Thanks for putting me in first place. It really means a lot.

Is bolder glad he made it to the honarabul mentions

Maud I love you X100 P.S. your name is so cute

Im imagining a emotionless and sarcastic voice with this wholesome comment lol

ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽

Hey,were pinkie?I need a b day party by tomorrow!!

Yaaaaaa...no i think he was to the real maud bie wich doesnt exist

Hi Maud Pie
You ARE the most memorable
That's it
You ARE the most memorable

@Mauricio Fuentes Same I have a good Maud impression And how is like at the rock farm Maud. I bet it's fun........

Hi Maud! I have to ask, what is it like in equestria?

Maud Pie You are my favorite character from the pie family since you're relatable

Maud Pie I read this in the Maud voice. :D


I knew Maud was going to be #1. She is actually my favorite character from s4. I don't just like her because she is "humorous," but that her character development is not like the other ponies. She is just straight/serious about everything, and that even with that, she can show love and affection for her family, just like what you said. But I loved how she also taught the other ponies a valuable lesson. She taught them that how they are so different, they are alike in many ways. (This was also used as the lesson in Equestria Girls!)

And while you mentioned him in the honorable mentions, I would've put Sea Breeze as #5. I honestly didn't know who you were talking about before when I first saw him. He should be on the list b/c he is a great leader and is wise, in my opinion.


If you made a top ten list for most memberable characters from the whole show number one would be discord like who could forget him

@Sawtooth Waves I love your videos Sawtooth Waves🦄🦄🦄

@°•Lunatic•° the person probably meant starlight and twilight would be on the top ten list for most memorable characters from the whole series.

@Yamam Sami Starlight was first introduced in season five not season four and twilight is the fuckin main character

@Yamam Sami I mean Twi is the fucking main character

Another two are Twilight and Starlight <br>OBVIOUSLY Who would forget them

Another two are Twilight and Starlight
OBVIOUSLY Who would forget them


He likes cats?? I OFFICIALLY LIKE THIS GUY

Dog Haters Disagree But I agree Cats and dogs are Cute I just Like cats More cause they don't hate me like dogs

ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽


tbh, i actually completely forgot about claude........

I was about to ask who Claude was and then the video started.

he's not that memorable really I fogot a bout him in jilust 1 hour😐😐😐😮

@emma bailey Derpy is best background pony!!!!:)

+Nataly Flores yes se won  my vote o for is poll


Yep,Maud is one of the ponys I remembered from S4, but coco pommel is just so cute,actually one of my favorite background ponies. Cool video btw!


Eternal night would be apocalyptic, no sun means no plants and thus no food, everypony would starve to death. Tirek was more of a direct threat though, and the most violent one since the Changelings.

but he took Twilight's alicorn magic after she raised the sun so eternal day... which would also burn the plants and break the breathing cycle of plants.


You're right. Who could forget Maud Pie? I'm only on season two of the show, yet I've seen bits and pieces of that episode in Youtube videos, and now I would recognize her anytime!


To be completely honest I didn't even remember claud until I watched this video.

@ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽 a pupeteer who looks like he could be Snips dad

ᴅᴏʟᴏʀᴇs ᴍᴀᴅʀɪɢᴀʟ👂🏽


I remembered Coco, but not Claude before you mentioned. ^.^;


Hey, i know a lot of people would like to see Coco Pommel again after that ep

She was cool, I just didn't find any memorable qualities that made her character stick out to me. It's just my opinion though!


I would like to see some reappearences of these characters in the future (but not terek) because the writers added a lot of characters, they might be adding them in the future. For example when Babs Seed appeared, she reappeared later on, along with Shining Armor, Sunset Shimmer, and Trixie.


I actually liked the episode "Pinkie Pride". Cheese Sandwich was a cool and funny character.


If we can add non-new characters. Applejack. Was in almost every episode and definitely had the best moments in it.


Not a bad list at all with Tirek on top. Another pony that personally made an impression on me was the Daring Do collector from "Trade Ya", I liked that she was soft behind her rather hard shell (and I actually liked Seabreeze for the same reason). And that poor crippled mare from "Leap of Faith" who spoke two lines. I thought she was very cute and likeable!


Well, Coco made a second appearance, unlike four of the five ponies on your list. Also, Silver Shill also was a main part of the Rainbow Magic stuff, so he should be on the list. And finally, Trenderhoof. He is memorable because he's annoying, ugly, and cruel to one of my favorite characters!


you know I forgot all about Kind Sombra but I would love to see him coming back somehow but after we saw his horn flying in the air I think he will come back because of a magical disaster and target Twilight because she is the one who found the crystal heart andd caused his defeat


Huzzah! Maud got first! Also, while it is true that Tirek does convey elements of black magic, his powers were more supposed to be evil than Satanic. The overall look of him is a look that's supposed to convey another mythological creature, try and guess which. Tirek was actually a villain from the first generation of MLP. Love watching your videos man, hope you're excited for the next season like I am.

@Cody Ohlerking
And Tirek has Hooves, Horns, goatee, and a red-ish complexion.
I'm sure that any satyrs, if ever presented in the show, will look more like goats.

No problem man, The only reason why I say he might not be based off Satan is because Satan is usually based off a satyr.

I am HYPED for s5. I know that Tirek is a centaur based after the G1 villain (I made myself watch that episode and it was pretty bad to say the least lol) But maybe the original was designed to look satanic. Many depictions of satan show a red or black goat like figure. His horns is what made me think that. idk. I'm probably wrong haha. Thanks man! /)


I personally would swap Cheese and Maud's places. Maud is cool and this is your list and I also respect that. I'm just pretty big into Cheese.


maud seems to keep her facial expression very well. like it was carved into a stone...


Boulder should have gotten second place. I could never forget about Boulder, one of the most memorable of characters.


along with goldie being memorable, notice how similar she not only acts and seems, but also appears to Pinkie?


