Could there be a tree of disharmony? Made by a good creature? Except maybe the creature six


Here’s my theory grogar made discord and then the pillars defeated discord and then discord came back and then got turned to stone by the sisters.


I love these theories,

Yin and Yang
Fire and Ice
Night and Day
Harmony and Chaos

Heck yea!


I have a theory that he is made out of chaos off equestria. Over the years the chaos built up and he was created.  What do you think. 🧐🧐


When I read the title I thought u were talking about the social media platform but when I saw the YouTube I was like
Wait I thought sastook only made pony related things
Then I saw the thumbnail lol


What if draconaqui didn't have chaos magic at all and if discords parents were both  draconaqui but discord got kidnapped by Grogar because  a draconaquist  is the only creature that can use the full potential of  such power and control it well . Grogar took Discord when he was young so he could teach him how to be a Big Bad Villain . After a thousand moons of training Discord created a bell for Grogar giving the bell half of his chaos magic .


I think that discord is a hybrid of a dragon and a goat and got so chaotic that he cannot live without chaos


can you make a video on how the sirens came to be?


If you’re asking what is he it’s revealed later that he’s a draconaquis (not sure if I spelled that right)


I think discord is a hybrid of a dragon and a goat and then became so chaotic that he cannot live without chaos. if you think this is true give a like, if you think this wrong give a dislike or just comment.


Some people say that Equestria is actually FUTURE Earth. (Yea...Ik, wut.) They think that ponies killed humans and took over the world!! Then, Discord was actually a human. But, to survive (or something), he had to sew on different animal parts onto his body. That's why he has: Dragon wings, Antler, etc.


I have a theory maybe he grogar made him but then the tree of harmony was made and he got banish and the sisters got the elements of harmony because discord had made absolute chaos And then the sisters banished him and then that’s how he is so old I know it’s not a good theory ;-;


what if star swirl made discord while he was in limbo trying to sent a message that he was still alive? idk i still haven't watched the last season


Lmao- the funfact is that discord pretended to be Grogar wAit- how does he knows all of those did he some how got a magic if you change to a person you are like them and know all the history, I am confused😃


What if in the future the spirit of Harmony and Discord fought


Discord could just be born by  parent's oof or related to someone we have seen but don't know much about . ...


𝘊𝘢𝘱𝘵𝘢𝘪𝘯 𝘖𝘳𝘦𝘰


I have a suggestion if grogar created discord why dosnt he have a stained glass window 🤔


DISCORD is actually Celestia and Luna’s pet he was with them when They Were coming to equestria from their old home


Maybe discord was trapped in a dimension and only got released after the tree of harmony and the mane 6


But here is the problem with this theory discord was around before star swirl was invented that timeline is correct but discord was alive before star swirl just he was not in power


(Adding to the theory) Yeah cause Discord is Grogar and though there was a real grogar thst will leave a very long GAP in the time line

𝙋𝙖𝙩𝙩𝙮 𝙏𝙝𝙚 𝙒𝙚𝙞𝙧𝙙𝙤 ★ !!


Maybe discord was waiting for his power to grow


Sorry to uh pour cold water on your theory but in one of the comics that show a young terik it shows discord so that means that discord was around long before the tree and probably the same age terik and in one episode discord taunts terik talking about his father


Wait Sawtooth Waves wouldn't in this theory discord will still be created by Starswirl?


I say this is correct and I agree with you on this theory


Evil cannot be in the world with out good, and vis-ver-sa. With out harmony then chaos would have never existed, so there for it is a sound theory.


don't know how, i've a theory before i wathched this video that i think when the two royal sisters were created, as the image of control, i think discord was created at the same time , as image of chaos. and i think it's has a connection between them??


maybe he is like mewtwo he could not open or even move for a while until a lot of years


Discord was turned to stone for a long time


Discord and terec are siblings after all so maybe that can help


I have a Ida

DISCORD could have Ben in a sivlisashin at the time then it got act and all he's
Kind where gone and and he's the only one left there could be another one
But the seasons are done and he's old so it must have happened a long
Time ago


I think star swirl did make discord but here is the Catch discord was an accident yes he did try and fuse the different creatures but star swirl was prepared once he planted the tree it made discord a prison once the tree was done growing the prison would disappear and the yin yang still works as the sprit kept in discord but the spirt saw he could be reformed and let him go and that is my idea on discord

I have no evidence for this but I like it


But that's just a theory. A BRONY THEORY!


now what if- and hear me out... Starswirl DID make discord.. but Discord wasn't big. He had to grow... and it just took him longer to do so..


you do know that discord has his own home and dimension that is were he is all the time pinkie pie also mansioned it when she was looking for something


Maybe discord was put on stasis because grogar was afraid that discord would betray him and kill him and takeover kinda like doctor light and mega man x because doctor light was afraid that x might turn on humanity.


Discord was defeated  by the sisters and turned into stone


In twilights kingdom pt.1 when terek meets discord then tirek was like my oldest friend


when ever he said discord i always think of the app


He said the tree created the guy he's talking about why do I think it took all of the like gems of harmony and then I put them all together because the guy in the story is nice but also chaos in the good side and the bad side and the good side has all the stuff andall of the matching up there's animals that are good animals that are bad and they all made a good person and somebody that needs chaos in their life

♡ᑭIIᑎKᗷᐯᑎᑎY♡


did starswill created discord and when he was banished did Celestia used his lab and mistakely created discord


I think grogar created dIsCoRd because didn’t Cliestya turn discord to stone?


What If star swirl Made discord but discord was Just small nothing and He need incubation time to grow. 🤔


I think you’re ram dude can’t remember his name right now theory is right because discord might’ve been trying to revive that ram dude.


If’s discord was good it’s done inside and out

Cool


You're right but I do have one thing to say the  To ying Yang situations come up And work in harmony


I think that riscord generate while star swirl is trap in limbo when he is completely build that when is he's first appearance


Can you please make a video who queen chrysalis used to be ...


Like T-Rex because T-Rex had to take some time to regain power before he started his Conquest


But discord is a species called a draconequis

{ Ｃｉｒｃｌｅ  ｇｕａｒｄ }


So... The three of harmony have a bad part too?


Discord may be in another dimension then during the gaps.


Umm I have a idea of discord
Instead of chaos he is also a spirit of disharmony that means there is a ELEMENTS OF HARMONY then there is ELEMENTS OF DISHARMONY?
And Discord might be the important element in DISHARMONY like Twilight she is magic and Discord's element is chaos.


um dude discord is more powerful than starswirl the bearded so no way he created discord


all weishenv's here when they heard yangyang: 👁👄👁


Witch discord-the website or the “mistake”


I think the tree of harmany created discord.


In Fluttershys part of the theme song (new one) Discord is in the background


Idk it’s not like discord got banished to the moon like nightmare moon and was there  about a thousand years


When the beard Guy created the school just called could have just been a baby. now he has beard like


I think discord was made by celestia herself


Discord is causing chaos among the fans now


Well I know one thing about Discord he has a child with Fluttershy


There is an episode where discord starts fading because he is a creature built on chaos... mystery solved?

I just realized right after I commented the part he said this came


Sawtooth Grogar is a... a creature not a person!


You can ask all your questions to my little pony on twitter 😐😐😐


No but I know I’m a year late but Terri was has been contained but he knew about discord as if they he heard of him and he had no way of knowing that and he must have gotten word he was reformed


Actually tirek didn't want to give up his magic how can you say that? Because he is annoyed inhis ear by pinkie pie isn't it?


Watch twilights kingdom pt.1  time stamp 13:50


Discord can be very old he waint a threat tell the tree of harmony was full groen and is the opposite of the tree of harmony:)


And When The tree was destroyed discord Became nice


DISCORDS REAL NAME IS CYLDE!

If anyone knows this reference I give u a sub


Who’s here after we found out growgar is discord


I think this  discord  is  grogar ,s  son 😊

I think this  discord  is  grogar ,s  son 😊


sorry to debunk your theory but discord is not a monster made out of animals like the bugbear but a spirt of chaos, why? well because in the episode "discordent harmony" when discord act normal he starts to fade away


yall its a rv-show what do u expect hes  just alive for no reason


YOU CANT SOLVE DISCORD

now replace discord with chaos
Boom 🤯


Discord is chaos somebody powerfull would have to create him maybe someone we don't know yet?


Ho-ly FRICK I just found out more about celestia and luna they are almost like ying and yang because without darkness there would be no light just like how if we had no sun then we would have no shadows AND THAT'S LITTARLY THE SAME THING but idk if this is a good theory ;-;


Frickin meme too funny throwing off the desk


But if discord is a living being and he dies who is his mom


If "The Creatures WIKI" says all real facts of draconiquuses like Discord,
How the draconiquuses was created in cosmos in astrologic?
Uhh, why i am finding logic in the chaos creators?


Maybe he just exist at the beginning of time and was never created


Maybe discord was young? That's not why he was there maybe? Just guessing


Please pin this comment if you actually read the comments!


1. Well
If it’s like the Yin Yang then if he lets a little Harmony (Yang)
Does that mean the harmony is also the friendship
He learned friendship SO
He knows where chaos goes and when it’s not needed and that’s starting to sound like Yang is now bigger then Yin
Even though they’re quite even
And we know how that works if he doesn’t go to chaotic he starts to fade away but he’s still here
And yet he’s not using much chaotic-ness and yet he still not disappeared already if it’s the case
He wouldn’t be here.
(Here’s if you wnat like Another explanation about the different types of creatures)

2. Here’s the thing if he was different types of animals but you said no but if you said yes it still wouldn’t be true

Even if his magic was stolen by force and not given like the other creatures it’s still his magic he would still go into the different types of animals he is because he’s magic is gone like the other creatures meaning isn’t a creation like the other ones


at 7:30 im the video i think discoed was doing chaos in different dimensions


I thought u meant the message thing discord u know like the discord that u can call people discord


if I cant have this theory.....NOBODY WILL.....bruh


This is in the thumbnail is a reference to the original Film Theory


Габріель Укр


discord was turned into stone twilight was born


How did twilight teleported  in equestria world ?


