This is just so beautiful and amazing! So fluid, VAs sound exactly like the real ones, beautiful and dramatic music, and the animation is just stellar! Incredible work that paid off and I'm so glad that I had the privilege to watch this. <br>Also, daaaaaaamn Starlight! Ya cut real deep, girl. Strange that I could actually see this line in the show, too

This is just so beautiful and amazing! So fluid, VAs sound exactly like the real ones, beautiful and dramatic music, and the animation is just stellar! Incredible work that paid off and I'm so glad that I had the privilege to watch this.
Also, daaaaaaamn Starlight! Ya cut real deep, girl. Strange that I could actually see this line in the show, too


Beautiful! The balance of the 3D props and background and the cartoon style characters blend so well with the mood of the story.


Oh my god the animation on this. Its beautiful! I only saw the movie once but this animation reminds me of it in some ways! The time and effort this much have taken! Seriously. Props. BIG. TIME. PROPS. To all who worked on this.


Visually stunning! Those backgrounds are especially grand. And I am very happy to see such a lovely Sunset Shimmer animation. Well done!!


I'm giving this MLP Animated film a 10/10 because it was fantastic, the animations and the visuals are gorgeous


It's a beautiful animation.. and a breath of fresh air for what feels like a dying fandom


I actually think Sunset’s parents neglect and her relationship with Celestia are the main reason why Sunset went bad. After being neglected by her parents, when Celestia took her under her wing, Sunset latched onto her as a parental figure. She wanted to please Celestia and make her proud and be like her. This is why she was so into her studies. But she was going too fast, and was trying to learn stuff she wasn’t ready for. So when Celestia refused to teach her, Sunset was hurt since she was trying to prove herself worthy in Celestia’s eyes. Maybe she even began to think that Celestia didn’t think she was worthy anymore and that was why she refused to teach her the magic she wanted to learn. Her hurt turned to anger, and her reason for wanting to gain power began to change from a desire to please to greed and to obtaining power for the sake of power.


This was pure magic, Minty. Just beautiful! Bravo!!


Man its been a while since I've seen a good animation like this. Back when Lullaby For A Princess came out


This was beautiful...hope Hasbro see this and actually hire you to work on the show.


beautiful animation. <br>thank you for sharing this.

beautiful animation.
thank you for sharing this.


This is actually amazing. Keep up the good work!


This was awesome, although I've always thought of Sunset running into the portal out of Celestia's grasp rather than Celestia showing up to the aftermath.


This is pretty good, & pretty close. There's only a few things missing from the comic book, but the concept, & events are pretty much the same.


Beautiful animation and very good with the voices! 10/10 would watch again


I love the animation style/models, they are grat. Good framerate tons of time must have been put into this


This is a bit of a mixed bag for me. The story is simple, yet touching, and the visuals in many scenes are genuinely immersive, bringing Equestria a sense of depth and "realness" I haven't seen before. On the other hand, the pacing leads to a weird, detached feeling for the overall plot. Individual scenes also suffer from timing issues, leading to animation and movement that feels "floaty" or "dizzy" in the way many SFM (source film maker) videos do. Still though, it's obvious a huge amount of love and effort went into this, and that shines brighter than any flaws. So... Thank you for sharing! And keep it up!


I’d watch the show all over again if it was animated like this.


The animation is so clean, but full of emotion


Well done! And mega kudos to the audio folks too. Spot on.


The colors are vibrant and the motion is fluid. The only issue I will confess with the animation itself is a over usage of shadows. It's often even hard to see the faces of the characters


So originally, Celestia was setting Sunset on the same path Twilight went through.<br>So if Sunset made friends and listened to Celestia... she would have basically took  Twilight's spot. Sunset would have been the princess of friendship.

So originally, Celestia was setting Sunset on the same path Twilight went through.
So if Sunset made friends and listened to Celestia... she would have basically took  Twilight's spot. Sunset would have been the princess of friendship.

sunset lost her chance to become a princess. also its clear that celestia and luna will still raise the sun and moon; they just won't rule.

I think Sunset very well could still be actually. Twilight is set to take over Celestia, so she defiantly needs an extra pony to help raise the sun and moon. I doubt the main 6 could do that.


Yay! You're back with these awesome animations! I love your take on Sunset's back story, but I wish you kept more to the comic, LOL. Any more Dinky animations coming sometime? Either way, this is awesome and I love your cute art! You're so talented and I need more vids! XD :3


I never liked the canon backstory for Sunset Shimmer, it's based on a bad notion of what it means to be "evil". This though, it's really beautiful. I like how Celestia is portrayed as the real antagonist in this situation (though if I were to write the tale of Celestia's lost protege I would have her still just have made mistake, and instead change Sunset Shimmer's character), and it stays faithful to Equestia Girl's backstory without being dependent on the end story.


I wish this would of been in the show. Sunset is one of my favorite characters and I hope they at least have something for her in the final season.


As long as there is a single fan alive, mlp will never die. Last season will live on forever


Eso fue lo que le pasó a la señorita Sunset Shimmer, pero a pesar de todo el daño y el mal que casi provoca en la dimensión, logro redimirse y ahora tiene amigos y amigas. Aprendió la lección gracias a la señorita Twilight Sparkle.


Spiffy! That's a proper project! I hope it was good for you. (Like both eating broccoli, and partaking in an enjoyable activity.) This looks like a huge effort.


I love the animation and voice actors you got to voice Celestia and Sunset Shimmer. However, the story itself well it’s good story don’t get me wrong, but it’s hard for me to believe that Sunset Shimmer became evil because Celestia forced her to learn friendship and forbidden her to learn magic. However, I am glad you made own version of the story instead of copying what IDW did with the comic. Creative originality shows you got great potential to be an awesome storyteller. Overall I think you did a fantastic job. Keep up the good work. :)


Have to say that some of it was mostly Celestia’ s fault, she pretty much forced sunset to go out and friends as an order while banning her from the library until she does so (that’s not who you try to make friends when your being forced to), sunset ddI try but seemed like some were jsut interested in getting close to Celestia’ s personal student


Cuando te das cuenta que un fan hace mejor animación que la serie original  xd


That was so beautifully made! And smooth!!!


Muy buen fan fim te quedo genial lo unico que creo que te fallo fue un poco en los movimientos (animacion) pero aun asi se nota la dedicacion.<br>Saludos desde Mexico

Muy buen fan fim te quedo genial lo unico que creo que te fallo fue un poco en los movimientos (animacion) pero aun asi se nota la dedicacion.
Saludos desde Mexico


This is so sad but beautiful I love it 😢❤


eugh... ill be honest. this was truly a piece of art, the animation was stunning and smooth.. but it lacked emotion, there was no passion in the characters or their voices. it felt flat, especially since the comics were so in depth. i feel like this had great potential but it fell short and ultimately meant nothing


This is sooo good. I love the animation and quality. This is better than the movie !!! You are really talented. :-)


I like how the ponies have the similar art style as the movie


This is a <b>beautiful</b> animation, :D


Someone give this person a budget to make a movie with this animation style holy shit.


Awesome job the animation the voice acting everything was great


IKR! This animation gave me several chill. I'll download it as appreciation because is damn good! XD

So good that only can be described into drawing!


