what if in the opposite worid the opposit happend


My name would be timothy from the time empire plsss


Because it happens and Sunset shimmer  universe ?


Why is  her name day breaker I like summer breaker you get it summer is the hottest  season


Weird cutie mark<br>(me looking back at this comment 1 year later)

Weird cutie mark
(me looking back at this comment 1 year later)


You forgot midnite sparcel as twilite sparcel becase she bacame one tu


Celestial not kidding space wolud turner into Daybreaker


Why luna don't have flowing hair in past


This is the mesege for the creater why would grogar be a consteleyshon


Wait if luna want night forever day breacer want day forever


Hey you !  Don't blame princess luna . And  if you were mlp fan you would not tell fake story's . And mind your own bizniss.


why not let had SOMBRA had be with her and made Celestia had be both marring her and be his right hand pony ,


Might Mare Noon

Did I just have a stroke?


𝕋𝕙𝕒𝕥 𝕣𝕠𝕓𝕝𝕠𝕩 𝕘𝕚𝕣𝕝 ☆


I think so last thing you can travel in the night and he can that's why he is done in night me I mean they breaker kar


dream wakling i whished i have nightmares so luna come to my dream or vice principal ..............................luna.


I know this show  I thinks night mar moon is ........


The WHAT IF MARVEL STUDIOS: Lolll- /but it is a good series, u need to watch it xD-


starlight glimmer change the cutie marks of princess Celestia and princess Luna's ink blot. in royal problem princess Celestia has princess Luna's ink blot so princess Celestia truns into daybreaker.


The browny notion name for me brilliant but lazy

i never liked it, hense the rebrand just a few videos after this one


I think it's like I'm a monster can get out of like a dream from the name from me like the ear on the nose or the mouth something like what's something like that like a nightmare or some s***? That's why loser dream walking cause my monster get out cause you know how I'm in one of those scenes where she's in the dream world when everyone in the world was in 1 dream and a nightmare we're trying to get out remember that that seems like wait till seems that's the point of everything that's why she's so drunk um dream walk and probably I don't know


I think its more than that but i also don`t have any other ideas


It is because your envelope is because your sister she got the kindness and love from Nanna people she worked in dreams but she had to do you want a quick please be like that working in the house is clean heart so I was kind of like it


Business business and a little bit of BUSINESS


Why I felt like ur wrong all wrong are u sure ur right


ok soo i thinc that in the fucher celestia will be DAYBREAKER


High Street and I have light on this page


Please please just do something about whoever your dad is Tesco episode about your dad I really hate this microphone app but I can't write so I'm alright you try using it I hope autocorrect is in on it


This what you know that Diamond pony I think I cannibal with name O its weary Willie where he has a little baby sister and I want you make a video about the memos the photos and maybe the of course that some cool meaning do you like to do so ponies is malik rainbow - where he came from OU have to you twilight cause I know the parents every noble you're so so just why I highly cuddy Teddy.


Music do you know couldn’t say anything and I mean because she couldn’t but I found it on something called Summit behind song one time I open the portal up to it and you’re not post to say no but if you come down now I’m teleporting to you song


i think i know how<br>bcs praaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaanktser sisters

i think i know how
bcs praaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaanktser sisters


Do you have tick tock everyone loves tiktok And real tiktok


it's a theory, my dude. a "what-if" scenario.


I was kind of disappointed at the finale of MLP FIM. I think celestia corrupting into day breaker would have been much more interesting instead of fighting old villains. Degz  points this out (3rd comment from the top) and I agree with her. It would make much more sense since the mane 6 fought nightmare moon the first episode. But then again it would be different because the elements and the tree of harmony would have been destroyed and they beat nightmare moon with the elements originally. I mean, daybreaker only appeared in 2 episodes. 2! “A royal problem” when she’s in starlights dream (as sawtooth mentioned) and in “the beggining of the end” in twighlights vision where celestia and Luna turn into nightmare moon and daybreaker because she failed as a ruler. But in that example, daybreaker only appears for a split second, so can you even count that?  I think this is a very interesting topic and I’m sad that it wasn’t explored more.


i 100% percent agree with this. :) i also think the reason luna started walking in dreams in the first place was to prevent her from getting jealous and from turning into nightmare moon again


Some of my ideas for alternative forms of the princesses (and honorary princesses)
Format: Actual Name - Dark Form / Enlightened Form
Celestia - Daybreaker / Solar Flare
Luna - Nightmare moon / Selena Satellite
Cadence - Pandemonium / Mi Odiare Cadenza
Twilight Sparkle - Midnight Sparkle / Eventide Sparkle
Flurry Heart - Hurricane Heartbreak / Tornado Treasure
Sunset Shimmer -  Nightfall Shadow / Sundown Shade
Starlight Glimmer - Cosmic Glint / Stellar Gleam


I did always wonder whether ponies nightmares just went unchecked for the thousand years Luna was banished. This would explain why they'd just endured any and all dreams as unalterable fact until she returned.


If the theory that Luna didn’t start walking in dreams until after she turned back was true, wouldn’t that disprove a part of your theory that alicorns were created by Starswirl the Bearded? Specifically the part about the realms that he put Celestia and Luna in charge of?


This theory is very interesting. I think there are parts of it that are very likely however, I don't think Daybreaker would be created due to jealousy. From the short time we see her, her only drive is power. She does not seem to be jealous at all of her sister, she wants to kill her. She literally says she wants to raise the sun and pretty much kill everyone to be all powerful. It is here where we return to the theory that Daybreaker would be created if Luna was not jealous of her sister. I 100% believe this however, I believe the circumstances are different. It is my belief that if Luna never turned into Nightmare Moon, Celestia would become Daybreaker. It has clearly been stated that Celestia overshadowed her sister and basked in the worship of everyone. I think the fact that Luna turned into Nightmare Moon was the universes way of ensuring Celestia would not go power crazy. Forcing her to banish her sister would create an immense amount of guilt and sadness for what she did to her sister. She would even have the Summer Sun Celebration to make her feel guilty similar to what Luna did with the Tantabus. I believe Celestia KNOWS that she has a lust for ultimate power and that she can turn into Daybreaker.  Because of this she created the Summer Sun Celebration to force herself to remember that it WAS HER who created Nightmare Moon and caused her sister to become evil. Now moving on to 1000 years later and Celestia see's a gifted student whom she decides will be her successor. She sends Twilight to Ponyville to get some friends and start her path to becoming an Alicorn. Now we know from Lauren that Celestia WAS the one to free Nightmare Moon. We can presume she always was able to do this considering she controls the stars and the moon. It is my belief that Celestia deliberately waited until she found a successor  before she decided to release Nightmare Moon. I believe she did this because she had finally decided at that moment that she was going to step down from the throne and that Twilight would succeed her. Throughout the show we see that Celestia is essentially useless, she never actually attempts to fix anything. Now some people might say that she was just getting old and her powers were weaker, but we know this isn't true. With how powerful Twilight is in the Season 4 finale we can assume that a mere fraction of that is Celestia's power, which from what we see of Twilight using this power, is still a substantial ammount. Even in the movie The Storm King steals the Alicorn power and becomes extremely powerful. So we know that Alicorns are actually super powerful, Flurry Heart also proves this. So why doesn't Celestia use this ever? You'd think that she would. It is my belief that Celestia deliberately avoids using her power out of fear of becoming like Daybreaker aswell as letting Twilight deal with these issues to ensure her place on the throne.  One particularly interesting thing I've noticed is the Daybreaker episode happens only a season before Celestia and Luna step down from their thrones. It is my belief that when Daybreaker and Nightmare Moon were defeated it was Celestia finally freeing herself of that fear. Even though the two were created in Starlight's dream we still see Celestia quite scared about it. Especially when Daybreaker say's "If Luna can turn into Nightmare Moon, you can surely turn into me..." This is why Celestia says "You will never exist again!" she's saying this because she is finally ready to step down from the throne and allow Twilight to succeed her. Her fear of becoming a power hungry monster is gone because she has finally decided her sister means more to her than power and they should step down. I realize this is both late and really long but I've been thinking about it for hours now and for me it's pretty much my head cannon.


There was one thing I noticed before, Luna knew who daybreaker was even though she wasn’t there when she announced Daybreaker’s name. Does that mean Daybreaker appeared before?

When Luna said “In order to defeat Daybreaker you need only to trust in your strength, as I did” and all I can think was HOW DID YOU KNOW HER NAME WAS DAYBREAKER.

There was one thing I noticed before, Luna knew who daybreaker was even though she wasn’t there when she announced Daybreaker’s name. Does that mean Daybreaker appeared before?

When Luna said “In order to defeat *Daybreaker* you need only to trust in your strength, as I did” and all I can think was HOW DID YOU KNOW HER NAME WAS DAYBREAKER.


I think Luna could walk in dreams in the past but she didnt quite understand emotional connections like she does now and the episode with Nighmare Night helped her to start to understand emotional connections


Most of the time, I go with sawtooth's theorys, but not this time. I think celestia will turn into day breaker when she relizes how much power she can use to her advantage. Because unlike nightmare moon, day breaker is selfish. While nightmare moon comes to be with inoccent  jelousey, day breaker comes to be with evil selfishness. While nighmare moon just wants to be respected, day breaker wants power.

I like this theory because it maches how day breaker acts in starlight's nightmare.


Here's a question. Why did Luna turn into Nightmare Moon (season 4: episode 1) with dark, long, wavy, season two hair and a more grown-up voice, but come back (season 1: episode 2) with light, short, non-wavy child hair and a childish voice? Did she de-age in the moon? We know that's what she looked like when she was younger soooo what happened?


I always took it that she was going into dreams mainly nightmares like now to help however the ponies didn't understand how or what she was doing.  I believe it cause them to fear her and call her nightmare moon because she comes into the nightmare by using the moon. Also leading her to pick that name because they already feared it. Being how long ago it was and that the 3 kinds of ponies just got together so no one but unicorns would same what understand what she was doing the others would just run in fear. Being that Luna and Celestia were the first and only alicorns at the time no one not even them fully knew what they could do.


I think maybe Luna had unlocked her dream walking power once she was brought back from being nightmare moon. Ever notice how Luna's hair wasn't flowy like Celestia's until her next appearance in the show?


