Analyzing Discord's Betrayal

Solution: Celestia and Luna allowing Discord to have his own holiday each year that everypony celebrates. It can be a sort of wacky reality-bendin day where stuff gets put all topsy turvy to a limited degree so that no one gets hurt, allowing his chaotic nature to be viewed in more of a positive light.

Wait...doesn't Discord already live in an alternate dimension were he can reek havoc, and chaos all he wants?

My solution is, Discord planned every part of this except losing his power.
He never really switched sides. He was hinting that they had most of their keys already at the very beginning of the episode, AND points them towards their diary, which held more clues to that... are we to believe it's a coincidence that he ALSO drops the last key in their laps?

The ponies should give discord a somewhat small piece of land to spread his chaos freeley. I mean seriously this whole thing could of been avoided if the rest of the mane six trusted him more or gave him a spot to use chaos freeley!

Give him a area that he can do what ever he wants but there are 2 rules 1: no grabing ponys unless they say its ok 2: can hurt the mass populated area

The real question is . . .
if Tirek never betrayed Discord, would Discord have kept on being evil, or would he have betrayed Tirek at some point, friendship prevailing in the end? m

This all could've been avoided if the ACTUAL PRINCESS OF F R I E N D S H I P just trusted him more.

In my opinion, the best solution would be a planned date when Discord can create as much chaos as he wants, as long as nopony gets hurt and that he cleans up after he's done. See it as an Equestrian holiday.

Best Character Of the the show

@The Brony Notion My theory about this is Discord never truly betrayed the ponies, but simply acted like he betrayed them. I thought of this in key moments of Twilight's Kingdom.

So my theory is that when he reads the journal kept by the 6 ponies he bookmarks 5 passages that depicts 5 of them displaying the elements they represent which turn out to be 5 of the keys to unlock the chest. He realizes that there's nothing about Twilight's element of magic, and then he is called by Celestia to stop Tirek. Discord wonders if the stealing of magic has something to do with Twilight's element so he joins Tirek and "betrayas" the ponies thinking that Twilight will have the same experience as the others and will be able to unlock the chest, but it doesn't happen and he continues to help Tirek and does believe Tierk is grateful for his help. This could be explained when Discord felt the change of magic when Twilight gained the Alicorn magic of the other 3 princesses and said "That can't be right" and wonders if that has something to do with Twilight's element and he didn't tell Tirek about it and when Tirek stole the magic and strength of the 5 Discord turns away in shame and sorrow for what he was watching and never realized that he would be the one to give Twilight the means to unlock the chest, and when he was in the bubble he was sad because he thought he had failed. So I thought he was secretly trying to help his friends all along and never told them because he wanted his "betrayal" to be convincing, and wanted to help Twilight unlock the chest. I'm sure there could be a few holes to that theory but it's what made sense to me as Discord thanks to Fluttershy knew about friendship already.

What about having a Discord Day? Like a holiday once a year which shifts from city to city by year, depending upon the host. Then, he can put everything all crazy and upside down for a day, and all the ponies celebrate it with him.

I believe I might have a solution for what to do with Discord! How about giving him his very own special day of the week in which he can have fun! We could call this special day Wonderday! Or perhaps it could be called Mad Hatter Day, lol! It should be regarded as a great 24 hour celebration in which all of Ponyville can participate in. It would be a grand all day party with delightful activities, such as mad tea parties, hilarious games and the like, along with all the crazy pranks that Discord is so fond of! There would be only four rules: 1. Nothing that happens by Discord's doing can cause any harm to anyone, 2. Nothing that is done can be done with malice or sinister intent, 3. At the end of 24 hours the party is over, and Discord cannot do anything to extend the party (examples: making the day last forever, stopping clocks from ticking, restarting the day, turning back time, extending time, you get the idea?), and 4. Everything must be returned to the way it was before the party began once the 24 hours is up. This potential solution would also be an excellent opportunity for Discord to make more friends. Everyone can get to know Discord better, and share the fun in his jokes along with him. I honestly don't think he is truly evil, per say. I think he just has a very, VERY unique sense of humor, lol!

Doesn't he already have a realm of chaos that he lives in? If that's not enough for him then I guess they could designate an area for him that he can use to mess with that small section of reality. And even let some ponies go there if Discord promises to let them return home when ever they please.

Ever heard of Bride of Discord? Discord disappears and then a few years later he comes back and then he makes a deal with them about not effecting Equestria with his magic and he uses the Castle of the Two Sisters to cause chaos since it's in the Everfree Forest anyway.

Spoiler:




Me: And then in Season 9, he literally lets 4 of Equestria’s worst villains out of Tarturus

Discord can flip realms upside down, so wouldn't he be able to make his own little chaotic world where he can do anything and everything?

I think the solution should be that: One day a year there should be a celebration (like Nightmare Night) were people would celebrate Discord were he spreads Chaos so that Discord would have time off.

I noticed after treik took discord's magic he acted different it was probably just the betrayal but what if discord's magic makes him wanteding choas.

I'm gonna be candid, I totally ship fluttershy and discord.

The fact that they never showed their powered up forms ever again just makes me sad

I can sorta see what he's saying about losing stuff that meant something to them, but at the start of the season, they learned that it wasn't the elements that held them together, and the memories aren't gone, and neither are their friends, Fluttershy could always see the Breezies one day, and Cheese is just wandering around. Still really enjoying watching tho! Also, shipshipshipshipshipshipshipship! Fluttercord forever!( I need help.)

3:01 The Mane Six losing their physical objects and having them turn into friendship keys didn't bother me a bit because the idea was that's part of the sacrifice they had to make; they had to lose something important in order to become stronger and defeat Tirac.

Twilight's house getting destroyed was sad but also important because again it shows the heroes losing something dear to them. It's not like in a lot of older kid's shows where everything turns out perfectly fine. And it's not like Twilight is left homeless at the end, since she gets a new home. I don't care that it's different; in fact it makes the series more interesting when things change as opposed to everything always staying the same.

Maybe he can use his magic to make ponyville a bit more fun and interesting and twilight could cast and spell on discord so that if he goes too far that magic will be undone.

In my opinion, this was NOT a betrayal by Discord. Discord (and possibly Celestia, Luna, and Cadence) planned this! In part 1, Discord shows that he knew about the keys to Twilight's mystery box by bookmarking each respective section in their diary/journal. If he knew about those other keys, who's to say that he didn't know about the 6th key (i.e. the pendent that Tirek had around his neck)? In order to get the pendent and considering Tirek's nature, it would take nothing less than earning Tirek's "trust" to get it from him. Attacking Tirek directly or trying to steal the pendent would most likely result in disaster (i.e. Tirek taking their magic). Discord probably knew this, and decided to "help" Tirek to earn his "trust" and to eventually have the pendent given to him.

In part 2, Discord gets the pendent from Tirek, but doesn't plan on Tirek stealing his chaos magic anyway. This is what Discord "didn't see coming". Even so, Discord is still able to literally hand over the 6th key to Twilight so that she and her friend can open the mystery box.

Answer for discord....ask Celestia to be aloud to run amok one April Fool's day! As long as he fixes it by the end of the day, it should be okay for one day out of the year :)

we can have national chaos day every month where everyonr can do anything as long as it can come to be normal by sunrise

idea for discord give him his own floating chunk of land for his chaos to run wild on

RIP Twilight's library home.

give him freedom on april fools day

1:10

No evidence he's being held back by his desires?


If he so much as moved a claw, he was threatened to being stoned again (mane 6 except for Fluttershy and Spike)!

He was literally on parole, not totally free.

Plus, he'd make as much chaos as he wanted in his dimension but what fun is there in making chaos if nobody's there to see it?

He couldn't do much in Equestria because one wrong move/accident and he'd be imprisoned again!

So, yeah. I'd say he is holding back, but at the cost of his sanity.

Sawtooth: Brings up how Twilight lost her home and all of the memories shared there

Me: DONT REMIND ME!!! 😭

I know this is an old post, but I'd like to give my two cents. I think that Discord should run an amusement park. Pinkie Pie wasn't the only pony to enjoy his antics when he was running amok.

I think that they could give him a unknown piece of Equestria so it could have cheios and be his home

I've mentioned this once before...
I personally don't usually put expectations on a show nor do I make guesses on how I feel it should go, but this was one of the times I did. See, I believe in balance (to a certain extent) and i felt that Discord gave balance to Equestria. Everything is so perfect, with rainbows and butterflies (yes I know it's a children's show, but still!). There's also magic in everything. The fact that two princesses are in charge of rising and setting the sun and moon, likely guided me to my 'theory'(?).
So I'll get to my point: what if now that Discord is reformed and all evil is being taken care of... The world started to break. The mane six frantically try to figure out why and (maybe with Zakura's help) realize that there is an imbalance. They approach Discord and explain that they need a little chaos. He is overjoyed, BUT-! When he tries to use his magic he is suddenly unable to. Just like when the mane six had their cutie marks switched; they couldn't use their skills and talents for what they were destined for. In this case Discord has forgotten why he is who he is and why it was that he caused chaos.
Basically this would touch on the concept of trying to change something, being true to yourself, remembering where you came from, and compromising.
By the end of this episode, they all would've come together and worked out a solution which allows Discord the freedom that everyone deserves.

Wow, this was great, although I had some thoughts, Discord betrayed them because he wanted freedom, but then he ends up being betrayed by tirac, then when twilight gives up ALL the magic for him ( and her other friends) he then gives her the medallion, I think it symbolizes that he is now willing to give up at least some of his freedom for, after what she did for him... or does this make no sense?

I think celestia and Luna should allow discord one day of random chaos, and call it chaos day or something like that, where he can be himself without punishment, as long as no one gets hurt, just harmless fun. Because discord is a pretty high ranking 'pony' in the royal hierarchy

This is why I loved it when they turned the old roots of the treehouse into a chandelier

i'd actually already thought of this solution B4 this video. Discord gets to own a piece of land allowing him to be free within its borders, as long as his chaos magic DOESN'T harm other parts of Equestria. Like say a uninhabited forest, somewhat like the ever-free, or a desert, just somewhere his powers won't be a bother.

I would honestly say, that probably in twilights castle there might be a room completely for discord so he can have his little' play room ' as it may, if discord can find more healthy means of letting his chaos out then he wouldn't be so ready to turn at the drop of a left. and yes that was a reference to fluttershy being scare of a left touching her flank.

If you think about it since trees are living things, we actually had a death in a kids show. lol

Once a day, Discord should be allowed into a room just for him that looks exactly like a house living room, bedroom, or other type of house room, and let him tear it apart, and every time that happens, the mane six fix his room, because they're his friends. That way, he can make chaos rain without any harm to any pony! Problem solved!

Give Discord a little area to be himself and put magical barriers around it so the chaos stays confined to that area. 

They could have avoided ALL the Discord conflict by doing that in the first place.

Change the Castle into a tree in season five.
Well season 9, the elements of harmony tree turns into a tree house so does that work





Sorry about saying tree a lot in the comment

Well, at the beginning of the 2-parter, Discord points out the significant entries in the journal, leading the main 6 to find 5 of the keys to that chest. I think that Discord realized that they still didn't have the element of magic's key, so he gave into his desire to have freedom because he knew it would lead to that final key... :P

I really do hope they put some more Fluttercord in season five. Everyone went crazy with the canon of Dislestia. >.> I'm more of a fluttercord shipper, Fluttershy was the one who really understood him and was really the only one who was willing to give him a chance. I think these two episodes were also focusing on the others finally accepting Discord as a true friend. I see so much potential in Discord, I really hope they give him more air time in season five.

I think discord can have his own holiday sort of like our april fools dayto let out his chaos urges

I've said it once and I'll say it again. discord's redemption arc was the best decision made for mlp, change my mind

another reason why I think it was so easy for discord to betray the ponies is that they just didn't trust him. other than fluttershy, the mane 6 really didn't think he had changed all that much. I mean, look at the beginning of the season 4. they immediately had no problem with turning discord back to stone and assumed straight away that he had caused the disappearance of celestia and luna. I mean in the ponies defense, it lowkey was him lmao, but still he probably would've told them what he did when celestia and luna first encountered him if they had just believed him at first, he was salty. and fluttershy is the only one to have believed him and actually let him off the hook, which is why it really was only emotional seeing flutteryshy's reaction to discord joining tirek, the rest of the mane 6 really should've just actually been a friend to him throughout the season, and it probably would've been harder for him to be convinced. also as soon as the mane 6 had to give up the elements of harmony the first thing they were concerned with was "how are we going to turn discord back to stone when he wreaks havoc on the world again," they didn't really think he changed just because of his sorta headstrong attitude haha. i feel like later in the series after the betrayal was when they really started to try and understand discord, and of course fluttershy was the pony he felt most comfortable with. he even went on to be friends with spike, big mac, starlight, trixie, thorax, celestia, luna, cadence, etc. the mane 6 being able to take discord back and accept his mistake was when they truly believed he was reformed, and it kept his friendships strong.

I think casting the same spell twilight used in magical mystery cure on him after removing all his friends could swap him back to star swirl and remove any chance of him creating chaos.

in the "Bride of Discord" fanfiction, Discord gets the abandoned Castle of the Royal Pony Sisters as it's called as his own personal place to make chaos. i think that would be the best way to give him a little more freedom as the spirit of chaos.

Is there a disorder where you give personalitys and names to inanimate objects or devises? Like the Librey. I felt like we lost a character. Or the castle. I feel like it has a personality, a life force. I personally believe the castle has a pompous rich personally like a snooty billionaire. However he is still faithful to his owner.
The Librey was a toned down refined character who liked to just play along.
This also carries over to real life and other franchises.

You know what I found sad, when discord gave twilight the pendant she didn’t even say thank you or anything except for going directly to the chest I wish twilight and the others have something in common with discord

I would treat discord with the love and friendship he deserves while trying to help him remember all the good times we had. That's how I would help dissy cord (this is my nickname for him) return to his good ways without him turning equestria upside down.

Besides letting Discord have his own Dimension to play in, I say maybe have a "Day of Discord" or something like that, just for Discord to have a little fun with the ponies once a year.

Honestly, (I know this video is old but), they should give Discord like a theme park. A park of chaos where he can do ANYTHING (besides endangering ponies). And have it where ponies can visit for fun. Chaos, when mildly controlled, is a lot of fun. Plus pinkie pie would go just for the rain.

