Absolutely stunning.  Not only is the animation gorgeous but Sunset Shimmer is one of my favorite ponies.  I definitely think she needed more screen time, and I loved every moment. :)

Still, it's never enough for me. :)@Saul Medina


Пересматриваю много раз.Это просто афигенно.Очень круто 😃


Does anybody know what the soundtrack that starts at 8:12 is? I tried looking but I didn't find it.


This comment is more than a little late.
But i am going to say it anyway.
First off brilliant animation. The only thing i have to say that isn't really a critic is the mouths. The animation of the mouths moving as the ponies talk could better. More often than not when i see this type of stuff it is usually because it is very hard to animated and O-shaped mouth to sound out any words that require that type of animation. When i saw this you did do a type of O-shaped mouth but it was mostly just the bottom part of the mouth opening and closing to match the words.
Second off the story was amazing. coming from a person who has already seen sunset's backstory from Hasbro if i hadn't seen this i would have accepted it as a form of fanfic canonicity until you were proven otherwise. so far though knowing what i know you were not far off the mark. Some things were correct and some were wrong. However a lot of what was shown is in the grey area where it could be canon or it could not.
Otherwise it is a brilliant animation I believe i will be watching your other works and may or may not critic them to so don't hate on me. i do to draw your attention to what can be fixed and worked on in the future. Think of them as heavy suggestions.


Holy sweet Celestia!!! I loved this! The animated film based on a comic to Sunset Shimmer's origin gave me a lot of tears!!! Well done for working this, it was really worth watching this! 😥😢😘💜


A story dedicated to my 6th favorite pony this is great The way love the animation it’s similar to the MLP movie!


GOSH <br>This is something i would pay to watch on the big screen!! This was so amazing minty!!HASBRO TAKE NOTES

GOSH
This is something i would pay to watch on the big screen!! This was so amazing minty!!HASBRO TAKE NOTES

I'm not gonna lie, this hit me 8n the feels

I KNOW RIGHT? In my opinion, this animator honestly deserves to be paid more than Hasbro.

Reminds me of one of those short films you watch after a full length movie. I could totally see this being a short film that comes with MLP the movie.


This looks like a mlp movie but 3D i guess<br>And i wanna say how good this is! Like tbh the voice actor of sunset is sooooooooo GOOD!!

This looks like a mlp movie but 3D i guess
And i wanna say how good this is! Like tbh the voice actor of sunset is sooooooooo GOOD!!


MLP animators: we're good quality show

This person: hold tea and crumpets


The sound effects could use some work but its still incredible


5:03 you can't order someone to make friends.
Friendship has to be something you want for yourself.

5:03 you can't *order* someone to make friends.
Friendship has to be something you want for yourself.

@Navy Rajyn Well, I'm 19 years old and she's let me grow my own wings and make my own decisions. We still talk every once in a while over the internet, and everything's been good so far.

It might be too early to tell, but I think we're on a better track now.

@Miguel Rojas have things gotten better between you and her?

exactly. Sometimes making friends just isn't your first priority in life. friendship is a great thing, but it isn't everything :I saying friendship is everything really punches people who have a really hard time making friends in the face..

Navy Rajyn I agree. My mother has been trying to do that to me for the longest time. Now, I'm a day away from being an adult...

... and in spirit, light years away from her.


Anyone else think the Celestia VA was channeling more of a Rose Quartz vibe?


"You're a hypocrite! You don't even have friends!"<br>Well she's not wrong.

"You're a hypocrite! You don't even have friends!"
Well she's not wrong.


это прекрасно..❤🤧

это прекрасно..❤🤧


people still make mlp aninations...it makes me happy...rly happy...


If they change the animation style of MLP in generation 5 then this better be it.


You altered some issues of the actual story, but it's fantastic!


One thing that makes me kinda sad is that twilight was basicly there to fix the mistakes celestia made. It shown celestia the she could be a ruler but still. I feel as though she mainly had twilight to make a friend and fix her mistakes. Also, to take over one day. It's kinda sad


I’m not really into MLP, but even I have to admit this animation is beautiful


"We didn't stand a chance!"

Well of course not, you don't even try to defend the princesses


Sunset Shimmer is my favourite character in mLP EG and always will be it's just so sad 😞 that she never got to have a happy backstory


certainly, it all looks very moving, I even cried at the end of the video


I think... I think my eyes have been blessed and my heart was stabbed. The fact that Celestia was pretty much alone... Oof...


The scenery and lighting has me in awe, it's so amazingly well made!<br>Great work!

The scenery and lighting has me in awe, it's so amazingly well made!
Great work!


that was good it almost looked like the movie style itself so it's like a fan made thing of how sunset shimmer became evil I might do a reaction video to this one day maybe.


You did such a good job on making this video


I wish I could use this animation for my upcoming equestrianville series but I don't know how to get it so ill have to keep it stop motion.


That was amazing Minty Root! I was dazzled when I saw this video. Your efficiency of animation and visual effects are getting better than ever. I love to see more again.


MLP called, they want their legendary animator back.


Man... your making me <b>LOVE</b> Sunset Shimmer

Man... your making me *LOVE* Sunset Shimmer


:( im holding bak tears, this is beautiful


You did an amazing job at adapting the comic. You captured the same style as the movie.


Tbh you gotta think abt it-
Celestia banished her sister
She probs doesn’t have parents
She is the most wanted pony EVER
She rules over a whole kingdom
…
It was quite convenient that twilight came cause you can see tia put others before herself and was tired..
She’s immortal no pony can live that long except alicorns and stuff
And then this just makes it deeply sad


And thus, the story ends with Twilight's first visit to Earth.


Magnifica historia épica del origen de sunser simet


Two Moondancers, that’s pretty unique, thumbs up for Wubcake and AnnaChloem for voicing Celestia and Sunset Shimmer

Well, one is a reference to the comic's version of Moondancer in "The Fall of Sunset Shimmer". Specifically the one with the long mane.

I’m glad I’m not the only person who noticed.

Wubcake yes, because they’re my waifus! 😍


@Minty Root That animation, those expressions. Truly a well polished and lovingly crafted work. Everyone involved should be proud. This is why I love this fandom. <3


this is so good, I NEED MOOORE!!<br>I always wanted to know what happened to Sunset when she arrived the human world

this is so good, I NEED MOOORE!!
I always wanted to know what happened to Sunset when she arrived the human world


АлексФорд Грэй


The lighting, settings, and magic were spectacular  while the giraffe necked Celestia and Sunset Shimmer walk to nowhere look like a child drew them and so the character animation and setting just doesn’t mix well. I wanted the characters to go away so I could just look at the backgrounds.<br>The script was poor as well. While the voice actors weren’t awful I felt like everyone was portrayed as really childish and the ending made little sense

The lighting, settings, and magic were spectacular  while the giraffe necked Celestia and Sunset Shimmer walk to nowhere look like a child drew them and so the character animation and setting just doesn’t mix well. I wanted the characters to go away so I could just look at the backgrounds.
The script was poor as well. While the voice actors weren’t awful I felt like everyone was portrayed as really childish and the ending made little sense


This is amazing Minty! And, like everyone said, this has to be one of, if not the best, MLP animation out there! Keep up the good work!


The animation is amazing, but the sound of the hoofsteps is really annoying. It very clearly doesn't match up with their actual steps at all, except in a few select areas.


Wow, that is cool. Sad and tragic. But it makes some sense. So awesome.


This might be one of the best mlp fan films I've seen in my life IMO. Even though it's inspired by the Fall of Sunset Shimmer by IDW It should instead be evaluated as it's own thing instead of an adaptation.
The use of 2D and 3D animation is smooth and perfect. And the use of shadows and dark colors is used perfectly. It almost rivals the MLP movie.
But what I love more is the tone. It's very melancholic. It's interesting to know that while in the comic Sunset came off as selfish in this film she came kind of sympathetic.
Very good fan film.


Hasbro: <b>We needa hire this talented Animator-</b>

Hasbro: *We needa hire this talented Animator-*


Princess Celestia sounds like Rose Quartz from Steven Universe in this.


it’s confusing me that the student’s voice sounds waaay older than the “teacher’s” voice? lol not sure what their relationship is


Minty Root: makes THIS masterpiece

Hasbro: excuse me wtf


Вот это рисовка. Очень красиво.

Вот это рисовка. Очень красиво.

ЮЛИЯ НИКОНОВА


Ah man how I've missed these MLP fan projects ^_^. I loved the story in the comic but wondered why the main series never really covered it. So nice to see someone give it life and movement. Till quite beautiful too, all that hard work really shows. Good job to everyone involved!


Celestia: "I guide others to a treasure I cannot possess"


Celestia cometio dos errores al hacer lo que creia correcto
Perdio a su alumna y desterro a su hermana
Obviamente no cometeria el mismo error con twilight


Oh..My..Sweet..Celestia THIS WAS SO AMAZING!! NEW SUBSCRIBER I WANNA SEE MORE YOUR SO GOOD AT ANIMATING AND LIKE, THE SPECIAL EFFECTS, THE EMOTION, JUST..EVERYTHIGN WAS SOO COOOOOOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! this is actually better than thw actual movies, like seriously. SO COOL!!


this fandom never ceases to amaze me; this was incredible


may i ask what app do you use to animate?


Amazing job! It almost like the MLP movie. Can't wait to see more.


This is amazing! Plus you just figured out Sunset's cutie mark


Who here is over ten but still watches my little pony and is embarrassed to talk about it but still really enjoys it?

Just me?

Okay..


This was an absolutely amazing animation! I've been waiting for this ever since its first teaser and now that it's out, that wait was completely worth it. Incredible job, Minty Root! 10 outta fucking 10!

Lol you were just telling that person what to do <br>Like isn't your life upto you anywayyy

Lol you were just telling that person what to do
Like isn't your life upto you anywayyy

@Rexo He must be so happy that he cursed

MorbidTheBrony : LANGUAGE THERES OTHER VIEWERS SHAME ON YOU


Was that giant hourglass keeping track of the day ever seen in the show? I feel like that's a canon artifact but I'm not sure


Tip: watch with brightness fully up. (Otherwise you can’t see bc some of the scenes are dark.)


Omg this was soooo good!!! You should be the designer for the animation of the next mlp movie!!


I can't believe this is made by fans.... The animation is much better than the original, I'm literally shocked, the details are so beautiful and realistic, seriously, I can't describe how impressed I am, it's an amazing job, you're awesome!! And of course I can't help but say about the plot, I really like your idea and the way you showed the conflict between Celestia and Sunset. It's such a heavy and emotional film, and I love it.


If it is going,the animation this great.this is epic!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  .it's nice that someone does such things . THANKS


"To.. do good things?"
"Yeah but to who! Sunset.. you must make friends.."

Its so deep on so meny levels.

@Navy Rajyn pretty much. If you watch the pilot episode of FIM, the reference guide said "The Elements of Harmony, Located in the Castle of The Two Sisters  are the only things that can defeat Nightmare Moon."

@FBEAR05 correct me if I'm wrong but that sounds like Celestia wanted Sunset to have friends just so that she can get her sister back AKA turning Sunset into a means to an end

@Navy Rajynmy guess is She wanted to make her the Element of Magic. She must've forgotten about the tree of harmony because the Elements fell dormant after Celestia used them to banish Luna. The Tree probably already knew Twilight was the chosen one and Celestia had no clue cause she forgot about the tree.

