My god, I love just how this song has this dreamy feeling to it, I can relax to it no matter when I listen to it! loved the song Replacer!


Holy christ on a bike. I remember first hearing this and thinking "Wow this fandom's got some great people in it" Thank you replacer for giving me a warm welcome all those years ago


This song legit makes me feel at complete peace.


Dude! I love your work! You've got this style that so reminiscent of Paul McCartney. The chord progression is so interesting, and your harmonies are spot on. You have an excellent feel for dynamic as well!

Keep up the amazing work! Perhaps you could collab with us in the future for another Paul song?


Nice one bro! Even though i'm not a MLP fan, it's great to hear you writing such good music, whatever the subject!


I got a Beatles vibe from this, more than Beach Boys... still, Replacer GREAT track as always. The first song I ever heard by you was Cerulean Blue and man was I hooked!


This is the first time I've commented on a YouTube video, and it's to say this song is awesome!  You mentioned shooting for a Beach Boys sound, but I'm reminded more of '70s artists like Alan Parsons and Al Stewart, especially in the lyrics.  That happens to be some of my favorite music, so I am absolutely in love with this tune.  Excellent work!


I just can't get over how amazing this community is! Everyday I'm blown away at the capabilities of Brony musicians, artists, and writers! Everyone here is just so extraordinary, and not to mention the kindness and acceptance of everyone! I am proud to be a long time brony and hope we only go forward from here! Mega brohoof //))


No offense to any of my other favorite artists, but I genuinely believe you have one of the best voices in the fandom. Excellent, excellent work! (Been looking forward to you releasing something like this since Cerulean Blue)


This song is absolutly brilliant!

My goodness, I think I am falling in love with your music Mr. Replacer.


I absolutely love you're music! you do a great job!!! I can't help but smile every time I listen to it~


I have fallen in love with this song, your vocals and the lyrics, and the melody, they're just so sublime :) It makes me happy inside.


You're my favorite singer. I love your voice, and your style. Keep up the good work. <3


This is *wonderful*. The verse especially is completely hypnotic, in the best way. Beach Boys indeed, and that's definitely a good thing!


Perhaps somewhere out there, there'll be a pony like me...
I love this. I haven't heard much beach boys, it does remind me of the beatles slightly, but I completely love this. I bet you're secrety a professional artist, your work is that good.


This is the kind of song I'll keep listening to long after the shows run is over. Absolutely Wonderful.


Replacer, you are now one of my favorite brony artists in existence.


Your music always brings tears to my eyes. It has inspired me to start drawing again


I love this song. It's so good. YouTube doesn't suggest it to me so I always have to search it manually.


i used to listen to this song all the time when it first came out... i was 12 and super into mlp and redwall good times glad to find this again


Shame I didn't discover you earlier, because this is absolutely brilliant! This really is a very fitting tribute to the Beach Boys!


I should've come back and commented on this months ago! I forgot how amazing this piece is.


Quite bouncy! I heard this song a while back, and I still enjoy it! It seems like most of the fandom I ask feel the same way about replacer! Just check out EqD


Its people like you that really make me feel good to be apart of this fandom. Please, give yourself a big fucking pat on the back because god knows you deserve it. Keep it up, please.


You will probably never see this. But If you do, my head would explode. In a good way of course. Anyways... Is this only you singing it at different ranges, or is it you and other people. If it is you, then you should ABSOLUTELY do more songs in this style.

Also your amazing and this might be better then the Beatles.


Replacer, this is very good music! After been introduced to it by Sean B Palmer I have been listening to your work for the last week.


+Tulder <br>And now I've just realized I have 6 tabs of only your music up. Damn you're so good

+Tulder
And now I've just realized I have 6 tabs of only your music up. Damn you're so good


I swear, I listen to this song at least once a day.


Excellent work, sir. This song reminds me of myself. Maybe someone out there needs a pony like me.


I'm not going to lie Replacer, I loved this so much at Toastbeard, in fact, seeing your name on th list of entries made me really, really nervous (because I knew you, like me, were a bit overdue for new track, and it would therefore be awesome). Even now, I hesitate asking EqD to consider my new song knowing that yours will be heading their way at the same time. Your production is just so wonderful, and your songwriting so refreshing and inspired. I can't help but feel trite in comparison.


It's a bit like Rob Cantor's "Perfect", from Not A Trampoline, too


This song is quite "chilled out" ;) . Replacer may soon be my favorite brony artist.


@dnotive That's kind of amazing to hear. I'd like to point out that some of what inspired me to start putting words in my pony music was your songs, so yeah :)


So, I saw "Let Your Mane Down" and listened... now I have downloaded the majority of your songs onto my flash drive and added it to my pony playlist that I listen to at school all the time ^.^ soon I will have your lyrics memorized and then I will be playing your songs on my piano


Your music is a strange mix, light melodies, with fairly strong lighthearted beats. They don't mix super well, but you pull it off all the same. And you voice...its...fucking...awesome!