Should be an extra in all future DVD credits! :P


This makes the outcome of "Welcome to the Show" better!


Wow :O you are talented some small mistakes here and there but can be fixed with practice and amazing lighting and stuff! Wow this must of taken hours and days and weeks


Me encanto la animación sunset shimmer es uno de mis personajes favoritos ♥


This is beautiful, but-... I can't hold back my  biggest gripe. Eyes don't drift they dart. X'(


I feel like this is how G5 will look. Hasbro said that they're going for 3D backgrounds and 2D characters for this generation.


Anyone else think Princess Celestia was a bit out of character? I get this is more than a thousand years before who she is in the show, but you would think she had SOME amount of friendship knowledge and more emotional control than she did here.


진짜 퀄리티가 장난이 아니네요..
내용도 재미있고..
This is AMAZING!! I LOVE IT SO MUCH


Why isn't this the movie? This is a much better story than what Hasbro cook up for the big screen. Also, this is a much better characterization for Sunset than the one note power hungry mare from the 1st EG movies.


The animation was really cute but I couldn't exactly tell if it was 3D/2D mix or what, still super cute and very smooth.


Graphics, animation, lights, all  better then in original


This video is amazing it almost made me cry


Hermoso😍<br>Me encanta Celestia  pero debo decir que su actitud con Sunset no me gusto para nada

Hermoso😍
Me encanta Celestia  pero debo decir que su actitud con Sunset no me gusto para nada


I’m not even in the mlp fandom and this is incredible, can I know what songs are played?

The first song is really gripping I love it


AMAZING ANIMATION!!! <b>CLAPPING HANDS</b>


you're telling me you can figure out the fundamentals of magic but simple friendship is too hard for you?

yeah, "teacher" pay attention to what's going on.  i'm having trouble making friends and it hurts that you're berating me for it, not understanding how I feel.    seriously, a mare sitting next to me teleported around me just to not be my lab partner.  ouch.

damn, I just want to hug Sunset and be her friend.


Celestia has never heard of socially awkward, shy, insecure, ...

she has, but sunset tried to control ponies into being her friends instead of actually trying.


Карто Фелина


Wow the animation was so beautiful and the story was really life like beautiful job keep up the great work


The animation is bootiful, just bootiful!


Whoa this looks incredible I love it and I subscribed


красиво и со смыслом

красиво и со смыслом


This animation is just like my little pony the movie !!!


Can anyone tell me the titles of the music tracks? I've checked the accounts written below the video, but couldn't find them ^^U


3:42 "How can i make myself some friends-"

-MIND CONTROL!  Ahem, mind control.  MIND CONTROL, SUNSET.


I am glad I decided to watch this before Hasbro takes this down for copyright infringement  that happened to the button mash adventures by jan animations. He just animated a goodbye music video which is sad.


WOOOOW THIS IS SIMPLY MAJESTIC, ¿Are you workng in some production?  A big one? Hasbro didn't contact you yet?,this is so high quallity!😍


Очень здорово! Особенно музыка!

Очень здорово! Особенно музыка!


good. I like it very much. I am impresst how much work went into this.


Have you or will you release the rigs you used? This could potentially replace sfm ponies.


I do enjoy it I never knew my friend mahri was in it


This is so amazing but i really cried lol😂😂!


...ok yea, that deserved to be #1 in the top 10


So this story takes place before the beginning of that show and My Little Pony: Equestria Girls movie.😦


If only you can make part 2 of it. EqG style..... (I'm too weird)


Celestia deserves when sunset told her she doesn't have friends Celestia can't force sunset to make friends


Wow....<br>I have no words other than: wow....

Wow....
I have no words other than: wow....

🧩Autistic and feeling proud of who I am! 💙


So it was Celestias fault that she ran away and WOW some teacher she is you can't force someone to make friends in one day SOME TEACHER YOU ARE!!!

it wasn't over a day. it was over a period of time; most likely a few weeks or so.


I don't like Sunset. But it's only my opinion. I love Twi 💜💎


Animation is beautiful, story dialogue and voice acting are shit.


Y'all ever heard of aspergers or autism? Or literally any other mental disability that makes making friends hard?  Cause I don't think ya have.


Пульсик Домашний


OML LOOK AT MOONDANCER IN CLASS SHES SO TINY TOO


Low quality animations with unoriginal models ripped from the show: Millions of views
This: 400k views

Absolute bullshit...


Селестию жалко

Селестию жалко

Носок в горошек


Cuando te sientes forever alone por se la única de habla hispana


I cannot be the only one confused that twilight is a princess and luna is still in the moon? The timeline. wheere did she go

The video starts in the present but shifts to the past, and then back to the present.


So Twlight sparkle goes to the human world like in MLP equestia girls


Good movie <br>But princess celestia neck freaks me out

Good movie
But princess celestia neck freaks me out


Justin Carawan - CarawanCo.PuzzleProductions CCPP


Y me gusto si el video pero como sonora con fandub español latino


I would hate Celestia too.... U can't go into the library.... U just took all my friends away...


Then it means that I probably have some negative values of heart ._.


As a kind of movie with My little pony and happy tree Friends with celestia and moon tired of retirement traveling to the other side of the sea discovering that there is an Equestria for two discovering the world of happy tree Friends seeing a castle in the city to rule the king shadow good characters and that his friends are those of happy tree Friends the villains that neozor and Big BOSS and that they have an army of purple bears and that they are the mane 6 of the future and that neozor and Big BOSS end Jan be their friends saying them that celestia and luna were planning to be princesses again the shadow castle called why he was thinking of withdrawing and giving his place to celestia and luna and Twitlit and her friends travel to happy tree Friends just the day they were planning their coronation when they realized They canceled his presence only until he left and in the end he found a war battle, just try it, I'll just give you an idea and I open it with great respect, but just try


@Reese Youtube sucks. my entire channel got demonitized but i feel alot more sorry for you. putting so much effort into something and not getting a single dime for it

you're not allowed to make money off of things like this. fan-made or not, its considered copyright infringement if you make money off of another person's work. this applies to MLP.


i'll be your friend sunset shimmer please!!!!!!!!!!!!


The animation style to beautiful and certainly adds to the story being told. <br>I also can't imagine how long or difficult was to make something as beautiful and powerful as this, but it certainly shows how much love and care went into this.

The animation style to beautiful and certainly adds to the story being told.
I also can't imagine how long or difficult was to make something as beautiful and powerful as this, but it certainly shows how much love and care went into this.


This was beautifully done! I only have some complaints.

Sometimes the darkness was too much and I couldn't see some bits at all where it seemed important to have light. In shadows, the characters looked flat when exposed to light, they seem well shaded enough to seem 3-D. I was also not a big fan of Celestia's voice actress, but Sunset's was amazing! Some of the characters looked wonky in shots, their proportions were off and looked out of shape


Freaking amazing. And here I was thinking MLP was past its prime with all the truly great works art in this fandom like Lullaby for a Princess, Double Rainboom, and Snowdrop long since past. You have single handily renewed my faith in this fandom. Thank you. In fact, I'd say the only thing that could really be improved upon would be the voice acting. If you asked, you might be able to get some of the other popular MLP fans that can voice characters well, like Magpie, Scribbler Productions, or maybe even Elliemonty. Your animation is certainly good enough that they might consider it.


