Duh, the shadow pony is tierek! It was a sign! What do u think

Ronge fox asked what I was smoking, and so I replied.

I also have an other reason because look since Luna POSSIBLY made them he probably didn't like the way he looked so he put a cloak and hat on because he didn't like the way he looked and therefore because of that he wanted revenge on Luna and that also explains why he stays at the castle. that an other theory. P.S what whith the talking about the drugs man?

@Morning Dusk ... What are you smoking right now?

@Morning Dusk And are they OCs or are they part of the show?

I happen to be good acquaintances with several bat-ponies!

@Morning Dusk Um, how would anyone see them more often than I would? I've seen all the episodes, so what could others know that I don't?

@Morning Dusk There isn't really enough information about the bat ponies to say that they aren't all evil. We rarely see them in the show and they don't play a huge part.

Being a bat pony doesn't automatically make you evil! It's kind of a bit like being born with red hair, or the ability to roll your tounge, everypony has that possibility in them, it's just a recessive gene. Sure, they're a bit shunned, but then Luna took them in! Which, unfortunately, led to even more bad rumors about them. They are decent fellows!

@victoria ivey I like that idea. Maybe they're coming back to get Luna and turn her into Nightmare Moon :o

It can't be tierek because he has Arms and hands,therefore it can't be tierek. But there is a chance it could be one of Luna's guards! The yellow eyes and Granny Smiths story "apart of nightmare moon?" The guards were most likely made by Luna , because no pony has ears like that! So there's my theory.

@***** Discord's a Dragonquu....ot however it's spelled

@nicholas blackburn Centaur* and I guess he might count as half pony, but I still don't think he's the shadow pony

That's what I was thinking, I mean....he was wearing a cloak when he confronted that Male Unicorn..

tirek isn't a pony he is a centure so no he isn't the shadow pony. using the theory that the bad guys are coming back in opposite order is a lil misleading don't you think?

it's hard to type in sarcastic tone of voice

-_- I WAS BEING SARCASTIC WHEN I SAID OR HE'S SOMBRA

"I've been defeated but before I get revenge, I shall purchase this nice wizardy hat it's so cool" Totally something the king of darkness would say

you don't know that, after the crystal empire thing he could have gotten a wizard hat

@Morning Dusk Sombra doesn't wear a wizard hat he isn't even a wizard

@Firesword theMoviegamer What if the shadow pony governs the town in season 5 and he just torments them and stuff

not really, he could have just heard them talking, not seen them. also Hasbro is never going to reveal who it is so... yeah.

Tirek has a hooded cloak not a wizard hat. Also he would've seen Alicorn Twilight

Well maybe Granny Smith is older than you think...

Btw, how do u know so much about mlp? I'm a huge fan as we'll, but u know WAY more than i do about mlp lol

You have a point, I just thought it was an animator's mistake with the hood #1 #2, again it may have been  a sign.

Nah, well he could be, but I don't think so. Nothing points to him being the shadow pony, except for the fact that they both have yellow eyes and hoods. The eyes are shaped differently and the hood doesn't look as rugged as Tirek's. Plus, Granny Smith was the first reported one to see the shadow pony, and that was long before Tirek escaped. idk you could be right /)


2:41 to 3:09 they talk about the pony of shadows in season 7 the episodes shadow play part one and two both ft the pony of shadows Im thinking that Sombra did  die but what if his spirit is the pony of shadows it is just darkness and shadows its not a real pony cause Stygian came back and they banished that darkness after


ok, so I think there are more than 1 shadow pony. Why? Cause in season 7 of mlp, when Starswirl and the pillars or whatever they're called returned, the shadow pony which was NOT King Sombra was there. His real name was Stigien ( I think thats how its spelled). So I know this is like a comment 3 years later but yea. :)


I have an idea that might overthrow your idea that's Sombra that's the ice I meant the shadow Pony what about the long horn I didn't see him having a horn in there and I watch the whole episode did I blow your mind.


well, MAYBE that leftover magic took over starswirl and MADE him the shadow pony


No, Starswirl isn't the pony of shadow , look to s7 final , he is in ,,limbo" (other dimension) over the 1000 years!

What is it with everyone and equating the Shadow Pony with Stygian? I get that he's referred to as 'the Shadow Pony', but he cannot be the pony of shadows which appears in Castle Mane-ia - he was in Limbo at that time with no way to escape!

The writers have caused unnecessary confusion by calling Stygian 'the Shadow Pony', but that does not mean he's the same character as the Shadow Pony from Castle Mane-ia.

What is it with everyone and equating the Shadow Pony with Stygian? I get that he's referred to as 'the Shadow Pony', but he _cannot_ be the pony of shadows which appears in Castle Mane-ia - he was in Limbo at that time with no way to escape!

The writers have caused unnecessary confusion by calling Stygian 'the Shadow Pony', but that does _not_ mean he's the same character as the Shadow Pony from Castle Mane-ia.

Actually he said the shadow pony meaning the shadow in the episode not the pony of shadows

You do realize that this video came out before that episode, right?


Star swirl the bearded banished the shadow Pony and himself and his crew to limbo because they wanted to make sure he didn't escape the shadow Pony  was created when star swirls friend, pigeon got jealous I think and star swirl and his crew banished him from his crew I think so he got mad or jealous and became the pony of shadows


Brony: star swirl the bearded is the shadow pony <br>Stigien: am I a joke to u

Brony: star swirl the bearded is the shadow pony
Stigien: am I a joke to u


I think that The Pony of Shadows is a Character from Season Nine

(Also this is just a joke so don’t take this seriously)


Starswirl's used to be one of his  friends stigian who was cast out by the others and turn to darkness


His name is not the shadow pony it is the pony at the finale episode of season 7


Aaaaand now we know that it was almost 100% stigian XD


Turn to shadow means they turned him to shadow . Before he did not have a shadow form


Sawtooth: who’s the shadow pony<br>Me: just wait a bit

Sawtooth: who’s the shadow pony
Me: just wait a bit


NO  ITS PINKI  THE  END OF THE EPISODE   SHE SAYS DAT WAS ME

+loke griberg no, but she's with the ponies when spike say " shadow pony.... yeah right " and then the shadow pony appears

Wow! So the case has LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONG been uncovered?!

@Kawaii Eyes there's nothing about the first good king of equestria in MLP.Maybe you're right about Tirek,but i don't see any logic.If that was a Tirek then Tirek will still magic at once.That's not Tirek.Do you even know what song Pinkie was playing? Do you even know that luna give her a notes of that song? do you even know why exacly that song?

@Kawaii Eyes a question please.Who was the first good ruler of equestria?(if you're the good fan).

+Daniel Antony Trixie didn't have yellow eyes.

+Kawaii “Apparently Beautiful” Eyes Tirek had Red eyes.

+Kawaii “Apparently Beautiful” Eyes who is tirek do you mean  tricksie


Maybe Hasbro will make an episode where we meet the shadow pony.


while apple jack was telling the story, i herd her say dark magic. star swirl dosnt have dark magic. he has unicorn magic.'' well, STORNG  unicorn magic. so now we know star swirl isnt the shadow pony

by


guys have some support he's trying his best


I think its zecora cause look at the clip ''evil enchantress'', the eyes are the same and she would have a cape , though it could also be one of her evil family members.

XGamerGirlRulesX She's an evil enchantress.....lol.....

Adolene Fowler if she didnt have family members then she wouldnt have been born.

XGamerGirlRulesX well that isnt the case she lives in the everfree forest just like the location of the palace of when we see the shadow pony for the first time right BUT she doesnt know where it is if she did she would've went there but she never claims she did. Boom

XGamerGirlRulesX I am not trying to be mean but I do not think Zecora has any family members great thought though


it could be star swirl because maybe he did a spell to leave his soul,a and then night mare moons left of evil that was left behind corrupted star swirl's soul.


I think its Star Swirl, BUT maybe like, somehow corrupted by some sort of evil or dark magic?


le shadow pony could be a leftover bit of starswirls magic after he got turned into discord


It could be chrysalis because she can transform into any thing so she could be planning her atack and taking form of nightmare moon

@***** in all honestly i dont believe it is chrysalis because from the looks of it she was sent the the Badlands, as i call it, or the land nopony has ever explored, so even for a whole 2 seasons it would be a long trip, and take notice, this is roughly about half a year after she was exiled (if any logical guess was to be made). she would have been weak and or injured.

But her eyes can obviously change. Think back to the wedding episode, her eyes were exactly like Cadence's exept when she herself changed them in This Day Aria.

@***** AND the shadow pony history is an old history, if she really was the shadow pony, she was doing it in the PAST, not necessarily in the present.

But if it were Chrysalis how could she come back after she was defeated by very powerful magic and if it is true why would she change form. I mean if I were her I would just let the Mane 6 know I was there, because they didn't have the elements of harmony with them. She could have easily defeated them right there while no pony was around for miles.

@***** No, there is some times that a fight is good vs evil, but not this time.

@***** Yes, but it was the only choice that she had. We don't know if there was another way to help her people, that fight wasn't a good vs evil battle, it was a battle for survival. It's like in the wild, a lion needs to kill other animals for surviving. One will live, the another will die.

@***** One way or another, technically she's not a villain, she was fighting for the survival of her people, she didn't have another choice :v

@***** Maybe, maybe not, i don't know why she would do it, but it's something that she can do.

Not only Chrysalis, any changeling could be the shadow pony. And being a grandma Smith's history, this shadow pony would be from the past, right?

@Elizabeth Spencer i dont think she is dead but was sent far away

@Elizabeth Spencer<br>How do you know,but not

@Elizabeth Spencer
How do you know,but not

no not that<br>he asked you not to say jerk

no not that
he asked you not to say jerk

i know that i was mearly defending what yoiu had said as i saw nothing wrong with it (my opinion)

the j word......k i used to be a mormon so i used to be against swearing and im pretty sure jerk is not a bad word so i dont think its offensive so if your offended thats your choice to be offended others should not have to bend down to your will because you chose to be offended when what they said was not offensive and was not even geared toward you

@OMGPOP1604 plz dont sey the j wrd and i did mis spell

I don't mean to be a jerk but you spelled she wrong

chrysalis isn't a pony because no cutiemark she is a changeling so she cant be the shadow pony


I think that 'Trixie' is the 'Pony Of Shadows' cuz she WAS kind of AGAINEST the 'Main 6'........


could it be one of the evil people when they went through time


But at the end of the episode well you showed us the bell on Star Swirl but when we saw the shadow pony there was no bell at the end of the hat so it couldn't be him


He was right, Star Swirl is the shadow pony


This theory is dead, but idc this was like 6 yrs ago 💀


I think the Shadow pony is the one that was sent to Limbo


discord does disappear through out the show where does he even go? the hat explains that he got it since he is star swirled the bearded


No he is not the shadow pony he is good I have good reasons bear with me hear
1     he is not dark magic
2      he was a normal pony NOT A SHADOW
3      he was the techer of clover the clever so if he was she  must of known that she surly would of told somepony
4       cilesta can see timeahead so I'm sure that he would have not been cilestas price student


IT IS ZECORA WHEN ZECORA WAS FIRST SEEN WE SAW THAT SHE WAS WEARING A BROWN CLOTH ALL OVER HER AND IT MADE A PRETTY POINTY HAT WHICH LOOKS SAME AS THE EPISODE WHERE WE SAW THE PONY OF SHADOWS


What if its the bad side of star swirl? There was a bad side of Luna from those creatures.....


