Has any of you guys noticed that this place Zephyr Heights might actually have been Canterlot


I really am intrigued with your theory Sawtooth. Both amazed by the creation of the crystals and the events that followed but also saddened by the fate of our beloved Twilight. Not that I'm against your theory for they may have some good and evident points, but I also like to share my opinion that there is more to it than meets the eye. Maybe, just maybe, there's more information about what really had happened on events that transpired besides of what know now.
I believe, that if the movie was a success and with requests and support of fans, they will make a series of the new generations focusing on their quest to continue spreading friendship again while discovery what truly happened to Twilight.
As some full fledged MLP fans/otaku, like myself, though we may accept the fact of what had happened to Twilight, we can't help but not wanting to believe that this is the sad fate of our beloved pony that we grew up with after what she had worked so hard on. I don't want think that is her fate and there's got to be more than that. Which is why I wish that the new Mane 5 will explore the history of Equestria and the deeds Princess Twilight and her friends even more. So that we too can find what truly happened without having this sadness of the thought about the lost of our beloved pony friends aching our hearts.
Even I can't seem to move on with this much sadness and despair in me, fearing of that this what has become of friend.
Thank you for sharing your theory with us. And I hope you understand how I feel about all this. Sometimes moving forward is not that easy with the feeling of sadness of what has become of the friends you grew up with and not knowing about.


sawtooth waves I love your vids but that is silly I doubt that twilight did that


always gives me so many questions ! gosh :D like the video and ur thinking of it


If that's true then where is Luna and Celestia

I love your vids


So what happened to Celestia, Luna and Cadance


Woah, it's so unbelievably fascinating to be here personally witnessing all these theories being created knowing many of those will most likely be debunked as false in the future.<br>Like I didn't expect it to be this fascinating since I got into MLP just in april 2021 when the show had already ended.

Woah, it's so unbelievably fascinating to be here personally witnessing all these theories being created knowing many of those will most likely be debunked as false in the future.
Like I didn't expect it to be this fascinating since I got into MLP just in april 2021 when the show had already ended.


what about flurry heart she should be alive she was only a child when twilight became princess and Ali corns are emortle unless something happened the only thing that keeps them from getting older is being turned to stone...
SOMETHING HAD TO HAPPEN.
that's my theory


Twilight sparkle, Princess of friendship. Twilight Sparkle, the queen of Equestria's twilight.


Mabey she disaperd because she gave her magic and life to make the crystals


This is a good theory, I have something to add to it though... What if Starswirl had a part in it? We knew he had a good relationship with Twilight and he has seen Equestria at its lowest points before. Maybe he and/or Twilight made them as a fail safe incase magic got into the wrong hooves again, since it happened with Cozy Glow once before. Maybe the villains escaped from their stone prison and tried to steal magic and bring their reign on terror on the ponies of Equestria once more, leading them to make the crystals as a failsafe


Lets just say twilight tested the new Gen ponies


OK, YOU HAVE GONE FAR ENOUGH, A THEORIST, ABOUT THE MOST NOSTALGIC AND GREAT SHOW THAT HAS A MUCH MORE COMPLICATED TIMELINE THAN FNAF!?!? YOU ARE WHAT WE NEED!! Shall I call you “sir” or “majesty”?


The creator of my littile pony tiding this account be like what I did not even think such thing but he is speaking logical


If twilight is gone, who raises the sun/moon? In Princess twilight sparkle: Part 1 we see that the sun and moon remain on dormant sides in the sky when Celestia and Luna disappear. If twilight is gone, and can't raise the sun or moon, then how does it rise and fall each day? And how do the clouds work, if Pegasi  aren't there to watch over and monitor them?


The meral has a unicorn with a golden horn and a Pegasus  with golden wings🤚🏽


Maybe she used abit of the tribe magic to create it but she still out there but she is weak


What about the other alicorns? What happened to them


Wait…whys the wing golden on the pegi in the start


hmmm... what if the reason the magic is gone because of the crack in the human world seaping out the magic from the world


She sacrificed her self for everyone else probley because mabey they became tolerant of each other and and there powers so to stop them she sepreted the universe and the power of pegisous, unicorn and earth ponies she had to sacrifice her self and magic to seoerate there magic!


I have a BIG QUESTION, how was the sun and moon raising and setting without magic?maybe with the help of a magic artifact but who would've been doing it?


I mean still she could have just died you know because that jeneration is years after crpwning twigjlight, she could have died  and if twighlight is gone where is princess celectia look you know just ask the develepor


If twilight isn't the Princess anymore, then who rules Equestria. there's only the Queen and princesses of the Zephyr heights but there isn't a Queen or a princess for The whole Equestria. And, I know that Sunny is already an Alicorn but was she even crowned Princess?


How can we find the new mlp when twilight became queen/new celestia


I think what you've mentioned is potentially true, although I am excited to see what the new season will bring in relation to the history and what has led up to the present era.


There's actually a tombstone with wings at the bottom right of the mural painting thing so does that mean twilight died O_O.......??!

Nononononoono  we're the painting thing idk I forgot what it's called like how there divided the part were twilights cutie mark is theres a tombstone with wings it's not BLUE it's grey with greenish wings

nope! it's not a tombstone, it's the infrastructure of zephyr heights, since it's above the pegasus segment and all! you can see designs like that all over ZH


twilight is the crystal i think thats why they r usless when they r apart bcs u need twilight in alacorn form thats why the horn is purple bcs twilight is purple and she was originally a unicorn


My Little pony generation 4 is my favorite


Be honestly if that's the case then the actual truth why did they put it in the movie it would have been a better story to tell in the fact of hearing that she sacrifices herself and live in normal ponies life again it's kind of sad cuz she is no longer alive and probably die happy with her friends if they were still alive at the time... But that doesn't explain the Crystal empire what happened to that unless it went missing or it disappears on maybe it was just that old and no longer existed but that means Luna in Celestia are still alive somewhere he just don't know where because alicorns are immortal right they should live forever so that means that cadence luna Celestia flurry Hart are still alive somewhere.....


Idk why I started to cry hard after listening twilight sacrifice herself for ponies 😭💘


Couldn't Twilight just make one crystal containing all her magic instead of 3? since making 3 would make it easier to lose and also easier for the tribes to separate.

That's why my theory is that Twilight flurry heart and Cadence infused Crystals with each of their magic which is why they're all different colors


At lest she died with her friends and not alone


Does anyone realize that Twilight sparkles cutie mark has five small Stars next to the big star and doesn't it make sense that there was six elements of harmony so doesn't this equal that Twilight is the big star and the rest of the small Stars or their friends it makes more sense like that so wasn't this like meant to be wasn't this supposed to be a destiny to be the element of magic

Her cutie mark has nothing to do with her being the Element of Magic. Her cutie mark is about her love of magic.


i think gen 5 caused the end of g4 and g4.1


Why pegasus And umicorn have yellow wings And Horn? Like Sunny when the Crystals combined? Kinda weird


What I am wondering more than anything is what happened to Discord and the other races. In the end, they had connections to so many other races, least of which were the hypogriffs and sea ponies. What happened to their magic? When magic faded, did all of the hypogriffs loose the ability to fly as well? There were no signs of other artifacts surviving the loss of magic. How many sea ponies were trapped underwater and drowned when the magic ran out and they could no longer hold that form?
Did the changelings starve to death? Did the crystal ponies just turn to statues or did they shatter when the magic ran out?

This also didn't show the earth pony magic being returned. They should have regained their incredible strength and endurance, yet none of them were helping to lift the trolly or pick up larger debris.


What about the rest of the mane 6/7? What happened to them?


Maybe twilight sparkles was sent to the stars.


If you look closer at the mural if you look in the bottom right theres something that looks like a grave. Im not sure so reply for theories


When twilight turns to alicorn you think she unbecame an alicorn cause i reversed it and her horn was hidden in her hair


Can we just appreciate their efforts in the video?..LIKE I COULD NEVER PUT SO MUCH EFFORT IN ANYTHING! 😞😞


the artafc is powered by every pony trib together and your rght about her.


ANDlIVE:IF WITHOUT THE MAGIC    HOW ABOUT THE PRINCES OF HARMONY WITHOUT THAT THE VILLAINS WELL RISE


So Twilight Sparkle and Oliver friends are starting to get old and die and the elements what would happen to them they probably would have died in the world would have ended but if it weren't for Twilight there wouldn't be a new generation so she used all of her power to sacrifice it on the three elements or whatever they are and now they're became a new generation and she couldn't do anything about it the what I'm questioning is where did her friends go though what would have happened to them

Sorry I said that wrong I meant all of her friends


Theses crytles are special and important and interesting


You know, talking all about twilights disappearance… what happened to all the other animals?? Like the dragons, and discord and so many others did they all separate too? Or did they go extinct?? I guess we’ll never know.


I think sunny mom is someone that we didn't or see her...maybe she is knows what happened 🤔


What about the fate of the past Alicorns and Discord?


Plot twist: She duplicated herself and only did what u said to her duplicate and shr just wandering somewhere just not recorded


I got a theory what if twilight sparkle apprentice is the mother of the new alcorn or twilight sparker's apprentice of there apprentice they are the mother of the new alcorn


What is the mane 5 (not including twilight) had Twilight's life span because they were the reason she became alicorn in the Frist place. Then the mane 6, Cadence,Luna,Celestia and Flurry   drained all of the magic in them to create the three crystal. Then magic of 5 alicorns and magic of  friendship made it so that the Crystals contained so much magic that it would last for eternity. They also made it so that the sun and moon would rise and set on its own acord. After the drained their magic by The Crystals since they had already outlived normal pony lifespans they all just died.... Twilight thought they had enough time After draining their magic to explain what they all did.. But after their magic was drained... so was their lives.......... so it remained a mystery what happened to The Mane 6,The Two Sisters and the Mother and Daughter(Flurry and Cadence )

Twilight must have thought alot before doing this. But the crisis was so dire that she had to leave equastiria rulerless. She made sure it was protected in their absence but she had thought there could be a separation of the tribes and they loose they're magic. After creating the Crystal signal explain people that they needed to stay together and about the Crystals but she couldn't do that as it costed her  and all those involved's lives .........
She created some form of protection from the windagows.