"you couldn't forget these people if you tried"

When season 5 came out everyone that watched that episode was like Maud pie who when I mentioned her


I thought Silver Shill and Trenderhoof were also pretty memorable
also Suri and Coco
actually all the key-givers were memorable


I've memorized the first poem Maud states in the episode she appears in. And I promise (I have my right hoof raised) That I did not just hear/read this before typing. Welp, here goes!
Rock
You are rock
Grey
You are grey
Like a rock
Which you are
Rock


Maud was the most memorable for me, too.


Speaking of boulder, me and my mom always make jokes about that. That is defintely one of the funniest episodes of season 4!


Goldie was so memorable that she was brought back in another episode.


Grrr, Tirek is memorable because he's from G1, and was actually cooler in G1 - but I certainly did a doubletake in excitement at a returning character.


Im just going to say this, the oonly reason Tirek was even memorable to me, was because he was a remake of Tirek from the VERY first mlp episode of g1 (which it was actually a special episode)


These are my top 5 most memorable ponies of Season 4:
#1-Coco Pommel: I don't know why, I just WOULDN'T be able to forget her!!!
#2-Tirek: Of course I couldn't forget him!!! He's one of the main villains in the show!!!
#3-Cheese Sandwich: He's funny and hilarious...and he seems like a perfect match for Pinkie Pie!!!
#4-Maud Pie: Hilarious in her own way...and she REALLY loves Pinkie Pie!!!
#5-Mane-iac: Another villain...in a VERY interesting episode!!!


I think you should add Suri polomare reason why is even though she'd  stolen  raritys fabric design if she didn't rarity wouldn't have created her hotel chic line of clothing so in a way Suri did her a favor Suri made raritys line even better


tirek is an origianal a character in mlp and was first inroduced in mlp G1 so technicly he is memorable in mlp to the writers and that's why he's probably back


How about the rest of the breezies and the Tazzlewurm?<br>Well, about Tirek, the original Tirek came from the first generation of MLP, in the episode which I believe is the pilot episode of that generation: Rescue At Midnight Castle. Not to mention they also added the first ever eternal night idea thingy. (Which somehow never showed up in the first generation of MLP).

How about the rest of the breezies and the Tazzlewurm?
Well, about Tirek, the original Tirek came from the first generation of MLP, in the episode which I believe is the pilot episode of that generation: Rescue At Midnight Castle. Not to mention they also added the first ever eternal night idea thingy. (Which somehow never showed up in the first generation of MLP).


Wait, what about Maud's cutie-mark? I've always wondered what it was (of course, it is most likely a rock)


Coco is actually pretty sweet and quite popular.


Huh. I actually don't know who I would put on a list like this, but I am pretty sure Claud, Goldie, and Tirek would not be on it. I would not have gone with Tirek because he is not a "Pony", and to me, Claud and goldie were pretty forgetable for me, the prior being a plot device, and the latter being a resolution device giving a mostly expected answer.


Coco Pommel should have gotten an honorable mention at least. I mean, she's like a Fluttershy/Rarity love child.


I have a good video idea. Who is Twilight's favorite friend out of the main 6?


Why don't you like Coco? She was my favoritie from this season.


I love Weird Al!!!! He makes great parodies~!


"I could totally become the crazy cat person"<br>I have 5 cats. One is a kitten. I am the crazy cat person.

"I could totally become the crazy cat person"
I have 5 cats. One is a kitten. I am the crazy cat person.

5 that's all, I can top that!

....

I've got 15 cats.
1.   Midnight
2.   Starlight (no i did not get it from MLP)
3.   Ginger
4.   Leo
5.   Spice
6.   Lilly-pad
7.   Sunshine
8.   Peony
9.   Willow
10. Blacky
11. Shy
12. Koto
13. Intruder
14. Shibby
15. Luna


I swear u got that picture of the satan monster from a doctor who episode if I remember my doctor who correctly their was a monster that looked like that

@Avery A. Being I read in Mac impression

The Brony Notion Yay!!!! We were right!!!!

+Kimberly Evensen (Kimmycat7) sorry  wrog perso

Yaaas it's David Tennant, from the first episode with the Ood. (At least in the regenerated season)

@The Brony Notion I agree that she looks happy to be in first place

@The cat gamer btw that wasn't just a Monster in the episode but the Devil himself ;)


Gummy should be on the list. I love it when we go inside his head and he is so deep. I laughed so hard


"Top 5 memorable ponies of season 4"

Tirek is not a pony...

He's a centaur, which is half horse and half man, so I guess it counts.


Chimera! I don't think you've noticed, but I'm a pretty big fangirl of mythological creatures.


Obviously Tirek, Cheese Sandwich, and Maud.<br>Tirek was a main villain, Cheese Sandwich is 1. Weird Al Pony, 2. The pony everypony ships with Pinkie, and Maud is Pinkie Pie's sister

Obviously Tirek, Cheese Sandwich, and Maud.
Tirek was a main villain, Cheese Sandwich is 1. Weird Al Pony, 2. The pony everypony ships with Pinkie, and Maud is Pinkie Pie's sister


Uh... I bet anypony can forget Goldie Delicious, but I agree with you with MAUD BEING NOT FORGETTABLE! MAUD PIE 4 EVER!! :D


I just realized in the Last episode of FiM

Pinkie named her child "Little Cheese"

But I can't put my finger on any pony whould fit the bill as Little Cheese's father……………Or maybe…………Could it be Cheese Sandwich ?


It's hard to even remember Maud is related to PinkiePie


if anyone has seen the show 'Teen Titans', Maud Pie looks like raven


I agree though Tirek didn't have any character he was the most threatening villain so far

He also was the first villain in mlp histroy that was created he was g1s first badguy


I had actually forgotten about claud the puppeteer.


