By writing this, I found another interesting idea.
1. Magic of friendship didn't work the first time - it does make sense if it won't work simply by yelling it out(twilight was sure it'll work).
2. In the end, the main blast happened AFTER Sunset Shimmer joined the group.
- Remember "Return of harmony"? When mane six started to shoot their element marks at Discord, and only when Twilight bound them together... so the final blast was fully charged...
- In EQ2 girls also started shooting their marks, then Twilight started charging Friendship Laser... seems to be lacking one little element finally awoken.

That makes me think:
- Events in EG1 caused to ANOTHER element of friendship started to form(or, to be precise - to form into one separate element). Also, they might've left a spark of 'energy' causing girls to transform on their own by performing music(something of representing their elements here, too - like not playing too fast for Rainbow and hearing Rarity at rare occasions clearly(giving her db's to other).
- Twilight is a bond to other elements, explaining and... taking it herself too much("I MUST'VE know everything! T_T"). Magic fits here perfectly like the result of all elements being formed together.
- The star on the crown has six points, with one being unoccupied. A possibility for a new element? No, too weak - the tree's design not allowing that for me.
- The element of Forgiveness makes sense. Compared to the moments mane six got their elements to a new level(a.k.a. Knowing the side effects and tricky moments PLUS teaching other ponies(and breezies) - if Sunset herself started to think twice about other's behavior and letting it go PLUS! pada-pada-tss, TEACHING others how to forgive other's mistakes and pointing on 'they changed and sorry, why not give them a second chance'

Long post, and english isn't my native T_T


Hmm. Interesting theory. I personally have a different one myself. My theory is that Sunset Shimmer is actually one of many lost Elements of Harmony. My full theory is this: Many centuries ago, there were many, many Elements of Harmony utilized by the ancient kings and queens of Equestrian to maintain peace and prosperity throughout their realm. These included the Elements of Love, Hope, Trust, Courage, Tranquility, Strength, Support, and Mercy. However, that all changed when a certain Lord of Chaos decided to shake things up a bit.
Discord plunged Equestrian into chaos, and it was up to the royals to stop him. Utilizing the vast number of Elements, the Equestrians waged a generation-long war against Discord, but could never beat him. During the war, all the Elements were thought to be destroyed... all except, that is, six of the strongest: Honesty, Kindness, Laughter, Generosity, Loyalty, and Magic. Celestial and Luna, the last of the royal bloodline, used all of these Elements at once to defeat Discord and restore order to the land.
The war was won, but the world had become distorted by Discord's corruption, needing to be cared for manually by the creatures living in it. (Save for very particular areas like the Everfree Forest) The rest of the Elements were thought to be gone forever... until they resurface within ponies seen today.


Ive been reading comments and want to discuss something. Since you need frienship (Sunset) or magic (Twilight) to keep the elements of harmony together they each have to remain in different dimensions or at least until the human dimension magic and friendship take their place. Twilight's Cutie mark as we all know has 5 white star around it that represent her friends, a purple star which is the element of magic and her self, and another white star behind the purple one. Could this one be Sunset Shimmer and the reason she's in the back is because she remains in the Canterlot High dimension.

Could this be possible? And if so, is it possible that a pony's cutie mark to change in case Sunset ever returns to Equestria according to this theory?


I think you do have a good point. After all, only bearers of the magic of friendship in the human world should be the ones who grow the tail things and ears and/or not, wings. Sunset Shimmer did actually get her ears and tail, so that should mean she is the 7th element of harmony, but only in the human world. She makes up for Twilight. That is what I think.


Well, so far the Equestria Girls movies have been entirely self-contained. So unless that changes, I can't see any of the ponies from the human world ending up in Ponyville, or at least, not for any longer than the duration of a single movie.

Though I suppose the notion of the movies being entirely separate and self-contained could change.


This is a great theory! Although, the ending had me confused, how is it logical that Two of each would Stay in each world? The rest of the pony mane six couldn't come With Twilight, since they could upset the balance, how can two twilights then be balanced? I have a feeling a Third movie Will come eventually, and explain human Twilight, but for now, those are my thoughts.

@Hannah Sarah<br>that's because the pairs haven't met. that will change in EG 3.

@Hannah Sarah
that's because the pairs haven't met. that will change in EG 3.


