"Rocks take on different properties when interacting with magic. With the right stone, you could rule all of Equestria if you wanted to." — Maud Pie

Iooo0po it qweettteuiouuut you t you yyy6h

HeLLo CEleStIa I nEEd tO hAve yOur aLicOrn mAgGic NoW

@꧁Nexsus Animates꧂ Yes and I have before but I don’t want to talk about that

Hello your majesty. Do you perhaps need an assistant or a manager, if so then I'm the one to call

You always look so beautiful princess celestia

CELISTIA!! can i become a moon princess :) (jk)

@LizzyU_U I was just pretending. FOR GOODNESS SAKE DODOS AREN'T DUMB! Stop insulting them human head

@Kamran Aimal I know I'm just pretending

@Sonia Shanker THATS NOT THE REAL CELESTIA DODO HEAD

@LizzyU_UThat doesn't even make sense. What kind of English did you learn? Wait,did you mention"Eid" and"Ramadan"?*<b>Gasp*</b> are you a Muslim?

@LizzyU_UThat doesn't even make sense. What kind of English did you learn? Wait,did you mention"Eid" and"Ramadan"?**Gasp** are you a Muslim?

That’s why I am so glad that rock experts like Maud are rare and not evil. And I guess that after retirement Princess Celestia started watching theory videos about Equestria.

Hiiiiiiiiiiii Princess Celestia, I seen you some of Sawtooth's videos before🤗

PRINCESS OF BANANA CAKE ON DAH SUN!!!!!!

@LizzyU_U what-?

I can't understand

Your too smart for my own good

@LizzyU_U what-?

I can't understand

*Your too smart for my own good*

@TheHamster_ Stuck in a muffin ummmmmmmmmmmmmmmm and the other one is a little too small to call me when you have a problem in the crystaling in the crystaling in the crystaling in the crystaling and I think you are the only person to be friends who are not in your family for the first time in the past and have been in the same like that for years EID that the most 1AM of Ramadan 1PM is going back 22PM to be not in the game and I

Princess Celestia are you my little pony Celestia

CELESTIA :O

I am honoured

even if I'm 3 years after

CELESTIA :O

*I am honoured*

even if I'm 3 years after

<b>your highness, Witness the great and powerful Trixe!</b>

*your highness, Witness the great and powerful Trixe!*

So, you mean to tell me that you FOUND A ROCK AND BECAME RULER OF EQUESTRIA BECAUSE OF IT?!

Are you really princess celestia from my little pony

@꧁Nexsus Animates꧂ yes, when will Celestia be daybreaker?

Princess Celestia <b>Me with a fake diamond I found buried in the sand of a playground</b> WeLl, I gUeSs I aM rUlEr Of EqUeStRiA

Princess Celestia *Me with a fake diamond I found buried in the sand of a playground* WeLl, I gUeSs I aM rUlEr Of EqUeStRiA

Celestia how did you become a princess!!!!!!!!!!!

Hello celestia. Will you ever be daybreaker?


I remember Maud saying "rocks take on different properties when interacting with magic. with the right stone, you can rule all of equestria if you wanted to" to starlight in rock solid friendship 😕


The puns started being funny for me when you said sedimental
No rocks and crystal are something completely different
Crystalheart=heart of a dragon
Alicorn amulet= enchanted
Elements of harmony=grown from pilers
3 gems=it's literally part of them
If rarity could sens magic then the 6 wouldn't have had so many problems
Dragons aren't the only creature that can eat rocks why do you think a rock farm exists and the pies eat rocks
The dogs I think they just look for gems to eat like dragons (not because of magic )


This video is a diamond. Just a shiny gem.

I’ve felt sedimental before, but this video rocked.

What do you think? Are my puns a jewel?

Or are they underground?

Okay I’ll stop now 💎

Looks like my puns are crystal hard to not laugh at. They seem to shine and cast an enchantment of humor.

Looks like I pass with flying colors too!

This video is a _diamond._ Just a _shiny gem._

I’ve felt _sedimental_ before, but this video _rocked._

What do you think? Are my puns a _jewel?_

Or are they _underground?_

Okay I’ll stop now 💎

Looks like my puns are _crystal hard_ to not laugh at. They seem to _shine_ and cast an _enchantment_ of humor.

Looks like I _pass with flying colors_ too!

This comment hit <b>rock bottom</b> on the joke scale

This comment hit *rock bottom* on the joke scale

WHY- 💎💎💎💎💎💎💎💎💎

WHY- 💎💎💎💎💎💎💎💎💎

wow those jokes are as powerful as the elements cuz its rlly deep *budumdum
I'm getting gud at this. its so hard to do puns like this as hard as a diamond *budumdum
wooo i can keep going but Im gonna stop and keep watching the vidd

And I can't think of anymore rock puns. I've hit <i>rock bottom</i> ;-;

And I can't think of anymore rock puns. I've hit _rock bottom_ ;-;

@Trixie Lulamoon Lol, trixie. "great and powerful" 🤣

@Artsy Abby I’m reporting you. I am an adult and you replying like that to a child is TOTALLY unacceptable. If you target audience young people then you have no business responding to anyone in that manner. Clearly you are not mature enough for this platform.

😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂😱😨😨😨😨😨*Littiraly* cant breath

😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂😱😨😨😨😨😨*Littiraly* *cant* *breath*

@Trixie Lulamoon wooow trixie lulamoon how dare you self promote yourself

<b>go on,your puns are great and powerful</b>

*go on,your puns are great and powerful*

Your going to be a sans too anddddd keep going there good


Me: <b>spike eats gems, why doesn’t he just eat the crystal heart? Or the elements?</b>

Me: *spike eats gems, why doesn’t he just eat the crystal heart? Or the elements?*

@MaryAlice’s Awesome vids amber(the dragon lord) is shown to be eating the gems/crystals that is apart of twilight’s castle showing that spike can eat twilight’s castle or the whole crystal empire

he probably understands the importance of it?

Cuz all stupids have some sense😂😂😂
just joking

Cuz all stupids have some sense😂😂😂
*just joking*

Umm so Why have I seen your comment 3 TIMES?!

@o well they don’t really NEED the Elements, after all their friendship is harmony enough, plus they are imbedded into a crown and necklaces which would probably be hard to get them out

@Evan Wu don't you mean the CRYSTAL Empire?

Lol so he would have to spin around and around and eat the gem for the crystaling

@°•Cloudiival•° yeah, cuz since he'll have the power of the Crystal Heart, he'll have to do the job of the Crystal Heart instead.

@o they <b>have</b> said in the show that they don't actually need the elements, as long as their friendship stays. But if Spike ate the crystal heart, he would probably have to stay in the crystal empire

@o they *have* said in the show that they don't actually need the elements, as long as their friendship stays. But if Spike ate the crystal heart, he would probably have to stay in the crystal empire

@Rusimi Emy Ma all gems are hard to bite.

Because is hard to bite it like a rock…? 😅 😅😅

The ponies would kill him if he did that <br>It would be funny though 😄😄😄

The ponies would kill him if he did that
It would be funny though 😄😄😄

@MaryAlice’s Awesome vids all gems have magic

Because those are magical and he couldn’t eat them

@NAYYARA CHOUDHARY spikes nice he wouldnt eat somthing his friends need . but if he turns into a full grown dragon we should keep him away from the crystal empire

@NAYYARA CHOUDHARY we must keep all dragons away from that Empire

Because that'd be stupid because he's friends with ponies who need said gems.


I think that the elements of Harmony get their power by the magic of friendship. And when that friendship grows they get more powerful.


Does anyone else think those sound effects when he made those first two jokes were hilarious 😂


I think I have a theory to the episode when spike got his wings! Each Dragon has a different limit to how much they eat gems,which is the reason why they have those gem things on their scales when they start to grow their wings!


Underground gems being perfectly polished and cut is truly magical


I agree with you saw tooth, as shown in the Equestria girls series, the element of harmony was not affected by the mirror but creatures are, also the dazzling still have magic, but then again, the memory stone and time loop device are stones and contraptions, but maybe the have a gem in them.🤗


Natural/miscellaneous gems and crystals have never been depicted as having inherent magic. I think gems and crystals are just excellent at soaking up and storing energy.


I agree with this theory. I think that gems are like containers for magic, only if they hold the same kind of magic that it was previously filled with. The crystal heart is a container for love, no other magic can enter it. The Elements Of Harmony can only hold the requested kind of magic, like this. The Element Of Magic can only hold good and pure magic, The Element Of kindness can only hold pure kindness. so on, so forth. The alicorn amulet can only hold the most powerful magic. The rest of these gems can hold tiny amounts of leftover magic until the right kind of pony fills it in. Kinda like the devise sci twilight holds and releases in the third movie.

Dragons are driven towards big amounts of magic, and can only feed off of the gems that have the medium amount. Unlike spike, Dragons that we have seen could care less for pony kind and could care more about themselves. If a dragon was crazy and powerful enough, it could try to take the elements of harmony, the crystal heart or any other powerful gem that ponies need. Spike, however, can feed off of the crystals with the smallest amount of magic, too much can make a dragon go crazy.

If starlight and sunset wanted too, they could take two gems and fill it with their magic and make the two new elements. Sunset would use a reddish gem to make the Element Of Forgiveness. Starlight would take a lavender gem to make The Element Of Learning (?). If Celestia and Luna wanted to, they would put their magic in gems to make the power of day and night endless. I feel like a gem can be an heirloom of power to the next pony in line.


Y'know, gems are considered to be magical in a ton of things, not just MLP. In a lot of medevil games and such, like, dungeons and dragons and such, they are seen to be an item of enchanting ability, or something


We are the Crystal Gems! We'll always save the day and if you think we can't, we'll always find a way. That's why the ponies of this world believe in: Cadance, Luna, Twilight and Celestia!
I know it's not in great order but Cadance is the love princess while Garnet is made out love.
Luna was Amethyst because...Well...She's very emotional about her backstory?
Twilight and Pearl should be obvious. If not, watch maybe one episode of Steven Universe.
Celestia...I dunno..Because she was the last option I guess...

+Ruby Red Rain 😲😆😆😆 one hour later... How can crystal gems can we just like those gems in my little pony like a ruby get it get it oh come on😂😂😂😅😅😅😆😆😆😅😅😅😄😄😅😆😆😆😅😅😅😄😄😅😆😆😆😅😅😄😅😅😅😆😅😄😄😄😄😅😅😅😅😆😆😆😆😨😰😂😂😂😊

@Kirsty Frazer I think you mean Sapphire, and if Celestia was Sapphire, who would be the Ruby? There are only four Alicorns.

Celestia is Ruby because Ruby's are very posh and diamondy comparing to her wings.

Loved it, but maybe they are the Crystal Ponies, see, cause their ponies??

+Sparrow Gaming  <b>claps for the wonderful Steven Universe song that's MLP verson</b>

+Sparrow Gaming  *claps for the wonderful Steven Universe song that's MLP verson*

Yeah but Jack, remember that Celestia is a lot happier than Luna. Luna is just coming over her past. Watch 'Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep?' . In almost every episode that we  see her (Underline almost) she's cheerful.