Im late ik but if you rewatch season 1 you could also think its secora, her eyes were also yellow when she had her first appearance


I say stygian a character that is going to be in the show because told star swirl about the sirens so that he could be recongnized and to save the day but it was star swirl and not stygian who was recognized but that just a theory


It could just be Discord trying to mess around with them


its star swirls shadow if i where banished and turned into a driqanicas i would get bourd so id use a spell to make something to play with so he made his shadow come to life and when he took over eqestrea his shadow left and haunted the cattle because it was the shadow of  star swirl not discord and it would miss its old life and it would get angry with discord and take that anger out on everyone who came in prepareing for when discord fonaly arived.


and discord is still living like himself


No it was not star swirl the bearded because before that his friend put together a force and he (the friend) later he stole the forces powerful items became the sadow pony and was banished to limbow and star swirl the bearded and his team were put there too. It shows this in season 7 the last episod.


Thanks to the season 7 finale, this theory is officially dead. star swirl has blue eyes


I say false...why you may ask...I started to realise that Discord is NOT " Star Swirl the bearded". I think there is a queen pony the mlp has not told us yet. Why am I saying this you may ask? Well I am saying that Luna and Clestea were not born an Alicorn. Star Swirl the bearded turned them into an Alicorn. But be for he made another Alicorn that was an earth pony, but he turned the earth pony into an unicorn, then an alicorn.
My other reason is if King Sombra is a KING then there must be a Queen...
I also relized that King Sombra and Twilight Sparkle and Luna have an conetion
But if King Sombra never have esisted then Luna would maby not become Nightmare Moon because in the battle he dose something that made he into Nightmare Moon but changed back befor Clestea got in relesed form king sombra...
Swirl the bearer is the "Tree of harmony"
I am not kidding... The shadow pony is another Alicorn! that is not shown yet


what if something went wrong when star swirl did some expirement or something and his shadow got life and they got seperated


I think that the shadow Pony is Nightmare Moon in Nightmare Moon was a shadow who took over Luna's body as Luna was her host


When they banished sombra all they did was turn on the light lol


This theory: exists <br>S7 finale: allow me to introduce myself

This theory: exists
S7 finale: allow me to introduce myself


http://mlpforums.com/uploads/post_images/img-2659437-1-Shadow_falling_over_library_S4E3.png
That looks an awful lot like a hat to me

@Ronge Fox There was no hat. This vid makes no sense. :(

~Dash~

@Ronge Fox There *was* no hat. This vid makes no sense. :(

~Dash~

Her Loyal Highness, Princess Rainbow Dash

oh and for the grand example look up episode the griffon brush off. pinkie does a face ground

for humans its face palm for ponies its facehoof and if the topic or situation is extremely retarded than its faceground for ponies. I mean what I say and say what I mean and I know what I'm talking about @Arista Pooya :)

congrats you won the acheivment of being older than a 9 year old

@***** what are you saying i am confused

for the time before it was a hint for season 4

Why the hell would Tirek be wearing that hat? I thought he had a hooded cloak

to be honest this realy makes a lot of sense :D

AND he was out for a wile beforde he started <br>magic stealing clestia said he had to have been weak afer getting out and had to have gotten stronger before  twilight's kingdom

AND he was out for a wile beforde he started
magic stealing clestia said he had to have been weak afer getting out and had to have gotten stronger before  twilight's kingdom

i just relized that XD but he was in tartaris

i say its not tirek because tirek was before luna/nightmare moon and he was in tartaris so he could not been him also tirek doesnt have yellow eyes.

YES IT IS this vid was uploded before that episode tho


The story of the shadow pony about nightmare moon helps.


Glad u made a theory but. I have a theory on thw stygian shadow "pony" look closely at himhe looks so much like a changeling but ....queen chrysillas cant have children unless she had a ...a um mate? Is that appropriate enough of a word so maybe its actually a changeling king cuz it sorta does the same as chrysillas but in a slight different way it cacooned stygian and looked like his love was being drained


I guess star swirl is the shadow pony, well I think so because in the season 7 episode I saw star swirl appearing right before my eyes.


So in Castle Mania they actually say that the Pony of Shadows was part of Nightmare Moon that didn’t get banished along with her. (Pls excuse bad spelling)


brony lotion well actully im a  lps fan but in the series of lps blithe the owner of the pets in halloween blith haved a cowgirl autfit for halloween and a horse oruand her and it looked like apple jack . mind blown. go shek it out its called littlest pet shop


But wasn't Star Swirl there when Luna was banished? I could be wrong but I thought I saw it in one of the comics, yet again I am not for sure🤔


Surprise theory;  it's an oddly shaped timber wolf!


Most signs point to star swirl like the hat and eyes also saumbra couldve been banished for 1000 years like star swirl mabey star swirl became saumbra before being banished to stay alive but then he was fully banished with the pssesed pony and the episode i think were in the same season. And i remember star swirl evil some point in the show. So all those signs point to HIM, star swirl and i belive saumbra is star swirl. Mabey star swirl was betraying the crystal kingom for some reason?


The shadow pony isn't a shadow pony once it was a pony then a book had a spell on him then he came a shadow pony.


It's tirek  because he was in the season 4


luna and celistia banshied sombra by using both of threir magic to make a powerful force.


When you are protesting against Granny Smith's legend, maybe it wasn't a psychical part. Like, magic is well... Magic. It takes the form of whatever people (ponies) want. Or, it just did it itself. (Too many Its in the sentance) I'm probably going on all weird, but thats what I think


I know the shadow pony it was 2000 years ago and there stood the shadowist she was banished and never came back by the guardian of the portal


Oh, yes umm Luna did not know about Astelle bc when Tia banned Astelle as her evil self while Luna saw.  Luna went out again so Tia took her every memory about Astelle and the battle and the wreck Astelle and Tia made. Luna had no idea of it.


The Brony Notion the shadow pony watch season 7 episode 26 you'll see who the shadow pony is.

Sprinkel Lps  how would you know that? do you have proof!?

The Brony Notion Honastly i still think it could be trixie only because in one of the episodes where we first see trixie is that she was jealous of twilights magical capabilities so she got a hold of a neclace that amplifies her magic and we see while she is using it her eye color changes to red and it couldnt have been Starswirl the bearded yes they look similar but the beard it would of been shown in the shadow when the shadow pony was first introduced and with that being said my hypothesis is that trixie is still mad at twilight or someone else.

eviljbrian Interesting observation but i still beleive that its trixie

fuck you😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈

fuck you😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈

Just saying IT WAS SEASON 4 TERIK WAS NOT A THING YET

tirek has horns!!! AND you see his cape is different and the shadow pony isn't as tirek like

Sprinkel Lps you are so right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!😃

He made this video before Tirek was even brought up.

No it was posted before terek was a thing stupid

No it was posted before terek was a thing stupid

this was posted before tierk and it's called a theory ok that what this channle is for theorys so don't come to this channle if you  don't like theorys

How can it be tirek it doesn't look anything like tirek

+Evie evilflowerpetals well it could be the hood that he wore when he broke free rember and the eyes of trek are not yellow they are red

+Jason Malcolm dont have to say it twice. 😒

+Jason Malcolm dont have to say it twice. 😒

Hey Brony nation, I know who is the Shadow Pony it's Heavy Matter's minions

+The Brony Notion I think it may have been Clover the Clever. Notice how he had a hood shaped like that?

@yakub jalloh HAHA! YOU HAVE NO PROOF IT WAS NIGHTMARE!!

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

nightmare was first seen in the ever free forest and same eyes same hat plus she or he can take any form no pony knows what gender it is

The villan in 4 is not the shawdow pony it's tirek

The villan in 4 is not the shawdow pony it's tirek

@yakub jalloh NO IT ISNT, NIGHTMARE IS LUNA GENIUS, HOW CAN IT BW NIGHTMARE IF LUNA IS IN CANTERLOT EXPLAIN THAT

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

+* MariStars * Discord isn't a pony but they still banished him.

+*** MariStars *** Discord isn't a pony but they still banished him.

ok i get it just don't talk about this video subscribe to my channle

And the fact that put your videos together with my season 1 - 3 guide book you get star swirled = the shadow pony

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

It was in "do princesses dream of magic sheep" and did you even look at your comment?  And I quote "Luna will have a nightmare"

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

Lines up with my creepy theory that some people are my past or future forms who changed their name at some point

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

Shut up look at my comments your knowledge is limited if you say "think like a little girl" I am a little girl

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

@eviljbrian The Paradox That I Am Saying Is The One That You Go Back To The Past And See Yourself Like A Clone Like The Predestination Paradox And The Shadow Pony Possibly Could Be The Time Traveller Star Swirl And Now Theres Discord And 2th<br>Star Swirl

@eviljbrian The Paradox That I Am Saying Is The One That You Go Back To The Past And See Yourself Like A Clone Like The Predestination Paradox And The Shadow Pony Possibly Could Be The Time Traveller Star Swirl And Now Theres Discord And 2th
Star Swirl

@Funky Real Nerd Cat it depends the kind of paradox as well. There's the bootstrap paradox (an example of this would be Terminator) where a person is sent through time and recovered by another person, who's actions then lead to the original person or object back to the time from when it came.

Then there's the predestination paradox, where one travels back in time, but causes events that leads to the initial cause. This is a paradox that Twilight had created when she went back in time to warn herself. In doing so, she set events into motion that caused Twilight to go through the actions to become Future Twilight.

Then the grandfather paradox, which one goes back in time and kills one's grandfather. However doing so, one of his parents would have never existed and as such he wouldn't exist, yet he did because he's the one that killed his own grandfather.

There's other paradoxes, but these three are the most viewed.

@eviljbrian And For That There Comes Another Theory,if got back in time he could made a time paradox and created a evil him,in discord theory he become a mutade into discord because of the paradox xould have 2 star swirls and theres the dimensional portal for alternate universe.What do you think?(srry for my poor english)

@***** He escaped in ''It's about time'' when the dog left

@Zoe Trend The pony it's tirek when he was tiny

@Zoe Trend The pony it's tirek when he was tiny

@The Brony Notion he didn't see Twilight, maybe he saw, but we have seen that he doesn't know much about Equestria and alicorns, he might have thought that it was normal to be alicorn

@All Fun Toy Collector No, It's Discord so he's right.

@The Brony Notion Well, maybe your theory was wrong and it really was the embodiment of Nightmare Moon's dark magic, also the creators said that Luna would have a nightmare in a Season 5 episode, so maybe Nightmare Moon will appear again and be defeated for good, finally bringing Luna some peace.