@FBEAR05 I'm not sure what you're saying here. What does twilight "friendshipping" Luna have to do with Celestia basically telling Sunset that her magic has no purpose without friends?

@Navy Rajyn she wasn't herself because from this part of the timeline, Luna is still on the moon. Twilight didn't "Friendship" her yet. Celestia is still stressed out having to work a graveyard shift with no rest

Sounds like Celestia is saying that Sunset has no purpose without friends. And that just doesn't sound right.

I really liked the part where she tries to bribe Moondancer for friendship, really shows how she gets the high school to follow her in a reverse foreshadowing kind of way.


Plz I need to know the name of the music at 8:20! This was a masterpiece tho I can’t stop rewatching it!!!


I'm really heartbroken you didn't get to animate the mlp movies this is all amazing!!


Celestia: Don't touch please! Only for skilled students!
Me: SUNSET GOES BACK AND FOURTH A L L T H E T I M E

Celestia: Don't touch please! Only for skilled students!
Me: SUNSET GOES BACK AND FOURTH A L L T H E *T I M E*


Wow this is a very beautiful video I love animations but I wish one day I’ll learn how to do it


1:22 Celestia’s eyes dilate as she comes into the light THE FRICK THE DETAIL-


Ahh; this is just so lovely! A project of love and dedication; well done!


How did you make this!! It’s incredible 😱😱


This is 1,000 times better than the entire eqg franchise.🙄


You know, It's kind of Celestia's fault. Sunset just didn't want friends.


Wow! You capture everyones voice even sunsets shimmers voice.


I love how u made the magic kinda like fire!😍


I love the two moondancers . Latw to the party. Well done


This animation is so... dark and... and just so much better then the original... :D


It's a bummer that Sunset has been made defunct by Hasbro, I guess it's good she's not in G5. I don't want Sunset in a show about activism.


I heard the music and immediately thought "Ah yes, Equestria At War!"


I think this clearly shows how sunset abandoned her studies in equestria


Whats the point of Celestia having friends if she will outlive them by thousands of years?


Wey noooooo me hiciste llorar en si la animación la considero bastante buena casi exacta a la de la serie digo casi por que en ciertas ocasiones he sentido que la animación fue hecha con animación en símbolos si eso es asi se ve que se ha hecho un gran esfuerzo,  igual buen trabajo


Damn this is well made! Especially the graphics dude. Only thing to make this a donald-trump-worth-watching movie is SLIGHTLY improving the mouth sync


This is the most amazing animation ever omg you deserve a reward hazbro should higher you


hi your a furry too I'm 1 too I'm a wolf


Who feels like this is better the episode its self....its so well animated


Wubcake sounds EXACTLY like Sunset Shimmer


this is absolutely gorgeous <33<br>i really didn't expect such quality with such a short amount of time to finish things!! May I just say how lovely the lighting is as well? the scenery and backgrounds were also really well done, as well as the voice acting!

this is absolutely gorgeous <33
i really didn't expect such quality with such a short amount of time to finish things!! May I just say how lovely the lighting is as well? the scenery and backgrounds were also really well done, as well as the voice acting!


Gosh dang you beautiful person you have restored my faith in this show


Why this is better than orginal MLP? ;-; It's amaizing. I love it ;-;


They should use this type of animating for G5, I might actually pay attention to the show + hopefully they have this calm shading. It's so satisfying and doesn't burn my eyes.


Celestia probably had friends but out lived them. She only had Luna but then she was banished to the moon! Oh wait...that would probably happen to Twilight too...


Impressive , it look like it took you a lot of work


i just want to say thank you i really needed this animation i wish the accual mlp told us this info


"You're a Hypocrite! You don't even HAVE friends"

Celestia: ........off to the moon with you


"Sunset Shimmer, a former student of mine. She started her studies not long before Twilight did"

Oh, Minty Root. You made things MOAH CONFUSING!!!

Edit: I came back to this comment after 1 year and what the flying fish i was such an idiot

"Sunset Shimmer, a former student of mine. She started her studies not long before Twilight did"

Oh, Minty Root. You made things *MOAH CONFUSING!!!*

Edit: I came back to this comment after 1 year and what the flying fish i was such an idiot

My theory is that Sunset started her studies a few years before Twailait (Celestia has been ruling Equestria for a 1111 years, I don't really know what she means by "not long before"). Celestia thought Sunset would be the one freeing her sister from the Moon, Sun (set) liberating Moon makes sense for me. But then, she saw a powerful pony get her Cutie Mark as part of a prophecy (Twailait) and she'd doubt about Sunset. That's why she urged her to prove she could make friends and at the same time teach Twailait, but since Sunset runs away she realizes she has been to harsh on poor Sunset and changes her ways of teaching. <br>Sorry for the long text :)

My theory is that Sunset started her studies a few years before Twailait (Celestia has been ruling Equestria for a 1111 years, I don't really know what she means by "not long before"). Celestia thought Sunset would be the one freeing her sister from the Moon, Sun (set) liberating Moon makes sense for me. But then, she saw a powerful pony get her Cutie Mark as part of a prophecy (Twailait) and she'd doubt about Sunset. That's why she urged her to prove she could make friends and at the same time teach Twailait, but since Sunset runs away she realizes she has been to harsh on poor Sunset and changes her ways of teaching.
Sorry for the long text :)

@Human Dog oh yeah that might be a logical explanation

But if sunset was a teenager (I think) that means she is older than Twilight because celestia said that she started her studies not long before Twilight
Confused screaming

But if sunset was a teenager (I think) that means she is older than Twilight because celestia said that she started her studies not long before Twilight
*Confused screaming*

Well if this were a real prequel of Sunset, I say it's better than the comic.

@brian hoang "Well what do you expect?" I expected you to <b>get</b> how it's a joke

@brian hoang "Well what do you expect?" I expected you to *get* how it's a joke

Well what do you expect? Sunset had a lot of arrogant and ambition like Starscream.

Well what do you expect? Sunset was once an arrogant unicorn with a lot of ambition like Starscream.

Moondancer was in the classroom. They were around the same age. Neither of them had friends at the time, so they wouldn’t know each other.

That only works in comics. This is animation. Go with it.

The sirens came from Equestria to the human world, and they didn't change much there either. To me, I think the two world's timespans are different

@Human Dog makes  it kind of sad that Sunset made that huge decision to run away at an early age

@monsterjambrony Cuz like I said,  Twilight came to school not long after Sunset did meaning she also came there at around the same age.

Human Dog If that’s the case then why are Twilight and Sunset the same age?

Sunset began her studies as a filly
A few months, which is clearly not long, Twilight got her cutie mark as a filly
Sunset went to the other dimension a few days after that, I guess and ruled it, and a few years she comes back to steal the crown

It was a transition from a flashback to the start of the first movie.

Maybe Celestia thought Sunset and Twilight at the same time? And they never crossed paths until after Sunset quit. And maybe they were both fillies at the same time, I mean you said that Celestia said “She BEGAN her studies not long before Twilight did.” Problem solved.

It basically means that sunset is way older than twillight, because celesta thaught twillight when she was a filly

The thing is after the Next day Twilight went to the school and got her cutie mark

(*Not long before Twilight did*)
Thats my theory


I believe it tells the story on how sunset ended up inside of the mirror


Can someone Tell me Title of the Music, in 6:25? ☺


I never understood the importance of making friends to Celestia


That was..... whoa. <br>It was so inspired, so awesome that I want to ask more from the creators of MLP to do soemthing similar to this... Tell us the story of Sunset Shimmer.

That was..... whoa.
It was so inspired, so awesome that I want to ask more from the creators of MLP to do soemthing similar to this... Tell us the story of Sunset Shimmer.


I love celestia even when she make mistakes I LOVE HER


Music :
Seventh Element
Album: The Ministry Mares
Track:  Twilight Sparkle


The first time a fanmade is well animated


The feeeeeels...

Wonderful job with the animation. The wait was definitely worth it.


Damn sunset was really like “uh i use magic for good cause it’s the right thing to do...” and then Celestia is like, “oKAY BUT U STILL NEED FRIENDS!”

Makes you realize that she was naturally a good pony being raised in the wrong environment.


I wish the storyline was as good as the art


What program did you use to animate this?


Que animación tan espectacular se parece a la original sus voces la animación TODO! es increíble , te felicito por un gran trabajo ❤


you need more subs and views!! gurl this is AMAZING!


OMS THIS IS SO SAD AND SO WELL DONE GOD THIS IS AMAZING!!


This is better than the my little pony that I watched as a lil kid


I absolutely enjoyed watching every minute of this great work to everyone who worked on this


Прослезилась в половине фильма,у меня же друзья только в соц.сети,а в реальности только мама... 😃


Estuvo chido y alguien me explica la historia porfis


Now this is a high-quality fandom creation. Every aspect of the animation, from the ripples to the shadows, was gorgeous.


Now I wonder how Twilight and Sunset never met each other, I mean if they are above the same age and both were students of Celestia, it's kinda weird


Is very beautiful and sad, This animated is perfect


Вау, это лучшее, что я видела в своей жизни(из видео про поняшек)


Your animations never cease to amaze me, even if I haven't spoken to you in awhile. I can't believe how long you've been working on this, and it paid off insanely. The unique style, all the wonderful scenery, how the 3D and 2D just mesh together- oh god I love it ALL. You did an amazing job Minty. I'm super proud of you.


Celestia lost her sister and sunset shimmer. Twilight was her last chance, so she is not a good friend or teacher or sister. She's just trying.


I am so glad that this showed up in my recc. You just got a sub!


Тут есть психологизм. В комиксе нет таких уточнений, да и грубовато там, а здесь все более полно... здорово! Amazing!


Oh My Goddess!  Minty this was simply "Epic"!  >_<   The beautiful animation, score and acting were so powerful.  The portrayals by Anne Chloe M and Wubcake's left me speechless and moved to tears they were so well done.  I love how you wove a story that seamlessly joints the IDW comic with the FIM/MLP show cannon.  Though seeing both version of Moon Dancer sitting side-by-side in the field was a little bit odd, but nice.  Bravo dear Minty, bravo beloved friend.  ^_^


"You're a hypocrite! You don't even have friends!"

I wouldn't want to make friends as an immortal being either.
Why bother making friends when you know you're just gonna outlive them anyway?


𝓑𝓣𝓢'𝓼  𝒹𝓇𝒶𝓌𝒽𝑜𝓁𝒾𝒸ン゙代


Two sun butts in one animation
You could say this is....

One hot topic

Huh, I thought that it meant two full moons. ; }

<b>I Write Sins Not Tragedies intensifies</b>

*I Write Sins Not Tragedies intensifies*

Funny I went to the Hot Topic store today in the mall, then to see this comment 😂


Watching this over and over again made me realise how much the story btw Princesse Celestia and Sunset Shimmer is so saaadddd


Anybody ever thought that maybe she wants her students so desperately to make friends because she doesn't want that they have to suffer from the same loneliness she did?


