The true power of Grogar is still present in Equestria. The power of time, the power to make them Forget. Every legend in Equestria´s history is real. Discord, The Pillars, The Pony of shadows, even Nightmare Moon was forgotten by ponysociety despite Celestia´s presence.  <br>The world keeps forgetting Things to be real. Daring Do puts artifacts Long forgotten by Society or dimissed as old Maretales into Equestrian Museums and is forgotten to be real by Equestria. They have no Fantasy books. "Honesty is imperative." ~Neighsay. Might as well be a rule for Equestrian Writers.

The true power of Grogar is still present in Equestria. The power of time, the power to make them Forget. Every legend in Equestria´s history is real. Discord, The Pillars, The Pony of shadows, even Nightmare Moon was forgotten by ponysociety despite Celestia´s presence.
The world keeps forgetting Things to be real. Daring Do puts artifacts Long forgotten by Society or dimissed as old Maretales into Equestrian Museums and is forgotten to be real by Equestria. They have no Fantasy books. "Honesty is imperative." ~Neighsay. Might as well be a rule for Equestrian Writers.


TBN: I want to start posting regularly!
Me: starts crying I'M GLAD I WAITED!!! IT WAS WORTH IT!!!!!! WELCOME BACK BUDDY

TBN: I want to start posting regularly!
Me: *starts crying* I'M GLAD I WAITED!!! IT WAS WORTH IT!!!!!! WELCOME BACK BUDDY


I think Grogar had a hand in the Griffons history too.  Before the reign of King Guto and the Arimaspi attack, Griffonstone already had 13 kings.  The stories of the Idol of Boreas made the griffons a force to be reckon with, and the Arimaspi looks very goat like so maybe Grogar created the Arimaspi to steal the Idol of Boreas.


That was a very interesting theory. :) I think I might accept it as my headcanon. :)


Hey can you figure out how long a pony year is (like how fast they age compared to real time or seasons) or figure out a timeline?


brony my little changling friend, you do have good thoughts there but there are older series of mlp that grogar was a part of that i think you should see. the series is called my little pony' n friends. the episode is called the return of tambelon. it was the first showing of grogar and his power as well as his bell and gusty who freed the ponies.


7:09 Are you trying to claim that Grogar was like the British empire taking land from the Native Americans?

Justin Carawan - CarawanCo.PuzzleProductions CCPP


Grogar didn't set NMM free, the spell undid itself at exactly 1000 years


Just go watch the old my little pony and learn grogars history there. These seasons of mlp completely ruined the aspect of the old one about how grogar was actually defeated.


can you do a theory on how magic made coz glow an alicorn?


its been confirmed that celestia  let out nightmare  moon since she controlled the stars, celestia knew that the main 6 had to do it because she has dreams of future


Even though Friendship is Magic is over the fandom will live on and there's no way in hell that I'll be watching G5 because G5 cannot top this and I'm gonna stick to G4 even if it kills me!!


The earth ponies either had an army and helped Gusty counter Grogars' land based forces, or worked behind the scenes supplying Gusty and her unicorns with whatever was needed. If for some reason they were not involved, then due pony egotism the legends of Gusty are probably seen as Unicorn and Pegasus propaganda and largely ignored.


So its a good theory Grogar actually created the harmony of the ponies at the beginning. If Grogar wasnt a Discord fake, he could have an interresting manipulation to destroy what he technically had caused.


Not only would it make sense but it honestly would line up with the Old Gen's own episode against Grogar as both Unicorn and Pegasi fought against Grogar and Gusty was one of the unicorns in that episode.


Here's a random thought. Older Twilight was wavey hair like Celestia and Luna. How come Flurry heart and Cadence don't? I thought it's because unlike Cadence and Flurry, The Sisters and Twilight have or had control the the sun or moon or celestial things. What's your opinion on it?


You're alive! Oh thank goodness! Keep up on doing these awesome videos!


I wonder if in Grogar Final Act he created the windigos to destroy the ponies out of revenge.


One flaw is that the tribes are not from Equestria, as the HW tale tells us that they came to Equestria from the North(?) . In fact the original pony homeland is most likely the Crystal Empire.


Great ! I love your vids and i cant wait for you to start doing them fortnightly😀😀😀


Hey love your work but dr wolf has a recent video and he has evidence that Celestia moved the stars to help nightmare moon escape but I do like your theory just like to point that out 😊


YES I WANT YOU TO REVAMP THE CHANNEL SO BAD!!! And although g4 if over you can still remwatch and come up with new theories like your genius self does and you can do g5 and g4.5 (pony life) stuff! YAYAYAYYA!


Actually, it was celestia who let nightmare moon out from her prison. Lauren faust said it on Twitter. So...


Yass TheBronyNotion is back again! 😁<br>I missed you and your theories ❤

Yass TheBronyNotion is back again! 😁
I missed you and your theories ❤


Could you please do who are discord’s parents or if grogar might be his fauther possibility please.


And then Lauren Faust basically said that Celestia orchestrated Luna's release


0:17 That P&F referance just made me lough out loud!


Is Grogar any relation to that skull in the lost treasure of Griffonstone?


Why do people notice that one tweet of Faust's, yet completely ignore the existence of her follow up tweet that if it's not addressed in the series, it's not canon? Since Faust's original idea was never addressed, it's not canon. Equally, it can't be canon that the stars were Grogar.

On a similar note, why do you assume that the series ended? You do remember the news of the Season 10 comic, right? There's still time for your headcanon theory to be debunked. And even without the Season 10 comic, there are the other comics to take into consideration. And before you give the argument that the comics aren't canon, there's a reason why I said "series" and not "show". The comics are secondary canon, which means that they are canon so long as they don't contradict the show. On that note, Season 10 will be primary canon, simply because it's a continuation of the show. It's accurate to say that there's still time for the other comics to have debunked canon. But since it's safe to assume that Season 10 will most likely act as an epilogue season, it's safe to say that there most likely won't be a Season 11 (but don't quote me on that, since I have no idea).

The show may be over, but the series is not.

Why do people notice that one tweet of Faust's, yet completely ignore the existence of her follow up tweet that if it's not addressed in the series, it's not canon? Since Faust's original idea was never addressed, it's not canon. Equally, it can't be canon that the stars were Grogar.

On a similar note, why do you assume that the series ended? You do remember the news of the Season 10 comic, right? There's still time for your headcanon theory to be debunked. And even without the Season 10 comic, there are the other comics to take into consideration. And before you give the argument that the comics aren't canon, there's a reason why I said "series" and not "show". The comics are secondary canon, which means that they are canon so long as they don't contradict the show. On that note, Season 10 will be primary canon, simply because it's a continuation of the show. It's accurate to say that there's still time for the other comics to have debunked canon. But since it's safe to assume that Season 10 will most likely act as an epilogue season, it's safe to say that there most likely won't be a Season 11 (but don't quote me on that, since I have no idea).

The _show_ may be over, but the _series_ is not.