No. She's just able to use Magic alongside Twilight. If there was a seventh element, the elements would never have worked for Twilight and the other five the other three times they used them, nor the time they were used against Discord and Sombra by Luna and Celestia.
There would also have been a seventh part on that tree.
The ponies are not "the elements", they can merely call upon them, and channel their magic through the physical manifestation of that element.


I just finish re watching Twilight's kingdom and at the end of the song Play your part; there is a faint red line. Maybe before there wasn't a need for a seventh element! I think we are seeing the process of a new element being born! It fits with a theory about the tree of harmony. I don't think the sun cutie mark on the tree is Celestia's. Because it got a strange S line down the middle and is two-tone also.

I think that mark is hinting at sunset shimmer.


I think that you should consider analyzing Sunset Shimmer's cutie mark. Taking a closer look at the potential meaning of it might help shed light on certain things, such as why she was chosen to be Celestia's pupil and what her destiny really is.


See, my thought is she'd be either Forgiveness, like you said, or Redemption.<br>But being Friendship would balance it out, 6 and 6.

See, my thought is she'd be either Forgiveness, like you said, or Redemption.
But being Friendship would balance it out, 6 and 6.


I personally think that the human form of sunset shimmer will ultimately be the one that goes to Pony twilight's world because it is the very idea  of two versions of one person being in the same world that could have very catastrophic consequences!<br>The first consequence of the idea is that the human version of sunset shimmer could move to where pony version of sunset shimmer is and be very curious as to where pony version of her self came from! And that is all I want to go over as of right now

 I personally think that the human form of sunset shimmer will ultimately be the one that goes to Pony twilight's world because it is the very idea  of two versions of one person being in the same world that could have very catastrophic consequences!
The first consequence of the idea is that the human version of sunset shimmer could move to where pony version of sunset shimmer is and be very curious as to where pony version of her self came from! And that is all I want to go over as of right now


as it may seem that would be logical, i doubt the writers would put both twilight's and sunset shimmers into the same worlds as there counter parts for good as it may cause confusion and easily cause cases of mistaken identity, however i could see them writing so sunset shimmer from equestria would have to take the human twilight under her her wing to show her the path of friendship and have human sunset accidentally come over causing irreversible damage to the mirror, thus not only needing to learn about friendship but also how to control her magic and adjust to equestrian life. . . if this type of thing were to happen i might be able to see the main six in the human world seeking out human twilight for help to get a brainiac bookworms point of view on how to get her back while the poneys tried to help from there end as well.


..Well considering it was corrected in the season 4 finale that Twilight's element is NOT Magic but instead Friendship and the fact that there can't be two of the same character in either world together or else the fabric of space and time would just explode all over..<br>When I saw the movie, I thought Sunset as the element of Music, the powerful magic used through out the film and what ultimately brought the mane 6 together at the end allowing them to defeat the sirens..

..Well considering it was corrected in the season 4 finale that Twilight's element is NOT Magic but instead Friendship and the fact that there can't be two of the same character in either world together or else the fabric of space and time would just explode all over..
When I saw the movie, I thought Sunset as the element of Music, the powerful magic used through out the film and what ultimately brought the mane 6 together at the end allowing them to defeat the sirens..


You my friend make a very great point? I mean...afterall we have two worlds that are counterparts of eachother so this definitely means that the human world has a real sunset shimmer which is still a mystery and we find out that there is a real human twilight in the human world, so i have a bad feeling that the sunset shimmer who came from equestria sees the real one and if the real human twilight find out about the whole magic stuff thats been happening it'll be both a very strange event and a big problem that will upset the balance between worlds. not to mention both the names of twilight and sunset both mean the center between light and darkness yet they both now have different roles, twilight understands friendship but sunset still has much to learn even though she has her own friends.


The show has been getting a bit on the lackluster side. The characters have already been so much it is hard to do stories that don't feel like rehash. Sunset Shimmer would definitely shake things up, but it would be odd from the mythos standpoint.


... Mind blown. I love this theory. It's AMAZING.


This does make sense but if u think about it two theories come up.
1-maybe Sunset Shimmer also represents magic since both her and Pony Twilight were Princess Celestia's students in magic but since Sunset Shimmer became evil and left early she couldn't finish her training.
2- she could also be the element of compassion because she seemed very compassionate to her friends even thought she never really had a special part in the mane-6 until the end. She did seem very compassionate throughout the battle of the bands.