The quality of animation is better than original mlp XD


Well one of the few animations I really watched the credits off, because how awesome the whole thing is. Thank you and your team for making it! :)

The story is awesome, the backgrounds and eyes of the ponies are very nicely and atmospheric done, also the music fits for the scenes and supports the atmosphere. Well done!

Only little thing I would like to point out is the way tails are contected to the ponies like at 6:54 when Celestia stood on the balcony or her leg animations while she flies over, that could have made a little bit better I assume. Still, great job!


as sunset said "your a hypocrite you don't have any friends" I was like ohhhhh that must have hurt so bad.


8:06 Hey, that's a remake of "Twilight Sparkle" by Seventh Element!


When you think about it Celestia is really bad at keeping relationships, like she sent her sister to the moon, she let sunset shimmer down, I'm sure the only reason Twilight seemed like her favourite is because THEN she had experience

@Reese Yeah, but keep in mind celestia kinda did  cause Luna to become nightmare moon, because she wasn't caring for her sister, so0000oo0o0o-

did you forget that celestia literally had no choice but to send Luna to the moon? if she let nightmare moon remain, equestria would've suffered under eternal night.


MY EYES IT BURNS!!!

Because of it's beauty


this was truly beautiful, might be even better than the comic.<br>you all did an amazing job on this. thank you for making it

this was truly beautiful, might be even better than the comic.
you all did an amazing job on this. thank you for making it


The next movie should be animated like this


Sunset was supposed to be Celestia’s successor instead of Twilight.


If mlp was this well animated we would get an episode evrey.....

How long?

Oh yeah

ONCE EVREY 1000 YEARS!!


Shoot I-I’m falling back into the brony phase


i swear when i see sunset shimmer it feels like im staring at mirror it makes cry at times i struggle to make friends


This is better than any My Little Pony episode or movie, Hasbro wants to hire you!


this was the second moment i cried when it was my little pony, the first one was a canterlot wedding part 1


This is beautiful!! I never seen anything like this.

Hey! What video are you making next? Is it gonna be about Princess Dark Matter?


I'm surprised anyone disliked this it's so amazing ÙwÚ


I kinda like it and it's beautiful and amazing.


Hi this is really great and I've tried both of those channels that you left in the description for the songs but I cannot find the song could you please tell me the name of the song you used at 8:31


is it just me or did Celestia think that sunset was gonna be the princess of friendship-


Simply amazing, especially the lighting, voice's! You and your crew  did a spectacular job!


OH MY GOD I WOULD MAY MILLIONS TO HAVE THIS PLAYED IN THE MOVIE THEATER IF I HAD THE MONEY THIS WAS BEYOND YOUTUBE-


hello, I loved your animation I would love to know if you would give me permission to do a dubbing in Spanish of it


Question: why do we in the very beginning see Luna and when celestia raises the moon you can clearly see nightmare moons mark on the moon


Holy shit!?!? Why am I barely watching this? Where was this? 💀 This is amazing


Loved it, especially the ending that lead to the begining of Equestria Girls


When celestia says "make friends" its make me<br> crying because i miss my best friend

When celestia says "make friends" its make me
 crying because i miss my best friend


Considering that Luna and celestia retired I think that sunset was going to be the next princess of the sun but when she left she had no successor with such a specific magic so she and Luna ended up needing to put there magic in a artifact for twilight to use I think this is why equestria fell as seen in gen 5 there was no successor immortality doesn’t meen you can do things forever.


I love the animation but some scenes look weird.


"You're a hypocrite! You don't even have friends!"
ME: Fuck yeah, Sunset! Great job! 10/10, Shut up and Take my Money! Jesus Christ! Ha! Got it!  Boom, bitch! Get out of the way! Captain America approves the references.

PS: But, seriously, the best line ever!


I was in tears the whole time watching, this, the music is soothing, the animation looks amazing!!! and the whole entire video is amazing! 😁


Seriously, this animation is better than the My Little Pony Movie.


I'll never regret subscribing to you because you make some the best animations in MLP fandom. You really do you show the creative side of this fandom.🎉❤


...That... Was... T_T

...Now, I wanna see what would your vision be, when Luna becomes Nightmare Moon and how she and Celestia repair their relationship, when Twilight and her friends restored her from Nightmare Moon.


if this was series 100% i will love it forever well not life but [ LOVE Bond Feelings yes to the series <3 ]


I can see who ever made the animation in this video, put their heart and soul in it.

Kill me.

The video is perfect.


This is SO BEAUTIFUL WHAT THE HELL. AHHH


Me wondering to myself: what would happen if they all went in? Obviously, some very confusing stuff. But seriously, why did they stop?


Looking at the cast
Of course she would be voicing sunset shimmer! 😂😂😂😂

*Looking at the cast*
Of course she would be voicing sunset shimmer! 😂😂😂😂


Wow... This is so gorgeous, never seen a long animation so well done, with 3D effects, in the fandom, your style is so cute and beautiful at the same time, Really really impressive !!
All those expressions, the voices are really well done too, this is a big projects and really worth, Omc really well done again !! :o
/)


What is the name of the 10:14 minute song?

Its from 7th element  ..you'll find the song there but 7th element is just recently uploading the songs used in this video so the song that your looking for will be uploaded in the near  future..(im also waiting for this song too)


Very good fan-projekt.
But something is bothering me.
Why has Twilight (At 0:50) already the Crown?
If it is the scene from the Movie
then why does sunset apear with out the Crown when Celestia walks from Twilight to the Mirror?
Or is it just a Flashback by Celestia?


The actress who plays Sunset sounds like her.


An Equestria where friendship is indeed NOT magic...


Ppl we still need to look at this issue from another perspectives. Try to look at from Celestia’a hooves...

Ya she’s a hypocrite


Hasbro should’ve hired you to make the Mlp movie


You should be hired to work on mlp<br> also i hope to see some more sunset animations n stuff

You should be hired to work on mlp
 also i hope to see some more sunset animations n stuff


But Luna wasn't there to ever meet Sunset until she came to Equestria looking for why her friends suddenly forgot her...


Outstanding work, thank you for including me in it <3


When your teacher realizes she is not your friend. <br>Also shouldn’t  sunset shimmer be psychically smaller than she was in the movies?

When your teacher realizes she is not your friend.
Also shouldn’t  sunset shimmer be psychically smaller than she was in the movies?


all is amazing except the way celestial acts. she's being too rude/mean<br>she's not like that

all is amazing except the way celestial acts. she's being too rude/mean
she's not like that


It's so... Cool! I can't even find any other words.


Fabulous animation. Everyone did a fantastic job I really love this story about Sunset Shimmer. Have a wonderful day Minty and Wubcake.

LINDA PLAYS YT Spoiler alert in this Comment. Now if you watched the 1st Equestria Girls then Equestria Girls Forgotten Friendships were Sunset Returns to Equestria and reunites with Celestia. You would understand it better. Sunset Desires Power in Equestria Girls 1st movie then overtime she learned the Magic of Friendship. However when Sunset and Celestia  meat in Equestria pony world, they have a special Moment of Forgiveness.

Idk the story behind sunset shimmer and im clueless to why this happened xd


Oh so magic is real. I mean how else does this happen in only <b>a year?</b>

Oh so magic is real. I mean how else does this happen in only *a year?*


"Your a hypocrite,you don't even have freinds"

The coach doesn't play

She does but shes too busy being princess

@Kags and Kiris special Somebody and that's probably the wisest decision you could make. It's just an awful clusterfuck

@MissShizko Uhhh I haven't even heard of that and if thats anime i'll never watch it.

Have you watched Simba JR at the world cup? Coaches DO play. And when they do, theyre OP

Artsplative

At that point, since Celestia is doing fine being too busy to maintain friendships, Sunset has a point on not needing them. The point is if friendship is so important, why would someone of great influence not have any, at least as Sunset figured, yet reprimand her for the same thing of not having friends? Is being a princess with responsibilities enough to excuse you from friendship?

@Conut Gnuz yeah not really she is full time princess she doesn't have time for that but I do agree celestia could of handle that better

Artsplative
She has to prove that she could to Sunset before Celestia forces her to do something Sunset struggles in doing
Basically set an example for Sunset for something as important as friendship

@Conut Gnuz I think she dose but she can't because you know she is a full time  princess almost anyone would be scared too and well she doesn't have time

but they know how to play, this coach doesn't


not gonna lie but she treated twilight with more love because she don't really want make it to happened it again

and that is really sad for the past of sunset =( it makes me me cry


I think the Princess should listen and talk with Sunset instead order her to make a friend immidiately . That was a mentor should do


Wow!!!!! That was stunning!!! I loved the style of the ponies and the shadows!!! And on top of that the story was really good ❤


Well actually I feel sunset has to be sad and angry
Celestia was more harsh to her but she was so kind to twilight
Celestia even didn't try to go to throw the mirror and at least ask her to come back (but she will probably do that for twilight)


I'm confused, is this 2D animated, or 3D animated?


This Moment when a fanart is better than the original👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻❤❤


The set pieces are gorgeous; it felt like I was looking at environments from the movie.  Though if I interpret canon correctly, Celestia was a hardass during the Sunset student years.

Mlai00 You still said she was a hardass in those years in canon. And if anyone’s going to comfort the actual situation until the show does, it would be the comics.

@AlzMarioWolfe Canon = The cartoons, including Equestria Girls.
Non-canon = All fan works, and the IDW comics.
And knowing canon implied she was different in those years does not make me dislike Celestia.

Mlai00 I’m... not even an IDW comic fanboy, I just know what the truth is and you know what I can’t stand? People who blatantly hate Celestia when she actually didn’t do any wrong. That’s what’s worse.

@AlzMarioWolfe Chill, spud, chillll.  Where do you see me saying this fan animation is canon?<br>I can't stand IDW Comics fanboys.

@AlzMarioWolfe Chill, spud, chillll.  Where do you see me saying this fan animation is canon?
I can't stand IDW Comics fanboys.

Mlai00 She didn’t “break the rules”, she was a literal threat to Celestia and the students. She chose not to befriend anyone, that’s literally all she had to do and she failed. And then she BROKE INTO THE DARK MAGIC LIBRARY. That’s probably breaking a LAW.

Mlai00 Oh look, you definitely didn’t read the comic that’s much more canon than this animation because she didn’t banish her from Equestria, only the castle. That’s fucking fair considering she basically told Celestia she wanted power in a selfish way and literally insulted ponies who congratulated her. This is all Sunset’s fault. I have no clue how you could even say that canon made Celestia a hardass about this situation because I personally can’t remember it being described in detail past Celestia recapping it at the beginning of the first movie.

@AlzMarioWolfe (1) Comic is not canon.  (2) Even if it was, nopony but a hardass outright exiles a pony for breaking the rules (a forgivable offense).


Holy crap she sounds exactly like sunset


Sunset: "you don't have friends either" <br>OOOOOOHHH!!! SNAP!!!

Sunset: "you don't have friends either"
OOOOOOHHH!!! SNAP!!!


Its not Really Sunset’s fault its Celestia cause She Forced/Encouraged her to have  <br>Friends if she doesn’t want too

Its not Really Sunset’s fault its Celestia cause She Forced/Encouraged her to have
Friends if she doesn’t want too


This is the best thing I think I have ever seen


It's so, so  beautiful and sad!  It's perfect!))) And the animation is wonderful!

