Wow, I absolutely adore how this song flows =D the lyrics are amazing, the vocals fit perfectly, and the instrumental is soooo pretty =) Brilliant work to all of you!
This might sound crazy, but it's like a cross between the Grateful Dead and Pink Floyd, with a dash of Queen in the bridge. And over it all, that Replacer vibe that's so recognizable. Amazing work, as always.
Thank you for not saying beatles :P I wrote it expecting it to be a gentle ballad, but then I actually just started to hear the chorus in Meat Loaf's voice...that changed the whole complexion of it and I knew I wanted an epic melodrama with a big guitar solo in the middle
Thanks a lot, I put a lot of thought into the structure of this song and pulled off some stuff I haven't done before. Something about the lyrics I was presented with just lit a fire in my brain, I might have to outsource lyrics more often in future if it gets me going like this
This is outstanding work. The refrain reminds me a lot of an older song but I can't quite put a name on it, I will have to ask my dad. Great song I love it!
so my reaction: 0:25 Well, just another sentimental song of Replacer 1:21 that's not bad, that is quite good Nice, I enjoy it! 2:38 Oh sweet Celestia... this is... 3:40 that solo... 4:43 OK I LOVE IT!!! This is the best Replacer's song since "Song For an Earth Pony"
@replacer When I heard it for the first time, I replayed it for about ten times. I'm really glad that music made by bronies becomes better and better. "Reach (All Along)" by Aviators and 4everfreeBrony, album "Something Special" by Forest Rain, album "Pink Side of The Moon" by 4everfreeBrony and other artists, "No Chance" by dBPony and MicTheMic, and now this. And what's more, one of the best ponyartists responds to my comment. That's why I love that fandom!
I happened upon this song 2 days ago... I have listened to All your songs for 3 days strait. Including today. Makes me feel good and happy. Thank you for creating Positive and Uplifting content. In contrast to some of the darker things i have seen come out of the Brony Community this is a Refreshing Ray of Ultra bright Sunshine that fills my mind with Goodness and Happiness. Keep up the good work and I look forward to your next songs.
Beautiful, beautiful stuff. Your compositional skills and knack for recreating some of the best sounds of great past eras of music continues to blow me away.
Wonderful. Lovely music, great lyrics, excellent production, best pony. Who could ask for more? I'm not enough of a musician to give much in the way of detailed feedback, but to add another band to the collection in the comments: the "Well maybe all I really need..." sections did give off a little bit of a Kinks vibe, to me if to nobody else! Whatever, fantastic all round.
After all these years I still come to your channel almost every month to listen to your music. I like to listen on youtube because I have a nice picture to look at :D You are definitely one of my favourite musicians, please never stop making music ^_^
That song is so cool, relaxing but also catchy :3 I always liked your voice but this song has something more that I can't find out, anyway great job, and i'd love to see you two working together again in another song :D
One of the best songs I've ever heard come out of a correlation. You've worked together and have ended up making a song that sounds physically huge, as if it fills the room with amazing sound. Your sounds and techniques mingle perfectly and have ended up creating something truly beautiful. I really hope you two correlate again in the future if music like this is the end result. Keep up the great work you two, I really hope you're proud of your amazing work.
Glad I turned a brony radio on the right moment. Great song :) And I can't help the feeling that I know the style. I'm certain I heard something similar somewhere, some time ago :3
At first I was getting a Pink Floyd, "Dark Side of the Moon" vibe, and then "Junk" by Paul McCartney, and now The Association... Maybe even B.J. Thomas... Basically, this song puts me back in touch with my feels... I'm in love with a song.
This is in my pony playlist, but I have no recollection of ever hearing it before. I wish I could say this was a rare occurrence. Apparently I just have a short attention span.
@***** that's a weird glitch. You're definitely viewing comments as 'newest first' by the way? Sometimes youtube marks comments as spam for no reason, but that didn't happen here.
Wow, I absolutely adore how this song flows =D the lyrics are amazing, the vocals fit perfectly, and the instrumental is soooo pretty =) Brilliant work to all of you!
30 likesReplies (3)
Thank you so much!!
3 likesMuch appreciated :)
5 likesYou are both very much welcome =) Keep up the amazing work! :D
1 likeThis might sound crazy, but it's like a cross between the Grateful Dead and Pink Floyd, with a dash of Queen in the bridge. And over it all, that Replacer vibe that's so recognizable. Amazing work, as always.