Your name do you live in Montgomery to ?? I live in tanamear sorry I'm bad at spelling names ??


You really explained your reasoning, so that made everything crystal clear  😂😂😂 Ok I know that if I’m going to make a pun, I should be a bit bolder about it... but no kidding. This video was really..........gneiss. A solid job. I wouldn’t be surprised if your headcannon was real; you had some concrete evidence. No pressure!


From this video, I suddenly had the question as to why spike was never even TEMPTED to eat the elements of harmony. Like even if he didn't try, you'd think he'd be tempted.


So, I'm gonna leave my own kinda-theory on here, if you don't mind.

Your theory about gems being used as a natural conduit is not at all bad, but I wouldn't really say it could be COMPLETE either. It's possible that that is one way gems are used, but for the more powerful gems, I think that there could be another explanation. Or at least, for some of the powerful gems.

This is going to be a bit of text, but bear with me, please. All will hopefully make sense in the end.

First, I'm going to explain about Magic. There are a lot of Anime that have something similar where magic, ki, chi, or whatever, some form of energy, is used, many times through a conduit. Whether it be through an object, like a weapon, a staff, or some other random bit, or if it's used using your body as a conduit for this energy to be accessed. There are just as many where the energy is produced from the person in question. So then, I'm thinking in general that there are two types of energy and 2 ways of using it. Either it comes from the person or the land, and its used through the person or through an object. There are 2 different anime that I'm thinking of to explain this: Naruto and Fairy Tail.

(If you already know how the energy works in these Anime, you can skip down to where I leave a line of these > * < which is where I'll explain further)

First is Fairy Tail, where they use magic. Magic in this world is a bit different. It isn't produced by the body, but is instead absorbed in from the land. It can then be used through one of two means: Holder Magic which uses an item to channel magic through to get a result, and Caster Magic which just uses your body to throw out the magic in  whatever wacky form your heart desires.

Next, in Naruto, there are 2 distinct forms of energy: Chakra from the body and Natural Energy from the Land. Chakra is produced by people naturally and regenerates over time, but if you use all that you have then you die. Think of it as your Life Energy. Chakra is used to do all sorts of superhuman acts, too many to number really, but it includes walking on walls and water, healing, and throwing around various elements. (stuff like fire, wind, lightning, earth, and water. Not wood, though certain bloodlines can, but I'm NOT getting into THAT  mess.) It can be used straight from the body, or it can be used in some sort of medium.
Natural Energy is produced by basically anything not human. It's the energy of the earth itself, separate and distinct from Chakra, which is unique from user to user, Natural Energy is pretty much the same no matter where you go in the world. Using Natural Energy is dangerous for people because instead of letting you guide it, it tries to turn you into part of it, aka. it tries to turn you into stone. A part of the earth. It is possible, but only through severe training or through using a medium.
(I'm gonna come back to this anime once I finish my explanation)

******************************************************

Both of these have very different ways of using the energy in these worlds, but both are necessary for my explanation. For kind of different reasons, but now I'm actually going into explaining something about crystals.

First up, Fairy Tail has objects called Lacrima. Lacrima are basically like magic crystals that can do many different things, and take the place of most modern day common electronics. Things like lighting, communication, movies and pictures, there's even a deodorant lacrima. They are different from regular crystals and gems because they are magically infused items. (or magically created. Either one.) Now it could be that Lacrima are crystals that kept absorbing magic until you get the result seen. But it could also be true that they are a separate substance entirely, being created from something created from magic alone.

Which is where Naruto ties into this. In Naruto (as far as I'm aware) the density of Chakra basically goes like so: invisibility, visibility, solidified, crystallized. It is used intangibly, it is used inside the visible spectrum, it is used in a solidified but still permeable manner, and it is turned into crystal from the sheer density of it. Crystallizing Chakra would take probably more Chakra than the average ninja (who produce probably 20 times the amount of an untrained civilian at the minimum) would produce in their lifetime. Solidifying Chakra is extremely intensive, with most ninja incapable of both producing and controlling the amount needed. The best example I can think of would be the Rasengan, which is a ball of Chakra pack together into a ball and then sent spinning to produce damage. Producing Chakra visibly is very easy for a trained ninja, difficult for one in training, and impossible for an untrained civilian. And using Chakra invisibly comes pretty much naturally from doing day to day labor. ex: enhancing muscles during exercise.

Okay, are you ready for this? Cause here is where I'm going to explain my theory.

I think that the more powerful gems aren't crystals infused with a lot of magic, but rather magic so dense and powerful that it solidified into a crystal.

Or rather, I think that some of the more powerful ones are. Crystals like the crystal heart in the Crystal Empire (wow, way too many crystals) are obviously crystals that were infused with the Power of Love and Friendship™ as was shown when they had to remake the heart, but the Elements of Harmony? I think that those were made from magic that was so powerful and in such concentration that it solidified into an object.

I also think that the reason there are so many gems in the pony world is because of the concentration of magic in the land. It's pretty much confirmed that the reason the Everfree Forest is so dangerous is because the magic there is different from the rest of the world. So it's already canon that magic has an affect on the planet. What's not to say that magic results in the encouraged growth of gems? According to your theory, gems are like natural magic conduits. So what if it's because the magic encouraged gems to grow from the earth and were infused with them as a result?

(P.S. Sorry this was so long. I didn't actually expect background explanations to take up that much room, but then I kept thinking of other things I should explain, and then simplifying to make it easier to understand. But it was kind of fun thinking it out.)

So, I'm gonna leave my own kinda-theory on here, if you don't mind.

Your theory about gems being used as a natural conduit is not at all bad, but I wouldn't really say it could be COMPLETE either. It's possible that that is one way gems are used, but for the more powerful gems, I think that there could be another explanation. Or at least, for some of the powerful gems.

This is going to be a bit of text, but bear with me, please. All will hopefully make sense in the end.

First, I'm going to explain about Magic. There are a lot of Anime that have something similar where magic, ki, chi, or whatever, some form of energy, is used, many times through a conduit. Whether it be through an object, like a weapon, a staff, or some other random bit, or if it's used using your body as a conduit for this energy to be accessed. There are just as many where the energy is produced from the person in question. So then, I'm thinking in general that there are two types of energy and 2 ways of using it. Either it comes from the person or the land, and its used through the person or through an object. There are 2 different anime that I'm thinking of to explain this: Naruto and Fairy Tail.

(If you already know how the energy works in these Anime, you can skip down to where I leave a line of these > *** < which is where I'll explain further)

First is Fairy Tail, where they use magic. Magic in this world is a bit different. It isn't produced by the body, but is instead absorbed in from the land. It can then be used through one of two means: Holder Magic which uses an item to channel magic through to get a result, and Caster Magic which just uses your body to throw out the magic in  whatever wacky form your heart desires.

Next, in Naruto, there are 2 distinct forms of energy: Chakra from the body and Natural Energy from the Land. Chakra is produced by people naturally and regenerates over time, but if you use all that you have then you die. Think of it as your Life Energy. Chakra is used to do all sorts of superhuman acts, too many to number really, but it includes walking on walls and water, healing, and throwing around various elements. (stuff like fire, wind, lightning, earth, and water. Not wood, though certain bloodlines can, but I'm NOT getting into THAT  mess.) It can be used straight from the body, or it can be used in some sort of medium.
Natural Energy is produced by basically anything not human. It's the energy of the earth itself, separate and distinct from Chakra, which is unique from user to user, Natural Energy is pretty much the same no matter where you go in the world. Using Natural Energy is dangerous for people because instead of letting you guide it, it tries to turn you into part of it, aka. it tries to turn you into stone. A part of the earth. It is possible, but only through severe training or through using a medium.
(I'm gonna come back to this anime once I finish my explanation)

********************************************************

Both of these have very different ways of using the energy in these worlds, but both are necessary for my explanation. For kind of different reasons, but now I'm actually going into explaining something about crystals.

First up, Fairy Tail has objects called Lacrima. Lacrima are basically like magic crystals that can do many different things, and take the place of most modern day common electronics. Things like lighting, communication, movies and pictures, there's even a deodorant lacrima. They are different from regular crystals and gems because they are magically infused items. (or magically created. Either one.) Now it could be that Lacrima are crystals that kept absorbing magic until you get the result seen. But it could also be true that they are a separate substance entirely, being created from something created from magic alone.

Which is where Naruto ties into this. In Naruto (as far as I'm aware) the density of Chakra basically goes like so: invisibility, visibility, solidified, crystallized. It is used intangibly, it is used inside the visible spectrum, it is used in a solidified but still permeable manner, and it is turned into crystal from the sheer density of it. Crystallizing Chakra would take probably more Chakra than the average ninja (who produce probably 20 times the amount of an untrained civilian at the minimum) would produce in their lifetime. Solidifying Chakra is extremely intensive, with most ninja incapable of both producing and controlling the amount needed. The best example I can think of would be the Rasengan, which is a ball of Chakra pack together into a ball and then sent spinning to produce damage. Producing Chakra visibly is very easy for a trained ninja, difficult for one in training, and impossible for an untrained civilian. And using Chakra invisibly comes pretty much naturally from doing day to day labor. ex: enhancing muscles during exercise.

Okay, are you ready for this? Cause here is where I'm going to explain my theory.

I think that the more powerful gems aren't crystals infused with a lot of magic, but rather magic so dense and powerful that it solidified into a crystal.

Or rather, I think that some of the more powerful ones are. Crystals like the crystal heart in the Crystal Empire (wow, way too many crystals) are obviously crystals that were infused with the Power of Love and Friendship™ as was shown when they had to remake the heart, but the Elements of Harmony? I think that those were made from magic that was so powerful and in such concentration that it solidified into an object.

I also think that the reason there are so many gems in the pony world is because of the concentration of magic in the land. It's pretty much confirmed that the reason the Everfree Forest is so dangerous is because the magic there is different from the rest of the world. So it's already canon that magic has an affect on the planet. What's not to say that magic results in the encouraged growth of gems? According to your theory, gems are like natural magic conduits. So what if it's because the magic encouraged gems to grow from the earth and were infused with them as a result?

(P.S. Sorry this was so long. I didn't actually expect background explanations to take up that much room, but then I kept thinking of other things I should explain, and then simplifying to make it easier to understand. But it was kind of fun thinking it out.)


I have a good theory. Since gems are like a  container that store magic like you said, the diamond dogs like gems because they have magic! That's probably also why Sombra loves crystals. So any creature that likes gems or crystals just wants more magic. Most of them. But I'm not saying that Dragons are evil and is gonna take over the world or anything. Dragons just maybe like gems because they are shiny and well, pretty. And we all know that dragons are greedy and like stuff and gems are pretty so that's maybe why they like gems so much. Do you agree? Do you disagree? Let me know. And also Happy very very very very very very very very, ok you get the point, -very late new years! Or not really late because new years was just 6 months ago.