P. S. I'm just learning to speak.

Вика Кошкина


Oh my ghawd this is the most that I've been found this is so smooth animation I love this


THAT'S SO SAD!😭😭😭😭😭😭<br>"YOU DON'T EVEN HAVE FRIENDS!"

THAT'S SO SAD!😭😭😭😭😭😭
"YOU DON'T EVEN HAVE FRIENDS!"


what's up with celestia choosing students with sky related names, not to mention redeemed villians with sky related names


This is so amazing. The good Old mlp Times are comming back to Life ❤


Celestia: it’s easy to make friends! You can figure it out!

Me: Well maybe she is shy

MAYBE she’s fine on her own!

MAYBE SHE HAS SOCIAL ANXIETY AND CANT HANDLE THE PRESSURE! EVER THINK ABOUT THAT? HUH? CELEST???

Sorry… went a little far there…


They Need to make a Movie about what really happen to Sun Set Shimmer and about her life how cool Would that be to watch .

Or a Movie in which Sunset Shimmer is not betraying Princess Celestia, so she becomes her first protege. So when Twilight Sparkle comes to Celestia's magic school, Sunset is the one who is the student mentor of Twilight.


DAM GIRL/BOI,you should be an animater for a movie or something you got talent


Hasbro could use you as an "mlp the epilogue" animator


Ummmm.............can I live in a world with this amazing lighting???😍😍😍


Who knows what the name of the song from 6:25 - 8:00. Tell me please


This animation is beautiful! I hope G5 is in this style.

Sike, now we have pony life...<br>Yaay... :|

Sike, now we have pony life...
Yaay... :|

I don't think g5 will be in this style, because mlp is supposed to appeal to young girls, and the colours are supposed to be bright

Lenichiou do you mean the fan animation or the 2017 ?

@Caleb Prescott the movie IS canon, right?

Looks like it would take a lot of time tho but yeah it would be awesome


анимация, конечно, не супер, но сюжет заставляет смотреть дальше.<br>(да, я знаю, что автор не русский)

анимация, конечно, не супер, но сюжет заставляет смотреть дальше.
(да, я знаю, что автор не русский)

шуряо миллис


i think its funny this is animated better than the series


This animation is really well done. I'm really proud of your work. Keep it up!


Extraordinary. Oh how YouTube policies have fallen😔


congratulations an excellent and extraordinary work


Did anyone notice the Celestia said disabayed instead of disobeyed?


I love animation of all kinds, especially smooth ones. This was absolutely amazing and a new favorite for me. Great job!!!


Jesus Christ the animation is stellar, the only thing even remotely off is the moon when she was raising it at 7:16 but it isn't bad


It's a good movie but maybe it was too dark


History 10/10
Animation 10/10
Voice acting 10/10


Hmm, looks a lot like the MLP Movie, that’s probably because it was animated in the same program as the movie.


The way I see it sunset shimmer didn't really try that hard to make friends.


Oh hey, I'm in there. In any case, good job, Minty, you make some, if not the most beautiful poniy animes in Equestria.


Oi! This is awesome, GJ really!<br>Also, so cool to hear Radiarc and Seventh musics :3

Oi! This is awesome, GJ really!
Also, so cool to hear Radiarc and Seventh musics :3


0:50 when mom comes to make sure you’re asleep and not on your phone at three in the morning

0:50 *when mom comes to make sure you’re asleep and not on your phone at three in the morning*


So how did the guy who created this short film got the voices right.


Me when I first watched this

Me before : idk what this is but this is adorable

Me now:
Dam , I was so dumb before


Next, please make animated other stories based on other comics like Nightmare Rarity and My Little Pony: The Movie prequels? But with different storylines and be careful changing the storyline so Please.🙏🙏🙏


Do I have the right to dislike? This is just sad man-


It's really amazing !! It's so beautiful... Everything is perfect. <br>Thank you so much for this <3

It's really amazing !! It's so beautiful... Everything is perfect.
Thank you so much for this <3


Base on your description u mean u animated the comic version of this amazing 😱😱😱😱😱


I guess Celestia dosent see Sunset as a Friend? That's like Twilight not counting Spike as a friend.


Esto es lo que todos queríamos ver en la serie real

Like si es asi


So that's what it happen before Equestria Girls 1...


Damn the animation is more complex than the og show damn u should be an animator to there company


Ohhhhhh, so this is where my little pony questria girl came from


It's a pity that I don't know English. The animation is great!


Aff queria q tivesse legenda em português


Can't believe what my eyes just saw. Amazing animation work.


Like the people i usted to know they all pretended something they could not change for It Is already written


No creo que eso fue lo que realmente paso


Am i the only one who thinks celestia tried setting up sunset to be the one in twilights spot?


Oh. My. CELESTIA.

I absolutely LOVE the way you mixed Animation with that beautiful cartoon art style of yours. Good Lordy the eyes on all the ponies are so hecking pretty and I love it. And I love the way you put emotion on their faces even though they’re Horses/unicorns/Pegasi/ Alicorns.

Ahhh good heck your art is just so pretty and I love it. Also the pacing of the story and the way you did the voice acting and just ahhhhh...I love everything about this movie okay?!


Ok look i love this animation but man celestias neck looks a little to thin at a angle


honestly i don't think that princess celestia would be that mean. I'm not saying that this video is bad. i really like it good job on the animation


It’s a nice song. Merry Christmas🎄 💫✨ ( but sunset shimmer never falls😉 )

I should delete this comment but i guess its proof of my mistske.. ill say sorry instead


This is so good like holy shit next level good


Who Made This Is Very Good I Like It Everything All Well I Can Watch It Every Time I Want Good Video


Just Finished watching it, and I have to say, Good Job.

The Animation was Great, Anna Chole Moorey was Great, Wubcake was Great. You did a Very Great Job on This Anination. :D


Bro Princess Celestia has the loudest footsteps ever


minty root best channel in whole of equestria


Amazing, simply amazing! I'll be surprised if this doesn't make #1 for top ten pony videos of March 2019.


When it's easy to make friends but you're actually anti social.....yup...

𝑵𝒐𝒗𝒂 𝑹𝒆𝒃𝒊𝒓𝒕𝒉


If she does that , I'm sure Sunset wont go to that mirror


The Animation is Beautiful!
It's like the MLP Movie, but with more detail!
Almost CGI!

@KingFisher hmmm yea your probably right.

It does use the same animation software as the movie, so that may account for the similarity


isnt it quite mean for celestia to banish sunset from the library until she makes friends...?

Yes, not the mention it restricts her ability to make friends. Having common interests and hobbies can be very helpful.


I get what sunset was saying but still its because calestia is a princess her royal duty's take up most of her time, sunset did try but it just didn't click in her head, sunset always thought magic was the only way to be respected, celestial learned about friendship through twlights letters a while after sunset left, after Luna returned celestia had her sister back but was still to busy to spend time with her, twilighy becoming a alicorn helped celestia see what she was doing that's why she handed over the kingdom to twilight when her and Luna retired so Luna and her could spend time like a family.


Wow so that's what had caused that Sunset Shimmer personality like in the first Equestria girls movie 🙁.


Gosh , i dont blame sunset for going in that mirror 👁👄👁


Can someone hire the people who help made this animation cause this is looks OUTSTANDING.


Боже! Мне их обоих жалко😭😭😭😭😭

Боже! Мне их обоих жалко😭😭😭😭😭


I'm surprised you have the same animation pack as the mlp movie I mean how's that possible? and almost the same voices in this.

The rigs for The Fall of Sunset Shimmer were actually built from scratch using the art book of the movie as a reference. The actual technique is somewhat different from the one used by the movie.
https://youtu.be/9oxZlIiG5kE
As for the voices, Wubcake and Anna just happened to be really that close to the original voices. The main reason I even started the project was because Wubcake wanted to see an adaptation of the comic to the big screen.


I think the reason why Celestia has no friends is because she is a princess and that everyone/pony  sees her higher than them and they treat her like that.

Twilight is an alicorn but her friends will age and sooner they'll die because they are getting older while Twilight isn't. It's just sad that Twilight would see her friends age while she doesn't... :'((((


9:30
I love how pinkie's just smiling like an idiot

Beautiful animation btw!!

WaterDorito Da one that’s why she’s my favorite. XD

Pinkie’s ALWAYS smiling like an idiot. 😂


She is right ! Lelestia dont have frinds ! Even twilight see her as a mother figur and teacher ! The frindship she has is littlerey a student teacher on ! Celestias only frind is on the moon as this point !


Did you work on the MLP movie because the high quality of the animation seems like it.


My.. this is better than the original “my little pony” it’s realistic.


Out of curiosity, why not follow canon of the comic?


wow Princess Celestia is really good at banishing people


8:07 Oh hey I know that tune, that piano. It's from Seventh Element's Fallout Equestria album. The track is called Twilight Sparkle. The second track on the album. What a coincidence, I was just listening to that album on my way home from work today.

@LynxGrey could You help me and tell me all the names of these soundtracks, please ?


Celestia:do some friends to be happy
Sunset:magic makes me happy
Celestia:but why do you do magic?
I mean wtf sunset already told her why because it makes her happy ofc lol
Amazing animation and art in this video i really enjoyed it
Keept it up with the amazing work


Why couldn’t this have been the actual backstory 😭

Wait...that back story isn’t cannon ether makes evil grin

Why couldn’t this have been the actual backstory 😭

Wait...that back story isn’t cannon ether *makes evil grin*

I consider everything except for pinkie pie marrying cheese sandwich and certain bits of the mlp movie cannon

@Sonicfan 240 sadly in mlp world you can be only fully good, fully evil or being discord. Only think you can do to go from 100% evil to 100% good with is sad.

This is a much better backstory than the one in the comic. I actually feel for Sunset here than in the comic, and I like that Celestia is antagonistic here, which adds a bit more layers to her character, knowing that she banished Luna, and having to deal with stress from ruling alone kinda would make her like this. It actually shows her flaws better than how the comic did. The comic, she really didn't face any internal struggles in her anger towards Sunset for being a greedy arrogant little bitch. This is a way better depiction of their fallout than what Hasbro did in the movie and comic.

@shiny sableye I'd probably treat the comics as what I think is called Level 2 Canon, where you treat them as canon unless something comes and contradicts something in them.

@lunacake1 not all comics are canon, what abt sombra's redemption? cant be canon after season 9

Because Lauren is good for setting up worlds and lore, but not that deep when it comes to backstories and further ironing out world-building.


Can you please make origin story for Cozy Glow / her redemption?

Cozy was never redeemed in the show, so there's no point in making an animation for that.


Sunset shimmer life is just filled with sadness 😞 but after friendship she started becoming happy


Why not, the mlp the movie like this? I mean look at the animation, its just too good to be JUST on youtube


This is AMAZING Minty! It's so BEAUTIFUL! VERY well done


To me Salestia wanted Sunset Shimmer to make REAL friends because Salestia was going to make her a princess but other ponys would try and be her friend but there not REAL friends because they are only one because she is a princess.

I hope that made seance to you. QwQ


Sunset; will you be my friend moon dancer?
Moon dancer; no..

Mean while with twilight...

