How even was nightmare moon banished to the moon?
Was she in the moon?
Was she on the moon?


But for some of the villain defeats were in morning time (chrysalis, tirek)


I think a group of stars where the least  of nightmare moon's magic cuz remember that time when applejack said not all of nightmare moon's magic was gone I think that was the group of stars that aid in her escape and if you ask where in only a thousand years maybe there was a lot the prevented her from escaping in the moon until a group of ponies was able to stop her


You said in another video that Pegasi fly using MAGIC, but if magic was erased from Equestria, then Pegasi wouldn't be able to fly.....


I think Grogar did aid in nightmare moons escape and is still watching down. I also think discord might know this


Uhhh, this is like the WORST time to say this but...

Who's grogar? 😅😅

Uhhh, this is like the *WORST* time to say this but...

Who's grogar? 😅😅


I had to double check the publishing date. Honestly this theory would of been so much cooler


I wonder if gusty the great was a mentor to star swirl

🌸-ᴍɪꜱᴛʏ ᴄʟᴏᴜᴅ-🌸


Astronomers: See three bright star next to each other
Astronomers: “ Omg that looks exactly like a ram!”

Astronomers: *See three bright star next to each other*
Astronomers: “ Omg that looks exactly like a ram!”


I'm still confused what kind of element does Sunset Shimmer has.

Maybe there are only six elements because the tree of harmony has room for only 6 diamonds

Well i think cause human twilight has the element of magic i think sunset has the element of forgiveness and we can see starlight glimmer in the future being the element of forgiveness its not canon i just made a theory

Рейв / Габріель

Рейв / Габріель


just saying, it was discord. AND i already know where grogar is, he was hidden inside one of the barns at sweet apple acers as a portrait, in one of the episodes a picture looked off and there was rams horns in it and a constalation but good theory


I think twilight controls the stars her cutie Mark has stars and her element has a star I think not only her element is Magic it might also mean stars


Well uh, technically Grogar would've never left his star prison because discord was impersonating grogar the whole time


after the season 9 finale, grogar was in fact discord... so this theory about grogar's escape a little off. Can you do an update on this?

I think Grogars just somewhere in Eqeustria


I follow the IDW comic. And there is a similiar concept.
Discord has crazy ex girlfriend who became bunch of stars. The stars fell, and when alicorns touched them, she became more and more awake.

Just saying

+yakir chernin   I hated that arc so much.
Not only the retcon messed things up with Discord and also messed with the sisters' significance of finding the Elements to beat him, but I really didn't like seeing Luna getting possessed and absorbed by Cosmos like that too.
And I feel like Luna got wasted since the whole stars thing here.

Type in the link plz, cuz i wanna see/read


Grogar was actually just Discord pretending to be him (I mean not in Equestria's history but like when he brought the villains together)


Technically some of this theory can still be canon


It’s pronounced Sagittarius not Satarus love you though! I just wanted to let you know because I’m a Sagittarius and it bothered me that it wasn’t pronounced correctly


Question about when the everfree forest unveited if celestia banish nightmare moon and had the element of magic after that how did the element of magic disapired in the first place did celestia make the element disapire or did it just disapire by itselft and i have alot of questions about those posters in the glass window in the end of the episode


did you forget that discord was acting as grogar, but i like your theory


I think discord helped in the escape even tho he was stuck in stone,but this theory is very possible there’s a lower chance of discord bc he was stuck in stone


Actually you forget that discord is the one protending to be grogar at season 9😁


the constellation on twilight's dress has 5 stars when only 4 bailed out nightmare moon


I love Astrology and mentioning some of the signs makes me fangirl 🤩


My theory is that grogar takes 100 years to round the moon


What if grogar and nightmare moon worked together when nightmare moon made princess celestia disappear in the first season?


I think yes Grogar did bail out Nightmare Moon


Star swirl bailed out night mare moon ! Look at the journal of the two sisters!


Fantastic job Dr Wolf & Brony Notion. I really enjoyed this video. Keep up the good work. Have a wonderful day.


I know the grill guard which was seen in the videos that lasted forever you know no question the one with all the ponies I don‘t member what it’s called but I do remember that girl card wasn‘t a real grow God it was discord pretending to be grow God


He may have been the stars but the spell didn’t stop


What would being banished to the moon be like?


Honestly, if this was a true theory, its cruel and would reasonably make grogar angry..

I mean think about it, stars are hot. Like REALLY hot- if somepony banished someone there they would just be burning for eternity..


No way! <br>And I think you’re right! I love watching your theory’s!

No way!
And I think you’re right! I love watching your theory’s!


No one had moved the stars that animator has done it.


Since we found out grogar was discord. I think grogar is still up there and may only come up in the future of equestria


Cozy glow used to be nice but then she wanted power just to make friends at the school of friendship. Cozy glow was sent to taruras for stealing all magic like tirek. Cozy: "hey neighbor! Wanna be friends?" *makes evil face*.


Teachnically at the final battle grogar didn't exscape Discord was just pretending to be like grogar duh!so grogar didn't really escape from the stars


I loved the video brony notion I liked being in the premiere chat you come up with the best theories and you have the best YouTube channel name ever! 😃


Faust confirmed that Celestia <b>herself</b> aided in her escape

Faust confirmed that Celestia *herself* aided in her escape

Keep Calm & Contemplate Your Life Choices

sebastian banguis oh ok I wonder what her thoughts on grogar

@Caleb Prescott Lauren left after season 3. And I don't think she would've kept the secret THAT long. At least a hint to the Grogar thing.

I am disappoint at lauren Faust about grogar twist


wouldn't cozy's spell have to happen before he helped nightmare moon?


Grogar DID bail out NightMare Moon because who do you think rised the sun,moon and stars.


Brony notion the stars that frees luna from the moon is the spirits that helps her when she gets scared in her dreams.


Do you plan on continuing to post after MLP ends? Love your videos~


So In Season 9 Grogar Was Discord So Does That Mean He Is Still In The Stars?


I have a theory on how Luna and Celeste are different drum cadence and twilight is because I think that and Celestia had more power then cadence and  twilight because if we go on with the Star swirl made Luna and Celestia an alicorn that means that they have more power then cadence and twilight


Your theory is still plausible because

Spoilers:

we find out that grogar actually is discord in disguise. So maybe the REAL grogar is still banished in the stars.


We found out that in season 9 grogar was actually dicord in disguise


Oh no the series ended!! What are gonna THEORIZE ABOUT

@Nehal Imran you please give my love of me


Grogar was revealed to be discord in disguise so he may still be up there

I think hes somewhere on the ground, not stars, since he was released by Cozy


celestia was banished to the moon too, in the first timeline, that starlight made, DUH!


Lauren Faust: let’s make this nonsense no one’s even gonna notice.  sawtooth waves : every video 😂🤣


and then the season 9 finale completely ruined all this hard work-


I think Luna freed herself.because Luna can control the moon and the stars,right?


... could the MLP stars be the souls of the dead ponys? (and other creatures)


Well considering Celestia somehow has a nephew, but Luna doesnt have any kids, perhaps it IS another sibling, or perhaps another sibling was around at some point


Hey it's so if Google was a calculation and Dusty was enabled and Dusty was gone when he came back so what that means is he's magic would already fail begone?


You're going to be so disappointed when the finale airs.

@Plonkett
technically, yes I agree
However not everyone is going to see it that way.

@Forsaken Fenix 24/25 is the finale, while 26 is the epilogue.


I'm from the future and discord (spoiler warning just in case) was grogar so that means... he still hasn't escaped...


Here’s my theory discord disguised as Kroger to get the villains together that’s why he didn’t get discord and of course the working together part that’s what the ponies would’ve said but when cozy glow drained all the magic out of the Equestria Kroger Didn’t get free Kroger is still in the stars but he might get out in pony life


also, grogar is STILL there! it was only Discord pretending to be. I know that this was made before we knew, but just wanted to say it


Your theory maybe true because the Grogar in MLP season 9 is just discord in disguise.

𝗜𝘁𝘇𝗚𝗲𝗼𝗿𝗴𝗲𝗛𝘂𝘁𝗮𝗯𝗮𝗿𝗮𝘁


If you haven't seen the few last episode
Well...

SPOILERS  !

Grogar wasn't actually Grogar... It was discord disguising as him, Discord wanted one last challenge for twillight beforr being the new ruler of equestria, but Tirek, Crysalis and Cozy managed to steal all of his chaos magic, so it didn't turned out how discord wanted-

I don't think Grogar escaped the stars then (if he was astually a constellation-)

Sorry if I misspelled something, I am not a native english speaker  ;;


wait, grogar in mlp was revealed to be discord. u said the grogar was released, but it doesn't add up. is he still a constellation? is he still out there besides discord?


SAWTOOTH WHAT DID LUNA DO if you dont know Luna moves the stars and the moon. When Luna was banished Celestia took over her job. Lauren Faust tweeted that the one who  bailed out Night Mare Moon controlled the sun moon and the stars and thats Celestia. Celestia CONTROLLED the sun moon and the stars so thats why Celestia did it   : 3


If night mare moon  can escape from the moon. Then grogar can escape from the stars . Then why didn't grogar escape when night mare moon escapes ?and why how did he get the power to set her free he doesn't have any power up there  .


Grogar when Luna gets reformed: I have made an error


“Aries”<br>Ah, okay, guess I’m a mythological talking villain ram-

“Aries”
Ah, okay, guess I’m a mythological talking villain ram-

Grogar is Demon Ram Necromancer and he is more powerful than 1.000 army.


Grogar was a villain in the previous generations before friendship is Magic


3:50 so your saying Grogar was a zodiac sign at one time? Cool


My sister watched this video with me and asked if gusty the great was the two alcorn sisters mother I was gonna say no then i got vary confused on how she thought of this 0-0


Spoiler alert - so I have seen the s9 finale and to be honest the theory is not explained and showed in the finale that is because grogar is actually discord. And was only the tryout by to help twilight gain more confidence by her defeating all three villains but it not how is goes. And here is a link for people who that would like to watch the finale episode in english
https://disk.yandex.ru/d/GmNOpb7BCl-H2A
It from episode 22-26 enjoy☺


I have a question, When a vilaine in MLP IS DEFEATED WHY DO THEY ONLY APEER 1000 YEARS LATER??? WHY NOT MORE OR LESS YEARS???


Gusty the great the army must’ve been her friends and they must’ve been the old owners of the elements of harmony come on think about it it all adds up I have been watching your videos


Wait a sec. Grogar wasn't Grogar it was Discord playing his role right?


Grogar was not really out discord was pretending to be grogar so his still in the stars


What if Cozy Glow got away with stealing the magic of Equestria how long would the magic be gone or in other words how long would it last??????????


Are we ignoring that he pronounced Sagittarius As “Satarus”


If grogar was the stars that bailed night mare moon where was he when he freed the dark mare ?


How can he move when he is still a consolation


Welll discord was grogar he changed into him with his magic....

