I love how, in this episode, Applejack takes a vacation from destroying her own farm so she can destroy Pinkie’s.


"Run,  Limestone is about to murder you."

This... this is a solid realization.

"Stop crying.  I've had enough of that.  This season."

No, no you haven't.  They make you smile in the best way, and you know it.  <3 for the ponies.


You're not the only one who thought Marble was adorable. Not by a long shot. She became quite popular. And considering she had Maud to compete with, that's saying something.

I love marble and maud. But Limestone just has this Charm thats makes her one of my favorites of the pies

@@jaelynnelson3455 Limestone is my favorite, too (besides Pinkie, of course).


22:18 "I don't understand how I make these... like I say stuff, and it happens."
Because the dialogue in this cartoon is very realistic.  It sounds like things actual people would say in similar situations.

And that is one reason why the show is so good


The one mistake on their tradition is letting Pinkie hide the presents, she's too good.

Especially considering all the party canons she hid in castle sweet castle that were never found


I love Maud’s subtle little expression change at 15:10 - she briefly goes wide-eyed, and then settles into a very nonplussed look (whereas she usually just looks unemotional)

I’ve never noticed that before. Nice catch!


Maud Pie: “I’m pushing as hard as I can too.”

Me: I find that hard to believe, Maud. You threw a huge rock to a far distance and smashed one into rubble before.

Plus Big Mac has the physical strength to effortlessly move an entire house. That thing should have moved much faster.

@@fusionomni305 for a good pussy, a man can move galaxies dude.

It could be that that Rock is way denser thus making it way stronger and heavier

@@fusionomni305 that was likely due to the the potion increasing his strength


Interesting to note that Ingrid Nilson voices all of Pinkie’s sisters, not just Maud. I already love how versatile she is.


9:51 "Limestone is enjoying this pain!"
Misery loves company.


8:04 - yep, that's the Triad of Adorably Shy Ponies; Fluttershy, Coco and Marble Pie. Myself, I prefer to call them "the Shy-fus" (a play on 'shy' and 'waifu' )


And thus was christened the great ship MarbleMac!  May she be fondly remembered!

They were MEANT for each other. Ugh we were robbed

@@nic558 Well accept for the fact that AJ and pinkie are maybe cousins which mean they are potentially cousins too which would be kinda weird


While we already know Maud, Limestone is quite strict, while Marble is - among all of Pinkie's sisters - such a shy sweetheart.


I feel like the only reason they brushed off Marble pie and big mac was because Big Mac realized that Marble could be a possible cousin(Which could be a bit weird dating your cousin), so he moved on to Sugarbelle but she didn't which left her heart broken in that Christmas Special.

yea i was questioning how weird that would be although they obviously not cousins its still implied so that wouldve been yikes


02:10 Next year Spike shall give her a book "How to choose presents for your friends" :J
05:55 "Elementary, my dear Applejack" ;)  Looks like Maud is Sherlock :)
06:18 Well, for starters... it's one of the hardest minerals on Earth (9 on Mohs hardness scale; diamond is 10). It's an aluminium oxide (Al₂O₃) that forms hexagonal crystals. When it contains chromium, it gets red and becomes ruby. When it contains iron or titanium, it gets blue and becomes sapphire ;) Infusing those ions and growing gemstones underground is part of their job on the rock farm :)
06:36 It's Marble Pie. And she's even more shy than Fluttershy in episode 1 :D  Can you believe? ;)
06:56 Just archaic ;)
08:56 Apparently they're lithotrophs :J  Maybe they got symbiotic cyanobacteria in their stomachs? :J
09:51 Hahah Limestone is like Little My from "Moomins" ;)
10:511 Potato Man! :D
11:27 Oh, I'm sure she remembers, she's just trolling Limestone ;D
21:31 If you think of it, all it needed is for Big Mac to ask the right question (nahmeen ;J )
12:45 That sounded very... religious :g
13:31 :D  Don't be silly, Applejack :D
13:45 She had a point, though. It might have worked pretty well if they were hiding presents for others to find, and if any pony actually found them :J
13:58 Who said traditions are to make sense? ;J   They usually don't. (Or at least they don't anymore.)
14:57 It's confirmed: Pinkie Pie is solar-powered ;)
15:15 How to get banned permanently:  Step 1. Come to someone's place. Step 2: Redecorate it your own style  :g
18:55 The Holder's Boulder was allegedly found in a Dragon's nest. And if you think of it, it kinda looks like a Dragon's egg, doesn't it? :J  I wonder if it's possible that it really is one?... :>
19:35 :D    P-S-Y-C-H-I-C ;>
02:11  Plot twist: What if you can influence reality that way, and whatever you say becomes true? :>  In that case, can you plesase say that season 10 of MLP is coming? :g

