Ponies eat rock candy <br>And rock candy necklaces

Ponies eat rock candy
And rock candy necklaces


BRONY STICK TO THEORIZING YOU ARE NOT MEANT TO BE A COMEDIAN! You know what? I want you to change your cutie mark to either a question mark or a magnifying glass.


Thats why i like gems so so mush !!!!!!!!!! 💎 so cool right ???


We all eat rocks. SALT IS MADE OUT OF ROCKS


Have you ever tried a bread rock Crystal


MABY THEY COULD BE ;) DRAGONS THAT EAT GENSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Gems don’t value anything and the puns 0/10


Like in the video they do like sinus stuff


I have a video idea for you if you need one so sunset shimmer was from the pony world and or Equestria so why has she not ran into her self in thare world because she is not from thare please make a video about this and everyone else who is looking 👀 at this have a wonder full day ......oh God I just sounded like cosey glow


You know about Magic ?! Umm it's not real okay


Maybe Celestia has the magical ring or not no I’m not understand it I am a cat so you can understand me


WE ARE THE CRYSTAL GEMS

Comment things if you like/know Steven Universe


That that one did not work out I meant that like I think it’s because it is pretty


Now the biggest question, why do you look like a male Littlepip?


Dear sawtooth i Lore  your videos from sofiaestrella 😊


that joke has just given you a subscriber


if anyones not laughing, why im the only one laughing to his jokes there funny!!!!


Ha ha ha ha. You are my favorite YouTuber


The diamond dogs are definitely searching for something pretty and shiny. It's what I do!! AROOOOO!


Me TOTALLY not laughing my butt off at how bad your sense of humor is: 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣<br>My mind: welp, at least you got SOMEONE to laught. Even though it wasn't the way you meant 😏

Me TOTALLY not laughing my butt off at how bad your sense of humor is: 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
My mind: welp, at least you got SOMEONE to laught. Even though it wasn't the way you meant 😏


“Do I look like a geologist to You?”<br>Well you are gray

“Do I look like a geologist to You?”
Well you are gray


I know who discord was made once there was 5 species they  fused it made them one it was broken it made them evil ;-; hek


What candy in the rain or sun light though it's not as tasty as pop rocks there just little fireworks in your mouth!!!


🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 rocked

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 rocked


This ones a gem what I think is rocked oh come on me:XD KIDDIN ME


0:18 HAHAHA! WELL THOSE JOKES JUST ROCKED!


5 years ago...........
3:17 i think those are fake and just a design


Looks like im not the only one that is bone dried by audiences.


princess celestia commented

Ok they not really princess celestia  but they name that:))

*princess celestia commented*

Ok they not really princess celestia  but they name that:))


Spiked probably can't eat anything else than jewels


2:43 I thought he said Imagine Dragons at first XD


No you are not the Bronx nation you are sawtooth waves


The dogs like gems, witch are shiny, hmmmmm, 2017.🦀🦀🦀🦀💎💎💎💎💎🦀🦀🦀🦀🦀💎💎💎💎


“Wrraaah! Crystals!”
- That guy who’s name I forgot
“ pppfffttt- AHAHAHAHAH WHY DID IT SOUND LIKE THAT??!!” - Me after he said that


you the niry ate r carrots  and can you see the joke 😂😂😂😂😂


0:16 that joke was so bad that i've laughted


Yes, you look like a geologist please tell us.


So he only tells my little pony information


Are you saying that any gem is magical??????😑😑😑😑😑😑😑


I smiled at “I thinked  it rocked and granite “

I smiled at “I thinked  it *rocked* and *granite* “


Little did we know, sans wrote the script this week.


You could be right about the elements, the season 9 finale confirms they never truly had any magic, it was the ponies using them


Funny no way that is funny you have to be more paneer 👍🦄


I'm watching this in 2016 and soon will be 2017 which it is Christmas morning she even heard of this why there is going to be at Twilight and right now middle of night and I'm watching and come on add Filary  hart


i like your resilience but rock puns arnt funny


Ok so the purple is a amethyst red I'd ruby green is emerald bule might me daimond and yellow might me yellow jade???????


1:05 yellow Diamond, peridot, and amethyst confirmed


I think you're right PS I Love You brownie Asian


Pinkie pie is haf dragon because she eats rocks and spicke eats rock so boom make a video about it


Lol you and your puns.......<br>they are bad but awsome but funny at the same time

Lol you and your puns.......
they are bad but awsome but funny at the same time


Hay do you know that pinkie pie is a changing too did you?


grantaed<br>😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

grantaed
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂


i think your write becuas why  is the tree of harmony then of crystals


great puns..... and yes u look like a geoligest


Nice pun but it wasn't very punny like .-. Bruh. Hey what do you call a gem? Rock-hard .<i>.like a diamond tho.,. Even tho they do break but I don't even care I also laughed at you "trying" to make a pun like sans from undertale.</i>.

Nice pun but it wasn't very punny like .-. Bruh. Hey what do you call a gem? Rock-hard ._.like a diamond tho.,. Even tho they do break but I don't even care I also laughed at you "trying" to make a pun like sans from undertale._.


I'm a Mexican but again I know English I don't know how I'd know English


꧁☃𝙵𝚛𝚘𝚜𝚝𝚆𝚊𝚏𝚏𝚕𝚎☃꧂


Yay yay 😊😎😎😎😎😎

Yay yay 😊😎😎😎😎😎


Roses are red and violets are blue, god made me beautiful but what about you?


is it possable that you can also say where you get ur music from  (Minde mah spelling i english good ok)


i liked the puns i dont care wut u think


Wait...the brony NOTION?!? I thought that is was the brony nation...umm...how did I not realize this?


Diamond dogs are idiots are idiots and are like bugs. Attracted to all things shiny


Hahahahaha
You have good joke

I'm sarcastic


This is actually interesting, because as people who practice Wicca know, crystals are actually very good at holding energy for spells. Certain ones are better for particular spells, but all can be charged and cleansed by moonlight.


That one bit when it was just cutie-markless Rarity getting dragged by her horn is just hilarious on it’s own 🤣 but that face just says it all.


The alicorn amulet is astell's also known as celestia and luna's big sister who wanted to get rid of magic


Do what do we know  If i ask it is hard  to say


they want magic from the gems cause they are just dogs


the gem is powerfulli ha get it fulli😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀


You see here if more did not have her cutie mark and pinkie pie was not her sister the rocks and the the shiny things will get together and then turn more to a monster and if that happens when more did not have her cutie mark and she was pinkie pie sister pinkie pie really the world but she be a blood drinking globe like pinkie pie cupcake party the game and all the friends will be doomed for their lives but if pinkie pie was not the element of laughter nobody will laugh only like rocks and celestial being even not there there's no such thing of any princess in the world


Did you ever think that this is a kids show?


If princess celestia and pink hair when she was little so how did she get that rainbow hair


Brony notion:oh come on.                 Frriiiiieeeennnnnddddddssss


guls is awesome yeah yeah and you know I'm saven and I have a tablet my tablet is Lenovo....!!!!!!!!


Maby the dogs just want bits money wut ever u call it


What if this is like Trollhunters where they harness gems for their power and beauty?


that's  a bud joke 😦heer try this one what's  a pony + a joker a pony😉 joker and that's  you becaus it's  you tell bud jokes but they are kinda god 😆


sawtooth waves: oh com'on

intro: FFFFFFRRRRRRIIIIIIEEEEEEENNNNNNDDDDDDSSSSSS


Do you have the most powerful the other side to become collecting can you believe that our other stuff I don’t know pirate wars is someone just came and gave them powers what are they contain the magic inciting they know that when they do that mine is like that but they put like the little sorry I didn’t know that food at your door like a day and a leg day they are magic do you know what you were saying since only didn’t want to find


As you know the equestria girl got the necklaces after defeating glorious and I think that those are the elements for the equestria girl and normal  elements of harmony for the mean 6.😁😉🤔


Twilight:I PASSED!!!!!
bring:and with flying colors too
Haha haha
Boom boom change! ;)


Terrible.....Terrible yet entertaining puns..........the Granite one was funny tho....


Try to make better choices of  jokes not to be

Meaning don't tell me your jokes


I watched a video by a different YouTuber Brony who talked about how rocks might be sentient...
COINCIDENCE?? I THINK NOT.

I watched a video by a different YouTuber Brony who talked about how rocks might be sentient...
*COINCIDENCE?? I THINK NOT.*


And I have a joke to shine bad jokes all around


cringy just cringy  a warning don,t let spike eat steven universe,s belly button


ayyyyyy cool anyone I have cheese does that make me cheesy


Me seeing this in my recommendation:

WE ARE THE CRYSTAL GEMS

WE ALWAYS SAVE THE DAY

AND IF YOU THINK WE CANT

WE’LL ALWAYS FIND A WAY

THATS WHY THE PEOPLE OF THIS WORLD BELIEVE IN

GARNET

AMETHYST

AND PEARL

AND STEVEN!

Me seeing this in my recommendation:

*WE ARE THE CRYSTAL GEMS*

*WE ALWAYS SAVE THE DAY*

*AND IF YOU THINK WE CANT*

*WE’LL ALWAYS FIND A WAY*

*THATS WHY THE PEOPLE OF THIS WORLD BELIEVE IN*

*GARNET*

*AMETHYST*

*AND PEARL*

*AND STEVEN!*


... okay ,number one plz never talk about jokes agin two work on ur puns man!


You posted this on April 2015 me watching this tusday September 3 2019


YASSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS U ARE DEFINETLY FJNNY


O yes rihgt i forgot to say to you i dont get the joke but hahahhahah!


"OH, come ON - FRRRIIIIIEEEEEEEEENNNNNNNNNDDDDDDDDDDDSSSSSSSSSS"


ARE U KIDDING MEEEE THE OPINING AGAIN!!!!!!!


Who laughed at all of his jokes even though some were corny?<br>Because I know I did

Who laughed at all of his jokes even though some were corny?
Because I know I did


Lemme make it crystal clear, you are bad at jokes.

Ok i will stop aswell

Lemme make it *crystal* clear, you are bad at jokes.

Ok i will stop aswell


I think the diamond dogs just one shiny things because they are light village we fight all the time he just wants germs and germs and germs so I think this one is it for a stupid girlfriend bye


LOL PUNS!<br>At least they're funny for me.

LOL PUNS!
At least they're funny for me.


the book I am writing also considers gems not as magical by themselves, but good at "conducting" magic like electricity because of their structures. Kinda interesting how a lot of people consider gems magical...