This theory is perfect >:D meaby is truth:0


Hello I think discord had a mom and dad like everyone


Guys there is a awesome song about discord on Spotify by cg5


Horse world because if Discord which is just being created then he was weak and Gathering Power to conquer questria


WAIT this might not work but wasn't discord in the garden that the school fillies went to or was that after the mane six banished him if not that couls be where he was that WHOLE time. This might not work cuz i don't quite remember


Ying and yang..... I'm sure it's not prnouced like that


Discord was NOT a animal  he was a stone

Discord was NOT a animal  he was a stone


What if discord was the ruler of aqestrea befor grogar what if discord created grogar

i don't think that technically would be possible


I don't see the Lord of choes being created by a anything


Uh he would be in the world of caos while he grows


Watch the second to last episode in sesune 9<br>And fokes the 2 sisters and make a video.

Watch the second to last episode in sesune 9
And fokes the 2 sisters and make a video.


What is discord was not a mistake what if he was born in the ever free forest as a normal animal party ever free forest twisted him


👁     👁
💧👄 💧
💧       💧 I’m soo sad mlp fim is ended but excited for g5


What is Discord i mean haf bat haf pony haf snake i mean what is all of that called bat snake pony


I am 10 years old and obossed with my little pony


Maby discord was a kid and it takes time to him to gro upp kuz he is discord maby😕🧐


Brony Notion I have waich this and the my little pony has already ended I know but I just had something that you may like to know about well I was watching the last episodes of my little pony and Fluttyshy came to see Twilight and the others and she came through a pordel and she said discord is sinceing at a cord invichen or he would be joining us so does that maybe mean they got married and she moved in with discord I don't know what do you think about this furry I have do you maybe think they maybe got married and Fluttyshy moved in with discord in the chaos land


Aftrer l saw this video and l though of the sisters and the sun and the moon they balince and complement each other without the moon and sun equestrian won’t exist it would be darkness and the if you watched the episode starlight terns good that last realm nothing was there there was no pony so without the sisters where it won’t exist . The older sister rises the sun the younger sister rose the moon.


What is discord was created out of chaos because the world cannot hold any more chaos just a theory


HAY HAY HAY LOOK WHO MIGHT HAVE GRADUATED


The mis-pronunciation of Yang physically hurts me TvT

@Sawtooth Waves bsjwj Oh hi there! Yeah you're good I was being lighthearted lol. I've been binging all your videos (the older ones for nostalgia and the newer ones cause they're just good) and I gotta say, keep up the great work! You're doing amazing dude.

chinese is hard but im closer than a lot of westerners!


Do you think you can think and talk about this theory of mine


... you do know discord is grogara... right...


Eugene I'm not gonna tell you my last name


diskord cod haveben ploting taking away sich by stich


Orrr.......it’s a kids series and they like to make funny n weird characters 😂😂


Here's something to think about: according to the Heart's and Hooves day episode, they mentioned about a dragon, kingdom falling, and chaos reigning. Is it possible that Discord would be introduced in that timeline? If that's the case, then it would be possible he may have reigned during the time the royal family was unable to perform the royal duty. He may have originally gave them the love poison, so he may have planned to rule over Equestria. Discord is known to be a trickster, similar to Loki, and knew that the poison would cause them to be unable to stop him. If it is a possibility, then it may have occurred during the time Starswirl and co. would've dissapeared in Limbo and when he was turned to stone.

Woahhhhhhh. I NEVER thought about that!! Now I'm going to send a screenshot to Sawtooth Waves.


I have my own theory about Starswirl creating Discord, and I think it actually explains away the plot-holes!

     Starswirl and the other Pillars, knowing the time has come to face the Pony of Shadows, create and plant the seed that would grow into the Tree of Harmony. But Starswirl has another thing he needs to do: create a being of powerful magic to guide Celestia and Luna in his absence. He's been working on it for years, hoping that the Pony of Shadows would be defeated by other means and he wouldn't have to use it, but he knows that there's no other way. He does the spell.
     But something goes wrong. The being that he creates is not what he wanted. Instead of being a guiding force for the princesses, this creature is the embodiment of pure chaos; the dark balancing force to the seed of light he and his fellow heroes had created. Before Starswirl can destroy it, the creature escapes.
     Years later, the Tree is grown, and so is the creature. He had hid in a cave for all that time, gaining strength and power. He knows nothing of the outside world except that it looks boring. He wants to have fun turning it upside down. He wants to cause chaos and mischief. He knows little of himself, either, having had nobody to interact with and learn about himself. All he knows of himself is that he is Discord, the Spirit of Chaos and Disharmony. With a mischievous, gleeful laugh, he goes off to reveal himself and play with the minds of the creatures he's seen while in hiding.


StarSwirl still might have made Discord... Hear me out, StarSwirl might have created Discord before he went to Limbo and during that time period, Discord was growing up but because there was no one there to lead him down the right path, he chose the easiest route to understand, chaos. After all he is the Spirit of Chaos, so that might have meant that he was blinded by the chaotic side of his powers. Maybe he was currupted by some kind of force which made him feel he only had one choice...


I’m with you sawtooth, I think after the pillars left and the tree of Harmony started growing discord started growing and when it was full grown and so was discord, so its sent discord out to bring balance it need the sisters to tern discord to stone to start the future of equestria then twilight and her friends to reform him which the tree plan it so it can protect equestria. Like if you agree


Maybe Discord is just another level of Alicorn, Even though he represents Chaos, he also represents unification of each kind. Did Discord become more powerful after every kind having a good relationship.


I would also like to add that even though Discord is made up of many animal parts, that's just it. They're parts*. Unlike how the other creatures spread into their separate creatures, discord only has one head; one consciousness. The other creatures like the goat-snake-tiger had *many consciousnesses. Three brains makes for three differing opinions as we see in their episode. Discord did not split into separate creatures because he's technically only one creature.  That's my explanation anyways.

I would also like to add that even though Discord is made up of many animal parts, that's just it. They're *parts*. Unlike how the other creatures spread into their separate creatures, discord only has one head; one consciousness. The other creatures like the goat-snake-tiger had *many* consciousnesses. Three brains makes for three differing opinions as we see in their episode. Discord did not split into separate creatures because he's technically only *one* creature.  That's my explanation anyways.


I know I'm a year late, but at the time when twilight and her friends were stuck in Tarterus, the magic that the creatures have were already gone. The magic that twilight borrowed was a different magic in itself. It was the magic that made them the creatures they are, not the abilities they have. The three villans only took his chaos magic. I know this has nothing to do with the theory, but I just wanted to point it out.


Wait.... According to a concept by a commentator of Even HoriXZ0n of this video, they said "proto-Discords" which.... Makes me think that maybe, Discords species had all been combined into a single entity maybe, in some way. In order to oppose the Tree of Harmony.


I like to believe that starswirls parents (or idk maybe some sorcerer from a long time ago) created discord so before we saw discord’s first appearance he was the actual grogar.


My theory is that when the frienship fire was ignited, the windigos, who where used to chaos, made the everfree forest, and to counter that the pillars planted the tree. The spirit of harmony (who was the tree) thought that the circle of countering is going to extend infinitely so to stop that she too the chaos from the everfree forest and put it together to make discord who she knew would be reformed and the cycle would end


Maybe whoever created Discord Thought he was evil and he kind of was So they kept him somewhere or turn them into stone But then he found a way to escape


I have a therory when grogar gets reaveled as discord he tell the others some of his magic is in the bell if it was a spell that trapped it maybe some of the magic got free during starswirl spell to limbo witch in turn would make him show up as he got most of his magic back so yeah if you get it thanks for reading


My idea is that Discord was a student of Starswirl. He wanted to turn into an alicorn to be with Celestia snd Luna. However, the potion failed, and he was turn into a being of disharmony. Celestia and Luna wanted to free him, but couldn’t. Celestia relized that the main 6 freed Luna, they could free Discord. However it didnt work, because Twilight knew about Nightmare Moon-Luna, but not Discord’s past self.


I've got a question, didn't Tirek already knew about the existence of discord? that means discord existed before Tirek was sent to tartarous


I think star swirl made discord but when he released he could never actually look after discord he decided to lock him up because they didn’t know how to split him apart again so as discord got older they forgot about him so soon he got to big for the cage and all ready had the power to bust out and did it when star swirl went missing


a year after this video was posted and i now understand why routine and spontaneity need each other


I have a theory discord could have been grogar's sidekick but he went into hiding because grogar was defeated or until the pillars were gone so that he could destroy equestria easily


I have Theory that will help strengthen dr. Wolf. what is the seeds Discord planted 1000 years to grow instead of growing separately it grew with the tree but after planting the seeds the princesses turned into stone leaving him and still in for a thousand years while the seeds grew with the tree. do you think that's possible?


It would also explain why he liked Fluttershy so much. He was chaotic and she was calming. Total opposites and his anchor from Chaotic Evil to Chaotic Good.


ok but the magic being taken by force and willingly giving magic thing does make sense because in that one changing episode where chrysalis was stealing the love from thorax im pretty sure he would have died or something but starlight told him to share it aka give it away willingly and it transformed him, and love and magic are the same bc of cadence since shes the princess of the magic of love


What if the tree of harmony growing made a hole in the pony’s dimension leading to discord’s and he found it and decided to also rule equestria since he’s been alone. And maybe Grogar did make him and didn’t like him so he put him in his own dimension that’s why there is such a huge gap between them same about the pillars creating him. Idk just an idea


Star swirl made discord how i know because he used him to test the strength of the seed that he planted and to make sure that Celestia and Luna were the right rulers and that they would do what they can to protect equestria he did this because when the pillars where created they where the ones who fought evil or as they call it the darkness but what did the princesses do …… nothing.


So when Discord started to fade, the spirit of harmony in the form of flutterboi was like "DENIED"


I think that except nightmare moon, sombre, and cozy glow all of the villains in MLP were some of the creatures grogar created but they didn’t know that they were created by grogar


I liked this theory but if it was true it wouldn't be possible the appereance of Discord in the Tirek backstory, which also is referred to in the shows finale with Discord mentioning king Vorak


starswirl: oops, made a god of destruction. whelp, time to hop to limbo and let my two proteges fix my problems.


