hobune Channels Contact About Donate

Should an Aryanne plush be considered "Hate Speech"? (Brony Commentaries #13)

Back to video page | Download comments jsonl

Comments (archived 2023-04-23 14:54; 29 top, 66 total comments)

Comic Field 2022-08-09 04:48:27

To the people disliking and giving me "hate" in the comments: You're just giving me more views, this is beneficial to my channel, no one has unsubscribed and I've actually gained a few since this videos release, so your intention to "hate on me" isn't doing me any harm lol

8 likes
Gorkachev 2022-08-09 01:07:25

w2c this lovely, divine work of art????? I don't agree that uncle H would dislike this, I believe he would be a stalwart devotee of of both MLP and Hoi4. THESE ARE GOOD PEOPLE, FOLKS!!!!!!!!!!

9 likes
Kalman Linietsky 2022-08-07 20:59:53

I am not a Brony, but I am a Jojo fan. I actually used to make fʉn of Bronies, but no more. I actually had the same kind of problem getting into my fandom, because there is a part were the bad guy is so eʋil that the heroes have no choice to team up with the ɴazɨs as the lesser eʋil, and I am Jeɯish. That was there from the author, Aɾyanne is a fan creation. I got over that part of the story. This connection has made me realize that Bronies are as innocent a fandom as Jobros. Take this olive branch from the Jojo fandom.

7 likes
Replies (4)
Comic Field 2022-08-07 21:09:08

Interesting, kinda curious how you found the vid if you're not brony tho lol

0 likes
Kalman Linietsky 2022-08-07 21:20:17

@Comic Field YT recommendations can be weird

0 likes
Comic Field 2022-08-07 22:50:56

@Kalman Linietsky gotcha

0 likes
Friendly Dodge 2022-11-11 02:30:38

/)

0 likes
Enduro 2022-08-08 19:36:15

The Brony Fandom started off as a 4chan joke thread about how the new My Little Pony TV show at the time was the greatest show ever made -that was then taken too far. The raids that followed were so immense pony posting is still banned on every 4chan board (yes including /b/) except /mlp/ and several other websites were left devastated by them.

4 likes
Replies (3)
Comic Field 2022-08-08 19:43:09

"too far" "left devastated"

Dude, chill, it's just pictures of MLP characters, it's not like we were posting ISIS beheadings or something, chill.

2 likes
Enduro 2022-08-08 19:55:44

@Comic Field
A) I thought the hyperbole was obvious.
B) If you were there to see the spam, it really was immense ngl. I’m not even attacking bronies rn, just recounting some old internet history. Even the Stormfront and Tumblr raids paled in comparison which is actually quite an impressive feat.

2 likes
Comic Field 2022-08-08 19:59:16

@Enduro Ah, I apologize for the misunderstanding, proceed.

1 like
Anon Anonymous 2022-08-10 22:06:00 (edited 2022-08-10 22:09:45 )

I love my Ary plushies and I am not afraid to say it. I am not a Nazi, I just like ponies. I find it hilarious that an earth pony is a unicorn supremacist.
Don't forget that wootmaster has drawn pictures of her, and did "friendship salutes" with other anons.
Also 500th sub lol.

10 likes
Replies (1)
Monnut GT 2023-04-05 21:39:44

Where did you get her from?

0 likes
Taku 2022-08-08 19:35:59

not a great look for bronies to be ‘parodying’ the nazis. people looking into the fandom from a normie standpoint won’t know that it’s a ‘joke’.
personally i disagree with this whole thing

14 likes
Replies (6)
The Incredible Fella 2022-08-08 23:32:39

No one cares what you personally disagree with. It's a joke that is specifically made to target snowflakes like you. And it works, and that's why people do it.

1 like
Chatorson 2022-10-21 03:28:22

Try seeing the downfall community.

0 likes
Taku 2022-10-21 22:38:22

@Chatorson well that’s to be expected about a film literally about the nazis

0 likes
Error 404 2023-03-30 11:58:10

​@Taku film?

0 likes
Taku 2023-03-30 14:07:40

@Error 404 downfall

0 likes
Error 404 2023-03-31 12:07:46

​@Taku ok

0 likes
Chernobyl Pone 2023-03-10 18:29:05

The irony, I made my own version of an Alicorn aryan pony. I created her from playing to much Axis n Allies and WW2 games.