Jems and crystals (and so on) can focus , convert and strain energy(difrent kinds, mabe even magic energy:P). Common example : rubins used in laser . Also they can keep informations . And did u heard about Crystal scul ? Real one , not from Indiana Jones. O_o


extraordinary Theory I completely agree also perhaps the magical abilities of the gems not only benefit the Dragons by increasing their magic but giving them more maturity not just the greed but mostly it's the greed of gems so perhaps knowing that the magical abilities of gems would cause them to mature more quickly when in large amounts


One of my nicknames is a geological term

Mafic, which means containing iron or dark, such as basalt.


I think the diamond dogs know that all gems have a little bit of magic in them and they're trying to get that magic by eating gems. It would take a lot of gems to equal the magic of a pony or baby dragon though.


This idea actually does fit in with my theory. My theory is that Equestria's Sun and Moon work with the Tree of Harmony and possibly certain other "Nodes", passing energy back and forth like a sort of "Celestial Dynamo". It is possible that the large Crystal structures like the Crystal Empire and the Caves under Canterlot and even Twilight's Castle receive the energy and spread it out to form the magical field that pervades Equestria (Which is what Pegasai actually fly on) where it collects naturally inside of animals and gems.

@Jordan W well, i could, but for some reason one of the many safety programs that installed themselves dont wants me to search anything.

um.. try searching on google  for websites

@Jordan W do u know people who can make websites? i want it to be as easy as breathing. u write a story, upload the data and baam, people can download it and read it when they want.

@Jordan W well, i kind of tried to publish it, but u know, it didnt work. do u have any website wher Copy And Paste are accepted means of writing? i tried at fimfiction.net and fanfcition.net, but both dont work for me and both randomly close after a few minutes and run so slow on my laptop that i cant write anything.

oh ok,if you published your fanfiction,post a link.sounds intresting

@Jordan W putting a pony in trance and under a spell to make it absorb energy from vegetables and fruits in exchange of food. the pony gets in contact with a being normal ponies call magic and then connects with it in a way only alicorns and the bearers of harmony do normally. well, in Equestria. this is the standart in another country, so yeah. after the trance spell ends, which only happens when the connection is strong enought to break the spell from the inside, the pony knows the levitation and teleportation spell and can shoot energy bolts. a normal snake pony (the creators of this technique) has the magical power of a foal in Equestria (for example Sweetie Belle), which is why they created this techniquein the first place. but because my OC is a pony from Equestria, he has much more magical power than a snake pony, so, compared to other equestrians, he seems very powerful. but he can just makes better use of his power.

@Jordan W and with some special training, u can acess the raw neutral magic flowing around the world. btw, do u have skype?

@***** That makes sense!thats kinda the general idea of what i said.if you are born with the magic of the elements,you can use them

@Jordan W thats what i thought, too. well, sort of. at some level. ok, im not really sure how much my theory fits with what u said, so here is my theory:<br>the elements of harmony are some sort of magical focus points, which allow the user, as long as (s)he can access these focus points, to use the raw power of Equestria´s magical field. my theory goes even further, because in my fanfic, my OC can acess the raw magical field of equestria thanks to 2 years of 24/7 training. he really just trained this technique and was put under a spell so he absorbed the life force of vegetables and fruits around him so he dont needs to eat. it is the normal way snake ponies learn magic, who taught him this technique. they live in another country on the other side of the planet (dont ask how he got there, just go with it). this special way of spell casting allows him to use his spells faster, with less mana use and at a stronger level than a normal unicorn, but his magical abbilities are weakened by strong magical disturbences, like a force field spell. The Crystal Empire and Twilight´s castle dont count, because they are magical anchors and keep the magical field of Equestria working, and, in fact, power up his magic when he comes close. many people say he is OP, but when he is inside a force field, or close to one, or just close to the diamond fields (or whatever they are called), he cant use his spells and even gets a little bit clumsy.

@Jordan W thats what i thought, too. well, sort of. at some level. ok, im not really sure how much my theory fits with what u said, so here is my theory:
the elements of harmony are some sort of magical focus points, which allow the user, as long as (s)he can access these focus points, to use the raw power of Equestria´s magical field. my theory goes even further, because in my fanfic, my OC can acess the raw magical field of equestria thanks to 2 years of 24/7 training. he really just trained this technique and was put under a spell so he absorbed the life force of vegetables and fruits around him so he dont needs to eat. it is the normal way snake ponies learn magic, who taught him this technique. they live in another country on the other side of the planet (dont ask how he got there, just go with it). this special way of spell casting allows him to use his spells faster, with less mana use and at a stronger level than a normal unicorn, but his magical abbilities are weakened by strong magical disturbences, like a force field spell. The Crystal Empire and Twilight´s castle dont count, because they are magical anchors and keep the magical field of Equestria working, and, in fact, power up his magic when he comes close. many people say he is OP, but when he is inside a force field, or close to one, or just close to the diamond fields (or whatever they are called), he cant use his spells and even gets a little bit clumsy.

@The Brony Notion Another awesome theory, Brony Notion!

@The Brony Notion maybe the elements of harmony were just gems.except magic,the element of magic channels the energy of the other 5 elements and just stored them in rocks.tha t s how they can use the magic of friendshi o without the elements.the elements just channel and focus the magic

I like that! I hadn't taken Twilights castle into consideration! /)


In the episode with the gemdogs one of the gemdogs said they loved Shiney and sparkly things that's why they wanted rarity because of her shiny horn that and she's good at finding gems


In my AU, Alicorn Amulets were created by an Alicorn King to allow non-Alicorn rulers the power they may need to aid them.


My theory is that the diamond dogs want gems to gain power.Hear is what I mean:as you said,unicorns can store magic in gems,so I think the diamond dogs want to find magical gems to help there own specie.I think they are trying to find gems that contains magic to take over the kingdom.But,they are doing it for a reason.Maybe,they want to to gain power to help other diamond dogs.Because you don't see any other diamond dogs,so maybe they are getting extinct and these 3 diamond dogs want to collect magical gems to take over the kingdom to help other diamond dogs.So,I think that they are finding gems for a good reason.I hope you enjoyed reading this comment,and make sure to leave a like!


I have a theory about the elements of harmony(this might be long)...

It all starts when the pillars first plant the tree the tree soon grows gems though they just helped power the tree but then the tree one day decides to give a part of it's magic to the gems now the tree can't survive too long without them and combined with the pillars power they whould soon become the powerfull elements we know today and eventually the tree with the magic that it has left it will be able to look like twilight and talk and be alive then when sombra destroys the tree like the student six said: "the tree must have used the last of it's magic to tell us to come and make sure it doesn't get forgotten"(that's probably not what they said but idk so don't mind it) and when the student six build there tree house the tree is able to help itself and make a stronger and better tree house.


I just thought that, since the show's originally geared toward girls, jewels are magical because "diamonds are a girl's best friend". Makes some kind of sense, at least.

Demon's are a girl's best friend.

Powerwolf...

@Dobby The Houself I think she didn't mean diamonds. Diamonds is a type of gem, so maybe it was an example.

Undead Ladybug But, there are no are no diamonds in the series-


Gemstones are usually minerals (but sometimes rocks) to which we give more value and that jewelers can make into something attractive. And rocks are made up of all kinds of minerals, and there are thousands and thousands of different types of minerals.


My guess:
The gems act as containment, like with Trixie in Magic Duel, she had eminence power while wearing her amulet, holding the power until called apon by the unicorn wearing it
So they are not naturally magic, the gems must first be imbued with magic

So after the vid, we basically  have the same theory, oh well


Here’s my theory about the diamond dogs: they use the gems to pay their servants. I mean, who doesn’t want servants that do anything for you, and since there seem to be so many, they need a lot of gems to pay them. I mean, who doesn’t want gems 💎 Anyway, that’s my theory about the diamond dogs 😁🦄 Oh, and all the puns are funny 😁🦄


I think that , since dragons can breathe fire , the fire in their bodies can melt even the strongest gem, and if the diamond dogs eat gems too, they might have a really strong stomach and jaw.


You can bring that kind of logic into the real world as well because some cultures like Wiccans and that use crystals to help heal people there actually rituals and that you need to do to charge crystals as well yes you have to charge the Crystals using a light from a full moon you also have to clean them of all negative energy they've absorbed some naturally clean themselves


Why do I do this to myself?!
Lol, you make me re-think my life choices and My Little Pony.
Not that this has anything to do with this video- but, in Slice of Life, Bon-Bon admits to being a secret agent, but after failing her mission, she said Princess Celestia shut it down and told everyone to keep it a secret. So what else is she hiding?


I think the diamond dogs use the gems to pay their servants. I mean, who wouldn’t want servants doing everything they say? And who doesn’t want gems?


I think that the gems need to be carved in to a special shape in order to be magically capable.


I just want to say how much I appreciate all your videos and thanks so much for all your hard work

@The Brony Notion i loved your rock puns😆😹🐎

Thank you! That really means a lot to me :D


When you talked about the sirens I actually asked myself why they are teenage girls if Starswirl banished them before he was trapped in Limbo.

Also if there dragons why aren't they dogs


By the way can you make a video explaining why some episodes of the show treat gems as currency
Despite them being a fashion statement for rarity
And food for spike


Diamond dogs remind me of dwarves, gems are filled with natural magic or an earth based magic.


I don't know what's worse<br>The puns, or the fact that I find them genuinely hilarious

I don't know what's worse
The puns, or the fact that I find them genuinely hilarious


ANNOUNCEMENT: I'm not trying to start a theory war or in anyway discredit this video, I'm just stating my opinion, which is just that, an opinion. If you don't like that, then you don't have to read it. With that out of the way, here's my theory on Gems/Crystals in MLP.

In all honesty, I feel like Gems/Crystals in MLP function similarly to how they work in the Eragon series/Inheritance Cycle. Basically, they are able to hold magic for later use for larger spells. However, since there is so much natural magic in Equestria, gems constantly store said natural magic. The larger the gem, the more magic it can store. This is why the Crystal Heart is so important. It is (to my knowledge) the largest crystal we have seen in the series, meaning it can store the most magic. As such, when it absorbs the love (which is a form of magic, just like friendship and harmony) of the Crystal Empire, it creates such a positive influence on at least Equestria. It's also why the Elements need to be used together (usually by ponies who care about each other) to work properly. When the Elements bond to their Bearers, they absorb the Harmony Magic created by the bonds between the Bearers. Then, when they are used, they unleash the stored Harmony Magic on whatever they're trained on. However, when they are used against another Bearer, the resulting Disharmony between the Bearers (and by extension, the Elements) is also absorbed by the Elements. This causes them to 'break' until they bond to new Bearers. This whole theory is supported by (again) the Crystal Heart. If crystals work like that, then, like a battery, they slowly lose the magic they had stored. If there isn't a constant source of love, the Crystal Heart loses it's store of love magic. Without the love magic, there isn't really a large source of positive magic, and that changes the very balance of the magic in Equestria. There are some flaws in this theory, such as how the Alicorn Amulet still had such a large amount of negative magic stored that it was able to change Trixie the way it did, but I think it's at least good food for thought.


actually  a crystal is a piece of a homogeneous solid substance having a natural geometrically regular form with symmetrically arranged plane faces.