ᗪOᑎ'T ᗯOᖇᖇY I ᒪIKE YOᑌᖇ ᑭᑌᑎᔕ

ᗪOᑎ'T ᗯOᖇᖇY I ᒪIKE YOᑌᖇ ᑭᑌᑎᔕ


Its mine time to shine get becuse gems shine


The jokes are funny all  of your jokes none of my jokes are funny to others!!!


Ya I no this is nothing  related to this but flurry heart name


I now why the diamond dogs are could diamond dogs at feary their ushwaly could diamond dogs cus they dont look bling to much and ther always attractive to diamond


That joke was not really good im not a hater ok


man is like to be eat gems beacese she like a dragon


You are very PUN-ny hahahahahahahahahahhhaahahahahaa


Spek like gems hiz eating yum yum yum yum yum


If you don't know who she is watch princess trixie sparkle!!!!!!!!


STOP STOP STOP STOP STOP STOP STOP he he


Why do u keep on making Videos at sweet Apple acers


WHY ARE YOU STANDING AT TREES LIKE REALLY??? PLEASE CHANGE THE PLACE!!!!


Yeah I think gems are just naturally capable of binding to/storing/recreating magic, but different ones are better with different kinds of magic. They’re the best conduits in most cases


Diamonds 2nd Account for her lil brother


Me:hears the two words crystal and gems
Me again:....

We ArE tHe CrYsTaL gEmS,wE'lL aLwAyS sAvE tHe DaY


Can someone tell me ho to add a pic on my account?

Click the account icon then click change picture.<br>Hope this helped😀👌

Click the account icon then click change picture.
Hope this helped😀👌


Ok I large at ever joke even if it sucks but they don’t suck


The sirens necklace  that negative  magic looks  when the rarity she had  the book


for the dragons eating gems I think it's more of a salt water fish thing, salt water fish because they live in salt water have to drink large amounts of water while fresh water fish get hydrated easily so they kinda never have to actually drink water. However with dragons being big by greed I guess that's their hydration if you will. They become healthier and stronger when they consume gems. this is why I said kinda like salt water fish because water wether it be salt or fresh don't make fish bigger but I think that's the "magic" aspect for the gems and I feel like consuming gems is also an evolutionary thing that's why dragons are able to eat them as opposed to ponies who don't seem to eat gems. also I thought that gems got their power cuz their kind of like containers for magic but they get their magic from deceased ponies idk that's what I thought


lembrando também o castelo da twilight q tem um mapa de equestria(a mesa do mapa é de cristal certo?),e também podemos citar os pequenos cristais de Equestria Girls 4( A Lenda de everfree) Eu e minha amiga temos uma pequena teoria que diz que aqueles pequenos cristais podem ser dos elementos da harmonia que estarão estava na árvore da harmonia ou do império de cristal mais provável da árvore da Harmonia, árvore da harmonia precisava daqueles cristais(dos elementos) para levar a magia da amizade para levar para o mundo de Canterlote High


I LOVE cats! and when I saw the diamond dog episode, I was like, "YES!! FINALLY A SHOW THAT MAKES THE DOGS THE BAD GUYS!! or, at least kind of the bad guy. BUT  YEAH. FINALLY!!!!!" haha. I REALLY said that.


I think the diamond dogs are trying to find gems that give them benefit in some way, maybe they find gems to make them stronger/take advantage of every single gem's ability.


first of all,good theory and,second i think,the diamond dogs are just obsesed with crystals because,they got hit on the head once ,or,they lot their favorite crystal once because of a bully.


Gems hold power for equestria,both dark and good,only a pony like luna could theoreticly control it


i think that alicorns make  crystals powerful by giving them magic


I like it when he uses a pun, and no one laughs, 'cause then, we laugh(usally)!


Haha, the jokes at the beginning were so funny in my opinion! 😅


WE ARE THE CRYSTAL GEMS WE'LL ALWAYS SAVE THE DAY AND IF YOU THINK WE CAN'T WE'LL ALWAYS FIND A WAY AND THATS WHY THE PONIES OF THIS WORLD BELEIVE IN GARNET AMETHYST AND PEARL AND THE ELEMENTS OF HARMONY


Omg the sombra impression was spot on lolol.


Maybe it makes them able to be god like the apple of immortality in Greek mythology


When Celly and Luna used the elements of harmony there were different shapes could the shapes somehow link to the mane six


i think the Dimond dogs get gems for them being sparkling


good thanks for showing why crystals are special


to many puns but some how i still laughed


OTHER CUTIE MARKS ARE ALSO POWERFUL TO HELP THE TOWN BRO


Hahahahahaha!!!!!!!!!!!!! Those jokes are AMAZING! I love the one that says when it comes to the theory this one is a gem!!!!!
The Brony Notion can you make more jokes in your videos!? Please say...
YES!!!!!!!!!!! OR I WON'T BE YOUR SUBSCRIVER!!!!!!!!!!


The crystal heart is full love that's the magic


maybe the bigger the gem the more the magic


gems are magical because they are magical X3 but it could be unicorn magic to make them magical that is probably why sombra took over the Crystal Empire and not somewhere else but heck if i know :T


My theory is that the jewel itself isn't ever magical and that an allicorn or a unicorn had to have enchanted it.


Maybe the dogs just want the magic? To be all for themselves?


i like that and it was so funny how you can be used for magic ha ha ha


What if spike were to eat one of the 'enchanted' gems?

Dragongirl821 he would have a very bad day


well what happens if the main six but on a friendship problem and they found out that the Friendship problem included a magical gem and if a magical gem was evil and that was the main problem for all the bad energy and Equestria what is that gem all the bad energy and just spread it through Equestria


Why is the  crystal heart powerful than another crystal


In Eragon they used gems to store energy, which Eragon or other spellcasters could draw upon the energy stored inside and use it to cast magic as well as other day-to-day tasks.


Ba-dum-tss!
Get it?
Because crystals crack?
No?
Sigh.


His jokes are sooooooooooo funny! Bwahahahahahahahahahahahaha


I liked your rock puns and yes Christls are rocks


The diamond dogs were interested in collecting gems because there were greedy about gems


i think the dimond dogs just want gems becuse there shiny


I think the diamond dogs are out for money, or something shiny. Nothing more cuz they are not very bright X3


I think that all jems have magic oh and that the diamond dog's are just searching for anything prity and shiny


I was laughing  at your puns I adore them MORE IN YOUR VIDEOS PLS I BEG YOU PLS DO THE PUN


This one's a gem - oh come on I think it rocked

Me: HAHAHA


I just got a random question. How did you get so popular?

Hollie savannah miner i love your videos Miner


how about a theory on the new movie legonds of eveefree


WELL! I thought your jokes "rocked" the video. NO REGREEEEEEETS!


I want to see a video of flurry heart is she an alicorn


put the captions on at 1:26

I bet marvel fans will laugh.


(sees title and starts humming steven universe theme song)


THE PUNS. THERE TOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO MUCH!


Gems? Ah ha! We... Are the crystal gems we always save the day! And if u think we can?! We always find a way! This is y the ppl of this world believe in.. Garnet! Amathist! and Pearl AND STEVEN!!!!


i would think that they eat them mostly because my dog would eat anything he can get his dirty little paws on


WOW! Try to beat THOSE jokes, Silver Quill!<unsubtle sarcasm>


OMG i know this guys dad, he also tells rock jokes. Brony Notion is a chip off the old ROCK!  HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA


DONT worry i will found out soon the DAZZLINGS powers


you don`t look like a geoligest but you do look like a rock with copper shaped like a ponie and the copper as the hair


I don't know about u guys but tbh... puns ROCK!! ;)


I Thought your jokes were hilarious!!!:-) Lol


well I haven't heard a joke like you hope you appreciate this


what I think your jokes are fun😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉


Where did you have in finding is a spell because twilight was able to cast it define where ready when the diamond dogs took her


I was laughing at the beginning...... its so sad


I thought the joke at the start was good!


The brony Notion should I make my own channel? If yes then how do you make a pony that can do the same things as yours? And how do I make other ponies come to my channel and how do I make a sqaure be on the screen and show what ever I want?


The dogs want to keep the jems to fool ponies won't can dig for them like slaves


CAUSE THEY TRY THEIR BEST TO GET THE JEMS BUT IN DAZZLINGS IS AN FAKE MAGIC BRO


Ha ha ha ha ha gem!!! Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha rocked!!!!! Granite!!!!! Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha so funny!!!!!!!!!!


I think..
When Sombra's horn fell off it was made into the alicorn amulet
Right


that pun was terrible and by that I mean it was awesome too awesome


When I heard the jokes, I just want to give up.


the dogs are just dumbly  looking for gemstones


You have the best jokes ever😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😍😍😍😍😍😍


dude am I the only one who sees a steven universe conection


hahahahahaha you're relly funny when is comes to rock joks


i just lost my damn internet connection why watching this


Your joke was a little bit ROCKY !? Yeah I just STONED your jokes !!!  Like this comment and you ROCK


we I thought those jokes were very funny


its ok aslo its almost imposible to makke me lagh.


high admiral insurance company will let us<br>buggy and I

high admiral insurance company will let us
buggy and I


He should me sans cause all the puns like if you agree with me


I mean people don't like my jokes either


your  not good with pony jokny    <br>get it


Joe Lappin. how about you be nice with Mexicans.


you stink at making gem jokes bcause i am a gem of a joker


Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha h<br>!!!!!!!!!🙃😘😝😜😚😂😱😅

Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha h
!!!!!!!!!🙃😘😝😜😚😂😱😅


Lolirock and my little pony 💕 byNavyaGlameringglow


It's so crayzyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy u are


this channle  is so osm  but this is a  little  boring


I hate those dog they ask me sick🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🐱🐱🐱🐱🐱🐈🐈🐩🐓🐶🐰🐰


i just have something to add, the power rarity has is magic, you can see her horn glowing, there might be a magnet that pulls her toward them, but thats unlikely, instead, there is a substance in the gem that makes it so Rarity can track gems, such the magic in the elements of harmony that brings the mane 6 together


I believe that the Diamond Dogs are like a Raven(bird) and seem to like shining objects for nesting.


and, about the diamond dogs, in the episode, they seemed greedy for the gems, they kinda looked like they needed them to eat, or they're obsessed with them. either way, they could both work


When comes to gems and dogs they live in the mine so of course they want the gems but not to eat them to steal them.And all of of them different gems like the heart gem💙,the diamond gem💎,and...yeah you should get it!😊


on the first of the Christmas episodes about hearst warming eave, didn't Star swirl Abearded make the elements of harmony with plain gems by putting a spell on them and having exceptional ponies put their energies into each of the elements? If so, then i think it might help support your theory'


Mod would be perfect explaining the rocks/crystals/gems XD


I think they do have magic too because to explain raritys cutie mark it is three gems and she has a ability to track rocks think about it like read this three times how is rarity supposed to reach the gems well it has a magic force that when rarity sence gems the magic from the gems connect to rarities magic so you are right they do have magic


gems, jewels etc are classes as rocks because under the ground when the climate is right the rocks form gems.


in real life dragons dont eat gems. i know how to look after one, just one baby dragon needs at least 300 cows to get fed.<br>so its not true that dragons eat gems

in real life dragons dont eat gems. i know how to look after one, just one baby dragon needs at least 300 cows to get fed.
so its not true that dragons eat gems


I think you r right the diamond dogs might be searching dumbly for something pretty and shiny


crystal gems: we are the crystal. Steven :gems. crystal gems :we always save the day. Steven :and if you think we can't we'll always find a way Connie and peridot that why the people on this word .  Greg : believe in .garnet,amethyst,and pearl ,Steven . narrator : Steven universe. extra.the author against us won't be easy but we're not gonna do it alone.


