


Don't know what you can do with this information, but twilights feather in the lighthouse is relatively close to 200 years old


I get how I could be wrong here, but what if the crisis required the crystals being made, was the human dimension? I don’t know if this was ever fixed or not, but in the legend of Everfree, it shows how all this equestrian magic has been seeping into the human world, there was a crack on the statue in canter lit high that is one of the portals to equestria, and the magic was leaking out: what if no pony or human really noticed and too much of that magic had leaked into the human world, causing the ponies to lose their magical abilities that they were born with. And because of this twilight used her own magic to create the crystals before it was too late, and equestria ran out of magic completely.

But I do see how much I could be wrong here, because if all that magic leaked into the human world, wouldn’t there have been a way to get at least some of it back?? They are both connected by these portals, but I’ve thought that if almost all of the magic leaked out from equestria, then that might have also included that magic that makes it possible to travel between realms. If this were the reason, it would make some sense for twilight to create the crystals, but it also wouldn’t.

This situation could easily have been avoided, both because of the mane 7 in the human world And because the original twilight has gone through the mirror multiple times, and knows much about the human world, and because the mirror is in her possession, she could have easily gone into the human world to stop the Magic from completely slipping away, and bringing back to equestria.

I don’t think I’m correct, but I also do feel as though this could be a possibility. But all I do know for sure, is that for twilight to sacrifice herself completely, and use artifacts to protect equestrian magic, the crisis must have been severe.

I would love to know what had happened if this Sawtooth theory is never debunked.


You forgot something interesting about magic. Artifacts are the only thing that doesn't seem to change when they are brought through the mirror portal.

While they don't act the same, they clearly still have a lot of magic in a magic less world. So artifacts might produce magic.

@DISNEY 101
Well, it still worked somewhat normally for twilight. It just worked like that for starlight. So it wasn't completely mirrored. A random spurt of magic changed a girl's mirror into a magic item and grew her to giant proportions after tricking her into thinking she was famous. . Another time some magic condensed into geodes that gave people powers based on their personality and wants.

Magic seems more alive and aware in the human world. The way it changes itself even makes it seem opportunistic, like an evil Genie willing to grant wishes and cause chaos to grow in power. Huh, in Equestria magic sometimes has a sense of being alive, but in the human world, it seems MUCH more desperate and active. Maybe magic is alive and it knows it can't survive in a magicless world without latching onto something so it changes to feed on anyone around.

@rolay 7 This actually makes sense. Like a mirror, it reflected it. Making the opposite of what it is.

@BassBoss yep, I am still confused why the crown of friendship turned Sunset into a demon. I am 90% sure it couldn't always do that at will, so the mirror portal did something to it.

You mean the Equestria Girls mirror portal thing right?


Where is Cadence, Flurry Heart, the Yaks, the Hippogriffs, the griffins, the changelings? What happened to the other spesies of Equestria?


broo this actually gave me chills watching this XD


"not again... "<br>wait, when was the last time a "chicken" turned you to stone?

"not again... "
wait, when was the last time a "chicken" turned you to stone?


Ok so from what I can gather from the episode from mark your mark growing pain the ariocorn at the end of chapter 1 tried to take control over magic but twilight stored the magic in the crtyles


Ok but hear me out, what if each of the gems is a little piece of Twighlights soul.
Not a full piece because reuniting them would bring back Twighlight.
But instead very small fragmented parts of her soul is in each of the gems.

Also side not, was the pegisi gem made from the crystal heart? Because the colors on each look the same.

If it must easy to take her out maybe Tirek or gogar take her out and kill her that’s gonna be bad

That’s my guess

@Soul_Raider maybe her soul not become one with sunny if twilight use magic to make her soul inside that crystal I think it should use very strong magic to make her out I think we should wait for next new generation movie?

That’s my guess

Weren't they combined at the end of the film?
Did her soul become one with Sunny in the finale giving her Wings and a Horn?

Idk, Just a guess

You mean like the horcruxes from Harry Potter?

Honestly my theory was that all the gems were made from the crystal heart and they're different colors because each part was infused with a different princesses Magic


If twilight lost her horn and wings when she made the unicorn and Pegasus crystals , then when she made the earth pony crystal then wouldn’t she lose all her magic and look like the earth pony’s from the episode where that one guy ( I don’t remember his name or the episodes name) took the magic for the earth pony’s and be all droopy with dull eyes?


But what if twilight's magic runs out I could imagine it would be due to pony's using it too much.


I think the Tirek, Chrysalis and Cozy glow have escaped and attacked Equestria.Then twilight had to give her alicorn magic which I think leaded to her death.


I think Twilight planned it
   That's why the Crystals were able to Combine

 By the way

  Argile seems to have familiar Colors for the mane and tail, perhaps...... A Decendent of Twilight ?


Ok but what if Twilight was so heartbroken about her friends no longer being with her that she decided that she didn't want anyone else to go through that much pain and irrationally decided to separate everyone's abilities

@Sara Samaletdin I agree which is why my theory is that Twilight ends up having to fight Spike and I actually have valid reason for that

Twilight had other friends and continued to make more, and other people and family she knew with long lives such as Spike, Cadance and Flurry chiefly, and Discord, Ember etc too. She would not despair so loosing the Mane 6 since she would not be alone. Celestia survived with much less.


I think that Sunny is a descendant of Twilight Sparkle witch is why she became an Alicorn when the artifacts were reunited.


Either it's this or she sacrificed herself and became the crystals itself


i predicted sunny being an alicorn five minutes in lol


My question: is twilight dead? If not, why not? If she is, where is her body?
And her tomb?
And what happened to her friends?
I NEED ANSWERS!


after rewatching the endings of FIM season 8 & 9, which were absolutely filled with intense emotion and joy to see our favourite mane 6 overcome their enemies, i would really love to see the story behind why Twilight had to make these crystals and why magic disappeared. i know it would probably be so sad, but i still would love to know what happened :(


My least favorite person in the new generation isn’t sprout or his mother , it’s the history teacher from the beginning of the movie


I think that twilight will come back if there is a session 10 in my little pony we will just have to see


Ok, random question for you: From a timeline perspective (not counting her time on the moon), Luna had been in power for most likely maybe a century and a half? Probably a little longer than an average pony lifetime (I think).  She never grew to Celestia's size, which I always just figured was because she was younger and hadn't had the chance to grow like her sister had. But then the season 9 finale happened and we saw that Twilight had grown to Celestia's size before her friends' lives ended. So how in the world did Twilight grow so much faster than Luna?

that would also explain why nightmare moons form was equal to the size of an alicorn, she was able to temporarily stun celestia before she used the elements which means her magic must have been stronger as nightmare moon too. Whereas she’s much smaller when she turns back into her pony form.

Is probably a magic thing like Celestia had more magic than Luna same with thorax and pharynx ,pharynx was the older brother but ended up being smaller in his new form

I think its because Twilight got some magic from both Celestia and Luna (to raise the sun and moon). I think the more magic you have, the bigger you grow. If you look at cozy glow when she turned into an alicorn and got hella magic from the bell thing, she grew 30 times her size.

@14th banana king but even without her time on the moon, she has ruled for over a century! Isn't that longer than Twilight was a ruler?

Maybe she didn't grow in the thousand years she was on the moon


No, Twirghlite just make crystals she didn't became an earth pony just to make crystals. And she get all of the magic in Equestria and put it in the crystals. That's what she did, i new it from comics.


