I reckon star swirl was trying to turn himself into an alicorn.

Star swirl the bearded was a gifted unicorn. But he was ambitious. And he was extremely envious of the princesses powers. So one day, he wrote a spell. Let's break it down...
From one to another, another to one.       Meant to transfer the princesses power to him. Giving the power 'from one to another'
A mark of ones destiny.        A cutie mark. Or in star swirl's case, the wings he was hoping to gain.
Singled out alone, fulfilled.       He was to be singled out alone, and fulfill his destiny, which he thought was becoming an alicorn.

But, star swirl wrote the last line in the spell wrong. Singled out alone, fulfilled. When he cast the spell, magic swirled around him, lifting him into the air. The spell went as planned, until he said the last line. There was a burst of light, and star swirl was lowered to the ground. But not as a unicorn, as a draconeques. He was singled out alone. Now the only one of his kind. He renamed himself discord, and vowed to wreak havoc on all of equestria, envious forevermore of the princesses power. But mind you, he still had a soft spot for celestia though.

I hope you enjoyed my theory!! please help me try and get this comment noticed and turned into a theory video! I might do one myself. Have a great day or night! And be yourself whoever you are. You are beautiful, don't let anyone ever tell you otherwise. You are not an angel, and you will not be one until you die. Remember that. Nobody is perfect.

While this is an amazing theory, we found out later in the show that star swirl the bearded is not discord. But it would be such a good plot twist. have good night/day

This theory sounds cool! But we already found out that Star Swirl isn't Discord of course! He trapped with all the legends together with the pony of shadows to protect Equestria.

So sad that this is literally so far off

Starswirl knew that the spel was not finished. So he never used it. And before he could finish it something happened to him, and he disappeared

𝕌𝕟𝕚𝕔𝕠𝕣𝕟𝕊𝕥𝕖𝕗𝟠


But for what purpose would Starswirl even create such a spell

Maybe to try and find the right person to fit the person?

Maybe he was studying friendship or cutie marks in relation to magic at the time.

@Yasmine Al-Dabbagh To reward Celestia and Luna for raising and lowering the sun and the moon.

Look at my comment,I think I know why,but it's a theory

In a more recent video, he makes the theory that starswirl created the alicorn, assuming this is what happened, startswirls intentions may have been to alter ones destiny because he seems to have an interest in changing the equestrian world

LCPony prolly star swirl wants to finish some nasty business with other ponies

He wanted to create a trigger to create alicorns

I think for learning more about cutie mark and their purpose in a pony ‘ s life and as a sorcerer he was not able to complete it because he does not know the greatest magic of all magic of friendship yes this is the reason he must have made this spell in the first place

SunnySideDia i dont think so because when he saw twilight he was shocked and was unknown

I'd presume that with the new "The Truth about Star Swirl" video there is a new perspective upon the "why"

If you’ve watched the video about Clover the clever being Twilight, then Starswirl may have known about this all along

Maybe he was planning to do what Starlight Glimmer eventually did when Celestia and Luna first began their quarrel? Though, apparently Starlight just has natural talent for pulling strings on cutie marks. (or kites).

TheMysticWeeaboo but unless he could see into the future... Was that why he worked on a time traveling spell? To see who the next successor after celestia and Luna would be?

LCPony so twilight can become a princess. And because he has a thing for musicals.


I have a theory about what would have happened if nightmare moon hadn't broken the other element stones, making them shards. This is only because twilight's element was the only whole element. If the other element stones hadn't been broken, would the other five have crowns like twilight? Just a thought.

Kimberly Hood A film theory!!!!(I had to)

m my gosha i❤them to like twinses🤗🤗🤗😮😯😯😢😸😸😸😸😸

Okay, it was just a theory. By the way, I love your videos!

It's a good idea, but I don't think so. The crown is like the leader of the others, which you only need one of. Plus the element of magic was always set apart from the others in different ways. I have a video that covers this here Twilight and Her Cutie Mark / Element of Harmony I hope that answers your question! :)


Well, buck. Now I have to pick up the remaining pieces of my brain from the floor and walls... oh look, there's one stuck to the ceiling. Now how am I supposed to get that? Congratu-pony-lations, TBN. You did catch me off-guard.

On the other hand, though, I'm having a hard time trying to figure out Star Swirl's role in the Equestrian history after the season 4 finale. Was he really just an unicorn magician? Gotta watch some episodes again.

Ffth  n fh    t▪\ <3w4v6wtey drwhvgdvx   T&dg5😃😅😁💨💣🕳💨💬asf dzb dwfh4w hvvdwvgffcgvbc  fq24🙈😺💟😸💋💞💔😸💕❣🙉💔🙊🙊😹🤖💌❤💘☠💖


Great theory as usual, but here’s something I’ve like to point out for those who didn’t notice it, when the elements first reformed in the shapes of their new bearer’s cutie marks 5 of the 6 took on the form of necklaces while the element of magic not only went completely unchanged in how the gem itself looked, but it went atop a crown unlike the others and this was before Twilight became a Alicorn, I’m almost certain the elements knew Twilight was destined to become an Alicorn so her element adjusted itself to befit royalty, and notice how the element of magic started reacting the moment Starswirl’s spell was spoken and changed the other element, you gotta remember Starswirl help create the elements so it would make sense the spirit that connects them would be to recognize the work of the pony who created them, not only that, but it was the element of magic that started the process for Twilight to become a princess and by extension save the tree of harmony as she did need a bit of a confidence boost if you ask me


Am I the only one who noticed that when Twilight's friends were calling to her, their shadows where walking?

Twilight: Yeah, no rush friends, Nightmare Moon was just about to squish me like a bug.


Star swirl could travel time. Right? Could i be that star swirl already knew what would happen and wrote that part to make it happen. Maybe Discord  is really star swirl and he is guiding her to fulfill the destiny :D Maybe that destiny is that he will become the king of equestria main antagonist. :)

OMG brony notions i am so glad you replied to my sister's comment tysm for the amazing content!

I like the way you think, and your probably right!  Only time will tell, but it would be notable to point out the alleged "pony of shadows" from "castle mania" has the qualifications to be Starswirl.  Can't wait until the finale!

I don't like the idea of discord being main antagonist but maybe there is something that is pushing them towards their destinies. Star swirl was mentioned since s2 and he is still mentioned by twilight. Maybe he has bigger role and maybe discord is not star swirl. Star swirl is main antagonist of series. :)

I've actually made a video about how Starswirl might be Discord: Why Discord IS TOO Star Swirl the Bearded But you gave me an idea that I never had before.  Maybe Starswirl didn't become Discord, but Discord eventually takes pony form and goes back in time!  Just a thought.  I wouldn't be surprised if there was some entity pushing all the ponies toward their destinies.  The odds of the elements coming together the way they did is almost impossible.  Thanks for your thoughts!


I have a theory, here is: (It ties in with the 'Discord=Starswirl theory)<br>Imagine how it would be if you were a powerful unicorn, but, two princesses were suddenly born, alicorns, more powerful then you? Would probably be annoying, right? Well, think of this: Starswirl wanted to be an Alicorn to have more power, so, he created this spell and became Discord. This makes sense, as in the spell it says: A mark of ones Destiny, his destiny was to be a powerful spellcaster. But then it says, "Singled out Alone fullfilled" He had no friends, and he was "Singled Out Alone", so their was no other people. Maybe, since the spell had no one else to go to, the spell turned him into a mix of all other animals, See where I'm getting at?

I have a theory, here is: (It ties in with the 'Discord=Starswirl theory)
Imagine how it would be if you were a powerful unicorn, but, two princesses were suddenly born, alicorns, more powerful then you? Would probably be annoying, right? Well, think of this: Starswirl wanted to be an Alicorn to have more power, so, he created this spell and became Discord. This makes sense, as in the spell it says: A mark of ones Destiny, his destiny was to be a powerful spellcaster. But then it says, "Singled out Alone fullfilled" He had no friends, and he was "Singled Out Alone", so their was no other people. Maybe, since the spell had no one else to go to, the spell turned him into a mix of all other animals, See where I'm getting at?

@JP_is_best_pony hopefully this is sarcasm, cause if it isnt I swear-

Actually... no. As we've all seen in season 7, Starswirl and Discord are separate beings. I have my own theory about the spell, it could have been a spell he was making during the time he made the Elements of Harmony with the other pillars. It could have been a friendship spell, like the magic in the Elements, and as we all know, Starswirl wasn't a big fan of friendship. So he discontinued making the spell. Starswirl at the time, wouldn't consider a friendship spell as worth his time. My logic beat yours to death!

Sarika, this comment was written before season 7.

No because Starswirl came back from being banished from limbo in season 7

Potter Pap this make sooooooooooo......little sence

PEY GARDINER what has that got to do with this?

Sorry but the season 7 finale destroys that theory.

Cinda. But star swerl is going to come back to life in the next season by a powerful spell that all the princess cast together by the most powerful magic source that they can find which leads me to the tree of harmony. You are probably asking why? Well I will tell you. The 4 princess are going to shoot the same spell at the center of the tree and after a few seconds the star of the tree will open with star swerl. But after he has come back to life he is seeking revenge on discord for trapping him and suffickateing him in the tree of harmony. Which leads me to wear star swerl terns discord back in to stone and traps discord in the tree of harmony permanently never to be seen again and after that star swerl goes were he belongs in heaven. You see were I'm going!🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴😎😜😝😛😊😅😃

Potter Pap that makes a whole lot of sense. don't know how, it just does😑😶

@Potter Pony<br>That's the closest thing we had to his clothing! And, Twilight was wearing it! It's still not a honest to goodness likeness of Star Swirl. For all we know, he could've been younger or older, or a different species. He could've even been an alicorn prince!

@Potter Pony
That's the closest thing we had to his clothing! And, Twilight was wearing it! It's still not a honest to goodness likeness of Star Swirl. For all we know, he could've been younger or older, or a different species. He could've even been an alicorn prince!

+Henry goh think about more carefully, how do we know that star swirl was still there?

Well we actually have. Twilights costume, the star swirl convention twilight and caedence went to..

@Potter Pony <br>This would make more sense if we actually had a legit picture of Star Swirl the Bearded! All we've seen are in-show knock off animations and fan art! I'm not even sure if that picture of Star Swirl is really accurate!

