shooter: "I hear voices in my head"<br>detective: "That's called thinking"

shooter: "I hear voices in my head"
detective: "That's called thinking"

@Angel sosa Some of the best mathematicians and musicians have no "inner monologue." I think having some monologue going on all the time would make a person thoughtless, just an audience member to some narcissistic personality. So I'm happy not to have one.

@Angel sosa Some of the best mathematicians and musicians have no "inner monologue." I think having some monologue going on all the time would make a person thoughtless, just an audience member to some narcissistic personality. So I'm happy not to have one.

Yo I heard a voice in my head when I read this! 😲😲

Yo I heard a voice in my head when I read this! 😲😲

@Babbling Along not trying to be rude but most people are like that, its quite literally called thinking

@Babbling Along not trying to be rude but most people are like that, its quite literally called thinking

@Ug Ne i mean if no one can hear you why not talk to yourself? it just feels more meaningful and you remember it better . though that could just be me as i have shit memory

@Ug Ne i mean if no one can hear you why not talk to yourself? it just feels more meaningful and you remember it better . though that could just be me as i have shit memory

@MITCH Clover deaf people can see and therefore visualise, eg. Having a version of you that signs words in your head To think

@MITCH Clover deaf people can see and therefore visualise, eg. Having a version of you that signs words in your head To think

The muppets treasure island is a good movie

@Christ-theKey parrots share food with each other if one cannot eat, a bonobo chewed a guys finger off and apologised a month later.

@Christ-theKey parrots share food with each other if one cannot eat, a bonobo chewed a guys finger off and apologised a month later.

@Peter - I don’t trust an oblivion profile pic,

@Peter - I don’t trust an oblivion profile pic,

@Ug Ne that’s called THINKING out loud, emphasis on the word THINKING, as in having a voice that tells you things.

@Ug Ne that’s called THINKING out loud, emphasis on the word THINKING, as in having a voice that tells you things.

@Peter - I don't have an inner monologue but to be clear it doesn't mean I don't think. In fact it helps me think faster because I don't need to take the time to express complex things in words, I can just deal with the things themselves. It doesn't make sense to someone who has an inner monologue, but the best way I can describe it is like a constant series of "realizations" - like when you realize something in an instant, but every thought is like that.

@Peter - i cant visualize at all, i can only think in words. it’s super weird to think of being able to see pictures in your head (is that even how it works idk)

@Peter - i cant visualize at all, i can only think in words. it’s super weird to think of being able to see pictures in your head (is that even how it works idk)

@Ug Ne not necessarily believe it or not everyone talks to the salt at least once in their life. Just because we don't talk about it doesn't mean it doesn't happen, and if someone does talk to themselves it doesn't instantly mean something is wrong with them

@Ug Ne not necessarily believe it or not everyone talks to the salt at least once in their life. Just because we don't talk about it doesn't mean it doesn't happen, and if someone does talk to themselves it doesn't instantly mean something is wrong with them

@Angel sosa there's a difference between an inner monologue and thinking

@Angel sosa there's a difference between an inner monologue and thinking

@Mauri Vanhanen yes! Exactly the same as me.

@Mauri Vanhanen yes! Exactly the same as me.

@Kit Well for instance in your head when you move your hand to grab something you don't think move my hand. You just do it right?

I'm sure your brain can pick up on speech and have a dialog however it's definitely not something everyone has.

@Kit Well for instance in your head when you move your hand to grab something you don't think move my hand. You just do it right?

I'm sure your brain can pick up on speech and have a dialog however it's definitely not something everyone has.

@Yovanii Red ...ok my partner can't dream and he's normal as fuck. I'm not doubting your anecdote I'm just saying you're getting dangerously close to making another broad generalization

@Yovanii Red ...ok my partner can't dream and he's normal as fuck. I'm not doubting your anecdote I'm just saying you're getting dangerously close to making another broad generalization

@Yovanii Red I think you're misunderstanding here--people without inner dialogue or without internal visualization are just processing differently, they're not "empty headed". They have a series of sensations and processes that you <b>don't</b> have instead.  Maybe people who think primarily in words or  pictures are the ones missing out 🤷 it's the same as not knowing whether my purple is the same as your purple--maybe the color I can see, if you could look through my eyes and still understand as you normally would, you might call it pink. But we would have both been trained to recognize that shade as purple, regardless of how we are processing it.

@Yovanii Red I think you're misunderstanding here--people without inner dialogue or without internal visualization are just processing differently, they're not "empty headed". They have a series of sensations and processes that you *don't* have instead.  Maybe people who think primarily in words or  pictures are the ones missing out 🤷 it's the same as not knowing whether my purple is the same as your purple--maybe the color I can see, if you could look through my eyes and still understand as you normally would, you might call it pink. But we would have both been trained to recognize that shade as purple, regardless of how we are processing it.

@MITCH Clover apparently deaf people with schizophrenia can see hands signing rather than hear voices (anybody able to confirm?) So idk. I don't think people need to think in spoken language, or in language at all per se, but many--arguably most--do think using some kind of language

@MITCH Clover apparently deaf people with schizophrenia can see hands signing rather than hear voices (anybody able to confirm?) So idk. I don't think people need to think in spoken language, or in language at all per se, but many--arguably most--do think using some kind of language

@Ug Ne I have inner monologue but sometimes you speak or say something even in public when you think "loudly"

@Ug Ne I have inner monologue but sometimes you speak or say something even in public when you think "loudly"

@DannyDevito No, there has been studies done; and he's right, it's a large amount of the population who claims to not have an inner voice, and they don't visualize.

What percent is misunderstanding the question, vs really can't think for themselves is unknown, but the recorded rate is rather high, like about 30%.

There’s some people who legitimately believe that the inner monologue we have in our head is someone else like God, demons, or other people.

There’s some people who legitimately believe that the inner monologue we have in our head is someone else like God, demons, or other people.

reminds me of the time i said i talked to myself in my head some guy was like “thats fucking weird” and i was like dude its called thinking

reminds me of the time i said i talked to myself in my head some guy was like “thats fucking weird” and i was like dude its called thinking

@Akrasia. its been proven numerous amounts of times, i was even friends with such, they operate like everyone elese cause they are humans, not some bazaar creatures just because they are different so it doesnt make sense to call " bullshit " just because you havent seen it

@Akrasia. its been proven numerous amounts of times, i was even friends with such, they operate like everyone elese cause they are humans, not some bazaar creatures just because they are different so it doesnt make sense to call " bullshit " just because you havent seen it

@Akrasia. oh, whoop, sorry ignore my other reply. I was thinking about something else.

@Akrasia. oh, whoop, sorry ignore my other reply. I was thinking about something else.

@Akrasia. Actually it’s true, they think through pictures.

@Akrasia. Actually it’s true, they think through pictures.

@Peter - i cant visualise, i was shocked when I found out that people can

@Peter - i cant visualise, i was shocked when I found out that people can

@The Moody Juice lost a few braincells to that, thanks

@The Moody Juice lost a few braincells to that, thanks

Yeah, it was settled when the shooter said he hears the voice inside of his head. People who hear voices can't distinguish between real voices and the fake ones

Yeah, it was settled when the shooter said he hears the voice inside of his head. People who hear voices can't distinguish between real voices and the fake ones

@Basketball Kev Nope it's always silent.

@Basketball Kev Nope it's always silent.

@The1dBumblebee i dont need to hear it, i know what im saying, its like when you are talking but you cant hear your own voice because of the loud noise around

@The1dBumblebee i dont need to hear it, i know what im saying, its like when you are talking but you cant hear your own voice because of the loud noise around

@Rush how can you talk to yourself if your inner voice is "voiceless"

@Rush how can you talk to yourself if your inner voice is "voiceless"

@Toeka Frank I am jealous I don't get that many likes on a logical comment 🤣🤣🤣

@Toeka Frank I am jealous I don't get that many likes on a logical comment 🤣🤣🤣

@MITCH Clover Deaf people can still see and read, genius. I suggest you use some metacognitive abilities before your next post.

@MITCH Clover Deaf people can still see and read, genius. I suggest you use some metacognitive abilities before your next post.

"I can read minds... But I need practice because right now, I can only read my own mind.. but gimme like 5 years, I'll be good"

That's... That's thinking! Literally everybody can do that!

"Wow! I just found out I could do this like two years ago, man..."

Get out!! Get Ooooouuuuuuttttt!!!!!

"I can read minds... But I need practice because right now, I can only read my own mind.. but gimme like 5 years, I'll be good"

That's... That's thinking! Literally everybody can do that!

