The real question is what actual horses would turn into in the Equestria world

@EpiclyR3MON it worked really well in the original series, although the original series also had different rules.

@•shi• there is a human in the mlp world. Lyra is a human XD

Carriages.

You can kill me for this joke

@🌸SidTheCoolBoy2007🌷 no they would be horses

@Craft _ Motion ponies exist irl aswell just not Pegasi and unicorns

@ShadowJennifer good memory indeed and that horse doesn't look anything like what they have in equestria, not even similar to Saddle Arabians.

@Alegria Déesse I remember seeing a horse in friendship through the ages when sunset was riding Apple Jack's horse.

@ForgottenFile_EXE.5 oh so then what are they gonna turn into? Flying cars?

@hi. NO too simple I’m ashamed you would even think that

I saw this question so i'm just gonna copy and paste my response:
Time to be a nerd-

Ok so like, I think since the horse is an animal the horse would be non-sentient. Once the  horse went through the portal it would automatically become sentient, yet still be a horse. However, going back through the portal would not change the fact it is already sentient. It is like how EQG Twilight's spike went through the portal and back and could talk. Equestrias spike also did not stop being  sentient once going through the portal. I've also heard that this could be how equastria was founded, but this couldnt be true since both portals seemed to be man made. One was made by twilight, i assume, and the other was made by whoever made the statue infront of the school.

Also: When EQG spike went through the portal he still stayed a dog, just like non-human animals might, like the horse

YOU! YOU READ MY THOUGHT! YOU A WIZARD! I'M CALLING THE SPANISH INQUISITION!

Eloise.exe has stopped working due to serious questions

The biggest question is that why are horses treated like, well horses in the pony world.

Maybe they just become non-sentient horses (we have horses in Equestria) or ponies

A pony, and like human world spike after visit it would talk

@•shi• THE FACT THAT HUMANS EXIST IN THE MLP WORLD IN OLDER GENERATIONS NOT IN G4 I THINK- IT SEEMS SO WEIRD.

Well, did we see any human world ponies, horses, cows, donkeys?<br>the only things we saw in both worlds are ladybugs, bunnies, birds, I count a cat and a duck in Fluttershy's bag in the friendship games, OMG WINONA IS A DOOOOG

Well, did we see any human world ponies, horses, cows, donkeys?
the only things we saw in both worlds are ladybugs, bunnies, birds, I count a cat and a duck in Fluttershy's bag in the friendship games, OMG WINONA IS A DOOOOG

Actual horses would probably end up looking like the delegates from Saddle Arabia.

Wait, if a pony goes into the equestrian world, would it turn into a human that can’t talk?

I think the magic would keep them horses or ponies but the magic would add more sentience considering Equestria their animals are more sentient idk they seem more intelligent so I think that would be the side effects

@•shi• wouldnt they just turn into a pony?

Actual people….HEY HASBRO WE NEED TO SEE THIS

Wait so piggybacking off of what the person 2 replies above me said, horses are not ponies so maybe the humans we see are creatures called Equestria girls and are not real humans, which is why their anatomy is so bad. So human -> horse and horse -> human

you guys are thinking about horses but mlp are ponies, so the real question is what actual PONIES* would turn into in the Equestria World

Wouldn't they become human in the pony world?

<b>creator's mind.exe has stopped working</b>

*creator's mind.exe has stopped working*

They could stay as it because real horses can exist in Equestria too.


Sawtooth: There’s just no way to know until a changeling actually goes through-
Also Sawtooth: realizing they are a changeling
Also Sawtooth:*devise plan to break into Twilight’s Castle*

Sawtooth: There’s just no way to know until a changeling actually goes through-
Also Sawtooth: *realizing they are a changeling*
Also Sawtooth:*devise plan to break into Twilight’s Castle*

@Amwer I DIDNT KNOW U WATCH SAWTOOTH WAVES-

@~HoneyMoon~ wait a minute…
WAIT A MINUTE
YOUR HERE

Oml true i was gonna comment that but urs s better


I love how he's physically disgusted with the diamond dogs

They shouldn't make them turn into a human it's really disgusting just no no I just hate it

I mean, front-facing spot was terrifying.

I thought Cadence look funky but the Diamond dogs in EqG make me regret thinking that!

If they had jobs it’s obvious the Diamond Dogs would be miners

I laughed quite a bit when he did that. 🤣

I don't know who wouldn't. I mean look at them! Especially the small one. yikes

@coldhaixx <b>this is so cursed its true</b>

The little one reminds me of mineta from mha


maybe it's based on their personality, like how spike used to assist twilight all the time and sometimes gets petted like a dog.

@Funtime *error* Oh, ok.<br>A FNaF fan, eh? Alrighty then

@Funtime *error* Oh, ok.
A FNaF fan, eh? Alrighty then

@Funtime *error* are griffons, yaks, kirins,... treated as pets or slaves?

@Le Croissant Girl have you seen the spring breakdown episode? Look it up

@Alegria Déesse yeah but don’t most if not all ponies get treated the same way? I mean not like pets or slaves or any of that, they’re all treated as ponies

right, i feel like its just a matter of manifestation. not as simple as pony = human and dragon = dog.

I was just about to write something similar, glad I looked first. 😂

I would also think that maybe Star's cutie mark would be the symbol of her Wand. But as it changes appearance so many times, it obviously couldn't be that.<br>And cutie marks also derive from discovering one's true calling, or destiny, which is shown to be the case the most in the Friendship is Magic series. For instance, it took the Cutie Mark Crusaders a long time to find their true calling, and when they did, their cutie marks appeared. For Star Butterfly, she spent the first two seasons, trying to learn more about life on Earth, but in the last two seasons, she discovers the her destiny is to defend Mewni, her home. So maybe her cutie mark would depict something like that. But I still think she'd become a Unicorn

I would also think that maybe Star's cutie mark would be the symbol of her Wand. But as it changes appearance so many times, it obviously couldn't be that.
And cutie marks also derive from discovering one's true calling, or destiny, which is shown to be the case the most in the Friendship is Magic series. For instance, it took the Cutie Mark Crusaders a long time to find their true calling, and when they did, their cutie marks appeared. For Star Butterfly, she spent the first two seasons, trying to learn more about life on Earth, but in the last two seasons, she discovers the her destiny is to defend Mewni, her home. So maybe her cutie mark would depict something like that. But I still think she'd become a Unicorn

And cutie marks also tie into the special abilities or the name of these ponies. Now take the main character from Star vs. the Forces of Evil, for instance. Her name is Star Butterfly and she already has a sort of symbol in the series itself. It's a star, representing her name, a butterfly, representing the royal family, and a heart, representing her signature cheekmarks. So if she were to ever travel to Equestria, her cutie mark would probably consist of two or more of these symbols<br>And as the breed of pony she would become, that part is quite simple: Star Butterfly was already born with magic powers and is already very much associated with unicorns, so obviously she would become a Unicorn, right?

And cutie marks also tie into the special abilities or the name of these ponies. Now take the main character from Star vs. the Forces of Evil, for instance. Her name is Star Butterfly and she already has a sort of symbol in the series itself. It's a star, representing her name, a butterfly, representing the royal family, and a heart, representing her signature cheekmarks. So if she were to ever travel to Equestria, her cutie mark would probably consist of two or more of these symbols
And as the breed of pony she would become, that part is quite simple: Star Butterfly was already born with magic powers and is already very much associated with unicorns, so obviously she would become a Unicorn, right?

I'm more interested in what a humanoid creature, who never been to Equestria would become. I'm guessing if ponies become humans then it must work the other way around too, right? Well if it is based off of personality, just like cutie marks are based off personality, then what about the breed of pony these people would become? Would personality also determine whether they'd become an Earth Pony, Pegasus, or Unicorn?

Like when the show first started they made toy spike stand on all fours like a dog

I literaly just wrote somthing in a similar vain great minds think alike.

then I would have expected the students from the human world to be more diverse as they went through the portal...

Oh no i just finished writing a comment with the similar theory, well your take on it was cool, i completely forgot he got petted sometimes.


"equine creatures become humans. If not, hooved creatures become humans"
Discord: *visible confusion*

"equine creatures become humans. If not, hooved creatures become humans"
Discord: **visible confusion**

discord becomes the app of the same name

@Alegria Déesse that would be chaotically funny

I always felt Discord would be a goat, cause he looks like one to me

if hooved creatures become humans what about discord

I totally see Discord go "Rules ain't for me" and staying his good old self

Im pretty sure hes a human cause i saw discord in the do it for the ponygram skit-

Imagine he goes through and is just a screaming pile of flesh lol

hahaha yup, discord would become...uh discord?


Sawtooth going through the portal would be a face reveal ngl

What about hive high cuz he's an UN-reformed changeling


the funny thing is that they're litteraly getting tired of saying the alicorn names lol like you can hear it in their voice they are getting tired of saying them😂

@I ❤ Florida/Warrior Cat Fan Actually, they/them pronouns can be used for everyone, if you're not feeling like a she or he, you can use they!

@ItsMeKristina They means multiple people try “it.”

@ItsMeKristina oh Im sorry! I never heard anything about this I will edit my comment to fit with this new information right away! Thank you for informing me 😁

@ShadowMoonlight_LPS no. I was talking about "he". Their pronouns are they/them.

@ItsMeKristina they? I think them is correct but if your talking about pronouns then I'm sorry I was not aware


I thought you were going to talk about age. Adult Princess of Friendship goes in. High school girl comes out.<br>Or maybe clothes? Naked pony goes in. Clothed human comes out. Not only clothed, but dressed in clothes consistent with her color scheme and interests.

I thought you were going to talk about age. Adult Princess of Friendship goes in. High school girl comes out.
Or maybe clothes? Naked pony goes in. Clothed human comes out. Not only clothed, but dressed in clothes consistent with her color scheme and interests.

Since the characters on both universe seem to stick to a theme or what they like or are, the Portal converts their cutiemark or essence into clothing that would match them.

I know it a character design thing but Rainbow Dash wears shorts and everyone dresses according to what they generally "are".

Also in the FiM they never stated how old they are but i think they are old enough to be teenagers or close enough in pony states? Once you past education, it seems nothing is holding you back so if you got the flair and bits, you can try your hand at whatever.