Don’t dragons live that long to settle maybe in this new generation there’s no go to like the dragon lands and find Spike and get his side of the story maybe even meet one of his kids and go on a journey with them


NO STOP WHAT IF THE CRISIS TOOK THE LIVES OF TWILIGHT'S FRIENDS omg just thinking about how tragic it would have been and at the very last moment she sacrificed herself with tears in her eyes UGH


Unpopular opinion: The three crystal is actually Twilight's Horcruxes. Each crystal contains her soul...


6:15 No, she didn't survive that. Because every kind of ponys has their own magic, so when she put all her magic into those crystals, she had no magic left for her own life. She spent the last moment of her life in unimaginable agony, as her soul itself split into those crystals. And yet, they do not remember what she did for ponykind.


Mabey when the crises ended, twilight couldn't go back and you know the rest


Look at the earth pony crystal and the key to tarterrus they look the same so maybe the crystals was already made be for twilight


What i saw in the mural was that Twilight put her magic in the crystals and became the crystals.


You are the nicest changeling I have ever seen ❤


Ok if this is real it will make my respect of Twilight increase more.


Do you know when they brought back the agent ponies there a percent of their king marks in their elements of harmony think they’ll find a Ponyville because I found other ones old town


My theory:when flurryheart destroyed  the  crystal  heart  the used the crystalling  gem to   build it again welll maybe twilight used  her magic in some sort  of gem and used alll her magic to make them   she also probably  used the help of candace and flurryheart  and twilight gave them to three special fillys and colts  sunnys dad . The pegasus queen. Alphabittle .  Which made the alicorns disappear. And you know the rest

I agree i always thought that each piece of the crystal was made from the crystal heart infused with each princess magic because they're all different colors also it would kind of make sense that Twilight would make the Unicorn Crystal because she used to be a unicorn Cadence would make the Pegasus Crystal for that same reason and then flurry heart would make her last Crystal being a combination of the two


Then what happened to flurry heart cadence and the crystal empire? Please make this theory.


well that may have told about twilight but what about the others Luna, Celestia, princess Cadence and her family, the pillars of equestria, and the rest that help saved equestria in the last known dilemma.  sounds like the foundation that she built fell apart easy


This is such an inspiring story, and has such a moral too. Someone should really make a full story of Twilight Sparkle, beginning from childhood all the way to the years after her memorable sacrifice. (hint hint Sawtooth)

171

Mollie Cool
Mollie Cool


I really hope that's not what happened. And + maybe that DID happen but somehow by the magic of friendship she got em back lol?


This would explain why she was going to be an earth pony in G5


Tbh this does seem to the answer, but here’s what I think. Aldo I do think this is what happened, Alicorn or not, Twilight and the other alicorns would have been dead by now, remember twilight’s era is now ancient equestria, so even if she didn’t did this, she would have either way died. Yes, alicorns have a REALLY long lifespan but…. Ok, OUR human realm is FAR close from equestria, ancient for us is thousands, thousands and sometimes even millions of years ago, and aldo alicorns have a long lifespan, I don’t think it’ll last that long. That also explains why the others are nowhere to be seen….. so yeh, that’s all I had to say, bai

!! - - 𝙋𝙖𝙩𝙩𝙮 𝙏𝙝𝙚 𝙒𝙚𝙞𝙧𝙙𝙤 ★


Yeah I think that's right twilight must have sacrificed herself for the future.


This all makes sense but.. what happened to FLURRY HEART ?
What i mean by this is, why aren't any of the crystal ponies or flurry Heart ever in the new movie? Could flurry Heart have been able to see the future from the crystal heart and brought her and the crystal ponies to where they wouldn't have had to deal with the future?

This all makes sense but.. what happened to *FLURRY HEART* ?
What i mean by this is, why aren't any of the crystal ponies or flurry Heart ever in the new movie? Could flurry Heart have been able to see the future from the crystal heart and brought her and the crystal ponies to where they wouldn't have had to deal with the future?


Twilight getting rid of her wings and horn would be like humans getting rid of their limbs. They are part of her. She can never get rid of it


One flaw. Flurry Heart and Cadence  they are alicons


So she gave up her wings, horn, and I guess magic core?


Doesn’t anyone get it?! Twilight is Sunnys MOTHER!


So, what about Princess Celestia and Princess Luna? Where were they? If alicorns can live for hundreds of years, it wouldn't make sense for Celestia and Luna to just dissapear. Especially if such a huge sacriface needed to be made. The story of where Twilight went makes sense, but we can't just ignore the other two, no, four, alicorns. Celestia, Luna, Cadence, and Flurry Heart. Though Cadence and Flurry Heart aren't as relevent as they live farther away, they still are also alicorns, and should've also been affected by what happened. Where were they?

luna and celestia were already over 1000 so they were probably long gone when the crystals were created and maybe the crystals were the things raising the sun and the moon since none of the crystals were locked in stone or anything so they maybe could have done the job.

Yes, and who is taking care of raising the sun and the moon?


Wait, if all of what you said is true...

 The tree of harmony might still be alive, But seeing all this Disharmony  and hunger of power it did'nt show up to help the ponies... Where's the Everfree forest? Surely someone must control it. (It could be Discord but it also could be the tree)& since The tree rarely responds to Powerful and strong friendship, It might even respond to sunny and her friends :O

Like it did to the Young six & Mane 6
Giving them something neat enough to make history on how it's still alive & magical.

Maybe Sunny's friendship is still raw, and will get stronger and powerful as time goes...
Maybe The tree wold respond..?


turned to stone and stayed in that state for thousands of years... <br>Sounds familiar... 🧐

turned to stone and stayed in that state for thousands of years...
Sounds familiar... 🧐


I feel like sunny is related somehow to twilight I kept seeing hints of it in her house


I think it could really be correct. It makes so much sense.


Adding to your theory, the crisis in question was caused by pony kind themselves.  See a theory I’ve had as to why magic went away is a mix of movies Pixars’ Onward and the Disney+ movie Upside down magic.  The Onward half is eventually technology grew more advanced over time resulting in magic being used less and less.  And the upside down magic half is magic is like a mussel don’t use for long enough you lose it.  At some point ponies just flat out disconnected magically from the land(hence why nature runs by itself naturally).  Twilight so desperate to preserve pony magic expelled her alicorn magic and forged it into the tribal crystals.

@Kjones520 probably because not only to do good use, but also some fall into the wrong hands that used magic to do evil things

That does makes sense. What's the purpose of using advanced technology if you have magic that can do almost everything? That's why most fantasy stories have more magic than technology.


Go and leave your mark vandalize my heart said you keep me safe now you're tearing me down


I think twilight just died because she used her earth pony magic as well her physical body would have just disappeared, her horn wings and body would be gone and she would be dead, missing.


i like to think twilight sealed herself in the crystles and can only come back once friendship and harmony are completely together again and everycreature is united again (like where are the yaks and griffins and hippogryphs and changelings????)