Daybraker is awesome. What if a spell brought her out of the dream realm and into the real world?


once upon a time, in the magical land of Equestria, two regal sisters ruled over the land. The eldest, used her magic to raise the life giving sun at dawn, the youngest, brought the gentle moon, the stars and the night sky
           _the two sisters ruled together, creating harmony for their subjects. But in time, the Eldest sister grew greedy for the shorter lived ponies frolicked and played in her beautiful day and shunned the youngest sisters night.
           One day, the Eldest refused to lower the sun to make way for the twilight of night. The youngest tried to reason with her, but the greed inside her heart had transformed her into a wicked mare of fire; Daybreaker. She vowed to burn the land in never ending flames and lava.
           The youngest was forced to use an ancient source of power, older than even the two princesses; The Elements of Harmony. Using these ancient weapons, the Eldest was sealed away in the burning sun, and the youngest took over the duty of raising the sun and moon

_once upon a time, in the magical land of Equestria, two regal sisters ruled over the land. The eldest, used her magic to raise the life giving sun at dawn, the youngest, brought the gentle moon, the stars and the night sky_
           _the two sisters ruled together, creating harmony for their subjects. But in time, the Eldest sister grew greedy for the shorter lived ponies frolicked and played in her beautiful day and shunned the youngest sisters night.
           _One day, the Eldest refused to lower the sun to make way for the twilight of night. The youngest tried to reason with her, but the greed inside her heart had transformed her into a wicked mare of fire; Daybreaker. She vowed to burn the land in never ending flames and lava._
           _The youngest was forced to use an ancient source of power, older than even the two princesses; The Elements of Harmony. Using these ancient weapons, the Eldest was sealed away in the burning sun, and the youngest took over the duty of raising the sun and moon_


That's possible, but what about Nightmare Moon? That other side of Luna still appears in Starlight's dreams. There's no possible way for Celestia to somehow somewhat turned to Daybreaker before or after Nightmare Moon's existence. We know their history before Nightmare Moon and after, as long as I'm concerned, Daybreaker will still only exist in Starlight's dream and nowhere else, or it would've turned Equestria's  history upside down, the ponies loving Luna and scared of Celestia, and Twilight would've never been an alicorn due to Celestia would've never been able to open her school for gifted unicorns and with all probability, there will be no such thing as "The mane 6" and Twilight would've stayed in Caterlot with a whole different story, and who in the world will raise the sun when Celestia's gone? (Prob with the old ways, a few dozens unicorns raising the sun)

Does that make sense?


In the Journal Of The Two Sisters (if you consider it cannon) Luna writes on page 102:<br>“Suddenly, it was like Celesta was on fire! She actually glowed with fury, and her voice echoed in the air.” On fire? Sounds like her mane, which turns into fire when she’s Daybreaker. Of course, she didn’t go full-on chaotic mode, and did turn back not remembering anything, so maybe it was a half transformation. Or I’m just rambling about something that isn’t cannon, i dunno.

In the Journal Of The Two Sisters (if you consider it cannon) Luna writes on page 102:
“Suddenly, it was like Celesta was on fire! She actually glowed with fury, and her voice echoed in the air.” On fire? Sounds like her mane, which turns into fire when she’s Daybreaker. Of course, she didn’t go full-on chaotic mode, and did turn back not remembering anything, so maybe it was a half transformation. Or I’m just rambling about something that isn’t cannon, i dunno.


Well Luna went to other peoples dreams and protected them people started to get fond of the sun and love the moon more because the emotional comfort the nightmares going away it’s like a dream forever and then they start to get annoyed of the sun so they decided to sleep earlier and then Celestia finally realize that her sister was becoming queen level even though celestia was the queen and then her rotten heart started to get more fishes and violent and then Celestia became Daybreaker and then when Luna tried to calm her sister down the elements of harmony had to knock out Daybreaker so Luna can enter her dream and make things right again But they break her try to destroy Luna even in the dream and then Luna finally calmed her sister down and Celestia felt so guilty so she made days quicker earlier for the ponies to become happy with Luna but then they started to go to Celestia well it was like an even match this was pretty long 😅


Cadence was there along with the other Princesses in the first place... But getting more to the point, if you put Pinkie Pie and the notion of time travel, and Pinkie Pie and someone else giving away the information about the world of dreams too soon... I can see where you're coming from with this one, and I understand the concern about the alternate time line, but Pinkie Pie isn't that way about her time travel and portal tendencies. She's very good at being quite on time to invite someone else to do something important to the cause, though.


I don't know if it's technically canon, but the comics state that part of Luna's transformation into Nightmare Moon involved a malicious spirit from the dark side of the moon that possessed her and fed on her jealousy... Correct me if I'm wrong


I think celestias breaking point would be her fears taking over, think about it, she try’s to make everyone happy, but a sudden fear happens, and she starts thinking she can’t make anyone happy, and her fear makes hers day breaker


I think Luna started to dream walk when the ponies started to like her, and I think when she raises the moon and then goes to sleep and the ponies get nightmares she wakes up in a place with doors, and then she opens one door and sees a pony in trouble, Luna helps.

                                                                                OR

At the end of season 3 when Twilight finished Starswirl's book and Twilight disappears and meets up with Celestia showing Twilight her memories. What if Celestia started dream walking and then "handed" it to Luna.


I think you're right.
However....
What if Twilight and Cadence also had alter egos? What if when the changeling replaced her, she reacted differently, and instead of being broken, broke others instead?


What a very well made and fascinating argument


So I know this video is 3 months but I couldn’t help but notice that daybreaker’s cutie mark has what looks like a sun/fire related thing around celestia’s original cutie mark that makes me think of the dark splotches around Luna’s cutie mark. Maybe the splotches represent when Luna was corrupt 🤔


When Luna at the first time...wouldn’t she have none moving hair...like she didn’t have the flowing hair means she didn’t have the magic she needed. She wanted more magic, in season 1 she had no flowing hair, she didn’t have her full ponuteakl,


also when celestia took over Lunas duties when she banished her to the moon, she obviously wouldn't be able to stay up all day (to do her own duties) while staying up all night to watch over the dream realm.


As I can say, daybreaker and nightmare moon are similiar. Especially they are the evil forms of princess Luna and princess Celestia.


I think that when Luna grew up (maybe that's why she has a diffrent hair style) that's when she got the powers to go into dreams.


didn't something like this happen in the comics? <br>there was an evil Celestia in the Reflection comics I think

didn't something like this happen in the comics?
there was an evil Celestia in the Reflection comics I think


Really cool theory. Thanks for the video!


Notice how Luna is shown to appear in the dreams of the CMC??? Obviously in the clips TBN showed


I dont think jealousy will cause daybreaker. I think Pride is Celestia's trigger.


If Celestia and Luna have an evil side, then why not Twilight?? You should make a video about that.


OK I've kinda already said this but, I HAVE MORE-<br> Ok it's like Tirek said in the first episode of season 9, "The land that would become Equestria, was a mere collection of farms and pastures" After Gogar was defeated, I'm assuming when the princess soon took over it was still like that. OK THIS IS MY THEORY: Celestia gets jealous because Ponies must work during her day, but had a chance to rest in Luna's night.

OK I've kinda already said this but, I HAVE MORE-
 Ok it's like Tirek said in the first episode of season 9, "The land that would become Equestria, was a mere collection of farms and pastures" After Gogar was defeated, I'm assuming when the princess soon took over it was still like that. OK THIS IS MY THEORY: Celestia gets jealous because Ponies must work during her day, but had a chance to rest in Luna's night.


She dream walks right her name is Luna tho

When she transformed she became “night mare “ moon which may have made her power of dream walking

So celesti could develope a power the day

She has day breaker tho so when she transforms she may break the days and try to make it stay day forever or stop time to save the day so she can see everybody the names line up Luna “nightmare moon dreams” celetia “daybreak” breaking the day it all makes more sense the names are related to the powers


I dont think that's the case...
I believe of the fact of how luna is respected emotionally by the ponies.

But i dont think celestia turning evil if luna wasnt nightmare moon In the PAST has anything to do with it...
I think it's because of the stress she's under with having to be the responsible one and to be in charge and the whole having to smile and be good for her subjects type of thing as it's ruler.
I also think its because of the burden of sending luna away and not seeing the pain she was in alot sooner before she became into nightmare moon and the whole shit twilight had to go through once she became a princess.
I think celestia mightve turn into day breaker LATER in that series and not in the PAST.
I think THOSE were the thing's that might've pushed her to her limit to become daybreaker.


The thing is, that Daybreaker wasn't only in Starlights nightmare she was also in Twilights fears in "Beginning of the end" so she <b>is</b> commen knowledge, meaning something must have happened right? but that's just a theory of mine

The thing is, that Daybreaker wasn't only in Starlights nightmare she was also in Twilights fears in "Beginning of the end" so she *is* commen knowledge, meaning something must have happened right? but that's just a theory of mine


Luna started walking from dream to dream after Nightmare Moon was defeated


I wish that Celectia was the one who went rouge because I like Luna more🙃


Everyone’s overlooking the obvious: All Alicorns are capable of such things apparently!

Which means...
Twilight can transform into Midnight Charcoal and Cadence into Cadaverous Quartz

Everyone’s overlooking the obvious: *All Alicorns are capable of such things apparently!*

Which means...
Twilight can transform into *Midnight Charcoal* and Cadence into *Cadaverous Quartz*


what if the timeline twilight brought starlight to is a timeline where daybreaker took over n the reason everything all dead is that the sun was out constantly n because of that, everything dried out?


Actually the answer is that Faust wanted mlp fans to know if Celestia went rouge cause if the whole timeline is reversed it's all wrong


Ok I'm just wondering scene luna is in charge of the moon/ stars, and stars are suns dose this make luna more powerful in the big picture?


Me, a Persona fan: it would make some sense if Luna gains some new ability after defeating Nightmare Moon, in Persona 4 the protagonists gain the ability to summon their persona after defeating their shadow, an alter-ego that consists of all the doubts and insecurities the character doesn’t want to deal with. I FiM Nightmare Moon is Luna’s shadow, she’s the personification of Luna’s fears and insecurities about her role in Equestria, by defeating Nightmare Moon Luna gains her powers, since Nightmares are the dark side of dreams Luna gains the ability to enter other ponies dreams and fight their nightmares.<br>Alternatively, Luna always had that ability but since ponies, like people, don’t necessarily remember their dreams while awake they had no reason to value Luna and took her for granted. It was only after she came back and they’d had to endure a lifetime of unpleasant dreams that they realized how much better they felt with Luna there.