"Wow! I just found out I could do this like two years ago, man..."

Get out!! Get Ooooouuuuuuttttt!!!!!

@Peter - visualization is distinct from having an inner voice though. I'm autistic and I can visualize literally almost anything. I have a super strong sense of justice and right and wrong. I do not have an inner voice though or understand even what the hell that might be other than just knowing intrinsically that it's wrong to hurt people in any way ever at all.

@Peter - I didnt when I was addicted to drugs!

@Peter - I didnt when I was addicted to drugs!

@Angel sosa least egotistical YouTube commenter

@Angel sosa least egotistical YouTube commenter

@depressed scooby doo how tf can you think without language? I call bullshit on all of this " no inner dialogue" bullshit, sorry but I just don't buy it.

@depressed scooby doo how tf can you think without language? I call bullshit on all of this " no inner dialogue" bullshit, sorry but I just don't buy it.

@Angel sosa you suppose that having an inner dialogue is “smarter”. Thinking using spacial relationships or in whole notions/concept without using real time, linear English could be a sign of a more advanced mind. You assume a “Dear Diary” type of thought is proof of free will or autonomy. Dunno.

I hear voices in my head they talk to me they understand :)

I hear voices in my head they talk to me they understand :)

@Onion skin 1,00 its called a conscience, we all think about things like that it's normal as fuck it's not that deep people are just overthinking in the comments

@Onion skin 1,00 its called a conscience, we all think about things like that it's normal as fuck it's not that deep people are just overthinking in the comments

You do realize Deaf people have a language, right? Typically people who are born hard of hearing are introduced to some sort of Signed Langage, or if it isn't severe and human voice can still be processed, then it could English or whatever they're surrounded by, or a combination of SL as their language. Verbal modality isn't the only type of language. And if visual thinking is already a commonly understood means, then why wouldn't Deaf people be able to visualize their language?

The voice in your head is your desires and God gave you your own mind to decide to do something bad or walk out that door and do the right thing .

The voice in your head is your desires and God gave you your own mind to decide to do something bad or walk out that door and do the right thing .

@Somebody No I just sense the meaning in my mind, no sound or voice needed, no pictures either, though I visualise thoughts often. Not when I'm writing replies on YouTube though.

@Somebody No I just sense the meaning in my mind, no sound or voice needed, no pictures either, though I visualise thoughts often. Not when I'm writing replies on YouTube though.

@Somebody I don't, I just type, I revise in my head, in silence, when necessary.

@Somebody I don't, I just type, I revise in my head, in silence, when necessary.

@Peter - you think faster if you don't make it into a voice.

@Peter - you think faster if you don't make it into a voice.

@Peter - im so confused by this. When you say inner monologue, do you mean an actual voice that you can literally hear? Like auditory? As if i was talking to a video recording of my self? I have thoughts to myself all the time and can form sentences, I can think of places and see them, I can imagine someone’s voice. Do I have internal monologue? I can talk to myself in my head, but I can’t literally hear my thoughts out loud.

@Starkilla Op Yeah ,i am one of those weirdos lmao

@Starkilla Op Yeah ,i am one of those weirdos lmao

@Nutella is disgusting As someone who doesn't have an inner voice ,yes we can dream and even someone with aphantasia can dream

@Nutella is disgusting As someone who doesn't have an inner voice ,yes we can dream and even someone with aphantasia can dream

@Peter - dude there people that have lived their life without thinking? They just do?

@Peter - dude there people that have lived their life without thinking? They just do?

I hear dialougue but I can't  visualize  things

I hear dialougue but I can't  visualize  things

@depressed scooby doo Do you hear the voices of a song that plays in your head after you hear music with singing ? ( and it gets stuck in your head ) <br>That would be the voice of thought. ( but in this case, using the singers' voice ).

@depressed scooby doo Do you hear the voices of a song that plays in your head after you hear music with singing ? ( and it gets stuck in your head )
That would be the voice of thought. ( but in this case, using the singers' voice ).

@Peter - I also can’t draw what I visualize 💀 I can draw a pretty cool stick figure tho

@Peter - I also can’t draw what I visualize 💀 I can draw a pretty cool stick figure tho

@Gabby Gutierrez <br>I can’t draw what I visualize so that’s a point on his side haha

@Gabby Gutierrez
I can’t draw what I visualize so that’s a point on his side haha

@Adeptus Fantasticushmm I only have inner monologue when I read but if I want to think I can only visualize, maybe because of that I am not really good at speaking.

@Adeptus Fantasticushmm I only have inner monologue when I read but if I want to think I can only visualize, maybe because of that I am not really good at speaking.

@Christ-theKey ...we still think, we still reason, it just. Isn't. Audible. I'd imagine it's similar to how it is when deaf people think :/

@Christ-theKey ...we still think, we still reason, it just. Isn't. Audible. I'd imagine it's similar to how it is when deaf people think :/

@Nutella is disgusting yup! I dream lots!

@Nutella is disgusting yup! I dream lots!

@Angel sosa ...we have thoughts just not audible ones bruv

@Angel sosa ...we have thoughts just not audible ones bruv

@circusofsix Helen Keller who was both blind and deaf spoke and wrote of this: basically her brain adapted to interpret the world for her through other senses and other thought processes . She adapted to the world around her using touch .there a photo of her touching Michelangelo’s David  and she wrote of how she experienced this too. She dreamt but not visually .

@HUMPTY having (or not having) an inner dialogue/monologue is not at all the same as an auditory hallucination. Some people have brains that do not have a mono/dialogue but they do not have schizophrenia.

@HUMPTY having (or not having) an inner dialogue/monologue is not at all the same as an auditory hallucination. Some people have brains that do not have a mono/dialogue but they do not have schizophrenia.

@User what are you talking about ? Was I talking to u about something ?

@User what are you talking about ? Was I talking to u about something ?

@James Stapleton this is more probably in relation to your brain figuring out if your body is ready for sleep or not. The brain can activate false sensory stimuli in order to basically test if youre falling asleep or not. Or ready to wake up as well. Failure to properly identify this time while waking up results in sleep paralysis as your body is still sleeping in a sense but youve returned to consciousness. Then your brain will make up images (demons, spectres, etc. ) to account for the extremely low heart and breathing rates and inability to move your arms and legs and all that. The body is wild.

@Peter - my little sibling is an artist but they can’t actually visualize anything mentally, like if you ask them to visualize an apple they can’t but if they put a pencil to paper they could draw one. It’s crazy

@Peter - my little sibling is an artist but they can’t actually visualize anything mentally, like if you ask them to visualize an apple they can’t but if they put a pencil to paper they could draw one. It’s crazy

@Akrasia. its a real thing dude. Aphantasia or something.

@Akrasia. its a real thing dude. Aphantasia or something.

@R. S yeah and thats called aphantasia if im not mistaken

@R. S yeah and thats called aphantasia if im not mistaken

@Aster Risk Heck I talk to myself a lot of the time plus I have that internal voice, everywhere I go there's a lively gathering occuring, so basically I'm rarely lonely!

@Aster Risk Heck I talk to myself a lot of the time plus I have that internal voice, everywhere I go there's a lively gathering occuring, so basically I'm rarely lonely!

Those voices could be like a traumatized event

Those voices could be like a traumatized event

@Good.
It’s like the narrator in movies, maybe you’ve seen Sherlock Holmes with Robert Downey Jr (I’ve seen it again not too long ago so it came to mind), Sherlock “thinks” out his actions before he does them and they’re narrated over the slow motion action scenes.
This might just be me, but when consuming a lot of media where people have a certain way of speaking, my “inner voice” copies it, like when I binched Limmy’s show, a Scottish comedian, I was thinking with a Scottish accent for a long while 😂

My brain hurts and it won't shut up yap yap yap yap

That means your thinking, Ricky

My brain hurts and it won't shut up yap yap yap yap

That means your thinking, Ricky

@Christ-theKey Animals can think too -_-

@Christ-theKey Animals can think too -_-

😅 I mean if those are the thoughts it’s not good thinking

😅 I mean if those are the thoughts it’s not good thinking

Oh my god😂😂 I read this before hearing it and it was more funny😂😭😭

Oh my god😂😂 I read this before hearing it and it was more funny😂😭😭

@Akrasia. I also don't have an "inner voice". I just think to myself without words. It's kinda hard to explain. If I try to form thoughts in the form of speech I get stuck putting the words together, so I rather just let the brain do the work and say the result of the process. I really struggle when I study, but if I understand it I can easily remember it.