I'm sorry to rain on your parade, but Lauren Faust confirmed that Celestia busted out Luna. Not Grogar.


We need to discuss the G1 Gusty the Unicorn
Because when Twilight was reading the story the cover looks JUST LIKE the old Gusty so maybe all the stuff that happened before aka G1 Not G2 and G3 Though
Is part of the history like them living in that castle thingy then the ponies split up then the Grogar time line comes into play then Gusty steps up
But Idk
Plz Like so the Brony Notion can see


This sounds perfectly accurate and I could completely see this what happens oh my gosh wait what if for generation 5 they do before the time of generation 4


Wait didn't Lauren Faust basically hint that Celestia helped Nightmare Moon escape or hinted that she did it herself???


Next can you look into the"Mysterious South" part of the map?


Even tho, as sad as it would be to know that MLP FiM is over, there will be MLP G5 which probably gonna bring something interesting to the table and possibly start a new fandom or revive the old one and convert it.


In this light, Grogar is less like Genghis Khan and more like Cyrus the Great for Equestria ;-)


Whoa! He didn't die!<br>Yes... This video was worth waiting for

Whoa! He didn't die!
Yes... This video was worth waiting for


with the season 10 comics the real grogar might appear


Grogar. The king of Tambleton with his donkey assistant and miss Gusty got a terrible temper


Lauren Faust confirmed on Twitter that Celestia released Luna from the moon.


SpoLiEr AlaRt : Discord know all of Grogar history and plan to make friendship like Grogar done.

Also Cloudsdale hat is best city hat.


I have two theories the first one being that mlp dragons are mammals. And that Spike is older than Smolder.


Me when I was 6: watches this channel daily

Me at 13 seeing him on my recommendation page: oh hey I remember him

Also me: immediately clicks on video


Grogar did not free NightMare Moon. Lauren Faust told us on Twitter that Celestia did it.<br>I guess another "youforgotaboutflurryheart" thing for you

Grogar did not free NightMare Moon. Lauren Faust told us on Twitter that Celestia did it.
I guess another "youforgotaboutflurryheart" thing for you


Okay, love the look-lol feathery things but, why are they a part of your OC now? Why did you decide to add them? Are they permanently a part of your OC now? Keep up the good work! Have an amazing day man!!!

Pom-pom. I meant pom-pom. Stupid autocorrect lol.


Except Lauren Faust stated on Twitter that Celestia helped nightmare moon escape


Is no one going to talk about the elephant in the room?
THE RANDOM FEATHER IN HIS MANE!?
I mean it looks nice but still it’s a bit random...


There's season 10 coming out in comic form and it carries on from the show, so maybe you aren't entirely safe...


<b>YAY</b> you’re going to start posting regularly!!!

*YAY* you’re going to start posting regularly!!!


I hope this isn't a dumb question but, what's with the the leaves on your sprite's head?

Also hey! Its been a while since I've visited your channel and videos


I'm still mad about the grogar twist and twilight awful design


i'm so happy your going to start posting regulARLY NOW!


If you think about it that video you posted about how groagar  got night mare moon out the moon it's very very wrong. Because cozy glow took all magic away after night mare moon was out the moon. You can see in that episode Luna is there. How could something that happend Soo long after be the cause that happened so long ago. Have you even thought about it.


Maybe do a theorie about celestia and luna's parents


there's talk about a 10th season, so don't count your dragon eggs before they hatch


*Cough* Season 10 comics *Cough*

But who cares. Dead Tree Media was always treated as B or C tier canon anyway.

**Cough** Season 10 comics **Cough**

But who cares. Dead Tree Media was always treated as B or C tier canon anyway.


In my theory is that grogar might be discords father.


Brony Notion You need to do a video on the Season 10 comics. The first one in fact will be about Zecora's homeland.


I love this so much. Also why do you have feathers? I wanna see you post regularly. I'm down to be a patreon.<br>Also no pegasi teir?!

I love this so much. Also why do you have feathers? I wanna see you post regularly. I'm down to be a patreon.
Also no pegasi teir?!

@Sawtooth Waves
:D thanks for the reply! And that males sense. What if pegasi become a discord thing? Like your mods are pegasi because they were a very military group? Idk xp.

Also the feathers look cute on ya.

oh hi cameo, thanks for being a patreon!! I only wanted 3 teirs and I had to decide which to leave out. and the feathers are just for fun ^^


Brony Notion's theory seems sound so I will definitely use it for fan-fiction, if you, Brony Notion mind.


Hate to rain on your theory but DrWolf just made a post about a creator of Mlp explaining who broke Nightmare moon out based on my memorie from her statement “Nightmare Moon was freed from the moon by the stars and who are in control of the stars” Celestia. Celestia knows all and can see the future she probley saw Twilight getting the Elements and freed Nightmare ai Twilight can start her destiney but the Grogar aa a consolation is still possible


Celestia released nightmare moon it was revealed by the creator


so many fans raged whee Grogar was revealed to be discord as many wanted him to appear


I think that Furry heart is a changling  or she is under a curse (spell)


You are the most awesomest therisor ever!


I've left this channel for so long...

I'm amped to be back!


Could you explain how if twilight is queen then who rises the sun and who the moon and does Luna even help with nightmares and does unicorns even die. All the other ponies just look older, but unicorns just become bigger and the hair suddenly floats and I never get a haircut


Ironically on my patreon I only have the Pegasus tier XD.


My birthday is in a couple of days and I was delighted when I saw you had posted, keep up the good work. Bro hoof.


Can you do theories about what happened to chaining armour and fluffy heart at the end of season 9


Didn't Lauren Faust hint at the fact celestia freed nightmare moon? :'D <br>Major oof there-

Didn't Lauren Faust hint at the fact celestia freed nightmare moon? :'D
Major oof there-


But Faust said that celestia freed Luna with the stars.


Are you planning on reading the season 10 comic for your theories?


Quick question. What is with the feathers in your mane


And yet Spike is still a chad.

Poor Spike, he didn't need that happen to him

Very good theories and such.<br>Still salty about Chad!Spike

Very good theories and such.
Still salty about Chad!Spike


That was a theory. What is truth:
GROGAR ≠ DISCORD
DISCORD WAS NOT GROGAR


Why am I here? The last mlp episode I saw was from season 3 goddammit... Okay. I'll Watch just this one because this fella seems nice.


I shouldn’t have watched this now I’m spoiled .-. My fault


And why didn't you mention the old  MLP where Grogar was present?


Discord channel name should've been The Brony Nation


The pink thing on your head what is it?

I guess your thinking pink...

Ill be in the corner now


Im sorry to say this but the creators of my little pony answered your theory i kinda quote " who has the power of the sun the moon and the stars??!! princess celestial" I think one of your fellow bronys made a video about that ??


Season 10 is on idw comics so technically they can still throw ya curve balls


I'm surprised that you know about the the "season 10" comic that's coming out soon.


Grogar is in the pony first move in the 90 and he is a Kroll whillen the slave ponys ade make them into dragon ponies and have them to drive groggers sled!