Me, a Persona fan: it would make some sense if Luna gains some new ability after defeating Nightmare Moon, in Persona 4 the protagonists gain the ability to summon their persona after defeating their shadow, an alter-ego that consists of all the doubts and insecurities the character doesn’t want to deal with. I FiM Nightmare Moon is Luna’s shadow, she’s the personification of Luna’s fears and insecurities about her role in Equestria, by defeating Nightmare Moon Luna gains her powers, since Nightmares are the dark side of dreams Luna gains the ability to enter other ponies dreams and fight their nightmares.
Alternatively, Luna always had that ability but since ponies, like people, don’t necessarily remember their dreams while awake they had no reason to value Luna and took her for granted. It was only after she came back and they’d had to endure a lifetime of unpleasant dreams that they realized how much better they felt with Luna there.


I actually think that "dream world" was actually discovered by Celestia after Nightmare moon Appeared Celestia knowing that her sister didn't know about "dream world" knew why Luna turned into nightmare moon and knew that Luna turned because of jealousy so Luna after turning back got to walk in dream

That's my idea sorry if it doesn't make sense for you


Day breaker mentioned that celestial has a hidden want for full control and that's what will trigger daybreaker


I can already tell but she is definitely going to lose it at some point it doesn't mean even at the end of the season


@Sawtooth Waves what did you use to switch the colours between Celestia and Luna. Cause I want to try  changing the colours of king sombras eyes when he shows everyone their fears.


I think that Luna had the power to walk in dreams but she did not know. Maybe princess Celestial knew about that she had the magic to walk is dreams that made her   jealous that made her daybreaker.


Theory: all princesses Have this dark sided area in them. Cadence would be envious of something and turn into a sort of evil changeling (no offense bro) that fed off of love, using it for bad. Flurry would hold the darkness, since she is the princess of light. And Nightmare moon and Daybreaker you know, and twilight Midnight Sparkle. It’s quite obvious I feel.


To understand the theory,read my other theory at "CELESTIA released Nightmare Moon"video

B-but if the Celestia turns into Day Breaker,who going to help her escape?!?Yea,the stars help Luna escape from moon,but if Celestia turns into Day Breaker,who is going to help her escape from Sun?Ok lets think that Day Breaker is at the Moon,but nothing still can help her escape.Because she is the Princess of the Day,not the Night.So she can't conect whit the stars,so she can't escape.And if she can't escape,the mane 6 can't meet!And if mane 6 can't meet...
But as my other theory at the "CELESTIA released Nightmare Moon" video,Luna going to conect whit the stars,and tell them "Release Day Breaker"

What do you think?


BUT WHAT IF evil starlight went to the past and got Luna to dream-walk and Luna didn't rule the land as night mare moon


The only thing He missed:Where did Daybreaker go after being vanished?


"One tiny detail would have flipped the script on the familliar first story this show ever told" <br>Uh that doesn't make grammatical sense

"One tiny detail would have flipped the script on the familliar first story this show ever told"
Uh that doesn't make grammatical sense


You have really good points in all your thorys you would make a good dective


Here is a thought how come the only time we see Luna Dreamwalking is with the Cutiemark Crusaders?


Well if i was luna i would use the elements of harmony and the crystal heart to kill the evil on that land


Check out when celestia first turned into day breaker!!


What caused Celestia to go rogue?<br>Me: someone stole her cake-

What caused Celestia to go rogue?
Me: someone stole her cake-


So two all powerful siblings that rule a mystical world with the one in dark color jealous over the light colored one and becomes evil.. where have I seen that before? “Bionicle” cough cough


Equestria at war community loves Daybreaker. All hail Solar Empire!


4:15 ...Starlights a good guy... Aaaand she's the one who saw it as a nightmare


I think that she started dreamwalking after her defeat


I think when luna is luna she makes nightmares disappear but when she’s nightmare moon she maks nightmares appear, when sh’s still in the moon she can still go into dreams and make nightmares without anyone knowing tht she’s in their dreams

Its just a theory


I named her earlier then this episode came out with absolute opposite

Daymare Sun


I think Celestia should not be confusined because when Luna got baneshed to the moon Celestia. Had to rule night aswell and in the royal problem she was confused

That was probably because she wouldn't of dream walked. Chances are she didn't know about it or that she never tried it out because she was always exhausted from stuff in the day.


Guys!!!! Season 1!!! Celestia came from the SUN when she first appeared!!<br>Was THAT Daybreaker????

Guys!!!! Season 1!!! Celestia came from the SUN when she first appeared!!
Was THAT Daybreaker????


Luna has always had been going in dreams it is her job


Also when Daybreaker says « If Luna can turn into Night Mare Moon, you can absolutly turn into me! » Princess Celstia had a black splotch


Or maybe she finally snapped from ruling for so long...


Luna will always be my favorite princess


Stallions can also be alicorns just look at celestia's and Luna's DAD


Maybe she wasn’t power in full enough to visit the dreamworld yet nightmare moon as in


Such a pity you didn't use the Doctor Who time vortex for that time vortex part at 3:03

Whovian bronies!
Whovian bronies!
Whovian bronies!


this is not about daybreaker its luna so she did not start dream walking when she was a kid but growing up to nightmare moon change after that she was defeated not about that too but when she was not evil celestia with her magic she gave luna dream walking that is my theory also luna was sad to do nothing but how did luna get her hair flowy cause when she was turned into normal luna she had normal hair then to the halloween episode her hair got all flowy so thats it sory for long time to read


okay... Honestly I'm thinking that Luna gave nightmares before


HOLD UP. I HAVE ANOTHER THEORY!

Luna - Nightmare moon

Jealous of celestia and wanting to be the only princess

Celestia - Day breaker

Jealous of Luna for having the interaction that she dosnt.

Twilight - Midnight sparkle?

Well what if sunset shimmer came back to rule with her? When her memory was erased, she didnt know what she was. Ik cause she said this, 'Wait- This isnt canterlot, PRINCESS CELESTIA? Please.. Somepony help..' Anyway, knowing sunset is before twilight, i remembered one of ur vids saying Did Sunset shimmer become an alicorn? I realized, maybe twilight would get jealous.

The origin explained. I hope 🤔

{Edit}
She came back to rule with her and her friends 😏
🟥 PLEASE MAKE A THEORY ABT THIS SAWTOOTH WAVES. 🟥

HOLD UP. I HAVE ANOTHER THEORY!

Luna - Nightmare moon

Jealous of celestia and wanting to be the only princess

Celestia - Day breaker

Jealous of Luna for having the interaction that she dosnt.

Twilight - Midnight sparkle?

Well what if sunset shimmer came back to rule with her? When her memory was erased, she didnt know what she was. Ik cause she said this, 'Wait- This isnt canterlot, PRINCESS CELESTIA? Please.. Somepony help..' Anyway, knowing sunset is before twilight, i remembered one of ur vids saying *Did Sunset shimmer become an alicorn?* I realized, maybe twilight would get jealous.

The origin explained. I hope 🤔

{Edit}
She came back to rule with her and her friends 😏
🟥 PLEASE MAKE A THEORY ABT THIS SAWTOOTH WAVES. 🟥


I've watched mlp ever scince I was 6 and the major thing that kept scratching the back of my head was this
-> 1:49 on the picture in the left, Lunas mane isn't wavey, glittery nor transparent as compared to the one on the right?
The first time we see Lunas mane as magical as it is now is in the episode "Luna Eclipsed", But Why!?!
Help!!! I'm now 12, the show's ended and I still don't know why!!! WHY!!!

I've watched mlp ever scince I was 6 and the major thing that kept scratching the back of my head was this
-> 1:49 on the picture in the left, Lunas mane isn't wavey, glittery nor transparent as compared to the one on the right?
The first time we see Lunas mane as magical as it is now is in the episode "Luna Eclipsed", *But Why!?!*
*Help!!! I'm now 12, the show's ended and I still don't know why!!! WHY!!!*


Daybreaker appered not because of jealousy but power


What I don’t understand is that how can Luna say ponies from their nightmares if she also sleeps it doesn’t make any sense??!


Hi sawtooth ! I watch your videos so much ,,so you got a new subscriber! I subscribed


I think I know why she turned evil you see whan Trek came all the alicorn gave their magic to twilight their cutie mark disappeared aseppet Luna's spolch but when starlight change their cutie mark..... The sploch was with Celestia maybe the sploch was the evil magic that turn Luna night marr  Moon


This must be edited! How could this be REAL MY LITTLE PONY?


Well i think about celestia : is luna interact with people and every time celestial join the pony and luna ignore her she become jealos well you know the rest<br>About luna dream walking :  after she was being who ever and was being scared of every pony she start it and make the ponys not scared anymore

Well i think about celestia : is luna interact with people and every time celestial join the pony and luna ignore her she become jealos well you know the rest
About luna dream walking :  after she was being who ever and was being scared of every pony she start it and make the ponys not scared anymore


Well Luna and selestia’s transformations are almost the same


Or Daybreaker only exists for fan service. Either or.


I think the video is wrong but I a right. What if Night Mare  Moon gave Celestia Day Breaker in the story so it would be eternal darkness.


she didnt acctully turned into daybreaker, it was a dream world + swap cutie marks u have not seen the episode where sunset switched the sisters cutie marks! u need u watch it to know what i mean!


Nightmare moon and daybreaker look bald when the mane is hard to see..


Maybe celesta and Luna was jealous of their work 🤭🥶🚴🏻♀🍡🌈🎂🎊🍭🍕🍰💸🌈🇮🇳🖥🎂🎊🍝🥶🦆🍧💝🍡🤭🍰🍭🍕😍💸👑🌅🤩🏘🚴🏻♀🍫🏳🌈🍿😄🪁


If celestia turnd into daybreaker then luna whould be the big sister


And celestia turned into day breaker cause she got karma luna sat on her and took away her blanket at night and broke her neck lol


Luna didnt know she can enter dream non of them did


Nah princess luna turned into nightmare moon cause Celestia sat on her and took away her blanket at night and broke her neck lol


But Sawtooh if you think about it in the episode royal problems if nightmares doesnt fix they would do someting to their sighky


OMG! I saw the thumbnail and thought it said “Her Virginity”


daybreaker is nightmare moon but inverted


Celestia is of Luna she gets all the smiles


Well you're one she the only reason why she turned into David Waco is that she was jealous of her sister in the very beginning will people didn't sleep for her day people dipped fuel unit night so you know sheet 22 daybreaker before the princess of the dog actually got you know


Because princess Alessia is jealous Luna walking dreamworld that’s the reason why she’s jealous because it turn to Daybreaker!


