As for a makeshift 6 -- Just because there was no rainboom doesn't mean the original main 6 are off the table.  Sure they would be impacted by the event, but assuming that was a kobayashi maru test for Twilight, she would have attended Celestia's school, just not been her personal student.  She still could have excelled and been magic or one of the other elements.  She also had a reason for being in Ponyville to see the Summer Sun Celebration, since she would have been more distanced from Celestia, but from her earlier memories as a filly still would be in awe of her.  Rainbow Dash might never have found her love for speed, but she is still quite the weather pegasus, and has a ton of pegasus magic.  If she still ended up the weatherpony of Ponyville, she could still be available.  Maybe even be a better loyalty if she was loyal to Gilda and Fluttershy.  Rarity wouldn't have gotten her diamonds mark, but she still loved dresses and such.  She could have gone in a ton of different directions.  Whether or not she stood out enough in Ponyville to be of interest as a candidate for an element, who knows, but it is possible in practically ANY direction.  Fluttershy would probably have never come to Ponyville without the rainboom.  I don't know what her destiny would be, but it would likely be very different.  AJ would have stayed longer in Manehattan, BUT this doesn't mean she wouldn't come back to the farm eventually.  She was miserable in Manehattan and has a strong family bent.  She could be even more honest without the rainboom if she is forced to be honest with herself and come back to Ponyville without prompting.  Pinkie Pie would likely have stayed on the rock farm.  Poor Pinkie Pie.

So, this means Twilight is still a possibility -- the weakest link being if she went to Ponyville to see the Summer Sun Celebration.  RD is still a pretty good chance.  Rarity is a possiblity.  AJ is a remote possibility.  The other 2 quite unlikely.  My guess is 2 or 3 of the main 6 would still be members of the main 6, and the other 3 or 4 different ponies.


Either that, or Luna never turned into Nightmare in the Discord universe.


Twilight never became her student so to save Luna celestia could've used the elements to save her


Or maybe in one of the timelines she never became nightmare moon.


I think that the only reason Celestia wasn't connected with the elements anymore, was BECAUSE THE SONIC  RAINBOOM happened, in a world where the sonic rainboom didn't happen, she was still connected to the elements and reformed Luna to help her with discord, as for the nightmare moon timeline I think your right that their different outcomes, the nightmare moon timeline was because when Celestia freed Luna discord destroyed the elements of harmony, but that's just a theory.


I have a idea, what if Nightmare moon never existed in this timeline? Celestia and Luna spent so much more time fighting discord that Luna couldnt turn in Nightmare Moon?

Or Celestia wanted twilight to defeat nightmare moon to become a alicorn. Celestia always could defeat her.


simple Discord Reformed her so that she and her sister could be his play things I bet he was like oh luna's evil now <b>snap</b> Reformed.

simple Discord Reformed her so that she and her sister could be his play things I bet he was like oh luna's evil now *snap* Reformed.


Every video answers many questions the fans have


Discord Is The Lord Of Kayos Maybe He Used His Power To Transform Her Back Into Princess Luna


I mean what if Luna didn't turn into Nightmare Moon?


Luna probably never turned into nightmare moon in the other timelines and discord never existed in the others.


I love the once with different timelines


Hey Sawtooth, have you seen the new mlp 2d series "clip"? 😭 Its absolutely horrifying

early mlp fim animation was a bit uncanny at times as well, im giving them a chance to iron things out, or for it to grow on me!


I also like this video very well just keep making similar videos because I will definitely like them too 🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂👍👍👍👍👍


Is it worng that I kinda want to live in the time line where discord takes over.


While Luna was in the moon who has been raising the moon was it her evil form or celestia found a way to🤔🤔


Maybe before discord became stone he may have freed her


What if Chelsea reformed her in one in the other she took over thank you for being an amazing YouTuber I hope you never stop ,Starshine Queen


Please do all of the multiverse video
I think in the Tirek timeline, Celestia doesn’t free Nightmare Moon and Discord was fooled by Tirek like in our timeline
And in a Sombra timeline, It May used to be a Chrysalis timeline too,
And Flim and Flam, that timeline is just plain stupid and they run out of villain
So my theory is
Discord only need himself to be effective
Luna and Tirek need Discord
Chrysalis need Luna
And Sombra need Chrysalis


Nobody: <br>Captions: how was nightmare moon reformed without the main sex

Nobody:
Captions: how was nightmare moon reformed without the main sex


The mane 6 would still exist but eithet in different circumstances, or they would be band of different ponies in many different timelines, there are some things are destined to happened, even timelines where the villains timeline wouldn't last long until their version of the Mane 6 bands together


FILLIES, COLTS, AND ENBY FOLKS--<b>happy enby noises</b>

FILLIES, COLTS, AND ENBY FOLKS--*happy enby noises*


Take into consideration that Luna bacame nightmare moon after Discord was turned to stone.
Remember, Celestia and Luna turned Discord to stone TOGETHER.
Then again, I might be wrong, just consider please.

Also, this is the daughter of the person whose account is being used.

Take into consideration that Luna bacame nightmare moon *after* Discord was turned to stone.
Remember, Celestia *and* Luna turned Discord to stone TOGETHER.
Then again, I might be wrong, just consider please.

Also, this is the daughter of the person whose account is being used.


I saw a video saying it might be Rainbow and Fluttershy who convinced Luna to do good since Rainbow was frozen in ice by Starlight. Maybe it was them


Heh- I'm early I think- it's 3am here I haven't slept for the past three days 😅 anyways love your videos! Keep up the amazing work! 🤭


All I’m wondering is how long it took me to finally notice that you have the bisexual flag behind your changling character in the channel logo.


Maybe discord took over before he was turned to stone for the first time.


Maybe Princess Celestia and Princess Luna had turn Discord into stone before Princess Luna became Nightmare Moon.


Hello sawtooth! I saw something just now and I think you should... At least have a fought about that if not make a video.<br>You know that black splach behind lunas cutie Mark? You realise celestia herself doesn't have that probably because DAYBREAKER didn't exist, but in starlights dream you can clearly see a orange fire behind daybreakers cutie Mark! Showing the dark side but what can it be? Since lunas one is the pony of shadows what can be celestias control?