I ENJOY ALL THE FUNNY PICTURES AND REFERENCES HE PUTS IN


your theory is correct. even in this world crystals and gems have power. take a salt lamp for ex. it can make you happy my the negative ions it gives off.


Some off the boys in my class have pet rocks they even named them! And made a house for them


So one reason of crystals being magical would be for protection?


I think the diamond dogs just like sparkly and pretty stuff


i loved your inside jokes XD i think they rocked...


A different gem has a different purpose and power.


WE, ARE THE CRYSTAL GEMMMMMMMMSSSSS, WE'LL ALWAYS SAVE THE DAY


maybe the diamond plate dogs wanted gems that weren't ruff to paw


I started thinking about Steven Universe when I watched this. Anyone else?? ^-^


I think the diamond dogs like jems because they are cool and shiny.


What about rock candy. And  MAGIC IS EVERYTHING and I like the rock joke


Wasn't this theory practically fan-cannon anyway?


i think dragons eat gems then there a kid so they could breath fire until there old enough to contain it so they could do it on their own or they contain enough so they could when ever they want


The jokes made me laugh don't feel bad it's OK I'm liking the jokes


Why did the elements of hamany change to the main 6s cutie marks when they used them the 1st time but not when Celestia used them with nightmearmoon!?


I think the diamond dogs just like shiny things


Maybe the diamond dogs want the diamonds so they want to be rich


what if the gems in MLP were 'Gems' from Steven Universe? XD XD XD


Better not let Spike find out the tree of harmony or he will eat it


i have a joke.
two rocks talking to each other.
rocks cant talk. -Maud Pie


the important crystals are all enchanted


i think diamond dogs like chrystals bacause they are shiny and beautiful


The dog did to Jim do you like to collect him and caused a super super sign and it's probably the roof that's the lady


maybe the dogs want some bling-bling I mean like look at there collars there one gem on each


why is celestia and Luna have the power to rise the moon and the sun


I think it's funny and I think it's because they think it's daemon🐟


Twilight from the human world has a necklace that contains magic.


on the portal there is gems! could that be something?....


I think they eat them.......  since jem are magic when they ate it may have given the ability to talk I mean have u ever seen a talking dog


Is some of the jewels might be from the elements of harmony by from the pony who might find the elements of harmony gems then the princess of Equestia's mom and dad found the elements of harmony gems and gave it to the princesses so they can stop discord then twilight sparkle, apple jack, flutter shy, rainbow dash, pinkie pie, and rarity found the elements of harmony gem to stop nightmare moon. And the rest might be found also the pony who found the elements of harmony so the evil ponys and people from equestia girls take the jewels for powerfor themselves.


Jokes are corny but the YouTube channel ROCKS!


My OC MagicShy has 4 crystals not just any crystals MagicCrystals! These magiccrystals have make different affects,the purple gem changes & fixes a pony/human,blue gem heals a wound or revives a pony that just "died" in front of you,orange gem changes a ponys mood,& pink gem makes magic stronger,now MagicShy already has magic that's in the middle not too strong & not too weak,she loves flying but RainbowDash was in a bad mood so she used the orange gem to make RainbowDash happy again! MagicShy always uses her magic & her gems for good use,but what about Changlings I don't know about that but lets just say if a Changling wanted to become a normal pony MagicShy would have to have Rairty & Twilight's help with a spell,since their magic is stronge,that's my theory about gems,idk about the others but that's something I'll comment on again!


The dogs want to be rich that's what I think


so because are both magical are they the same thing


The gem joke was like a nook joke sirosly


princess twilight sparkle is the magical


ha ha ha ha ha I get the jokes ha ha ha ha ha!😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂


i like your supposedly kinda lame rock puns

Nobody was taken Because everyone is here


+The Brony Notion correction! The crystal heart is a crystal, not a gem! And the only way you would know that, is if u were Rarity. XD

No wonder spike haven't eaten twilights Chrystal castle, throwing all 5 seasons he eats nothing but gems.


me: oooo  SHINEY!Marissa: don't touch that <del>I explode</del>

me: oooo  SHINEY!Marissa: don't touch that -I explode-


Didn't Maud Pie ate a big jewel by mistake, and she seemed 'fine'. um oh yeah maybe you turn like Maud Pie if you eat a jewel.


jems are so beuti and dogs wanna them and be reach :-)


Why didn't celestia, Luna, and cadence just store all their manic in a stone along with twilight's when terek was taking over

+Elizabeth Archer (Liz) but then think about the elements of harmony, they are normal crystals that have magic way more powerful then the princesses, And all the villains in MLP. COMBINED!

way too much magic for any stone to hold


Good one😀😀😄😆😆😆😆😆

Good one😀😀😄😆😆😆😆😆


Yes, yes you look like an geologist.  :3

Yes, yes you look like an geologist.  :3


umm well I don't think the dogs eat the gems  because spike turned into a dog and when he got hungry he wanted a dog snack so ya and plus I think the dogs eat diamonds Cuz its in there name 💙🐕🐕🐕


umm well I don't think the dogs eat the gems  because spike turned into a dog and when he got hungry he didn't want gems so ya and plus I think the dogs eat diamonds Cuz its in there name


+Judy Palombi umm I LOVE YOU VIDS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


no! rairity find the j<br>gems beacause hes cuttie mark is gems

no! rairity find the j
gems beacause hes cuttie mark is gems


dood rock puns are out donuts are the Dell now


Why are there bags that have there cutymark


your jokes are soooooooooooo funny so haaaaaaaa


nice jokes I thought they were funny but it didn't make me lol actually I even face flamed my self now that makes me lol. lol.


😂gem😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

😂gem😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂


кιттуσ ѕαяαн


lets see who can make me laugh.....brony notion vs maud pie! MAUD PIE WINS BECAUSE BRONY NOTION'S JOKES ARE NOT FUNNY!jk i got a little chuckle! ;)


maybe the dogs are cra cra no one laughed? UGH we both having a bad laugh day Brony I'm a reporter on mlp to!


Ana: Not cool dude.....not cool i  make better jokes then you I am not saying i'am beter then you to cool to be true to you!!!!!


heyjus so u kow i laught at all ur jokes it wus so lol


Wa wa wa to ur joke at first part of vid but good vid


U are even worse than me at jokes and that is saying something<br>No offence

U are even worse than me at jokes and that is saying something
No offence


OIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII YOUR A CHANGLING GET BACK HERE


It seems to me that gemstones and magic in Equestria function similarly to plant life on Earth.<br>Plants having all those variables, they could coincide with similar gems. Plus the Tree of Harmony would add credence to this theory, no?

It seems to me that gemstones and magic in Equestria function similarly to plant life on Earth.
Plants having all those variables, they could coincide with similar gems. Plus the Tree of Harmony would add credence to this theory, no?


I always figured that magic was a natural resource for ponies since they do use electricity in Equestia, however significantly less than humans. The Flim Flam Brothers used their horns to power their cider machine, but if that magic can be found in crystals, then that magic would surely save a lot of labor for ponies. So maybe the shiny rocks that make jewelry might be recycled. Like if a gem has been used and no magic remains in it, but it can still make a pretty earring or necklace, then why not make a decoration out of it?


Gems are naturally occurring collections of crystallized magic. The magic gathers inside the rock turning them into gems from the inside out. That's why you rotate the crops on a rock farm so that all the magic doesn't get sucked out of the land in one harvest. You have to give the land time to recover between rotations.

Some changeling didn't pay attention in Earth Pony 101!


I agree with your theory on gems and magic, and about the Diamond Dogs, I think that gems give them the ability to talk and give them more human like abilities because as we know, Winona, Applejack's dog can't talk. So maybe the Diamond Dogs use the magic in gems for that reason.


I believe that the dogs are just digging gems up to collect them. second I do agree that in Equestria that gems have some base level magic, however why some are naturally more powerful are several ways, one is that the largness of the gem means that one could hold power but even small gems could be just as naturally powerful why? well that brings my second point depending on how the gems formed and under what conditions they formed under could determine how powerful they are. of course you could always make gems more powerful by enchanting them, now depending on the skill and/or the amount of power the enchanter wants to put into the gem can determine its increased power. Say for example the crystal heart that could have been made from a large crystal ore (if you will) shaped and then enchanted with magic and love which made for a powerful crystal and it's power is renewed or increased by the annual festival!


Something i want to say is that for the element of harmony I thought that they were normal crystals just inchanted by starswirl


this might be a little random and might get a little off topic, but here are some thoughts... I think that magic is actually just an energy, and some gems can contain higher levels of energy, like food. some food is healthier than others. why else would a dragon eat nothing but gems? how would it survive without energy? i think that dragons have hot stomach acids to break down the gems, and that's why they can breathe fire. I think that all of the gems can capture energy/magic that flows everywhere, but we can't see it, like friendship and hate. the gems can capture either friendship (elements of harmony/any regular gems found) or hatred (alicorn amulet). and the only way they can contain the magic is because they have mirror like walls on the inside to keep reflecting the magic to stay in the middle. sorry if that stuff was a little random..


I Think The Fire Ruby Heart Has Some Love Magic In It.


I think normal dragons don't eat them much, and consider them like we consider sweets and desserts. If they had to much magic, they could get sick. The reason spike has no problem eating gems is that his pony like mind is using magic to combat the dark compelling draconian mindset. Also, their wings could be their manifestation of magic, and spike, wingless and pony like, is using up magic as he gets it. So gems taste amazing to him since they are full of the magical nutrients he needs.


if you can store magic in gems then why didn't the sirens just find new gems for their necklaces?