I personally belive this theory . What do you think of it Sawtooth ?
And sorry for any grammatical/spelling mistakes I didn't re-read the comment.


You are right i have see the movie and it make sense now!!!!!!


I need a name for the new my little pony w. W. W. W.. W. W. W. W. E. E. E. E.. W. W


I hate this I wish twilight sparkle didn’t go away there story was nice


I hope Twilight doesn't forget to charge her tail


THANK YOU, this is what I was thinking about!


What about the others? like Starlight  Spike,Fluttershy and AppleJack.


WAIT IS LUSTER DAWN SUNNYS MOM????????!?!!?!?!!


Is nobody questioning what happened to the changelings what happened to the dragons what happened to the mer ponies and not only that but what happened to flurry heart what happened to flurry heart's mom and what happened to Equestria all together

I just realized so each of the alicorns are a different type of like magic in some way right Celestia and Luna were moon and Sun Twilight was the embodiment of friendship flurry heart would be the embodiment of magic and flurry Heart's Mother would be the embodiment of leadership right what if when flurry heart died flurry heart made magic disappear almost all together except for Magical devices


I’m sure she just magic to make the crystals I mean twilight sparkle sparkle


So perfect version, magic is friend'ship.<br>I russian, sorry my English language

So perfect version, magic is friend'ship.
I russian, sorry my English language

Веселый_ Руся


This is a really amazing theory! I hope we will see it become canon.


Eyeball is yet probably cease from the Crystal because he's a furry


I think discord had a part this the magic being gone


I think after loosing all of her friends Spike being the last one when the crisis came she didn't hesitate and made the 3 crystal knowing all too well she outlived a normal pony's life and disapeared... dying as the miracle happened.


Cool, cool. Any1 knows why there is no applejack equivalent in new gen?


Oh my gosh this makes so much sense especially now that make your mark is our

𝔍𝖆𝖓𝖊'𝖘 𝕯𝖗𝖊𝖆𝖒𝖘


This new movie makes no sense because they had started inviting griffins and all different types of creatures and they are no where. To be seen


That’s wrong Twilight Sparkle just have to get out a little bit of them and he still owe me an Alcorn but not so powerful than the other trimes  give some more

محمد الفغم١١٥٦٧٧٧١٠


Luna and celestia can't die . so where are they??


It’s impossible try like it you could power a go away like maybe she can make a crystal with Alex or magic six she split her Alcorn magic do you want to run that means she still has Alacon magic but the face she hear she’s having you say that you see her new students actually maybe she’s the new Alcorn that’s ruling but the other villains maybe took her down in her put her in a cave and then maybe twilight movie to come out discovering twilight


Ok the theory is really understandable and logical, but hear me out:
Celestia -> Daybreaker
Luna -> Nightmare Moon
Twilight Sparkle -> Midnight Sparkle
Since the royal Princesses turned into their evil selves, what is stopping Twilight from doing the same and destroy the Equestria she ruled?

Sunset shimmer : Solar Shimmer Starlight glimmer:  Midnight Glimmer


Please do why twilight couldn't do a age spell on her friends

Because no such spell exists. Trixie only could do it because of the Alicorn Amulet.


Watch my little pony make your mark and you’ll see


My sister said friendship is magic is fiction in mlp a new generation

Nope. G5 is set in the same world as Friendship is Magic.


Love ur work! Ur amazing and i have been eatching u for 6 years now! Ur amazing... Keep up the good work


You guys now sunnys dad i think he is twilights child they look the same and he knows the true story


ok but why does sunny her father look like twilight


It looks like sunny with the earth pony crystal


I used to wach twilight sparkle when i was 6:( today im 11! and finding this out...idk i feel like a freind passed away


Twilight gave up her mortality but what about Celestia and Luna did they give up their mortality too so where are they today


But…. What happened to celesta, did she help twilight with this? Did she live on? did she go back to ruling then stoped again?


How did ponies lose there magic then? What happened


I'm more curious how this sort of thing would happen in relation to her FIRST student, after all, they have magic In that world as well. (and don't tell me they're unrelated, we've had Three different places Refferensing characters from that world already, In particular the one from the Series Finale.) And even though the magic in their world connecting them was not Born there through "natural" means it is connected to it nonetheless. (the Hu-mane 7 wouldn't have been able to use their Gem-powers otherwise)


Twilight took her heart out so she is dead


What does Baka made the crystals to save the future


Hey this is all great but theres a problem and that problem is lusterdawn what happened to her? She probably became princess of canterlot. If this is the case then twilights fate must have been before wich doesn't really work out so this theory would be great if it was lusterdawns cutie mark.


More evidence for her breaking apart her Alicorn magic if you can see in the glass there is a purple triangle in the back of each crystal and if you put them together they make her cutie mark  1:20


isent she powerful enough to get magic back


That theory is actually very sad, but it makes a lot of sense


I think you might be right but how and why did the crisis happen and who or what made the crisis


in part 2 of it where is twilight did she die?


What about celestia and Luna they are alicorns?


I like to imagine that after giving her magic to the crystals, Twilight turned into a regular horse


Did you know when twilight was a demon and sunset saved her sunset was an alicorn b

She wasn't an alicorn. She was a phoenix.


Reading the comments makes me so sad T-T


Hey !? We're the cutie mark of the new generation?


Personally my theory is that Twilight you over self in the crystals and when the crystals come back she'll come back you can tell they're not in Equestria


Hmmm maybe in the next movie the mane 5 would find twilight and her friends from god knows who


I think the crisis involved the season 9 villains but there is one question what about the windagoes why weren’t they appearing with so much disharmony.

@Reese saw there was a video to a possible reason behind it. Also magic wasn’t completely gone since it was in the artifacts

They're beings of magic. No magic = no Windagoes.


i saw in another vid twilight sparkle was in THIS movie


Hi Sawtooth. I would like you to please try this topic and make a theory: Watch "Saddle Row Review" Season 6 again. Plad Stripes (I do not know the spelling) and AJ (Applejack) Have the same color skin tone.


looking at all the crystals earth pony crystal is a hoof pegusus crystals are wings unicorn crystals is a uincorn horn so.....there has to be a misunder standing


Oh, btw alicorns are not immortal. It doesn't mean your theory is wrong, it's amazing. Also, Magic is needed in this world. If you have no magic, Magic might get shoved back into you or you get kicked out of the universe entirly. (Show World tieing in, That's why I was in LightningBolt's body while in the MLP Universe, and now that I have MLP magic of my own I should go back and see what happens.)


alltho the elements were destroyed what happened to the tree house in other words the tree of harmony replacment did it just get abandoned?


Twilight sacrifices her self so she didn’t have to leave her friends in death. That might be it.

I mean thats not impossible, but at that time she was already the ruler of Equestria for decades and knows how big her responsibility is to her subjects, so i dont think she only did it for her friends if it meant leaving her subjects, and I also think the other mane6 will never agree/let her to do that since they also know the responsibility for equestria cause theyre all in the friendship council thingy. So i think something else might have happened


What about the villans who turned into stone are they still  here


Doesn't mean sunny dis a kingdom hearts and has twilight's heart inside her


4:48 also notice how around the crystals seems to be pieces of her cutie mark little bit more evidence that she herself is the crystals in some way or is a part of them

oh...this is a bit dark and anyways Hasbro did went to reach an older audience.


If alicorns do not die then where are the princesses


Another thing is: where are the windghosts on this movie??? They fly away and take some holidays or something? Because if ponies arguing the windghosts appears?


Soo... Does twilight now is, you know... Oof


I love this theory but one small problem: How would Twilight know that alicorns are not just princesses but they have a combination of magic from all three tribes? Celestia and Luna didn’t know this and this is all before you consider how she would separate the three tribes’ magic.

@AlphaXbox The first episode of the show shows all too well that books don’t contain everything about the MLP world.

@average Fair, however I would assume becoming the new ruler also permitted her the entire research ect from canterlot.

@AlphaXbox Well we don’t know if Celestia and Luna told Twilight about this and even if they did, Twilight would still have to find out how to separate the Alicorn magic

But Celestia and Luna did know (presuming Luna) Celestia even mentioned in the first season that Alicorns contain magic of all three tribes. So it makes sense Twilight would know as well


I thought that twilight sparkle was here all this  time maybe twilight sparkle was sunny


What happened to the magic anyways<br>fifth

What happened to the magic anyways
fifth

my next analysis video will be about that....


The fact that sunny became an alicorn because of the 3 crystals just <br>makes this theory more exciting.

The fact that sunny became an alicorn because of the 3 crystals just
makes this theory more exciting.


There is one myth that rainbow dash could be the leader.


Everyone’s thinking about what happened to the ponies but what happened in the human realm

I know that has been going through my mind they must be so far ahead technology wise since they already had phones


Well at least Sawtooth didn't say that Twilight became the crystals, but maybe that would make for a very interesting plot point if they continue the story?


It makes perfect sense. I mean, like she was, don't crying for me, not at all, so fucking dumb like.like I make perfect sense, because after all, she is the princess of friendship


Question if alicorns we're imortal then shouldn't Queen galaxia be alive or be ruling Equestria just asking

Galaxia is not canon to the franchise; she's a fan-made character.


Even more shocking than *Swirl is discolored ha


This makes a lot of sense, what if Princes Celestial and Luna did the same by creating artefact to keep the sun and moon changing similar to the thing they gave twilight when they wanted to retire.

However, I’m still wondering what happened to Flurry heart and the children/ ponies from the main six’s generation. What happened to the crystal heart? Where are the other creatures?

well at least in the s9 finale we saw in the back the cmc and diamond tiara as grown mares so id say flurry is probably in her 20s there and took over the crystal empire for a while but idk


What happened to the princess of merchandise then isn’t she Alcorn


Look at each shape.
One looks like a peice of the crystal heart

Second looks like the storm kings staff

Finally= we all dont know....