Moon dancer; hey twilight will you be my friend?
Twilight; ofcourse!


This is beatiful. BEAUTIFUL! The acting, the style, the story... your best work, I dare say!


This is better than the comic book because this explains more why Sunset doesn't want to have friends


Well, I know what I'm watching when I get the free time.


Wow it’s butiful and I like the voice acting


What's the name of the final soundtrack?


I <i>really</i> like how you did the portal effect! Gives me Stargate vibes and I LOVE IT!

I _really_ like how you did the portal effect! Gives me Stargate vibes and I LOVE IT!


That way modeled her after twilyght. Shes her own pony/person


You should do King Sombras backstory! I would say Nightmare moon's but to many have done that and non have done Sombras or Crysalis

(Omg idk how to spell the names of those two lol)

Am I the only one who ships Radiant and Sombra?

a good video of sombeas story is the tale of one shadow

If you want to do an alternate Nightmare Moon story, try one where she was on the Moon for 1000 years, plenty of things to talk about there that the Fans have touched upon: Shadows of The Lunar Republic : where she used her powers to create the Lunar Ponies 900 years before the events of the series and be loved like she wanted to back in Equestria, only for them to be wiped out just 19 years before the first episode when the Vashta Nerada arrived and began to devoured everyone of her subjects until only one Lunar Pony was left: Viva, the Last of the Lunar Ponies. To spare her life, Luna offered herself up to the endless hunger of the Vahsta Nerada for 19 years until she escaped... driven completely insane by the process of having her flesh and muscle continuously being stripped away only to instantly regenerate again: reverting her back into Nightmare Moon...

My Night Will Last Forever... : A tragic tale of love and loss as it turns out Nightmare Moon wasn't the Only Alicorn that was sent to the moon, Luna was pregnant and was about to have her foal when she became Nightmare Moon...

The Moon and Her Star : Nightmare Moon is alone and wishes to have a daughter to share her kingdom on the moon with. Twilight is alone and wishes to have a mother that will love her. What happens when their wishes are granted?

If you want to do an alternate Nightmare Moon story, try one where she was on the Moon for 1000 years, plenty of things to talk about there that the Fans have touched upon: _Shadows of The Lunar Republic_ : where she used her powers to create the Lunar Ponies 900 years before the events of the series and be loved like she wanted to back in Equestria, only for them to be wiped out just 19 years before the first episode when the Vashta Nerada arrived and began to devoured everyone of her subjects until only one Lunar Pony was left: Viva, the *_Last_* of the Lunar Ponies. To spare her life, Luna offered herself up to the endless hunger of the Vahsta Nerada for 19 years until she escaped... driven completely insane by the process of having her flesh and muscle continuously being stripped away only to instantly regenerate again: reverting her back into Nightmare Moon...

_My Night Will Last Forever..._ : A tragic tale of love and loss as it turns out Nightmare Moon wasn't the *_Only_* Alicorn that was sent to the moon, Luna was pregnant and was about to have her foal when she became Nightmare Moon...

_The Moon and Her Star_ : Nightmare Moon is alone and wishes to have a daughter to share her kingdom on the moon with. Twilight is alone and wishes to have a mother that will love her. What happens when their wishes are granted?

Allow me to help

Sombra (you got this one correct, just don't forget the ' when you're taking the name in sentences like that (Sombra's)

Chrysalis (you got this one pitched buddy)


Does  anyone  know the name of music  used  in this video?


Time ticks by..... <br>Waiting for 30 moons...

Time ticks by.....
Waiting for 30 moons...


Did someone know the title of the music? - 0:00


Best background story for both princess Celestia and sunset shimmer!! I love it!!


Nah, you make friends by giving them food.


can u make a part 2?? if u make it i will sub??


Absolutely subliminal
Incredibly gorgeous wow
I love how you treated the backgrounds and the lighting and how the animatiom really ressembles that of the Mlp movie!!!! amazing job :3

edit: forgot to rant about how good the voice acting is. WOW!!!


I think the princess is being hard on Sunset

@Skittlez
Shut up.
Celestia didn't want to make the same mistake she did with Sunset, so she tried to be less hard on Twilight, anyway Sunset and Celestia met again in an Equestria Girls episode.

@♡{ŤÂŘÂ Channel}♡ Shut up.<br>Celestia didn't want to make the same mistake she did with Sunset, so she tried to be less hard on Twilight, anyway Sunset and Celestia met again in an Equestria Girls episode.

@♡{ŤÂŘÂ Channel}♡ Shut up.
Celestia didn't want to make the same mistake she did with Sunset, so she tried to be less hard on Twilight, anyway Sunset and Celestia met again in an Equestria Girls episode.

@♡{ŤÂŘÂ Channel}♡ I hate twilight too sunset should have become a alicorn instead of twilight

Yeah sunset shimmer is not like twilight she can't make friends ☹☹☹
I'm think sunset is more better than twilight😍😍
Celestia is get to hard to sunset ☹☹
I'm hate twilight sparkle 🤬


꧁ɈØSᵾɆ SȺNŦƗȺǤØ ɌØɈȺS꧂


The castle looks like Alfea, not gonna lie


Oh my Gosh!!!!!!!!!!! Thas so good graphics!!!!! Good for ya!!! And a beautiful story!!!!


Ooooooohh I finally understand why celestia was looking to the mirror. She was thinking in her aventure with the alternative sombra. If is not then i don't know


This person did the scenery better then the movie


Wow that is so beautiful minty i was emotionally proud of you dude ❤❤❤😭😭😢😢


My headphones: high volume
Celestia: I know...
Me: screetches cuz loud sudden noise

My headphones: *high volume*
Celestia: I know...
Me: *screetches cuz loud sudden noise*


me waching this at school like "I already know this s h i t."


Эта анимация, эта озвучка, это видео, оно прекрасно


What's the song at the end and at the credits?


Oh my word! This is purely amazing! I am in total awe!


Целое наслаждение смотреть этот видео

Целое наслаждение смотреть этот видео

Цветок Стриж

Только Сансет Шиммер жалко

Только Сансет Шиммер жалко

Цветок Стриж


H O L Y .......SHIIIIT!!!! FREAKING AMAZING!!!!


When the fans animate better than the creators....


I haven’t watched it yet but I know it’s gonna be AWESOME!

Edit I watched it. It was AMAZING! Everything about this video is awesome! It’s flawless! Good job!

I haven’t watched it yet but I know it’s gonna be AWESOME!

-Edit- I watched it. It was AMAZING! Everything about this video is awesome! It’s flawless! Good job!


Thanks Youtube Recommendations for giving this to me 4 months late!🤣


Gorgeous work here! Almost mistaken you for Roger Deakins x3


some people are just creative

I could re-create this but I'm lazy af


*holy* *frick*

the quality is beautiful


"You don't even have friends"

That made me cry ;-;


To say it in Memes:
Animation 100
Speaker, who sound fimiliar/same to the original 100
Acting 100
Story 100
Entire Video 100


Minty Rootさん。
字幕をつけてくださりありがとうございました。
おかげで動画を楽しめました。


How is sunset still there and not evil yet if we see twilight and spike at 0:52? And besides they've never met before until the moment sunset was caught stealing twilight's crown


Sunset: Your a hypocrite! You don't even have friends!
A dead body has been discovered

Sunset: Your a hypocrite! You don't even have friends!
*A dead body has been discovered*


8:49 I was wondering if you could help me I've looked in both the channels for the song that you used this part but I could not find it could you please give me the link to the song

@Crystal Reverie thanks unfortunately I have already tried that and it did not sound the same either but thank you for your help

I think it's modified version of "Twilight Sparkle" from the album The Ministry Mares by Seventh Element, but I can't find the full song.


It reminds me of fifth grade my teacher try to force some kids to play with me....... But in the end it made school bad.....


This is amazingly beautiful, I wish you millions of views !


Disney lost there animator... I found them!!!!


You should work for Hasbro , this is amazing. I’m crying I love this so much!


“You don’t even have friends!” Me: that’s WHY she’s probably pushin ya to make friends!!!


Hello I have a question could you finally want to make an animation  of my oc ?


It's great... but make it a little less slow?


Amazing voices and animation!  c:<br>Really awesome and stunning video!   /)

Amazing voices and animation!  c:
Really awesome and stunning video!   /)


サンセットシマーも世間知らずだった、相手との接し方すらわからなかったんだな。

サンセットシマーも世間知らずだった、相手との接し方すらわからなかったんだな。


Celestia chasing sunset..

Mean while twilight voice behind the background said "my crown!!! My crown!!!"


Don't mind me, just stopping by to see how many people are still bronies.<br>A handful. Neat!

Don't mind me, just stopping by to see how many people are still bronies.
A handful. Neat!


So what did ponies do without the moon between the time Celestial banished Luna to before she came back?

The Ozzie stuff  I recommend watching some mlp episodes to understand more but celestia raised and lower the sun and moon


Its honestly weird sunset tries so hard and Twilight just goes up to ponies hello <b>pinkie pie makes a party</b> -.-

Its honestly weird sunset tries so hard and Twilight just goes up to ponies hello *pinkie pie makes a party* -.-


YOOO i need a behind the scenes of this or something, i love the way the atmosphere is created!


Who’s here in 2020 where they finished mlp?


This is a great animation and this is even better than creator. Sorry for some fans.


Sunset probably could have been a princess. If she didn't try to rush her training and tried harder. She's just as powerful as twilight


But why Luna was near Celestia first , and than Celestia rose up the moon with someone on it?

because that scene was set before the events of the first Equestria Girls, and then it panned to the past.


>Watch this
>Immediately watch Equestria Girls Forgotten Friendship
>Try not to cry

well, forgotten friendship could be better

Дима Самсонов 2

@Dark Cyan I watched this. Is really sad, but beaultiful

It's one of the Equestria Girls specials. Sunset reconciles with Celestia in it


Seems like the fall of the crystal empire animation


OH MY GOD THIS ANIMATION IS BEAUTI...NO VERY AMAZING<br>(sorry for my english i from Russia)

OH MY GOD THIS ANIMATION IS BEAUTI...NO VERY AMAZING
(sorry for my english i from Russia)


I love The animation put the link for the website


Ok but tf celestia, making friends is a long process and you just can’t ban someone from the library for making friends like wtf even

She makes mistakes okay. Do you see how much better she does with twilight sparkle?


日本語訳付いてる！ありがてぇ……

日本語訳付いてる！ありがてぇ……


really tells the story of what happened before SunSet end on the other side


Honestly, i don't think celestia would be so angry at sunset

and keep in mind she seemed to be a much different pony back then as she banished her sister?

but maybe she got frustrated and felt like she wasn’t doing good enough with the advice she gave her so she let her anger out on sunset although it’s not necessarily her fault


That was the best looking mlp animation I've ever seen, nice work


song Title 08:08 , anyone?
08:51 got me so much.


Celestia sounds quite impatient in this. I wonder..............


Who is the main character out of the friends in MLP


Me: whats good on YT.
finds animated film
Me: I guess this.
watches a bit of the video and thinks
Me thinking: Wow, this animation is so amazing!

Me: whats good on YT.
*finds animated film*
Me: I guess this.
*watches a bit of the video and thinks*
Me thinking: Wow, this animation is so amazing!


