I got another theory.

What if Discord's dimension is one he created for himself so he could have a realm of chaos all to himself since he can't plunge Equestria into chaos?

thats... what I thought the whole time automaticly-.

I have a very similar theory. First of all, I think that are many Draconeqqus, other than Discord, and second, I think that the reason we don't see them is because they each have their own dimensions that they make their very own, and that most of them don't associate with Equestria much.

I think he could have power from all dimension

Oh that’s a good one. Like a blank canvas, begging to be filled with whatever discord wants! Though, I feel bad for the mailpony LOL!


2:01 Wait...was that an "entering the Nether Portal" sound effect from Minecraft...?

It doesn't quite have the teleportation "woosh" so more like idle active nether portal.


The Story of the Smooze:<br>He's a weak defenceless body and when he eats magical items, the magic converts to goo aka a magical forcefield. Discord takes him around so he can just throw the Smooze in front of him if the alicorns use their turn to stone spell on him :) Think about it, if he didn't need the Smooze he would just go to the Gala using his ticket with Fluttershy (he coped with the MANE 6 for a whole 2 episodes Return of Harmony Pt 1 and 2 - I think he could've coped with Treehunter for.a few mins)

The Story of the Smooze:
He's a weak defenceless body and when he eats magical items, the magic converts to goo aka a magical forcefield. Discord takes him around so he can just throw the Smooze in front of him if the alicorns use their turn to stone spell on him :) Think about it, if he didn't need the Smooze he would just go to the Gala using his ticket with Fluttershy (he coped with the MANE 6 for a whole 2 episodes Return of Harmony Pt 1 and 2 - I think he could've coped with Treehunter for.a few mins)


THE REFERENCES THE FLUTTERCORD!!!! I think that episode of mlp was my absolute fave!!!

@甘雨 haver it's. Fiction but it's prob bc he's immortal not old lol? Immortal ppl don't age on looks but only on number ig but that's a different he's a immortal not a normall.pony lol

Fluttercord is the nastiest ship in history

Oh not good like my joke Q:what room can you not go in to? A:a mushroom

Speaking of fluttercord ever read/watched a fanfic called Bride of Discord by DisneyFanatic2364? It is stinking awesome!!!!!!!!! Just an idea for a next video <b>cough cough review cough</b>

Speaking of fluttercord ever read/watched a fanfic called Bride of Discord by DisneyFanatic2364? It is stinking awesome!!!!!!!!! Just an idea for a next video *cough cough review cough*


I think you're brilliant, and I'm definitely going to start analyzing the show in greater depth.

Definitely overlooked that the Smooze grows/glows from only certain consumables. It's invulnerability to magic wasn't something I gave much thought to either, but given its history in the older generation and the multi-dimensional theory you mentioned, it does weave a pretty beautiful story. This video, as many others, definitely gave my head canon another boost.

Thanks as always for your thoughts /)


FINALLY!<br>SOMEONE ELSE KNOWS ABOUT THE OLD VERSION OF THE SMOOZE!

FINALLY!
SOMEONE ELSE KNOWS ABOUT THE OLD VERSION OF THE SMOOZE!

I know what the SMOOZE is...G1 is darker than you think...G1 Tirek turns pony's into dragons, G1 Grogar wants slaves and almost succeeds....And....Um...G1 is dark, that's all I'm going to say.

I literally used to have the old movies I threw them away since I thought it was terrifying

i do !! i watched that movie when i was a kid :]


I have spent half of my day watching your videos.<br>+1 sub.

I have spent half of my day watching your videos.
+1 sub.

+xDeviantx xTitanx many thanks, just steer clear of some of the old ones ;)


When tirek absorbs discords magic he doesn't feel weird I think when he takes magic ✨ that magic turns into his magic


This dude is LITERALLY the smartest person I know!


What would have happened if she'd gone through the portal?

Fluttershy and Discord wouldnt be friends, thats all I know

The sock puppet would’ve devoured all of her life energy

Athena Bassett she would turn in to a puppet

Athena Bassett she would turn into a sock puppet?

Athena Bassett she would have either been stuck in the dimension or she could have turned into a pony sock puppet


I love how the Smooze totally reminded if FiW.<br>I mean, it's "Lord Smooze" in FiW, so it's powerful. And it resisted alicorn magic. It's green, just like the goo the cult followers put on their face, and, well, the name obviously. (And I probably forgot other references)

I love how the Smooze totally reminded if FiW.
I mean, it's "Lord Smooze" in FiW, so it's powerful. And it resisted alicorn magic. It's green, just like the goo the cult followers put on their face, and, well, the name obviously. (And I probably forgot other references)


3:04 I don't even watch ether Star Wars or Star Trek but that made me vocally exclaim my discontent as having a basic knowledge of both franchises.

I was sleeping but I found myself suddenly waking up angry.

TEHewy ARGH THANK YOU LIKE CMON ALL IT TAKES IS A FUCKING GOOGLE


When you mentioned Smooze eating the gems, glowing, and growing in size, I thought that him consuming and utilizing the magic in the gems sort of game him an immunity to magic, and that he ate so many magical gems that he eventually became immune to Alicorn magic.

