I never thought that if there were more stallions in the mane six, that the power would be weaker. I always thought that there should be a stallion or more for the main six because it would give a message to kids that you can make friends with anybody. But I think it is true, same genders have more of a chance to be friends with each other than non same genders.


Actually, I think the Elements were reserved for the Mane 6 specifically. My proof is in Twilight's Kingdom, where the Mane 6 get up, unfazed by Tirek, while the rest of Equestria is left paralyzed (Except the other 3 alicorns, Discord and Spike, but draconequus magic is an unknown, I don't think Spike had much taken away from him except his fax abilities, and the other 3 alicorns gave up their magic as opposed to having it stolen, so that's something different altogether). How did they get up so quickly? Their magic was stolen, but not all of it. The Mane 6 have protected magic inside them; magic that, when combined with the power within the chest, was amplified so many times, they themselves became one with their Element of Harmony. Think about it... Why would their remaining magic be amplified to be equal to that of the Elements? It's obvious... that magic IS the Elements! But who's to say they didn't pick this up when they first used the Elements? Maybe what happened was the Elements' magic fused with the Mane 6's magic and vice versa when they were used. I don't think so, because there's something else I want to bring up. Even as fillies, the Mane 6 still represented their Elements:

 - Rainbow Dash showed Loyalty through her motivation to start the race to defend Fluttershy

 - Fluttershy showed Kindness when calming down the woodland critters after the Rainboom

 - Applejack showed Honesty in Manehattan when she stopped trying to hide who she was

 - Rarity showed Generosity by using the gems she found purely for the school play... thing

 - Pinkie Pie showed Laughter by throwing that party to get her family to at least smile

Notice something here? This all happened when they got their cutie marks! And we all know that cutie marks are a form of magic, so what do you suppose that means? Between this and the first topic, it's quite obvious. The protected magic inside them was ALWAYS there! But that leaves us with perhaps the most peculiar question of all... Namely, "Why doesn't Twilight fit into this trend?" If we remember how Twilight got her cutie mark, magical crap was blowing up, and Celestia came in and Twily got her CM. How she got her cutie mark: Magic. Her Element: Magic. Voila! But it's not that simple. When she used the same kind of magic on the Elements to make the sixth appear, nothing happened. It was the Magic of Friendship that caused it to appear, and it was the Magic of Friendship that was used every time after that. It's even in her cutie mark: She was destined to meet the rest of the group. And yet, even as a filly, proved in the BBBFF song, she didn't understand the Magic of Friendship. Anyone else noticing a contradiction here? The Mane 6 had their "Elemental magic" in them from the start, and yet Twilight was against hers. We see in the pilot that she was appalled by the very idea of making friends, so why would that be her destiny; her Element? I don't have all the answers yet, but other than that, this theory is fairly plausible.

Actually, I think the Elements were reserved for the Mane 6 specifically. My proof is in Twilight's Kingdom, where the Mane 6 get up, unfazed by Tirek, while the rest of Equestria is left paralyzed (Except the other 3 alicorns, Discord and Spike, but draconequus magic is an unknown, I don't think Spike had much taken away from him except his fax abilities, and the other 3 alicorns gave up their magic as opposed to having it stolen, so that's something different altogether). How did they get up so quickly? Their magic was stolen, but not all of it. The Mane 6 have protected magic inside them; magic that, when combined with the power within the chest, was amplified so many times, they themselves became one with their Element of Harmony. Think about it... Why would their remaining magic be amplified to be equal to that of the Elements? It's obvious... that magic _IS_ the Elements! But who's to say they didn't pick this up when they first used the Elements? Maybe what happened was the Elements' magic fused with the Mane 6's magic and vice versa when they were used. I don't think so, because there's something else I want to bring up. Even as fillies, the Mane 6 still represented their Elements:

 - Rainbow Dash showed Loyalty through her motivation to start the race to defend Fluttershy

 - Fluttershy showed Kindness when calming down the woodland critters after the Rainboom

 - Applejack showed Honesty in Manehattan when she stopped trying to hide who she was

 - Rarity showed Generosity by using the gems she found purely for the school play... thing

 - Pinkie Pie showed Laughter by throwing that party to get her family to at _least_ smile

Notice something here? This all happened when they got their cutie marks! And we all know that cutie marks are a form of magic, so what do you suppose that means? Between this and the first topic, it's quite obvious. The protected magic inside them was *_ALWAYS_* there! But that leaves us with perhaps the most peculiar question of all... Namely, *"Why doesn't Twilight fit into this trend?"* If we remember how Twilight got her cutie mark, magical crap was blowing up, and Celestia came in and Twily got her CM. How she got her cutie mark: Magic. Her Element: Magic. Voila! But it's not that simple. When she used the same kind of magic on the Elements to make the sixth appear, nothing happened. It was the Magic of *Friendship* that caused it to appear, and it was the Magic of *Friendship* that was used every time after that. It's even in her cutie mark: She was destined to meet the rest of the group. And yet, even as a filly, proved in the BBBFF song, she didn't understand the Magic of Friendship. Anyone else noticing a contradiction here? The Mane 6 had their "Elemental magic" in them from the start, and yet Twilight was against hers. We see in the pilot that she was appalled by the very idea of making friends, so why would that be her destiny; her Element? I don't have all the answers yet, but other than that, this theory is fairly plausible.


Season 4 confirmed that Celestia has visions. How far ahead they go is a mystery, but we know that she has ways of planing for major events to happen. (i.e Twilight's princessdom [ Luna's book in The Crystal Empire] ) She could have been planning and anticipating all the major events in the show.


Interesting analysis, but two things in particular stuck out to me as inconsistencies in the logic.

First, you said that it could be possible than anyone else that particularly embodies one of the elements could use them, but when Spike tried to use the Element of Loyalty with the rest of the Mane Six sans Rainbow Dash against Discord, it failed. Although, maybe Element of Loyalty had already become specifically attached to Rainbow Dash, and at that point no one else could use it? Until maybe they were left alone for some time, or... really, how does one lose their connection to their element? Celestia lost hers to all of them when the Mane Six used them against Nightmare Moon, but we don't really know why, Anyway...

The other problem was that you said the Mane Six using the elements was somehow stronger than Celestia using them, and this one is more obvious. Against Discord, Celestia and Luna used the elements to trap him for 1000 years, and when the Mane Six used them, they got the same result. Maybe they got the same result this time because Celestia was actually using them with Luna and thus the elements were being used to their maximum potential, but the "trapped for 1000 years" result is the same as Nightmare Moon. So why hadn't anything more significant happened to Discord? Maybe he couldn't have had evil purged from him like in Nightmare Moon's case, but it's inconsistent that they had the same result.

+Jessica Stehley well except for twilight, that is

+IronicTB I always thought it was because all of the mane 6 was corrupted in thought, and were the opposite of their true selves. So they wouldn't really be carriers of the elements during this time because they were the exact opposite of he elements they were meant to carry.

Maybe the elements have to have a new "set". In the sense that you can't simply replace a friend. If Spike had the element all along and RD tried to use it, it would have had the same effect. It wouldn't have worked.

@IronicTB Maybe they didn't have the same result? Who's to say the second time the mane six froze discord that he would have stayed frozen for more than 1000 years? We don't know since they awoke him later on purpose, but still.
And the thing about spike... I think they would have to be extremely loyal to bear the element, not just average Joe off the streets, and I also think that each element can only have a specific bearer at one time. That, or spike didn't have as good as a friendship to them that Rainbowdash did.
Wait, didn't the elements also not work then because they were grey/changed from their elements? IE Fluttershy was mean, Applejack was a liar, ect. That also probably had something to do with it
So yeah, that's my take on it.


I feel like the MLP show works around the basis that destiny exists as a solid path that shapes the people walking on it, or ponies in this case.
In reality, I believe it's strictly coincidences, not some predetermined path.
But I agree with this video as long as ponies are involved. I mean, if destiny wasn't solidified, then cutie marks couldn't work, theoretically speaking.


Okay, here's my theory
destiny
Let me explain
Have any of you read the wings of fire?At the end of the Dragonet Prophecy(the actual prophecy, not the book) it mentions five dragons hatching together, born to end the fight. The mane six got their cutie marks all together, at the same time. Is it any coincidence that they were the bearers of the elements? The elements are the Elements of, keyword here, *harmony*. To have greater power, there must be as much harmony as possible. Based on the mane six's ages in equestria girls, they seem to be the same age, roughly. I might even go as far as to say they were born at the same time

Okay, here's my theory
*destiny*
Let me explain
Have any of you read the wings of fire?At the end of the Dragonet Prophecy(the actual prophecy, not the book) it mentions five dragons hatching together, born to end the fight. The mane six got their cutie marks all together, at the same time. Is it any coincidence that they were the bearers of the elements? The elements are the Elements of, keyword here, *harmony*. To have greater power, there must be as much harmony as possible. Based on the mane six's ages in equestria girls, they seem to be the same age, roughly. I might even go as far as to say they were born at the same time


Here's what I think:After Twilight had that large burst of magic and attracted Celestia to the testing room where Twilight was (The day Twilight gained her cutie mark), Celestia saw what Twi's cutie mark was, and automatically assumed she was destined to be the bearer of the element of magic. Hence why she took Twilight as her own personal student, and allowed her to work by her side. Then, once, Nightmare Moon was coming back, Celestia told her to make friends, so there could be new holders of the elements. I feel as though there was a strange attraction between the main six, though it might not have been strong, it helped keep them together after the pilot episode, and they later became the new holders of the elemnts


To me their elements, each of those elements is what you need too be a good friend 'Friend Is Magic'
-Loyalty
-Honesty
-Generosity
-Kindness
-Laughter
And Magic too finish it off


I agree with this ^^ It fits a lot of missing pieces together! Actually, just the other day I was just thinking about this topic. I was thinking, if the Mane 6's meeting was destiny, what would happen if Nightmare Moon was never banished? Would they meet in another way? This theory also kinda ties into my own about the Cutie Mark Crusaders being the next hosts of the Elements of Harmony. Was it coincidence the Crusaders met during call of the cutie? And is it coincidence that they share so many similarities to the Mane 6? Just my little headcanon.

ya, the whole shows base is from nightmare moon

It may ^^ I just said G5 because G4 mostly follows the current Mane 6 and their lives. If anything happens in G4 to lead into new Elemental Hosts, it'd probably be the last few episodes of the last season of G4 ^^

Well no, they just gave up the Elements to replenish the tree's magic, but once the magic is full power again, the Elements could probably be taken again. Also the Elements still has to have "hosts" in order to still have magic, because it's the friendship and harmony that makes their magic strong. As Twilight said " We are connected to the Elements, the Elements are connected to the tree, the box came from the tree.... There must be a connection!" It's highly possible that in G5 (if they make it) they can bring back the elements.