OK this is completly irrelevent but. So, when the sirens store "negative" energy all the people fight, I thought their negative energy was taken away? And the sirens have already been defeted in the pony world so they must know that good magic WILL overthrow bad. I know it seems a bit odd because of the colour of that energy and their transformation of the sirens but they've already got the bad magic in theм so it could've mixed??


I like your theory, but rarity’s gem finding spell is an actual spell because later in that same episode twilight explains that rarity taught her the spell once. So, it is unlikely that a unicorn’s horn can just “feel” the magic, I think there is spell for the horn to be able to do this, not naturally though.


What if some gems were more powerful them others because what if when the alicorns turned the elements of disharmony back into the elements of harmony their life forces just faded away and soaked into the ground and the gems and depending on how many life forces touched the gem and how strong each one was the gem turned more powerful.


You forgot the part where maud told starlight where to store the magic of a entire village


Perhaps the Diamond dogs were once regular dogs, and a magical crystal caused them to mutate into more mutant-like dogs and gave them more subsequent autonomy. Considering dogs in this world are not magical, it makes sense how some creatures by a few gems would look more off-putting and speak weirder than your average pony.


Magic makes them be cut perfectly
Maybe the tree of harmony did it
Either way, they rock


The elements of harmony thousand years ago
Kindness=yellow
Loyalty =red
Honesty=green
Genracity=purple
Laughter=blue
Elements of harmony after 41 thousand years ago
Kindness=light pink
Loyalty =red
Genracity=purple
Laughter =a whole new shade of blue
Even shapes are different(well the picture in the book,when tia uses them all are same shape)
WHY????


I'd imagine the diamond dogs are collecting gems because of money.  Being typical bandit archetype characters, I don't see any evidence in the show of the dogs using or possessing magic.


gems ARE considered rocks in MY OPINION . Because rocks can have sediments of LUSTER, this is what makes a rock or jewel glimmer.


You deserve every subscriber and view you get. Your theories are solid. (No pun intended) I really believe your theories could be possible. Keep up the good work with the theories dude. I am glad I stumbled upon your videos. It's really got me to think about the show and examine it more in depth. I'm a fellow brony and YOU are the one whose actually getting me more interested in the show. I'm honestly saying this to be honest and I'm not wanting the attention. But damn, you've got the best theories I've seen for the show. I really think your theories can inspire us all to think about what's going on in My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic. So keep up the good work Brony Notion.
P.S: If it's not too much of trouble, I'm not demanding, or wanting you to do this. I'm just asking if YOU would like to do this. Would you care for doing your Notion remixes on like say a Wednesday, and your theories on a Friday, and dear princess Celestia on a Friday? I would like to hear your thoughts on this idea.

Have a good one Brony Notion.

@Wesley McWilliams As a pegasister, I declair this small speech as interesting and worthy of this crown! ♔

He does deserve all his subs.<br>Some people get subs because they comment or like something that the other person likes.

He does deserve all his subs.
Some people get subs because they comment or like something that the other person likes.

Dang it. My autocorrect messed me up, I meant “Your theories on a Thursday.”


Just as an added point many people in our own history; including today - humans use crystals, gems, and stones as a way of channeling, activating, or storing metaphysical or magickal energies with certain types of stones having certain natural magickal properties. This theory as good grounding in our own world.

Concerning why I spelt magick the way I did: modern witches and Wiccans spell it this way to seperate it from actors like Harry Houdini preforming illusions on a stage to entertain people.


I study gemstones that are in our world. Tho not like the ones in MLP they do hold special magical properties. Especially when combined with intentions. Ones like amethyst are good to prevent drunkenness. They are truly something special.

And hey even if they didnt have magic we can still protect ourselves with them... you just need enough force and the right spot and it can k!ll someone


Yo creo que tirek podría ser un gran guardian de el castillo de tuailaist


U say u can't eat a sapphire cupcake...but what about rockcandy?

K just imagined spike eating all of the important crystals including the crystal empire

@The Brony Notion but Pinkie Pie says her sister Maud’s secret recipe for rock candy is real rocks

Terius Bakuim Harnord Junske yes, of course

Terius Bakuim Harnord Junske yes, of course

you see rockcaerndey in one video of mlp

you see rockcaerndey in one video of mlp

@The Brony Notion ,  @Amber Moon , @Princess Twilight Sparkle , @nerdy waffle , @DuDeofASG , @Ellie Wright , @sushi , @catlover991188 Mswolfy81 , @Mizuko NoNeko , @Cyber Dash , @violet rose , @James Otis , @TheReplayArchive , @Autum Breeze , @Daniel Figueroa , @Shannon Mumford , @Veronika Lowe and @Bunny <b>DO YOU RECOGNIZE STORY CLASSIC SPYRO AND THE LEGEND OF SPYRO ?</b>

@The Brony Notion ,  @Amber Moon , @Princess Twilight Sparkle , @nerdy waffle , @DuDeofASG , @Ellie Wright , @sushi , @catlover991188 Mswolfy81 , @Mizuko NoNeko , @Cyber Dash , @violet rose , @James Otis , @TheReplayArchive , @Autum Breeze , @Daniel Figueroa , @Shannon Mumford , @Veronika Lowe and @Bunny *DO YOU RECOGNIZE STORY CLASSIC SPYRO AND THE LEGEND OF SPYRO ?*

>_< THIS IS FLUTTER SHY WHEN CAMERAS ARE FLASHING AT HER

	:D THIS IS PINKIE PIE YUM I LOVE CHOCOLATE PIES

0_0 emmmm......when you do ALL THE BORING TALKING I LOSES INTEREST  HALF-WAY  THROUGH

MY QUESTIONS :
1.What about chaos emeraldS from sonic franchise ? DO YOU THINK THESE ARE MAGICAL GEMS OR ENERGY GEMS ?
2. WHAT is different MAGIC and ENERGY ?
3. MAGIC VS ENERGY ?
4. WHAT is DIFFERENT POWER TO USED CHAOS EMERALDS AND ELEMENTS OF HARMONY FOR THESE GEMS ?
5. WHAT IS DIFFERENT FORM OF MAGIC and ENERGY ?
6. DO YOU know STORY CLASSIC SPYRO AND LEGEND OF SPYRO CHARACTERS ?

Amber Moon coolest joke ever LOL LOL LOL LOL

Amber Moon coolest joke ever LOL LOL LOL LOL

Emoji Queen yes there is it is found in the caves of Party planet located in Bakersfield CA the

Amber Moon  I think no such thing as a candy rock

The Brony Notion I can not find your new videos you need to tell me how pls I am huge fan

Golden diamond I bet you just came here for your note dude if you did the Bring Notion should have had enough<br>of people doing that

Golden diamond I bet you just came here for your note dude if you did the Bring Notion should have had enough
of people doing that

funny you should be to get to the new York and the other hand and the other hand and the other hand and the other hand and the

It a special candy recipie and the right amount of time to make it DELICIOUS

+Amber Moon EXACTLY that's what I keep thinking

It's a "special type of rock" that's what maud said anyway -_-

rock candy is technically Really hard candy...

i made this comment in may and people are still commenting...

+Sydney Hassell at times, i thought they hit rock bottom

The reactions to his puns were just stone cold

I know but rocks are ruby diamonds and jewels duh<br>

@Amber Moon yeah pinkie can mostly eat anything in mlp so I guess ponies can eat sapphire cupcakes.....and rock candys

@Cyber Dash well the rock candy necklaces looked like GEMS

@Noelle Williams  i cqan eat them although im a bat/changeling/alicorn pony

@Amber Moon Spike eats sapphire cupcakes

@Amber Moon Spike eats sapphire cupcakes

@Noelle Williams no, there was an episode there the ponies ate rock candy made of REAL ROCKS.

Lol BUT its is true but she doesnt the candy pon pinkies dress was diferant

I agree with that but than rarity would be putting candy on the cloths she made and that would be weird ( except the dress she made pinkie for the Galla)

@Noelle Williams I think they just hard like a rock

@Noelle Williams ponies would be able to eat rock candy.

@Amber Moon Yeah. But only Spike can eat them. . . :(

@The Brony Notion Rock candy hurts our teeth. . .

Good point, but that would be tasty, I think anypony could handle that

Rock candy is just sugar, which I'm sure ponies can handle ;)


You are right brony notion because if you watched season 9 the ending of the end you would see that twilight says "now i truly understand, the elements are just symbols, the real magic has always been right here" but thats not true. When they got their connection it was because of the rainbooom. Thank you everypony.


I think because each gem has a different ability and they may have fell off a magical artifact


I think I laughed a little,maybe gems naturally are magic less but it is something that is giving them their power


I  think that you should do a video on on pony naming habits. It seems that almost all of the main six have a name that matches their cutie mark, besides Pinkie Pie.  If this is true for most of the ponies then I think that it will be safe to assume what Apple Bloom, Scootaloo, and Sweetie Belle 's cutie marks will look like.

@Aiden Kelley so apple bloom woould be a florist, scootaloo would do something with scooters, and sweetie bell would be soft music (belle= bell)?


Saw 2 have you ever wondered how some of My Little Pony after the Elements of Harmony they are gems in Spike never went out after them you never try to eat them at all maybe he thought that the elements were important to the main six and well didn't eat them because he knew that they would need the elements who wants to eat them because well the tree no not now because the tree of Harmony was destroyed pumpkin Sombra how did he manage destroy the Elements of Harmony and the tree of Harmony to break them both from his new entry he broke the tree and then the elements fell to the ground shattering into pieces it's bad because all the question would be doomed if that happened it's the onions Works destroyed that King Sombra would never come back never again this is a really homecoming so by YouTube by myself actually looking for a YouTubers Channel called Hunter Carter future Metals called that hotel for one that's my picture and subscribe if you're wondering I know you're Changeling


I love your rock jokes I laughed so much


Gems are full of meaning, symbolism and magic. They have a lot to do with witchcraft.


I love the jokes! I passed! Yes and with flying colors too. Rim shot!


We are the crystal gems, we'll always save the day

<b>🎵And if you think we can't, we'll always find a way. That's why the people of this world believe in... Garnet,Amethyst, and Pearl.🎵 And Steven!!!!!!!!!</b>

*🎵And if you think we can't, we'll always find a way. That's why the people of this world believe in... Garnet,Amethyst, and Pearl.🎵 And Steven!!!!!!!!!*

Ik what it is.... but I can’t put my finger on it

I like shows references.Good one.I love the show too!!!

And if you think we well alawys find a way

BriarJay We are in the future, here we are in the future and it’s bright.

Ok, don’t get my fan girl side started 😳😖

@Pizza Bot epicness <b>Insert drum sound effect</b>

@Pizza Bot epicness *Insert drum sound effect*

We are the crystal gems
Well always save the day
And if you think we can’t
Well always find a way
That’s why the people
Of
This
World
Believe in
Garnet
Amethyst
And pearl
AND STEVEN!

theultimateusukfan <br>And if you think de can't, we'll allways find a way, that's why the people of this world... Believe in GARBET, AMATHYST, AND PEARL ¡AND STEVEN! 😂

theultimateusukfan
And if you think de can't, we'll allways find a way, that's why the people of this world... Believe in GARBET, AMATHYST, AND PEARL ¡AND STEVEN! 😂

not the same way as use different form power ! What is different magic and energy ?