Umm... hey! Really enjoyed ur video but, Lauren Faust confirmed that celestia set nightmare moon free


HAS NO ONE NOTICED THE THING ON HIS HAIR


They should make a spike spinoff series check out in the comments for video name mlp theory is spike a magic Dragon.


Can you talk about  the people from gen 1 and  what  happened to  them because  they are never seen  again  till the Eqg series for a camo


Thank you or this video when it comes to season 9 of My Little Pony there isn't much on grogar 😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁


Have u seen Lauren fausts tweet that says celestia released nightmare moon?


Hey Bronynotion, how about check out the my little pony Disney chronicles on fimfiction.


what if starswirl isn't discord..... but starswirl..... IS THE REAL GROGAR :O


is the show over? Hasbro has confirmed that the 2021's movie and G5  might be conected to friendship is magic by some way and some people like me might say that the first episode was the final episode of friendship is magic but so might not be true so i'm taking to as a pinch of salt

Oscar Kambouris
They confirmed the movie and g5 before season 9 of g4 even finished airing.
We got that news a while ago.
And the G5 world is going more or less going to be connected like the human and G4 pony worlds.
Where one world lies there’s countless others.
So the human world is one but many could connect to the pony world of g4.
Using this logic g1-3 could exist though a portal out there somewhere.
However that’s all it will be connected to g4 a portal.
And the 2021 movie is supposed to bridge the gap between the two.
Give us one final goodbye to the g4 equestria but also at the same time introduce us to g5’s world.

Pony life keeping the G4 Va’s and... it being a G4.5 of sorts we might get them back in g5 just a little different from what we know and love.

Please keep in mind nothing i said here is 100% accurate it’s just what i heard though the grape vine.


Hey dude! nice to see you didn't die, i missed your videos while you were gone :)

also, could i be pinned for no reason? :D


There is a my little pony movie coming in 2021 no joke


ITS BEEN 5MONTHS, FINALLY YOU POST YASSSS


Oof I just got everything spoiled because season 9 isn’t on Netflix yet..


You posted this on my bday! I'm actually a preteen 0.0 11 years!


I thought it is the same goat from ealier generation


Hay did you hear about the comic continuing the mlp season and what Rebecca said about luna’s return


Hey brony notion  can you give us a story on how you got your cutie mark and also please pick my comment if you don't I will be upset but I will understand and if you do I will be the happiest pony in all of Equestria


Where Were You!? I even thought you were Dead!!


М. Түвшинжаргал


Brooooo I watched this like 4 years ago!


sure bro keep doing the channel and more videos but please tell me whats in your mane?...


..... I'm right here..... In case you want to consult me or anything.


Star swirl and Jesse the great are siblings


The Brony Notion if you see this comment go to your first vid about Growgar and then read what i said ok?


Also what's with the thing on your head?


Three months ago, <b>Three months latea</b> SIX MONTHS AGO (joke and also im BOREDDDDD)

Three months ago, *Three months latea* SIX MONTHS AGO (joke and also im BOREDDDDD)


Wow nice hat like if it oh know what I'm talking about


Pega city city pega pega city city unicorn unicorn city city unicorn 🦄 yeah!


Ya I’m sorry for spoiling but discord was grogar !!!!!!!!!!!!!


Everyday sometimes Grow garden Discord Discord is a fun guy and how hard is I mean guy some of them will see where some of them are not it's just that don't between Czar hard in the well in Ponyville everything is nice there they don't fight anymore in the clouds jails the unicorns pegasi and the earth pony on together they don't fight anymore so don't be mean to each other well I don't cars can fly up to the clouds nails if they want to to be nice everyone's nice and ponytail and Equestria everyone lives in Equestria it's just like everyday someones the roller and it's just like combining The Elements of Harmony is nice but crowbarred in the score don't touch the sun shines do funny visit sometimes this word do funny business and he likes Fluttershy but her own guard is a mean guy he likes only evil stuff evil evil evil sometimes someone that gets texts sometimes the Elms harp Harmony is more powerful it's all ponies use your magic and Elements of Harmony and throttle so the Bergen can see if they can all work together and destroy it even some that are not powerful in a little bit it just goes from power and Grace said that all the powers memes funny business and serious business and go to the store and proguard can fight each other books Turbo


I have to say  I  was curious if the pony history


Simply amazing. I personally find it GREAT that you take this step on THEORIES at this exact moment where there are no more CANON boundries for you mistoe upon.

This, you know...until G5 come kicking everyone's backdoor


I'm super excited that you're back!!! Video idea: What does it take for someone to use chaos magic? I think its something worth looking into 😜


Yes you should definitely continue posting, I will definitely watch them.


I’m glad the S9 twist didn’t get you down too much. Your theories are the best in the fandom, and I’m always interested in what you have to say. /)


Glad to see you back! I’ve been watching your videos for..I don’t remember but a few years I’ve always liked your work and theories 😊


I like this theory.  Much like the theory of him using the stars helping NMM to escape, I like to think Grogar has been around for thousands of years and has had a huge impact on several important events effecting Equestria even before it was born.


I'm happy to hear you want to do more videos again!  And I'd love to  hear your theory on what the magic crystals that appeared in the human world in EQG are!


Ok I thought of something, there’s still strong evidence that grogar was behind the mythological beasts by combining animals, and discord is a combination of animals, what of grogar was one of the creatures that made up discord, that would explain discord’s intelligence and immense power while explaining how he seemed to know grogar was real while everypony else assumes he was fake


Hey! I missed you :’) nice theory, really wraps up the whole 3 tribes coming together thing, too bad Faust tweeted about Celestia being the one to aid in Nightmare moon’s escape, I thought your grogar theory was pretty cool, everything is debunked too quickly haha. Anyway, I’m thrilled to hear you say you’ll post more often, don’t feel too much pressure to keep to the schedule strictly, we know life’s busy. Alsoo, not gonna lie, I’m dying for you to post some of the music in the outros you said you would a while ago ^ ^ so please share your music! I love it so much, you’re talented my guy, and once again thank you for everything, it’s crazy to think that I’ve been enjoying your videos for 4 years now


I'm glad your theory still holds up. And I like your expansion of it. When you say that the show is over, remember that we still have a couple of events that might add to the official canon. Not 'Pony Life', which likely exists in its own, self-contained pocket universe! I mean the 'Season 10' comics and maybe the 2021 'MLP' movie.


I'll be honest, I wasn't impressed with most of your previous theories and found quite a lot of flaws with them. However, this is the first theory that, I must admit, makes perfect sense and does fit really well with the history of the ponies. Good job on picking out the details and inferring the theory.


I missed this channel so much! If he does post regularly I can’t wait!


Speaking of the pony tribes unifying on that first Hearth's Warming. I can't help but wonder...did Grogar create the Wendigoes like how he created the other monsters?


