What about Discord? Wouldn't he stop the Changelings? Fluttershy haves tea with him every week.

It was Starlight, Trixie, and Thorax who told him where flutter shy was. Since Starlight wasn’t there to inform Trixie, both of them wouldn’t have a clue anything was wrong with the mane 6. Then again, discord may suspect something was up. But he couldn’t of guessed that they were all trapped in the changeling castle. But discord never walks anywhere. He could teleport to flutter shy and end up at the changeling palace. He might think it’s a malfunction with his magic about 20,942 times until he thinks that flutter shy may be at the changeling palace, but he wouldn’t know his way around and might easily inform the changelings he is in the castle, and eventually just get captured like what happened in the episode. He also may not be able to walk to the castle (without crying like a baby at least). He wouldn’t be able to find his way to the throne room either, if he did, there would be guards there. He couldn’t of distracted the guards. But maybe he could, it isn’t really hard to think of a distraction, the only thing that’s in his way is the changeling not falling for it. (They aren’t that smart though, so it may of been just as easy as it was in the episode) if he eventually made it to the throne room, he would of immediately been captured by queen crysalis. He couldn’t of broken the throne without catching attention, and he certainly doesn’t have the heart or brain process to make a whole entire speech about friendship.

@Sawtooth Waves What about the Storm King?

Also I added some interesting theories in a comment of my own connecting this idea with G5 if you're interested. 😉

@awesometacular You have a point there, but with Queen Chrysalis' line about the shard to Cozy Glow is kind of sketchy

Even Discord's magic doesn't work in the Changeling hive, remember. The throne sucks up all non changeling magic.

@Brooke K I don’t think that’s true… Fluttershy would recover from the loss

@Forest Grump But, it would be because of Fluttershy that he wouldn't abandon anypony else though

I get the feeling if he saw the invasion coming he would have just taken Fluttershy and her friends to his dimension and left equestria to it's fate. The only pony he cared about was Fluttershy for the most part, and a little bit about Twilight. He would bring Fluttershy's friends because he would want her to be happy, but as for the wide world of equestria? ...I don't think he would care.

@Sawtooth Waves But here is what I don't get...Apple Jack's comment when the trio returned to the present timeline wouldn't make sense if they were from a different Timeline..."What is she doin' here"?

@Sawtooth Waves What about Grogar's bell? Thorax said the magic of the throne is ancient magic. Do does the bell. In Season 6 finale Discord problably couldn't go after the bell cause he couldn't let the team go on without him. But in this timeline he is all alone. No Starlight and Trixie, and no Thorax. <br> Tirek:  "Look's like the magic of friendship is your only weakness."

@Sawtooth Waves What about Grogar's bell? Thorax said the magic of the throne is ancient magic. Do does the bell. In Season 6 finale Discord problably couldn't go after the bell cause he couldn't let the team go on without him. But in this timeline he is all alone. No Starlight and Trixie, and no Thorax.
 Tirek:  "Look's like the magic of friendship is your only weakness."

I think he will like help them keep the changelings quarantine or something like Equestria will probably gone once they move the green Crystal stuff in but yeah or who knows maybe they'll make a deal and t Fluttershy will go out and make a resistance

@Sawtooth Waves i like to think that discord would hold them off at least out of equestria creating a stalemate kinda like in the sombra timeline

@scifi DINO to be fair, i don't think Discord is THAT smart. He may be the lord of chaos, but he was never the god of science

@Sawtooth Waves Couldn't Discord create like a particle accelerator or something, load in some dirt from the enviroment (which obviously isn't made out of magic) and then precisely take out the throne? (Use like a spying glass that can see through walls or something to locate it)

discord relied heavily on the other three. he's heavily impaired without his magic, which chrysalis' throne blocked


Ok but like, did you ever wonder if Starlight, Twilight and Spike ever existed in the other timelines? Cause compared to the human universe wherein you can see their human selves, it’s never shown where Starlight, Twilight, and Spike are in the other timelines..


Depressing? Nah. This is a way to show if someone disappeared or never existed everything could go wrong. Everyone they love might be hurt or worse. The world could maybe even end. That's kinda inspiring


Wait a sec... if they went to a different timeline, wouldn't they run into that timeline's version of them?


Ok. So here is the issue with your theory. Twilight may have not even affected the past by being there. The race went on as though nopony knew they were there. So what if they were there in the original timeline but it wasn't noticable. That means that they were destined to return to the past and leave an unchanged present. Like when twilight used a time spell to try to warn herself. It happened and it left the present unchanged. They were mostly where the racers (including Rainbow Dash) could see but they were too busy focused on the race to notice.<br>I am sorry for doing this.

Ok. So here is the issue with your theory. Twilight may have not even affected the past by being there. The race went on as though nopony knew they were there. So what if they were there in the original timeline but it wasn't noticable. That means that they were destined to return to the past and leave an unchanged present. Like when twilight used a time spell to try to warn herself. It happened and it left the present unchanged. They were mostly where the racers (including Rainbow Dash) could see but they were too busy focused on the race to notice.
I am sorry for doing this.


Simple, discord can travel between dimensions time and and space, dreams and timelines, fluttershy would beg discord to bring twilight and spike back and then when he does twilight will ask discord to bring starlight back and he will refuse until fluttershy ask him.


But if twilight, spike and starlight went into a different timeline that was identical then there would be 2 twilights, 2 spikes, and 2 starlight's. So I think that they went into the original timeline.


You think of timelines like they are parallel universes. I think they are not. Probably Starlight just changed original timeline several times. When Starlight and Twilight came back it still was the same universe but its past is a little bit different


probably the timeline where twilight starlight and spike came from just stopped existing, or just like you said it was reconnected after the rain-boom


If they got teleported to another identical timeline, wouldn’t there be other versions of twilight and starlight?

They didn't join a timeline they moved forward in to a timeline, there would never be 2 of them in this time travel design


This would probably be the timeline where nobody wins out.  Keep in mind that, if Cozy and Tirek teamed up in a Chrysalis timeline, there could still be someone involved trying to stop them: the Changelings.  Would they succeed, though?  Maybe, maybe not.  We know that Discord was affected, too...or was he?  If I recall correctly, he didn't show up in School Raze at all.  Who knows if he could have helped out the Changelings, since without the Season 6 finale happening, Discord would have no reason to find the Changelings to be a problem.  This is the same guy who teamed up with Tirek, and Chrysalis and her army remained in unknown circumstances up until the Season 6 finale.


If this is true than the 9th timeline can be the timeline where everything is broken and destroyed


So here's the reason this mess happened: they really couldn't change the fact that they were there unless, Starlight did. And they didn't know this mess could happen. Simple right????


I think They actually were there in the Original Timeline. It’s just that Nobody ever noticed them, and we never saw them in the Flashback, but I bet they were just off screen. Rainbow Dash was too high on adrenaline to notice, so she never would’ve been able to relay the information to the modern day Twilight. There’s also the fact that Season 5 hadn’t been written by this point. So in all reality, we never actually left the original Timeline, aside from when Starlight stopped Rainbow Dash those 7 different times, leading to all the events we saw in the Episodes.


Wait a minute, now that I think about it, if that’s how the time travel works, wouldn’t there be multiple twilights in some timelines?


When starlight changed reality she MADE new timelines so there is no way that new one was sitting there wiith all the past already there, just an opinion


Maybe they managed to save the world without twilight spike in the other girl they are strong and learned a lot


I personally think that them being at the rainbow was bound to happen no matter what and it’s kinda like those time loop thingys that I don’t like thinking about because they make me confused


0:48
>Unless we assume Starlight being there and Twilight talking her down was already part of the original timeline.

The Harry Potter franchise has a lot of logistical plot holes, but it handles time travel very cleanly. In Prisoner of Azkaban, Harry and Serius are dying, but are then saved by future Harry, who traveled back in time. Present Harry survives (as the result of his future self's actions) and later in the story, travels back in time, becoming future Harry, who saves his past self. Basically, the actions of his future self were already part of the past. No alternate timelines exist because the original timeline required that he go back in time to ensure events would play out the way he experienced them.

And we have evidence that this is the same with Equestria's time travel. Exhibit A: "It's About Time," where Twilight travels back in time and (unintentionally) ensures the same course of events that caused her to travel back in time in the first place happen the way she experienced them. Future Twilight's appearance in past Twilight's library mandated that past Twilight's timeline would result in her becoming future Twilight and traveling back in time to maintain the timeline as it was supposed to happen.


There are way more than 9 timelines. Let's just say they leave the timeline of Rainboom. Twilight grows up founds the Mane 6 they do everything get to Starlight and the time travel part happens. Starlight and Twilight goes back in time and creates another universe with the same events as the AU the first Starlight created. The Original universe is probably in chaos, but there are more than 9 universes.


I think they went back but realized they couldn't see them so they went back but discovered that it was a timeline that has no Celestial or Luna so ponyvill was sad and disappointing so they went back and fixed everything and returned to there timeline


I like to think those timelines were just blips of possible timelines but nobody in them was real. It was just an illusion for understanding cause and effect so no alternative timelines were created, time was just paused as the 3 ventured through possibilities before they ended the illusion when starlight decided to go back.

Imma just say the reason she ended the illusion instead of the rest of the show being an illusion is just because she's just ultra overpowered with magic.

This is just what I tell myself to make less depressing. Take it if you want, leave it if you like the alternative worlds

And if we do go to this alt world I think they'd turn to sunset shimmer to figure out what happened to Twilight and everything. She could do it and she could probably find a solution somehow.


I am simple girl, I see sawtooth has a new theory I click


Boi i want a remembrance scale series of this concept


That theory couldn't be possible because eventually Twilight would run into the other Twilight from that universe and then they would know something is wrong.