You can hear the beginning of Equestria girls where twilight is worried about becoming a princess blah blah blah..


So this is part of the first Equestria girls movie


АлексФорд Грэй


THIS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL AND SMOOTHEST ANIMATION I HAVE EVER SEEN!!!


The animation is better then the movie my little pony


YOOOOOO this is IT FAM. this is seriously some  high quality shit!!!!! I love thisssss!!!!😻😻😻😻😭😭😭😭


That Looks Awesome!!! l Can't Believe That Animation Was Made on Toon Boom Harmony!!! 😍😍😍


so that's what happened before there was the Equestria Girls movie?


I used to want friends. Now I want the world to burn.


Beautifully produced - obviously a lot of hard work for a labor of love. Well done.<br>That said, I did not like the story - it failed to establish a credible motivation for defying Celestia let alone risking all in a leap of faith through the mirror - what was Sunset running from and what was she hoping to achieve? Further more, it places far too great a focus on the [alleged] responsibility of Celestia instead of bringing into sharp resolution Sunset's own faults and ultimate culpability for her own downfall.

Beautifully produced - obviously a lot of hard work for a labor of love. Well done.
That said, I did not like the story - it failed to establish a credible motivation for defying Celestia let alone risking all in a leap of faith through the mirror - what was Sunset running from and what was she hoping to achieve? Further more, it places far too great a focus on the [alleged] responsibility of Celestia instead of bringing into sharp resolution Sunset's own faults and ultimate culpability for her own downfall.


When your mom forced you to have friends at School be like-

And you don't what to but you have no chose-


Dang

Sunset just told celestial off

Welp i would do the same thing if someone forced me to have  friends that i don't what to do it


Really cool job! You style animation is interesting :)


HOW MANY EPISODES HAVE I MISSED OUT?! ived been gone for a while .-.


Moondancer, Minuette, Lemon Heart, Twinkle Shine and Lyra?


Ohhh i get it! Celestia replaced sunset with twi twi


Sunset Shimmer
Starlight Glimmer
Twilight Sparkle
To eventually replace Celestia of the sun


Аааааа как это классно!!;

Аааааа как это классно!!;


一弓月女金金難尸尸火竹十戈口日


Does anyone notice that the fans make the movie better than the creators


THIS IS THE BEST THING I EVER SAW PARTY TWO PLEAAAASE?


Let’s just ban you for what your good at. That will spice in up your friendship issues


YOU'RE TOO GOOD ! THIS ANIMATION IS REALLY COOL ! HASBRO HAVE TO KNOW YOUR LOCATION ! 😍😍😍😍


Holy crapp, that was incredible. I. Just. Wow.


6:27

You are being to hard on her Celestia 😑


Im 100% confused...is this happening after the movie? before? xd

It’s kind of like a backstory of what happened between sunset and Celestia, this is pretty much Celestia remembering what happened between her and sunset as she looked in the mirror it brought those memories back. sorry if this doesn’t make any sense I’m tired


What the actual titles of the song used in this? You have me hooked.


Omg I have no words to explain what this animation is its just, wow great job I also like of how you used 3D models and some 2D ones it really fits in well


5:00 Figure it out Alexander.
 That's an order from your commander.

5:00 _Figure it out Alexander._
 *_That's an order from your commander._*

@Twilight Hairball telling the story of tonighhhhhtttttt! Lets have another round tonight~

@_Sproopi_ Yes!!! Raise a glass to all of us! Tomorrow there'll be more of us!

and iT WILL FOREVER BE, BECAUSE WE WILL NEVER BE SATISFIED!

Holy hay that's a lot of likes and replies Cough, I mean

tHiS fANdOM iS sTiLL aLiVE, eVeRyONe!!!!

-Holy hay that's a lot of likes and replies- Cough, I mean

*tHiS fANdOM iS sTiLL aLiVE, eVeRyONe!!!!*

Oh my gooodddd I didn't expect seeing this here! :O

@Erii Lee Oh, thank you! What's your username?

@Erii Lee Omg am I so famous? 🙈 And, well yes, I am on Hamino with the same profile!

@wolfgang grimmer does not deserve to die I'm proud someone found this❤


Some of the scenes the characters look like paper on a background, no offence more just some hopefully constructive criticism


Está bien animado y toda la cosa está de la putamadreeeeee

(De la buena forma)


Part 2 is the first Equestria Girls movie.


It's sad twilight suited because sunset failed


Could sunset shimmer be Celestias daughter


How does this not have 1 billion veiws!?


Just to be clear, Luna was THERE when sunset was Celestias student

Is anyone here from 2020 or 2019


If sunset can make friends she defeat nightmare moon


한국 자막 없어서 아쉽네요ㅠㅠ

한국 자막 없어서 아쉽네요ㅠㅠ


AAAAAAAAAAA this is truly amazing, thank you so much for doing this <3


@Sard no I looked everywhere on the channel

Yoo, did you found it? I'm searching too XD


3:51 what happened to the scenery it just cut off at the side ??


So, is this the fall of sunset shimmer or the fail of princess celestia?


Почему я плачу?

Почему я плачу?


IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS, AND ITS SO FLIPPIN BEAUTIFUL!!!!! <br>my favorite comic.... IS NOW MY FAVORITE ANIMATION!!!!!!!!!!

IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS, AND ITS SO FLIPPIN BEAUTIFUL!!!!!
my favorite comic.... IS NOW MY FAVORITE ANIMATION!!!!!!!!!!

@The Furry With no money the fall of sunset shimmer, its a cannon (i think) comic


NOW IS GIVES ME A MORE INFO ABOUT SUNSET SHIMMER!! IS AWSOME!!! I LOVE IT!!!!!!! AT WHY SHE WAS SOO MEAN IT WAS HARD FOR HER TO Make friends? but making friends is not hard as it looks you just need there trust.


At 2:15 there is a pony who looks like starlight glimmer. Any one notice. Like if you did.


Wow just wow thats awesome and great looking animation! <3


Why Celestia have a magic mirror that teleports U to human world?


UwU i wanna learn using this software but it led me to a huge fail


can someone please tell me what is the song called at 08:11 ???

0nn6m9d thank you so much and yes it does sound different from the animation :(


I have never seen such a beautiful animation 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💜💜💜💜💜💜👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍


that "i know" at the start was too loud my ears


I was just thinking about sunset and twilight and everybody then I realized, wait so celastea ( sorry I don't know how to spell ) is the princess of day, Luna is night, imbetween those are sunset and twilight.......OOOOO😳😃I get it now!!!


Графика вообще клас

Графика вообще клас

Надежда Дикун


Um, hello? How was that Sunset Shimmer's fall??


my gosh i am totally blessed. Minty you are legendary!


If I were you sunset I’d watch my mouth😥😕


Question <br>If Luna and Celestia are the princesses who is the king and queen

Question
If Luna and Celestia are the princesses who is the king and queen


You are amazing u should make a movie or a eps


This is freaking beautiful in so many ways, like holy shiiiiiiii-


Am I the only one who thinks this film is better than the original serie?


You know fan make better movie than creators


Honestly  I love what you did Its freaking amazing Animation and i love the details on the animations its feels your really watching MLP FIM and part from MLP EG  :)


Aawwweeee I am gonna cry now :< dis is so sad


9:15 which is the name of that background music?

*9:15** which is the name of that background music?*

@Sard <b>Thank you very much friend!</b>

Yoo! Did you found it? I'm still searching


So real life then the series show of her


Disney called, they want their animator back,.


See Mom see Dad? This is why you dont force your kids to socialize!


Why are the voices so loud I clicked on the video and all I heard was<br>“I K N O W”

Why are the voices so loud I clicked on the video and all I heard was
“I K N O W”


But princess luna was there in the beginning. Confusion!


starts of Peaceful

Celestia: i kno-

MY DAMN EARS HOLY SH-

*starts of Peaceful*

Celestia: *i kno-*

MY DAMN EARS HOLY SH-

Lol i have my headphones All the wave up

When she say that

IT FREAKING HURTS MY EAR

@James Goodman she said she knows luna needs to gaurd the night

꧁ Rose ꧂ don’t really know what she meant by that tbh...


But actually i confused about Sunset Shimmer Cutie Mark was. Beacuse, Celestia got the cutie mark by raise the sun. Like Fluttershy say in (Horse play). Fluttershy: Next, the student name Celestia. Discover she have power to raise the sun herself. Without draining her magic.<br>That was Fluttershy was saying. And if that was happen, how Sunset Shimmer can get her Cutie Mark anyway? We all see that Sunset cannot Raise the Sunset. But, we all see in human world was, Sunset Shimmer sing a song about (My Past Is Not Today). We all see that Sunset Shimmer raise the Sunset all by herself. That how the pony can get the cutie mark. But actually, why in the pony world, that Sunset cannot raise the Sunset all by herself now? If she cannot raise Sunset that mean, she cannot ger her own special Cutie Mark. You should better know about the series.

But actually i confused about Sunset Shimmer Cutie Mark was. Beacuse, Celestia got the cutie mark by raise the sun. Like Fluttershy say in (Horse play). Fluttershy: Next, the student name Celestia. Discover she have power to raise the sun herself. Without draining her magic.
That was Fluttershy was saying. And if that was happen, how Sunset Shimmer can get her Cutie Mark anyway? We all see that Sunset cannot Raise the Sunset. But, we all see in human world was, Sunset Shimmer sing a song about (My Past Is Not Today). We all see that Sunset Shimmer raise the Sunset all by herself. That how the pony can get the cutie mark. But actually, why in the pony world, that Sunset cannot raise the Sunset all by herself now? If she cannot raise Sunset that mean, she cannot ger her own special Cutie Mark. You should better know about the series.


Absolutely like! That' the best stuff I've ever seen:
Such screen resolution (2160 OMG!!!), 12 subtitles languages!!!
I'm sure that is the quality of Youtube of future!!!


Princess Celestia was a bit out of character


Why does sunset sound like Juniper Montage????


ii𝙱𝚛𝚘𝚔𝚎𝚗𝙱𝚎𝚎ii

in the beginning of Equestria girls she is seen with a mint green aura


Sunset Shimmer is not evil Twilight is evil)


No one's gonna find you
When you're hiding in the dark
No one's gonna find you


Celesta honey, it's not easy to make friends and your being to pushy chill lady xd


I think Sunset Shimmer is the next generation of Princess celestia because she also has the  cutie Mark of sun ? And cool Movie 😍👍


Did you help with the MLP movie by any chance


Amazing Work, I think your animation is a bit shy in exageration but that's great !


Spike is a real ride or die for twilight hahah


Damn, like this animation is like, WHAT!?! Its so good!


Торин Дубощит Король под горой


Friends bring happiness....... NOPE.....


WoW ... Just ... WoW, thank you for this Amazing Job you made !


Dear Sunset Shimmer I love so much about you and me love you and I missed you so much and you missed me too


What's that intense song tho?!? at 8:31  plz someone help me


Olivia and Jose caricoa are falling in love and best friends forever and ever


I've been away from the fan base for quite a while. Came back to see what was going on as the show and conventions are ending.<br>Good to see the fan base is still generating excellent content like this.