So that's why the people of this world, believe in...


1:39 "Let's say some ancient unicorn cast some of his magic into a gem." Picture about Starswirl.
"We plant chrystal seeds with the essence of our powers" - Sommambula
This is how the elements (gems!) came to be!
You predicted it years before it was confirmed! I always loved your theorys, but just now, as the show ended I'm starting to see what a genius you are!


Theres one more theory. If gems run out will dragons too. Its like a food chain if the producer runs out so will the consumer right?


I think when a crystal has a pond with a creature it gives the pony power and abilities and the dogs don't have power so they want the jets for themselves.also why are those dogs different to apple jacks dog.


You mean my little pony equistria girls legend of everfree


the flying colors pun was actually pretty good


In mythology (not sure what mythology) dragons hoard jewels and gold because they think they give them power... is this another piece of evidence for your theory?


Gems are magic because they are shiny and glittery so hasbro said:"they are shiny and glittery and thats why we use them as a magical and dangerous weapon everypony can use"<br>That would be a reason

Gems are magic because they are shiny and glittery so hasbro said:"they are shiny and glittery and thats why we use them as a magical and dangerous weapon everypony can use"
That would be a reason


I feel like this is a perfect setup for a Steven Universe crossover.

Jacob Dauphinais What about energy power ?


Crystals have magical properties in the real world to and all are quite strong.


The joke was good and so are your videos. Man I love theme so much


"Do I look like an archeologist to you?"<br>No you look like a pony

"Do I look like an archeologist to you?"
No you look like a pony


I think the diamond dogs are just looking for something shiny. They arent exactly the smartest.


Gold isn't a gem, its a metal...

I'm gonna go and r/wooosh myself now.


What if magic was stored (or was originally magic) in a gem and spike ate one and he turned into a ginormous dragon


Just like the new gems in MLP:A New Generation. :)


Because they are awesome in the real world and other shows they are used as magical objects so why not?


I clap to your puns my friend. I clapped. As well as laughed .


Maybe all the gems and cristal were one big gem that contains lots of magic, then on a day it boom in to thousands of shards


Hold the phone and shut the freaking front door, I just got an idea for a head canon! Okay, so Brony Notion said that maybe a wizard from a long time ago cast his magic into a crystal and that crystal became magic, right? Well, what if he cast HIMSELF into the crystal like Sauron and the one ring?! That could mean that there are tons of cursed and possessed items in Equestria, like the Alicorn Amulet and the inspiration book from inspiration manifestation! They all hold the souls of ponies that were once the elements of disharmony and they were too powerful to be kept in a physical form! Ooohhhh, goosebumps!


I'm sick and the rock puns made my day thanks


An emerald with flaws is more valuable than a diamond without flaws


OMG you are on a roll with the puns!!!! Say that when you’re winning at a game involving rolling balls


Gems made from underground areas are made at the beach too like in seashells


When you started talking about the diamond dogs, I couldn't help myself but think "Hi, I'm Jessica"


"I passed!"
"Yes and with flying colors too."
Genius xD


Can you ever imagine spike eating the elements, the amulet or even the crystal heart? I mean he loves gems after all...


Blue gem name: sapphire
Green gem name: peridot and emerald
Red gem name: ruby
Orange gem name: citrine and garnet
Purple gem name: amethyst
Pink gem name: spinel and rose alabaster
Light blue gem name: aquamarine


what happens to dragons when they eat them. they dont seem to blast powers like unicorns even tho they eat gems containing power


Guys when we saw the sirens in their siren form the crystals are a part of them they just made it look like it was a necklace to avid attention


they're the (get ready for this) most rockinest jokes out there!


Later on in the sepiasons with maud and starlight, maud mentions rocks are magical when messed with magic or something like that and after starlight said huh? And maud smiled sort of which I think was part of the writers idea<br>I really dont remember but thats what i remember

Later on in the sepiasons with maud and starlight, maud mentions rocks are magical when messed with magic or something like that and after starlight said huh? And maud smiled sort of which I think was part of the writers idea
I really dont remember but thats what i remember


I loved those rock jokes I laughed so hard


Maybe they want the game for building basses for the film and dogs


In the episode when we saw what would happen if the mane 6 never stopped the villain’s King Sombra’s warriors have the amulet that Trixie used on their foreheads!


I think some unicorns and alicorns have a connection with gems


I think your reply to the silence was funnier than your puns😁😁😁😁


I laughed at all the puns..  I feel so ashamed..

I did not laugh at all and I fill ashamed cause everyone laughed but I do not get it

I laughed at how bad and was like bruh really

Don't be ashamed they were fun to me and if you found them funny to that's ok

I am in love with the puns!!! I just can't believe that you're so good at...LAUGHING!!! TwT I am sans in soul.


Good theory! Now I know that Halloween is a long way away but should I dress up as Maud? ~ Rockfeather


Love the puns . Amd the dog just want stuff that are pretty and shiny


You know what I believe you the gems and jewels in my little pony could be magical


If gems give dragons magic,perhaps dragons actually NEED magic to survive. I think the way dragons scales dont  burn when touching lava is magic and not having enough gems could lead to a "magic deficiency" , causing their scales to burn up. Maybe how they fly is magic too(when Tirek took the pegasy magic, they lost the ability to fly).Ponies and dragons might not be so different after all.


The diamond dogs are probably searching for a magical gem that can grant them powers or something.

I just think that they are searching for it cause they are pretty


But I guess some gems r so magical! Like elements of harmony like what other things u mentioned....... not so rare gems r normal like other things


MY QUESTIONS :
1.What about chaos emeraldS from sonic franchise ? DO YOU THINK THESE ARE MAGICAL GEMS OR ENERGY GEMS ?
2. WHAT is different MAGIC and ENERGY ?
3. MAGIC VS ENERGY ?
4. WHAT is DIFFERENT POWER TO USED CHAOS EMERALDS AND ELEMENTS OF HARMONY FOR THESE GEMS ?
5. WHAT IS DIFFERENT FORM OF MAGIC and ENERGY ?
6. DO YOU know STORY CLASSIC SPYRO AND LEGEND OF SPYRO CHARACTERS ?


I love your rock puns
Keep it up
You rocked
😄😄😄😄

I love your rock puns
Keep it up
You *rocked*
😄😄😄😄


The elements of harmony have magic because pony's  powerful have but magic in them


OMG the puns in this one....just...the puns :D

Did you actually look up the periodic table just to make that joke?

It's hard to come up with puns now.

It seems like all the good ones argon.

@TheLozzibele I hope that doesn't boulder you.

@TheLozzibele Well, it's sedimentary, my dear Watson.

I feel like you're taking my rock jokes for granite.

@Jack Montgomery Sorry about that... I was pretty stoned.

It was just SO GOOD!

Dwayne Johnson would've loved it!

(Keep reading until you get the pun!)

I agrees these puns were solid
They go so well with the theories which were
crystal clear

I agrees these puns were *solid*
They go so well with the theories which were
*crystal clear*

@Bugsyjr9000 I still love GT jokes though tbh.

@Thelooneyturtle What are you talking about?

I thought that these puns totally rocked!

@Thelooneyturtle What are you talking about?

I thought that these puns totally *rocked!*


Who else is wanting this and when the gems could store magic came up was shocked because it is right.


+The Brony Notion<br>they're minerals, which are considered a part of rocks.

+The Brony Notion
they're minerals, which are considered a part of rocks.


I think the dogs want to make something magic with the 💎


I'm disappointed Steven Universe was not referenced.

TirquTell Fennec The Brony Notion More like The CLOD Notion


i have question: in the ep 'maud pie' pinkie made rock candy how do they eat that? i mean they r also rocks but edible. if you have time plz answer my question


And a while later the elements of harmony break without magic coming out


I could use gems in my clothing to make magic outfits!


Yeah, rock puns are always taken for GRANITE. Do you see what I did there?


maybe the dogs look for gems as a defense,if ponies see them with somemany jewels,they might scared of the magic stored inside them.


I think the alicorn Amulet is a element of disharmony


Chrystals are technically gems which are rocks or minerals and I'm a geologist so I know


i think they have hundreds of safes around so they keep them there


I think that there were certain crystals that alicorns enchanted for certain reasons. I have no idea why spike eats normal crystals, but not the enchanted ones like the elements of harmony or the crystal heart!

+Black Diamonds well that is a good point even if people didn't let him eat them isn't it strange he wasn't at least dribbling when he walking thro the crystal empire?

Probably because nobody would let him because they are too magical and rare.


I just realized that the jewel in celestia’s necklace thing looks like rarity’s element


Green element of harmony? I hope you can explain it! I saw it.


Wow. Never thought I’d say this, but.. StEvEn UnIvErSe CoNfIRmiNEd


Yes gems are powerful because my mom is a witch and turned out one time I found a gem and Mom had her knee down in the gym was like faint and then the next when Mom got better it was gone so I think a jam is in my mother howling her Power Ranger Up


that's actually a good theory-for once-.


Those puns were so good, they should be set in stone


Wait in the picture of the old elements of harmony there’s a green element but when they transform to necklaces there no green element it is either in applejacks element or there’s another element we never seen


I think all the mlp gems have some magic in them just some have more magic and can be used.


that rock Joke was extra super Duper silly it made me laugh


tree of harmany is enchanted and the elements of harmany got there magic from it!


I think normal rocks give spike his magical fire


Can we take a moment of silence and remember that this was in 2015 FIVE YEARS AGO!


Why is it that every time I watch his videos then i wanna watch mlp


i think the gem dogs are looking for the elements of harmony or other powerfull gems etc....


''this theory's a gem. What? I think think that rocked!'' MASTAPICE


Some gems are made to be powerful so somepony like rarity enchanted them


the diamond dogs carve their furniture from gems (my opinion)


the elements of harmony were infused with magic by starswirl (very magical pony who died ) and there were others like the mane six, and Celestial was only a filly back then but then they became the princesses of The earth ponies then when she grew up she was the Princesses of canterlot😺

Starswirl is still alive if you didn’t know

+Serendipity Speaks       "thx 😝" I'll give you a https address and show you were I got it from.


But the answer lies in the fandom in a fandom.

Once upon a time, before Equestria, before the ponys, and before the world as we know it, a star grew prideful and was filled with greed. He attempted to drown out all other songs, but he failed and was killed. As he fell, he landed on a planet, killing all the inhabitants. Soon life began anew, and ponys, zebras, and many others repopulated the world. Only the crater from the star was left untouched untill a tribe of zebra built a city, and they learned the song of the fallen star. The screams then grew unbearable for many stars, untill one of the stars plunged down to destroy the darkness. Unfortunately, the star was consumed by this darkness, and only two fragments escaped, one to the sun, and the other to the moon. Then the dryed husk of the star scatterd across what would become Equestria. When the star fragments from the star came to the world, they removed many evils and started Equestria, unfortunately, the smaller fragment was twisted by the darkness and began the first great war of that world.