The foreshadowing with the three is a crowd episode is interesting, and I think it adds to discord a lot. I think you are missing out on a big possibility. What if Discord realized that having to sacrifice magic maybe the only twilight could have a moment for her element to shine? By allowing himself to not sit the villain, this gave him the freedom to be the friend he needed to be.
Evidence:
1. Discord can sense any shift in magic. Discord probably already knew Terik was free and upsetting the balance in the magic force.
2. Discord was reading and making notes in the pony diary. He was able e asu planning from that moment and knew how to open the box. He knew twilight was the one without a gift.
3. Discord is still in the process of becoming a good friend. He doesn't quite know how to express his friendship to the ponies not in chaotic forms. By planning and setting twilight up for success that was his way of trying to be a good friend. This is also why I think twilight so forgiving of him for us betrayal.
4..This would also be a great way to show more proof that he is star swirl the bearded. If star swirl did happen to mix himself up with many different creatures, this could have also mixed up his brain. Why he likes chaos and why he can only express thoughts through chaotic plans. It may be chaos to everyone bug him, and this chaotic situation is the only way he could make sense to the ponies.

I have a solution to the freedom problem with discord. Use the old castle in ever free as a chaos zone/home for discord

3:50 Did Castle Sweet Castle treehouseify the castle enough? I think it did, and I nearly cried at the end.

I actually liked the song the princesses sang. It shows true symbolism in Twilights role in Equestria, "know that your time is comming soon as the sun rises so does the moon and love has a place in every heart, you are a princess you'll play your part." It means the sun (Celestia) and the moon (Luna) rising as a sign that Twilight will rise to new expectations and find out where her place in Equestria is, and love in every heart means as long as she loves her friends and treasures their friendship she can become the princess she is meant to be and rise to new challeges. It might not be like the challeges Celestia and Luna faced when they first became princesses (i read the journal of the two sisters book! XD) but she will have to face things big or small to discovery her role in Equestria.

I truly hope the show touches on the friendship he recently forged with Princess Luna while trying to fix the sleepwalking he was experiencing, or rather sleep chaosing :-D

I think the best way for Discord to use chaos is to let him but make it timed so whatever hes done wears off in a hour or a day that way he still has his fun and ponys lives go back to normal quicker

i think a way to help discords problem is having a episode that helps it other than the one where it was pretty much just him and flutter, he should see what they do in they're everyday lives but if they do this they will obviously do at least one frame of kaos

Discord's freedom can easily be shown in that between worlds realm that you described which is basically his home. So, he should be able to do whatever he wants in his own place so long as it won't affect anypony else. There he can wreck all kinds of havoc and therefore not have to feel longing for mischief.

Give discord his own bubble of insanity then he’ll be able to cause as many things to go wrong without hurting anyone

Maybe a Chaos Sanctuary? A place were Discord could do what ever chaos he wants. Maybe on certain days fillies and colts could take field trips their and learn about the AWESOMENESS of a Draconaquus. Can you say "Best field trip ever!"

I think a good way for Discord to unleash his inner-chaos is by either; Making a little bit of land that Discord can shape with a mess up all he wants, or, one day of the year that Discord gets to go into chaos, but only for one day.

Actually,now that I think about it... Why couldn't the box just plant itself in the library tree and made it the castle?

The nation of Mania, ruled by king Discord. Theoretically, he could have as much land as he wanted seeing as he doesn't fallow the rules of reality so a 500 acre piece of land could easily be double or tripled in size because of his senseless chaos magic. And lets face it, his chaos would be awesome to live in. I can easily see some ponies and other creatures going to live there.

Maybe there can be an episode in which Pinkie helps Disord create his own amusement park where he can wreak as much chaos as he wants and ponies can have endless fun exploring this constantly changing atmosphere.

I had a theory myself, just never posted it. I think Discord planned all of that without meaning to. Remember the potion that Zecora made for Alicorn usage only? You know, the one that provided visions to Twilight? After the Tree of Harmony was saved, Discord had her drink it again, to show what he did after his defeat by Celestia and Luna way back when. At the time, it was a sort of payback. Now, give or take 1500 years later, the Elements of Harmony are needed to save the Tree, and sacrificed. The tests to release the Elements was likely unknown to him, and so were the lessons involved, just so the ones meant to awaken the Elements would get a MAJOR power boost to reverse all damage done by a MASSIVE threat, one that he wouldn't be able to defeat. Namely, Tirek. Granted, he wouldn't have known of the threat, but he's Chaos Incarnate.

Chaos and Life have some sort of agreement that makes them practically one and the same. Here or any world, really. It wouldn't surprise me in the slightest if he can predict the future, without technically seeing into said future, and thus preparing everything needed for it, without knowing he's preparing for it, or even that he SHOULD, for that very reason. He understood a small part of Friendship, the good part, from Fluttershy, but Tirek showed him a Bad Friendship, filled with Lies and betrayal. That showed him the Full Truth of Friendship, which answers the question of the "Multiple test of Friendship" Discord had given.

But I'm getting off topic a bit. So, Discord's role in Tirek's defeat. An unknowning Double Agent, putting the plans into action when he was first defeated, and then the ones to beat the bigger threat, one he couldn't stop, but never really looked into, enough of a power boost a ways into the future, when it was needed most. He goes with Tirek, following him, until the final moment, when he learns a lesson he didn't see coming, but gives the final key needed to unlock the box, which ends up spelling Tirek's defeat by the Elements of Harmony, which, by his own actions, were sealed away and then empowered upon initial release, thus the physical changes and shockwave returning everypony's magic to the populace.

In short, while Discord may not have seen it coming, he prepared for it, in the event something happened that he couldn't stop. His actions caused the Tree of Harmony to retake the Physical form of the Elements. The Trials increased the Mane Six's connection to said elements. Each Trail gave a key to unleashed the, at the time, sealed power of Harmony. Discord gave the Final key needed. With that Key, the Power of Harmony within the Magic of Friendship was released, and took down the biggest threat at the time: Tirek. The defeat released a Shockwave through the excess Power, thus returning the Magic to Equestria.

Chaos works in a Round-about way. So, in a roundabout way, Discord set up everything for Tirek's defeat. Whether he knew it or not, the only way someone will know is if they ask him directly. Anyone else think of this being a possibility? It's my theory, at least.

Well technically speaking Discords betrayal was supposed to happen so it's very forgivable plus freedom (real freedom) is a treasure for people who don't have it like Discord sorta didn't. Discord has always been an interesting character to analyze since his motives aren't always clear especially now since he is reformed

Twilight's doubts sounded completely logical.
First she was worried about being a princess but by the point of the finale she realized that it didn't mean that much.


The castle makes perfect sense to me. She is now a proper princess.

we learn in later episodes that discord seems to have his own realm where he is completely chaotic but of course, you did not know this at the time.

Solution: they could build a magic isolated room that he could do whatever he wants

I have to say, that was a good review, but nothing on the final character designs of the finale? Nothing?? They were terrible! I could almost feel my eyes melting out of their sockets they were so bad! Though I have to say, it's not surprising that Twilight eventually received her own kingdom, however I liked the old tree house library better than her new castle.

In my previous comment I forgot that Mr. Notion asked what a good solution is to Discord wanting more freedom, for the answer I point to Bride of Discord. In case you don't want to look it up and read it, or for somehow you don't like Fluttercord, then I'll tell you. In it Discord gets to stay in the castle of the two pony sisters and the surrounding area is his to do whatever chaos he wants. It's not all of Equestria or a whole town to himself but it's something, though I think he's fine in his home in the chaos dimension, which makes me wonder why he wanted to take over Equestria in the first place if he already has a chaos dimension. Oh well.

I think Twilight should search for places with oppression and lack of freedom. When she finds them, she can call up Discord and let him have some fun, thus teaching him the positive side of chaos and freedom.

There should be a day of chaos every year like a holiday where everyone connect weird as long as he puts it back to how it was before and doesn’t do anything too extreme it Would be fun and not just for him but for everyone like a stress reliever

Actually, ever since "Keep Calm and Flutter On", I've felt that Discord was only faking being reformed.  It was only under the threat of being returned to stone that he was forced to "reform".  One might ask, well if the Elements of Harmony were back in the Tree of Harmony, what would stop him from just taking over again?  One would have to believe the spell Celestia put on the Elements to stop Discord from messing with them would still be in effect, and a quick teleport back to the tree would spell Discord's return to stone once more.  He was merely biding his time until he could return to chaos and get revenge on the ponies that imprisoned him.  And yet part of him wanted his scheme to fail judging by the advice he's given to Twilight over the season.

You know, I think that the physical memories in the rainbow power episodes are NOT gone. The objects were the keys, and the keys are the throne they have in twilights castle.

Give him his own plot of land where he can freely cause as much chaos as he pleases. It's already been done in a fluttercord fanfic

Okay, can we talk about how none of the Mane 6 but Fluttershy like Discord?


This isn't a betrayal of anyone but Fluttershy, because honestly it cant be considered a betrayal if they were friends to begin with

I feel like discord knew about the magic of friendship but he somehow got really tempted by tirek
other than that discord is good

Solution: Make another realm then let discord do his thing then he can come back to the real universe with all his friends

I'm so agree with u!! Tree house, gone, the objects they got, gone! Even though they would not of be able to open the chest, still, gone!

I think maybe the transformation from a treehouse from a crystal imitation of a tree that clashes with the rest of ponyville is a sign that there will be changes and more responsibility as things get more complex( like the video about human-twilight going to pony world) maybe there will be a major plot twist with the cutie mark crusaders and a big commotion about princesses and what belongs to who and where. Plus it looks like discord could start to use his magic for battle fare like when he tried to stop tereck(idk how to spell😣). I think discord would now be more responsible with freedom since he knows the outcome and would have an outlet for disaster. I feel like the creators are starting into a new storyline with a possible "7th element" and plugging into something deeper like with the sirens going into the human world or something could happen like a clash or rip in the portal or no separation between the worlds like the fact about every thirty moons it opens breaks (again maybe the cmc will have a part and discord possibly fighting for equestria)

I really don't know cause these are random ideas I just put out. I'm also kinda new to these concepts because I haven't watched all of the episodes or rainbow rocks besides clips and trailers although I saw twilight's kingdom 1 and 2 and watched equestria girls and at least 12 mlp episodes including the first. This most likely is wrong or unreasonable but just consider this because the characters are definitely developing and growing more mature/powerful(mane six each get a throne [ownership troubles/wars with discord or cmc might happen idk]) I really don't know what I'm thinking I'm sorry I really am not an organized person sorry

I don't know, I feel like Discord should have been a lot more resistant to manipulation by Tirek. I mean, it was pretty obvious to all of us from the beginning that Tirek was just using Discord to get what he wanted. As someone who was no stranger to manipulating others, I feel like Discord shouldn't have fallen for that so easily. Honestly, I think Discord let Tirek push him around to a degree that the Mane Six and even Fluttershy couldn't get away with. And because Discord is my favorite MLP villain, I was a bit disappointed with that.

In the grand scheme of things though, that's really a minor complaint. Season 4 was really good, and I'm looking forward to season 5 and beyond.

I always thought his betrayal wasn't a true betrayal, but rather his own chaotic way of helping the Mane Six overcome the battle with Tirek and the mystery of the box. I mean, given that he's the "Element of Disharmony", it would make perfect sense that he'd be connected to the tree in some telikinetic fashion and go out of his way to ensure the tree grew stronger by helping them so he, too, could grow stronger and remain even as he limits his power to small things in favour of his affection toward the Mane Six.

I feel like Disneyfanatic2364 did a great job in bride of discord of finding a way to let discord use his powers to help woo flutters

You're the only person I know that gives theories that are actually interesting.

I think they should give Discord an area where he can be purely chaotic without upsetting every pony. 

I think discord should be able to create a few chaotic events as long as he puts everything back the way it was before. Perhaps he may also find an outlet for his chaos in making little misadventures for the mane 6. Besides, you can't learn if you don't experience, and a little bit of chaos never truly hurt anyone in season 2, did it? Nopony was shown to be injured or killed by Discord's fun. Another thing, if there isn't any chaos, no one really knows what the standard would be for harmony, correct?

I believe that discords evil will resurface, and they will then beat him. With the lesson to be learned is that friends need space in which they can be themselves. Which means discord should be given an area in which he can cause all the chaos he wants too.

what if there was a place already crazy. A place discord could run free. what if there was somepony there who could fix anything with a quick potion. Somepony discord could relate to. That's right I'm talking about the everfree forest and Zicora

In all honesty, I'm sure Discord has a realm meant for him to have his fun with.

He just needs one area of Equestria, even just a room where he could "express himself".

Well, if we look back to the first episodes of season 4, we know that Twilight use a spell to summon discord. This being said, who's to say discord was not given another realm a realm of chaos to control. Or at least a completely separate part of the planet that they live on as she has to summon him using magic.

In my fan fiction that I'm still writing, there is a point where discord gets ahold of resurrection magic and tries to bring back his old race that was killed off.... the draquoniquines. And he was the only survivor, SINCE in season 2 episode 1, cheeralee blatantly calls discord a draquoniqus.

Give Discord his own part of equestria to cause chaos, like a new kingdom where discord is allowed to wreak havoc to any degree.

Giving discord the castle of the two sisters is a good solution.

Actually while it is true that Discord's motivation may have been freedom to be himself, I feel that the other contributing factor is that none of the other main 6 really treated him like a friend. Fluttershy was the only one to stand up for him in the season opening. Pinkie Pie would have cared for Discord in the episode where he pretended to be sick but she also gets too easily distracted and that episode also showed his insecurity as to where he stands with the other ponies besides Fluttershy. So by the time the finale comes she is the only one he is betraying and it was more out of curiosity than anything else. Was he being held back by his friendship? Was there something more? Only way to find out was to go ahead and give up on friendship and see.

I always thought that directing his havoc would have been better. let him use his mischief to teach lessons to heroes and villains alike (lets face it, that's a regular occurrence every season and given the fact that it took 4 seasons worth of villains appearing in the space of one year, should give discord something to do). give him challenges to face and overcome, even give him that section of empty waste land if he wants it outside Equestria. Havoc directed healthily is better then havoc suppressed.

Give Discord an area to run as a themepark? Only condition that ensures no one is hurt and can leave when they want?

Lets face on, a themepark run on Discord's powers would be pretty awesome.

2:00 this moment in the episode was so funny I couldn't breathe

i think that in the show it would be cool that celestia could let discord have a bit a land to make chaos or a chaos day once every year

ya know, discord does have his own little chaotic world. it was in the episode "make new friends but keep discord"

Give Discord his own dimension.

It's about Discord fighting his own nature, his dark desires he's had for some time.
Just like anyone else's sinful desire they may have.

What if he knew the magic box was the key to Tirek's defeat and planned the entire thing?

They should give him a place in the everfree to do what ever he wants but have force field to keep his chaos from reaching ponyville
But he can leave whenever he
Wants

Ladies and Gentlecolts, step right up! Come and see the wonders of Discordia! That's right, Discord, the spirit of disharmony, has created a theme park of pure chaos! Be boggled, be inspired! Visit Discordia today!
(Disclaimer: Discordia is not responsible for any changes to the guests, enter at your own risk.)

