kind: youtube#commentThread

kind: youtube#comment

textDisplay:
Since the portal only opens every 30 moons (Months?), it's likely that Sunset's departure through the mirror was maybe 2 1/2 years or 5 years before the events of 'Equestria Girls'.

 It stands to reason that when the mane six received their cutie marks, and Twilight was picked up as Celestia's new prize pupil, that this also happened after Sunset's departure.


textDisplay:
Moondance, Lyra, minuette and the rest I think were meant to be fillies when the sunset flashbacks were happening, meaning it takes place about 10 years before the events of Friendship is magic.  It's an estimate of course.  As for time paradoxes of sunsets age, it is my belief the two worlds function differently with time.

At least it is until Twilight ties a new mirror to the magic within the book making a permanent portal.


textDisplay: Nothing like a late comment😁 but this took place before Twilight became Celestia’s student


textDisplay:
Hi and thanks for the great reaction! A few suggestions/requests for you to react to that I have are:
-Snowdrop-MLP Fan Animation
-Fall Of The Crystal Empire-MLP Fan Animation
-Katy Perry~ Dark Horse (sung in MLP Voices)

Thanks again!

textDisplay: I’ve already reacted to snowdrop and fall of the crystal empire if you want to check those out

textDisplay: @PonyBro I Guess :) definitely

textOriginal: @PonyBro I Guess :) definitely


textDisplay: You know rainbow road trip isn’t available


textDisplay:
Here is a links to Equestria Girls Friendship games deleted scenes And a version of What more is out there just encase you haven’t reacted to them. I’ll try to find a playlist of the Equestria girls Summertime shorts. If I do and you don’t have another video up expect another comment on this one.

Here are the links deleted scenes:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=x7c4ki7Gs7c

Deleted song:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Y4E3KPiha_Y&t=7s


textDisplay: Yaaaayyy booyyy

textOriginal: Yaaaayyy booyyy


textDisplay: I knew you had it in you to react to this fanmade MLP short, dude. Feels more canon when you see how well this short connects both MLP and EQG.

textDisplay: Well the story itself is from the MLP comic, they just put their own spin on it 🤍


textDisplay: You should so react to the other side. Rarity sings it and it’s from the better together series


textDisplay: 3:10 PonyBro The voice of Sunset Shimmer is a very talented voice actress. Wubcake has a wonderful voice for Sunset Shimmer. Celestia taught Sunset 1st then Twilight. In the Comic The Fall of Sunset Shimmer. There is a seen were Princess Cadence is with Filly Twilight. Sunset is older then Twilight. When Sunset Lost her way & goes through the mirror. That’s when Celestia starts to teach Twilight the magic of friendship. I hope that helps you out. Keep up the good work. Have a wonderful day.

textOriginal: 3:10 PonyBro The voice of Sunset Shimmer is a very talented voice actress. Wubcake has a wonderful voice for Sunset Shimmer. Celestia taught Sunset 1st then Twilight. In the Comic The Fall of Sunset Shimmer. There is a seen were Princess Cadence is with *Filly* Twilight. Sunset is older then Twilight. When Sunset Lost her way & goes through the mirror. That’s when Celestia starts to teach Twilight the magic of friendship. I hope that helps you out. Keep up the good work. Have a wonderful day.


textDisplay: Make another ponytown video but in vc

textOriginal: Make another ponytown video but in vc


textDisplay: Yeah this can't be cannon because sunset is going to school with moon dancer, minuet and others whose name I can't recall at the moment.(you know the ponies twilight went to school with as a filly at celestia's school of magic and are depicted as being about the same age in the show). Also sunset was celestia's student before twilight as stated by celestia herself.<br>It's a great animation and an amazing story, it just doesn't fit in with the information we have in show. Still I give it 9.5/10.

textOriginal:
Yeah this can't be cannon because sunset is going to school with moon dancer, minuet and others whose name I can't recall at the moment.(you know the ponies twilight went to school with as a filly at celestia's school of magic and are depicted as being about the same age in the show). Also sunset was celestia's student before twilight as stated by celestia herself.
It's a great animation and an amazing story, it just doesn't fit in with the information we have in show. Still I give it 9.5/10.