Aren't the elements of harmony gone though? I guess they could still represent the elements, but they can't really host them.

That's true. She's so difficult to figure out XD

@Auria_Autumn That makes sense. Twilight kinda fits with all the elements and so does Sweetie Belle. Maybe Sweetie Belle would be magic.

That's true ^^' She's honestly hard to figure out, or at least to me.

I can see it ^^ It just throws Sweetie Belle off for me if she were. I originally thought Sweetie would be Laughter because her music connects people just as Pinkie's jokes and parties, but then I realized she would be making people laugh. Next I thought Magic for her, but she doesn't have raw talent, nor does her special talent (music as shown in "The Show Stoppers") have very much of magic use involved. I finally went with Kindness because how similar she acts to Fluttershy.

I was going to say that Babs was Kindness because her weakness is being a bully (like Fluttershy), and she learned to treat others with kindness, but your version makes sense too.

Well, actually, I'm working on a video right now that addresses my theory ^^ Will take me quite a bit of work before it's up, but either way XD In the video I'm addressing various similarities between the Mane 6, who I think is what element and why, etc. For example, the Mane 6 before season 3 was made up on a pair of each species. Going further, you find one creative Unicorn, one powerful Unicorn, one hardworking and dedicated Earth Pony, one spontaneous Earth Pony, one Pegasus who was a natural flier, and one Pegasus that was a weak flier. If the pattern follows, the mystery crusaders will be a Unicorn and Pegasus. From what we know of the CMC, Scootaloo is a weak flier, Sweetie Belle is a creative Unicorn, and AppleBloom (though not to Pinkie's extreme) is spontaneous. And if the pattern continues, Babs will be the hardworking Earth Pony, the mystery Unicorn would be a powerful Unicorn, and the mystery Pegasus will be the natural flier. AppleBloom would be generosity because as a designer (as shown in "The Show Stoppers") she is very generous in order to share her thoughts and creative vision with the world. Scootaloo would be honesty because, even if she learns to fly, she will have to admit that she won't be the best flier around, and thus not like Rainbow Dash. Babs would be Loyalty because in "A Bad Seed" she went with Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon to be bullied, but at the end joins the Crusaders and stays loyal to them when given the choice to join Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon in the bullying once more. Sweetie was hard for me to figure out, but she would be Kindness because of the way she often acts, as well as she being the more rational and reasonable (and sensitive) of the main 3. That means the mystery Unicorn is Magic, and the mystery Pegasus would be Laughter. Babs is also AppleBloom's cousin, and Pinkie is suggestively AppleJack's cousin. Sorry about this long thing ^^' Didn't know it'd come out this long...

Makes sense.I think Babs Seed would actually be the "new Fluttershy".

@sykosam In Apple Family Reunion, Babs mentioned two new Crusaders joined the Manehattan branch ^^ I believe it's only mentioned once because they could hardly chat the rest of the time.

Well, there are only three Cutie Mark Crusaders. Four, if you count Babs Seed. What about the others?


I had once imagined one pony bearing all elements and becoming 'the avatar of harmony' but yeah, what you said makes a lot more sense.


Although I could agree that the elements of harmony could be used by possibly anypony, there's still the aspect that each of the Mane Six' cutiemarks matched the symbol on their representative element of harmony. That being said, perhaps the Tree of Harmony itself chose each of them personally. And that includes Luna and Celestia. Because on the Tree of Harmony, it contained six slots for each of the Mane Six' elements of harmony. But there were not six individual symbols on the Tree of harmony, there were eight. There were the six that belonged to what we refer to the Mane Six, plus two more that hat Celestia's and Luna's cutiemarks. So the reason why Luna and Celestia had the ability to harness the power of the elements of harmony was because they too were chosen by the Tree of Harmony. Luna and Celestia were also element bearers. And that being said, perhaps the Mane Six would be more accurately referred to as the Mane Eight. How's that for a fan theory?


My theory is that the six pointed star is a much more universal symbol for magic, itself. After all, Shining Armor has it as well. My theory is that she knew what was coming and was preparing for it. She knew the Element of Magic would bring the others together, so she focused on that. Her first attempt was with Sunset Shimmer, to whom she told her plans. Knowing she was "destined" to save Equestria, she became arrogant, which lead to her fall from grace. As for the others, it's hard to say. Fan fictions have had some interesting theories as to why those specific mares were the ones to bear the Elements, but the truth is, we may never know.


Interesting... It's also worth mentioning that, being sisters, Luna and Celestia already had the magic of friendship on their side. After Luna became Nightmare Moon, Celestia presumably had no friends, meaning the elements were pretty much useless. So she took on students to perhaps pass this ability on to.


Personally I think that adding something such as older person or male person or different species (not equine species like dog cat dragon etc) could at first weaken it but if overcome and ACCEPTED (emphasis) would actually cause it to strengthen the bond of friendship as it becomes more encompassing to others. But that's how I see it.


well i do believe celestia's forsight actually in the sombra two part when celestia tells twilight to go to the crystal empire it seemed as if celestia already knew wahat was going to happen


I think it’s pretty silly to think gender would affect the group somehow.<br>(If anything the young six later on in the series proves that it really doesn’t)

I think it’s pretty silly to think gender would affect the group somehow.
(If anything the young six later on in the series proves that it really doesn’t)


One thing we do know for sure is Celestia shows tremendous foresight when it comes to Twilight Sparkle specifically. Remember that Cadence was her "foalsitter" since before Twilight had her cutiemark. We do not know about the others, but it certainly appears as though Celestia has been grooming Twilight for princess-hood from a very early age, perhaps since birth. Personally, I think this is something the writers will have to explain sooner or later. I also find it hard to believe that Twilight has not seemed to realize this, or is not bothered by this at all. This question goes to the heart of who she is and where she came from, and where she is going. It seems important to me.


your missing something, celestia told twighlight there would be some special ponys that would be very important to her mission, those ponies just happened to be the other 5 elements SHE set it up


(Like you said (Brony Notion) in that part about the rainboom) Usually, no 2 (or 6) ponies get their cutie marks at the same time. So if they ALL got them at the same time, wouldn't that lead to eventually meeting? If the cutie marks are destiny, won't ponies getting them at the same time mean their destined to meet?


There are no coincidences<br>everything happens for a reason

There are no coincidences
everything happens for a reason


I'm a woman and the closest I ever truly feel to "friendship magic" or peace or personal harmony or whatever you want to call it, is when I'm with my best friend, who is a guy. We have a strictly platonic relationship, and I love him as much as I love my actual brother. I wish the world, or even the mlp world, OR EVEN the mlp fandom would accept that men and woman can love each other platonicly.


I agree, this makes a lot of sense. I never actually looked into this as much, very fascinating!)


I got two things to say I cannot believe I never thought of this before only those worthy may posses it's power sound like I've hear that ho right Thor's hammer in which the master or creator or what ever decides who gets in now because this a magic tv show I'm just going to say this I think Mother Nature foretold it you may think I'm crazy well look as at who created the elements oh right a magic tree from nature


Ok so here’s my theory, so why the mane 6 where chosen is way long ago when the 3 tribes didn’t get along. There where 6 ponies that matched the elements perfectly. One of them was clover the clever, clover the clever matched the element of magic perfectly. That’s my theory


yes,I agree with the theroy and I got a few things to say about the age and gender.Age would get in the way,unless your in the same age group,think about it,if your friends with a baby then all they could say is goo goo gaa gaa,or my not no whats going on,their brains are still developing.
Being friends with an old person doesnt make any sense,they would either be sleeping or might think it's baby stuff.
Now about gender,it doesn't matter unless your just making fun of them or whatever.Boys can be friends with girls,not love,they can just be regular best buds,if they match the elements and are true to their friends then the power of magic can be unlocked


I think the way the elements work is that it brings out what's on the inside what I mean by that is nightmare moon when celestia first defeated her their was darkness inside of her the second time there was a slight bit of good inside of her returning her to normal. Discord had a heart as cold as stone so he got turned into stone that's what I think at least please take it into consideration


While I fully respect your opinion that any five random ponies could've become friends with Twilight and wielded the remaining elements, it's frankly pretty silly to me.

1: They wouldn't even be able to relate to each other if they were a mish-mash of ponies of all different kinds. Also, I don't think the viewers could relate to the scrambled group whose only common trait with filly Twilight is that they were affected by the sonic rainboom and got their cutie marks. It's totally unattractive and makes no sense, which is part of why what actually happened, happened.

2: Since it's been a long day and I can't think of any other arguments at the moment, your statement that "there's no real answer that justifies why they were put together" pretty much sums it up. Destiny is hard, if not impossible, to understand with the concept of logic. It occurs because, owing to an obscure set of reasons we can't grasp/aren't meant to grasp, it is meant to occur. Destiny itself wouldn't have a purpose if we could explain why every event in a given sequence in a pony's life occurred. It would be degraded from a mysterious, magical concept to an ordinary one in... ten seconds flat. Sorry, I couldn't resist!

From me to you, from one MLP fan to another, destiny is remarkable, and life is nothing without mystery.


I think that celestia would have to find new barriers of the elements of harmony because she lost a possession with a elements that's because she never said anything about Luna so she wasn't being honest and that's why the elements didn't do there full potential.


But if thats true, why the element of loyalty did not work with spike when discord appears? In my opinion is the destiny of the cutie marks


Pretty sure Celestia knew Twilight was the destined bearer of the Element of Magic when she got her cutie mark, which matched the Element symbol on the Tree of Harmony. As for how she knew who the other five were, well, Sunbutt works in mysterious ways.