Queen of the changelings = flight representing their shiny wings being the most important to represent the beginning of their transformation

T-reck represents earth pony because he is the closest to it, he as earth ponies takes from the land

Cozy glow represents magic for thats all she ever wanted was power.  Friendship is magic, and magic is power
'Friendship is power"

These 3 main villains represent the pony tribes in a odd way, yet each symbol represents the 3 tribes. When turned to stone one is preserved not dead.


But what happened to luna and celestia?,.. They're still an alicorn..., so r they still alive?...


Twilight and have her on vacation and it’s all a lie do you have the rest of her life as an alibi!


wait a minute... she could have died in that moment! thats why she is not on the mural as an earth pony because this most likely happened after the others were gone, she dies instantly from old age. NOW THATS SUPER SAD!<br>another detail I just noticed that pretty much solidified this theory is that all unicorn magic was purple... the color of Twilights magic.

wait a minute... she could have died in that moment! thats why she is not on the mural as an earth pony because this most likely happened after the others were gone, she dies instantly from old age. NOW THATS SUPER SAD!
another detail I just noticed that pretty much solidified this theory is that all unicorn magic was purple... the color of Twilights magic.

@coldhaixx could be considering how old she most likely was

Maybe when she was separating her magic<br>It took out her form as a pony being aswell and turned into ashes

Maybe when she was separating her magic
It took out her form as a pony being aswell and turned into ashes


Why isn't cadence or flurry heart ruling


Uncle Charlie sparkle became the crystals


You know Twilight died right Like what the heck she died


it looks like typical zephyr heights architecture, wouldn't call it a grave necessarily


EARLY!! Can’t wait for this amazing video <3 well done! Also you should maybe make a video about the sisters? How they went into history? Idk just a theory :> ANYWAY IMMA WATCH THE VIDEO!!


If the ponies are separated why didn’t the windogos


The think is the crystal is for the pony to be together and to live each other but thats not not the think they have hope becese when sunny and her father believe that they can still be friends bease thirs hope in sunnys heart and in her fathers heart to


And so she put her magic in the crystals to keep a piece of her and her friend legacy and the Crystal only worked when they were together proving that all the gem had to be united.


this theory makes the most sense out of the theories I've seen others make.


I believe G5 and G4 are separate worlds because why would MLP G5 would be 3D and MLP G4 would be 2D that wouldn’t make sense! And so quickly it would be 3D (like come on use ur brain!)


if all tribes turn apart why didn't the Wendigos come back?


Well.....she is in canterlote and sunny  is in meritime bay soooo....thats why twilight is not in the movie and the crystal might of come from twilights coronations


"Somewhere in a hidden dragon village"

Spike: Hey, waddup?


Look at the beginning of the movie maybe it has something to do with it

And what about the human world if magic disappeared won’t the human world magic disappeared


in the panel with Twilight's cutie mark, there is a gravestone with wings in the lower right hand corner. So does this mean that Twilight passed away???


Soo what if she sacrifacied her alicorn magic then celestia luna twighlight and cadence (u talked about a nother dimonsen where alicorns live at a nother vid)what if they go to the alicorn dimonsen (just a teohrie


My little pony:a new generation official channel


And as always you actually might have a point!


where is flurry heart? and princess cadence??


XiaoIsSleepyまた、日本語を教えてくださいと言いたいです。


then what happend to Celestia Luna Cadence and Flurry heart they are Alicorns so they must be Imortal


Wow I can't want to tell my mom and sister😉! It's just cookbook cool am I right?


So. Twilight used her magic/for summy can bi a alacorn?


I am right by there something I need to say about what happened


What if the reason argyle knows so much about the past especially about twilight's past, is because he's actually related to her?

@Gracekim24 he does, and maybe he has it because he's related to her!

It’s very possible because Sunny is daughter of him and she became an Alicorn too


Look now she is shown an alicorn in the hologram at the brite house


This makes sense but I feel like it doesn’t at the time but can’t put my finger on why🤔🤔🤔🤔


In the whole movie, they were focusing completely on the crystals than friendship, isn't that what they actually did?  2:04


No. G5 takes place FAR far into the future, after Twilight and the others have passed on.


Sawtooth Waves 🦄🤔
have you seen my little pony comic book the one
with discord shows about Twilight and the crystal


Nut one thing what happend whit twilight sparkle in the human world? <br>And what happend with celestia and Luna?

Nut one thing what happend whit twilight sparkle in the human world?
And what happend with celestia and Luna?


"People of Equestria!" Didn't you mean: "Ponies of Equestria!" 🤣

@Rio Gaming ROBLOX yep!! personhood as a concept is not inherently human

@Sawtooth Waves  Dragons, griffins, hippogriffs, yaks, changelings, sirens, zebras, kieran, buffalo, reindeer and diamond dogs are people too aren't they?

@Argamis (SilverComet) Everycreature is people then!! Ponies, dragons, griffins, hippogriffs, yaks, changelings, sirens, zebras, kieran, buffalo, reindeer and diamond dogs.

Rule # 2:  Ponies are People  (Zebras too)


Hey can you please make a video about Rainbow Dash becoming an alacorn


Wait but if the tribes hated eachother what about the windigos??


Umm weird thought that I need to stay maybe all the ponies in the stained-glass windows are Earth ponies hear me out the end of a new generation Sonny has a pair of golden clear wings and a horn if you look at the stained glass window both the unicorn and the Pegasus golden horns and wings that do not match their body color at all now they could be just glowing because you know the connection of earth pony unicorn and pegasi I don't think that's it because I think it was given to 3 Earth ponies if you notice in the movie every time the Earth ponies talk about the unicorns or Pegasus they talked about them together like they worked together to fight against the Earth ponies what if that's true the unicorn in the pegasi made a truce to fight against the Earth ponies because they had the crystals

Honestly this is not very thought out it just kind of popped up in my head


I guess that explains why twilight "won't outlive her friends"...

wow i'm early–

@yondaime500 very interesting. She clearly knows more than we do!

@Dagger the Dragon Meghan McCarthy tweeted it back in 2013. Look up the exact quote “Twilight will not outlive her friends” and you should find many sources pointing to it. I tried to post the link but it looks like my comment got deleted.


Hey I am sorry but why didn’t twilight sparkle used friendship magic


AND IAM SORRY THE  HORBALE TURTH OF TWILIGHT


Youre rocking that scarf<br>Also great theories

Youre rocking that scarf
Also great theories


Bro.. This is just so sad ok hate me if im wrong but I'm kinda annoyed they made that movie cuz I wish they didnt like skip a billion generations like that like the fact in the new movie ponies starting to get used to electronics because half of there magic was transferred to equestria I wish there magic wasnt weakened bro .. It just makes it to well idk nostalgic 😭


I really wish the last few seasons of my little pony went differently and didn't connect to the movie the way it did, and I wish there was a separate series that explained more about what happens to Equestria after the mane six are gone.
Obviously since Twilight isn't very old throughout the series, and since she's a princess, I would assume she'd live a long time like Celestia and Luna or even possibly be immortal-
She's literally the princess of magic-
I just wish there was more of a clear cannon explanation


Impressive insight and theory into what happened - it makes sense. :-)


Sawetooth, you never cease to amaze me! I think this theory makes the most sense, as it fits with canon lore and Twi's personality.


Love this! I never thought about it like that. Blew me away! (Also your voice is adorable and has great storytelling vibes! x3). But good work on this amazing video!


I really love how you  tell your theories


I like your theory, but I also think... she very well could be contained within those crystals. Idk why it's just a hunch on my end.


I still have so many questions,  like what happened to the crystal empire,  wouldn't the crystal heart be filled by the love of the ponies , is it possible that the empire might remain,  the three artifacts combined brought back magic,  would that also mean that the crystal heart might still be active but not only that what about its heir,   what about flurry heart , she is also an alicorn would it still be possible she lived or would she have done the same for her subjects,  sacrifice herself  to keep the  crystal heart going, fuling it with her own immortality  and love is it possible that the same spell that took the empire away for a thousand years was not only learned but aslo used to save the empire and its people,

( just letting my brain come up with this )


if this isnt what canonically happened, I'm rage quitting mlp <br>this video is so good it gave me goosbumps

if this isnt what canonically happened, I'm rage quitting mlp
this video is so good it gave me goosbumps


This all feels like a very MLP thing for Hasbro to do, i can see this being what actually happened, lol


I support this theory a lot, really i do! There’s only 1 problem with it... in the season 4 finale (where we first meet tirek) the 3 princesses gave all of their magic to twilight, now lets compare it to sawtooth’s theory here. Imagine twilight as the 3 crystals seen in the G5 movie, the princesses gave up all their magic and gave it to twilight, although neither of them unbecame an alicorn, they just lost their cutie marks. Even so, they could have also lost their immortality for a while which, might also explain sawtooth’s theory you could still be right, this theory was a blast! Hope to see more like this soon


My jaw dropped of what you said about Twilight, and my jaw just kept being open for the rest of the video. I was so stunned.


2:36 im thinking that thered be a chance that the tree of harmony died or at least something happened to it- since it naturally had an affect on creatures promoting them to friendship and to do the right thing she might have made them as a fail safe or something like a punishment- if they forgot what was important and tried to focus on their differences theyd lose the one things that made them unique
kind of like how the crystal ponies had a crystal heart something they all could unify together despite the odds, something thatd only work if everything was together; the citizens, the heart, and the new born
4:59 while this is sound reasoning its possible that a similar situation as what happened with the pony of shadows occurred, in order to make them she had to trap herself somewhere and is potentially still trapped somewhere, unicorns dont seem to know much about actual spells so if this is the case she could be trapped for thousands of years without even a thought
5:48 but doesnt that conflict with facts already made clear in the story? if magic comes from friendship then wouldnt the quest to unite the groups like what happened trigger the magic within them all rather than a source from an element. since twilight herself more so displays friendship than magic, what would be the point of making a magical source if the magic of friendship could be lost anyway, as opposed to just a physical object becoming the source for the different ponies to unite under.