Hello sawtooth! I saw something just now and I think you should... At least have a fought about that if not make a video.
You know that black splach behind lunas cutie Mark? You realise celestia herself doesn't have that probably because DAYBREAKER didn't exist, but in starlights dream you can clearly see a orange fire behind daybreakers cutie Mark! Showing the dark side but what can it be? Since lunas one is the pony of shadows what can be celestias control?


But Discord escaped because Celestia and Luna weren't tied to the elements any more, the main 6 were, so without them how did he escaped?


I know that I´m late, but Discord was rulling eqestria before nightmare moon. When Luna and Celestia defeated Discord, they became the rulers of Eqestria. But when Luna realised, that her sister got way more attention and every pony didnt even looked at her, she got jealous and also didnt like the fact that the ponies were asleep at night, while beeing happy at day. So she wanted to defeat her sister and turned into nightmare moon


Discord is the lord of chaos he has power over all reality prob if this happend discord would 100% win


Funny thing is, all of these are possible


if you like different timelines, then check the timeline where nmm exist bcs of the coruption of a goddess. for more details just asking is enough


Question Couldn't have twilight and the main six be the elements themselves? You know like the elements are kinda them and they were born out of the element but then moved to a new family? This theory could explain how Luna was reformed without the main six she was actually instead taadaa and to explain the reasoning of the new family part basically the element would send a sliver of itself into a sperm cell their chosen one which they would make look like a normal pony.


what if in one world with discord nightmare moon becomes Luna and fails to fight discord and in the empty timeline celistia becomes day breaker to fight discord but then loses control


But The Mane 6 Represented The Elements Of Harmony


These time lines are very different and confusing 😀⌚👑🍉


Discord happened even before Luna or Nightmare moon. 🌕


That time was before nightmare moon their earliest period in the timeline


So I’m not very smart but maybe as an answer to 0:49 maybe she could have freed her sister herself but was waiting for the right people to do it? As you said in a video about the theory of alicorns saying Celestia was looking for the right people to rule Equestria once she went back to her home, maybe freeing her sister from the cell was the test to decide it all and she was just waiting for that moment to arrive


how will changelings reproduce now without a queen?🤔


What would have happened if Princess_Celestia found the Elements with the help of Twilight Sparkle and freed her sister by herself while the other ponies were living normal lives?


I thought of another theory.What if Celestia let free nightmare moon then she met discord and they teamed up, destroyed Celestia and halve of the land was nightmare moons and the other halve was discord’s?!


#3 hi i’ve got a question so remember your discord video when you were when you were making up theories about who could the score do you wanna be in the human world well I think he could’ve been a assistant principal that was working with principal Luna and principal Celestia and then when he was working he was making up trouble with luncheons by changing the ingredients or making the classes longer and making the bells ring at the wrong time and then principal Luna and principal Luna did a contract with discord and now he’s not with them for 10 years but then the next 10 years he’s back and he’s stirring up trouble but now with the main seven they try to convince this girl to be good and that’s the rest of the story tell me what you think 🦄🐴


Another theory is that celestia released nightmare moon reformed her but Luna starts dream walking. In a world where hope is lost because there is not main 6 Luna could provide comfort for the ponies. Then celestias evil side comes to life.

Edit: this means the universe we left behind is open for new theories, kinda like a new pov of mlp. So from season 6 on we get to fill in the pages of the last story this show every told


Since discord can break Tierks and Cosy Glow out of Tartarus brought back King Sombar whatever to him in season three. Then give them magic which isn’t his (as it not chaos magic) <br>And from season two he can rise and set both the sun and moon. He probably when ok “Click”day time oooh Nightmare Moon “Click” now Luna “Click” now a clown. As you said. Now discord have only lost when he had lost he magic when Tierk took it ……oooooh too many ideas running though my head now. Can’t let this comment go to long.

Since discord can break Tierks and Cosy Glow out of Tartarus brought back King Sombar whatever to him in season three. Then give them magic which isn’t his (as it not chaos magic)
And from season two he can rise and set both the sun and moon. He probably when ok “Click”day time oooh Nightmare Moon “Click” now Luna “Click” now a clown. As you said. Now discord have only lost when he had lost he magic when Tierk took it ……oooooh too many ideas running though my head now. Can’t let this comment go to long.


I would wanna live in a timeline where derpy had the element of magic

Alicorn derpy


I think Nightmare moon Was freed by Princess Celestia And they talked,Fight and then when it started to be peaceful she used the Elements of harmony years later Discord came and started chaos but without the main Six the princesses have to defeat the villains demseleves, So they fought Discord but Like you said Discord may have gotten Luna's magic so It was only Celestia and who won? Discord


This is just a hunch but didn't They defeat Discord before Luna become nightmare moon

So it can be possible that Discord defeat Luna and Celestia and corrupted there brains like he did with the main six but in a different way.

So it's possible that Discord took that opportunity to take control while the princess were under his control, so the future could have been changed that the main six was never needed or never existed in the first place with Rainbow dash sonic rainbow or Celestia taking twilight as her student.

Because it all happened from the start when Celestia and Luna first fought discord but failed to stop him.

But that's just a theory

A Pony theory!


Didn’t discords rule happen before Luna turned into nightmare moon?


Did you randomly select ponies to be the wielder of the Elements of harmony? How come there's more earth ponies and only one Pegasus pony in the group?


Can you do a theory video about why the writers of the MLP FIM show decided not to give Spike the same kind of character development as the Mane_6 since he's the male protagonist of this show despite being a Dragon and not a pony? The only thing I don't understand is that why did Celestia give Spike to Twilight Sparkle instead of returning him to the Dragon Land after he hatched from his egg. Why does Spike even exist in this series if he can't be treated like an equivalent to Twilight and her friends which makes them jerks and racists for not having any kind of sympathy for him?


