Jannes Veuger something like this would be much harder to come up with for the Bedrock edition, mostly because no-one has made a good enough C++ decompiler yet.
Christopher Smith idk tbh. I guess it comes from when I was doing all this with a client side mod that would throw the items out so quickly that it would have already thrown out 10 stacks before you're able to pick anything up again. But yeah, I guess that many items aren't really necessary for this method.
This didn't work for me on a server (Spigot). I tried the process several times, but keep getting "Player seed not found" on the second step. Perhaps it's because they use a different random number generator than vanilla?
I didn't manage to get to the enchanting step (got stuck on step 2...couldn't find the seed), but for dummy items I was using shovels. Does the item type affect the outcome? I'm not sure of the Spigot version, I don't control the server.
Same issue here... Playing on a pure Vanilla server 1.12.2 or even the latest BETA (no matter if SSP or SMP) makes no problem. As soon as I enter my Bukkit based community server, it doesn't work.
I can get the XP seeds, but calculation of the Player seed fails.
"This server is running CraftBukkit version git-Bukkit-94b0980 (MC: 1.12.2) (Implementing API version 1.12.2-R0.1-SNAPSHOT)" Maybe this helps? ;)
Good question. I'm just a user, not an admin of it. All I know is, that it's hosted via Cubedhost. maybe there's a "/plugins" command... ..... yup! "Plugins (7): CoreProtect, Waypoints, AcceptRules, Simple-AutoSave, WorldEdit, WorldGuard, GriefPrevention"
Hey no worries mate, I had much the same issues getting OBS to cooperate with my system as well when using Game Capture and fullscreen. Turns out Nvidia overlay was fighting for control over it and disabling that fixed it up just fine.
Hope you don't mind me asking but does it affect anything if another person on a multiplayer server does any of the things you shouldn't do, and once you've gotten your player seed does that change per world, and does the player seed differ for each person on a server? Sorry for asking so many questions,but i hope you get back to me, thank you for your help.
Hey man, so I got the enchantment seeds right? when I tried calculating the player seed it said it couldn't calculate it.. Did I do something wrong?? I ran the enchcracker.bat file and that's all I did.. Did I forget to do something??
@Earthcomputer Are you sure it works (the mac version)? Ive tried opening the jar and looking at it but there seems to be nothing there i can use to open it, unless its the wrong jar in which case where is the mac download? P.S. i don't know much about programing so i might be being super dumb right now...
@Earthcomputer 2 quick qs: 1) (Not to be that guy in the comment section of an old technical video but) Does anyone know if this still works in the current 1.16 versions of Minecraft? 2) Would this work on a Multiplayer world where others may be eg. dying, killing mobs, gaining xp etc? Or does it only require the player doing the enchanting to not do those first actions?
Anyway, super cool concept and video, and very well done for making this!!
RaysWorks made a video about this on april fools. I thought it was fake but then he mentioned that you had an explanation. This is really impressive, well done! It's absolutely ground-cracking (pun intended).
the technical minecraft players love to upload creations on april fools, to make a lot of players think the stuff is fake. Like the shulker shuker or edd's bedrock in survival (both are working creations)
Mojang Dev: "You know someone can crack this enchant system, maybe we should work on it some more." Managment: "That's crazy talk! Who does that? No one would ever put that much work into cracking the seed. Ship it."
@John Doe This is how it basically was before 1.8. Were the seed was random each time you put something into the enchanting table. But you always had to put it in and out again to get a specific level, which was really annoying.
no one at mojang ever made the game with the intent to make it inaccessible to the more technically inclined audience, though it would not be out of the realm of possibility for microsoft to do something counter to that logic ;P
@FilliamPL Not true at all. The original version of endermen were specifically built to break mob grinders. That is why they pull up blocks (there used to be no limit to what blocks they'd steal), and why they teleport away from water (all farms back then used water). It was only after the players were in a fury over endermen destroying all builds (not just grinders), that Mojang changed them to their current incarnation. There have been lots of little changes over the years that were designed to break grinders, and only more recently have they taken a more lax attitude to them.
@Livid Imp And because of that continuous failure mojang definitely embraces the technically inclined playerbase to tinker with aspects of the game
0 likes
Jack Eldridge2021-06-13 09:32:16 (edited 2021-06-13 09:33:13 )
Not how it works bro, it's fundamental to the function of Java. RNG manipulation relies on the fact that in Javascript RNG is generated from a set hexidecimal number, which is a seed, using a standard equation. Eventually numbers repeat bc Java is essentially a virtual machine running on your system running a complier that takes the C code your computer uses and compiles it into JS. This virtual machine is 32-bit, it cannot exceed integers greater than that when dealing with real numbers. Therefore the size of the hexidecimal numbers it can calculate is inherently limited. Basically, try running Windows 10 on a Pentium MMX. That's what you're asking of Java
@Jack Eldridge I feel like you got some things wrong with this technical explanation. First of all, you're switching between Java and JavaScript, despite the languages being completely different. Secondly, the JVM converts bytecode to machine language/processor instructions. Neither C nor Javascript are involved in that process whatsoever. Third, Java comes in 32 or 64 bit varieties, and even then I'm sure it has some form of large integer type. Finally, the analogy with "the random function only takes 32 bit seeds" to "it's like running windows 10 on a 20 year old processor" doesn't make much sense.
@cachemist Cheers man I can't code for shit, you definitely clarified a lot of things about my very simple understanding, but I'm certain of one thing and that's that my 32-bit thing is correct LOLL. MC only used 32-bit Java until 1.17 released, and most of its integer functions are limited by that still. That's why the Pentium comparison came in, it's integer limited in the same way 32-bit Java is, although in terms of not being able to run 64 bit instructions as opposed to not understanding 64 bit instructions u feel?
Oh wow. How long did it take you to do this? This is insanely cool. Especially how you even explained how everything works in the end. Only figuring this out could take a long time, but then actually cracking it, thats insane
Oreo Lamp it took about a month to work from an observation in the code to the method you see in the video. The last 5 minutes took a few days to edit :)
so "no dummy" is the programs way of telling you that you are the dummy, because you would have gotten the enchant if you just went for it, instead of spending hours punching in numbers into the tool xD Great video.
Step 1. Get all the items as shown in the video. Step 2. Take a dummy item and enchant it. After that put it in the bin. Step 3. Take another dummy and use the info as shown in the video (5:52) Step 4. When you got the seed from the step 3. dummy enchant it and throw it away. Step 5. Repeat step 3. with another dummy except this time DON'T enchant it at the end. Step 6. Than you throw the necessary amount of items on the ground (18:45) Step 7. Once you've done that you enchant the dummy from step 5. Step 8. And now enchant the real item (for example diamond sword)
Step 9. (if you have more items): Press done on the cracker and calculate again. Step 10. Now throw out the amount of item which you get in the cracker. Step 11. Enchant a dummy item. Step 12. Enchant the real item.
For another item repeat the process from step 9. to step 12.! And also it works from 1.11.1 - 1.12.2.
Hope this helps!
Section 1. Paragraph 1. : What to type in the enchant text box in the manipulate section of the EnchCracker?/ When I type an enchant in the text box the outline turns red and nothing happens! if you have encountered any of the two problems keep reading ;)
Section 1. Paragraph 2. - Possibilities There's 3 possibilities: 1. You typed the enchantment ID wrong or you don't know what to write, if so Section 1. Paragraph 4. is your problem solver, if not try possibility 2. 2. Your item is a treasure enchant which basically means getting it via an EC isn't an option, more on that in the Section 1. Paragraph 3. 3. Your item is an exception, if you thing that's the case and you've tried both of the options above read Section 2.
Section 1. Paragraph 3. - Treasure enchants Treasure enchants. As the name suggests they are only obtainable via strongholds, spawners, end cities etc. with treasure (chests with loot). These enchants are: Mending, Thorns, Curse of Binding, Curse of Vanishing, Frost Walker. If your enchant is listed here you got your answer if not there are exceptions listed in Section 2. that also includes Thorns in case you are still encountering the problem from Section 1. Paragraph 1.*)
Section 1. Paragraph 4. - Enchantment ID List
(if your enchant had an "*In exception list*" tag you might want to read Section 2. Paragraph 1. )
Protection protection Fire Protection fire_protection Feather Falling feather_falling Blast Protection blast_protection Projectile Protection projectile_protection Respiration respiration Aqua Affinity aqua_affinity Depth Strider depth_strider Sharpness sharpness In exception list Smite smite In exception list Bane of Arthropods bane_of_arthropods In exception list Knockback knockback Fire Aspect fire_aspect Looting looting Sweeping Edge sweeping Efficiency efficiency In exception list Silk Touch silk_touch Unbreaking unbreaking In exception list Fortune fortune Power power Punch punch Flame flame Infinity infinity Luck of the Sea luck_of_the_sea Lure lure
Section 2. Paragraph 1. - Exceptions
And the ones listed below are exceptions (via EC = via Enchanting table) 1. Bane of Arthropods (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on Axes, otherwise easily obtainable for Swords via EC) 2. Unbreaking (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on Elytra, Hoes, Shields, Flint and Steel, Carrot on a Stick, otherwise easily obtainable for all other tools via EC) 3. Sharpness (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on Axes, otherwise easily obtainable for Swords via EC) 4. Smite (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on Axes, otherwise easily obtainable for Swords via EC) 5. Efficiency (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on Shears, otherwise easily obtainable for Pickaxes, Shovels, Axes via EC) 6. Thorns (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on all pieces of armor except for the Chestplate)
Section 2. Paragraph 1. - Explains Section 2. Paragraph 1. Some enchants of the enchants from above can be done just by enchanting a book in the EC and than proceed to the Anvil (for example: Unbreaking on Elytra) others which arent listed on the long list below and are in the treasure enchant section need to be found in nature and than combined via Anvil (for example: Mending on Elytra)
What a discovery! Did you discover this on your own? If so than you're really going places and I can't wait to see what other Mojang-angrifing discovery you end up with mastering next.
Thanks a lot for making the video! I can not iamgine how much work you have done in order to dive in to the code of the RNG and get the current result with a clear and easy to use.jar file. I think that month must be tough. It is really a pity that a find this video too late and without ray's ideo I can not even got to know this.
Why youtube just not recommend sth like this to me every day. Dam.
Ok, back to the concept. Thanks again for your work to try some incredible cool stuff like controll the enchantment. A lot of people want to do some with the random part of minecraft but i think you go maybe the a lot of sters further than them. I am thinking about this can be a useful stuff for the UHC like ETA said ot even can be a useful stuff for changing the whole boring and though starting session of minecraft.
As we all know the beginner 's farm is slime farm, iron farm and a simple wither skeleton farm. In which two of the three will need a good looting 3 sword which can not be easily get before. But know we can just do it by using your code! Oh man, I really want every one to know it, especially me! I currently started a new world maybe three weeks ago and ban the fishing for myself which I think is the most cheaty thing in minecraft. So it takes me almost one week to have the breeder and combine two looting 2 book. The easy process can chage it into five min job! Thanks again and keep it up!
Ok, enough prase, it is the question time. I have watched the whole video and the only problem is a bit of laggy and I think it can be easily solve the next time so do not worry. I want to make sur that if we can do the same thing to the shovel and diamond pickaxe with the program? Then we can have a brand new way of strating the minecraf in the first few days.
Also I am thinking about other "random" stuff in the minecraft, like the drop from the mobs, the result of the fishing and also maybe the radomness of the tnt and ender pearls. I know that not all of them belongs to the same concept also we can fix tht with the carpet mod or some cool contraption like Xcom do to the ender pearl. But before this video we can do nothing to the echantment and the mob drops. You may have already get my point. Yes the mob drop. How did it caculate? I will apperciate if you can take a look to them and also maybe in the future we can make some kind of random factors then kill the wither skelton and get a skull for sure! That may not make sense. But think about the overpowered buggy helmet of the rider of the Skeleton trap like what ray should before. That is defenitely worth to do it to reduce the AFK time.
At last thanks again for the great work! if you can read the long comment,I will appericiate a lot since I do not know how to contact you with some other way (Sorry for that).
段学达 thanks for your comment! Yes this works on any enchantable item. As for mob drops, unfortunately these are calculated by different RNGs so you wouldn't be able to use the same technique. That doesn't mean it's impossible though, and if I find a way I'll make a video for sure.
@Stealthfang 270 you don’t need stone specifically it’s any item, you don’t need that many just an amount he gave himself (at most at had to throw out 3 stacks, usually under 1), and you get a lot of blocks in UHC regardless
Just an update this still WORKS in 1.14.4, I am on a public server and it works perfectly. Just make sure you are careful about knowing how many book shelves you have, it can get confusing some times
This is pretty interesting. Congrats on finding this out.Is the player seed static? If so does that mean that if you found your player seed once you only need to get the Xp seed once in combination with the current XP seed to start of the process or is this just wishful thinking.When skimming trough the comments some plugins mess with the process, if a plugin resets the xp seed every X minutes speed will be a major factor and skipping one of the 2 xp seeds will make it more usable on servers. Do you have any more information on this?
Just by accident I lost my sword and have a good opportunity to try out the method by myself and works quite nice as it should.
Thanks!!
And get a lot of more questions and advices which I want to talk with you.
1. Will the weather affect the enchantment? I was a luck boy then when I finished all the enchantment it just started to be a thunderstorm. So I have no chance to test it by myself. Since the thunder is kind of randomly summon an entity (as well as the skeleton trap) and cause fire. Also the fire has random tick to spread and extinguish. So I think they need the RNG to work with. So I am thinking about will that has some effect with the enchantment. I think rain itself is kind of fine but maybe some lightupdate also the clock to stop the rain etc. And maybe we will have the foggy or some other weather in the future. So maybe we need to better make sure that we do all the enchantment in a great sunny day?
2. In my personal opnion, there are still some place we can do to improve the .jar file like we can copy and paste the exp seed to the next step. Also I am not sure is it that intended that we can not type in the" fire aspect" in any kind of captiality.
3. Any kind of mob spawning or entity processing will break the RNG or it is just according to all the player motions? Since the RNG is according to the player seed maybe not that problem. But may be other thing like "taking damage" or "riding a horse" and some kind of other stuff related to the mob should be mentioned to not to do. (Maybe I just think too much. lol)
Again, Thanks for all your amazing work. Also if it is possible then maybe you can publish some progress update in the next concept.
Hi, 1 and 3 are easiest to answer, so let's start with them. The player RNG used for this is separate from the world RNG used for weather and mob spawning, and other RNGs used for other players and mob AI. So unless those things decide to come and attack you you should be fine. 2. In the latest version of the enchantment cracker (1.1.3 currently) you can copy and paste the XP seed from the first tab. If you have any more suggestions, make sure to put them on the issue tracker on the GitHub page, as I get to see them all rather than just what YouTube decides to show me. Have a nice day!
@Earthcomputer I have questions about RGN too: 1-Does multiplayer break/affects your RNG of the enchanting? 2-(Oh i Just realized you already answered this one to others) If another player does one of the things you shouldn't do during the process does it affect your RNG? 3-If mobs die but not because of the player killing them do they affect the RNG? 4-Is flying sonething to not do? (Cuz on a server i have VIP) 5-Is dropping non stackable items like dropping 64 items? 6-Does fortune act like unbreaking? 7-Am i annoying you? (if yes, Im Sorry i didn't wanted to)
@GregFRDT 1) No 3) No 4) No, but be careful not to fall from a height of 3 blocks or more, that will cause landing particles that break it 5) No 6) No 7) Certainly not :P
I am pretty sure that the code would make it impossible but can you find a seed that will create double enc? If so then it would be cool to spend a significant amount of time enchanting dummy items to get there.
I had the "No Player Seed Found" issue, but i tried it again another 3 times and eventually got it. You have to be triple sure you are doing it right. Thanks heaps for this!
Hey, this is really cool and a very useful tool, I must say! Good job on cracking the code! But I do have one question: I can't seem to type "silk touch" into your programm. Am I writing it wrong?
Wow! Very nice! thank you very much. Ive been playing with this all week. Works great. Im guessing you cant order thorns on your armor because it is too rare aka "impossible"? I can get it on books all day long but the program wont allow it on armor. would it be possible to alter the program slightly to clear the slot1/2/3 boxes after i hit "add"? This would speed up the XP seed steps alot. It would also be nice to include the words "enchant dummy" after/before the "throw items" in the instruction line just to keep me from brain farting. While your at it, could you just put buttons for each of the tool/armor and enchantments. Im asking alot. Just throwing ideas at ya if you wanted feedback, but regardless this is great and thanks again for sharing this. Subcribe!
What happens if it says 14 bookshelves at the end, do you have to drop the items first or block the bookshelves first?
0 likes
Wish IV me2020-07-24 02:39:27 (edited 2020-07-24 02:40:00 )
hey! do you think you could do the same type of thing with piglin bartering? like if you throw this many items with this player seed you would get ender pearls and so on
idk if its possible. I'm not a specialist on this type of things but piglin drops are based on loot tables with chances so its impossible to crack it based on logic.
i think this means that you created some form of rng during the calculating. meaning that you made random numbers generate. examples. breaking blocks?, picking up xp(its random), mending, elytra use(i think), unbreaking, sharpness, smite, ect. also You can't relog, change dimension or die during the process. some servers plugins break this process also
well i knew this was possible but i wouldnt have thought it practical since i d have expected you d have to search all 2^48 and not just 2^32 seeds which takes hours even on GPUs. it isnt exactly useful for technical play maybe something similar could be done for finding villagers, although i guess it wouldnt be so easy to get that to work properly since they detect doors at random and such things. i m sure there is some sort of proper application for something along these lines in technical minecraft but i cant really think of one
Jendrik Weise it's especially good for getting lots of the same enchantments in bulk. True, on a well-established server you can do the same thing with villagers, but in mid-game you may not quite have the resources to build massive crop farms and villager breeders to get the perfect trades. But honestly, it's probably more useful in UHC.
For everyone coming here recently wondering about MC 1.17.1, I tried it in singleplayer 1.17.1 and IT WORKS. I'm using Fabric (fabric loader) and have a few client side mods, none broke it. It probably works in vanilla and on any vanilla/fabric SMP too.
Wow... this is incredible... By the way, I am making a server based almost entirely on the enchantment table. Is there any way I can keep players from doing this all the time? Some way to randomize the player's seed every time they open the table?
Edit: Is it possible to make a special seed for players that is only used in enchanting? That way players can't influence their enchantment number using something else (like item throwing)?
heh, I've been working on rewriting that program in C++ since I first saw this video yesterday and after lots of reading Oracle's Java docs, reading MCP code, replaying parts of this video, tweaking, and debugging, I finally managed to get it to produce the correct levels given a seed, so I hope that's one of the hardest parts done.
awesome! btw, any actions/events that cause the player_rng to be called could be used, but throwing items is easier to control. this means that a player could still save his "setup" if he accidentially used the player_rng, by substracting from the number of items to throw away, right?
You make an interesting point. That's almost correct yes, except throwing an item used the player RNG 4 times, so to fix it you would have to realign yourself with that and then subtract from the item throws. But it would also require you to have exact knowledge how how many times the action you accidentally performed used the RNG, which probably makes it easier to just restart the process IMO.
In 1.14.4 I discovered, (completely by accident) Placing 3 torches in a northern northern facing triangle (directly next to the enchant table) locks the enchantments that you get, so they do not seem to change.
I love how this worked on my potato pc, with broken mouse, which double clicks randomly (guess I need to rng rl), but when I tried diamond_boots it showed me a lot of "impossible"s. Are there "too heavy" combinations?
Great tool, surprisingly easy to use! When I asked for Efficiency 4 unbreaking 2 diamond pickaxes it would reply "impossible". Is this because of the player seed or is that combination of enchants not possible to get?
I’ve done some testing to find that this seems to work tentatively on the Legacy PS4 edition. I’ll have to run some more tests later to ensure consistency, but getting maxed out diamond armor with the requested enchantments seemed almost too coincidental...
Every time I start looking for the XP seed and I get to about 65-ish % on finding the first seed, the cracker seems to overwhelm my computer and the program goes into a 'not responding' status. I'm not sure on why it would, does anyone have a good idea on how I could avoid that?
Big question here: with the randomness of the player being figured out, is it possible to potentially predict fishing loot and other loot table based things? or is it based on the timing of the server? Wondering if this could be any more game breaking. Great work, very nice!
Is there going to be a version for 1.13? I tried the program with 1.13-pre1 and it kind of worked, but not quite. The enchantments themselves matchup, but their levels seem to be random.
This is incredible! Maybe you could add a option to erase the last info you added because sometimes you just fuck up and it's anoying to start again( did this a couple of times in the first dummy)
I know they changed it so the enchantment seed is stored per player in 1.8, is there any way to replicate this in an earlier version, preferably 1.1? It only goes up to IV and there are no anvils until 1.6. Is it possible to do this?
I know this used to work in older versions, but I tried this in 1.14 and it didn't work, probably because new enchantments were added to the game which changes a lot about it.
Are you planning on updating it? I would love to see that, this is such an amazing feature!
i know this is a really old video but enchantment rng still works for now and i was wondering. Does you player seed change when you rejoin the game. when does the player seed change. is it per server?
OK then... There are issues with enchanting bows, specifically with certain enchantments like Infinity. Also, you can make the process more efficient and include more options to chose from. I know too little about the code, but couldn't this process also be used for more things besides enchanting?
1) known issue, will be fixed soon! 2) more efficient in what way? I'd say it's already quite efficient. 3) yes, there's some upcoming videos about that
Hello my question is can u get sharpness 4 looting 3 knockback 2 fire aspect 2 unbreaking 3 sweeping edge 3 (so a fully equiped sword) and can u throw the same items that u have already thrown away and picked up or not thanks a lot
Try inputting those enchantments into the tool, it should tell you whether it's feasible. You should be able to pick up all your items again, that doesn't affect anything ;)
Hello , This is incredibly cool , amazing. But i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
although the FPS isnt the best, Holly heck, i am happy to see people tinkering with MC to the extent, of searching how many trillions of seeds to get a Perfect enchant. Well done EC!
Hi! I know this is an old video but I have a question. When I try to find the first seed It appears as "No possible seeds" I don't know what I'm doing wrong and I was wondering if this works in realms/1.15.2
1) make sure you are following all the instructions precisely 2) make sure you are not doing any of those things you can't do (there's additional things in the description) 3) make sure the server isn't modded. Spigot by itself is okay, but some plugins are known to mess the process up.
Wow my man legit god of Minecraft, on from being weird tho thanks for spending prob the hours u did to do this it was very simple and eazy to understand and it worked first try but i forgot to enchant dummy at the end and now i have op wooden sword lol
Hi! found this recently in a SkipTheTutorial video and was wondering if this works in bedrock as well. If it does, then I have an incredible shop opportunity on my server.
i have tried this on servers in hopes for starting a busness and making a lot of money but remember one thing that if your server has plugins then they can mess with this cracker and it also doesnt work if your sever is paper
I'm playing 1.13.2 multiplayer, the program says the player seed was not found, and I've followed your video exactly like you did, enchanted the items with the torches all like in your video's momentums, and I'm using the latest version of your program, how does it not work?
please do not tell me you wasted that much time, this is outdated bro 💀💀 technically it still works but you could just use a fabric mod he made called "client commands" and call it a day instead of doing this much effort
@Endora 0 it is not a mod, it's a program to determine what to do to get the rng perfect to get your own enchantments you technically can do this if you're super clever and you know what to do without the program
Ok, did it on 1.14 and it kinda works. If I want efficiency 4 and unbreaking 3, the outcome wold give me both efficiency and unbreaking but at different levels. But I was still able to get silk touch.
Then you realize that 2b2t and most other servers you'd want to use this on run on Paper, which breaks or changes just about every single technical aspect of the game, including the manipulation of enchantment tables.
I have a question: you have to do that every time you want to enchant something? i mean, if you do all this an then you keep playing your survival world like usually; you have to do everything again to get the player seed?
I'm very sure that's a yes because if you do any of the things mentioned at the start (gain xp, etc.etc.) you change the player seed that is used for the table seed.