I dunno. I always kind of assumed he was born out of the chaos that created the universe in the first place.

I dunno. I always kind of assumed he was born out of the chaos that _created_ the universe in the _first_ place.


here's something you can maybe figure out: how did discords... uhm world? realm? well... the place where his home is appear? did he make it? if not, who did?


Good points.
We all need a little chaos in our lives now and again.

Good points.
We all need a little *chaos* in our lives now and again.


Discord can be made by Stars World the time he was gone he was somewhere hiding and gaining power.


What if discord was from a group of draquonaqui? (How do you spell that, srly) he could have been banished for some reason, or left. The draquonaqui (or however u spell it)could have been keeping the balance between chaos and harmony until discord, the LORD of chaos left, they had to pull their kingdom together after THE LITTERAL EMBODIMENT OF THE ONE THING THEY HAD TO CONTROL LEFT. Soon they may return as their world’s harmony is through the roof and their is no balance between chaos and harmony whatsoever.


What about the mlp comic where Cosmos was introduced as his ex girlfriend?  Both of them are the same species but their chaos levels are different. Cosmos likes to use chaos for killing and destruction while Discord uses chaos for fun which is also why he broke up with her. Discord really didnt want to use chaos on others in the first place and he even wiped everyone's memories of Cosmos because its for the best. Instead he chose to take the blame for Cosmos' actions.


If you see the last episodes of season 9, Grogar is actually Discord!


my theory is that : MLP is a "lovely" kids show, not a big mystery.  It's made for KIDS.


I like where this is going in other words i like the theory that Discord is connected


Wait, discord is a mixture of everything, so logically he is also a part of a pony 😳


i thought he was already a villain, and was turned into a hybrid thingy still was evil and got taken over with friend ship and yeah.... :/


thank you so so much for keep uploading more mlp videos


I think I know how discard was made... maybe it was just when he was playing when he was a kid something came and mixed them together soo thta what I think


being honest, just throwing stuff out here, maybe there r so many plot holes and everything can't fit in place and make sense, cause the creators weren't expecting people with logic and intelligence to try and put things together and pick them apart XD


the monsters that was all trapped in a cage must be together and make a Discord


He was a stone statue before meaning he must have existed before the season 2 premiere what did he do before to turn him to stone

To gay or not to gay that is the question


But what if  star swirl try to make a clone of himself with his knowledge  but made it in where the everfree forest was and then the evil magic and the monsters magic went inside him


I still think the starswirl created discord theory is an option
If starswirl made DISCORD and realized he was evil he, starswirl would probally prison him in a magical prison like the stone prison(he would do this Cuz he didnt know the power of friendship at the time). Just like the stone prison h
The magic wdould fade and he broke free. With starswirl gone discord made the world chaotic until the tree of harmony grew up and the princesses used the elements of harmony to prison discord once again...

I still love the theory of ting and yang i just wanna point out that starswirl might have created him anyway


It's possible that a Draconequus is a natural part of the MLP world. And have been wiped out in a way simpler to how the Dinosaurs have been. And Discord was "fixed" by aither Grogar or by Starswurl. And becoming the "spirit/lord of chaos" was jab at revenge for what life did to him. But forgot about sins he was having so much fun. And thanks to friendship. That forgotten rage had been put to rest, and reincarnated into something playful.


Easy way- they could of just told discord how he came to be

Problem solved 😌

Easy way- *they could of just told discord how he came to be*

Problem solved 😌


I thought Discord was pulled into this realm by the tree of harmony


Choas + discord = evil fun but harmony + choas + discord = fun in a good way but this means that discord is half evil half bad so if discord is half evil half bad he must have a connection with the griffins because he has the same details as them so what do we get if we put griffins and choas together it makes discord and his species because if I compared the choas with a griffin it must had made discord and his kind was band because they cause chaos long ago making discord the last one because his spices was extinct so that means discord was the last of his spices (theory I got in my head with a snap!)


Yes but they did say that discord was ruling a questionnaire before the sisters


The way discord’s magic was forced from him makes sense because thorax didn’t transform until he willingly gave his love, which is a form of magic as shown by love being cadence’s realm


Or when something chaotic or dis harmony happened in that time line he was maybe because of the sirens because they brought dis harmony but he was different  and chaos is in different ways like chaos disharmony and evil does are the things that made discord a long time ago

These are the people who agree with me
👇👇👇👇👇


k theory

So lets say that star swirl DID make discord
and discord IS an experiment gone wrong When Star swirl saw that Discord was causing chaos he banished him into some sort of world.
We have seen this before with the sirens so why not discord? But the thing is that lets say that even with Star swirl's power, He can only send people into ONE portal at a time so when the sirens were banished discord was set free and he began his rein of terror
I really like this theory (and If someone made this theory before me let me know in the reply section😉)


discord is actually grogar because in the episode the ending of the end part 2 chrysalis actually called discord grogar


all the trekkies are watching this like "all of these theories are invalid since discord is Q"


what if grogard was discord and gave up some of magic and creaited all the rest of the mutated animals


What if he was created by star swirl as a baby dracroniquis like he turned celestia and luna alicorns as fillys right before he went to limbo leaving discord by himself all alone as a baby and discord learned how to use his magic by himeself and started to develop hate towards equestria because his creator just up and abandoned him thats why he wanted to conquer equastria but the royal sisters were already old enough to fight him and the tree was fully grown. Thats just my theory tho


welp we can all agree that discord backstory is to chaos for us


this makes sense because discord is the spirit of chaos AND disharmony. If chaos isn't the opposite of harmony, disharmony is


Well if you think about it and I know it's 1 year Late but anyway if you noticed when the cutie mark Crusaders were fighting on a field trip discord was a stone Statue so that explains where discord was but that also brings a question how did he become a statue in the first place


what if discord is from another land of chaos and he escaped maybe grogar did not make discord but he escaped or traveled in equestria like the human world did not look worth concouring and equestria looked perfect think about it discord can do anything as long as he belives so he is obviously stronger than grogar so if you think aboutnit discord is from another world or dimension maybe <br>speaking of dimensions what if he is from a dimention where he is considered normal and maybe even weak

what if discord is from another land of chaos and he escaped maybe grogar did not make discord but he escaped or traveled in equestria like the human world did not look worth concouring and equestria looked perfect think about it discord can do anything as long as he belives so he is obviously stronger than grogar so if you think aboutnit discord is from another world or dimension maybe
speaking of dimensions what if he is from a dimention where he is considered normal and maybe even weak


MLP: Creates a character<br>Sawtooth Waves: Find me my history book

MLP: Creates a character
Sawtooth Waves: Find me my history book


Well of course ur first theory of star swirl making discord could be true!! Discord would have to be a baby when star swirl created him or left meaning discord the sisters and the tree had time to grow


I have a fairy how to discord was created starswirl did in fact creating him but when starswirl went to limbo discord thought he  betrayed him and set off  to make a plan on to control all ponies and make them pay so  when he was on his journey you found how to use his power fully I'm created powerful seeds to destroy the Tree of harmony so so he knew about it starswirl and fought there was no way that no one could get the elements except him!!!!!!!????,?,🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤯🤯🤯🤯😡😡😱😱😱😱😱😱


What if discord was sent to Tartarus then by the time the two princess where older he hade found out how to control his magic and escape.


If star swirl made discord the reason he was gone because he was learning how to control his powers


But as we know it could have been a lie cause we know in that video Discord him self was acting like grogar


Didn’t celestial say that they ‘saw’ how horrible life was for the ponies. Doesn’t that mean that discord was “ruling “ before the royal sisters came from a strange land?(see what I did there?) any way just a bit of food for thought.<br>Edit:typo

Didn’t celestial say that they ‘saw’ how horrible life was for the ponies. Doesn’t that mean that discord was “ruling “ before the royal sisters came from a strange land?(see what I did there?) any way just a bit of food for thought.
Edit:typo


Well there are moderators that code programs, and then they host a website and send a download link


What if Starswirl did indeed made Disord and Discord was a kid or a baby. If Discord was growing while the tree of Harmony was growing.


Discord real origin is that before hearts warming discord ruled equastria until after hearts warming the ponies came and Luna and celistista turned him to stone.


How about this? He became dicord!! It is possible right? Maybe He was trying to get back his bell but eventually became discord..It is a good theory right?


Whoever wrote that comment thank you so much !!! Because of your comment now others can also understand 😁


Well i think discord is starswirl.. if you think about it, discord can turn into any creature, for examples: Grogar. Maybe he also can turned into starswirl.. discord was banished after starswirl's sacrifice, because if you see where twilight goes into the past, Luna is already grown up and starswirl vanished when they are very young and he planted a seed to kill the tree which is planted before starswirl vanished. What if once discord is nice, and turned into a pony, starswirl and teach the princesses, after he sacrifice to go to limbo, he came back with his true form and play he's role as the lord of chaos, so does this mean discord is good and evil? Yes. you probably thought reforming the lord of chaos would take a long time, but he is reformed within a few days, you may think it is because of fluttershy but no, fluttershy or no fluttershy he will be reformed quickly, that is because he also had good inside him. now back to the past, He was turned to stone and discord is no more, but the CMK set him free by arguing, and then got defeated by the element of harmony again. then celestia wants to reform him, after he is reform he also learn friendship (In his evil form), then starswirl defeat stygian, and he also learn friendship (In discord's nice form) he learned friendship when he is good and evil, and if you watch mlp after starswirls is back, discord was never with starswirl at the SAME TIME!! well, when twilight dispowered cozy glow, tirek and chrysalis there is starswirl and discord, but maybe discord multiplied himself!! And i think discord cause chaos just to test the strength of celestia and luna 1000 years ago and also the strength of twilight and her friends, he did release 4 of the worst villain to test twilight, so he turn into starswirl, teach the princesses, turn into discord, and then test their strength. so that is my theory about "starswirl=discord"


Maybe Discord was young during each event until his first appearance <b>continues to watch video</b> ohhhhh that makes sense