I think that the discord timeline happened before luna became nightmare moon and after she became she took over


But I thought that discord only escaped because celestia and Luna weren’t connected to the elements anymore in the first place? I really like the first theories but they wouldn’t be possible if discord hadn’t broken out of his statue (which wouldn’t have been possible without the main 6 using the elements to reform Luna). So I personally think the theory with the “replacement” for the main 6 would make the most sense, but as you said why wouldn’t celestia just do it herself? I always speculated that celestia only tried to force twilight to make new friends and sent her to pony ville because she saw potential of a new princess and a new ruler in her and that reforming Luna would just be the first step of learning about some kind of new magic (if she didn’t also plan that twilight would become the princess of friendship). So why would she use replacements for the main 6 in the ulternate timeline? (Since she could have done it herself) THIS IS HARD HELP


the tree of harmony was destroyed freeing disord and luna since it was the elements that put both in there place luna was put in the moon by celestia and discord was seal with the elements with both princess sooooo if the tree of harmony was broken would not both get free? for the reformed part ....... lets say wean night mare moon was finally free she was going to defeat her sister but discord change her back case he can. IF discord can fake a harmony summon the cutely mark magic he could do things that unicorns cant this is my theory..🦓🐴🦄


or a timeline if celestia got corrupted and luna was ok


The main six weren’t there and I actually thought that she would actually do it where you would be like the slap your face like what did you think she would do apparently just magically get them out there


In MLP ( the series) we saw living beings in there except ponies like changeling and yaks <br>But in MLP new generation.....do they still exist

In MLP ( the series) we saw living beings in there except ponies like changeling and yaks
But in MLP new generation.....do they still exist


btw at the first episode twilights book says how the stars will come together and free the mare in the moon after 1000 years (edit: wait they said that)


“I dont have a problem! I can stop when i want”<br>Me: Are you sure your ok? Im starting to become concerned

“I dont have a problem! I can stop when i want”
Me: Are you sure your ok? Im starting to become concerned


mabye she never became nightmare moon in the discord time line


Hi sawtooth remember season 4 ep 1 and 2 the discord thing happened before Luna trainedformed into nightmare moon


i think discord deafeted night mare moon but celestia was crisales and deafeted the both meanings chrisales met discord but had a battle and lost in the mean time celestia used the elements of harmony and deafeted nightmare moon so then she teamed up with others and then grogar , teirk and cozy glow then grogar lost because of the belle and the villans ruled as the time no princess can defeat them


Hey sawtooth can you do a theory about the human world and how it’s changed


Tirek defeated sombra, Sombra defeated queen chrysilis, Queen chrysalis defeated nightmare moon and nightmare moon defeated discored?

Is discored really that weak?


nah if they never defeat discord then no they won’t rule so she won’t get jelly


Maybe nightmare moon wanted to become luna again. I have a pretty good theory which I want to post on my channel, whenever I start it.


For discord to be released did the CMC have to be friends. If so then Pinkie Pie and Applejack would need to be friends for Apple Bloom to go to Pinkie for help finding her cutie mark and for her to end up in the party. If Apple Bloom never went to the party the CMC wouldn't become friends making it less likely for them to talk to each other. Maybe they never would have argued and set discord free?


The timelines are so confusing, you could make videos on them for years...


In the other timelines Luna never Turned in to nightmare moon


Sawtooth watching all 9 seasons of mlp without blinking everyday looking for any thing to make a video on;


Sawtooth…<br>Then who released nigtmare moon in our timeline?…. Discord?

Sawtooth…
Then who released nigtmare moon in our timeline?…. Discord?


Well ig the spell only lasted for thousand years.


maybe it took place when luna and celestial were fighting discord?


What if there wasn't a Nightmare Moon in the timelines


My opinion is that is that in the alternate timeline Luna she didn't have to be Nightmare Moon at all.
Also did you notice anything strange in 3:40? :|


luna was in the past that time line is from the past like celestia said a old enemie of mine it was luna cause twilight went to the past in the past luna wasent nighmare moon<br>so thats how she isnt nightmare moon

luna was in the past that time line is from the past like celestia said a old enemie of mine it was luna cause twilight went to the past in the past luna wasent nighmare moon
so thats how she isnt nightmare moon


Ahem did you forget? when the princesses defited discord the mane 6 whearnt born


JESUS CHRIST,you gotta feel bad for the Chrysalis timeline if that's the case! First Discord,then Nightmare Moon,then Chrysalis!


Discord was free and princess luna fought each other in one time line princess luna won in her time line and the discord time line discord won by taking luna evil magic


The stars tub how do you get out of the moon in that and then Princess Celeste Dia turned her back by herself sup


I still think grogar helped nightmare moon escape


Oh don't be sorry I love alternate time lines just as much as you!😅


How come when Luna gets was to maybe be released by discord her hair is flowing already cause when the main 6 defeated nightmare moon her hair was just regularly<br> to the blue

How come when Luna gets was to maybe be released by discord her hair is flowing already cause when the main 6 defeated nightmare moon her hair was just regularly
 to the blue


Discord only escaped from the CMC and if they didn't fight their it wouldn't of happened


Breaking News, changeling Queen gets roasted by changeling.<br>(Epic)

Breaking News, changeling Queen gets roasted by changeling.
(Epic)


Wooww Lyra and Bon Bon is my favorite! Basically after ten thousand years Luna was trapped at the moon right? But when Luna was become nightmare moon and was banish she was young when she turned to a nightmare moon she still have white hair and then when I saw discord was chasing them why does Luna looks like older now she has what celestia look now even she was young when she was banished at equestria. Did discord transforms her into older? Because sometimes I caught discord very demanding and irritating maybe discord does not like what Luna looks like when she was younger then he turned her into older cuz Discord can do a female pony into a male pony.


But Luna was there the first time they banished discord to stone....she help her sister use the elements


I missed the "alternate time-line" theories 😅👍


Who knows, maybe their really was a different version of the mane six


I don't think. Discord would get the elements because in a timeline without the rainboom the main six will not get their cutie marks at the same time and they will not come together  and go into the everfree forest and discover the elements the elements are in their form because of the Mane six and in a world without the main  six no elements


Oop I got a good idea maybe discord reformed her so he could do chaos on her or something


👀 what would happen if discord met one of his variants ?