Ahhh everytime I see that you posted I want to scream Brand New Pair Of Wings at the top of my lungs and say "HE POSTED A VIDEOOOO". Then I proceed to watch the video with a giant dorky smile the whole way through. You were the first brony analyst I've ever watched and definitely my favourite. Please never stop posting! <333


Okay, so I've made an observation.
Twilight said that Gusty and her unicorn warriors were trying to get to *Cloudsdale*.
This is in the Grogar Era, long before the Windigos came and made everything snowy and forced the 3 tribes to go and find some new land to live on, i.e. Equestria
Because remember ponies originally didn't live in Equestria, they lived in whatever land they lived, before the Windigos and made it so they had to find new land and therefore, found Equestria.
But the Pegasus city Gusty was trying to get is called Cloudsdale just like the modern Equestrian city of Cloudsdale.
So yeah, an observation I made.

Okay, so I've made an observation.
Twilight said that Gusty and her unicorn warriors were trying to get to *Cloudsdale*.
This is in the Grogar Era, long before the Windigos came and made everything snowy and forced the 3 tribes to go and find some new land to live on, i.e. *Equestria*
Because remember ponies originally didn't live in Equestria, they lived in whatever land they lived, before the Windigos and made it so they had to find new land and therefore, found Equestria.
But the Pegasus city Gusty was trying to get is called *Cloudsdale* just like the modern *Equestrian* city of Cloudsdale.
So yeah, an observation I made.

@Lautaro Roldan Pizzorno yeah that makes sense
Although my point that ponies still didn't live in Equestria because they discovered Equestria due to the Windigos still kinda stands so its weird
¯\_(ツ)_/¯

They probably just moved Cloudsdale to the land of Equestria, remember Cloudsdale is mobile


My headcanon is that Grogar did in fact escape from the stars thanks to Cozy Glow. But Discord sensed it and stopped him. Or so he thought. I think it's then that Grogar's ghost actually possessed Discord and used him as his vessel to unite the Villians. Discord being oblivious to his own actions, Grogar's puppet.

I remember imagining Grogar's spirit influenced Discord subconsciously to make this iffy plan in order to set things up for his resurrection(as in the seal of his bell being broke and pieces all being in place)


great video! I have a small theory, how did Twilight Sparkle transform into a Celestia sized Alicorn? how did Luna and Celestia do it? or did it just happen over time? xxx


We may not have had grogar in the finale but we still got to see his power through the trio of terror because the magic they took from the bell was grogar’s. We know that grogar has enough power to take on an army and destroy a castle (shown through these 3) but there is still more to uncover

First let’s look at cozy she is an alicorn which means the real grogar must of had a ton of alicorn magic

Then chrysalis she has magical accessories so we know that grogar must of had some (probably his collar)

And then tirek he seems to be physically stronger so we can apply that to grogar

And on top of all that grogar was the father of monsters maybe like the ones in Tartarus

In conclusion grogar is probably the most powerful creature in equestria (discord coming in with a close second tho)

Omg I’ve been noticed! :D<br>Btw Lauren Faust sadly debunked the grogar freed nightmare moon apparently Celestia freed her sis grogar may still be in the clouds

Omg I’ve been noticed! :D
Btw Lauren Faust sadly debunked the grogar freed nightmare moon apparently Celestia freed her sis grogar may still be in the clouds


Hey Notion, I have a theory that goes with your alicorn theory line. I'm putting this on the newest video so it's easier to see:

So you know how Celestia, Luna, and now Twilight (because of the last episode) all have wavy hair, but Cadence doesn’t? Well, I think that this is because they were directly affected by the Elements of Harmony:

Celestia used the Elements to banish Luna, and Twilight is the bearer of the Element of Magic. Cadence had, if any, very little contact with the Elements.

Just a little idea I had that I thought I'd share with you.


I have a question I've been wondering for quite a while now, will the future of MLP FiM live on in Teen Titans? Now i know that sounds bonkers but here me out, we know that hasbro originally planned on making a show called "Pony Life" and the designed resembles Teen Titans Go. The Teen Titans and The Mane 6 also share the elements of harmony. let me explain: each titan and each pony represents each element. Pinkie and Star fire represent laughter bc of their positive personality, rainbow dash and cyborg represent loyalty when it comes down to their friends in danger, applejack and robin represent honesty bc they know the truth is always the right choice even after a lie, beast boy and fluttershy represent kindness bc of their love for animals, and raven and rarity represent generosity bc of their ability to think of their friends and not themselves. although there's not a titan who represents magic with twilight, i think its terra bc they both care for their friends and the ones they love. i mean terra literally sacrificed herself to save everyone.


I absolutely love your video you always have great theories I cannot wait to see more


You should make a My little pony Timelime! From the very beginning of equestria to now and the history they stated throughout the episodes!


Don't worry, I will totally continue watching, even though the show is "over."

I'm actually quite glad that someone might be still making content. It will help the fandom from... well... not dying if people still make stuff. (Like the fanfiction community, which is smaller, but still continuing just the same.)


from the chronology  I think you are doing good in placing it Grogar's rule before the unification of the tribes of Hearth Warming. But what I wonder is why would he be called the first Emperor of Equestria in the first place, why not the the Emperor of the Goat Empire instead? Did he conquer Equestria all on his own or did he had an army in his back, and what was the land he came from and did they have a land to come back to or be resupplied to? To me signs point that their might have that their was a previous alteration of Equestria and was just the name of the land and not a define nation, but with no actual central government, like you propose. if he actually called himself the first Emperor of Equestria, and not just turn this land of Equestria (they were further north at the time according to the tail)  into a province of his own nation that he came from or probably conquered before he build up his forces toward the ponies after? I would guess that the answer is either he couldn't go back or it didn't exist anymore for some reason, maybe it's Tombelom that was in another plan of existence that he was cut off from or that he escaped a ruin/destroyed nation which didn't exist any more or that he was exiled and wanted to stand apart from that nation, so he might as well have called his Empire by the lands name and inhabitant  and was trying building up his own power base there too (we have seen this from the Andel and Saxon and the Danes from Britain). I those are my thoughts on the matter of the Real Grogar at least


Assuming he did bring all of pony kind into the three tribes, wouldn't this also mean that he might have caused creaturs such as dragons, griffins, yaks, etc. to potentially become seperated in some way. Not saying all of these creaturs sided with Grogar but it makes you wonder how much of an impact he had on other creature cultures as well.


About your theory why grogar waited for cosy glow:<br>You said he had to wait because his spell would lose its power. But if the REAL Grogar is still up there, that means, his spell has to be secured by some artefact.

About your theory why grogar waited for cosy glow:
You said he had to wait because his spell would lose its power. But if the REAL Grogar is still up there, that means, his spell has to be secured by some artefact.


Lauren Faust has already told us who released Nightmare Moon, the one who controls the stars. The only being that we knew that'll have that power would be the only Alicorn that had control of both the sun and Moon, Celestia so I doubt that Grogar was the one to have released NM if that's what the Lauren said.