Also, Smooze reminds me of the cheap horror film the Blob
Aaaaand I get the feeling that you intentionally mixed up Star Wars and Star Trek...


I wish they went through the portal. I would honestly travel anywhere in the world just to see magical 2D ponies from a different dimension.


I was wondering when he would manage to fit in a fluttercord clip.

@Mike Prophete bro u prob talking Abt the age gap but it's prob because he's a immortal

@gamergirl20 the last episode of season 9 proves it is a thing, lol


Brony Notion: I think I’m starting to make sense of Discord’s nonsense<br>Discord: that’s illegal

Brony Notion: I think I’m starting to make sense of Discord’s nonsense
Discord: that’s illegal


I think the smooze's reaction to all magic types is kinda like a balloon to air, the smooze itself being the balloon, and magic being the air, it rebounds the magic within itself, and the constant flow of magic causes it to expand.


I spent all night last night watching your videos. I LOVE them! Could you do more theories with the CMC? I'd love if you replied. Kitty Corner signing out until next comment. BroPaw!


I must say I am really impressed by how you twissted Discord's non-sense into sense. He lives in a void between worlds, with magic of its own. That totally makes sense.


Actually, the "Sonic Bliss" could very well be a real thing. As I'm sure almost everyone who's taken physics knows, sound waves have different frequencies depending on their pitch. Notice that the "Sonic Bliss" has two different parts to it: a very low, constant note (a C to be exact), and a very high-pitched, varying note, which is indeterminable, since it's changing within the amount of time it's played. So one constant, relatively slow wave, and one ever-changing, relatively fast wave, constantly alternating. Now let's take a look at the Smooze. It definitely seems like a creature that would respond to sound waves, given its... Smooziness. Think of it as a massage of sound waves. Now this may be another factor of its magic, or it could just be a thing that has nothing to DO with magic. But whatever it is, Tree Hugger's "Sonic Bliss" makes sense, and is probably why the Smooze was stopped.


Love your theory!<br>Also the gem one connects with this very well.

Love your theory!
Also the gem one connects with this very well.


This stuff first appeared in Generation 1's "My Little Pony: The Movie" if I'm not mistaken. It was purple then and made from a list of gross and one difficult to obtain ingredient. We only see one witch and her two bumbling daughters make it, but it's implied that others know how to make the (at least semi-cognizant) goop. It wasn't able to be defeated by the Rainbow of Light. The only thing that could "defeat" it was the flutterponies. They blew it back to the volcano, thus not defeating it, just sending it back.

I can get behind Discord's home being between all dimensions. I can also get behind your theory about crystals and their magic being something that would strengthen dragons and the Smooze. I use this theory with the dragons (and kirins) of the MLP-based land I rp for.


The snooze came from The Mineraft dimension  (since dimentinal portals are cannon in both worlds) they're both out for shiny things  (player armor, tools ect), they both range in sizes, and they actually look the about the same


In many cases, there is a 'space between worlds' in books and tv shows and whatnot where alternate dimensions are cannon. However, sometimes that space is pure void, and other times there's something more there, like a bunch of sleepy ponds an trees. I like your theory about how the chaos place where discord lives is this space, it would fit in better that way than an alternate diminsion. Like Fluttershy said in that very episode, Discord's magic is chaos based. This brings into question his backstory. Many believe that Discord is Starswirl the Bearded after he failed the spell that Twilight fixed in Magical Mystery Cure. I like this theory, because it brings up the importance and balance that having friends has on magic (them being basically the same thing). Deffinitly would love to see this adressed in the show, or maybe a new video?


i think what tree huger did was perfectly valid and what she did physically effected him and i wanna think that ponies outside of equstria have their own spiritual ways that don't  work on the same level as magic. yes i am stating that the spiritual either isn't magic or is different enough to be classified as something else.


I loved the 1980s Smooze! I loved it then, I love it now. As a teen, when I was reading HP Lovecraft, I read about the Shaggoth and I thought, I've seen this! It's the Smooze. The green stuff that Discord dragged in... that let me down. It is logical that the Smooze comes from a different dimension. In the movie, it was summoned when witches threw ingredients into a volcano. And only the flutter-ponies had the right kind of magic to stop it.


I love the world between worlds reference he made to Magician's Nephew. and I like how you even showed an image of all the different pools. Magician's Nephew is one of my favorite but thank you for doing that.bro hoof!


Your theory sounds similar to something I thought of some time ago (how multiple fictional worlds are actually parts of the multiverse).


In my mind a see gems as being like a semi-conducter, being highly enchant-able, or in terms of electricity high utility. As for the smooze I see him as being like rubber, a magical insulator. So in a way it makes sense that the smooze could eat gems and make a non conductive substance, as a semi-conductor can be made conductive or non conductive.


I think that's a fun headcanon. I prefer thinking that that Smooze is from an alternate version OF the old generation 1 show. And I do like the notion that Discord would be a creature of the in-between.

Kind of like Bill Cipher in that regard. (Journal 3 explains the alternate universes a lot better than the show does.)