Maybe Discord was young during each event until his first appearance *continues to watch video* ohhhhh that makes sense


Maybe grogar did make discord  but before equestria discord spread chaos somewhere else but if he didnt split apart maaybe because grogar took pure chaos and therefore made discord maybe my theory is wrong but i just wanted to say it


Wait by first appearance, do you mean first appearance in the show? Because wasn't discord friends with celestia and luna or something when they were younger


If you look closely in the episode 53 of My Little Pony there is a little so what you cannot see but you can


star swirl could still be discord because we never see them together.


surprised noone thinks Discord was a child. tottally didnt age


Maybe it could be you forgot about that he was turned into a statue by Luna and celestia


What if discord is the one who would free the three turned to stone as being one that was turned and reformed...


my theory is that discord just popped into existence


Please watch the return of harmony part one again and the gap will make more sense


I think, nobody created discord. If discord lives off just around chaos then nobody needs to create him because chaos is technically a natural thing. Discord is a symbolic meaning of chaos? I guess his first appearance could have been when he was old or strong enough to use his power bc "discord's magic is so chaotic no other creature can use it but him". Discord for a long time could have been practising his abilities which is why no other cReAtUrE can use it since they dont understand it like he does. So if discord just exists bc chaos exists in the world, then there is no need for someone else to create him. Him being made up from different creatures could represent the chaos from all creatures instead from just one :p


i always thought that celestia wanted to reform discord because he was powerful and his magic could have been used for good instead of evil


I believe discord is his own thing as he got his own dimension and power beyond anything and in the short equestria girls with see a discord plushie so I believe there is only one in all dimension


I'd say....

Discord was made by the app Discord.
Thats my thought UwU


That evil laugh sounded soo cheesy Hihihihi I like it


But when you realised the spirit of hormony kill the tree , but it says the spirit of hormony but its still create choas so it must the spirit of hormony and the spirit of choas is together from the first place


I was just watching mlp all over again, and in S2 E1 celestial says discord is the SPIRIT of disharmony.  S2 E1 5.40 - 5.50.


maybe someone opened a portal to his realm?


maybe he was from another,dimonsion but then he found the pony,dimonsion and he went in


Maybe discord was just a kid when star swirl got sent to limbo


Discord has his own dimension doesnt he?


When the Pillars planted the tree discord was created


there is a song that is called starswirl´s frakeinstein and it says that starswirl created discord


Umm Sawtooth if starswirl is discord how would he still be in equestria (how ever its spelled) if the whole time he was in limbo


You could brush off the the mlp mobile game as not cannon but, Discord has a cousin, I don't know much more info other than what she looks like as i have the screenshot of it and the knowledge of discord telling us of his cousin's existence.


Discord is a creature of chaos that spreaded chaos wait wait wait we have a problem the spirit of discord existed before the spirit of harmony I just don't understand the point


this nightmare tonight that i will have at 3 o clock in the morning is sponsored by raid shaddow legends.


0:56 burn the heresy! May the emperors holy light bring down the dark gods and make there followers repent! FOR RUSS AND ALL FATHER!!!!


Discord is the Lord Of Chaos <br>That's why he is a half animal

Discord is the Lord Of Chaos
That's why he is a half animal


But if the tree is destroyed wouldn’t discord be destroyed too.


While discord was gone thru out the season maybe he was being created then a mistake happend and he went to pony ville and made a ton of chaos

Ehh idk random

Sorry for my bad grammar, but maybe :>


Sprit of tree of harmony:I am your parent.<br>Discord:nuuuuuuuuu

Sprit of tree of harmony:I am your parent.
Discord:nuuuuuuuuu


°᯽{𝚄𝚋𝚎𝚄𝚖𝚎}᯽°


GASP i always ho to the discordant harmony!

Its a tea party. UwU

*GASP* i always ho to the discordant harmony!

Its a tea party. UwU


7:10 Awwwwww! Baby Tirek looks so cute! :)


Discort is the king of cayos so discort is stone befor and he was not created he is made from <br>a horse snake dragon  and deffrent animals and fluttershy is the key for discort the only thing he wanted is friends and fun not doing evil thing anymore if he knew friendship

Discort is the king of cayos so discort is stone befor and he was not created he is made from
a horse snake dragon  and deffrent animals and fluttershy is the key for discort the only thing he wanted is friends and fun not doing evil thing anymore if he knew friendship


You said grogar combine those creature (the bugbear, manticore, cockatrice, chimera and more) and that is a mythological creature.. so grogar and equestria is part of the greek mythology??????


When he said It may be someone just as old if not older I thought Granny Smith?


Wait how did the tree f harmony was created sure starswirl but how can he make a seed powerful grogars power.


I think discord joined the good side because a flutter shy and he didn’t want to lose a friend


But how did luna and celestia know abaut the element of hormony ?


Hi there I started watching you when I was 3 in 2013 but in 2015 I got YouTube takin away from me but just like 2 weeks ago I found your channel again and it’s so much butter then when I started watching


Excuse me but can you explain what happened to fluttershy ' s  parents 😕


I KNOW WHAT TIREK IS

If you play Zelda-

TIREK IS A LYNEL


So we all know that a Questria is in alone but it just doesn’t make sense Equestria does sound similar to the word America and it’s not the only state we all know the Dragon land and yak yak and Stan are a part of a Questria but they’re around it what about the other parts so maybe the Alcorn civilization is it fake just out of reach


Remember your video that you said that the Alcorn civilization isn’t there well maybe I think that video was right about star swiRemember your video that you said that the Alcorn civilization isn’t there well maybe I think that video was right about star Making Alcorns but maybe there’s a different continent that is the Alcorn civilization it’s just that Celestia and Luna weren’t part of it


Star swirl made discord and I have proof


Wait didn't celestia and Luna tell discord they didn't want to do anything to him maybe he was a friend of celestia and Luna but then he became evil


Can you do a vid were you tell us why did cozy glow,tirek and Queen crisalis<br>Team up

Can you do a vid were you tell us why did cozy glow,tirek and Queen crisalis
Team up


Me seeing 4:52 : Wait ...hold it- whAT iS hE aNywAys?


have you ever met Matt Pat from game theory
also I love your channel
i'm nine years old and I've been watching since I was four


I Don’t Think Star Swirl Created Discord


Ok he’s a species not one of a kind an definitely not the first of his kind did you not pay attention in the  episode were he first comes into it 😤


my inner asian is cringing hard at how he says 'yang' ...  but then my Malay side says yang is a real pronunciation but not for Yin and Yang... aghhhhh

but the fact that I am of Chinese origin and Yin and Yang are also from Chinese origin means it is not the Malay version sooo I cringe even more... dang it's like the surname 'Tan' all over again aghhhhhh sorry for the rant.. just cringe taking over no hate


Discord was egg when Thwe tree of harmony was not fully grown


He meant t-rec didnt split up into ahorse devil and giant


But why did discord not help on anything with twilight but make 8t hard and why is all of the enemies listening to discord if he did even do it like luna could have If she turned into nightmare moon but why would she do it when she was normal she was mad when she could have done it and why to twilight why would one of the enimeis take away his magic did someone make grogar along time ago when luna and celestia wasent here? I think someone did and he had to get power to turn back to his normal self or does he just want to be powerful idk how but I think twilight could have made discord because she could have needed help so she made something it couldn't have happend it just may have it's just what I think but did celestia and luna make him for a warning or reason was there apost to be another ememie but then why did they turn him to stone if they could have made him. It could have been a warning for discord to be mean to twilight and everyone but not luna maybe they could have been teamed up but then celestia told everyone that they would make discord alive not stone and as the video sed she could have thought chaos is not evil and can become friendship do u agree to what I think?


I do like the Starswirl made Discord theory a lot.  My head cannon would be that Starswirl made Discord, and Discord saw him as a “fatherly” figure for sorts but he always stayed in hiding out of fear. After Starswirl was vanished, Discord slowly went bonkers and thought the world owed him for taking away his creator


grogar IS discord and was the whol time,so ther is relly not much there


There is not just 4 Princess there is 5 because there’s another show about my little pony alcove in my little pony first princess actually the queen she was the first  alcone


So i know that im mounths late and that yo have already up loaded your one video about gorhars past but ifyou look at gorhgar and discard together the look really similar the both have light blue eyebrow tufts and there eyes colors are yellow and red, and i know that is where the simularities end but like, could gorhgar be discards father!? Or am i just over reacting, also if that is true then who would discords mother be? Aslo gathering information from when you said that discord seemed young and not experienced it would only make sense that discord was growing up during that time period from when his “father” was gone. Like, if he was getting more and more power as the tree grew and grew, so when the time came that the tree was fully grown he had just gotten his full power so he wanted to do something  instead of waiting and scheming! I really hope that this made sense to anyone who is reading this.              —Abby


Thinking it was about discord the chating app XD I am out


Discord is a  Chicana Chris your cannabis you’re kind of questions do you


I legit thought this was gonna be MatPat


Haha u won dr wolf cant even get close to u ur the beeest


Like in the legend of Korra Rava vs vatu


INTO THE UNKNOWN!  Wait a minute im at the wrong Youtuber


Discord was baby so that why he was not seen before carystria and Luna


But hey its just a theory a brony theory


What the last episode of The Grow garden episode and then you will know that grow Garden this court is on the same person.


I see what you did there an undertale amalgemate


I think i saw one of the Undertale monster-<br>Undertale I see hehe

I think i saw one of the Undertale monster-
Undertale I see hehe


Starsaler crated discord he was maybe have been in the stars aroooo tagres


Im CONFUSION
I think i need sleep
Cuz is 6 pm or i say am


um.....you might wanna refresh bc SPOILER ALERT!!! discord IS  tereck


Okay I love your videos but my question is why do you do this why did you watch mlp?


There are not 9 secoThere are not nine seasons in my little pony


hes a pretty interesting unique character


So this is my Throry that when star swirl creating discord  but star sworlKnew he made a mistake chaired up dis when it starts really got banished from limbo discord got released I know I was trying to find Questria I’m in season two that is when he found it there plzzzzzz pin thissss


i just realized this was posted on my birthday last year :P


he turned in to  aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa <br> HES A CHANGELING VIDEO SEE? oh i am not saying i am mad at him

he turned in to  aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
 HES A CHANGELING VIDEO SEE? oh i am not saying i am mad at him


Maybe discorn? Have a family and her family is from animal and pony <br>And the pony kill the animal discorn sad And than discorn be come now?

