When you were asking questions about discord I heard you say "was discord banished?" I thought you had not Watch my little pony


Kinda like in the episode when the 2 sisters fought starlight said without both of you theres no harmony


I hope they add in more of discords past in the show before it ends


Congratulations on 500k Sawtooth!!! <333


Maybe because discord was hiding and regaining his power or maybe just growing up he might be still a little baby when star swirl accidentally created him or whatever and he was send to another desanation growing up and when he was a teanager like I guess now  he know how to control his magic and teleport out of there and start the chaos?


I think that discord Knew  that the Tree of harmony will be destroyed so he freed the villains to test how will the others react to when the s Tree of harmony is destroyed ,to see if they will fall apart


Waves: The Tree of harmony is the reason for Discord.<br>Me: That means Fluttershy is older then Discord….😳

Waves: The Tree of harmony is the reason for Discord.
Me: That means Fluttershy is older then Discord….😳


Am I the only one who gets shocked all the time with these theories?

Edit: Omg thanks for the heart :3


In between that time line maybe   Discord was growing up


Maybe star swirl created discord after or before the banishment of the shadow thing and created discord as a grown creature


Here is what I think the parts of Discord are: Head of a goad, horn of a deer, wings of a griffin and a dragon, body of a hipogryff, foot of a deer, foot of a lizard, tail of a dragon.  Hand of a lion, and hand of a hawk. n

Basically, Discord is total chaos.


I love the tree I love the thethe spirit of the tree of Harmony I love it I love when it made that funny face that is so funny you might become mad Pat someday for all we know you might be his son


“The next word that grogar spoke blew my mind”

O-O-O-O’REILYYYYYY AUTOPARTS

“The next word that grogar spoke blew my mind”

*O-O-O-O’REILYYYYYY AUTOPARTS*


I think that the theory that you finished on is corect and it makes the most sence both with the time line and in a if this world was real sence


Sawtooth you missed something with flurry heart and cadence since cadence is an alicorn  and she is married so flurry heart is born an alicorn


Y’all’s rival x friends situation is so cute


Maybe discord was a...failsafe?grogar was banished right?maybe discord was a seed of his own set by grogar!a last attempt to send the world plummeting into evil.


I think Discord WAS around before his first reign over Equestria, we just don't see or hear anything about it

I mean he couldn't have just popped up out of nowhere and caused that much chaos in the time it took for the Sisters to fight him, find the tree, and take the elements, right?

Besides every hero/villian needs to have a reason for doing the things they do - something had to push Discord enough to begin his fist reign


Me at first: wtf how did starswirl create a chaos god?!<br>Me later: ohhhhhh

Me at first: wtf how did starswirl create a chaos god?!
Me later: ohhhhhh


But if discord was pretending to be grogar to challenge twilight and he said he created many creatures then how did discord know did he hear story's ot did grogar create him?


Omg what if discord was supposed to give chaos's to palaces that needed it but was   mest up while being made buy what ever made him and turned into his own element


Sadly that Gorgar wasn't even real. It was Discord. Wap wap!


Sprit of harmony:hi nice to meet u!
Discord: teleport everywhere*
Spirit of harmony: TRIGGERED: UMM HELLO
Discord :still teleports*
Spirit of harmony:THAT'S IT

@Random person i think its cause its not that funny

Minecraft teleporting noise intensifies!

haha back to war and making equestria our playground battlefield


Hmm, Maybe Discord Was Like A Newborn Pony, That Star Swirl Experienced On, Trying To Make A Alicorn And It Went Wrong, Creating Discord.


so grogare made discord makes sens but when grogare lost magic he was discord and they said faked to be grogar so I'm curious about this


Nah, discords' status is akin to a God. He pretty much just the Loki of MLP.


Yeah I know I’m a year late, but you’re forgetting the Clash between Lord Terik and discord, though I’m sure many other people have address that in the comments.


What if Discord lived in the Nightmare realm but left because he didn’t want to be the ruled by a Bill after hearing what Bill did to his home dimension.


every single person in this universe makes theories and then there is me just watching theories and forgetting them the next day <:


But discord said he was alive for thousands of years


maybe discord was growing up, so the gap was just discord growing to be what he is


Half way through the video I thought about that ying and yang. 10 seconds later and you arrive to the same conclusion! Coincidence of thought or action it might be.


Discord Is a creature of pure chaos that’s why he was born from chaos .


Discord seems to be made from 7 colors like the 7 gems


A centuar is a Greek mythology creature which is the hybrid of a horse and a <b>human</b>

A centuar is a Greek mythology creature which is the hybrid of a horse and a *human*


Here’s a theory We now  Celestia and Luna Did it come from Equestria so maybe they already knew discord from their world and that’s where they banished him from


Did you know Discord actually has a sister name Eris? She first appeared in one of the mlp comics. It was quite a surprise to me when I found out! 😁

The comics aren't canon with the TV show.


Harmony is not Order. It's balance between Order and Chaos.


The creators just probably made a design and wanted to use it 😔


my theory ( it makes sense dude ) i actually think discord is very old like he haves been since the G1 MLP series or even before bc discord is a spirit hes inmortal and he’s caos and there was caos before G1 so discord is very but very old and i dont think he was created i think the caos made him and the fact he haves animal parts like grogar monsters doesnt make one of them because if we can remember when tirek took his magic away he didn’t split up like when twilight sparkle did with the other monsters that they actually split up and he knew how grogar actually was like the perfection and pretended to BE HIM and TELL exactly how he was defeated and BY WHO like discord actually was there because isn’t coincidence that discord knew every detail of grogar history and defeat so i think discord is the oldest and most powerful character...

fact: star swirl couldn’t had created him bc as i said discord is a spirit and spirits cant be created just summoned the fact that discord COULD have been summoned again and didnt appear on the G2 G3 series or G1 yo know stuff anyways even celestia said it “ spirit of chaos and dissarmony” bro spirits just can be summoned.

discord could have been before grogar and after but also summoned many time later like by accident or by itself so yeah that’s my theory.


What if discord was made from the collective chaos of the ponies like the doom in Rya the last dragon. This would explain why discord was freed by the CMC when they where arguing they where makeing chaos like in Rya where the tribes where makeing discord then broke the dragon orb then the doom appeared maybe the orb didnt break because it fall maybe it broke become of the discord Poland hate in the room (In how discord was made)


It all makes sense. Discord did end up being Grogar in the end. But, what if he said that, cause discord knew that Grogar created him, and discord knew it. And he said that, cause he was the first creature that Grogar created, so that's how he knew Grogar was responsible for the other creatures. This also got me thinking, what if Grogar creating tireks species. And then they mutipled and went off to a far land to gain power, and rule themselves instead of Grogar ruleing them. Back to discord, but, even though we know the reason why discord played as Grogar, how do you think he knew so much? More than that was in the legends. Because he was one of Grogars first creations. Discord knew more than what could be found in legends. No pony actually knew if Grogars bell was in the mountains, no pony even knew if Grogar was even real in the first place. Unless, they knew him personally. Which is why I think that theory is perfectly reasonable. But I have another. And yes it involves discord and Grogar.

Ok so, what if Grogar and discord are one in the same? Now here me out, here me out. What if, Grogar did create discord, and realized his power as the Lord of Chaos, and figured that he'd be more powerful with that Magic, and merged with discord using his Magic. And when discord said, "now they have all the real Grogars magic" That means they could have very well stolen Grogars magic that's inside discord, while stealing discords magic himself. And all along Grogar has been within discord with no way to escape. And by reforming discord, they reformed Grogar as well. And this while time, Grogar and discord are one in the same. That theory may not make as much sense as the other, but maybe, just maybe, it's true.

Or maybe Discord predates everything else like in Greek Mythology -- Chaos came first.


Sawtooth just cuz Discrod stopped causing chaos and darkness he still had chaos in his realm so he would not have faded away


I also thought grogar and discord were connected in some way


Well he got bored messing with Picard and left our universe to the equestrian parallel universe abandoning the Q continuum to live as a goat snake


Not possible that discord is born like that because I remembered that discord was playing with Celestia and Luna when the were young.


2:50 A Pegasus, a Unicorn, and an earth pony=Alicorn
Alicorn + Monsters=Discord
Discord is King Confirmed, get game theory to give me a reward.


I feel like discord has been in human version because if you watch all the movies there is magic roaming around but it may not be true


I think know I think discord was a connection of tree of harmony but twilight didn't know that  that's why  Celestia told the mane 6 to free him  but discord didn't know that too that's why he starts destroying ponyville


i disagree in the series it says discord is a draconequus


The person who's part of the studio making mlp who just made Discord out of boredom be like:  👁👄👁


Discord is my favorite mlp character, for some reason the reformed villians are my favorite😁


7:26 you forgot about his home in another dimension


i was thinking mabey discord was acctually some normal animals fused together by magic since he has different animal parts cause the animals may of been in a magical explosion or something that made them fuse together and the explosion was cause by chaos or mabey a fight and thats where discord got the magic and mabey if the creature gives the magic it turns into its normal form but if it is forcefully taken they may not be in a normal form/forms


I didn’t know you liked Undertale!

(He directly referenced their amalgamates by showing us Endogeny)


But didn't discord admit that he pretended to be grogar?


Like Grogar what he said he must haves created Discord and released him and he took over Equestria until Celestia and Luna turned him to stone and them they took rule of Equestria


well as you said harmony kind of need chaos for balance, so what if the world (aka earth)created discord to have balance to the world (i still don't know where he has been hiding all at time but still..


Idk if someone has already commented on my theory but here (even tho I'm like a few years late—)

What if, discord was an experiment, but his soul was found by someone powerful. So the powerful creature made discords soul into a body. But by the current timeline of the mane six, he must be like frozen before his first (I mean his actual first not the one in season 2) appearance.

Ik the first line sounds crazy but the other does indeed sound like it. If u could, Sawtooth, could u make a vid on this?
Btw love ur vids!!

Idk if someone has already commented on my theory but here (even tho I'm like a few years late—)

What if, discord *was* an experiment, but his soul was found by someone powerful. So the powerful creature made discords soul into a body. But by the current timeline of the mane six, he must be like frozen before his first (I mean his actual first not the one in season 2) appearance.

Ik the first line sounds crazy but the other does indeed sound like it. If u could, Sawtooth, could u make a vid on this?
Btw love ur vids!!


He was looking for his creator (Starswirl)


Me: Watching Equestria girls with my sisters
Me: Looks at phone and sees upload
Me: YASSSSSSSS!!!!!
My sisters: Are you OK?