I can see gems being able to contain magic for this ain't the first season to play on that look at my favorite novel seires the inheritance cycle in witch gems were use as a place to hold energy in reserv for magical spells


i think the dogs searches crystals to become magic. they want those because they feel like the only notmagical creatures aruond. after we said that gems hold magic, I think this makes sense, does it? So every gem holds a little magic, but I think its like an USBStick: It v´can, but hasnt to hold data/magic. just with the difference that every gem holds a little magic.


When he said it "rocks" I laughed so hard XD


you know that there have been instances where ponies eat rocks like maud pie and hearthbreakers.


could the gems just be symbolic? or could they have some sort of spell on them?


That explains why diamonds make the best armor( minecraft) and why gems are magical in general.


I have a theory. What if trixie was a descendent of starswirl the bearded and that's why she wants to be great and powerful, because her ancestor was a great and powerful ( and famous ) pony.


I have a theory!its that the gems are connected to the tree of harmony which means it has a lot of power to use that's the end of my theory


I laughed so hard at the "Rawr crystals"


I think King sombra filled the alicorn amulet, princess cadence filled the crystal heart, and twilight tWith the element of magic.


Pinky made rock candy and it looks like a gem. Wouldn't that count?<br>


the elements of harmony was cast by unicorn there is one clever unicorn and the other like laughter kindness and royalty twilight and the other is just the second unicorn and Pegasus and earth pony that has been chosen to be one with the element of harmony this is true i have discover it.


doesnt everyone already know why gems are magical? they're aliens from another planet who draw weapons from their gems. of course, aliens made out of false matter are super badass.


I think that gems are like rock candy for dragons.


The rock puns were REALLY funny! They were. REALLY!


those were funny jokes lol 😂😂😂😂i cant stop laughing 😂😂😂😂😂


What if Spike (or any dragon) ate the Elements of Harmony?


"Dragons, Imagine that" When you said that I was thinking "Imagine Dragons" the band. lol


Spike:Hey I will look after your crystals and gems, Rarity
Rarity:Oh thank you
                                                                                5 HOURS LATER
Rarity comes back-
Looks at the box of crystals and gems-
Sees all the gems and crystals are gone-
Screams-
Rarity:SPIKE!!
Spike doesn't answer-
Finds spike in a room-
Sees Spike eating her gems-
Kicks Spike out-
Rarity:GRRRR


i think that because ponies have and like AND need crops,and all that other stuff, there is not that much stuff for the diamond dogs, so, they chose diamonds.Just a hunch!


I think that to dragons, jewels are like rock candy


Drinking game: drink every time he says magic, magical, or gems/ a name of a gem


Gems are magical because they are hologram projectors that project creatures like Garnet, Amethyst, Pearl and Rose (she is currently in her gem) which have mass. Whoever is a Steven Universe/ My Little Pony fan, I love ya!


The crystal heart was enchanted by Cadence's father


Okay how about this the reason why dragon and diamond dogs are up sets with gems is because they think by eating or having them can give them God like power. That right and the reason why some gems have magic is because they were not from Equestria at all but from another planet with God like warriors that ether combine Thar magic or body's on the gems.


When you said today were gonna learn about rocks I sneezed


BEST JOKES EVER! who lagphed with him at the intro because those where the best jokes I ever heard so far!


The gems are magical, because children like big shiny things,
and crystalline transparent plastic is easy to produce.
THEORY DEBUNKED


like the element of harmony is cast by magic for a 1000 years


I think the diamond dags are like pirets they still diamond bc 2 became rich and its like goold 4 pirets


"I PAST !! "Yes and with flying colores too XD


the title reminds me of a song oh yea! "We are the crystal gems!" ~steven universe


I think the dogs are looking for powerful jems


Lot of creatures in My Little Pony are also in the Greek mythology do you think that My Little Pony is related with Greece? (sorry for my English I am from Greece)

γιαννης γκινης


My lesson is about rocks so that made me a kid geologist


have you ever see the chaos emeralds if you did they have chaos in said


Since when did celestial learn dark magic


That's why spike is in love with rarity!!!Except for the fact that he just thinks she's beautiful But still!!!!


omg can u do a video were u explain why ponys dont grow up in mlp ? thx im a really big fan thx


Dogs: Just looking for something pretty.<br>Theory: ☑

Dogs: Just looking for something pretty.
Theory: ☑


They called amberi?ambaro?umbaro you can see in sombra's magic or like abrosable one in equestria girls friendship games they make same things stroge the magic


the diamond dogs I think like shiny stuff


Twilight: I passed!                                                                                You: Yes, and with flying colors too!                                                                                Me: I dont get it.


I have a question when the element of harmony became necklaces why didn't twilight sparkle have a necklaces like the other instead why dose she have a crown?


i think that they eat them because they were all like: um shiny jems. hunt for the dragon. does anyone agree?


On Thursaday? I thought you made more videos on Wednesdays.


maybe they just like shiny shiney stuff??


I think there trying to contain the gems magic and rule canterlot


But princess celestia had the gems before twilight sparkle even became and made friends but how are the gems colors the same colors as the mane 6


that was my name gem anyway the gem dog is really powrful to find gems or should i say jewels gems are powerful too about all gems that rarity found she discover gems or rubies so everypony know cause of rarity oh and by the way the first who discover gems or rubies or jewels is celestia and luna and cadance so if my solution is correct that the answer is that twilight was a powerful pony who study because of the rubies she found and canterlot high she go


I know I did Jim dogs like jms because verities so pretty that they want some gems so they would look nice


They are probly just some done dogs that love shiny things


I LOVED YOUR PUNNY JOKES! Get it? Funny-PUNNY.... No?


I think your jokes SHONE there.;)
If anyone hates me for that,I'm just a SHINING person for these jokes.;)
One may say I'm CRYSTAL clear to find opportunities for jokes.;)

+Jade Jade  Come on,making those puns were the GEM on the dress,one might say. That one made no sense,but these puns are DIRT cheap.I like making puns like that.Don't judge.


In polish gem sounds like dżem. XDDDDD
(pol.)     (eng.)
Dżem       Jam


I don't get the gems pun.....I don't get it.


first the puns, second the dogs are just stupidly looking for shiny stuff


Are you a pony... Cause Every time you say BRO HOOF Rainbow Dash and Applejack kinda do a BRO HOOF...


Hi me again I love your work but that's no it because remember that spike was holding rarity when he was super dragonafied he was looking for gewels until rarity reminded him


yeah they probably just want shiny things you know just because they're pretty I mean I get so attracted I get so attracted to shiny thanks I mean they're so pretty I mean when I was in kindergarden I always looked at the score trophy it got me into trouble and they had to put the trophies away and so it the windows with all sorts of dumb stuff maybe if I didn't make stuff so shiny lightweight the diamond dog likes shiny things then why don't they go after the crystal ponies I mean they're shiny but just go to cancel or they would be eating whole building.

I'm pretty sure if the reason they wanted gems was because they were shiny they would be the diamond birds.


what episode is the green HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE dragon in                   Kitten pun: youve got to be kitten me right meoow


they are magical because they want to be duh :P


this keeps going get it a boulder rolls around hahahahaha😂😂😂😄😄😄😅😅😅😆😆😆😨😰😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😆😆


Oh............. My god. THE PUNS!!!!!! SO MANY CRYSTAL/ROCK PUNS! But then again, some of 'em are real "gems" Da da ping


hahahah steven universe refrence aka the crystal gems which are too many to list


Lets go woder colts! err...ok...Acadea from the friedship games is sooo catcy


I have an answer for you, buddy. <b>eyes homeworld</b>

I have an answer for you, buddy. *eyes homeworld*


hey i saw young rarity  pony from the past


i think they ARE like dum dogs that search for shiny things, but  they only  collect gems, not anything else, i'm confused.


the first joke was funny,but not the second one.


0:19 That WAS a good joke. I liked it WAY better than the stupid CNN news puns, -.-  0.-


your puns need work, ask sans to help you x"D  im jking


Not a good joke, anyway I think that I will ROCK you


you look like a geologist to me, actually.😕


u got that right. Boooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!😣


I think the dogs are just dumly searching


aaahhh aahh aahh aahh aahh i i i i git it


really it rocked think of something better


i tingk     bekos   they    koolekt    them

i tingk     bekos   they    koolekt    them


i have no idea how to comment this????????????😒😒


The way I see gems, I think of a gem's magical ability as their world's version of the piezoelectric effect we get from them. They have magic and can release or absorb it. Seeing as Tank's flying machine seems to have one inside it, powering it, I think this seems like a possibility.


I think that maybe all of the technology in Equestria which seems too high tech for the ponies actually run on gems, like a refrigerator or a helicopter, kind of like how we use electricity. Possibly there may even be some sort of gem to power all the lights and machinery for Equestria.


I would like to add a thought - the Elements of Harmony could be just ordinary gems infused with magic, but how could that magic be replenished? I think that the Roements are just focal points for the magic the ponies themselves create with their friendship. After all, "Friendship is Magic" Also, I believe that there is leftover magic in them after they are used. Sunset Shimmer had to pull all of that from something. But it might be a different kind of magic, the mundane kind. Sunset couldn't use the friendship kind of magic, but it is stated in Episode 1 that the Elements were "the most powerful magic known" even without a set of friends to use them. And I don't want to accept that Celestia represented all elements at once. I just think that she used the magic inside them as a normal enchanted item, like the Alicorn Amulet, but without the corrupting power.<br>Just a thought.

I would like to add a thought - the Elements of Harmony could be just ordinary gems infused with magic, but how could that magic be replenished? I think that the Roements are just focal points for the magic the ponies themselves create with their friendship. After all, "Friendship is Magic" Also, I believe that there is leftover magic in them after they are used. Sunset Shimmer had to pull all of that from something. But it might be a different kind of magic, the mundane kind. Sunset couldn't use the friendship kind of magic, but it is stated in Episode 1 that the Elements were "the most powerful magic known" even without a set of friends to use them. And I don't want to accept that Celestia represented all elements at once. I just think that she used the magic inside them as a normal enchanted item, like the Alicorn Amulet, but without the corrupting power.
Just a thought.


What would happen if a dragon ate an element of harmony or any of the other particularly powerful magic gems? And couldn't the problem of the evil ones just be solved by being eaten by a dragon? Or can dragons only eat the less magical ones?


Crystals are minerals. To be a mineral you need to have all of the following; naturally forming, inorganic (never was alive, so not coal), solid at room temperature, and have a predictable atomic structure. Maybe the predictable atomic bonds are sort of a natural focusing lens for magic.