I think the mane 6 should just build Discord a house or something where he can have all the chaos he wants as a birthday gift or something. He is the friend of the princess of friendship, so the mane 6 could do that much for a friend.

I feel like discord can see through the time and he planned it

I do have another problem with Discord's betrayal, and that's not the fact he betrayed them. My problem is that I see no reason for Discord to cooperate with Tirek.
Yes, Tirek says he will give Discord the freedom to bring chaos to Equestria after he stole all the magic, but what is stopping discord from doing exactly that?
It could be argued that it was out of gratitude for Tirek, but that's not how I judge an evil Discord. He also can't see Tirek as a new friend in my opinion because
A) Tirek is offering Discord freedom INSTEAD of friendship, making it pretty clear he is not interested in friendship
And
B) even if tirek did mean it like that, Discord chose to abandon friendship for freedom, so why would he want a new friend if discord believes in that moment that friends only limit his freedom?
Furthermore, it's obvious that Tirek only cares for himself and is bound to Betray discord. Not seeing the possibility is stupid, and while discord is crazy and has a lot of hybris sometimes, one thing I can't see him as is stupid.

And my last problem, Discord is definitely morally conflicted when Tirek steals the mane 5's magic (mostly because of fluttershy), and again, since he traded friendship for his absolute freedom (even reality bows to his will for Nightmares' sake), why in Tartarus would he do something (or let something happen) he feels is wrong?

Also, i want to add a detail to his whish for freedom. Since Discord was able to hear Celestia while being a statue, he heard what's she said. "But I have use for Discord's magic if it can be reformed to serve good instead of evil."
... She has a use for him. That's not how one should talk about a living, sentient creature you hope to resocialise into society. That's how one talks about a weapon or a tool. She basically says that if she could use his magic without needing him, she would do it. At least that's what it could sound like to discord.
next thing happened at the end of "keep calm and flutter on". Celestia (more or less) secretly left the elements in ponyville as weapons against Discord. Which could be problematic for Discord's relationship with equestria in two ways.
1)it's treated as a secret what the purpose of the elements in ponyville is. They clearly don't trust him, so why should he trust them?
2) it's weapons specifically against him. Celestia could have made it broader and say that the elements should remain in ponyville because the mane 6 then have easier access to them if a threat appears. Then they would not have been specifically against discord.

I know it's getting long, but please bear with me for a little bit more. I think it's wrong to see his betrayal as stepping back into evilness after being completely reformed. His reformation is only completed after season 4. Look at the end of "princess twilight sparkle". As soon as he realized that the elements are gone, he's making new, most certainly evil plans and only stops after fluttershy yells at him. (His friendship with) fluttershy is a morality chain. He isn't reformed, his morality chain just let's him act as if he was. As soon as that chain was gone (when he saw his friendship over), he reverted back to his original self. I also suspect that he always doubted if fluttershy is honest until he saw her crying in that cage, same way he felt it was necessary to test if twilight truly was his friend

i think the rainbow powers were AWSOME and i think they will always have a memorey of the items they lost

i know im about six years to late, but if discord can do ANYTHING with a snap of a claw, then i think he should create a parallel universe, that only he could go to, and when he gets bored, go there and do as he pleases, or take it a step further, and copy Equestria, and everything about it in different universe, and then rule over that himself, do what he wants to do

I know! all of those special gifts, by ponys they almost never see. gone forever! I was like really?! no other versions?! would it have been so hard to make duplicates. keep the original. problem solved. COME ON HASBRO!!

Discord was only convinced to betray Equestria. Tirek put it in his head that the ponies were only using him for the benefit of his magic. Tirek also mentioned that the friendship thing was only an act to keep Discord imprisoned. Discord was in denial at first, but then gave in the second time just like that. Even before he was betrayed, he did pity the ponies and the mane 6 of having their powers drained. I think he will never change in pulling a few harmless tricks every now and then, but I believe he has completely moved on from causing chaos. Still, I don't know what his future episodes will be like. But I don't think the other 5 of the mane 6 will ever change their distrust of him especially RD. I hope the writers listen to the fan theories, and his backstory will one day be revealed in a episode. Where he was always treated as an outcast and a monster due to his appearance. His only friends were Celestia and Luna, and he used his magic to make all ponies suffer as he suffered. Where it is a rather sensitive episode about Discord where he gets pity for ounce.

I have a theory that twilight's element of harmony isn't magic, but friendship. All of the elements used to be just colored gems, except for the "magic" one. 6 points, 6 friends. Also, when Discord gave Twilight that necklace, he gave it to her as a sign of friendship. Not a sign of magic. Please do a video about this! :-)

Discord seems to regret his decision from when Shining get's his magic stolen. My headcannon is that he would warn Twi just after he got betrayed.

I almost started crying when Discord betrayed Fluttershy. Him and Gummy are my favorite characters.

Look to keep discord satisfied I think they should give home his own land with a few ponies who wouldn't mind discords rule so as he could have fun. Though the thing I never got was why were they so fearful of him sure he has the power to hurt someone but we have yet to see him actually hurt anypony

Pause it at 2:07 - Discord's face is priceless! 😂

Could discord not make an alternate reality were only he can travel to and wreak havoc there and then come back to the normal reality whenever he wants and be friends with the main 6?

Discord didn't betrayed them at all. My theory is that Celestia had a vision and conspired with Discord to obtain the last key and open the chest

I say, let discord have his freedom! I mean the episodes he was introduced in were my absolute favorites. (Although Fluttershy probably wouldn't be too happy about that and...) Nevermind! I take it back! #FlutterCordForever!

"If you were at the end of Equestria, you'd be standing on a big A!"

Discord should be a party entertainer. He could even team up with Pinkie and make a job out of it. That would be the best party ever!

the look on his face at 1:51; I was dying!: ) LOL I think that discord should try telling fluttershy his feelings.

3:19 I know!!! That's exactly what I was thinking at this moment!!! Just, you know, turning this object from really close friends/helpful lessons into keys that can only be used once ... Nevermind! RAINBOW POWER!!! 
And I HATE the new castle ... It's so shiny in an EXTREMELY distracting way ... and unnatural ... and doesn't suit literally anything around it ... and it's so shiny in an EXTREMELY distracting way ... 

Can we just look at her magic regeneration in her eyes for a second when the necklace shined?

Maybe discord could help twilight understand the pinkie sense. Their both chaotic.

I say it was awesome that Princess Luna finally got to sing in a song.

Maybe twilight gets captured some how and the others search for her but can't find her. They lose hope. And discord is the one to find twilight in Tartarus and discord has to make a choice too. This would have an intense battle between discord and Tirac. But the battle is only to trick Tirac and transport twilight away. It would give discord's key much more meaning and an epic season premiere. If discord was able to change, crysalsis could too?

Give discord a land to play with that is his own so that way he can serve his purpose and his existence to make balance between good and bad which wouldn’t end up in Ponyville being the chaos capital of the pony world

I think that they should just make a little place for him that you can just do whatever chaos he wants

its been 6 years and I still miss the treehouse

I laughed so loud this episode XD

When the new non-pony 6 Re-created the tree of harmony into a crystal tree-house within the walls of the abandoned castle of the two sisters, does that count as bringing back Twilights library in some way???

Discord could become a painter. It would actually be really good for him if you think about it.

don’t worry twilight’s treehouse I SHALL AVENGE YOU!!!

Honestly It makes sense, the mane 6 taught Discord friendship, with Tirek, Discord had friendship AND freedom

When you were talking about twilights house it depends on the pony there are four types one is old school for all the memories Which you were thinking ( same with me) another is future ones which they would be the ones that move a lot and like a change another is you like a small house to live in another would be like rarity likes big like fancy the old house staying would be a move for the old school and small house ponies the new house is future ponies and moving ponies

I'm also going to answer your question. I'm using Bride of Discord for this idea, BTW. I think that Discord should be given a designated area in the Everfree Forest to use his chaos. Not like anypony would care about the Everfree being messed with, anyway.

I keep taking a look back at this too I think we all noticed that discord gave up so much to be friends with the mane six and nine of them had to change at all in my opinion I enjoy the Capitol of Chaos discord much better than imma have a tea party with flutters discord. Sorry for the lack of quote and hyphens

Technically, Discords has freedom but he doesn't know it yet. In season 5 his house was full of chaos I mean look at the floating house and the dimension not to mention he can still freely use his chaos magic. Just in a good way. If you look back to the episode where Discord pretends to be sick just to prove friendship between Twilight and himself! He caused trouble by (almost) flooding the treehouse! And singing that ridiculous song talk about picky. He's still evil but in a complete lower level.

Well... It is clear to me that Princess Celestia had planned this. She also cannot tell Twilight about it, else Tirek will find out. For the other three giving their Alicorn magic to Twilight... OBVIOUSLY it would make the young princess' magic out of control, making it a decent bait for Tirek.And Discord... well, they needed someone capable to get that amulet from Tirek -- technically given freely -- only discord could, Also, Discord now had something to lose, so he gave the amulet to Twilight. Also, that Twilight chose her friends over magic was too... because friendship IS magic. I suppose Discord saying it aloud meant something too. Saying it was a test of friendship just cleared things out...

They could give discord some uninhabited land to make havoc in. That might not work.
Or let him wreck havoc in prisons. It might make the prisoners want to reform more wouldn't it?

This video should be about how Discord TOTALLY planned this all.
No, seriously, he did. He did all of this for Twilight. It must've torn him inside, but he did it for a good cause.

Give discord his own land a few miles away from equestria and clone some ponys that he could rain his chaos on. Then when he gets his need to be crazy out he can reateurn to equestria. And for discord I dont think it being a few miles away seeing that he can telliport. PS: I think he is the funniest charicter in the sieries.

I think if anything, Discord needs to be accepted for what he is, and be allowed liberties with his abilities. When Fluttershy is befriending him, she allows him to become comfortable by changing his surroundings to better suit his personality. Why are the other ponies unwilling to allow for some of his chaos? It seems that they should put forth a better effort to accept Discord instead of expecting him to do all the work. After all, it's been established that he does not know much about friendship. Twilight, most of all, should be leading the way in making their new addition welcome. Instead she seems to be openly hostile to anything Discord says or does. Now I'm not saying that he should be allowed to do whatever he wants, but he should be expected to cause some chaos, though given the rule that he can do so as long as it doesn't harm other ponies. Friendship is full of compromise after all. I think it would be only fair that ponies be willing to accept some chaos into their life for the sake of keeping a friend rather than making an enemy. Discord can't change who he is, so those who profess to be his friends should be willing to accept him for his faults as well as his gifts. You have to admit, having the power of Discord on your side is pretty handy. 

I think they should give discord a chaos castle in the everfree forest asking as he keeps all the chaos there, he can be chaotic and the ponies remain safe!

I agree with the castle thing I mean c'mon they have got to bring the library back. I do love the castle though

I hope I'm not the only one who's saddened by the fact that more tears were shed at the fact that a stupid tree burned down than Fluttershy crying over Discord's betrayal.

he could get a house of his own with walls around it and its garden so he can discordify inside his walls and leave the rest of equestria on the other side of the wall alone

The fact that one of his main problems with the episode was a single shot

I would give Discord some place where he can spread his chaos like he wants, kind of an own kingdom. I personally love Discord and for his sake, I would give him that, even when I would be a pony, I would him do it in my house.
I even imaged that he maybe has some sort of mini Equestia in his bathroom, playing with that and only the mini Fluttershy is still nice, while he plays jokes on the others.

I suggest that discord should have a empty room and there he can do all of chaotic thing's!

I think discord should have a kingdom to reek havock in it would stop him from invading other kingdoms

Let him make another dimension where he can wreak as much havoc as he wants.

I have an idea how about having a little bit of both friendship and a little bit of chaos 🤔

What if he had his own kingdom out of equestria that means he could do whatever he wants over there

Discord's longing for freedom is a problem that really does need to be addressed. Call me a copy cat, but in the fan fiction Bride of Discord, Discord had his own area where he can have as much freedom as he wanted, but only in his "territory" or "property" so there is still harmony in Equestria and Discord doesn't have to chose between Freedom and Friendship. I kinda think that's the best option. Yeah, he'd be only in his area, but it's like giving him a house and saying "Do what you want with this and make it your own home. Just don't mess with my property." (I don't claim this idea, I'm only summarizing a solution that was presented in Bride of Discord, one of my more favorite MLP fan fiction works along with Cupcakes, Smile HD, and My Little Dashie.)

Maybe we could give discord an area so he can do his chaos like maybe the ever free forest but then Zacore might have to move out in the castle ruins would be ruined it doesn’t he already have his house and that was one dimension thing

You know maybe the princesses can get together and use there magic altogether and make a magic chamber for discord so he like and think up anything he wants and do whatever he wants with it.

Couldn't Celestia let Discord play a few harmless pranks? Like loosening the lid to the salt? I think Discord was bored of being "good" and wanted to have a little bit of fun.

One day out of each year sounds like a plan hehe (hell, we have April Fool's Day)

He could also cause a storm of chaos on any enemies that threaten the ponies, that'd be fun to watch ^^

Just saying - discord didn't have to take over ponyville I mean - he made the evergreen forest grow out of controll in one of the episodes so couldn't he just - use the evergreen forest? It would give him freedom to do what he please but could also keep harmony to all the other places Manehattan, ponyville Etc like zicora discord could have rule over evergreen forest. But how would that play out in the next season?

Honestly I just think that discord needs more friends seeing that the only pony that actually trust him are Celestia and Fluttershy.

Honestly I just think that discord needs more friends seeing that the only pony that actually trust him are Celestia and Fluttershy.

Discord repays kindness, the only reason he trolls the mane 6 (and the main reason he betrays them) is that they were always jerks to him. Except for Flutters who he is actually friendly to.

I've always thought it was obvious that Discord had the entire thing planned out so that Twilight could win against Tirek.

give discord his own town to play with and do what he wants in the town be as chaotic as he wishes

maybe like once a like year or so the ponys could have something called: 'Caos day' or something? where discord can do his caos for that one day and the next just snap and clean up his mess!

Solution: Twilight has strong magic right? well she could some of that magic to make Discord a area to cause chaos and have some fun. since Twilight has strong Magic, she can regenerate the area so if Discord is board, he can just do it again. Plus, Twilight can make make the area look different every time.

