another amazing pmv to put a smile on my face this is why im apart of this fandom all the amazing people and amazing art/works i can see and appreciate keep up the good work man to some of us like myself it brings out a smile
Personal opinion? Well if you insist...ahem...THAT WAS THE MOST AMAZING PMV EVAARRRRR!!!!! THE LYRICS ARE AMAZINGLY DONE, THE EDITING IS AWESOME, AND ALL AROUND IT LOOKS AMAZING!!! WOOOO!!! WOOOOOO!!!! passes out from light-headedness
Awesome epic atmosphere, good music and video... Just perfect... I think, you are one of the best PMV channel on the youtube next to the names like a TheAcleps, izeer1337, LittleshyFiM and others...
That typography and embers effect already makes this better than most other lyrical versions of the song. Though it is a good edit. Maybe a bit more pony points, Burny-Twi, Philomena, Something more pony that just dash using an African-colored flag as warpaint.
ken rick I can turn off e-mail notifications for comments, yes. I do not want to do that though, as I like to be able to know of all of my new comments, and be able to read them as soon as I can. Furthermore, I really request you two not use my comments section as a chatbox. I don't want to see dozens of comments in my monthly report just from you two, as it will provide me with false statistics for the month. :p
Dante K ken rick Hey guys. I hope I do not come off as too demanding or offensive, but I just wanted to make a request? I get e-mail notifications every time I get a new comment, and I've gotten quite a few just from you two. If you could perhaps move it to somewhere else, or cut down on the replies, it would be highly appreciated. Thanks!
I'm very torn with this PMV. On one side you did awesome work, but on the other side, i can enjoy only 50% of it. I noticed the trend in your PMV's to just put in flashing lyrics, which isn't really "PMV". i don't wanna say that your work is crap, which it is definitely not, just trying to give feedback what i dislike about your PMV's. I'd rather have a 50% shorter PMV than these flashing lyrics parts in between.
ZX Hey ZX, you're totally right! There's the communication gap between us humans, so it's between you and God what you do, with hopefully a chance of getting across - whether in an intellectual way, emotional way or both - to the viewers.
"I just don't want subscribers that don't appreciate my content solely because it's not mediocre. " I didn't subscribe to you because i expected mediocre content. You explained pretty well in your previous comment how one can make a highly qualitative PMV, which also mostly contains pony. You also proved in your past PMV's that you can do exactly that.
Also, we mostly agree in what makes a good PMV, you just went closer into detail. When i wrote to select scenes fitting to the lyrics, that also includes scenes that one makes fit the lyrics by re-purposing its meaning. Also, you wrote something about using more than stock footage, i wrote about animating something yourself. So as you can see, we basically agree about what makes a good pmv and you've proven that you can make exceedingly good pmv's. I didn't come here for mediocre content, i came here for exactly these kinds of PMV's.
I just wanted to give you the feedback from my side that i don't like the lyrics showcase(for the reasons i explained).
D0mmac Showcasing the lyrics in the video is not a step up, or a step down. It's a step to the side, as it allows me to expand and broaden my horizons. If all of my videos were done in the style of my original PMVs, I would never get anywhere, and I would never develop my own creative style. By experimenting with lyric-based videos, it allows me ,as a content creator, to expand my skillset outside of just picking scenes from the show. That takes relatively little effort, and is, in my opinion, one of the easiest ways to produce a PMV. I do not wish to forever create PMVs, and I envision myself, down the road, working on original content. I would never be able to achieve such a feat by limiting myself to such restrictive content.
In my opinion, the things that make a good PMV editor is someone who can re-purpose a scene from the show, to bring out an entirely new meaning. You can see this reflected in "Rebirth" as well as "Lose Yourself" and "Say Something" in regard to solely new content. A good PMV editor is also someone who created a Pony Music Video with more than stock footage. This is something I have done before, and have even done in this video. Lip-Sync is only appropriate if the context of the scene fits the lyrics being spoken. You wouldn't want a smiling Pinkie Pie talking about losing someone, or anything of the like. Which is hard to avoid, and is a common mistake for most editors.