@eviljbrian Well, i'd like to think that it was really part of Nightmare Moon's dark magic, you see the creators clearly stated that Luna's gonna have a nightmare in Season 5, so maybe that's why that figure appeared in the end Castle Mane-ia, maybe they were planning on showing the Pony of Shadows but not until they have a proper opportunity. I really hope that Luna's nightmare has something to do with the time she spent in the moon and that Luna and Nightmare Moon finally interact and she's defeated for good so Luna can sleep like baby.

@The Brony Notion I have a feeling that it might very well be Starswirl the Bearded. Although hat aside (anyone can get a wizard's hat)
Starswirl the Bearded was the most powerful unicorn in Equestria's history. (Before Twilight, but who's to say she won't surpass his skill if she hasn't allready.)
Starswirl's magic has the ability to banish others to other worlds, as seen in Rainbow Rocks when he banished the Sirens.
Starswirl has an entire wing in the Canterlot Library named for him, and also houses time-related spells. (As shown when Twilight uses a Time Travel spell to go back in time to warn herself.)
Unlike Twilight, who could only go backwards in time for a few short minutes, Starswirl is the one that created the spell, and as such, he may not only have the ability to travel further back in time and also for longer periods than Twilight, but he may also be able to travel forwards in time.
But at the same time, in Magical Mystery Cure, Celestia gave Twilight Starswirl's unfinished spell. It's a spell that altered destinies. Starswirl may have other unfinished spells, and what if something went wrong with a spell? (As has happened before and stated in The Journal of the Two Sisters)
Starswirl had to be extremely old, as he was around when Tirek was banished, and could very well have helped both Celestia and Luna banish Tirek. This could bring up another scenario, in which he was around for Sombra's banishment. It's unsure as to how many years  had passed between banishing the Sirens and imprisoning Tirek, however since he was around in both instances (As it was Scorpan that warned Starswirl, and Starswirl in turned warned Celestia and Luna)
If the gap is large enough, that means he would be extremely old. There are only two instances where this could happen:
1. He found a spell that could enable him to live a very long life (or again, a time travel spell gone wrong, again as stated in the Journal of the Two Sisters)
or 2. What if Starswirl was not a unicorn, but actually the only male Alicorn in existance. He is always seen with his trademark cloak and hat, so it is uncertain whether or not he has wings underneath.
These are just my theories and observations about Starswirl.

@The Brony Notion AND Tirek isn't a pony

@The Brony Notion AND Tirek isn't a pony

Марија Писаревић

I don't think it was Tirek. Couldn't have been, he would have seen Alicorn twilight and that would have ruined the surprise.


In Season 7 Finale The Pony Of Shadow Maye Left A Few Drops Of Magic In The Everfree Foserst


No way triek was the season 4 evil so he can’t


I don't think Star Swirl is the shadow pony, isn't that art fanmade?The time we see the actual Star Swirl is in Rainbow Rocks, when he banishes the sirens, he is shown to have red-pink(similar to Rainbow Dash) eyes, not yellow, so he can't be the shadow pony


PINKIE PIE! let me explain... remember the mare pond?  One pony DIDN'T go back to the pond and follows the Mane Six around to find out what's going on in Equestria despite being Pinkies clone


Discord is't starwizard i dont remenber his name

Sahaaf 2016 so u meant to say : Discord isn't Starswirl because I don't remember his name? That doesn't make sense.

I also would like you to respect Frances bonnefoy from hetalia, the representation of France.

you mean star swirl the bearded? have some respect.


You wanna know the big baddie of Season 4? <br>Tirek

You wanna know the big baddie of Season 4?
Tirek


I don't think the PONY OF SHADOWS (it's NOT Shadow Pony) even exists. It was just a STORY that Granny Smith made up to amuse Apple Jack


You find the shadow pony in season7 episode25 and star swirl the bearded and toe other ponds banished the pony of shadow


i dont think the shadow pony is anyone, i think its not just one pony, i think its just leftover magic


Could grogar be discised as the shadow pony


Maybe when discord was turned to stone a part shadow escaped into the everfree forest


Terek can not be the pony of shadow<br>in season 4

Terek can not be the pony of shadow
in season 4


Luna was a baby when her sister was banished so she wouldn't know about the banishment only Celestia would know about the banishment of their older sister


WHO CARES?!?!!!!!!!!!!!!! (i am not sure why you have put a lot of exclamation marks but i guess it's some kind of a race so i putted a lot of them in this comment just to make sure. Hope you don't mind mister :))

youtube was available (according to the powers of math) 1,008,500 yrs ago?<br>idk math is wrong lmao

youtube was available (according to the powers of math) 1,008,500 yrs ago?
idk math is wrong lmao

Circus Baby The Clown aaaa no you didn't this was 3 weeks ago when you did this reply

Cosmicilluminationn I'm watching in 2017

i dont hate the video i just wanted to know if some people are watching it in 2016

me and i hate comments like those. they annoy me.

+crazy pitoguro and the villan in season 5 is starlight glimmer

me and in season 4 the bad guy was tirek wow just wow 😒


if you look into your more recent videos, you say, that discord was star swirl the bearded


Calling it. King Sombra is the pony of shadows


well since there was left over evil maybe it made a evil clone of star swirl and the evil clone was the shadow pony!......yeah I think I figured it out!........


Its sydyian he was the shadow pony. Go watch the season 7 finale


Stigyan is the shadow pony in season 8 I guess .see the clip mane 6 and the five pillars defeat shadow pony your question will be solved


yes it is Tirek he came a few episodes and he had yellow eyes


Sawtooth: starswirl is the shadow pony stigian:im I a joke to u


Ive got it! The Shadow Pony is obviously Golden Freddy!

+Zero Ace dude....IS THIS A CROSS-OVER EP WITH A GAME OR WHAT FAT HEAD<br>WHADDA GONNA DO 'BOUT IT?

+Zero Ace dude....IS THIS A CROSS-OVER EP WITH A GAME OR WHAT FAT HEAD
WHADDA GONNA DO 'BOUT IT?

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

We got back on track and besides: it might be coincidence like everything else is on this channnel

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

That doesn't sound right I'm a girl and I refer to myself as a "dude"

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

Yep<br>I totally agree with krystin bedwell

Yep
I totally agree with krystin bedwell

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

Hamster gaming is correct he's black or dark grey

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

You guys totally got off to a different subject and why is Bonnie watching mlp?

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

You are SO stupid WHY would they combine mlp WITH FNAF?! Unlikely

Psÿçhøtïç Åmbítìøñ

I have to say for a 9 year old kid that Is pretty funny

runs out
Twilight: AH!! FOXY'S COMING!! closes left door
Credits.
That's the end everypony! Or is it? DUN DUN DUUUUUNN!!

*runs out*
Twilight: AH!! FOXY'S COMING!! *closes left door*
Credits.
That's the end everypony! Or is it? DUN DUN DUUUUUNN!!

XD I have a story too

Chica: comes in window and says pizza
AJ: speaks in her... AJ accent not tonight chicachi! hoofkicks chica
*Foxy comes out from pirate cove and says ya'll be dead after I kill ya!

XD I have a story too

Chica: *comes in window and says pizza*
AJ: *speaks in her... AJ accent* not tonight chicachi! *hoofkicks chica*
*Foxy comes out from pirate cove and says ya'll be dead after I kill ya!

Yeah like pinkie would probably get her confetii cannons or something... Yeah that would be hilarious!

Yeah. They would probably kick their butts. Because of fluttershy, Rainbow Dash, Twilight, and Rarity.

I know right. Unless they animate him being in MLP.

#Zero Ace how could Golden Freddy be in MLP?

That's not possible because if Golden Freddy was in pony form he would be yellow and King Sombra his color is...His color is... srcew it his color is unknown hopefully someone will know his color.

Good one you will be a warwolf<br>              but good try

Good one you will be a warwolf
              but good try

I totslly Can urn in to a wolf :says sarcasticaly:

sorry I belive  in things weardly .  So say you have pawers I will belive you

UGH WE WERENT TALKING TO YOU lol, this is the longest conversation i have ever had in  a vid

SHES JUST JOKING DO DO HEAD JK YOUR PROBABLE REALLY FUN XD

@Zero Ace WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT!  LUREN FOUST(EAN) WILL NEVER MIX 5 NIGHTS AT FREDDYS AND MLP!  YOU ARE SO CRAY CRAY!

@***** Coming from the guy who cant even spell "Brony" right

@***** so im with you now, sorry for making a mistake.

@***** u r right, at the end their was still a shadow and their was yellow eyes, and in the twighlights kingdon part 1....... <br>he was small, had yellow eyes, and he had a cloak

@***** u r right, at the end their was still a shadow and their was yellow eyes, and in the twighlights kingdon part 1.......
he was small, had yellow eyes, and he had a cloak

@***** i agree. the shadow pont was pinkie pie, remember?

No no no. It's worse, it's Just a Beaver.


Shadow pony could be someone we haven't seen.


Star swirl was not banned he found the elaments of harmony


Tirek is the shadow pony!!!!! because in the season 4 final he is weak has glowing yellow eyes and has a cape. in season 4 episode3 it's the same design. weak. yellow glowing eyes. cape


How was the pony of shadows Stigian (spelling I’m sorry) if he was in Limbo?


Pinkie Pie is not shadow pony she just found the piano and pretty much started playing it I would say -_-<br>PINKIE IS GOOD NOT EVIL  not trying to be mean about yelling im just funny like pinkie pie in real life XD

Pinkie Pie is not shadow pony she just found the piano and pretty much started playing it I would say -_-
PINKIE IS GOOD NOT EVIL  not trying to be mean about yelling im just funny like pinkie pie in real life XD

Oh, so that wasn't an arbitrary semicolon. Well gee, I feel kinda guilty now...

Yes! This episode had no real value to the actual plot for future villains etc. etc. It was Pinky in the end as was revealed her wearing that same cape. I think the glowing yellow eyes was just a tension builder. I thought it was obvious who the "shadow pony" was...

Well gawd I have<br>NOT watched the episode in like months how am I supposed to remember

Well gawd I have
NOT watched the episode in like months how am I supposed to remember

thing isn't that opera phantom pretty much the same thing dude?<br>|:(

thing isn't that opera phantom pretty much the same thing dude?
|:(


Hi! I'm from the future! The Shadow Pony is actually Stigian (idk how to spell it)! He brought together the Pillars to banish the Sirens or Syrens (idk how to spell their name just like idk how to spell Stigian), but only the Pillars were famous for that, not the one that brought them together! So, Stigian became jealous and went missing. When he returned, he became the Shadow Pony!


"The shadow pony" which one pony of shadows, the one from s4 e4, king sombra, nightmare moon or any other one that we don't know about


Not to start any fights but the shadow creature is actually Tirek. If you notice in the episode with Tirek he has the right head form of the cloth as the hat shape in the shadow pony episode. Also, his eyes had a yellow glow while trying to convince Discord.