Maybe celestia or discord didn't free Luna maybe it was in the past before the Mane 6 or before discord was turned in to stone


Discord was before nightmare moon so it had nothing to do with the mane 6. So if discord won Luna had no time to get jealous

And when Luna was reformed she looked  a lighter shade but when twilight looked back in time to when Luna was banished she looked like how she does now


♥💖💞🦄 i cant blieve you thought that this cort could take all the magic from lona saik and she turndcin to the night mermon


On the 1000th day the  cliustius spell that she put luna wore off and she came back down


It's possible that in that alternate timeline they didn't manage to ever banish Discord, and so it's been chaotic all the way since the first battle.


Princess Celestia has used the elements of pornany to send Luna to the moon but when twilight and her friends has used them they didn't send her to the moon because princess Celestia was with them when Applejack finish her words so she didn't wanted to send her back she give her a chance to be a good princess.So she reforme because of discord cause he's an another animal and he has powers powerful than unicorns so he and princess Celestia just can do it because princess twilight cannot reforme her when she wasn't a princess.So I think just princess and discord can just reform her.
(Can I get pinned?)


It was never a form without winning she would have nothing to go off of becoming nightmare Moon so she would just be Luna and she would have been in the Future movie


6:34
Me: this is discord his power is very unknown


Didn't nightmare moon appear after they had sealed discord away


Question <br>When the royal sisters switched cuity marks celesta said when raising the moon “that was easier than raising the sun” then who raised the moon when night mare moon was in the moon

Question
When the royal sisters switched cuity marks celesta said when raising the moon “that was easier than raising the sun” then who raised the moon when night mare moon was in the moon

Celestia? The book at the start literally says "The elder sister took on responsibility for <b>both sun and moon,</b> and harmony has been maintained for generations since."

Celestia? The book at the start literally says "The elder sister took on responsibility for *both sun and moon,* and harmony has been maintained for generations since."


Can you talk about the other 5 timelines


OR... Luna didn't turn into nightmare moon at all... I mean why would Luna be mad about controlling only the moon when Discord was controlling both? <b>dun dun duuuun</b>

OR... Luna didn't turn into nightmare moon at all... I mean why would Luna be mad about controlling only the moon when Discord was controlling both? *dun dun duuuun*


This guy could give Doctor Who a headache.


okay this sure is pretty uh, mind boggling


I think night mare moon doesn't exist in the discord time line as discord is the villain before night mare moon


Discord came after the mane 6 reformed luna


That was Luna before she turned into nightmare moon


My ancestor Derpy is the one who became the new alicorn princess after Twilight Sparkle's death and she's leading her troops into war with the unicorns and earth ponies.


What if the elements of harmony unleashed nightmare moon!


Well in Cutie remark there are many problems
1 why didn't Twilight changed nor her cutie Mark
2 how did spike even exist cuz we saw twilight was fail to hatch egg ?


Error if celestia freed luna in 2 other timelines after discord is free celestia trapped luna with the elements then how was she able to find and free luna from prisonment


1st up love the thumbnail and great video I agree with this allot and great to see you still making videos 👏👍❤


He said he can stop whenever he wants but I don't think he can 😏


Wait....could discord go between all the timelines


Now what im wondering is who are the four stars or “forces of good”


i was gonna say that maybe nightmare moon never came to be but

NIGHTMARE MOON HAPPENED BEFORE THE MANE 6 LOL


bro it could’ve happened before luna became deppreso


You know discord was there before nightmare moon,right?!?


i think discord CAN  remove corruption magic let me explain

chaos has no definition that's why it's so chaotic discord as the spirit of chaos has an unlimited amount of power including taking power so i think
DISCORD REFORMED NIGHTMAREMOON


Make a video on cosmos and princess eris<br>They are also a draconequus

Make a video on cosmos and princess eris
They are also a draconequus


Luna looks  reform  but  this was before  she became  nightmare  moon


What if some or most or maybe even all the timelines are just if the certain villain came into power depending on some timelines the villain failed but in someday succeeded in staying in power what if that’s what it is some succeeded in saying in power and some failed so that’s made a new timeline?(just thought of that when watching)


Maybe Luna did not become nightmaremoon in other time lines


Luna was reformed Not by the main 6 by the way this is a great video


Tirek is the strongest valían in my little pony


What about Apple bloom, Scootaloo and Sweetie bell


Now do a theory as to how the Flim-Flam brothers destroyed Equestria with capitalism


This happened before she became nightmare moon


3 comment)
1) You might as well talk about all the alternate timelines as many times as you want because lots of programs that involve alternate timeline tend to have a lot to say.
2) I think there was one MLP FIM comic book that may explain how all the other timeline came to being.  I think it was called MLP FIM Deviations.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_tE6MNRUVVI
3) I'm pretty sure even if the "forces of good" didn't release Nightmare Moon, she still would have found a way to escape and return just like how Discord found a way to be free from his stone prison, like how Kings Sombra found a way to escape his inter dimensional prison or like how Tirek escaped Tartarus.


??? Isn’t the timeline with Discord ruling before Luna became Nightmare Moon? I believe in the season 4 flashback when Celestial and Luna defeated Discord with the Elements of Harmony before Luna became Nightmare Moon. I might be wrong. I like your theory though awesome job!


Can you do a video about what all powers Spike could have gotten in the Power_Ponies episode of the MLP FIM show instead of making him look like comic relief behind Twilight Sparkle and her friends which made me hate this episode?


So this means that chrysalis's unreformed self isn't even fully developed either. So ladies and gentlemen if this new chrysalis is your butterfly then the old chrysalis is your caterpillar.


Hey sawtooth maybe that timeline was because moon queen was not evil yet


Ok so this may be a normal question but Pls make a video of it because when twilight became the new queen of equestria what happened to her canterlot prep friends since she needed to be in equestria every day?


This timeline was before Luna turned into nightmare moon?


This is great it’s like my little ponies what if ?


I actually have a theory

What if Twilights student actually caused the fight between ponies I mean she did disliked friendship in the first place right?

This doesn't connect to the vid but I just want answers


Wait several questions and suggestions on videos like what would happen if star light goes back and stops him from getting his cutee mark, where is Discord now, where are the elements, can ponies now become curropted like luna i am sorry probably boring you just to many problems


And how is princess luna back from the moon?


why are princes Luna and princes celestial alive in the human time line since they are around 1000 years old when humans only live up to around 120 years but the average is around 80 years


When starlight stoped rainbow dash's rain boom night mare moon was EVIL! So how DID celestia free her, or whoever did?