Whether or not you've grown tired of PMVs comprised of clips from the show is your own matter, and not mine. However, I have grown tired of using scenes from the show to construct my videos, as with 91 episodes, there's only so much that can fit tracks that I do / want to PMV. It can become exhausting using the same material, and I've all but run out of new scenes to use appropriately.
If further content of this design means you'll no longer find what you're looking for here, then I suggest you look elsewhere. Content in the form you're describing is a dime-a-dozen and I can immediately direct you to a dozen other channels that produce content of that form. Whether or not you stay a subscriber is your choice. I just don't want subscribers that don't appreciate my content solely because it's not mediocre.
First, i want to clarify that my following points are not meant as an insult but rather a personal opinion: I don't see where the creative work of a video editor is supposed to be in slapping lyrics on the screen and adding flashy effects. To me this just looks like video editor run out of ideas.
I understand that you want to do more than just adding scenes from the show, but showcasing the lyrics is, in my opinion, a step down, not a step up. This isn't even a music video, it's music with lyrics.
In my opinion the things that make a good pmv editor is finding scenes fitting the lyrics or even making own animations. Also, if the situation feels like a charekter should be saying the lyrics, lip-sync shouldn't be neglected.
And if i'm tired of scenes from the show, i shouldn't be watching PMV's ;) (i, for one, could never grow tired of the twi/tirek fight scene).
But like i said, these are my opinions, if you want to follow another path, this just means that i won't find what i'm looking for on this channel anymore. i will still keep the subscription, since you said that not every one of your videos will be that way.
And again, i want to apologise if anything offended you, i didn't mean it like that.
I thank you for your honesty and your opinion. PMVs, for me, have been evolving past simply using scenes from the show put to music. Most scenes have been used too many times, and people are growing tired of them. (Twilight Vs Tirek, for example.) Additionally, with these past two (three? four?) videos, I've been trying to make them more.. Music Videos, than just Pony videos. Represent the song better, and appear as if it's something that the original artists would put out alongside their track . I apologize if this is a style you aren't comfortable with, and I can assure you not every one of my videos will be in this way. I just hope you can see through it that this is a step for me in evolution as a video editor. I had a ton of fun editing this video, and it;s unfortunate that you can't enjoy more than just the scenes from the show.
I never took them to be war-like. Before you say, "Well they have the royal guards," let me stop and tell you that they aren't really built for war-fare. They're armor is gold, which, while flashy, is about as useful in combat as aluminum foil. They seem more like the type to act as security, like a police officer.
I'd just like to point out that what type of metal it is means nothin in a world that has magic, because it could be enchanted. Additionally, it could just be gold-plated. I'd say the real indicator that they're meant as more of some sort of police force is that their armor covers none of the vital areas, like the throat or the heart. Then again, the armor could be enchanted so as to shield the entire body, but in terms of show canon, let's assume not.
very nice PMV. Nice Typography but often, especially in the Parts where Clips from the Show are shown, it's very hard to read the Text cause its White on White oder yellow.
***** Yes most defiantly will do looking to re-vamp it in April when i get my new computer built so i can do completely original content and pmv's :D again thanks so much!
theheftygamer I took a look at your channel, and I saw a lot of hype! I like how you structured your videos on top of a base constructed of fan-made content, as well as re-interpreting the Grand Theft Auto V intro! It was neat! There was just more hype than there was delivery! Haha! Maybe.. you should consider having a new design for your channel, to go along with your return..? ^_~ Just let me know!
theheftygamer Hey hey.. I actually made custom thumbnails for my videos, and just did a recent update to all of them with help from a friend of mine. So it's actually a good sign. :)
I like your videos, but it seems like there is very little Pony footage to be a PMVs. They are more like Lyric videos with a little pony thrown in them. Still good, though.
Darn...THIS HAD SO MUCH FREAKING POTENTIAL!!!!!! Too. Many. LYRICS KID! This could be the best freaking PMV ever if you added more scenes from the show. In all honesty, this isn't even a PMV XD Its more of a lyrics video.
This song made me deaf cause its so loud.
35 likesWorth it.
Rise from the ashes like a Phoenix. Those words burn deep in my heart since I became a Brony.