Lol I love how you deliberately mixed star wars and star trek up in was hilarious<br>Also I think you may be onto something and I think the show should do an episode revolving around parallel dimensions but what do you think?

Lol I love how you deliberately mixed star wars and star trek up in was hilarious
Also I think you may be onto something and I think the show should do an episode revolving around parallel dimensions but what do you think?


Wait a minute. If Discord lives in another dimension, or even between dimensions, how could the average pony postman even get there on hoof? Wouldn't he need a portal of some sort? Are there naturally occurring portals between worlds in the hidden depths of Equestria? Does the postal service have access to a paid-for portal? If none of this is true, then where does Discord live that could be so chaotic yet still reachable by walking there? I know the postman gets lost, but he still manages to get there, eventually.


I suppose, though, I like the idea that the snooze draws power from gems to survive like they are magic batteries.<br>Also, I'm going that socket puppet world is a world like Elmo's world, not ours

I suppose, though, I like the idea that the snooze draws power from gems to survive like they are magic batteries.
Also, I'm going that socket puppet world is a world like Elmo's world, not ours

What if it was actually DHMIAS? :D<br>Let's never be creative again...

What if it was actually DHMIAS? :D
Let's never be creative again...

@The Autistic Pony Yes it was Elmo's world lol!

its defintly elmo's world
starts singing Elmo's world theme song

its defintly elmo's world
_starts singing Elmo's world theme song_

@Discord Draconequus sorry i tried to stop him lord discord but he bucked me in the face

@The Autistic Pony uh...you do that.
*Tears up Warning sighs in front of Portal*

@The Autistic Pony uh...you do that.
**Tears up Warning sighs in front of Portal**

Oh my gosh! I'm not the only person who thinks it's Elmo's World? :3 <b>hugs</b>

Oh my gosh! I'm not the only person who thinks it's Elmo's World? :3 *hugs*


For the sake of scientific accuracy, you should say universes, not dimensions; the two are vastly different concepts.<br>Also, I'd say that Discord's home is more in line with a pocket universe than a space between worlds. If such a thing were to exist, then I doubt even he could shape it into what he has on the show. Even chaos magic has to obey physics.

For the sake of scientific accuracy, you should say universes, not dimensions; the two are vastly different concepts.
Also, I'd say that Discord's home is more in line with a pocket universe than a space between worlds. If such a thing were to exist, then I doubt even he could shape it into what he has on the show. Even chaos magic has to obey physics.


If they're incompatible with each other, how could Discord's magic be stopped by the elements of harmony and stolen by Tirek?


I found it funny when he said he heard sci-fi nerds yelling at him, and pretty much all sci-fi nerds knew the reason was actually because Q wasn't in TOS, he premiered in TNG.

Let alone he said Star Wars instead of Star Trek


That would make sense especially if discord was star swirl so far there the only two we know can open portals at there own will with there own magic not using objects


YASSSSS HE SHIPS FLUTTERCORD @***** @Carmen -Mary Medley- @Nstone53

@Pinkie Rose 6 years later but I love this :)

@Awestruck Green but SugerMac is a thing now as for Dislestia it could be a thing

♡L̆̈ŭ̈z̆̈ N̆̈ŏ̈c̆̈ĕ̈d̆̈ă̈♡

Yeah I ship it!
I hate discelestia
And twicord

No I'll report to the court ! * Joke * Ha ha ha

( sees ending of fluttercord)

My reaction: THE SHIPPERS ARE COMING THE SHIPPERS ARE COMING!!!!

+[Twel Saloom] even Nicole Oliver (celestial) wants Celestial to go on a bowling date with discord at babscon2014

@Awestruck Green He only wanted discord at the gala because she said if discord is not there it would be boring.Also he only gave flowers because he was so happy on that day and he wanted to share his happiness. She only laughs at his jokes because she think it was funny but others didn't think so.

+[Twel Saloom] Dilestia is meant to be
-He gave her flowers (Twis Kindom pt2)
-She laughed at his joke (make new friends....)
-she wanted discord at the gala
-

@Twel saloom you don't what me to answerer that

@Twel saloom because i find brony notions videos interesting and as something to entertain me  it doesn't matter that i don't ship fluttercord (yelling doesn't help though)

Also twel discord doesn't like the fluttercord

Twel don't shout inside voice please
sips cup of tea

Twel don't shout inside voice please
*sips cup of tea*

@Pinkie Rose
*Stares at you ticked*
*Says in Soft angry voice*
I dont like you, or your ship

@Pinkie Rose
**Stares at you ticked**
**Says in Soft angry voice**
I dont like you, or your ship

don't listen to them awestruck green dislestia for life

The Potato Queen is a lie. I stole her crown. She is no more. I threw her over enemy lines as a peace offering.

@Pinkie Rose If we let this become a argument about ships nopony is gonna be happy. Instead, worship Potato Queen!

I'm being honest when I say that pictures of Fluttermac are most adorable things I've ever seen.

Okay, while I do like Fluttercord more, I do admit that Fluttermac is pretty adorable as well. And there's no actual proof of Fluttercord being cannon, and even if there was that wouldn't mean that people couldn't think that Fluttermac is better. That's the point of head cannons, and always fallowing exactly what the show says is cannon is boring. So I say ship whatever cute ponies you feel like!