Bravissimo. This short was simply WONDERFUL! Everyone involved did an excellent job from the gorgeous animation to the stellar voice acting. Not only does it look like the second FIM movie we never got in terms of quality, but it also offers a different perspective to Sunset's backstory, making us wonder if Celestia was also to blame for her downfall, but still keeping Sunset's ambition to excel as well as her passion for magic. Of course, this doesn't make Celestia the villain of the story either, she is still going through a lot after Luna's banishment.

Overall, this is my favorite animation from you, Minty. Congratulations to you and the whole crew.


Coming from someone who hasn't read most of the lore (I've only started on Season 6) I can really say this is a very beautiful production
✓Great animation
✓Great acting, helps carry out the tone and emotion
✓Special effects, very fitting
✓The music and sound effects, on spot
My verdict, this really should be in the Top 10 Pony Videos of March!


This, right here, is what I call pure art. The way the backstory is told just catches you and doesn't let you look away. OMG...I even teared up. These are the kind of things I love the fandom for, the pure and amazing artwork it comes from it. <3 /)


Wow. That was... impressive, and I was expecting a lot. Kudos to everyone who worked on this.


So poetic that every scene takes place during sunset, love the symbolism of that... or am I overthinking?

The only thing that prevents this from matching the actual show's quality is the lack of comedy.


This is beautifully animated, The lighting was absolutely stunning. Amazing job ♥


It's definitely a very different take on her backstory. With the original comic the emphasis was on her ambition to be like Celestia, whereas here it seems to be significantly more innocent, that she tried making friends and it just wasn't working, and Celestia is being painted more as the one at fault.

I did like that scene of Celestia raising the moon with Luna's face on it after Sunset calls her out on "not having any friends." Very powerful.

It's definitely a very different take on her backstory. With the original comic the emphasis was on her ambition to be like Celestia, whereas here it seems to be significantly more innocent, that she _tried_ making friends and it just wasn't working, and Celestia is being painted more as the one at fault.

I did like that scene of Celestia raising the moon with Luna's face on it after Sunset calls her out on "not having any friends." Very powerful.


How are you so talented?! This is the best animation style and design I have ever seen! This can't get any better! Make sure to remind the voice actors of how good the were! Minty, you just got yourself a new subscriber! This is much better than the animations "The Moon rises" and "Spare" combind!


Other than the occasionally stilted walk cycle and Celestia's neck being weirdly thin, this is so absolutely amazing.


Celestia realized halfway through that Sunset was right, and she seemed to push everyone she could call one away.

Now this nearly made me cry, it's really emotional.

I love it!

Celestia realized halfway through that Sunset was right, and she seemed to push everyone she could call one away.

Now this nearly made me cry, it's really emotional.

*I love it!*


Beautiful Animation. I couldn't think of anything more amazing.


Wow, this is such an amazing animation, I'm sure gonna sent it to my friends for them to watch too.


That. Was. AWESOME! I'm begging you. Please, please PLEASE DO KEEP ON MAKING MORE OF THESE! I can't imagine just how tricky and complicated it is, just to animate something!


I appreciate the work/time were put into this


It felt a bit disconnected at times, like I was watching scenes from a trailer rather than a film, the character models felt a little off at times (same problem the movie had), the animation of Celestia flying didn't look that good, the voice acting sounded a bit weird (but maybe that's just me) and maybe the plot could have been handled a bit better. But still, this is very good for a fan animation, the effects look good (even if they do clash a bit with the aesthetic), the music is good and it definitely has a couple of great moments, I particularly liked the ending with Celestia looking at how Spike runs after Twilight and questioning why she didn't do the same.


This is amazing
The picture Is outstanding
The music REALLY makes the video seem like a short movie

I really enjoyed watching this


😮 i have no words sto describe how AMAZING this is it has more work put into it than a movie👍


This is awesome, I always wondered as a younger kid what it would look like animated!!


Can you make (me) a list of the music parts? They are so beautiful, and I wanna hear them more often, especially the flute :)


I am utterly amazed. That is all. Love it <3


I havent watched your videos in a hot minute, but your animation has gotten better! So proud!


My daughter and I thought that this work was very well done!


Beautiful production brought a tear to this pony's heart too.


So good. Beyond amazing. Couldn't have done it better myself


for an mlp fan animation, this is definitely one of the best (and i mean the BEST) animations i’ve seen :)


This animation is amazing. Its detail is similar to the movie


Wow you improved quite a lot. If only Gen 5 will look this good. The shading is epic.

This creativity is what I like to see from the fandom. And I hope Gen 5 will spark a second golden age. I missed out on the first, and I've seen so many pony fan animators give up in recent years. I'm glad you didn't, Minty.


Excelente!!! Ojalá en un futuro saques la confrontación de Nightmare Moon vs Celestial


Props to whoever did the animation for this you did beautifully my God this is beautiful animation good work


I was so happy to find this! I thought the fandom was dead


You've really improved, and this is FANTASTIC!


The animation style is like sfm but it’s all animated with high detail, BRILLIANTLY WELL MADE MY DEAR ANIMATOR


This was animated by one person!? Amazing.


Did I mention this is now on my 'favorite videos of all time list' the list that includes works like "Lullaby for a Princess", "The Moon Rises", and "Snowdrop"


I love how smooth is the animation & the ambientation, mg*


once in a blue moon the brony anime community blesses us with some of the best anime ive ever seen.

actually its youtube recommendations<br>dammit recommend more stuff like this youtube

actually its youtube recommendations
dammit recommend more stuff like this youtube


The animation looks just like that in My Little Pony: The Movie.


Bro, this is amazing!!! This is by far one of the best mlp animation ever!!!!


This video here is dark yet it is enjoyable to a degree. Big screen worthy.


It'S One of the best animations I've seen in my whole life, this Is worth more than my life ;>;


wow, this is some really pretty animation.


"You don't even have Friends"...

Well, I emphasize too much with Celestia and hearing made me feel Celestia is more lonely than I originally thought. I know many of you know want to teach me that Luna was more lonely than her because we ONLY KNOW LUNA's Side of the Story. We never saw Celestia's Side of their Past. Just because the Ponies celebrated the Sun it doesn't mean that Celestia was happy with it. It's all just Headcannon the Ponies just loved her a Princess with the Ability to rise and set the Sun. And now after she banishing Luna, what she didn't want but Nightmare Moon was an actual Threat, You cannot blame Celestia for wanting to protect her Folk, ruling for 1000 Years alone rising and setting both Sun and Moon but also never had any Friends. Guards only see her as an Idol to protect, Her Students just a Teacher or Mother-Figure but not as a Friend.
And even if it's just my own Headcannon it makes me feel really sad and sorry for Celestia


You have skills, I can barely make a simple water drip without mucking it up! Also the music is amazing.


That animation... it's... it's... <b>magnificent</b>

That animation... it's... it's... *magnificent*


The smoothness and lighting is <b>legendary.</b>

The smoothness and lighting is *legendary.*


Celestia always favored twilight over anyone else. Thats one of the reasons why twilight became a princess.. She wouldnt be one without the others.


this animation was the best i have ever seen! I cant stop watching!


very VERY nice, top notch animation, it's a shame the sound design is not very...professional. Amazing work though


It's criminal that this gem has so little views!


