hobune Channels Contact About Donate

Mein Herz Bleibt Stumm (This Nearly was Mine fan music)

Back to video page | Download comments jsonl

Comments (archived 2023-02-11 21:26; 51 top, 51 total comments)

LaRaikaa 2012-03-23 06:42:17

Well I love the musical pwnies, they're awesome. I particularly like Octavia because she can totally work the classy appearance. So no, it's not an accident, they get special treatment xP

0 likes
KangTheSpartan 2012-03-22 21:56:09

Trust me when I say that your Allegrezza theme is one of my favorite fan made MLP themes OF ALL TIME, so there's nothing wrong with experimenting from time to time. Don't focus too much on just making "good" music, write whatever comes to mind. Who knows, maybe you'll hit a jackpot like that again. If the result turns out poorly you have at the very least improved your skills a bit. Lucky brohoof to your future projects! /)*(\

0 likes
CMB505 2012-03-23 05:18:02

Good on ya mate! It sounds lovely, and I know Billy appreciates it as well. Fine gift you made.

0 likes
Aisu 2012-03-24 05:10:51

This is really nice, I love it. Just yesterday read this fanfic too :)

0 likes
Raven DM 2012-03-23 02:27:43

So quiet... but so touching. Feels good to hear some of your work again mate! Will you be doing other fanfic related songs in the future? Also I notice that you often make music for fics with the two musical ponies (Octavia and Scratch) is that simply a coincidence or is it purposeful?

0 likes
Lykcos 2012-03-29 07:07:47

Is there a sheet music for this? It's beautiful :(

0 likes
Mr. Chiselfist 2012-05-05 08:50:15

At 1:28 you get this sense of overwhelming frustration! But then at 1:50 the classical poise comes back, and it's just brilliant.

0 likes
gobulgobbler 2012-03-22 20:58:44

I like this. I get a real feeling of building tension throughout it, much like the fic. Is there any genre you can't do justice?

0 likes
Bombideer 2012-03-23 04:48:25

Considering that I am currently studying Chopin's work, let me say that this is quite nice ^__^ -From a classical musician, Thanks.

0 likes
LaRaikaa 2012-03-22 21:19:51

I dunno man, my Allegrezza theme was used on a Bronyville episode, that's hard to top. But this song I wrote to be good and not an experiment so you might be right. Thanks for your kind words thought! I appreciate nice, well thought out comments like these.

0 likes
CMB505 2012-03-23 07:32:39

I have no clue how he found out. Just popped into a chat he and I visit, says "Holy cow, TNWM has fan music!" and dropped a link. We all applauded on your work.

0 likes
Brony God 2014-03-01 10:02:39

You have good taste in music for having Birth Of A Penguin from the Batman Returns soundtrack as the inspiration for this song and yes the Batman Returns soundtrack is one of the greatest soundtracks ever made

0 likes
Nimbus Buster 2012-03-22 22:51:45

So.. you made a song about one of my favorite stories, let alone fan fics. Well Let's see.. *Listens* I, good sir, approve this. *Liked and Add to Favorite*

0 likes
Luna Light 2012-03-24 01:03:39

So subtle and soft, some of the quiet parts could be a little louder though, just to level it a bit would be cool. Very nice though, love music like this :)

0 likes
BurntBacon8r 2012-04-25 01:35:44

1:28 There's just so much power in that one section...

0 likes
DanglerFish 2013-10-05 23:11:49

If you've got and eye for detail, then you've got talent that's simply locked. I don't make music, but I can hear and fix the flaws. I thought I'd never be able to draw because I could never get the image from my head onto the page, but then I worked on something simple. Start with an eye and perfect it, then move on to the other facial features. That's how you learn to draw well. (I still refuse to draw pegasi, though, because wings are a pain in the arse)

0 likes
KangTheSpartan 2012-03-22 21:04:40

I only read through the story rather quickly earlier today, but I do think that you nailed it with this music. Not only is it a fine piece on its own, but it also has a certain character to it, like it embodies the very story and its main protagonists struggles. In many ways I actually think this is a better fanfic theme than your Allegrezza theme. You really have improved yourself greatly over the past few months. ...man, I take this way too seriously, don't I? Oh well, I'm a brony after all.

0 likes
Berry Goosey 2012-03-23 18:01:50

Classical with a bit of chanting mixed in. Me Gusta. Mucho Me Gusta.

0 likes
Reteras 2012-03-22 20:36:58

A really nice and slow melody. I like that really.