Sawtooth: My 6 year old wants to know if you can explain how & why the Mane 6 are related to the Elements of Harmony and if Twilight teaming up was a coincidence or planned by Celestia, or just fate?


if she had created the crystals for each tribe of pony type, then you’d think the different types of ponies should taken dire care of them down the generations? because the unicorns crystal was sitting in a pub to be gambled for, the pegasus crystal was just being used as crown decor, and the earth pony one was chilling with random earth pony being used for a lamp


Hi I love this theory but I thought since twighlight represented magic she maybe made it but I don't think she needed to sacrifice herself,remember alicorns are not immortal so maybe over time she just passed down power to her successor and the gems. Twighlight is a pony who thinks ahead so she probably realised anything could happen in her absence so she created the gems😄. But, my question is what happened to their maps the two are completely of! It's like their in two different worlds or something! So that's my problem that needs tackling


What if Twilight turned starlight into an alicorn and starlight sacrificed herself instead she is more likely to have separated her three kinds into three crystals because they have the same colors as her.


This also seems like the best reason for the tribes to separate rather than just fear and propaganda as in the movie. We’ll probably find more out about what happened between g4 and g5 as the new series of the show comes out next year.


I kinda like this theory, but to add onto it i feel it would be cool if Twilight retained her alicorn life but lost her magic and losing her friends caused her to pull a luke skywalker and she become a recluse away from society, it would be cool that in the coming series if the next gen characters discover her and help her see the magic of friendship again.


Adding more fuel to the fire, I theorize Twilight had to take on all the alicorn magic from the other princesses, just like she did vs Tirek,  before splitting it all up.


"The people of equestria"<br>Its ponies but its OK! I love the video ive been wondering this! Thank you for making this.

"The people of equestria"
Its ponies but its OK! I love the video ive been wondering this! Thank you for making this.


Did anyone else notice how argile looks very similar to twilight, therefore leading me to believe him and sunny are both descendants of twilight after she became an earth pony she started a family in knowing that equestria would fall and teaching her descendants to keep the memories alive, so that when equestria does fall her relatives would bring it all back together. Idk something I noticed and figured could be a possibility 🙃


The new movie was good idea,but I didn’t like how it was basically completely cut off from the show we all know and love


When the mane 6 passed away instead of finding new ones to take their place which we thought would happen with her star pupil, she instead decided to give each tribe a crystal to keep the magic. With friendship bringing magic but twighlight no longer having her friends this is the course of action she decided to do


but what about when cadence,celestia,and luna had to give their magic to twilight so she could defeat tirek? and when tirek took all the alicorn magic including twilights and she was basically unharmed.  the princesses didn't die,lose their wing, or lose their horns just their magic


Here is my theory: Bridlewood used to be the Everfree Forest then the unicorns saw that Ponyville was in it. Then they restored the structures. my guess is Zephyr Heights once used to be Canterlot because of the palace and they just restored it. Maretime Bay my guess is Horseshoe Bay and they just put structures there.


Two theories i have that one or both can be true, based off this video.
 1: Once twilight became a mere mortal with no magic, she'd be a magicless earth pony. Like all the earth ponies are now. Think about it. The earth ponies, even after magic returned in the g5 movie, have yet to actually show signs of earth pony magic again. It is there, but they don't know it. But what if twilight became a fully magicless pony, and had descendants? Those descendants would have the place where the crystals were made as their home. And they would have kept hope no matter what, even after all the tribes of ponies went their separate ways. As time passed, everypony thpught it was just folklore and fairy tales. But one family never gave up hope. Sunny's family. The descendants of twilight. I know it sounds crazy, but only sunny's father has any knowledge of twilight, and could tell the stories in great detail. The journal he has is twilight's final days written down. That's why it has maps to the 3 tribes. She went there before she died. And only her descendants, leading down to sunny, knew of her existence. You may be wondering what made me even think of this. Well, it all comes down to who actually gained the power of all 3 tribes and became a kind of alicorn at the end. Sunny was the only one chosen, and looking at what happened, it was oddly like the magic of the crystals was returning to the owner. If twilight's magic was inside the crystals, who else would the magic return to since twilight is long gone? Well, the final descendant of twilight. Sunny, as the final child of twilight's bloodline and the strongest in friendship, gained back the magic her ancestor had given up. And if the crystals contain the final bits of magic needed to restore magic to equestria's ponies, what else could it have contained? That leads to my second theory.
     2: If twilight gave her magic, and potentially even her life, to create the crystals, where would her spirit have gone? Into the crystals. That's why only when friendship and love were restored, the crystals activated, reunited, and restored the magic. What caused all these elements to be needed if it was just a relic? Something or somepony had to be inside the crystals. And while twilight may have had a lot of magic, i doubt she alone could have restored magic to equestria. I think all the alicorns who remained sacrificed their lives to create it. That's why friendship and love were needed. It's possible celestia and luna merged with the sun and moon so they'd continue to function properly, while cadence, flurry, and twilight sacrificed their lives to create the crystals. Hence why love, friendship, and maybe even whatever flurry came to rule over, were all needed from all the tribes to activate the crystals. With those 3 united, it gave the magic back. Also, i think the crystals may have even been created using crystals from the castle of friendship, the crystal empire, and canterlot. The 3 realms of the 3 princesses who sacrificed everything for the future of equestria.


Did anyone else notice that despite their cutie marks, all unicorns have the same PURPLE (cough twilight's color) magic? Strange when you think about how magic color matches cutie marks in G4


Hello, I have a theory myself, I think you are correct about her making the crystals, but I think, you need all of the magic to BE an alicorn, with the lost of harmony, who needs a princess? Who needs someone with all the magic? NO ONE!!! So she just disappeared, and left the crystals.


Your theory kinda makes sense. Maybe Twillight didn't do it alone, she probably did it with her friends. After they did it, they all vanished from Equestria (?). That's maybe why they aren't in the new world. And Twillight probably did the big part in the process cause her cutie mark is the only one in the stained glass.

Or just Twillight let her friends don't it.. she did it alone cause she didn't want them in danger.. since Hasbro said Twillight didn't outlive her friends.. After she made the crystals, she died. Since the horns go cuz of the unicorn crystal and the wings go cuz of the pegasus crystal and the body goes too, because the earth pony crystal. That was probably Twillight's last day..

Eek! Imagine if Hasbro did an actual episode on our theories! I hope they give us the answers 🙂


Wow when i was very little i used to watch my little pony friend ship is magic and this video makes me miss it my little sister watches my little pony and i hope they bring back the main 6 so my sister can watch it :)


Maybe twighlight learnt from Celestia and had the idea with the crystals. Celestia made the elements of harmony, maybe having the idea of disharmony, but then she trusted in Twighlight and everything turmed out fine. Maybe Twighlight found a pony SHE culd trust with learning and teaching friendship.

Celestia didn't make the Elements of Harmony. she and Luna found them in the Tree of Harmony, which had already existed long before they even arrived to Equestria.


Tbh I was hoping for some good action at the end but all we got was a adult pony with a pile of junk trying to destroy a lighthouse while calling his mom “mommy” like a four year old, and throwing a tantrum while doing so.

I can say I am pretty disappointed.


this is so sad :( but, man! I love your channel, i never see you before! Nice work!!


It is also possible that Twilight not only sacrificed her power as an Alicorn, but she also may have died resulting in the creation of the crystals. Celestia banished her own sister to the moon for 1000 years. And while she survived she also lost someone she dearly cared about as a result of it.  Or Starswirl and the Pillars, they united their powers and abilities to take down the Pony of Shadows, but knew in doing so they would be locking themselves in the realm of shadows with Stygian and felt that sacrifice was for the greater good.

So maybe in order to end the crisis at hand, with her companions greatly aged the six of them unite the power of the elements to create the crystals but they themselves vanish as the crystals are created. Everyone left behind by them tries to keep the Twilights legacy alive, but without her wisdom and guidance, the beings in Equestria dissolve their alliances with the ponies. Alicorns like Cadance, Luna, Celestia, and Flurryheart fade into obscurity, or perhaps as a result of this spell all the Alicorns cease to exist. So Flurryheart just becomes a normal unicorn or Pegasus for example. And without the Alicorns to represent and unite the three pony tribes, unity between the three tribes fades causing them to drift apart as well.


either twilight lived as a mortal after she gave her magic up, or she aged super quickly afterwards and died very soon afterwards; why? because she mightve lived past a normal ponies life span, and her alicorn magic kept her alive…. kinda morbid, sorry


When I saw my sibling watching I was hold up what?! I loved the old series when I was a kid😢


What if Argyle has met Twilight or maybe be a distant relative to her it could also makes sense why Argyle would have a similar design of unicorns and and why he still belives that unicorns and pegasus are not dangerous or why or still searched about the ancient artifacts. Could that be another theory?


I guess could be some dark magic attacking and it would erase all memories and defeat her so she though  that she could create 3 different gems that connected they would like generate magic and if not they would have no magic (like she did magic would depend of these) so.. even if they separate they would found the way back to magic and frienship at some point they just had just figure it out just like they did in the past. It's just like a puzzle she left i think.


this makes so much sense but now I'm sad :") for being a kids/teen show this is pretty depressing lol


<b>I theorize the crystal empire either followed the same fate as the Babylonian Empire or possibly even Atlantis.</b>

*I theorize the crystal empire either followed the same fate as the Babylonian Empire or possibly even Atlantis.*


I am still wondering what happen to discord when the tribes started to separate? Then the next question will be if Luna stayed and her sister gone because I realize that in the movie there were no mural or a statue about Alicorns at all except for Twilight Cutie Mark.