Wait, I just thought of something!
Most people (including me) may think that if Flutter hadn't been bullied, then Rainbow Dash wouldn't have done the race and performed the sonic rain boom, thus making Fluttershy the reason they're all together. But, if you think about it, it was because of the bullies that they're together!
Think about, they had been teasing Fluttershy cause she couldn't fly. If they hadn't bullied her, rainbow dash wouldn't have protected her friend. So it's basically because of the bullies..... No? Okay then =)


This also got me thinking about princess Celestia. I don't think she was over powered by chrysalis or duped by Discord that easily. Shes been around a long time and I think she has tons of wisdom. I believe before the season 3 conclusion shes been holding back her true power to test and teach twilight, at any moment I think Celestia could have taken control of the situations that were going on.


If you don't know the pillars ( starswirl and the others ) said that the main six represented their own elements which mathched perfectly with their talents


I kinda disagree with the theory that 1 person can't use the elements of magic to there full patiental because when Luna and Celestia used the elements of harmony together they still left the evil in discord and just turned them to stone nothing else happened . Ofcourse this is just my opinion can you tell me what you think?


I thought, the five other ponies became the other elements because they represented the value of the elements TO Twilight. She realised it during the spark-moment. Her element looks different to the others and it is her who activates the powers of the elements. so it`s technically her, who is in charge and the others are the choosen ones to carry one element. Maybe any other pony could happend to become one if Twilight would had seen the one as one of the elements. Bon Bon for Generosity maybe...etc.<br>That`s why Luna and Celestia could carry more than one element. Because they resembled the properties for each other.Luna held Loyalty,Laughter and Honesty. She could`nd use them anymore, because Celestia didn`t see Loyalty, Laughter and Honesty in her sister anymore after she became Nightmare Moon. Celestia could`nt use them again after she banished Nightmare Moon with the elements because she doubt´ed herself and Luna didn`t see Generosity, Magic and Kindness in her anymore, after she got banished with the elements. Maybe Celestia could still carry Magic, if she banished Luna with her own magic and not with the elements....

I thought, the five other ponies became the other elements because they represented the value of the elements TO Twilight. She realised it during the spark-moment. Her element looks different to the others and it is her who activates the powers of the elements. so it`s technically her, who is in charge and the others are the choosen ones to carry one element. Maybe any other pony could happend to become one if Twilight would had seen the one as one of the elements. Bon Bon for Generosity maybe...etc.
That`s why Luna and Celestia could carry more than one element. Because they resembled the properties for each other.Luna held Loyalty,Laughter and Honesty. She could`nd use them anymore, because Celestia didn`t see Loyalty, Laughter and Honesty in her sister anymore after she became Nightmare Moon. Celestia could`nt use them again after she banished Nightmare Moon with the elements because she doubt´ed herself and Luna didn`t see Generosity, Magic and Kindness in her anymore, after she got banished with the elements. Maybe Celestia could still carry Magic, if she banished Luna with her own magic and not with the elements....


If anyone that is loyal could bear the element of loyalty why did it not work with spike then?

Celestia also used the word destiny in celestia's Ballid which would hint that she knew that this was twilight's destiny all along.


celestia was the one who put twilight in charge of the celebrations, with a specific itinerary. each one corresponded to a main five job. since we haven't seen any competitors that could have been in ponyville at the time of the event, celestia told twilight specifically to find each member of the main five (except for pinkie, who finds you). so what do you think the chances are that celestia ordered twilight to check up on the 4 of 5 people she would need to save the day?


I was thinking, only the element of magic is shaped like Twilight's cutie mark right off the bat. The rest of  them only became shaped how they were after the crystal shards circling around the ponies, maybe being exposed to their magic or something. I think the only reason these 5 are the elements of what they are is because twilight was the friend that sparked it, and the qualities were basically created to fit the ponies chosen to bear them. The reason they were generic shapes before is that the two princesses used them , and only saw them as magic, not as the magic of these 6 ponies.


Well it makes more sense with the meeting of the six dcshgs (2nd gen) than the mane six in FiM or at least the backstory is less complicated


If you look at the past on how the elements were created youed find out your answers, the elements created by lots of ponys not just one making them very powerful


Okay, I have a theory. We all heard Celestial say, “I only said to make friends.”, so what if SPIKE was the only reason it “said” , “simply stop reading those dusty old books!” Do a video, please!


Even I think even discord can use the elements of harmony and I bet it would reform him to a whole new form because the power of harmony and in chaos together will make a whole balance a friendship


While I do think anyone could bear the elements of harmony, I thing your theory of Twilight being Clover the Clever plays in with her cutie mark being the element of magic.  Like how Sunset Shimmer was implied to be Celestia's first choice for being the bearer of the element of magic.  If Sunset hadn't become too greedy for power, she might have actually been the one to bear the elements alongside the other mane five instead of Twilight.


It could have been a mix of destiny and a coincidence. Remember Celestia's Ballad? The final line says, "...your destiny." So it WAS Twilight's destiny to be the Princess of Friendship. So it was destiny that she would make friends. But particulary the Mane Six? Possibly. Though, because the Sonic Rainboom, by best pony, got the Mane Six's cutie marks at the SAME TIME, it is possible that it was destiny that they would be friends, or the bearers of the Elements of Harmony. Also, the elements of harmony are in the shape of the Mane Six's cutie marks. (Also, I know that they were just crystals when Celestia used them, but Twilight's element was almost EXACTLY the shape of her cutie mark.) Also, I'm pointing out that not anyone can just USE the elements. Even if they are extremely [insert any harmony element here]. Remember in Return of Harmony, when the Mane Six (Five) were going to use the elements on discord, but nothing happened. Spike is VERY loyal, but nothing still happened. (I'm also pointing out that if RD NEVER pulled off the Sonic Rainboom, then destiny would be broken.) So, it almost IS destiny that the Mane Six would be the bearers of the Elements of Harmony. But going to Celestia's foresight, even though Celestia is basically Equestria's god, I think that she knew that the Mane Six were going to unite and defeat Nightmare Moon, but not in the form of destiny. I think that she knew Twilight was going to be the Element of Magic, because she was there, but I think that she knew that the other five were probably the future bearers. But she knew that Twilight wouldn't just go to Ponyville, and make friends, so she tried to convince Twilight to go to Ponyville and befriend the other five. So she has probably been to Ponyville and met he other five, and she knew Pinkie would welcome almost ANYONE, so she told Mayor Mare (or Mayor [I don't know]) that Twilight was going to a new resident of Ponyville and that she was going to live in the Ponyville Library. So when Pinkie gasped, ran off, she probably went to the mayor and asked about Twilight's new home, and then she ran to the other five (four) and told them (best impression [my standards]), "PARTY. LIBRARY. NIGHT. SURPRISE. NEW PONY." and then the events of the first episode happens. So Celestia knew that Twilight needed to make friends with the other five, so she did the best she could to get Twilight to meet them. So the events of the first episode wasn't destiny.

But hey, that's just a theory...
A PONY THEORY!!!
THANKS FOR READING!! (Game Theory puns! ^_^)


It's kind of funny to hear him talk about how the Mane 6 may not have met if it weren't for the rainboom after the Season 5 Finale.


They were chosen because they represent those specific elements loyalty,honesty,laughter,kindness,generousity and Magic they were meant for eachother


I think the elements were stronger with Luna and Celestia than they were with Celestia alone. After all the bond between the royal sisters is extremely powerful. However the elements still weren't as powerful as they were with the mane 6.
When Celestia used them they were a super-powered version of her own magic beam. She couldn't summon the rainbow of harmony on her own.
I think that Celestia was serious about books being old and dusty. Also, there was a previous mane 6 but that one failed.


So ponies possess magic inside them?...

Technically, they were already the elements of harmony before they met. Applejack was naturally honest, Pinkie was fun and so forth. I guess that's kind of the point...

Anyway, still. Does this mean that anypony can be that way? If Derpy has bad luck and breaks stuff alot, what would HER element be? Clumsiness? I'm just using her as an example. I know you already answered this question in the vid, but why the main six? They all got their cutie marks at the same time. If other ponies got theirs at the same time, does that mean they'd be future best friends? Rainbow Dash was the one who did the sonic rainboom which made the rest realise their talents and destinies, but what if it affected others? For all we know, Carrot flipping Top could have gotten hers at that time! Though it seems that only these particular characters were connected. Why?


Me and my friends are just like the main six
We each represent an element
Summer: Loyalty
Chelsey laughter
Mia: kindness
Janice: Honesty
Me: Generosity
(Even if it's only the five of us)


Tia was told a tad by Star Swirl. It's the in the canon journals, according to my sibling, who owns the book.


I do think celestia had some for sight because I do think the tree of harmony played a part in the main six meeting<br>


When discord brought chaos, twilight put the element of loyalty necklace on spike bc she didn't have rainbow dash by her side at the moment. And he didn't rise like the others did and he was still a friend. But with him not "pony" that goes with it, plus that he isn't a pony might be a flaw in my theory.


My theory (based on yours) is that Celestia realized the main six got their cutie marks at the same time and decided to wait til they were old enough, so that she could get them together...


I agree with you but I say that the elements of harmony are a bit sentient since they know who to go to and they know who there master was since Spike had the element of loyalty on and his is very loyal to Twilight. When an element is bared it choices to let that pony use them or not. meaning that there is some form of mind or intelligent within the elements themselves. The magic they have is only at its strongest when all six are under the bare of friends. See what I'm saying.


Somehow I think the reason why and how the main six were chosen to be the new bearers of the Elements of Harmony is because maybe when Rainbow Dash performed the "Sonic Rainboom", it probably not just helped the other five find their destinies one what make them happy, but also maybe have effected both the Elements and the Tree of Harmony.  Like maybe the "Sonic Rainboom" was a sign to the magic in the Elements or the Tree on who their new chosen "Spirits of Harmony" should be, after their magic lost their connection with Celestia and Luna (due to Luna betraying Celestia).


Your bit about Celestia is wrong, you forgot that during the "fight" with Discord, Celestia wielded only a few of the elements while Luna wielded the rest. Without Luna the elements were incomplete, only being able to send the nightmare to the moon. Had it been somepony else overtaken by darkness Celestia and Luna would have been able to rid that pony of said darkness. If it happened again, while the elements were still in play, say to one of the mane six they'd only be able to send the problem away not fix it. The elements need to be complete in order to work.