Whoever is watching this in 2022 after “Make Your Mark” series the whole story was explained thanks to sunny(No efense)


I never really liked the idea that artificial magic or magical artifacts being more resistant to magical syphoning, but I could get that a purposed build long lasting artifacts designed to reawaken Equestrian magic being blocked off is plausible to me, but what if that Twilight herself alone wasn't enough to do it, or to last that long, how about Celestia, Luna, Cadence, Fleury Heart also taking a part in it's creation, or had done similar sacrifices for the long lasting greater good of ponies/creatures. But if Twilight did foresee the disaster coming, and created that artifact in anticipation of it, and from Izzy is just can randomly one day after the ponies were divided, it suggest  that the knew that Twilight herself wouldn't be to top the disappearance of magic or that she would just have also been seeped in it and become magicless anyway. I think that what ever happen, Twilight KNEW(possibly might even be partly the cause of it) that what ever what blocking their magic what to powerful to overcome when it finally reared it's ugly head, but that it would eventually weaken over a long period of time, and that it would only need a catalyst to reawaken the magic, or more precisely, not just ant magic, but the magic of friendship. She sealed off her alicorn essence into the artifacts to be reactivated later to unlock the magic, and was intentionally given to prominent representatives of all three tribes with a subdual to keep, but it was so long ago that their purposes  were forgotten, that the schedule time was forgotten. and most were lost. I could also wonder the lost of magic was also choice made Twilight to force ponies to stop relying so much on magic and focus more on technology instead for a while, THEN, go back with magic with an amalgamation of the two working.

@ChristinewhoYT Actually I think you bring up another interesting detail to this. What if the artifacts also involved time travel magic in a way that actually slowed down the degradation of magic contained inside, or just dislocated it in time to keep it unaffected making the resilience of the magic contained last so much longer then all artifacts created before even more so then King Sombra's curse on the crystal Empire which was am impressive feat. It could also be that that the artifacts here divided up to make sure that on one tribe would have a complete control over it's powers or dividing it. Or, it could be that the artifacts are actually keys that allow magic spell ACTIVE only from the PAST lock in in the time and location in the future and activate a micro porthole that to seep in and travel to the present spreading in Equestria where the magic was truly gone at that time and place. or has a build in cascade effect to make it's spreading all the more potent. Heck it could even be that Doctor Whooves had something to do in this. If magic well and truly dead in that time it would mean that League of Evil probably were freed from their stone prison, and lived out a long magicless lives and couldn't do anything to change whatever happened and just eventually died including all other magical immortal creatures. So it could truly be that Equestria has a nearly complete blank slate of when it come to magic in this world.

Actually the Crystal Empire also seems to have gone mixing so you could be right.


HOW DID I NEVER NOTICE THE STAINED GLASS AT THE END OF GEN 4 SHOW


That is what I said . Twilight has the power of the 3 tribes so she can create the 3 crystal parts.


So she committed the ultimate sacrifice by giving up her immortality so the new generation could have magic ? Woah. Well at least she’ll grow old with her friends.


Oh my gosh you were right about the 3 Unity Crystals in make your Mark Chapter 2 Growing Pains!


As far as I'm concerned, your theories are canon. They just fit way to well into the story to not be. This is just, the perfect explanation and ties into Twilight's alicorn journey


Ok so...
About this....
What about the other princesses??
What if they WERENT IMORTAL!
Or Twilight is still around...
And still watching...
And may be in the new show coming out!
Idk just some thoughts that came to my mind!

Lucy Twilight (Moved Too MyLittlePonyMusicCovers)


Tbh I thought it was like a three generation so sunny star scout could prob be twilights grand child..think about it he has the purple like body as twilight and his mane is also purple like twilight so my theory is twilight made a child who is arkil mom then arkil mom made a child that child is arkil (sorry if I spelled his name wrong) ok so arkil passed on the memory of his grandma twilight on sunny star scout and maybe that’s why she’s kinda connected to the magic crystals maybe that’s why SHE was the one chosen to do this..maybe this was twilights final wish.....(I really liked twilight sparkle and her friends I rrly wish it has more series with them and it didn’t have to end so quick and skip to a new generation 😔 maybe in a next movie they may have a little hallucination of twilight or maybe when there in trouble again a spirit form of twilight maybe come to help? I rrly wanna see the main 6 again hopefully mlp developers can add them somehow👏)


What if while she sacrifice her magic at the same moment she sacrificed her life I mean for the pegasus she sacrifice the magic of her wings so they disappeared,for the unicorns she sacrifice her unicorn magic so it disappeared to and for the earth pony she sacrifice her pony magic Wich could mean by doing that she erased herself just like that whitout having to die naturally...


i dont think she lived out the rest of her days as a mortal

rather seconds.

i dont think she lived out the rest of her days as a mortal

_rather seconds._


I really like the idea of Twilight sacrificing herself to keep magic alive in Equestria, it makes sense because she is not only the princess of harmony, Twilight seems to represent magic in it's pure form, and putting her powers into the artifacts so that ponies can use magic is a cool idea


I actually wonder what happened to equestria girls? Did the magic disappear after the real ponies died? Who are the new 7 girls who possess the magic now? What happened to the necklaces they had??


what I think is that the movie should have been first but coukdnt complete it so they did the series of my little pony first so what i think is that <br>sunny is the mother of celestia and luna and there was someone there before that had the same cutie mark as twilight so they carriend on the generation and the crystals became the elements of harmony

what I think is that the movie should have been first but coukdnt complete it so they did the series of my little pony first so what i think is that
sunny is the mother of celestia and luna and there was someone there before that had the same cutie mark as twilight so they carriend on the generation and the crystals became the elements of harmony


Oh my god i havent watched your videos in so long im glad to be back here😭👍🏼


What if sunny isn't actually and aliccorn and its sorta like another version of the alicorn amulet maybe that's why sunny doesn't have physical wings and horn


all mlp theorist need to come together as one and discuss this further


Good riddance tbh. I found her character super annoying. I really like how the new gen has a different look on the stereotypical pony kinds we saw in fim


Wait a minute. If the pony world is sooooo advanced with phones and other modern day items how does the Human world look like? Can you please do a video about this topic? I reeally am curious.


SAWTOOTH! I HAVE A VERY VERY BIG THEORY THAT MIGHT LITERALLY RUIN THIS VIDEO!!! 😣😔😖WHO RAISES THE SUN AND MOON IF THERE ARE NO ALICORNS THAT DO THIS !!!


Now the last Question is: Why?
Did Tirek and the others return?
Did Cozy erase the Worlds natural Magic?
Maybe the Main 6 were too old and frail to fight against them again and couldn't stop them, so Twilight decided to seal away her own Magic in those Artifacts to keep the 3 Tribes Magic alive in some form
Or maybe Tirek found a way to drain the Friendshop Magic from the Main 6?
But there's another Question: What happened to their Allies?
There was shot with an Equestria's Map and it seemed ALOT smaller amount of Land then back in the day
Maybe a War broke out between the different Species? Maybe they were the one's to free Tirek and the others so they could could take the most effective weapon of the ponies away? Magic! Maybe they took over all that land and left the ponies with that small bit


I... am gonna write a continuation that doesn't go down this catastrophe route >~>


Hold up if celesta and Luna can live thousands years who says that twighlight can’t. But if she can’t what about celesta and Luna they don’t look old when the end comes flurry heart to.


That makes me cry please take care of the Twilights crystals because now I know that Twilight sacrifice for those crystals


This theory just ruined my childhood favorite show..


this would also explain twilight’s brief message in make your mark!


I think twilight sacrifice herself to save whole equestria and protecting the crystals and equestrians and maybe after her sacrifice everypony honored her


What if Twilight had a son after and that is Argyle so sunny is twilight’s grandaughter


I sometimes don’t get what you say but today I started to cry


1:10 just realized how brilliant this shot framing is: Sunny is filling in where the earth pony window should be

I thought the same, missed it in my watch through.


How threatening has to be the new villain (spoilers) <del>evil alicorn</del> for Twilight to end up doing this

How threatening has to be the new villain (spoilers) -evil alicorn- for Twilight to end up doing this


Something must’ve happened to Twilight like some bad guy she would’ve made a sacrifice to defeat like she died or got missing so that she wasn’t around


Meanwhile Hasbro when they saw this: WELL I DID NOT KNOW WHAT WOULD BE, WELL YOU KNOW.