18 likesReplies (2)
Thank you for not saying beatles :P I wrote it expecting it to be a gentle ballad, but then I actually just started to hear the chorus in Meat Loaf's voice...that changed the whole complexion of it and I knew I wanted an epic melodrama with a big guitar solo in the middle
3 likesFOR REAL!!! He be sounding like Pink Floyd.
0 likesThis song has everything, smoothing melody, great guitar solo's, multiple paces and buildups with payoffs.
9 likesI LOVE IT.
Replies (4)
Thank you soooo much. I'm totally stoked. It being my first pony related song and all.
1 likeThanks a lot, I put a lot of thought into the structure of this song and pulled off some stuff I haven't done before. Something about the lyrics I was presented with just lit a fire in my brain, I might have to outsource lyrics more often in future if it gets me going like this
1 likeFor whats it worth, I bought it for $5,- and Fluttershy is my least favorite character....
0 likesSorry.., I meant was.
@Kyderra thank you so very much for the support!
0 likesThis gives me the feeling of those 70's soft rock songs that I love. Good job!
24 likesThe guitar solos are amazing too.
Replies (1)
It was a good thing we did. :)
12 likesKeepin the old groove alive.
7 likesOoh, wow, that was glorious. Bravo, both of you!
11 likesReplies (2)
Thanks man, I'm really pleased with what we did :)
5 likesThank you so much. I appreciate it!
3 likesThis is the kind of music I like and love! So many feels, emotions and brilliance!
5 likesThis is outstanding work. The refrain reminds me a lot of an older song but I can't quite put a name on it, I will have to ask my dad.
3 likesGreat song I love it!
so my reaction:
15 likes0:25 Well, just another sentimental song of Replacer
1:21 that's not bad, that is quite good
Nice, I enjoy it!
2:38 Oh sweet Celestia... this is...
3:40 that solo...
4:43 OK I LOVE IT!!!
This is the best Replacer's song since "Song For an Earth Pony"
Replies (3)
Nice! sounds like you really came along for the ride with this one
5 likes@replacer When I heard it for the first time, I replayed it for about ten times.
1 likeI'm really glad that music made by bronies becomes better and better. "Reach (All Along)" by Aviators and 4everfreeBrony, album "Something Special" by Forest Rain, album "Pink Side of The Moon" by 4everfreeBrony and other artists, "No Chance" by dBPony and MicTheMic, and now this.
And what's more, one of the best ponyartists responds to my comment.
That's why I love that fandom!
Thank you so much! I really appreciate all the kind words.
1 likeAmazing! Great job you two <3
23 likesReplies (2)
Thanks so much feather!
4 likesYaaay :3
6 likesI happened upon this song 2 days ago... I have listened to All your songs for 3 days strait. Including today. Makes me feel good and happy. Thank you for creating Positive and Uplifting content. In contrast to some of the darker things i have seen come out of the Brony Community this is a Refreshing Ray of Ultra bright Sunshine that fills my mind with Goodness and Happiness. Keep up the good work and I look forward to your next songs.
2 likesThis is the best song I've ever heard from the fandom. It really has everything. Congratulations!
6 likesReplies (2)
Oh you are way to kind <3
1 likeI do my best~
2 likesLove it!
2 likesBeautiful, beautiful stuff. Your compositional skills and knack for recreating some of the best sounds of great past eras of music continues to blow me away.
5 likesReplies (2)
Thanks, always good to know people still like me! ^^;
1 likeSome of the best? Everything made by replacer is the best! Replacer is awesome!
1 likeBeautiful, classy, and just refreshing! Love this
2 likesThis song reminds me of "Walk 500 Miles" in some places. Very good song, brilliantly done. Love it.
2 likesReplies (1)
I am a big fan of them myself. Thank you!
0 likesI think this is my favourite brony song...
7 likes<3
This is what I'd call music. Superb performance!
7 likesReplies (2)
Thanks, means a lot ^^
1 likeThank you so much!
1 likeEven though this fandom has already accomplished such amazing feats already, nothing reminds me so quite like an amazing song. I love this.
1 likeReplies (1)
Thank you so much!
0 likesThis song is beautiful, your music really isnt getting the credit it deserves
3 likesI don't think I can fully express how much I love this song :'D
0 likesThirty seconds through the opening chords, I am in LOVE with this song... <3
1 likeWell, I'm just going to put this on repeat for a while.