It  was  a   dream   starlight    gilimmer    though    that     celestia   would    get    jeles    of     luna   because    she   was     important     now


Luna is now nice like when she help sweetie bell


ik this is random but when you srsly turn into a pony princess your immortal or what

Iᴀᴍ sᴛᴏᴏᴘɪᴅ :ᴅ


Daybreaker: NO<br>Might Mare Noon: YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

Daybreaker: NO
Might Mare Noon: YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS


I wish that it was the other way, Luna would’ve been the true queen.


Well luna celestia got the black spot so and luna gots that spot when she turned from night mare moon back to luna en then celestia has the black spot so she can transform in daybreaker


Ughh can you please stop showing solar flare`s/day breaker`s evil eyes with the yellow background colour because its so creepy.


Wait sir...did you say daybreaker did not telled ever in the mlp series wait a minute daybreaker and nightmare moon is in glass of cartelot.


The princesses both of them just seem really dumb to me all they really do is wait for Twilight and her friends the only princesses that I like is Twilight and baby flurry heart she is a little snow demon I can't get over that that joke some of the episodes I think this video is one of my favorites


Well when the princesses took the others job Luna was just like Celestia and Celestia was like Luna and Luna has night mare moon so Celestia had to have a bad side too! Right?


"daybreaker". that sounds like an undertale soundtrack.

NICKHALAZ <del>randomness and more!</del> yup


If daybraker existed Twilight Sparkle would be Luna Apprentice a royal problem wouldn't have happened it would just be daybreaker all over again

Luna would probably choose someone else though


LOOK! ITS SHATTERED DREAM SANS! oh wait.


Hhhhmmmmm.Well Lunanmight wanna protect the ponies just like her sisters so that might he the reason why she started dream walking,to prtoect ponies from nightmares.But Celestia doesnt kind of ring a bell.I think she was jealous to i mean Luna was able to go to dreams and bond to them.So Celestia might get jealous about Luna being able to bond through dreams.But it hink its more like she was sad she wish she could also protect ponies and that might turn her to daybreaker.


I like night mare moon and daybreaker thank you


This is not very right well she has daydreams take care of doesn't sheI'm just saying daydreams are similar to dreams that happen in the night


I am evil because I my sister drool on me!


no school from celestia no twilight going to poniville and no mane 6


Egg.

 M

M

That’s all I wanted to say tbh

Egg.

 M

M

That’s all I wanted to say tbh


Put a flashing colours warning before your intro jeez


But in daybreaker haz a spoch like her sister but sulesteya have not been terned evil


Daybreaker or as I like to call her mightmare Doom

Me:a good change right?oh and I love ur videos!!!


Nah your on this on. I cannot prove you wrong


i words to all time line of life there is [ Good LIGHT and DARKNESS Evil ] point to , Reason , life , exp to learn , then or depends [ how YOUR Feelings of ] [ Good Light or Evil Dark ]

it's your life your Reason your Future [ 1 living i Full Life ] [ 2 Choose to do Reason ] [ 3 life Goal to work i Future ] 100% understand i think XD LOL


<b>THIS MMUUSSTTTTTTTTTT BEEE RRIIGGHHHTTTTTT</b>

*THIS MMUUSSTTTTTTTTTT BEEE RRIIGGHHHTTTTTT*


The reason for the dislike is because of the horrible joke


Woah I was only 7 when I wrote that jeez


it does really make sence and olso i allready subcribe to u like yesterday bye


Im an idiot so Im never seen in this comment section Yes this is a secret comment you may never see me again 🍜


But i koat like luna nightmare moon taon celestia


Like who are the perents of sweety bell and apple blooms


awkward 😂❤😃😂😂😃😂😃😂😃😃😃

awkward 😂❤😃😂😂😃😂😃😂😃😃😃


But you to didn t here wen daybraker sey to celestya to bycome here she seys "I never become you a g i n e" i hurt dat was wery wery quiet but i hurt it im seros you know wat dos it mene


But I saw have some when she murder well I think do I like sunset shimmer Insta.


Mudra. 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

Mudra. 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢


Ofc Li<br>Ofc luna vas jelouse Celestia did not vant ty dy it ty Luna but day breker konto Celestia

Ofc Li
Ofc luna vas jelouse Celestia did not vant ty dy it ty Luna but day breker konto Celestia


Can I get pinned? I diddnt get pinned one time...


She looks like twilite. madnes.idont.no.her.name.but.she.liltte videos.she.is.nothing.she.trun.like.cestya.then.do....then.do.for.her.mabye.celtyaBeing.twilite.she.like.....l.looks.like.her🤔🤩😏


I think this would have been interesting. Celestia would have been so much more interesting if we clearly knew all her faults. Luna’s faults are why she’s so interesting and adorable. It would have been so great.


Daydreaming is a thing too. And as I have added into a fanfiction I write, just because there are pegasi who take care of the day weather, there has to be ones who take care of night weather. I am sure there are all sorts of ponies across each kind that are asleep in the day and awake at night. Maybe there weren't as many in the time of Luna becoming nightmare moon, but still another aspect that would need exploration in the case. It spreads even further though, because daydreaming is a thing, panic and anxieties and fears that Luna deals with in night dreams is also a possibility in daydreams as well. Instead of being called a daydream, though, they are called daymares. Which, no pun intended, would fit perfectly into this world.
So, into the idea of daybreaker. What if in an au, Luna did not dreamwalk at night alone. There was peace, and much of the dreams of the most likely much smaller populace were just simple things, like farming not being as good as they hoped that season. So, instead, what if Luna found a way to enter into daydreams and daymares as well? She would be encroaching into Celestia's territory by entering into the powers of the day when she is a being of the night. What if the appreciation and love she gained from helping end the daymares and turning them into daydreams caused Celestia to feel resentment towards her sister?
Sure, Celestia was there to help strengthen the bonds and keep the days bright and happy. But then, Luna would be there to truly give in to that happiness. She would be easing the normal fears that can even be felt during the day through simple fantasies of the ponies that turn into daymares, like an anxiety attack could cause a normal human to suffer.
So, Luna would be there to comfort and protect, both during the night when or if needed, but also in turn during the day where needed. This could lead to Celestia feeling left out and useless. Feeling the need to be more powerful and more loved, it could cause her to break as well. And if Luna was too busy caring for everypony else, she may not have noticed her sister's needs because she was simply too tired from working on and off both day and night. Celestia would have begun to feel useless, and not knowing how to change it, she wanted to overthrow and be the only one for anypony to love.
This leads to the question, though, of why future Luna doesn't walk through daydreams then. Simple. She is too tired to do it. As you can see in the episode about the two sisters not appreciating what each other does, by the end of the night with all her duties done, she can barely stand on her hooves. The populace has grown, Equestria has grown, since her banishment. It is not the small collection of villages she once knew. It is thousands, if not millions, more ponies than before. And then the Crystal Empire is awoken on top of that? And who knows how many nightmares may still haunt those ponies of the time of Sombra's reign that she is still helping soothe. So, the daydreams and daymares ponies have continue into their nighttime dreams and nightmares where Luna has the strength to handle the nightmares and feel joy from the dreams. This could also cause for some interesting future villains as well, because, to loop back to my initial paragraph, there have to be ponies awake at night and asleep during the day. What if there is no one there to help those ponies now, and darkness and hatred could grow from the nightmares? Luna even said in the episode, A Royal Problem, that if something wasn't done, "it could have a grave consequence on Starlight's psyche." This implies that it could cause her to completely change her and break her mind. So, what if other ponies, ones who receive no help because they only sleep in the day, were to deal with recurring nightmares that only grew stronger with time, and caused them to break?
But, this is just into my land of theories.


One thing to keep in mind is that while Luna was locked away, Celestia took the spot of Luna. If dream watching was a thing back then, than Celestia wouldn’t of complained about how difficult it is to go through the dream realm when they switched cutie marks


Given how Daybreaker acts in Starlight’s dream, I thought that it would be Celestia giving into pride and arrogance to cause the transformation, like how it was envy and jealousy that turned Luna into Nightmare Moon.


It would have been cool to see Luna as sole ruler. I wonder if after things were resolved and Twilight and her friends defeated Daybreaker she would go back to being the main ruler or if Luna would stay in that role.


I wish them to make an alternative story or have a future celestia boil over!


So I stumbled across your channel for the first time in years, back when you were still the Brony Notion. Came across you in my reccomended and was like "Wait, that guy looks familiar." So I went over to your channel, scrolled down a little and realized who you were. Cue me watching your newer videos and damn, you actually have a point with a lot of them. It reminds me of the times where I believed any theory I came across, haha. But these make sense and you do it very well. Gotta hand it to you there. Thanks for being apart of my past and factoring into one of my interests.


The whole Nightmare Moon thing could've been avoided if insomnia was a thing in MLP. Think about it.

Luna wanted to be appreciated and adored, if there was at least one insomniac pony around who had the tendency to walk around to try and feel tired enough to fall asleep Luna would've had someone to appreciate her night and wouldn't be so mad, hence, no Nightmare Moon.

If only everyone in MLP wasn't such a day person, according to my limited knowledge anyway. I'm not a ponyholic, I'm just here for the analizations and the fun ideas, please don't come at me because I missed one little detail.


This makes you think.. what would Twilight's or Cadance's antagonistic version look like and how would it break out?


Actually Nightmare Moon is created by Luna’s jealousy and insecurities.

Daybreaker, however, is the exact opposite. She always boasts about herself and her powers because she has to much self-esteem, and this is what would happen if Celestia will stop restrain herself and just stops caring about everyone


About Luna not being able to dreamwalk before being banished, it's actually been confirmed by issue 4 of the FIENDship is magic comics. She learns to dreamwalk from creatures that live on the moon and create dreams for ponies


These videos feel like they're still stuck in 2013...and I love it


I admit, this is a good thought, and gels well with my own headcanon. (yoinks idea) Though it DOES fail to address Tia's comment "You will never exist again*." Yeah, sure, that can easily be explained away as about her existing in the dream world vs getting into the real world. But that's the *boring answer.