I think there was a war between ponys and creatures all the creatures were lost, twilight split into 3 crystals as she carrys all magic from all types of ponys to she did it to try end the war but all it did was literally separate them i mean i dragged them apart she thats why she knew it would drag them apart but she didnt know how far. Each crystal followed one type of pony to the places the got dragged. All the ponys started buillding homes the earth ponys blamed the other types of pony for geting dragged to diffrent places and the other ponys thought all blamed each other too. So the ones that got dragged told their children that other types of ponys were bad their children told their children and so on. They each used the crystal for diffrent things it seems like with the unicorns they saw it just as a crystal. the pegasus gave it to royalty and royalty passed it down as a crown. the earth ponys put it in an shop or work shop. where someone boght it and passed it down thats how sunny got it. But there were ponys who just after getting dragged knew it wasnt anypony trying to hurt them thats why sunny beleived that some ponys even after 1000 years even if none said it was true they just knew and that mind set passed down.. the reson for the war with creatures was one Yak not wanting to hurt anyone put a poster saying "anypony come here for me to test stuff on" ponys thought he was trying to hurt other the ponys started screaming the yaks started trying to hurst ponys now the drgons were one of the first creatures that a pony talked to they were on the ponys side but the ponys thought all creatures were bad so they hurt them and hurt every creature untill they were lost. the pony thought that unicorn had more power than anyone so they attaked at night then an earth pony hit an pegasus (friendly fire) that started the war..... but when the crystals were put back toghether earrth ponys and pegasus got more magic twilight hoped that it wouldnt happen at all even her friends were inclueded in it but they werent dragged they were lost giving their magic to their side to in hopes their side won twilight knew already she had to end this but this was the last straw the unicorn were trying to control the other pony the pegasus were trying to grab ponys now that the creatures were all gone earth ponys didnt have much power at al thats where Apple Jack and Pinkie Pie came they had a bit of power more than others thats why they gave their powers while when she friendship but the other just did it to get their side to win. Thats where twilight is, her magic still remains she hoped she could spread more friendship she felt like she failed so she gave her frienship to everypony. trying to get the unicorn even to bring back creaatures and they will hopefully live in harmony once more. but with no pony or creature trying to hurt them every creature geting along is her goal. her brother and parents had also been in this war. cutie marks were still there but you got it at an very very young age like 3 because she saw sweetie belle and her friend struggle and fell sad but happy when they got them. this is why she tryed to spread more friendship trying just to pull them apart a bit but thats not what happend...... her friendship is there forever sunny has a toy of her that will remind ponys after sunnys gone friendship is everywhere and the crystals will not be needed for frienship that is what it will teach them and that you dont need power for friendship and she knew crystals wont make friendship that wanst the lesson it was you dont need magic crystald or evan have be related to magic to get along,,,,


Idea: All the others of the main six have passed and twilights long alicorn life has Cursed her, this means that the mane six who created/found the friendship of magic have disappeared along with the magic, twilight is devastated and is trying to get the power of friendship back so she creates three interlocking crystals to try and bring back the magic of friendship within the three categories of ponies, of course this fails and thus follows with the movie


i think the only thing you didn’t get right imo is that she probably didn’t die because she stopped ageing slowly. since alicorns are all types of pony she would have given up her horn, her wings, and also her pony body. so imo she either died on the spot or her body vanished but her spirit is still in those artifacts


Sawtooth: She sacrificed everything<br>Hasbro: I'm about to end this mans whole career

Sawtooth: She sacrificed everything
Hasbro: I'm about to end this mans whole career


I HAVE A THEORY
we see none of the magical beings in ANG meaning that something happened to them
Maybe when the magic disappeared from equestria they all were turned to stone and more should’ve happened so they might have been buried under something after all or maybe one pony/ a race of ponies hid them somewhere


Cozy Glow came back and turned Twilight and the others to stone. Cozy used propaganda to make the Ponies lose friendship, but Twilight made the gems as a last ditch effort to reignite magic.


I think what's most unfortunate about this theory is what's most tragic. At the end of the FiM series, the elements of Friendship were old, ready to depart. Twilight would have been the only one left from the OG. She gave up her immortality and the magic that kept her alive. At that age? She wouldn't last a minute. I don't think she lived out her life. I think she died, right then and there.


Saw the movie. Loved it. But one thing I noticed. It was that the ponies still never got their full cutie marks by the end.


<b>intro</b> exactly wtf happened, when i saw everything i was like 1 what happened to all the magic and the bad guys leftover their statues and bodies how did this whole split happen of the ponies how did history repeat when it ended with literally every race coming together in harmony, how could so much time have passed in between that not only the ponies lost all their magical abilities but also isolated themselves purely away from each other, and what happened to discord, twilight may have passed on the magic after a while but discord couldnt do that without the bell.

*intro* exactly wtf happened, when i saw everything i was like 1 what happened to all the magic and the bad guys leftover their statues and bodies how did this whole split happen of the ponies how did history repeat when it ended with literally every race coming together in harmony, how could so much time have passed in between that not only the ponies lost all their magical abilities but also isolated themselves purely away from each other, and what happened to discord, twilight may have passed on the magic after a while but discord couldnt do that without the bell.


I have an addictional teory: on The mural the artifact are in white circle, but what also is in the circle is unicorn horn and pegasai wings. It may be, beacuse artifact react to it, but I think The crisis could be that pegasai and unicorn stopped being born. Like in mixed relationships there were more chance for earth pony to be born and The other tribes went extinct. Thats why twilight had to give them artificial horns and wings, and they had to go apart or this same thing happens and the unbalance might happen again. And without 2 tribes There were probably magic problems too. That would also explain why the wendigo didn't appear, since it isn't a conflict but rather planned separation.


what i think is that twighlight could've stayed an alicorn if she seperrated her magic, but i don't know. Make more videos!!!!


I get the long lasting effects of artifacts, But! What if the crystals are keys that sealed the ability to use magic🔐🪄. Because Equestria, as we know from Equestria Girls, is a world of magic that exists. And Twilight sacrifice herself to seal that ability to use magic for ponies. Magic is everywhere, as learned in mlp gen 4, so it doesn’t make sense that all magic 🪄 is gone. That’s assuming the other races can still use their natural abilities.


From what i see there's a panel messing the earth pony should be under this missing panel probably the one twilight is on  The pieces just don't match up there's that middle panel is the key to know what really happened


I think it happened another way tho idk about her getting rid of her alicorn magic like when celestia,cadence,and Luna got rid of there magic they just lost there cutie marks not the alicorn of themselves


wow that make os much sense. That would also explain why she can´t name a new leader for equestria. Because she had no magic left that a new leader could get to lead the kingdom.


OMG that’s what I thought... this is amazing


Well i have a theory myself, what if sunny is twilight sparkle i mean think about reincarnation, what if twilight was reincarnated into sunny!
Also look at sunny's dad he looks kinda like twilight sparkle.
(just my theory tho)


if this makes sense i have a feeling sunny dad you know him he looks a lot like twilight just a hunch tho


Hey I’m very curious if Celestia and Luna can have evil Alcorn forms can Cadence, Twilight, and Flurry heart have one too??


Sorry. Quick sidebar cause I can’t comment on the Wendigo video. I was wondering, is it ever stated that G5 is in Equestia? Maybe the Wendigos are only native to Equestia which is why they aren’t there. Or with the same way as how the magical animals in Equestia got magic at the end of the movie. Maybe they have regained magic too. I wonder if we’ll get into the crystal empire next because of the heart hooves prints after credits. Also I’m curious about Discord and the other creatures like dragons and hypogriffs as well as the Everfree forest. Could these new characters be descendants from the main 6 or other characters? AND! ARE CUTIE MARKS NOT INATE MAGIC?!? How does this culture still have cutie marks???


But where was Flurry Heart during the whole movie? What about the crystal empire?


Im still crying about the new generation of mlp and when I watched I was like yeah my childhood is ruined like why is the timeline modernized and 3D like you cant even call it a cartoon anymore . omg now that I think of it what if all of this happens to tom and jerry , spongebob and other cartoons will we even have cartoons . I guess we'll just have anime then 😭😭😭😭

3D cartoons are still a thing. also just give it a try.


hey I know you probably  wont see this comment but now that g5 is finally out what do you think will happen to sprout do you think he'll come back even more evil, go neutral, or even become sunset shimmer but with a better reformation arc. What do you think sawtooth I would absolutely love to hear your opinion. mostly because very few youtubers have analyzed sprout the only people who did was dannyballsub and Dr Wolf.

i also used roblox fim to make her design

also I for some reason I would love to see what happened to the crystal empire. I made my own li'l fanfic in my journal about how its been so long and even flurry retired but had no successor so for many moons they had  been stuck with no happiness and are filled with anger and are in anarchy. Then a unicorn who is banished for protesting a democracy not knowing that she would soon bump into a newly reformed sprout they would eventually bond over that there being pressured to be perfect and feel like they a watched and ponies are waiting for them to fail. They would fall in love over a little while(there relationship is not mushy at all and have standards rather than acting like lovers they just do a few flirty jokes and act like best friends) Soon She would be elected as president of the crystal empire 1 moon later.


Where the heck did Celestia and Luna go?are they dead yet?they are still alicorns right?and where are the other creatures?like yaks,dragon,and the sort...


Explain what happened to Discord because he is literally immortal he was be able to tell everyone about friendship


what if twilight and the other did something like starswirl and the pillars did to the pony of shadows?
what if the mane six are trapped somewhere too?
think about it, the elements are three: unicorn (rarity), earth pony (applejack, pinkie pie), pegasus(fluttershy, rainbow dash) = magic. (twilight)
what if the magic in those thing are their magic? maybe thats why sunny father likes the mane six that much... probably he found twilight old book. (the one we saw at the ending and at the start of the serieses)
another question is that where the hell are dragons, hippogriffs, griffons, ecc?
another thing, where are cadence, celestia, luna, flurry heart? they are alicorns which means that they never died? or maybe something happend to them too, maybe someone actually tried to set free cozy glow, and the others back and they had to fight
just a thought tho, i really need answers i hope we will get them in the awaking season


I don’t think twilight twilight disappeared because she be with United them elements of harmony and then they formed into the crystals with twilight I’m going away and disappearing in less than aAsh of wind wind wind disappeared like like the winds blowing her away and the thin air and then she disappeared forever and ever and ever


So what if twilight put everything in it including herself! So what if when the gens are together she might come back I don't know it's a theory I've been thinking about


My opinion, I think Grogar, the real Grogar, is the one who behind all of these and serve as a Last Boss in this generation....

กฤษดา กลิ่นพิกุล


I’d say your right about this, it seems the most logical.