Flutter cord FOREVER!!!!! Fluttermac doesn't even exist they haven't even seen each other much only in Filli Vanilli. Fluttercord is CANON! :)

@Adam taleb <b>holds you gently stroking your hair</b> shhh shhh shhhh..it's ok.. it's all in your head.

@Adam taleb *holds you gently stroking your hair* shhh shhh shhhh..it's ok.. it's all in your head.

@Pinkie Rose Ah! Potato Queen is here, all bow before her now! By the way your highness, I love BoD sooooo much, you guys do amazing work.

No Fluttermac and Dislestia ! Like if you agree!


Hey, kind of off topic, but do you think if Star Swirl didnt turn himself into Discord, he might've become an alicorn? I mean, in terms of magic, Star Swirl is just as powerful as Twilight if not more powerful. He definitely has (or rather had) what it takes to contain and control alicorn magic.


I thought you were gonna call the Smooze a sentient pool of melted gems. Which, would make complete sense honestly. That he is nearly pure magic. I like that idea. Though it entirely ignores his purple cousin's origins.


Actually, it would make sense for Discord to be able to open the portal like Star Swirl the Bearded based on your previous theories that Discord was once Stars Swirl.


Pinky Pie's more chaotic abilities also seem like they could be interactions with other dimensions


I think, the Smooze is just another thing that creators of FiM "borrowed" from first generations, same as Tirek and Scorpan in end of Season 4. And after I heard, the Discord named the think "Smooze", I've got the instant flashback of G1 My Little Pony Movie from 1986. But it's bit interesting, the Smooze has been recoloured from purple to some sort of lime green and his "character" has been changed in comparison with G1 Smooze... There's many things, what I can discuss about, but there's not enough space to express my thinkings...


the only episode I ever watched of the original mlp series was the episode with the smooze, I saw it a very long time ago so I remembered it only when I saw the image, and this thing isn't just scary by looks but also by how it demolished everything in the original series, not eating JUST shiny jewel stuff.


In my fantasy, every series and stand alone has its own dimension, for example, there's a Warrior cats dimension, a My Little Pony dimension, a Wings of Fire dimension, and a Percy Jackson dimension, among others


The ending was all I needed to LOVE THIS CHANNEL!!!!    Bart Simpson's Woo Hoo


A thought just came to mind, if Discord can open portals to different worlds, than who's to say he can't come to our world and the mane six?


I liked your idea that discord is star swirl and while I tried to find proof that he is, I found proof that he isn't: Before discords second episode (or third, wateva) he had no experience with friendship. But star swirl befriended Tiraks bro (scorpan?). And Tirak seemed to know who discord was, and lord Tirak was imprisoned for years. And since Star swirl was a pony at the time, Tirak would've had no idea who he was.

And the princesses turned Discord to stone. He ruled equestria for a while, and I think that Tirak was imprisoned sometime after discord was turned to stone.

If you could prove me wrong, that would be awesome.


All right, I've been thinking. There's no way Discord can be Star Swirl the Bearded. Star Swirl was around before Equestria was made, when the ponies argued and froze their old land (as the character Twilight played in "Hearth's Warming Eve" said that Star Swirl taught her about Wendigos), and after Discord had been defeated. Why, you ask? Tirek and Scorpan didn't come to Equestria till after Discord was defeated, because Celestia and Luna didn't rule until they had defeated Discord. And Scorpan alerted Celestia and Luna to Tirek's threat, and was friends with Star Swirl.


I think treehugger’s singing DID do what you said it didn’t. Many animals respond only to vibration and sound. It’s possible the Smooze works the same way.


For me, from what I saw, this just proves the Star Swirl the bearded theory. Star Swirl is the only one we have seen open a rift to another world. And then Discord can now magically open one. Maybe its just a coincidence, or maybe he remember this magic trick from his younger pony-formed days when he opened a portal/ rift to another dimension to banish the Dazzlings. <b>gasp</b>     (I know, kind of weird, but you somewhat understand the theory...)

For me, from what I saw, this just proves the Star Swirl the bearded theory. Star Swirl is the only one we have seen open a rift to another world. And then Discord can now magically open one. Maybe its just a coincidence, or maybe he remember this magic trick from his younger pony-formed days when he opened a portal/ rift to another dimension to banish the Dazzlings. *gasp*     (I know, kind of weird, but you somewhat understand the theory...)

Ok why is there so much talking? Sorry but still I can't read all of what you put down ALERT TOO MUCH TALKING!!!!!!!! So sorry about that but yeah........:|

@***** True but we also see Discord trying to discourage Fluttershy before finally resorting to forcing her to be discouraged through magic so I don't think Discord would apply magic in this way. Also when he was turned to stone he looked overly confident until the last second, suggesting he did not think they would pull it off and thus that it did not warrant extreme magic

@***** I agree that we could use some more information, atm it's just a possible(albeit unlikely) theory

@***** "stone and couldn't be star at the same time"
after getting out of stone, Discord could go back in time and shape shift to look like star, as for a time limit, there is nothing supporting a time limit on shape shifting and there is nothing to say that there isn't a more powerful time spell. Also if you have seen the most recent episode
[minor spoiler warning]
Discord lives in an alternate dimension, what's to say that from that dimension he couldn't go back to the "normal" Equestrian dimension at a different time?

