Wait... The elements would be hidden and Nightmare Moon or Dark Luna would be in control... princess Celestia would be in Moon.... She wouldn't be able to teach Sunset shimmer nor tell her about the portal... Which would mean sunset would never be able to think of that plan... She might have been a solider or a subject to Nightmare Moon.... But she wouldn't even know the elements, nor the portal. And all the other villains would be able to take control of certain parts of equestria


Sunset Shimmers Endgame might've been a major disaster
It's only a theory that she was strong enough but might've been outnumbered from the crystal empire so she knew only one thing to do

SCORCHED EARTH


Yeah without that boom-boom Sunset would have no way of obtaining that power- In fact, I don't even think she would have had a motive in the first place! That waste-land, I personally think it's because of all the war and destruction brought about without the six friends.


Your theory for sunset not being able to do her plan was actully true!


Now, in a far off comer of Cybertron, a young Autobot who decides Sunset Shimmer must be stopped...
His name is Rodimus
Could he be the Next Prime?

Robertson Skywalker (Creator of CANON TF EG)


Easy answer: because EqG is a spinoff kept separate from the main series.
But that's no fun.
I think you're on to something with your explanation.


Could you think about why cozy glow wanted to transport all magic of equestria to another realm? Is she from another realm? Why she couldn't absorb it all?


Well you said that the waste land timeline had no villain but what was the villain that was an emperor and was banished by gusty the great?


if the mane six were defeated there wont be a point so twilights element of magic wouldnt work but what about celestias?<br>she was betrayed by her why not take her crown? the baren place can be possible of the war sunsets power with celestias crown would be so much damage her motive was power so her power grew and grew... destroying everything BUT she ended up destroying the land nothing to rule she ended all of it years after it grew to a waste land

if the mane six were defeated there wont be a point so twilights element of magic wouldnt work but what about celestias?
she was betrayed by her why not take her crown? the baren place can be possible of the war sunsets power with celestias crown would be so much damage her motive was power so her power grew and grew... destroying everything BUT she ended up destroying the land nothing to rule she ended all of it years after it grew to a waste land


Hmm so here's a thought what if the barren wasteland was actually a timeline of if celestia and luna were never actually alive cause before celestia and luna it was 6 unicorns who raised the sun and moon but without them the sun and moon wouldn't rise and if the sun was what was up when the unicorns no longer had the ability to move the sun and moon then it would cause catastrophic disasters to the land and atmosphere making one side of there planet so hot it would burn everything to ashes hense the dust being blown around and the brown clouds are really dust and water mixed together with no ability to actually precipitate due to the constant heat from the sun


I kinda feel the last area was so empty and dark beacuse the powerfull villains including Nightmar Moon, King sombra, Lord tirek, Queen chrysalis and even discord had a battle with each other cuze all of them wanted to be the ONLY one who rule the Equesteria so because of their battle they all have been defeated som how and there was nothing else left except an emptiness and darkness...

That's what I think!


But how would Sunset Shimmer ruin Equestria if she was defeated because they were in the future then the one that ruined Equestria would be king Sombra


sunset wouldn't have had the chance to become the she demon cuz if the mane 6 never met the element of magic wouldn't be revealed, neither would've the other elements.


The reason we didnt see the sunset-timeline is bc, twilight did not become a princess, and the element of magic was still nowhere  to be seen, witch means she can't sunset cant have gotten the element to the human world, Twilight never came to that world to get the crown bc the crown was still in Equestria!

Ps: hope you read this!


I'm pretty sure the last timeline was because of discord somehow STILL coming into contact with fluttershy and then still being set free from friendship by tirek


Let's talk about Starlight glimmer why is she so powerful and remember when the mane 6 visited Starlight's village back in the end she had a spell she sudied for years but could never do


Maybe she could have some how use a spell to use the rest of them and do a different plan.


You said about a waste land,right?<br>Well,Did you miss the part where twight said it was because of starlight.

You said about a waste land,right?
Well,Did you miss the part where twight said it was because of starlight.


Twilight did not become an allicorn. That might change stuff from what we see in the movie, where Sunset tries to steal her crown which would never be found like the elements and Sunset would not have an army of zombies. Just think about it. Edit: I did not see the whole video yet before making this comment.


Remember sunset shimmer's power.in that timeline there was no sign of life there wasn't even a sun or moon I believe that was the outcome of evil sunset


My theory before I watch the video
So I’m like a couple seconds in and I wanna answer why there wasent a sunset timeline
Now sunset put one the crown and become evil
But if twilight and her friends where never there there would just be the elements but not in their necklace/crown forms
That would mean that sunset couldn’t steal the crown and she would never be evil
Reply if you like this theory
Edit: soo umm I am basically half way through the video anddd well I basically just typed out what sawtooth said


Is it possible its an evil celestia time line? Daybreaker could potentially have been the reason why we see a barren waste land. A land scorched by the sun?


Theory drconoques existed and discord looked similar enough that people called him one and then they went extinct <br>Theory 2 there is a spirit for everything and they take different forms and discord chose to look like this and been so long he forgot he is the chaos sporit

Theory drconoques existed and discord looked similar enough that people called him one and then they went extinct
Theory 2 there is a spirit for everything and they take different forms and discord chose to look like this and been so long he forgot he is the chaos sporit


The last timeline is clearly Fallout: Equestria.  (Disclaimer: I don't know anything about Fallout: Equestria.)


I'd say that the baren wasteland could have been the parasprites. I mean they eat everything soooooooooo, they could have multiplied and eaten all of Equestria then gone extinct due to lack of food. Just an Idea.


2:04 Well, who almost did that was Midnight Sparkle.


what if the mirror world was not affected by the timeline alteration<br>because it's a different world with its own timeline.

what if the mirror world was not affected by the timeline alteration
because it's a different world with its own timeline.


Video Idea: What If Human Twilight (Sci-Twi) wasn't forgiven for Midnight Sparkle Indecent at The Friendship Games.


Sawtooth Waves: remember the prophecy 'when the five are present a spark will cause the sixth element to appear That was Twilight SPARK
ME: Thats why they named her Twilight Sparkle TO make the spark

Sawtooth Waves: remember the prophecy 'when the five are present a spark will cause the sixth element to appear That was Twilight *SPARK*
ME: Thats why they named her Twilight *Sparkle* TO make the *spark*


I think that 7th timeline is what would Daybreaker do.


The 7th timeline could be that cozy glow transported all equestrian magic to another realm leaving it without magic causing what is shown at 7th timeline


I think I know about that timeline

It is all the timelines. With about 6 timelines of course their is nothing there. Equestria was doomed and the villens would have caused so much damage. The timelines are the same. Each Villain killed each other. Last got bored

This I just as crazy as me fixing It's about Time


How will Sunset know where are the Elements of harmony.  Only if she knew where the Elements of Harmony were she could find them. Can you also make a video on how the Main Six got the same Cutie Mark after Starlight Glimmer changed the future cause there has to be an explanation of all of them have the same Cutie Mark they had before the changed future. Anyways Great Video.


If the mane six never met, the elements couldn't have formed into the crown and necklaces they are today and said crown would have never been able to make it to the human world, having not existed, resulting in sunset shimmer graduating and peaking in high school to become a drug addict attempting to use Human Resources to make a potion that lacks the magic that goes into it, trying to recreate magic without knowledge as to how.


The last thing could’ve been the storm king timeline where he took over???


What if that empty timeline was because of daybreaker...


You always know all about my little pony and everything.


Cause there was no crown within her reach I bet.  If there even was the elements of harmony as six ponies, whoever they would be in the alternate timelines, a timeline where she is able to get ahold of the crown would be rare and few between.  Like if noob minecrafter tried to find diamonds without any help or clue.  So she would be without the crown for several timelines and/or never get it, ie impossible mission or it never existed as the crown.  So if such a timeline where Sunset took over did exist, I doubt that barren timeline is the timeline where she got it, because I think it would take at least a 100 more tries at getting rid of the Rainboom to reveal a timeline where she succeeded.  The barren timeline might've been the result of all the villian's fighting for control of Equestria or. . . <b>Gulps and holds up Daybreaker picture</b> this coming into play. . . Neither are good with the second possibility being worse than horrible.

Cause there was no crown within her reach I bet.  If there even was the elements of harmony as six ponies, whoever they would be in the alternate timelines, a timeline where she is able to get ahold of the crown would be rare and few between.  Like if noob minecrafter tried to find diamonds without any help or clue.  So she would be without the crown for several timelines and/or never get it, ie impossible mission or it never existed as the crown.  So if such a timeline where Sunset took over did exist, I doubt that barren timeline is the timeline where she got it, because I think it would take at least a 100 more tries at getting rid of the Rainboom to reveal a timeline where she succeeded.  The barren timeline might've been the result of all the villian's fighting for control of Equestria or. . . *Gulps and holds up Daybreaker picture* this coming into play. . . Neither are good with the second possibility being worse than horrible.


Why is always the Equestrian militairy/gaurds a white unicorn/pegasus? There’s only a few of them that are gray unicorns sometimes, and the ones in the Crystal empires is always like purple or light blue or something


I also think we didn't;t see Sunset Shimmer's timeline was because she came from a different world. All the timelines we saw were from Equestria. But Sunset comes from the human world. :)


I mean, The military isn't very good in MLP. Plus hypnotism can render them completely useless.

It could have happened if Celestia made Twilight (or someone else she trusted) with the Alicorn Amulet. Like with no other choice she went out of her way to find it and gave it to someone she trusted. Given how the amulet can't be removed without the barer giving it up this spells so much trouble with Sunset.

Now before anyone says anything about how the Amulet would have a different effect in the EqG verse, with the sirens, it has been proven that not all magic becomes different in that world. This means Sunset would get the power of the Amulet and becomes even more corrupted ruining Equestria...Still I don't think she will take it that far as to make everything dirt and ash. She is still flawed and when shown another way, it is possible for her to be persuaded to take it off...