*Insert super duper mega ultra cool name here*

it's possible he's just still sealed away


If grogar actually is those stars the ram is like a big line the stars surrounding the moon where all spread out around her


Are you going to post again??? I miss the theories 😭😭😭 but I get it if you're busy, take as much time as you need👌🏻😁


Remer you said that luna control's the moon and the stars so that means that luna baled her self out


Um you do realize that grogar wasn't really grogar in the episode where he frees the villains it was discord setting up a challenge for the mane 6.😕

The video was posted before the episode, he didn't now its was discord<br>His theory can still be right, but grogar wasnt freeded from the stars.

The video was posted before the episode, he didn't now its was discord
His theory can still be right, but grogar wasnt freeded from the stars.


Dude! Spoiler warning that Nightmare Moon escapes the moon?? I haven't seen that episode yet!

@robloxgirlwithadog  it just i different things one time

@Sawtooth Waves dude can you do something else like gaming

Bruh, how are you a Brony if you haven’t seen the first episode? 🤨

@Sawtooth Waves hey bro I never seen mlp so Steve unverise

Uhhhh that was the FIRST episode.<br>WHAT THE HECK!!

Uhhhh that was the FIRST episode.
WHAT THE HECK!!

Dude! That was the pilot episode! How did you not see it?

@Hu Tao's Simp Same here Uni. Same here.

Inky Scrolls turns out he was not joking.

TheBlueBuilder the first episode I watch was crystal empire...

XD guess you have not seen ep. 1 yet then. or all of MLP. You might want to go watch it. lol.


I Love this theory so much. It has so much proof but discord what is Google but this theory could still be true


I have been watching your episodes and gusty the great was the last owner of the elements of harmony that’s what I think all your videos add up think about it


What am I missing when did season 9 come out?!?!


You still uploading makes me happy! 💚💜 dude you were my childhood!!


how did the sun and the moon rise without princess luna and celestia


I think gorger aided in night mare moons escape too and if he couldn't get out he would of course <br>bail out nightmare moon if he could NOT escape he would help nightmare moon escape seeing as they are both villains he would help her escape to do more evil things.. ok now listen that's MY theory if nobody agrees that's perfectly fine it's my theory others can have other theories :)

I think gorger aided in night mare moons escape too and if he couldn't get out he would of course
bail out nightmare moon if he could NOT escape he would help nightmare moon escape seeing as they are both villains he would help her escape to do more evil things.. ok now listen that's MY theory if nobody agrees that's perfectly fine it's my theory others can have other theories :)


Sawtooths-Waves's next thumbnail:<br>Why didn't Sawtooth Waves watch the whole season before making up theories?

Sawtooths-Waves's next thumbnail:
Why didn't Sawtooth Waves watch the whole season before making up theories?


Bra I’m still waiting for season nine to come out on Netflix-


❗Spoiler Alert ❗Grogard that we know now is really DISCORD!!! I saw it in one of the final episodes!!!!!!!

mlp unicorn lovers say spoiler or delete comment


But Discord turned out to be Grogar, Grogar could still be up there


your just ignoring one little detail who knew that grogar was going to let free Nightmare moon because the book said Nightmare moon will be free in a 1000 years


So Aeris is both the god of war, and a ram constellation?


Please don't get mad at me for pointing this out but... at around 4:28 ish you say that the constellation was Aries... that was actually Taurus... sorry. Wrong constellation.


What is this? Can youtubers hold videos? I never seen this and don't understand it. Could someone please explain it. Thanks.

@CaitoThePotato i think you did pretty good

It's a premiere, it's like a live as of the live chat and everybody watching it is seeing it all at the same point, but it's a video that they've already made and picked for it to be shown out to everybody at the same time. Sorry that I'm not very good at explaining!


I have not seen all season 9 yet I think this theory is a bit wrong bc Discord was disguising as Gorgar...


He might have given aid to nightmare moon but he was not freed because u know why if somebody wants to know about Grogan its a spoiler so don't read it if u don't want to know before watching but technically it was discord who was pretending to be grogar


How do grogar scape and cosy glow drain magic so past time


You died for a while then post like what 3-5 videos.<br>Good job! I love your channel.

You died for a while then post like what 3-5 videos.
Good job! I love your channel.


So now that season 9 is long past imagine this theory being rights it’s just Grogar is still Ares


6:58
Me : * hears a door opening*
Dr Wolf : * casually walks in for no reason whatsoever*
Me : WHAT THE HELL ARE U DOING HERE?


I think in the My Little Pony Universe stars are little balls of magic not dispose of gas Magic


but one more thing were missing.... discord, in the MLP season 9 grogar ended up Discord the question is is discord THE grogar or is he just grogar then ????

Grogar is a real figure, but Discord was pretending to be him


It reminded me how stars are portraited in Fallout Equestria at the beginning :3


No grogar never escaped because in season 9 it was discord who<br>Pretended to be grogar

No grogar never escaped because in season 9 it was discord who
Pretended to be grogar


It can’t be Groga because it was discord who was pretending to be Grogar


Sawtooth: GROGAR WHERE THE STARS

face flurry: let me just interrupt-

Sawtooth: GROGAR WHERE THE STARS

face flurry: *let me just interrupt-*


I would like to say the Gusty the great's cutie mark looks like stars.


When will the video summarize the entire all show and all theories be?


that's not right when chrisilis cozy and tirek used the bell they were stronger and I think the 4 stars were her magic because when she was nightmare moon she was powerful enough to beat her sister


Sawtooth your making me the best mlp oc theory to make thanks to you


The Crusaders were not the ones that let discord go because Celestia said that Luna and her had the elements of harmony and they use that to turn discord into stone but when the main six got them it stop the elements of harmony’s magic and let him go because they were not the ones that trapped him Luna and Celeste did that is what Celestia said I am not lying and that’s also why nightmare moon was able to go because Celetis banished her and on the longest day of the year she was able to come back but she just needed some help so Grogar helped her


SPOILER!!!<br>Even tho Starswirl didn't turn out to be Discord... Grogar did!

SPOILER!!!
Even tho Starswirl didn't turn out to be Discord... Grogar did!

@Dark he/she means Grogar in the episodes was not the Grogar from the stories

Or rather, the Grogar we saw in the episodes. Tirek's description in the S9 opening strongly implied Grogar was very real.


Think you are right it make sense his was stuck there in the fist please. But what about the area the stars what do the rest   <br>they were stuck too.

Think you are right it make sense his was stuck there in the fist please. But what about the area the stars what do the rest
they were stuck too.


Those stars are like the ones in the portal


Idk why but I think you always make the logic in mlp


How can twilight's book know that in the future grogar will help nightmare moon escape when he will stillbe trapped himslf


How old are the princesses and what is their life span

sriya mellacheruvu
They’re immortal and they were students under StarSwirl when he was originally around which was about 1000 years prior to the timeline of the show
So over a 1000 years.


There’s one thing that’s missing: What does the My Little Pony Planet look like?


Sawtooth: Calls Sagittarius Centarus
Me: Okay, dude, I’ll respect your pronouns, but I won’t respect you frigging up the name of my Zodiac sign loads shotgun of wisdom with bullets of pure astronomical knowledge

Sawtooth: *Calls Sagittarius Centarus*
Me: Okay, dude, I’ll respect your pronouns, but I won’t respect you frigging up the name of my Zodiac sign *loads shotgun of wisdom with bullets of pure astronomical knowledge*


Wait a minute. Watch this clip: 0:38. Why is the magic around Twilight's horn clear? Shouldn't it be pink?


Alternate video title: A evil ram that is a star sign<br>Me as a Aries ♈: so what you’re saying is that I’m evil?

Alternate video title: A evil ram that is a star sign
Me as a Aries ♈: so what you’re saying is that I’m evil?


End of season 9 = we haven't actually seen Grogar. Soooo...

Yeah but grogar is still confirmed to exist


School: Lasts 1000 years
Grogar (The teacher): Opens class door after 1000 years
Nightmare Moon: Ight imma head out

5 mins later
Nightmare Moon: I'm back to retake school again


Wait a minute, isn't the Posiedon in the video on 2:31 from Poptropica ? I play Poptropica and I love it !!!! Also the Posiedon in the video is from the Poptropica's ' Mythology Island ' .....


I think that Starlight Glimmer bailed out Nightmare Moon


But grogar was also discovered to be desguiesd


Ummm does noone know that grogar in season 9 is just the lord of chaos trying to help twilight .....


So if discord is grogar, where is he now and what is he doing and is he planning something for the grown up main six


Wait on twilight’s dress there was 5 stars but the book said 4 stars will aid her escape.


Well now we figured out Grogar is discord wait.. is this cannon or was it only released in Australia btw everything changed


I’m trying to think of a joke about Space Core, Wheatley, And Nightmare Moon all being on the moon but I’ve got nothing


wasnt grogar in season 9 actually discord so how does that make sense shouldnt he still be up there cause it wasnt actually.


I personally think that I can fly and touch the sky and all I ever wanted was a mac and cheese but I only got macaronis


I don't think that grogar escaped because it was discord pretending to be grogar


@Optimus prime polska season* grogar* real* grogar* and don’t give mf spoilers

Is my astrological sign ( I’m a Capricorn ♑ ) in the mlp universe?

@Optimus prime polska Grogar is real, it’s just that the one we saw was a fake.

<b>DrWolf001</b> you shall never know unless you watch THE video

*DrWolf001* you shall never know unless you watch THE video

@Optimus prime polska you spoilled my favorite show when i was 3 and btw im 8 so it was 5 years ago but i havnt watched any of the new videos for some reason but im on my moms phone

@My Gymnastics World I am talking about actual laws. Legally speaking you shouldn't have an account before you're 13. 13 is the minimum age. Sure you're mom says you're old enough but that doesn't change the law.

@My Gymnastics World 1) you're not suppose to even have a YT account.
2) I have multiple comments here. There is no context to which one you're referring to.
3) this thread is old as hell.

@XxMidnightwolf xX I wasn't<br>wasn't blaming anyone and YOU were the one who jumped into a dead conversation. Bye

@XxMidnightwolf xX I wasn't
wasn't blaming anyone and YOU were the one who jumped into a dead conversation. Bye

@Cameo Shadowness I said don’t blame me I didn’t say you blamed me stop before this turns into an argument good day

@XxMidnightwolf xX did I blame ANY of you? No I didn't.

@Cameo Shadowness I’m watch it on Netflix and it stops at season 8 but they are 9 seasons so don’t blame me and others might not have seen it

@XxMidnightwolf xX do you not realize how old this thread is?

@my Talking Ginger and talting Hank polska grogar*

You shall NEVER know where the “Dr. Wolf” sign came from. (P.S. it came from saw 🦷🌊🌊🌊)

Plus I think Aries is the God of war. Not a group of stars.

He definitely didn’t impersonate you at all

DRWolf001 so um... did you have a meeting with Sketchy? Because notion and AnY... umm... nevermind. Ill tell you thenext time i see you at a con

@my Talking Ginger and talting Hank polska dude! I liked you! How dare you!