I would love to hear from you more often. Just don't run yourself into the ground!


Regular updates? Yes please. Gosh I haven't gotten good mlp content in a while.


It’s been confirmed by the goddess herself that Celestia was the one to release Nightmare Moon


Once again fantastic video. Keep up the good work Brony Notion. Have a wonderful day.


I have a question. Can changelings turn invisible?


You can say that Gusty had the high ground 😏


I am still borderline FURIOUS with the twist. I mean, it CAN’T be Discord doing all this. This is why I just think of the finale as an alternate universe.


I can't believe it! You're changing the name! I'm so proud of you!


So he was the first ruler that oversaw the equivalent to the forced transition from a Neolithic era to city states caused by war with a more advanced civilization that already had those attributes.


Unfortunately, you're wrong about Grogar aiding nightmare moons escape as Lauren Faust confirmed it was Celestia who freeded nightmare moon.


You pretty much nailed grogars story, grogar was the one who pushed ponies to civilization.  Would have been cool to see the real grogar but I can live with that. Looking forward to more videos from you.


Well I wasn't expecting this video! Nice to see you back ^^


I am so ready for the next history class of My little pony world!


How about this- Grogar created the unicorns and Pegasi! Hear me out. At the beginning of season 9, “Grogar” said how he created so many monsters with his magic by combining animals with animals. What is unicorns and Pegasi are the same? Pegasi- horses and birds Unicorns- horses and... corn? Idk those are just my thoughts. Tell me what you think.

Ps, I love your little mistletoe in your mane :p


I am glad you are back ♡ we missed you 💝

😅 Just realized that I been subscribed for 4 years now, I am glad I subscribed Because your videos are still awesome 😍


"Its still possiblethat he helped Nightmare moon escape" Nope , Loren Faust saind that celestia did it


Very interesting. I can see that happening.


Wait :0 I haven’t seen you for two years this brings back so many memories wow.I still watched my little pony


I still can’t believe grogar was Discord the whole time how blizzare and dark is that?....well I wouldn’t say that but still it hit me hard like hard hard


So, what about Discord in this timeline?<br>Discord's chaos kingdom was a important part of Equestrian history

So, what about Discord in this timeline?
Discord's chaos kingdom was a important part of Equestrian history


Holy shit you're back, I literally screamed when I got the notification! Also, nice vid, good ol' BronyNotion; never change man, love you


Even if new information gets put put, it would be hard to proof you wrong because of the fact that you talked about equestria loooooooooooong ago


I have a question,is Maud a crystal pony? If so, would that make Pinkie one?


Pleaseeeeeeeeeeeeeee do a time line / history of the entire world I guess ( pony edition). Now the show is over I hope we can get 2 history lessons. A confermed one and a theory one.


Grogar noticed when somebody work together(main six or pegasus and unicorns) will deafet his/other evil. He said that when he save tirek, crysalis or cozzy. So pegasus and unicorns work together to defeat him. So Grogar make his own team.


I wouldn’t get too cocky about “no new information debunking theories”. There is a season 10 comic series which is canon so we’ll have to see what happens there.


Grogar was from the OG mlp series the very original series and that's what we knew of him from. Grogar is from Gen 1 of my little pony


Wow I happy to hear you going be posting regular. Can't be 4 years since then, I still remember that 😮😱


What if Discord was Grogar? Discord doesn't see himself as the real Grogar much like how Darth Vader doesn't see himself as Anakin. Perhaps, after losing his bell, Grogar sought out new magic. That magic transformed him into a whole new creature. Now the spirit of chaos, Discord completely dissociated himself from the creature he once was. Just a theory.


Hope in the season 10 comics we get the real grogar


So technically, grogar is the William the conqueror of equestria


I honestly thought that if was Celestia who bailed out nightmare moon because the stars aided in NMM’S escape and while Luna imprisoned in the moon Celestia raised the moon and stars and when Luna was back to her old self Celestia appeared and Luna seemed to be surprised to see her like she didn’t know where Celestia was


Totally unrelated note but,
       What I think happened to Discord was including your theory that Starswirl made Discord. So like you said earlier Starswirl DID create discord though realizing he was dangerous and “unstable” sent him to Limbo. Fast forward to Pillars and Pony of Shadows getting thrown in there Discord managed to escape without them realizing. (They were kinda busy ya know getting chucked into Limbo) We don’t see him because he is creating his realm and figuring out who HE is and what the heck has happened. Then he strikes Equestria and we know what happens from there. (Turning to stone all that junk)

        (If I missed some news like it’s been debunked or other I haven’t seen a lot of pony stuff recently so sorry if that happens)
Kinda random but  ya


Sorry, no, Grogar did not help Nightmare Moon. Lauren Faust made a statement saying that it was always Celestia who controlled the sun, the moon, and the stars. It was Celestia herself that helped Nightmare Moon escape. And just because the series is over doesn't mean the original creators can't shoot down your theories. Good luck on the one where Grogar was the individual responsible for setting things in motion for Equestria becoming a kingdom. But then again, is Tirek really a reliable source for pony history?


Cloudsdale was made after the founding of Equestria


9:46 as an Earth Pony, I feel very triggered by this


2 questions,

1, what if they did like the cast behind Gravity Falls?

2, ...............when was Grogar's regime? we know it happened under MLP Gen 1, but............ when was that? 3.000 years before the show? 10.000? or......... maybe 900.000 years? it happened while humans were still able to get to........... ponyland fairly easy, we know that at least,

2 questions,

1, what if they did like the cast behind Gravity Falls?

2, ...............when was Grogar's regime? we know it happened under MLP Gen 1, but............ when was that? 3.000 years before the show? 10.000? or......... maybe 900.000 years? it happened while humans were still able to get to........... *_ponyland_* fairly easy, we know that at least,


YES YES PLEASEEE DONT STOP UPLOADING THEORIESSS..... the show ending is already depressing enough for uss


Like drax said in the infinity war said I can do you one better: what if there were two grogars and the original one was discord?


Hello Brony Notion , I got a Question .. Is twilight...well twilight? In the Episode where twilight from the future came to twilight the past I had something on mind : "who is the responsible for the future twilight to go to past twilight?" . I want to know who is the real twilight? Is the real one has another timeline? I hope you  answer my question . I wish you a good day!<br>-long ago subscriber

Hello Brony Notion , I got a Question .. Is twilight...well twilight? In the Episode where twilight from the future came to twilight the past I had something on mind : "who is the responsible for the future twilight to go to past twilight?" . I want to know who is the real twilight? Is the real one has another timeline? I hope you  answer my question . I wish you a good day!
-long ago subscriber


holy shit i saw the first second of the vid and it brought back so many memories?????? spike (is that his name) isnt a babey and twilight grew up?? ohmygod i miss this show


I hope you'll be able to make weakly videos again. Good luck!


