As someone very concerned with the specifics and phrasing of lore details, I appreciate the distinction between immortality and eternal youth. Also that twist at the end was a nice touch.
There's even a Greek myth about that exact thing! Eos and Tithonus. The goddess of dawn had Zeus turn Tithonus immortal but forgot to ask for him to have eternal youth.
Anouther thing to kinda disprove the whole apple gives immortality thing is Luna, because she was stuck on the moon for a thousand years and yet hasnt seemed to age a day since she was banished, granted you could say whatever dark magic transformed her also gave her immortality, but we have also seen multiple other creatures who are seemingly immortal who also could not have been eating any apples. Tyrek, Discord (though he is kinda a bad example), Sombra, just to name a few. Sure you can give your own reasons for why these guys are seemingly immortail (Discord is Discord), but that alone shows that apples are not nessesarly the way for immortaility. Just my view tho (:
Luna did age maybe her ageing stop on the moon but when she came back she started ageing again she went from being short,light blue colour to taller and Dark blue with flowy mane
Luna was possessed and it was dark magic that made her age in the first place. When she was purified she was returned to the same age as she was when possessed
@Akira He has only lived that long because the majority of that time was spent in limbo along with the other pillars, who havent seemed to age a day, even him since he was kinda already old looking before that.
@jw777 no he said “even a pony like me who has lived a thousand years would think he has nothing to learn but it appears I still have something to learn,friendship” he’s saying like he studied for a thousand years before limbo because you can’t do anything in limbo
she was SEALED 'in' the moon for a thousand years,t hat fancy paint job on the surface wasnt just for show,s he wasnt on the moon, she was part of it, stone as much as discord was, unageing.perhaps semi aware, but not truely concious....dispite what the comics sugest.
discord is discord is one of my new favourite things to say. and pickleberyll. Isn't that just the funnest thing to say? pickleberyll pickleberyll pickleberyll. say it with me. pickleberyll qumquatch pickleberyll qumquatch pickleberyll qumquatch chimmi cherry chaka!
well Tirek was from another world maybe one where you are immortal Sombra was turned to shadow discord is discord and all possessed some form of dark magic
Discord have a kind of god's powers with his chaos magic. he could just be an actually god or his species has just a very long life span. meanwhile, Sombra losts his physical form when celestia and luna defeated him. but not his life/soul apparently. so maybe Sombra is just a kind of shadow pony (with a different biology) or is just a very skilled wizard that invented a spell to preserve his soul after death ? (in the crystals for example ?) i dunno, these two can be excluded from the theory, to me. but yeah, Luna's existence knocks down the apple theory xD
Neither Tirek nor Sombra are percieved immortal. Especially not Sombra, who technically isn't any older than an average pony (the 1000 year banishment of the Crystal Empire doesn't count).
@Akira he was stuck in limbo, in many mythologies and string theory infinite multiverse theory, limbo is an extra-dimensional void in between dimensions and thus out of the realms of time(and space, but we're focusing on the temporal(Time) aspect here.) thus time will have seemed to have stopped from the perspective of the person viewing the world inside limbo, or move extremely fast as if someone had hit fast forward, idk 😶 I've never been in limbo, a coma is the closest to limbo anyone has ever gotten, and those who can astral project, but let's be practical here, no one wants to be in a coma, and not everyone can astral project.
@Sawtooth Waves that's true, we do know that Princess Celestia used the element of harmony to banish Luna to the moon, but we don't know the nature of the seal or how the spell was cast in the first place, certain magical seals, not all, has what I call a half-life which is the amount of time it takes the seal or spell to degrade or wear off, or requires certain conditions to be met to be released without the caster releasing it on his or her own, like with the theory that Princess Celestia released nightmare moon, however we DO know that Luna was up there for a thousand years, what we DON'T know is what spell was cast with the elements of harmony and how it was cast, figure that out and we will have solved the mystery of Luna's banishment, of course magic is unpredictable, I mean if twilight can accidentally turn her parents into plants during her test right when the rainboom happened, than magic is truly limitless in power, the only limit is your imagination.
Theres this theory where the faster you move the slower time is Years ago scientists putted a clock in a plane flying at high speed around the world while also keeping track of another clock on earth When they retrieved the clock in the plane they saw that the clock was behind So my guess is with the earth and moon rotating en spinning and stuff it causes Luna to age more slower. Remember Rosalina from Super Mario Galaxy? She started as a ordinary girl before taking care of the Lumas but is now alive for at least a few thousand years. And what is she doing all that time? FLYING AROUND THE COSMOS WITH A COMET AT ABNORMAL HIGH SPEED
Or maybe it just work with alicorn magic. If the apples are magical, they would effect the different types of ponies differently. Like if an alicorn eats it, they gain immortality or eternal youth, because Equestria needs them alive to protect the citizents. But if a non alicorn would eat it, it just wouldn't work, or it could make them sick.
@Edits and arts yes maybe when luna was banished to the moon she didn't age at all when nightmare moon was destroyed we see luna the way before transforming into nightmare moon
I don't know enough about mythology to be sure, but I remember the golden apples having some sort of extremely specific instructions for growing them. Maybe normal golden apples have immortality, but the care of those trees to actually induce the proper effects have been lost to time or something. Or, as an alternative, Celestia's golden apples are a failed experiment - I remember the Chronicles of Narnia had apples (not golden) that cured any disease and brought back youth. But when planted in a world not suited to them, they were just merely very tasty apples that were extremely healthy for you. (That tree later provided wood for the famous Wardrobe in the first book of the series.)
Perhaps Starswirl/Celestia/Luna found a golden apple tree of immortality in an alternate universe, got excited (how excited would you be as an immortal to finally be able to have friends that would no longer wither around you?) and tried to plant it in Equestria, but the magic was the wrong kind, or the soil didn't have the exact right nutrients. So Celestia now just has an extremely exotic apple tree, even though her plan to give other ponies immortality failed.
I would like this idea more, if the tree was merely from a far away land (such as the land of the alicorns mentioned in the Journal of the Two Sisters (Which I still believe is cannon). In that book it explains how alicorns age differently, but maybe a golden apple tree restores health? In Scripture, in the book of Revelation, the leaves of the Tree of Life are used for healing (not the exact same thing, but it suggests the same idea). This same tree mentioned in Scripture also has 12 different fruits (12 being a significant number) which would suggest it's a grafted tree (which also has a significant meaning) but I think the fruit was meant to offer eternal life.
Hey Sawtooth, I've been watching you since I was a child and I just wanted to say that I'm really glad you're continuing making content and how the quality of them is increasing z keep up the great work!!
My inner Greek mythology nerd would like to propose an alternate theory: those golden apples DO offer immortality. To alicorns. In the Percy Jackson series, nectar and ambrosia will kill demi-gods if they eat too much of it, and presumably the same for mortals - or would just kill mortals. Nectar and Ambrosia share a lot of parallels with golden apples, with some people believing their is overlap in the role of golden apples and the role of nectar/ambrosia in mythology. What if the golden apples in MLP were poisonous for normal ponies, but if an alicorn eats it, it grants immortality?
Goodness, this channel is still going on with more G4 theories, I'm quite surprised knowing G4 came to an end (not sure tho) cause of the new movies, yet this channel kept on coming up with more and more G4 content. This channel btw is possibly the first channel I ever got interested on hearing about MLP lore and theories. It's just the way you explain stuff is impressive! All so clear and straight to the Why's and How's. With that, a sub is given, it's not much but I hope to see your channel grow to a million subs!
Random note: I guess I joined the ranks of the Brony Army now. It's an honor LOL
I love how you notice little things in the show and are able to give reasonable explanations. ^^ It's kinda weird that of all things the apple is associated with great power/immortality in different mythologies. Are apples that good? Why not strawberries or tropical fruits? Apples are wide spread, even without humans, so it isn't a special fruit.
@Butterfly Monarch Studios The forbidden fruit isn't an apple though, I don't know when that myth started, but I think apples have been used to portray other meanings as well, such as lust and desire. In Scripture the Tree of Life is portrayed as yielding eternal life giving fruit, and the leaves are said to be used to healing. The tree of knowledge doesn't give life, it only takes life.
If the apples are wish granting apples, but grow slowly, perhaps they were used to combat the tragedies - just indirectly. A wish like "I wish we had someone to take care of Equestria once I'm gone" could have been used to tie the mane 6 together (Note how when modifying the timeline, they tend to end up in key positions, even without the Rain Boom). An earlier wish to grow old with her sister could also be what kept Celestia Young while her sister was away - you can't grow old with someone who isn't there.
I do like the idea of the apples only working on alicorns. It wouldn't rule out any of the other possibilities and why Twilight couldn't have shared with the others the youthful looks, though there's no prove they didn't indulge until they just wanted to let their bodies age naturally with the world around them. I'd joke that Rarity might hold on the longest to her youth and those apples but at the same time, that just doesn't seem like her. She's wearing the gray in her mane loud and proud in the last episode while the others don't have any gray while undoubtably older looking. Sure she may just be graying before the rest of them, what's a little premature gray hair between friends when we don't have a solid idea of who the oldest of the mane six is and it could very well be Rarity, but the gray isn't a short little bit, it's an entire chuck that had a lot of time to grow out to be as long as the rest of her mane. Rarity may have been the first to cut the golden apples out of her diet if she had any at all. At least that's how I see it in terms of eternal youth sources. Correct me if the comics or some other episode confirms she wants it or is younger than another mane six like how we know Fluttershy is at least a year older than Pinkie.
In the Journal of the Two Sisters they refer to the fact their aging was different solely due to being alicorns. This was before they even moved to Canterlot, while they were young living in Castle of the Two Sisters. Know your having fun, but this one was stated in accepted media.
Those golden apples only two alicorns maybe Twilight friends didn't know that they having golden Apple maybe alicorns keep them a secret so that nobody can eat the golden apples
Those apples are alicorns but white alicorns keep those eloquent from other ponies like pegaside unicorns Earth ponies only alicorns eat them only if Granny Smith is so old and she doesn't eat those golden Apple so maybe celestia is eating the golden apples and Twilight are eating the golden apples to be big if alicorns are just eating those apples and and luna's getting big but she's like so small youngest one so if Twilight is big maybe Luna we just like celestia and celestia getting old and old and still eating the golden apples.
@Joginder Maheru spike said something about a group golden fruit trees with golden fruits hanging from them. Some fruit sounds good and healthy. But what if spike meant indirectly?
I’ve been wondering if Twilight is aging fast for an alicorn or in other words normal for a pony. Consider this, she’s as tall as Celestia after roughly 25-30 years of ruling but Luna and Cadance who were already older than/about 30 were always smaller than Celestia.
My guess for the height thing is, genetics. It's possible that while there all alicorn, they still have different heights. The MANE thing( sry had to say it😂😂😂) is that they're all taller than average ponies and I think that's what helps classify them as alicorns!😁😁😁
@Butterfly Monarch Studios lol Yes! You absolutely had to do the mane thing! I would agree, and it could be a possibility except every other alicorn we’ve seen, the bigger they are the older they are, implying age is a factor for size. …could also be the writers being lazy about alicorns like they always have lol.
I believe that her magic also influenced it. She already had so much magic in her before becoming an alicorn (element of magic) and becoming an alicorn made gave her a larger horn and made her taller. I think that after receiving the magic of two other alicorns and keeping it for such a long time* is what caused her to grow that large after her years of ruling Equestria officially.
*She’s gotten all of the alicorn magic before in that Tirek episode, but she only held onto it for so long. In the final episode, it’s shown to have been YEARS.
Or maybe more times than 25-30 years has passed. We don't know after all how long ponies lives and at which rate they age. Thought i remember someone mentioning a lifespan of 200-300 years for averages ponies. Point is, a century could have passed and you wouldn't know it.
It might be where, the golden apples do grant immortality, but only alicorns can receive the effects, like in Greek mythology where mortals can't eat the ambrosia, or drink the nectar, but that is what gives the gods, or in our case, the alicorns their immortality. This way, all of the princesses may want to share the apples, but they can't. Great video, by the way.
The thought process is near flawless. Though, I cannot point out any. Love the video! I also like the little beginning and end bits! You do so well! Have a good day! (To everyone)
Hm...I do have a theory but it might be a bit farfetched. What if the Golden apples actually help a pony actually deal with the power of being an alicorn? Like, yes, we saw how Twilight became an Alicorn and she seemed to handle it pretty well...at first. So what if those golden apples help ponies whom have become Alicorns deal with their new powers. Think about it! Imagine having three different kinds of magic inside of you at once. That might put a lot of strain on your body physically. So maybe the apples work as a stabilizer of some kind!
maybe alicorns can only get to the size of luna and cadence without apples, which is why celestia, and later, twilight, are so big. however, luna has also lived for a similar time to celestia so idk
i don't know i think that would have been the subject of an episode or a comic, and tia would have come with one when twi got her wigs, and do not think that the kind of item you want to teleport to you if it stabilise alicorn magic inside the body could have the oposite reaction when spells are cast on it
@HearMeOut17 I think you're misinterpreting the definition of a stabilizer. Flurry Heart had a spell put on her that's common enough to have a name and is likely designed for Unicorn foals in general to control their magic. And don't get on my case about Flurry being an Alicorn and not a Unicorn, because that's just a semantic argument. The point of the spell is to control the magic of a foal who is capable of using magic at will.
A spell like that would not be common knowledge if it was for stabilizing an alicorn's magic, because alicorns aren't common enough.
@Tabii Canim the reason luna is smaller is because when she was in the moon it stunted her growth. when she is first released she is much smaller and younger looking because thats how she was when she got “eviled” you later notice that she gets slightly taller and her mane gets longer. i think alcorns are like humans, the older you get the taller you are. which is why celesta is so much taller than the average pony and taller than luna because she is older and luna had her growth stunted. same thing with cadence and twilight. according to the diary of the two sisters it claims that alcorns age slower than the average pony which would make sense why cadence has only grown a little bit since when we saw her as a teenager foal sitting twilight. it also explains why in the final episode we see in the stain glass that flurry heart has grown up but is only as tall as a adult pony and not a adult alcorn. we also see that twilights hair gets “flowy” in the last episode so that probably also has to due with age/growth who knows maybe its a puberty thing 🤷
I'm really glad you brought this up, and I think it's a good theory. I personally believe that alicorns don't live forever, and instead just age differently. Luna and Celestia have lived for a really long time, beyond many life spans, and have gotten really tall as they aged. You can see that the older an alicorn is, the taller they are. Like how celestia is really tall, luna is shorter as her little sister but still taller than average, and cadence is a little bit taller than average. Not sure about how twilight was, but the important thing is that their height depends on age, yet within, not even a full life span, twilight sparkle grew to be the same size as celestia. I think celestia and luna used some way, such as a golden apple, to stay alive because the world needed them, but all the other princesses aged like an alicorn.
I believe that her magic influenced it. She already had so much magic in her before becoming an alicorn (element of magic) and becoming an alicorn made gave her a larger horn and made her taller. I think that after receiving the magic of two other alicorns and keeping it for such a long time* is what caused her to grow that large.
*She’s gotten all of the alicorn magic before in that Tirek episode, but she only held onto it for so long. In the final episode, it’s shown to have been YEARS.
@Éfar Isti Oh yah, I guess it was kinda confirmed now. I mean, that evil alicorn person has lived for a pretty long time, so yup, pretty much. tbf I wrote this comment 7 months ago, but you are right, g5 does debunk the theory that I had.
If the golden apples grant eternal youth, then why is Nightmare Moon still young? The more likely candidate for eternal life is dark magic. We know that Celestia, Twilight, and Sombra can all use dark magic, and it is conceivable that other 'eternal' characters are also capable.
Even I missed this minor detail. I have seen golden apples used in multiple media from Minecraft to “Class of the Titans” series. I even learned more about their mythology in your video, wow!
In Minecraft, Gold apples gave you Temporary extra health, strong regeneration, and some other buffs I think I might have forgotten in game ( & the god apples required even more gold like whole blocks but I think where removed from the game, unfortunately )…
In “Class of the Titans” the tree itself made god-like friends & Allie’s immortal by just existing , but the villain figured as long as he had a few of its fruits himself, he could destroy the tree & wipe out immortal competition, but his wicked plan was foiled by the tree being regrown from a left over gold-apple core, saving every one from doom.
Hearing that the Alicorn-princess had a “gold apple tree” makes me wonder just what purposes or attributing things they exactly provided??? Only wishes like in the comic? Healing? Youth or immortality?… or a rare medicine, cure, or extravagant power boost & etc?!?!? … or more lower just an extravagant ingredient?
You would think if it hade rare medical or healing powers 🏥, why not use it to cure “swamp fever” instead of that rare honey in that one episodes?… & did or didn’t the the “Pillar of Healing” or any of “The six pillars eventually mention this in later episodes once they came back? Did even StarSwirl use them before to live a 1,000 years before the 1,000 years being trapped in limbo?
This is like a flood gate of questions I now wished they did an episode on!
Second to only wondering how Equestria got turned upside down a few generations later in G5 and all its questions! (Like what happened when a earth ponies(or etc.) had a unicorn or pegasus as a child… in G5? Did they need to run & live in an underground village for the life of their children & family?!?!?)
After all this theorizing, I'd find it funny if it were just a statue of an apple tree made out of gold to commemorate the contributions of farmers to the general wellbeing of Equestria.
The Golden apples could also bring up knowledge to the future or the past too. I find it a little odd how Celestia knew about nightmare moon being defeated. Maybe it told her what would happen in the future or something. She just seems calm sometimes when disaster strikes
Idea (⚠️SPOILER ⚠️): The Golden Apples grant the flowy mane thing. We’ve only seen alicorns with these manes. This could explain why Luna had non-flowy hair after Nightmare Moon’s defeat. Luna had no access to these apples thus no flowy hair until she had some later on and got it back. Candace and Twilight lived too far to be able to regularly access these until she gets one later on when she becomes ruler and lives in Canterlot. Also maybe it only works for alicorns, thus only alicorns has these manes.
2 likes
A Perry2022-04-10 03:08:55 (edited 2022-04-10 03:11:01 )
Based off of the thumbnail I thought you were going to bring up dark magic. Since Sambra was alive as long as Celestia (who clearly used it) and Twilight who seemed to live a similar long life (who also had used it at least once). Like if you think about it, we never see old Caidence or Flurry Heart so maybe they aged like everypony else. And with how easily it corrupts and manipulates the usser it makes sense why that magic isn't shared/taught. I also want to add that being corrupt tends to be assorted with a form of "dark magic" in the show. Giving more reasons to why Luna and possibly other villains also could live as long as they have.
Hi, Sawtooth! I'm a new subscriber who's been binging your video library for a few days.
What if the apples are something entirely mundane? Like, the tree and its fruit are actually just some gold sculpture the extremely wealthy princesshood commissioned as a centerpiece for her garden? What if it's not a real plant at all?
Maybe twilight wouldn't... She came a long way because of friendship but she's always been the more scientific,practical pony so after she became imortal she knew her friends wouldn't be with her forever....so she grew to except that...or maybe because the rest of the mane 5 are not alicorns and dont contain amplified magic from all 3 tribes they age but only physically?
I just had a big exam and I was rewatching a bunch of your theory videos to chill out afterwards like I usually do when I need a study break and then see a brand new one is released… bless I needed this today 🥺💖🙏✨
Well, based on the first theory, maybe you need Alicorn magic to access the apples. You need to have all three magic types combined to access them, and eat them. If a normal pony eats one, maybe it would speed up the aging process tremendously, instead of showing it down to immortality.
Can we appreciate how much hard work they put into their videos for us and they never fails us to entertain us and they always makes our day or night even better keep it up with the awesome work!
What I am curious about is how magic seams to affect different creatures differently…what I mean is Tirek went from looking old and weak to a Goliath when he stole magic…Discord just stayed himself unless he stopped being chaotic in which case he fades away…and when the princesses gave their magic to Twi the sisters simply lost their wavy mains they all lost their cutie marks and Twi gained a colorful trail and speed boost when she tried flying and couldn’t control her teleporting
Thanks for sharing your ideas with us, Sawtooth! The golden apple theories were interesting to listen to. Also, this is my first time hearing about the wish-granting golden apples in comic canon. Those might have been cool to see in the show. ^_^ The topic of alicorn immortality theories reminded me of how longevity has been handled in some other works of fiction. In the film The Life & Adventures of Santa Claus, Nicholas is granted immortality by a group of immortals after a lifetime of good deeds. Someone could have done something similar for the royal sisters since they were the best at raising the sun and moon. Also, in an episode of Elliott from Earth, there's an alien who wears a special pendant to slow his aging down due to his species aging very quickly. Maybe the sisters' crowns or necklaces have some age-delaying powers. Just some ideas.
If we were to go with the "Apples grant immortality" idea, maybe the reason no other pony is seen using them is because no pony other than Alicorns are powerful enough to handle them. I mean when you think about it, an apple that grants the eater eternal life would have to be full of an extreme amount of magic to work, and single ponies no matter how powerful, would be unable to store that much raw magical energy in their body. Alicorns however, since they possess the combined magics of all three races, they can store and even control that energy. The reason why the princesses never give the apples to dieing ponies is not one of more or less greed, but because of the often postulated idea that too much magic- exerted or otherwise- is not in any way good for bodies that weren't made to handle it.
Maybe you are right, and it could be that Starswirl planted the golden apple tree like the tree of harmony though it might be that only very powerful or worthy ponies can use them like alicorns.
Unfortunately to say, Twilight didn't keep her immortality, one of the G5 comics showed that Canterlot is in ruins, and Discord's horn is found by Sunny.
Wow! Great vid! Your theories are so great & very interesting & you put so much effort into making these videos for us to be entertained by! Thanks Sawtooth for all your hard work!
idea for a vid: in lesson zero Twilight used the "want it need it" spell, after use she says "works every time" indicating she used it before but, why? also the way the hearts come out of her horn reminds me of princess cadence... did cadence teach it to her? and if so, why!?
I really love theory videos, the reason being that people somehow give absolutely stupid and frankly wrong ideas, some sense of based foundation which is insane
Keeping youth/imortality granting appels from the general population could hardly be considered evil. There would never be enough for everpony, and knowledge of the apples would just lead to conflict over them until the tree was destroyed. Remember, in myth, planting a golden apple does not give you another golden applebearing tree. It is also possible for Twillight to use the apples without knowing what the do, as she inherited the staff from Celestia & Luna. That way she might get the apples as part of her standard meals.
I think this one is true about dark magic and now why because she show us about dark magic in SS2(Zombra) she show dark magic to twilight that’s mean she use dark magic to make her life longer(maybe) but I don’t know about big body it about magic or golden apple but Nightmare moon it look like a same size of Celestial That’s very confused but I think it because of magic if that apple make longer life I think why no one stole? And why guard didn’t stole that apple and make his life more than 1000+ years I always think Celestial use magic to make life longer like ancient one:)
When I read the journal of the two sisters one of them said (I think it was Celestia) that starswirl said that raising the sun and moon will give Celestia and Luna more power and rejuvenate them so they wouldn't age. So I think now that they stopped raising/lowering the sun and moon themselves they'll start to age grow old and eventually die. Now that Twilight is doing it she'll stay young and live forever, that is until g5
Now that you showed me how many mythology references there are in the MLP, I'm sad they missed the chance to put something form Slavic mythology. Though it is incredibly horrifying. For example, there is something called "psoglav", creature with head of the dog with iron teeth, human torso and legs of horse/goat, has one or three eyes. They dig up graves to eat corpses, but also hunt for human meat.
I think that because an alicorn has SO MUCH magic energy in them that it extends their life span as as they get older it takes up more of their energy to keep them alive. We've seen the older alicorns struggle with using their magical powers to their full extent explaining why celestia andluna dont directly fight back and when they do its not very well. Cadence while being younger weve seen start struggling with this when the gang go to the crystal empire as shes fighting off sombra. Ignoring their own experience with using magic because that obviously varies between the bunch this is a decent explination. Perhaps the golden apples cut down on this magic for life span cost they make to live longer (probably against their will because alicorn biology). Like lets say to live longer as an alicorn it takes up 10% of your overall magic capacity, over time this will take up 50% making the usage of more taxing magic harder to pull off, now lets say that golden apples reduce this cost by a certain amount. This explains how alicorns can live a really long time but still end up dying of old age in the end as there arent any alicorns anymore in gen5 because while you can make it last longer you will eventually reach the 100% threshold and die as an alicorn.
This is a really god theory! My question that I haven’t seen an answer for is what happened to the human counterparts of the pony’s? Very curious what has been happening over there
Sawtooth has been trying to understand flurry heart for a while and I have a theory on that. What if Flurry is the next princess of love and destined to take over after cadence she was born an Alicorn because her role as a princess was pre determined. There arn't going to be infinite new magics to earn wings with and older alicorns are either immortal or are going to die eventually thus needing heirs for the same spot in the alicorn pantheon he proposed in last video on why flurry has wings.
Ok, so lets say if the golden apples were able to grant eternal youth for Celestia and Luna but would need to be eaten every number of years to keep the youth. Then if that be the case, wouldn't Luna be older and or look older than Celestia from Luna's time on the moon for a 1000 years? Including Discord and other mystical magical creatures that have lived for a really long time and youthful and have had no access to the golden apples.
What if Celestia herself doesn't realize after all it's not so farfetched to think Star Swirl harnessed the power of the golden apple tree to make alicorns immortal. After all Star Swirl probably wouldn't care for sharing immortality with others, and he almost certainly forgot later on.
I always love these videos. Please, please keep making them! It makes me enjoy watching MLP much more when people notice the tiny details and analyze them to make theories.
Assuming the Golden apples give you immortality, even if twilight offered them to her friends, knowing them they'd probably not accept it. Having to live on as protectors of equestria (as mentioned in season 9) along with twilight would definitely not be their ideal roles, as that's twilight's job now as the sole ruler. Besides they wouldn't want to watch their friends and or family pass on, especially Apple jack or Pinkie pie. If that's the case twilight wouldn't present them with this option either because as an alicorn she never had that choice, and must know the hardships that come with it.
I have some interesting theorys that might interest you but they involve the comics and the books, so it's a lot more outlandish
Also a ramble about the video, I think it probably is wish granting apples but they only use it for emergencys they know they cannot control, like a fail safe, but like when they would physically be able to get to the apples, explaining why they didn't use it in the crystal empire, against the changelings and during the movie
I thought you were gonna say that Alicorns being able to use dark magic like King Sombra's makes them immortal. King Sombra was immortal so maybe it was something about his magic and then Twilight and Celestia being able to replicate it somehow made them immortal.
Or what about the flower that made the cutie mark crusaders grown ups? I think it belonged to starswerl or something so maybe Celestia used it to increase her life pr something. Example: In both ocations the flower could have done something to do with age, right?
I think the golden apples in celestia garden are wish apples and are able to grant wish while also keep the pony’s young until they decide not to use them.and I think the reason why alicorns are immortal is because they have magic beyond the normal magic that unicorns have that’s why alicorns are immortal because they can keep themselves alive.
If the golden apples are an anti-ageing spell, it'd mean cadence wouldn't be immortal like everyone else since she doesn't have her own. I mean she could plant her own tree I guess but all the vegetation we see are all crystal plants, I'm not sure she could grow it there.
I think Celestia is wise enough to know that wish granting can have unpredicatable consequences and it's better not to use it unless last ressort. But she's not wise enough to put a security system around it apparently. Speculations. But why wouldn't apples that grant eternal youth be useful to old ponies? If your body stay young, it doesn't age so you do become effectively immortal.
Hey sawtooth, I'm river I'm a human (you know what that is right) anyway I found a portal to the equestrian world I've been observing your videos since I was a Philly or a child it is so inspiring to me that you came out as non-binary (side note I love that you're non-binary and that you're OC is a changeling:) ) your video quality has only improved and watching you work so hard to keep this fandom thriving is amazing to me thank you for what you do.
Well, one thing to notice is that the kirin represents the Japanese people while the ponies like Mist Mane with a different horn represents the Chinese people.
I agree they could give enturnal youth but only to alicorns cause of the exstended life span if given to a mortal pony they'd have very dire effects on them due to the limited life span. But thats just me.
There is a book that is called “the journal of the two sisters” a real life book that you can buy off eBay, and this book holds a lot of answers, the book says that Luna learned how to move the stars, and the legend was the the stars would Aiden her escape, check out the book and see for yourself 🤗
WOW just WOW! You’ve made such a good point! Can i just say I love how much work you put into these videos!? You always do such a good job and always make me question things I never thought about before! Also, Happy National Unicorn Day!
I would just assume, the golden apple tree would be a highly classified magic reserved only for alicorn rulers. For the same reason the highest of classified information in the government is not talked about publically. Don't want to cause panic (the the most assumed reason).
On the other hand, maybe they are just a special rare breed of apple tree.
hey! one of your really really old viewers, returning after YEARS to ask to make a video about Starlight possibly becoming a Princess? Like the princess or Destiny or the princess of Time? I remember when you used to be "The Brony Nation" & I was so invested in all your lovely theories and I finally came up with another one I thought you may like to look through -- considering the ones you've made on Starlight in the past. Even though we know that Starlight currently teaches @ Twilight's school, its not impossible that she could be a ruler at some point.
also, if those apples did grant immortality, maybe celestia keeps them from the citizens bc it is known that people fear death, but that immortality leads to one outliving their loved one's and that after a while, life becomes dull. so maybe she did it for their own good idk
We also gotta count the golden apples from minecraft, when eaten, they give the player protection, regeneration and absorption, but the enchanted golden apples grants the player regeneration, protection, absorption but also fire resistance, that make the player harder to almost impossible to kill while the apple is still in effect.
I'd like to take a moment that when the writers and showrunners of the series were asked if the Princesses were immortal they were told that they weren't. So this 'the princesses are immortal' is disproven by the people who made the show - and thus the Princesses have an indefinite lifespan, a lifespan so long that it is unknown how long they actually live. Now, how those lives are extended and what not is up in the air, but the immortal thing really needs to stop.
As usual those are some interesting theories Sawtooth, and i agree with what you said it could be possible that the golden apples do make Celestia young just not in the way we would think because like you said the apples probably only make Celestia look young physically but she's actually really old and when she starts showing signs of wrinkles she has to keep eating the golden apples to maintain her youthful appearance.
Well like Sawtooth said in the video it is possible to be eternally old. So yes it is a possibility that Celestia's golden apples do make her appear young physically when she's actually old and if that were so then that would mean Celestia would have to eat the apples constantly because just like the water from the fountain of youth, the effects of the golden apples eventually ware off.
@-Elliott- average dragon enjoyer And it didn't cross your mind even once that some of us might've already known that this dude didn't pick up on it before you noticed that he didn't?
@-Elliott- average dragon enjoyer What i'm getting at is that even if this dude stated what was said in the video, that doesn't mean you have to tell him that.
@-Elliott- average dragon enjoyer Well as you can see he edited his comment and fixed his error, which means he probably figured it out for himself by actually finishing the video i mean there's still such a thing as finding this out for yourself you know.
It has been confirmed through multiple episodes that ponies do have longer lives. In the season 1 episode winter wrap up Twilight cold Spike that ponyville was founded by Earth ponies silver hundreds of years they have never used magic to clean up winter. In the episode simple ways it was stated at the beginning that Granny Smith was on the committee because she was one of the original founders of ponyville. Not to mention I cannot remember the name of the episode but there was a flashback where granny Smith's family stopped in canterlot and princess Celestia pointed them toward what would become future ponyville. Also in the episode where the other ponies discover pinky secret party planning cave Applejack did find Pinky's plans for her parents 50th wedding anniversary 100th wedding anniversary and 500th wedding anniversary. At the same time in hearts and hooves day you see the cutie Mark crusaders interrupting a funeral. So we do have confirmation about long lives for ponies. Don't know so much about the other races but evidently centaurs also have a very long lifespan. But where the normal ponies do age I did find it odd that the alicorns who have been confirmed to be alive or more than 1100 years seem to be quite Young and beautiful. I also thought for the longest time that the flowing hair was only reserved for the alicorns until we were introduced to cadence and that one unicorn who was a part of the original six. Maybe being an alicorn does slow the aging process. But it is not confirmed that alicorns live forever. They just might live twice as long or longer than the normal ponies. We know that Celestia had been raising the Sun for about 1111 years and for at least a thousand years also raising the Moon. Beyond that we do not know what their actual ages are.
Even though I do agree that this theory is very well made and everything the others say, I am gonna say this right now: Am I the only one worried about Sawtooth's safety?! Like, at the begining I was so confused about what happened to them and at the end it seemed as if they were captured by someone! Why is no one worried about them?! Who even took them?!(if I accidentally used he/him pronouns, sorry!😥)
as someone who thinks anything is possible in a world of magic,my thoughts are i think there is a spell only allicorns can use to make one have eternal youth of course there would be the golden apple farm but i think those are just very flavorful royal fruits :)
Sawtooths point that immortal is differnet than internal youth is true in the greek myth of Tihonus who was the lover of the goddes Eos and a amazing guy because Eos begged Zeus to grant him immortality so they could be together forever but forgot to ask for internal youth. Tihonus become immortal but continued to age, after a few hunderd years his size became a grape growing smaller forever.Maybe this is how alicorns die?
Another thing that tends to complicate theories is that evidence suggests that Cadance was succeeded by Flurry Heart by the time of Luster Dawn, which implies that Cadance isn't immortal.
Its nice to see your still going! I have been watching you since 3rd grade and now im starting highschool- helped me feel not ashamed of liking mlp in middle school
A thing to note is that I would not share knowledge of apples that make you immortal, esp. in a world with people like Sombra Crysalis and others, as there are many people who really don't need to be immortal. Also, I don't think just not sharing these is evil, especially as we have no knowledge of how many grow at any given point. I can see your point of view, and why you'd think that it would be wrong not to share, I just think that there's too little information to make any form of harsh judgement against Celestia.
I like this idea but then again we saw that king sombre was technically immortal using crystals and tirek I think that comes down to him being a different species that can consume magic so maybe he can passively intake magic in small amounts from like breathing etc and chrysalis can a also be argued to be immortal since she consumes love and that itself could lead to temporary immortality and with Luna we saw her age just like cadence but the difference being that Luna manes flow so I think an alicorns “immortality” could be connected to their cutiemarks like celestia is connected to the sun Luna the moon Cadence the crystal heart and love and twilight connected to the stars and friendship aka platonic love and this brings into question mistmane who sacrificed her beauty but maybe she gained something more in return you know
Your kinda on point with that Greek mythology but Hera didn’t have a golden apple tree the golden apple was created by the Goddess of Chaos Eris for not being invited to a party thrown by Zeus she threw the apple up and the apple was used to say which goddess is the most beautiful.Three goddesses fought over the apple causing the Trojan war to happen.There is more about the story go and read it if you want to I didn’t cover all the points
We could also take the magic from equestria flowing into the human counter part. We already know objects there have gotten magic like the mirror and phone so maybe something similar could appear there to.
Maybe the fruit is specific to the magic of alicorns, and are too dangerous for just any pony to use, I think it would also extend to other animals, like dragons because twilight is only like 5 or 6 years older than spike yet he doesn't seem to have aged too much. I don't know, but that's my theroy.
Funny how the pony who has been alive over a thousand moons sort of happens to be a pony that is a royal and rules over all equestria who lives in a castle with a pet Phoenix and- Yeah, of course she has golden apples. What does Celestia not own that is part of mythology, excluding creatures? Well, we don't know... Who knows what random thing is just sitting in a basement...
In my defunct Horror-Hero Fanfic universe, that i still hope to do one day... Alicorns are are portrayed as a big more Powerful then in Canon, but at a price... a very harsh price.
In my stories, Twilight's Ascension happened as her in Canon, but the scene on "Da Otha Side" went differently... cuz her ascension was not planned, the version we got was just a story Twilight told her friends.