I believe that Sunset is the 7th mane. At first during the 2nd movie at the sneak peek, when the 3 ominous girls barged in the cafeteria singing this seductive song, I thought the song has got to Sunset and she was gonna betray the mane human 6. But she proved me wrong. She now has a pure heart and would never do these bad deeds again :)


also,it works with their cutie marks too. twilight, a star in the night, sunset shimmer, the sun of the day. It even makes sense with their names.


in the journal of the 2 sisters they tell you the answer. star swirl told them about the tree of harmony and how powerful it is. the 2 sisters thought that if they put there castle there they would be strong .[they were planning where to put there castle.] and they also met the same manitore from the pilot. luna can talk to the manitore.  star swirl thought the 2 sisters. because there alicorns obviously!


Am I the only one who thinks Sunset Shimmer should've been the main character instead of Twilight, but with a secret past as a villian that she tries to hide and maybe has flashbacks from? It would teach a good moral to kids (Well, a better version of the EQG enemy>friend moral. That one was a bit dodgy imo). I dunno, just thought that would be cool.


I think Sunset is the element of redemption. Trixie is more suited for the element of forgiveness


I think your thought is actually possible.  It is showing that the movies are getting to be cannon to the TV show series due to that fact.  Show it can be possible that during one of the moon's time that allowed the first movie to happen, may happen again for either a movie or a tv show which will blow everyone's mind ^^


one I think Sunset Shimmers element maybe the element of something like Hope, Faith, or Belief because in the beginning sunset lost hope in herself and twilight helped her back and she gave the girls faith in rainbowrocks when the girls where fighting. I also believe that the human sunset shimmer maybe the one to go or already is in equestria to protect the balance


I think this theory is really onto something. However, and this by far is nothing final, I would like to point out that in the book version of Rainbow Rocks, Sunset Shimmer grew wings. Why was this not in the movie? Perhaps because it will be explained later in the show...?

I think the part of the theory where one of the humans go to the pony world is pretty sound. However, that doesn't mean it's likely to happen (MLP with sound logic... Doubtful)


Who else thinks that Sunset Shimmer will have a real roll in season 5 of MLP FIM?


But Sunset's element wouldn't be a star shape right? I kinda expected it to be in the shape of a curvey sun


I never thought about it before!  I think you have a point ♥ (and by the way. . You are AWESOME!!)


If exist a human Twilight, exist a human Sunset. But, in Equestria this issue is more complicated. As Ying & Yang, opposites from a same complement: Celestia & Luna. Sun and moon. And... seems that we found a next Equestrian Princesses: Twilight as the sun, and Sunset as the moon. So, Sunset Shimmer must come back soon to Equestria. Their character have a great potential.<br>This is my little conjecture.

If exist a human Twilight, exist a human Sunset. But, in Equestria this issue is more complicated. As Ying & Yang, opposites from a same complement: Celestia & Luna. Sun and moon. And... seems that we found a next Equestrian Princesses: Twilight as the sun, and Sunset as the moon. So, Sunset Shimmer must come back soon to Equestria. Their character have a great potential.
This is my little conjecture.


I do not think the Human Twilight will go to Equestia   I think she will gain the Element of Magic for the Human  but the idea of a 7th Element has already been reviled   its Love.   In the card game  Princess Cadiance is said to hold the Element of Love. and Love is the 7th Element.   Now  I do believe Sunset Shimmer will gain an Element  as for the human version it will be nice to see were they go with her.   Then again  Even though ever one in Equestria has a Human countpart so far   We not seen one of the Zebra Girl (At less I did not see her)   so  Sunset Shimmer might have trained under Princess Celestria  she might not be from Equestria   she might come from a Distant land were she does not have a Human counterpart or at less 1 not at or around the school. Also there are many characters we not seen human version of yet either  Princess Cadiance or Shining Armor.   The Mayor, and many others so it could be safe to say for now at less the Sunset Shimmer's human version does not live near by.  If this is the case it would also be a case to say  we might never see her.


i think that your theory is perfect and hopefully they make a 3rd movie so they can explain this


I think Sunset Shimmer is like Ken from Digimon the parallels are almost scary they were both villains turns good guys both had a period of self regret and most importantly of all they had an amazing self realization moment that let them let go of the past both were handled extremely well as a hero but were eh as villains. I say this all to say that Sunset should be an element holder man I would love watching Sunset and  Twilight