1 likeWonderful. Lovely music, great lyrics, excellent production, best pony. Who could ask for more? I'm not enough of a musician to give much in the way of detailed feedback, but to add another band to the collection in the comments: the "Well maybe all I really need..." sections did give off a little bit of a Kinks vibe, to me if to nobody else! Whatever, fantastic all round.
1 likeWhat an amazing song. Those transitions are excellent.
1 likeReplies (1)
thanks, I put a lot of work into em :D
1 likeSo beautiful! I'm disappointed that it has taken me this long to find this. Great work you guys! c:
0 likesA beautiful song for the most beautiful pony!
2 likesAfter all these years I still come to your channel almost every month to listen to your music. I like to listen on youtube because I have a nice picture to look at :D
0 likesYou are definitely one of my favourite musicians, please never stop making music ^_^
Yep this is why I follow you. Funny cause I'm not that fond of the bands you apparently sound like... keep up the good work!
1 likeI get the feeling y'all really love 60s and 70s soft and classic rock. Just a hunch.
0 likesThat song is so cool, relaxing but also catchy :3
0 likesI always liked your voice but this song has something more that I can't find out, anyway great job, and i'd love to see you two working together again in another song :D
One of the best songs I've ever heard come out of a correlation. You've worked together and have ended up making a song that sounds physically huge, as if it fills the room with amazing sound. Your sounds and techniques mingle perfectly and have ended up creating something truly beautiful. I really hope you two correlate again in the future if music like this is the end result. Keep up the great work you two, I really hope you're proud of your amazing work.
4 likesReplies (3)
thanks a lot, it means a lot to get this sort of praise after the work that went into it. I think you mean "collaboration" by the way :)
1 like@replacer Oops, my bad. Great work though man, keep it up
0 likesI really appreciate the kind words! I'm working on some new stuff as I write this, stay tuned :)
0 likesGlad I turned a brony radio on the right moment. Great song :)
0 likesAnd I can't help the feeling that I know the style. I'm certain I heard something similar somewhere, some time ago :3
This is a beautiful song.
2 likesI think I'm in love with this song. It's absolutely beautiful!
0 likesThe lyrics are amazing !!! This is now my favourite song
0 likes5 years ago I heard this song, and it is still very nice! :)
0 likesAnd yea, that guitar solo really reminds Queen.
2 songs in 2 weeks?!?!?!?!
2 likesI must be in heaven or something! 0_o
AWESOME I LOVE IT!!!
Thanks so much 8D Stay awesome you two!!!
Ahhhh one of my favorite Replacer songs of all time.
2 likesFantastic as always, Replacer ^.^
0 likesThis is seriously amazing
2 likesReplies (2)
Thanks!!
2 likesThank you ^^
2 likesThis is actually really good.
2 likesBrilliant! Absolutely brilliant good song guys!
0 likesMy friend: "Who listens to Replacer at 3 in the morning?" Later...Alarm rings Me: "Oh boy 3 AM!" plays Replacer playlist
4 likesI am just in love with this song !, it’s wonderful !
0 likesreally nice job on this. /)
3 likesReplies (1)
Thank you!
0 likesBeautiful song :3
1 likeWonderful! Simply marvelous! Superb! I could go on! Fantastic!
2 likesI love this, such a good release replacer
0 likesThis is a wonderfully song. I love it.
0 likesseveral months later this is still great
0 likesLove the song!
0 likesI love this music guy, I am a french brony and I love your songs.
0 likesThat instrumental around 3:50 reminds me of Hotel California. Love that song, love this one
0 likesReplies (2)
I definitely had that type of thing in mind, I was pretty happy with the result
1 likeThank you!! I love the Eagles.
1 likePretty good song! I found it when I was on DeviantART
2 likesI almost expected the first line to be "Run, rabbit, run".
4 likesSong sounds a bit retro, not often do I hear that in the fandom.
1 likeThat solo though.
2 likesAt first I was getting a Pink Floyd, "Dark Side of the Moon" vibe, and then "Junk" by Paul McCartney, and now The Association... Maybe even B.J. Thomas... Basically, this song puts me back in touch with my feels... I'm in love with a song.
0 likesI love this song it's so cute and beautiful.I also love the art for the song to :3
0 likesOnly through ability.
0 likesOnly through capability.
Only through capacity.
Only through skill.
Only through talent.
I think the song is a mix between Chicago, Toto and Electric Light Orchestra with a little bit of Hotel California ( 3:37 - 4:43 ).