I get hasbro is basically holding back the rabid fans to set up G5 to go on the road but geez, all these mystery is sure one way to get everyone interested.


So twilight is missing and there’s 3 crystals maybe she made them so if they do separate they will notice that they have to be together just  like sunny found out hopefully twilight is okay idk if there is anymore twilight coming but sunny is a bit like twilight she got wings but not horn maybe twilight licked sunny to find out that same thing she found out idk if this true or nit I just hope twilight comes back she my favourite


I think your right sawtooth waves twilight sparkle's sacrifice was a big sacrifice.


So how come they didnt have magic when they were lost?


It’s all crazy enough to be possible! She gave up everything, including her unicorn magic, for the sake of harmony…


my theory is alicorns are immortal right because of the mixed breed of earth pony,pegasi and unicorns but what if when the magic disappeared the immortality in the alicorns bloodline disappeared too because the ponys lost their magic and so is the immortality in the alicorns thats why they banished (correct my grammatical errors)


because if twilight had a twin with the exact same magic as her she couldve took the bullet so twilight could go on


Ok, I love the theory, but the only thing throwing me off is the colors. It’s Starlight Shimmer’s colors, not Twilight.


I think your theory is a really good idea! However, when the other 3 alicorns transferred all their magic to Twilight is a similar scenario. Celestia and Luna seem to be hundreds, if not thousands, of years old - so if they lost immortality wouldn’t they instantly die of old age? Or maybe Luna didn’t age when she was in the moon but we still don’t know exactly know how old the sisters are.

I heard of another theory of Luna & Celestia becoming the sun and moon permanently to keep rising.


In the Netflix series there are some hints from Twilight herself about the 'crises'


OK so you may be asking what about the other allicorns and I was thinking about that catastrophic event sawtooth suggested but instead of it just bein twilight who had to sacrifice her magic to restore it what if All the allicorns had to use their magic combined to restore it to create or help the new generation to live on and maybe this theory could lead onto the other allicorn we saw in make ur mark so this catastrophic event would have to end friendship is magic also consisting of storing the allicorn magic outside of The princesses to save G5 but then again G5 would have to be leaden by somepony so what if it were this mysterious allicorn, but when the tribes separated that allicorn lost her sense of connection with magic and the tribes


Your ending is a lil off i believe. Sure Twilight could go & retire but she'd still be known to ppl & would help leave a government in place. Even if she did all that it wouldn't have lead to the friendship era ending


Ever since the movie came out, I've came up with a small theory. We all know that all three ponies lost their own type of magic, right? Well, there is an important character during G4 that never got her magic in the first place. Scootaloo. I haven't developed a whole theory to the idea yet, but what if the loss of magic began with her? Then after generation to generation, the same effect kept happening. Less ponies were able to have their own magic inside of them, to eventually they all became divided, blaming it on Earth ponies, Unicorn, and the Pegasus. I would love to see a video going more into depth on the idea!!

Woah, that’s actually a cool thought....but I think scootaloo was just disabled. Her wings never grew to the regular size of a pegasi, which is why I think she couldn’t. Whereas the present pegasi HAVE fully developed wings, but they can’t fly due to lack of magic.


4:30 DONT YOU DARE SAY SHE USED HER BODY OR SOUL TO CREATE THEM ;-;


I’m just glad that I have some answers about Twilight😭😭😭


equestria from the past is what celestial wanted to be now its twilight turn to make a new world


What about Candice? Wasn't she an alicorn too?🤔


yo this was so fucking cool, Saw
I'm so proud of you!!!! omg!!!!
this was so well made <3

that means so much to me, thank you so much <333


What is cozy glow, terek, and crysaliss rid the world, of magic? They could have escaped and they were the final threat that twilight and her friends have to face before twilight sacrificing herself. Since they were getting old so many factors could have come into play with this but soon the mane 6 may have failed and the magic was gone. As twilight used the last ounce of energy she had to get rid of the 3 for good, she must have then sacrifiecedbherbown magic after not finding on how to get the magic back.


I was just thinking that this could be an alternate universe


What if Twilight is still alive and Equestria was still around but after Twilight made the artifacts Equestria was put under a curse because of Twilight making the artifacts so Equestria disappeared like how the crystal empire did when zambra put a curse on the entire crystal empire and Twilight and her friends are still alive!!!?


im still sure of it that sunny's dad is related to twilight + he looks exactly the same but as a male


It would be amazing if you just managed to predict exactly what they had planned for the entire run of the tv series lol


That could be it but you have to remember if she stayed a princess she would've out lived all of her friends so maybe that could've also been a reason why she decided to give it up.

Show staff said that it's up to fans to decide if she outlives them or not, and a lot of us chose that she doesn't.


you're the smartest person in this fandom


No did you know Netflix make another episode. In the episode twilight said ( an evil  pony try to take all of equestria magic and almost almost take it. I try to put all of my power  and put the magic but the spell was broken ) i let the you to discover the rest. Thank you


BROOO this is actually depressing but it does make a lot of sense as you said, for the information that we have for now, one of my favourite theories of yours so far! You never fail to impress us Sawtooth :>


Imma be honest. I hate this movie. Because it basically tosses everything that happened in MLP out the window. This movie has so many plot holes, it’s infuriating. What happened to all the other species we learned about? Hippogriffs, yaks, Changlings? This movie should’ve been it’s own story in an alternate universe, not a continuation of a show that had a perfect ending


1:21 we're it shows twilights cutie mark on that section in the right of the painting thing you can see a tombstone with greenish wings like not the bottom part the top part like we're twilights cutie mark is like how there divided there's something in the right corner 👀


Also, when you combine purple 3-sided stars around crystals, you get an incomplete Twilight's Cutie Mark! It seems to confirm this theory.


But, hey that’s a just a theory, a film theory

Couldn’t resist


as u can see in the cutie mark there are five stars surrounding the big one in the middle which my represent the six the big star in the middle being twilight maybe by using all of her friends magic and hers she made the crystal maybe explaining the disapearence of all of them.


If so. Dying is a lot more meciful. Twilight is the princess of friendship and in the season 9 its quite obvious that she'll live longer than sher friends so... Yea its a win win situation for her, for me.


What if the crystal kingdom is within the crystals? It may sound stupid but yeah


I see one problem. When philars heve given theri magic (of corse not all) to a Tree of Harmony and still they where poverfull. Thay dont need to give up all of magic. Correct me if i'm wrong. (I still hope to see some of past characters like Discord or Twilight.)


There is a 70% chance that this theory is true


I wanna watch my little pony so bad now omg it’s been years


you know how you said her fate, a SPARKLE at TWILIGHT! basically her name switched around


I never knew I was gonna cry through this 😢😭but
Love this theory 💜
As heart breaking as it is 💔
It's beautiful 💖


i think the meural for the earth ponies isnt there because its a train station where earth ponies can go up to zephyr heights.


I know this isn’t related to the video but, since the time period in mlp gen 4 it’s 1995-2005 based on the mannerisms and rainbow dashes style, when they showed season 9 and mlp gen 5 it showed what would happen in the future. So today it’s 2021 in mlp gen 4 right now.


I think that Twilight turned into the crystals and one day she will come back.


The glass is like that because that castle is princess Celestias castle.