Why are gems magical? The answer popped into my head the moment I heard- well, read the question. Gems have an ability to modify the appearance of light, and that in canon, magic is supposed to be light. It would make sense, considering the most basic of spells, levitation, casts an aura of light onto an object they are levitating. The gems modify how the raw magic going through them work.
Why do dragons love gems? If gems do, indeed, have the ability to modify the magic of a pony, then regular gems must amplify the magic of a pony, and possibly friendship or love. (friendship/love is considered good, aka light) Dragons love to eat gems, and hoard gems, and gems...
Dragons get cranky without gems, and furious when you try to take just a few out of a mountain of gems, like episode Dragonshy. I like to think that dragons aren't greedy, but rather than the greed you perceive, dragons are trying to "hoard" magic, and with their giant size and strength, they are protecters of magic. Dragons clearly aren't dumb, as Spike + Dragonshy shows.


I have a theory, long long ago the two sisters found a strange shaped rock so the decided to cast a spell on it to make it magical the rock turned into a gem and then had special powers discord found out about the gem and tried to steal it the two sisters caught him and discord dropped the gem shattering it the magic from the gem then spread throughout Equestria and landed on several other gems giving them powers as well some evil some good and in the present the gems still hold onto this power. So that was my theory


i have a theory. the magic gems were actually  crystal gems which fought in the rebellion. the homeworld gems used a "portal" as their trash can. as they passed thrpugh the portal, their minds twisted and they werent able to reform bcoz of the magic dimension properties


You can actually put some physical evidence behind this theory. On atomic level gems and crystals in general are defined by a repetitive structure tat spreads throughout the entire stone. Depending on the type they can for example be made up by a cubic, tetrahedric, or hexagonal-prismatic grid.
There can also be flaws in the grid, when a specific section is messed up and screws with the muster of the rest.
Scientists are actually working on systems that allow you to programme these flaws into a gem and later read them out again, thus making a crystal an immense digital storage space.
If you go with the explanation of magic as "another form of science, that we don't have access to", it is very reasonable to assume that the repetitive structure of a crystal is way easier to enchant than other materials. The might even be ways of creating something like a spell matrix inside a chrystal by altering the molecular stucture.


I have a thereoy on how the elements of harmony were created. Ready? <b>Ahem</b> In equestria, there was like, 100 threats, so they needed a way to defeat the evils. Star Swirl took 6 gems. A Ruby, a sapphire, a topaz, a amythest, and a few others. Then, he enchanted them. But, he couldnt really enchant them because he didnt know the strongest type of magic, friendship. But, when clover the clever came, she was the unicorn who helped seal the tear between the 3 tribes. She understanded friendship. so, she asked the three tribes to choose they're most loyal, generous, honest, kindest, and silliest ponies to help. Then, she used her magic to channel their feelings of loyaty, kindess, generosity, etc. and enchanted the gems so powerful, that they could ward off almost any evil. Then, for the sixth gem, Clover the clever poured her magic in, along with all her memories of good times with her friends. Then, the jewels became..DUN DUN DUN...the elements of harmony!

I have a thereoy on how the elements of harmony were created. Ready? *Ahem* In equestria, there was like, 100 threats, so they needed a way to defeat the evils. Star Swirl took 6 gems. A Ruby, a sapphire, a topaz, a amythest, and a few others. Then, he enchanted them. But, he couldnt really enchant them because he didnt know the strongest type of magic, friendship. But, when clover the clever came, she was the unicorn who helped seal the tear between the 3 tribes. She understanded friendship. so, she asked the three tribes to choose they're most loyal, generous, honest, kindest, and silliest ponies to help. Then, she used her magic to channel their feelings of loyaty, kindess, generosity, etc. and enchanted the gems so powerful, that they could ward off almost any evil. Then, for the sixth gem, Clover the clever poured her magic in, along with all her memories of good times with her friends. Then, the jewels became..DUN DUN DUN...the elements of harmony!


My theory to why Diamond Dogs like gems is that they have what I like to call, Magpie Instinct. Magpie Instinct is named after the bird for it's love of shiny things and its irrational need to take them. Which, if you can see by the Diamond Dogs, is pretty much what they have, or they're just ridiculously stupid with there speech patterns and their whole "Pretty pretty shiny" vibe. That's my input anyways.


I think the reason gems are so shiny is because the magical energy inside them and the diamond dogs want the shiny ones because they hold more magic


i think the gems had different types of magic poured into each gem meaning different things


Thank you for explaining how my character travels across the multiverse though a necklace;<br>anymore of my secrets you want to give away?

Thank you for explaining how my character travels across the multiverse though a necklace;
anymore of my secrets you want to give away?


I wonder if the Crystal Empire, being obviously related to crystals is actually what gives gems, crystals and jewels the "default" magic you talked about in the video. It would be understandable if the Crystal Empire would empower crystals worldwide, like a crystal network of some sort. And when the Empire was under the rule of King Sombra, it would affect all of Equestria negatively, leading to the princesses being forced to take him down. As for that time when the Empire disappeared, maybe the crystals were in a way like the tree of harmony, and sustained themselves with the magic they stored until the Empire returned. It's a theory.


I think it might be naturally enchanted by the forces of nature.


I think that maybe the gems are fragments of the Chrystal Empire that spread away across equestria when d'ombra was turned into shadow and the empire vanished... So maybe that explains how they can become light-magic-gems, as for the elements of harmony if influenced by love or some dark-magic-gems like the alicorn amulet that Trixie used, if influenced by hate... Aaand that wuold explain even more my theory that i wrote in the video about the elements of disharmony


Maybe the diamond dogs also use them for magic to disguise as ponies and sell the gems the gems do look really expensive but that's just my theory


The last pun got me. 😆 Maybe the diamond dogs end up trading with bigger dragons? And earn maybe protection or something? Plus why is it when Spike went to the human world he became a dog? And the diamond dogs counterparts where human? I'd have thought maybe dogs from Equestria would become dragons in the human world. 😕


Sorry for out of subject but in wings of fire the book series there's animus (in Latin) dragons that can send power into crystals and make dream visitors and other crystal possessed with power that's why I thought of it

That is my relation with magical crystals in my little pony friendship is magic


I think the container idea was a pretty good idea.


What if the dogs absorb the magic from the gems when they are in their presence?


Well, I think u r right!!!!! Maybe those magical gems could be unknown legendary super duper, and a couple more super dupers, crystals and gems.


I think the diamond dogs just want have so many gems because their pretty and crystals and gems are similar but there completely different like cats and dogs there similar but their completely different.


also the sirens came from the everfree forest and were born with gems but when they switched worlds the gems could be distroyed


I have a theory about diamond dogs, In MLP equestria girls rainbow rock (Player Piano) Rarity needs help with her heavy piano so she calls the diamond dogs and they seem to be interested in her for another reason than the equestrian diamond dogs, I think your theory about the pretty stuffs is the right one.


We are the crystal gems, we'll always save the day!


I kind of like rock puns. But my FAVORITE part was the "wa wa wa" it's SO funny!! 😊😊😊😊😊 by the way I'm a girl. 😊😊😊


Loving your theory. I think all gems are magical cos why Not?


what if in equestria instead of the piezoelectric effect there is a piezomagical effect? <br>or something like that.

what if in equestria instead of the piezoelectric effect there is a piezomagical effect?
or something like that.


i think you are right about the magic rock stuff


Those rock jokes were so funny (i looked in a dictionary and i finally said "oh i get it!"


I think u have a fairly good point about the gems and jars and stuff ...but I do think ur a bit off. Instead of jars I think some gems are actually rooted to some sort of magic just mean really.we already know that they can be found under ground and the diamond dogs are searching for those special gems that come in contact with a magical source like the alicorn amulet..but I could be wrong it's just a guess


Sorry for out of subject but this reminded me of wings of fire book series when a animus (in Latin) dragon touches a mineral or crystal and sends power into it to make a dream visitor or anything else that relates to a powered crystal

That's my relation with my little pony friendship is magic


Orrrrrrrrrrrr unicorns just favored enchanting jewels. I mean, there is no evidence in the show that says they can't just enchant anything. Even things that have no magic. Dragons and Diamond Dogs like them because they are sparkly and valuable.  And the empire thing is because there just happens to be a great magic in the area, so, to highlight that, they made everything out of elegant crystal to establish that they are important and stuff, cause if I personally saw someone with a castle with these blue diamonds, I would think that they where a very magical important figure.  So this theory is now debunked, at least by my standard.

Imnothatingijustwantedtopointoutwhythisisprobablynottruebutitsjustatheoryamlptheorythanksforreading


i think with the diamond dogs with them i think they want them because maybe a PONY could of told the diamond dogs that the crystals or gems are magical because those dogs look dirty and stupid so maybe a pony could of told them that the gems were magic so as they look dirty and they probably are because there digging for the gems and there magic. and some gems might be powerful then others because some contain lots of gems with lots of ponies and even if there really powerful like the empire one gem would contain less.


but aren't the elements of harmony suppost to be magical gems that have been there since before celestia and luna could even speak then who cast a spell on them or are they gems like take the chaos emeralds from sonic the back story on those is that the gods created ultimate sources of unlimited power into seven mystical emeralds and one bigger emerald to control these if they get out of hand so couldn't we say the elements of harmony are like the chaos emeralds that they were created by gods to benefit the world


Can you please do a video on the tree of harmony and where the elements of harmony.


We
Are the crystal
gems

we'll always save the day!


I think i think that they are looking for magic in the gems like you said it holds magic in them


I think the diamond dogs eat the gems to get stronger!


I agree that gems have magic energy but in Cutie Mark Chronicles Rarity was brought by her horn to a rock filled with gems but what attracted Raritys horn to bring her to the rock well I think that unicorn magic and gems is kinda like a magnet I guess Rariyts magic them was so weak the gems attracted her horn instead in the episode where Rarity was looking for gems then found the diamond dogs I saw that on the collar of the diamond dogs was a gem or a jewel I guess Rariyts magic was still too weak and it drew her in again still I'm not sure about all of this PLEASE HELP MEEEEEE!


I have only seen Spike eat gems, and maybe that's why he never grew up! The only way to break the spell is to hoard. Interesting theory or no?


After this video was uploaded 'make new friends but keep discord' came out, where the 'smooze' eats gems and grows while glowing.


I woke up my family just replaying hundreds of time at the beginning


Diamond dogs have gems on their collars. Enough said.


O God... The puns... Are giving me... FLASHBACKS!!!! Time to chalk them up on the pun list OH COME ONE!


Yea puns really... Really funny totally loled myself!


