Seeing this man slowly come to the realization that Weird Al was voicing a character in MLP was one of the greatest things I've seen!  XD


I love how the concept of this episode is that they needed someone to put Pinkie’s element to the test just like each of the other Mane 6 in this season, but how do you make someone a believable rival to freaking Pinkie Pie? How do you make a character who can outgoof the Element of Laughter herself? <br>The only solution: make them Weird Al!!! The king of goofiness in the real world.

I love how the concept of this episode is that they needed someone to put Pinkie’s element to the test just like each of the other Mane 6 in this season, but how do you make someone a believable rival to freaking Pinkie Pie? How do you make a character who can outgoof the Element of Laughter herself?
The only solution: make them Weird Al!!! The king of goofiness in the real world.

Weird Al will destroy the world and I'm honestly fine with this.

Nah your almighty goddess pinkie pie still rules the world muhahahaha and if she doesn't in your book she will come to you


They didn't have to try too hard to get Weird Al . . . He's a huge fan of the show!  XD

True Edge I didn’t know he watched this show prior to him being on it. That’s cool!


Pinkie and Cheese's voices sound so beautiful together❤

The minute he saw Pinkie again in this episode, he probably instantly thought- "She is going to be my wife."


Pinkie vs Weird Al is a battle for the ages.


3:24 "Even Pinkie can see your bulls#!%, Diamond Tiara."
Still, you gotta admit that filly has a surprisingly good singing voice.

That naturally comes back in the next musical episode

@@Narrator007  I wish she was allowed to appear post reformation

@@Icy-be5vl If by better you mean more entertaining, then of course!  It's not even a contest.

I know I wish she had more screen time after season five to see her bond with the CMC

@@BaileeFerguson82 I kept hearing at conventions that the writers and other show staff wanted to write more stories for Diamond Tiara after that season, but the Hasbro execs just weren't interested.  😕

@@Narrator007 Well that sucks cause I wanted to see some character growth!


This episode..., ah man it’s awesome. Lol! I never expected to see guest stars in MLP, but having Weird Al starting this trend took me by surprise. This episode with its wacky shenanigans between Cheese and Pinkie, I just can’t get over these two here. And the songs, they are all great as well. Great reaction man!

I know this is 2 years old but John De Lancie technically started that trend in Season 2 by voicing Discord.


As always, an excellent reaction to an extra fun episode!

Another bit of trivia -- Pinkie Pride originally aired back in 2014, two years earlier (in 2012) William Anderson (the composer of much of MLP background music) was hanging out with Weird Al and William posted a brief video segment where Al mentioned that he'd like to be on the show.  You can see it here: https://youtu.be/771H5ob4atU

And speaking of pony related videos, are you planning to fit in any other fun "pony extras" as the season rolls on?  I (for one) would love to see you react to the very first pony-thing ever ("Rescue at Midnight Castle") in the not too distant future!  Gotta love the weirdness that the '80's cartoons could get away with.  (Shoo be doo!)


I knew when you said you love Weird Al that you would be in for a good time with this episode. This is one of my favorites. It's a really entertaining ride through and throughout that still hasn't gotten old. Sometimes, they'll do a musical episode packed with songs. And when the songs all hit the mark like they do here, it makes a pretty special episode.


It is always a damn RIOT to watch a reactor when they first realize who's voicing Cheese.

Fantastic how the story just keeps jerking us around emotionally. The delight of "ZOMG WEIRD AL" runs headlong into "ZOMG PINKIE SAD NO," and then Pinkie's heartbreaking song suddenly turns around into the most joyous ditty we've gotten since Smile.

13:42 We've already had inexplicable references to Clint Eastwood's Man with No Name--so why not toss in an inexplicable reference to "3:10 to Yuma"?


Been waiting for this one. My fave episode of all time. Partly cause of Wierd Al being in it, but also Pinkie is my fave pony and I just loved her in this episode.

This for me is the best Pinkie episode and is what made Amy Keating Rogers my fav writer of the show, well, next to Meghan McCarthy and Larson.  I was so sad when she left the show, even though it was understandable.


I would definitely want Pinkie Pie as my party planner. I mean come on who wouldn't want her.


I'd qualify these types of episodes as the 'musical' episodes, where about half of it the episode is song, often starting and ending (Or close to ending) with songs.

Another way to tell if it’s a musical episode is if Daniel Ingram composed the score instead of William Anderson. You see, Ingram normally only worked on the songs, but for every musical episode of the series (as well as the theatrical movie) he composed all the music.


Rainbow’s cake had 21 candles (which supports the idea that the Mane 6 are early 20s). But there might be candles on the other side of the cake that we can’t see (when she blows out the candles she’s going round the back of the cake where we can’t see)

Or maybe the candles were just more aesthetic than indicative. . .