Maybe discorn? Have a family and her family is from animal and pony
And the pony kill the animal discorn sad And than discorn be come now?


I SAW AN UNDERTALE CHARATER<br>FROM THE TRUE LAB IN UNDERTALE

I SAW AN UNDERTALE CHARATER
FROM THE TRUE LAB IN UNDERTALE


But in my little pony one of the the teacher said that he is a   J-Kwon a qwis


Awesome! I completely agree with this theory, it seems pretty Valid. I’ll look into it!


You once did a video about how there might be elements of chaos, and now there is also a spirit of chaos AND a spirit of harmony, and both sets are like yin and yang!


Had always assumed discord just existed somewhere like another dimension or just another part of... Equestrian world. In the movie we see there are a lot of other towns and even civilizations (if... Yea, call them civilizations), Discord may have came from another side of the world, not created here exactly at the same place where ponies live, but your theory seems more legit


What if he has been around this whole time and has been  making some of the villains ,still making chaos just has been hiding in the shadows and when most of his creations fail he tries to handle it himself. And yes I know there is that 1 dude in season 9 that says he made creatures but what if Discord had made him as a replacement if something had happened to him

Edit:I am probably wrong,haven't seen season 9 yet


I would like to point out in one of the episodes it states that Discord was the last of his species so their would of had to have been more and the reason discord started messing with the ponies was because he was the last of his kind meaning something happened to the others maybe because of discord. I've had this theory for years now. Also my theory would explain why he didn't fall apart when his magic was taken from him. Also he would have to be at least as old as celestia maybe younger.

I don't think anyone ever stated Discord was the last of his kind in the show. You may be misremembering something.


I think Discord came from Thanos. The reality stone splits your body parts, it could've been done with many creatures, and the parts were put together to make what we know as Discord.


Wait a minute ... discord planted the seeds  and star swirl said that he was holding back the evil vine things that grew from the seeds before the tree was planted


I think that I have a work around for the time line thing.

Let's say that starswirl did create discord and soon after discord lost control, forcing starswirl to imprison discord in a way (I would say put in suspended animation in a pod, but this is a fantasy world). only for discord to breakout years later when what ever spell was used for off of some one broke him out.


Except in Make New Friends But Keep Discord, he brings out smooze, and smooze is centuries old. Discord also brought up that the smooze and him  ‘Went to collage together’ or whatever that means. But if discord was banished as soon as he was created how would he have known the smooze? I noticed this after rewatching all of the seasons again.


Well, nice… Ying/Yang, yes.

But… Harmony is what I think is the BALANCE that came out of it eventually.

Order... well, there has been different presentations of order, one after another. From Wendigoes (as in stasis), Grogar and Sombra -- to Celestia, Luna and Twilight.


Perhaps Discord and the Spirit of Harmony have already met? Maybe even before the Student 6 met the Spirit? I mean.....look how Discord helped the Mane 6 realize who they really are in S9EP2! Discord does have a bit of harmony in himself and I think the Spirit of Harmony may have noticed that in finale eps of season 4! Imagine....both of the spirits having a plan for the mane 6. Perhaps they worked together to make the Mane 6 release they don't need the elements when friendship is the most powerful magic of all. That's how a balance came between Equestrian yin and yang


What if Discord was ONCE A PONY?! Think about it, a powerful pony other than Starswirl who was able to create much oddness and many strange creations... What if he was trying to make a creature to harness chaos which was flowing through the land at the time? Something could've gone wrong and HE became that creature.

His memories fading and his mind set on chaos...


I have one answer to one of your question, you said that Discord was there even before My Little Pony started. So since season one, in the theme song Discord is peeking out of Fluttershy's cottage so has she been living with discord but on the other hand in the Return of Harmony reforming Rainbowdash, Twilight said that "if you don't catch her then Discord will achieve" then Fluttershy said, "that big bad meany". So I am not really sure where else he could be.


“This is already Discord’s base form!”
shows discord shaking

im laughing my ass off

“This is already Discord’s base form!”
*shows discord shaking*

im laughing my ass off


You’re also forgetting about the whole season of bright the right of discord where he married flutter shy when he told her about his past how his he lived in a land full of creatures just like himself


I know it’s late (since when I commented this the last ep is already out long) but maybe, Discord can help the mane six to fight using his chaotic power to trap or something the antigonist?


Maybe discord was created by a powerful emotion by someone so powerful that they created a bunch of nonsense maybe that powerful emotion combined with a few spirits of animals which created Discord.


I like this theory! I hope the awnser comes in season 9! Cause I haven’t watched it yet!


Even tho i like the theory of the tree bringing discord in the world but starsweil could have still have created him he could have been weaken for while intill the tree was fully grown the tree could have gave him the sheath to do his thing and try to put the whole world in balance


This guy has an imagination bigger than the universe. Really.


Maybe Grogar knew that he would not rule forever so he made discord come to life after his reign ended, but he thought that he would rule longer which explains the gap.


I think I know how this could we came to Be The pillars planted the seed then the spirit of the tree of harmony might be discord because I mean he planted vines that captured princess Celestia and Luna so I think you were right at the beginning but not only star swirl created discord all the other pillars Also created discord


this isnt very related to the video but i think the spirit of harmony partially took a form that resembled twilight because she's a neat freak.


I think star swirl made discord.
Like when someone comes in to existence, they know nothing. Even if the ying and yang thing was true, then what happened when discord is redeemed or turned to stone? That would increase harmony.
Also, how often does discord be chaotic anymore? There seems to be more harmony then chaos in the show. Literally any time some sort of chaotic sorce arrises, its drowned in harmony after. Try to explain that.  w

I think star swirl made discord.
Like when someone comes in to existence, they know nothing. Even if the ying and yang thing was true, then what happened when discord is redeemed or turned to stone? That would increase harmony.
Also, how often does discord be chaotic anymore? There seems to be more harmony then chaos in the show. Literally any time some sort of chaotic sorce arrises, its drowned in harmony after. Try to explain that.  -w-


while i know this is not a particularly exciting theory...but ive always perceived Discord as a primordial spirit that has always existed.


I saw something in a film that somewhat reminded me of discord realm it's in the film "simbad" theres a goddess called Aris the goddess of destruction and where she lives kinda reminds me of where discord lives basically the boarder reminds me of the border of discord chaos realm


“Almost all the monsters we’ve seen in the show are combinations”<br>Otherwise everyone in the show are unjustifiably racist🤔😅🤣

“Almost all the monsters we’ve seen in the show are combinations”
Otherwise everyone in the show are unjustifiably racist🤔😅🤣


Let's take slightly more Egyptian approach, Chaos/ Discord came before Grogar, he was the first thing infact but then he accidently created harmony, a millenia later he finally gained some power back after being severely weakened by his own creation so he created Grogar who immediately wreaked havoc, with Grogar's defeat Discord enraged came up with a plan to defeat the ponies, despite knowing he was vulnerable and weak. 1000 years later...  Fluttershy reforms discord, from joining the forces of good he is weakened, gravely, due to his new advantage of teamwork all the power he loses goes to Grogar's bell which means later in season Grogar's bell now is now capable of stealing Discord's magic despite Discord being it's creator. So basically Discord created everything then weakened himself by becoming good, and that is how Discord came to be.


I think that he is going to far in his speculation, Discord is magical creature of chaos he doesn't need someone to exist because it would lead to asking who created the darkness who took over the friend of the 1st 6 heroes of Equestria. And also the knowledge of Discord seemed infinite so if we supposed that he was just born in the same time that the tree of harmony where all this knowledge come from.


I have an idea on the star swirl created Discord.
Star swirl was good but knew him and the pillars were getting older so he created something to help protect equestria Discord.
Discord was loyal to star swirl and would do anything for his master but when he was sent to limbo with the pony of shadows he was left in despair.
Discord must of seen this happen and thought the pony of shadows did it so that's why he wanted to rule and punish ponies.
Like if you agree


Maybe this theory isn’t really all that true. In season 9 when Discord is chained up in the canterlot dungeons, he is taunting Tirek and he says that deep down he’s afraid that he’ll never be enough to please dear old dad King Vorak. So maybe Discord didn’t come to be because he was the opposite and equal reaction of the tree of Harmony. Maybe the center of his origin story isn’t the tree of harmony but King Vorak...


Theres a chaos dimension sorta thing, so like how ya said star swirl made dimensions for celestia and luna, maybe he did make discord and the dimension before the tree of harmony because he new there'd need to be balance if he wanted to make the tree. Maybe discord was kept in control by star swirl [because he's such a powerful unicorn maybe he could] and when star swirl left discord couldve found out somehow and determined a way to escape his chaos dimension into the pony world
Who knows tho, thats just what came to my mind
Its also legit imo that he could have just spawned on his own cuzza the tree too like the fighting back and forth of chaos and harmony history presents


I honestly feel like these people are smarter than the writers


Discord has been captured on stone for a long time I believe I hope that answers your question of where he has been


Discord is a Draconequus, How did they know the name? See my theory, Discord wanted to rule Equestria, and we know that there are many places outside of Equestria, and in equestria girls "most likely to be forgotten" Clover the clever defeated the evil sorceress, that means there are more villians out there, now we come to the Draconequus part, as we see before Equestria was discovered the ponies still needed each other....what if Draconequuses like Discord had created so much chaos that the lead the ponies to fight against each other, some how the other the Draconequuses were defeated maybe or they were attacked by the windigos, So that would have meant the ponies still fought because now there is a bigger threat, what if discord was the only Draconequus who escaped and wanted to take over this land for revenge...we see celestia hesitating a little to use the elements of harmony on him that could have meant that discord was at equestria earlier too, maybe he was pretending to be good and asked starswirl for 2nd chance but starswirl did not trust him, but celestia still asked for it for 2nd chance...maybe he was so overwhelmed to take revenge for his fellow Draconequuses that he did not see the Good in Equestria...<br>(Dont mind the spellings)