That's a nice theory brony notion although I would like to see watt Equestria Girls 3 would do with the original human Twilight Sparkle. Then again if Sunset Shimmer does become the 7th element, I really hope she goes back to Equestria with Twilight Sparkle n become a pony again. I think she'd make a nice addition to her old home again. N if U take requests or already have a theory in thought, I wonder watts gonna happen to the Dazzlings in the future. Idk.


i've heard that equestria girls will be getting it own show now

オオカミ王の目Ōkami-ō no me


I think sunset shimmers element would be the element of acceptance because they accepted her even after she almost took over equestria and the school


Well, there's always Season 5 of My Little Pony! Maybe you can get clues from there!


The colors in the rainbow don't correspond to their Element colors, they're their coat colors, but since Sunset's is too much like Applejack and Fluttershy's, she gets red.


I wouldn't be surprised if Twilight and Sunset are pulling an Optimus and Ultra Magnus did in RID 2001 and they are both sharing the Element if Friendship somehow (just like Optimus and Magnus ended up sharing the Matrix of Leadership in that series)


I think you're onto something with this theory. We'll just have to wait for Hasbro and Faust.


i think this will be temporary, being that they are two of the same ponies, it would be easy to teach each other friendship.<br>once they have been taught friendship, human twilight would go back to the human world with pony sunset, since she has a bond with the other humans, and human twilight would move to equestria, so the balance would be restored.

i think this will be temporary, being that they are two of the same ponies, it would be easy to teach each other friendship.
once they have been taught friendship, human twilight would go back to the human world with pony sunset, since she has a bond with the other humans, and human twilight would move to equestria, so the balance would be restored.


I know all secrets of c.h.s but your solution was in front of you if you remember the elements of harmony banish all evil but the Dazzlings are still intact so what I'm trying to say is the Dazzlings know all seven elements and possibly need to go find the way back to equestria and destroy the pony that represents the seventh element.


I think that we should now more about Sunset in season 5


the hints for season 5 say " will she be prepared for this? "


She could be, I mean one of the most important element of friendship is forgiveness


What would the name of the 7th element be?

Forgiveness? Redemption?


What if the human Sunset Shimmer went into the pony world instead of the human Twilight. Wouldn't this make things not as confusing? As Twilight said, "Better not. It would be kind of confusing if Canterlot High suddenly have two of all of you!" So, wouldn't it be confusing if Equestria suddenly had two Twilight Sparkles? Why couldn't there just be one Twilight and one Sunset Shimmer in each dimension. And, kind of going off topic, but what is the third dimension that Twilight started talking about in the scene in "Rainbow Rocks" when she created the portal opening up, and describing how she will open up the portal. Isn't it sort of strange to you?


Sunset could be the element of forgiveness or friendship since she and twilight are from equestria and were celestia's students she may return


I completely agree with you and I love sunset shimmer!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


no, actually, i think Pony sunset should go into equestria. and become alicorn. and become princess. princess of....sunset time??? idk but i want pony sunset and pony twilight to be together<br>although then human sunset would not have a clue about the whole 5 girls-magic-of-friendship thingie...ARGH! AGAIN, E.G GETTING TO MA HEEEAAADDD!!!!!

no, actually, i think Pony sunset should go into equestria. and become alicorn. and become princess. princess of....sunset time??? idk but i want pony sunset and pony twilight to be together
although then human sunset would not have a clue about the whole 5 girls-magic-of-friendship thingie...ARGH! AGAIN, E.G GETTING TO MA HEEEAAADDD!!!!!


LET'S JUST GET ONE THING STRAIGHT:

In rainbow rocks Twilight Sparkle Said:
"Now I can use the mirror when i need to"


How is sunset shimmer the element of friendship? Since u mentioned "many many times" that friendship =magic and friendship makes it all complete, what about in the first movie? And wouldn't she be the element of restoration? Because she became a new person,and in doing so she restored her past and what she did bad, she made up for it


also 7th element was a lost element that the two sisters didn't know about but the maker of the elements knew and he or she was the only one that knew about the secret element


maybe the new element be booster, like what do with zero no tsukaima ,they have new power to help on later adventures


See, I don't think there ever WAS an alternate Sunset.

I do't think the "Human" world is a direct parallel. Maybe I'll be proven wrong in the future, but I'm sticking by it until that time.