Also Tirek knew to go for exactly Discord, knowing he would want freedom due to the recent events of him being " reformed " and being held against freely expressing his chaos personality. Also he specifically had the Main six ponies being held against and trapped. This could quite possibly show that he Tirek knew about their elemental power and he knew he could easily be defeated by them, therefore, it is quite possible the shadow pony was actually Tirek


Gaia Everfree could be the Shadow Pony. She has yellow eyes too.


I think that star swirl IS discord, so that would mean discord is the shadow pony in my opinion. OR it could be nightmare moon....JUST SAYIN


It could be star swirl the bearded but the eyes that are seen area darker yellow


My theory is go into wiki it said that the shadow of ponys was a unicorn that found some of nightmare moons power and he was jealous coincidence I think not perfect match for a villain to want power


I think that starswirl had an evil aprentise who turned evil and was banished to another world. just like the sirense


First of all<br>Sombra isnt dead he is on Taratrus

First of all
Sombra isnt dead he is on Taratrus


Brony notion do think that if sombra comes back he could turn twilight evil and make her his Queen


Another thing on your video where you say flurry hart isn't a real alicorn you say celestia and luna came to equestria because of discord but you say they defeated sombra first <br>Another thing sombra wasn't turned to shadows he was turned BACK to shadows

Another thing on your video where you say flurry hart isn't a real alicorn you say celestia and luna came to equestria because of discord but you say they defeated sombra first
Another thing sombra wasn't turned to shadows he was turned BACK to shadows


I think it's discord. if discord is starswirl maybe Discord's shodow   is shaped like his old starswirly self


the pony of shadows was actually shown in season 9 aka the end of my little pony


I don't think that Star swirl bearded was the shadow Pony


Wait a min so star swirl and the pillars banished before sombra so when he came back the shadow pony left idk just making theories


Could you make a vid on Queen Crystalest past beacause i dont think its likely that she would have a normal past and is it posible she was some kind of Pony?


The shadow pony is a real pony inside a evil shadow star swirl sent it to limbo a long time ago


Wow what if the shadow pony is a side character like a character that had strong hate for some pony making them create a shadow version of them self✨✨✨✨✨


I don't think it is Starsweirl the Bearded,if so wouldn't his horn would of been shown in the shadow?


Brony notion watch my dear Luna that's how I found out it shows how shadow was Luna's friend when they were young and lived in the castle of the two sisters since Luna's banishment


You were close <br>The shadow pony is related to starswirl the bearded

You were close
The shadow pony is related to starswirl the bearded


So ...Tirek... was banished before Sombra?
HANG ON...
This theory does not tie in to Starlight Glimmer...
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

So ...Tirek... was banished before Sombra?
HANG ON...
This theory does not tie in to _Starlight Glimmer..._
_AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA_


The shadow pony is stigian the pony who made starswirl form an alliance


I come from season 8 and the shadow Pony was banished before Sombra and starswirl bearded banished him so it can't be him


Oh my goodness the shadow pony is a myth and it could  of been a prank


so... discord is the shadow pony? i thought he was chaos not dark


what if starswirl got taken over by the left over magic from night mare moon


The sister's vanished sombra of combined the magic powr of sun and darkness and luna maded powerful maybe? So there is possible that zombra is the shadow pony


In the episode of the old sisters castle i saw in the background that there was a shadow pony in wasn't tirek he didn't have the body of no certain pony


maybe the shadow pony is the left over magic of nightmare moon


hey what if they just did not need elements of harmony versus sombra


Lol I'm one of that species...

Wait, are shadow ponies even a species?

Idk, I'm just a shadow


Ah, now we actually have a pony of shadows.
this theory is oof

Ah, now we actually have a pony of shadows.
*this theory is oof*


why, because star swirl is seen with the other pillars and the mane six, defeating the pony of shadows and bringing back Stigen.


What if it’s a combination of all the vilains


Wait a minute are you talking about some other Pony not Celestia and Luna?


I'm from the future... and star swirl the bearded is not  the shadow pony....because he vanished it


The shadow pony is a Normal pony who got took in over by darkness


Little did past you know that starswirl brought a villan ti limbo but him and the other pillars had to banish themselfs to limbo to


The legend is so inaccurate it hurts. It was actually Stygian.


Terck might have been banished before Discord


It ....is .....just..... MAGIC!!!!!! IT DOSEN'T HAVE AN IDETADE!!!!!!!!!


I saw a episode were Twilight brought Stars World bearded from somewhere. It might of been where he was banished!!!


It is the magic that makes sambar a unicorn 🦄


Wow all of this <b>shadow</b> thing was in the season 7 finale. dang 3 years foreshadowing XD LOL

Wow all of this *shadow* thing was in the season 7 finale. dang 3 years foreshadowing XD LOL


discord and tirek can't be shadow pony because they arent ponys


2:58 HOLD UP,HOLD UP,HOLD UP!!!!! So are you saying that the bits of Nightmare left behind is the cause of The Pony Of Shadows? ARE YOU SAYING THAT LUNA IS THE CAUSE OF STYGIAN BDCOMING EVIL?!?!?!?!?!?!

2:58 *HOLD UP,HOLD UP,HOLD UP!!!!! So are you saying that the bits of Nightmare left behind is the cause of The Pony Of Shadows? ARE YOU SAYING THAT LUNA IS THE CAUSE OF STYGIAN BDCOMING EVIL?!?!?!?!?!?!*

Nightmare moon was after Stygian and the pillars where sent to limbo


Come on Star Swirl was in limbo when the shadow pony was here so you’re wrong


STARSWIRLS GOST!!! when he died he hounted the castle!!


Season 4's villian was Discord, then Tirek.


Shadow Pony is Luna. Came from "Nightmare Moon" magic. Luna ~ Nightmare moon


Ok in one of the fourth season's episode a mare named Trixie came into town to show off. Astelle comes to Town and see' s Trixie and thinks she has potential. Astelle is the one who gave Trixie the red necklace.

Seriously? Are you really pulling that off with DisneyFanatic?


I think it's the wear wolf's u know the ones that live in the ever free forest and are made out of sticks those do have yellow eyes but I don't know about the hat


Plot Twist: Granny Smith followed them into the Castle of the Two Sisters to scare everypony, but found them scaring themselves enough.


Star swirl was trapped in limbo when this episode came


that is false. the truth is, trixe got some alicorn jem and now with all that power she can be shadow horse. Or her magic ticks actually work


He and the pillars made a sacrifice to banish shadow pony. They were banished to limbo.


But the pony of the shadows was pinky in that episode?!😕


I don't get it,  star swirl is suppose to be good right?, I mean Twilight looks up to him?why would he be the shadow pony?  can you explain that?


star swirl could still be discord because we never see them together.


Hmm, I f Discord could be Star Swirl the Bearded. Would it be like he put a spell on him self while practicing?


you forget Crysalis the changeling queen and the pony o shadow


star swirl the bearded could be the shadow pony because he could have ex sorbed the dark magic for all of equestrian life 👧👩👵


I wonder if tirek was banished before sombra then


And star swirl was still in limbo at the time


the shadow pony is so oviously luna. It would make sence that at least one of the two sisters visited there old castle.


Stars world could Have gone evil and Luna and Celeste could have banished stars world the bearded


We already know who is the shadow pony you will see who it is in shadow play that’s what the episode is called sombra isn’t the shadow pony


It couldn't have been star swole the bearded cuz he was banished to limbo


Sombra is shadow pony ....and it's true becoz  I have read the book of  the villians of mlp in sombra his mother said him that he is a shadow pony and he should destroy the crystal heart or else the crystal heart will destroy him


Wait wait wait.... the Pony of Shadows was in 2017... NOT 2013!!


I think star swirl the bearded is the shadow pony


They did in season 7 the last 2  episodes!


Chrysalis I think is the shadow pony in s4


0:16 Everyone was keep telling that. But I always knew he's alive! No one ever belived me. And now season 9 premier is here! And Sombra is alive! I was right all time!

@Nischal Dahal His physical form was broken and his shadow form was bannished to the ice. Just like before. You see him rise as a shadow first, because he was bannished without a body

Sombra was dead. Discord brought him back


The shadow Pony is living inside of luna which transforms her into nightmare moon


its possible that she is Right because in almost all Videos theres a Person that seems good but terns agents them p.s you Awesome


No it was the pony of shadows from season 7 finale


He was there when the shadow pony was banished.


Maybe because we do not see Star swirl the bearded in the series. The way he got banished. Was maybe no friendship. And when he did find a friend I am sombra or someone like that.He turned with the person so then he became evil and had to get banished. Please pin this or respond back to this bronynotion


The Brony Notion, I disagree or I mean the evidence was great but didn't you think Stars wor the bearded (or however you spell it) was discord?


Discord is not starswirl and he banished himself to protect ponies from the pony of shadows


Mabey star swirl tried to stop night mare moon but she won and turned him into a shadow   .......so she killed him in a way


Night mare moon,so bra and the shadow pony all wanted darkness so maybe you should talk about nithg mare moon


when starswirl did the spell that he did not finish, he turned into discord right? AND SOME PARTS OF THE SPELL TURNED INTO SHADOWS!!! ok that sucks


we will find out who it is because it's the main bad guy  of season 7


star swirl the breaded might be the one see look apple jack says not all of nightmaremoon/luna magic didn't go it stay maybe star swirl the breaded was going into the castle for research and Luna dark magic turn him into the shadow pony see his eyes are yellow and the shadow pony has yellow eyes and trixie hat so it might be star swirl the breaded.

can somebody answer my question


Its Tartus or Daybreaker

Edit: In my opinion


WAIT A MINUTE what if in the shadow posses rarity and plays her like a puppet in the season 7 finale could nightmare rarity be a thing? could that be why it is called shadow play?


If samba was the shadow pony how did he get out of the frozen north then because he was banished to the frozen north


Season 8 finale, this is getting ridiculous


Considering the S7 Finalle has been leaked, I think it's easy for anyone to go find out.  Me, I'll wait till it's released on time... though I've been antsy just waiting, hehe


Nightmare moons magic brings starswirld's ghost alive


When i first heard of it i thought it is "the pony of thanos"


Yeah. Star swirl is PROBABLY the shadow pony.


star swirl is in limbo according to the finale of season 7


MMM.. but MMM was banished after discord and sombre of the pony of shadows was banished then again came back and gave it's evil Power to Sombre and then discord and Luna


Stigieon... just
STIGIEON!!!

But just wait... THE HAT???

Only star wars fans get it. ITS DARTH SIDIOUS HAT IS HIS CAPE AND THE YELLOW EYE. HIS PROBLYBLY OLD SO HE WALK LIKE A PONY


I think it's someone who has not been introduced yet


2:29 brony:oh so stars wirld the breded
Season 7 stars wirld the breded:I AM TRAPPED NOT IN REALITY


what if shadow pony is a reference to shadow people?


In season eight star swirl comes and said he knows about the shadow pony


4th Return is crysalis 5th is tirek 6th is cozy gule 7th is Daybreaker 8th is midnight sparkle 9th is Nightmare rarity 10th is Sunsetshimmer 11th is Evil spike 12 is Elements of insaity ponys 6. 13 is evil Twilight 14 is Evil Brony 15 is Evil starlight glimmer. Thats all after 1000 and 2000 years


The shadow ponye is Stichion from season 7!!!