Or maybe an insane red manticore plays a part of draining her or something...

Makes me want to write a fan fiction around this.


The reason that you didn't see sunset 'cause of the main six the ellement of magic became the crown. THAT never happend so.... No crown no sunset dragon creacer


The rainboom changes every thing of the plot so rainbow dash is very important in mlp


Sunset simmer might even have still been Celestias pupil still because celestia would hide it father in the castle so that no one could find it except for her and maybe Luna and celestia could explain to sunset simmer and maybe she'd even be a princess in that timeline well failing at certain times in the different time lines


Me: Scrolled by this video
My brain: G O. B A C K.

Me: *Scrolled by this video*
My brain: G O. B A C K.


I think that this time line was created by evil Celestia , maby Luna didn't  become evil in this future and Celestia did and their fight ended out with the destruction of Equestria


Maybe that timeline was when the dragon was asleep and snoring causing black smoke to cover the sky and the mane 6 didn't go wake the dragon? Because there was no sunlight the land suffered and crops didn't grow


Ну, знаешь, если у нас были миры со злодеями после найтмер, возможно элементы как-то появились, так что технически линия Сансет могла бы быть. Просто Сансет в другом проекте,в EG, поэтому её не добавили, вероятно


I an idea about that last timeline, now this is crazy but what if that was the "cozyglow timeline" think about it, she said "friendship is power" then trys to get drain magic, something dont add up i think there an unknown reason why she did that, but what if she did win and all the magic was gone, celesetia would not have the magic to raised the sun, making food to not grow and if the magic was gone in the day, maybe the couldsdale may need magic to make the weather and i know that thay could just get the water but what about the seasons, if couldsdale did need magic to make the weather, then seasons would not happened and if seasons dont happened, growing food would been really hard and would kill anypony...yes i know this really out there but hey this could have happened


But you forgot something. Princess Twilight had the crown in the castle. But they couldnt do anything about that then she wasnt Even there in the first place.


Maybe the destroyed timeline happenned bc of Twilight, maybe bc she was not able to use magic she Just freaked out and started to do something that destroyed everything or something like that

𝐿𝑖𝑙𝑎𝑐 𝐷𝑟𝑒𝑎𝑚𝑒𝑟


I think demon sunset is related to king sombra because when u look at the eyes there both green so is the something in common


Okay guys hear this, what if Diamond Tiara true meaning of cutie mark is to be a leader, a princess even. After reforming tirek and cozy she realizes what her true future is, being the Princess of Forgiveness, not only to others but to oneself, cause forgiving your past and looking to the future is what she did. So then she becomes an Alicorn and Twilight that was expecting her student to be one gets super suprised.


I know why they didn’t use sunset if they never met up then there would be no element of harmony bam 💥


Can you do a Theory vedio about the wasteland alternative time line and who was the villian that caused it. I don't think you've done that one yet I could be wrong.


That timeline looks like result of Nuclear war.


Starlight glimer's alternate timeline is the deserted world


HELLO DONT MISUNDERSTAND THIS: Celestia was trying to get sompony to take over her and her sister's thrones for when they retire. Celestia was doing it alone because she was seen more by the ponies, she rules the day and does all that other stuff. Celestia was trying to find many ponies like hope, sunset, and finally, Twilight Sparkle, who was perfect, finally. Sunset was not angry from the start and learned about the mirror unlike other ponies (and the other ones not to see the mirror for this reason,) and sunset saw her chance to gain power, and took it. after then twilight became allicorn but twi was not allicorn when sunset ran away to other realm, ok as you can see, I have a lot to say. if you have any questions pls reply.


Corrupt Versions of Luna and Celestia working together


It was nightmare Moon cuz she was a evil one in the movie in the my Little pony movie because she was trying to take all everything inside a ponyville


2:22 yup that’s sunset demon look in the sky isn’t that a SUNSET And if you’re thinking
“Oh that’s just a sunset”
Well look in the upper is black so it’s has to be her.

My theory is she actually got  to the portal but risked her tribe once she went in she used her power to rain chaos in the castle Luna and celestia were obviously warned  but once they went up there  she knew he would be defeat so she was ready she shoot celestia horn and Luna tried to fight her but her power is weaker then her sister so she failed she got rid of them in a pit once she was sone she rained terror across pony ills and the 5 main were there to stop her but without twilight, there magic was nothing she defeated them with the magic she had all elements and did something never before she destroyed it using the crowns she angled it to the crown and shot! The ground broke and dust appeared the ground was cactus like she rained over there  for a couple millenniums until her rain was over the other villains rained there creating terror in equestrian with them ruling it was a wastE land of nothing.


but how would she have gottwn the crown as the elemnt has never been activated and made into a crown


@Sawtooth Waves   hi i have one crazy teori what even tuching to the last alternativ space, but its realy hard to write it full, but for start its about one "pony" what show her self in basikly all big fights across all seazons and in Eguestria girls was person what look same but in EG she had Red hairs and slowly changing to White and in MLP was allready full White. Soo my teory is about As EG are acualy a long (around 50 000 years) past vz MLP and she no even survive what will hapen there, but allsoo maybe did it.<br>if yes She probably did even the last alternativ space as not mean to make thing worst but to Restart the World after probably global catastrofe (not just lokat as was all thing before even in MLP)(ps interesting thing in MLP when Tyreck steal all magik from ponies all for them was weaker, but you can see her when he kignap Main friends that she standing there without problems)sorry im not greath in English and i hope its interesting to you.

 @Sawtooth Waves   hi i have one crazy teori what even tuching to the last alternativ space, but its realy hard to write it full, but for start its about one "pony" what show her self in basikly all big fights across all seazons and in Eguestria girls was person what look same but in EG she had Red hairs and slowly changing to White and in MLP was allready full White. Soo my teory is about As EG are acualy a long (around 50 000 years) past vz MLP and she no even survive what will hapen there, but allsoo maybe did it.
if yes She probably did even the last alternativ space as not mean to make thing worst but to Restart the World after probably global catastrofe (not just lokat as was all thing before even in MLP)(ps interesting thing in MLP when Tyreck steal all magik from ponies all for them was weaker, but you can see her when he kignap Main friends that she standing there without problems)sorry im not greath in English and i hope its interesting to you.


Wind, burn tree log, sand, created by hot wether.


Why didn’t sunset stay in equestria she could have taken over the equestrian army’s or is it different?


New video idea : Why does moo ndancer  look like twilights mum


marvel what if...? episode 1, what if sunset shimmer won


Gonna admit, surprised there is a changing tier


Another world we can only think about: Sunset becomes evil, yeah. But what if the mane 5 without twilight went to the castle and found the elements, with sunset going as well, she might be the spark they needed, with her becoming the princess of... well, whatever she would be. Then she becomes good, becomes Celestia's student again, and keeps going down the path of becoming an allicorn. Who knows? Also, Celie was trying to get sompony to take over the throne for a while. Think about all the other ponies she had at her school. Probably why she has the school. If not this, something else could happen. Who knows? ANYTHING can happen.


Can you talk about what is beyond the everfree forest


COULD YOU DO A VIDEO ON LEGEND OF EVERFREE ??? like a theory or something!!!


Sunset was a student of Celestia maybe Celestia want to teach sunset how to make friends cus shes a part of the elements of harmony maybe it needs to pop up if sunset could have discovered that she was apart of it if sunset could have discovered shes apart of it in the pony world not in the human world obviously its not gonna pop up there because shes not in the pony world shes in the human world that why Celestia wanna help sunset make friends like if you argee its only a Theory :) hope this helps


hey i have a question when sunset shimmer went into the human world what happened to the man sunset simmer i mean her clone from the human world

1) She might be in a whole other place in Earth
2) She accually met her countrepart and pony Sunset proove her to go to the other world with her whole family but she lives in another land by transforming into another creature like a yack, a hippogriff or a zebra or much more with some sort of spells.
3) She lived centuries ago because I notice that if the piilars wherent in limbo for 1000 years, they will be already dead and I think in the human world, they are in history, same with the princesses and the principals. I think human Sunset lived in Middle Age
4) She doesnt exist because her parents never married here


But, the crown wouldn't exist at all without Twilight


Can you please please please please please please please do a video on reforming king sombra. PLEASE!!!!!!!!!


I don't think the power of the crown would carry over because sunset would change back to pony and since a: she would be a new kind of pony monster thing, she was a she demon in the human world so wouldn't she be some weird creature in the pony world and b: wouldn't the crown not be powerful because she is now in the pony world, if she changes in to a pony or something then the crown would not work. She would be no match for the guards also she could not be faced with guards, when Sunset stole the crown Twilight yelled so loud that the other mane 6 heard it and the guards weren't there. This kinda leaves a gap between this theory and the movie and the show, I would want an answer to these questions and once you do maybe the theory will change. :l

Btw of course the other elements with out the crown the other elements would not be powerful not working at all and the human world would be totally different, Sunset wouldn't need to go to the human world, but when sunset said " I know all about this alternate world " it seems like she has went there before.


Do you wonder what happen to twilight castle when she no longer live there


What if the SIRENS weren't defeated? if they got to restore their power to reach its full potential and travelled back to Equestria, in the movie they were restoring it little by little, somehow it would have worked somehow


3:5t we did not see her, she was still in hums. World, wonder why she not come back to the pony world. And as a plan for, since you picture of her look like fire, he amost could set all the tree on fire and make a home of bad leaves.  And take over ponyville


Can someone tell me who put the thumbs up


well I think it was nightmare moon and daybreaker timeline


bronynotion i saw you watch studio c i recommend watching the older videos instead of the new ones


Simple Sunset would not get the crown of twilight if twilight never teleported to the human world.If the main six wasn't there then no one went through the portal to the human world except sunset herself


Dear Sawtooth waves what is 30 x 24 = 720 so how many days are in 30 moon's it's 720 days.