Very interesting theory I could learn a lot from him new thing to watch and learn of mlp sweet


In a episode with the tree of harmony there was a sun element somewhere on the tree and sunset shimer has a sun cutie mark so she could be that sun element


Wouldn't it be creepy having 2 of sunsets in the human world and then having 2 twilight in the pony world??? Also it will be confusing just like twilight said in the beginning of rainbow rocks


can you do a video on:<br>in EG and rainbow rocks why dose twilight keep her wings and not her horn?

can you do a video on:
in EG and rainbow rocks why dose twilight keep her wings and not her horn?


well there is this one theory that Sunset Shimmer actually killed her human counterpart to maintain her place there


I think it would be far more logical if the true human Twilight remained in the human world. There is far more balance in there being a "soul exchange" of the same character than allowing two of the same to co-exist in the same world. It would make much for sense for human Twilight to learn about friendship from pony!Sunset and the main five than send her to Equestria to interact with her doppelganger and then stay there. Likewise for human!Sunset.


I think that the 7th Element of Harmony would be courage. (Think about it)


What if sunset shimmer is a tool to get the human Twilight to canterlot high? At the beginning of the season Twilight wasn't interested in friendship until Celestia sent her to ponyvile and she understood the magic of friendship and found the elements of harmony. I'm sure the human twilight is like the old twilight and has no interest in friendship. In the credit clip of Rainbow Rocks she shows interest in the school because something is going on there and that's because of Sunset Shimmer and the pony Twilight Sparkle. Because there is no way for human Luna to become nightmare moon Sunset Shimmer could be there to bring the human Twilight to canterlot high and help her discover the magic of friendship


I think that human sunset will go through the mirror to the  pony world.😀


Probably is true because there are 6 main ponies or humans and there are 7 colors in a rainbow so if they added sunset shimmer it would make sense<br>


but yes you are right about the red appearing in the rainbow, but if you look back to equestria girls when they defeat her there is red too? why would that be? could you clearify this please? you are alot smarter than me sooo...


I never noitced that there are 2 Sunset Shimmer's. I forgot that's how it worked, but then where is the real human Sunset Shimmer? Is she where the real human Twilight is?


Also celestial must have saw something in her since she taught sunsets shimmer


Sunset shimmer was first a pony then went into chs as she has said that she was celistria prized student at the time


This is wrong. The real thing is probably that twily from the human world works the same as pony. She would be also experienced in friendship. She was probably what pinkie was talking about when she said: "do you have a twin sister that lives in the city with a dog that looks just like yours?". Pinkie knows her!!


Sunset shimmer and twilight sparkles is sisters or real good friends when they were younger but sunset shimmer moved away far from twilight and they nevered see them again but who knows :T they might be sis they might be really good friends. That's what I think of them two :D


omg i could imagine this, when that twilight goes to equestria....they should make a movie of it


I think twilight should stay in ponyville and sunset shimmer can be in the human world so sunset shimmer is the element of forgiveness


I had a feeling that sunset shimmer was the 7th element


I think human sunset would go to equistra, and human twilight would stay where she is.


I think the elements aren't full charged so that is why sunset turned into that and why twilight could not defet trek but I do think if this was true she would be the element of forgiveness


If sunset shimmer was a student of celestia just like twilight..<br>What did she do?

If sunset shimmer was a student of celestia just like twilight..
What did she do?


Legitimately, Rainbows element is already red.


Wow I think on the next movie  there will be 7 elements in the human world  because  twilight said w without the magic you brought back from Equestria there nothing but 3 harmless teenage girls in the human Twilight will not know anything about friendship for the magic can you make a video about that


Sunset shimmer is in the mane 6 because at the end of rainbow rocks she defeated adagio,sonata,and aria with the mane6<br>


i think sunset would be element of magic


In the MLP Movie called "Rainbow Rocks", during the ending, while Sunset Shimmer played, her pony ears appeared. Then they all beat the Dazzlings. Maybe in the future movies or episodes, she could be part of it. But Idk if there is a place for her. In the last episode of season 4, there was a devil bull thingy. He didn't believe about the 4th princess. Just like the 7th element. Hmm.. Imma go reasearching.