@Zach Jollimore I still don’t understand how people can know exactly how they’re thinking. When i see trebuchet, it’s like the word and the image appear simultaneously in my mind. Like I don’t feel like the language nor visualization is dominant over the other form. Honestly I have know idea how I think, it just happens.

@Angel sosa Yep, lotta NPCs with no voices of their own is right. Trust the sCiEnCe, obey, and don't question anything

@Angel sosa Yep, lotta NPCs with no voices of their own is right. Trust the sCiEnCe, obey, and don't question anything

@MJ Stray they said “hue man”, definitely no source

@MJ Stray they said “hue man”, definitely no source

@Prince Christian I got that theme song stuck in my head when I read the comment 🤣

@Prince Christian I got that theme song stuck in my head when I read the comment 🤣

@Dr0ne yeah that’s what a lot of people say. It’s indeed not going to happen when you place a limitation upon yourself based on false identification with your personality. Does the universe have adhd?

@Dr0ne yeah that’s what a lot of people say. It’s indeed not going to happen when you place a limitation upon yourself based on false identification with your personality. Does the universe have adhd?

@Chief lol I have adhd that isn’t gonna happen

@Chief lol I have adhd that isn’t gonna happen

@Angel sosa Or maybe certain people perceive consciousness differently. It doesn't necessarily mean they're without thought.

@Angel sosa Or maybe certain people perceive consciousness differently. It doesn't necessarily mean they're without thought.

I do hear voices in my head but it’s a copeing mecsimome (sorry i can’t spell im dyslexic)

I do hear voices in my head but it’s a copeing mecsimome (sorry i can’t spell im dyslexic)

No. Studies have found that only about 23% of humans think in voice. Many people who think they do, don't.

Now, hearing one or more voices that aren't your own, is common with psychosis. It's generally accepted that they are your thoughts, but for some reason your brain is misidentifying them, and that's why they seem foreign.

@Rust exactly you’d think they would do their research

@Rust exactly you’d think they would do their research

@친남 okay really where tf r y’all getting these politics from. We’re talking about inner monologue, not red or blue.

@친남 okay really where tf r y’all getting these politics from. We’re talking about inner monologue, not red or blue.

@DannyDevito wtf? Did you read the other comments? They’re not talking about political views at all. Just people with no thoughts. Yeah, calling them npcs is probably really mean (I can’t say if it is or isn’t since I have thoughts), so you might be right on that bit, but I really don’t get where you got the second half from.

@HUMPTY not always. People with extreme anxiety and ptsd can hear voices for years. Some enter temporary psychosis. Isolation/confinement within prison often brings this in fruition. It’s actually more common than people think. If you hear voices and suffer no other symptoms of schizophrenia, look into ptsd, head trauma, and anxiety. Misdiagnosing is worse than being left untreated.

It's not just an Internal voice it's concepts and images and . idk . idk how to describe how my mind works but I guess it's both

It's not just an Internal voice it's concepts and images and . idk . idk how to describe how my mind works but I guess it's both

@Akrasia. it isnt bullshit though. I had seen a video about how some people cannot visualize. Like if you tell them to imagine an apple their head would be blank. Its like a scale, some people would make a vivid image of apple in the head thats almost real while some have problems doing that.

@Akrasia. it isnt bullshit though. I had seen a video about how some people cannot visualize. Like if you tell them to imagine an apple their head would be blank. Its like a scale, some people would make a vivid image of apple in the head thats almost real while some have problems doing that.

I read this with the voices in my head AHHHHH

I read this with the voices in my head AHHHHH

@Nutella is disgusting I have very vivid dreams but the most I see when I think is vague splotches of colour, can’t speak for the people with no inner voice, though.

@Nutella is disgusting I have very vivid dreams but the most I see when I think is vague splotches of colour, can’t speak for the people with no inner voice, though.

@Peter - They don’t have any spatial intelligence, it’s sad.

@Peter - They don’t have any spatial intelligence, it’s sad.

@Angel sosa Dude, imagine thinking that you're not the NPC for not being able to think without wasting time on pretending that someone's talking to you.

@Angel sosa Dude, imagine thinking that you're not the NPC for not being able to think without wasting time on pretending that someone's talking to you.

Also it's 3% of people at a Max not 25% as stated in comments. <br>It took me until I was 24 to realise.

Also it's 3% of people at a Max not 25% as stated in comments.
It took me until I was 24 to realise.

@Peter - I'm one of those people, it's called Aphantasia but it's not very well studied even though it was first documented in the 18th century.

@Peter - I'm one of those people, it's called Aphantasia but it's not very well studied even though it was first documented in the 18th century.

detective: hate to break it to ya kid, so does everybody else lmao u think ur so special

detective: hate to break it to ya kid, so does everybody else lmao u think ur so special

@MITCH Clover yeah I didn’t know that was normal until now either

@MITCH Clover yeah I didn’t know that was normal until now either

@Angel sosa that’s- that’s not how it works. So I have this thing that you’re talking about, no inner voice, there’s just no sort of voice whatsoever, my thoughts don’t need or use any sort of “sound” to exist, so when I think, it’s just quiet thoughts

@Angel sosa that’s- that’s not how it works. So I have this thing that you’re talking about, no inner voice, there’s just no sort of voice whatsoever, my thoughts don’t need or use any sort of “sound” to exist, so when I think, it’s just quiet thoughts

@Lumonetic Visually, very visually. I see pictures of everyday things or people, moving clips, or abstract forms, colours changing etc..

@Lumonetic Visually, very visually. I see pictures of everyday things or people, moving clips, or abstract forms, colours changing etc..

@A H Reading mostly directly grasping the meaning of the words, sometimes I hear a version of my own voice that stops the second I stop reading. Writing is completely silent, I just put the meaning I have in mind in text.

@A H Reading mostly directly grasping the meaning of the words, sometimes I hear a version of my own voice that stops the second I stop reading. Writing is completely silent, I just put the meaning I have in mind in text.

@Babbling Along Wait, So how do you think?

@Babbling Along Wait, So how do you think?

@Peter - everyone doesn't have inner dialogues?

@Peter - everyone doesn't have inner dialogues?

@Koi Goi I have this same thing. I am on autism spectrum though. High functioning but non-the-less.

@Koi Goi I have this same thing. I am on autism spectrum though. High functioning but non-the-less.

Shooter: “I heat voices in my head”

Detective: “No, that’s the randy Orton WWE walkout theme song “

Shooter: “I heat voices in my head”

Detective: “No, that’s the randy Orton WWE walkout theme song “

Oh I do that I'll say some things in my head and others out loud. I do it subconsciously so I'll never know unless someone tells me.

Oh I do that I'll say some things in my head and others out loud. I do it subconsciously so I'll never know unless someone tells me.

@Angel sosa Well thought just isn't done with an internal monologue, but more in shapes and actual concepts. rather than the language that we use to convey those concepts.
Like if this was a conversation about trebuchets and you were in the 25% and thinking about a trebuchet, you'd not immediately think of the word trebuchet, but rather a physical representation of a trebuchet.
Somewhere in the brain, this physical representation gets turned into language and that falls outta your mouth.
Most people just have the monologue instead.

@Peter - it can’t be too common right? How would you do mental math without an inner voice? Or read to yourself?

@Peter - it can’t be too common right? How would you do mental math without an inner voice? Or read to yourself?

Yeah the hilarious thing is ppl never realize its not voices IN your head its voices FROM your head and you're not supposed to realize that if your an actual schizo otherwise its not actually alienating you

Yeah the hilarious thing is ppl never realize its not voices IN your head its voices FROM your head and you're not supposed to realize that if your an actual schizo otherwise its not actually alienating you

@Onion skin 1,00 that’s almost exactly how my schizophrenic cousin’s voice works. Arguing / talking to herself was the first “step” in the condition revealing itself / worsening.

I’m not one of those people without inner dialogue, and how you described it isn’t how that stuff works. Literally all I could think about was my cousin reading your comment. Have you ever been assessed?

@Babbling Along what’s it like when you read and write?

@Babbling Along what’s it like when you read and write?

@depressed scooby doo idk how to explain, its not like an external voice talking to me. its just me thinking and it feels like a voice talking in my head but its just me thinking you know?

@depressed scooby doo idk how to explain, its not like an external voice talking to me. its just me thinking and it feels like a voice talking in my head but its just me thinking you know?