I think that Twilight is quite literally the crystals. Let me explain. So, as you mentioned, there could have been some kind of major crisis, which I think is ponies losing their magic entirely, so Twilight could have used some sort of spell, or maybe a potion, to separate her magic into the crystals, but without her magic combined to make her exist physically, she would be separated into the crystals, one kind of magic into each. Also, I just have to point out that the crystals match something that makes the tribes special: the unicorn crystal looks like a horn, the pegasus crystal looks like wings, and the earth pony crystal looks like a hoof, which is what earth ponies are commonly known for, farming with their hooves.


I was just thinking you said that we have never seen the human sunset but the first time we saw sunset her magic was blue but later when sunset human rainbowdash an human twilight the magic of sunset is red so maybe we did see the human sunset


If what you are saying is true then what happened to the other princesses?


Why is sunny not an alicorn like Twilight sparkle and now at the beginning the crystals show the cutie mark or elements of harmony this is amazing Pegasus's queen has her rights the article the Miraculous new year for all of as but now I see the fate of Twilight sparkle ends now or never


Pre-Alicorn Twilight was, as near as can be seen, destroyed. Can she separate without sacrifice her Alicornhood without giving up her physical form?
What of Flurryheart?
Did Gryphons survive the magic loss event? What of other combined forms?
I don't know if we have enough information on how G4 and G5 relate to each other to do much speculating at this time.

Ponies still have cutie marks, even without magic... So I think the kind of magic that makes up physical beings is still around, it's just that the kind of magic that can be <i>used</i> that vanished.

Ponies still have cutie marks, even without magic... So I think the kind of magic that makes up physical beings is still around, it's just that the kind of magic that can be _used_ that vanished.


If think Christina Ikerenge is right.

Twiligt must have sacrificed her own life to create the crystalls to save the world and the magic for everyone. In order to restabilize harmoni to the world.

I'll bet she must have fought some kind of evil power that stole their original powers away or destroyed them for good.

As the leader of everyone she made the only rightful choice. To create, the crystalls by sacrificing herself completely. The new crystals cealed away or destroyed the evilness.
Maybe together with her five friends: Fluttershy, Rarity, Rainbowdash, Pinkypie and Aplejack?  Since their combined power of friendship is the strongest magic their is.
And the reign and era of Alicorn magic ended.

Though the new magic power crytalls wasn't enough to maintain, peace for long since everybody wanted the crystall power for themselvs and the three pony types went their own seperated ways, each with their own crystall part.


I think maybe she actually died, giving up herself for the fate of equestria. She must of cast a spell which would of been a lot of magic making her cutie mark appear. It sounds like Twilight to give herself up for everypony else. Maybe she saw into the future and saw what would happen but also saw Sunny. She would know what must have to be done…


What is cozy glow, terek, and crysaliss rid the world, of magic? They could have escaped and they were the final threat that twilight and her friends have to face before twilight sacrificing herself. Since they were getting old so many factors could have come into play with this but soon the mane 6 may have failed and the magic was gone. As twilight used the last ounce of energy she had to get rid of the 3 for good, she must have then sacrificed hre own magic after not finding on how to get the magic back.


But what if twilight sparkle had to give sunny her magic ? That's why the crystal where surrounded her!!!


I have a different theory

What if, when the disaster that caused magic to slowly disappear began, Twilight didn’t just create the 3 crystals. She is the 3 crystals.

Here’s how I imagine the scenario occurred.

One day, in Equestria, Princess Twilight started hearing reports of magic beginning to disappear once again, though not in the same way it did when Cozy attempted to send the magic to another realm. This time it was more natural.

Because nocreature was causing the disappearance of magic this time, they had no idea how to undo it. Days went by, and the situation became more dire.

When only small fragments of magic were left, Twilight had an idea, but it would cost her everything. Using the remaining magic she still possessed, she turned herself into 3 magical artifacts, preserving the last of all magic and locking her soul within the artifacts for all time.


Twilight could become a villian like Nightmare Moon or Sauron


The music literally made me SCREAM! This is a good vid, but couldn't you have at least made it LESS scary? :{


maybe somebody took twilight I think that when celestia and luna they were taken by the wines I think that happens to every ruler  in  equestria


she took all of equestria the magic stands in a comic


I still think the ponies purposefully sacrificed magic in order to destroy the Windegos. Even if they are of "Ancient Magic" Banishing magic is banishing magic. As you stated, innate magic is the first to go and when you are physically made of magic as the Windegos are, they would be the first to go. Whatever event, spell or ritual was performed to destroy magic stopped before it was able to drain all magical artifacts. So I agree with you that there was a crisis and it was likely Twilight who made the stones to protect the magic, but that perhaps that was done to rid the world of magic due to the Windegos. If magic came back too early and the tribes still hated each other, the Windegos would just come back. Thus you needed some sort of unity to be sparked in order to trigger the gems... so they wouldn't just right back to a Windego fueled winter apocalypse that magic was banished in the first place to escape.

That's my theory anyway.


Wait so if twilight is gone doesn’t that mean that flurry heart would have to take over since she was born an alacorn and there for can’t take away what wasn’t given to her… so where is she?


Wait,your a 'changeling' so can't you just go ask them what's going on?


What about the two wars it talks about in the beginning of the movie?


My mind is too dark, when I heard "untransformed" I thought Twilight literally ripped herself apart and stored the pieces in the crystals


I saw a horn of a pony inside twilight's cutie mark that may mean that swatooth was right if you look very closely you will see a horn.


what i don't understand, is why did she have to do it anyway? We saw the last episode and how all creatures united. Equestria was fine before.


WOW  I didn't  know what happened to Twilight sparkle in the future


I think is awesome that if your look behind each crystal on the mural, there are points of twilights cutie mark, only proving and pointing to those theory more!


I love my little pony and it's a part of my childhood and it so sad hearing she die

@Blade and Dylan FTW Black Lilac FTL lol bro that hurt dude


I watched theory about the alicorns and what happend when celestia and luna leaved equestria to let twilight do the job but maybe twillight wit her powers creates the crystals becouse she didnt have any students that was good for becoming an alicorn or maybe even the mane six had to savrifice becouse of big dangwr for the school maybe then damger was gone but also the the ruler , flurry heart took control of equestria and there were no alicorns left to lure the equestria after flurry heart fought to defeat another danger  so the species of ponies fought who should rule the equestria now and  ended up having three diffrent cities of thrre diffrent species of ponies qhat j saud mugjt be a little complicated but ya know ._.


Twilight making the artifacts makes sense considering that when all three were together, Sunny became an alicorn


Wait what about cadence and her daughter would their powers be separated to?


But if u think about it twilight could have used the crystal heart and the elements and a seed of the crystal tree and mor things to make them and what if twilight didn’t make it but she just sacrificed her element “of harmony” and another alicorn princess did because we know that a princess can’t rule on her own she needs some one like Celestia and luna and cadence and her daughter. So i think that the alicorn magic and the magic things did the crystal (a question about something else .what happened to the changlengs and dragons and th rest¿


i pieced the way twilight separated the magic, is based on the solving alicorns video... But idk if it's true or not


my theroy as to why magic is so rare:   Fluttershy died, Discord left and took it all with him.  Because the magic was gone from his life.  remember....before he had only ever been IMPRISONED, never killed or LEFT. and then he lost his First friend EVER.   There are consequenses to unseating the mental state of the embodiment of Chaos.