@Potter Pony
This would make more sense if we actually had a legit picture of Star Swirl the Bearded! All we've seen are in-show knock off animations and fan art! I'm not even sure if that picture of Star Swirl is really accurate!

@***** The theory is false. Starswirl lived during the time Discord was stoned.

Starswirl the Bearded was very good friends with the princesses, and even grew wise enough to offer Celestia some wisdom in her early days as a ruler. He was content with his position because, though he was not an alicorn, he still possessed skill in magic that could only be matched, or topped, by the two sisters, who were basically treated like gods in their time.

I see I get it now maybe your right 100% right it rhymes with the story spread the word


THis still doesn't explain starswirl's intentions in creating the spell...

@Cl0wnyVX wait if starswirl coudnt figure out his own spell did he switch someponies cutiemarks?

Mabey it was supposed to be a swith body spell because he did get it wrong

Yeah maybe he was bored but he could easily have looked into the future


also the meaning of an amethyst may play a role in this, Twi's element is a star, composed by Amethyst, which is a stone that can bring prosperity, enhancing magical ability and pureness, also known for increasing psychic abilities


You may have actually put the final patch in the story I've been trying to get out of my head for a while. The heal/face turn of Discord was a little too abrupt in my opinion and I had always looked for a way to make it seem a little more natural. Discord trying to create a friend and having that friend turn on him (because you can't force someones friendship it must be earned) would be the origin of the lessen he learns in "Flutter On"
The problem I kept running into was "why" he would do that, I mean I could always chalk it up to "chaos" and my original moral held that chaos it's self can neither be good nor bad, because the friend Discord created was indeed chaotic but not evil, but that always felt lazy.
So check this idea. Star Swirl after creating the spell from "MMC" ends up in a mixed up bizzare body, in a last ditch effort to fix himself he get's the idea that it may take multiple ponies with multiple cutie marks to finish the spell. The end result is "Patch Work" who has lost his mark and the backfire of the spell causes Star Swirl to loose what little sanity he has left. Remembering little except that he feels Patch is "his" in some way he tries to force a friendship on the one creature that wants nothing to do with him. They part company chaos ensues, etc.etc.
Hmm, Yep a writers block finally tumbled. Now to write it up. . . and hide it where no one can see it, cause it seems only a very select few are permitted to actually write fanfic that won't immediately get tossed in the trash.


Okay, I have to point this out. On twilight's cutie mark, there is five stars surrounding the main one. When you put the mark against the tree of harmony, I realized that the small stars go in the same direction as the branches of the tree, where the other elements go. Another, less complicated explanation, the small stars can represent her friends. Tell me about what you think about this theory.


So perhaps starswirl was trying to make a spell that would utilize the power of the elements of harmony. Maybe the spell was made after celestia and luna lost their connection to the elements and starswirl didn't want Equestria to go on without it's greatest weapon against evil. I'd like to say the spell didn't turn starswirl into discord because how the spell is worded, he knows he needs the aid of other ponies for it to work, or the elements themselves, but then it would have resulted in an accident similar to magical mystery cure. Also the spell itself doesn't turn one into an alicorn, it transported Twilight, and it was celestia's magic that activated Twilight's ascension. So was starswirl's spell just something to focus the power held by the elements into something greater?


Puns aren't funny at all that's what makes the funny


I have a theory of where the spark came from (I don't have much info yet). When I saw a glow with the sound of kind of like a spark, it was in Twilight's eyes. When I saw the second spark before she fixed the spell, it was in her eyes. So I think that the spark comes from somewhere inside Twilight, or her very spirit, which activates her element of magic. I think there might be a connection between her element and her destiny that helped her become the princess she is today. Think about it. The elements of harmony definetly helped her and her friends in a lot of situations, which is when their spirits activated the elements of harmony. But when they defeat Tyrek, (I hope I spelled his name right), it seemed that they couldn't activate the elements of harmony, because they gave them up to the tree of harmony. But when they put the keys in the box, they suddenly transform and defeat him, but this time they weren't wearing the elements of harmony. It's like as if the elements of harmony activated the spirits of the elements of harmony.


i always thought
"from one element to another, another to one, one alone's destiny is fulfilled."
Which means switching the elements and one's destiny is fulfilled, meaning the other 5 might have more of a purpose, since twi was singled out alone, her destint fulfilled.


Damn it, I liked the fan art of Starswirl before he was officially in the show. I think the darker coat, golden eyes, and generally more intimidating fan art (like the thumbnail of this video) would be more suited for his appearance in the show than the dorky dude with a short beard, far too gangly legs and just pathetic Starswirl we got in the show. Damn you, Hasbro.


I've just watched this again now and I find you missed a spot:
At the time Star Swirl's spell was written there were no six ponies to bare the elements, only two princesses.
So why was there a need for one to be singled out alone and who was that one supposed to be?
Was it Celestia or Nightmare Moon who commissioned this spell to help overthrown the other sister? Or was it Star Swirl's own attempt to take power?

I have a theory:<br>What if Starswirl created the time travel spell that was locked away in the Canterlot archives and Twilight used to warn herself in the past (can't remember the name of the episode) and used the spell himself to travel to the time the elements were swapped by a spell that he had yet to make, because of the limited time on the time travel spell he wasn't able to see the completion of the spell, back in his own time, he copied the unfinished spell and try to solve it himself but failed to do so, a failed attempt at the completion of the spell might have turned him into Discord. That way he knew who the future beares of the elements would be.

I have a theory:
What if Starswirl created the time travel spell that was locked away in the Canterlot archives and Twilight used to warn herself in the past (can't remember the name of the episode) and used the spell himself to travel to the time the elements were swapped by a spell that he had yet to make, because of the limited time on the time travel spell he wasn't able to see the completion of the spell, back in his own time, he copied the unfinished spell and try to solve it himself but failed to do so, a failed attempt at the completion of the spell might have turned him into Discord. That way he knew who the future beares of the elements would be.

No political authority, perhaps. But the question remains: Who was it for? Who's mark was to be singled out alone?

Celestia and Luna weren't in power yet when that spell was written, they became rulers after Discord was turned into stone for the first time.


Here's one thing that I guess you could also add to this theory, that one clip where Princess Celestia tells Twilight that "Starswirl didn't understand friendship" like she did. But in the book expanding on the Diary of the Two Sisters, It looked like Starswirl was good friends with Tia and Luna, and he was also friends with Tirek's brother. At first I thought Celestia was lying to Twilight for the purposes of the "Princess Test". But then I realized there wasn't any point to that. And then I thought that what she said was true, but not really expanded on. Maybe only the True Element of Magic/Friendship could complete the spell, hence enhancing the destiny prospect of Twilight in Magical Mystery Cure. Food for thought I guess.


Like Twilight, Cadence got her cutie mark before she found out what the entire point of it was. I also think that that one pony said "Behold the crystal princess" was implying that the ponies already knew about the Crystal Princess and was waiting on Cadence to save them all from their suffering or there was another "Crystal Princess" before Cadence that's why I assume that Twilight still must find out why she has her cutie mark is for aside from Magical Mystery Cure and Twilights Kingdom. Besides remember the magical aura that was on Cadences cutie mark when she was activating the Crystal Heart, Twilight still must do the same to confirm her destiny
I know that this might not really relate to the video but it's the most relatable situation to the episode
(Correct me if I'm wrong)

yeah I don't think about it like they do I think someone who can  weild it like that is thecprincess


Hmmm. Interesting. I didn't consider Twilight's ascension to be  fulfillment of her mark explicitly. Guess I always viewed her as the larger star because the other 5 were there to help her grow in so many ways. Your interpretation of Star Swirl's spell makes it seem like he just wrote the plot for the episode though. I think it had personal meaning to him.

Here's my take on Star Swirl's spell.

Firstly, I believe Twilight "fixed" the spell by writing a new answer rather than completing the old one. In fact, they're answers are complete opposites in my eyes.

Star Swirl strictly followed the path of a scholar to its final conclusion. His unfinished masterpiece (From one to another, another to one. A mark of one's destiny, singled out alone, fulfilled) represents his approach to life. To reach one's full potential, he believed isolation and training held the key. As his verse describes a solitary journey of accumulation, Star Swirl gained arcane magic for his own sake. This granted him a wealth of knowledge about those types of magic, but little about the magic born through bonds with others (a.k.a. friendship magic).

Just how Star Swirl represents the culmination of only seeking knowledge, Twilight reveals an alternative answer. As a pony who began following a similar path, Twilight would have reached a similar ending; however, the guidance of her friends and Princess Celestia sparked a change of heart. After experiencing the magic of friendship, Twilight continued magical studies while forging ever deepening bonds with her friends. Thus, giving birth to a new answer that Star Swirl couldn't conceive. "From all of us together, together we're friends. With the marks of our destinies made one, there is magic without end". Sharing their lives with one another has intertwined their fates- giving birth to magic that grows without limit: friendship.

Since Star Swirl aimed to answer how to lead a fulfilling life, and fulfill one's destiny, the spell sets you on the path he followed. Singled out alone to focus on your goal without distraction. This made the Elements of Harmony a prime target since it symbolizes the unison of different elements/ponies to achieve something none could accomplish alone; however, Star Swirl would have believed this held them back, a sentiment Twilight expressed at the start of the series. And while only the five pillars of the Elements of Harmony had their cutie marks swapped, the citizens of Ponyville were also emotionally separated and argued with one another - which makes sense since "the elements of harmony" were thrown into disarray. It's the connection between ponies that makes Equestria such a magical place, and gave birth to the land in the first place. Friendship is what brings about the elusive sixth element; an answer that evaded Star Swirl because of how far he'd walked alone: Friendship is Magic.