I think that Soultide Boltune is a most worthy mention. Due to his inability to cope with his diverged personality, he's shown that he is omnipresent in more than one pony body. If you'll recall in S2:E7, there was an odd pony in the background with a Laphraford Dominicus Solarid-tide CM on his flank. Remember the grey scarf and recall the blue tie? Although these do not change in any form he takes, his body does. If you got this Saw Tooth ( or Sawtooth?), I hope you take this background character into consideration. I would be more than thrilled to see one of my most puzzled over BC give some spot in the limelight~ signing out from one YouTube legend to another, this Avirex Galaxy. Bro hoof and God speed, fellow YouTuber. :{ )

He's talking about the most remember able characters of season 4. Not season 2.


2:06 every time hear the name "Clint Eastwood" I can't help but remember the Gorillaz Sing :P


The sun is needed to warm us and grow our food. If Nightmare Moon, or, as I think of her, Miss Moon, had not been overthrown, then the ponies of Equestria would have starved to death- if they didn't freeze to death first.

But we don't know Tirek's character well enough to know if he would leave the ponies to die.

that may be true, but tirek stole their magic. Without magic, pegasi cant tame the weather. Earth ponies cant grow food. And unicorns cants do magic. And alicorns cant raise the sun/moon.


I like Coco. The one I forgot about was the one who gave applejack the bit. The disguise one. The one who worked for Flim and Flam. I don't even easily remember his name And I know all the ponies.


Can you do Top 5 Most Memorable Characters of Season 5? 💖💖💖


#5 Silver Shell
#4 C-Breeze
#3 Dr.Cabaleron
#2 Cheese Sandwich
#1 Muad Pie and Bolder


Tirek was inspired by the G1 villain of the same name.


You forgot to add chrysalis to the villain list and tirek didn't have what magic she had left.


Wait who's Claud?

I really forgot all about him

Goldie I remembered her the most


i think cats are most adorable creatures in the whole world...even more adorable than babies...cats are just crazy, cute and funny...thats how i love them


and the number one most memorable pony in season 4 is...... twilight because she is also in every other season


oh my gosh I LOVE CATS SO MUCH!!! and my little pony and doctor who!! (we have a lot in common actually!)


you forgot Queen Crystalis (I cant spell it)<br>She is a Villian, maybe she just didn't make the cut in being really EVIL

you forgot Queen Crystalis (I cant spell it)
She is a Villian, maybe she just didn't make the cut in being really EVIL


my favorite character from season 4 with cheese sandwich like I love how he is played by Weird Al and he was just like so amazing and at first I didn't know he was played by Weird Al but when I found out I was so amazed because I loved Weird Al and I just can't believe cheese sandwich was played by Weird Al I just love teasing much and I love Weird Al long-lived cheese sandwich and I hope she's sandwiches in another there episode later on his cheese sandwiches amazing


Maud and cheese sandwich are both new favorite. Also your obsession of cats and being messy reminds me of someone I know XD


<b>sees cheese sandwich, starts to sing "Now That's What I Call Polka!"</b>

*sees cheese sandwich, starts to sing "Now That's What I Call Polka!"*


YOU CANT FORGET QUEEN CHRYSALIS, WAIT... SHE IS IN SEASON 4 :(


Wait wait wait! How come twilight has to defeat tirek at S4 instead of Princess Celestial? Celestia was the first one in MLP before Twilight  .
After twilight became a princess.
To me it looks like princess celestia wants twilight to defeat all the villains. Celestia did defeat Discord, But past it to Twilight.
Could celestia be a coward? Cuz in all Seasons 1 - 4 (5) Twilight all defeat the villains.

+Abigaille Reyes No, All this time Celestia is in a weird way her teacher,  she is preparing her, she could just defeat the bad people with one spell, interesting thought though :).


I can relate to Goldie's grey saddle bag cat


Maud reminds me of a kid in my class,<br>She NEVER and I mean NEVER smiles!!!!!

Maud reminds me of a kid in my class,
She NEVER and I mean NEVER smiles!!!!!


Cocoa Pummel is like one of my favourite character /(ㄒoㄒ)/~~


D:
I just had a TERRIBLE thought.
Levi from AOT (Attack On Titan)
and Maud somewhat act the same.. how they don't really show how they feel, and their..expressions..
But of course, Maud was never a thug...and Levi does smile...once or twice...
(Not in the animated series, and not fanmade)


I would have forgot Claude if you didn't remind me of Snips and the way he said " plenty of room for MAH PUPPETS."


CHEESE ALSO WORE A FEZ!!!! My life was complete when I saw Cheese Sandwich wear a fez.


Coco Pomel! :3<br>But I soooo agree with your #1

Coco Pomel! :3
But I soooo agree with your #1


mrs harshwinny because she is one of the few mares who have seen that has a unique face and facial animations, manny others including the main 6 are recoloured templates with a new hairdo (few exetions like mrs cake and granny smith), but good god Harshwinny looks like she is drawn and animated by someone else entirely, she is the most visually memorable to me at least.

That is true, but I think she was introduced into the series before season 4 though


Duh, flash sentry from threes a crowd,that smile well getting on the train though. We all know it was at twilight

Oh it is im ever so sorry for the trouble i caused

@BEAUTIFUL SABRINA <br>No it's the eleventh episode in season 4

@BEAUTIFUL SABRINA
No it's the eleventh episode in season 4


Does Maude remind anyone of Juvia from Fairy Tail?


Top five most memorable characters from the show
Discord
Starlight
Cozy glow
Derpy
Flurry heart


Goldie is prob one of my personal faveorite character because before mlp I have had and still have a ginger cat with green eyes who always trashes things and his name is Goldie he was named that before mlp started


You called the episode "most memorble PONIES" yet Tirek doesn't exactly count as a pony. Neither do SeaBreeze, Boneless, Boneless 2 and Boulder.

@RubberyCat<br>and i call a CHICKEN = scootaloo :D

@RubberyCat
and i call a CHICKEN = scootaloo :D

@***** I refuse to give an actual reaction to a comment that is lacking in grammar.

@RED Soldier<br>I call Boneless a CHICKEN!

@Bronya Stagg Boneles still doesn't count as a pony, no matter how alive he is...