3 likesWow, you managed to build a really great atmosphere for the video, which worked really well with the music! :3
13 likesanother amazing pmv to put a smile on my face this is why im apart of this fandom all the amazing people and amazing art/works i can see and appreciate keep up the good work man to some of us like myself it brings out a smile
1 likeAnother masterpiece!! :D Love this... and the song! Long live Fall Out Boy!
1 likeAmazing work! I don't know why I haven't found you before, but you definetly have some great works. You've earned a sub. :D
4 likesThis PMV is AWEEESSSSOME!!!!
1 likeThis should have WAY more likes!
So much epicness! This PMV pulsates with it. I feel like my PC monitor is going to blow up unable to contain it on the screen!
6 likesReplies (1)
Gray Fur coming from you that is saying something
0 likesPersonal opinion? Well if you insist...ahem...THAT WAS THE MOST AMAZING PMV EVAARRRRR!!!!! THE LYRICS ARE AMAZINGLY DONE, THE EDITING IS AWESOME, AND ALL AROUND IT LOOKS AMAZING!!! WOOOO!!! WOOOOOO!!!! passes out from light-headedness
1 likeI wonder if this video is going to break 100,000 views.
32 likesReplies (8)
it made it
0 likesI wonder if this video will break 200,000 views...
2 likesYes.
1 likeYou did it good job man love ya vids
0 likesnowdied YEAH !!!
0 likes+rainbowdashzx It did XD
0 likes+rainbowdashzx Almost
0 likes***** Well, there is a chance to.
0 likesman this song is so cool! Fall Out Boy is one of my favorite music artists! But this right here makes me wanna cry. ;')
1 likeI have to say, I'm no fan of Fall Out Boy, but what the hell, this song is actually good. Plus, a great PMV to go along with it! Good job.
1 likeHoly shit. This PMV is awesome.
3 likesAlways loved the song but this made it 500 tines better.
1 likeI am a phoenix, and I approve this Song/ Music video.
1 likeThis deserves more views and likes
2 likesI don't know what could be better than this
0 likesThis is definitely your best pmv.
1 likekeep up the good work
Well played Wyatt ,well played
2 likesDAYUM! This is epic! I love it!
1 likeYOU HAVE AN AMZINH TASTE IN MUSIC FIRST TEENAGERS THEN THIS!!! AMAZING!!
1 likehigh five m8 ur awesome keep this talent up you have a talent that's really awsome
2 likesTHAT WAS AN AWESOME SONG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(please note the extensive amount of exclamation marks used to hammer my point home.)
2 likesI am blown away by coolness
1 like"You are a brick"
11 likes-Fall Out Boy
Replies (1)
The Funtime Reaper lol
0 likesi can't tell how much i love this!!!
1 likeI like this!
4 likesomg this is awsome
2 likesholy shit this is awesome
3 likesAwesome epic atmosphere, good music and video... Just perfect... I think, you are one of the best PMV channel on the youtube next to the names like a TheAcleps, izeer1337, LittleshyFiM and others...
1 likeReplies (2)
Oh... I didn't know it... So you are already the elite... I'm not surprised :D
0 likesYou're doing a awesome job.
Funny you should say that! I know them on a first-name basis, and have worked alongside them before.
0 likesPMV - It's Time (A PMVToday Collaboration)
this is......SO BUCKING AWESOME!!!!
1 likeNo tengo palabras para expresar mi opinión de este vídeo tan chingón que acabo de ver, ni en inglés ni español
Replies (2)
I'm not swearing. Don't mames xD
0 likesMauricio Jimenez CANADIANS BE LIKE:stop swearing its not nice.......
0 likesvery good i got to say well done didn't expect rock in mlp to look good but its epic well done good sir :3
1 likevery amazing video love it so much :D
6 likesWith only Sony Vegas, holy shit this is awesome! :DD
1 likeomg is sooooo Epic at the First <3
2 likesThis is SO AWESOME!!
1 likewow thats awesome very good and men i love the song ! :D
1 likethat was cool
2 likesThat was amazing
1 likeFall out boys rock can you do more of there songs
2 likesLIKE!! THIS IS AMASONG :O
1 likeMY BRAIN! TOO MUCH AWSEOMENESS!