@Arachnid iruma no I don't. I said, I was pissed someone ruined the story for others, I gave a warning and a chance to back off. The other who I addressed firstly didn't. You had no chance to skip it if you wanted to. There was no warning, just HERE GOES THE MOST IMPORTANT PLOT TWIST. With no room to avoid if you read comment chains.

I did it in a specific way so people can avoid if they desired. The other didn't.

@Cameo Shadowness but I thought you were cool with it you basictly said so in your last comment someone has two different stories here 🤔

@my Talking Ginger and talting Hank polska stop spoiling for them OK actually spoiler alert

Pinkie pie and cheese have a baby and before that and I mean long before that in episode 25 s9 the villain squad took the magic from the bell and destroyed half of canterlot done also sorry if you got spoiled

@Emma Maher so did I. Such a great way to end the show. Although I never saw the Final episode I saw part 1 and 2 of The end of the End

@my Talking Ginger and talting Hank polska as Melody Pond once said "Spoilers"

DRWolf001 hey, what are you gonna do about that sign? And when? (Dr.Wolf is onto you)

@Hate the fangirl they're telling the truth, I saw the three final episodes but only with subtitles because it's in a different language sorry everyone for the spoiler.

DRWolf001 which mlp is better is it the idw comic or the show

@Mahantesh Patil Stop what?  I'm not the one going around ruining an entire show for people.

https://youtu.be/jEWai4jYrGo shhhhh i didnt say anything...

Are you gonna do anything about that sign?

@my Talking Ginger and talting Hank polska WHY YHE FUCK ARE YOU GIVING SPOILERS?!

That is a good question that is for another day


Lol I’m an Aries ♈
It’s funny that grogar is a ram and he is also my sign

(I’m not evil!)

@Alicorn Kristina
I’m sorry I’m stupid,
What sign is that?


I dont think that it was grogar who helped the villians to escape because discord was pretending he was grogar!!!


What if the princess had a star sister to help trap goargar


I love this video it's so funny and intresting in teh same way


6:42 It's "The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe"


when they are banished dosent mean they can t see or hear you


But then it turned out "Grogar" was Discord so the released Grogar theory is out the window...

Or is it?

But then it turned out "Grogar" was Discord so the released Grogar theory is out the window...

*Or is it?*


and now that's a great example of don't just assume it to be because that grogar is discord in disguise


This might sound dumb but is there a princess of all magic in genral?


5:07 "that must've been one heck of a year"
All of us post-2020, tiredly: I'd believe it.

5:07 "that must've been one heck of a year"
*All of us post-2020, tiredly:* I'd believe it.


3rd royal sibling? You mean ancestor of that annoing Blueblood right ? :)


And doesn’t grogars magic aura is the colour if stars in a night sky


If you have seen equestria girls, spike turned into a dog. What would happen if you brought Wanona or opalescence into the other world?


Night mare moon used the stars to escape


3:51 so i'm a aries so that means my sign in mlp is grogar-


Please make a conspiracy on what will happen to celestia and Luna now that twilight is the new ruler of equestria???

Рейв / Габріель


I like the theory there over sibling cousin  /their dad


The new Grogar was proven to discord. Now this wouldn't make sense.


sawtooth said the night sky was its own realm<br>that explains why astroponies dont exist

sawtooth said the night sky was its own realm
that explains why astroponies dont exist

wow and ppl think nobody ever uses the letter x


Nightmare moon was released because she was released on the longest day of the 1000 th year


Then it turns out grogar's still in the stars and grogar in earth was actually discord


Sagittarius which I have a bachelor's degree well certified by the Department of education with the full knowledge of modern astronomy and sagittarius is the centaur constellation which also I am a beyblade fan as well as a casual fan of MLP I remember that the Beyblade Saggitario which is the beyblade based off the constellation saggitarius uses the exact depiction of the actual spirit of the constellation and even rock Aries or in this case Grogar is the exact same thing but I have a theory that Grogar is an actual spirit of the constellation Aries but some of the  villain's like Tirek is the embodiment of saggitarius which is seen the beyblade anime as well which  in this case Tirek does not have a human face but the torso of a humanoid figure and the hands in this case have thumbs and thumbs that are like what humans have are seen in every single mythological lore even the vast lores of the native American tribes of the muscogee which is the tribe I hail part of there are lore of mythological creatures with opposable thumbs like humans.
But this is going off topic but Grogar in my theory is the embodiment of the constellation Aries which in this case is a bad constellation that is from the negative energy of evil and hatred. And same with nightmare moon I think that in the case of princess luna becoming nightmare moon she was possessed by jealously which is one of the seven deadly sins in biblical stories under the name of the term envy which is jealously. I theorize that Luna was possessed by jealously in the early years of the sisters which made nightmare moon a reality and that moment Celestia discovering the elements of harmony and using them on nightmare moon making the longest day on 1000th year with the return of nightmare moon unavoidable and making it inevitable for the elements to be used for the embodiment of harmony linking the mane 6 together with their cutie marks becoming the spirits of harmony and thus progressing the future of equestria but I also notice that Grogar was also seen in the tale of clover the clever which was just his face and not his body meaning that he was watching from afar using his magic that is controlled from the constellation Aries.
But I don't know it's just my own theory of Grogar


well, but now we know that grogar was discord the whole time, so you should rethink this theory


The student six's "elements" are:
Silverquil is laughter
sandbar is kindness
smolder is loyalty
yona is honesty
ocellus is generosity
gallus is magic?
the proof is in the final song of the series before the end credits
If you look closely, you can barely see gallus in twilight's verse?


yes the magic  goon but the magic went back so if the magic went back  then grogar  should be a constellation  yes i know i am late  and yes discord is grogar but  i just thought that you needed to know :)


Well a certain discord is grogar and we find that out in the season nine finale so maybe grogar is still in the stars soooooooooooooooo, yeah....


The theory was RIGHT until it was revealed that DISCORD FAKED TO BE GROGAR


So does this mean grogar is like ares' (god of war) counterpart of another world?


I still think grogar is FAKE
Like I Said in last discord ting
But I like this lol


Grogar is beautiful, map is screaming with bloody ears


6:51 and thats why, kids, this theory is canon
becouse grogar didnt escape. its just discord in discuase also telling other what grogar was real long time ago


anybody hear the door creak at 6:58?

no? just me? ok


But dude if ya look at the final few episodes released in the Netherlands or whatever, lol **spoilers tho**, it shows that Discord IS posing as Grogar xD like wth is that story twist


maybe grogar yeah he did a spell for magic creature villains to throw their revenge on equestria


I love all your vids I comment on them my Little pony is a good show it's my favorite I watch it on Netflix and it means a lot to me that you are doing theories about my Little pony because it's so epic anyways I hope you have an amazing day I do not know how to pronounce your name I'm sorry


I think that the original rotary is trapped in Tartarus, but has a lot more security measures in place than just a big door and a three headed dog. That’s why he didn’t break court like tirek did. He may of been the original prisoner of Tartarus


Me: I know who controls the stars and glitter and emotions
Sawtooth: who
Me: me!


Grogar is actually discord if you have watched all the episodes

Coolyboy11 3658 grogar is real if you watched all the episodes...

grogar was still VERY much real. tirek didn’t know discord was pretending to be grogar with his magic but he still said to him and the rest of the villains that he heard of him when he was younger and thought he was just a legend, which means it’s still possible he was real


Tis confirmed, my father is connected to a horse universe by a mere zodiac sign.


you didn't need Dr wolf to help with your" oh why does this spell stay and the other doesn't" ! discord was pretending to be grogar!! which means this is totally fine theory! just that grogar helped nightmare moon and never came out! there done!


Did you know the sun is just a big big star!!??


I'm just going to sit and watch what will happen next and laugh continues on and on but when it happened... I'm just going to say... You are wrong in so many reasons 🤣. Sorry ik it's a theory but. You'll see what happens...

richbuild well done, you didnt spoil it yet

Oml I am so glad I'm not the only one who knows what is really gonna flip the table on this


that wasn't him discord disguised as grogar so... HE WAS NEVER SET FREE!!!


I have 1 of they most insane there're i thick the entity named void termina who must of freed nightmare moon and in my dream I had once teamed up with goegar and I did killed gigamos by me used both the amulet of avalar and the bewitching bell and taking him down


When you realize the zodiac signs also are constellations:

Oh wow

When you realize the zodiac signs also are constellations:

*Oh wow*


This theory makes me laugh cause discord was grogar the whole season 9

L1zziebear The Music Freak And mind I quote Celestia. "While you reunited this three villains, you also PRETENDED to be Grogar?"

Magi Hussie no, discord said, and I (Mostly) quote, ‘The league of villains now have the Real grogars powers.

Magi Hussie no, discord said, and I (Mostly) quote, ‘The league of villains now have the *_Real_* grogars powers.

But gorgar  is still, well, WAS still a real being. He could’ve aided in her escape just fine, and discord could’ve still pretended to be him.

@• L1zziebear • By "real" Grogar as in basically Discord's disguise, then yes.

@Dark Warrior While apparently being a stone statue for a millennia at the same time.

Despite the final just remember grogar might still have been the one who freed nightmare moon


People from the future know that Grogar is DISCORD XD But he was Grogar in the past..... perhaps he died


Wait what’s the final season I’ve only seen 8 seasons how many are there 😭😱


lemme tell it to you grogar never returned he still is trapped discord had faked him in s9 finale the mean three suck discords magic so the knew he was a fake up the the no longer waited and attacked equistria thats when the pillar 6 the mane 5 and student six power up twilight<br>to beat the mean 3

lemme tell it to you grogar never returned he still is trapped discord had faked him in s9 finale the mean three suck discords magic so the knew he was a fake up the the no longer waited and attacked equistria thats when the pillar 6 the mane 5 and student six power up twilight
to beat the mean 3


WHEN MISTER WOLF SHOWED UP DID YOU KNOW THAT GROGAR WAS DISCORD!?


Little does Sawtooth know, that I'm Grogar in disguise (I'm an Aries)


**DRWolf appears**
Premiere chat: *FURRY*

@Sponandi Better fucking yet, what do furries have to do with bronies?

Or this video?

NOTHING.

@Cider Of The Arctic Still:<br>What does TikTok have to do with anything?

@Cider Of The Arctic Still:
What does TikTok have to do with anything?

TIK TOK SUUUUCKS, LEAVE DA FURRIES ALONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


I mean in the class room I saw a globe so it’s probably round?


2:42 grogar:i am the most beautiful person


Thanks for the shout out @thebronynotion (I'm an Aries and I was super happy that you mentioned aries in this theory)


I think that the moon was the Crystal globe


That isn’t Grogar that’s discord in disguise Grogar was never seen again since gen 1

Soo he might be in a place we've never seen, or in Everfree! I believe he was freed tho

Techno Dark technacly  what he is  saying is grogar 石actually fｒｅｅ


Hey big fan of your videos and I just thought of something that I don’t think anyone has thought of before  so I think my question would be a great idea for your next video what do you think about this  question for your next video what  does the cmc stand for in the equestria girls world like we know that in  the pony world the cmc stands for cutie mark crusaders but if most humans have their pony version’s cutie mark on their clothes and humans don’t really earn them like their pony versions do then what would the cmc stand for in the human world if the pony version of sweetie belle apple bloom and scootaloo  kept trying to find ways to earn their cutie marks?


