Before it came out, I was discussing it with my non-brony friend who likes to analyse pony stuff and we were thinking it would follow the clichés of interdimentional travel movies- suddenly and inexplicably thrown into a new world, the hero must search for a way to get back and a villain blocking their path must be defeated only to open the way, coincidentally saving the local world in the process. After I watched EG, I told him about how Twi was sent there on a planned quest, the door was open the whole time and she was trying to defeat a villain from her own world in order to protect that one from where she was. However, after talking about how it was all 'teen movie' and seemed to follow the 'popularity contest against the popular bitch' format of half the teen movies in existence, he summed it up as follows: "So they managed to dodge one cliché only to run face first into another."

@DazeDream it should have every villain in the entirety of FiM attack, Nightmare Moon (Luna actually becoming evil and resentful instead of on purpose) and Discord (again, evil and truly chaotic, not his nice new air of fun) and all the rest in the whole series.

Lol this just reminded me of an old Robot Chicken sketch from before FiM came out-
"My little ponies, apocalypse ponies! Punish mankind for their sins!"
If you haven't seen that you should totally look it up it's hilarious. It's probably on You Tube. I laughed my head off at it long before I was a brony. I love that sort of comedic juxtaposition of innocent and horrible, it's why I watch things like FiW and MLP:YTPs

Haha I agree.  A my little pony movie with actual ponies shouldn't be a novel concept.  I can see the adds now: normal girly intro "... the new My Little Pony movie!" screen goes dark and sinister, voice becomes evil "... The Shadow Apocalypse" violent action scenes "Coming soon!" lol

Haha I agree.  A my little pony movie with actual ponies shouldn't be a novel concept.  I can see the adds now: *normal girly intro* "... the new My Little Pony movie!" *screen goes dark and sinister, voice becomes evil* "... The Shadow Apocalypse" *violent action scenes* "Coming soon!" lol

It was not bad, I kinda liked it but it just didn't have the same quality it could have had. The next one might be okay too, but I really want to see an mlp movie that actually has ponies in it. Something big and epic with the fate of all Equestria on the line. Instead of "My Little Ponies: Rainbow Rocks" do "My Little Ponies: Shadow Apocalypse" or something. ... that was lame. I dunno, I'm bad at names. You know what I mean.

Eeyup.  That's exactly what they did.  I did like that movie, but the cliches were pretty bad.  And now there making a rock band... |:(  FiW saw this coming in there "Horse Women" teaser, when FiW Twilight said "Let's start a rock band!"


This is a very nice way to look at a movie that I saw as trying to hit every stereotype as if they had a quota of bad writing to fill. I don't think it was a subversion at all, and the movie is still to this day the very worst thing to ever come from FIM. I saw something made with no heart, everyone on the team knowing this was only a cashgrab to sell toys... It was what everyone expected of FiM before they watched it. If anything, it subverts the main series as being an actually good show with likable characters and good plot.

But it's nice to think of it your way.


0:18 hand? what is a hand? i only know hooves


We’re al in this together I love the hidden message thing


How did Sunset know where to gwt the crown and knew how the crown looked like?


PLEASE JUST DONT TALK ABOUT HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL!!!

@worm time! You didn't know you were being replied to by a popular person back then. Look at this now.

@The Brony Notion omfg this comment... I lost my cool when I read it! XD I couldn't help but break down and laugh.

But... this could be the start of something new! I feel like if we bop to the top and work this out, we could be breaking free. Where all in this together so why stick to the status quo? Some one needs to get their head in the game. ;D


Seeing Eg and the critics on it. i have to agree with the critics more. Heck I plan to do a rewrite to make a better story on the concept of EG


I'm watching every one of these videos. No regrets so far.


I replayed that part were you said what! like 7 times<br>E-yup bra

I replayed that part were you said what! like 7 times
E-yup bra


Me as my 10 year old self (I am 10 right now) : I WAS 3 WHEN THIS VIDEO CAME OUT


Bad writing or hidden message?<br>Or maybe a little bit both 🤔

Bad writing or hidden message?
Or maybe a little bit both 🤔


For once, Hasbro needs to make SOMETHING go wrong and not get fixed. It was all plotted out perfectly to make it work perfectly. But wen you look deeper, you see these kinds of things! It sounds perfect, but something needs to go wrong and they don't have the solution and let if fly. I would like to see how the Mane Six would handle it. A new experience maybe for those who have watched MLP:FiM!


I just dont get it why twilight always wins

Maybe because they make the good guy almost every time win?


This is how many times he said "But No"
 |
V


I DID TOO! I THOUGHT SHED SAY SUNSET SHIMMER!


The game itself makes a lot better but I don’t know


i loved equestria girls and i hate high school musical


i agree with all of that but just wow that blew my mind always forget to like this time i will remember


Can you make a video about the story behind sunset shimmers cutie mark? This is a random question, but I just am really curious. Because when you look at it, it kinda reminds you of princess celestias cutie mark. So is Sunset shimmer princess celestias child or something??? Please do a video on this.


so......High School Musical: Subversion<br>???

so......High School Musical: Subversion
???


they just want to tell the people was watching it who be one of other and kind to each other😎✌


Equestria girls seriously reminds me of teen beach movie

@Ajoya Monell  Not judging .I don't like it either. It seems cliched

Omg nothing's worse then that movie :x don't judge me!


Can we get to 100 Followers without any videos?


how did Apple bloom and the others go to high school!


DONT TALK ABOUT HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL!!! AND IF YOU DO I WILL TROW MEMES AT YOU


Were do you think sunset will fit in at lunch if she wasn't so evil


Zahwa kazi + The Brony Notion
Pls check out my comment on 'who exactly is cadance?' Cause u have not responded to the bunch of comments trying to give u clues about the magic aurora stuff......
Merry Christmas!!😊🎄🎅🎉🎊🎈🎁🎆


Thats because mlp is for mostly kids so hasbro make mlp eg <br>A high school life for kids

Thats because mlp is for mostly kids so hasbro make mlp eg
A high school life for kids


You have a cutie mark you should know what they mean


I think Twilight with Rainbow Dash, Rarity and FlutterShy,


Mr Notion I am a big fan of you please make 50000000000000000000000000,00000000000000000000000 in your future!😊😊😊😊😊😳😳<br>


I have a question: is apple bloom and her friends steel sisters with applejack, rarity and rainbow dash in equestria girls?


Buttercupkat Productions CHRISTMAS RIGHT! (HALLOWS EVE IS NOT COORRRECT I GUSEEEEss


...it's WAY too early to say merry christmas

@Sounds_spp - Oh nah, you're fine-- XD I made this comment 6 years ago, and sometimes I like to reply to my past self for the heck of it lol. Apologies if it seemed like I was upset at you 🙇♀


stupid play list I ment for that one to be on the Scootaloo episode.


Thanks for sharing man I was starting to wonder if you liked it or not.


HAS BRO?!?!?!?!?!?        ( Is that how you spell it? )          I don't like how they just take popular stuff into a game get everyones ope up in how something will hapen


Dude you are watching a little girl show

Yes he's is do you have a problem with that's.