What if Tia did become Daybreaker? Not necessarily the full-on Demon Alicorn we saw in the dream, but rather: When she saw, for the first time really saw*, the distain for the sister she had to banish the ponies of Equestria held, something... Broke. She turned her back on being the Just Queen, on being merciful and forgiving. If the Ponies wanted to be ruled by The Sun, *she'd give them the sun*. Leading to a (relatively) brief period as a despotic Tyrant. And her gentle mane became tongues of flame as she reveled in the suffering she caused until her firing fury finally burned itself out after a few decades. Twilight's fears about "Imprisoning Fluttershy in the place she banished her to" wasn't paranoia (well, not *only paranoia), but genuine fear at what Celestia had done in the past while she was mourning her sister.

But those are my thoughts.

I admit, this is a good thought, and gels well with my own headcanon. (yoinks idea) Though it DOES fail to address Tia's comment "You will never exist *again*." Yeah, sure, that can easily be explained away as about her existing in the dream world vs getting into the real world. But that's the *boring* answer.

What if Tia *did* become Daybreaker? Not necessarily the full-on Demon Alicorn we saw in the dream, but rather: When she saw, for the first time *really saw*, the distain for the sister she had to banish the ponies of Equestria held, something... Broke. She turned her back on being the Just Queen, on being merciful and forgiving. If the Ponies wanted to be ruled by The Sun, *she'd give them the sun*. Leading to a (relatively) brief period as a despotic Tyrant. And her gentle mane became tongues of flame as she reveled in the suffering she caused until her firing fury finally burned itself out after a few decades. Twilight's fears about "Imprisoning Fluttershy in the place she banished her to" wasn't paranoia (well, not *only* paranoia), but genuine fear at what Celestia had done in the past while she was mourning her sister.

But those are my thoughts.


Maybe, just maybe, you know, Celestia's place is taken by Twilight, and her student does not valuable friendship, and then she finds friends. It looks like a time loop. The thing is, we can never see Cadance in the episode "One Last Problem". What if Cadance took over Luna's place & became nightmare moon, or I would call her "Heart Breaker", the Twilight defeated her & banished her somewhere. And then, the picture about Flurry in the castle would be Taking over the Crystal heart from Cadance, so she is the new princess of Love//Light.<br>It would be interesting to see a theory video from u, because you always dig so deep to confirm the theories or tell why are they fake.

Maybe, just maybe, you know, Celestia's place is taken by Twilight, and her student does not valuable friendship, and then she finds friends. It looks like a time loop. The thing is, we can never see Cadance in the episode "One Last Problem". What if Cadance took over Luna's place & became nightmare moon, or I would call her "Heart Breaker", the Twilight defeated her & banished her somewhere. And then, the picture about Flurry in the castle would be Taking over the Crystal heart from Cadance, so she is the new princess of Love//Light.
It would be interesting to see a theory video from u, because you always dig so deep to confirm the theories or tell why are they fake.


I understand the story...dream walking was new,think about it who would be doing dream walking whilst she was in the moon
Celestial would not have been unable to enter the dream
So therefore given that she got jealous, it means she would not have been given any public attention


Have you noticed that when Daybreaker appeared she had the same splotch on her flank? Maybe the splotch shows the her evil side just like Luna


What if she only found the dream walking power after Luna spent one-thousand years watching ponies in their dreams but never being able to interact with them.


Anybody notice how in the second episode when the main 6 free Luna she looked young, but then when Twilight drank the potion Zequra (I can’t spell btw) gave her, Luna looked normal and changed into nightmare moon-?


This sounds like a good theory. May I give it a try for a comic I'm working on?


my theory:
1) i feel like daybreaker is someone celestia would turn in the future
 OR
2)shes a history-mystery you know (a topic that celestia doesnt want it to be written in the history because she doesnt want to let the future pony to know that she once turn into daybreaker)maybe before night mare moon ,their was daybreaker

ok i think the first one makes more sense than the second one, cause do you ever wonder why starlight had that kind of dream in the first place?she might have seen something that she didnt share to the others, we all know that starlight has the magic that can travel to the past and future, maybe starlight travel one of those(past n future) and saw something about daybreaker

and on the other hand , i also think the second one also makes sense,cause if you watch the whole episode of that we can see that celestia went to get luna on her dream and went back on starlight dream, after that we can hear luna saying "u can defeat daybreaker  if bla bla bla", so the question here is how did luna know daybreaker?? even when celestia didnt mention her(daybreaker) name ,theirs probably only two possible answer (1) like i said celestia might have turn into daybreaker in the past (2) she might have went into an old pony dreaming about daybreaker

the only thing i cant explain is why/how did she turned inyo daybreaker?


If this theory  could have been what happened if Luna stared walking in dreams where would daybreak been banished to?<br>Would it be the sun or still the moon?

If this theory  could have been what happened if Luna stared walking in dreams where would daybreak been banished to?
Would it be the sun or still the moon?


I think luna started walking in dreams while trapped in the moon ... or at least she started testing her magic for it


Can you make a video about Cadence? Or make a made up backstory for her? Or find something that could point to Cadences backstory, and make a video about it? And would the crystal heart spell be a canon source of information?


Sawtooth you forgot that when Celestia defeated daybreaker she said "You will never exist again" indicating daybreaker already has come out because the whole point of dreams is that they are not real.😮


In fact, I think Celestia did transformed into Daybreaker in the past because of one detail that caught my attention. We must watch carefully and especially listen carefuly. Luna knows the name of Daybreaker... but nopony told her.... mystery...


I have a simpler explanation...

Luna: steals a piece of Celestia’s cake
Celestia: goes Daybreaker  “SO YOU HAVE CHOSEN... DEATH...”

I have a simpler explanation...

Luna: *steals a piece of Celestia’s cake*
Celestia: *goes Daybreaker  “SO YOU HAVE CHOSEN... DEATH...”*


This would be a great idea for a video, but its too hard i think.
What would've happened if Celestia DID turn to daybreaker (or Might Nare Noon) and Luna is the one ruling equestria?
What if daybreaker took over?
Would there be a mane 6?
Celestia is the one that formed the mane six because of her top student, Twilight.
If she was daybreaker, then Twilight may not be herself. Maybe she would have a different cutie mark, and maybe there would be different heroes because either luna is the princess, or daybreaker took over equestria? Again, this would be too hard because you would have a completely different timeline to make.


it makes sense celestia could have become day breaker but there wasnt an actual oppurtunity <br>if luna walked in dreams in the past daybreaker wouldve been the one banished and luna would have been the ruler of equestria, interactions,friends and everything she wanted

it makes sense celestia could have become day breaker but there wasnt an actual oppurtunity
if luna walked in dreams in the past daybreaker wouldve been the one banished and luna would have been the ruler of equestria, interactions,friends and everything she wanted


Didn't they say that comics where all basically canon? Well from what I understand, in Friendship is Magic comics, it was revealed that Nightmare Moon was created by a group of extraordinarily entities known the Nightmare Forces.


why does Starlight Glimmer knows about Daybreaker? I mean, if it appeared in Starlight's dream it means that she had seen her before.... if we remember the video about how starlight had the power to affect time itself, maybe she was able, in some moment of her studies, to see a different time line in where Celestia was the one who was corrupted and no Luna.


If Celestia and Luna can turn evil, can't Cadance and Twilight?

Cause cadence and twilight represent magic. Love. And friendship


Maybe Luna started dream walking when the black spot of her cutie mark appeared? Because in the episode where Starlight switches their cutie marks the black is also seen on Celestia. And I believe before Nightmare Moon,Luna didn't have that.


My theory: Before Luna turned into Nightmare moon for the first time, I think she never knew she could walk into dreams, so, after, she ‘accidently’ walked into (maybe) her sister or another pony’s dream ;>;<br>Daybreaker, will be late bc Celestia is pure and not easy to be jealous

My theory: Before Luna turned into Nightmare moon for the first time, I think she never knew she could walk into dreams, so, after, she ‘accidently’ walked into (maybe) her sister or another pony’s dream ;>;
Daybreaker, will be late bc Celestia is pure and not easy to be jealous


Ok, what I want to know is does Celesta rule over day dreaming or is that Luna?


Well technically cellesea never really turned in to daybreak that was a thiry of star light so we don't know if she looked like daybreak in starlights dream or even if cellesea had the capability and power to turn in to daybreak


I have a theory that every Alconorn earns there flowing mane when they complete a big part of there distance and walking in dreams must be why she has a flowing mane now


This theory makes a lot of sense, but what If  it were a bit different. What I am saying  is what if Princess Celestia was jealous of Luna because during the day the ponies needed to work hard but in Luna's night they got the chance to rest. I know it might not make a lot of sense the way your theory does but It's just a thought.


Just to point out when you see Daybreaker (aka Celestia)in the the dream realm take a closer look at her cutie mark
It looks just like Luna's aka Nightmare Moon that cought my eye
I'll live it up to you Sawtooth Waves ;)


This also explains who protected ponies in their dreams they simply didn't have them


I think it was some creature that triggered Celestia like it did Luna ( the tantabus) but if you look closely daybreaker has a cutie mark that has a splotch like Luna.


I think what would of caused daybreaker was if Celestia never formed those bonds like she did with twilight and cadence.


What if Daybreaker in the episode was Celestia's Tantabus so to speak?


but wouldnt this clash with starswirl's theory... he made her the ruler of the dream world, so she woulldhv already hv had this job


And yet, this mystery will remain <b>unsolved.</b>

And yet, this mystery will remain *unsolved.*


If the pony started being awake at night or the bigger sister would be Luna instead   of celiesta<br>it can turn her to day barker .

If the pony started being awake at night or the bigger sister would be Luna instead   of celiesta
it can turn her to day barker .


this is amazing ill make a fanfic out of this.... other fanfic writers......TO YOUR KEYBOARDS!!!


Doesn't the fact that celestia could become corrupted and that luna did become corrupted hint at the fact that maybe all alicorns have a hidden potential to lose control and become corrupted.


Me: never finished MLP, never saw Daybreaker until now
Also me: Interesting.

Me: *never finished MLP, never saw Daybreaker until now*
Also me: Interesting.


I literally thought the same thing ever since that episode came out!


Luna turned into nightmare moon cause of that jealousy and the nightmares. Read the book where rarity turns into nightmare rarity Luna explains everything. Maybe if the tables did turn the nightmares would of went to celestial instead of Luna


Gotta do a pinkie pie actually tapping the glass and interrupting your outtro for a brief moment.<br>(April fools?)

Gotta do a pinkie pie actually tapping the glass and interrupting your outtro for a brief moment.
(April fools?)