I'm back so now let's keep on going I leaved off by saying that in season 5 it starts with the mane six is sitting in there thrones and all of a sudden the cycle changes into a map with has all of equestria and some other lands that they have to travel to but they do not know were they are going so they are a little bit scared of what lies ahead but that is as much as I am going to say but I thank that the map will lead them to the 7 the element if there is ( I will be back in another comment )

there is a thing about season 5 it was kind of like what you said . And in the mlp comics in issue 25 it was like continuing the season 5 thing. Because the season 5 thing stopped in Apploosa. Where Applejack's cousin lives. And the comic continues it starts in Apploosa. I did not read the comics but I saw the first page .So I might be wrong.


I though Sunset Shimmer would be the element of Courage because she was afraid of joining in with the group.


I have no idea but I think your theory is right dude


you seem to be viewing it as a parallel world instead of as an alternate world cause you think the human world has to be similar to Equestria in away which is not wrong but also subdues many other Theories and i also feel the need to tell you how common the idea of "Replacing" Twilight is now same goes for the idea of "Forgiveness" but being "Common" is not wrong either its just "bland" but of course i agree with the fact Sunset Shimmers home is in the human world and Twilights home is in Equestria but i'm sure mostly everyone does
______________________________________________________________________
my own Theory would be "Balance" cause her Cutie Mark has the symbol of yin & yang in it which means "Balance" between good and evil.and cause her 2 other transformations between a Demonic form and Half Pony form which can easily fit into that "Balance Between good and evil thing".then theres the scene before facing the Dazzlings where she brings "Balance" back to the Rainbooms (https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/YlI8xYSuxQB0jukOYEax4-zj_-1DtjKMlbtzCu3laUo=w702-h527)
the other theories i have heard would be "Trustworthiness,Inspiration,Forgiveness,Wisdom,Redemption" but i honestly think "Trustworthiness" can be canceled out cause Twilight had to trust Apple jack when hanging from that hill in episode 1/2 inless thats how the show itself likes to hint at it kinda like the song "Life in Equestria" when it comes to Sunset "Shimmers" name

you seem to be viewing it as a parallel world instead of as an alternate world cause you think the human world has to be similar to Equestria in away which is not wrong but also subdues many other Theories and i also feel the need to tell you how common the idea of "Replacing" Twilight is now same goes for the idea of "Forgiveness" but being "Common" is not wrong either its just "bland" but of course i agree with the fact Sunset Shimmers home is in the human world and Twilights home is in Equestria but i'm sure mostly everyone does
________________________________________________________________________
my own Theory would be "Balance" cause her Cutie Mark has the symbol of yin & yang in it which means "Balance" between good and evil.and cause her 2 other transformations between a Demonic form and Half Pony form which can easily fit into that "Balance Between good and evil thing".then theres the scene before facing the Dazzlings where she brings "Balance" back to the Rainbooms (https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/YlI8xYSuxQB0jukOYEax4-zj_-1DtjKMlbtzCu3laUo=w702-h527)
the other theories i have heard would be "Trustworthiness,Inspiration,Forgiveness,Wisdom,Redemption" but i honestly think "Trustworthiness" can be canceled out cause Twilight had to trust Apple jack when hanging from that hill in episode 1/2 inless thats how the show itself likes to hint at it kinda like the song "Life in Equestria" when it comes to Sunset "Shimmers" name


I believe ur theory is good but it is way off only because as twilight said in Rainbow Rocks if the other main six were to go with her to Equestria High it be be confusing due to have two of each pony which would cause confusion and eventually disharmony. To make ur theory more clear it would be more efficient if human sunset shimmer, the one previously there before the pony version, was to live in ponyville and become the element of FAITH. I say this because after the events in the first film the mane six began to trust her and befriend her. As it came close to the end of the RR sunset shimmer placed her Faith in the mane six to stop the Dazzlings and when they fail they place their Faith in her and allowing her to try and stop them their by activating activating her element of Faith and her as well transforming into her half pony form with the magic of friendship also coursing through her. So in my opinion it would in fact make since if here element was Faith not Friendship since all the element combine to make the magic of friendship any way it just wouldn't make since.


If she is the 7th element some people are already calling her the element of forgiveness


why leave her family to live in a magic pony world?