Love this <3 Am I the only one who got a Corpse Bride vibe from this?? The music just sounds like it :3!!


I just found out about you and while listening to this and Cerulean Blue I found out that you've got real talent and lots of creativity :3
+1 sub <3


Had two windows opened at the beginning, didn't even notice a difference with the beat. Props, this song is worth the amount of gold in minutes


Wow, every video I click on, I expect it not to be as good but geez, ALL your songs are awesome, I'm getting so many songs on my iPod, KEEP IT UP ^^


This has a bit of a FLaming Lips vibe to it that I adore. And it's so sweet, and so is your voice..just.. gah. Fave Sub Like <3


Words cannot describe how awesome your music is.


Second song i've listened to by you... Think i found my new Favorite singer <3
Keep Singing :)


Is this in an MIDI file anywhere?

God you are amazing!


Why is this man not signed on a 30 album record deal?


What are your biggest influences in music ? I love this song


w0w,this song is so great and so unlike any other brony made songs = D just want to say it rules and keep up with the great work ^^


I know people say this is like the Beach Boys, but it reminds me even more of Badfinger. And that's a great thing.


Regardless of what it is, it definitely gave me a laugh when I heard it.  I dunno, maybe it's just one of those things only I would find funny.
Also, now is a good time to say you're amazing.
Yay.


The fandom?

Well, you can't have one without the other, they are like a symbiotic bond, so let's just let them coexist. :)


I can't believe I just now stumbled across you. You're fabulous!


it's a calm and relaxing song, came home just now from hard school and all i can say is aahhhh...


Replacer: Replacing your iTuned library with his music, one track at a time.

Is his stuff actually on iTunes?? Holy cow, I was about to cry when I saw mp3 and Bandcamp!

@Derpy Hooves <br>I am aware of the irony.

@MIdnight Muse The sheer irony of you thinking Brony is too girly....

@Hrodebert Coad :P lazy lazy brone. (Brony is just too girly for me, I must preserve my last vestiges of masculinity, therefore, I am a Brone.)

Yeah, I realized a while ago but never felt like fixing.


Replacer, why do I always freak out when you release a new track? Oh... I remember now...


For some reason this is the greatest song ever.  But around the 100th time I listened to is, I noticed something.  On the downloaded version, if you have good headphones (I have studio ones), at around 0:55, during the "Hmmm hmmm hmmm", I can very distinctly hear someone turning from the mic and yelling "F-CK!".  I hope I'm mistaken.  Maybe it was shuffling papers.


Nice, this sounds like it came from side 3 of "The Magical Mystery Tour."


This is unlike anything Ive heard - and I love it


You are SO AMAZING! i know you get that a lot but still PLEASE STAY WITH US BRONIES FOREVER!


oatmeal? AND an amazing song? I might be a bit brash here, but I <3 you instantly.


God i want to start making music because of you. If i start playing guitar again than its entirely because of you.


It's like Tally Hall, but for Pony Lovers!


This song is so great!! is there a .wav download with vocals? :3


don't be offended man but all your songs are soooooooooo damn GOOD!!!! but they all end up in my sad brony songs playlists AND can i mention to you how much song for an earth pony comforts me when i'm sad. Thank you so much your songs are sooooo touching


Wow domain this song cut me deeper than your explanation. I was totally on the wrong track. Good song, good song.


omg you should be classed as the best singer on youtube :)


Yes! Another HDR pony song! :-)
I can see why Mic says your vocals "scare the shit out of him", hehe. This needs its own EqD post, NAOW!


Hi! Would it be okay for me to upload a remix of this song, using part of your vocals? I would of course refer to this video.


Congrats! I never knew FIVE were used. O.o I just heard this and Cerulean Blue. What were the other songs used? I love you by the way... You are a big inspiration for me...


You are seriously not known well enough. This is brilliant.


I am glad you are still around making masterpieces.


This song is already 3 years old. I feel old.


really beautiful indeed, but sounds like you got a lil trouble now and then with the high tones, not tht I am offensive against you. Really beautiful <3


does this song sound a little like a song from Coraline? P.S.  I love this song!!!


Just gotta say, this is right there with Radiohead.


Oh my gosh!!!!!!!!!!

Hello!!!!!!

You are amazing!!!!!

*Explodes*

You are amazing and should absolutely team with tombstone!!!!!

(My god this was hard to write without going full on fan mode and looking like a total fool)


@BeatleBrony Thank you ^^ Sounds like an awesome idea.


just found you channel, listened to 3-4 of your songs, subbed.


Hehe, so I'm probably going to be at the Bronycon this year, and I will even wear a jacket that says 'LET ME LOVE YOU REPLACER' to make sure that you find me.... k..... hope you see me.....


This is my favorite song of yours I can't believe I it doesn't have more views :(


You're voice.... Is just so beautiful u.u


sounds alright BUT its really hard to here some of the lyrics over the music in spots and then its way to loud in others. That's just my opinion and what I noticed on first listen through.