@Alegria Déesse Makes sense. Maybe in pony world they are older than in human world and different age than each others. Rainbow dash was the first one in her class to get her cutie mark, and Applejack was the last. They got their cutie marks at the same time, so Rainbow dash must be younger than Applejack.

@** mmmh... Rarity has hold her boutique for a while, I'd hardly believe she's a teenager...

In usa oldest high school students are 18, so maybe pony twilight is 18 in season 4 as well. Also in the first equestria Girls movie there were 3 pics of Sunset shimmer from every previous fall formal. I think the fall formal is held every schoolyear, so freshman, sophomore and junior. They're highschool seniors now.

@SoulBFKinz Katcupkakes5 APTWA Well, yeah, of course. But what are the magical mechanics behind it?

It is a kids show. Of course theyre going to give the humanized versions clothes.


the real question is: what would happen if an EQG horse went through the portal to Equestria? 🤔

A horse would probably become a neanderthal or a very tall human

@《☆PatchyKnight☆》 <br>I believe🌟 in horse-centaurs 😇

@《☆PatchyKnight☆》
I believe🌟 in horse-centaurs 😇

@Maria Tereza <br>"Explode"😯? Into a hundred pieces? 😲

@Maria Tereza
"Explode"😯? Into a hundred pieces? 😲

@Waluigi <br>Hey😠. Don't tell anybody to shut their mouths👄 up⬆, you Ebenezer old Grinch 😠

@Waluigi
Hey😠. Don't tell anybody to shut their mouths👄 up⬆, you Ebenezer old Grinch 😠

@Portable hole from the future <br>I like female♀ winged unicorn🦄 better 😇

@Portable hole from the future
I like female♀ winged unicorn🦄 better 😇

@}Nuqman_games{ <br>The Crystal🔮 Mirror is the magic🌠 portal🧿 between the Human👩 World🌎 of Canterlot High School🏫 and the Pony🦄 World🌍 of pony🦄 Equestria Land🏞, and it has the magic🌠 power🔋 of blending in. Creature🦄 by Pony🦄 World🌎 of pony🦄 Equestria Land🏞, and human👩 by Human👩 World🌏 of Canterlot High School🏫

@}Nuqman_games{
The Crystal🔮 Mirror is the magic🌠 portal🧿 between the Human👩 World🌎 of Canterlot High School🏫 and the Pony🦄 World🌍 of pony🦄 Equestria Land🏞, and it has the magic🌠 power🔋 of blending in. Creature🦄 by Pony🦄 World🌎 of pony🦄 Equestria Land🏞, and human👩 by Human👩 World🌏 of Canterlot High School🏫

Time to be a nerd-

Ok so like, I think since the horse is an animal the horse would be non-sentient. Once the  horse went through the portal it would automatically become sentient, yet still be a horse. However, going back through the portal would not change the fact it is already sentient. It is like how EQG Twilight's spike went through the portal and back and could talk. Equestrias spike also did not stop being  sentient once going through the portal. I've also heard that this could be how equastria was founded, but this couldnt be true since both portals seemed to be man made. One was made by twilight, i assume, and the other was made by whoever made the statue infront of the school.

Also: When EQG spike went through the portal he still stayed a dog, just like non-human animals might, like the horse

@}Nuqman_games{ Easy on the insults there, you’re misunderstanding what’s being talked about. In Equestria Girls (EQG), there are horses just like the ones in our world. The question is what would happen if one of those horses traveled through the portal going from EQG to Equestria. They wouldn’t be ponies because ponies are human in EQG.

@Minecraft gaming EQG stands for equestria girls which means a horse from the human world

@}Nuqman_games{ bruh we're talking about a horse in the human world going into the pony world not a human going through the portal

Simply put, I think they'll turn into a human.

@}Nuqman_games{ are u even talking about egq horses going in the portal to Equestria

What’s an EQG horse, I am guessing that they are real horses

@}Nuqman_games{ they are asking what would a human world horse/pony turn into if they went to equestria

@}Nuqman_games{ Maybe if you read my comment and the comment at the top of this thread properly, you would realise that we are theorising from the point of view from the human world. If you still can't figure it out, the existence of ponies in the human world imply that there are humans in the pony world too, otherwise what would these ponies transform into if they went through the portal from the human world.

Time to go bleach my mind!!! Pretty smart tho

They would become those rat horses discord created!!!!

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

Good question.

I want answers now.

They’d be a...human?
Ponies from equestria become humans when they go through the portal
Ponies/horses if they went through the portal possibly become a human
Maybe a monkey?
A pony form?

maybe the horse will start talking or something

Now I'm wondering how someone react if they're a non-pony creature and I went through the portal and they were just a horse

You guys didn't understand anything have you guys ever see that sunset is in the human world and go back to the Equestria They turn into pony idiot 😺😺😺😺😺

@RedPandaMurphy they're turn into pony just like the other friendship pony just use your brain

Well I think they will become Arabian horse or whatever they call it in Equestria

Yeah, if the eqg universe is like ours, they have pony’s and horses, so what would happen, do they just gain the ability to talk, become human, become completely different???

That does beg the question, if there are ponies in the human world, are there humans in the pony world?

@Desalegn Ogbamichael yeah you really didn't read it right lol

Pfttt oh no omg he is a changeling he can be a owl


When it comes to Changelings, I think it's simple. Changeling main power is changing into whatever they want, and the portal changes your appearance. Because of this, I believe changeling would be immune to the changes done by the portal. Discord may also be immune simply because the portal wouldn't know what to change him into.


Dogs represent loyalty spike is the most loyal dragon as he is extremely loyal to twilight

So it could be due to personality traits

And creatures that regularly perform trade or practice performed by humans transform into humans.


Personally I would love to see thorax drawn as a human

Why do I picture him as a cat in the human world?  Idk seems fitting for his personality


I thought it was based on how complex they're able to think. Like... most dragons originally were seen as just monstrous and didn't speak much nor live a "Civilized" life so to speak; however ponies and sirens and the diamond dogs do speak. The dogs wear clothes and I assume the sirens have some type of organized civilization of sorts.


"Owl Gallus isn't real, he can't hurt you."

Uhh I don’t think weird looking owls that came from a world of ponies hurt you

@Robyn Guthrie what is this gravity falls

wait what if an owl in the pony world went through the portal... what if it turned into a griffon in the human world

@BioniclesaurKing4t2 I see I’ve met someone of taste

This is gonna haunt my dreams for a while.

@BioniclesaurKing4t2 <b>not owl trowel!</b>

"Are piles of Gallus Owls blocking your mind thoughts?  Then you're gonna need Owl Trowel!"


It would actually be cool if he made a video of what happened to the cutie mark map when they all went separate ways I'm very curious to know what could have happened to it.


Hypothesis: Dragons would become wolves, as they are the feral forms of dogs.<br>However, Spike was raised by ponies, and behaves very different to any other dragon. That's why he became a domestic dog.

Hypothesis: Dragons would become wolves, as they are the feral forms of dogs.
However, Spike was raised by ponies, and behaves very different to any other dragon. That's why he became a domestic dog.


Here are some additional questions I could think of -
 What would happen if one of the animals from the human realm went through into the pony realm? For all we know, the bugs and animals could be ponies or something like it! Although, maybe the regular animals just stay as regular animals considering they exist in both worlds, though that just opens up more to talk about.
 If a changeling went through the portal, would they be able to shapeshift? Would it it work the same as it does on the pony side? Would the things they can transform into stay the same or would they only be able to take the form of creatures in that dimension?

I think changelings can use there power on the human world after sunset brings the magic in that dimension


I am reminded that when Sequestrian magic was used on the Mane six, they became seaponies but Spike turned into a Puffer fish.<br>Maybe there's something specific about dragons that buck transformative trends?

I am reminded that when Sequestrian magic was used on the Mane six, they became seaponies but Spike turned into a Puffer fish.
Maybe there's something specific about dragons that buck transformative trends?


I'd like to ague something. The statement you made "why would a literal dog become whatever the heck this is?" Well you could also ague that "why would a literal pony like apple jack become a human?" Also I think there someone you didn't take into account for the Siren's. I believe that the Siren's were just ponies that had magical artifacts and not a completely difference species of creature. I mean we've seen magic alter ones appearance in the pony world, but when they went to the human world that magic was rendered useless. We've also seen mystical artifacts like the Alicorn amulet that grant the user magic. Another part to this argument is that we've never seen magic that was apart of someone manifest into magical artifacts. Take a look and Sunset and Twilight, their unicorn and alicorn magic didn't manifest into crystal necklaces. And as one final piece of evidence, we've seen magical artifacts retain their abilities in the human world e.g the element of magic and the storm kings staff. @UCD_VOth7RmckN6DbmFJa__A


Interesting thoughts, Sawtooth! Thanks for sharing your ideas with us! ^_^
I'm guessing that the portal's transformation logic might be based less on general species counterparts and more on matching the species of each specific individual's other world counterpart. There might be a universe where EG Spike is human. It just happened that the mirror led to a world with a dog version of Spike.
The mirror portal is certainly mysterious. How long has it been around? Who made it? Star Swirl? I can understand the creator setting the portal so that it would give travelers forms that would blend in with the populace, but why not include the option to keep one's form (and magic for unicorns)? And why put the other end of the portal in such a public place where anyone might see? Hmm…


In the first movie when Sunset was about to destroy the portal, Twilight said, "Fine destroy the portal, Equestria will find a way to live without my element of harmony." What would happen if Sunset actually destroyed the portal and Twilight was stuck in the human world?

@Ginjerbreadfake I... Never actually thought about that 😂 poor rainbow dash would be pacing back and forth waiting for twilight and suddenly get bonked in the face with a flying hammer 😭

Also, wouldn’t the hammer just go through the portal?


Weird question: you know how human twilight became a she-demon and opened a way into the two worlds, the students that were almost falling were still human, even tho they were had crossed to the other world. If one of them were to fall through and then cross through the portal in the pony world, what do you think would happen?

@david bettini Maybe <b>I did</b> , maybe I didn't.

@david bettini Maybe *I did* , maybe I didn't.

@Galactic spritz did you just illuminate theme my question? 😂

@Koala From Tomorrow Maybe they just remain as humans, same thing if a pony goes through one of those... Uh... Lets call them holes .

You see... What if this whole "CH portal thing" actually had some kind of filter  ? It could be made by someone, like StarSwirl (Remember the Dazzlings? They didn't need the portal to become humans...), or something "bigger" made it, like the Tree Of Harmony .