Discord is a Draconequus, How did they know the name? See my theory, Discord wanted to rule Equestria, and we know that there are many places outside of Equestria, and in equestria girls "most likely to be forgotten" Clover the clever defeated the evil sorceress, that means there are more villians out there, now we come to the Draconequus part, as we see before Equestria was discovered the ponies still needed each other....what if Draconequuses like Discord had created so much chaos that the lead the ponies to fight against each other, some how the other the Draconequuses were defeated maybe or they were attacked by the windigos, So that would have meant the ponies still fought because now there is a bigger threat, what if discord was the only Draconequus who escaped and wanted to take over this land for revenge...we see celestia hesitating a little to use the elements of harmony on him that could have meant that discord was at equestria earlier too, maybe he was pretending to be good and asked starswirl for 2nd chance but starswirl did not trust him, but celestia still asked for it for 2nd chance...maybe he was so overwhelmed to take revenge for his fellow Draconequuses that he did not see the Good in Equestria...
(Dont mind the spellings)


I know this isn't relevant to Discord, but in the finale, there is another mystery to be solved. Prince Blueblood. In season 1 episode 3, Rarity says, "Princess Celestia herself. And the princess would be so taken with the style and elegance that she would introduce me to him! Her nephew." She then goes on to dream about him marrying her and she says, "We would have a royal wedding, befitting a princess, which is what I would become upon marrying him." This shows that Prince Blueblood is of royal descent...but from who? The only known royals in Equestria at the time were Princess Celestia and Princess Luna (and Cadence, but she wasn't introduced yet). But, Rarity says that he's Celestia's nephew. So, is Luna his mother? Or is there another royal sibling that we dont yet know about?


I think you got yin and yang mixed up. Yang =Light  while Yin= darkness.


Hi! Just one question, if discord was made at the exact time of the first known instance of the tree of harmony then how was here supposed to conquer equestria so soon?? No hate (if u think I’m a hater 😅)


Ok so I was thinking after I watched this, grogar (I think that's his name) wasn't actually real discord was pretending to be him and the shadow guy that was trying to take control of the crystal palace he said that grogar was just a legend that he heard when he was just a foal just wondering I started thinking about that

Ps I watched every single season I just only pay attention to the main characters names not the bad guys


And also how could it be possible that Discord was born in the same time that the tree of harmony if even when Lord Tirrek ( not sure if it's written correctly) after spending I don't know how long in Tartarus knows about him.


As they say one cannot leave without the other they are like the Spirits of Good and Evil yes like Yin and Yang but yes maybe when the Tree of Harmony was planted it started to Grow and spread more Harmony and Peace that the existence of Discord Came to be. Discord is Like Despair but with Despair there is Hope enter the Tree of Harmony and there will always be Despair those who wanna destroy it. Like in Avatar Legend of Korra Rava and Vatu or Tui and La. Put it this way in the Legend of Korra Vatu (Discord) Killed Rava (Tree of Harmony) but Rava was found inside of Vatu that symbolizes in despair there is hope just like in the MLP Series Discord and Tree of Harmony = Discord and the Tree House of Harmony


Maybe the spirit of harmony is discord because when king sombra said he would work on her s own so discord (grogar) decided that he could bring king sombra back to destroy the tree of harmony so the mane 6 would see that their friendship is stronger and they don't need the elements of hparmony


I’m not saying you’re wrong, but I think starswirl <b>did</b> make discord. I think that he created him before planting the tree, but he banished him to his homeland of chaos, and then discord found out how to escape. Then he took over Equestria and you know the rest. I hope you see this...

I’m not saying you’re wrong, but I think starswirl *did* make discord. I think that he created him before planting the tree, but he banished him to his homeland of chaos, and then discord found out how to escape. Then he took over Equestria and you know the rest. I hope you see this...


I really like this theory, it makes sense


So your theory that Discord was Starswirl turned out to not be so! That doesn’t mean that there wasn’t a connection between the two


Well when Discord was created I bet he was a child and his magic wasn’t powerful enough to try and take over Equestria yet?
...
WAIT!!! WHEN YOU FIRST TRY SOMETHING YOUR NOT VERY GOOD AT IT BUT WITH PRACTICE YOU GET BETTER AT IT SO WHAT IF DISCORDS A LATER CREATION THATS MORE POWERFUL AND HAS MORE RESILIENCE.
...
Ok, uhm nvm I might just delete this comment...


Maybe like how the wendigos can slowly form over time by the disharmony caused by ponies, perhaps the chaos caused by villain of the past. Like a sort of Athena situation.


In MLP shorts it says; “And one of the greatest sorcerers of all time spent most of his life toying with ponies” or something, I think it was celestias school shorts it says something about discord and I think he was around before his first appearance in the show


starswirl did create discord and was able to control him as he was a baby and discord was fully grown and under starswirls control but when satrswirl was gone he took his chance took over equestria


Idk? I think that starswirl actully created, Discord... Wanna know how i think that? I wonder... What if  Starswirl made discord, he found him as a horrible mistake, so he might of hidden him in a stone prison. Or maybe even sent him somewhere, banished. Starswirl warned him before he had went missing. Luna and Celestia kept on guard. A long time later they found out that he has escaped. They knew that they had planted a seed, they went to see the tree for the first time, using the elements to defeat him. Yeah this could be true.


But the CMCs unleased discord so the first episode with him is not when he was created


Something I must mention is that maybe Grogar did not create centaurs.


Discord is the chaos spirit, he was summoned by someone or something as punishment or his duty to ballance the scale of good and evil.


Celestia and Luna created this court and then they put him in a spell and then the spell broke and then the score decided that these people to powerful so we went to take over Ponyville and that’s how that happened but not a bang


i feel like Discord was a lab expirament by ponies and then they made him by misteak


what if while gusty the great imprison grogars bell he did so with discord to and he came back because: The spell faded, he saw the perfect opportunity, or when pony chaos did happen it was so strong which pulled him swards contriving it.


I don’t get it. Maybe i missed something but.... how did they plant the tree? With what? Like a magic seed the found or something???


Wait a minute the Tree of Harmony was destroyed and Discord was still alive.


TheThe crystal heart is another element of harmony because the elements of harmony or made by crystals just like the crystal heart


This reminds me of game/film theory, it’s all about the timeline.


If discord was created BEFORE his first appearence he was probuoly helping others then something in side him snapped so he got a motovasion to take over!


maybe discord was an ordinary creature who absorb magic and turned into a magical monster


Ponies use their magic and make tree
While that they use their magic make disc
They combine meegic
Just like how discord is a combo of creature
:////
Maybe he got suck in limbo
But maybe he escape :///
He is powerful he is chaos
Maybe he can escapeee


Ok i have this theory but i don't know how to prove it completely but what if there was a whole species of draconeques and discord was among them but what if something happened to the whole race like something stronger then all of them and they all became extinct except discord and soon met celestia and luna a younger foals and witnessed celestia raising the moon and stuff what if they were all friends with discord until people noticed his differences and conflict happened between discord and the ponies maybe also celestia/luna
Then discord takes over equestria so on and so forth because in "Keep Calm Flutter On" at the end of the episode the final scene when fluttershy complements discord all the other ponies are kind of unsure but celestia was the only one who looked the most unsure the same face when twilight makes a mistake like a big mistake that might mean celestia/luna made a BIG mistake in the past that may have resulted in discords villainy.

But your theory also seems too good to be true and may actually be true
Please let me know what you think of my theory.


Hey video creator.<br>Can you make a video on why the spirit of harmony look like twiglight?

Hey video creator.
Can you make a video on why the spirit of harmony look like twiglight?


I answer to you Star Swirl could create discord but after being create he said only tata to his creator and eclipsed himself soon after and Star Swirl say «well that not what I planned, I should fix it but later it’s not like I have no other time!» <br>So Star Swirl create Sentience to the Chaos

I answer to you Star Swirl could create discord but after being create he said only tata to his creator and eclipsed himself soon after and Star Swirl say «well that not what I planned, I should fix it but later it’s not like I have no other time!»
So Star Swirl create Sentience to the Chaos


What if discord came from the same distant land as Scorpan and Tirek


0:35 4everfreebrony comes in with Starswirl's Frankenstein.


Did you forget the part where princess Celestia and Luna said they had already banished Discord and that he broke out? ;-;


Discord is made of good and bad that might be why he's mixed with a bunch of different animals if discord is able to reform to then he might be apart of good and bad though discord might be deciding witch is best for him if you think about it grogar and the 6 ponies are two different Species discord always goes to his crazy dimension when he's defeated he might be so many different animals because he is being put on two sides


What i learned after watching 8 videos ... EVERYTHING IN MLP IS CONNECTED ;^;^; never let something out cuz it might hve a connection


Just know one thing

"What's fun in making scence?"


I’m not sure if the fact that discord pretended to be Grogar changes the Grogar created discord discord Theory at all but if it does yay for you


Maybe he wasn’t evil at the time something happened and he turned evil


Maybe when the tree of harmony was destroyed it formed discord and he started


Discord:waltzes into tree house* ELLO!!!!!!!!
Spirit of harmony: wut the...
Discord:makes chaos via dragon kitsune*


Well he is the lord of chaos so I don't think he is supposed to be solved


Is Discord’s name based off of the actual Discord app?


Then found a way to escape and started ruleing equstria


maybe discord had something to do with dark magic


If this is true then star swirl Spanish discord but then he got out and The two sisters banish discord ceiling him up in his own realm The time that he got out and started conquering Questria The two sisters where are ready fully grown so as The tree of harmony


Well the grogar is discord theory was sort of right

Can we get to 100 Followers without any videos?


Discord came from a pumpkin. (Bride of discord fans will get it)


Celestial and Luna have parents so maybe the turned Descord to stone right?