@RED Soldier you KINDA wrong because to Cheese and Pinkie, Boneless is real. Either that or Cheese never had friends and created a best friend from a rubber chicken. OMG we could make a fanfic about Cheese and Boneless' history together!

@Shivam Kamil Then how do you explain his horns?

Tirek is half-human half-horse, but those other four...

@yinyuck13 Maud isn't bland, she's just different from all the overly-excited ponies in Equestria. Heck, I know someone who's alot like Maud, and he's a great person to talk with.

@RubberyCat no SEABREEZE SHOULD'VE BENN #1 ATLEAST HE ISN'T BLAND UNLIKE SOMEPONY <b>points to maud</b>

@RubberyCat no SEABREEZE SHOULD'VE BENN #1 ATLEAST HE ISN'T BLAND UNLIKE SOMEPONY *points to maud*

@RED Soldier
I agree.
Fully.
However, I do agree with Maud being at the top :D

@Waterfall drop Filly Yes, it *does*. It's a very misleading title.

@DocWolph That doesn't explain SeaBreeze, Boneless, Boneless 2 and Boulder. One is a Breezie, two of them are rubber chickens and the last one's a rock.

Tirek is a technicality. He is a demonic centaur.


mmmmmm......Lightning Dust......?! I mean, she did get a place in my brain for reckless wonder bolt.


I can relate to goldy d. In the same way


!!! i literally just watched that episode of doctor who! gosh i feel like such a nerd for knowing that haha


In my eyes discord would win even though he wasn't in the running 😀😡


As soon as I saw number 5 go off the screen I forgot about him. He is very forgettable. What is his name even, again? (no I'm not using that to make a point, I seriously forgot his name)

Same i don't even remember one single thing about him :D


I'm not sure if you have made a video about this, but can you do an analysis on Maud's cutiemark? Thanks!


I remember all of those except the puppet guy


I would replace tirek and place the one from the my little pony episode were rarity got the gift that girl :)<br>


I think at the end of season 6 the episode should have the new characters from season 5/6 there to show the mane 6 the are inportent


Also,Maybe Pinkie and Cheese sandwich are brother and sister?You know how Siblings sometimes fight,Those two Fought the WHOLE episode


To be honest I remembered Coco better then the puppeteer


I don't know, after Inspiration Manifestation I never thought about Claude.


I just realized Maud's cutiemark is Tom!


Does Cheese remind anyone else of Kalin Kessler (Kyosuke Kiryu) more than Clint Eastwood?
No? Just me?
ok. :(
Does anyone actually know who Kalin is?


@Ollie Noir Wolf Yeah... I am a little late....

@Lunaknight 364 I think you're a little late with this comment. If you read the comments following the one I'm suspecting you read, you would see that this whole thing was resolved in 2014.

@Ollie Noir Wolf Apple Jack is a very good character, people should like her more.

+Margaret Baca that's my life!😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻🐱🐱🐱🐱🐱🐱🐱🐈🐈🐈🐈🐈🐈🐈🐈🐈🐈🐯🐅🐆😺😸😹😼😽🙀

Pixel Pixie     CCCCCAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATTTSSS

Hi! Thank you everyone for sending stuff to me!

@ihascookiequake 123<br>It has pointy ears the mouse one has round ears

@ihascookiequake 123
It has pointy ears the mouse one has round ears

+Pixle Pixie My childhood wish was to have a cat

+Ollie Nogitsune Wolf <br>(Snicker, snicker) Not trying to be mean, but i am laughing at right now!

+Ollie Nogitsune Wolf
(Snicker, snicker) Not trying to be mean, but i am laughing at right now!

+The Brony Notion <br>Dude, you should find my comments and read them. I really need your help with my first video!

+The Brony Notion
Dude, you should find my comments and read them. I really need your help with my first video!

THESE ARE MY REAL LIFE KITTY'S 😺😼😸😹😻😽😿😾🙀 yes I own all of these Kitty's and those are they're personality's!!
😺she is always lovely and always cute
😼she is mean to the rest of my cats she's like a bully
😸she is full of saying meow and always thinks its a joke
😹he always takes things as a joke
😻she is very kind and guilty for what bad she does
😽he is a lover
😿he is fighting over depression (true story)
😾she is a greedy cat
🙀he is always sick

these a re my real life Kitty's and these are they're true personality's😺😼😸😹😻😽😿😾🙀 MEOW MEOW MEOW

+Pixle Pixie <br>YOU GET ME ALL OF THE CATS😻🐱😺😸

+Pixle Pixie
YOU GET ME ALL OF THE CATS😻🐱😺😸

OOPS WRONG WAY I MEAN<br>CAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATTSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

OOPS WRONG WAY I MEAN
CAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATTSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

:3
CATS CATS CATS CATS!
CAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATS!!!

@EvilSteven Steve Sheets
CAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATS

@SunlightDash Toast<br>Lol that's okay, it happened to me as well and caused a HUGE sh**storm, so yeah, also that was my reaction too!

@SunlightDash Toast
Lol that's okay, it happened to me as well and caused a HUGE sh**storm, so yeah, also that was my reaction too!

@Pixle Pixie im sorry, my sister got ahold of the computer and wrote this on my behalf. sorry. now let me say what i would have said.
ehem...
OH MY GOSH IT DA BRONY NOTION!!!!!!!

@SunlightDash Toast<br>I never said I hated her, she's just my sixth best. And also, I just said that Notion inspires me, just calm down dude, I never said I want to be exactly like him! And your telling ME to get a life, the one that is looking through the comments of a My Little Pony analysis episode?

@SunlightDash Toast
I never said I hated her, she's just my sixth best. And also, I just said that Notion inspires me, just calm down dude, I never said I want to be exactly like him! And your telling ME to get a life, the one that is looking through the comments of a My Little Pony analysis episode?

@Pixle Pixie APPLE JACK SHOULDNT BE LIKED THE LEAST!!! she's not MY favorite, but I don't hate her!!! and no pony likes fan boys! or in this case fan girl. you need to find your own path! don't just slave away trying to be like The Brony Notion!!! he's great but please...GET A LIFE!!!