@Peter - I don’t have an inner monologue telling me what to do but I can visualize very well

@Peter - I don’t have an inner monologue telling me what to do but I can visualize very well

@circusofsix Well, animals,babies,etc. have no real “structured” language yet they still think and have emotions. I think that without language to bind thought it would be centered around emotion, and other primal urges. Without language I have a theory that we would become closer to animals. Language is what keeps us civilized and language is what allows us to learn.

The closest we can get to how someone thinks without language is we can look to “Feral” children these are kids who are usually neglected or abused and are raised by animals. They actually usually do not see a need for language and it’s very hard for them to see a use for it, one such girl from Ukraine describes that she thinks and communicates more visually than with language. This makes sense because 90% or so of communication is visual.

@MITCH Clover if deaf persons have never heard a voice and words in any language, what would their thinking sound like?? i’m asking honestly.

@MITCH Clover if deaf persons have never heard a voice and words in any language, what would their thinking sound like?? i’m asking honestly.

No not exactly, there’s demons talking to them.

No not exactly, there’s demons talking to them.

@Angel sosa i can turn off my voice and think things on deeper lvl, don't call someone npc because u cant understand how he is working ; D

@Angel sosa i can turn off my voice and think things on deeper lvl, don't call someone npc because u cant understand how he is working ; D

@Locke. Professional Simp Destoryer cool that ur able to do that but OK

@Locke. Professional Simp Destoryer cool that ur able to do that but OK

@Rush <br>Thanks, that’s really interesting

@ThenameisEton Thats for sure! We are able to live in this body that does all these things for us automatically, thats true love from the universe 🙏

@ThenameisEton Thats for sure! We are able to live in this body that does all these things for us automatically, thats true love from the universe 🙏

@Chief  your right, im stupid not to include people with disability like people with total loss of hearing/deaf and mute. The human body is truly an amazing creation

@Chief  your right, im stupid not to include people with disability like people with total loss of hearing/deaf and mute. The human body is truly an amazing creation

@Babbling Along Yeah, often I struggle to verbalize my thoughts as it feels like I have to translate my thoughts into my limited vocabulary, just like my comment I made.

@Babbling Along Yeah, often I struggle to verbalize my thoughts as it feels like I have to translate my thoughts into my limited vocabulary, just like my comment I made.

@Koi Goi We've got similar processes going on in our minds! Well explained, got the same. Meaning comes first, the linguistic expression second, and we don't express that meaning in language inside our minds, only when speaking or writing.

@Koi Goi We've got similar processes going on in our minds! Well explained, got the same. Meaning comes first, the linguistic expression second, and we don't express that meaning in language inside our minds, only when speaking or writing.

@Peter - Yeah, I can visualize though. I don't really know how to describe it but I'll do it the best I can. Talking with words is one way to convey a message. Each word has its own meaning/purpose which interconnects with other words to form a coherent message, it's like when you translate you know the meaning of the message and use the correlating words/phrases from one language to another. Instead of simply thinking to myself via a "voice" I just directly think without the use of words. I suck at explaining but it's the best way I can describe it. Also it's super weird when I imagine a voice in my head reading out my thoughts, perhaps its because I have to actively do it instead of it being second nature to me. Also when I read I do the same as I described above, interpret what the book is telling me instead of having a voice read it to me, it's like skipping a step.

@Prince Christian I HEAR VOICES IN MY HEAD THEY SPEAK TO ME THEY UNDERSTAND

@Prince Christian I HEAR VOICES IN MY HEAD THEY SPEAK TO ME THEY UNDERSTAND

@Akrasia. It’s an actual thing and my friend has it. Instead of an inner monologue they think of things in a more abstract way.

@Akrasia. It’s an actual thing and my friend has it. Instead of an inner monologue they think of things in a more abstract way.

@MrBazzos Yes I dream vividly but I don't have aphantasia. Would be interesting to hear how a person with aphantasia dreams.

@MrBazzos Yes I dream vividly but I don't have aphantasia. Would be interesting to hear how a person with aphantasia dreams.

@Nutella is disgusting yes i dream in images but remember my dream as "facts"

@Nutella is disgusting yes i dream in images but remember my dream as "facts"

@Akrasia. its called aphantasia look it up

@Akrasia. its called aphantasia look it up

@Peter - Almost all, if not all animals dream even if most don’t have an inner monologue. It’s safe to say these people that also don’t have an inner monologue dream.

@Peter - Almost all, if not all animals dream even if most don’t have an inner monologue. It’s safe to say these people that also don’t have an inner monologue dream.

@Aphrodite  I think in images, pictures like photographs but also moving colours, abstract forms like abstract paintings, sometimes little movies play out in my head. So mostly in realistic or abstract images. I have no trouble translating this to words, I can do that instantly so I don't have to think during conversation. I don't form sentences in my head, I just speak. Also I feel a lot while I think. So, feeling + visuals, that's how I think, hope it helps a little. I can ask you a similar question, how do you think? Do you form whole sentences in your head that take you from thought A to thought B or is it more chaotic?

That's his mom yelling at him "whyyyyyyyyyyyy? whyyyyyyyyyyyyyy?"

That's his mom yelling at him "whyyyyyyyyyyyy? whyyyyyyyyyyyyyy?"

@Yovanii Red not everyone has to be, think, and feel the way you do. It doesn’t mean they aren’t alright in their head. I can’t believe how arrogant you are for being mediocre

@Yovanii Red not everyone has to be, think, and feel the way you do. It doesn’t mean they aren’t alright in their head. I can’t believe how arrogant you are for being mediocre

@Angel sosa Not having an inner voice doesn't mean they're incapable of independent thought.

@Angel sosa Not having an inner voice doesn't mean they're incapable of independent thought.

@IKaRu that’s really cool! I wish I had that

@IKaRu that’s really cool! I wish I had that

@depressed scooby doo Of course we have, sometimes the voice is so loud that I think they are talking with me in real life. Sometimes I'm sleeping and I wake up with myself talking to me to wake up or something like that.<br>Sometimes I even forget to talk, I answer in my head but not in real life

@depressed scooby doo Of course we have, sometimes the voice is so loud that I think they are talking with me in real life. Sometimes I'm sleeping and I wake up with myself talking to me to wake up or something like that.
Sometimes I even forget to talk, I answer in my head but not in real life

Other cop: "What'd he say?"
Detective: "He said he had an inner monologue."
Other cop: "Unbelievable. Next you're going to tell me that he has dreams when he is sleeping, too."

Other cop: "What'd he say?"
Detective: "He said he had an inner monologue."
Other cop: "Unbelievable. Next you're going to tell me that he has dreams when he is sleeping, too."

@Akrasia. it is called aphantasia, atleast when people are unable to visualise things in their head.

@Akrasia. it is called aphantasia, atleast when people are unable to visualise things in their head.

Are you being serious? We're is the information for these type of people/npc's

Are you being serious? We're is the information for these type of people/npc's

@Locke. Professional Simp Destoryer wow that's so cool

@Locke. Professional Simp Destoryer wow that's so cool

@Gina Smith how does it work like how do you think lol

@Gina Smith how does it work like how do you think lol

@Babbling Along how do you think without the voice? It's so hard to imagine lol

@Babbling Along how do you think without the voice? It's so hard to imagine lol

@juul cat is it easier to organize better in your head? Or perhaps an advantage in memorization if you can see it visible? I just process and comprehend what I consume. I don’t know what makes up my thoughts, if I can’t even hear or see them. Sometimes it becomes a blur for me and I lose track.

@juul cat is it easier to organize better in your head? Or perhaps an advantage in memorization if you can see it visible? I just process and comprehend what I consume. I don’t know what makes up my thoughts, if I can’t even hear or see them. Sometimes it becomes a blur for me and I lose track.

@Peter - really? of course I have a consciousness, but I don’t think of it as a separate entity. It’s just me thinking and processing. I don’t hear or see my thoughts out loud either, again just me processing and comprehending what I consume. Some people say they see or hear themselves thinking, which I think is really cool. It’d probably be easier to organize thoughts better that way.

@Christ-theKey morality is highly subjective

@Christ-theKey morality is highly subjective

@Christ-theKey

 There is no fine line between humans and animals as humans are animals. Therefore what we would expect to find in non human animals are different levels of intelligence reasoning ability and even morality. We in fact do see this in our closest relatives the chimpanzees and bonobos.

@Peter - really? I thought everyone could

@Peter - really? I thought everyone could

@Gina Smith So you do you have dreams with people talking or is everyone mute?

@Gina Smith So you do you have dreams with people talking or is everyone mute?