Attempted a few times, kept getting "No Possible Seeds". Followed the steps carefully in survival (bukkit server) Player seed not found twice; 14th attempt finally works, though not 100% consistent with the output.
I have a question, does the playerseed stay when you relog/cross dimenions (nether/end/overworld)? Thanks and great work.
Kuno as mentioned in the description, the player seed does not stay constant when you do those things. There's also some other important information in the description you should check out.
I'm currently playing on a 1.17 server and your enchantment method enticed my interest. However when I was watching your video I had a question. When using your method, is it okay to use multiple tools and types of armor? ex: diamond_sword, diamond_axe, diamond_pickaxe, diamond_helmet, diamond_chestplate, diamond_leggings, and diamond_boots. I also have another question which is about the dummy items. Do the dummy items have to be the same item as the tools or weapons you are trying to enchant? Your videos are amazing and I've been recently watching them. You deserve more subscribers and I hope you grow as a content creator! :)
hi earth computer, i really need help, every time i try to calculate the xp seed, they always tell me it fail to calculate. I got this like 3 times now, do u know how to fix this? Thank you and the video is great
Okay so I found a problem for MP. Everything works fine on singleplayer, tested it on MY 1.12.2 server seems to work just fine BUT when I try and do it on another 1.12.2 vanilla server it never works... Any clues?
Edit: nvm it was just the fact that I was sprinting...
Could this technology be used to figure out world seeds?? Maybe giving cords of certain biomes until it finds only one seed with such biomes on those cords.
19:03 How are you throwing it out? I've been able to get the player seed using a dispenser for the dummy swords, but the only way I know how to drop items individually is either single clicking them off the side of the inventory, or pressing q, both of which you said you couldn't do. I tried making a dispenser bin for the dropping of the stacks of items, but it won't work.
TL;DR What are you clicking to drop them individually like that?
You are allowed to throw out items (by whatever means you like, Q, clicking, etc), as long as the method explicitly says you can. You just can't throw items any other time.
Hello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
But i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
@Earthcomputer oh thanks for the response , seems the server is at bungeecord , then i can't make it. I subscribed and liked , i really hope a new dupe comes out soon , thanks!
I'm having trouble getting this to work fully with books. I can always get one of the enchantments that I add (say, efficiency 4 from a list of efficiency 4, unbreaking 3, and silk touch) but almost never the other ones. Is there something special about books, am I doing something wrong, or what? I'm making sure to use the amount of bookshelves it says, too.
Hmmm... I just tried this, it worked flawlessly in singleplayer, but on my server it doesn't seem to work - is this not possible to use on spigot servers ... or am I just messing up?
This is fantastic! An incredible breakthrough, and all built into an easy tool. Do you have any other codebreaking gadgets for minecraft in development?
Can we use the player seed to get a mending book every time we go fishing? Or even a chest full of them every time we open a dungeon chest?
Yes, it will probably be possible to manipulate fishing loot, I'll look into that. Not dungeon chests, though, they depend on the world seed not the player seed.
The dummy type does not matter (I used iron pickaxes for dummies as we like to use them as throwaway picks for projects). "Changing tools" is a bit vague, but if you mean by enchanting multiple different items in succession then the answer is no - it will not affect anything.
does this work on a 1.14.4 spigot server and if so, would the others have to be ofline or can i just go into an unloaded chunk and do it or another dimension and do it
Hello, I have a quick question about the seed. What I would like to know is if I find my seed is that' my seed and it doesn't change or do I need to recalculate every time? Thank you.
Usually you can press "done" and it knows your seed already, but if you do one of the forbidden actions (including logging out and in) you will have to recalculate the seed from scratch.
@Earthcomputer Okay awesome thank you, another thing that im gonna post onto the issues tab for github is that the file cant find the native folder so its forcing me to use the slow version and the first add info never loads, because its too much for the program.
@Earthcomputer Never mind. I just read through your posts on the issues board and you said you don't support mac libraries which is what I'm on, so I'll have to ask a friend to help out. Thanks for creating this amazing tool and I hope they never get rid of it.
What's the reason Ray used this discovery for his April Fools video? It seems to dismiss that this actually works, even though it's treated as an April Fools joke. Why would you let people laugh at an invention instead of actually showing it properly.
Sander Bos, while it's not as useful to a well established technical player (villager-wise), it is rather i insanely powerful, though I doubt Mojang would actually change the enchanting code for it, it does help keep it a bit hush in a good way, though I doubt it will stay that way, but to restate myself, I doubt Mojang would change the code just because of this.
You do realize that it's a tradition to release ground breaking ideas on april fools right? Started with some people, especially in zipkrowd with panda's release of his enderdragon xp farm, then a spawner generator. Lots of content is released that day just to mess with us and the awesome ones are remembered.
If you don't mind me asking, by whom? I was replying to the original person who asked why Ray's video was released on April fools day. Rays released it on the first, and Earth on the 28th. Earth gets the credit but ray showcases the idea while making us wonder if it was real or not. Edit: Nvm you must be referring to Earth. Btw the comment you are replying to is on Earth's channel lol.
ArmedWithWings Oh, I didn't realize which video I was on... (I clicked on the notification and immidiately scrolled down) yeah, this is the original video.
I'm playing in 1.18 and using the 1.18 cracker but whenever I try to calculate player seed it says "Fail!" I don't think I'm doing anything wrong. I just open chests, open dispensers, break torches and enchant. Basically nothing wrong. I calculated the amount of levels and lapis I need. Could someone help me out?
When I click "Calculate" in the player seed tab it says "Player seed not found". Can anyone help me. (Using minecraft 1.12.2, have double checked this in single player and multiplayer, am running a 64 bit version of java.)
Harry Chacksfield most likely you did one of the listed things you shouldn't do. You must have done it in between the first dummy enchantment and the second, resulting in the two XP seeds not being consecutive.
Harry Chacksfield I tested it yesterday on Spigot and it worked. All I can say is make sure you're following all the steps exactly. Make sure you didn't miss anything out or do anything extra. Make sure you don't do anything I mention at the start of the video or in the description.
Hmm there's no beacon in my base and also i went to another place to test if location matters but it still showin player seed not found (Note: I am playing on a spigot multiplayer server and i tested this on singleplayer and it worked..)
I'm on a server with mcmmo and so far I'm not having very much luck. My most "successful" run resulted in an unknown xp seed at the end, and I'm absolutely certain I have not done any of the things I shouldn't have. Could the xp seed be one that isn't one of the 2^32? (Edit: fixed, got my first XP seed, I might've done a typo or miscount somewhere) (Edit2: successfully enchanted what I wanted, but I now have a question. If you do some of the things you shouldn't after you have the player seed, do you have to do the entire process over again?)
Is that Sancarn reincarnated?! Lol I’m joking but I’m super glad that a fellow Brit has managed to make this incredible technical discovery! P.S you sound like you are from Manchester :P Congratulations on this achievement!
According to wiki, the enchantment names (in SGA) also relies on the enchant seed. For server playing you can directly get the seed high28b from server, and for speedrunner can make a SGAtoseed?
Actually the original implementation of this method exploited this, but isn't included in this method since it's not vanilla. Unfortunately using the high 28 bits only works in single player (which is useless since you could just directly access the seed). In multiplayer, you only get 12 bits because the seed is truncated to a short over the network. If you want a mod which exploits the 12 bits, take a look at my clientcommands code link in the description, then if you cba compiling there is a releases page.
@Earthcomputer using the high 28 bits in single player in IGT speedrunning mean you can capture screen and slowly analyze the string, rather than using lots of time placing torches, breaking torches and seeing each ench
@More Girl it's not as easy as that. The text displayed on the screen doesn't give you 12 (or 28 in sp) bits of the seed. It is generated from those 12 bits. But those bits of the seed are stored client side, so with a modded client you can access the data directly. Otherwise, you have to crack the seed. This would actually be more efficient in multiplayer, since 12 + 20 is a more even split than 28 + 4.
@More Girl no in sp its generated from 28 bits. There may be something you could do which is smarter than brute force but it will be more brute forcing to get those 28 bits.
Gaming in Dark2022-03-19 12:09:08 (edited 2022-03-19 12:09:54 )
I used my 20-25 minutes here and i realised i don't have pc and i can't do this on mobile wow I can play Java because I have launcher but i can't open cracking tool
Earthcomputer aight then i did something wrong. everything went as expected, but the predictions were just wrong, am playing on a 1.13.2 spigot server. does this not work in 1.13.2? does it matter at wich level/bookcase amount you enchant the dummy items? do you have to pick the drop items back up before enchanting?
- it works in 1.13.2 - no - no I tested it on Spigot back in March and it worked, but it may have been fixed since then. Some plugins are also known to break it. Other than that it should work, ensure you're following the instructions precisely enough.
It says "Impossible" if it didn't get it after 1000 simulations of enchantments. This is a precaution against infinite loops if the combination is actually impossible. You'll have to split it into two enchants and combine in an anvil.
Sorry i know this is late but, is it compatible with 1.12.2? If you could reply that would be great. And also, if you have your player seed, do you need to find your xp seed again?? Thanks!
As said in 0:56, you can't do anything of these things because it will change the player xp seed and therefore all future enchantments are different after it.
I did everything as shown in the video and at the end after setting the enchantments, and then clicking on calculate, it shows no match for throwing the cobblestone... pls help
0 likes
Cavan Morber2021-12-10 19:43:08 (edited 2021-12-10 19:44:03 )
So...whenever I attempt to do this, I alt+tab back and forth between Minecraft and the Enchant Cracker application, and randomly Minecraft will freeze, go blank, stay frozen or completely crash, and I don't know why! It seems to be completely random, sometimes happening right when I alt+tab or sometimes when I am so unbearably close to cracking my XP seed. My mouse often freezes and then sometimes Google Chorme gets glitchy too, does anyone have any advice for me? Edit: I don't think this is because of the Enchantment Cracker application specifically, Minecraft just doesn't like me alt+tabbing to a different window for whatever reason.
Earthcomputer: So this is a way to crack enchantment table mojang dev: take the wiki, there is a new feature minecraft wiki from next day: Enchantments tables are now crackable
What does it mean when it says "Failed!" when you press calculate seed (after getting two XP seeds) I was able to make it work on the 4th try. But I just wanna know what this error means so that I'd be aware of what mistakes I did to avoid them next time.
I had one go where the XP seed stayed at 3 possible seeds. And im already at 2 bookshelves. Are there other ways to avoid this? I went from 15,14,13,12,9,6,3, 2. Like you did. The only other way i can think of is getting silk touch to take 1 bookshelf at a time.
@Carlo Espiritu you can try other combinations of torches for 5, 8 etc bookshelves, but in the rare event it never goes down to 1 seed, you just have to do a dummy enchant and start the whole process again, sorry.
wow bro you need nobel prize for this! and a question this player seed changes every time? (for example log out and come back) cant we just note this and use it again when we need it? and is there another way of finding this seed? + you got star for this project on github. im pretty noob at every thing but glad to help you
Do you think the 1.13.2 version is actually working? I tried 2 times already [And i did indeed follow the stuff with RNG like not sprinting,potions,relog etc] but everytime i try it just says "player seed not found"
Correct, you only crack the first to seeds at the beginning of the whole enchanting session. If you then go and do something else, and come back and start another session, only then do you have to find the first two seeds again
@Earthcomputer oh ok, I was hoping I can do this once and then just have my seed and join another world and start doing my stuff, but this is still amazing.
Am i the only one that this fails? I've tried this with 6 different seeds and all of them say "fail!"? Pls send help, I'm playing on 1.16.5 on a hardcore server
rip me, I cannot seem to be able to get the xp seed to be brute forced in my C++ rewrite even as fast as in your java program, even though I made mine multithreading to use all of my laptop's 4 cores... I guess either Java is just super optimised in those parts, or I'm overlooking something major. I'll have to investigate your mod's code a bit closer to make sure I haven't missed anything obvious, I guess, and after that I'll have to see how I could optimise my code better, I must've made some wrong assumptions about performance. Although I guess all of the effort I've put into this is ultimately pretty unnecessary since most people probably have a better computer than you anyway so the wait time really isn't so significant.
fdagpigj E that part of my program was written in C++ (for speed obviously). That's what all the DLLs are for. There's nothing super-special about the code I wrote. Just make sure to only match against the numbers on the right, and don't start trying to generate the enchantment clues for each seed as well since that would slow it down a lot.
I even tried it in creative after wasting tons of xp in survival :< Think its broken, followed EVERY single step of the process and still get "no possible seed" everytime
Nope, sadly I don't know which ones do. I made a spigot only server and it worked on that. But I don't know what plugins on the big servers conflict with it, I only know there is plugins that do, sorry. Anyone please post an answer here if you found out. Maybe we can find a fix for spigot If we know the plugin
tried it . I found the 2 seeds by following the video but it said it could not find my player seed. What could I be dong wrong? this is on a server if that matters
I tried without any mod on 1.16.1, without doing absolutely anything else, nor having any effects applied and making sure to enchant a dummy with one lapis before searching each xp seed. The Calculate Seed button Always fails :(
Hello i need help after the first seed i get i enchant a dummy then proceed to get the second one and then after there are 6 book left i enchant and it found the seed, but when i press calculate player seed it just says fail im on version 1.15.1 on a spigot server
Does not work for me. Version: 1.15.2 Important note: I'm on a server which is running "Craftimize", I do not know if that interferes or not. The server does not appear to be running Paper however.
The seed-finder appeared to work, but then when I followed the instructions to get Unbreaking 3, Sharpness 4, Looting 3, etc. it did not work. The first time it gave me sharpness 3, looting 2, and unbreaking 3. The other times it did not follow the expected pattern at all. (or not that I noticed). One other note is that I accidentally enchanted one of the stone swords instead of one of the diamond swords, but then I clicked done and re-calculated, instead of enchanting another sword.
I followed these steps, and I thought I made no mistakes. Is there any common mistake I may have made? - I unbound sprint and did not double-tap w to sprint - I did not eat after enchanting the first dummy item - I did not gain xp or die after enchanting the first dummy item - I did not throw any more or less items than it told me to (unless I made an error here?) - I used the correct amount of bookshelves
Any thoughts or help? Does this not work on 1.15.2? If I had to guess I'd say its the "Craftimize" plugin, can anyone look into that and see whether "Craftimize" interferes with RNG manipulation?
it didnt work for me in 1.17 i did everything ok and when i went over to the enchantments i chose and pressed calculate it showed a window which says u must enter the player seed. but i had filled up both the xp seed 1 and xp seed 2 still it didnt work
Can't detect the 2nd XP seed, whenever i only have 3 bookshelves left and i need to place a torch in a corner im screwed and cant put in 0 as it doesnt detect it
Will this process work as intended if I play Minecraft on PlayStation 4 while simultaneously using my laptop to run your program?
In other words will this work on console version? Assuming of course that the RNG methodology is identical for every version of Minecraft in existence.
Whenever I do step 2 and enter 2 bookshelves, I don't get the XP seed. 1 bookshelf doesn't give 3 enchantment slots; what do I do? I've been placing the torches just as you were doing, and looking at the enchantments and not actually enchanting anything
PaulZ try more numbers of bookshelves. If 0 and 1 aren't working, try 2, 3, 4, 5,..., 14, 15. In the very rare case that you still can't crack the seed with all these, you'll have to do a dummy enchantment and start the process again.
Earthcomputer Ah ok, one other thing: does the dummy item need to be the same type of item as the target item? If I'm enchanting books, do the dummy items need to be books as well?
emm i tried it in 1.16 i did all the step correct i got the player seed i went to enchantment calculator i pick the enchantments i wanted i hit calculate and it said no match
In the description you said that it won't work if the server's running PaperMC. Do you know about other ones like Spigot, SpongeForge, or perhaps one that will work?
@Earthcomputer I thought the random seeming movement of particles and random spawning of mobs would use random numbers... but I guess those are made with the server random number seed, not the random number seed for the player... Thanks!
Wow, this seems to work. It's a shame that Ray chose April 1st to share this really.
OLD COMMENT FOR REFERENCE: Trying to figure out if this is real. First attempt: Minecraft actually froze, "Not responding". May be unrelated to this. Second attempt: Got the desired enchantments, may be by chance. Third attempt (by pressing Done and doing another one immediately): Got the wrong enchantments, may be an error in my method, I might've left a torch when doing the dummy item.
I did that, at least I think I did. I've just tried again and all working perfectly now though! Maybe I accidentally sprinted the first time or something. As for the game freezing, I was suspecting that if this was an april fools thing then perhaps it was hooking into the game somehow, and just failed because I have a few mods. Clearly that's not the case as it's now working fine, and nothing looked suspicious when decompiling the jar.
I was testing out the 1.14.4 version with optifine and it was never able to find the enchantment seed, it just kept saying no seeds found after the second attempt. I am doing everything right, is it possible optifine changes the enchantment seed?
edit: I relaunched 1.14.4 without optifine and it still doesn't work.
edit 2: I just realized it requires a wooden sword because each material has different enchanting levels associated with them...
@Carlo Espiritu yes. Their is a new version for 1.14.4, and it seems to work. You might have some issues with blocking off the bookshelves as it seems to be very particular, so I would suggest using the exact bookshelf setup that is shown in the video.
2 quick qs: 1) (Not to be that guy in the comment section of an old technical video but) Does anyone know if this still works in the current 1.16 versions of Minecraft? 2) Would this work on a Multiplayer world where others may be eg. dying, killing mobs, gaining xp etc? Or does it only require the player doing the enchanting to not do those first actions?
Anyway, super cool concept and video, and very well done for making this!!
No positive but I tried multiple times in 1.16.4 and it didn't work :( in other versions it should work if the activity in the world doesn't involve you i.e. you drop stuff or someone kills you.
I know that it is meant to work for 1.15.2, but I have no clue how to run it. The readme says to run the batch file in the 'bin' folder, but I don't know where that is. Is it the gradlew.bat file? I'm sorry, I have no idea about any of this stuff, so if it isn't too much trouble, could you tell me how to actually run it properly?
Yo, crazy work done! But it actually didn't work on version 1.18.1 on a multiplayer server. I've tried multiple times, but it still didn't. Can you help me?
The 1.4.5 version does not work for me, but the 1.4.4 works, but only in survival. In multiplayer it does not find the right xp seeds. I tested it on my own spigot server. The 1.4.5 error says "Could not serve enough space for object heap". Some help?
@Earthcomputer I tried reinstalling the java but I am not sure if it reinstalled the 64 bit version cause I don't get the option of which one to install I think it should have installed the 64 bit version because the older version worked ok. I wil try some more. And one thing more the oleder version crashed when the first enchantment value was 5 or 6.
I am having trouble opening the batch file at the moment and I think that this is probably the problem, but im not very educated on these types of things.
it failed to calculate the player seed 2 times in a row the enchanting seed worked anyone know what i did wrong? edit: just realised that its a paper velocity server. i wasted 2 hours nice
You use the ID for the enchantment. The ID for sweeping edge is "sweeping", and the ID for luck of the sea (for example) is "luck_of_the_sea". I believe there's a list of the wiki somewhere.
So. I can NOT relog during this, but after the process when I am done and I log off, when can I do this again? Or is it just the first login possibility?
i try doing this on a server I play on and every time I get both the seeds it eventually just says 'failed', I installed the mod and typed the ccrackrng command and every time I type it, the game spits out a new player seed, not to mention there's no ingame overlay or anything? Could you do a tutorial on the mod?
I did try turning off all nearby beacons as part of my troubleshooting but I had no luck. I was still getting the "no player seed found" error. I guess it has to be a plugin, then. What sort of plugin would affect this?
when i opened enchcracker.bat file it said error occurred during initialization of VM couldn't reserve enough space for 2097152KB object heap I'm not sure if its my fault but isn't that too big?
I really need help. I tried this o 1.17.1 Multiplayer (PaperMC) (i was alone at the time), i already go away from my base, not using armor etc, then follow the instruction. i've got the seeds but when i want to calculate, it said "fail!" i tried it for 3 times and it still the same. please help
I have downloaded the program and i do not get any bat file and when i start the file that i think is the bat file i wont open can someone please help me? i have tried to run it as an administrator?
Yes - your seed is dependent on your player state. If you pay close attention to the introduction of the video, he states that LEAVING THE SERVER will change the seed and therefore invalidate the process over multiple servers. You must do the initial step of finding your first two seeds each time you begin the process in a new server.
Doesn't work on Forge 1.12.2 server. The enchantments are wrong. Following the process from start to finish you get "Player seed not found", but if you take the 2nd seed and make it the 1st seed and then do the process of getting the 2nd seed again then you get the player seed. However, in doing that even though the programs states that after throwing out 52 stacks and 48 items to get diamond sword with smite 5, u3, l3 you get nothing of the kind. Instead I got Sharp 4, L3, U3, KB 2 (and yes I excluded the knockback enchantments). I have attempted SEVERAL times to get the player seed following the instructions to the "T" and get no player seed unless I do what I described above.
Okay, you are not following the instructions precisely enough. For a start you forgot to do the initial dummy enchant, and I'm gonna guess if you went for 52 stacks then you probably miscounted (it would probably have been faster to split the enchant list in half and anvil them together)
As I stated I did follow it to a "T" to start with and got "Player seed not found". The process I did was: dummy, then did the torch/numbers, got 1st seed, reset, torch/numbers, got second seed, calculate "Player seed not found" (during the whole process I did nothing but what was instructed). And when that didn't work, I used the 2nd seed as the 1st and redid the 2nd seed process to get a new 2nd seed. Then it would give me the player seed. Now unless placing the dummy enchanted items into a chest to get the desired item to be enchanted out causes an issue then I am uncertain what I could have done that would cause it to not give me that player seed as described in the instructions.
32bit java cant reserve space above 1,5GB of ram. Oracle often gives you 32bit Java when using default download Button. Download 64bit from "offline" section and you will be fine.
Walmart are you following the method precisely? Every detail matters. Also, you can't use the give command during this process. Just modified the video description to say that.
I think so. I was initially trying on a spigot server and couldn't get it to work. When I tried in singleplayer it worked. So I'm guessing this doesn't work on spigot servers? or idk.
I tried it once again on spigot and it worked. I'm sorry for wasting your time because it must've just been random mistakes I made, such as going into creative quickly to grab items, and I think I must've accidentally sprinted a few times. Honestly, I can't thank you enough for making this and for taking the time to reply and try to help me out. You're honestly the best dude.
The 1.13 version will work for items which have had no changes in terms of enchantments. Note this therefore wont work for books since new enchantments have been added to them. It also wont work for armour at all since there was a change to how the protection enchantments are applied.
well for some reason it isn't working in a server that has NCP and paper 1.12.2, i've tried and it cant calculate the seed, am I doing something wrong?
@Earthcomputer can you pick up and throw items like for example it says to throw 6 stacks of stone, i only have 3 stacks and i throw it twice in a row, will it work?
@Myles Hallett there are other things which can cause the same problem too. After double-checking the list of banned actions, try using the mod instead https://github.com/Earthcomputer/clientcommands/releases which gives you more detailed information about what went wrong. You have to first enable it by running the command `/ctemprule set enchantingPrediction true`, then there is a built-in enchantment cracker which works the same way as this one. Also run `/ctemprule set playerRNGMaintenance false` for more error-catching. The mod requires the Fabric mod loader. Install fabric from https://fabricmc.net/use , you also need Fabric API (install it like any other Fabric mod): https://minecraft.curseforge.com/projects/fabric . Let me know how it goes.
Release 1.1.4 on vanilla Minecraft 1.12.2 server is not working whatsoever. Have attempted three times, each time found a player seed, but none of the seed gave the correct enchantment. My attempt at Eff IV / Unb III / Silk pick rolled Fortune II instead of Silk, my attempt at Eff IV / Unb III / Silk shovel resulted in Fortune III / Unb III, and my book attempt for Eff IV gave Feather Falling IV.
I even unbound my forward move and sprint keys to and only moved using A/S/D to prevent mistakes. The only things I did throughout the process were breaking and removing torches and inserting/removing items from chests.
Does this work with Bukkit? I tried and it didn't work. It kept saying "Fail!". I tried the client commands mod and it still didn't work. It said the server is modded.