0 likesThat typography and embers effect already makes this better than most other lyrical versions of the song. Though it is a good edit. Maybe a bit more pony points, Burny-Twi, Philomena, Something more pony that just dash using an African-colored flag as warpaint.
1 likeReplies (2)
I am sorry. :(
0 likesPlease refer to the description. :)
1 likeThis is amazin-blarghhhhhhhhhh-AH, WHY IS THE AWESOME MURDERING ME?
9 likesReplies (11)
***** Ok :(
0 likesken rick I can turn off e-mail notifications for comments, yes. I do not want to do that though, as I like to be able to know of all of my new comments, and be able to read them as soon as I can. Furthermore, I really request you two not use my comments section as a chatbox. I don't want to see dozens of comments in my monthly report just from you two, as it will provide me with false statistics for the month. :p
0 likes***** Whoops! sorry! Can't you turn it off though?
0 likes***** :( cries in a corner while singing "warriors"
0 likesDante K ken rick Hey guys. I hope I do not come off as too demanding or offensive, but I just wanted to make a request? I get e-mail notifications every time I get a new comment, and I've gotten quite a few just from you two. If you could perhaps move it to somewhere else, or cut down on the replies, it would be highly appreciated. Thanks!
0 likesken rick Neither can I
0 likesOne problem though... I CAN'T STOP LISTENING TO THIS!!!
0 likesken rick I don't know!
0 likesA mystery we will never know
0 likesken rick how do we keep finding eachother?
0 likes...Such awesome...
0 likesLove this song :D
1 likei love this the origenal video is creepy but i like what you did with my little pony :)
1 likeNice, very nice indeed.
1 likeStill great in 2016! :D
1 likei love this song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1 likewhat do you use to make these and put it together? ive been wanting to make my own :) this is absolutely awesome btw
3 likesReplies (3)
+rainbowdashzx my only problem with the video is that I can't easily read the lyrics,overall 9.5/10
0 likesthx!! :D
0 likesLucky Icecube I use Vegas Pro 12, though I am now adapting to the Adobe CC Suite! I've made two PMVs with it so far.
1 likelove it so much
1 likeThat was a sick (in a good way) typography portion(s); Very holliwood :2
1 likeME ENCANTOOOO😍😍😍😍😍
1 likeThis came out on my 10th birthday xD
2 likesSo very cool!! good going... /)
1 likenew best pmv
0 likeswhen i first heard this i was suprised it was fall out boy
2 likesReplies (1)
I know its confusing aloutgh thaeyve made alot like this now
0 likesFall out boy and ponies...
1 likeBEST COMBO EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BROHOOF /)
I had a feeling it was going to be this song
3 likesI'm very torn with this PMV. On one side you did awesome work, but on the other side, i can enjoy only 50% of it.
12 likesI noticed the trend in your PMV's to just put in flashing lyrics, which isn't really "PMV". i don't wanna say that your work is crap, which it is definitely not, just trying to give feedback what i dislike about your PMV's. I'd rather have a 50% shorter PMV than these flashing lyrics parts in between.
Replies (5)
ZX Hey ZX, you're totally right! There's the communication gap between us humans, so it's between you and God what you do, with hopefully a chance of getting across - whether in an intellectual way, emotional way or both - to the viewers.
0 likes"I just don't want subscribers that don't appreciate my content solely because it's not mediocre. "
0 likesI didn't subscribe to you because i expected mediocre content. You explained pretty well in your previous comment how one can make a highly qualitative PMV, which also mostly contains pony. You also proved in your past PMV's that you can do exactly that.
Also, we mostly agree in what makes a good PMV, you just went closer into detail. When i wrote to select scenes fitting to the lyrics, that also includes scenes that one makes fit the lyrics by re-purposing its meaning. Also, you wrote something about using more than stock footage, i wrote about animating something yourself.
So as you can see, we basically agree about what makes a good pmv and you've proven that you can make exceedingly good pmv's.
I didn't come here for mediocre content, i came here for exactly these kinds of PMV's.
I just wanted to give you the feedback from my side that i don't like the lyrics showcase(for the reasons i explained).