I think Human Sunset Shimmer will go to Equestria, so there is still balanced. One Sunset and Twi in Equestria, and one Sunset and Twi in Canterlot High.


maybe as sunset shimmer left her world her human counterpart will do the same


That is excacly what I think of the elements


the two can be the element of magic o the can own together.


no sun set will ether be the Element of friendship or ether the Element of understanding i stand my point bc when aj and rarity said somthing about sun set said non taking she did not go all crazy and she would not have been the Elament of magic


it will not work by having 2 ts in the same world becas she could go back and all heck will brake loose so we do not need that but you could have the other sunset in the pony world so it would not work hens sunset would be 7th so she could be the mane and can be a student for one of the princeses or be the 7th so that is what i say.


Mlp is more than just pretty little ponies. It has plot, enjoyment, humor and brain teasers. Mlp is one of the most awesome shows to watch, in my opinion.


That is a good thought but... The human version of twilight does not know that the other exists sooo... That would be a little hard to handle for her especially sense she doesn't know magic exists ether so it would role out a big carpet of problems such as... Would she have magic? Would she be a princess too or even if they would get along I don't know about you but if there was another version of me I would feel pretty threatened by it what are your thoughts Brony Nation???


It will be less confusing if only one of each Sunset Shimmer and Twilight stays in there own world or dimension


Twilight Sparkle-    Magic/Friendship
Rarity-            Generosity
Rainbow Dash-        Loyalty
Fluttershy-        Kindness
Applejack-        Honesty
Pinkie Pie-        Laughter
Trixie-            Humility
Sunset Shimmer-        Repentance
Derpy-            Acceptance
Cheerilee-        Education?
Lyra-            Curiosity
Spitfire-        Leadership
Button's Mother?-    Nurturing?


Wait....why does twilight at 2:18 have pegasus wings?


I think sunset shimer is the element of forgivenes or is it to help...


i think sunset shimmer element is a sun set shaap and light orang colour, because apple jack's element is already orange. is that ok?


good job i didnt even notice the 7th color!!!!!!!!


Sunset new element, yes, same shape, no. Human Twi and Sunset goes to Canterlot High make friends with the human five and stay while pony Sunset goes back to her original home


Sunset and twilight should rule both worlds because sunset shimmer used to be a prize pupil of celestia and so does twilight , and if suset shimmer learns about friendship,then sunset shimmer will tell celestia about what she learned , then celestia will make sunset shimmerjoin in with twilight as a prize pupil and be princess in both worlds , and one more thing is that sunset shimmer started in the pony world just like twilight! Like if you agree dislike if u dis agree, tell me also what part u dint understand what i said.


If i could say one thing it would be a barley understanded what you said about the real human twightlight in equestria


am i the only who wants crystles to be reformed?she could spy on da villans! :D


I saw the new movie she's not a villain anymore I feel bad for her


i dont know which kide of haronmy she can have


Wait a second look when pony sunset shimmer went to stay in the human world that means that the human sunset shimmer will be banished to the pony world and human twilight sparkle will go to help the ponyvalle
Just like the pony version of them see that is right I think since the human twilight is in the city well she will come to the hight school right??
Just like pony twilight


Thinks for that intonation saibla Ray it helps alot


I've all ready heard and seen  that in season 5 of my little pony friendship is magic in the first episode wait I'll have to come back to this ok do you all remember that in the final episode of season 4 ended with the mane six going into there new Castle and you seen six thrones that were in a cycle and in the middle was a cycle with a star on it ok now back to the first episode in season 5 I have to finish this in another comment so be back soon


I thought she would've been love or something like that what about bravery🙆🙆🙆🙆😎😎


It is a grate idea it will make a grate move.


One more thing, Rainbowdash abandoned LighteningDust!! LighteningDust is best pony!


but if there is two of both of them how will you tell wich one is wich


u know what........ I think your right Brony Nation. I THINK that the next Harmony is in the future. think about it her red thing a bling showed up in the Harmony light that came from there magic of the 6. we will never know what comes next in the future u guys. im done to say so see u in a other vid lol bye :)


Um... U lost me at 1:06..... But I do kinda see your point. If anypony can explain it would be much appreciated


So there is another twilight in that world. watch the scene after the credits. That is human twilight. 1. b/c spike doesn't talk. 2. twilight had already left.


it should be a frendsip element for sunset shimer


maybe her element of forgiveness necklace is a yellow sun?<br> If in My little pony exist the 7th Element of Harmony.

maybe her element of forgiveness necklace is a yellow sun?
 If in My little pony exist the 7th Element of Harmony.

is this going of the tree? or something else?