Hold on is gusty the great gusty from gen 1? Gusty from gen 1 was a unicorn too


The captions say “gussy the great”[near the end]


Sadly this is now disproven because that wasn't grogar


But Grogar was actually Discord, so he never escaped!


Grogar never escaped form the stars it was discor


but in season nine it also showed that grogar was discord


this theory is debunked considering the leaked finale of the show. not gonna say anything but...uh it, wasn't grogar ahaha

Jroxs12pone why? There’s no proof of him being dead and originally in the mlp in the 80s HES not dead

Despite the final just remember grogar might still have been the one who freed nightmare moon


Excuse me    Grogar didn't returned because I have seen mlp final and it shows that discord pretended to be Grogar


all of this dosent completely line up cuz discord was pretending to be grogar all along


Grogar escape from the stars and bail nightmare moon out


there is nothing wrong here grogar was discord the whole time maybe grogar was still in the constilation but as justwatchingyoutubenothingelse said discord said grogar was real he said it himself quote ''they got the real Grogar's magic from the bell''


Does any one rememder that discord pretend to be grogar to try to help twilight
PS.love your YouTube videos


Spoiler :
Don't read it if u don't want to know it

Discord is grogar and got the Bell
En then the villains stole "grogars"  power with the Bell they stole from him
And grogar turnen out to be discord they stole the princesses power with the Bell they got more power full they had the power of grogar in the Bell and they took it to in the beginnen (crysalis trek and cozy glow)

Sorry for my bad  english

i'm sorry but even with this the theory still holds, just look at the design for grogar and at the scene where it is said that he was the first ruler of equestria and you'll see the spoiler being outed from the first episode of the season add to this the fact that the spirit of harmony has similar powers as gusty and discord and you'll see why and what happened there actually


yeah good theory but wasn't discord pretending to be grogar


HEADCANNON SILENCED. GROGAR IS DISCORD. I SAVED YOU A SEASON. YOU’RE WELCOME. BYE.


In season 9 grogor was discord pretending to be grogor


6:54 well he isn’t free so your theory can make sense


GROGAR IS DISCORD<br>Bruh did you not see the last episode

GROGAR IS DISCORD
Bruh did you not see the last episode


You are awesome👍. The question you have an opinion of a visit and New Haven? Edit that I think I ever read anything about the title and I can not be able and see how the other two people belong here than the internet? If they are


If he was banished there he was still trapped and still is be discord pretended to be grogar


what you said the whole time was correct


But you made a video saying that Princess Celestia released Nightmare Moon.


when luna was in the moon she turn back when she get out from the moon


Plot twist growger is dead and that’s actually Discord pretending to be growger. 😱 What a crazy theory !!


He is in prisoned in the stars STILL HE Is still in the starts


Excited for a new vid from horse theory senpai! (ﾉ◕ヮ◕)ﾉ*:･ﾟ✧


Gusty killed  Grogar  because  he was Discord Cozy said it  herself


One thing tho if your theory want ruined <br>When did nightmare moon return of it was a different season than school raze how did grogar move?

One thing tho if your theory want ruined
When did nightmare moon return of it was a different season than school raze how did grogar move?


Of course Grorgar is still banished <br>It was  Discord who pretended to be Grorgar, (mlp end )😉

Of course Grorgar is still banished
It was  Discord who pretended to be Grorgar, (mlp end )😉


Me: sees Aries in the background at the end and it disappears
Also me: uhhhhhh dude?
You: what?
Me: he just escaped o-o
You: 0-0
Me: 0-0
Us: runs for our lives

Me: *sees Aries in the background at the end and it disappears*
Also me: uhhhhhh dude?
You: what?
Me: he just escaped o-o
You: 0-0
Me: 0-0
Us: *runs for our lives*


Imma debunk ur theory in the dress of twilight the ram has 5 stars but only 4 aided in nightmare moons escape so it wasn't grogar lol


ı guess growgor was who control the stars because his horns glow as stars but only his horns are glowing so he waited till nighit mare moons anger grows till she wanted to get a big revange when this anger in side nighit mare moon he send her free to distroy ponywill


Oh, yeah

Theory is no longer cannon

bEcAUse DiSCord wAs gROgaAR


lauren faust told that stars helped luna escape but who controlled moon and stars while luna was trapped in the moon

thats right  CELESTIA


You wanna know something funny when you said "when opening a microwave when it beeps" the microwave in my house was beeping


My MLP essential handbook: Grogar, Species unknown<br>Me: GOAT!

My MLP essential handbook: Grogar, Species unknown
Me: GOAT!


I just stare at the microwave and get it on one second


And now we know grogar isnt free. All exept for his freedem could realy be true and sounds logic


Well ..... ok so you all don't know yet that discord is Grogar maybe because the episode is not their yet but what if someone comes in like dr wolf and shows you that episode <br>You will probably think why you had wasted your time in this theory

Well ..... ok so you all don't know yet that discord is Grogar maybe because the episode is not their yet but what if someone comes in like dr wolf and shows you that episode
You will probably think why you had wasted your time in this theory


I thought Grogar Is Discord from ep 24 or 25


Would you imagine a group of villains based on the twelve principal constellations? :0


Mini Luna get out of the stores by herself because she has dramatic but maybe she can get out of her own spell


Come on, we all open the microwave door right when it beeps. Don't lie to me.


It’s kinda coming together. But I’m still confused. MLP STAFFS ALWAYS CHANGE EVERYTHINGGGG


I’m amazed, at least I’m not the only one that’s “to old to watch this”


You forgot that Grogar was discore in saeson 9


Nightmare moon is my only favorite character in mlp period. She is my baby. So this video made me so happy.


Discord was acting as Grogar to troll the villans in the final season.

thats discord for ya


SPOILER ALERT

What I think? I think that DISCORD IS GROGAR

HE WAS PRETENEDING TO BE DISCORD, DOESENT MEAN HE IS DISCORD!


the weird thing was that "grogar"turned into discord and somepony was like "so groar been discord this whole time" so idk if grogar was a real character or just discord in disguise plz rply back to me about discord been grogar or me making a misunderstanding about that fact on discord  :,)


Excuse me I’m not trying to be rude but your a little wrong you might be right that gusty the great could have trapped grogare in the stars and gusty’s spell could have been strong enough to keep grogare in the stars forever because discord was pretending to be grogare which means grogare never left the star and maybe never will bye 👋


its discord instead of grogar look at it the magic he uses


The one who set nightmare moon is twighlit sparkle


Lauren Faust actually answered this theory....

It was Celestia 😉 p.s Sorry for miss spellings

Tanbir H games aren’t cannon so aren’t a reliable source

@Dark it does - in the mlp game it says Celestia is responsible for the stars as well

Pin Rhyme but that doesn’t really make sense?


My sister was about to go to sleep while we were watching this then he said “Aries” and she quickly got up and said “LIA YOUR A CONSTELLATION!?”-


Actually zodiac signs are connected with stars


Um the magic was drained in season 8 nightmare moon,s return happened in season 1 so that’s impossible


Tho I think it’s discord acting like grogar to get informations for the princesses and the real grogar is still the aris sign


OMG 49 MNUTES AGO!
#KindaEarly!
I love your vids bro! I always get ideas of other theories! You have great ideas man, keep it up!


I’m from the future and the m l p show has been done and gro gar was ACTUALLY DISCORD


Now..uh…there’s a small problem.. Grogar is..uh.. DISCORD..It doesn’t destroy the theory, but he’s not alive in the season.


What so discord (aka grograr) balled nightmare moon? I DON'T BELIEVE IT


Ares is the god of war,just thought that was interesting.

Ares and Aries are two different things. It's weird how close they are tho


BRUHHH GROGAR DIDN’T ACTUALLY RETURN IT WAS DISCORD PRETENDING TO BE GROGAR!!! 😳😳😳


That can’t be possible because discord was pretending to be grow guard


Actually it was discord pretending to be grogar


What would happen if cozy glow wasent a villain? Can u predict?


Roses are red
Violets aren’t just blue
Yay I got a like
But why is it blue


Ah grogar never escaped from the stars that was discord making an obstacle course for the mane 6


6:51 THIS CHANGELING CAN TELL THE FRICKING FUTURE


But Spoilers...
|
|
V

Grogar was Discord the whole time.. The last few episodes he was revealed it was him.

@M Saleem <br>Do you want me to explain?


Realizes grogar never escaped and it was just discord


Hmmm...........How did grogar become a star?


What about the fact that Grogar was never in gen 4.

It was discord

According to Doc Harris aka Grogar's voice actor that Grogar is alive and his also part of the history in the MLP:FiM.


If you ever get tired of YouTube and want to be a detective someone would have to put of their right mind to not hire you


No, Discord didn- I mean grogar didn't free nightmare moon.


I think:
Grogard was 1 of the stars  maybe in seson 10 there will be new villins maybe there are only 2 other maybe 1 star is a real evel star gust kidding but it was maybe the truth
⭐        ⭐
       🌜
⭐        ⭐


But discord was pretending to be grogar in season9


I open the microwave 1 second before it beeps

Xxmidnight_werewolfxX Somebody call the military on this dude


wait wasent dicord pretending to be grogard?


in what order are these episodes ment to be watched in


Didn’t nightmare moon going to turn back to princess luna


Wasn’t Grogar actually discord in disguise??


I think Grogar was real (comment from my daughter Marianne, age 6)


the fact that he used the poptropica Poseidon


What is mean is celestia is the one who let night mare moon out


Did you think that nightmarmoon was disperd before grogoer


Uhh..This was a great theory but Crogar was never there!Discord pretended to be Crogar...

Grogar could still be real, but Discord just turned into Grogar for certain reasons. Maybe because of the Legends.


It been two years but wasn’t discord the guy pretending to be him the whole time


ok so my zodiac sign in mlp is grogar. i am very ok with this.


You're wrong because in the season 9 that wasn't grogar it was discord

This was made before that and it doesn't necessarily disprove grogar freeing nightmare moln


SPOILERS

Isn't this theory cancelled since grogar is actually discord

Νατασα 16269


In season 9 there was no grogar it was discord


Maybe because That Grogar Was Far Away But To reach Nightmare Moon And That would Take 1000 Years So yea


Uhmm. Actually. When chrysalis, cozy, and tirek took his bell. It sucked grogars magic. But.. discord disguised as grogar. So.. i think gro is still the stars. ( if he even is. ;)


why didn't i start?it's loading all the time.