After reading the comments I am not agreeing on any of the points made. What's the fun in having a trustworthy discord I was upset by this episode because it truly did strip discord of most of his character and played off of key points. I know everyone was complaining that discord forgot fluttershy a name and all. But fueling the shipping is just all they were trying to do with the good discord and truly evil is what the played up in his betrayal. Being a huge fan of discord it hurt my heart guts to watch this episode but I agree on most of the videos point anyway. I want there's a crowd discord back he was perfectly balanced in the shipping, the chaos, and leave the flipping incredibly evil discord out

I think discords reasons to be evil didn't involve him getting revenge or ruling equestria, my theory is that he just wanted 2 c equestria in chaos just as the joker wanted 2 c Gotham burn in the dark knight

I can just imagine how happy he was about S5: Episode 3 X3

If It Wasn't For Discord Twilight Never Would've Gotten Her Key To The Chest And If She Never Got It Tirek Would've killed 2 birds in one stone , Good On Ya Discord!!

I think there should be a special day for Discord to do whatever he wants as long as he doesn't harm or change the ponies.

Discord should get a small area of land for him to do whatever he pleases, so that way nothing gets out of hand, and discord can have freedom

1: "No interesting villain is evil just for the sake of being evil."  True, true, but some real one are.
2: "Literally being the spirit of chaos, its only in his nature to wreak havoc."  Please don't use words interchangeably when they don't have at least similar definitions.
3: "He'd never experience true friendship."  He also wouldn't be on Equestria's side to betray them.
4: Actually that's all I have.  Well done Notion, you have finally excited my expectation. 

I think discord could be allowed to bring chaos ONLY on April 1st every year BUT once the day is over,it must stop

I think that like in the fanfic 'Bride of Discord' he should be given some land to do whatever he wants with, maybe even land in the everfree forest like in the fanfic.

Its really hard to have discord cut loose for one day without it wreaking havoc on equestria. He has to have an outlet maybe he can do that later on or we can explore that later on in season 5.

He should get to completely torture EVERYONE in the underworld, and when a new enemy pops up, it's his turn to have a slice of chaos :3

Retreehousification has actually happened, guys. Watch 'Castle Sweet Castle'.

That moment at the end with teary Twilight is fucking adorable

Oh, good job Discord ,
You killed my best customer's house but you gave her a god damn medallion

I think that they should give discord a certain amount of land that has no ponies to reek havoc on

I think Discord should have one day of the week to do whatever he wants to do. As long as he turns everything back to normal, doesn't mess with the lives of animals, and can only do harmless pranks on peopl- I mean ponys. He can do whatever he is allowed to do. If he wants, he can help other ponys. But only if he wants to.

Maybe Discord needs a job. I wondered if he was actually in Equestria Girls but was busy teaching chemistry or art or something. What kind of job could he do in Ponyville? He has lots of magic and could use it for Ponyville's upkeep or something. He could be deputy mayor.

"It was pretty cool to see the Relation SHIP betwean Fluttercord and Dish-shy."
Me: wait. So fluttershy washes dishes now? 😆

When the mane six lost there special gifts they weren't lost forever now there are in the form of keys to unlock the box and let out that rainbow of death

I thought that discord betrayed the ponies because he wasn't feeling any type of friendship from the others except from Fluttershy. The other five ponies were always quick to point fingers at him and Fluttershy was the only one who seem to care about him. Maybe he consider his friendship with them not much of a lost.

as i saw many videos  about the betrayal that discord portrait in the season finale i come up with a theory. that he actualy put all toghether to let them obtain the last objective that was  the rainbow powers and may i say that because his first try to give twilight her key to the chest have fail. he actualy plot to use the tireks theart to make them archive a bigger reward, and like i this i bring the  question what is the best way to make someone find and answer for me ad many people would be not giving them the answer it will be better  to make them get to it by themselves so they get true knowledge and a better lesson, and  for thisi shall reffer  to the firts episode of the season and when discord said to twilight to lose the oportunity to teach a leson to her. for me that is how discord's mind works  not giving you the answer but making you realize it.
So to conclude this i will say that my theory is that discord plan all this thathe knew that tirek would "betray him"" to put twilight in a difficult choice to  really test her limits in friendship  and taking the risk to find out, afterall hes not trully evil hes is justa god a spirit that could fnd amusment in what motals do and test them to see if they can overcome their limits. and to tell i ifnal agument to this theory i will refer tothe creation  of the character he is based on Q from star trek and what does he do test the humanity if they can become more and surpas his limation and in the process learning from them
And  thats my theory 

They should give discord a teeny-tiny little corner of Equestria and anypony or anydragon can live there😆 it's the perfect plan lol (this post is a joke but if any body thinks it's a good idea im gonna take credit if it hasn't been posted yet)

Technically, he has his own realm, does he not? He could simply wreak havoc there anytime he wished..

My idea was that Discord was playing a long scam just to get Tirek's amulet so he could give it to Twilight.

well I think they should have made an area in the middle of no ware and put up magic fences so that the magic couldn't escape then he could go there to use his magic exept with rules like 1 no using magic on ponies 2 no using magic on animals 3 no using magic on living things and 4 no using out of control magic out of that area then let ponies and donkeys and dragons and such go visit him if they want so that he feels wanted and not held back.

your making the loss for her tree house more sad then it needs to be. ):

2:06 that face though

when I first sam twilights kingdom, i thought the castle grew out of the the library, personally i think that would've been better

Right, so I think you should give Discord some land that he can spread his chaos(got that one from bride of Discord) 😊

Rest In Peace treehouse you had a good life

Actually I feel sorry for Discord. I mean he was meant to be reformed in Season 3, but nopony besides Fluttershy ever believed in him and still have a huge dislike against him. He's even reformed! Well, it's understandable, that Twilight, Rainbow Dash and Applejack still don't trust him as a friend, but seriously, Rarity and Pinkie Pie? I wouldn't expect them to be mean as well. And then there's "Make new friends but keep Discord" (I know, Discord behaved like a jerk). Sorry, I don't want to rant about several episodes, but I've got a theory, that Discord was always alone and was still alone after Season 3. Of course, he had Fluttershy, but in the Season 4 finale, Tirek made him an even bigger offer and finally manipulated him.

Well, I hate Fluttershy because of her exagerrated cowardice, but I really really like her because of her kindness and her love to everything. She believes that everything has got a bright side and her chemistry with Discord was just so cute.

I still don't see what's the problem with ceos!
Go discord!

Give discord a small part of equestria like the 2 sisters old castle in the everfree forest and let him go nuts on only that area like he demanded in bride of discord great YouTube series

maybe once every other week we give discord a little time to spread soem chaos but it ends ant the end of the day sounds good right?

I think they should have a holiday for Discord where he can be as chaotic as he wants and everypony just rolls with it and has fun! If you were a filly, would you really be that freaked out by cotton candy clouds or a shuck of popcorn?👆👇👉👈👏

Even though it was gone they have the castle to remind them of the chest so they will remember the things

They could give him a piece of the ever free forest just for causing chaos. And have him still be able to visit his friends what do you think?

Gonna call it "no great villain is evil for evils sake" for MLP this is true but for other forms of media Joker calls bullshit on it. other then that great video

I think Discord knew he must betrayt M6, because Twilight didnt have her key. It was Discord, who knew, how to get theire keys. Mabye he was guardian of elements of harmony but in past it was happend somethig and he forgot it. He could altered elements of harmony to elements of disharmony and stop him can only new guardian of elements of harmony (Celestia and Luna or M6). And now, when he is friend of M6, he remembered it and therefore he is tracking and helping them.

Maybe discord could have his own area of land in equestria where he could reek all the havoc he wants.

Maybe Discord never really betrayed them in the first place? Maybe he had a plan all along?

Don't forget that the tree IS saved as it was confirmed for season 5.
Also beyond note I always knew that Discord would betray when he said a quote in keep calm and Flutter on "I will use my magic for good (most of the time)" I wonder what more enemies there will be in 2015 NOT looking forward to Equestria Girls.... Any who I forgot Again what the Hell I was going to just say Ill edit this if I figure it out again.

I think he should have a castle of his own to mess around with

Darn I wish Discord should be evil again. I mean he didn't want to KILL or take over anything (like most villans.) He just wanted to have fun! And I agree with him, the world he wanted looked fun. A place I would live in. But the mane 6 had to ruin it?! Good job mane 6 good job.

+The Brony Notion
Like you said, Discords chaotic desires are just going to keep building up until he goes back to evil, but maybe this would be the time where Mattel will introduce April fools day or a day like it. A day where Discord can "rule" Equestria and let all the build up out.

i say discord should just have his own little part of the place were he can cause all the trouble he wants with out it affecting anypony else

2:11 fell of my chairxD

What if Discord just occasionally made it rain chocolate milk with cotton candy clouds. That was the least harmful thing that happened to aquestria during his reign of terror. A lovely surprise of you ask me. Seriously, imagine looking out the window and your friend's just filled your swimming pool with ice cream or whatever. It's playful, harmless, and generally a fun time.

Just imagine if discord became the king of his own land, not too far from ponyville so he could visit, but make it so that he could have a place to make however he pleases, and others who love a good amount of chaos (me) could live in peace with the rest of Equestria. Just a thought that may give ideas to others who watch this video. There aren't any kings yet anyway, and this show is all about friendship and equality, so why not?

I think it's funny that you mention retreehousifying Twilight Sparkle's home because in Season 9 the Tree of Harmony is reformed into the Treehouse of Harmony by Twilight Sparkle's students.

Just give it scored his own uninhabited part of a Questria where he can spread chaos throughout the land and no one will get hurt because really when he was evil he didn't really seem to have any intention of hurting anyone physically anyway

discord should have a spot in the evrfree forst were he can be well free to do what he wants like if you agree

He’s friends at the threat of what is pretty much death! That makes me sad.

He should make his own world and have TONS of chaos just for him!

Just give Discord the whole thing! Popcorn, cotton candy, chocolate milk, what could be better! And, if I remember, we can drink the glass too! It will be GLORIOUS

At least one bit was paid into that castle. The bit that applejack got, at least the castle got one cent into it

My theory is that discord is the 7th element because in the final episode he said where is my throne and fluttershy answer with your not there yet and I want to here your thoughts on the topic

i think they should give the old castle of the two sisters to discord to play with or something like that.

but when tirek destroyed twilights library it made me think of tirek as complete awesomeness

Discord does have his own realm after that episode

They could do what they did in Bride of Discord: Give him part of the Everfree Forest. I mean, he's not confined or anything.

If discord truly does want free dom the princesses can just give him some abandon land and let that be is area for chaos

the best thing they could do is let discord mess with the ever green forest I mean if its that bad why not all he could do is make it better and yes I know zecora lives there so just make sure discord leaves that part alone but besides that this is probably the best solution unless there's  another random place in equestrian were he can do what he wants but if any else has a better idea please tell

i think the solution should be making a giant place where ponies can even come in,in witch Discord is alowed to do anything,but only inside,wile it can be like his little easy to acces pocket dimension using magic to make it bigger on the inside,and ponies can come in and play around with Discord,maybe even make some sort of tradition in witch you have to stay inside for as long as you can,and you get given something,like a mini-game of ponyville in witch Discord is the game master,and you have to play by his rules for the time you stay inside,wile you should be able to enter and play with Discord not just as a mini-game of pony-ville ,but as a little way to keep him from doing evil,and to become friends with him and have random fun,he might be just the right time of chaos,the fun one wen its in control,controlled chaos

No order without discord. The greatest character ever.
Edit: don’t feel bad I am a proud Fluttercord shipper

Let Discord run theme parks and fun houses, he gets to cause Chaos in a controlled fashion AND entertain ponies.  Everybody wins!

Me going back to an old vid and being hit by the bad audio

I think they should teleport discord to a different land and he could do chaos there were nothing is there and chilled it up so nothing can get out
Except discord

The chest gave something that together take all the memories and make something that will always stay

Honestly I think the only explanation to Discord's betrayal was because he like Celestia and Fluttershy probably fell for one of the "oldest tricks in the book."

Send him to the kingdom of the Changlings and Queen Chrysalis and let him loose! They've got to be somewhere, right?

discord day where he gets to do what he wants thats my solution

2:48 to 3:01 I do think she had adjusted but what does the princess of friendship do? I think that was what the writers were trying to address that and it's not as clear as princess of the day and princess of the night also princess of love

what if they let Discord have reign over the Ever Free forest? where he's allowed to chaos-ify everything in there. He could turn trees into candy canes, ponds into chocolate milk. He could make it rain only over the forest. The ever free forest is already chaotic to ponies because it runs on its own without the need for the ponies. what better place for Discord then the Ever free forest?

They could give discord a holiday!!! Nightmare moon got nightmare night (which Luna later found to enjoy). Celestia gets the summer sun celebration. And Cadence pretty much has hearts and hovers day. Discord should get one day or week of chaotic fun and then once the day is over (with a timer of corse) and then restore order for the rest of the year. Like a discord festival! . . . Oh god another festival! O.o

maybe they could let him let loose in some other land that has no one in it. it's a pretty simple solution if you ask me.

my solution is discord id perfect and the other ponies should try to more like him

i dont understand why discord joined tirek in the first place.  tirek convinced him that discord was still kinda imprisoned but the elements of harmony are gone.  discord didnt need tirek, discord could have taken over equestria easily without tirek.  then later, discord could have just teleported away when tirek tried to steal his power and even though tirek was powerful, i still dont think he was as powerful as discord seeing as discord controls reality and can counter any spell.  so my two complaints about this are why did discord join tirek and why didnt discord just teleport away and defeat tirek later on.

Discord runs off periodically to severely "F" with Equestria's actual enemies, keeping them off balance and unable to do anything meaningful.

Why not give Discord a piece of land to let his imagination roam wild, but he can't go out of that piece of land, and if he does, that piece of land get taken back. Just an idea but still.

Hmm, since Twilight stuck her neck out to call Discord her friend, I have to wonder if season 5 will have some sort of conflict about who Discord likes more: Twilight or Fluttershy.  How will those mares react to his decision?

hes a powerful spell binder, why cant he just create a pocket dimension and do crud in there

Maybe a bunch more weird mythical creatures come to Equestria and start turning it into chaos and then Discord gets his own kingdom to rule his subjects and he can turn that place into complete chaos.





Wait.


No.

That's a terrible plan.

correct me if im wrong, but im pretty sure that Discords betrayal was just ploy from the beginning, at least on his end. he was the one who pointed twilight in the right direction as far as opening the chest at the Tree Of Harmony. im pretty sure they all forgot about it seeing as how no pony mentions it after the start of the season until Discord brings it up, he even bookmarks the pages she needs to read in the diary in order to figure it out. Left on her own im not sure she never would have figured it out. Tirek also talks about how smart Discord is, meaning if he knew how to open the chest he also knew twilight needed to overcome an obstacle dealing with magic. telling any pony anything would jeopardize the "lesson" she needed to learn which would mean he had to fool everyone. doing so he painted himself the bad guy, fooled every pony into believing it making the lesson genuine so to speak. if he had given her the answers she wouldn't have learned anything. plus the whole winking at Princess Sun Butt at the end makes it pretty convincing they both he and she where in on it. Plus only a true friend would go through this much trouble for you.   

maybe give discord a day he could wreck havoc every year or maybe give him a place where it's okay for insanity

maybe Discord could get his own land in Equestria like Apple Jack has her own just a bit larger for his needs. He could make his own land how ever he wanted like in the one episode he was staying at Fluttershy's home and changing it only you know, on his own land. It would give him the freedom to make his own land unique in his own ways and he could change it whenever he wanted. If so there would be no reason to change all of Equestria and create havoc everywhere.