He's says Fluffy Heart instead of Flurry Heart at 2:44


Monarchy ,oligarchy and military juntra coming together as harmonic society ....... Yeah especialy considering history of mistrust and discrimination. I always thoght that  newly discovered land was colonized by all 3 tribes and eventualy turned into new independent state that eventualy ate other pony nations. Stable rule of alicorns created and trained by Starswirl would be first to secure country destroyed by some magical foe or disaster. It would also explain why former monarchs and nobilty exist alongside democratic institusions like mayor and EEA.


Perhaps grogar is responsible for removing the humans from the world of Equestria and sending them to what is now the human world of the Equestria girls.


Cute hairpin! It's good to have you back, friend!


inb4 the season 10 comics gives some more backstory. XD
inb4 inb4 the staff, old and new, reveals everything in detail on their twitters. XD

Jokes aside, a very interesting theory there. Solitary ponies, scattered here and there, now making groups and tribes for their own kind when a threat appears. Although, when they were scattered like that, who took care of the sun & moon? Was it the ancient alicorns? Guess they were hiding in their high and mighty palaces when the rest of the world was being threatened (multiple times).

It could be the ancient alicorns, that's an interesting idea!


I even mentioned the real Grogar in my Grogar/Discord comment.


I used to watch my little pony stuff.. But I've never seen this channel before, but it got recommended to me.. Although... It looks like a MLP version of game theory 😕


You should do Theroies on miraculous ladybug, and gravity falls or whatever you like :) love your videos


MLP isn't completely over because the comics are still being published (with a "season 10" coming soon).


You can search deeper into the history and episodes


Hey how about a video on sombra I think he is or at least once was an alicorn


You know I went back to Esquestria Girl and sudeenly asked myself how did sunset knows thst twillight have a crown? And she is at the crystal empire??????


Finally, you post again! I’ve been waiting forever!


More frequent videos? Do my ears deceive me?


I like that accessory thing, is that new?
Am I missing something?
I feel like I’m supposed to know what it is but I don’t oops


Dang I felt like I was watching a crash course/ oversimplified history vid


i think this is all true buuuuut Grogar still didnt release nightmare moon. Celestia did. confirmed by Lauren


what sort of content are you gonna be making now that mlp:fim is over? 👀 do you think you'll branch out?


YAY MORE BRONY NOTION I have literally been re-watching all of your vids! YOUR THE BEST MY LITTLE PONY YOUTUBER EVER! thx for making me happy every morning.


Magical beams that wove into one?

COLORS WEAVE INTO A SPIRE OF FLAMES

DISTANT SPARKS CALL TO A PAST STILL UNNAMED


You know there was a season 10 comic coming out soon


Hey person who replied to my reply saying, “By ‘real grogar’ you mean discord right?” Discord makes it offical! GROGAR DID EXIST!


Also you should make a video about fillies age using diamond tiara in pinkies song when cheese sandwich was introduced.


Actually, princess Celestia bailed out Luna...... Mlp confirmed it


Question..

What's with the feathers on your head?


I started watching this since there where theories of season 1!! Which was when I was like, 3 now I'm 11 which is about 8 years! Also why do you have that feather thing on yo head?  Same day Edit: Also I have a theory, was twilight royalty even BEFORE she became an Alicorn? Because shining armor married princess cadance before she became an Alicorn so is shining armor also royalty since his wife sister, AND kid are all alicorns. And we all know Cadance is the niece of princess Celestia so when shining armor and Cadance got married that would make shining armor Celestia's nephew and twilight her other niece. So in a way not only twilight was royalty but shining is too, please do this theory.

Oh, hello past self! Learn grammar, No need to put ‘same day edit’ and I think you sound mean despite it not trying to sound rude!

Except Cadence was an alicorn at her wedding. She was one ever since Twilight was a filly.


Brony notion i love ur video so much, i tthink your the best mlp theorist~<br>Also yas cloudsdale hat!

Brony notion i love ur video so much, i tthink your the best mlp theorist~
Also yas cloudsdale hat!

Brony have you heard that lauren faust had commented on someones question and she replied that CELESTIA was the one that freed nightmare moon(sort of, thats what people got from that..)? Dr wolf did a video on that too


Alternate theory: Gusty the Great reformed Grogar like Fluttershy did with Discord and they also got married. But the legend remained, just like ponies still remember Discord as the bad guy

@MrConredsX Well, the Comics were always in this weird Limbo of.... "kinda Canon, but not really"

@Johannes Seyfried Well Sombra was reformed in the comics

If someone like Sombra doesn't get reformed, then I don't think Grogar can be.


Yes, do that, also,talk about fan series too, even mine


I would but I don't have any bits. Love your videos


nah, Lauren Faust said Celestia freed nightmare moon


I also think you could read peoples fanfics or show peoples art


Here's a suggestion can you make of video about how the apples parents died


I just watched this at yesterday saying its been a long time since you uploaded. Here you are


You know the season 10 is in the cómics ?


I am making a MLP book after Princess Twilight becoming The ruler of Equestrian can u maybe read it?


And the he says Fuzzy Hat (I think he's joking tho)


will you be there for the new gen of mlp?


But what if g5 is a continue of g4's equestria


Can you make a video about ho gusty the great was.


Omg I didn't think you'd ever upload again!


Why not play footage from gen 1 to further your point?


The brony notion upload video
me: but MLP is done
also me : click the video


What is this thing on your head? Why is it there?


Earth Pony Tier and Unicorn Tier, huh? Now supporting pony racism, are you?


BRUh I haven't watched u since I was like, 10 or sumn

-uh edit: who the uh heck is Grogar, I prolly should catch up w/ this show lol


Reeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!I thought you were dead thank God you're not!


If I make a mlp theory you might check it out


There a revrences in miraculeus ladybug and mlp. And more revrences 🤔

Btw i was wating for this video📽
Love it 💗


Me:wakes up
My phone :youtube notifications
Me:some comment reply...
My phone: comment rep the brony notion
Me:WAIT WHAT?! :D

Me:wakes up
My phone :youtube notifications
Me:some comment reply...
My phone: _comment rep_ the brony notion
Me:WAIT WHAT?! :D


Where have you been it's been 5 months 😭


YOU HAVE NOT UPLOADED IN A BILLION EARS!!!!!


yay you post again i thout u were done with this channle


@Lautaro Roldan Pizzorno K then nevermind!

@Lautaro Roldan Pizzorno didn't she say thats how equestria was made,or am i wrong?

@Zenev Power  That has nothing to do with Grogar or Discord, just the foundation of Ponyville

@Lautaro Roldan Pizzorno The one she tells in the episode where she goes to applebloom's school.


I love the brony notion!!! Without it spike wouldn't of gotten  wings 😒


YouTube won’t actually put my notifications on. Also you uploaded at 3am


I hate that people don't check the date of the video before commenting. It's annoying and repetitive. Also what's that on your hair?


Oof I bealive Grogar is good oof like if u agree lol


2:36 did he just say flurry face
Edit: 2:45 did he just say fluffy heart
?!?!