I think when they went in a different time line they got replaced with fake versions of themselves


well, Time Travel works when you interface with a certain someone from the past if you go back into the past without doing anything then things should seem normal, that forgotten world isn’t really there it’s still the first original world that the main 6 live in (if you get what i mean) that forgetten world would only exist if spike and twilight got stuck in one of the other time places they got sent to in my opinion


ik this isn't relevant to this but I was wondering if you had a theory on the different varieties of ponies like the sea poneys. also how that relates to the Umbra and what exactly are they


OR... It was all one timeline, that allowed itself to be temporary split. Almost like your destiny theory. So one fat line that split and came back to one big line

Edit: guess I didn’t watch the whole video


It think I know the change that would have happened.<br>Someone saw Starlight, Spike and Twilight, and it could have messed with their head. So something could have happened between the time of the rainboom and the present

It think I know the change that would have happened.
Someone saw Starlight, Spike and Twilight, and it could have messed with their head. So something could have happened between the time of the rainboom and the present


And the original world thinks starlight is evil because she WAS evil when she went to the time machine.


.... <b>Sits in corner having an MLP thought crisis</b>

.... *Sits in corner having an MLP thought crisis*


Just a theory, but what if the G5 new generation we’re seeing is the “abandoned” timeline? Thoughts?


Lol MLP brings me back to the 2012 days good times


His voice ain’t helping the fact that it’s 12:42 am, and I decided to watch this for no reason. No offence to him, this was a nice video, so keep it up!


I disagree but you do have a Point about two different timelines but I think they would merge back together.


But doesn’t that mean there has to be another Twilight in the “new” timeline?

I figure the main timeline is just as likely to get a replacement set of time travelers as the new timelines.

The new timelines twi and star probably also time traveled and got sent to another timeline and it kept repeating….the main timeline is lonely


I think how time travel works is a by changing things back and causing a New Rainboom

  It becomes a Paradoxical phenomenon as the original Rainboom would've "NEVER" happened Because of Starlight

  The timeline they return to is the future after the Rainboom they caused

  The Original Rainboom timeline isn't Abandoned

  But, Erased


I don't think MLP time travel is that complicated.


The way I see it, with The Magic of Friendship still being viable and all the removal of Twilight and Spike would mean someone else would end up filling their places somehow. Most if not all of their problems could still be overcome. I'm sure there is a lot that could have happened to compensate for their loss.


Even though I want to bileve that you’re wrong, you’re too smart lmao you convinced me. They left that timeline


Hey, Sawtooth! I know I shouldn't be pushy, but could you please do a video on that clip where apple bloom is a crystal pony?


Yes but I think Luster or Flurry heart could be Twilights replacement Trixie might see sunburst since with snow covering his homeland he would have to move to some other land where trixie might meet up and relate to since she is a traveling magician then lister would happen and even though without Twilight to help her realize friendship is not useless  her friends could tell old tales of their adventures and maybe she would realize it has worth and find other friends to help with chrysalis. On the other hoof remember when Twilight said Flurry was equestrias last hope if they failed? Flurry being the giggly hopeful child she is could gather other friends from other lands she could save the crystal empire beat chrysalis. Without twilight the world may still have luster and Flurry to save it. :)


I have not seen this episode, but I see how it would forcibly create another timeline. What happens in time travel does not matter, everything will and have happened (Twilight, Spike, and Starlight would have spontaneously not existed in one timeline, leading to the same tragedy).

I have not seen this episode, but I see how it would forcibly create another timeline. What happens in time travel does not matter, everything *will* and *have* happened (Twilight, Spike, and Starlight would have spontaneously not existed in one timeline, leading to the same tragedy).


Oh! What if Gen 5 took place in the abandoned timeline?


They could't merge back into one timeline because Butterfly Effect. Their presence was a change at the beginning...

I took it as a fact from the beginning and didn't really think about it much, because I spent an awful lot of time on the topic of time travel.

I mean, if they couldn't merge back there would be one abandoned timeline and one timeline with 2 twilights, 2 starlights and 2 spikes? We have seen 2 twilights talk to each other in it's about time so why wouldn't that happen in this timeline?

@Epik Gerbil Gaming It should be noted that these are all just theories. We can't argue about it because time travel is not possible yet...

@Lunatic Flame i look at it like this:  If you go back in time and move your car keys 5 inches to the left, everything from that point on would play out the exact same way because the change was so minor and inconsequential that the future played out the exact same way.  the butterfly effect scales in correlation to the significance of the change, which is something i NEVER see anyone talk about.  they always liken it to "moving a pebble 5years in the past will always result in the apocolypse in the present" or some asinine BS like that.  because the restoration of the rainboom event was done in a way where their appearance would go largely unnoticed, the present was effectively reverted to the prime version.

@Epik Gerbil Gaming Yes, even if you return to look at the first creature that came out from the sea to land and then return to the presence, you would return to different presence that could be exactly same ...

if anything, their presence would be largely inconsequential.  a few extra spectators wouldn't have much effect, and would likely be easily forgotten.  it would be like going back in time to witness the cubs winning the 2016 world series in person.  Yes, you get to see it happen, but apart from one extra ticket being sold, the only real change in the future would be that there was one extra person nobody paid any attention to.  As a result, the future is largely the exact same, with the exception of a few bits of currency in different locations.


Plot twist: the original timeline without Spike, Twilight and Starlight is the world without friendship, the world "The new generation" tells about🤔

Света Пономарева


I have two requests for theory videos
1) what happened to gallus's family
And
2) the story behind the young 6's window

@Sawtooth Waves   thanks for reading and responding to my comment you really made my day☺

fraid there's not enough information on either! my guess for the window was it depicts the student six making first contact with an alien civilization


Here's my theory if they want back in time then technically they're still version of herself so when they went all the way back then there would be two versions of herself and then they would be too but that isn't true so they probably did merge creating some super duper cool stuff


yes there's another timeline but think about it they went back in it but the scroll made a magical action doing a burst maybe the scroll turned then into the normal timeline idk how time travel works tho


When you talked about Sunburst being Sunset Shimmer's brother and Trixie and Sunburst being Luster's parents, could Luster be the niece of Sunset Shimmer?


But, this should mean there is two Twilight's in the Timeline with Twilight, Spike, & Starlight.


I sure another comment has brought this up but! This would most likely wouldn’t do anything, as you said in the video the timeline likely merged as once changing it was alway like that.

Idk just some thoughts, great video!!!


Whenever Sawtooth posts videos, it makes my day. :)


i like your theory but i think its the same timeline since the spell vanished after i hope so at least :)


This kind of reminds me of terminator set the timelines are a little difficult


Well, since we didn't know, what time itself is, we can't say what actually happen. But still, we didn't see original new timeline Twi, Spike and Glimmer, so It also could be old timeline.

Данил Булатов


Theory: there was also another twilight of the world twilight is in now so they switched places aka one twilight went to another world the twilight from that world went to hers then they would be identical places


How dare you... Now I need an audio version of this end like Bride and Daughter of Discord.


But if Starlight, Twilight, and Spike went to another timeline, wouldn’t there be other versions of them?


I think the new time line they came back too over rights the old one.  Where it still happened but doesn't exists any more.


I think this definitely has fanfic potential


Sawtooth, you're giving me chills up my spine!


I think that since there are no major changes that happened to affect anything majorly or even minimally that they still returned back into the same timeline also if they went into a new timeline where are the twilight starlight and spike of that other timeline? It just doesn’t add up or make sense so it was most likely since no major changes happened that they just returned back to the same timeline that they were from and everything just continued


If Twilight, Starlight and Spike abandoned the original timeline they should’ve find another Twilight, another Starlight and another Spike in the timeline they continued in


I have an idea for the 7th timeline : What If In This Timeline, the storm king Came Early, And Caused that storm Not Likely, but just a thought


maybe the other timeline was created, but starlight, spike, and twilight continued on in the original timeline. so the other timeline was forgotten


I've bin recently Going Back And watching stuff that I would always watch back when I was younger And rn I'm Going thru MLP stuff And damn it's bring me back a hole tone of nostalgia


what if the "desert" IS the forgotten timeline<br>Creepy to thing about am i right

what if the "desert" IS the forgotten timeline
Creepy to thing about am i right


Sawtooth a time line can't be abandoned.


heres another question what if what starlight did was ment to happen and what we saw in the past was what truely happened?


I think it's more of an avengers type deal where them going back in time was supposed to happen.


3:56 she wouldnt have taken over as she took over for friendship, without Twilight then she wouldnt have met the small 6 and would have no reason to try and take over


A difference that MAKES no difference IS no difference.  If nopony noticed Twilight, Starlight, and Spike and acted on it later, the two timelines would quickly merge.  Even the butterfly effect relies on actions taking place (or not).  Don't work yourself up over nothing.


But if they travelled to another timeline, twilight's friends recognised them so that means that theres another twilight, spike and starlight travelling to the original timeline so its like nothing changed (maybe)


4:08 I really don't like how you paint abandoned timeline as doom and gloom, how about this hypothetical, while Cozy Glow did still try her plan and succeeded, she unintentionally salvaged the timeline, sure no magic(like Gen 5 timeline... Hmmm) but atleast Chrysalis loses her magic as well. And since you buy the "butterfly effect" theory, how about this. Since timeline is so different, couldn't even cozy glow change? What if in this timeline she wants to drain magic to SAVE everyone, or atleast to spite Chrysalis.


i don’t think this is what happened but it’d make for a great creepypasta


Oh my god, I'm just recently getting back into My Little Pony since it ended and this right here? Wow very good analysis on the theory :) ❤ (cries on the inside)


maybe they were totally supposed to do that, like a time loop the same thing as the "It's about time" episode.


I think the wasteland one is just when I had no Idea what I was doing in EAW and ended up getting everyone killed


What about starlight, twilight, and spike from the new timeline? Surely there would be a paradox


I can't watch a single video of yours and not end up completely mind blown...🤯


Doctor Hooves could've known about what happened if he stumbled upon it in his journeys, let the Mane 5 and Celestia know.   But then does Doctor Hooves alter timeless when he goes in and out?......


This is like the meme,
Time traveler moves a chair a centimeter:

The timeline:


But wouldn’t there but two copies of Twilight (albeit one is younger and the other is older) if the original stayed in the new timeline if they did stay there? The same can be said for Spike and Starlight


I have channeled aliens and they described time as an ocean with currents. Yes, the 9th timeline would happen.


I Like How This Channel Goes Real Deep Into Some Stuff In MLP. I Really Do.