How can she get the crown if the mane 6 didn't exist so the crown wouldn't exist so thats what I think


Sooo... What's going on in the dessert future ?


well i just noticed that equetria girls and my little pony are simular look at sunset she became like nightmaremoon so the end might be same too my little pony


so what if the rianboom was pervented i think in know how it happend so sunseat would go back to the pony world and thout she didnt sucsed but the eleament of magic she would think its powered by magic right then she would use her magic then get the eleament but what if she took the other eleaments then the wastelank we saw could have been the distruten of deman sunset with all of the eleament thats how i think the wasteland came to be hope you like my sunset sorneo bye

i forgot saying that she defeted celastia

i mean it could not be the case but thats my vison


i think that was a time line for sunset because sunset = sun which its fire  and  wahat are the effects BOOM ITS SUNSET TIMELINE which could have killed celestia and i dont sunset  can fit BUT with the other elements gone there that could effect the element of magic which it could have whore off BECAUSE everything looks burnt SO THE WHOLE EQ COULD BURN TO FIRE!!


What If Sunset Shimmer Was Queen Chrisalis


Well the "Future" what there was. Was propably cause without Twilight and her friends wouldn't have defeaded all the "Bad guys". In the end all the bad guys like. King sombra and tirek and all would have destroyed themselfes. And the whole world with it. So yeah i think its like that.


And convince the twins to do it I feel like it is good look the land is bored burned


So if rainbowdash never ever made the rainboom then-


This isn't related to this particular episode but when Double Diamond bork the volt why was so wek


I think it was grogar who cused the  baron wasteland future


Hi ummm I really like these videos you make and I had an idea you could use (or not I don’t even know why I’m doing this) it’s about discord at the end of the episode about reforming discord when flutter shy said “see he can be a real sweetheart” (or something like that) princess cylestia makes a strange face and my sister said that was because she knew that because maybe she had liked him a while back like before she had to turn him to stone. What if it had something to do with why he attacked equestria or something


Why did sunset want to take over equestria


This makes total sense but what doesn't make sense is why that was there could it be possible that it was grogard tereck or cozy glow ?


Hi I know you not going to see this but clear shy cutie mark dose not make sense to me like how dose she have a cutie mark with wind and sun as a unicorn?


Likes: 6.9k
Me: likes video
Likes: 7k
Satisfaction..


Sawtooth shark

Are you a shark cause there's a sawtooth in your name


And happy thanksgiving my bro ur doing good on Yt


Starlight was doing it for sunset because starlight and sunset were best friends ok and sunset was chosen and starlight  . Starlight pass the test and sunset fail so yeah ok I know that


Ya lo sé cómo sería y si son cestería no era uno aparece en la primera vez un pony dos la segunda vez cuando invito a twilight que genial y tres ya la vi en un episodio donde estaba tu ayuda y no sabía twilight regreso y no importan y dijo twilight si me verías de


Like the element won't be a crown like that remember first episode


Why in equestria high sunset shimmer doesn’t have a double because she was born in equestria so where is her double


Heart me plzzz
I’ve never been hearted

Wait I have an Idea

Sawtooth Waves
Sawtooth Waves
Sawtooth Waves

Will it work?


I think we didn't see her was because she never was there think about she the crown and she was defeated so in the time line she never was there 😳


I believe the timeline where Equestria was nothing more than a barren wasteland might have been caused by Daybreaker.

Think about it, what would an unrestrained Celestia do it she believed she could have it all. Perhaps she was tired of holding back and decided to make everything burn, maybe as an attempt to bring order to Equestria. Kinda like Judge Death in the sense that the crime is life and the punishment is death.


Is sunset from the human world if not where in pony sunset?


Crogar if I spell this wrong it is because I don't know how to spell it


Hey I was wondering should I make a chanle like this?


Here is something we should not forget: Twilight would have ultimately become a princess and Spike would have been born regardless of how Starlight affected the timeline. Spike never disappeared and Twilight never lost her wings throughout any of the events we saw.

This also implies that Twilight ultimately finds the Mane 6 and the element of magic regardless of what happens, possibly because they already ultimately found their ways to Ponyville before Twilight arrived, as seen in “Celestial Advice”. Perhaps one reason as to why the events of the alternate timelines happened was because Starlight caused everypony to either learn that bullying was a good example or want to become just as powerful as her, driving Chrysalis, Sombra, etc. to ultimately have high enough ambitions to achieve their dreams, but perhaps the sonic rainboom is indeed a magical explosion that increases the amount of magic in areas below.

In other words, we never saw a timeline where Sunset won because nothing Starlight did could have affected it, but this does not stop us from dreaming up our own timeline. Even if Sunset could drum up an army of victims, they may not do much past the portal because they would be forced to learn how to walk as ponies for the first time and perhaps stumble a lot, though I’m unsure whether there would be a 100% guarantee of ponification.

But let’s assume that Sunset and Sunset alone were indeed a force to be reckoned with. If the element of magic can indeed work without the other elements, who’s to say that the other elements can’t also work in isolation? Five of the Mane 6 would equip the remaining elements and, backed by Celestia, Luna, and Cadence, easily defeat Sunset. While the EQG series would not be as interesting with only six of the seven main characters, the outcome of Sunset’s misdeeds would likely be the same.


I'd would have liked to see a timeline where Sunset never became evil. I wonder how her presence would have affected Equestria.

Might be a good idea for a video.


2:23 My personal theory on what caused the "Barren Lands" Timeline is The Pony of Shadows. Now hear me out, sure the Pillars contained him but he was eventually freed when Sunburst found Starswirl's journal. He seems powerful enough to defeat the Pillars even at a weakened state, so at full power, I'd think the two sisters wouldn't stand a chance. His motive also aligned with what happened to the timeline, he doesn't want to rule, he wanted to "drain all the light and hope of this miserable world", with the potential outcome showing in the timeline.

As for how he is freed when the Elements aren't formed, the answer is simple Sunburst. Elements or no, Sunburst is a knowledgeable pony with a love for antiques, meaning he'll eventually come across Starswirl's journal. He'll then try to bring them back to prove to himself that he is worth something even after flunking at Celestia's school for gifted unicorns. Perhaps he'll even have Celestia to help to prove himself to her. Once he freed the Pony of Shadows however, he'll be devastated that the Darkness may actually seduce him to the dark side too. Making the Pony of Shadows even stronger and eventually destroying everything.

I know it's a bit of a stretch but that's the closest thing I could think of what happened to this timeline.


You could’ve explored a hypothetical alternate reality, not caused by Starlight’s intervention, instead exploring what if she had managed to do it in the prime timeline. That way, you can explore what would’ve actually happened if she had made it to Equestria with the element and her army.


I think the “Barren Wastland” timeline could be something caused by someone really important, like Twilight or the Princesses. Hekk, this might even be Flurry Heart or someone else, as we don’t know how far into the future that timeline really is. I think it’s a very interesting topic nonethelees.


I always saw the barren wasteland as soemthing created of fire.

And there is an entire kingdom of dragons out there.
In my opinion, under Torch himself, an invasion of Equestria could even bring the ruin to the land.
But only under him.
What made Dragonlord Torch mad enough to burn Equestria to the ground? I don't have any ambition to know that.

I always saw the barren wasteland as soemthing created of fire.

And there is an entire kingdom of dragons out there.
In my opinion, under Torch himself, an invasion of Equestria could even bring the ruin to the land.
But _only_ under him.
What made Dragonlord Torch mad enough to burn Equestria to the ground? I don't have any ambition to know that.


First off, cute hairpin, it's adorable and you should wear it more often <3
Secondly, my thoughts as to what could've caused the destruction timeline, maybe it wasn't one person. We've seen villains able to team up before. What if it wasn't one entity, but most of the villains teaming up and draining everything from the land to get what they want? Each in varying degrees. When Chrysalis couldn't drain anymore love, she left to other places, leaving everyone permanently miserable. Tirek drained all their power to make himself the head monarch so everyone was weak and empty. Discord ran rampant with chaos, making these sad, tired ponies agitated and cynical. All the while they played with the ponies in their own twisted ways and stripped the land of all its sources and all its magic until... there was nothing left. The ponies were no more. The land of Equestria was no more. And soon, maybe... the world was doomed to fall apart.
But, hey that's just a theory.


A bit after watching this, I came up with an idea where Sunset could've succeeded, albiet the Rainboom barely has anything to do with it. Picture this:

Sunset follows through with being Celestia's student, and eventually gets sent to Ponyville. The key differences so far is that Sunset still has power on her mind and there is no Spike to attract any form of Fluttershy. Anyway, she goes down to Ponyville and meets a few "Friends" (I'd say they would stay the same as Twilight's friends, except Applejack and Fluttershy wouldn't be there and probably are replaced by other ponies, who knows) and learns of Nightmare Moon and the Elements of Harmony. Flash forward, they arrive at the castle and face off Nightmare Moon. You see, I don't believe the Elements of Harmony are really drawn to good nor evil, the only reason they have done good is because the ponies using them were good. I mean you've seen what the Element of Magic itself did to Sunset. Instead of Twilight's Realisation of "Friendship is Magic and a strong force for good", Sunset's realisation would've been more like Cozy Glow's, "Friendship is Power which I can use." When she realises this, the Element of Magic shows itself (I imagine all of the Elements look like a corrupt version of Twilight's Timeline) and she destroys Nightmare Moon and by extension Luna instead of freeing her, and transforms into demon Sunset Shimmer. The other 5 would start running and their elements vanish, being scattered across Equestria Chaos Emerald style. Sunset Shimmer takes over, Celestia appears but gets defeated by Sunset, end of the world.

But what do you all think? Did I think too much into this as usual or-


Interesting take.