@Oak I must be doing something wrong because i tried to do it on a new map in 1.15.2 without mods, no resource packs, both using torches and using a silk touch axe to remove bookshelves, and the same issue. It HAS to work on this version because there's another youtuber that i have seen him using this on 1.15.2 and it worked for him.
Compiled the source code for mc version 1.14 and ran it on my vanilla realm. Seems like it doesn't give the correct enchants afterwards. Still working on updating for 1.14 or am I the dummy?
@Earthcomputer Aight so after reading it, I found my mistake. So I found the batch file and all that, but now when I use the enchcracker batch file, it opens for half a second with an error message and then closes its self...
You need to install java. If I get it right, the official launcher is “kinda” having its own java so you can play minecraft without java installed. But other programs still believe your computer haven’t installed it.
Do i habe to sign up on the plattform to download this? If not, then i still need help because im too stupid to find out how to downliad the codebreaker.
Hello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
But i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
Hello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
But i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
Hello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
But i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
Hello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
But i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
Hello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
But i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
I tried running the batch file but was greeted with
"Error occurred during initialization of VM
Could not reserve enough space for 2097152KB object heap
Failed to launch enchcracker!
1. Ensure you have installed Java correctly and that Java is in your PATH.
2. 64-bit Java is recommended for enchcracker.
3. 2GB of RAM is a minimum requirement. enchcracker will fail to start if you don't have more than 2GB of RAM to spare.
4. If you still think this is an error, please report it to https://github.com/Earthcomputer/EnchantmentCracker/issues
Press any key to continue . . ."
I have no idea what to do to resolve this
I have 16GB of ram so I don't know how to allocate more to this thing.
Sorry About doubling the comment! :D It wasnt showing the first and I angrily wrote it again :/ the second one is better understandable so just ignore the first one :)
Why does it show me an error when I try opening " enchcracker.bat " ?
The error says: " Error: Could not find or load main class enchcracker.EnchCrackerWindow
Failed to launch enchcracker! "
Okko Heiniö Did you tried troubleshooting? Everytime minecraft crashes, it makes a log file, if you open that text file at the top there is error code. You can search that code on the internet to aid your problem
Yalkın ÇIRAK well I repaired it with the minecraft installer, but it didn't work. Also I can still sometimes load a world in it but it is very unstable. I can open the client but it freezes when I actually start playing. Tried changing the directory, the update, the profile (my snapshot profile won't even open) I'm not sure about the java update but I have alvays played minecraft with that version.
Oh I miss playing with java. There is so many important features to move to the bedrock version. The Json nbt you put in commands is so weird it says I'm missing a bracket when I'm not, and the whole scoreboard command is missing.
Erm Hey EarthComputer... So I Tried the method on 1.18.1... Whenever i try to get player seed after getting 2 xp seeds, it always fails... I tried multiple times but still it fails
I would recommend using the mod, not the tool since it does most of what you need to do automatically and says if you accidentally broke the rng manipulation
uhhh I know this is a little late (ok, very late) but does this work for 1.17.1? and also how do I open the enchcracker window, I can't find it in the download file.
@Pedro270707 Wait I see what I did wrong ok I found it I opened the Windows Batch file in the bin folder now it has command prompt open do I wait or...
@Pedro270707 Wait sorry one last thing, you said it works on 1.17 but there is no option for 1.17 on the enchant cracker thing, when im inputting the enchantments i want and don't want. So are you sure? and if so, do I just select 1.16?
@PZ11 i have not tried yet but i think you just have to use the newest version and it will work for 1.17 ps also tell me if you try and tell me if it works
I've tried it a few times on bedrock, not sure if it's because it doesn't have support for 1.18 (maybe it does on Java), or because Java has enchantments not included in bedrock like sweeping edge which I would assume would affect the seeds/what's possible. Nevertheless It has yet to work for me on Bedrock 1.18.1
this is to complicated, is there easier way? or minecraft hacked client mod that does that automaticly? mod will be the best (or hack mod becauze mod that will give you op enchants in second will be little like a hack), it will be game breaking on anarchy! :)
@Earthcomputer thank you so much for the quick reply! i saw on the 1.13 video that you could get unbreaking with this as well? how do you do that and does it work on 1.12.2
@Parmeet Gill It's possible, it depends on the plugins. It doesn't work on paper as I said. I'd double check the list of banned actions, including those in the video description, to make sure you're not doing any of them
fdagpigj E mostly because most of the code was either generated by a Gui tool or copy-pasted from either the reference implementation or my open-source stronghold finder (for the enchantments themselves). Just thought the code would be too messy to open-source :)
It works in the most current version. You did something wrong either: by accidentally manipulating your seed, entering the incorrect numbers, or doing a step incorrectly/out of order.
The tool shouldn't fully work before 1.11.1, when sweeping edge was added. The concept however should work back to 1.8, if someone were to write a tool for that version.
do i have to start with 15 book shelves only not more than that because i am a larger enchantment roon with about 120 bookshelves which are 3 blocks high
Unfortunately the message "player seed not found" could be caused by so many things that I can't really tell you what's going on other than to follow the instructions more closely.
Shift-right-click inside the enchcracker folder, select "Open Command Window Here" or "Open PowerShell Window Here". Then type "java -jar enchcracker.jar" and hit enter. That way we should get an error message so I know better what's going on.
I cannot install the cracker because when i run the file command prompt said Error: Could not find or load main class enchcracker.EnchCrackerWindow
Failed to launch enchcracker!
1. Ensure you have installed Java correctly and that Java is in your PATH.
2. 64-bit Java is REQUIRED for enchcracker. This catches a lot of people out. To check your Java version, run "java -version".
3. 2GB of RAM is a minimum requirement. enchcracker will fail to start if you don't have more than 2GB of RAM to spare.
4. If you still think this is an error, please report it to https://github.com/Earthcomputer/EnchantmentCracker/issues
Press any key to continue . . .
Terminate batch job (Y/N)?
@Earthcomputer when i connect two xp seed to get player seed it said failed. i tried on 1.14.4 and on 1.14.4 works with no problems. Maybe i do something wrong, gonna try again and if it say failed again i will comment that
sorry for being a pain in the arse, trying to do this trick on an anarchy server now. got all the items prepared but the problem is when i click on the executable jar file it does nothing, doesnt even start the program, do i need any additional software for it to work?
You cannot determine the seed with only 2 of the 3 numbers in the enchanting table. The only way it will work is if the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd enchantment numbers are provided.
Kubrad Lithjer if you mean 32-bit Windows, then unfortunately not sorry. You will either need to use a 64-bit machine or wait till I get round to making a Java implementation of the XP seed finding.
Done, can't believe I missed it :p On holiday so I can't release the new version at the moment, in the mean time iron_helmet should be equivalent to turtle_helmet
@FilliamPL Proof? I remember this working before but now it doesn't seem to anymore. Recent comments show exactly what I mean -- final step ends with 'no match' or 'fail' despite following the instructions to a T.
@Kevin Tyrrell “Proof?” I wouldn’t say “Yes” if I hadn’t done it on 1.16 more than three dozen times. It works, I’d think you’re doing something wrong. Additionally, if you’re doing everything correctly, then it is a matter of something else that you probably didn’t think of.
Are you ready? Depending on your seed, the algorithm cannot find a way to enchant an item with the desired enchantments. It is seed dependent. If you’re lucky, your seed is able to be manipulated (dropping items one at a time) in a way to achieve the enchantments. If you have a bad seed, then you’ll get a no match.
Proof?: I’ve done this successfully more times than you
Im having trouble running the program on mac, its so annoying. Cant find library in java so runs it with slower jav that always freezes on fist input. Im fucking pissed off.
Earthcomputer changed it and says cannot execute binary file in the terminal, when i load java it says failed to load native enchcracker library. Thank you for trying to help i got the sword I wanted already so wont be using the program. Thanks again!
Earthcomputer Appreciate your work :) Did you go through the source code to figure out the way to hack an enchantment table?If yes I would like to know how did you get the source code?
Java versions are numbered 1.0 to 1.8 and then the latest is Java 9. Maybe you mean Java 1.8_u131? The program was compiled for Java 1.8 and all 1.8 and 9 versions should work.
That error message was not created by my program. It was created by Java itself when it tried to load classes compiled by a newer version. That what happens when you use a very outdated Java version, things start not working.
The difference is I didn't demand anything of you, and I'm just feeding him a little of his own medicine. Sorry, I'm just not as patient with people that make demands of others.
Dr_lolig what's your OS? If you're on Windows, go to the enchcracker folder, Shift-right-click inside it, press "Open Command Window Here" or "Open PowerShell Window Here", then type `java -jar enchcracker.jar`. This will give us an error message so I know what's going on.
Earthcomputer the error says i have java 32 bit and it needs java 64 bit. I have java 64 bit but I delete and install it again maybe it will work after that
Why would anyone spend 10 minutes doing this unless they're doing it for the amazement obtained from the glitch. Insane luck with enchants are possible and enchantment books from villagers kind of makes this redundant and asinine. You may also say people would do this so early in the game which is when they couldn't possibly have these enchantment books, but what would also be the point of that? If you were going to cheat to begin with, why didn't you just switch to Creative and back to Survival? At this point I'm just criticizing the users of this game-breaker.
first, you are not changing the game files or enabling cheats. this is like using a seed finder tool and then using a stronghold finder tool. second, there are servers out there where this could be useful, like anarchy servers or just normal survival servers.
Sorry about the loss of frames at the start of the video!
347 likesReplies (62)
Earthcomputer are you deleting comments?
5 likesCerugon no, I haven't deleted any comments
12 likesEarthcomputer weird... there was one gone...
5 likesYou mentioned you were going to put a download link?
4 likesChristopher Smith the download link is fixed now, it's in the description
10 likesbedrock version pls
1 likeJannes Veuger something like this would be much harder to come up with for the Bedrock edition, mostly because no-one has made a good enough C++ decompiler yet.
5 likesIs there a reason why you have so many stone in your inventory? Why not just pick up the items and re-throw them?
1 likeChristopher Smith idk tbh. I guess it comes from when I was doing all this with a client side mod that would throw the items out so quickly that it would have already thrown out 10 stacks before you're able to pick anything up again. But yeah, I guess that many items aren't really necessary for this method.
5 likesThis didn't work for me on a server (Spigot). I tried the process several times, but keep getting "Player seed not found" on the second step. Perhaps it's because they use a different random number generator than vanilla?
0 likesChristopher Smith just done it on the latest version of Spigot. Which items are you enchanting? What version of Spigot are you on?
1 likeI didn't manage to get to the enchanting step (got stuck on step 2...couldn't find the seed), but for dummy items I was using shovels. Does the item type affect the outcome? I'm not sure of the Spigot version, I don't control the server.
0 likesChristopher Smith type /version to get the version
1 likeAh! CraftBukkit version git-Spigot-4bd94dc-f4ca180. MC: 1.12.2. API: 1.12.2-R0.1-SNAPSHOT. 15 versions behind.
0 likesSame issue here... Playing on a pure Vanilla server 1.12.2 or even the latest BETA (no matter if SSP or SMP) makes no problem. As soon as I enter my Bukkit based community server, it doesn't work.
0 likesI can get the XP seeds, but calculation of the Player seed fails.
"This server is running CraftBukkit version git-Bukkit-94b0980 (MC: 1.12.2) (Implementing API version 1.12.2-R0.1-SNAPSHOT)"
Maybe this helps? ;)
What plugins do these servers have?
1 likeGood question. I'm just a user, not an admin of it. All I know is, that it's hosted via Cubedhost. maybe there's a "/plugins" command...
0 likes.....
yup! "Plugins (7): CoreProtect, Waypoints, AcceptRules, Simple-AutoSave, WorldEdit, WorldGuard, GriefPrevention"
I've got:
0 likesPlugin (9): CoreProtect, PlugMan, LuckPerms, Announcer, DiscordMC, WorldEdit, BanManager, Multiverse-Core, XStaffChat
Hey no worries mate, I had much the same issues getting OBS to cooperate with my system as well when using Game Capture and fullscreen. Turns out Nvidia overlay was fighting for control over it and disabling that fixed it up just fine.
0 likesEarthcomper I cant get it to work
0 likesIt does not remove any seed it just does nothing when i tab add info pls help me
0 likesJohn9boy Juhl make sure your Java is 64-bit
1 likeEarthcomputer jave 64 bit???
0 likesJohn9boy Juhl yes. If you only have 32-bit Java the add info button won't work.
1 likeEarthcomputer thank you
0 likesso, any news on the bukkit/spigot incompatibility? o.O
0 likesMaybe you should put a "copy to XP seed 1" and "copy to XP seed 2" button on XP Seed tab :P
2 likesStart and all the rest of the video...
0 likesIs there a list of inputs? The enchantments are pretty hard to figure out...
0 likesMac OS PLS!
0 likesI have a problem because my program won't even start up afer clicking enchcracker.bat. Can u help me ?
0 likesHope you don't mind me asking but does it affect anything if another person on a multiplayer server does any of the things you shouldn't do, and once you've gotten your player seed does that change per world, and does the player seed differ for each person on a server? Sorry for asking so many questions,but i hope you get back to me, thank you for your help.
1 likeIs it there a 32bit version too?
0 likesHey man, so I got the enchantment seeds right? when I tried calculating the player seed it said it couldn't calculate it.. Did I do something wrong?? I ran the enchcracker.bat file and that's all I did.. Did I forget to do something??
0 likesAlso, what is the "Force Player seed"?? I didn't fill that out yet cuz I thought that's were the player seed would be calculated..
0 likesDoes the bedrock version use the same java rng? (can i use this for bedrock version enchanting?)
0 likesJust found my question asked down in the comments. Doesn't work on bedrock. I figured as much. :D I will definitely test this out on java though!
0 likesperfect it functions perfect just perfect!!!1
1 likeDoes it also break if any other people on the server do the things that break the process?
1 likeIs 5is compatible with ps4 edition? Or just java?
0 likesIs there a way to download it on Mac
1 like@Theory Translator same as the other operating systems, go to the releases page and download the jar
1 like@Christopher Smith I'm having the same problem, failing to find player seed (1.15.2 I think spigot, will edit later when certain).
0 likesSo you cant pick up any items but you can pick up torches?
0 likes@max_ishere you can pick up items, you just can't drop them
1 likewhen I start the .bat file, it says 'could not reserve 2097152KB object heap'. How can I fix this?
0 likesWould this also work for villagers that sell enchanted tools or armour?
0 likes@Earthcomputer Are you sure it works (the mac version)? Ive tried opening the jar and looking at it but there seems to be nothing there i can use to open it, unless its the wrong jar in which case where is the mac download? P.S. i don't know much about programing so i might be being super dumb right now...
0 likes@Earthcomputer 2 quick qs:
2 likes1) (Not to be that guy in the comment section of an old technical video but) Does anyone know if this still works in the current 1.16 versions of Minecraft?
2) Would this work on a Multiplayer world where others may be eg. dying, killing mobs, gaining xp etc? Or does it only require the player doing the enchanting to not do those first actions?
Anyway, super cool concept and video, and very well done for making this!!
it says the app is not safe
0 likesWhere is the app or that you use I did not find it and can I do it at 2021?
1 likeDude i downloaded the latest version 1.5.1 it says that it has support for 1.17.1 but inside the tool in the versions section it only goes till 1.16.5
0 likes@GDR Marmokaite its in the description u need to download the zip file then extract
0 likesDoes this work on bedrock @Earthcomputer
0 likesit dosn't work for me it says fail every time.
0 likesi play singleplayer 1.17.1 optifine
Does it still work in 1.17?
0 likesis it possible to make a bedrock version?
0 likesBruh why cant i open this? It said:unable to access jarfile
0 likesHow to download the cracker?
0 likes@Earthcomputer are you ever going to make a bedrock version?
0 likesthe second arrival of christ
0 likesThanks and I wanted to know, it works in all versions and it works in bedrock if I have a PC to see the Java script
Just to ask, how to calculate the number of items to get a perfect item?
0 likesRaysWorks made a video about this on april fools. I thought it was fake but then he mentioned that you had an explanation. This is really impressive, well done! It's absolutely ground-cracking (pun intended).
252 likesReplies (4)
ICrapple Lol it's not fake?
10 likesPosting an unbelievable video that is actually real on april fools is like the worst thing to do
the technical minecraft players love to upload creations on april fools, to make a lot of players think the stuff is fake. Like the shulker shuker or edd's bedrock in survival (both are working creations)
11 likes@Okko Heiniö it is fake
0 likesIt ist NOT fake!
0 likesMojang Dev: "You know someone can crack this enchant system, maybe we should work on it some more."
231 likesManagment: "That's crazy talk! Who does that? No one would ever put that much work into cracking the seed. Ship it."
Replies (10)
couldn't they just update the seed every time you open the enchantment table and that would fix it?
3 likes@John Doe This is how it basically was before 1.8. Were the seed was random each time you put something into the enchanting table. But you always had to put it in and out again to get a specific level, which was really annoying.
1 likeno one at mojang ever made the game with the intent to make it inaccessible to the more technically inclined audience, though it would not be out of the realm of possibility for microsoft to do something counter to that logic ;P
2 likes@FilliamPL Not true at all. The original version of endermen were specifically built to break mob grinders. That is why they pull up blocks (there used to be no limit to what blocks they'd steal), and why they teleport away from water (all farms back then used water). It was only after the players were in a fury over endermen destroying all builds (not just grinders), that Mojang changed them to their current incarnation. There have been lots of little changes over the years that were designed to break grinders, and only more recently have they taken a more lax attitude to them.
1 like@Livid Imp Talking about the ability to decompile game code boss, not enderman xD
0 likes@FilliamPL Well of course they can't stop that. Every attempt ends in failure.
0 likes@Livid Imp And because of that continuous failure mojang definitely embraces the technically inclined playerbase to tinker with aspects of the game
0 likesNot how it works bro, it's fundamental to the function of Java. RNG manipulation relies on the fact that in Javascript RNG is generated from a set hexidecimal number, which is a seed, using a standard equation. Eventually numbers repeat bc Java is essentially a virtual machine running on your system running a complier that takes the C code your computer uses and compiles it into JS. This virtual machine is 32-bit, it cannot exceed integers greater than that when dealing with real numbers. Therefore the size of the hexidecimal numbers it can calculate is inherently limited. Basically, try running Windows 10 on a Pentium MMX. That's what you're asking of Java
0 likes@Jack Eldridge I feel like you got some things wrong with this technical explanation.
0 likesFirst of all, you're switching between Java and JavaScript, despite the languages being completely different.
Secondly, the JVM converts bytecode to machine language/processor instructions. Neither C nor Javascript are involved in that process whatsoever.
Third, Java comes in 32 or 64 bit varieties, and even then I'm sure it has some form of large integer type.
Finally, the analogy with "the random function only takes 32 bit seeds" to "it's like running windows 10 on a 20 year old processor" doesn't make much sense.
@cachemist Cheers man I can't code for shit, you definitely clarified a lot of things about my very simple understanding, but I'm certain of one thing and that's that my 32-bit thing is correct LOLL. MC only used 32-bit Java until 1.17 released, and most of its integer functions are limited by that still. That's why the Pentium comparison came in, it's integer limited in the same way 32-bit Java is, although in terms of not being able to run 64 bit instructions as opposed to not understanding 64 bit instructions u feel?
0 likesOh wow. How long did it take you to do this? This is insanely cool. Especially how you even explained how everything works in the end. Only figuring this out could take a long time, but then actually cracking it, thats insane
59 likesReplies (1)
Oreo Lamp it took about a month to work from an observation in the code to the method you see in the video. The last 5 minutes took a few days to edit :)
27 likesso "no dummy" is the programs way of telling you that you are the dummy, because you would have gotten the enchant if you just went for it, instead of spending hours punching in numbers into the tool xD
181 likesGreat video.
Replies (1)
liquidminds well, technically in the first two stages you do 2 dummy enchantments. But I guess I shouldn't be ruining a good joke :p
49 likesSo lemme write it down for you really quick:
427 likesStep 1. Get all the items as shown in the video.
Step 2. Take a dummy item and enchant it. After that put it in the bin.
Step 3. Take another dummy and use the info as shown in the video (5:52)
Step 4. When you got the seed from the step 3. dummy enchant it and throw it away.
Step 5. Repeat step 3. with another dummy except this time DON'T enchant it at the end.
Step 6. Than you throw the necessary amount of items on the ground (18:45)
Step 7. Once you've done that you enchant the dummy from step 5.
Step 8. And now enchant the real item (for example diamond sword)
Step 9. (if you have more items): Press done on the cracker and calculate again.
Step 10. Now throw out the amount of item which you get in the cracker.
Step 11. Enchant a dummy item.
Step 12. Enchant the real item.
For another item repeat the process from step 9. to step 12.! And also it works from 1.11.1 - 1.12.2.
Hope this helps!
Section 1. Paragraph 1. : What to type in the enchant text box in the manipulate section of the EnchCracker?/ When I type an enchant in the text box the outline turns red and nothing happens! if you have encountered any of the two problems keep reading ;)
Section 1. Paragraph 2. - Possibilities
There's 3 possibilities:
1. You typed the enchantment ID wrong or you don't know what to write, if so Section 1. Paragraph 4. is your problem solver, if not try possibility 2.
2. Your item is a treasure enchant which basically means getting it via an EC isn't an option, more on that in the Section 1. Paragraph 3.
3. Your item is an exception, if you thing that's the case and you've tried both of the options above read Section 2.
Section 1. Paragraph 3. - Treasure enchants
Treasure enchants. As the name suggests they are only obtainable via strongholds, spawners, end cities etc. with treasure (chests with loot). These enchants are: Mending, Thorns, Curse of Binding, Curse of Vanishing, Frost Walker. If your enchant is listed here you got your answer if not there are exceptions listed in Section 2. that also includes Thorns in case you are still encountering the problem from Section 1. Paragraph 1.*)
Section 1. Paragraph 4. - Enchantment ID List
(if your enchant had an "*In exception list*" tag you might want to read Section 2. Paragraph 1. )
Protection protection
Fire Protection fire_protection
Feather Falling feather_falling
Blast Protection blast_protection
Projectile Protection projectile_protection
Respiration respiration
Aqua Affinity aqua_affinity
Depth Strider depth_strider
Sharpness sharpness In exception list
Smite smite In exception list
Bane of Arthropods bane_of_arthropods In exception list
Knockback knockback
Fire Aspect fire_aspect
Looting looting
Sweeping Edge sweeping
Efficiency efficiency In exception list
Silk Touch silk_touch
Unbreaking unbreaking In exception list
Fortune fortune
Power power
Punch punch
Flame flame
Infinity infinity
Luck of the Sea luck_of_the_sea
Lure lure
Section 2. Paragraph 1. - Exceptions
And the ones listed below are exceptions (via EC = via Enchanting table)
1. Bane of Arthropods (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on Axes, otherwise easily obtainable for Swords via EC)
2. Unbreaking (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on Elytra, Hoes, Shields, Flint and Steel, Carrot on a Stick, otherwise easily obtainable for all other tools via EC)
3. Sharpness (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on Axes, otherwise easily obtainable for Swords via EC)
4. Smite (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on Axes, otherwise easily obtainable for Swords via EC)
5. Efficiency (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on Shears, otherwise easily obtainable for Pickaxes, Shovels, Axes via EC)
6. Thorns (needs to be done thru an Anvil in order to get it on all pieces of armor except for the Chestplate)
Section 2. Paragraph 1. - Explains Section 2. Paragraph 1.
Some enchants of the enchants from above can be done just by enchanting a book in the EC and than proceed to the Anvil (for example: Unbreaking on Elytra) others which arent listed on the long list below and are in the treasure enchant section need to be found in nature and than combined via Anvil (for example: Mending on Elytra)
Thanks for reading!
Replies (16)
Great list! One slight correction, it doesn't matter how many torches you have placed when you enchant the dummy item.
42 likesNot worth reading for me.
3 likesty for all the likes
11 likesTq dude
2 likesWoah
1 likeDoes it work rn?