I just want to add, that one, you have pushed me off neutrality and have gotten me to decide to learn more about the backstory and all that of mlp. Second, if you analyze Twilights cutie mark, you notice 5 stars, which from what i assume represent that in order to fulfil her destiny, she requires the help of five other ponies, her friends. it isn't a huge or significant fact, but it explains that her friends were required in playing a role of her destiny


I HAVE A THEORY, AND IT'S A DOOSEY.
So, let's look at Starswirl and Clover. In 'Hearth's Warming Eve', we saw Clover could in some way wield/manipulate the magic of friendship and get rid of the Windigos. At this point, she was still Starswirl's apprentice, and we can safely think it's very likely he enjoyed having such a lot of magical power. He of course will have learnt of the spell she cast, and thought she was far more powerful than him, and with the preliminary feeling of enjoying power meant he now felt he could take the power she had from her so he could be that much more magical himself. He thought about how he'd go about this and concluded he should take her Cutie Mark from her (since it seems the most easily manipulated magical aspect of ponies, for instance Starlight Glimmer) in order to get her magic.
He started devising a spell to do so, which ended up abandoned as he couldn't get it right to do what he wanted. When we look at his spell, "From one to another, another to one (him swapping with Clover), a mark of one's destiny (their Cutie Marks), singled out alone (I'll get to this one xD), fulfilled (he saw being very magical as being his destiny, so it'd be fulfilled). As for 'singled out alone', even though this related highly to Twilight's element in 'Magical Mystery Cure', it may have related to him having no friends. When we think about it, if he realised that friendship ignited Clover's power, he wouldn't try and steal it but instead realize friendship himself. Although, I find it uncanny both ways the spell was used ended up involving a pony very adept in the magic of friendship.
Hm, I feel like I filled a gap of knowledge but to no impact. Oh well, I think this theory is great xD


I would love to know you view on how Celestial and Luna were able to use the elements of harmony on their own.  For twilight there is only one pony per element, yet the princesses somehow could use all of them. Is this why magic worked in the equestria girls? Does alicorn magic have enough strength to use all six?


A little late to the party I guess, and this might have already been said, but I feel the need to draw on a few of your videos here.
So the spell, as Starswirl wrote it, was essentially to help fulfill one's destiny. Cadence and Twilight always thought they had done everything to fulfill theirs, but then we got an episode out of finding out they didn't. Starswirl could have had the idea he was missing something in life and forged the spell to help him find it. Then boom, your Discord=Starswirl series takes from there. Doesn't that all seem to fit?
Now, I sincerely doubt anyone on the staff would ever think of that, but it's like you said. They haven't said anything on it yet, so nothing in the story we've been given so far says it didn't happen.


Fixing what I previously said,
 it seems like a switch spell, like in a movie of which I can't remember, where a spell caster uses a spell to swap places with someone to live longer. in this sense, Star Swirled used it to switch with another pony due to his old appearance.
maybe the spell isn't unfinished, but unwritten. perhaps he did use the spell to switch with someone and forgot to write the finished product down.........or, taking Discord's side, he didn't have a chance to due to some  alicorn otherwise known as an eidolon, false god, i.e. Celestia and her sister, Luna.
one reason Star swirled might have had trouble with this spell is that he notes "a mark of ones destiny, singled out alone, fulfilled" has two interpretations.
1. he wanted to switch the destiny (cutie mark) with him so he could keep his fate the same.
2.he wanted Equestrians to have only one cutie mark ,therefore only one fate....... wow! star swirled is evil. fact proven
     that last part was a stretch but literally, in this sense, it means the transposition of a fulfilled cute mark from one to another (and so on) this part is debatable.


Let me throw a wild idea everyone's way:

What if the spell actually wasn't incomplete, and Celestia merely failed to comprehend what it was truly for; hence dubbing it unfinished.

If the spell was in fact unfinished, why did it successfully target something and act upon it?  That sounds like all the elements of a complete spell.  Perhaps the only reason it didn't work as intended was that Twilight callously read the spell aloud without a focal point.

Now for the second part of my wild idea: consider Discord for a moment.  He's supposed to be the mischievious spirit of Chaos (Celestia's own words).  This is not so much a being as it is a fundamental force of nature, by design.  Yet Discord from what has been known of him thusfar in history has shown him merely to be a trickster; a being with Godlike power who refuses to kill IN SPITE of being the very aspect of something that shouldn't care about life or death.

My hypothesis from these two pieces of intel plus the timeline presented?  Starswirl crafted this spell when the TRUE spirit of Chaos began terrorizing the land thousands of years ago.  In doing so he condemned himself to a hellish enternal existence where he would never be able to die and would lose himself; becoming another being altogether...

...BUT it would also trap the spirit of Chaos within a somewhat limiting physical form, provide it a sentient conscious with a comparitively strong sense of ethos, and alter its destiny in reality overall.

And thus, DISCORD was truly born.  An amalgam of the true spirit of Chaos, the sacrificed spirit of Starswirl the Bearded, and one "unfinished" spell designed to make this sacrifice work.

:3

Let me throw a wild idea everyone's way:

What if the spell actually wasn't incomplete, and Celestia merely failed to comprehend what it was truly for; hence dubbing it unfinished.

If the spell was in fact unfinished, why did it successfully target something and act upon it?  That sounds like all the elements of a complete spell.  Perhaps the only reason it didn't work as intended was that Twilight callously read the spell aloud without a focal point.

Now for the second part of my wild idea: consider Discord for a moment.  He's supposed to be the mischievious spirit of Chaos (Celestia's own words).  This is not so much a being as it is a fundamental force of nature, by design.  Yet Discord from what has been known of him thusfar in history has shown him merely to be a trickster; a being with Godlike power who refuses to kill IN SPITE of being the very aspect of something that shouldn't care about life or death.

My hypothesis from these two pieces of intel plus the timeline presented?  Starswirl crafted this spell when the *TRUE* spirit of Chaos began terrorizing the land thousands of years ago.  In doing so he condemned himself to a hellish enternal existence where he would never be able to die and would lose himself; becoming another being altogether...

...BUT it would also trap the spirit of Chaos within a somewhat limiting physical form, provide it a sentient conscious with a comparitively strong sense of ethos, and alter its destiny in reality overall.

And thus, DISCORD was truly born.  An amalgam of the true spirit of Chaos, the sacrificed spirit of Starswirl the Bearded, and one "unfinished" spell designed to make this sacrifice work.

:3


I loved this video but I realized once you said twilights cutie mark was on the tree of harmony before she had ever come to see it well I realized that the same thing happened to cadence so shouldn't it have been obvious that the tree of harmony would have become her new home in ponyville some how


The Unfinished spell was actually written by an imposter posing as Starswirl the Bearded and this imposter Starswirl is the true hidden main antagonist of My Little Pony Friendship is Magic


(i actually think the whole elements being in one was meant to represent the tree of harmony needing the elements back but i do like your idea on it ^^)


well after watching this a few times i saw why she had the 6th elemant of harmony i her eye,it was because she did something that followed her destiny.

@The Brony Notion 4:40 Why!?!? Just... why?


Seeing as the show is now finished there is one thing that bothers me. When twilight finished the spell and cast it we are never shown what the spell actually did. I'm sure many say it turned her into an alicorn but I felt it was pretty clear that Celestia did that. So I have the theory that the spell when it basically killed her or whatever it did when it transported her to what ever realm celestia was in took twilights and the other 5 main characters values storing them in the elements and when they put the elements back into the tree gave the tree sentience. After that the tree started to do things on its own, making the box and growing all kinds of buildings and giving test and stuff. Its just a theory and needs to be cleaned up a bit but its the only explanation i really have as to why the tree and elements weren't already sentient for the last 1000 years but now all of a sudden are. It used the new spell which was friendship magic to gain sentience and become like their own friend in a way.   Just a thought...


I didn't realize till just now, but when the elements of harmony get "assigned" to the main six, the 5 of honesty, loyalty, generosity, laughter, and kindness became necklaces.

But with Twilight's element of magic, it became a crown. Part of it may be due to how big it is compared to the others, but anyone else think that the crown could be foreshadowing, from the start, that she'd become a princess later on?


Remember in the season 4 premier, Discord told twilight, that he helped her learn a valuable lesson in friendship/being a princess? Well if what you say is true, the probability of the discord-star swirl relation got boosted to 70% in my mind, since star swirl wrote the spell to help twilight become a princess.


Watching this episode after not watching mlp or you in years, my jaw is dropped. I’ve never slapped my mouth in shock so hard.


Its bothered me for a while this spell actually. Ive always argued she should have been the Princess of HARMONY. Because - she combines the elements. When the last part of the spell is cast the power of the other elements shoots INTO her, almost like they are powering her up.
The spell itself 'marks of our destinies made one'. The others' cutie marks represent their destinies AND their elements. So if their destinies become one, why not the elements? Could Twilight be wielding the power of all 6 elements?
Lastly - even Princess Celestia says she has all the qualities of a princess (using words for the elements as she goes, AND the 'camera' zooms in on the corresponding pony)

iono. its just always been my opinion...


Here is a question, what was Star Swirl trying to do when he created that spell that was "unfinished". He didn't have any friends in witch to mess up the cutie marks, he also doesn't have any connection to the elements of harmony so he wasn't trying to do anything with them so it was probably a coincidence that when twilight used the spell that it just so happen to do the mane six. Unless Star Swril was perposly trying to mess with Celesta and Luna witch held the elements in those days. Another question is what dose Twilight's new spell (That justifies her becoming a princess) actually do besides fix star swirl's broken spell. What if she her new spell again when their destinies aren't switched up?


Okay, I have to point this out. On twilight's cutie mark, there is five stars surrounding the main one. When you put the mark against the tree of harmony, I realized that the small stars go in the same direction as the branches of the tree, where the other elements go. Another, less complicated explanation, the small stars can represent her friends. Tell me about what you think about this theory.


Alternate idea (and to go along with the whole Discord=Starswirl):

The reason the spell is unfinished is when Starswirl first made the spell and said it, it TURNED HIM IN TO DISCORD. Think about it. This spell does nothing but create CHAOS. And since there is no evidence that Starswirl had friends for this spell to backfire on, the spell backfired onto him, making him chaos incarnate, aka Discord. Just a thought. Also, since Discord is still around, the same transformation would not happen to Twilight since she had friends for this to affect. I have a longer explanation for this, but that's the shorthand of it. Also, I have a 'theory of everything' for the series that takes into account alot of your theories.


I never really payed attention to the spell star swirl had made, now i have a reason to, when it says "There is magic without end" i get what that means, it means that there is FRIENDSHIP with out end. "singled out alone, fulfilled" This spell was always confusing to me, i actually never cared, pony notion has brought more knowledge to me about MLP than any other person i've ever watched. That line meant that, what notion said, her element/cutie mark stayed untouched, and when she finishes the spell and brings her friends back together, like when discord changed them, she fulfills her destiny to be the princess of friendship, or to just fulfill her destiny to become the fourth princess. If you agree or disagree on this concept please replay to this comment.