It will come out at 11 am (est), stay tuned!!!


think grogar is the wind that protects the bell since he wants the bell more then anyone so he protects it reply for different answer


No unicorn could’ve use that kind of magic they would have to be an à la corn but what is the trustee the great was actually in Elkhorn it might be a little weird but I mean no nobody can cast a spell like that I’m stars world what was powerful are probably then an hour corn but Dusty was probably more powerful and Dusty must’ve been older than stars world and maybe see in which the Alcorns in your video you said that that star‘s World invented the Alcorns but no Dusty had to invite them because wait maybe after she Banished grow grow grow it to the stars but what if she was really in Elkhorn this whole time well I mean she might’ve started out as a unicorn but what if she was really in our corn


“Darn it Newton get out of my videos”
I haven’t watched in a long time what did I miss

“Darn it Newton get out of my videos”
I haven’t watched in a long time *what did I miss*


hmmm but isn't that olden might so it would last for weeks right? and maybe discord did it because he has the power to do everything right so wene his power got sukted away slip away and free him?


WARNING!!!!! Spoilers below!!!!! WARNING!!!

Discord is Grogar and tirek, cozyglow, and chrysalis use the bell to give them selves great amounts of power. Cozy becomes an alicorn tirek just grows in my opinion and chrysalis gets armour and new powers. The bell can be used to take power or give power. They use the bell on discord stripping him of his form of grogar turing him back to himself. He now has to run away on his own feet. They try to give his power to cozy but it doesnt work so they keep it in the bell. They actually take over eqestria by taking out everyone that could stand a threat besides the crystal empire. Then at the very end twilight uses the past, present, and future ponies/creatures that hold the power of friendship connected to the tree to defeat the villains. At the end stripped of their power celestia luna and discord whisper about something then turn them to stone just like discord. The last episode will not be spoiled here tho that is never to be done it would be evil. Lets just say it ends up in the future a little confusing i know but after watching you will understand.

@berthearthoover some people are so dumb that they blame others for something that is their fault. I thought that is i say this now rather than later people like that would know. And it was to help those who would question what i said is true.

Yes they are real and yes i did warn you and if you blame me it is actually your fault not mine i warned you.


Princess celestia stand for celestial and celestial means stars and the sun is a star and she just wanted her sis back BOOM 😎


gusty : I am going to banish you

grogar : nooooooo ! my hooves are gone and I am on two legs ? gusty gusty gusty !

gusty : your a human ha ha !


Sawtooth Waves: Let's create some interesting lore for MLP<br>MLP creators: MWAHAHA IT WAS DISCORD ALL ALONG MWAHAHAHAHAA!

Sawtooth Waves: Let's create some interesting lore for MLP
MLP creators: MWAHAHA IT WAS DISCORD ALL ALONG MWAHAHAHAHAA!


Maybe the stars un equestria are prisons 🤯🤯🤯


Imma de confirm this theory GROGAR IS DISCORD SHAPE SHIFTED


GROGAR IS DISCORD BECAUSE 12 OR MORE MINUTES LATER DISCORD ADMITS IT!


10:25 think stars just other worlds in mlp. i say worlds because there no space in mlp, Luna is the space so wont make sense if there was a true space or Luna is doing nothing these hole years. same thing could have happen to her sister. and ya they cloud have third sister and a family. cant be born without a family as they away say.


"grogar" is acctually the lord of chaos oof but i see your logic- kind of-//

grogar was a historical figure, discord just impersonated him.


Lol they didn't know discord was Grogar and grogar was still up there


In the Grand galloping gala one of the Ponies have a cutie mark of Orion


but if gusty 's magic wore off  what about the  spell in the mountian


Sawtooth waves: last I checked he was flesh and blood<br>Me: last I checked he was discord

Sawtooth waves: last I checked he was flesh and blood
Me: last I checked he was discord


Brony Notion: it could even be on a flat disk on like the Earth 😏😒<br>Me: immediately likes video

Brony Notion: it could even be on a flat disk on like the Earth 😏😒
Me: immediately likes video


But grogar was discord so grogar was still a constalation


What is mean is celestia is the one who let night mare moon out as the sun is a star


I want to see sawtooth turn into a human

Yeah he could do that when she talks a out the human world


Me seeing this a year later: 👀<br>Grogar didn’t really escape from the stars since it was discord the entire time

Me seeing this a year later: 👀
Grogar didn’t really escape from the stars since it was discord the entire time


I think celestia and luna's mom queen galaxia bail out nightmare moon


Nobody:
sawtooth: SO CROGAR WAS HID AS ARIES
Zodiac fans: [facepalms through time and space]

Nobody:
sawtooth: SO CROGAR WAS HID AS ARIES
Zodiac fans: *[facepalms through time and space]*


Where the heck are you suppose to find the seasons after season 6


Grogar is discord so he is still in the stars


umm discord is grogar so that means discard bailed out nightmare moon but he couldn’t because he was banished to stone


You know discord was disguised as crogar right?


Hold up..wasnt discord dressing up as grogar????


brony notion: the earth is not flat

me: well i guess im going to throw what i thought i knew out the window


Grogar was discord the real grogard is gone or somewhere


How did ponies now that stars(Grogar) wil help Nightmer moon?


Wait the thing is nightmare moon have stay in the moon for a thousand years then how & why she have to escape?


Look with the last season of MLP i think you should look at twilights cutie mark im say to me with the last season. Let's just say the middle star of her mark is equestria and the is the other kingdoms in the MLP serious


One I see the microwave at 5 seconds left, I just stare at it with my hand on the handle


The Grogar we saw with the mean 3 is Discord!


Ooooor just like everything else they through Grogar into the garbage can.. cough cough canterlot high...
I don’t remember what it’s actually called please correct me..

Ooooor just like everything else they through Grogar into the garbage can.. *cough cough* canterlot high...
I don’t remember what it’s actually called please correct me..


I thought discord was pretending to be grogar


I have a question how much is a coin worth in my little ponys pinky pie said that 2 coins for three tomatoes is  outrageies


Hi it might be a dress mistake but doesn't aris have 5 star's and there were 4 star's that aidad in night mare moon's escape sorry if I miss spelled some word's


I  was  thinking  it was  Luna's  father

I  was  thinking  it was  Luna's  father


But grogar didn't bring the villans together discord did


lauren Faust eluded to it being celestia on her twitter


True very true but why could we not see grogars constalation in any episode of any season oh and why did grogar free him self frist


AND THAT SPELL THAT DISCORD DID FADED AWAY


Or maybe it’s just a show for little girls and it all happened because the plot said so???


SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!!!!!

Grogar was actually Discord!!
but if that did not happen......

I think that when nightmare moon was banished to the moon, she met  Grogar. I think that they did not get along because in season 9, Chrysalis, cozy glow and tirek did not get along although grogar (Discord) told them to work toghether to take over Equestria.Villians always don't like each other so that is my evidence that nightmare moon and grogar did not get along.When they finally got along, they agreed for nightmare moon to get out of the moon by grogar and if she was sucessful, she would help grogar get freed and take over equestria.Since Nightmare moon was not sucessful, grogar watched as the other villans got free in order to get himself freed and take over equestria.

But this is not true, it was just a theorie.

Sorry if I wrote too much
:)


Well celestia and Luna have a third sister called Ingrid


um.. wasn't Discord acting like Grogar  but where is the real Grogar?


GOGAR IS DISCORD THO HE IS STILL IN THE STARS


Who else is watching these all over again to see if they can find anything that relates to the new g5 movie?…..I feel like it’s just me


Do you know Grogar was a villain from g3 My little pony


I think that grow Ghar is the group of Star,s


4:26 that’s not aries, it’s taurus! (sorry it’s just astronomy buff time lol)

but for some reason that ram is in it instead of a bull...


You do know grogar was just discord in the end


You make these videos but then never end up actually explaining them


Was it already a year ago season nine started? I’m still waiting for them to get translated ;-;

Congratulations, your the <b>first</b> comment!

Congratulations, your the *first* comment!


He was right it wouldnt make sense that hes back...


He still  didn’t Figured out about what happened with sketchy


Did u know the 2 sisters have another sister


maybe grogar didint come up with that idea


oh the lunch belle rang ding what if grogar wasn’t banished to the stars what if he was banished to be the tree of harmony what if twilight didnt kill the tree cause how did the castle come out of the chest of harmony how did the book discord could not have that drained all the magic from a questria that discord got what if that book was the  same thing cosy glow used so do you think grogar was in the tree of harmony? it all makes sence now?


video: Grogar was aries

me: I AM GROGAR!!


Like when you open the microwave just when it beeps

Timing 100


Your basically saying that me, an aries is a villan in the longest way posiible lol


Grogar in seson nine IS Discord pertending.

Edit: Revomed unnessasery text.


Gdogar is still in the night discourt waspretending to be grogar


Have you forgotten that discord pretended to be grogar.?

kanin power check the date of this and check the date of the release of that episode


I’m just gonna say I know what the stars find emojis I’m noticing the answers can’t tell me what they have five corners but it’s not five colors straight it’s like a circle but on the outside it has two corners on the bottom and also two corners on the sides why don’t you just say I know one point the corner on the top


Gorgar is discord so gorgar is still in the stars


EXACTLY THE GROGAR IN MLP S9 WAS DISCORD FOR FLIP SAKES


Sawtooth where did that sign come into place


Can't you remember discord disguised as grogar


I think celestia made a giat bubble when she sleep she forget about the bubble that nightmare moon is in the bubble I really think celestia forget


Grogar isnt free discord is just faking to be him


Wait aren’t twilight’s cutie marks stars


This video was made BEFORE show's finale? LMAO


How to reform grogar Luna  both banished to the sky >~<


Um mm my apologies but ummm the mlp staff said that celestia bailed out her sister ;^;<br>rip :to the theory about  Grogar bailing her out

Um mm my apologies but ummm the mlp staff said that celestia bailed out her sister ;^;
rip :to the theory about  Grogar bailing her out


Sawtooth could you please do a face reveal


Did you get fired from Hasbro studios for reviling all of there secerets


If you want to know about my little pony why not just ask the creator and then tell us in a video


Wait but grogar was just discord in those episodes


But where is Grogar now ( just you know I'm Marie)


Brony nation can you make a video about pony’s age through the <. 1000. >.  Years


discord was pertend ing to be growgar  thats ow hes magic was taken and be for discord was stone he planted seeds that was taking majec from the tree=


I AM SO SHOOK RIGHT NOW !!!!!!!!<br>LIKE SHOOK AS HECC!!!!!!!!

I AM SO SHOOK RIGHT NOW !!!!!!!!
LIKE SHOOK AS HECC!!!!!!!!


You that feeling when you accidentally dislike a video or comment? I did that to this video


later on in the seres we find out grogar is discord


So did twilight sparkle get nightmare moon free


“Who know’s Equestria and the lands around it could be flat discs, unlike the earth,

AHEM, unlike the EARTH.” >:(


Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!! Grogar is Discord as of season 9. Besides, Grogar isn't real. :>


1000 years....
can they even eat???????
how didn't they die?
how do they breath...?
then HOW CAN CELESTIA AND LUNA BE LOOKING SO YOUNG?

ok this made sound weird or dumb...