Notion i have a question Starlight Glimmer looks like the purple siren from Equestria girls but she smiles more can you explain Starlight to the purple siren? (  forgot the purple siren's name)


dude, I loved the jokes and good job!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Maybe the dogs are searching for a magical gem so they could use the power of the gems


It's a possibility, but I don't think we're gonna get a answer from the show, kid show and all


Interesting is that the gems are taking out from the underground just grinded.


If the Diamond dogs don't eat the gems, then what do they eat?


Maybe the diamond dogs have some god that they worship or something and they give them gems to show their respects? You never know!


Maybe the diamond dogs sell their gems to dragons.


Sunset Shimmer, Twilight Sparkle, Starlight Glimmer.<br>They've gotta be cousins or something.

Sunset Shimmer, Twilight Sparkle, Starlight Glimmer.
They've gotta be cousins or something.


Can I be on your channel some day. I think your theories are very interesting and I would like to discus some of my theories with you


The sirens gems aren't actually magical their host to an evil spirit star swirl defeated long ago that like all other chaos spirits feed of of disharmony like discord.


Is it me or did king sombra sound kinda like soos off of gravity falls


So,then if there gems or whatever spike can eat the elements of whatever and be the most powerful thing in the world?


gems are so magical cause they came from the Everfree forest


Why are gems magical? Because: "Gems. Gems are truly outrageous......They are truly truly truly, outrageous."

-Taric


Well There Are The Other Element Of Harmony Before Than Ts,Rr,Rt,Pp,Fs,Aj So Theres Something Might Be Possesed In These Gems Like Before Villians And Hero That Is Most Known As Powerful


its true we do crave them ;3 we eat them as a snack


If Dragons eat jewels, they poop with. ...Glitter?


<b>*Steven Universe theme plays muffled in the distance*</b>

**Steven Universe theme plays muffled in the distance**


im surprised at no chaos emerald reference thats actually the only reason (i watched to hear about chaos emeralds)


I think Gems use Magic to all the ponies and the dog


I though all of those puns were pretty funny


These rock jokes were pretty good though.


I think the diamond dogs want gems and jewels so the can be rich!


duude, all computers are crystals (at least for now) =)


I think they're magical cuz they're SHINY!!!!   :3


Same with safire! Safire stone safire shores!! Think a connection? Maybe


'Watches beginning' RAH crystals dies laughing XD


Sen animals are attracted to shiny things so I think the dds are too


before I watch this video, gems are powerfull for one reason ... steven universe


about the dogs... they're just looking for shinies.


my name being diamond i get alot or puns with it so i laughed for your puns


i was really hoping for a Steven Universe joke


I swear I heard you say the Omelets of Harmony...


you are telling us the gem's are made out a magic


I think the dogs just want awe Mutch pretty and shiney things like I want as many DW action figures I only have a few rn couse if they eat them then they wouldn't give all of the gems to rarity sooooo us


I think that the dogs just like shiney things


i think the cristal hart is the seven elament of harmony

cristal hart=princess Catoens(<--i know i spelled dat wrong


I think the diamond dogs like gems because they need food


OH MY GOD YOU PUT TOM IN THERE
and than the puns...
Really?


Why did pinkie eat rocks?umm.... you know!rock candy or candy rock or what ever!?
BOO
this is gonna be a joke!


The puns were "punny" to me though (get it punny if not well okie)


they eat rock candy so and I thought he hit rock bottom


we, are the crystal gems......OH WAIT NO I FORGOT ABOUT SPIKE NOPE NOPE NOPE


These jokes work have you red my name its a gem


wait was calling gems ROCKS a joke becose that was funny


I have a better ANSWER everyone! Watch Steven universe..that's how gems are magical


i think the dogs are just dumbly looking for sparkles.


3:26 that's it, I'm done watching these

I want a real answer DX


Gems are magical because Steven universe


Meaby gems are a magical resources whitch pony's ,dragons, and dogs need


Rarity x spike

Rarity should b an alicorn


there group name is the diamond dogs right well there maybe addicted to diamonds and equstria is a magical world so there might be crazy things no effence  Hasbro but yeah it's a crazy world eyup


This is fake in real life a gem is magic because there is always a spirt of the gem like in my jasper


I wanted to make a Bj joke about this but it blows, and you will think it sucks


They are spoiled or should I say Jewled 💎(Drum) yah that wasn't that funny


Are you going to make good videos, ore are you just going to make shitty puns? Of quartz you would go with puns...


пони 2 грозки


<b>gasp!</b> oh now i know what u meant by that last joke hahahahhahahahahaha <3 she farted, am i right? l:T

*gasp!* oh now i know what u meant by that last joke hahahahhahahahahaha <3 she farted, am i right? l:T


Oh cheeses Christ them jokes are so cheet


Dumbly searching bro and for info I'm a girl


Serisly  the puns! Please gem are magical dragons are dum.they whant eneything that shinig


Oh god stop!!!! For the sake of humanity, STOP!!!!!


Ok this is my thought: srry I don't speak englesh

And I'm not stupid I know how to spell * drums start * get it spell GET IT SPELL HEY WHO STOLE MY LAUHTRACK


Personally I've always found the Diamond Dogs to be that sort of dumb and semi-obligatory dumb species in any fantasy. Like Kobolds and Goblins in most fantasies and Murloks in Warcraft (since their goblins are actually the most intelligent, having contraptions such as mechs, airships and even motorbikes) and the Diamond Dogs are driven to gather gems in order to try and harness their magical powers. However maybe they aren't meant to use magic, but they don't know it, hence their massive hoarding of gems, since they may figure that if they can't draw magic from a few gems, they MUST be able to do so from hundreds if not thousands of them.

This "All Gems and Crystals possess some measure of magic inside them" also lines up with a theory that seems VERY prevalent as fact in the Final fantasy series as a whole. Crystals in Final fantasy are used as sources of power, able to allow empires to create airships of war that border on science fiction, and to give cities electricity and heating.

This theory I have however goes like this.

When you get a massive, massive, MASSIVE amount of a specific type of magic or energy focused in a small area due to pressure, that energy will concentrate to the point that the particle bond to create stones, gems and crystals. These crystals, gems and stones are then conduits for these magics, able to store them in and collect them from ambient sources, while also allowing the right minds to harness them in creations of enchanted items such as swords, necklaces and even machinery.

As to how dragons can stomach gems, well... there are scientific theories around the biology of literal dragons (which are seeming to be more and more real from very few really gnarly and wicked-looking bones) in how they can breathe fire.

It went along the lines of "Dragons ingest a special mineral which is then turned into a form of gas, this happens in a second stomach, and the inside of a dragon possesses some kind of ability to create a spark of some kind" I think.

But even if ignoring that, Dragons likely use gems in order to gain magic to create the flame that they can breathe. It would make perfect sense as nothing that dragons otherwise eat would allow them to breathe fire. Cartoon or not, laws of life still apply, just in different ways, magic is the fuel that dragons need for their most effective form of self-defense and attack, since they can't harness magic themselves like Unicorns can since...

Well a Unicorn's horn is a literal focusing rod for magical energies, though more for raw magical energy.

That's just my 2 cents anyways.


Oh my gosh. I love your puns and wordplays so much.
I completely agree with you that gems contain magic; certain gems contain different types of magic and conduct it differently.
From the beginning, this was a gneiss theory. Basalt, that would explain the elements, the Crystal Heart, and the amulet.
It also explains the dragons' apatite and extreme growth when consuming large amounts of gems. Yeah, it's also their greed, but, I mean, when you're fed up with crystallllsssss...
Sorry, I'm doing asbestos I can and I'm not sure if it's working. Granite, these puns all rock when I say them, but are probably pretty boron to you all.
Well, I still have a few others. We could talc about how Cadance's cutie mark portrays the Crystal Heart, and that they glowed at the same time when the Empire was restored. I have a theory about that one. However, it's too long to post here, so I shale save it for another time. Of quartzite could just send it to you, Notion, and see what you think. :)
Sorry if this comment was a bit agate*ing for you. I had fun writing this. I'll clean my *slate by next Thursday, so no puns on the next video. Unless I see that it fits into the context.

And I challenge The Brony Notion to a pun-war.

Oh my gosh. I love your puns and wordplays so much.
I completely agree with you that gems contain magic; certain gems contain different types of magic and conduct it differently.
From the beginning, this was a *gneiss* theory. *Basalt*, that would explain the elements, the Crystal Heart, and the amulet.
It also explains the dragons' *apatite* and extreme growth when consuming large amounts of gems. Yeah, it's also their greed, but, I mean, when you're fed up with crystallllsssss...
Sorry, I'm doing *asbestos* I can and I'm not sure if it's working. *Granite*, these puns all *rock* when I say them, but are probably pretty *boron* to you all.
Well, I still have a few others. We could *talc* about how Cadance's cutie mark portrays the Crystal Heart, and that they glowed at the same time when the Empire was restored. I have a theory about that one. However, it's too long to post here, so I *shale* save it for another time. Of *quartzite* could just send it to you, Notion, and see what you think. :)
Sorry if this comment was a bit *agate*ing for you. I had fun writing this. I'll clean my *slate* by next Thursday, so no puns on the next video. Unless I see that it fits into the context.

And I challenge The Brony Notion to a pun-war.


Thats a really good theory!

 (Spoiler alert!!!)

It also explains how when the elements of harmony in the pilot, when nightmare moon crushed them, the magic inside "escapes" ofcourse the magic of friendship fills them with magic and repairs them again later.


This is actually a very good theory. From all we've seen, most of the time, some sort of very powerful magical element had a some sort of envolvement with a a crystal. The Crystal Heart, The Elements Of Harmony, even Twilight's Crown. So it is very possible that this theory is correct.
------
Also, So Many Puns xD Annie one else approve of the puns? Or was he just digging his own graves?
...
I'm...i'm not the best with puns .-.


I have often figured that crystals amplify dark magic, since every time we see dark magic it's being cast on a crystal and projected outward (except for the time vision potion, Twilight cast dark magic directly on that. Not sure why she used dark magic, but whatever) I figure Sombra wanted the Crystal Empire because the whole city is one big amplifier, so he'd be more powerful there than anywhere else.


I think that when some magic escapes it's beholder it is absorbed by gems closer to the surface. But the gems farther from the surface have less magic.<br>


It just so happens that in this dimension, gems are able to hold and control magic energy and possibly other types. I had been looking into this theory but never considered it to be in MLP... Nice theory.


First off I just need to say that your rock/gem puns were on point. Anyways, your theory about the Diamond Dogs is great, but I don't think they're that magically knowledged to know about much magic. They seem like miners, or some kind of workers or even thieves. Gems are valuable, and probably could earn them coins. So, they could be wanting these gems for money and wealth, but them just collecting them dumbly because they look good sounds about right


I think you're right! in fact, this same "magic storing" property is found in a lot of games I play! For instance, in most (if not all) the elder scrolls games, there are crystals called "soul gems".