The fragments of shell would still have magic, and would become gems.


I think the dogs want the gems so that they can have powers because every pony and the dragons have powers but they don't so the want the gems to many get powers🙂


Am I the only one who laughed and his joke really slowly when I saw drinking my water? XP

Screams intentionally

Am I the only one who laughed and his joke really slowly when I saw drinking my water? XP

*Screams intentionally*


I laughted at all the puns they were so funny!


i don't think all gems are magical but they are shiny and it contains a lot of money 😊😊😊😊😊

@TastesLikeDonuts YT I had a stroke reading what you said

honestly we see them SOO much they're actually starting to seem common to me

drishti swami Swami  ARE YOU CRAZY I MEAN GEMS ARE BUTEIFULL BUT THAY ARE MAGIC sorry im half pinkie and half raimbow XD


Crystals aren't magical. They're just good batteries. Probably got the same minerals in them as a battery with zinc and stuff. And through a process we can never understand because we don't have magic over here, that stuff pools inside. Without needing any kind of acid stuff. Probably. I utterly love the idea of handling magical things in a really scientific way.

I think your "gems are just always a bit magical" is completely flawed. In all these examples the samples have already been contaminated. Ponies are magical by nature, they cast spells constantly in small amounts, of widescale during battles. Over the years I am sure that his magic doesn't just fade away. It spills into the ground. Into the gems. This is why I bet that Equestria is the only place with magic gems. That this makes Equestrian gems much more valuable. And this is why Diamond Dogs seek out specifically Equestrian gems to then sell onto foreign countries. Maybe to people like the Storm King.

Must say though, I never thought about the dragon food thing. Them eating the magic makes more sense than I could come up with for why rocks could be considered a snack.


Sawtooth: The sirens<br>Me: You mean the dazzlings?

Sawtooth: The sirens
Me: You mean the dazzlings?


The elements are enchanted by the Pilar’s aka  star swirl and his friends


about elements of harmony i think the elements are only enchanted stones or gems


I have a theory.  What if spike ate the elememts of Harmony?


GEMS ARE MAGICAL BECAUSE THEY FART OUT RAINBOWS AND MAGIC!! X3 SAY I IF U AGREE

No problem I'm just stating what's true!


I would say you’re first two jokes have hit rock bottom


Gems and gemstones are rocks they are just shinier and Vera to find then just regular rocks


Nice thoughts but i definitly dont eat gems cause they increase my magic ability i eat them cause they r tasty

Spike xx


Maybe the dogs don’t naturally have any magic so they need gems magic ,no matter how little it might be, to sub stain themselves


I think that the diamon dogs ,are -not similar to dragons ,Why

 Yes they like gems but they are also as filthy as dragons

Dragons breath fire
Diamon dogs dig
They both like gems but they have sources of different s

Why :diamond dogs are  bilders for gems(gem bilders)


Am i the only one who laugh at his rock puns


All of those rock jokes are cool and funny


What if gems are magical and spike eats them to make him a fire breathing Dragon without him realizing it?


The Brony Notion will soon become Sans...

- undertale didn’t exist back then know it does it’s very sad

>=) hihihi hehehe AHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA (yandere laugh) stabby! >=}

- slow clap i am sans too so its a metamorphic stage (get it cause the metamorphic rocks? The rock puns are killing me. End my suffering)

- *slow clap* i am sans too so its a *metamorphic* stage (get it cause the metamorphic rocks? The rock puns are killing me. End my suffering)

VeryVPlayz Don't pick a bone with him.

dum dum pum

VeryVPlayz Don't pick a bone with him.

*dum dum pum*

- yes, and then will I finally subscribe.

selanity whaaaaaaaat no way Undertale always existed, it just wasn't found yet! The time wasn't readyyyy!

Undertale wasnt even a thing when this was published ;-;


I giggle to his jokes......even the first one from the video.


I think starlight is the princess of 🌟 stars


Wow! These push you came up with are true GEMs <b>insert drum sound thingy</b>

Wow! These push you came up with are true GEMs *insert drum sound thingy*


Sawtooth: do i look like a biologist to you?

Me: yEs


Him: making it seem like NOBODY laughed at hes jokes
Me: laughing my butt off

Him: *making it seem like NOBODY laughed at hes jokes*
Me: *laughing my butt off*


"Do I look like a geologist, to you??

me: "yes, stone gray and and dirt brown mane."


9:13 That a good joke it rocked my dayXXXDDD


I hope that was your last joke because it was hilarious


Saw tooth waves i love all your videos but i want to see if you would here my suggestion what about the sirens from equestria movie like what would happen if the sirens were good they do have frienship but whats missing is them getting along


Season 8 all thos enchanted things some stronger than some gems and crystals so I don't think that they are that special but you got me thinking the shine so maby they can make the magic stronger I mean everyone knows the brighter a laser the more powerful so maby it helps the enchantment to be stronger


Maybe Gems are crystallized magic. I mean there's a reason why dragons love to eat them.


i have three question 1 how to be an alicorn member 2 how magical gems got power 3 is 3


0:24 Yep. Male, likes EDM, common interests, "Oh, come on". He's definitely secretly George Greener.


your "oh come on" face is what made me laugh not the pun XD


An inch away from laughing at his jokes!


i love gems i actually ended up stealing one from my friends :( he hates me


I am so happy that lots of people make puns


hEY! WAIT A SECOND! The crystal heart is in a movie that was made before mlp, sharkboy and lavagirl! (anyone know that movie?)


that reminds  me  of  the  crystal  gems from steven universe


What Equestria do without Magical gems, ha? 😉


Maud was happy until he corrected himself to gems


I'm sure the sapphires on the cupcake are made of sugar, my friend.


Well done. Well done. Puns are the best!


If there just looking for pretty and shiny stuff then that’s obviously why they took Rarity


Maybe the dogs use them to trade with ponies and other creatures who desire the gems


Notion: That ROCKed
Me: giggles
Notion: Oh come on!
Me: Am I mute again?

Notion: That ROCKed
Me: *giggles*
Notion: Oh come on!
Me: Am I mute again?


I liked his joke at the start of the video


Rarity you found destiny her horn was picking her to the gym so it's magical


Personally I thought the jokes were funny  😂 🤪


I think the dogs just are dumb ang looking for something pretty 😕


"The 3rd reason is... dragons. Imagine that." ( 2:43 )

Did... did you just tell me to Imagine Dragons?


There isn’t much to like when you live in a cave so what do you think they would like


If gems are magical rarity wouldn't have a problem finding them <br>In the apple orchard

If gems are magical rarity wouldn't have a problem finding them
In the apple orchard


So does the crystals powerup dragon fire breath????


That Sombra cameo

Not like you have that many quotes to chose from when it comes to the big bad crystal King of season three.
Though he's kind of dead now.
But still....
"Crryyyssstallsssss.."
Mwahhahaha Cough Cough
Sorry

That Sombra cameo

Not like you have that many quotes to chose from when it comes to the big bad crystal King of season three.
Though he's kind of dead now.
But still....
"Crryyyssstallsssss.."
Mwahhahaha *Cough Cough*
Sorry


gems are magical but what happen if a pony take all magic in it?


I love EMERALDS!!! <br>And I like MoonStones!!!

I love EMERALDS!!!
And I like MoonStones!!!


I dumbly search for things that are shiny and pretty! (Mostly on the floor...)


<b>SU fandom laughing in the background</b>


I think not all gem and cristal has magic but if you enchant them it will be magical and rerity  has macic so she can find gems and cristal easyly and i, m an big fan of yours thats all i can say bye.


Usually I actually laugh at really bad puns and jokes but I was low-key silent when watching this. I'm sorry


Am i the only one who laughed at the puns?


Dragons, imagine that :D

imagine dragons reference?


I stand by my point that u should have a cutie mark for making puns


Crystals are rocks I learned that from school!


Can you make a update of the concerning the episode "Rock solid friendship"


Oh my,  the puns!  You had Azilean of them. It may have gotten a Ryze out of some people, but nami. Annie one else approve of his puns? Or was he just digging his own Graves? I regret nothimg. I Garen-Tee it. #sorrynotsorry.
All that aside, your theory works very well for the land of Equestria. But what about the Tree of Harmony? I'm not sure if that was created. And, if the Two sisters planted it, did they fill it with magic? I sense a conundrum. Or more lore we need to know.

+Dawnstar ThunderClan Eeyup. I think that was the point.

I'd say it was before celestia and Luna and that the tree of harmony was like the jewels filled with magic and planted to protect the evergreen forest and the elements of harmony were placed there

@The Brony Notion yeah your's were awesome
#BroniesUnite

@Shadowstar_Darkpon3 I doubt they planted it, they used the gems to defeat Discord originally, this suggest (though admittedly not absolute) that they found them. It's also interesting that the tree resonates so much with the mane 6, perhaps the evil to equestrian has had more then just this 1st 1000 year cycle and thus the tree is massively ancient and helps each millennia's heros as much as needed to bring harmony.

Wasn't he on sale for 440 RP a while ago? Even then, you could always buy an rp card if you don't want to go online

@David Selimović Darn rich people.... I have 400 RP, and Kennen's taken me about a month. 500 IP left.

Hm...I'm not sure, I'm waiting for him to be on the RP Champ Sale

@David Selimović Sounds fun. Are you saving for that?

@***** <br>Meh,  all I know is that I want to try out Taric at some point

@*****
Meh,  all I know is that I want to try out Taric at some point

@David Selimović NOooooo. I made those puns with League character names because a spirit possesed me... I main Soraka, saving for Kennen.

@***** <br>Ever played League of Legends?

@Shadowstar_Darkpon3  Dang it! You beat me to 'em! But you missed the BEST possible one!<br>In any case, Gems? Gems are truly outrageous. They are truly, truly, truly outrageous.

@Shadowstar_Darkpon3  Dang it! You beat me to 'em! But you missed the BEST possible one!
In any case, Gems? Gems are truly outrageous. They are truly, truly, truly outrageous.

When looking at the tree of harmony it looks like a crystal tree... Living crystal that lives of magic and keeps balance in the world with a few helping hooves.

@The Brony Notion You can only sensibly chuckle at them if you play League of Legends. I was prepping for a pun-day, I felt it was nasus-ary (Yes, I went there) Also, there is no such thing as a bad pun, just more well-known ones. I regret nothing. Another video well done.

@The Brony Notion i like your jokes i though they where funny


I liked the puns! I hope my sister doesn't see this, or else she'll call me insane......


even here on earth all gems are magical, i can tell you as a witch that is a fact so why cant mlp jewels be too


Apparently rocks arnt funny
5020: What are rocks? We have levitating circles that are very hard!

*Apparently rocks arnt funny*
5020: What are rocks? We have levitating circles that are very hard!