The roles of Celestia and the Sonic Rainboom have clearly been described in the episodes 'Celestial Advice' and 'The Cutie Re-Map'.


Remember how twilight got wings as Celestia said it was to fulfil her destiny? Well Celestia definitely knew her destiny. So maybe Celestia knew that twilights future was the 5 friends, so she sent twilight to ponyville.


Could be just me.. But Celestia, in equestria and the high school, both seem to know a whole lot more about is and will be happening.

The one in HIGH SCHOOL?! Noooo, no no no no. Have you seen Rainbow Rocks? Those two are useless in that world. Also, I don't see how Principal Celestia knew anything about the plot of Equestria Girls. I mean, sure, she did say "Princess Twilight" despite not knowing she was a princess, but she explained what a princess truly is seconds before that and Twily had recently been crowned Princess of the Fall Formal, so... yeah, just the one in Equestria. Either way, you might be onto something about Celestia knowing all this stuff...


I love ur videos but i think you’d be able to explain a lot more if the video lengths were longer


I’m guessing that celestial wasn’t chosen to have the elements of harmony but the main six were destined


i love your videos   Thanks for making them!:)

                      ~Mabel


Another thing should be noted: Sunset Shimmer had to fail as Celestia's student in order for Twilight Sparkle to replace her. That means there is much more to this.


0:11 WAIT! WHY IS MINUETE IN THE BACKGROUND? ISN'T SHE SUPPOSED TO BE IN CANTERLOT WHEN TWILIGHT RUNS OFF?


Does being secretly loyal to a group while 'betraying' them to get on the enemy team to tear them inside out and rejoin your friends still count as loyal?


I also think the main six were chosen is because they were the people who showed the strongest aspects as the element they bare. Like as you said the quills and sofas seller could be one, but he might not show the strongest aspects of that element. He might be loyal but not loyal enough :)


It couldn't be a coincidence, that I agree, but I highly doubt any other pony would be able to use the other elements.

Ok so let's see, they all got their cutie marks at one time, which in a way was by accident and was caused by the impact (let's call it that for now ;p) and influenced their destiny or talent (and what makes them special I guess) so their cutie mark influences their destiny, and because Celestia wasn't experiencing the magic of friendship she wouldn't be able to use the full power of the elements to stop and appease her sister, however the mane six come in, already have found their destinies, etc. So let's see... By one simple glimpse at the cutie marks it'd be hard to tell or assume what their destinies were, however (again) it was caused by accident, on rainbow's rainboom occurrence. So they all find peace and friendship and together finally accept each other, for instance, twilight was obviously annoyed by the five alone, but her destiny finally starts coming into play, and accepts them, then she turns to an alicorn and has trouble accepting that she is a princess. It's all on pace, so was it an accident? Depends on what you're looking at, Celestia obviously meant for Twilight to earn some fri- WAIT! Celestia was outside in Twilight's outburst! She knew what her cutie mark meant! She had to finish Twilight's destiny like Twilight finishing Starswirl's spell! So in the beginning, it was most likely on accident, then Tia realized what Twilight was going to be, and helped her reach the "goal" of her destiny in becoming a princess!

Great theory btw but yeah, I doubt that unless the "another pony" was there from the very start, then I doubt that they can use the elements.


Maybe there is a secret room celestia goes to hidden in the mountain way above canterlot and that room has prophecy-telling abilities, so celestia saw what was coming and knew what to do next.


I have an idea! You Know the rainboom  to make the mane six get there cutie marks?Well that made them drift together because thats how they all got there cutie marks so there destened to be friends!!
If u agree
   I
   I
   I


I think no other ponies could wear the elements because, in the return of harmony, she tries to get spike to use the element while rainbow was under discords spell. That's just a thought.


Remember that one episode where Twilight had to use dark magic on the potion then it turned white? When she had the flashbacks Luna was helping Celestia with the elements of harmony! So that's my theory..


I almost feel like perhaps  when Celestia was younger, she bore only one element of harmony, generosity. If you look at Celestia's crown and necklace they both have a purple gem that looks almost exactly like rarity's element. Perhaps she started out being mainly just generous, but gained other elements along the way. Also, this is completely off-topic but where did rarity get her British accent? We've seen her parents. They are definitely not British and Rarity even said she was born in ponyville. So where did that exactly come from?


The elements of disharmony's 6 should be called the insane six :)


When someone says ''Sirius''
Me:OH MY GOODNESS,THE PUN! XD
Sirius: I'm Sirius.
Me:.....okay?


Well the Rainboom had its share in this. Still... food: did the Applefamily volunteer, particularly with so much of it for their family reunion anyway? Rainbow handling the sky alone (bet she wanted to show off) -- Rarity volunteered for the decoration I suppose -- Pinkie won't give up until you ARE her friend, Fluttershy with the birds... all in all, it went fast. Still, they chose to join Twilight. She didn't ask or expect it (but she sure needed them).


Did you know that a Picture of an Apple in ancient Greek could mean the symbol of Knowledge, gravity or Honesty. and there are two others that matches. Rarity's. The three gems means wealth, (what ever that p word is  pospirity?) and Generosity.

Fluttershy is the other one. Butterfly does mean Kindness, Flight, and will.

strange how three of the mane cast have cutie marks in Greek mythology.

Golden compress the book series.

if Applejack, Rarity, and Fluttershy's cutie mark have a connection to Greek Mythology Twilight, Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie Must have a connection too but not as straight forward.


She had temporary power with the elements she only had 3 traits magic honesty and generosity the others were luna loyalty laughter and kindness


2:03 i was watching tangled last night 😂


My guess is that somehow The Elements of Harmony somehow disappeared sometime in the past and maybe they became Cutie Marks and being ponys get them from destiny my guess is that The Mane 6 are The <br>Elements of Harmony. I wouldn't be at all surprised to see that revolution being I've seen it happen in other shows like this so I wouldn't be surprised if The Mane 6 are The reincarnated forms of The Elements of Harmony.

My guess is that somehow The Elements of Harmony somehow disappeared sometime in the past and maybe they became Cutie Marks and being ponys get them from destiny my guess is that The Mane 6 are The
Elements of Harmony. I wouldn't be at all surprised to see that revolution being I've seen it happen in other shows like this so I wouldn't be surprised if The Mane 6 are The reincarnated forms of The Elements of Harmony.


I don't think any pony could bare the elements because I don't think every pony has the extreme on the element yes many could be loyal and honest ect. but the main six go to a certain extreme with it. look at pinkie she won't stop at anything most would probably just give up cause they don't control it the right way


I support your idea, but I'll wrinkle it up a bit:<br>The main 6. Fluttershy,Pinkie Pie, Rainbow Dash, Rarity and Applejack are already friends,thus powering the friendship more than just complete strangers with each other! So that is easier for Twillight to fit in, the 5 pieces of the jigsaw is already there, we just need one more.

I support your idea, but I'll wrinkle it up a bit:
The main 6. Fluttershy,Pinkie Pie, Rainbow Dash, Rarity and Applejack are already friends,thus powering the friendship more than just complete strangers with each other! So that is easier for Twillight to fit in, the 5 pieces of the jigsaw is already there, we just need one more.


I believe since the rainboom made them habe there cutie marks apear at the same time celestia was like oh hey there personallys match the elements of harmony.

Or celestia knew the rainboom was going to happen and the main six would get there cutie marks and then she decided to alter there fates a bit to make them the true elements of harmony.


Why is everyone a girl!!!! Well almost everyone!!!


It's not a mistake ✨, It's a masterpiece


I have the power of elements of harmony and friendship on my side! 😁👌


Twilight: ...but the fate of Equestria does not depend on me making friends.
Me in 2020 rewatching MLP: I've never heard such a wrong statement in my life

Twilight: ...but the fate of Equestria *does not* depend on me making friends.
Me in 2020 rewatching MLP: I've never heard such a wrong statement in my life


anypony can use the elements
But these six were already connected by fate (Or a sonic rainboom)
So it might strengthen the elements power even more!
Just like how the CMC are connected by destiny and are friends. But their friendship came BEFORE their destiny
Or did it?
I mean, I doubt they would have met without the mane six, so perhaps there's something more to this theory


2:13 but the others seem to be...dare I say...expendable. XD


I think that Princess Celestia sent Twilight to Ponyville because she knew that Nightmare Moon was coming back, so she assigned the jobs that Twilight would oversee to "a very special group of ponies" that she mentions. Celestia knew that if they became friends, Twilight was bound to figure out the connection and save the day. That would explain why she didn't sound at all surprised when Luna came back and the new bearers of the elements of harmony got their necklaces (and tiara).


Celestia could have planned it out. She probably knew the mane 5 were the spirits of the elements of harmony. so she made them plan the summer celebration.


Maybe,here are some possible answers.

One,on how the Mane 6 got their cutie marks through the rain boom.The rainbow actually represents unity and,of course,friendship.And only Rainbow Dash can do that not because of her mane,but because of what she did.She stood up for Fluttershy by competing in a race against the bullies.And it did'nt ended up getting her first rain boom, it also got her and the Mane 6 cutie marks.

Second, why they were chosen.The Elements of Harmony represents qualities of a true friend. Honesty can help you solve your problems if you tell them the truth.Kindness can make your friends happy. Laughter can cheer up a person despite his or her problems. Generosity can influence others. Loyalty can make friendships stronger.The Mane 6 had already posessed these qualities.We just don't see them.We saw them show it in the pilot episode.

Third, why include Twilight?It comes to show that even a student who doesn't learn to make friends can learn to do so. It proved that there are some things that you can't learn in school.

Lastly,did Celestia set this up? Was it her intention to pick Twilight as the overseer of the Summer Sun Celebration and become the bearer of the Element of Magic? No. A BIG FAT NO.It was destiny.How do I know this?Celestia knew that she couldn't defeat Nightmare Moon and bring back Luna with her power alone.She needed the power of friendship to defeat Nightmare Moon and prove that friendship can overcome any circumstances. And the perfect bearer is Twilight Sparkle. Why?Because once she's focused on something or on a goal,she'll do anything to get it.All she needs is to keep on convincing Twilight to do that.She didn't tell Twilight about Nightmare Moon because she didn't want to see her getting pressured.


I think the "evil magic" that made Luna turn into night mare moon then went into sunsetshimer.