1 likeyes
1 likeholy frick
1 like@Razia Sultana it doesnt work for me on 1.17.1
0 likesIt works as of 1.18, just tried it
4 likes@Koda yesssss
1 like@Koda yea bwoiiiiiiiii
0 likesThx
0 likesHOLY SHIT A+ FOR YOUR ESSAY
0 likesUnfortunately doesn't work on 1.18.2
0 likesit didnt work in multiplayer :(
0 likesWhat a discovery! Did you discover this on your own? If so than you're really going places and I can't wait to see what other Mojang-angrifing discovery you end up with mastering next.
5 likesThis video is so well detailed and made, I appreciate it so much. I left a sub and like, but you deserve so much more!
0 likesI hope this person is doing well, thanks for helping alot of us :) i currently was suffering from constantly dying and needed some enchantments
2 likesThanks a lot for making the video! I can not iamgine how much work you have done in order to dive in to the code of the RNG and get the current result with a clear and easy to use.jar file. I think that month must be tough. It is really a pity that a find this video too late and without ray's ideo I can not even got to know this.
43 likesWhy youtube just not recommend sth like this to me every day. Dam.
Ok, back to the concept. Thanks again for your work to try some incredible cool stuff like controll the enchantment. A lot of people want to do some with the random part of minecraft but i think you go maybe the a lot of sters further than them. I am thinking about this can be a useful stuff for the UHC like ETA said ot even can be a useful stuff for changing the whole boring and though starting session of minecraft.
As we all know the beginner 's farm is slime farm, iron farm and a simple wither skeleton farm. In which two of the three will need a good looting 3 sword which can not be easily get before. But know we can just do it by using your code! Oh man, I really want every one to know it, especially me! I currently started a new world maybe three weeks ago and ban the fishing for myself which I think is the most cheaty thing in minecraft. So it takes me almost one week to have the breeder and combine two looting 2 book. The easy process can chage it into five min job! Thanks again and keep it up!
Ok, enough prase, it is the question time. I have watched the whole video and the only problem is a bit of laggy and I think it can be easily solve the next time so do not worry. I want to make sur that if we can do the same thing to the shovel and diamond pickaxe with the program? Then we can have a brand new way of strating the minecraf in the first few days.
Also I am thinking about other "random" stuff in the minecraft, like the drop from the mobs, the result of the fishing and also maybe the radomness of the tnt and ender pearls. I know that not all of them belongs to the same concept also we can fix tht with the carpet mod or some cool contraption like Xcom do to the ender pearl. But before this video we can do nothing to the echantment and the mob drops. You may have already get my point. Yes the mob drop. How did it caculate? I will apperciate if you can take a look to them and also maybe in the future we can make some kind of random factors then kill the wither skelton and get a skull for sure! That may not make sense. But think about the overpowered buggy helmet of the rider of the Skeleton trap like what ray should before. That is defenitely worth to do it to reduce the AFK time.
At last thanks again for the great work! if you can read the long comment,I will appericiate a lot since I do not know how to contact you with some other way (Sorry for that).
Replies (4)
段学达 thanks for your comment! Yes this works on any enchantable item.
8 likesAs for mob drops, unfortunately these are calculated by different RNGs so you wouldn't be able to use the same technique. That doesn't mean it's impossible though, and if I find a way I'll make a video for sure.
段学达 Me too
2 likesI have been playing Minecraft since before the wither skeleton has been added, and I still haven't made a farm for it.. is it really that easy?
0 likesChris Walker I recommend you to check genembon ‘s video about the wither skeleton farm or some simple one designed by tango tek.
0 likesThat is incredibly cool! I could imagine this being very useful for UHC
119 likesReplies (8)
I remember LapisDemon wanted to use something similiar in a Hermitcraft UHC...
10 likesuhc is new versions wow awesome!
1 like@Vunga this works for 1.8 - 1.16.5, might even work on 1.17 but theres no dropdown for 1.17 yet so we'll have to see
1 like@snJtiu Y. worked in sp 1.17.1 did not try multi tho
0 likesDon't think you could get everything
0 likes@snJtiu Y. it works in 1.17.1 despite there not being any drop down option (just select 1.16.5), just tested it
0 likesHow would you get that much stone in uhc...
0 likes@Stealthfang 270 you don’t need stone specifically it’s any item, you don’t need that many just an amount he gave himself (at most at had to throw out 3 stacks, usually under 1), and you get a lot of blocks in UHC regardless
0 likesThat's incredibly cool! Glad I found this, thanks for your research! Great video!
3 likesJust an update this still WORKS in 1.14.4, I am on a public server and it works perfectly. Just make sure you are careful about knowing how many book shelves you have, it can get confusing some times
1 likeThis is pretty interesting. Congrats on finding this out.Is the player seed static? If so does that mean that if you found your player seed once you only need to get the Xp seed once in combination with the current XP seed to start of the process or is this just wishful thinking.When skimming trough the comments some plugins mess with the process, if a plugin resets the xp seed every X minutes speed will be a major factor and skipping one of the 2 xp seeds will make it more usable on servers. Do you have any more information on this?
0 likesthis is so cool! Do you think you could modify it so that it works with villagers and other RNG things in the game?
0 likesThis is absolutely insane, what a mad lad. Thank you so much!
1 likeJust recently lost my wonderful pickaxe, and am going to try this, thanks for the help.
2 likesThat's amazing ! You deserve soooo much more subscribers. I look forward to your new videos ! I hope mojang doesn't fixe that to ^^'
0 likesYou are an absolute legend mate. This is freaking awesome!
1 likeJust by accident I lost my sword and have a good opportunity to try out the method by myself and works quite nice as it should.
17 likesThanks!!
And get a lot of more questions and advices which I want to talk with you.
1. Will the weather affect the enchantment? I was a luck boy then when I finished all the enchantment it just started to be a thunderstorm. So I have no chance to test it by myself. Since the thunder is kind of randomly summon an entity (as well as the skeleton trap) and cause fire. Also the fire has random tick to spread and extinguish. So I think they need the RNG to work with. So I am thinking about will that has some effect with the enchantment. I think rain itself is kind of fine but maybe some lightupdate also the clock to stop the rain etc. And maybe we will have the foggy or some other weather in the future. So maybe we need to better make sure that we do all the enchantment in a great sunny day?
2. In my personal opnion, there are still some place we can do to improve the .jar file like we can copy and paste the exp seed to the next step. Also I am not sure is it that intended that we can not type in the" fire aspect" in any kind of captiality.
3. Any kind of mob spawning or entity processing will break the RNG or it is just according to all the player motions? Since the RNG is according to the player seed maybe not that problem. But may be other thing like "taking damage" or "riding a horse" and some kind of other stuff related to the mob should be mentioned to not to do. (Maybe I just think too much. lol)
Again, Thanks for all your amazing work. Also if it is possible then maybe you can publish some progress update in the next concept.
Replies (10)
Hi,
9 likes1 and 3 are easiest to answer, so let's start with them. The player RNG used for this is separate from the world RNG used for weather and mob spawning, and other RNGs used for other players and mob AI. So unless those things decide to come and attack you you should be fine.
2. In the latest version of the enchantment cracker (1.1.3 currently) you can copy and paste the XP seed from the first tab.
If you have any more suggestions, make sure to put them on the issue tracker on the GitHub page, as I get to see them all rather than just what YouTube decides to show me.
Have a nice day!
@Earthcomputer
0 likesI have questions about RGN too:
1-Does multiplayer break/affects your RNG of the enchanting?
2-(Oh i Just realized you already answered this one to others)
If another player does one of the things you shouldn't do during the process does it affect your RNG?3-If mobs die but not because of the player killing them do they affect the RNG?
4-Is flying sonething to not do? (Cuz on a server i have VIP)
5-Is dropping non stackable items like dropping 64 items?
6-Does fortune act like unbreaking?
7-Am i annoying you? (if yes, Im Sorry i didn't wanted to)
Also thanks a lot, you are Genius.
@GregFRDT
1 like1) No
3) No
4) No, but be careful not to fall from a height of 3 blocks or more, that will cause landing particles that break it
5) No
6) No
7) Certainly not :P
@Earthcomputer
0 likesParticles break it?
I would never expect that
Only sometimes
1 like@Earthcomputer
0 likesI tried the method by myself in a server 1.12 and the tool didn't found any xp seed and i don't understand why, mabye it's the server?
@GregFRDT I believe this is a 1.13+ method only
0 likesNot sure about that
@Jovan04 Nope, it depends by the file you download
0 likes@GregFRDT does the server have any plugins? Some plugins break it
0 likes@Jovan04 OFC what server doesn't have plugins
0 likesI am pretty sure that the code would make it impossible but can you find a seed that will create double enc? If so then it would be cool to spend a significant amount of time enchanting dummy items to get there.
0 likesI had the "No Player Seed Found" issue, but i tried it again another 3 times and eventually got it. You have to be triple sure you are doing it right. Thanks heaps for this!
0 likesHey, this is really cool and a very useful tool, I must say! Good job on cracking the code! But I do have one question: I can't seem to type "silk touch" into your programm. Am I writing it wrong?
1 likeReplies (2)
Tilnit you need to type "silk_touch 1". The format is <enchantment_id> <level>
4 likesGotcha! Thanks for the fast reply! Appriciate it a lot :)
0 likesJust tested this on 1.16 Pre7. Works completely fine! Amazing!
1 likeReplies (1)
doesnt work in 1.16.1 yet right or am i doing it wrong...
0 likesAmazing! Great work!
1 likeI wonder where can I get the decompiled and deobfuscated Minecraft code?
Replies (1)
It's public, you should just have to look around
0 likesThanks for the informative explanation, I feal like I finally semi understand the process now.
0 likesWow! Very nice! thank you very much. Ive been playing with this all week. Works great. Im guessing you cant order thorns on your armor because it is too rare aka "impossible"? I can get it on books all day long but the program wont allow it on armor. would it be possible to alter the program slightly to clear the slot1/2/3 boxes after i hit "add"? This would speed up the XP seed steps alot. It would also be nice to include the words "enchant dummy" after/before the "throw items" in the instruction line just to keep me from brain farting. While your at it, could you just put buttons for each of the tool/armor and enchantments. Im asking alot. Just throwing ideas at ya if you wanted feedback, but regardless this is great and thanks again for sharing this. Subcribe!
0 likesWhat happens if it says 14 bookshelves at the end, do you have to drop the items first or block the bookshelves first?
0 likeshey! do you think you could do the same type of thing with piglin bartering? like if you throw this many items with this player seed you would get ender pearls and so on
10 likesReplies (1)
idk if its possible. I'm not a specialist on this type of things but piglin drops are based on loot tables with chances so its impossible to crack it based on logic.
0 likesI've tried this so many times... I can get both of the XP seeds but when I calculate the player seed it says it's not found
6 likesReplies (1)
i think this means that you created some form of rng during the calculating. meaning that you made random numbers generate.
1 likeexamples. breaking blocks?, picking up xp(its random), mending, elytra use(i think), unbreaking, sharpness, smite, ect.
also You can't relog, change dimension or die during the process.
some servers plugins break this process also
well i knew this was possible but i wouldnt have thought it practical since i d have expected you d have to search all 2^48 and not just 2^32 seeds which takes hours even on GPUs. it isnt exactly useful for technical play maybe something similar could be done for finding villagers, although i guess it wouldnt be so easy to get that to work properly since they detect doors at random and such things. i m sure there is some sort of proper application for something along these lines in technical minecraft but i cant really think of one
15 likesReplies (1)
Jendrik Weise it's especially good for getting lots of the same enchantments in bulk. True, on a well-established server you can do the same thing with villagers, but in mid-game you may not quite have the resources to build massive crop farms and villager breeders to get the perfect trades.
9 likesBut honestly, it's probably more useful in UHC.
For everyone coming here recently wondering about MC 1.17.1, I tried it in singleplayer 1.17.1 and IT WORKS.
16 likesI'm using Fabric (fabric loader) and have a few client side mods, none broke it.
It probably works in vanilla and on any vanilla/fabric SMP too.
Replies (15)
Thanks man so much
4 likesThx bro
0 likesYour the goat bro
0 likesDoes netherite work? Or do u have to enchant before you upgrade
0 likesThats so OP 0_0
0 likesThank you very much!
Thx dude, that rly was helpful
0 likesAyyy nice!
1 likeOhh thanks man
0 likesWhy i cant open this?
0 likesBut why doesn’t it work on my paper server
0 likes@Cev_da_one Paper patches stuff like this, maybe try Spigot.
0 likesdoes this work for 1.18?
0 likes@Olderbob how do i tell if a server is paper or not?
0 likes@nidhee maheshwari Press F3 and look around it says server software somewhere
0 likes@Olderbob it isnt therw
0 likesThank you this is awesome! Now i don't have to build a large trading hall with lots of librarians!
2 likesReplies (1)
Does it still work in 1.17?
0 likesGreat work! I usually never put likes on video, but not this time :)
18 likesWow... this is incredible... By the way, I am making a server based almost entirely on the enchantment table. Is there any way I can keep players from doing this all the time? Some way to randomize the player's seed every time they open the table?
4 likesEdit: Is it possible to make a special seed for players that is only used in enchanting? That way players can't influence their enchantment number using something else (like item throwing)?
Replies (2)
Lightning _11 if you still want an answer, probably give like .01 seconds of a potion effect to generate a particle when they open enchanting table.
2 likes@Deltuhvee very true
0 likesheh, I've been working on rewriting that program in C++ since I first saw this video yesterday and after lots of reading Oracle's Java docs, reading MCP code, replaying parts of this video, tweaking, and debugging, I finally managed to get it to produce the correct levels given a seed, so I hope that's one of the hardest parts done.
1 likeawesome! btw, any actions/events that cause the player_rng to be called could be used, but throwing items is easier to control.
1 likethis means that a player could still save his "setup" if he accidentially used the player_rng, by substracting from the number of items to throw away, right?
Replies (2)
You make an interesting point. That's almost correct yes, except throwing an item used the player RNG 4 times, so to fix it you would have to realign yourself with that and then subtract from the item throws. But it would also require you to have exact knowledge how how many times the action you accidentally performed used the RNG, which probably makes it easier to just restart the process IMO.
2 likes@Earthcomputer would you know how many it would be for entering the nether?
0 likesIn 1.14.4 I discovered, (completely by accident) Placing 3 torches in a northern northern facing triangle (directly next to the enchant table) locks the enchantments that you get, so they do not seem to change.
0 likesso its been a really long time since this video but im just wondering if your player seed resets on a specific save/server
0 likesI love how this worked on my potato pc, with broken mouse, which double clicks randomly (guess I need to rng rl), but when I tried diamond_boots it showed me a lot of "impossible"s. Are there "too heavy" combinations?
0 likesexcellent video, im subbing with notifications! do you think its possible to get "illegal" enchants through rng manipulation?
0 likesReplies (1)
No, rng manipulation can only be used to make something that's already technically possible happen.
1 likeGreat tool, surprisingly easy to use! When I asked for Efficiency 4 unbreaking 2 diamond pickaxes it would reply "impossible". Is this because of the player seed or is that combination of enchants not possible to get?
0 likesReplies (1)
its cause you can only get multiple enchants if you do a lvl3 enchant and when you do a lvl3 enchant you can only get unberaking 3
0 likesWith the same type of program but different equations could you find the world seed in any way?
0 likesNice to see you are still updating it with each minecraft version and tweaking it ! :D
2 likesReplies (1)
Means it still works in 1.16.4?
0 likesI’ve done some testing to find that this seems to work tentatively on the Legacy PS4 edition. I’ll have to run some more tests later to ensure consistency, but getting maxed out diamond armor with the requested enchantments seemed almost too coincidental...
3 likesReplies (3)
one question how do i download this
0 likesThe download is linked in the description, I just downloaded it to my computer and followed the steps on my console
0 likes@KyloRenmcgoo wel i downloaded it but now it says error when i try to get the seed i done the full steps
0 likesCrazy stuff, great work!
0 likesCould you update the program for 1.17? thanks! : )
4 likesif this can be done for fishing it would be super usefull. Can this type of RNG be used for fishing?
3 likesa year ago i tried it and failed like 5 times and i thought its fake now i gave it a try and works perfectly i am amazed <3
1 likeReplies (1)
can you help me pls ?
0 likesEvery time I start looking for the XP seed and I get to about 65-ish % on finding the first seed, the cracker seems to overwhelm my computer and the program goes into a 'not responding' status. I'm not sure on why it would, does anyone have a good idea on how I could avoid that?
1 likeReplies (1)
That has to do with how powerful your computer is, so I don't think there's anything you can try
0 likesBig question here: with the randomness of the player being figured out, is it possible to potentially predict fishing loot and other loot table based things? or is it based on the timing of the server? Wondering if this could be any more game breaking. Great work, very nice!
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes, that definitely sounds feasible. I'll look into it
0 likesoh hell yeah, throw 16 stones, fish out mending book, throw out 45 stones, fish out mending/prot4/unb3 book
0 likesGreat find! Do the dummy items need to be of the same type as the item that you want to enchant?
2 likesReplies (1)
i dont think so
0 likesSUBBED YOU NEED MORE SUPPORT MATE!!!!
1 likeThis is amazing and i even understand it :))))
Wow. What a ritual, I feel like I'm one of the ancient civilisations.
3 likesI just did it on my smp, and my friends are so confused how I got all the good enchantments while they get average ones XD
10 likesReplies (4)
I put god enchantments on leather armor just for laughs and giggles xddd
2 likesWait, this works on servers??
0 likes@dblum3 it does if the server has no plugins cause some plugins mess with this
0 likes@nidhee maheshwari oh
0 likesDoes it work on bukkit or normal servers?
0 likesAlso does the other player affect this process?
Is there going to be a version for 1.13? I tried the program with 1.13-pre1 and it kind of worked, but not quite. The enchantments themselves matchup, but their levels seem to be random.
1 likeReplies (2)
There will be an update for 1.13 when the full release comes out
1 likeThat's great! Thanks for quick reply
0 likesNice! Enchant tables are finally useful...
0 likesThis is incredible!
0 likesMaybe you could add a option to erase the last info you added because sometimes you just fuck up and it's anoying to start again( did this a couple of times in the first dummy)
Really helped... I'll try it on the version 1.16.3
0 likesThank you so much
This is amazing im totally doing this
0 likesI'm interested in learning how to crack RNGs, any suggestions?
0 likesI know they changed it so the enchantment seed is stored per player in 1.8, is there any way to replicate this in an earlier version, preferably 1.1? It only goes up to IV and there are no anvils until 1.6. Is it possible to do this?
0 likesI know this used to work in older versions, but I tried this in 1.14 and it didn't work, probably because new enchantments were added to the game which changes a lot about it.
0 likesAre you planning on updating it? I would love to see that, this is such an amazing feature!
Replies (2)
Yeah I tried it too, can't get the player seed
0 likesYep same, the first seed turns into “000000” :/
0 likesDo dispensers/droppers work exactly like manual throwing? (I also need to know if it's dispenser/dropper exclusive or not)
0 likesi know this is a really old video but enchantment rng still works for now and i was wondering. Does you player seed change when you rejoin the game. when does the player seed change. is it per server?
1 likeReplies (2)
Yes, and yes. I believe
0 likesIt was like 1 month old when you commented lol
0 likesGreat job!
0 likesI have done some excessive testing. Might it be possible to discuss the results?
Replies (7)
Gaëtan De Weert sure, go ahead
0 likesSomewhere less public? :-p
0 likesOK then...
0 likesThere are issues with enchanting bows, specifically with certain enchantments like Infinity.
Also, you can make the process more efficient and include more options to chose from.
I know too little about the code, but couldn't this process also be used for more things besides enchanting?
1) known issue, will be fixed soon!
0 likes2) more efficient in what way? I'd say it's already quite efficient.
3) yes, there's some upcoming videos about that
Good to hear! I will wait for those videos before I make some propositions of my own :-)
0 likesThis could be abused as well, so I don't want to give players with bad intentions any ideas by explaining my findings publically.
0 likes@Gaëtan De Weert u think normal players came here to have a gale time enchanting? ofc they came here to abuse this lol
1 likeWow! The UI for the current version is so nice!!
0 likesReplies (1)
doesnt work in 1.16.1 yet right or am i doing it wrong...
0 likesYou have earned my subscription!☺
2 likesThis is some fucking crazy shit! Thanks for making the tool and all the work you have put in.
1 likeIts so cool! I hope it works in newer versions too.
0 likesReplies (1)
it does, just tested it in 1.17.1
0 likescan you collect all the xp then crack the seed, enchant your item, collect more xp then, enchant an item to reset it. then use the same seed
0 likesif the bookshelf number isn't 15, does that apply to both the dummy and the real sword?
0 likesHello my question is can u get sharpness 4 looting 3 knockback 2 fire aspect 2 unbreaking 3 sweeping edge 3 (so a fully equiped sword) and can u throw the same items that u have already thrown away and picked up or not thanks a lot
0 likesReplies (2)
Try inputting those enchantments into the tool, it should tell you whether it's feasible.
0 likesYou should be able to pick up all your items again, that doesn't affect anything ;)
thanks a lot a tried it but it cant make it coz i think my computer isnt strong enough :(
0 likesI tested this to try and get a prot 4 unbreaking 3 diamond chestplate and it was one level off from prot 4
0 likesHello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
0 likesBut i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
although the FPS isnt the best, Holly heck, i am happy to see people tinkering with MC to the extent, of searching how many trillions of seeds to get a Perfect enchant. Well done EC!
0 likesThis is actually epic level stuff .
0 likesI confirm. It work. It's hard to do it the first try but THAT WORK!
0 likesHi! I know this is an old video but I have a question. When I try to find the first seed It appears as "No possible seeds" I don't know what I'm doing wrong and I was wondering if this works in realms/1.15.2
1 likeReplies (5)
u need the step with torches correctly. look how he do that
0 likesSkyZi Play Does it still work in 1.15.2?
0 likes@Complex8723 idk, not checked fully again yet. last time i had in connecting 2 xp seed fail
0 likes@Complex8723 i do that again with making sure i dont sprint get lvl etc and it said failed
0 likesyes it works in 1.15.2
0 likesI tried this and I got the error "No player seed found" when I tried to calculate the player seed. I tried it twice, did not work. Thanks for the vid!
2 likesReplies (2)
1) make sure you are following all the instructions precisely
3 likes2) make sure you are not doing any of those things you can't do (there's additional things in the description)
3) make sure the server isn't modded. Spigot by itself is okay, but some plugins are known to mess the process up.
@Earthcomputer can you pick out which ones?
0 likesThat's just completely crazy I hadn't thought that minecraft is this manipulatable
0 likesWow my man legit god of Minecraft, on from being weird tho thanks for spending prob the hours u did to do this it was very simple and eazy to understand and it worked first try but i forgot to enchant dummy at the end and now i have op wooden sword lol
0 likesHi! found this recently in a SkipTheTutorial video and was wondering if this works in bedrock as well. If it does, then I have an incredible shop opportunity on my server.
0 likesReplies (1)
i have tried this on servers in hopes for starting a busness and making a lot of money but remember one thing that if your server has plugins then they can mess with this cracker and it also doesnt work if your sever is paper
0 likeshas anyone else used this on java realms? I've been getting "no possible seed" when I try on realms
0 likesThat's really amazing!
0 likesDoesn't seem to be working for me in 1.14, worked in 1.13.2 however. Any ideas why? Could they have changed the enchanting mechanics in 1.14?
0 likesReplies (2)
How did you do it in 1.13.2? Can you help, im able to get two xp seeds but no player seed
0 likes@Zeta If you have the two XP seeds already, you just need to click the calculate button to get the player seed. Thats all.
0 likesI'm playing 1.13.2 multiplayer, the program says the player seed was not found, and I've followed your video exactly like you did, enchanted the items with the torches all like in your video's momentums, and I'm using the latest version of your program, how does it not work?
4 likesReplies (1)
I think 1.13 broke a lot of RNG manipulation, so I think it only works with 1.12 and lower.
1 likeDamn! You're a genious!