@The Brony Notion<br>Eh hem, sorry, I am a huge fan!! You were my first Brony Analyser and are a huge inspiration to me, and really want to make my own analysing is magic vids but i don't have the time, money or equipment :-(. But keep doing what you are doing, you are amazing and you couldn't be better at what you do (and you like applejack the least, me too!). I hope you one day get to 1 mil subscribers!! And if you already do then CONGRATULATIONS!!!!! Also plz don't start swearing like other Bronies cause then I won't be able to watch, thank you so much!!

@The Brony Notion
Eh hem, sorry, I am a huge fan!! You were my first Brony Analyser and are a huge inspiration to me, and really want to make my own analysing is magic vids but i don't have the time, money or equipment :-(. But keep doing what you are doing, you are amazing and you couldn't be better at what you do (and you like applejack the least, me too!). I hope you one day get to 1 mil subscribers!! And if you already do then CONGRATULATIONS!!!!! Also plz don't start swearing like other Bronies cause then I won't be able to watch, thank you so much!!

@The Brony Notion<br>OH MA GAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IT'S THE ACTUAL BRONY NOTION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

@The Brony Notion
OH MA GAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IT'S THE ACTUAL BRONY NOTION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


I'm thinking maybe you should be on the TV programme "The Hoarder Next Door".


You should put Seabreeze from it isn't easy being a Breezy


haha oops! I guess I just meant from the show. :P


+The Brony Notion actually, tirek is from G1, so he isnt from s4, same with breezies ( but isntead of G1 is G3 )


Hey +The brony nation remember that one time line you had where when each villain was defeated and return well I think terek was the one before and after sombra!!!!


When he looked at the villains he forgot to mention Chyrislis


Hey! My dad was a good villain! He gave even celestia nightmares


I have a theory about Maude. Although many of you probably won't read through the whole thing, here we go anyway.

I think Maude is introverted.

Now before all of you just put hate below, let me explain. Introverts get their energy from keeping to themselves, and often spend quite a bit of time doing their own thing. Throughout the episode, Maude seemed tired when spending time with the rest of the main six, even to the point of just leaving after a bit.

Maude also seemed to know that getting along with Pinkie's friends was super important to her, and she knew nearly straightaway that it wasn't working out. You think this would make her appear a bit worried, disappointed, or even just really sad. She almost never expresses her emotion throughout the entire episode (the exception being at the end when she smiled talking about how much she loves Pinkie Pie) Introverts are better at reading emotion rather than expressing them. This also explains how she knew the main sixes' feelings towards her so early.

It's just a bit of food fir thought, but I think it makes a lot of sense. Leave a comment saying anything you think I forgot, as well as your thoughts on this theory.


MAUD PIE  YESSSS   THE BEST CHARACTER  IN THE WHOLE SEASON XD


Maud Pie deserves first place.

(Also, aren't cats the best-?!)


Okay so if i remember right Tirek is in s4. And i was watching one of your old videos ( i don't remember what xD) luna is s1 and and you know what...<br>And Tirek is s4! Meaning ( if im right ) he was banned before sombra? I dont know xD just a guess i guess :) keep up that work!

Okay so if i remember right Tirek is in s4. And i was watching one of your old videos ( i don't remember what xD) luna is s1 and and you know what...
And Tirek is s4! Meaning ( if im right ) he was banned before sombra? I dont know xD just a guess i guess :) keep up that work!


I ♥ CATS! Every type of cat! Especially big cats like lions! ( I also like dogs.)


Coco pommel, suri polomare, prim hemline, dr caballeron, ahuizotl, ak yearling and the dazzlings (if they count)


Actually i totally forgot about Claud the puppeteer...


i can always forget clauad and then remember cocoa its my buiss!


C Brezzie should be at no.1 cause he is too cute to forget and so are the other brezzies


i think you should take fluttershy 's brother, marble pie, lemon pie and twilight 's parents


so i have somethink on my mind.. when discord was singing the "tiny glass of water" he sayd the word cheese sandwitch and a in the very next episode cheese appeird ? isnt this weird? here's why i think that: http://www.deviantart.com/art/Cheese-Please-447061555


What I don't get is how the funniest jokes on MLP are all related to rocks.  There has to be something to analyze about that.


ok so I know the person who voiced cheese sandwich his name is weird al yankavic he's a comedian that makes a lot of music parody's including white and nerdy, and a lot of star wars stuff and my uncle once worked with him


You should make more top 5 mlp chachers in season 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, and if you watched season 8 put that on


Derpy hooves should be on the list she it's everywhere


I would have said Tom was memorable but he's in season 2


My little penny i didnt rlly hear but what about Derpy Hooves if she isnt in season four she should at least be an honorable mention @The Brony Notion


In the villains you forgot queen Chrysalis


I already forgot about claud actually... and Goldie delicious <br>and I think that lightning dust should be here, wait... was she in season 4?  am pretty sure she was

I already forgot about claud actually... and Goldie delicious
and I think that lightning dust should be here, wait... was she in season 4?  am pretty sure she was

+Yulia Fabrikant lightning dust was season 3.


Boulder obviously should have been #1. Hooves down best character.  :3


You should do something like what is Muad pies cutie mark if she even has one. She always wears a dress covering her flank


1:19 Nice Doctor Who Reference ya had there Notion.


my best friend is crazy about cats. when she comes over, first thing she does is look for my cat frisky


Maud pie reminds me of raven from the teen titans.


the mane 6 are the most memorable chas of season 4.


Tirek maybe my Favorite Villain <br>Maud Pie Rocks

Tirek maybe my Favorite Villain
Maud Pie Rocks


Goldie Delicious Is At The Series... When The Apple Family Knows About They're Parents

How About Flurry Heart?