That's all very nice, but what did Star Swirl intend the spell to DO exactly? I think he wanted to find a way to activate the Elements of Harmony.


The spark was in her eyes when she saw how much her new friends cared about her


To those asking about the purpose of the spell, i think starswirl was making a spell that could turn him into an alicorn. But it didnt work because he wasnt destined to be an alicorn ye


My theory is Starswirl is so powerful he can change forms. He was Mr. Moochick, then he was a female earth pony, in these stories he is as he should be.


4:40...... i spent FOREVER trying to stop at this spot, and I've finally done it!!....

OMG I spent like 20 minutes trying to😖😖😖 OMG it is SOOOO FUNNY!!!!! 😂😂😂😂😂

+RedGeoBlaze hahaha same here.... I was able to move the red bar for the time on the video but I couldn't actually stop it and then pause it still on that... The first time I saw it though when the video was playing, I thought I was going insane! XD so I checked the comments to see if anyone else saw it and lo and behold!

@LittleshyFiM FanGirl XD i just slowed to 25% and got it by luck first try


Star Swirl's spell sounds more like a prophecy than a spell. Twilight fulfilled her destiny long after she got her cutiemark. It sounds like Star Swirl had some sort vision or a blurred dream that made him write this spell/prophecy. Also I think Cadence saw the Crystal Empire when she was just a little foal. Maybe she was born there as a royalty but born a pegasus and later got her alicorn status when Celestia adopted her as her royal niece. Just think of that pony who called her the "crystal princess." Maybe he recognized her from the Crystaling when Cadence was born.


and Celestica had to of already know her destiny because she was the one that sent her the book. She has been there since the beginning of the show to the end of season 4, guiding Twilight by either giving her info or by sending her the things she needed on her quest to become a princess.


The spark that you said is the same spark have from pinkie pie from
"Giggle at the ghostly",when twilight have the spark or the different kind of spark and in magical mistery cure.
Great theory!


Twilight's first character arc was 'fulfilled.'
Call the rainbow a 'Karma Blast.'
Twilight also got a much bigger 'spark' in her eyes after thinking about her friends in 'Magical Mystery Cure.' This could be counted as a 'sparkle fulfilled.' And didn't Rarity say "Sparkles always does the job" in the pilot?


My mind... is blown! The story behind the show mixed with your head cannon, is... AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!


From one to another ( Aj's cutie mark going to pinkie) another to one ( rarities cutie mark going to applejack )The mark of ones destiny (twilight) singled out alone ( didn't get swapped with another pony ) and fuffilled ( to be the princess of friendship ) took me a while to figuer that out but I did it!😄😄


Quick question- how did Star Swirl know what Twilight's destiny would be long before she existed? We know that Pinkie is probably psychic, but what about others? Like possibly Star Swirl?


Twilight...'Spark'-le.... Hmm... An easy coincidence?-or not... I may sound very silly here, but maybe Star Swirl predicted that one day, the six would be created, maybe even he created their destinies somehow with a spark. Maybe Twilight went back in time and told the wizard to never finish the spell on purpose, so time would stay as it is. So Twilight can one day learn that one important lesson and finish the spell. And if he did create Twilight somehow with a crazy prediction, maybe he made her name from her going back in time and telling him. Like, that one episode from the powerpuff girls :P . . . I dunno really, but it does seem that Twilight makes so many imprints in history...she's so important. It just makes me think that she was made for a reason. . . <br>~Fantasy

Twilight...'Spark'-le.... Hmm... An easy coincidence?-or not... I may sound very silly here, but maybe Star Swirl predicted that one day, the six would be created, maybe even he created their destinies somehow with a spark. Maybe Twilight went back in time and told the wizard to never finish the spell on purpose, so time would stay as it is. So Twilight can one day learn that one important lesson and finish the spell. And if he did create Twilight somehow with a crazy prediction, maybe he made her name from her going back in time and telling him. Like, that one episode from the powerpuff girls :P . . . I dunno really, but it does seem that Twilight makes so many imprints in history...she's so important. It just makes me think that she was made for a reason. . .
~Fantasy

@Janine Alborez<br>no but in Brony's videos hes always saying that twlight's cutie mark matchs here name and when ponys are born they dont get their cutie mark when their born so yeah

@Janine Alborez
no but in Brony's videos hes always saying that twlight's cutie mark matchs here name and when ponys are born they dont get their cutie mark when their born so yeah

@SneakingMOUSE No she got her name by her parents


My thoughts on the cutie mark swap: How in the hoof does it even work? I mean if you look back to the cutie mark chronicles it showed how each of the mane 6 earned they're cutie marks. Rainbow Dash got hers by winning the FLYING race with a Sonic Rainboom in Cloudsdale. Rarity's is to locate gems by using her MAGIC. As shown in Magical Mystery Cure, Rarity had Rainbow Dash's CM and Applejack had Rarity's. Rarity isn't a Pegasus and AJ isn't a Unicorn, how were they supposed to "earn" they're "CM


The real mystery is, why would starswirl create this spell in the first place? What purpose does it have? My theory is that he maybe made the spell to help celestia and luna. He could have seen them growing apart, as well as luna's gealousy, and tried to swich their cutie marks to get them both to see how it was from eachothers points of view. This is just my idea, but I dont really see the last line of starswirl's part of the spell fitting into this.


Did you know that the six white lines of the pink star resembles the small white stars which sum up and make a bigger version of it. The pink star represents the element of magic which is her destiny,to be a alicorn /princess.  This is what her cutie mark means


You keep saying the Element of Magic is in the shape of Twilight's cutie mark, but maybe you got that backwards. Cadence's cutie mark is in the shape of the Crystal Heart, an item she had never seen before she got her mark. If the cutie mark is a mark of destiny then it's more likely Destiny influenced Cadence's cutie mark to take the shape of the Crystal Heart and influenced Twilight's cutie mark to take the shape of the Element of Harmony, haven sensed their potential and special talents and took a more proactive role in guiding them down the paths they chose.


iggug yet you have to go frame by frame to see it clearly

+Brianna McVay who is Fluttercage? The one at 4:40 ?

@Ellen Farrell ha ha ha. (stares at you with that "srsly" face)


Well,for the magical mystery cure episode,at one point two ponies had the same cutiemark,like when fluttershy realized her destiny wasnt being a party animal,Dash had her cutiemark! In my opinion,i would have thought it would have set of a chain reaction,since two ponies having the same cutiemark was never heard of...also if Discord is Starswirl,then why arent there mant clues for him being Starry? In my opinion,i would think when Fluttershy made him realize that he had no friends,I was hoping later in the episode,he would ask Twilight to talk to him in private and the  tell her everything that happened and that he is Starswirl the Bearded and that he was sorry for what was going to happen next....also i have a theory: So,we all saw how the ponies got their marks,right?well,Applejack got hers much differently from the others,but,Rarity is the same.Apple and Rarity were far from their home/hometown when they got their cutiemarks(yes i know AppleJack was home when she got hers,but she REALIZED that she should go back,if she never realized that,then she wouldn't have gotten her cutiemark,or atleast the one she has now) Rarity was simply letting her horn drag her to the dumb rock,and she got HER cutiemark then.Why am I repeating all of this?Well,everyone knows how AJ and Rarity didn't like eachother,and are now begining to like eachother more and more every episode with them in it?What if they were long lost sisters or cousins?Since AJ's parents are missing,and Rarity's parents are always on vacation! It would make sense considering the fact they would help eachother out a lot( like the sisterhooves social) and are begining to like eachother more.Maybe on time off they meet up and tell eachother things about themselves.Heck,if AJ stayed where she was a filly,then she would have gotten a fancy lookng cutiemark like Rarity's! This may not make much sense now,but think it through,and then tell meif its a good theory or not :3


Love this video! But how come it only did the 5 other ponies? Why didn't it do the same thing to Twilight? And would it do the same thing to other ponies? And how would Star swirl know about all of them? AND WOULDN'T THIS CREATE COMPLETE CHAOS noting that discord could also be Star Swirled the bearded! Da da da!


I think you just answered your own question about the aura, the one on twilight and the other on cadence, they fulfilled their ultimate goal.


This is my thought:Twilight's elemant is the connection beetween all elemants,the rainbow had all the basic colors of the mane six, showing the elemants and the tree are all connected to their freirndship and alone, it all makes sense. Just a hunch ;)


MY JAW DROPPED. WOAHHHHHHHH. I never thought of her cutie mark like that.


Is it just me, or when twilight was ascended down from the bright light, there were 6 white stars instead of 5. In MLPEG 2, Sunset Shimmer was included in the band when she was needed, and helped defeat the Dazzlings (aka sirens), created the 7th color in the rainbow.  I think Sunset Shimmer was the 6th white star.


Here is my theory but i think it's a little unconnected so yeah I think star swirl can see the future and all of this was meant to happen because star swirl somehow managed to see the elements of harmony and the harmony tree and he knew that was  cutie mark of some pony and <br> he knew that twilight was the chosen one so to make sure celestia will chose twilight as the 4th princes he wrote an unfinished spell knowing that twilight will complete it and celestia will chose twilight to be the 4th princess

Here is my theory but i think it's a little unconnected so yeah I think star swirl can see the future and all of this was meant to happen because star swirl somehow managed to see the elements of harmony and the harmony tree and he knew that was  cutie mark of some pony and
 he knew that twilight was the chosen one so to make sure celestia will chose twilight as the 4th princes he wrote an unfinished spell knowing that twilight will complete it and celestia will chose twilight to be the 4th princess


Something that intrigued was how twilights cutie mark has 5 stars around it 5 STARS maybe that in a way symbolizes the other elements. ok off topic i had this theory that the ponies are actually cutie marks and the pony form is just a protected shell so like they're actually cutie marks not ponies and because people will be like ' then why don't they show they're marks at birth' well maybe the marks don't show because they're not mature yet and are hidden until they matured and discovered they true talents i hope brony does a video on this


From one to another, another to one release the doves surrender love i just randomly mixed these lines together and yeah


"Rainbow death orb of friendship" <br>Yup that's pretty much what it is

"Rainbow death orb of friendship"
Yup that's pretty much what it is


I didn't notice the spark in magical mystery cure. I agree with you, i think your theory is logic.


well, actually, it did fulfill her destiny. After switching, and singing, Princess Celista came and turned her into the princess, of friendship; Her Destiny.