1 likethe live stream with Knifeh where awesome and we got a preview of this song now... its even better
1 likeReplies (3)
Burning! <3
0 likes@MegabyteBrony Mega!! i see you still live, Dino keeping to the shadows then?
0 likes@burningruin666 yes:)
0 likesReally pretty song >~<
1 likeIs it just me but in the beginning it sounds like a Beatles song
12 likesReplies (1)
The beginning chords are somewhat reminiscent of Paul McCartney's song; "Uncle Albert"
2 likesOh my... This is amazing!
0 likesReplies (1)
Thank you so very much!
1 likethis song is awesome!
0 likesThis is in my pony playlist, but I have no recollection of ever hearing it before. I wish I could say this was a rare occurrence. Apparently I just have a short attention span.
0 likesGreat song :D
0 likesI dunno why but, I can't stop thinking of David Bowie.
1 likeI must have the chords!!! <33333
0 likesOh my, I really luv this song.<3 :'3
0 likesYou lucky bastards going to bronycon :p
0 likesAwesome song, as always :)
Replies (2)
Oh I'm not at Bronycon, I was just acknowledging that it's on at the moment haha
0 likes@replacer
0 likesaww :(
When I look at the picture I'm like "Oh what lovely stallions <3 They're so sweet and handsome! Oh and there's that fluttershy too..."
1 likeThat bridge fills me with so many good feels ;-;
0 likesahh, so peacefull sounding, and idk, almost a beatles sound to it.
0 likesReplies (1)
That's what Replacer was going for when we were working on this. It's great! /)
0 likesLove it love it love it
0 likesawesome! Very pretty :)
2 likesThis strangely reminded me of Wonderwall... lol~
4 likesReplies (2)
That's kinda cool. Always interested to hear comparisons to bands I wasn't thinking about during the process, it lends another perspective ^^
7 likes@replacer Hrmmm, I got a strong late-70s vibe myself... Absolutely fantastic!
1 like
0 likesAmazing! This reminds of The Beatles.
Has it really been 6 years already?
0 likesReplacer's expression though
1 likeReplies (1)
I accept no responsibility x3
0 likesB-e-a-utiful song!
1 likeyour voice is so soothing ;u;
2 likesWhy have those ponies behind flutters got such pretty eyes?
0 likesDoes anyone else sing along with this sounding like "mumble mumble mumble FLUUTTERSHYYYYYY!!!"
0 likesDash is gonna be pissed at this lack of loyalty!
1 likeReplies (1)
Dash and I have an understanding, it's cool :P
1 like<3
3 likesReplies (1)
Thanks man! :)
1 likeSOO COOL^^
0 likesmakes me think of the beatles for some reason ^_^
0 likesso lovely, so soft, so aaaaaaaaaaaah :3
2 likesReplies (1)
Thank you! This is my first pony related song. I'll be doing more stuff soon <3
1 likeGroovy man
1 likeThis is a very good song. The tune is very catchy. Strange that there are no comments despite there being over twenty-two thousand views.
0 likesReplies (4)
@***** there are too comments :o
0 likes@replacer - Weird. A little line of text stated that there were none, and I thought mine didn't show up at all when I hit post.
0 likesI've gone to look, and my comment is not visible. The latest comment I can see is from two weeks ago, from Lil' Gadgetzan.
@***** that's a weird glitch. You're definitely viewing comments as 'newest first' by the way? Sometimes youtube marks comments as spam for no reason, but that didn't happen here.
0 likes@replacer - Yes, newest first.
0 likesOnly 670 likes!?!?!? what is life?!?!?!?
1 likei go sleep with mlp song and i add this song to sleepsong list :D sleepsong list on mobile
0 likesLooks like you two have a crush on somepony
0 likesReplies (2)
Who doesn't have a crush on Yellowquiet?!
2 likesOf course ;)
2 likesCalming
0 likesI don't know why but it won't let me download this on bandcamp
0 likesReplies (1)
sorry to hear that, I gave it a try and it seems to work fine for me, but here's an alternative link anyway http://nc.harmonytreehouse.com/s/wRd7wKKYaYSb25j/download
0 likesfluttershy is best poni
0 likesIs the singer using auto tune?
0 likesHey I have some bad news
0 likesReplies (1)
I just want to point out that I didn't write the lyrics and didn't draw the art so for all I know it was from discord's pov the whole time :P
1 likethy
0 likes