Also: the plot thickens! Syannax is no longer on good terms with Sawtooth! Together with Yoshi Darklord, they continue to disappoint Sawtooth and our questions continue to stand unanswered.


I have wild theory about the military gear from Dragon quest. Camo is easily explained in researching animals but I haven't seen any Quards or Wonderbolts using the equipment that mane 6 had in the episode.

Theory goes this way Sunset or somepony went EQ world and bring back some wacky stuff that Equestrians can examine. The military gear was impractical for the Equestrian military because there haven't been any large scale war/conflict. Instead of scrapping the equipment, they just sell it as cosmetic.

And why I'm 3AM over analysing show that's target demographic is kids?


I feel like there could be another possiblity on why she wasn't in one of the timelines, the mane 6 could've somehow still found each other, except when they found the elements Nightmare Moon won, and shattered them. This could have an explaination. It could be that, their friendship just wasn't as strong and Twilight could've given the wrong spark to the elements. So, instead of fighting alongside Twilight with their designated elements, they probably just stood behind her watching. So, Sunset wouldn't have had an element to steal, not in the first place, but anymore because it's broken, or shattered.


What if the timeline thing had even more villains?
Pony of Shadows: First, Sunburst and Twilight would have to have a different relationship than they had in the main timeline. They have to be much closer. One would find out about Starswirl's journal, and the two of them would find all those artifacts, release the Pony of Shadows, and since Twilight never met the Mane Six, no Elements of Harmony to help the Pillars, and no Cutie Map to tell them where Stygian is. The Pony of Shadows would then cover Equestria in darkness, and when Twilight shows up, she has to light her horn to see, but it has a much weaker light.
Windigos: Chrysalis causes distrust between the three pony types before the wedding, because of something happening, probably Trixie losing the duel, and ending up in the Changeling Kingdom instead of wherever the Alicorn Amulet was. When Twilight arrives, she is covered by snow, and the snow activates the spell, sending her back. Or, Flurry Heart destroys the Crystal Heart, covering the Crystal Empire in snow, and the Crystal Empire reflects this across Equestria, and all the ponies begin fighting each other
Trixie: Twilight still meets Trixie, probably during a Canterlot show, and after Trixie loses, she finds the Alicorn Amulet, and Magic Duel happens, but without the help of the Mane Six and Zecora, Twilight loses. Trixie then proceeds to take over Canterlot, and when Twilight arrives, everything is a Trixie show. Also, Trixie has banned wheels.
Sirens: They discover a portal to Equestria, and begin doing whatever they were doing before the Pillars. This would also cause the Windigos to arrive, but the Sirens somehow manage to control them.
Grogar: The energy from the Rainboom gets sent to space, and Grogar gains the power to escape by himself. When Twilight arrives, everypony is working their butts off for Emperor Grogar.
Starlight Glimmer: Complete starvation, but the ponies aren't dead yet, and there's still grass. No idea how Starlight even conquers Equestria, but somehow it's gonna happen.
Cosmos: Pretty much the Discord timeline, but much more malicious, with actual harm coming to the ponies.
Sunset Shimmer: Her plan no longer involves the Element of Magic, but now involves manipulating the other villains into helping her. Every villain mentioned above, plus Cozy Glow, Chrysalis, Sombra, Nightmare Moon, Discord, and Tirek would end up helping, and somehow, she would turn Celestia into Daybreaker, leaving Cadance as the only Alicorn Princess. Maybe Flurry, if the villains haven't already attacked.
Parasprites: Without Pinkie in Ponyville, the Parasprites devour the entirety of Equestria, leaving only Yakyakistan, because the yaks figured out the Parasprite music thing, with the Yovidiphone.
Also, in my headcanon, the reason Rainbow Dash is so fast is because Sonic the Hedgehog and Barry Allen blessed her as a baby. Don't ask why. Just don't.


I think I know what happened.
We all know now that the elements didn't get discovered by Twilight and her friends because they didn't discover the magic of friendship.
And in the season 4 premier, the Tree of Harmony shows to be dying without the Elements of Harmony. And as Twilight said, each present is worse than the last. What would be a worse present/future for Equestria than for the Tree of Harmony to completely die off?!

Here's the thing. The elements don't get reunited with the Tree, and the Tree dies completely.
Now I know what you're all thinking, why didn't we see any of the vines or thorny clouds then?
Here's why.

The vines were able to grow when the trees protective power started to die.
So when the tree dies completely, it allowed the vine to grow to a massive level.
But when things start to overgrow, they can die off.
I believe that's what happened, is the vines got to overrgrown on each other, and consequently killed itself off over time.
But not before causing destruction to Equestria and its inhabitants.
Without the Earth ponies to take care of the earth, and the Pegasi to handle the weather, and without the overall protection of the tree, Equestria itself just died and faded away.


So, the butterfly effect stopped Sunset from succeeding in the alternate timeline? Huh, never thought of that. Great theory as always.


I personally think the last timeline that is empty and dull is the Starlight timeline. If she took all cutie Marks from equestria, the earth ponies wouldn't be able to grow    food. Pegasi would't be able to controll the weather and the sisters wouldn't be able to do day and night. So all the ponies would die then  and there would be nothing to see


She could have done things differently by taking the five elements and merging them together to make the sixth element which could have obviously caused destruction in Equestria meaning that that lifeless timeline could've been hers but like you said, it's frightening because it's unknown.


I don't think Sunset could have used the Element of Magic... however, there are other sources of magic in Equestria that she may have been able to use. However whether she would have been able to get a hold of any of them is another matter entirely. Also I'm not sure that the Mirror would have been moved to the Crystal Empire had the Sonic Rainboom not happened, as it's likely that things would have played out differently and Celestia would have decided to keep it in Canterlot (she said she moved it there for safekeeping, but that's only because the Crystal Empire was safe after Twilight and them were able to defeat Sombra, without Twilight it likely wouldn't have gone as well).

Another thing to note is that Demon Sunset may have turned more of the Canterlot High kids into those demon forms she turned Snips and Snails into, so it's possible that they could have been more of a threat than just regular zombie ponies. But that's hard to tell. Either way, Sunset winning at the end of Equestria Girls could make for an interesting fanfic or something.


Alternate timeline where celestia has to use the elements so the sixth appears. She stores them closer to her for emergencies, this keeps equestria safe. She takes them to the crystal empire to defeat sombre. That is how sunsets plan works.


I like to imagine that Sunset probably would've turned all the students into demons, like she did with Snips and Snails.


What if she was drawn to, and ultimately found, the human world's elements (the geodes)? She might have used the combination of those elements to overthrow Celestia. After all, those geodes give you interesting powers - reading memories and emotions, super speed, talking with animals, exploding sprinkles, shields and other structures, telekinesis, and super strength. I imagine a super powered evil Sunset travelling to overthrow Celestia.


The Ash world, in my oppinion was always when Solar Flare/Day Breaker eclipsed Nightmare Moon. It just reminds me of a world burned to ashes.


I like to think that the cause of the apocalypse in the last timeline is Celestia.  They have shown one villain after another and the next threat to Equestria beyond Nightmare Moon is Celestia herself.


But heres the thing, when twilight got her spark it became a positive impact on the elements of harmony whereas sunset shimmers spark was the negative impact of the elements of harmony her deprive for magic was so negative because she was desperate but having that was a good thing because with the defeat of sunset shimmer she became a better person/pony and changed her error of her ways and now she has a home in the human world where she could use the element of magic usefully. Just like how daylight shimmer defeated midnight twilight; with the words of “ take my hand twilight let me show you theres another way, just like someone once did for me” that someone was twilight sparkle and with that sunset shimmer spread the element of magic across the world, so in the end i think it was better off not to have a sunset villian in the pony world.


1:39 what I think about that timeline. is actually a foreshadow of the "end". you know when all 3 villains mess everything up? they got so greedy that the world couldn't give them anything anymore. so what we seeing is a result if they have won.

well that's my theory on that part of the timeline. it made sense to me.

because they turned the ponies against each other. also the villains would fight against each other once they have finished there 1st step. so when they fight against each other to spread there kingdoms. they end up with nothing. because little did they know. they need balance an order to live long and not let the world die off. like I said they have gone to greedy to really gone anywhere. like Tirek would keep taking magic an order to out power anyone in his way and Chrysalis and her children would keep taking love energy. knowing how bugs spread so many babies every year. is bad news for her to spread that fast just to out army anyone and anything. Cozy...I really don't know about her. besides her tricking each side so she would have the upper hand. she wont be trusted for long.

if I were Discord I would boot Tirek and Chrysalis out the world or just seal them in another realm. Cozy doesn't seem to be a type to actually worry about if you think about it.


Maybe the barren land timeline could have been formed by the group of tirek, cozy and crysalis when they came together. Cause the stopping of the rainboom would effect the future as well as the past


Well, in my personal oppinion, all posible multiverse and timelines, including the ones where Sunset Shimer won the battle against the main 6 , are existing in the same time. Just imagine our whole life is like a flipbook, it needs to be done so the animation can exist, so, in my oppinion, that happened in that episode from MLP too: from the beginning of whole universes those posible scenarious were existing; so there are already infinite of timelines where Sunset Shimer won the battle, and that episode where Twilight Sparkle made a loop in time was alewady existing too, she was only moving to a continuing timeline all the time she turned back in time, she wasn't actualy turning back in time, just creating a whole different universe and telling that Twilight, not to herself, but a Twilight with exactly same knowlege as her till that moment, than she came in and so on, with that we explained how she was 2 times, if was only turning back in past, (which in my oppinion is imposible without moving the universe as well) she was changing the knowlege of her ownselfe as well, that didn't happened. <br>In the conclusion, in my oppinion, I think we saw a Sunset Shimer timeline, 'cause after a while, we didn't really saw what Starlight did to stop the main 6, so we can addmin she only opened a random timeline, and the one you talked about, the one with nothing but only chaos and distroies, is actualy one of the timelines where Sunset Shimer won.