textDisplay: This video isn't suggesting that Sunset wasn't a student before Twilight. The start of the video where you see Celestia and Luna being together is the present day, basically during the beggining of the Eqg movie. Then, Celestia goes to Twilight's room when she is sleeping with Spike (right before Sunset would come in and steal Twilight's crown). Then, Celestia goes to the mirror and then she touches it . When she does that, she remembers the old days with Sunset, that's when the flashback starts. All of Sunset's story is a flashback that Celestia remembers and then after the flashback ends, we're back to present day,Twilight going through the mirror. This backstory is from the comics

value: UCQuClKjMJJBzSJKzxdZxfKQ


textDisplay: i am fivth

textOriginal: i am fivth


textDisplay: This reaction was stellar 👌

textOriginal: This reaction was stellar 👌


textDisplay: Thank you for accepting my request for this means alot i adore this animation thanks again


textDisplay: Sunset is voiced by Wubcake! She voices Sunset and Adagio in a lot of fan projects.


textDisplay:
Every time I watch this particular MLP video, I cannot help but be in awe of the overall visual designs (characters and backgrounds). Even the voice acting is spot on, really good!

I’ve read the comic based on Sunset’s backstory and it was very interesting. I really like how the premise of that story was interpreted in this fan animation. Minty Root did an amazing job making this pony animation. Thanks for checking this one out, PonyBro.😉


textDisplay: reac audio drama remembrance episodes pls


textDisplay:
Basically it close to the canon story it takes place after the first EQG movie. Celestia has a flashback to the betrayal and on the other side of the portal sunset is having a nightmare. So the story switches between Sunset telling the girls and Celestia telling Luna.

It hints that the timeline of sunset Betrayal is the same day as the Sonic Rainboom event.

The comic has an scene where twilight as a little filly without a cutie mark is seen with Cadence who is an alicorn in the book.

They miss the twilight scene in this animation.

Believe or not Sunset Shimmer was a small girl after crossing. Which spawn the theory that portal turns you into the correct age as you are acting. Since Sunset was a grown or nearly an adult mare throwing a temper tantrum the portal turned her into a five year old girl. It isn’t shown but there is a flash and a scream. And on limited editions there is a line. I will have my revenge Celestia!


textDisplay: Nice reaction! 😍 It would be really cool if you reacted to "My little pony in a nutshell.“ There is a viedio to almost every episode, and the videos are usually only 3 minutes long. (Sometimes longer)

value: UCZOwgejWARKgOscAN-Acvtg


textDisplay: This animated film is so good...

textOriginal: This animated film is so good...

textDisplay: Agree,it literally took up to the next level


textDisplay: My understanding is that the first scene of her seeing twilight asleep and going to the mirror was present day, around the first eqg movie. then after she touches the mirror we enter a flashback to when sunset shimmer was still in equestria. then in the end when she touches the mirror again we go back to our right before twilight goes to canterlot high.


textDisplay: Friendship is the most important and difficult thing to master in MLP... and real life. Seriously though, the person who made this should be in charge of animating a full length feature with a high budget. Imagine what could be done with more resources.


textDisplay: Although they took liberties on the story, this overall storyline is from the MLP comic series; and was a really good arc. It was flashbacks mostly in this video. The comics show Sunset is older than Twilight, but not an "adult". Sunset is like.. preteen/teenager age when Twilight was a filly. (So another comparison maybe, Twilight is a Freshman when Sunset is a Junior or Senior) Moondancer was only added because the other white unicorn with a red mane.. that was the OG Moondancer. So the animation had literally 2 Moondancers in it, the old and the new lol.


textDisplay: Are you going to do reactions to the Ink Potts animatics?  Dr. Pinkie and Ms. Pie and The Count of Monte Cristo?


textDisplay: Could u react to the fan animations by Animated James? These include the Sonic vs Mlp series and others like Mane 6 Cartoons.


textDisplay:
This was taking place during the first Equestria Girls movie. When Sunset returned and stole the crown, it brought Celestia down memory lane as she recalled her relationship with her former student. Notice that Luna walked up to Celestia near the beginning, but the next time she set the sun, Nightmare  Moon's shadow was all over the moon. During those times, it was a flashback.