I think that there is something in it when she said: "You are not real,! And you will never exist AGAIN!!!" <br>I mean yeah... she might have been talking ABOUT Luna, but she was TALKING TO Daybreaker. just saying... what if she once DID exist?

I think that there is something in it when she said: "You are not real,! And you will never exist AGAIN!!!"
I mean yeah... she might have been talking ABOUT Luna, but she was TALKING TO Daybreaker. just saying... what if she once DID exist?


In the meantime: that's just a theory. A PONY THEORY.


“Better not to give Starlight Glimmer any ideas.” <br>Lol 😂

“Better not to give Starlight Glimmer any ideas.”
Lol 😂


Maybe Shortly After Twilight Took The Rule, If Luna Was Still DreamWalking, Celestia... NIGHTMARE NOONED HERSELF!!


So do all alicorns have an evil alter ego?


What if she was broken by the pressure and felt pain and stress which caused her to become day breaker


Wait... isnt daybreaker even in one of the comics from mlp? I think she was in the mirror comic with parallel universes!


I think luna only walks on dreams when somebody has nightmares


What about the creature that helped Luna to be Nightmaremoon .


I think that Luna is now accessing dreams because she has been trapped in the moon the 1000 year


If Luna can get Banished to the moon then can Celestia can get banished to the sun?


But in royal problem starlight thought if the sisters kept fighting ,day breaker will form just like nightmare moon


When you said "Might Mare Noon" I actually laughed! XD


Well it all makes sense  celestia went evil because pepole started giving I bit more attention to luna


I remember when I first saw “Might Mare Noon” ( Lol XD ) I had nightmares for like a week. Idk why she just terrified me for some reason- I’m so, so confused tho. Why did I have nightmares about herrrrrrrrrrrrrrr????????


Day breaker was maxed in a dream just like nightmare moon so they both exist in a different universe


What if she did go evil whenever she wasn’t in the scene


She probably go Rogue and become daybreaker if the sun disappeared in the day was no more


Please never stop making those videos about ponies


I like all of these Ideas like there so good I see that it’s very mystery and mystic


there is a point to ruling the dream world by day  (drum-roll please) for the nappers!


I think that day breaker is from a different universe. cause in the my little pony game in one of the limited time story's it shows the two sisters as villians and king sombra the hero.


My theory is she would go rogue when the fact that Luna is best princess gets into the pony world


If luna could go into the moon then day Celestia may have gone to the sun


I have a theory for u to make! Who is the one who controls the stars? (How did the stars let out nightmare moon)


Day breaker sounds like a villain name for miraculous ladybug


So would daybreaker be banished To THE SUN?!


Day breaker should be banish to the sun ☀


Well she probably got permission from celestia<br>I don't know what else would've an answer from me

Well she probably got permission from celestia
I don't know what else would've an answer from me


I think that celesta turned into day breaker because of heartbrake


Well I think that daybreaker was jealous that everypony is scared of nightmaremoon


Waaaaaaait. This proves the theory that star swirl created alicorns wrong.


Sheesh. You stop watching a series for a while and this is what you get when you come back 0_0


the way that nightmare noon would come out of Celestia would be that somebody went back in time and told her something that would have gone wrong or made her jealous say that Luna was never ever turned into nightmare Moon then she would then she still went to go dream walking  her sister would gotten jealous and turned into  nightmare noon and she gets  jealous of Eva Luna because she does not get the mental like Luna she gets physical so she'd become jealous and turn into nightmare new which would make her be nightmare Moon so all I'm saying is that she would get jealous by Nas heaven the amount of attention she does have attention but she doesn't have the mental tension like Luna so she only has  physical


Go fanfiction writers. To your keyboards.


Celestia didn’t become daybreaker it’s all in starlight head


Twilight sparkle vs peanut butter
Twilight uses magic
Peanut butter uses tightness
Twilight uses magic
Peanut butter defeats twilight


the answer to daybreaker is daydreaming!!


Who remembers those days where his name was Brony Notion?


Theroy Luna is the cosmic owl in adventure time


The I Alicoin sisters got into another fight and Starlight’s dream Becomes reality


I don’t even watch MLP and I clicked on this-


Maybe because of Luna,s cutimark Nightmare moon come and when Starlight change their cutemarks Luna,s  cutimark  go to CELESTIA maybe because of that Daybreak come.


Actually when Luna got angry then she became night mare moon


I wonder why celestia turn into daybreaker. What is it daybreaker want?

{ѕσρнιє ℓєє}


What if the sisters could control when they ternd it to there dark form to fight or something


I think that one day Luna got all the attention and Celestia got jealous sorry if I’m saying this wrong but maybe it’s the same thing that corrupted Luna that corrupted her for no reason


When you know was little her hair is different but when she was big and her hair was floating can you talk about that in a video please


Every one hidden under the shade on hot days and that makes her upset  then daybreaker.


2 thing a ponies cutie mark changes when they become evil like nightmare moon's and day breakers but how? And on the nightmare night   ep where luna cancels it but how does she control turning into it because we can see her tranform back into luna so how has she managed to control it?


Great theory oh and I love all of ur theors !!!!!!!

As i like to call her Might mare Doom a good change right?


Well isn't Luna technically still a child


Wait if nightmare moon was banished to the moon does that mean day breaker would be banished to the sun


Brony i have a theory: well this IS starlights DREAM in her dream princess celestia and luna were still fighting for who has the HARDEST job,so my theory is if there still fighting it will become a reality which turns luna to nightmare moon and celestia will become day breaker ( i think i got it wrong idk tell yours) BRONY NOTION


daybreaker? your forgetting about nightmare star from rememberence


So—— she gets trapped in the sun??? Ooo dat otta hurt


<b>THEORY</b> Ik this is late and idk if it was already said BUT i remember brony notion saying the the flank of nightmare moon is black because of the bad thing. Also... if all of you realise... DAY BREAKER ALSO HAD THAT MARK just that its orange!!! That prooves the theory of the black mark O.O LIKE wow

*THEORY* Ik this is late and idk if it was already said BUT i remember brony notion saying the the flank of nightmare moon is black because of the bad thing. Also... if all of you realise... DAY BREAKER ALSO HAD THAT MARK just that its orange!!! That prooves the theory of the black mark O.O LIKE wow


what if celestia already turn to day breaker. When ? I think in the war against sombra. Why ? ponies can use dark magic and sombra is a master,   i also remebered a thind about the sun it had black area on it so celestia also ad a dark side from the begening sombra could use his magic on her and she turned in daybreaker or sombra badly hurt luna an celestia gone mad

(i apologise for terrible my english i am french so ... )


Ok this is a good video.
But the only thing that boters me is.......
HOW DID LUNA GROWS ??????


Wtf have they done to this show i leave for a year and come back to this? Lmao


Makes SOoooooooOoOOoooOooOooooooooooooo0OooOOOoo much sense


you should do can pirncess luna raise the sun btw i am a fan of mlp


I don't know but it is not really Princess Celestia is just not daybreaker it's just a dream


{ѕσρнιє ℓєє}


inhale i know have to re think everything ive ever know about mlp and create a regular and corrupted version me in my head MY, YOUR HAND WILL GET CRAMPED, AND YOULL END UP CRUMPLING A LOT OF PAGES me drawing it i shouldve listened to my brain when i had the chanced

*inhale* i know have to re think everything ive ever know about mlp and create a regular and corrupted version *me in my head* MY, YOUR HAND WILL GET CRAMPED, AND YOULL END UP CRUMPLING A LOT OF PAGES *me drawing it* i shouldve listened to my brain when i had the chanced


There's a Darkness Pony in My Little Pony increase your Castle you are crashing one


But if nightmare moon never happened then twilight woupd have never met the mane 5


how did this get in my recommendations all i do on this account is listen to undertale soundtracks


He true walk in dreams if celestia banishes luna in the moon he don't   <br>Have the power to walk at the dream realm

He true walk in dreams if celestia banishes luna in the moon he don't
Have the power to walk at the dream realm


This is a theory of mine:

In the season 5 Finale, when starlight was altering different timelines, of you take a look at the nightmare moon timeline, something else happened. Luna did not just defeat Celestia and vanished her to the moon. There had to be something else.

Luna must have been clear of the solution to her problem, and she would’ve never turned into nightmare moon. But then Celestia became jealous, and turned into Day breaker. Luna, herself would have to then vanish day breaker to the moon. Because of course, the mane six wouldn’t be there or know anything. So then the elements of harmony would be against Day breaker.

Anyway, then, Celestia was banished to the moon for 1,000 years, and come back for revenge. Luna would try to talk it out with Day breaker, but without the mane six there, Day breaker would’ve not turned back to Celestia. Which means that therefore, Luna had no other choice but to banish her sister back to the moon again, this time forever.

After some time, Luna realized that she can also turn into nightmare moon, just like her sister turned into Day breaker. So then Luna wanted all the power for herself and wanted to rule with her own rules, and that’s when she became nightmare moon and made equestria even worse. That’s how everyone became ruled under nightmare moon.

I know the subject of Day breaker didn’t come up at the time yet, but still, this would’ve been interesting.


Light Mare Noon is better than day breaker lol


Holy- that- that makes sense<br>Dang it I'm stupid

Holy- that- that makes sense
Dang it I'm stupid


luna is hardly ever in the serieses so i don't get it and what i don't get is princess twilight is the main character but applejack is in them more like if u agree


Daybreaker
As I like to call it Might mare noon
Me: HAHA


1.daybreaker
2.nightmare noon
3.nightmare day
4.scarenoon


Hey, ummm. I have a theory that this video inspired me to make. It’ll be on my YouTube channel.


I love thise theory I just watched thise 3 times


Maybe is the brown as you know that basically lunatic and she was jealous of celestial her sister but what if it was that Luna get all the appreciation in the world from dreams but if it was the other way round if I don’t make sense but I think I know if you swapped around because basically on the Gmail let’s imagine what ever you want but when you’re playing you just do it once but I think Luna gets all the appreciation of dreams unless you just really is jealous of Luna so basically that’s provided by standing today by car or the appreciation went into when you are have a good dream when you dream you get what you want but when you play not really much what you want so that’s my comment so just trying to find out to go out closely well bye


because Celestia was not jealous like nightmarmoon


Mabe Luna dono't know that she can wake in pony's drime.So she ma think that she has only the power to  razing the Moon 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔


Celesta is not day breaker because in the Royal problem celestial and day breaker where there not just day breaker sorry that just confused me in the title and thumbnail


....i see you using the film theory font.