Me: sees title
Me: What happened to twilight....
Me: Gets idea
Me: There's a simple explanation. She's dead. she got dethroned by the pegasi, earth ponys, and unicorns UwU

Me: *sees title*
Me: What happened to twilight....
Me: *Gets idea*
Me: There's a simple explanation. She's dead. she got dethroned by the pegasi, earth ponys, and unicorns UwU


Theory coming<br>Well the father of sunny is twilights son it and flash and twilight had a kid and that's twilight son and they the mother of sunny is a Pegasus and the father of sunny is a unicorn that's why her father has a long hair and the hair covers the horn see my point now

Theory coming
Well the father of sunny is twilights son it and flash and twilight had a kid and that's twilight son and they the mother of sunny is a Pegasus and the father of sunny is a unicorn that's why her father has a long hair and the hair covers the horn see my point now


I just had a thought lol I’m probably really late for not noticing this sooner but the sun and moon don’t move on their own but in a world with out magic how did day and night continue I wonder if that artifact celesta gave twilight to raise the sun and moon is still out there and some pony has been using it this whole time it’s been awhile since I’ve seen the episode I’m pretty sure it broke in the end but maybe some one fixed it but idk 😅

@Myra Arora that's an interesting idea to

I never thought of that. Maybe Celestia & Luna kept raising the sun n moon & Twilight only raised it during the summer sun celebration as a symbol of her taking over.


Idk why but I feel like the 3 crystal things are gonna become a magic crown that sunny wears to become an alicorn or smt like the crown twillight had that had a magic gem or smt. Just a random though.


Wait i have a question how did twilight be an unicorn again thats impossible


how about celestia and luna? where are they and why are they not helping?


NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! It can NOT end like that for twilgiht


what if Luster Dawn had something to do with it?


can you do one where you find about cadence or flurry heart?


I hope the ponies of newly born equestria reconnect with the yaks hippogriffs griffins and changelings again i hope their not all extinct


How did Twilight create the crystals?
Me: GASP She Died!

How did Twilight create the crystals?
Me: *GASP* She Died!


But what about the Crystal Empire there was a child that was born an alicorn would that not change the story?


Ok I’m where yr explaining how twighlight died or wtf, but what if the main 6 all agreed to share their power into the artifacts and that’s like what happened


What about the other alicorns like Celestia, Luna, Cadence and Flurry Heart


What about the crystal empire I mean the empire could’ve made them think about it


am glad to still see you posting! i remember when you were once called brony notion :D

@Sawtooth Waves hehe it really has! take care my friend <3


Oh my god.......
When they finally end mlp.. This will happen to twilight!! Think about it mlp  revolves around twilight being the main character! So when they end it something must have to happen to Twilight! Something she did.. Lead to her demise.. What if when she put her magic in the artifacts it simultaneously killed her? Shes never had all of her magic taken away the shock of no magic could kill her ending the mlp serie i mean she was born as a unicorn. She always had magic.

Sawtooth waves if you read this please do a video on my comment and consider this as a possibility


In my mind I'm thinking she went out to go look for Mordecai


Argyll looks mighty similar to twilight if you ask me


Also there is no way you can tell me sunnies dad isn’t like a descendant of twilight or something JUST LOOK AT THAT HAIR.


I'm not going to be able to sleep after finding out my childhood princess IS LITERALLY DEAD-


It made me think of a different cartoon. Princess Sofia and Princess Elena. Elena being stuck in the amulet. Instead of dying (I know she died it just made me think of this) she is inside the gems. Again I know it isn't true it just made me think of it.


can you please make a video about how a earth pony like Sunny became a alicorn?

how does a Pegasus like Rainbow Dash become a alicorn?

she's not an alicorn; the wings and horn are temporary.


He will be gone forever! NOOOOOOOOOOOOO. Twitter why in the world did you do that? I will miss you Twitter......


OK here's what I think I think Twilight sparkle is still  an allocorn and your being silly for thinking she would do that  I'm sure if that happened it would be on Hasbro's My Little pony records


him : I WAS STONE<br>ME : good exscuse for not wanting to make a 3D Character

him : I WAS STONE
ME : good exscuse for not wanting to make a 3D Character


I wonder what happend to the crystel empire and the other alicorns…


Twilight could have made them by the other crystals that King Sombra broke. (The Elements of harmony) cuz only unicorn, Pegasus, and earth pony can use them. (Twilight, Apple jack, Rainbow dash, Pinkie pie, and Flutter shy) when spike tried to use them he couldn't. And I didn't think Sombra could too.

But spike couldn’t use it because unlike rainbow dash spike is not the embodiment or spirit or whatever u call it of loyalty


I think twilight died and the rulers know


But why does sprouts mom look like the filly we see at the end of season8? And note pinkie and cheese sandwich had kids remember?


Holy cow god I don't know what is in his drink but I think I just saw princess twilight sparkle.


where did princess Celestia and Luna went, well they all are the sun and the moon and twilight is actually the twilight,, but the princesses were born pure at birth, pure alicorn blood with both parents being alicorns


still throws the questions whats with spike discord for examble <br>since discord alone is immortal

still throws the questions whats with spike discord for examble
since discord alone is immortal


i think twilight sparkle just vanished or disappeared knowing that she did in fact died or twilight is the true villian


But I guess another mystery remains, what happened to Cadence and Flurry Heart throughout all this?


Ong I don't think I'll every watch that new one. I'll stick to the one with twilight. It's the one In my generation I was able to watch through. And it's also a reboot of the other one. I had a book for the previous one with the pink pony on the cover.


Is there a new my little pony that is realistic?


No this is what actually happened Princess Alessia and Princess Luna and Twilight sparkle made crystals


Sounds like someone's desperate for some copium.


i wonder who controls the sun and moon...


I found sunny very annoying🤷♀ my opinion


Thats may accualy be why sunny didn't become a full alicorn


How come my boi still didnt get 1M subs?


Hasbro kidnapped Twilight sparkle and forced her to create new toy's

ɪɴᴅᴜsᴛʀɪᴀʟ ɢʀᴀᴅᴇ ᴛʀᴏʟʟ


Good morning, I have a question about my little pony.can you make a video about conscious with my little pony friendship is magic and my little pony a new generation .


If you want to know where twilight is she’s dead


"IN. MY. OPINION. THIS. GLITCH. IS. WHAT. EVERYONE. USES. AM. I. RIGHT?"
"E.ETHY.BAR"

"WHAT. IS. THIS. SONG. USED. IN. THE. VIDEO?"
CERTIFICATED

*"IN. MY. OPINION. THIS. GLITCH. IS. WHAT. EVERYONE. USES. AM. I. RIGHT?"*
*"**E.ETHY.BAR**"*

*"WHAT. IS. THIS. SONG. USED. IN. THE. VIDEO?"*
*CERTIFICATED*


Argyle’s colours are similar to Twilight’s dad - what if he is of some relation to them? Also, what if Sunny’s unknown mother is Luster Dawn? Their colours are similar as well!

If it was Luster, we would have seen the tribes and creatures being together and we could have seen the Mane 6. The Gen 5 takes many many years after Gen 4, so no, Luster Dawn cannot ve the mother :/


this kinda explains why sunny became a alicorn somewhat 5:57


The creators: Ok let's just put some random crystals that Twilight Sparkle would make or whatever the kids will probably like it.<br>The fandom: DEATH. SACRIFICE. BIG BOOOM.

The creators: Ok let's just put some random crystals that Twilight Sparkle would make or whatever the kids will probably like it.
The fandom: DEATH. SACRIFICE. BIG BOOOM.


What about flurry and celestia and Luna because they are all alicorns and also flurry’s mother I forgot how to spell her name lol


I'm using my moms account but, what about celestia and luna?


4:28 sawtooth:let’s talk about how the cristals were made
Me: (realizing what he’s going to say)
Nooo she…she didn’t😢😢😭🥺


Jesus loves you guys, I just had to say it❤


ok but I have several problems with this generation. how about all the other princesses? how do the sun and moon work? where's Discord? where are the villains? where are all the other creatures? gen 5 really just feels like the people who made it thought that referencing the last generation was fun but didn't think about any of the details or problems that would cause
edit: another problem is why did Sunny turn into an alicorn for uniting everyone when that had already been done and the pony who did it (clover the clever) didn't turn into an alicorn himself? and, wasn't it pretty much a rule that only unicorns can turn into alicorns? earth ponies don't have magic, how do you create new magic to become a princess if you don't have the ability to do so in the first place? I know I'm just ranting but damn this has so many problems

ok but I have *several* problems with this generation. how about all the other princesses? how do the sun and moon work? where's Discord? where are the villains? where are all the other creatures? gen 5 really just feels like the people who made it thought that referencing the last generation was fun but didn't think about any of the details or problems that would cause
edit: another problem is why did Sunny turn into an alicorn for uniting everyone when that had already been done and the pony who did it (clover the clever) didn't turn into an alicorn himself? and, wasn't it pretty much a rule that only unicorns can turn into alicorns? earth ponies don't have magic, how do you create new magic to become a princess if you don't have the ability to do so in the first place? I know I'm just ranting but damn this has so many problems

Sunny isnt actually an alicorn. If you look at the new upcoming mlp toys, you'll see sunny doesn't have wings or a horn anymore but she does still have the rainbow streak in her hair

Likely the villains would have been free but ultimately powerless once magic was gone.

While I can’t answer most of these questions, Cadence was a pegasus-turned alicorn, so I don’t think there’s any rule stating that only unicorns can be turned into alicorns.


I wonder what actually happened to the Kirin the hippogriffs the Griffins Dragons yaks and the Changelings


So I called it, the crystals were a fail safe pretty much lol


My dumb butt just thought it's a way of summoning her


It's just like when magic was being drained in the episode School Raze.


Maybe she took the power away is that to teach friend ship because friendship was the way to teach a lesson of friend ship and the power is unlocked bye friend ship

She was obviously trying to teach something about friendship maybe by taking all the power so she can show friendship is the most powerful


But where are the sister’s? They didn’t give up their magic. Maybe it wasn’t just twilight. But ALL THE ALICORNS.


This theory is 100X better then my theory that Twilight simply offed herself after her other friends died.
This is much better.
My new headcanon, though it's very likely true.