I've been away from the fan base for quite a while. Came back to see what was going on as the show and conventions are ending.
Good to see the fan base is still generating excellent content like this.


Oh, my gosh! I love this animation so much! The art style, the voices, the story-line! It's all good! I know how it feels like trying to make friends. I hardly have any. Most of the friends I make just later on end up leaving me alone forever and never talk to me ever again. I do have a BFF on the internet, though. And we've been friends for a couple or so years, I believe. I love her so much and I am so very glad to have her. She's basically the only friend I have on the internet. (Or is it "in the internet?" I don't know, you get the point.) None of her friends talk to me or spend time with me, though. She's the only one I have and I trust her more than anyone else. She's hilarious, kind and sweet and I am just really glad that I can finally be friends with someone and I am really glad that I can be loved by her. She means everything to me. She always makes me happy and laugh. And I am just super glad that she wouldn't ever leave me alone. If she did, I... I wouldn't know what to do or how to feel about that... I hope that someday we could even meet each other in person.

BECKY IS SECRETLY A POTATO, I TELL YA!!!


Youre literally bringing back the level of love I used to have for the show. I still watch the occasional episode if the plot seems good but now I am hyped for the finale season and want to catch up lol


This is why I love the fandom. the endless creativity and skill of the fandom is overwhelming. The animation is stunning, and the story is touching.

However, I have a problem with the sound effect. The hooves sound effect. The sound effects are inconsistent. The hoofsteps are too fast and sound incoherent with the animation. Most hoofsteps are also silent, whilst hoofsteps make sound at the beginning. The sound effect is just lacking in general. There are a lot of actions where there should've produced a sound, but it's just silent. For example, when a unicorn use magic, it horn glows but doesn't produce sound.

I also notice that the anatomy in some parts are inconsistent. Some body parts are also incorrectly drawn in some parts of the short. These are some examples that I found: Sunset's back legs and neck in 4:22, Celestia's jaw and neck in 5:27, Sunset's snout and eye in 3:38, Celestia's head in 6:17, and Twilight's eye in 9:23

The animation is stunning, but it has some problems. First, there are too many frames and it seems unnatural. Then, some parts are too quick, when Celestia reacts to Sunset in 1:44, Sunset approaches the mirror in 1:59, Minuette teleported to Lemon Hearts in 3:03, and Twilight apporached the mirror in 9:34. Last, there's an animation error in 3:26 where Celestia's mouth isn't moving when she's talking.

Overall, this is a great short. I myself can't do the short better than you did. I'm still learning myself and I'm nowhere near professional in animation, so take my words with the largest grain of salt you could find. Keep up the good work!

- Irza Liando -


Damn, amazing job!!! The 3D, yet almost kinda 2D style, outstanding backgrounds, and stunning effects and particles make this a pleasure to watch!! Keep up the great work, can’t wait to see future content just as good, or maybe even better, than this!!! <33


I was beginning to think that we had lost the spark of zeal and originality that made the brony community what it is. I thought there was no way there could be another Lullaby for a princess or Children of the Night but you have proven me wrong. Bronies are not dead we live on today, Thank You for sharing this master piece with the world.


This animation is beautiful! I look forward to more of your work!


I remember watching you back when shadowbox came out, and this is just beautiful. I knew you were gonna do great things, but I didn’t know this would happen.


For such unique animation quality, mimicking the voices of the originals near-flawlessly, and feeling more dramatic in tone than most MLP official episodes, this is magnificent.

Plot? Sunset was blinded by selfish ambition in her magic that she was unable to understand the true meaning of friendship.

Moral: Whatever the circumstance, there's more to value than just your own personal goal alone.


Holy crap this was...amazing - it felt as if hasbro did it themselves...it felt so real this is a true work of art


This might actually be the most amazing thing I've ever seen lately. 😍


I loved it the animation the voices the love and work on it well done :) I love it. it's right next to princes lullaby.  Amazing.  I hope there will always be more fandom from you and other fandoms. you are amazing good luck. and don't let people put you down.


Whilst the animation itself is somewhat decent at times, the real star of the show (or should I say short film!) is the visuals. FUCK me if they’re not gorgeous. I am at awe at it! Bravo!


I absolutely adore this animation, but I realized something. Lots of people were commenting on how Sunset finally pointed out that Celestia was a hypocrite for not having her own friends... but Celestia is like, hundreds of years old, right?
I was thinking, what if Celestia used to have actual friends? But because she’s an alicorn, she outlived them all.
So, maybe she stopped making friends to avoid the pain of eventually losing them. And that’s why she encourages everyone else to make friends, because she understands just how important they can be and she wants them to have the happiness she can’t.

Or Celestia is indeed a hypocrite- either way, I made myself sad thinking about it. (´°̥̥̥̥̥̥̥̥ω°̥̥̥̥̥̥̥̥｀)


I love this Short Movie.

The Animation, Style, Sound ... OMG I love it! So amazing. <3

Sure it was a lot of work to do. So brilliant . :)


Pacing was a bit slow and there were a few spots where the animation was buggy but overall it was great! Given the time and product I think it’s one of the best animations.


Es muy lindo que personas se esfuerzan tanto para crear un vídeo como este espero que sin importar el tiempo siga existiendo cosas como esto Muchas gracias


The animation is gorgeous (altho the lighting really could be improved on. It's so god damn dark I can barely see the characters in some of the scenes) and the voice acting is decent but my lord the writing...Celestia feels really out of character? She seems really rude to sunset and super pushy about the whole "friendship" then. Like I get it she doesn't want her to be alone but man.  What so Sunset wasn't allowed to be her student anymore because she couldn't make friends? And Tia saying  "didn't even try" wow that's very out of character. Tia wouldn't say something like that, that's way too mean spirited. Tia said that Sunset became evil because she didn't get things as fast as she wanted and went down a dark path...not because she couldn't make any friends. Her being power hungry and being impatient is barely focused on here which is pretty much like a big part of her backstory?


this animation is beautiful, amazing job


it seems over the years that Celestia may have forgotten how to make friends.


This animation is so smooth and atmospheric and s o<br>G o r g e o u s.

This animation is so smooth and atmospheric and s o
G o r g e o u s.


I have no words , this is all amazing .<br>Good job Minty. I applaud

I have no words , this is all amazing .
Good job Minty. I applaud


Jakby tak wyglądało my little pony to byłby cud tak piękna grafika


Una animación hecho por un fan supera a la misma serie 0w0 buen trabajo


This is like a prequel to all MLPEG Movise! Beautiful


This is soo good animated, I don't even have words for it.


Sunset has the same color scheme as her pony in mirror magic, forgotten friendship, and spring breakdown. She also looks as if she was in My Little Pony The Movie. Which if she is going to be in the future for MLP the movie 2. I would flip out


This is amazing and deserves more views!!


Omg this looks like it’s in the show! THE ANIMATION IS SOOOO GOOD


Celestia damn.....
this feels like a good art style to start
I wish hasbro uses this on G5

FreshlyPositive We can only pray and hope, friend. We can only pray and hope...


This was amazing!👏🌹I love you so much Minty Root!💙


Wow! The animation is so beautiful! With 2d and a 3d clash! And damn! Sunset just burned Calista.


Loved it, is better that most of what happen in the show lately


Can you say the name of the music in the end, when Twilight is going into the portal, please? °^°

Ивлева Александра


THE ANIMATION IS AT ITS BEST ITS TOUCHING EVEN SIMPLE DESIGNS YOU MADE IT CONGRATULATIONS FOR ME YOU SHOULD BE A MOVIE MAKER I LOVE IT


This is better animation than the real MLP!


I.......
I thi-

AMAZING!!!

Btw the animation on this is actually better than the actual mlp

I.......
I thi-

*AMAZING!!!*

Btw the animation on this is actually better than the actual mlp


The animation for the event horizon of the mirror is just like the event horizon of the stargate.


THIS, Has to be the NEXT gen MLP after Hasbro has finished.


I know what it feels to be alone too sunset ... 😞
I use to be jealous for other students in my class for having someone or a group who cares for them...

And it is my only Nightmare in my existence😔


This is so god damn GOOOD OMG Hasbro are gonna be triggered once they check this better version LMAOOOO


When the animation is better that the actual thing o - o


Best animation on YouTube  I've ever seen


My eyes are wet. Please, keep creating 💙


Omg this has such great animation! I luv it


What would've Twilight been had Sunset listened to Celestia all the way?

Jefferson Huang Probably Sunset's Starlight Glimmer. Twilight would have probably grown up to be knowledge hungry, and cook up some universe-altering trouble. Sunset would then pull her out, and take her down (what would be in her eyes) the right path. But Twilight would not see eye-to-eye with Sunny, and she would turn into the next Nightmare Moon. Forcing Sunset to banish her somewhere else.

Essentially, she'll turn into a pony Sci-Twi with a dark origin that makes actual sense.


It's AMAZING, AWESOME!
I love this animation!!

I have been like Sunset in this minute 3:04

As Always :'|


holly shit this animation is so. so. so indescribably well done!


Congratulations on half a million views! 🎊🎉👏🏿


Это потрясающе!

Это потрясающе!


THAT ANIMATION !!!! ITS SOOOOOO GOOD!!!!


WHY DOES THIS DONT HAVE LIKE A MILLION VIEWS???!!!! ITS SOOOOO BEAUTIFULL!!!!!


If Moondancer is there, so should be Twilight.


Btw this movie is amazing, Hasbro have to make this for the sereies or something and you get the biggest credit


Wow. This was very good i enjoyed very much such cute animation.


Mop creators and animators should hire her to make their animation better


I at first didn't like this but after a little while I happen to enjoy it now sense it kinda resembles on how sunset left equestria


wow is this going to be a movie it looks good!


I think reason why celestia was trying get sunset to make some friends because her sister return was getting closer by day and celestia still thought sunset was bearer of element of magic was possibly even grooming sunset to eventually become princess alicorn but celestia knew that sunset would have to let friendship into her heart that could also be why celestia didn't handle situation way she could have.


I genuinely thought that was Luna’s actor at first :0


That makes sense Princess Celestia felt bad for her and was sad....at the end of the movie when twilight came back to equestria Princess Celestia asked twilight “how’s sunset shimmer is she okay?” This video explains awful lot


Sun but neck looks like a lollipop stick...

I LOVE IT


Wow you should make a movie or something more like this


That Animated Movie Looks Like My Little Pony The Movie!


Now that I think about it, maybe sunset was gonna be the new Celestia and twilight was gonna be the new luna


very well in animation
very smooth
good sound   but the sound was quite loud


Excellent animation, very good visual effects, mediocre voice acting, terrible writing.

I was going to complain but yeah I agree, the writing on this is pretty bad which is a shame because visually it's stunning. Shame the writing isn't up to the same standard. That seems like a common theme in this fandom: amazing animation, terrible writing.


Can 2D movies come back please????

Like if you want 2D animation in theaters.


6:25 At this point they start to have a falling out


i liked how she pointed out the fact Celestia doesn't have any friends...