Who else forgot all of them after one day


Your missing the most member able character Slender Mane he is awesome and you can see him a at a specific time in pinky apple pie


Right when you got to Goldy Delicious my cat came and sat on my lap! :3


1:55 I always call him as 'Chesseburguer' xDU


Trek was sent back to his home before sombra  and nightmare moon and discord


I like Pinkie better than Cheese for these reasons:
She's a girl
She's completely pink
She's hilarious
I don't know what else


i just realized that Claude from mlp looks like the puppet master in Pinocchio<br>cowinsadince I THINK NOT

i just realized that Claude from mlp looks like the puppet master in Pinocchio
cowinsadince I THINK NOT


Why are Princess Celestia and Princess Luna called Princess's when they are technicly queen? And you forgot one of the villians. QUEEN CHRYSILIAS!!!!


To be Honest on who I would have liked to seen on the list is Scorpan (I think that is how you spell it( Tikreks brother for his understanding of friendship and beytrayle of his brother to alert the alicorn sisters. If my brother was.....Whatever tirkek was I would not DARE cross him :I

Wait who's Scorpan? Is He A Villain. (reads the rest) OH! now i remember!

@The Brony Notion He is in G1, I believe it was Rescue from Midnight Castle. /)

That was an interesting part of the story. I would like to see Scorpan's story expanded on.


Maud,Cheese sandwich and coco are at a tie for most meber able  ponies here they are in meber able order for #1 maud,coco and cheese sand witch


I think that Seabreeze should be on the list


Lol, I really do have a Maud Pie T-Shirt on right now


Threatening to Terri but not danger that's my new alicorn can you guess


HOW COULD YOU NOT INCLUDE DARING DO?!?!?!?!?!?!?!??!?!?!?!?!?!?!


Alright here's a pony missing from the list...COCO PHOMEL!!!!!!


Maud is Wednesday from the Addams family.


No chrysalis?<br>Tatzlwurm?  Zipporwhill?  The griffins in the Equestria Games?

No chrysalis?
Tatzlwurm?  Zipporwhill?  The griffins in the Equestria Games?


i think coco pamel deserved to e on the list


speaking of weird al.. you forgot to me mention the at cheese sandwich is played by weird al.


I AM CHANGELING PINKIE!!!! ( come on Chrissie needs some joy)


Nice joke with Boulder boneless and boneless 2 XD


Tho I have to admit cheese is kinda cute <3


Soarin we see another side to hem then just a pie lover


coco. i will remember her always because i 1 piece of art with her in it


For the first pony you menchened
theres a character in Monster High
named Claued but spelled different

i like cereal but I am NOT a cereal killer_


Tirek is not a pony. But I think that the power ponies should replace Tirek.


the only pony i remember is Swanky Hank<br>i mean look at his freakin colour!

the only pony i remember is Swanky Hank
i mean look at his freakin colour!


Also #1 should have been the fake sick discord or regular discord


equestria would have been screwed if tirek would have appered at the start of season 1, 2 or 3 lol :D


Who's the most important? Twilight princess of course. 🐎🐴


I didn't remember any of them, other than the last 2 Cx


MAKE MOST MEMORABLE ANIMALS p.s. MAUD IS HILARIOUS


that's funny, because I would have never remembered #5 and #3 if you hadn't said anything.


cheese sandwich and maud are best ponies<br>after flutters

cheese sandwich and maud are best ponies
after flutters


Actually I don't think maud is the most memorable character in fact,she is a blooper!!!when you see pinkie pie's past maud is a dilly with gray hair and purple skin but now she seems to be the opposite (purple hair and gray skin) so I think that's a HUGE mistake by messing up a character!!!REALLY HASBRO!!!!! Maud is an imposter now!!!!!


I am similar to goldie I love cats and my room is a pigsty even when I clean it it becomes messy in seconds


I like how made the reference of weird al and cheese sandwich!


I have always wondered.... does Maude Pie have a cutie mark?

When she saved pinkie from the rock you'll see that her cloth open a little and shows a rock diamond cutie mark


then there is me knowing all of the ponies they named in the show UvUz


Maud is so opposite of her sister because pinkie saw the sonic rain boom and became happy because she was depressed and that's how pinkie is party lover and maud is well a rock pet owner


I think Maud Pie might have Alexithymia. It's a rare disorder where a individual can't express emotion.


Well guess what I forgot Maud WHILE I was watching Maud pie so GUESS WHAT UR WRONG no offense


Remember that background pony in manehattan with the grumpy cat cutie mark?


i just realized that your oc has the body of a mare!


BOLDER IS MY FAVE PERSON IN MLP GO BOLDER!!!!!!


I have a question. How did u make a pony of yourself?


Doctor whooves should be on the list make a vid about him


what do you think is maud's cutey mark. i can't spell. i think it might be rocks but it could be something else, because we have never seen it.


he said  he likes  cats, I am  wearing  cat socks and a cat hat right meow.

pun intended


0:24 YOU CLODS! XD Steven umiverse rocks. (get it??)


anyone gonna mention where tireks arrow kinda points to....


I wish I can sync bring Amber them but I just can’t


Was Safire shores in s4 because I remember her


Ummm Tirek's Not a pony... Maybe I Forgot Something xD


I have 6 cats
Boys:
🐱Ash is a little kitten that is lovable colour:black
🐯Rupert is a big cat like garfield  colour:ginger
🐱Twinkie is like ash but not a kitten colour :black
🐺Bissa is a little adult cat colour: grey
🐱lucky is a big black cat colour black

girl:
😻Tink is a lovely cat that we saved for getting squashed on the mane road colour :black


Cats are the most popular house pet I heard that on the wiki so dogs lose


Hmm.... I wonder what Maud Pies cutie mark would be?


I think Coco and Fleetfoot. :3  But yours was good too.