I actually think she changed the spell just to stop the rainboom so if they were there they would still go back to the time they returned to because she only wanted to stop the rainboom


The time lines go back together end of story


I doubt this is the case now. In the My little manga comic a day in the life of equestria volume 3 (Which deals with an alternate timeline where the elements weren’t present with nightmare moon) Discord states that time corrects itself with these things and that mostly happens, well it turns into pony life. But still, them being there would have been even less of an correction, They probably got sent back.


There must be a twilight in that dimension so they must've swapped places


Imagine the first timeline was the reason mlp g5 world is the way it is now


What if the original timeline turned into G5?


After that twilight went to the equestria girl world and was remembered so I think that she might go to the same time line that she was in before or in the other time line you said


4:21 depressing and kinda engaging at the same time.

2:22 the sad music starts and I nearly cry again, great. rip original timeline, you will be missed


Technically if you are no time in Equestria then you should think about the beginning to the end of the show how long does it take to make all the seasons maybe then you'll know what


You forgot one thing, without starlight maybe the princesses would become evil, also maybe the “Worlds” we saw was the WORLD they left behind.

Edit: also I forgot to say this, maybe the lost element of harmon is the element of time?

Because: where was twilight sparkle in those timelines?


Shouldn't there be another Twilight and the gang if they're in a new timeline? What are they doing?


bro I've always thought about this since the first time I saw this episode, like: "what? but what about the fucking original timeline?"

thanks for answering my question


I just got back to watching these and I forgot how relaxing there voice is.


No defeance i think time treavel just work diffently.

Ex. WoW's WoD (video game. WoD = Warlords of Dranor) grarrsh hellscream time traveled and did some stuff to change the timeline of main timine but it never changed. It just crated it's own timeline and NEVER changed the main tyimline.

"The expansion is set after the events of Mists of Pandaria and takes place in an alternate universe on the world of Draenor, the original homeworld of the orcs as it appeared in Warcraft II: Beyond the Dark Portal, prior to its destruction in the ending of that game and the creation of Outland as featured in Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne and World of Warcraft: The Burning Crusade. Legendary characters of Warcraft's past, such as Grommash Hellscream, Ner'zhul, Gul'dan, and Blackhand appear.[13]

At the end of Mists of Pandaria, Garrosh Hellscream is overthrown as Warchief of the Horde by a combined Alliance–Horde force and taken into custody by the Pandaren so that he can stand trial for the atrocities he committed in Pandaria. However, before he can be judged, Garrosh escapes captivity with the aid of Kairozdormu (a renegade bronze dragon) and travels to the orcish homeworld of Draenor 35 years in the past, prior to the rise of the Horde. As soon as they arrive Garrosh kills Kairoz then proceeds to change history by preventing his father Grommash from drinking the blood of the demon lord Mannoroth, which led to the orc's corruption by the Burning Legion and played a major role in the events of the first three Warcraft games. This interferes with history, creating an alternate timeline where the orcish clans unite into an "Iron Horde" by using technology Garrosh brought from his time. The Iron Horde begin a war of conquest on Draenor by killing Mannoroth and building a Dark Portal that allows them to travel through time and lay siege to the Azeroth of the present era.[14] The adventurers storm the Dark Portal and with the help of Khadgar fight back the Iron Horde Vanguard back into the alternate Draenor. The adventurers use the Iron Horde's own weaponry to destroy the Draenor side of the Dark Portal but are subsequently forced to flee in order to evade the full might of the Iron Horde. The Azeroth Vanguard flee to the docks and split into two ships; with the Alliance following the Draenei and the Horde joining the Frostwolf Clan. Afterwards, the Alliance and Horde establish bases with portals to Azeroth to bring in supplies and soldiers.

The Alliance and Horde and their Draenor allies fight back the Iron Horde and ultimately confront the escaped war criminal Garrosh Hellscream in Nagrand. Garrosh lashes back and the forces are saved by the intervention of Thrall who challenged Garrosh to mak'gora - a duel of honor that can lead to death. In the battle that follows, Garrosh initially has the upper hand and blames Thrall for his failures since Thrall picked him as Warchief, but Thrall countered that it was caused by his own choices. Thrall then kills Garrosh by using his elemental powers.

With the creator of the Iron Horde dead, the Alliance and Horde adventurers and their Draenor allies set to dismantle the Iron Horde. The adventurers storm into the Gorian Empire's capital of Highmaul to defeat the Iron Horde's allies. In the raid, the adventurers kill the Warlord of the Shattered Hand Clan, Kargath Bladefist. They proceed to slay the creations of the Gorian Empire, including the spellbreakers and the Sorcerer King Imperator Mar'Gok.

Later the Blackrock Clan, led by Warlord Blackhand, challenge the Horde and Alliance to assault their domain; the Blackrock Foundry. The adventurers take up the challenge by storming through the forge, destroying important Iron Horde machinery, and blocking further growth of the Iron Horde's weaponry. Finally, the adventurers arrive at Blackhand's crucible and slay him.

Next, Gul'dan confronts Grommash and the remnants of the Iron Horde. He again offers Grommash the blood of Mannoroth; Grommash not only refuses but also attacks Gul'dan but he is subdued by him. With Gul'dan's offer of ultimate power, Kilrogg Deadeye, the Warlord of the Bleeding Hollow Clan, ignores Grommash's warnings and drinks the demon blood. The fel blood corrupts Kilrogg, turning him into a monstrous fel orc. Gul'dan assumes control of the Iron Horde and Grommash is imprisoned. It is at this time that the adventurers, with the help of Khadgar, construct a naval fleet to invade Tanaan Jungle and take the fight to Hellfire Citadel to stop Gul'dan and his Iron Horde.

Throughout all this, Khadgar works alongside his bodyguard, the Night Elven Warden Cordana Felsong, to grant the Commander a powerful boon by helping them create a magical ring that will give them the edge they need to face Gul'Dan. Catching wind of their plan, Gul'Dan reveals that he has brainwashed the alternate version of Garona Halforcen and sends her to assassinate Khadgar and the Commander, but Garona is defeated and the spell over her is broken, allowing Khadgar and the Commander to not only gain her as a valuable ally, but also allow them to finish the ring. However, when the ring is finally completed, it is revealed that Cordana's doubts and frustrations with Khadgar's leadership, as well as corruption from a Shadow Orb she had recovered earlier, has allowed Gul'Dan to corrupt and brainwash her just as he did Garona, and the fallen Warden attempts to steal the ring on Gul'Dan's orders. The Commander defeats Cordana, but she escapes.

In the Hellfire Citadel raid, the adventurers slay Kilrogg and remnants of the Iron Horde. When confronted, Gul'dan resurrects Mannoroth only for the adventurers to kill him and free Grommash, who actually joins them. Gul'dan then summons Archimonde to invade Draneor and, with Yrel and Grommash's help, the adventurers kill him too. At the end of the battle, Archimonde in his final moment flings Gul'dan through a portal to Azeroth of the main timeline in order to fulfill his pact with the Legion, setting the stage for the next expansion."

i know my cross revaing two complately worlds but this was my best thought of time travel and how it would nopt change the timeline

"The alternate universe of the Warlords of Draenor expansion already existed prior to Kairoz and Garrosh's arrival. However, their arrival 35 years into the past of this universe has changed the course of history for this timeline."

But never changed the main timeline.


I think that princess Celestia and princess Luna couldn't protect the land by them-selves, so in that case they would be powerless  against the evil that is still in the land. speaking of that any pony at any time could become evil anywhere, it would be impossible<br>for them to get to one side of the world to the other. So in my case of theory the land would become evil and sad, and it would be forgotten.

I think that princess Celestia and princess Luna couldn't protect the land by them-selves, so in that case they would be powerless  against the evil that is still in the land. speaking of that any pony at any time could become evil anywhere, it would be impossible
for them to get to one side of the world to the other. So in my case of theory the land would become evil and sad, and it would be forgotten.


Hey sawtooth waves i got two theorys for you
1.if celestia, luna, cadence,twilight, and flurry heart are all considered princesses then whos the king and queen of equestira and can there be a king/prince so far in equestria history there has been no sign of a stallion ruler shure theres shining armor but other than him theres no good king/prince.

2. why is the human cadance the dean instead of princible after all pony cadance is ruler of the crystal empire and if the human pricible sinch is princible of crystal prep then what does that make the pony sinch.


I mean the only way they could of possibly split into the new timeline is if someone saw them and as a result their life was altered thats the only way that could possibly be possible


Would flurry heart still break the crystal heart if twilight spike and starlight were gone?


A prediction that is wanting us to protect the sacred timeline


I think they returned into the normal timeline because it’s impossible for them not just to return


I've been thinking<br>what if g5 is in the first timeline and that's why ponies live separately from each other, because there is no Twilight anymore

I've been thinking
what if g5 is in the first timeline and that's why ponies live separately from each other, because there is no Twilight anymore


I never even thought of this, this is so sad :((
why don't I just nameless it

I never even thought of this, this is so sad :((
*why don't I just nameless it*


Wouldnt they asked discord? I think its safe to assume that discord would be their last resort if they didnt find twilight spike and starlight themselves?


Aw heck yeah! Double bug Queen timeline.


“celestia would have to find a replacement for twilight” <b>thoughts abt sunset shimmer</b>

“celestia would have to find a replacement for twilight” *thoughts abt sunset shimmer*


No, twilight just time traveled back to the present. There is no posibility that twilight was gone in that alternated universe since they just time traveled back when they were just little foals so that multiverse is just doing as fine....


I just figured it was similar to how Marvel did their time travel


There’s one issue with this theory <br>Where is the twilight, starlight and spike of the new timeline they came into? Because if the timeline they came into would have to be an exact copy so twilight, spike and starlight wouldn’t notice. So if they were a copy there would have to be a original twilight, spike and starlight in this timeline. What happned?

There’s one issue with this theory
Where is the twilight, starlight and spike of the new timeline they came into? Because if the timeline they came into would have to be an exact copy so twilight, spike and starlight wouldn’t notice. So if they were a copy there would have to be a original twilight, spike and starlight in this timeline. What happned?