The animation of the main six is similar to the movie


Hola puedo preguntar algo si puede subir el mismo video pero con fandub español o latino eso es mi pregunta


Hey I from Hasbro team and I want more about this animation it so amazing


You guys who are watching this  you need to watch lullaby for a princess


Whar did Celestia know? Did she know that the crown would get stolen because of her visions like in Season 4 finale with Tirek? Or did she skow it was shift change? 0:25


Wait what?? Nightmare moon was luna again before twilight was a allicorn!! BUT THIS WAS AN AMAZING FILM!!!


.. what a sunset...<br>She will never see the sunrise again..

.. what a sunset...
She will never see the sunrise again..


First ten seconds<br>Me: this is gonna go viral

First ten seconds
Me: this is gonna go viral


When Luna raised the moon why did it have the nightmare moon shape on it lol


😢😢😭 el inicio de todo 🤓😍😍😚 que buena historia,  😍😍😘


This video made me remember your "Luna's Determination" animation Stile, but better. The fells :')


Wait Celestia is day Luna is night Sunste Shimmer is sunset Twilight sparkle is twilight <br>Coincidence I think not.

Wait Celestia is day Luna is night Sunste Shimmer is sunset Twilight sparkle is twilight
Coincidence I think not.

@Niall Tantary I bet she feels left out right now..........

If you're replying to my comment it was a JOKE

Alolan Raichu well it doesn’t really work with her name.


Феномен MLP-FM продолжается. <br>Всё идёт так как и должно быть.

Феномен MLP-FM продолжается.
Всё идёт так как и должно быть.

Я даже этому рад

Я даже этому рад


Is this Toon Boom Harmony? Looks kinda neat


Sunset Shimmet was still a pony of  good heart after Luna's return?

@katcantsleep i saw Luna at the beginning next to Celestia

This was during the banishment u can see the moon has Luna’s face in it


Вау...
Это так круто!
Такая кросивая анимация!!!
Люблю, ценю, уважаю.
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Просто Хомяк

@Просто Хомяк 😂

@Просто Хомяк 😂

История трогательная... анимация и стиль лучше, чем в оригинальном мультике.

@Максим Кудинов неть айм ноть русский(￣^￣)

Просто Хомяк

Урааа...<br>Русские...

Урааа...
Русские...

Максим Кудинов


HOLLY COW!! You are such an amazing animator!


hear this...?

its the disney animators crying

hear this...?

*its the disney animators crying*


Just some points where you need to focus a little on - don’t take these personally, I just wanna give you some advice that I hope will help you in the future ;

- try to mesh the texture of the characters with the backgrounds so they don’t look too different from each other
- try to make sure that the lighting impacts the shading of the characters, skin, eyes/eye shine, and shadows
- try to make the sound affects of the portal and other sounds constant, aka the footsteps of the hooves or a more appropriate noise for the water of the portal dependent on the force that the characters giving it
- and overall, try to give the animation a harder and more confident feel, make the pauses in animation a little stronger so it doesn’t look like they’re not putting in any effort when they’re moving

However! Overall, the animation was beautiful and the styles were mesmerising


What happened to them on the other side ? Btw This is so Great !


This story is touching my heart......

•Iam feeling crying when i was watching this


Sunset- YOU'RE A HYPOCRITE! YOU DON'T EVEN HAVE FRIENDS!
Me- Then what do you call Celestia? A friend right? So therefore she does have a friend. And that friend is YOU Sunset

Sunset- *YOU'RE A HYPOCRITE! YOU DON'T EVEN HAVE FRIENDS!*
Me- Then what do you call Celestia? A friend right? So therefore she does have a friend. And that friend is YOU Sunset


Can someone tell me the name of the last song used pls


DANG! This was so good! I can’t believe that this is so good! It was better than expected.


Why is Celstia keep petting Sunshet Shimmer like a dog?


Скорее всего у Селестии нет друзей из-за того что она безсмертна и ей больно видеть как её друзья умирают?


3:05
That girl above Moondancer... Isn't she like another version of the same character?


Hasbro need to hired you like seriously, if G5 look like this and is by you I'm ok


It's finally arrived! Also I feel sad about this😢


Why did Sunset have green magic for a second?

Hella Planty But of course it wouldn't be mentioned in the show. Sunset isn't a full time character of the main franchise. Nor would it make sense to mention her aura's color in the movies or in the online series, as her magic doesn't use auras of any kind. But unless Hasbro says otherwise, the wiki is the best we got to work with. Unless someone can hopefully email Rebecca Shoichet...

@Miguel Rojas I have watched it and I know her aura is red, pretty sure it's likely an animation error. Also wikis are not exactly reliable sources for information, funny how that was mentioned on the wiki but not in the actual show (to my knowledge at least, I could be wrong)

Hella Planty Watch the Equestria Girls shorts where Sunset returns to Equestria and interacts with starlight Glimmer. You'll see her aura's red. It's even stated in her wiki that her magic's color changed to symbolize her reformation.

@Miguel Rojas Nah it seems as if it was an error unless it's be confirmed anywhere else. Her aura is supposed to be aqua

LucyByTheOcean Pre-reformation, Sunset's magical aura was aquamarine. But post-reformation, as a representation of her change of heart, her aura turned to red.


Sunset Shimmer does have a point to what she said to Celestia


I was woundering can you make the video when sunset and princess meet again and patch things up


Also, may I asked what is the name of the track @8:09?


<b>Hasbro wants to know your location📍📍</b>

Her Loyal Highness, Princess Rainbow Dash

@MarshaNPI'm27IndonesiaLove🇨🇦 better hurry before she ends up like MrDavy-

I still mad at hasbro of the grogar twist and twilight awful design !

ΉΣΛVY ΛПGЯY BᄂӨᄃK MΛП

@Skaz32225 your right it doesn't make sense but hasbro does whatever it wants so who knows

But that doesn't make sense. Sunset Shimmer is, eversince her repentance in Equestria Girls, one of the fan favorites. Or maybe Hasbro is saving her character for the newly formed G5.

I mean no because they want to keep sunset away from the main show for some reason and only have her appear inmovies or animated shorts

No they don’t probably too expensive to do episodes or a movie of this animation:p

IKR! This animation gave me several chill. I'll download it as appreciation because is damn good! XD


I like the 3D and the effects. They are really nice!<br>But I don't find the story interesting...

I like the 3D and the effects. They are really nice!
But I don't find the story interesting...


Did you guys know that the same cutiemark as Celestia aka the sun is the same sun in the Disney princess movie Rapunzel

Like if you've notice it to


Was the 3D also done in toon boom Harmony?

The 3D was done in Maya, most of the scenes were rendered in Arnold, but some used Hardware 2.0.
The only elements using the 3D engine of Toon Boom were the crowns and the royal guard armors.
The 3D environments from Maya were composited with the Toon Boom characters in After Effects. Some shots used a separate pass with a checkerboard that was tracked in After Effects to match the camera movements, while others were tracked by hand with the background.


Just an opinion I think this animating is better than the original.


Wth.. How did u make it?! What program did u used?!! ITS SO COOL AND GOOD!!! 😄😄😄😄😄


I thought <br>「Is this a new MLP movie...?」


No entendí ni un carajo pero estuvo bueno


"Twilight Sparkle" track from Seventh Element's album "The Ministry Mares".


I saw this on my SMART TV's YouTube once.


OMG yessssssssssss thank youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu


It's been a whioe since you nade something over 10 minutes

Radiarc in the BG?


7:50 #ZPOZFOREVER because sunset shimmer and han are gone


Me: Meh MLP is just dumb now
This fan created amazing video: Hello I exist :D
Me: ITS NOT DUMB ITS MLP YEEEE


Ппц, какие же вы наркоманы и безумцы, но молодцы)

@The Dolphin Queen потому что только больным взбредёт тратить столько усилий на поняш


They should get you to make the map mobies


Это 3D или 2D?

Это 3D или 2D?

Старый Мемчик


Shouldn’t there be two sunset shimmers then? In the person world


Disney called they want their animatior back


Uh oh 😧<br>Sweet mother of Jesus 😣 This is very bad. I guess so Princess not happy with Sunset shimmer

Uh oh 😧
Sweet mother of Jesus 😣 This is very bad. I guess so Princess not happy with Sunset shimmer


MLP fans: Omg Sunset Shimmer!!!<br>Me: lol SunSHET shimmer.

MLP fans: Omg Sunset Shimmer!!!
Me: lol SunSHET shimmer.


I like this version way more bwtter then the oh how do I put this nixely than the no bright colour one


are those moon dancer from g1 and moon dancer form g4 xDD


Why isn’t this the animator of mlp?!
Its so much better than the show

Edit:
Celestia: friends bring happiness
Me: not according to my ex friends


Did you know sunset shimmer is the new sun princess
And Twilight sparkles the new princess of the night
Because Luna and celestial die


This is beautiful but I wish it had been a story accessible to people outside the fandom. It has a wonderful dream-like quality. The dialogue is great and feels like it's from the late 70s or early 80s.

I love this.


My god, this was gorgeous. I've never read the comic, so I was consistently on the edge of my seat. The models could use just a hair of straitening out here and there, as could scene timings/durations, but that's only to say that the piece wasn't perfect. This is still a fantastic piece of work, especially in the case of 10+ minutes in just a number of months!

I think my favorite visual scene was the guard shining his light down the camera's hall near the beginning, though the mirror-surface work looked excellent as well. I'd pick the scene of Sunset hiding behind the tree roots, being very back-and-forth about the idea of going to see the other ponies as my favorite for feeling (and I wish I knew what Sunset mouthed there), and the scene of Celestia apologizing on the verge of tears outside of Sunset's room was a close second. If I may make a comment on that, however, I was at first unsure whether Celestia was supposed to be talking to herself over Luna in that instant.
Thank you for making this, and I hope you feel that your effort was well-spent!

My god, this was gorgeous. I've never read the comic, so I was consistently on the edge of my seat. The models could use just a hair of straitening out here and there, as could scene timings/durations, but that's only to say that the piece wasn't perfect. This is still a fantastic piece of work, especially in the case of 10+ minutes in just a number of _months!_

I think my favorite visual scene was the guard shining his light down the camera's hall near the beginning, though the mirror-surface work looked excellent as well. I'd pick the scene of Sunset hiding behind the tree roots, being very back-and-forth about the idea of going to see the other ponies as my favorite for feeling (and I wish I knew what Sunset mouthed there), and the scene of Celestia apologizing on the verge of tears outside of Sunset's room was a close second. If I may make a comment on that, however, I was at first unsure whether Celestia was supposed to be talking to herself over Luna in that instant.
Thank you for making this, and I hope you feel that your effort was well-spent!


Using Radiarc's music made this even better.<br>Thank you for creating such a magneficent film, I enjoyed every bit of it. Keep up the good work!

Using Radiarc's music made this even better.
Thank you for creating such a magneficent film, I enjoyed every bit of it. Keep up the good work!


The work put into this masterpiece... the whole thing is just gorgeous!


That was astonishing. Touching, and I couldn't believe how well made it was all the way through.


Well, it's certainly been a while. I for one have been looking forward to the release of another high quality fan animation of one of my top favorite series. And this did not disappoint. /) well done!


This was great, far superior to the original comic (or anything else the comics have produced, for that matter), and on par with that fantastic animation from years back about Sombra's fall, A Tale of One Shadow.  Even after a decade, the brony community still shows there are still new heights of creativity, art, and quality to discover.  Very well done!