This theory is 100X better then my theory that Twilight simply offed herself after her other friends died.
This is *much* better.
My new headcanon, though it's very likely true.


in general that speaking sounds believable, I believe in it


I don’t think ponies need artifacts to make or use magic in this timeline. I think twilight may have made those if there was ever a time in the future where ponies became distant and distrustful. Twilight wasn’t going to be around forever (alicorns aren’t immortal, they are just long-lived). I think the artifacts are used to teach a lesson in trust and friendship. The magic disappeared when ponies became distrusting of one another and took one piece of the artifact. This timeline takes place so far in the future that twilight’s timeline is called “ancient equestria.” This means her books, castles and other things tied to the mane 6 are gone or relics. Similar to relics from ancient Egypt or China.


Sawtooth: "Twlight sparkle"<br>Me: 'twinkle sprinkle"

Sawtooth: "Twlight sparkle"
Me: 'twinkle sprinkle"


Has anyone else noticed the change of his channel's pfp? I think Sine is taking over again. Well, good luck with THAT one, Sawtooth! 😂


I think in season 10 of mlp fim idw comics answered everything

Spoiler

The knights of harmony talked about how discord, chrysalis and cosmos caused fear and distrust in the past and fights among other kingdoms which lead to the knights of harmony hiding The trees of harmony. And in the last page of season 10 we can see chrysalis breaking free and the grey pony said that she's early. So what if chrysalis caused equestria to have fear and distrust again

Sadly I have spoiled myself but it is worth it since I can't find them where I live except online on the Enemy side (has a name that starts by "a" and ends with a "n" and an arrow that goes from the a to the z) so yeah.


Flurry Hearts like: bye-bye aunt twily-boo at 2:36


This does not make sense, Friendship is magic and she would never outlive her friends. And why did twilight give up her alicorn hood?

Well when she did the sacrifice her friends might have been alive, or just died


Wait do u guys see Sawtooths new profile pic? Looks like Sine took over the channel 😞


Old Sky Army fans having flashbacks to old intro music of Skydoesminecraft.


Sawtooth are you ok? Your YouTube profile shows your clone so I’m a little worried. Please respond!


The saddest part about this head cannon is that ultimately: everything twilight did was STILL a waste of time.

Because their societies, even while sadder, could still function without magic. And in the end they separated and Magic faded.

Which is why this sequel sucks. Because instead of yelling a new story, it undoes the first one so I can tell it again (CAUGH CAUGH STARWARS)

Out of context, but...

WHY ARE THESE THREE PEOPLE HAVE SUCH BIG BRAINS!!!
(ノT＿T)ノ ＾┻━┻

Well its possible something else happened. I do agree it is odd. But as societies grow and evolve, sometimes unrest, disagreement, etc. Becomes morr prominent. Thus why there's so many countries on Earth for example, all split into different groups of different cultures and societies while also being alike still. However there is also conflict, such as war or civil unrest. So I think once the actual G5 show comes out and we start seeing more of the story, it may build on it much better and be far more enjoyable. Though its a 50/50 of it either working out or not working out. Who knows.

Or from the business perspective, they decided to have it build off the previous generation instead of completely rebooting it. That way new audiences can experience what G4 had, or long time fans get to enjoy something building off their favorite past generation. Cause from that perspective it makes more sense conceptually and for financial reasons most likely.
I will say on the bright side it's not looking like its going to be a cheap ass show like how many other franchises are getting right now. They're at the least putting in effort.
Personally I dont mind the film. I enjoyed it. I actually liked the concept of seeing what it was like for the tribes to be separated like they were in the beginning before the founding of equestria.
I will say it seems like a play on the "history repeats iitself" kind of thing

To be fair....in this scenario I feel like this is similar to history and what we have in the present.. There's so many rules and objects people create that perhaps the person felt like would be useful but over time it grew to become useless and a waste of time. What was the point of even creating those rules when it was all going to downhill? Why do we even have a government if we know one day these governments will also disappear? Why do we have buildings that will collapse and be destroyed by the environment? Why do we have to go to school and learn different subjects when not all of these subjects will be used in our individual lives?<br> I wouldn't compare this to Star Wars either as Generation 5 still has a series to give us more explanation and detail to the movie. This was more of an introduction, and it's main target is still for children so they can get to know the characters and I'm sure over time just like the main six we'll be able to see some character development and learn more about the separation of the ponies than what we currently have. There is still room for G5 to fill in the gaps between Twilight's reign, how they learned to function without magic (certainly interested how the unicorns dealt with that change and how the pegasi had to adapt), and if there's even anything in the world left of G4 (Tree of life, castle of the two sisters, Canterlot castle, dragons, I wonder what happened to discord, what became of cloudsdale, the yaks, crystal empire, etc)

To be fair....in this scenario I feel like this is similar to history and what we have in the present.. There's so many rules and objects people create that perhaps the person felt like would be useful but over time it grew to become useless and a waste of time. What was the point of even creating those rules when it was all going to downhill? Why do we even have a government if we know one day these governments will also disappear? Why do we have buildings that will collapse and be destroyed by the environment? Why do we have to go to school and learn different subjects when not all of these subjects will be used in our individual lives?
 I wouldn't compare this to Star Wars either as Generation 5 still has a series to give us more explanation and detail to the movie. This was more of an introduction, and it's main target is still for children so they can get to know the characters and I'm sure over time just like the main six we'll be able to see some character development and learn more about the separation of the ponies than what we currently have. There is still room for G5 to fill in the gaps between Twilight's reign, how they learned to function without magic (certainly interested how the unicorns dealt with that change and how the pegasi had to adapt), and if there's even anything in the world left of G4 (Tree of life, castle of the two sisters, Canterlot castle, dragons, I wonder what happened to discord, what became of cloudsdale, the yaks, crystal empire, etc)


Or maybe there is another possibility.Remember when u thought Grogar's essence was sealed in the bell,maybe Twilight's essence was sealed in the gems.Well here is my first evidence,remember when the gems were attached together and the magic didn't got restored, well think about it just because the gems were attached together doesn't mean it would bring the tribes together,so if it's true Twilight's essence was in the gems then the magic wouldn't restore unless ponies reunite. Here is my second evidence,when the tribes got together it restored the magic of course but just before that event Sunny became into an alicorn and I think Twilight knew this from the beginning that she has the qualities to become an alicorn just like how Celestia thought Twilight would become an alicorn,temporary of course since she has a lot to learn about friendship so ya.


Weather this theory holds any water or not, it’s ironic to imagine that it wasn’t some chaotic villain or powerful curse that defeated the mane 6 or divided Equestria, but rather fear, and hostility. Something more real and finite to comprehend.


I think Twilight made these crystals so the tribes would divide and after become friends so they understand friendship like how celestia taught her to make friends and also she did not sacrifice her alicorn hood she just took a tiny bit of it and gave it to the crystals


It's might be true there is a high chance I'm sorry but that just reuven's My Little Pony for me........


I LOVE MLP💖💚💙💜❤💛💋👄💋👄💋👄💋👄💋👄💋💕💓💕💓💕💓💓💕💞💕💞💕💞💕👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍😻😻😻😻😻😚😗😗😗😚😚😗😚😗😗😗😗😚😍😍😍


4:58 look at twilight cutei mark I can see her face


This everybody is my comfort channel, you literally can’t hate it and if you do you’re wrong 🙄 /j

@Isbah loves dinos oh? Well then forgive me. But your choice of emoji was kind of giving away the vibe that you were upset or even angry with the people that have different opinion than yours.

I still remember when he announced his channel name change. I have been here for a long time which might not have been that long sadly I don't keep track of time well and as we grow older the years starts to fly by faster.

@Hiccy69 it’s not as serious as you think it is 😒

I'm sorry, but you do realize that there is a thing called "opinion" right? If they hate these kind of channel, well, it is their opinion. You can't force them to change that opinion, might as well respect it. Same as everything in this world.


ميراكلوس ١٠٠

@ميراكلوس ١٠٠ omg u are

@ميراكلوس ١٠٠ omg u are

ميراكلوس ١٠٠


twilight is dead in that move.. also i love ur viodeos


Here's my theory on why the crystals were created and it may not be all that depth in detail.

But I think that she created them for the reason that if ponies overtime start to drift apart over the years from friendship to where ponies start to see friendship as a distraction and no longer needed and she may have seen early signs of this, to where she would need these crystals to help bring the ponies back together again and help them realize that friendship is still needed and is still around and only the crystals will help them see that it isn't the crystals that will bring their magic back, but the friendships and the harmony they will have with each other and its the crystals to help them see that by bringing them together and the friendships they have made.

But by creating the crystals, led to Twilight becoming a normal unicorn again from the amount of magic needed to create them. So for if friendship fades over the years and the magic gone with it from the ponies, the crystals will bring it back.


She is still her  tall queen self but just. With no horn or wings maybe?

★𝗣7𝗙𝗙𝗬𝗦𝐓𝗔𝗥𝗦_𝗬𝗧★


What  if   the   mane 6   got   sucked in the   crystals


Sorry I am and you were stuck a long time Twilight my take died and give up for magic


———————————-sunny starscout—————————-twilight sparkle———————- dead sunny——————twilight kills sunny starscout because she’s sus—————-sunny starscout is A imposter—————————sunny kills twilight and her friends—————applejack calls a meeting wish sus it’s sunny run————— sunnny kills applejack—————————-


At least Twilight isn't immortal in the end here, so she doesn't have to see like the literal extinction of ponies


No No she not died she just left the place where she live


Discorn has wings in his body but he doesn't fly?

He's a spirit of chaos. he doesn't need wings to fly.


How should i watch my little pony new genration


Twilight light stared as an earth pony then a unicorn then a alicorn


@Chelsea Mudgway nah she's probably dead


Bet twilight will be find by the new friend in the show soon. Then sabe the world o er there again.  And learn stuff form the kids who are the mane 6.  And they boy pony is flash the police looking for his lost love. And the amboned house of the start of video might be hiding the mirror to human world.   And wings now the invisible like new spell. Because if you fly evil can see you easy. And so new wings can make you sneak little more easy.   Twilight alway got a plan.


請問你們可以出中文版的嗎？

請問你們可以出中文版的嗎？


What about the new trailer on after netfilx?