I think ther is an episode where twilight gets home sick of the castle

its funny when he was like uh you given me nightmares really that akward shot could have been avoided pretty easily

Discord is like that one parent that puts you in a situation you don't like to try to make you prepared for life. XD

I think that they should give Discord a piece of abandoned land for him and his coo-coo ness

You should make Discord follow Celestia around and prank her... that way she gets a taste of her own medicine

Oh my god, are people really gonna start bitching and complaining about that stupid tree house? Okay, I'm sorry if this is rude or jack assish at all, but now your all going too far. That's like everyone getting mad because they decided to give Applejack a bandanna to go along with her hat. That's really how stupid it is. You all might just being to damn picky or too damn sensitive about what happens in the show, I mean seriously? As far as I'm even concerned, the tree house didn't even get destroyed forever. All that happened that it got an upgrade. It got an improvement and made it 50 percent cooler. Who cares, it's not like they took off a character all together.

it's like, if you don't release steam in an old locomotive, the boiler and pistons will burst. if discord hadn't unleashed chaos when he did the results could have been fatal.

Discord should own a piece of land that he can do whatever he wants in. Since Twilight already has a castle maybe he could have The Castle of the Two Sisters.

Ponies could let Discord have a single day a year to do as he pleased as long as no one would get hurt. Like April Fools.

every year, have an equestrian day of chaos. let discord brew some mischief (in public) for a day once every year and not be punished for it.

at least it does have a bit of tree in it (the real thing not the toy)

Well... Discords Chaos is not unhealthy per se... you might get mad and dizzy, but nothing harmful. Why not give Discord a piece of land - any land as he can change it to anything at all - for him to do what he wants. And then invite Ponies to this as a Carneval or so. As long as he changes them back when they leave, nobody is going to complain.

It´s not real freedom of course, but real freedom needs boundaries too, which is a problem on itself. As Discord is all-mighty per definition (if he weren´t screwing around or underestemating his enemies, he should never lose...) I guess he never had anyone teach about what is good and what is bad, which explained his view of Freedom compared to the freedom of what the Ponies thought.

I love that idea of him having his own theame park reminds me of Eggman a bit i also think Discord Should have his own pet or a pony who has the exact same powers of him and was good friends with Fluttershy so when he couldnt be with Fluttershy hed have someone to help when he ever feels lonly☺

They already made the playset of Twilight's Kingdom and it is the best thing ever. It only comes with Twilight though but she's rainbow

He should just do all of it in his dreams

that castle isn't very popular.

I do agree with what you said about the library, but omg that book thing in 'Trade Ya' was terrible! Let's teach children to be hoarders, shall we? The whole Pinkie Pie and Twlight part of that ep was my least favourite....

i think that twilight and the princess should create discord something of his own world where it has no real effects on equestria and we have seen twilight creat a portal before i mean look at the human world she had created some changes and her power with the princess celestia and luna raise the sun and moon so i think creating a portal should be easy

I'd like if Discort became like a house designer for the ponies. Call me crazy, but if I was a pony I'd absolutely want an upside down house or something.

ok just thought of something amazing... "deep breath" 
IF Star Swirl = Discord and Star Swirl was talented with TIME magic then maybe he saw into the future.
And IF he did and saw himself as Discord as a friend to an ALICORN with the symbol of MAGIC as her CUTIE MARK then what do you think would happen?
You see if you look closely Discord knows more than he lets off about Twilight (maybe he read ahead in the script) . thats MY opinion ...

okay i see a lot of people saying give him one day a year and others saying give him some open uninhabited land. why not do both? one day a year? come on you all know how hard it is to wait for your birthday or christmas. surely he'll get antsy in between the yearly event. so he needs space for when that happens, so just put both together. a stretch of land for the rest of the year, and all of equestria for one day.

One thing that got me thinking is; why is Twilight's castle made out of crystals if she's not in the Crystal Empire or connected to the Crystal Empire?
So I was thinking and then it hit me. Twilight Sparkle is connected to the Crystal Empire; she is the bearer of the element of magic which is the main element of harmony.

And if you look on the MLP trading cards the crystal heart is said to be the
7th element of Harmony; the element of love. Who bears this element exactly? Oh yeah Twilight's brother and her sister-in-law.

If Discord want more freedom maybe you should let him do some magic inside a rum there it doesn't do any damage or maybe on a children party, ^^ just for a little time.

I have a solution that does end in that. Just give him some land he could do whatever on and call it discord land like a theme park

chaos day! a day where discord can unfold all his chaotic desires... and then after a day's time it'll all go back to normal... i mean isn't that the main issue with discord? ponies not liking the unpredictable envioment? but if it was a predictable date it would be less horrorfying

Soooo, no complaints on how stupid the rainbow powers look. None? Not a single nitpick? Come on, they were SOOO BAD!! I mean they even changed their cutie marks!

Tia and Luna should give discord an area in the everyfree where he and relax and be free to do what he wants so that he can stress out or ruin things some where in the every free forest

They should give discord a small amount of land to do what ever he wants with that way ever pony is happy

I think we all knew where we were, when the tree was blown the f*ck up... Places hat on chest. Fare thee well, good friend...

Fluttercord 4 everrrr!!! ;P

I know Celestia should give discord a land that no animal could live on and he can just mess around with it like a kid's room or a playroom or a park so discord can have some freedom

To be honest I don’t blame him for betraying them, I mean yes Fluttershy was nice to him and twilight tolerated him, but rainbow dash, Applejack, and rarity were WAY too eager to turn him back to stone in the season 4 two parter, so as far as I’m concerned they never were friends with him. I mean it’s essentially the same as threatening to send someone to prison just because you speculate, but have no actual proof, that they did something wrong. Would you do that to someone you considered a friend, or would you give them he benefit of the doubt?

Furthermore, while Fluttershy was clearly nice to him and twilight at least tolerated him, it’s entirely possible that the other ponies’ antagonism convinced him that the way Fluttershy and to a lesser extent twilight acted was just a facade they were displaying to use him so his magic could be used for the benefit of Celestia and her allies, and that they never even liked him at all.

So keeping that in mind, is it any wonder he sided with tired, who from his perspective was probably the first living thing to show him “genuine” concern and respect? (Obviously tirek was lying but keep in mind i said from discord’s perspective)

On another note, I’m pissed at the way hey handled his betrayal, instead of making a one liner like “surely you saw this coming” he should have snapped at them when they accused him and said something that showed how much their distrust hurt him and how he believed they never liked him and were only using him, all while he’s clearly on the verge of tears to show how genuine his feelings were. Then , when twilight was battling tirek, they should have cut back to he rest of he mane six and discord imprisoned and shown a scene where they apologized to discord for acting in that way and convinced him they did care, and that hey should have shown it better. Then, discord, realizing his error, apologizes to them and especially Fluttershy for his betrayal and for not believeing that she cared for him.he, that would have been much better in my opinion

Maybe if its possible have a spell that can lead to a pocket dimension for discord to have some freedom

I say discord should have the castle of the two sisters u know to give him some land to use his magic the way he likes

Come on bronies, really? The series needs more big shocks and changes. Twilight's house being destroyed was a brave move by the makers of the show and I think it was a good one. The last thing we want is the series to be safe and stagnant.

I for one thing Twilight becoming a princess was also a GREAT idea, she'd been developing towards it, it just made sense and was very satisfying. And her coming to terms with it had to be covered in the main series because guess what? MOST PEOPLE DON'T WATCH EQUESTRIA GIRLS! I sure don't, it just seems stupid to me, I saw 5 minutes and then just noped out of it.

But seriously come on people, you need to encourage brave moves when they happen. Remember how much it sucked when they "fixed" Derpy. Maybe they wouldn't have done that in the first place if people didn't criticize them every time they did something hard or controversial.

I would love to see more dramatic emotional moments and more big character changes personally! Maybe the mane six could all become princesses at the end of a series once they've all learned the true meaning of friendship, and then they could be like the Celestia for a whole new generation of ponies, teaching them about friendship!

The mane six could still go on missions, in fact they could go on really epic missions like exploring a new land or something! And there could be all kinds of dragons and other types of ponies and stuff!

The last thing we need is the series getting stale and reptitive. I'm all for change, and you should be too! Shake things up Hasbro, I for one support it!

Let discord be Tireks personal torchurer. THAT'S FOR OUR LIBRARY-TREE HOUSE.

or maybe a Discord related holiday? Where once every month on one specific day let's say the 13th of every month in the pony world Discord is allowed to turn the pony world upside down but make it fun and he could go around pranking just like how Rainbow and Pinkie do. So instead of making chaos everyone hates the chaos could be something the ponies could enjoy it would be like a big chaotic party. Chocolate milk and popcorn for everyone ^__^

Perhaps Discord should be given freedom, but in just one segregated area. That way, if any ponies wanted to live there, they would be free to, but there would be a choice.

One word:BALANCE. There has to be a balance between Chaos and NON Chaos. If Discord can't create chaos He will turn evil and sadly... So would equestria because someone would start a fight. HOWEVER Discord wouldn't use his powers all the time as he would need to have his powers in check.

Let Discord take a vacation to a world with a small amount of chaos already present and make it twenty percent more chaotic for about a week or two.
Well, this did happen in one fanfiction already... A Naruto and MLP:FiM crossover... I can see cotton candy clouds over Konoha right now...
Man I wish someone would write a fanfiction with Discord going into the Ghost Zone and screwing with that already chaotic place and making Walker trying and failing to arrest that chaotic trickster.

discord should just find his own land, make it his own, and visit the ponies frequently.

3:42 - oh phooey on you. Just remember who this programs' TARGET audience is, and that Hasbro's primary purpose IS to make money from toys. You gotta take these things with a grain of salt.

Simple, let him have the castle of the two pony sisters. Most pony's stay out of the forest, so he could have all the chaos he wants within its boarders. Heck he could make a crazy chaos themed park that Pony's visit. 

I think I have a solution for discord. They should give discord his own
little town filled with pony`s who are willing to live with chaos.

Who else thinks Discord looks great in a police outfit?

Discord should be allowed to be him self in a place like the everfree forest where he could be creating those choco rains without nobody destourbing him?☁️

I think that celestia will give discord the two sisters old castle so he can bring disharmany as much as he wants also it should be a excuse to why the. Mane 6 were tiding it

Since Celestia said openly admitted that she invites Discord to the grand galloping gala to liven things up, maybe one week a year with no laws, just so long as nobody got hurt in the process.

Well, the design of Twilight's new castle does pay homage to the golden oak library!

You know the only reason Fluttershy is so kind is probably because she's was chosen to be the element of kindness

Dude that opening was beautiful!

It has already been done when fluttershy told discord that being normal is destroying him so you can be chaotic good

How about doing what Disneyfanatic did in her fanfic "Bride Of Discord", give him a piece of land where he's free to use his chaos magic however he desires as long as it says within his land? Not a bad idea right? :)

Discord could make things like haunted houses only... crazy houses :D

Give him his own land where he can make chaos whenever the fuck he wants and he can also make chaos towards the future villains

is it just me, or is what they end up doing, and hanging the roots of her former home from the castle chandelier kinda morbid?
"Your old home was destroyed and you shall miss it forever, (forever truly being forever as you are an immortal alicorn whose friends will all die one day) so we shall put the remains of it here where you can see it every day and remember it is gone."

I have forgiven you for the angel.

its been proven that luna can turn into nightmare moon on command season 2 so why didn't she fool tierek into joining him becuz she evil the kick his but at the end

Discord was evil before without motive. So what is your point?

And Twilight's castle is "treehousified". If you don't see the castle set into a giant tree, I feel very bad for you. :(

~Dash~

they should have discord day, he gets to do anything he wants for one day a year

What if the princesses create a large building that discord can do whatever he wants in it? He'll still have freedom without wreaking havoc on ponyville. Or equestria for that matter.

Give Discord a place to be chaotic. Just like in bride of Discord.

What if, on Nightmare night, Discord opened a haunted house of chaos! The ponies would have a good time and Discord would get to reek havoc in a productive manner. :D

Why do the mane six trust discord. He took your wings, took your horns, hide the elements of harmony, made then the opposite of their elements, put equestria in choes, knew about the vines and kept it a secret even though it was important for them to know, betrayed them, broke fluttershy' heart, and though that freedom is more important than friendship

In my opinion, Discord´s betrayal was totally plausible. Let´s see. Discord, master of chaos and disharmony, former ruler of the world, after being released for a second time he sees an opportunity to trick the mane six while they are trying to reform him. He mocks the friendship Fluttershy offers him as he believes it is a mere fraud in order to keep him from taking over the world. In fact, he didn´t do that because of the Elements´s presence. Later, Fluttershy states that despite all she has tolerated from him she quits and renounces to try to befriend him. He suddenly feels devastated and agrees to be reformed. If this wasn´t seen as legitimate, he proved it when his first impulse after the Elements were given wasn´t conquering Equestria (sort of, since he considered). During the season 4 beginning and in "Three´s a crowd" it is easily discernible that Fluttershy is the only pony in the mane six who sees him as a friend (and Pinkie, who finds him amusing), while the others see him as a total annoyance. The sentiment is reciprocal, and so Discord disturbs the rest of the mane six while he treats nicely Fluttershy. That is what any logical person would do; be good with who is good to you and vice versa. And then is when Tirek comes, and offers him something really interesting. He can decide to keep a sole friend (who only intended to befriend him for interest, although that might be different now) in a world where no other person appreciates him deprived of his freedom and abandoning his nature, or siding with someone who actually appreciates his true self and will allow him to do anything he wants. After the treatment he received it is not surprise that he changed sides. But let´s admit it; if the mane six had been nicer towards him he wouldn´t have betrayed them. Sure, Discord was a dick all the time, but so he was to Fluttershy, and in the end he became kind towards her. If the rest of the mane six had actually tried to make friends with him he might be less of an annoyance and proven true loyalty.

I think a good idea for fixing the problem with discord and freedom is he shood have a space for cayos or gust discord taritory

id say that for discord to not go off the rocker again, they have a day (much like April fools) where he can cause SAFE chaos. Harmless pranks causing no permanent damage. for 24 hours every year Discord can have fun with his passive powers (cotton clouds, milk rain, ice roads, giant card houses, ect.)