Dang... why did you have to go and start becoming my favorite pony musician...


2 o'clock in the morning...I'm looking up MLP songs. I think I just got into the awkward part of YouTube. I need to go to sleep but I won't too awesome


It isn't anypony in particular. I just imagined a story in which a lonely character tries to befriend somepony else he thinks is on the same wavelength.


Oh I'm not sure I'd go that far xD  But yes I did sing all the parts...not the easiest thing as it turned out.


Was your song used in the brony documentary? I could've sworn this was in the background.


@Trixie Wolf Yeah, Replacer definitely follows in the Elton John and Bee Gees tradition of singing stuff in head voice.

+Com Hurri It's not actually that high.  Replacer's a baritone, by my ear.  There's a little falsetto in there, if that's what you mean.

@Swirly the Pony lol sometimes YT notifies me of comments in isolation and I have to follow the link to get the context, and this was one of those times.

It involves hot water and VERY tight undies :D


This fandom just keeps on surprising doesn't it? ^,^


Do you know the group Tally Hall? Cause I find your style very similar.
And indeed by similar to Tally Hall I mean awesome.


Its really no wonder that this guy has almost 9000 subscribers, he was a Beatle. ☺


I don't know why, but this song seems to be kinda creepy and stalkerish...  Still, fun to listen to!


The duality of the cutie mark is very creative.


I heard it on this youtube version quite clearly, not just the downloaded


I subscribed because I love Rarity's song becoming popular and I love ur OC :D


this sounds like Madness! utter Madness!


There's no 'right' way to interpret songs...Just because I wrote the song doesn't mean it has to mean the same things to you that it does to me. Whatever you heard is correct.


@DanielSuperStereo Haha, somepony who gets the Beach Boys :D Also wow that is ridiculously flattering


ur the best pony musician at this time! lmao! AMAZHAHAZING~~


Can you make a copy of this with no lyrics. my band wants to make a cover


Am i the only one that thinks that cutie mark is genious?


3rd anniversary of the upload and I'mmmm stiiiiiilllll listenniiiiiiiinnnnnggg!


I love this song. I listen to it all the time in ICT class in school on Last.com. I am an animator for a webtoon series and I need help learnig how to make music. Can you help?


Dis Replacer song.
Dis makkon artwork.

Wow. Just wow, man.


I don't quite understand the message. The pony he's speaking to sounds like it could be Fluttershy, but the lyrics also make said pony out to be a bit depressed with the "do you seek to end it" line, which Fluttershy wouldn't. Is this just talking to a mare in general, or to a specific pony?


Downloaded with the force of a thousand keyboards.


Can... can I have a hug at Ponycon? Would you let me hug you?


Why is the wav so heavy? the same happens to Crusade no more


@LoDork earworms are a phenomenon outside of spongebob, there's even a Wikipedia article about it


The beginning sounds like silent hill 2 o.o


i know ppl say this is the beatles if they were bronies, but if they were, would they be called the bronies? or...


I don't think that I can hear the f, but I'm very certain I heard "-ck" at the end. It might be just what dominian42 said though, just a breathing sound, as it doesn't have any pronounced letters besides the "-ck" at the end.


@epicbrony20 Yep, check the description :)


I think I hear it....don't think that's what it is though, more likely one of a number of breathing sounds and other little noises I didn't clean up properly....I've been more careful about that sort of thing since


Will this turn out to be a Tumblr ID ???


What was that? Oh sorry, just that subscribe button again.


where is ponycon i want to go! and i am like u dude


No no i didn't mean you were wrong, you wrote the song. It was supposed to be a complement on how it sounded much much better and professional it sounded than how you seemed to put it.


@Chromeover9000 If it were not for that bright pink ball of sunshine, pinkie, it would be the random.


It was...actually five of my songs were xD


Dude I swear I hear a faint “fuck” in the background at 0:55 that or I’m losing my mind XD

@replacer Wow thanks for the reply! I actually really like the mix on this track, but I thought it would be very “you” to reference the Beatles subtly like this. Interesting coincidence though.

funny, you're not the first to point it out, so a little while ago i was going through the original tracks of this song for a potential remaster and i checked out that spot specifically...it turned out to be a combination of a couple different extraneous noises picked up by the mic, not an actual swear word, even though it's believable there would have been plenty of swearing trying to lay those vocals down. I wasn't very careful about audio cleanup back then, this song has a lot of bad artifacts throughout


Why do you sound down is most of the songs I have listened to?


so are you the one who made the video or did someone else do it for you.

@replacer so what did you use to record this video.

Maurice Marsh I usually put the videos together myself

Maurice Marsh Makkon drew the artwork for me on this one.


Any idea why the music image shows for less than half a second then the video is black for the rest of the song?

I used to upload in a particular format which worked fine until it got broken in a site update, and it affects all my videos prior to that...not much I can do about it :c