An Alicorns Power, Youth, and Longevity comes from them being somewhat Vampyric... they absorb life-force passively from everything around them, within their "Area of Influence"... Celestia, as the sole Ruler of Equestria, could Sustain herself by taking a Month off of everypony's Life expectancy in Equestria... how much life is passively absorbed depends on how much power the Alicorn is willing to Absorb as well, Celestia, having to manage the entire Kingdom AND the Sun and Moon(with the Moon resisting...), she became the tall, imposing figure she is in the modern Era as a necessity to fulfill he myriad duties...
Then Cadance showed up and unexpectedly became a Alicorn herself in a desperate moment via the power of Love, which fueled her Ascension... after Celestia found and explained the cost to her, Cadance opted to remain at a Minimum level of power, which is why she is much weaker then the others... and smaller.
She only lessened Life-expectancy by a few hours to a few days due to this.... then that burden was eventually moved to the already-long-lived Crystal Ponies following the Return of the Crystal Empire.
Which was great, because when Luna returned she cut Life Expectancy by another week at first... then by closer to three weeks when she achieved her starry-haired form.
Twilight's ascension was a little better planned, and the Ethereal Plane chat was prepared for in advance... But despite this, Looking into Twilight's eyes, she sort of.."Forgot" to mention the cost, she did not want to break her heart... which lead to a period of Twilight being constantly hungry, and eating a ton of Hayburgers(as seen in that one CMC episode.. Twily Time i wanna say? Not sure, been ages), and other Pony fast foods, never really getting any satiety... and wasting away...
Celestia had hope'd that Twilight would passively feed off the Exceptionally Potent life-force of her friends(at Twilight's current state... PInkie Pie could of theoretically sustained her with maybe seconds off her life, a more vibrant Life Force Celestia has never seen before) without her having to be Aware of it yet... but her nature pretty much cept her from siphoning PERIOD.
when Celestia finally Told her, Twilight was.. a little angry, but ultimately took the cost as a Challenge to overcome... it's also why she barely grew any in height, even compared to Cadance, during the show... she was basically on a starvation diet.
The plot proper would of started a little while after her Ascension, a few months, and coming to terms with her Curse/Blessing... shit starts going wrong in Equestria.... Luna, for all the good she's done since she returned, had always feared the creatures she created during the Nightmare War, that raged before her banishment, would return eventually with her up and about... sadly she was right...
One by one Tragedies befall the main cast... they all pull through in various ways, tho many of them aren't quite what they were before hand....
The only Fic i got finished was the "Iron Man" for this Fic Universe... a story about Zecora and a cursed she has bore for most of her life... she was basically a Ghoul, and never ate any sapient flesh, using potions and a Rhyme-based Meditation practice to abstain from Cannibalism completely.... She was going to be the first Monster-Pony recruited by Twilight into a "Night Watch" group to hunt monsters with those marked BY monsters.
Only ones that stayed the same were Fluttershy(whom has been managing her Flutterbat condition in secret for two years at this point), and Rainbow Dash, whoms the designated Badass Normal.
...No one is gonna read this, but i may just go Write the next fic now, so thanks for digging up a old idea i had since like season 3, Sawtooth!
Just a thought i had while watching this. What if the golden apples only grant you eternal youth or immortality if u are an alicorn/have magic from all three tribes. If u are only one you might get an extra year or two if u eat them but immortality or eternal youth is only for alicorns.
Hi Sawtooth, i have a theory i' d like to share with you. Remember the princess of love who used a love potion to get a man? I think it was Crysalis sometime long ago. And she turned evil because of love.
The golden apples might hold the key to eternal youth but you might have to be an alicorn to be able for the apples eternal youth powers to effective on you. Just like nectar and ambrosia would only work for the Greek Gods the golden apples could only work on a pony's body that was in complete harmony aka a pony who body had elements of all three tribes aka an alicorn.
This reminds me of another immortal known as the "Kitsune Fox" (yes I'm a kitsune Fox) they are known to live past 1,000 years old as well as staying young with out any special food or water and the only way they can die is being stabbed in the Heart or by sacrificing themselves to save another
What do Celestia's golden apples do? Another tie to her solar charge, no doubt - 'the Golden Apples of the Sun'. Luna most likely has 'Silver Apples of the Moon' as well.
Hey hey, Here me out in G5. Twilight's friends died and this caused ponies of 3 species begin to fight, she tried to bring them back together but they wouldn't listen. She set up something in Heartswarming that included the 2 sisters and the 2 crystal empire princesses but it all went wrong and just made the situation worse. The windigos formed and since there is no known solution to this but friendship(she couldnt make bring them back together) she casted a spell that took her friends' hearts(not literally) including hers that took a the form of their element, Twilight combined the elements to the 3 crystals that we all know now. With the help of the other princesses' magic she managed to trap the windigos forever along with herself, the 2 sisters, Cadence, and Flurry.
Twilight combined Aj and Pinkie to be the earth crystal, RD and Fluttershy to be the pegasus crystal, and Her and rarity to be the unicorn crystal despite her being an alicorn. Thats why the 3 crystals can be apart.
Yeah, but since we have a theory that alicornship is something Starswirl the Bearded had invented to unite ponykind plus have someone to raise the Sun themselves, wouldn't that prove the existence of a "magical genetic engeneering" study there or something? You know, to make golden apples correspond to only alicorn DNA.
Maybe the golden apples could just be apples made of gold and she sells them to have money for all the costly repairs to the castle every time someone invaded and destroyed it in an epic battle.
I think its a bit close minded to say that Celestia is "evil" for not sharing golden apples of immortality. If everyone was immortal then Equestria would eventually be unlivable because there would be too many pony's. There wouldn't be enough food available either. Just because you have something doesn't mean you HAVE to share it. Certain things are better only in the hands of a select few. Sure it would piss us all off they had it for themselves, but depending on who had it, it would be for the best. I also don't think Twi would share it with her pals. Especially if Celestia told her not to. She is a HUGE rule follower, she would follow it even to the detriment to others. I like the idea of there being an golden apple and all but personally I think alicorns just have a much longer life span. A sort of by product. Or because the writers say so lol
You know how you said in the shinning armor video that twilights friends won’t be able to live as long as her well that had me thinking about the crystals maybe twilight made them to bring her friends. But they’re different types of pony’s so she had to divide them to bring them together.
For countless centuries, I've tried to discover the secret of the Golden Apple's gift of Eternal Youth, and ten thousand years ago I've gotten so close, but I used my last Golden Apple Tree about fifty centuries ago... for the remaining centuries I've been searching for more trees. And now, thanks to you, my little grey pony friend, I now know where to get another! And, because of you, Equestria will be laid siege to, then all Ponykind enslaved!😈😈😈
Immorality doesn't prevent ponies from having foals, you know. If Equesrtia ever became overpopulated with immortal ponies, they would starve and turn in to something else, being unable to die. That is, before something else takes over and uses the ponies in experiments to discover the source of their immorality.
Some people are arguing that star swirl has aged over time just because he looks old or something along those lines, but the magical recording of the whole banishing the pony of shadows shows that Starswirl didn't age between going into limbo and leaving limbo, and in the same episode it is stated by twilight "It (limbo) isn't one place or another, its in-between. So time stands still." And personally, I think when star swirl said "Even a pony like me who has lived a thousand years would think he has nothing to learn, but it appears I do have something to learn, Friendship." I think he was also referencing his time in limbo rather than just generally living that long
Maybe only alicorns are able to digest them! It’s very possible that because of the high amounts of magic that are in them that grant longer lives, they would cause problems for normal ponies. Kinda like how a blood overdose can be painful and even kill people/demons in demon slayer
When Sawtooth Said Celestia had an Extremely Powerful Fruit, Until It was Revealed to Be Golden Apples, I thought He Meant the Forbidden Fruit from The Bible
I don't think it's possible for two reasons. First Cadence: she lives really far away from Canterlot and I can't imagine how often she would have to go back to Canterlot just for a few apples. And now that she have Flurry she would need to go even more often !
The second is why did Twilight age then ? Because in "The last problem" she's definitly older than when she sat on the Equestrian throne. I think keeping the normal pony size would be more intelligent as if she's treathned she could easily hide her alicornhood with a cloth.
5:50 What if celestia did use it Back then when she was younger and naive What if u can make a wish but there’s a price Celestia used one but it made her sister go evil So she had to trap her sister on the moon for 1,000 years?🤔
He’s so quick but so good at explaining like he dosent just be like: hey celestia has golden apples then moves on to the mane 6 in two sec sawtooth you so cool
From my theory we all know that the difference from ponys,unicorns,and Pegasus,and alicorns are alicorns magic so there’s a chance immortality has something to do with alicorn magic
I'm really happy you uploaded! I found you again last night while I was tryna find mlp theories and I binge watched a lotttt of your videos. It was nice to wake up to this video especially because I had a nightmare. Keep up the good work Sawtooth, MLP is a part of my childhood and legit is my comfort show when I'm sad
Hey! I found your channel initially about 6-7 years ago. After i fell out of love for the show, I forgot about this channel. But I’ve recently come back and rewatched the series and found your videos again! You’re still doing amazing, and i’m so glad you’ve stuck around!
"How cruel would it be to have the cure for death but keep it all to yourself." "Even if there was a spell capable of giving immortality [...] it would break the balance. Some would be immortal, others wouldn't. Mortals would begin to envy the immortal. There would be riots. If everyone were immortal, there would be no room for new generations. Equestria would be overcrowded and unable to feed everyone." -- Eveeka, TLA, page 25.
"Golden apples grants wishes to whoever eats them. [..] Surely we would have seen them in use by now." Maybe... through very cleaver wording, it is why no permanent damage is ever done. Elements of harmony? Friendship magic? Nah, just a very carefully worded and timed wish. XD "Everything just always somehow magically worked out for you, Celestia." -- Scootertrix, Episode 26.
As for Eternal Youth, I'm sure Rarity would love a bite. ;)
4 likes
Alana Mariyam2022-04-14 07:39:53 (edited 2022-04-14 07:40:41 )
I love this theory. But have you still completed yeh theory of who the shadow pony was in the castle of the two sisters? I know it's a old episode, but it's still a huge mystery, atleast to me. If you have, could someone give me a link
I absolutely love the theory, it sounds very convincing and is a very cool concept. I was honestly surprised when you had mentioned a hint to aboriginal Australian culture. I'm also black Australian, and not a lot of people know about our existence let alone our culture. As far as I have heard, but for you to point that out I knew you really do your research carefully! Keep up the great work Sawtooth!
Maybe alicorns have to reach a certain age for a specific spell to become immortal or live longer lives than a normal lifespan because luna didn't age at all maybe while she was banished to the moon also a young alicorn like twilight no spell was cast on her as soon as she became an alicorn or really ever so maybe like 20 years later they'll cast the spell and maybe 4 decades for Flurry Heart to give her immortality
I mean, I need to disagree that an item granting youth would be useless to your everydaypony. Let's be frank - being old sucks. It doesn't mattrer whether you live "only" max 80-100 years, downsides of age start hitting you around your 30's or 40's, so it would be great to not have to suffer from it, even if it didn't extend your life per se.
Off topic but I am curious: Has it ever been explained why Starlight Glimmer has not become an alicorn? Did she fail her studies or gave up? Starlight is proven to be a very powerful unicorn, I doubt she would fail. If that is the case, why would she give up? I have not seen all the episodes in sometime, so I might be going for stretches here, but maybe another explanation could tie into another theory.
It is theorised that Luster Dawn is Sunburst's and Trixie's/Starlight's daughter. What if Starlight gave up her studies once she saw Luster's magical potential? Maybe Starlight could still be consumed with guilt over what she did to the village. Maybe she saw Luster as a better candidate for being the next Alicorn Princess?
Celestia and Luna did rule for a thousand years before making new alicorn princesses, at the end of their reign, maybe it is that Twilight planned to do the same?
When he said that Twilight could have share her diet of golden apple but she didn't because immortality is something that you can't share it made me think that maybe only alicorn can eat golden apples without getting sick, maybe the golden apples can be poisonous to normal pony or other creatures because if golden apples have magic maybe it takes all three pony magic to digest
Correct me if I'm wrong, but in Greek mythology only the golden apples could be touched by the Greek gods because if a mortal touched it, they would die, so that could be another possible theory.
Hi sawtooth could you talk about Princess Luna's Mark splotch? I'm going to make an assumption that the splotch isnt a part Luna's cutie mark because the splotch wasn't gone when Luna gave her magic to twilight . We saw that daybreaker now has a new splotch that Celestia didnt have before. is the splotch the cause of turning evil or was it just starlight glimmers imagination?
The thing is though, only Celestia and Luna are immortal or just have extended lifespans, because according to everything else didn't the creators say Twilight aged and died shortly after her friends? She's not immortal by any means, but also seemed to not have had a successor (looking at the new generation) so really, I have no idea what's going on with the royal sisters.
I have a theory that golden apples only work on alicorns, because like you said alicorns are ponies that have magic from all three tribes, so alicorns and normal ponies might have a different biologies. And only alicorns can eat the golden apple because their biologies can sustain golden apples, while normal ponies can't and maybe when they eat golden apples something bad will happen to them(ex. they can die). But that's just my theor. (sorry if the grammar is not correct, english isn't my first language)
Omg I am so happy to be one of the first ones to watch this. Love your pony avatar, backstop and voice and most of all your effort. The effort u put into you clone story, time skip story back story and this intro story. Luv ur work!
This was an awesome theroy to think about but something else is on my mind... What happened to t reck(goodness I can't spell his name correctly)Queen Chyrysalis and of course CozyGlow's Statue? Where is it today in the new generation? 😅This keeps bugging my mind.... but yeah!
I just assumed that Celestia's power came from her ability to be tall enough to ride all of the rides in Los Pegasus! 🤤
4 likes
Fire GalaxyYT2022-05-30 22:24:25 (edited 2022-05-30 22:24:52 )
This would make a lot of sense referenced in multiple mythologies, even possibly Christian mythology though it's never explicitly stated there is a possibility it still exists though it's not the fruit that Adam and Eve ate, Because it wasn't even an Apple that they eat in that only gave them knowledge not long life/yourh
I like how we're talking bout this but not about the fact lunas hair started to move after she was saved from being nightmare moon but celestias hair was already moving before luna became nightmare moon
i think if the golden apples were to gain immortality, twilight would make the decision to remain mortal, something that she would discuss with the other 5.
Cool, but I have another question that might not be related to this. Why does Human Twilight have wings when she ponies up in the HUMAN WORLD, but not the pony world. In other words, shouldn’t she have NO wings in BOTH places because she isn’t REALLY an alicorn? Am I going too deep with this one?!
Wish granting items in fiction tend to have limits depending on where they come from too. I remember in DBZ that the pig character, can't remember his name for the life of me, suggested that they get rid of the sayians before they came to earth but Shenlong said that the task was not possible for him to do for whatever reason
That's true we always assumed long lifespan and different aging had something to do with alicornhood, but that's true that it was never directly said. However I think immortality/long lifespan is not exclusive to alicornhood, if your theory about Starswirl being a thousand years old aside from his time into Limbo is right.
While I'm here, and I'm sorry to talk about it at each video, but I'd really like my theory to be acknowledged... I'd like to talk again about my comment on the video about the forgotten timeline, the original timeline going on without Starlight, Twilight and Spike who traveled in time. I wondered, if the time travelers ended up in a timeline that isn't theirs, tho identical, where are their alter egos from this timeline? And the answer was easy to find, they traveled in time too. That means they too created other timelines (probably the same ones as the original time travelers created, considering this timeline is identical to the original) and ended up in a timeline that isn't theirs but is identical. And in this timeline too, their alter egos traveled in time and ended up in an other timeline, and so on. That means from here, the timeline split turned into a timeloop that creates timesplits. So from here there's an infinity of timelines created, supposedly of each outcome we saw in the series, including the one identical to the original timeline but in which the time travelers were there at the Rainboom. But there still is only one original timeline missing the time travelers... And I'm so eager for this to be known because when I realized that infinite loop of timesplits I thought it was so big and MLP went too far into chaos... And because infinity is something that personally scares me, so thinking about it made me sick.
So I thought of a solution to abort this chaos. I think likely that great minds and sorcerers as Starlight and Twilight (with unfathomably valuable allies as Starswirl, Sunburst and Stygian for example) would come to talk about such a big thing and spot the problem, and organize an expedition through the timelines to do so the time travelers go back to their own timeline after the final travel. Their travel would then apply in a timeloop where the otherwise abandoned timeline was actually never abandoned, and... it actually doesn't solve the infinite loop of splits. But hey, it's a good start! OR ELSE The expedition could do so the last travel actually leads to the original timeline, to create a loop where the travelers were actually always here at the rainboom in the original timeline, and the new timeline that is identical to the original but is a separate one is not created, so there is no other timeline where Starlight, Twilight and Spike traveled in time.
There, time travel mess solved! I really hope you see this very too long comment, Sawtooth Waves. Thanks for reading, and sorry about mistakes, English is not my native language and we talk about seriously complex things here...
i wouldnt say celestia is evil cuz she wont give immortality to everyone...perhaps only alicorns are "strong enough" to consume the Golden apples without negative effects/consequences?
Am I the only one that just never questioned celesta being alive for 1000 years
0 likes
Charles Willis2022-06-11 19:35:13 (edited 2022-06-11 19:36:43 )
The ancient Mythology that i learned is that Unicorns and Pegasus live longer than earth ponies and alicorns live up to 10 times longer than that. That would mean an average life span of 250 years!
@Sawtooth Waves Can someone explain to me why Twillight from the Human-World does have wings when she "Pony-Up" and doesn't have wings when she is in Equestria? Twillight from Equestria and Rainbow Dash from Human-World on the other hand has wings in both worlds.
I once read this book that has this alchemist that made a potion of eternal life, but forgot to drink the one for youth, some funny stuff happened when he finally remembered to drunk the one for youth
okay I need a story about what happened to flurry heart, in mlp new generation she's not mentioned or seen throughout the movie, while twilight has action figures of her and her friends. Flurry was put into stained glass in the last episode of my little pony. but where is she now
What about Luna/Nightmare Moon? She was on the moon for a millennium, and hadn't aged... Unless 'tia sent some to the moon every so often to keep her corrupted sister alive?
So, going back to the alternate timelines, When Starlight stopped the rainboom did the main six ever get their cutiemarks? Because they got their cutiemarks because of the rainboom. So, would they have their cutiemarks? -Snowdrop
Fun fact : opaline quotes this “ They should bow down to there IMMORTAL rulers.” THATS a big hint that your theory is wrong. I mean OPALINE has lived for so long maybe even before twilights time (maybe)
I'm confused why does Celestia have golden apples I mean there a golden apple tree well it a lifetime for Alicorns not Ponies tho but what if the golden apples help the ponies stay young or turn into an alicorns well it strange but it real for some people. I been a long-time viewer and how the quality of your videos improved is honestly inspiring. 🥰
This video gives me ARG vibes. I don't know why, but I certainly enjoy it ^~^ Also enjoyed the references to various mythologies. Maybe you can find a way to do a theory involving the fountain of youth and Tir Nan Og? I wouldn't be surprised if the Hippogriffs/Sea ponies have something similar to that
Hey I have a theory Wait I have a theory: Maybe twilight didn’t know about the golden apples maybe tia put the apple in her food without her knowing that’s why the rest of mane 6 aren’t immortal because tia Knew if twilight would know she would give it to her friends and tia only wanted alicorns to be immortal 🧐🧐🧐
omg omg omg, FINALLY someone other than me noticed that spike said that. I probably noticed it years ago, and I wanted it to be talked about for all that time. Thank you Sawtooth!
I think that alacorns are mortal and twilight just went through a Second puberty and grows into the big form we see in the final episode and there is some evidence that this is the case like the fact that twilight became taller when she became an alacorn and for the people who say "but twilight was an alacorn for years and we never see her grow at all" might I remind you that the cutey mark crusaders grow at all over the years of time that we see them so it is possible that twilight is growing and we just don't see it happening
also, even IF her golden apples could grant long life or wishes, i dont think it would nessisarily be a BAD thing she didnt share them. think about what happens if something as powerful as everlasting life or wish granting was available to just ANYONE. or even if it was just public information. rioting, wars over this kinda power, people getting these powers that dont have good intentions, or at the VERY best, overcrowding or chaos. the world would be a dark place is EVERYONE could live forever or could get wishes simply by getting an apple from celestia. thats why if her fruit COULD do that, i could understand keeping it to just those who had important, over ruling jobs.
New theory what if the mirror pool is in fact a window into other timelines and when pinky used it she wasn't cloning herself but instead grabbing pinkies from other timelines that didn't know her memories because they had different ones.
I was half expecting an army of PJO fans to rise but anyway, this theory isnt the most likely as there are villains and there’s discord. They have lived for like a thousand years but still. Great video!
In the journal of the two sisters celestia and luna when they were just crowned alicorns they didn’t have there cutie marks luna said it’s normal for alicorns because we don’t age or something so celestia and luna got there cutie marks when they were alicorns
Saw tooth what was that little golden apple thing in the security camera thing at the end in the beginning great video by the way but I’ve got questions I hope next week you will provide answers
hey you know the celestia and luna in the human realm how are they alive when the pony world version of them were born around 111 years ago (princes twilight time)
Ok I would like to talk about season 1 episode 11 because spike mistakes twilight for “mommy” We know that he doesn’t have a mom since we saw twilight hatch his EGG… So. You in for a theory?
Technically, why using youth spells in a world where you can't die. In the show there is always a difference being made from creatures, like monsters, and animals -in fact, anything else-. What is carnivores animals eating? We never see them do. Spike eats stones. It seems that, even if it is for gags, all animals have intelligent and human behavior and act as how a kid would see them behave in some situations. Yes it seems great for marketing for children, but in terms of lore, it destroys everything you can build. I say that because, in the episode where Starlight mess with the past and Applejack tell the war with the empire of Sombra, even great big and properly sized armies of ponies, with all the reasons to end each other, just punch themselves with no realism anywhere. Ponies can't die. Anyone considered living not timberwolves can't die. In fact, even them can be undying, they may could respawn anywhere else in the forest if destroyed. Or any things else.
In the Lion King when the hyenas have chased Simba one fall in the spiky plants and jumps out humoristically. We can imagine these types of moments are comedy, and the true story meant behind it is that it hurts really bad, but no one will remember that moment with fear or empathy for the hurt. 5 minutes or such before, and Mufasa died from fell damages, and possibly the repeated strikes of the herd. The difference is made yet it doesn't answer any of its questions. It was made for youth too right? Why sometimes some things hurts but some doesn't? A solution is to imagine the 'real' actual events being worse and bloody as they realistically should be, because everything else is consistent with it, if not why having carnivorous or like dragon's big teeth if it doesn't hurt and make you die, plus if it eat stones why would herbs would be afraid of them in the first place? and what the camera sees is kind of a theatre show. Answering why Pinkie and Discord sometimes looks at the camera btw.
I have difficulties imagining ponies and other creatures, even feel pain. Why? How? In our world pain have been invented by evolution to let us know what is dangerous. Or let us guess, at least. Ponies have no danger. In the Maud's introduction episode when Pinkie Pie is stuck in rocks on the pile at the end of her race -strange for her to be suddenly in danger out of nowhere where she been barely touched by a dragon strike, Rarity says afterwards, "We almost lost her". Lost her to what? Wouldn't she just be a bit high-headed falling down the rocks in cartoon way having stars over her head? An overwhelming number of times the characters fall, are exposed to fire, blasts, or anything that would like, at least, hurt in a long consistent and lasting time. But they aren't. They are never. The big inconsistence stand when Rainbow is immobilized when she broke her wing. Multiple times all other characters would have took damages. But they never did. I think, following that statement, that magic prevent any beings to pain. Or actually, hurt. Or maybe it tries its best to avoid that. And that is also why Fluttershy exists. In the episode when she talks to the dragon, it submits to her. In a world where hurt exists, that makes no sense. It can be explained by the reason that its her magic cutie mark, and can resolve magically any animal situation. But wait. When way after that time, in season 9 I think, when Angel is jealous and annoying a wolf at Fluttershy's shelter, there is a difference between carnivorous and herbivorous. But. How. If no one dies. Where comes the meat? Why the dragon isn't just a mean dragon that have to be undone? All the time the show have a big baddie, it never dies. Chrysalis flied when defeated. Sombra apparently where buried in deep rocks or idk. Why no single one can be done. It could be to give infinite comebacks in terms of marketing. But once again. The characters are living in a world where no one can, at my knowledge and maybe I've missed a few clue, die. How is that possible. And also, how scary that is. Discord, completely magically took energy from 1 dispute of ponies to comeback from stone. The baddies will surely do same. Very strange for Discord to return precisely when the 6 are formed. Like, what he was doing 1 year before. There must be some ponies having disagreements in from of the statue before? He is the lord of chaos. Couldn't he create an entire army or something? Whats with his dimension btw?
The population should go infinite by now. We never heard of decreases. Just, "once upon a time, in the past... Stuff happens". But wait. It means they still exists? Everyone ever existed should be still living in Twilight's future? Is oldness the only possibility to die? Twilight should have her great great great parents aside of her then? How only few licorns like the great bearded guy can make people eternal? What where before the known time, before him, before starswirl the bearded? Before Grogar named himself a thing? Our would answer its existence before us. There been reptiles, dinosaures, big fishy creatures, and rocks and stuff. The problem with the magic of friendship and everything of that is itself. It doesn't works. Windygos are ancient. But where are they from? Are they from the time 'the hurt have been ended'? Are they to counterwise the easy and peaceful life of anyponies since the birth of friendship and the magical 'everything is awesome' era? Like, where does the lake of Pinkie's clones come from? Like. When? I know its medieval yet, but ponies should be able to find stuff from before a couple thousand years ago. A civilization that may have ended hurt? Probably as time resistant as pyramids compared to us.
It's crazy how much time and effort they put into their videos for us to make our day or night even better they are such a hard working person and they deserve the best from us keep it up with the awesome work you're the BEST! 🙂
I’ve got a question or a video idea (or both): How did Princess Luna’s hair change like other pony’s hair to he one that we see every other time with her except the first time we see her (it season 1 episode 2)
Hi! I have a theory and I'm wondering if u could do a vid on it?! When Pinkie and Cozy Glow interacted with Grogar's Bell, they both got insane power and Cozy became an alicorn. Maybe Celestia had a deal with Grogar at one point, or broke a deal? And that preceded the events of Clover the Clever hiding Grogar's bell, with Grogar stealing the bell from Celestia and then Clover stole it and hid it. Like maybe Clover was a friend of Celestia and Luna and was scared of what could happen if it got in the hands of the wrong creature, so she stole it after Grogar got it back to hide it
In my school vr game the character goalius doesn't age ( do to him being the son of both sun and moon princess and a living computer virus named evox) it was showed during the boss fight rush mission called saving lives where the tree was there but the apple had a odd affect where the boss sg blue/goblin/basilisk ( shattered glass) had one and it causes him to spilt Into 3 separate beings
maybe having magic from all 3 tribes gives you 3 lifetimes? Also, weren't the princesses (Celestia and Luna) alicorns before they saved equestria and she raised the sun? So she wouldn't have had access to the tree of golden apples to give her eternal youth.
I have a random question: I noticed that in one of the cutie mark crusaders songs they sang “we have hearts as strong as horses” this shows that horses exist in the mlp world but apple bloom isn’t one. what’s the difference between earth ponies and horses?!
Maybe the golden apples provide slight extra regenerative powers like golden apples from minecraft, or maybe the eternal youth like you said. Idk, just my thoughts
maybe the golden apple has a powerful power that only the alicorns eat it and have eternal youth.Beacuse Twilight would share with others if they could eat it.
or
some pony maked it so only the alicorns eat it and have an eternal youth.Beacuse if Spark know it so the other ponies know the golden apple.If everypony knows some ponies can use it fot their own advantage.So maybe some alicorn make it that powerful.-but which pony is that powerful?...
Counter Theory the golden Apples are litteral GOLD Apples a magical kind of apple that developed a metalic shell to ward of insects and birds eating them and Celestia was keeping them to keep the currency Stable (ignore the pun) and as a twist there can be equestrian myths about those apples granting immortality because immortal celestia and luna have those apples
"How cruel would it be to have the cure to death, but keep it all to yourself".
But immortality is more like a curse. That is not fun and cool. That is smth that can easily drive you insane. It would be GOOD to keep it to yourself, that would be an act of self sacrifice. If Celestia would ever have such apples, I can only imagine her giving them to the royal family and other important ponies until they find a replacement.
Hi Sawtooth, I have an interesting theory, what if the mane 6 (Of MLP 4th generation) are descendants of who they played in the season 2 hearths warming episode
Just one question. Luna. When she was nightmare moon how did she not grow old. She was an alicorn. So how did Luna not grow old? Sure her dark magic may have been it but I just wonder
I think her golden apples only work on alicorns since only the alicorns have really probably had them so twilight’s friends aged without her? I don’t know I’m just trying to make this make sense
I always thought that Celestia had intentionally kept herself alive so that she could see Luna's return, and then when she did return, she held on a bit longer so that they could make up for lost time.
I am a german and I also know more about german mythology than others at my age, but I don't know how and why changelings are based on german mythology. So if someone knows that, can he explain it to me?
Going back to the new 5th generation movie, what if this isn't the future of the Equestria we know and love but one of the other timelines that starlight created, that would make sence why the main six don't exist anymore(this could be the one they left and the secound time they came around), or they do just not as powerful or famous, and the mural could be of when twilight left the time line with starlight, and it could have been T-wrecks timeline and Celestia made the crystals to give ponies some sort of magic agian, or the king Sombra timeline and the crystal empire was lost agian but without the northern lights magic started to fade and Princess Celestia made the crystals to keep the magic around just my idea I would love to see you make a video on this.
Do changelings have all pony magic and more types? All changelings appear to be alicorns in their natural state however Queen Chrysalis had a much more similar appearance to the pony princesses and ponies in general (normal eyes, long legs & horn, a mane) and also the first changeling to become nice, who is now the king I think, became leggy as soon as he became good (although I may not be remembering properly) so maybe leggyness is not directly connected with age? This is a bit random
Changelings also seem to be able to use the properties of who or what they turn into, so do they have a special copying magic which allows them to shapeshift, or do they have all types of magic in them?
Wow. That an golden apple is behind immortality eternal youth sounds really intrigany. Also that we have seen lore of it in the comics has a lot of mean. What if the golden apples grant wishes limitlessly? As if there is no rule about the wish, or depending the user's power the wish varies on power too? So as Celestia is an alicorn she can wish eternal youth limitless. Wow great video!
Since this video started out with Celestia using Sombea’s spells I assumed this was going to direction that Celestia was using dark magic to stay young like Ancient One in Doctor Strange.
I don’t mean to be nit picky but changlings actually come from Irish culture and mythology not German. that is where they originated from, season two upwards to around season six-ish the series was taken on by cartoon saloon an Irish animation studio, when they where coming up with a new villain ideas they took inspiration from Irish folklore but instead changed the more gremlin like representation of traditional Irish Changlings looked like and gave them a bug inspired look instead.
The whole Immortality/Eternal Youth thing might simply be caused by the use of Age Spells, we've seen in the Episode Magic Duel that they do exist, and that they can make one Older or Younger, so perhaps Celestia has been using them like once a year to shave a year off herself or something, creating the illusion that she's not aging, while also extending her own lifespan, granting her a personal Fountain of Youth, thus making her be a pseudo-immortal, but now that Twilight has taken her place, she may not need to use Age Spells, and can finally allow herself to grow old and finally die of old age, so that she may at last rest in piece.
well quince tree has golden apple well yellow... and the quince tree is the mother tree of apple and pear trees... and there meant to be rock hard. (kind of remind you of a certain pony family)
Hey did I mention that I saw, in Sunny’s (from the mlp G5 movie) house, Grogar’s bell? Also, btw now I think that, on the terms of the elements of DISharmony, maybe Grogar’s bell could be the element of selfishness or the element of cruelty? Just wait until I get my own channel…
Hello could you please explain princess’ celectia’s and Lucas family husbands ( celestia’s king hepheus ) older sis ( Ingrid) and other info because there is so many info about them but also so many fakes like twilight is celestia’s step doughter etc please do family tree + explanation please!!!
Personally I think the golden apples do grant the wishes of those who eat them, however instead of the wish being able to be used for others the those who eat the fruit have to use the wish on themselves. And it could be a form of punishment for trying to replicate or taking the golden apple tree from wherever Celestia and Luna came from. It could also be a draw back since Equstria soil might not be the same as where the two princesses com from. So while the princesses want to help the other pony’s they can’t. The one question to ask now is why don’t Celestia and Luna just give the apples to the pony’s, let them make their own wishes, well perhaps that the apples only work with alicorns and not regular pony’s, Pegasus or Unicorns
On a second thought. What if the last time line we saw. Was not from sunset shimmer, instead of daybreaker? I mean it would me possible. After all it took only a spell to reveal day break to us.
Okay so I was watching a few episodes of My Little pony and I was watching the episode where Celestia and Luna's cutie marks are switched when Celestia goes up in the air fighting daybreaker and nightmare Moon she is Luna's cutie mark on both sides but whenever she flips it only shows it on one side and not the other so why is it on both in that specific scene
okay- but what if it's like ambrosia from greek mythology? normal people cant drink it without dying and demi gods cant drink too much or they die. so if might've been Twilights friends couldn't eat it without dying quicker then wanted
Theory: Remember that new MLP movie where there is a new generation, twilight was mentioned that she was not there anymore, maybe the golden apples ran out? Man i suck at making theory’s-
I don't really know why theories exist, there fun to watch but I'm not sure the creator's intended to hide anything or dark theories in the series... it's just a kid's show about magic pony's and friendship
I think the apples have something to do with the apple of Eden. Like, nopony is allowed to eat from them and if they do, they'll be bucked out of equestria
0 likes
Mary Taylor2022-07-11 02:13:18 (edited 2022-07-11 02:14:20 )
Actually, The REAL reason why Celestia lives so long is because every 50 years, and alicorn gets 1 year old. Thats why she lives so long. According to google, actually. the other thing is that she can live up to 8,000 years.
0 likes
K Hoff2022-04-09 15:17:47 (edited 2022-04-09 15:49:04 )
Maybe the Golden Apple Tree grows apples made of pure gold; not good for eating but are instead a symbol of prosperity.
Alicorns and a golden apple have been given immortality and youth. Does that go the same for princess Luna and princess Cadence. 🤔🤔And what about Discord. Discord said he was" centuries old" plus the fact that he been stuck in a statue when Luna and Celestia keep him prison in stone.
Siblings? One associated with the sun and the other associated with the moon? The favored one being the sun one? Some kind of darkness takes over the moon one? And now, the sun one being associated with golden apples? Sounds awfully familiar.
I know right? I really feel like those other siblings shouldn't have to be skeletons though. Nevertheless they are pretty cool and I was just about to comment the same thing.
@Katie Dizon fun fact: despite the Dreamtale comic/animation going to continue having Dream and Nightmare as skeletons for the sake of recognition and consistency, they are canonically humans now.
@CrystalKitty1220 Wait really? I was just thinking that it would be better if they were alternate versions of Frisk and Chara or humans at least yesterday. How did you know? Where can I find it?
The golden bow in sawtooths mane and wings... Huh-?
I know since theyre a changeling they can just change their appearance as per the episode for the theory but.. I don't? Get why a yellow bow and wings have anything to do with golden apples :squint:
Why does thorax get to be the king chrysalis served the hive longer than he has way before he was even a hatchling. Maybe for honering his late big sister larynx.
Sooo I want to say something I have discovered its that sunny looks like scootaloo so I think she married sunnies dad and sunny was born which explains a lot about sunny so would you try to talk about this
Celestia and Luna themselves StarSwirl Starlight And even twilight
If stars world can make things to go back in time
Wooden starSwirl will be able to give a spell to make them last Youthful for eternity? You know they’ve been around when the princesses were Really young So when they became rulers wooden stars will be like
“ if they’re gonna be the rollers they need to last for a long time I’ll make a new spell?” Don’t you think that might be an explanation to
Back on the golden apple topic
I have no reason for them existing Maybe Celestia was bored one day and it’s like “ i’ll make a golden apple, they’re shiny why not?”