If can the ponies die? so Luna might be have lock in the moon but she might cant get old like she can't get old but she is old like 1009 something like that old
celestia trapped Luna for 1000 years but

How can Celestia look so young how can she looks like a young pony but other ponies will die form old age they'll have grey hair but she doesn't?


BUT DISCORD DID A SPELL AND WHEN COZY GLOW TIREK AND CHRISALIS FOUND THE BELL THEY USED IT TO DISCORD


So. Do I want to read all the MILLIONS of comments going on about this?


🤔 in the MLP world what is kroger was the squad and ISKCON gave life to the founders Monsters then then I will be correct right


Grogar libero a Nightmare moon de la Luna


What that make sense that's why the Aries are known for being really angry!😲


Bruh,Discord turned into Grogar,so twilight would defeat him,and be confident to be ruler of Equestria,did you even watch da series? -.-


22 seconds in; is roasting flat earth society.


Does that mean my little pony and the real world are the actual real world


When u realise that grograr is just discord


But the real grogare is some where else because what we thought was grogar is discord


brony notion  : tells a little bit of stuff about cassiopeia<br>me: THATS MY NAME

brony notion  : tells a little bit of stuff about cassiopeia
me: THATS MY NAME


By the way celectiea was pink when she was young


Dear Brony Notion,
Grogar is Discord.
           Sorry.
(BTW, is any one else glad Marble Stone Pie and Big Mac didn't end up together? Ya know, they could be related.....)


You sound pretty cool though not to mention. If it is a big thing you should be fighting to make you think of these cases in 9 minutes of your own level or pun and how much of your life and you can get a good game and New Mexico to play the first time you could have fun with your own real world fetch huffy too! It could also claimed a colonial group where Jimmy Smith got his first and was pretty bad about me but they have the other day and I thought the whole time on that. But all it has was on. It even more about me being in one side the entire point is because it's why not even more like people on your relationship or was not. Edit and your title would want a few years old Mexico for me your post was one thing and you could break down to this one to my friends with you in that thread because of these. I'm pretty good with it as much appreciated from this perspective up their perspective! I'm surprised how do people breed you a couple months later in this game that the only person who wants the city does to have been around. And get your own. But the problem isn't in the middle school and the young men have an abortion which we do with that and it will become very nice with you to have them that way around and I can be more comfortable to a hill from here to you than a man or no reason you have said the other hand to be a child? And you can do something wrong about a relationship that he had been doing the other way and the season will have the time you want. But I


a l l  s c e n e s  o f  g r o g a r  i s  j u s t  d i s c o r d  r o l e p l a y i n g  did he really escape or whatever


Grogar ended up being discord under cover

But a real grogar existed, discord admitted it


Stella why do the bars of the sky prison look like cheese


Brony nation: Darn it, Newton! Get out of my video!<br>Me: I wish I could subscribe again! 🤣

Brony nation: Darn it, Newton! Get out of my video!
Me: I wish I could subscribe again! 🤣


This theory is possible now that discord was grogar. He could still be up there.


Grogar is not grogar that discord was pretending to be grogar


Nightmare moon was in theLuna body turn evil


Well discord might be grogar but the real could still be free


dont worry, i do the microwave thingy too, WERE NOT THE ONLY ONES!


U know that some pony have a cutie mark look like a star welp try to think who is the most strong pony


Fun fact I’m Grogar XD jk seriously though I’m Aries Aries is my star sign 😁❤


Someone tell me how I watch this episode 😓


am I the only one who watched the third last episode of season nine? Because in the last season grogar isn’t grogar he is discord.

This was before that and grogar was still confirmed to be real


At the begining of the show twilight's magic was white but at the end it was of the show it was hot pink like really pink so did her magic get stronger did she change or did they make a lasey job of it but my last theareoy is that really the real twilight we saw in season 1.........................


I'm really sorry about this but if you haven't what's the movie ful grogar was actually discord


THE SHAPE OF THE EARTH DOES NOT MATTER PEEPS


Hi brony notion I know you probily won't look at this but I was looking at a video on you tube and found this video of pinkie pie and said that they didn't deafeat groagar because he's discord check it out for your self


Welp Discord turned out to be Grogar ;-;


* when they find out Grogan is discord * Ò-Ó


I open the microwave right when it beeps to....😅


hey notion so everything is over maybe you can talk about what the frick happened between "the ending of the end" and "the last problem" because OMFreakingG WHY IS THAT?!? HOW DID?!? WAT?!?!? just plz explain what happened I'm so confused


It's not an old goat it's Celeste Celestia and Luna's older sister my AU And Maggieponys


i know is gone and the gruds put her down and she`s making nosie like nightmare moon


make a theroy about the other sunset shimmer  as all of us know that thier is 2 of each like 2 appel jacks 2 pinkipes  ect


And you know why Luna has that likes blotch on her cutie mark I'll tell you later


wait does he know that in the end that's actually discord lol


This video: Zodiac Signs <br>Me: I'm listening BTW I'm a Sagittarius

This video: Zodiac Signs
Me: I'm listening BTW I'm a Sagittarius


Notion Dr Wolf 🐺 might have been watching this 😏


What the two sisters mom and dad name was?


What If the planet equestria is on, is flat?


well this vid needs a  re do since in the show its actualy discord and not grogar


I opened a microwave too just as it beeps


But Grogor (idk how to spell it) is discord...


No actually that is Discord after T- wreck


Grogar is discord!❗❗❗❗❗❗❗❗(In disguise).


The same pony is in paraty visits canterlot


(Sawtooth Waves) Darn it nootin get out of my videos<br>(Me) 😂😂😂😒 I feel you trust me people think I’m a man but devin is my dads name :|

(Sawtooth Waves) Darn it nootin get out of my videos
(Me) 😂😂😂😒 I feel you trust me people think I’m a man but devin is my dads name :|


and in the human world when sunset dischord the portel magec be seeking out


Well really grogar never came back it was discord


Aries: I'M GROGAR SO YOU ALL SHALL BOW TO MEEE (jkjk its a joke hehe)


Grogar from season 9 is actually discord


I hate that this theory isn't real! Curse the mlp writers!


You sasage grogard is still in prison discord was acting as grogard😔


Hay i was going to tell you that luna and calestia left poiny vill but whem they left twilites hair was flowing


why discrok have a power of darknes but he the friendship power ?????? or she a spirit


I think prince of stars do it named stary


Nightmare Moon
Evil Twilight Sparkle
Daybreaker
Discord
Starlight Glimmer
Grogar
King Sombra
Cozy Glow
Sunset Shimmer
Storm King
Pony of Shadows
Wallflower
Flim & Flam
Trixie
Me: Villians united destroy Equestria 😈😈😈


Who is more powerful luna or celestia its...

Luna luna controls the moon and the stars the sun is a star who is do you  want to be in charge


Me coming back to brony nation after a long break: DA FUK⁉⁉


did you see the constalashin in the dacrown of the video


They talk about My little pony season 9 but there is no season 9


im aries HAHAHA I FREED NIGHTMARE MOON HEHEHEH jk i didnt


This theory is back and strong because it turns out he ISN'T back<br>YAY

This theory is back and strong because it turns out he ISN'T back
YAY

Also Discord is definitely the most powerful ever


I think gusti the great is sis or mom of luna


Hey so it turns out discord was grogar so yeah


Hey could you please do a clap with On striker brownie Thank you


Sawtooth waves seriously you think it’s  grow gar it’s obviously stars for all bec he has the word star in his name it’s not princess


Did anyone see my little pony life cause I'm scared....


Nah!
Grogar Was Actually Discord
If you watched season 9 episode "Ending Of The End" Part 1


Sawtooth waves .what is earth in pony form what I mean is that is eqestria earth and what do ponys call thet planet?


Twilight forget to put my star sign on her dress mine is Taurus

Honestly, do we ever see the other side of her dress?


Well here guys ur YT content MLP is over RIP, MLP was always be my childhood


Be hood a random man came out of nowhere


Seriously, the " Grogar" in season 9 is actually a Discord in disguise fooling the baddies


キャメロン・スコット (Cami JS)


Guys is mlp the swon where was this line
-What are the stars?
-Giant balls of gas.
-phhhhh.
I remember this lines from somewhere but dont remember when from.So pls tell me


Hi I’m 8 and I love my little pony but I have no heard of season 9


Wait but grogar was discord O-O so confused....


ARE U SAYING ARIES ARE EVIL!<br>Im afanded


Video idea is what I have..........so at the beginning of the show


IM WATCHING THIS EXACTLY ONE YEAR IN THE Future


Um- wasn't Grogar discord in the end.. so uh-


No I just think See just teleport him and to the human world

محمد الفغم١١٥٦٧٧٧١٠


All for all main six I mean when all the time when he watch all the losers Super 8 ball he hurried up voice prisoner friend for kids with chocolate and all the madness finger and close the Goon no to hear then he went out the Stars Escape real Ross


Grogar is discord in the last season lol you got it wroung sry


I think that the pegiside were working on weather when the unicorn army was fighting Grogar.


Were is the next video!<br>Rrrrrrrrrrrrrreeeeee I need more theory’s

Were is the next video!
Rrrrrrrrrrrrrreeeeee I need more theory’s


He says aries Scorpio cancer *me: 👁👄👁 man be talking bout zodiacs


It is.....      twilight sparkle I’m not joking 😑


Umm hello grogar was chaos dude he can transform man


She banished him incinerating Ynow classic kids cartoon stuff


Little do you know…its not really grogar its diiiissscord <b>with the song little do you know tune</b>

Little do you know…its not really grogar its diiiissscord *with the song little do you know tune*


OMG mlp has zodiac signs and WHY  is there no pisces and there is cancer the one called more uncommon zodiac! Ok im getting to angry.

₵ØØ₭łɆ ₵ⱠØɄĐ


Discord was the won how just like burn the hoves of grogar


Ur telling me season 9 came over 1 year ago and its still not in finland


Dr pepper would want the same effect in 0 or a day of life?! And get mocked for you if I want? This much. The first few hours that are still good for it to have the best song on that same game you areI have to change for this. I'm closely sure to be the best. I'm closely related but in my experience. If a guy is no other one thing I did read any. I'm pretty  sure you have no clue how you could think of this but you are not the problem? The question of how you got your point. Also if I don't even remotely


Discord the powerful ini Universe find a save The power of dark and The power of light


Wow the sky 🌌 i don’t think that but the what


Are you going to start posting reguarlly?


Wait but gregarious was... umm discord....


yea its so i like it when i open it the same second it coems on 0<br>and its SO HARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

yea its so i like it when i open it the same second it coems on 0
and its SO HARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Not to worry bbur Grover is really discor


Pls do a Face Reveal at 1 Million Subscribers plz


Aye thanks for the free shoutout! (Where my aires squad at?) ♈


hey those non earth pony non pegasus non unicron pony and non alicron pony you still jump bai to in yours theory video


Uhhh discord Grogar and he was stache for a long time Ok.


was this uploaded before it was revealed to be discord?