Which while it sparkle being allo corn trigger her adjust like DE breaker and nightmare moon could it happen


If also it must be that day breaker and night mare moon must be sis's


i knew it xd,but is this important to explain?


I don't really sleep during the night sometimes I'm scared Luna was true and they seem inform I won't be scared no no no no nothing no no no no nothing tobacco my dreams night mode moon emoji animoji moon emoji Ledo's ladles


I dont know the story i dont watch so much mlp


You are write . The story is confusing to me


We're would daybraker be banished to because luna was going to the moon so we're does daybraker go


Me just watching this and thinking: “ wait- if they transform into evil pony’s- their kinda having a tantrum 👉👈”


Okay why celestia have pink hair? Now ln the episode she has rainbow hair

{ѕσρнιє ℓєє}

{ѕσρнιє ℓєє}


its bicase luna havs al the power in the world and celestia has onlie haf of it


If leona as nit meur moon consist slender to be evll


Can I hang up by my moms on my C yeah I think


Hi my name's  fire storm  I'm the princess of fire


Might mare noon how about bright mare noon


I honestly think that celestia would become daybreaker because of all the work she does. In the episode “The Royal Problem” she said that lunas job would be easy but it wasnt and nightmare moon was before that obviously so maybe replace nightmare moon with day breaker and she didn’t know how hard lunas job was so she thought that Luna had a super easy job and didn’t get tired out maybe??? I don’t know lol


Wadha Is sooooooooooo cool amjad mirza baig


Please why do you have us at the same time with my sister and she's going crazy but we didn't see it


can you mack a  video daybacu went geem worckng  in the pas


Next in your video can you tell ppl how to unite yourself in Roblox? Cause I got muted cause I was roleplaying AND I WAS TRYING TO DO A LAB ROLEPLAY WITH A CAT AND SHOCKING PPL IS IN ROLEPLAY BUT ME DR. RUSTY IS TO CRINGY! Sorry.. got to mad


I acutely don't have anything to say so bye lobe you all


Why I like Luna and not can 😢 I like the sun but I like the moon well I like the moon and I hat the sun  I know why I hat the sun it's because I don't want to walk up😮😯🙁


idk why they call Celestia evil alterego : Daybreaker because its doesn't sound evil at all look at Luna as least her alterego has Nightmare in her name so we know that is a villian for sure but Daybreak itself has a meaning and if i don't get it's wrong its mean early morning ??? so what evil with that "EARLY MORNING" ??? and more over that Day+breaker I mean come on how it gonna get any meaning that Celestia is a villian all I can think about this word "Daybreaker" is tjalousie but may be very massive of dark emotion/power from some spell or artifact collect that can store its released to herself toward.


I'm glad to see somebody else recognizing that Luna didn't always walk in dreams. That's one thing from the official comics which makes much more sense as canon than non-canon: the "Fiendship is Magic" mini-series shows her learning to manipulate dreams on the moon from the original stewards of dreams (whom she then corrupts, of course, so they'll help her bring nightmares). And surely we must accept that as at least mostly true, since Luna dreamwalking before her banishment makes no sense for exactly the reason you gave.

That said, I'm not sure that Celestia was ever in a mental place where she'd go berserk over Luna having a more personal connection with their subjects. Her high status can make it difficult for her subjects to connect with her, but they still undeniably respect and appreciate her since her role is extremely public. It would take a lot to change that enough that such a strong reaction as Daybreaker would make sense.


I can get on board with this theory. Makes sense in a way. What if, when Luna returned to normal, she reverted to her younger firm since the Rainbow-Friendship-Mega-Blast sends the target back to a “time” or form where it was the happiest, or “friendliest.” Which would make sense as to why she had a younger form from Season 1, and in the flash back, her current form. Even IF Celestia went dark, she would still have her current form.


I think you’re good for the most part but whenever she or Luna started her dream walking ability was celestial who informed her of the ability because she thought it would be a good attribute to help calm her down to avoid another Mayham


This is absolutely BRILLIANT!!!! Love your theories


I think you theory with Luna makes sense because in the song "You'll Play Your Part", Luna says "I know how hard it is to wait, to spread your wings and soar" - I think this relates to her finding her purpose (beyond breaking the curse of nightmare moon), then your theory about her dreamwalking makes a lot of sense 👍


I still personally ascribe to the theory that the "wasteland" bad future we saw Twilight take Starlight Glimmer to was the result of Celestia going Daybreaker when either faced with an enemy that left her with no other choice but to employ such extreme measures, or some other unknown stressors provoked her into deciding to nuke everything.


In my vision, Luna might have had a nightmare of her ponies calling her a "deception", a "disgrace", and saying that she is "evil as plain as the mark on her flank" since they could still think she is Nightmare Moon.


I honestly wish this was how the story went. I like Luna more than Celestia, so it would be interesting to see the roles reversed.


Makes sense. Now what would tip Cadance over the edge? The grief of losing her husband? And what would her name be when evil?


Someone mentioned how Celestia said to daybreaker "And you will never exist again " saying it suggests that Day Breaker did exist at one point in time...

But from Celestia's personality and everything, I'd say she became Day Breaker out of anger rather than jealousy (although Starlight's dream suggests it was thirst for power) and was defeated in a short time.

Someone mentioned how Celestia said to daybreaker "And you will never exist *again* " saying it suggests that Day Breaker did exist at one point in time...

But from Celestia's personality and everything, I'd say she became Day Breaker out of anger rather than jealousy (although Starlight's dream suggests it was thirst for power) and was defeated in a short time.


I'd like to think that Luna tried Dream Walking before she came back from her Thousand Years prison, but at the time, she was inexperienced and didn't know how to really help people with that. Because of that, she would have failed saving several ponies from their nightmares, which explains how she even knows that nightmares can actually damage someone's psyche. With that, maybe she got traumatized and never tried to do that again, until she was reformed.

But again, it's just an idea I had right now, I may be speaking a lot of nonsense here.


Well it could also be that Celestia was evil along. I like your theory though, but her evil side still lives on, see the video below to maybe get a new understanding.

https://youtu.be/fACzoXV2fWk


I remember the feeling of watching this show being younger. Now I want that again. So if you will excuse me I’m going to watch a pony show I’m too old for


I think that before Luna got banished, she only had the responsibility to raise the moon because she was young. When she came back from being banished she was still visibly much younger and more naive, celestia might not have trusted her back then to control ponies' dreams, maybe she thought it would be too stressful?


I mean, that does make sense thinking about it. In the episode, Daybreaker is mainly after Nightmare Moon, so that does explain why she was when you think of it that way


Lottie 151 is right when you said that in the Alicorn video that star  Swril put them in charge of the realms i think he only did it to Celestia but then he thought of putting Luna in charge of another realm in the future but didn't tell her.Then years later she finds out about the dream realm and gains control over her own realm.And Lottie 151 also pointed out that something else could have triggered Luna's transformation.The part where you said that Daybreaker wanted more attention could have been the opissite. In our timeline Luna was the on who wanted more attention that triggerd her to become nightmare moon so the same thing like you pointed out with daybreaker but remeber when i said star swril put Luna in charge of her own realm in the FUTURE i think in the timeline before discord celestia became daybreaker in betwen when discord came and when equestria was still at peace. Some where in the middle she tured into daybreaker.But hey thats just a theroy A FILM THROEY AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAND CUT


Well maybe after Luna got free of her evil form Celestina taught her how to dream walk because maybe she didn’t learn it when she was jealous.

This is just a random theory from me. Also love your videos!


maybe she got her power of dream walking when she became nightmare moon. she got the power from all the power she gained when she went to the dark. and she still has some of her powers as nightmare moon


So I was watching other theory’s if the two sisters and it stated: Luna’s cutey mark was originally a crescent moon until after Nightmare Moon she had a black splotch added to her cutie mark. In season 4 when Terik comes, and her magic is taken away (given to twilight) her black splotch stayed. But in the royal problem when their cutie marks were switched the splotch appeared on Celestia’s flank. So, my point is. If the splotch represented Nightmare moon, the evil side of Luna. And it was transferred to Celestia, could that be the reason why Daybreaker appeared? Idk it doesn’t make fully sense ;v;


I’m thanking you for feeling the part that was missing on me to be in the mlp world again


I haven’t watched Brony in 3 years ! And the channel is just like the good old days .


I thought Luna was the one that took Cadence in. In "A Canterlot Wedding" it said that Cadence is Celestia's niece, so wouldn't that make Luna her adoptive mother? (I could be wrong, though).


Hey I was just thinking that instead of Princess Celesta’s dark side being called Daybreaker, it should have been called “Midday Sun” since Princess Luna’s dark side is called Nightmare Moon


Not a brony, but this theory vid seems pretty interesting, nice job, you captivated a non-brony's attention


What if Daybreaker would only show up if Celestia became imprisoned in the moon. We only see Daybreaker fighting Nightmaremoon. If Nightmaremoon has somehow won, Celestia would swear revenge, becoming Daybreaker.


What do you all think a civil war between Daybreaker and Nightmare Moon would look like?<br>And what Equestria species besides ponies would join them?

What do you all think a civil war between Daybreaker and Nightmare Moon would look like?
And what Equestria species besides ponies would join them?


I think that you are right, but I think that maybe Luna didnt know HOW to walk in dreams before, and she learned after returning


Anyone remember when the evil Celestia used to be called Solar Flare by the fandom before the Daybreaker episode?


This messes with your theory that starswirl created alicorns. In that theory starswirl gave Celestia the alicorn transformation dimension, and Luna the dream dimension. This would mean that Luna watched over the dream world long before nightmare moon.


Well technically you can rule the dream world by day because day dreaming is a thing

          1:55


Fact: If you swap Nightmare's colours via negative filter, you'll receive Daybreak's.