They should give discord his own little section in the ever free forest were he could do as much chaos as he wants just in that little section or he looses it The Brony Nation

Maybe give Discord his own little village. Not with any other living thing living in it though. So Discord can cause chaos there. It would be like in movies where they make up a town so they can blow them up. It would give Discord some freedom, heck he could even make fake ponies to crush and stuff if he feels like it.

just give him his own little slice of land somewhere, a couple Acers wear he can be himself. who knows maybe it'll turn into an attraction of some kind, and he'll get a whole bunch of visitors who Want to see what de dose.

we know discord has his own little section of equestia that is chaos incarnate maybe one or twice a year he could invite pones (other then the mail pony) to come experience chaos with no ill after effects. the daring ponys my like him better after that.

To be fair to Discord, non of the ponies except Fluttershy really treated Discord like an actual friend, no wonder he wanted something more, ponies like AJ were treating him horribly even though they were apparently supposed to be his friends.

The soronding areas of equestria should be only for discord so he can do everything he wants but keep it from flooding into eqwestria

I haven't watched your video yet but I think discords betrayal was not a betrayal at all. My theory suggests discord betrayed them because he wanted all of Equestria to have one good friend because he was trying to turn t-reck good so he would give all the magic back and feel and spread the magic of friendship across Equestria, another powerful figure that spread friendship. At the end he gave twilight the amulet not just as a sign of gratitude and friendship also as an apology gift like a pizza 🍕 will I'm sorry on it. Get my point love your vids :D buh-bye please make this a video! Ok bye 👋

He can't hold back evil. And in my emgnashun a wolf named Huteress made friends with Discord. Discord needs to keep Huteress a serrated.

For Discord to have an area were he can bring chaos just say a two x two miles square. That way he can be somewhat free but doesn't betray anyone. Like or responde if you agree please. Plz. pretty plz.

I support your theories and I love your vids

They should give discord some area to inflict with chaos that would not harm ponies, like the badlands

Sending every bad villain into a random dimention, and letting discord have free reign! :)

if you miss the golden oak library, then you might like the newest episode of season 5.

It's not gone but changed it's different.Same with the tree house the memories are with her.

i am not upset by the tree house blown up, i am upset the writers being forced to blow up the tree house by Hasbro for a New Toy Sale! not surprised... but that doesn't make me less pissed about it.

i really hope they remake the tree house didnt they make the new castle out of the old house and if they did then how did twilight go back and visit the old treehouse

I feel pretty bad for Discord.

Let Discord have some kind of little, forgotten area to wreak havoc in. Like, say, I don't know, THE WHOLE OF APPALOOSA?!?!

oh they could give discord a magic room that alows him to work chaos with out wrecking any thing and then if he likes his creation he can save it and go back to it even after making another creation (i make alot of impossible invention ideas)

Maybe he can have a room the shows the chaos that he displays but does't leak into equestrian.

Can't the four princesses be generous enough to give discord a part of equestria so he can be as free as he wants, why don't give him the ever free forest after moving zecora out of it or give him the weird biome from the episode someone to look over me!!!!!

What if they do like in one of my favorite (cough* cough* fluttercord cough* cough*) fanfics just give him a large plot of land in say, the everfree forest where he is free to be chaotic and reek havoc.

they should have discord rome free sometimes but not all the time (and by rome free I don't mean turning roads into soap or flipping houses over)

they should let him have fun with a spot deep within the forest ... like the old castle!

is discord a real villan? i mean well he never even did much to hurt anypony or take over equestria and he never did anything truely bad but in his perspective "have fun"

4:00-4:07 Ladies and gentleman, today is the three-year anniversary of Twilight's treehouse library destruction. Please join me in a moment of silence for this beautiful treehouse. "My Heart Will Go On" starts playing Thank you. I now return you to your regularly scheduled programming.

easy. send discord to an abandoned piece of land and let him make chaos there and ponies can go there to have "fun" if they think its fun. but discord cant force them to stay.

CREATE CHAOS CITY!!! also, for about the six friendship keys (or whatever), I think it's actually somewhere in the castle (why not?)

Season five they actually address the fact that the old tree house had memory's in it and how this new castle didn't

solution:they could make a place in the forest where discord could make every thing all wacky.

how about discord makes his own world where he is free to make chaos but not in equestria?

Couldn't the 4 princesses make Discord his own world? With all the villains and he would be the ruler?

If Celestia sent him to the moon he could wreak all the havoc he could ever dream of.

That awkward moment when you realise Discord is actually Q from Star Trek

They should give discord the ever free forest. Where he will be ever free to play with a little chaos. That's what the name should be for.

4:04 never stop smiling

I got all of the Equestrian girls dolls when I was younger :D they were my favorite toy for like three months 😆

I really did not think that twilight's house needed to be destroyed, but could have been remodeled that does not look like a hasbro play set. Plus, having the items that each girl received back to them to cherish those important lessons. I though that discords betrayal was kind if stupid and that discord should have known better after fluttershy reforming him. However, him having the lack of freedom does give some idea of why discord did what he did.

if they treated discord like a normal pony maybe he wouldn't desire freedom so much

Easy , get him his own dimension
- Celestia

Discord just wanted to spread complete CHAOS to Equestria.

I think celestia should designate a small piece of equestria for discord so he can be himself!

Here's an idea give the guy his own little bit of forest and say "here you go now go play and brake everything and when you're bored fix it if you please but till then go nuts."

So Technically Tirek Killed Himself By Letting Go Of Discord While He Didn't Know Discord Had The Key!!

GIVE DISCORD HIS OWN KINGDOM

I died at 2:12 of adorableness

hope season 5 will have more  discord in it doing more stuff and when i mean stuff i mean fun chaos stuff not bad chaos just fun chaos.

THAT ONE MOMENT MADE ME FAN GIRL...DISCORD'S FACE!! ^_^ I LUV IT!

He has endless powers so he should create his own land for that purpose.

that was what i thought! seriosly, i wanted them to keep the tree house and the idems

I think Discord should have a day we’re he can do anything and have all the freedom that he deserves but for 1 rule that he can harm anyone/anything/any pony

I think letting discord go to a inhabited part of Equestria and letting him toy around there. Heck! LET HIM BRING THE LONG LEGED BUNNIES BACK!!!

give him a plot of land to own limit him to that land. BAM. problem solved. But it has to stay inside his owned land and a bit off from any big cities and well preferably close to ponyville.. . but his land should be spacious.. but not to big either..
If anything like say a crazy muscled up bunny or a bunny with REALLYYYY long legs escapes.. then as punishment his land amount gets reduced and vise versa for a major good deed but has a limit of how big and how small his land can get as well!

They could do the same thing for him as they did the bats

Give discord a piece of land he can do with what he will

i say have celestia make a dimension that looks a lot like ponyville only enhabited by stuffed dummies instead of living beings and that only discord can enter or exit.

I'm glad they honored the Library in the latest episode 'Castle Sweet Castle'

You should do an analysis why the main 6 changed their cutie marks in the rainbow power thing episode! =:3

I really miss Twilight's tree. :'(

if there was somewhere that Discord could just "run free" and do anything, like make stuff float around, and any thing else that he want's to do, as long as fluttershy says that he's not really hurting anypony, then I think it might be OK. That's long. 

give discord his own realm to wreak havoc upon

maybe discord can make a duplication of the pony world or at least find another world to mess with

Give him a chunk of land to do whatever he wants to do in it

Well, TBN, can I call you TBN?
I'm calling you TBN.

I think a solution could be to give Discord a space he can do all of his chaotic activities in. For example, take Bride of Discord, he is given the castle in Everfree.

He is able to life there, defy gravity and do such.

maybe they should give discord a plot of land that he could do whatever he wants with

I can't be the only one who thinks Discord would enjoy April Fool's Day, can I?

I have a book on my tablet that tells about tirek past and fuss who it was... DISCORD so I'm thinking tirek let him help because he rembers him even though he was a teen back then

Twilight: completes spell~ becomes a princess
Fluttershy: Reforms Discord (is it just me or is what fluttershy did seriously better than what twilight did?)~ doesn't become princess?

i personally think that maybe discord(please do not laugh) secretly has a teensy crush on discord and maybe thinks that its over. dittershy can not end!

I want to be evil sometimes for no reason I just think it would be cool

they could deal with discord by letting him wreak havoc on some waste land

Discord should get a space just for him to mess up and be free a little

Perhaps give him a day a year to do what he wants like a pony April fools day

giving him a day to chose haviec in a safe way somehow

one of the other reviewers-DWK, I believe- sums up the castle and the rainbow power forms pretty handily. with a hypnotic chant. Buy our toys. Buy our toys. Buy our toys...

Discord should get his own land to reach havoc on.

Give him a huge place to live like the everfry and one rule don't hurt zucora

i dont really blame Discord for betraying them, only Fluttershy really cared about him, the rest didnt give two craps. also i feel that they could have done Discord turning back to good a little different, i ment the only reason he turned on Tirek was because he stole his powers, i just think they could have done that better thats all

Easy, just give him his own little corner of equestria to wrench havoc in. One where no pony lives.

In the intro, did anyone notice that Discord was in Fluttershy’s window googling at her while she was giving Angel and apple? Just a thought..

4:37 I think discord should create a new realm and cause chaos in it or cause chaos in a different realm

I think discord should have his own land to cause chaos on

They should give April fools day to discord, Then he could play tricks without announcing anypony

Discord just needed a space for his chaos like a discord Land yeah there's his house but he could have visitors

perhaps discord could show twilight sparkle what he knows about magic he gets to demonstrate/use his chaos magic

I know this vid is super old but I think that Discord could just create another dimension for himself that is the same as equestrian exept without the the ponies he cares about that he can do whatever he wants with, or the princesses and the mane six agreeing to him having a day a year to do whatever he wants with equestria. (he might get carried away but FLUTTERSHY TO THE RESCUE!!) my thoughts The Brony Notion .

Boneless was sacrificed for the good of Equestria. I hope I'm not the only one who noticed this.

Yeah, it's solved by making a new world where only he is which will never make sense to me ;-;

he should have his own world

What if Discord had his own sector of Equestria to be free?

If you know the bride of discord you should know what I'm talking about. So maybe Luna and Celestia can give discord a castle (their old home) so he can be all chaotic and stuff

i would like it if the conclusion ended in chaos.

I think Discord should get at least a little bit of Equestria to rule.... Mabey the Everfree forest? That would make a ton of sense, the Everfree forest is crazy, Discord is crazy..... =D

02:11 discord's awardly adorable face..lol

Doesn't Discord literally have a chaos dimension, where his house is?

Maybie, they could have discord wreak havoc on a specific spot like cough cough The equalization town this in season 5I dunno..

"Ugh, you keep giving me nightmares. What is that? Really?"
That's illuminati. Just look at it, there's a triangle in the middle. O.O Illuminati Confirmed

I guess it was half of a good thing I only watched till season 3 xD

a smallish plot of land nobody needs and he can reek havic on the land but he can't go over a magic barrier or friend ship n stuff

Discord could also help Rarity make some awesome clothes

I think he should have Discord have day's when he can cause a little chaos like chocolate rain!!... Or maybe I just want to see Pinkie skip around drinking chocolate rain man she was lucky. And a little chaos never killed anyone or maybe I just want to see some more chaotic Discord~!

ps. Am I the only one who fangirl when he talked about Discord and Fluttershys friendship? No only me?

Make his own crazy dimension!

give discord his own land to play with

I think Discord should have a plot of land to spread chaos.

I got nightmares from mrs.fly above me for the rest of my life and scare me half to death

Give him half of equestria and his own tv show

I Think discord should have a tiny park Of chaos where he could do what I like to call harmless chaos like cotton candy clouds raining chocolate milk or corn popping right into popcorn not changing animals and ponies

He should have a small area in Equestria to use his magic. At least give him a SMALL area....

Let discord have a chaos playground a place he can reshape how he wants just like alcohol to a alcoholic a little bit and that's enough

The everfree forest is already filled with choas so give him a home in the forest

Discord could help pinky pie plan some awesome parties

That was so funny when he did the slow motion!

maybe reserve a section for discord in the everfree forest! so he could fool around as much as he wants!

that B&W picture with music and the writing rest in peace made me cry ...
for 2 secs

Okay if you listen close to three is a wheel you here twilight saying i don't even know were-discord interrupts.We know that she has no idea where he lives. So I think that there should be a whole episode about finding out where Discord lives.And people seriously need to stop thinking that Discord lives in Celestia's castle dungeon.

What if they let discord be chaotic in some part of the ever free forest.

Let me guess, Discord is going to marry Eris, the Greek spirit of strife, and she would turn all of applejack's apples into golden apples of discord

Let Discord make chaos. But have him fix it later. Even if he turns the town hall into a giant bowl of pudding, it's not the end of Equestria as long as he turns it all back. But let him do it only if it doesn't get out of hand or too confusing. Maybe let him have a "chaos zone" where things in 5 feet of him do weird stuff but go back to normal when they/he leaves.

I think Princess celestia should turn discord into a pony so he can regain his trust/friendship with the rest of the mane 6

rest in peace twilights library/treehouse/old never forgotten home! 😢

I say let him have 1 month of freedom a year to keep his erg for caos calm but saddle to.

give discord one part of the land for he to do whatever he wants

Give him a plot of land where he can do whatever the freak he wants
(Watch bride of discord vids)

I need to go join like this page... Also: With downcast eyes, I put my hat, not previously anywhere in sight, over my heart. R.I.P. Twilight's Tree House...

Season 8 already and they still haven't granted your tree wish Brony Notion.

maybe they can give him his own place to do chaos

Solution for discords freedom, give him his own pocket of Equestria (there is enough free space) and let him create a chaos amusement park, that way ponies can enjoy the chaos and he can make more friends.

I say there should be an episode were past twilight comes and says "your Castel is nice what about the memories

BN I agree with you on the whole marketing thing but the items about the keys is something that needed to happen

Let Discord run wild in the Everfree Forest. Just so long as he dosen't lay waste to Zecora's home.

GIVE DISCORD HIS OWN REALM WHERE HE CAN DO WHATEVER HE WANTS WITHOUT HARMING THE PONY WORLD???????

GOOD IDEA???????

Give discord a dimension like with giratena but not banishment so he can do what ever he wanted like in cloud cuckoo land

They could have a Discord Day in Equestria! A day for just chaos and chocolate rain ( mm... Chocolate rain...) Yeah!

a solution is simple has anyone watched daughter of discord/ bride of discord? well the answer is the everfree forest. let him reek his havoc there.