Perhaps the gems have different storages of magic because of how much it happens or occurs so the gems then gain the powers that are appearing, unseen though. And the gems might be also powerful because for the dark gem that made people evil, (not the singing gems) maybe the usage of how many people using it caused how much power is being gained or lost.


I have a theory to blow your mind.
As said by the notion dragons benefit from the magic in gems. But they also benefit from other rypes of magic, as shown when spikes  'friends' try to eat phoenix eggs. I think that depending on the color of the dragon, different gems give them most power. As the leader in the gang of spikes 'friends' was red and the phoenix magic would give most power. Dragons are magical creatures and magic benefits them. I think since spike was born of twilights magic, her alicorn magic will age spike without the negative side effects greed has. Since greed (could be ) an element of disharmony. If it exists. The elements of disharmony probably existed in pony medieval times. (That is information from an episode ). I'm guessing dragons came into contact with ponies during that time.
My hamster approves of this theory.


this is the most underrated show I have come across so far xD well let me add a one to it, good show and I hope you continue to create more in the future


I think the diamond dogs want the gems because they know the gems contain magic and, not being able to preform magic/ not being a "magical creature", collects the gems to provide more magic to themselves


If Spike and Rarity had a child (or any dragon and any pony), I feel like the child would look like a pony, though I know many people think they'd be a dragon-pony hybrid. But since they would still have a dragon as a parent, no matter what they looked like, they'd some qualities that dragons have. For example, eating gems. So if a unicorn and dragon had a child, would the gems the child ate strengthen their magic? Because, if so, that would be a really interesting thought. After a while, their magic would get <b>really</b> strong and they would be able to do more complicated spells. maybe their magic would strengthen so much it could rival Twilight's. I dunno.

If Spike and Rarity had a child (or any dragon and any pony), I feel like the child would look like a pony, though I know many people think they'd be a dragon-pony hybrid. But since they would still have a dragon as a parent, no matter what they looked like, they'd some qualities that dragons have. For example, eating gems. So if a unicorn and dragon had a child, would the gems the child ate strengthen their magic? Because, if so, that would be a really interesting thought. After a while, their magic would get *really* strong and they would be able to do more complicated spells. maybe their magic would strengthen so much it could rival Twilight's. I dunno.


Crystals have special molecular structures, so a fantasy story could very use that as a way to store magical energy. As Plastic is a crystal, an interesting Speculative Fantasy story could be about people in such a world inventing plastic, and seeing its effects on society and the world.

In G1, Applejack inserted gems into the eyes of ponies who were blinded by years of underground slavery serving an evil wizard by collecting gems, and the gems in their eyes allowed them to see again. (the wizard's name was Ruby, and the story was originally in, like, welsh. also, AJ killed Ruby. G1 was like that)

The G1 Princess ponies all had actual gems in the centers of their Cutiemarks, and they were some of the few ponies capable of manipulating nature- generally, the weather manipulators were non-ponies, such as the Dell Dwellers (who did most of it in their factories) and the Weather Witch. Sure, Queen Majesty's "whatever the plot demands and often what it doesn't" complete overkill powers controlled nature, but they also controlled EVERYTHING ELSE. Also, the reason Stars are a thing in G1 is because Twilight bound them to the night, or something like that.

There's a reason I ship Twijesty, and that is because, given their personalities, Dream Valley would be an even worse hellhole than in canon if they weren't, like, together, or at least very close friends, and it is impossible to imagine G1! "I will only come out at night while covered in mist and speak cryptically while screwing with you" Twilight or Queen "I am like Trollestia, but much much worse and regularly condemn relative innocents to fates worse than death for mildly inconveniencing myself or my subjects and am also a terrible mother to my son whom I created using only magic" as having any friends at all.
(also this way Lucky gets at least one good mom, because in the G1 Pilot, Twilight is shown to be an excellent parental figure to Ember)


That is a nice theory and I personally think they are just the best materials at conducting magic, like metals conduct electricity


If hoarding gems as a Dragon causes them to grow and become more greedy, perhaps loose the ability to talk maybe that's the opposite for diamond dogs

The magic within the gems could be what gives them the ability to talk or 'think' beyond that of an animal. notice how the armored dogs without gems don't really talk.


I think the diamond dogs want the gems for wealth. I mean, they DO live underground, and it'd be much nicer for actual shelter. And dogs in real life go after objects that "amuse" them, so maybe the diamond dogs want it for wealth AND for...the sake of having them. Kind of like a chew toy? I lost my thought....


I just thought of something to support your theory, related to the crystal heart. The crystal empire. Celestia stated that the crystal empire spreads love, light, and happiness all over equestria. Wouldn't that mean the crystal empire, being made of crystal, would be one of the most magical places in equestria?

Also, in "Castle Sweet Castle", the gems in the chandelier hold memories, and could they do that without magic?


so this shows I'm not the only one thinking about gems actually being able to absorb and contain aetherical energy.
I made an entire 8 chapters book on the magic about gems in the way I think it works, how to keep it and how to bear it, even for earth ponies and pegasus.
And this is just for the world of a fanfiction I will constantly create but not being able of writing it down...


I love your videos and think that  these theories are mostly true, and very interesting.


What if only hoofed animals like deers, horses, goats etc. are natrually sentient in equestria, and the rest like dragons or diamond dogs get their sentience from magic, such as the magic stored in gems? Just a random though I felt like throwing out there.<br>Nice video~

What if only hoofed animals like deers, horses, goats etc. are natrually sentient in equestria, and the rest like dragons or diamond dogs get their sentience from magic, such as the magic stored in gems? Just a random though I felt like throwing out there.
Nice video~


Speaking about gems, I would like to make a point. How was Luna able to defeat Discord with Celestia in the episode where The Everfree Forest invaded Equestria when earlier (or a few thousand years ago) in the episode she was defeated by the Elements? I would like you to make a video about this @The Brony Notion because you are good at theories and I think you will understand the point I'm trying to make. This is very hard to explain and find the answer to... So if you are a genius and think you can answer my question, i have fun in the comments below this comment. By the way @The Brony Notion , if you do a video on this, you will earn a few more subs because LUNA IS BEST PONY!!!


To me it seems that rarity's gem finding spell comes from her special talent


Has brony notion ever explained "magic" itself? What it is?<br>Because i've been going through the show, with the theory, that "magic" is just a word, that represents the usage of contolled magnetic fields, but... the more i think about it, the harder it gets to understand and explain it.

Has brony notion ever explained "magic" itself? What it is?
Because i've been going through the show, with the theory, that "magic" is just a word, that represents the usage of contolled magnetic fields, but... the more i think about it, the harder it gets to understand and explain it.


If gems were actually conselers then some day they would lose there magic. So if your theory is correct then the crystal Heart, elements of harmony, and alacorn amulet would all lose power and would creat chaos.


About the Diamond Dogs,I think they are only after money.Let's put it this way.If they found that many gems,they can exchange it with a unicorn for money.Although the eating gems theory also works,as I also think they could be using it as energy and are faintly related to dragons.


I cannot see why gems wouldn't be inherently magical nor why they couldn't store magic, as crystals have long been associated with mystical properties by many cultures and in fiction.

I do prefer to think that Diamond Dogs are just magpies that love gemstones, though that is only because we didn't really get to see all that much of them or their motivations. As for dragons, well, it is fairly possible they just enjoy eating gems as that is really the only context upon which we have seen Spike eat them. It may be fun to guess at a deeper meaning, but it is something I prefer to take at face value unless something comes along to complicate things.


I think that something happened when star swirl tuned to discord and affected some of the gems and thousands of moons later somepony found them and wanted to sell it not knowing the power.


All of The Brony Notions puns are hilarious even if he sometimes shoots them down all by himself. They bring to light how funny just a simple play on words can do.


Crystal Abilities/What they do to you or others:
(Note that these can be related to one of the Crystals of Harmony, Crystals of Harmony have their own since that is what keeps the pony world together.)
Red: Makes any pony MAD crazy for power, proof is that The Siren's gems are red, and is the Alicorn Necklace too.
Blue: Spread of Love. Proof:the crystal heart is blue... (And maybe because it is a heart shape)


i'd say that diamond dogs want the gems for basically the same reasons ponies do, for enchanting and making magical artifacts.


Oh, god. For Celestia's sake, go watch Ink Rose!!! The elements of harmony WERE just regular gems, until Star Swirl and Clover the Clever enchanted them. Star Swirl took five of the most loyal, funny, kind, generous, and honest earth ponies, pegasai, and unicorns, had them remember the time they demonstrated this trait, and used his magic to import the trait into each crystal. Then, Clover the Clever imported some of her most powerful magic into the final gem, thus creating the Elements of Magic, Laughter, Kindness, Honesty, Loyalty, and Generosity. Years before, the Castle of the Two Sisters was built above the ravine where the Tree of Harmony was. Star Swirl suggested they Celestia and Luna there because it would make them feel more powerful. (Well, DUH! It's got their cutie marks on there!) Nearly 2,000 years later, Twilight gave up the Elements to the Tree of Harmony, releasing Celestia and Luna. Will Celie and Luna return with the element bearers? Or will Twilight have to go into exile there in the far, far future? MAKE IT A VIDEO!!!


Those rock puns we're definitely worth putting in: ) Maud would be proud


if your theroy is right about the gems i think the diamond dogs might make a appearance in season 5. the way they collect gems and the gems have power maybe stored together there creating something ?


The gems are magical idea is a core concept in the fallout equestria. The arcane science of that universe is a progressed form of the enchantment of gems combined with advanced technology.


Idea for a video: Do Sunset Shimmer and Princess Celestia have some sort of relationship? I mean think about it.

Their cutie marks are both Suns. Sunset shimmer's name has gotten to do with the sun,  Celestia's job has also gotten to do with the sun.


I love really corny puns. Second best comedy to me. First is irony.


i so agree that gems can hold magic abilities


When he said 'the crystals and the gems' the first thing came to my mind was Steven Universe and the Crystal Gems.


Well, it doesn't have to be that ALL gems are innately magical, but maybe the magical "gems" - or artifacts - we see are just fused magic.  Like, if the Elements of Harmony were (instead of the retcon-creating tree [ugh]) the spirits of several powerful ponies who died for a righteous cause, and so became the essence of their most defining attribute as they died, or were made into them to preserve their souls.  By that theory, the Crystal Heart may well be the spiritual essence of the Crystal Princess, imbued with a love for her people.