Well It could be like this: What if the more viewed background ponies were the elements of harmony like Octavia Generosity Vinyl Laughter Doctor Hooves for Loyalty and so on<br>wouldn't any one agree?

Well It could be like this: What if the more viewed background ponies were the elements of harmony like Octavia Generosity Vinyl Laughter Doctor Hooves for Loyalty and so on
wouldn't any one agree?

There's actually a video for this theory, like, an entire short film for it XDD


I want to know more about the bat ponies that delivered Luna in the Nightmare Night episode. A lot of people say they are demons from Tarturus bound to her service, but I think they are just bat ponies, like when Fluttershy turned into Flutterbat. I thought they looked so cute. P.S. I am making a music video on my hypothesis of it. Hopefully I get the story across


I do not think a pony of the main six as a stallion or a filly will have an effect at all as long as they bear that element of harmony is what matters.


i think it was destiny. when they got their cutie marks or even when they were born, they had the destiny of meeting the element of magic


As brony notion told us, the mane six has a friendship that no other pony has yet mastered. This might even make friendship a magic that might be stronger than celestia herself. Celestia herself with the elements  of  harmony  could banish nightmare moon, (A.K.A. princess  luna) to the moon for l,000 years, (or 100 I can't remember ) but twilight
Sparkle and the other five with the elements of harmony could free princess luna and also set her free from darkness. This is the pegasister notion signing out until the next brony notion video. hoof bump!


well, destiny, as all knowing as it is, saw which pony would be the definition of the element of magic, twi, and got its old buddy fate to make sure the magic stayed balanced as good and bad. ay, but that's just a theory........A PONY THEORY!

Princess Luna Your majesty,BOWS
thanks for coming to my nightmares Yesterday;)

Princess Luna Your majesty,*BOWS*
thanks for coming to my nightmares Yesterday;)

+Princess Luna i agree btw I love u u are the best princess ever

hi Luna, and people She is not game ripping offing! she likes the name, so she wants to have it. someone is name princess bubble gum, she is a cartoon princess, and no one hates on her that she used "princess bubble gum" as her account name.

+Mia Sanchez you are totally right. rainbow should be second in command.

So.... Adorable... <del>gets hypnotized by Luna's cuteness</del>

So.... Adorable... -gets hypnotized by Luna's cuteness-

@Princess Luna You should watch it...It's called "How to NOT become a alicorn"

@Princess Luna Hi Luna!  I just needed to tell you the Celestia watched a video of Twilight with the Alicorn Amulet to take Celestia's wings and become a Alicorn (hehehe)!  I had to tell her that Twilight just did do that when she said Twilight would never do that...

@Princess Luna yeah ik i just like making a big deal of things on youtube. XD

@Yoav Gutman no im not. i just like the catch phrase

@***** hello scootaloo. how are you facing your fears?

@Alexandria Ijeh ..............3 words. ELEMENTS. OF. HARMONY.

@Gage Botts hey, not trying to rip off anything, it was just something cool, and im not the first 1 2 do it


I think the reason that those 6 where chosen because some of them have dreams and celestia knew that they where going to accomplish them and that they would stand up to there element of harmony and people like pinkie were so  funny and fluttering was the sweetest pony in pony ville


If one pony can have the six qualities and six ponies each have one of the main qualities does that mean two people can have three of the main qualities each three ponies can have two main qualities or even uneven ones like five ponies altogether and one has two of the main qualities instead of one


I think the main 6 were chosen because they have a super strong connection.


I know how the princess knew stars world a birdied he had a spell to go back in time so she went back in time to tell the past princess what to do in the short time limit that's the truth about everything


I dunno, it could have been a counsidence. Or maybe not, IDK! Anyways, ITS 2015!!!!! SEASON 5 COMES OUT DIS YEAR!!!!!!!!!! :D :D :D :D :D :D

it couldnt be THAT far. besides, all shows end at some point. and other people tend to hate us Bronies/Pegasisters <3<

@Kendra Curtis I think that I read it from Equestria Daily or from the other one

Where did you hear that? Wiki or is someone trolling you?

@EnderSpot Gamming what?! But I have read that there is coming a big movie at 2017 of g4

Oh MLP's gonna end? Oh nos!!! :( Lets enjoy it while it lasts, I guess...

thats what i saw on one of ILoveKimPossibleAlot's video for him.

@EnderSpot Gamming ah he's not doing it anymore?

and then MLP ends this year, as it was said by John deLancie ;(

i can see that your impatient for it :P ill be glad when it will come out too


What if the fact that they all got there cutie marks at the same time and through the same means is the reason they bear the elements of harmony. they might have more magic in them because of the strange twist of fate.


i think it's destiny because it makes sense with all the magic in the show plus the reasons the brony notion used makes sense


What I find funny is Twilight didn't follow Celestia's request/order in the pilot, bu like in later episodes Twilight seems strangely nervous around the Sun princess and almost never goes against Celestia's wishes now.


But unless Celestia can see the future than I don't think so, she knows that Twilight could free Luna and that Twilight is a princess. When Twilight broke the spell on Luna Celestia said that every year she raised the sun it was just a reminder of banishing her sister, so I believe that Celestia only had a general idea of Twilight being able to free Luna only form the magic she already showed. As for the other ponies Celestia didn't have anything to do with the rainboom and once again most likely saw stand out ponies pre elements. The main five without Twilight all take on great tasks in the town, such as in winter wrap up they were group leaders.


I think that, the bearers of the elements of harmony, only need to view eachother as equals to bear the elements. But, that's just a guess.


I think that the 6 weren't chosen they were just perfect. Anybody could. The gems just took form of their cutie marks


Although I don't believe Celestia predicted the Maine Six identities about who they are, but I believe that she did sense that some ponies were effected by that sonic rainbow she focused on Twilight because she was close at hand there's a loophole or two in my theory but I think I'm a little close what are your thoughts Brony Notion


Interesting. I suppose there could be some driving forces.


You guys are so... First comment hungry. Can't you say something interesting, or about the video?


Celestia said that there was a special group of ponies in ponyville, so she knew that she they had to meet to defeat Nightmare Moon.


I did have a theory that the main 6 were reincarnated from the 6 pillars. tho I made it before I got to the end of season 7. but I think it could be what may have happened, maybe the pillars died going to limbo, and the main 6 were reincarnated from them, and when they were brought back, the pillars gained their physical forms backs, but maybe not their souls. I still think its a long shot tho


I think that Celestia thought of these ponies is because #1 they are best at what they do and #2 they demonstrate friendship better than anypony else


@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus @Ender Eye  New comment section for you ^-^

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus Yeah :3 So has Note Worthy, he is awesome ^-^

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus He has done one on Tree Hugger!!!!

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus I want him to do one on Tree Hugger :3

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus Have you watched his new video? :3

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus I think we have BN to thank :)

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus It was one of those hey iv made a friend! Moments :3

@Rio Bray Wanna collab in my comics(I might voice Flower though)?

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus That video should be labelled Rio and Vincent- The Pegasi and Alicorn :)

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus Yeah.... the memories of Brony Notions videos....

@Rio Bray yeah, i remember this ;) <br>awww... so much memories :3

@Rio Bray yeah, i remember this ;)
awww... so much memories :3

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus And I said your Cutiemark was neat too! :D

@Rio Bray Yep ^3^ it was a really... Nice moment :3 i knew you were a good person :3

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus Yes! We did! I said the exact opposite to mine :3

@Rio Bray that we have almost the same OC :3

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus What did you ssy :3

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus You still remember it :)

@Rio Bray I like Pewds more than Markiplier.HERE COMEZ MARK FANZ WHO EANTZ TO RANT ABOUT ME

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus Do you remember what we said to each other :)

@Ender Eye Yeah, I do like him, but I like Markiplier better :)

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus This was where we first talked ^-^

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus <b>plays Illuminati theme song</b>

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus *plays Illuminati theme song*

@Rio Bray 1500th comment's :O jesus... you that were gonna fill the comments of Brony Notion's Video x3

@karatek The Blue Shell Pegasus Yep, we hit it ^3^

hee hee thank you ^3^ ( over 1000th comments! :O )


Well wat if Celestia DOES have that much foresight and that she DID see way into the future and saw all the villans and that it was Twilight and those ponies who HAD to be the bearers of the elements. Cause Celie is pretty magical. Just a thought.


Well I have mixed feelings about that every pony who is really loyal or kind or whatever can use the element because when discord turned the main 6 their oposide self when twilight find the elements and they kinda worked even if rarity, applejack, pinkie and fluttershy weren't their usual selves  but  the element of loyalty didn't work even the slightest and I think that everyone knows that spike is loyal so I really don't believe if everyone who is kinda representing one of the elements could use them like the main 6.


I've always wondered how two ponies could be connected to six elements??!!!


This really reminds me of the secret of the scroll in Kung fu panda where master oogway said "accident, or destiny?"


Don't forget, in one episode, Luna and Celestia said "Do you think that she's ready for the task to come?" FORESHADOWING


No one is complaning about how the wagon can stay still in the air and that the Royal guards fly like rendeers.


The main six are the only ones who can use the elements of harmony. In the season 2 finale the elements did not work with spike rather than rainbow dash. Isn't spike loyal enough?


Twilight has more magic than any other pony .Twilight is very talented in magic


I love how you put a red shirt from star trek all the red shirts are good for is dieing well all of them but Scotty he is one red shirt the would not die

+The Brony Notion thx for Harry Potter he's my fave character serious

@The Brony Notion Friendship is always on your side I didn't have many friends when I was out an about even in school a long time ago and as soon as I watched my little pony friendship Is magic I made friends so many that I couldn't remember there names friendship makes it complete thanx
Best regards
A brony

@BioniclesaurKing4t2  the YouTube video of "How Star Trek Should Have Ended" lol that was funny and in the end it did not work and they went through the black hole just to be shot down by the death star and Dearth Vader says "Oh we are going to get a lot of shit for that!" And the older Spock beams from out of now where and does a Vulcan perasher point and nocks him out

"We're too heavy to escape the black hole.  Scotty, I need you to eject the engine cores and every crew member wearing a red shirt!"
"But I'm wearing a red shirt!"
"Just do it!"
(while putting on a yellow uniform) "Aye, aye, sir!"