Season 4 is probably tirek or cosy glow or (most likely) Chrysalis idk I didn’t see season every season instead of season 1


I think it's Derpy. You know the klutzy, yellow and gray one with bubbles for her cutie mark.


But in a book hope and the princesses saved sombra


many because once you think about it starswirl was still alive before sombra


This Theory has been debunked in season 7 finale... not such a good sorcerer aren’t you Star Swirl now huh?


I think the shadow pony is...QUEEN CRYSTALIS!!!


You know what's better it's.........2017!!!!!!!😻😻😻


Is it the shadow pony or the pony of shadows


The pony of shadow was vanished by star swirl


the sun made king sombar made him Shadow.


I know who the shadow pony is it is....... Derpy! think about it 🤔


The shadow pony is the pullers friend he betrade them and he turned to shadow


Its not star swirl because he was sent to limbo with the shadow pony


It was pinky pie. At the end of that episode it was pinky pie that was playing the piano and had a hoodie that looked exactly like the shadow.


The shadow pony mightbe Stigeon/Shadow Plays.


Bronynotion probably hates the s7 finale. It ruins slot of his theories


yeah it could be Terek he has yellow eyes and a wizerd hat


If the shadow he is a shadow and then it's made by magic well I guess there's no one playing no pony playing the shadow for me because it's made of magic so I guess that's why


Wait until season 9 the trailer reveals that he comes back somehow


Maybe the shadow pony is the ghost of star swirl the bearded


the shadow is prob is the next villian in season 4 or maybe twilights evil twin..


so think of every evil pony with yellow eyes or probably the the evil creature from rainbow rocks because she's still in equiestra then before she gone to cantorlet high school


Before u read that comment saying starswirl was the shadow pony , I actually guessed he was


It does not make sense because the elements where completed by clover then it was given to celestia  and Luna when the ponys found out  and plus he would be 3 people discord star swirl and the shadow pony


The shadow pony is star swirl the bearded


thats looks so same, but when i see it again, the horn wasn't appear on shadows, and the shadows has a "thing" (i dunno thats name) behind the neck. but dont trust this cus its just my theory


Maybe when star swirl turned into discord he lost a little power\magic and that formed into the pony of shadows

Actually, your theory has been wrong. If you watch the end to season 7, you will see that another pony, Stygian,  was the Shadow Pony. Star Swirl, Discord, Stygian , were three different people.<br>I’m not trying to be rude, I’m just giving information.

Actually, your theory has been wrong. If you watch the end to season 7, you will see that another pony, Stygian,  was the Shadow Pony. Star Swirl, Discord, Stygian , were three different people.
I’m not trying to be rude, I’m just giving information.


Discord was turned to stone not shadows.


Stingy is the shadow pony from season nine


Is the shadow pony the one you see in season 7


1,000 years?<br>HOW OLD IS CELESTIA AND LUNA

1,000 years?
HOW OLD IS CELESTIA AND LUNA


who said sombra was defeated permanently...


If star swirl is discord why in season 7 he is still him self and celestia was a filly wen Stygian was the Shadow pony

😇😇😇😇😇😇😋😋😋😋😋😋🤔🤔🤔🤔😎😎😎😎😎🤔😎deal with it

😇😇😇😇😇😇😋😋😋😋😋😋🤔🤔🤔🤔😎😎😎😎😎🤔😎deal with it


I thought Star Swirl the Bearded was a good guy.


I NOW THIS IS SEVERL YERES LATE but the poney of shodos could be starswarls evil side and or a vergon of him but evil
that would explain the similarities, and it would explain why the pony of shodose semed so violent to starswrl and his
Friends. It would also  explain why it went to poses a friend of him, and not another pony. I got think that would make
sens.


so what your saying is the shadow pony is not sombra  because you said that the shadow pony got banished before sombra


wait arnt you forgeting in the movie rainbow rocks there was there free girl in it that were banshistes ...but after a long time after it happend so wouldent it be the three evil girls from rainbow rocks?


I thought it was the remains of Nightmare Moon, when I first saw it.


Starswirl didn't get banished but imprisoned. Meh it helped save Equestria.


Well we know now that starswerl is not the shadow pony. Season 7


I think it's Discord as starswirl the bearded might be Discord and besides Star Swirl the bearded is not that tall how to spell that you that starts with beard and meet since he had no no friends to switch it could turn could have turned him into Discord


Seeing the S7 finale<br>BN: What is life....

Seeing the S7 finale
BN: What is life....


there where 2 shodow ponys <br>i think the shodow ponys are luna and celestia

there where 2 shodow ponys
i think the shodow ponys are luna and celestia


I saw in a vid that there was a pony that name shadow and had a necklace with a rose


no he got banished in and he came back in season 7 or 8


Thank goodness Chris Stars world with banished to limbo the game you all know by heart * 12 was banished to play that game for eternity and somehow Star Swirl found a way to get out of the limbo and make a spell so it would look like that starts will just died but really he got out of his body went to the castle of the two sisters and at the same time the ponies went to the castle for two sisters


from first to last of the villains and MLP My Little Pony and yes I was there the band Discord even before she turned into Nightmare Moon does that make a point to you?


I know who it was!   Lord trek he has yellow eyes was banished and has a pointy hat!


Spoiler Alert:The season 4 villian is Tirek


I think that the shadow pony is nightmare moon's shadow.🍿


Guys Can we talk about how the series is over but we still don't know what what thing was..... WHYYYYYY!!!!!


In the sombra method I saw them join powers or horns I guess and make a rainbow.wait...OMG :)


If Grannie Smith knew about Nightmare Moon‚ how come other ponies didn't?

Zhi Wei Lim Granny Smith knew that Nightmare Moon was banished. She didn't say anything about her return


mabey star swirl made a minion to help him but it went evil!!!


Light can't reflect of walls!!!! The pony of shadows is literally a shadow!!!

That's true! Maybe it was Pinkie's shadow and the eyes were something else. ~ Mintstar


And then all your theory's are out the window in season 7 and 8


I would get that star swirld  could be but what if  it was Trixie changed her eye color so she can have refenge


Starswills  were banished  with the shadow  pony in season 7


it could be tricksy beacause in the shadow there is no belles


It could be a mess of different character's


Welp you were wrong about one thing. Star swirl isn't discord. Star swirl is Star swirl.


You are right. I never noticed that before.


But that means that discord was the shadow pony


i think chrysilas is the shaow pony be ause she is the only villian that hasnt been banished int eh time line


🤔 Sawtooth if you watch season 7 finale there's also a pony of shadows but they may be two different ponies.  Maybe???

at that time he still in limbo so that isn't possible


That actually looked like pinkie but with yellow eyes


Star Swirled the Bearded with a evil spell on him????


THE SIRINSSSS!!!!!!!!!

How did you not know what came next in the storyline. 😒


Any one noticed that the timber wolves have yellow eyes and are black like a shadow...


I think it’s the person brought the Travis Carter


If you guys are true pony Dan's you guys should know.


Omg StarSworl was trapped in a different world


New villain for season 6 finally anyone?


GASP THE DARK MAGIC THAT TOOK OVER THE S7 VILLIAN ALSO TOOK OVER LUNA... BUT WHO IS THE DARK MAGIC??? (Please read)


It was Celestia and Luna's sister yes they have a sister don't ask okay look up magpies princess Trixie Sparkle that's where I got this information from get her channel to find this information


It must be the pony of shado . But it was gone long ago . But not all of it's power was gone . And the shado called out to luna because of luna's jealousy for her own sister and she listen and became the mare of the moon night mare moon did you realy forgot about it you put a video of luna and you forgot it


It is tirek in a 2 episode later tirek comes in and his eyes are yellow


Zecora uses shadow potion to watch twilight


Star swirl had a beard but the shadow pony don't, but i think that i really think is sunset shimmer, yellow eyes!, and the hat maybe a cloke?


What About The Other Sesons With Nightmare Moon?


Tirek is that big bad villain and starswirl the bearded is good not evil


I think the shadow pony is a character from a therory I have it's not on YouTube though


Yes I think Star swirl is the shadow pony #don't judge


The destroyed simba brings me to the question how did simba return to take over crystal empire

Correction he was not destroyed as fluttershy says


Maybe it might be queen chrisalis, i might be wrong,but hey,it's just my own theroy

Emma Allison {Quirk: Water Manipulation}


Me watching this in 2021,knows who it the shadow pony:HmMMm..inTrESinG


maybe its G R A G O R? (I probably spelled his name wrong)


I know who the shadow pony isI think it was shown on season seven


I think so that star swirl is the shadow pony.....20%....


Discord, nightmare moon and sombra were banished by rainbows


yeah I could starswirl a bearded's shadow haunting the castle


Guys this is six years ago and the pony of shadows is stegeon if I spelled that right

*Stygian and Ikr ppl always comment things and never check the release date


What if the Shadow  pony  is grogar I did usted to be the castle for the two sisters so he could be looking for something


but stars sweal maked the shadow  along with his Friends but at the end the ahadow ponie had a own will culd that Mien that the ahadow ponie was sombra?


do ponies die and be a devil or a angle?


Hey Brony nation, I know who is the Shadow Pony. It's Heavy Matter's minions


maybe it's tirek we do see a shadow hat and glowing eye's  in the episode twilights kingdom part 1.


that is tirek because the vision of princess celestia tirek appears on it and his eyes is yellow and glowing<br>come on

that is tirek because the vision of princess celestia tirek appears on it and his eyes is yellow and glowing
come on


Nope star swirls friend is the pony of shadows


It's called the pony of Shadows and it's the other Pony as house went to limbo got to watch that episode of My Little Pony so everyone can know please


This might be a dumb theory but Mabey it celestia's and Luna's friend Idk or a maid or butler it just a theory


ur a awesome nerd and im a brony and a brony fan


stygian is da shadow pony (spoiler alert for any one who didnt watch the completeseries)


I need second can you make a video to explain discord can turn into stone himself I saw in one of the videos I watched the series all the way to season nine and I saw the discord can turn into stone himself and break himself to pieces if he can do that then he could probably trick-princess Celestia and Luna into thinking he was in stone but he was just discord stone yeah spreading discord magic through I saw you on the video about pinkie pie he could please do you know letting pinky use some of his magic


Maybe the Shadow is simply that: A shadow Pony. You know, The race that Sombra was revealed to be a part of in the comics? I mean, locking up one individual is one thing, but locking up an entire Race? Not even the humans in Undertake could have sealed ALL of them!! That, and even if they did, more ghosts would come into existence afterwards. That, and Dracula and the others come into the picture later on as well. So, is it really that hard to believe that a few shadow ponies managed to give the royal sisters the slip?