@***** "stone and couldn't be star at the same time"
after getting out of stone, Discord could go back in time and shape shift to look like star, as for a time limit, there is nothing supporting a time limit on shape shifting and there is nothing to say that there isn't a more powerful time spell. Also if you have seen the most recent episode
*[minor spoiler warning]*
Discord lives in an alternate dimension, what's to say that from that dimension he couldn't go back to the "normal" Equestrian dimension at a different time?

@***** He was a unicorn in disguise when he met Tirek.

Time travel messes up story lines. It turns a line into a ball of wibbly wobbly timey wimey stuff. Plus discord shape-shifts all the time meaning he could have shape-shifted back into star swirl.

@***** Alternate theory, Discord was keeping Twilight away so she would not realize that Discord is star

"didn't say that the spell that mixed up cutie marks was his last it was just said to be unfinished, which gets rid of the theory that the spell mixed him up into discord"
no, a different spell could, or the unfinished spell could have been his last but Celestia didn't feel like mentioning it, hell Celestia could have known and purposefully left that out

"He most likely wouldn't have planned to switch his body so he wouldn't have cloned and the only thing we see that change forms are changlings"
Just because we have only seen changelings change form does not mean nothing else can, it simply means we have not seen it.

@***** I wouldn't say i "Crashed"<br>it >:3

@***** I wouldn't say i "Crashed"
it >:3

@Mister Mixup We haven't gotten a true full history yet though, we don't know how star swirl died and those he could have been transformed into Discord. His unlimited power is what would make the spell last longer.

@niamy1
While you're not wrong, remember that time travel was shown to be largely impractical, ineffective and extremely difficult to pull off. Not to mention VERY brief.
Yeah you could argue that with Discord's seemingly unlimited power supply, he could use time travel magic to a much greater effect, but then there would be no fathomable reason for him to have ever lost in the first place.

So yes, while it's fully possible for Discord to be Star Swirl, and there's nothing going against that, there's nothing really supporting the theory either.

That and, such a prominent historical figure can't just become a corrupted demigod without, you know, history mentioning it.

@niamy1
While you're not wrong, remember that time travel was shown to be largely impractical, ineffective and extremely difficult to pull off. Not to mention VERY brief.
Yeah you could argue that with Discord's seemingly unlimited power supply, he could use time travel magic to a much greater effect, but then there would be no fathomable reason for him to have ever lost in the first place.

So yes, while it's fully *possible* for Discord to be Star Swirl, and there's nothing going against that, there's nothing really supporting the theory either.

That and, such a prominent historical figure can't just become a corrupted demigod without, you know, history mentioning it.

@Mister Mixup You are forgetting that Star Swirl knew time travel magic. Time travel means you can be in two places at once. <br>So there is no lore at the moment that can discredit the theory.

@Mister Mixup You are forgetting that Star Swirl knew time travel magic. Time travel means you can be in two places at once.
So there is no lore at the moment that can discredit the theory.

@vc Turtle Discord and Star Swirl both existed at the same time. Tirek remembers Discord from before he was imprisoned in Tartarus, and Tirek's brother was friends with Star Swirl.<br>Can't be the same being.

@vc Turtle Discord and Star Swirl both existed at the same time. Tirek remembers Discord from before he was imprisoned in Tartarus, and Tirek's brother was friends with Star Swirl.
Can't be the same being.

@***** twilight went back to warn herself not to worry, thus showing discord could

He didn't do anything while stone but he was a time traveler so that means he could easily have been in multiple places at once including being unaware of himself being Discord to coronate the sisters in his pony form.

@***** after being released from stone discord could have gone back in time looking like star to complete the timeline

@***** But Star Swirl created spells for traveling through time and dimensions. If we assume that Discord and Star Swirl are one and the same, then it's certainly possible that Discord cast a time spell, or that Star Swirl cast a time spell that both changed his existence and sent him back in time. Spells can often have unintended effects, as was the case the first time Star Swirl tried casting a time travel spell in the Journal of the Two Sisters: his beard became shorter because it had the unintended side effect of also being an age spell.

@niamy1 In the Journal of the Two Sisters, it is stated, among other things, that Star Swirl coronated the two sisters and that the sisters had only heard that the Tree of Harmony contained the elements of all things harmonious. Since Discord was defeated with the Elements, the princesses couldn't have defeated him before they knew the significance of the Tree of Harmony.

@***** Where is that canon? I'm curious so I can quote it for later. :)

@rillegas08  Well thank you for understanding. For most people would have had a nervous breakdown, about how 'Discord Isn't Star Swirl the Bearded!' So thank you for understanding

@vc Turtle in the comic "Fiendship is Magic # 5", it shows Star Swirl sending the Sirens through the Crystal Mirror to the Equestria Girls world. But I agree, this does lend some more credence to the theory.