Me: *Watching Equestria girls with my sisters*
Me: *Looks at phone and sees upload*
Me: YASSSSSSSS!!!!!
My sisters: Are you OK?


big tooth lizard is discord’s nickname from now on


Discord must have invaded some other land before equestrea


What if discord was already created and star swirl made him better?


What if discord was the mistake of the show much like his nature


Hey, I really love your theories and songs. New Pair of Wings keeps getting stuck in my head and since Mlp is gonna end, I have one last question..

Will you make a last song?

I'm so glad you appreciate my music. I do have more original music planned 😊 I used the instrumental for one of them in the outro of this video, and another one in the last outro


I think discord is a mix of many animals and chaos stuck him together but... he was trapped in another dimension until the tree emerged.


didn't discord exist before the mane 6 did? cause I saw an episode where Celestia introduced discord using the glasspanes


Harmony != Order;
Chaos != Disharmony;
According to Ing-Yang Dark+Light=Chaos(Change)+Order(Save)=Harmony=*THE GREAT GOOD*.
And Disharmony=Domination=Evil.

Данил Фёдоров


Sorry for the new comment but I’m the Tirek comic we can see Discord in the throne room and he’s older than Tirek and Scorpan because the comic is when they were around teenage years. So maybe he’s as old as Equestrian itself maybe an ancient being.


Alright, I am really sorry to see this white now after two years but I just found out of your account and there's something I should thought before I saw this video..... I always noticed that there was something wrong with Discord, and I didn't know why he wants to be angel like to have friends ponies, and at the same time to be evil like, having fun with someone who can't trust! I mean look at his face when he team up with Lord Tirek.... And I didn't really know how does he exists in my little pony... But after I watched this I can't understand who actually made Discord. STAR SWIRL OR GROGAR.  I mean star swirl really look like the person who will make him I mean there is no one that don't makes mistakes some times, and the grogar look like his brother or dad. That is actually not Important they look like family but there is maybe sense that Discord can't decade of angel or evil. That's now pretty clear, but I still don't know who make him....


I think Tirek is a mix of miniatour ( I do not know how to spell) and a demon


Kinda like how u said the tree of harmony made discord so it kinda created him


I found something discord was actually Groger the whole time right now


Isn't discord a pony i mean he said it himself in one episode that he was part pony what if he was the first pony but got messed up and ended up being who is i mean he is an immortal right???


/Timeline\

Long while later, Discord pertands to be Grogar

|Discord is reformed|
Mane six save equeastra
Discord returns
Mane six save equeastra
Nightmear Moon returns
Cleastria rules alone
Nightmear Moon
Normal
Sombra
Royal sisters rule equeastra
Discord apeers and takes over equeastra
Tree of Harmony is planted
Everfree forest
Friendship fire
Windgos
Tribe's trade
Growgar's rule

Farms and pasters

/Timeline\

-Long while later, Discord pertands to be Grogar-

|Discord is reformed|
_Mane six save equeastra_
*Discord returns*
_Mane six save equeastra_
*Nightmear Moon returns*
_Cleastria rules alone_
*Nightmear Moon*
_Normal_
*Sombra*
_Royal sisters rule equeastra_
*Discord apeers and takes over equeastra*
_Tree of Harmony is planted_
*Everfree forest*
_Friendship fire_
*Windgos*
_Tribe's trade_
*Growgar's rule*

-Farms and pasters-

Vilan returns (in two parters) | AKA
                                                                    (V2 means verson 2 or came back for the 2nd time.)
Nightmear Moon | NMM, The mear in the moon
Discord | Spirit of chaos

Queen Chrisalis | Chrisalis, The Changeling queen
King Sombra | Sombra
Tireck | Lord Tireck
Starlight Glimmer | Starlight
Pony Of Shadows
Cozy Glow | Cozy, CG
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NMM, Discord, Chrisalis, Sombra, Tireck, Starlight, Starlight v2, Chrisalis v2, Pony of Shadows, Cozy, |Chrisalis, Tireck, Sombra, Cozy and 'Grogar'|, |Chrisalis, Cozy and Tireck (and Windagose) |


I know this lore has a bit of sense but GROGAR IS THE LORD OF EVIL AND DISCORD IS THE LORD OF CHAOS.... HOW OR WHY DID GROGAR EVEN MAKE A CREATURE AS POWERFUL AS HIM?!?!?!?!      IM SO GOOD AT THIS THANK YOU YOUR WELCOME or what if GROGAR and discord are sibling's? Maybe you could help me solve that kind of lore pleaseeeee

Shadow Freddy Fazbear The Ruler we can clearly see from season 1, he is quite powerful maybe even more powerful than his “brother” Grogar since he had to create other monsters to help him keep his raid. So with that we can kinda come with a conclusion that Discord might have ruled all alone since no other being was stronger than him and with that mindset he came to equestria and was defeated by the elements of the harmony.

@yt user  that could make sense but if Discord ruled other worlds...wouldn't he bring the army to the world of (idk how to spell it) and would have taken over a long time ago and it would bring more questions than answers

Shadow Freddy Fazbear The Ruler Maybe discord ruled in other worlds but after his brother raid stoped ,he came to this world to continue it but at that time the elements of the harmony already existed so he got defeated....

xxx LIZZIA_18 xxx That can make sense but why didn't they rule together? Also if they were brothers and they had to practice their magic to be that powerful. And if they were why didn't anybody notice them rising. I do agree with you but it brings more questions.


But didn’t discord always say he is eons old and or billions of years old or something like that? Or do you think he was just being chaotic and lying about his age?


Discord was a baby when star swirl created him when star swirl got banished to limbo discord grew and thought somepony did this to star swirl discord looked everywhere and he found ponyvill he thought somepony there banished star swirl to limbo so he turned it into the chaos capital of equestria


What if discord is a poltergeist generated by all the chaos in Equestria?


What if starswirl created growgar and growgar created discord  but how did discord  know where the tree was in the episode where you know who tried to steal everybody's magic I thin your theory about the tree creating discord could be right


What if...

Discord = Apophis
Spirt of harmony = Ra

(I've been thinking about mythology to much)

Since Ra is a sun god, then Celestia  must be Ra's equivalent

I thought about that too, but wouldn't it make more sense for Celestia to be Ra, since she's the princess of the sun, as well as being a symbol of order? From a meta perspective, I doubt that the writers had plans for the series this far out when they were writing Discord's debut in season 2, so it makes more sense that a mythological inspiration for Discord would only relate to information we received early on in the series. The backstory of Discord ruling the world in chaos until the sun goddess (kind of) Celestia defeated him to restore order to the world relates more to the myth than just the order/chaos connection between Discord and the spirit of harmony.

I know Luna was also there; Khonsu, the Egyptian moon god has nothing to do with this legend, but Discord has always been more associated with Celestia anyway.

My sis has been going on a Disney tirade,  so all I can think of is this.
Discord:mauwi
Tree:heart
Twilight:mowana
...I'm sorry!!! She's been watching the movie all day every day! I love it, but too mucccchhhhh dissssssnnneyyyyyy. ...

Nooooo... That's absolutely reasonable! I side with you!
Discord = Coyolchalqui = Veles = Lankalua
Harmony = Huitzilopochtli = Perun = Maui ...
And so on!


But didn’t tirek know who discord was in season 4?


I'm a really big fan of you Sawtooth Waves but can  you make a video about applejack because I want to know how she got her strength


What if discord was invented by a evil  power  then converted into  stone by good power and then it got Freed again after soo much time


im at 1:28 and i can say that (im pretty sure) he came from stone soooooooooooo wasn't he banished before?


Is no one else bothered by the fact he’s saying “yong” not “yAng”?

@Kenedy Russell isn't it Chinese? I'm confused

Oh I got VERY triggered when he said that 😅

I don't watch My Little Pony anymore but I still watch him he's funny and there's some cool stuff you can think about

@Kenedy Russell It's Chinese. The pronunciation of Yang is akin to a mix of a and u.

I literally went looking for this comment after the first time he said it lol 😂🤣

First of all thats how its pronounced<br>Secondly he's technically saying yAHng not Yong

First of all thats how its pronounced
Secondly he's technically saying yAHng not Yong

Chloe Spencer Yin and Yang is, as we all know, a Japanese term and so, it’s pronounced differently than English. A is ah, E is eh, I is ee, O is oh, and U is oo

That's the actual pronunciation of it though. Yang is what us English speakers started to pronounce it because that's how it's spelled.


I think I know ok there is my way to explain I think maybe stars swirl did create discord that yes there timeline will  be disconnected but like the sonic season shadow was created so he was there in the container and doctor eggman open it and then he got revived maybe this is the same thing with this good star swirl made him but when he was gone then discord wasn't fully made with magic you know that discordis full of surprises so without enough magic discord wasn't alive then when the tree of harmony came discord toke some of the magic from the tree because the tree had enough magic to fill discovered I hope you understand love your videos bye


Ohh this must be correct, since in the new movie, the tree have no magic again, thats how discord dissapeared


Grogar is Discord and in the last episode Discord reunited as a  good person, demon, pony, whatever you call him but tgis is just my opinion.


I thought Discord was created just like the Chaos gods in Warhammer 40k


well... if the tree of harmony was a seed planted the where was discord when the tree was a sapling? And what was discord then at the time i mean the tree had officially come to life then that means discord was alive to right? If not then how on EARTH was HARMONY and CHAOS BALANCED. And what was balancing it at the time i mean those questions were left behind but who on earth am i to judge its not like i'm SANS heehee anyway i hope you read this when you're not doing anything but thanks anyway. From your #2 fan ZOE


Your right discord must have came to be because of the tree of harmony


Grogar is just an old blue goat that is evil!


Maybe Starswirl made an egg and then it hatch and Discord was there, or maybe Discord was involving after the tree of harmany was made :v


Me at 1:42 "What id discord had to grow and develop his powers after he was created? Or, what if StarSwirl trapped him, but he escaped?


I have a theory of my own what if luna and celestia aren't real what if they spirits and there reference as 'sisters' is actually refiring to opposites, because they are complete opposite but still bring balance  maybe that leads to being immortal and when they retired they went to a kind of spirit world and still rose the sun and moon , and maybe other alicorn's when transformed are destined to be spirits and bring balance when they find there opposites


How many times did Sawtooth say ''Chaos'' in this video


We now know that Grogar was discord but perhaps he still created discord, why he knows what grogar looks like imply he knew grogar maybe as a young chaos child as grogar maybe new about his impending banishment he made discord to cause chaos as revenge till he may get free possibly the spirit of harmony was a cause of discords existence both needed time to grow the tree as a sapling and discord learning his magic


I have nothing original to say. You just blew my mind. Again. You blow my mind in each of your videos. And that's awesome. What else, I've gotta say something you and your subscribers don't know. Yet, I have nothing else to say.


discord is not created by grogar because when he got his magic soaked by grogars bell me was in one peice


What if Discord was waiting to get stronger


I love you but video so much I appreciate the fact that you like to make us new things everyday


What if discord was made from chaos from back then from every creature.