Guys did you now grogar is discord beacose discord can do anythin his a kaous


Darn it Newton get out of my videos <br>Me: lol

Darn it Newton get out of my videos
Me: lol


Nope all fake because grogar was……. Discord so he is wrong no hate


Your kinda crazy... not your facts though there amazing


I hate next generation it won't be the same without dashie


Can you please answer? because I'm confused. If you have time to do it


My mind is just trying to process this but Im an Aries weowok


Hey do you have a girlfriend!!!!!!! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂


Dint you remember grogar whas acutualy discorde just doing a joke


THE EARTH IS FLAT CONFIRMED SINCE WE ALL KNOW EQUESTRIA IS ON A PLANET LIKE EARTH!


banishment for 1000 years only  for thing that live .-.


Umm don't u know that discord is grogar 🙄


But did you know the guy with the horns right was discord ha


I open the micro wave right wen it beans to


I found out somthing in your vids it dosent make any sense im thinking that well u will see soon i mean like why what were how?


win are you going to make a video abot the last mlp epsod?


But groyguard is discord did you not seee


Heyyyyyyyyyyyy.....soooooooo. about that q&a...


No it is right because discord pretends to be grogar, remember?


No he was just deguised as the real Grogar. The real Grogar should be still on the stars


No Discord was just deguised as Grogar. He was mentioning the REAL Grogar. I think he is still on the stars.


I wachetd all the seseons but i dont know rember woh is grogar


Admit it, its 2020. Why are you back here? didnt you grow out of this phase? Tsk tsk, I mean im one to talk though-


I have watched some of your past videos, and have seen one where you said that if there was a 7th Element, then for sunset shimmer it would be forgiveness, well for obvious reasons. Now, I am getting the same forgiveness vibes from starlight, as they both were evil and were shown friendship by the mane six, And in other episodes, you can see her show forgiveness and sometimes influences other to do the same (E.G: When the map calls both Starlight Glimmer and sunburst, Starlight says, “I think the friendship problem is with our parents” and says something along the lines of “They’re our parents, we can’t just hate them for life, we need to forgive them, as it would keep us and them sad and has no benefit for any pony”, showing forgiveness, so, my conspiracy is, is that sunset AND starlight both share the 7th element of harmony (Which would be forgiveness) but it would be a friendship <b>bracelet</b> . But, to make it possibly more interesting, they have to be in the same world/dimension for it to actually connect and work. I’m actually in love with this idea and I think bracelets work best in this scenario as the 5 of the girls have necklaces, then a crown, so it would fit to be a bracelet to. Hope you see this 😚❤

I have watched some of your past videos, and have seen one where you said that if there was a 7th Element, then for sunset shimmer it would be forgiveness, well for obvious reasons. Now, I am getting the same forgiveness vibes from starlight, as they both were evil and were shown friendship by the mane six, And in other episodes, you can see her show forgiveness and sometimes influences other to do the same (E.G: When the map calls both Starlight Glimmer and sunburst, Starlight says, “I think the friendship problem is with our parents” and says something along the lines of “They’re our parents, we can’t just hate them for life, we need to forgive them, as it would keep us and them sad and has no benefit for any pony”, showing forgiveness, so, my conspiracy is, is that sunset AND starlight both share the 7th element of harmony (Which would be forgiveness) but it would be a friendship *bracelet* . But, to make it possibly more interesting, they have to be in the same world/dimension for it to actually connect and work. I’m actually in love with this idea and I think bracelets work best in this scenario as the 5 of the girls have necklaces, then a crown, so it would fit to be a bracelet to. Hope you see this 😚❤


Grogar was discord. It was said near the last two episodes of mlp. Discord wanted to set the whole issue with uniting cosy,chrysalis and Tirek to prove that twilight was right for the throne. Before, twilight was freaking out that she couldn’t handle the big request.


I'm sure you're aware of how the finale practically destroyed your theory. But I have another question for you to answer. Does Grogar's "backstory" have any merit? That is, is it just a modified version of an actual story? Or is it just made up. If it isn't made up, then is the story actually true along with Grogar? I don't think you're going to be able to answer any of these questions without some uncertainty, but those are just some thoughts I had after re-watching this video with knowledge of the finale


I'm sorry if I'm commenting on an old video, but I may have something to add. In the Season Seven episode "Flurry Of Emotions", there is evidence of how Gusty the Great looks like, and more detail on her/he/their battle with Grogar.


Remember when Discord taunted Tirek about being a failure in the eyes of his father King Vorak.

DRWolf001 made a video about this, too.
Okay, so with the supposed Grogar being a disguised Discord, this theory still stands.
Either Grogar did aid Nightmare Moon, or Vorak did.
I, however, think that DRWolf001 might be right about King Vorak possibly coming in Generation 5.


While the circumstances of grogar returning were ruined with the finale, the theory of him being a constellation and freeing nightmare moon are still possible. After all (spoiler alert), he'd still be up there. Perhaps the real grogar will come back for real in the next movie.


There’s 1 thing wrong with this theory.... you can see stars on the Ursa’s but NOT on Grogar


So with your "star swirl " theory that he has wing he could of casted a spell to not have wings to hide that hes an alicorn so he could pretend he might have made alicorn or he was ashamed


I know this is a bit of a stretch but I think that Kroger was the Moon the spiritually the Moon and his bells are the stars even though it seems a bit far-fetched we honestly don't know much of his magic besides that he can summon creatures and this is how he got out what I believe is similar to your theory cozy glow came nearly closed and the Stars aligned for him to Escape his Moon prison along Gathering up his magical Bells restoring his magic all together but when cozy glow fails he had to go to hiding and after cozy glow got sent to Tartarus he gathered all the villains- Luna and Discord to his Aid to work together and defeat Equestria little did he know that cozy glow tirek and Crystalis have a plan against him how did that sound I know this seems a bit far-fetched like I said earlier I just find this Theory a little fun it's just food for thought as well


List of a couple things I question

Who made the prophecy

What magic did he use in that time of aiding in her escape

How dose the time line fit in before and


Another theory disproven. Grogar was never freed, and Discord pretended to be him the whole time


Okay so I had this insane theory recently and I need to share it
Okay so my idea (headcanon) is actually a backstory. Okay first: Bewitching bell is a powerfull artefact with ability to steal magic, blend it and bestow to another beings. It was created by Grogar during his dark reign. Grogar had many servant one of them was Bray a donkey who was bullied a lot by Grogar for his incapability and annoying personality!
Okay so here is the theory:
Bray was sick of being bullied so he decided to betray him and to accomplish that he needed to learn how to use the bell against Grogar, but after a failure he unintentionaly turns himself into a monster after absorbing incredible ammount of various types of magic from the bell creating chaos magic in process! In the battle Grogar not knowing bell is depowered confronts Gusty The Great (celestia's and luna's mother:) and is banished for good! Gusty hids the bell and Bray is uncapable of turning himself back to normal, slowly learning the ways of his new powers he meets Celestia and Luna alicorn (to be) princesses not knowing that in the future he would become one of the biggest threats and most powerfull beings in history know as draconequus Discord The lord of chaos! Also isn't it a little suspicious that Discord immediately knew how to use the bell when he got it?

@Magi_H Well everybody is like Grogar created Discord so I'm like okay but lets make it more interesting. It is kinda cliché but it makes a lot od sense atleast for me. Also I never copypaste ;)

What type of unoriginal, nonsensical, copy and paste tomfoolery of a "headcanon" am I looking at here...?


Too bad the final ruined everything.<br>But the real Grogar might still be somewhere out there, and now that his bell has been freed from Gusty's spell, maybe he'll be back for good someday...

Too bad the final ruined everything.
But the real Grogar might still be somewhere out there, and now that his bell has been freed from Gusty's spell, maybe he'll be back for good someday...


I always thought ‘the stars will aid in her escape’ meant Twilight who’s cutie mark is stars, helping Luna escape Nightmare moon through the elements? Idk I might be wrong


Can you explain why you left the changelings? Did you have that little "Thorax" feeling?


Next video:<br>Why was Tirek able to have Discords magic in season 4 but in season 9 "Discords magic is too chaotic for any creature other than Discord to control" -Tirek

Next video:
Why was Tirek able to have Discords magic in season 4 but in season 9 "Discords magic is too chaotic for any creature other than Discord to control" -Tirek


You know what would have been epic

If the REAL  Grogar formed a Zodiac-esque group of villains for him to use as vessels , with him representing Aries

Taurus — The Storm King

Gemini — Gizmonks (G1)

Cancer — Crabnasties (G1)

Leo — Katrina(G1)

Virgo — Cozy Glow

Libra — Pony of Shadows

Scorpio — Ahuizotl

Sagittarius — Tirek

Capricorn — Chrysalis

Aquarius — Squirk (G1)

Pisces — the Dazzlings

You know what would have been epic

If the *REAL*  Grogar formed a Zodiac-esque group of villains for him to use as vessels , with him representing Aries

Taurus — The Storm King

Gemini — Gizmonks (G1)

Cancer — Crabnasties (G1)

Leo — Katrina(G1)

Virgo — Cozy Glow

Libra — Pony of Shadows

Scorpio — Ahuizotl

Sagittarius — Tirek

Capricorn — Chrysalis

Aquarius — Squirk (G1)

Pisces — the Dazzlings


What about the other constellations like Scorpio, taurus, and cancer? Do you think they are real creatures too? Maybe they were banished like him? Or maybe got there in another way.


After watching this, I had decided to have a 'listening marathon' to your remixes, and why did I think of this_? Aria Blaze, one of the Dazzlings/Sirens, why does _she and Starlight Glimmer look so similar?

After watching this, I had decided to have a 'listening marathon' to your remixes, and why did I think of _this_? Aria Blaze, one of the Dazzlings/Sirens, why does _she_ and Starlight Glimmer look _so_ similar?


SPOILER ALERT

Actually the Season 9 finale shows that this theory is not entirely incorrect. Tho it may be because the spell is held in the stars and not in equestria. That could explain why Grogar didn't actually escape, because his containment spell wasn't effected by the spell outage. Actually, Tartarus also wasn't affected, so maybe magical prisons aren't effected by magic outages


If this theory is correct and Grogar is still up there because in the second to last episode of MLP it's revealed that Discord was pretending to be him the entire time


Without the bell grogar was weakened right?So he had to wait


Technically discord was pretending to be Grogar so Grogar didn’t escape from the prison


That makes so much sense, gosh, my chickens could understand that! (not in a bad way, as in you break it down really well so that it's super easy to understand)


The Theory is inaccurate. If Grogar were actually present in the show then your assumption would then make sense... However , its not the case due to Grogar is discord in disguise - and new footage recently was released of twilight sparkle in the future much older and having celestias stature which confuses me and contradicts your other video of alicorns (the truth about flurry heart)


What if stars are just holes in the container so we can breathe??


Okay okay okay I know that I'm late but did you see the final episode where Twilight have flowing hair! What about your theory I mean I know it's to the birds right now but still how did Twilight get that kind of magic that her hair is flowing?