I honestly don’t think the Crystal Heart would be destroyed because first of all, Twilight offered she’d watch Flurry Heart with Pinkie and second she put both Pinkie and Flurry in a bubble because Flurry was flying around crazy and when she separated Pinkie and Flurry she started to cry which caused the heart to be destroyed but if Twilight wasn’t there, someone else would watch Flurry which might not cause her to destroy the Crystal Heart


“Just being there could change the timeline.”

Flash intensifies

“Just being there could change the timeline.”

*Flash intensifies*


They shouldve gone back and edited the original episode, making it so in a flash in the background u can see the three standing on a cloud


technically all the stuff they did to try to fix it actually wouldn't make another timeline the only stuff that WOULD make a timeline is the major stuff when starlight prevented the rainboom <br>all the stuff with twilight preventing it already happened to put it simply when you go back to the past and go back to the present nothing will change as you have already made those changes if that makes sense so when twilight persuaded starilight they would just go back to the same present

technically all the stuff they did to try to fix it actually wouldn't make another timeline the only stuff that WOULD make a timeline is the major stuff when starlight prevented the rainboom
all the stuff with twilight preventing it already happened to put it simply when you go back to the past and go back to the present nothing will change as you have already made those changes if that makes sense so when twilight persuaded starilight they would just go back to the same present


Whell that is one of the Darkest things or Theories or possibilities I've ever heard dame.


Now i understand why Equestria lost the magic in the next movie))

Саша Кузнецов


Hear me out in my little pony a new generation the unicorns magic is gone If cozy glow succeeded could that be the reason the magic is gone


What if the other world have a new mane six?


I'm just waiting for the TVA to come pick up Starlight Glimmer for crimes against the sacred timeline


Does that make the original timeline is now a alternate universe?


Sci-twi would probably take Twilight’s place


But if that's true, then the alternated timeline should have two Twilight, Starlight, and Spike


The 1st would become what we know as a rogue world as the temp goes lower and lower below -100 C


So if original Twilight ended up in alternate timeline number 9, where is the twilight from alternate timeline 9?


Twilight other time line lives and also the reason discord was released from stone caused the main six Bonded with the Elements of Harmony so how did he escape in the new timeline


This is where Disney got ideas for the Loki series 💅


I can’t believe I didn’t notice this-

THANK YOU


If there was a 9th timeline, there would be 2 twilights in the world, both would be alicorns cuz there is the castle and mane 6, so I'm pretty sure that there isn't a 9th timeline


I wanna write a fanfic about the abandoned timeline now...


"oh I have a time travel question why don't I just Nameless it" 😂😂😂😂😂 I died laughing


I like to think it’s another “Bootstrap Paradox” type deal again.


Sawtooth Starlight was in Cozy Glow’s plan bc she was trapped in the orb thingy


Ahahaha oh man I love Nameless just showing up annoyed like LEAVE ME ALONE


(Spoiler alert) after I watched the episodes of Loki from avengers on Disney+ I noticed that there were time travel guards apparently??. But imagine if that happened with the ponies as well and with discord that would be a huge twist!


There's also nothing that says they dont travel to the original timeline. Sure, when heading to the future, we see multiple timelines, duh. But, this could be attributed to malice. Maybe there's some other half of the spell or so that shows that they returned to the original timeline. We don't know, because we can't really see it ourselves.
What I propose is that the "Forgotten Timeline" Is the one they return to. Or, in other words, the only difference between the timelines is someone came from somewhere, then disappeared without another thought. Nothing more, nor less.

The Original Timeline stays the same, the one we see, the one we watch, etc. and it goes on with everyone at hand.
The "Forgotten Timeline"- in my case, the top bar in his diagram- is the one with the extra three who appear and disappear for a few moments.

Honestly, I have a whole theory on timelines and universes and yahyahyah, but, too much for one comment, and especially since it doesn't fully relate to the video. But, perhaps at some point I can make a response, with art of m'own, just to discuss. It is an interesting topic, after all.

Also, to note, if it seems I trample over myself with the way I explained something, or if I come across as a broken record, I do apologize. ADHD is a helluva mental disorder, and it's hard to get my thoughts out properly 'cause of it.

Thank you for reading ze wall of text. Have a wonderful day/night/timezones're weird~!
~~Snowhead W. Blitz

Edit: I also forgot to say- and since TheStarryArcher1213 said it and reminded me- we see no doubles of Starlight, Twilight, or Spike, so that's a point to going back to the original timeline. The Tree Map also seemed to be connected to the spell, so it could be that the tree itself corrected where they would end up. It's called the Tree of Harmony, it probably has some play in the balance of time.


But at the crystaling pinkie was taken by twilight into a different bubble from fluffy heart, if twilight wasn’t there then they wouldn’t have been separated and the heart would not have been broken


The "bad future" idea remined me of a very old game... Sonic CD.


“Do I look like a search engine? Oh I have a time traveling question let’s just nameless it”


What if it was the same and starlight with the scroll can make them invisible?


i think hasbro just put how we understand time travel concept back in when we were kids, since this show is made for kids


I have a question for you. This has nothing to do with this video but something to do with the g5 movie ( had to comment on this because comments are turned off on the other one). What happened to all the different creatures? What happened to the dragons, hippogriffs, griffins, changlings, and all the others?


@Sawtooth Waves YES THE ALICORN PRINCESS HAS POSTED!

@Sawtooth Waves OO OO I, as a nonbinary, MADE A NONBINARY TERM FOR KING/QUEEN!!
Zing

@Sawtooth Waves OO OO I, as a nonbinary, MADE A NONBINARY TERM FOR KING/QUEEN!!
*Zing*

I'm more of an alicorn princess really 🤔


I figured out were all the elements of disharmony are. Ther in another dimension. The one were all the people are the opposite. So if everybody is opposite that means all the magic artifacts must be opposite


Another possibility is that they were there the entire time but we're never seen until now as time is a tricky and changing the past isn't truly possible unless you can perceive a way to prevent the impending paradox that comes with it cause if you change the past then you create an instance where you never needed to go back in time in the first place, if you see where I'm going with this then good on you, thus thus such an action would cause a distortion in reality, which may be what those alternate timelines are


Wait- this is very random but-

If they went to a different timeline then where are the Twilight, Spike and Starlight from that timeline?
Would they be in the timeline that was abandoned or smt-
This is making me confused


The time chrysalis attached twilight was not a princess yet so this has nothing to do with this part because twilight would of disappeared after chrysalis tried to take over the crystal empire.


Dear Celestia, this is darker than Nightmare Moon's night 😐😥


What if, the abandon world is the world we see in gen 6?! (Forgot If its 5 or 6) if magic was drained for equestrian by cozy glow? I don’t know how they would get the gems, but it’s just a theory 👌


There is a series I'm reading where Rainbow Dash Saw the Trio of time travelers Everything changed. Little Glimpses


Maybe other heroes would intervene , we have no parameters to tell all events would be the same  or develop the same, maybe at the moment twilight disappear new heroes rise up.


Ngl, this was really chilling to think about... The original world would've gone into chaos.. It's also to think about how Twilight's friends would finally figure out.

Edit: Wait! I just got a theory from a comment I saw. So, what if they went to another timeline like you said but the other Twilight & Starlight in the timeline they just went to, went to their timeline. (Aka, before the Starlight time travel thing) They had a big switch a woo because two of the same pony can't live in the same world

(Please don't point out Equestria Girls and that incident at the end of Friendship Games. I'm not really sure what happened after that)


This is the only theory where I hope to Luna that you’re wrong


What if the past timeline was already in the present timeline that made the future-present timeline


Can king sombra's future still look bright?


Ok so I love to draw MLP stuff from bases and stuff so im making that the main 5 would look like after twi glimmer and spike went missing


I believe it is the time line were everything is gone,the event already took place


That thumbnail jump scared me LMAOOOO 😂😂😂

It's freaking me out right now, and I was trying to go to sleep now😂🥲


Flurry wouldnt have cried and killed the crystal heart because she cried cause she was separated from pinky, just an opinion


discord couldve stepped up in the first timeline if it was abandoned, hes like s god he can fix anything lmao


What if the  new generation  is that time line...


It could explain the plot for the new movie


What if this the timeline, the movie takes place in, Think about it. I would make sense, after the sisters' grew to old or passed on the once strong connections started to break and With Twilight's disappearance, they could very well grow warry of each other, heck Cozy glow could have become the leader of the Pegasus. And also why Sun has figures of Twilight as the same size as the other main six instead of her towering image, because she we last seen as that size.


I think that in the original timeline... there were three extra spectators.


We saw the effects of those three not being there eg. King sombra take over, the changlings with the other ponyville pony’s, that’s just a guess tho but it could have been true and only because Twilight visited those timelines she’s still known by her friends


what if mlp g5 takes place in the "forgetten world". I like the theory that u came up with in ur most recent video but what if the reason why the three pony tribes weren't together was because of twilight,spike and starlight being missing? It might be a stretch...


Daaannnng…
Never thought of it like that…
Didn’t even realize they technically left their old timeline

I just imagine are just doing their thing and then they find Twilight and Spike MISSING they put up posters all over Equestria but it doesn't matter they vanished Into Thin Air they learn to move on celestia can't find another Apprentice and that's the world that G5 is in it's really kind of dark if you think about it


I know a new timeline<br>Where the pink Pegasus is desperate as twilight was when she wants to learn magic

I know a new timeline
Where the pink Pegasus is desperate as twilight was when she wants to learn magic


Headcanon : the Last timeline wich had nothing and just empty space was the one they originally left and the rainboom had nothing To do with it. That is just the equestrua if twilight wasn't there


Time travel is very VEEEEEEEEERY different in the my little pony universe so yes they did connect back together and there is no ‘forgotten world’ how do I know this??? Because I watched it over and over again before I saw it it’s complicated to explain and also I’m saying this so nobody (ehem) or pony would get they’re childhood destroyed like blowed up by TNT so hope that helps :D

Time travel is very VEEEEEEEEERY different in the my little pony universe so *yes* they did connect back together and there is no ‘forgotten world’ how do I know this??? Because I watched it over and over again before I saw it it’s complicated to explain and also I’m saying this so nobody (ehem) or *pony* would get they’re childhood destroyed like blowed up by TNT so hope that helps :D


I think they go back to the original timeline when Twilight go to Canterlot High to response the Sunset Shimer call from the frienship games.<br>Or this is the timeline where the Human Sunset Shimmer go, to equilibrate the twiligt absense. Even the human Starlight can be here in the abandoned timeline.