Instead of calling the smooze "IT", you can call it "Hermophrodite Hexapod." Meaning: It is neither male or female. Look it up. It's from Doctor who. The 3rd doctor (I think) calls "Alpha Centauri" a hermophrodite hexapod in "The Curse of Peladon".


SOMETHING BAD IS GOING DOWN, HAVE YOU HEARD THE NEWS?! <b>some next lines...</b> NOTHING CAN STOP, THE SMOOZE! (Apart from those pixie/fairies ponies that whooped their flank in the movie...)

SOMETHING BAD IS GOING DOWN, HAVE YOU HEARD THE NEWS?! *some next lines...* NOTHING CAN STOP, THE SMOOZE! (Apart from those pixie/fairies ponies that whooped their flank in the movie...)

The… the breezies? That name was invented during g3, and now breezies are in g4, <del>silly seabreeze</del> uhh flutter ponies

The… the breezies? That name was invented during g3, and now breezies are in g4, -silly seabreeze- uhh flutter ponies


I got that Narnia reference! Also I totally think that's possible, but if Discord's home is the world between worlds and Discord's magic is compatible with multiple kinds of magic, how did he get that kind of colossal power and ability simply from a mistaken transformation since he was, according to the Brony Notion at least, (I agree) originally Starswirl the Bearded.


He looks identical to the ooze created by the Changelings, and he seems resistant to magic in the same way, perhaps when Changeling ooze is in great enough quantities it develops a consciousness? <br>Would also explain how small amounts of the ooze were able to be destroyed by unicorn magic during the Canterlot Wedding, maybe they only become resistant to magic after reaching a certain size

He looks identical to the ooze created by the Changelings, and he seems resistant to magic in the same way, perhaps when Changeling ooze is in great enough quantities it develops a consciousness?
Would also explain how small amounts of the ooze were able to be destroyed by unicorn magic during the Canterlot Wedding, maybe they only become resistant to magic after reaching a certain size


Ever since season 2, alicorn magic have been on a steady decline for me. Since the show have failed to demonstrate that it is anymore powerful than normal magic.

@Zaron728 No, they just don't have that power.


I personally think while Luna was in her "nightmare moon" phase she made a deal with discord he could make the smooze for Luna but he could depower it at any time this also explains why we've never seen the smooze before season 4/5(I forgot) because discord hid it in his dimension until he got jealous and it explains how he knows and I forgot if we actually saw Luna at this gala but if we didn't that also explains it too


Your theory seems very well thought out. I mean when his magic is taken from him the background doesn't change in it. IT changes. Which means his magic is acting like a window to the fabric of space. And maybe time. <b>goes on to talk about the 1-5 walls</b>

Your theory seems very well thought out. I mean when his magic is taken from him the background doesn't change in it. IT changes. Which means his magic is acting like a window to the fabric of space. And maybe time. *goes on to talk about the 1-5 walls*


The smooze must have an protecter which is the thick outline on him and the smooze is made out of both blue and yellow magic coloured waste so when ever he feeds off of gems the magic between all three had a reaction causing him to grow


With the Discord's dimensional powers, you think Discord met Clockwork and Walker (both from Danny Phantom, and I can see Walker trying and epically failing to arrest Discord to the point he tries to ban that crazy Draconequus) at one point? Man, this makes many crossovers so much easier! [Squeals.]


I would dive into how I think the “world between the worlds” idea works, buut that’d be a very long story.


You mentioned that different dimensions have been canon since Equestria Girls. However, the flaw in that statement is that Equestria Girls is not canon. Equestria Girls is basically the equivalent of the older Dragonball Z movies. They aren't canon. In fact, if you were to try to place the movie, Broly: The Legendary Super Saiyan into the DBZ timeline, it wouldn't fit in properly. It takes place during the Cell saga. But when you think of it, you won't be able to find a specific point because you will find too many contradictions. You could say that it takes place after Cell was defeated, considering the peaceful time it takes place. But the flaw in that is that if that were the case, Future Trunks would've gone back to the future by this point. And even if it was before he left for the future, Goku is still alive, where Goku was killed during the battle. Perhaps you could place it before the Cell saga. But the two main flaws come from the fact that Future Trunks wouldn't have come back yet, and Gohan had his Super Saiyan powers, which he gained during the training for the Cell Games. So you can place what time it would exist in. But it wouldn't fit in with the canon of the main series.

I'm not saying alternate dimensions wouldn't be a thing, since Discord revealed that they do exist. But a non-canon movie can't make something canon...Also, on the subject of canon, I don't care who says what, Derpy Hooves is Derpy's canon name. Sure, when they remade that episode, they took out the name. But it was said, which proves that the name 'Derpy Hooves' was canon to the makers. And the name Ditzy Doo is not a nickname for Derpy. The makers even remade Winter Wrap Up to change the design for Ditzy so that she wouldn't be confused with Derpy. In fact, it annoys me that people still insist that her name is Ditzy, even though the show put effort into pointing out that Ditzy isn't Derpy. Don't get me wrong, when there was the internet war before that one episode that was debating whether her name was Derpy or Ditzy, I was on the side of Ditzy. But the show made Derpy canon and I accepted that.

...But I digress.


