kind: youtube#commentThread

kind: youtube#comment

textDisplay: I’m still mad this channel isn’t bigger than it is. Your music has always been my favorite among the mlp community

authorDisplayName: Muse the Insomniac


textDisplay:
The Replacer curse.

Whenever I randomly go onto a replacer video for no reason, I suddenly find or see a video relating to the video I looked at.

First it was seeing SGaP mentioned in the comments right before learning of a documentary about him.

This time, a Passing By VIP is released less then an hour after I look at Days of Silence again.

The unbreaking curse of the coincidence.

authorDisplayName: Emotion Nexus

textDisplay: @Maxwell Garnaat its released by a channel called orchidtothewinter. It has a bunch of fans discussing his impact and a bit of his behavior.

value: UCsvHHxzHGtGrWMgGVETyQfA

textDisplay: What's the SGaP documentary? I'd love to learn more.

authorDisplayName: Maxwell Garnaat

textDisplay: @stevenstrumpf7 ?

textOriginal: @stevenstrumpf7 ?


textDisplay:
YES YES YES!!!
My favourite song you've done and one of my favourite all time song!!!
Both versions are amazing and I can't chose which one I prefer >_<
I'd love to hear more like these with the piano and the drums (especially with the lofi effect in it or whatever it is)
Cheers!!! ❤

authorDisplayName: Camix!


textDisplay:
The way this piece tonally weaves, I adore its unpredictability. Defo gonna learn this one on the piano. Question, was it all recorded in a take, or are there several layers of piano playing at once? I was improvising over it earlier, and was having a hard time figuring out what was being played by the right and left hands around 1:20.

Either way, love your stuff, always look forward to hearing your songs whenever you put them out 😊👍👍

authorDisplayName: The Sitch

textDisplay: haha, this is definitely not for two hands - the original had two pianos and I added two more in this version, although I don't think more than 3 pianos are playing at any one time<br>you might be able to distill a duet or something out of it though.

textOriginal:
haha, this is definitely not for two hands - the original had two pianos and I added two more in this version, although I don't think more than 3 pianos are playing at any one time
you might be able to distill a duet or something out of it though.

authorDisplayName: replacer


textDisplay:
Damn, your harmonies in this one really dope.
I appreciate that kind of music :')
<3

authorDisplayName: Filacki


textDisplay: The beginning sounds so much like a mixture of stairway to heaven + mad world, a little bit later reminds me of makkon (also i can hear some sims) and everything alltogether sounds like your music. I haven't heard the original version, but this one will have a spot in my favourite music playlist.<br>Do you plan to add vocals to this?

textOriginal:
The beginning sounds so much like a mixture of stairway to heaven + mad world, a little bit later reminds me of makkon (also i can hear some sims) and everything alltogether sounds like your music. I haven't heard the original version, but this one will have a spot in my favourite music playlist.
Do you plan to add vocals to this?

authorDisplayName: &I

textDisplay: thank c: and no I never had any plan to put vocals on this


textDisplay: Beautiful atmospheric piece. It tells a nuanced story. Someone already said below that this would be great music to listen to while creating art, yourself, and I agree. Most of the time when I'm listening to your work, it provides an explosion of creative energy and I have to go rush to sculpt or draw again. 'Dunno how to describe it, but it's great! Thanks for another wonderful tune!

authorDisplayName: ClayInTheCarpet


textDisplay:
First I got some Nightmare Night vibes, but soon I realised it's got a whole different melody and feel to it.
Sounds like ideal track to listen to while doing something creative. Very calm. Give us more please.
We all love your music.

authorDisplayName: Frisky


textDisplay: Yes!!!!! New replacer music!!!!!!!

textOriginal: Yes!!!!! New replacer music!!!!!!!

authorDisplayName: Ultra B


textDisplay: This is like the love child of Debussy and LoFi Hip Hop and the lobby of a doctor’s office.

authorDisplayName: Super Trampoline the Bat Pony


textDisplay: Replacer you’re style is something that actually isn’t replaceable to me. Keep dropping surprises man! Glad to see ya uploading again!

authorDisplayName: Nebby14 ★


textDisplay: Very sweet this VIP version !! Both are amazing, you're a so great pony music composer ^^<br>/)

textOriginal:
Very sweet this VIP version !! Both are amazing, you're a so great pony music composer ^^
/)

authorDisplayName: Koron Korak


textDisplay: Been going through my old library of pony music and reminiscing, and I'm really glad to see that you're putting out new stuff. Most of the big pony musicians from the fandom's hey day have moved on from the fandom, but I always admired your work as one of the greats.

authorDisplayName: Artsy Omni


textDisplay: This song is so relaxing, I can feel myself just get taken away when the piano hits at 1:03. Definitely dropped into my favourites of yours.