I think they go back to the original timeline when Twilight go to Canterlot High to response the Sunset Shimer call from the frienship games.
Or this is the timeline where the Human Sunset Shimmer go, to equilibrate the twiligt absense. Even the human Starlight can be here in the abandoned timeline.


I love it how you upload right as I get in bed to chill

Brb getting my snacks too 💕


What if this is the timeline where cozy glow does drain magic from mlp world into equestria girls world and thats why they lost the magic in the new generation but they got magic back bc someone in equestria girls world went into mlp world?


Wait... Nameless? Timelines? Different worlds? You wouldn't have happened to have read the Crystal Ball Trilogy by RQK, have you?
Edit: nevermind, saw the pinned comment, explained it to me
(Though I would still recommend reading that trilogy as the 2nd story plays with the alternate timelines idea)

as a reading? I'm not sure but I don't think so. You can find it here: https://www.fimfiction.net/user/208413/RQK/stories starting with "Feedback"


The original timeline if there is one it would be the timeline of the new generation because twilight sacraficed herself but it could be just a myth.


I can morph into you maybe I could add in the argument that the tarorous dog didn't give it powers at all because it had to be calmed down this would make a weak stat and the magic would have been easily taken by force twilight did that ofc and the gate guard dogs separated.


Here’s a theory! ( SPOILERS FOR THE MLP GEN 5 MOVIE!! ) so in the movie we figure out that something happened to the main six that made earth pony’s, unicorns, and Pegasus separated and lose their magic, blaming it on each other. So what if this movie wasn’t only taking place in the future but also in that abandoned universe? With out Twilight the other 5 wouldn’t have their six element and leader. Twilight won’t be able to rule of that universe like she did with the one we see her in, at the end of gen 4. In the movie we know that the main 6 had to have been famous for something as Sunny ( the protagonist in gen 5 ) has toy dolls of the main six, it would make sense that the main 6 would be famous even before this happened. God this is confusing 😅 sorry if the explanation is bad! I’m not so good at explaining <3


imagine this connects to generation 5 XD


Thats a really good and interesting theory.


Wait if that’s the 9 world, how do her friends know who starlight and twilight are? 🤔

Everything else is the same, so maybe they just got dumped into a reality where the spell just killed their counterparts.


If twilight never went behind starlight , starlight would go to another time and everything will be the same BUT! without starlight equestria would be doomed😑🙄


There may be a 10th timeline as well. Since Starlight also traveled to when she was a filly

Another bit of possible indication of that is. Starlight remembers Sunburst shoving her aside and when she showed Twilight he didn't. Either she exaggerated when retelling it to Spike, or time traveling to Sire's Hollow changed things.


That explains why Sombra sounds so bad in the newer episodes


I love this it sounds so realistic but it scared me so much like bro


Also, at 3:11 isn’t starlight missing as well? From the forgotten time line?


But wouldnt there be an alternate twilight when they made the copy timeline-


What if the last timeline was THE FUTURE? I have my own little theory.

The dry, apocalyptic timeline? That was the future. Starlight is one of the most powerful unicorns. Equestria would no longer be. Instead, in G5, it was A DIFFERENT PLACE. After the apocalypse all the ponies left. How, exactly, did this apocalypse come? War. So, Twilight's dead in this last `timeline`. Sunset, instead, was the ruler. Princess Sunset still had that evil inside her... And it showed. She started a war with...  Surprise! ALL THE OTHER SPECIES. Yeah. So the other species lost. All deceased. And by the evil that Sunset still had, the apocalypse was made. She decimated Equestria. So the ponies moved to a new place. New Equestria. And after that G5.
Tell me what you think! Thank you for listening to my TED-Talk.


Ben 10 Omniverse: Only we had guts to imply that the original timeline is dead/long forgotten

MLP S6 Finale: Hold my hay


The first one is correct cuz if she did come back to the same timeline she would be old because she was all fully grown in that time so ur correct...


I never even thought about it like that…woah. That’s pretty deep..


Imagine he jus figured out why G5 has only 5 main characters,


Maybe the completely barren one we saw might be the one they left behind


Maybe g5 is taking place in the original timeline? Like, the disapearence of the princess of friendship would drive all the pony races into paranoia and distrust? Idk


Imagen if that abandoned time line is where G5 play out. That's just a theory that came to my mind when I heard you said that about the abounded timeline. I just find it interesting and working if that was possible.

(This probably won't be noticed but if that could be a working theory I would liked to see a video about it if it's a possible theory)


Maybe time travel will literally just put in three identical clones and everything goes on the same


They will found out that Starswirl's spell has been stolen


If princess celestia had to found a new student I believe she would choose moon dancer


@RandomShadow555 your boyfriend to!?That's so cool!

Me, my friends, not to mention MY BOYFRIEND


Dear sawtooth did you know there are 195 episodes in MLP on Netflix


One of the laws of quantum mechanics says that just observing an event will change the event so...probably. just look at dragon ball


Could the forgotten timeline have lead to the events of the next generation movie and the change of location on the map associated with it due to the events of the crystalline and potentially the frozen north spreading??? Just a thought.


If you are sad, i am too. But i have created a perfectly logical and short explanation of how they still came back to their original time line.<br>Nopony saw them right? If so, the only thing that would really change is the hoof prints on the cloud. Which isnt a big deal. Easy peasy lemon squeezy.

If you are sad, i am too. But i have created a perfectly logical and short explanation of how they still came back to their original time line.
Nopony saw them right? If so, the only thing that would really change is the hoof prints on the cloud. Which isnt a big deal. Easy peasy lemon squeezy.


I always wanted to see a timeline where Cozy glow, Tirek , and Queen Chrysalis took over Equestria and I  think this might be it. Here me out, if Chrysalis took over Equestria Cozy glow would still most likely pen pal Tirek and have tried to drain all magic from Equestria. and maybe before she could finish she was discovered by a changeling guard/solder and taken to Chrysalis who allowed her to do it under the condition that changelings get to keep there magic or something and Cozy was successful and it allowed the changelings to keep an even more firm grip on the ponies now being the only ones with magic. As thanks Chrysalis let Cozy become her royal adviser and Cozy  told her that Tirek had told her how to drain all magic from Equestria and Cozy now has a reason to break him out of Tartarus and bring him back. After that this mostly progress like in our timeline Cozy glow still forces them into a weird family dynamic and things go on as normal. Same ending, completely different circumstances. What do you think? 😊

I'd love a comeback of Cozy Glow, Tirek and Queen Chrysalis no matter how it happens. Chrysalis is such a delightful evil queen.


What about twilight being an alicorn wouldn’t everyone freak out about the 4th Allicorn not counting flurry


SAWTOOTH I HAVE A QUESTION:"so in the episode where all of the cutie marks are switched pinkie has trouble on the farm.so how does she connect with earth?she's she's party planner but she is an earth pony that has nothing to do with land?pls do a video explaining this.


Oh my goodness dimensions don't work like that every dimension has its own present pass and future this is impossible I know a lot about stuff like this my dad claims to be from another dimention so I hear a lot about stuff like this


What if there was a timeline with cozy glow and nightmare rarity


nightmare moon  wouldnt have been stopped and celestia would still be in the moon


Unless a timeline where they weren't there to see the rainboom never existed and this was always destined to happen


I think the forgotten world ends up as the barren wasteland world where there is nothing


The thing I don’t get about this is that if they were in a different world where is that world’s twilight, starlight, and, spike


The studio that only made a kids show without thinking of anything: AHHHHH- (Inspired by another comment)


The original timeline branched off into Gen 5


What if I told you that that was how the rainboom happens all along


The "voice acting" ruins it, both in writing and in execution. Just tell us your case normally. Voice acting only works when you've got the experience to do it. This isn't the case.


If there was a second timeline then cozy glow wouldn’t want power and the magic of friendship because first we saw Cozy glow when she was crying by a tree asking for help cmc do you really think she will want that power

Yes she saw how powerful friendship is at twilight's school but if twilight wasn't there then even the school wouldn't be there I think and even the artifacts wouldn't be there in the school<br>Sorry if I made any spelling mistakes

Yes she saw how powerful friendship is at twilight's school but if twilight wasn't there then even the school wouldn't be there I think and even the artifacts wouldn't be there in the school
Sorry if I made any spelling mistakes


Maybe someone else saved the crystal empire?


What if in the original universe, twilight and starlight were there, like it was supposed to happen or something, idk


this is unrelated but in that one episode where pinkie pie made duplicates of herself and they had a test to find out whos the real one what if they brought away the wrong pinkie pie and the current pinkie isnt the pinkie from the beginning


What if the og timeline is when MLP a new generation takes place....just a thought


That timeline is already deleted from existence


Also don’t you think that in this different timeline where they were present wouldn’t there be 2 twilights 2 spikes and 2 starlights each doing what they were originally doing


or its part of the original time line that there is 3 more spectater there because lets be honest we are watching the rainboom from ranbowdashs perspective i dont think she will notice 3 spectaters while in a race also if it was a diffrent timeline the map will send them back it knows what its doing


I've seen something like this before. Have you played red alert in your childhood well the same thing happened. After WW2 in 1946 Einstein created a machine called the paradox device it's basically a Time machine, so what he did was kill Hitler in 1924 many years before his rise to power. By doing a hand shake with Hitler Einstein was sent back to 1946 his timeline but he accidentally created a new alternate universe The red alert timeline. In this new timeline WW2 happens but the Reich did not start the war but it was the Soviet union that started the war if you played the games and other Command and conquer games Tiberian and generals you will know.


What if the three from the new timeline got put in the old timeline.


But what if it was all destined to happen, because they are in the timeline with the spectators from begin with.  <br>It’s just a loop.