But of course that’s just me you have your own opinions
Sawtooth i have a question on luna cutie mark look at here she has a moon but with a black mark around it and thousands of years ago she did not had that black mark so what is going on please do a video on this love you Sawthoot
I have a new theory idea! The rainboom was what caused the main 6 to come together. And rainbow dash was the one who made the rainboom. But what did the others have to do?
Dark magic is just a trick that probably only alicorn can do, it probably didnt have anything to do abt their age
if the golden apple make people immortal then all the pony there can just become immortal, if twilight knew this she could give it to all her friend and people who needs it, ok maybe they didnt say a word to twilight but what about luna and cadence
not all alicorn immortal, in fact it was probably never (except MAYBE for flury heart), being a alicorn just make u life longer than any pony does (but idk)
its because most people cant handle the fruit of immortality. and she exists to protects you guys.
and if everyone is immortal and keeps having babies there's gonna be to many people. they aren't bad, they want what's best for you. you might freak out living to long...
i think its being given the Title.. maybe its like One for All.
One thing that makes this theory toast, Cadence rules the crystal empire and there are no trees or plants there, even outside the crystal empire there's just a train stop and nothing else. You could say cadence could leave the crystal empire and go eat those golden apples, however in the episode Princess twilight sparkle, the gaurds say 'Cadence overseeing the empire' which probably means she doesnt go outside to eat those apples.
Ok sawtooth now this is odd In new generation pony’s had no cutie marks but in tell your tale charters like zipp have cutie marks Can you make a theory about that?
Technically if they do have they will not share it because nobody love to live forever the only reason the princess live longer it's because they have duty and it's pretty rare to came across a successor to be a princess
When I saw the befening of this vidio with the apples and immortality I thought of the golden apples spike talked about celestial golden apple tree . But you already said that, lol.
I just thought of a theory. It kinda explain why their a 7 elements. What it is and where it in pony world The 7th element of harmony is redemption / forgiveness (both work). The element in pony world got corrupted and became alicorn armlet . That why it the the only one. In the original friend/creator of elements of harmony/ the pillars. The 7th is Stygian
In pony world it starlight glimmer And human world it sunset simmer The reason they belong to different people is because time twist and that why it belongs to different people . If u think the idea work just see if u can find more evidence and just mention me
What if they are wish granting apples, but there aren't a ton of apples? Like one apple every 10 years or even 100 years? And what if that rare apple was used to bring Luna back?
Getting scientific here. Things age and then die because cell reproduction doesn't work as well anymore. So eternal youth would mean eternal good working cell reproduction and that means the body has no biological reason to die. This is a show about magical talking ponies though so 😂
Can you do a theory video about why the writers of the MLP FIM show decided not to give Spike the same kind of character development as the Mane_6 since he's the male protagonist of this show despite being a Dragon and not a pony? The only thing I don't understand is that why did Celestia give Spike to Twilight Sparkle instead of returning him to the Dragon Land after he hatched from his egg. Why does Spike even exist in this series if he can't be treated like an equivalent to Twilight and her friends which makes them jerks and racists for not having any kind of sympathy for him?
Ok so true gold apples, and not the golden delicious variety of apples are said to be from the realm of the gods. And alicorns are sometimes considered to be gods and goddesses. And from this stems the belief of eternal youth and immortality. Only alicorns can eat these sacred apples, because for a normal pony to eat one would be detrimental to them. Cadance and Flurry Heart would have to come to Canterlot on a regular basis in order to have some of these apples in order to truly sustain themselves. While Luna was on the moon she couldn't have access to the true gold apples, however what if there was a similar true silver variety of apples that was available for her to eat and sustain herself with.
I have a theory My Theory is that in the mlp universe the sun and moon had rotation had but one day a powerful alicorn/unicorn tempered the sun and moon tempered the rotation and it couldn't be fix for thousands of years
I think maybe if this theory was true the golden apple maybe only celesta knows, maybe she is putting them in food. They don’t know but that why ( just a theory )
Is it just me or is Celestia way weaker than she is described as 💀 like, she lost to a single changeling yet a unicorn could take an entire kingdom of them 😂
Been loving this Channel for years wish I had enough money to be an alicorn but still watch every vid religiously and I’ve just been mind blown seen almost every vid a million times ❤️❤️❤️❤️
this isn't on topic but if you would notice this comment i would be surprised! so theres this thing ive been wondering about g5. if all the tribes hate each other whats up with the windigos? if they feed on hatred, shouldn't they appear anytime soon if the g5 universe is the same one was g4's? i haven't watched the movie but if there is any info on it in the movie i would be surprised at least. maybe you could do a video on that?
Actually I think you know there's a new movie of my little pony you see when twilight got older sun and moon wasn't able to visit her so maybe can you make the new theary
Sawtooth Waves Можно я переведу ваши видео на русский?(да,такие уже есть,но никто давно не переводил,точнее не все видео переводили,я хочу,чтобы все были на русском) Естественно с указанием автора, если важно могу указать канал на котором собираюсь делать переводы
I think she is an evil, extraordinarily powerful conquerer, and there is lots of evidence to support it. I am thinking of making a video on it but.. it might be a while as im still new to youtube and have no animation or editing skills.
Everyone : discussing about the video/ other thingz Me : looks at Applejack Applejack’s eyebrow: ascending I BELIEVE I CAN FLY I BELOEVE I CAN TOUCH DA SKYYYYYYYY
1 like
The Boba Dog2022-04-09 19:49:55 (edited 2022-04-09 19:50:02 )
What if they’re immortal bc they’re the queens of equestria just asking
Hello i have a question . How did they become princess and how did they convince them to believe in friendship. They just couldnt just came and become princess
@Th3_Jelly_OnE They mean, Cadence may have a dark side that we might never see. The only time we see a dark Cadence is in the comics, but that was in the mirrored world.
@Sawtooth Waves I Kept Commenting The Same Subject In SEVERAL Of Your Last Videos This One Was The First Comment \/
Isn't It Weird How Every Princess Has A Dark Side In Different Realities
EXCEPT For Cadance
Why Is That?????
Edit: PLEASE MAKE A THEORY VIDEO ABOUT THIS
If nightmare moon was an Alicorn and trapped in the MOON for 1000 years That means there are no goldden Apple trees so how is she the same age. When she was first trapped in the moon??
Listen man.... I think applejack would know about any enchanted legendary golden apples. Cuz you know.... Apples are her thing... And her familys thing.
Maybe it would be a legend and Applejack only knew it as such so Spike would still want to show it to her.
What if only alicorns can handle the powerful magic that makes them immortal and regular ponies can’t eat them because they can’t handle all that power
Sawtooth is now a pegasus!! ( sorry idk how to copy and paste time) at 3:39 you can see that he clearly has wings :) in " The truth about poison joke" he was an Earth pony... Unless you're a changeling and can change from pegasus to earth pony to alicorn :)
If the California is a mix of all three tubes it would make sense if they had 3 times the life span but then again that's just a theory a sawtooth waves theory
Ok ok, but i feel like Princess Celestia is using a spell because I mean she has access to all of the magic because of the magic Scrolls in the castle that she lives in so she probably has access with spell that could keep them looking young forever I agree with the rest except for like that she uses apples or fruit to look young
In the whole video I was just thinking about Minecraft's Golden Apple! 🤣🤣 and i think Celestia's golden apple only give 2 extra heart😅😅 But think that if there's Enchanted golden apple! it's very op! 😅
The could very easily be immortality apples and if so she wouldn't share them cus it's a curse living forever watching every one around you die that's not something you want many the royals ate one without knowing twilight was probably stressed with work found the tree stoped for a snake to relax as for the princess they could of found it as fouls many it only activate when there older
Can you do a theory video about what happened to all the creatures from outside Equestria like Griffins, Hippogriffs, Yaks, Changelings and Dragons in the MLP G5 universe if it's even in the same universe as MLP_G4 since they we're welcome in Equestria in the MLP FIM show?
Hey, did you release a theory video that wasn't not only completely off the rails but riding off into the sunset after taking out half the train station?
Mabey she did not used a golden Apple mabey she used some kinda spell to keep her young and what about Luna she lived as long a celestia there sisters after all mabey she used a spell bc mabey she needed to be alive to rule before she met twilight first celestia made twilight her pupal then princess of friendship now celestia retired and now twilight is ruling
Well what you could be saying is true but I have two possibilities number one maybe it Earth it lies around Celestia's big fun Sun cutie mark maybe she has golden apples actually keep her life and she Pat she passed it on to Luna and Luna passed it on to Cadence who is Pastor Don to Twilight so on so forth and after that Best Buy idea my other idea is basically again and it lies around Celestial fun maybe instead of keeping golden apples her alive their cutie marks Twilight keep studying and studying and studying wow no one and Luna keeps breaking the moon rise in the moon rise in the moon like she keeps Rising the sun rise in the sun rise in the Sun Amna and also Cadence shoes the Crystal Empire Yeti out of gotta think it's possible
Ummmmm ok not wanting to be against the information you have given us But What about luna? She was stuck in the moon for 1,000 years doesn't that mean that she never had access to the apples on the time and she would have died? But she did not She is still alive
Another sawtooth conspiracy... Heres a conspiracy for you- Sombra is a ponified version of Putin because Twilight traveled back in time and then came to earth and banished a piece of Putins soul to ancient equestria!(I don't know if that's insensitive. if it is I will totally remove it)
There's another myth with immortality granting fruit in Journey to the West, the monkey king eats all the immortality granting fruit. P.s. I like your wonderland theme especially the bow. Wonderland really correlates with the fact it's Autism Acceptance month. 🙂
I was watching an old video and it makes me ask what happened to the treehouse of harmony and all the other species we didn't see anything of them in the future world
Bruh what is the golden apples cause their hair to be moving like that lol I know it's just a joke but Cadence doesn't live in Canterlot (so she doesn't have access to the gloden apple tree i guess) and her hair is not moving the way Celestia's, Luna's and then Twilight's does
Ok, if the golden apples do give eternal youth but only to pony’s that are already immortal, such as “alicorns”.. Couldn’t sunny the new Alicorn go get these apples. Or if her alicorn status is temporary could she still eat one and have eternal youth because she still has magic from all three tribes? Do the apples still work. Do they count as relics? Does celestias garden/castle/tree even exist. What about outside of equestria. Where they effected?
Thought if I just thought of a theory where are the other three villains because we don't see them anywhere in G5 and also one villain that knows how to suck magic and flight out of ponies just a little theory I just thought of
Heyo, so… I’m a newfound Brony as of maybe 2 months ago, and Sawtooth’s channel is the only form of large piece of the community that still seems to be around. Does anyone know any other places that one can converse with their fellow brony?
Maybe it’s like the golden apple from Minecraft? And maybe when you eat one you’ll just gain more live spand bc when you eat one you’ll get few more hearts.
What happened to the sisters in the human world in the pony world Luna was banished to the moon but was brought back by the main 6 there is no main six in the human world until twilight came so what happened to Princess Luna? This is one I think you can do 👍✨
It's weird no PONY has ever eaten the goldden Apple's only the royal do so what's the Pont if there's so many of them on the tree and WHO the heck CONTROLS the STARS I think it's twilight because HER CUTIE MARK is a STAR itself and did celestia give twilight Alicorn powers to make the crystals because twilight did not do anything about it until.... she made the crystals so twilight was never an Alicorn So... let me get it straight CELESTIA KNEW TWILIGHT NEED ED THE ALICORN POWER NOT JUST TO RULE EQUESTRIA BUT ALSO TO MAKE THE CRYSTALS AT FIRST I DIDD NOT NOW EAL GOLDDEN APPLE TREES ARE REAL AND I THINK BACK AT CELESTIA AND LUNAS HOME YOU SAID WHEN THERE READY TO GO home they can finally meet the family slow-mo: OR EVEN CHILDREN that's what i Mena and I love your videos And your amazing and how do you know about mall so much? And that was my last word ok I will stop commenting I been doing this for so long I just started at morning and now it's midnight ok it's my bedtime and I am sleepy ok bye I love your vids and I love mlp
Did celestia give twilight Alicorn powers to make the crystals because twilight did not Do anything about it until.. she made the crystals so I think twilight was never an Alicorn because she was given the Alicorn powers just to keep some magic left in equestrian so she was never an A-a-Alicorn
Hi...not relatable but i was playing My little pony Magic princess and then something came out...characters from comics that have representing elements,i google the place and its so hard to find,its called The Kingdom Of ORNITHIA,i think its Captain Celaeno home..theres a lot of elements representable but i dont know if there's any crystals
Ceridwen- ELEMENT OF EQUALITY (master of shape-changing) Mannah- ELEMENT OF ACCEPTANCE (master of water) Taranis- ELEMENT OF PRIDE (master of wind) King Thaumas- ELEMENT OF PROTECTION Prince Aello- ELEMENT OF KINDNESS Balor- ELEMENT OF THE SAME NAME (master of Magic) Princess Ocypete- ELEMENT OF HOPE Queen Ozomene- ELEMENT OF GENEROSITY Prince Hugiin-?
Oh yeah one more ting i think golden Apple's takes ages or hundreds of years to grow so it's fair to just give imorltality for the important ponies that control the sun and moon and a ponie that rules a kingdom and a princes that a smarty pants and calld the princes of friendship so why not keep the important ponies now comment if you disAgree and tell me your complaints
I have a question was pinkie pie traveling between the pony world and the human one ? Because the human pinkie pie knew about the elements of harmony and the pony pinkie pie knew Twilight loves Flash.
I hate to tell you but no, there is no such thing as being eternally old. Age and mortality are linked to the point where they cannot be separated. Because dying as a result of your age is a direct result of the ageing process. Alicorns would have to be immune to every single disease and injury that old age brings with them. And we already know for a fact that they are not, as demonstrated by the short in which Twilight got sick. As well as the fact that Cadence felt the need to cast a magical health bubble when Discord pretended to be sick. In fact, immunity to disease seems to be non-existent in the mlp universe as even Discord himself got sick in that episode.
Sawtooth please tell us what the device twilight human counterpart used was I need to know what a circle container thing was please tell us you know the containment from friendship came to humans way they used to take the magic from the human means sex and turn into my next book in the first place please you have to tell us what the device with sawtooth and who created it please tell us in your next episode now!!!!
Maybe celestia gets her life span from the sun. Maybe the princesses don’t become immortal, but just get the life span from their ‘princess of’ element. Maybe if love became obsolete Cadence would die, but obviously their is no way to prove it—it’s just a theory.
Can you please do a video of what happened to celestia and Luna after Twilights coronation are they still alive and if so where are they? what are they doing
Ive always thought the same of celestia sincs when she first met granny smith she was young and so waa granny smith but now granny smith is a granny and celestia stayed young and desame
@Reese He said he had more than 1000 years of experience. (Episode: Friendship University) He can't get experience being frozen, so he must have gotten it before he went to limbo
Sawtooth did you forgot some Thing Sunset ask Twilight what Happens If you Take one Elemente of harmony to the human world? That means that If sunset Toke one of Them she had the Same Power as when she had the element of magic. Thats my commentaren to the Sunset won thearory
Man a theory if what if celessia Luna know about the golden Apple and know what's gonna happen or predict the future and they tell twilight if she's up for the task
hey has anyone thought about what happened to the 3 villains statue in gen 5 like where is it now and will the same thing that happened to discord happen to it
If/if you had golden apples she would have to get them from somebody and I would think they would come from their parents but their parents arnt alive so I’m thinking it’s just Alcorn
Please talk about the sirens! Like where are theyre parents and what will be theyre future? (Pls don't bei Mad about my english! I'm German and Love your Videos!!)
Now that Sawtooth has mentioned it, it's likely that alicornhood doesn't grant thousands of extra years of life. We know that Celestia and Luna haven't aged a bit in the last 1,000 years. This would imply that they are somewhere around 30-70 years old physically. This would mean that they still have many centuries left, but flash forward to modern times, and they're no where to be found. This would imply that lots of time has passed. But according to Sawtooth's theory about how Twilight gave up her "immortality," we know that the crisis started within the show's runtime. And based on the human world side, magic seems to be flowing through at a fast pace. So in modern times, it is likely that Celestia and Luna died not to long before the movie (by alicorn standards). So we have an explanation for why Celestia, Luna, and Twilight aren't around anymore, but what about Cadence? It probably wouldn't be long enough for her to die of old age, since she hadn't even gotten her energy hair before the time jump episode. So what happened to her? It's my theory that only the Royal Sisters had access to whatever lengthened their lives by so much, but Candace and Twilight didn't have access to it, for whatever reason. Based on the lack of any alicorn in modern times, it is likely that alicorns have naturally longer lives, but not for thousands and years like Celestia and Luna. They had their own spell or artifact that lengthened their lifespans.
But hey, that's just a theory, A Film Theory! Thanks for reading!
sawtooth waves you are under arrest for high treason against my mother princess celestia (a oc of mine is a powerfull light fury who was adopted by her)
I have another idea. Seeing as the Changeling mythology had been expanded in MLP to what it is, I wouldn’t be surprised if the apples also got an expansion of quirks. So, my proposal is this: What if the golden apples of Equestria only respond with eternal youth to alicorns due to magic? I’d like to also say that while you are correct with the difference between immortality and eternal youth, I believe eternal youth is just immortality with extra features (the youthful appearance) or that it stops aging entirely (in the time that it is being digested). So, considering that, what if, when the golden apples were discovered, that when Celestial tried to share it with other ponies, dangerous consequences were found. This would be due to not enough magic in the ponies being able to absorb the powers of youth. I’d then liken this to a chemical reaction. What if, in this scenario, magic acted as a catalyst to break down or build up whatever the apples had into the power of eternal youth? So, due to other ponies having less magic than alicorns, they’d have a build up of the initial substrate in their systems until it, at worst, killed them. I don’t know, I just really want the golden apples of eternal youth thing to be true because otherwise the alicorns are once again op because of their immortality. Speaking if op, I don’t think even the most powerful unicorns can equate to an alicorn for golden apple consumption (sorry not sorry Starlight).
Another thing... In she talks with angel, angel mentioned that fluttershy wants to marry discord. Say she does marry discord, would discord do some weird magic thing too make her live as long as he does, or not?
I can't help but realize that if the golden apples did JUST keep one young, the chaos that could unfold if Celestia or any of the Alicorns let slip the secret of the golden apples. Villains would come knocking and try to take the golden apples for themselves in order to stay alive just as long as Celestia, if not longer.
Well I hate to burst your bubble about celestia's eternal life but 1 moon is more than likely equivalent to one lunar cycle (29.5 days) so following that logic, celestia would be 80 years old, which would still bring up questions as to why celestia doesn't look like granny Smith but with a white coat, wings and a horn, it just simply isn't enough time to suggest that there's a sinister secret to the "immortality" that they have, maybe it's just the combination of the lifespans of all 3 of the types of pony or maybe they maintain youth through their own magical power.
Think one maybe the apples you can only use 1 time every a 100 years or something like close to that like if you take a bite and you may wish when it's old when you finish it you can't make any more wishes or something named closer that's why you're using there's something I'm close to that I like you you use this button to inside I wish to be a nail corner or something yeah and that's it that's all I think oh actually
I think that immortality is a bad thing because seeing your friends and family die in front of you is not cool dying with you friends and family by your side that cool it's like Richard Pryor said in Harlem nights the movie but that's just my opinion
IS pinkie a PONY version of discord ?? Because she can teleport she can remember anything like almost the day when she was born and uses hair as an extra lim she can swallow a whole cake and a whole lolly pop and...... MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS- * calms down...I LOVE CANDY
I'm not done with the video yet, but it's nowhere said the Apple of Discord is from the garden of Hesperides. In a kids book I have, it was even said she used a regular apple she turned to gold, but that one is not very canon. Anyway. Since these already belong to Hera I don't believe she'd have played the game, but rather gone "hey b***h what makes you think you can steal my apples and then pretend you offer them to me?!"
2 if apple = eternity, then Twilight had the reserve of apples... And could technically have gave some. If one apple was enough for one immortality, then there wouldn't be any need for a tree so an interesting guess is that Celestia and Luna decided to give their access to the apples with their job. I don't think it's selfish if it's kept and distributed with wisdom. Immortality has its downsides.
hey umm i found a my little pony book and it says for celestia's family older sister of luna ADOPTIVE AUNT OF PRINCESS CADANCE and for luna it says younger sister of celestia ant of princess cadance i just wanted to tell you
Fun simple thought I had is that maybe over the years Celestia just got into horticulture, and that tree is a breed she cultivated over the centuries XD
Mia Dolenšek2022-04-20 14:53:34 (edited 2022-04-20 14:57:24 )
the fact that Luna didn't visibly age during her banishment easily debunks this tho. If golden apples wrere the key to immortality or youth, Luna would have died long before the 1000 years were over or would be all wrinkly at the very least.🤷♀
@Kiddie Winnie Roblox Gaming you can't compare the moon and limbo, limbo is suposed to be this nothingness where space and time don't exist, therefore it's logical you wouldn't age. On the moon that is not the case.
@Mia Dolenšek well we do not really know besides you cannot really debunk my theory because it is a mystery how the banishment work in equestria besides we also do not know how heavenly bodies work in equestria for all we know the sun and moon if you were banish to it maybe be like limbo.
Can you do a video about what all powers Spike could have gotten in the Power_Ponies episode of the MLP FIM show instead of making him look like comic relief behind Twilight Sparkle and her friends which made me hate this episode?
Yeah but think of it this way how are all old ponies are still alive and the young ones haven't even gotten old yet over a thousand years maybe you should think of it that you know
@Reese but she did not forgive star she rejected her and left in fury and in rage and said that's it i am leaving and i am never coming back ever agian.
My théorie is luna and celestia comes by another place than equestria so maybe the place luna and celestia born has a immortal tree golden apple or something make them immortal but luna take ages when it was not anymore in the moon but after she take ages she stop to get more ages anymore and that’s I can’t explain why cause if she take ages in like 2 episodes so why she didn’t take ages anymore???
Can you make more videos about the new my little pony that came out you know the movie and I really like your videos I might if I can like and subscribe if you don’t mind byee from carabelle
How people can talk for so long about a show which is based on the wrong perception of reality that pacifism and democracy (which harmony represents) are is the way to fix the world.
Democracy doesn't always succeed. Look at China it is authoritarian and it is a great success. This whole show makes no sense. Channelings had a better military. There was no way Harmony could mobilize so quickly that they were able to win the battle after the invasion of Canterlot. This whole thing makes no sense.
Maybe the apples have a catch. It could be like the potion that allowed Twilight to see the past, but it only responds to alicorn magic. Maybe the apples only work on alicorns 🤔
Those apples do grant you youthful looks and it’s what gives em the wavy look on their hair should they eat it once in a while cadence doesn’t have it since she lives way far in crystal empire. There is a foundation of youth right there in the castle ground and it’s been shown in screen however no one knows about it except the two princesses. Oh I can go on foreva on why they didn’t share it and that the foundation was destroyed when the trip was freed chrysalis, cozy, and tirek and it’s why no alicorn exist in the new series blah blah they took over Equestria and yeah
Golden apple. makes more sense minecraft stuff. shouldve said that to make it shorter. although I love yer vids reminds me of my old self when I liked mlp lore
I think celestia and luna are not alicorns what if celestia and luna got a pair of wings and horns from twilight i mean we have sin twilight’s parents but it didn’t say that those are twilight’s parents what if celestia is twilight’s mom and that’s why she made her an alicorn i know that celestia has flowing hair but celestia is the one that bring twilight in the world
Hey Sawtooth I don’t think alicorns are immoral. When I looked up “Is Princess Twilight Sparkle immortal?” it said she wouldn’t. It was never confirmed that alicorns were immortal instead they just live longer like dragons. That’s what it said not me. But while digging deeper one line got my suspicions up. It said something like this “Twilight will not outlive her friends because Twilight and her friends can’t die.” That could be a lie but what if and you never know maybe it’s true.
i have a theroie so in the begging of seris one the book opens and at seson 9 the book closes so what if the new generation was reading it to the old one or something like that
Since you did a video about why Rainbow Dash doesn't deserve her element, can you do a similar video about Rarity since it's hard to tell that she is generous since acts very picky about small things, she acts like she was born in Canterlot and she takes full advantage of Spike's crush for her? Along with Twilight Sparkle who cares more about books than anything else and who is an abuser when she's with Spike. Don't take it the wrong way but if you've seen the show real carefully, you'd know what I mean
Well maybe I can have a different game going on maybe instead of golden apples we have something called last year has a big sign for her cutie mark the two possibilities that I love to explain number one I know it could be true
I have a stupid question or you everyone knows how twilight grows bigger and immortal will princess Celestia be the same height as princess twilight and will twilight be taller than princess luna? (please respond)
Wait you know undertale right but do you know the dreamtale this is Cleary similar to the story dream is +500 that means di celestia steal the golden Apple from dreamtale that might be it just if you donat know the story about dreamtale and if you know Its acsualy really similar to the story the dreamtale story is a brother that got left behind but in this mlp world is about sister that left behind or is this mean its a dreamtale AU or multivers of them its kinda hard to tell but i still believe this is related to dreamtale
I have to say this but in your last video about poison joke the comments were off but I wanted to say this I got your discord song reference when you said "I really don't like puppeteers but have a nagging fear that someone else is pulling at the strings."
Wait I have a theory: Maybe twilight didn’t know about the golden apples maybe tia put the apple in her food without her knowing that’s why the rest of mane 6 aren’t immortal because tia Knew if twilight would know she would give it to her friends and tia only wanted alicorns to be immortal 🧐🧐🧐
I want to tell you something you know the rainbow apples in the forest where the Apple acres family lives you know the apples they found their rainbow but not gold and of course not but they don't do anything but what if they do do something like what if these apples connect to friendship like the elements of harmony they are rainbow and so are the apples maybe the apples have to do something with the elements of harmony I don't know I'm just thinking this I don't know what they could do I don't know why I'm thinking this but it's just a thing for me
... Or has Celestia been a reformed changeling all along who needs the love of her kingdom to keep her on the side of the angels?! ( Sorry, went all Appaloosa Jones there for a sec ... )
they give power to the powerless that's why Celestia and Luna are so useless when Equestria is in great danger and need to rely on the main 6 to fix the problem themself
princes of Equestria my shiny metal a$s
0 likes
Sonic ranger2022-04-11 04:52:12 (edited 2022-04-11 04:52:54 )
So think changlins could been normal pony’s once. That what all about! My comment to long to understand. 😬😂
Maybe its a mix of the comics and the eternal youth, Celestia's apples differ from other golden apples because they've been spellcast to only grant one wish: eternal youth.
I have a question.I don't understand how dragons grow up. I mean spike ( born ) when twilight was a child and he is still a bady when she is a teen .how is that possible!
Maybe they're an ingredient to a very special shampoo that makes Celestia's and Luna's hair flow like it does? You just need a long time of regular use, though regaining the effect after a stop only takes a little bit. It may also require some form of magic i.e. Rarity does not have. An Earth Pony maybe, at the cost of not being able to use it as an extra limb or Bigger-from-the-inside storage space.
i don’t know if you ever discussed this but if Sunset Shimmer originally came from the pony world was there ever an original Sunset in the human world??
what about discord and some of the other villians? if they were evil, celestia wouldn't just give them the golden apples. Yet they stayed alive for a long time as well.
My issue with this theory is the fact that not once in the entirety of the show, or even the comics, novels, or the writers themselves, has it ever been affirmed that alicorns are immortal.
But if there is anything that is connected to their perceived immortality, my theory would be the magic connecting them to their celestial objects.
Now if I am thinking about Sunny she could be one last hope for the ponies when it comes to the future since if Sombra comes back everyone would be aware about it since and due to the drain of magic that would put him at a disadvantage making it a fair fight but who knows probably just me thinking about something else that I don't have the knowledge about
0 likes
Tim Ross the boy2022-04-10 04:56:25 (edited 2022-04-10 04:57:07 )
Because a LOT of MLP's lore and creatures stem from all sorts of mythologies. Sirens, sea serpents, hydras, Cerberus (guard dog of the Underworld), WIndigos, things like that.
Golden apple makes some youtuber lose their shit over a line dropped in season 1 to come up with a stupid reason to make a video to get some clicks and some likes ...
I saw Fantastic beast: Dumbledore's secret. I compares Kung FU Panda, Harry Potter/Fantastic beast and My Little Pony with each other. Oogray, Dumbledore and Celestia. I love their personality. All 3 universes develops to be deeper and deeper.
I think it´s the one about eternal youth. I don´t think Twi wouldn´t share eternal life with her best friends. She IS the princess of friendship. But just think of Celestia seeing her friends die one by one. Poor girl.
Are you sure Celestia is not going to kill you because you are literally telling her deep in darkest secret well have fun and Ponyville or whatever you live
Don’t forget in Greek mythology the myths arund the cicada being created started with one of the goddesses lovers who she wished would be immortal but did not wish to be young. He grew old and his songs were all about dying and someone setting him free. He was old and immortal not young and immortal so he was turned to a cicada and the sound that cicadas make are from that old man singing about his death.
Interesting theory. I do like the idea that the apples grant ones who are already immortal (or at least long living) eternal youth. Doesn't seem quite as sinister that way. On an entirely separate note, the part where Applejack's eyebrow raised up into the sky got a chuckle out of me.😄
I think defendant happen means not getting any ring girls, because you know people daddy happy lang girls sometimes hurts help, girls, school, I think a shrink
Hey thought you waves there's no like golden apple and like My Little pony so why was there a picture of a golden apple and all so I'm sorry for saying this in like the very like someone beginning of the video but like are you saying that Celestia killed someone for a golden apple and then she ate it I'm supposed to be believe that the reason why Luna isn't dead because she got half of the golden apple like you're saying I'm sorry for saying this but like I'm just trying to protect if in the rest of the video you're going to say that Celestia ate one half of the Apple then Luna ate the other half of the Apple that way they both be immortal
in my theory, the immortality is given just to the alicorn in power (ruler of whole equestria). so, the moment that Celestia and Luna retired, they are back to aging. Meanwhile, we can see Twilight with youth appearance in the last episode, unlike her friends who, on the other hand, have obvious signs of age. now, i don't remember who, but an insider of the series confirmed that Cadence is not immortal, during an interview, for example. (ok, she's a royal but not the ruler of equestria, indeed). so, again, i guess that average alicorns (or royal alicorns of some equestria's kindgom) maybe have a really long life-span, but the immortality is a power for the main ruler of ponies world alone. (maybe the king of dragons and queen Novo too ?). anyway, the gold apple theory is kinda interesting too, but I don't think it has a lasting foundation at this point. but maybe i'm wrong, it would be interesting to explore it! :D
And allycorns is not born to be allycorns they just suddenly grow wings or horns to get that is only one ting just like how super heros get their super human powers iiiiiitssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss Being the MAIN characters ;)
Celestina golden apples are really nothing. Never even remember seeing the app,e anywhere in mlp. Her long lives is just little pony story. It go princess alway live forever of twice a longer there friends. After great wizard set a spell on the upcoming princess. The wizard know who be running in next 5 years or so. So he pick to let the ruler of pony land longer. Make sense in other part beside usa. Because princess or king can be there forever if they want to be. And be tired to pick new on every 4 or 2 years like we done.
Random theory: the golden apples are actually a way to clone ponies that's why all the royal guards look identical. And that's how Princess Celestia got her guards. Maybe instead of being eaten they would be used in a spell or magic potion!
Then perhaps the golden apple tree and the mirror pool are linked somehow, maybe they both have the same intrinsic magical essence or something. The tree could watered with the water from the magic mirror pool, or there is am underground system that the tree taps into. Either way, they both have shiny surfaces that reflect a pony looking at it to signify its cloning abilities. Alternatively, Celestia could have used her magic or something else to contain the essence of the mirror pool into creating fruits that do the same thing for easier access
I think their power is conditional on what type of pony you are. They Grant Wishes for Earth Ponies and provide Eternal Youth for Alicorns. We haven't seen what happens when a Pegasus or Unicorn eats one.
Here's a thought. Granny Smith's father was renowned as a seed collector. She said he was the greatest seed collector in all Equestria. That doesn't sound like a profession worth celebrating, no matter how good you are at it. Unless Granny Smith's father made a living going out into dangerous places and gathering the seeds of rare plants that don't grow in tamer ecosystems. Also, in the part of Granny Smith's founding of Ponyville story where she talks about how Celestia granted her family the frontier land that would become Ponyville, I could be mistaken, but the wording of her story seems to imply that the land grant was in part due to Celestia recognizing value in what Granny Smith's father did. If you think about it a certain way, there could be more than novelty to Spike's idea of showing Applejack Celestia's Golden Apple Tree. What if the Golden Apple Tree was the product of a rare seed gifted to Celestia by Granny Smith's father? Perhaps as thanks for the land, or even for the honor of having his value recognized by the 'Greatest Pony in the land'?
Unfortunately, most apples in mythology aren't even apples. The Golden Apple of Discord and the apple of the Hesperides are two different fruits as well. But that only let's your first bit fall apart. New evidence for Eternal Youth? Look no further than Tirek
I as going to Netflix QUICKLY AND GOING TO THE EPISODE TO SEE IF IT WAS TRUE!!!!!!!!!!!!! AND.........IT...................WAS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱
1 like
Anna BC2022-05-05 01:30:45 (edited 2022-05-05 01:34:45 )
Uhhh i tought you are a boy why are you wearing a ribbon? But what the when you said raise an eyebrow but the eyebrow was flying 🤣😂
I heard a bad story about the mame 6 First up pinky pie rainbow dash apple jack Fluttershy raraty die when they were old eccept twilight sparkle survive being a princess
its also posible that the golden apples do grant immortality but only to alicorns, there may be something about them that makes them poisonus to normal ponies, perhaps they are packed full of magic energy and a normal pony just doesnt have room for the amount of it and it causes them damage isntead of rujuvination....its also posible that celestia just casts an age spell on herself every few hundred years, she has the capability by now.
What if alicorns were the only ponies that have enough magical power to absorb the golden apple's magic? That means that only alicorns can use it and if a normall pony eats it, it doesn't do anything. That explains why twilights friends grew old and Twilight didn't.
I think that the reason why the non-alicorns didn’t eat the golden apples / why they weren’t shared is bc it might be dangerous or deadly for non-alicorns (maybe it’s bc I’m in the Percy Jackson fandom but I think the golden apples might work like Ambrosia)
I completely disagree. Celestia would never keep inmortal fruit to herself. She’s been a great friend and mentor to Twilight. I can’t imagine she would do something so sinister. Celestia is good and will always be there for Equestria, princess or not.
I just want to point out one thing, her not giving out the apples if they were immortality giving, there are millions of ponies, how would she even be able to supply it to everyone? You can say she could breed them to be that many but it's obviously heavily magic based and there is no garenteed that they can even breed properly, let alone the other nastey side affects they could possibly have.
Eternal oldness doesn't work. The only reason you die due to old age is due to 'oldness'. If such apples could reduce the effective age of a pony biologically, it isn't like they'd die at 80 of a heart attack despite otherwise being at peak health.
Much more likely are the age-spells which we know to be canon - though then there is the open question of why she hadn't cast them on her friends (maybe they lose their effectiveness with repeated use)
My guess is why she is immortal (possibly why luna was immortal as well) is that their essence was tied to the elements of harmony which would arrest their aging. This connection would be severed however when the mane 6 would take up the elements and their connection severed when they were destroyed.
Sawtooth, can you stop ignoring me for once and listen to this, what is the element of Flurryheart (Yes I'm assuming you can figure that out with your big brain gameplay) Well, don't keep me waiting, make a video about it and name it "The Element Of Flurryheart Finally Solved" Pwease? Pwetty pwease? (I'm asking politely in a cute tone)
As someone very concerned with the specifics and phrasing of lore details, I appreciate the distinction between immortality and eternal youth. Also that twist at the end was a nice touch.
1236 likesReplies (5)
There's even a Greek myth about that exact thing!