0 likes
Reno Fox 2022-08-20 21:45:57

Like someone put it, "Do you think Hitler would prefer that Nazis are still so feared that even uttering their name causes terror, or that they've become a joke?"

0 likes
SaucySacrifice 2022-08-08 19:38:11

Comparing this to a game doesn't really work. A game is meant to simulate war and has more depth than a fan made pony. In the end, it doesn't MATTER if this was made ironically or not because however you want to put it a swastica will ALWAYS be a symbol of hate. Someone can't just draw a swastica on something and deny all the historic backstory, especially when it is something extremely tragic like world war 2.

3 likes
Replies (4)
Comic Field 2022-08-08 20:03:17

We parody the Soviet Union and communism, but no one goes and says "NO, YOU CAN'T MAKE THOSE JOKES, PEOPLE DIED UNDER STALIN'S REIGN" like dude, we know that, I have watched countless documentaries, I have knowledge of WW2

4 likes
The Incredible Fella 2022-08-08 23:47:35

Symbols, like words, only have the power you give them. You seem to give it a lot of power. Because you're weak.

2 likes
The Incredible Fella 2022-08-08 23:49:43 (edited 2022-08-08 23:51:38 )

@Comic Field Agreed. It's like those fools like say you can't say "The N word" (I can't spell it out because yt will delete the comment.) Because it "has a history"

All words have a history and connotation. Slavery and communism have far, far worse connotations and history than "the N word" and yet we joke about it all the time. I really hate people that try to censor jokes or words because they themselves are offended.

0 likes
Silver Spoon 2022-11-26 09:26:26

Both are work of fiction. Do cope.

0 likes
DustyGamma 2022-08-06 23:11:46

starts timer for how long the video's up till youtube's image detection takes it down

3 likes
Neko 2023-02-12 15:09:39

If liking Aryanne makes you a nazi, then liking Starlight makes you a communist. Which is of course to say, it doesn't. And Starlight is a canon character, so that would imply the writers are communists too right?

1 like
Tarp Nitsua 2022-08-07 02:37:11

I unironically want an aryanne plush cuz I see hwr as the pony in Equestria who is a legit nazi, and nopony takes her seriously. She is the single fan of an obsecure thing that doesnt exist to people at a convention. Like a brony at a lawnmower convention. She would be loved in Equestria and deserves hugs, everypony knows nazis arr not real, thats just a silly thing made up for our small humans.

4 likes
Replies (1)
betelplayer 2022-08-07 05:48:24

i'd use one for toilet paper.

0 likes
DinoPony 2022-08-07 00:59:11

You made a very good point lol!

0 likes
Prince Sri Dash 2022-08-07 10:19:42

All ponies are cute!
I don't have hate for anyone of them

2 likes
Plastic Bag 2022-08-08 15:20:59

A yes 4chan known for being not racist in any way

8 likes
Replies (4)
Comic Field 2022-08-08 15:45:09

They're just trolls on a board about MY LITTLE PONY. People keep forgetting that this fandom watches a show for little girls, when we do crap like make a nazi pony, we're not taking it seriously!

0 likes
Storba 2022-08-09 00:26:57

Unironically yes.

0 likes
OrkTv 2022-08-21 14:48:47

@Comic Field They took it mighty seriously and mighty personally when Derpibooru tried to gatekeep them out lol

0 likes
6-D Pegasus 2023-01-11 17:19:42

@Comic Field  technically x3 the show isn't for little girls, it is and always was a family show intended for all ages, Hasbro just marketed it HARD as only a little girls show through merchandise and ads, so that's the impression everyone, including me when I first heard of this show, had of it on a quick glance

1 like
Jello 2022-08-09 08:20:36

I mean... I could see how it could have originally been a joke but going as far as having plushies made seems off to me. "Hate speech" isn't exactly the right word, but if I found out someone I knew was really into the character and had a plushie and made or reposted fan art I'd definitely be side-eyeing them. Anything other than "oh lol a nazi pony that's so edgy okay moving on" seems like a weird ass reaction to me. This definitely feels like an edgelord teenager joke that went overboard.

0 likes
Mysticfox2010 2022-08-07 20:19:01

Stop giving evil power. The easiest way to take the power away from evil people is to meme and mock it. There is a reason dictators attack comedians first.