This is a good theory but what about cadance,flurryheart,shinibg armor,crystal ponies and the crystal empire?


what if sunny was a great grandchild of twilight


Ok, people who watched mlp know the stone sleep spell. What if summing her last bit of magic, twilight put her and her friends in stone sleep. That way, in the future they would be able to guide equestria toward peace, but no one remembers where the ponies where placed.. this theory would explain why we don't see cadence or flurryheart. Twilight cast a spell on the most important creatures in equstria to wait till they were needed. But as I've mentioned, the places where long forgotten, a myth in the books of time. The other creatures in disarray without their leaders, went into hiding. Not coming out at all. The ponies however, divide equestria. I think, Sunnis dad, I a member of the twilight family, like later in the future. This is my thoughts on this. Let me know what u think.

I hope this is true<br>Would be an awesome comeback

I hope this is true
Would be an awesome comeback

"I think we're forgetting something"
"If you forgot then it wasn't important"
"Yeah, you're probably right"

Well, in the episode that first introduces discord, he was awakened from a stone sleep. And in season 8, there is an episode that says it again.

stone sleep spell? in what episode does it mention that ?


I just now watched this and i cant put it together that twilight is dead....:(


what about cadance and flurry heart though. She must of warned then before she did it right?


but why?why wouldent she just choose to keep living?


What if they used the artifacts to bring back twighlight


Would be amazing if Twilight and her friends had to seal away magic. But fans tend to come up with the more epic ideas than the actual writers...


Wow that got depressing fast… I loved it but still… wow…


Well, it is time we talk about how she made the crystals.....insert ad here


I’d be extremely extremely surprised if what you said isn’t at least 98% what happened


When you come back and there is now a 3rd dimension


if im correct im pretty sure ridle wood is based off the crystal empire, zepher/zever hights is canterlot, oh and canterlogic or maretime bay equals twilights village, my memory is crappy so please, remind me if im wrong.


wait i always thought that all the ponies who lived together are hidden i mean all the earth ponies and all live a part they don't know canterlot so did it also disappear like Crystal Empire disappeared once might happen to others with all the land other ponies might have got out of it but forgot they all lived together ? i thought that to twilight and her friends are in the disappeared  lands ? hidden to keep it safe or something els for other to use magic who got out she made that giving to to the father of sunny's fathers family passing it down thats why it was in her house ??


Then wait what happened to the Crystal Empire with Princess Cadence and Flurry Heart or 2 Sisters, what happened to them because of this Crisis


Wait but what about the other Alcorns  and what happened to the crystal empire   And flurry heart they could of had challenges in equestria were it was hard to face without Twilight Magic

Also what about the other species like dragons, Eagles, changelings and the others


That intro of you calling chickens was everything!


Lauren Faust apparently said Twilight doesn’t have the same lifespan as Celestial and Luna, so Equestria only had her ruling for a single generation. Put simply: Twilight’s Dead, and given how badly she screwed up being in charge (seriously the Tribes regressed to their pre-Celestia racist days) I just can’t believe she was smart enough to separate her magic when she screwed up so many times before 😒😒😒


Wait, If your theory is correct Sawtooth, Twilights wings become the pegasus crystal, Twilights horn become the unicorn crystal, And she became the earth pony crystal, If im correct if the 3 crystal's breaks maybe twilight can come back, That's just my theory


The symbol of her cutie mark was just a reference (I think)


They killed a mlp tradition within the 4 generations of my little pony for fun. We no longer have pinkie pie from generation 1, or twilight from generation 2, applejack from generation 1, the fact rarity used to only be rainbow dash until they wanted to change rainbow from loving beauty of rainbows to loving sports and they put her old personality into rarity. They killed it all for Netflix and made glitter induced characters and killed a story the original writers and Lauren Faust worked really hard to create. And a lot of people don’t even have Netflix. They don’t even play it on the hub anymore. It’s just disrespectful all over

1. Hasbro made it clear that they weren't going to use the Mane 6 anymore for future generations.
2. The Hub hasn't been "The Hub" for years now.
3. Yes, they still play it on there.


I realized something. Argyle might be the descendant of Twilight Sparkle. This is just speculation, and I know ponies can share similar colors, but look at Argyle. Light purple skin, purple hair, purple eyes, and streaks of a light purple/pink in his hair. I just realized that, and it lines up a bit to perfectly to be a coincidence. Not to mention the idea of him passing down the legacy and him knowing about the crystals, magic, everything. I am now beginning to think Twilight Sparkle is Sunny's ancestor. And it would be fitting that the descendant of Twilight would bring alicorn's back once more. That's what we see in the movie, Sunny becomes an alicorn. Even the name "Sunny Starscout" kind of rings a tone beside the name "Twilight Sparkle."

I think Argyle and Sunny might be the descendants of Twilight Sparkle.


I’m not trying to sparkle and I love twilight sparkle and I love how you make your video so


I think one alicorn is still alive frozen in time and space.


I didn’t watch the show, but i presume Twilight was trying to test them……buuuuuuut I don’t know

I want to see twi gen again though


I have a theory. Twi is alive in the magic. So twilight didnt give the magic away she BECAME the magic


this makes complete sense and its pobsbly why the new mlp movie happened the way it did and this is the best thoery about it all


oh my gosh, this makes sooooooooooooo much sence!!


Hey man I have a theory in the movie of the next generation. I was wondering if you could do a video of it? If you do here's my theory I know who are the descendants of the main six.

And i wonder if Hitch could be Applejack's and Fluttershy's descendant.

Sunny is Twilight's descendant.
Hitch is Fluttershy's descendant
Zip is Rainbow Dash's descendant
Pip is Rarity's descendant
And Izzy is Pinkie pie's descendant.


another way could that one of twlight studen or descendants who has same looking cutiemark as twlight made the gem thinking it would help the ponys

not knowing what twlight knows


Amazing Sawtooth! I love the vid! I have a question. What exactly happened that made all the magic disappear which inevitably led Twilight to this decision?

@Charles Walker Oooooh I rlly like that! That would be really interesting!

Maybe The Real GROGAR Returned To Equestria And Freed Lord Tirek, Queen Chrysalis, And Cozy Glow........And Together They Fought The Mane Six, Spike, And Starlight Glimmer.........In One Last Battle.


actually the title is supposed to be called ''what happened to Twilight?''


Take a look at twilight mural again. You will see a gate/door and this could be an another clue where she is right now


But in one of the new episodes she has her wings and horn so she a alicron still


“I’ve come to the shocking discovery!”

Twilight is the Avatar

why does is this make so much more sense

but when equestria needed her most she vanished


Soo twilight transformed into a alucorn what if she changed into the artifacts them selfs ? ( excuse my typing and spelling )


I don’t agree if princess sparkles did split the elimants from her she wood come back when the cristals are together


Shouldn't she have made someone a princess before she went away?


So what happend to all the creatures like dragons, changelings, yaks, griffons, hippogriffs and Discord tho? What could have happend to them? Great vid btw!

During Twilight’s rain she made Equestria a place for all creatures from all kingdoms to live together in harmony but after Equestria became divided all “non-ponies” returned to their home lands


the main characters died everyone died. and the only ones left are alicorns is what i assume


Or that she made them, that way some ponies from the three tribes would find the together to form a bond. I think this because twilight is the alicorn of FRIENDSHIP, So yah lol


I think Twilight is the crystals like her spirit is like inside of them


I can’t be the only one who tought that it was weird that no one had proplems with widigoth- I LENA LIKE THEY WERE HATING EACH OTHER AGAIN!!