AM I THE ONLY PERSON WHO SAW THE FLUTTERS FACE FLASH!!!!!????

omem gosh you are totes not alone😀😀😀😀😀wait you thought you were alone i thought every one saw it or was i wrong i gotta think🤔hmmm..... I GOT IT LISTEN  WAIT READ ON the people who saw it might be keener of sight  than those who didnt see it does any one still read comments of so tell me what  they think👇🤔🤣😣

It's spelled Fluttershy. Why is everyBrony so lazy? They always forget to add first names. EveryBrony keeps shortening names, as if to say that watching MLP for the story isn't worth their time, Just there because the characters are entertaining, i bet.

Wow two years later,I see fluttershy’s face,I check the comments,The first one is this one.Wow

Ya I got a pic of it and she has a mans face...... ;-;

Eminates no I did to but sense he’s a changeling I’m not surpried

It was flutter shy with a Nicholas cage face LOL😂😂😂

LilMiley1010 Your not alone gurl your not alone


When Star Swirl was making this spell, what did he even want it to do? There was no way he could be a princess or have anything to do with the elements of harmony, because he made the spell before Princess Luna and Celestia got the elements of harmony. And why was it unfinished?


Before ending of season 3:OMG!EQUASTRIA IS A OCD HORROR LAND!RUN FOR LIVES!After ending of season 3:OMG!EVERYTHINGS IN PERFECT BALANCE!YAY!<br>On a more series note,huble of words make much  more sense.Thanks!:3

Before ending of season 3:OMG!EQUASTRIA IS A OCD HORROR LAND!RUN FOR LIVES!After ending of season 3:OMG!EVERYTHINGS IN PERFECT BALANCE!YAY!
On a more series note,huble of words make much  more sense.Thanks!:3


See I think their is someone who decides what cutie mark each pony should get so before Twilight got her cutie mark the symbol was used to represent a great (or big) kind of magic and when that someone saw the Twilight abilities so that someone put the same symbol as Twilight cutie mark
And that someone was celestia because she only showed Twilight that
She got her cutie mark


Now that we know how the tree and elements were created and have met the ponies that made them, maybe we have a better idea of why starswirl made the spell? Idk why, but I just feel like it might be connected to the tree. Maybe it was meant to be the start of a spell to activate or enhance the elements or tree?


"Or should I say *Crystal clear*?"
 Me : * giggles*
My bff: ;-; girl get yourself together


When you pause at 1:50 the small white stars are in front of her friends and the pink big star is in front of twighlight meaning that she is the tsar among her friends so her cutie mark symbols that her friends are part of her destiny.


So then let me ask you this, I know for a fact that you believe in the theory that Discord is Starswirl the Bearded, so then let me ask you this, how exactly then did this spell in its original context effect and change Starswirl as it had change the main six before Twilight's big fix? How od you think it exactly changed Starswirl when using it that may hold the Discord theory true?

Okay, I was just curious on your opinion on the matter

It's all rather loose and very debatable, but in a nutshell: I observed the switching results of the spell when Twilight used it, and imagined what the swap spell would do if their were no friends to swap (in starswirl's case) I imagined it would swap his body parts instead. It's just a theory so idk.  /)))


this REALLY got me when u think about it. if you see around that big star in-between the 5 stars, that makes your theory even more possible. a big star amongst her 5 friends. <b>wink,wink</b> :P <3

this REALLY got me when u think about it. if you see around that big star in-between the 5 stars, that makes your theory even more possible. a big star amongst her 5 friends. *wink,wink* :P <3


What if spell wasn't supposed to work, like it did? Maybe only presence of elements of harmony gaved this unexpected effect? Maybe that spell was supposed to change cutie mark of the user?


I stopped it right on fluttershys face flash and it is Nicholas Cage's face on fluttershys face on his face. Confusing but it is funny. X333


I believe that Starswirl's Unfinished spell was not really written by Starswirl the Bearded but an imposter posing as him and this imposter is the true hidden main antagonist and tricked Twilight into fixing the Unfinished spell


I think his spell was unfinished because he was banished before he  was able to finish. I wish they would tell more about Starswirl The Bearded so we could know about him a lot more.Nice puns by the way.


I forgot to add this, SORRY. In hearts warming eve, Twilight acts has Star swirls student, and they also said that Celestia chose them for the play. Maybe, since Celestia was alive during these times, she meant for that to happen, so she learnt why it is bad to hate. Also, they say the storm was caused by hatred and disharmony. May star swirled died during this time and didn't want Twilight to die in the same way he did. I bring this out because at the end, you hear the things that make the storm outside, causing them to stop and Rainbow closes the window. Maybe it was not noticed, or maybe Mlp is going somewhere with this. I hope so


anyone notice that near the end of this video notions hair flashes to fluttershy's? near here: 4:36


i have a theory
when the stars will aid nmm escape we see 4 stars moving to the moon
and we see twilight cutie mark a lot in the episodes (in the tree of harmony), so here what i think
i think twilight have some connection with the old elements of harmony coz her cutie mark like the old elements of magic
when twilight became under her self spell after she writ the spell  celestia cam to her, jest how celestia know what she will wrote  and how did she teleport to twilight
celestia know about twilight spell and she who give her the magic to become an alicorn
as twilight cutie mark is an ancient mark for the magic things she will travel back in time
and will help nmm to escape with help with somepony for give her self the control of the elements of harmony

i have a theory
when the stars will aid nmm escape we see 4 stars moving to the moon
and we see twilight cutie mark a lot in the episodes (in the tree of harmony), so here what i think
i think twilight have some connection with the old elements of harmony coz her cutie mark like the old elements of magic
when twilight became under her self spell -after she writ the spell-  celestia cam to her, jest how celestia know what she will wrote  and how did she teleport to twilight
celestia know about twilight spell and she who give her the magic to become an alicorn
as twilight cutie mark is an ancient mark for the magic things she will travel back in time
and will help nmm to escape with help with somepony for give her self the control of the elements of harmony


Did anyone else notice that Twilight’s cutie mark has to be representing her element because the amount of smaller stars around her main star on the cutie mark were 5 and there are 5 friends/elements before the “spark” so then twilight has to have that cutie mark because of destiny


I would like to have everybody realized,that when twilight finishes the spell the writes it left to right instead of left to right XD


If Starswirl had used the spell before, did that mean the elements had been switched before? Maybe that's why Applejack and Rainbowdash seem to conflict with their elements. Or maybe something else switched?


did anyone else see fluttershy  at 4:39😕

did anyone else see fluttershy  at 4:39😕

Lord i pause just right and i look like..... oh god no its it..

Its tye wiedest thing ive seen 7t was at 4:40

Yes it's cos he really likes that character.

Caitlyn Mccurdy and when i paused it at the right moment it was at 4:40 on the dot

Caitlyn Mccurdy it took me forever to pause it at the right moment XD

I was gonna ask the same question........ I wonder why he put it there?


But what does the spell do now? The first one fulfills your destiny, now what does it do? From Twilight's encounter with Celestia, it is implied the spell now has something to do with friendship, but what is it?


And you can get deeper then that. I say all the Mane 6 could become Alicorns. I know Pinkie as an Alicorn? scary!
I never noticed until Someone pointed out Rarity's cutie mark was already on the tree too.

The star=twilight.
the spots where the gems goes if connected form a heart=Candace
the sun and moon, celestia and luna.

the colors that are shown off are Red, green yellow and blue=Rainbow Dash.
the white orbs have a pattern that's found on rarity's cutie mark.
Strange shaped lights on is a butterfly and a round one.


Twighlight has six stars on her flank. The big star could stand for her while the other five are her friends.


lots of things make sense. and i think the spark is more a spark of realization. i also kinda what to think that twilight and Star Swirl the Bearded are from the same lineage. i don't know its just another head cannon like any other


I just discovered something about Twilight' s cutiemark! It has 5 stars around it and one in the middle! the five stars around is the other elements and the one in the middle is the element of magic!

But exist a big white star which is behind the magenta one. That star is Sunset Shimmer.

yea i know but i didn't watch the video before i wrote

@IxwiCraft duh... that's what he kinda said

Actually every one notice that so keep you shit close


I feel like the discord~starswirl theory could be confirmed by something like discord seeing starswirls spell and having recollection.


"'s if they weren't the type of pony they needed to be in order to actually earn they're cutie mark. I think that the spell did so much more than simply change they're "destinys" I don't even think the spell changed they're destinys at all. If the spell REALLY changed they're destiny's wouldn't they be able to take on the tasks just fine? then again the Mane 6 weren't taking on the destiny's just they're occupations...But the spell must have changed they're memories also, right? when twilight wa


If you ever watched sailor moon, I think they are going to pull a Saturn with twilight.

What I mean by that is I think they are going to say twilight is/was reborn with out memory. That is why she is in the history of equestria but seems so younge.

Just like what they did in sailor moon. They made it seem like sailor Saturn had died but later she comes back as a VERY important child.


Well if this has not been said than thank you, well in the book of the two sisters they had mentioned that celestia had wanted to meet twilight but that was thousands of years before this had ever happened.i mean like  it was destiny for celestia to meet twilight and for twilight to have great power.idk if that even makes sense.


did anyone see that quick head swap in the video. i think i was fluttershy's head

I think discord  cutie mark a evil face.

I think discord  cutie mark a evil face.

Ruby The Gem Nicholas Cage’s face on fluttershy’s body

it is I look at it and it is definitely her head


What I ultimately want to know is what Starswirl was trying to accomplish with this spell. Was he trying to become an alicorn princess? Is the sole purpose of that spell to find princesses? Or did that spell have some other purpose and Twilight's alicornhood was just a byproduct. /super late comment on super old video - but hey, the question hasn't been touched on at all in the series yet. So still valid right?


i have a feeling that the spark was the spark of friendship. if they left twilight then she would have never had made friends and unwind thousands of years of planning. but what I want to know is that if twilight was left on her own would nightmare moon use her magic to corrupt twilight and then they would rule equestra? ps sorry for the bad spelling.


wait hold up,  if star swirl is so powerful with spells,  was he a alicorn?


Rainbow death orb of friendship was the perfect way to describe that dude!


Hey. did everypony loss there memory in magical cure

Star swirl spell may have changed the past or swapped out the ponies memories likely the ladder

TheKhaosMachine I think some of it, yeah.