Uh I think she might of unintentionally killed him or the spell was permanent... because of finalally reason


This is the best theory video I've ever seen.


In the diary of the two sisters it shows that ponies can manipulate the stars


So something I noticed look at Lunas and nightmare moons character design manely [Pun intended]  Her cutie mark and what's around it Luna black Nightmare moon purple/bluish. This is what I think when nightmare moons darkness took over it moved out from the area in had been contended in and took over Luna. When Luna was freed from the darkness the darkness fled back to the area around her cutie mark just a theory but you should look into it


I used to watch you like 4 years ago. Still as cool as ever


Hello! I'm an old viewer of yours, The Brony Notion, I was a child enjoying yours videos as a kid XD I stopped watching you for a while. Until now, Even if I thought you were... Dead?... You're still super awesome!


He really needs to make a video about the last episode of mlp


It's been freaking years since I've seen this guy, holy crap


If Luna turned evil do you think the other alicorns could have turned evil


What if... it was a new being

Someone maybe MAYBE be revealed in season 10 er11

Your theory is good for the present but you really forgot the most important part

 of a theory ?

THE FUTER if it wasn’t grogard er.. however you spell it then your gonna have to say it’s just a futuristic character
Now what do we do ? Your theory was really convincing but I don’t really think the producers thought that far into the show
Sure they always do hidden plot thickens and twists that. You never expected but this is just .. I don’t know
Besides they only ment it as an exciting plot thickening show for kids and teens so it wouldn’t be THAT much of thought put into it as much as fun it is making a theory you really need to understand The definition of Theory  more
And sure your hidden clues part of the theory could prove me wrong but ... it could be a coincidence
I mean they might’ve just thought “ hmm now what are the most popular stars  AHAH ! These ones let’s put them up on the shoe “
Or maybe they were just too lazy to think about a new star they just went back to the plot script and thought the same part of your theory about him looking like the star
Coincidences can always happen and you know you have to always keep that in mind when you’re making a theory


Ik it may seem irrelevant to this video, but how fast is Rainbow Dash's speed in EG? A fandom website says that in Legends of Everfree, she gains supersonic speed. Is this true?


I think it was Celestia who freed Luna hoping she would be good and bring her back. She would be able to do this because the sun is actually a star.

And Grogar never came back, it was just Discord.

Also it would be really exiting for all the ponies, and probably the best summer sun celebration ever if Luna did come back as Luna (Instead of Nightmare Moon). But she didn't.


Too bad that the s9 grogar was discord. Albeit the stars could still be grogar.


<b>spoiler!</b> wellllll discord was confirmed to be covered as Grogar so maybe grogar wasn’t even ‘alive ‘ by then

*spoiler!* wellllll discord was confirmed to be covered as Grogar so maybe grogar wasn’t even ‘alive ‘ by then


SPOILER FOR SEASON 9 FINALE BROS

Now that it was revealed that Discord had transformed into Grogar to have the villain 3 work together, Grogar could still technically be banished in the stars,,,,,,,


In your video "I'm a Changeling" it got thinking if a reformed changeling has a baby would the baby be the old changeling or would the baby have the reformed gens? Sorry that it's off topic but ya.


Does someone know why twilight from the human world has wings when she sings but when she went to the pony world shes a unicorn


Wait until episode that you find out something you'll never believe that will ruin this theory


Basically the Sun is a star, that means Celestia controls the stars? If not Luna controls them meaning that Luna controls the sun because the SUN is a STAR


You do realize that Discord pretended to be Grogar right?


Grogar wasn't even real it was just discord who eventually screwed up


HEY I just noticed that in one video   u said maybe equestria is earth but I think not because in heart warmthing eve it said they had found a land. So they lived a different land. That gets me to think that what was the land before they found equestria?


But if twilight was an artificial allicorn the why did twilight make her hair flowing in season 9?


Grogar was Discord.<br>So, do you have any explanation for this?

Grogar was Discord.
So, do you have any explanation for this?

The only thing it disproves is that the actual Grogar was freed when the magic was largely drained from Equestria.


Thank it was Groger that added in mightmare moon,s exscape


Hey Brony I have a BIG question in Twlight’s kingdom and school raze the sun and moon rise even though no one‘s doing it in school raze who brings down the sun because on the first day everypony loses there magic and in Twlight’s kingdom who sets the sun because the princesses gave there magic to Twlight so.HOW.DOES.WORK!!!!!!


Soooo.. Did Discord bail out Nightmare Moon?


Scrap all the theories BronyNation! So much to discover now that my little pony has ended! <br>(ah my child hood!)

Scrap all the theories BronyNation! So much to discover now that my little pony has ended!
(ah my child hood!)


SPOILERS!

this theory Is good but wasn't it reaveld that grogar is just Discord in the finaly?  Would that mean that grogar is still banished?

For those who don't what i'm talking about https://youtu.be/4y97daP70e8


I’m so sorry about mlp ending I now wonder what you will talk about . I hope you have theories of what could happen next . If you do I think the hole of mlp is done all over again but with different characters


well know we know that grogar IS still a constellation and that grogar on the show was just discord


Gusty uses magic from the pony of shadows


New vid idea: who will rise and set the sun when twilight becomes the princess

The Bread Cat who’s going to take care of the ponies in their dreams


Spoiler read at your own risk

Grogar was discord so real grogar is still in the stars


I dont think so discord is actually prednting  to be grogar in the fanili and discord wasn't reformed in season one


Hello The Brony Notion!<br>can you see the video titled "Give me your wings" at 04.01 minutes look at the yellow pony, he has wings and horns, is he the next Alicorn? please look

Hello The Brony Notion!
can you see the video titled "Give me your wings" at 04.01 minutes look at the yellow pony, he has wings and horns, is he the next Alicorn? please look


Hire an editor to be faster. There’s so much the show leaves unanswered


From Nightmare moon to grogar to zodiac signs cozy glow to grogar to nightmare moon to grogar


Can you do theory about princess Amore, please❤


alrighty im watching in 2019 and just wanted too say...I MADE A PRINCESS OF THE STAR'S! her name was estella! estella mean's star soo...OH AND YES I GOOGLED A NAME MEANING STAR! estella came up from the google! she's younger than the sister's of the sun and moon but just because of estella being my OC of the princess of the star's doesnt mean she ACTUALLY is a real character!

i seriously didnt need too mention the 2019 part...my bad! lol also dont think im bragging i just wanted too say since this is mostly about star's


SPOILER ALERT for the finale
.
.
.
No, but it would've been better if you were right.


Hey the brony notion i have question for you. “Where Ursa Major comes from”


Mlp producers: oh there getting answers and making logic we can’t have that! Let’s ruin it by coming up with a contrived plot twist with <b>picks a name out of a hat</b> discord!

Mlp producers: oh there getting answers and making logic we can’t have that! Let’s ruin it by coming up with a contrived plot twist with *picks a name out of a hat* discord!


U do realize that Discord pretended to be Grogar right?


Nope, Discord was Grogar. The theory of why Grogar was back is fake


Are you...

Are you dead? Because I want a theory on the ENTIRE SEIRIES NINE!!!!!!
How in equestria have you not covered the last problem yet?


Wait what season and episode was grogar In I never noticed that he was even a thing😢🦄🍁


Well sadly, mlp show that this theory is not true... it's a good theory tho


Wait it was discord who was on season 9 and not grogar 🤣


But brony, before the stars aid lunas escape, they arent in the form of aries


you do not know how much im questioning how much im questioning why in here but hey, I miss the brony notion


I think yes grogar was a star group but not aries mlp aries has a star in the leg so i think he was a diffrent star group


I want to ask is cozy glow the villian is a alicorn?


I saw the final sooooo I know what happens


I saw that  when was trap she made a Sonic rainbom then that was probably how the rainbow came to be a legend


Will you be posting another video after the last episode?


Doctor wolf helped you a lot and interesting video


When mlp and mlp characters grow older and so do you!😭😭❤


5:44
Him: Darnit Newton get out of my videos 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I AM DEAD


Me - watches this video
The brony notion - mentions Aries
Also me - oh das me boi uwu


hey brony notion theres a problem genaration 5 is up and the old friendship is magic is gone im so sorry i love your vids and i dont want you to end so please do more teory vids for genaration 5


Is Brony Notion MugGod or is he approved to translate Notion's videos (into Russian) because I've been seeing the exact same videos (Same theory, same pony changeling character thing) but the voice-over is simply translated into Russian

I'm just curious because it seems like this channel is straight up ripping off the videos

Unsure if it's all the videos because I've only watched the truth about flurry heart


mlp ended but teories are still up so I think mlp have so much teories that are not discovert


For everyone who’s watched S9...<br>XDDDDDD

For everyone who’s watched S9...
XDDDDDD


Are you going to make a reaction video about The last problem?


Ok I’m 11 but ur bringing me back to MLP XD


my theory--- gorger IS discord (we know that) so therefore grogar simply never existed or is still banished


But Grogar was Discord if you see another video from mlp


Well after the finally......this is awkward


Who immediately watched school daze mlp after this XD


I have a app that app tells where are the stars apps name is Night Sky that app work on iphones if you have a iphone you are lucky.


What are gonna post when the series is over?


I got something important to tell you there is website like YouTube but for mlp fans where you can upload any mlp videos call pony.tube

I'm telling you this because due to the new rules and I don't want you to be gone

I highly recommend to join it before it is too late

From one of your fans GaijinPiro 🎮✏


This theory doesn’t work any more because discord is “Grogar” here and the real grogar is long dead


Are you going to end your channel because mlp is ending??


Is it the last theories of my little pony


Oof I missed soo much now I must watch e..v...e...reeeee MLP Episode


Nooooo grogar is discord ksksksk(latching)


Spoiler alert Discord was masquerading as Grogar the whole time.


wut “grogar” wasnt actually grogar it was discord


Not realated

Where is human sunset simmer the one we know is pony simmer


This is remind me of grian and mumbo jumbo.....


Sorry to say but your theory is wrong grogar is discord


I can answer all there questions in this video cause mlp already showed u what happened and that’s not Grogar was actually Discord so he escaped


Wach ep. 4 ho is the lost cristol princess?


brony notion....

PLEASE GIVE ME A HEART!!!!!!!!!!!


Discord=Grogar!When The Mean Three betrayed him and drained his power,he was Discord!


'Aries'<br>Ok nice too know im some pony mythological yeah yeah thingy

'Aries'
Ok nice too know im some pony mythological yeah yeah thingy


Yeah. Wassup. What will happen to the channel now?


WHAT DO YOU MEAN DARN IT NEWTON I LIVE IN NEWTON ooooohhh you mean the guy newton sorry I still LOVE  your vids

Mihaela Alblinger I need to see some 1 kill


This theory has just one thing that doesn't fit (spoiler warning):

Grogar is actually Discord😂

ℕ𝕚𝕘𝕙𝕥𝕚𝕟𝕘𝕒𝕝𝕖🪐