02:10 Next year Spike shall give her a book "How to choose presents for your friends" :J
05:55 "Elementary, my dear Applejack" ;)  Looks like Maud is Sherlock :)
06:18 Well, for starters... it's one of the hardest minerals on Earth (9 on Mohs hardness scale; diamond is 10). It's an aluminium oxide (Al₂O₃) that forms hexagonal crystals. When it contains chromium, it gets red and becomes ruby. When it contains iron or titanium, it gets blue and becomes sapphire ;) Infusing those ions and growing gemstones underground is part of their job on the rock farm :)
06:36 It's Marble Pie. And she's even _more_ shy than Fluttershy in episode 1 :D  Can you believe? ;)
06:56 Just archaic ;)
08:56 Apparently they're lithotrophs :J  Maybe they got symbiotic cyanobacteria in their stomachs? :J
09:51 Hahah Limestone is like Little My from "Moomins" ;)
10:511 Potato Man! :D
11:27 Oh, I'm sure she remembers, she's just trolling Limestone ;D
21:31 If you think of it, all it needed is for Big Mac to ask the right question (nahmeen ;J )
12:45 That sounded very... religious :g
13:31 :D  Don't be silly, Applejack :D
13:45 She had a point, though. It might have worked pretty well if they were hiding presents for others to find, and if any pony actually found them :J
13:58 Who said traditions are to make sense? ;J   They usually don't. (Or at least they don't anymore.)
14:57 It's confirmed: Pinkie Pie is solar-powered ;)
15:15 How to get banned permanently:  Step 1. Come to someone's place. Step 2: Redecorate it your own style  :g
18:55 The Holder's Boulder was allegedly found in a Dragon's nest. And if you think of it, it kinda looks like a Dragon's egg, doesn't it? :J  I wonder if it's possible that it really is one?... :>
19:35 :D    P-S-Y-C-H-I-C ;>
02:11  Plot twist: What if you can influence reality that way, and whatever you say becomes true? :>  In that case, can you plesase say that season 10 of MLP is coming? :g


21:52 that was the cutest “YES!” you’ve ever done, I’m also typing and watching this before Christmas, and it feels pretty great!!


Put Fluttershy, Coco and Marble together and you have the council of the shy ponies.

And I actually believe Maud is stronger than Big Mac.

More like The Council of Protecc with your dying breathe

I bet it would make a pretty good fanfic if they all met up, but there probably wouldn't be much dialogue.

@@fusionomni305  No problem, for me it would be enough if it contained some action :)

Fluttershy may probably be the most assertive of them all I guess

If big Mac was raised on a rock farm he would definitely be stronger than Maud


Now you met my favorite pie, and its obviously... limestone pie, no big surprise there.

We finally met pinkies family, and like we all expected, they are all extreams.

Well we technically met them in season 1 but yeah.

@@joshblackwell8632 yeah... technically :p


9:50 limestones expression is the best...

She’s definitely a borderline sadist…and that’s why I love her!


2:14 "Twilight looks so satisfied with herself."
Doesn't she always?  At least, like, 70% of the time?  :)


You are officially halfway through the series


I love Pinkie’s sisters, but Marble Pie is the cream of the crop in my personal opinion. Another bundle of adorable pony goodness just like Fluttershy and Coco Pommel!