+The Brony Notion its like they lived another reality. if you have read cursed child, this would make more sense

They only lost memory of there real cutie marks

+The Brony Notion I'm an alicorn but using my grandpa's phone with my to foils Maryanne and Alexander Fletcher i'm the princess of candy my sisters are Rainbow Dash and Daring Do.

I think so, that is a good theory! The Brony Notion will have to consider it!

+The Brony Notion I love your videos and theories about my little pony

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ (Excellency at Wørst)

But what about like the apples was AppleJack still their sister but she was working at the shop and pinkie was just working there. How did that work?

They seemed to lose their own memory and gain the memory of someone else... its very mysterious.


here is something else, when twilight is in the sky, celestial sings the line "to fulfill your destiny"


I thought this was really interesting to watch. I didn't know season 5 was out. Post some more videos please @TheBronyNotion


I'm just wondering what was star swirls intentions when starting to create this spell? What was he going to use it for?


Well after the elements of harmony, the main 6's cutie marks, combined and shot at her, Twilight was made a princess. Combined or 'made one'. And Twilight represents magic, so 'magic without end', is maybe saying Twilight will become very powerful with her magic?


Am I the only one that saw a flash of fluttershy's face?

Mags H. Nope I saw that too<br>In the end of the show

Mags H. Nope I saw that too
In the end of the show

Omg that was so creepy it was fluttershy with a human face

Ok. I'm not going insane. Or, maybe I am. Who knows?


I think the last part where it says "Fulfilled" I think it meant that she fulfilled her destiny (her destiny that she was meant to become an Alicorn)

Like her Cutie Mark (#element 🌟👑) was singled out because she was meant to fix everything and fulfill  her destiny as a Royal Alicorn ☄🦄


the real question is...

what if someone else in the mane six cast the spell and fixes every thing.. would they be the alicorn?

the real question is...

*what if someone else in the mane six cast the spell and fixes every thing.. would they be the alicorn?*


If what you say is true about discord being Star Swirl the Bearded then it could play in with how he never had friends of his own, so he caused chaos for others.


The mark of one's destiny fulfilled means  she fulfilled her destiny by getting her wings


Twilight is not affected by the spell, and thus, singled out alone. By curing the others and finishing Star Swirl's spell she becomes a princess, and her destiny is fulfilled. "From one to another, another to one, a mark of one's destiny singled out alone, fulfilled..."


But what was Star Swirl trying to accomplish when he started writing the spell?


It is a spell! It is going to sound weird. Maybe the spark is just an Equestrian way of light bulbs in their heads. Also I feel l've seen the spark to other ponies. Like when they get their cutie marks... The spark is the idea of destiny maybe!


Hu uh, I actually have no corrections this time, and I'm a big pony mythology geek, but it all kind of lines up, but I know why Celestia wanted Twilight to be a private student at the school, because she knew that she would be a big part of equestria, not by the explosion, but the cutie Mark, she was just alarmed by the explosion, and, maybe, it was part of her destiny, in the second part of the first episode of seoson 1, she had the same explosion as the seen at her audition, what do you guys think?


Her cutie mark was fufilled after she completed a mission sooo that mission was sent by celestia so propaly referring back keep calm and flutter on celestia probably cast a spell to protect her crown thingy


Do one about how the colors of the magic and how they look like the colors of their eyes like twilight's eyes are purple and so is her magic


In S4 the other mane 6 characters each receive a spark when they get their keys too


weird thought, maybe twilight is a far descendant from starswirl the bearded? he has been mentioned several times and celestia claims he could never finish ihis spell because he did not understand friendschip like she did.


If discord was star swirl, then where did he get the new parts?
A: magic
B:from other animals
Either way, where did his old parts go?
A: dissaperaed into thin air (magic)
B: transferred to the animals he got the parts from
Pls do a vid on this

That is a really good question I think The Brony Notion should do a vid on that


Guau i never noticie that little spark in her eyes in those episodes thats amazing.<br>Thanks brony Notion 😊

Guau i never noticie that little spark in her eyes in those episodes thats amazing.
Thanks brony Notion 😊


in my opinion if Twilight  hadn't have cast that spell in the first place she might never have became a princess to begin with. But who gave her the book? Maybe  Celestia it's been awhile since I've  seen  that episode


Hey Brony Notion have you ever considered doing MLP What If videos where you theorize what could happen if a different path was chosen in an episode.


You know Im really wondering on why magic matches a ponies eye color. Please do make a video and help explain it it would help a lot


“My friends!”

(Literally known each other for 2 episodes)


Wow i really understand your explanation in this episode


I also believe the imposter Starswirl the Bearded is the Shadow Pony an ancient evil even older than Celestia and Luna


Star Swirl is always seen wearing a robe/cape, so possibly could there be wings under there? he could be a alicorn? If Star Swirl is a discord, and he used the spell to change him, would that be why discord has wings? And also notice Twilight writes right to left..!?


Well we can't be sure if Cadance seen Crystal Empire before or not. And creating sixth element is rather wrong word. Rather recreating. But beside this one this theory was quite good... but I'm dissapointed because You didn't even mention the topic of this what this finished spell really do. That's the great mistery about this spell and this whole episode.


for your next episode every time the main 6 use the elements of harmony they release a sonic rainboom but I thought Rainbow Dash was the only one that could do the sonic rainboom .


Probably because she was the one to cast the spell.I mean, the spells that are meant to affect everypony in the show don't always affect the one who  cast it.


but what if Star Swirl had a prediction or something about Twilight and did it on purpose?😂


Really great analysis, but I have one question: what was the point in Star Swirl the Bearded's spell? Why would he create it? Before Twilight "finished" it, as she read it aloud, it did <b>do</b> something (switch the cutie marks around), which meant that it was still technically a spell. But why would Star Swirl make a spell like that, and why was it officially completed when Twilight added "friendship" to it? If the spell were to be said aloud again, what would happen? Also, why did it only switch the cutie marks of her friends? I'm really curious about this now and hope that maybe you could make a video about it.

Really great analysis, but I have one question: what was the point in Star Swirl the Bearded's spell? Why would he create it? Before Twilight "finished" it, as she read it aloud, it did *do* something (switch the cutie marks around), which meant that it was still technically a spell. But why would Star Swirl make a spell like that, and why was it officially completed when Twilight added "friendship" to it? If the spell were to be said aloud again, what would happen? Also, why did it only switch the cutie marks of her friends? I'm really curious about this now and hope that maybe you could make a video about it.

One theory that may answer your question about Cadence's cutie mark could be that even though her cutie mark is specifically the Crystal Heart, The actual Crystal Heart from the Crystal Empire is used to spread light and love all throughout Equestria. So even though her heart is specific, Her ability is to spread love between ponies just like the Crystal Heart is used to protect the empire by spreading love throughout the Ponyverse

Also, you said in the video that Cadence's cutie mark (understandably) didn't make sense. How could she have it if the way to get your cutie mark in the first place is to realize and accept the thing that makes you special/different? If she didn't understand what it was, then how could she realize it made her special? Granted, you could say it was her ability to make ponies love each other, but the heart she had was specifically the Crystal Heart. This question could also apply to most of the main six's cutie marks. Was it solely 'Destiny' that made her cutie mark for her?


I think star swirl made that spell on purpose and friendship ruined his evil master plan so he became discord and notice of how twilight sparkle has a crown and here friends don't. Well it makes scenes while she's a princess and whenever twilight got her cutie mark celestia was astonished by her power of magic and also to conclude this theory or whatever twilight didn't want to make friends just like star swirl I guess then everything changed when the elements of harmony came along. So maybe the elements of harmony must have done something that triggered in her mind. So there u have it and plz make a video about this plz


And those small pointed white tips behind the big purple star could be the new main 6 creatures...
Sandbar, silverstream, ocellus, yona... etc.

Anyone else?


This episode really got me thinking... it made me what to do more research about star swirl

Thx!! :-) :-)


The mlp staff never does things like this anymore :(


I'm thinking this;
The spark is the one that is really the one that fullfilled the destiny. I know you said Celestia was the one who chose destiny in a previous episode, but let me explain;

The spark could happen to whoever came, giving them the right elements. But the so call 'spark' chose Twilight. The question is 'who made the spark.'
Well, Star Swirl of course! He knew this would happen, or at least knew there was a chance, so he created the 'spark'. He knew he wouldn't finish it, but he tried to spell anyway. Turning into discord, the spark remained. The 'spark' was the 'last chance of Star Swirled's pony form.' This is how he knew the spell must be changed by a pony with a friend. He noticed the connection between the 6, and let the spark be shown.

Kitty Lin oh. I would get that that cause if sometimes u were a wizard you wouldn't have time to socialize because you are always writing spells. But, i think it was unfinished because,like you said, he turned into discord.

Flaming Shield : protector of the weak Yes, because Star Swirl disappeared after he tried the spell, and that's when Discord appeared. The spell was supposed to switch his friends, but since he had none, it switched himself.

Kitty Lin so wait, StarSwirl Is DISCORD!?!?!?!?!?!?


Do you realize what twilight did? She had NO IDEA what the spell did. And it was from one of the most powerful unicorns in history. AND SHE TESTED IT IN HER HOUSE TO SEE WHAT IT DID. Imagine if you got the worlds most powerful weapon and you set it off in your house to see what it does. Not very smart, huh?


Any one else realize that Twilight's cutie mark has 5 stars around it!


Twighlight never had to fufil like Cadence did. She might have gotten it when she had to hatch spike from his egg ( I Watch a lot of MLP stuff )

I Meant she was having a lot of troble doing magic to hatch the egg but something rainbow ( sonic rain boom ) scared her and then she activated her magic then she got her cutie mark when she finally hatched spikes egg


I noticed that when the C.M.C. went looking for rainbow dash and bumped into twi. she didn't get her cutie mark because she was frighten by the sonic rainboom it was when she was first connected with her friends


Ok so I think when star swirled abieded ( did I spell that right?) said the spell over and over again he switch the cutie marks many times but on the last he switched only rainbow and aj but not there cutie marks but their elaments!


Fulfilled can also mean her friend getting their correct cutie marks. So the their destiny is fulfiled


Does anyone notice that the spell doesn't work without the elements of harmony


The Spark was probably friendship that's like the easiest thing to figure out.