Reminder that her name is Muffins. Calling her D*rpy is very offensive to her and disabled people and is considered a slur which is why her name was changed canonically


I want a heart form u sawtooth waves!!!!


I think you Are right bc we never saw hos she reformed


Btw, discord took place BEFORE nightmare moon. Nightmare moon happened after discord was turned to stone. Did u forget that the sister found the elements to defeat discord? And Celestia already had them to stop nightmare moon. So yeah discord happened long before the mane sox and so did nightmare moon obviously. Celestia still would banished nightmare moon and the story goes on without the name six

Yes. I’m attempting to explain It, I think the first comment comes off as I’m trying to disprove it. I realise now that my comment is kinda stupid so yeah 😂


Season two episode one Celestia says me and Luna fight discord so in that universe were discords wins that means they lost


because discord was turned to stone before luna became nightmare moon


Here’s a video idea: what does the human world look like now.. with the whole segregation thing that was happening in equestria.. how does that transfer over to the human world?


0:19 yah right... well before you "quit"😏 will you make a theory on how tirek wasn't defeated?


Make a episode about another stain glass window in the future


sawtooth, I don't understand this video! Sawtooth, can you please an understandable video about who is Gusty The Great?


I thought that timeline scene happened before she was banished to the moon.

nope! the timelines split off at the rainboom!


Discord was first then night mare moon came in and it was before he turned to stone


I have so many questions/ theories about the new movie


if it was 1 timeline as you said. then wouldn't there only be 2 timelines then. ! is the original and the other one is connected somehow?


Why does flurry heart as a baby look different from those two babies from the bakery


Maybe it's never have a nightmare moon at the first place because celestia can't find the element too vanish discord or all the the villian in another timeline or something like that.

Or maybe element can't use in another timeline


3:41 why does Scootaloo not have her wings?

@The American Girl Doll Film Channel   O:

@The American Girl Doll Film Channel   O:

Random animation error, or……

Maybe it was Discord’s chaos magic starting to randomly go out just before  he freed.


Hmmm..<br>Maybe Nightmare Moon never existed. She never got jealous of her sister? Hmmmmm…..

Hmmm..
Maybe Nightmare Moon never existed. She never got jealous of her sister? Hmmmmm…..


Theory: What if Luna herself did not corrupt before discord the cutie mark crusaders may have not been the one to set discord free could've been multiple ponies or any pony for a matter of fact we know that discord became stone BEFORE luna became nightmare moon {Mabye..? tell me if i'm wrong} it's possible some other ponies set discord free even before she corrupted there are to many questions towards these timelines and you always seem to wow me thinking of things i never even looked closely into,i lve you're work and i'm always looking for more from u ^_^


Can you do a video about what spitfires nickname could be pleasssssssssssssse


Why is Derpy the one with the crown!?! That’s way more dangerous than all the other villain (reformed and not reformed ) combined!


in a place where dicord rules it means that luna neveer turned into nightmare moon


i think nightmare moon got free because of the stars but idk if twilight sparkle can defete 'nightmare moon' because acording to my mr. milk 'that anything is possible like if your a god you can defete nightmare moon'<br>thats all

i think nightmare moon got free because of the stars but idk if twilight sparkle can defete 'nightmare moon' because acording to my mr. milk 'that anything is possible like if your a god you can defete nightmare moon'
thats all


Which villian or villians do yiu think created the desolate timeline?


oh sawtooth LUNA WASN"T NIGHTMAR MOON BACK THEN


I don,t agree . In alternative timeline celestia was not ruling and Luna did not have any reason to be nightmare moon


ummm, wasn't the fight between celestian and luna and Discord?, and then after that luna became nightmare moon?


Wait a minute I thought discord came BEFORE princess Luna becomes nightmare moon and that means that Luna didn't get to become nightmare moon because there's already chaos

No hate tho


I think princess luna was reformed by a new mane six


Maybe nightmare moon was not reform maybe it’s just you know before discord then nightmare moon so that’s why Luna was there in the episode princess twilight sparkle when she drink the potion Luna was there with Princess Celeste


Could   night mare moon not possible be there. The main six  wouldn't be born


But that doesn’t make sense those two are completely different timelines one time line is what would happen if they didn’t stop nightmare moon and the other one is if they hadn’t stopped dicorn


is  luna and celestia still around in gen 5 if they are that means tha twilight is too


It can be That celasia Return Nightmare Moon to Luna because After 1000 years she learn how to do that.


... You Still In Winter? It's Nearly February's End Ya Know?


uhm I thought Luna turned into nightmare moon AFTER banishing discord to stone....


I've still been wondering what happened to Twilight Sparkle in the timelines when she failed the exam (failed to hatch Spike) [no sonic rainboom].
What was she doing during the war with the Crystal Empire?
Chrystalis' rule?
Nightmare Moon's rule?
Discord's rule?
etc.

In "The Cutie Re-Mark", we only saw Twilight Sparkle cross over from the original timeline.  She didn't looked up her alternate self.
[Marty McFly never met the version of himself who was supposed to be in a boarding school.]


Wait cilesia mention that she isn't connected to the elements no more maybe that's how Nightmare Moon was free and Discord because any spell that's she used with the elements it became undone


YOOOOOOOO!!! Luna theory!!! great video!


This was before she became nightmare moon


im thinking a bit that maybe tirek also could have been in that but idk


Hey Saw tooth what happen to the griffins, dragons, yaks, and changelings in MLP A new Generation?


I think the elements of harmony was just did not last for ever so star just aid and Luna just came before discord show up


What if she never did become night mear moon


In that timelime. maybe things changed and she wasnt nightmare moon!


Luna became nightmare moon before Luna and Celestia knew Discord-?


Princess Celestia made a timer To release princess Luna


I think I read a fanfiction about this exact situation


I know I know that nightmare moon is reformed by celestia and DISCORT by ......... discord HELPED celestia reform nightmare moon to luna that's why she is playing . They became friends.