Well, in my personal oppinion, all posible multiverse and timelines, including the ones where Sunset Shimer won the battle against the main 6 , are existing in the same time. Just imagine our whole life is like a flipbook, it needs to be done so the animation can exist, so, in my oppinion, that happened in that episode from MLP too: from the beginning of whole universes those posible scenarious were existing; so there are already infinite of timelines where Sunset Shimer won the battle, and that episode where Twilight Sparkle made a loop in time was alewady existing too, she was only moving to a continuing timeline all the time she turned back in time, she wasn't actualy turning back in time, just creating a whole different universe and telling that Twilight, not to herself, but a Twilight with exactly same knowlege as her till that moment, than she came in and so on, with that we explained how she was 2 times, if was only turning back in past, (which in my oppinion is imposible without moving the universe as well) she was changing the knowlege of her ownselfe as well, that didn't happened.
In the conclusion, in my oppinion, I think we saw a Sunset Shimer timeline, 'cause after a while, we didn't really saw what Starlight did to stop the main 6, so we can addmin she only opened a random timeline, and the one you talked about, the one with nothing but only chaos and distroies, is actualy one of the timelines where Sunset Shimer won.


The reason is because FiM never treated EG as cannon. Unless I'm missing something big, not once in all 9 seasons did any of the events or characters of Canterlot High get mentioned.


2:29
You could see some fire dust and burned trees so it's possible that sunset was the reason and we all saw how she could make people into zombies so what if she won against the princesses and ended up destroying all of equestria
I also have a crazy idea! When starlight met sunset they got along pretty well so what if they met each other and because  starlight is more powerful than twilight they got to the elements of harmony and used some kind of spell to create some powerful tool or the element of magic and that's how (starlight will get along since she was also left out like sunset)


there are only 7 timelines that we know of. I think that Twilight and Starlight went back and forth with who won and lost. Sunset could have won in one of the 6 timeline that Starlight lost.


Sunset & Sirens timeline. She's smart, she'd come up with a new plan. The Sirens would be a great hint, as they would flock to any output of magic.


What I want to know is if there’s a seventh element (The Element of Empathy) in the Human world, which Sunset bears, is there a pony equivalent? Would it still be empathy? Is equestria girls considered canon in this case?!


Going back to the elements of disharmony theory, what if sunset was able to corrupt the elements with 5 others? Would they then become the elements of Disharmony?


My answer: Sunset crossed over and defeated the two sisters and well took over. She took control over all of equestria and that timeline was a land that Sunset would banish betraying servants/ponies


Has anybody ever thought about how they have the exact same cutie marks on the alternate timelines? The cutie marks they could only acquire by their shared moment by the rain boom? Specifically, look at Fluttershy and Pinkie’s flank in the Chrysalis timeline. Fluttershy still has her butterflies, and Pinkie has balloons like usual... So... Can somebody explain to me?


I've always thought that timeline was from all the villains taking over  because the main six didn't know  eachother  and its not like the villains would agree they all have the same motive world domanation and we saw how three villains worked imagine if all the villains worked together Celestia probably wouldn't be the same Ethier imagine her in just a couple of years if the main six didn't save luna then Celestia would have to banish her or join her in evil


Maybe Sunset would have gone after the Alicorn Amulet instead. With no Twilight in Ponyville, Trixie would have never sought it out, so it would still be in that store.


The last time line looked like the storm king's time line


Sunset might team up with Microchip, that dude is pretty smart, with his tech powers, they might even rule multiple dimensions at the same time.


Can you explain each of the 7 timelines that showed up though? Like how that villain prevailed over the others and such~


Just wanted to say we never really saw the tantupus win either. Of course Luna wouldn’t have to have created it if she won as nightmare moon but she would have probably used it to get more power. But maybe that was the last vision.


Starlight only met sunset after season 6 in Equestria Girls Movie Magic so that might possibly explain why we never got to see if sunset was deafeated and it’s disappointing we never got to see Sunset in Friendship is Magic (an actually appearance) even though she appeared in Twilights group shot in the last episode.


2:22 My theory is that during that final timeline was If Midnight Sparkle from Equestria Girls: Friendship Games succeeded to open all the rifts and destroy all of Equestria. Since The Season 5 Finale and Friendship Games take place around the same time.


Maybe just maybe  sunset went after Celestia's crown hoping it would give her some magical powers but  Celestia's crown probably doesn't have magic and sunset wouldn't have anything to go after so she was never able to become vilan in the first place that's  why we don't get to see her timeline


The wasteland timeline is probably a result of all the villains taking over. They all collided and battled for equestria, destroying it while fighting.


Here’s my question: what if Sunset were killed trying to steal the crown rather than having successfully made off to the human world, with Princess Twilight forced to stand trial?


Interesting. Sawtooth Waves, this is completely unrelated but what do you think about my theory of Changeling. Do you have any theories about the origin of Changeling. You know i believe that maybe the reformed Changeling or as the MLP Fandom Wiki site called them Metamorphosis Changeling was actualy their real formed. The appearance many people hate might have been intended by the creator as their real appearance. I mean look at the folklore behind  Changeling, they are an elve or fairy child that swapped by the dark or evil fairy and elve with human's child to get human love but in reality they are actually just a child with dissability or deformed body part that their parent renounced as their own child. I mean look at those deformed leg, tail and wing full of hole. They also always starved and very aggresive toward the ponies just to get love, something that they could nurture themselve and share among themselve. I believe that all this time Chrysallis rule as a Queen, she are actually just harming the Changeling without she actually realized it. The very same frienship she called "disease" was actually nurture from the love energy among the ponies, isn't it weird if she think that Changeling should not nurture it as it was "disease" but at the same time they should steal it from the ponies since they were starving of love energy ?
 My keypoint was that deformed leg, tail and wing full of hole, their aggresive personality and the constant state of starvation and their name "Changeling", looking into the folklore behind Changeling in our world. Beside, a lot of people said the new Changeling look like a hippy but if you look carefully the new Changeling with exception of Pharynx, their colour scheme was based on the nature like flower, vine and leaf around them.  We never know where Changeling came from or their origin. Only the comic FIENDship is Magic which Hasbro never comfirmed. In fact the FIENDship is Magic for Sombra also go against what the official series have established, so i don't think that comic was cannon.

On a site note someone told me maybe it's design was inspire by the European Stag Beeetle and Jewel Beetle.


Well ya see in sunset's transformation when she said to twilight "I have power and you have nothing"  in equestria girls her hair glowed like fire now take a look at the final timeline it dusty windy and like ashes so my theory is that sunset must have came back to equestria with her teenage army and destroyed the land with her new powers well celestia will try a bit to make her good a again the she will fail leaving her prized citizens to fight on their own like you said in another video the equestrian military is useless so is celestia so sunset ruled over equestria winning by using equestria many moon ruler's uselessness


That makes absolutely 100% sense why since that sunset's timeline didn't show


I think the last timeline that starlight created might of been her timeline if she wasn't defeated


1:50, I always thought that's what happened when Tempest and the Storm King weren't defeated.


The last timeline was created by parasprites. Without the rainboom Pinkie Pie stayed on the rock farm and wasn't there to deal with the parasprites and they devoured everything in sight. When the ponies fled, nothing was left but a barren wasteland or rocks, sand, and the skeletons of a few scraggly trees...


Without the rain boom none of this would've happened so I do believe that you're right that makes complete sense


I was actually searching up sunsets shimmer theories when I saw this. Also, what is everybody’s opinion on sunset?


I think sunset could of one by making an element with her own powerful magic


Hypothetically if sunset had a motive I could see her leading a coup of some kind. I mean think about it, 4 villains each almost winning that’s too close- way too close and it only stated when Luna showed up so maybe they blame it on her? Maybe they think she’s still evil? Which leads to a civil war of some kind which kinda messes everything up??

@Rens Corner!  The fact the sisters weren't included in the final rainbow laser really adds salt to their wounds there.

@night shroud96 I agree I think it would have been interesting to have the two sisters be more involved in the lives of the mane six maybe they even see a little of them selves in them m? (The sisters did bear the elements after all)

@Rens Corner!  And the fact she kept falling flat on her face after her return when some bad guy attacks. That or forced to be sidelined.<br>No way she would be completely fine about that.

@Rens Corner!  And the fact she kept falling flat on her face after her return when some bad guy attacks. That or forced to be sidelined.
No way she would be completely fine about that.

@night shroud96 I agree it could have been such an interesting arc

Really, the show should have touched on how all the bad guys kept popping up after Luna came back.<br>Like would Luna begin to feel like she's heralded disaster to Equestria by retiring.

Really, the show should have touched on how all the bad guys kept popping up after Luna came back.
Like would Luna begin to feel like she's heralded disaster to Equestria by retiring.


I didn't think of it this theory before until this video... nice work!


But if the Rainbow never happen, Sunset can't steal the element of magic since Twilight never find it, so she can't turn into that devil form.<br>No ?

But if the Rainbow never happen, Sunset can't steal the element of magic since Twilight never find it, so she can't turn into that devil form.
No ?


Maybe that was the reality where daybreaker took over and burned everything so it was devoid of life


The canterlot guards have never actually been useful lol


So ... "That's just a theory, a pone theory"? How have I not found this channel until now?


I feel sunset shimmer and starlight glimmer have a great connection


there an easy answer on why we didnt see that timeline. Its because Hasbro doesn't want anything to do with equestria girls in the main series sadly.


Wait... So, Luna's hair turned flowy after she became nightmare moon right? Because, Celestia's hair was flowy before NightmareMoon. So does that mean Celestia turned bad before Luna? (I don't mean Daybreaker)


I think the last timeline was if Daybreaker won and burned Equestria to the ground.