This would explain why they turn into ponies if they go through an artificial/natural portal, like the CH portal and in the Spring Breakdown Special, and don't when they go through a hole/forced portal, like in the Friendship Games.

Idk If that makes sense, this just came in my mind xD .

@Koala From Tomorrow Maybe they just remain as humans, same thing if a pony goes through one of those... Uh... Lets call them *holes* .

You see... What if this whole "CH portal thing" actually had some kind of *filter*  ? It could be made by someone, like *StarSwirl* (Remember the Dazzlings? They didn't need the portal to become humans...), or something "bigger" made it, like the *Tree Of Harmony* .

This would explain why they turn into ponies if they go through an artificial/natural portal, like the CH portal and in the Spring Breakdown Special, and don't when they go through a hole/forced portal, like in the Friendship Games.

*Idk If that makes sense, this just came in my mind xD* .

K I mean they didn't go through the portal


In the music video “Friendship through the ages” there is a part where Sunset Shimmer is riding a horse..... this brings up even more questions

@WolfGamer 3610 I knew ponies were the rulers Over all

maybe animals just exist there? those animals were just born there ,, and its a human world ,, it would be unrealistic if normal animals like horses didnt exist.

No. The humen world has everything we have in our world.
So of course there would be both ponies, horses And zebran.
That is why they in the first movie did not question what a pony was when the found out that twilight was a pony from another world.
Because ponies exist in there world to, but just as animals

Well it would make sense. Horses are obviously gonna be in the human world. Their not gonna be pony’s or a pony from Equestria
When Twilight went through the portal, she obviously wasn’t gonna come out as a pony still she’d come out as her human form.
So it makes sense why not only Applejack would have a horse on her farm seeing as she’s a farm girl therefore it would make sense why Sunset Shimmer would be on a horse

@ArcMedicalResearch Lol probably not tho, might just become a pony like cr- oh!<br>Pony from Saddle Arabia! Or some weird thing close to it.

@ArcMedicalResearch Lol probably not tho, might just become a pony like cr- oh!
Pony from Saddle Arabia! Or some weird thing close to it.

@WolfGamer 3610 Horses are from the human universe. You probably can't turn into one through the portal. So are all the animals and the people themselves. Oh, here comes the whole breaking the balance thing again. Just don't try it out, ok guys?

Dude its a horse not a pony. Its the human universe. So, just ignore it. It actually means nothing.

That’s sort of like Sunsets enslaving a equestrian citizen

WHAT THE— <br>OML WHAT SOCIETY IS THIS PORTAL

WHAT THE—
OML WHAT SOCIETY IS THIS PORTAL

@jabby Nope. It will remain as a horse.

It is THE SAME as:  "What will happen if the Winona born in Equestria (pony!Applejack´s pet) went through the mirror?"
.   She will not become a dragon in the human world (the "porpouse" of the "filter" in the statue at C.H.S. is to PROTECT the human world from magical creatures).
  -> She will remain as a normal, non-magical dog in both world.

.  A Jackelope (horned rabbit from Equestria), a "plant monster" (strange & powerful, but "not magical", technically speaking) could cross through the "dimensional rifts" in Friendship Games without being transformed.

The same thing happened to Sci!Twi´s pet dog (Spike), who went to and from Equestria multiple times without changing (because he did not had any magic at that point).
-> Because dog!Spike has being "uplifted" with magic into sapience (he is as smart as a human or equestrian pony), he MAY become a dragon now [it really depends if the "equestrian_magic" he absorbed from human!Fluttershy can change its "type" to Elemental_Fire or not].

@jabby Nope. It will remain as a horse.

It is THE SAME as:  _"What will happen if the Winona born in Equestria (pony!Applejack´s pet) went through the mirror?"_
.   She will not become a dragon in the human world (the "porpouse" of the "filter" in the statue at C.H.S. is to PROTECT the human world from magical creatures).
  -> She will remain as a normal, non-magical dog in both world.

.  A Jackelope (horned rabbit from Equestria), a "plant monster" (strange & powerful, but "not magical", technically speaking) could cross through the "dimensional rifts" in Friendship Games without being transformed.

The same thing happened to Sci!Twi´s pet dog (Spike), who went to and from Equestria multiple times without changing (because he did not had any magic at that point).
-> Because dog!Spike has being "uplifted" with magic into sapience (he is as smart as a human or equestrian pony), he MAY become a dragon now [it really depends if the "equestrian_magic" he absorbed from human!Fluttershy can change its "type" to Elemental_Fire or not].

I think about that scene a lot and honestly I'm scared to know what would happen if you took the horse through the portal. would it turn into a more realistic looking human that acts like a horse???

@Hiccy69 just a little correction: was when Fluttershy was helped by Applejack that she wear a posey costume.

There were monkeys on the first Grand Galloping Gala (from the "Gated Garden of Canterlot Castle").<br>-> A unicorn like Sunset Shimmer riding a horse in the Equestria Girls universe it would be the same like if Sci!Twi went through the portal to Equestria (becoming a unicorn) & visited pony!Fluttershy´s Animal Sanctuary,  casually meeting a big gorilla.

There were monkeys on the first Grand Galloping Gala (from the "Gated Garden of Canterlot Castle").
-> A unicorn like Sunset Shimmer riding a horse in the Equestria Girls universe it would be the same like if Sci!Twi went through the portal to Equestria (becoming a unicorn) & visited pony!Fluttershy´s Animal Sanctuary,  casually meeting a big gorilla.

You know what....yeah...you do bring a point.......

That horse isn't from across the portal.  You can tell from its eyes.  On the other hand, what of that giraffe in Fluttershy Leans In?  Could it...be a person from the other side of the portal?

if a horse goes the other way through the portal it becomes a human in Equestria

I thought about what you said & I think I have a theory for that.  Maybe some equines don't change into humans like horses (ponies & horses are somewhat different from each other). And that horse from the video looks like Troubleshoes so maybe that's his counterpart?

Thats not the only horse reference in EG. There were also an episode of "Choose your ending" where Fluttershy doesn't know what costume to wear to Bulk's costume party. When Sunset help her, Fluttershy wear a horse costume with G1-G3 design. Also, in one of the shorts called "Festival Filters" they have pony filter, which turn their faces into G1-G3 design, and the Mane 6 instantly disgusted by that look


In order to figure this out, you have to ask yourself the question that is the title. How Does the Portal Work?
A portal is an opening in space that connects two points in space allowing for transit time of zero from point A to point B. In this case, it went beyond one universes spacetime and tapped into another universes spacetime. Before we talk about a dimensional or universal shift, lets talk about a spatial rift to points inside a universe. A spell is cast, via unicorn horn or alchemy or even whole spells read out loud. The first half is a location finding portion and the last part of the spell opens the rift in the location selected and a location near the caster. This is the simplest spell anyone can cast, if they know what they are doing. The spell more or less opens a wormhole that is held open by ambient magic, being manipulated by the spell, instead of exotic matter. That's it. You have a working portal. More complex spells can attach rifts to objects, like a mirror or base of a statue, but that is Star Swirl tier magic.
Now lets add dimensional travel to this. It works like before, but there needs to be something more. Discord lives in another dimension in the MLP multiverse. (I'll say this right now. The MLP universe is massive. Dimensions and universes are not the same thing. We see one universe in the FiM series and its pretty much the only universe we deal with throughout the generations. Equestria Girls is just another universe in the MLP multiverse. I say it is another universe because it has the same entities, though they aren't the same species. Now back to dimensions.) There are ways into other dimensions in the MLP universe. Some stay open, some need to be opened. But adding dimensional transportation to a portal doesn't require adding much more  to the spell. Star Swirl can open portals to other to other dimensions as well as to other universes in their multiverse . Star Swirl sent the sirens to the EG universe. There is a portal to that universe, but was it made before or after the sirens were sent there? I think he may have accidentally discovered that universe and built the portal as a means to not have to keep casting a spell to open the portal. He wanted to learn about that universe and kept the portal open. He may have been limited, or limited it himself, and that is why the portal deactivates for some time before reactivating. Anyway, he saw it didn't have magic so he sent the sirens there in hopes they wouldn't be able to use the magic they had in their original universe. There may be something in the EG universe that has enough magic to activate the portal when it gets close enough or shows fully somehow and that could be why it does open and close after a while. I have another theory but I'm getting sidetracked.
Opening a portal to another universe requires there to be something powerful in play. I believe it was the fact that it was Star Swirl, and not just a spell from a book, that allows the portal to open. The spell is linked to a consciousness. But that would require a consciousness to be able to recognize it. So that brings me to this. But first, lets recap.

Portals open by a spell. There are at the very least three types of portals. Inside a universe. To other dimensions (inside the same universe.) And multiversal portals. It requires someone to knock and someone to answer to open a portal to another universe.

Not a ghost. They cannot use the spell to travel like that because they have no vessel. Lets talk about the mind stone. It contained a consciousness and was essentially power that has been concentrated into its most pure and powerful form. In our universe, we haven't been given that cosmic power in a stone form. It just exists as an intangible force. It mostly isn't believed it exists, but it does. Even if the other forms of power the infinity stones represent doesn't exist, the "Mind Stone" exists for the purpose of granting access to the multiverse. In the MLP universe, it isn't represented in any way whatsoever. It isn't the Elements of Harmony, even though there are six of them. The Elements exist apart from what is known as the Infinity Stones. Every universe has the equivalent to the mind stone. This is what allows the portal to open to the EG universe.

That consciousness sees the species and determines what it would best be in the universe it is entering based off of Universal Entity Recognition. Does this entity exist in the universe it is entering? If so, then it will look exactly like that entity. If not, then hey! Why not have fun, am I right? Just don't go trying to open a portal through the multiverse to MLP-0 because I don't think you would like what travel there does to human physiology.


i came back to this channel to see how it was doing, still going strong.

i used to watch you when i was in my mlp phase, which occurred when i was about 7-8 years old.

i’m a little older now, great to see you’re still uploading!


Might I add, The Sirens are the Sanderson sisters from Hocus Pocus.

Adagio Dazzle = Winifred Sanderson.
Sonata Dusk = Sarah Sanderson.
Aria Blaze = Mary Sanderson.

(Probably what they were going for in the first place anyway, but still, I see it, BTW if I have the order wrong, feel free to correct me, but I definitely do have it right!!!)