D0mmac Showcasing the lyrics in the video is not a step up, or a step down. It's a step to the side, as it allows me to expand and broaden my horizons. If all of my videos were done in the style of my original PMVs, I would never get anywhere, and I would never develop my own creative style. By experimenting with lyric-based videos, it allows me ,as a content creator, to expand my skillset outside of just picking scenes from the show. That takes relatively little effort, and is, in my opinion, one of the easiest ways to produce a PMV. I do not wish to forever create PMVs, and I envision myself, down the road, working on original content. I would never be able to achieve such a feat by limiting myself to such restrictive content.
0 likesIn my opinion, the things that make a good PMV editor is someone who can re-purpose a scene from the show, to bring out an entirely new meaning. You can see this reflected in "Rebirth" as well as "Lose Yourself" and "Say Something" in regard to solely new content. A good PMV editor is also someone who created a Pony Music Video with more than stock footage. This is something I have done before, and have even done in this video. Lip-Sync is only appropriate if the context of the scene fits the lyrics being spoken. You wouldn't want a smiling Pinkie Pie talking about losing someone, or anything of the like. Which is hard to avoid, and is a common mistake for most editors.
Whether or not you've grown tired of PMVs comprised of clips from the show is your own matter, and not mine. However, I have grown tired of using scenes from the show to construct my videos, as with 91 episodes, there's only so much that can fit tracks that I do / want to PMV. It can become exhausting using the same material, and I've all but run out of new scenes to use appropriately.
If further content of this design means you'll no longer find what you're looking for here, then I suggest you look elsewhere. Content in the form you're describing is a dime-a-dozen and I can immediately direct you to a dozen other channels that produce content of that form. Whether or not you stay a subscriber is your choice. I just don't want subscribers that don't appreciate my content solely because it's not mediocre.
First, i want to clarify that my following points are not meant as an insult but rather a personal opinion:
0 likesI don't see where the creative work of a video editor is supposed to be in slapping lyrics on the screen and adding flashy effects. To me this just looks like video editor run out of ideas.
I understand that you want to do more than just adding scenes from the show, but showcasing the lyrics is, in my opinion, a step down, not a step up. This isn't even a music video, it's music with lyrics.
In my opinion the things that make a good pmv editor is finding scenes fitting the lyrics or even making own animations. Also, if the situation feels like a charekter should be saying the lyrics, lip-sync shouldn't be neglected.
And if i'm tired of scenes from the show, i shouldn't be watching PMV's ;)
(i, for one, could never grow tired of the twi/tirek fight scene).
But like i said, these are my opinions, if you want to follow another path, this just means that i won't find what i'm looking for on this channel anymore. i will still keep the subscription, since you said that not every one of your videos will be that way.
And again, i want to apologise if anything offended you, i didn't mean it like that.
I thank you for your honesty and your opinion. PMVs, for me, have been evolving past simply using scenes from the show put to music. Most scenes have been used too many times, and people are growing tired of them. (Twilight Vs Tirek, for example.) Additionally, with these past two (three? four?) videos, I've been trying to make them more.. Music Videos, than just Pony videos. Represent the song better, and appear as if it's something that the original artists would put out alongside their track . I apologize if this is a style you aren't comfortable with, and I can assure you not every one of my videos will be in this way. I just hope you can see through it that this is a step for me in evolution as a video editor. I had a ton of fun editing this video, and it;s unfortunate that you can't enjoy more than just the scenes from the show.
0 likesI've heard that intro sound before in a video game. Crash of the Titans
1 likethis fire is so impressive, I love the whole video! please tell me what programme you used! this is like so awesome <3
1 likeReplies (3)
NellyTV
0 likesI think it's just a green screen footage and then put it on SV
What? How did you made this amazing fire?! o.O Just with SV?!
0 likesI use Sony Vegas Pro 12. :)
0 likesMy head exploded from too much awesome
1 likeThis is the theme song to my oc, Jake McAwesome
2 likesHOLY SH*T MAN THATS SONY IS EPIK-
0 likes---------!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!My OC is a Phoenix so this is kinda my theme song
2 likesReplies (1)
shes inspiration im still working on it
0 likesyou deserve i think much more subs :) and views
1 likeI have no idea what ur guys r so mad about I thought it was awesome!!! Amazing Job!!! 🐺 😂
0 likesI never took them to be war-like. Before you say, "Well they have the royal guards," let me stop and tell you that they aren't really built for war-fare. They're armor is gold, which, while flashy, is about as useful in combat as aluminum foil. They seem more like the type to act as security, like a police officer.