When the picture of that toy came on I just repeatedly said I have that over and over because I had no idea it was my little pony

Discord could have like his own dome to cause chaos in, than everyponys happy!

HOW DID YOU GET TO SENTIMENTAL FROM TALKING ABOUT DISCORD'S BETRAYAL?!????!!?

Maybe Discord should be in charge of punishment, like spread chaos to those who should be punished I thank you for reading this comment.

I say give him an uninhabited part of the everfree, then he won't use Ponyville as a playground

I think his freedom was wanting to have friends.I think?

Twilight should make him a fake magical reality where he can do what every he wants for a while and satisfy his need for freedom and then come back out

He could have the everfree forest and the castle of the two sis to make chaos on ps not zecoras place

What if he created a little room/dimension to turn around 😜

i think the main six could create discord his own dimension to decorate?... with rainbow power📊

Anyone notice who the fair was celebrating when discord intervened with Twilight and Cadence's together time? :3

Mabey they could set an area of land for discord to go crazy in

I know they should give him a abandon pece of land that he can do whatever he wonts with. Lest that will solve the problem of him turning on the ponies again.

Re-Treehouseify Twi's Castle? Did you miss the part where it's a TREE OF HARMONY?

Would be Cool if Celestia would give Discord a part of Equestria where is none population where he can do what ever he want to do... :D

Hmmmmmmm....if discord is going to be a part of the elements of harmony......I say he is the element of peace......because he realized that friendship is more powerful than evil and chaos......any opinions about this?

Give discord a piece of land (where no one lives) and problem solved.

give discord some land tht he can do whatever he wants with and then on a day of the year he can do whatever he wants

During the first few seconds of the video, a part of Discord´s arm is missing ^^

Easy. Discord gets the old abandoned castle in the Everfree :)

Discord creates an alternate dimension so he can reek havoc there

WHY NOT GIVE HIM THE EVER-FREE FOREST TO DORK AROUND IN!!??!!!
i mean....
1.Ponies avoid that area, for the most part, so causing chaos there wouldn't effect the pony inhabitants.
2. The area is well known as  dangerous/abnormal , for the plants, animals and weather, so even if Discord were to change things up to fit his "style" the way the forest is seen then/now would be basically the same. 
3. He could recycle the old castle of the Pony sisters and give it some use. (instead of being a decaying plot of land)
4. He could benefit Equestia by using his chaos to keep evil inhabitants of the forests  (like timber wolves) at bay, and away from the ponies; even providing safe passage to ponies passing through.

  This solution, in turn, accomplishes three goals....
1.GIVE DISCORD A PLACE A PLACE OF HIS OWN CLOSE TO PONYVILLE. (the new friendship empire)
,2.GIVE DISCORD FREEDOM TO EXPEND HIS NATURAL ABILITIES.
3. GIVE DISCORD THE POWER TO BREAK OFF THIS FEAR EQUESTIRA BEARS TOWARD HIM.
4. GIVE DISCORD A CHANCE TO PROVE HIS FRIENDSHIP TO THE MANE 6, AND THE REST OF EQUESTIRA BY BEING SIMPLY HIMSELF

That's my piece thank-you very much~! bows 

(also Fluttershy visiting him in the forest with a picnic, or just going to see him cause now he's CLOSE now, seems ssoooooo~ooooo cute! doki doki 0v0......^0^ SO CUTE! <3)

I think discords freedom is to escape from freindshi9 and become chaos

I think the princesses should give discord the ever free forest to be himself except I didn't think about zacora maybe zacora wouldn't mind

So I take it that you ship Fluttercord? Awesome, because they're my favorite ship!

give discord a little bit of land he can do whatever he wants to it

4:42 well he has his own house and it's kinda like that

Why not give Discord a piece of Equestria and call it Chaos Corner or something?

Maybe Discord could have a special day to PRANK ponies. Only to prank and be a little free

Celestia giving Discord his own island that is all i got

When he feels da need to wreak havock he can do it DEEP in da everfree forest

I wish that all of the mane six could become allcorn

Give him a space ( preferably next to fluttershy's') to rece havoc on really anything...

3:48 guess what, Season 5 episode 3 "make this castle a home" (or whatever the actual name is)

they should give land in a bubble :)

Hmm let's see give discord an abandoned town in the everfree forest and let him do whatever he wants? (I had story of the blanks flashbacks typing this so I hope you love this idea)

i know this is odd but what about the books themselves what is ponyvilliw gonna do when they need a book

couldn't discord have a part of equestria to do that stuff

I think they will retreehouseify the castle in "Castle Sweet Castle."

So did this season finale poke a hole in your discord is starswirl the bearded? It did kinda for me

She gets her tree house 🏡

Yeah that’s cute it makes mad 😡 that he betrayed her

Simple he gets ONE day every two months to make chaos on a small or abandoned town

Maybe the ponies could let Discord wreak havoc if;
it didn't harm anybody, thing
he fixed it up afterwards

Now he has his alternate dimension home where he cam me chaotic

He can create a little caous on April 1

give him his own land he can do whatever with

Discord sould own the ever-free forest, his own chaotic place of freedom

Why not give him a small part of the ever free forest to do what he wants with.

Give Discord a useless wasteland to chaos-ify!!!!

i agree, they need her libary/tree

NEW CONSPIRACY: PINKIE PIE IS PLAYED BY MEGAN MCCARTHY

HOLY TREE OF HARMONY!!!

The sound at 2:06 is the same as HUMAN FLUTTERSHY when human Rainbow Dash said the Rainbooms could play her song!

Coincidence? I think NOT!

(Points to anypony who knows that quote.)

But if discord doesn't betrayed them, Twilight wouldn't get the necklace thing and the mane 6 cannot unlock the chest and defeat tirek.

Take a piece of ponyville and let discord do anything with it

The flutter shy part so funny

Get an entire fake world for discord full of fake ponies to wreak havoc on and no one (except for the ponies (and twighlights tree house. Lol) ) get hurt. Win win.

give discord a small land he can do what ever he wants on

I know the name of the music played during the moment of silence. Its called 'Asleep the Snow Came Flying.'

Fluttercord and Disshy, huh? I assume you ship Fluttercord, like I do. :) Cuz that would be AWESOME.

I didn't even notice the passing of the amulet in three's a crowd

When u pointed out 'these ponies' u forgot to point out spike, he made that face too

R.I.P

Twilight's Libary 2010-2015

if he had some land to himself it wood help

he should have a sort of play area

The solution is twilight gives discord some land to be free so whenever he feels like chaos he can do it there. Now I'll make this comment longer muahahahah

The triangle charm thing discord gave twilight made me think "illuminati"

They had to make the rainbow power ponys, so rainbow rocks and that box with the 6 keys make since. Now that they have rainbow power, they can use it in equestira girls, now with the new movie coming out soon.
I was not happy too see rainbow power, at first, now I'm OK with it.
I also like twilights castle!!!!!! Its nice.
RAINBOW ROCKS!!!!!!!
bye :)

DISCORD DAY!!!!!!!!!!!! Have a day dedicated to Discord wrecking havoc all over Equestria. He can just clean it up later lol I just liked the sound of Discord Day

maybe they can give discord a plot of land ponies dont use like in bride of discord?

This is random but did you know that season 5 is coming out spring in 2015?! I saw it on a commercial and totally freaked the freak out!

He was SO fanboying... Also, excuse me; I have a corner that requires my undivided attention...

Discord should be given a plot of land(maybe in the Everfree Forest) where he can do anything he wants.

let discord turn ponyville into chaos every other thursday.

Does anyone notice twilight saying yes behind the sound of the clop in the ending BROHOOF

He could simply just annoy the ever living crap out of sun butt, because SHE can't turn him to stone no more

Back to stone Discord would have been sent back to stone

HOW ARE THEY FLYING SIDEWAYS?

take a uninhabitable corner of equestria ,and let discord do thangs.

And twilight a tree house is now a castle and twilights happy for it because one she feels that she has a purpose as a princess

Now and again make it rain chocolate milk! He gets my vote!

oh good heavens, that audio quality. the good old days of 2014 youtube

i say let Discord and Pinkie team up ((no not like a shipping)) I'm thinking Discord and the chocolate factory. those two bouncing off the wall ideas off eachother and her mirror pool clones can be the staff.

EMEGESH I HAD A REALIZATION, maybe more people has but whatevsss, so in your theories you state that discord is the unicorn that twi admires (forgot his name sorry) and that twi was actually clover the clever, so maybe somehow twilight knew that her mentor was going to turn into discord, but she didnt really tell him so she wont alter the future, and by the time passes she tries to turn discord into her mentor once again by defeating him and reforming him..? i dont know if that makes sense but ;-;

they do take the roots of her old house and make it a chandelier in the castle

Give discord his own land

In threes a crowd cadence and twilight go to the end of equestrian and nobody lives there I think discord can go there and when ever he wants to do a littel chaos he can do it there not harming pony's

give discord the castle of the two pony sisters a territory where discord can release his caose☺

i ship celestia and discord but Fluttercord is really cute :3

2:12 DAT FACE!! XD

Maybe they could make Discord his own place to be crazy and random like a land called crazy world or something like that.

Merbe celesty could make discord his own realm or wuteves and he could live there and visit ponyville when he wants or whateva

Oh ma gawd brony notion throwback! Such different videos!

I didn’t know anyone else did a tribute to the tree house thank god I’m not alone

at 2:31 rainbow has a broken wing

Give discord the castle of the 2 sisters with fluttershy as his wife (wink wink)

solution: Allow Fluttershy to do this cause you know SHIP SHIP SHIP!

R.I.P Twilight's library we will miss you 😛

on "bride of discord" discord got his own land to spread chaos in

Hey, your not the only one who ships fluttercord. I do too.

its easy in an arey outside of ponyvil discord can make nice chaos so his friend can vist

Give discord a pilce to be him.

i think discord can have a nice room in flutters home were he can make caos [ sorry if spelled wrong ]

other than princess luna discord would need to be my favorite

2:12 INCREDIBLY LOL

I like Flutterdash a lot more than Fluttershy/Discord

I wonder what happened to twilight's owl-

I think discord should be sent to live in the everfree forest

I would allow discord to a few days called discord day every year and end of every Discord Day every thing will reset to the previous morning including if somepony got kill or died They would wake the previous morning just would everypony else would

That audio quality tho 👌

And twilight didn't even say thank you to discord

He was ivel becouse he could have friendship and ivel, but be good after he could not have both things, I think

If you watch LittleShyFim I saw in one of his videos Twilights castle literally looks like a middle finger ( the stem )

R.I.P twilights tree house...😪😭

Give him his own land maybe?

I have one question though......why did hashbro go with those silly looking rainbow power designs?I mean yeah......they look funny but those hairs?Good grief!Have they really ran out of ideas?

little question,can i be in the brony notion even though im a girl

You can ask discord to go to the space and do whatever there.

I think the ponies should make discord a place to go wild

tie hi up in a no magic spell or something and show him a la his baby pictures!

discord day aka April fools day discord is free to do what ever he wants for one day he stars wanting more they can just use rainbow powers

Pinkie and/or Rainbow Dash needs to teach Discord how to prank people. It would be a nice outlet for Discords Chaos, retouch on a part of Rainbow Dash's and Pinkie's character from season one, and just be funny for us to watch. 

move discord to a big cage with fake ponys and stuff he will make miscief instead of all over ponyville.

When it comes to pinkie pie's gift: There is a rumor saying that Pinkie is getting a mate in season 5 :3 Cross your fingers for Cheese sandwich :3

Admit it. You're a shipper...

OK I will amit it it was pretty awesome come on their hair but I don't think the keys had to do with it it could of been Discord :-\ :-[ :-)

Shipping fuel to the max right here

They need to give him his own little area with no pony around to be chaotic. As we all know their are different dimensions in MLP [ Equestrian girls ] their should be one or two dimensions people don't mind him being able to teleport from and to. LIKE COME ON I can name 1000000000000 shows on TV with deserted dimensions MLP must have at least 2 dimensions that he can teleport 2 and back. Maybe its like his place he can visit when he is not busy having picnics with Fluttershy and giving Twilight nice necklaces [ 2 amulets from Discord in one season. he's a great  character but seriously]! Well any way if Megan Macalsky adds it im having a party ! P.S: IF Megan Macalsky is reading this make Fluttershy and Discords love thing happen.

let him out of the out of the stone and hug him

Sawtooth waves they put her memories in cristals

R.I.P Twilights house but what if Discord never betrayed the mane 6 then the sixth key would not of been found In this episode

the three alicrons were making a......TRIANGLE DUN DUN DUN ILLMITNE CONFROMED

3:38 we have that play set XD

use discord to lay waste to equstrias enemys

easy find a place where no one lives a big plot of land and just say to discord when you feel the need to go nuts come here and go nuts

Make an area for discord to wreak havoc.

give him the grounds of the roller pony sires (bride of discord) and the fact he has puppy dog eyes for flutters is to cute!!!! 

your moment of silence isn't silent.... XD

Maby he can have some proprty called"kaos space"to wreak havoc on and not pony vile(sorry dumb spell check thing)

have discord back in his true nature 

give him space somwhere where no pony lives

DOESNT HE HAVE A REALM TO DO DAT IN???

3:37 BUY OUR TOYS

Please, make a video about Sprinkle Stripe, Lucky dreams and Lovestruck, becouse they're all looks like Mane Six.

You kinda predicted season 5 episode 3...

yeesh, looks like they went super sayan at the end of the episode

I know why discord said those things about fluttershy. Because he is in love with fluttershy.

Rip Twilight library tree 😢

Discord has his own world

I think maybe having something you know we have April Fool's here why don't we have something like over there the question or ask that signifies that particular day just for disc or as long as if no pony gets hurt I personally say he should have a day dedicated to him once a year so he can be able to express himself and be able to let loose without being so easily convinced of what freedom is course we all should know that freedom doesn't necessarily mean just to be free to do things estate of mine

Rest In Peace
Golden Oak Library





That's what twilight's home was called right?

let discord have fun on the moon.

What in season 5 it's showing he has his own dimantion to live in

2 be honest I like discords version of ponyvile better

flutter cord, so adorable

ITS THE SEASON 6 ENDING THAT PROVED FLUTTER CORD

Twilight's library
2010-2014
never forget :'((((

:'( R.I.P Golden Okes Library.

Discord can have a building blocks set that he can destroy!!! dabs

Maybe if fluttershy like did her stare on the pony/creature not giving discord freedom and befriended them so they could see what
Friendship is like.

Well I think that is the best sulwshn for discord the literal Speer it of crazy

R.I.P Twilights Tree House

The UTIAMTE betrayal was the season 9 >:(

I sujest the princesses make a dumetions that Discord could bring chaos to.