Twilight's Cutie Mark Told The Future From Her Becoming The Element Of Magic And The Balance Of 3 Princess But Became 4 When Her Destiny Was Furfilled.


I think that spark was pushing Twilight towards her destiny. (which it obviously did lol)


ima go on a limb and say this- <b>This is the alicorn creator spell</b>

ima go on a limb and say this- *This is the alicorn creator spell*


I suppose you could've called it the friendship cannon, though that is the sonic rainboom...


Pause at the end of 4:40, THE HORROR!! Also great video


If you remember at the end if the crystal empire episodes when they leave on the train Luna shows clestia the book and clestia nods maybe that was the final test too see if she was ready to be a princess?


So, If philosophy is magic based on starswirl's spell, is gummy a powerful wizard?


He wrote the spell in the past so that someone  would finish it and become an alicorn


Referencing the episode 'the cutiemark chronicals', it is also revealed that the elements are kind of tied together via Dashes sonic rainboom

Yep mr The Brony Notion without RD the other 5 wouldn't have thiere cutie marks

It was all part of destiny, bringing them together. I loved that episode so much!


my friend told me her idea to why the cutiemarks changed to who.
if Rainbowdash fell instead of doing her sonic rainboom then she would of been with the animals.
Fluttershy would still be in cloudsdale being made fun of because her weak flying, over time she would fail on purpose to make people laugh so she could laugh with them.
Applejack never seeing the rainbow to go home would of gotten into fashion
Pinkiepie being from a farm could of gotten her cutiemark in that after moving to ponyville.
and Rarity's is kinda iffy but her after being led to that rock and getting nothing and failing to get good enough costumes for the play could of been walking about when it started raining and she moved some clouds to avoid getting wet when she started messing around with them and got her cutiemark.


i don't think twilight's element of harmony is magic i think it's friendship in in season 2 episode 1 discord stole twilight's horn she should turn gray or something because she lost her element, but in part 2 she turned gray because she lost her friends, do some kind of theory on this or something.


nice theory but i have a question? Thes spell was unfinished right? so this makes me believe the straswirl used this spell in the past for a test... this is the only way he would have known that it don't work at all. i think its interesting topic ;)

i think you are right about the test.....but i also think that test is for the princess of friendship


Ok,i translated it alone from English to ita(my native language)and for me it makes more se c'è,this is what I got
Ing
"from one to another,to another to one..."
Ita
"da uno all'altro,dall'altro a uno..."
Ing
"...a mark of one's destiny..."
Ita
...il marchio della destinazione di uno..."
Ing
"...Singled out alone,fulfilled"
Ita
"...singolato fuori da solo,successo"

The last part I didn't get it at first but when it was explained I got why it was like that

Wait
Was that spell MADE for someone to fulfill their destiny!?!?

Edit: please answer my question someone

In one comic, Starswirl can Time travel. So, I think maybe he time traveled and saw Twilight fulfill her destiny and he made the spell for Twilight To find.


Cadence's cutie mark did make sense. Her ability is the same as the actual Crystal Heart.  She spreads love between ponies. So when she got her cutie mark, She knew her destiny. However, she didn't know that the Crystal Heart or the Crystal Empire existed until she had to go there and use it. Once she saw it, She knew. But not before then. The Crystal Heart being an actual relic didn't change the fact that she spread love between ponies. It just made her purpose even more grand because the Crystal Heart also spreads love throughout all of Equestria


4:40 exactly after he says: i cant wait... Straight after 'wait' you see the picture of Fluttershy with the weird head


2:45 you should have called it a beam instead of an orb


That single frame of Fluttershy near the end XD


The spark is friendship. Twilight says it herself.


Call the "Friendship rainbow" "The friendship hammer".


I think their "marks" are one in twilights cutie mark, because she is ,as you said, a big star in the middle of her friends


A mark of one destiny is fulfilled I think that means she has that half of the things that she needs to be a princess but a  mark of ones Destiny is fulfilled so it's not fully filled once she cast that spell she didn't have her wings and then once she was done at the end of the video she did have wings mark of ones Destiny is fulfilled so her Destiny is fulfilled like this a mark of Twilights Destiny is fulfilled like that


before Twilight was born and before she figured out friendship the element of magic (element of harmony) was still her cutie mark but with the others the elements were only their colors and not their cutie marks.


i think star swirl tried to make the spell but he couldn't make it so he decided to wait until somepony had that spark to make it work and twilight was born with the destiny to finish it and be that spark.


even though the show says this, I can't see it being a properly written spell. it requires something to rhyme with fulfilled to end the spell.

for example,
 "From one to another, another to one, a mark of one's destiny singled out alone, fulfilled...'May this be the day the earth stood still'",,, I don't know, but the point is made.


Maybe star swirl knew that a pony like twilight would have been born so he created a spell so that her destiny would be fulfilled? And maybe he tried it on himself and nothing happened? So he gave up...or something...


I know this a old video but if star swirl did this spell he might have not any friends so doesnt that mean it effected him I always thought were did discord come from the beards look alike what if star swirl = discord, after all how is discored so powerful


"That one rainbow death orb of friendship"<br>                               --The Brony Notion

"That one rainbow death orb of friendship"
                               --The Brony Notion


It was fulfilled because she finished the spell and became alicorn


I figured out the magic spell
"From one to a another,another to one,a mark of destiny singled out alone,fulfilled"
It means:
A element to another, another to element,a cutie mark of destiny out alone,?(fulfilled)?
                                                             means:One element of destiny leave it alone


u know when Twilight sees the shadow of the mane 6 the spark in her eyes represtns the spark for the element of MAGIC


star swirl could’ve wanted to be an alicorn though


Wait a minute ... "Twilight's cutie mark was on the tree eons before she was born." In you video when you think Twilight Might be Clover the clever you think she used Starswirl's time travel spell to BE Clover the clever maybe thats why! In frogotten friendship she might be so excited about finding about more about Clover the clever be caus eshe does not know what she did yet because she has not done it yet this makes so much sense!


what if (for twilight's cutie mark) the 5 white stars are 5 sparks. it happened twice already, will it happen 3 more times.

P.S.
      for your 'shadow pony' video, this video proves my theory


Can you update this please? Because if this spelled did happen years ago:<br>A few ponies might have gotten their cutie marks mixed up and lived their lives with their new destines…

Can you update this please? Because if this spelled did happen years ago:
A few ponies might have gotten their cutie marks mixed up and lived their lives with their new destines…


You know thinking about this logically if you think that all the ponies destiny are pre determined then when you look at how ponies get their names and is pinkie pyshci then this may help you understand, pinkie since her special talent is to throw parties and helping cheer ponies up she may be actually able to either look at a pony or their cutie mark and be able to tell why their sad and help cheer them up but in doing so she must see their destiny to because the cutie mark defines them so it tells about the future and after throwing parties with everypony in Equestria she gathers a big picture but she is not consiussly doing this therefore if something is about to happen then she gets her pinkie sense.Now onto the naming of the babies that might also have to do with pinkie but if not then this may still apply to this situation so pinkie or mother by looking at the cutimarks of the parents can see maybe into the destiny of their child getting a whisper of who their offspring will be and if you check there may be episodes where when the pony gets their mark it might not be a suprise to the parents. But for now it's just a theory


Why does twilights crown(element of magic) have those extra blue gems<br>Is that for decoration or does it mean something

Why does twilights crown(element of magic) have those extra blue gems
Is that for decoration or does it mean something


"From one to another, another to one".... "Singled out alone fulfilled".....Yep....


the spell was made so he could steal lunas a tias powers, or to make himself a new alicorn. remember the spell was made before the elimants were removed from the tree, so i could have been originaly ment for them.


what if starswirl did not make the spell, what if it was instead clover the cleaver(aka possibly time traveling twilight sparkle).  If that was the case twilight would have written her own destiny.


if the other  element orbs in the pilot weren't  broken wouldn't  the elements  all be crowns


If starswirl used the spell the pillars would switch


I think that the last part of star swirls spell was relating to what celestia. "Time for you...to fulfill your destiny." From magical mystery cure. I am not sure, but this just an idea


maybe the words "singled alone fulfilled" meant for twilight to fulfill her destiny as user of freindship


when the six are coming up the staircase, I realized that they are freaking loud!


Also the imposter Starswirl is a new villain Twilight Sparkle her friends and Spike haven't met or defeated yet and I believe it's the Shadow Pony a surprise new villain


You could have called it, that rainbow without the whole of death part.


Hey... Twilight has five sparkles around the big star in her cutie mark..... Like her five friends are around her in the picture Spike sends to Celestia in the theme..... These ponies have such an overload of destiny  it's almost unbelievable!!!!!😍😃😃😋


First of all, she wasn't affected becase she cast the spell. Second, Cadence had that hart right? well did you see how she made that couple that were fighting to the same couple but they were being all the romantic and did you see when she can have her fill her destiny there was a big blue blob around her . The same with Twlight but the pink blob was going around her body who did you not see any of that are you blind? and one more thing the blobs were different colors! Sorry if you didn't notice this and put it on the video I didn't watch the whole thing sorry if you didn't notice but if you didn't I mean this


i have  a thing for a theroy. why is it when fluttershy gets her cutie mark back, no one has pinky pies cutie mark. yet, there are two of fluttershys cutie mark. it is impossible to have to of the same cutie mark on two different ponys. if you could make a therory on this that would explain a lot more of the show to me.


Except the star in the middle or behind the pink or magenta star on twilights cutie mark there are five other stars that she was meant to have the elements of harmony because those five extra stars then say pinkie pie Rainbow Dash applejack flutter shy and rarity that's why she had the Secret six element of Harmony


I strongly suggest for you to check out Ink Rose's theory about Starswirl being Imprisoned in time by Discord.


Also you know how you said that she is the star to all of her friends. Coincidence or not Twilight’s cutiemark has 5 surrounding stars. Just like her five friends.


OML YES I forgot the same spark! The reason she has the spark is probably because her cutie mark is giving her the answers?


In a cantorlot wedding part 2 you will see that as Luna and celestia are standing next to each other while Luna magic poofs starswerles spell book


Did anyone else notice the flash of Fluttershy on the screen during the outro? 💓


twilight's destiny was singled out causing it to be fulfilled at the end of the episode


twilights family have a link to the royal family with hers and her brothers cutie marks are around the same symbol and so does her parents and knowing cadence as a foale sitter and celestia as a mentor and teacher so boom


I could see where twilight was un affected because well I guess it would be because she was the one who did the spell...