1 likeReplies (1)
I'd just like to point out that what type of metal it is means nothin in a world that has magic, because it could be enchanted. Additionally, it could just be gold-plated. I'd say the real indicator that they're meant as more of some sort of police force is that their armor covers none of the vital areas, like the throat or the heart. Then again, the armor could be enchanted so as to shield the entire body, but in terms of show canon, let's assume not.
0 likesvery nice PMV. Nice Typography but often, especially in the Parts where Clips from the Show are shown, it's very hard to read the Text cause its White on White oder yellow.
1 likedang good song
0 likesholly shit this fucking amazing
1 like1:44 Make a career out of Robin Banks? He's a Radio Dj and Tv presenter, so Yeah those are good careers.
2 likesHi! Can you help me? Who know the name of this background? Thank you!
0 likesis this a re-upload? or did youtube nuke your other channel :P Great vid love to see it again btw :D
0 likesReplies (5)
*****
0 likesYes most defiantly will do looking to re-vamp it in April when i get my new computer built so i can do completely original content and pmv's :D again thanks so much!
theheftygamer I took a look at your channel, and I saw a lot of hype! I like how you structured your videos on top of a base constructed of fan-made content, as well as re-interpreting the Grand Theft Auto V intro! It was neat! There was just more hype than there was delivery! Haha! Maybe.. you should consider having a new design for your channel, to go along with your return..? ^_~ Just let me know!
1 liketheheftygamer Hey hey.. I actually made custom thumbnails for my videos, and just did a recent update to all of them with help from a friend of mine. So it's actually a good sign. :)
1 likei just remember seeing this before and the thumbnail was different :P my mistake
0 likesWhat makes you think it's a re-upload?
1 likeHey ZX if you ever read this can you make a PMV for numb/encore by: jay z and linkin park
1 likeGood music
0 likesI have an OC named Phoenix
1 likeThis be her theme song now
where is the epilepsy warning D:
0 likeswho does this song
0 likesi never understand these PMV thingys its like a downgraded version of a animated music video
1 likeI like your videos, but it seems like there is very little Pony footage to be a PMVs. They are more like Lyric videos with a little pony thrown in them. Still good, though.
1 likeThe Doctor Doctor whooves
1 liketime for a war... Earth... versus the Dark Time Knight... me
Replies (2)
time to unleash choas on Earth
0 likesShining Light will be on my side as well
0 likesFall out boy
0 likesThis is too coo 5 me
0 likesyour the beat pmv maker
0 likesStill had to sing
0 likes💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
0 likesThe editing is great the song is great pretty much ever thing i said is like 20%cooler
1 like0:52-0:57 When you declare war on catholic nation just to convert them to protestant
1 likeEuropa Universalis 4 players will know.
cool😃😃😃😃
0 likesWORNING LOUD
0 likesYou messed up the lyrics
0 likesReplies (2)
+rainbowdashzx Heart-Attacked. the song says Heart-Attack
0 likesWhere? :o
0 likes5,610 subscriber
1 likeI hate to be this person, but you misspelled attack in heart-attack. Sorry!
0 likesPie the best
0 likes*attack
0 likesMLP X FOB I'm happy again
0 likesOk rainbow who does rainbow dash like in the show lol I'm using my dad's about and a boy lol
0 likeswhy mmmbop
0 likesI CAN'T WATCH IT RAGES
0 likesFUF
0 likesPMV was good, fall out boy, in general, SUCKS. (that includes the song used in this vid)
0 likesReplies (2)
+Fluttershy Fan In my opinion, not a single piece of music sucks. People are just picky about what they like.
0 likesEveryone is entitled to their own opinion i guess...
1 likeThanks for ruining this song for me -.-
0 likesReplies (1)
You're welcome.
2 likesDarn...THIS HAD SO MUCH FREAKING POTENTIAL!!!!!! Too. Many. LYRICS KID! This could be the best freaking PMV ever if you added more scenes from the show. In all honesty, this isn't even a PMV XD Its more of a lyrics video.
1 like