Might I add, *The Sirens are the Sanderson sisters from Hocus Pocus.*

Adagio Dazzle = Winifred Sanderson.
Sonata Dusk = Sarah Sanderson.
Aria Blaze = Mary Sanderson.

(Probably what they were going for in the first place anyway, but still, I see it, BTW if I have the order wrong, feel free to correct me, but I definitely do have it right!!!)


The real question is…<br>What would happen if a DISGUISED changeling went though the portal?

The real question is…
What would happen if a DISGUISED changeling went though the portal?


I think we are all overlooking the fact that the sirens were sent to the human world via different means and not the portal. It was Starswirl's magic that sent them there, not the portal.


is it just me or 0:19 EMBERS DOG DESIGN IS BEAUTIFUL!!!


Maybe it could also be age related combined with species considering spike is a baby dragon and recognised as the portal as less mature but a subservient and still intelligent species a dog would be the fit.


It could be based on what your otherworld counterparts already  are .
Spikes = dog
Twis = human
And sci twi would throw a wrench in this except she's a Twilight that hasn't reached her full potential yet thus still a unicorn while pony twilight has therego a alicorn but I'm not sure if their human appearances vary that much beyond wardrobe and highlights ...maybe pony twi is a little taller ...i don't know .


Here is sequence:
Ponies (4 legs) -> human (2 legs)
Dragons (mostly use 2 legs) -> dog (4 legs)

@Samantha Freeman they float magically, they don’t need them

• Kïtšütåtśhį •

@Shawn Pickett Pauley💙🎩<br>Hmmm💭 What's⁉  (🚳🚯🚭)[🗯💬💣](😍🤩😘)🤯🤠 up🔝 with all🚻 the emojis😀

@Shawn Pickett Pauley💙🎩
Hmmm💭 What's⁉  (🚳🚯🚭)[🗯💬💣](😍🤩😘)🤯🤠 up🔝 with all🚻 the emojis😀

@Leander's Main Channel <br>Dog🐶 Spike♂(🐶🌠🦸♀)[🦴🗞🖊](💫👩❤👩💞)💚💜 is human👩 Twilight🌟 Sparkle♀'s pet dog🐶

@Leander's Main Channel
Dog🐶 Spike♂(🐶🌠🦸♀)[🦴🗞🖊](💫👩❤👩💞)💚💜 is human👩 Twilight🌟 Sparkle♀'s pet dog🐶

@Sheena Branton <br>Owlowiscious♂🦉🤎 is pony 🦄 Twilight🌟 Sparkle♀'s pet owl🦉

@Sheena Branton
Owlowiscious♂🦉🤎 is pony 🦄 Twilight🌟 Sparkle♀'s pet owl🦉

@Feral_Cat <br>They have front horse🐎-legs🦵. P.S, talk🗣 about toung👅 patch🏞

@Feral_Cat
They have front horse🐎-legs🦵. P.S, talk🗣 about toung👅 patch🏞

@Allister The Birb sirens have 3 legs get it! #tailpuns

@Allister The Birb sirens have *3* legs get it! #tailpuns

Maybe the answer is that because Twilight kept Spike as a pet, they would turn into a pet?

following that griffen would turn into something with 2 legs like as said owl

but.. but the diamond dogs use two legs mainly

@Allister The Birb they are literally just there. They don't need them

@Allister The Birb sorry, forgot they had hooves lol

@Feral_Cat well what do they use their hooves for then, knitting?

@Allister The Birb they don't even have legs


heres what i think the creatures would be (based on what they've been through and based on what animal they represent a bit)
Ponies: Human
Dragons: Dogs/Wolves
Griffin's: Bird/Leopard
Changelings: Anything
Hippogriffs: Human/Mermaid/man
Yacht: Human/Buffalo

Heres why i think changelings can turn to anything, in their forms in equestria, they can change to any creature, so i think when they go throught the mirror, they have to think on what they want to be, for example thorax goes through, if he thinks of a human, he will be a human, if he thinks of a ladybug, he will be one.

Those are all my theories right now


I believe, that the crucial thing isn't the character's spices, but their position instead.

"Independent and free" characters like Twilight and the blue griffin become humans. The same clearly appears on sirens.

For example the Diamond dogs live independently in the cave, so in human world they would be men who live independently.

And characters' sidekicks/pets become dogs and other pets we know. Spike lives as Twilight's pet/sidekick, so he remains the same position in human world. That's why he became a dog


I actually think most dragons who haven’t discovered friendship would be come wolves the wild counter part to dogs maybe friendship is part of it


When a changeling goes in the portal; From it's name, it depends on what form it took prior to going in the portal.
Old form = leech
New form = Random from Dragonfly, Bees and Butterfly to Housefly (Insect type with crystal/clear type wings)
Copy forms = same as the original of that form
The exemptions: Age, strength of magic and power of magic (If anyone wants to keep there looks they can but it would translate to what animal counterpart there is closes to there original form)
Young Spike = Dog (Young age, low in magic)
Older (Buff) spike = Human bar bouncer spike lol


I hope we see in the EG series a land speed record attempt (did you know that cars already were almost 500 kp/h fast in 1937?)


You should show what all different creatures that are known and steamed in many of the episodes let's see what they would be through the portal to turn ponies into humans


There is a connection between dragons and dogs and dogs they're mythological mounts  Corgis were thought to be the mounts of Fairies And we know that it is fantasy that dragons were people's mounts Is in some mythological stories


Here's a question: why must a changeling necessarily turn into anything else upon exiting the portal? Their whole thing is that they already transform, so would the portal just force them to change form, but not much else? Could they simply turn back upon exiting the swirling thing, or are they stuck to single form? If they're stuck into a single form, wouldn't they find the inability to change disturbing, as if somecreature just lopped off their horn?


Hot take: Dragons not raised by ponies become wolves

Holy mother of the alicorn abomination your right!

@Ameigh Ameigh probably wolves too, more than 1 creature in equestria can become 1 creature in the human world

that is a FABULOUS theory. it would also make sense since they travel in packs, have alpha-like roles in their communities, and tend to resource guard. that is such a good idea


I just love the way you explain things about mlp, which didn’t make sense to me until I discovered YOU, sawtooth. 😁


personally i think all sapients become human unless their life story requires them to be something else in a human context. spike was basically adopted by twilight, which in the human world would only really make direct sense with a dog, so spike, and specifically spike, becomes a dog


While I think bugs are likely for changelings, and the portal demagicifies things, I also think changelings would become... changelings, like the human <-> fairy kind in folklore. They would seem perfectly human but like how the pony-humans sometimes sprout tails/ears/wings as appropriate, the changelings would take on fae traits: fairy wings, maybe not shape-shifting but glamour, etc. Like the diamond dogs they likely look a bit different than ordinary humans, maybe they are taller or shorter than usual (as the pony humans already have kinda fae proportions).


Maybe the portal uses chaos magic. Chaos magic seems random

@LightningStripe25 maybe he stays the same

I don't think so...because then ev'ryone that passes though the portal would be different species. Let's put it like this Twilight becomes human, Sunset did too, and Starlight too! It couldn't be random if three ponies became humans, I guess...

that reminds me, we still dont know what Discord would look like through the portal... (besides fan-art)


I think the portal might be more of a sorting hat- type deal, analyzing what makes more sense for the character and their intent when going through the portal. Spike is loyal to Twilight like a dog, and if he was human, I’d imagine he’d have been more like a kid, but then, it’s a lot harder to hide a child in your backpack on a high school campus than a dog.


I think it depends on the relationship between the creatures, not completely thought<br>Twilight and Spike as an example, Spike is Twilight's best friend and is loyal helpful to her, giving him categories of dogs towards their human friends

I think it depends on the relationship between the creatures, not completely thought
Twilight and Spike as an example, Spike is Twilight's best friend and is loyal helpful to her, giving him categories of dogs towards their human friends


Changelings have the ability to create their own unique pony form (i.e., Chrysalis as a unicorn photographer), so one would most likely take on a human form analog to what the unique pony form would be. I think it'd be on a case-by-case basis for dragons, mainly based on what position/profession they would hold in Equestria. While I currently have no explanation for Diamond Dogs becoming human, it could be possible for any sentient species in Equestria to translate that way.


2:34 - Okay. This proves Innsmouth exists in Equestria Girl world.


What if it depends on their self-image/identity? While most others turn human because they see themselves as individuals separate from anyone else, could Spike have turned into a dog because of his faithfulness and loyalty to Twilight? He identifies as her companion and helper. What better exemplifies these traits than that of a canine companion?


Here's my thoughts:

1.  Since this is a parallel world with alternate versions of the same characters, I'm willing to bet that the Sirens just simply have human counterparts in that world somewhere.

2.  Let's not forget that, in the comics, Star Swirl created many of these portals in the past during his experiments.  One that he and Tia jumped through led to a prehistoric world and they didn't turn into dinos, suggesting that the transformation probably needs to be 'programmed' into the portal's abilities.  He most likely added this ability to the one that leads to the human world in order for users to blend in and survive in the alternate world.  Also, portals that most likely naturally exists, such as the one found on that island in the human world, might already have this ability by chance.  Those portals that Midnight Sparkle (SciTwi's dark version) created doesn't seem to have that transforming ability.  If you can recall, pony Twilight's hand did show as a hoof when she tested the portal after arriving in the human world in the first EQ movie.  However, when humans were hanging partly through MS's portals in the Friendship Games movie, their lower half of their bodies didn't transform.

3.  Here's a big one that this vid didn't cover.  Cross breeding abilities of different characters in one world could have an impact on what they are in the other world, since this would impact if they can have offspring in the other world as well as family relationship.  With this thought, one would wonder if diamond dogs and equestrian ponies are able to have kids.  I know that sounds crazy, but let's not forget the inter-species breeding that is possible with Mobians from Sonic the Hedgehog's world.  Pokémon also have this ability.  In fact, there is probably evidence that it has happened in the pony world already, since hippogriffs are allegedly the half breeds of griffons and equines, according to mythology.  This could be a strong indication that griffons and hippogriffs might also be human in the human world.

4.  Another thought that you might be interested in is how agelessness would impact the existence of characters in each world.  We all know that alicorns are ageless.  However, humans, such as Tia and Luna's counterparts, aren't going to be ancient, yet they exist.  Reincarnation is a possible route for continuous existence when agelessness is not available.  With this in mind, the hidden mechanism behind reincarnation could simply be the existence of an ageless counterpart in another world.