No star swerl is not the pony of shadows star swerl is the one who banished the pony of shadows but star swerl had to banish himself to limbow a pony named stigian is the pony of shadows you see this hapend becous of a mistake star swerl thout that stigian wanted to be the most powerful pony but no stigian only wanted his respect that is why star swerl had to banesh himself and the pony of shadow so star swerl is not the pony of shadows


What if the shadow pony is not actually starsworld the bearded but just using his image so he won't be caught


So um well I think that the pony of shadows is a well just a shadow made by NMM


The shadow pony is no a pony. Eyes don't glow on shadows  the shadow pony is a shadow that it's eyes


No notion its Stygian understand not star swirl


maybe star swirl the bearded was there when luna went to the moon


How about the pony of Shadows is inside a pony


This is a very good theroy but maybe this one is not very true in the final episodes of season 6 of mlp the six pillers we're praised for saving a village when really one of there old friends told them the village was in danger and got jealous and just like Luna turned into an evil


I mean... He might be... There is a big schance for that...


no I don't think star serwerl is the pony  of shadows


What if the shadow pony was the red moster guy i forgot his name  i think you made this video before it came out


Why would cilesty and Luna hurt discored because they were friends as kids


It is star swirl because the eyes and the hat and yellow Aroara that mache his eyes


Maybe it was just a joke and has no meaning. Easter eggs are great for getting people to talk about the subject.


Yes but in that video wasn't it pinky?? Or am I mistaken


Nope not star swirl because SS was the powerful unicorn maybe its the old queen that Princess Celestia banish before luna born


Hey Brony nation, I know who is the Shadow Pony it's Heavy Matter's minions


Well the (star wizard) is star swirl and why would grany smith be in the video for???


It has to be discord, really<br>That or it was just Luna

It has to be discord, really
That or it was just Luna


Maybe but it didn't look like star swirld's hat or cloak


Shadow pony is the pony of shadows stygien season 7


same as last episode, THE THEORY DISPROVING MAGICAL SEASON 7 HAS SILENCED ALL OF YOUR AGREEING HEADS


OR the shadow pony is just the shadow pony


Season 4 Tirek <br>Season 5 Starlight ……


I now:<br>The pony of shadow pony is stigin

I now:
The pony of shadow pony is stigin


is sunset shimmer belong in the pony wold or the human world?she must have a copy


I am the only one that thinks that the shadow pony is the tantybus (sorry for my English......)


I really think it was NOT star swirled the beared because twilight would have not liked him I the first place and hasbro would have said it in mlp.


no its the prinnsses older sister  lona sister banished  her and star swral was trened into a tree


NO HE IS NOT THE SHADOW PONY,  cause I remember something saying that pasted away so


The shadow pony is tirek how it is ............back in season 4ep twilights kingdom we see tirek even know he's not a pony he dose have yellow eyes and it is I season 4....... Peace out


Btw in you forgot crisalis (I can't spell) in s2. Plus I'm watching this in 2017 lol


what about when nightmare night episode she had a cape and her eyes were similar!


the shadow pony is a pony named stigiien


Take a look at season 7 the last 2 episodes and there is your answer


in s7 star swrl says that the pony of shados is stygian


Now who we actually have more information, this makes since and yet It doesn't


Shadow play, episode 25 and 26 season seven:
I am here to provide you

Knowledge

Shadow play, episode 25 and 26 season seven:
I am here to provide you

*Knowledge*


8 year later we know who is the shadow pony is

at that time he still in limbo so that isn't possible so that could be tirek


Well I am from 2021 so sombra comes back


Your about to find out in the Season 7 Finale


Ya starswirl is the shadow pony wich is sombra cuz starswirl turned to sombra


He could be cuz he is dead and that's his spirit


It's the shadow darkness NOT her form dummy so then it goes in to rarity


I new nightmare moon was the shadow pony because her mane is just like the thing in eqestria  big nightmare


It is starswirl's friend from starts world secret


I think sombra is shadow pony. Cuz of ur theory. And ik u didnt know this way back when but he came back in 9. Lol


Maybe shadow pony is nopony we know. Just shadow pony.


hello make a from the in the episode Pinkie Pie was wearing a cloak and when taric was introduced he had the same clothes my guess is that the shadow Pony with Pinkie Pie but a duplicate and Discord had made it into Target butt did for his plan food Twilight her castle and unlock box or chest with her 62 get that he had to get Target and so she could defeat him and give her the key for the rainbow chest thing and whatever that was so in conclusion the shadow Pony was just a duplicate Pinkie Pie who was later introduced as T-Rex in this series later on when Twilight unlocked the box or rainbow chest to get her castle and being named the Friendship princess so that is what actually happened mr. so mind I would like you to make a video on this or something cuz this is what the people need to know no no no no no no no where am I going to let you just do this it is the duplicate Pinkie Pie that is turned into T-Rex


Stair swirl was bannased with the shadow pony my little pony says that


Nightmares moon brings starswirlds ghost alive


Maybe the Syrians got banished before king sombra agree or not


Special bearded can I be the shadow of Tony because statue of bearded was from limbo


Granny smith could be right because it not actually night mare moon it  was said  that it was n.m.m magic


i thought it was star swirl before watching this :D


I think the shadow of pony is zecora idk


its imposibll for star sworl can't be the pony in shadows because star sworl banished him remember


I think turned to shadow means shadow frome My dear Luna.


its actally nightmare  its kind of like venom from spider man  but its a virus


And then season 7 came out -__- great video btw


It's star swirls they have a hat  green eyes same face ? Well in then Shawdow it hade some  kind of   A same eyes shape also smile if star swirls was sliming it would look the same  hmmmmm also  I now star swirls magic is danger also the   shadow pony  magic is danger and they have the same  shape I mean star swirls he'd  is an ball also the shadow pony they are evil sorry Twilght but favorite  is evil proof they are twins maybe it will reaveld in season 7


l don't think star swirl is the shadow pony maybe discord and sunset shimmer worked together


Shadow pony aren't there 3 one from the fairy tail that was in limbo and sombra


yup it's totally him because Star swirl isn't in the show yet but maybe no maybe yes I don't no but if he appears in the show without any shadow costume on i will scrim loud as i can cous i don't no anymore


Stars who is the shadow pony but how can hit changes colour into a shadow


But the pony of shadows doesn't have A horn
like Starswirl so...
theory DEAD
and S7 srry


WELL I'M POSTING THIS ON 2018, WOW, any ways if you ever see this I just want to let you know that if AppleJack said that Granny Smith said there was dark magic left, so it must have happened after NightMare Moon was banished, so it happened before season 1 and after NightMare Moon.


Boii your just makeing me more confused

Edit: that was probably one of the nightmare forces and or one of those wolves see yellow eyes


So the shadow pony is. The pony. Of. Shadow is night mare moon but she turned back into Luna


but starswirl has a beard the shadow does not what mabye a older alicorn


Nope what till season 8 then you'll know but it does involve star swirl


Plus we don't even know where star swerl is


Do anyone reads the date that this was posted in.... THIS WAS MADE IN 2014. 3 YEARS BEFORE THE SEASON 7 FINALE!


Remember kids, this was before season 7 outdated vid:)


OMG STIGIAN WAS THE SHADOW PONY WE KNOW LOOK AT THE LAST EPISODE OF MLP MLP IS ENDING!!!!!!!


Well I tink night mare  moon did something to starswil


Who is the shadow pony well me AHHHHHHHHHH


I think you theory is grate the hat,eyes lines up many granny smith did not know what it was and though iit wan nightmare moon because of her night smock In the first episode


its timar wolfs imean its a shadow and its got yellow eyes 👁so clear awedans


Is not Star Swirl.'is looki'😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😂😂😂😃😂😃😂😃😂😃😂😃☺☺☺☺☺☺☺😀


i think there is a nightmare killer blood who shadow pony


the shadow pony  is  all sater sirlw the bired  trexi and sombra


maybe it was pinkie because she was wearing that hoodie and she was playing the piano everypony was scared until pinkie took of her black hodie


Watch my dear Luna and then your answer is there


you should watch magpiepony video of princess Trixie Sparkle it has a pony that is a shadow and a pony that has a name for  shadow


Guys chill season 6 is done now so chilll XD


real shadow is in the song.               My Dear luna


the shadow pony is the creator of the pillar's


it cannot be tirek.this more looks like star swirl


and the really sadow pony is a noter sombrea


no because shadow pony is gonna be bad pony it could be nightmare moon or shadow bolts because this to are like shadow


Um there's eight seasons and then 9 and it is a pony that you  don't know and I know it


No ink rose said it was discord then sombra then nightmare moon


i know who is the Shadow Pony is he is sombra and twilight so that means they are in love! i maybe wrong i am a nerd!


Star Swirl is not the pony of shadows...😒Check out in Shadow play Episode...You will know who is the pony of shadows...It's Stygian...

I made this video a long time before that episode lol


What about chrysalis?She has to be before discord and after Sombra.Plus she never fought them in the first place!She was with Zecora!

1.Tirek

2.sombra

3.chrysalis

4.discord

5.nightmare

6.starlight


Look at the wolves their eyes are yellow


This video: THE SHADOW PONY IS STAR SWIRL.<br>Star Swirl: No, its my friend.

This video: THE SHADOW PONY IS STAR SWIRL.
Star Swirl: No, its my friend.


We now the shadow pony is a pony named givin or something


I know i know it is star swirl because the eyeeeeeeeeeees


do you now he is not a really sadow pony  an sadow pony name somdra made the old sombra was a pony


Brush Baby may be star swirl is still alive


i wachts the season 7 finale it was so cool


I think estel of princess Trixie sparkle


maybe it's Crystal this I mean Crystal Lake nevermind it's something like Crystal what Crystal has these things and she has done he has tile Antietam come out of ponies


I believe if something to do with trickie mother because look at her and the shadow it look simular to trickie  form. and it's not a male I believe.


If you haven't finished all the seasons You don't know star swirl was st UK in limbo that's we're he disappeared

This was made before season 7, at that time this theory made sense


No because starwirl banished him so that’s not true


Well we know who it is because the season 7 fnial


Dis is outdated in season 9 sombra comes back!


He cant be because he went to limbo a wile ago😁🤣😃😍


i dont now who is the shadow pony bot i now who is shea shes star swirl the berdead or king sobra


There is S5 and S6 so S6 had shadow pony  banished before star swirl S6 S5 S4 S3 S2 SO like that


But the timber wolf''s arnt tey the pony of shadows okey i get that the timber wolf''s arnt ponyes but still


you know it cold be trixy and zcora camdind with a shdow all to gether or just picky pulling a trick agen [cfedy]


Watch the sesone  7 final it will explanation it all I watched it


Haven't you seen the new episode of shadow pony


The shadow pony duh 🙄 I'm not being mean it's just fun to judge people because I'm from the future


The fact that the comments are from the future


Isn't shadow pony nightmares boyfriend 🤔


yes but it could be that pinkie pie was playing the organ to the outside that could of made that shadow or some of that magic left could have tooken a form of a pony and still be a shadow


I mean yellow eyes, some sort of pony type head


Is the pony Of shadow is Start  swirl banished to limbo


the Shadow Pony is StarSWIRL and
1= StarSWIRL is a pony or shadows
🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔


Easy the shadow pony is not star swirl the bearded but a village pony who actually assembled the group that star swirl was in but something he did was took the wrong way and he was cast out of the group and he turned into the shadow pony. also I am pinky pie but with a different username .also I am sykick

at that time he still in limbo so that isn't possible


i think that he is not because other wise he would not be one of twilites itles


It was pinkie pie if you watched till the end!!!!!!!!