I hope hasbro chooses 3D animation of this level and won't overdo it with writers. Six writers! What for?! As they say in Russia at eight nurses the child without an eye...


Seems more realist the short film than MLP:The Movie


Iteresting and well animated... but give the contradictions to how it goes in the show its making it hard to follow what the story idea that you had forr this was and the leaps in time that the video takes even with knowing the show seem too jarring... great animation overall though


My sister and I think this is really good animation!


Please, name of song at 8:09, i fell in love with it ❤

вы позорите фонд

it's called "Twilight Sparkle" from Seventh Element's album "The Ministry Mares". although the video's version sounds different...


The movements are a bit off. The audio could be better. But the scenery and lighting are a top notch. I don't think it's the best MLP animation I've seen though.

Okay, but we can’t disregard how much effort was put into this and despite your views it truly is an amazing animation.


Best video I see, pretty legit, great work👍🏻


Dang this is so good nice work man keep it up👍


Surprisingly beautiful. No words. Omg...


Oh. My. God.
How
The animation is so beautiful like LOOK AT THOSE SUBTLE MOVEMENTS
H O W
SMOOTHER THAN A BABIES SKIN—
EVEN THE BLINKING

HHHHHHHHH


Omg. This is so fuckin beautiful. It makes the comic look like a rough sketch for this. I love. So much.


!!!OMG!!! This Is really REALLY AWESOME IS THE BEST SHORT FAN FILM THAT I'VE SEEN in the mlp comunity. Minty root you are the Best. I hope this fan animation have a sequel in a future because if happened it would be amazing.  😁😁😁😁😁✋✋✋✋👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍


As good as the animation is, your time line is WAY off. You show Celestia looking in on Princess Twilight. This would put it after Season 3 and before Sunset Shimmer returned to Equestria. If this is how it transpired Twilight would have know Sunset but, as we know from the first Equestria Girls movie, Twilight did not know her.(I've still never understood why this is myself because they would have been studying at the same time as they are about the same age, yet she is never mentioned prior to the movie, and the movie doesn't really address how Twilight ~doesn't know her.)


excellent👍✨ . This animation is the best 🙂 . Good luck to you 🌹 .


How this little 11 min short can be much better than 9 years of hasbro MLP series and movies???


Haha thanks for the birthday present lol this video has beautiful animation


SHE SHOULD MAKE HER OWN FAN MADE MOVIE!!! 1 HOUR LONG


OMG I LIKE THIS BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL SERIES


Animation was excellent but the writing was far too toxic and aggressive...


I’m not a brony b-baka

Beautiful visuals 👌👌


You can't force someone to make friends. Thats not how that works.


This makes the Movie almost non-existent!


What are the names of the songs that you've used?


I think Celestia's necklace is a little <b>too</b> big...

I think Celestia's necklace is a little *too* big...


Can't make friends?.. okay I'll ban you from the thing you love most and could maybe bond with a friend over. Nice move Tia.


OH MY GOODNESS!!! THIS IS AMAZING!!! EVERYTHING IS SO SMOOTH!!!! YOU NEED MORE SUBS TwT!!!!HASBRO NEEEDDDSSSSS TO HIRE YOUUUU!!!


*_I can al most FeEeElL it, it looks soOo ReEAaAalL_*


Sometimes no matter how nice you are , people will still hate you.


So this is how equestria girls was born and that why Princess Celestia take twilight sparkle for her students and to make thing right in the future. Very nice animation now I know how sunset shimmer hate Celestia so much because she doesn't know about friendship was.


bright scenery
Celestia: HaAa I kNoWwW
MY EARS

_bright scenery_
Celestia: *_HaAa I kNoWwW_*
MY EARS


I just saw a dora the explorer advertisement but in real life......

Edit: it probably has NOTHING to do with my little pony😂😂


poor sunset she didn't have friends first place until twi help her and I feel sorry to her and now I like sunset


BITCH U SNAPPED WITH THE ANIMATION AND THE LIGHTing and darkness 😩😍😍😍


lol xD esta genial<br>y que le paso a luna xD?

lol xD esta genial
y que le paso a luna xD?


Is this 2015 because my 11 year old is hating hard on Celestia all over again


That Shadows are so dark in the atmosphere


THIS ANIMATION SHOULD BE IN THE MLP:MOVIE THE DIRECTORS A FUKHEAD


nice job, now make a complet film with a different story, that must be during 3 hours XD


Hmm... I get the feeling that I already know that animation style... it's good and all but... meh. Maybe you should try something else?


U can make a movie with dis good animation


Can you work in Hasbro? Your animations are better


Что за мызыка которая в конце

Что за мызыка которая в конце

Светлая Планета


4:14 OMG I LOVE THAT BUTT THAT U DRAW TO SUNSET!!! XD


The faces little bit weird but other stuff is amazing 🤩 I really like sunset now more then twilight


Then sunset say she dont have friends and then celectia rise the moon she start to Think about her sister celectia rally miss luna she know why she trapp luna in the moon but celectia want luna back celectia and luna wars more then sisters they wars best friends and a family


So why is Luna in the opening sceen and than in the moon?

@Lina Nerd ah yes ok, but choose your words more  carefully next time.


J'ai pas checké, mais c'est-tu parce qu'elle a pissé sur sa robe ?


Wow! you make it like a real movie<br>Also can you make like the eg  ifen is alredi make

Wow! you make it like a real movie
Also can you make like the eg  ifen is alredi make


Них*я не понимаю, но очень интересно

Них*я не понимаю, но очень интересно


I don't need friends, they disappoint me


Sunset never became an alicorn; she lost that chance.


The amount of effort and love that went into this shines through. Thank you so much for creating this for the fandom.


This is a under-rated masterpiece. It almost rivals Lullaby for a princess.


I’ve always had this passing fascination with the MLP franchise/concept, but by far the fan works are out of this world. <br>The production values are spectacular.

I’ve always had this passing fascination with the MLP franchise/concept, but by far the fan works are out of this world.
The production values are spectacular.


This is truly the pinnacle of my little pony animation. I am nearly in tears as to how impressed I am at your adoption from a 2-D animation tweet 3-D masterpiece. You have blown me away and I really loved what you did. This is a really nice take on sunset shimmer. I just wanted to congratulate you on your masterful work of this beautiful piece with a very similar voice actresses I applaud you.


I love the way this animation frames the beginning of Equestria Girls. The animation here is just, stellar. Just seeing the way they move, the subtle expression in the body language, it's just beautiful.


I CANNOT EXPLAIN HOW AMAZING THIS LOOKS!!!
THE ANIMATION IS SUCH HIGH QUALITY, THE SHADING IS JUST SO GOOD, THE BACKGROUNDS.. I CANT IMAGINE HOW LONG THIS MUSTVE TAKE!
THIS IS ONE HECK OF A EFFORT THATS BEEN PUT IN, AND THIS IS JUST THE MOST BEAUTIFUL ANIMATION IVE EVER SEEN.
YOU ARE AMAZING MINTY! Thank you for all the effort to make this movie for all of us :’) it’s really good. I’m proud.