꧁ℙ𝕦𝕞𝕜𝕚𝕟 𝕡𝕚𝕖꧂


Tirek: no one can use chaos energy but discord<br>Also Tirek, but a few seasons ago: mmm yummy chaos energy

Tirek: no one can use chaos energy but discord
Also Tirek, but a few seasons ago: mmm yummy chaos energy

@Gamer Dylan 6 Why do you assume he wasn't able to absorb it just because he didn't? He didn't say that he couldn't do it, or try and then fail. He just made no attempt in the first place. He warned Chrysalis and Cozy Glow that no creature besides Discord could control it; i.e., he knew from experience that absorbing Discord's magic didn't do him any good the last time he tried it, so he didn't see any point in trying it again.

@Epesi yah except how was he able to absorb his energy previously but not in the final season?

Well, he absorbed it, but he didn't demonstrate any chaotic abilities afterward. Nothing contradictory there.


Wait a minute stuff doesn't add up Grogar said first emporer of equestria but a lot of time later on the first ponies with the friendship fire heart thing thing when I watched the pageant they were the ones who named it but now grogar knew they name thing


hmmm so are u trying to say is when the tree of harmony was created discord was created? or when the tree of harmony was fully grown discord was created? and he was created for balance?


cerberus isnt a bad boy, in any cenario including mythology


Maeby discord was created by the magic in Grogar's bell


I think that discord was locked in Tartarus after he was created


wait. what if the sparkely twilight was DISCORD?!!


You are such a genius My mind was blown 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯.


Discord was in stone that is where he was


He was created by chaos itself, thats how he IS chaos


The episode before the end it changes that  discord was grogar


Hold on when the tree of harmony was planted discord new about it and he planted (dropped) those seeds how is that possible that's what's confusing

Well when the princesses went to confront him with the elements of harmony


Maybe Discord is the Alicorn of Chaos, or even Mister Mxyzptlk. ;) (Grogar = Centaur and Minotaur, in a world without humans.))


The Video: Thunder
The cloud who was raining on my home: TTHHUUNNDDEERR

The Video: *Thunder*
The cloud who was raining on my home: *TTHHUUNNDDEERR*


I watched a sawtooth waves vid from 2014 and <i>wow</i> has your audio quality improved

I watched a sawtooth waves vid from 2014 and _wow_ has your audio quality improved


Wait wait wait wait... What if the everfree forest made discord!! Maybe he was created by the everfree forest, from like a tree or something?!


hmmm i think Discord may be in tartarus when in the time line of Grogars rain and his first terror if not then how did Tirek hear about discord since he probably spend years in tartarus and how did Tirek hear that Discord is turned to stone since he  was in tartarus unless he met him since when Tireks first appearence in the show he said <br>Discord? Your free?? Maybe he was reffering to Discords banishment from stone but how did Tirek  hear of him is there mail in tartarus or wut

hmmm i think Discord may be in tartarus when in the time line of Grogars rain and his first terror if not then how did Tirek hear about discord since he probably spend years in tartarus and how did Tirek hear that Discord is turned to stone since he  was in tartarus unless he met him since when Tireks first appearence in the show he said
Discord? Your free?? Maybe he was reffering to Discords banishment from stone but how did Tirek  hear of him is there mail in tartarus or wut


I think you know The pillars planted the tree of harmony right and the tree of harmony how to spirits of the tree and then how coincidently there


Discord is a poltergeist just like Peeves


Hey Sawtooth , I think TIREK created DISCORD


Didn't make discord but then catch him up and and he broke out and then the Royal sisters found it and then turned into stone


There’s something really really really very very very very we don’t know how old is discord


he split into a a a a a............he split into an a.


Just so you know tirek is a demon and horse


Is there a really strong cutey mark than the alicorns have


Maybe discord isn’t from the pony world? XD


I thought discord is evil animal  that change his heart to good


Is there a mistake about different creature married?


True but if that theory is true where is the chaos in the spirit of harmony?


Element of Harmony DISCORD WILL BE STONE


Is it just me or am I the only one who is angry with how he said yin-yang.


But Yin stands for female and Yang stands for male<br>;-; which I think so because I just watched a YouTube video

But Yin stands for female and Yang stands for male
;-; which I think so because I just watched a YouTube video


No it is because twilight and her friends freed him from being a statue


Happened to discord where was he born and who is his mother<br>Please give me an answer quick because I really wanna know

Happened to discord where was he born and who is his mother
Please give me an answer quick because I really wanna know


He was statue since the sisters made him that


I did have this idea but i thought it was silly xd


But when discord reformed the the spirit of how many did not disappear


This got me thinking why are the six different kind Applejack and pinkie pie a earth pony rarity and twilight unicorns and rainbow Fluttershy Pegasus the twilight is the alicorn so how does that make her unicorn if you saw one of the episodes where working sombra took everyone's magic but she was in the unicorn side how does this explain the theory


discord was made at the beginning of time !!! <br>have not thought of that. -,-

discord was made at the beginning of time !!!
have not thought of that. -,-


Kroger when he went to stroyd them he came out


i think all the combined animals made discode


this is annoying me I know he may say Yang how he says it but it sounds like ` Yawn ` Not  `Yang`


And is there a pony or a pegasus or whatever  born with mistake?


He's Q's pet, obvious. That or Eris had sex with a dragon


In the very last episode rainbow and Apple jack were had a argument about chores did they get married?


Mmmm I think discord was just first a statue


He said yin yong instead of Yin Yang ._ ·

ᚺᛖ᛫ᚹᚺᛟ᛫ᛒᚱᛁᛜᛊ᛫ᚦᛖ᛫ᚹᚨᛊᛏᛖ᛫ᛟᚠ᛫ᛏᛖᚱᚱᚨ


this back round music was taken by G-switch


wiattttttttttttttttt........can we talk about what that thing on your google search is???


ITS A HORSE AND AN ELF NOT GOAT OR HUMAN OR BULL sorry I just was really mad because you could tell that it was a elf and a horse


I just realized you showed endogeny from undertale A


Mah oc is basicly discord but mostly pony.. TwT


Wasn’t discord stone in the show somewhere is the show

Nvm I guess it was after he ruled but then got turned into stone


Bruh for your information discord is a draconaquis


Discord much come from another dimension???????????????????????????


But discord reformed but the did not spirit of harmony did not disappear


it like the sun and the moon and hot or the cod


Look on avatar the last air bender because thee is a good sprit and a bad one if one is destroyed it is still alive in the other sprit


Next time just cut 2 the chase in other words just get to the point.


Beauty of love Abby love is so cool and Nicely good


so why boy did you pretened to by doctor wolf?


ok srsly i have no idea what is happening😶


Maybe discord went to limbo tooo but escaped

And when he escaped then he started ruling and got turned to stone

Snap his fingers and got out, or maybe someone got him out

Like twilight did to star swirl


I think the school is mix out of every normal animal snake cocktail points and yes maybe FaceTime is made out of something that’s putting a snake and a horse so maybe he must be grill guard Batman thing so do you know who he really is I know who he really is I will tell you in the next one in the next video but you have to give me $1000 so I can tell you who created this cool because I know


ying and yang

the president of Ukraine being a comedian


Did you guys know that Discord has a weakness? On Season 7 episode 12, fluttershy clarified that if Discord continues to be normal he'll be *destroyed*, I see the reason why he started doing chaotic stuff as soon as he was released from his statue state. Discord is the Spirit of Chaos he can't be the Lord of Chaos if he can't make create chaos. Also I think Grogar made Discord, not sure if Discord is known as a monster but a Draconequus. No wander why Discord pretended to be Grogar in season 9.. just a theory ^


Amazing Theory but... The theory that star swirl created discord is still plausible because discord could have been created as a young creature (maybe even a baby) in case the fusion went wrong and it had to be destroyed. I know this is a lot of assumptions but bear with me... Maybe star swirl added an age spell in there too, this is why star swirls disappearance and discord’s appearance are so far apart... Discord would have spent all that time in hiding, growing up and learning new things about his chaos powers... Also, we can assume he became evil on his own, living in the wild all his life would have taught him that the only way to survive is to show dominance, this is why he invaded Equestria... Maybe as a child, he ran away, either because he didn't like the living conditions or because he was going to be destroyed and disposed of by star swirl, survivor instincts kicked in and he fled.


Actually, the theory is great, yet I don't see the problem with Discord being Starswirl's creation in the simple way (like in the beginning of the video). Discord could have been under Starswirl's control 'till the latest moment. The Royal sisters came to "finish his era of terror and chaos". The gap between, when the sisters and the Tree grew, might be that "era".


I just had an idea, after having watch the video, read the pinned comment and read the comment of @Purriesi !. What if Grogar was the first incarnation of chaos. It's possible that due to him  existing so long ago and that the magic of friendship wasn't "around" so to speak that due to the world being less friendly and more chaotic back then that the spirit of chaos would have those aspects amplified too. Which could explain why when Discord came into existence, he was more of a chaos for the sake of fun and less chaos for the sake of power as Grogar seemed to be.


In that random episode where Discord held a tea party for Fluttershy, she mentioned that he was a creature of pure chaos, but somewhere it’s noted that chaos isn’t always bad. My idea, Discord was created because everything was normal, which is nuts in equestria. He was created from himself, to spice things up a bit. And because he’s made of chaos it’s totally possible that he created himself


I love this theory about discord. It gives a discord a bigger part to play and since he is my favorit character I  rally like this.


I think that when the tree was made so was discord. Like a counter to the tree of harmony. Discord i think is like the yin to the trees yang. Because you cant just have harmony all the time so the magic of equestria needed to create a balance for this. Thus discord is born. At least that's my take on Discord.


And I just realized something maybe when the spirit of chaos I mean the Spirit of Harmony was finally full grown Discord means the spirit and your god of chaos was drawn to Equestria to right the wrong of how much Harmony there is Andy was overloaded by his Natural Born instincts of magic itself to cause chaos because of how much Harmony not enough chaos to the point that he ended up accidentally losing control to Wood and then being blamed for something he can't really control and that's why Fluttershy stare all it did was really get his own mind in control and not his instincts it's like saying I see what you want to do instincts but I don't want you to do it so here's a here's a spray bottles spray spray


Because Discord, the griffs, and Tirek are basically ponies but in different bodies, they can't really get "split apart". For example, (a lame example) Twilight didn't turn into a narwhal and the Saddle Arabia horses when she lost her magic. The monsters, on the other hand, are just animals.<br>This really makes you sweat when the show introduces things like Capper and the parrot pirates because they already exist as normal animals rather than ponies with different forms.