@Hannah Ringer Yeah, she did in her battle versus Nightmare Moon in A Royal Problem

@Hannah Ringer Her mane is literally made of fire, and she showed control over fire beams, breathing fire, and giant fire balls during her battle with Nightmare Moon


I think it's the human twilight. If sunset shimmer was banished, that means the portal was there. And also human twilight's access to magic. And Human twilight's motive was to steal all of the magic so she could study them. Maybe that's why the world looks so... Lifeless?<br>Also, twilight might pull a tirek and stole all of the magic from others using her gadget.

I think it's the human twilight. If sunset shimmer was banished, that means the portal was there. And also human twilight's access to magic. And Human twilight's motive was to steal all of the magic so she could study them. Maybe that's why the world looks so... Lifeless?
Also, twilight might pull a tirek and stole all of the magic from others using her gadget.


Pop quiz question was...what happens when u bring AN ELEMENT OF HARMONY......not specifically magic...pretty sure 5 would have given her power enough...she only took it bcoz it was easily within reach....as far as the apocalypse....it could be bcoz of the villains fighting ( everything wouldbe collateral damage to them).......all of them .... no one to stop them....all wanted the whole of equestria.......yeah...that should do it....we saw the destruction caused in wars between creatures with immense power in twilight  <br>V/s tirek....and it was just two beings

Pop quiz question was...what happens when u bring AN ELEMENT OF HARMONY......not specifically magic...pretty sure 5 would have given her power enough...she only took it bcoz it was easily within reach....as far as the apocalypse....it could be bcoz of the villains fighting ( everything wouldbe collateral damage to them).......all of them .... no one to stop them....all wanted the whole of equestria.......yeah...that should do it....we saw the destruction caused in wars between creatures with immense power in twilight
V/s tirek....and it was just two beings


I love your vids! You should be "the pony investigation channel"


btw i wanna tell you this just in case you don't know but grogar actually first appeared in the mlp 1800s/1900s version and also you know that we have mlp Equestria girls (practically the human ver ) but also in the 1800s/1900s ver ponies and humans actually lived together.So I'm thinking what if something happened between the humans and the ponies that made them decide to live separately idk what do you think? (plz response)


Answer:

The wasteland that has been created in the mlp world where starlight glimmer and twilight sparkle and spike travel time to time was the world when the land was never created the wasteland was a land when the god of mlp rested to create it and it could be true because the only true villians that normally exist are the other villians that are included to my little pony and it couldn’t be possible for sunset shimmer to get them into the portal she was focussing on twilight and her friends and an answer that sunset shimmer in her past she never became evil but follow the evil deeds and abandoned princess celestia’s teachings for her and chose to be  a different pony and disobey the kindness surroundings celestia taught her again, it cant be possible because once she does it again the portal still wont work because remember it said that “the portal will be closed for 30 moons”


This is the wasteland that would have resulted if a bunch of highschool / college humans had come through inter-dimensional travel into Equestria...<br>GUYS !!! STOP LOOKING FOR THE PORTAL !

This is the wasteland that would have resulted if a bunch of highschool / college humans had come through inter-dimensional travel into Equestria...
GUYS !!! STOP LOOKING FOR THE PORTAL !


Sunset could have used her magic to find the final element


Hi Sawtooth i love your vids and just got into the brony fandom a few months ago because of your vids! Thanks! Also can you do a video on Cozy Glows parents, if you want to, that is. Sven gala looks a little like Cozy Glow, Their colors ar similar, but i dont know who the possible mother could be? Thanks alot for ur vids! Hop you liked my idea!


I thought that if the main six never met, the the elements wouldn’t have existed either? I mean, they did discover them...

The elements where created by the Pillars of Equestria. This was explained in the episode 'Shadow Play', pt. 2 (I think)


The look of the thumbnail looks nice! :>


how would sunset have even succeeded once twilight had won the fall formal? she threatened to destroy the portal with a hammer but wouldn’t it just have gone through the portal?


Sawtooth I just realized something you could do a theory on<br>In Equestria Girls Spring Breakdown Sunset, Twilight, and Rainbow Dash go into the pony world, and in The move Forgotten Friendship and some other movies Twilight has wings that means she’s an Alicorn right? But in Spring Breakdown when Twilight and the others go in the pony world but the human Twilight that was turned into a pony because she went into the pony world doesn’t have wings! This is just an idea of it I don’t know if you do the Equestria Girls but here’s something.

Sawtooth I just realized something you could do a theory on
In Equestria Girls Spring Breakdown Sunset, Twilight, and Rainbow Dash go into the pony world, and in The move Forgotten Friendship and some other movies Twilight has wings that means she’s an Alicorn right? But in Spring Breakdown when Twilight and the others go in the pony world but the human Twilight that was turned into a pony because she went into the pony world doesn’t have wings! This is just an idea of it I don’t know if you do the Equestria Girls but here’s something.


What if sunset could get the element of magic to apper? But what if sunset got a friendship with other villans and could reach the elements of harminy including magic, but when she did they would have turned into the elements of dishamarny because sure the villans would be friends but in a different way but for the  the dishameney element of magic to apper and if the disharmany version of  magic was a disharmany it would cause the other elements to become disharmany- ish as well.


But what if sunset DIDNT trip over spike’s tail, they wouldn’t have ever known that the crown got replaced, thus twilight would not need to do into the portal. That way sunset’s teenage zombies could have worked out.


@Sawtooth waves，I think you can do a “what’s all with the glowing hairs”


If the main six  wouldn't meet Twilight she would never discover the magic of friendship, night mare moon would be able to destroy the elements completely and sunset wouldn't stand a chance.


My with of thinking is that it was all about Fanfic. See now every story from Cup Cakes to Trotting Dead can become real because not main six to stop it from happing.  That how I want to make believe that Fallout Equestria can be canon.


Maybe that was the timeline where Starlight succeded, i mean the first time


Well Maybe Sunset is still Celestia's student becuase the rainboom gave twilight the power to open spikes egg and if sunset was still celestias student then left and was good maybe she found friends And She had the spark instead but.. then left for an unknow reason and became evil and so did her friends so they overthrew celestia and become the new rulers of equestria


What if the that unknown timeline was what it would look like if Equestrianever existed so let me explain it would be a timeline where all the villains teamed up and ruled Equestria together that means the Mane six never defeated any of them and and the elements of harmony would be covered in malignant roots and vines because the Mane Six's friendship wasn't there to keep them at bay and also I'm pretty sure that they would be living in eternal darkness cuz Nightmare moon would destroy Celestia or just keep her in a prison and destroy the sun. Anyways they villains would be there doing villainous things until Starlight and Twilight pass through their timeline and Queen Chrysalis would see them and follow them but to make sure that they don't notice she'd make a copy of the spell and would bring it to the other villains. She'd tell them about it and ask them what they should do with it Discord would suggest using it to go back in time and take control of the founders of Equestria but the others would deny it saying that it was too risky and that it would and it would have a dangerous effect on the timeline Discord would act like he agreed with them so that no one would suspect anything until in the middle of the night he would take the spell and use it to go back in time to put his plan into action. He'd go back in time and would use his power to attack everyone in sight thus eliminating them then he'd eliminate the dragons, the Yaks, and the Kirin he'd try to eliminate the hippogriffs but would fail and give up then he'd go back to his timeline and find everything decimated there is no one and no life in sight and it was all a desert. The villains were gone the only ones living would be the Hippogriffs but they would still be in hiding. Sad, Angry, and Confused Discord would lay on a rock to think about what would have caused this to happen then it would hit him it was his actions that caused this. The Changlings would have been starved to death because the ponies would be gone thus giving theme no love to feed off of, Tirek would also be gone because the unicorns would be gone and no magic no food no life, The Flim Flam twins would be gone cause the they wouldn't exist if they were never born, Nightmare moon and Celestia wouldn't exist cause they'd destroyed cause the unicorns would be destroyed and they would have never been born. Destroyed to realize what he has done Discord tries to use spell to fix what he had done but Starlight never existed to make the spell so now he lives alone looking for others to help him fix all that he has done.


If your last theory is right then nightmare moon would not have defeated and the other villian would come in her reign only and the would have a war a big one and then the all are defeated by the elements not anything else that means they are equally strong so who will win?<br>Thats a big question...🤔🤔

If your last theory is right then nightmare moon would not have defeated and the other villian would come in her reign only and the would have a war a big one and then the all are defeated by the elements not anything else that means they are equally strong so who will win?
Thats a big question...🤔🤔


0:16 Because without Twilight we wouldn't have the crown, and without the crown Sunset doesn't have a plan, but hey, that's just a theory. Aaaaaaaaa My Little Pony Theory. Good night.

Edit: Lol, I predicted the video.


I think mostly sunset shimmer came after starlight glimmer that's why they didn't have a timeline with her


In the darkworld realm with no leader could have been cozy glow’s wrath because she tried to erase all magic she would end everything without magic


What if in that empty futur time line is when starlight finished her plan then no talents and harmony and then nothing can get done so coul'd become chaos and endup empty.


maybe that timeline  has something to do with Grogar being back


These theories are too complicated to be for a kids show


Maybe the wasteland is because the wrong use of magic from celestia's lessons and having a fight with celestia and destroyed the land


Here are some video ideas
Who are cozy glows parents
Why did rarity's parent leave her
Why is discord the only deconerquise in all equestria
What happened to gusty the great( because last time we saw her was stealing grogar's bell then she just disappered)
How did discord come to equestria if he was living in a demenion the whole time
Where did the changlings come from


You know Equestria girls friendship games, you know the ending were Twilight came and see her human side she say, she had to go back in time lap and was the craziest thing that happened to her and believe nothing happens in the human would at all


In the beginning of the end part 2 there where pagues that where crystal  ponies that had wings and the crystal empire are only earth ponies and I hope you can do a vid on it you can see for your self :)


ok here me out, i have 2 theories:

1. ok so my first theory is for why we didn't have a sunset shimmer timeline. think about it; if twilight wasn't a princess, she would never have gotten her crown, so sunset wouldn't be able to steal anything, and also if princess cadence was taken over by sombra, then the portal wouldn't be there but still at the royal palace, which she wouldn't be able to get out of without getting caught, so she wouldn't have even got an element in the first place. and if the main 6 weren't friends the elements would still be unavailable to her for her to use, because they had no one who showed all 6 qualities who could bare all the elements. so therefore, she wouldn't have magic and she wouldn't have even brought it into her world, so she wouldn't turn into a demon and the humans wouldn't have any way of accessing the pony world because there wasn't portals everywhere leading to it.