1 likeThanks a lot
"Fail!" is the result of calculating player seed after finding two XP seeds. I guess librarian villagers are still better
2 likesReplies (5)
please do not tell me you wasted that much time, this is outdated bro 💀💀 technically it still works but you could just use a fabric mod he made called "client commands" and call it a day instead of doing this much effort
0 likes@Corruptedz_Incline I thought I was doing something wrong for the wrongest time, thanks
0 likes@iLectus np i hope you have fun getting op enchants on ur gear
0 likesbut is it possible in minecraft 1.18 whithout the mod
0 likes@Endora 0 it is not a mod, it's a program to determine what to do to get the rng perfect to get your own enchantments
0 likesyou technically can do this if you're super clever and you know what to do without the program
Ok, did it on 1.14 and it kinda works. If I want efficiency 4 and unbreaking 3, the outcome wold give me both efficiency and unbreaking but at different levels. But I was still able to get silk touch.
0 likesReplies (2)
Do you use the modded client or separate program
0 likes@Zeta I used the program.
0 likesdoes this still work if you want to enchant multiple different items (such as a full set of diamond armor?)
0 likesImagine this being coded into Baritone
18 likesReplies (4)
Holy shit yes!
1 likeThen you realize that 2b2t and most other servers you'd want to use this on run on Paper, which breaks or changes just about every single technical aspect of the game, including the manipulation of enchantment tables.
5 likes@AutiAuto fucc
0 likesi might get used too much and get pached
0 likesI have a question: you have to do that every time you want to enchant something? i mean, if you do all this an then you keep playing your survival world like usually; you have to do everything again to get the player seed?
0 likesthanks for releasing it for 1.18 really appreciate it
0 likesfeels like using cheat engine when you want to search for certain values. neat
1 likeWorked ! =D Thank you Earthcomputer !
0 likesI did all the steps but when i caculate the seed it keeps on failing, can anyone help?
3 likesReplies (1)
Same
0 likesonce the player seed has been found, do you have to redo the player seed to do enchantments the next time at the table?
0 likesReplies (1)
I'm very sure that's a yes because if you do any of the things mentioned at the start (gain xp, etc.etc.) you change the player seed that is used for the table seed.
0 likesAttempted a few times, kept getting "No Possible Seeds". Followed the steps carefully in survival (bukkit server)
0 likesPlayer seed not found twice; 14th attempt finally works, though not 100% consistent with the output.
I have a question, does the playerseed stay when you relog/cross dimenions (nether/end/overworld)? Thanks and great work.
Replies (1)
Kuno as mentioned in the description, the player seed does not stay constant when you do those things. There's also some other important information in the description you should check out.
0 likesI'm currently playing on a 1.17 server and your enchantment method enticed my interest. However when I was watching your video I had a question. When using your method, is it okay to use multiple tools and types of armor? ex: diamond_sword, diamond_axe, diamond_pickaxe, diamond_helmet, diamond_chestplate, diamond_leggings, and diamond_boots. I also have another question which is about the dummy items. Do the dummy items have to be the same item as the tools or weapons you are trying to enchant? Your videos are amazing and I've been recently watching them. You deserve more subscribers and I hope you grow as a content creator! :)
1 likeReplies (1)
I don't think it has to be the same exact item but I am not 100% sure.
0 likesThis works for me on 1.18.1 singleplayer, it feels so surreal lol ty
0 likesEdit: it didn’t work on my friend’s server
Replies (1)
where u using the mod?
0 likesim pretty sure this would've worked but due to my inability to not make mistakes it didn't
3 likescool tutorial though
is something similar possible with finishing or looting swords?
0 likesReplies (1)
It hasn't been done yet, but yes, although it wouldn't be worth it without a modded client
0 likeswow, it works great!
1 likehi earth computer, i really need help, every time i try to calculate the xp seed, they always tell me it fail to calculate. I got this like 3 times now, do u know how to fix this?
0 likesThank you and the video is great
Replies (1)
Doesnt work on paper servers
0 likesI downloaded it but it won't work right for some reason, the bat file opens and then immediately closes after
5 likesReplies (2)
make sure you have the latest 64-bit java installed
6 likesI had a similar problem, make sure you have the 64-bit version of Java installed. If not, I recommend installing it.
6 likesOkay so I found a problem for MP. Everything works fine on singleplayer, tested it on MY 1.12.2 server seems to work just fine BUT when I try and do it on another 1.12.2 vanilla server it never works...
0 likesAny clues?
Edit: nvm it was just the fact that I was sprinting...
Replies (1)
lol
0 likesCould this technology be used to figure out world seeds?? Maybe giving cords of certain biomes until it finds only one seed with such biomes on those cords.
0 likesReplies (1)
aged like wine
0 likesWhen I try to run it, launcher says that I have an old version of java. But I am using Java 17. Any tips to help?
1 like19:03 How are you throwing it out? I've been able to get the player seed using a dispenser for the dummy swords, but the only way I know how to drop items individually is either single clicking them off the side of the inventory, or pressing q, both of which you said you couldn't do. I tried making a dispenser bin for the dropping of the stacks of items, but it won't work.
0 likesTL;DR
What are you clicking to drop them individually like that?
Replies (2)
You are allowed to throw out items (by whatever means you like, Q, clicking, etc), as long as the method explicitly says you can. You just can't throw items any other time.
1 likeEarthcomputer ohhhhh. That makes sense. Thank you!!
0 likeswhy does it always say Fail! at the end everytime (I've literally lost 20 lvls already and its still fail!)
4 likesHello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
0 likesBut i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
Replies (2)
It does not work on bungeecord period. Bungeecord is a fork of paper which it does not work on.
0 likes@Earthcomputer oh thanks for the response , seems the server is at bungeecord , then i can't make it. I subscribed and liked , i really hope a new dupe comes out soon , thanks!
0 likesAre you planning to update the enchantment cracker for 1.14?
0 likesReplies (2)
Have you tried it on 1.14? Did it work for you on 1.13?
0 likes@Jovan04 it worked on 1.13 and when i tried on 1.14 it didn't work.
0 likeswhen trying to get looting 3 on book, we get piercing 3, i need somebody to confirm this version 1.14.4
0 likesReplies (1)
1.14.4 version isn't out yet
0 likesI'm having trouble getting this to work fully with books. I can always get one of the enchantments that I add (say, efficiency 4 from a list of efficiency 4, unbreaking 3, and silk touch) but almost never the other ones. Is there something special about books, am I doing something wrong, or what? I'm making sure to use the amount of bookshelves it says, too.
0 likesReplies (1)
okl just reproduced the issue. It's probably some bug in the code. Thanks for letting me know!
2 likesHmmm...
6 likesI just tried this, it worked flawlessly in singleplayer, but on my server it doesn't seem to work - is this not possible to use on spigot servers ... or am I just messing up?
Replies (1)
less plugins the better really
0 likesThis is fantastic! An incredible breakthrough, and all built into an easy tool. Do you have any other codebreaking gadgets for minecraft in development?
0 likesCan we use the player seed to get a mending book every time we go fishing? Or even a chest full of them every time we open a dungeon chest?
Replies (1)
Yes, it will probably be possible to manipulate fishing loot, I'll look into that. Not dungeon chests, though, they depend on the world seed not the player seed.
0 likesplayers: perfectly balanced
0 likesMojang: .. we did that on purpose
Is it possible for you to add sweeping edge for the manipulator's list of enchants?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes. The enchantment ID for sweeping edge is sweeping.
1 likeis it possible to switch tools while going through them? would the type/material of the dummy matter?
0 likesReplies (1)
The dummy type does not matter (I used iron pickaxes for dummies as we like to use them as throwaway picks for projects). "Changing tools" is a bit vague, but if you mean by enchanting multiple different items in succession then the answer is no - it will not affect anything.
0 likesIt failed to calculate my player seed
3 likesIs the player seed you find still valid after relogging etc?
0 likesReplies (2)
No. Make sure you read the extra list of things you can't do in the video description :)
0 likesEarthcomputer thanks for clarifying. I thought the process was only counting the finding of the seed
0 likesdoes this work on a 1.14.4 spigot server and if so, would the others have to be ofline or can i just go into an unloaded chunk and do it or another dimension and do it
0 likesOMG THIS ACTUALLY WORKS! 3 YEARS LATER AND IT STILL WORKS, YOU ARE A GENIUS! THANK YOU!!
0 likes<3
Replies (2)
how
0 likesshow me a example
0 likesHello,
0 likesI have a quick question about the seed. What I would like to know is if I find my seed is that' my seed and it doesn't change or do I need to recalculate every time?
Thank you.
Replies (3)
Usually you can press "done" and it knows your seed already, but if you do one of the forbidden actions (including logging out and in) you will have to recalculate the seed from scratch.
0 likes@Earthcomputer Okay awesome thank you, another thing that im gonna post onto the issues tab for github is that the file cant find the native folder so its forcing me to use the slow version and the first add info never loads, because its too much for the program.
0 likes@Earthcomputer Never mind. I just read through your posts on the issues board and you said you don't support mac libraries which is what I'm on, so I'll have to ask a friend to help out. Thanks for creating this amazing tool and I hope they never get rid of it.
0 likesWhat's the reason Ray used this discovery for his April Fools video? It seems to dismiss that this actually works, even though it's treated as an April Fools joke. Why would you let people laugh at an invention instead of actually showing it properly.
16 likesReplies (9)
He does that almost every year.
9 likesSander Bos, while it's not as useful to a well established technical player (villager-wise), it is rather i insanely powerful, though I doubt Mojang would actually change the enchanting code for it, it does help keep it a bit hush in a good way, though I doubt it will stay that way, but to restate myself, I doubt Mojang would change the code just because of this.
5 likesYou do realize that it's a tradition to release ground breaking ideas on april fools right? Started with some people, especially in zipkrowd with panda's release of his enderdragon xp farm, then a spawner generator. Lots of content is released that day just to mess with us and the awesome ones are remembered.
8 likesArmedWithWings, it was released on the 28th the month before by another person.
0 likesI would still suggest checking their channel out.
0 likesIf you don't mind me asking, by whom? I was replying to the original person who asked why Ray's video was released on April fools day. Rays released it on the first, and Earth on the 28th. Earth gets the credit but ray showcases the idea while making us wonder if it was real or not.
1 likeEdit: Nvm you must be referring to Earth. Btw the comment you are replying to is on Earth's channel lol.
ArmedWithWings Oh, I didn't realize which video I was on... (I clicked on the notification and immidiately scrolled down) yeah, this is the original video.
0 likesand then you mentioned that 😐
0 likesBecause people think it's fake, but it isn't, so he basically fools them.
2 likesjust a question, I couldn't open lots of the files within the enchantment cracker file. Why?
0 likesThis is like doing an occult ritual to change laws of nature which were never meant to be changed
0 likeswill this work in that beta 1.9 pre version where you can get fortune 3 + silk touch on a single pick?
1 likeReplies (2)
have u tried?
0 likes@Maxblau i did not but i think he stated that its version specific, so i doubt
0 likesI'm playing in 1.18 and using the 1.18 cracker but whenever I try to calculate player seed it says "Fail!" I don't think I'm doing anything wrong. I just open chests, open dispensers, break torches and enchant. Basically nothing wrong. I calculated the amount of levels and lapis I need. Could someone help me out?
1 likeReplies (1)
same question right here
0 likesWhen I click "Calculate" in the player seed tab it says "Player seed not found". Can anyone help me. (Using minecraft 1.12.2, have double checked this in single player and multiplayer, am running a 64 bit version of java.)
3 likesReplies (15)
Harry Chacksfield most likely you did one of the listed things you shouldn't do. You must have done it in between the first dummy enchantment and the second, resulting in the two XP seeds not being consecutive.
5 likesdoes collecting an item or breaking an item do anything?
2 likesHarry Chacksfield what do you mean breaking an item? If you mean breaking a tool, yes, that would invalidate it.
4 likesI broke a placed torch and picked it up during the process.
2 likesDo you know if spigot affects this?
2 likesHarry Chacksfield I tested it yesterday on Spigot and it worked. All I can say is make sure you're following all the steps exactly. Make sure you didn't miss anything out or do anything extra. Make sure you don't do anything I mention at the start of the video or in the description.
2 likesForgetting to do the dummy enchantment at the start or in the middle could also cause it.
3 likesI just tested this for 10/12 times and it kept saying player seed not found.. pretty sure i have followed all your instruction.. idk wt hppen
0 likesI've just recently discovered that beacon effects affect it. Do you have any beacons active? If so, disable them and try again.
3 likesHmm there's no beacon in my base and also i went to another place to test if location matters but it still showin player seed not found
2 likes(Note: I am playing on a spigot multiplayer server and i tested this on singleplayer and it worked..)
ok. Must be down to the Spigot plugins then.
3 likesdoes mcmmo causes this somehow?
1 likeok. It certainly could do. An easy way to test is to add the plugins one by one and see after which plugin it stops working.
2 likesTry reinstalling Java
1 likeI'm on a server with mcmmo and so far I'm not having very much luck. My most "successful" run resulted in an unknown xp seed at the end, and I'm absolutely certain I have not done any of the things I shouldn't have. Could the xp seed be one that isn't one of the 2^32?
1 like(Edit: fixed, got my first XP seed, I might've done a typo or miscount somewhere)
(Edit2: successfully enchanted what I wanted, but I now have a question. If you do some of the things you shouldn't after you have the player seed, do you have to do the entire process over again?)
Wow that must have taken a while to code and work out the pattern
0 likesWhy do I get "Player seed not found" after calculating in the Player Seed tab?
1 likeEdit: Got it this time, but not the enchantments I wanted...Why could that be?
It keeps failing when I try to find the player seed, I'm in version 1.14.4 and I've tried 5 times already :(
1 likeIs that Sancarn reincarnated?! Lol I’m joking but I’m super glad that a fellow Brit has managed to make this incredible technical discovery! P.S you sound like you are from Manchester :P Congratulations on this achievement!
0 likesOMG it works on pultiplayer thx a lot 2b2t coming
10 likesAccording to wiki, the enchantment names (in SGA) also relies on the enchant seed. For server playing you can directly get the seed high28b from server, and for speedrunner can make a SGAtoseed?
0 likesReplies (5)
Actually the original implementation of this method exploited this, but isn't included in this method since it's not vanilla. Unfortunately using the high 28 bits only works in single player (which is useless since you could just directly access the seed). In multiplayer, you only get 12 bits because the seed is truncated to a short over the network.
1 likeIf you want a mod which exploits the 12 bits, take a look at my clientcommands code link in the description, then if you cba compiling there is a releases page.
@Earthcomputer using the high 28 bits in single player in IGT speedrunning mean you can capture screen and slowly analyze the string, rather than using lots of time placing torches, breaking torches and seeing each ench
0 likes@More Girl it's not as easy as that. The text displayed on the screen doesn't give you 12 (or 28 in sp) bits of the seed. It is generated from those 12 bits. But those bits of the seed are stored client side, so with a modded client you can access the data directly. Otherwise, you have to crack the seed. This would actually be more efficient in multiplayer, since 12 + 20 is a more even split than 28 + 4.
0 likes@Earthcomputer so even in single player the text is generated from 12 bit of randomness?
0 likes@More Girl no in sp its generated from 28 bits. There may be something you could do which is smarter than brute force but it will be more brute forcing to get those 28 bits.
0 likesYou were lagging like hell but that doesnt even matter you just made my day
0 likeswhen i try to calculate my two seeds it just says "Fail!" anyone know why??
1 likeReplies (1)
Doesnt work on paper servers
0 likesI used my 20-25 minutes here and i realised i don't have pc and i can't do this on mobile wow
1 likeI can play Java because I have launcher but i can't open cracking tool
Does it also break if any other people on the server do the things that break the process?
3 likesReplies (3)
No
0 likesEarthcomputer aight then i did something wrong. everything went as expected, but the predictions were just wrong, am playing on a 1.13.2 spigot server. does this not work in 1.13.2? does it matter at wich level/bookcase amount you enchant the dummy items? do you have to pick the drop items back up before enchanting?
0 likes- it works in 1.13.2
1 like- no
- no
I tested it on Spigot back in March and it worked, but it may have been fixed since then. Some plugins are also known to break it. Other than that it should work, ensure you're following the instructions precisely enough.
Can anyone help? I tried cracking the player seed and it said "Fail!", how can i fix this?
0 likesI’m very late on this but hopefully someone could tell me if other players on multiplayer could affect my enchant seed?
1 likeThis kinda works. It does definitely get at least one enchantment you wanted, but it doesn't get all of them, especially if they are three.
0 likesReplies (5)
EDIT: After a couple of more tries. This definitely doesn't work. Enchantments are totally off.
0 likes@Wup Are you playing 1.14.3? The tool hasn't been updated to that version just yet.
1 like@Earthcomputer I was when I tried it. Would a different version cause the tool to not work like that?
0 likes@Earthcomputer will it be?
0 likes@Wup they changed enchanting in 1.14.3
0 likesCurious if this works on 1.11.2 as well.
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes! After a quick Google, I found that this tool should work since 16w50a (release 1.11.1). The theory applies all the way back to 1.8.
1 likeIts just fantastic, using computer science, programming and those stuff in minecraft.
0 likesI tried making a power 4, unbreaking 3 infinity bow and it said "Impossible".
0 likeswhy did it say it was impossible?
Replies (4)
It says "Impossible" if it didn't get it after 1000 simulations of enchantments. This is a precaution against infinite loops if the combination is actually impossible. You'll have to split it into two enchants and combine in an anvil.
0 likesthe thing is, i decided to remove the unbreaking 3,
0 likesand then I got unbreaking 3 anyway, so that is why I asked.
liorhaddad really? That's very interesting. Do you still have your player seed? If so, send it to me so I can see what's going in.
0 likesI don't have it anymore, sorry ):
0 likesSorry i know this is late but, is it compatible with 1.12.2? If you could reply that would be great. And also, if you have your player seed, do you need to find your xp seed again??
1 likeThanks!
Replies (1)
He is using 1.12.2 in this so yes
0 likesjust wondering does this still work on 1.17 and above bcoz i cant find a reason not to
1 likebtw insane job
Replies (1)
yes it does
0 likesso, i did it all right but when i hit "calculate" on the tool it says "Fail!"
1 likestill cant believe this only has 4k views after all this time. Is it bad of me to hope it stays that way so only we the lucky few know?
0 likesDo you need to start the whole process again when you, you know dont enchant anymore?
0 likesReplies (1)
As said in 0:56, you can't do anything of these things because it will change the player xp seed and therefore all future enchantments are different after it.
0 likesI know the method used here doesn't work on papermc, but is there any work around for it to work?
0 likesI did everything as shown in the video and at the end after setting the enchantments, and then clicking on calculate, it shows no match for throwing the cobblestone... pls help
0 likesSo...whenever I attempt to do this, I alt+tab back and forth between Minecraft and the Enchant Cracker application, and randomly Minecraft will freeze, go blank, stay frozen or completely crash, and I don't know why! It seems to be completely random, sometimes happening right when I alt+tab or sometimes when I am so unbearably close to cracking my XP seed. My mouse often freezes and then sometimes Google Chorme gets glitchy too, does anyone have any advice for me?
1 likeEdit: I don't think this is because of the Enchantment Cracker application specifically, Minecraft just doesn't like me alt+tabbing to a different window for whatever reason.
Im getting an error every time "player seed not found" (spingot 1.13.2 server) what's the problem?
0 likesEarthcomputer: So this is a way to crack enchantment table
0 likesmojang dev: take the wiki, there is a new feature
minecraft wiki from next day: Enchantments tables are now crackable
What does it mean when it says "Failed!" when you press calculate seed (after getting two XP seeds)
0 likesI was able to make it work on the 4th try. But I just wanna know what this error means so that I'd be aware of what mistakes I did to avoid them next time.
Thanks for this, man!
Replies (3)
I had one go where the XP seed stayed at 3 possible seeds. And im already at 2 bookshelves. Are there other ways to avoid this?
0 likesI went from 15,14,13,12,9,6,3, 2.
Like you did.
The only other way i can think of is getting silk touch to take 1 bookshelf at a time.
@Carlo Espiritu you can try other combinations of torches for 5, 8 etc bookshelves, but in the rare event it never goes down to 1 seed, you just have to do a dummy enchant and start the whole process again, sorry.
1 like@Earthcomputer
0 likesOh of course i see.
Thanks a lot dude!
what am i doing wrong? i keep doing this and it shows "no possible seeds" on 13 bookshelves
1 likewow bro you need nobel prize for this! and a question this player seed changes every time? (for example log out and come back) cant we just note this and use it again when we need it? and is there another way of finding this seed?
0 likes+ you got star for this project on github. im pretty noob at every thing but glad to help you
Replies (1)
Logging out and in means you have to recrack it. There may be other ways to reverse it, but that's very much current research.
1 likeDo you think the 1.13.2 version is actually working? I tried 2 times already [And i did indeed follow the stuff with RNG like not sprinting,potions,relog etc] but everytime i try it just says "player seed not found"
0 likesReplies (3)
Yes it does. The server isn't running spigot is it?
0 likesIts a single player map,was just curious to test it here before doing it on servers
0 likeswas it patched on spigot?
0 likesThis man deserves a comment from notch
2 likesChange my mind
What is the input for sweeping edge? I've been putting in variations and nothing's working, sorry for any hassle...
0 likesReplies (1)
It's "sweeping", as per the enchantment IDs
0 likesare you unable to do the things you mentioned at the start of the video while getting your player seed or while enchanting your items
0 likesReplies (1)
Do not do any of the things at all during the entire process. If you do, then you will change your seed and ruin the process.
0 likesCan one throw items before an ench to prepare for the next one without wasting a stone sword?
0 likesReplies (2)
Nope, enchanting the stone sword "applies" the changes you made by throwing items, so it's necessary.
0 likes@Earthcomputer but enchanting the last diamond sword also do the apply
0 likesWorks! Thank you so much dude!
0 likesOnce you get your playerseed you dont have to get the 2 other enchant seeds again right?
1 likeReplies (2)
Correct, you only crack the first to seeds at the beginning of the whole enchanting session. If you then go and do something else, and come back and start another session, only then do you have to find the first two seeds again
0 likes@Earthcomputer oh ok, I was hoping I can do this once and then just have my seed and join another world and start doing my stuff, but this is still amazing.
1 likeis it possible you can make a website version?
0 likesHey, Im having trouble opening the tool on mac. I went to terminal and put the thing it said and it says no such file found.
0 likesReplies (1)
Solution: Get windows
2 likesAm i the only one that this fails? I've tried this with 6 different seeds and all of them say "fail!"? Pls send help, I'm playing on 1.16.5 on a hardcore server
2 likesCan I use that method to set loot chest? (same random source?)
0 likesReplies (2)
No
0 likesthe loot chests are generatet by the server but the enchanting thing uses the playerseed so you can influence it
0 likesrip me, I cannot seem to be able to get the xp seed to be brute forced in my C++ rewrite even as fast as in your java program, even though I made mine multithreading to use all of my laptop's 4 cores... I guess either Java is just super optimised in those parts, or I'm overlooking something major. I'll have to investigate your mod's code a bit closer to make sure I haven't missed anything obvious, I guess, and after that I'll have to see how I could optimise my code better, I must've made some wrong assumptions about performance. Although I guess all of the effort I've put into this is ultimately pretty unnecessary since most people probably have a better computer than you anyway so the wait time really isn't so significant.
0 likesReplies (1)
fdagpigj E that part of my program was written in C++ (for speed obviously). That's what all the DLLs are for. There's nothing super-special about the code I wrote. Just make sure to only match against the numbers on the right, and don't start trying to generate the enchantment clues for each seed as well since that would slow it down a lot.
0 likesI even tried it in creative after wasting tons of xp in survival :< Think its broken, followed EVERY single step of the process and still get "no possible seed" everytime
0 likesReplies (1)
In what version did you try?
0 likesMaybe try vanilla 1.12.2 without forge
is the seed locally stored? or will it not really work on multiplayer?
0 likesReplies (3)
works on multiplayer, just not on bigger servers, because there is some plugins that make it stop working.
1 likeFl05k8r could you give me examples of plugins that can conflict with this
0 likesNope, sadly I don't know which ones do.
1 likeI made a spigot only server and it worked on that.
But I don't know what plugins on the big servers conflict with it, I only know there is plugins that do, sorry.