I really liked this theory. It's sad and feels like it lines up with the show immensely. This just gives me another reason as to why Twilight is my favorite pony🥰🥰💜💜


Hey, Why not make an episode describing an Alicorn Army or if there could be one because I saw Luna And Celestia  Actually defeating Sombra BY THEM SELVES


aaaaand now ive been dragged back into the fandom


Does anyone know which episode is at 2:32 ? I can't find it anywhere


Well what about cadence and flurry heart did they just vanish for some reason like why didn't flurry or cadence replace twilight and keep Equestria together


As we know, Twilight can live hundreds of years because she's a princess, but her friends can't...

Maybe after twilight was in a difficult situation with an enemy or something even worse, and that along with her having lost her friends made her take this decision to sacrifice her "body" to keep everything in order.

This is actually a pretty sad event to be on the show, but if my little pony actually happened (on a real timeline), that theory can't be dismissed

I hope that one day the producer will reveal more information to us.


Thatll explain why she wasn't seen as an alicorn as a toy in the new movie


So twilight sacrificed herself<br>THATS DARK-

So twilight sacrificed herself
THATS DARK-


Ded, ded as a doornail, which I hope is the case cause gen 5 looks like it’s got the lea way to cut loose and actually capitalize on good ideas for stories.


What happened to her other 5? Or candace,celestia and luna


“Your mother was seduced by the dark side of the force. She ceased to be Twilight Sparkle and became Götterdämmerung. So what I told you was true, from a certain point of view.”


What I believe: Discord actually betrayed them and Wanted delights magic but she refused but discord took all magic except here and set it free of he got some of her magic so she made the crystals but it wasn't discord it was yes twin brother Miscord, Miscord Only cares about magic and wants it all to himself but when that's reaveled the Crystal separated and gone to all 3 Kinds but Miscord tried to drine the magic and twilight and Discord stopped him so this whouldn't happen again to her people she ran away still alive to save her people and put the in danger once again.


Can you please make a video of what happened to the young 6 or what happened to the old 6?

𝕊𝕒𝕞𝕡𝕪'𝕤 𝕎𝕠𝕣𝕝𝕕


I don't like the whole new mlp at all 9 seasons of understanding friendship and uniting everyone just is gone now it's only ponies again now that the 3 kinds are together again it's so sad that all kinds of being didn't stay united along with the ponies :( also that twilight and her friends are a myth breaks my heart 🥺💗


Interesting theory what happened to celestial and Luna, discord and other figures whithout celestial and Luna the sun  and moon can’t rise or set like when the weeds took the, captive it was half night half day, so what happened to them?? I’m confused about that


twilight is so kind!! she loves her people and she sacrificed everything for everyone!!


Like I said maybe twilight quit or she said “I’m done with my job I’m done with mlp I fulfilled my destiny so I’m done bye-bye Equestria I am a princess no big one”. :c


Hmm. What if her friends died and she didn't want to be an alicorn anymore?


Yes your right we’ll mostly she also made them so if they disagree and argue a lot then the gem try’s to kill them


Wait this might have something to do with the clock tower video when she turned back time she must have hid the crystals only she didn’t make it but the crystals did

Maybe all the princesses disappeared as well since they weren’t princesses yet


i agree with all of this, but, wouldn't her dividing her magic technically kill her there and then? Seeing as she also sacrificed her earth pony magic? She would have nothing left, meaning that she would technically just fade away.

so twilight would just be the bottom of the barrel, with nothing left, frowned upon by those who once worshipped her. its great to know that she wouldn't just die, but she would still be left to a terrible fate...

nope! ponies are physical creatures who can live without magic. see when tirek took their magic. they survived, but in a weaker, sadder state


I think this video ruined my love for MLP, and scared me half to death. ;-; At least is isnt as scary as my friend's sister...


My threoy:princess twilight  got herself and idea she mix element of harmony and crystal heart happen of cozy glow, drain back in past twilight create 3 type crystal is unicorn Pegasus and earthpony and it stick together few years later 3 triple pony goes on to each other twilight sacrifice herself when villain was broken out from prison and king sombra return again mane 5 of twilight's friend disappear twilight sacrifice everything to crystal to let pony have magic until few day crystal was broken into 3 piece earthpony is, sunny father took earthpony crystal used it make gift for his daughter zipp and people mom took Pegasus crystal use it for her crown and izzy dad took unicorn crystal he place it in somewhere and for now twilight will be not founded again (also in mlp make your mark chapter 2 twilight is returning to home earth)


I hate the new MLP I miss the old one😭😭😭😭😭😭


I mean it can make sense since Twilights's friends were very old in the last epsiode of MLB. She probably sacraficed her alicorn magic for her people in the future and so she also join her friends after her death.


I think that  she  was terrified  if ponies  had a fight so she made it.


Isnt the middle pony that little pony that told twilight she wanted to go away?


I don't think thats happend I think That she maybe lost a fight against the supervillan from the new mlp. And in the new trailer "Make your mark" you can see Twilight with her Alicorn magic


What if sunny is twilight? Just half of her spirit. And her goal was to bring back friendship to all races?? Due to the hole alicorn power up thing just like the crystals ‘earth, flight, magic’. Tbh idk what I am thinking


That is a very well thought theory! Personally I would love to see the old Alicorns/Twilight in new series, but I guess they probably wouldn't be around anymore lol<br>Unless some kind of magic trick happened, like turning into stone?

That is a very well thought theory! Personally I would love to see the old Alicorns/Twilight in new series, but I guess they probably wouldn't be around anymore lol
Unless some kind of magic trick happened, like turning into stone?


I'm not sure if twilight made her alicorn gone starlight glimmer might help her or she used her and her freinds transformation  where they made the Pegasus and pony and unicorn magic to come back and used that transformation power to the crystal


I thought I was the one walking around on the screen for a moment. That was jarring.


I thought you were going to say twiligt was dead lol


Not to be a pessimist,but does anyone realize there is a grave stone to the right of twilight's glass?Nice theory btw🔮✨


But what happened to Twilight and the other princess before the new generation


Okay but what about at the end of My little pony a new generation where under the ground Glew up.


Make your mark vid there was one where twilight came back and turns out there was a villain so I guess it was her that was the crisis that villain wanted to take all magic so twilight made the crystals to keep the magic and the villain couldn’t take it but because twilight lost her strength the villain might’ve ended her….that’s why she isn’t here but I don’t think she’s dead if she was how could she communicate with them maybe it was like starswirl she left a message and there had to be something to activate it so she could tell them when twilight was telling them the message she was still an alicorn so I think she just lost her magic but kept her form there till could be hope that she’s alive.


i have to tell some thing luster is the mom of sunny starsccout because of the hooves and the names are cliser to sun and the dada is mire like twilights son thats why

Nope. By the time Sunny is born, several hundred (or thousand) years have passed.