It’s heartwarming to see how dedicated the MLP community is to this day


Between the beautiful animation style, the music and the voice acting...I have to give this animation a 100 out of 100. This is better than the animated show itself! I hope you get hired by Hasbro at some point because this animation is flawless! You e just earned another subscriber!


Beautifully animated. Love the voice acting. Everything was just so good


This is just absolutely stunning! The visuals, the animation style, the voices... AHHH! Soooo good! This is unbelievably amazing! Great job to you and everyone else who worked on this! You're all amazing!


Can I just say
I love the lighting and just everything with this?
You've done an amazing job on this!!
You should be so proud of yourself!


Really well done animation! It seems like a rigging technique? I don't know, but the movements are almost really natural. I really like the who effect with the eye dilation and magic and whatnot. But the irises were a bit wonky, and sometimes the "rigging" effect goes a little haywire. But other than that, I think this animation was done beautifully. This is just some things that I noticed and felt like could be improved on, but please do not feel forced or pressured to take any of these notes into heart. I was just trying to help! I can't wait to see the improvement you'll make when you do more!


Ignoring the fact I'm over MLP, this is a wonderful video; I love the details and how it's made!


The tone is beautiful.
Lighting, fantastic.
Backgrounds, stunning.
Voices, perfect fits.
Voice Acting, emotionally resonant.
Music, complimentary.
Order of Events felt natural.
Style, unique and familiar.

But the animation needs a lot of fine-tuning. The facial movements and overall animation felt jerky, unnatural and distracted from the story.

8.5/10


This is incredible! One of the best animations I've ever seen. I am Russian, I use Google as a translator. I can’t even imagine how long it took. I wish further development


wow, that was amazing!
<br>I do have some doubts about the overall narrative tempo, but, anyway I'm so glad this animation exists!

wow, that was amazing!
I do have some doubts about the overall narrative tempo, but, anyway I'm so glad this animation exists!


What a smooth animation we have there.
And I like it how it's shown even Celestia isn't perfect.

It just bothers me that there are many anathomy and layer errors and those background being 3D while characters are 2D


It's an great feat that you made a film this long with this high quality is a single year .


Impressive, animation exceeds even the movie.


This is incredible quality, absolutely wonderful work!


How long did this animation take?Because it's beautifully animated.When I saw the castle on the outside I was stunned!


Very well done, impressive.  Keep up the good work.


A beautiful animation,  I loved it. 10/10


beautiful not only how the story is told but also that everything is animated


wow. this was very very well done! great job, had me the feels and everything!!


This was AMAZING! Hasbro should hire you before some other big company takes you.


OMG... i'm speechless after watching this animation. i'm also crying because it was so beautiful. honestly, really good job Minty Root.


DANG MINTY! You been busy!  Also, major props on merging the 2d characters with the 3d environment! Really well done!


So sad, but this is a very true masterpiece!


hasbro has too much to learn about this. Its really great, the dark tones, the effects of light, the colors; its really great


Gorgeous animation (Toon Boom Harmony is awesome!) but you lost me in the writing at "that's meant for very highly skilled students." Not only does it throw shade at Sunset for no reason, it implies that cohorts of top students were allowed to touch and (by extension) use it to visit the other world? Celestia would instead have said not even she herself knows what would happen in the mirror and no one is allowed to use it, it's too dangerous.


I felt like i was there! This was simply beautiful


esta animacion esta hermosa muy hermosa se ve que si le ha puesto mucha dedicacion a esto ya que para mi si entra en mi top de las mejores animaciones de my little pony encerio


Holy crap.  This is almost show quality.  I am very surprised this doesn't have more views.  Awesome work to all involved.  :)


Short of "going to the dark side" part, this hits <b>very</b> close to home for me.

Short of "going to the dark side" part, this hits *very* close to home for me.


Dude, this is actually FIRE! This is literally the best mlp parody ive ever seen.


I really love this animation, is beautiful, well skilled,


The Animation is So Beautiful it made me cry Because of the amazing story All of the detail is also very amazing!!!


This is some extremely professional stuff! Like I am in awe that I don't know what to say/comment. Like is this from an actual movie scene?


The animation is so beautiful and so inspiring!!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤


Ok you really truly did extraordinarily well with this one the animation and the voices everything nice job it’s way better than the comic .


Princess' expression changes to a smile after Spike rushes through the mirror. A nice touch.


I need a part 2 cause this is amazing!!!!!


I think YOU should be the animator for MLP. <br>This is just BEAUTIFUL!

I think YOU should be the animator for MLP.
This is just BEAUTIFUL!


Oh my gosh this animation is so much better than the original and it's..its amazing I'm very impressed!!!


quite good video, Sunset deserves more history and animations, her past is way to dark and, secrets al still to be told... har past, parents, how meet celestia an soo on.... once again, quite good :3


Awesome work, dude)<br>I have no words to explain how is it cool-made...

Awesome work, dude)
I have no words to explain how is it cool-made...


Nice voice acting and flawless animation


I hope gen 5 will have a animation Style like this.


this is my first time watching this channel and i just have to say it: THIS IS SO GOOOD! HOW DO YOU NOT HAVE MORE SUBSCRIBERS?


I’m feeling like Sunset and Celestia have a close Mother-Daughter relationship.


This looks better than the mlp movie 😂 good job bro 👍


10 min of genius.<br>56 seconds of elysium.

10 min of genius.
56 seconds of elysium.


Nice art style. The pacing was a little slow. I enjoyed it though!


That was really good and great animation and I love the voices they were really good I just loved it good job


this had beautiful animation and the story was even better your very talented =)


This is so making it to the Top 10 Pony Videos of March 2019


Mucho mejor que la pelicula,te te tienen que hacer director de la siguiente pelicula XD


No wonder it looks like the movie...you're using toon boom harmony!!! Good job pal...love the details on every sec 😁


Shit.... I got goosebumps from this..... Real powerful story. Love the animation. The voices are real good too!!!! This actually explains a lot.


SEAS MAMOOOOON!!!!! está hermoso!!! ;u; Es... simplemente hermoso... P*TAMADRE ME HIZO LLORAR!!! >:'''v


Why is this animated better than the series?!


great work. only problem I see is that luna was trapped on the moon for 1000 years. so sunset would never have met or even knew of her


"You can figure out the fundamentals of magic but can't make friends" me


God this is amazing to watch, I’ll raise a beer to this hell ya🍺


It was so beautiful I had to wait till the end to comment. Couldn’t take my eyes off ^_^


This animation is actually better than the real episodes on the show (my opinion)


This animation is gorgeous okay just wanna lead with that
voice acting is wonderful
this is wonderful
you're wonderful


THIS IS SICK! I love it so much❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ great job! 👌😙


Dude, I don't like MLP, but your movie is absolutely fantastic....


Wow that was so good  good job on it keep it up.


YOU DESERVE MORE THAN 15K SUBS THIS IS A PIECE OF ART AND YOU HAVE A NEW SUB!