Also...this was uploaded on my birthday! :D


I Know This Is Late But, I Think The Shadow Pony


Tirek is not base on the satan . he is base on roman centaurs mythology. in roman mythology centaurs were aggressive and have horns unlike they friendly Greek self

@XxMarshmallow PuppyxX  not many people know that. most people think Roman and Greek mythology are interchangeable. i was just pointing out the  show used Roman mythology. he may know he may not but i prefer point it so he does not leave it behind next time

J marine he nose he just used dat pic cuz he felt like it


Thou when u we're discussing about tirek u said he took all the magic of the ponies in equestria but actually I should say that he took all of the ponies magic "except " twilight and her friends and discord and spike

+Riza Chica Nope. He HAD their magic at one point. What he didn't have was the magic of their friendship which was released at the tree of harmony through the keys.  But their own personal magic so to speak was gone.


I can look at cheese sandwich and forget him


Should me oc be a changeling or a griffon??


maud is too much like norway, sweden, iceland and japan. halp.


for who i tought should have benn is drum roal please derpy!!!! see he in the background!


I didnt remember 5 that much and 3 i forgot the name


I don't care what anyone says... Cheese is most memorable and best pony(along with Pinkie)

There was this au on tumblr where Anna was too late to save Elsa and she became queen.

*looks at ur username* but Anna....ur a princess...Elsa is a queen

**looks at ur username** but Anna....ur a princess...*Elsa* is a queen


I literally forgot everyone in this video<br>At once

I literally forgot everyone in this video
At once


yay maud...... :I i have never been more excited in my life :l


YASSS KITTY CATS ARE DA BEST! #Favoriteyyoutuber  #Mostrelateableyoutuber


My classmates ask me if I'm a cat or human,🐱🐈meom meow🐱


cheese sandwich is related to Wird Al Yankavink


i forgot the puppetier in less than a hour


i dont know i think goldie should be before tirak


Claus fly shouldn't have been on the list………


hey i have a question it looks like you made your OC on Pony creator am i right?


#5 who? Oh wait, him
#3i thought he was a apple family hoarder
She has cats

#1 Really?!? REALLY!?! Come on dude seriously...


Who ever is upsesed with cats is just like my friend


i think pinkie is the dauther of granny, you maybe can to reserch about that ?


And I forgot to mention that I forgot Claud


That one black and white cat reminds me of Japan cat... I don't know why..


Plenty of rooooooooom for mah puppetzzz
-Claude... Puppeteer

*Plenty of rooooooooom for mah puppetzzz*
-Claude... Puppeteer


For a minute, I thought the title says "miserable" haha


My fav from season 4 which o shall never ever forget BONELESS🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 boneless 2 is pretty good to


In season 9 pinkinpie has lil chesse with cheese sandwich


umm well I think daring do should be on list 🐴🐴🐴🐴🐾🐾😺😺


Did anyone else realize that Owlicious was probably still in the tree house...?

@Twyla Cousins
Are you for real?
Owl is owl.
Not much of powers or abilities of anything.
So, my deduction leads me to assume that you are somehow misinformed on what a "Mary Sue" is, and should read up on it.
(All the other possible assumptions is directly degrading, indirectly degrading, or assuming things you do not seem to have any motive for, so the only remaining probability is you being misinformed.)

@Twyla Cousins How the F()&K is she a MAry Sue?!?!?!?!

Actually Twilight had Owlicious in her arms as the house exploded so he's ok!


here is a question for a video is MLP roman base or Greek base


cheese sandwich and pinkle pie argue about the best regards


Plz make a vid on why cadence is only on 4 or 5 episodes


most memorable PONIES
shows rubber Chickens and a rock XD
i mean Breezies r technically ponies...


Hell naw!!!!!!! No pony surpasses pinkie pie she's hilarious cheese sandwich is not even close


During the video up until #2 I was just thinking cheese sandwich cheese sandwich cheese sandwich cheese sandwich cheese sandwich cheese sandwich cheese sandwich.


I'm like you Brony Notion im a Goldie Delicious 2.0 I LOVE cats they are so cute loveable and adorable


your missing slender mane in pinkie apple pie yes its true....


i knew it was maud pie ( im not lying :D )


Maybe this isn't a character, but a tree? THE GOLDEN OAK LIBRARY WAS REPLACED BY AN EXTREMELY UGLY CRYSTAL TREE. I know that the Golden Oak Library was since season one, but STILL.


Pinkie pie fluttershy shining armor twilight sparkle <br>


I honestly hated Cheese Sandwich. In my opinion he was more annoying than funny.


so cute 😍😘😗😙😚🤐

so cute 😍😘😗😙😚🤐


I WILL BECOME A CRAZY CAT LADY I AM ADDICTED TO CATZZZZZZZ. No seriously I have more than 90 toy cats plus two real ones


And who's Claud I don't I have seen that episode before


TREEHUGGER! I HEART HEART CATS I HAVE 1 CAT THAT THINKS SHE'S A DOG (JUST TAKE MY WORD FOR IT ITS TRUE, SHE TRIES! TO PLAY FETCH).
P.S. IN THE WORDS OF RAINBOW DASH YOU ARE SO AWESOME!
:-D


I hate cats one because I'm allergic into because it messes with my asthma and I'm highly allergic to it like I need an EpiPen for it🐱


I don't think the puppeteer was memorable


2 of course how can anyone forget the one that maid pienkie kry ( I only hate 3 ponies he's one)


claud the puppeteer hmmm don't think i've seen that episode


I forgot most or all of them well I remered tierk and cheese sandwich


BUCK YOU! BONELESS DESERVED THAT TOP SPOT!


maud pie your silent and sweet I wish I could be like you


wow i thought cocopomel would make dat list but okay !


can you make a video about the my little pony equestrian girls  rainbow rocks movie?