Those were bootyful puns <b>clap clap clap</b>

Those were bootyful puns *clap clap clap*

@Bettie Tippett <b>head explodes 29.62 times</b>

@Bettie Tippett *head explodes 29.62 times*


Not me being 13 and still watching mlp 😩🤞‼


I am just smiling by looking mod pies face


AND, the crystals in mlp g5 too. The only thing with magic when the ponies have 0 magic


if the gems ARE stored with magic. why would they be able to give magic to the pony who holds the gem like Trixi for example she had the alicorn amulete and that gave her dark magic how did she use the magic. does it just flow though her body?. and can normal ponys and pegesur <b>can't spell don't judge</b> use the magic aswell?

if the gems ARE stored with magic. why would they be able to give magic to the pony who holds the gem like Trixi for example she had the alicorn amulete and that gave her dark magic how did she use the magic. does it just flow though her body?. and can normal ponys and pegesur *can't spell don't judge* use the magic aswell?


Gems are the moss Beautiful and powerful


1:29 Witness the evil but still great and powerful Trixie

1:29 *Witness the evil but still great and powerful Trixie*

<b>Way to go,Trixie. That was great. That was perfect. That was awesome.</b>

*Way to go,Trixie. That was great. That was perfect. That was awesome.*


Gotta say. Your puns ROCK. and this video is a JEWEL.


Me: <b>spike eats gems, why doesn’t he just eat the crystal heart? Or the elements?</b>

Me: *spike eats gems, why doesn’t he just eat the crystal heart? Or the elements?*


yes, actually, you do look like a geologist to me. Also a historian.


laughs at first two, but doesn't laugh at granite


@Yasmine Al-Dabbagh but what about evil dragons?


i like when you said that rock punn and the next one


Wait wait wait what about Celestia's  gem that is on top of her crone?


Wait could it be like Twilight was evil the whole time I mean sure she's a main character of course she couldn't be evil but look the main character is someone popular to be the main character but seriously no the Shopkins I like the Siri the Stars The Rock please everything even things are not hurt like Starlight glimmer Starlight glimmer sure Twilight Hood have wanted to protect her or she wanted to make everything work as she planned so Twilight cuz it's a little weird for someone to just come here and then and then buy on someone and watch them all time that's just so weird what kind of person


My BIGGEST question right now is “Can non-pony creatures use the alicorn amulet?”

Probably,all creatures have some kind of magic(some more than others).When wearing it, their magic would just be "enhanced".


Gems crystal and diamonds are made on Steven universe. Got rocked arent ya?


Just the sayings umm..Didn’t celestia cast a spell on a crystal and it made some weird shadowy thing..IS THAT MAGIC!?


This made me think of the book series Eragon, where those who use magic can store magical energy in gems until they need it.


1:29 after seeing red one, i think she from the human world. and even join force with evil. plz do video on her


<b>The Crystal Gems and Homeworld has entered the chat</b>

*The Crystal Gems and Homeworld has entered the chat*


not all gem are magical bc they won't be fun or rare then bc cause every one would have one so only some are magical

:D


OMG! WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THE CRYSTAL GEMS?! :D (Like if you get that joke)


Not a fan of ponies but love this setting


Ur Rock and gems jokes are... pretty funny to me


Nice puns! They are very Punny!
Do you like pizza? I think those conversation is about to get cheezy.
Do you like nuts? Because I'm about to get cracking at some puns.
I'll see myself out now.

Not bad yet over used puns.<br>All in all,Glitched Quill,3(.5 for mercy)/10

Not bad yet over used puns.
All in all,Glitched Quill,3(.5 for mercy)/10


As a baby I ate small rocks at the lake and just swallowed them whole


The elements of harmony we're made by star swirl but he didn't have a Enough magic too do so all of ponies from  heartwarminging eve in the. History part put the Magic in them of friendship


CRYSTAL GEMS CONFIRMED, WUUWUUUUUWUUUUUUWUUUWUU

jk


I liked when he said    buenos dias amigos in spanish


It’s of topic but Wait how did the elements change shape


wow he was really ROCKING those rock puns! AAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYY


Wow u start the vid by saing 'buenos Diaz' but for me its almost 'buenos noches' !


And the Tree of Harmony is made of crystal


can i ask a question why is the elements of harmony look like there cutemarks


Waittt what would happen if an alicorn/unicorn had put all their magic in a gem and a dragon ate it would they have the old magic what would happen???


XD I speak a little Spanish (jest saying)

I love how you just used Spanish and Japanese together XD


Why are gems magical? Because, they are the crystal gems!


Your videos are so good can you make a video of the new man 6ples


Simple, ask Rebecca sugar and her show and you have the answer for the question in the title! I just introduce you to an awesome show, you”re welcome.


Rarity loves gems rarity is six letters 6 divided by 3 is 2 the number 2 times 3 is 6 seem funny i thought so! Rarity has 4 feet rainbow dash also has 4 feet and 2 wings 6 divided by 3 is 2 rainbowdash is illuminati confirmed

Actually, that confirms Half-Life2:Episode3.


Maybe the gems that spike eats are rock candy


am I the only one who likes to go back and compare the theories with the cannoned idea/answers to the theories? and see if the theories would have been better or worse than the cannon ideas


Rocks are way different than crystals or gems. Gems and crystals are called minerals

I LOVE YOU. YOU ARE MY FAV CANNEL! 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😇😇😇😇😇😇😇

destiniee Gomez, My god he's not even a real pony

destiniee Gomez, My god he's not even a real pony

The Brony Notion Hey I think your puns rocked no really they were rock solid YouTube should not take you for granite your a rolling stone  Ok I'll stop now I guess I kinda did hit rock bottom

The Brony Notion is the best at being punny no pun intended

The Brony Notion you are the best ha ha ha

The Brony Notion you are the best ha ha ha

will princess celestia turn in to daybreaker wen shes mad?

I Thought Your Puns Were Really coal!

My Sister Says They ROCKED!

I Thought Your Puns Were Really *coal!*

My Sister Says They *ROCKED!*

The Brony Notion HELLO BRONY NOTION I HAVE A REGEST FOR A THEORY EVERYONE SAW IN MIRROR MAGIC WERE SUNSET MEETS STARLIGHT AND THE MAGICAL GIODES THAT THE MANE 7 HAS I SAY THERE DEFINITELY THAT WORLD'S ELEMENTS OF HARMONY BUT THERE'S 7 IN THE HUMAN WORLD BUT 6 IN EQUESTRIA SO MY THEORY IS, IS THERE A SEVENTH ELIMINATE AND IS STARLIGHT IS THE ONE TO WEELD IT IF YOU COMPAR STARLIGHT AND SUNSET THERE VARY SIMILAR WITH A VARY SIMILAR PAST AND SUNSET'S GIODE I CALLED THE ELEMENT OF FORGIVENESS AND STARLIGHT WHENT THRUE THE SAME THING AND THE TWONS PONYS FORGIVE HER AND SHE FORGIVE HER SELF AND OTHER'S QUOTE "THE GRATE AND POWERFUL TRIXY" SHE DIDN'T CARE ABOUT FOR PAST MISTAKES AND FORGIVE HER AND FORGIVE ME FOR THIS COMET IS LONG I SAY WHAT'S ON MY MINDE AND SOME MISS SPELLD WORDS IM DIXLEXIC BUT I JUST WONT YOU TO JUST THINK ABOUT IT, IT'S YOUR CHOICE.

P.S. IF YOU WONT CHECK OUT MY CHANIL I DO COMEDY VIDEOS AGAIN YOUR CHOICE.

The Brony Notion I thought those two jokes were funny. 😸😹😀😁😂

The Brony Notion it least I like your pun's

The Brony Notion it least I like your pun's

Marianne Rocks Can I may ask to you ? please ? I need discussion.

The Brony Notion MY QUESTIONS :
1.What about chaos emeraldS from sonic franchise ? DO YOU THINK THESE ARE MAGICAL GEMS OR ENERGY GEMS ?
2. WHAT is different MAGIC and ENERGY ?
3. MAGIC VS ENERGY ?
4. WHAT is DIFFERENT POWER TO USED CHAOS EMERALDS AND ELEMENTS OF HARMONY FOR THESE GEMS ?
5. WHAT IS DIFFERENT FORM OF MAGIC and ENERGY ?
6. DO YOU know STORY CLASSIC SPYRO AND LEGEND OF SPYRO CHARACTERS ?

The Brony Notion do more videos I probably got here late I hope I didn't join after your channel died

The Brony Notion i laughed at all your jokes.../:0

The Brony Notion i laughed at all your jokes.../:0

The Brony Notion your life is a great way of saying that it was the first half of the year and I love it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good time to go for it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good year old you yay for the next day I love it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good time to go back and I love it and it is a good time to go back and I have a great day

The Brony Notion great jokes😂😂😂😂😂😊😊😊😊😊😊☺😊☺😊☺☺☺😀😁😂😃😄😅😆😇😇😇😉😉😉😉😉😉😏😏😏

The Brony Notion Your so funny😆oh jems are known as rocks

The Brony Notion your videos are  my favorite. I am new to your channel. You also make me laugh. Nice rock puns 😂

The Brony Notion 🐷 ha ha ha ha jokes the best this is me 😂😂😂😂

The Brony Notion the jokes at the beginning was funny

The Brony Notion+ I literally laughed at your jokes. Even the ones that no one laughed at.

The Brony Notion can you do a thing how come alacorns were never born like that and how did they earned there wings

omg hi I'm derpy hooves and I want you to do a How Did Derpy's Eyes Get Crooked?

I get your jokes but I Gotta admit they were quite funny

Edit tell me what you want me to because you're freaking awesome I love you

Hey Brony I was wondering if you could do a theory video on dragon magic. Personally I don't think they have magic only a select few. But as you said I believe you when you say that gems are containers of magic and that some have some by defalut. I wrote a comment on your video Why doesn't Spike have Wings? video. I stated that I don't think dragons have magic. But now that I think about it I think your gem theory and my dragon theory are the same. Some have magic by defalut and others are <br>enchanted sometimes or gain it. I was wondering if you could do a video on the dragons magic theory. I would also like it if you could tell me your thoughts on my dragon magic theroy. You don't have to but that would be cool. Thanks!

Hey Brony I was wondering if you could do a theory video on dragon magic. Personally I don't think they have magic only a select few. But as you said I believe you when you say that gems are containers of magic and that some have some by defalut. I wrote a comment on your video Why doesn't Spike have Wings? video. I stated that I don't think dragons have magic. But now that I think about it I think your gem theory and my dragon theory are the same. Some have magic by defalut and others are
enchanted sometimes or gain it. I was wondering if you could do a video on the dragons magic theory. I would also like it if you could tell me your thoughts on my dragon magic theroy. You don't have to but that would be cool. Thanks!

Thx for the puns ....  YYYYYYAAAAAAASSSSS PPPPPPPUUUUUNNNNNSSSSS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Hey I send you a photo on Instagram  <i>cutebunnygirl</i> (It's a keep calm photo of you )

Hey I send you a photo on Instagram  _cutebunnygirl_ (It's a keep calm photo of you )

You diden't even know if we were laughing! Personaly, I think it rocked to!<br>What?