5.  Here's a fun one.  Has anyone ever wondered what a pony from the human world would turn into if they went through the portal to Equestria?  We do know that such creatures exist in the human world, but they can't cross-breed with humans.  If my breeding theory above had any merit, then they would have to become something else.  Who knows what that would be. 😲

@WhiteTiger Yeah, I tend to think too much on cartoon theories, for some odd reason.

You must have put a lot of thought into this


I think it doesn't have to do with the species at all? I think the mirror portal finds your counterpart in the human world and turns you into their form. At least that's what I've always thought since the first EG movie was released


I think that the portal picks which race someone from Equestria should be, depending on the first entry.  Magic works in mysterious ways.


When you think about it being able to use magic like the one to give them wings and ears doesn't make since. Obviously it’s some sort of shapeshifting magic but the thing is that’s not a kinda of magic in either world. (Side note my head cannon kinda goes like this: both worlds started with the same magic but they evolved differently and the humans can’t use the magic like ponies can) but shapeshifting is something we’ve only seen once in changelings (And whether or not changelings are even part of this world of its magic is a whole other can of worms) think about it besides changelings and the human world there hasn’t been any kind of shapeshifting going on I mean I guess you could kinda count becoming an alicorn to that but that’s a bit of a stretch and they don’t seem to have much in common with changings..unless the world was changelings that formed themselves into humans and generations later they only now touch back into that magic because of the exposure to equestrian magic but only the ones who were really exposed can and only the smallest things like ears or wings and that would be the first things they transform to again cause that’s what they had centuries before……..nah that’s impossible. So yeah it doesn't make much since


The portal is so inconsistent. Spike’s counterpart is a dog, but the Diamond Dogs’ counterpart are humans, but then Winona’s counterpart is still a dog.

WTF are the rules?

@Rafe Lafornara but then spike is also humanoid but he becomes a dog

Diamond Dogs are humanoid, which means they would become human.

@Angora HM No, like whether they turn into a different creature or not depends on if they talk. Winona doesn't talk, so she didn't. Gummy doesn't either, so gummy is just an alligator.

@Mai but spike talks and becomes a dog - which doesn't talk

I just think it's about if the creature can talk or not.

@Angora HM Well kind of what I mean is he's closer to a dog than a human personality wise

@Appsnake does spike really count as a pet, though?

Yeah, like why did Spike become a dog when dragon are just overgrown fire breathing lizards?

Maybe if they are a pet in the pony world they are a pet in the human world


I personally think if a pony has a pet, then if the pet goes through the portal they would be a pet. (For example, spike = dog) Even tho spike is not considered a pet entirely, i still count him as twilights pet.<br>but if a normal dragon goes through that is not "owned" by anyone they would most likely be a human.

I personally think if a pony has a pet, then if the pet goes through the portal they would be a pet. (For example, spike = dog) Even tho spike is not considered a pet entirely, i still count him as twilights pet.
but if a normal dragon goes through that is not "owned" by anyone they would most likely be a human.


The one's you put in the equin colum can actually become something  else not just humans. For example zebras will  stay as zebras. And buffalo will stay buffalo. And Yaks will stay Yaks. And nonquine such as Griffin's would become lion's or Eagle. And   a  a changeling would become a bug or a pony.


In his (adult-roriented) fanfiction Off the Mark novel series, author Bernard Doove describes it as the result of an adaptation spell on the mirror portal which changes a traveler to Equestria into a lifeform which suits them most. Maybe this theorem can also be applied here?


I think it is about dependence: spike is like an assistant of Twilight and counts on her for his life (a dog or pet-like feature) but twilight,, the sirens and diamond dogs work for themselves and are independent (a human-like feature).


Hey Sawtooth you always post at the best moments.Awesome theories as usual.


maybe it has something to do with what's in their mind.

spike while intelligent play's an almost subservient role to twilight, a willing one but still almost the role of a pet of sorts. so maybe their form on the human side is determined by how they view themselves not just what they are.


I'd say it's dependent on the role the creatures play in the story. Ponies are basically our point of view characters. Spike is twilights assistant and loyal companion. Dogs (as a pet) are often seen as very loyal and helpful companions.
The diamond dogs aren't pets, but antagonists to rarity and the main six. So they are similar enough to be seen as humans.
Creatures similar to horses or that can be seen as pov characters, antagonists or protagonists are human. Cranky, the donkey from ponyville is a human. I imagine that dragons are going to be a weird grey area, but they could always be werewolves or something. They're seen as one of the more savage species in the series, so wolves in general would suit them. Which makes sense since spike (a dog) is more tamed and civilised.

But most likely, they just didn't care about a system and just went "what would look good or be interesting to transform this character into? "


Here's why I think the Diamond Dogs didn't stay dogs. One possibility could be that they are not pets. Because the Mane Six's pets in the human world were just like they were in the pony world. Another possibility could be that they are very unusual dogs. I mean,  first of all, their tongues are blue....There is no such thing as a blue-tongued dog in the human world.


I feel Hypogriffs (if not human) would be cats,I just get that vibe

Would seapony become fish or would that not work since fish exist in the pony world as well


It could also vary depending on WHICH portal they went through


i've been thinking that it's mostly all sentient creatures that become humans, and the reason spike was a dog was because he was pre-molt, if he goes through the portal now, post-molt, he'd be human


Wow
I actually have a hypothetical answer to this one.  It's imperfect, but it's an answer.
My own writing has "humans shapeshifting into animals" as a possibility, and even has "humans born with the power to become animals" as an option.  However, there are some rules for what animal they can become, and the most relevant for this situation is probably size: no matter what a human shapeshifts into, they are always the same weight as what they started as (unless external magic is involved, but that exception doesn't apply to born animal-shifters).  Full-size horses are too big and heavy for humans to become, but ponies are the right size.  Most dogs are too small to shapeshift into, but some breeds are large enough.
There's another rule for my shapeshifting that would have to be thrown out for this theory to apply fully, because they've canonically already broken it (four limbs only; pegasi and alicorns have six limbs, and according to that shot sirens only have two, but they've all become humans when going through the portal).  But the size thing could make sense; telling scale in Equestria is difficult because there are no actual humans for reference, but comparing those creatures to their real-life counterparts where applicable and to each other when there's not an irl counterpart, we can probably make some decent guesses.  Equestrian equines clearly are the right size to become humans; probably anything that's the same size as a pony would also make the cut (yaks and buffalo are too big).
My theory for what happens with dragons is that...there might never be a time when a dragon's size matches up to a human in any meaningful way.  Spike is a baby dragon, and he's small enough to ride on a pony without weighing them down too much (ten pounds?).  He'd be a toddler if he went through that mirror and came out human on the other side (determination to be helpful to Twilight probably is what turned him into a dog, which would be "adult" at that size and a believable companion).  I'm also guessing that by the time a dragon is considered properly "adult" it's larger than a pony; too large to become even an adult human.  If there is a period of time where a dragon could go through that mirror and become a human, it'd be a pretty slim one probably centered on the dragon equivalent of teen years.

*Wow*
I actually have a hypothetical answer to this one.  It's imperfect, but it's _an_ answer.
My own writing has "humans shapeshifting into animals" as a possibility, and even has "humans _born_ with the power to become animals" as an option.  However, there are some rules for what animal they can become, and the most relevant for this situation is probably size: no matter what a human shapeshifts into, they are always the same weight as what they started as (unless external magic is involved, but that exception doesn't apply to born animal-shifters).  Full-size horses are too big and heavy for humans to become, but _ponies_ are the right size.  Most dogs are too small to shapeshift into, but some breeds are large enough.
There's another rule for my shapeshifting that would have to be thrown out for this theory to apply fully, because they've canonically _already_ broken it (four limbs only; pegasi and alicorns have six limbs, and according to that shot sirens only have two, but they've all become humans when going through the portal).  But the size thing could make sense; telling scale in Equestria is difficult because there are no actual humans for reference, but comparing those creatures to their real-life counterparts where applicable and to each other when there's not an irl counterpart, we can probably make some decent guesses.  Equestrian equines _clearly_ are the right size to become humans; probably anything that's the same size as a pony would also make the cut (yaks and buffalo are too big).
My theory for what happens with dragons is that...there might never be a time when a dragon's size matches up to a human in any meaningful way.  Spike is a baby dragon, and he's small enough to ride on a pony without weighing them down too much (ten pounds?).  He'd be a _toddler_ if he went through that mirror and came out human on the other side (determination to be helpful to Twilight probably is what turned him into a dog, which would be "adult" at that size and a believable companion).  I'm also guessing that by the time a dragon is considered properly "adult" it's larger than a pony; too large to become even an adult human.  If there _is_ a period of time where a dragon could go through that mirror and become a human, it'd be a pretty slim one probably centered on the dragon equivalent of teen years.


In my theory, I think pets from the Pony World will stay as pets in the human world. If you are considered a pet despite what creature you are, you become a pet. So since Spike is considered Twilight's pet since he kinda is one, he is converted into a dog because of Spike being domesticated in nature, like how dogs were domesticated by humans. If the creature's species are already existing in the human world, they wouldn't get converted. That's my take about form conversion in MLP.


A pony an a dragon walk into a portal, sounds like the beginning of a bad joke but it’s actually the beginning of a bad movie

I know we're all hoping for the nostalgia renaissance where film producers decide to rewrite bad kids movies into genuinely good ones.

@Chaos Queen They dont need to address it's their opinion

@Chaos Queen bruh im just saying its their opinion so dont need to be mad everyone has opinions

@diya g Yes ik it is their opinion but the person who commented this Didnt say it was only their opinion so how come you are calling out Derek Baker only?

Thank you for making me laugh here’s a like


It probably depends on the relationship. Spike was meant to be a pet for Twilight, but now he’s more than that; a friend


Weren't there horses in equestria too? I remember in the grand galloping gala they used magic to turn mice into horses who were a lot bigger than the ponies. What would happen if they went through?


I think for changelings it depends on the form. If I’m their original state they become a bug. Reformed become butterflies, unreformed ladybugs.