If Sunset Shimmer belongs in the human world.Why did Princess Celestia reference her as one of her student in the first movie of EQ


but what if that worlds sunset shimmer goes to Equestra


No! Sunset is not the 7th element cuz she is a friend of twilight so she be like them but she is NOT the 7th element!!!


Sunset shimmer doesn't belong in the human world! She belongs with twilight.


No not friendship just magic sunset shimmer would be the element of magic because friendship doesn't egsist without all the elements


I think human sunset should live in Equestria and Human twilight in the human world<br>BUT I don't like that theory, with a forienger for each worldd.....i dont like it...sorry, but I...argh! this whole equestria-girls-human-counterpart-concept is blowing my mind and at the same time getting to my head! WAIT i just realised why its called Equestria GIRLS - cus its the ponys from EQUESTRIA, in a different world as human GIRLS (why am i so dumb??!!)

I think human sunset should live in Equestria and Human twilight in the human world
BUT I don't like that theory, with a forienger for each worldd.....i dont like it...sorry, but I...argh! this whole equestria-girls-human-counterpart-concept is blowing my mind and at the same time getting to my head! WAIT i just realised why its called Equestria GIRLS - cus its the ponys from EQUESTRIA, in a different world as human GIRLS (why am i so dumb??!!)


I think you are right but.... i think the jewel will be not a star but a sun like her cutie mark( with 6 or 5 sun beams or what ever)


0:13 wow u read my mind, I was thinking she was forgiveness, BUT I didn't even see that video so...


Acctually, you're cutie mark is explaining stuff, not singing. Not once has anyone heard you sing in you're YouTube videos. I:T


Wel Hasbro  said that equestria girls and mlp are 2 separate things


Wow your right twilight is in equstia and sunset shimmer is in whatever shes in but twilight goes so who is going to be leader so sunset shimmer replaces her it make since  get what i am saying.


You are right. Sunset. Shimmer. Is. The. Last element of. Harmony


. At the end of a rainbow rocks we see normal human Twilight Sparkle just like in the series My Little Pony Friendship is Magic we see the first episode that Twilight has no use for friends only books so regular human Twilight in rainbow Rock has never gone to school cuz she's too smart and that's why we never seen her and why nobody knew who she and spike was Twilight who came to  equestria in the human world through the magic mirror is basically like not real because there two of everyone human mane 6 and pony when Twilight goes through the magic mirror she is basically still a pony only they see her as a human but as we see at the end of the movie Twilight is human but she's not like pony human she's just a regular human like thier two everyone  in humans so at the end of the movie there's another Twilight cause thier two of everybody


You devited the two human and the one pony


Well………*Gasp*MAYBE SUNSET SHIMMER BEEN IN THE HUMEN WORLD!!!


Is that possible of sunset is celestia's daughter? Cuz her name is sunset and sunset is just like sun and her cutie mark is a sun with fires and why hasbro didn't make a story of sunset parents?


my friend says "i think its a very good theory but if its wrong i think that sunsetshimer's element would be the element of secondary magic!(Ahhh)" i dont get it but theres more. "or if she doesnt have an element of harmony then she will be a........................................................................................................BFF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! buutt since she did have a colorthen she would probobly have the element of magic but taking over for twilight instead of having her own element." whoo finaly im done typeing like this  comment if you agree thanks and WATCH MY VIDS PLZ I NEED SUBS SO I CAN BE COOL IN SCHOOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


And rainbow has seven colors Aj=orange flutter shy=yellow rainbow dash=light blue i guss twilight sparkle=purple pinkie pie=pink rarity=white but they don't have red one of the most important color in rainbow and that is sunset shimmer that why


ther is one Sunshet she go at the worlds


i love u the brony notion i gives this 100 likes!


I think your thery is very very very very wrong sunset shimmer is a 7th element


Sorry but that doesn't make any sense they should put in another equestria girls that sunset shimmer meets the other sunset shimmer and calls twilight through the book and and twilight goes to the human world with spike of course and twilight meets the human twilight which they take sunset shimmer back to equestria and she lives her life there again all over again and change princess Celestias mind about her


!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Sunsut shimmer just little scared of princess Celestia that's why she don't go back to canterlot


Threw the hole vidieo I am like what the crap