2 likes
this channel is suck: Some randomcontent 2022-08-07 03:00:43

nice theory

1 like
Crimson Stratosphere 2022-08-07 01:59:25

My thoughts on this made as joke twitter bunch sad people.Also news flash simpsons were taking stabs at man himself they even joked about his death in bart vs australia they showed him hiding such.so See no problem with this

0 likes
dziura w bani 2022-08-07 21:03:47

is the plushie available for purchase? (asking for a friend)

0 likes
Replies (1)
Comic Field 2022-08-07 22:51:17

Yeah.

1 like
Jeremy Zavorski 2022-08-08 14:09:37

Wtf did I get in my recommendations?

6 likes
Replies (3)
Kyle Planktonic 2022-08-09 00:50:41

I'm seriously confused by the YouTube algorithm too, wtf is this shit.

1 like
G_Boy 2022-08-09 10:09:57

same what the fuck is this

1 like
pennythelioness 2022-12-13 02:15:12

@G_Boy literally why the fuck am I here

1 like
The Incredible Fella 2022-08-08 23:33:44

Who defines "hate speech" though? Hate speech is not a real thing, despite what many try to claim. One day calling someone stupid could be considered hate speech, another day it's something like...a pony with a swastikas cutie mark? what?

1 like
Replies (2)
Leon O'Donoghue Burke 2022-08-09 06:56:45

"I don't know what hate speech means, therefore it isn't real"

0 likes
The Incredible Fella 2022-08-09 15:58:15

@Leon O'Donoghue Burke hate speech is not a real thing. This is fact.

It's something people made up so they can point to something they don't like hearing and go "that! That's hate speech!" It's so stupid. .

1 like
b d 2022-08-06 23:25:24

Ohhh

0 likes
Error 404 2023-03-15 23:02:23

Too short did watch

0 likes
Trident H 2022-08-08 16:21:31

Seems rather poor taste really.

3 likes
Dennis The Menace 2022-08-07 23:43:31

I mean I find this really humorous. Saw this 200 view video creeping in my recommendations about how a pony plush is hate speech. And her cutie mark is a freakin swastika! HAHAHA.
Man what has been going on in this fandom since I dipped. I dont remember no Nazis

1 like
Replies (3)
Comic Field 2022-08-08 01:04:03

The point of the video is to say this character is a parody, there are no actual nazis here.
I myself am a Monarchist, and I personally hate Fascism, but I like Aryanne because she's just a funny joke, I have no idea if this is meant to be a "hate comment" and I'm not a huge fan of the fact that you "dipped" (AKA just left the fandom, one of the factors of it dying for awhile)

2 likes
Dennis The Menace 2022-08-08 01:28:11

@Comic Field Sorry, no this wasnt supposed to be a hate comment or what have you, just my poorly articulated shock/amusement at seeing a nazi plush. I had never heard of this joke character so I found it pretty funny. In regards to the fandom falling off that really is a shame, and I was considering going to that last Bronycon they had back in like 2019 for old times sake, it's just that my interest with the fandom waned as time went on. I still keep up with some music creators I'm still subscribed to but thats about it unfortunately

0 likes
Comic Field 2022-08-08 01:40:00

@Dennis The Menace It's all good, sorry, I get a little mixed up with some things, you're all good.

1 like
Cake Dog 2022-08-08 01:57:25

everyone in this comment section and this video creator needs their minds hooked up to some science machine to be studied in depth. are you serious?

5 likes
Replies (4)
Comic Field 2022-08-08 02:03:53

You need to take a fandom about ponies less seriously lmao

2 likes
Cake Dog 2022-08-08 13:02:24

@Comic Field you need to take 16 million people getting killed a bit more seriously lmao

1 like
Lil Euphie 2022-08-08 17:38:10

@Cake Dog Is this your first day on the internet? Oh, you sweet summer child. May your eyes never stumble upon the farthest reaches on this space.

1 like
Error 404 2023-03-30 11:56:10

​@Cake Dog at least it's not 4chan

0 likes
ash cake 2022-08-09 15:36:08

Get a life mate. You have gone down the deep end.

0 likes
Replies (1)
Comic Field 2022-08-09 15:43:30

I have a life, clearly you don't because you chose to go onto a video and leave hateful comments like this.

1 like
Cort Madril 2022-08-06 23:47:20

I have no problem with Aryanne. She’s just a joke, nothing more. People are just way too sensitive.

3 likes