Oh god I just realised something extremely interesting. On the glass pannels, both the unicorn crystal and the unicorn's horn are circled in white, and her horn is yellow, even though a unicorn's horn is white. On the pegasus pannel, both the crystal and the pegasus's wings are cirled in white, and the pegasus's wings are yellow with red accents, they are clashing with the pegasus's body color. And the most interesting thing about the pegasus pannel is that it shows maretime bay! The bottom of the pannel shows the sea, and in the up right corner of the pannel, there is a lighthouse in the background (look at pannel at around 41:00 in the movie). And who live in maretime bay? Earth ponies, not pegasi. The unicorn pannel features a forest in the bottom, it can be Bridlewood, but the unicorn herself in not inside of bridlewood, but outside. It's dufficult to understand where the earth pony is supposed to be because we do not see the bottom of her pannel and the trees overlap her pannel.
When Sunny is an alicorn, she does not have a real horn and real wings, she has them made of a yellow energy.
What if the crystals were supposed to allow any pony to grow wings and a horn when they want to? Maybe Twilight created them because ponies were jealous of each other's magic and they all wanted to be allowed to fly and use magic when they visited another tribe's city, and maybe overtime tribes grew overprotective of their own crystal, not wanting to share anymore, leading the tribes to anger and distrust.
In the earth pony glass pannel, it's the plants that are circled, I guess plants are a earth pony magic.
There is one another thing regarding Earth pony magic. Sunny doesn't just get a horn and wings when she transforms, she gets a rainbow strand of hair, which is the same color as the hoofprints the little pony from the post-credits scene left on the ground. Is that the influence of the earth pony cristal? It is not quite visible on the pannel, the earth pony doesn't have a rainbow stripe in her hair on the pannel. But we don't know yet whaf those hoofprints mean anyway, maybe it will become clear once we get an explanation.


Love your vids!
But I have a question
Is there a season 10 of mlb?


Haven't the creators confirmed that Twilight <b>did not</b> outlive her friends?

Haven't the creators confirmed that Twilight *did not* outlive her friends?

The conformation of Twilight did not outlive her friends was wayy back in 2013 where Twilight was only a alicorn princess. But as we can see in the last episode in 2019, Twilight Sparkle became the ruler of Equestria and still looking young unlike the rest of Mane 6 were aging old like a normal pony.

i dont care what the writers say unless it ends up in an episode or a movie or something

I think they said that during the early stages of alicorn Twilight. It's VERY likely that changed as later in the series it was obvious Twilight hit full alicornhood, meaning she's immortal.

Man I hope cuz that's gonna be really sad


But hey that's just a theory. A Sawtooth theory!


Yeah, but if she gave her earth pony magic then what would she be then, she couldn’t be a pony…. Cause she has literally no pony magic of any kind or tribe anymore. So that means that either your thwart isn’t possible or twilight LITERALLY sacrificed herself. By giving away the magic, it killed her. That’s really dark and sad to think about 😬


if that is the real earth pony window thing than doesn't it look like the girl that I think princess twighlight student


This should’ve been canon. But hey, maybe g5 will do what g4 did and make the comics a different universe.


Me giving a round of applause to twilight’s selfishness


Is any one else a little disappointed about sunnys alicorn transformation comrade to twilights?


It’s like listening to Super Horror Bro except it’s not about horror


Well, we can't say the movie has nothing to do with the original timeline that ended in season nine.

Because the movie features twilight in specific parts.

I believe sunny's dad may have some relationship in particular with the Mane 6s, as he already has a great deal of knowledge of them that no one else in equestria seems to have in the film.

I think the movie should be set a MUCH time after where the series ended.

So one thing I can say is that many things happened without us knowing


OHHH THAT WHYY THAT MAKES SO MUCH MORE SENSEE


Or the crystals got created when she became an alicorn and she just died..?


I think she created the crystals because she felt danger so that was the only solution she felt it but I think she did it because probably magic was in danger again it makes sense now I think she un became an alicorn


:-0 Maybe that's way in her concept art for generation 5 shes a earth pony!


I think twilight mayde herself be artefacts for saving magic and ween the poney puts the artefacts together the poney become twilight but just the power of twilight <br>(I hope you understand 😅)

I think twilight mayde herself be artefacts for saving magic and ween the poney puts the artefacts together the poney become twilight but just the power of twilight
(I hope you understand 😅)


Awww twilight is not an princess anymore 😢😢


I think that the mural might have another meaning besides what could of happened to Twilight and the origin of the crystals. Since the middle part of the mural that represents the earth-ponies is completely gone, that could mean that possibly the reason the three tribes separated is because of something an earth-pony or ponies did as the rest of the mural was rather intact for the most part.

The whole thing just reminds me of the Trolls World Tour movie and "Raya and the Last Dragon". But something else seems odd that stuck out more to me is that while the Unicorn and Pegasus kept their crystals out in the open for all to see, why was the earth-pony crystal kept hidden?


Twilight had to sacrifice yourself in order to create the crystals she is apart of the 3 different types of horses


In the New generation  movie all the princesses were forgotten


Is it just me or does the earth pony in the mural look like the pony from the last episode....


And maybe twilight traveled to there world to make those elements


Omg double m.<br>O my my goodness. I just noticed sunny from the mlp new generation her main looks like Twilight sparkle's main.😱😱😱😱😱🤯🤯😱🤯😱😱

Omg double m.
O my my goodness. I just noticed sunny from the mlp new generation her main looks like Twilight sparkle's main.😱😱😱😱😱🤯🤯😱🤯😱😱


I have proof  you see the unicorns use magic and all have the same cutler ...purple


since Allicorns can live so long where is Celestia and Luna?


I saw a really nice piece of fanart of an alternative ending to A New Generation. The sky was all colorful after the magic was restored. Luna and Discord were standing on top one of the hills in Maritime Bay, with Discord saying: " I wish Twilight was here to see this ".<br>So, the theory of Twilight passing away and not around anymore is definitely a well known one.

I saw a really nice piece of fanart of an alternative ending to A New Generation. The sky was all colorful after the magic was restored. Luna and Discord were standing on top one of the hills in Maritime Bay, with Discord saying: " I wish Twilight was here to see this ".
So, the theory of Twilight passing away and not around anymore is definitely a well known one.


Well there in a different realm where we don’t know


Sooo where is Cadence and Flurryheart?!?


The one spike put in to open the door in one of the videos it looks like the earth pony gem


Hey sawtooth, just wondering, if this theory checks out then how come Cadence didn't lose her horn/wings in season 4 episode 26? Because remember in season 6 episode one celestia said that equestria had never before seen the birth of an alicorn. Which means that cadence was born either as a  pegasus/unicorn/earth pony. Just curious.

@Gaming CH Celestia and Luna don't know either

@Reese but how did flurry become Alicorn (I don’t  know)

it was already confirmed that Cadence was born a pegasus.


I clicked on a link from one of your videos while I was breaking youtube with inspect bc I wanted to mess around, but I clicked a link and I got here and I didn't even know you had made another video. YES!

This was awhile ago and it happened again lol


Twilight Sacrifice her alicorn magic that is so shocking I can’t be how did she created the crystals? How?


Can someone animate this event it would be so epic


Wait I just realize why isn’t the other princesses there?


Your stuff the wrong time may be Twilight give up for magic and also died


I think your right about it btw love vids


This makes so much sense! She is the element of Magic. This is her purpose! :0


i haveny watched mlp in ages and i dont get anything in this vid but its just so interesting🗿


but here is one thing what happened to the crystal empire and flurry


Why I noticed in the mural it’s morbid but it looks like a winged headstone in the bottom right corner of the top mural


Ima just be honest, Twilight is the smartest princess in the 5, and she is the most important because she is the only one who is able and does stop the evil from ruining the world, a think princess cadance is the second because she is actually protecting something and she served a purpose, while the two sisters are more like presidents than anything, they always the choices and do big party's, the only thing I have see them done is defeat discord and raise the sun and moon (correct me if I'm wrong). They sit in their castle all day unless its for a party. Twilight has defeated all evils and she even thought about the future of the ponys


i never thought about that i believe your right hope theirs a g5 series


I think the crystals did not work cause twilight made them together the unity of the three tribes and crystals need to stay togehter to work


OK OK call me stupid but what if sunny's transparent wings and horn are actually Twilights..