kind: youtube#commentThread

kind: youtube#comment

textDisplay: This is a good episode. A great expansion on Granny Smiths' character. The founding of Ponyville story is pretty cool. Not sure how Granny figured out any of that stuff.


textDisplay: If Granny Smith really founded the town of ponyville she said not only would that make her hundreds of years old, being Twilight said the town is hundreds of years old in winter wrap but it would mean the entire town is descended from her. Which might explain why her name is literally Granny.


textDisplay: Granny Smith is the most important pony in the region.

textDisplay: granny smtth is the g.o.a.t

textOriginal: granny smtth is the g.o.a.t

textDisplay: She is basically the mother of Ponyville

textDisplay: Granny Smith is very important of equestrian history


textDisplay: Made me think ponies live hundreds of years.

textDisplay: If we assume she was 8-10 when Ponyville was founded, she could easily be in her 70's or 80's. A town can easily grow in the space of 50-70 years.

textDisplay: @Foodfangirl Yea but twilight said ponyville's existed for hundreds of years in winter wrap up

textDisplay: @eqtnpgd2008 It might just be a myth.

textOriginal: @eqtnpgd2008 It might just be a myth.

textDisplay: @eqtnpgd2008 equestria exists too

textOriginal: @eqtnpgd2008 equestria exists too

textDisplay: @Foodfangirl a grown pony

textOriginal: @Foodfangirl a grown pony

textDisplay: @eqtnpgd2008 maybe ponies lived in the land for a long time before, but perhaps was so rural it wasn't considered a town. Until Granny came along and put it on the map.

textDisplay: @nick o' the wisp i think she meant ponies lived in the area, but it wasnt officially a town yet. thats possible irl. a place can have people living in it but wont be considered a town until a certain point.


textDisplay: Apple Bloom’s rabbit outfit and bonnet are cute.


textDisplay: Celestia and Luna defeated discord in ponyville, a few years before Celestia banished nightmare moon to the moon

textDisplay: it also happened on season 4 episode 1

textOriginal: it also happened on season 4 episode 1

textDisplay: Actually it wasn't ponyville, at least I don't think so? In the IDW comics there's a map that shows that Discord's defeat was past the Appleoosan Mountains and was quarantined after he was turned to stone. https://www.google.com/search?q=mlp+idw+map+of+equestria&rlz=1C1OPNX_enCA944CA945&sxsrf=APq-WBsxjDzFtG09oi0RoPjaIgDF1unLkg:1647408383854&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjx2JO88sn2AhWLk4kEHWvODdQQ_AUoAXoECAEQAw&biw=1536&bih=754&dpr=1.25#imgrc=8U4aY6YXC0ZHfM

textDisplay: Where have you hears this<br>Nowhere in the show does it say that, and I don't recall it in the comics either.

textOriginal:
Where have you hears this
Nowhere in the show does it say that, and I don't recall it in the comics either.

textDisplay: I dont recall when twilight dranked the cum potion and saw the vision of the defeat of discord saying that it was in ponyville

textDisplay: It doesnt say it was in ponyville…. Unless it did im not sure all i know is thatit ouldve just been in canterlot or some other land


textDisplay: This episode hits different after reading An Apple Sleep Experiment


textDisplay: 13:39 “And maybe get our cutie marks in murder!”- Scootalo

textDisplay: scootabuse

textOriginal: scootabuse


textDisplay: Nah Granny’s just an immortal being

textOriginal: Nah Granny’s just an immortal being

textDisplay: granny smith is a pony being than twilight


textDisplay: I swear Granny Smith is so pretty as a young mare omg!


textDisplay:
0:23 You're too early ;)
1:32 I was pretty it's called Friend-With-Benefits. Oh well.
4:20 Bitch, it's still season 2 and we still hate you.
4:49 Kids.
4:54 Well, that's not dark at all. Facts though.
5:32 RIGHT?!
6:50 Imagine being named Filthy Rich.
7:28 Where should I start with that Bully...
9:16 Clever "Eureka" play!
9:45 "I don't want any whinin' or cryin' or crackin' under pressure!" It cracked.
14:59 ROLL THE CREDITS!
15:37 Granny Smith doesn't even care.
16:00 PonyBro would've smashed Young Granny Smith. Noted.
17:03 After pilgrimage? That's sounds AWESOME!
18:08 The timberwolves are a-howlin'! The timberwolves are a-howlin'! – literally first line in the episode.
19:49 Basically.
20:28 Call the firemen!
20:47 Whoa there! Granny Smith is amazing, but there's Derpy in Ponyville, okay?
21:56 Comeuppance!
22:24 *crying from the future*