Because Discord, the griffs, and Tirek are basically ponies but in different bodies, they can't really get "split apart". For example, (a lame example) Twilight didn't turn into a narwhal and the Saddle Arabia horses when she lost her magic. The monsters, on the other hand, are just animals.
This really makes you sweat when the show introduces things like Capper and the parrot pirates because they already exist as normal animals rather than ponies with different forms.


I don’t really think so. Discord might have come from beyond equestria in some kind of place where draqonequus live and thrive with chaos, and Discord might have been given a kind of power which he can have almost infinite power, and soon he left the land and went to Equestria and promised that he would take over Equestria with chaos. When he came there, he saw Grogar and he was in his rein of evil. Grogar taught Discord many things about his power and soon, Discord came back to his land and when he came back Grogar wasn’t there anymore and then yeah.


A question you forgot to address: why does Discord look the way he does?
1) Chaos
2) This is the form that HE chose to have

Easy


the timeline can be somewhat solved discord of course is pretty powerful star swirl put a spell that kept discord put and when he went to limbo it got dis free by being on magic for so long he needed to heal years later he was having a plan to attack Equestria then did it though failed and since the spell star swirl put on him didn't last it was clear another creation of his wouldn't last. Done!


Discord must have KNOWN about grogars igsenstence to pretend to be him. If discord came from the tree of harmony, (love that theroy) how did he find out about grogar? How did he pretend to be him? Where did he get that orb thing and that house lair place? And did grogar REALLY give life to foul creatures, or did discord make that up while pretending to be grorgar?


imagine his face when he finds out that grogar IS discord


I have a theory of my own. As discord is the only dracaenaquis we are shown. What if he was part of a whole species of dracaenaquis people. Like he had parents and siblings and a whole village far away from Equestria. Something might have happened to the species that wiped them out entirely leaving a young discord to wonder the lands around him looking for a place to plant roots and remake his population somehow. When he saw Equestria and the magic it held within it. Discord could have thought of a way to bring back his species with that power but he need to make it chaotic so that his species would be able to regrow and see how there powers work. When he saw Celestia and Luna he didn't think of them as threats as he didn't fully understand the magic that Equestria held and didn't know what harmony was. Leaving an open space for Celestia and Luna to freeze him in stone.

My theory probably doesn't make much sense


Honestly I think that discord and alicorns are more realated.He is meant to show alicorns what the bad is and what good is so they(Alicorns)Dont go around spreading darkness and he was created by none other than star swirl the bearded.He already taught luna and celestia what the difference between good and evil is so he just did his own thing until he took over


I think discord was created b star swirl the bearded because he needed to learn to control his chaotic magic like when (twilight sparkle became an alicorn she had to learn to control the wings and when in the season 4 or something when tierk made his appearance she had to learn to control the alicorn magic) so maybe discord was trying to get used to the different parts and chaos (magic like when Cozy Glow or Pinkie pie took discords magic from the bell they couldn't control it)


Discord is from another world....as you can see he opens portals...Discord is like WONDERLAND in an organism....he might have come from a world of only chaos creatures he might have seen this world's magic and after seeing the goodness in equestria he lived there...so my conclusion is discord from another world


You do know that chimeras, and cocatrices existed in mythology, right?


These are all great theories, but I like the one in the Inkrose Equestria origin video the best.


Maybe discord was created by the universe to balance both chaos and harmony. Therefore implying that he was created by no one, and appeared from nothing. Similar to how the Wendigo horse storm started when the pegasai, pony's, and unicorns were fighting.

Your theory is good but I don't think discord necessarily had a creator.


4:10  Your evil laugh needs work.  :P

6:55  My first thought was the timeline problem.

8:45  ...Well scientifically cold is defined as a relative lack of heat, not something existing in and of itself, but I take your meaning.

11:10  Yep.  Reminds me of Jackie Chan Adventures where Uncle wanted Shendu sealed in stone rather than killed.  Balance in that case was satisfied by him being alive, regardless of whether he was active.


Maybe when Starswirl made Discord, he banished him to some weird wonky unicorn-made FAKE limbo and when he went to real limbo, it brings me to another of my theory where when you leave the dimension you cast a “permanent” spell, it starts to fade. So when Starswirl left pony world, the fake limbo he created, faded away until it disappeared and Discord was forced back into his original dimension. Now I have no way of proving that Discord wouldn’t have just faded with the fake limbo. This was VERY long.


I think how discord came to be was that the tree of harmony created discord because the tree knew what it had to do. Then celestia had some vision and told the mane 6 to free him from the stone


tirek did not split into a base form because it did not originate from a combination of creatures like the other creatures trapped in the tartarus, it has already been shown in comics that tirek has a family so he couldn't have separated because it would be something like a genetic inheritance from King Vorax, something similar may have happened with discord, in the comics we have Princess Eris, who is his cousin,so maybe that discord has parents, uncles and maybe more creatures of chaos besides discord, cosmos and Eris


If twilight is the princess of harmony (idk) Discord gave her the last key to open the box thing where the “ tree” or “spirit”of harmony is. In that way Discord(chaos) boosted the power of harmony in order to stop Tirek.


I'm at 1:41 right now.
Didn't they say they saved Equestria from Discords reign, by getting rid of him.
he could've been growing and then began ruling whole of Equestria in the thousand years of absence of Starswirl.


I for one think that your theory that when Equestria was found so was he, but taking it in depth he must've been a pure creature who turned to chaos because of being rejected, kind of like Queen Chrysalis. He actually might just be a normal <b>hybrid</b> creature, like T-rek, but instead of being part of another civilisation, he was rejected. This may have affected his thoughts on who he was and what was his purpose and wanted to take revenge. But, after meeting the main six and seeing their power, he might've looked at a whole new perspective. This is also supported by how he was surprised when Flutter Shy accepted him for who he was, I mean why else would he be bias?

I for one think that your theory that when Equestria was found so was he, but taking it in depth he must've been a pure creature who turned to chaos because of being rejected, kind of like Queen Chrysalis. He actually might just be a normal *hybrid* creature, like T-rek, but instead of being part of another civilisation, he was rejected. This may have affected his thoughts on who he was and what was his purpose and wanted to take revenge. But, after meeting the main six and seeing their power, he might've looked at a whole new perspective. This is also supported by how he was surprised when Flutter Shy accepted him for who he was, I mean why else would he be bias?


Not to debunk any theorys, but if discord is sprit of chaos, he would have a "tree" of chaos, which is what, also discord would have to grow like the tree and Celestia and Luna.


What if starsworld created discord then banished him to a different realm but before he could discord tried learning starsworld way to realm hop and he didn’t perfect it until years later but he also knew that starsworld would just banish him away more indefinitely so he spent the rest of the time he was there learning magic and that is why discord is so powerful


What if LONG ago there was so much chaos in the world that the chaos needed to escape somewhere, not as mush as escape more of evolved into Discord, so really nothing CREATED it, take it into consideration


Wait........didn't Star Swirl technically still create Discord because The Pillars planted the Tree of Harmony....🤔🤔


Didn't discord said that "I haven't walked that far in a millennium" in a season finale?


Disproven I know. I don't know what you guys think but I feel like he was everybody's chaos that came from everybody's dark side...<br>Edit: Like a cointainment of everyone's hate exploded and combined...

Disproven I know. I don't know what you guys think but I feel like he was everybody's chaos that came from everybody's dark side...
Edit: Like a cointainment of everyone's hate exploded and combined...


Maybe discord was created by starswirl  but starswirl saw how dangerous he was and banishing him for as long as he could


Do you think that's why the spirit of harmony took the form of the obsessive compulsive control freak that we know as Twilight? 😂😂😂 maybe it took that form to make discord angry I mean Twilight didn't warm up to discord until WAY later than the rest of the main 6 😂😂😂😂😂


I think discord might be a being created from grogars chaos magic and not a hybrid


The voice factor that plays him is from star trek next generation and he is my third fav actor


Wow I started yesterday and already saw all of the vids!!!
You are amazing!
Got a new subscriber <3


6:43 if discord needs chaos to have a body and exist then discord wouldn’t be a ghost because he has chaos


Did starswirl and his friends have enemies maybe when they made the tree of harmony maybe their enemy also made a tree of chaos there has to be one somewhere think about it when else do we hear about ponies disapearing much like starswirl and the others maybe then we can see maybe who created him


As you were saying in the time line, maybe dicord used to be neutral?


Maybe someone tried to make hik good to protect Equestria but failed and made him the lord of chaos


Well then how does discord know who grogar is let alone how he looks?


I think that discord was made by starswirl because discord might have never been the spirit of chaos and got cursed.


I agree with you on everything in this video


I have a thry that harmony and chaos were in balance till the tree of harmony was founded  upsetting the balance in harmonys favor so for balance to be restored something needed to be able to make chaos to balance thing out thus discord was formed. He is known as the spirit of chaos the key word being spirit


when celestia told the mane 6 to release him she told a name like its from a specie,so its basically like an animal so he have not been create he born


Discord planted a seed and it did something in the future like how the pillars wanted to plant a seed in the past that would help the future yes makes sence


1:38 I think discord was learning how to use his powers


What if the elements of harmony were created as a result of discord’s existence.


Notice how discord has grogar’s eyes and eyebrows I believe that discord could be grogar’s Failsafe like when he was suppose to be banished to the stars but instead turned in to chaos feeding off the essence to stay alive and powerful without his bell. His bell is almost equal in strength as discord’s chaos and with grogar as discord he can still be an emperor but of chaos shadows and weird creatures not to mention dimensions as well as we see discord rip a hole in his universe at the grand galloping gala. So it is strongly possible grogar = discord

Mahek Faisal yes I know that my point was maybe discord is grogar he changed his being in order to not be banished or something like that

Sea Fork the series ended months ago. We already saw that grogar was discord. The real grogar was probably banished years ago