51 likesEos and Tithonus. The goddess of dawn had Zeus turn Tithonus immortal but forgot to ask for him to have eternal youth.
I love lore details as well. "Overanalyzing" shows makes me appreciate and love them so, so much more.
26 likesThey are like yin and Yang in my opinion one can’t be used without they other
3 likesCelestia was not full of light than we believed
2 likes@Adnan Minecraft rolblox Well you can have eternal youth and not aging so you are being effectively immortal.
0 likesAnouther thing to kinda disprove the whole apple gives immortality thing is Luna, because she was stuck on the moon for a thousand years and yet hasnt seemed to age a day since she was banished, granted you could say whatever dark magic transformed her also gave her immortality, but we have also seen multiple other creatures who are seemingly immortal who also could not have been eating any apples. Tyrek, Discord (though he is kinda a bad example), Sombra, just to name a few. Sure you can give your own reasons for why these guys are seemingly immortail (Discord is Discord), but that alone shows that apples are not nessesarly the way for immortaility. Just my view tho (:
980 likesReplies (35)
Luna did age maybe her ageing stop on the moon but when she came back she started ageing again she went from being short,light blue colour to taller and Dark blue with flowy mane
171 likesStar swirl has lived for 1000+ years yet he looks old
63 likes@Akira technically he hasn't since he was stuck in limbo
97 likesLuna was possessed and it was dark magic that made her age in the first place. When she was purified she was returned to the same age as she was when possessed
63 likes@Akira He has only lived that long because the majority of that time was spent in limbo along with the other pillars, who havent seemed to age a day, even him since he was kinda already old looking before that.
42 likes@jw777 no he said “even a pony like me who has lived a thousand years would think he has nothing to learn but it appears I still have something to learn,friendship” he’s saying like he studied for a thousand years before limbo because you can’t do anything in limbo
42 likesshe was SEALED 'in' the moon for a thousand years,t hat fancy paint job on the surface wasnt just for show,s he wasnt on the moon, she was part of it, stone as much as discord was, unageing.perhaps semi aware, but not truely concious....dispite what the comics sugest.
36 likes@PrysmT.Kitsune yes
6 likesI don't think Luna was exactly "alive" during banishment. She was fused to Moon or something.
22 likes@Akira time in limbo is stuck so that doesnt work
8 likes@VcSaJen there's no way to prove that though.
3 likesdiscord is discord is one of my new favourite things to say. and pickleberyll. Isn't that just the funnest thing to say? pickleberyll pickleberyll pickleberyll. say it with me. pickleberyll qumquatch pickleberyll qumquatch pickleberyll qumquatch chimmi cherry chaka!
12 likesMaybe only ponies need the golden apple.
6 likesit's not clear if the apples would be a one time thing. even the nature of luna's banishment is unclear
94 likeswell Tirek was from another world maybe one where you are immortal Sombra was turned to shadow discord is discord and all possessed some form of dark magic
4 likes@twilight sparkle tirek
1 like@Praying Assassin my i key fell of and i couldn't be bothered putting it on at the time
1 like@Edits and arts Her form when she got reformed was her weaker form, she regained her original form later on. That was not aging
4 likesDiscord have a kind of god's powers with his chaos magic. he could just be an actually god or his species has just a very long life span.
2 likesmeanwhile, Sombra losts his physical form when celestia and luna defeated him. but not his life/soul apparently.
so maybe Sombra is just a kind of shadow pony (with a different biology) or is just a very skilled wizard that invented a spell to preserve his soul after death ? (in the crystals for example ?)
i dunno, these two can be excluded from the theory, to me. but yeah, Luna's existence knocks down the apple theory xD
@Sawtooth Waves you are alive!!!!!!🥳
0 likesNeither Tirek nor Sombra are percieved immortal. Especially not Sombra, who technically isn't any older than an average pony (the 1000 year banishment of the Crystal Empire doesn't count).
4 likesehhh...luna kinda went from child to adult from between the second ep to her halloween one soooo
2 likesUh oh
0 likes@Akira he was stuck in limbo, in many mythologies and string theory infinite multiverse theory, limbo is an extra-dimensional void in between dimensions and thus out of the realms of time(and space, but we're focusing on the temporal(Time) aspect here.) thus time will have seemed to have stopped from the perspective of the person viewing the world inside limbo, or move extremely fast as if someone had hit fast forward, idk 😶 I've never been in limbo, a coma is the closest to limbo anyone has ever gotten, and those who can astral project, but let's be practical here, no one wants to be in a coma, and not everyone can astral project.
0 likes@Edits and arts well can do things in limbo, but they wouldn't achieve anything.
0 likes@Sawtooth Waves that's true, we do know that Princess Celestia used the element of harmony to banish Luna to the moon, but we don't know the nature of the seal or how the spell was cast in the first place, certain magical seals, not all, has what I call a half-life which is the amount of time it takes the seal or spell to degrade or wear off, or requires certain conditions to be met to be released without the caster releasing it on his or her own, like with the theory that Princess Celestia released nightmare moon, however we DO know that Luna was up there for a thousand years, what we DON'T know is what spell was cast with the elements of harmony and how it was cast, figure that out and we will have solved the mystery of Luna's banishment, of course magic is unpredictable, I mean if twilight can accidentally turn her parents into plants during her test right when the rainboom happened, than magic is truly limitless in power, the only limit is your imagination.
0 likes@Edits and arts He said that about learning? Huh.
0 likesGotta rewatch it, but that would add a nice detail to his story.
Awesome and cool!
0 likesTheres this theory where the faster you move the slower time is
0 likesYears ago scientists putted a clock in a plane flying at high speed around the world while also keeping track of another clock on earth
When they retrieved the clock in the plane they saw that the clock was behind
So my guess is with the earth and moon rotating en spinning and stuff it causes Luna to age more slower.
Remember Rosalina from Super Mario Galaxy?
She started as a ordinary girl before taking care of the Lumas but is now alive for at least a few thousand years.
And what is she doing all that time?
FLYING AROUND THE COSMOS WITH A COMET AT ABNORMAL HIGH SPEED
i thought princess luna was turned into like a tattoo for the moon (something like that)
0 likes@jw777 Age spell, sawtooth mentions that in another vid
0 likes@Akira no fair reference
0 likesY
0 likesOr maybe it just work with alicorn magic. If the apples are magical, they would effect the different types of ponies differently. Like if an alicorn eats it, they gain immortality or eternal youth, because Equestria needs them alive to protect the citizents. But if a non alicorn would eat it, it just wouldn't work, or it could make them sick.
0 likes@Edits and arts yes maybe when luna was banished to the moon she didn't age at all when nightmare moon was destroyed we see luna the way before transforming into nightmare moon
0 likesI don't know enough about mythology to be sure, but I remember the golden apples having some sort of extremely specific instructions for growing them. Maybe normal golden apples have immortality, but the care of those trees to actually induce the proper effects have been lost to time or something. Or, as an alternative, Celestia's golden apples are a failed experiment - I remember the Chronicles of Narnia had apples (not golden) that cured any disease and brought back youth. But when planted in a world not suited to them, they were just merely very tasty apples that were extremely healthy for you. (That tree later provided wood for the famous Wardrobe in the first book of the series.)
188 likesPerhaps Starswirl/Celestia/Luna found a golden apple tree of immortality in an alternate universe, got excited (how excited would you be as an immortal to finally be able to have friends that would no longer wither around you?) and tried to plant it in Equestria, but the magic was the wrong kind, or the soil didn't have the exact right nutrients. So Celestia now just has an extremely exotic apple tree, even though her plan to give other ponies immortality failed.
Replies (2)
I would like this idea more, if the tree was merely from a far away land (such as the land of the alicorns mentioned in the Journal of the Two Sisters (Which I still believe is cannon).
12 likesIn that book it explains how alicorns age differently, but maybe a golden apple tree restores health?
In Scripture, in the book of Revelation, the leaves of the Tree of Life are used for healing (not the exact same thing, but it suggests the same idea). This same tree mentioned in Scripture also has 12 different fruits (12 being a significant number) which would suggest it's a grafted tree (which also has a significant meaning) but I think the fruit was meant to offer eternal life.
Celestia just crafted 8 gold with an apple
0 likesHey Sawtooth, I've been watching you since I was a child and I just wanted to say that I'm really glad you're continuing making content and how the quality of them is increasing z keep up the great work!!
53 likesMy inner Greek mythology nerd would like to propose an alternate theory: those golden apples DO offer immortality. To alicorns. In the Percy Jackson series, nectar and ambrosia will kill demi-gods if they eat too much of it, and presumably the same for mortals - or would just kill mortals. Nectar and Ambrosia share a lot of parallels with golden apples, with some people believing their is overlap in the role of golden apples and the role of nectar/ambrosia in mythology. What if the golden apples in MLP were poisonous for normal ponies, but if an alicorn eats it, it grants immortality?
0 likesGoodness, this channel is still going on with more G4 theories, I'm quite surprised knowing G4 came to an end (not sure tho) cause of the new movies, yet this channel kept on coming up with more and more G4 content. This channel btw is possibly the first channel I ever got interested on hearing about MLP lore and theories. It's just the way you explain stuff is impressive! All so clear and straight to the Why's and How's. With that, a sub is given, it's not much but I hope to see your channel grow to a million subs!
6 likesRandom note: I guess I joined the ranks of the Brony Army now. It's an honor LOL
I love how you notice little things in the show and are able to give reasonable explanations. ^^ It's kinda weird that of all things the apple is associated with great power/immortality in different mythologies. Are apples that good? Why not strawberries or tropical fruits? Apples are wide spread, even without humans, so it isn't a special fruit.
62 likesReplies (4)
Apples are known as the Fruit of Knowledge so it makes sense for them to have strong powers/grant immortality since Knowledge is Power!😁😁😁
6 likes@Butterfly Monarch Studios The forbidden fruit isn't an apple though, I don't know when that myth started, but I think apples have been used to portray other meanings as well, such as lust and desire.
1 likeIn Scripture the Tree of Life is portrayed as yielding eternal life giving fruit, and the leaves are said to be used to healing.
The tree of knowledge doesn't give life, it only takes life.
I mean, there is a famous saying: “An apple a day keeps the doctor away”
3 likesBut also, to be fair, an apple a day will keep anybody away if you throw it hard enough.
@Ruby Wade A pretty interesting and dark look at it. I like it
1 likeomg... i'm impressed... you solved so many mysteries that even MLP producers didn't think of! you are amazing! i just love your work! keep going!
6 likesCelestia's lifespan is still shorter than the average loading time for Internet Explorer
777 likesReplies (16)
Have you tried Microsoft Edge?
18 likesLol
8 likesLol
7 likesFR
4 likesLMAO
4 likesTrue lol
2 likes@Dile0303 or Google chrome
2 likesWhat if it’s luna’s because spike says princess
1 likeCelestial life span is shorter than the loadig time for Netscape navigator
0 likesFacts
0 likesIt's also shorter than the time it takes File explorer to scan a directory and make icons.
0 likes@P. Wingert and building anything at least 5 blocks tall in Minecraft
2 likesThat’s why Microsoft edge is a thing
0 likesDont ya mean dial-up?
0 likesThis comment is so underrateddd
1 likeSo true
0 likesIf the apples are wish granting apples, but grow slowly, perhaps they were used to combat the tragedies - just indirectly. A wish like "I wish we had someone to take care of Equestria once I'm gone" could have been used to tie the mane 6 together (Note how when modifying the timeline, they tend to end up in key positions, even without the Rain Boom). An earlier wish to grow old with her sister could also be what kept Celestia Young while her sister was away - you can't grow old with someone who isn't there.
4 likesI do like the idea of the apples only working on alicorns. It wouldn't rule out any of the other possibilities and why Twilight couldn't have shared with the others the youthful looks, though there's no prove they didn't indulge until they just wanted to let their bodies age naturally with the world around them.
3 likesI'd joke that Rarity might hold on the longest to her youth and those apples but at the same time, that just doesn't seem like her. She's wearing the gray in her mane loud and proud in the last episode while the others don't have any gray while undoubtably older looking. Sure she may just be graying before the rest of them, what's a little premature gray hair between friends when we don't have a solid idea of who the oldest of the mane six is and it could very well be Rarity, but the gray isn't a short little bit, it's an entire chuck that had a lot of time to grow out to be as long as the rest of her mane. Rarity may have been the first to cut the golden apples out of her diet if she had any at all. At least that's how I see it in terms of eternal youth sources. Correct me if the comics or some other episode confirms she wants it or is younger than another mane six like how we know Fluttershy is at least a year older than Pinkie.
Man this guy makes one of the best theory videos of My Little Pony ever.
3 likesIn the Journal of the Two Sisters they refer to the fact their aging was different solely due to being alicorns. This was before they even moved to Canterlot, while they were young living in Castle of the Two Sisters. Know your having fun, but this one was stated in accepted media.
3 likesive been a long-time viewer, and how the quality of these videos improved is honestly inspiring <333
1120 likesReplies (50)
thank you so much!!!
118 likesYes!
15 likes@Sawtooth Waves youre very welcome!! <3333
17 likes@Sawtooth Waves you make amazing content!
6 likesI am also a long time viewer and I strongly agree!!!
6 likes@The Weirdo Channel You’re correct!
3 likesExactly!!!
2 likes@Sawtooth Waves yeah! I'm a big fan
2 likeshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iJ7CCdzCCI0 you like learning the truth
0 likesSame and I agree though there are still a few mysteries left I hope sawtooth waves will continue to post videos.
3 likesSame😀
3 likesSame.
0 likesIkr
1 likeSame
0 likesSame And Very True
1 likeindeed it’s honestly amazing
2 likes*I've *thank
0 likes@Rebekka Jones kindly stop
0 likesyesss
1 like*Yesss
1 like*I've
0 likes@Rebekka Jones why does it need to be capitalized?
0 likesOh no could sawtooth cursed by the fruit?
0 likesThose golden apples only two alicorns maybe Twilight friends didn't know that they having golden Apple maybe alicorns keep them a secret so that nobody can eat the golden apples
0 likesThose apples are alicorns but white alicorns keep those eloquent from other ponies like pegaside unicorns Earth ponies only alicorns eat them only if Granny Smith is so old and she doesn't eat those golden Apple so maybe celestia is eating the golden apples and Twilight are eating the golden apples to be big if alicorns are just eating those apples and and luna's getting big but she's like so small youngest one so if Twilight is big maybe Luna we just like celestia and celestia getting old and old and still eating the golden apples.
1 like@Joginder Maheru well twilight is one great princess. But why her and not her friends? Surely the other could be alicorns too.
1 like@Joginder Maheru spike said something about a group golden fruit trees with golden fruits hanging from them. Some fruit sounds good and healthy. But what if spike meant indirectly?
0 likes@Sawtooth Waves btw, ur awesome for supporting Ukraine!!
1 likeUr little pfp pic is so cute!!
2 likes@VexTheFurry thank you!
1 like@VexTheFurry evil meanies
1 like@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 what.
1 like@VexTheFurry sorry
1 like@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 why did you call me a “evil meanie”???
1 like@VexTheFurry not you any.
1 like@VexTheFurry he's a changeling
1 like@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 what??
1 like@Just a normal alien I learned never to help the mean 3 with anything.
1 like@VexTheFurry I learn to never help sawtooth with anything.
1 like@🖤Lanny Le Artist💜 I learned to never help horrid Henry with anything.
1 like@🖤Lanny Le Artist💜 thorax got all the love and affection but chrysalis got all the hatred and rejection.
1 like@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 did u mean to reply to me?
1 like@🖤Lanny Le Artist💜 nope
1 like@Just a normal alien it's fine to correct grammar, but if it's stupid then sure, frick off.
0 likesExactly 👍
1 like(●’◡’●)ﾉ hi:)
0 likesYess
1 likeTrue
2 likes@Sawtooth Waves I love ur Content
1 likeYes I’ve been here from the beginning
2 likesShe can also share them with mistmane to help bring back her beauty as she was once the most beautiful unicorn
4 likesI’ve been wondering if Twilight is aging fast for an alicorn or in other words normal for a pony. Consider this, she’s as tall as Celestia after roughly 25-30 years of ruling but Luna and Cadance who were already older than/about 30 were always smaller than Celestia.
42 likesReplies (4)
My guess for the height thing is, genetics. It's possible that while there all alicorn, they still have different heights. The MANE thing( sry had to say it😂😂😂) is that they're all taller than average ponies and I think that's what helps classify them as alicorns!😁😁😁
13 likes@Butterfly Monarch Studios lol Yes! You absolutely had to do the mane thing! I would agree, and it could be a possibility except every other alicorn we’ve seen, the bigger they are the older they are, implying age is a factor for size. …could also be the writers being lazy about alicorns like they always have lol.
3 likesI believe that her magic also influenced it. She already had so much magic in her before becoming an alicorn (element of magic) and becoming an alicorn made gave her a larger horn and made her taller. I think that after receiving the magic of two other alicorns and keeping it for such a long time* is what caused her to grow that large after her years of ruling Equestria officially.
4 likes*She’s gotten all of the alicorn magic before in that Tirek episode, but she only held onto it for so long. In the final episode, it’s shown to have been YEARS.
Or maybe more times than 25-30 years has passed. We don't know after all how long ponies lives and at which rate they age. Thought i remember someone mentioning a lifespan of 200-300 years for averages ponies. Point is, a century could have passed and you wouldn't know it.
1 likeIt might be where, the golden apples do grant immortality, but only alicorns can receive the effects, like in Greek mythology where mortals can't eat the ambrosia, or drink the nectar, but that is what gives the gods, or in our case, the alicorns their immortality. This way, all of the princesses may want to share the apples, but they can't. Great video, by the way.
17 likesThe thought process is near flawless. Though, I cannot point out any. Love the video! I also like the little beginning and end bits! You do so well! Have a good day! (To everyone)
48 likesHm...I do have a theory but it might be a bit farfetched. What if the Golden apples actually help a pony actually deal with the power of being an alicorn? Like, yes, we saw how Twilight became an Alicorn and she seemed to handle it pretty well...at first. So what if those golden apples help ponies whom have become Alicorns deal with their new powers. Think about it! Imagine having three different kinds of magic inside of you at once. That might put a lot of strain on your body physically. So maybe the apples work as a stabilizer of some kind!
590 likesReplies (7)
maybe alicorns can only get to the size of luna and cadence without apples, which is why celestia, and later, twilight, are so big. however, luna has also lived for a similar time to celestia so idk
49 likesi don't know i think that would have been the subject of an episode or a comic, and tia would have come with one when twi got her wigs, and do not think that the kind of item you want to teleport to you if it stabilise alicorn magic inside the body could have the oposite reaction when spells are cast on it
5 likesI know there's definitely a stabilizer out there, because it's mentioned that this is given to Flurry Heart.
21 likesSo it could be very possible.
@HearMeOut17 I think you're misinterpreting the definition of a stabilizer. Flurry Heart had a spell put on her that's common enough to have a name and is likely designed for Unicorn foals in general to control their magic. And don't get on my case about Flurry being an Alicorn and not a Unicorn, because that's just a semantic argument. The point of the spell is to control the magic of a foal who is capable of using magic at will.
8 likesA spell like that would not be common knowledge if it was for stabilizing an alicorn's magic, because alicorns aren't common enough.
Also, it's called Fledgeling's Forbearance.
@Tabii Canim the reason luna is smaller is because when she was in the moon it stunted her growth. when she is first released she is much smaller and younger looking because thats how she was when she got “eviled” you later notice that she gets slightly taller and her mane gets longer. i think alcorns are like humans, the older you get the taller you are. which is why celesta is so much taller than the average pony and taller than luna because she is older and luna had her growth stunted. same thing with cadence and twilight. according to the diary of the two sisters it claims that alcorns age slower than the average pony which would make sense why cadence has only grown a little bit since when we saw her as a teenager foal sitting twilight. it also explains why in the final episode we see in the stain glass that flurry heart has grown up but is only as tall as a adult pony and not a adult alcorn. we also see that twilights hair gets “flowy” in the last episode so that probably also has to due with age/growth who knows maybe its a puberty thing 🤷
5 likesWhy is this so true
2 likesyea that is a great theory!
1 likeI'm really glad you brought this up, and I think it's a good theory. I personally believe that alicorns don't live forever, and instead just age differently. Luna and Celestia have lived for a really long time, beyond many life spans, and have gotten really tall as they aged. You can see that the older an alicorn is, the taller they are. Like how celestia is really tall, luna is shorter as her little sister but still taller than average, and cadence is a little bit taller than average. Not sure about how twilight was, but the important thing is that their height depends on age, yet within, not even a full life span, twilight sparkle grew to be the same size as celestia. I think celestia and luna used some way, such as a golden apple, to stay alive because the world needed them, but all the other princesses aged like an alicorn.
28 likesReplies (3)
I believe that her magic influenced it. She already had so much magic in her before becoming an alicorn (element of magic) and becoming an alicorn made gave her a larger horn and made her taller. I think that after receiving the magic of two other alicorns and keeping it for such a long time* is what caused her to grow that large.
0 likes*She’s gotten all of the alicorn magic before in that Tirek episode, but she only held onto it for so long. In the final episode, it’s shown to have been YEARS.
Didn't the G5 confirmed that Alicorns are immortals?
0 likes@Éfar Isti Oh yah, I guess it was kinda confirmed now. I mean, that evil alicorn person has lived for a pretty long time, so yup, pretty much. tbf I wrote this comment 7 months ago, but you are right, g5 does debunk the theory that I had.
0 likesIf the golden apples grant eternal youth, then why is Nightmare Moon still young?
88 likesThe more likely candidate for eternal life is dark magic. We know that Celestia, Twilight, and Sombra can all use dark magic, and it is conceivable that other 'eternal' characters are also capable.
Replies (3)
She ate hers when she was physically younger than her sister!
2 likes@Ellie Vergo Golden Apples are generally required as a consistent supplement to the diet, as opposed to a one-time thing.
3 likesMaybe?
2 likesMan I love how you did your homework SawTooth!!!📚
1 likeEven I missed this minor detail. I have seen golden apples used in multiple media from Minecraft to “Class of the Titans” series. I even learned more about their mythology in your video, wow!
In Minecraft, Gold apples gave you Temporary extra health, strong regeneration, and some other buffs I think I might have forgotten in game ( & the god apples required even more gold like whole blocks but I think where removed from the game, unfortunately )…
In “Class of the Titans” the tree itself made god-like friends & Allie’s immortal by just existing , but the villain figured as long as he had a few of its fruits himself, he could destroy the tree & wipe out immortal competition, but his wicked plan was foiled by the tree being regrown from a left over gold-apple core, saving every one from doom.
Hearing that the Alicorn-princess had a “gold apple tree” makes me wonder just what purposes or attributing things they exactly provided??? Only wishes like in the comic? Healing? Youth or immortality?… or a rare medicine, cure, or extravagant power boost & etc?!?!? … or more lower just an extravagant ingredient?
You would think if it hade rare medical or healing powers 🏥, why not use it to cure “swamp fever” instead of that rare honey in that one episodes?… & did or didn’t the the “Pillar of Healing” or any of “The six pillars eventually mention this in later episodes once they came back? Did even StarSwirl use them before to live a 1,000 years before the 1,000 years being trapped in limbo?
This is like a flood gate of questions I now wished they did an episode on!
Second to only wondering how Equestria got turned upside down a few generations later in G5 and all its questions! (Like what happened when a earth ponies(or etc.) had a unicorn or pegasus as a child… in G5? Did they need to run & live in an underground village for the life of their children & family?!?!?)
(But that question is for another video, right?)
After all this theorizing, I'd find it funny if it were just a statue of an apple tree made out of gold to commemorate the contributions of farmers to the general wellbeing of Equestria.
2 likesThe Golden apples could also bring up knowledge to the future or the past too. I find it a little odd how Celestia knew about nightmare moon being defeated. Maybe it told her what would happen in the future or something. She just seems calm sometimes when disaster strikes
5 likesIdea (⚠️SPOILER ⚠️): The Golden Apples grant the flowy mane thing. We’ve only seen alicorns with these manes. This could explain why Luna had non-flowy hair after Nightmare Moon’s defeat. Luna had no access to these apples thus no flowy hair until she had some later on and got it back. Candace and Twilight lived too far to be able to regularly access these until she gets one later on when she becomes ruler and lives in Canterlot. Also maybe it only works for alicorns, thus only alicorns has these manes.
2 likesBased off of the thumbnail I thought you were going to bring up dark magic. Since Sambra was alive as long as Celestia (who clearly used it) and Twilight who seemed to live a similar long life (who also had used it at least once). Like if you think about it, we never see old Caidence or Flurry Heart so maybe they aged like everypony else. And with how easily it corrupts and manipulates the usser it makes sense why that magic isn't shared/taught. I also want to add that being corrupt tends to be assorted with a form of "dark magic" in the show. Giving more reasons to why Luna and possibly other villains also could live as long as they have.
1 likeLove the videos!
Hi, Sawtooth! I'm a new subscriber who's been binging your video library for a few days.
0 likesWhat if the apples are something entirely mundane? Like, the tree and its fruit are actually just some gold sculpture the extremely wealthy princesshood commissioned as a centerpiece for her garden? What if it's not a real plant at all?
Maybe it's just the rich being rich!
I'm pretty sure Celestia uses that Golden Apple Tree for Regeneration II and Absorption while in the Nether.
164 likesReplies (5)
You mean Tartarus?
2 likes@Elias I mean Nether. It's in Tartarus's Basement
7 likesThen there is me who saw the apple and thought of the Tree Of Feelings from Dreamtale: . . . :T
4 likesYou play Minecraft?
2 likes@christy5213
1 likeI like your cut G
Maybe twilight wouldn't...
2 likesShe came a long way because of friendship but she's always been the more scientific,practical pony so after she became imortal she knew her friends wouldn't be with her forever....so she grew to except that...or maybe because the rest of the mane 5 are not alicorns and dont contain amplified magic from all 3 tribes they age but only physically?
I just had a big exam and I was rewatching a bunch of your theory videos to chill out afterwards like I usually do when I need a study break and then see a brand new one is released… bless I needed this today 🥺💖🙏✨
18 likesReplies (3)
best of luck on your scores!!!
8 likes@Sawtooth Waves ty Sawtooth I just got my mark back and it’s a 95.83%!! Your videos keep me sane during school lol tysm 🥺🙏💖
1 likeGasp
1 likeWell, based on the first theory, maybe you need Alicorn magic to access the apples. You need to have all three magic types combined to access them, and eat them. If a normal pony eats one, maybe it would speed up the aging process tremendously, instead of showing it down to immortality.
0 likesOh my god your eye to detail is amazing tysm for making these videos for us!
6 likesReplies (1)
Thank you for the heart
1 likeCan we appreciate how much hard work they put into their videos for us and they never fails us to entertain us and they always makes our day or night even better keep it up with the awesome work!
219 likesReplies (4)
<333
30 likes@Sawtooth Waves Hi <3
7 likesOoh hi
2 likes@Mememaker ExDee hi there 🙂😎
1 likeThis makes a lot of sense and would explain a lot
1 likeWhat I am curious about is how magic seams to affect different creatures differently…what I mean is Tirek went from looking old and weak to a Goliath when he stole magic…Discord just stayed himself unless he stopped being chaotic in which case he fades away…and when the princesses gave their magic to Twi the sisters simply lost their wavy mains they all lost their cutie marks and Twi gained a colorful trail and speed boost when she tried flying and couldn’t control her teleporting
Thanks for sharing your ideas with us, Sawtooth! The golden apple theories were interesting to listen to. Also, this is my first time hearing about the wish-granting golden apples in comic canon. Those might have been cool to see in the show. ^_^
5 likesThe topic of alicorn immortality theories reminded me of how longevity has been handled in some other works of fiction. In the film The Life & Adventures of Santa Claus, Nicholas is granted immortality by a group of immortals after a lifetime of good deeds. Someone could have done something similar for the royal sisters since they were the best at raising the sun and moon. Also, in an episode of Elliott from Earth, there's an alien who wears a special pendant to slow his aging down due to his species aging very quickly. Maybe the sisters' crowns or necklaces have some age-delaying powers. Just some ideas.
Let's just appreciate how well made these vids are. Thanks so much for making them.
5 likesIf we were to go with the "Apples grant immortality" idea, maybe the reason no other pony is seen using them is because no pony other than Alicorns are powerful enough to handle them. I mean when you think about it, an apple that grants the eater eternal life would have to be full of an extreme amount of magic to work, and single ponies no matter how powerful, would be unable to store that much raw magical energy in their body. Alicorns however, since they possess the combined magics of all three races, they can store and even control that energy. The reason why the princesses never give the apples to dieing ponies is not one of more or less greed, but because of the often postulated idea that too much magic- exerted or otherwise- is not in any way good for bodies that weren't made to handle it.
1 likeReplies (1)
Or celestia doesnt allow any other pony, its like a secret.
0 likesMaybe you are right, and it could be that Starswirl planted the golden apple tree like the tree of harmony though it might be that only very powerful or worthy ponies can use them like alicorns.
2 likesUnfortunately to say, Twilight didn't keep her immortality, one of the G5 comics showed that Canterlot is in ruins, and Discord's horn is found by Sunny.
11 likesWhat if the golden Apples only work on Alicorns? That the power is so extreme that you can only use it when you have magic of all three tribes?
2 likesWow! Great vid! Your theories are so great & very interesting & you put so much effort into making these videos for us to be entertained by! Thanks Sawtooth for all your hard work!
7 likesidea for a vid: in lesson zero Twilight used the "want it need it" spell, after use she says "works every time" indicating she used it before but, why? also the way the hearts come out of her horn reminds me of princess cadence... did cadence teach it to her? and if so, why!?
90 likesReplies (5)
Me just commenting to make this popular so that Sawtooth can see, because this is a really good video idea
9 likes@Annie Loves Horses thanks!
2 likesGreat idea! Here's hoping Sawtooth sees this.
4 likesNo, Cadence didn't teach her the spell. Cadence's magic is love magic, and the Want It, Need It spell may be love magic but not the kind Cadence uses.
8 likes@Reeseeven so we still know that she has used the spell before but why? that part of the question still remains
10 likesI really love theory videos, the reason being that people somehow give absolutely stupid and frankly wrong ideas, some sense of based foundation which is insane
7 likesNice work on this one Sawtooth! I even have an idea on where the Golden Apple Tree came from! It may be a bit far-fetched but... still!
0 likesMaybe the apples only react to Alicorn magic like that one potion. I wouldn't be surprised if they even lack flavor as a surprising twist.
11 likesKeeping youth/imortality granting appels from the general population could hardly be considered evil. There would never be enough for everpony, and knowledge of the apples would just lead to conflict over them until the tree was destroyed. Remember, in myth, planting a golden apple does not give you another golden applebearing tree.
0 likesIt is also possible for Twillight to use the apples without knowing what the do, as she inherited the staff from Celestia & Luna. That way she might get the apples as part of her standard meals.
if she's using dark magic to keep herself alive for a thousand years then she should be renamed as the ancient One from Doctor strange.
120 likesReplies (4)
Yes
2 likesBut she should be bald
3 likesI think this one is true about dark magic and now why because she show us about dark magic in SS2(Zombra) she show dark magic to twilight that’s mean she use dark magic to make her life longer(maybe) but I don’t know about big body it about magic or golden apple but Nightmare moon it look like a same size of Celestial That’s very confused but I think it because of magic if that apple make longer life I think why no one stole? And why guard didn’t stole that apple and make his life more than 1000+ years I always think Celestial use magic to make life longer like ancient one:)
2 likes@Joetino Official maybe it not a same magic type (maybe) that’s why she didn’t bald
1 likeWhen I read the journal of the two sisters one of them said (I think it was Celestia) that starswirl said that raising the sun and moon will give Celestia and Luna more power and rejuvenate them so they wouldn't age. So I think now that they stopped raising/lowering the sun and moon themselves they'll start to age grow old and eventually die. Now that Twilight is doing it she'll stay young and live forever, that is until g5
0 likesNow that you showed me how many mythology references there are in the MLP, I'm sad they missed the chance to put something form Slavic mythology. Though it is incredibly horrifying.
0 likesFor example, there is something called "psoglav", creature with head of the dog with iron teeth, human torso and legs of horse/goat, has one or three eyes. They dig up graves to eat corpses, but also hunt for human meat.
I think that because an alicorn has SO MUCH magic energy in them that it extends their life span as as they get older it takes up more of their energy to keep them alive. We've seen the older alicorns struggle with using their magical powers to their full extent explaining why celestia andluna dont directly fight back and when they do its not very well. Cadence while being younger weve seen start struggling with this when the gang go to the crystal empire as shes fighting off sombra. Ignoring their own experience with using magic because that obviously varies between the bunch this is a decent explination. Perhaps the golden apples cut down on this magic for life span cost they make to live longer (probably against their will because alicorn biology). Like lets say to live longer as an alicorn it takes up 10% of your overall magic capacity, over time this will take up 50% making the usage of more taxing magic harder to pull off, now lets say that golden apples reduce this cost by a certain amount. This explains how alicorns can live a really long time but still end up dying of old age in the end as there arent any alicorns anymore in gen5 because while you can make it last longer you will eventually reach the 100% threshold and die as an alicorn.
0 likesThis is a really god theory! My question that I haven’t seen an answer for is what happened to the human counterparts of the pony’s? Very curious what has been happening over there
1 likeSawtooth has been trying to understand flurry heart for a while and I have a theory on that. What if Flurry is the next princess of love and destined to take over after cadence she was born an Alicorn because her role as a princess was pre determined. There arn't going to be infinite new magics to earn wings with and older alicorns are either immortal or are going to die eventually thus needing heirs for the same spot in the alicorn pantheon he proposed in last video on why flurry has wings.
0 likesCan't imagine the power Alicorns would have if they got their hooves on enchanted golden apples
1 likeOk, so lets say if the golden apples were able to grant eternal youth for Celestia and Luna but would need to be eaten every number of years to keep the youth. Then if that be the case, wouldn't Luna be older and or look older than Celestia from Luna's time on the moon for a 1000 years? Including Discord and other mystical magical creatures that have lived for a really long time and youthful and have had no access to the golden apples.
0 likesWhat if Celestia herself doesn't realize after all it's not so farfetched to think Star Swirl harnessed the power of the golden apple tree to make alicorns immortal. After all Star Swirl probably wouldn't care for sharing immortality with others, and he almost certainly forgot later on.
1 likeI always love these videos. Please, please keep making them! It makes me enjoy watching MLP much more when people notice the tiny details and analyze them to make theories.
1 likeAssuming the Golden apples give you immortality, even if twilight offered them to her friends, knowing them they'd probably not accept it. Having to live on as protectors of equestria (as mentioned in season 9) along with twilight would definitely not be their ideal roles, as that's twilight's job now as the sole ruler. Besides they wouldn't want to watch their friends and or family pass on, especially Apple jack or Pinkie pie. If that's the case twilight wouldn't present them with this option either because as an alicorn she never had that choice, and must know the hardships that come with it.
7 likesI have some interesting theorys that might interest you but they involve the comics and the books, so it's a lot more outlandish
0 likesAlso a ramble about the video, I think it probably is wish granting apples but they only use it for emergencys they know they cannot control, like a fail safe, but like when they would physically be able to get to the apples, explaining why they didn't use it in the crystal empire, against the changelings and during the movie
I thought you were gonna say that Alicorns being able to use dark magic like King Sombra's makes them immortal. King Sombra was immortal so maybe it was something about his magic and then Twilight and Celestia being able to replicate it somehow made them immortal.
0 likesOr what about the flower that made the cutie mark crusaders grown ups? I think it belonged to starswerl or something so maybe Celestia used it to increase her life pr something. Example: In both ocations the flower could have done something to do with age, right?
2 likesI think the golden apples in celestia garden are wish apples and are able to grant wish while also keep the pony’s young until they decide not to use them.and I think the reason why alicorns are immortal is because they have magic beyond the normal magic that unicorns have that’s why alicorns are immortal because they can keep themselves alive.