Who watch MLP when young and still looks at the fan fics XD


Love this <3 and i know this gonna be viral :3


que bella animacion...quiero aprender 😢😭😭😭😭😭


I've always thought sunset and twilight are classmates but good animation though


I would have thought Luna was trapped in the Moon while Sunset Shimmer was still around.


I always wanted to live in the mlp universe but the whole thing being about "friendship" and making friends I can't handle that cuz I'm introverted


En ese momento Hasbro sintió el verdadero terror v: xd


It's up there with Lullaby For A Princess


Who has a theory that Twilight might be Celestia's daughter?


Sunset shimmer wasnt a bad pony, she just felt wronged, but that also doesnt give her the right to hurt others


For a second, I thought this was official.


Ohhh yesss theres voice oversss 😍😍😍<br>This made the whole vid amazing

Ohhh yesss theres voice oversss 😍😍😍
This made the whole vid amazing


Анимация лучше, чем в самом мультике

Анимация лучше, чем в самом мультике

Белка Летяга и её команда


весняна кульбабка


Анастасия Кваснина


Its kinda true that making friends is easy cause i was on a playground they had some doll houses there so i played with them and another girl played with them too i said hi she said hi and i said can i borrow that piece? She said sure and im all like cool can i be friends? She said sure then she had to go and we didnt even know our names


Hey nice job on the vid sunset shimmer is one of my favorite characters in eg you did great


Dont watch mlp so was lost af bur its pretty art so good job


So I'm totally focused on the wrong thing, but can you make an hourglass that goes for like 12 hours?


Sunset:
🎶 I do my little lonely dance, performing for my only fan
Cause its my kind of party
the LIBRARY is where my heart is

Sunset:
🎶 I do my little lonely dance, performing for my only fan
Cause its my kind of party
the *LIBRARY* is where my heart is


Very best than equestria girls xD i love this vid!


Im not a fan of ponies<br>BUT HECC IM A FAN OF SUM GOODASS ANIMATION

Im not a fan of ponies
BUT HECC IM A FAN OF SUM GOODASS ANIMATION


The animation is a little bit wacky, but the style looks beautiful, the lighting is on point and the voice acting is really well done, also. :) Maybe you should practice on your 3D and the movement of the pans you make (I'm no professional animator, but that's where I saw most glitches)! Good job over all!


OMG I AM LATE BUT IT IS NEVER TOO LATE. I AM AMAZED. OOOOOMGGGGG THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR MAKING THIS !!!


When Celestia said "I know" it almost earraped me


HOLY MOLY THIS IS SOO GOOOOOOOOOOD!

CAPS op


This is beautiful, but why didn’t you stick to the original source material? This version just makes Celestia look like a tyrant... In the comic, Sunset Shimmer is a total brat and completely deserved to get kicked out. This version makes it look like her evil was justified.


@Lily Orchard, I think you would love this.


Что за мелодия в конце?

Что за мелодия в конце?


That was something else at least I got to find out what happened from the very beginning of there story together I would think that they were friends student and teacher


Your story is wrong, in the movie My Little Pony: Equistria Girls Princess Celestia said that when Sunset did not got what she wanted as fast as she wanted she became cruel and dishonest Princess Celestia tried to help her but she didn't listened and she went to the different dimensions through the portal thats the true story

this is based on the COMICS, not the movie. do research.


You forgot to put Luna in the video when twilight got to the human world


why the music is so... Silent Hill 'ish?


This is too much... The princess wouldn't FORCE ponies to be friends.


Офигеть вот это анимауия афигеть ну ну у меня просто слов не


Holeehhhh shettttt this issmooth and bootiful qwqq


"You don't even have friends" fuck her up Sunset Shimmer


You're making me not like the actual episode in that episode just supposed to be happy not sad


Is anyone else confused on what happened


It’s.    Sad.    That sunset shimmer cannot make friends maybe she should’ve done it like twice I did


Это что, анимация от Дисней?

Это что, анимация от Дисней?


We😂🆖✏😬🆖🆖😂😂😂ppppp

We😂🆖✏😬🆖🆖😂😂😂ppppp


No one want to be my friend.

My friend's name is "No one"


<b>Disney want’s to know your location.</b>


Хелп ми кто нибудь знает перевод?

Хелп ми кто нибудь знает перевод?


Of course there not gonna want to be your friend there both Moondancer so there confused on who your referring to


That was exceptional production. The atmosphere from the very beginning all the way though till the credits was really emotional. Every element from the voice acting, animation, colours and music were so astonishingly well done. The length is so impressive too, it is nearly half an episode.

This will be a future classic web fan animation for sure.


Wow! This was such a beautiful re-enactment if the story. The shading and coloring was on point. The style was a perfect mix of the characters personality and other values most viewers desire. I enjoyed this a lot and I guess if you would like any constructive criticism, maybe try perfecting the backgrounds, I think the castle and the towns needed a bit of work but you succeeded in a 10 minute animation so it’s something that can be let passed. <br>I enjoyed this a lot and I’m enthusiastic about seeing more from you!

Wow! This was such a beautiful re-enactment if the story. The shading and coloring was on point. The style was a perfect mix of the characters personality and other values most viewers desire. I enjoyed this a lot and I guess if you would like any constructive criticism, maybe try perfecting the backgrounds, I think the castle and the towns needed a bit of work but you succeeded in a 10 minute animation so it’s something that can be let passed.
I enjoyed this a lot and I’m enthusiastic about seeing more from you!


I am in awe. Amazing work, dude. The art is just gorgeous and eye catching, the voice actresses did such a wonderful job. You should be very proud of yourself :)


This animation is AMAZING. Wow. Just wow. I'm so happy people still feel Sunset Shimmer is relevant and deserving of a decent backstory. This was great. I love her so much ❤


This is gorgeous! The VA for Sunset really stood out, she sounds almost exactly like Rebecca! Celestia was really good too, and you could feel how hurt and heartfelt she was <3 great job!


Love love loved it. Honestly, half the time I was trying to figure out if it was in 2D or 3D, and the other half was just spent purely enjoying it!! Certainly a contender for the Best Pony Video of the Month, and almost definitely one of the best of 2019. Also, the voice talent was amazing, but the real stand out for me was the amazing music by Radiarc and Seventh Element, who are both awesome at making very atmospheric tracks. Also, even though I'm not sure if this was intentional or not, but I thought it was really cool that every time they touched the mirror and you heard the sound of water droplets, the sound was pretty much in tune with the music at that specific moment.

All in all, amazing work, Minty! Not only for animating this fantastic video, but also for finding such amazing talent to help you with it. This is a total ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ video. Keep it up!


The animation is beautiful, and the music goes along so well and sets such a tone for the film.


Wow. Many of those scenes looks waaaaay more high quality than they should considering how comparably little time it took to make this.<br>This is incredible!

Wow. Many of those scenes looks waaaaay more high quality than they should considering how comparably little time it took to make this.
This is incredible!


What a mighty impressive and wonderful animation!
Super nice work you did!
Such wonderful music, the animations done so perfectly.. The voices...
Well done my friend, i simply envy your skills :D


It's beautiful! I've been wanting an animation for so long and I thank you for giving me this piece of artwork.


Wow! I haven't been apart of the fandom for a while but this video came up in my recommend. So I watched. You just brought me back. Very smooth animation, great voice acting, great pacing of the story!! Well done!!