I have a theory: what if Discord IS GROGAR IN DISGUISE?!  I don't think I should list why though
Ok, fine I will.
1: Grogar and Discord both are very powerful
2: Grogar and Discord were both around at the same time
And 3: Discord could disguise himself as Grogar

season 9:grogar is discord in disguise<br>you:discord is grogar in disguise

season 9:grogar is discord in disguise
you:discord is grogar in disguise


Star Swirl still might have created Discord because the two Alicorn sisters, celestia and luna turned Dicord to stone when they cast a spell on him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


By who and how long.... did discord have a voice in his head? OH MAN ITS ALL COMING TOGETHER!

Like if you got this reference!


2:40 i will edit this when i find a way to brake this theory. ok got it if it was multiple beings then they would all have consisnece not just the one of them. Evidence: simple, the snake, goat, tiger, thing.


My theory: a deer, dragon, horse, snake and Pegasus, they married eachother, and then a weird figure came out of the tummy of the horse, lol.


All these theory things of different shows, I swear the creator just noticed this themselves after watching these videos


What if grogard made him we know there is more land not only equeastria or he was weak like Teri know was


i really like how sawtooth discibes franshship


“So that’s why I’m hesitant to subscribe to that theory”
Subscribe button has joined the chat
The Brony Notion:😐

“So that’s why I’m hesitant to subscribe to that theory”
*Subscribe button has joined the chat*
The Brony Notion:😐


i think discord was turned into moon or something and when he came out it was very late i think starlsward mad discord


Well one thing I know discord definetly doesn't have parents


But how did terek knew about discord if terek was before discord’s time


Pupper Pocket covered all pawsibilities ? Fur real? Bow wow that's a first<br>.

Pupper Pocket covered all pawsibilities ? Fur real? Bow wow that's a first
.


Well Discord said multiple times that he is REALLY OLD like "eons" and "centuries" so I always assumed that he must be older than the Princesses. Also Tirek known Discord, because when they met after his return he recognizes him, and the dude was banished to tartarus before the tree of harmony grew. And I doubt that he had a pen pal back hen, because he didn't know about the fourth princess.<br>I always thought it was weird hat if Discord was the only one of his kind, that ponies would have a species name for him. Wouldn't he be just... Discord? I think that draconequuses must have existed somewhere (and maybe got extinct or just live somewhere else) and becoming the spirit of chaos was like a royal thing, like becoming an alicorn? Or maybe all of them are equally powerful but Discord is the only one who made it to Equestria.  Also before his first apperance in Equestria, Discord could have travelled between dimentions and spread chaos in different realms of reality, I mean his home is in some kind of chaotic pocket dimention. He can have more worlds to be in, which could explain why he is sometimes absent from major Equestria events (like the ENTIRE MOVIE, SERIOUSLY WHY CELESTIA DIDN'T ASK HIM FOR HELP UUUGH).

Well Discord said multiple times that he is REALLY OLD like "eons" and "centuries" so I always assumed that he must be older than the Princesses. Also Tirek known Discord, because when they met after his return he recognizes him, and the dude was banished to tartarus before the tree of harmony grew. And I doubt that he had a pen pal back hen, because he didn't know about the fourth princess.
I always thought it was weird hat if Discord was the only one of his kind, that ponies would have a species name for him. Wouldn't he be just... Discord? I think that draconequuses must have existed somewhere (and maybe got extinct or just live somewhere else) and becoming the spirit of chaos was like a royal thing, like becoming an alicorn? Or maybe all of them are equally powerful but Discord is the only one who made it to Equestria.  Also before his first apperance in Equestria, Discord could have travelled between dimentions and spread chaos in different realms of reality, I mean his home is in some kind of chaotic pocket dimention. He can have more worlds to be in, which could explain why he is sometimes absent from major Equestria events (like the ENTIRE MOVIE, SERIOUSLY WHY CELESTIA DIDN'T ASK HIM FOR HELP UUUGH).

@Sawtooth Waves I asumed that he was a stone for just over a thousand years, so right before Nightmare Moon. Because princesses never used the elements between theese two events (if they did there would be a  stained glass depicting it in season2) And "eons" is way more than thousands, its more than millenias even, that's what influenced my thinking. He also said to Fluttershy in season 5 that he is "centuries old" as an argument of him having other long-time friends, and that would not make sense if he had spent all that centuries turned into stone, rigth after his creation (and Fluttershy would be the first pony to know how old he acutally is)... But who knows. I would love to know more about Discord and not only have him as a semi-anthagonist of the episode cousing trouble to his friends. Why the others can not learn something from him? The only episode that did it reeeeaaaaly rigth was Discordant Harmony.

Your idea that he was stirring chaos in other dimensions is really interesting and makes a lot of sense! Your other points aren't necessarily contradictions though. If discord is as young as I proposed, that's still very very old. Before nightmare moon! And as for how Tirek knew of him, Discord gave no indication of being familiar with Tirek, so it may have been a one way thing. Remember that Tirek escaped Tartarus once Ceburus left his post in season 2. This would have given him plenty of time to learn about discord, and perhaps even see the statue, all before twilight became a princess at the end of season three.

Poke DESTROYS Brony Notion's THEORY video in less than 24 HOURS using FACTS and REFERENCES


Sawtooth: Grogar<br>Subtitles: girl guard


Something tell me that discord is a lot more powerful than grogar why?? When pinkie took discord power out of the bell she says this after: i will transform the cosmos so everything is made of icing: transforming the cosmos if grogar had more power than discord he maybe could turn the cosmos to destruction or something he likes don't forget grogar created monsters by combining creatures and give them power but discord he creats life out of the non living in the end we know discord creat a creature of sometype a pineapple monster if grogar's stronger than discord he should've summon infinite creature lol idk


Sawtooth: Not Starswirl the bearded, but he is just as old.
Me: GARGO!
Sawtooth: and that person is Grogar.
Me: XD


What If star swill did make him well inside tartiris but being so chaos filled discord was able to escape


11:26 the mlp game says that discord Is “chaotic neutral”.

@Sandro Sixarulidze nice to see somebody gets it👍😃

@Fresh2000 ZCORD Exactly my thoughts! Though I do not consider people who looked over his heroic act as anyone who really watches this show, or understands Discords character. I do believe that both, his Grogar roleplay and risking self to save friends are truest representation of his chaotic goodness. Doing something stupid no one has ever expected, to do good and risking own life whilst having no magic juice and tricking 3 most powerful creatures in Equestria in that moment to save friends. If this 2 actions are not the best representation of what chaotic good is, than I can't imagine what chaotic good is.

@Sandro Sixarulidze true he had character development in a slow burn way he never stopped being well chaotic and etc but he changed in ways overtime sadly because of the grogar twist people look over how he risked his life to help the mane 5 and spike escape which he wouldn't have done in his first appearance for no one.

just thought about, it seems like his character changed over time from chaotic bad, through chaotic neutral to chaotic good. He wasn't really chaotic good until last season but his character was slowly moving towards it.

Hes chaotic neutral with some traits of Chaotic Good as he ultimately resides with the Good Guys even if he has some "edge" to him


Maybe discord needed to get more power like terik


At his home till he new there were more worlds before he was good he wanted them all


Maybe he was made when the 3 kind of ponys weren't friends.


I 99.5% agree with u and .5% the grogar theroy


if discord and the tree oh im sorry the "spirit of harmony" had a fight im guessing discord would try hard and lose

@Sawtooth Waves giving how powerful each are and now that the tree's... DANG IT I DID IT AGAIN sorry the "sprite of harmony"
full potential has been realized (Or has it? is the spirit of harmony its final form.....) i think if discord went evil again i think it would use all its power it try to help discord going as far as to use other species and not just ponies to try to help but i could be wrong

P.S. Thanks for the heart your channel is one of my favorites


Tree Hoger is the one who created Discord


I think peaple did Discord accidentally, they did chaos like Flutterhy in that episode, so Discord was being formed!!!!


He was made befo limbo because he was waiting for his dad then he tried to make him prod with taking over or he did say and call grogar "dear old dad -discord


That makes a lot of sense but we don't have any solid proof that harmony and chaos are like yin and yang


Where was he during that in between said time? I don’t know, something tells me roaming the numerous dimensional layers. Just a hunch!

he had a whole own dimension to make a chaos islands in it!

Michael Williams that very well could be plausible. Why would he just stick around in the land of Equestria? Definitely more for him to explore and live in.


я думая он появился вместе со вселенной. сам хаос как никак. а ещё я думаю что возможно всех злодеев сериала достовал из закрамов он дабы научить твайлайт нормально справляться с трудностями. типо хоть он и выглядит дурачком желающим только веселится  на самом деле он поумнее и ращётливее селестии.


I don’t think it’s true  but I think discord may have been created unknown and he is the only one of his kind now he may have came from a different realm that is unknown and had spawn there when he was a baby because he is mix in with a lot of thinks like a bird a dragon a snake and a pony plus a ram and a deer.... 🤔🤔 and I don’t know we’re he got hiss magic from


I think that its yin and yang because he looked like he was just born and the tree of harmony was his mom or dad because there must have been a normal tree then they fell in love and had discord as there one and only child and maybe he dosnt like his mom or dad (the tree of harmony) because it always destroys his work and he must have been a kid at that time


What a friendship when if a villain took friendship


Woah, that's deep. Really makes you think...

Also, hell yeah! Discord best boy!


Excuse me for crossing fandoms, but the Q Continuum got sick of Q's shenanigans and exiled him to Equestria.


But when the two sisters turned him too stone he said he planted the tree. When the the tree broke she drinks the thing and there you see he did it soo<br> hmmmmmmmmmm

But when the two sisters turned him too stone he said he planted the tree. When the the tree broke she drinks the thing and there you see he did it soo
 hmmmmmmmmmm


8:43

I’m-I’m sorry to burst your bubble But cold does not exist I’m sorry but it’s true cold is literally the lack of heat it’s the lack of heat not cold so yeah sorry


He was stone because the true show of discord when he came out of stone because the cutie mark Crusaders got him out of stone


Maybe when the tree of harmony was created a little of  Grogers magic must have created discord


Sawtooth waves  he may have sent to tarnris or  the princess  may have turned him to stone


Maybe Discord is same age with Tia and Lun.


what if well, im dumb so this is all i think. maybe their was no chaos for the time being, so all the kings or queens of harmony or something created discord because like you said, harmony needs chaos to live or something. and also because discord has like, all the different ponys as one. soooo, yeah


The making of discord was probably discoordinated


5:05
GALLUSTREAM!!! Woohoo! Shipping the ‘griffs! That’s how it’s done!
(I may be getting too excited that TheBronyNotion showed Gallus and Silverstream together...)

5:05
GALLUSTREAM!!! Woohoo! Shipping the ‘griffs! That’s how it’s done!
-(I may be getting too excited that TheBronyNotion showed Gallus and Silverstream together...)-


Chaos and harmony can be equal
As  twilight get her castle discord  can  be
Good or bad
Chaos mean good or bad


what if. Star Swirl did create Discord before them both but he created baby discord! that would help the timeline placement


The first time I saw discord was when the princesses retired


"Grogar create discord" ... after the s9 final "well ..."

“...llew” lanif eht retfa ... “drocsid etaerc ragorG”


If Grogar created discord how can Grogar have chaos and which he would give


Issue #75 (and it's subsequent parts) seem to (heavily) suggest that Discord is not from Equestria. He existed in an external dimension of chaos on his own until meeting Cosmos. Together, they traveled dimensions, settling at last on Equestria because Cosmos had a strange liking for it. This arc also explains that the Everfree Forest is a result of the aftermath of Cosmos's unbridled power. Not even Discord was able to reverse all the effects of her reign. If you haven't read it yet, I highly recommend you do. There are places you can read it free. This theory still can hold up, though, because it is possible that what drew the chaotic couple to Equestria in the first place was the overwhelming harmony. Great theories!


lol i think loads of people have the grogar theory


Honestly Discord is Discord and Discord be Discord. I can't believe that makes sense, what is the Discord count?


Me: leaving area 51 raid with the nowlage of where discord came from
All mlp theorists ....
I DONT NEED SLEEP! I NEED ANSWERS!

Me too!!!! Just by watching dis one videoಠ‿ಠ


your overlooking something... DISCORD WAS TRAPED IN STONE


But discord said he's attended college with the smooze...


celestia took the elements from stone how did they go back in stone? comment if u have a answer and like if ur confused


bruh watch back my little pony 1st generation, they have humans before and yes they have grogar, scorpan and tirek in it but not discord and chrysalis


I think that discord is grogar and<br>When he got banished not all his magic didn’t go with him and some of that magic formed  discord

I think that discord is grogar and
When he got banished not all his magic didn’t go with him and some of that magic formed  discord

@It's Daxx I dont really get the Pony-of-Shadows-was-Nightmare-Moon's-leftover-powers theory, cuz it doesnt add up. But I do think it was the leftovers of <b>Grogar's</b> . The Pony of Shadows's goal and purpose fits Grogar to a tea

@It's Daxx I dont really get the Pony-of-Shadows-was-Nightmare-Moon's-leftover-powers theory, cuz it doesnt add up. But I do think it was the leftovers of *Grogar's* . The Pony of Shadows's goal and purpose fits Grogar to a tea

@logan bair when Nightmare moon was banished, some of her power remained. And it came upon Stigian. Creating the pony of shadows. Because the limbo thing could have happened around when Celstia had to banish Luna. And thats how Stigian found the shadows. In that one episode where the main 6 went to the old castle ruins, its mentioned that not all of Nightmare moon was banished (this is a tall tale but its highly likely considering how this world functions).

So it is possible that grogar when banished, not all of him went. And some of his power of destruction remained. Which would explain why discord was able to copy his appearance and voice detail for detail and use that goats eye orb thing. But who knows.

@logan bair it's like the pony of shadows was formed by luna

that makes sense but how would grogar's magic form discord


I know this has nothing to do with mlp but in mlb (miraculous ladybug) that part where they showed like discord and the spirit of harmony fighting is like tikki and plagg AND they are both opposite


Discord:the yin of yin-yang
But..
Astral Twilight:the yang of yin-yang


I think discord is the re incarnated grogour.


But isn't grogar just discord???

Im so confused 😢


How would he know about the tree if he was just made


Me jamming out to the end music be 💣 BOMB 💣


Wait what? You are wrong with  Yin and yang ,chaos and harmony
Discord is a spirit of CHAOS
The tree of harmony is spirit of HARMONY NOT ORDER !!!
Harmony is combination of elements working together
Balance is a state in which opposing forces are equal

The opposite of chaos is order not harmony

Harmony would be if chaos and order worked together
Balance would be if chaos and order were equal but not necessary work together


Hmm.. this video reminded me of danganropa. “Harmony, chaos” “hope, despair”


11:30 An endless sea saw back and forth what if it stop at one side no balance?


Or discord was formed by some kind of powerful chaos made by the did harmony of friends


Discord is  opposite of neatness or order maybe ever since they were his order discord came to be


Thought: Event HoriXZ0n said that Faust said That Discord was a Mistake made by Equestria.
What if Equestria is also it''s own entity. one that made all the differing species, to create harmony in it'self? headed by the meekest, yet strongest species: the Ponies? simply makeing some by mistake?

also, another thought: it was said that Discord was also a ruler of Equestria for a short time, before going nuts, and letting his chaos go. what if this was the point that Celestia and Luna became the rulers of Equestria? Furthermore it was never said that Celestia and Luna were needed before they were born. so, what if the sun and moon being stuck and only moved by the Royal sisters was a side-effect of Discords reign? or, perhaps those powers were given by the fledgling tree to Celestia and Luna as part of a greater purpose? to balance out the Yin and Yang of other magical forces?


So close yet so so  far growgar IS discord


sawtooth waves:but he did'nt split into a horse and a a uh a but he didn't split into any components "nailed it": thats funny


But gorar is discord didn't you see the video he used his cases magic to transform him into gograr


Maybe without he’s “owner” he went on to evil side..LOGICCccCcCcC


He literally said in the bride of discord he said he was born


So in the end starzwirl really create discord!!😂😂


I had a dream where there was a new video on how celestia was a war goddess...<br>Sadly it did not come true.

I had a dream where there was a new video on how celestia was a war goddess...
Sadly it did not come true.


Sawtooth: And Tirek didn't split into a horse and a.... and a....?


🤯 we haven’t seen 9 yet but this makes so much sense


I Think There Was More Like Discord Long Ago But Since Discord Was Turned Rock Maybe By Time They all died Altough What I'm Sayng Doesnt Make Much Sense But I Tried.


I think discord came from the spirit wanting to not be lonely so it created discord, but discord decided to rebel and therefore cast the spirit to be bound to the tree until six ponies(or creatures) that represent the elements to free it

This takes place in the beginning. I imagine that the spirit of harmony was first. And that the tree that was planted by the first six represents the tree that the spirit was trapped for what if discord actually destroyed the tree during his reign and a new one was planted so he tried destroying that one

This is a weird theory but at least I tried TwT

Oh God I saw the finale. So erm I think this theory is busted


I'v heard that before Princess Celestia and Luna came to Equestria Discord Rulled until the Princesess deafeted him.


8:42 cold technically doesn't exist /lh (according to my earth science teacher at least)


At one point he said Tartarus and I heard tardis and I got excited


🎶🎵🎶 I can’t sit I mean I can’t move at all I cures the name the one behind it aaaaaaaall, Discord I’m howling at the moon and sleeping in the middle of a summer afternoon, discord whatever did we do to make u take our world away?!🎵🎶🎵


I think the creature world wiki might help

I still confused why he has a  species when he's the only one like literally. I'm not trying to be mean but why when just calling him Discord is simple and is his name.....


Hey sawtooth i have somethiny for starswirl created discord

If starswirl did create discord he problly put him in a temporary place for a while which broke when he went in limbo
And then discord attacted equistra as revenge for being isolated for so long and kaotic was his only thing/powres


Maybe discords dad IS grogar... Cuz when u look closely into discords and grogars eyes look same so may be grogar is discords fater


well in ep 17 s9 discord said to the mane 6 "i knew the 2 sisters for longer than any of you i use to torment them they turned me in to stone" so i dont think the tree made him but it might have something to  do with him taking over...

I haven't seen any episode that hasn't aired in the U.S. yet. But if that's all he says about that, it's not in conflict with the tree causing his existence. Twi's flashback in s4 already told us that much anyway.

I noticed that too in the new episode and your totally right.


Disparity, dark souls intro cutscene show that disparity brings change and deviation comparisons and how the world can rock back and forth.


I just thought he was the mistake between a like ninthsum of nine different animals


I see the scorpions alive because of the tree of Harmony because light and dark cannot exist without each I think this is true because you said your video and I


But in the episode in the gallping galla wear discord brought a slime ...Discord said I'm about a 100000000000 years old


"A whole other person-"
*spits out tea*
Me: you mean a whole other ram..

"A whole other person-"
**spits out tea**
Me: you mean a whole other ram..

@froggy OMGGGGG yours is just a little brighter than mine


Sooooo did the tree of harmony summoned discord or did it created discord?


Me:
The app Discord is chaotic

Discord is chaotic

Boom

Me:
The app Discord is chaotic

Discord is chaotic

*Boom*


I saw this and for a sec I thought it was discord chat until he called the pony thing discord watching in 2020 btw


But didn’t discord plant the seeds before


discord planed seeds that was takeing magic from the tree


4:01
iF I CaNt HaVE tHiS tHeRoY tHaN nEiThEr CaN dR WoLf
(ze evil laugh)


This there could be true but discord could also be from when the tree of harmony was planted because discord might of had to grow up so he was still a teen when he firt aperd  cuz it could varry well still be a Ying yang thing but discord had to grow up with the tree of harmony


I just realised that last theory is the <b>ENTIRE MORAL OF MY FUTURE SHOW.</b>

I just realised that last theory is the *ENTIRE MORAL OF MY FUTURE SHOW.*

Me: Is anyone watching in 2020<br>Comments: You and a lot more people

Me: Is anyone watching in 2020
Comments: You and a lot more people


why didn't Discord take over Equestria when he was created?


Maybe tirek would have split into a goat,monkey,and a horse


I dont even like MLP anymore, yet here I am

@Sawtooth Waves i just love your channel tbh. It makes me nostalgic about the time I would binge your channel


Yung? I've ALWAYS heard it said y-A-ng. Even form my sensei said it yin and y-A-ng. Huh.


This is what Discord is: ThE Dr6coN3qUuS 5plrT Of Cha0s!!!1!11111!!!!!!!!!!!

(I tried to make it look as chaoic as posible.)

This is what Discord is: ThE Dr6coN3qUuS -5plrT- Of Cha0s!!!1!11111!!!!!!!!!!!

(I tried to make it look as chaoic as posible.)


Uh when u said grogar made discord should all the cobinations he made was the only ones cuz when you think of it there is only 1 cerberus 1 mandicor and a driconiques and the rest of animals he made so im not sure....... but when grogar was in tarturus i was thinking he created discord there and made him go to equestria to destroy it so discord was stone when grogar was in tarturus orrrrrr idk


But... t rek is actually a Minotaur...<br>At least that’s what queen crystilis said

But... t rek is actually a Minotaur...
At least that’s what queen crystilis said


Sawtooth: where was discord                                   me:May he was an egg or a baby?


Discords a hybrid mix of cat,dog,dino,chicken,a bird,horse and MYTHICAL CREATURES


Ik im late to this video but what if celeatia banished discord for 100 years like nightmare moon but at the time celestia didnt think discord would come back so she never mentioned it to anypony


I love how you tried too destroy Dr. Wolf’s theory.


Discord was busy making his world when he came to mlp he was done making his world!


My thoughts are that what if discord is not created and he is simply born and he have mom and dad, he is lord of chaos which means there must be more chaos, and he is a chaos mean that his parents must be chaos


You know I think that the tree of harmony made him I know that’s crazy but I don’t care


maybe... discord was in some egg or some thing... not fully grow... until the time line


The Brony Noition Uploads
Me: Puts Crack In Screen Clicking The Notification

Edit:Nani I Got A Heart

*The Brony Noition Uploads*
Me: *Puts Crack In Screen Clicking The Notification*

Edit:Nani I Got A Heart


DISCORD AND EVENT are powerful monsters. evil and mean.


Sawtooth putting a note that says “oops!” In the background of the video.
Me: Hi!

(Pls tell me someone understands😭)


actually sawtooth I have the satisfying answer ;) I'm ready to spill the tea :)))) but warning it's a bit dark...


sawtooth: There are lots of hybrids in this world

my mind:Sawtooth waves and MatPat hybrid


Your like the film theory of my little pony lol


Maybe discord just hung around in some other dimentions :|


sawtooth waves i have a question for you

where did you watch season 9 of my little pony????????


I'm shaking watching this lol<br>this happens all the time when your new vids come out lol

I'm shaking watching this lol
this happens all the time when your new vids come out lol


Do you think discord exists in the human world


Sawtooth waves maybe there were a species of juconaquises then they were got killed then discord became the last one


I know I'm a year late but what about discord's cousin, Princess Eris? She probably has a part in this, right?


Watching gameplay of one of my favorite games with one of my channels playing said game

Sees notification that Brony Notion uploaded a video

Drops everything and watches this video

*Watching gameplay of one of my favorite games with one of my channels playing said game*

*Sees notification that Brony Notion uploaded a video*

*Drops everything and watches this video*


your mix opposites hear. chaos is the opposite of order not harmony. harmony is what is depicted by the yin yang symbol.


Maybe my little pony life has some lore. Just joking there’s nothing


what if discord was created by the tree of harmony whenever something good is created it creates its oppisite that wut i thiink i have more details on that but im pretty sure u said that in this theory


11:15 to 11:21| Lawful, Neutrel, Chaotic .,., Good. Neutrel, Evil


THE NEW EPISODE SHOWS THAT DISCORD IS GROGAR


Bruh Grogar is discord 🙂if you dont know the villains take grogars bell and suck up his magic and turns into discord


butt we must remember discord is not from Equestria realm he is from a completely different world


One word where discord may had been

✨limbo✨


May be there's a dryconoques civilization because discord is his name but dryonoques is his species.


When I think of Discord, I'm actually thinking of the app named Discord...

Discord is that awesome that even one of app has his name.


I think 🤔 discord is just a chacther to make the show more interesting so there might be no meaning to discord .He is just I don't know discord.


Wait you know the shadow Pony I think that's Discord just think about it


You keep saying ‘where was discord’, maybe he was in a different planet or something, coursing chaos there, after all, he must of gotten a bit bored, just causing chaos in just the other planets


Discord is made out of chaos shouldn’t he have some differences


Elon musk
Loved the song discord  and the character
So he named it after the song!


Uh for the people who might have saw my comment about how discord also could have been made I haven’t watched 3:27 yet (sorry people I didn’t realise that this was already a theory😳


Yen yawn means the “dragon” and the tiger so you may have a point


I theory to ruin your game(I don’t want to ruin your game I just thought it would be a cool name sorry)

What if I repeat what if

Discord has existed for years moons centuries(i’m pretty sure I watched the video well I know I watch the video on how long noons are but I don’t remember it was a long time ago sorry)
 He just never had a reason to come to Equestria

Think about it if everything was balanced by ponies what would he have any reason to come over there he can travel through dimensions what would make him want to come to a pony world?

A force of harmony and content maybe?

A big power for the opposite reason that he wants?

Something full of Harmony?

The elements of harmony?

The tree of harmony maybe?

Maybe he just wanted to take over is a good in that world so he went over there and started to take it over

now what would the ponies have to do?

Use the elements of harmony to freeze him because they don’t know what he is so named him discord for the lack of instruction and following the rules think about it discord is a weird name but discord is weird it makes sense just like scorpion(first name I thought of)
Sounds kind of aggressive but scorpions can attack good with their tail think about it doesn’t that make logical sense as well as your own theory and I am so happy you said this because it’s true it could’ve been true but my theory also could’ve been true so now you just have to figure out which one makes more logical sense hope you enjoy reading comments


bruh I clicked on this thinking it was about the app discord


In my little pony I didn't know that discord was that


Before Brony Notion uploded a video:I’m tired,I need to catch some sleep.<br>After Brony Notion uploads a video:WHO NEEDS SLEEEP ?!

Before Brony Notion uploded a video:I’m tired,I need to catch some sleep.
After Brony Notion uploads a video:WHO NEEDS SLEEEP ?!


Maybe source well the beaded banish discord but then he came back when the world sisters were old enough to banish him with the elements of harmony then he came back and Twilight banished him when you came back by the elements of harmony and Tara like and her friends friended just called


U know most of the monsters are bast off of Greek mythology


4:51 turn into a horse and uh... and uh... that made laugh sooooo hard😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆


I do agree but what about flutterShy she had a big part in discord being on the same side of them???


OK I know this is completely irrelevant but I just need to get it off my chest, you are pronouncing Ying and Yang wrong, well at least not the correct Chinese pronunciation


I loved that insanity of real ran its mik


one simple question that pulls me out as all of us may no that wen you plent something it will all ways bloom once intill its planted again but the plunder seads in season 4 didnt they all bloomd and allsow wy did they bloom again at season 9 and all sow how did the seads came from the ever free foristsat at season 9 im not a farmer but all i know i think its inough like im not giving you my all but as i think more discord is a creatur of chaos creatid from star swirll (mr who doesint listen to star light and allmost brought an end to equestria ) and where has he bean first saying to star swirll that he is a good sors of creatur and then betrauland gathers info of who runs things so he can over throw them and run the kingdom him self i dont know but this way i get him allsow being a creatur of hope so i think thats how he starded of and ending evil and keep klame but fluter on boom .<3


He was kinda correct because discord WAS grogar whatcha the finale of mlp


DISCORD IN MLP: Why
THE APP DISCORD: YOU

DISCORD IN MLP: *Why*
THE APP DISCORD: *YOU*


Grogar? But in 1 episode turns out he was discord he even helped the oder ponies bcs of flutter shy


"At about the time the tree was full grown-"
ThE TrEe cReAtEd DiScOrD!!!

XD really though maybe?
Edit: I made this comment without watching the whole video XD wow im so amazing


what if discord is not the opposite of the tree but the main six


can a non unicorn became alicorn??? except flurry heart.... or?


What if star swirl did create discord, what if star swirl took the magic DNA from various magic creatures and then stirred it up and created chaos magic and then injected that chaos magic inside of an egg an egg that discord would later hatch from and when the pony of shadows happened star swirl totally forgot about the egg and when he and the pillars where send to limpo Discord had hatch from the egg a what if he got pick on as a child cause of hes different aperince and so with no one to guide him on the right path he decided that if he could not be like everyting else then he would use he's powers to make everyting else like him


I think that discord was born by Terri’s dad


Question 1:where do u watch mlp I watch them in Netflix.Question 2:Is there a season 10 or something? cause in Netflix its just 9 seasons, and I don't know who grogar is, soooo........... yeah


What if mlp director take future show ideas from this video


Maybe grogar and star swirl both made discord


You're back! Also I've been wondering this since Star Swirl was shown. Haha.


Discord is made of chaos like he is sewed out of chaos


i think star swirl made him and then because him went away discords spirt went away until loona and her sister were powerful anof to be like star swirl


7:27 maybe he was a baby and was only shown when he was an adult?? idk


Do you think the my little pony logo probably has something to do with the show maybe you should look into that


2:15

WHY DID I THINK HE WAS GONNA SAY GRANNY SMITH-


<i>why i am i weirdly attracted to King Sombra... an animated evil unicorn king XD</i>

_why i am i weirdly attracted to King Sombra... an animated evil unicorn king XD_


What kind of magic did he use what let's just say he's been there since way before anyone else was born and as much older then he looks do you order the you know who and well she could be the father of him because species creating different species I can't happen in science


did you forget he got banished in stone for 1000 years? Not trying to be rude, just trying to remind you


I- GROGAR!???? HOW!!! HERSS DA REAL:

You are right, Starswirl is the creator of discord  but he


My theory:
Star Swirl created Discord, Discord waited for awhile for Star Swirl and he never came so he attacked Equestria so that Star Swirl will appear
(Kinda like yours)


but discord existed before or next to the grogar


Maybe split in he splits into a mini two and a horse


Discord may have been in the chaos world


Discord was on growgurd time line prinse cleast said  me and my sister  found pony village I can't remember the rest but they said it was suffering whither biscord a long time


What if there's a species of discords and nopony knows yet because it's way outside of the equestria even beyond that  But they only know discord cause this "the only speeches that ever came into equestria.. so on so fourth.


How discord as born:he was made from a very powerful pony more powerful than star swirl <br>hahahahahahahaha u thought so he is discord he was oh pop in to earth 🌎 lol

How discord as born:he was made from a very powerful pony more powerful than star swirl
hahahahahahahaha u thought so he is discord he was oh pop in to earth 🌎 lol


Me trying to watch my little pony for fun
see the theory
me:😐

Me *trying to watch my little pony for fun*
*see the theory*
me:😐


But in the future of equestria we knew that grogar was discord


If 1 more person says my little pony's "for girls" or "for kids" ima riot


mlp's creators be like:
oh, yes exactly, that is totally the story and origins we were going for, hehe.. uhm.. *cough. we, .. we are surpised it took you a while to figure it out, good job, hehe
Sawtooth: Oh really?! coz I think there is only one issue that contrasts with this explaination
Mlp creators: Oh...oh really, .. I mean yeahh that is right, . well I am gonna let you guess what it is,, hehe, .. coz we are definitely not trying to use your ideas which are more fitting than our original one, ahem ahem...


Sob story if starswirl made him. He was an old enough he wasn’t 18 yet so we couldn’t Rome in the world

𝘾𝙍𝙔𝙎𝙏𝙓𝙇𝙕𝘽𝙊𝘽𝘼𝙏𝙀𝘼 not posting a lot


What is grogar was training discord how to used his power.


Actually it’s pronounced yin and ( y_ang


This video is really cool and all, but the Tirek component doesn't make sense.

 Tirek said that he heard about stories of Grogar, He would've been like OMG THAT IS THE PERSON WHO CREATED ME when he met him. (well I don't think that he would actually say that, but he would've not disobeyed Grogar and ect.) Tirek likely wasn't created by Grogar either. I don't think that component to your theory against Dr. Wolf makes sense but I don't really see any problem with the others.

Tirek also said that he thought Grogar was a legend, which he wouldn't have said if he was one of Grogar's creations.


Say that discord actually magic of Harmony


Oh thank god, you ditched the Starswirl theory!

The Brony Notion shows got 6 more episodes to be released. Most of this theories will be lost in the shadows unless a writer/creator legitimatizes them. I fear this to be the case... unfortunately!

I'll ditch anything that gets falsified ¯\_(ツ)_/¯


*11:14** - Or just Baldur's Gate series xD*


I thought this was a video on the chatting platform discord...


Wait so Mlp was filled with normal animals until the villain combined them together?!

Not necessarily. The monsters in tartaurus maybe, but I doubt think hybrids like griffons came from Grogar.


discord is as weird as pinky pie(idk if u made a video about pinkie in human form and pony 101% guessing who twilight really is)  i mean discord is the creature im most confused of. his origin.. how he do things, he's damn powerful but he's-well, discord. and... meh. i mean HES LIKE BEYOOOONNDDD


I heard that Grogar turned in to discord


So this is the Guy Death Battle is putting against Bill Cypher? Interesting...He ain't beating Bill though👁


9:30 Yeah but I remember he said something like "Oh I'm millenniums old" I don't remember exactly what he said.


He was turn to stone  by  the sun princess .


THE THEORY HORSE I FOUND YOU AFTER SCROLING FOR 3 HOURS


TREC it’s already one hole he was never two parts


ok it sounds  good but does it bunk your other thoerys?


Hi guys I got a theory about flurry heart.

By the end of the show we see that twillight doesn’t have any child of her own . Even celestia and luna dont seem to have a spouse nor a child.

So it can be assumed that cadence is the only alicorn who has a child.
This could explain  why there has never been an alicorn birth. Its cuz no alicorn actually mated to produce one.
In time it might even be that alicorns become an entire seperate race. If The existing alicorns mate. As there is a great chance that alicorn genes are more dominant than any other as alicorns in themselves are more powerful.
Also think about the possibility of the power that twillight could possess if she uses the alicorn amulet along with her innate alicorn power.


Do you think fluttershy and discord are made for each other


here is how the time line works

So there where five children at the restaurant and the killer / purple guy asked them to follow me, then they followed him

and then he slaughtered them and someone was coming  after that he stuffed them in the suits and the animatronics became haunted

and then the second location opened up which is known as Freddy fazbear's pizza 2 and It all happened at the restaurant

the toy animatronics became haunted   and then the horror attraction came which is known as fazbears fright it burned to the ground after a decade of being closed down from the previous location known as freddy fazbears pizzaria 1 then the crying child we saw in the death scene at fredbears family diner we played the game in the crying childs coma after he had that he woke up then sister location came Elizabeth was born before Security breach happend Gregory was born before the pizzaria opened up and then 2 years later he got lost in The pizza plex and that is my


Yes Tara did not split into a horse a human and a bull


Wait
Discord in the Human world
Lord help me what a mess that would be


Doo baa doo baa doo baa doo baa doo baa doo baa doo baa doo baa doo DOO BAA DOOOOOOOOO


Discord is annoying,I hope we never work together again

He's at least more great and powerful then you!


He discord came from the the past when doctor hoves time mechanic gone wrong


in your earlier vidio you said there were one element of dis harmony exsist maybe discord is some how connected to the element of dis harmony


I got something to say sorry if I am going  against didn’t Celestia said to discord when you let the villains out you also pretending o be Kroger


Sees Brony boi uploaded

Me: Yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaas :D Time to get our bro hoof's on today!

Edit: Hears him say "yong"

Me: IT BE YANG XD

(nah just teasing, it's okay :3)

*Sees Brony boi uploaded*

Me: Yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaas :D Time to get our bro hoof's on today!

Edit: *Hears him say "yong"*

Me: IT BE YANG XD

(nah just teasing, it's okay :3)

yeah its the correct pronunciation. Yong


1:41 I think that at that period he was a baby


Wait who was close to discord except fluttershy are there more legends like discord?


Tirek is a centaur a human mixed with a horse like creature


theory youtubers making theories of MLP)<br>The Mlp develepers who didn´t have any mysteries of any of the characters:;-;

theory youtubers making theories of MLP)
The Mlp develepers who didn´t have any mysteries of any of the characters:;-;


<b>screams in matpat fan who was tricked</b>


I think that to many Magic And chaos Cant be together


So swirl creating this cold then he wouldn’t of tried straight disharmony wouldn’t he oh is source well past to evil because if source well created discord he wouldn’t of tried to make this harmony or did he maybe this cold was just a natural being from from a natural place that turn to disharmony then went to a Questria to make this harmony Princess celestial throws him friend he got out Twilight sparkle throws him got out<br>Is a normal creature

So swirl creating this cold then he wouldn’t of tried straight disharmony wouldn’t he oh is source well past to evil because if source well created discord he wouldn’t of tried to make this harmony or did he maybe this cold was just a natural being from from a natural place that turn to disharmony then went to a Questria to make this harmony Princess celestial throws him friend he got out Twilight sparkle throws him got out
Is a normal creature


My friend made this so I’m sharing it :)
.         .
   👄


Winn-Dixie card was made because of his egg hatching in the world and for the destruction would like that too hard for me and he took form on him someday when he always keep up power Lou and Lou until this court takes over was gone forever and tell them one hundred years same and discard me to his end of the


Wasn't discord was turned to stone by the royal sisters and put into a weird stone statue garden then was freed by sweetie bell ,apple bloom and scootalo fighting allowing him to be freed and to make chaos again

Wait thats true what if discord werent evil he needs chaos to life it gives him power he dont have option


who else thinks  hes the film theory of mlp


When you realize in last epidoes of mlp Gragor is discord so... :/


The story of the expatriate প্রবাসীর গল্প


When does Twilight sparkle was studying and then she made discord


no I think discord was made by the poisen joke


But What If..... Discord Made Starswirl

Mind Intestifies

But What If..... *Discord Made Starswirl*

*Mind Intestifies*

I've never had 10 likes no lie no scam

NVM I now have a comment with 144 likes


may be discord was stone when starswirl created him then when starswirl disapeared like if  agree


I can’t imagine you with a short video HAHHAHA


Aaaaaa sawtooth you now right that the compiend monster is grogar watching over the sufering equistria


Or maybe Grogar is Discord
Discord turned in to Grogar so he
Can teach friendship to Villains
But it didn’t turn out well
It doesn't make any sense lol

Idk this is my tinkling lol


Another Theory: What if he was created at the start of time and he practiced with his chaos powers then,he realized chaos is power and maybe he was created even before the pillars or maybe even ponies existed.


Oml I remember watching you all the time when I was about 8? Now I’m 12 wow


I thing i have a idea where is discord between his creation and conqured of equestria in season 9 final three episode cozy glow want to use discord magic but tirek stop her he say discord magic to powerful anybody expect him cannot control this power and like tirek said cozy cannot control it so maybe in the beggining discord also dont now how to use chaos magic so after his creation first master at using chaos magic then try to take over equestria


Your wrong discord is centuries old. Like he said in make new friends but keep discord episode.


But in the future in one of the episodes and in the normal episode this is called start being terrorising wouldn’t of that made him disappear I think discord is go garden creation but talks move go girls magic that table team to stay together


I'm outside in the dark to watch this video, damn it. notice my comment lmaooo

also, great video. this makes sense-


"Amalgamation"
*proceeds to show undertale amalgamate aka my fear*

"Amalgamation"
**proceeds to show undertale amalgamate aka my fear**

Nope, not for me XD, I legit threw my device upon seeing photoshop flowey. Anything else isn’t that scary for me


hold on isnt discord old af  doesnt he know of king voracks existence isnt king vorack old


If discord was made then who made pegasi and unocorn


What is Twilight cutie Mark I Think it’s friendship


I play pathfinder which is a lot like DND


nononono, you realize that discord is literally centuries old? hes even mentioned it. so im just gonna assume that he was just.. in another realm doing whatever he wanted? he is literally chaos itself.
ALSO, chaos and harmony are not antonyms. harmony MEANS balance. the tree/spirit of harmony is completely different. discord also isnt a literal spirit. when he was stripped of his magic, he just became a regular old draconequis. so he couldnt have just popped into existence because of a tree.
my opinion here is that discord is the creator of the world itself. he can literally pop anything he wants into existence! he even admitted that he was pulling the strings every time a villain attacked equestria. so my theory is that before equestria, he was off hanging out in his realm, when he just decided to create a new one. he came back later cause he was bored. he didnt realize, though, that while he was gone, it had grown to be more powerful than himself. so he was turned to stone. yada yada yada, discord is reformed, yay!
i think back in discords realm, things like him are just normal occurrences. other creatures in his realm probably have created other realms similar to equestria. yknow? anyway thats just what i think

@LITTLE-BEAN hes not really a GOD, but he can create things, we've seen that many times before. his creation, though, grew much more powerful than he thought.

But what about when he got trapped in stone??? Because if he’s that much of a god then he couldn’t have gotten trapped in stone like that.

So basically for you discord is god in my little pony


discord was made of kauos  when ponys are mad scard or sad thats when discord was made


lets hope we dont see discords moderators.


homies telling me to watch some1 elses video, nah bro ill stick to my Sawtooth


When they where destroyed discord was created


I saw that the monstars and savers form our yin and yang


I watched one of you're videos you're now my favorite too


Well than last evidence discord knew tirek father


WAIT: mabye he was stitched together by baby animals and he was growing?


And something random I thought of what if Sweetie Belle wasn’t Rarity’s sister but her....DAUGHTER!!!


Theroists no longer watch shows but analylies them.


Wut if Celestia created him? wut if she knew harmony comes with chaos?


I think Starlight glimmer love ying and yang theory


Orrr long story short this may not make sense but

what if any hybrid that talks will stay how they are-

Yeah it doesn’t make sense don’t go with mine :/

Orrr long story short this may not make sense but

*what if any hybrid that talks will stay how they are-*

Yeah it doesn’t make sense don’t go with mine :/


in make new friends but keep discord discord says he kneww the smooze for centuries so if he was onlynborn bacuase of the spirit of harmoney then he lied,was able to live in another dimesion when turned to stone or your thery is a goner


What if discord was created by star sir but star sir vanish discord vanish him to a unknown world but broke out of unknown world that became here to this world


𝕊𝕒𝕕𝕚𝕪𝕒 𝔸𝕙𝕞𝕖𝕕 ♡


So ur saying this is how discord the app got its name so I can go up to my friends tommorow and say discord is named from my little pony XD


What if fluttershy created discord, it is possible because discord loves fluttershy so much.


I think discord alr exist before even tirek exist cuz in season 4 she says "discord,ur free?." And he knows that grogar or wutever is real

And we all know tirek go to torturous  before her brother leave so means discord is alr a stone when star swirl was young


im 11 watching this now on my pc if my parents see this there gonna thnk im wieard butt dicord and all this stuff intreeged me bc i used to watched this when ias 7 so i wanted to know what i missed all this time


Brony Notion:posts

Me:… wait that’s illegal

Brony Notion:posts

Me:… *wait that’s illegal*


First from never made Alcorn never made Discord he never made that I know that that I disagree disagree unicorns kids rings on because of Princess Celestia


You know your more fun than dr      wolf

You know your more fun than dr      wolf


MLP will be the new FNAF for ultimate furries.


Wait a sec but if your theory is right the king sombra destroyes the tree of harmony then the discord should be gone?Bc you said that tree of harmony when it growed full the discord appeard soo when the tree was gone the discord should be gone.

sombra destroyed the physical tree of harmony, but we know the spirit of the tree was still alive as the student 6 used the spirit to create a replacement and we see the spirit of harmony interact with the student 6 even after the original tree is destroyed

I was about say the same thing, heck his '" death "' was played like a joke


anyways DISCORDDDD IM HOWLING AT THE MOON AND SLEEPING IN THE MIDDLE OF A SUMMER AFTERNOON


Hey I might have a theory that might or might not be true.


And didn't split into a horse and a troll


If I geht News my phone Rings : YAY ! (Of Fluttershy) 😂😍


Grogard isnt discord<br>Grogard is stil alive but discord is not grogard

Grogard isnt discord
Grogard is stil alive but discord is not grogard


Were did the elements of harmeny came from


do the smile theorie and iceberg oo and the fact that alicorns arnt actually immortals
and the end of the world and a https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cO9R7-ZOcs4 pony


Me:ugh he hasnt posted in a long time
Him;uploads×
Me:don't realise until 5 days later×WHA


Yo I thought that every singles animal discord is just had sex-


I thought this was about the app discord


I think that the person who posted yin yang comment is so right


grogar nor the tree of harmony made dicord


Hello present yashiro so just a question if the tree of harmony made discord does that consider the tree of harmony a mom?

☆ 𝙮𝙖𝙨𝙝𝙞𝙧𝙤 nene ☆

- - - . > o g • Q B• • • . • . . i ho . r p I em \ my H S *. @ @ @ o @ q Iff T s U U ~ . U t T ~ In ~~ s~ fn

And if the tree of harmony is a mom will she be a milf? knowing that one side of the mlp fandom they will consider the tree of harmony a milf because she made discord

☆ 𝙮𝙖𝙨𝙝𝙞𝙧𝙤 nene ☆


Discord could of been spreding  caos  somewhere else !duh.


Oh by the way all your answers to discord well not all but just some are in some series of of Bride of discord and daughter of discord from his past of how he took over  Equestria and how he was never created he had parents like everyone else but the parents died I guess or gone missing I don't know😕


The chaos this year Kyaa discovered where is Meat stars fault in this cost plus net that Stars was the beer that make this good maybe Celeste Celeste Tia make this course maybe chala Sim is the score okay this is not truth I’m like that Layla


I wonder who would win bill cipher or discord


I think discord mad by starswril and when he mad hem he jest levas and then when he vanish to the limbo some year ago and discord was waiting to starswril to go and when he hard of it than he jast  go for it and he didnt see the almants of har many


Little known fact - Fluttershy want to marry him


DISCORD IS THE GOD. DUH. THAT'S HIS ORIGIN. HE HAS ALWAYS BEEN.

OH and MLP Fans, you have to read the MLP comics too. There is so much info in them.


Time :  10 :32  <br>Brony Notion : Time to upload

Time :  10 :32
Brony Notion : Time to upload


Hu........ What thing is he he is a lizard🦎 😂 or...  an elephant🐘 😊😂😂😂 . But I think that grogar is the powerful or.... not 😁


JELLY it not a mistake it a ✨ masterpiece ✨


Well I mean idk about u but the animals in my little pony don’t even talk and like the only pony who could hear the animals talk is fluttershy and everyone could hear discord bc he can talk so that is the problem


In the. Return of harmony  celestial and Luna can only raises sun and moon so how can discord change the moon and sun


Jevil is QUAKING
CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS CHOAS

Jevil is QUAKING
*CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS CHOAS*


Plz plz plz! Can you give us an idea what happened to discord now!?!


I'm not the only one that hates the way he says yin and yang right?

@Sawtooth Waves fair enough. It is a very hard language.

Nope lol, all I know is that the pronunciation I'm used to is wrong (Y-ay-ng). It's closer to how I did it, but still off. Chinese is hard, man.


What of discord is Born  from an egg that someone magicly made magic and he only hatcht  thousend years later (sorry for my Bad englisch)


Wait his name is discord soooo there the same because there both chaotic


HAI I luv ur vids and the theories u make


Come on seriously I won't ask you again who is Queen Chrysalis partner in you know what who is your dad seriously


Discord is called a hogpog of chaos and animals he is not a made by chaos more like insanity he is chaos and insanity not just chaos he is a ying Yang of harmony and chaos with insanity


Oh toot are you going to apologize to Dr wolf?


You confuzal me alot with that matpat red blue and green font

I know that lots of other people use that too but i saw this and was like matpat watched mlp?


grogar is not real because grogar is the same eye color as discord


Or... maybe an unknown monster was created or a pony...... 😬😬🤔


I’m Ned to tal you a some fenk Gro gor make da deskord so Dan deskord Chang to grogs?? So l'm saying deskord make da grogor !


I keep rewatching all his videos the second it comes out.


Fyi discords species is the draqqueniqui  (probably spelled something wrong)


Mimi your next video should be about one of the comments


Oh hello! You made a new vid finally. <br>(Im actually early)

Oh hello! You made a new vid finally.
(Im actually early)


I think discord  is so funny because  i love chocolate  and discord  made chocolate rain


Gender swap from the Schooner restaurant be this phone chaos kiddos Chaos Chaos I can’t even tell me


<b>Wait This Video Is Illegal</b> You Uploaded

*Wait This Video Is Illegal* You Uploaded


wait aren't there 17 seasons...? oh well this video is 2 years old so...nvm


I have a  question what is the cutei mark of starswal


After binging the series yet again: I always thought Discord worked like The Chaos Gods from Warhammer. The Chaos Gods are the embodiments and representatives of certain emotions that manifested in the warp. I always thought the strife and chaos in early Equestria congeled and manifasted in form of Discord,a literal embodiment of Chaos.

I'm not too up to date on the lore but it's a headcanon I've had for a while.


Hey sawtooth. Just wanna say, when twilight gets her magic ripped, doesn’t the magic of friendship stay? Also she still has a connection to the tree of harmony, which doesn’t really<br>Make sense unless she still has her magic. Also, what if discord was made of magic, embodying all the chaotic and less constructive parts of magic, and thus he can’t be destroyed since, like quarks, he is the smallest unit possible. Think of it this way. Discord, being a pillar of the universe, can’t be destroyed even though he is made of pure, chaotic magic. This, despite being having his power ripped away from him, he is still fine. Also, he could act as a spirit of discord, just like the spirit of harmony. And being discord, it could be justified that he is like he is due to his focus on chaos. Also he could have forgotten his past due to either his artifact, which may have been similar to the tree of harmony, being destroyed but him living on because he embodies chaos itself, which still exists. After all, it can’t be that harmony was only invented after starswirl, but it’s more likely that was spread out until it coalesced into the elements. I know there are probably a lot of holes in this theory, but one last thing. If discord embodies chaos and, well, discord, then why should he himself follow any order? More specifically, why should his memories follow any order. What if, before he was the discord who conquered, he was another discord. Maybe long ago he ruled alongside a powerful spirit of harmony, until they both fell to some unknown calamity and lost their memories. Almost like the fall of gods.