AnthrozilWarrior3 that’s what I was implying with “there might be candles on the other side of the cake”

That makes her 42 years old. Somehow the idea of Rainbow – being 42 is really neat

Well it’s confirmed that they’re young adults. I’m pretty sure that the candles go all around (it would be weird to put candles only one side of a cake), but they are in fact adults.

@@magicmon What do you mean? Pretty sure these ponies age the same as humans, not like actual horses.

@@magicmon huh? The Mane 6 looks really young for being "42"


Weird Al did not write any of the songs in this episode, but The Super Duper Party Pony is exactly his type of song. Also, the guy who made the music score for this series (at least to this point) used to be in his band

That’s true because the score composer of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic himself, William Anderson used to be in Weird Al’s band back in 1985 in The Stupid Tour before he started composing music for commercials, film, TV, gaming and theater, but mostly composing music for animation, in the early ‘90s and he also scored and produced the music of The Weird Al Show back in 1997.


17:48 "I'm sorry I got all swept away by Cheese Sandwich." "We all are."
Forget Flash Sentry. Cheese Sandwich was the ultimate waifu stealer all along.

Flash sentry and Timber : we are the ultimate waifu stealers! <br>Cheese sandwich : hold my canon child

Flash sentry and Timber : we are the ultimate waifu stealers!
Cheese sandwich : hold my canon child


15:15 "How is she eating so many cupcakes?"
When you fly as fast as Rainbow Dash does, you burn a lot of calories.

15:15 "How is she eating so many cupcakes?"
When you fly as fast as Rainbow Dash does, you burn a _lot_ of calories.


Still my favorite episode after all these years.


"how does she keep the full intergrity  of the rainbow"
oh that's simple by:
DO
NOT
QUESTION
PINKIE PIE

"how does she keep the full intergrity  of the rainbow"
oh that's simple by:
*DO*
*NOT*
*QUESTION*
*PINKIE PIE*


You know it's a good one when you need to recover afterward! Great episode, great reaction.


I really liked this episode, but I liked weird Al as Cheese better in season 9's the last laugh because in this episode Cheese is encroaching on Pinkies territory and he's kind of an asshole to her as a result in the last laugh they're  starting to fall in love with each other they are married by the last episode and have a child together.


Been waiting for you to get to this gem of an episode for awhile, glad you enjoyed it. It was a great reaction. :)


Been waiting for this episode when you let slip in an earlier season you where a Weird Al fan. Your enthusiasm did not disappoint. XD


This is my 2nd best episode in the series. Weird Al as a pony is great. A great test of Pinkie Pies' element. The goof off is insane.


I guess we’re going to gloss over that there’s something extra in the picture of Pinkie’s first party with her family.

She just gets created by the writers in thin air just gets atomically created from nothing


That has to be one of my favorite reactions of you on this show. Three cheers for Weird Al, and bro hoof. /)


Here's the direct translation of the Spanish portion of the song:<br>Give it, give it, give it, don't lose your mind, because if you lose it, you lose your way

Here's the direct translation of the Spanish portion of the song:
Give it, give it, give it, don't lose your mind, because if you lose it, you lose your way


screaming
I LOVE this episode!! Can't wait to watch your reaction to it!

*screaming*
I LOVE this episode!! Can't wait to watch your reaction to it!


I came back to watch your reaction to this episode. It is one of my top 10 episodes of the entire series, and I need to consult my list, but I think I put it 5th or 6th. It and the season 5 episode Slice of Life, which you have already reacted to, are both at those two slots and switch depending on my mood. As for Weird Al Yankovic, he is a self confessed brony and asked if he could make a guest appearance on the show. He is not going to be the last famous person you encounter on here in a guest role.


I cannot express how much I love this episode


20:09 Rainbow: "Enough with the warm fuzzy stuff, you two."
PonyBro: "What?  I like warm and fuzzy, Rainbow."
That would explain your infatuation with so many of these mares.  ;D


Werid Al Yankovic is the weridest guy in a good way his Weirdness is represented in this episode and its perfect


Pinkie pride is one of the best episodes in the show 👍🏻


The episode where Pinkie met her husband lol


Wow… right off the bat you recognized Cheese’s voice!  That’s impressive.


3:50 "How is she keeping the integrity of the rainbow?"
Rainbow isn't the honest one; that's Applejack, silly!  =P


12:10 Role reversal: Derpy and the other background ponies are in the foreground, while the main characters are in the background.


21:16 is the cutest freezeframe for this episode!


It is SO GOOD to see another Weird Al fanatic! Your reactions were almost identical to mine.


Weird Al Yancovich is so perfect for this show, and in the second musical, too!