2. my second theory is for what timeline lead to the waste land. ok so if we go in order, nightmare moon would've sealed celestia away in the moon if she won, which means there was no one to stop her, but the other villains would still come. like discord would awaken, so he would probably try to take over equestria for himself, then seeing all the chaos, chrysalis would still need to feed her hive, so she would also fight for equestria, also, tirek would still break free and get his strength back, he also wanted equestria, so he would also fight. think about it, if all of these powerful villains were to all fight against each other, what do you think would happen? that's right, everything would most likely be destroyed, including the villains themselves, resulting in, you guessed it, a wasteland.

i hope you read this! and if you do, thank you I hope you like my theories!

@night shroud96 ik i realized that. be sure to loomat my edit tho!

@Lemon Leaf ...Nightmare Moon.<br>Its a abbreviation for her.

@Lemon Leaf ...Nightmare Moon.
Its a abbreviation for her.

@night shroud96not true, are forgetting that it took all the elements to defeat him? which NMM doesn't have btw.  also discord is literally the god of chaos, so it would take way longer to actually defeat him, and also almost right after discord would be broken out of his case, I'm pretty I'm sure it was chrysalis attacked, so therefore, all the villains would still end up fighting each other at the same time. also do you really think that all the others would just wait after equestria was taken over? noo, they would challenge her for the throne.

Since NMM said she ruled for a few years, most likely she already dealt with Discord there since he would have broken free within less than a year.  <br>She must have dealt with the other villains too.

Since NMM said she ruled for a few years, most likely she already dealt with Discord there since he would have broken free within less than a year.
She must have dealt with the other villains too.


Wouodnt it be epic if this evil version of her was named ‘Eclipse Rising’

So we'd have Nightmare Moon, Daybreaker, Midnight Sparkle and Eclipse Rising?<br>Noice.

So we'd have Nightmare Moon, Daybreaker, Midnight Sparkle and Eclipse Rising?
Noice.


umm i kinda have a theory

in the episode royal problem luna said to celestia

do not presume how its like to govern the dream realm

so luna is the governer

so there are already so many people in the dream realm and luna is only the leader

so in your theory who will replace luna they just pick a new governer

As people could live there and Luna is just a visitor


Maybe sunset shimmer could've studied magic to the point were she would be able to teleport the 6th element. She could've used the magic she learned to get the elements to work for her. I'm not good with theories and this is just what I think.

Or maybe without twilight there sunset would lose her motivation. If that happens then starlight would have almost no one stoping her from stealing the cutie marks from all ponies and she succeeded but it turned out bad as you saw in the 7th timeline


What if She was ruling Beside someone..Someone who wasn't In The timeline but appears in the Finale. COZYGLOW. They did not show Cozy Glow to spoil the movie.She was Looking for the most powerful crown. She waited for the next princess.


You know how you said in one of your videos that sunset did not repent till after she was defeated a twilight did not well what if she did not repent because she did not have any friends to remind her but twilight did and her servants were already turned evil so sunset would not have turned evil if she had friends I know this is not a theory on this video but I want to say it anyway because we did not know anything about sunset living in equestria all we know is she was a student of celetia sorry can not spell her name


well if you think about it sunset wouldn't of been evil because twilight wasn't celestial's student


1:50, I can't be the only one from when I saw that scene, I thought of Swag.mov lmaooo


well technically if the mane 6 never met sun set would probably be celestia's idk what or in the human world just living without a crown or anything that is from equastria


Maybe Sunset Shimmer cause a MLP version of the SCP-001 "When Day Breaks" event or... Maybe Daybreaker can do that...


i think sunset lost to celestia and destroyed eqeustria so no one can rule eqeustria if she cannot


Hi Sawtooth! So I have a question about Thorax. When he says Pharnex is his brother, what does she mean? I mean, isn't all changlings his brother, or are there changling families?... Also subscribe to my channel FallAndFlameTheFoxes!


The wasteland is maybe Starlight successfully taking over Equestria

Or

Fallout Equestria confirmed


Can you do a video explaining how pinkie pie came out pink while her sisters parents and even twin sister came out grey and muted purple.


MLP: This show is for all ages!

Also MLP: Haha death,slavery and brutality go brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr


Well everything would be butterfly effects


I think that if no one was their defeat sunset shimmer if she went to eqestria she would honestly destroyed eqestria  & if starlight was still evil they would team up and take over eqestria


The final timeline world exist with a few possibility, all the villain in Equestria destroying each other cause this apocalyse or Twilight become the most sinister overlord and kill every living things in the planet.


I can answer the question

THE PONYS ARENT THE HUMANS. We never here about anything in the show about tmhe movie that’s why


Sunset  could of envyed someone else then and that could of lead that sunset shimmer not knowing what friendship is then twilight could.of met her friends their. and then twilight and her friends helped turn everything back to normal


she got the powers of twilights crown and without her friends she wouldnt have  it without her friends


Maybe Sunset brought some nukes to equestria


I don't think this is true cause if twlight didn't find friends she would've stayed in canterlot and the mirror was in the crystel empire so sunset isn't a villain she is just a bully


Sunset wouldn't even have the crown if twilight wasn't around bruh


Ur oc is looking good with that clip on ur head


I have ideas for ur next video...if u need some...
About rarity
About apple jack's parents
About how changelings look in the human world...???(my biggest doubt)
About why starlight and Aria blaze look the same
About how Apple Jack's parents died
AND I think Octavia Melody and DJ Pon 3 are SISTERS🤔
AND I saw that Lyra and bon bon, AKA "agent" sweetie drops are... MARRIED (I saw it when I looked closer at the newspaper that twilight was looking at in 'the last problem ' ) !!!
Can u call my name in ur video? Or at least show my comment?


It could be that last timeline if starlight stole al the cutiemarks from evryone and that would happen


Maybe It is just because the budget isn't enough


MLP has the same mystery as FNAF

I think?


What if sunset shimmer timeline did happened what if everytime rainbow dash do the sonic rainboom a different  timeline is created👍


I think i know....THIS IS GROGARS TIME LINE!!!!

Ok to night mare moons time line in this time line she did take over but what if grogar and night mare moon knew each other grogar had helped her escape and in return she had freed him and in wich he came back yet he had been decitful he wanted to END PONY KIND! so he had used his old magic bell and destroyed every pony but with nobody to feed the land raise the sun and moon or to change the weather....he killed every thing because every creature DEPENDS ON PONY KIND and he ended by killing himself in the proses.....think about it it kinda sounds like somthing that would happen


Sunset shimmer or midnight shimmer, the magic are equally powerful for the mane 6 and that monster, can u make a vid the is about what if the mane 6 became daydream


But what happens if Sunset was super successful that she became princess? Honestly don’t know where I got this idea- I just started typing


Wait, what happened to the human sunset shimmer. She was from the ponyworld.

Du du dun


Why did sunset shimmers magic turn to Light blue to dark red


Is no one going to talk about the fathers in his head


Maybe you should say "but hay the just a theory a mlp theory" in the end of video

Wait a minute.
I feel like you just a Matpat in Disguise.
All you need to do use voice changer and voice editing, and the reason why his video quality isn't the same as Matpat's video is because He has to do this secretly so noone will know that he is a brony.


Ya but then sunset turned nice she just wanted attention and friends


Yeah I was thinking that the whole time haha


My idea is the desolate wasteland is Celestia or should I say Daybreaker


Hey sawtooth why don't u do a video about why sci twi was a unicorn in the pony world and an alicorn to in the human world sunset should b an alicorn here and there right ?

Pls make it happen 😸


Without her friends she could not get her element that's why sunsetshimer was not seen


that's the fipping shadow pony's undefeated worled


Yeah, I also think about WHEN DID I COMMENT THIS


Yo know she just burn the place I guess something get wrong in that future.


I think this timeline for me and my sparkle


I think that sunset shimmer is twilight’s secret sister and she don’t have the crown


Well I guess you are correct but if rainbow dash did not get her cutiemark because of starlight then twilight did not become a princess so....sunset could not have stolen twilight's crown.....that means she did not have become a demon.....


What will happen if sunset shimmer have a fight with princess celestia


Wait apple jack rainbow dash and flutter shy have  sunsets colors…does that mean if they never met the rest that theyed be evil?