0 likes
Vv4rn0vV 2012-04-03 13:00:25

hamma Arbeit. echt wunderschön =)

0 likes
LaRaikaa 2012-03-24 22:22:23

Yeah there's an oboe in there with flute and clarinet. I also have a bassoon and contrabassoon in there. Do you make your own reeds?

0 likes
DanglerFish 2013-10-04 16:32:19

Tip for the 'layering' issue: Hand draw your OC. It takes more time, but it looks infinitely better.

0 likes
LaRaikaa 2012-03-23 06:46:19

Oh dude I didn't reference any of Chopin's work lol. I'm not a very avid listener of classical music and certainly not piano solos. I am merely a film score type of musician ^^; But thanks for the lovely compliment, I'm glad you liked it.

0 likes
Sand Josieph 2012-03-23 02:03:56

You guys have to stop making such great music for me to favorite! I haven't been able to get back to listening to the first videos that I put on my PONIES! playlist! D:<

0 likes
LaRaikaa 2012-03-23 11:04:25

Oh hey it's you again! We need to collaborate sometime dude. I need the real sounds of the mittelalterlichen sackpfeife. Vielen Dank für das Kompliment c:

0 likes
Sebhauser1516 2012-03-23 10:00:06

Sehr gut! Mach weiter so! Brohoof-Grüße von einem deutschen Dudelsack-Spieler.

0 likes
Bird Overlord 2012-03-24 03:47:15

YEAH! Lol, I'm pretty sure that's an oboe, that's an oboe, right? It's just, I play oboe, it's my favorite instrument, so I really want to know if it's an oboe, awesome job!

0 likes
Jozbirkza 2012-03-22 20:56:00

it's weird, this comes out and just about 30 minutes ago, i bookmarked it into my "need to read" folder

0 likes
LaRaikaa 2012-03-22 21:14:59

Yes, Gangsta Rap. There is no such thing as justice for it.

0 likes
Chris 2012-03-22 21:09:21

Tell me more about your heart remaining silent :D

0 likes
Sebhauser1516 2012-03-30 20:21:49

Gern geschehen :) Would be great to work with you. I would like to do my part for our community.

0 likes
EhSilentGuy 2012-03-22 21:09:05

"gotta read'em ALLL" "fanfics" also good job on this song guy

0 likes
Blobby & Friends 2012-03-23 02:11:35

My Heart Remains Silent.

0 likes
Geoffrey Miank 2012-03-23 06:07:15

No! That "dislike" was supposed to be a "like!" Blast these hooves and touchscreens!

0 likes
LaRaikaa 2012-03-23 06:43:38

Why thank you, and he knows about this one? I didn't tell him about it lol.

0 likes
Raven DM 2012-03-23 12:34:09

Have you read Off-Key yet? I highly suggest it! (And not just because Chromosome is my friend, or because I edit it) I genuinely think you`ll like it! [Needless advertising complete]

0 likes
Lykcos 2012-03-23 01:47:14

<3

0 likes
sparkst0rm 2012-03-23 03:56:17

I like it. Alot

0 likes
LaRaikaa 2012-03-22 21:17:06

I had to pick the most emo title I could possibly think of :P

0 likes
Bird Overlord 2012-03-25 05:17:06

Not yet, but I will be learning soon.

0 likes
LaRaikaa 2012-08-26 02:06:03

Why are you offended by an instrumental piece of music?

0 likes
DanglerFish 2013-10-07 18:24:56

... yeah ... you take that however you want to. Imma be over ... there.

0 likes
Reteras 2012-04-08 22:39:19

Did i missed something or Why is the title in frigging German!? WISO?

0 likes
DanglerFish 2013-10-04 14:57:18

Lets see ... poopstache- Check. Blue hat- Check. Poor layering- Check. Yup, even worse.

0 likes
LaRaikaa 2012-03-23 01:43:34

Because it's classy and pretentious :P

0 likes
LaRaikaa 2012-03-22 21:15:48

I love you? (>O3o)>

0 likes
AnEnemyStand 2013-01-22 12:04:38

iz gut

0 likes
JohrnyReport 2012-08-27 00:02:49

no what i mean is that some one is raging because the name is german

0 likes
JohrnyReport 2012-08-26 01:44:36

Im german and i feel offended mayb a german idea

0 likes
JohrnyReport 2013-08-25 00:46:08

No kidding, your oc is even worse Besides: comment is a year old

0 likes
ZeroCompany2008 2012-03-22 21:53:10

why a german title?

0 likes