HES Stygian Have You Seen "Does Stygian Deserve Banisment?"  Meh Just WATCH Till The End To See His Transformation

Bro this was released like 7 years ago bruh


Ugh the shadow pony is stygian just watch it already


Tear it was the first man that got Van Ness


It might be Terick he ended up after seasons 1 2 and 3.


Wait i thoaut sombra was lunas brother or something


Who is the mayor in the Moon I would like to know please


S4 was Discord <br>Discord-StarSwirl, STARSWIRL

S4 was Discord
Discord-StarSwirl, STARSWIRL


Hasbro copied your idea.but not starswirl but a friend of his


Hey take a look at a video that I found on YouTube it’s called the fall of the Crystal Empire fan made


ja mislim da je pre kralja sombre lord tirak poni iz senke


It is stygian from from your own video Star swirl secret


Granny smith is right cause if u reed the night mare rairity comic the night mare looks like that


Mabey another prencess exsid and starswerl basht her to a dark relm for his punishment he was danished to that relm and toke the prencesses poer


STIDION FROM SEASON 7 IT WAS STARSWIRLED IN LIIMMBOOOO


maybe the shadow ponies is a spirit or came drome


No it can't be star swirl he has  blue eyes

that is just a fan art so that couldn't be true


Maybe star swirl is the shadow pony maybe not ps brony notion I love ur vids and mlp


I don't think it could be her she doesn't have yellow eyes


God, dead?! We ain’t going there...0-0 he was BANISHED! Not killed, god, this is a kids show!


Starswirl the bearded Spanish the shadow Pony that is true I know this😎😎😇😇😇🕵♀🕵♀🕵♀


Luna her here is the seme with kig Sandra


Couldn't be sauce with the building cuz he was banished to limbo


gise The Tree of Harmny is star swerl he got banished by CLESTEY,S OLLDER SISTER


Dis theory dead!<br>S7 Final: Am I a joke to u! Seriously man.

Dis theory dead!
S7 Final: Am I a joke to u! Seriously man.


he got bansnd by acidentlely because the sister did not have contrle of there magic cause  tgey were only little when he got banished


No i see the video i thing it's.......PINKIE!!!! with something in she's hat


More like the pony of shadows P's..  Watch seasong 7 final


I think it was tirek when he was weak😟 and couldn't take magic🤕


at that time he still in limbo so that isn't possible


m ake one on why fluttershy in power pony  was mean😭


So you haven't watched princess trixie sparkle


and he badle him and sombrea  tern to a sadow and got on him


wait wait you no the shadow pony was tall so it cant be a pony it needs to be someone tall so it cant be discord it was smaller to discord like midiam so im thinking chisilis she is midiam that makes sense dusunt it


it's not star swirl think off someone not star swirl how likes brewing poison,s  its zacora because no one knows any knows anything  on her and why would she like brewing position,s a lot if she,s not a witch


Have a problem blame Star Swirl
Need help to to Star Swirl
Need to make yourself feel better by proving you school is better then someone else's and make him like yours tell Star Swirl


I am the cd of the my little pony crator and that is indeed star swril  it's a hint for seson seven wich is last ep of seson six thank you very much.........sorry I like to humor


When the pillars turned their backs on him


So let's go way back. CUZ u know when u in that vid when u said Celestia and Luna came from an alicorn survivle tribal or something? Well maby their parents know about wut happened /w/ the shadow pony. This leads to u making a vid about all I just typed! Plz CUZ this sounds important! REALY important! Or iz this just a coincidence? I'm not sure about dis, but still it could be true!


WWWWWWHHHHHHAAAAAAAATTTTTTT,no it is Tirck


that wasn't the pony of shadow that was someone else i think?


Everybrony is like "that theory's dead" but nobrony's like "but it was a good thought process". It's not because that theory wasn't fruitful that it means it was useless, it trained your eye for detail, your ability to link things together...


no i dout it he is on the good side so he is not the sadeow pony


GISE STAR SWEAR THE BEARDE WAS BANISH INOT THE TREE OF OHMEY

Everything I know is a lie... You watch Princess Trixie Sparkle too?


Do you think spike lothers sunset shimmer


HmmmmmMmmMmmmMMmmmMMmMmmmM
cough cough
Season 7 finale

HmmmmmMmmMmmmMMmmmMMmMmmmM
*cough cough*
Season 7 finale


good good dut 1. how can he make his how eyes turn yellow like no black?


Welp it means hes the evil that have fight Star swirl and the other legend.

Yes, I AM EARLY from mlp season 7 ;).


finke if twilight was adopted by twilight velvot. What if she was celestiyas daughter???????????


Sombra has not died so teaser trailer anyone


He ded hahahahahaha! lol lol 😅😂😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😌😌😌😌😌😌😌😌😌😌 I’m not okay with this


the shadow is celestia and luna i watch that ok


+ Pups love don't say that, Galaxy Munchkin could be right

she has green eyes dum dum why would she cainge for that


my thorey its ether a hood not a hat or its starswirls ghost


I still think it was like you know kind a granny Smith's a legend think he she made up because were for certain kind a look like Zacara in her


at that time he still in limbo so that isn't possible


I LOVE YOU😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻

I LOVE YOU😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻


The pillars banish the shadow pony so it’s not possible stars world of beer that could be it.😑😐🐴🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄😠🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄🌞🌳🌚


Cool 😇😇😇😇😂😂😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀

Cool 😇😇😇😇😂😂😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀


its me the shadow PONY MUAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAAHAHHAA

but i cant say me name because you know...... :l


ıʂ ɬɧıʂ 2011?

ıʂ ɬɧıʂ 2011?


When you said not a lot of comments on your videos there is like 3.8k comments on this video or more and sorry if I got that wrong if it was actually something else not when you said a lot of comments ok


Mby the shadow pony’s name is king garmadon


Is It True There Is A Baby? That  Flutter Shy? Has A Shes Married To Descord? Right????????????????????????


Mlp s7 finale ep.<br>(the pony of shadows real name starts with a "S")

Mlp s7 finale ep.
(the pony of shadows real name starts with a "S")

ギャビージェリーヌとカツオ

Actually he said the shadow pony meaning the shadow in the episode not the pony of shadows


I.    love you r.          video of the.     show pone

I.    love you r.          video of the.     show pone


Shadow Pony=Star Swirl the Bearded. Obviously


The Shadow Pony Is A.K.A Stidgeon The Season 7 Finale


star swirl is not this not because he's hat has a swirl but the shadow pony has a wrecked one


Looks like a little bit of time and a 5th to make a little bit of time to make a little


mebe es the pony of shados es savan thate we dontbnow


hello  but star swril wasant the pony of shadows<br>and i love speken  englesh buuuut i am from slovakia for prof AHOJ  A MAM RADA my little pony.

hello  but star swril wasant the pony of shadows
and i love speken  englesh buuuut i am from slovakia for prof AHOJ  A MAM RADA my little pony.


what time e is my little  pony  in like what year?


Why does it looks like celestia annd luna

Why does it looks like celestia and luna


Achaly sombra was the secand to be punesd becose thers a video adout sombra crating nightmare moon


is it tirek right hmmmmmm 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔.............................


I know ho esete a old lunas Friends he was a was a shadow and poney.


Uhhh shadow pony star swirl is a pony but look like a unicorn i sorry i don name so is no star swirl


Mabye that left over Evil Made star swirl the bearded? Like if you agree


Sato pony us to be frends with him wach the video<br>🤔🙂🙂😇👌🏻

Sato pony us to be frends with him wach the video
🤔🙂🙂😇👌🏻


is the last pony becose sesin 6 the epesod that throraxe defetid chryslis and the canglings werr RAINBOW?!?!?!


hi im on my pops laptop so hi your  corcd im 7 and im/the kid loves your vid plz tell dantdm plz o plz


at the time he post this it doesn't appear yet


Maybe it is a descendant of Starswirl the Bearded? We can't always assume that every powerful pony mentioned is automatically immortal. He could have had a descendant or child that looked like him or dressed like him out of ancestral pride?


You know, a new pony can always be introduced. Maybe also with a very similar hat and yellow eyes. The shape of the eyes don't really match Star Swirl The Bearded, and if it was Star Swirl, I think it would also have the shadow of the bells on his hat.


I've heard the very weak Tirek, Derpy Hooves, Starswirl, and even a pony who will be revealed in Season 6. I think the extremely weak Tirek is the most plausible.

Prince of Determination & Video Mogul Black Star


The shadow pony is Tirek. Why?

First of all, we know that whoever the shadow pony is must be evil, because we see the figure squint it's eyes at the end in anger. This would mean that the shadow pony can't be star swirl, zecora, or anybody else who is good. Besides, I'm pretty sure that Sombra or Trixie would have no reason to be in the old castle.

The next evidence we have, is the shadow pony's clothing. In the season 4 finale, when Tirek was in his weak form, he was wearing a worn out black cloak with a hood, that looked exactly like the one the shadow pony was wearing.

Next, is the eye color. TWICE in the season 4 finale, Tirek was shown glaring with glowing yellow eyes at both Discord, and an unknown pony that he stole magic from.

As we know in the episode "It's about time", a cerbus, who is a creature that guards the gates of tarturus (if I spelled that correctly :p) came to ponyville and began to attack the place. The princesses in the season 4 finale, explained that Tirek must have escaped when the Cerbus left it's post at the gates. When Tirek escaped, he probably ventured into the castle of the two sisters, to live there until he had enough power to start stealing magic from ponies.

Also, the makers of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, wouldn't add something like the shadow pony at the end of an episode for no reason. The shadow pony that was shown at the end of "Castle Mania" was probably a teaser for the upcoming season finale.


to be completely honest, if starswirl were banished, it would most likely be because of becoming to powerful... think about it. he was able to banish the sirens to another DIMENSION. wait... discord was about to banish tree hugger into another dimension.... are these events linked? maybe so... personally i dont believe the whole "starswirl is discord" but it does kind of make sense.


Also, maybe Granny Smith's story is true. It may be that Lunas left over magic haunted the place, but didn't want its look to be too obvious, so it shaped into a relative. Or maybe Star Swirl to confuse us all.


I think the shadow pony is the remaining bits of darkness when they took over luna. In the nightmare rarity comic, it says that not all of her darkness are destroyed  when they defeated nightmare moon and applejack said something similar in the episode.


Theres something I don't like about the banishment timeline. If the first banished was Sombra, then Discord, and Nightmare Moon, and every time the elements are used (apart from Sombras case) the normal banishment span is 1000 years then how does it get reversed. If Sombra got banished (or I guess "shadowed) to the ice, wouldn't it be for a thousand years? Same for Discord and Nightmare Moon. So technically this doesnt make sense. If each villain (apart from Luna) got banished surely the timeline would be Sombra, Discord, Nightmare Moon, THEN Sombra, Discord, Nightmare Moon? I know this is disproven by the show itself but I don't like how this came to be.