I actually have some interesting theories on several aspects of Equestrian magic.
Maybe I should try for horse-fame!
(Or maybe I'll just stick to commenting on others' YouTube videos)


interesting theory, although crystals are crystalline in structure if anything the sapphire cupcake wold take like glass, just a bunch of glass shard in your mouth ouch if you aren't able to stomach them


This vid is a gem! You totally made that theory crystal clear! U ROCK the brony notion!


The Diamond Dogs are probably driven by instincts more than brain power.  what little brain matter they have, might have to be fueled by simply holding gems.


your gem theory is good but I think the dogs are only attracted to gems like magpies because the gems are shiny and colorful.


What if the Diamond Dogs wanted the gems because of greed?  Rarity, being the element of generosity, would clearly be at odds with greed based creatures, right?


excuse me but the crystal heart isnt exactly a gem, its a relic.


The Sirens gems could actually be the same gem as Trixie's amulet, but it is very far-fetched.


your rock jokes make me groan. please keep using them. :3


And I think that they want to invade the crystal empire because if all gems have magic in them that means that they will gane lots more power because ......well......you know lots of magic in the city .... You know


Maybe the diamond dogs collect gems\diamonds? Like how people have rock collections.... they could be like that!


Your puns are as funny as Danny's ax puns in "Beauty Marked" (Danny Phantom). XD


those cupcakes look so good your amazing at jokes by the way


Brony Notion the gems that are magical could have come from the crystal empire at times but then you also forgot about the tree of harmony (say this because it look like a crystal tree which it is) that the elements of harmony come. But that just my opinion and observation.


I thought all the rock puns were funny. I laughed so hard I ROCKED the house! Get it?


I think this video just blew every Steven Universe fan's minds.


Well the reason elements are magical because they come from the tree of harmony first of all u forgot that also that not all gems have power only certain ones as u said the Alicon amulet is magical but how anyway all of the magic must come from the elements because the elements is what help protects equestria because discord nightmare moon so maybe that is what powers the magical gems the elements well thanks anyway for this'd


I believe the dogs gather gems because they can be used as currency. In 'Rarity Takes Manehattan' she gives a doorstallion/bellhop pony a gem and tells him to 'keep the change'.


Captions: "actually capable of spreading love entire empire or giving Tony Stark magic"

lovely.


when you got to the 'Diamond Dogs' biit, that reminds me...

Ever read or listen to @Illya Leonov's reading of "Leviathan" ?


I think you should do a episode on Celsita and Luna and there relationship between Them with King Sombra


love the puns lines XD

preatty much agree on every point you make and i think the D-dogs are just after them for the shiiiiiny preatty geams that sparkels XD
(ther presessssss)


Pinkie prefer normal rocks to eat, they have a special kind of magic. Thar's why a rock farm exist.<br>And some humans eat rocks.

Pinkie prefer normal rocks to eat, they have a special kind of magic. Thar's why a rock farm exist.
And some humans eat rocks.


In our human world, gems are usually thought to be able to channel energy and help people harness energy. This is brushed off in our scientific world, but in a magical world of Equestria, I imagine that jewels in Equestria naturally conducts magic through them- like metal conducts electricity.

I like your dragon theory more than Rarity's gem finding power. If it's really because she's a unicorn and can sense the magic from the gems, surely we would see Twilight sensing them as well, or maybe the Earth ponies, since gems are from the Earth.  Plus, Rarity's gem finding power is a part of her cutie mark- she gets it after finding out she can naturally find gems (which she then uses for fashion). After all, her cutie mark is diamonds not a needle and thread.

Dragons probably just have a stronger jaw/digestive system and can eat rocks. I mean, they also breathe fire and can stand to swim in lava- so they're quite durable as far as creatures in Equestria go. As for Diamond Dogs, I think they probably gain power from having gems around them. It could be a visual thing, but we also see them wandering with pockets full of gems- so they could be able to absorb the magic through touch.  The gems might be the source of their limited speech/reasoning abilities, since they're portrayed as dumb but not like animals (Ursa Minor/Major).

@IANOYTYK What I read from Young Discoverers:
"Crocodiles eat rocks.About 20 percent of a croc's weight maybe rocks."
It may be a fusion of the Crocs,and the king cobra.


I think that the dimond dogs are holding gems because there trying to get more power to invade cantorlot or the. Cristal empire to gane control over the ponys


Why are all gems in equestria perfectly cut and polished in the ground?


All rocks and metals are technically crystals.


I sorta have a question.. What's up with both Luna and Celestias hair? Why is it magical and no one else's is...?


The diamond dogs are just the mp version of high school bullies who take your lunch money.


Hey Brony Notion, are pony's cutie marks directly related to their names? It just seems like their names describe their cutie marks, like Berry Punch's cutie mark is berries. Like, when their parents give their kids a name, do they have an idea of what their future may be? Reply plz!


Question: WHY ARE THERE PERFCTLY-CUT GEMS JUST LYING IN PATCHES IN THE GROUND??? (sorry for caps :/)


I think the dogs want money cause gems are valuable


Every time I see one of ur videos I keep thinking of that twilight sparkle or princess celestia is probably one of the daughters of the wizard god something so yeah


did anyone else realise that 1:07 there was a green element of harmony. ha! what would that element even be


why didn't spike eat the crystal heart or the alicorn thing or the elements of harmony


Pfft. No eating rocks? BITCH! (Pardon my language) I eat ROCKcandy all the time. It taste soooo good! I cant get enough. I know what their magic is! Its getting people hooked on the first clump they bite into! That stuff is just WAY to good to be that cheap.


Does Sweet Apple Acres produce applesauce?


Mabye its the way the gems are cut and crafted. what supports this idea is that of the magical gems we have seen all of them have a special shape and with the alicorn amulet it was in a special necklace. As for the sirens it was shown In twilights book about them that the gems are a part of them only in the human form are they spate. The shape also seems to change what magic they have the crystal HEART spreads love and the elements of harmony are shaped like the cutie marks of the ponies with those personality traits.


Hank is offended you didn't use the word "mineral"


explain the chaos emeralds, sol emeraslds and master emerald


What does rarity's gem.or diamonds represent? Or does her cutie mark also represent magic or something?


I think the Diamond Dogs just sell their gems.


dude there is a youtuber called Ink Rose and shes makin stories (therois) about the elements of harmony


I think that gems jewels and crystals are full of magic because little kids and girls think gems and crystals are "good" &  "pretty" like remember playing with gems and stuff when you were little pretending that they could cast magical spells on you? Now your catching on.


in the second line of my speech, I ment to say rockcandy. Not rockcany! lol


speaking of gems, my name is Gemstar! XD


brony notion, rarity went behind you going off finding some gems


Jesus Christ Marie! They're Minerals! xD


* WAITS CALMLY FOR WITCHCRAFT TO HELP EXPLAIN *...


My holiday is here finally!! Momma is making homemade chili Colorado! Yay!


Idk why but I found every pun you said in this video very punny. See what I did there?


Maybe diamond dogs just like jems like come on who doesn't


Maybe it has something to do with steven universe


Interesting theory! Or should i say...
puntastic...no...ok. lol
PUNS,SO MANY PUNS!


rocks are crystals but crystals are not rocks


My cutie mark is a heart gem like the crystal empire's crystal heart


I tink they put on
The floor and cover
Them in
Dirt


trys to think of rock pun*<br>I got nothing

trys to think of rock pun*
I got nothing


I know why the dogs like gems. They want to be rich.


I'm with u on Jews but I think the dogs eat then that why there called diamond dogs


i guess you could say this video was very punny HA


I found it funny,really...people be like,😐I be like,😂😆😅😝😄😃😁😀


So what i`m about to say, is weird. If Pinkie Pie can eat rockcandy, why can`t people/ponys eat rocks? (aka, gems) Spike eats gems, alot. Pinkie eats rockcandy, that`s like saying, "I like to eat rocks." that`s weird. Rockcany is rocks, but dyed? Sapphire Cupcakes are cupcakes but with gems. You can`t eat rocks/gems normally in real life, but how can Pinkie stand eating rockcandy if their dyed? Warned you it was weird!


That's actually a good theory coming from u just not good puns


There magic because the thingy ms boby book said so


The diamond dogs are just greedy as fuck. They don't care for magical value, they just like things that could, possibly, be worth a fortune.


I HAS EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT UR THEORY!! please respond

someone on twitter who works on the show (dunno who) said that only animals with hooves can talk.. donkey, horse, mule, cow, deer, sheep so on so worth
but dogs have PAWS not HOOVES!!!!! so they want so many gems so they can communicate.... another theory based on that THAT'S WHY THERE GRAMMAR NO GOOD

P.P.S those puns were really funny/punny :P

P.S I was talking about MLP one day to my non-brony friends and out of all the people on youtube of the brony community he watched you! not to sound bad but... you aren't the most popular one out there.. and now we talk about your videos together (I think i made him a brony)


I lovded the 1 joke hahahahahhahahahahhaha...!!


How about this Was discord a pony?<br>PLZ


The subtitles on this are just...weird. O_O


How does he now that I mean look at his cutie mark


@The Brony Notion Yeah, its some stupid "Shiny" thing. .-. In that episode they obviously kept repeating the word "Shiny". Did I even have to explain that?


yes you do look like a geoaligist because you are gray and stone is gray


can you stop with the rock puns my joke in my earlier comment on an old vid i said "pinkie pje rocks!" that was a good rock joke


some were actualy funny fyi im ten my spellings fine


Bad joke there in the beginning of the video


IDK. LOL. And plz stop the puns dude. I'm starting to get a headache dude. 😲


This reminds me of the man from CNN Student News... ":/


<sarcasm>BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!<br>THOSE PUNS SUCKED!!! BOOOOOO!!! </sarcasm>

<sarcasm>BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!
THOSE PUNS SUCKED!!! BOOOOOO!!! </sarcasm>


HI MOM IM USING THE INTERWEBS (I'm so cool 😝😎)


No offense but you have got to work on your jokes.


I think the dogs are just stupid there useless I don't even know why they had to make a episode of stupid dogs making Rarity find gems the dogs are never seen anywhere else in any other episodes why did they make these stupid dogs in the first place oh i know why cause they didn't have any good ideas and they thought let's make some stupid ugly gem dogs to make Rarity cry and complain half of the episode cause it the best idea ever NOT! I think this is why they made these stupid dogs and I know if this might not make sense but to me it dose well this is the longest comment I ever typed I guess I'm done 😄


apuesto que no sabe lo que escribi <br>reed this an pos me if you now what is sead

apuesto que no sabe lo que escribi
reed this an pos me if you now what is sead