My molar is growing in and it hurttttttttssss

Ya I don't think you care


I'm not gonna do your patreon  sorry I'm 12  and I'm trying not to steal my grandma's money


gah, yaaaaaaaaaaaaaah
uhhh......
ummm......


Doctor Wolf tot de storing hout Celestia actually frituur sister


Im sorry i cant cause i cant give u dollar guess why?🇮🇷 yup


Can I have a shout out I've been watching since 2015


I’ve always wondered if Grogar had a backstory. Turns out, he does.


I remember that I said on one of your videos, " Maybe flurry heart is the princess of joy!" I still stand by that! I haven't got a chance to take a closer Look at the glass mural in Canterlot castle (season 9 last episode) of flurry heart.

yeah yet another unanswered question. at least not overtly.


I love your videos! i can't wait to watch more of them! i wish i could support you on patron but i can't :/ Keep up being awesome 🧡

@Sawtooth Waves  and your reply makes me happy <3

thanks!! your comments are support enough ^^


So you're telling me that Grogar was the Agricultural Revolution of Equestria? Neat!!


You're alive!!! I missed you alot💕!! I can't wait till you start posting again. It's scary how your theories are so smart


You don’t know how happy I was to hear you say you wanted to start posting again!!!!!! WELCOME BACK!!!!!!


Wow! I can't wait! I always get so excited when I see one of your videos come out! I watch them instantly! Good luck with your future videos! XD


I think a story about a G1 character would try to make a few shout outs to G1 with out repeating it so you would need to see G1 a little too and see what names and info you have to work with.

as for future videos I would like to hear your idea of what things happened in that time skip we got for the Last Problem.

you could also tackle filling in the gaps between other episodes of other shows.

I welcome any Brony who can make weekly or monthly content now the series is over and still draw an audience  even if they have to talk about other shows.  It proves you weren't here just for the  new episodes.
We lost a lot of great Youtubers with things like the end of Yong  Justice, the final episode of Korra,  and  the disappointment of MLP season 5.

@Sawtooth Waves there are quite a few plot points the show dropped and never wrapped up and back ground things that are never explained. I would need to brain storm to figure a few out but I enjoy listing ideas with people who actually read and respond to them.


I just posted a different comment and then looked in the description and saw you used something from Firefall-MLP. I can't help but feel some sort of happiness seeing one of my favorite, no, my absolute favorite MLP theorist use one of my friend's pieces, even if it's just a bit.


Just wondering, what's the little accessory on your character for?


I mean if you want a suggestion for a topic here is one: can you explain Equestria's patchy industrialization and technology lapses within the cannon?
I mean we know they have proper factories and at least turn of the century tech but you also see hamster wheels :|
My bet was clean air zones and government intervention but I'd love to see your opinion...


At 6:03 to probably answer your question:the earth ponies were probably still working their cutie marks off tending to the crops for all of both Unicorns and Pegasi as well as themselves under torturous weather conditions.


Celestia aided Luna's Escape! The writer answers it in a tweet!


So glad that your still uploading after the show


I wonder what the next generation of My Little Pony would look like.


(PLEASE READ THIS) I know what you said COULD be true. But, then I thought "Wait a minute, if Discord isn't REALLY the real Grogard, then what really happened to him? When Grogard had his bell, did he became immortal at that time? Then when Dusty took his bell away, did he became mortal and died?" Now the reason why I am saying he's immortal, it's because of all the magic he had. Think about Celestia and Luna, they are both alicorns, with a lot of magic and power which makes them immortal, just like Twilight. She became immortal because of power and magic. Now Grogard was immortal long ago because he has his bell and in that bell carries his magic and powers. Without a lot of magic or powers in him, he becomes weak. Just when you said "When Dusty took his bell, he became weak and was banished" (something like that), that means all Grogard magic is not in him. Sure there's some but there wasn't A LOT in him, which made him mortal. Maybe that's because he doesn't actually show up in the show because (possibly) he's dead. Because he was here in Equestria for so long! And he could not live that many years, without his bell. So it's possible when his bell was taken, Grogard became weak. You can also see the proof of this in Celestia and Luna. When Terek took their magic, they became weak and their hairs weren't flowing anymore. And their eyes became tireding. It's possible this is how Grogard felt long ago. But, why did Discord changed into Grogard. Well, think about this, Grogard has been in this land long ago. It's possible that Discord was here long ago as well, but, once you think of it, he was only here when he creating Chaotic and the two alicorns sisters stoped him. Maybe Discord just got born. But not born as in he has parents. Born by magic. As he was created by magic. Remember when Grogard said he can create monsters? Well it's possible that he created Discord but him as a baby. That's when Grogard became weak but manages to make Discord strong, by giving his powers to Discord. But, why did anypony notice a strange creature in their home? Maybe Grogard didn't want Discord to get hurt so he send him somewhere far away. Besides, Discord IS Grogard amazing creations and he didn't want him to get hurt nor stopped. Maybe Grogard knew that Discord will be strong and powerful in the future. And when Discord came back to Equestria, grown up, he gets his revenge and tries to take over Equestria. Until he was stopped by the two sisters by turning him into a stone. Oh snap! This is my first time making up a good theory, what do you think Brony Notion (and everypony)


Welcome back we missed you. I also have never clicked on a video notification so fast.


I have a theory, what if the bad guys are not the bad guys. Think about it, the "good guys" have there own thoughts on life, the "bad guys" have there's. If you dont submit to the ideas of the "good" you get punished. Even children are not safe, you may get a second chance, but look at the ones who do. They are powerful creatures, and if you disobey, and can be fought easily, you get the boot. Think about it from the "bad guys" for once and see.


I saw the notification while playing destiny and swiped it away from habit but I caught a glimpse of "the" and saw grogar and discord silhouettes and immediately realized it was our lord and savior "the brony notion". Never been so excited from a notification.


I thought your channel was dead! Nice to be back!


oH my god I was literally binge watching all your videos yesterday but then got sad because you hadn’t uploaded for 4 months and the show ended and THEN U UPLOADED THIS AND I WAS LIKE WOOOOAOAOAAAAAHHHH


I thought I was done with this series dangit


So when are people gonna call Cozy Glow a mary sue?


Ain't gonna lie
More than half of us though you died.
Dude.
We love ya but , gosh darn are you worrying us


...wait this makes no sense!!! What did I miss??? I watched the final!!! Granted I skipped to the final episode...


😱😱😱😱😱 YASSSSSS YOU POSTED ANOTHER VIDEO!!!! I LOVE FAN FICTION!! Don't rush urself tho


Hi again! This is amazing that you are back!


When G5 comes out, are you gonna make theory videos on that?


An update I’ve always been checking up on dis  channel even though I stopped watching mlp in like season 8


From what my friend told me there will be a gen 5 idk if it's true though


I have a video idea , when rainbow dash did the sonic rainboom when she was small, the mane six got their cutiemarks together at the sametime. So then when he did another rainboom, did the young six were born at the same time?