But what if it was all destined to happen, because they are in the timeline with the spectators from begin with.
It’s just a loop.


The thing is, where did the twilight spike and starlight from the “new and current” timeline?


Sawtooth: Nameless!
Nameless: what is it?
Sawtooth: if you go back in time and return without changing anything, does it still branch of into it's own timeline?
Nameless: so you want to know the secrets of time itself now, huh? Do I look like a search engine to you? Oh! I have a time travel question. Let's NAMELESS it.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 It was sooooo funny 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

What about when their name is already a verb?

I've Rainbow Dashed myself into some tight spots before...

I guess verbing people is just a thing now.

*insert Twilighting joke here*

I guess verbing people is just a thing now.

**insert Twilighting joke here**


What if the last timeline we saw was the first timeline result of no twilight spike and starlight


Wait a minute, sawtooth you are still in the first timeline so you should know if it changed since you and didn't go with twilight,Spike, and starlight .  So if they are in your timeline than you will get your answer and don't need nameless to answer it . Sorry, I just thought about this after watching the video also your the best! 😅🙂


In the mirror thing when pinkie cloned herself they kill the real pinkie. Proof is- the pinkie that survived told the clone story that she went in the water to clone herself- the real pinkie pie never touched the water.. she pulled the clone out of the water…..


Your theories are so good I suggest you make theories of miraculous ladybug (short form mlb )

As they say even the smallest things done in miraculous is done for a reason


About to start get ayaka she can wait this is more important

I was on the grind for two days, just so I could finish the Archon quests and even get to Inazuma. I'm finally there, and yeah, I took a break just to watch Saw's new vid. Worth it

@Raptor Zeraora thank you lmao I typed too fast


probably not,if so where would the Twillight,Spike,and Starlight of this new timeline theyve arrived be?

Best case scenario:The timelines merged again.
Worst case scenario:the spike,twilight,and starlight of this 9th AU are on the 1st universe OUR spike,twi,and starlight left from.


Can we pretend that airplanes in the night sky are like shooting stars?


I think that they did a reverse spell to redo and then,it's still the same timeline/world


But if they are now in a new timeline then what about the spike twilight and starlight of this new timeline?

Seems just as likely another some and Twilight could have replaced them in the original timeline. Still interesting fiction fuel


A little change in history can snow ball  for future twilight said it herself clearly there is a wasteland  time line a time line we’re there is nothing
But what if it was the forgotten time line without the element of magics without twilight what could the world turn into well a wasteland
There is more proof but the wasteland and forgotten timeline click together I know the forgotten timeline should include twilight sparkle ✨
Friends but what if they lose hope loosing a person who you care about so much they would pass away but without  the main 6 the barriers
Of the elements of harmony nobody stopping the villains that will come after the world will become a wasteland  no princess celestia no Luna
Because looking at there ruined world they would pass away even before passing away celestia could not have tried  to look for new barriers
The main6 were the only barriers in that time and the students in friendship school 🏫 could never be next in line to become the barriers
So I think the forgotten timeline and wasteland timeline are one
Sawtooth plz put this theory in the next video
😜😜😜😜


I think it is all spikes fault if he had not picked star swirls magic spell than... everything whould go just fine


But... I think they went back to the present... because... the events went as it went at the end. So their present is the same.


Time travel is officially the thing that give you ever you want to go 5


It's just a idea, but now that we've see the film, maybe the G5 is the timeline abandonned by Twilight, Spike and Starlight.<br>In the movie, the three species of pony live apart and the magic is gone. Prehaps after the Twilight's demise, the Mane 6 failed to stabilize and federate friendship and has Twilight faded his element of harmony completely lost his magic causing the other in the process.

It's just a idea, but now that we've see the film, maybe the G5 is the timeline abandonned by Twilight, Spike and Starlight.
In the movie, the three species of pony live apart and the magic is gone. Prehaps after the Twilight's demise, the Mane 6 failed to stabilize and federate friendship and has Twilight faded his element of harmony completely lost his magic causing the other in the process.

The Unicorns moves to the ancient Ponyville, now covered to the Everfree forest. The Pegasus settled in the high Montains and rebuild the old Canterlot. And the terrestrials building a small town by thé sea.
The centuries pass and the old Equestria, the Crystals and the Mane 6 are now only  historys, and tales and legends that are told to the young foals.
The three species have a boundless hatred towards each other.
Only a stalion and his daugther Sunny still believe that friendship is possible between all ponies. So, begins the G5 movie !
So what do you think ? Do you think it's good ?
Sorry for my vocabulory language, I am french 😅😊.

A semblance of Harmony is then established. But being afraid, the ponies no longer speaks to other creatures (goodbye yaks, dragons, griffins or other...). We Can imagine that the descendant of Mane 6 took over after a while and in turn protects the crystals. But conflicts begin to set in and more than once the crystals have been nearly stolen or destroyed. For more security, the descendant (Unicorn, Pegasus and terrestrials) decide to separate them, One species each taking its own and each settling in a different city.

Mane 6 then brings back the crystals and announces the death of the princesses. The fear is then much stronger and more present in Equestria, but the Mane 6 more or less manages to control all that. We Can imagine that one part or another Sunset and Tempest Shadow will join them for help. Sunset no longer to able to use magic in human World, would use the last shards she has to somehow get back to Equestria and get stuck here. Tempest, first sent by the Storm king to steal the magic, will notice that no longer exists and stay with the Mane 6 for protect the three crystals.

On Cadance advice, they shapes them and incorporates what remains of the Pegasus, terrestrial and Unicorns Magic. Celestia, Luna and Discord will die in the process.

The stars are completely out of control, circling around Equestria without magical insistence. <br>In addition, the Everfree forest begins to invade them ! Then looking the for clues, they all go to the tree of Harmony. If the other elements still works just a little. Twilight's element broke. Seeing no other solutions, the Princesses, the Mane 6 and Discord travel thé Cristal empire. They choose three cristals (when the cristals unite at the end of the movie, it looks like the Northern Light when the cristal heart activates.)

The stars are completely out of control, circling around Equestria without magical insistence.
In addition, the Everfree forest begins to invade them ! Then looking the for clues, they all go to the tree of Harmony. If the other elements still works just a little. Twilight's element broke. Seeing no other solutions, the Princesses, the Mane 6 and Discord travel thé Cristal empire. They choose three cristals (when the cristals unite at the end of the movie, it looks like the Northern Light when the cristal heart activates.)

In fact, it's not that he no longer control her, he loses her ! Other events are noticed too. Pegasus can no longer fly, land ponys lose their forces and Unicorns no longer have Magic. Even Celestia and Luna can not control the sun and the moon.

The proof, we don't even talk about the wendigos in the movie. They don't even seem to exist ! And we don't even know if a Unicorn can raises the moon or the sun ! We don't talk about it at all !
So, here's my theory :
Maybe after the Twilight's demise, Equestria descends into chaos. But not one of Discord can create and control ! This chaos is none other than Fear. Keeping her cool to a minimum, Celestia ask to the Mane 6 and Discord to find Twilight. Several weeks, then months, then years pass. The purple alicorn and the little dragon are not found. Even Discord can't do it. Moreover, he noticed than the more time passes, the less he manages to control his magic.


Well even if they did go back to a different one you're assuming a new timeline was created meaning there is another twilight there an that twilight just going to do the exact same thing and the twilight will keep moving universes,/timeline for every


And things were never the same again.....


Oh hell! What if the Original Timeline is G5?!


Umm, mr sawtooth. Do you know that camp everfree has sunsets shimmers element? But in the actual pony world there is only 6 elements? Even though there just parralel universe


...welp, time to scrounge fimfiction for the continued original timelime


What if in the original timeline Twilight sparkle spike and starlight were there.


what about the original twiling spike and starling in the current timeline or the timeline they teleported to shoudnt there be another spike twiling and starling there


What if... the abandoned timeline IS THE TIMELINE G5 IS FROM?! THAT WOULD COMPLETELY EXPLAIN WHY TWILIGHT JUST ISN'T THERE , BUT THE MANE 6 ARE STILL REMEMBERED!

AND IT ALSO EXPLAINS WHY THE CRYSTAL EMPIRE ISN'T IN G5 BECAUSE IT WAS DESTROYED WHEN FLURRY BROKE THE CRYSTAL HEART!

Not to mention, Equestria without Twilight is like the Whoniverse without the Doctor. Everything would fall apart as soon as these particular individuals were removed.

What if... the abandoned timeline IS THE TIMELINE G5 IS FROM?! THAT WOULD COMPLETELY EXPLAIN WHY TWILIGHT JUST ISN'T *THERE* , BUT THE MANE 6 ARE STILL REMEMBERED!

AND IT ALSO EXPLAINS WHY THE CRYSTAL EMPIRE ISN'T IN G5 BECAUSE IT WAS DESTROYED WHEN FLURRY BROKE THE CRYSTAL HEART!

Not to mention, Equestria without Twilight is like the Whoniverse without the Doctor. Everything would fall apart as soon as these particular individuals were removed.


I don't think there is a 9th time line. They are in their own time line. They are home


Plot twist: The abandoned world was actually the world of the new MLP generation, G5.


What if the other same timelines twilight‚starlight and sike came into the original timeline


The original time line is the New mlp series! Generation 5 😱


What if when spike, starlight and twilight we're gone Celestia would have to find a new replacement for Twilight and that is Sunset Shimmer so thats why in the equestria girls Sunset Shimmer is part of the six elements. :>


I understand this, but the world twilight traveled to, would have the same events that happened so, doesn’t that mean, that the world twilight originally came    from, would have the twilight from the other world, if so nothing changed except different twilight’s would go into different worlds.