1 likeIf the golden apples are an anti-ageing spell, it'd mean cadence wouldn't be immortal like everyone else since she doesn't have her own. I mean she could plant her own tree I guess but all the vegetation we see are all crystal plants, I'm not sure she could grow it there.
0 likesI think Celestia is wise enough to know that wish granting can have unpredicatable consequences and it's better not to use it unless last ressort. But she's not wise enough to put a security system around it apparently.
0 likesSpeculations. But why wouldn't apples that grant eternal youth be useful to old ponies? If your body stay young, it doesn't age so you do become effectively immortal.
Mad respect, you picked up that detail and made a whole theory on it, you madlad!! 🤣
0 likesHey sawtooth, I'm river I'm a human (you know what that is right) anyway I found a portal to the equestrian world I've been observing your videos since I was a Philly or a child it is so inspiring to me that you came out as non-binary (side note I love that you're non-binary and that you're OC is a changeling:) ) your video quality has only improved and watching you work so hard to keep this fandom thriving is amazing to me thank you for what you do.
0 likesWell, one thing to notice is that the kirin represents the Japanese people while the ponies like Mist Mane with a different horn represents the Chinese people.
2 likesI agree they could give enturnal youth but only to alicorns cause of the exstended life span if given to a mortal pony they'd have very dire effects on them due to the limited life span.
1 likeBut thats just me.
Are people going to ignore Sawtooth’s ✨YASSIFICATION✨ he looks stunning 🤩
3 likesThere is a book that is called “the journal of the two sisters” a real life book that you can buy off eBay, and this book holds a lot of answers, the book says that Luna learned how to move the stars, and the legend was the the stars would Aiden her escape, check out the book and see for yourself 🤗
0 likesWOW just WOW! You’ve made such a good point! Can i just say I love how much work you put into these videos!? You always do such a good job and always make me question things I never thought about before! Also, Happy National Unicorn Day!
8 likesI would just assume, the golden apple tree would be a highly classified magic reserved only for alicorn rulers. For the same reason the highest of classified information in the government is not talked about publically. Don't want to cause panic (the the most assumed reason).
0 likesOn the other hand, maybe they are just a special rare breed of apple tree.
Suddenly turned into a Greek Mythology lesson less than 5 minutes in and I love it.
0 likesI enjoy your content and lore videos soo much ♡ aiii the bow looks so cute on you
0 likesI've wanted to ask this for awhile but can you make a theory about Zecora? She's such a mysterious character
10 likesRandom theory idea : how EXACTLY did Rainbow Dash lose her wing in the Sombra timeline
0 likesAlso, as someone who has been watching this channel for years, your videos have gotten so much better!
hey! one of your really really old viewers, returning after YEARS to ask to make a video about Starlight possibly becoming a Princess? Like the princess or Destiny or the princess of Time?
0 likesI remember when you used to be "The Brony Nation" & I was so invested in all your lovely theories and I finally came up with another one I thought you may like to look through -- considering the ones you've made on Starlight in the past. Even though we know that Starlight currently teaches @ Twilight's school, its not impossible that she could be a ruler at some point.
I just found this man’s channel and i gotta say I never thought I’d be this intrigued in a mlp theory
0 likesalso, if those apples did grant immortality, maybe celestia keeps them from the citizens bc it is known that people fear death, but that immortality leads to one outliving their loved one's and that after a while, life becomes dull. so maybe she did it for their own good idk
0 likesI think the G5 movie kinda confirmed that Alicorn are not really immortal like gods in most legends and the bible, they are "technically" very slow aging like the elves from Lord of the Rings, due to the fact that then naturally have powerful magic. As for her golden apple garden, have you seen the G4 Movie? If so, maybe her motive in not using or letting anypony use the golden apple might be similar, but not as extreme as Queen Novo's motive in being overly protective of her subjects especially her "Pearl of Transformation."
0 likeshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FwU4Gu1AjeI&list=PLfJpfTZK5SWBLMkEGiL5tZersbT3AXW0r&index=17
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKHsignpbdM&list=PLfJpfTZK5SWBLMkEGiL5tZersbT3AXW0r&index=18
We also gotta count the golden apples from minecraft, when eaten, they give the player protection, regeneration and absorption, but the enchanted golden apples grants the player regeneration, protection, absorption but also fire resistance, that make the player harder to almost impossible to kill while the apple is still in effect.
0 likesI'd like to take a moment that when the writers and showrunners of the series were asked if the Princesses were immortal they were told that they weren't. So this 'the princesses are immortal' is disproven by the people who made the show - and thus the Princesses have an indefinite lifespan, a lifespan so long that it is unknown how long they actually live. Now, how those lives are extended and what not is up in the air, but the immortal thing really needs to stop.
0 likesAs usual those are some interesting theories Sawtooth, and i agree with what you said it could be possible that the golden apples do make Celestia young just not in the way we would think because like you said the apples probably only make Celestia look young physically but she's actually really old and when she starts showing signs of wrinkles she has to keep eating the golden apples to maintain her youthful appearance.
27 likesReplies (11)
They literally said that in the video
2 likesI believe that'sd exactly what sawtooth was touching toward the end there ^^
2 likesWell like Sawtooth said in the video it is possible to be eternally old. So yes it is a possibility that Celestia's golden apples do make her appear young physically when she's actually old and if that were so then that would mean Celestia would have to eat the apples constantly because just like the water from the fountain of youth, the effects of the golden apples eventually ware off.
3 likes@-Elliott- average dragon enjoyer Way to state the obvious you don't have to rub it in you know.
3 likes@Infernocon23 well clearly it isn’t obvious because this dude didn’t pick up on it.
1 likeWay to not think about what you’re writing :/
@-Elliott- average dragon enjoyer And it didn't cross your mind even once that some of us might've already known that this dude didn't pick up on it before you noticed that he didn't?
0 likes@Infernocon23 I was the first to reply. I informed them of their mistake. I really don’t understand why you are getting hissy with me over this.
0 likes@-Elliott- average dragon enjoyer What i'm getting at is that even if this dude stated what was said in the video, that doesn't mean you have to tell him that.
0 likes@Infernocon23 why not? He didn’t hear it so I told him. YOU heard it and so did I, he didn’t.
0 likes@-Elliott- average dragon enjoyer Well as you can see he edited his comment and fixed his error, which means he probably figured it out for himself by actually finishing the video i mean there's still such a thing as finding this out for yourself you know.
0 likes@Infernocon23 but what’s wrong with me correcting him? I assumed he missed the last part of the video
0 likesCelestia is kinda too good of a ruler
13 likesShe has Fricken guards and won't let them fight a villain to the death-
Sooo cool. I actually read a fanfic that was along a similar thread-how celestia gets her immortality and youth. But seriously a really good thought
49 likesI love how he makes theories and then debunks them in the same video
0 likesIt has been confirmed through multiple episodes that ponies do have longer lives. In the season 1 episode winter wrap up Twilight cold Spike that ponyville was founded by Earth ponies silver hundreds of years they have never used magic to clean up winter. In the episode simple ways it was stated at the beginning that Granny Smith was on the committee because she was one of the original founders of ponyville. Not to mention I cannot remember the name of the episode but there was a flashback where granny Smith's family stopped in canterlot and princess Celestia pointed them toward what would become future ponyville. Also in the episode where the other ponies discover pinky secret party planning cave Applejack did find Pinky's plans for her parents 50th wedding anniversary 100th wedding anniversary and 500th wedding anniversary. At the same time in hearts and hooves day you see the cutie Mark crusaders interrupting a funeral. So we do have confirmation about long lives for ponies. Don't know so much about the other races but evidently centaurs also have a very long lifespan. But where the normal ponies do age I did find it odd that the alicorns who have been confirmed to be alive or more than 1100 years seem to be quite Young and beautiful. I also thought for the longest time that the flowing hair was only reserved for the alicorns until we were introduced to cadence and that one unicorn who was a part of the original six. Maybe being an alicorn does slow the aging process. But it is not confirmed that alicorns live forever. They just might live twice as long or longer than the normal ponies. We know that Celestia had been raising the Sun for about 1111 years and for at least a thousand years also raising the Moon. Beyond that we do not know what their actual ages are.
0 likesEven though I do agree that this theory is very well made and everything the others say, I am gonna say this right now: Am I the only one worried about Sawtooth's safety?! Like, at the begining I was so confused about what happened to them and at the end it seemed as if they were captured by someone! Why is no one worried about them?! Who even took them?!(if I accidentally used he/him pronouns, sorry!😥)
0 likesas someone who thinks anything is possible in a world of magic,my thoughts are i think there is a spell only allicorns can use to make one have eternal youth of course there would be the golden apple farm but i think those are just very flavorful royal fruits :)
0 likesSawtooths point that immortal is differnet than internal youth is true in the greek myth of Tihonus who was the lover
12 likesof the goddes Eos and a amazing guy because Eos begged Zeus to grant him immortality so they could be together
forever but forgot to ask for internal youth. Tihonus become immortal but continued to age, after a few hunderd years his size became a grape growing smaller forever.Maybe this is how alicorns die?
I just wanted to say your bow is so cute! And I think it gives something when you change your profile to the season! I love it😊❄️🌸🌼🍁
0 likesAnother thing that tends to complicate theories is that evidence suggests that Cadance was succeeded by Flurry Heart by the time of Luster Dawn, which implies that Cadance isn't immortal.
0 likesIts nice to see your still going! I have been watching you since 3rd grade and now im starting highschool- helped me feel not ashamed of liking mlp in middle school
0 likesA thing to note is that I would not share knowledge of apples that make you immortal, esp. in a world with people like Sombra Crysalis and others, as there are many people who really don't need to be immortal. Also, I don't think just not sharing these is evil, especially as we have no knowledge of how many grow at any given point. I can see your point of view, and why you'd think that it would be wrong not to share, I just think that there's too little information to make any form of harsh judgement against Celestia.
0 likesI like this idea but then again we saw that king sombre was technically immortal using crystals and tirek I think that comes down to him being a different species that can consume magic so maybe he can passively intake magic in small amounts from like breathing etc and chrysalis can a also be argued to be immortal since she consumes love and that itself could lead to temporary immortality and with Luna we saw her age just like cadence but the difference being that Luna manes flow so I think an alicorns “immortality” could be connected to their cutiemarks like celestia is connected to the sun Luna the moon Cadence the crystal heart and love and twilight connected to the stars and friendship aka platonic love and this brings into question mistmane who sacrificed her beauty but maybe she gained something more in return you know
0 likesYour kinda on point with that Greek mythology but Hera didn’t have a golden apple tree the golden apple was created by the Goddess of Chaos Eris for not being invited to a party thrown by Zeus she threw the apple up and the apple was used to say which goddess is the most beautiful.Three goddesses fought over the apple causing the Trojan war to happen.There is more about the story go and read it if you want to I didn’t cover all the points
0 likesWe could also take the magic from equestria flowing into the human counter part. We already know objects there have gotten magic like the mirror and phone so maybe something similar could appear there to.
0 likesYou put in so much research for your theories, so cool!!
23 likesQuestion: Do you think you'll tackle what happened with the Young Six in their stained-glass window pane?
0 likesMaybe the fruit is specific to the magic of alicorns, and are too dangerous for just any pony to use, I think it would also extend to other animals, like dragons because twilight is only like 5 or 6 years older than spike yet he doesn't seem to have aged too much. I don't know, but that's my theroy.
0 likesThey're powers could also just work with Alicorns. Like, something within their bodies or magical makeup or something.
0 likesFunny how the pony who has been alive over a thousand moons sort of happens to be a pony that is a royal and rules over all equestria who lives in a castle with a pet Phoenix and-
0 likesYeah, of course she has golden apples. What does Celestia not own that is part of mythology, excluding creatures? Well, we don't know... Who knows what random thing is just sitting in a basement...
this reminds me of something... STORY TIME!:
0 likesIn my defunct Horror-Hero Fanfic universe, that i still hope to do one day... Alicorns are are portrayed as a big more Powerful then in Canon, but at a price... a very harsh price.
In my stories, Twilight's Ascension happened as her in Canon, but the scene on "Da Otha Side" went differently... cuz her ascension was not planned, the version we got was just a story Twilight told her friends.
An Alicorns Power, Youth, and Longevity comes from them being somewhat Vampyric... they absorb life-force passively from everything around them, within their "Area of Influence"... Celestia, as the sole Ruler of Equestria, could Sustain herself by taking a Month off of everypony's Life expectancy in Equestria... how much life is passively absorbed depends on how much power the Alicorn is willing to Absorb as well, Celestia, having to manage the entire Kingdom AND the Sun and Moon(with the Moon resisting...), she became the tall, imposing figure she is in the modern Era as a necessity to fulfill he myriad duties...
Then Cadance showed up and unexpectedly became a Alicorn herself in a desperate moment via the power of Love, which fueled her Ascension... after Celestia found and explained the cost to her, Cadance opted to remain at a Minimum level of power, which is why she is much weaker then the others... and smaller.
She only lessened Life-expectancy by a few hours to a few days due to this.... then that burden was eventually moved to the already-long-lived Crystal Ponies following the Return of the Crystal Empire.
Which was great, because when Luna returned she cut Life Expectancy by another week at first... then by closer to three weeks when she achieved her starry-haired form.
Twilight's ascension was a little better planned, and the Ethereal Plane chat was prepared for in advance... But despite this, Looking into Twilight's eyes, she sort of.."Forgot" to mention the cost, she did not want to break her heart... which lead to a period of Twilight being constantly hungry, and eating a ton of Hayburgers(as seen in that one CMC episode.. Twily Time i wanna say? Not sure, been ages), and other Pony fast foods, never really getting any satiety... and wasting away...
Celestia had hope'd that Twilight would passively feed off the Exceptionally Potent life-force of her friends(at Twilight's current state... PInkie Pie could of theoretically sustained her with maybe seconds off her life, a more vibrant Life Force Celestia has never seen before) without her having to be Aware of it yet... but her nature pretty much cept her from siphoning PERIOD.
when Celestia finally Told her, Twilight was.. a little angry, but ultimately took the cost as a Challenge to overcome... it's also why she barely grew any in height, even compared to Cadance, during the show... she was basically on a starvation diet.
The plot proper would of started a little while after her Ascension, a few months, and coming to terms with her Curse/Blessing... shit starts going wrong in Equestria.... Luna, for all the good she's done since she returned, had always feared the creatures she created during the Nightmare War, that raged before her banishment, would return eventually with her up and about... sadly she was right...
One by one Tragedies befall the main cast... they all pull through in various ways, tho many of them aren't quite what they were before hand....
The only Fic i got finished was the "Iron Man" for this Fic Universe... a story about Zecora and a cursed she has bore for most of her life... she was basically a Ghoul, and never ate any sapient flesh, using potions and a Rhyme-based Meditation practice to abstain from Cannibalism completely.... She was going to be the first Monster-Pony recruited by Twilight into a "Night Watch" group to hunt monsters with those marked BY monsters.
Only ones that stayed the same were Fluttershy(whom has been managing her Flutterbat condition in secret for two years at this point), and Rainbow Dash, whoms the designated Badass Normal.
...No one is gonna read this, but i may just go Write the next fic now, so thanks for digging up a old idea i had since like season 3, Sawtooth!
Just a thought i had while watching this. What if the golden apples only grant you eternal youth or immortality if u are an alicorn/have magic from all three tribes. If u are only one you might get an extra year or two if u eat them but immortality or eternal youth is only for alicorns.
0 likesHi Sawtooth, i have a theory i' d like to share with you. Remember the princess of love who used a love potion to get a man? I think it was Crysalis sometime long ago. And she turned evil because of love.
1 likeNice bow, I love it. :)
1 likeThe golden apples might hold the key to eternal youth but you might have to be an alicorn to be able for the apples eternal youth powers to effective on you. Just like nectar and ambrosia would only work for the Greek Gods the golden apples could only work on a pony's body that was in complete harmony aka a pony who body had elements of all three tribes aka an alicorn.
0 likesThis reminds me of another immortal known as the "Kitsune Fox" (yes I'm a kitsune Fox) they are known to live past 1,000 years old as well as staying young with out any special food or water and the only way they can die is being stabbed in the Heart or by sacrificing themselves to save another
1 likeWhat do Celestia's golden apples do? Another tie to her solar charge, no doubt - 'the Golden Apples of the Sun'. Luna most likely has 'Silver Apples of the Moon' as well.
0 likesYou should read Robbe-Grillet's Recollections of the Golden Triangle. Apples feature prominently in the novels core themes
0 likesСпасибо,что выпускаете видео, сейчас это одно из того,что меня отвлекает, от того что происходит
2 likesHey hey, Here me out in G5. Twilight's friends died and this caused ponies of 3 species begin to fight, she tried to bring them back together but they wouldn't listen. She set up something in Heartswarming that included the 2 sisters and the 2 crystal empire princesses but it all went wrong and just made the situation worse. The windigos formed and since there is no known solution to this but friendship(she couldnt make bring them back together) she casted a spell that took her friends' hearts(not literally) including hers that took a the form of their element, Twilight combined the elements to the 3 crystals that we all know now. With the help of the other princesses' magic she managed to trap the windigos forever along with herself, the 2 sisters, Cadence, and Flurry.
0 likesTwilight combined Aj and Pinkie to be the earth crystal, RD and Fluttershy to be the pegasus crystal, and Her and rarity to be the unicorn crystal despite her being an alicorn. Thats why the 3 crystals can be apart.
Yeah, but since we have a theory that alicornship is something Starswirl the Bearded had invented to unite ponykind plus have someone to raise the Sun themselves, wouldn't that prove the existence of a "magical genetic engeneering" study there or something? You know, to make golden apples correspond to only alicorn DNA.
0 likesMaybe the golden apples could just be apples made of gold and she sells them to have money for all the costly repairs to the castle every time someone invaded and destroyed it in an epic battle.
0 likesI was sort of concerned when you started the golden apple idea however you added proof which was real nice
0 likesIt's a combination of alicorn genetics, and the golden apples. The golden apples interact with alicorn genetics differently than with other ponies.
7 likesI think its a bit close minded to say that Celestia is "evil" for not sharing golden apples of immortality. If everyone was immortal then Equestria would eventually be unlivable because there would be too many pony's. There wouldn't be enough food available either. Just because you have something doesn't mean you HAVE to share it. Certain things are better only in the hands of a select few. Sure it would piss us all off they had it for themselves, but depending on who had it, it would be for the best. I also don't think Twi would share it with her pals. Especially if Celestia told her not to. She is a HUGE rule follower, she would follow it even to the detriment to others. I like the idea of there being an golden apple and all but personally I think alicorns just have a much longer life span. A sort of by product. Or because the writers say so lol
0 likesThe Secret Ending At The End Of The Video-
2 likesAWESOME! :0
I’ve always had a hunch that something was going on 🤔 love the work you put into this 😁
27 likesI love the theories that saw -tooth waves make 🤩😎
0 likesYou know how you said in the shinning armor video that twilights friends won’t be able to live as long as her well that had me thinking about the crystals maybe twilight made them to bring her friends. But they’re different types of pony’s so she had to divide them to bring them together.
0 likesFor countless centuries, I've tried to discover the secret of the Golden Apple's gift of Eternal Youth, and ten thousand years ago I've gotten so close, but I used my last Golden Apple Tree about fifty centuries ago... for the remaining centuries I've been searching for more trees. And now, thanks to you, my little grey pony friend, I now know where to get another! And, because of you, Equestria will be laid siege to, then all Ponykind enslaved!😈😈😈
0 likesDude, This gave me the explanation i needed, I've been looking for answers since forever!, thank you! and new subscriber here!
0 likesI've been binge watching your old videos and their still enjoyable. It's crazy how much you grown through the years <3
1 likeReplies (1)
I'm on a road trip rn that's why I'm binge watching lol
0 likesI think that this is your best video so far. You must have worked a lot for this one.
0 likesImmorality doesn't prevent ponies from having foals, you know. If Equesrtia ever became overpopulated with immortal ponies, they would starve and turn in to something else, being unable to die. That is, before something else takes over and uses the ponies in experiments to discover the source of their immorality.
0 likesThat eyebrow raised edit, awesome!😂👍
0 likesSome people are arguing that star swirl has aged over time just because he looks old or something along those lines, but the magical recording of the whole banishing the pony of shadows shows that Starswirl didn't age between going into limbo and leaving limbo, and in the same episode it is stated by twilight "It (limbo) isn't one place or another, its in-between. So time stands still." And personally, I think when star swirl said "Even a pony like me who has lived a thousand years would think he has nothing to learn, but it appears I do have something to learn, Friendship." I think he was also referencing his time in limbo rather than just generally living that long
0 likesMaybe only alicorns are able to digest them! It’s very possible that because of the high amounts of magic that are in them that grant longer lives, they would cause problems for normal ponies. Kinda like how a blood overdose can be painful and even kill people/demons in demon slayer
0 likesWhen Sawtooth Said Celestia had an Extremely Powerful Fruit, Until It was Revealed to Be Golden Apples, I thought He Meant the Forbidden Fruit from The Bible
0 likesI don't think it's possible for two reasons. First Cadence: she lives really far away from Canterlot and I can't imagine how often she would have to go back to Canterlot just for a few apples. And now that she have Flurry she would need to go even more often !
0 likesThe second is why did Twilight age then ? Because in "The last problem" she's definitly older than when she sat on the Equestrian throne. I think keeping the normal pony size would be more intelligent as if she's treathned she could easily hide her alicornhood with a cloth.
5:50
1 likeWhat if celestia did use it
Back then when she was younger and naive
What if u can make a wish but there’s a price
Celestia used one but it made her sister go evil
So she had to trap her sister on the moon for 1,000 years?🤔
He’s so quick but so good at explaining like he dosent just be like: hey celestia has golden apples then moves on to the mane 6 in two sec sawtooth you so cool
0 likesI wonder if those 2 weird bits are gonna be explored any time soon felt a lot like a cliff hanger
1 likeFrom my theory we all know that the difference from ponys,unicorns,and Pegasus,and alicorns are alicorns magic so there’s a chance immortality has something to do with alicorn magic
0 likesI feel like twilight could have taken the magical abutment and changed the age of her friends so they wouldn’t die, ofc just once to make it fair
1 likeI'm really happy you uploaded! I found you again last night while I was tryna find mlp theories and I binge watched a lotttt of your videos. It was nice to wake up to this video especially because I had a nightmare. Keep up the good work Sawtooth, MLP is a part of my childhood and legit is my comfort show when I'm sad
0 likesHey! I found your channel initially about 6-7 years ago. After i fell out of love for the show, I forgot about this channel. But I’ve recently come back and rewatched the series and found your videos again! You’re still doing amazing, and i’m so glad you’ve stuck around!
1 like"How cruel would it be to have the cure for death but keep it all to yourself."
4 likes"Even if there was a spell capable of giving immortality [...] it would break the balance. Some would be immortal, others wouldn't. Mortals would begin to envy the immortal. There would be riots. If everyone were immortal, there would be no room for new generations. Equestria would be overcrowded and unable to feed everyone." -- Eveeka, TLA, page 25.
"Golden apples grants wishes to whoever eats them. [..] Surely we would have seen them in use by now."
Maybe... through very cleaver wording, it is why no permanent damage is ever done. Elements of harmony? Friendship magic? Nah, just a very carefully worded and timed wish. XD
"Everything just always somehow magically worked out for you, Celestia." -- Scootertrix, Episode 26.
As for Eternal Youth, I'm sure Rarity would love a bite. ;)
I love this theory. But have you still completed yeh theory of who the shadow pony was in the castle of the two sisters? I know it's a old episode, but it's still a huge mystery, atleast to me. If you have, could someone give me a link
0 likesIf it really was the apples giving them immortality, would Celestia bring them to silver shoals?
0 likesI absolutely love the theory, it sounds very convincing and is a very cool concept. I was honestly surprised when you had mentioned a hint to aboriginal Australian culture. I'm also black Australian, and not a lot of people know about our existence let alone our culture. As far as I have heard, but for you to point that out I knew you really do your research carefully! Keep up the great work Sawtooth!
2 likesCan you solve Rookhoof's mystery? Like why did he suddenly get visibly stronger?
0 likesNice bow ;^), and a great video! Loved it form start to end :^)))
1 likeI love that you decided to wear a bow for today’s video! So cute sawtooth
0 likesSawtooth is an underrated VA, their voice impressions are always on point
1 likeI love your videos your so smart the theories are awesome mlp is full of many mysteries so thank you for making it interesting ❤️
1 likeMaybe alicorns have to reach a certain age for a specific spell to become immortal or live longer lives than a normal lifespan because luna didn't age at all maybe while she was banished to the moon also a young alicorn like twilight no spell was cast on her as soon as she became an alicorn or really ever so maybe like 20 years later they'll cast the spell and maybe 4 decades for Flurry Heart to give her immortality
0 likeseven if they do provide immortality
0 likesthey would be cursed apples because at some point you would become bored,
apathetic,miserable
Celestia wouldn't be evil for keeping it for the alicorns.
I mean, I need to disagree that an item granting youth would be useless to your everydaypony. Let's be frank - being old sucks. It doesn't mattrer whether you live "only" max 80-100 years, downsides of age start hitting you around your 30's or 40's, so it would be great to not have to suffer from it, even if it didn't extend your life per se.
0 likesI’m just glad this side of her is finally getting addressed by someone :’)
0 likesOff topic but I am curious:
0 likesHas it ever been explained why Starlight Glimmer has not become an alicorn? Did she fail her studies or gave up?
Starlight is proven to be a very powerful unicorn, I doubt she would fail. If that is the case, why would she give up?
I have not seen all the episodes in sometime, so I might be going for stretches here, but maybe another explanation could tie into another theory.
It is theorised that Luster Dawn is Sunburst's and Trixie's/Starlight's daughter. What if Starlight gave up her studies once she saw Luster's magical potential? Maybe Starlight could still be consumed with guilt over what she did to the village. Maybe she saw Luster as a better candidate for being the next Alicorn Princess?
Replies (1)
Celestia and Luna did rule for a thousand years before making new alicorn princesses, at the end of their reign, maybe it is that Twilight planned to do the same?
0 likesWhen he said that Twilight could have share her diet of golden apple but she didn't because immortality is something that you can't share it made me think that maybe only alicorn can eat golden apples without getting sick, maybe the golden apples can be poisonous to normal pony or other creatures because if golden apples have magic maybe it takes all three pony magic to digest
0 likesThis is such a cool theory! I always love the feminine things in your hair! Sparkle ✨ 🦄
1 likeCelestia could of wished for eternal youth
1 likeYou know it’s a good day when sawtooth uploads
16 likesA Golden Apple a Day keeps the reaper away 💀
3 likesReplies (1)
Lol💀
0 likesCorrect me if I'm wrong, but in Greek mythology only the golden apples could be touched by the Greek gods because if a mortal touched it, they would die, so that could be another possible theory.
0 likesnope the reason celestia lived so long is bc everyone 50 years a pony lives celestia only gains 1 year
1 likeHi sawtooth could you talk about Princess Luna's Mark splotch? I'm going to make an assumption that the splotch isnt a part Luna's cutie mark because the splotch wasn't gone when Luna gave her magic to twilight . We saw that daybreaker now has a new splotch that Celestia didnt have before. is the splotch the cause of turning evil or was it just starlight glimmers imagination?
1 likeReplies (1)
It's a birth mark.
0 likesI was so happy when you did this video. Thank you so much 💕.
1 likeThe thing is though, only Celestia and Luna are immortal or just have extended lifespans, because according to everything else didn't the creators say Twilight aged and died shortly after her friends? She's not immortal by any means, but also seemed to not have had a successor (looking at the new generation) so really, I have no idea what's going on with the royal sisters.
0 likesReplies (1)
That was never confirmed.
0 likesI have a theory that golden apples only work on alicorns, because like you said alicorns are ponies that have magic from all three tribes, so alicorns and normal ponies might have a different biologies. And only alicorns can eat the golden apple because their biologies can sustain golden apples, while normal ponies can't and maybe when they eat golden apples something bad will happen to them(ex. they can die). But that's just my theor. (sorry if the grammar is not correct, english isn't my first language)
0 likesOmg I am so happy to be one of the first ones to watch this. Love your pony avatar, backstop
1 likeand voice and most of all your effort. The effort u put into you clone story, time skip story back story and this intro story. Luv ur work!
I click on the video and hear "forget everything you know about Celestia" lol
15 likesReplies (2)
who's celestia
7 likesvery good..
4 likesThis was an awesome theroy to think about but something else is on my mind...
0 likesWhat happened to t reck(goodness I can't spell his name correctly)Queen Chyrysalis and of course CozyGlow's Statue?
Where is it today in the new generation?
😅This keeps bugging my mind.... but yeah!
I just assumed that Celestia's power came from her ability to be tall enough to ride all of the rides in Los Pegasus! 🤤
4 likesThis would make a lot of sense referenced in multiple mythologies, even possibly Christian mythology though it's never explicitly stated there is a possibility it still exists though it's not the fruit that Adam and Eve ate, Because it wasn't even an Apple that they eat in that only gave them knowledge not long life/yourh
0 likesI like how we're talking bout this but not about the fact lunas hair started to move after she was saved from being nightmare moon but celestias hair was already moving before luna became nightmare moon
0 likesWhen I saw the title, I immediately thought "Dang, had Celestia gone full Dumbledore?" XD
0 likesi think if the golden apples were to gain immortality, twilight would make the decision to remain mortal, something that she would discuss with the other 5.
0 likesAh yes, this must be the long foreshadowed Celestia is secretly Grogar theory.
3 likesI HAVE BEEN BAMBOOZLED
OH MY GOSH YOUR BOW IS ADORABLE. Anyways, I remember you connecting mlp with mythology. This makes so much sense! ❤️
2 likesCool, but I have another question that might not be related to this.
1 likeWhy does Human Twilight have wings when she ponies up in the HUMAN WORLD, but not the pony world. In other words, shouldn’t she have NO wings in BOTH places because she isn’t REALLY an alicorn? Am I going too deep with this one?!
Wish granting items in fiction tend to have limits depending on where they come from too. I remember in DBZ that the pig character, can't remember his name for the life of me, suggested that they get rid of the sayians before they came to earth but Shenlong said that the task was not possible for him to do for whatever reason
5 likesMaybe they give you a mites touch and what ever you touch after eating one turns to gold
1 likeI’ve been a fan sense he had 100 subscribers. I’m actually proud, sawtooth
0 likesYou do a great job with these videos ^^ and the possibilities of each and every theory you claim really make us think :)
3 likesAlso what would a golden apple even taste like? XD
Replies (3)
thank you!!! well in the comics pinkie seemed to think it tasted especially good, so probably not like gold XD
0 likes@Sawtooth Waves thank goodness ^^ I don’t think I’d like the taste of something metallic in my mouth. And luckily I like apples so :)
0 likes@Luna The Angel golden apple tree?
0 likesI believe that alicorns can and will die, they just have much longer life spans because they hold magic from all pony species.
0 likesThat's true we always assumed long lifespan and different aging had something to do with alicornhood, but that's true that it was never directly said.
2 likesHowever I think immortality/long lifespan is not exclusive to alicornhood, if your theory about Starswirl being a thousand years old aside from his time into Limbo is right.
While I'm here, and I'm sorry to talk about it at each video, but I'd really like my theory to be acknowledged...
I'd like to talk again about my comment on the video about the forgotten timeline, the original timeline going on without Starlight, Twilight and Spike who traveled in time.
I wondered, if the time travelers ended up in a timeline that isn't theirs, tho identical, where are their alter egos from this timeline?
And the answer was easy to find, they traveled in time too.
That means they too created other timelines (probably the same ones as the original time travelers created, considering this timeline is identical to the original) and ended up in a timeline that isn't theirs but is identical. And in this timeline too, their alter egos traveled in time and ended up in an other timeline, and so on. That means from here, the timeline split turned into a timeloop that creates timesplits.
So from here there's an infinity of timelines created, supposedly of each outcome we saw in the series, including the one identical to the original timeline but in which the time travelers were there at the Rainboom. But there still is only one original timeline missing the time travelers...
And I'm so eager for this to be known because when I realized that infinite loop of timesplits I thought it was so big and MLP went too far into chaos... And because infinity is something that personally scares me, so thinking about it made me sick.
So I thought of a solution to abort this chaos.
I think likely that great minds and sorcerers as Starlight and Twilight (with unfathomably valuable allies as Starswirl, Sunburst and Stygian for example) would come to talk about such a big thing and spot the problem, and organize an expedition through the timelines to do so the time travelers go back to their own timeline after the final travel. Their travel would then apply in a timeloop where the otherwise abandoned timeline was actually never abandoned, and... it actually doesn't solve the infinite loop of splits.
But hey, it's a good start!
OR ELSE
The expedition could do so the last travel actually leads to the original timeline, to create a loop where the travelers were actually always here at the rainboom in the original timeline, and the new timeline that is identical to the original but is a separate one is not created, so there is no other timeline where Starlight, Twilight and Spike traveled in time.
There, time travel mess solved! I really hope you see this very too long comment, Sawtooth Waves.
Thanks for reading, and sorry about mistakes, English is not my native language and we talk about seriously complex things here...
i wouldnt say celestia is evil cuz she wont give immortality to everyone...perhaps only alicorns are "strong enough" to consume the Golden apples without negative effects/consequences?
0 likesWow! You never fail to amaze me! 🤯
3 likesAm I the only one that just never questioned celesta being alive for 1000 years
0 likesThe ancient Mythology that i learned is that Unicorns and Pegasus live longer than earth ponies and alicorns live up to 10 times longer than that. That would mean an average life span of 250 years!
0 likes4:21 Legend says that Applejacks eyebrow is still floation and going up in the sky and has reached the solar system😆😆
0 likesNow don’t take me wrong i love your theory but what if the so called “Golden Apple Tree” is just an apple tree with a spell put on it
0 likesBeing an Alicorn makes them stay alive and the apples make them look young
1 likeReplies (1)
Hey sawtooth
0 likesOh my, I can't believe that you managed to catch THE ONLY time the Apple Golden Tree is mentioned
0 likes@Sawtooth Waves Can someone explain to me why Twillight from the Human-World does have wings when she "Pony-Up" and doesn't have wings when she is in Equestria? Twillight from Equestria and Rainbow Dash from Human-World on the other hand has wings in both worlds.
2 likesReplies (2)
Because SciTiw isn't an alicorn; the wings were there because of the magic.
0 likes@Reese Yes, but if SciTwi isn't a alicorn why would the magic give her wings. Why hasn't she the same "Pony-Up"-Form as Rarity and Sunset?
0 likesI think Celistia's golden appel tree is just a golden apple tree... If it could do anything special, Twilight would have used it or mentioned it :-)
0 likesI think Immortality for Alicorns are Natural. There magic keeps them young. That's why they have magic waving hair
0 likesall i know is gapples give a strength boost and absorption hearts so maybe theyre like healing apples
0 likesI once read this book that has this alchemist that made a potion of eternal life, but forgot to drink the one for youth, some funny stuff happened when he finally remembered to drunk the one for youth
0 likesI think it comes with being an alicorn and some dark magic spell (sombra)
0 likesI'm still in love with his intro lol
1 likeWell I have a suggestion I think that when celestia banished luna to the moon she gained immortality from the elements of harmony
0 likesokay I need a story about what happened to flurry heart, in mlp new generation she's not mentioned or seen throughout the movie, while twilight has action figures of her and her friends. Flurry was put into stained glass in the last episode of my little pony. but where is she now
0 likesWhat about Luna/Nightmare Moon? She was on the moon for a millennium, and hadn't aged... Unless 'tia sent some to the moon every so often to keep her corrupted sister alive?
0 likesThank you for making these videos they keep us entertained I’m sure you work so hard thank you for working hard to entertain use
3 likesSo, going back to the alternate timelines, When Starlight stopped the rainboom did the main six ever get their cutiemarks? Because they got their cutiemarks because of the rainboom. So, would they have their cutiemarks? -Snowdrop
0 likesFun fact : opaline quotes this “ They should bow down to there IMMORTAL rulers.” THATS a big hint that your theory is wrong. I mean OPALINE has lived for so long maybe even before twilights time (maybe)
0 likesMy theory is that alicorn magic + the golden apple = eternal life that means Twilight was not able to give it to her friends.