Omg i noticed that around the ending i saw the bony notions face glitch to fluttershy for a qpick instant. 1 blink and you miss it.


The spark is in the eyes in the pilot episode


This video gave me an idea for how to relate things in the fanfic i'm writing about the founding of equestria...


I think that spark was the spark of realization


In cutie mark chronicles when twilights ccutie mark appears celestia says she will make her a prized student. What could have happened was celestia realizing twilights destiny because of her cutie mark looking like the tree of harmony.


I think that Twilight is supposed to rule over Celestia In My Little Pony Friendship is Magic #magic :-) awesomeness


I Think twilight being tutned into an alicorn is her destiny fullfilled


wait this means twilight this means twilight had finished star swirl the breaded two times?!?!? WOW


Twilight fulfilled her destiny (turning into a  alicorn) alone


Wait if he wrote it he must of said the spell .i think that the spell happened before!there cutie marks before the old main 6 starswirld changed the element not to know.nobody changed it.so then in the spell threre was the REAL cutie marks if would of stayed like the not destined another pony would of took the main fives places mind blowing!


It all makes sense if you really think about it


I feel like you're Game Theory disguising as a brony so no one will know you watch mlp XD

But anyways, I have just found you today and watched a few of your videos, and I'm like "HOLY. SH*T." Keep up the good work!


A little before 4:40 his character changed so can someone please tell me what he turned into?


Why exactly did Starswirl the Bearded make this spell? What use would he have for it....?


But twighlights cutie mark isnt the only one that has a star on it... Shining's as well


i study the my little pony's more than the brony notion and could answer just about any question.


Have you seen the end a season 7? Star Swirl is back, So is Stygian is back too! You may not know who Stygain is.


I tried to get my non-pegusister friends to get the elements of harmony necklaces. They refused 😭🎺🎺🎺🎺


Well, haven't you noticed her mark looks.... kind of like a <b>spark</b>?

Well, haven't you noticed her mark looks.... kind of like a *spark*?


did you see the spark as twilight put the full stop on the paper?


4:40 You need to pause at exactly the right moment to see that his face is....


4:40

Me: literally shook

screaming intensifies

(I was so speechless when I saw it)

4:40

Me: *literally shook*

*screaming intensifies*

(I was so speechless when I saw it)


if you look at the twilights cutey mark there are five stars which might represent the five elemnts


To clear y'all

Discord-Spirit of chaos,a draconequus,maybe created by  all magical animals and non magic animals

but....
.
.
.
.
.
for...
.
.
.
.
.
Starswhirl The Bearded - A WIZARD,A UNICORN....!!!
.
.
BUT I HOPE I MADE YOUUU CLLEEEARRR ABOUT THIS SITUATION


4:40 flutters... I'm willing to bet he has a fluttershy shrine somewhere


Remember that aura I was talking about in a previous comment? Well what if there's 2 parts. One in the piolet, and the final push.


Wait a minute there is a big star in the center and five smaller stars around it I swear celestia made twilight and her destiny to befriend the other 5 ponies


i have a theory that rarity was actually supposed to become an alicorn and not twilight


But later in that episode twilight gets her wings. Didn't she fulfill her destiny when she got her wings?


So Starwill guy is the guy how did everything in the show to happend and the true true hero mind=blown yes I did misspell but is true


I only have one question.How do the other main sixes cutie marks blend in with the show?

@Crystal Starling the cutie marks match the names. except pinkie who never follows rules.

@radio rebel<br>they don't follow that rule

@radio rebel
they don't follow that rule

@radio rebel<br>But Applejack, Twilight Sparkle, Rarity, Pinkie Pie, Applebloom, Scootaloo, Sweetie Belle, Luna, Celestia, Mi amore cadenza (Cadence), Granny Smith, Bon Bon, Tropical Storm, Time Turner, Carrot Top, ect.

@radio rebel
But Applejack, Twilight Sparkle, Rarity, Pinkie Pie, Applebloom, Scootaloo, Sweetie Belle, Luna, Celestia, Mi amore cadenza (Cadence), Granny Smith, Bon Bon, Tropical Storm, Time Turner, Carrot Top, ect.

Sorry I freaked BTW mabey you can help me out I'm trying to find out something, how come a ponys name is like there personality like flutterSHY, and rainbowDASH,

I didn't mention your question directly, but I got the general point across that Twilight's cutie mark is different from the others. There is a significance behind the six point star that the other's marks don't have, so only Twilight's appears throughout the show. I hope that answered your question!  :))

I don't mind at all!<b>squeels of exitment</b>

I don't mind at all!*squeels of exitment*

Good question!  I would like to address this question in my next video. I hope you don't mind waiting for wednesday. /)


So bras backstory what drove him to go mad with power if you haven't already


OH MY GOSH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! my mind exploded!! (2x) this video is EPIC!!!!!!!:)


Maybe the spark came form the tree of harmony.

ΓΙΩΡΓΟΣ ΓΙΑΛΥΤΗΣ


i thought Twightlights purpose as a princess was to raise the stars for the night


ever since I started watching the brony notion I've been looking at mlp from a new angle (Mind blown)


If you see this, pause and go to 4:40. It's when he says "can't wait".


Twilights cutie mark has 5 sparks and 1 <br>big spark so the other 5 spark could be rainbow pinky fluttershy AJ and rarity

Twilights cutie mark has 5 sparks and 1
big spark so the other 5 spark could be rainbow pinky fluttershy AJ and rarity


what if that spark was the tree of harmony spirit?


Maybe Twilights QT mark as it is a star with 5 other stars around it it is maybe a connection between her and her friends


The Brony Notion: In all the MYSTERIES in Magical MYSTERY Cure, prehaps the most MYSTERIOUS . . ."

Me: SORRY NO UNDERSTAND BYE

*The Brony Notion:* In all the MYSTERIES in Magical MYSTERY Cure, prehaps the most MYSTERIOUS . . ."

*Me:* SORRY NO UNDERSTAND BYE


Wait what episodes are there where Candace isn't the Princess of Crystal Empire? Like her past? Thanks!


Twilights cutiemark is single out alone and her destiny to be princess is fulfilled thats what the last phrase is about


Ok, I think you got it! I can't think of anything else!


hey I love ur channel rewatch this video and when u c the spark in twighlights eyes u notice it looks similar to her cutie mark maybe ur going somewhere with ur videos. bro hoove! :)


and there uncle has the mark on his pendant that cadence (evil) had a problem with in the episode a canterlot wedding part 1


does each star around the the pink star resemble each one of her FIVE friends


Star swirl have too many crystals if he uses the magic on crystals...


Can you redo this video cause we now know that the elements didn't exist when starswerl was around they were created after he was sent to limbo so what was the spell originally meant for ???


Hey, did anyone else catch the sudden flash of a fluttershy picture on his face near the end?


6 stars 6 spikes on twilights cutie mark just like 6 eliments thus the eliments are her destiny


If Twilight read the completed spell to Discord when he become Star swirl the bearded


Did your notice the white stars around twilights cutie marks are roundabout in line with her friends


Maybe the field means that she became an alicorn


TWILIGHT SAID "that didn't make any sense"
Eh- wh- what? WAS THIS SPELL?
What was this for?


Did you see that at the end, his head turned into fluttershys head for a split second.


2:24
*Blinks*
I never noticed this, but... Twilight writes right to left in that scene?

2:24
**Blinks**
I never noticed this, but... Twilight writes right to left in that scene?


Am i the only one who thinks if he recorded this in a closet with a $5 microphone?


OMG what language was twilight writing to change the spell because she was writing from right to left and the book was meant to write from left to right!


“What in the hoof is that supposed to mean?”
FRIENDS
Me: Ik it means FRIENDS!


Also who knew that a simple period could change someponys life


It's almost like they all switched to a secondary element, but one that doesn't fit them as well as the one. Let's be honest here, Pinkie almost NEVER lies, and when she does, she's terrible at it. Fluttershy makes all the animals happy, AJ is generally generous, Rarity is normally loyal, and Raindow normally tries to be kind, in her own way, so they all kinda went to some kind of second element fraise.


discord is star swirl the bearded but as he was making the spell he didnt have any friends to swap cute marks with each other so when he finally said the enchantment words he vecam3 disord because there was not anything he could change into so he changed into half quarter wotsit of everything your question is solved my name is LilliCrazyCat and im 10 yrs old your welcome!


Am I the only one who noticed near the end his face flashed as Fluttershy?😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂


I'm appliance shopping and I'd like to know, What toaster did you use to record your audio?


maybe s.s.b made the spell to get someone else's cutiemark to see what lives they had but ended up switching OTHERS cutiemarks


Maybe the reason twilight is over obsessed with star swirl is because he and the group created the tree of harmony and cause twilights cutie mark is all over it


I think twilight has a speshel conection with her element the others don't (but she dose not know it)


Celestia turn twilight into a princess by giving her the book she knew that twilight was going to be a princess so that is really what I have to say.


My theary goes

The spell was made for twilight to giver her that push "the mark of wans deastany singeld out alone fufiled" twilight became a prinsess

Tell me what you think


how did the cutiemarks on celestia and luna ended up on the tree of harmony?


I realized that spark in her eyes the first time I saw the episode to.


You should watch ink rose and her mlp videos after I watched those I watched these and everything makes sense but according to her u got what happened to cadence wrong (not in this video but in another one)

PEACE


What if the spell was never unfinished but lile when you in an exam there is a sentence and you have to full in the gap


I don't know if you mention this 'cause I'm in the middle of the vid but there are five white stars around the pink start in Twilight's cutie mark possibly representing each friend/element?


Wait,why do they say “what in the hoof does that mean?” Humans don’t say “what in the hand does that mean?” XD


That one RAINBOW DEATH RAY OF FRIENDSHIP 🌈 -The Brony Notion


what!!! on the tree of harmony there's a sun and a moon :O what! do a video on that maybe it like twilight?? i think it whold be mind blowing


Starswirl left it unfinished for twilight aka clover the clever


Wait... Was that a sonic rainboom? When they used the elements of harmony?!


Spark is the power of the friendship fire thing and her element of course It isn't in it's full from<br>

With out full friendship the friendship fire is not complete


4:39 for like one sec you can see he face changed