The animation style of this reminds me a lot of the My Little Pony movie. It has that floaty animation style. This also matches "Road to Rainbows" movie because it was done by the same crew as the MLP movie.


textDisplay: I'd love to see you react to Scootertrix: The Abridged

textDisplay: I will be soon

textOriginal: I will be soon


textDisplay: @ 5:06 Anyone else found it strange that two versions of Moondancer are in the same dimension?


textDisplay: It starts off at the beginning of Equestria Girls, then flashes back 30 plot years.<br>(still salty the show never explained how long a "moon" is supposed to be)

textOriginal:
It starts off at the beginning of Equestria Girls, then flashes back 30 plot years.
(still salty the show never explained how long a "moon" is supposed to be)

textDisplay:
It is supposed to be just 30 cycles of the Moon (about the same as a month).
-> The "30 Moons" of wait would have meant that Princess Twilight (& Spike) would get "trapped" in another world for more than 2 years [a sad thing, but not a true tragedy].
Note: Luna was talking about the "Moon Cycles" of the "other world" (since that is what Twilight would had to observe IF she fails to return to Equestria in time).

.  Sunset Shimmer must have "skipped" at least ONE oportunity to return to Equestria (since Celestia said to kept the mirror in her throne room, waiting for her to come back).
. There is circumstantial evidence that 8 "Mirror Cycles" passed since Sunset Shimmer went into the Human World ("Pedestria") & her return in the first Equestria Girls Movie ("Through The Mirror").

. She was registered as a "new person" [since she aparently lacks a counterpart] not long after crossing the mirror. She was not a baby, but rather looking exactly like she does in all the movies: a teenager (the transformation made by the mirror "locks" the shapeshifted pony preventing all aging, this also seems to have happened to the Dazzlings).
-> This is also why Sunset Shimmer is only now taking classes in a highschool [since the "papers" say that she is within the "right" age to do it]; unlike Princess Twilight who just "usurped" the identity of Sci!Twi without realizing it [Canterlot Highschool & Crystal Prep Academy do not share their private databases]; so Principal Celestia only had the basic "National Identity" information from the last Census to check out (that simply says that a "Twilight Sparkle" of the apropiate age lives not so far away)].

The reason Sunset Shimmer is so skilled on EVERYTHING (including fine hand coordination for things like drawing, painting or playing guittar) is because she has being practicing for almost 2 decades in a body that never changes.

textDisplay: @Argamis (SilverComet) Interesting theory, though I kinda figured the Dazzlings/sirens were immortal from absorbing the life essence of others, up until their gems got shattered.

textDisplay: @Strebiskunk They are STILL "un-aging" (not the same as inmortal).<br>-> They needed the energy to power their "glamour" powers (mind control), so they can get housing, food & comforts for free [now they have to actually work to live].

textOriginal:
@Strebiskunk They are STILL "un-aging" (not the same as inmortal).
-> They needed the energy to power their "glamour" powers (mind control), so they can get housing, food & comforts for free [now they have to actually work to live].


textDisplay: While a lot could be explained as being flashbacks mixed with the time around the first EqG, the presence of Moondancer and other current day ponies with Sunset definitely makes this a weird one, possibly suggesting that Celestia was tutoring both Sunset and Twilight at the same time, but neither being aware of the other


textDisplay: Calestea is forcing friendships on sunset not like what she did with twilight Sparkle


textDisplay:
Sunset was clearly blinded by greed and selfish ambition.

Moral: There’s more to value than what you already have. Start anew.


textDisplay: Pinkie is like 👁👄👁

textOriginal: Pinkie is like 👁👄👁