"We're too heavy to escape the black hole.  Scotty, I need you to eject the engine cores and every crew member wearing a red shirt!"
"But I'm _wearing_ a red shirt!"
"Just do it!"
(while putting on a yellow uniform) "Aye, aye, sir!"

@The Brony Notion Finally! I've been asking people all day "Guess who's birthday it is today!".... I feel so lame knowing this fact.

Haha true! Today is actually Deforest Kelly's birthday. Happy birthday McCoy! XD


they are just good together and if i was celestia i would choose them :-)


I think Celestia knows a lot more that she's not telling, like how she knew that in equestria girls the other mane 6 could not go into the portal because if the space time continuum fuck up or whatever, so she knew that only twilight could go because maybe she knew the other twilight was not present, but why is she not present? I dunno just an idea I guess


When Celestia used the elements it's yellow and when the main six used it it was rainbow


Celestia controls 3 of the elements.<br>Luna controls the other 3.

Celestia controls 3 of the elements.
Luna controls the other 3.


@The Brony Notion And i hope to contribute by using my voice to help you out :)

Thank you, Morgan Freeman, for your contribution to this video.


In the season 7 premier we get confirmation that she knew about them.


I have a friend that is male and we have a lot in common. Our teacher says that we represent harmony between opposite genders  pretty well, but we talk a lot in class XD


I have hada bit of a Headcannon that a lot of things in show have basicly been puppeted by Celestia all this time.


Well, I mean it was explained in future episodes that this was planned out by Celestia.


Also Twilight could have been replaced if the destiny didn't change her ( the sonic rainboom ) and with the ability of replacing all of them , I think your question is answered


I feel that this has a part to play on Season 9


And like brony notion said twilight's cutie mark was the magic symbol and the others weren't but after the second episode the elements were molded to fit there cutie mark and I don't think this would happen to someone else if they wore it and I think the only reason that twilight's was already molded was because hers was the most powerful


do you think it would be less exciting if they were all staleons?


I think Celestia set everything up. She was the one who manipulated these events into happening


''PERFECTLY DESCRIBE CELETSTIA'' well hell no Tia can not describe as not even one of elements why you may ask well.
Honesty: She never told Twilight or anyone NightmareMoon was Luna, olso Tia lied about Luna.
Kindness: when Luna turned into NightmareMoon she didnt even hold back and not only Luna when King Sombra attack or turned evil there was no holding back too.
Loyalty:she wasnt loyal to her sister Luna and u'all may say'' but butt she was too busy with her LOYAL duty'' What loyal duty she has tons of LOYAL GUARDS  plus you are waiting loyalty from a princess who is a lier.... yeah makes sence.
Generosity:We all know why Princess Luna turned evil cause no one notice her tanks to who's rules olso Luna allways under Tia's shade,Tia is the selfish one.
Laughter:Do I need to explain.Well When the last time Tia was laughing unconscious how about NEVER and if you going for happyness well screw u'all too she hardy was smiling after she banished Luna to moon.
Magic:Tia is the weakest Princess in Equestria. Before some of you try to kill me let me explain Princess Celestia, princess of Sun and Day Time. Princess Twilight princess of Friendship.Princess Cadence princess(or Queen.. yeah she is married why the hell she is still a pincess) of Love. And Princess Luna princess of Moon,Night and Stars.olso theres is Queen Chrysalis  princess(did you see what I did there) of Changelings. you see with power of love Chrysalis beat Tia then Cadence beat Chrysalis with power of love so Cadence>Chrysalis>Celestia. Olso magic of friendship beat NightmareMoon but before that NightmareMoon beat Celestia(after she returned) Twilight>NightmareMoon>Celestia but we also know  Luna>NightmareMoon if you take a look at who is what's princess you will find this Luna>Cadence>twilight>Celestia. The reson why Elements let Tia use them vs luna cause Luna was filled with Rage and turned evil and want all Night in other hoof Tia was kinda selfish can make balance between Night and Day .back in the day elments let tia use them but that was for one time for some reson...
I hope you will look at this.


Wait,if the spell lasts only thousand years,how much years needs pony to get old?I mean,Celestia should be 1.000 or more years


When Sawtooth showed Sirius Black when he said “serious” I screamed


A theory has been put out that the Elements, even in their dormant state, were drawing the six ponies who best represented them together.  Think about it.  Applejack, even as a filly, was honest to a fault.  Rarity was much more generous than the average filly or colt, using the gems she found for her costumes rather than for personal gain.  Pinkie Pie is harder to place, but as we've seen, she had that party spirit in her all the time.  Fluttershy was extremely kind, willing to help frightened animals she only just met.  And Rainbow Dash is extremely loyal.  In fact, if she had known about Fluttershy falling, I know she would have forfeited the race just to help her.  As for Twilight, everypony wanted to be her friend.  She was the one resisting.  So, even as fillies, the Mane 6 represented the Elements of Harmony so much that they were drawn to them eventually.

Sorry for the wall, I just didn't know where to split it in two.


Celestia knew that the mane 5 could connect to the element and celestia send twilight to release luna from mightmare moon and create the spark


I like to think that Celestia didn't right the dusty old books part, but that spike tried to make up an exuse for twilight to stop reading so spike and twilight could do stop OUTSIDE her studies.


Perhaps it was a vision from celestia. She had a vision in the episode twilights kingdom. Perhaps she had one and saw the mane 6 in the future


Also if not for that rainboom none of the mane six would've got their cutie marks and could've been blank flanks forever


The reason why Clelestia  only locked nightmaremoom in the moon for a thousand years and the mane six turned her back to Luna was cause Celestia didn't fully represent three of the elements so the spell was broken


i think that celestia knew that twilight was the element of magic and the elements are settleing for the other 5


it says that celestia was and owned half the elements of harmony while luna owned and used the other half. Also probhably the reson why it only lasted 1000 moons was b/c they were no longer contected and it wasn't right for celestia to used all of them against luna. SO there fore it worked but it only worked for a little bit. The other reason why i can prove this b/c when ever the mane six evil ppl, they hasn't so far come back because they are all connected. But if it was just one of them like rarity or twilight using the elements to defeat terek and not the mane six them i bet that the evil ppl would be able to find a way to escape some how.  i also know yall may be wondering well, terek escaped and the princesses used it against him. Well the reason why he escaped it wasn't cause of the elements of harmony but possibly because the three headed dogs escaped from their post back in its about time. and terek was probably spending all that time to gain power to steal magic and by the time he did that was when in the episode Tiwlight's Kingdom. Think about it and let me know if you agree or have anything to say. Thanks!


Dis doesn't have to do with any of this,but,well I always think..."The universe is so big there could be MORE of us out there still looking for many solutions...Maybe we are not alone..." And then I thought this "Equestria might,just,might be one of those planets out there in the universe where ponies have technology and can talk...Maybe THEY are the other "Humans" and the writers know about them!" Then I thought it was dumb :/


Mane are their elements<br>Flutter shy is the most kindest pony in equestria Apple Jack is the most honest Rarity is the most generous Rainbow dash is the most amazing, awesome, cool, daring, loyal [oh sorry got a little carried away] what I trying to say is that their perfect the way they are they deserve their elements

Mane are their elements
Flutter shy is the most kindest pony in equestria Apple Jack is the most honest Rarity is the most generous Rainbow dash is the most amazing, awesome, cool, daring, loyal [oh sorry got a little carried away] what I trying to say is that their perfect the way they are they deserve their elements


Destiny its what I always believe in it so to me coincidence is just superstition I like to think Destiny is best because Destiny is how you choose a path you go so Destiny


No, that is a misconception. Nightmare moon's imprisonment, was not for 1000, but was even longer. "The stars will aid in er escape" SHE ESCAPED!!! She wasn't let free or the curse didn't end there, she escaped and Celestia knew that she would


Has anyone else thought that Dare Do could have something to do with this? I mean like she does fight evil to.


its a good theory but any one can be an element of harmony.lets say that the mane 6 were boy they would still control the elements right?


also celestia could of set it up coz remember when celestia saw twilights cutie mark she saw it on the tree and her element she must of tried to set it up then also granny smith with the zap apples thats what made ponyville celestia saw the seeds and said they were good for some reason why maybe she wanted the apple family to make ponyville and dont ask me how she knew about applejack SHES A FREAKIN ALICORN WITH POWERFUL MAGIC SHE CAN PROBABLY SEE INTO THE FUTURE USING HER MAGIC SHE HAD A FREAKIN DREAM WHICH WAS A VISION!!!!! sorry about shouting well the others can come in later on in the show


If I was an element, I would be the element of anger lmao, and I think they are elements opposite the elements of harmony


But even if this was the destiny would celestia brought them together sooner to become friends?


well i think it is because how they act in the past but even though they sometimes don't that will never change the past


Twilight was born to protect the tree of harmony.Because her cutie mark resembles it!!the most importent one is magic that's why it is the only one showing on her cutie mark.The 5 stars surrounding it represents the elements of harmony!!


What if there's an episode in season 5 where the main 6 meets the male main six it would be awesome!


But does that make the Mane Six better and "more special" than other ponies?


I think that the answer to the question is that those 6 not only fit in each one of the elements, but they are connected in a very special way because of the Sonic Rainboom. This event made Twilight get her cutie mark that is very special, because it's directly related to the elements of harmony, and with the magic exposed by the Sonic Rainboom, those 6 ponies became linked somehow, as all of them only got their cutie marks because of the same thing, and one of them has a very special role on the history of Equestria, that is Twilight's cutie mark. I don't know if Celestia planned to all the other 5 to get along with themselves, but i think that somehow she discovered the bond that those 6 have, and that's why she sent Twilight to Ponyville. However, one thing that I want to point is that maybe it was the friendship from ancient ponies that created the elements, as we see in one episode, Clover the Clever makes that "magic fire heart", and that incident may be what allowed the elements to exist in the first place. If that's true, the mane 6 shouldn't even need the elements after some point, because they're the elements. The essence of friendship is what created the elements, they're just a tool that holds this power. The mane 6 are the ones that creates and have this essence with them. And if the theory of Clover being Twilight is correct, that explains everything. Knowing friendship and having a great experience in doing magic, she would easily be able to unite all of them there and doing such great feat, and by being so, her cutie mark didn't come from the elements of harmony, it's the element that received the same shape of Twilight's cutie mark. I think this would explain everything.