22:13 that's because you have theirs mindset. Good on you man.
You just ran through this season like rabbit running from a rabid dog... I will leave the countryisems to applejack :p


Out of all the Hearth’s Warming-themed content this show has produced (4 episodes and a special), Hearthbreakers is the one I inexplicably chose to be my annual holiday tradition. Every year since 2015, I’ve always watched this episode on either Christmas Eve or Christmas Day. It’s probably my most-watched episode of the entire show, in fact.


Fluttershy: Yay!
Marble: Mhm...
Coco: I'm Coco , I'm okay.


Twilight and I have the same Christmas tradition! My family opens presents the day before Christmas too!


Pinkie and Applejack jinxing each other and laughing about it is actually cute.


The pie sisters are all based on the four humors.


I'm a little disappointed that you didn't notice Applejack's bewildered expression looking up and down after Pinkie's 19 hooves. XD


I really like Pinkie's sister limestone.


This is a great episode. It's nice to see the whole Pinkie Pie and Applejack thing expanded on. Pinkie Pie has an interesting family. Marble Pie is just cute.

I don't know why Big mac dumped Cherilee and especially Marble Piie..! 😢😢😢


And with this reaction, you're officially more than halfway through the entire series (episode 111 of 221). At this pace, you should be caught up by the middle of November. ^_^

And what then though? There's nothing to catch up with, because there's nothing more.


Crusaders of the Lost Mark has been taken down.


what i can say about that? The Apples meet the Pies, two family with so many difference... this is just funny to see Applejack and her family trying to endure the Rock soup, The boulder ceremony and all the traditions of the Pies.

Also, the Sisters Pie are so different of each other: Maud is just unable to have emotions, Limestone is just a grumpy angry pony, Marble is shy and quiet and Pinkie is just always happy


5:43 you can see applejack looking around in creeped out/disbelief

I can’t believe I’ve never noticed that before! I really need to start paying more attention to the background…


Ponybro. Rocksoup is wierdly a real thing. Its a special type of rock that has minerals which disolves into the soup

That's not too hard to believe. Technically, there is a rock that people generally eat every day, salt.

@@fusionomni305 i mean belive it or not its real. Ive actualy had it. Its not bad.

@@miguelbailey95 I believe it. Not entirely sure if I'll ever try it, but I might.

@@miguelbailey95  Do you have to eat the rock too? :J<br>@FusionOmni:  that's true :)  That, and sugar ;)

@@miguelbailey95  Do you have to eat the rock too? :J
@FusionOmni:  that's true :)  That, and sugar ;)

@@bonbonpony no u dont eat the rock. Normaly the rock is in the pot of soup/stew then you pour or spoon out the soup. Ussualy its just one big rock


I actually kind like Limestone. she seems rough and hardworking and probably a good leader.

But why do they call it houlders boulder and not limestones boulder

Yes, i agree. She really does cares about her family, even though she can get aggressive. For me my favourite of Pie family is Marble, because sweet, gentle, kind and shy people are my type.


No spoilers, but... spoilers!<br>You mentioning Rarity and no spoilers confused me a bit since 'that' scene is in season 6

No spoilers, but... spoilers!
You mentioning Rarity and no spoilers confused me a bit since 'that' scene is in season 6

He's a psychic, remember? :J<br>Or maybe he saw that picture somewhere?

He's a psychic, remember? :J
Or maybe he saw that picture somewhere?

Yeah, that confused me too. I’m convinced that he can see the future.


season 5 is the best written season of the show


Pinkie is fine crazy but her family. I will never eat a rock.


Am I the only one who thinks that Twilight is so stupid to forget that Spike hates books because that is what twilight only cares about the most books 🤦🏼♀.


Applejack is a little unlikeable in this episode.


Ya rly can't deny that ya're one of the shows writers in desguise, can ya? 🪨🤠✨


Bout your "predictions", you must be a pony on the inside ;)