Anyone please post an answer here if you found out. Maybe we can find a fix for spigot If we know the plugin
i don't know why , but when every time the new enchantment cracker gets both seeds and i press calculate, it says fail.
0 likesReplies (1)
same
0 likestried it . I found the 2 seeds by following the video but it said it could not find my player seed. What could I be dong wrong? this is on a server if that matters
1 likeReplies (1)
The Dark Sword I've read the description over and over; what are you referring to? I can't find whatever it is your alluding to.
0 likesI have just been informed that this does not work for 20w51a
0 likesSo I have 6 diamond shovels with useless enchantments
when i press calculate seed it says failed. does anyone know what happened. it calculated my xp seeds tho
1 likeThe terminal is just this thing where you type instructions into the computer. Ive never really used it before.
0 likesReplies (1)
oops, I ment to reply to my old comment. I never comment
0 likesquestion- is this patched in recent updates? (e.g. 1.16.4)
0 likesReplies (1)
Nope
1 likeHmm... Maybe placing and breaking torches does not work because it failed me a couple of times. Gonna try mining the bookshelves instead.
0 likesReplies (1)
I tried without any mod on 1.16.1, without doing absolutely anything else, nor having any effects applied and making sure to enchant a dummy with one lapis before searching each xp seed. The Calculate Seed button Always fails :(
0 likesWhat effect does forge/modded minecraft have on this?
0 likesReplies (2)
I tried it recently, forge doesn't affect it. But I am not sure about mods since they can add new enchantments messing up the IDs
0 likes@Лучший Танк good so I can use this with the Minestuck mod since that mod doesn't have enchantments
1 likeawesome! but can you not calculate mending? it doesnt seem to be a valid input for the program?
0 likesReplies (1)
It's impossible to get mending in an enchanting table.
1 likei guess its not possible on the server i am on, the enchantment cost changes whenever i enter and exit the enchantment table gui
0 likesHello i need help
0 likesafter the first seed i get i enchant a dummy then proceed to get the second one
and then after there are 6 book left i enchant and it found the seed, but when i press calculate player seed it just says fail
im on version 1.15.1 on a spigot server
Replies (1)
Make sure you enchant a dummy BEFORE the whole process too. Also, spigot should be fine, but if you're running PaperMC, it won't work.
1 likeit doesnt work on the web version anymore. it keeps saying "no possible seeds"
0 likesAwesome, can I enchant armour?
0 likesCan other people on the server do all those things in the beginning or do you need to have everyone stand still in a hole and not eating?
0 likesReplies (1)
Players are separate from each other, i.e. It doesn't matter what the other players are doing
1 likeBro, you're amazing, you know that ?
0 likesDoes not work for me. Version: 1.15.2
0 likesImportant note: I'm on a server which is running "Craftimize", I do not know if that interferes or not. The server does not appear to be running Paper however.
The seed-finder appeared to work, but then when I followed the instructions to get Unbreaking 3, Sharpness 4, Looting 3, etc. it did not work. The first time it gave me sharpness 3, looting 2, and unbreaking 3. The other times it did not follow the expected pattern at all. (or not that I noticed). One other note is that I accidentally enchanted one of the stone swords instead of one of the diamond swords, but then I clicked done and re-calculated, instead of enchanting another sword.
I followed these steps, and I thought I made no mistakes. Is there any common mistake I may have made?
- I unbound sprint and did not double-tap w to sprint
- I did not eat after enchanting the first dummy item
- I did not gain xp or die after enchanting the first dummy item
- I did not throw any more or less items than it told me to (unless I made an error here?)
- I used the correct amount of bookshelves
Any thoughts or help? Does this not work on 1.15.2? If I had to guess I'd say its the "Craftimize" plugin, can anyone look into that and see whether "Craftimize" interferes with RNG manipulation?
Replies (1)
paper dont work because all entities share same rng
0 likesso give up
If I get two seeds and press calculate, it says "FAIL!"(I did it exactly)
0 likesWhen I used this for my friend's SMP server, it said no player seed found. Can someone help?
0 likesReplies (1)
Same here
0 likesWhy doesn't this work on PaperMC servers exactly? I need an in-depth analysis, please.
0 likesReplies (1)
TheNja09 Because all entities share the same RNG. You may as well give up.
0 likesit didnt work for me in 1.17
0 likesi did everything ok and when i went over to the enchantments i chose and pressed calculate it showed a window which says u must enter the player seed. but i had filled up both the xp seed 1 and xp seed 2 still it didnt work
Please make this for bedrock too! :)
2 likesReplies (1)
that's not how that works lol
1 likeIt says impossible if I put over 2 enchants in wanted list in 1.14.4 version
1 likeReplies (1)
What enchants to what item did you put
0 likesHow do you make the program bigger because when I download and use it, it is very small.
0 likesdoes this work if other players are doing their own thing? specifically 250?
0 likesThis is god-mode! Wow! Does this work in multiplayer servers?
2 likesReplies (1)
It also works. tried it on my spigot server. Don't use Paper
0 likesSometimes, the stone says No match. What does it mean?
0 likesCan't detect the 2nd XP seed, whenever i only have 3 bookshelves left and i need to place a torch in a corner im screwed and cant put in 0 as it doesnt detect it
0 likesReplies (1)
you can get two bookshelfs by removing a torch on any one of the edge pieces. it doesnt effect the rng outcome
0 likesWhen I get both of XP Seeds and press calculate it says Fail! what can I do I tried this second time and it's still not working :(
0 likesI do it but when i distribute all the bookshelves it says 2 possible seeds
0 likesWill this process work as intended if I play Minecraft on PlayStation 4 while simultaneously using my laptop to run your program?
0 likesIn other words will this work on console version? Assuming of course that the RNG methodology is identical for every version of Minecraft in existence.
Replies (1)
No console
1 likeWhenever I do step 2 and enter 2 bookshelves, I don't get the XP seed. 1 bookshelf doesn't give 3 enchantment slots; what do I do? I've been placing the torches just as you were doing, and looking at the enchantments and not actually enchanting anything
0 likesReplies (3)
PaulZ try more numbers of bookshelves. If 0 and 1 aren't working, try 2, 3, 4, 5,..., 14, 15. In the very rare case that you still can't crack the seed with all these, you'll have to do a dummy enchantment and start the process again.
0 likesEarthcomputer Ah ok, one other thing: does the dummy item need to be the same type of item as the target item? If I'm enchanting books, do the dummy items need to be books as well?
0 likesDummy enchantments can be any enchantable item.
0 likesdoes this work in all post-lapis-use versions of the game?
0 likesReplies (2)
Yep
1 likethats insane. thanks for making this tutorial
0 likesHow do you use the mod? I have it installed but don’t know where to go from there…
0 likesemm i tried it in 1.16 i did all the step correct i got the player seed i went to enchantment calculator i pick the enchantments i wanted i hit calculate and it said no match
0 likesIn the description you said that it won't work if the server's running PaperMC. Do you know about other ones like Spigot, SpongeForge, or perhaps one that will work?
0 likes19:45 what the...
0 likesI respect you. That's awesome.
Do mob spawns and enderchest particles mess this up?
1 likeReplies (3)
No to both
1 like@Earthcomputer Thanks
0 likes@Earthcomputer I thought the random seeming movement of particles and random spawning of mobs would use random numbers... but I guess those are made with the server random number seed, not the random number seed for the player... Thanks!
0 likesI would rather just grind for enchants instead of this. But good trick out there
0 likeswould it work on modded mc if there were like 100 new enchants?
0 likesDoes this work in servers?
0 likesBTW whats the total amount of enchantment seeds all together
1 likecan this be done on servers?
1 likewhen do you think there will be an update for 1.14.4?
1 likeWait what's the enchant seeds for again? i didn't see it used at the end in the manipulate section
0 likesIt always fail to calculate the player seed in multi player :(
0 likesdoes going i creative affect this
1 likeEDIT: it keeps saying failed when i caclculate seed :/ SECOND EDIT: i think its coz im in 1.16.1 :P
Replies (1)
Yeah it does not work for 1.16.1 yet -_-
0 likesWhat if you use more than 15 bookshelves?
0 likesReplies (1)
Then it counts as 15
1 likeXPseed does not work on 32bit processor and operating system..running win7 pro 32bit
2 likesare you planning to include Netherite?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes
1 likeHi is there a enchant,ent cracker program that works for mobile or can be used in the browser because all the ones I tried don’t work.
0 likesReplies (1)
This is a method for Minecraft java edition, mobile is programmed completely different
0 likesWow, this seems to work. It's a shame that Ray chose April 1st to share this really.
0 likesOLD COMMENT FOR REFERENCE:
Trying to figure out if this is real.
First attempt: Minecraft actually froze, "Not responding". May be unrelated to this.
Second attempt: Got the desired enchantments, may be by chance.
Third attempt (by pressing Done and doing another one immediately): Got the wrong enchantments, may be an error in my method, I might've left a torch when doing the dummy item.
Replies (1)
I did that, at least I think I did. I've just tried again and all working perfectly now though! Maybe I accidentally sprinted the first time or something. As for the game freezing, I was suspecting that if this was an april fools thing then perhaps it was hooking into the game somehow, and just failed because I have a few mods. Clearly that's not the case as it's now working fine, and nothing looked suspicious when decompiling the jar.
0 likesCan you have more xp than you need?
0 likesReplies (1)
Of course you can
0 likesatleast worked on my creative testing world, after 13 tries. dont know if it will work on servers.
0 likesdoes this work on bedrock edition aswell?
1 likeI was testing out the 1.14.4 version with optifine and it was never able to find the enchantment seed, it just kept saying no seeds found after the second attempt. I am doing everything right, is it possible optifine changes the enchantment seed?
0 likesedit: I relaunched 1.14.4 without optifine and it still doesn't work.
edit 2: I just realized it requires a wooden sword because each material has different enchanting levels associated with them...
Replies (3)
Gonna try this tomorrow
0 likesJust to be clear. It's still working for 1.14.4 right? And you used wooden swords for the dummy enchants?
@Carlo Espiritu yes. Their is a new version for 1.14.4, and it seems to work. You might have some issues with blocking off the bookshelves as it seems to be very particular, so I would suggest using the exact bookshelf setup that is shown in the video.
1 likeThanks man!
0 likesquestion... can we select a higher enchantment level than vanilla minecraft
0 likesReplies (2)
No
0 likes@Earthcomputer ok
0 likesHoly fucking shit this takes enchanting stuff and actually makes it so that it doesn't waste tons of xp.
0 likesdoes this work in 1.17? All im seeing for the drop down menu is up to 16.
0 likesReplies (1)
I did this in 1.18.1 with the mod, works fine
0 likesMy good sir, will this still work on the bedrock version? I'm on the xbox 360
0 likesReplies (2)
No
1 like@Earthcomputer ok, thanks
0 likesso you cant do everything written on the intro item names (the things). but after enchants u can do those things again right?
0 likesReplies (1)
nah you cant ever eat again
0 likesDoes this also work on Bedrock Edition?
1 likeI just found your video and I wonder if this works for 1.15.2?
0 likesReplies (3)
Yes
0 likes@Earthcomputer thank you for your time. I tried it and it doesn't work. I must be doing something wrong. I will keep trying.
0 likes@Zed Quincey theres a version list so, ur probs in another version
0 likes2 quick qs:
1 like1) (Not to be that guy in the comment section of an old technical video but) Does anyone know if this still works in the current 1.16 versions of Minecraft?
2) Would this work on a Multiplayer world where others may be eg. dying, killing mobs, gaining xp etc? Or does it only require the player doing the enchanting to not do those first actions?
Anyway, super cool concept and video, and very well done for making this!!
Replies (1)
No positive but I tried multiple times in 1.16.4 and it didn't work :( in other versions it should work if the activity in the world doesn't involve you i.e. you drop stuff or someone kills you.
1 likeI wonder if this works on 1.13 servers.
0 likesReplies (2)
Should do!
1 like@Earthcomputer Thanks for the info! ☺
0 likesI know that it is meant to work for 1.15.2, but I have no clue how to run it. The readme says to run the batch file in the 'bin' folder, but I don't know where that is. Is it the gradlew.bat file? I'm sorry, I have no idea about any of this stuff, so if it isn't too much trouble, could you tell me how to actually run it properly?
0 likesReplies (2)
It sounds like you downloaded the wrong file, you are supposed to download it from the "releases" page
0 likes@Earthcomputer Yes you're right, I downloaded the wrong one. Thank you :)
0 likesI tried this on vanilla and optifine 1.17.1 and all of the times the cracker either said "No Possible Seeds" or "Fail" anyone know why?
2 likesReplies (4)
it finally worked for me, i tried this in vanilla 1.17.1 afer 5 tries i got it.
0 likesmake sure you dont drop any item during the find seed proces
@Pokedatschu how do u install it?
0 likes@Jonaynay787 link in descripton
0 likes@Pokedatschu I wasn't dropping items
0 likesCan anyone tell me how to download it from the website? Do you need to login or something?
0 likesYo, crazy work done! But it actually didn't work on version 1.18.1 on a multiplayer server. I've tried multiple times, but it still didn't. Can you help me?
0 likesReplies (2)
For me it worked fine, would you please say what you tried to do exactly?
0 likesProb paper server doesnt work on paper servers
0 likesEvery time I put in the info and check it says it found no possible seeds.
1 likeWELL OBVIOUSLY IT IS A POSSIBLE SEED CUZ I GOT IT.
will you be updating it to 1.19? it doesnt work anymore for me since we're in 1.19
1 likehope youll fix it soon!
Hey, does it work in servers?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes, although some Spigot plugins are known to stop it working
0 likesThe 1.4.5 version does not work for me, but the 1.4.4 works, but only in survival. In multiplayer it does not find the right xp seeds. I tested it on my own spigot server. The 1.4.5 error says "Could not serve enough space for object heap". Some help?
0 likesReplies (2)
Have you tried the suggested solutions, including checking you are actually running 64 bit Java?
0 likes@Earthcomputer I tried reinstalling the java but I am not sure if it reinstalled the 64 bit version cause I don't get the option of which one to install I think it should have installed the 64 bit version because the older version worked ok. I wil try some more. And one thing more the oleder version crashed when the first enchantment value was 5 or 6.
0 likesdoes anyone know what the enchantment id is for respiration?
0 likesReplies (3)
It's respiration
0 likesEarthcomputer it doesn’t seem to work for me
0 likesMake sure you are typing in the item it's going on first. Respiration can be applied to helmets and books.
0 likesdoes it work for 1.14?
0 likesThis is the best thing since sliced bread
1 likeDoes this work with multiplayer?
0 likesHow do I make sure the Java is in my PATH
0 likesI am having trouble opening the batch file at the moment and I think that this is probably the problem, but im not very educated on these types of things.
So in theory of any gacha games that also uses similar rng systems wouldn’t it mean any gacaha game can be cracked? :0
0 likesI have my bookshelves stack two high. If I put a torch on the floor does it stop just one shelf?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes, just one in that situation
0 likesThis program does not work on 1.18, I literally tried the process demonstrated in the video perhaps 20 times.
0 likesReplies (2)
Doesnt work on paper servers
0 likesI was testing the program on single player 🤷
0 likesit failed to calculate the player seed 2 times in a row
0 likesthe enchanting seed worked
anyone know what i did wrong?
edit: just realised that its a paper velocity server. i wasted 2 hours nice
Does this work on spigot server 1.14.4?
0 likeswhats the exact list of rng that effects the player?
0 likesReplies (1)
There is a list of things at the beginning of the video, and a few more things in the description
0 likesHow do you add enchants with 2 words like sweeping edge?
0 likesReplies (2)
You use the ID for the enchantment. The ID for sweeping edge is "sweeping", and the ID for luck of the sea (for example) is "luck_of_the_sea". I believe there's a list of the wiki somewhere.
0 likesThere you go. Just make sure you do it without the "minecraft:" prefix.
0 likesIs this now an april fools joke or not? I cant figure it out! So much work...
1 likeReplies (2)
It's real
3 likesnice!
1 likeSo. I can NOT relog during this, but after the process when I am done and I log off, when can I do this again? Or is it just the first login possibility?
0 likesReplies (1)
You can't relog during the process, but you can relog before and after that's okay, and then you can re-crack the seed and do it again if you want.
1 likeAwsome video man! This is fantastic for servers but I have one question. Could this be used for any version? Including console perhaps?
0 likesi try doing this on a server I play on and every time I get both the seeds it eventually just says 'failed', I installed the mod and typed the ccrackrng command and every time I type it, the game spits out a new player seed, not to mention there's no ingame overlay or anything? Could you do a tutorial on the mod?
0 likesI dropped a torch when I finished the process and I didn't mean to so I have to start the process all over again :(
2 likeswhat do i do if there are only 2 enchantments
0 likesYou pointed out that it does not work with paperMC but is it just that or is it any plugin thing that will make it fail?
1 likeAfter I got the player seed When I tried to add enchantment it doesn't work!
1 likedoes this work on 1.18.2 with mods and multiplayer?
0 likesDoesn't appear to work on the PaperSpigot server I play on. I'm positive I'm doing everything right, though. Any ideas?
0 likesReplies (4)
Yes it's most likely a plugin. I tested it on Spigot with no plugins and it worked fine.
1 likeAmeer oh yes beacons affect it, really should have mentioned that! I'll add it to the things I missed in the description.
1 likeI did try turning off all nearby beacons as part of my troubleshooting but I had no luck. I was still getting the "no player seed found" error. I guess it has to be a plugin, then. What sort of plugin would affect this?
0 likesAnything which uses the player RNG would break it.
0 likesYou're a good programmer but not very good at UI/UX, still good job
0 likesReplies (1)
The program from the video was hacked together in a day, the ui ofc looks better by now
1 likeHELLO Dos it work in 1.14.2 and if yes were can i get it?
1 likeReplies (1)
Read the description and try it
0 likesso i tried this on 2 different anarchy servers and i dont know if i did something wrong.
0 likesdoes paper spigot patch this?
Replies (2)
Read the description
0 likes@Earthcomputer oh, ok sorry for disturbing.
0 likesand thanks :)
This might be a stupid question but it works on multiplayer servers as well right?? cuz it would be kinda pointless if it just worked on singleplayer
0 likeswhen i opened enchcracker.bat file it said
0 likeserror occurred during initialization of VM
couldn't reserve enough space for 2097152KB object heap
I'm not sure if its my fault but isn't that too big?
Replies (2)
delete java and install java 64 bit
0 likeshttps://www.java.com/en/download/manual.jsp
go down and click Windows Offline (64-bit) after installing you should be good
@MagikalSkid Thank You it worked for me
0 likesI really need help. I tried this o 1.17.1 Multiplayer (PaperMC) (i was alone at the time), i already go away from my base, not using armor etc, then follow the instruction. i've got the seeds but when i want to calculate, it said "fail!" i tried it for 3 times and it still the same. please help
0 likesReplies (6)
in description u can do in papermc
0 likes@Neko yes ik but it didnt worked
0 likes@Joshua Clavi i want to ask a question.
0 likescan i use those things after enchanting? the things that ur not allowed to in the list
@Neko i think yes you can after enchanting, since if you want more than 1 item u need to do it again right
0 likesYou cant use it if the server is PaperMc
0 likes@Fabiii got any reason tho? I need some to make sure hehe
0 likescan we get an updated tutorial?
2 likesfor multi player can other people do the things or not?
0 likesTurn it to 1.25x speed to get his voice normal and a nice fps
0 likesHow do you install this? Because on Windows 11 the only batch file I get is called gradlew
0 likesI keep getting 00000000 as my first seed dont know what im doing wrong or if I just happen to actually have 000000 for me seed.
0 likesdoes this work for 1.15?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes
0 likeshmmm, might be a bit late. Does it still work, I found this and I NEED to know.
0 likesI have downloaded the program and i do not get any bat file and when i start the file that i think is the bat file i wont open can someone please help me? i have tried to run it as an administrator?
1 likeim gonna need a video tutorial of how to install
0 likesDoes this work for all versions?
0 likesReplies (1)
Assuming Mojang has not changed how player seed manipulation and enchanting works, then I will assume that - Yes, it works across all versions.
0 likescan you pls share that world so we can test it
0 likesAre you making it for 1.14?
0 likesReplies (1)
Have you tried it on 1.14?
0 likesi cant open the enchant cracker, can someone help me out
0 likesdoes it work for 1.15.2?
1 likeReplies (1)
Yes
1 likeDoes this work for bedrock edition?
1 likedoes this work on bedrock edition?
0 likes“Player seed not found” do I have to fill in the force player seed if so what do I put in there
0 likesReplies (2)
I did everything, step by step in the video and I'm having the same problem.. Explanation??
0 likesKyler Curtis I figured it out you also can’t fall remember that
0 likesdoes the tool work on bedrock??
0 likessorry for the late comment but does this work for 1.12?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes
0 likesis it possible to make a bedrock version?
0 likesdo I have to do the process many times if I want to do it on different servers
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes - your seed is dependent on your player state. If you pay close attention to the introduction of the video, he states that LEAVING THE SERVER will change the seed and therefore invalidate the process over multiple servers. You must do the initial step of finding your first two seeds each time you begin the process in a new server.
0 likesDoesn't work on Forge 1.12.2 server. The enchantments are wrong. Following the process from start to finish you get "Player seed not found", but if you take the 2nd seed and make it the 1st seed and then do the process of getting the 2nd seed again then you get the player seed. However, in doing that even though the programs states that after throwing out 52 stacks and 48 items to get diamond sword with smite 5, u3, l3 you get nothing of the kind. Instead I got Sharp 4, L3, U3, KB 2 (and yes I excluded the knockback enchantments). I have attempted SEVERAL times to get the player seed following the instructions to the "T" and get no player seed unless I do what I described above.
0 likesReplies (2)
Okay, you are not following the instructions precisely enough. For a start you forgot to do the initial dummy enchant, and I'm gonna guess if you went for 52 stacks then you probably miscounted (it would probably have been faster to split the enchant list in half and anvil them together)
0 likesAs I stated I did follow it to a "T" to start with and got "Player seed not found". The process I did was: dummy, then did the torch/numbers, got 1st seed, reset, torch/numbers, got second seed, calculate "Player seed not found" (during the whole process I did nothing but what was instructed). And when that didn't work, I used the 2nd seed as the 1st and redid the 2nd seed process to get a new 2nd seed. Then it would give me the player seed. Now unless placing the dummy enchanted items into a chest to get the desired item to be enchanted out causes an issue then I am uncertain what I could have done that would cause it to not give me that player seed as described in the instructions.
0 likesAn absolute legend...
0 likeswhat is the highest version that is available?
0 likeswhen I start the .bat file, it says 'could not reserve 2097152KB object heap'. How can I fix this?
0 likesReplies (2)
Looks like 32bit java
0 likes32bit java cant reserve space above 1,5GB of ram. Oracle often gives you 32bit Java when using default download Button. Download 64bit from "offline" section and you will be fine.
0 likesis this real? i tried 5 times and each time it says "Player seed not found" after inputting the two XP seeds into the player seed calculator.
0 likesReplies (4)
Walmart are you following the method precisely? Every detail matters. Also, you can't use the give command during this process. Just modified the video description to say that.
0 likesI think so. I was initially trying on a spigot server and couldn't get it to work. When I tried in singleplayer it worked. So I'm guessing this doesn't work on spigot servers? or idk.
0 likesWalmart I just tested it on the latest build of Spigot and it worked. But I wouldn't count on it working on Spigot for long.
0 likesI tried it once again on spigot and it worked. I'm sorry for wasting your time because it must've just been random mistakes I made, such as going into creative quickly to grab items, and I think I must've accidentally sprinted a few times. Honestly, I can't thank you enough for making this and for taking the time to reply and try to help me out. You're honestly the best dude.
0 likespls help it says cannot launch enchcracker I have the latest version of java and it is installed correctly and 16gb ram
0 likesWorking 1.13.2 2019/04/20
0 likesDoes this work on servers?
0 likesdoes this work on bedrock edition?