Or maybe every single timeline happen in a different year or in a different month it’s possible


because luna and celestia stoped discord before luna turn into nigtmare moon


Ok, one question
How da fak Flim and Flam rule the world in their timeline???
I mean, they can be unicorns, but don't have the enough power to beat Discord, Nightmare moon or even Celestia 🤔


I thought they defeated discord before she was nightmare moon?????


i think it was her dad who fred her or it was gargord because he turned into the stars and so he propule got vanished and wanted revenge so i think he tryed to free her to get revenge maby i am rong or i might be right


How is princess luna back to normal from nightmare moon?


Wait i just realized. Where are the crystal ponies in mlp new generation!?


Wait how did she change because she was different


You got no problem just you want to continue your theories on it and videos


because celestia will die someday (ik sad) and she needs somebody to carry on the elements and keep them safe


Uh did you know that discord going to stone before Luna's turned to nightmare moon right


Actually that time when Luna was not nightmare Moon she was not nightmare Moon yet that’s why


I think that no-one released night mare moon maybe she was released by magic , there's always been a 1000 years thing so maybe magic whithers away around a 1000 years <br>Brohoof

I think that no-one released night mare moon maybe she was released by magic , there's always been a 1000 years thing so maybe magic whithers away around a 1000 years
Brohoof


Completely unrelated to this video in the episode where they reenacted the older Equestria  where Celestia and Luna weren’t there yet why are they on the flag?


Maybe she wanted twilight to do it so she can learn friendship


That was before luna became night mare moon


What if in the discord timeline she never became nightmare moon?

You said in one of your videos that if Luna walked in dreams before she became nightmare moon celestial became daybreaker. But if she didn’t there would be no reason for the mane six to come together.

nightmare moon was in the moon when the rainboom happened


I got a question k so yk when the human twilight is a unicorn in equestria right and then when she powers up she has wings ????? WINGS


night mair moon  never done she was loved all the time but day bracer


When discord first came nightmare moon wasn't here yet


Discord got free before Luna Walst bolth of the sister’s arrival fighting Luna wouldn’t have the jealousy to celestia


0:20 thats what drug addicts says and yet they cant


So, your saying chrysalis can’t exist without help?


Discord had the elements , maybe he used them

i dont think discord exemplifies the elements or harmony in general lol


This came out the day before my birthday


Do remember, that different things happen in the past, from the smallest difference can led to different results in the future


Did you know that princess Celestia is married to scorpan


Wait but what if the cuitemark crusaders didn’t meet if the rainboom didn’t happen I mean maybe applejack stayed in manhattan and then applebloom went there to or maybe rarity and her family would not live in ponyville and then sweetiebell wouldn’t be there. But it the cutiemark crusaders didn’t meet then they weren’t the ones who broke discords stone prison so who did?


What do you think Luna would be like if she never became Nightmare Moon? Is Princess_Cadence the only Alicorn without a dark side?

Luna would've looked how she does in the show in season 2, as that's what she looked like in the past. As for Cadence, technically, she does have a dark side but it's from the comics, which aren't canon.


Which villains would win in a fight in a free of all? Let me know who and why😈


Wouldn't discord not be free cause qithought a mane 6 there still control the elements so discord won't  be free


Ζørrøsε Μγτhøs


hey in discord timline it might be Luna is good and never turned into nightmare moon


were the elements even found u think princeusse luna turned to nightmare moon becuse of the sonic rainboom but think about it when the elements were use on discord luna was thier but in a wolrd where the sonic rainboom dident happen would the elements change magic and symblos  u ask questions about timelines but heres the thing u dident consirerd if luna and celista never found the elements and use them agaist discord would luna even turn into nightmare moon in the first place Noo bc celista and luna would of tryed fighting discord so nightmare moon couldent be reformed in this timeline bc thiers no nightmare moon Nightmare moon was never thier bc discord had so munch power that he could of just hide the elements and then destoy the realm so the timeline where thiers no sonic rainboom thier could also be no nightmare moon or unless they could be if luna tranformed into nightmare moon being fed up of discord turning discord into stone and making sure celiste doesent find the elments of harmony again traps her sister in a moon and then finds the elements and keep thems in her castle for hiding


Maybe he sicssdid  the first time and Luna didn't become jealous?


Unless the time of Discord was before she was Nightmare-moon

Oh yeah, this world is literal CHAOS<br>ANYTHING can happen

Oh yeah, this world is literal CHAOS
ANYTHING can happen


Please, make a theory about Sunny Starscout's father. I have a feeling he's a very mysterious and interesting pony who must know a lot about Equestria and the Mane 6.
I have been looking at his things in their house, in the movie, like ancient maps of Equestria and I think I noticed a book that showed a picture of the Tree of Harmony.
Like, what if he's from a lineage of ponies who knew how to put all three pony types together, just like you told in your theory about what happened to Twilight?
And he was with the earth ponies artifact, that's mysterious, right?


How old are you? I'm not being rude but i want to prove my dad that even gronw up like My little Pony


You're making a lot of assumptions here.


This doesn’t make sense because the regular time line Luna got free on her own but other time line thare is no nightmare moon I can see discord freeing her but why will we ever now


Make miraclous theories pls you would figure everthing out maybe another channel


Cool i am from Romania 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍


How old do you think Spike would be in the new generation if he still be able to be around I mean just look at the last dragon lord he was big and he had to be old


But that was before luna was nightmare moon


I was rlly starting to miss the long videos


Maybe luna was not nightmare moon maybe this was when they went to discord and failed sorry for being derpy. :3


Hmmm this actually makes sense<br>WHO knows meaby in a couple of years you wil replace matpat or at least help

Hmmm this actually makes sense
WHO knows meaby in a couple of years you wil replace matpat or at least help


I have a question you know the MLP movie what happens to the portal the twilight went threw and what happens to canterlot high


I'm the 1000th comment HAHAHAHA

About the makeshift theory, derpy can probably oneshot all they needed was their assigned element, lmao.


Wait didn't Celestia say Discord got free by that she and Luna din't have controll over the elements anymore and it was because the mane six had the controll now?