I wish I got hearted and pinned.... I work hard on my theories too


Me:goos video
My friend:hE LoOkS gAy!
Me:wait wha-


I REMEMBER WATCHING U LIKE 5 YEARS AGO OML SORRY BUT I TOTALLY FORGOT ABOUT YOU


Well discord's timeline didn't show up either


All the future and I decide to go see a girls night out with Sarah and her magic powers that you do I baby what is burger and a beer


Oooooo little cute pom pom leaves in his hairrrr <3


There was no crown because twilight didn't came to Cristal empire


what if it was not sunset what if it was human twilight


Whatever it is but keep work with your work in urdu we say apne kam se kam rakh


Can you make a video abot starlight glimmer and sunshine glimer


U never pot discord  happen the bell & discord  become monster form like grogar


maby sunset wontid  the elemint so shy can distroy inqestriya and shy olso wontid  to brak  frenship


I  hate  sunset shimmer  <br>I  love twilight

I  hate  sunset shimmer
I  love twilight


I know but anyways what happens welcome flag in the book sunset shimmer garden and emotion but how does a magic and six elemental it means I know it means can I be the one to both of you singing like the feelingslime place to yeah

ปนิดา ขําบางยาง


No twillight: no crown: no evil sunset or magic thing of this neclace ( or how ever you write that sorry im german )


If the elements had never been connected to the main 6 by their friendship then no one would have Beaufort them back to the tree of harmony and then the forest would have overgrown so for any of those futures to be real somepony would have had to bring the elements to the tree of harmony, which means that some pony did have the elements


Do you think spike lothers sunset shimmer


There one more it day dreamer I have never seem her


No offense but aren’t you a little old to be into all this mlp stuff. This show ended.


hey changeling what where you doing then??


becases sunset shimmer was in another world


if the main six never met, twilight wouldn't have gotten her cutie mark and enrolled in the school of magic. The only reason she became celestia's star pupil is because of this. And the reason sunset shimmer became a villian in the first place was because celestia found someone else. if twilingt hadent been there, sunset wuld have remained celestias star pupil meaning she wouldnt have haad a motive to become aa villian. secondly, the elements wouldnt have been use because the main six never met, which means that they probably would have remained lost for all that time. Therefore sunset would have had to know of their existance in order to seek them out. And no one would have known of their power anyway.


Hm, this is interesting to think about.

I think that sunset probably would have kept looking for different ways to invade equestria without the element, and without anyone to stop her (the mane six obviously aren't united because twilight's not princess and therefore never in contact with the mirror anymore.) she could very well have manipulated and threatened her way into adulthood, (and if their human world is anything like our human world) possibly leading an entire country or the entire world into war against equestria with the promise of a new brighter future using magic. This would have let her bring things like nuclear weapons and such to equestria, the likes of which they'd never seen and would struggle to combat knowing nothing about them, explaining the barren, destroyed wasteland.

I don't know this got sort of headcannon-y.
Great video by the way!


I like to imagine the wasteland timeline is a nod to the FO:E fanfics. They don't need to say who caused it, because in the fanfics it ultimately doesn't matter who pulled the trigger first.


I remembered a time when Sunset said "do you know what happens when someone brings a magical element from another world?" or something, but so far we have not had a clear answer. I think it fits very well here too. My theory is that when someone brings a magic element to another world, that same world they were taken to becomes dependent on that same element. So if that element is taken away, the world creates a new force to replace what was taken away to balance the empty space in time. Which would give another meaning to the Cutie mark of Sunset Shimer, which has the symbol of the universal balance of good and evil but without "good in evil" and "evil in good". This is because there is no good or bad to balance, only the magic between the two worlds, sealed by fate.

...

Perhaps ... in these alternative realities, Sunset never betrayed Princess Celestia, but since Sunset never knew the power of friendship none of this was worth it ...


Here's what I had assumed the "Wasteland Timeline" was.

Since Starlight prevented the rainboom, when all the villains returned among their respective timelines, they arose victorious. We all know this. However, my idea is that, since the Mane Six defeated all of the  villains on the same timeline, who's to say they couldn't all come back on a common timeline and cause mass destruction without the Mane Six to stop them? I believe that the Wasteland is a result of a massive clash of power, specifically, the villains' power, (I know that specification was unneeded, but I had to finish the sentence somehow) and in the end, they destroyed each other and everything around them.

I apologize if time was wasted reading this, but I hope you enjoyed me rattling on about my thoughts!

Edit: I'm looking back on this and seeing how confusing this sounds....


i remember seeing some theories going around that the wasteland timeline is actually starlight's. we don't know what her true plan was in turning everyone equal but considering how important they are and how incapable the ponies after being stripped of their cutie mark, the results could've been devastating.
imagine if starlight got the cutie marks of celestia and luna. they could no longer raise the sun and moon. if starlight wanted to rule equestria this way. I could imagine society falling apart as no one would be able to do what is necessary to keep it thriving.

maybe this a stretch but the fact that that's the timeline twilight shows starlight to show the consequences of her meddling with time could've been a hit or something.


The part that always got me about Sunset...is...how did she even know about the crown. Where was she and who could of gave her this information about it? Because if I remember right the portal was closed. So the only thing I could think of was...maybe she was connected to it in some way.

As for the barren wasteland alternate timeline, my guess, would be Luna. It was because of the mane-six she was defeated and the darkness in her destroyed. But what if she wasn't? If you think about it...if the moon over took the sun...there'd be no plants, no water, no life...just...nothing. There is a faint glow of yellow in the background but lower to the horizon with a dark shadow above it. So, it almost feel like an eternal eclipse. Also, the table map, shows little to no housing. Maybe ponies took shelter elsewhere or underground.


The whole wasteland timeline sounds so different from the rest. It's been seen that Equestria was still able to somewhat have some life in it, even in timelines where a villain took over the land. A universe where almost nopony exists would likely require some really big thing to have happened, as if a nule was dropped there or something
The only idea I have is that in that exact timeline, all of the villains were taking over, but they soon started clashing with each other cuz each wanted all of Equestria to him/herself. This big clash actually led to all of them..."ending" each other, leaving Equestria completely destroyed
IK it's a pretty bad theory. I just thought of it cuz we've seen some villains take over & it'd be cool to imagine all of them fighting but leading to that timeline occuring

The whole wasteland timeline sounds so different from the rest. It's been seen that Equestria was still able to somewhat have some life in it, even in timelines where a villain took over the land. A universe where almost nopony exists would likely require some *really* big thing to have happened, as if a nule was dropped there or something
The only idea I have is that in that exact timeline, all of the villains were taking over, but they soon started clashing with each other cuz each wanted all of Equestria to him/herself. This big clash actually led to all of them..."ending" each other, leaving Equestria completely destroyed
IK it's a pretty bad theory. I just thought of it cuz we've seen some villains take over & it'd be cool to imagine all of them fighting but leading to that timeline occuring


I always thought that the last timeline was caused due to Nightmare Moon's everlasting night. Meaning the ponies' main food source of plants could not flourish, and thus would deplete the food supply. Leaving the ponies starving and thus they could no longer take care of crops and land, thus leaving Equestria a barren wasteland.


I think that the universes were causually isolated from each other, as in, if time travel affects one universes timeline, the other would experience no effect, so nothing was really happening over on the human side


I love how this man made a super compelling theory and I was like okay yeah...then debunked it and I loved every minute of it 🤣🤣🤣


2:25 I think that unknown timeline might have been Starlight’s timeline. How? I’ll explain it.
Since the mane six never came together, there wouldn’t be any barriers for Starlight’s cutie mark philosophy back when she ruled that village. Her plan was to make all of Equestria give up their cutie mark, and she could’ve spread to other areas of Equestria. She could’ve cast a spell to her village in order to help her take over one area. After that, she would unite all those who lost their cutie mark as part of her army. It kept getting larger.

With the staff of sameness, she could’ve secretly have took away the princesses’ cutie marks, and probably used all of the cutie marks she got to make herself powerful and stronger. Without anyone stopping her, she would’ve caused even more damage to everyone and maybe even got to a fight with Celestia and Luna, and since she’s good with magic, she would’ve caused a lot of destruction. And eventually defeating them. And with all that power, she would’ve probably destroyed several parts of Equestria because she was angry of her past and could’ve gonce crazy over it. And leading up to a wasteland.


I think the last part of Starlight's alteration had to do with the war between the ponies and the imps. I believe that the imps are responsible for all the barren wasteland that Starlight did that Twilight showed to her. We believe that th imps should have been the next villains after the defeats of the three villains.


I always wondered what that wasteland dimension was... I mean, there's really no other villain that- wait.<br>OK, I know this is going to sound crazy, but what if it's Trixie? The alicorn amulet corrupted her and gave her a whole lot of power. And if what you said in your Sombra video was true, it could be possible that it corrupted her to such an extent that it transformed her into an alicorn? Also, I know this is a bit out there, but stay with me on this one--- The way Trixie "ruled" always reminded me of Scar from the lion king. And the outcome of HIS ruler ship ended in a dead, wasteland much like we see in that future. What if Trixie was in the same position as scar in this situation? And I know you said that there wasn't any structures there, so you couldn't tell what happened... BUT. Same as Scar, the environment would have crashed and burned. That land could possibly be a destroyed Everfree Forest. 🤔

I always wondered what that wasteland dimension was... I mean, there's really no other villain that- wait.
OK, I know this is going to sound crazy, but what if it's Trixie? The alicorn amulet corrupted her and gave her a whole lot of power. And if what you said in your Sombra video was true, it could be possible that it corrupted her to such an extent that it transformed her into an alicorn? Also, I know this is a bit out there, but stay with me on this one--- The way Trixie "ruled" always reminded me of Scar from the lion king. And the outcome of HIS ruler ship ended in a dead, wasteland much like we see in that future. What if Trixie was in the same position as scar in this situation? And I know you said that there wasn't any structures there, so you couldn't tell what happened... BUT. Same as Scar, the environment would have crashed and burned. That land could possibly be a destroyed Everfree Forest. 🤔


I figured the last timeline was one of two: results from the parasprites eating everything. Or two, discord. After all, when I think of chaos, I think of multiple stages of it, starting with a bit of disorganization and confusion, And ending with a waste land of nothing.


After a lot of thinking upon my multiple theories, it would make the most sense if the scorched wasteland timeline was of Daybreaker. Perhaps Nightmare Moon won in this timeline as well but didn't kill or banish her sister, but rather imprisoned her. After a while Celestia would likely be driven mad and turn into Daybreaker. Being able to control the sun she could easily scorch the land and pretty much everything would be dead. Just like in that timeline.

@Sawtooth Waves Oh I wasn't expecting to be noticed lol. Thanks for the heart Sawtooth! Love your videos!!!