I have 3 question. Do any of the shows give hints that sunset shimmer might be the one causing some of the problems? I mean, is she even mentioned at all in the shows? Or even been spotted  anywhere in one of the shows?Just curious.


In my opinion I think Sombra is the shadow pony because if you translate "shadow" (English) to Spanish it is Sombra, I don't think it is Tirek because Tirek is like a devil, and I Nightmare Moon might be it because when the Moon blocks the Sun from Earth it makes a shadow, a big shadow.


well it might be a mix of sombra(or his shadow) zecora and Trixie or starswirl . this is how I came up with this idea, sombra's shadow took some of Trixie's or starswirl's magical essence and he also took some of zecora's potions that had some of her essence in and thus became all three of them I now it sounds a little iffy but it's an idea


ok, so...I have a theory! What if....the elements of harmony had something to do with the whole "shadow pony" thing? What if star-swirl the bearded created a spell of transformations...then tried it out on HIMSELF? I'm pretty sure that would explain the whole thing...RIGHT?!? I mean... maybe he was taken by his will... (by the spell) and then transformed to the shadow pony...or maybe even sobra? Just a thought....


I do some what agree but I have some ideas of my own, here is what im thinking... yes I agree with the fact that the shadow pony could be Star Sworld... at least the SHADOW of his ariginle self but here is the real thing im talking about Star Sworld is Disscord, Celestia and Luna find out what has becaume of him use the shadow spell on him and only ponys can see him as a shodow pony at the castle! Lets to say the only reason Disscord wanted the elements was to turn himself back to normal as in Star Sworld,  isnt that how he turned into Disscord in the first place?


couldn't star swirl just be dead? if he did turn evil they would have mentioned it you know like lunar went all swirly tuning into nightmare moon, also he would have got rid of the portal to the human world, just like he got rid of the reforming spells. as for the shadow, zacora probably finding out what all the screaming was.


A very good theory but remember the shadowbolts in season one when nightmare moon was banished and that dark magic was said to not fully leave pony vill take a look at season four what does the pony of shadows look like


It's actually zecora because in the first place zecora wears the with hat and a cape with her eyes glowing yellow eyes. they to search zecora is the opposite of Trixie you can see that zecora has the yellow eyes with the Cape and the witch hat so that's all I Know :)


Shadow pony could be somepony we don't know yet. Maybe it's ghost/magic/soul (idc how wanna call it) what changed Luna... maybe it could be tantabus? We don't know yet but I think it's tantabus in it's true version. What do you think about this?


The shadow pony is a part of Luna. I think that would mean that the shadow pony is kinda like a mini Luna


you could be right because maybe he turned himself in to the Shadow Pony practicing a new spell like the one that Twilight used to mix up the elements and Destiny's and cutie marks


I just wanted to tell you  that I love your theories:D


it could be that shadow form from that one show when Luna was punishing herself in her dreams


I thought the shadow pony was Pinkie pie even thought the yellow glowing eyes were just added for affect, I'm sure she was going around in a pointed hood cloak and was playing the organ and scaring the rest of the mane six...


well in seson 4 it was tirek so he must have been banished BEFORE sambra as it says that tirek has returned and that he feeds of the magic from ponies


i have a feeling that it is tirek. He does have yellow eyes and was banished in season 4.


The shadow pony is an evil pony spirit that possesses ponies.  It had possessed the young magic student in the Crystal Empire that later became King Sombra. In keeping with another fan made animation I do like the idea that the shadow pony jumped from Sombra to Luna during the battle thus turning Luna into Nightmare Moon.  Luna transformed back and a ghostly Sombra appeared shortly after.

It is the spirit of the "I died evil" Starswirl the bearded.


season 4 is tirek.<br>And you totally changed my mind like i was "is luna first banished?" "who was the first one banished"

season 4 is tirek.
And you totally changed my mind like i was "is luna first banished?" "who was the first one banished"


Zecora doesn't have yellow eyes but her eyes were glowing yellow when we first saw her...


animated have a different reaction because of the levels of magic or maybe their destinies slash purpose in life


Well he could be. But it could also just be her loose magic or something. <br>(Someone kill this theory)

Well he could be. But it could also just be her loose magic or something.
(Someone kill this theory)


I think it's zecora because she had the Cape and the thing in her head.<br>I saw that in a random video

I think it's zecora because she had the Cape and the thing in her head.
I saw that in a random video


Star swirl could have cast a spell to make himself invincible or something like that🤓


maybe it's a combination of trixy and zicoa and sombre?☺


If he's the shadow pony why is he so famous for doing good stuff????


Tirek was banned before  Sombra and returned after him


Someone  once told me that the shadow  pony was Celestia's sister


It's Tirek, though I don't know if he was banished before sombra.


wait star swril the bearded was also known as sombra... WAIT does that make discord and sombra bothers?


The shadow pony is starswirl the bearded because after he swapped bodies with discord he got touched by the magic of nightmare moon it transformed him into the pony of shadows!


I think the shadow ponie is the ponie who turned Luna into nightmare moon


Perhaps it is King Sombra, or Star Swirl, but maybe it is just as Applejack said "An element of Nightmare Moon's dark magic.


Starswirl could be it but the magic could taken control of him


Or when Starswirld turned into a discord starswirld personality start fight with discord's discord. When discord's discord wins... He take starswirld's personality away in shadow form.


I think it's trixie you know coming for revenge or something to do with the magical tree been poisoned


Do a video about who is the best villain


I loved CC video ubout the main six in back ground ponys. And I think that zkorer is shato pony!


I saw some of that episode, and I saw Pinkie Pie as the shadow pony


It Could Be Starswirl...Or Zecora wearing hood


Actually the real meaning of Shadow is umbra


maybe it is nightmare moon's magic just corrupting star swirl turning  him to shadow


I'm thinking its t-rek but he was banished before that episode if so he escaped quickly but he would need some strengh!


It cant be them,the shadow ponies are FLYING.Starswirl doesn't have wings.Even Trixie.


its NOT star swirl the bearded because if it wasnt it would have to be trixy  and zacora so maybe they used their powers together to make a new villan before zacora knew trixy was evil and thats why all the ponys thought zacora was evil


Most of the villains make a lot of sense to be the shadow pony, but i feel like it might be some one new, like maybe a season 6 pony (or some weird creature thats not a pony xD" i feel like discord isn't bad any more, he is mischievous but not all bad, plus i feel like it wouldn't be trixie because shes not a ghost, i think its star swirl the beirdent how ever you spell or pronounce his name, lol. But i cant remember if hes a ghost or not.

Lol i just reread my comment and realized that i said "i feel" or "i feel like" about 3 times "i feel" lol i don't even say that a lot xD


1.opal
2.gummy
3.owlisious
4.angel
5.winnonia
2
3
4
5


I think that starswirl the bearded's shadow became the shadow pony


actually granny smith might be right but over all these years she might have exaggerated cos she IS old (not to be mean about age or something) and when you get old u don't remember stuff or u confuse it with other stuff out of the theme (take it from me when I was ten my grandpa was 90 years old)


its star swirl the bearded because his hat yellow eyes <br>and when applejack said her grandmother told her not every bit of dark magic when with nightmare moon since she was in the moon so maybe star swirl the bearded die in the castle of the sister gang the dark magic and became evil

its star swirl the bearded because his hat yellow eyes
and when applejack said her grandmother told her not every bit of dark magic when with nightmare moon since she was in the moon so maybe star swirl the bearded die in the castle of the sister gang the dark magic and became evil


I think it is sombre because  in Crystal empire part 1 celelectia say sombra was banashid to  a shadow shadow pony sound fammille


Maybe... Just maybe..... I totally believe in discord being Star Swirl. But when Star Swirl used the spell to make him discord it banished star Swirl's soul from that form creating a new form of Something? XDDD * SHRUGGGG *


well it was a vilain you had that point right but pretty much the rest wrong


I think it is King sombras daughter and yes he has a daughter


we all know that discord is star swirll so it can't be him.


isn't the shadow pony like maybe starset shimmer?


brony notion I found some "info" it's in 2nd equestrian girls movie idk if it's true BUT the shadow pony COULD have not been a pony in the past. YES YES I know the 2nd movie said that the 3 villains are  the sirens BUT what if they where only parts of the sirens song and the shadow pony COULD be the remaining magic OF THE SIRENS. plz reply to this comment if you see it


I think  that it was the spirit of nightmare moon because when the elements changed nightmare moon back to Luna maybe the dark spirit was wetting to tech over another pony and meyby that dark spirit has been whacking all the pony in pony Ville and found the 6 ponys and then went to tech the form of a change line so he could change into slender men and thats hoo we saw on th 3 season so if alllllllllllllllllllll that info does not help I HAVE NO CLUE WHAT WILL.


well it could be but isn't star swirl that good wizard pony that twilight like and if it is star swirl then why would he do something like that because he's a good guy or maybe he was framed???


I think its the Shadow bolt You see they are made of shadow and Granny Smith said its something to do with Nightmare Moon and Nightmare moon Created Them..


well in season 4 tirek returned, who would be the shadow pony, is it pinkie?


Watch the end of the episode it was Pinkie in a room in a black cloak playing the organ


After star swirl turned into discord he transformed into the shadow pony


I know who it is!!!  If it was someone who was banished maybe it was Celestia based off your video Celestia Banished to the Sun?          Just a thought.


I know it is sombra is the shadow pony you have to know that if you watch sombra videos


Well it could have bin star world whatever or it was king sombra he was turned in to shadow right


it could not be Tirek because he dose not have yellow eyes.


we all know who the shadow pony is king sombra if I Evan spelt that weight


THE PONY OF SHADOWS IS SNOWDROP ITS GOTTA BE FROM A VIDEO I WATCHED IS RETURN OF SNOWDROP YOU NEED TO CHECK IT OUT


its night mare moon she tried turning equesrtia to a whole night


I think that the shadow pony is the remaining pieces of Luna in that 1vidio do princess' dream of magic sheep.


it can't be star swerld the bearded because he was around for saumbra pluses he died


I think star swirl the beerded died and his soul is  the shadow pony.


i still believe your star swirl is discord theory so i don't believe this theory


do Flash Sentry and Twilight Sparkle name matches 😕


it can't be star swirl because there is no horn


But the shadow didn't have a beard or cape it's a good therie and all but that is something to think about!!!!


Yes star swirl is shadow pony makes sence


MAYBE STARSWIRK WAS BANNISHED THEN CAME BACK AS DISCORD!!!


It's Star Swirl The Bearded I think it's him but isn't he good?

No he was not good because he wanted to be an alicorn and tried to steal princesses magic


I have a great idea for you I think it was trikse


it can't be star swirl he has a horn....the shadow pony don't have a horn.......


Stars world of bearded is the shadow Pony


I did have other thoughts but you had proved me rong.


Sombra is turned to .......... SOMBRA???????? (funny?)