This is one of the best theories for what happened that I’ve seen but it doesn’t explain what happened to Discord who is immortal and also flurry heart and the entire crystal empire. Also how the Pegasus earth and unicorns fought since the same thing happens in the season finale of season 9 but the students of twilights friendship school brought them back together. Also what happened to the hippogrifs, griffins, yaks, changlings and other friends of equestria. Also what happened to the pillars and the new friendship 6 who are technically the successors of the mane 6. Celestia and Luna and also somewhere in retirement still alicorns. You’ve already addressed the windigos. Maybe you will able find answers to all these questions and if so please make a new video covering all the details.


It gives me total chills how all of this makes so much sense! Although what about the other 5? I mean im kinda tired seeing twilight being the center all the time. In the whole series, twilight always ends up as the hero but, she's not gonna be the princess of friendship without friends right? Just saying that maybe the production kinda focused on twilight a little too much


Could you make a video on WHY the ponys can use magic without the crystal. What happened to they’r natural magic? is it somehow trappes in the crystals? I’d love to hear your theory


Hi sawtooth, I just wanna say that in the background of a scene you see a board that looks like a map with post it notes. On the post-its there are cutie marks of the mane six I think that instead of giving away her alicorn magic she gave some of her magic. I think   the mane six persewed there dreams, rarity a fashion sensation, rainbow dash is a famous flyer, and twilight is living with some of her magic left somewhere, probably learning about more friendship. The others I don't know but what do you think.🤔


I noticed on the mural of g5 station, the stained glass of the middle earth pony doesn't line up with the earth pony panel, indicating a portion of  it could have been taken out, like maybe something historical was being hidden or covered up

Same. I think maybe an alicorn is missing from it


You should be asked to be verified! You meet the requirements and you deserve it! I wish the best!<br>😃

You should be asked to be verified! You meet the requirements and you deserve it! I wish the best!
😃


I think you hit the nail on the head, I mean it makes sense, Twilight would preserve her Alicorn magic inside the crystal artifacts, each piece of her inside a crystal shaped like the part of her given, and the mural at the station showing Twilights cutie mark above all three pony kind transforming into the artifacts, something big could have happened to cause her to do this, or maybe, and this is what I believe, she was lonely, with all her friends dead or dying of old age, she wanted to be with them and thought life would not be worth living without her friends and she chose to give up her own life to join her friends, this makes sense and I can see them explain this in a future episode.


I have a question. How did ponies get cutie marks? Because in one of the episodes when tirek took magic from all ponies there cutie also went away.That means cutie marks also required magic.


I agree with everything ur saying and the overall theory, but I think Twilight IS THE ARTifacts!
Like some EXTREME Crisis happened in equestrian history, taking away ponies primary abilities , if not weakened them so much that over generations those abilities faded without magic there.
that crisis was SOOo TERIBLE And threat to all equestria and all magic that I think all remaining magic was either  transferred to her ( like when Tirek took over 1st time) and she had to sacrifice herself into the crystals, if not all magic atleast, in order to save magic itself, and hope for future.
I also think that Crisis made the 3 pony races separate in order to protect, if not hide, their given artifacts from a forgotten evil. That I think eventually in far future the New Generation will have to face, but instead 3 races separated and hiding all will come together and stay together to face that foe.
HECk( I just thought of this) what if Tirek, Queen Crysalis, and the the Pegasus filly escaped and some evil was released again.

Something I can’t wait to see again is the creatures and other species of the world in future, if not the deep Lora toon of equestrian, and surrounding world history.😁😁😅
I’m gettin to deep in these theories lol 😂 😅


You have such a GREAT MIND, i love analisys in your videos. You take into concideration so much details, if not all of them


When I saw the new My Little Pony movie I was like where is twilight and then when I saw this video it changed everything the ending of the TV show ruined my childhood a little bit ruined my favorite show ruined everything thanks for finding out what happened to twilights and the rest of her friends


Your theory is good but has some flaws, if twilight sparkle “ unbecame an alacorn she would beat earth pony she wouldn’t have gone back to being a unicorn because if she went back to being a unicorn she wouldn’t have gave any magic for the unicorn Crystal but if she had turned into an earth pony she wouldn’t have given any magic to the earth pony crystal and she wouldn’t have just disappeared and thin air I’m thinking she cast a very powerful spell to turn  Magic from the elements into the gems that are shown in the movie please put this comment I want everyone to see this theory and please do make a video about this


I am hoping that Hasbro will make a tv series on the G5 and when/if they do I hope it can explain what happened. And maybe some of the new characters in G5 are related to some of the mane 6 from G4. And what happened to the other creatures! Like they where absent from the G5 movie!


a sparkle in the twilight sky that fulfill her destiny

love this line


The only thing I’d would add - maybe Twiglight wanted to become mortal/ die. After all, she was the only immortal from the group of her friends, maybe she wanted to join them in the afterlife


I had quite a big shower thought.

In the new movie A New Generation What happened to like Mt. Aris and like The Changelings and all the other creatures G4 Equestria befriended? I tried solving this on my own but I couldn't so i came to an expert. And also this is a really good theory on what happened and I really believe that this is what happened to twiglight n stuff


Twighlight probably didn’t have a choice to stay with her friends. If the three types of ponies had to separate into the south ( probably the south) the mane six had to separate as well.

Sure the tribes must have lost trust in each other over years and years but probably not to long that the mane six would be so old that they would pass on after a while. The ponies and creatures of equestria would learn that the windagos would not overtake them if they had gone to claim their own land away from each other.

Sad 😢 I know… but it would be the only possible explanation for every pony in the whole land of equestria. 🥺


Did you ever notice Pipp’s wings are unusual compared to the other ponies?


Wouldn't they still live for a long time without their alicorn magic though? When Luna, Celestia, and Cadence all gave up their alicorn magic in season 4 episode 26.. they put it all in Twilight.. if that was a permanent thing would twilight have lived as long as Celestia and Luna would? Would Celestia and Luna die sooner? Also Cadence didn't lose her horn and/or wings.. even though she was not born a princess and made a princess like Twilight was. Her alicorn traits didn't leave. Only the magic. And all of their cutie marks disappeared. So if Twilight had to make the crystals with her alicorn magic then it wouldn't NOT make her an alicorn it would just take away the alicorn magic from within her. Including her cutie mark which is what makes her, her. So if something bad did happen to the world then she would not be able to stop it anymore because her magic is gone. And her purpose in life is gone because of the cutie mark leaving as well.. I don't understand why she would give up her cutie mark and all of the power that can save Equestria if something bad happened, due to such a simple issue as what you have stated. In the long run it would not be a great decision on her part as the ruler. I do however, understand her wanting to make sure that a long-term solution such as artifacts can work if something were to happen to the other types of magic buuuut... it doesn't help her to prevent anything that could happen before such artifacts are ever needed.. if she were to make that decision, and your theory is valid, then that would mean it would have to be her last resort. And I do mean absolute LAST resort... If this is true that I'm eager to find out what in the heck happened that was SO BIG that the princess of magic and friendship couldn't even stop...


If Equestria lost its magic, Twilight would lose her alicorn magic anyway. With or without placing her magic in the crystals she would have become unmagical and very mortal in the end.


I think your right but I think she put not just hers but all magic in the artifacts because sunny Is not the only one who got magic everyone did and I don't think twilights magic alone was enough to power the whole world


It’s so sad of what I heard but I’m glad of what she did


Mano esse vídeo é muito incrível e muito legal


1 ) I have a question for you , in the new generation movie in mlp,
The Queen , or Zipp and Pipp ‘s mother,(I don’t know her name)
How is she right to be queen she isnt Alicorn  either,
And there is no connection to twilight with her.
Is she the replacement for twilight and one more question.
 2) Didn’t flurry heart be the new ruler of equestria? Where is she?
She should’ve known about this or did she also pass away because she wasn’t given an age spell?And wouldn’t have flurry heart and the Crystal empire also have been effected?


I sort of came to that same conclusion.. twilight sacrificing herself for the greater good. I wanted to believe that she was the crystals..


The question still stands, who are what was it that caused Magic to disappear from Equestria to the point that Twilight had to sacrifice herself?

I can only think of one answer:

Grogar

The question still stands, who are what was it that caused Magic to disappear from Equestria to the point that Twilight had to sacrifice herself?

I can only think of one answer:

*Grogar*

Grogar would've been too weak to go against Twilight.


If that's what happened to Twilight, and we know Princess Celestia and Princess Luna stepped down from the throne and retired to Silver Shoals, what happened to Princess Cadence, Flurryheart, and Shining Armor?


what if there was already a war and twilight used her magic to make the crystals so if the ponies fought each other again it would take away her magic so she sacrificed her magic for peace.


About what happened to Twilight. Maybe when the pony races lost their magic Twilight also lost hers ans her immortality. But was still an alicorn.


Wait... without alicorn magic , how the heck did the sun and moon still keep moving ?! maby Twilight is still around or there is something that controls the sun and moon.


It makes sense. When we see Izzy and the unicorn next to her we see their magic be purple......just like twilights. It could be then possessing her magic

Twilight's magic is magenta not purple, lol


She gave up her power, the relics can store her power so one day somepony could find them and become a alicorn again and no dought this may have killed herself or made herself really old, maybe the worlds magic will return one day


Wait. But when Celestia and Luna lost their Magic they were still alicorns. If Twilight lost her Magic from making the crystals wouldn't she still be an alicorn?


Maybe Twilight went into some kind of existential crisis after the deaths of all her friends and holed up in a palace under the sea or something.


it also explains how none of the new generation knew what an alicorn was


I believe the magic is the only rite of keeping the winnebagos away. If any of you remember, when the ponies get divided, the winnebagos come to cause a perpetual winter. With that said, and G4 having taken place in the same universe... maybe that's the only reason the winnebagos aren't there in the G5 movie.


I have a theory. The movie My Little Pony: A new generation, when the crystals combine it does not work. And if you watch the movie till the end you see that there is picture broken then all earth pony, unicorn and pegasus put the broken picture back together. Then Sunny turn to an alicorn, i think Twilight is still an alicorn. That is my theory.