You're still gonna have to worry about your theroies being torn by those supposedly canon Season 10 comics starting this April. Though that will give you some more things to make theories about seeing as you're planning a comeback now.


I like the new head thingie<br>And you are alive!

I like the new head thingie
And you are alive!


Well well well. <b>clears throat</b> ITS ALIVE

Well well well. *clears throat* ITS ALIVE


I’m sure you now know that your theory of nightmare moon got debunked.

you mean Faust's tweet? I'll talk about it in a future vid


Also what’s with the feathers? I like them but did I miss something?

They’re Yun’s hair feathers from Yona of the Dawn.


heyyyy you're not ded great to see you back #brohoof


Is No one gonna talk about the feathers on his oc and the minecraft music in the background 🤨


So what do you you think of celestia twilight??

@Sawtooth Waves same I've been waiting to see her like that someday! Lol

just curious about it, like, is she immortal now? i like her design though


First VIDEO of Brony Notion!!! Love you and your theories Brony Notion!!


@AusMeinemVerdammtenVerstand oh ok thanks!

<i>jam universe</i> I think you can find them on YouTube Or Ebooks

_jam universe_ I think you can find them on YouTube Or Ebooks

@AusMeinemVerdammtenVerstand I mean the mop comics in general, not the tenth one

<i>jam universe</i> The Season 10 comics aren’t coming until April

_jam universe_ The Season 10 comics aren’t coming until April

Idk where to find or get the comics tho!!😭 I've always wanted to read them since I found out they existed


ths is the best day of 2020 warning corona virus


The days your wear hone i ben hearing your music soooo meny time :3


@Sawtooth Waves Just curious. Looks cool!

saw someone wearing it in an anime and liked it c:


Did you graduate yet? Or did you drop out of collage?

just got my as degree so I'm gonna focus on the channel for a while :3


Can I get an invite to ur discord sever please


Legend has it that you'll get pinned if you're early.

Lol jk I really don't care that much


Who are you and what are you doing in my subscriptions


And is commander  hurricane commander iron pin fater


Ok I'm sorry I know it doesn't relete to any of this but a thousand  army's? Any army here???

Just me ok


YOU SED FLUFY HARET INSDED IF FLERY HARET!!!😲😲😲


just the opposite! new video coming this afternoon ^^


I am afraid your whole theory is wrong. The ponies,unicorns and pegassis discovered Equestria when they ran away from their former home looking after a new one were there wouldn’t be any windigoes. Then,they arrived in mudvielle,unicornia and pegassopolis. But,the ponies fight one an other and the windigoes attacked them again. But clover the clever understood they could defeat the windigoes by working together. After the windigoes were gone they named that new land Equestria! And there they made cloudsdale,ponyvielle and canterlot. So when gusty attacked grogar equestria already existed and the unicorns,pegassis and earth ponies were already friends. So maybe that’s how things went. As we know from season 2 in their former home , the unicorns were raising the sun and the moon. So when all the kingdoms got in new equestria so did starswirl the bearded with the rest of the unicorns. Through those unicorns were present celestia and luna. As we know from the season 8 play
Celestia was starswirls student and she had raises the sun on her own. I think then she became the first alicorn cause of her skills and then luna, starswirl’s second student raised the moon and became an alicron too. Now everything was kinda perfect but then grogar appeared. Since the ponies didn’t live in equestria for too long, therr really were pretty many farms. Grogar perhaps turned celestia and luna into his own slaves with the promise he won’t hurt the rest of equestria if they continue to do whatever he said. And he kinda helped equestria cause he built cloudsdale and so on but he has never ever had anything to do with ponies unity. Ponies were already united and they decided to fight with grogar for their freedom lead by gasti a powerful unicorn.  She fight together along with the unicorns,pegassis and earth ponies. They fought in cloudsdale and the beams weren’t strong enough but then celstia and luna appeared. They escaped their prison and were ready to join in the fight with their help gasti managed to steal grogar’s bell absorb all grogar’s magic and hide it Then gasti sent grogar back where he come from and grogar powerless didn’t dare to turn back again. Then gasti rescued starswirl who was also in prison for his power . Now he didn’t have to worry about the sun and the moon anymore and he was free. He decided to start protecting equestria and stop the everfree forest and save equestria from any other villain.  While the royal sisters ruled equestria again . Then the mermaides appear and made disarmony so starswirl wanted to stop em. Stygian made him and the rest of the pillers a group and banished the sirenas. Then we know what happend. Stygian wanted to become a piller and so on. After starswirl and all the pillers plus the pony of shadow were gone in limbo. Celestia and luna had to protect equestria alone. Until then the pillers protected everyplace: they kept the everfree forestt undercontrol and took care of any possible villain. After a while luna and celestia saw they didn’t need to take care of the everfree forest anymore. They didn’t know why but they found out later. Thx to the seeds planted by the pillers. But even if they got rid of one problem there were still many!!! Tirek and scorpan arrived but luna and celestia managed to chain him thx to scorpan. Then king sombra attackted the crystal empire and the sisters defetead him too even if the empire was gone. Then appeared discord. The two sisters looked for a way to defeat him and finally found the tree of harmony. They took the elements away discord planted other seeds so the tree will die but u already know this story. Discord was anyway turned to stone. Then,luna became nightmaremoon and celestia banished her. But then i think canterlot was made cause the castle of two sisters was ruined by luna’s anger . After cantetlot was made,celestia became a teacher just like starswirl so the unicorns will learn how to protect equestria. The wonderbolts were made so both pegassis and unicirns were now guarding equesstria.After that i think a powerul wizard got to the momery stone and started to get ponies memories an clover the clever stopped her. Maybe this happend even sooner but even so i think it happend herr being kinda the last bad eveniment because until then there were a lot of bad eveniments so there wouldn’t be enough time for that to happen. Only if the the memory stone thing had happend while an other eveniment als happend like in the same time. Then there was a loooong period of harmony I In that harmony period, the apple familt arrived in canterlot and celestia sent em somewhere else on some meadows. Thx to granny smith Ponyville was made but you areleady know the story.But then sunset shimmer ran away into that other world making damage only in celestia’s heart not in equestria. So still harmony. Then, twilight appeared  and she saved equestria from nightmaremoon. And here we are! The present!!  Then we all know what happend: trixie,discord,flim and flam,chrissalis,sombra,
Trixie again,discrod was reformed,twiligh’s wings, everfree forest got over ponyvielle, tirek, starlight,bugbear,tantabus,starlight again,crystal heart was destroyed,chrysallis again,the pony of shadow, king storm and tempest,school of frienship, cozy glow, PRINCESSES RETIREMENT twilight taking over, sombra again,tirek and cozy and  that was it! End of story!


Hi sawtooth pla do vid whats discords past


Gacha life girl and goanimate is Awesome 9805 Heart


why is the big bad guy not seeing of and Grogar is be is a father of bad guys is here ,


@Sawtooth Waves Only the universe conforms to a mary sue. The hero conforms to the universe.


kingzilla destroyer of the multiverse 1978