And who made up the legend about in a 1000 years Luna would be free?¿


Or it is a mistake from Hasbro and it wasn't intended


And we never saw twilight at any of them ??????🤔😶🦄


Mlp for me makes no sench but i whood love to see that princess Luna And princess Celestia make colts happy as clowns


But- but if there no main 6 or à New main 6 the élément couldn't be here- there Stone like on the first épisodes 🤔


Simple answer the mane six probably just reformed nightmare moon and then discord probably took over simple answer


She could not of become night mare moon.🌜😈


Whats going on with cutie marks in a new genertion. Cutie marks could be a diffrent kind of ancient magic thats not in the crystels but nobody knows.


Well that's before she turns into nightmare moon u dude earth pony


but what abot cozy gloe did she got her time line


Sweet. I’m early. I’m on a plane so I’ll watch it when we land. We haven’t taken off yet


What button I have to press for a date with you?


I think you are right. and by the way i am a kid and a big fan of you


It’s been such a long time since I wanted you


If the rainboom does not happen would that mean the mane six have different cutee mix???


But then in our timeline..How could she go back if 1 timeline celestia is imprisoned and 1 she is reformed?


If you know my favorites i like Applejack derpy and someone live in the farm with red hair a girl


😠 so not true what are you talking about the mane 6 reformed nightmare moon end of story!! <br>Just saying that's all!

😠 so not true what are you talking about the mane 6 reformed nightmare moon end of story!!
Just saying that's all!


Please make such a video only in russian


HOW SHE WAS REFORMed is because she growed up and her her is a wavy mane then that is similar to nightmare moon with good power so thats how she got reformed


In the clip you show with discord. Nightmare moon not born yet. But then bad guys took over each lands they where at in 1st episode they show in.  And with battle or fake battle means more love or friendship.  Because most see her fighting beside nightmare moon clip.  Only how with discord how he got out of jail. This part have to take part after season 2 where they beat discord. And remember saying that 2 princess say we not remember discord after mane 6 battle. But lot of that know for saying like Disney princess alway say to keep us safe.  Discord review next plz, on same clip you are showing here.  Otherwise glad in normal world of mlp discord and Luna is good. Cat believe mlp with out to funny side pony’s or whatever you call them.


I think this happened before the hole drama


Uhh can you use it in a full sentence please.


Touch his waist I know this is a devout Caribbean but I was walking the new mind that a pony movie again and I knows there is a picture of stars worlds the bearded when they were showing Sunny's dad making that dingy it was behind a bunch of boxes really hard to notice maybe maybe stars where the B day lived for that long


Derpy is kind
Derpy is nice
Derpy is the community
Derpy is us
Derpy is you
Be like Derpy

Derpy is kind
Derpy is nice
Derpy is the community
Derpy is us
Derpy is you
*Be like Derpy*


Luna tandon tonight moon later when discount was defeated


And I want question if we need to defeat like my moon then why did night my moon game to celestial and she is a beautiful and kind princess I think this is I can think even more because night mode is son of the sister I mean she is only

I am I am really sorry stopped in only I will continue that in this message okay only the person whose near celestia so I think so Twilight sparkle and all can not friendship long friendship so why did wanted night lonea to be the sister


Since you did a video about why Rainbow Dash doesn't deserve her element, can you do a similar video about Rarity since it's hard to tell that she is generous since acts very picky about small things, she acts like she was born in Canterlot and she takes full advantage of Spike's crush for her? Along with Twilight Sparkle who cares more about books than anything else and who is an abuser when she's with Spike. Don't take it the wrong way but if you've seen the show real carefully, you'd know what I mean


She is reformed by celestiala   beacuse celestiala didn't no how reformed Luna before now she knows how to reaform with the elements of hormey


Still bothering you sorry but you think cadence is the alicorn of love you are right but you are wrong about flurry heart the alicorn hope she was born a alicorn to bring the people hope think about love and hope are what the crystal heart is about they had love cadence but no true pure hope so the HEART blessed cadence and equstria with the alicorn of hope one step closer to embodying all mental traits into a powerful embodiment


My man literally rosted Crystalis
(Too lazy to fix her name)
((Not that I care😏✨))


I’m At school so I gotta watch this later when I’m home


I watch all your videos and u post I have to watch your videos


about scorpion My Little pony and what happens to to Queen Chrysalis when starlight defeats her and after she makes his clothes at the My Little pony the five the six friends what happens to her after that what do you think happens and and in the movie like what do you think who why were they all like why didn't the map show all those places even before they went there because like wouldn't that map show you the entire world though first I think that's weird and in the future twice hair starts slowing like Alessia and lunas did and starlight she gets the entire School of friendship in the future and gets married to whatever his name is I'm guessing twilight's purple is related to them cuz she has her skin and and he has her hair his hair like it's obvious and who's the very first bad guy in this world who is it hope you can find out


Um, i have a request. Whom did Twilight actually married. Because the pony Twilight actually loves the human Flash but the human Twilight loves another guy. So I really wanted to know whom Twilight actually married to. Can you tell me


Ur my favorite YouTuber  please reply 😭💕

Ur my favorite YouTuber  please reply 😭💕


Hey 😊  this nightmare moon and celestia  the timeline  2 twilight put nightmare moon  in the moon  and then <br>Celestia this  which the timeline   l maybe

Hey 😊  this nightmare moon and celestia  the timeline  2 twilight put nightmare moon  in the moon  and then
Celestia this  which the timeline   l maybe


……please fix the subtitles they are replacing 6 with s#x ;;


Me I think that discord  let luna escaped because he felt bad for her because she was trapped inside the moon it might have gave discord painfull merrmiors of him being trapped inside stone


Moonselight#Roadto300 (Join my edit comp)


Because it was before nightmare moon existed


This is not how timeliness work, delete this and come to me if you want to know how they really go. Discord was raining chaos before she was nightmare moon

This IS how timelines work. One change can have drastic effects on future events; season 5's finale proves this by showing how stopping the Sonic Rainboom doomed Equestria.

Something very well could've changed prior to her becoming Nightmare Moon. Perhaps her jealousy reached its limits before Discord started to rain chaos on the land, causing her to become Nightmare Moon much earlier? THIS IS WHAT THEORIES ARE FOR.


What happened to discord in the current time


It's clear that Sawtooth is running out of ideas...