If discords dimension connects to other shows that would explain why the smooze wouldn't react to alicorn magic. Think about it. If the smooze and discord came from the same dimension then the smooze should have reacted to alicorn magic beacuse discord has been defeated by celistia and luna, sure they had the help of the elements of harmony but still. Now here is where the smooze comes in. If that is the case then they couldn't be from the same dimension, but the smooze is originally from g1, which dosent have alicorns, which would explain why it wouldn't react to alicorn magic, the smooze in g1 was made up of various things that the two witches gathered, in the end the smooze was defeated by the rainbow of light, but this would very well explain why the smooze didn't react to alicorn magic beacuse its originally from g1, which dosent have alicorns.


I wish they kept the smooze from before, it would have made a great episode, a slightly scary one maybe!


(Spoiler Warning) The comic books also have alternative dimensions.  One was reversed in morality (good guys were bad and bad where good) and Princess Celestia had crossed over in a device made by StarSwirl the Bearded.  She actually had a star crossed lover things going with good King Sombra


I think Discord's magic is chaos to Equestrian beings because it is interpreted by Equestria in this manner. In his world, this kind of magic makes sense as his world is lawless, but to us it would be chaos as our world must obey set laws of physics and Equestrian types of magic. So, his magic is neither absolute chaos nor absolute logic. It is only to the interpretation that this seems to become certain.


Just a thought here: what if the Smooze is like the Blob, but doesn't absorb ponys, animals, or people, but magic and shiny things instead?

There a couple horror movies you'd need to watch to understand the Blob reference, sorry.


Q and Discord is indeed quite simular, but I do not belive them to be one and the same.<br>However, if you look at how soulmates work in the game Ni No Kuni, Q and Discord might be soulmates across multidimensional realms.

Q and Discord is indeed quite simular, but I do not belive them to be one and the same.
However, if you look at how soulmates work in the game Ni No Kuni, Q and Discord might be soulmates across multidimensional realms.

@KvaGram I'll ship Q and Discord. The only problem I'm seeing is all the reality warping they'll be doing for shits and giggles. And the Egos.... and the Narcissism.... and the Egos.... and the Egos. Also the Egos. Have I mentioned their Egos?


The smooze in the movie was made by a potion, and in the song "Nothing can stop the Smooze", they say, well, nothing can stop the smooze. That would make sense why the alicorns can't stop it. I believe at the end of the movie the smooze is stopped by the magic of the original breezies or fairies. Also, I know all this because I own the movie! ^_^ Also I subbed


If the Smooze's magic is completely incompatible with the magic of Equestria, then how could he benefit from the equestrian magic in gems.


Yes, Discord lives not only between dimensions and has the power to cross them but he also has extended knowledge he doesn't tell ponies about. I'm still waiting for the episode that confirms Discord and Celestia previous relationship. I know there had to be one. If Celestia honestly thought Discord was dangerous she wouldn't have invited him. Also I still believe Celestia is training Twilight to be her replacement, her power is running out since she had to raise the sun and moon herself which shortened her life expectancy that's why she doesn't fight that much. I believe she could have a powerful attack called Rage Of The Sun but I never seen her use it.


I'm sure you were joking about Star Trek but it actually sorta makes sense after hearing about Granny Smith's dream in The Big Mac Question. Anyone else think that's interesting?


DUDE did you notice how similar aria from the dazzlings,and Starlight glimmer look like?You NEED to do a video oh that!!! (Ok you don't have to but you really should)

Actually,adagio DOES have a cutie mark,if you get the singing adagio dazzle doll,it shows her cutie mark on her face.or you can just look up pictures of the doll.

It would still be nice if he made a video addressing this. I, for one, like listening to his theories and opinions.

@*****  well they are not exact cutie marks but they do have, on adagio is on her belt, on aria her hair and sonata in her shirt

@Adam taleb  even if you can turn to siren to pony its impossible, the time travel spell is in the starswirls section of the library in canterlot so i don't think she could get it. another thing is that starlight wants equality, why would aria want equality, and the sirens FEED of negative energy so even if she changes to look like a pony she still needs it to eat.,

No. Please no. Why do people even consider equestria girls part of this series? It really isn't. They're not ponies, they're badly designed humans whom are purely for toy sales. Not to say mlp isn't purely for that purpose though. But come on...

Your right she doesn't go back to equestria but I have more info,so it is possible to turn a Pony into another creature but I guess they do have different cutie marks,but I also realized another thing,rainbow rocks takes place BEFORE the cutie map part 2 did,unless when starlight went through the cave and teleported back In Time,and there actually IS a spell for time travel,so this still stands a possible theory.

@Adam taleb i'm pretty sure thats... IMPOSIBLE. C'mon she's a siren and always be, even if she goes back to equestria she will still be. also she can't change from siren to pony at will because her magic doesn't work that way, another thing is that, if you look at starlight's cutie mark its diferent form aria's, ( prove: welcome to the show, check on her boots, they also have cutiemarks and CM don't change between dimensions. and she has no reason at all to go back to equestria after all, she needs adagio and sonata. <br>thats my opinion and thats why i dont like to think starlight its aria blaze...