I miss twilights old tree house but I like the new house or castle to hey don't blame me I'm a girl 😝

I hope they build on the fact of discord having a crush on flutter shy in season five  

Turn him to stone!!!!!😣😣

A bit of land to go krazy with

Let him have a place to be kaoic

his own half of eqestria! seems fair right >:)

one day a month when discord can create as much chaos as he wants for the entire day without hurting anypony. Than at the end of the day he snaps his fingers and it's all fixed. That would be fun and entertaining!  

THE 90s ARE BACK! (I'm talking about the rainbow powered hair)

Get his own smal kingdom

ok so discord wants freedom right? Why wont he gets his own little plot of land to do his chaos magic thing.....ya :D

and spike was there two he was with the Maine six two did ya forget about him

Discord deserves freedom

Easy give discord a pocket dimension to make chaos in stede of pony vill

Golden Oak Library Replaced with Middle finger Castle

I like to think that all the objects reappeared in the castle.

TWILIGHT CASTLE LOOKS LIKE A MIDDLE FINGER ok i’m done now

your complaint number 1: come on! if you would become a prince or king, it would take long to adjust to it. Number 2: have you heard of something being dramatic?  After such a good season, i think hasbro deserved this. YOU ARE OVER REACTING, this is a CHILDRENS show, you are becoming Digibro

0:12 Anypony else see Twilight give the camera an annoyed look !

Twilight's' home is now the so called "Monstrosity".

>library gets destroyed
>ice house thingy appears
my books, why? ;_;

discord,his mother and father were the only dacanagirsedv (how do spell),then discord's mother and father die and he trys to forget his pain with crazy-ness

(for cows)
moo moo:moo moo moo moo moo mooooooo moo

hmm lets think discord--twilight--library--castle--fluttershy--love
is this what the video is about ?

Dude, you missed the point of the entire show. The entire series is one long toy commercial. The only reason Hasbro made the MLP cartoon was to make sales for a declining toy franchise.

4:04 evryone sad-HASBRO:BUY OUR TOYS BUY OUR TOYS BUY OUR TOYS BUY OUR TOYS BUY OUR TOYS BUY OUR TOYS BUY OUR TOYS BUY OUR TOYS BUY OUR TOYS BUY OUR TOYS

Dont yall think the cutiemark chronicals should get their cutiemarks in season 6 or something im getting annoyed #needmorecutiemarks

lett him have his own space to cors KAOSS

Maby use magic to give him a realm where chaos is everywhere. O i donno maby he can name it HELL! Celestia is God in Eqestria....when ponys say O My God, they say O My Celestia. So it makes sense to think of discord as the devil. Where luna falls in this, i donno.

His own area to cause chaos

0:01 Wtf is with his lion arm?

2:48 The egs are NOT CANON !

Give him his on town. Kinda like they don't did in bats

DISCORDS OWN DIMENSION COLD BE WHERE HE GETS ALL CHAOS-Y 
its another dimension that celestia gave him that allows him to make chaos and keep her kingdom safe
HMMMMMMMMMMMMM

nothing is worse than equistria girls
EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Twilight’s Treehouse
Rest in spaghetti
Never forghetti

Discord's box..oh sorry not like Pandora's box XD I mean like a 1 mile maybe? a half? Spot of property for discord!

Turn discord into stone..........again!

2:55, Equesteria Girls, if you remember, is NOT cannon

Great idea TimeKaiser !

You do realize you said fluttercord and DISHY

A arce of equestria to himself

Omg omg at 4:13 look at the dots inside of the triangle that the three allicorns are making, if u look really closely at it, it kinda looks like an eye... O. o

well brony notion thats true
because in episode Castle sweet Castle she didnt feel like home
i think the ending would be more nice if they had shown tgat she got her "TREE" HOUSE back with her castle.

Tree chandelure, imbued with gems of all the good memories!

make a hole universe thats lush and not alot of animals and put discord in it so he can do whatever
oh he destroyed that one? make it again
oh he destroyed that one? make it again

It's not things that keep friends together just like what apple Jack said

Read DisneyFantic's fan fictions and because of flutter shy discord is then able to control his chaos as he lives a happy life.

He's both bad and good.
: .)

i thick he want reveng for being stone for 1000 years

let discord help pinkie with her parties

A Facebook Page Just for Twilight's Library????? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

because he was a power crazed lunatic. Who would give that up??

turn discord to stone!😠

But is Treelibrary Kill?!?!?!? *X-files theme plays

Umm discord gets his own area to mess with?

Foreshadowing? Yes!

If Discord likes chaos, I HAVE AN IDEA THAT MAYBE SAVE EQUESTRIA! Discord is friends with Fluttershy right, FLUTTERCORD FOREVER! Anyways if he would do anything for Fluttershy he could do this, If any evil thing or something Discord can use his chaos on the evil guy and he can enjoy the chaos he is commiting

I think I know why flutter shy like discord so much on discord like flutter shy so much because flutter shy takes care of animals and likes animals and can talk to animals but every single pony can talk to discord but what are shy I don’t think he knows that because the school is a animal so that’s why flutter shy like discord the most

You obviously haven't seen Season Five Episode Three Castle Sweet Castle yet.

TAKE. HIM TO EARTH AND RELEASE HECK ON US SO WE GET TO SEE DISCORD!!!!!!!!!!!

B-but chaos is fun

okay i think letting discord bring a little bit of chaos like the cholate rain would be okay and like maybe putting chaos to good? 

4:18 ILLUMINATI CONFIRMED

you forgot the roots on the roof

that is why he wanted freedom

oh oh or he can come to our world every now and then and make it total chaos. please do

Also R.I.P twilight's libraru

discord should have a speciel place or part in equestrea equeistria where he can go...................................................................
WILD

ehhhhhh,so is discord gonna keep cracking?

R.i.p. Library 😭

Have a designated area for discord to do is magic in

How about giving dicord the castle of the two sisters

Umm OH I KNOW Discord shuld have his OWN pece of land like the casel of the royle pony sisters and the ever green forest right?

My birthday was on the same day TK ran, and the song about her role was so cringe-worthy I cried, which is when I got a year older. -_-

Your crazy I already have that play set

I think they should just give some land. thats not where anyone lives so he could just rep havoc there and not go chaos crazy again.

I ship Celesticore!

Also is it just me or am I the only one that does not care about tree house being blown up???

fluttershy and disscord falling in LOVE

I don't like discord anymore after the awful final

he gets a part of the ever free forest mabie?

4:15 ILLUMINATI CONFIRMED !?!?!??!?!?!??!?!?!?!?!?!?

THIS IS NOT FOR REAL I JUST WANNA HHAVE A LAUGH so discord should be a pony hhahahahahhahahahahahahahahaah😂

0:32 TWILIGHT SPARKLE WORKS FO THE ILLUMINATI

You should watch THE BRIDE OF DISCORD.

Let discord cause giant chaos+confuison to villans placees

Did he just ad the twighlight treehouse part for filler

anyone who makes fluttershy  cry deserves a punch in the face.

GONE GONE GONE GONE EVERYTHING GONE GONE GONE GONE GONE GONE GONE GONE GONE GONE GONE GONE GONE GONE Also flutter cord does anyone remember that moment when Fluttershy was saying we aren't worth it then discord is like you are I get teared up trying to tell people about it I'm crying on phone screen thinking about fluttercord I mean disshy I mean shipping shipping shipping shipping shipping shipping shipping shipping shipping shipping shipping shipping
seriously though rip twilights house
join the rip twilights libary Facebook page

Awesome and cute.

XD he ships flutter cord you know wut Brony I respect that

a thing they choud do is give discord his own land to rule over there he choud make ash mutch chaos ash he wants to make

he got brainwashed by tirek

He said said a moment of silence.
Play's music

I like conspirapon3 s take on it

discord is a double alicorn?i mean look at him he has tow horns a chicken hand a bear hand and..…bla bla bla im boring to tell everything

COME ONNN!!!
In which of those houses wold YOU live in eh EH?

That face

me:*crying*WHY TWILIGHT'S TREE HOUSE?!?!?!?!?
sombra:*blasts sonamyfan1256
me:*covered in ash*COUGH*anyway...R.I.P: twilight's old*cough*library*faints from coughing alot

DUDE DIDN'T YOU HEAR? ON THE equestria NEWS TWILIGHT'S HOUSE WAS RE-CREATED AND TURNED BACK TO A TREE-HOUSE!!!

Less freedom for discord!

Memories are not in those objects gifts. They are in us. Aah axel (lea) from kingdom hearts should teach you a lesson. Got it memorized?

Ummmmmm in the season 5 trailer twilight and spike hugged and cried about twilight 's library




(I'm not joking. )

you ruined my childhood 😪

tears P.S spoiler alert in a episode they 5 other ponies decorate twilights castle with the remains of her old house.p.s I wrote this on 12-21-2017

descored does have freedom he just does"int youse it in the seris

Transform your OC to a human form MLPEG

TOTAL CHAOS!!! thats my slouition

I can't believe you ship Fluttercord.😑

Disshy...shiping so hard!

3:36
Oh Hasbro had to make it the middle finger

I kinda wish that they would just stick to the ponies instead of Equetria Girls

Who is best villain? Reformed or not?

i love discored XD

Solution to discord for him to be free send him off too another dimension. done good alrighty 

He moves in a howes !

Ok so do you ponies know why Tia said that a birth of an Alicorn is something Eqestria has never seen?
Because she didn't want any pony to know she has a big casin thats why!

twilight 's home r.i.p😢

Cough fluttercord Cough Cough Cough Cough Cough Cough Cough dies of hardtack

RIP twighlight house

Sentimental objects are nothing! Merchandise is more important!

walks to discord's house

Create Chaosville!!!!

DAMN YOU HASBRO!!!!!

But I do miss her library

WHATS AN MLG THING DOING IN AN MLP VIDEO!?

I all the items the mane 6 got from ponies who's lives were changed by them but they still remember them and if they forget don't they still have that journal that they wrote in?

Simple
Choas # evil

OMFG IDEA (dear Hasbro) Discord could have his own part of equestria to wreck havoc in then he will not be harming everypony ELSE kind of like starlight glimmer and ugh 💩EQUALIST💩 village shudders in disgust 😛BUT WITH DISCORD INSTEAD!!:D

R.I.P Tree

Really I did have a moment of silence

ok so  princess celesia  gets her blue green pink flowy mane luna gets her stary-night flowy mane and princess cadence gets her long white pink purple mane though twilight does have some color in her mane she just has 2 stripes so I think twilight should be able to get hat amazing mane we saw in season 4 fanile!!!

0:56 THANK YOU! suck it maleficent haters!

rest in peace

twilights castle is a crystal tree with her cutie mark

please do face reveal your my fav youtuber

Maybe... Maybe this means that EqG isn't cannon after all! HURAY!!!1

Dude. That was not silence.

Fluttershy and Discord sitten in a tree k-I-s-s-I-n-g!!

i think they did not ment to put a same seen in the same ep

R.I.P Twilight Sparkle's Treehouse.

So true you are amazing pony power

The castle sweet castle episodes that the tree chandelier represents the golden oak library memories


REMEMBER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

RIP Twilight's old home 

I blame twilight

Discord and flutter shy get married and princess clelasity gets jelus and ruins the wedding

I don't really like equestria girls. I REALLY don't like that they're making a sequel to Equestria Girls

now sing the F***ing national anthom

Woah when he show us discord and Mane chix rainbow had wing bent

To do what he wants for a while and then stop OR do what he wants NOT in ponyville OR honestly I forgot what I was gonna say ORANGE JUICE

In the dream world twilight maked her treehouse aigen

I love the backwards all new and hub lol

discrot has a crush on fluttershy but she see's him as a dad is my trery .

DO HARDCORE

YOU KNOW WHATS MY COMPLAINT?!?!?!? *turns around and shoots fluttercord ship* *turns back around with shades on* thug life(THIS IS FOR CELESTIACORD MUAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA)

Oh my god we were talking about equetria girls marketing

Isn't Megan Mcarthy a Viner

lol you are so funny

Ok so in the NEXT season they cre8 a tribute

he wants to be a pony

Give him a plot of land where he can do whatever he wants!!!!
Duh!!!!!!!

Hi im thinking about making a pony OC channel do you have any advice? Thank you ;)

tree house not gone the root of the tree is going to be in the new one.

discord is part of the ilummanti

how about one that looks like 4:42

0.0 maybe T what's-his-name (XD) was the Shadow "Pony"! (that was off topic but still lolz) that would explain the shadow's yellow glowingish eyes and why it was so tall. idk lol

Dat face is so funny!!!!!!hahahahahahahahahhehehehehhehehehe

Introduce Discord to Minecraft

Seriously?????????????????


RIP Twilight's library home.

twilight's castle's living room has the roots of the library as a chandelier

Meh. At least Twilight's new place doesn't look like it belonged to the Beirsteined Bears.

im on discrords side I will get you freedom discrord>:(

WHAT IS THAT SAD MUSIC?!?

Discord macks a kasel whith some land given him so he can have some fun

Ya Maddie Labb I agree 10000000 prensent they should let discord spread chaos in the castle of the two pony sisters because that place is aboned like in bride of discord

1:12 LOL THATS MY WALLPAPER XD

Discord = CHAOOOOOSSSSS CONNNTROOOOOLLLLLLLLLL

Why did you say fluttercord?

I liked twilites old house better

Discord's Theme Parks

season 6 might not come out

IS NOT FLUTTERCORD!!! It's fluttermac

It sounds like you used to record on a toaster lol

me too
it's already 2016

But this is kinda like sunset shimmer she gave up her greed so discord gave up his chaos

LOL 2:11 XD

I say he can do chocolate rain but no further

ASK FOR HELP DISCORD

discord needs love your love brony notion kiss discord

create a place (CONTENT)for animals or draconocus whatever stuff to rome free
discord would live there duh!

hey I'm born in 5th October , that's when twilight's treehouse was demolished 😟😭

My mind is blown

there not lost they were made into a castle who repersent their friendhsip

I ship it!

whatch season 5 they put memories in her castle the roots

RIP Library

FLUTTERCORD?!?!? DISHSHY?!?!?!??! BRUH! IT'S FLUTTERSHY AND DISCORD >.> XD sorry but its true

I don't get it. What's wrong with the shot?

I know! Pinkie pie parties!

2:36 pinkie pie looks like she hates the world!

Give a little bit of land to play with.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣😂😂🤣🤣😂 you are so fane

and its DARK VERY DARK

I am amazed he's not a dispie is the pinkie pie x discord thing

Whey bella bunny that is genius

Explain tirek then

Her house died on my birthday WHY?!?!?

FLUTTERCORD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FINALLY A YOUTUBER WHO SHIPS THEM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD