your theory is good. but the new movie equestria girls and the legend of everfree . near the end the human twilight said she hold the power of friend. and during that movie sunset shimmer ponyed up when she said your friends are in there. As well near the end they all got a necklace almost like the element of harmony. so I'm guessing sunset shimmer is the 7 element. but if she is the 7 element what element would she be?

@Aimee Dominguez after her little... let's say episode in Equestria Girls the Mane 6 with the exception of Twilight gave her time and forgave her for her past actions and when Pony Twilight came back she forgave her too and after helping defeat the Sirens the rest of the school finally forgave her as well. Then when Human twilight went all Midnight sparkle afterwards sunset passed on what the others gave her to her and forgave Sci twi

@Jaron Batiste what do you mean by forgiveness<br>

Aimee Dominguez redemption or forgiveness. I think redemption because on the website it says she stands for redemption


atcttuly sunset shimmer is also the elment of magic because if you watch the freindship games ending some of you might wondering whhy is there a orane star? becaue inn the first say


Why doesn't Sunset have wings, if she's probably an alicorn? '-'


But if sunset shimmer is from equestrian so that means that there is 2 sunset shimmer in the human world because there are a different world but same character


Element of forgiveness but starlight should be a element to because she's by twilights side also become a allicorn make a vid on that plz


𝚂𝚑𝚎𝚛𝚎𝚎𝚗_𝚝𝚑𝚎_𝚛𝚊𝚌𝚘𝚘𝚗


when the friendship games are over Sunset Shimmer went to the pony world


i think that the other unknown sunset shimmer will go to equestria


SUNSET SHIMMER IS NOT THE ELEMENT OF FREINDSHIP! TWILIGHT IS!!


The Brony Notion sunset shimmer is the 7th element of forgiveness.


I wonder what does the human Sunset Shimmer do in our world¿ Hmmmm....


she is the 7th element of harmony and her element is red storm

I think it would be a yellow sun,cause the red storm is rainbow's,and There isnt a yellow one


ummmmmmmm...I think you thought could be the pony sunset shimmer stays at canterlot high and the original sunset shimmer goes to ecrestria.


I think human sunset will go to equestria


but....i think so human sunset shimmer should go to equestria and human twilight should stay


I think Starlight glimmer represents the element of Reformation


Does it matter to anyone, that the Human World has a name?


Human twilight is staying here for the next movie


No because if she was an element hers would be in the tree


Can you also theorize that can Starlight Glimmer be the 8th element of harmony? I know its crazy but DO IT


I don't get it how are there two of  the same characters in each of  the worlds


Wait wait wait She is the seventh element so that means there is human Twilight sunset shimmer can be the 7th element I think sunset shimmer is the seventh element human Twilight makes the sunset as like the 7th element


Why starlit have the same cutie mark like they have star's .


im not sure if thats right sunset may look like she has a 7th element she does not the elements of harmony would not work with one gone at the bearer cannot be replaced so its very confusing i will explain the rest in a reply to this comment

+queen chrysalis my point is twilight was there is some way EVERY TIME so if she were gone in every way nothing happens at all


I think that sunset shimmer is from Pony ville.


Sense but....What should be done with sunset shimmer in the 3 series rainbow rocks, equestia girls and friendship games?


Wouldnt news spread all over equestria if there is 2 twilight?<br>Btw I cant spell

Wouldnt news spread all over equestria if there is 2 twilight?
Btw I cant spell


I think so would be the 6 one of the human world in replace


Idk I believe won pony for won won twilight and won sunset but not at the same world


I think she is the element of frienndship


And I forgot....... Rainbow Rocks toooo....<3


Nope shes the seventh element cause if theirs a twilight in the pony world their a twilight in equestria world just look at the friendship games


That is not possible there can't be two of the same in one place


Where is the sunset shimmer who was already in the "human world" did she take care of her?


Because there has to be one of every single pony that exists in a Questria in the human world and if there’s two twilights in a Questria  and if there is two sunsets in the human world then it wouldn’t make sense because if there’s not a  Sunset in Equestria then she doesn’t exist at all to those ponies if there’s no twilight in the human world she doesn’t exist to all the humans so there has to be one of every single human in the human world and one of every single pony in  A Questria because me be nerd


pretty smart but element of forgiveness makes more sence because friendship is also about forgiving each other


sunset shimmer's cutie mark is shimmering sun not a star


I am the kind of person on YouTube who clicks the like button on pretty much every video I enjoy... which means I have over 4,000 liked videos... I was procrastinating late work so I scrolled down in my liked videos playlist and finally got to the bottom. This, ladies and gentleman, is the first YouTube video I ever liked.


why does photo finish and twilights cutie mark is the same?


Mop Twilight or human Twilight is permanent


rw: cause i mean anybody or pony should have a 2nd chance.


I know this has nothing to do with the element and sunset shimmer but, human twilight has alicorn wings but when she entered the human world she was a normal unicorn.


DONDE ESTARA LA SUNSET DEL MUNDO HUMANO?


Starlight comes to human world<br>Me:WTF


okay, I know sunset changed and is a much better person, I still really don't like her.


Oh great so sunset now wait till the future when its starlight


I know Sunset Shimer element it is confidence.


I disagree.  Because if this was true, there would not be a whole NEW color to the rainbow.  Therefore, I thinkit would be most likely that she IS in fact, a different element.  The element of Forgiveness.

                                                                                Sincerely,
                                                                                Sandra, a huge fan.

Probably not though. Maybe her element could be Trustworthiness?

Diamond oak your right   the element of forgiveness

Also, wouldn't human Twilight take on the role of pony Twilight?


I think of the human sunset is the future villane in eg 4


i guess human sunset and human twilignt should stay in thier human world and pony sunset and pony twilight should stay in equestria.wait they didnt find human sunset right?????


I think maybe pony sunset and pony twilight should be in equestria and human sunset and human twilight should be in the human world because the ponies should maybe be in the pony world and the humans should be in the human world


Sunset is the element of forgiveness the other twilight sparkle is not going back and there's no other sunset thank you for your time!!!!!😇😤


I think spike should. OK ITS WEIRD I KNOW HE IS SO LOYAL ( MAKE HIM REPLACE RAINBOW DASH!!!)


yeah I say human sunset and pony twilight in equestria


The human twilight is the elemint of magic just lik pony twilight is


No no no she is not the setith element I have prof 1 the elements of harmony only have six they said there is no way there more so no but its still possible that there is a riffing kind of magic


Yeah sunset shimmer did replace twilight sparkle


still dont trust Discord to be fully reformed.


Sunset shimmer means sacrifice so I would believe it’s forgiveness or sacrifice


i think the element are really 7 but twilight and the other are find out the element when there not already meet sunset and the element had a 6 points up side is rainbow dash and the four in left and right are applejack,fluttershy,rarity,and pinkypie and the down side is sunset shimmer 😀😁😄😃

but i dont know what is her harmony😅


they made legand and everfree and can't go back she is a element


I think sunset shimmer should go to pony world


Hey Sunset watching you’re vid is awesome OwO and idk idk if I’m a seventh element but i really don’t care -_-


Now that I've seen friendship games, and seasone 6 episodes 1&2, I think sunset shimmer will go back to equestria. Then, Starlight Glimmer will go into the world 2. Starlight and si-twi will be forgiveness, and princess Twlight, and sunset will be friendship.


YOU COULD BE RIGHTSUNSET SHIMMER COULD BE ALICORN HER NAME CEARLY SAYS SUNSET AND IF SHE EVEN IS A ALICORN CLESTIE DOUSNT NEED TO DO THE SUNSET .


I thinks its better if the humans sunset his to equestria and the human twilight stay in the human realm


that's not balanced because if human twilight and the pony tail light stay in the same place that can cause trouble if other pony's don't get it and human twilight has a place in the human world if human sunset shimmer went to the pony world she might get the same punishments the pony shimmer was soppused to get so if any one was to go back or go there for the first it'll be the human sunset


I think human twilight should be in the human world and pony ss (sunset shimmer) should stay in the human world and pony twilight stay in the pony world and human ss stays in the pony world because there is 1 sunset shimmer in each world and human ss well I think does not know friendship AKA magic


Wait but there is another twilight fro. The human world maybe she also will be part of the elment too


What will happen when there's actully six when , those elmelants of harmony are attached to suset shimmer this tells me problem about seven beetween six , six is a even number seven is a odd number, will this work better then six ,when twilight was in ponyviell their was five ponys without twilight being the leader this is weird


SHE BETTER BE THE SEVENTH ELEMENT!! SHE IS MY FAV CHARACTER!


out of topic but, why sunset chose the human world? hehe forgot what were the name of the world


So this video is out dated... GOSH DANG IT MLP!! WHY YOU GOTTA COMPLICATE THINGS?


I sought in the few years in a questionnaire I saw that That color


As much of a fan of you I am I really dislike two same in each dimension


Well, I found a list of season 6 Episode names, the third episode is: The Starlight Express, probably the episode where Starlight Glimmer joins the mane 6- As the roumor has it...
The last 2 episodes are called: The element Of Courage part 1 and The element Of Courage Part 2
Sooooo, there is gonna be a 7th element?
Maybe it will be Sunset...probably not, since Starlight needs the element (part of the mane 7)
So, I don't think that Sunset is the element of courage, but Starlight did not show almost any signs of her deserving the element
But, she has 21 episodes to proove herself so...yeah...that's all I have
I know this video is old, but I just..I had to :3


you made little mistake Sunsets element is magic not friendship y simple there originally was no magic on earth universe there for according to the prophesy at episode one the spark is the 6 element after "discovering" the other five and twilights element is not magic because here "talent" is magic there for the six element in the prophesy is friendship not magic and that is way there is magic in earth after twilight left in the first movie if you remember magic despaired after she left and way sunset  did not understand way there was magic again AFTER twilight left is because sunset was originally from equestria  were magic is a bundle and all over the place , see ya later and have fun I know I have ☺ oh and ps try not too think to hard sometimes the answers are plain in sight hahaha ☺


Sunset shimmer is element of friend ship


the human twilight has wings its  in a music thingo


If the pony sunset is living in the human world then where is human sunset and why is she not revealed in the eposides or movies.


If Sunset is the element of Magic what kind of element ist the human thwiligt. Could you Post an Update for the theorie


I think in the fourth movie human sunset shimmer will come to equestria and will live there while human twilight and pony sunset shimmer will stay in the human world


Patriots QB Tom Brady's wife's name is Giselle.


ThATS IT BRONY MOSTER! ,it is actually like this.<br>Sunset shimmer is the leader of indigo ,sunny ,sugarcoat ,soursweet and lemonzest. gET IT MR BRONY?!?

ThATS IT BRONY MOSTER! ,it is actually like this.
Sunset shimmer is the leader of indigo ,sunny ,sugarcoat ,soursweet and lemonzest. gET IT MR BRONY?!?


A line from the future and will know you are wrong I'm telling you you are very wrong


Or maybe sci-fi twi is the element forgiveness.......

Okay I'll SHUT up now


Or it could be human sunset in the pony world because Celestia said that you not many ponies can be in the human world because it will cause a disbalance hurt the world s plus it would be too confusing if human Twilight went to the pony world and human sunset would stay with pony sunset


Yes yes yes yes! Sunset shimmer is best pony and element its empathy!!!!!!!!


I  don't think human Twilight sparkles she can't stay in the pony world with her other self because both worlds would be destroyed


I have a question If there s two twilight sparkle there should be two sunset shimmers?


When I was looking for a sawtooth waves vid to watch I was eating corn on the cob when I saw the name of the vid I bit my tongue 😂😆😂😂😂😆😆.lol


i think she is the 7th element but I think she is forgiveness because twilight is a princess of freindship and everyone forgave sunset shimmer


SOMEBODY IS ASKING WHERE IS THE HUMAN SUNSET SHIMMER BECAUSE IN THE FIRST MOVIE OF EQUESTRIA GIRLS  SUNSET SHIMMER APPEAR IN PONY VERSION


😆😆😆 don't worry lots of his vids aged by now

You might wanna look at the date this was made....(yikes 2014!)


You should do was granny Smith the mayor of ponyville because in granny Smith flash back it said her and her mom and dad and the other Apple's family made ponyville and she also said that there were no ponyville because the pineness  cetina gave the land to her so yeah do that plz plz plz plz plz plz plz plz plz plz


Sorry element of friendship A.K.A. element of magic


I DID HAVE THIS THEORY ABOUT THE 7TH ELEMENT OF HARMINY BUT I DONT KNOW ABOUT SUNSET REPASEING TWILIT BECUAS. SHE IS THAR IN SPERET AND I THINK THAT THE 7TH ELEMENT IS WITH IN SUNSET DOSE ENNY ONE AGRES WITH ME.


Sunset shimmer should be the element of forgiveness and her element is a sun like her cutie mark but a light orange colour


Sunset shimmer is not the seven element didn’t u hear there is only six elements not seven If it seven I would have seen it at the first episode


I'm sure you know that there is no human sunset shimmer rite?Cuz she's the human AND pony sunset so that will never work sry


And spike is the green element because his spike hair i dont know well gye


Do a video about y sunset shimmers magic changed l8ke it use t9 be blueish green and when she went back to pony Villa, her magic was red


I think your right but when you put her in. It will be a half of the star


sorry i meant<br> equestria games and not rainbow rocks. lol

sorry i meant
 equestria games and not rainbow rocks. lol


Watch DRWOLF vote video "there's allways been an 7'th element


I would love if sunset shimmer is the 7th of the mane six...U CAN KICK RAINBOW DASH OUT NOW!!!

Stormie McEwen Also, it is kinda confirmed in Legend of Everfree --' Equestrian girl have like their own harmony element


I wonder where is sunset shimmer other half


no no no she was not born in the human realm she was ment to be with twilight helping her with things bc she was te first student 3/6/21


BUT SUNSET SHIMMER CANT BE. THE ELEMENT OF FRIENDSHIP CUZ FLUTTERSHY IS THE ELMENT OF FRIENSHIP NOT SUNSET!!!


What  if  human  twi  and  pony  sunset   were  in  pony  world  and  pony  twi  and  human sunset  was  in  human  world?


I think human sunset  should go in pony world and human twilight should stay in human world so doth worlds will have sunset and twilight your saying that there will be human twilight and pony twilight in pony world and human sunset and pony sunset in human world but if human sunset goes in pony world then both the world will have sunset and twilight, human one and the pony one


umm i didnt understand the last thing u said that 2 twilights in pony world and 2 sunsets in human world???how?!?!?!


I have a queston selestia has almost the same cuty marke  as sunset shimer why is that could you finde out please.


can't u leave this all at the writer?<br>I am not being rude

can't u leave this all at the writer?
I am not being rude


How about sunset is element of understanding

No maybe she's the element of friendship because twilight is the element of magic right? reply if in wrong plz -_-


Wouldn't if be sunset shimmer in pony worked I mean actual human sunset. And it would be more balanced and it won't be more confusing


that is what I've been saying sunset being forgiveness


But what if she isn't  in equestria girls  what element  is she  going  be it should  be  forgiveness  in Ponyville


the UNnown sunset shold go to ekwestria so because she might help twilite at some thing hey u need forgivness in pony twilite World


Right twilight doesn’t be in the human world all the time. Maybe sunset is the element of magic in th ehuman world


I think her element is bravly beaus if you watch rainbow rocks she sings but she dint won't to


𝙻𝚒𝚝𝚝𝚕𝚎𝙲𝚑𝚒𝚕𝚕𝚊𝚡


Sunset Shimmer is the element of Forgiveness watch the friendship games she forgive human twilight after all happenings


Who is scooterloo and how was she born by rainbowdash? could somepony I mean somebody help me


There  are 7 elements  of harmony  in human  world


their is a comfered 7th element of harmony you in the show watch friendship is magic or whatever the first 2 episodes where called and secret of my success you at conspiraPon3 and you'll see my pount


there is 1 Sunset Shimmer and that is the pony Sunset Shimmer in the human world and the human Twilight lives in the human world too


I think a sun shape element of forgiveness could be the<br>element of sunset shimmer

I think a sun shape element of forgiveness could be the
element of sunset shimmer


Discord vs sunlight,who is the most powerful?

Sunlight is super-powerful. It's responsible for a heckuva lot of life on Earth.


sunset shimmer  and twilight are different


There are 8  the seventh is bravery  idk what the eath is


well to make the worlds balenced maybe the oringinal Sunset Simmer will go back to the pony world?(like if you agree)


if she is what would it be ???????????????


I human   sunset shimmer well go back to  equestrian to replace the gap that pony sunset shimmer left is in equestrian that way we both worlds are complete and I think that the human  sunset shimmer Will then become the student of the  Princess  again


you should do who is better rainbow dash or Applejack?


??? I don't get it can you make another videos and talk about it more


I bring the point of non equestria sunset not mentioned, brony


Brony help I need to learn how to make a super cool not Mary Sue oc


It should not be humen twilight sparkle it should be sunset shimmer


I wish they made a movie about sunset shimmer was talking to drixie about being friendly I wish and rainbow dash said sunset u no she is powerful don't teach her.and apple jack said why is everone saying .SUNSET SHIMMER WE ARE SORRY1!


Ok I love sunset and all but seriously she's not ready she turned into a demon for goodness sake she doesn't deserve it yet!!!!!!!!!


You know,I agree that she is the element of forgiveness.


No because twilight sparkle only has 5 white stars and only one hot pink star do no more elements of harmony all except the mane 6


i mean like she cloud be because um lets see did you see there was a episode and in the ep in the human world sunset became the 6th element of harmony you know


i asked hasbro there is not another sunset shimmer


+The Brony Notion<br>um the mane 7 confirmed :D

+The Brony Notion
um the mane 7 confirmed :D


That sounds terrible. Two ponys in da same world? Umm, nu uh.


I really think your on to something there


Star light glimmer neckles is à glimmer duhh


I kind of want to know, where is Sunset Shimmer's human counterpart, will the two Sunset Shimmers ever meet? Would the human Sunset adventure into the pony world and evenly be befriended by the mane 6 as well as Starlight? Anyway, regarding the elements of harmony, I think in the EG world, there are seven elements that are known, where's in the pony world, there are six elements known, however there might be a good chance of Starlight becoming the seventh element at some point, not turning her into an Alicorn but helping her to make peace with herself and her past, so forgiveness is a good possibilty for that element, it doesn't need to have any major magical power behind it, just reflecting upon the pony who had to discover what its like to be forgiven for their mistakes and help others to forgive themselves.

ChristineshyWhoDurand-P there should've been a teaser at the end of legend of everfree that showed human sunset


Legend of Everfree says she's 7th element


HEY BRONY    NOTION   HOW DID YOU GET YOUR CUTIE MARK


Really 7th element is sunset shimmer for forgiveness


Were its the real twilight the human twilight no elemens of harmony you know


Sunset shimmer live in equestria sunset techer is princess celestia wach when the sayrinst came in the woman world sunset said princess celestia give this when I was her student when sunset sent a message in equestria


Legend of everfree : CONFIRMED

(Coz she has her own "geode" and she also has it as a necklace like the other 6)


She's the element of Harmony - like her cutie mark ying and yang

No she's the element of light and her name is sunset shimmer


Watch the friendship games deleted scenes


there is a twilight in the human wourld its siw twi


hmhmhm i thot Starlight gliimer and sunset shimmer to last name same and she conconted to Starlight


Nelson 16 actors like last year but just like the sun so that means and the best we will become my own and do everything right reason the sun and shower raising the moons of the sun sets out to be the most


I think sunset shimmer just not long time in the element of harmony.because twilight and her frendsip.its long friends.


the element of harmony was friendship or bravery. In my opinion. In The saga, Sunset either was very brave to sacrifice her friends or it's the power of friendship that made her sacrifice. Human twilight is magic. Did you know Applejack and Rainbow could swap elements?


the sunset shimmer was not good she is bad why 7th element of harmony take it


noooooooooo my life of<br>sunset shimmer


There's 8 elements  don't for get twilight in human world


or is sunlight the 7th element?<br>Did u think of that!

or is sunlight the 7th element?
Did u think of that!

𝙻𝚒𝚝𝚝𝚕𝚎𝙲𝚑𝚒𝚕𝚕𝚊𝚡


Sunset is a pony how will she have a pony sunset


This Is Someone From The Future And Sorry But Your Theory Is Wrong Maybe You Got It Mixed Up But Still Wrong Sorry


i love it. but not that much  not trying to be mean but not as much ok.


I still agree for her being the element of forgiveness


yes. I love you 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍💑💑💑💑💑💑💑💑💑💑💑💑💑💏💏💏💏💏💏💏💏💏💏💏💏💖💖💖💖💕💕💕💕💕💞💞💞💞💞💝💝💝💘💘💘💟💟💟✌🎧🎸🎶🍻🍼🌈🌞💒💐💎💍💌🚼🚺🚹🚼:-)


I Don't  like sunset shimmer I like twilight  only and think that twilight  Deserves to be a princess  of Friend ship not sunset

and she Doesn't  Deserve to be an part of element of harmony


Or she can be the element of.................uh i have no idea it is really forgiveness

But she isn’t an embodiment of forgiveness she’s just proof of it


I usually like your theories, but this one is pretty bad.


Hello then where is the human sunset simmer this one is pony simmer


Also in the legend of everfree  all seven of them had the geodes


what? wtf rainbow dash's element is red and applejack's is orange.so what color will sunset's be?dark red,yellow????


love the theory\vid.

...wait you watched Enchanted!!!


What about Discord?
Who saw the episode?

WHAT ABOUT STARLIGHT?? Element of forgiveness!!

SunShim = Element of Friendship!!??? LIKE HE SAID


Janne kananen polittinen youtube vaikuttaja


And then Sci-Twi appeared and ruined this teory. :(


If sunset shimmer is the element of forgiveness to restore balance starlight too can become the element of forgiveness


Starlight deserves to be 7th element of harmony more than Sunset shimmer


Am I the only one who does not understand this????????


Oh, and I'm new and my name is Penny Tee Pei Ee, but you can call me Penny for shot.


Shouldn't Sunset Shimmer element of harmony look like her cutie mark the sun


Ahhhhhhhhhhhhh sunet is pincess alicorn ( 0~0) uh oh noooo what


What happend to human sunset becuse we got human pinky and pony pinky but if pony sunset lives in the human world were is human sunset?


Hey that's what I said well in another video


Starlight Glimmer ban es it Since wE do not Knowles human starlight or sunset


Liar i am the new princess of friendship of canterlot high not sunset shimmer


did you no that sunset shimmer is 7th element of harmony forgiveness!


I HATE SUNSET SHIMMER SO DUCK OFF BACK EQUESTRIA THATS IT MOVE YOUR FLANK


I hate sunset shimmer and I really hope she is NOT an Alicorn it will change everything !!!


I think starlight is gonna be the 7th element of harmony

Starlight glimmer Mary sue 2c powers 😒logic


i am a human not a pony fyi also do a video about me


Yep she's an element of Harmony, Legend of Everfree just proved this.

\Eevee/  No, the geodes are not the elements. They're the source of Humane Seven's magical abilities, like Sunset said during the Crystall Ball. Altough it would be great if Sunset has her own element.

yup totally that makes sooo much sense she did have her own crystal

did I forget to mention that known as elemental bearers?

making original human twilight a part of the group Is making everything so confusing. Goodbye previous canon. nice knowing ya!

Ya The legend of ever free twilight is there the twilight from the Human world

+Happy  I agree because in Legend of Everfree  she replaced twilight with helping the mane 5 defeat the demon

how about if you look at twilight's cutie mark carefully you see that there's a seventh star behind the purple one, now that's pretty coincidental is it not?


OF COURSE SUNSET SHIMMER IS THE SEVENTH ELEMENT DON’T YOU KNOW THE RAINBOW BRONY?!?!?!?


sunset is a element of harmony.The legend of everfry  proved it


i HATE sunset shimmer, i dont know why, but i think this will be one of the reasons.<br>There are 6 elements oif harmony and the mane 6! there are much sersies where there just appears another character en than become's one of the mane! that was something i hated, and then also a element!? oh no that will defeat the whole world!

i HATE sunset shimmer, i dont know why, but i think this will be one of the reasons.
There are 6 elements oif harmony and the mane 6! there are much sersies where there just appears another character en than become's one of the mane! that was something i hated, and then also a element!? oh no that will defeat the whole world!


Magic is just honestly the connecting element; it makes it all happen. If Sunset is the 7th Element, she would sort of represent Magic but she represents more than just the connection between the elements. I think Sunset is like Twilight, a natural leader, but more hands on. Twilight likes to read and observe notes. She doesn't get very into it, making her magical abilities less experienced. Sunset seems to be more experienced and willing to try what Twilight won't do. I suppose that may be because Twilight was mentored for so long by Celestia that she adopted a similar mindset. Reminds me of the differences in leadership between Celestia and Luna. Celestia is hands off and rarely intervenes unless she has to. Luna prefers to go in and be apart of the 'experiment'.In essence, Sunset may be able to discover things that Twilight has not because of their learning styles. It would be interesting to see if Sunset and Twilight correspond with one another via their magical journals and learn from each other that way, like how scientists share their data with one another and discover more from those lessons. They are both natural leaders and, if Sunset DOES become a princess, would make them both astounding rulers and examples for future generations.


Just out of curiosity, wouldn't having a "second pony twilight" in equestrian throw off the balance even more as there is a "second twilight (moondancer)" in equestrian already? Even having the human sunset shimmer go to equestria would be slightly ineffective as the original (assumed to be a shadowbolt) would have as of yet not lost her faith in everything (Celestia) As she as of yet has not entered into Canterlot High, meaning that the Sun set shimmer there originally would still have the magic of friendship?


If equestrian girls had their own tv series, that would be amazing!


I think there should be one sunset and one twilight in each world, to keep the balance that has been thrown off by pony sunset being in the human world in the first place. It would restore balance in both worlds and both worlds will consist of an element of friendship and an element of magic.


I feel like human world Sunset could be a great villain in Season 6, because just as human world Twilight is just like Pony Twilight before she met her friends. Human world Sunset could be just like Pony Sunset before being reformed. I think it'd be cool to see human world Sunset cross over to the pony world and be a villain.


Theories that make the most sense for Sunset

1. Element of Forgiveness: Forgiveness, being forgiven and forgiving others is a obvious part of Sunset's character.
2. Element of Redemption: She's possibly the best reformed/redeemed character so far in my opinion and has shown that its made her strong.
3. Element of Friendship: If you think about it Sunset is the best of all the main 5's personalities, even Twilight herself and i'll explain why

She's Honest like AJ
Generous like Rarity
Kind like Fluttershy
Loyal as Rainbow
Funny like Pinkie
Expert in Magic like Twilight and a genius.

With Human Twilight officially a member of the group the human world now has 7 elements however I don't think they are the elements of harmony but the elements of friendship. Because if you remember the elements of harmony are 6 physical objects but are also manifested in the spirits of the mane 6 as stated by Twilight in the first episode however Celestia never exactly explains how they came to be and why they are what they are, but magic does what it wants so it gets a pass.

The pony world has the elements of harmony and the mane 6(Possibly 7 is human world sunset goes to their world)

So it would make sense for the human world to have a contrast to that as they do with everything else aka The Elements of Friendship aka the Human 7. BN also brings up a good point in Rainbow Rocks about how Sunset's transformation at the end adds a 7th color(Red) to the rainbow, with that at that very moment I believe Sunset became the element of Forgiveness, Redemption or Friendship cause really all three could work depending on the context.

Really hoping they elaborate on this more in the next movie


I agree with you, also the balance would be complete again. It used to be 2 unicorns, 2 pegasi, and 2 Earth ponies, but now that Twilight is an Alicorn, the balance is broken. Sunset Shimmer, being a unicorn, could fix that balance again, so it would be: 2 unicorns, 2 pegasi, 2 Earth ponies, and 1 alicorn. I hope you get what I'm trying to point out here. Maybe she's the element of balance?


I say that after Sunset Shimmer absorbed the harmonic energies from the crown directly, the leftover magic allowed her to have the same harmonic statis as Twilight, meaning she is also a bearer of the element of Magic. That's why in Rainbow Rocks her addition to the group increased the amount of there musical harmonic attack, because there were two elements of Magic. When you think about it, Sunset and Twilight are alike in many ways.


I love this channel! I think sunset shimmer  ( my 2 favorite pony ) will stay in the human world and twilight  ( my 1 favorite pony ) will stay in the pony world!


Watch season 1 episode 2 and season 4 episode 2.<br>There are 6 arms plus a big orb on top. 6+1 doesn't make 6 but 7. And to prove it the mane 6 was never said in the show. I think that is the hint we need

Watch season 1 episode 2 and season 4 episode 2.
There are 6 arms plus a big orb on top. 6+1 doesn't make 6 but 7. And to prove it the mane 6 was never said in the show. I think that is the hint we need


Spiler Alert (for Friendship games) Here's my thoughts on all of this. Is Sunset the 7th Element (That of Forgiveness)? More than likely not.  But then again we have to look at this end scene from Friendship Games. and this is seeing BOTH Twilights existing in the human world (Pony Twilight steps out of the mirror, and sees literally her human doppleganger.. and the Human sees her pony doppleganger.. the end results ar ethat at best, these two will exist as "Twins in the human world, but does this mean that Human Twlight can go to Equestria? (and exist in the same realm as her megical counterpar?) And it's this paradox that makes it highly crazy.. As DrrWolf001, pointe dout, there is a human Twilight and a Pony one, but no Pony equivalent of SUnset, and the only logical aspect I could come to conclue lies within the Season 5 opener (The Cutie Map) and that maybe Starlight Glimmer is the Polar Opposite to Senset Shimmer... in short we have good Sunset and Evil  Starlight. , and it's that scene where Human Twilight transforms into her "Negative side, that makes me wonder.. what other possibilioes exist here? Sure we have a Discord in the Pony realm, but what about a Human version as well?  Perhaps he instead of being the lord of Chaos is more of a practical joker who loves to priank everyone. (Sort of the Class Clown., and maybe it's this one that is befirendd by a certain human girl (with Pink hair) that makes him realize that he too could be more powerful, but this girl keeps him in chesck (Oh tI can hear the Head Cannos exploding right about now..)

But this beings up a myriad of questions and very few answers.. Maybe Brony Notion can try to explain this as it seems that what we have is te Twin Pardox, combined with teh "Matter Anti-matter. (Brony Notion, can you come up with this idea of how Human twilight was able to rip the fabric of  this paralell universe, and was abile to let others be exposed to this form of magic? (I mean that  is the problem.. some of the magic may have leaked into the human world, and that this could destabilize the entire paralell universes.. (Okay my mind is officially blown...)


It does make sense and i really do believe that Sunset will be the next element of harmony.


I like watching a movie like this, and how did you think of this movie? It's so great. And do you think sunset shimmer touches twillights ellement of harmony will turn half of its side red or orange? I think so.


If you think about it, her element is probably "Friendship"<br>Twilights' element is "Magic" I mean, its in the title of the Series.

If you think about it, her element is probably "Friendship"
Twilights' element is "Magic" I mean, its in the title of the Series.


I dunno about you, but I think Forgiveness is a pretty vital element that helps make friendship magical. Don't you?


sunset shimmer does represent the element of friendship because she said in the friendship games in twilight's transformation that the most important magic of all is friendship,Lianne # 1 fan 'girl'


Although it makes sense it really doesn't make sense. It would be unbalanced if there was two twilights and two sunsets in the same world. Celestia said it herself and so did twilight before. I like where this is going but if anything, the second sunset shimmer should live in equestria while the second twilight continues to live in the human world, so it could be equal and balanced.


Two Twilights and Two Sunsets in each universe? Both the Doctor Whooves in the pony world and yet to be seen human counterpart of Doctor Whooves would have a field day with all the paradoxes!


It would make far more sense for Human Sunset Shimmer to come and live in Equestria than for there to be two Twilights.


Technically human sunset shimmer wouldn't be... consumed by evil considering she was never celestia's apprentice. Which also means she never wanted power or to become a princess. So human sunset shimmer may have discovered the magic of friendship even before pony sunset shimmer.


Well, here's my question: We haven't seen the real human Sunset Shimmer. and we don't know what she is like. So, they could make a whole other mpvie about it, leading to more questions with few more answers.<br>'

Well, here's my question: We haven't seen the real human Sunset Shimmer. and we don't know what she is like. So, they could make a whole other mpvie about it, leading to more questions with few more answers.
'


I like this theory. It makes perfect sense.


she wouldn't be the element of friendship because since sunset shimmer was reformed she started to teach everyone to forgive each other under the stage and she was the only one noticing the tension between the "mane 5" she's basically telling everyone under the stage to forgive each other rather than being a super op character I mean think about it friendship is the most powerful magic and the elements of harmony are PARTS of friendship itself and forgiveness is a trait a friend should have idk what do you think?


I think that Human Twilight will stay where the human ones live,and pony twilight in Equestria. I also think that sunset shimmer will return to Equestria on the search for friendship and forgiveness from Celestial.Just my theorie. Nice video! I like all of your vids btw.


I like the theory, but the character distribution seems wrong. It seems that it would make more sense if the original human Sunset Shimmer went to Equestria and the original human Twilight stayed where she was. Like both worlds would have one Twilight and one Sunset.  A perfect balance between the two worlds if you will.


You are actually correct I just watched the third film and it is confirmed


Until proven otherwise, I'm sticking to my headcanon that original human Sunset is dead, having either died before this sunset arrived, and perhaps taking advantage of her grieving parents to take her place, or if you want to go a darker route, Sunset killed her upon arriving.


remember what Celestia said it would upset the balance of the two worlds so the human sunset is supose to be in equestria.


Has anyone noticed how everyone was obsessing over the theory of human twilight ( not the twilight in equestria, the Twilight in the human world)   this was later confirmed in the friendship games, but did anyone think about the other human sunset shimmer?


alright, well i guess im going to have to do a response to this. seeing as i have my own thoughts on this exact scenario, just never seen any headcannons in this. so please, take no offence when i link you my video when i do it, for it is simply to share my thoughts on the topic.


I think the theory has basis--that Sunset Shimmer will eventually be the leader of the Mane Six in the human world. This seems to be the overriding point of the coming movie, EG: The Friendship Games.


interesting theory, but what about the fact that the pony twilight is in love with the human flash? how is that going to work out? sunset shimmer was Princess Celestia's student before twilight, and as seen in the 2nd movie is actually a lot smarter than twilight  who's powers where only unlocked by rainbodash's sonic rainboom in the first place. I'm going to watch the 3rd movie tonight and see what they did with "midnight sparkle" weather it's the human twilight or the pony twilight they both seem to be the key to the magic now in the human world....not sunset shimmer. I believe that sunset shimmer was meant to be a princess in Equestria, based on her name alone. Luna, Celestia, twilight, and sunset. the only princess that doesn't fit is MI amore cadenza. or basically the pony of love. I think your theory of an additional element is closer to being correct. However, I feel like the creators haven't found a way to work sunset shimmer back into the pony world just yet. If the magic from the crown was able to unite with the elements that made it in the first movie, and sunset shimmer was able to draw from the power as well in the 2nd movie, that would imply that she has an element of harmony within her. It's possible that the tree of harmony didn't need her key to unlock the box bc she was not in that world at the time, should she return her element could show up on the tree. The elements have been around since before the main 6 where even born, they seem to be intertwined with destiny, by abandoning her studies/ Equestria/pony form, sunset shimmer quite possibly changed her destiny and was not harmonious in any way. so her element couldn't appear at that point.....just my thoughts


Maybe it's better if Human Sunset Shimmer will go through the portal, making it balanced that there is one Sunset Shimmer in Equestria, and another in the human world. And the exact same this with Twilight- one in Equesria, and one in the human world.


OK but, if two twilights in one world and the two Sunset shimmers in the other than wouldn't it cause a paradox?


After the friendship games if Sunset shimmer was the seventh element, it wouldn't be "Forgiveness"  but rather "Understandment" since if you watched the premire.


Sunset Shimmer is not the element of forgiveness. Twilight was the one who forgave her. If anything she would have the element of "Apologies". In all seriousness, her element is friendship. If you have seen all three EQG movies it will make sense.

EDIT: I think Sunset Shimmer (from Equestria) was meant to play a role very similar to Princess Celestia. She will be teaching human Twilight about the magic of friendship and she has been teaching the "humane six" about Equestrian magic. She also has a sun-butt cutie mark.


i still dont understand why there would be another twilight in the friendship games. if she said "why does everyone at this school know who i am..." why would the mane 5 know that shes different?


I think your thought is correct I mean it seems that after meeting sunset shimmer that she might replace twilight at the high school I think there is a 7th element so I think your thought is correct


But I have a question

If The Human twilight would go to equestrian, wouldn't it be odd to have two twilight's?

One Unicorn Twilight and  an alicorn twilight?

What would become of human twilight?


hey cool video do you think you could do a theory on rainbow power in both the human world and equestria


good theory but I would say that forgiveness  would be the best element for sunset shimmer because she was bad and evil in the first movie then twilight defeat her then she was sorry for everything in the second movie she is learning then help the human twilight towards the end of the second movie


you are right about the Sunset shimmer thing because of the friend ship games


I think in Rainbow Rocks they created a new element of harmony


I have one idea on what element she has if:
Firstly, didn't you see the mane six and their elements? I mean Applejack was honest from birth, Dashie knew no other thing than being loyal, we knew Rarity since she was so generous, etc. I'm saying their element is matching their personality since birth... Sunset became something new AFTER Twilight showed her a better way, then she understood the friendship and became a new somebo-WHOOPS-pony. So after she felt the magic she became one of the elements!
- The element of reborn. You remember the song "My past is not today"? She said "Like a Pheonix burning bright in the sky". The pheonix is the greek's symbol of reborn, you die from the bad things you did, the you rise from that things as a new somepo-WHOOPS again-body. She represents the element of reborn.
(For those who thought she's the element of forgivness, I'm sorry, but she has to represent the element, not to have help from that element.)


i think there should be a element of trust


There should be one twilight and one sunset in each side of the portal.


you were right she is a alicorn i just watched the movie and at the end she is


You know in the Pony world I've somehow grown wings... so I'm a Pegasus... which proves I may grow a horn... so I may become an alicorn... and become the 7th element... the element of POWER!!!

+My Minecrafter Videos still got no cutie mark though... :(


Interesting theory, It would be nice if It would be true.


No.... sunset shimmer might be the missing element of harmony inspiration


i do not believe there is a human Sunset<br> in the first EG movie, the only people we saw were human versions of ponies that have permanent residence in Equestria. Sunset no longer lives there and has no desire to return.

i do not believe there is a human Sunset
 in the first EG movie, the only people we saw were human versions of ponies that have permanent residence in Equestria. Sunset no longer lives there and has no desire to return.


Good ..... Theory? Well it would be awesome if Sunset WAS the element of friendship.


Valid opinions everyone. I myself believe that Friendship Games will easily answer some questions about this.


makes sense but it would be weird two twilights and two sunsets in one world is weird. But sunset being to seventh/sixth element is cool


Yes!!!!!!! Finally some one who thinks <br>Like me that's exactly what I thought! I hope it's true though. Cross your fingers! Every one😆

Yes!!!!!!! Finally some one who thinks
Like me that's exactly what I thought! I hope it's true though. Cross your fingers! Every one😆


OMG I NEED TO ASK YOU THIS!!!! OK, OK......if Sunset Shimmer is from Equestria, then should there be a Sunset Shimmer in the human world?? if someone knows the answer PLEASE TELL ME!!! I NEED TO FREAKING KNOW!!!!!!!

I mean another Sunset Shimmer from the Human World


Actually she could be the  princess of fire.


yea that makes sense but would she be able to be an alicorn in ponyvillie


Cool theory but there is one thing you you need to think about it if real human twilight go to the pony would with pony twilight and stay there with her and become a part of the main show but what about her parents and her brother too wouldn't they notice her not coming back from school or coming home and wouldn't they miss her too? So yeah that the probably with your theory I hope you reply :)<br>Ps nice video🙃

Cool theory but there is one thing you you need to think about it if real human twilight go to the pony would with pony twilight and stay there with her and become a part of the main show but what about her parents and her brother too wouldn't they notice her not coming back from school or coming home and wouldn't they miss her too? So yeah that the probably with your theory I hope you reply :)
Ps nice video🙃


i liked the theory of sunset being the jalternate twilight, but it all got ruined by the newest movie and human twilight staying with them Dx


sunset shimmer is the element of forgiveness , but i havn't seen sunset shimmers twin in equestria girls. i hope the next movie of equstria girls will show sunset shimmers twin


hey i don't think her element would look like twilights cutie mark i think it would be her own cutie mark


If it true there is a 7 element I think it would be courage but sunset I don't think she would be the element of friendship because she is still learning


Nah this y would there be two twilights in the same place ? That would mess up tons of stuff and then y would the rest of the mane six stay behind it doesn't make sense unless two would make the characters disappear.


I hope sunset be the7th element ,the element of forgiveness


me and my sister agree but wear is the human version of sunset shimmer and  forgiveness is an good element.


Wouldn't it make sense if original human sunset went to equestria.


technically sunset has not met the OFFICIAL main 6... she has not met the real rainbow dash/rarity/fluttershy etc... she should come back with twilight for once..


Wait! Hold Up If Sunset Was The Element Of Forgivness Would The Element Would Be Simmlar To Her Cuttie MaRK? BOOM! I Blew Your Mind :3


Now with the trailer out you gotta do another theory or at least the shorts cause there so much that need to be answered these people are comin up with somthin but wat could they be planning


The mlp writers were dropping hints of how sunset's element is empathy :P


Wait a minute if sunset shimmer came from equestria then where is the human sunset?!


Your right, I wached the friendship games and sunset shimmer said the magic of friendship!


In friendship games hasbro was planning to make sunset go to equestria


In one video about what does the stars will aid her escape what if it was Sunset Shimmer?


Sunset is the sixth element of magic in the human world so she takes care of that world and twighlight takes care of the pony world..


If Sunset came to the USA what will happen if another world was messed up and broke because of the reactions of a pony-human using magic on another universe. Reply is you know. :/


if sunset shimmer went though the portal would that mean that there is another sunset shimmer?


You make some sense but I think it will be human Sunset Shimmer because we can not have two Twilight in Equestria because then Equestria could be in doom or the Pony Sunset Shimmer go's back to Equestria after human Sunset Shimmer come's to Equestria High to save Both words.


What if in the end twilight takes over Lunas place and sunset shimmer ends up coming back and taking the place of Celestia.  Pony sunset cant stay in the human world for ever after all.


I think the human twi and the human sun would stay in the human world. And the pony twi and the pony sun would stay in ponyville.


If the human twilight comes to Equestria, I'll surely gonna break my PC! I don't want two twilights!!!


Oh my gosh. The way I saw Human Twilight's hair, AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH, it's real messed up... It was just messed up.


This comment contains spoilers from the friendship games and season 5. (also please excuse my bad english^^")

In the Video it was stated that the Human Twilight goes trough the portal to restore balance. Now in the Movie "Friendship Games" we saw Sunset Shimmer with the magic of the other Elements deafeat and reform the Human Twilight (for future reference Midnight... the paraell world confusion) Sparkle. So far I agree with the teory of Sunset beeing the 6th element, but what does this make of Midnight as she clearly wants to stay at Canterlot High to research magic in the human world, not in equestria?

Fan-Conspiracy time:

What if in a past Event the Human Sunset Shimmer  did go trough the portal - before Sunset herself went to the Human world? What if the whole Event of Sunset escaping through the mirror was pre-destined, intended by the elements to restore balance? I know this does seem very far fetched, but I dont see anything to proof otherwise.
This leaves the question of where the pony-turned Sunset went.

Now its time for some far-fetched Headcannon:

We know its possible to dye the coat a new color (episode one, S1) and we know that its possible to give the mane a nw style (pleny of episodes^^) what if, beeing originally from an other world and possible making bad experiences in the human world human-sunset fled far away from canterlot and build up her life on her own. Notice where im going? Starlight Glimmer. Starlight Glimmer possesses unique Magic maybe due to beeing from another world. Creating an own village which is not marked on any map (according to the cutie map theres just rocks, for celestias sake!) because she didnt know about equestrian government and society. The whole Equalism thing has been buggin me too, its just too similar to some of our human-world governments.

Thank you for reading the theory up till here. If there are any flaws or errors, please, by all means, tell me.


i think that luna and sunset are the same because they all want to be the best like celestia=twilight and luna=sunset wan stay always better and that is why sunset is on rainbow rock on the back round and later she show up than the dragons a kinda give her a chanse


if human twilight goes though the portal than will she turn into a princess alicorn too? but if there's 2 twilights in equestria will both be alicons?


but there isn't 2 sunset shimmers and even if twilight (who goes to crystal prep) goes to equestria there wouldn't be any point because not having 2 twilights cuz of her ability to use magic in a talented way she would become celestia's student, learn about friendship and become a 5th princess.
But this only my point of view so if you have something to back that up please say in you next video
thanks!

+Blitzdactyl Moonlight  lol XD yea I guesses maybe there won't be mlpeg 4 oh well :(

I have no idea why I wonder how the 4th EG movie will be called.... while the 3rd didn't even aired.... XD

+Blitzdactyl Moonlight  oh of course I never thought of it like that. Well maybe the other sunset shimmer goes to crystal prep? Err well maybe we're just going to have to find out:)

@cupcake sisters There's alway two of kind, I have no idea of the 2nd Sunset Shimmer's whereabouts, but I'm sure there are two of them since Celestia said Sunset is one of her old students.


maybe the Original Sunset Shimmer might be in the forth movie of Equestria Girl


If there is a twilight in the
human world.
is there a real sunset shimmer in the human world?


Well sunset might be the seventh but I wonder if there was a seventh element wouldn't we know about it? ( like if u agree )


tbh I think you should see if u can see if she is cuz friendship games came out


i am confused about something... how is sunset shimmer in the human world? okay okay i know how she got there but i was thinking, wouldn't there be two sunsets? how come there are two twilights two rainbow dashes two rarities etc. but not two sunsets. is there another sunset in the pony world, the human world, maybe crystal prep? i have no idea but hasbro is gonna need to fill up some plot holes


Yeah if she goes into pony world and  of course with the element of forgiveness


Friendship Games.....watch it. It totally bombs this theory.


You are correct it's a Sunset is a replacement for T Sparkle in the human world


shouldn't there be two sunset swimmers in the human world


she is going to be in twilight place in equestria girls


Could be possible but not quite possible its a hard one but its true sunset shimmer could be the 7th element because she teams up with the main six and its also true that in rainbow rocks a 7th colour did appear I think her element might be the element of friendship because that's all she really cares about now.


there has too be a Sunset Shimmer in the human world when will she come up


Actally....This has nothing to do with her,she was actally named after a famous person although the queen safire was very selfish she was princess but really back then she was young. she had red hair although she is real twilight isn't. she is a fake one but sunset was before. and she was better until she grew selfish. and celestia tried transforming her into the act like twilight until she hid it somwhere,where she could run. she was soon kicked out.After she ran into her room and knocked out the gaurds with illness then came back darned and deturmond to get that crown to make her the queen,queen safire had aqua marine eyes as sunset shimmer although it is related but,my thinking took till my friends went off forever. I still stayed on until i finally figured out that sunset shimmer was hidden from the scenes. she is an alicorn! because the englishmen said she had wings of fire and eyes of an angel because she was selfish (Goes for her wings) and looks like an angel (for her eyes) and she became devestated for somones crown. thats all i have to say like this if you want more. discrip  is below.

                  |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
                            |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
                                                                                Her Crown Link for safire.
                                        http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-mi-NILcmp3c/TtawUv4JP8I/AAAAAAAAEp0/UQSlIjCVtk8/s1600/QueenVictoriaSapphireCoronetTiara.jpg

                                                                                here for her pics and crown

http://smg.photobucket.com/user/Nellie99/media/comp/QVsapphcomp.jpg.html

|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||Im sorry her real name was saphire.||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

     ~|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||OOOOOOOO||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||~

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||Sunset Shimmer||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||


but wouldn't human sunset still be evil in real world becuase she hasn't learned magic of friendship and pony human sunset good


If she was an element of harmony it will probably be sympathy


what if human sunset simmer goes to Ponyville than the same theme would  apply but with sunset simmer


i find your theory wrong cause in equestrian girls 3 there is human twilight doing magic so your old video about the element of forgiveness makes more sense

+Fernando Gomez and i also think human sunset shimmer should go to the pony world so we have a experience pony sunset in the human world with a un experience twilight, and in equestria we will have a experience twilight with a un experience sunset shimmer


I wish sunsetshimmer was but they wouldn't do that because nothing happens in the equestria girls that doesn't happen in the show


I have a question. So what happened to the Sunset shimmer in the human world. before pony sunset shimmer came to the new world?


I don't think she'll become the element of forgiveness because she hasn't forgiven anyone.

@***** <br>yes but the elements are what they themselves embody.

@*****
yes but the elements are what they themselves embody.


Sunset Shimmer  mane 7 7th elements elements of forgiveness


ok maybe your correct but sunset shimer is only in twilits spot when she in PONY VILLE yay


Sunsetshimer element is her cutie mark like the mane six cutie mark is their element


No I think Sunset Shimmer is the element of courage . There are loads of evidence! She had the courage to take twi's hand in the first movie. Hell, she even had the courage to steal her crown when she was evil. In the rainbow rocks movie she had the courage to speak up for her friends to n the fight. In the third movie ( BTW, was shown AFTER this vid ) she had the courage to stand up against the human world Twilight ( shown as Midnight Sparkle ) Whoops, to those that didn't watch the movie, SORRY FOR THE SPOILER!


I think that if sunset shimmer was born in the pony world that means that should be sunset shimmer in equestria so well the movie came human twilight was there what about the real human sunset shimmer she should appear around equestria what do you guys think


I am really confused about this friendship sunset shimmer and twilight sparkle take over thing yet how is there a different twilight sparkle in the human world???I really want to know now


no my grandma is the one who plays mare mare and I play sunset but I'm on my friends old tablet !)


why your pony twilight wings is pegasus not alicorn?


or will human twilight be an unicorn only and pony princess twilight be an allicorn? and how come there's not another sunset shimmer? I mean theres 2 of everyone so how come there's no human sunset? because sunset shimmer was born in equestria and is naturally a unicorn but how come if there's a unicorn sunset there's no human sunset?


+the brony notion could you make a new video because the new movie friendship games there are now 7 in the group with twilight from the han wirld


no sunset shimmer mayor be  jelous forma twilight


TBN: it's just like enchanted

Me: ...IT ALL MAKES SENCE NOW!


And it dosent make sense BEACAUSE enchanted was different from your theory


in the eg friendship games this is cannon


I think that there was no human sunset shimer. & the human twlight will stay in the human world. All this human & pony world stuff makes my head hurt. Lol XD


sunset is  not the element 8f forgiveness


The true  thing is the elements are every were it doesn't matter honesty kindness Lafferty genres and lollate sorry if I spelled these wrong  but it's everywhere


ahhhhhhhh does this mean?????? Yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


SUNSET SHIMMER ELEMENT OF FRIENDSHIP :DDDDDDDD


pony sunset shimmer was in the pony world


is episode made in manehatten is when twillight goes to esquastia girls


what about orignal human sunset? mabe she will learn the magic of friendship like how in eqestria girls pony twilight shows pony sunset the magic of friendship in rainbow rocks they work together to get rid of the sirins and in friendship games pony sunset shows human twilight the magic of friendship, mabe there will be one with orignal human sunset and pony twilight? can you do a vid on this (no one listens to me if there is a counter part of EVERYONE there is bound to be a human sunset to if not then how? where is she and why is she not in caterlot high or cristal prep? is it all a scam so they can squeze a cool story in ? )


but were is the original human sunset shimmer the one who is in the human world belongs to the pony world so were is the original sunset shimmer from human world


maybe sunset's element is helpus but ı only gess


NO. I HATE THIS ONE BEACAUSE I DONT BELIVE THAT SUNSET WONT BACK


I have talked to hasbro on the phone and they Hung up on me


human sunset will porp go the pony world


Gosh spoilers for Enchanted! lol jk who hasn't seen that movie?!


I keep getting mind fucked. XD they make sense but these theories mind fuck me XD


no sorry but i don't agree you can't just replace an element if so why couldn't enyone eles


That's what I know to know where is she I hope she makes a appearance in the third movie like human Twilight


lol its like sunset shimmer is the atheor side of twight hmm....


no one sunset in pony world one twi in human world


3rd movie came out other twilight dident go soooooo YOUR WROING


SUNSET SHIMMER
ELEMENT OF FORGIVENESS
I WANTED TO TYPE THAT WHEN U SAID THAT


Sunset shimmer is a princess because you came the princess she isn't about friendship when you know since its your name right about friendship so I feel fat now  She's now princess


Sunset shimmer is us is a <br>Us together we not balance too rainbow's?...

Sunset shimmer is us is a
Us together we not balance too rainbow's?...


Umm te human twilight does not go through the portal


that so cool  but all pony like bon bon have a cuties hahah  i am now that how sunset shimer is time to pony  how is i am dont now  ooh  i am mos forgten if sunset is pony new  ........


i am confused what u just talked about video


Aha i am from pilipines ,Pilipinas!!!!!!

Kababayan Ko!!!!!!!!! <br>Pinoy Rin AKO!!!!


I am so Sciences summer will be come I N account I saw that in the network  freshers tha line and work alone his work with events please come my Anaconda I like it because this is like to sister a lot


This actually makes sense honestly.

I myself watched the movie about 7 times, I bought it because it's really better than the first. I watched RR about 7 times, with about 20 replays of the final scene with Sunset's element.

When we are first given all the details of the elements in how they operate, which we currently know (In Season 1's premier episode (2-parters I view as dualisodes or dual episodes) and in Season 2's finale episode) is that the elements of harmony cannot work while it is missing an element, but you also cannot have someone stand-in for an element of harmony.

This would mean that the Elements of Harmony also existed in the human world, Maybe even created by Human Twilight similarily, since you can't have some other element take the place of magic, as most "collect them all and activate them to get an effect" artifact sets always are very strict in their operation.

Spike couldn't fill Rainbow's place simply because he's not attuned to the elements like she is.

Sunset however has been reformed by Friendship and is indeed best friends with the Mane 5 in the human world, more than likely she spent enough time that the element of Friendship attuned to her.

Ofcourse I kinda am driving into cloudy territory, because then there's questions of "How do the elements choose their bearers?" and "If you can't have too little Elements, then why would it work if there's technically two magic-type elements of harmony?"

But Sunset being Friendship would make sense in the way that she presented an element to the final boss and contributed in the Holy Bolt Unicorn of Friendship's creation, which ended up foiling the sirens.

Just my 2 cents. I think I lost focus there. There's kinda more questions here since the original elements had to be manifested by the resulting bearers with the help of Pony Twilight, yet Pony Twilight is not native to Earth, which works differently in nearly every way to Equestria's planet, yet they still work anyways...

Who knows.

I feel she could be the element of peace/reform (??)<br>Since her reform, she has turned many villains of the human world back to normal, so i feel it suits

I feel she could be the element of peace/reform (??)
Since her reform, she has turned many villains of the human world back to normal, so i feel it suits


Your theory makes sense except for the last part (though I give you credit for the balance part of it). The humans at Canterlot high showed evidence of Sunset Shimmer being super popular there, kind of like those snobby girls in high school movies. Therefore, it seemed to have some evidence that Sunset Shimmer, while in Equestria, was from the human world, and simply returned to where she belonged after taking Twilight's element. When Twilight entered the human world and met up with the Mane Six's counterparts, one of them stated that the human Twilight from that world was gone for a trip or vacation. (This would make sense since the producers would have to figure out how to fix the problem of two Twilights in the same place). Anyways, once Sunset was reformed, Twilight returned back to her home in Equestria. So that means the original human Sunset Shimmer (represented by her silhouette and the question mark in your video) must actually still be a pony living in Equestria....somewhere. As I stated before, Twilight's human self was apparently on vacation, or somewhere that required her to leave school. Students didn't say whether Sunset was somewhere else, so it's safe to say that the pony Sunset Shimmer that stole the element, was just the human Sunset Shimmer living in Equestria (for who knows how long). Which brings me to my final point. If human Twilight Sparkle were to come to Equestria, there would be two Twilights, and only one is actually an Alicorn.
There are plenty of holes in my argument, but I just wanted to point out stuff that i thought made sense as well. XD
Also, I haven;t seen Rainbow Rocks (is that what the "sequel" is called?), so the some points of my argument may or may not have been filled in.


In Equestria Girls: Friendship Games (the 3rd movie), Twilight (the one originally from the human world) has been confirmed to join the side the mane 6 are fighting against. The whole movie is basically Wonder Colts VS Shadow Colts. So, human Twilight cannot be the 7th element of Equestria, because she's on the dark side. Also, pony Twilight becomes 'Midnight Sparkle' (don't ask). I've also notices how Wonder Colts and Shadow Colts are VERY similar to Wonderbolts and Shadowbolts, one is evil, one isn't (plus the names are similar). I must analyse that piece of information sometime....<br>Anyway, I think the theory of Sunset being the human element that replaces Twilight is right.

In Equestria Girls: Friendship Games (the 3rd movie), Twilight (the one originally from the human world) has been confirmed to join the side the mane 6 are fighting against. The whole movie is basically Wonder Colts VS Shadow Colts. So, human Twilight cannot be the 7th element of Equestria, because she's on the dark side. Also, pony Twilight becomes 'Midnight Sparkle' (don't ask). I've also notices how Wonder Colts and Shadow Colts are VERY similar to Wonderbolts and Shadowbolts, one is evil, one isn't (plus the names are similar). I must analyse that piece of information sometime....
Anyway, I think the theory of Sunset being the human element that replaces Twilight is right.


I completely agree with u. If sunset shimmer was apart of the elements of harmony then the magic of friendship would become more stronger. And it would help alot if sunset shimmer was the leader in the mane six in equestria girls so that twilight would not wait another thirty moons or waste princess celesta's magic book. It is a possibility.;)


You made come up with a new theory. We know that Twilight is the element of magic, but for some reason she is identified as the Princess of Friendship. So what if Sunset, if she became a Princess, was to become the Princess of Magic? Is her magic stronger than Twilight's? It's possible since they needed even more than Twilight's magic to defeat the Sirens. I'm still toying with this idea, so it's a bit of a far reach, but I think Sunset's friendship studies in the human world will start to merge the two worlds together and create a whole new type of magic.

Timothy’s Beyond the Fifth Panel Entertainment


I think sunset shimmer's element should actually be the element of courage since sunset shimmer stood up for her friends. Also, sunset never really forgave anybody. Sunset shimmer was the person who had to be forgiven.


I actually would like to see sunset join the main cast.


I like the idea of Sunset being the element of forgiveness because friendship ushally needs forgiveness to survive along with Kindness, honesty, etc.


I do think this is true. I just wish the story writers could write the movies/ episodes like this, but water it down a bit so younger audiences could understand. ☺


I agree with your theory except for the 2 in each thing. That might cause a rip in the time space continuum.


I agreed with several points in this video, but all sensibility was lost when he believed that Original Human Twilight would go to Equestria. I highly doubt it. That theory would involve having to change the names of one of the Twilight Sparkles. They'd never change the name of a princess, and I get the feeling OHT wouldn't want to change her name, either. But I do like some of the logic he used as to Sunset being a seventh Element of Harmony.


I actually think that this theory could be correct and could close the solution between both worlds


I think sunset should be element of courage for standing up to the dazzlings :)


My theory:

I think Sunset Shimmer does replace Twilight.Also,I think there is a lost 7th element that was probably destroyed or something and maybe it was thrown away in the human world.


I thought she was forgiveness too, but I then realized, "OH SHE DIDNT FORGIVE ANYONE SHE WAS FORGIVEN" but this makes MUCH more sense.


☺ Hmm...I've been wondering this myself; considering that she was a part of the "Element Rainbow" in MLP Equestria Girls - Rainbow Rocks ☺


I think that there IS a 7th element of harmony because in your first section of scenes I saw a lowered  circle pedalisa and the elements of magic  having 6 points, 1 dulled point. Also she completes the rainbow. anyone else agreed?


Hm. YEP! AGREE! Also I read some comments about what her element would be. And I read a very great idea of her element being Forgivness.


I agree with your theory, but what if human Sunset Shimmer goes to equestria? You see pony Sunset seems to be learning the magic of friendship from pony Twilight so why doesn't she teach human Twilight and pony Twilight teaches human Sunset? That would balance the amount of the same person in each world and who is and isn't experienced with friendship.


S.1 E.2 If you count the small stone orbs, you count 6. Twilight's element doesn't come out of either. The episode where Spike gets greedy, In his stash is that 7th element of harmony. I think that one of the reasons that Twilight and Sunset were both Protogés of Celestia was because she knew they were both connected to the elements. This would explain in Rainbow Rocks, They could only defeat the sirens with Sunset, because they needed her. That 7th element could very well be Sunset's element, explaining her color joining that rainbow. It is my theory, but there accually ARE 7 elements.


Twi:Magic
FS:Kindness
RD:Loyalty
AJ:Honesty
Pinkie:Laughter
Rarity:Generoisty
Sunset:Forgivness
All Elements :P


What if human-pony Sunset already found and eliminated the real human Sunset? That would explain how a potentially homeless teenage girl got her hands on a smartphone.


I do agree with your theroy, but at the same time, Sunset Shimmer`s element might be her cutie mark, like Twilight`s. "Special Ponys" (aka, alicorns, aka Sunset Shimmer :P) should have a different shape, like her cutie mark.


That conspiracy is very intriguing but doubled Twilights and Sunsets would get confusing right? So a human Twilight going to Canterlot High and a pony Sunset living in Ponyville would make the most sense to me.


I think it makes sence that she is the element of friendship. Listen to this, im repeating most of what he said. So in the theme, it says "Magic makes it all complete." well, in the human world, Twilight kind of leaded the main 6 humans. Without twilight, they are not "complete" sence twilight is magic. So, if Sunset shimmer is the element of friendship, she would lead them because friendship=magic. That would make them equal, plus, i dont think sunset shimmer is going back to the pony world anytime soon. :)


I don't think there is a new element but I do agree with the whole Equestria has magic and the human world doesn't thing. That's what I though too. But yes I think there is just a different side to Twighlight's element than there being a whole new element.


I enjoy your insights on the show and think they're very much on the mark...Bro-Hoof


that's interesting but i think that the normal sunset should go to the pony world and that the normal twilight should go to the human world


I guess since there is a human Twilight, there is a human Sunset Shimmer. But Hasbro didn't give us any clues if there is a human Sunset Shimmer.... which is weird. Hey, what if human Sunset Shimmer went to equestria because she knew she was already replaced with pony Sunset Shimmer... but I'm pretty sure there's a 0% chance of that happening.


I think that if Sunset Shimmer was an element, it'd be the element of Adaption. She didn't do so much forgiveness as adaption i think.


What would they do with the episodes if the human twilight went into the pony world?<br>They have never put equestria girls into the my little pony episodes. I think they are going to keep equestria girls specifically for the movies.

What would they do with the episodes if the human twilight went into the pony world?
They have never put equestria girls into the my little pony episodes. I think they are going to keep equestria girls specifically for the movies.


Your right it would be balanced since theres 2 in both worlds. That makes complete sense.

Also it might be possible she could be the 7th element. Maybe there will be a episode/movie with her CREATING the 7th element and changing the rest of the universe.


That makes sense, but if there are 2 of the same characters in one world, wouldn't other characters confuse them with the original character in the world? Like if the human twilight went to equestria, there would be 2 twilights in one world. And as in canterlot high, when the original twilight crossed worlds, at the end she did end up going back to equestria to return the crown and go home. Am I right? So if human twilight went to equestria, wouldn't she have a desire to go back to the human world? Leaving no sunset shimmer in equestria.


If Sunset was the 7th element (which I think she is) she would be the element of hope. But being me I have no idea!


😢 😭 thank you for the information about Ponyville you cleared my eyes


it would really make sense is there was a 7th element, but why element of friendship? i know its every were like twilight said, but it does not make much sense. to me, since sunset shimmer try's to encourage the mane six ( like in rainbow rocks ) so that means the her element might have something to do with helping and encouragement.<br>plz reply if you dont agree with me and tell me your idea.

it would really make sense is there was a 7th element, but why element of friendship? i know its every were like twilight said, but it does not make much sense. to me, since sunset shimmer try's to encourage the mane six ( like in rainbow rocks ) so that means the her element might have something to do with helping and encouragement.
plz reply if you dont agree with me and tell me your idea.


No no no,  there can't be an element of friendship, because the whole reason of the elements is friendship so she would represent the element of forgiveness.


If Sunset Shimmer is an element, I would like her to be the element of responsiblity


If there's two Twilight's in Equestria, that probably will make things confusing just the same in the human world if there's to Sunset Shimmer's!


I'd really prefer if pony Sunset went back home to the equestria. It's weird for there to be two Sunsets in one place. I wouldn't want for human Sunset to go live in equestria as a pony either. Wouldn't human Sunset miss being home, eating meat, or using a toilet? It's like with the fandom making pony personas of themselves. Just because they made a pony version of themselves doesn't mean they want to become an actual horse and live like that forever.


In an interview published on Equestria Daily someone said that Meghan thinks that the element of Sunset Shimmer is the empathy.


I thought something magical like a gem was going to appear after the the movie which would have been her element after her signature was put in the rainbow


I think human sunset will go back to Equestria. Two of the same pony will be confusing, and there should be one of each character in each world. Besides, if human twilight went to Equestria, she would be trapped there for 30 moons or disappear cuz she doesn't belong there. Just sayin'.


I think that sence the pony sunset came to the human world and the human sunset and human twilght are there in order to regain balance the human sunset should go threw the portal to make sure theres no clones. But thats my guess.


Don't you think that it will be wired to have two of them in each world ?


yes i belive sunset could be the 7 element because only elements can get wings etc in the human world


It would  be even more balanced if original sunset shimmer went to Exestia and then there would be one of each still one knowing about friendship and one not 😀


But also sunsets element could be the forgotten element of forgiveness


I agree but  when Twilight gets her castle she is named The princess of friendship so her element would be friendship and sunset would be named magic. plus when the rainbow appears in R.R it show the element teaser or that sunset is an different form of Twilight. :{)


<br>Well the rainbow actually had the colours of the ponies bodies not the elements and they didn't use the elements to defeat the dazzlings they used music but I think sunset is the element of magic in the human world like you said


I agree it's just that instead of it looking like twilight sparkle's it should more look like a sun with yellow and red like her cutie mark Like everybody else


The jewel that Celestia wears around her neck could be the other element


Wouldn't it be kinda weird having TWO Twilights?


Sunset is the 7th element of harmony.I think her element is or would be in a shape of the Sun.The element of Peace maybe.✔✅☑


If that double twilights in Equestria ever happens....I can already see fanfic writers shipping Twilight with....Twilight....


Oh my gosh! I want to marry this barony! Your brilliant!!!!


i think ur right! great job detective!!!!


I disagree wuth this theory because as Celestia said all ponies have magic they just use in different ways like pegasis use them to control weather earth ponies could tend the land better than other races and  unicorn can  channel the magic through their horns Sunset is from Equestria so she has equestrian magic she brought that magic with her  and it is still wothin her...


Ummm..... If sunset was the 7th element... It would probably be a mystery one and the elements would be useless with out all of them together... But nice theory


also for my previous comment if there where 2 twilight's in 1 world wouldn't that change the balance of the universe.


What if sunset shimmer was the evil element of magic but it changed and to the element of forgiveness and maybe the same with Luna and discord and maybe tikreks brother now this might seem crazy but maybe the theory is true like it was there  destiny but  when they turned evil the evil elements just gave them what they represent if they were good and and when they turned good it changed the element so if it's true 2 more villains would need to be reformed


repentance is a good element for sunset shimer(I think so!)


Wasent derpy gonna be 7th element becuase she helped alot the main six and she was allways with them...? I'm confused😂
Maybe... She would be 8th...
Lol nope.
But think about it...
She would be the element of acceptence becuase the main six accepter her and became their friend,leaving behind her "problems" or "derpyness" (KAWAII) ... Ok I'm sooo CANNON🎉
1. Magic
2. Honesty
3. Loyalty
4. Kindness
5. Laughter
6. Generosity
7. Forgiveness
8. Acceptence..?


I liked the theory about the seventh color Sunset Shimmer added but why red?I mean each one of the main six, added her skin color but not Sunset.Her skin color is not red but some sort of brown, yellow and orange.


i believe that sunset simmer is the 7th element of forgiveness she would be great in the main then it would be called the main seven


Sunset wouldn't be the element of friendship because of twilight is princess of friendship and wouldn't be the leader of mane six in the human world because if the pony world has Twilight it wouldn't make since of the 5 in the human world like the pony world without Twilight. I think it would be mixed up for Sunset is replaced as Twilight in the human world.


I think sunset shimmer is the 7th element of harmony wich i think is the element of forgivness and hasbro did a vid that sunset has powers and has wings wich means that hasbro is up to something<br>


So does that mean Twilight and sunset shimmer share the same element of friendship


She might because you can see on twilights cutiemark it like there is another star under maybe it represents sunset shimmer and it's like it's yet to be uncovered<br>


Amazing but I think it will be the human sunset shimmer


Your theory is really agreeable. Since magic does not exist in the human world except if pony Twilight is there, the element of Friendship would replace it. And also, since the human Twilight stays in the city and the human Sunset hasn't been seen yet, pony Sunset would totally replace pony Twilight's position in the human Mane 6. But, will the human Sunset be seen in a new EG movie? And what will happen if pony Sunset returns to Equestria?


Seems reasonable to me, but I might have the human sunset shimmer in Equestria... no reason


if one of the human Twilight or Sunset Shimmer would come to the pony world wouldn't make more sense if human Sunset came so there would be 1 of each in each world? i know this is a late comment but please reply.


she can be the seventh element of harmony because i saw a seventh element in spikes pile during when he was a big dragon  there will six elements before but plus 1 that seven we may not have heard of this element or  it can be a Easter egg both are likely we shall never know <br>you may think this theory is wrong but it is just a theory so don't get mad or happy if this is wrong or right i just thought it was a good  idea to build on

she can be the seventh element of harmony because i saw a seventh element in spikes pile during when he was a big dragon  there will six elements before but plus 1 that seven we may not have heard of this element or  it can be a Easter egg both are likely we shall never know
you may think this theory is wrong but it is just a theory so don't get mad or happy if this is wrong or right i just thought it was a good  idea to build on


Non princess twilight as a pony????? Awesome idea!


maybe your right but still we have not seen the human sunset yet .


Nope its cadence ,they say the 7th element is love ,so yeah


I think you're right and there's also that  since the represent the rainbow and there should be seven colors in total


there are now 7 elements of harmony. sunset shimmer is the element of ambition


I think this is very intresting...........i never thought that it WOULD be them element of forgivness but NOPE might acctually be friendship


:O OH MY GOD! SUNSET SHIMMER COULD BE THE 7TH ELEMENT OF HARMONY! But.....( Yes, There's always a but XD) wouldn't that mean instead of the mane six....there would be the mane 7!? :O


i think she would have discovery,you do need to discover a few things, don't you.


Red: Sunset Shimmer, Element of Bravery.
Orange: Apple Jack, Element of Honesty
Yellow: Fluttershy, Element of Kindness
Green: (Erm... does not even exist. Lol.)
Blue: Rainbow Dash, Element of Loyalty
Purple: Twilight Sparkle, Element of Friendship
Last but not least, Pink: Pinkie Pie, Element of Laughter


After I saw Rainbow Rocks,  I would keep thinking that Sunset Shimmer would be Twilight in the human world. Since the real Twilight had to go back to Equestria. Then I saw the trailer for the 3rd one and got really confused. Although I do remember Pinkie Pie asking Twilight if she had a twin sister who lives in the city in the first movie. This is all getting really confusing. Would Pony Twilight meet the human Twilight? What would happen if they did met? I have so many questions to ask. I need help.


If sunset shimmer is the 7th element that would be AWESOME plus on rainbow rock her color was in the rainbow so PLZ LET HER BE THE 7TH ELEMENT HASBRO DX<br>


Before me and my friends said Mabry sunset shimmer could be the element of forgiveness!


Somepony needs to write a Sunset parody of Discord!


Anyway, you think the me and the other sunset shimmers on YouTube really deserve an element of harmony?


I don't care if she does or doesn't have an element, I want pony shimmer dammit...


i think that sunset shimmer isn't the 7th element because she never really came back to Equestria to have a role in season 5. Plus I don't really want her to join the main 6 because I like the way it is. What could her element  be? Courage? I think it would be courage... But however if she does join the main 6 Hasbro would have to make her element key. Which is too late as they already defeated Tirek and got a castle. AND for each of the ponies they got their own chair to sit on. They can't just create a chair for sunset can they? Sunset should come back to Equestria but not join the main 6. Maybe make another group of friends. And when it comes to episodes of season 5 she should contribute with the main 6. Or maybe have her own episode. So i don't think shes that ready to be the 7th element :) Brony notion please read my opinion<br>as it will help alot !

i think that sunset shimmer isn't the 7th element because she never really came back to Equestria to have a role in season 5. Plus I don't really want her to join the main 6 because I like the way it is. What could her element  be? Courage? I think it would be courage... But however if she does join the main 6 Hasbro would have to make her element key. Which is too late as they already defeated Tirek and got a castle. AND for each of the ponies they got their own chair to sit on. They can't just create a chair for sunset can they? Sunset should come back to Equestria but not join the main 6. Maybe make another group of friends. And when it comes to episodes of season 5 she should contribute with the main 6. Or maybe have her own episode. So i don't think shes that ready to be the 7th element :) Brony notion please read my opinion
as it will help alot !


well I think there movie like that they are going to bring her into it like in the one before rainbow rocks but just plain equestrian girls pinkie says "do u have a twin that looks exactly like that with the same exact dog like that?" twilight answers "maybe" but pinkie can also break time and space know exactly what twilight did in each world and stuff so I guess that is just pinkie.


Personally, i do think sunset shimmer would be another element. I mean seriously, if the elements of harmony only work with a few certain ponies, then why wouldn't she be? I mean if sunsets magic worked just as well as twilight, wouldn't that mean she would be another singular leader of the elements of harmony. Now, this also brings up the fact of there names. Twilight and sunset. Twilight is the stars, and before you get the stars, you get a sunset. This is personally my theory, hope you can look over this!


i agree she is replacing twilight in the human world...


I was actually going to your channel to tell you about this, lol i guess great minds think alike<br>


This theory makes loads of sense. Bronyman97


No one can replace twilight . plus he can't just use twilights cutie mark and change it  another color.


Sunset Should Defiantly be the Seventh element!!! what Hasbro is doing is just making us all say SUNSET IS ELEMENT 7!!!!!!!! honestly this NEEDs to happen!


I'm wondering... what if Sunset Shimmer from human world doesn't exist/isn't a human? ( like alternate Rose from Doctor Who)


I have one thing I don't agree with.  That there should be two of each in the same world no I think that the human sunset should go to equestria not stay


I like your theory, but i think that sunset shimmers element should be the element of understanding. Because she didn't really forgive anyone, but everyone forgave her for talking over everybody and trying to takeover equestria. I think she should be the element of understanding because she understood what was wrong in equestrian girls 2, when the mane 6 didn't. Do u see where I am going with this? even though sunset is still learning about friendship, but she would still be the element of understanding. In your previous video, u said that the only one that understood twilight was sunset, thus proving that she could have the element of forgiveness!


You're getting old because I hear Freiiiiiiends ALL THE TIME WHEN IT SAYS THE BRONY NATION!


I have  a feeling that she will become the element of forgiveness


But isn't Princess Twilight the princess of friendship so sunset couldn't really be the element of friendship when that is kind of Twilights job as a princess and friend.


She is the 7th element!!!! Don't care what peeps say she is definitely the 7th element


I think sunset shimmer will be the seventh element


Brony why would you think of a seventh element and why would sun set shimmer not go back to  equestria?<br>


Two twilights in the same universe do you even watch doctor who 2 reasons y that would never happen 1 IT WOULD TEAR THE UNIVERSE APART number 2 anything in equestra girls and friendship is magic don't support each other so if you don't see equestra girls friendship is magic it will still make sense


Sunset shimmer will forever with no doubt stay in CHS FOREVER!!!! It's just not right Twilight is Equestrias main 6 leader<br>


I was just wondering how isn't there two sunset shimmers in the human world


I never thought about the human sunset shimmer


OMG how do you think that their could be 2 of each ponie/person in each work that doesn't make sense and also how could sunset shimmer be the element of friendship because twilight is the princess of friendship!

Pleas is there anyone else who agrees with me?!


Sunset Shimmer is who I consider the Golbez of My Little Pony.


I agree  that sunset shimmer  But wouldn't  it make  sense  that the human  sunset  simmer  go to equestria  <br>


i like your idea I have been wondering myself what happened to the original human sunset shimmer and the original twilight sparkle I have an idea human pinkiepie when she first met twilight asked if she had a twin sister living in the city and had a dog just like hers that is where the original human twilight is but where is the original sunset shimmer I have an idea that maybe the original sunset shimmer is somewhere in equestria she left canterlot high when pony sunset showed up


I think that sunnset is living in the city with original twilight


Just realised that ofcurse their is as "real" Sunset shimmer cause the one we know is from equestria!  It makes sense now!!!<br>(It dident when i wachted it the first time)

Just realised that ofcurse their is as "real" Sunset shimmer cause the one we know is from equestria!  It makes sense now!!!
(It dident when i wachted it the first time)


Wouldn't be weird with 2 Twilights and 2 Sunset Shimmers???


i think that there is only one twilight but 2 of all the other mane 6.


In one of my made up stories ( story number 55 out of 70 stories ) went back to equestria.


I Think SUnset Shimmer Of Cantorlot High Will Go


Its possible but in the human world there is another twilight.


Well instead of friendship how about forgiveness:
its because in the first eg sunset was evil but in the end the mane 6 FORGIVED her
so in my locations if she was the 7th element there would be NOT a mane 6 but a
mane 7 and when celetestria (idk how to spell it lol) and luna died or moved to another world and never came back Candance and twilight will be the new rulers BUT if she
moved too or died than sunset shimmer WILL be next in line and she will be the 5th princess
(that's how I think so don't judge meh)

wow there is so many suggestions on sunset's  element and many options ;3

Maybe redemption because in sunset shimmer's song my past is not today, it shows how there is another side to her, and also her cutie mark shows the ying and yang symbol (as the two sides dark and light, evil and good) so I think if she was the bearer of the seventh element it might be redemption.

@Erica Jo Nuguid Element of Humility maybe?

@Erica Jo Nuguid I also don't know how to spell princess candance lol


Lol, thats what me an dmy friend Derrel where talking about the other day!


How about the human sunset shimmer goes to equstria, while human twilight and pony sunset shimmer stays in the human world


Lol you took a reference from one of my fav movies


i think human sunset will go 2 equestria.


i thinks that sunset shimmer is coll she should be the7th element of harmony<br>

الامين عثمان


You spoiled Enchanted for me THANKS. I was going to watch that


Maybe human  sunset shimmer will become a pony, to avoid a paradox of the humans versions or pony versions meeting each other.


YES YES YES SUNSET IS THE 7TH ELEMENT OF HARMONY YAY!!! (everypony is looking at me) ummm... Princesss cadence was the one screaming.... (runs away) Princess Cadence: ...... Sunset Shimmer: i'm the 7th element? Me: (comes back) yes you are and i said that... Sunset Shimmer: (hugs faniashy) Me: (throws sunset's element to her) THERE NOW STOP HUGGING ME!!!! DX


Sunset Is The Element Of Forgiveness In The Human World. And She Is The Element Of Magic In The Pony World. But Friendship=Magic So I Think That Twilight Ans Sunset Are Secretly Related But Nopony Knows...


your a bit off the new movie is coming out
eqeustria girls friendship games the normal
twilight also has magic and if sunset shimmer
stayed in pony world there would have been
no sunset thats why we never saw the normal twilight in the first two movies


part of this I'm like what and another part I'm like yeah


What new elements could come? Trust, Forgiveness and what else?

@Emilie Birch If you haven't yet read the comics do so. There is a short series where in a different world there are other elements. While not all are shown it is shown that Trixie is the element of humility, discord the element of order and chrysalis the element of love or purity (can't remember exactly)

@Emilie Birch Humility. Being humble is important among friends. If you view yourself as better, then you cant be equals.


Maybe sunset shimmer didn't have a human she could have never existed because sunset shimmer had traveled there to many time or she locked her up some were.


No I am the 7th element 😡😋😑 the element of love!


<b>nosebleed</b> i have no idea, my mind is blowing

*nosebleed* i have no idea, my mind is blowing


Me and my sis think that's a good thirey


Not to be rude or anything but sunset shimmer  does not replace Twilight in the human world that job goes to human twilight


i thought it would be forgiveness too 0:21


friend:...3....2......1 me:BRUH i could write a fanfic about da the human world.....we can fix i----i mean do it yea (bob the builder reference for the win)


when i mena pont twi i mean human twi  who going to be unicorn not alicorn twi


wow that makes since nice job I agree also who else is watching this in july


In the human world the human Sunset Shimmer world go to the pony world and she would become friends with pony Twilight Sparkle and pony Sunset Shimmer will stay in the human world and make friends with human Twilight Sparkle and show her the magic of friendship and friendship is magic


why is there not a twllight in the human world???


That … ...................:.made no sense but it made sense ya get me????       .0.


Nope the 7th is discord what stop looking at me like that


Wat would sunset shimmer look in pony ville

@Leoni2468 Leoni2468 she was shown at the beginning of EG 1


I thought her as memories .. but like you say it's just a suggestion (opinion)<br>