@Aster Risk whaat that's crazy i had no idea

@Aster Risk whaat that's crazy i had no idea

@James Scherer Sometimes I hear like a warped version of my own voice when I read, yeah, it stops instantly when I stop reading though. It's probably the closest I come to having voices in my head. But it's not always when I read, often I grasp the meaning of the words immediately and I picture what I read visually.

@Rust Scariest crap ever was being right at the edge of sleep and hearing a firework (cannon, gun, big ol' boom, etc)  go off next to your head and clear a solid four foot jump in bed multiple times a night, at it worst.

@Rust Scariest crap ever was being right at the edge of sleep and hearing a firework (cannon, gun, big ol' boom, etc)  go off next to your head and clear a solid four foot jump in bed multiple times a night, at it worst.

@J R I wouldn't know since I don't have it. Ask someone who has 😀👍

@J R I wouldn't know since I don't have it. Ask someone who has 😀👍

@Aster Risk That's absolutely insane! It's very hard to imagine someone not having an inner voice and that honestly is a little bit unsettling to me.

@Aster Risk That's absolutely insane! It's very hard to imagine someone not having an inner voice and that honestly is a little bit unsettling to me.

No, some ancient hobgoblin is trying to reach me from the middle east!

No, some ancient hobgoblin is trying to reach me from the middle east!

@DannyDevito lol whattt dude u reading way to into this u trippen

@DannyDevito lol whattt dude u reading way to into this u trippen

@Locke. Professional Simp Destoryer usually it happens in school when class is in session I’ll here my name half whispered half shouting faintly. It pretty much is just spooks me for a couple seconds then I get back to reality or my mental debate to pass time on everything under the sun

@Locke. Professional Simp Destoryer usually it happens in school when class is in session I’ll here my name half whispered half shouting faintly. It pretty much is just spooks me for a couple seconds then I get back to reality or my mental debate to pass time on everything under the sun

@Peter - I'm one of those people. I've been asked before what my inner voice sounds like for reasons I don't wanna get into, but I literally hear nothing

@Peter - I'm one of those people. I've been asked before what my inner voice sounds like for reasons I don't wanna get into, but I literally hear nothing

@kael kirkby same like my brothers and my mom but some are just unknown like the thing I heard in my bathroom  that "oOo"i got scared cuz it was out of nowhere my brother heard it too he thought he was hearing voices but it was just something that the wind does when its windy and damn do I always spell alot?!

@Peter - strange AF, The only “Dialog” I have is when I am trying to type or write something down. I think very logically and scientifically so maybe it’s people that are either more social or artistic/visual thAt have that.

@Peter - strange AF, The only “Dialog” I have is when I am trying to type or write something down. I think very logically and scientifically so maybe it’s people that are either more social or artistic/visual thAt have that.

@Babbling Along If you're reading silently, do you not hear what you're reading in your head?

@Babbling Along If you're reading silently, do you not hear what you're reading in your head?

@kael kirkby visit a doctor before it gets too severe please♡

@kael kirkby visit a doctor before it gets too severe please♡

@Babbling Along that's so interesting 🤔🤔

@Babbling Along that's so interesting 🤔🤔

@Peter - i do visualize stuff in my dreams

@Peter - i do visualize stuff in my dreams

@Peter - yea aphantasia, i ant visualize stuff, i cant hear my inner voice its just voiceless, but i can still think or "talk to myself"

@Peter - yea aphantasia, i ant visualize stuff, i cant hear my inner voice its just voiceless, but i can still think or "talk to myself"

man i thought my inner demons told me the answers to the test

man i thought my inner demons told me the answers to the test

"They council me, they understand, they talk to meeee"

"They council me, they understand, they talk to meeee"

@Locke. Professional Simp Destoryer the same happens to me but it’s always over my shoulder but when I turn around the person I thought called my name was nowhere to be seen. The voice I usually someone I have regular contact with

@Locke. Professional Simp Destoryer the same happens to me but it’s always over my shoulder but when I turn around the person I thought called my name was nowhere to be seen. The voice I usually someone I have regular contact with

i would love live without thoughts they suck

i would love live without thoughts they suck

@Locke. Professional Simp Destoryer did u visit a doctor...? I highly recommend so.

@Locke. Professional Simp Destoryer did u visit a doctor...? I highly recommend so.

@Babbling Along inner monologue is like that cartoon where you have a devil and angel on your shoulder and their both arguing.

@Babbling Along inner monologue is like that cartoon where you have a devil and angel on your shoulder and their both arguing.

@DannyDevito I agree. typical leftist way to behave, it's called "bigot"

@DannyDevito I agree. typical leftist way to behave, it's called "bigot"

@Mauri Vanhanen that's a pretty neat ability. I'm starting to train myself to do what you do but it's pretty hard since I always verbalize what I subconsciously thought to understand it more. There are 3 voices in my head whenever I think about something and it's pretty annoying when I repeat what the fastest one thought 2 more times.

@Nutella is disgusting  do electric sheep dream

@Nutella is disgusting  do electric sheep dream

When you meditate and try to stop thoughts (which is not the way to do it by the way) you will find that you can indeed think without words or inner voice. Its goes through visuals and feelings mainly. Its not that weird.

When you meditate and try to stop thoughts (which is not the way to do it by the way) you will find that you can indeed think without words or inner voice. Its goes through visuals and feelings mainly. Its not that weird.

@Peter - what? So hes a zombie? How would he survive if he does not have an inner self, the body is only a representation of the inner self. Who controls the body?

@Peter - what? So hes a zombie? How would he survive if he does not have an inner self, the body is only a representation of the inner self. Who controls the body?

Can you time stamp bc this is a ling video

Can you time stamp bc this is a ling video

@Jonathan Edwards damn he enjoyed it? Thats crazy

@Jonathan Edwards damn he enjoyed it? Thats crazy

Tbh I actually hear voices in my head but eh not going crazy over it its just voices anyways 🤷♂ like it always says my name thats all like in different voices even a low voice a far away voice a echo away and a whisper voice not really bothered tho I don't want to say much

Tbh I actually hear voices in my head but eh not going crazy over it its just voices anyways 🤷♂ like it always says my name thats all like in different voices even a low voice a far away voice a echo away and a whisper voice not really bothered tho I don't want to say much

@Angel sosa They're just people who have a different though process. Ironic you insult them while displaying 0 imagination yourself.

@Angel sosa They're just people who have a different though process. Ironic you insult them while displaying 0 imagination yourself.

@Peter - i have zero inner monologe i think to myself the world will hear it. im able to keep it to incoherent mumbling but than i just look crazy. its a bitch but i cant help but find it funny. now that i think about it i find almost everything funny and i don't know whats so funny.

@Peter - i have zero inner monologe i think to myself the world will hear it. im able to keep it to incoherent mumbling but than i just look crazy. its a bitch but i cant help but find it funny. now that i think about it i find almost everything funny and i don't know whats so funny.

@MITCH Clover<br>Yeah, think of it as a play, all the characters are written by the same person but have different thoughts, opinions, etc, I’m not sure if it’s like that for everyone, but it can be as simple as the little cricket in Pinocchio’s head

@MITCH Clover
Yeah, think of it as a play, all the characters are written by the same person but have different thoughts, opinions, etc, I’m not sure if it’s like that for everyone, but it can be as simple as the little cricket in Pinocchio’s head

@Babbling Along I seem to have two gears. One with a voice that handles complex thoughts that run a logic train, while driving and playing video games are conceptual and almost as if I have "brain hand" that Dale Gribble was on about in King of the Hill "Propain."

@Babbling Along I seem to have two gears. One with a voice that handles complex thoughts that run a logic train, while driving and playing video games are conceptual and almost as if I have "brain hand" that Dale Gribble was on about in King of the Hill "Propain."

@Babbling Along <br>Yeah don’t take it the wrong way, I might have worded it badly

@Babbling Along
Yeah don’t take it the wrong way, I might have worded it badly

@depressed scooby doo <br>It’s not “voices” as in the “I think I’m possessed”, but think of it as the cartoon angel and demon on the shoulder or the cricket in Pinocchio, part of it might also be something I heard about called the “Mecosystem”, like your “inner mom/dad”, it’s hard to explain

@depressed scooby doo
It’s not “voices” as in the “I think I’m possessed”, but think of it as the cartoon angel and demon on the shoulder or the cricket in Pinocchio, part of it might also be something I heard about called the “Mecosystem”, like your “inner mom/dad”, it’s hard to explain

@Yovanii Red damn you indirectly called me dead .__.

@Yovanii Red damn you indirectly called me dead .__.