Oh my god. This is absolutely beautiful. It may be better animation than MLP itself.


This absolutely exquisite!!! The attention to detail is mindblowing!!! You should be very very proud of yourself!!!


Wow. I truly believe this is the most visualy beautiful fan animatio for this fandom. Congratulations and thank you very much for making it possible!


This animation is breathtaking and beautiful <br>It definitely deserves way more likes than it has right now!

This animation is breathtaking and beautiful
It definitely deserves way more likes than it has right now!


Great work! This is quite good overall, and a really nice take on what happened to Sunset. Featured on episode 253 of our podcast.


It's amazing really. Looking back at her past really makes you acknowledge how far Sunset Shimmet has come by making friends ^^


Great animation. Amazing soundtrack. Well done everyone /)


Nicely done!

How long did it take to make this? The animation looks very well made


This is amazing ! An absolutely great piece of art ^^


This is fucking amazing. On behalf of the entire fandom, I must commemorate you and the team of people working on this for your amazing creation. Thank you. :3


This was amazing!!!! If I had to give advice, I’d say try to minimize the amount of empty space. Not animation-wise, like dialogue! There’s too many needless soundless scenes in here that in my opinion, would cause the story to flow better without them in it


The soundtrack is so deliciously beautiful! Was it custom made for the animation or are there track titles?


Wow, this is incredible production not just for a fanmade project, but overall.


How the hell did you get such quality animation and production in such a short time? This is so impressive!


Beautiful animation, i practically squealed when i saw this in my notification bar. Always enjoy your animations. Keep up the good work :)


God dang, the work you put into this really shows Minty. Wonderful work~


That was amazing! Better than the movie of MLP! I guess now I have a better understanding of how sunset shimmer made an appearance in the other world. And, seeing as she couldn't make friends in Equestria, she manages to break up a friendship in the other world, and at the end, becomes friends and is still learning. Talk about character development!


Much better than MLP:The Movie. This is the masterpiece, I love it so much!


sksksk where did this come from wHaT-
Im speechless.
Holy crap.
This was???? Beautiful???
The backgrounds, fluid models, voice acting, effects, just, EVERYTHING!
Also can someone please tell me why this single person is better at melding 3D models with 2D figures then the actual official my little pony movie?
(also, that water ripple effect on the mirror, i didn't expect that but it looked GORGEOUS!!


I absolutly love this the voices the scenery and the story makes me feel sad for sunset


One of the best pony animations I’ve seen in quite a while!!


Wow, this was VERY well made, great job! ^w^


This is so frickin epic...
And the VA for Sunset Shimer was scarily accurate lol
Beautiful animation, dramatic camera angles, wonderful backgrounds; I could go on. Superb animated film.


The animation is gorgeous and the voice acting is brilliant 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟<br>I love it! A million stars

The animation is gorgeous and the voice acting is brilliant 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
I love it! A million stars


holy HELL this is amazing! Everything is so smooth and gorgeous! You’re really damn talented 💜💜💜 <br>Please teach me your ways 😭

holy HELL this is amazing! Everything is so smooth and gorgeous! You’re really damn talented 💜💜💜
Please teach me your ways 😭


GORGEOUS!!!! I lovelovelove the "you're a hypocrite, you don't even have friends!" line... I had never put that together before but she's right. Celestia really doesn't.


Cool video, thanks for this. Did you use the same software they used to make the movie, with a bit more 3d thrown in?


It looks almost like MLP movie, that's so beautiful I love everything about this ♡♡♡


That was beautiful. It was smooth and very emotional. It was amazing


I hope Hasbro goes for this style in the upcoming movie!


It is a shame that Hasbro is going to end with MLP-FiM. They've said that they will continue with MLP in an other form. Well, changes can be good but I wished that Hasbro would have continued with MLP-FiM but with the quality of the animation as in this video. That would have been so awesome. Anyway, you did more than an awesome job Minty Root. And I am glad that you have picked Sunset Shimmer's story. She is my favorite MLP character. Wubcake doing Sunset's voice was spot on. It almost appears that Rebecca Shoichet herself was in this video. I hope you can do a MLP-EG video as well. Thank you very much Minty Root. You rock!


Wow. For the first time ever, i finally meet someone that made a smooth mlp animation. I really like it


Man. As someone with AS, Sunset's lack of friendship skills is so relatable. This is basically what it's like to have autism. Including Celestia's reactions.


Holy crap! One about Sunset Shimmer! My poor baby 😭!! Beautiful animation as always! I love the voices and the tone of the video. I can’t wait to see more of your work Minty Root.


Бесподобно! Шедеврально! Невероятно! У меня не хватает слов, что-бы выразить свои эмоции!<br>Ты заслуживаешь похвалы всего мира) Поэтому, получай из России)

Бесподобно! Шедеврально! Невероятно! У меня не хватает слов, что-бы выразить свои эмоции!
Ты заслуживаешь похвалы всего мира) Поэтому, получай из России)


This deserves all the love in the world.
Its so amazing! The animation, the voices, the background music.
Its all soooo god damn gooooooood!!


Well at least Sunset’s mood was significantly better in the past compared to the comics. In the books she was just means and condescending. But here she just insecure and inexperienced and just kinda got……broken :O

In any case this was amazing. I’m glad I came across this  :D


Makes me wonder: If Sunset had been able to do what Celestia wanted, Twilight would probably never have met her friends and became a princess because it seems at times as if Twilight is the replacement for Sunset Shimmer.


Amazing! :O You did a really great job! It is so beautyful and moving!


Even though I don't watch this show anymore I love the animation!


This is amazing and I could tell wubcake did sunsets voice she's the best sunset voice actress ever please keep making these I wish fans like u could be in charge of the movies u guys rock


I have no words for a the animation, its absolutely amazing ! But the character's lines could have been better tbh


This was a good ten minutes of my life 👏👏👏


Nicely done.  You’ve got yourself a subscriber.


Wow! Other than Celestias neck looking a bit off from time to time, this was thoroughly enjoyable!!!


Anyone know the tune starting at 6:26?? I absolutely love it


So amazing! Right up there with the moon rises!


ok hoestly the best mlp animation ive watched for 2019 the animatin is amazing <br>i love everything about this animation

ok hoestly the best mlp animation ive watched for 2019 the animatin is amazing
i love everything about this animation


Omg that was so beautiful. I had vibes of Lullaby For A Princess.


Nice love tne style the colours the voice actors they are all perfect KEEP IT UP i love everything about this


Прекрасное творение, творцы молодцы, это не будет забыто...


I guarantee this will be voted as #1 for top 10 pony videos of march and of 2019


i love it with all my hearth this is even better than the comic ♡o♡


C juste magnifique l'animation le scénario y'a rien a redire


The animation is much better than that of the My Little Pony Movie!


Awwwww
That was actually amazing!
:D
I really enjoy seeing this animate film!
This was so good :b!!!!!


Holly shit, this a beautiful. This animation is so smooth and the colors are balanced. this is also a great story. i love this animation.


Masterpiece, i have even noting to say, bravo!

Кривенко Віталій


Hasbro should just straight up hire you right now!