0 likesCorruption lays deep in the heart of Pony bureaucracy!
1 likeBut why would celestia have a dark secret?
8 likesReplies (1)
Why? WHY?
0 likesIf you have to ask, you're not ready to know.
I'm confused why does Celestia have golden apples I mean there a golden apple tree well it a lifetime for Alicorns not Ponies tho but what if the golden apples help the ponies stay young or turn into an alicorns well it strange but it real for some people. I been a long-time viewer and how the quality of your videos improved is honestly inspiring. 🥰
1 likeThis was amazing but there is one thought in my head which is who takes care of the dream realm ever since Luna was gone?
0 likesThis video gives me ARG vibes. I don't know why, but I certainly enjoy it ^~^
0 likesAlso enjoyed the references to various mythologies. Maybe you can find a way to do a theory involving the fountain of youth and Tir Nan Og? I wouldn't be surprised if the Hippogriffs/Sea ponies have something similar to that
Thank you for finally using comics after all these years of me pestering you <3
0 likesOmg early I love your channel
5 likesAlso I appreciate how much effort you put in your videos it’s so amazing seeing your hard work
Replies (1)
Hey I have a theory
1 likeWait I have a theory:
Maybe twilight didn’t know about the golden apples maybe tia put the apple in her food without her knowing that’s why the rest of mane 6 aren’t immortal because tia Knew if twilight would know she would give it to her friends and tia only wanted alicorns to be immortal 🧐🧐🧐
I love the bow ❤
0 likesWhat if the golden apples give eternal youth to only alicorns and not anyone else
1 likeomg omg omg, FINALLY someone other than me noticed that spike said that. I probably noticed it years ago, and I wanted it to be talked about for all that time. Thank you Sawtooth!
0 likesI knew Celestia was the Ancient One from the cinematic Marvel universe and the first 10 seconds of this video proved it ;)
0 likesI think that alacorns are mortal and twilight just went through a Second puberty and grows into the big form we see in the final episode and there is some evidence that this is the case like the fact that twilight became taller when she became an alacorn and for the people who say "but twilight was an alacorn for years and we never see her grow at all" might I remind you that the cutey mark crusaders grow at all over the years of time that we see them so it is possible that twilight is growing and we just don't see it happening
0 likesI love your little yellow bow✨
0 likesalso, even IF her golden apples could grant long life or wishes, i dont think it would nessisarily be a BAD thing she didnt share them. think about what happens if something as powerful as everlasting life or wish granting was available to just ANYONE. or even if it was just public information. rioting, wars over this kinda power, people getting these powers that dont have good intentions, or at the VERY best, overcrowding or chaos. the world would be a dark place is EVERYONE could live forever or could get wishes simply by getting an apple from celestia. thats why if her fruit COULD do that, i could understand keeping it to just those who had important, over ruling jobs.
0 likesis the bow on your avatar new (i havent seen a video of yours in a while)? its cute :))
0 likesIt all starts adding up the Applefamily has been blacked mailed by celestia
8 likesReplies (1)
Omg
1 likeNew theory what if the mirror pool is in fact a window into other timelines and when pinky used it she wasn't cloning herself but instead grabbing pinkies from other timelines that didn't know her memories because they had different ones.
0 likesI was half expecting an army of PJO fans to rise but anyway, this theory isnt the most likely as there are villains and there’s discord. They have lived for like a thousand years but still. Great video!
0 likesIn the journal of the two sisters celestia and luna when they were just crowned alicorns they didn’t have there cutie marks luna said it’s normal for alicorns because we don’t age or something so celestia and luna got there cutie marks when they were alicorns
1 likeSaw tooth what was that little golden apple thing in the security camera thing at the end in the beginning great video by the way but I’ve got questions I hope next week you will provide answers
0 likeshey you know the celestia and luna in the human realm how are they alive when the pony world version of them were born around 111 years ago (princes twilight time)
4 likesOk I would like to talk about season 1 episode 11 because spike mistakes twilight for “mommy” We know that he doesn’t have a mom since we saw twilight hatch his EGG… So. You in for a theory?
1 likeTechnically, why using youth spells in a world where you can't die. In the show there is always a difference being made from creatures, like monsters, and animals -in fact, anything else-. What is carnivores animals eating? We never see them do. Spike eats stones. It seems that, even if it is for gags, all animals have intelligent and human behavior and act as how a kid would see them behave in some situations. Yes it seems great for marketing for children, but in terms of lore, it destroys everything you can build.
0 likesI say that because, in the episode where Starlight mess with the past and Applejack tell the war with the empire of Sombra, even great big and properly sized armies of ponies, with all the reasons to end each other, just punch themselves with no realism anywhere.
Ponies can't die. Anyone considered living
not timberwolvescan't die. In fact, even them can be undying, they may could respawn anywhere else in the forest if destroyed. Or any things else.In the Lion King when the hyenas have chased Simba one fall in the spiky plants and jumps out humoristically. We can imagine these types of moments are comedy, and the true story meant behind it is that it hurts really bad, but no one will remember that moment with fear or empathy for the hurt. 5 minutes or such before, and Mufasa died from fell damages, and possibly the repeated strikes of the herd.
The difference is made yet it doesn't answer any of its questions. It was made for youth too right? Why sometimes some things hurts but some doesn't?
A solution is to imagine the 'real'
actualevents being worse and bloodyas they realistically should be, because everything else is consistent with it, if not why having carnivorous or like dragon's big teeth if it doesn't hurt and make you die, plus if it eat stones why would herbs would be afraid of them in the first place?and what the camera sees is kind of a theatre show. Answering why Pinkie and Discord sometimes looks at the camera btw.I have difficulties imagining ponies and
other creatures, evenfeel pain. Why? How? In our world pain have been invented by evolution to let us know what is dangerous. Or let us guess, at least. Ponies have no danger. In the Maud's introduction episode when Pinkie Pie is stuck in rocks on the pile at the end of her race -strange for her to be suddenly in danger out of nowhere where she been barely touched by a dragon strike, Rarity says afterwards, "We almost lost her". Lost her to what? Wouldn't she just be a bit high-headed falling down the rocks in cartoon way having stars over her head? An overwhelming number of times the characters fall, are exposed to fire, blasts, or anything that would like, at least, hurt in a long consistent and lasting time. But they aren't. They are never. The big inconsistence stand when Rainbow is immobilized when she broke her wing. Multiple times all other characters would have took damages. But they never did.I think, following that statement, that magic prevent any beings to pain. Or actually, hurt. Or maybe it tries its best to avoid that. And that is also why Fluttershy exists. In the episode when she talks to the dragon, it submits to her. In a world where hurt exists, that makes no sense. It can be explained by the reason that its her magic cutie mark, and can resolve magically any animal situation. But wait. When way after that time, in season 9 I think, when Angel is jealous and annoying a wolf at Fluttershy's shelter, there is a difference between carnivorous and herbivorous. But. How. If no one dies. Where comes the meat? Why the dragon isn't just a mean dragon that have to be undone?
All the time the show have a big baddie, it never dies. Chrysalis flied when defeated. Sombra apparently where buried in deep rocks or idk. Why no single one can be done. It could be to give infinite comebacks in terms of marketing. But once again. The characters are living in a world where no one can, at my knowledge and maybe I've missed a few clue, die. How is that possible. And also, how scary that is. Discord, completely magically took energy from 1 dispute of ponies to comeback from stone. The baddies will surely do same. Very strange for Discord to return precisely when the 6 are formed. Like, what he was doing 1 year before. There must be some ponies having disagreements in from of the statue before? He is the lord of chaos. Couldn't he create an entire army or something? Whats with his dimension btw?
The population should go infinite by now. We never heard of decreases. Just, "once upon a time, in the past... Stuff happens". But wait. It means they still exists? Everyone ever existed should be still living in Twilight's future? Is oldness the only possibility to die? Twilight should have her great great great parents aside of her then? How only few licorns like the great bearded guy can make people eternal? What where before the known time, before him, before starswirl the bearded? Before Grogar named himself a thing?
Our would answer its existence before us. There been reptiles, dinosaures, big fishy creatures, and rocks and stuff. The problem with the magic of friendship and everything of that is itself. It doesn't works.
Windygos are ancient. But where are they from? Are they from the time 'the hurt have been ended'? Are they to counterwise the easy and peaceful life of anyponies since the birth of friendship and the magical 'everything is awesome' era?
Like, where does the lake of Pinkie's clones come from? Like. When?
I know its medieval yet, but ponies should be able to find stuff from before a couple thousand years ago. A civilization that may have ended hurt? Probably as time resistant as pyramids compared to us.
Yeah if the golden apples do grand wishes I will keep them hidden so they won’t be use for evil
1 likeIt could also be that the golden apples only work on alicorns.
0 likesIt's crazy how much time and effort they put into their videos for us to make our day or night even better they are such a hard working person and they deserve the best from us keep it up with the awesome work you're the BEST! 🙂
21 likesReplies (2)
I know right😃🥳👍👍👍
1 like@Nena Carreon 😀😀😀
0 likesI’ve got a question or a video idea (or both):
0 likesHow did Princess Luna’s hair change like other pony’s hair to he one that we see every other time with her except the first time we see her (it season 1 episode 2)
I got happy like " omg, maybe the mane 6 can be together forever ! "
0 likesAnd then it was crushed like an old mushy apple...
Hi! I have a theory and I'm wondering if u could do a vid on it?! When Pinkie and Cozy Glow interacted with Grogar's Bell, they both got insane power and Cozy became an alicorn. Maybe Celestia had a deal with Grogar at one point, or broke a deal? And that preceded the events of Clover the Clever hiding Grogar's bell, with Grogar stealing the bell from Celestia and then Clover stole it and hid it. Like maybe Clover was a friend of Celestia and Luna and was scared of what could happen if it got in the hands of the wrong creature, so she stole it after Grogar got it back to hide it
0 likesI think the golden apples mean Living forever I think it's kind of shocking But you don't get old really fast That's why They don't have wrinkles
0 likesIn my school vr game the character goalius doesn't age ( do to him being the son of both sun and moon princess and a living computer virus named evox) it was showed during the boss fight rush mission called saving lives where the tree was there but the apple had a odd affect where the boss sg blue/goblin/basilisk ( shattered glass) had one and it causes him to spilt Into 3 separate beings
1 likei love your springtime bow sawtooth!
0 likesRandom theory: Could Sunny be related to scotaloo somehow? they look alike
0 likesI freaking love the bow
1 likeI hope you do a video about the G5 comic of the characters finding Canterlot and your thoughts about it.
0 likesmaybe having magic from all 3 tribes gives you 3 lifetimes? Also, weren't the princesses (Celestia and Luna) alicorns before they saved equestria and she raised the sun? So she wouldn't have had access to the tree of golden apples to give her eternal youth.
3 likesI have a random question: I noticed that in one of the cutie mark crusaders songs they sang “we have hearts as strong as horses” this shows that horses exist in the mlp world but apple bloom isn’t one. what’s the difference between earth ponies and horses?!
0 likesMaybe the golden apples provide slight extra regenerative powers like golden apples from minecraft, or maybe the eternal youth like you said. Idk, just my thoughts
0 likesi have an another theory..
1 likemaybe the golden apple has a powerful power that only the alicorns eat it and have eternal youth.Beacuse Twilight would share with others if they could eat it.
or
some pony maked it so only the alicorns eat it and have an eternal youth.Beacuse if Spark know it so the other ponies know the golden apple.If everypony knows some ponies can use it fot their own advantage.So maybe some alicorn make it that powerful.-but which pony is that powerful?...
(what do you guys think?)
Something else to consider is that enchanted golden apple are better tan golden apples
1 likeI just love how this uploaded as I was about to get my niece and nephew into mlp lol
0 likesCan we talk about what if Sombra Joined The Legion of Doom
0 likesand Fought with Queen Chrysalis , Cozy and Tirek
Would they have win?
Fun Fact: Golden Apples DO exist in Equestria. In the Comics, Pinkie eats one that grants her every wish that comes out of her mouth
0 likesMaybe the magic only works on Alicorn Biology, anyone could eat them, but only Alicorns can harness the magic
0 likesCounter Theory the golden Apples are litteral GOLD Apples a magical kind of apple that developed a metalic shell to ward of insects and birds eating them
0 likesand Celestia was keeping them to keep the currency Stable (ignore the pun)
and as a twist there can be equestrian myths about those apples granting immortality because immortal celestia and luna have those apples
"How cruel would it be to have the cure to death, but keep it all to yourself".
0 likesBut immortality is more like a curse. That is not fun and cool. That is smth that can easily drive you insane. It would be GOOD to keep it to yourself, that would be an act of self sacrifice. If Celestia would ever have such apples, I can only imagine her giving them to the royal family and other important ponies until they find a replacement.
Hi Sawtooth, I have an interesting theory, what if the mane 6 (Of MLP 4th generation) are descendants of who they played in the season 2 hearths warming episode
0 likesI think it is only the life cycle of being a alacorn . Being youthful for only 1000 years or something like that.
0 likesThe only thing that would have made that end better is Tia's hoof stomping on the Apple core just as the camera cut out
0 likesHi Sawtooth Bloom! (Seriously the best cosplay you’ve ever had and I’ve been a fan for 3 years lol)
0 likesCel is my favorite character and she will always be
0 likesIt’s cool how it looks like sawtooth used an in show character
0 likesJust one question. Luna. When she was nightmare moon how did she not grow old. She was an alicorn. So how did Luna not grow old? Sure her dark magic may have been it but I just wonder
0 likesI think her golden apples only work on alicorns since only the alicorns have really probably had them so twilight’s friends aged without her?
0 likesI don’t know I’m just trying to make this make sense
This got dark fast- I totally missed spikes line and I've rewatched mlp many times.
6 likesWhat if the 'golden apple tree' isn't a 'golden apple' tree, but a golden statue of an apple tree? Like a fancy decoration? Kinda ruins the theory xD
0 likesI always thought that Celestia had intentionally kept herself alive so that she could see Luna's return, and then when she did return, she held on a bit longer so that they could make up for lost time.
0 likesAm i the only one whos going to ask why they have a bow in their hair?
1 likeYou're rocking it, not gonna lie 🎀
The journal of the two sisters says alicorns age different the princesses not only live longer but got their cutie marks later
0 likesI am a german and I also know more about german mythology than others at my age, but I don't know how and why changelings are based on german mythology. So if someone knows that, can he explain it to me?
0 likesSo... She is staying young forever because she eats a enchanted golden apple? Okay.
0 likesIf you actually made this your final video, like you said at the beginning...well, that advertising of darkness wouldn't be uncalled for.
0 likesGoing back to the new 5th generation movie, what if this isn't the future of the Equestria we know and love but one of the other timelines that starlight created, that would make sence why the main six don't exist anymore(this could be the one they left and the secound time they came around), or they do just not as powerful or famous, and the mural could be of when twilight left the time line with starlight, and it could have been T-wrecks timeline and Celestia made the crystals to give ponies some sort of magic agian, or the king Sombra timeline and the crystal empire was lost agian but without the northern lights magic started to fade and Princess Celestia made the crystals to keep the magic around just my idea I would love to see you make a video on this.
0 likesThese never fail to amaze me
4 likesActually mabey golden apples are so powerful only alicorns can withstand the power of immortality, that's why only royalty get golden apples.
0 likesi don't think it's true... it could just be that some alicorns can have eternal youth.
1 likeDo changelings have all pony magic and more types? All changelings appear to be alicorns in their natural state however Queen Chrysalis had a much more similar appearance to the pony princesses and ponies in general (normal eyes, long legs & horn, a mane) and also the first changeling to become nice, who is now the king I think, became leggy as soon as he became good (although I may not be remembering properly) so maybe leggyness is not directly connected with age? This is a bit random
0 likesReplies (1)
Changelings also seem to be able to use the properties of who or what they turn into, so do they have a special copying magic which allows them to shapeshift, or do they have all types of magic in them?
0 likes"golden apple tree" could also be apple tree that itself is golden so not like "golden-apple tree" but but "golden apple-tree"
0 likesWow.
6 likesThat an golden apple is behind
immortalityeternal youth sounds really intrigany.Also that we have seen lore of it in the comics has a lot of mean.
What if the golden apples grant wishes limitlessly? As if there is no rule about the wish, or depending the user's power the wish varies on power too?
So as Celestia is an alicorn she can wish eternal youth limitless.
Wow great video!
Replies (1)
Since this video started out with Celestia using Sombea’s spells I assumed this was going to direction that Celestia was using dark magic to stay young like Ancient One in Doctor Strange.
1 likeI don’t mean to be nit picky but changlings actually come from Irish culture and mythology not German. that is where they originated from, season two upwards to around season six-ish the series was taken on by cartoon saloon an Irish animation studio, when they where coming up with a new villain ideas they took inspiration from Irish folklore but instead changed the more gremlin like representation of traditional Irish Changlings looked like and gave them a bug inspired look instead.
1 likeMaybe the Princesses Live long and Forever but their looks age aswell so the golden apples just make them look younger?
0 likesMaybe the golden apples only cause eternal youth to alicorns, and if a unicorn, pegasus, or eath pony ate then, it would make them older?
0 likesMan that tree would be good for Minecraft speedrunning
1 likeThe whole Immortality/Eternal Youth thing might simply be caused by the use of Age Spells, we've seen in the Episode Magic Duel that they do exist, and that they can make one Older or Younger, so perhaps Celestia has been using them like once a year to shave a year off herself or something, creating the illusion that she's not aging, while also extending her own lifespan, granting her a personal Fountain of Youth, thus making her be a pseudo-immortal, but now that Twilight has taken her place, she may not need to use Age Spells, and can finally allow herself to grow old and finally die of old age, so that she may at last rest in piece.
3 likesDo you have a video of how their teleportation works?
0 likeswell quince tree has golden apple well yellow... and the quince tree is the mother tree of apple and pear trees... and there meant to be rock hard. (kind of remind you of a certain pony family)
0 likesI think her golden apples are just inedible
0 likesJust for looks in her garden lol
What happened to the Golden apple tree after the main 6 disappeared? What about Sunny?
1 likeAm I the only one who think about minecraft when hearing golden apples
4 likesAm I the only one who loves this videos and mlp in general but too scared admit it to my friends? 😂
0 likesHey did I mention that I saw, in Sunny’s (from the mlp G5 movie) house, Grogar’s bell? Also, btw now I think that, on the terms of the elements of DISharmony, maybe Grogar’s bell could be the element of selfishness or the element of cruelty? Just wait until I get my own channel…
0 likesMe: gets a theory for the golden apples
0 likesSawtooth:Says the theory I just thought about
Me:...... Why
Hello could you please explain princess’ celectia’s and Lucas family husbands ( celestia’s king hepheus ) older sis ( Ingrid) and other info because there is so many info about them but also so many fakes like twilight is celestia’s step doughter etc please do family tree + explanation please!!!
0 likesPersonally I think the golden apples do grant the wishes of those who eat them, however instead of the wish being able to be used for others the those who eat the fruit have to use the wish on themselves. And it could be a form of punishment for trying to replicate or taking the golden apple tree from wherever Celestia and Luna came from. It could also be a draw back since Equstria soil might not be the same as where the two princesses com from. So while the princesses want to help the other pony’s they can’t. The one question to ask now is why don’t Celestia and Luna just give the apples to the pony’s, let them make their own wishes, well perhaps that the apples only work with alicorns and not regular pony’s, Pegasus or Unicorns
3 likesI think you ARE right about the golden apple thingy.
0 likesOn a second thought. What if the last time line we saw. Was not from sunset shimmer, instead of daybreaker? I mean it would me possible. After all it took only a spell to reveal day break to us.
0 likesApple Jacks eyebrow SENT ME 😂
1 likeoh my god i love your bow 🥺🥺
4 likesReplies (1)
eeeeee thank youuu <3
1 likeThe golden apples are probably just rare and are used for medicine
0 likesOkay so I was watching a few episodes of My Little pony and I was watching the episode where Celestia and Luna's cutie marks are switched when Celestia goes up in the air fighting daybreaker and nightmare Moon she is Luna's cutie mark on both sides but whenever she flips it only shows it on one side and not the other so why is it on both in that specific scene
0 likesI like it. I don't know if I'll remember it, but I'll say it's canon.
0 likesI just thought about the zapapples and that granySmith said that they are magical but when they ate the apple and had no affect on them.
1 likeDon’t forget that in season 1 when Trixie had the alicorn amulet, she was able to do age spells and that was for the highest level unicorn
3 likesReplies (1)
I love this idea
0 likesI think it's effects are regeneration 2 for 5 seconds and absorption for 2 minutes
0 likesI'm a bit late to this party but what if the golden apples only worked on alicorns?
0 likesokay- but what if it's like ambrosia from greek mythology? normal people cant drink it without dying and demi gods cant drink too much or they die. so if might've been Twilights friends couldn't eat it without dying quicker then wanted
0 likesTheory: Remember that new MLP movie where there is a new generation, twilight was mentioned that she was not there anymore, maybe the golden apples ran out? Man i suck at making theory’s-
0 likes"I need you to forget everything you know"
5 likesWait, why did I click on this video again?
Edit: 我忘了怎用英语么打字
Replies (2)
What is a video?
2 likesyessss... excellent.......
2 likesI don't really know why theories exist, there fun to watch but I'm not sure the creator's intended to hide anything or dark theories in the series... it's just a kid's show about magic pony's and friendship
0 likesHow would you eat a golden apple though? I think my teeth would explode before I make a mark...
0 likesI think the apples have something to do with the apple of Eden. Like, nopony is allowed to eat from them and if they do, they'll be bucked out of equestria
0 likesActually, The REAL reason why Celestia lives so long is because every 50 years, and alicorn gets 1 year old. Thats why she lives so long. According to google, actually. the other thing is that she can live up to 8,000 years.
0 likesMaybe the Golden Apple Tree grows apples made of pure gold; not good for eating but are instead a symbol of prosperity.
4 likesYou're awesome Sawtooth!
0 likesMaybe Celestia apples give her powers when she eats it or turn her into a alicorn
0 likesAlicorns and a golden apple have been given immortality and youth. Does that go the same for princess Luna and princess Cadence. 🤔🤔And what about Discord. Discord said he was" centuries old" plus the fact that he been stuck in a statue when Luna and Celestia keep him prison in stone.
0 likesI think that the golden apple helps to make celestia and Luna have eternal life
0 likesSiblings? One associated with the sun and the other associated with the moon? The favored one being the sun one? Some kind of darkness takes over the moon one? And now, the sun one being associated with golden apples? Sounds awfully familiar.
6 likesReplies (5)
I know right? I really feel like those other siblings shouldn't have to be skeletons though. Nevertheless they are pretty cool and I was just about to comment the same thing.
1 likeDream and Nightmare are just Celestia and Luna but in the context of the undertale multiverse.
1 like@Katie Dizon fun fact: despite the Dreamtale comic/animation going to continue having Dream and Nightmare as skeletons for the sake of recognition and consistency, they are canonically humans now.
1 like@CrystalKitty1220 Wait really? I was just thinking that it would be better if they were alternate versions of Frisk and Chara or humans at least yesterday. How did you know? Where can I find it?
1 like@CrystalKitty1220 Do you mean that they are now skeletons because they were once humans or?
1 likeits possible, and i think ur right about the Eternal Youth. and I think Starswarl gave her it.
0 likesmaud pie said that, 'with the right stone, you could rule all of equestria, if you wanted', and tia wears a gemstone round her neck...
0 likesWait before I watch the rest is she like the ancient one from dr strange and uses evil magic to keep herself alive and young.
0 likesOMG OMG IM EARLY
4 likesReplies (2)
so am i
2 likesthanks for the heart 😭❤️
0 likesThey could keep her mind flowing
1 likeMaybe Celestia told Twilight the apples help alicorn magic and are dangerous to non-alicorns
0 likesSpike didn't say Celestia had golden apples. He said she had a golden apple tree.
0 likesHe didn't say what colors the apples were.
Maybe only alicorns can consume them and normal ponies will not be able to endure their magic.
0 likesTherapist: The MLP version of film theories doesn’t exist, they can’t hurt you
3 likesThe MLP version of film theories:
Replies (1)
Yep
0 likesJust turn around
1 likeThey are literally right behind you
I like your bow tie, it's cute x3
0 likesI love your bow by the way.
0 likesThe golden bow in sawtooths mane and wings... Huh-?
0 likesI know since theyre a changeling they can just change their appearance as per the episode for the theory but..
I don't? Get why a yellow bow and wings have anything to do with golden apples :squint:
She has sunspots
5 likesReplies (2)
I know
1 likeYou may just be right
1 likeGame theories:finally a worthy opponent,our battle shall be legendary!
0 likesWhy does thorax get to be the king chrysalis served the hive longer than he has way before he was even a hatchling. Maybe for honering his late big sister larynx.
0 likesSooo I want to say something I have discovered its that sunny looks like scootaloo so I think she married sunnies dad and sunny was born which explains a lot about sunny so would you try to talk about this
0 likesYour biw is really cute :3 and this is interesting theory, definitely something i havent thought of
0 likes4th
3 likesMaybe Celestia only keep it to herself and Luna
0 likesSo in the MlP G5, there is no Twilight to be seen
I love your videos! Plz update your channel more offhan
1 likeMy only question about this video is
0 likesOK you’ve done your research
Clearly
But just why
Think about it for a minute
Alcorns or a mixture of all three tribes
And you know some very powerful ponies
Celestia and Luna themselves
StarSwirl
Starlight
And even twilight
If stars world can make things to go back in time
Wooden starSwirl will be able to give a spell to make them last Youthful for eternity?
You know they’ve been around when the princesses were Really young
So when they became rulers wooden stars will be like
“ if they’re gonna be the rollers they need to last for a long time
I’ll make a new spell?”
Don’t you think that might be an explanation to
Back on the golden apple topic
I have no reason for them existing
Maybe Celestia was bored one day and it’s like
“ i’ll make a golden apple, they’re shiny why not?”
But of course that’s just me you have your own opinions
Sawtooth i have a question on luna cutie mark look at here she has a moon but with a black mark around it and thousands of years ago she did not had that black mark so what is going on please do a video on this love you Sawthoot
0 likesMaybe they're literally made of gold.
0 likes"Destroys Golden Apples"
1 likeI have a new theory idea! The rainboom was what caused the main 6 to come together. And rainbow dash was the one who made the rainboom. But what did the others have to do?
0 likesLets talk about King Sombra...
0 likesAnd about What if he Fought with The Legion of Doom?
I think they have some kind of healing ability
0 likesI think that maybe its a combination of the magic of the tribes and the goden apples
0 likesDark magic is just a trick that probably only alicorn can do, it probably didnt have anything to do abt their age
0 likesif the golden apple make people immortal then all the pony there can just become immortal, if twilight knew this she could give it to all her friend and people who needs it, ok maybe they didnt say a word to twilight but what about luna and cadence
not all alicorn immortal, in fact it was probably never (except MAYBE for flury heart), being a alicorn just make u life longer than any pony does (but idk)
Sorry fir typos
Oh wow I never thought of this before, so awesome!
0 likesCan you do a video about Luna? I love Luna 💕
0 likesCan we just appreciate how much they probably work on their videos?
1 likeThese videos are stunning and im a mlp fan :D
0 likesI think you're right but I also think that non alicorns bodies can't handle it.
0 likesits because most people cant handle the fruit of immortality.
0 likesand she exists to protects you guys.
and if everyone is immortal and keeps having babies there's gonna be to many people.
they aren't bad, they want what's best for you.
you might freak out living to long...
i think its being given the Title..
maybe its like One for All.
That eyebrow is raised alright 🤣
0 likesHaven’t watched the video yet but i assume that celestia steals life for other ponies
0 likesEdit: Yup this comment Did not age well
this may be true. all the proof you have is convincing me anyways!
0 likesTwilight didn’t know about the golden apples so that’s why she was gone in the recent generation
0 likesGold apples look so great.rich pony’s should have them.
0 likesI love your bow!!
0 likesOne thing that makes this theory toast, Cadence rules the crystal empire and there are no trees or plants there, even outside the crystal empire there's just a train stop and nothing else. You could say cadence could leave the crystal empire and go eat those golden apples, however in the episode Princess twilight sparkle, the gaurds say 'Cadence overseeing the empire' which probably means she doesnt go outside to eat those apples.
0 likesOk sawtooth now this is odd
0 likesIn new generation pony’s had no cutie marks but in tell your tale charters like zipp have cutie marks
Can you make a theory about that?
Technically if they do have they will not share it because nobody love to live forever the only reason the princess live longer it's because they have duty and it's pretty rare to came across a successor to be a princess
0 likesMaybe golden apples are very magical, and of the ponies, only Alicorns are able to withstand such powerful magic, they are adapted to powerful Magic.
0 likesWhen I saw the befening of this vidio with the apples and immortality I thought of the golden apples spike talked about celestial golden apple tree
2 likes. But you already said that, lol.
Replies (1)
Ooooo! Sawtooth! I can't belive you likes. I absolutely adore everything about your vidios!
0 likesThe raising the eyebrow thing was so funny. 😂🤨⬆️😆
0 likesI just thought of a theory. It kinda explain why their a 7 elements. What it is and where it in pony world
0 likesThe 7th element of harmony is redemption / forgiveness (both work).
The element in pony world got corrupted and became alicorn armlet . That why it the the only one.
In the original friend/creator of elements of harmony/ the pillars. The 7th is Stygian
In pony world it starlight glimmer
And human world it sunset simmer
The reason they belong to different people is because time twist and that why it belongs to different people . If u think the idea work just see if u can find more evidence and just mention me
Is anyone else confused why he’s waring a bow?
0 likesHey sawtooth! I was wondering if you've even done a video on the kirins?
0 likesSawtooth waves, how did you get your wings?
1 likeI have a question how did chrysalis (idk how to spell it) turn it a changeling? How did she start all of the changeling war?
1 likeReplies (1)
She was always a Changeling.
0 likesIt's celestia's magic alicorns keep their faces normal ages
0 likesOmg I love it great job ❤️ dude I've been watching you far Year's now 😂
0 likesWhat if they are wish granting apples, but there aren't a ton of apples? Like one apple every 10 years or even 100 years? And what if that rare apple was used to bring Luna back?
0 likesWhen twilight took over she said it’s time to go away because she got 100 years of life
0 likesI MEAN... i dont see this as a DARK secret... just a magic secret. i saw this title and thought she was like.. sacrificing ponies or something XD
0 likesGetting scientific here. Things age and then die because cell reproduction doesn't work as well anymore. So eternal youth would mean eternal good working cell reproduction and that means the body has no biological reason to die. This is a show about magical talking ponies though so 😂
0 likesor probably the golden apples work only for allicorns bcs they are special?
0 likesi think immortality is just of alicorn magic.
0 likesGolden apples do exist. Eight gold ingots and one apple :p
1 likeCan you do a theory video about why the writers of the MLP FIM show decided not to give Spike the same kind of character development as the Mane_6 since he's the male protagonist of this show despite being a Dragon and not a pony? The only thing I don't understand is that why did Celestia give Spike to Twilight Sparkle instead of returning him to the Dragon Land after he hatched from his egg. Why does Spike even exist in this series if he can't be treated like an equivalent to Twilight and her friends which makes them jerks and racists for not having any kind of sympathy for him?
0 likesOut of topic
0 likesDidn't Celestia have a pet phoenix in that 1 episode? What happened to it? Irrelevant?
Ok so true gold apples, and not the golden delicious variety of apples are said to be from the realm of the gods. And alicorns are sometimes considered to be gods and goddesses. And from this stems the belief of eternal youth and immortality. Only alicorns can eat these sacred apples, because for a normal pony to eat one would be detrimental to them.
0 likesCadance and Flurry Heart would have to come to Canterlot on a regular basis in order to have some of these apples in order to truly sustain themselves.
While Luna was on the moon she couldn't have access to the true gold apples, however what if there was a similar true silver variety of apples that was available for her to eat and sustain herself with.
I have a theory
0 likesMy Theory is that in the mlp universe the sun and moon had rotation had but one day a powerful alicorn/unicorn tempered the sun and moon tempered the rotation and it couldn't be fix for thousands of years
Nah bro they op. They give you fire resistance, more health, healing bro they epic
1 likeI dont think celestia can give others golden apple of eternal youth because the poulation would be to big
0 likesIn Chinese stories golden apples take centuries to grow so they can’t be mass produced so she can’t share the apples with everyone
0 likesI think maybe if this theory was true the golden apple maybe only celesta knows, maybe she is putting them in food. They don’t know but that why ( just a theory )
0 likesIs it just me or is Celestia way weaker than she is described as 💀 like, she lost to a single changeling yet a unicorn could take an entire kingdom of them 😂
0 likesReplies (1)
fr
1 likeEarly villains be like
0 likesLaughing during lighting
That was pure lol
Been loving this Channel for years wish I had enough money to be an alicorn but still watch every vid religiously and I’ve just been mind blown seen almost every vid a million times ❤️❤️❤️❤️
0 likesthis isn't on topic but if you would notice this comment i would be surprised! so theres this thing ive been wondering about g5. if all the tribes hate each other whats up with the windigos? if they feed on hatred, shouldn't they appear anytime soon if the g5 universe is the same one was g4's?
0 likesi haven't watched the movie but if there is any info on it in the movie i would be surprised at least. maybe you could do a video on that?
Are unicorns/Pegasus part earth pony or 70 percentage of an alicorn
1 likethis is a cool theory, and one thats probably accurate
0 likesits been said alicorns live up to 1000 years or more and so far its kinda been proven ish
0 likeshonestly golden apples is te most logical explanation rn considering that mlp in fruits is known to be apples and the grand galloping gala
0 likesActually I think you know there's a new movie of my little pony you see when twilight got older sun and moon wasn't able to visit her so maybe can you make the new theary
0 likes* lip smack * my favorite thing from mlp, the changlings, are German based? I can just imagine what they would do at a gustavs...
0 likesGotta say, thats a pretty solid theory.
0 likesMaybe there used as a crafting material for the royal guards?
0 likesSawtooth Waves
1 likeМожно я переведу ваши видео на русский?(да,такие уже есть,но никто давно не переводил,точнее не все видео переводили,я хочу,чтобы все были на русском)
Естественно с указанием автора, если важно могу указать канал на котором собираюсь делать переводы
I think she is an evil, extraordinarily powerful conquerer, and there is lots of evidence to support it. I am thinking of making a video on it but.. it might be a while as im still new to youtube and have no animation or editing skills.
0 likesin my HeadCanon
0 likesit's who ever wears the crown, (a.k.a. who ever rules Equestria)
shall live as all as they rule
when you are no longer the ruler,
you'll start ageing normal
ive been watching this dude sense i was five and he STILL posting!!!!!!!!
0 likesEveryone : discussing about the video/ other thingz
1 likeMe : looks at Applejack
Applejack’s eyebrow: ascending I BELIEVE I CAN FLY I BELOEVE I CAN TOUCH DA SKYYYYYYYY
What if they’re immortal bc they’re the queens of equestria just asking
0 likesCelestia grows golden apples because obviously see likes her food real CRONCHY
1 likehow does princess celestia have a nephew, he made an appearance once and was never talked abt again
0 likesI’m at 3.54 and I haven’t watched the whole video yet but does the golden apple thing mean Luna uses them too?
0 likesHello i have a question . How did they become princess and how did they convince them to believe in friendship. They just couldnt just came and become princess
0 likesDid anyone else notice Sawtooth's new wings? Hmm...
0 likesme and my roomate, muledonkey love this toot. nice mustche. yum fruits.
1 likeCan You Make A Video Explaining Why Cadance Is The Only Alicorn That Doesn't Have A Dark Side?????
1 likeReplies (3)
...that we know of...