@Aster Risk well im one of those people who dont have inner voices but usually i would think of how it sounds like tho

@Aster Risk well im one of those people who dont have inner voices but usually i would think of how it sounds like tho

@R. S yea i’m terribly with picturing things and “thinking” as if it’s my own thoughts. so my brain makes up another voice to make it make sense to me. also i can’t read books because i can’t picture the words. but i’m not out here killing people lmaooo it’s just brains work weirdly sometimes

@R. S yea i’m terribly with picturing things and “thinking” as if it’s my own thoughts. so my brain makes up another voice to make it make sense to me. also i can’t read books because i can’t picture the words. but i’m not out here killing people lmaooo it’s just brains work weirdly sometimes

@Nutella is disgusting I have two people in my family who say they have never dreamed in their lives, and I knew one guy who only dreamed in black and white, and the dreams were very short and boring. Sucks to be them, I love my lucid, full color, engaging dreams. :V<br>P.S: The people who said they didn't dream aren't all there in the head.

@Nutella is disgusting I have two people in my family who say they have never dreamed in their lives, and I knew one guy who only dreamed in black and white, and the dreams were very short and boring. Sucks to be them, I love my lucid, full color, engaging dreams. :V
P.S: The people who said they didn't dream aren't all there in the head.

@Peter - That's actually scary. Inner dialogue, imagination possibilities, form-playing, music, colors, words, pitches and tones, memories, books, smell relocation, movies, art, and images in my brain have literally never turned off in my life. Just imagining being empty headed is almost like being dead. :l

@Akrasia. You may have an inner voice but it doesn’t look like you can think, lol. Even 1 second of research about this (meaning Google it) would give you an answer as to whether or not it’s true.
You could have done that faster than you typed “I call bullshit”.

Like who cares what you call? Smh

@Angel sosa The thoughts simply don't "sound" like anything. I can see text in my mind, or preferably images. I can also easily skip conscious thinking and simply come to a conclusion based on subconscious processing.

@Angel sosa The thoughts simply don't "sound" like anything. I can see text in my mind, or preferably images. I can also easily skip conscious thinking and simply come to a conclusion based on subconscious processing.

@depressed scooby doo lol yeah. For me it’s just voices telling me to do something like to get out of bed, do hw, etc, sometimes (for me) I argue it’s myself. Also I have intrusive thoughts, those too are audible in my brain. But idk tho bc I usually don’t think at all lol.

@depressed scooby doo lol yeah. For me it’s just voices telling me to do something like to get out of bed, do hw, etc, sometimes (for me) I argue it’s myself. Also I have intrusive thoughts, those too are audible in my brain. But idk tho bc I usually don’t think at all lol.

@Angel sosa "NPCs" don't exist, you just have a superiority complex over other people. I'm willing to bet these people you think have no thoughts of their own are just people who have different political thoughts to you and you've dehumanized them because of this.

@Angel sosa "NPCs" don't exist, you just have a superiority complex over other people. I'm willing to bet these people you think have no thoughts of their own are just people who have different political thoughts to you and you've dehumanized them because of this.

That’s a mistake these people make. Auditory hallucinations are heard coming from outside, not from inside. They sound like actually being spoken to.

That’s a mistake these people make. Auditory hallucinations are heard coming from outside, not from inside. They sound like actually being spoken to.

@Peter - do people actually have an audible voice in their head? I don’t hear it or see the dialogue form, I just think and comprehend. Weird

@Peter - do people actually have an audible voice in their head? I don’t hear it or see the dialogue form, I just think and comprehend. Weird

@Adeptus Fantasticus well, no it’s sort of a stupid ass thing to say that we think in language. What do people born death think? Ya no. Language and thinking doesn’t necessarily go hand in hand

@Adeptus Fantasticus well, no it’s sort of a stupid ass thing to say that we think in language. What do people born death think? Ya no. Language and thinking doesn’t necessarily go hand in hand

@Christ-theKeytldr, while I don't believe most animals are metacognitive, I believe more are than we know and it's only our hubris that keeps us from identifying it

@Christ-theKeytldr, while I don't believe most animals are metacognitive, I believe more are than we know and it's only our hubris that keeps us from identifying it

@Christ-theKey I agree with you, but I think animals simply have base instincts that drive them, the same base instincts that drive us, but they are more controlled by their desires as a matter of preservation, whereas we have, through the creation of civilization, rid ourselves of the base need of perseverance, leading to a hotter adrenal system that is only sometimes activated instead of the majority time being activated in the animals adrenal system.

@Adeptus Fantasticus we have moral laws, i do not believe animals do.

@Adeptus Fantasticus we have moral laws, i do not believe animals do.

@Christ-theKey this is actually a logical fallacy, believing ourselves superior to animals who we aren't capable of recognizing the cognizance of, proof of this is that rats are metacognitive, meaning there are more other metacognitive animals besides humans on this earth. By the way being able to think about thinking is what being metacognitive is, and almost all humans are metacognitive, almost all.

Dude most people don't meta think tho. They don't think verbally, which is why you see slot of people mouthing their words while they're typing or writing or reading, because they don't have a voice in their head they're listening too while reading. I don't know if it's that they aren't thinking tho, I believe if you aren't thinking in spoken language you're still thinking, just in imagery, smells and psychosomatic feelings.

@Peter - wait what? People actually have inner dialog?!?

@Peter - wait what? People actually have inner dialog?!?

@Peter - It's funny how we don't understand each other huh. But let me try to elucidate: I don't have to speak out loud to think. I can sit in silence and think. I visualize and feel. Sounds vague, but I've solved math problems this way, so it can be a logical process.

@Peter - It's funny how we don't understand each other huh. But let me try to elucidate: I don't have to speak out loud to think. I can sit in silence and think. I visualize and feel. Sounds vague, but I've solved math problems this way, so it can be a logical process.

@Babbling Along <br>It’s weird for me but inner monologue/ dialogue might be a strange thing to you, it’s a small difference if you’re able to think out loud I guess

@Babbling Along
It’s weird for me but inner monologue/ dialogue might be a strange thing to you, it’s a small difference if you’re able to think out loud I guess

@Nutella is disgusting <br>These people do dream I think, but I’m not sure on that, but the people that can’t visualize might not be able to dream visually

@Nutella is disgusting
These people do dream I think, but I’m not sure on that, but the people that can’t visualize might not be able to dream visually

@Akrasia. it isn't bullshit it's common. I'm one of those people, I feel like I'm missing out big time lol.

@Akrasia. it isn't bullshit it's common. I'm one of those people, I feel like I'm missing out big time lol.

I never thought I'd laugh so much during a criminal interrogation

I never thought I'd laugh so much during a criminal interrogation

@Babbling Along yea but the fact that you even have inner thoughts is ok its the people who literally have none that are npcs

@Babbling Along yea but the fact that you even have inner thoughts is ok its the people who literally have none that are npcs

@Angel sosa Haha don't worry I have thoughts of my own, I just think non-verbally.

@Angel sosa Haha don't worry I have thoughts of my own, I just think non-verbally.

@Peter - it's true, I am one of them. No voice or voices in my head, no inner dialogue or monologue. I can visualize though.

@Peter - it's true, I am one of them. No voice or voices in my head, no inner dialogue or monologue. I can visualize though.

That inner voice of moral reasoning is the Most High inside of us. That is what sets hue man apart from animal who's drive is primal instinct

That inner voice of moral reasoning is the Most High inside of us. That is what sets hue man apart from animal who's drive is primal instinct

54:36 "Can I think?" Dave Chappelle once joked this is how you can tell whether your bf/husband's tryna concoct lies. "Holdon & just lemme think! Can I think?"

54:36 "Can I think?" Dave Chappelle once joked this is how you can tell whether your bf/husband's tryna concoct lies. "Holdon & just lemme think! Can I think?"

@Akrasia. is supposedly true. Yet I've never met someone personally who is affected by this... which is odd.. I've met at least 6 people... maybe more

@Akrasia. is supposedly true. Yet I've never met someone personally who is affected by this... which is odd.. I've met at least 6 people... maybe more

Hes insane....pretending to be insane...but he clearly enjoyed it. Which almost seems worse

Hes insane....pretending to be insane...but he clearly enjoyed it. Which almost seems worse

@Peter - how is that even possible?! Although I have a friend who talks to herself out loud while alone in public, maybe she's one of those people..

@Peter - how is that even possible?! Although I have a friend who talks to herself out loud while alone in public, maybe she's one of those people..