You diden't even know if we were laughing! Personaly, I think it rocked to!
What?

+James Baxxterr that's such a good joke lol well done

+The Brony Notion I love your jokes! XDD

+The Brony Notion I love your jokes! XDD

+The Brony Notion me if so yes and already did

+The Brony Notion me if so yes and already did

hey I got a therey befor the elements of harmeny were just crysels so someone must have put magic in them I think someone did the same to the crystal haert.

why did you add a comment on your own video

why did you add a comment on your own video

Nobody was taken Because everyone is here

+Kneisha Miles hey! Add a spoiler alert!

+Kneisha Miles hey! Add a spoiler alert!

+nana ok the Cutie Mark Crusaders got there cutie mark

I love you💖💖💖❤💜💓💓💓💓💗

I love you💖💖💖❤💜💓💓💓💓💗

@Magic Note If he's dead, he won't be able to answer you, you know that?

Dude, you dead? You haven't posted any videos in two months!

+The Brony Notion LoL. You're dubble-joke at the beginning was really funny. Sadly, your "Granit"-joke wasn't...


She feels it 😍😍😍😍😍😍💎💎💎💎💎💎

She feels it 😍😍😍😍😍😍💎💎💎💎💎💎


You're the one who didn't make laughing noises understanding that the jokes weren't the best


Czarina Kaleeyah Ximone NENENG Leonardo Galupo


well u can eat rock candy which they are made out of rocks


This video rock ed
Was that a good joke? Don’t take it for granite

This video *rock* ed
Was that a good joke? Don’t take it for granite


I need more concrete Proof.

That was a rock joke btw

I need more concrete Proof.

*That was a rock joke btw*


I think it rocked lol lol so funny   this one is
A gem lol so funny


I like to laugh and you’re joke is funny


If the gems weren't magical, they couldn't save humanity from the diamond authority, DUUHH


i loved youre joke i fell out of my chair


0:26
Me: I think giraffes say “I just don’t know what went wrong” everything but in giraffe (because the giraffe was called Derpy and the line from the last roundup)
Aw come on!
Me: what


And then of course, we have Spike’s snacks...


Don't worry, I found you're puns genuinely hilarious. Also, there are crystals IRL that can surprisingly store energy. They're called Piezoelectric Crystals, and only certain minerals can form crystals that have that property. So it's not strange at all to say that some crystals hold more energy than others, or that they do at all.


What if the dogs just like to collect gem


What's the Earths crust made of?

Sedimentary, my dear Watson.


I get it 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣

I get it 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣


Crystals ARE rocks. A type of rock, anyays


I guess Dimond dogs just want gems .a lot


maby just maby they want to see if the can find "magical" gems or diamonds 😀😀


I mean yeah I know there magical and stuff but,that's just the point!Who made them.How did the elements of Harmony Got created.


you had good jokes and the dogs are getting shining stuff I think?


Thank that you could do "who is stronger of the main 6 between rainbow dash and apple jack "video?


Tittle: what are gems

Spike: my favourite food


I honestly think this video is a gem
It really rocks

k I L L m e

I honestly think this video is a *gem*
It really *rocks*

*k I L L m e*


Maybe just tiny and beautifulBy Tainy I meant shiny


I think those puns are very "egg"-celent


So this might explain why pokemon mega stones work........?


I Thought Your Rock Puns Were Really <b>COAL!</b>

I Thought Your Rock Puns Were Really *COAL!*


i wonder if spike could eat the elements of harmony....


Wait rember from one of the episodeds spike gave rarty a red heart gem
And it looks like a red version of Cristal heart

did spike steal the Cristal heart?!?!

Wait rember from one of the episodeds spike gave rarty a red heart gem
And it looks like a red version of Cristal heart

*did spike steal the Cristal heart?!?!*


It was a good Joke and they are funnny 😂😂😅😂😂😅😅😁😁


3:27 Diamond Dog theory. THEY ARE JUST PLAIN NASTY GREEDY BEASTS!!!!!!


you solve many quetions but what about the cake twins?????


GEMS SIMPLY LOOK LIKE THEY POSSESS MAGICAL ABILITIES OK


<del>/-aggressively makes chocolate rocks-/</del>

-/-aggressively makes chocolate rocks-/-


i like this 'spiderman's style' jokes  XD


Wait so if gems are very magical in mlp if steven universe went in ecuestrya he could use his destrucive powers probly t to defet bill cipher cause his power multiplied


Nah i know about this but i had a lot laugh at the puns


I  COULDN'T BREATH WHEN YOU SAID THE JOKES


I looooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooove ,gem. And diamonds and crystals


They are magical cause its literally my little pony


0:23  I laughed. At the absolute failure of a pun XD

(No offense meant)


this is your brain and this is your brain on Brony puns 0:20


The dogs might need gems to stay like that cuz if they didn’t they would be small but i don’t know I’m not the creator of MyLittlePony


I guess the crystal empire is magical???


@minie'sart that's so smart maybe they just do want magic


i was, not "cracked up" with the puns and OH GOD THE CURSE IS SPREDING


“Gems are magical”<br>Me:Steven universe...? 👀

“Gems are magical”
Me:Steven universe...? 👀


Diamond dogs I think that they are just Stanley searching for anything Preddy


<b>Thinks for a moment</b> WAIT, RAIRIY'S CUTIE MARK IS 3 JEMS AND SHES A UNICORN :O

*Thinks for a moment* WAIT, RAIRIY'S CUTIE MARK IS 3 JEMS AND SHES A UNICORN :O


those puns may be good but remember, be MAUDest


(When the rock/gem puns/jokes came)Pffffffft.........Lol


Maud pie would love the beginning of the video


we know that not all gems are magical  we have indeed seen a lot of gems in MLP :  theory  wrong :😠😠


If you were talking about rocks maud pie would love you forever


them puns good bro<br>especially the last


Gems are made magic some of them because befor they made the gems they putted magic in them then they made the gem then bam magical gem :3


nerd time: crystals and gems are minerals

everyone else: NEEEEEEEERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRD


Maybe this has somthing to do with what the CRYSTAL ponies are and where the CRYSTAL empire came from


I think the diamond dogs dumbly like shiny and pretty stuff like that saying diamonds are are a girls best friend


Rocks in Equestria has different properties,.


Use this recipe in order from Amazon for more info


Think they want the magic to destroy of poo always kept on making fun


Can somepony maby cast a spell on every jewel in Equestria that will last forever?


Ha ha ha that was funy I love it and I like your Chanel


Magical gems r magical cuz there r ponies making them magic...they dnt make all the gems magic...its only a cartoon...dnt worry about their theory so much...enjoy it...It's not like anything is real


You'd have to be /stoned/ to come up with some of those puns.


Amazing puns! UwU I just can't believe your so ROCKY ^w^ was it good?


What if the diameddogs don't eat gems but eat dragons ? Mabee the wanted the gems to get dragons that's wi they stole rairity to get gems AND spike


Am I the only one that laughed at his horrible rock puns?


Nah the diamond dogs wants the Jems bc they are drugs in the pony universe XD


How do cutie marks work in the human world.?


3:00 we have sugar crystals or rocks I can't remember but I know that they are edible


I think that the reason why the dimond dogs search gems 💎 is because they are greedy.


I think your jokes are  really funny! They made me laugh so hard that I throwed up is that funny bye bye


i think the diamond dogs look for magical gems and try to get the magic contained in them and give it to themselves and they'll try to over  throw celestia and luna


Would spike try to eat the elements of harmony


Hey Brony<br>Did king sombra have the ALICORN AMULET???????

Hey Brony
Did king sombra have the ALICORN AMULET???????


I was laughing so much that I wrote so many h a 💛


This happened Yesterday....

Teacher:Ok will be learing about rocks!!

BEACAUSE THE ROOM IS FULL OF PONY FANS

Us: So where is Maud?!

XDDDDDD,LOLZ

This happened Yesterday....

Teacher:Ok will be learing about rocks!!

*BEACAUSE THE ROOM IS FULL OF PONY FANS*

Us: So where is Maud?!

XDDDDDD,LOLZ


browny ihave a question who is star light glimer in the human world?


Why r de gems all perfect well kept and cut in that cave or underground like that crystal mine but how r they so shiny <br>HMMMMMM

Why r de gems all perfect well kept and cut in that cave or underground like that crystal mine but how r they so shiny
HMMMMMM


When you had no laugh that's when i laugh😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😁😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂


THAT's WHAT HAPPENED TO ALL MY ANIMAL JAM GEMS!

jk


uhh one queshion is apllejack more stronger


Everyone gangster until the diamond dogs steal the crystal heart


Notion:That rocked
Me:giggles
Notion:oh come on
Me:am i mute


when i was 8 I could tell gems are not rocks


don't feel bad I also make bad jokes but no one laughs :(


Soo maybe that’s why spike breathes green fire because the diet he eats?


Some gems are infused with the power of destiny<br>Edit: Are you in collage? (originally made this while watching.)

Some gems are infused with the power of destiny
Edit: Are you in collage? (originally made this while watching.)


Of course you look like a geologist, do I look like some random viewer who's joking?! Yeah.


Well dogs do like shiny things or at least my dog dose


that joke :l ... WAS SO FUNNY HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA


Hey i love your videos im a YouTuber and i do mlp videos


about eating the saphire cupcakes in one of the episodes of hearths warming eve when pinkie and aj go to pinkies rock farm they eat rock soup and they eat the rocks like its totaly normal


Not aall gems in my little pony are magical some are just ordinary


Why iz everyone taking his jokes for granite?


In season 7 finale, Solnambula said this "each of us infused a crystal seed with our magic" and then I think that the crystal seed was the elements that had magic in them


The last joked what its I thought it rocked so funny


I laughed at your jokes at the beginning.

Well... not out loud... but I laughed to myself!


Good morning ☀ I love your smile and your videos


YAY! I'm magical XD

In case u haven't noticed look at my name
Crystal Marie
Yes its my real name >w<

YAY! I'm magical XD

In case u haven't noticed look at my name
*Crystal* Marie
Yes its my real name >w<


Well technically if your counting non mangma rocks then yes gems are rocks but if you are going your own way like som people do and saying non mangma rocks are Not real rocks then no gems are not rocks but if you are saying that you are saying non mangma rocks (other than gems) are not rocks too! And that theory really does not make sense to me and HOLY CRAP IM GIVING SEINCE LECTURE ON A ANALYZER OF FRICKING MLP VIDEO WHAT IS MY LIFE


IMAGINE DRAGONS also your puns are so cheesy their good


Calls the crystal gems*
Pearl:WHO MADE FUN OF US AND ROSE QUARTZ!
Me:BRONY NOTION
Pearl:GAHHHH:
Me:PEARL USE POKE
Pearl: stabs brony with nose*


Dragons imagine that wait … Imagine dragons ?


0:25 wow your puns are gong already lol

Like, 3 minutes later: WOW, OVER ALREADY?


They're magic because WE ARE DA CRYSTAL GEMS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Uwa!! So Undertale and we'll always save the day


I wish dude cadense know she is a princess😣