authorDisplayName: NGnir


textDisplay: The mixing of piano and synth gives a Minecraft-esque tone. The percussion (along with the pacing) are more akin to Terraria, though. I suppose the true beauty of the song is that it isn’t fully either; it’s a unique piece with its own feel.

authorDisplayName: Ultimate Expander


textDisplay: Absolutely loving the new sections!! How it briefly goes to the darker places even for just a small nudge, or a peek, it makes ALL the difference in how the piece is dancing around and telling you its story. <br>Wasn't expecting a VIP of this but it's really appreciated :3

textOriginal:
Absolutely loving the new sections!! How it briefly goes to the darker places even for just a small nudge, or a peek, it makes ALL the difference in how the piece is dancing around and telling you its story.
Wasn't expecting a VIP of this but it's really appreciated :3


textDisplay: So chill and relaxing in a special way <3 Your signature magic..! Awesome VIP! ^.^


textDisplay:
you're SOOO underrated
completely love your stuff <3
this was such a chill and calm song

authorDisplayName: Alumx


textDisplay: This is absolutely remarkable and spectacular i love it.

authorDisplayName: The Commenter Dragon


textDisplay: I can't decide which version I like more, I only know that I love both

authorDisplayName: El WaKa


textDisplay: Don’t mind me I’m just doing my biyearly replacer music catch up this definitely belongs in a video game

authorDisplayName: Bryan Chandler


textDisplay: This is beautiful, I need a whole album of this. Glad you're back❤

authorDisplayName: Morning Coffee Cat


textDisplay: Just discovered this artist 2 days ago and cannot stop listening. So glad to see a new song posted /)

authorDisplayName: Saber Cat


textDisplay: Very refreshing to listen to, always a treat when you upload.


textDisplay: a little walk for the mind - perhaps not revolutionary, but positively good-natured and wholesome.

authorDisplayName: Boromir Smith


textDisplay: Replacer dropping new songs is the highlight of a 2 month stretch. I will follow you until the end of days.

authorDisplayName: ShiraZen


textDisplay: YES I LOVE INSTRUMENTAL MUSIC!

textOriginal: YES I LOVE INSTRUMENTAL MUSIC!

authorDisplayName: Quantum Rain


textDisplay: Aw I love this one <3 And I love that you're still making music!

authorDisplayName: Kristy M


textDisplay: Oh very nice work keep it up.

textOriginal: Oh very nice work keep it up.

authorDisplayName: Mix-up


textDisplay: Love it. 🤘

textOriginal: Love it. 🤘

authorDisplayName: Minati Music


textDisplay: i knew there was another replacer song but i didnt remember where it was since the original is not here, and those extract beats do add up and i love both versions but i will admit this one is a bit more detailed


textDisplay: Another fine addition to my collection!

textOriginal: Another fine addition to my collection!

authorDisplayName: Mike Dragon


textDisplay: Awesome work

textOriginal: Awesome work

authorDisplayName: Zephysonas


textDisplay: Oh my gosh more replacer!!

textOriginal: Oh my gosh more replacer!!

authorDisplayName: Atriark the Zebra


textDisplay: yay!!! more of Replacer!!! ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

authorDisplayName: ZecoraLaCebra


textDisplay: I adore this.

textOriginal: I adore this.

authorDisplayName: Tristan Frodelius


textDisplay: Another Replacer song already? Best news I've seen since the last song you put out.

authorDisplayName: McKay Cheatham


textDisplay: Make sure to never soil this masterpiece with words.

authorDisplayName: NotOrdinaryInGames


textDisplay: Why is your music so underrated?

textOriginal: Why is your music so underrated?


textDisplay: Yeees. More replacer music

textOriginal: Yeees. More replacer music

authorDisplayName: Pad Griffin


textDisplay: Ohh yeeees! Some good music is here boys!

authorDisplayName: Иван Чиковани


textDisplay: Good to see you again.

textOriginal: Good to see you again.

authorDisplayName: AnimatronicPony


textDisplay: you inspire me

textOriginal: you inspire me

authorDisplayName: Hyper Dash


textDisplay: Reminds me of Erik Saties work

textOriginal: Reminds me of Erik Saties work

authorDisplayName: Morning Coffee Cat


textDisplay: Man, what the hell are you doing with just 12 thousand subs?

authorDisplayName: Shearer Foo


textDisplay: never die

textOriginal: never die


textDisplay: All i got is EEEEE

textOriginal: All i got is EEEEE

authorDisplayName: Petgasys


textDisplay: OwO

textOriginal: OwO

authorDisplayName: HYPERION8089008 Nakayama


textDisplay: Hello again Commander

textOriginal: Hello again Commander

authorDisplayName: Lesbian Carwasher