@Peter - i call bullshit. Where do you have that from? That would be crazy

@Peter - i call bullshit. Where do you have that from? That would be crazy

@Peter - yea theres literally npcs just walking around existing with no thoughts of thier own

@Peter - yea theres literally npcs just walking around existing with no thoughts of thier own

@Peter - My husband is one of those people. Apparently the estimate is 25% of people don't have that inner voice.

@Peter - My husband is one of those people. Apparently the estimate is 25% of people don't have that inner voice.

@R. S <br>It’s even more common than you would think, it’s insane

@R. S
It’s even more common than you would think, it’s insane

some people don't have any inner dialog/monolog/can't visualize, better to hear voices than lack that

some people don't have any inner dialog/monolog/can't visualize, better to hear voices than lack that


Could you imagine thinking "I'll act insane" and picking the evil Victorian-era villain-style hand squeezing to be your go-to crazy move....and then having to do it for years to make people think you're insane? That seems exhausting.


I just watched the video of anthony padilla, interviewing one of the survivors of parklands school shooting and seeing the perpetrator act in that way to make people feel empathy for him seriously is the most disgusting thing ever


Besides being incredibly fascinating, I greatly appreciate this video for making it highly, highly impossible for anyone to idolize Cruz. They called out his selfish attempt to absolve himself from blame for his disgusting crimes. He has <b>nothing</b> to hide his pathetic self behind and I'm glad this video can highlight that.

Besides being incredibly fascinating, I greatly appreciate this video for making it highly, highly impossible for anyone to idolize Cruz. They called out his selfish attempt to absolve himself from blame for his disgusting crimes. He has *nothing* to hide his pathetic self behind and I'm glad this video can highlight that.


I can’t believe this channel is getting their videos taken down. Y’all make the best content and you don’t deserve this!

its a disgrace. the videos are literally my favourite on youtube.


This man really put finger guns to his head and thought “yeah, this will DEF fool them,”

@Weird-Creations FR as someone who is suicidal i have NEVER put a finger gun up to my head???

Reminds me of a guy I dated. He literally once put ketchup (or maybe hot sauce?) on his arm to make it 'look like' he hurt himself. He posted it to Instagram with some edgy quote.<br>I said "Is that ketchup?" and he deleted the post immediately

Reminds me of a guy I dated. He literally once put ketchup (or maybe hot sauce?) on his arm to make it 'look like' he hurt himself. He posted it to Instagram with some edgy quote.
I said "Is that ketchup?" and he deleted the post immediately

That’s totally what I thought you. It made me cringe.

@SamIam _ really though, second hand embarrassment is high through this entire video.

@30minutetesti I remember a kid said that to me and a few days later when I had a panic attack after I got through it when he asked me what caused it (like I’d fucking know) looked him straight in the eyes and said “demons”

Lmao dude really trying to convince anyone while putting finger guns to his head this sht legit made laugh and gives me second hand embarrassment💀💀💀

@J Robb people just said they felt bad for him because he’s incredibly stupid for thinking something like that could work not actually feeling bad

You guys felt for him? This evil, vile person murdered all those children at Parkland!<br>Please don’t feel bad for him - that’s what he wants.

You guys felt for him? This evil, vile person murdered all those children at Parkland!
Please don’t feel bad for him - that’s what he wants.

@skid mark licker LITERALLY SAME THATS WHY I WAS LIKE 👁👄👁

@Dev04 IKR IM NEVER SEEN SOMEONE SO DESPERATE😭

@SamIam _ i had the worst 2nd hand embarrassment from that like just witnessing him do that made me feel bad about myself 😂😂😂

You can even see his smug smile while doing so. He definitely thought he had this all in the bag.

@Heather IM SORRY I LOVE EVAN PETERS AND AHS 😭😭😭

@skid mark licker NOO OMG NOT THE TATE REFERENCE

i was like "oh damn o.o LMAOOO that wil really show em!!"

I keep thinking "what a first class DOUCHE!!!"

Honestly. In situations like that, (why I keep my nails short now) I used to aggressively scratch my arms to where they would draw blood. Always said it was an anxiety thing. But in reality it was a self harm thing. The finger gun to the head thing, is an "edgy uwu fake being sucidal" thing

@SamIam _ There are times when I say I am embarrassed as an exaggeration but this is a rare time when I feel genuine, crippling secondhand embarrassment LOOOL

@Heatherand when he tried “cutting “ and “biting” himself💀

I love how he earnestly thinks he's fooling the detective. He truly believes his horrible, HORRIBLE acting is working.

I'm sure he has had suicidal thought and depression but he is too scared to kill himself

I had to pause multiple times and fix my pillow during that scene

@SamIam _ i wanted to pat his back and said u tried 😭😭

@SamIam _ LITERALLY i felt embarrassed for him when he looked in the camera LOL

this guy  reminds me of fake deppressed kids at my old school<br>"demons man"

this guy  reminds me of fake deppressed kids at my old school
"demons man"

I had second hand embarrassment from that I swear bro😭


The guy who was actually insane was so scary. He was so honest and just had no emotion, and he explained everything like someone would be talking about their day. Nicholas just looks like a twit.


62 million views and only 10 comments? What are they doing to JCS? This is awful. You guys are doing amazing work I hope you’re not gone forever.

Does anyone know why he stopped posting?

@The Senate yeah that’s sounds about right

The whole video got taken down then reinstated, all comments got wiped


This whole thing is secondhand embarrassment. I feel embarrassed to even accept this guy as a human. I now identify myself as an alien from another galaxy.


i still remember the times where it's mostly just true crime fans, being taken down like this for a few times is a badge of acknowledgement that the community is pretty much growing in size


This guy is just roasting the shit out of a murderer for his acting skills for an hour

@invalid-user you are saying that a person that admitted to murder (on camera mind you) is innocent

@Dave -  A lot came out if it for future interrogators. Just because he didn't get a confession doesn't mean it wasn't vital to disproving the kid's claims, and this particular detective knew exactly how to keep him talking by playing the dad role. Which is the toughest part, right?

@Dave an hour of entertainment is what I got out of it

@invalid-user For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life. John 3:16😁

@I Know Look again; video is only 59 minutes

@Dalton Taylor you should actually after that bad baited

@Dave I wouldn't say that.. it entertained thousands of people and has been used as a tool for training in these situations.

@invalid-user damn I hope this is sarcasm

@Daveyou mean apart from the complete analysis of the killers demeanour and delusional state, discovering the motive and the premeditated nature of the murder? Yeah, total waste of time man. You should be a detective.

@user445 a quality bait, I might add, but I could be wrong.

@Dave this one because if so no it wasn’t they literally proved he was faking insanity off it

His interview was literally a waste of time. Nothing came out of it

A thousand likes on this comment in just one hour 😂


I hope someone makes another video platform for channels like this. Interesting content that allows to peak into the dark side of the human psyche not as valuable as people doing stupid banal challenge videos. What an insult to creatives everywhere


I feel like people who commit crimes and then pretend to be mentally ill to “get away with it” don’t know any really mentally ill people in their lives (or at least, don’t have compassion for them). Anyone who’s had to deal with chronic or serious health issues in nearly any facility will tell you how dehumanizing it is. That it takes so much time and effort and money for most “professionals” and “institutions” to tell you you’re exaggerating or faking it anyway lol. It doesn’t make sense how so many people think that that’s a better alternative


Welp, here we are before our comments get deleted too. All the low effort reaction videos are still up, but this one's been targeted, age restricted (at least in my country) and deleted for months. Oh well, it's a damn good video, and the JCS team should be proud of themselves for it. It really succeeds in showing just what a pathetic loser this guy is, and does a better job of de-mystifying school shooters than most mainstream channels do, and it probably has dissuaded some teenagers from idolising these freaks, and from wanting to emulate them.


I applaud these detectives who sit with these murdered for hours sometimes holding back the urges to probably strangle them AND holding back all the laughter at them faking being "crazy"


I’ve watched this so many times and still crack up at “Does the demon know an attorney?” 😂

@unreal one you could call him... A Devil Advocate

They probably asked that because their curious if it’s more than one person that was involved

@unreal one As far as attorneys fees go, that's pretty low.

All that time you spent watching this you've kinda sorta wasted away considering all the other stuff you can do. The covid pandemic isn't that bad anymore so you can't use that as an excuse. I'm just tryna help.

This detective was so savage calling out his bullshit. Love it.