We need to know where is the human sunset shimmer there has been a human version of almost everypony

@Oliver I guess  Highly unlikely. Sunset Shimmer isn’t capable of murder. Even at her worst during the Fall Formal, when she kidnapped Spike so she could lure Twilight out, she didn’t threaten to hurt him to get the crown back. She let him go and then proceeded to threaten to break the portal in return for the crown.
She may have tried to kill Twilight a just a few minutes after that, but she was transformed into a demon and corrupted by the crown’s magic when it happened.

She wouldn’t try to kill anyone for any reason (much less her own counterpart) in any other situation.

@Oliver I guess  Highly unlikely. Sunset Shimmer isn’t capable of murder. Even at her worst during the Fall Formal, when she kidnapped Spike so she could lure Twilight out, she didn’t threaten to hurt him to get the crown back. She let him go and *then* proceeded to threaten to break the portal in return for the crown.
She may have tried to kill Twilight a just a few minutes after that, but she was transformed into a demon and corrupted by the crown’s magic when it happened.

She wouldn’t try to kill anyone for any reason (much less her own counterpart) in any other situation.

What if she was trapped in the human world for 1000 years?

@Oliver I guess well that's what <b>I</b> thought 😂 but I think it was either sawtooth or another bring theorist that came up with the idea that since pony sunset was at least several years older than pony twilight, the original human sunset shimmer was likely already an established adult doing adult things no longer in high school when pony sunset came through the portal but ended up a high schooler... And then when pony twilight came through she was also a high schooler, it was explained deeper in the video but it kinda made sense in a way? 🤔 ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

@Oliver I guess well that's what *I* thought 😂 but I think it was either sawtooth or another bring theorist that came up with the idea that since pony sunset was at least several years older than pony twilight, the original human sunset shimmer was likely already an established adult doing adult things no longer in high school when pony sunset came through the portal but ended up a high schooler... And then when pony twilight came through she was also a high schooler, it was explained deeper in the video but it kinda made sense in a way? 🤔 ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

There was gonna be an official answer to that with an hour long finale. One of the creators or writers or someone that worked on the show posted about it. I’m so sad they aren’t letting him complete the answer! I must know!


personally always saw it as being a mental problem, spike always felt like he does not belong at least subconscious so the portal turned him into dog


I think that a bigger possibility might be that like how spike became a dog, twighlights human self had a pet dog named spike with the same facial features, maybe whatever that is most connected to their portal self will be what depends on what they become, so that means that if the other creatures come through the portal, that means that what ever is closest to their portal selves is what they become. And I just want to say even though this is a really late comment I hope you see it and take it into consideration. Thank you!


I think hypogriff would become frogs, cuz yknow silver stream, griffins become some sort of bird depending on their personality, changelings become chameleons, and that's all I can think of for now. Or perhaps it's personality based seeing that a dragon should become a lizard or something reptilian. Or maybe it's if your equine or hooved if your not either you automatically become a human or humanoid because that solves the diamond dogs.


I think the Portal has some kind of Automagical process that idenifys your essence or core, transmutes your body and shapes clothing around you that fits your "Cutiemark" and personality.

The Eq Girls always dress around their theme or character, sure it cux the designers made them like that but it could be a subtler magic working behins the scenes. We know alot of stuff exists but there even morw subtler stuff we sussed out and ib EqG maybe who they are manifests ideas for designers inshow to make it just for the characters.


My headcanon is that changelings become fae, since they're vaguely pony-shaped but more bug-based (sort of like how fae look mostly human but aren't really) and because their name and abilities are loosely tied to real fae mythology. ^u^

@River Heinze It's an alternate name for fairy/faerie. I used it in this case to imply that I was referring to the mythological trickster, shapeshifting, occasionally child-kidnapping type rather than the modern Disney type. :D

@Roundabout R That's true! I'd forgotten that the sirens had their original powers. <br>On that train of thought, in EqG the sirens' powers were held in their necklaces, which, looking back to their Equestrian forms, seem to have once been parts of their bodies. I wonder if EqG changelings would have something similar that they would have to wear in order to shapeshift, like how merrows in Irish folklore needed a red cap and/or cape to breathe underwater and selkies could only become seals when wearing their sealskins? So much to think about! :D

@Roundabout R That's true! I'd forgotten that the sirens had their original powers.
On that train of thought, in EqG the sirens' powers were held in their necklaces, which, looking back to their Equestrian forms, seem to have once been parts of their bodies. I wonder if EqG changelings would have something similar that they would have to wear in order to shapeshift, like how merrows in Irish folklore needed a red cap and/or cape to breathe underwater and selkies could only become seals when wearing their sealskins? So much to think about! :D

If the sirens become humanoids with siren powers, then I think fae are more than possible.

@Jenna Vanilla Maybe not; the lack of any magic would definitely shoot down my theory fast. XD
I suggested it because I actually headcanon that some form of magic does exist in the human world, just not Equestrian magic in particular; Professor Cinch (who seems very practically-minded) had no issues believing that the CH students were using magic to cheat, meaning it's possible that magic exists as at a hypothetical concept there at the very least, and Trixie seems to use some form of real magic to teleport Sunset to the other side of the door in Forgotten Friendship, but it doesn't have the same appearance as Equestrian magic. Thus, it's possible that magic exists in that world, but is only accessible to humans in very minor forms (or maybe they're still not aware of it in general), and some of the major users (the fae in this case) are hidden.
It's hard to say for sure though; now that the series has ended, we're only left to speculate. :)

Yeah, uh, sorry, but...the human world is supposed to be a place where magic doesn’t actually exist. So I don’t really think changelings would become fae.

changelings in Equestria were based off of changelings from European folklore, so maybe they look something like them? its still a long shot though


hey if a changeling went through the portal would they still be allowed to shapeshift?

what if they had already become a different species? would they become what they would become what that particular species would become or would they become what they would become as a changeling?

I have so many questions 👁👄👁


I'm wondering, does what you turn into when you go through the portal have some link with personality or social status with others? Becuase, Spike turned into a dog, and in the pony world, Spike has a son/pet relationship with twilight, kind of like you would with a dog.


I think that the relationship between age in equestria and ‘human’ world is sublinear or logarithmic.


To me it sounds like the portal just turns whatever goes through it into anything it wants to turn them into. Even if it means turning them into an abomination. (The grey human things)


The portal too the EQG world really and how it works really is a strange phenomenon, in fact what usually puzzles me about when pony characters go through the portal and they turn human they end up wearing clothes as well as if they were a natural part of their molecular strutcure or something...i mean i know it was just to keep the movie PG but still...basically what i;m saying is that it's interesting how when the ponies enter the portal wearing nothing at all the portal itself seems to magically clothe the pony in question sort of like magical molecular structural bonding it's a scientific thing, surely on some level you all see where i'm going with this.

to me the portal tries to match euqestrial and human rules to make it's versions of the characters, like they have clothes on but their clothes have a cutiemark on them. Humans don't have tattoos magically appearing on their skin when they realize their life purpose, but the symbol of it may appear into their minds so they manage to incorporate it into their clothing or even make an actual tattoo of it if they choose to.

@The Pony of Glory I said he's cool because I like his comments... And I was still watching the video when I saw it.

@o Don't blame him blame the words, it's not his fault that what he's talking about requires so many words, and what do you mean it's cool because it's from him?...don't talk like you know him, because i would imagine you really don't...sorry for the rudeness but what i say is true.

Well, considering the fact that most magic in the EQG universe changes the characters' outfits so that Hasbro can sell more toys, maybe the portal (and magic in general) just has some fashion sense!

Perhaps you could think of it like this. Where'd her fur go?

@Princess Flutterheart a good question! I believe they would be wearing the same outfit, fitted to their human form

@Undertaker9711  that also makes a lot of sense but what do you think would happen if a pony was wearing clothes & went through the portal? would they be wearing that same outfit or not?

Ok guys, we get it. The real reason is to keep things PG. But its fun to speculate on a canon reason for it. I like the "fit with societal norms" theory. The portal changes them to match their surroundings. Spike didnt just become a dog, he became a dog with a collar. That way, he wouldn't be seen as a stray and picked up by a dog catcher

Because its a show watched by Kids and they shouldn't be naked when they found themselfs in a new form!

Ponies don't need clothes to fit in with societal norms. Humans do. Magic portal is able to compensate. Humans wearing clothes seem to be able to come out in Equestria without them, often wearing a backpack-turned saddlebag, right?

Real reason is bc PG and marketing. Headcannon doesn't have to match tho.

@The Pony of Glory Oh I absolutely agree! It's a good question.

@IndoDINO Youtube PG or not, it's still a valid topic in it's own right but would you admit that?...I doubt it.


its simple how the portal works,its not a type  transformation,but rather Transmutation.
You see,the portal doesnt create the appearence of something to what it "thinks" will look like in the Human World.
it changes the appearence of said species to its "Human World" equivalent,spike became a dog because its counterpart was one.
Any other dragon could pass trough the portal and became anything,it only depends on what it look like in the human world,if tsuch dragon's counterpart its a lion it will turn into such.

BUT,if a some creature pass trought the portal that has no counterpart in the Human World,the portal will turn the "user" into the Human World standards,just in this situation the portal transforms the "user" in what it "think" should be/look like in the Human  World.

Human Discord Confirmed :0

its simple how the portal works,its not a type  transformation,but rather Transmutation.
You see,the portal doesnt create the appearence of something to what it "thinks" will look like in the Human World.
it changes the appearence of said species to its "Human World" equivalent,spike became a dog because its counterpart was one.
Any other dragon could pass trough the portal and became anything,it only depends on what it look like in the human world,if tsuch dragon's counterpart its a lion it will turn into such.

BUT,if a some creature pass trought the portal that has no counterpart in the Human World,the portal will turn the "user" into the Human World standards,just in this situation the portal transforms the "user" in what it "think" should be/look like in the Human  World.

*Human Discord Confirmed :0*


My theory is that changeling will be a bug in their base form, but if they turn into a pony, they'll be a human, if they turn into a dragon they'll be a dog etc.


Many they become animal/ human that they are most similar too.<br>I love your thoughts about the human universe and the pony universe! 😀

Many they become animal/ human that they are most similar too.
I love your thoughts about the human universe and the pony universe! 😀


"A pony and a dragon walk through a portal, sounds like the beginning of a bad joke." I mean, depending on how you feel about Equestria Girls..


I have a theory that, the creatures that walk in 4 legs (like ponies and diamond dogs or have something with ponies (like the sirens) become human, and the ones who walk on 2 legs, like dragons, become pets.