@The Brony Notion I really think you should give a look at my last comment, and thanks for making me thinking about those things, it's not the first time that I evolve and create a theory based on the theory of someone. It's amazing that MLP has so much things to think about, it's a great world and history to be explored by theories and stuff.


That's why I wonder why RainbowDash isn't a alicorn or the element of magic cause she was the one who made the other 5 get their cutie marks and was the only one who did help with out saying Twilight cause she already had magic going on


i like to think that Celestia was WAY out of this picture  Celestia new that twilight had the potential to become an alicorn and because of her own grief didn't want her to end up like her self as we no  Celestia has no real friends that we can see in the show so ya she was just preparing her for the future well that's what i think at least  : )


u make a great point, I like your theory and it helps explains a lot


I don't think age or gender matters. If anything relating to each other dispite diffences is more what friendship is about.


Coincidence and destiny are very similar but in the end you never know what will happen


To be honest I think its destiny and these 6 ponies were meant to save equestria and be the bearer of the elements of harmony, I guess its all fate.


The fact that things went horribly wrong without the Rainboom is proven when starlight glimmer stops it


So, you're telling me that Celestia is a party pony like Pinkie,or the elemnt of laughter?<br>


if your theory about ages and gender mixes is correct , why cant the mane six be stallions??


Why was just Twilight made Alicorn, hence, IMMORTAL? Because she is the only REAL bearer of the element of magic. When her friends all, um, END, she will make new friends with the same elemental qualities. The only non-expendable one is Twilight. So she was made immortal.


I know what makes them so special they have balance two of each race!


Actually, Celestia would be perfectly be a B le to use them cause she brings harmony that's my though :D


Could you make a video on which EoH Celestia & Luna represented?


What about when spike had the element of loyalty in return of harmony. He is very loyal to the main 6 but when he wore it it did not work so it has to be rainbow dash who wears it


Mabye Starswird knows this and told Celestia to help him fulfilled the future princess's destiny


Celestia have known, that Twilight will be the Princess of Magic, because in the past she saw Twilight's cutiemark on the tree of harmony!

Тася Беляева


I think that you are right and make more videos on this kind of ponies.


Good theory, but girls can have just as strong friendships with boys. Heck, half my friends that i can truly count as friends are boys. Other than that,  this was an interesting theory.

same i a more popular with the.boys than girls


I'm starting to think Sawtooth is the element of Theories


Another thing about twilight's destiny is Her cutie mark  the main star in the center representing the element of magic and the other five around representing the other elements


Neither. The Tree of Harmony rigged it all. And I mean it ALL. Tirek, NMM, Discord, Chrysalis, Sombra, etc. etc.


then why was king sombra still evil after the mane six used their magic on HIM?


Maybe only the main 6 can do it becuse they all got thier cutiemarks at the same time.


The whole rainboom was the mane event of the season 5 finale.


This was confirmed in season 7 (Celestia Advice)


Don’t get it but because here’s the thing I think I know why they were chosen it’s because of their personality traits 🙄


Starswirl is a time traveler so he created destiny, nuff said.


celie could have planned even more far than you think. Wasn't granny smith's family supposed to start pony ville? Coment if you agree


I'd say coincidence DID happen, but not in the way you'd expect.
Fans believe in Trollestia because their mindset said to them: This setup is BS, there's no such things as Coincidence (second bit is Rule 39 from NCIS). But actually there is coincidence in this episode. Twilight followed her list, but did Celestia KNOW who got their Cutie Marks during the Sonic Rainboom incident? We don't really know because there's nothing supplementing this.
It could easily have been coincidence for Celestia to choose them based on their skills rather than their elements.
1. Fluttershy is known to work with animals and could easily gather a choir of birds to sing for her arrival.
2. Applejack was having her family reunion and Celestia asked them because there were dozens of Apple cooks that could make multiple treats without a hassle.
3. Rainbow Dash just happened to be one of the ponies having a weather job AND was known for being fast. She could clear the skies easily even with a tight deadline.
4. Rarity was an up and coming designer with a fantasy for Canterlot. Asking her to decorate for her visit was a step into the right direction for Rarity's dream (again, coincidence that it would help Rarity's standing).
5. Pinkie Pie is a legend in Ponyville for throwing excellent parties that surpass the GGG (because Tia knows just how 'great' the GGG really is... YEAR AFTER YEAR AFTER YEAR!! (LOLZ!!)). I wouldn't put it past Tia to ask Pinkie Pie to organize the celebration because she wanted a bit of fun before returning to the mundane job of ruling Equestria.
SO yeah... I can believe the coincidence. It just so happens that destiny had the final say and guided the six of them together immediately after NMM returned and brought about the Eternal Eclipse.
Thoughts anypony? Could this idea be legit (I REFUSE to call it a theory because I'm going with the facts that were given to Twilight on the list and possible reasons behind it given future episodes)?


Do a Pegasus have to have the element of loyalty? Or a earth pony have to have the element of honesty? Or a unicorn have to have the element generosity? Please answer my question!

No, I don't think it matters what type of pony one is, if Rarity was the honest one, she could be that element.


You know it is just a show. Isn't it pretty likely that the writers just had an idea in mind for the main characters, so they just put it together that way.


Then why is the element of Harmony the cutie marks of the main 6?


whoes to say just those 6 got their cutimarks due to the sonic rainbow just cuz it  wasnt mentioned other ponies coulda had it effect them too. Also i dnt think it had to be those 5 to get the elements of harmony  since the elements did shape themelves to their cutie marks minus twilight it could of been any other 5 that fit also through pinkie pie was friends with everypony in ponyvile the others came together because  of twilight so if others had been in charge then they could been the ones to come together i guess minus rainbowdash the others just BEST represented that element through i find generosity (rarity) and sharing (fluttershy) to basically be the same thing

i exlucded rainbow dash because she is selfish and egotistically through toned down througput the seasons and i dnt really see why she gets loyalty or an element at all through


I think that destiny helped the mane six to meet each other


oh and the reason why the spell was broken was because of the stars or Celestia no longer became connected to the elements


maybe somepony who travels through time told Celestia that Twilight had to go to ponyville & told her that the ponys preparing & TW will help Equestria, so Celestia had to  send TW


in a clover is twilight theory this all make sense.  twi go back in time become clover but past celestia discover it and ask about the future. twi said that to celestia and a thousand years later celestia would alredy know her pupil Twi and her friends.<br>As you said in that episode (is Twi colver the clever?) Twi cannot know if what she do in the past change the future.

in a clover is twilight theory this all make sense.  twi go back in time become clover but past celestia discover it and ask about the future. twi said that to celestia and a thousand years later celestia would alredy know her pupil Twi and her friends.
As you said in that episode (is Twi colver the clever?) Twi cannot know if what she do in the past change the future.


I figured this out a wile back the six in real life if you met the my main six you would have  thought  they were the opposite of their elements the were chosen because rd doesn't seem like she would be loyal and applejack in real life would be tricky or a cheater or a Liar and so on but i dont really know about fs and pp but rest of them would like how discord change them


i agree but there 1 thing im not certain about<br>remember back when discord takes over and got turned into stone by Luna and Celesta? does that mean only Luna has 3 of them elements in her personality? since you already covered that celestia has all.

i agree but there 1 thing im not certain about
remember back when discord takes over and got turned into stone by Luna and Celesta? does that mean only Luna has 3 of them elements in her personality? since you already covered that celestia has all.


there is no such thing as coincidence only inevitability. it was destiny.


I think your next video should be your predictions for season 5 or the Cutie Mark Crusaders cutie marks


That's why they were destined to be the elements of harmony there the main characters


Celecita saw those 5 ponies and knew they were very special not destiny


Me and my friends carry the elements of harmony.
Me= Magic
Chanel: Laughter
Sibora: Honesty
Emyalynn: Generosity
Ariana: Loyalty
Julia: Kindness
BTW u don't know any of these people
Also when we put my crystals I gave them together we got the
tails ears the whole she bang


Celestia just sent her away because like Twilight was alone a lot of her life besides with spike and her brother.


'If there were stallions in the group then wouldn't be able to relate as well'

And I thought Bronies were the progressive ones


𝗧𝗶𝘁𝘁𝗹𝗲: Coincidence or Destiny?<br>𝗠𝗲: No. Its he SPIRIT OF HARMONY

𝗧𝗶𝘁𝘁𝗹𝗲: Coincidence or Destiny?
𝗠𝗲: No. Its he SPIRIT OF HARMONY


Some things should just be left unexplained.<br>


What do stallions do in equestria besides farming since there's all lot of ponies doing work than other stuff


one thought of mine was that they needed them to do it for the friendship rainbow ro look more like a rainbow then just a line of random colors.. Just a thoguht!


well I think that the main six are connected so they bear the elements


That's what makes you a true mlp fan your theory's and morals you are the best man bro hoof


They were put together because the were connected before they knew each other.


Okay... This is my thought. It was Derpy- wait... what? Never mind. Music did it! (Why do you think that?) 'Cause it's music! Oh, and the books! Books are full of know-how. They might decode this encrypted data. (... Are you serious?) Not even in the slightest! (... Wow. So, you only did this on a whim?) Pretty much!~ Pinkie Pie's Purple Party Popcorn Paradox~ (I really think you need to go see Zecora. There must be some kind remedy for this.) Persibree noktease for blue cheese~ (Come on. You're coming with me to the Everfree Forest.)


I.mean yeah.Princess Celestia well always be there for Taillight.Can't you tell when she turn into a Alicorn.