This vid:sawtooth asks nameless about time travel<br>100moons before G5:"pinkie seems to be pinkie regardless "sawtooth said

This vid:sawtooth asks nameless about time travel
100moons before G5:"pinkie seems to be pinkie regardless "sawtooth said


Well... one option is that no new future is created but the past itself is altered. Think loop movie. When finger is cut from young you the old one loses it but it may not have the memory or the memories come back depending on the person. Instead of new world the previous one is altered. Like in game setting game on peaceful and all hostile mosnsters buffed away. When you set normal back the monster you named Woll is back. Or turning between online and offline in dark souls, your friend is still your friend :^)


Btw u forgot that the new main six also wouldn’t come because twilight wouldn’t open the school and the tribes wouldn’t come and that concludes to no new tree house :(


But also it wouldn’t make sense because if it was a different time line then there would be another twilight unless the both twilights from both dimensions both traveled together and switched time line in that case everything would still be normal just twilight starlight and spike have swiped time lines


I think it turned to be g6 when all ponies split in to 3 tribes unicorn, earth pornies, and pegaside they all fought till sunny saved the tribes bye becoming a alicorn.


I think this theory is right, BUT I think that other twilight the twilight from a bit of the past went to the original timeline and all went the same with that it isn't the same twilight but there is one and our twilight is on another universe


if they went to the present of the alternate timeline in and the world is saved and everything's fine then where did the twilight from the alternate timeline go to?


Wouldn't there be another twilight in the new time line twilight is in


yayyyyyyy<br>sawtooth i love ur videos so much

yayyyyyyy
sawtooth i love ur videos so much


How was Discord able to break free of his stone prison in the discord timeline since the reason he did break free was because the CMC were arguing which created enough chaos to set him free and the CMC would never form because they only did when they attended diamond tiara’s party which was hosted at the sugar cube corner which would be out of business without pinkie pie’s influence since the only reason she moved to ponyvile was to spread laughter to the citizens there. Ugh, guess I better Nameless it.


Maybe you can do a theory on the mlp after life?


The timeline might be the wasteland.. with the villans, all the snow, and an element short.. the universe, the ponies, Equestria.. is destroyed. And G5 never exists..


But were are the originals Twilights? I mean in each Timeline is a Twilight, right?


Do you think all the villains would fight for who becomes equestrias ruler and then Princess celestia will have her chance to defeat the weakened villain that survived😳


The real time line must be a queen chrysalis time line how I didn’t know that that time line was a fake time line?


It’s to sad to believe this and i don’t believe this theory I believed every other theory except for this I think they went back to the original world


9 Universes... 9 seasons. Coincidence? Probably


"why dont I just NAMELESS it"<br>(I swear that made me laugh- nameless is a master of sarcasm-)

"why dont I just NAMELESS it"
(I swear that made me laugh- nameless is a master of sarcasm-)


maybe the abandon world could be the place where the new generation starts with sunny , pip, hich ... who knows


SAWTOOTH I HAVE HUGE NEWS ABOUT HOW THE PORTAL TO THE HUMAN WORLD WORKS!!! THE DIAMOND DOGS THAT KIDNAPPED RARITY TURN INTO HUMANS IF THEY CROSS THE PORTAL!!!! I was rewatching the movie Rainbow Rocks and at time 28:41 I saw the dogs AS HUMANS!!!! PLSSSSS SEE THIS!!! I'm really shocked abt this cause i thought that they would just turn into dogs


nah that ain't happening, cuz there will be two twilights in this world - adult and kid, adult returned  to the main timeline and twilight as a kid get's a cutie mark


Well what happened to the new timeline’s twilight,starlight and spike? Did they also make new timelines?


OR the og timeline had the trio when the rainbow boom happened! they were returning to og timeline, branching it off on one moment. what if they were meant to go back there and do this, because thats what really happened?


Wait wait wait sometimes time travel is twisted so he could be right….

-ℝ𝕠𝕓𝕚𝕟.𝔹𝕦𝕔𝕜𝕝𝕖𝕪-


I think this connects to the lost pinkie pie, think about it maybe she was sent there? Just a theory! :)

Edit talking about the missing pinkie pie theory


Starlight is dead? that might actually be good news. but Twilight and Spike? Equestria needs those two...


I think if it would be true then there would be a other twilight bc maybe that twilight may have gone to the original if this theory is true and maybe they just switched places maybe


What about the friendship games? OUR twilight came through the EQG portal and told the humane six+human twilight about her time traveling adventure.


What about sunset shimmer what about equestria girls


Just image flutter she’s face when she realizes that their gone


Wait, idk about spike, but little Twilight and Starlight was already at that timeline, so wouldn’t there be two of them each?


But then there would be 2 Twilights in that timeline.


My favorite quote "why don't I just Nameless it?!"


the "original" timeline just may not exist because how could it exist if it's past didn't happen


Hold on, if there are multiple alternate universe, wouldnt there be alternate timelines for the human world? If so i assume it has something to do with something happening to sunset as she brung the two worlds together. However it may have domething to do with the human worlds ORIGINAL sunset.


I am late, but I got a Loki add before this video, maybe Equestria needs a TPA (Time Pony Authority) to get rid of those extra timeline


Well I don't think that the rainboom will bring them back to there own timeline because when starlight stop  rainbow dash to make the rainboom the others have gone ahead and that will affect the timeline when they both of the rainbow from the original  and the copied world they have make the rainboom in a different time. So that means they are still in the copied world but they just skip all the way to the to there original place in the copied world.

Wait that make me think do the copied timeline twilight went to the past just like the original twilight.


Normally I would comment on my main account, but I don't have access to it at the moment. When there's little to no variance in a, what do you call, timeline, we'll call them timeline A and timeline B, they do merge back together. This is because the divergence number hasn't changed significantly. Everything continues normal in both of them. You would perceive this as I merge. It's very difficult to explain this in a way individuals like yourself can understand it, but if you have any further questions don't hesitate to reach out to me


At first I was like
Ok, kind of a reach, the video ends in the first 20 seconds.
But then I was like
bro


What would happen to sunset shimmer???<br>For god's sake she's the best character and she literally travel's between time and space!😤💔

What would happen to sunset shimmer???
For god's sake she's the best character and she literally travel's between time and space!😤💔


Idk but maybe Sunset Shimmer may replays Twilight but different wayyyyy different or somebody else that is like Twilight. It's a real head-scratcher for me.


What if, in the past they were there, but not noticed?


I'm going to make my own scary timeline
When the rain boom happen rainbow dash died from doing a super rainbow
The other main five still get their cutie marks except for rainbow dash because she died from Sonic rainbow
The other early quest area still stays the same
This time the elements only has five they couldn't defending nightmare Moon without the other element
Aand then nightmare Moon banned Celestia to the Moon
And then nightmare Moon destroys Twilight library house and Spike died
Discord doesn't break out of stone
Twilight tries to figure out a plan to stop nightmare Moon and it's still sad after Spike's death
And then Twilight tries to make this thing power and it's like this black thing and possesses you it's first host is Twilight sparkle
And twilight kill nightmare moon


I was saw that episode I was so confused I was like there is no way they're in the right world


I though you were going to say the creepy pasta time line yes that's real!


………… I’m still in my childhood and you killed it
I loved my little pony
You ruined it
😭


I think you’re right I think that time line was the final time line


Damn sawtooth you ruined my childhood but if you watch other time travel things , they go back to the, timeline they were in so twilight went back which means probably g5 will be one of the other timelines . But these are all theories and I’m sure hasbro wouldn’t want to make it dark and crush our hearts into bits and pieces so we wouldn’t sue them


@SawtoothWaves I'm going to write a fanfiction about life in this forgotten world. I'm going to give credit to you for the idea, but could I use the thumbnail for the fanfic? It's okay if not.


Cidney Poshi

19 minutes ago

can you please make a video of the 7th alternate time line, the wasteland? What was the cause of this time line? I think it was Starlight Glimmer. Please make the video ASAP!


Sawtooth Waves, then what happened to the pony of shadow (in the real time)? Cause he actually banished in the human world but there is movie or news about that?


That abandoned timeline is the Gen 5 world


if there is a change between those worlds,Does it relate to that ladybugs in equestria's change?!


me realizing this cool multiverse thing can go horribly wrong:OH MY F.ING GOD


Maybe sunset comes back in that timeline.


The spooky tone in your voice just made me feel like laughing the whole time im sorry


The mane 5 would think that Twilight just abandoned them


Sawtooth I love ur vids I know everyone says this but I watch ur vids on the hour


Unless the 7th wasteland timeline was the original timeline.


Then Twilight become part of the organization to protect the timeline as Ms.Minutes 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣<br>(Just voice actress joke Haha)

Then Twilight become part of the organization to protect the timeline as Ms.Minutes 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
(Just voice actress joke Haha)


I think it's the same timeline because if it's a different timeline wouldn't we have see a clone of Twilight??? but it's just my theory


the creators of mlp = This human knows too much.


OR Twilight and the rest went to a timeline were that world's twilight went to another and the world they left behind was back to normal as a twilight from another timeline came to that world so on so fourth 😉


But if it was a different timeline then there would be 2 twilights


Honestly, I understand the theory, I still don't believe it.


CAN YOU MAKE A VIDEO OF THE ELMENT OF HOPE [ I CANT SPELL HER NAME ] ABOUT HER HOME BEFORE SHE WAS A PILLER NO ONE KNOWS ABOUT THAT PLACE AND IS ABOUT EYGIPT I THINK [ OK EVERYONE KNOWS THAT PROBABLY] PLEASE MAKE A VIDEO OF THAT PLEASE


What if the forgot time line is the time line that gen 5 is in


plot twist it is the new my little pony time line.


I think we saw this timeline...what if that seven one was the one twilight left......


How does that happen with them just being there, im so confused


Dude I was waiting for sequel of MLP of starlight traveling through the muliverse with doctor whooves and tixie and the gray pony


Maybe  the timeline that when they were there in the rain boom is fine because starlight twilight and spike returned to the timeline that when they weren’t there the rain boom happend so everyone is safe


But what happened to the twilight and spike of the timeline they went into?


I think  there in the place where they meant to be , original equestria.