<b>Is it me or Celestia's voice kinda sounds like Rose Quartz?</b>

*Is it me or Celestia's voice kinda sounds like Rose Quartz?*


Am I the only one who’s not a fan of the animation?
Like, the movement is smooth and the shading looks really nice for the most part. The voicing and sound design is spot on, and the story is pretty good from what I know.
It’s just.. some frames look kind of awkward? Like the anatomy looks really strange and the way their mouths move can look weird and unnatural at times.
Other than that, it’s pretty good.


Nice animating looks better than actual mlp


Ok, minty root, if you can make a series of this, you got yourself a sub for life, this kept me on edge, I kind of wanna know what's on other side of mirror please? I never did watch the full tv series, was a bit of a ill bug, spent most time snoozing lol x
Edit
Forgot to add, take time, defo worth it :)


Goddamn minty this video is the reason i subscribed to you.you outdid yourself on this one.hope you can keep making videos like this and good luck on the channel.


Holy good bejebus this animation is so good compared to a lot of the other fan animation things, heh, great jobbo mdudes


Wait I got questions:

-Why is this better animated than the actual my little pony
-why did youtube recommend this to me?
-This is just fucking beatiful


This is the one thing I have a problem with. I have a feeling that sunset shimmer was Celestias pupil AFTER Luna was sent to the moon<br>Otherwise this is amazing!!!

This is the one thing I have a problem with. I have a feeling that sunset shimmer was Celestias pupil AFTER Luna was sent to the moon
Otherwise this is amazing!!!


Thanks for this, I will not forget your efforts


..i still really prefer the old animation way. all this..flash using is really weird.
not to mention the movement and the pace in the entire video is weird, way too slow and boring.
the art still super amazing and beautiful
all draw so well, color, lighting, all spectacular.
but the animation still needs way more work to make it less feel unnatural.
using flash help lots in speed as god thx u don't have to go through frames by frames sh anymore but this kill the beautiful nature movement that 2D brings.
well, u have many more chance to learn how to use flash right!
this is overall a well-done work.
not perfect but good.
smooth and stuff but the movement of characters really threw off my hope for this.
love the art though, amazing and skillful!


wow, you really do incredible animations, you made the luna and celestia, you can do the cadance?


WTF dude i have no words to describe this awesome piece of art just congratulations i hope this awesome work be noticed and payback


BOY ITS SO GOOD THAT I CANT EVEN BREATHE-


Animations like these always get over 10 million veiws. Just know I was here before it even got 1 million.


eh, i don't really like this. something about how the audio doesn't quite fit with the animation, and the dialogue just sounds kinda... disjointed? i just didn't enjoy it because of that. however, the lighting was fantastic, and the settings were very well done. i did like the part at the beginning where the guard shines a light at the viewer, that particular animation was lovely. all in all, i can see how much effort was put in to this, but it just fell flat for me.

edit: the story was pretty good, just the way it was shown was unenjoyable and disjointed


Toon Boom Harmony was the same program they used to make the MLP movie. Good Job.


It's beautiful 😍😢<br>Where i can listen the soundtrack is verry beautiful

It's beautiful 😍😢
Where i can listen the soundtrack is verry beautiful


This is so awesome!! I'm gonna subscribe!!!


How can Luna still be trapped in the moon if Twilight is an alicorn and has the Element of Magic in her crown?


I had to sub that animation was flawless and beautiful


Love this.   ^^

Am gonna suggest it to Applegeek.  ^^


I don’t even like my little ponies but damn this is great


Damn that was far far better then I thought it was going to be. Like.


Can y’all just animate the show from now on please?


Hi! This video is amazing😍 I want to translate it to hungarian. Do you let me do it?


Wow! Do you animate stories from fimfiction.net? Because I have some stories on that website you might be interested in.


Part of me understands Sunset and blames Celestia but the other part thinks Sunset overreacted and just shut the would out


Technically, sunset did make a friend, if only a little bit, the princess herself...same other way....just saying lass, Sunset is kind of right, you also can't FORCE people to try to make friends...makes them stick out even more and makes them seem desperate poor Sunset, I fell your pain xx


the first 3D ponies animation which look very good!<br>Congratulation!

the first 3D ponies animation which look very good!
Congratulation!


I think this film is made better than the original


Sweet shitake mushrooms, that animation quality!


sunset's voice is WAY to low to present her age. XD


Is this real or based on real part of the series ?


Those were some fucking shadows and ripple effects I'm dead on the floor here that is Disney quality animation


i like your animation but you gotta make celestia's neck a little thicker XD im not hating okay?


Please tell me the name of the song at 1:40. Can't find the name :(


Stop comparing this to L4AP, the animation here is sloppy and the plot is unrealistic. L4AP kicks this animation's ass.


What is this I see? The Mirror of the Erised?


wow thats another deleted scenes part in eqg 1 :D


She is... the only reason she isn't at the end is because it's past that time.


Now I see why Celestia sent Twilight away. She feared if she restricted privileges such as the library and more advanced magic from her, she would become resentful to Celestia and might’ve gone on the same path as Starlight. Man has Celestia developed so much as a character.


i didnt watch the whole video yet so dont screech at me

celestia: get in the fucking mirror ya lil shit
student: CELESTIA IM SORRY I DIDNT MEAN TO BREAK UR #1 PRINCESS MUG
celestia: GET IN THE MIRROR

*i didnt watch the whole video yet so dont screech at me*

celestia: *get in the fucking mirror ya lil shit*
student: CELESTIA IM SORRY I DIDNT MEAN TO BREAK UR #1 PRINCESS MUG
celestia: *GET IN THE MIRROR*


Thorax is better queen then Celestia.....HE THINKS BEFORE HE SPEAKS


At first I thorought this was going to be a song


Omgoshhh its ... itssss wonderfullll wasome


I know everyone saying this is sad and all but is everyone just going to ignore the fact that SUNSET SHIMMER KILLED 2 GAURDS!?!?


Princess Celestia. Have you come too rescue me?
Sorry BVK not today.
To what do i owe the pleasure?
Minty Root the amazing animator what do you know about them.
Nothing only what I've seen recently you really shouldn't have to ask Tia.
What did you say you've seen?
Iv'e frequently been watching the same video. The one based from Sunset Shimmer.
Sunset Shimmer?
She was once a student of yours wasn't she?
Yes years ago.... unfortunately she took a dark path. I couldn't help her the way she wanted.
And  now you think that taking in Twilight will make up for your failure with your previous pupil?


Celestia: "Lol, you can't make any friends? Just go out and make friends. No library for you."

Celestia: "Well, I tried all I could." shrug

Celestia: "Lol, you can't make any friends? Just go out and make friends. No library for you."

Celestia: "Well, I tried all I could." *shrug*


astonishing is the only ward  have for this


Мне понравилось но только нет про русски😅😅😅😅

Арина матюшкина


Srry but  I don’t get it ?lol srsly princesse celestia just be friendly ? Really even the princess of friendship can explain better than that


It's not like that sunset shimmer goes to human world very along time. After too many years left them celestia told twilight. I know all about it i have seen all episodes of my little pony and equestria girls from season 1 to season 9 alll


Be my friends<br>This is easy way lol I figured it out

Be my friends
This is easy way lol I figured it out