@Adam taleb i'm pretty sure thats... IMPOSIBLE. C'mon she's a siren and always be, even if she goes back to equestria she will still be. also she can't change from siren to pony at will because her magic doesn't work that way, another thing is that, if you look at starlight's cutie mark its diferent form aria's, ( prove: welcome to the show, check on her boots, they also have cutiemarks and CM don't change between dimensions. and she has no reason at all to go back to equestria after all, she needs adagio and sonata.
thats my opinion and thats why i dont like to think starlight its aria blaze...

So then here is what probably happened, starlight glimmer  Was a Siren and then transformed into a pony and then when she went through the cave in Cute map part 2 she transformed back Into a siren and went through the portal and became a human.its just a theory.


I think what tree hugger meant was the snooze was over stimulated. I get overstimulated pretty easily, so if I was a giant blob, I’d do the same thing


No, the smooze probably isn't from another dimension since Twilight seemed to recognize it. In My Little Pony: The Movie, only flutter ponies could stop the smooze. The smooze has clearly evolved since then (I think it's the same universe), but that part hasn't changed and that's why alicorn magic is useless. Of course, alicorns didn't exist yet when those witches tried to destroy Ponyland with the smooze, but alicorns came into existence when the six princess ponies transferred the magic from the Heart of Ponyland into themselves in order to defeat the draconequi, and obviously the Heart of Ponyland didn't have the magic needed to stop the smooze. The magic in the Heart of Ponyland was what made the world work. Unfortunately the princesses didn't realize that before they removed it. That's why ponies have to raise and lower the sun and the moon, control the weather, make the plants grow, and take care of the animals.


Didn't the witches in the original movie summon the Smooze from elsewhere?

So what if Discord just got it from the same place the Witches did, and then used his powers to keep it from being the more crazy-destructive power it was in that movie so that he could try to get fluttershy to like him rather than destroy everything?


What if they undid the "Limited Power" spell since they now trust him. Because if he used the smooze he could take over ponyville, he is more powerful now I guess.


PRAISE LORD SMOOZE

Friendship is Witchcraft references for the win!

ShadeTheNarwhal I love going on ponytown role playing as Sweetiebot!!!

Shade The Pony Fan of Wisdom 🙄😒😶😐😑 really? :/

+<i>GHosT_GAmeR</i> No, all KILL Lord Smooze!

+_GHosT_GAmeR_ No, all KILL Lord Smooze!

Yey I thought the same thing " ALL HALE LOURD SMOOZE!!!!!!!"

@Shade<br>im already on episode 11......i know what happens - so funny

@Shade
im already on episode 11......i know what happens - so funny

Guys Discord has been confirmed for next FiW episode: "You Smooze, You Lose". Hype.

Praise smooz that brony doesn't try hippy meditation again

@Shade no, she doesnt like pokemon, she just acts like Pikachu because she repeats her name like a Pokemon. Plus did you know RD (FiW version) is blind? And Scootaloo is her daughter?

Rainbow Dash likes Pokémon in FiW? I haven't seen her liking it in an episode. Is it in Horse Woman?

@ポニ子Poniko<br>Sweetie Bot: "Hmm Insufficient beauty"

@ポニ子Poniko
Sweetie Bot: "Hmm Insufficient beauty"

Omg I really like Twilight coz she wants to rule da world! Also RD coz shes like  pokemon! LOL

I love FiW. :)<br>Sweetie Bot is my favourite character.

I love FiW. :)
Sweetie Bot is my favourite character.

YES PWEEZ! I would LOVE to! I wanna see what his voice will sound liek XD 😂😂😂

@Shade #PRAISELORDSMOOZE

Bill Cipher is love......

Hey guys who wants to see Discord in a Friendship is Witchcraft episode? The amount of amazingness.

Lord Smooze is love, Lord Smooze is life.

Someone needs to make that with Gmod please if you do then you deserve an award of pure awesomeness.

So that's where they got it from, well played witchie, well played

@deadly destructive gaming X400 lol no, just, no... on so many levels, no.


Would the Elements of Harmony effect Smooze? I mean Discord did get turn into stone by it, would it turn Smooze into stone or something different?


Since Discord lives between worlds, does this mean that he wouldn't change form traveling between worlds?


The type of magic between the two Worlds (If there are two Worlds) is compatible. Otherwise the smooze wouldn´t grow when it eats magical stuff.


I think that dimension was created by Starswirl to contain Discord but unfortunately it wasn’t strong enough to hold him <br>I also think that Oooz was something Discord made to show he has other friends

I think that dimension was created by Starswirl to contain Discord but unfortunately it wasn’t strong enough to hold him
I also think that Oooz was something Discord made to show he has other friends


Omg he used a World of Goo reference, I'm so happy. I love that game more than any sane person would.


wait so if Discord could live in between every dimension, even other shows could that mean he lives with Giratina & Hoopa, as they both live in dimensions parallel to Ash's


Wait... if discord’s home is in-between dimensions, how did the Mailpony get there?


Actually, that was normal unicorn magic. Apparently, alicorn magic is that dark, evil looking stuff Twilight used for that potion she drank that told her about the tree of harmony.