Go Maud   go Luna go.......DISCORD???????😆


Honestly, I completely forgot who Goldie Delicious was until he explained it...


cheese pie or pinkie sandwich. Either they should date. WHY HASN'T MY SHIP SAILED like if U agree


omg u are just like me! i <3 cats AND my room looks like a dumpsite XD


The guy with blue hair in the wonderbolts acabemy


the crazy old cat person that is me too : )


CAT'S CAT'S CAT'S CAT'S CAT'S CAT'S :3 I LOVE CAT'S


What About Zury polem  and coco pomell from rarity takes Manhattan ?,:(


Whattya mean by "parodoxically interesting"?


all of y'all were commenting about Claud and i had no idea who u guys were talking about


I am like goldie because my room is all ways a mess and i have 4 cats


Bolldor sould be in list becesze i like rocks and  i name a rock rocky


Excuse me... not trying to be annoying I probably already am but what um... pony creator thing do you use? Cause I kinda want to make my own oc. If you can tell me I'd be super happy! Thank you!


Cat obsession, you and me both brony notion


Boulder is best pony... Er... Pet... 🐉<---- not awesome  ( Boulder ) AWESOME!!! <del>---</del>> 🌑

Boulder is best pony... Er... Pet... 🐉<---- not awesome  ( Boulder ) AWESOME!!! -----> 🌑


caaaaaaaaaaaaaatttttsssss 😻😻 I'm like Goldie😻😻😺


I sher her obseshon with cat and kittins and my rooms Aymes


1:18 AAAAHHHHH THE NOTION WATCHES DOCTOR WHO AAAAAHHHHHH!!!!!


Everyone I see in here is talking about coco but......who is coco


maybe a top 10 videos of season 4?? pls answer this PLS again??

@Shane Claire Ragay and you missed the vampire fruit bats


CAT POWA!!!! 😺😺😺😺😺😺😺😺😺😺😺

CAT POWA!!!! 😺😺😺😺😺😺😺😺😺😺😺


slender mane XD no i saw him in the show


goldie is like the old version of applejack


cats rule💞💖💗💕🐅🐆🐈🐱🌈🎆🎶

cats rule💞💖💗💕🐅🐆🐈🐱🌈🎆🎶


Twilight is the most popular pony in my little pony


when you say Mod pie I btend to show her in my hand!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Hey the brony notion tierk is not a pony and the title of this episode is 5 most memorable PONIES not creatures


Sombra is best vilan discord doesn't count

@***** i like sombra because 1. black 2. king 3. cape


Lol I see what u did there....... Weird Al


ok the puppet pony i forgot 5 mins after the episode is done and i never remeber him intile i see this video


Interesting. They suppose they are memorable.


Alright here's a pony missing from the list... COCO PHOMEL


Cheese sandwich doesn't even compare to the super duper party pony tat pony is me pinkie I was the hole reson he was ever a party pony in the first place (tats the pinkie me talking)


eternal night would be the worst cuz that means no food


+Molly Murphy Coco Pommel Rarity's friend?☺

Yeah but somtimes I have to totally agree with him


do not ever say that thats just pinky  will all ways be the funnyest and wildest pony


Reply if goldie is a cat horder! The person with the funniest reply gets a su scription for me!


How old are you? Lol btw awesome video!!


I love cats so much. I fanted and mist the video🐱🐱🐱🐱🐱🐱🐱🐱caaaasssts


My name is weird al!
But now I'm a pony!
I never acually hugged a girl!
Can't believe I just said that
RAINBOW DASH YOUR FACE IS FAT!
Cmon and try my CHEESE zoomba fad!!!


Idk who else should be on the list sorry


Had to do it at some point, so I brohoofed the screen.


what about mauds pet rock it is also memrable


CATS RULE🐈🐈🐈🐈🐱🐱🐱🐱😸😸💙💙💙💙💕💕

CATS RULE🐈🐈🐈🐈🐱🐱🐱🐱😸😸💙💙💙💙💕💕


I should be in that list because I am not I will eat all your apples 😋


You forgot somepony drumroll please (drumroll starts) he is scary SLEDERMANE OR SLEDER PONY yep I said it him in the episode of my little pony him and im in a dark room and im scared now


my thorey is cheese sanwitch is based on weird al XD


i still dont get cheese sandwitch s cuitie mark come on his talant is not eating cheese sandwitch


what obut a villin that is queen crislis


I love cats too they are the best animal ever I am not a dog person  no offense to people who like dogs


yes. she my 3rd favorite after twilight and rainbow dash


Doctor who pic !!!! I will comment every time u use one


extras u forgot extras i think i am spelling that corect


WHERE THE HECK IS DERPY!!!!!! SHE MA WIFU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


i forgot aabout ALL of them just put wierd al first PLZ!


I where fezs now fezs are cool cheese sandwich /doctor who reference


Who is sambra                                           JK

Who is sambra                                           JK


The puppeteer from "Inspiration Manifestation"


Wut about  slender pony in pinkie Apple pie


lol brony  notion life is bettter if u have cats :P


And so cute and so cute and the first half of a new 😇👈👉💋


Did  you  know  that  that  the  actor  playing  Cheese  Sandwich  is actually  Weird  Al 😰!?

I love Cheese Sandwich and I love Weird Al! They're just random.


I cannot agree anymore then I do now I'm happy I'm always happy and I would like you to know that

@The Brony Notion I 2 am a cat person!!!!


Yes I 2 em going to be the crazy of Person


So obvious

Not... you didn't even spell "Weird" right


Can we be friends 😊🐚⭐<br>Please. Please please

Can we be friends 😊🐚⭐
Please. Please please


HI You SSSSSSSSSSSOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO SWAG! HI


I hate cats and cats hate me cats are such haters


I don't think they were most memorable..........


No f***ing internet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!UGH SOOO ANOYING


Like for Coco Pommel.<br>Comment for Suri Polomare.

Like for Coco Pommel.
Comment for Suri Polomare.

@Mr. Brony 88 for coco and 4 for suri polomare but nobody likes suri cuz she a cheater

THE SAME THING! LITERALY IF YOU WERE A YOUTUBE WOULD YOU LIKE TO READY 50 COMMENTS THAT ARE NOT IMPORTANT THIS IS WHY MOST PEOPLE DONT READY COMMENTS ARE THEIR CHANNEL!  please stop wasting the my, the hundred people reading that and the brony notion.

So it's all tied up at 2 votes for each!