Like, a creature walks in 4 legs in equestria, in the human world became a human, a creature that walks in 2 legs, the same with creatures that walk in 2 legs in equestria, became a creature that walks in 4 legs in the human world.

@Papaya I wasn't saying that being transformed has to do with magic, I was saying it had to do with sentience.

But the diamond dogs walk in 2 legs and are humans

@Papaya The pets don't have magic like the ponies and creatures.

@Puppygirlman18 yeah, that's what i said about only fantastical creatures changing species hehe

@Papaya The pets might stay the same in both dimensions because they aren't sentient, or, at least, they dont speak normal pony language. This might mean that the portal (supposedly made by Starswirl, a pony) would ignore them and let the pets go back and forth without being transformed.

@LightningStripe25 maybe also i realized that in Sunny's room there's no merch of Spike or Luna present making me think they COULD appear in g5

@LightningStripe25 I didn't mean about the case of discord, but yeah, i don't think he will show up in g5, I was saying about, seeing the human world again, even with other creatures crossing the portal, and Discord isn't the only draconequus, so, yeah.

@LEGENDARYnoob oh, I thought that they walk on 4, well, I think they do that sometimes, but, ok, my theory is ruined

@Stephany166 off topic a little, but do you think Discord will show up in G5? he's immortal, so even if G5 takes place many years after G4, he would still be alive, probably still taking care of Sweerfeather sanctuary in Fluttershy's place. only time will tell

@Fire Red Spike walks in 2 legs, and speaks, that's not anthropomorphic for you?

@ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽 appearance dont count

@Stephany166 Spike dont is anthropomorphic, other dragons are

@LightningStripe25 oh, you're right, and yeah, we will never know, because, EG is over, unless, G5 but I don't think so

that could work, but some dragons, like Dragon Lord Torch, prefer to walk on 4 legs because of their size. And there's also the question of what Discord would be if he went through. Most people would think he becomes human, and there's even fan-art of human Discord, but we just don't know.

@Fire Red but dragons are anthropomorphic, and Spike became a dog

@ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽 well, idk, i said that the sirens became human because of pony like, but I really don't know

Sirens have 2 legs and A Tail does that count?

ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽

my theory is that, regardless of race, the equestrian must be anthropomorphic enough to be a human

@Stephany166 hmm i guess it could be just the anthropomorphic fantastical creatures in equestria that change when you go through the portal, the animals you'd expect to see in the human world stay the same

@Papaya yeah, I don't know why, but, it's weird, and not all the pets are alive or in there, Owlicius never appeared and Gummy is just a plushie

but all the pets and stuff stay the same in both dimensions 🤔


OMG SAWTOOTH I JUST REALIZED SOMETHING!!!!!

Flurryheart was born and destined for greatness as a young child, the first alicorn baby, and possibly the last. Flurry heart had done nothing in her life yet, other than loving her parents. I don't think that this is an explanation to the phenomenon that is flurry. If flurry's destiny IS to rule along side with her mother, don't you think that would be "fortold." I propose that flurry being born with wings symbolizes her destiny as a future great ruler. She could be the first Queen equestria has had, but I don't think that is the case. Celestia had the same future and great potential, as did luna, but she wasn't born with wings. If flurry heart's destiny is sealed just like that, wings would represent it. Flurry heart will be the princess of destiny.


I think they just change to match their counterpart in that world. Spike is a dog because his other self is a dog; if Ember's counterpart was sheep then she would become that as well. Spike is the only dragon character we've seen so we don't know if all members of a species turn into the same thing.


Have you notice that the purple syren as human actually look like Starlight?


Sorry if he already said this in the vid but I feel like it depends on the personality, well at least for who stays unhuman<br>For example spike turns into a dog dogs are known for being loyal and spike is quite loyal to twilight dogs also become attached to their owner spike has known twilight since he was born so he is quite attached they have quite a good relationship and it's only gone stronger from the beginning due to twilight learning the meaning  and power of friendspip

Sorry if he already said this in the vid but I feel like it depends on the personality, well at least for who stays unhuman
For example spike turns into a dog dogs are known for being loyal and spike is quite loyal to twilight dogs also become attached to their owner spike has known twilight since he was born so he is quite attached they have quite a good relationship and it's only gone stronger from the beginning due to twilight learning the meaning  and power of friendspip


"A Pony and a Dragon walked into a portal "
Bronies: N o

"A Pony and a Dragon walked into a portal "
Bronies: *N o*

@Linx actually I was just doing a joke from Gravity Falls

@JC J NO! IT IS BETTER IN EVERY SINGLE WAY POSSIBLE. Well at least the first 3 movies. THE REST IS A LITTLE BIT WORST BUT ITS STILL VERY GOOD AND YOU SHOULD GIVE IT A TRY FOR WHAT IT IS. AT LEAST ITS BETTER THAN PONY LIFE.

@JC J in my opinion equestria girls is better than mlp

@Horn Crunch Equestria Girls is really hated in the MLP fandom

@Pearl the Person I been seeing 666 manifest a lot

The Virginian s emerge with the nations capital. And here's the piece de resistance.

@Alexa Vertsberger the immigrant emerges with unprecedented financial power, a system he can shape however he wants

@GlowStyc They emerge with a compromise having open doors that were previously closed, bros

@Horn Crunch its because there was a lot of brony beef against the equestria girls movie thats the joke

Two virginians and an immigrant walk into a room

@Horn Crunch it’s not Don’t think about it too much


Gallus as an owl made me laugh way too much-


So... if someone got out of Tartarus and set a real in the portal, per say a piece of string just inside two dimensional layer of the portal. Would the sting and whoever went through be fine, would the string and up inside of them, or would the string scissor them in half. That portal is awful dangerous. But then all that depend s if the portal only allows organic material. This may be the case but two get cloth when going through it so then that allows it to disobey the conservative of matter. Or is it taking organic matter that has gone through it and converting it into another compound, and does it discriminate between important matter like one's brain and hair to convert into clothing, also btw if the portal converts matter into other compounds, that proves the existence of the multiverse in the case of it does follow the laws of conservative of matter. Welp back to the idea that whoever goes through does not interact with the string, implying that it could be a teleporter of some sort, whoever goes through is being atomically disassembled and reassembled into something else, so now what type is it when two goes through is she being converted into energy and being sent some were else or does it use an on site power source? If the portal only open in that on spot is it just coincidence that the pedestal thing was built there or did the building of it accidentally create the portal, maybe the portal automatically aligns to something of the nearest dimentions... If it's just random then weird. But if auto align that would imply the portal might be reducing one's atomic mass or just compressing one's atomic makeup from what little I've seen (I've not seen eqg) just YouTube tidbits of the man's 6 were all ready there send two went through that would mean the portal/teleporter might be supper intellegent or of double of them were made by them going through that would mean atomic compression possibly.


hey sawtooth i have a theroy about the first episode. we know celestia went missing and no one knew what happened to her but when twilight and the others defeat nightmare moon and the sun begins to rise (on its own i might add) celestia seems to appear from inside the sun. my theory is this: nightmare moon trapped celestia in the sun as a sort of punishment in nightmare moon's mind and had hoped she would stay there for at least a thousand years but celestia having raised both the sun and moon for a thousand years she was naturally stronger in her magic and could break out any time but chose to wait until the elements had come together and twilight found the magic of friendship. this would suggest that celestia knew all along what was to happen.


The fact this was made half a year ago shows how fast these days are


Sawtooth waves: “magic mirror”

Me, an intelectual: nether portal

Sawtooth waves: “magic mirror”

Me, an intelectual: *nether portal*

End the portal Ender is caming (End Portal)

I  love   ur    channel ❤💞🥞🦚🍔🍟🍱🎨🖼🌌🌉🌇🌆🌅🌄🎠🌈💧   my   name              is    Kashvi

@Dasiyland09 minecraft and he spawn in basalt and get hitted by ghast

Now the only question is, which side is hell?

wait a second...

HEY, DOES ANYONE WANNA HELP ME BUILD THE MLP WORLD IN MINECRAFT?
if i manage to keep myself motivated i mean lol

Just imagine twilight walking through nether portal

I love minecraft! Especially the nether!

@•°Ananya°• congratulations have fun

2 weeks later: addicted

@Mary Beth Ferguson I got Minecraft few days ago

@Mary Beth Ferguson same XD I just got a enchanting table XD and diamonds

Ya cause only the nether could create the likes of this 2:27

I really wanna like this but you already have a stack of likes...


to be honest look at the sirens they tearned  into the same beast it could be that they were ponys who earned the magic by feeding of hate


Maybe it relates to the intelligence level of the species or how common they are.


The sirens would be humans probably because of their mythology. Sirens are known as mermaids that have a powerful, seductive singing voice that lears ships to them. And because mermaids are basically humans with fish tails it makes perfect sense.
Just listen to the sirens songs in ‘under our spell’, ‘battle of the bands’ and ‘welcome to the show’. See how they effect the humans?
The students of canterlot high are under their spell leard by their song to go against each other.
It would make perfect sense why the sirens would come out as humans. Their beautiful looks might have helped get the students to vote for them in the battle of the bands seeing as sirens in mythology are typically very beautiful women to seduce the people on the ships to lear them to them


I have an interesting theory for you, are ponies destined to fall in love like how cutie marks are a destined talent. Think about it, mrs and mr cake have the similar cutie marks but had it way before they met. Then you got the apple family which all somehow have cutie marks relating to fruit, shouldn't there at least be one pony in that family that doesn't have a fruit related cutie mark?


Anyone else noticed Sawtooth's new wings? It's probably a changeling thing-

Luckyyy

Anyone else noticed Sawtooth's new wings? It's probably a changeling thing-

*Luckyyy*


Where'd you get owl Gallus from? He looks hilarious.


I think it's more like what is the creature that goes throuth induvidually, Sike is Twilights assitsant and he became a pet. Spike is very much Twilights friend and not pet but if you look at it Spike is kind of the wizards goblin servent kind of thing which makes him a dog in the human world persona. If Ember went into the portal she would prob be a human because she is indipendant and more like that sort of thing and if like the first big dragon we saw in season 1 would be prob a bear or something. So like less of race and more of job, lifestyle and etc. (sorry for bad spelling)


I consider the Kirin more canine. They look like fox lion things


Okay, I have an idea on why Spike turned into a dog. Dogs are pets and companions to humans. And while Spike isn’t exactly a pet to Twilight, he <b>is</b> a companion. He is always there for Twilight, and helps her whenever she needs help. Kinda like how dogs are always there for their owners. Dogs know when we’re feeling down. Dogs help us. So I don’t have an answer on what Griffins or Changelings would be like in the human world, but this was my theory on why Spike transformed into a dog.