But what happened  to the other creatures


How do you feel about mlp friendship is magic leaving netflix

@Sawtooth Waves then do you watch mlp on dvd or blue ray


In these other dimensions if the main six didn’t get their cutie marks what happened to them did they oof 🥺

In most of the timelines you see that they each ended up getting the right cutie mark eventually so the question is do they literally have a magical connection that is non-existent if they don't all get their cutie marks as a result of the same event? If so, how does it work exactly? Does it prevent the from meeting in Ponyville? Does it just prevent Twilight from discovering friendship? Does that mean Celestia didn't assign her to be in charge of the Summer Sun Celebration? Literally what is "cutie mark magic"?


What About the Mane six still getting their Cutie Marks in the alternate timelines?

He explained it in another video; the Mane 6 would've gotten their marks in different ways not connected to the Rainboom.


I USED THE ENGLISH AUTO GENERATED CC BYEEE 😭😭😭 THE MAIN S- 😭😭😭😭😭 BYEE I'M SO SORRY 😭😭


You said only 2 timelines but 3 showed up😦😧


of discord happened before night mare  moon -_-


I think it just was discord took over before some how and Luna did not feel what she felt to be come nightmare moon a because she was not jealous because they did not rule sorry if this is not good gamer end spell my ip keys oare disid choseing to not wrok


THE StArS will aid her escape so.... duddddddeeeee isn't sunset shimmer twilight sparkle twilight velvet and starlight glimmer have stars on their pony marks and twilights crown and even when she gained her power were stars what if it was a sign that a new princess is emerging huh???? <br> also, I got another theory what if.. just what if.... twilight wasn't there but moon dancer was right? without twilight, Moondancer would be the smartest celestial student what if she was sent and she was sent to ponyville and her friendship just wasn't strong enough without the rainboom connection? like maybe applejack was late from Manhatten rainbow dash was a bit less arrogant Fluttershy started liking animals a bit late and so and so on they're friendship would come to exist but a bit late!

THE StArS will aid her escape so.... duddddddeeeee isn't sunset shimmer twilight sparkle twilight velvet and starlight glimmer have stars on their pony marks and twilights crown and even when she gained her power were stars what if it was a sign that a new princess is emerging huh????
 also, I got another theory what if.. just what if.... twilight wasn't there but moon dancer was right? without twilight, Moondancer would be the smartest celestial student what if she was sent and she was sent to ponyville and her friendship just wasn't strong enough without the rainboom connection? like maybe applejack was late from Manhatten rainbow dash was a bit less arrogant Fluttershy started liking animals a bit late and so and so on they're friendship would come to exist but a bit late!


This is not related to the video but do u think Grogar created the windigos


So this means that thorax wasn't just chrysalis's subject but he was also her son.

@Reese I think sawtooth has a big messy house.

@Reese remember Betty white from the golden girls.

But the nursery hive. I saw him split his egg.

@Reese so then why did sawtooth say that human thorax was human chrysalis's son?


Sorry for the mean comment I thought you forgot about me I'm so sorry


Here’s what I think:

Remember that back in episode 1-2 (Friendship is Magic) when Twilight finds a book where she reads the part “On the longest day of the 1000th Year..”. After this, it says “the stars will aid in her escape” meaning that someone who controls the stars released her, probably being Celestia herself because the Sun is a star.

Maybe all the timelines were created like this. You might have been right about the fight with Discord and Alina, but what about the elements? The elements should have still worked, maybe only with Celestia. If that worked, Discord would have gotten turned to stone, and Luna would take over Equestria, creating the Nightmare Moon Timeline. The Discord timeline? Like you said, discord would overpower Luna, send her back to her other form and crush the elements to shards like how Nightmare Moon did on the 2nd Episode. King Sombra timeline? Well, Cadance and Shining Armor would be defeated without the main six, therefore, making a war against Equestria. Queen Chrysalis timeline? Without the main six, Chrysalis gains control over Shining Armor, defeats the other princesses. Applejack, Rarity, and Rainbow Dash are possibly imprisoned.  Also, another possible future: Trixie! Trixie becomes upstoppable with the Alicorn Amulet, and without friendship to stop her, she makes the princesses bow to her and make them work as servants.


Buddy you do have a Dixon from ultimate time lines you really do stop 😑😑😑😒😒😒😒


By the wey this discord time Line is e a exaly what we twighlit seas wen she drinks that white poison from zecora two times that means that the royal sisters defidid discord befor Luna beceme nightmare monn


I think it’s that nightmare moon didn’t even exist

Look now maybe discord defeated them before they tern him to stone


1:00 the f**k is wrong with the subtitles bro?!, it got drunk or some? haha!


I know Why but if you heart  this comment I will tell you in an edit


Where is discord family all creatures of the equestria we all the mythical creatures but except draconequus should Twilight find discord kind but draconequus are not in equestria there somewhere else in the human world they have continus like America South America Europe Asia Australia but in the quest yet they also had countenance like the episode scooters parents showed the global of the world how many contest of course your world has and how many creatures they are the answer is we need to discover and find out


Sooo Just a ideal for your next video- are applejack and rainbow dash lesbian?

@Sawtooth Waves I didn't actually expect you to respond. Thank you!!

dash, absolutely. jack, most likely. regardless they're a lesbian couple by the end!! <3


ABOSUS says: Me f**k off because I amogus

Шакарим Копжасаров

I don’t understand what the hell is saying something but o o o aaaaa so I don’t give a damn I’m amo ...

Шакарим Копжасаров


Почему это не на русском

Почему это не на русском


Why Celestia didn't reformed Luna herself? She was Lazy!!!

Because Luna was still Nightmare Moon, who was still hellbent on making Equestria's eternal night.


@Sawtooth Waves omg I never thought you would reply


Games Aptoide Aptoide look up Fast and Furious games Iron Man how to unlock Star Wars theme


If discord could take away the corrrupted magic then shouldn't he just take on all the villians. Even we know that freed villians that doesn't mean all of them.


ꨄRęgì kàwaií ûní gąchꨄツ


prolific content 38 and prolific content 37


Oh my God it's just a little baby show it's not a FBI show it's just a show there's no hidden secrets in it Jessie show what every little girl or boy watched when they were kids either you are a kid or you are not