The 9th timeline could never be joined back with the old  once it’s made you can’t go back and even if the timeline did join back wouldn’t aquestria have a lot of questions to ask like we’re they were

This gives me a lot of questions on the 7 universes how did apple jack get her original cutie mark without the rainbow to point her back how did pinkie bring the partie to her family how did rarity discover her love of fashion how did flutter shy realise her awsome controll over animals how did twilight still become a allicorn how did rainbow dash go at the speed she loved to realise her love of wining they might of had the same destiny but how did they figure it out


Plot Twist: The MLP G5 Takes place in the Abandoned Timeline


This kinda reminds me of Persona 2 Eternal Punishment


Sawtooth you've been on youtube for years WHEN ARE YOU DOING A FACE REVEAL


Nameless I demand to see the elements of neutral


i think it is the same timeline because there is possibility that in the original timeline they were present but we did not see


Mordetwi is on S T O N K right now civilian. -optimus


I just noticed sawtooth has a bi flag in his pfp <b>we love a bisexual king</b> 🥰

I just noticed sawtooth has a bi flag in his pfp *we love a bisexual king* 🥰


Wait... If the original timeline really is true was abandoned, then the new generation (The new season) might take place in that timeline since the new mlp looks very human-like? 'Cuz Unicorn has no magic, the three tribes aren't united like in Equestria does (Like how irl there are many races and it's an issue like there is racism and there is also a culture shock between races, like how the earth pony was shock and freaked out when they see unicorn and has many assumptions about them like we see on the trailer), the Crystal Empire might turn into Antarctica without the Crystal Heart, and the Mane 6 is just a legend in the new season. So in my theory if the original timeline was really abandoned, imo the new generation is from that timeline.


I bet the new world is the new generation. That's why all the races separated. Lack of the magic of friendship.


What if tirek destroyed the chest and the tree of harmony before the mane six got there what would happen because we saw tirek destroy the forest what if he hit the tree of harmony and the chest would the mane six still win or not would tirek steal the magic Pearl power hippogrifs and could tirek still the changelings magic or could he not because of the throne because if the mane six lost then the changeling never would of reformed so would the magic force Field give all the magic back or not because we saw that tirek can steal changeling magic could he steal the force field magic and steal all the changelings magic and keep going till he had all the magic or something else but what do you think sawtooth


I just started watching your vids so if you are right what happened to the abandoned world what happened to the starlight glimmer twilight and spike from the world we know??


Maybe they WERE supposed to be there. Even if we didn’t see them.


i think the original timeline would have been wiped out of the grandfather clock thing people are talking about.


Hi saw tooth i know this is a old video but yes flurry heart would be born but in the clip it looks like flurry started crying because  pinkie pie stoped holding onto her so the mane 5 wouldn't  have to go to Crystal empire pinkie pie wouldn't  stop holding her because she wouldnt be there  and crystalis wouldnt have been attracted  to flurrys love and they would have been gone and without twilight the school of friend ship wouldnt be open and cozy glow wouldnt be crying by the crusaders tree house for twilights school test there for it would just be normal and the would just have to get used to not living with twilight


Maybe the Twilight from the new timeline went to the old timeline and the one from the old timeline went to the old timeline. •-• Or it's just the same timeline and I'm an idiot.


u r wrong bc then what happened to the twillightin the duplicated world starlight,spike and twilight returned to the main world that we know no other timeline was created due to this change but there is another fact we can look into so in the episode where twilight goes to tell her past self that something is very wrong in the future it does make a huge impact in the future so even if  future twilight just went into that world for 1 second and past twillight saw her it would change how twilight thinks and make a huge impact in the future so I don't think that being present in the past does not make any difference I just think that it dosen't change the timeline thus it only makes a loop that keeps on happening instead of traveling to another realm and ending the loop


Maybe they came Back to the original world and left the world where they were for a short few seconds live the rest normally but some ponies would just feel a disturbance in the force


i think the abandoned world went to the human world and turned into the mlp humans that we see today in the humanworld


1:26 😂 my earbuds died here and I thought he just ended the video with: "nothing."


Maybe the original timeline had them but we couldn't see


mabye in the other one sunset comes back after hearing twilight went missing! just a thought


What if in the 1 world they saw all 3 of them dead ☠


When you and the Nameless guy talk I think it’s funny


What if they ARE in the different timeline but its similiar situation as last time with twilight,new twilight from different timeline came into her place etc.


Sawtooth your always right accept this time you are wrong


If there was a different but similar time line would 'nt there be a Different  twilight sparkle  who also tried to stop starlight from preventing the rainboom🤔🤔🤔🤔


funniest thing ever "oh i have a time travel question why don't i just NAMELESS it?!


tbh this scared me along side it was night time


When it rlly was like that.. wouldn't there be an ohter Spike,Starlight and Twillight? And when it would give them then it might gives some option's! Maybe they where going back in time too and then land in the Original dimension ,but where are they if they are real?


Theory the next generation<br>Of pony live there this explaining why there's no magic it's cozy glow

Theory the next generation
Of pony live there this explaining why there's no magic it's cozy glow


This can’t be. if it was then where is the Twilight from this timeline. they were just yours there is another Twilight Who found the man six.


Me at 2:20: sir you need to start narrating creepy pastas your voice just BRIH


The last one the completely destroyed timeline when they stopped the rain boom it would only take a matter of time


Holy shit that's sad I think that what you said would happen but something different with Celestia she and twilight were really close sending letters spending time together she was like her daughter and now she has to rule equestria I think that'd be enough to snap and you know what that means DAY BREAKER 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 EQUSTRIA WOULD BURN TO THE GROUND


Sawtooth I'm a changeling as well I take place as an alicorn and I'm as powerful as flurry heart so I can go to divorce realm I think that's where the real statue.


rainbow dash probably have a memory of those three being there


Hey no one saw them In the past? No one could remember seeing them. What if they was there in the original. Just like the loop with future Twilight warning her past self about the future.<br>No one saw them, so they weren't in the flashback

Hey no one saw them In the past? No one could remember seeing them. What if they was there in the original. Just like the loop with future Twilight warning her past self about the future.
No one saw them, so they weren't in the flashback


If its a seperate timeline, then where are the alternate spike twilight and starlight? Are they still there? Did they  go back to the original timeline?


I only disliked this because I am heartbroken, shocked, and in disbelief. And now I am depressed.


You are right sawtooth The world of pony Vill is a wreck


Lauren Faust: I JUST WANTED TO MAKE A HOURSE SHOW.


Hey can you plz do a vid of what would happen if celesta was day breaker and Luna ruled and how different everything would be


I like the merging in the end ideas better then that... depressing ideas


What if there is a tat imagine where there’s capitalize Queen and fire queen because of the night the moon is cold enough to date hot


ayo i remember when u were called the brony notion. i used to binge watch your videos as a kid cus i was cool :D


I will never like theories like this

I don't think any of this happened since, well, it's a kids show, it's not supposed to be this complicated/deep


I just noticed that the student 6 will not take the main 6 element of harmony  they will make there one


This is why i hate/scared of time travel-


Imagine they go again in a time line and go tot he abandonded one


hasbro watches be likes: WE CAN EXPLAIN!!!


MLP s forgetten World is from future, Twilight Sparkle in finale has change to Real Alicorn but has later been to gone, And in new generation Sunset Shimmer has ruler of eqwestria?


The way you said all this stuff gave me chills, you did a great job, same for the nameless one


Well that should mean in the first timeline twilight was lost because she went to other timelines and came to a new timeline where there exists no other twilight.. Then that timeline............. Must've been the first timeline she left! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA


If they really went back to that moment that means that in the origenal they were also there becuse that woud just mean that they were at 2 places at the same time but in diferent ages
(What if in the origenal timeline they where also there)

Sorry for bad grammar😅


I don’t think it is true because when they came back all of them was happy to see them and I don’t really think that makes kinda sense for me 😅 it’s not another world because if it was I feel like half the world would change


I’m pretty sure that The real World doesn’t exist anymore The Real timeline it’s gone


I really hope your wrong because it real sad 😔 and starlight would spend her life in tarderis if they get back but hopefully they merge back together


perhaps this is why in the new mlp movie gen 5? frenship lost its purpouse in another vid u mentioned perhaps winter drove poinies away sooooooo maybe the  movie is set in the left behind timeline


Wait your wrong because they went back to the  1st world so the 2nd world wouldn't be abandoned because baby twilight was still in the world and if I was wrong there would be 2 twilight's in the same world


What happened to the uplifting fun voice you had when you started I want that sawtooth back


Nope, there would be 2 of each one of those 3... It's "magic".

New subscriber, thanks for sharing, I MISS M.L.P. F.I.M.!


If it was a different universe when their twilight


can you please check out your did celestia bailed out night mare moon. In the comments I think I found out who bailed her out.


Celestia would replace twighlight with rainbow dash probably because they act similar even though Pegasus she might turn alicorn


what happens if they were there in the original au so nothing happens


if a timeline it like a line of water it block with your hand witch time travel it redirect but water somehow find it way back together but if the route is too different then it never merge


I was just watching another video and what if flurry heart ruled the dream realm


I think the allacorns name shud be princess crystal.


Thorax was cold hearted changeling killer.


I would just get a puddle, put a little toothpick and see if anything changes, nothing changes then yay..something changes, oh no-


While sunset shimmer just relaxing in the other dimension


The tree is harmony was in control of where they went right? Therefore it would think of things like this and avoid them


Hmmm Time traveling how can I time travel? Oh wait you’re not gonna answer that are ya?


Sawtooth waves make a theory about why dont tirek  takes discord power in the end of the end  when he takes it in princess twilight sparkle does grogars bells multiply power or something bc he said no being can handle discords power when he can


Its 10pm where I am and u maid me think😐<br>Also I watch alot of realistic syfi cinda programs aswell and by there logect at some point if there is 2 timelines they will collide🤯

Its 10pm where I am and u maid me think😐
Also I watch alot of realistic syfi cinda programs aswell and by there logect at some point if there is 2 timelines they will collide🤯


Ok so what if your first theory is true wouldn't all the ponies be at war with each other and the villains. Like : windigoes, sombra, cozy, chriseles and terek


Umm sorry to delete your theory from the world of mlp Mr. waves, but this is not possible at all, and all thanks to Discord: You said yourself that he lives in between worlds so wouldn't he probably know if the 3 ended up in another world but we totally see discord acting as NORMAL as he can be, without a warning or even a surprised look next time he shows up.


Maybe Generation 6 is the abandoned timeline