Okay, I have an idea on why Spike turned into a dog. Dogs are pets and companions to humans. And while Spike isn’t exactly a pet to Twilight, he *is* a companion. He is always there for Twilight, and helps her whenever she needs help. Kinda like how dogs are always there for their owners. Dogs know when we’re feeling down. Dogs help us. So I don’t have an answer on what Griffins or Changelings would be like in the human world, but this was my theory on why Spike transformed into a dog.


I like how Gallus looses his hecking neck in the thumbnail


3:02 I think I know how to contact spike with dogs. So spike never left twilight and he was always by her side sense the first day twilight adopted him just like a boy would. Dogs always will be by their owners side sense the first day they adopt them and take care of them. I think that’s why spike turned into a dog when he went to the human world even though dragons and dogs have no connections. this can make things easier but also a bit messier because other dragons aren’t like spike so they might not turn into a dog and some more things that have to be explained like if this is how this magic works we have to know every tribes personalities and culture and more though I did came up with something that can explain why ponies become humans in the way I explained why spike became a dog here’s he short of it. As far as i know ponies where the most intelligent creatures in Equestria (I don’t know I wrote it right or not) and their in charge for most of the things like raising sun and moon just like humans and as we see on mlp new generation ponies technologies (as far as I can remember) and this is very similar to the human world. I know humans in human world had technology long time before equestria had but equestria still had some technologies that humans had so I guess this is why ponies turn into humans. hope you see this and I hope you like it 😁 I know it’s not a good idea but I guess there is a very small chance it be possible (I hope so)


Since the sirens to me look more dragoness than they do any form of pony I think it's as simple as just when you go to the portal you get turned into whatever your counterpart is Spike's not a dog because dragons turn into dogs Spike the dog because it's counterpart is a dog because of that we have no idea what say amber would turn into because we have not seen accountable


I’d like to think it’s at least hoofed mammals because the idea of Buffalo (which are coded as indigenous equestrians) becoming animals is uh quite problematic


I'm pretty sure what someone turns into is based upon what their counterpart is in the mirror world. The mane six all have human counter parts and spike just happens to have a dog counterpart.


Donkeys also become humans cause we saw Cranky as a teacher at the school.


Something tells me that Spike was never a human. It seems that the first season episode, "Green Isn't Your Color", revealed that Spike had a crush on Rarity. Megan McCartney said that this concept is making no sense as it turned out that Rarity and Spike could have break and ended their relationship according to concepts. And I guess the G5 version might put Equestrian Girls (which if anybody want Hasbro to let Spike become human) on it.


How about this? That human world could have aliens, making the changelings' counterpart could be aliens due to bug eyes. Those moon aliens in Ducktales reboot, like Lunaris and Penumbra, had similar eyes like the changelings excluding their queen.<br>And if hippogriff/campus got magic form like the mane 6, they could be 'mermaids'.

How about this? That human world could have aliens, making the changelings' counterpart could be aliens due to bug eyes. Those moon aliens in Ducktales reboot, like Lunaris and Penumbra, had similar eyes like the changelings excluding their queen.
And if hippogriff/campus got magic form like the mane 6, they could be 'mermaids'.


I just had a theory about the royal sisters
Here:
I have been thinking about it a lot, and something that fixes a lot of things is if Celestia and Luna's parents were alicorns.
Then it would make sense that they would think its a regal thing and say the thing about Flurry Heart and stuff.
They are the daughters of King cosmos and Queen Galaxia or somepony like them.
It actually make sense because of the fact that when I hear "blah blah never alicorn b4" I heard that they were not born in equestria (I mean, obvious already) but also that they were born royalty. This starts to make sense the more you think about it, so just think...


I think Spike became a dog just because his primary trait going through was subservient loyalty to twilight.  That said, I do not think Ember would be a dog on the other side.


<b>He was so disgusted by the human versions of the diamond dogs-</b>

*He was so disgusted by the human versions of the diamond dogs-*

HAVE YOU SEEN THOSE GREMLINS ABSOLUTELY A DISGRACE TO MLP

@Kirk Lundberg not to mention Kim il sung Kim jong un Julius Caesar not sure if Vladimir Putin counts but yeah and so much More including the dictator of Belarus so yeah

@Blaize Gottman most dictators are corrupted by absolute power like Hitler and Stalin.

@Kirk Lundberg OK because Twilight Care's about everyone a Savage dictator like Joseph Stalin doesn't Care about anyone

@Kirk Lundberg oh OK so she isn't like Joseph Stalin

@Blaize Gottman no, the definition of a dictator is one or few who hold a lot more power, but most dictators don't care about their subjects.

@Sarina Bock and Twilight is not a dictator that would be More like tirek or Chrysalis

@Kirk Lundberg well never discord so definitely sawtooth Waves

@Blaize Gottman face it would you rather have a democracy under sawtooth or a funocracy under discord

@the Ark yeah they look similar to the bullies from power Puff girls and his claim that Twilight is a dictator is wrong 100%


I feel like Spike became a dog because of his relationship with Twilight, he is her loyal companion in the pony world. And what better creature is a loyal companion to a human?


eh, my guess is Changelings default to human, while in their personal or pony forms, but it one were to go through as a dragon they would be a dog on the other side. Basically their disguise becomes their body in the "human" world. <br>I hesitate to even call them human though, since no human i know has bright pink, blue, yellow, or purple skin

eh, my guess is Changelings default to human, while in their personal or pony forms, but it one were to go through as a dragon they would be a dog on the other side. Basically their disguise becomes their body in the "human" world.
I hesitate to even call them human though, since no human i know has bright pink, blue, yellow, or purple skin


maybe its a matter of legs? spike and the diamond dogs in the pony world are two legged, but become 4 legged in the human world, meanwhile creatures that are 4 legged, become two legged (although technically the sirens only have 2 legs, they still have that equine connection that make them treat their tails like their back legs)


I think it is relative to the role they play in the story<br>Spike is a company in character to twilight so spike became a companion creature in the human world

I think it is relative to the role they play in the story
Spike is a company in character to twilight so spike became a companion creature in the human world


Maybe the tranformational magic of the portal is defined by those attuned to it and the end result is based on the relationship  to those atunned


theory about changelings : changelings will turn into humans but they attend a different school, an acting school. this could explain their 'change'ling part. maybe they're good at pretending to be other people? or maybe in their past form the school they attended was a strict school with a strict dress code. when they were reformed, principal chrysalis disappeared from the reformed changelings. they chose a new leader and made a new acting school! when mixed with the "starlight attends hive high" video maybe there could a drama club in the school! though it brings up the problem that is the drama club the only club in hive high? maybe principal chrysalis refused to accept other clubs except for the drama club.


Hm.. didn´t know if you even read comments under older videos but:  What if it hasn´t to do anything with the species... but with the relationship of characters?   Spike is Twilights pet dragon... so he turns into a pet that matches his persona... so for example he is loyal to Twilight what we assosiate with a dog rather than a cat or rabbit for example.... but if an other dragon... lets say Emer walks through the portal... she also could come out as a human because she has no pet relation to someone else.


Sawtooth: There’s no way to know until a changeling goes through the portal-<br>...I'm a changeling...🤔

Sawtooth: There’s no way to know until a changeling goes through the portal-
...I'm a changeling...🤔

Also at the end of the vidio, he turned into a differnt pony, so i think he is a changeling.

Since changelings are shape-shifters, if they go through the portal and magic now exists in the Equestria Girls universe, wouldn't they have the ability to shape-shift into anything in that universe?

I literally just said the same thing. And if he ever decides to go on with that we could possibly get a fave reveal.


I think it would be something like this take spike for example even though he is a dragon if he walks on all four he would look like a dog and I believe depending of  how the creature looks it depends what he'll be in the other world so if a griffin go through the portal it would be a bird because he looks like one.


What if all ponies becomes human and every other thing turns into what they personality relates to.

For example: spike is like a loyal dog to their owner


I Believe the portal works depending on how many legs you walk on, think about it, ponies walk on four legs and when they go though the portal they turn into a creature that walks on two legs in this instant humans, Spike walks on two legs so when he went through the portal he turned into a creature that walks on four legs,a dog. Before you go saying, what about the sirens, if it were not for the fins and the fact that they could fly, they would walk on four legs, therefore when they went through the portal they would turn into something that walked on two legs. Same for the diamond dogs, they walk on four legs so on the other side of the portal they would be something that walks on two legs.


to be fair dragon are known as shape shifter... so maybe spike took the form of a dog by random... as in he could had the ability to change shape as in human lore dragon can take on the form of other creature.   It even said at time they need the dna of the thing there taking the form of. From there it easy to say maybe a hair or something from a pet was present for him to take the form of it. (Basically your only thinking of pony lore you forgot to mix in the human lore bit.)   It also can be how one think of themselves... spike see himself as a pony not a dragon so spike may have took a form closer to how he see himself. so the world compensated and turn him into something common that has 4 legs.  His name also could had play a part also.


Love your vids Sawtooth! Keep the good work!!


I think that the reason that Spike turned into a dog is to reference the fact that he is the most loyal to Twilight Sparkle. He went against Celestia who wanted it to just be a journey for Twilight to take. Plus dogs are often the first thing people think of when it comes to the word loyalty. I think its more than just if it's a dragon it will automatically be a dog. I think the mirror CHOSE for Spike to take on the form of a dog since it is the form that was most appropriate.


neste mundo também tem magia (como sirenes e frindship), então por que o changelling não pode mudar a forma para todos os tipos de criaturas no mundo humano? (como um cachorro, um humam, insetos, coelhinhos, gatos, etc...) with changellings magic.


A changeling would probably become a comeleon. I mean it makes sense right? Changelings mimick other creatures and things. While a comeleon mimicks colors. I could be wrong but that would be cool


The diamond dogs are already dogs so they switch to a non-dog creature at least that’s what I think what’s going on. Sawtooth if you see this please let me know your thoughts please and thank you.