2 likes@Th3_Jelly_OnE They mean, Cadence may have a dark side that we might never see. The only time we see a dark Cadence is in the comics, but that was in the mirrored world.
1 like@Sawtooth Waves I Kept Commenting The Same Subject In SEVERAL Of Your Last Videos This One Was The First Comment
1 like\/
Isn't It Weird How Every Princess Has A Dark Side In Different Realities
EXCEPT For Cadance
Why Is That?????
Edit: PLEASE MAKE A THEORY VIDEO ABOUT THIS
Yayyyy Sawtooth Waves! :D
0 likesNo offense but remember when Sawtooth had a basketball head? Things have amazingly changed-
0 likesHm i think celestia is keeping the golden apples for themselves because they are from a special seed that takes a long time to bloom?
0 likesIf nightmare moon was an Alicorn and trapped in the MOON for 1000 years
0 likesThat means there are no goldden Apple trees so how is she the same age. When she was first trapped in the moon??
rarity would beg to have some golden apple brunch tho
0 likesBe careful! They might got you!
0 likesWhat if the Golden apple 🍏 heal injuries and illnesses
1 likeListen man.... I think applejack would know about any enchanted legendary golden apples. Cuz you know.... Apples are her thing... And her familys thing.
0 likesMaybe it would be a legend and Applejack only knew it as such so Spike would still want to show it to her.
Maybe the Golden apples only work on alicorns
0 likesWhat would happen if this sort of thing was explored in MLP_G5?
0 likesWhen he says golden apple my mind goes straight to Minecraft 🤣
0 likesWhat if only alicorns can handle the powerful magic that makes them immortal and regular ponies can’t eat them because they can’t handle all that power
0 likesLoving the vh music in the background 🤩
1 likeHaaaaaaaang on...is there overarching lore in the Sawtooth videos now? 👀
0 likesIf they can't stay young without appels then it would explain why Twiglight disapear in the Netflix movie
0 likesI have a video Idea and a theory
1 likeSunny is luster moons daughter
I mean they do have some similarities but like I'm not a hundred percent sure
What kind of 🍎 can grant eternal life?!?!?
0 likesDid you notice...
0 likesSawtooth is now a pegasus!!
( sorry idk how to copy and paste time) at 3:39 you can see that he clearly has wings :) in " The truth about poison joke" he was an Earth pony...
Unless you're a changeling and can change from pegasus to earth pony to alicorn :)
If the California is a mix of all three tubes it would make sense if they had 3 times the life span but then again that's just a theory a sawtooth waves theory
0 likesOk ok, but i feel like Princess Celestia is using a spell because I mean she has access to all of the magic because of the magic Scrolls in the castle that she lives in so she probably has access with spell that could keep them looking young forever I agree with the rest except for like that she uses apples or fruit to look young
0 likeswhat if only alicorns can eat them because they are made of gold
0 likesIt is possible that Golden apples contains too much power for ponies that are not alicorns or there is a limit for the golden apples
0 likesCelly found a notch apple in a nether fortress lmao
0 likesalso notice that cadance, luna, and twilight did age up even though theyre alicorns
0 likesIn mlp canon Luna and her sister are the Moon and Sun respectively btw
0 likesIn the whole video I was just thinking about Minecraft's Golden Apple! 🤣🤣
0 likesand i think Celestia's golden apple only give 2 extra heart😅😅
But think that if there's Enchanted golden apple! it's very op! 😅
I'm wondering, what happened to Sunny's dad from the new movie - My Little Pony A New Generation?
0 likesIt also happens to be in possession of minecraft, when consumed it gives players extra hearts but only for a limited time
0 likesThe could very easily be immortality apples and if so she wouldn't share them cus it's a curse living forever watching every one around you die that's not something you want many the royals ate one without knowing twilight was probably stressed with work found the tree stoped for a snake to relax as for the princess they could of found it as fouls many it only activate when there older
0 likesCan you do a theory video about what happened to all the creatures from outside Equestria like Griffins, Hippogriffs, Yaks, Changelings and Dragons in the MLP G5 universe if it's even in the same universe as MLP_G4 since they we're welcome in Equestria in the MLP FIM show?
0 likesReplies (1)
They're not going to do that yet.
0 likesHey, did you release a theory video that wasn't not only completely off the rails but riding off into the sunset after taking out half the train station?
0 likesI'll have you know I won't stand for this
Is Somnambula a Cleopatra mare? She has the make up and even the headress of a Cleopatra...also...what is a Cleopatra?
0 likesCelestia eats the apples for fire resistance and absorbption
0 likesWait why is Celestia’s Horn magic golden
0 likesI am so happy you finally posted a video and I think that your thoeries are amazing!!!!
0 likesThis made me wonder if anypony had tried to combine Assasin Creed plot with MLP…🤣🤣🤣
0 likesinhale AAAAAAAAAAAA
0 likesFellow changeling... Your freaking amazing!!!
Love the bow btw
Mabey she did not used a golden Apple mabey she used some kinda spell to keep her young and what about Luna she lived as long a celestia there sisters after all mabey she used a spell bc mabey she needed to be alive to rule before she met twilight first celestia made twilight her pupal then princess of friendship now celestia retired and now twilight is ruling
0 likesbut, did anyone mentioned they are immortal in the first place
0 likesit could just mean she has a big orchard of golden delicious apples
0 likesWhat if her golden apples only affected alcorns even if the main six eat the apples they won’t be affected by them
0 likesSeeing the apples
1 likeMe:Sawtooth waves what have you done
One Of The Small Clips In The Begining Of The Video
1 likeSawtooth Pretended To Be One Of The Flim Flam Brothers
Interesting and cool vid. Interesting thoughts. Interesting ending.
0 likesWhat if celestia let twilight on her little secret so she could have youth forever?..
0 likesactually no, the finale disproves it
0 likesMAYBE they make their hair glisten 😂
0 likesAw I love the bow💛🎀 and the research you do
0 likeswhat I Think Is That They Give You All The Potion Effects You Get When You Eat AN Enchanted Gapple In Minecraft!
0 likesI never knew that the changelings were German
1 likeCries in being broke, also theorys are amazing as always
0 likes….AUNT TIA?!(concerned and to find her aunt celestia to ask this as a question)
0 likesWell what you could be saying is true but I have two possibilities number one maybe it Earth it lies around Celestia's big fun Sun cutie mark maybe she has golden apples actually keep her life and she Pat she passed it on to Luna and Luna passed it on to Cadence who is Pastor Don to Twilight so on so forth and after that Best Buy idea my other idea is basically again and it lies around Celestial fun maybe instead of keeping golden apples her alive their cutie marks Twilight keep studying and studying and studying wow no one and Luna keeps breaking the moon rise in the moon rise in the moon like she keeps Rising the sun rise in the sun rise in the Sun Amna and also Cadence shoes the Crystal Empire Yeti out of gotta think it's possible
0 likesUmmmmm ok not wanting to be against the information you have given us
0 likesBut
What about luna?
She was stuck in the moon for 1,000 years doesn't that mean that she never had access to the apples on the time and she would have died?
But she did not
She is still alive
Good theory, but what about Luna? She has been stuck on the moon for 1,000 years and comes back with youthful skin.
0 likesReplies (1)
She was sealed within the moon, not on the moon itself.
0 likesAnother sawtooth conspiracy...
0 likesHeres a conspiracy for you- Sombra is a ponified version of Putin because Twilight traveled back in time and then came to earth and banished a piece of Putins soul to ancient equestria!(I don't know if that's insensitive. if it is I will totally remove it)
Can you make a video telling about what the heck happened to the mirror/portal to the human world.
0 likes"Eternal youth"
0 likesSawtooth how can you explain twilight and her friends being dead in g5
Replies (1)
they did a video on that already
0 likesWell done sawtooth Waves I may have agree with you on this love your pony oc I'll see you on the next review video
0 likesSoo great and interesting video!
0 likesThere's another myth with immortality granting fruit in Journey to the West, the monkey king eats all the immortality granting fruit. P.s. I like your wonderland theme especially the bow. Wonderland really correlates with the fact it's Autism Acceptance month. 🙂
0 likesWow that was a lot to take in and to tell the truth I kinda wanted to see that golden apple tree
0 likes“A fruit forbidden to but those in power you may think I’m crazy”
0 likes✨capitalism where EVERYONE wins! except you
I was watching an old video and it makes me ask what happened to the treehouse of harmony and all the other species we didn't see anything of them in the future world
1 likeIm pretty sure celestia said that when your a alicorn you live longer
0 likesReplies (1)
She never said that.
0 likesJust like golden enchanted Apple's in Minecraft it gives you IMORTALITY for 30 seconds
0 likesWho is to say it was public knowledge? Spike might just not know how important it was.
0 likesYeah wouldn't it be funny to eat a golden apple and then you never get older. (or if your old you get young and never age.)
0 likesYou think Cosy Glow ate one of those apples?
0 likesCan u do theories on dinosaurs in equestria?
1 likeLol the whole time I was waiting for an APRIL FOOLS 😂😂
0 likesBruh what is the golden apples cause their hair to be moving like that lol I know it's just a joke but Cadence doesn't live in Canterlot (so she doesn't have access to the gloden apple tree i guess) and her hair is not moving the way Celestia's, Luna's and then Twilight's does
0 likesOr the golden apples only work on Al acorns
0 likesJust because alicorns are immortal doesn’t mean they can’t be killed! *reloads gun*
0 likesOk, if the golden apples do give eternal youth but only to pony’s that are already immortal, such as “alicorns”.. Couldn’t sunny the new Alicorn go get these apples. Or if her alicorn status is temporary could she still eat one and have eternal youth because she still has magic from all three tribes? Do the apples still work. Do they count as relics? Does celestias garden/castle/tree even exist. What about outside of equestria. Where they effected?
0 likesThen makes the question
0 likesWheres Twilight in G5 future
I think AppleJacks eyebrow went to Starlight’s multiverses
0 likesBut it would be cool seeing the mane 6 all tall and stuff
0 likesThought if I just thought of a theory where are the other three villains because we don't see them anywhere in G5 and also one villain that knows how to suck magic and flight out of ponies just a little theory I just thought of
0 likesWait…
1 likeWasn’t he invisible last video…?
What happened with that…?
Heyo, so… I’m a newfound Brony as of maybe 2 months ago, and Sawtooth’s channel is the only form of large piece of the community that still seems to be around. Does anyone know any other places that one can converse with their fellow brony?
0 likesMaybe it’s like the golden apple from Minecraft? And maybe when you eat one you’ll just gain more live spand bc when you eat one you’ll get few more hearts.
0 likesOh yea…. Raise an eyebrow… NOT INTO OUTERSPACE!!!😂
0 likesAnd that’s how applejack lost an eyebrow , people !
0 likesWhat happened to the sisters in the human world in the pony world Luna was banished to the moon but was brought back by the main 6 there is no main six in the human world until twilight came so what happened to Princess Luna? This is one I think you can do 👍✨
0 likesWow! You really flipped my mind around...
0 likesBut if alicorns live forever why would Celestia and Luna retire? Also what's with the bow...
0 likesWow this went dark real quick sawtooth
0 likes4:22
1 likeLmao
Raise an eyebrow
if celestia had a golden apple which made her long lifspan,how about the human world,how did celestia life for a 1000 yeras without magic
0 likesIt's weird no PONY has ever eaten the goldden Apple's only the royal do so what's the Pont if there's so many of them on the tree and WHO the heck CONTROLS the STARS I think it's twilight because HER CUTIE MARK is a STAR itself and did celestia give twilight Alicorn powers to make the crystals because twilight did not do anything about it until.... she made the crystals so twilight was never an Alicorn
1 likeSo... let me get it straight CELESTIA KNEW TWILIGHT NEED ED THE ALICORN POWER NOT JUST TO RULE EQUESTRIA BUT ALSO TO MAKE THE CRYSTALS
AT FIRST I DIDD NOT NOW EAL GOLDDEN APPLE TREES ARE REAL
AND
I THINK BACK AT CELESTIA AND LUNAS HOME YOU SAID WHEN THERE READY TO GO home they can finally meet the family slow-mo: OR EVEN CHILDREN
that's what i Mena and I love your videos
And your amazing and how do you know about mall so much? And that was my last word ok I will stop commenting I been doing this for so long I just started at morning and now it's midnight ok it's my bedtime and I am sleepy ok bye I love your vids and I love mlp
Why do I get excited when you post?🌚
0 likesAye been waiting for this one good work saw keep it up😎
0 likesI love there videos there so amazing at it and all there theory's make scene
0 likesMaybe only the princesses/ alicorns can digest the apples and if anyone else tries it’s poison
0 likesDid celestia give twilight Alicorn powers to make the crystals because twilight did not
1 likeDo anything about it until.. she made the crystals so I think twilight was never an Alicorn because she was given the Alicorn powers just to keep some magic left in equestrian so she was never an A-a-Alicorn
Replies (1)
twilight became an alicorn because she created new magic
0 likesCelestia is Notch confirmed
1 likeWhat’s with the Apple in the title?
1 likeEdit: after watching the video I see why
Hi...not relatable but i was playing My little pony Magic princess and then something came out...characters from comics that have representing elements,i google the place and its so hard to find,its called The Kingdom Of ORNITHIA,i think its Captain Celaeno home..theres a lot of elements representable but i dont know if there's any crystals
0 likesCeridwen- ELEMENT OF EQUALITY (master of shape-changing)
Mannah- ELEMENT OF ACCEPTANCE (master of water)
Taranis- ELEMENT OF PRIDE (master of wind)
King Thaumas- ELEMENT OF PROTECTION
Prince Aello- ELEMENT OF KINDNESS
Balor- ELEMENT OF THE SAME NAME (master of Magic)
Princess Ocypete- ELEMENT OF HOPE
Queen Ozomene- ELEMENT OF GENEROSITY
Prince Hugiin-?
Maybe she gives these to the royale guard!
0 likesI love your Videos ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
0 likesWho lives longer? Celestia vs Queen Elizabeth (the II)?
0 likesBronys are so smart, i love them!!
0 likesNot me genuinely thinking this was a late April fools prank
0 likesBut if Luna was on the moon for 1,000 years she would have to at least eat one and does this mean that if that tree dies it would be pure chaos
0 likesor maybe spike said golden apple-tree instead of golden-apple tree
0 likesYour attire is interesting.
0 likesOh and the apple theory too...
Golded apple give u extra hearts and fire resistance:D
0 likesThis is gonna be awsome!!
1 likeThat eyebrow got me XD
0 likesSo nice to have our flag on your avatar), for World Peace!
0 likesOh yeah one more ting i think golden Apple's takes ages or hundreds of years to grow so it's fair to just give imorltality for the important ponies that control the sun and moon and a ponie that rules a kingdom and a princes that a smarty pants and calld the princes of friendship so why not keep the important ponies now comment if you disAgree and tell me your complaints
0 likesI have a question was pinkie pie traveling between the pony world and the human one ? Because the human pinkie pie knew about the elements of harmony and the pony pinkie pie knew Twilight loves Flash.
1 likeI love your videos I have to watch every post I used to be a crazy MLP fan
0 likesI hate to tell you but no, there is no such thing as being eternally old. Age and mortality are linked to the point where they cannot be separated. Because dying as a result of your age is a direct result of the ageing process. Alicorns would have to be immune to every single disease and injury that old age brings with them. And we already know for a fact that they are not, as demonstrated by the short in which Twilight got sick. As well as the fact that Cadence felt the need to cast a magical health bubble when Discord pretended to be sick. In fact, immunity to disease seems to be non-existent in the mlp universe as even Discord himself got sick in that episode.
0 likesThey're probably just for decorations
0 likesThe raise an eyebrow tho ✨🤌
0 likesShe’s lived for like ever!
0 likesSawtooth waves: i need you to forget everything you think you know!
0 likesMe: braindead
Do a video about sombra reforming
0 likesSawtooth please tell us what the device twilight human counterpart used was I need to know what a circle container thing was please tell us you know the containment from friendship came to humans way they used to take the magic from the human means sex and turn into my next book in the first place please you have to tell us what the device with sawtooth and who created it please tell us in your next episode now!!!!
0 likesIt’s probably because she has hair that flows like the wind
0 likesMaybe celestia gets her life span from the sun. Maybe the princesses don’t become immortal, but just get the life span from their ‘princess of’ element. Maybe if love became obsolete Cadence would die, but obviously their is no way to prove it—it’s just a theory.
0 likesCan you please do a video of what happened to celestia and Luna after Twilights coronation are they still alive and if so where are they? what are they doing
1 likeReplies (1)
They went to Silver Shoals for their retirement.
0 likesflutter shy + sawtooth waves = flutter waves
1 likeWell that means that celestial told twilight about this
0 likesI'm a new subscriber for a month and I love you
1 likeIve always thought the same of celestia sincs when she first met granny smith she was young and so waa granny smith but now granny smith is a granny and celestia stayed young and desame
0 likesI think those apples drain youth and then alcorns eat them and are young
0 likesWhat about Star swirl the bearded? He lived for 1000+ years, yet he looks old
1 likeReplies (2)
He was stuck in Limbo, frozen in time.
0 likes@Reese He said he had more than 1000 years of experience. (Episode: Friendship University) He can't get experience being frozen, so he must have gotten it before he went to limbo
0 likesSawtooth did you forgot some Thing Sunset ask Twilight what Happens If you Take one Elemente of harmony to the human world? That means that If sunset Toke one of Them she had the Same Power as when she had the element of magic. Thats my commentaren to the Sunset won thearory
0 likesaverage user: wow that was good!
0 likesme: why is he a Pegasus?
Your videos are the best and I love them
0 likesI love my little pony the most show it’s my favourite since the first season hundred and watch a movie on the way to the next one that came out
0 likesif alicorns evil then that means celestia is a demon!
0 likesHey, I’m writing a story and I think I accidentally used your pony avatar in these videos by mistake. Anyways, I’m so, so sorry I did that.
0 likesPerhaps the golden apple tree is not real perhaps its a wooden carving of something cause stuff like that usually is fake
0 likesI think the golden apples only work if is was ate by an alicorn
0 likesWhat if the golden apple tree give one golden apple per 1000 years😳
0 likesMan a theory if what if celessia Luna know about the golden Apple and know what's gonna happen or predict the future and they tell twilight if she's up for the task
0 likesWhats with the bow? it's adorable.
0 likeshey has anyone thought about what happened to the 3 villains statue in gen 5 like where is it now and will the same thing that happened to discord happen to it
0 likesI think it's food with a cool royal look.
0 likesI feel like Princess selestia is golden apples make you liv for eternity👸💁♀️👱♀️👩🦳
0 likesWhy is Luna the only one with dark magic on her cutiemark
0 likesWait. PEGASUS SAWTOOTH IS BACK!!!
1 likeSawtooth can you send me the link to the picture of the sphinx you used at 2:25 please
0 likesReplies (1)
it's from "daring done?" season 7 episode 18 of friendship is magic
0 likesIf/if you had golden apples she would have to get them from somebody and I would think they would come from their parents but their parents arnt alive so I’m thinking it’s just Alcorn
0 likesWhat does a gold apple tree look like?
0 likes0.0
Please talk about the sirens!
0 likesLike where are theyre parents and what will be theyre future?
(Pls don't bei Mad about my english! I'm German and Love your Videos!!)
That ending was creepy. Omg what could have happend to sawtooht?
0 likesNow that Sawtooth has mentioned it, it's likely that alicornhood doesn't grant thousands of extra years of life. We know that Celestia and Luna haven't aged a bit in the last 1,000 years. This would imply that they are somewhere around 30-70 years old physically. This would mean that they still have many centuries left, but flash forward to modern times, and they're no where to be found. This would imply that lots of time has passed. But according to Sawtooth's theory about how Twilight gave up her "immortality," we know that the crisis started within the show's runtime. And based on the human world side, magic seems to be flowing through at a fast pace. So in modern times, it is likely that Celestia and Luna died not to long before the movie (by alicorn standards).
2 likesSo we have an explanation for why Celestia, Luna, and Twilight aren't around anymore, but what about Cadence? It probably wouldn't be long enough for her to die of old age, since she hadn't even gotten her energy hair before the time jump episode. So what happened to her? It's my theory that only the Royal Sisters had access to whatever lengthened their lives by so much, but Candace and Twilight didn't have access to it, for whatever reason.
Based on the lack of any alicorn in modern times, it is likely that alicorns have naturally longer lives, but not for thousands and years like Celestia and Luna. They had their own spell or artifact that lengthened their lifespans.
But hey, that's just a theory,
A Film Theory!
Thanks for reading!
I suggest you might wanna look on your daybreaker video it may help you and ive commented something that makes alot of sense.👍🏾
0 likesi love your videos
0 likesMaybe they can make flurry a filly
0 likessubscribed ever since i was in fifth grade:( i remember when u were still brony notion aaaa so nostalgic, u r my literal childhood love u broo
0 likesIf you eat one you'll get teleported to a different universe
0 likesLove the bow saw tooth hehehe
0 likeswaaaait- THE GOLDEN APPLE OF DISCORD? discord runs into room at high speed
1 likemuledonkey and i are very proud of you toot. nice beard. yum fruit.
0 likesThis videos are what's stopping me from taking a bath with my toaster
0 likesReplies (1)
hey if you can, there's no shame in getting help and confiding in others. nothing wrong with it at all.
0 likesMaybe the golden apple tree is not there anymore thus Twilight can’t share because there is nothing to share🤷🏽
0 likesReplies (1)
🐎🐎🐎🐎🐎🐎🦄🦄🐴❤️
0 likesluna too, everybody always forgets about best pony
0 likesthe golden apple tree is now empty thanks to you. shame on you toot.!
0 likesYou mispronounced the Nordic youth gods name. That symbol that looks like a d is not a d. It makes the same "th" sound as the word "with"
0 likes2:44 OKAY SEE THAT WAS UNCALLED FOR😭
0 likesCan you do a theory about princess Luna (how long she sleeps at day?)
0 likesReplies (1)
She sleeps from dawn until dusk. This was shown already.
0 likesI like the Ribbon Bow
0 likessawtooth waves you are under arrest for high treason against my mother princess celestia (a oc of mine is a powerfull light fury who was adopted by her)
1 likeReplies (1)
oh never mind
0 likesInformative 🤓😃
0 likesWhy does pharynx get to be the guard chrysalis served his longer than he has way before he was even a hatchling. Maybe ocellus like him.
0 likesI have another idea. Seeing as the Changeling mythology had been expanded in MLP to what it is, I wouldn’t be surprised if the apples also got an expansion of quirks. So, my proposal is this: What if the golden apples of Equestria only respond with eternal youth to alicorns due to magic? I’d like to also say that while you are correct with the difference between immortality and eternal youth, I believe eternal youth is just immortality with extra features (the youthful appearance) or that it stops aging entirely (in the time that it is being digested). So, considering that, what if, when the golden apples were discovered, that when Celestial tried to share it with other ponies, dangerous consequences were found. This would be due to not enough magic in the ponies being able to absorb the powers of youth. I’d then liken this to a chemical reaction. What if, in this scenario, magic acted as a catalyst to break down or build up whatever the apples had into the power of eternal youth? So, due to other ponies having less magic than alicorns, they’d have a build up of the initial substrate in their systems until it, at worst, killed them.
0 likesI don’t know, I just really want the golden apples of eternal youth thing to be true because otherwise the alicorns are once again op because of their immortality.
Speaking if op, I don’t think even the most powerful unicorns can equate to an alicorn for golden apple consumption (sorry not sorry Starlight).
Another thing...
0 likesIn she talks with angel, angel mentioned that fluttershy wants to marry discord.
Say she does marry discord, would discord do some weird magic thing too make her live as long as he does, or not?
I can't help but realize that if the golden apples did JUST keep one young, the chaos that could unfold if Celestia or any of the Alicorns let slip the secret of the golden apples. Villains would come knocking and try to take the golden apples for themselves in order to stay alive just as long as Celestia, if not longer.
0 likesWell I hate to burst your bubble about celestia's eternal life but 1 moon is more than likely equivalent to one lunar cycle (29.5 days) so following that logic, celestia would be 80 years old, which would still bring up questions as to why celestia doesn't look like granny Smith but with a white coat, wings and a horn, it just simply isn't enough time to suggest that there's a sinister secret to the "immortality" that they have, maybe it's just the combination of the lifespans of all 3 of the types of pony or maybe they maintain youth through their own magical power.
0 likesReplies (2)
5:05 or maybe, just maybe the golden apple if eaten without the magic of an alicorn is effectively poison to a pony
0 likescelestia was around 1000 years ago, not moons
0 likesWait so that means her mom or dad of celestial and lunas parents probably got the golden apples so they can probably be alive- or am I wrong hmm
0 likesI thought it's gonna be horcruxes like Harry Potter like there is already snape in it
0 likesThink one maybe the apples you can only use 1 time every a 100 years or something like close to that like if you take a bite and you may wish when it's old when you finish it you can't make any more wishes or something named closer that's why you're using there's something I'm close to that I like you you use this button to inside I wish to be a nail corner or something yeah and that's it that's all I think oh actually
1 likeHow long can a pony live
0 likesWhy does the Apple remind of dreamtale- anyway nice vid like always
0 likesI think that immortality is a bad thing because seeing your friends and family die in front of you is not cool
0 likesdying with you friends and family by your side that cool
it's like Richard Pryor said in
Harlem nights the movie but that's just my opinion
We don't know if celestia hid or took the tree or diddent tell twilight or forgot to tell twilight sparkle
0 likesI love your videos
0 likesShe’s a cyborg-corn JK!
0 likesOr it could be that only alicorns who eats the apple are imortal as only the power of the apple would only work with alicorn magic
0 likesyou ate the golden apple? didn't you?!
0 likesBut what if the golden apples are solid gold
0 likesIf your saying apples are like memory of the past your basically saying apple jack is special because she has the apple cutie mark
0 likesIS pinkie a PONY version of discord ?? Because she can teleport she can remember anything like almost the day when she was born and uses hair as an extra lim she can swallow a whole cake and a whole lolly pop and...... MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS MORE SWEETS- * calms down...I LOVE CANDY
1 likeSpike said princess celestia had a golden apple tree
1 like5:51 BUT, this wish granting plant is going extinct, and i wouldn’t be surprised if more than one thing gives wishes
0 likesReplies (2)
6:10 true true
0 likes6:19 hidden alicorn wings, the original sunny starscout
0 likesSawtooth: Golden apples make u immortal
0 likesminecraft: a few hearts, take it or leave it.
Mc players: k?
The front of the video: celestia with a golden Appel from Minecraft
0 likesI liked the theory.
1 likeRe-watch best night ever Spike state's that there is a golden apple tree in the gardens
0 likesI found a pattern!! I know your upload schedule!
0 likesPlot twist: Spike was referring to the normal "yellow" apples when he said "golden apples"
1 likeReplies (2)
@🌘Jenny Melanie Jema🌟 Hi Jenny! I didn't know you watch this channel. Nice to know that's something we have in common!
1 like@🌘Jenny Melanie Jema🌟 me too! I’ve been watching since I joined YouTube
1 likeWhy is there a bow on your characters head?
0 likesCan I just say, I love the yellow bow accessory
2 likesWho's that dashing pony salesman?
0 likesWow I had never thought of it that way
0 likesI have not watched mlp in roughly 8 years
0 likesWhy am I here
Great video btw!
That's how i'm alive till this day
0 likesNot only were getting amazing mlp videos but we get history lessons!
0 likesWhat happened to Twivine Sparkle (Twilight Sparkle’s evil twin).
0 likesI don't like thinking that clestia is bad, but good job spotting that. (the line about golden apples)
0 likesBut what if they are for apple bottom jeans, boots with the fur? Perhaps I watch too much of your meme channel nowadays.
0 likesmaybe the golden apples can make you'r wishes come true
0 likesTime to interrogate AJ for her extended apple-related knowledge :3
1 likeYou confirm every answer i have!
0 likesI'm not done with the video yet, but it's nowhere said the Apple of Discord is from the garden of Hesperides. In a kids book I have, it was even said she used a regular apple she turned to gold, but that one is not very canon. Anyway. Since these already belong to Hera I don't believe she'd have played the game, but rather gone "hey b***h what makes you think you can steal my apples and then pretend you offer them to me?!"
0 likesReplies (2)
2 if apple = eternity, then Twilight had the reserve of apples... And could technically have gave some. If one apple was enough for one immortality, then there wouldn't be any need for a tree so an interesting guess is that Celestia and Luna decided to give their access to the apples with their job. I don't think it's selfish if it's kept and distributed with wisdom. Immortality has its downsides.
0 likesOkay last question is about other immortal beings. Like: what about Discord?
0 likesHey I have a question about the mlp new generation because I wanna know if dragons, Griffin's, Hippogriffs and maybe changelings still exist
0 likesReplies (1)
We won't know that until the actual show starts.
0 likeshey umm i found a my little pony book and it says for celestia's family older sister of luna ADOPTIVE AUNT OF PRINCESS CADANCE and for luna it says younger sister of celestia ant of princess cadance i just wanted to tell you
0 likesSawtooth Waves come out with your hooves up
0 likesBeen here for 4 years and you are still the best
0 likesThat one kid after seeing this : welp. Gotta find it.
0 likesDoes no one else see that he has WINGS!!!
0 likesEven more mythology
0 likesAlright you fake, we saw the basement clips.
0 likesWHERES SAWTOOTH.
And what do the apples have to do with anything?
(All jokes but would like to unravel the mystery!)
Happy Birthday Sawtooth
1 likeReplies (1)
Hi
0 likes4:22 Wat
2 likesNoooooo eyebrow where are you going!? X'D
Can someone tell me when he changed his design please
0 likesHmm... Star Swirl older than Celestia and Luna? He is the teacher of the two royal sisters...
0 likesI SMELL LORE !!
1 likeI dont know celestia have a golden apple
0 likesWhat would happen if Celestia was banished and she was the villain for the first two episodes and luna was the one who banished her
0 likesSawtooth you made this on my birthday :D
0 likesI thought the picture was the golden Apple from Minecraft, Nevermind
0 likesFun simple thought I had is that maybe over the years Celestia just got into horticulture, and that tree is a breed she cultivated over the centuries XD
0 likesYou are sooooooo helpful
0 likesthe fact that Luna didn't visibly age during her banishment easily debunks this tho. If golden apples wrere the key to immortality or youth, Luna would have died long before the 1000 years were over or would be all wrinkly at the very least.🤷♀
1 likeReplies (3)
Unless being banish to the moon prevent her from aging. Like Starswirl and pillars they been millenia old but in limbo they have not age a year more.
1 like@Kiddie Winnie Roblox Gaming you can't compare the moon and limbo, limbo is suposed to be this nothingness where space and time don't exist, therefore it's logical you wouldn't age. On the moon that is not the case.
0 likes@Mia Dolenšek well we do not really know besides you cannot really debunk my theory because it is a mystery how the banishment work in equestria besides we also do not know how heavenly bodies work in equestria for all we know the sun and moon if you were banish to it maybe be like limbo.
0 likes3:21 Me: OHHHH MYYYY GOOOOOODDDD!!!!
1 likeCan I just say how Sawtooth comes up with these predictions.
1 likeCan you do a video about what all powers Spike could have gotten in the Power_Ponies episode of the MLP FIM show instead of making him look like comic relief behind Twilight Sparkle and her friends which made me hate this episode?
0 likesReplies (1)
You've asked that several times now. They're not going to make a video on it.
0 likesYeah but think of it this way how are all old ponies are still alive and the young ones haven't even gotten old yet over a thousand years maybe you should think of it that you know
1 likeMaybe It is the age spell
0 likesYour videos are the best.
0 likesUnless that was the sawtooth clone
0 likesalicorns are evil? swatooth why didn't you tell this before?
0 likesShe will always be banned from the hive and never forgiven by any changeling or creature.
0 likesReplies (4)
And yet, Starlight was willing to forgive her.
0 likes@Reese but she did not forgive star she rejected her and left in fury and in rage and said that's it i am leaving and i am never coming back ever agian.
0 likes@Reese yeah i guess.
0 likes@Reese in fact thorax is too good because who would want an old lady like chrysalis anyway.
0 likesshe's queen Elizabeth's horse lol
0 likesshe's evil and i think she kidnapped sawtooth that day.
1 likeReplies (4)
She's not. Also I thought you were done with MLP.
1 likei see you're keeping up with the disney fan lore as well
0 likes@Reese she did not kidnap toot?
0 likes@Sawtooth Waves she did not kidnap you?
0 likesCelestia got Notch apples.
0 likesMy théorie is luna and celestia comes by another place than equestria so maybe the place luna and celestia born has a immortal tree golden apple or something make them immortal but luna take ages when it was not anymore in the moon but after she take ages she stop to get more ages anymore and that’s I can’t explain why cause if she take ages in like 2 episodes so why she didn’t take ages anymore???
0 likesCan you make more videos about the new my little pony that came out you know the movie and I really like your videos I might if I can like and subscribe if you don’t mind byee from carabelle
0 likesWell what have learned today?
0 likesAPPLEs are ruling every world !!! Ours Earthen and their Equestrian ... and etc.
When are we going back to you in the new timeline?
1 likeSo nobody gonna talk about the background? On the tree
0 likesAlicorns aren’t immortal they just mature slower than normal ponies.
0 likesHow people can talk for so long about a show which is based on the wrong perception of reality that pacifism and democracy (which harmony represents) are is the way to fix the world.
0 likesDemocracy doesn't always succeed. Look at China it is authoritarian and it is a great success. This whole show makes no sense. Channelings had a better military. There was no way Harmony could mobilize so quickly that they were able to win the battle after the invasion of Canterlot. This whole thing makes no sense.
ah yes the clones have come to k(yeah that might trigger some one so no) us all. (not 'bout the vid, just the intro)
0 likes99% of comments: (basically the theory but diffrent)
0 likes1% of the comments (me) nice bow 👍🏻
Ok so.....if i had the secret of eternal life like, JESUS, then it would be selfish not to share my faith
0 likesIf this is true why isn't celestia and the other immortals in the mlp G5
1 likeReplies (1)
who says they aren't?
0 likesWHO replaced Twilight When she gave away HER Alicorn powers to the crystals??
0 likesReplies (1)
she didnt
0 likesMaybe only alicorns can eat the apples?
0 likesnow that was fax! Nice vid Sawtooth!
0 likesMaybe the apples have a catch. It could be like the potion that allowed Twilight to see the past, but it only responds to alicorn magic. Maybe the apples only work on alicorns 🤔
1 likeSawtooth please do a Collab with FOB Equestria
0 likesThose apples do grant you youthful looks and it’s what gives em the wavy look on their hair should they eat it once in a while cadence doesn’t have it since she lives way far in crystal empire.
0 likesThere is a foundation of youth right there in the castle ground and it’s been shown in screen however no one knows about it except the two princesses. Oh I can go on foreva on why they didn’t share it and that the foundation was destroyed when the trip was freed chrysalis, cozy, and tirek and it’s why no alicorn exist in the new series blah blah they took over Equestria and yeah
Love the bowtie
2 likesGolden apple. makes more sense minecraft stuff. shouldve said that to make it shorter. although I love yer vids reminds me of my old self when I liked mlp lore
1 likeMe listening to this and thinking about Fan-fics.
0 likes"Write that down! Write that down!"
Replies (2)
Sorry what
1 like@Ash / InkyKK I'm saying this has a lot of Fan-fic potential
0 likesI WANTED TO ASK ON YOUR LATEST VIDEO IS LUSTER DAWN SUNNY STAR SCOUTS MOM?
1 likeWow your videos are awesome
0 likesThat’s her secret?
0 likesThat also explains why Applejack and why she likes apples so much maybe she celestia ask Granny Smith’s parents that she needs golden apples
0 likesChangeling myths aren’t German or at least not only German. I’d think of Scottish and Irish first
0 likesMe seeing thumbnail: Oh no, it's r/place's Among Us fruit!
0 likesThen what about Luna everyone forgets Luna
0 likesthat golden delicious comment was harsh but also funny...