Lol yes I love that.  I also love how the detective nonchalantly mentions how he grabbed the wrong key for a second time, as if that matters at all to this killer who's life has just been destroyed

I did an entire drawing about that line LOL

@Carter Hatfield and his fee is an eternity in hell

The only appropriate response is that the demon is your attorney

But as it only comes between 11 and 12 you only have a short time frame to ask the demon 🤣🤣

What time stamp?

edit: found it xD 56:48


I love your content man makes me sad to see youtube purge some of the most well made, educational, informative content on the platform. This story is insane the fact that this guy murdered that many people because he was bullied and then proceeded to pull the fake voice in my head bullshit like a 12 year old. Who on earth thinks that’s a solid idea even after the entire act. He called himself stupid and he really was Lmfao


Point blank:Youtube killed this channel because it was too popular. The other channels still exist but they're allowed to exist because theyre so small youtube doesnt worry about them causing any family friendly issues. Jcs was just so massively popular youtube didnt want tens of millions of people seeing these things. Which is a shame because jcs an incredible amount of work into these. I can only hope the owners can make a new channel and do something similar one day. Genuinely sorry jcs


What’s hilarious to me is that I know someone with schizophrenia and he always describes those voices as though someone is in the room with him who isn’t actually there, not an actual voice inside his head like your internal monologue is, like the one that literally everyone has. He says it sounds more like it’s behind him, and that’s what’s truly terrifying to me. Imagine you’re just laying in bed, with no possible way anyone can be behind you since your back is against something and you still hear “JOHN!”. Yeah, fuck that


Detective: "Do you see demons, like in the corner and stuff".
Cruz: "No"

Keeps on frantically looking in the corners and all around the room, even though the detective got a clear answer out of him about him NOT hallucinating.
It's almost like he forgot his own act 🤦♂🤦♂

I’m a totally normal person and I see shit in the corner of my ceilings, woww……<br>He can’t even keep up with his own lie 🤮

I’m a totally normal person and I see shit in the corner of my ceilings, woww……
He can’t even keep up with his own lie 🤮


I have no idea why this was recommended to me, but I couldn’t stop watching a whole hour in and now I’m subscribed. Incredible content.

That happened to me a year ago. I'm subbed to probably 4 or 5 JCS style channels now.

Welcome aboard bro, this channel is like a cr@ck addiction

I feel like this is the video most of us started with

Same here! I’m actually going to school to become a victims advocate, so I feel like this channel is perfect for me!

Youtube knows Your demons. And mine too, apparently :-D

I watched this a long time ago yet YouTube still recommends every single day.  Same with other videos.  Is there a way to get them to stop?

yeah we all started on this one ^^ welcome 2 the family we will be seeing you on his other JCS uploads thats a promise hahaha u are now officially hooked :P

LITERALLY ME RN ITs 2 AM BUT I CANR SLEEP UNTIL I FINISH IT LMAO

Every video is great. Just want more!! 🤣

This was ONE HOUR ???? i didnt notice lol

Exactly, People are actually diagnosed with BPD,and bipolar 1 etc and these fools are playing crazy.I like many have a diagnosis of the aforementioned.And these fools are extremely naive.But what I do recognize is fools like this suffer from ASPD without the diagnosis.

Razorsharplifestyle101 Hardwork and dedication

A dog grooming video brought me here...<br>I have no idea what's going on.

A dog grooming video brought me here...
I have no idea what's going on.

the same thing happened to me- it's so interesting!

I'm thinking the same thing. I have no idea whatsoever why this came up in my recommendation. It has actually been showing up for around a week now and I am just getting around to watching it right now. I'm actually surprised that I'm 45 minutes and so far because this is definitely not the type of video that I normally watch on YouTube.

SAME!!!!! I’m glued!!! YouTube is scary good 😅

same here. man. I binge watched all of his videos and get bummed when I have to wait months for a new video. Great videos always.

You too huh I don't know why this is recommended to me either but hey caught my interest

same tbh no idea where the recommend came from but im here now, didnt even realize it had been that long

That’s exactly what just happened to me.

Same, YouTube is clearly on random mode today. Watched this and a documentary on Hyena Gangs in Nigeria today.

same dude same, probably cuz ive been inhaling chemicals

😂😂😂Not sure why it was recommended to me either. Either my algorithm says I'm crazy or I know crazies.

Demetri, it's recommended to you to observe your baseline. They are looking at what you do online when you think nobody is watching. Then they will ask you later and see if you lie.

If I were you, just walk away. Don't click on anything. Don't say anything. Anything you do can be used against you.

I remember watching this on the news. That dude got life. What he needed was life in solitude.

@Miguel Barajas all of his content is absolutely not on YouTube, he states on his Patreon that all future content will be hosted on YT but his previous 36 episodes will stay on Patreon for viewers/contributors to stream. This was posted by him on July 31, 2020.

I have no idea where you're getting this "he doesn't get money from his Patreon" thing given it was and still is an active community. I've been a subscriber and contributor since he launched it.

This is a ridiculous conversation. Can't even make a suggestion about helping people get content they haven't seen without some know nothing running into the comments section and "wellll akkksshhuually"-ing it.

@Miguel Barajas all of his content is absolutely not on YouTube, he states on his Patreon that all *future* content will be hosted on YT but his previous 36 episodes will stay on Patreon for viewers/contributors to stream. This was posted by him on July 31, 2020.

I have no idea where you're getting this "he doesn't get money from his Patreon" thing given it was and still is an active community. I've been a subscriber and contributor since he launched it.

This is a ridiculous conversation. Can't even make a suggestion about helping people get content they haven't seen without some know nothing running into the comments section and "wellll akkksshhuually"-ing it.

@Jared Smith JCS was having problems with the Patreon, I know he told all his subscribers to stop paying because he doesn’t see a cent of it anymore so all his content is here on YouTube

I came across this page earlier this morning <br>I done watched four videos definitely a new subscriber. Love these videos

I came across this page earlier this morning
I done watched four videos definitely a new subscriber. Love these videos

@Jared Smith where can I find that? I want to watch all of the videos they are so interesting

Make sure you check out Jim's Patreon, too. You can toss him a dollar a month and get access to like 30+ other videos.


I wonder how many times I've seen this video. Very fascinating. I am not a psychology major, and yet the interview that was conducted with Nick was very intriguing. The detective work is insanely good, without me knowing at all what qualites a good detective should have when conducting this sort of investigation. Thank you for sharing this, truly.


I couldn’t imagine sitting across the table from someone who murdered my sibling. Absolutely horrible.


imagine being a lawyer for this guy, having to manage the courts for this pathetic little man


I was watching a documentary without knowing it was about him, and was shocked to see it was. This video doesn't put into motion (for me anyways) the gravity of the situation, but God that documentary shows everything. Kids were videoing everything, it was horrible.


“Burn, kill, destroy”<br>This man’s inner demon sounds dangerously close to plankton

“Burn, kill, destroy”
This man’s inner demon sounds dangerously close to plankton

AHAHAHAH 😂 that was such an unexpected funny comment. Thank you

Reminds me of that Courage the Cowardly Dog episode with the mutant carrot. "Grow! Expand! Ex-PLO-O-O-ODE!"

@Ash Lee I was wondering if I’d see someone else say this lol what a throwback

Sounds like the Mad King Aerys Targaryen 😂

"what are the evil songs you listen too?" "panzermensch." everyone that knows the lyrics to panzermensch: its about german tankers not about demons

Hahahah Damn I almost fell off my chair reading this 🤣

@Okc
->dangerously close to plankton
ROFL, that was a next level response!

Krush Kill n Destroy (KKND) is a classic old-school RTS game.

"F" is for fire that burns down the whole town! "U" is for uranium... Bombs! "N" is for NO SURVIVORS!

Can't believe that was on a kid's show 😫😂

oh! c'mon, my demon demon are so much worst than that and still they would never ask me to arm myself, in fact they are the one who prevent me to do it, they saved my life once...

Actually reminds me of half the 6 yr olds I come in contact with.

Omg JAHFHJSJA<br>Words can’t describe how proud I am to be the 666th like

Omg JAHFHJSJA
Words can’t describe how proud I am to be the 666th like

"Burn, kill, destroy, steal Krabby Patty formula"

I guess he needs to learn how to be more insertive

out of the terrible video this guy is in this comment made me laugh my ass off thank you haha


I never knew any of the people that unfortunately found themselves within this tragedy or any of the parents of the victims, but I genuinely hope that each one may recover from this horrific event to some extent, and I am incredibly sorry for all the people who had lost their lives.


I laughed so hard when he was aiming his fingers to his chest 😂


Every so often I come back to this channel and rewatch your videos. I really miss the in-depth analysis :(


I can’t believe bro made finger guns to try get out of a murder conviction