textOriginal:
0:23 You're too early ;)
1:32 I was pretty it's called Friend-With-Benefits. Oh well.
4:20 Bitch, it's still season 2 and we still hate you.
4:49 Kids.
4:54 Well, that's not dark at all. Facts though.
5:32 RIGHT?!
6:50 Imagine being named Filthy Rich.
7:28 Where should I start with that Bully...
9:16 Clever "Eureka" play!
9:45 "I don't want any whinin' or cryin' or crackin' under pressure!" It cracked.
14:59 ROLL THE CREDITS!
15:37 Granny Smith doesn't even care.
16:00 PonyBro would've smashed Young Granny Smith. Noted.
17:03 After pilgrimage? That's sounds AWESOME!
18:08 The timberwolves are a-howlin'! The timberwolves are a-howlin'! – literally first line in the episode.
19:49 Basically.
20:28 Call the firemen!
20:47 Whoa there! Granny Smith is amazing, but there's Derpy in Ponyville, okay?
21:56 Comeuppance!
22:24 **crying from the future**


textDisplay: How come in the winter wrap up episode twilight said that for hundreds of years in ponyville they’ve been doing it the Earth pony way even though I’m pretty sure Granny Smith and filthy rich aren’t that old

textDisplay: Maybe Twilgiht wasn't talking about Ponyville specifically, but rather the entire region where Earth Ponies lived.  When Ponyville was founded, Granny probably brought all of the Earth Pony traditions to the town and those those traditions might be hundreds of years old.

textDisplay: Obi-Wan Kenobi all of Equestria has earth ponies, Pegasi, and unicorns living together. Ever since the founding of Equestria, except from Appaloosa and cloudsdale, there hasn’t been a land just for one type of pony in Equestria

textDisplay: Stinkin' Rich not Filthy.

textOriginal: Stinkin' Rich not Filthy.

textDisplay: Ro Noble it’s definitely filthy

textOriginal: Ro Noble it’s definitely filthy

textDisplay: @Youssef Lataoui No, Stinkin' Rich is the one in the flashback. Filthy Rich is (from what I can tell on the Wiki) his grandson.

textDisplay: @skylander king stinkin rich is rich but stinky

textDisplay: @Youssef Lataoui including stinkin rich

textOriginal: @Youssef Lataoui including stinkin rich

textDisplay: @Ro Noble he's filthy alright

textOriginal: @Ro Noble he's filthy alright

textDisplay: @Youssef Lataoui pegasus, earth pony, unicorn

textDisplay: @Obi-Wan Kenobi twilight is the young and granny smith is the g.o.a.t

textDisplay: @Alex Naanep what do you mean?

textOriginal: @Alex Naanep what do you mean?


textDisplay: I feel sorry for AppleBloom here.

textOriginal: I feel sorry for AppleBloom here.

textDisplay: same here

textOriginal: same here

textDisplay: @Jordan Jaramillo Because Diamond Tiara treats her like she is no one.


textDisplay: Yay

textOriginal: Yay

textDisplay: all hail the mane 6

textOriginal: all hail the mane 6

textDisplay: @Alex Naanep yup

textOriginal: @Alex Naanep yup

textDisplay: @Mary Bell EEYUP

textOriginal: @Mary Bell EEYUP

textDisplay: @Alex Naanep god pls save me

textOriginal: @Alex Naanep god pls save me

textDisplay: @Mary Bell god will save all of us

textOriginal: @Mary Bell god will save all of us

textDisplay: @Alex Naanep good

textOriginal: @Alex Naanep good

textDisplay: @Mary Bell we’re on the good side

textOriginal: @Mary Bell we’re on the good side

textDisplay: @Alex Naanep yep

textOriginal: @Alex Naanep yep

textDisplay: @Mary Bell eeyup

textOriginal: @Mary Bell eeyup

textDisplay: @Alex Naanep I need cookies

textOriginal: @Alex Naanep I need cookies


textDisplay: Not even close

textOriginal: Not even close

textDisplay: EENOPE

textOriginal: EENOPE


textDisplay: Diamond Tiara is the most stupid filly ever and AppleBloom is sweet.


textDisplay: 1:31 what are you? A angry gorilla or som