0 likesI am not sure if this actually works in 1.14 or not but I'm pretty sure it doesn't I really hope it does work
0 likesReplies (4)
It should do but not for all items yet till I update the tool
0 likesSo should I use 1.13 version for 1.14
0 likesThe 1.13 version will work for items which have had no changes in terms of enchantments. Note this therefore wont work for books since new enchantments have been added to them. It also wont work for armour at all since there was a change to how the protection enchantments are applied.
0 likes@Six Sugar Gang Interesting. I will have to look into that. When the 1.14 tool is released, it should work :)
0 likesi tried this 48 times and it failed every single one
0 likeswell for some reason it isn't working in a server that has NCP and paper 1.12.2, i've tried and it cant calculate the seed, am I doing something wrong?
0 likesReplies (5)
Paper breaks it
0 likes@Earthcomputer how do I disable it in paper?
0 likes@rogos you can't. Uninstall paper.
0 likes@Earthcomputer rip
0 likes@Earthcomputer can you pick up and throw items like for example it says to throw 6 stacks of stone, i only have 3 stacks and i throw it twice in a row, will it work?
0 likesDoes this work in 1.15.2?
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes
0 likes@Earthcomputer thanks
0 likesDose this work in bedrock edition?
0 likesdoes this work in 1.15.2?
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes
0 likes@Earthcomputer Thank you!
0 likesjust tried in 1.14 and does not work. I can calculate the player seed, but after that it doesnt give me the enchangments i want :|
1 likeReplies (4)
Hi, the tools still needs updating to 1.14, it should work once thats done
4 likes@Earthcomputer THANK YOU MANY PRAISES
0 likes@Earthcomputer ty
0 likes@Earthcomputer hey I saw somone had updated it to 1.14 on guthub, but had not made it a release - do you know how i would go about compiling it?
0 likesWill this work for 1.14?
0 likesReplies (2)
It does
0 likes@Earthcomputer It doesn't
0 likesI susbscribed! :D Nice vid! Will try ASAP.
0 likesfor 1.14.2 it says impossible to calculate? i followed step by step
0 likesalternate title: understanding minecraft enchantment language
0 likes2 times ive tried it now, got both seeds and when I press calculate it says fail, am sad.
0 likesReplies (3)
Are you on a paper server? It doesn't work on paper.
0 likesEarthcomputer No, I’m on single player. Though I am using optifine, I know that is just client side rendering but maybe that changes something?
0 likes@Myles Hallett there are other things which can cause the same problem too. After double-checking the list of banned actions, try using the mod instead https://github.com/Earthcomputer/clientcommands/releases which gives you more detailed information about what went wrong.
0 likesYou have to first enable it by running the command `/ctemprule set enchantingPrediction true`, then there is a built-in enchantment cracker which works the same way as this one.
Also run `/ctemprule set playerRNGMaintenance false` for more error-catching.
The mod requires the Fabric mod loader. Install fabric from https://fabricmc.net/use , you also need Fabric API (install it like any other Fabric mod): https://minecraft.curseforge.com/projects/fabric .
Let me know how it goes.
i open the .bat file in the exact location, but it opens a black window and closes immediatley. :(
0 likesRelease 1.1.4 on vanilla Minecraft 1.12.2 server is not working whatsoever. Have attempted three times, each time found a player seed, but none of the seed gave the correct enchantment. My attempt at Eff IV / Unb III / Silk pick rolled Fortune II instead of Silk, my attempt at Eff IV / Unb III / Silk shovel resulted in Fortune III / Unb III, and my book attempt for Eff IV gave Feather Falling IV.
2 likesI even unbound my forward move and sprint keys to and only moved using A/S/D to prevent mistakes. The only things I did throughout the process were breaking and removing torches and inserting/removing items from chests.
Replies (2)
It is working. You must be doing something wrong. Beacons are something that usually catch people out.
0 likesDon't have a beacon placed. I'll attempt it again and record it just to be sure.
0 likesdoes this work on MC 1.15.2?
0 likesReplies (4)
Yes
1 likeEarthcomputer Hi ;) thanks ;) And do you know if it also works on Server (vanilla, Self-hosted on a pc from a College)?
0 likes@Jaime Taboada yep
0 likes@Earthcomputer Nice :) Thanks - I will try to do it this afternoon :=)
0 likesDoes it work on bedrock edition?
0 likesDoes this work with Bukkit? I tried and it didn't work. It kept saying "Fail!". I tried the client commands mod and it still didn't work. It said the server is modded.
0 likesReplies (1)
It's purely vanilla, but it has a VanillaTweaks Datapack
0 likesI tried to do this multiple times but the same error message occurred over and over again “player seed not found” please help me
0 likesHmm. It doesn't seem to work for me. Does it work in 1.18.1? Maybe that's the problem?
0 likesReplies (1)
Doesnt work on paper servers
0 likesError: Could not find or load main class enchcracker.EnchCrackerWindow what does that mean?
0 likesReplies (6)
Are you using this on Windows? Do you have the Java installed or up-to-date?
0 likes@FilliamPL yeah to both
0 likes@Kalamari Are you launching the correct file?
0 likes@FilliamPL yes the one that he opened in the video
0 likes@Kalamari Are you using a 64bit version of Java or 32bit?
0 likes@FilliamPL 64 bit java
0 likesDoes the most recent version work with 1.17.1
1 likeDoes this work for 1.14+?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes
0 likesDoesn't work on minecraft Realm servers, tried it several times.
2 likesReplies (1)
worked for me
0 likes@earthcomputer please help when i get the two seeds it tells me fail what do i do i tried it twice
0 likesReplies (4)
I tried 8 times on 1.16.1 and it does not work for me. I even tried removing all mods.
0 likes@Naburi its only updated to 1.16 just wait until its updated :V
0 likes@Oak I must be doing something wrong because i tried to do it on a new map in 1.15.2 without mods, no resource packs, both using torches and using a silk touch axe to remove bookshelves, and the same issue. It HAS to work on this version because there's another youtuber that i have seen him using this on 1.15.2 and it worked for him.
0 likes@Naburi well not sure then
0 likesCompiled the source code for mc version 1.14 and ran it on my vanilla realm. Seems like it doesn't give the correct enchants afterwards. Still working on updating for 1.14 or am I the dummy?
0 likesPlease make an updated version because i am confused
0 likesAny word if this is current? I've had it work a couple times but doesnt seem to be consistent
0 likesReplies (1)
It should work still. I haven't tested in the latest snapshot but it worked in the early 1.14 snapshots
0 likesidk if someone will answer but does this still work?
2 likesI just did both seeds and it didn't work, just realised it doesn't work on paper :(
0 likes@earthcomputer do your seedcracker work for MC 1.16+ Java? It keep saying error when Mr playing multiplayer
2 likesDoes it work in 1.15?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes
0 likesI have no clue where to go when I reach the files, What do i do?
0 likesReplies (2)
There are instructions in the readme
0 likes@Earthcomputer Aight so after reading it, I found my mistake. So I found the batch file and all that, but now when I use the enchcracker batch file, it opens for half a second with an error message and then closes its self...
0 likesThe program won"t open on my computer. When I try to start it it says "javaw" cannot be found.
0 likesReplies (2)
You need to install Java
1 likeYou need to install java. If I get it right, the official launcher is “kinda” having its own java so you can play minecraft without java installed. But other programs still believe your computer haven’t installed it.
1 likeit says "JAVA_HOME IS NOT SET AND NO 'java' command could be found in your PATH
0 likesit works 👍👍but i havent tried on 1.17.1 i tried on 1.12.2
1 likeDoes this work on vanilla servers?
0 likesdoes it work on servers?
0 likeshi, i downloaded all the assets but could not open the program for some reason. could you help me in this situation? thanks
0 likesDoes this work on bedrock edition?
0 likesReplies (1)
No
0 likesim having a problem with it crashing at 1052000000 seeds searched, it does it every time
0 likesReplies (2)
Zakk Stoops try allocating more RAM to the program. If this doesn't work, create a bug report on the GitHub page, including the log file.
1 likeI needed to upgrade to java x64 that resolved the problem but thank you for the reply
1 likeWill this work on bedrock?
0 likesDo i habe to sign up on the plattform to download this? If not, then i still need help because im too stupid to find out how to downliad the codebreaker.
0 likesDoes this work in 1.16
0 likesDoes it work on multiplayer?
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes
0 likesOk thx
0 likesDoes this work on 1.17.1?
0 likesdoes this work in 1.17.1?
0 likestbf id rather do this process than constantly re roll the table to get the enchants
0 likesdoes this thing work on 1.16?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes
0 likes@Earthcomputer
1 likeCan u tell how to do this for fishing mending books??
Replies (1)
Search fishing rng manip on youtube he maid a different video about this
0 likesDoes this work still?
0 likeswhenever I try to open the enchant cracker it says Error: Unable to access jarfile enchcracker.jar
0 likesReplies (6)
Exterrata download the latest version and it should be fixed.
0 likesredownloaded it and still says that I think it because of the security stuff.
0 likesand it will open if I click open outside on enchcracker.jar but none of the buttons will work.
0 likesExterrata you shouldn't have to, but try running the batch file as administrator and let me know if that makes a difference.
0 likeshow do I do that
0 likesRight click on it and press run as administrator
0 likesCan you link me a video for the bin?
0 likesReplies (1)
??
0 likesIs this holding up in 1.16?
1 likeReplies (1)
It does not seem to work for me on 1.16.1
0 likesDoes this work on bedrock?
0 likesReplies (1)
No
1 likeDoes this still work?
0 likeshow do you install it?
0 likesHello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
0 likesBut i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
Hello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
0 likesBut i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
Hello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
0 likesBut i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
Hello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
0 likesBut i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
Hello , This is incredibly cool , amazing.
0 likesBut i seem to perfectly get it to work on singleplayer , but i can't make it in an anarchy online server (it says 'Fail' after i combie the 2 seeds) , I don't know if it's spigot or any other things like bungeecord or else. Please , can you help?
Why it's not calculating the player seed on 1.14.2 version???
0 likesWhat do i write for force player seed?
1 likeReplies (4)
You are using an old version of the tool, please use the latest version.
0 likes@Earthcomputer oh its because im playing ön 1.12.2 forgot to mention that
0 likes@Szilárd Novák the latest tool has a version dropdown, so use the latest tool and select 1.12 from the dropdown.
0 likes@Earthcomputer oh right, i didn't know that. só in the latest version u van choose which Minecraft version u are ön?
0 likesEdit: I re read the sentence and it got tó my Brain ők ty for the Quick reply
gets stuck on 2 possible seeds whats the fix
0 likes?
Replies (1)
This is a rare situation that's possible, you just have to start again. It shouldn't happen often.
0 likesDOES THIS WORK IN 1.16.4???
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes
0 likesIs it the same on bedrock edition
0 likesDoes this work on servers?
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes, except paper servers
0 likes@Earthcomputer Is thee a possible workaround on paper servers?
0 likesit didnt work in 1.13.2 D: ive been sitting here for two hours trying to do it but no it wont work
0 likesReplies (1)
Then chances are you're not following the instructions closely enough. One tiny mistake and the whole thing stops working.
0 likesWill it work in a multiplayer server where I’m not opped or anything
0 likesReplies (2)
Revanroles gaming yes it should do
0 likesHey,so I just tested it and it stopped at 4278000000
0 likesYou making working on making this for 1.14?
0 likesDoes this still work in 1.15.x?
2 likesReplies (3)
Yes
2 likes@Earthcomputer Just want to comment that the Encracker works flawless.
3 likesGreat job!
Earthcomputer might want to pin this
1 likeWoah!!! It's still working on 1.17.1!!! Like & sub for that!
1 likeReplies (1)
how do u open n run it?
0 likesI don't think this works with Bedrock, does it?
1 likeReplies (1)
no it wont
0 likesI tried running the batch file but was greeted with
1 like"Error occurred during initialization of VM
Could not reserve enough space for 2097152KB object heap
Failed to launch enchcracker!
1. Ensure you have installed Java correctly and that Java is in your PATH.
2. 64-bit Java is recommended for enchcracker.
3. 2GB of RAM is a minimum requirement. enchcracker will fail to start if you don't have more than 2GB of RAM to spare.
4. If you still think this is an error, please report it to https://github.com/Earthcomputer/EnchantmentCracker/issues
Press any key to continue . . ."
I have no idea what to do to resolve this
I have 16GB of ram so I don't know how to allocate more to this thing.
Anyone have a solution for my sorry soul?
Replies (3)
I also had Problems a the start but unfortunatly I cant remember my Error-Code :/
1 likeTry this:
For Step 1 that is recomended with the path I would recommend: https://www.codejava.net/java-core/how-to-set-java-home-environment-variable-on-windows-10
And although I thought I had Java installed through Minecraft already I somehow hadn`t! I downloaded it here: https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/jdk13-downloads-5672538.html (only try the first link after having installed Java)
I dont know what System you have but I have Windows 10:
0 likesI also had Problems with it at the start but unfortunatly I cant remember my Error-Code :/
Try this:
The first recommended step is About the path. Here I would recommend this for instructions:
https://www.codejava.net/java-core/how-to-set-java-home-environment-variable-on-windows-10
But before you do all that make sure you have installed Java. I thought I had it through Minecraft already but I couldnt find the actual Program Java so I downloaded it here:
https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/jdk13-downloads-5672538.html (you just have accept the Licence in the box and you can immeadiatly
Sorry About doubling the comment! :D It wasnt showing the first and I angrily wrote it again :/
0 likesthe second one is better understandable so just ignore the first one :)
How do you download this machine??
0 likesIt says no possible seed? I checked it twice
0 likesI can't get fire aspect on the list
0 likesWish this work in bedrock sigh 😔
0 likesMojang's gonna change this now and make it no longer work.
0 likesReplies (2)
Exterrata if they do, it'll most likely be by accident!
2 likes@Earthcomputer ;D
0 likesi have both the seeds but it shows that it failed
0 likesthis still works in 1.17?
0 likeswhat is xp seed ??
0 likesbecause he's earthcomputer, of course he'd destroy the enchanting mechanics
0 likesI've tried and tried, but I can't open it on my mac. I don't have windows, so is there a way to open it?
0 likesReplies (9)
Jet_Mouse do the instructions in the readme work for macs? I don't have a Mac so haven't been able to test it.
0 likesOops. I don't know.
0 likesWhat instructions?
0 likesJet_Mouse open the file named README.txt
0 likesGot it! Thanks!
0 likesI put it in terminal, and it said no such file or directory
0 likesJet_Mouse have you navigated to the enchcracker folder in terminal?
0 likesa website that does it would be great. Do you think you could just make a website that does the calculations? Thanks!
0 likesI would, but that requires money which I unfortunately don't have. What error message do you get if you run the shell script?
0 likesThis still work in 1.16????
0 likesHas ANYONE actually gotten this to work? in MP, SP, anywhere? No matter how much I follow these steps, it never works for me
1 likeReplies (3)
@Jacob Pratt Ye it doesn't work for me in 1.17 too
1 likeKinda obvious tho as the program hasn't been updated to this version
0 likesAnd I haven't lost hope since he was very fast with updating to 1.16 and 1.16.5
0 likesThis is mindblowing
0 likesDoes it have to be on PC and what do I do after I click the link
0 likesReplies (3)
Yes it has to be on PC, and there are instructions in the README
0 likesOk thank u
0 likesIt will not work it only shows me the code and not to where I can input the stoff in
0 likesDoes this work in bedrock?
0 likesReplies (1)
No
0 likesdoes this work in 1.8
0 likesReplies (1)
No
0 likesThis is really cool
0 likesCan anyone tell me if this works in multiplayer servers if you're not near any player
0 likesDose it work to 1.15.2 ?
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes
0 likes@Earthcomputer i have a problem when i do the 14 its write me nopossible seed
0 likesGonna use it in my friend's SMP 😏😏😏😏
0 likesray uploads basically this on april 1st...
1 likethis video is uploaded on 28nd...
pinned comment shows as "1 month ago"
therefore I have deducted it to be a quadruple troll, if not a triple one...
Replies (1)
jan harald it was unlisted until the 28th
0 likesWhy does it show me an error when I try opening " enchcracker.bat " ?
0 likesThe error says: " Error: Could not find or load main class enchcracker.EnchCrackerWindow
Failed to launch enchcracker! "
Does this works on 1.16+ ?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes
0 likesplease make a vid on how to download this when i tries it didnt seem it work
0 likesDoes this work in every Version?
1 likeReplies (2)
From 1.8+, yes
1 likeEarthcomputer Oh Nice! Glad u answered so quickly
0 likesDoes This work on the minecraft pocket edition the bedrock version?
0 likesReplies (1)
no
0 likes@Earthcomputer when i try to open the jar file for the application to get the seeds it doesnt open what do i do
0 likesReplies (3)
Well you actually have to open the enchcracker.bat file
0 likes@LUKAS tysmm
0 likes@LUKAS it command prompt it says Could not find or load main class enchcracker.EnchCrackerWindow
0 likesDoes this still work?
0 likesIs this only works on 1.12?
0 likesDoesnt work for me on spigot 1.12.2 server
0 likesyo @Earthcomputer when will u update this to 1.17.1 ?
0 likesDoes it work on bedrock?
2 likesReplies (5)
No, not much is known about the Bedrock code unfortunately so not a lot of things like this work on Bedrock.
5 likesI would use java but for some reason it crashes every time I try to play
0 likesOkko Heiniö Is your java 64 bit and updated?
0 likesOkko Heiniö Did you tried troubleshooting? Everytime minecraft crashes, it makes a log file, if you open that text file at the top there is error code. You can search that code on the internet to aid your problem
0 likesYalkın ÇIRAK well I repaired it with the minecraft installer, but it didn't work. Also I can still sometimes load a world in it but it is very unstable. I can open the client but it freezes when I actually start playing. Tried changing the directory, the update, the profile (my snapshot profile won't even open) I'm not sure about the java update but I have alvays played minecraft with that version.
1 likeOh I miss playing with java. There is so many important features to move to the bedrock version. The Json nbt you put in commands is so weird it says I'm missing a bracket when I'm not, and the whole scoreboard command is missing.
doing this feels like belnder camera tracking
0 likesErm Hey EarthComputer... So I Tried the method on 1.18.1... Whenever i try to get player seed after getting 2 xp seeds, it always fails... I tried multiple times but still it fails
0 likesPlease tell a fix...
Replies (10)
maybe enchantment mechanic slightly changed in 1.18 or 1.18.1
0 likes@Crafterz_ Thnx for the reply but it wasnt working because i was trying it in a paper server
0 likes@GargAmogh i played on paper server too. I thought it didn’t work because a version :)
0 likesdid you do anything that resets xp seed
0 likes@ItsFrostyKun No...
0 likesI followed the tutorial exactly
@GargAmogh did you sprint
0 likes@ItsFrostyKun nope
0 likes@GargAmogh try asking in discord
0 likes@ItsFrostyKun Thanks for the suggestion but I believe its not working because it is a Paper server...
0 likesI tried on a singleplayer world and it worked flawlessly
0 likesi have tried about 6 times from the start on different worlds but it didnt work :(
1 likeReplies (3)
same
1 likeit finally worked for me, i tried this in vanilla 1.17.1 afer 5 tries i got it.
0 likesmake sure you dont drop any item during the find seed proces
@Pokedatschu i didnt drop any items
0 likesi didnt collect any xp
i didnt kill any mobs
i didnt sprint
i didnt eat
and still it didnt work
when I try to run the program it triggers my antivirus
0 likesReplies (1)
then disable it
0 likesdos this work in 1.18 ?
0 likesIs it working multiplayer?
1 likehow do i install this, i have to open it with a specific app and IDK what that app is
0 likesReplies (1)
I would recommend using the mod, not the tool since it does most of what you need to do automatically and says if you accidentally broke the rng manipulation
0 likesIt works for every minecraft version?
0 likesum how do u open that enchantment cracker thing, i downloaded it and put it in mod folder, then what... @earthcomputer
0 likesthis works on multiplayer?
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes
0 likesYes, for the most part.
0 likesThere are some plugins that break it, though
The program doesn't work :/
1 likeWhen I click calculate it just says "Fail!"
0 likesReplies (1)
Do you have two seeds? Did you do anything that invalids the process (as explained in the beginning of the video)?
0 likes@Earthcomputer i have a problem when i do this it write me nopossible seed
0 likesuhhh I know this is a little late (ok, very late) but does this work for 1.17.1? and also how do I open the enchcracker window, I can't find it in the download file.
0 likesReplies (11)
Extract the .zip then open enchcracker.bat
0 likes@PZ11 It's supposed to be called "enchcracker-1.5.1"
0 likes@PZ11 And yes, it works 1.17.1
0 likes@PZ11 You downloaded the source code.
0 likes@Pedro270707 But I went to the place that says Enchantment cracking tool download? In the description?
0 likes@Pedro270707 Wait I see what I did wrong ok I found it I opened the Windows Batch file in the bin folder now it has command prompt open do I wait or...
0 likes@PZ11 Just wait and it'll open, unless you didn't extract it
0 likes@Pedro270707 Wait sorry one last thing, you said it works on 1.17 but there is no option for 1.17 on the enchant cracker thing, when im inputting the enchantments i want and don't want. So are you sure? and if so, do I just select 1.16?
0 likes@PZ11 i have not tried yet but i think you just have to use the newest version and it will work for 1.17
0 likesps also tell me if you try and tell me if it works
@Eggy Yea I tried it works for 1.17 just select the 1.16 option
0 likes@PZ11 Choose 1.16.5, works for 1.17 too
0 likesdoes this work on 1.17?
0 likesReplies (1)
yes
0 likescan I use this on mac?
0 likesDoes this work on smp
0 likesdoes this work on servers or only single player
0 likesReplies (4)
Works on servers, but some Spigot plugins and mods are known to break it.
1 likelooks like I just did something wrong the first few go arounds, I got a player seed this time
0 likesdo you have discord
Yes it's Earthcomputer#9825
0 likesI added you
0 likesDoes it work in bedrock??
0 likesReplies (1)
No
0 likesDoes this work on 1.17.1?
0 likesReplies (1)
yes, and theres a new one for 1.18
0 likesHow do I get the software... I tried to download it but it wouldn’t run
0 likesReplies (3)
You need to run the .bat file
0 likes@ThaumicTom the .bat just closes instantly without doing anything
0 likesnevermind, fixed a separate issue and it works now
0 likesDoes it work on 1.18 paper?
0 likesReplies (1)
Nope
0 likesi keep on getting the unable to access jarfile error any help?
0 likesReplies (1)
Make sure you have the Java developement kit installed.
0 likesaND IF THAT DOESNT WORK, install jarfix.
how do i use the app?
0 likesnice job
0 likesCan it go for books 2?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yisrael Pinto yes, except you have to pay closer attention to the exact amount of bookshelves it asks you to block/keep visible.
0 likesit doesnt work on singleplayer 1.18.1 for me
0 likesDoes it work on spigot servers?
0 likesReplies (1)
IIRC, no it does not
0 likesPretty cool man.
0 likesdoes it still work?
0 likesReplies (1)
Yes
0 likesDoes this work on 1.16.2? This vid was bring out 3 years ago and i just see it now (my english is bad so sorry if u cant understand what am i saying)
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes
0 likes@Pedro270707 i tried 4 times. It crash 3 times and the 4 th try doesnt worj
0 likesI’m guessing this doesn’t work on bedrock
0 likesReplies (1)
I've tried it a few times on bedrock, not sure if it's because it doesn't have support for 1.18 (maybe it does on Java), or because Java has enchantments not included in bedrock like sweeping edge which I would assume would affect the seeds/what's possible. Nevertheless It has yet to work for me on Bedrock 1.18.1
0 likesWorks in 1.13.1?
0 likesReplies (1)
Should do, yes
0 likesI couldn't get it to work on 1.18.2
2 likesIt's broken! No possible seeds!
0 likesReplies (1)
yeah... thats because youre probably not playing on 1.14-1.14.2
1 likeit works with mods?
0 likesdoes this work for modded minecraft 1.12.2
0 likesWill it work on Bedrock?
0 likesdid i have to install every file?
0 likesWhat is the forced player seed
0 likesReplies (1)
A text field you can leave blank
0 likesthis is to complicated, is there easier way? or minecraft hacked client mod that does that automaticly?