This was one of my favorite episodes of season 4


ive been waiting for this notification to come through i love this episode great job and all will be reviled about the rainbow eye thing soon


Weird Al did amazing voicing Cheese Sandwich!


I still love watching your slow realization that Weird AL was the voice of Cheese Sandwich. Most people don't realize it at all in their reactions.


this was my first episode i watched new. had seen a couple of reruns before this but this is the one that made me fall in love with the show


Cheese vs Pinkie was fun, but Cheese WITH Pinkie is better!


21:11 "How many candles is that?"
21.  Now RD won't have to hide her cider from the authorities.  :)


"Never boring even for a minute. It's my world and we're all livin' in it!"

I just got here after watching Milo Murphy

@@Silver-Arm Sweet. Can't go wrong with Weird Al!


It’s Pinkie Pie don’t question her. If you do It’ll drive you insane.


I had no idea weird Al was in that episode. I don’t even know who he is but that’s cool you recognized his voice in the episode!


This is the best Pinkie Pie episode & my favorite Pinkie Pie episode, and my favorite episode of season 4


7:45 ponybro got so excited over Cheese Sandwich he blew all over the mic.


Element of Loyalty, everyone. Element of Loyalty.
Shakes head in disappointment

Element of Loyalty, everyone. Element of Loyalty.
*Shakes head in disappointment*

Yeah, you disappointed us for the last time Rainbow Dash!

"How many times do we have to teach you this lesson old man!"


01:28 I'll tell you a the end if you won't guess it until then ;J But I guess that your comment section will be flooded with people telling you that ;J
02:28 Pinkie can run upside down :q
02:46 What is going on with that clock? :o
05:37 Bingo :> Yes, yes it is him ;)
06:46 Here you totally look like happy otter :)  So I can sure tell that you're happy :)
08:11 Cheese Sandwich looks like a male version of Pinkie Pie. I mean, even the hair style is the same :J
09:55 I wonder if it was intentional that this song sounds so similar to "A True, True Friend".
11:22 Note to myself: make yourself a hall of pictures that will remind you about all your successes and achievements, in case you forgot about being awesome :J Actually, everyone should have such a hall.
12:17 I don't know, to me it sounded like a skidding car :D
16:42 Yup, and it's not just some random Spanish, the lyrics seem to be relevant here. In English, it goes pretty much like this:
"Go on, go on, go on, Don't lose your goal, Because if you lose it, You'll lose the entire way."
Quite ironic, considering what was Pinkie's original goal in this episode: to make Rainbow Dash happy with her birthday party.
20:30 And that's why people should join their forces more often instead of competing :J They could be much stronger together.
21:03 Pony dance party :) Call me weird, but I like this short song the most :J
OK that's it for this episode. I'll thumb-up your video after someone messes up that perfect score ;J


12:16 "Rarity, are you really flirting with him?"
She wants to find out whether Cheese's accordion is the longest thing he's got.  ;)

'Course not! Longest thing he's got is his party pony career!


And here starts the great Cheese Pie ship<br>which was later confirmed in the last problem

And here starts the great Cheese Pie ship
which was later confirmed in the last problem


21:31 Behold princess Rarity the princess of animation errors


ah there is my episode 12 fix now i just need EVEN MORE


Listen again the "Make A Wish" song and only watch Rarity you gonna see something error/easter egg


I loved your reaction to the singing battle, you where just vibin


Rainbow Dash has always felt like the least loyal friend in the group imo


THREAT? 4:45 Cheese ain't no threat he's her MAN...or STALLION.

There are cultures that wouldn't understand your point :D


A musical but it’s in a 20 minute episode


And dude, at this point, embrace bronydom. You are clearly a brony at this point. Also, I've actually seen pics of dudes in the army with patches of Rainbow Dash's cutie mark on their camos


you think this episode has a lot of songs? believe me youve seen nothing yet


You the only one who caught the rainbooms in the pond. Besides me.


Tomyhill I have the remembrance reaction being uploaded in the next few days so there’s some sfm for ya


Hello, pony bro. I wonder if you can react to:
1 Double Rainboom?
2 MLP Meets Videos?
3 Pony Meets World?
Thank you in advance.


17:56 - you didn't do a f-ckin' thing, Spike...as usual. :p


I’m sorry to ask this but whose weird Al


Whos weird al?? Its not a joke i dont know him can someone tell me?

you can just search for his name in YouTube or Google or somewhere

He's a hilarious comedian and musician who got noticed by doing parodies of very famous songs that were always on the radio (Madonna, Queen, even stuff as recent as Lady Gaga)


Barack Excellent Saddam Worther King Hussein Obama II Obama Care Washington Black Kardashian Wasilla West President Hawaii Pony Obamaton Obama Jr


Extended/full version of "Make a Wish". https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c-Sx_42DrAg