I only have part of a story but maybe on the day Twi got her Cutie Mark Celestia was attracted because she had seen that mark on the tree of harmony. Maybe she thought that she was suppose to be the next bearer so she happened to set her up to finds her friends or something.... Idk you guys try and sole the rest :P

Celestia can be subtle, and she doesn't need to know ALL the details. However, as we see Granny Smith tell Applebloom's class... Granny Smith's father had collected a variety of seeds, which impressed Celestia for some reason and assigned them to the place that became Ponyville. So having the Apple Family as feast-providers makes sense. Not to mention the zap-apple jam founding Ponyville! Just makes sense for Twilight to connect with that much history as well.Also, the Rainboom hardly escaped her notice. She'd certainly want to know more. However, Twily's uncontrolled magic boost was an emergency she needed to take care of first. Celestia likely learned about Fluttershy from Rainbow Dash (I imagine RD as being very concerned about her to the point she just won't listen to anything until she knows FS is safe.). So she knows four of them as is. Also, I guess Celestia arranged for Rainbow Dash to be an early graduate from the Flight School, (which the two bullying colts could interpret as RD being kicked out to tease her about it). With a job in Ponyville weather team to boot. She likealso arranged for Fluttershy's apartment. These two would then be there...Next step... is it that much to assume there was a list of preferences about the party given in advance to Mayor Mare? Like some things specific to Apple Family and a bird choir for music. Rarity volunteered to make the decorations. And... well, Pinkie did everything on her own.


well... you can have lasting friends of any age. I know I do, I have my family, people that are way younger than me, way older than me, and not many people my age.


I would say Cleastia planned this, because of Clestial advice


i think thats because the mane six have the same age group. it could also be because they all poses one thing, friendship. twilight is the princess of friendship but they all bare friendship


if celestia did set up the six to meet twilight due to their jobs for the prep then why was did she never make pinkie have one of the jobs (pinkie just twilight by random and not by twilight having to meet her)


For some reason this episode reminds me of the Doctor Who episode "Father's Day".


No man can escape from it's own history...<br>


What about Stars World may be he was behind all this  . Well he is from the past. He might have to find some ponies whose gargen will not stop or some ponies who can sacrifice there life for there friends , who would understand the true meaning of friendship


If the theory is true then princess celestia  asked  who was the best party planner that means laughter.Who was the pony who got along with animals means kindness .Princess Celestia  already knew  apple jack's family because she gave them the spot at ponyville for their farm. But I don't know why she choose rarity and rainbowdash?or maybe she asked  cloudsail  who made the rainboom then she picked  rainbowdash because a rainboom was just a lengend. But I still don't understand why rarity.


Actually it was celestia revealed in celestial advice


I don't agree about one thing: Celestia bear the elements "alone" because her sister (the second bearer) was still there  even if she was in NM form. When she was banished on the moon Celestia couldn't use the elements anymore (if celestia was loyalty as official wikipedia says) she betray her sister so she is not loyal anymore. The elements turn to stone until the mane six arrive.


i think its all linked to twilight:
you see heres my idea (P.S. i have no proof)
twilight had all the magic for the elements then when she met the other main six somehow it spread through out them.
but i dont have any proof so somebody please back me up


celestia also knew twilight  would be a princess cause at the  end of cyrstal empire part 2 celestia and launa  seemed to agree it was time for her to fulfilll  her destiny when celestia brought out the BOOK that contained tha spell.


before twilight got wings there was 2 of each kind of pony in the main 6


The weird thing is there are 2 earth ponies 2 pegasus and well there used to be 2 unicorns.


I disagree about the gender part I seem to hav the same bond on males and females and also the same w/ my friends


Why do i kinda think the tree of harmony picked them because the tree of harmony isn't alive (well sort of is but every alive tree is) its the spirit of harmony


That and the fact that now the elements are now tied to the particular ponies. Remember when discord hypnotized the mane 6 and twi game the loyalty pendant to spike, it didn't work


Think about this DISCORD he could use the element of magic just fine so WHY has HE NEVER EVEN USED IT!?!?!?!!!!


mabye the sonic rainboom is the thing that Destiny use to bind the Mane Six together. It gave them their cutie marks. And that is the plot.(get it)


Destiny decided it. Who are we to question that fact?


I don’t like celestia... she’s too perfect 👌🙃


this is completely irrelevant to this video but.

its Zecora, she is the shadow pony, she was prob banished to the everfree forest and thats y everypony was afraid of her

the first time we see her she is wearing a hood and her eyes glow/shine yellow

also when we first hear about the shadow pony they're all in the castle in the everfree forest


Destiny is not the only thing that matters it's about friendship😁


Rule #39: There is no such thing as a coincidence.


Actually to be truelful NO Tia may have set it up some how but I think I may know how mlp episode just about time the time travel spell they never had a limit to how far u could go or how many times u use it she may have known what to do ahead of time in plus WHAT WAS TIA DOING IN THERE I mean I would get it if she walked past the entrance also she may have used her sister hint hint NOT LUNA ( season 5 Tia and Luna r supposed to have a long lost sister) who has the cutie mark of TIME so she may have just used her to c into the future


Nice theory's. love to chat with you sometime about ponies... And stuff...


In Magical Mystery Cure Celestia sings "To fafill Your destiny"	(sorry i dont know How to spell good English) A destiny , which is a cutiemark. Was Twilights destiny to be a princess?


the rain boom made them 6 a part of the elements of harmony


celestial advice confirmed this! you were right!


i think the mane six had to be those ponies because it isnt because it cant just be a random pony representing a element they have to have friendship


This is what I think:
There was this prophecy never mention in FIM its self that went something like this: "Legend will unite those who will use the six to defeat evil many times"
Legend: Sonic Rainboom performed by young Rainbow Dash
Those: The Main Six
The Six: The elements of Harmony
Evil: Every evil character defeated by the main 6

+Mr_Snoo i think that makes sense also where was the prophecy mentioned

Which episode was that prophecy mentioned in?


you know all there should be an episode for some of the background ponies no main six just background ponies


i really dont understand but my mind is blown so great job! :)


Sometimes when I watch or play adventure games/movies, I wonder why they even did this, you know? They could of just when to bed...


The fate of Equestra does not depend on me on making friends!--Twilight Sparkle
Wait a few seasons
THEN SHE'S SHE THE PRINCESS OF FRIENDSHIP


Watch season 5 finale and you'll understand


Didn't twilight say herself that equestria did rest on her making friends in season 3 or 4...


They are called elements of harmony and they share the harmony and friendship when they defeated night mare moon because


Someone should write a fanfiction of an AU episode 1 and 2 of S1 with the ponies at 3:36 instead of the mane 6 😂😂


Pillars and the Young 6: I'm gonna end this man's whole career


Sirius is alive?! I knew that he  died. I am so happy!😀


I think that it has to do with the fact that they are linked through the sonic rainboom event were they got there cutie marks


I think she did and even planed her to become  a princess cuz in won episode when twilight was going to take her test aka Chrystal empire  Luna was scared and Celestial said something like dont worry she will do it and the more closer she will be ready aka become a princess


I think it was desteny,I mean in seson 7 theres a soulucion she was surly get them the jobs so the easy think was just to sent Twilight to Poniville everything else was alredy done.Right?


even if anypony could bear the Elements of Harmony, Twilight Sparkle must still be the Element of Magic. Why? Twilight Sparkle is the Princess of Friendship/Magic. In Equestria, friendship is MAGIC! Am I correct? Or am I wrong. Just thought of it.


quick thought, twilight is the princess of friendship right, well the title of the show is call my little pony friendship is magic, so wouldn't twilight also be the princess of magic to? plz do a vid on this if ur reading this bn!


Most people think the main six are teens but in pinkie pride diamond tiara sang "she planed my quinceañera" implying that she is 15 soooo have any ideas?


Well, Fluttershy kinda already knew Rainbow Dash before the Sonic Rainboom incident.


What if princess Celestia is a changling and she has clones of herself in different forms witch could be an evil/good character like: Twilight, Discord,and Other characters.


No celestia didnt repersent all the elements but the main six did


Destiny made Celestia to send Twilight in Ponyville


And will u make a video of why the elements changed into necklaces?


you should do a video on Maud Pie THAT WILL BE AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D :D :D


becuz shes one pony! even tho shes a alicorn that's very powerful, its still less powerful than 6 ponys' friendship magic !


You know. When princess celestia was banishing her sister to the moon she started fake smiling


Yes because the spell only lasted 1,000 years...not long at all...


Are you saying I can't be friends with myself? Aw man


I just realized that Brony Notion predicted the season 5 finale.


It is destiny and for twilight it was chosen fate because frim season 1 to now they have been teaching her on how to be a princess and the tree of harmony had twilights cutie mark so celestria knew in what she would become by a look at her cutie mark


I think that it probably was destiny.....but u make a good point


And you literally just said anypony and everypony can break the fourth wall JUST LIKE PINKIE PIE.


actually have you noticed that in rainbow rocks when they make the rainbow at the end it doesn't show green? But when it makes the rainbow ball that has wings it shows green. THIS IS WERID......


The elements also match their cutie marks. That's why they were chosen. Just like Twilight.


Do you think that celestia didn't mean to send Luna to the moon? Maybe she ment to turn Luna back but it went wrong or maybe she's a princess with no soul and ment to send her sister to the moon


it's Destiny, Twilight's Cutie Mark show's it
A Big Star - Princess Twilight
Five Stars - Mane 5


I know why its them six. the were destined together from when they got their cutie mark.


Celestia set this up 1000 years ago. Celestia and Luna used the Elements against Sombra and Discord. Celestia then sent Luna/Nightmare to the moon with the Elements. When she did this, she broke Harmony and could not use the Elements. Didn't the mane six have to find the Elements of Harmony? Celestia used her magic to protect Equestria for nearly 1000 years. It seems that only now are the enemies of Equestria are able to attack. Remember that Discord's seeds could not attack Equestria until now. The Crystle empire and Sombra did not return until now. The Changelings attack now. Celestia knew she would not be able to protect Equestria forever. Her powers are getting weak. The Changling Queen defeated her rather easily. One day, she will not be able to raise the sun. I think Sunset Shimmer was to be her replacement for sunrise (her cutie mark is a sun) and Twilight Sparkle for moonrise (her cutie mark is a star). I think Celestia and Luna will die defending Equestria and Twilight, Sunset, and the Elements of Harmony will defeat this last greatest enemy and peace will reign.


destiny. because she know that twilight had the magic.


I think Flister you knew when all the main six were born and then she's Plana a big plan and then they made well she made the race and so they can all meet when they didn't even met yet


What episode can u see how They got their cutiemarks? Most have missed it


Here's a question. How much is The pony currency 'bit'?


Don't you notice that Twilight's cutie Mark has five around it then in the middle is six soooooo......... maybe twilight is the reason that the mane six  has elements

just my opinion like if you agree with me also reply if you think that too👍👍👍