0 likesmod will be the best (or hack mod becauze mod that will give you op enchants in second will be little like a hack), it will be game breaking on anarchy! :)
is it on bedrock?
0 likeswhen I try to open it it brings me to a notepad with weird numbers and symbols
0 likesReplies (1)
I think you tried to open it with an editor, I reccomend using the mod, it has a lot of fun features
0 likesthats insane
0 likesis there a linux vertion which is not the mod? cuz the mod dosent work for me...
0 likesIt failed to calculate the seed.
0 likesDoes it work for bedrock?
0 likesReplies (1)
no
0 likesDoes it work in 1.16
0 likesdoes it work in 1.17?
0 likesReplies (1)
yes
0 likeswill this work in 1.16.4??
0 likesReplies (4)
It was recorded in 1.16.4
0 likes@Earthcomputer eyyy thx
0 likes@Earthcomputer ok nvm visible confusion this vid was uploaded 3 years ago
0 likesso will it work?
@The Moosh Yes it does still work in the most current MC build.
0 likesdoes it work on multiplayer
0 likesReplies (5)
Yes
0 likes@Earthcomputer okay yes and how do I add blast protection
0 likes@rogos The same way as adding any other enchantment
0 likes@Earthcomputer it's showing red things
0 likes@rogos the id of blast protection is blast_protection and you need an applicable item such as iron_chestplate
0 likesDoes this work on servers?
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes from 1.8-1.18, Good travels friend
0 likes@Jed Jed ok
0 likeshow do i use the file
0 likesThe java thing doesn’t work
0 likesDoes this work 1.17
0 likesso does this work on spigot?
0 likesReplies (2)
It did back when I tested it. Dunno if they fixed it
1 like@Earthcomputer thank you so much for the quick reply! i saw on the 1.13 video that you could get unbreaking with this as well? how do you do that and does it work on 1.12.2
0 likesdosent work and I have cheked ,I have 16 gigabyte ram ,I have 64 bit java, I dont understand what to do?
0 likesargh. hasnt been working for me. dont know what it is that i'm messing up
0 likesAnything that is random shouldn't be done in the process.
0 likesWhen I press the add info button it doesn't do anything, what am I doing wrong?
0 likesReplies (6)
Lx35z what's your OS and Java version? Are you using 64 bit Java?
0 likesi am using Windows, and i believe im using 64 java but im not sure, how can i check?
0 likesLx35z open the command prompt, and type `java -version`
0 likesIt just gives me the version doesnt tell if its 64 or 32, however i just searched it on google how to do it, i have 32 bit java
0 likesYou need to update your Java to 64 bit. So many people are having the same problem that I think I'll add it to the description.
1 likeok, thanks for replying so quickly
0 likesnot working for anyone else in 1.12.2?
0 likesReplies (1)
You're doing something wrong then. In this video he is using 1.12.2
0 likesThis guy’s brain has gigantamaxed.
1 likeIs it my connection, or is the video really laggy?
0 likesReplies (1)
See pinned message.
0 likesDoes this work on bedrock minecraft?
0 likesAnd if it shows 00000000 seed so?
0 likesMy program wont combine the 2 seeds
0 likesReplies (7)
Are you on a paper server? It doesn't work on paper.
0 likes@Earthcomputer no I think its cuz I picked up a torch in the process
0 likes@Earthcomputer ty for this
0 likes@Parmeet Gill picking up items is allowed, it must have been something else, like sprinting or accidentally throwing out an item
1 like@Earthcomputer probably, but can it be because I am on a spigot server?
0 likes@Parmeet Gill It's possible, it depends on the plugins. It doesn't work on paper as I said. I'd double check the list of banned actions, including those in the video description, to make sure you're not doing any of them
1 like@Earthcomputer thank you so much! I recently just lost all of my good tools and armor, so this will help alot
0 likesdoes this work for Minecraft: Xbox One Edition
0 likesReplies (1)
RagexPrince 683 No else than java
1 likeDoes this also work on 1.19?????
1 likeReplies (6)
Yes, just make sure you look at the Minecraft wiki article on how to count bookshelves because it's different than in the video.
1 likethank u ur lifesaving
0 likeswait
0 likes1 Other question
0 likesCan u plz say if i can break and place blocks while during the concept or do i dont
0 likes@DaddyToasti Yes you can
1 likeIt keeps going down to 2 seeds after all of the enchantment combos are tried, anyway to prevent this?
0 likesReplies (1)
MrSolarWaffle It happens rarely, try again
0 likesi dont think this works on 1.15.1
0 likesReplies (3)
It does!
0 likes@Earthcomputer I tried and it gives me the right enchantments but not all of them and at different levels
0 likes@Earthcomputer nevermind i didn't follow the steps correctly
0 likesits not working for me on 1.17.1 and i dont understand why is there anything i coud be doing wrong
0 likesReplies (2)
How did you try this? With the mod or with the tool? Single player or Multyplayer? What enchantments did you try to get?
0 likesDoesnt work on paper servers
0 likes1.15 compatible?
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes
1 like@Earthcomputer Thanks man
0 likesdoes this work for minecraft bedrock edition?
0 likesReplies (2)
no
1 like@BLOOD_MOON_1 ty
0 likesdoes it work on bedrock edtion
0 likesReplies (2)
No
0 likes@Earthcomputer Thank you :} good night from NJ!
0 likesdoes this work on bedrock
0 likesReplies (1)
No, Bedrock has a different system than java on almost everything.
0 likeswhat were you doing with ENIGMA? i saw it on desktop....
0 likesworks on Servers?
0 likesReplies (2)
Walter Prz yes
0 likesHowever, there are some plugins that break it
0 likesWhy is that program not open source?
0 likesReplies (1)
fdagpigj E mostly because most of the code was either generated by a Gui tool or copy-pasted from either the reference implementation or my open-source stronghold finder (for the enchantments themselves). Just thought the code would be too messy to open-source :)
0 likeswell i followed all the steps but didn't get it
0 likesI love it!!!
0 likesDoes this still work?
0 likesReplies (1)
yes
0 likesdoesnt work on 16.3 right?
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes it does
0 likes@Earthcomputer hmm ok I didn’t get the right enchantments. Probably a fault on my side
0 likesdoesnt work in 1.16.4
0 likesReplies (1)
It works in the most current version. You did something wrong either: by accidentally manipulating your seed, entering the incorrect numbers, or doing a step incorrectly/out of order.
0 likeswould this work these days
1 likewhy is there no mending in the program
0 likesor thorns 3
Replies (2)
Because you cannot get mending or thorns 3 in an enchanting table
0 likes@Earthcomputer thanks i didn't know that
0 likesLmao I just got banned for doing this from server.
0 likesReplies (1)
WOW i say WOW coz its just a u being big brain and they being tiny brain! they just jelly
0 likesi cant manage toh get the player seed it always keep saying Fail
1 likeReplies (1)
same i found the two different seeds but it still fails
0 likesIs this 1.16.3 working
0 likesReplies (2)
1.16.2 is
0 likes@solid i dont get it i've tried all i could in 1.16.3 on a SMP server and it wont work it only goes "Fail!"
1 likeso uhh, i dont know how to open the file, can u tell me or something
0 likesCan mobs be near by
0 likesWill this work on my dads $50 walmart computer
0 likesReplies (1)
if it has jave then it should work fine
0 likesit suddenly stopped working for me and I don't know why...
0 likesWhich protein is that at 27 minutes?
0 likesnot working in 1.11 right?
0 likesplayer seed not found
Replies (3)
1.12 - 1.12.2
0 likesWorks all the way back to
0 likesBeta 1.8Release 1.0 I'm pretty sure. You must be doing something wrong.The tool shouldn't fully work before 1.11.1, when sweeping edge was added. The concept however should work back to 1.8, if someone were to write a tool for that version.
2 likesWhen trying to get the player seed on my friends minehut server it says fail. why doesn't this work? and is there any fix?
0 likesEarthcomputer that was great but i have an issue
0 likesi can't open the program plssss help me with it
Does it work on 1.8? I guess it doesn't because there are less enchantments available.
1 likeReplies (1)
Егор Гомон the tool would need to be modified to work for 1.8, but the theory still applies
0 likesIt doesn't work anymore on 1.16.3 minecraft
0 likesReplies (2)
Yes it does
0 likes@Earthcomputer I see, maybe I did something wrong in the vid. Ill try again. Thanks for the great VID
1 likeit says i dont have java in my PATH
0 likesi put in 11 instead of 9
0 likesdo i have to start with 15 book shelves only
1 likenot more than that
because i am a larger enchantment roon with about 120 bookshelves which are 3 blocks high
Replies (2)
Wat
0 likesYou only need 15 to max it out
0 likesFor some reason it wont work. Can anyone help me with this problem?
0 likesReplies (2)
What is happening when you say it doesn't work?
0 likes@Earthcomputer Oh sorry, forgot to say I fixed it. But still thanks for the fast reply.
0 likesDoes this still work?
0 likesReplies (8)
Yes
0 likes@Earthcomputer Weird because when i press "Calculate" when i got two XP seeds it just says "Player seed not found"
0 likesEDIT:The Player Seed worked but im not getting the right enchantments anyhow
@Earthcomputer What do i have to write on force player seed? It says player seed not found
0 likes@GregFRDT you leave it blank
1 likeUnfortunately the message "player seed not found" could be caused by so many things that I can't really tell you what's going on other than to follow the instructions more closely.
1 like@Earthcomputer It finds the 2 xp seeds but i keep seeing "player seed not found"
0 likesDunno, mabye godmode or fly is interfering?
@GregFRDT some Spigot plugins are known to interfere with it yes
1 like@Earthcomputer After 3 aptempts or didn't worked, i will try it later in a single player server, thanks for the help anyway!
0 likesit keeps saying no possible seed
0 likesMine just wont add the Info I put in😕 any one Who can help
1 likeReplies (8)
blockycubing what's your OS/computer specs? This seems to be happening to a few people and the more information I have to fix it the better.
1 likeEarthcomputer not much of an expert but if it is what you meant: I use windows
1 likeShift-right-click inside the enchcracker folder, select "Open Command Window Here" or "Open PowerShell Window Here". Then type "java -jar enchcracker.jar" and hit enter. That way we should get an error message so I know better what's going on.
1 likeEarthcomputer It says 1 cant load AMD 64-bit.d11 on a IA 32-bit platform
1 likeI think this might be a problemen?
1 likeblockycubing yes, make sure you are running a 64-bit version of Java.
1 likeEarthcomputer il try that, thanks!
1 likeThanks I Got it to work! !
1 likeToday I will stop, I will not say: How'z here cuz rays works" no, they don't deserve those types of comments
0 likesReplies (1)
Msg by: Theodd1sOut
1 likeEarthcomputer is this works on console edition?
0 likesReplies (1)
Probably not, I think it only works for JE, sorry.
0 likesWow!
0 likesWill it work in 1.18.1
0 likesReplies (2)
unfortunately no, i had to learn the hard way :'(
0 likesYes but not on paper servers and there also is now a more user friendly version of the programm
0 likesIs there a possibility of applying this to the bedrock version?
1 likeReplies (1)
Quite a bit more research is needed until that's possible.
1 likecan you help me i cant download it?
0 likesDoes it still work in 2022??
0 likesThe best!
0 likesim useing 1.16.5
0 likesI cannot install the cracker because when i run the file command prompt said Error: Could not find or load main class enchcracker.EnchCrackerWindow
0 likesFailed to launch enchcracker!
1. Ensure you have installed Java correctly and that Java is in your PATH.
2. 64-bit Java is REQUIRED for enchcracker. This catches a lot of people out. To check your Java version, run "java -version".
3. 2GB of RAM is a minimum requirement. enchcracker will fail to start if you don't have more than 2GB of RAM to spare.
4. If you still think this is an error, please report it to https://github.com/Earthcomputer/EnchantmentCracker/issues
Press any key to continue . . .
Terminate batch job (Y/N)?
Replies (1)
...Did you look at all 4 steps and confirm that you pass all the requirements?
0 likesdont work on 1.15.2
0 likesbtw it showed me that video dsy after that was posted 2 years ago
Replies (9)
Yes it does work on 1.15.2
0 likes@Earthcomputer when i connect two xp seed to get player seed it said failed. i tried on 1.14.4 and on 1.14.4 works with no problems. Maybe i do something wrong, gonna try again and if it say failed again i will comment that
0 likes@Earthcomputer i tested that again. of course i didnt sprint log out etc and it said failed again.
0 likeson 1.14.4 work fine but im playing on 1.15.2
@SkyZiPlay are you on a papermc server? It doesn't work on papermc. If you try on 1.15.2 singleplayer or a vanilla 1.15.2 server then it works.
0 likes@Earthcomputer tried on singleplayer and even checked on spigot and dont work
0 likes@SkyZiPlay well you've done something wrong because it works for me.
0 likes@Earthcomputer i downloaded from github latest version
0 likes@SkyZiPlay u might have to change the version... theres version list
0 likes@Oak im not using it btw
0 likesdoes it work in 1.17
0 likesReplies (1)
yes
0 likesServer works?
0 likesfollowed to the T several times on 1.12.2 vanilla. never worked.
0 likesReplies (3)
That's because it's 1.13+
0 likesIf you don't like that, make one for pre-1.13 yourself
@Jovan04 but hes using 1.12.2 in this video
1 likethere is a version list so u could be using wrong version :V
0 likesthat so cool
0 likessorry for being a pain in the arse, trying to do this trick on an anarchy server now. got all the items prepared but the problem is when i click on the executable jar file it does nothing, doesnt even start the program, do i need any additional software for it to work?
0 likesReplies (3)
i use version 1.4.1 for 1.12
0 likesUse the latest version, it supports many Minecraft versions
0 likes@Earthcomputer tyvm
0 likes“No dummy” please help me!
0 likesReplies (2)
I explained in the video what to do in this case
0 likesSorry then, I guess I missed it
0 likesWill u upload an update vedio for 1.18??
1 likeworks with mending books? @Earthcomputer
0 likesReplies (2)
1. By using @ he won't see your comment
2 likes2. Mending books can't be obtained from enchanting
Me i
0 likesNdinf is a
Tesuere dnchenmtnet
who is force player seed
1 likeDoes it work now?
0 likesReplies (1)
yes
0 likesamazing but , it doen't work on server
0 likesReplies (2)
For me it did (1.18.1), are you sure you didn't miss a little step?
0 likesDoesnt work on paper servers
0 likeswhy i cant open the app?
0 likesIt won't let me download it or I'm doing it wrong
0 likesReplies (1)
Are you using the instructions in the readme?
0 likesEarth computer why when i disable all the book shelfs im at zero book shelfs and it puts 2 seeds
0 likesReplies (3)
Update: I got both seeds but when i click combined it says fail bug or fix.
0 likesPlugins:OpenInventory,SimpleTpa,AcceptRules,Geyser-Spigot,ServerListPlus,MobHealthBars,ImageOnMap,LoginSecurity,BedrockPlayerManager
And the server i play on with my friends is on java but the owner wants bedrock people to join
0 likesYou cannot determine the seed with only 2 of the 3 numbers in the enchanting table. The only way it will work is if the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd enchantment numbers are provided.
0 likesEarthcomputer the cracker wont open when i open it
0 likeswhat does fail! mean
0 likesWhy dont it work on paper
0 likesReplies (1)
Because all entities share the same RNG. You may as well give up.
0 likesEarthcomputer Works in a System of Windows x32??
0 likesReplies (2)
Kubrad Lithjer if you mean 32-bit Windows, then unfortunately not sorry. You will either need to use a 64-bit machine or wait till I get round to making a Java implementation of the XP seed finding.
0 likesOk, thanks.
0 likesdidnt worked on optifine 1.18 gonna try on default ver later
0 likesReplies (2)
Did you have success on vanilla?
0 likes@Herobrine nah i gave up
0 likesSo cool
0 likesadd turtle_helmet please
1 likeReplies (1)
Done, can't believe I missed it :p
3 likesOn holiday so I can't release the new version at the moment, in the mean time iron_helmet should be equivalent to turtle_helmet
dose it works on mulitiplayr?
0 likesReplies (1)
depends on the server. use the mod and test it out it will take 15min
0 likesSry but I cant even figure out how to open the FILE FROM THE DOWNLOAD AND HE IS HERE DOING THIS?
0 likesReplies (6)
pzl im not joking halp
1 like@Scense wait I'll help u
0 likes@Scense I'll be using this on my flat world if this works then my survival world
0 likes@Doge I figured it out but you have NO IDEA the journey I went on I literally had to spend like and hour downloading stuff
1 like@Scense bro when I find the two xp seeds and then press calculate seed it just says fail
0 likes@Doge same :(
0 likesdamn i don't understand. always got fail when calculate seed anyway i use 17
1 likeReplies (4)
same
1 likeit finally worked for me, i tried this in vanilla 1.17.1 afer 5 tries i got it.
0 likesmake sure you dont drop any item during the find seed proces
@Pokedatschu so i assume there new some seed?
0 likes@Faris Hirmare idk i just used the newest Version of enchbraker and it worked
0 likesAMAZING
1 likeThey might fix this bug or whatever
1 likeReplies (1)
Yisrael Pinto it’s not a bug...
5 likesNo mending :(
0 likesReplies (1)
It's impossible to get mending in an enchanting table
2 likesIs this will work in 1.16+
0 likesReplies (3)
Yes
0 likes@FilliamPL Proof? I remember this working before but now it doesn't seem to anymore. Recent comments show exactly what I mean -- final step ends with 'no match' or 'fail' despite following the instructions to a T.
0 likes@Kevin Tyrrell “Proof?” I wouldn’t say “Yes” if I hadn’t done it on 1.16 more than three dozen times. It works, I’d think you’re doing something wrong. Additionally, if you’re doing everything correctly, then it is a matter of something else that you probably didn’t think of.
0 likesAre you ready? Depending on your seed, the algorithm cannot find a way to enchant an item with the desired enchantments. It is seed dependent. If you’re lucky, your seed is able to be manipulated (dropping items one at a time) in a way to achieve the enchantments. If you have a bad seed, then you’ll get a no match.
Proof?: I’ve done this successfully more times than you
Im having trouble running the program on mac, its so annoying. Cant find library in java so runs it with slower jav that always freezes on fist input. Im fucking pissed off.
0 likesReplies (2)
Does renaming "libenchcracker.so" to "libenchcracker.dylib" solve your issue?
0 likesEarthcomputer changed it and says cannot execute binary file in the terminal, when i load java it says failed to load native enchcracker library. Thank you for trying to help i got the sword I wanted already so wont be using the program. Thanks again!
0 likesThis process is grindy and tedious, might as well just use commands since they are practically the same lol
0 likesReplies (2)
Try using commands on a server you are not opped ;)
1 likeEarthcomputer Appreciate your work :) Did you go through the source code to figure out the way to hack an enchantment table?If yes I would like to know how did you get the source code?
0 likesdo not work on papermc due to #0070 patch bois rip
0 likesReplies (1)
Yep, as stated in the video description
1 likei cant open the file!!!!!!!!!
0 likesim in 1.18
Replies (1)
What file?
0 likesThis man like has 10 000 iq like u need 10 mil subs like sheeesh
0 likesi type vernything correct but it says 'no seeds possible' i wonder whay
1 likeReplies (1)
It doesnt work on new seeds i think
0 likeswhy wont the file open?
0 likesReplies (1)
windows? mac? linux?
0 likeswhy it does not work on paper mc
0 likesSo we can use dummies in Minecraft
0 likesI cant open it up
0 likesHow download and use
0 likesHow do I do this on mobile
0 likesReplies (1)
You don't. Its for Minecraft Java edition
0 likeslink ???
0 likeshow to download it
0 likesIs it a virus?
0 likesWow nice
0 likesOk I hope my friend does not see this
0 likespatched?
1 likeReplies (2)
No
2 likes@Earthcomputer pog
1 likeBig boy get good
0 likesBlender!
0 likesxd
0 likesthe newest one contains a coinminer XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
12:22
0 likesit doesnt work
0 likes:O
1 likeDoes this mean silk touch & fortune on the same pickaxe?
Replies (1)
no its not
3 likesur a haxxor!11!!1!!
0 likes(Just kidding. Nice video!)
It just keeps saying no possible seeds?
2 likesReplies (1)
for me too
0 likeswhat am I on minecraft keto now
0 likesBedrock?
1 likeReplies (1)
no
0 likesNice
0 likesthe program doesent work I downloaded it and I tell me I need java 131 but I cant go BACK in java versions I'm in java 168
0 likesReplies (7)
RedstonePotato Java 131 isn't a Java version. Neither is Java 168.
0 likesJava versions are numbered 1.0 to 1.8 and then the latest is Java 9. Maybe you mean Java 1.8_u131? The program was compiled for Java 1.8 and all 1.8 and 9 versions should work.
1 likeok well that should have been more expliced but no it just says that it cant find java 131, obviously it isn't looking for any other version
0 likesThat error message was not created by my program. It was created by Java itself when it tried to load classes compiled by a newer version. That what happens when you use a very outdated Java version, things start not working.
1 likeI use 1.8u151 ik because optifine latest version only works with java 1.8u151
0 likesJust because someone isn't being very nice in the comment section doesn't mean you can be nasty back.
2 likesThe difference is I didn't demand anything of you, and I'm just feeding him a little of his own medicine. Sorry, I'm just not as patient with people that make demands of others.
0 likesnoice
0 likeslol it dont work on my laptop
0 likesReplies (7)
Dr_lolig it should do. What exactly doesn't work?
0 likesEarthcomputer If I click on add info nothing happens
0 likesDr_lolig try updating Java to 64-bit
1 likeEarthcomputer i have Java 64 bit
0 likesDr_lolig what's your OS? If you're on Windows, go to the enchcracker folder, Shift-right-click inside it, press "Open Command Window Here" or "Open PowerShell Window Here", then type `java -jar enchcracker.jar`. This will give us an error message so I know what's going on.
0 likesEarthcomputer the error says i have java 32 bit and it needs java 64 bit. I have java 64 bit but I delete and install it again maybe it will work after that
0 likesLol now it works. I don't know what the issue with java was but now it works. Thanks to your support
0 likesnice
0 likescan u make video about my quecsion ?
0 likesnot working
0 likesI am watching at 2021 who ever find this comment nice for u
1 likeEarth computer i need help
0 likeshow downlaod
0 likesBRUH dounphin swim.....
0 likesHey Earthcomputer maybe you shud make dis to an app on Android and iOS becose people are having problems with the encantment cracking tool???
0 likeswhat is javaw
0 likesReplies (1)
Java
0 likesThat is hacks
0 likesReplies (2)
no u
1 like@Earthcomputer earthcomputer singlehandedly just slashed that creeper
0 likesit doesn't work me no matter how i tried it doesn't worked so i give up i follow the whole instructions and nothing works
0 likesApril Fools!
0 likesReplies (1)
nope, i think
1 likethere is only 11 bookshelves... corners don't count
0 likesima shelha meta
0 likesdidnt work just wasted about an hour
0 likesReplies (1)
It does work. You must only use 15 bookshelves during the entire process. He doesn't state this, but it might not work with a full 30 bookshelf table.
0 likesNasa should invite u
0 likesWho's here from wifies
2 likesDoes this work on bedrock
0 likesWhy would anyone spend 10 minutes doing this unless they're doing it for the amazement obtained from the glitch. Insane luck with enchants are possible and enchantment books from villagers kind of makes this redundant and asinine. You may also say people would do this so early in the game which is when they couldn't possibly have these enchantment books, but what would also be the point of that? If you were going to cheat to begin with, why didn't you just switch to Creative and back to Survival?
0 likesAt this point I'm just criticizing the users of this game-breaker.
Replies (1)
first, you are not changing the game files or enabling cheats. this is like using a seed finder tool and then using a stronghold finder tool. second, there are servers out there where this could be useful, like anarchy servers or just normal survival servers.
0 likeswtf
0 likesBRUH
0 likesThis vid is stolen from @rayworks
0 likesReplies (1)
If you had checked the date of this video, it was released before his. And I was also in his video, which links to this one.
4 likes