In my opinion, Luna didn’t walk into dreams probably due to ponies not having any...
It’s just pure black.
A whole lotta nothingness
She became jealous due to people recognizing Celestia more than here since she would interact with ponies in daytime while luna’s only way to interact with ponies is through dreams
Sadly, she couldn’t due to ponies not having dreams
Her jealousy went to her head causing her to go evil
She figured, if I can’t interact with ponies, THEN YOU CAN’T EITHER
causing Celestia to banish her sister to the moon
talk about getting booted
Now,
The Daybreaker part needs more backstory to be revealed. It also will need tweaks in the story line for Celestia to turn into Daybreaker
The only reason I can find for Daybreaker is that power went to her head and her seeing that ponies enjoy day more than night, caused this
Or
Possible corruption

In my opinion, Luna didn’t walk into dreams probably due to ponies not having any...
It’s just pure black.
A whole lotta nothingness
She became jealous due to people recognizing Celestia more than here since she would interact with ponies in daytime while luna’s only way to interact with ponies is through dreams
Sadly, she couldn’t due to ponies not having dreams
Her jealousy went to her head causing her to go evil
She figured, if I can’t interact with ponies, THEN YOU CAN’T EITHER
causing Celestia to banish her sister to the moon
*talk about getting booted*
Now,
The Daybreaker part needs more backstory to be revealed. It also will need tweaks in the story line for Celestia to turn into Daybreaker
The only reason I can find for Daybreaker is that power went to her head and her seeing that ponies enjoy day more than night, caused this
Or
Possible corruption


it's not strictly canon, but the official comics said she got the dream powers by enslaving the moon bunnies(?) as Nightmare Moon. So after she was gone, that stolen power remained.


A night shift job must not really be a thing in Equestria. Even in a big city like Manehatten.


I think that daybreaker would have come because what Celestia's doing is usually all fake but Luna is doing her job with her heart, not her head


I kinda thought Celestia became Daybreaker because of greed because she said lines like
"Deep inside you know how powerful you are"
"Who needs balance when you can have it all?"
But it was only what I thought, it's not the actual


So, I went from crying about an extinct locomotive to watching this<br>What a recommendation

So, I went from crying about an extinct locomotive to watching this
What a recommendation


The [Daybreaker] made me thought this was about an SCP, but hey, I also love MLP theories, so win win


Louna could’ve been vanishing Celeste you to the sun she could’ve walked in dreams first and less you could’ve got jealous and turned into Daybreaker End it might be sunset shimmer or starlight glimmer leading


I think Luna was dream walking but all the ponies were dreaming about was their appreciation for Celestia that's what caused Luna or at least that's what I think what caused Luna to become Nightmare Moon because the ponies giving all their appreciation to Celestia and not to Luna I think it's a very good explanation because how would Luna everything about dream walking because she had most likely done it in her past


Daybreaker is also in twilights imagination in the beggining of the end twilights biggest fear is disappointing celestia and luna then they turn to Daybreaker and Nightmaremoon.


What if Luna formed a connection with the moon and found a wat to travel through it but only when she was FORCED to see it by the banishment


"the ponies enjoyed Celestia's day but slept through Luna's night"
night shift workers: am I a joke to you?

"the ponies enjoyed Celestia's day but slept through Luna's night"
night shift workers: *am I a joke to you?*


Wait. But why didn't Luna use dreamwalking to fill her holes befor turning into Nightmare Moon? What if Luna didn't have that power before Twilight's stories? If it is true, then how did she get dreamwalking?


Celestia actually had a school before Luna turned into Nightmaremoon, so she had special bonds at that time. (Just read the comics)

He also made a video saying that she created it to find a potential alicorn princess to fill in for her when she and Luna go back to their home, the alicorn kingdom. (It makes more sense if you watch it) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zRZbjMioRL8&t=159s


I think your right about the dream walking thing . Think about it in season 1 episode 1 when did the story say any thing about dream walking BUT there is a thing called missing books and page's.... I could be wrong tho


The pixie hollow OST smacked me in the face with nostalgia and feels lol I MISS THAT GAME, also, this is great.


Sunset messed up the fricken eg timeline. I can forgive her tho, she's my favorite character and is the perfect example of sympathy.


Wouldn't the people of Canterlot see the sisters fighting in the sky? Would it cause a panic?


If luna didnt turn into nightmare moon, twilight sparkle would not have met applejack, Pinkie pie, rarity, fluttershy, and rainbow dash, and they wouldnt know they were part of the elements


Whenever he solves easy cases in mlp hE mAkEs mE cOnFuSEd.


So after celestia banished Luna didn’t she also have to take care of raising and lowering the moon too? So would that mean celestia could also dream walk too or would that some how be done by another pony?


I'm pretty sure Daybreaker WAS a thing when Celestia says <b>"You'll never exist AGAIN!"</b> - implying she did at ine point.

I'm pretty sure Daybreaker WAS a thing when Celestia says *"You'll never exist AGAIN!"* - implying she did at ine point.


Maybe when Luna came back celestial or some pony gave her the power to walk in dreams to stop her turning back into nightmare moon.


Okay so, i wached the episode a royal problom, and i wanted to point some things out. First, when starlight switches the cutie marks and celestia is doing lunas job, she seems suprised how and i quote, “my list used to be twice as long!”, “your talking to yourself celestia...” and makes a point she has no idea how to dream walk. My theory, is that she never raised the moon, or dream walked, or did any of lunas job. Is there’s is a pony god (another one of my theorys) would aid in lunas escape, so she could bring peice to the ponys dreams.


Luna surely werent visiting dreams before, it wouldnt make sence to be jelous and angry if she helped sleeping ponies solve their issues and problems


It should have started the mlp series with nightmare moon (which is actually true) and ended the series with daybreaker as the last villain

They never used her anymore totally potential wasted


Wait a sec,does this mean Daybrearker (Celestia) will get banished to the sun?


I think what would have made celestia jealous of Luna is that Luna can only walk in dreams but celestia can’t all celestia douse is talk to pony’s and watch over them and see how they are going but on the other hoof Luna comforts them in dreams.what do you think?


Who else thinks cadence should have an evil side called heartbreaker that may have made for an interesting episode or a 2 parter


Also when Celestia defeated both she said “you will never exist again”


I feel like Daybreaker would have been just as bad and even harder to fight than Nightmare Moon....and...you can't banish anyone to the son...they would die.....XD (I mean moon too but that seems doable with magic. The sun.....eeeeh death trap XD)


I think its all about luna’s cutie mark. We know luna turned into nightmare moon. And when starlight changed their cutie mark the dark magic in luna transport to celestia. And then daybreaker appeared


Where is an episode where Celestia who never helps with the mane 6 turns to Daybreaker?


But doesn't that mean that Celestia has more work than Luna because nobody's really awake at night(Like c'mon)


Or maybe tia just ACCIDENTALLY entered our world and saw all her haters in the fandom...😜😂


Can you explain how twilight increase the heat of the sun in the magic battle between her and trixie. And how did her hair  turn into fire and her coat became white, are twilight and celestia connected somehow to blood or the sun.


Can you make a video on what would happened if Luna ruled for a 1,000 years


When you havent seen the last 3 seasons and are confused


I dont really like the idea of daybreaker,because thats what made luna special and i feel if celestia has a dark side it just makes celestia more powerful and special than luna,luna turn into nightmare moon beause of celestia day and i feel its not fair to luna.


...or sunset shimmer or starlight told things that made Celestia to daybreaker or maybe she wanted more power to be more stronger than Luna


This is logical. Maybe we will get this in GEN5


Day breaker has color around her cutie mark Just like Luna so that shows that Luna did get that dark splodge from becoming nightmare moon.


I don't know about my theory because I'm thinking it can happen when they were young after transforming into an alicorn...<br>IDK

I don't know about my theory because I'm thinking it can happen when they were young after transforming into an alicorn...
IDK


Maybe it was something to do with “who free nightmare moon. Like she changed into daybreaker but then... anything’s possibly!


Why have all the crusaders met Luna in their dreams? (I just noticed that)


Y'all forget that if MLP was realistic, a lot of introverts would hate Celestia because the sun is too bright lmaoooooo-


Looks like Luna didn't age while on the moon.


Daybreaker is more sexy than Nightmare Moon, change my mind.


I agree with you but how is it that the princesses can turn into such things


"Might Mare Noon" This man deserves more subscribers


What if Daybreaker did happen and was babished to the sun, and left Luna in charge, she had a failed student Twilight that ran away and a pupil that became a princess, Sunset Shimmer


So Daybreaker is just Nightmare Moon with the colours inverted? wOw


I always thought daybreaker should be named sunburn


Ohhh Wow that would be soo cool to see What would happen if Celestia went evil instead of Luna!


So when we first saw Luna she had no wavy hair like celestia until season 2 Luna has wavy hair that’s when I think she first started watching over dreams


But bro if the two alicorn have their potential evil forms then twilight and cadence must have theirs?


But in the Song "a lullaby for a princes " the Story is that Celestia forgot about Luna and that the reson is why Luna turnt into Nightmer moon. So maybe Celastia will turn into daybraker bekos she falt lonly without Luna.


EXCUSE ME!? WHO DOESN'T LIKE NIGHT MORE!?DAY ISN'T NEARLY AS GOOD AS NIGHT!


I think luna started walking to dreams from the music of <br>"the children of the night

I think luna started walking to dreams from the music of
"the children of the night


Hey has anyone realised that the headless pony looks like Luna headless look at the tail and size + the legs on the body


TBH This 100% makes sense for these reasons

1. Luna is younger and smaller than Celestia, therefore not a full-grown alicorn (or maybe she's just short? I mean other races have different heights so I guess Alicorns can too)
2. Her first confirmed Dream walking is with the CMC
3. The CMC discover their purpose is helping others learn their purpose
4. It's been shown that having your cutie mark doesn't always mean you know your purpose in life, as the CMC has helped ponies earn cutie marks as well as helped ponies with cutie marks discover the true meaning of their mark
5. When you put all this together, Luna hadn't reached nor understood her full potential yet


One problem with why Luna turned. What about the bat ponies did they not exist back then otherwise who were the night guards?


Hold up celestia turned evil? I haven’t watched this show since I was like 8..


To look at it...Celestia DOES control the SUN and SUN breaker maybe IS Celestia! :O maybe Celestia was jealous of something??


Maybe Luna wants physical attention not emotion


MAYBE THE SAME THING THAT HAPPENED TO PRINCESS LUNA?!


what i think wouldve happend is so just like u said starlight goes back to the past and more then after she turns day breaker she brings iternal day  luna gets mad and raises the moon and becomes NIGHTMARE MOON and just like startlights dream they fight then too alicorns banish them to where they belong daybreaker sun nightmare moon in the moon they come back and yeah u know


Omg thanks you for making this theory and then this is makes sense now also love ya vids!


O gawd, seeing those scenes again is giving me PTSD, 😵