0 likesGeez even Minecraft has powerful gold apples dang if it's in mc then it must be important
0 likesPls make more eps I already watched every single one
0 likesReplies (1)
Omg!!!!!
0 likesGolden apples are evil.
0 likesI think celestia and luna are not alicorns what if celestia and luna got a pair of wings and horns from twilight i mean we have sin twilight’s parents but it didn’t say that those are twilight’s parents what if celestia is twilight’s mom and that’s why she made her an alicorn i know that celestia has flowing hair but celestia is the one that bring twilight in the world
1 likeHey Sawtooth I don’t think alicorns are immoral. When I looked up “Is Princess Twilight Sparkle immortal?” it said she wouldn’t. It was never confirmed that alicorns were immortal instead they just live longer like dragons. That’s what it said not me. But while digging deeper one line got my suspicions up. It said something like this “Twilight will not outlive her friends because Twilight and her friends can’t die.” That could be a lie but what if and you never know maybe it’s true.
0 likesThe Apple is for eating
0 likesWhat is the apples helps give the royals their flowing manes.
0 likesu need to make a vid based on the new series. I'm beggin
0 likesMlp suddenly became Minecraft real quick
0 likesAn apple guessing they eat mAgIc ApPLe
0 likesi have a theroie so in the begging of seris one the book opens and at seson 9 the book closes so what if the new generation was reading it to the old one or something like that
0 likesCan you make a video about pinkie pie's daughter please
0 likesI see you were able to get back to the past sawtooth welcome back buddy
0 likesReplies (1)
i wish
0 likesSawtooth: golden apples
1 likeMe: mINcRAFt AYYYYY
Yo what if the apples make their hair all wavy and cadence doesnt hav them is bc they didnt know how they worked on that type of Alicorn but it worked
0 likesSince you did a video about why Rainbow Dash doesn't deserve her element, can you do a similar video about Rarity since it's hard to tell that she is generous since acts very picky about small things, she acts like she was born in Canterlot and she takes full advantage of Spike's crush for her? Along with Twilight Sparkle who cares more about books than anything else and who is an abuser when she's with Spike. Don't take it the wrong way but if you've seen the show real carefully, you'd know what I mean
0 likesI was recommended this just after 12 minutes you posted this
1 likeI love your video
0 likesOk so no one is asking about the wings
0 likesSawthooth are you stealing golden apples!?!?!?!!??!?
0 likesWell maybe I can have a different game going on maybe instead of golden apples we have something called last year has a big sign for her cutie mark the two possibilities that I love to explain number one I know it could be true
0 likesCelesitea is actually dark
0 likesI have a stupid question or you everyone knows how twilight grows bigger and immortal will princess Celestia be the same height as princess twilight and will twilight be taller than princess luna? (please respond)
0 likesWait you know undertale right but do you know the dreamtale this is Cleary similar to the story dream is +500 that means di celestia steal the golden Apple from dreamtale that might be it just if you donat know the story about dreamtale and if you know Its acsualy really similar to the story the dreamtale story is a brother that got left behind but in this mlp world is about sister that left behind or is this mean its a dreamtale AU or multivers of them its kinda hard to tell but i still believe this is related to dreamtale
1 likeFinally watching you again
0 likesBut she can go first potions I will keep them alive forever
0 likesUmm how was sawtooth back in friendship is magic Equestria when he got stranded in G5 Equestria?
0 likeshow many times have you rewatched G4?
0 likesI have to say this but in your last video about poison joke the comments were off but I wanted to say this I got your discord song reference when you said "I really don't like puppeteers but have a nagging fear that someone else is pulling at the strings."
0 likesWait I have a theory:
1 likeMaybe twilight didn’t know about the golden apples maybe tia put the apple in her food without her knowing that’s why the rest of mane 6 aren’t immortal because tia Knew if twilight would know she would give it to her friends and tia only wanted alicorns to be immortal 🧐🧐🧐
I want to tell you something you know the rainbow apples in the forest where the Apple acres family lives you know the apples they found their rainbow but not gold and of course not but they don't do anything but what if they do do something like what if these apples connect to friendship like the elements of harmony they are rainbow and so are the apples maybe the apples have to do something with the elements of harmony I don't know I'm just thinking this I don't know what they could do I don't know why I'm thinking this but it's just a thing for me
0 likesReplies (1)
Are you talking about the Zap Apples? They have nothing to do with harmony, friendship or the elements; they're just a rare type of apple.
0 likesnice video but pls make videos on my little pony :tell your tale I mean there is always a mystery or something in mlp
0 likesgolden apple power is love
0 likesI like your videos
0 likesits getting darker then the merch vid showed up
0 likesWhat's with the bow and wings?
0 likes... Or has Celestia been a reformed changeling all along who needs the love of her kingdom to keep her on the side of the angels?!
1 like( Sorry, went all Appaloosa Jones there for a sec ... )
Sawtooth... you good bro?
1 likewhy do you think celestia is evil?
0 likesThere’s no god but ALLAH❤️❤️❤️
0 likesminecraft players seeing the thumbnail video be like : OMG G APPLE >:D
0 likesWhy are you always trying to bring back those old equestrian pony real estate sceams!?
0 likesWhat was that eated golden apple at the end ????
0 likes3:18
0 likesOh wow, i never noticed that
i saw the golden apple tree
0 likesI thought it was going to be April fools video xd
0 likesHalf way through i thought of the idea that maybe the golden apples grant immortality only to alicorns like a magical reaction.
0 likesLike in Minecraft probably give you more health just guessing 🍎🍏
0 likes-enchanted golden apple
0 likesoh me wow! i love your videos
0 likesJUST ONLY ONE VOD AND THAT IS OUR CREATOR GOD
0 likesTHE HAIR BOW
0 likesDoes anyone else find this whole Alcorn thing kind of fucked up
0 likesI know a good video for you do you'll get flowy hair when you age when she's normal no flown hair but older she has float hair
0 likesthey give power to the powerless
0 likesthat's why Celestia and Luna are so useless when Equestria is in great danger
and need to rely on the main 6 to fix the problem themself
princes of Equestria my shiny metal a$s
So think changlins could been normal pony’s once. That what all about! My comment to long to understand. 😬😂
0 likesGolden apple be like...
0 likesDream sans from dream tale
(Dream swap)
MMM YES MYTHOLOGY MY BEST FRIEND
0 likes...
WHY ARE YOU IN A HORSE THEORY WHAT
As a greek,i just like to hearing about greek mythology in ponytheorytubers that i really like tho😅
1 likeMaybe its a mix of the comics and the eternal youth, Celestia's apples differ from other golden apples because they've been spellcast to only grant one wish: eternal youth.
0 likesIve just realized that ur a pomy version of film theory
2 likesHim: says me and my sister. Me:😮 🙀
0 likeswhy waves she was my fav character man
0 likesI just went to my little pony and I went to the episode and spike said to pinky pie said the golden apple tree
0 likesthe apple give hope
0 likesI have a question.I don't understand how dragons grow up. I mean spike ( born ) when twilight was a child and he is still a bady when she is a teen .how is that possible!
0 likesReplies (1)
Twilight isn't a teen, though.
0 likesCan you do mlp friendship is magic School Raze?
0 likesOMG THIS MIGHT BE TRUE I-
0 likesI'm making a MLP oc what type of pony should it be or should I make it a discord or changeling
0 likesIs the Multiverse real in mlp as well
0 likesWhat about starswirl?
0 likesFan br dub 🇧🇷 for this channel plsssss
2 likesBut Minecraft told me they give you regeneration
0 likesWhy would she do this!!!😭
0 likesBut careful equestria can be a dangerous place.
0 likesWhat about Granny Smith?
0 likesI like your channel
0 likesMaybe they're an ingredient to a very special shampoo that makes Celestia's and Luna's hair flow like it does? You just need a long time of regular use, though regaining the effect after a stop only takes a little bit. It may also require some form of magic i.e. Rarity does not have. An Earth Pony maybe, at the cost of not being able to use it as an extra limb or Bigger-from-the-inside storage space.
0 likesYour bow 😎👍🎀
0 likesi don’t know if you ever discussed this but if Sunset Shimmer originally came from the pony world was there ever an original Sunset in the human world??
0 likesHim: “gapples”
0 likesMe: “MINECRAFT!?!” 😭
1:58 "Golden Apple of Discord"!?
0 likesNah celestia just found a way to teleport to minecraft and steal some apples.
0 likeswhat about discord and some of the other villians? if they were evil, celestia wouldn't just give them the golden apples. Yet they stayed alive for a long time as well.
0 likesMy little pony is just my little pony what's so Important about it
0 likesWhy were the changelings shown when he said German?
0 likesI have a theory about flutter shy
0 likesBecause no one remembered zap apples
0 likesYou should make a q&a video
0 likesCan YOU MAKE A VIDEO ON WHO THE HECK CONTROLS THE STARS IT MI G T BE...... T-T-TWILIGHT BECUASE HER CUTIE MARK IS A STAR ITSELF
0 likesI love ur video 😁😁😁😁😁crazy😳🦄#pony magic🐴🦄
0 likesFrom the VIDEO ON WHO names the ponies.... Wait then WHO named ponies when celestia wasn't born yet???!!! :O
0 likesI never thought of this before
0 likesIs where the golden apple of DISCORD IM HOWLING AT THE MOON
0 likesWhat would Queen Chrysalis sound like if she got reformed? Since her voice sound distorted
0 likesReplies (1)
Her voice hasn't been distorted since the season 2 finale.
0 likesI must say, FR where is discord in the new MLP? 🤔
0 likesI believe this is true
0 likesMy issue with this theory is the fact that not once in the entirety of the show, or even the comics, novels, or the writers themselves, has it ever been affirmed that alicorns are immortal.
0 likesBut if there is anything that is connected to their perceived immortality, my theory would be the magic connecting them to their celestial objects.
… WHY DID YOU NOT TELL ME-
0 likesWhy is this reminding me a lot of Minecraft
0 likeswhy everyone got wavy hair but cadence
0 likesFinally early to a sawtooth vid!
0 likesTo be honest I'm sometimes I'm sacred with your theorys but I'm still watching 😄
0 likesUhm... I'm not sure about that, wait a sec.
1 likeWell if your crazy I'm the shadow of all ponies
0 likesyou sound so different omg.
0 likesI watched almost all of the videos from today and last year
0 likesthey make it rain cotton candy
0 likesYou are correct
0 likesNow if I am thinking about Sunny she could be one last hope for the ponies when it comes to the future since if Sombra comes back everyone would be aware about it since and due to the drain of magic that would put him at a disadvantage making it a fair fight but who knows probably just me thinking about something else that I don't have the knowledge about
0 likesRip our boy killed by the pony FBI
0 likesHoldup changelings are german mythology??
0 likesWhy are you stopping pls make more :'( we all love you
0 likeswell nightmere moon lived for a long time on the moon without having any brithing problomes soooooooooooooooooooooo please explen that
0 likesWhat does mythology have to do with MLP FIM?
0 likesReplies (1)
Because a LOT of MLP's lore and creatures stem from all sorts of mythologies. Sirens, sea serpents, hydras, Cerberus (guard dog of the Underworld), WIndigos, things like that.
0 likesThe truth has been answered
0 likesThere’s golden apples in Minecraft too… 👁👄👁
0 likesThe thumhnail:Grape hair <3333
0 likesu should rlly keep that yellow bow it’s sooo cute on u
0 likesI dare you to celebrate Christmas and not to scare you sawtooth but I’m a hu-men
0 likesSo what happens we are eating golden apple in minecraft
0 likesThis is confusing 😵 💫 🥴
1 likeWho made the portal to Equestria and the human world
1 likeshe's been around 200,915
0 likes104 comments. IN 10 MINUTES MY GUY but I love your ♥️ My theory I bought 3 T-Shirts Tysm for the BEST QUALITY SHIRTS ro everyone who wants to buy one
0 likesSawtooth waves love your content
0 likesLiking the bow man!!
1 likei like your video
0 likesHappy Saturday🎉🎊
0 likes👏😀
0 likesJust a question so are you a DJ
0 likesBy the gods I LOVE that you touch into other religions and mythos! My pagan heart is happy
0 likesThe amount of research u put in these vids is amazing!
0 likesWhat just happened I'm scared will you post again your my favourite YouTuber don't leave
0 likesWhy are you wearing a giant yellow bow?!
0 likesa little late to the party, but ayyyyee
1 likeHi the demmi show here I might have some important news I think that sunny starscout is scootaoos daughter
0 likesI've been a long time you were too but I watched your video since you first uploading and your music on your videos hear me😅😮
0 likesOk wow but how u get all of this dude 👍😭
0 likesGolden apple makes some youtuber lose their shit over a line dropped in season 1 to come up with a stupid reason to make a video to get some clicks and some likes ...
0 likesI am a changeling aswell!
0 likesIt’s probably the elements of harmony
0 likesReplies (1)
No.
0 likesha, golden apples like in minecraft lol
0 likesWait wait wait i just saw a golden apple in the series or is it yellow not the cutie mark
0 likesReplies (1)
Yellow apples exist.
0 likes... whats with the wings his normal pony form is an earth pony why is he a pegiases? somethings off...
0 likesim learning very confusing facts
0 likesTHEY ALL LIVE FOR EVER BECAUSE ITS A KIDS SHOW AND NO ONE WOULD MAKE DIEING IN IT WHAT THE HECK
1 likeMYTHOLOGY RULES NEW FAV YOUTUBER
0 likesHappy Easter
0 likesI have a book lol with a golden Apple that pinky pie eats
0 likes<3
0 likesI saw Fantastic beast: Dumbledore's secret.
0 likesI compares Kung FU Panda, Harry Potter/Fantastic beast and My Little Pony with each other. Oogray, Dumbledore and Celestia. I love their personality. All 3 universes develops to be deeper and deeper.
It doesn't make sense because why did miss mane died when it was alive
0 likesBecause she an alicorn
0 likes💖💖💖
0 likesreads about page
0 likesHOLY SH1T-
why are you wearing a bow?
0 likesI think it´s the one about eternal youth. I don´t think Twi wouldn´t share eternal life with her best friends. She IS the princess of friendship. But just think of Celestia seeing her friends die one by one. Poor girl.
0 likesAre you sure Celestia is not going to kill you because you are literally telling her deep in darkest secret well have fun and Ponyville or whatever you live
0 likesLazy moonbow trisy moonbow are they related they are both unicorns
1 likeAt the end where are you see twilight in Apple Jack when she’s show star lights kid lit why it’s not Granny Smith is not in it
0 likesCool and funny video 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂👍👍👍👍👍
0 likesi see the Apple gold
0 likesIs there a human word trek
1 likeI bet you're good at math
0 likesNice bow
0 likesDon’t forget in Greek mythology the myths arund the cicada being created started with one of the goddesses lovers who she wished would be immortal but did not wish to be young. He grew old and his songs were all about dying and someone setting him free. He was old and immortal not young and immortal so he was turned to a cicada and the sound that cicadas make are from that old man singing about his death.
0 likesInteresting theory. I do like the idea that the apples grant ones who are already immortal (or at least long living) eternal youth. Doesn't seem quite as sinister that way.
0 likesOn an entirely separate note, the part where Applejack's eyebrow raised up into the sky got a chuckle out of me.😄
I think defendant happen means not getting any ring girls, because you know people daddy happy lang girls sometimes hurts help, girls, school, I think a shrink
0 likesJschlatt would be happy
1 likeLove you😍
0 likesMaybe she uses the apples when going to Nether or for quick heal 🤔
0 likesWho found you???😱
1 like❤️🧡💛💚💙💜💞💓💗💖💝
0 likesdude waves are you a girl ( i'm saying that because in your profile pic has you whereing a flower and in the video you have a bow )
0 likes#SawtoothWavesSquad
1 likeOmg spike gave it away
1 likeWhy the wings?
0 likesReplies (1)
wouldn't you want wings if you could take any form?
0 likes3:15 Bro? The Hell?
1 likeSoo are we just gonna like- atleast im early🤠
0 likesare they gods
0 likes3:20 SAY WHAAAAAAAAAATTTT!!!!!!
0 likesI made it halfway sorry I gtg I don’t wanna ruin my childhood at least what’s left of it
0 likesOMG WOW
0 likesWell... whats...going...on....
0 likesWAIT WHAAAAT
1 likeDream/nightmare Sans?!?!?!
0 likesWait a minute what about discord is immoral too
0 likesWow makes sense
0 likesI’m your biggest fan
0 likesOmg it's a kid show it's not got 1 MILLION THEORIES ITS A KIDS SHOWWW
0 likesI see a Minecraft reference
0 likesWhat about the other alricons
0 likesGood evil lol
0 likesWOW
1 like( pols at a gun )
0 likesHey thought you waves there's no like golden apple and like My Little pony so why was there a picture of a golden apple and all so I'm sorry for saying this in like the very like someone beginning of the video but like are you saying that Celestia killed someone for a golden apple and then she ate it I'm supposed to be believe that the reason why Luna isn't dead because she got half of the golden apple like you're saying I'm sorry for saying this but like I'm just trying to protect if in the rest of the video you're going to say that Celestia ate one half of the Apple then Luna ate the other half of the Apple that way they both be immortal
0 likesWhat if the golden apples were the fruits that also made their mane flowy.
1 like♥️
0 likesI think they have the power of dilishesnes
0 likesYOU TOOOOOP COOL BRO
0 likesWait Kirin are Chinese that’s great cause I’m chinese
0 likesU thank that the Golden apples thorn the bad gis in to good gis
0 likesNotch Minecraft golden apple alert!!!
0 likesIt's the zapapples
0 likesLuna is best princess
0 likesThe night shall last forever
Not useless celestia x
does king thorax know about this?
0 likesReplies (2)
What reason would he have to use the apples? He's fine the way he is.
0 likes@Reese not the apple. Sawtooth.
0 likesI am over 20 million years old that is more then celestia
0 likesThis actually makes sense it would explain why and how Celestia has lived awhile and I've been waiting to watch this for five hours XD
0 likesWhy did apple bloom did not get poison joke
0 likesNice wings
1 likeCool
1 like5:22
0 likesno thoughts. only thought video.
0 likesor maybe when their bodies grow too old or their hair falls,they just change bodies with flowy hair (they even turn it on and off)
0 likes❤
0 likesTitling your vids like MatPat now, eh? /jk XD
0 likes6:26
0 likesThe elements of harmony
0 likesReplies (1)
Nope.
0 likesWOW WOW
0 likesin my theory, the immortality is given just to the alicorn in power (ruler of whole equestria). so, the moment that Celestia and Luna retired, they are back to aging.
0 likesMeanwhile, we can see Twilight with youth appearance in the last episode, unlike her friends who, on the other hand, have obvious signs of age.
now, i don't remember who, but an insider of the series confirmed that Cadence is not immortal, during an interview, for example. (ok, she's a royal but not the ruler of equestria, indeed).
so, again, i guess that average alicorns (or royal alicorns of some equestria's kindgom) maybe have a really long life-span, but the immortality is a power for the main ruler of ponies world alone. (maybe the king of dragons and queen Novo too ?).
anyway, the gold apple theory is kinda interesting too, but I don't think it has a lasting foundation at this point. but maybe i'm wrong, it would be interesting to explore it! :D
5:20
0 likesI like that
0 likesheeeelppp saw tooth pls i will be a patron
0 likesPov dream sans sees this
0 likesi see gold apple
0 likesAnd allycorns is not born to be allycorns they just suddenly grow wings or horns to get that is only one ting just like how super heros get their super human powers iiiiiitssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
0 likesBeing the MAIN characters ;)
Defense secretary
0 likesNICE A NEW VIDEO
0 likesSo that’s how Granny Smith stayed alive? She had a tree as well.
0 likesWhy are you wearing a bow
1 likeIf everypony had immortality everything would fall into chaos.
1 likeOr luna or cadence
0 likescool
0 likescool
0 likesCelestina golden apples are really nothing. Never even remember seeing the app,e anywhere in mlp. Her long lives is just little pony story. It go princess alway live forever of twice a longer there friends. After great wizard set a spell on the upcoming princess. The wizard know who be running in next 5 years or so. So he pick to let the ruler of pony land longer. Make sense in other part beside usa. Because princess or king can be there forever if they want to be. And be tired to pick new on every 4 or 2 years like we done.
0 likes3:20
0 likesIt's my birthday today :D
0 likesUm Isn't chrysalis your mom? And twilight froze her.
0 likesUm ..... um you exposed me
0 likesI don't want your time shirts.
0 likesОго, я б хотіла виразити вдячність за підтримку України, розумію відео не про це але це дуже мило з вашого боку! Дякую!
0 likesInvestigate it
0 likesWho has boneless 3,4,5
0 likesMake her young everyday she have to eat it because she'll get over her
0 likes2:50
0 likesHi. It is me again. I stil have the question if there are Albino changelings. If it doesn't metter that i'm askin.
0 likes2:20
0 likes3:10
0 likesCelastia is very old
0 likesseeing this on April 22nd oop
0 likesHi,l'm new!!!😊😊😊
0 likes3:30
0 likesGive me a pin. Can't? Make a new vid tomorrow it will make me happy🍓
0 likesTey crieit flurereets!
0 likesSoooo your alive orrr what?
0 likesChrysalis has no place in the hive anymore. Plus even if she did change her ways thorax will never let her back in the hive.
0 likesReplies (7)
For the last time, he would let her back in once he's seen she's changed. He's not the same leader as she was once.
0 likes@Reese sawtooth why do you want chrysalis back i mean can you even think of one nice thing that lady ever did for you?
0 likes@Reese ok i guess so.
0 likes@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 Can you not spam the same comment?
0 likes@Reese sorry
0 likes@Reese like thorax cares about old chrysalis?? want he saw her he got angry at her and said beat it you old lady get out now.
0 likes@Reese there no way thorax could have fallowed her down the path she was going.
0 likesCelestia may have the Golden Apple, but no one can know the true power of ENCHANTED GOLDEN APPLE!
0 likesUhhhhhhhhhhh she abandoned me BRUH?!!!
0 likesAre you ok!?!?!?!??!?!??!?!?!?!
0 likes🍏🍌
0 likesRandom theory: the golden apples are actually a way to clone ponies that's why all the royal guards look identical. And that's how Princess Celestia got her guards. Maybe instead of being eaten they would be used in a spell or magic potion!
1 likeReplies (2)
I love this idea, but I'm so attached to a previous theory by sawtooth they said that Celestia used the mirror pool to clone her gards.
0 likesThen perhaps the golden apple tree and the mirror pool are linked somehow, maybe they both have the same intrinsic magical essence or something. The tree could watered with the water from the magic mirror pool, or there is am underground system that the tree taps into. Either way, they both have shiny surfaces that reflect a pony looking at it to signify its cloning abilities. Alternatively, Celestia could have used her magic or something else to contain the essence of the mirror pool into creating fruits that do the same thing for easier access
0 likes8:12 oof
0 likesGood point
0 likesGranny Smith>
0 likesgive hope
0 likesUhm lol you had a bow
0 likesQuestion......i don't have any questions.....you iter answered most of them or ignored them...
0 likes3:00
0 likeswhy dont the pony's bleed
0 likesReplies (1)
Because kids show.
0 likes1:02
0 likesTie evil
0 likesponywater
0 likes🥇🍎
0 likesWhy is there so many alicorn videos
0 likesWait wait how did u become a pegasus😑🤨
0 likesReplies (1)
They're a changeling?
0 likesI think their power is conditional on what type of pony you are. They Grant Wishes for Earth Ponies and provide Eternal Youth for Alicorns. We haven't seen what happens when a Pegasus or Unicorn eats one.
0 likesA is for-
0 likesHere's a thought. Granny Smith's father was renowned as a seed collector. She said he was the greatest seed collector in all Equestria. That doesn't sound like a profession worth celebrating, no matter how good you are at it. Unless Granny Smith's father made a living going out into dangerous places and gathering the seeds of rare plants that don't grow in tamer ecosystems. Also, in the part of Granny Smith's founding of Ponyville story where she talks about how Celestia granted her family the frontier land that would become Ponyville, I could be mistaken, but the wording of her story seems to imply that the land grant was in part due to Celestia recognizing value in what Granny Smith's father did. If you think about it a certain way, there could be more than novelty to Spike's idea of showing Applejack Celestia's Golden Apple Tree. What if the Golden Apple Tree was the product of a rare seed gifted to Celestia by Granny Smith's father? Perhaps as thanks for the land, or even for the honor of having his value recognized by the 'Greatest Pony in the land'?
0 likesAre you seriously a DJ because all of the music videos you have been I mean like have got to be DJ I know you are a DJ
0 likesUnfortunately, most apples in mythology aren't even apples.
0 likesThe Golden Apple of Discord and the apple of the Hesperides are two different fruits as well.
But that only let's your first bit fall apart.
New evidence for Eternal Youth?
Look no further than Tirek
What THEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!! 😱😱😱😱😱😱 I.......CAN ......NOT .....BELIEVE ......ITTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2 likesReplies (2)
Did not expect this!!!! From Celista!!!!😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱
1 likeI as going to Netflix QUICKLY AND GOING TO THE EPISODE TO SEE IF IT WAS TRUE!!!!!!!!!!!!! AND.........IT...................WAS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱
1 likeUhhh i tought you are a boy why are you wearing a ribbon? But what the when you said raise an eyebrow but the eyebrow was flying 🤣😂
0 likesequestrianwater
0 likesMinecraft golden apple hahaha jk 😅😆😆
0 likesBro where are we ponies
0 likesPlz do wat if Changlings was real ponies or where genn5 map
0 likesI heard a bad story about the mame 6 First up pinky pie rainbow dash apple jack Fluttershy raraty die when they were old eccept twilight sparkle survive being a princess
0 likesI think day breaker is real
1 likeReplies (1)
She's not.
0 likesHi sawtooth waves
0 likesit can be too eat
0 likesThis is minecraft
0 likesNot related to the theory, but now I’m very interested in mythology corellations... does anyone know any videos that walk through it?
0 likesAaaaaaaaaaaa loookk aaaaatttt Yyyyyyoooouuuuurrrrrr Baaaacackkkkkrrrroouuuunnndd!!!!?????!!???!?!??!???!?!?!?
1 likeThere is only one thing that has golden apples and it is not miythacal minecraft
0 likes🍎😦
0 likesWait really?
1 likeno soundwave whatever your name if it's not right
0 likesMaybe they are not fruits and are money 🙄🙄🙄🙄
0 likes1:30
0 likesleave your thoughts in the comments... says the pony who turned off coments last video
0 likesWhy haven’t you splats
0 likes♾️
0 likesits also posible that the golden apples do grant immortality but only to alicorns, there may be something about them that makes them poisonus to normal ponies, perhaps they are packed full of magic energy and a normal pony just doesnt have room for the amount of it and it causes them damage isntead of rujuvination....its also posible that celestia just casts an age spell on herself every few hundred years, she has the capability by now.
0 likescough Undertale cough
1 likeReplies (1)
This has nothing to do with Undertale.
0 likesSo sawtooth is a Ukrainian-soviet royal?!
0 likesReplies (6)
NO. They're showing support for Ukraine BECAUSE UKRAINE IS BEING INVADED BY RUSSIA.
0 likes@Reese yeah because of that mean old Vladimir Putin.
0 likes@Reese are they royalty at least?
0 likesSo their the monarch of the Soviets.
0 likes@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 You know nothing about the current war.
0 likes@Reese no I guess not and neither do you my friend.
0 likes6:00 I don't understand what you are saying?
0 likes:D
0 likesThis is nolonger a channel about ponies this is an arg.
0 likesSo sawtooth is a soviet??
0 likesReplies (5)
NO?
0 likes@Reese so where did toot come from the Soviet Union changeling hive??
0 likes@Reese so he's not a soviet?
0 likes@ponyhorse & muledonkey.🐎🐴 NO THEY ARE NOT. PLEASE STOP CALLING THEM A HE. THEY'RE NON-BINARY.
0 likes@Reese get they are gender less.
0 likesI got 3 question?
0 likesat least queen chrysalis does not know about this.
0 likesReplies (2)
It wouldn't effect her, as they're only for alicorns, and she's not an alicorn.
0 likesNot the apple. Sawtooth.
0 likes1:00
0 likes😎😎😎😎😎🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂
0 likesWhat if alicorns were the only ponies that have enough magical power to absorb the golden apple's magic? That means that only alicorns can use it and if a normall pony eats it, it doesn't do anything. That explains why twilights friends grew old and Twilight didn't.
0 likescorn
0 likes😳😳😳😳😳😳😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱
0 likesMy birthday is April 22nd
0 likesI think that the reason why the non-alicorns didn’t eat the golden apples / why they weren’t shared is bc it might be dangerous or deadly for non-alicorns (maybe it’s bc I’m in the Percy Jackson fandom but I think the golden apples might work like Ambrosia)
0 likesTHE CHANGELINGS ARE GERMAN DO YOU MEAN FROM GERMANY OR SWITZERLAND
0 likesMy power it being drained no
0 likesI completely disagree. Celestia would never keep inmortal fruit to herself. She’s been a great friend and mentor to Twilight. I can’t imagine she would do something so sinister. Celestia is good and will always be there for Equestria, princess or not.
2 likes… … … … … … … they figure it out f!#$@$@#
0 likesDamm you mythologies, you copied Minecraft!
0 likesI just want to point out one thing, her not giving out the apples if they were immortality giving, there are millions of ponies, how would she even be able to supply it to everyone? You can say she could breed them to be that many but it's obviously heavily magic based and there is no garenteed that they can even breed properly, let alone the other nastey side affects they could possibly have.
1 likei swear your theories are so on point
2 likesANOTHER GREAT JOB SAWTOOTH!
2 likesNow I'm going to find a golden apple in Minecraft.
2 likesWow this makes so much since plus how much times did you have to rewatch that sene of spike saying that lol
2 likesThis is so interesting!!
2 likesI like the reasoning in this one. Nice vid ^^
1 likeBe careful Sawtooth, they're after you
2 likesReplies (2)
huh??
0 likes@Sawtooth Waves nopony (or creature) was supposed to know....
0 likesI love your videos and they are very Interesting
1 likeMy god I love these videos
2 likesMake so much sense! (Love your videos!!!)😁
1 likeThis theory might be real.
1 likeAmazing job 👍
0 likesAwesome and cool!
2 likesSawtooth ate a golden apple!
1 likeOh great another alicorn video, welp, my friends owe me 5 pounds
1 likeMlp still has lore to discover?????
1 likeAmazing video i like it
1 likeSawtooth wave this is Equestria smiles agency open up
2 likesEyy they’re back!
1 likeOnce the mlp g5 comics come out please make a theory video
1 likeCool Video!
2 likesOoh! Awesome!
1 likeremember you said celestia is grogar
1 likeAwesome video
0 likesYES NEW ONE
1 likeThird Ig
1 likeYour video are the best
The theorys and everything... Even the songs
My favorite is brand new pair of wings 😍
Keep it up👍
hello i like your channel.
1 likeOMG, i am so early..anyway love ur videos
1 likeHuh, interesting.
1 likeI don't know maybe how knows 🍎 and you look beautiful lol
1 like😮
2 likesCool
2 likesI liked the vid
1 likespooky
1 likeLet me guess you got into undertale au's assess with the apples in dreamtale. Heheheheheheheheheheheh I mean you know you know
0 likesWhoa I’m so early!
1 likeI cant beleive im early-
1 like1 minute ago….dang :3 I was early for once
1 likeApple.
1 likeWant to be in my anamation movie with a bunch of other anamation youtubers
0 likesWow
1 likeOooOoOoOoMG saludos desde Perú pipipiii
1 likeI am here lov your videos
1 likeWhy flutershy can talk to animals
0 likesLol you always put memes in your videos for some reason? 🤨
1 likeEarly gang 😃
1 likeHi I'm a long time viewer
1 like✨😊Hello 😊✨
1 likeYou look very nice in a ribbon
1 likeReplies (1)
thank you so much ^^
0 likesHi Sawtooth
1 likeYou steal a Applem forum Dreamtale the put in the cover.
0 likesReplies (5)
I'm not sure that specific one was from Dreamtale
1 likeDoesn't look like Joku's artstyle
@CrystalKitty1220ok????
0 likes@flying Flame Did I read your comment wrong? It's kinda all over the place.
1 like@CrystalKitty1220 They're accusing Sawtooth of "stealing an apple from Dreamtale", not realizing that they could've made it themselves.
1 like@Reese okay so I did read it right
1 liketell aboud human srarlight's life
2 likesReplies (5)
check out my video "starlight attends hive high"!
0 likes@Sawtooth Waves we would go more deeper
0 likes@Sawtooth Waves or maybe why twi light's magic color change
0 likes@Sana Eba💜 What do you mean? Her magic changed because Hasbro's animation team got better at it.
0 likes@Reese maybe the is more going on
0 likesYour cute :3
1 likeReplies (2)
thank you!!!!!
1 like@Sawtooth Waves woah you actually comment I’m surprised 😱 you also look cute with that bow :)
0 likesMy earliest view on a video with me being 8 seconds late
1 likeno no no
1 likeHow 🤔 ❓
0 likesWhen did he
0 likesEternal oldness doesn't work. The only reason you die due to old age is due to 'oldness'. If such apples could reduce the effective age of a pony biologically, it isn't like they'd die at 80 of a heart attack despite otherwise being at peak health.
0 likesMuch more likely are the age-spells which we know to be canon - though then there is the open question of why she hadn't cast them on her friends (maybe they lose their effectiveness with repeated use)
1 min early
2 likesYOOO
0 likes@2:22 your mean pilipino well bakunawa
0 likesIs this his last video
0 likesReplies (1)
No, it's not their last video.
0 likesOh ya
2 likesSo many fricking bots.
1 likePolice and helicopter
1 likeWoohoo
1 likeIn how seosons come and go?winter
0 likesSpring etc
hmm...
0 likesOmg the first minute
2 likesFirst time early suiiii
1 likeBut Luna = nigtmare mon she whas yers 100 days band how did she not get it
0 likesReplies (1)
Yers not days
0 likesEarly
1 likeEarly
1 like🦄☀️😈
0 likesOr it just
0 likesWho r u?
1 likeWhat?
0 likesHi
2 likeshi
1 likehiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
0 likeswhat
0 likesAhhhhhh😑😑come on!!!!!!! I have commented a million times
0 likesHey hey hey
0 likesHi
1 likeHi
1 likeHi
1 likeMy guess is why she is immortal (possibly why luna was immortal as well) is that their essence was tied to the elements of harmony which would arrest their aging. This connection would be severed however when the mane 6 would take up the elements and their connection severed when they were destroyed.
0 likesOof
0 likesYou know Celestia and Luna are Norse mithologie copies. Just wiki what moves the sun and moon in norse mithologie, you'll see.
0 likesIam humen not any tybe of well anything thats not a humen but i like ur vids
0 likesHello
2 likes444th viewer
1 likewhy you didn't post
0 likesearrrllly
1 like🤔🤔
0 likeshi
0 likesSo many comments from me
0 likesyeah
0 likesHey I just realized that were is discord and the mean 3 .
1 likeHey
0 likesNão ê bon😠😠😠
0 likesYes I get to post the first comment also what😟
1 like441 comments
0 likesBye
0 likesDannnggg
1 likeReally
0 likesHey
0 likesFirst
1 likeooo
0 likesum
0 likesOooooo
0 likesDunno
0 likes.
0 likesMLP
0 likesE Die 1.9
0 likesNerd
0 likesDo you support ships
0 likesHey uh Sawtooth your comments for poison joke video is turned off
0 likesSawtooth, can you stop ignoring me for once and listen to this, what is the element of Flurryheart (Yes I'm assuming you can figure that out with your big brain gameplay) Well, don't keep me waiting, make a video about it and name it "The Element Of Flurryheart Finally Solved" Pwease? Pwetty pwease? (I'm asking politely in a cute tone)
0 likesReplies (2)
Flurry Heart has no element. We never see her fully grown in the show, and there's little to no hints on what her title is.
0 likes@Reese Wait, no element? Oh
0 likes