Hey sawtooth. Just wanna say, when twilight gets her magic ripped, doesn’t the magic of friendship stay? Also she still has a connection to the tree of harmony, which doesn’t really
Make sense unless she still has her magic. Also, what if discord was made of magic, embodying all the chaotic and less constructive parts of magic, and thus he can’t be destroyed since, like quarks, he is the smallest unit possible. Think of it this way. Discord, being a pillar of the universe, can’t be destroyed even though he is made of pure, chaotic magic. This, despite being having his power ripped away from him, he is still fine. Also, he could act as a spirit of discord, just like the spirit of harmony. And being discord, it could be justified that he is like he is due to his focus on chaos. Also he could have forgotten his past due to either his artifact, which may have been similar to the tree of harmony, being destroyed but him living on because he embodies chaos itself, which still exists. After all, it can’t be that harmony was only invented after starswirl, but it’s more likely that was spread out until it coalesced into the elements. I know there are probably a lot of holes in this theory, but one last thing. If discord embodies chaos and, well, discord, then why should he himself follow any order? More specifically, why should his memories follow any order. What if, before he was the discord who conquered, he was another discord. Maybe long ago he ruled alongside a powerful spirit of harmony, until they both fell to some unknown calamity and lost their memories. Almost like the fall of gods.


he brought up an interesting point, when discord learned to embrace that little  bit of harmony everything got better. so doesn't that mean that if harmony embraced a little bit of chaos then the yin yang circle would be complete, they would understand a little bit of them both so harmony doesn't make it too perfect and make it boring, and since chaos(discord) understands a little bit of harmony he can cause chaos but not soo much that it becomes mean and scary. so the conclusion is the spirit of harmony needs to learn some chaos as discord learned harmony. this would make true yin yang


My theory of Starswirl and Discord: Discord was made by Star and he was very young, he trust Star with his life and so he didnt hurt him but he heard that he was gone and where was unknown, he was saddened and furious so he took it out on the only other beings he knew were apart of him... The royal sisters. He wanted to concur Equestria to find him because if he was see by ponies he could have been attacked if he wasnt in charge. So he grew his power until when he first appeared.


I love the theory that Discord is one of windigoes who has changed in a strange way.
In season 2 we saw 3 windigoes, but in season 5 there was only 2 of them. Moreover, from comics we know that Discord can change his meal (from chaos to order)🤔
And that is why he couldn't get to Equestria before: the magic of pink burning heart was stopping him. But as soon as he became a spirit of chaos (not a spirit of violence), it wasn't a problem any longer.

Света Пономарева


i would love to see you update your theory about this and try to connect it back to the alicorn/elements of disharmony


Seriously, there must be a show in which the spirit of harmony and discord talk, discuss, and that sort of thing. It would be hilarious 🤣


I love this theory and agree wholeheartedly that your theory is probably the fact we need.


I like your theory. And I think it might almost be correct. But I see 1 problem with your timeline. When Discord and Tirek teamed up in season 4, Tirek first talked to Discord like they've met before. And based on their body language and what they're saying it sounds to me like they've teamed up before. What do you think of this?

Oh, and another thing that can support my theory is when Tirek asked Discord how to use his magic in The Ending of The End part 2 where Discord replies; "I certainly won't tell you, after you lied to me the LAST time we teamed up". Discord said last time, most likely meaning they've teamed up before.


but if discord really is to be connected with the spirit of harmony then wouldn't he have been born when the seeds were planted in the first place? I mean the tree of harmony cant just think to itself "okay, today im going to start giving out friendship magic by using magical rocks" no, the magic would have grown over time and discord growing along with it

it's just some food for thought, i've had this question for a while.

although i do like the idea of discord being the spirit of chaos 🙂🙂👍🏻👍🏻


Maybe after the royal sisters took command of equestria and brought peace all the left over chaos magic created discord. This also explains how he disappears by being normal. All that chaos magic is being converted into normal magic and since discord is a being of pure chaos this would cause him to fade. <br>I don’t know just a thought

Maybe after the royal sisters took command of equestria and brought peace all the left over chaos magic created discord. This also explains how he disappears by being normal. All that chaos magic is being converted into normal magic and since discord is a being of pure chaos this would cause him to fade.
I don’t know just a thought


I just thought of something maybe the tree of harmony is a reincarnation of a living thing like how you said discord might not be the only one of his species and maybe each represented something like distraction, greed, and others one of them represented harmony but then something happend to them so in a attempts to keep the balance between chaos and harmony they created the tree I mean we know they are powerful enough for example discord was able to completely change a whole world and how it works so it’s not to far off to assume that they can make a tree that will have a power related to their meaning maybe that how discord was made. he was made along side others of his kind just with a kind of different appearance each representing something and they are just kept apart to avoid a war like how the friends used the gyms found by the tree to stop him meaning one is always going to be stronger than the other like paper beats rock but rock still beats scissors. (I know this might be a little far of from the theory in this video I just wanted to share this because it seems like a cool idea)


Maybe when they planted the seed of the tree of harmony another tree grow and it's called the tree of disharmony and discord was a pony once who found the tree and it turned him into chaos or he was already like that and he was like Twilight and when he found it .It gave him the power of chaos like Twilight got the power of harmony


I like to think that discord existed for all of eternity as a force embodying chaos, and that there are other similar forces (albeit maybe not as a singular entity) created from the birth of the universe, and discord is merely one of many other forces. he is chaos given form


They should introduce ponies that are kinda like the main six but for discord instead of the tree of harmony 🤔


Yea I think it’s true and watching this video gave me the same idea when the tree of harmony was planted Discord came to be but lime the tree at the beginning he was young and over time like the tree he got older


3:42 Ya I know how that feels, making a video and seeing that someone beat you to the race!!! I would have done the same.


I used to listen to head cannons created by someone named Ink Rose. She had written a story about Celestia and Luna meeting Discord at the age of fouls. Ink Rose had claimed that discord was a draconicus too. A mix between dragon and other species. Discord does have a dragon wing. Although I don’t think your theory is incorrect, I feel as if there are more creatures EXACTLY like discord. Maybe discord has or used to have his own species? And also, the tree of harmony was made by a magical seed created by the 6 pillars, so what kind of magic made discord appear? Equestria<br>DOES have many hybrids.. what if discord is like a tribrid of tribrids between tribrids? Or something like that..?

I used to listen to head cannons created by someone named Ink Rose. She had written a story about Celestia and Luna meeting Discord at the age of fouls. Ink Rose had claimed that discord was a draconicus too. A mix between dragon and other species. Discord does have a dragon wing. Although I don’t think your theory is incorrect, I feel as if there are more creatures EXACTLY like discord. Maybe discord has or used to have his own species? And also, the tree of harmony was made by a magical seed created by the 6 pillars, so what kind of magic made discord appear? Equestria
DOES have many hybrids.. what if discord is like a tribrid of tribrids between tribrids? Or something like that..?


In that time period after Starswirl created Discord he could have been in hiding and gaining power likewise with grogar


I always thought that there were three spirits: chaos, harmony, and order<br>harmony feels sorta like a mixture between chaos and order

I always thought that there were three spirits: chaos, harmony, and order
harmony feels sorta like a mixture between chaos and order


I think discord came from an alternate demension (where he lives) and then one day was like "I wanna take over another demension" so he took over equestria


When the tree of harmony was planted discord was created to keep the balance of the world because without chaos there is no harmony and without harmony there is no chaos


11:59

Either Discord just sang his heart out, or he started spamming the Discord notification sound.


Have you ever thought that after Twilight told herself how to do what she was going to do but she didn't get to finish Maybe she went more back in time and at that long time ago that she went to after going to Twilight Maybe she created Discord and then went back to her own timeline and the Maybe she mixed up a lot of animals and maybe you know how the girl said that well the grown up girl said that there was only supposed to be one kind of Discord Maybe she tried again but made a dragon and a pony that explains why there's more of Discord except dragon and Pony


I think that Star Swirl did make Discord before the tree of Harmony I think that the gap was spend gaming power and making sure he wasn't too weak


Maybe discord was off somewhere else spreading chaos but the ponies there stopped it so he went to another place another place in another place and they vanished him in each place until he found a Questria


I think that discord was created by starswirl but he was only created as a project, meaning that discord just needed to increase his own magical abilities and grow as his magic did naturally


I think your right Grogar created discord but he was a mix of all the animals then when his Magic was taken away He didn’t split into parts because only his magic was taken away not The animals that created him


Okay, I haven't looked into this what what if the Chaos of the tribes disagreeing, so he's kinda like Terech,gaining power It leaves a HUGE gap in the timeline and I need to look into it. But it seems logical as of now.


But that still leaves a question how did discord the master of chaos knew grogar if grogar lived long before him,and it's not like we could say that discord studied grogar or heard of him,because the two alicorn sister the trapped him in Stone until twilight and her friends released him and we only saw discord read a few books and I'm sure he never read through all of them so where did he knew grogar from?🤔


5:50
but dr wolf has disproves his first theory by the second theory

at his first theory he sad that grogars magic only be given voluntarily. but in his second theory he sad that grogar wants the monster he created to spread darkness in any case. if that what grogar wants then why would he give the monsters the ability to give their magic away?


No, that's literally it. You got it there bud.
Harmony doesn't intervene physically, but influences to gain strength.
Chaos loves to intervene physically to bring more chaos for strength.

Discord has always been a spirit since the very beginning. All he is, is a physical manifestation of that chaos, hence why he knows so much.
He's naive simply because he's never been able to intervene fully as himself until the spirit of harmony also got a more physical form, the tree.
The spirits have been fighting for ages.
Discord likely had a different manifesting form back before the tree existed, and was likely not nearly as strong as he became. Either being stuck as a simple trickster spirit that was making a friend or having a temporary form that struggled to stay together for long periods of time before having to retreat and recharge.

The tree coming into existence and boosting harmony by giving it a more physical base. Once it was full grown, it was fully grounded in our world which is when Discord was also at a more powerful state to hold a form indefinitely, grounding him to our world as well.

TLDR; Discord was simply a more trickster spirit with a temporary pass, having some fun here and there before having to recharge in his realm. Until the toh was planted and fully grown, allowing him to have a better foothold in our world, thus allowing him more room to stretch and play around with his power.
Thoughts?


Ironic how discord and harmony have to work in harmony, but end up in discord


I think triek is a form of more than 2 creatures i mean look at the cynara, its made from a tiger goat and snake so triek is from three creatues, a horse and maybe bull and something else


I think the one who made tirek made discort because when their magic was taken they did not split


Sawtooth waves wasn’t discord frozen along time ago so he must’ve been frozen for so long but then was free when Apple Bloom screwed in sweetie Belle sendfree set him free


Star swirl: hmm, lemme just combine this spell.....and this one.....
*discord appears*
Star swirl: ight imma head out

Star swirl: hmm, lemme just combine this spell.....and this one.....
**discord appears**
Star swirl: ight imma head out


All I heard was alot of big brained theories that I can't even imagine to think of... This is something to contemplate...


maybe he is a spirit that the tree let out so ponies will appreciate it's presence and make them value the princess ( ponies like you ! who keep on interrogating them! ( but i like that))


Remember in episode “the maud couple” pinkie searched for maud in discord’s dimension.

That must be where he was in between his turning into stone and his birth